The Possibility of Possibilities: Creative-Listening Spaces in Art Education
72
The Possibility of Possibilities: CreativeListening Spaces in Art Education Samantha Messer This selfpublished manuscript was originally submitted in partial fulfillment of my degree in Masters of Arts in Art Education in the College of Design, Art, Architecture, and Planning at the University of Cincinnati. I have published this text as an online archive because I believe that a creative society benefits from a culture of sharing ideas. I invite others to take up this research and its related threads, weaving new possibilities and outcomes for this work. This work exists both in digital form and as a tangible book; there are inevitable and fascinating differences across and within each of these diverse media. In the digital form, links are provided to guide readers to content both inside and outside of the text. I welcome feedback, comments, and questions. Contact me at [email protected] samanthamesserartist.com
-
Upload
samantha-messer -
Category
Documents
-
view
221 -
download
2
description
In this qualitative, arts-informed case study, the researcher explores how listening practices could be influential in the study and teaching of art and art education. Key words: listening, art education, collage, layers, hermeneutics, dialogic practices, contemplative practices, the felt sense.
Transcript of The Possibility of Possibilities: Creative-Listening Spaces in Art Education
13 13 13 13 13
The13 Possibility13 of13 Possibilities13 13
Creative-shy‐Listening13 Spaces13 in13 Art13 Education13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13
Samantha13 Messer13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13
This13 self-shy‐published13 manuscript13 was13 originally13 submitted13 in13 partial13 fulfillment13 of13 my13 degree13 in13 Masters13 of13 Arts13 in13 Art13 Education13 in13 the13 College13 of13 Design13 Art13 Architecture13 and13 Planning13 at13 the13 University13 of13 Cincinnati13 13 I13 have13 published13 this13 text13 as13 an13 online13 archive13 because13 I13 believe13 that13 a13 creative13 society13 benefits13 from13 a13 culture13 of13 sharing13
ideas13 13 I13 invite13 others13 to13 take13 up13 this13 research13 and13 its13 related13 threads13 13 weaving13 new13 possibilities13 and13 outcomes13 for13 this13 work13 13
13 This13 work13 exists13 both13 in13 digital13 form13 and13 as13 a13 tangible13 book13
there13 are13 inevitable13 and13 fascinating13 differences13 13 across13 and13 within13 each13 of13 these13 diverse13 media13
In13 the13 digital13 form13 links13 are13 provided13 to13 guide13 readers13 to13 13 content13 both13 inside13 and13 outside13 of13 the13 text13
13 I13 welcome13 feedback13 comments13 and13 questions13 13 Contact13 me13 at13 samanthamesser11gmailcom13
samanthamesserartistcom13
RUNNINGampHEADampTheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
Abstract(
amp Inampthisampqualitativeampartsltinformedampcaseampstudyamptheampresearcherampexploresamphowamp
listeningamppracticesampcouldampbeampinfluentialampinamptheampstudyampandampteachingampofampartampandampartamp
educationampampGadamerrsquosamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamppracticesampinamp
educationalampcontextsampandampGendlinrsquosamptheoryampofampfeltampsenseampprovideampaampphilosophicalamp
foundationampforamptheampresearchampwhileampnarrativeampinquiryampphenomenologyampandampaamp
reflexiveampartamppracticeampinformamptheampmethodologyampandampmethodsampTheampconceptampofampcreative(
listening-space(theampsiteampinampwhichamplisteningamppracticesampareampembeddedampinampactsampofampmakingamp
andampviewingampworksampofampartampemergesampthroughamptheampanalyticampandampreflectiveampprocessesampofamp
theampstudyamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 2amp
Table(of(Contents(
Acknowledgementsampamp4amp
thread1ampIntroductionampamp5amp
amp CreativeltListeningampSpaceamp6amp
amp ResearchampIssueampamp7amp
amp BoundariesampandampLimitationsampofamptheampResearchampamp7amp
amp Dataampamp8amp
amp DearampReaderampTheampStructureampofampthisampPaperampamp9amp
thread2ampCollagingampExperienceampamp11amp
thread3ampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampamp14amp
thread4ampReviewampofamptheampLiteratureampamp15amp
amp HermeneuticsampampamptheampFusionampofampHorizonsampamp15amp
amp DialogicampPracticesampamp19amp
amp ContemplativeampPracticesampamp22amp
amp TheampFeltampSenseampamp26amp
thread5ampResearchampMethodologyampandampMethodsampamp30amp
amp CaseampStudiesampamp30amp
amp Phenomenologyampamp31amp
amp NarrativeampResearchampamp32amp
amp Methodsampamp33amp
thread6ampImmersedampinampDataampamp35amp
amp SurveyampResponsesampamp36amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 3amp
amp amp SurveyampThemesampamp37amp
amp CreativeltListeningampSpaceampCaseampStudiesampamp39amp
thread7ampRespondingamptoampResponseampLayersampofampListeningampUnderstandingampamp40amp
thread8amp(In)Conclusionsampamp47amp
looseampendsampReferencesampamp53amp
braidsampArtworkampReferencesampamp58amp
Appendixampamp61amp
amp
amp
amp
ampamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 4amp
Acknowledgements(
ThankampyouamptoampLaurenampNanditaampandampShannonampforampbeingampexcellentampwonderfulampartamp
educatorsampwhoampmakeampmyampworldampaampbetterampplaceampampYouampeachampteachampmeampnewampthingsampaboutamp
artampallamptheamptimeampandampIamploveampyouampforampitamp
ThankampyouamptoampDrampVittoriaampSampDaielloampforampbeingampanampexcellentamplistenerampampNoamponeampelseamp
wouldamphaveampencouragedampmyampweirdnessampinampsuchampspecificampwaysampampYouampareampmyamproleampmodelamp
Thankampyouamptoampmyampparentsampforamplettingampmeampbeampanampartistampandamphelpingampmeampwithampeverythingamp
ThankampyouamptoampPampforampgivingampmeamptheampbestampcritiquesampandampneveramplettingampmeampgetampawayampwithamp
anythingampampThankampyouampforamplettingampmeampcryampwheneverampIampwantampamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 5amp
(thread1(
The(Possibility(of(Possibilities(Creative=Listening(Spaces(in(Art(Education(
TheampartsampinampeducationampshouldampthusamprecognizeamppossibilitiesampthatampopenampnewamphorizonsampinampbothampformampandampsubstanceampampThisampisamptrueampnotamponlyampinamptheampartsampbutampalsoampinampeducationampinampitsampvariousampmanifestationsampampTheamppossibilitiesampofamptheampworkampofampartampmustampbeampcentralampmustampbeamphonoredampampIfampweampcanamphonoramptheampvisualamppoeticampandampgesturalamppossibilitiesampinamptheampartsampweamp
thenampcanampbeginamptoampunderstandamptheampopeningsampmadeampaccessibleampbyampamplivingampin-theampquestionsamp(Greeneamp2013amppamp252)amp
ampamp
amp CollageampholdsamphighampesteemampinampmyampcreativeamppracticeampampItampisampnotampthatampIampvalueampitsamp
visualampimpactampoverampotherampformsampofampmediaampnorampdoampIampenjoyampitampmoreampthanampotherampmodesampofamp
creativeampexpressionampampSimplyampputampcollageampisampusuallyampwhatampgetsampmeampunstuckampampItampisamptheamp
leverampIampuseamptoampfreeampmyselfampfromampaampdisappointingampdrawingampampInsteadampofamplaboringampoverampaamp
workamporampthrowingampawayampanampotherwiseampinoffensiveamppieceampofamppaperampIampuseampcollageampasampaamp
lastltditchampeffortamptoampmakeampsomethingltltanythingltltthatampIampdontamphaveamptoampstruggleampagainstampamp
Theampdrawingampisamptornampupamppaintedampoverampstapledampsewedamptogetherampcutampintoampstripsampandamp
wovenampampMaybeampitsampjustampthrownampinampmyampdrawerampofampsadampbadampdrawingsampthatampareampallamp
waitingampforamptheamprightampmomentamptoampbecomeampnewampampTheamppointampisampwhatampbeganampasampaampbadamp
drawingampandamppossiblyampaampbadamporampfrustratingampexperienceampdoesntamphaveamptoampremainampinampmyamp
mentalamparchiveampofampDrawings-That-Have-FailedampampInsteadamptheseampworksampareampsimplyamp
deconstructedampandampfoldedampintoampanotheramppossibilityampampCollageampengagesampwithamptheampactampofamp
layeringampandamptheampsenseampofampfearlessnessampgainedampwhenampIampholdampontoamptheampfactampthatampthereampisamp
alwaysampanotheramppossibilityampforampaampworkampamp
amp Theampphysicalampactampofamplayeringamphoweverampisampinampserviceamptoampaampdeeperampsenseampofamptheamp
wordampampWhenampweamparticulateamppowerfulampviewingampexperiencesampwordsampoftenampfailampusampampWeamp
mayampsayampthatampweampfeelampaampclickampaampconnectionamporampanampaestheticampexperienceampwhenampviewingampaamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 6amp
pieceampampTheseampareampwaysampweampexpressamptheampprelinguisticampfeltampdimensionsampofampbeingampwithampaamp
workampofampartampampTemporallyampthisamptakesampplaceampwithinampaampsingleampmomentampinamptimeampampButamp
meaningfulampencountersampwithampartampareamponlyampmeaningfulampbecauseamptheyampareampcomposedampofamp
countlessamppreviousampmomentsampwordsampexperiencesampknowledgeampconversationsamp
relationshipsampandampallamptheampminutiaampthatampconstituteampanampindividualsampidentityampampInampthisamp
conceptionampofampmeaningltmakingamptheamplayersampofampexperiencesampwithinamptheampindividualamptheamp
groupampandamptheampspacesampbetweenampareamprespectedampforamptheirampvalueampinamptheampformationampofamp
singularampandampcollectiveampidentitiesamp
amp Oftenampviewersampandampeducatorsampdiscussampinterpretativeampprocessesampfromamp
frameworksampsuchampasampaampworksamppositionampinampartamphistoryamptheampbiographyampofamptheampartistamp
socialampimplicationsampandampsoamponampampThereampisampaampparallelamptoampbeampfoundamphereampinamptheampdrawingamp
processampampIfampweamppresupposeampthatampthereampisampaampcorrectampwayamptoampinterpretampandampaampperfectamp
drawingamptoampbeamphadampweamprunamptheampriskampofampnotamptryingampforampfearampofampfailureampampItsampnoampstretchamptoamp
sayampthatampindividualsampwhoamplackampartsampexperienceampareamphesitantamptoampengageampwithampaampworkampofamp
artampforampfearampofampexposingamptheirampsupposedampignoranceampampOnamptheampotheramphandampifampweampengageampinamp
aampwayampofampviewingampthatampidentifiesampwithamptheampfluidityampofampcollageampweampcanampacknowledgeamp
possibilityampasampaampfeatureampofampinterpretationampampByampconceivingampofampinterpretationampasampaampformamp
ofampcollagingamptogetherampmeaningfulampexperiencesampviewersampcouldampgainampaccessamptoamptheamp
complexamplayeredampandampmessyampdimensionsampofampmeaningampwhenamptheyamplistenamptoampaampworkampofamp
artamp
Creative=Listening(Space(
amp Iampofferamptheamptermampcreative(listening-spaceampasampanampalternativeampmodeampofamp
experiencingampviewingampandampproducingampcreativeampworksampampInsteadampofampplacingampsubjectamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 7amp
matterampinformationamporamptheamproleampofamptheampeducatorampatamptheampcenterampofamptheseampexperiencesampIamp
proposeampthatampactsampofamplisteningampbeampembeddedampinampmakingampandampviewingampartampampTheamptermamp
creativeltlisteningampspaceamprefersamptoamptheampfluidampandampflexibleampspaceampinampwhichamplisteningamp
practicesampareampanampintegratedampessentialamppartampofampviewingampdiscussingampandampproducingamp
creativeampworksampampArtistsampviewersampstudentsampandampeducatorsampcanamptransformampartamp
classroomsampstudiosampandampsitesampofampviewingampartampintoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhichampareamp
notampdefinedampbyampphysicalampformamporampstructuralampboundariesampampRatheramptheyampareampdefinedampbyamp
specificamppracticesampthatampoccurampamongstampindividualsampandampgroupsampinamptheampcontextampofampartamp
educationampamp
Research(Issue(
amp Theampoverarchingampconcernampinampthisampresearchampisamptheamppotentialampoutcomeampforampusingamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampwithinampartampeducationampampTheamppracticesampIampdiscussamphereamphaveampinamp
commonampaampdistinctiveampflexibilityampandampmalleabilityampampTheyampmayampbeampadaptedamptoampvariousamp
ageampgroupsampeducationalampsitesampandampcontextsampampWhileampIampofferampsuggestionsampIampexpectampthatamp
theamppractitionersampwhoampwishamptoampuseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwillampdeviseamptheirampownamp
methodsampofampimplementationampbasedamponamptheirampspecificampneedsampandampcontextsampampThoughamptheamp
ideaampofampcreativeamplisteningampspacesampemergedampwithinampanampartsampeducationampcontextampampthisamp
conceptampmayampholdampvalueampforampotherampdisciplinesamp
Boundaries(and(Limitations(of(the(Research(
( Iampundertookampthisampresearchampinampfulfillmentampofampaampmastersampdegreeampinampartampeducationamp
atamptheampUniversityampofampCincinnatisampCollegeampofampDesignampArtampArchitectureampandampPlanningamp
(DAAP)ampampTheampresponsesampexperiencesampandampartworkampgeneratedampduringamptheampcourseampofamp
thisampprojectamphaveampoftenampcenteredamparoundampthatampinstitutionampwhichamphousesampaampprimarilyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 8amp
whiteampmiddleltamptoampupperltclassampstudentamppopulationamponampanampurbanampcampusampampIampamampaampwhiteamp
femaleamppursuingamphigherampeducationampampIampwantamptoampacknowledgeampthisamppositionalityampalongamp
withamptheamppersonalampbiasesampaamplifetimeampofampexperiencesamphasampaffordedamptoampmeampampOneampinternalamp
goalampthatampdevelopedampoveramptheampcourseampofampthisampworkampwasampaampcontinuedampconsistentampeffortamp
toampuncoverampandampinterrogateampmyampownampbiasesampasamptheyampmanifestedampampThoughampweampcanampneveramp
beampfreeamporamppureampofamptheseampbiasesampconstantampexaminationampofampthemamphasampbeenampmyampchosenamp
routeamptoampcounteringamptheiramppowerampandampinfluenceampamp
Iampamamppassionateampaboutamptheampmeaningfulamppossibilitiesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampInamprespectampofampmyampownamplimitationsampandampthoseampofampthisampworkamphoweverampIampwillampnotamp
claimampthatampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampareampfeasibleampwithinamptheampcontextampofampeveryamp
educationalampsettingampnorampthatampthisampwayampofampviewingampmakingampandampexperiencingampworksampofamp
artampisampmoreamporamplessampvalidampthanampothersampampRatherampIampsuggestamptheamppossibilityampofamplivingampinamp
possibilitiesampasampaampwayamptoampcultivateampmeaningfulampencountersampwithinampartampandampartamp
educationamp
Data(
amp ForampthisampresearchampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponampthreeampformsampofampdataamp
participantampsurveysampcaseampstudiesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampandampreflectiveamppracticeamp
formsampofampartmakingampallampcollectedampduringampaampfourltmonthampperiodampampToampgatherampparticipantamp
responsesampfromamptheampsurveysampandampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampreliedamponampaampmultitudeampofamp
friendsamppeersampandampcolleaguesampampIampconnectedampwithamptheampmajorityampofamptheseampindividualsamp
duringamporampasampaampresultampofampmyampexperiencesampatampDAAPampampampIampusedamp37ampsurveyampresponsesampaboutamp
listeningampexperiencesampwithampaampparticipantampageamprangeampofamp14amptoamp47ampampParticipantsamp
educationalamplevelsampspannedamphighampschoolamptoampgraduateampschoolampampIamppersonallyampsolicitedamptheamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 9amp
majorityampofamptheamplisteningampsurveysampatamptheampcollegeamplevelampandampaboveampampTheampbulkampofamptheamphighamp
schoolltagedampresponsesampwereampsolicitedampbyampmyampcolleagueampaampphotographyampteacherampatampaamp
Cincinnatiltareaamphighampschoolamp
amp Iampconductedampfiveampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampexperiencesampwithampsixampindividualsampasamp
partampofampthisampresearchampagainampusingampmanyampofamptheamppersonalampandampprofessionalampconnectionsamp
cultivatedampthroughamptheampDAAPampprogramampampIampdeliberatelyampchoseamppeopleampwithampwhomampIamphadamp
variousamplevelsampandamptypesampofamprelationshipsampampIampwillampspeakampmoreampinltdepthampaboutamptheseamp
experiencesampasampwellampasampexploreamptheampsurveyampresponsesampinamptheampResearchampMethodologyamp
andampMethodsampsectionamp
amp Lastlyamptheampdevelopmentampofampanampartmakingamppracticeampwasampessentialamptoampmyampownamp
personalampunderstandingampofamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatampcomposedampmyampresearchamp
ReadersampwillampnoticeampthatampimagesampareampembeddedampinampthisamptextampampTheseampareampimagesampofamptheamp
resultingampproductsampofampaamppracticeampofampunderstandingampthroughampmakingampampIampwillampdiscussamp
themampthroughoutampvariousampsectionsampofampthisamppaperampampamp
Dear(Reader(The(Structure(of(this(Research(Paper(
DearampReader(s)amp
amp Letampmeampbreakampforampaampmomentampfromampstandardampacademicamprhetoricampbeforeampthisamp
paperampreallyampgetsampstartedampampIampknowampwhatampyoureampthinkingltltnineamppagesampinampandampthisamppaperamp
hasntampevenampstartedampyetampampAlasampthisampsectionampisampmyamponeampofampmyampfavoriteampandampmostampoftlt
skimmedamppassagesampofampanampacademicamppaperamptheampstructureampofamptheamppaperampampThisampisamptheamppartamp
whereamptheampwriterampsaysampwhatampshesampaboutamptoampsayampbeforeampsheampsaysampitampampampItsampanamp
organizationalampstrategyampandampitsampthrillingampampLuckilyampforampyouampniceamppersonampwhoampisamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 10amp
readingampthisamppaperampIamphaveampprovidedampaamptranslationampfromampthisamptextsamporiginalampAcademiaamp
intoampnormalltpeopleltlanguageamp
amp Theampstructureampofampthisamppaperampisampasampfollowsampamp(Im-about-to-tell-you-whats-in-this-
long-ass-paper)ampampFirstlyamppleaseampnoteampthatampIampuseamptheamptermampthreadampinamplieuampofampchapteramp
asampanamporganizationalampstructureampIamppreferamptheampformerampbecauseampofamphowampitsampconceptualamp
qualitiesamprelateamptoampmyampworkampamp(Thread-is-awesome-and-you-can-do-tons-of-stuff-with-it-
like-sew-knot-tie-weave-etc--Chapters-are-not-nearly-as-exciting)--Iampwillampfirstampshareamp
myampresearchersampreflexiveampnarrativeampamp(I-made-up-a-cool-story-about-this-project-to-
describe-where-it-all-came-from)ampampThenampIampshallampofferampaampdescriptionampofamptheampqualitiesampofampaamp
creativeltlisteningampspaceampamp(Yes-I-shall)ampampIampwillampdiscussamptheampliteratureampthatampinformsamptheamp
backboneampofampmyampresearchampGadamersamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamp
practicesampandampGendlinsamptheampfeltampsenseampamp(Like-a-typical-graduate-student-I-have-done-
an-insane-amount-of-reading-during-the-past-two-academic-years--A-significant-
portion-of-this-reading-has-been-dedicated-to-those-topics--Dont-ask-me-to-type-them-
out-again-because-Im-seriously-done)ampampTheseampsectionsampbeginampwithampaamppassageampderivedamp
fromampsurveyampresponsesampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampamp(I-got-a-bunch-of-people-to-fill-
out-surveys-for-this-research-and-then-I-put-those-responses-in-my-paper)ampampTheseamp
experiencesampwithamplisteningampwereampprovidedampbyampresearchampparticipantsampamp(Super-nice-
people-I-know-and-some-I-dont-helped-me-out)ampampTheyampareampthereamptoampgroundamptheamp
conceptualampframeworksampinamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampamp(This-basically-means-
none-of-this-research-is-worth-shit-unless-it-can-be-used-in-the-real-world((I-hope-youll-
agree)ampampIampwillampthenampshareampmyampresearchampmethodologyampandampmethodsampamp(Im-going-to-tell-
you-about-how-and-why-I-did-this-project-in-using-big-smart(sounding-words)ampampLastlyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 11amp
Iampwillampconcludeampwithamppossibilitiesampforampthisampresearchampamp(Ill-figure-out-what-I-learned-and-
share-it-with-you-my-new-best-friend-who-made-it-all-the-way-to-the-conclusions-
section)ampampInampthisamppaperampreadersampwillampnoticeamptransparentampimagesampinteractingampwithamptheamp
textampamp(Its-my-art-on-transparent-sheets-in-this-very-paper)ampampTheseampareampworksampofampartamp
thatampIampcreatedamptoampgroundamptheampresearchampinampaamppracticeampofampmakingamptheyampareamptheampphysicalamp
embodimentampofampconceptualampideasampandamptheyampareampalwaysamppresentamptoamptheampresearchampamp
(Research-papers-with-pictures-are-much-more-tolerable-am-I-right)amp
amp Hereampweampgoamp
amp
thread2(
Collaging(Experience1(
amp ImagineampthatampyouampareampanampartistampseatedampatampyourampstudioamptableampampYouamphaveamp
everythingampyouampneedampampTheamproomampisampquietampsaveampforamptheampmuffledampsoundsampofampaampdistantamp
outsideampworldampampYouampsurveyamptheampcollectionampofampimagesampyouamphaveampgatheredamparoundampyouampamp
OnampyouramprightampisampaampraggedamppageampfromampanampoldampsketchbookampampGlossyampjewellttonedampswatchesamp
fromampaampdiscardedampfashionampmagazineampareampstackedampupampglisteningampinamptheamplightampampMonthsamp
agoampyouamppickedampupampaamphandfulampofampblackampandampwhiteampphotosampfromampaampsecondhandampstoreamp
todayamppastyampfacesampofamptheampunknownampsubjectsampstareampthroughampyouampblanklyampampAamppaleampyellowamp
scrapampofampleftoverampfabricampisampdrapedampoveramplastampweeksamppleatedamptoltdoamplistampampTheseampandamptwoamp
dozenampotherampscrapsamppiecesamppilesampandampcrumbsampareampyouramptoolsamptodayampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampamp1ampThisampsectionampisampsupposedamptoampbeampmyampresearchersampreflexiveampnarrativeampaamppassageampaboutampwhereampmyampresearchampideasampcameampfromltltandampinampfactampcollageampisampactuallyampwhereampthisampideaampcomesampfromampampOneampofamptheampfirstampresearchampinterestsampIampdiscussedampwithampmyampprofessorampDrampKristopherampHollandampwasamplayersampbothampphysicalampandampconceptualampampHeampwasamplikeampOhampampYoureamptalkingampaboutamphermeneuticsampSoampinampaampwayampthisampresearchampprojectampbothampbeganampandampconcludedamp(moreamponampthatamplater)ampwithampideasampofamplayeringampandampcollageampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 12amp
amp TheampresidueampthatampclingsamptoamptheseampscrapsampisampexperienceampampTheampoldampsketchbookamp
pageampisampanampimageampofampaampwomansamplegamprenderedampwithampchunkyamppencilampstrokesampampYouampmadeampitamp
whenampyouampwereamplivingampinampyourampoldampapartmentampoverlookingamptheampsquareampampItsampaampwomansamp
footampbutampitampremindsampyouampofamphavingampaamproommateampandampaampgrayampfutonampandampaampsummerampthatamp
wasampdesperatelyamphotampampItampisamponlyamppencilamponamppaperampbutampitampremindsampyouampofamptheampgreenamp
grassyampcenterampinamptheampmedianampofamptheampstreetampampOneamppencilampdrawingampofampaampwomansamplegamp
remindsampyouampofampthatampoldamplifeampandamptheampversionampofampyourselfampyouampwereampthenampitampisamptheampfirstamp
dominoampinampaampseriesampofampcascadingampdetailsampandampmemoriesampamp
amp EachampfragmentampsittingamponampyourampstudioamptableamphasampaampstoryampampEachampcameampfromampaamp
placeampandampwasamptouchedampbyampanotheramphumanampampEachampisampembeddedampwithampexperienceampcoloramp
memoryamptextureampandampinfiniteampdetailampbyamptheampmereampfactampofampitsampownampexistenceampamp
amp YouampbeginamptoamppickampapartamptheampephemeraampampYouampalternateampbeingampcarefulampandamp
carelessamp
amp Cuttingamptearingampburningampstretchingampfoldingampwhitewashingamprippingampcreasingamp
sewingampwritingamppaintingampencasingampfasteningampfillingampsoakingampdyeingampwashingamp
dryingampbitingampscratchingamppryingampyankingampsmoothingampsandingamppokingampstabbingamp
stretchingampfryingampheatingampdustingampcleaningampsculptingampslicingampdicingamppunchingamp
floatingamptwistingampflippingampdrippingampstaplingampstrippingampstripingamppatterningamp
designingampdrawingampsketchingampliftingampcollectingamptapingampgluingampbuttoningampknottingamp
weavingampknittingamp
amp YouampdoampallampofamptheseampthingsampandampprobablyampmanyampotherampthingsampampTheampfragmentsamponamp
youramptableampchangeampshapeampandampgetampsmallerampampFromamptheseamppiecesampyouampbeginamptoampbuildamp
somethingampampThisampsomethingampisampbothampnewampandampoldampampJuxtapositionsampbloomampnewamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 13amp
connectionsampareampfusedampbyamptheampweightampofamppreviousampexperienceampampPastampandamppresentamp
liquefyampintoampendlesslyampcirculatingamppossibilitiesampampYouampcouldamptheoreticallyampcontinueampthisamp
processampofamplayeringampandampreconstructionampforeverampamptheamponlyamplimitsampareampyourampownamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 14amp
thread3(
what(is(a(creative=listening(space(
ampampampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeamplisteningampspaceampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampwhatampdoesampitampsoundampsmellamptasteampfeelamplikeampampampampampampampwhatampampisampamptheampamptextureampampofampampthisampampamp
spaceampampampanswerampmoreampquestionsampampamp specificsampandampgeneralizationsampareampbothampimpossibleampampmaybeampaampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampgoodampstartampwouldampbeampthisampampamp amp amp amp amp safeampampampamp amp amp amp amp foldedampampamp amp amp amp amp amp embodiedampamp layeredampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampconnectedampampampamp amp ampamp
(it-might--be-like-gently-holding-on-to--
a-knot-of-questions)-amp
ampampampampampampampampampamp
(possible)ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 15amp
thread4amp(
Review(of(Literature((
( AnampexplorationampofampGadamerrsquosamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampeducationalampcontextsampandampGendlinrsquosamptheoryampofampfeltampsenseampwereampintegralamptoamp
theampcreationampofamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampWhileampcompellingampconstructsamponamp
theirampownampwhenampdrawnamptogetheramptheseampphilosophicalampperspectivesampvibrateamp
holisticallyamptoampsuggestampintriguingamppossibilitiesampforamptheampuseampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
inampartsampeducationampampInampthisampsectionampIampreviewamptheampliteratureampandampconnectamptheampvariousamp
pointsampofampstudyampampamp
Hermeneutics(amp(the(Fusion(of(Horizons((
It-actually-feels-really-great-knowing-that-other-people-will-enjoy-the-art-you-created-and-knowing-they-know-your-reasoning-and-story-behind-it--Honestly-you-cant-know-if-your-words-are-getting-through-to-them-but-the-cool-thing-about-art-is-that-it-can-be-
interpreted-in-so-many-different-ways---(Survey-response-EK-age-15)-
ampamp Hermeneuticsampwhichamphasampitsamprootsampinamptextualampinterpretationampcanampbeampdefinedampasamp
aamptraditionampofampthinkingamporampofampphilosophicalampreflectionampthatamptriesamptoampclarifyamptheampconceptamp
ofampverstehenampthatampisampunderstandingamp(Brunsamp1992)ampampRicoeuramp(19691974)ampexplainsamp
thatamptheampkeyamphypothesisampofamphermeneuticampphilosophyampisampthatampinterpretationampisampanampopenamp
processampwhichampnoampsingleampvisionampcanampconcludeamp(pamp109)ampampWithampthisampinampmindampIampwillamp
exploreamphermeneuticsampasampitampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp HansltGeorgampGadameramp(1900lt2002)ampinvestigatesampaampmoderateampformampofamp
hermeneuticsampthatampisampparticularlyamprelevantampinampserviceamptoampartampeducationampampGadameramp
breaksampwithamphermeneuticamptraditionampbyampproposingampthatampthereampisampnoampabsolutelyampobjectiveamp
interpretationampreadersampareampnotampableamptoampescapeamptheampprejudicesampofamptheiramptimeamp(Gallagheramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 16amp
1992)ampampThisamphoweverampbecomesampanampopportunityampforamptheampcreationampofampmeaningampInampaamp
passageampthatampechoesamptheampendlesslyampunfoldingampnatureampofampcollageampCaputoamp(2000)amprefersamp
toampanampexchangeampbetweenamppastampandamppresentampinamptheampcreativeamppossibilitiesampofamphermeneuticamp
interpretationamp
amp Thereampisampaamprichnessampinamphistoricalampeventsampthatampjustampkeepsampunfoldingampwhichampisamp
amp certainlyampnotampgraspedampbyamptheamporiginalampprotagonistsampwhichampgraduallyampunfoldsamp
amp overamptheampcourseampofamptimeampandampwhichampisampinampprincipleampneverampfullyampunfoldedampItampisamp
amp anampexcessampwhichampkeepsampspillingampoveramp(pamp47)amp
amp Gadamersampphilosophyampofamphermeneuticampunderstandingampisampformedampthroughamphisamp
notionsampaboutamplanguageampdialogueampandampconversationamp(Caputoamp2000ampSeebohmamp2004)ampamp
InampadditionamptoampGadamersampimplicitamprelianceamponamplisteningampasampheampdiscussesampdialogueamphisamp
workampcapitalizesamponamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampinamplanguageamp(Heelanamp1985)ampmakingamphisamp
formampofamphermeneuticsampparticularlyampapplicableamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp Gadamersamptermampfusion-of-horizonsamprefersamptoamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampwithinampaamp
varietyampofampencountersampampAampfusionampofamphorizonsampcanampbeampdescribedampasampaampdialogicamp
conversationampbetweenampreaderampandamptextamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampWithinamptheamptextualamp
paradigmampGadamerampbelievesampthatampaampwrittenamptextampisampopenamptoampanampinvisibleampandampindefiniteamp
readerampwhoampentersampintoampanampunknownampadventureampofamptheamptextamp(Ricoeuramp2013amppamp13)ampamp
Theamphorizonampitselfampisamptheamprangeampofampvisionampthatampincludesampeverythingampthatampcanampbeampseenamp
fromampaampparticularampvantageamppointamp(Gadameramp2004amppamp301)ampampLikeampcollageamptheampfusionampofamp
horizonsampisampaampprocessampcomposedampofamppastampandamppresentampwhichampareampopenamptoampandampinfinitelyamp
effectedampbyampeachampotheramp(Bourgeoisamp2007)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 17amp
amp Similarampconnectionsampcanampbeampdrawnampwhenampviewerampandampartworkampareampsubstitutedamp
forampreaderampandamptextampampInterpretationampandampunderstandingampbecomeampanampentwinedamp
creativeampendeavorampinampwhichamptheampviewerampparticipatesampasampmuchampasamptheampcreatorampbyamp
constructingampmeaningamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampPalmeramp(1969)ampalludesamptoamptheamppluralityampofamp
meaningampinampstatingampthatamptoampfocusamppurelyamponamptheamppositivityampofampwhatampaamptextampexplicitlyamp
saysampisamptoampdoampanampinjusticeamptoamptheamphermeneuticalamptaskamp(pamp234)ampampToampfocusamponampwhatampisamp
explicitampinampaampcollageampworkampwouldampbeamptoampdisregardamptheampconnectionsampandampcontradictionsamp
ofamptheampwholeampinampfavorampofampaampdirectampreadingampofamptheampindividualamppartsampthusampmissingampoutamponamp
otheramppossibleampdimensionsampofampmeaningamp
amp Theampkeyamptoamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampeducationampinamptextampandampbetweenamp
individualsampisamptheampabilityamptoamplistenampwithampopennessampampDefensiveamplisteningampisampaampwayampofamp
listeningampwithoutampopennessampitampisampaampwayampofampprotectingampourampsmallampversionampofamptheampworldamp
andampavoidingampmoralampclaimsamponampourselvesamp(Levinamp1989amppamp79)ampampLevinamp(1989)amp
discussesampplayfulamplisteningamp(pamp233)ampasampaampwayampofampcounteractingampdefensiveamplisteningampampamp
Bohmamp(1996)ampdiscussesampsuspendingampassumptionsampaampprocessampofampattendingamptoamp
assumptionsampratherampthanamprepressingampthemamporampcarryingampthemampoutampampNicholamp(1996)amp
explainsampaampcircumstanceampinampwhichampyouampencounterampaamppersonampyouampfeelampisampanampidiotampampampYouamp
wouldamprefrainampfromampsayingampsoampoutamploudampbutampyouampwouldampalsoamprefrainampfromampscoldingamp
yourselfampforampthisampthoughtampratherampyouampwouldampseeampthisampreactionampwithoutampfullyampengagingamp
withampitampampSimilarampsuggestionsamplikeampbracketingampofampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampareamp
discussedampinamptheampfollowingampsectionampamp
amp Gadamerampbelievesamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampwhatampallowsamptheampselfamptoampapproachamp
theampotherampitampisampaampprocessampinampwhichamptheampideasampofamptheampotherampbecomeamponesampownamp(Caputoamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 18amp
2000)ampampThisampisamphardlyampanampuncommonampexperienceampampInampfactampweampregularlyampencounteramptheamp
fusionampofamphorizonsampbyampintegratingamppastampunderstandingsampwithampcurrentampexperiencesampaamp
processampundoubtedlyampcomparableamptoampeducationamp(Zuckertamp2002)ampamp
amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsamplikeampeducationampcanampbeampfrustratingampandampemotionalamp
becauseampeachamphighlight[s]amptheampfinitudeampofamptheampinterpreterampandamptheamplimitationsampofamphisamp
understandingamp(Bourgeoisamp2007amppamp79)ampampTheamptermampsharesampsimilaritiesampwithamptheamp
problematic-momentampaamppedagogicalamptermampreferringamptoampaampbreachampinampaampdominantampgroupsamp
discourseampduringampwhichampsomethingamprepressedamparisesamp(KentampampampCummingamp2008)ampampKentamp
andampCummingamp(2008)ampexploreamptheampproblematicampmomentampasampaampdiscursiveampsiteampforamp
examiningampprejudiceampwithinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampandampitsamp
moreamppoliticallyampchargedampcounterpartamptheampproblematicampmomentampbothampexploreamp
Gadamersamp(1996)ampampassertionampthatamptheampotherampmayampnotamponlyamphaveampaamprightampbutampmayamp
actuallyampbeamprightampmayampunderstandampsomethingampbetterampthanampweampdoamp(pamp82)ampampAampcreativelt
listeningampspaceamplivesampinampthisamppossibilityampampamp
amp Lastlyamprelayingampofampappropriateampexpectationsamptoampparticipantsampisampaampnecessaryamp
featureampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampdemandingampampItamp
requiresampparticipantsampwhoampareampawareampofamptheamprisksampandamphardshipsamptoampenterampintoampitampampItamp
isamptheampresponsibilityampofamptheampeducatoramporampgroupampleaderamptoampmakeamptheseampexpectationsamp
knownampasampwellampasamptoampmodelampthisampbehaviorampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionamphermeneuticallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Areampopenamptoamppossibilitiesampandamptoamptheampotherampbull Conceiveampofampthemselvesampasampengagingampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamptheamprisksampinvolvedampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamplimitationsampofamptheirampunderstandingamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 19amp
Dialogic(Practices(-
I-felt-that-everyone-was-open-and-interested-in-what-I-had-to-say---Perhaps-I-felt-this-sense-of-understanding-due-to-the-nature-of-the-discussion((-
it-felt-[like]-more-[of]-a-dialogue-as-opposed-to-a-standard-critique-(Survey-response-MW-age-22)-
(amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampartampeducationampreliesamponampanampopenampdialogueampduringamp
experiencesampwithampartampselfampandampothersampampWhatampIampfoundamplackingampinamphermeneuticsamp
howeverampwasampaampdiscussionampofamptheamphowltlthowampisamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampachievedampandamp
howampdoampindividualsampmeaningfullyampengageampwithampeachampotherampampInampanampeffortamptoampclarifyampthisamp
Iampwillampdiscussampdialogicamppracticesampasamptheyamprelateamptoampmeaningfulampverbalampexchangesampandamp
listeningampencountersampinamptheampclassroomampandampstudioampamongstampstudentsamptheiramppeersampandamp
educatorsamp
amp Communicatingampthroughamplanguageampandampdialogueampisamphowampweampcoltconstructamp
worldsampwithampourselvesampandampothersampnotampjustampthroughampanampactampofamptransmissionampbutamp
becauseampourampcommunicativeampactsampgiveampbirthamptoampworldsamp(Lipariamp2014amppamp507)ampampSableamp
(2014)ampdescribesampdialogueampasampaampgenerativeampinterchangeampbetweenampparticipantsampasamp
opposedamptoampanampexchangeampofampviewsampwhereampindividualsampsimplyampadvocateamptheiramppositionsamp
(pamp8)ampampForampBohmamp(1996)ampitampisampaampstreamampofampmeaningampflowingampamongampandampthroughampusamp
(pamp6)ampampTheampnatureampofampdialogueampandampconversationampisampinherentlyampunplannedampampThisamp
dimensionampofampconversationampisampimportantamptoampGadameramp(2004)ampwhoampfindsampthatamp
participantsampinvolvedampinampconversationampareamplessamptheampleadersampofampitampthanamptheampledamp(pamp
385)ampampSableamp(2014)ampechoesampthisampbyampwritingampthatamptheampmostampimportantamppartsampofampanyamp
conversationampareampthoseampthatampneitheramppartyampcouldamphaveampimaginedampbeforeampstartingamp(pamp
8)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 20amp
amp Theseampareampnotionsampofampdialogueampamongampothersampthatampfindampaampparallelampinamptheamp
creativeampprocessampampFairfieldamp(2011)ampwritesampthatampinampprincipleampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinamp
dialogueamp(pamp83)ampaampsentimentampthatampalignsampwithampaampcommonampissueampencounteredampduringamp
theampcreativeampprocessltltnotampknowingampwhenampaamppieceampisampdoneampampAampquoteampoftenampattributedamp
toampLeonardoampdaampVinciampspeaksamptoampthisampideaampArtampisampneverampfinishedamponlyampabandonedampamp
Snowberamp(2007)ampdrawsampparallelsampbetweenampmentorshipampdialogueampandamptheampcreativeamp
processampfindingampthatampdeepamplisteningamppracticesampconnectampallampthreeampampSheampfindsampthatamptheamp
taskampofamptheampmentorampisamptheampsameampasamptheamptaskampofamptheampartistampthatampisamptoampbringampoutamptheamp
naturalampqualitiesampofamptheampstudentamporamptheampmediumampampSnowberamp(2007)ampcommentsamponampanamp
ideaampwellltknownampamongampartistsampwhichampisampthatampaampworkampofampartamphasampaamplifeampofampitsampownampthisamp
notionampisampreminiscentampofampGadamersampstatementampaboutampbeingampledampbyampconversationamp
ampamp Dialogicamppracticesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampeducationampemphasizeampaamp
phenomenologicalampdimensionamprequiringamptwoampthingsampfromampparticipantsampampFirstlyamp
participantsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampmustampfindampvalueampinamplisteningamptoamptheamp
narrativesampofamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampampTheseampparticipantsampknowampthatampeducationamp
isampforemostampaboutamptestimonyampaboutampsharingamptheampexperienceampofampbeingamphumanampsharingamp
lifeampconvictionsampandampknowledge((Wiercinskiamp2011amppamp109)ampampNarrativesampareamp
conceivedampofampasampaampwayampofamphumanampknowingamp(Vitanovaamp2010amppamp29)ampthatampmakesamptheamp
selfampampSecondlyampwhenamplisteningamptoamptheampnarrativesampofampothersampparticipantsampareampexpectedamp
toampbracketamptheirampownampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsamp(LindsethampampampNorbergamp2004)ampampThisamp
encouragesamplistenersamptoampexperienceampandampfindampmeaningampinamptheampnarrativesampofampothersamp
whileampfreeingamptheampspeakerampfromamptheampfearampofampbeingampjudgedampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 21amp
amp Bracketingampjudgmentampandampconclusionampisampaamppotentialamptoolampwithinamptheampcommonamp
artampeducationamppracticeampofampgroupampcritiquesampampElkinsamp(2001)ampfindsampthatamppeopleampwhoamphaveamp
experienceampinampartampjudgeampveryampquicklyampandampmostampteachersampwillamphaveampaampprovisionalamp
opinionampaboutampaampworkampinamptheampfirstamptenampsecondsamp(pamp121)ampampBracketingampconclusionampandamp
judgmentampisampparticularlyampimportantampforampeducatorsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
whoseampvolumeampofampviewingampexperiencesampcouldampleadamptoampeasyampassumptionsampwhenamp
encounteringampaampnewampworkampampamp
amp Elkinsamp(2001)ampdiscussesampthatampcritiquesampcanampalsoampbeampseenampasampexchangesampofamp
storiesamporampcollaborativeampstorytellingamp(pamp145)ampwhichampisampyetampanotherampwayampofamptalkingamp
aboutamppossibilitiesampforampdialogueampandampnarrativeampwithinampartampeducationampampElkinsamphoweveramp
findsampstorytellingamplimitingamponceamptheampdeeperampnarrativesampareampdiscoveredamp(2001amppamp
145)ampampThisampimpliesampthatampheampfindsamponlyampaampsingularampmeaningampandamponeampthatampisampnotamp
necessarilyampusefulampforampcollaborativeampgroupampcritiquesamp
amp Insteadampparticipantsampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampbringampknowledgeampofamp
polysemyamptoampcollaborativeampcritiqueampexperiencesampasampwellampasamptoampexperiencesampofampmakingamp
artworkampampAccordingamptoampMuldoonamp(2002)amppolysemyampisamptheampqualityampofampaampwordamporampotheramp
languageampunitampthatampcanampbearampmultipleampmeaningsamp(asampcitedampinampWorsleyamp2012amppamp308)ampampamp
Aamptextualampexampleampofampthisampisamptheampmultipleampmeaningsampofamptheampwordampcan-Iampcanampdriveampaampcaramp
Idamplikeampaampcan-ofampsodaampheampwasntampworkingampveryamphardampsoampIamphadamptoampcan-himamp(Munozamp
2014)ampampampButampifampweampconsideramppolysemyampmetaphoricallyamporampvisuallyamptheampideaampthatampaamp
singleampunitampimageamporampintentionampcouldampbearampmultipleampmeaningsampcouldampbeampproductiveampinamp
creatingltlisteningampspacesampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 22amp
amp Thisampunfoldingampofampmeaningampworksampwellampinamptheampcontextampofampcollageampandampdialogueamp
asampwellampasamphermeneuticsampampInampfactamphermeneuticsampimpliesamppolysemyampbecauseampofampitsamp
notionampthatampitampisampalwaysampaamppossibilityampofampmyampunderstandingampthatampisampplayedampoutampwhenampIamp
understandampaamptextamp(Grondinamp2002amppamp38)ampampPolysemyampcouldampbeampconceptualizedampasampanamp
alternativeampexplorationampofampmeaningampthatampfunctionsampcollaborativelyampwithinampcritiquesampamp
Forampexampleampeducatorsampcanampaskampstudentsamptoamprespondamptoampaampworkampthroughampcollageamp
journalampentriesampmusicampfilmampasampindividualsamporampinampgroupsampampKnowledgeampofamppolysemyamp
couldampalsoampbeampusedampasampaamptoolampforampcreatingampimagesampthatamprecognizesampaamprelationshipamp
betweenamptheampvisualamptheamplinguisticampandamptheampmultipleamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionampdialogicallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Placeampvalueamponampexperientialampnarrativesampbull Practiceamplisteningampbyampbracketingampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampbull Embraceamppolysemicampexplorationsampofampmeaningampamp
Contemplative(Practices(
I-knew-I-was-being-heard-because-of-her-mannerisms-and-the-look-on-her-face--She-was-calm-attentive-and-not-trying-to-jump-in-and-offer-any-advice--She-asked-questions-that-pointed-to-things-I-had-not-openly-articulated-because-of-uncertainty--
This-was-one-of-the-ways-I-knew-I-was-being-heard-(Survey-response-LS-age-27)-
(amp Ifamphermeneuticsampandampdialogicamppracticesampgiveampusamptheampbroadampstrokesampofampactivityampinamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampcontemplativeamppracticesampseekamptoamptuneampstudentsampandamp
educatorsampintoampnuanceampdeliberationampandampdeepampexplorationampampThisampisampaampmostlyamp
individualampinternalamppursuitampthatampfocusesamponampformsampofampselfltlisteningampbutampcontemplativeamp
practicesampareampalsoampformedampbyampanampawarenessampofampinterconnectednessamp
amp InamppursuitampofampcriticalampthinkingampSableamp(2014)ampoutlinesampaampsetampofampcontemplativeamp
practicesampforampstudentsampthatampincludeampmindfulampmeditationampstructuredampcontemplationamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 23amp
journalampwritingampmindfulamplisteningampreflectiveampinquiryampandampdialogueamp(pamp4)ampampWhileamp
Sablesamp(2014)ampmethodampforampcontemplativeamppracticesampprovidesampaampconcreteampframeworkamp
withampspecificampstepsampmanyampofamptheseampconceptsampcouldampbeampappliedampwithoutampsuchampaamp
prescribedampstructureampampForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwillampbeamp
primarilyampdiscussingampSablesampconceptsampofampstructuredampcontemplationampreflectiveamp
inquiryampandampjournalampwritingamp
amp ForampSableamp(2014)ampstructuredampcontemplationampisampaampformampofampbeingamppresentampandamp
focusedamponampaampparticularampquestionampstatementamporampimageampampWithinampthisampmodeampofampinquiryamp
participantsampareampexpectedamptoampholdamptheampobjectampofampcontemplationampinamptheirampmindsamp
deepeningampunderstandingampasamptheyampfocusampwithoutampanalyzingampitamporampmanipulatingampitampinamp
anyampwayamp(pamp5)ampampThisamppracticeampdrawsampcomparisonsamptoamptheampbracketingampofampjudgmentsamp
andampconclusionsampsupportedampinamptheamppreviousampsectionampbutampstructuredampcontemplationamp
occursamponampanampindividualamplevelampratherampthanampdialogicallyamp
amp Reflectiveampinquiryampbearsampsomeampsimilaritiesamptoampstructuredampcontemplationampbutamp
Sableamp(2014)amppositionsampitampasampanampactivityampbetweenamptwoampindividualsampaamplistenerampandampaamp
speakerampampTheamplistenerampisampagainampaskedamptoampsuspendampjudgmentampbutampalsoamptoampengageampinampaamp
formampofampcuriosityampinampwhichampinnocentampquestionsampareampaskedampinamporderamptoampgainamp
understandingampampSableamp(2014)ampcontrastsampinnocentampquestionsampwithampleadingampquestionsampamp
ForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwouldampcharacterizeampthisampinnocentamp
questioningampasampaampformampofampopenltendedampquestioningampampSableamp(2014)ampidentifiesampanamp
exampleampofampanampinnocentamp(orampopenltended)ampquestionampWhatampdidampyouampmeanampwhenampyouamp
saidamp________ampConverselyampaampleadingampquestionampisampDidampyouampmeanamptoampsayamp________ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 24amp
amp Sableamp(2014)ampusesampjournalampwritingampasampaamppieceampofamphisamplargerampstructureampofamp
contemplativeamppracticesampbutampjournalampwritingampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampcouldamp
potentiallyampoccupyampaampsignificantamproleampampIampconceiveampofampjournalampwritingampinampmyampownamp
creativeamppracticeampasampaampformampofampdocumentationampthatampmakesampmeampmoreampawareampofampmyamp
creativeampprocessamptheampemotionalamphabitsampthatampsurroundampitampandamptheampthemesampthatamp
structureampmyampworkampampIampconceptualizeampthisampwayampofampwritingampasampaampformampofampselfltlisteningamp
relatedamptoampaampkeyampconceptampofamphermeneuticsampfoundampinampGadamersampassertionampthatampallamp
educationampisampaampformampofampselflteducationamp(Grondinamp2011)ampampamp
amp Germeraadamp(2013)ampusesampjournalampwritingamptoampexploreamptheampemotionalampandamprationalamp
relationshipsamptoamphisampcreativeampprocessampparallelamptoampexecutingampaampnewampbodyampofampworkampampHeamp
findsampthatampwritingampduringamphisampprocessampisampaamptoolamptoampunderstandamp[his]amppsycheamptoampeaseamp
theamppainampthatampanampartisticampprocessampcanampbringampandamptoamprelieveampartisticampblocksamp
(Germeraadamp2013amppamp21)ampultimatelyampdeclaringampthatampitamphelpsamphimamptoampbetterampunderstandamp
hisampworkampampInampaampstyleampofampwritingampthatamposcillatesamparoundampjournalingampdocumentationampandamp
poetryampdeampCossonamp(2002)ampexploresamphisampoverlappingamprolesampasampanampartistampresearcherampandamp
teacherampampOtherampartistsampbluramptheamplineampbetweenampartamppracticeampdocumentationampandamplifeamp
furtherampstillampbyampofferingampdocumentationampasampartamplikeampSophieampCalleamp(Calleamp2011amp2008amp
2005)ampandampMaryampKellyamp(1973lt1979)ampampamp
amp Karpiakamp(2003)ampestablishesampcontemplativeamppracticesampfromamptheampperspectiveampofamp
theampeducatorampaskingampthemamptoampmineamptheampsubtleamp(pamp71)ampusingampattentivenessamp
attunementampamplificationampandampassociationampampTheseampexercisesampinampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampsetamptheamptoneampasampwellampasampprovideampaampmodelampofampbehaviorampforampotherampparticipantsamp
withinamptheampspaceampampKarpiakamp(2003)ampoutlinesampactivitiesampthatampeducatorsampcanampuseamptoampdrawamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 25amp
outampandamputilizeamptheseampsubtleampsensationsampinamptheampserviceampofamptransformativeamplearningamp(pamp
68)ampampamp
amp ForampKarpiakamp(2003)ampattentivenessamprequiresampawarenessamptoampverbalampandamp
nonverbalampcuesampasampwellampasampanampawarenessampofampwhatampisamphappeningampamongampandampwithinamptheamp
studentsampandamptheampeducatorampampAttunementamprequiresampanampeducatoramptoamporientampherselfamptoamptheamp
otherampandamptoampadoptampanampattitudeampofampunhurriednessampofamppatienceampandampofamphumilityamp
concerningampbothamptheampprocessampandamptheampoutcomesampofamptheampteachingamp(Karpiakamp2003amppgamp
72)ampampAmplificationampisampaampprocessampofamphonoringampcommunicationampthatampcentersamponamptheampideaamp
ofamphearingamponeselfampintoampknowingampitampincludesampusingampparaphrasingampandampclarificationamp
activitiesamptoampgainampinsightampintoampmeaningampampLastlyampassociationampentailsampidentifyingamp
patternsampandampweavingampthemamptogetherampwithampstudentampexperienceampclassroomampdiscussionamp
andamptheampideasampofampothersamp
amp TuningampintoampsubtletyampimpliesampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceampampTheampmanifestationsamp
ofampsilenceampinamptheampclassroomampareampendlessampandampitsampvalueampisamptooampgreatamptoampbeampignoredampwhileamp
tooampvastamptoampbeampfullyampabsorbedampampLevinamp(1989)ampremarksampthatampsilenceampisampaampclearingampwhereamp
thereampisampnothingampforamphearingamptoampholdamponamptoampinampwhichampmanyampfindampunbearableampanxietyamp
(pamp79)ampampNearlyampallampofampusamphaveampexperiencedampthisampunbearableampanxietyampaampstrainampofamp
whichampcanampbeampfoundampinampeducationalampcontextsampdueamptoamptheampfactampthatampclassroomsampareamp
oftenampstructuredamparoundampimplicitampandampexplicitamprulesampaboutamptalkampandampsilenceamp(Schultzamp
2010amppamp2848)ampampForampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampanampawarenessampofampsilenceampimplicatesamp
whatampisampleftampunsaidampandampwhatampisampunsayableltltespeciallyampimportantampbecauseampofamptheamp
unsayableampqualityampofampartworksampampForampSchultzamp(2010)ampsilenceampimpliesamppossibilityamp
becauseampitampcanampholdampmultipleampmeaningsampforampindividualsampwithinampandampacrossampracialamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 26amp
ethnicampandampculturalampgroupsamp(pamp2833)ampampLevinamp(1989)ampfindsampthatamptoamplistenamptoamp
somethingampweampmustampfirstampgive-itampourampsilenceamp(pamp232)ampampThisamppracticeampofampgivingampsilenceamp
isampparticularlyamphelpfulampinamptermsampofampviewingamporamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartamp
amp Gradleamp(2011)ampoutlinesampaamppracticalampvisionampforampviewingampartampthatamprequiresamp
silenceampandampdeliberationampampForamptheamppurposesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampwouldamp
reconceptualizeampthisampasampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampampGradleamp(2011)ampinstructedamp
herampstudentsamptoampspendamptimeampwithampaampworkampofampartampoutsideampofamptheirampeverydayampworldviewamp
attentivelyampviewingampitampforampaboutamptenampminutesampeverydayampforampaampweekampampAfterampeachampviewingamp
experienceamptheampstudentsampwroteampinamptheirampjournalsampampTheampresultsampindicatedampthatampthisamp
processampofampsustainedampsilentampdeliberationampcoupledampwithampanampengagementampofamptheiramp
intuitiveampperceptionsampaboutampartworkampleftampstudentsampfeelingampempoweredamptoampengageampinamp
discussionampandampappreciateampunfamiliarampartampformsampampThisampactivityampisampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoamp
aampworkampofampartampthatampincorporatesampSablesamp(2014)ampconceptampofampstructuredampcontemplationampamp
Weavingampaamprelationshipampbetweenampsilenceampcontemplationampandampattentivenessampisampaamp
significantampendeavorampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
Contemplativeamppracticesampfunctionampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Engageampinampformsampofampviewingampwritingampandampexperiencingampthatamphonorampselfltlisteningamp
bull Attuneamptoampsubtletyampandampnuanceampbull Listenampandampviewampdeliberatelyampbull Cultivateampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceamp(
The(Felt(Sense(
When-someone-understands-what-I-am-talking-about-when-I-talk-about-art-I-am-delighted--Art-is-my-everything--Its-my-passion--When-someone-understands-that-I-
am-instantly-filled-with-joy--That-tells-me-someone-gets-it-(Survey-response-CTF-age-16)-
(
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
RUNNINGampHEADampTheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
Abstract(
amp Inampthisampqualitativeampartsltinformedampcaseampstudyamptheampresearcherampexploresamphowamp
listeningamppracticesampcouldampbeampinfluentialampinamptheampstudyampandampteachingampofampartampandampartamp
educationampampGadamerrsquosamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamppracticesampinamp
educationalampcontextsampandampGendlinrsquosamptheoryampofampfeltampsenseampprovideampaampphilosophicalamp
foundationampforamptheampresearchampwhileampnarrativeampinquiryampphenomenologyampandampaamp
reflexiveampartamppracticeampinformamptheampmethodologyampandampmethodsampTheampconceptampofampcreative(
listening-space(theampsiteampinampwhichamplisteningamppracticesampareampembeddedampinampactsampofampmakingamp
andampviewingampworksampofampartampemergesampthroughamptheampanalyticampandampreflectiveampprocessesampofamp
theampstudyamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 2amp
Table(of(Contents(
Acknowledgementsampamp4amp
thread1ampIntroductionampamp5amp
amp CreativeltListeningampSpaceamp6amp
amp ResearchampIssueampamp7amp
amp BoundariesampandampLimitationsampofamptheampResearchampamp7amp
amp Dataampamp8amp
amp DearampReaderampTheampStructureampofampthisampPaperampamp9amp
thread2ampCollagingampExperienceampamp11amp
thread3ampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampamp14amp
thread4ampReviewampofamptheampLiteratureampamp15amp
amp HermeneuticsampampamptheampFusionampofampHorizonsampamp15amp
amp DialogicampPracticesampamp19amp
amp ContemplativeampPracticesampamp22amp
amp TheampFeltampSenseampamp26amp
thread5ampResearchampMethodologyampandampMethodsampamp30amp
amp CaseampStudiesampamp30amp
amp Phenomenologyampamp31amp
amp NarrativeampResearchampamp32amp
amp Methodsampamp33amp
thread6ampImmersedampinampDataampamp35amp
amp SurveyampResponsesampamp36amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 3amp
amp amp SurveyampThemesampamp37amp
amp CreativeltListeningampSpaceampCaseampStudiesampamp39amp
thread7ampRespondingamptoampResponseampLayersampofampListeningampUnderstandingampamp40amp
thread8amp(In)Conclusionsampamp47amp
looseampendsampReferencesampamp53amp
braidsampArtworkampReferencesampamp58amp
Appendixampamp61amp
amp
amp
amp
ampamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 4amp
Acknowledgements(
ThankampyouamptoampLaurenampNanditaampandampShannonampforampbeingampexcellentampwonderfulampartamp
educatorsampwhoampmakeampmyampworldampaampbetterampplaceampampYouampeachampteachampmeampnewampthingsampaboutamp
artampallamptheamptimeampandampIamploveampyouampforampitamp
ThankampyouamptoampDrampVittoriaampSampDaielloampforampbeingampanampexcellentamplistenerampampNoamponeampelseamp
wouldamphaveampencouragedampmyampweirdnessampinampsuchampspecificampwaysampampYouampareampmyamproleampmodelamp
Thankampyouamptoampmyampparentsampforamplettingampmeampbeampanampartistampandamphelpingampmeampwithampeverythingamp
ThankampyouamptoampPampforampgivingampmeamptheampbestampcritiquesampandampneveramplettingampmeampgetampawayampwithamp
anythingampampThankampyouampforamplettingampmeampcryampwheneverampIampwantampamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 5amp
(thread1(
The(Possibility(of(Possibilities(Creative=Listening(Spaces(in(Art(Education(
TheampartsampinampeducationampshouldampthusamprecognizeamppossibilitiesampthatampopenampnewamphorizonsampinampbothampformampandampsubstanceampampThisampisamptrueampnotamponlyampinamptheampartsampbutampalsoampinampeducationampinampitsampvariousampmanifestationsampampTheamppossibilitiesampofamptheampworkampofampartampmustampbeampcentralampmustampbeamphonoredampampIfampweampcanamphonoramptheampvisualamppoeticampandampgesturalamppossibilitiesampinamptheampartsampweamp
thenampcanampbeginamptoampunderstandamptheampopeningsampmadeampaccessibleampbyampamplivingampin-theampquestionsamp(Greeneamp2013amppamp252)amp
ampamp
amp CollageampholdsamphighampesteemampinampmyampcreativeamppracticeampampItampisampnotampthatampIampvalueampitsamp
visualampimpactampoverampotherampformsampofampmediaampnorampdoampIampenjoyampitampmoreampthanampotherampmodesampofamp
creativeampexpressionampampSimplyampputampcollageampisampusuallyampwhatampgetsampmeampunstuckampampItampisamptheamp
leverampIampuseamptoampfreeampmyselfampfromampaampdisappointingampdrawingampampInsteadampofamplaboringampoverampaamp
workamporampthrowingampawayampanampotherwiseampinoffensiveamppieceampofamppaperampIampuseampcollageampasampaamp
lastltditchampeffortamptoampmakeampsomethingltltanythingltltthatampIampdontamphaveamptoampstruggleampagainstampamp
Theampdrawingampisamptornampupamppaintedampoverampstapledampsewedamptogetherampcutampintoampstripsampandamp
wovenampampMaybeampitsampjustampthrownampinampmyampdrawerampofampsadampbadampdrawingsampthatampareampallamp
waitingampforamptheamprightampmomentamptoampbecomeampnewampampTheamppointampisampwhatampbeganampasampaampbadamp
drawingampandamppossiblyampaampbadamporampfrustratingampexperienceampdoesntamphaveamptoampremainampinampmyamp
mentalamparchiveampofampDrawings-That-Have-FailedampampInsteadamptheseampworksampareampsimplyamp
deconstructedampandampfoldedampintoampanotheramppossibilityampampCollageampengagesampwithamptheampactampofamp
layeringampandamptheampsenseampofampfearlessnessampgainedampwhenampIampholdampontoamptheampfactampthatampthereampisamp
alwaysampanotheramppossibilityampforampaampworkampamp
amp Theampphysicalampactampofamplayeringamphoweverampisampinampserviceamptoampaampdeeperampsenseampofamptheamp
wordampampWhenampweamparticulateamppowerfulampviewingampexperiencesampwordsampoftenampfailampusampampWeamp
mayampsayampthatampweampfeelampaampclickampaampconnectionamporampanampaestheticampexperienceampwhenampviewingampaamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 6amp
pieceampampTheseampareampwaysampweampexpressamptheampprelinguisticampfeltampdimensionsampofampbeingampwithampaamp
workampofampartampampTemporallyampthisamptakesampplaceampwithinampaampsingleampmomentampinamptimeampampButamp
meaningfulampencountersampwithampartampareamponlyampmeaningfulampbecauseamptheyampareampcomposedampofamp
countlessamppreviousampmomentsampwordsampexperiencesampknowledgeampconversationsamp
relationshipsampandampallamptheampminutiaampthatampconstituteampanampindividualsampidentityampampInampthisamp
conceptionampofampmeaningltmakingamptheamplayersampofampexperiencesampwithinamptheampindividualamptheamp
groupampandamptheampspacesampbetweenampareamprespectedampforamptheirampvalueampinamptheampformationampofamp
singularampandampcollectiveampidentitiesamp
amp Oftenampviewersampandampeducatorsampdiscussampinterpretativeampprocessesampfromamp
frameworksampsuchampasampaampworksamppositionampinampartamphistoryamptheampbiographyampofamptheampartistamp
socialampimplicationsampandampsoamponampampThereampisampaampparallelamptoampbeampfoundamphereampinamptheampdrawingamp
processampampIfampweamppresupposeampthatampthereampisampaampcorrectampwayamptoampinterpretampandampaampperfectamp
drawingamptoampbeamphadampweamprunamptheampriskampofampnotamptryingampforampfearampofampfailureampampItsampnoampstretchamptoamp
sayampthatampindividualsampwhoamplackampartsampexperienceampareamphesitantamptoampengageampwithampaampworkampofamp
artampforampfearampofampexposingamptheirampsupposedampignoranceampampOnamptheampotheramphandampifampweampengageampinamp
aampwayampofampviewingampthatampidentifiesampwithamptheampfluidityampofampcollageampweampcanampacknowledgeamp
possibilityampasampaampfeatureampofampinterpretationampampByampconceivingampofampinterpretationampasampaampformamp
ofampcollagingamptogetherampmeaningfulampexperiencesampviewersampcouldampgainampaccessamptoamptheamp
complexamplayeredampandampmessyampdimensionsampofampmeaningampwhenamptheyamplistenamptoampaampworkampofamp
artamp
Creative=Listening(Space(
amp Iampofferamptheamptermampcreative(listening-spaceampasampanampalternativeampmodeampofamp
experiencingampviewingampandampproducingampcreativeampworksampampInsteadampofampplacingampsubjectamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 7amp
matterampinformationamporamptheamproleampofamptheampeducatorampatamptheampcenterampofamptheseampexperiencesampIamp
proposeampthatampactsampofamplisteningampbeampembeddedampinampmakingampandampviewingampartampampTheamptermamp
creativeltlisteningampspaceamprefersamptoamptheampfluidampandampflexibleampspaceampinampwhichamplisteningamp
practicesampareampanampintegratedampessentialamppartampofampviewingampdiscussingampandampproducingamp
creativeampworksampampArtistsampviewersampstudentsampandampeducatorsampcanamptransformampartamp
classroomsampstudiosampandampsitesampofampviewingampartampintoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhichampareamp
notampdefinedampbyampphysicalampformamporampstructuralampboundariesampampRatheramptheyampareampdefinedampbyamp
specificamppracticesampthatampoccurampamongstampindividualsampandampgroupsampinamptheampcontextampofampartamp
educationampamp
Research(Issue(
amp Theampoverarchingampconcernampinampthisampresearchampisamptheamppotentialampoutcomeampforampusingamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampwithinampartampeducationampampTheamppracticesampIampdiscussamphereamphaveampinamp
commonampaampdistinctiveampflexibilityampandampmalleabilityampampTheyampmayampbeampadaptedamptoampvariousamp
ageampgroupsampeducationalampsitesampandampcontextsampampWhileampIampofferampsuggestionsampIampexpectampthatamp
theamppractitionersampwhoampwishamptoampuseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwillampdeviseamptheirampownamp
methodsampofampimplementationampbasedamponamptheirampspecificampneedsampandampcontextsampampThoughamptheamp
ideaampofampcreativeamplisteningampspacesampemergedampwithinampanampartsampeducationampcontextampampthisamp
conceptampmayampholdampvalueampforampotherampdisciplinesamp
Boundaries(and(Limitations(of(the(Research(
( Iampundertookampthisampresearchampinampfulfillmentampofampaampmastersampdegreeampinampartampeducationamp
atamptheampUniversityampofampCincinnatisampCollegeampofampDesignampArtampArchitectureampandampPlanningamp
(DAAP)ampampTheampresponsesampexperiencesampandampartworkampgeneratedampduringamptheampcourseampofamp
thisampprojectamphaveampoftenampcenteredamparoundampthatampinstitutionampwhichamphousesampaampprimarilyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 8amp
whiteampmiddleltamptoampupperltclassampstudentamppopulationamponampanampurbanampcampusampampIampamampaampwhiteamp
femaleamppursuingamphigherampeducationampampIampwantamptoampacknowledgeampthisamppositionalityampalongamp
withamptheamppersonalampbiasesampaamplifetimeampofampexperiencesamphasampaffordedamptoampmeampampOneampinternalamp
goalampthatampdevelopedampoveramptheampcourseampofampthisampworkampwasampaampcontinuedampconsistentampeffortamp
toampuncoverampandampinterrogateampmyampownampbiasesampasamptheyampmanifestedampampThoughampweampcanampneveramp
beampfreeamporamppureampofamptheseampbiasesampconstantampexaminationampofampthemamphasampbeenampmyampchosenamp
routeamptoampcounteringamptheiramppowerampandampinfluenceampamp
Iampamamppassionateampaboutamptheampmeaningfulamppossibilitiesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampInamprespectampofampmyampownamplimitationsampandampthoseampofampthisampworkamphoweverampIampwillampnotamp
claimampthatampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampareampfeasibleampwithinamptheampcontextampofampeveryamp
educationalampsettingampnorampthatampthisampwayampofampviewingampmakingampandampexperiencingampworksampofamp
artampisampmoreamporamplessampvalidampthanampothersampampRatherampIampsuggestamptheamppossibilityampofamplivingampinamp
possibilitiesampasampaampwayamptoampcultivateampmeaningfulampencountersampwithinampartampandampartamp
educationamp
Data(
amp ForampthisampresearchampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponampthreeampformsampofampdataamp
participantampsurveysampcaseampstudiesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampandampreflectiveamppracticeamp
formsampofampartmakingampallampcollectedampduringampaampfourltmonthampperiodampampToampgatherampparticipantamp
responsesampfromamptheampsurveysampandampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampreliedamponampaampmultitudeampofamp
friendsamppeersampandampcolleaguesampampIampconnectedampwithamptheampmajorityampofamptheseampindividualsamp
duringamporampasampaampresultampofampmyampexperiencesampatampDAAPampampampIampusedamp37ampsurveyampresponsesampaboutamp
listeningampexperiencesampwithampaampparticipantampageamprangeampofamp14amptoamp47ampampParticipantsamp
educationalamplevelsampspannedamphighampschoolamptoampgraduateampschoolampampIamppersonallyampsolicitedamptheamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 9amp
majorityampofamptheamplisteningampsurveysampatamptheampcollegeamplevelampandampaboveampampTheampbulkampofamptheamphighamp
schoolltagedampresponsesampwereampsolicitedampbyampmyampcolleagueampaampphotographyampteacherampatampaamp
Cincinnatiltareaamphighampschoolamp
amp Iampconductedampfiveampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampexperiencesampwithampsixampindividualsampasamp
partampofampthisampresearchampagainampusingampmanyampofamptheamppersonalampandampprofessionalampconnectionsamp
cultivatedampthroughamptheampDAAPampprogramampampIampdeliberatelyampchoseamppeopleampwithampwhomampIamphadamp
variousamplevelsampandamptypesampofamprelationshipsampampIampwillampspeakampmoreampinltdepthampaboutamptheseamp
experiencesampasampwellampasampexploreamptheampsurveyampresponsesampinamptheampResearchampMethodologyamp
andampMethodsampsectionamp
amp Lastlyamptheampdevelopmentampofampanampartmakingamppracticeampwasampessentialamptoampmyampownamp
personalampunderstandingampofamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatampcomposedampmyampresearchamp
ReadersampwillampnoticeampthatampimagesampareampembeddedampinampthisamptextampampTheseampareampimagesampofamptheamp
resultingampproductsampofampaamppracticeampofampunderstandingampthroughampmakingampampIampwillampdiscussamp
themampthroughoutampvariousampsectionsampofampthisamppaperampampamp
Dear(Reader(The(Structure(of(this(Research(Paper(
DearampReader(s)amp
amp Letampmeampbreakampforampaampmomentampfromampstandardampacademicamprhetoricampbeforeampthisamp
paperampreallyampgetsampstartedampampIampknowampwhatampyoureampthinkingltltnineamppagesampinampandampthisamppaperamp
hasntampevenampstartedampyetampampAlasampthisampsectionampisampmyamponeampofampmyampfavoriteampandampmostampoftlt
skimmedamppassagesampofampanampacademicamppaperamptheampstructureampofamptheamppaperampampThisampisamptheamppartamp
whereamptheampwriterampsaysampwhatampshesampaboutamptoampsayampbeforeampsheampsaysampitampampampItsampanamp
organizationalampstrategyampandampitsampthrillingampampLuckilyampforampyouampniceamppersonampwhoampisamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 10amp
readingampthisamppaperampIamphaveampprovidedampaamptranslationampfromampthisamptextsamporiginalampAcademiaamp
intoampnormalltpeopleltlanguageamp
amp Theampstructureampofampthisamppaperampisampasampfollowsampamp(Im-about-to-tell-you-whats-in-this-
long-ass-paper)ampampFirstlyamppleaseampnoteampthatampIampuseamptheamptermampthreadampinamplieuampofampchapteramp
asampanamporganizationalampstructureampIamppreferamptheampformerampbecauseampofamphowampitsampconceptualamp
qualitiesamprelateamptoampmyampworkampamp(Thread-is-awesome-and-you-can-do-tons-of-stuff-with-it-
like-sew-knot-tie-weave-etc--Chapters-are-not-nearly-as-exciting)--Iampwillampfirstampshareamp
myampresearchersampreflexiveampnarrativeampamp(I-made-up-a-cool-story-about-this-project-to-
describe-where-it-all-came-from)ampampThenampIampshallampofferampaampdescriptionampofamptheampqualitiesampofampaamp
creativeltlisteningampspaceampamp(Yes-I-shall)ampampIampwillampdiscussamptheampliteratureampthatampinformsamptheamp
backboneampofampmyampresearchampGadamersamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamp
practicesampandampGendlinsamptheampfeltampsenseampamp(Like-a-typical-graduate-student-I-have-done-
an-insane-amount-of-reading-during-the-past-two-academic-years--A-significant-
portion-of-this-reading-has-been-dedicated-to-those-topics--Dont-ask-me-to-type-them-
out-again-because-Im-seriously-done)ampampTheseampsectionsampbeginampwithampaamppassageampderivedamp
fromampsurveyampresponsesampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampamp(I-got-a-bunch-of-people-to-fill-
out-surveys-for-this-research-and-then-I-put-those-responses-in-my-paper)ampampTheseamp
experiencesampwithamplisteningampwereampprovidedampbyampresearchampparticipantsampamp(Super-nice-
people-I-know-and-some-I-dont-helped-me-out)ampampTheyampareampthereamptoampgroundamptheamp
conceptualampframeworksampinamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampamp(This-basically-means-
none-of-this-research-is-worth-shit-unless-it-can-be-used-in-the-real-world((I-hope-youll-
agree)ampampIampwillampthenampshareampmyampresearchampmethodologyampandampmethodsampamp(Im-going-to-tell-
you-about-how-and-why-I-did-this-project-in-using-big-smart(sounding-words)ampampLastlyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 11amp
Iampwillampconcludeampwithamppossibilitiesampforampthisampresearchampamp(Ill-figure-out-what-I-learned-and-
share-it-with-you-my-new-best-friend-who-made-it-all-the-way-to-the-conclusions-
section)ampampInampthisamppaperampreadersampwillampnoticeamptransparentampimagesampinteractingampwithamptheamp
textampamp(Its-my-art-on-transparent-sheets-in-this-very-paper)ampampTheseampareampworksampofampartamp
thatampIampcreatedamptoampgroundamptheampresearchampinampaamppracticeampofampmakingamptheyampareamptheampphysicalamp
embodimentampofampconceptualampideasampandamptheyampareampalwaysamppresentamptoamptheampresearchampamp
(Research-papers-with-pictures-are-much-more-tolerable-am-I-right)amp
amp Hereampweampgoamp
amp
thread2(
Collaging(Experience1(
amp ImagineampthatampyouampareampanampartistampseatedampatampyourampstudioamptableampampYouamphaveamp
everythingampyouampneedampampTheamproomampisampquietampsaveampforamptheampmuffledampsoundsampofampaampdistantamp
outsideampworldampampYouampsurveyamptheampcollectionampofampimagesampyouamphaveampgatheredamparoundampyouampamp
OnampyouramprightampisampaampraggedamppageampfromampanampoldampsketchbookampampGlossyampjewellttonedampswatchesamp
fromampaampdiscardedampfashionampmagazineampareampstackedampupampglisteningampinamptheamplightampampMonthsamp
agoampyouamppickedampupampaamphandfulampofampblackampandampwhiteampphotosampfromampaampsecondhandampstoreamp
todayamppastyampfacesampofamptheampunknownampsubjectsampstareampthroughampyouampblanklyampampAamppaleampyellowamp
scrapampofampleftoverampfabricampisampdrapedampoveramplastampweeksamppleatedamptoltdoamplistampampTheseampandamptwoamp
dozenampotherampscrapsamppiecesamppilesampandampcrumbsampareampyouramptoolsamptodayampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampamp1ampThisampsectionampisampsupposedamptoampbeampmyampresearchersampreflexiveampnarrativeampaamppassageampaboutampwhereampmyampresearchampideasampcameampfromltltandampinampfactampcollageampisampactuallyampwhereampthisampideaampcomesampfromampampOneampofamptheampfirstampresearchampinterestsampIampdiscussedampwithampmyampprofessorampDrampKristopherampHollandampwasamplayersampbothampphysicalampandampconceptualampampHeampwasamplikeampOhampampYoureamptalkingampaboutamphermeneuticsampSoampinampaampwayampthisampresearchampprojectampbothampbeganampandampconcludedamp(moreamponampthatamplater)ampwithampideasampofamplayeringampandampcollageampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 12amp
amp TheampresidueampthatampclingsamptoamptheseampscrapsampisampexperienceampampTheampoldampsketchbookamp
pageampisampanampimageampofampaampwomansamplegamprenderedampwithampchunkyamppencilampstrokesampampYouampmadeampitamp
whenampyouampwereamplivingampinampyourampoldampapartmentampoverlookingamptheampsquareampampItsampaampwomansamp
footampbutampitampremindsampyouampofamphavingampaamproommateampandampaampgrayampfutonampandampaampsummerampthatamp
wasampdesperatelyamphotampampItampisamponlyamppencilamponamppaperampbutampitampremindsampyouampofamptheampgreenamp
grassyampcenterampinamptheampmedianampofamptheampstreetampampOneamppencilampdrawingampofampaampwomansamplegamp
remindsampyouampofampthatampoldamplifeampandamptheampversionampofampyourselfampyouampwereampthenampitampisamptheampfirstamp
dominoampinampaampseriesampofampcascadingampdetailsampandampmemoriesampamp
amp EachampfragmentampsittingamponampyourampstudioamptableamphasampaampstoryampampEachampcameampfromampaamp
placeampandampwasamptouchedampbyampanotheramphumanampampEachampisampembeddedampwithampexperienceampcoloramp
memoryamptextureampandampinfiniteampdetailampbyamptheampmereampfactampofampitsampownampexistenceampamp
amp YouampbeginamptoamppickampapartamptheampephemeraampampYouampalternateampbeingampcarefulampandamp
carelessamp
amp Cuttingamptearingampburningampstretchingampfoldingampwhitewashingamprippingampcreasingamp
sewingampwritingamppaintingampencasingampfasteningampfillingampsoakingampdyeingampwashingamp
dryingampbitingampscratchingamppryingampyankingampsmoothingampsandingamppokingampstabbingamp
stretchingampfryingampheatingampdustingampcleaningampsculptingampslicingampdicingamppunchingamp
floatingamptwistingampflippingampdrippingampstaplingampstrippingampstripingamppatterningamp
designingampdrawingampsketchingampliftingampcollectingamptapingampgluingampbuttoningampknottingamp
weavingampknittingamp
amp YouampdoampallampofamptheseampthingsampandampprobablyampmanyampotherampthingsampampTheampfragmentsamponamp
youramptableampchangeampshapeampandampgetampsmallerampampFromamptheseamppiecesampyouampbeginamptoampbuildamp
somethingampampThisampsomethingampisampbothampnewampandampoldampampJuxtapositionsampbloomampnewamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 13amp
connectionsampareampfusedampbyamptheampweightampofamppreviousampexperienceampampPastampandamppresentamp
liquefyampintoampendlesslyampcirculatingamppossibilitiesampampYouampcouldamptheoreticallyampcontinueampthisamp
processampofamplayeringampandampreconstructionampforeverampamptheamponlyamplimitsampareampyourampownamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 14amp
thread3(
what(is(a(creative=listening(space(
ampampampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeamplisteningampspaceampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampwhatampdoesampitampsoundampsmellamptasteampfeelamplikeampampampampampampampwhatampampisampamptheampamptextureampampofampampthisampampamp
spaceampampampanswerampmoreampquestionsampampamp specificsampandampgeneralizationsampareampbothampimpossibleampampmaybeampaampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampgoodampstartampwouldampbeampthisampampamp amp amp amp amp safeampampampamp amp amp amp amp foldedampampamp amp amp amp amp amp embodiedampamp layeredampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampconnectedampampampamp amp ampamp
(it-might--be-like-gently-holding-on-to--
a-knot-of-questions)-amp
ampampampampampampampampampamp
(possible)ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 15amp
thread4amp(
Review(of(Literature((
( AnampexplorationampofampGadamerrsquosamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampeducationalampcontextsampandampGendlinrsquosamptheoryampofampfeltampsenseampwereampintegralamptoamp
theampcreationampofamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampWhileampcompellingampconstructsamponamp
theirampownampwhenampdrawnamptogetheramptheseampphilosophicalampperspectivesampvibrateamp
holisticallyamptoampsuggestampintriguingamppossibilitiesampforamptheampuseampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
inampartsampeducationampampInampthisampsectionampIampreviewamptheampliteratureampandampconnectamptheampvariousamp
pointsampofampstudyampampamp
Hermeneutics(amp(the(Fusion(of(Horizons((
It-actually-feels-really-great-knowing-that-other-people-will-enjoy-the-art-you-created-and-knowing-they-know-your-reasoning-and-story-behind-it--Honestly-you-cant-know-if-your-words-are-getting-through-to-them-but-the-cool-thing-about-art-is-that-it-can-be-
interpreted-in-so-many-different-ways---(Survey-response-EK-age-15)-
ampamp Hermeneuticsampwhichamphasampitsamprootsampinamptextualampinterpretationampcanampbeampdefinedampasamp
aamptraditionampofampthinkingamporampofampphilosophicalampreflectionampthatamptriesamptoampclarifyamptheampconceptamp
ofampverstehenampthatampisampunderstandingamp(Brunsamp1992)ampampRicoeuramp(19691974)ampexplainsamp
thatamptheampkeyamphypothesisampofamphermeneuticampphilosophyampisampthatampinterpretationampisampanampopenamp
processampwhichampnoampsingleampvisionampcanampconcludeamp(pamp109)ampampWithampthisampinampmindampIampwillamp
exploreamphermeneuticsampasampitampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp HansltGeorgampGadameramp(1900lt2002)ampinvestigatesampaampmoderateampformampofamp
hermeneuticsampthatampisampparticularlyamprelevantampinampserviceamptoampartampeducationampampGadameramp
breaksampwithamphermeneuticamptraditionampbyampproposingampthatampthereampisampnoampabsolutelyampobjectiveamp
interpretationampreadersampareampnotampableamptoampescapeamptheampprejudicesampofamptheiramptimeamp(Gallagheramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 16amp
1992)ampampThisamphoweverampbecomesampanampopportunityampforamptheampcreationampofampmeaningampInampaamp
passageampthatampechoesamptheampendlesslyampunfoldingampnatureampofampcollageampCaputoamp(2000)amprefersamp
toampanampexchangeampbetweenamppastampandamppresentampinamptheampcreativeamppossibilitiesampofamphermeneuticamp
interpretationamp
amp Thereampisampaamprichnessampinamphistoricalampeventsampthatampjustampkeepsampunfoldingampwhichampisamp
amp certainlyampnotampgraspedampbyamptheamporiginalampprotagonistsampwhichampgraduallyampunfoldsamp
amp overamptheampcourseampofamptimeampandampwhichampisampinampprincipleampneverampfullyampunfoldedampItampisamp
amp anampexcessampwhichampkeepsampspillingampoveramp(pamp47)amp
amp Gadamersampphilosophyampofamphermeneuticampunderstandingampisampformedampthroughamphisamp
notionsampaboutamplanguageampdialogueampandampconversationamp(Caputoamp2000ampSeebohmamp2004)ampamp
InampadditionamptoampGadamersampimplicitamprelianceamponamplisteningampasampheampdiscussesampdialogueamphisamp
workampcapitalizesamponamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampinamplanguageamp(Heelanamp1985)ampmakingamphisamp
formampofamphermeneuticsampparticularlyampapplicableamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp Gadamersamptermampfusion-of-horizonsamprefersamptoamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampwithinampaamp
varietyampofampencountersampampAampfusionampofamphorizonsampcanampbeampdescribedampasampaampdialogicamp
conversationampbetweenampreaderampandamptextamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampWithinamptheamptextualamp
paradigmampGadamerampbelievesampthatampaampwrittenamptextampisampopenamptoampanampinvisibleampandampindefiniteamp
readerampwhoampentersampintoampanampunknownampadventureampofamptheamptextamp(Ricoeuramp2013amppamp13)ampamp
Theamphorizonampitselfampisamptheamprangeampofampvisionampthatampincludesampeverythingampthatampcanampbeampseenamp
fromampaampparticularampvantageamppointamp(Gadameramp2004amppamp301)ampampLikeampcollageamptheampfusionampofamp
horizonsampisampaampprocessampcomposedampofamppastampandamppresentampwhichampareampopenamptoampandampinfinitelyamp
effectedampbyampeachampotheramp(Bourgeoisamp2007)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 17amp
amp Similarampconnectionsampcanampbeampdrawnampwhenampviewerampandampartworkampareampsubstitutedamp
forampreaderampandamptextampampInterpretationampandampunderstandingampbecomeampanampentwinedamp
creativeampendeavorampinampwhichamptheampviewerampparticipatesampasampmuchampasamptheampcreatorampbyamp
constructingampmeaningamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampPalmeramp(1969)ampalludesamptoamptheamppluralityampofamp
meaningampinampstatingampthatamptoampfocusamppurelyamponamptheamppositivityampofampwhatampaamptextampexplicitlyamp
saysampisamptoampdoampanampinjusticeamptoamptheamphermeneuticalamptaskamp(pamp234)ampampToampfocusamponampwhatampisamp
explicitampinampaampcollageampworkampwouldampbeamptoampdisregardamptheampconnectionsampandampcontradictionsamp
ofamptheampwholeampinampfavorampofampaampdirectampreadingampofamptheampindividualamppartsampthusampmissingampoutamponamp
otheramppossibleampdimensionsampofampmeaningamp
amp Theampkeyamptoamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampeducationampinamptextampandampbetweenamp
individualsampisamptheampabilityamptoamplistenampwithampopennessampampDefensiveamplisteningampisampaampwayampofamp
listeningampwithoutampopennessampitampisampaampwayampofampprotectingampourampsmallampversionampofamptheampworldamp
andampavoidingampmoralampclaimsamponampourselvesamp(Levinamp1989amppamp79)ampampLevinamp(1989)amp
discussesampplayfulamplisteningamp(pamp233)ampasampaampwayampofampcounteractingampdefensiveamplisteningampampamp
Bohmamp(1996)ampdiscussesampsuspendingampassumptionsampaampprocessampofampattendingamptoamp
assumptionsampratherampthanamprepressingampthemamporampcarryingampthemampoutampampNicholamp(1996)amp
explainsampaampcircumstanceampinampwhichampyouampencounterampaamppersonampyouampfeelampisampanampidiotampampampYouamp
wouldamprefrainampfromampsayingampsoampoutamploudampbutampyouampwouldampalsoamprefrainampfromampscoldingamp
yourselfampforampthisampthoughtampratherampyouampwouldampseeampthisampreactionampwithoutampfullyampengagingamp
withampitampampSimilarampsuggestionsamplikeampbracketingampofampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampareamp
discussedampinamptheampfollowingampsectionampamp
amp Gadamerampbelievesamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampwhatampallowsamptheampselfamptoampapproachamp
theampotherampitampisampaampprocessampinampwhichamptheampideasampofamptheampotherampbecomeamponesampownamp(Caputoamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 18amp
2000)ampampThisampisamphardlyampanampuncommonampexperienceampampInampfactampweampregularlyampencounteramptheamp
fusionampofamphorizonsampbyampintegratingamppastampunderstandingsampwithampcurrentampexperiencesampaamp
processampundoubtedlyampcomparableamptoampeducationamp(Zuckertamp2002)ampamp
amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsamplikeampeducationampcanampbeampfrustratingampandampemotionalamp
becauseampeachamphighlight[s]amptheampfinitudeampofamptheampinterpreterampandamptheamplimitationsampofamphisamp
understandingamp(Bourgeoisamp2007amppamp79)ampampTheamptermampsharesampsimilaritiesampwithamptheamp
problematic-momentampaamppedagogicalamptermampreferringamptoampaampbreachampinampaampdominantampgroupsamp
discourseampduringampwhichampsomethingamprepressedamparisesamp(KentampampampCummingamp2008)ampampKentamp
andampCummingamp(2008)ampexploreamptheampproblematicampmomentampasampaampdiscursiveampsiteampforamp
examiningampprejudiceampwithinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampandampitsamp
moreamppoliticallyampchargedampcounterpartamptheampproblematicampmomentampbothampexploreamp
Gadamersamp(1996)ampampassertionampthatamptheampotherampmayampnotamponlyamphaveampaamprightampbutampmayamp
actuallyampbeamprightampmayampunderstandampsomethingampbetterampthanampweampdoamp(pamp82)ampampAampcreativelt
listeningampspaceamplivesampinampthisamppossibilityampampamp
amp Lastlyamprelayingampofampappropriateampexpectationsamptoampparticipantsampisampaampnecessaryamp
featureampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampdemandingampampItamp
requiresampparticipantsampwhoampareampawareampofamptheamprisksampandamphardshipsamptoampenterampintoampitampampItamp
isamptheampresponsibilityampofamptheampeducatoramporampgroupampleaderamptoampmakeamptheseampexpectationsamp
knownampasampwellampasamptoampmodelampthisampbehaviorampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionamphermeneuticallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Areampopenamptoamppossibilitiesampandamptoamptheampotherampbull Conceiveampofampthemselvesampasampengagingampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamptheamprisksampinvolvedampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamplimitationsampofamptheirampunderstandingamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 19amp
Dialogic(Practices(-
I-felt-that-everyone-was-open-and-interested-in-what-I-had-to-say---Perhaps-I-felt-this-sense-of-understanding-due-to-the-nature-of-the-discussion((-
it-felt-[like]-more-[of]-a-dialogue-as-opposed-to-a-standard-critique-(Survey-response-MW-age-22)-
(amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampartampeducationampreliesamponampanampopenampdialogueampduringamp
experiencesampwithampartampselfampandampothersampampWhatampIampfoundamplackingampinamphermeneuticsamp
howeverampwasampaampdiscussionampofamptheamphowltlthowampisamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampachievedampandamp
howampdoampindividualsampmeaningfullyampengageampwithampeachampotherampampInampanampeffortamptoampclarifyampthisamp
Iampwillampdiscussampdialogicamppracticesampasamptheyamprelateamptoampmeaningfulampverbalampexchangesampandamp
listeningampencountersampinamptheampclassroomampandampstudioampamongstampstudentsamptheiramppeersampandamp
educatorsamp
amp Communicatingampthroughamplanguageampandampdialogueampisamphowampweampcoltconstructamp
worldsampwithampourselvesampandampothersampnotampjustampthroughampanampactampofamptransmissionampbutamp
becauseampourampcommunicativeampactsampgiveampbirthamptoampworldsamp(Lipariamp2014amppamp507)ampampSableamp
(2014)ampdescribesampdialogueampasampaampgenerativeampinterchangeampbetweenampparticipantsampasamp
opposedamptoampanampexchangeampofampviewsampwhereampindividualsampsimplyampadvocateamptheiramppositionsamp
(pamp8)ampampForampBohmamp(1996)ampitampisampaampstreamampofampmeaningampflowingampamongampandampthroughampusamp
(pamp6)ampampTheampnatureampofampdialogueampandampconversationampisampinherentlyampunplannedampampThisamp
dimensionampofampconversationampisampimportantamptoampGadameramp(2004)ampwhoampfindsampthatamp
participantsampinvolvedampinampconversationampareamplessamptheampleadersampofampitampthanamptheampledamp(pamp
385)ampampSableamp(2014)ampechoesampthisampbyampwritingampthatamptheampmostampimportantamppartsampofampanyamp
conversationampareampthoseampthatampneitheramppartyampcouldamphaveampimaginedampbeforeampstartingamp(pamp
8)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 20amp
amp Theseampareampnotionsampofampdialogueampamongampothersampthatampfindampaampparallelampinamptheamp
creativeampprocessampampFairfieldamp(2011)ampwritesampthatampinampprincipleampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinamp
dialogueamp(pamp83)ampaampsentimentampthatampalignsampwithampaampcommonampissueampencounteredampduringamp
theampcreativeampprocessltltnotampknowingampwhenampaamppieceampisampdoneampampAampquoteampoftenampattributedamp
toampLeonardoampdaampVinciampspeaksamptoampthisampideaampArtampisampneverampfinishedamponlyampabandonedampamp
Snowberamp(2007)ampdrawsampparallelsampbetweenampmentorshipampdialogueampandamptheampcreativeamp
processampfindingampthatampdeepamplisteningamppracticesampconnectampallampthreeampampSheampfindsampthatamptheamp
taskampofamptheampmentorampisamptheampsameampasamptheamptaskampofamptheampartistampthatampisamptoampbringampoutamptheamp
naturalampqualitiesampofamptheampstudentamporamptheampmediumampampSnowberamp(2007)ampcommentsamponampanamp
ideaampwellltknownampamongampartistsampwhichampisampthatampaampworkampofampartamphasampaamplifeampofampitsampownampthisamp
notionampisampreminiscentampofampGadamersampstatementampaboutampbeingampledampbyampconversationamp
ampamp Dialogicamppracticesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampeducationampemphasizeampaamp
phenomenologicalampdimensionamprequiringamptwoampthingsampfromampparticipantsampampFirstlyamp
participantsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampmustampfindampvalueampinamplisteningamptoamptheamp
narrativesampofamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampampTheseampparticipantsampknowampthatampeducationamp
isampforemostampaboutamptestimonyampaboutampsharingamptheampexperienceampofampbeingamphumanampsharingamp
lifeampconvictionsampandampknowledge((Wiercinskiamp2011amppamp109)ampampNarrativesampareamp
conceivedampofampasampaampwayampofamphumanampknowingamp(Vitanovaamp2010amppamp29)ampthatampmakesamptheamp
selfampampSecondlyampwhenamplisteningamptoamptheampnarrativesampofampothersampparticipantsampareampexpectedamp
toampbracketamptheirampownampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsamp(LindsethampampampNorbergamp2004)ampampThisamp
encouragesamplistenersamptoampexperienceampandampfindampmeaningampinamptheampnarrativesampofampothersamp
whileampfreeingamptheampspeakerampfromamptheampfearampofampbeingampjudgedampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 21amp
amp Bracketingampjudgmentampandampconclusionampisampaamppotentialamptoolampwithinamptheampcommonamp
artampeducationamppracticeampofampgroupampcritiquesampampElkinsamp(2001)ampfindsampthatamppeopleampwhoamphaveamp
experienceampinampartampjudgeampveryampquicklyampandampmostampteachersampwillamphaveampaampprovisionalamp
opinionampaboutampaampworkampinamptheampfirstamptenampsecondsamp(pamp121)ampampBracketingampconclusionampandamp
judgmentampisampparticularlyampimportantampforampeducatorsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
whoseampvolumeampofampviewingampexperiencesampcouldampleadamptoampeasyampassumptionsampwhenamp
encounteringampaampnewampworkampampamp
amp Elkinsamp(2001)ampdiscussesampthatampcritiquesampcanampalsoampbeampseenampasampexchangesampofamp
storiesamporampcollaborativeampstorytellingamp(pamp145)ampwhichampisampyetampanotherampwayampofamptalkingamp
aboutamppossibilitiesampforampdialogueampandampnarrativeampwithinampartampeducationampampElkinsamphoweveramp
findsampstorytellingamplimitingamponceamptheampdeeperampnarrativesampareampdiscoveredamp(2001amppamp
145)ampampThisampimpliesampthatampheampfindsamponlyampaampsingularampmeaningampandamponeampthatampisampnotamp
necessarilyampusefulampforampcollaborativeampgroupampcritiquesamp
amp Insteadampparticipantsampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampbringampknowledgeampofamp
polysemyamptoampcollaborativeampcritiqueampexperiencesampasampwellampasamptoampexperiencesampofampmakingamp
artworkampampAccordingamptoampMuldoonamp(2002)amppolysemyampisamptheampqualityampofampaampwordamporampotheramp
languageampunitampthatampcanampbearampmultipleampmeaningsamp(asampcitedampinampWorsleyamp2012amppamp308)ampampamp
Aamptextualampexampleampofampthisampisamptheampmultipleampmeaningsampofamptheampwordampcan-Iampcanampdriveampaampcaramp
Idamplikeampaampcan-ofampsodaampheampwasntampworkingampveryamphardampsoampIamphadamptoampcan-himamp(Munozamp
2014)ampampampButampifampweampconsideramppolysemyampmetaphoricallyamporampvisuallyamptheampideaampthatampaamp
singleampunitampimageamporampintentionampcouldampbearampmultipleampmeaningsampcouldampbeampproductiveampinamp
creatingltlisteningampspacesampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 22amp
amp Thisampunfoldingampofampmeaningampworksampwellampinamptheampcontextampofampcollageampandampdialogueamp
asampwellampasamphermeneuticsampampInampfactamphermeneuticsampimpliesamppolysemyampbecauseampofampitsamp
notionampthatampitampisampalwaysampaamppossibilityampofampmyampunderstandingampthatampisampplayedampoutampwhenampIamp
understandampaamptextamp(Grondinamp2002amppamp38)ampampPolysemyampcouldampbeampconceptualizedampasampanamp
alternativeampexplorationampofampmeaningampthatampfunctionsampcollaborativelyampwithinampcritiquesampamp
Forampexampleampeducatorsampcanampaskampstudentsamptoamprespondamptoampaampworkampthroughampcollageamp
journalampentriesampmusicampfilmampasampindividualsamporampinampgroupsampampKnowledgeampofamppolysemyamp
couldampalsoampbeampusedampasampaamptoolampforampcreatingampimagesampthatamprecognizesampaamprelationshipamp
betweenamptheampvisualamptheamplinguisticampandamptheampmultipleamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionampdialogicallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Placeampvalueamponampexperientialampnarrativesampbull Practiceamplisteningampbyampbracketingampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampbull Embraceamppolysemicampexplorationsampofampmeaningampamp
Contemplative(Practices(
I-knew-I-was-being-heard-because-of-her-mannerisms-and-the-look-on-her-face--She-was-calm-attentive-and-not-trying-to-jump-in-and-offer-any-advice--She-asked-questions-that-pointed-to-things-I-had-not-openly-articulated-because-of-uncertainty--
This-was-one-of-the-ways-I-knew-I-was-being-heard-(Survey-response-LS-age-27)-
(amp Ifamphermeneuticsampandampdialogicamppracticesampgiveampusamptheampbroadampstrokesampofampactivityampinamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampcontemplativeamppracticesampseekamptoamptuneampstudentsampandamp
educatorsampintoampnuanceampdeliberationampandampdeepampexplorationampampThisampisampaampmostlyamp
individualampinternalamppursuitampthatampfocusesamponampformsampofampselfltlisteningampbutampcontemplativeamp
practicesampareampalsoampformedampbyampanampawarenessampofampinterconnectednessamp
amp InamppursuitampofampcriticalampthinkingampSableamp(2014)ampoutlinesampaampsetampofampcontemplativeamp
practicesampforampstudentsampthatampincludeampmindfulampmeditationampstructuredampcontemplationamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 23amp
journalampwritingampmindfulamplisteningampreflectiveampinquiryampandampdialogueamp(pamp4)ampampWhileamp
Sablesamp(2014)ampmethodampforampcontemplativeamppracticesampprovidesampaampconcreteampframeworkamp
withampspecificampstepsampmanyampofamptheseampconceptsampcouldampbeampappliedampwithoutampsuchampaamp
prescribedampstructureampampForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwillampbeamp
primarilyampdiscussingampSablesampconceptsampofampstructuredampcontemplationampreflectiveamp
inquiryampandampjournalampwritingamp
amp ForampSableamp(2014)ampstructuredampcontemplationampisampaampformampofampbeingamppresentampandamp
focusedamponampaampparticularampquestionampstatementamporampimageampampWithinampthisampmodeampofampinquiryamp
participantsampareampexpectedamptoampholdamptheampobjectampofampcontemplationampinamptheirampmindsamp
deepeningampunderstandingampasamptheyampfocusampwithoutampanalyzingampitamporampmanipulatingampitampinamp
anyampwayamp(pamp5)ampampThisamppracticeampdrawsampcomparisonsamptoamptheampbracketingampofampjudgmentsamp
andampconclusionsampsupportedampinamptheamppreviousampsectionampbutampstructuredampcontemplationamp
occursamponampanampindividualamplevelampratherampthanampdialogicallyamp
amp Reflectiveampinquiryampbearsampsomeampsimilaritiesamptoampstructuredampcontemplationampbutamp
Sableamp(2014)amppositionsampitampasampanampactivityampbetweenamptwoampindividualsampaamplistenerampandampaamp
speakerampampTheamplistenerampisampagainampaskedamptoampsuspendampjudgmentampbutampalsoamptoampengageampinampaamp
formampofampcuriosityampinampwhichampinnocentampquestionsampareampaskedampinamporderamptoampgainamp
understandingampampSableamp(2014)ampcontrastsampinnocentampquestionsampwithampleadingampquestionsampamp
ForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwouldampcharacterizeampthisampinnocentamp
questioningampasampaampformampofampopenltendedampquestioningampampSableamp(2014)ampidentifiesampanamp
exampleampofampanampinnocentamp(orampopenltended)ampquestionampWhatampdidampyouampmeanampwhenampyouamp
saidamp________ampConverselyampaampleadingampquestionampisampDidampyouampmeanamptoampsayamp________ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 24amp
amp Sableamp(2014)ampusesampjournalampwritingampasampaamppieceampofamphisamplargerampstructureampofamp
contemplativeamppracticesampbutampjournalampwritingampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampcouldamp
potentiallyampoccupyampaampsignificantamproleampampIampconceiveampofampjournalampwritingampinampmyampownamp
creativeamppracticeampasampaampformampofampdocumentationampthatampmakesampmeampmoreampawareampofampmyamp
creativeampprocessamptheampemotionalamphabitsampthatampsurroundampitampandamptheampthemesampthatamp
structureampmyampworkampampIampconceptualizeampthisampwayampofampwritingampasampaampformampofampselfltlisteningamp
relatedamptoampaampkeyampconceptampofamphermeneuticsampfoundampinampGadamersampassertionampthatampallamp
educationampisampaampformampofampselflteducationamp(Grondinamp2011)ampampamp
amp Germeraadamp(2013)ampusesampjournalampwritingamptoampexploreamptheampemotionalampandamprationalamp
relationshipsamptoamphisampcreativeampprocessampparallelamptoampexecutingampaampnewampbodyampofampworkampampHeamp
findsampthatampwritingampduringamphisampprocessampisampaamptoolamptoampunderstandamp[his]amppsycheamptoampeaseamp
theamppainampthatampanampartisticampprocessampcanampbringampandamptoamprelieveampartisticampblocksamp
(Germeraadamp2013amppamp21)ampultimatelyampdeclaringampthatampitamphelpsamphimamptoampbetterampunderstandamp
hisampworkampampInampaampstyleampofampwritingampthatamposcillatesamparoundampjournalingampdocumentationampandamp
poetryampdeampCossonamp(2002)ampexploresamphisampoverlappingamprolesampasampanampartistampresearcherampandamp
teacherampampOtherampartistsampbluramptheamplineampbetweenampartamppracticeampdocumentationampandamplifeamp
furtherampstillampbyampofferingampdocumentationampasampartamplikeampSophieampCalleamp(Calleamp2011amp2008amp
2005)ampandampMaryampKellyamp(1973lt1979)ampampamp
amp Karpiakamp(2003)ampestablishesampcontemplativeamppracticesampfromamptheampperspectiveampofamp
theampeducatorampaskingampthemamptoampmineamptheampsubtleamp(pamp71)ampusingampattentivenessamp
attunementampamplificationampandampassociationampampTheseampexercisesampinampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampsetamptheamptoneampasampwellampasampprovideampaampmodelampofampbehaviorampforampotherampparticipantsamp
withinamptheampspaceampampKarpiakamp(2003)ampoutlinesampactivitiesampthatampeducatorsampcanampuseamptoampdrawamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 25amp
outampandamputilizeamptheseampsubtleampsensationsampinamptheampserviceampofamptransformativeamplearningamp(pamp
68)ampampamp
amp ForampKarpiakamp(2003)ampattentivenessamprequiresampawarenessamptoampverbalampandamp
nonverbalampcuesampasampwellampasampanampawarenessampofampwhatampisamphappeningampamongampandampwithinamptheamp
studentsampandamptheampeducatorampampAttunementamprequiresampanampeducatoramptoamporientampherselfamptoamptheamp
otherampandamptoampadoptampanampattitudeampofampunhurriednessampofamppatienceampandampofamphumilityamp
concerningampbothamptheampprocessampandamptheampoutcomesampofamptheampteachingamp(Karpiakamp2003amppgamp
72)ampampAmplificationampisampaampprocessampofamphonoringampcommunicationampthatampcentersamponamptheampideaamp
ofamphearingamponeselfampintoampknowingampitampincludesampusingampparaphrasingampandampclarificationamp
activitiesamptoampgainampinsightampintoampmeaningampampLastlyampassociationampentailsampidentifyingamp
patternsampandampweavingampthemamptogetherampwithampstudentampexperienceampclassroomampdiscussionamp
andamptheampideasampofampothersamp
amp TuningampintoampsubtletyampimpliesampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceampampTheampmanifestationsamp
ofampsilenceampinamptheampclassroomampareampendlessampandampitsampvalueampisamptooampgreatamptoampbeampignoredampwhileamp
tooampvastamptoampbeampfullyampabsorbedampampLevinamp(1989)ampremarksampthatampsilenceampisampaampclearingampwhereamp
thereampisampnothingampforamphearingamptoampholdamponamptoampinampwhichampmanyampfindampunbearableampanxietyamp
(pamp79)ampampNearlyampallampofampusamphaveampexperiencedampthisampunbearableampanxietyampaampstrainampofamp
whichampcanampbeampfoundampinampeducationalampcontextsampdueamptoamptheampfactampthatampclassroomsampareamp
oftenampstructuredamparoundampimplicitampandampexplicitamprulesampaboutamptalkampandampsilenceamp(Schultzamp
2010amppamp2848)ampampForampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampanampawarenessampofampsilenceampimplicatesamp
whatampisampleftampunsaidampandampwhatampisampunsayableltltespeciallyampimportantampbecauseampofamptheamp
unsayableampqualityampofampartworksampampForampSchultzamp(2010)ampsilenceampimpliesamppossibilityamp
becauseampitampcanampholdampmultipleampmeaningsampforampindividualsampwithinampandampacrossampracialamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 26amp
ethnicampandampculturalampgroupsamp(pamp2833)ampampLevinamp(1989)ampfindsampthatamptoamplistenamptoamp
somethingampweampmustampfirstampgive-itampourampsilenceamp(pamp232)ampampThisamppracticeampofampgivingampsilenceamp
isampparticularlyamphelpfulampinamptermsampofampviewingamporamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartamp
amp Gradleamp(2011)ampoutlinesampaamppracticalampvisionampforampviewingampartampthatamprequiresamp
silenceampandampdeliberationampampForamptheamppurposesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampwouldamp
reconceptualizeampthisampasampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampampGradleamp(2011)ampinstructedamp
herampstudentsamptoampspendamptimeampwithampaampworkampofampartampoutsideampofamptheirampeverydayampworldviewamp
attentivelyampviewingampitampforampaboutamptenampminutesampeverydayampforampaampweekampampAfterampeachampviewingamp
experienceamptheampstudentsampwroteampinamptheirampjournalsampampTheampresultsampindicatedampthatampthisamp
processampofampsustainedampsilentampdeliberationampcoupledampwithampanampengagementampofamptheiramp
intuitiveampperceptionsampaboutampartworkampleftampstudentsampfeelingampempoweredamptoampengageampinamp
discussionampandampappreciateampunfamiliarampartampformsampampThisampactivityampisampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoamp
aampworkampofampartampthatampincorporatesampSablesamp(2014)ampconceptampofampstructuredampcontemplationampamp
Weavingampaamprelationshipampbetweenampsilenceampcontemplationampandampattentivenessampisampaamp
significantampendeavorampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
Contemplativeamppracticesampfunctionampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Engageampinampformsampofampviewingampwritingampandampexperiencingampthatamphonorampselfltlisteningamp
bull Attuneamptoampsubtletyampandampnuanceampbull Listenampandampviewampdeliberatelyampbull Cultivateampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceamp(
The(Felt(Sense(
When-someone-understands-what-I-am-talking-about-when-I-talk-about-art-I-am-delighted--Art-is-my-everything--Its-my-passion--When-someone-understands-that-I-
am-instantly-filled-with-joy--That-tells-me-someone-gets-it-(Survey-response-CTF-age-16)-
(
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 2amp
Table(of(Contents(
Acknowledgementsampamp4amp
thread1ampIntroductionampamp5amp
amp CreativeltListeningampSpaceamp6amp
amp ResearchampIssueampamp7amp
amp BoundariesampandampLimitationsampofamptheampResearchampamp7amp
amp Dataampamp8amp
amp DearampReaderampTheampStructureampofampthisampPaperampamp9amp
thread2ampCollagingampExperienceampamp11amp
thread3ampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampamp14amp
thread4ampReviewampofamptheampLiteratureampamp15amp
amp HermeneuticsampampamptheampFusionampofampHorizonsampamp15amp
amp DialogicampPracticesampamp19amp
amp ContemplativeampPracticesampamp22amp
amp TheampFeltampSenseampamp26amp
thread5ampResearchampMethodologyampandampMethodsampamp30amp
amp CaseampStudiesampamp30amp
amp Phenomenologyampamp31amp
amp NarrativeampResearchampamp32amp
amp Methodsampamp33amp
thread6ampImmersedampinampDataampamp35amp
amp SurveyampResponsesampamp36amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 3amp
amp amp SurveyampThemesampamp37amp
amp CreativeltListeningampSpaceampCaseampStudiesampamp39amp
thread7ampRespondingamptoampResponseampLayersampofampListeningampUnderstandingampamp40amp
thread8amp(In)Conclusionsampamp47amp
looseampendsampReferencesampamp53amp
braidsampArtworkampReferencesampamp58amp
Appendixampamp61amp
amp
amp
amp
ampamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 4amp
Acknowledgements(
ThankampyouamptoampLaurenampNanditaampandampShannonampforampbeingampexcellentampwonderfulampartamp
educatorsampwhoampmakeampmyampworldampaampbetterampplaceampampYouampeachampteachampmeampnewampthingsampaboutamp
artampallamptheamptimeampandampIamploveampyouampforampitamp
ThankampyouamptoampDrampVittoriaampSampDaielloampforampbeingampanampexcellentamplistenerampampNoamponeampelseamp
wouldamphaveampencouragedampmyampweirdnessampinampsuchampspecificampwaysampampYouampareampmyamproleampmodelamp
Thankampyouamptoampmyampparentsampforamplettingampmeampbeampanampartistampandamphelpingampmeampwithampeverythingamp
ThankampyouamptoampPampforampgivingampmeamptheampbestampcritiquesampandampneveramplettingampmeampgetampawayampwithamp
anythingampampThankampyouampforamplettingampmeampcryampwheneverampIampwantampamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 5amp
(thread1(
The(Possibility(of(Possibilities(Creative=Listening(Spaces(in(Art(Education(
TheampartsampinampeducationampshouldampthusamprecognizeamppossibilitiesampthatampopenampnewamphorizonsampinampbothampformampandampsubstanceampampThisampisamptrueampnotamponlyampinamptheampartsampbutampalsoampinampeducationampinampitsampvariousampmanifestationsampampTheamppossibilitiesampofamptheampworkampofampartampmustampbeampcentralampmustampbeamphonoredampampIfampweampcanamphonoramptheampvisualamppoeticampandampgesturalamppossibilitiesampinamptheampartsampweamp
thenampcanampbeginamptoampunderstandamptheampopeningsampmadeampaccessibleampbyampamplivingampin-theampquestionsamp(Greeneamp2013amppamp252)amp
ampamp
amp CollageampholdsamphighampesteemampinampmyampcreativeamppracticeampampItampisampnotampthatampIampvalueampitsamp
visualampimpactampoverampotherampformsampofampmediaampnorampdoampIampenjoyampitampmoreampthanampotherampmodesampofamp
creativeampexpressionampampSimplyampputampcollageampisampusuallyampwhatampgetsampmeampunstuckampampItampisamptheamp
leverampIampuseamptoampfreeampmyselfampfromampaampdisappointingampdrawingampampInsteadampofamplaboringampoverampaamp
workamporampthrowingampawayampanampotherwiseampinoffensiveamppieceampofamppaperampIampuseampcollageampasampaamp
lastltditchampeffortamptoampmakeampsomethingltltanythingltltthatampIampdontamphaveamptoampstruggleampagainstampamp
Theampdrawingampisamptornampupamppaintedampoverampstapledampsewedamptogetherampcutampintoampstripsampandamp
wovenampampMaybeampitsampjustampthrownampinampmyampdrawerampofampsadampbadampdrawingsampthatampareampallamp
waitingampforamptheamprightampmomentamptoampbecomeampnewampampTheamppointampisampwhatampbeganampasampaampbadamp
drawingampandamppossiblyampaampbadamporampfrustratingampexperienceampdoesntamphaveamptoampremainampinampmyamp
mentalamparchiveampofampDrawings-That-Have-FailedampampInsteadamptheseampworksampareampsimplyamp
deconstructedampandampfoldedampintoampanotheramppossibilityampampCollageampengagesampwithamptheampactampofamp
layeringampandamptheampsenseampofampfearlessnessampgainedampwhenampIampholdampontoamptheampfactampthatampthereampisamp
alwaysampanotheramppossibilityampforampaampworkampamp
amp Theampphysicalampactampofamplayeringamphoweverampisampinampserviceamptoampaampdeeperampsenseampofamptheamp
wordampampWhenampweamparticulateamppowerfulampviewingampexperiencesampwordsampoftenampfailampusampampWeamp
mayampsayampthatampweampfeelampaampclickampaampconnectionamporampanampaestheticampexperienceampwhenampviewingampaamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 6amp
pieceampampTheseampareampwaysampweampexpressamptheampprelinguisticampfeltampdimensionsampofampbeingampwithampaamp
workampofampartampampTemporallyampthisamptakesampplaceampwithinampaampsingleampmomentampinamptimeampampButamp
meaningfulampencountersampwithampartampareamponlyampmeaningfulampbecauseamptheyampareampcomposedampofamp
countlessamppreviousampmomentsampwordsampexperiencesampknowledgeampconversationsamp
relationshipsampandampallamptheampminutiaampthatampconstituteampanampindividualsampidentityampampInampthisamp
conceptionampofampmeaningltmakingamptheamplayersampofampexperiencesampwithinamptheampindividualamptheamp
groupampandamptheampspacesampbetweenampareamprespectedampforamptheirampvalueampinamptheampformationampofamp
singularampandampcollectiveampidentitiesamp
amp Oftenampviewersampandampeducatorsampdiscussampinterpretativeampprocessesampfromamp
frameworksampsuchampasampaampworksamppositionampinampartamphistoryamptheampbiographyampofamptheampartistamp
socialampimplicationsampandampsoamponampampThereampisampaampparallelamptoampbeampfoundamphereampinamptheampdrawingamp
processampampIfampweamppresupposeampthatampthereampisampaampcorrectampwayamptoampinterpretampandampaampperfectamp
drawingamptoampbeamphadampweamprunamptheampriskampofampnotamptryingampforampfearampofampfailureampampItsampnoampstretchamptoamp
sayampthatampindividualsampwhoamplackampartsampexperienceampareamphesitantamptoampengageampwithampaampworkampofamp
artampforampfearampofampexposingamptheirampsupposedampignoranceampampOnamptheampotheramphandampifampweampengageampinamp
aampwayampofampviewingampthatampidentifiesampwithamptheampfluidityampofampcollageampweampcanampacknowledgeamp
possibilityampasampaampfeatureampofampinterpretationampampByampconceivingampofampinterpretationampasampaampformamp
ofampcollagingamptogetherampmeaningfulampexperiencesampviewersampcouldampgainampaccessamptoamptheamp
complexamplayeredampandampmessyampdimensionsampofampmeaningampwhenamptheyamplistenamptoampaampworkampofamp
artamp
Creative=Listening(Space(
amp Iampofferamptheamptermampcreative(listening-spaceampasampanampalternativeampmodeampofamp
experiencingampviewingampandampproducingampcreativeampworksampampInsteadampofampplacingampsubjectamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 7amp
matterampinformationamporamptheamproleampofamptheampeducatorampatamptheampcenterampofamptheseampexperiencesampIamp
proposeampthatampactsampofamplisteningampbeampembeddedampinampmakingampandampviewingampartampampTheamptermamp
creativeltlisteningampspaceamprefersamptoamptheampfluidampandampflexibleampspaceampinampwhichamplisteningamp
practicesampareampanampintegratedampessentialamppartampofampviewingampdiscussingampandampproducingamp
creativeampworksampampArtistsampviewersampstudentsampandampeducatorsampcanamptransformampartamp
classroomsampstudiosampandampsitesampofampviewingampartampintoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhichampareamp
notampdefinedampbyampphysicalampformamporampstructuralampboundariesampampRatheramptheyampareampdefinedampbyamp
specificamppracticesampthatampoccurampamongstampindividualsampandampgroupsampinamptheampcontextampofampartamp
educationampamp
Research(Issue(
amp Theampoverarchingampconcernampinampthisampresearchampisamptheamppotentialampoutcomeampforampusingamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampwithinampartampeducationampampTheamppracticesampIampdiscussamphereamphaveampinamp
commonampaampdistinctiveampflexibilityampandampmalleabilityampampTheyampmayampbeampadaptedamptoampvariousamp
ageampgroupsampeducationalampsitesampandampcontextsampampWhileampIampofferampsuggestionsampIampexpectampthatamp
theamppractitionersampwhoampwishamptoampuseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwillampdeviseamptheirampownamp
methodsampofampimplementationampbasedamponamptheirampspecificampneedsampandampcontextsampampThoughamptheamp
ideaampofampcreativeamplisteningampspacesampemergedampwithinampanampartsampeducationampcontextampampthisamp
conceptampmayampholdampvalueampforampotherampdisciplinesamp
Boundaries(and(Limitations(of(the(Research(
( Iampundertookampthisampresearchampinampfulfillmentampofampaampmastersampdegreeampinampartampeducationamp
atamptheampUniversityampofampCincinnatisampCollegeampofampDesignampArtampArchitectureampandampPlanningamp
(DAAP)ampampTheampresponsesampexperiencesampandampartworkampgeneratedampduringamptheampcourseampofamp
thisampprojectamphaveampoftenampcenteredamparoundampthatampinstitutionampwhichamphousesampaampprimarilyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 8amp
whiteampmiddleltamptoampupperltclassampstudentamppopulationamponampanampurbanampcampusampampIampamampaampwhiteamp
femaleamppursuingamphigherampeducationampampIampwantamptoampacknowledgeampthisamppositionalityampalongamp
withamptheamppersonalampbiasesampaamplifetimeampofampexperiencesamphasampaffordedamptoampmeampampOneampinternalamp
goalampthatampdevelopedampoveramptheampcourseampofampthisampworkampwasampaampcontinuedampconsistentampeffortamp
toampuncoverampandampinterrogateampmyampownampbiasesampasamptheyampmanifestedampampThoughampweampcanampneveramp
beampfreeamporamppureampofamptheseampbiasesampconstantampexaminationampofampthemamphasampbeenampmyampchosenamp
routeamptoampcounteringamptheiramppowerampandampinfluenceampamp
Iampamamppassionateampaboutamptheampmeaningfulamppossibilitiesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampInamprespectampofampmyampownamplimitationsampandampthoseampofampthisampworkamphoweverampIampwillampnotamp
claimampthatampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampareampfeasibleampwithinamptheampcontextampofampeveryamp
educationalampsettingampnorampthatampthisampwayampofampviewingampmakingampandampexperiencingampworksampofamp
artampisampmoreamporamplessampvalidampthanampothersampampRatherampIampsuggestamptheamppossibilityampofamplivingampinamp
possibilitiesampasampaampwayamptoampcultivateampmeaningfulampencountersampwithinampartampandampartamp
educationamp
Data(
amp ForampthisampresearchampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponampthreeampformsampofampdataamp
participantampsurveysampcaseampstudiesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampandampreflectiveamppracticeamp
formsampofampartmakingampallampcollectedampduringampaampfourltmonthampperiodampampToampgatherampparticipantamp
responsesampfromamptheampsurveysampandampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampreliedamponampaampmultitudeampofamp
friendsamppeersampandampcolleaguesampampIampconnectedampwithamptheampmajorityampofamptheseampindividualsamp
duringamporampasampaampresultampofampmyampexperiencesampatampDAAPampampampIampusedamp37ampsurveyampresponsesampaboutamp
listeningampexperiencesampwithampaampparticipantampageamprangeampofamp14amptoamp47ampampParticipantsamp
educationalamplevelsampspannedamphighampschoolamptoampgraduateampschoolampampIamppersonallyampsolicitedamptheamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 9amp
majorityampofamptheamplisteningampsurveysampatamptheampcollegeamplevelampandampaboveampampTheampbulkampofamptheamphighamp
schoolltagedampresponsesampwereampsolicitedampbyampmyampcolleagueampaampphotographyampteacherampatampaamp
Cincinnatiltareaamphighampschoolamp
amp Iampconductedampfiveampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampexperiencesampwithampsixampindividualsampasamp
partampofampthisampresearchampagainampusingampmanyampofamptheamppersonalampandampprofessionalampconnectionsamp
cultivatedampthroughamptheampDAAPampprogramampampIampdeliberatelyampchoseamppeopleampwithampwhomampIamphadamp
variousamplevelsampandamptypesampofamprelationshipsampampIampwillampspeakampmoreampinltdepthampaboutamptheseamp
experiencesampasampwellampasampexploreamptheampsurveyampresponsesampinamptheampResearchampMethodologyamp
andampMethodsampsectionamp
amp Lastlyamptheampdevelopmentampofampanampartmakingamppracticeampwasampessentialamptoampmyampownamp
personalampunderstandingampofamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatampcomposedampmyampresearchamp
ReadersampwillampnoticeampthatampimagesampareampembeddedampinampthisamptextampampTheseampareampimagesampofamptheamp
resultingampproductsampofampaamppracticeampofampunderstandingampthroughampmakingampampIampwillampdiscussamp
themampthroughoutampvariousampsectionsampofampthisamppaperampampamp
Dear(Reader(The(Structure(of(this(Research(Paper(
DearampReader(s)amp
amp Letampmeampbreakampforampaampmomentampfromampstandardampacademicamprhetoricampbeforeampthisamp
paperampreallyampgetsampstartedampampIampknowampwhatampyoureampthinkingltltnineamppagesampinampandampthisamppaperamp
hasntampevenampstartedampyetampampAlasampthisampsectionampisampmyamponeampofampmyampfavoriteampandampmostampoftlt
skimmedamppassagesampofampanampacademicamppaperamptheampstructureampofamptheamppaperampampThisampisamptheamppartamp
whereamptheampwriterampsaysampwhatampshesampaboutamptoampsayampbeforeampsheampsaysampitampampampItsampanamp
organizationalampstrategyampandampitsampthrillingampampLuckilyampforampyouampniceamppersonampwhoampisamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 10amp
readingampthisamppaperampIamphaveampprovidedampaamptranslationampfromampthisamptextsamporiginalampAcademiaamp
intoampnormalltpeopleltlanguageamp
amp Theampstructureampofampthisamppaperampisampasampfollowsampamp(Im-about-to-tell-you-whats-in-this-
long-ass-paper)ampampFirstlyamppleaseampnoteampthatampIampuseamptheamptermampthreadampinamplieuampofampchapteramp
asampanamporganizationalampstructureampIamppreferamptheampformerampbecauseampofamphowampitsampconceptualamp
qualitiesamprelateamptoampmyampworkampamp(Thread-is-awesome-and-you-can-do-tons-of-stuff-with-it-
like-sew-knot-tie-weave-etc--Chapters-are-not-nearly-as-exciting)--Iampwillampfirstampshareamp
myampresearchersampreflexiveampnarrativeampamp(I-made-up-a-cool-story-about-this-project-to-
describe-where-it-all-came-from)ampampThenampIampshallampofferampaampdescriptionampofamptheampqualitiesampofampaamp
creativeltlisteningampspaceampamp(Yes-I-shall)ampampIampwillampdiscussamptheampliteratureampthatampinformsamptheamp
backboneampofampmyampresearchampGadamersamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamp
practicesampandampGendlinsamptheampfeltampsenseampamp(Like-a-typical-graduate-student-I-have-done-
an-insane-amount-of-reading-during-the-past-two-academic-years--A-significant-
portion-of-this-reading-has-been-dedicated-to-those-topics--Dont-ask-me-to-type-them-
out-again-because-Im-seriously-done)ampampTheseampsectionsampbeginampwithampaamppassageampderivedamp
fromampsurveyampresponsesampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampamp(I-got-a-bunch-of-people-to-fill-
out-surveys-for-this-research-and-then-I-put-those-responses-in-my-paper)ampampTheseamp
experiencesampwithamplisteningampwereampprovidedampbyampresearchampparticipantsampamp(Super-nice-
people-I-know-and-some-I-dont-helped-me-out)ampampTheyampareampthereamptoampgroundamptheamp
conceptualampframeworksampinamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampamp(This-basically-means-
none-of-this-research-is-worth-shit-unless-it-can-be-used-in-the-real-world((I-hope-youll-
agree)ampampIampwillampthenampshareampmyampresearchampmethodologyampandampmethodsampamp(Im-going-to-tell-
you-about-how-and-why-I-did-this-project-in-using-big-smart(sounding-words)ampampLastlyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 11amp
Iampwillampconcludeampwithamppossibilitiesampforampthisampresearchampamp(Ill-figure-out-what-I-learned-and-
share-it-with-you-my-new-best-friend-who-made-it-all-the-way-to-the-conclusions-
section)ampampInampthisamppaperampreadersampwillampnoticeamptransparentampimagesampinteractingampwithamptheamp
textampamp(Its-my-art-on-transparent-sheets-in-this-very-paper)ampampTheseampareampworksampofampartamp
thatampIampcreatedamptoampgroundamptheampresearchampinampaamppracticeampofampmakingamptheyampareamptheampphysicalamp
embodimentampofampconceptualampideasampandamptheyampareampalwaysamppresentamptoamptheampresearchampamp
(Research-papers-with-pictures-are-much-more-tolerable-am-I-right)amp
amp Hereampweampgoamp
amp
thread2(
Collaging(Experience1(
amp ImagineampthatampyouampareampanampartistampseatedampatampyourampstudioamptableampampYouamphaveamp
everythingampyouampneedampampTheamproomampisampquietampsaveampforamptheampmuffledampsoundsampofampaampdistantamp
outsideampworldampampYouampsurveyamptheampcollectionampofampimagesampyouamphaveampgatheredamparoundampyouampamp
OnampyouramprightampisampaampraggedamppageampfromampanampoldampsketchbookampampGlossyampjewellttonedampswatchesamp
fromampaampdiscardedampfashionampmagazineampareampstackedampupampglisteningampinamptheamplightampampMonthsamp
agoampyouamppickedampupampaamphandfulampofampblackampandampwhiteampphotosampfromampaampsecondhandampstoreamp
todayamppastyampfacesampofamptheampunknownampsubjectsampstareampthroughampyouampblanklyampampAamppaleampyellowamp
scrapampofampleftoverampfabricampisampdrapedampoveramplastampweeksamppleatedamptoltdoamplistampampTheseampandamptwoamp
dozenampotherampscrapsamppiecesamppilesampandampcrumbsampareampyouramptoolsamptodayampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampamp1ampThisampsectionampisampsupposedamptoampbeampmyampresearchersampreflexiveampnarrativeampaamppassageampaboutampwhereampmyampresearchampideasampcameampfromltltandampinampfactampcollageampisampactuallyampwhereampthisampideaampcomesampfromampampOneampofamptheampfirstampresearchampinterestsampIampdiscussedampwithampmyampprofessorampDrampKristopherampHollandampwasamplayersampbothampphysicalampandampconceptualampampHeampwasamplikeampOhampampYoureamptalkingampaboutamphermeneuticsampSoampinampaampwayampthisampresearchampprojectampbothampbeganampandampconcludedamp(moreamponampthatamplater)ampwithampideasampofamplayeringampandampcollageampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 12amp
amp TheampresidueampthatampclingsamptoamptheseampscrapsampisampexperienceampampTheampoldampsketchbookamp
pageampisampanampimageampofampaampwomansamplegamprenderedampwithampchunkyamppencilampstrokesampampYouampmadeampitamp
whenampyouampwereamplivingampinampyourampoldampapartmentampoverlookingamptheampsquareampampItsampaampwomansamp
footampbutampitampremindsampyouampofamphavingampaamproommateampandampaampgrayampfutonampandampaampsummerampthatamp
wasampdesperatelyamphotampampItampisamponlyamppencilamponamppaperampbutampitampremindsampyouampofamptheampgreenamp
grassyampcenterampinamptheampmedianampofamptheampstreetampampOneamppencilampdrawingampofampaampwomansamplegamp
remindsampyouampofampthatampoldamplifeampandamptheampversionampofampyourselfampyouampwereampthenampitampisamptheampfirstamp
dominoampinampaampseriesampofampcascadingampdetailsampandampmemoriesampamp
amp EachampfragmentampsittingamponampyourampstudioamptableamphasampaampstoryampampEachampcameampfromampaamp
placeampandampwasamptouchedampbyampanotheramphumanampampEachampisampembeddedampwithampexperienceampcoloramp
memoryamptextureampandampinfiniteampdetailampbyamptheampmereampfactampofampitsampownampexistenceampamp
amp YouampbeginamptoamppickampapartamptheampephemeraampampYouampalternateampbeingampcarefulampandamp
carelessamp
amp Cuttingamptearingampburningampstretchingampfoldingampwhitewashingamprippingampcreasingamp
sewingampwritingamppaintingampencasingampfasteningampfillingampsoakingampdyeingampwashingamp
dryingampbitingampscratchingamppryingampyankingampsmoothingampsandingamppokingampstabbingamp
stretchingampfryingampheatingampdustingampcleaningampsculptingampslicingampdicingamppunchingamp
floatingamptwistingampflippingampdrippingampstaplingampstrippingampstripingamppatterningamp
designingampdrawingampsketchingampliftingampcollectingamptapingampgluingampbuttoningampknottingamp
weavingampknittingamp
amp YouampdoampallampofamptheseampthingsampandampprobablyampmanyampotherampthingsampampTheampfragmentsamponamp
youramptableampchangeampshapeampandampgetampsmallerampampFromamptheseamppiecesampyouampbeginamptoampbuildamp
somethingampampThisampsomethingampisampbothampnewampandampoldampampJuxtapositionsampbloomampnewamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 13amp
connectionsampareampfusedampbyamptheampweightampofamppreviousampexperienceampampPastampandamppresentamp
liquefyampintoampendlesslyampcirculatingamppossibilitiesampampYouampcouldamptheoreticallyampcontinueampthisamp
processampofamplayeringampandampreconstructionampforeverampamptheamponlyamplimitsampareampyourampownamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 14amp
thread3(
what(is(a(creative=listening(space(
ampampampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeamplisteningampspaceampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampwhatampdoesampitampsoundampsmellamptasteampfeelamplikeampampampampampampampwhatampampisampamptheampamptextureampampofampampthisampampamp
spaceampampampanswerampmoreampquestionsampampamp specificsampandampgeneralizationsampareampbothampimpossibleampampmaybeampaampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampgoodampstartampwouldampbeampthisampampamp amp amp amp amp safeampampampamp amp amp amp amp foldedampampamp amp amp amp amp amp embodiedampamp layeredampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampconnectedampampampamp amp ampamp
(it-might--be-like-gently-holding-on-to--
a-knot-of-questions)-amp
ampampampampampampampampampamp
(possible)ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 15amp
thread4amp(
Review(of(Literature((
( AnampexplorationampofampGadamerrsquosamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampeducationalampcontextsampandampGendlinrsquosamptheoryampofampfeltampsenseampwereampintegralamptoamp
theampcreationampofamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampWhileampcompellingampconstructsamponamp
theirampownampwhenampdrawnamptogetheramptheseampphilosophicalampperspectivesampvibrateamp
holisticallyamptoampsuggestampintriguingamppossibilitiesampforamptheampuseampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
inampartsampeducationampampInampthisampsectionampIampreviewamptheampliteratureampandampconnectamptheampvariousamp
pointsampofampstudyampampamp
Hermeneutics(amp(the(Fusion(of(Horizons((
It-actually-feels-really-great-knowing-that-other-people-will-enjoy-the-art-you-created-and-knowing-they-know-your-reasoning-and-story-behind-it--Honestly-you-cant-know-if-your-words-are-getting-through-to-them-but-the-cool-thing-about-art-is-that-it-can-be-
interpreted-in-so-many-different-ways---(Survey-response-EK-age-15)-
ampamp Hermeneuticsampwhichamphasampitsamprootsampinamptextualampinterpretationampcanampbeampdefinedampasamp
aamptraditionampofampthinkingamporampofampphilosophicalampreflectionampthatamptriesamptoampclarifyamptheampconceptamp
ofampverstehenampthatampisampunderstandingamp(Brunsamp1992)ampampRicoeuramp(19691974)ampexplainsamp
thatamptheampkeyamphypothesisampofamphermeneuticampphilosophyampisampthatampinterpretationampisampanampopenamp
processampwhichampnoampsingleampvisionampcanampconcludeamp(pamp109)ampampWithampthisampinampmindampIampwillamp
exploreamphermeneuticsampasampitampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp HansltGeorgampGadameramp(1900lt2002)ampinvestigatesampaampmoderateampformampofamp
hermeneuticsampthatampisampparticularlyamprelevantampinampserviceamptoampartampeducationampampGadameramp
breaksampwithamphermeneuticamptraditionampbyampproposingampthatampthereampisampnoampabsolutelyampobjectiveamp
interpretationampreadersampareampnotampableamptoampescapeamptheampprejudicesampofamptheiramptimeamp(Gallagheramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 16amp
1992)ampampThisamphoweverampbecomesampanampopportunityampforamptheampcreationampofampmeaningampInampaamp
passageampthatampechoesamptheampendlesslyampunfoldingampnatureampofampcollageampCaputoamp(2000)amprefersamp
toampanampexchangeampbetweenamppastampandamppresentampinamptheampcreativeamppossibilitiesampofamphermeneuticamp
interpretationamp
amp Thereampisampaamprichnessampinamphistoricalampeventsampthatampjustampkeepsampunfoldingampwhichampisamp
amp certainlyampnotampgraspedampbyamptheamporiginalampprotagonistsampwhichampgraduallyampunfoldsamp
amp overamptheampcourseampofamptimeampandampwhichampisampinampprincipleampneverampfullyampunfoldedampItampisamp
amp anampexcessampwhichampkeepsampspillingampoveramp(pamp47)amp
amp Gadamersampphilosophyampofamphermeneuticampunderstandingampisampformedampthroughamphisamp
notionsampaboutamplanguageampdialogueampandampconversationamp(Caputoamp2000ampSeebohmamp2004)ampamp
InampadditionamptoampGadamersampimplicitamprelianceamponamplisteningampasampheampdiscussesampdialogueamphisamp
workampcapitalizesamponamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampinamplanguageamp(Heelanamp1985)ampmakingamphisamp
formampofamphermeneuticsampparticularlyampapplicableamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp Gadamersamptermampfusion-of-horizonsamprefersamptoamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampwithinampaamp
varietyampofampencountersampampAampfusionampofamphorizonsampcanampbeampdescribedampasampaampdialogicamp
conversationampbetweenampreaderampandamptextamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampWithinamptheamptextualamp
paradigmampGadamerampbelievesampthatampaampwrittenamptextampisampopenamptoampanampinvisibleampandampindefiniteamp
readerampwhoampentersampintoampanampunknownampadventureampofamptheamptextamp(Ricoeuramp2013amppamp13)ampamp
Theamphorizonampitselfampisamptheamprangeampofampvisionampthatampincludesampeverythingampthatampcanampbeampseenamp
fromampaampparticularampvantageamppointamp(Gadameramp2004amppamp301)ampampLikeampcollageamptheampfusionampofamp
horizonsampisampaampprocessampcomposedampofamppastampandamppresentampwhichampareampopenamptoampandampinfinitelyamp
effectedampbyampeachampotheramp(Bourgeoisamp2007)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 17amp
amp Similarampconnectionsampcanampbeampdrawnampwhenampviewerampandampartworkampareampsubstitutedamp
forampreaderampandamptextampampInterpretationampandampunderstandingampbecomeampanampentwinedamp
creativeampendeavorampinampwhichamptheampviewerampparticipatesampasampmuchampasamptheampcreatorampbyamp
constructingampmeaningamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampPalmeramp(1969)ampalludesamptoamptheamppluralityampofamp
meaningampinampstatingampthatamptoampfocusamppurelyamponamptheamppositivityampofampwhatampaamptextampexplicitlyamp
saysampisamptoampdoampanampinjusticeamptoamptheamphermeneuticalamptaskamp(pamp234)ampampToampfocusamponampwhatampisamp
explicitampinampaampcollageampworkampwouldampbeamptoampdisregardamptheampconnectionsampandampcontradictionsamp
ofamptheampwholeampinampfavorampofampaampdirectampreadingampofamptheampindividualamppartsampthusampmissingampoutamponamp
otheramppossibleampdimensionsampofampmeaningamp
amp Theampkeyamptoamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampeducationampinamptextampandampbetweenamp
individualsampisamptheampabilityamptoamplistenampwithampopennessampampDefensiveamplisteningampisampaampwayampofamp
listeningampwithoutampopennessampitampisampaampwayampofampprotectingampourampsmallampversionampofamptheampworldamp
andampavoidingampmoralampclaimsamponampourselvesamp(Levinamp1989amppamp79)ampampLevinamp(1989)amp
discussesampplayfulamplisteningamp(pamp233)ampasampaampwayampofampcounteractingampdefensiveamplisteningampampamp
Bohmamp(1996)ampdiscussesampsuspendingampassumptionsampaampprocessampofampattendingamptoamp
assumptionsampratherampthanamprepressingampthemamporampcarryingampthemampoutampampNicholamp(1996)amp
explainsampaampcircumstanceampinampwhichampyouampencounterampaamppersonampyouampfeelampisampanampidiotampampampYouamp
wouldamprefrainampfromampsayingampsoampoutamploudampbutampyouampwouldampalsoamprefrainampfromampscoldingamp
yourselfampforampthisampthoughtampratherampyouampwouldampseeampthisampreactionampwithoutampfullyampengagingamp
withampitampampSimilarampsuggestionsamplikeampbracketingampofampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampareamp
discussedampinamptheampfollowingampsectionampamp
amp Gadamerampbelievesamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampwhatampallowsamptheampselfamptoampapproachamp
theampotherampitampisampaampprocessampinampwhichamptheampideasampofamptheampotherampbecomeamponesampownamp(Caputoamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 18amp
2000)ampampThisampisamphardlyampanampuncommonampexperienceampampInampfactampweampregularlyampencounteramptheamp
fusionampofamphorizonsampbyampintegratingamppastampunderstandingsampwithampcurrentampexperiencesampaamp
processampundoubtedlyampcomparableamptoampeducationamp(Zuckertamp2002)ampamp
amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsamplikeampeducationampcanampbeampfrustratingampandampemotionalamp
becauseampeachamphighlight[s]amptheampfinitudeampofamptheampinterpreterampandamptheamplimitationsampofamphisamp
understandingamp(Bourgeoisamp2007amppamp79)ampampTheamptermampsharesampsimilaritiesampwithamptheamp
problematic-momentampaamppedagogicalamptermampreferringamptoampaampbreachampinampaampdominantampgroupsamp
discourseampduringampwhichampsomethingamprepressedamparisesamp(KentampampampCummingamp2008)ampampKentamp
andampCummingamp(2008)ampexploreamptheampproblematicampmomentampasampaampdiscursiveampsiteampforamp
examiningampprejudiceampwithinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampandampitsamp
moreamppoliticallyampchargedampcounterpartamptheampproblematicampmomentampbothampexploreamp
Gadamersamp(1996)ampampassertionampthatamptheampotherampmayampnotamponlyamphaveampaamprightampbutampmayamp
actuallyampbeamprightampmayampunderstandampsomethingampbetterampthanampweampdoamp(pamp82)ampampAampcreativelt
listeningampspaceamplivesampinampthisamppossibilityampampamp
amp Lastlyamprelayingampofampappropriateampexpectationsamptoampparticipantsampisampaampnecessaryamp
featureampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampdemandingampampItamp
requiresampparticipantsampwhoampareampawareampofamptheamprisksampandamphardshipsamptoampenterampintoampitampampItamp
isamptheampresponsibilityampofamptheampeducatoramporampgroupampleaderamptoampmakeamptheseampexpectationsamp
knownampasampwellampasamptoampmodelampthisampbehaviorampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionamphermeneuticallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Areampopenamptoamppossibilitiesampandamptoamptheampotherampbull Conceiveampofampthemselvesampasampengagingampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamptheamprisksampinvolvedampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamplimitationsampofamptheirampunderstandingamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 19amp
Dialogic(Practices(-
I-felt-that-everyone-was-open-and-interested-in-what-I-had-to-say---Perhaps-I-felt-this-sense-of-understanding-due-to-the-nature-of-the-discussion((-
it-felt-[like]-more-[of]-a-dialogue-as-opposed-to-a-standard-critique-(Survey-response-MW-age-22)-
(amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampartampeducationampreliesamponampanampopenampdialogueampduringamp
experiencesampwithampartampselfampandampothersampampWhatampIampfoundamplackingampinamphermeneuticsamp
howeverampwasampaampdiscussionampofamptheamphowltlthowampisamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampachievedampandamp
howampdoampindividualsampmeaningfullyampengageampwithampeachampotherampampInampanampeffortamptoampclarifyampthisamp
Iampwillampdiscussampdialogicamppracticesampasamptheyamprelateamptoampmeaningfulampverbalampexchangesampandamp
listeningampencountersampinamptheampclassroomampandampstudioampamongstampstudentsamptheiramppeersampandamp
educatorsamp
amp Communicatingampthroughamplanguageampandampdialogueampisamphowampweampcoltconstructamp
worldsampwithampourselvesampandampothersampnotampjustampthroughampanampactampofamptransmissionampbutamp
becauseampourampcommunicativeampactsampgiveampbirthamptoampworldsamp(Lipariamp2014amppamp507)ampampSableamp
(2014)ampdescribesampdialogueampasampaampgenerativeampinterchangeampbetweenampparticipantsampasamp
opposedamptoampanampexchangeampofampviewsampwhereampindividualsampsimplyampadvocateamptheiramppositionsamp
(pamp8)ampampForampBohmamp(1996)ampitampisampaampstreamampofampmeaningampflowingampamongampandampthroughampusamp
(pamp6)ampampTheampnatureampofampdialogueampandampconversationampisampinherentlyampunplannedampampThisamp
dimensionampofampconversationampisampimportantamptoampGadameramp(2004)ampwhoampfindsampthatamp
participantsampinvolvedampinampconversationampareamplessamptheampleadersampofampitampthanamptheampledamp(pamp
385)ampampSableamp(2014)ampechoesampthisampbyampwritingampthatamptheampmostampimportantamppartsampofampanyamp
conversationampareampthoseampthatampneitheramppartyampcouldamphaveampimaginedampbeforeampstartingamp(pamp
8)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 20amp
amp Theseampareampnotionsampofampdialogueampamongampothersampthatampfindampaampparallelampinamptheamp
creativeampprocessampampFairfieldamp(2011)ampwritesampthatampinampprincipleampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinamp
dialogueamp(pamp83)ampaampsentimentampthatampalignsampwithampaampcommonampissueampencounteredampduringamp
theampcreativeampprocessltltnotampknowingampwhenampaamppieceampisampdoneampampAampquoteampoftenampattributedamp
toampLeonardoampdaampVinciampspeaksamptoampthisampideaampArtampisampneverampfinishedamponlyampabandonedampamp
Snowberamp(2007)ampdrawsampparallelsampbetweenampmentorshipampdialogueampandamptheampcreativeamp
processampfindingampthatampdeepamplisteningamppracticesampconnectampallampthreeampampSheampfindsampthatamptheamp
taskampofamptheampmentorampisamptheampsameampasamptheamptaskampofamptheampartistampthatampisamptoampbringampoutamptheamp
naturalampqualitiesampofamptheampstudentamporamptheampmediumampampSnowberamp(2007)ampcommentsamponampanamp
ideaampwellltknownampamongampartistsampwhichampisampthatampaampworkampofampartamphasampaamplifeampofampitsampownampthisamp
notionampisampreminiscentampofampGadamersampstatementampaboutampbeingampledampbyampconversationamp
ampamp Dialogicamppracticesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampeducationampemphasizeampaamp
phenomenologicalampdimensionamprequiringamptwoampthingsampfromampparticipantsampampFirstlyamp
participantsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampmustampfindampvalueampinamplisteningamptoamptheamp
narrativesampofamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampampTheseampparticipantsampknowampthatampeducationamp
isampforemostampaboutamptestimonyampaboutampsharingamptheampexperienceampofampbeingamphumanampsharingamp
lifeampconvictionsampandampknowledge((Wiercinskiamp2011amppamp109)ampampNarrativesampareamp
conceivedampofampasampaampwayampofamphumanampknowingamp(Vitanovaamp2010amppamp29)ampthatampmakesamptheamp
selfampampSecondlyampwhenamplisteningamptoamptheampnarrativesampofampothersampparticipantsampareampexpectedamp
toampbracketamptheirampownampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsamp(LindsethampampampNorbergamp2004)ampampThisamp
encouragesamplistenersamptoampexperienceampandampfindampmeaningampinamptheampnarrativesampofampothersamp
whileampfreeingamptheampspeakerampfromamptheampfearampofampbeingampjudgedampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 21amp
amp Bracketingampjudgmentampandampconclusionampisampaamppotentialamptoolampwithinamptheampcommonamp
artampeducationamppracticeampofampgroupampcritiquesampampElkinsamp(2001)ampfindsampthatamppeopleampwhoamphaveamp
experienceampinampartampjudgeampveryampquicklyampandampmostampteachersampwillamphaveampaampprovisionalamp
opinionampaboutampaampworkampinamptheampfirstamptenampsecondsamp(pamp121)ampampBracketingampconclusionampandamp
judgmentampisampparticularlyampimportantampforampeducatorsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
whoseampvolumeampofampviewingampexperiencesampcouldampleadamptoampeasyampassumptionsampwhenamp
encounteringampaampnewampworkampampamp
amp Elkinsamp(2001)ampdiscussesampthatampcritiquesampcanampalsoampbeampseenampasampexchangesampofamp
storiesamporampcollaborativeampstorytellingamp(pamp145)ampwhichampisampyetampanotherampwayampofamptalkingamp
aboutamppossibilitiesampforampdialogueampandampnarrativeampwithinampartampeducationampampElkinsamphoweveramp
findsampstorytellingamplimitingamponceamptheampdeeperampnarrativesampareampdiscoveredamp(2001amppamp
145)ampampThisampimpliesampthatampheampfindsamponlyampaampsingularampmeaningampandamponeampthatampisampnotamp
necessarilyampusefulampforampcollaborativeampgroupampcritiquesamp
amp Insteadampparticipantsampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampbringampknowledgeampofamp
polysemyamptoampcollaborativeampcritiqueampexperiencesampasampwellampasamptoampexperiencesampofampmakingamp
artworkampampAccordingamptoampMuldoonamp(2002)amppolysemyampisamptheampqualityampofampaampwordamporampotheramp
languageampunitampthatampcanampbearampmultipleampmeaningsamp(asampcitedampinampWorsleyamp2012amppamp308)ampampamp
Aamptextualampexampleampofampthisampisamptheampmultipleampmeaningsampofamptheampwordampcan-Iampcanampdriveampaampcaramp
Idamplikeampaampcan-ofampsodaampheampwasntampworkingampveryamphardampsoampIamphadamptoampcan-himamp(Munozamp
2014)ampampampButampifampweampconsideramppolysemyampmetaphoricallyamporampvisuallyamptheampideaampthatampaamp
singleampunitampimageamporampintentionampcouldampbearampmultipleampmeaningsampcouldampbeampproductiveampinamp
creatingltlisteningampspacesampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 22amp
amp Thisampunfoldingampofampmeaningampworksampwellampinamptheampcontextampofampcollageampandampdialogueamp
asampwellampasamphermeneuticsampampInampfactamphermeneuticsampimpliesamppolysemyampbecauseampofampitsamp
notionampthatampitampisampalwaysampaamppossibilityampofampmyampunderstandingampthatampisampplayedampoutampwhenampIamp
understandampaamptextamp(Grondinamp2002amppamp38)ampampPolysemyampcouldampbeampconceptualizedampasampanamp
alternativeampexplorationampofampmeaningampthatampfunctionsampcollaborativelyampwithinampcritiquesampamp
Forampexampleampeducatorsampcanampaskampstudentsamptoamprespondamptoampaampworkampthroughampcollageamp
journalampentriesampmusicampfilmampasampindividualsamporampinampgroupsampampKnowledgeampofamppolysemyamp
couldampalsoampbeampusedampasampaamptoolampforampcreatingampimagesampthatamprecognizesampaamprelationshipamp
betweenamptheampvisualamptheamplinguisticampandamptheampmultipleamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionampdialogicallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Placeampvalueamponampexperientialampnarrativesampbull Practiceamplisteningampbyampbracketingampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampbull Embraceamppolysemicampexplorationsampofampmeaningampamp
Contemplative(Practices(
I-knew-I-was-being-heard-because-of-her-mannerisms-and-the-look-on-her-face--She-was-calm-attentive-and-not-trying-to-jump-in-and-offer-any-advice--She-asked-questions-that-pointed-to-things-I-had-not-openly-articulated-because-of-uncertainty--
This-was-one-of-the-ways-I-knew-I-was-being-heard-(Survey-response-LS-age-27)-
(amp Ifamphermeneuticsampandampdialogicamppracticesampgiveampusamptheampbroadampstrokesampofampactivityampinamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampcontemplativeamppracticesampseekamptoamptuneampstudentsampandamp
educatorsampintoampnuanceampdeliberationampandampdeepampexplorationampampThisampisampaampmostlyamp
individualampinternalamppursuitampthatampfocusesamponampformsampofampselfltlisteningampbutampcontemplativeamp
practicesampareampalsoampformedampbyampanampawarenessampofampinterconnectednessamp
amp InamppursuitampofampcriticalampthinkingampSableamp(2014)ampoutlinesampaampsetampofampcontemplativeamp
practicesampforampstudentsampthatampincludeampmindfulampmeditationampstructuredampcontemplationamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 23amp
journalampwritingampmindfulamplisteningampreflectiveampinquiryampandampdialogueamp(pamp4)ampampWhileamp
Sablesamp(2014)ampmethodampforampcontemplativeamppracticesampprovidesampaampconcreteampframeworkamp
withampspecificampstepsampmanyampofamptheseampconceptsampcouldampbeampappliedampwithoutampsuchampaamp
prescribedampstructureampampForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwillampbeamp
primarilyampdiscussingampSablesampconceptsampofampstructuredampcontemplationampreflectiveamp
inquiryampandampjournalampwritingamp
amp ForampSableamp(2014)ampstructuredampcontemplationampisampaampformampofampbeingamppresentampandamp
focusedamponampaampparticularampquestionampstatementamporampimageampampWithinampthisampmodeampofampinquiryamp
participantsampareampexpectedamptoampholdamptheampobjectampofampcontemplationampinamptheirampmindsamp
deepeningampunderstandingampasamptheyampfocusampwithoutampanalyzingampitamporampmanipulatingampitampinamp
anyampwayamp(pamp5)ampampThisamppracticeampdrawsampcomparisonsamptoamptheampbracketingampofampjudgmentsamp
andampconclusionsampsupportedampinamptheamppreviousampsectionampbutampstructuredampcontemplationamp
occursamponampanampindividualamplevelampratherampthanampdialogicallyamp
amp Reflectiveampinquiryampbearsampsomeampsimilaritiesamptoampstructuredampcontemplationampbutamp
Sableamp(2014)amppositionsampitampasampanampactivityampbetweenamptwoampindividualsampaamplistenerampandampaamp
speakerampampTheamplistenerampisampagainampaskedamptoampsuspendampjudgmentampbutampalsoamptoampengageampinampaamp
formampofampcuriosityampinampwhichampinnocentampquestionsampareampaskedampinamporderamptoampgainamp
understandingampampSableamp(2014)ampcontrastsampinnocentampquestionsampwithampleadingampquestionsampamp
ForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwouldampcharacterizeampthisampinnocentamp
questioningampasampaampformampofampopenltendedampquestioningampampSableamp(2014)ampidentifiesampanamp
exampleampofampanampinnocentamp(orampopenltended)ampquestionampWhatampdidampyouampmeanampwhenampyouamp
saidamp________ampConverselyampaampleadingampquestionampisampDidampyouampmeanamptoampsayamp________ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 24amp
amp Sableamp(2014)ampusesampjournalampwritingampasampaamppieceampofamphisamplargerampstructureampofamp
contemplativeamppracticesampbutampjournalampwritingampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampcouldamp
potentiallyampoccupyampaampsignificantamproleampampIampconceiveampofampjournalampwritingampinampmyampownamp
creativeamppracticeampasampaampformampofampdocumentationampthatampmakesampmeampmoreampawareampofampmyamp
creativeampprocessamptheampemotionalamphabitsampthatampsurroundampitampandamptheampthemesampthatamp
structureampmyampworkampampIampconceptualizeampthisampwayampofampwritingampasampaampformampofampselfltlisteningamp
relatedamptoampaampkeyampconceptampofamphermeneuticsampfoundampinampGadamersampassertionampthatampallamp
educationampisampaampformampofampselflteducationamp(Grondinamp2011)ampampamp
amp Germeraadamp(2013)ampusesampjournalampwritingamptoampexploreamptheampemotionalampandamprationalamp
relationshipsamptoamphisampcreativeampprocessampparallelamptoampexecutingampaampnewampbodyampofampworkampampHeamp
findsampthatampwritingampduringamphisampprocessampisampaamptoolamptoampunderstandamp[his]amppsycheamptoampeaseamp
theamppainampthatampanampartisticampprocessampcanampbringampandamptoamprelieveampartisticampblocksamp
(Germeraadamp2013amppamp21)ampultimatelyampdeclaringampthatampitamphelpsamphimamptoampbetterampunderstandamp
hisampworkampampInampaampstyleampofampwritingampthatamposcillatesamparoundampjournalingampdocumentationampandamp
poetryampdeampCossonamp(2002)ampexploresamphisampoverlappingamprolesampasampanampartistampresearcherampandamp
teacherampampOtherampartistsampbluramptheamplineampbetweenampartamppracticeampdocumentationampandamplifeamp
furtherampstillampbyampofferingampdocumentationampasampartamplikeampSophieampCalleamp(Calleamp2011amp2008amp
2005)ampandampMaryampKellyamp(1973lt1979)ampampamp
amp Karpiakamp(2003)ampestablishesampcontemplativeamppracticesampfromamptheampperspectiveampofamp
theampeducatorampaskingampthemamptoampmineamptheampsubtleamp(pamp71)ampusingampattentivenessamp
attunementampamplificationampandampassociationampampTheseampexercisesampinampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampsetamptheamptoneampasampwellampasampprovideampaampmodelampofampbehaviorampforampotherampparticipantsamp
withinamptheampspaceampampKarpiakamp(2003)ampoutlinesampactivitiesampthatampeducatorsampcanampuseamptoampdrawamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 25amp
outampandamputilizeamptheseampsubtleampsensationsampinamptheampserviceampofamptransformativeamplearningamp(pamp
68)ampampamp
amp ForampKarpiakamp(2003)ampattentivenessamprequiresampawarenessamptoampverbalampandamp
nonverbalampcuesampasampwellampasampanampawarenessampofampwhatampisamphappeningampamongampandampwithinamptheamp
studentsampandamptheampeducatorampampAttunementamprequiresampanampeducatoramptoamporientampherselfamptoamptheamp
otherampandamptoampadoptampanampattitudeampofampunhurriednessampofamppatienceampandampofamphumilityamp
concerningampbothamptheampprocessampandamptheampoutcomesampofamptheampteachingamp(Karpiakamp2003amppgamp
72)ampampAmplificationampisampaampprocessampofamphonoringampcommunicationampthatampcentersamponamptheampideaamp
ofamphearingamponeselfampintoampknowingampitampincludesampusingampparaphrasingampandampclarificationamp
activitiesamptoampgainampinsightampintoampmeaningampampLastlyampassociationampentailsampidentifyingamp
patternsampandampweavingampthemamptogetherampwithampstudentampexperienceampclassroomampdiscussionamp
andamptheampideasampofampothersamp
amp TuningampintoampsubtletyampimpliesampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceampampTheampmanifestationsamp
ofampsilenceampinamptheampclassroomampareampendlessampandampitsampvalueampisamptooampgreatamptoampbeampignoredampwhileamp
tooampvastamptoampbeampfullyampabsorbedampampLevinamp(1989)ampremarksampthatampsilenceampisampaampclearingampwhereamp
thereampisampnothingampforamphearingamptoampholdamponamptoampinampwhichampmanyampfindampunbearableampanxietyamp
(pamp79)ampampNearlyampallampofampusamphaveampexperiencedampthisampunbearableampanxietyampaampstrainampofamp
whichampcanampbeampfoundampinampeducationalampcontextsampdueamptoamptheampfactampthatampclassroomsampareamp
oftenampstructuredamparoundampimplicitampandampexplicitamprulesampaboutamptalkampandampsilenceamp(Schultzamp
2010amppamp2848)ampampForampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampanampawarenessampofampsilenceampimplicatesamp
whatampisampleftampunsaidampandampwhatampisampunsayableltltespeciallyampimportantampbecauseampofamptheamp
unsayableampqualityampofampartworksampampForampSchultzamp(2010)ampsilenceampimpliesamppossibilityamp
becauseampitampcanampholdampmultipleampmeaningsampforampindividualsampwithinampandampacrossampracialamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 26amp
ethnicampandampculturalampgroupsamp(pamp2833)ampampLevinamp(1989)ampfindsampthatamptoamplistenamptoamp
somethingampweampmustampfirstampgive-itampourampsilenceamp(pamp232)ampampThisamppracticeampofampgivingampsilenceamp
isampparticularlyamphelpfulampinamptermsampofampviewingamporamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartamp
amp Gradleamp(2011)ampoutlinesampaamppracticalampvisionampforampviewingampartampthatamprequiresamp
silenceampandampdeliberationampampForamptheamppurposesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampwouldamp
reconceptualizeampthisampasampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampampGradleamp(2011)ampinstructedamp
herampstudentsamptoampspendamptimeampwithampaampworkampofampartampoutsideampofamptheirampeverydayampworldviewamp
attentivelyampviewingampitampforampaboutamptenampminutesampeverydayampforampaampweekampampAfterampeachampviewingamp
experienceamptheampstudentsampwroteampinamptheirampjournalsampampTheampresultsampindicatedampthatampthisamp
processampofampsustainedampsilentampdeliberationampcoupledampwithampanampengagementampofamptheiramp
intuitiveampperceptionsampaboutampartworkampleftampstudentsampfeelingampempoweredamptoampengageampinamp
discussionampandampappreciateampunfamiliarampartampformsampampThisampactivityampisampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoamp
aampworkampofampartampthatampincorporatesampSablesamp(2014)ampconceptampofampstructuredampcontemplationampamp
Weavingampaamprelationshipampbetweenampsilenceampcontemplationampandampattentivenessampisampaamp
significantampendeavorampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
Contemplativeamppracticesampfunctionampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Engageampinampformsampofampviewingampwritingampandampexperiencingampthatamphonorampselfltlisteningamp
bull Attuneamptoampsubtletyampandampnuanceampbull Listenampandampviewampdeliberatelyampbull Cultivateampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceamp(
The(Felt(Sense(
When-someone-understands-what-I-am-talking-about-when-I-talk-about-art-I-am-delighted--Art-is-my-everything--Its-my-passion--When-someone-understands-that-I-
am-instantly-filled-with-joy--That-tells-me-someone-gets-it-(Survey-response-CTF-age-16)-
(
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 3amp
amp amp SurveyampThemesampamp37amp
amp CreativeltListeningampSpaceampCaseampStudiesampamp39amp
thread7ampRespondingamptoampResponseampLayersampofampListeningampUnderstandingampamp40amp
thread8amp(In)Conclusionsampamp47amp
looseampendsampReferencesampamp53amp
braidsampArtworkampReferencesampamp58amp
Appendixampamp61amp
amp
amp
amp
ampamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 4amp
Acknowledgements(
ThankampyouamptoampLaurenampNanditaampandampShannonampforampbeingampexcellentampwonderfulampartamp
educatorsampwhoampmakeampmyampworldampaampbetterampplaceampampYouampeachampteachampmeampnewampthingsampaboutamp
artampallamptheamptimeampandampIamploveampyouampforampitamp
ThankampyouamptoampDrampVittoriaampSampDaielloampforampbeingampanampexcellentamplistenerampampNoamponeampelseamp
wouldamphaveampencouragedampmyampweirdnessampinampsuchampspecificampwaysampampYouampareampmyamproleampmodelamp
Thankampyouamptoampmyampparentsampforamplettingampmeampbeampanampartistampandamphelpingampmeampwithampeverythingamp
ThankampyouamptoampPampforampgivingampmeamptheampbestampcritiquesampandampneveramplettingampmeampgetampawayampwithamp
anythingampampThankampyouampforamplettingampmeampcryampwheneverampIampwantampamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 5amp
(thread1(
The(Possibility(of(Possibilities(Creative=Listening(Spaces(in(Art(Education(
TheampartsampinampeducationampshouldampthusamprecognizeamppossibilitiesampthatampopenampnewamphorizonsampinampbothampformampandampsubstanceampampThisampisamptrueampnotamponlyampinamptheampartsampbutampalsoampinampeducationampinampitsampvariousampmanifestationsampampTheamppossibilitiesampofamptheampworkampofampartampmustampbeampcentralampmustampbeamphonoredampampIfampweampcanamphonoramptheampvisualamppoeticampandampgesturalamppossibilitiesampinamptheampartsampweamp
thenampcanampbeginamptoampunderstandamptheampopeningsampmadeampaccessibleampbyampamplivingampin-theampquestionsamp(Greeneamp2013amppamp252)amp
ampamp
amp CollageampholdsamphighampesteemampinampmyampcreativeamppracticeampampItampisampnotampthatampIampvalueampitsamp
visualampimpactampoverampotherampformsampofampmediaampnorampdoampIampenjoyampitampmoreampthanampotherampmodesampofamp
creativeampexpressionampampSimplyampputampcollageampisampusuallyampwhatampgetsampmeampunstuckampampItampisamptheamp
leverampIampuseamptoampfreeampmyselfampfromampaampdisappointingampdrawingampampInsteadampofamplaboringampoverampaamp
workamporampthrowingampawayampanampotherwiseampinoffensiveamppieceampofamppaperampIampuseampcollageampasampaamp
lastltditchampeffortamptoampmakeampsomethingltltanythingltltthatampIampdontamphaveamptoampstruggleampagainstampamp
Theampdrawingampisamptornampupamppaintedampoverampstapledampsewedamptogetherampcutampintoampstripsampandamp
wovenampampMaybeampitsampjustampthrownampinampmyampdrawerampofampsadampbadampdrawingsampthatampareampallamp
waitingampforamptheamprightampmomentamptoampbecomeampnewampampTheamppointampisampwhatampbeganampasampaampbadamp
drawingampandamppossiblyampaampbadamporampfrustratingampexperienceampdoesntamphaveamptoampremainampinampmyamp
mentalamparchiveampofampDrawings-That-Have-FailedampampInsteadamptheseampworksampareampsimplyamp
deconstructedampandampfoldedampintoampanotheramppossibilityampampCollageampengagesampwithamptheampactampofamp
layeringampandamptheampsenseampofampfearlessnessampgainedampwhenampIampholdampontoamptheampfactampthatampthereampisamp
alwaysampanotheramppossibilityampforampaampworkampamp
amp Theampphysicalampactampofamplayeringamphoweverampisampinampserviceamptoampaampdeeperampsenseampofamptheamp
wordampampWhenampweamparticulateamppowerfulampviewingampexperiencesampwordsampoftenampfailampusampampWeamp
mayampsayampthatampweampfeelampaampclickampaampconnectionamporampanampaestheticampexperienceampwhenampviewingampaamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 6amp
pieceampampTheseampareampwaysampweampexpressamptheampprelinguisticampfeltampdimensionsampofampbeingampwithampaamp
workampofampartampampTemporallyampthisamptakesampplaceampwithinampaampsingleampmomentampinamptimeampampButamp
meaningfulampencountersampwithampartampareamponlyampmeaningfulampbecauseamptheyampareampcomposedampofamp
countlessamppreviousampmomentsampwordsampexperiencesampknowledgeampconversationsamp
relationshipsampandampallamptheampminutiaampthatampconstituteampanampindividualsampidentityampampInampthisamp
conceptionampofampmeaningltmakingamptheamplayersampofampexperiencesampwithinamptheampindividualamptheamp
groupampandamptheampspacesampbetweenampareamprespectedampforamptheirampvalueampinamptheampformationampofamp
singularampandampcollectiveampidentitiesamp
amp Oftenampviewersampandampeducatorsampdiscussampinterpretativeampprocessesampfromamp
frameworksampsuchampasampaampworksamppositionampinampartamphistoryamptheampbiographyampofamptheampartistamp
socialampimplicationsampandampsoamponampampThereampisampaampparallelamptoampbeampfoundamphereampinamptheampdrawingamp
processampampIfampweamppresupposeampthatampthereampisampaampcorrectampwayamptoampinterpretampandampaampperfectamp
drawingamptoampbeamphadampweamprunamptheampriskampofampnotamptryingampforampfearampofampfailureampampItsampnoampstretchamptoamp
sayampthatampindividualsampwhoamplackampartsampexperienceampareamphesitantamptoampengageampwithampaampworkampofamp
artampforampfearampofampexposingamptheirampsupposedampignoranceampampOnamptheampotheramphandampifampweampengageampinamp
aampwayampofampviewingampthatampidentifiesampwithamptheampfluidityampofampcollageampweampcanampacknowledgeamp
possibilityampasampaampfeatureampofampinterpretationampampByampconceivingampofampinterpretationampasampaampformamp
ofampcollagingamptogetherampmeaningfulampexperiencesampviewersampcouldampgainampaccessamptoamptheamp
complexamplayeredampandampmessyampdimensionsampofampmeaningampwhenamptheyamplistenamptoampaampworkampofamp
artamp
Creative=Listening(Space(
amp Iampofferamptheamptermampcreative(listening-spaceampasampanampalternativeampmodeampofamp
experiencingampviewingampandampproducingampcreativeampworksampampInsteadampofampplacingampsubjectamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 7amp
matterampinformationamporamptheamproleampofamptheampeducatorampatamptheampcenterampofamptheseampexperiencesampIamp
proposeampthatampactsampofamplisteningampbeampembeddedampinampmakingampandampviewingampartampampTheamptermamp
creativeltlisteningampspaceamprefersamptoamptheampfluidampandampflexibleampspaceampinampwhichamplisteningamp
practicesampareampanampintegratedampessentialamppartampofampviewingampdiscussingampandampproducingamp
creativeampworksampampArtistsampviewersampstudentsampandampeducatorsampcanamptransformampartamp
classroomsampstudiosampandampsitesampofampviewingampartampintoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhichampareamp
notampdefinedampbyampphysicalampformamporampstructuralampboundariesampampRatheramptheyampareampdefinedampbyamp
specificamppracticesampthatampoccurampamongstampindividualsampandampgroupsampinamptheampcontextampofampartamp
educationampamp
Research(Issue(
amp Theampoverarchingampconcernampinampthisampresearchampisamptheamppotentialampoutcomeampforampusingamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampwithinampartampeducationampampTheamppracticesampIampdiscussamphereamphaveampinamp
commonampaampdistinctiveampflexibilityampandampmalleabilityampampTheyampmayampbeampadaptedamptoampvariousamp
ageampgroupsampeducationalampsitesampandampcontextsampampWhileampIampofferampsuggestionsampIampexpectampthatamp
theamppractitionersampwhoampwishamptoampuseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwillampdeviseamptheirampownamp
methodsampofampimplementationampbasedamponamptheirampspecificampneedsampandampcontextsampampThoughamptheamp
ideaampofampcreativeamplisteningampspacesampemergedampwithinampanampartsampeducationampcontextampampthisamp
conceptampmayampholdampvalueampforampotherampdisciplinesamp
Boundaries(and(Limitations(of(the(Research(
( Iampundertookampthisampresearchampinampfulfillmentampofampaampmastersampdegreeampinampartampeducationamp
atamptheampUniversityampofampCincinnatisampCollegeampofampDesignampArtampArchitectureampandampPlanningamp
(DAAP)ampampTheampresponsesampexperiencesampandampartworkampgeneratedampduringamptheampcourseampofamp
thisampprojectamphaveampoftenampcenteredamparoundampthatampinstitutionampwhichamphousesampaampprimarilyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 8amp
whiteampmiddleltamptoampupperltclassampstudentamppopulationamponampanampurbanampcampusampampIampamampaampwhiteamp
femaleamppursuingamphigherampeducationampampIampwantamptoampacknowledgeampthisamppositionalityampalongamp
withamptheamppersonalampbiasesampaamplifetimeampofampexperiencesamphasampaffordedamptoampmeampampOneampinternalamp
goalampthatampdevelopedampoveramptheampcourseampofampthisampworkampwasampaampcontinuedampconsistentampeffortamp
toampuncoverampandampinterrogateampmyampownampbiasesampasamptheyampmanifestedampampThoughampweampcanampneveramp
beampfreeamporamppureampofamptheseampbiasesampconstantampexaminationampofampthemamphasampbeenampmyampchosenamp
routeamptoampcounteringamptheiramppowerampandampinfluenceampamp
Iampamamppassionateampaboutamptheampmeaningfulamppossibilitiesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampInamprespectampofampmyampownamplimitationsampandampthoseampofampthisampworkamphoweverampIampwillampnotamp
claimampthatampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampareampfeasibleampwithinamptheampcontextampofampeveryamp
educationalampsettingampnorampthatampthisampwayampofampviewingampmakingampandampexperiencingampworksampofamp
artampisampmoreamporamplessampvalidampthanampothersampampRatherampIampsuggestamptheamppossibilityampofamplivingampinamp
possibilitiesampasampaampwayamptoampcultivateampmeaningfulampencountersampwithinampartampandampartamp
educationamp
Data(
amp ForampthisampresearchampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponampthreeampformsampofampdataamp
participantampsurveysampcaseampstudiesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampandampreflectiveamppracticeamp
formsampofampartmakingampallampcollectedampduringampaampfourltmonthampperiodampampToampgatherampparticipantamp
responsesampfromamptheampsurveysampandampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampreliedamponampaampmultitudeampofamp
friendsamppeersampandampcolleaguesampampIampconnectedampwithamptheampmajorityampofamptheseampindividualsamp
duringamporampasampaampresultampofampmyampexperiencesampatampDAAPampampampIampusedamp37ampsurveyampresponsesampaboutamp
listeningampexperiencesampwithampaampparticipantampageamprangeampofamp14amptoamp47ampampParticipantsamp
educationalamplevelsampspannedamphighampschoolamptoampgraduateampschoolampampIamppersonallyampsolicitedamptheamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 9amp
majorityampofamptheamplisteningampsurveysampatamptheampcollegeamplevelampandampaboveampampTheampbulkampofamptheamphighamp
schoolltagedampresponsesampwereampsolicitedampbyampmyampcolleagueampaampphotographyampteacherampatampaamp
Cincinnatiltareaamphighampschoolamp
amp Iampconductedampfiveampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampexperiencesampwithampsixampindividualsampasamp
partampofampthisampresearchampagainampusingampmanyampofamptheamppersonalampandampprofessionalampconnectionsamp
cultivatedampthroughamptheampDAAPampprogramampampIampdeliberatelyampchoseamppeopleampwithampwhomampIamphadamp
variousamplevelsampandamptypesampofamprelationshipsampampIampwillampspeakampmoreampinltdepthampaboutamptheseamp
experiencesampasampwellampasampexploreamptheampsurveyampresponsesampinamptheampResearchampMethodologyamp
andampMethodsampsectionamp
amp Lastlyamptheampdevelopmentampofampanampartmakingamppracticeampwasampessentialamptoampmyampownamp
personalampunderstandingampofamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatampcomposedampmyampresearchamp
ReadersampwillampnoticeampthatampimagesampareampembeddedampinampthisamptextampampTheseampareampimagesampofamptheamp
resultingampproductsampofampaamppracticeampofampunderstandingampthroughampmakingampampIampwillampdiscussamp
themampthroughoutampvariousampsectionsampofampthisamppaperampampamp
Dear(Reader(The(Structure(of(this(Research(Paper(
DearampReader(s)amp
amp Letampmeampbreakampforampaampmomentampfromampstandardampacademicamprhetoricampbeforeampthisamp
paperampreallyampgetsampstartedampampIampknowampwhatampyoureampthinkingltltnineamppagesampinampandampthisamppaperamp
hasntampevenampstartedampyetampampAlasampthisampsectionampisampmyamponeampofampmyampfavoriteampandampmostampoftlt
skimmedamppassagesampofampanampacademicamppaperamptheampstructureampofamptheamppaperampampThisampisamptheamppartamp
whereamptheampwriterampsaysampwhatampshesampaboutamptoampsayampbeforeampsheampsaysampitampampampItsampanamp
organizationalampstrategyampandampitsampthrillingampampLuckilyampforampyouampniceamppersonampwhoampisamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 10amp
readingampthisamppaperampIamphaveampprovidedampaamptranslationampfromampthisamptextsamporiginalampAcademiaamp
intoampnormalltpeopleltlanguageamp
amp Theampstructureampofampthisamppaperampisampasampfollowsampamp(Im-about-to-tell-you-whats-in-this-
long-ass-paper)ampampFirstlyamppleaseampnoteampthatampIampuseamptheamptermampthreadampinamplieuampofampchapteramp
asampanamporganizationalampstructureampIamppreferamptheampformerampbecauseampofamphowampitsampconceptualamp
qualitiesamprelateamptoampmyampworkampamp(Thread-is-awesome-and-you-can-do-tons-of-stuff-with-it-
like-sew-knot-tie-weave-etc--Chapters-are-not-nearly-as-exciting)--Iampwillampfirstampshareamp
myampresearchersampreflexiveampnarrativeampamp(I-made-up-a-cool-story-about-this-project-to-
describe-where-it-all-came-from)ampampThenampIampshallampofferampaampdescriptionampofamptheampqualitiesampofampaamp
creativeltlisteningampspaceampamp(Yes-I-shall)ampampIampwillampdiscussamptheampliteratureampthatampinformsamptheamp
backboneampofampmyampresearchampGadamersamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamp
practicesampandampGendlinsamptheampfeltampsenseampamp(Like-a-typical-graduate-student-I-have-done-
an-insane-amount-of-reading-during-the-past-two-academic-years--A-significant-
portion-of-this-reading-has-been-dedicated-to-those-topics--Dont-ask-me-to-type-them-
out-again-because-Im-seriously-done)ampampTheseampsectionsampbeginampwithampaamppassageampderivedamp
fromampsurveyampresponsesampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampamp(I-got-a-bunch-of-people-to-fill-
out-surveys-for-this-research-and-then-I-put-those-responses-in-my-paper)ampampTheseamp
experiencesampwithamplisteningampwereampprovidedampbyampresearchampparticipantsampamp(Super-nice-
people-I-know-and-some-I-dont-helped-me-out)ampampTheyampareampthereamptoampgroundamptheamp
conceptualampframeworksampinamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampamp(This-basically-means-
none-of-this-research-is-worth-shit-unless-it-can-be-used-in-the-real-world((I-hope-youll-
agree)ampampIampwillampthenampshareampmyampresearchampmethodologyampandampmethodsampamp(Im-going-to-tell-
you-about-how-and-why-I-did-this-project-in-using-big-smart(sounding-words)ampampLastlyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 11amp
Iampwillampconcludeampwithamppossibilitiesampforampthisampresearchampamp(Ill-figure-out-what-I-learned-and-
share-it-with-you-my-new-best-friend-who-made-it-all-the-way-to-the-conclusions-
section)ampampInampthisamppaperampreadersampwillampnoticeamptransparentampimagesampinteractingampwithamptheamp
textampamp(Its-my-art-on-transparent-sheets-in-this-very-paper)ampampTheseampareampworksampofampartamp
thatampIampcreatedamptoampgroundamptheampresearchampinampaamppracticeampofampmakingamptheyampareamptheampphysicalamp
embodimentampofampconceptualampideasampandamptheyampareampalwaysamppresentamptoamptheampresearchampamp
(Research-papers-with-pictures-are-much-more-tolerable-am-I-right)amp
amp Hereampweampgoamp
amp
thread2(
Collaging(Experience1(
amp ImagineampthatampyouampareampanampartistampseatedampatampyourampstudioamptableampampYouamphaveamp
everythingampyouampneedampampTheamproomampisampquietampsaveampforamptheampmuffledampsoundsampofampaampdistantamp
outsideampworldampampYouampsurveyamptheampcollectionampofampimagesampyouamphaveampgatheredamparoundampyouampamp
OnampyouramprightampisampaampraggedamppageampfromampanampoldampsketchbookampampGlossyampjewellttonedampswatchesamp
fromampaampdiscardedampfashionampmagazineampareampstackedampupampglisteningampinamptheamplightampampMonthsamp
agoampyouamppickedampupampaamphandfulampofampblackampandampwhiteampphotosampfromampaampsecondhandampstoreamp
todayamppastyampfacesampofamptheampunknownampsubjectsampstareampthroughampyouampblanklyampampAamppaleampyellowamp
scrapampofampleftoverampfabricampisampdrapedampoveramplastampweeksamppleatedamptoltdoamplistampampTheseampandamptwoamp
dozenampotherampscrapsamppiecesamppilesampandampcrumbsampareampyouramptoolsamptodayampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampamp1ampThisampsectionampisampsupposedamptoampbeampmyampresearchersampreflexiveampnarrativeampaamppassageampaboutampwhereampmyampresearchampideasampcameampfromltltandampinampfactampcollageampisampactuallyampwhereampthisampideaampcomesampfromampampOneampofamptheampfirstampresearchampinterestsampIampdiscussedampwithampmyampprofessorampDrampKristopherampHollandampwasamplayersampbothampphysicalampandampconceptualampampHeampwasamplikeampOhampampYoureamptalkingampaboutamphermeneuticsampSoampinampaampwayampthisampresearchampprojectampbothampbeganampandampconcludedamp(moreamponampthatamplater)ampwithampideasampofamplayeringampandampcollageampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 12amp
amp TheampresidueampthatampclingsamptoamptheseampscrapsampisampexperienceampampTheampoldampsketchbookamp
pageampisampanampimageampofampaampwomansamplegamprenderedampwithampchunkyamppencilampstrokesampampYouampmadeampitamp
whenampyouampwereamplivingampinampyourampoldampapartmentampoverlookingamptheampsquareampampItsampaampwomansamp
footampbutampitampremindsampyouampofamphavingampaamproommateampandampaampgrayampfutonampandampaampsummerampthatamp
wasampdesperatelyamphotampampItampisamponlyamppencilamponamppaperampbutampitampremindsampyouampofamptheampgreenamp
grassyampcenterampinamptheampmedianampofamptheampstreetampampOneamppencilampdrawingampofampaampwomansamplegamp
remindsampyouampofampthatampoldamplifeampandamptheampversionampofampyourselfampyouampwereampthenampitampisamptheampfirstamp
dominoampinampaampseriesampofampcascadingampdetailsampandampmemoriesampamp
amp EachampfragmentampsittingamponampyourampstudioamptableamphasampaampstoryampampEachampcameampfromampaamp
placeampandampwasamptouchedampbyampanotheramphumanampampEachampisampembeddedampwithampexperienceampcoloramp
memoryamptextureampandampinfiniteampdetailampbyamptheampmereampfactampofampitsampownampexistenceampamp
amp YouampbeginamptoamppickampapartamptheampephemeraampampYouampalternateampbeingampcarefulampandamp
carelessamp
amp Cuttingamptearingampburningampstretchingampfoldingampwhitewashingamprippingampcreasingamp
sewingampwritingamppaintingampencasingampfasteningampfillingampsoakingampdyeingampwashingamp
dryingampbitingampscratchingamppryingampyankingampsmoothingampsandingamppokingampstabbingamp
stretchingampfryingampheatingampdustingampcleaningampsculptingampslicingampdicingamppunchingamp
floatingamptwistingampflippingampdrippingampstaplingampstrippingampstripingamppatterningamp
designingampdrawingampsketchingampliftingampcollectingamptapingampgluingampbuttoningampknottingamp
weavingampknittingamp
amp YouampdoampallampofamptheseampthingsampandampprobablyampmanyampotherampthingsampampTheampfragmentsamponamp
youramptableampchangeampshapeampandampgetampsmallerampampFromamptheseamppiecesampyouampbeginamptoampbuildamp
somethingampampThisampsomethingampisampbothampnewampandampoldampampJuxtapositionsampbloomampnewamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 13amp
connectionsampareampfusedampbyamptheampweightampofamppreviousampexperienceampampPastampandamppresentamp
liquefyampintoampendlesslyampcirculatingamppossibilitiesampampYouampcouldamptheoreticallyampcontinueampthisamp
processampofamplayeringampandampreconstructionampforeverampamptheamponlyamplimitsampareampyourampownamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 14amp
thread3(
what(is(a(creative=listening(space(
ampampampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeamplisteningampspaceampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampwhatampdoesampitampsoundampsmellamptasteampfeelamplikeampampampampampampampwhatampampisampamptheampamptextureampampofampampthisampampamp
spaceampampampanswerampmoreampquestionsampampamp specificsampandampgeneralizationsampareampbothampimpossibleampampmaybeampaampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampgoodampstartampwouldampbeampthisampampamp amp amp amp amp safeampampampamp amp amp amp amp foldedampampamp amp amp amp amp amp embodiedampamp layeredampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampconnectedampampampamp amp ampamp
(it-might--be-like-gently-holding-on-to--
a-knot-of-questions)-amp
ampampampampampampampampampamp
(possible)ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 15amp
thread4amp(
Review(of(Literature((
( AnampexplorationampofampGadamerrsquosamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampeducationalampcontextsampandampGendlinrsquosamptheoryampofampfeltampsenseampwereampintegralamptoamp
theampcreationampofamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampWhileampcompellingampconstructsamponamp
theirampownampwhenampdrawnamptogetheramptheseampphilosophicalampperspectivesampvibrateamp
holisticallyamptoampsuggestampintriguingamppossibilitiesampforamptheampuseampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
inampartsampeducationampampInampthisampsectionampIampreviewamptheampliteratureampandampconnectamptheampvariousamp
pointsampofampstudyampampamp
Hermeneutics(amp(the(Fusion(of(Horizons((
It-actually-feels-really-great-knowing-that-other-people-will-enjoy-the-art-you-created-and-knowing-they-know-your-reasoning-and-story-behind-it--Honestly-you-cant-know-if-your-words-are-getting-through-to-them-but-the-cool-thing-about-art-is-that-it-can-be-
interpreted-in-so-many-different-ways---(Survey-response-EK-age-15)-
ampamp Hermeneuticsampwhichamphasampitsamprootsampinamptextualampinterpretationampcanampbeampdefinedampasamp
aamptraditionampofampthinkingamporampofampphilosophicalampreflectionampthatamptriesamptoampclarifyamptheampconceptamp
ofampverstehenampthatampisampunderstandingamp(Brunsamp1992)ampampRicoeuramp(19691974)ampexplainsamp
thatamptheampkeyamphypothesisampofamphermeneuticampphilosophyampisampthatampinterpretationampisampanampopenamp
processampwhichampnoampsingleampvisionampcanampconcludeamp(pamp109)ampampWithampthisampinampmindampIampwillamp
exploreamphermeneuticsampasampitampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp HansltGeorgampGadameramp(1900lt2002)ampinvestigatesampaampmoderateampformampofamp
hermeneuticsampthatampisampparticularlyamprelevantampinampserviceamptoampartampeducationampampGadameramp
breaksampwithamphermeneuticamptraditionampbyampproposingampthatampthereampisampnoampabsolutelyampobjectiveamp
interpretationampreadersampareampnotampableamptoampescapeamptheampprejudicesampofamptheiramptimeamp(Gallagheramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 16amp
1992)ampampThisamphoweverampbecomesampanampopportunityampforamptheampcreationampofampmeaningampInampaamp
passageampthatampechoesamptheampendlesslyampunfoldingampnatureampofampcollageampCaputoamp(2000)amprefersamp
toampanampexchangeampbetweenamppastampandamppresentampinamptheampcreativeamppossibilitiesampofamphermeneuticamp
interpretationamp
amp Thereampisampaamprichnessampinamphistoricalampeventsampthatampjustampkeepsampunfoldingampwhichampisamp
amp certainlyampnotampgraspedampbyamptheamporiginalampprotagonistsampwhichampgraduallyampunfoldsamp
amp overamptheampcourseampofamptimeampandampwhichampisampinampprincipleampneverampfullyampunfoldedampItampisamp
amp anampexcessampwhichampkeepsampspillingampoveramp(pamp47)amp
amp Gadamersampphilosophyampofamphermeneuticampunderstandingampisampformedampthroughamphisamp
notionsampaboutamplanguageampdialogueampandampconversationamp(Caputoamp2000ampSeebohmamp2004)ampamp
InampadditionamptoampGadamersampimplicitamprelianceamponamplisteningampasampheampdiscussesampdialogueamphisamp
workampcapitalizesamponamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampinamplanguageamp(Heelanamp1985)ampmakingamphisamp
formampofamphermeneuticsampparticularlyampapplicableamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp Gadamersamptermampfusion-of-horizonsamprefersamptoamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampwithinampaamp
varietyampofampencountersampampAampfusionampofamphorizonsampcanampbeampdescribedampasampaampdialogicamp
conversationampbetweenampreaderampandamptextamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampWithinamptheamptextualamp
paradigmampGadamerampbelievesampthatampaampwrittenamptextampisampopenamptoampanampinvisibleampandampindefiniteamp
readerampwhoampentersampintoampanampunknownampadventureampofamptheamptextamp(Ricoeuramp2013amppamp13)ampamp
Theamphorizonampitselfampisamptheamprangeampofampvisionampthatampincludesampeverythingampthatampcanampbeampseenamp
fromampaampparticularampvantageamppointamp(Gadameramp2004amppamp301)ampampLikeampcollageamptheampfusionampofamp
horizonsampisampaampprocessampcomposedampofamppastampandamppresentampwhichampareampopenamptoampandampinfinitelyamp
effectedampbyampeachampotheramp(Bourgeoisamp2007)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 17amp
amp Similarampconnectionsampcanampbeampdrawnampwhenampviewerampandampartworkampareampsubstitutedamp
forampreaderampandamptextampampInterpretationampandampunderstandingampbecomeampanampentwinedamp
creativeampendeavorampinampwhichamptheampviewerampparticipatesampasampmuchampasamptheampcreatorampbyamp
constructingampmeaningamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampPalmeramp(1969)ampalludesamptoamptheamppluralityampofamp
meaningampinampstatingampthatamptoampfocusamppurelyamponamptheamppositivityampofampwhatampaamptextampexplicitlyamp
saysampisamptoampdoampanampinjusticeamptoamptheamphermeneuticalamptaskamp(pamp234)ampampToampfocusamponampwhatampisamp
explicitampinampaampcollageampworkampwouldampbeamptoampdisregardamptheampconnectionsampandampcontradictionsamp
ofamptheampwholeampinampfavorampofampaampdirectampreadingampofamptheampindividualamppartsampthusampmissingampoutamponamp
otheramppossibleampdimensionsampofampmeaningamp
amp Theampkeyamptoamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampeducationampinamptextampandampbetweenamp
individualsampisamptheampabilityamptoamplistenampwithampopennessampampDefensiveamplisteningampisampaampwayampofamp
listeningampwithoutampopennessampitampisampaampwayampofampprotectingampourampsmallampversionampofamptheampworldamp
andampavoidingampmoralampclaimsamponampourselvesamp(Levinamp1989amppamp79)ampampLevinamp(1989)amp
discussesampplayfulamplisteningamp(pamp233)ampasampaampwayampofampcounteractingampdefensiveamplisteningampampamp
Bohmamp(1996)ampdiscussesampsuspendingampassumptionsampaampprocessampofampattendingamptoamp
assumptionsampratherampthanamprepressingampthemamporampcarryingampthemampoutampampNicholamp(1996)amp
explainsampaampcircumstanceampinampwhichampyouampencounterampaamppersonampyouampfeelampisampanampidiotampampampYouamp
wouldamprefrainampfromampsayingampsoampoutamploudampbutampyouampwouldampalsoamprefrainampfromampscoldingamp
yourselfampforampthisampthoughtampratherampyouampwouldampseeampthisampreactionampwithoutampfullyampengagingamp
withampitampampSimilarampsuggestionsamplikeampbracketingampofampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampareamp
discussedampinamptheampfollowingampsectionampamp
amp Gadamerampbelievesamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampwhatampallowsamptheampselfamptoampapproachamp
theampotherampitampisampaampprocessampinampwhichamptheampideasampofamptheampotherampbecomeamponesampownamp(Caputoamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 18amp
2000)ampampThisampisamphardlyampanampuncommonampexperienceampampInampfactampweampregularlyampencounteramptheamp
fusionampofamphorizonsampbyampintegratingamppastampunderstandingsampwithampcurrentampexperiencesampaamp
processampundoubtedlyampcomparableamptoampeducationamp(Zuckertamp2002)ampamp
amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsamplikeampeducationampcanampbeampfrustratingampandampemotionalamp
becauseampeachamphighlight[s]amptheampfinitudeampofamptheampinterpreterampandamptheamplimitationsampofamphisamp
understandingamp(Bourgeoisamp2007amppamp79)ampampTheamptermampsharesampsimilaritiesampwithamptheamp
problematic-momentampaamppedagogicalamptermampreferringamptoampaampbreachampinampaampdominantampgroupsamp
discourseampduringampwhichampsomethingamprepressedamparisesamp(KentampampampCummingamp2008)ampampKentamp
andampCummingamp(2008)ampexploreamptheampproblematicampmomentampasampaampdiscursiveampsiteampforamp
examiningampprejudiceampwithinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampandampitsamp
moreamppoliticallyampchargedampcounterpartamptheampproblematicampmomentampbothampexploreamp
Gadamersamp(1996)ampampassertionampthatamptheampotherampmayampnotamponlyamphaveampaamprightampbutampmayamp
actuallyampbeamprightampmayampunderstandampsomethingampbetterampthanampweampdoamp(pamp82)ampampAampcreativelt
listeningampspaceamplivesampinampthisamppossibilityampampamp
amp Lastlyamprelayingampofampappropriateampexpectationsamptoampparticipantsampisampaampnecessaryamp
featureampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampdemandingampampItamp
requiresampparticipantsampwhoampareampawareampofamptheamprisksampandamphardshipsamptoampenterampintoampitampampItamp
isamptheampresponsibilityampofamptheampeducatoramporampgroupampleaderamptoampmakeamptheseampexpectationsamp
knownampasampwellampasamptoampmodelampthisampbehaviorampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionamphermeneuticallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Areampopenamptoamppossibilitiesampandamptoamptheampotherampbull Conceiveampofampthemselvesampasampengagingampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamptheamprisksampinvolvedampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamplimitationsampofamptheirampunderstandingamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 19amp
Dialogic(Practices(-
I-felt-that-everyone-was-open-and-interested-in-what-I-had-to-say---Perhaps-I-felt-this-sense-of-understanding-due-to-the-nature-of-the-discussion((-
it-felt-[like]-more-[of]-a-dialogue-as-opposed-to-a-standard-critique-(Survey-response-MW-age-22)-
(amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampartampeducationampreliesamponampanampopenampdialogueampduringamp
experiencesampwithampartampselfampandampothersampampWhatampIampfoundamplackingampinamphermeneuticsamp
howeverampwasampaampdiscussionampofamptheamphowltlthowampisamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampachievedampandamp
howampdoampindividualsampmeaningfullyampengageampwithampeachampotherampampInampanampeffortamptoampclarifyampthisamp
Iampwillampdiscussampdialogicamppracticesampasamptheyamprelateamptoampmeaningfulampverbalampexchangesampandamp
listeningampencountersampinamptheampclassroomampandampstudioampamongstampstudentsamptheiramppeersampandamp
educatorsamp
amp Communicatingampthroughamplanguageampandampdialogueampisamphowampweampcoltconstructamp
worldsampwithampourselvesampandampothersampnotampjustampthroughampanampactampofamptransmissionampbutamp
becauseampourampcommunicativeampactsampgiveampbirthamptoampworldsamp(Lipariamp2014amppamp507)ampampSableamp
(2014)ampdescribesampdialogueampasampaampgenerativeampinterchangeampbetweenampparticipantsampasamp
opposedamptoampanampexchangeampofampviewsampwhereampindividualsampsimplyampadvocateamptheiramppositionsamp
(pamp8)ampampForampBohmamp(1996)ampitampisampaampstreamampofampmeaningampflowingampamongampandampthroughampusamp
(pamp6)ampampTheampnatureampofampdialogueampandampconversationampisampinherentlyampunplannedampampThisamp
dimensionampofampconversationampisampimportantamptoampGadameramp(2004)ampwhoampfindsampthatamp
participantsampinvolvedampinampconversationampareamplessamptheampleadersampofampitampthanamptheampledamp(pamp
385)ampampSableamp(2014)ampechoesampthisampbyampwritingampthatamptheampmostampimportantamppartsampofampanyamp
conversationampareampthoseampthatampneitheramppartyampcouldamphaveampimaginedampbeforeampstartingamp(pamp
8)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 20amp
amp Theseampareampnotionsampofampdialogueampamongampothersampthatampfindampaampparallelampinamptheamp
creativeampprocessampampFairfieldamp(2011)ampwritesampthatampinampprincipleampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinamp
dialogueamp(pamp83)ampaampsentimentampthatampalignsampwithampaampcommonampissueampencounteredampduringamp
theampcreativeampprocessltltnotampknowingampwhenampaamppieceampisampdoneampampAampquoteampoftenampattributedamp
toampLeonardoampdaampVinciampspeaksamptoampthisampideaampArtampisampneverampfinishedamponlyampabandonedampamp
Snowberamp(2007)ampdrawsampparallelsampbetweenampmentorshipampdialogueampandamptheampcreativeamp
processampfindingampthatampdeepamplisteningamppracticesampconnectampallampthreeampampSheampfindsampthatamptheamp
taskampofamptheampmentorampisamptheampsameampasamptheamptaskampofamptheampartistampthatampisamptoampbringampoutamptheamp
naturalampqualitiesampofamptheampstudentamporamptheampmediumampampSnowberamp(2007)ampcommentsamponampanamp
ideaampwellltknownampamongampartistsampwhichampisampthatampaampworkampofampartamphasampaamplifeampofampitsampownampthisamp
notionampisampreminiscentampofampGadamersampstatementampaboutampbeingampledampbyampconversationamp
ampamp Dialogicamppracticesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampeducationampemphasizeampaamp
phenomenologicalampdimensionamprequiringamptwoampthingsampfromampparticipantsampampFirstlyamp
participantsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampmustampfindampvalueampinamplisteningamptoamptheamp
narrativesampofamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampampTheseampparticipantsampknowampthatampeducationamp
isampforemostampaboutamptestimonyampaboutampsharingamptheampexperienceampofampbeingamphumanampsharingamp
lifeampconvictionsampandampknowledge((Wiercinskiamp2011amppamp109)ampampNarrativesampareamp
conceivedampofampasampaampwayampofamphumanampknowingamp(Vitanovaamp2010amppamp29)ampthatampmakesamptheamp
selfampampSecondlyampwhenamplisteningamptoamptheampnarrativesampofampothersampparticipantsampareampexpectedamp
toampbracketamptheirampownampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsamp(LindsethampampampNorbergamp2004)ampampThisamp
encouragesamplistenersamptoampexperienceampandampfindampmeaningampinamptheampnarrativesampofampothersamp
whileampfreeingamptheampspeakerampfromamptheampfearampofampbeingampjudgedampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 21amp
amp Bracketingampjudgmentampandampconclusionampisampaamppotentialamptoolampwithinamptheampcommonamp
artampeducationamppracticeampofampgroupampcritiquesampampElkinsamp(2001)ampfindsampthatamppeopleampwhoamphaveamp
experienceampinampartampjudgeampveryampquicklyampandampmostampteachersampwillamphaveampaampprovisionalamp
opinionampaboutampaampworkampinamptheampfirstamptenampsecondsamp(pamp121)ampampBracketingampconclusionampandamp
judgmentampisampparticularlyampimportantampforampeducatorsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
whoseampvolumeampofampviewingampexperiencesampcouldampleadamptoampeasyampassumptionsampwhenamp
encounteringampaampnewampworkampampamp
amp Elkinsamp(2001)ampdiscussesampthatampcritiquesampcanampalsoampbeampseenampasampexchangesampofamp
storiesamporampcollaborativeampstorytellingamp(pamp145)ampwhichampisampyetampanotherampwayampofamptalkingamp
aboutamppossibilitiesampforampdialogueampandampnarrativeampwithinampartampeducationampampElkinsamphoweveramp
findsampstorytellingamplimitingamponceamptheampdeeperampnarrativesampareampdiscoveredamp(2001amppamp
145)ampampThisampimpliesampthatampheampfindsamponlyampaampsingularampmeaningampandamponeampthatampisampnotamp
necessarilyampusefulampforampcollaborativeampgroupampcritiquesamp
amp Insteadampparticipantsampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampbringampknowledgeampofamp
polysemyamptoampcollaborativeampcritiqueampexperiencesampasampwellampasamptoampexperiencesampofampmakingamp
artworkampampAccordingamptoampMuldoonamp(2002)amppolysemyampisamptheampqualityampofampaampwordamporampotheramp
languageampunitampthatampcanampbearampmultipleampmeaningsamp(asampcitedampinampWorsleyamp2012amppamp308)ampampamp
Aamptextualampexampleampofampthisampisamptheampmultipleampmeaningsampofamptheampwordampcan-Iampcanampdriveampaampcaramp
Idamplikeampaampcan-ofampsodaampheampwasntampworkingampveryamphardampsoampIamphadamptoampcan-himamp(Munozamp
2014)ampampampButampifampweampconsideramppolysemyampmetaphoricallyamporampvisuallyamptheampideaampthatampaamp
singleampunitampimageamporampintentionampcouldampbearampmultipleampmeaningsampcouldampbeampproductiveampinamp
creatingltlisteningampspacesampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 22amp
amp Thisampunfoldingampofampmeaningampworksampwellampinamptheampcontextampofampcollageampandampdialogueamp
asampwellampasamphermeneuticsampampInampfactamphermeneuticsampimpliesamppolysemyampbecauseampofampitsamp
notionampthatampitampisampalwaysampaamppossibilityampofampmyampunderstandingampthatampisampplayedampoutampwhenampIamp
understandampaamptextamp(Grondinamp2002amppamp38)ampampPolysemyampcouldampbeampconceptualizedampasampanamp
alternativeampexplorationampofampmeaningampthatampfunctionsampcollaborativelyampwithinampcritiquesampamp
Forampexampleampeducatorsampcanampaskampstudentsamptoamprespondamptoampaampworkampthroughampcollageamp
journalampentriesampmusicampfilmampasampindividualsamporampinampgroupsampampKnowledgeampofamppolysemyamp
couldampalsoampbeampusedampasampaamptoolampforampcreatingampimagesampthatamprecognizesampaamprelationshipamp
betweenamptheampvisualamptheamplinguisticampandamptheampmultipleamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionampdialogicallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Placeampvalueamponampexperientialampnarrativesampbull Practiceamplisteningampbyampbracketingampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampbull Embraceamppolysemicampexplorationsampofampmeaningampamp
Contemplative(Practices(
I-knew-I-was-being-heard-because-of-her-mannerisms-and-the-look-on-her-face--She-was-calm-attentive-and-not-trying-to-jump-in-and-offer-any-advice--She-asked-questions-that-pointed-to-things-I-had-not-openly-articulated-because-of-uncertainty--
This-was-one-of-the-ways-I-knew-I-was-being-heard-(Survey-response-LS-age-27)-
(amp Ifamphermeneuticsampandampdialogicamppracticesampgiveampusamptheampbroadampstrokesampofampactivityampinamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampcontemplativeamppracticesampseekamptoamptuneampstudentsampandamp
educatorsampintoampnuanceampdeliberationampandampdeepampexplorationampampThisampisampaampmostlyamp
individualampinternalamppursuitampthatampfocusesamponampformsampofampselfltlisteningampbutampcontemplativeamp
practicesampareampalsoampformedampbyampanampawarenessampofampinterconnectednessamp
amp InamppursuitampofampcriticalampthinkingampSableamp(2014)ampoutlinesampaampsetampofampcontemplativeamp
practicesampforampstudentsampthatampincludeampmindfulampmeditationampstructuredampcontemplationamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 23amp
journalampwritingampmindfulamplisteningampreflectiveampinquiryampandampdialogueamp(pamp4)ampampWhileamp
Sablesamp(2014)ampmethodampforampcontemplativeamppracticesampprovidesampaampconcreteampframeworkamp
withampspecificampstepsampmanyampofamptheseampconceptsampcouldampbeampappliedampwithoutampsuchampaamp
prescribedampstructureampampForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwillampbeamp
primarilyampdiscussingampSablesampconceptsampofampstructuredampcontemplationampreflectiveamp
inquiryampandampjournalampwritingamp
amp ForampSableamp(2014)ampstructuredampcontemplationampisampaampformampofampbeingamppresentampandamp
focusedamponampaampparticularampquestionampstatementamporampimageampampWithinampthisampmodeampofampinquiryamp
participantsampareampexpectedamptoampholdamptheampobjectampofampcontemplationampinamptheirampmindsamp
deepeningampunderstandingampasamptheyampfocusampwithoutampanalyzingampitamporampmanipulatingampitampinamp
anyampwayamp(pamp5)ampampThisamppracticeampdrawsampcomparisonsamptoamptheampbracketingampofampjudgmentsamp
andampconclusionsampsupportedampinamptheamppreviousampsectionampbutampstructuredampcontemplationamp
occursamponampanampindividualamplevelampratherampthanampdialogicallyamp
amp Reflectiveampinquiryampbearsampsomeampsimilaritiesamptoampstructuredampcontemplationampbutamp
Sableamp(2014)amppositionsampitampasampanampactivityampbetweenamptwoampindividualsampaamplistenerampandampaamp
speakerampampTheamplistenerampisampagainampaskedamptoampsuspendampjudgmentampbutampalsoamptoampengageampinampaamp
formampofampcuriosityampinampwhichampinnocentampquestionsampareampaskedampinamporderamptoampgainamp
understandingampampSableamp(2014)ampcontrastsampinnocentampquestionsampwithampleadingampquestionsampamp
ForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwouldampcharacterizeampthisampinnocentamp
questioningampasampaampformampofampopenltendedampquestioningampampSableamp(2014)ampidentifiesampanamp
exampleampofampanampinnocentamp(orampopenltended)ampquestionampWhatampdidampyouampmeanampwhenampyouamp
saidamp________ampConverselyampaampleadingampquestionampisampDidampyouampmeanamptoampsayamp________ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 24amp
amp Sableamp(2014)ampusesampjournalampwritingampasampaamppieceampofamphisamplargerampstructureampofamp
contemplativeamppracticesampbutampjournalampwritingampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampcouldamp
potentiallyampoccupyampaampsignificantamproleampampIampconceiveampofampjournalampwritingampinampmyampownamp
creativeamppracticeampasampaampformampofampdocumentationampthatampmakesampmeampmoreampawareampofampmyamp
creativeampprocessamptheampemotionalamphabitsampthatampsurroundampitampandamptheampthemesampthatamp
structureampmyampworkampampIampconceptualizeampthisampwayampofampwritingampasampaampformampofampselfltlisteningamp
relatedamptoampaampkeyampconceptampofamphermeneuticsampfoundampinampGadamersampassertionampthatampallamp
educationampisampaampformampofampselflteducationamp(Grondinamp2011)ampampamp
amp Germeraadamp(2013)ampusesampjournalampwritingamptoampexploreamptheampemotionalampandamprationalamp
relationshipsamptoamphisampcreativeampprocessampparallelamptoampexecutingampaampnewampbodyampofampworkampampHeamp
findsampthatampwritingampduringamphisampprocessampisampaamptoolamptoampunderstandamp[his]amppsycheamptoampeaseamp
theamppainampthatampanampartisticampprocessampcanampbringampandamptoamprelieveampartisticampblocksamp
(Germeraadamp2013amppamp21)ampultimatelyampdeclaringampthatampitamphelpsamphimamptoampbetterampunderstandamp
hisampworkampampInampaampstyleampofampwritingampthatamposcillatesamparoundampjournalingampdocumentationampandamp
poetryampdeampCossonamp(2002)ampexploresamphisampoverlappingamprolesampasampanampartistampresearcherampandamp
teacherampampOtherampartistsampbluramptheamplineampbetweenampartamppracticeampdocumentationampandamplifeamp
furtherampstillampbyampofferingampdocumentationampasampartamplikeampSophieampCalleamp(Calleamp2011amp2008amp
2005)ampandampMaryampKellyamp(1973lt1979)ampampamp
amp Karpiakamp(2003)ampestablishesampcontemplativeamppracticesampfromamptheampperspectiveampofamp
theampeducatorampaskingampthemamptoampmineamptheampsubtleamp(pamp71)ampusingampattentivenessamp
attunementampamplificationampandampassociationampampTheseampexercisesampinampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampsetamptheamptoneampasampwellampasampprovideampaampmodelampofampbehaviorampforampotherampparticipantsamp
withinamptheampspaceampampKarpiakamp(2003)ampoutlinesampactivitiesampthatampeducatorsampcanampuseamptoampdrawamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 25amp
outampandamputilizeamptheseampsubtleampsensationsampinamptheampserviceampofamptransformativeamplearningamp(pamp
68)ampampamp
amp ForampKarpiakamp(2003)ampattentivenessamprequiresampawarenessamptoampverbalampandamp
nonverbalampcuesampasampwellampasampanampawarenessampofampwhatampisamphappeningampamongampandampwithinamptheamp
studentsampandamptheampeducatorampampAttunementamprequiresampanampeducatoramptoamporientampherselfamptoamptheamp
otherampandamptoampadoptampanampattitudeampofampunhurriednessampofamppatienceampandampofamphumilityamp
concerningampbothamptheampprocessampandamptheampoutcomesampofamptheampteachingamp(Karpiakamp2003amppgamp
72)ampampAmplificationampisampaampprocessampofamphonoringampcommunicationampthatampcentersamponamptheampideaamp
ofamphearingamponeselfampintoampknowingampitampincludesampusingampparaphrasingampandampclarificationamp
activitiesamptoampgainampinsightampintoampmeaningampampLastlyampassociationampentailsampidentifyingamp
patternsampandampweavingampthemamptogetherampwithampstudentampexperienceampclassroomampdiscussionamp
andamptheampideasampofampothersamp
amp TuningampintoampsubtletyampimpliesampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceampampTheampmanifestationsamp
ofampsilenceampinamptheampclassroomampareampendlessampandampitsampvalueampisamptooampgreatamptoampbeampignoredampwhileamp
tooampvastamptoampbeampfullyampabsorbedampampLevinamp(1989)ampremarksampthatampsilenceampisampaampclearingampwhereamp
thereampisampnothingampforamphearingamptoampholdamponamptoampinampwhichampmanyampfindampunbearableampanxietyamp
(pamp79)ampampNearlyampallampofampusamphaveampexperiencedampthisampunbearableampanxietyampaampstrainampofamp
whichampcanampbeampfoundampinampeducationalampcontextsampdueamptoamptheampfactampthatampclassroomsampareamp
oftenampstructuredamparoundampimplicitampandampexplicitamprulesampaboutamptalkampandampsilenceamp(Schultzamp
2010amppamp2848)ampampForampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampanampawarenessampofampsilenceampimplicatesamp
whatampisampleftampunsaidampandampwhatampisampunsayableltltespeciallyampimportantampbecauseampofamptheamp
unsayableampqualityampofampartworksampampForampSchultzamp(2010)ampsilenceampimpliesamppossibilityamp
becauseampitampcanampholdampmultipleampmeaningsampforampindividualsampwithinampandampacrossampracialamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 26amp
ethnicampandampculturalampgroupsamp(pamp2833)ampampLevinamp(1989)ampfindsampthatamptoamplistenamptoamp
somethingampweampmustampfirstampgive-itampourampsilenceamp(pamp232)ampampThisamppracticeampofampgivingampsilenceamp
isampparticularlyamphelpfulampinamptermsampofampviewingamporamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartamp
amp Gradleamp(2011)ampoutlinesampaamppracticalampvisionampforampviewingampartampthatamprequiresamp
silenceampandampdeliberationampampForamptheamppurposesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampwouldamp
reconceptualizeampthisampasampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampampGradleamp(2011)ampinstructedamp
herampstudentsamptoampspendamptimeampwithampaampworkampofampartampoutsideampofamptheirampeverydayampworldviewamp
attentivelyampviewingampitampforampaboutamptenampminutesampeverydayampforampaampweekampampAfterampeachampviewingamp
experienceamptheampstudentsampwroteampinamptheirampjournalsampampTheampresultsampindicatedampthatampthisamp
processampofampsustainedampsilentampdeliberationampcoupledampwithampanampengagementampofamptheiramp
intuitiveampperceptionsampaboutampartworkampleftampstudentsampfeelingampempoweredamptoampengageampinamp
discussionampandampappreciateampunfamiliarampartampformsampampThisampactivityampisampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoamp
aampworkampofampartampthatampincorporatesampSablesamp(2014)ampconceptampofampstructuredampcontemplationampamp
Weavingampaamprelationshipampbetweenampsilenceampcontemplationampandampattentivenessampisampaamp
significantampendeavorampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
Contemplativeamppracticesampfunctionampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Engageampinampformsampofampviewingampwritingampandampexperiencingampthatamphonorampselfltlisteningamp
bull Attuneamptoampsubtletyampandampnuanceampbull Listenampandampviewampdeliberatelyampbull Cultivateampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceamp(
The(Felt(Sense(
When-someone-understands-what-I-am-talking-about-when-I-talk-about-art-I-am-delighted--Art-is-my-everything--Its-my-passion--When-someone-understands-that-I-
am-instantly-filled-with-joy--That-tells-me-someone-gets-it-(Survey-response-CTF-age-16)-
(
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 4amp
Acknowledgements(
ThankampyouamptoampLaurenampNanditaampandampShannonampforampbeingampexcellentampwonderfulampartamp
educatorsampwhoampmakeampmyampworldampaampbetterampplaceampampYouampeachampteachampmeampnewampthingsampaboutamp
artampallamptheamptimeampandampIamploveampyouampforampitamp
ThankampyouamptoampDrampVittoriaampSampDaielloampforampbeingampanampexcellentamplistenerampampNoamponeampelseamp
wouldamphaveampencouragedampmyampweirdnessampinampsuchampspecificampwaysampampYouampareampmyamproleampmodelamp
Thankampyouamptoampmyampparentsampforamplettingampmeampbeampanampartistampandamphelpingampmeampwithampeverythingamp
ThankampyouamptoampPampforampgivingampmeamptheampbestampcritiquesampandampneveramplettingampmeampgetampawayampwithamp
anythingampampThankampyouampforamplettingampmeampcryampwheneverampIampwantampamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 5amp
(thread1(
The(Possibility(of(Possibilities(Creative=Listening(Spaces(in(Art(Education(
TheampartsampinampeducationampshouldampthusamprecognizeamppossibilitiesampthatampopenampnewamphorizonsampinampbothampformampandampsubstanceampampThisampisamptrueampnotamponlyampinamptheampartsampbutampalsoampinampeducationampinampitsampvariousampmanifestationsampampTheamppossibilitiesampofamptheampworkampofampartampmustampbeampcentralampmustampbeamphonoredampampIfampweampcanamphonoramptheampvisualamppoeticampandampgesturalamppossibilitiesampinamptheampartsampweamp
thenampcanampbeginamptoampunderstandamptheampopeningsampmadeampaccessibleampbyampamplivingampin-theampquestionsamp(Greeneamp2013amppamp252)amp
ampamp
amp CollageampholdsamphighampesteemampinampmyampcreativeamppracticeampampItampisampnotampthatampIampvalueampitsamp
visualampimpactampoverampotherampformsampofampmediaampnorampdoampIampenjoyampitampmoreampthanampotherampmodesampofamp
creativeampexpressionampampSimplyampputampcollageampisampusuallyampwhatampgetsampmeampunstuckampampItampisamptheamp
leverampIampuseamptoampfreeampmyselfampfromampaampdisappointingampdrawingampampInsteadampofamplaboringampoverampaamp
workamporampthrowingampawayampanampotherwiseampinoffensiveamppieceampofamppaperampIampuseampcollageampasampaamp
lastltditchampeffortamptoampmakeampsomethingltltanythingltltthatampIampdontamphaveamptoampstruggleampagainstampamp
Theampdrawingampisamptornampupamppaintedampoverampstapledampsewedamptogetherampcutampintoampstripsampandamp
wovenampampMaybeampitsampjustampthrownampinampmyampdrawerampofampsadampbadampdrawingsampthatampareampallamp
waitingampforamptheamprightampmomentamptoampbecomeampnewampampTheamppointampisampwhatampbeganampasampaampbadamp
drawingampandamppossiblyampaampbadamporampfrustratingampexperienceampdoesntamphaveamptoampremainampinampmyamp
mentalamparchiveampofampDrawings-That-Have-FailedampampInsteadamptheseampworksampareampsimplyamp
deconstructedampandampfoldedampintoampanotheramppossibilityampampCollageampengagesampwithamptheampactampofamp
layeringampandamptheampsenseampofampfearlessnessampgainedampwhenampIampholdampontoamptheampfactampthatampthereampisamp
alwaysampanotheramppossibilityampforampaampworkampamp
amp Theampphysicalampactampofamplayeringamphoweverampisampinampserviceamptoampaampdeeperampsenseampofamptheamp
wordampampWhenampweamparticulateamppowerfulampviewingampexperiencesampwordsampoftenampfailampusampampWeamp
mayampsayampthatampweampfeelampaampclickampaampconnectionamporampanampaestheticampexperienceampwhenampviewingampaamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 6amp
pieceampampTheseampareampwaysampweampexpressamptheampprelinguisticampfeltampdimensionsampofampbeingampwithampaamp
workampofampartampampTemporallyampthisamptakesampplaceampwithinampaampsingleampmomentampinamptimeampampButamp
meaningfulampencountersampwithampartampareamponlyampmeaningfulampbecauseamptheyampareampcomposedampofamp
countlessamppreviousampmomentsampwordsampexperiencesampknowledgeampconversationsamp
relationshipsampandampallamptheampminutiaampthatampconstituteampanampindividualsampidentityampampInampthisamp
conceptionampofampmeaningltmakingamptheamplayersampofampexperiencesampwithinamptheampindividualamptheamp
groupampandamptheampspacesampbetweenampareamprespectedampforamptheirampvalueampinamptheampformationampofamp
singularampandampcollectiveampidentitiesamp
amp Oftenampviewersampandampeducatorsampdiscussampinterpretativeampprocessesampfromamp
frameworksampsuchampasampaampworksamppositionampinampartamphistoryamptheampbiographyampofamptheampartistamp
socialampimplicationsampandampsoamponampampThereampisampaampparallelamptoampbeampfoundamphereampinamptheampdrawingamp
processampampIfampweamppresupposeampthatampthereampisampaampcorrectampwayamptoampinterpretampandampaampperfectamp
drawingamptoampbeamphadampweamprunamptheampriskampofampnotamptryingampforampfearampofampfailureampampItsampnoampstretchamptoamp
sayampthatampindividualsampwhoamplackampartsampexperienceampareamphesitantamptoampengageampwithampaampworkampofamp
artampforampfearampofampexposingamptheirampsupposedampignoranceampampOnamptheampotheramphandampifampweampengageampinamp
aampwayampofampviewingampthatampidentifiesampwithamptheampfluidityampofampcollageampweampcanampacknowledgeamp
possibilityampasampaampfeatureampofampinterpretationampampByampconceivingampofampinterpretationampasampaampformamp
ofampcollagingamptogetherampmeaningfulampexperiencesampviewersampcouldampgainampaccessamptoamptheamp
complexamplayeredampandampmessyampdimensionsampofampmeaningampwhenamptheyamplistenamptoampaampworkampofamp
artamp
Creative=Listening(Space(
amp Iampofferamptheamptermampcreative(listening-spaceampasampanampalternativeampmodeampofamp
experiencingampviewingampandampproducingampcreativeampworksampampInsteadampofampplacingampsubjectamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 7amp
matterampinformationamporamptheamproleampofamptheampeducatorampatamptheampcenterampofamptheseampexperiencesampIamp
proposeampthatampactsampofamplisteningampbeampembeddedampinampmakingampandampviewingampartampampTheamptermamp
creativeltlisteningampspaceamprefersamptoamptheampfluidampandampflexibleampspaceampinampwhichamplisteningamp
practicesampareampanampintegratedampessentialamppartampofampviewingampdiscussingampandampproducingamp
creativeampworksampampArtistsampviewersampstudentsampandampeducatorsampcanamptransformampartamp
classroomsampstudiosampandampsitesampofampviewingampartampintoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhichampareamp
notampdefinedampbyampphysicalampformamporampstructuralampboundariesampampRatheramptheyampareampdefinedampbyamp
specificamppracticesampthatampoccurampamongstampindividualsampandampgroupsampinamptheampcontextampofampartamp
educationampamp
Research(Issue(
amp Theampoverarchingampconcernampinampthisampresearchampisamptheamppotentialampoutcomeampforampusingamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampwithinampartampeducationampampTheamppracticesampIampdiscussamphereamphaveampinamp
commonampaampdistinctiveampflexibilityampandampmalleabilityampampTheyampmayampbeampadaptedamptoampvariousamp
ageampgroupsampeducationalampsitesampandampcontextsampampWhileampIampofferampsuggestionsampIampexpectampthatamp
theamppractitionersampwhoampwishamptoampuseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwillampdeviseamptheirampownamp
methodsampofampimplementationampbasedamponamptheirampspecificampneedsampandampcontextsampampThoughamptheamp
ideaampofampcreativeamplisteningampspacesampemergedampwithinampanampartsampeducationampcontextampampthisamp
conceptampmayampholdampvalueampforampotherampdisciplinesamp
Boundaries(and(Limitations(of(the(Research(
( Iampundertookampthisampresearchampinampfulfillmentampofampaampmastersampdegreeampinampartampeducationamp
atamptheampUniversityampofampCincinnatisampCollegeampofampDesignampArtampArchitectureampandampPlanningamp
(DAAP)ampampTheampresponsesampexperiencesampandampartworkampgeneratedampduringamptheampcourseampofamp
thisampprojectamphaveampoftenampcenteredamparoundampthatampinstitutionampwhichamphousesampaampprimarilyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 8amp
whiteampmiddleltamptoampupperltclassampstudentamppopulationamponampanampurbanampcampusampampIampamampaampwhiteamp
femaleamppursuingamphigherampeducationampampIampwantamptoampacknowledgeampthisamppositionalityampalongamp
withamptheamppersonalampbiasesampaamplifetimeampofampexperiencesamphasampaffordedamptoampmeampampOneampinternalamp
goalampthatampdevelopedampoveramptheampcourseampofampthisampworkampwasampaampcontinuedampconsistentampeffortamp
toampuncoverampandampinterrogateampmyampownampbiasesampasamptheyampmanifestedampampThoughampweampcanampneveramp
beampfreeamporamppureampofamptheseampbiasesampconstantampexaminationampofampthemamphasampbeenampmyampchosenamp
routeamptoampcounteringamptheiramppowerampandampinfluenceampamp
Iampamamppassionateampaboutamptheampmeaningfulamppossibilitiesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampInamprespectampofampmyampownamplimitationsampandampthoseampofampthisampworkamphoweverampIampwillampnotamp
claimampthatampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampareampfeasibleampwithinamptheampcontextampofampeveryamp
educationalampsettingampnorampthatampthisampwayampofampviewingampmakingampandampexperiencingampworksampofamp
artampisampmoreamporamplessampvalidampthanampothersampampRatherampIampsuggestamptheamppossibilityampofamplivingampinamp
possibilitiesampasampaampwayamptoampcultivateampmeaningfulampencountersampwithinampartampandampartamp
educationamp
Data(
amp ForampthisampresearchampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponampthreeampformsampofampdataamp
participantampsurveysampcaseampstudiesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampandampreflectiveamppracticeamp
formsampofampartmakingampallampcollectedampduringampaampfourltmonthampperiodampampToampgatherampparticipantamp
responsesampfromamptheampsurveysampandampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampreliedamponampaampmultitudeampofamp
friendsamppeersampandampcolleaguesampampIampconnectedampwithamptheampmajorityampofamptheseampindividualsamp
duringamporampasampaampresultampofampmyampexperiencesampatampDAAPampampampIampusedamp37ampsurveyampresponsesampaboutamp
listeningampexperiencesampwithampaampparticipantampageamprangeampofamp14amptoamp47ampampParticipantsamp
educationalamplevelsampspannedamphighampschoolamptoampgraduateampschoolampampIamppersonallyampsolicitedamptheamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 9amp
majorityampofamptheamplisteningampsurveysampatamptheampcollegeamplevelampandampaboveampampTheampbulkampofamptheamphighamp
schoolltagedampresponsesampwereampsolicitedampbyampmyampcolleagueampaampphotographyampteacherampatampaamp
Cincinnatiltareaamphighampschoolamp
amp Iampconductedampfiveampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampexperiencesampwithampsixampindividualsampasamp
partampofampthisampresearchampagainampusingampmanyampofamptheamppersonalampandampprofessionalampconnectionsamp
cultivatedampthroughamptheampDAAPampprogramampampIampdeliberatelyampchoseamppeopleampwithampwhomampIamphadamp
variousamplevelsampandamptypesampofamprelationshipsampampIampwillampspeakampmoreampinltdepthampaboutamptheseamp
experiencesampasampwellampasampexploreamptheampsurveyampresponsesampinamptheampResearchampMethodologyamp
andampMethodsampsectionamp
amp Lastlyamptheampdevelopmentampofampanampartmakingamppracticeampwasampessentialamptoampmyampownamp
personalampunderstandingampofamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatampcomposedampmyampresearchamp
ReadersampwillampnoticeampthatampimagesampareampembeddedampinampthisamptextampampTheseampareampimagesampofamptheamp
resultingampproductsampofampaamppracticeampofampunderstandingampthroughampmakingampampIampwillampdiscussamp
themampthroughoutampvariousampsectionsampofampthisamppaperampampamp
Dear(Reader(The(Structure(of(this(Research(Paper(
DearampReader(s)amp
amp Letampmeampbreakampforampaampmomentampfromampstandardampacademicamprhetoricampbeforeampthisamp
paperampreallyampgetsampstartedampampIampknowampwhatampyoureampthinkingltltnineamppagesampinampandampthisamppaperamp
hasntampevenampstartedampyetampampAlasampthisampsectionampisampmyamponeampofampmyampfavoriteampandampmostampoftlt
skimmedamppassagesampofampanampacademicamppaperamptheampstructureampofamptheamppaperampampThisampisamptheamppartamp
whereamptheampwriterampsaysampwhatampshesampaboutamptoampsayampbeforeampsheampsaysampitampampampItsampanamp
organizationalampstrategyampandampitsampthrillingampampLuckilyampforampyouampniceamppersonampwhoampisamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 10amp
readingampthisamppaperampIamphaveampprovidedampaamptranslationampfromampthisamptextsamporiginalampAcademiaamp
intoampnormalltpeopleltlanguageamp
amp Theampstructureampofampthisamppaperampisampasampfollowsampamp(Im-about-to-tell-you-whats-in-this-
long-ass-paper)ampampFirstlyamppleaseampnoteampthatampIampuseamptheamptermampthreadampinamplieuampofampchapteramp
asampanamporganizationalampstructureampIamppreferamptheampformerampbecauseampofamphowampitsampconceptualamp
qualitiesamprelateamptoampmyampworkampamp(Thread-is-awesome-and-you-can-do-tons-of-stuff-with-it-
like-sew-knot-tie-weave-etc--Chapters-are-not-nearly-as-exciting)--Iampwillampfirstampshareamp
myampresearchersampreflexiveampnarrativeampamp(I-made-up-a-cool-story-about-this-project-to-
describe-where-it-all-came-from)ampampThenampIampshallampofferampaampdescriptionampofamptheampqualitiesampofampaamp
creativeltlisteningampspaceampamp(Yes-I-shall)ampampIampwillampdiscussamptheampliteratureampthatampinformsamptheamp
backboneampofampmyampresearchampGadamersamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamp
practicesampandampGendlinsamptheampfeltampsenseampamp(Like-a-typical-graduate-student-I-have-done-
an-insane-amount-of-reading-during-the-past-two-academic-years--A-significant-
portion-of-this-reading-has-been-dedicated-to-those-topics--Dont-ask-me-to-type-them-
out-again-because-Im-seriously-done)ampampTheseampsectionsampbeginampwithampaamppassageampderivedamp
fromampsurveyampresponsesampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampamp(I-got-a-bunch-of-people-to-fill-
out-surveys-for-this-research-and-then-I-put-those-responses-in-my-paper)ampampTheseamp
experiencesampwithamplisteningampwereampprovidedampbyampresearchampparticipantsampamp(Super-nice-
people-I-know-and-some-I-dont-helped-me-out)ampampTheyampareampthereamptoampgroundamptheamp
conceptualampframeworksampinamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampamp(This-basically-means-
none-of-this-research-is-worth-shit-unless-it-can-be-used-in-the-real-world((I-hope-youll-
agree)ampampIampwillampthenampshareampmyampresearchampmethodologyampandampmethodsampamp(Im-going-to-tell-
you-about-how-and-why-I-did-this-project-in-using-big-smart(sounding-words)ampampLastlyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 11amp
Iampwillampconcludeampwithamppossibilitiesampforampthisampresearchampamp(Ill-figure-out-what-I-learned-and-
share-it-with-you-my-new-best-friend-who-made-it-all-the-way-to-the-conclusions-
section)ampampInampthisamppaperampreadersampwillampnoticeamptransparentampimagesampinteractingampwithamptheamp
textampamp(Its-my-art-on-transparent-sheets-in-this-very-paper)ampampTheseampareampworksampofampartamp
thatampIampcreatedamptoampgroundamptheampresearchampinampaamppracticeampofampmakingamptheyampareamptheampphysicalamp
embodimentampofampconceptualampideasampandamptheyampareampalwaysamppresentamptoamptheampresearchampamp
(Research-papers-with-pictures-are-much-more-tolerable-am-I-right)amp
amp Hereampweampgoamp
amp
thread2(
Collaging(Experience1(
amp ImagineampthatampyouampareampanampartistampseatedampatampyourampstudioamptableampampYouamphaveamp
everythingampyouampneedampampTheamproomampisampquietampsaveampforamptheampmuffledampsoundsampofampaampdistantamp
outsideampworldampampYouampsurveyamptheampcollectionampofampimagesampyouamphaveampgatheredamparoundampyouampamp
OnampyouramprightampisampaampraggedamppageampfromampanampoldampsketchbookampampGlossyampjewellttonedampswatchesamp
fromampaampdiscardedampfashionampmagazineampareampstackedampupampglisteningampinamptheamplightampampMonthsamp
agoampyouamppickedampupampaamphandfulampofampblackampandampwhiteampphotosampfromampaampsecondhandampstoreamp
todayamppastyampfacesampofamptheampunknownampsubjectsampstareampthroughampyouampblanklyampampAamppaleampyellowamp
scrapampofampleftoverampfabricampisampdrapedampoveramplastampweeksamppleatedamptoltdoamplistampampTheseampandamptwoamp
dozenampotherampscrapsamppiecesamppilesampandampcrumbsampareampyouramptoolsamptodayampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampamp1ampThisampsectionampisampsupposedamptoampbeampmyampresearchersampreflexiveampnarrativeampaamppassageampaboutampwhereampmyampresearchampideasampcameampfromltltandampinampfactampcollageampisampactuallyampwhereampthisampideaampcomesampfromampampOneampofamptheampfirstampresearchampinterestsampIampdiscussedampwithampmyampprofessorampDrampKristopherampHollandampwasamplayersampbothampphysicalampandampconceptualampampHeampwasamplikeampOhampampYoureamptalkingampaboutamphermeneuticsampSoampinampaampwayampthisampresearchampprojectampbothampbeganampandampconcludedamp(moreamponampthatamplater)ampwithampideasampofamplayeringampandampcollageampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 12amp
amp TheampresidueampthatampclingsamptoamptheseampscrapsampisampexperienceampampTheampoldampsketchbookamp
pageampisampanampimageampofampaampwomansamplegamprenderedampwithampchunkyamppencilampstrokesampampYouampmadeampitamp
whenampyouampwereamplivingampinampyourampoldampapartmentampoverlookingamptheampsquareampampItsampaampwomansamp
footampbutampitampremindsampyouampofamphavingampaamproommateampandampaampgrayampfutonampandampaampsummerampthatamp
wasampdesperatelyamphotampampItampisamponlyamppencilamponamppaperampbutampitampremindsampyouampofamptheampgreenamp
grassyampcenterampinamptheampmedianampofamptheampstreetampampOneamppencilampdrawingampofampaampwomansamplegamp
remindsampyouampofampthatampoldamplifeampandamptheampversionampofampyourselfampyouampwereampthenampitampisamptheampfirstamp
dominoampinampaampseriesampofampcascadingampdetailsampandampmemoriesampamp
amp EachampfragmentampsittingamponampyourampstudioamptableamphasampaampstoryampampEachampcameampfromampaamp
placeampandampwasamptouchedampbyampanotheramphumanampampEachampisampembeddedampwithampexperienceampcoloramp
memoryamptextureampandampinfiniteampdetailampbyamptheampmereampfactampofampitsampownampexistenceampamp
amp YouampbeginamptoamppickampapartamptheampephemeraampampYouampalternateampbeingampcarefulampandamp
carelessamp
amp Cuttingamptearingampburningampstretchingampfoldingampwhitewashingamprippingampcreasingamp
sewingampwritingamppaintingampencasingampfasteningampfillingampsoakingampdyeingampwashingamp
dryingampbitingampscratchingamppryingampyankingampsmoothingampsandingamppokingampstabbingamp
stretchingampfryingampheatingampdustingampcleaningampsculptingampslicingampdicingamppunchingamp
floatingamptwistingampflippingampdrippingampstaplingampstrippingampstripingamppatterningamp
designingampdrawingampsketchingampliftingampcollectingamptapingampgluingampbuttoningampknottingamp
weavingampknittingamp
amp YouampdoampallampofamptheseampthingsampandampprobablyampmanyampotherampthingsampampTheampfragmentsamponamp
youramptableampchangeampshapeampandampgetampsmallerampampFromamptheseamppiecesampyouampbeginamptoampbuildamp
somethingampampThisampsomethingampisampbothampnewampandampoldampampJuxtapositionsampbloomampnewamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 13amp
connectionsampareampfusedampbyamptheampweightampofamppreviousampexperienceampampPastampandamppresentamp
liquefyampintoampendlesslyampcirculatingamppossibilitiesampampYouampcouldamptheoreticallyampcontinueampthisamp
processampofamplayeringampandampreconstructionampforeverampamptheamponlyamplimitsampareampyourampownamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 14amp
thread3(
what(is(a(creative=listening(space(
ampampampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeamplisteningampspaceampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampwhatampdoesampitampsoundampsmellamptasteampfeelamplikeampampampampampampampwhatampampisampamptheampamptextureampampofampampthisampampamp
spaceampampampanswerampmoreampquestionsampampamp specificsampandampgeneralizationsampareampbothampimpossibleampampmaybeampaampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampgoodampstartampwouldampbeampthisampampamp amp amp amp amp safeampampampamp amp amp amp amp foldedampampamp amp amp amp amp amp embodiedampamp layeredampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampconnectedampampampamp amp ampamp
(it-might--be-like-gently-holding-on-to--
a-knot-of-questions)-amp
ampampampampampampampampampamp
(possible)ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 15amp
thread4amp(
Review(of(Literature((
( AnampexplorationampofampGadamerrsquosamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampeducationalampcontextsampandampGendlinrsquosamptheoryampofampfeltampsenseampwereampintegralamptoamp
theampcreationampofamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampWhileampcompellingampconstructsamponamp
theirampownampwhenampdrawnamptogetheramptheseampphilosophicalampperspectivesampvibrateamp
holisticallyamptoampsuggestampintriguingamppossibilitiesampforamptheampuseampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
inampartsampeducationampampInampthisampsectionampIampreviewamptheampliteratureampandampconnectamptheampvariousamp
pointsampofampstudyampampamp
Hermeneutics(amp(the(Fusion(of(Horizons((
It-actually-feels-really-great-knowing-that-other-people-will-enjoy-the-art-you-created-and-knowing-they-know-your-reasoning-and-story-behind-it--Honestly-you-cant-know-if-your-words-are-getting-through-to-them-but-the-cool-thing-about-art-is-that-it-can-be-
interpreted-in-so-many-different-ways---(Survey-response-EK-age-15)-
ampamp Hermeneuticsampwhichamphasampitsamprootsampinamptextualampinterpretationampcanampbeampdefinedampasamp
aamptraditionampofampthinkingamporampofampphilosophicalampreflectionampthatamptriesamptoampclarifyamptheampconceptamp
ofampverstehenampthatampisampunderstandingamp(Brunsamp1992)ampampRicoeuramp(19691974)ampexplainsamp
thatamptheampkeyamphypothesisampofamphermeneuticampphilosophyampisampthatampinterpretationampisampanampopenamp
processampwhichampnoampsingleampvisionampcanampconcludeamp(pamp109)ampampWithampthisampinampmindampIampwillamp
exploreamphermeneuticsampasampitampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp HansltGeorgampGadameramp(1900lt2002)ampinvestigatesampaampmoderateampformampofamp
hermeneuticsampthatampisampparticularlyamprelevantampinampserviceamptoampartampeducationampampGadameramp
breaksampwithamphermeneuticamptraditionampbyampproposingampthatampthereampisampnoampabsolutelyampobjectiveamp
interpretationampreadersampareampnotampableamptoampescapeamptheampprejudicesampofamptheiramptimeamp(Gallagheramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 16amp
1992)ampampThisamphoweverampbecomesampanampopportunityampforamptheampcreationampofampmeaningampInampaamp
passageampthatampechoesamptheampendlesslyampunfoldingampnatureampofampcollageampCaputoamp(2000)amprefersamp
toampanampexchangeampbetweenamppastampandamppresentampinamptheampcreativeamppossibilitiesampofamphermeneuticamp
interpretationamp
amp Thereampisampaamprichnessampinamphistoricalampeventsampthatampjustampkeepsampunfoldingampwhichampisamp
amp certainlyampnotampgraspedampbyamptheamporiginalampprotagonistsampwhichampgraduallyampunfoldsamp
amp overamptheampcourseampofamptimeampandampwhichampisampinampprincipleampneverampfullyampunfoldedampItampisamp
amp anampexcessampwhichampkeepsampspillingampoveramp(pamp47)amp
amp Gadamersampphilosophyampofamphermeneuticampunderstandingampisampformedampthroughamphisamp
notionsampaboutamplanguageampdialogueampandampconversationamp(Caputoamp2000ampSeebohmamp2004)ampamp
InampadditionamptoampGadamersampimplicitamprelianceamponamplisteningampasampheampdiscussesampdialogueamphisamp
workampcapitalizesamponamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampinamplanguageamp(Heelanamp1985)ampmakingamphisamp
formampofamphermeneuticsampparticularlyampapplicableamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp Gadamersamptermampfusion-of-horizonsamprefersamptoamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampwithinampaamp
varietyampofampencountersampampAampfusionampofamphorizonsampcanampbeampdescribedampasampaampdialogicamp
conversationampbetweenampreaderampandamptextamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampWithinamptheamptextualamp
paradigmampGadamerampbelievesampthatampaampwrittenamptextampisampopenamptoampanampinvisibleampandampindefiniteamp
readerampwhoampentersampintoampanampunknownampadventureampofamptheamptextamp(Ricoeuramp2013amppamp13)ampamp
Theamphorizonampitselfampisamptheamprangeampofampvisionampthatampincludesampeverythingampthatampcanampbeampseenamp
fromampaampparticularampvantageamppointamp(Gadameramp2004amppamp301)ampampLikeampcollageamptheampfusionampofamp
horizonsampisampaampprocessampcomposedampofamppastampandamppresentampwhichampareampopenamptoampandampinfinitelyamp
effectedampbyampeachampotheramp(Bourgeoisamp2007)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 17amp
amp Similarampconnectionsampcanampbeampdrawnampwhenampviewerampandampartworkampareampsubstitutedamp
forampreaderampandamptextampampInterpretationampandampunderstandingampbecomeampanampentwinedamp
creativeampendeavorampinampwhichamptheampviewerampparticipatesampasampmuchampasamptheampcreatorampbyamp
constructingampmeaningamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampPalmeramp(1969)ampalludesamptoamptheamppluralityampofamp
meaningampinampstatingampthatamptoampfocusamppurelyamponamptheamppositivityampofampwhatampaamptextampexplicitlyamp
saysampisamptoampdoampanampinjusticeamptoamptheamphermeneuticalamptaskamp(pamp234)ampampToampfocusamponampwhatampisamp
explicitampinampaampcollageampworkampwouldampbeamptoampdisregardamptheampconnectionsampandampcontradictionsamp
ofamptheampwholeampinampfavorampofampaampdirectampreadingampofamptheampindividualamppartsampthusampmissingampoutamponamp
otheramppossibleampdimensionsampofampmeaningamp
amp Theampkeyamptoamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampeducationampinamptextampandampbetweenamp
individualsampisamptheampabilityamptoamplistenampwithampopennessampampDefensiveamplisteningampisampaampwayampofamp
listeningampwithoutampopennessampitampisampaampwayampofampprotectingampourampsmallampversionampofamptheampworldamp
andampavoidingampmoralampclaimsamponampourselvesamp(Levinamp1989amppamp79)ampampLevinamp(1989)amp
discussesampplayfulamplisteningamp(pamp233)ampasampaampwayampofampcounteractingampdefensiveamplisteningampampamp
Bohmamp(1996)ampdiscussesampsuspendingampassumptionsampaampprocessampofampattendingamptoamp
assumptionsampratherampthanamprepressingampthemamporampcarryingampthemampoutampampNicholamp(1996)amp
explainsampaampcircumstanceampinampwhichampyouampencounterampaamppersonampyouampfeelampisampanampidiotampampampYouamp
wouldamprefrainampfromampsayingampsoampoutamploudampbutampyouampwouldampalsoamprefrainampfromampscoldingamp
yourselfampforampthisampthoughtampratherampyouampwouldampseeampthisampreactionampwithoutampfullyampengagingamp
withampitampampSimilarampsuggestionsamplikeampbracketingampofampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampareamp
discussedampinamptheampfollowingampsectionampamp
amp Gadamerampbelievesamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampwhatampallowsamptheampselfamptoampapproachamp
theampotherampitampisampaampprocessampinampwhichamptheampideasampofamptheampotherampbecomeamponesampownamp(Caputoamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 18amp
2000)ampampThisampisamphardlyampanampuncommonampexperienceampampInampfactampweampregularlyampencounteramptheamp
fusionampofamphorizonsampbyampintegratingamppastampunderstandingsampwithampcurrentampexperiencesampaamp
processampundoubtedlyampcomparableamptoampeducationamp(Zuckertamp2002)ampamp
amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsamplikeampeducationampcanampbeampfrustratingampandampemotionalamp
becauseampeachamphighlight[s]amptheampfinitudeampofamptheampinterpreterampandamptheamplimitationsampofamphisamp
understandingamp(Bourgeoisamp2007amppamp79)ampampTheamptermampsharesampsimilaritiesampwithamptheamp
problematic-momentampaamppedagogicalamptermampreferringamptoampaampbreachampinampaampdominantampgroupsamp
discourseampduringampwhichampsomethingamprepressedamparisesamp(KentampampampCummingamp2008)ampampKentamp
andampCummingamp(2008)ampexploreamptheampproblematicampmomentampasampaampdiscursiveampsiteampforamp
examiningampprejudiceampwithinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampandampitsamp
moreamppoliticallyampchargedampcounterpartamptheampproblematicampmomentampbothampexploreamp
Gadamersamp(1996)ampampassertionampthatamptheampotherampmayampnotamponlyamphaveampaamprightampbutampmayamp
actuallyampbeamprightampmayampunderstandampsomethingampbetterampthanampweampdoamp(pamp82)ampampAampcreativelt
listeningampspaceamplivesampinampthisamppossibilityampampamp
amp Lastlyamprelayingampofampappropriateampexpectationsamptoampparticipantsampisampaampnecessaryamp
featureampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampdemandingampampItamp
requiresampparticipantsampwhoampareampawareampofamptheamprisksampandamphardshipsamptoampenterampintoampitampampItamp
isamptheampresponsibilityampofamptheampeducatoramporampgroupampleaderamptoampmakeamptheseampexpectationsamp
knownampasampwellampasamptoampmodelampthisampbehaviorampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionamphermeneuticallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Areampopenamptoamppossibilitiesampandamptoamptheampotherampbull Conceiveampofampthemselvesampasampengagingampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamptheamprisksampinvolvedampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamplimitationsampofamptheirampunderstandingamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 19amp
Dialogic(Practices(-
I-felt-that-everyone-was-open-and-interested-in-what-I-had-to-say---Perhaps-I-felt-this-sense-of-understanding-due-to-the-nature-of-the-discussion((-
it-felt-[like]-more-[of]-a-dialogue-as-opposed-to-a-standard-critique-(Survey-response-MW-age-22)-
(amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampartampeducationampreliesamponampanampopenampdialogueampduringamp
experiencesampwithampartampselfampandampothersampampWhatampIampfoundamplackingampinamphermeneuticsamp
howeverampwasampaampdiscussionampofamptheamphowltlthowampisamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampachievedampandamp
howampdoampindividualsampmeaningfullyampengageampwithampeachampotherampampInampanampeffortamptoampclarifyampthisamp
Iampwillampdiscussampdialogicamppracticesampasamptheyamprelateamptoampmeaningfulampverbalampexchangesampandamp
listeningampencountersampinamptheampclassroomampandampstudioampamongstampstudentsamptheiramppeersampandamp
educatorsamp
amp Communicatingampthroughamplanguageampandampdialogueampisamphowampweampcoltconstructamp
worldsampwithampourselvesampandampothersampnotampjustampthroughampanampactampofamptransmissionampbutamp
becauseampourampcommunicativeampactsampgiveampbirthamptoampworldsamp(Lipariamp2014amppamp507)ampampSableamp
(2014)ampdescribesampdialogueampasampaampgenerativeampinterchangeampbetweenampparticipantsampasamp
opposedamptoampanampexchangeampofampviewsampwhereampindividualsampsimplyampadvocateamptheiramppositionsamp
(pamp8)ampampForampBohmamp(1996)ampitampisampaampstreamampofampmeaningampflowingampamongampandampthroughampusamp
(pamp6)ampampTheampnatureampofampdialogueampandampconversationampisampinherentlyampunplannedampampThisamp
dimensionampofampconversationampisampimportantamptoampGadameramp(2004)ampwhoampfindsampthatamp
participantsampinvolvedampinampconversationampareamplessamptheampleadersampofampitampthanamptheampledamp(pamp
385)ampampSableamp(2014)ampechoesampthisampbyampwritingampthatamptheampmostampimportantamppartsampofampanyamp
conversationampareampthoseampthatampneitheramppartyampcouldamphaveampimaginedampbeforeampstartingamp(pamp
8)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 20amp
amp Theseampareampnotionsampofampdialogueampamongampothersampthatampfindampaampparallelampinamptheamp
creativeampprocessampampFairfieldamp(2011)ampwritesampthatampinampprincipleampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinamp
dialogueamp(pamp83)ampaampsentimentampthatampalignsampwithampaampcommonampissueampencounteredampduringamp
theampcreativeampprocessltltnotampknowingampwhenampaamppieceampisampdoneampampAampquoteampoftenampattributedamp
toampLeonardoampdaampVinciampspeaksamptoampthisampideaampArtampisampneverampfinishedamponlyampabandonedampamp
Snowberamp(2007)ampdrawsampparallelsampbetweenampmentorshipampdialogueampandamptheampcreativeamp
processampfindingampthatampdeepamplisteningamppracticesampconnectampallampthreeampampSheampfindsampthatamptheamp
taskampofamptheampmentorampisamptheampsameampasamptheamptaskampofamptheampartistampthatampisamptoampbringampoutamptheamp
naturalampqualitiesampofamptheampstudentamporamptheampmediumampampSnowberamp(2007)ampcommentsamponampanamp
ideaampwellltknownampamongampartistsampwhichampisampthatampaampworkampofampartamphasampaamplifeampofampitsampownampthisamp
notionampisampreminiscentampofampGadamersampstatementampaboutampbeingampledampbyampconversationamp
ampamp Dialogicamppracticesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampeducationampemphasizeampaamp
phenomenologicalampdimensionamprequiringamptwoampthingsampfromampparticipantsampampFirstlyamp
participantsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampmustampfindampvalueampinamplisteningamptoamptheamp
narrativesampofamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampampTheseampparticipantsampknowampthatampeducationamp
isampforemostampaboutamptestimonyampaboutampsharingamptheampexperienceampofampbeingamphumanampsharingamp
lifeampconvictionsampandampknowledge((Wiercinskiamp2011amppamp109)ampampNarrativesampareamp
conceivedampofampasampaampwayampofamphumanampknowingamp(Vitanovaamp2010amppamp29)ampthatampmakesamptheamp
selfampampSecondlyampwhenamplisteningamptoamptheampnarrativesampofampothersampparticipantsampareampexpectedamp
toampbracketamptheirampownampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsamp(LindsethampampampNorbergamp2004)ampampThisamp
encouragesamplistenersamptoampexperienceampandampfindampmeaningampinamptheampnarrativesampofampothersamp
whileampfreeingamptheampspeakerampfromamptheampfearampofampbeingampjudgedampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 21amp
amp Bracketingampjudgmentampandampconclusionampisampaamppotentialamptoolampwithinamptheampcommonamp
artampeducationamppracticeampofampgroupampcritiquesampampElkinsamp(2001)ampfindsampthatamppeopleampwhoamphaveamp
experienceampinampartampjudgeampveryampquicklyampandampmostampteachersampwillamphaveampaampprovisionalamp
opinionampaboutampaampworkampinamptheampfirstamptenampsecondsamp(pamp121)ampampBracketingampconclusionampandamp
judgmentampisampparticularlyampimportantampforampeducatorsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
whoseampvolumeampofampviewingampexperiencesampcouldampleadamptoampeasyampassumptionsampwhenamp
encounteringampaampnewampworkampampamp
amp Elkinsamp(2001)ampdiscussesampthatampcritiquesampcanampalsoampbeampseenampasampexchangesampofamp
storiesamporampcollaborativeampstorytellingamp(pamp145)ampwhichampisampyetampanotherampwayampofamptalkingamp
aboutamppossibilitiesampforampdialogueampandampnarrativeampwithinampartampeducationampampElkinsamphoweveramp
findsampstorytellingamplimitingamponceamptheampdeeperampnarrativesampareampdiscoveredamp(2001amppamp
145)ampampThisampimpliesampthatampheampfindsamponlyampaampsingularampmeaningampandamponeampthatampisampnotamp
necessarilyampusefulampforampcollaborativeampgroupampcritiquesamp
amp Insteadampparticipantsampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampbringampknowledgeampofamp
polysemyamptoampcollaborativeampcritiqueampexperiencesampasampwellampasamptoampexperiencesampofampmakingamp
artworkampampAccordingamptoampMuldoonamp(2002)amppolysemyampisamptheampqualityampofampaampwordamporampotheramp
languageampunitampthatampcanampbearampmultipleampmeaningsamp(asampcitedampinampWorsleyamp2012amppamp308)ampampamp
Aamptextualampexampleampofampthisampisamptheampmultipleampmeaningsampofamptheampwordampcan-Iampcanampdriveampaampcaramp
Idamplikeampaampcan-ofampsodaampheampwasntampworkingampveryamphardampsoampIamphadamptoampcan-himamp(Munozamp
2014)ampampampButampifampweampconsideramppolysemyampmetaphoricallyamporampvisuallyamptheampideaampthatampaamp
singleampunitampimageamporampintentionampcouldampbearampmultipleampmeaningsampcouldampbeampproductiveampinamp
creatingltlisteningampspacesampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 22amp
amp Thisampunfoldingampofampmeaningampworksampwellampinamptheampcontextampofampcollageampandampdialogueamp
asampwellampasamphermeneuticsampampInampfactamphermeneuticsampimpliesamppolysemyampbecauseampofampitsamp
notionampthatampitampisampalwaysampaamppossibilityampofampmyampunderstandingampthatampisampplayedampoutampwhenampIamp
understandampaamptextamp(Grondinamp2002amppamp38)ampampPolysemyampcouldampbeampconceptualizedampasampanamp
alternativeampexplorationampofampmeaningampthatampfunctionsampcollaborativelyampwithinampcritiquesampamp
Forampexampleampeducatorsampcanampaskampstudentsamptoamprespondamptoampaampworkampthroughampcollageamp
journalampentriesampmusicampfilmampasampindividualsamporampinampgroupsampampKnowledgeampofamppolysemyamp
couldampalsoampbeampusedampasampaamptoolampforampcreatingampimagesampthatamprecognizesampaamprelationshipamp
betweenamptheampvisualamptheamplinguisticampandamptheampmultipleamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionampdialogicallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Placeampvalueamponampexperientialampnarrativesampbull Practiceamplisteningampbyampbracketingampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampbull Embraceamppolysemicampexplorationsampofampmeaningampamp
Contemplative(Practices(
I-knew-I-was-being-heard-because-of-her-mannerisms-and-the-look-on-her-face--She-was-calm-attentive-and-not-trying-to-jump-in-and-offer-any-advice--She-asked-questions-that-pointed-to-things-I-had-not-openly-articulated-because-of-uncertainty--
This-was-one-of-the-ways-I-knew-I-was-being-heard-(Survey-response-LS-age-27)-
(amp Ifamphermeneuticsampandampdialogicamppracticesampgiveampusamptheampbroadampstrokesampofampactivityampinamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampcontemplativeamppracticesampseekamptoamptuneampstudentsampandamp
educatorsampintoampnuanceampdeliberationampandampdeepampexplorationampampThisampisampaampmostlyamp
individualampinternalamppursuitampthatampfocusesamponampformsampofampselfltlisteningampbutampcontemplativeamp
practicesampareampalsoampformedampbyampanampawarenessampofampinterconnectednessamp
amp InamppursuitampofampcriticalampthinkingampSableamp(2014)ampoutlinesampaampsetampofampcontemplativeamp
practicesampforampstudentsampthatampincludeampmindfulampmeditationampstructuredampcontemplationamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 23amp
journalampwritingampmindfulamplisteningampreflectiveampinquiryampandampdialogueamp(pamp4)ampampWhileamp
Sablesamp(2014)ampmethodampforampcontemplativeamppracticesampprovidesampaampconcreteampframeworkamp
withampspecificampstepsampmanyampofamptheseampconceptsampcouldampbeampappliedampwithoutampsuchampaamp
prescribedampstructureampampForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwillampbeamp
primarilyampdiscussingampSablesampconceptsampofampstructuredampcontemplationampreflectiveamp
inquiryampandampjournalampwritingamp
amp ForampSableamp(2014)ampstructuredampcontemplationampisampaampformampofampbeingamppresentampandamp
focusedamponampaampparticularampquestionampstatementamporampimageampampWithinampthisampmodeampofampinquiryamp
participantsampareampexpectedamptoampholdamptheampobjectampofampcontemplationampinamptheirampmindsamp
deepeningampunderstandingampasamptheyampfocusampwithoutampanalyzingampitamporampmanipulatingampitampinamp
anyampwayamp(pamp5)ampampThisamppracticeampdrawsampcomparisonsamptoamptheampbracketingampofampjudgmentsamp
andampconclusionsampsupportedampinamptheamppreviousampsectionampbutampstructuredampcontemplationamp
occursamponampanampindividualamplevelampratherampthanampdialogicallyamp
amp Reflectiveampinquiryampbearsampsomeampsimilaritiesamptoampstructuredampcontemplationampbutamp
Sableamp(2014)amppositionsampitampasampanampactivityampbetweenamptwoampindividualsampaamplistenerampandampaamp
speakerampampTheamplistenerampisampagainampaskedamptoampsuspendampjudgmentampbutampalsoamptoampengageampinampaamp
formampofampcuriosityampinampwhichampinnocentampquestionsampareampaskedampinamporderamptoampgainamp
understandingampampSableamp(2014)ampcontrastsampinnocentampquestionsampwithampleadingampquestionsampamp
ForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwouldampcharacterizeampthisampinnocentamp
questioningampasampaampformampofampopenltendedampquestioningampampSableamp(2014)ampidentifiesampanamp
exampleampofampanampinnocentamp(orampopenltended)ampquestionampWhatampdidampyouampmeanampwhenampyouamp
saidamp________ampConverselyampaampleadingampquestionampisampDidampyouampmeanamptoampsayamp________ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 24amp
amp Sableamp(2014)ampusesampjournalampwritingampasampaamppieceampofamphisamplargerampstructureampofamp
contemplativeamppracticesampbutampjournalampwritingampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampcouldamp
potentiallyampoccupyampaampsignificantamproleampampIampconceiveampofampjournalampwritingampinampmyampownamp
creativeamppracticeampasampaampformampofampdocumentationampthatampmakesampmeampmoreampawareampofampmyamp
creativeampprocessamptheampemotionalamphabitsampthatampsurroundampitampandamptheampthemesampthatamp
structureampmyampworkampampIampconceptualizeampthisampwayampofampwritingampasampaampformampofampselfltlisteningamp
relatedamptoampaampkeyampconceptampofamphermeneuticsampfoundampinampGadamersampassertionampthatampallamp
educationampisampaampformampofampselflteducationamp(Grondinamp2011)ampampamp
amp Germeraadamp(2013)ampusesampjournalampwritingamptoampexploreamptheampemotionalampandamprationalamp
relationshipsamptoamphisampcreativeampprocessampparallelamptoampexecutingampaampnewampbodyampofampworkampampHeamp
findsampthatampwritingampduringamphisampprocessampisampaamptoolamptoampunderstandamp[his]amppsycheamptoampeaseamp
theamppainampthatampanampartisticampprocessampcanampbringampandamptoamprelieveampartisticampblocksamp
(Germeraadamp2013amppamp21)ampultimatelyampdeclaringampthatampitamphelpsamphimamptoampbetterampunderstandamp
hisampworkampampInampaampstyleampofampwritingampthatamposcillatesamparoundampjournalingampdocumentationampandamp
poetryampdeampCossonamp(2002)ampexploresamphisampoverlappingamprolesampasampanampartistampresearcherampandamp
teacherampampOtherampartistsampbluramptheamplineampbetweenampartamppracticeampdocumentationampandamplifeamp
furtherampstillampbyampofferingampdocumentationampasampartamplikeampSophieampCalleamp(Calleamp2011amp2008amp
2005)ampandampMaryampKellyamp(1973lt1979)ampampamp
amp Karpiakamp(2003)ampestablishesampcontemplativeamppracticesampfromamptheampperspectiveampofamp
theampeducatorampaskingampthemamptoampmineamptheampsubtleamp(pamp71)ampusingampattentivenessamp
attunementampamplificationampandampassociationampampTheseampexercisesampinampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampsetamptheamptoneampasampwellampasampprovideampaampmodelampofampbehaviorampforampotherampparticipantsamp
withinamptheampspaceampampKarpiakamp(2003)ampoutlinesampactivitiesampthatampeducatorsampcanampuseamptoampdrawamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 25amp
outampandamputilizeamptheseampsubtleampsensationsampinamptheampserviceampofamptransformativeamplearningamp(pamp
68)ampampamp
amp ForampKarpiakamp(2003)ampattentivenessamprequiresampawarenessamptoampverbalampandamp
nonverbalampcuesampasampwellampasampanampawarenessampofampwhatampisamphappeningampamongampandampwithinamptheamp
studentsampandamptheampeducatorampampAttunementamprequiresampanampeducatoramptoamporientampherselfamptoamptheamp
otherampandamptoampadoptampanampattitudeampofampunhurriednessampofamppatienceampandampofamphumilityamp
concerningampbothamptheampprocessampandamptheampoutcomesampofamptheampteachingamp(Karpiakamp2003amppgamp
72)ampampAmplificationampisampaampprocessampofamphonoringampcommunicationampthatampcentersamponamptheampideaamp
ofamphearingamponeselfampintoampknowingampitampincludesampusingampparaphrasingampandampclarificationamp
activitiesamptoampgainampinsightampintoampmeaningampampLastlyampassociationampentailsampidentifyingamp
patternsampandampweavingampthemamptogetherampwithampstudentampexperienceampclassroomampdiscussionamp
andamptheampideasampofampothersamp
amp TuningampintoampsubtletyampimpliesampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceampampTheampmanifestationsamp
ofampsilenceampinamptheampclassroomampareampendlessampandampitsampvalueampisamptooampgreatamptoampbeampignoredampwhileamp
tooampvastamptoampbeampfullyampabsorbedampampLevinamp(1989)ampremarksampthatampsilenceampisampaampclearingampwhereamp
thereampisampnothingampforamphearingamptoampholdamponamptoampinampwhichampmanyampfindampunbearableampanxietyamp
(pamp79)ampampNearlyampallampofampusamphaveampexperiencedampthisampunbearableampanxietyampaampstrainampofamp
whichampcanampbeampfoundampinampeducationalampcontextsampdueamptoamptheampfactampthatampclassroomsampareamp
oftenampstructuredamparoundampimplicitampandampexplicitamprulesampaboutamptalkampandampsilenceamp(Schultzamp
2010amppamp2848)ampampForampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampanampawarenessampofampsilenceampimplicatesamp
whatampisampleftampunsaidampandampwhatampisampunsayableltltespeciallyampimportantampbecauseampofamptheamp
unsayableampqualityampofampartworksampampForampSchultzamp(2010)ampsilenceampimpliesamppossibilityamp
becauseampitampcanampholdampmultipleampmeaningsampforampindividualsampwithinampandampacrossampracialamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 26amp
ethnicampandampculturalampgroupsamp(pamp2833)ampampLevinamp(1989)ampfindsampthatamptoamplistenamptoamp
somethingampweampmustampfirstampgive-itampourampsilenceamp(pamp232)ampampThisamppracticeampofampgivingampsilenceamp
isampparticularlyamphelpfulampinamptermsampofampviewingamporamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartamp
amp Gradleamp(2011)ampoutlinesampaamppracticalampvisionampforampviewingampartampthatamprequiresamp
silenceampandampdeliberationampampForamptheamppurposesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampwouldamp
reconceptualizeampthisampasampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampampGradleamp(2011)ampinstructedamp
herampstudentsamptoampspendamptimeampwithampaampworkampofampartampoutsideampofamptheirampeverydayampworldviewamp
attentivelyampviewingampitampforampaboutamptenampminutesampeverydayampforampaampweekampampAfterampeachampviewingamp
experienceamptheampstudentsampwroteampinamptheirampjournalsampampTheampresultsampindicatedampthatampthisamp
processampofampsustainedampsilentampdeliberationampcoupledampwithampanampengagementampofamptheiramp
intuitiveampperceptionsampaboutampartworkampleftampstudentsampfeelingampempoweredamptoampengageampinamp
discussionampandampappreciateampunfamiliarampartampformsampampThisampactivityampisampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoamp
aampworkampofampartampthatampincorporatesampSablesamp(2014)ampconceptampofampstructuredampcontemplationampamp
Weavingampaamprelationshipampbetweenampsilenceampcontemplationampandampattentivenessampisampaamp
significantampendeavorampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
Contemplativeamppracticesampfunctionampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Engageampinampformsampofampviewingampwritingampandampexperiencingampthatamphonorampselfltlisteningamp
bull Attuneamptoampsubtletyampandampnuanceampbull Listenampandampviewampdeliberatelyampbull Cultivateampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceamp(
The(Felt(Sense(
When-someone-understands-what-I-am-talking-about-when-I-talk-about-art-I-am-delighted--Art-is-my-everything--Its-my-passion--When-someone-understands-that-I-
am-instantly-filled-with-joy--That-tells-me-someone-gets-it-(Survey-response-CTF-age-16)-
(
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 5amp
(thread1(
The(Possibility(of(Possibilities(Creative=Listening(Spaces(in(Art(Education(
TheampartsampinampeducationampshouldampthusamprecognizeamppossibilitiesampthatampopenampnewamphorizonsampinampbothampformampandampsubstanceampampThisampisamptrueampnotamponlyampinamptheampartsampbutampalsoampinampeducationampinampitsampvariousampmanifestationsampampTheamppossibilitiesampofamptheampworkampofampartampmustampbeampcentralampmustampbeamphonoredampampIfampweampcanamphonoramptheampvisualamppoeticampandampgesturalamppossibilitiesampinamptheampartsampweamp
thenampcanampbeginamptoampunderstandamptheampopeningsampmadeampaccessibleampbyampamplivingampin-theampquestionsamp(Greeneamp2013amppamp252)amp
ampamp
amp CollageampholdsamphighampesteemampinampmyampcreativeamppracticeampampItampisampnotampthatampIampvalueampitsamp
visualampimpactampoverampotherampformsampofampmediaampnorampdoampIampenjoyampitampmoreampthanampotherampmodesampofamp
creativeampexpressionampampSimplyampputampcollageampisampusuallyampwhatampgetsampmeampunstuckampampItampisamptheamp
leverampIampuseamptoampfreeampmyselfampfromampaampdisappointingampdrawingampampInsteadampofamplaboringampoverampaamp
workamporampthrowingampawayampanampotherwiseampinoffensiveamppieceampofamppaperampIampuseampcollageampasampaamp
lastltditchampeffortamptoampmakeampsomethingltltanythingltltthatampIampdontamphaveamptoampstruggleampagainstampamp
Theampdrawingampisamptornampupamppaintedampoverampstapledampsewedamptogetherampcutampintoampstripsampandamp
wovenampampMaybeampitsampjustampthrownampinampmyampdrawerampofampsadampbadampdrawingsampthatampareampallamp
waitingampforamptheamprightampmomentamptoampbecomeampnewampampTheamppointampisampwhatampbeganampasampaampbadamp
drawingampandamppossiblyampaampbadamporampfrustratingampexperienceampdoesntamphaveamptoampremainampinampmyamp
mentalamparchiveampofampDrawings-That-Have-FailedampampInsteadamptheseampworksampareampsimplyamp
deconstructedampandampfoldedampintoampanotheramppossibilityampampCollageampengagesampwithamptheampactampofamp
layeringampandamptheampsenseampofampfearlessnessampgainedampwhenampIampholdampontoamptheampfactampthatampthereampisamp
alwaysampanotheramppossibilityampforampaampworkampamp
amp Theampphysicalampactampofamplayeringamphoweverampisampinampserviceamptoampaampdeeperampsenseampofamptheamp
wordampampWhenampweamparticulateamppowerfulampviewingampexperiencesampwordsampoftenampfailampusampampWeamp
mayampsayampthatampweampfeelampaampclickampaampconnectionamporampanampaestheticampexperienceampwhenampviewingampaamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 6amp
pieceampampTheseampareampwaysampweampexpressamptheampprelinguisticampfeltampdimensionsampofampbeingampwithampaamp
workampofampartampampTemporallyampthisamptakesampplaceampwithinampaampsingleampmomentampinamptimeampampButamp
meaningfulampencountersampwithampartampareamponlyampmeaningfulampbecauseamptheyampareampcomposedampofamp
countlessamppreviousampmomentsampwordsampexperiencesampknowledgeampconversationsamp
relationshipsampandampallamptheampminutiaampthatampconstituteampanampindividualsampidentityampampInampthisamp
conceptionampofampmeaningltmakingamptheamplayersampofampexperiencesampwithinamptheampindividualamptheamp
groupampandamptheampspacesampbetweenampareamprespectedampforamptheirampvalueampinamptheampformationampofamp
singularampandampcollectiveampidentitiesamp
amp Oftenampviewersampandampeducatorsampdiscussampinterpretativeampprocessesampfromamp
frameworksampsuchampasampaampworksamppositionampinampartamphistoryamptheampbiographyampofamptheampartistamp
socialampimplicationsampandampsoamponampampThereampisampaampparallelamptoampbeampfoundamphereampinamptheampdrawingamp
processampampIfampweamppresupposeampthatampthereampisampaampcorrectampwayamptoampinterpretampandampaampperfectamp
drawingamptoampbeamphadampweamprunamptheampriskampofampnotamptryingampforampfearampofampfailureampampItsampnoampstretchamptoamp
sayampthatampindividualsampwhoamplackampartsampexperienceampareamphesitantamptoampengageampwithampaampworkampofamp
artampforampfearampofampexposingamptheirampsupposedampignoranceampampOnamptheampotheramphandampifampweampengageampinamp
aampwayampofampviewingampthatampidentifiesampwithamptheampfluidityampofampcollageampweampcanampacknowledgeamp
possibilityampasampaampfeatureampofampinterpretationampampByampconceivingampofampinterpretationampasampaampformamp
ofampcollagingamptogetherampmeaningfulampexperiencesampviewersampcouldampgainampaccessamptoamptheamp
complexamplayeredampandampmessyampdimensionsampofampmeaningampwhenamptheyamplistenamptoampaampworkampofamp
artamp
Creative=Listening(Space(
amp Iampofferamptheamptermampcreative(listening-spaceampasampanampalternativeampmodeampofamp
experiencingampviewingampandampproducingampcreativeampworksampampInsteadampofampplacingampsubjectamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 7amp
matterampinformationamporamptheamproleampofamptheampeducatorampatamptheampcenterampofamptheseampexperiencesampIamp
proposeampthatampactsampofamplisteningampbeampembeddedampinampmakingampandampviewingampartampampTheamptermamp
creativeltlisteningampspaceamprefersamptoamptheampfluidampandampflexibleampspaceampinampwhichamplisteningamp
practicesampareampanampintegratedampessentialamppartampofampviewingampdiscussingampandampproducingamp
creativeampworksampampArtistsampviewersampstudentsampandampeducatorsampcanamptransformampartamp
classroomsampstudiosampandampsitesampofampviewingampartampintoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhichampareamp
notampdefinedampbyampphysicalampformamporampstructuralampboundariesampampRatheramptheyampareampdefinedampbyamp
specificamppracticesampthatampoccurampamongstampindividualsampandampgroupsampinamptheampcontextampofampartamp
educationampamp
Research(Issue(
amp Theampoverarchingampconcernampinampthisampresearchampisamptheamppotentialampoutcomeampforampusingamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampwithinampartampeducationampampTheamppracticesampIampdiscussamphereamphaveampinamp
commonampaampdistinctiveampflexibilityampandampmalleabilityampampTheyampmayampbeampadaptedamptoampvariousamp
ageampgroupsampeducationalampsitesampandampcontextsampampWhileampIampofferampsuggestionsampIampexpectampthatamp
theamppractitionersampwhoampwishamptoampuseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwillampdeviseamptheirampownamp
methodsampofampimplementationampbasedamponamptheirampspecificampneedsampandampcontextsampampThoughamptheamp
ideaampofampcreativeamplisteningampspacesampemergedampwithinampanampartsampeducationampcontextampampthisamp
conceptampmayampholdampvalueampforampotherampdisciplinesamp
Boundaries(and(Limitations(of(the(Research(
( Iampundertookampthisampresearchampinampfulfillmentampofampaampmastersampdegreeampinampartampeducationamp
atamptheampUniversityampofampCincinnatisampCollegeampofampDesignampArtampArchitectureampandampPlanningamp
(DAAP)ampampTheampresponsesampexperiencesampandampartworkampgeneratedampduringamptheampcourseampofamp
thisampprojectamphaveampoftenampcenteredamparoundampthatampinstitutionampwhichamphousesampaampprimarilyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 8amp
whiteampmiddleltamptoampupperltclassampstudentamppopulationamponampanampurbanampcampusampampIampamampaampwhiteamp
femaleamppursuingamphigherampeducationampampIampwantamptoampacknowledgeampthisamppositionalityampalongamp
withamptheamppersonalampbiasesampaamplifetimeampofampexperiencesamphasampaffordedamptoampmeampampOneampinternalamp
goalampthatampdevelopedampoveramptheampcourseampofampthisampworkampwasampaampcontinuedampconsistentampeffortamp
toampuncoverampandampinterrogateampmyampownampbiasesampasamptheyampmanifestedampampThoughampweampcanampneveramp
beampfreeamporamppureampofamptheseampbiasesampconstantampexaminationampofampthemamphasampbeenampmyampchosenamp
routeamptoampcounteringamptheiramppowerampandampinfluenceampamp
Iampamamppassionateampaboutamptheampmeaningfulamppossibilitiesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampInamprespectampofampmyampownamplimitationsampandampthoseampofampthisampworkamphoweverampIampwillampnotamp
claimampthatampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampareampfeasibleampwithinamptheampcontextampofampeveryamp
educationalampsettingampnorampthatampthisampwayampofampviewingampmakingampandampexperiencingampworksampofamp
artampisampmoreamporamplessampvalidampthanampothersampampRatherampIampsuggestamptheamppossibilityampofamplivingampinamp
possibilitiesampasampaampwayamptoampcultivateampmeaningfulampencountersampwithinampartampandampartamp
educationamp
Data(
amp ForampthisampresearchampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponampthreeampformsampofampdataamp
participantampsurveysampcaseampstudiesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampandampreflectiveamppracticeamp
formsampofampartmakingampallampcollectedampduringampaampfourltmonthampperiodampampToampgatherampparticipantamp
responsesampfromamptheampsurveysampandampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampreliedamponampaampmultitudeampofamp
friendsamppeersampandampcolleaguesampampIampconnectedampwithamptheampmajorityampofamptheseampindividualsamp
duringamporampasampaampresultampofampmyampexperiencesampatampDAAPampampampIampusedamp37ampsurveyampresponsesampaboutamp
listeningampexperiencesampwithampaampparticipantampageamprangeampofamp14amptoamp47ampampParticipantsamp
educationalamplevelsampspannedamphighampschoolamptoampgraduateampschoolampampIamppersonallyampsolicitedamptheamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 9amp
majorityampofamptheamplisteningampsurveysampatamptheampcollegeamplevelampandampaboveampampTheampbulkampofamptheamphighamp
schoolltagedampresponsesampwereampsolicitedampbyampmyampcolleagueampaampphotographyampteacherampatampaamp
Cincinnatiltareaamphighampschoolamp
amp Iampconductedampfiveampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampexperiencesampwithampsixampindividualsampasamp
partampofampthisampresearchampagainampusingampmanyampofamptheamppersonalampandampprofessionalampconnectionsamp
cultivatedampthroughamptheampDAAPampprogramampampIampdeliberatelyampchoseamppeopleampwithampwhomampIamphadamp
variousamplevelsampandamptypesampofamprelationshipsampampIampwillampspeakampmoreampinltdepthampaboutamptheseamp
experiencesampasampwellampasampexploreamptheampsurveyampresponsesampinamptheampResearchampMethodologyamp
andampMethodsampsectionamp
amp Lastlyamptheampdevelopmentampofampanampartmakingamppracticeampwasampessentialamptoampmyampownamp
personalampunderstandingampofamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatampcomposedampmyampresearchamp
ReadersampwillampnoticeampthatampimagesampareampembeddedampinampthisamptextampampTheseampareampimagesampofamptheamp
resultingampproductsampofampaamppracticeampofampunderstandingampthroughampmakingampampIampwillampdiscussamp
themampthroughoutampvariousampsectionsampofampthisamppaperampampamp
Dear(Reader(The(Structure(of(this(Research(Paper(
DearampReader(s)amp
amp Letampmeampbreakampforampaampmomentampfromampstandardampacademicamprhetoricampbeforeampthisamp
paperampreallyampgetsampstartedampampIampknowampwhatampyoureampthinkingltltnineamppagesampinampandampthisamppaperamp
hasntampevenampstartedampyetampampAlasampthisampsectionampisampmyamponeampofampmyampfavoriteampandampmostampoftlt
skimmedamppassagesampofampanampacademicamppaperamptheampstructureampofamptheamppaperampampThisampisamptheamppartamp
whereamptheampwriterampsaysampwhatampshesampaboutamptoampsayampbeforeampsheampsaysampitampampampItsampanamp
organizationalampstrategyampandampitsampthrillingampampLuckilyampforampyouampniceamppersonampwhoampisamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 10amp
readingampthisamppaperampIamphaveampprovidedampaamptranslationampfromampthisamptextsamporiginalampAcademiaamp
intoampnormalltpeopleltlanguageamp
amp Theampstructureampofampthisamppaperampisampasampfollowsampamp(Im-about-to-tell-you-whats-in-this-
long-ass-paper)ampampFirstlyamppleaseampnoteampthatampIampuseamptheamptermampthreadampinamplieuampofampchapteramp
asampanamporganizationalampstructureampIamppreferamptheampformerampbecauseampofamphowampitsampconceptualamp
qualitiesamprelateamptoampmyampworkampamp(Thread-is-awesome-and-you-can-do-tons-of-stuff-with-it-
like-sew-knot-tie-weave-etc--Chapters-are-not-nearly-as-exciting)--Iampwillampfirstampshareamp
myampresearchersampreflexiveampnarrativeampamp(I-made-up-a-cool-story-about-this-project-to-
describe-where-it-all-came-from)ampampThenampIampshallampofferampaampdescriptionampofamptheampqualitiesampofampaamp
creativeltlisteningampspaceampamp(Yes-I-shall)ampampIampwillampdiscussamptheampliteratureampthatampinformsamptheamp
backboneampofampmyampresearchampGadamersamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamp
practicesampandampGendlinsamptheampfeltampsenseampamp(Like-a-typical-graduate-student-I-have-done-
an-insane-amount-of-reading-during-the-past-two-academic-years--A-significant-
portion-of-this-reading-has-been-dedicated-to-those-topics--Dont-ask-me-to-type-them-
out-again-because-Im-seriously-done)ampampTheseampsectionsampbeginampwithampaamppassageampderivedamp
fromampsurveyampresponsesampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampamp(I-got-a-bunch-of-people-to-fill-
out-surveys-for-this-research-and-then-I-put-those-responses-in-my-paper)ampampTheseamp
experiencesampwithamplisteningampwereampprovidedampbyampresearchampparticipantsampamp(Super-nice-
people-I-know-and-some-I-dont-helped-me-out)ampampTheyampareampthereamptoampgroundamptheamp
conceptualampframeworksampinamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampamp(This-basically-means-
none-of-this-research-is-worth-shit-unless-it-can-be-used-in-the-real-world((I-hope-youll-
agree)ampampIampwillampthenampshareampmyampresearchampmethodologyampandampmethodsampamp(Im-going-to-tell-
you-about-how-and-why-I-did-this-project-in-using-big-smart(sounding-words)ampampLastlyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 11amp
Iampwillampconcludeampwithamppossibilitiesampforampthisampresearchampamp(Ill-figure-out-what-I-learned-and-
share-it-with-you-my-new-best-friend-who-made-it-all-the-way-to-the-conclusions-
section)ampampInampthisamppaperampreadersampwillampnoticeamptransparentampimagesampinteractingampwithamptheamp
textampamp(Its-my-art-on-transparent-sheets-in-this-very-paper)ampampTheseampareampworksampofampartamp
thatampIampcreatedamptoampgroundamptheampresearchampinampaamppracticeampofampmakingamptheyampareamptheampphysicalamp
embodimentampofampconceptualampideasampandamptheyampareampalwaysamppresentamptoamptheampresearchampamp
(Research-papers-with-pictures-are-much-more-tolerable-am-I-right)amp
amp Hereampweampgoamp
amp
thread2(
Collaging(Experience1(
amp ImagineampthatampyouampareampanampartistampseatedampatampyourampstudioamptableampampYouamphaveamp
everythingampyouampneedampampTheamproomampisampquietampsaveampforamptheampmuffledampsoundsampofampaampdistantamp
outsideampworldampampYouampsurveyamptheampcollectionampofampimagesampyouamphaveampgatheredamparoundampyouampamp
OnampyouramprightampisampaampraggedamppageampfromampanampoldampsketchbookampampGlossyampjewellttonedampswatchesamp
fromampaampdiscardedampfashionampmagazineampareampstackedampupampglisteningampinamptheamplightampampMonthsamp
agoampyouamppickedampupampaamphandfulampofampblackampandampwhiteampphotosampfromampaampsecondhandampstoreamp
todayamppastyampfacesampofamptheampunknownampsubjectsampstareampthroughampyouampblanklyampampAamppaleampyellowamp
scrapampofampleftoverampfabricampisampdrapedampoveramplastampweeksamppleatedamptoltdoamplistampampTheseampandamptwoamp
dozenampotherampscrapsamppiecesamppilesampandampcrumbsampareampyouramptoolsamptodayampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampamp1ampThisampsectionampisampsupposedamptoampbeampmyampresearchersampreflexiveampnarrativeampaamppassageampaboutampwhereampmyampresearchampideasampcameampfromltltandampinampfactampcollageampisampactuallyampwhereampthisampideaampcomesampfromampampOneampofamptheampfirstampresearchampinterestsampIampdiscussedampwithampmyampprofessorampDrampKristopherampHollandampwasamplayersampbothampphysicalampandampconceptualampampHeampwasamplikeampOhampampYoureamptalkingampaboutamphermeneuticsampSoampinampaampwayampthisampresearchampprojectampbothampbeganampandampconcludedamp(moreamponampthatamplater)ampwithampideasampofamplayeringampandampcollageampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 12amp
amp TheampresidueampthatampclingsamptoamptheseampscrapsampisampexperienceampampTheampoldampsketchbookamp
pageampisampanampimageampofampaampwomansamplegamprenderedampwithampchunkyamppencilampstrokesampampYouampmadeampitamp
whenampyouampwereamplivingampinampyourampoldampapartmentampoverlookingamptheampsquareampampItsampaampwomansamp
footampbutampitampremindsampyouampofamphavingampaamproommateampandampaampgrayampfutonampandampaampsummerampthatamp
wasampdesperatelyamphotampampItampisamponlyamppencilamponamppaperampbutampitampremindsampyouampofamptheampgreenamp
grassyampcenterampinamptheampmedianampofamptheampstreetampampOneamppencilampdrawingampofampaampwomansamplegamp
remindsampyouampofampthatampoldamplifeampandamptheampversionampofampyourselfampyouampwereampthenampitampisamptheampfirstamp
dominoampinampaampseriesampofampcascadingampdetailsampandampmemoriesampamp
amp EachampfragmentampsittingamponampyourampstudioamptableamphasampaampstoryampampEachampcameampfromampaamp
placeampandampwasamptouchedampbyampanotheramphumanampampEachampisampembeddedampwithampexperienceampcoloramp
memoryamptextureampandampinfiniteampdetailampbyamptheampmereampfactampofampitsampownampexistenceampamp
amp YouampbeginamptoamppickampapartamptheampephemeraampampYouampalternateampbeingampcarefulampandamp
carelessamp
amp Cuttingamptearingampburningampstretchingampfoldingampwhitewashingamprippingampcreasingamp
sewingampwritingamppaintingampencasingampfasteningampfillingampsoakingampdyeingampwashingamp
dryingampbitingampscratchingamppryingampyankingampsmoothingampsandingamppokingampstabbingamp
stretchingampfryingampheatingampdustingampcleaningampsculptingampslicingampdicingamppunchingamp
floatingamptwistingampflippingampdrippingampstaplingampstrippingampstripingamppatterningamp
designingampdrawingampsketchingampliftingampcollectingamptapingampgluingampbuttoningampknottingamp
weavingampknittingamp
amp YouampdoampallampofamptheseampthingsampandampprobablyampmanyampotherampthingsampampTheampfragmentsamponamp
youramptableampchangeampshapeampandampgetampsmallerampampFromamptheseamppiecesampyouampbeginamptoampbuildamp
somethingampampThisampsomethingampisampbothampnewampandampoldampampJuxtapositionsampbloomampnewamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 13amp
connectionsampareampfusedampbyamptheampweightampofamppreviousampexperienceampampPastampandamppresentamp
liquefyampintoampendlesslyampcirculatingamppossibilitiesampampYouampcouldamptheoreticallyampcontinueampthisamp
processampofamplayeringampandampreconstructionampforeverampamptheamponlyamplimitsampareampyourampownamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 14amp
thread3(
what(is(a(creative=listening(space(
ampampampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeamplisteningampspaceampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampwhatampdoesampitampsoundampsmellamptasteampfeelamplikeampampampampampampampwhatampampisampamptheampamptextureampampofampampthisampampamp
spaceampampampanswerampmoreampquestionsampampamp specificsampandampgeneralizationsampareampbothampimpossibleampampmaybeampaampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampgoodampstartampwouldampbeampthisampampamp amp amp amp amp safeampampampamp amp amp amp amp foldedampampamp amp amp amp amp amp embodiedampamp layeredampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampconnectedampampampamp amp ampamp
(it-might--be-like-gently-holding-on-to--
a-knot-of-questions)-amp
ampampampampampampampampampamp
(possible)ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 15amp
thread4amp(
Review(of(Literature((
( AnampexplorationampofampGadamerrsquosamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampeducationalampcontextsampandampGendlinrsquosamptheoryampofampfeltampsenseampwereampintegralamptoamp
theampcreationampofamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampWhileampcompellingampconstructsamponamp
theirampownampwhenampdrawnamptogetheramptheseampphilosophicalampperspectivesampvibrateamp
holisticallyamptoampsuggestampintriguingamppossibilitiesampforamptheampuseampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
inampartsampeducationampampInampthisampsectionampIampreviewamptheampliteratureampandampconnectamptheampvariousamp
pointsampofampstudyampampamp
Hermeneutics(amp(the(Fusion(of(Horizons((
It-actually-feels-really-great-knowing-that-other-people-will-enjoy-the-art-you-created-and-knowing-they-know-your-reasoning-and-story-behind-it--Honestly-you-cant-know-if-your-words-are-getting-through-to-them-but-the-cool-thing-about-art-is-that-it-can-be-
interpreted-in-so-many-different-ways---(Survey-response-EK-age-15)-
ampamp Hermeneuticsampwhichamphasampitsamprootsampinamptextualampinterpretationampcanampbeampdefinedampasamp
aamptraditionampofampthinkingamporampofampphilosophicalampreflectionampthatamptriesamptoampclarifyamptheampconceptamp
ofampverstehenampthatampisampunderstandingamp(Brunsamp1992)ampampRicoeuramp(19691974)ampexplainsamp
thatamptheampkeyamphypothesisampofamphermeneuticampphilosophyampisampthatampinterpretationampisampanampopenamp
processampwhichampnoampsingleampvisionampcanampconcludeamp(pamp109)ampampWithampthisampinampmindampIampwillamp
exploreamphermeneuticsampasampitampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp HansltGeorgampGadameramp(1900lt2002)ampinvestigatesampaampmoderateampformampofamp
hermeneuticsampthatampisampparticularlyamprelevantampinampserviceamptoampartampeducationampampGadameramp
breaksampwithamphermeneuticamptraditionampbyampproposingampthatampthereampisampnoampabsolutelyampobjectiveamp
interpretationampreadersampareampnotampableamptoampescapeamptheampprejudicesampofamptheiramptimeamp(Gallagheramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 16amp
1992)ampampThisamphoweverampbecomesampanampopportunityampforamptheampcreationampofampmeaningampInampaamp
passageampthatampechoesamptheampendlesslyampunfoldingampnatureampofampcollageampCaputoamp(2000)amprefersamp
toampanampexchangeampbetweenamppastampandamppresentampinamptheampcreativeamppossibilitiesampofamphermeneuticamp
interpretationamp
amp Thereampisampaamprichnessampinamphistoricalampeventsampthatampjustampkeepsampunfoldingampwhichampisamp
amp certainlyampnotampgraspedampbyamptheamporiginalampprotagonistsampwhichampgraduallyampunfoldsamp
amp overamptheampcourseampofamptimeampandampwhichampisampinampprincipleampneverampfullyampunfoldedampItampisamp
amp anampexcessampwhichampkeepsampspillingampoveramp(pamp47)amp
amp Gadamersampphilosophyampofamphermeneuticampunderstandingampisampformedampthroughamphisamp
notionsampaboutamplanguageampdialogueampandampconversationamp(Caputoamp2000ampSeebohmamp2004)ampamp
InampadditionamptoampGadamersampimplicitamprelianceamponamplisteningampasampheampdiscussesampdialogueamphisamp
workampcapitalizesamponamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampinamplanguageamp(Heelanamp1985)ampmakingamphisamp
formampofamphermeneuticsampparticularlyampapplicableamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp Gadamersamptermampfusion-of-horizonsamprefersamptoamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampwithinampaamp
varietyampofampencountersampampAampfusionampofamphorizonsampcanampbeampdescribedampasampaampdialogicamp
conversationampbetweenampreaderampandamptextamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampWithinamptheamptextualamp
paradigmampGadamerampbelievesampthatampaampwrittenamptextampisampopenamptoampanampinvisibleampandampindefiniteamp
readerampwhoampentersampintoampanampunknownampadventureampofamptheamptextamp(Ricoeuramp2013amppamp13)ampamp
Theamphorizonampitselfampisamptheamprangeampofampvisionampthatampincludesampeverythingampthatampcanampbeampseenamp
fromampaampparticularampvantageamppointamp(Gadameramp2004amppamp301)ampampLikeampcollageamptheampfusionampofamp
horizonsampisampaampprocessampcomposedampofamppastampandamppresentampwhichampareampopenamptoampandampinfinitelyamp
effectedampbyampeachampotheramp(Bourgeoisamp2007)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 17amp
amp Similarampconnectionsampcanampbeampdrawnampwhenampviewerampandampartworkampareampsubstitutedamp
forampreaderampandamptextampampInterpretationampandampunderstandingampbecomeampanampentwinedamp
creativeampendeavorampinampwhichamptheampviewerampparticipatesampasampmuchampasamptheampcreatorampbyamp
constructingampmeaningamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampPalmeramp(1969)ampalludesamptoamptheamppluralityampofamp
meaningampinampstatingampthatamptoampfocusamppurelyamponamptheamppositivityampofampwhatampaamptextampexplicitlyamp
saysampisamptoampdoampanampinjusticeamptoamptheamphermeneuticalamptaskamp(pamp234)ampampToampfocusamponampwhatampisamp
explicitampinampaampcollageampworkampwouldampbeamptoampdisregardamptheampconnectionsampandampcontradictionsamp
ofamptheampwholeampinampfavorampofampaampdirectampreadingampofamptheampindividualamppartsampthusampmissingampoutamponamp
otheramppossibleampdimensionsampofampmeaningamp
amp Theampkeyamptoamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampeducationampinamptextampandampbetweenamp
individualsampisamptheampabilityamptoamplistenampwithampopennessampampDefensiveamplisteningampisampaampwayampofamp
listeningampwithoutampopennessampitampisampaampwayampofampprotectingampourampsmallampversionampofamptheampworldamp
andampavoidingampmoralampclaimsamponampourselvesamp(Levinamp1989amppamp79)ampampLevinamp(1989)amp
discussesampplayfulamplisteningamp(pamp233)ampasampaampwayampofampcounteractingampdefensiveamplisteningampampamp
Bohmamp(1996)ampdiscussesampsuspendingampassumptionsampaampprocessampofampattendingamptoamp
assumptionsampratherampthanamprepressingampthemamporampcarryingampthemampoutampampNicholamp(1996)amp
explainsampaampcircumstanceampinampwhichampyouampencounterampaamppersonampyouampfeelampisampanampidiotampampampYouamp
wouldamprefrainampfromampsayingampsoampoutamploudampbutampyouampwouldampalsoamprefrainampfromampscoldingamp
yourselfampforampthisampthoughtampratherampyouampwouldampseeampthisampreactionampwithoutampfullyampengagingamp
withampitampampSimilarampsuggestionsamplikeampbracketingampofampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampareamp
discussedampinamptheampfollowingampsectionampamp
amp Gadamerampbelievesamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampwhatampallowsamptheampselfamptoampapproachamp
theampotherampitampisampaampprocessampinampwhichamptheampideasampofamptheampotherampbecomeamponesampownamp(Caputoamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 18amp
2000)ampampThisampisamphardlyampanampuncommonampexperienceampampInampfactampweampregularlyampencounteramptheamp
fusionampofamphorizonsampbyampintegratingamppastampunderstandingsampwithampcurrentampexperiencesampaamp
processampundoubtedlyampcomparableamptoampeducationamp(Zuckertamp2002)ampamp
amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsamplikeampeducationampcanampbeampfrustratingampandampemotionalamp
becauseampeachamphighlight[s]amptheampfinitudeampofamptheampinterpreterampandamptheamplimitationsampofamphisamp
understandingamp(Bourgeoisamp2007amppamp79)ampampTheamptermampsharesampsimilaritiesampwithamptheamp
problematic-momentampaamppedagogicalamptermampreferringamptoampaampbreachampinampaampdominantampgroupsamp
discourseampduringampwhichampsomethingamprepressedamparisesamp(KentampampampCummingamp2008)ampampKentamp
andampCummingamp(2008)ampexploreamptheampproblematicampmomentampasampaampdiscursiveampsiteampforamp
examiningampprejudiceampwithinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampandampitsamp
moreamppoliticallyampchargedampcounterpartamptheampproblematicampmomentampbothampexploreamp
Gadamersamp(1996)ampampassertionampthatamptheampotherampmayampnotamponlyamphaveampaamprightampbutampmayamp
actuallyampbeamprightampmayampunderstandampsomethingampbetterampthanampweampdoamp(pamp82)ampampAampcreativelt
listeningampspaceamplivesampinampthisamppossibilityampampamp
amp Lastlyamprelayingampofampappropriateampexpectationsamptoampparticipantsampisampaampnecessaryamp
featureampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampdemandingampampItamp
requiresampparticipantsampwhoampareampawareampofamptheamprisksampandamphardshipsamptoampenterampintoampitampampItamp
isamptheampresponsibilityampofamptheampeducatoramporampgroupampleaderamptoampmakeamptheseampexpectationsamp
knownampasampwellampasamptoampmodelampthisampbehaviorampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionamphermeneuticallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Areampopenamptoamppossibilitiesampandamptoamptheampotherampbull Conceiveampofampthemselvesampasampengagingampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamptheamprisksampinvolvedampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamplimitationsampofamptheirampunderstandingamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 19amp
Dialogic(Practices(-
I-felt-that-everyone-was-open-and-interested-in-what-I-had-to-say---Perhaps-I-felt-this-sense-of-understanding-due-to-the-nature-of-the-discussion((-
it-felt-[like]-more-[of]-a-dialogue-as-opposed-to-a-standard-critique-(Survey-response-MW-age-22)-
(amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampartampeducationampreliesamponampanampopenampdialogueampduringamp
experiencesampwithampartampselfampandampothersampampWhatampIampfoundamplackingampinamphermeneuticsamp
howeverampwasampaampdiscussionampofamptheamphowltlthowampisamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampachievedampandamp
howampdoampindividualsampmeaningfullyampengageampwithampeachampotherampampInampanampeffortamptoampclarifyampthisamp
Iampwillampdiscussampdialogicamppracticesampasamptheyamprelateamptoampmeaningfulampverbalampexchangesampandamp
listeningampencountersampinamptheampclassroomampandampstudioampamongstampstudentsamptheiramppeersampandamp
educatorsamp
amp Communicatingampthroughamplanguageampandampdialogueampisamphowampweampcoltconstructamp
worldsampwithampourselvesampandampothersampnotampjustampthroughampanampactampofamptransmissionampbutamp
becauseampourampcommunicativeampactsampgiveampbirthamptoampworldsamp(Lipariamp2014amppamp507)ampampSableamp
(2014)ampdescribesampdialogueampasampaampgenerativeampinterchangeampbetweenampparticipantsampasamp
opposedamptoampanampexchangeampofampviewsampwhereampindividualsampsimplyampadvocateamptheiramppositionsamp
(pamp8)ampampForampBohmamp(1996)ampitampisampaampstreamampofampmeaningampflowingampamongampandampthroughampusamp
(pamp6)ampampTheampnatureampofampdialogueampandampconversationampisampinherentlyampunplannedampampThisamp
dimensionampofampconversationampisampimportantamptoampGadameramp(2004)ampwhoampfindsampthatamp
participantsampinvolvedampinampconversationampareamplessamptheampleadersampofampitampthanamptheampledamp(pamp
385)ampampSableamp(2014)ampechoesampthisampbyampwritingampthatamptheampmostampimportantamppartsampofampanyamp
conversationampareampthoseampthatampneitheramppartyampcouldamphaveampimaginedampbeforeampstartingamp(pamp
8)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 20amp
amp Theseampareampnotionsampofampdialogueampamongampothersampthatampfindampaampparallelampinamptheamp
creativeampprocessampampFairfieldamp(2011)ampwritesampthatampinampprincipleampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinamp
dialogueamp(pamp83)ampaampsentimentampthatampalignsampwithampaampcommonampissueampencounteredampduringamp
theampcreativeampprocessltltnotampknowingampwhenampaamppieceampisampdoneampampAampquoteampoftenampattributedamp
toampLeonardoampdaampVinciampspeaksamptoampthisampideaampArtampisampneverampfinishedamponlyampabandonedampamp
Snowberamp(2007)ampdrawsampparallelsampbetweenampmentorshipampdialogueampandamptheampcreativeamp
processampfindingampthatampdeepamplisteningamppracticesampconnectampallampthreeampampSheampfindsampthatamptheamp
taskampofamptheampmentorampisamptheampsameampasamptheamptaskampofamptheampartistampthatampisamptoampbringampoutamptheamp
naturalampqualitiesampofamptheampstudentamporamptheampmediumampampSnowberamp(2007)ampcommentsamponampanamp
ideaampwellltknownampamongampartistsampwhichampisampthatampaampworkampofampartamphasampaamplifeampofampitsampownampthisamp
notionampisampreminiscentampofampGadamersampstatementampaboutampbeingampledampbyampconversationamp
ampamp Dialogicamppracticesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampeducationampemphasizeampaamp
phenomenologicalampdimensionamprequiringamptwoampthingsampfromampparticipantsampampFirstlyamp
participantsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampmustampfindampvalueampinamplisteningamptoamptheamp
narrativesampofamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampampTheseampparticipantsampknowampthatampeducationamp
isampforemostampaboutamptestimonyampaboutampsharingamptheampexperienceampofampbeingamphumanampsharingamp
lifeampconvictionsampandampknowledge((Wiercinskiamp2011amppamp109)ampampNarrativesampareamp
conceivedampofampasampaampwayampofamphumanampknowingamp(Vitanovaamp2010amppamp29)ampthatampmakesamptheamp
selfampampSecondlyampwhenamplisteningamptoamptheampnarrativesampofampothersampparticipantsampareampexpectedamp
toampbracketamptheirampownampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsamp(LindsethampampampNorbergamp2004)ampampThisamp
encouragesamplistenersamptoampexperienceampandampfindampmeaningampinamptheampnarrativesampofampothersamp
whileampfreeingamptheampspeakerampfromamptheampfearampofampbeingampjudgedampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 21amp
amp Bracketingampjudgmentampandampconclusionampisampaamppotentialamptoolampwithinamptheampcommonamp
artampeducationamppracticeampofampgroupampcritiquesampampElkinsamp(2001)ampfindsampthatamppeopleampwhoamphaveamp
experienceampinampartampjudgeampveryampquicklyampandampmostampteachersampwillamphaveampaampprovisionalamp
opinionampaboutampaampworkampinamptheampfirstamptenampsecondsamp(pamp121)ampampBracketingampconclusionampandamp
judgmentampisampparticularlyampimportantampforampeducatorsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
whoseampvolumeampofampviewingampexperiencesampcouldampleadamptoampeasyampassumptionsampwhenamp
encounteringampaampnewampworkampampamp
amp Elkinsamp(2001)ampdiscussesampthatampcritiquesampcanampalsoampbeampseenampasampexchangesampofamp
storiesamporampcollaborativeampstorytellingamp(pamp145)ampwhichampisampyetampanotherampwayampofamptalkingamp
aboutamppossibilitiesampforampdialogueampandampnarrativeampwithinampartampeducationampampElkinsamphoweveramp
findsampstorytellingamplimitingamponceamptheampdeeperampnarrativesampareampdiscoveredamp(2001amppamp
145)ampampThisampimpliesampthatampheampfindsamponlyampaampsingularampmeaningampandamponeampthatampisampnotamp
necessarilyampusefulampforampcollaborativeampgroupampcritiquesamp
amp Insteadampparticipantsampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampbringampknowledgeampofamp
polysemyamptoampcollaborativeampcritiqueampexperiencesampasampwellampasamptoampexperiencesampofampmakingamp
artworkampampAccordingamptoampMuldoonamp(2002)amppolysemyampisamptheampqualityampofampaampwordamporampotheramp
languageampunitampthatampcanampbearampmultipleampmeaningsamp(asampcitedampinampWorsleyamp2012amppamp308)ampampamp
Aamptextualampexampleampofampthisampisamptheampmultipleampmeaningsampofamptheampwordampcan-Iampcanampdriveampaampcaramp
Idamplikeampaampcan-ofampsodaampheampwasntampworkingampveryamphardampsoampIamphadamptoampcan-himamp(Munozamp
2014)ampampampButampifampweampconsideramppolysemyampmetaphoricallyamporampvisuallyamptheampideaampthatampaamp
singleampunitampimageamporampintentionampcouldampbearampmultipleampmeaningsampcouldampbeampproductiveampinamp
creatingltlisteningampspacesampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 22amp
amp Thisampunfoldingampofampmeaningampworksampwellampinamptheampcontextampofampcollageampandampdialogueamp
asampwellampasamphermeneuticsampampInampfactamphermeneuticsampimpliesamppolysemyampbecauseampofampitsamp
notionampthatampitampisampalwaysampaamppossibilityampofampmyampunderstandingampthatampisampplayedampoutampwhenampIamp
understandampaamptextamp(Grondinamp2002amppamp38)ampampPolysemyampcouldampbeampconceptualizedampasampanamp
alternativeampexplorationampofampmeaningampthatampfunctionsampcollaborativelyampwithinampcritiquesampamp
Forampexampleampeducatorsampcanampaskampstudentsamptoamprespondamptoampaampworkampthroughampcollageamp
journalampentriesampmusicampfilmampasampindividualsamporampinampgroupsampampKnowledgeampofamppolysemyamp
couldampalsoampbeampusedampasampaamptoolampforampcreatingampimagesampthatamprecognizesampaamprelationshipamp
betweenamptheampvisualamptheamplinguisticampandamptheampmultipleamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionampdialogicallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Placeampvalueamponampexperientialampnarrativesampbull Practiceamplisteningampbyampbracketingampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampbull Embraceamppolysemicampexplorationsampofampmeaningampamp
Contemplative(Practices(
I-knew-I-was-being-heard-because-of-her-mannerisms-and-the-look-on-her-face--She-was-calm-attentive-and-not-trying-to-jump-in-and-offer-any-advice--She-asked-questions-that-pointed-to-things-I-had-not-openly-articulated-because-of-uncertainty--
This-was-one-of-the-ways-I-knew-I-was-being-heard-(Survey-response-LS-age-27)-
(amp Ifamphermeneuticsampandampdialogicamppracticesampgiveampusamptheampbroadampstrokesampofampactivityampinamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampcontemplativeamppracticesampseekamptoamptuneampstudentsampandamp
educatorsampintoampnuanceampdeliberationampandampdeepampexplorationampampThisampisampaampmostlyamp
individualampinternalamppursuitampthatampfocusesamponampformsampofampselfltlisteningampbutampcontemplativeamp
practicesampareampalsoampformedampbyampanampawarenessampofampinterconnectednessamp
amp InamppursuitampofampcriticalampthinkingampSableamp(2014)ampoutlinesampaampsetampofampcontemplativeamp
practicesampforampstudentsampthatampincludeampmindfulampmeditationampstructuredampcontemplationamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 23amp
journalampwritingampmindfulamplisteningampreflectiveampinquiryampandampdialogueamp(pamp4)ampampWhileamp
Sablesamp(2014)ampmethodampforampcontemplativeamppracticesampprovidesampaampconcreteampframeworkamp
withampspecificampstepsampmanyampofamptheseampconceptsampcouldampbeampappliedampwithoutampsuchampaamp
prescribedampstructureampampForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwillampbeamp
primarilyampdiscussingampSablesampconceptsampofampstructuredampcontemplationampreflectiveamp
inquiryampandampjournalampwritingamp
amp ForampSableamp(2014)ampstructuredampcontemplationampisampaampformampofampbeingamppresentampandamp
focusedamponampaampparticularampquestionampstatementamporampimageampampWithinampthisampmodeampofampinquiryamp
participantsampareampexpectedamptoampholdamptheampobjectampofampcontemplationampinamptheirampmindsamp
deepeningampunderstandingampasamptheyampfocusampwithoutampanalyzingampitamporampmanipulatingampitampinamp
anyampwayamp(pamp5)ampampThisamppracticeampdrawsampcomparisonsamptoamptheampbracketingampofampjudgmentsamp
andampconclusionsampsupportedampinamptheamppreviousampsectionampbutampstructuredampcontemplationamp
occursamponampanampindividualamplevelampratherampthanampdialogicallyamp
amp Reflectiveampinquiryampbearsampsomeampsimilaritiesamptoampstructuredampcontemplationampbutamp
Sableamp(2014)amppositionsampitampasampanampactivityampbetweenamptwoampindividualsampaamplistenerampandampaamp
speakerampampTheamplistenerampisampagainampaskedamptoampsuspendampjudgmentampbutampalsoamptoampengageampinampaamp
formampofampcuriosityampinampwhichampinnocentampquestionsampareampaskedampinamporderamptoampgainamp
understandingampampSableamp(2014)ampcontrastsampinnocentampquestionsampwithampleadingampquestionsampamp
ForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwouldampcharacterizeampthisampinnocentamp
questioningampasampaampformampofampopenltendedampquestioningampampSableamp(2014)ampidentifiesampanamp
exampleampofampanampinnocentamp(orampopenltended)ampquestionampWhatampdidampyouampmeanampwhenampyouamp
saidamp________ampConverselyampaampleadingampquestionampisampDidampyouampmeanamptoampsayamp________ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 24amp
amp Sableamp(2014)ampusesampjournalampwritingampasampaamppieceampofamphisamplargerampstructureampofamp
contemplativeamppracticesampbutampjournalampwritingampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampcouldamp
potentiallyampoccupyampaampsignificantamproleampampIampconceiveampofampjournalampwritingampinampmyampownamp
creativeamppracticeampasampaampformampofampdocumentationampthatampmakesampmeampmoreampawareampofampmyamp
creativeampprocessamptheampemotionalamphabitsampthatampsurroundampitampandamptheampthemesampthatamp
structureampmyampworkampampIampconceptualizeampthisampwayampofampwritingampasampaampformampofampselfltlisteningamp
relatedamptoampaampkeyampconceptampofamphermeneuticsampfoundampinampGadamersampassertionampthatampallamp
educationampisampaampformampofampselflteducationamp(Grondinamp2011)ampampamp
amp Germeraadamp(2013)ampusesampjournalampwritingamptoampexploreamptheampemotionalampandamprationalamp
relationshipsamptoamphisampcreativeampprocessampparallelamptoampexecutingampaampnewampbodyampofampworkampampHeamp
findsampthatampwritingampduringamphisampprocessampisampaamptoolamptoampunderstandamp[his]amppsycheamptoampeaseamp
theamppainampthatampanampartisticampprocessampcanampbringampandamptoamprelieveampartisticampblocksamp
(Germeraadamp2013amppamp21)ampultimatelyampdeclaringampthatampitamphelpsamphimamptoampbetterampunderstandamp
hisampworkampampInampaampstyleampofampwritingampthatamposcillatesamparoundampjournalingampdocumentationampandamp
poetryampdeampCossonamp(2002)ampexploresamphisampoverlappingamprolesampasampanampartistampresearcherampandamp
teacherampampOtherampartistsampbluramptheamplineampbetweenampartamppracticeampdocumentationampandamplifeamp
furtherampstillampbyampofferingampdocumentationampasampartamplikeampSophieampCalleamp(Calleamp2011amp2008amp
2005)ampandampMaryampKellyamp(1973lt1979)ampampamp
amp Karpiakamp(2003)ampestablishesampcontemplativeamppracticesampfromamptheampperspectiveampofamp
theampeducatorampaskingampthemamptoampmineamptheampsubtleamp(pamp71)ampusingampattentivenessamp
attunementampamplificationampandampassociationampampTheseampexercisesampinampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampsetamptheamptoneampasampwellampasampprovideampaampmodelampofampbehaviorampforampotherampparticipantsamp
withinamptheampspaceampampKarpiakamp(2003)ampoutlinesampactivitiesampthatampeducatorsampcanampuseamptoampdrawamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 25amp
outampandamputilizeamptheseampsubtleampsensationsampinamptheampserviceampofamptransformativeamplearningamp(pamp
68)ampampamp
amp ForampKarpiakamp(2003)ampattentivenessamprequiresampawarenessamptoampverbalampandamp
nonverbalampcuesampasampwellampasampanampawarenessampofampwhatampisamphappeningampamongampandampwithinamptheamp
studentsampandamptheampeducatorampampAttunementamprequiresampanampeducatoramptoamporientampherselfamptoamptheamp
otherampandamptoampadoptampanampattitudeampofampunhurriednessampofamppatienceampandampofamphumilityamp
concerningampbothamptheampprocessampandamptheampoutcomesampofamptheampteachingamp(Karpiakamp2003amppgamp
72)ampampAmplificationampisampaampprocessampofamphonoringampcommunicationampthatampcentersamponamptheampideaamp
ofamphearingamponeselfampintoampknowingampitampincludesampusingampparaphrasingampandampclarificationamp
activitiesamptoampgainampinsightampintoampmeaningampampLastlyampassociationampentailsampidentifyingamp
patternsampandampweavingampthemamptogetherampwithampstudentampexperienceampclassroomampdiscussionamp
andamptheampideasampofampothersamp
amp TuningampintoampsubtletyampimpliesampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceampampTheampmanifestationsamp
ofampsilenceampinamptheampclassroomampareampendlessampandampitsampvalueampisamptooampgreatamptoampbeampignoredampwhileamp
tooampvastamptoampbeampfullyampabsorbedampampLevinamp(1989)ampremarksampthatampsilenceampisampaampclearingampwhereamp
thereampisampnothingampforamphearingamptoampholdamponamptoampinampwhichampmanyampfindampunbearableampanxietyamp
(pamp79)ampampNearlyampallampofampusamphaveampexperiencedampthisampunbearableampanxietyampaampstrainampofamp
whichampcanampbeampfoundampinampeducationalampcontextsampdueamptoamptheampfactampthatampclassroomsampareamp
oftenampstructuredamparoundampimplicitampandampexplicitamprulesampaboutamptalkampandampsilenceamp(Schultzamp
2010amppamp2848)ampampForampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampanampawarenessampofampsilenceampimplicatesamp
whatampisampleftampunsaidampandampwhatampisampunsayableltltespeciallyampimportantampbecauseampofamptheamp
unsayableampqualityampofampartworksampampForampSchultzamp(2010)ampsilenceampimpliesamppossibilityamp
becauseampitampcanampholdampmultipleampmeaningsampforampindividualsampwithinampandampacrossampracialamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 26amp
ethnicampandampculturalampgroupsamp(pamp2833)ampampLevinamp(1989)ampfindsampthatamptoamplistenamptoamp
somethingampweampmustampfirstampgive-itampourampsilenceamp(pamp232)ampampThisamppracticeampofampgivingampsilenceamp
isampparticularlyamphelpfulampinamptermsampofampviewingamporamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartamp
amp Gradleamp(2011)ampoutlinesampaamppracticalampvisionampforampviewingampartampthatamprequiresamp
silenceampandampdeliberationampampForamptheamppurposesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampwouldamp
reconceptualizeampthisampasampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampampGradleamp(2011)ampinstructedamp
herampstudentsamptoampspendamptimeampwithampaampworkampofampartampoutsideampofamptheirampeverydayampworldviewamp
attentivelyampviewingampitampforampaboutamptenampminutesampeverydayampforampaampweekampampAfterampeachampviewingamp
experienceamptheampstudentsampwroteampinamptheirampjournalsampampTheampresultsampindicatedampthatampthisamp
processampofampsustainedampsilentampdeliberationampcoupledampwithampanampengagementampofamptheiramp
intuitiveampperceptionsampaboutampartworkampleftampstudentsampfeelingampempoweredamptoampengageampinamp
discussionampandampappreciateampunfamiliarampartampformsampampThisampactivityampisampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoamp
aampworkampofampartampthatampincorporatesampSablesamp(2014)ampconceptampofampstructuredampcontemplationampamp
Weavingampaamprelationshipampbetweenampsilenceampcontemplationampandampattentivenessampisampaamp
significantampendeavorampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
Contemplativeamppracticesampfunctionampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Engageampinampformsampofampviewingampwritingampandampexperiencingampthatamphonorampselfltlisteningamp
bull Attuneamptoampsubtletyampandampnuanceampbull Listenampandampviewampdeliberatelyampbull Cultivateampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceamp(
The(Felt(Sense(
When-someone-understands-what-I-am-talking-about-when-I-talk-about-art-I-am-delighted--Art-is-my-everything--Its-my-passion--When-someone-understands-that-I-
am-instantly-filled-with-joy--That-tells-me-someone-gets-it-(Survey-response-CTF-age-16)-
(
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 6amp
pieceampampTheseampareampwaysampweampexpressamptheampprelinguisticampfeltampdimensionsampofampbeingampwithampaamp
workampofampartampampTemporallyampthisamptakesampplaceampwithinampaampsingleampmomentampinamptimeampampButamp
meaningfulampencountersampwithampartampareamponlyampmeaningfulampbecauseamptheyampareampcomposedampofamp
countlessamppreviousampmomentsampwordsampexperiencesampknowledgeampconversationsamp
relationshipsampandampallamptheampminutiaampthatampconstituteampanampindividualsampidentityampampInampthisamp
conceptionampofampmeaningltmakingamptheamplayersampofampexperiencesampwithinamptheampindividualamptheamp
groupampandamptheampspacesampbetweenampareamprespectedampforamptheirampvalueampinamptheampformationampofamp
singularampandampcollectiveampidentitiesamp
amp Oftenampviewersampandampeducatorsampdiscussampinterpretativeampprocessesampfromamp
frameworksampsuchampasampaampworksamppositionampinampartamphistoryamptheampbiographyampofamptheampartistamp
socialampimplicationsampandampsoamponampampThereampisampaampparallelamptoampbeampfoundamphereampinamptheampdrawingamp
processampampIfampweamppresupposeampthatampthereampisampaampcorrectampwayamptoampinterpretampandampaampperfectamp
drawingamptoampbeamphadampweamprunamptheampriskampofampnotamptryingampforampfearampofampfailureampampItsampnoampstretchamptoamp
sayampthatampindividualsampwhoamplackampartsampexperienceampareamphesitantamptoampengageampwithampaampworkampofamp
artampforampfearampofampexposingamptheirampsupposedampignoranceampampOnamptheampotheramphandampifampweampengageampinamp
aampwayampofampviewingampthatampidentifiesampwithamptheampfluidityampofampcollageampweampcanampacknowledgeamp
possibilityampasampaampfeatureampofampinterpretationampampByampconceivingampofampinterpretationampasampaampformamp
ofampcollagingamptogetherampmeaningfulampexperiencesampviewersampcouldampgainampaccessamptoamptheamp
complexamplayeredampandampmessyampdimensionsampofampmeaningampwhenamptheyamplistenamptoampaampworkampofamp
artamp
Creative=Listening(Space(
amp Iampofferamptheamptermampcreative(listening-spaceampasampanampalternativeampmodeampofamp
experiencingampviewingampandampproducingampcreativeampworksampampInsteadampofampplacingampsubjectamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 7amp
matterampinformationamporamptheamproleampofamptheampeducatorampatamptheampcenterampofamptheseampexperiencesampIamp
proposeampthatampactsampofamplisteningampbeampembeddedampinampmakingampandampviewingampartampampTheamptermamp
creativeltlisteningampspaceamprefersamptoamptheampfluidampandampflexibleampspaceampinampwhichamplisteningamp
practicesampareampanampintegratedampessentialamppartampofampviewingampdiscussingampandampproducingamp
creativeampworksampampArtistsampviewersampstudentsampandampeducatorsampcanamptransformampartamp
classroomsampstudiosampandampsitesampofampviewingampartampintoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhichampareamp
notampdefinedampbyampphysicalampformamporampstructuralampboundariesampampRatheramptheyampareampdefinedampbyamp
specificamppracticesampthatampoccurampamongstampindividualsampandampgroupsampinamptheampcontextampofampartamp
educationampamp
Research(Issue(
amp Theampoverarchingampconcernampinampthisampresearchampisamptheamppotentialampoutcomeampforampusingamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampwithinampartampeducationampampTheamppracticesampIampdiscussamphereamphaveampinamp
commonampaampdistinctiveampflexibilityampandampmalleabilityampampTheyampmayampbeampadaptedamptoampvariousamp
ageampgroupsampeducationalampsitesampandampcontextsampampWhileampIampofferampsuggestionsampIampexpectampthatamp
theamppractitionersampwhoampwishamptoampuseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwillampdeviseamptheirampownamp
methodsampofampimplementationampbasedamponamptheirampspecificampneedsampandampcontextsampampThoughamptheamp
ideaampofampcreativeamplisteningampspacesampemergedampwithinampanampartsampeducationampcontextampampthisamp
conceptampmayampholdampvalueampforampotherampdisciplinesamp
Boundaries(and(Limitations(of(the(Research(
( Iampundertookampthisampresearchampinampfulfillmentampofampaampmastersampdegreeampinampartampeducationamp
atamptheampUniversityampofampCincinnatisampCollegeampofampDesignampArtampArchitectureampandampPlanningamp
(DAAP)ampampTheampresponsesampexperiencesampandampartworkampgeneratedampduringamptheampcourseampofamp
thisampprojectamphaveampoftenampcenteredamparoundampthatampinstitutionampwhichamphousesampaampprimarilyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 8amp
whiteampmiddleltamptoampupperltclassampstudentamppopulationamponampanampurbanampcampusampampIampamampaampwhiteamp
femaleamppursuingamphigherampeducationampampIampwantamptoampacknowledgeampthisamppositionalityampalongamp
withamptheamppersonalampbiasesampaamplifetimeampofampexperiencesamphasampaffordedamptoampmeampampOneampinternalamp
goalampthatampdevelopedampoveramptheampcourseampofampthisampworkampwasampaampcontinuedampconsistentampeffortamp
toampuncoverampandampinterrogateampmyampownampbiasesampasamptheyampmanifestedampampThoughampweampcanampneveramp
beampfreeamporamppureampofamptheseampbiasesampconstantampexaminationampofampthemamphasampbeenampmyampchosenamp
routeamptoampcounteringamptheiramppowerampandampinfluenceampamp
Iampamamppassionateampaboutamptheampmeaningfulamppossibilitiesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampInamprespectampofampmyampownamplimitationsampandampthoseampofampthisampworkamphoweverampIampwillampnotamp
claimampthatampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampareampfeasibleampwithinamptheampcontextampofampeveryamp
educationalampsettingampnorampthatampthisampwayampofampviewingampmakingampandampexperiencingampworksampofamp
artampisampmoreamporamplessampvalidampthanampothersampampRatherampIampsuggestamptheamppossibilityampofamplivingampinamp
possibilitiesampasampaampwayamptoampcultivateampmeaningfulampencountersampwithinampartampandampartamp
educationamp
Data(
amp ForampthisampresearchampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponampthreeampformsampofampdataamp
participantampsurveysampcaseampstudiesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampandampreflectiveamppracticeamp
formsampofampartmakingampallampcollectedampduringampaampfourltmonthampperiodampampToampgatherampparticipantamp
responsesampfromamptheampsurveysampandampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampreliedamponampaampmultitudeampofamp
friendsamppeersampandampcolleaguesampampIampconnectedampwithamptheampmajorityampofamptheseampindividualsamp
duringamporampasampaampresultampofampmyampexperiencesampatampDAAPampampampIampusedamp37ampsurveyampresponsesampaboutamp
listeningampexperiencesampwithampaampparticipantampageamprangeampofamp14amptoamp47ampampParticipantsamp
educationalamplevelsampspannedamphighampschoolamptoampgraduateampschoolampampIamppersonallyampsolicitedamptheamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 9amp
majorityampofamptheamplisteningampsurveysampatamptheampcollegeamplevelampandampaboveampampTheampbulkampofamptheamphighamp
schoolltagedampresponsesampwereampsolicitedampbyampmyampcolleagueampaampphotographyampteacherampatampaamp
Cincinnatiltareaamphighampschoolamp
amp Iampconductedampfiveampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampexperiencesampwithampsixampindividualsampasamp
partampofampthisampresearchampagainampusingampmanyampofamptheamppersonalampandampprofessionalampconnectionsamp
cultivatedampthroughamptheampDAAPampprogramampampIampdeliberatelyampchoseamppeopleampwithampwhomampIamphadamp
variousamplevelsampandamptypesampofamprelationshipsampampIampwillampspeakampmoreampinltdepthampaboutamptheseamp
experiencesampasampwellampasampexploreamptheampsurveyampresponsesampinamptheampResearchampMethodologyamp
andampMethodsampsectionamp
amp Lastlyamptheampdevelopmentampofampanampartmakingamppracticeampwasampessentialamptoampmyampownamp
personalampunderstandingampofamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatampcomposedampmyampresearchamp
ReadersampwillampnoticeampthatampimagesampareampembeddedampinampthisamptextampampTheseampareampimagesampofamptheamp
resultingampproductsampofampaamppracticeampofampunderstandingampthroughampmakingampampIampwillampdiscussamp
themampthroughoutampvariousampsectionsampofampthisamppaperampampamp
Dear(Reader(The(Structure(of(this(Research(Paper(
DearampReader(s)amp
amp Letampmeampbreakampforampaampmomentampfromampstandardampacademicamprhetoricampbeforeampthisamp
paperampreallyampgetsampstartedampampIampknowampwhatampyoureampthinkingltltnineamppagesampinampandampthisamppaperamp
hasntampevenampstartedampyetampampAlasampthisampsectionampisampmyamponeampofampmyampfavoriteampandampmostampoftlt
skimmedamppassagesampofampanampacademicamppaperamptheampstructureampofamptheamppaperampampThisampisamptheamppartamp
whereamptheampwriterampsaysampwhatampshesampaboutamptoampsayampbeforeampsheampsaysampitampampampItsampanamp
organizationalampstrategyampandampitsampthrillingampampLuckilyampforampyouampniceamppersonampwhoampisamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 10amp
readingampthisamppaperampIamphaveampprovidedampaamptranslationampfromampthisamptextsamporiginalampAcademiaamp
intoampnormalltpeopleltlanguageamp
amp Theampstructureampofampthisamppaperampisampasampfollowsampamp(Im-about-to-tell-you-whats-in-this-
long-ass-paper)ampampFirstlyamppleaseampnoteampthatampIampuseamptheamptermampthreadampinamplieuampofampchapteramp
asampanamporganizationalampstructureampIamppreferamptheampformerampbecauseampofamphowampitsampconceptualamp
qualitiesamprelateamptoampmyampworkampamp(Thread-is-awesome-and-you-can-do-tons-of-stuff-with-it-
like-sew-knot-tie-weave-etc--Chapters-are-not-nearly-as-exciting)--Iampwillampfirstampshareamp
myampresearchersampreflexiveampnarrativeampamp(I-made-up-a-cool-story-about-this-project-to-
describe-where-it-all-came-from)ampampThenampIampshallampofferampaampdescriptionampofamptheampqualitiesampofampaamp
creativeltlisteningampspaceampamp(Yes-I-shall)ampampIampwillampdiscussamptheampliteratureampthatampinformsamptheamp
backboneampofampmyampresearchampGadamersamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamp
practicesampandampGendlinsamptheampfeltampsenseampamp(Like-a-typical-graduate-student-I-have-done-
an-insane-amount-of-reading-during-the-past-two-academic-years--A-significant-
portion-of-this-reading-has-been-dedicated-to-those-topics--Dont-ask-me-to-type-them-
out-again-because-Im-seriously-done)ampampTheseampsectionsampbeginampwithampaamppassageampderivedamp
fromampsurveyampresponsesampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampamp(I-got-a-bunch-of-people-to-fill-
out-surveys-for-this-research-and-then-I-put-those-responses-in-my-paper)ampampTheseamp
experiencesampwithamplisteningampwereampprovidedampbyampresearchampparticipantsampamp(Super-nice-
people-I-know-and-some-I-dont-helped-me-out)ampampTheyampareampthereamptoampgroundamptheamp
conceptualampframeworksampinamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampamp(This-basically-means-
none-of-this-research-is-worth-shit-unless-it-can-be-used-in-the-real-world((I-hope-youll-
agree)ampampIampwillampthenampshareampmyampresearchampmethodologyampandampmethodsampamp(Im-going-to-tell-
you-about-how-and-why-I-did-this-project-in-using-big-smart(sounding-words)ampampLastlyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 11amp
Iampwillampconcludeampwithamppossibilitiesampforampthisampresearchampamp(Ill-figure-out-what-I-learned-and-
share-it-with-you-my-new-best-friend-who-made-it-all-the-way-to-the-conclusions-
section)ampampInampthisamppaperampreadersampwillampnoticeamptransparentampimagesampinteractingampwithamptheamp
textampamp(Its-my-art-on-transparent-sheets-in-this-very-paper)ampampTheseampareampworksampofampartamp
thatampIampcreatedamptoampgroundamptheampresearchampinampaamppracticeampofampmakingamptheyampareamptheampphysicalamp
embodimentampofampconceptualampideasampandamptheyampareampalwaysamppresentamptoamptheampresearchampamp
(Research-papers-with-pictures-are-much-more-tolerable-am-I-right)amp
amp Hereampweampgoamp
amp
thread2(
Collaging(Experience1(
amp ImagineampthatampyouampareampanampartistampseatedampatampyourampstudioamptableampampYouamphaveamp
everythingampyouampneedampampTheamproomampisampquietampsaveampforamptheampmuffledampsoundsampofampaampdistantamp
outsideampworldampampYouampsurveyamptheampcollectionampofampimagesampyouamphaveampgatheredamparoundampyouampamp
OnampyouramprightampisampaampraggedamppageampfromampanampoldampsketchbookampampGlossyampjewellttonedampswatchesamp
fromampaampdiscardedampfashionampmagazineampareampstackedampupampglisteningampinamptheamplightampampMonthsamp
agoampyouamppickedampupampaamphandfulampofampblackampandampwhiteampphotosampfromampaampsecondhandampstoreamp
todayamppastyampfacesampofamptheampunknownampsubjectsampstareampthroughampyouampblanklyampampAamppaleampyellowamp
scrapampofampleftoverampfabricampisampdrapedampoveramplastampweeksamppleatedamptoltdoamplistampampTheseampandamptwoamp
dozenampotherampscrapsamppiecesamppilesampandampcrumbsampareampyouramptoolsamptodayampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampamp1ampThisampsectionampisampsupposedamptoampbeampmyampresearchersampreflexiveampnarrativeampaamppassageampaboutampwhereampmyampresearchampideasampcameampfromltltandampinampfactampcollageampisampactuallyampwhereampthisampideaampcomesampfromampampOneampofamptheampfirstampresearchampinterestsampIampdiscussedampwithampmyampprofessorampDrampKristopherampHollandampwasamplayersampbothampphysicalampandampconceptualampampHeampwasamplikeampOhampampYoureamptalkingampaboutamphermeneuticsampSoampinampaampwayampthisampresearchampprojectampbothampbeganampandampconcludedamp(moreamponampthatamplater)ampwithampideasampofamplayeringampandampcollageampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 12amp
amp TheampresidueampthatampclingsamptoamptheseampscrapsampisampexperienceampampTheampoldampsketchbookamp
pageampisampanampimageampofampaampwomansamplegamprenderedampwithampchunkyamppencilampstrokesampampYouampmadeampitamp
whenampyouampwereamplivingampinampyourampoldampapartmentampoverlookingamptheampsquareampampItsampaampwomansamp
footampbutampitampremindsampyouampofamphavingampaamproommateampandampaampgrayampfutonampandampaampsummerampthatamp
wasampdesperatelyamphotampampItampisamponlyamppencilamponamppaperampbutampitampremindsampyouampofamptheampgreenamp
grassyampcenterampinamptheampmedianampofamptheampstreetampampOneamppencilampdrawingampofampaampwomansamplegamp
remindsampyouampofampthatampoldamplifeampandamptheampversionampofampyourselfampyouampwereampthenampitampisamptheampfirstamp
dominoampinampaampseriesampofampcascadingampdetailsampandampmemoriesampamp
amp EachampfragmentampsittingamponampyourampstudioamptableamphasampaampstoryampampEachampcameampfromampaamp
placeampandampwasamptouchedampbyampanotheramphumanampampEachampisampembeddedampwithampexperienceampcoloramp
memoryamptextureampandampinfiniteampdetailampbyamptheampmereampfactampofampitsampownampexistenceampamp
amp YouampbeginamptoamppickampapartamptheampephemeraampampYouampalternateampbeingampcarefulampandamp
carelessamp
amp Cuttingamptearingampburningampstretchingampfoldingampwhitewashingamprippingampcreasingamp
sewingampwritingamppaintingampencasingampfasteningampfillingampsoakingampdyeingampwashingamp
dryingampbitingampscratchingamppryingampyankingampsmoothingampsandingamppokingampstabbingamp
stretchingampfryingampheatingampdustingampcleaningampsculptingampslicingampdicingamppunchingamp
floatingamptwistingampflippingampdrippingampstaplingampstrippingampstripingamppatterningamp
designingampdrawingampsketchingampliftingampcollectingamptapingampgluingampbuttoningampknottingamp
weavingampknittingamp
amp YouampdoampallampofamptheseampthingsampandampprobablyampmanyampotherampthingsampampTheampfragmentsamponamp
youramptableampchangeampshapeampandampgetampsmallerampampFromamptheseamppiecesampyouampbeginamptoampbuildamp
somethingampampThisampsomethingampisampbothampnewampandampoldampampJuxtapositionsampbloomampnewamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 13amp
connectionsampareampfusedampbyamptheampweightampofamppreviousampexperienceampampPastampandamppresentamp
liquefyampintoampendlesslyampcirculatingamppossibilitiesampampYouampcouldamptheoreticallyampcontinueampthisamp
processampofamplayeringampandampreconstructionampforeverampamptheamponlyamplimitsampareampyourampownamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 14amp
thread3(
what(is(a(creative=listening(space(
ampampampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeamplisteningampspaceampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampwhatampdoesampitampsoundampsmellamptasteampfeelamplikeampampampampampampampwhatampampisampamptheampamptextureampampofampampthisampampamp
spaceampampampanswerampmoreampquestionsampampamp specificsampandampgeneralizationsampareampbothampimpossibleampampmaybeampaampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampgoodampstartampwouldampbeampthisampampamp amp amp amp amp safeampampampamp amp amp amp amp foldedampampamp amp amp amp amp amp embodiedampamp layeredampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampconnectedampampampamp amp ampamp
(it-might--be-like-gently-holding-on-to--
a-knot-of-questions)-amp
ampampampampampampampampampamp
(possible)ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 15amp
thread4amp(
Review(of(Literature((
( AnampexplorationampofampGadamerrsquosamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampeducationalampcontextsampandampGendlinrsquosamptheoryampofampfeltampsenseampwereampintegralamptoamp
theampcreationampofamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampWhileampcompellingampconstructsamponamp
theirampownampwhenampdrawnamptogetheramptheseampphilosophicalampperspectivesampvibrateamp
holisticallyamptoampsuggestampintriguingamppossibilitiesampforamptheampuseampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
inampartsampeducationampampInampthisampsectionampIampreviewamptheampliteratureampandampconnectamptheampvariousamp
pointsampofampstudyampampamp
Hermeneutics(amp(the(Fusion(of(Horizons((
It-actually-feels-really-great-knowing-that-other-people-will-enjoy-the-art-you-created-and-knowing-they-know-your-reasoning-and-story-behind-it--Honestly-you-cant-know-if-your-words-are-getting-through-to-them-but-the-cool-thing-about-art-is-that-it-can-be-
interpreted-in-so-many-different-ways---(Survey-response-EK-age-15)-
ampamp Hermeneuticsampwhichamphasampitsamprootsampinamptextualampinterpretationampcanampbeampdefinedampasamp
aamptraditionampofampthinkingamporampofampphilosophicalampreflectionampthatamptriesamptoampclarifyamptheampconceptamp
ofampverstehenampthatampisampunderstandingamp(Brunsamp1992)ampampRicoeuramp(19691974)ampexplainsamp
thatamptheampkeyamphypothesisampofamphermeneuticampphilosophyampisampthatampinterpretationampisampanampopenamp
processampwhichampnoampsingleampvisionampcanampconcludeamp(pamp109)ampampWithampthisampinampmindampIampwillamp
exploreamphermeneuticsampasampitampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp HansltGeorgampGadameramp(1900lt2002)ampinvestigatesampaampmoderateampformampofamp
hermeneuticsampthatampisampparticularlyamprelevantampinampserviceamptoampartampeducationampampGadameramp
breaksampwithamphermeneuticamptraditionampbyampproposingampthatampthereampisampnoampabsolutelyampobjectiveamp
interpretationampreadersampareampnotampableamptoampescapeamptheampprejudicesampofamptheiramptimeamp(Gallagheramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 16amp
1992)ampampThisamphoweverampbecomesampanampopportunityampforamptheampcreationampofampmeaningampInampaamp
passageampthatampechoesamptheampendlesslyampunfoldingampnatureampofampcollageampCaputoamp(2000)amprefersamp
toampanampexchangeampbetweenamppastampandamppresentampinamptheampcreativeamppossibilitiesampofamphermeneuticamp
interpretationamp
amp Thereampisampaamprichnessampinamphistoricalampeventsampthatampjustampkeepsampunfoldingampwhichampisamp
amp certainlyampnotampgraspedampbyamptheamporiginalampprotagonistsampwhichampgraduallyampunfoldsamp
amp overamptheampcourseampofamptimeampandampwhichampisampinampprincipleampneverampfullyampunfoldedampItampisamp
amp anampexcessampwhichampkeepsampspillingampoveramp(pamp47)amp
amp Gadamersampphilosophyampofamphermeneuticampunderstandingampisampformedampthroughamphisamp
notionsampaboutamplanguageampdialogueampandampconversationamp(Caputoamp2000ampSeebohmamp2004)ampamp
InampadditionamptoampGadamersampimplicitamprelianceamponamplisteningampasampheampdiscussesampdialogueamphisamp
workampcapitalizesamponamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampinamplanguageamp(Heelanamp1985)ampmakingamphisamp
formampofamphermeneuticsampparticularlyampapplicableamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp Gadamersamptermampfusion-of-horizonsamprefersamptoamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampwithinampaamp
varietyampofampencountersampampAampfusionampofamphorizonsampcanampbeampdescribedampasampaampdialogicamp
conversationampbetweenampreaderampandamptextamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampWithinamptheamptextualamp
paradigmampGadamerampbelievesampthatampaampwrittenamptextampisampopenamptoampanampinvisibleampandampindefiniteamp
readerampwhoampentersampintoampanampunknownampadventureampofamptheamptextamp(Ricoeuramp2013amppamp13)ampamp
Theamphorizonampitselfampisamptheamprangeampofampvisionampthatampincludesampeverythingampthatampcanampbeampseenamp
fromampaampparticularampvantageamppointamp(Gadameramp2004amppamp301)ampampLikeampcollageamptheampfusionampofamp
horizonsampisampaampprocessampcomposedampofamppastampandamppresentampwhichampareampopenamptoampandampinfinitelyamp
effectedampbyampeachampotheramp(Bourgeoisamp2007)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 17amp
amp Similarampconnectionsampcanampbeampdrawnampwhenampviewerampandampartworkampareampsubstitutedamp
forampreaderampandamptextampampInterpretationampandampunderstandingampbecomeampanampentwinedamp
creativeampendeavorampinampwhichamptheampviewerampparticipatesampasampmuchampasamptheampcreatorampbyamp
constructingampmeaningamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampPalmeramp(1969)ampalludesamptoamptheamppluralityampofamp
meaningampinampstatingampthatamptoampfocusamppurelyamponamptheamppositivityampofampwhatampaamptextampexplicitlyamp
saysampisamptoampdoampanampinjusticeamptoamptheamphermeneuticalamptaskamp(pamp234)ampampToampfocusamponampwhatampisamp
explicitampinampaampcollageampworkampwouldampbeamptoampdisregardamptheampconnectionsampandampcontradictionsamp
ofamptheampwholeampinampfavorampofampaampdirectampreadingampofamptheampindividualamppartsampthusampmissingampoutamponamp
otheramppossibleampdimensionsampofampmeaningamp
amp Theampkeyamptoamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampeducationampinamptextampandampbetweenamp
individualsampisamptheampabilityamptoamplistenampwithampopennessampampDefensiveamplisteningampisampaampwayampofamp
listeningampwithoutampopennessampitampisampaampwayampofampprotectingampourampsmallampversionampofamptheampworldamp
andampavoidingampmoralampclaimsamponampourselvesamp(Levinamp1989amppamp79)ampampLevinamp(1989)amp
discussesampplayfulamplisteningamp(pamp233)ampasampaampwayampofampcounteractingampdefensiveamplisteningampampamp
Bohmamp(1996)ampdiscussesampsuspendingampassumptionsampaampprocessampofampattendingamptoamp
assumptionsampratherampthanamprepressingampthemamporampcarryingampthemampoutampampNicholamp(1996)amp
explainsampaampcircumstanceampinampwhichampyouampencounterampaamppersonampyouampfeelampisampanampidiotampampampYouamp
wouldamprefrainampfromampsayingampsoampoutamploudampbutampyouampwouldampalsoamprefrainampfromampscoldingamp
yourselfampforampthisampthoughtampratherampyouampwouldampseeampthisampreactionampwithoutampfullyampengagingamp
withampitampampSimilarampsuggestionsamplikeampbracketingampofampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampareamp
discussedampinamptheampfollowingampsectionampamp
amp Gadamerampbelievesamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampwhatampallowsamptheampselfamptoampapproachamp
theampotherampitampisampaampprocessampinampwhichamptheampideasampofamptheampotherampbecomeamponesampownamp(Caputoamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 18amp
2000)ampampThisampisamphardlyampanampuncommonampexperienceampampInampfactampweampregularlyampencounteramptheamp
fusionampofamphorizonsampbyampintegratingamppastampunderstandingsampwithampcurrentampexperiencesampaamp
processampundoubtedlyampcomparableamptoampeducationamp(Zuckertamp2002)ampamp
amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsamplikeampeducationampcanampbeampfrustratingampandampemotionalamp
becauseampeachamphighlight[s]amptheampfinitudeampofamptheampinterpreterampandamptheamplimitationsampofamphisamp
understandingamp(Bourgeoisamp2007amppamp79)ampampTheamptermampsharesampsimilaritiesampwithamptheamp
problematic-momentampaamppedagogicalamptermampreferringamptoampaampbreachampinampaampdominantampgroupsamp
discourseampduringampwhichampsomethingamprepressedamparisesamp(KentampampampCummingamp2008)ampampKentamp
andampCummingamp(2008)ampexploreamptheampproblematicampmomentampasampaampdiscursiveampsiteampforamp
examiningampprejudiceampwithinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampandampitsamp
moreamppoliticallyampchargedampcounterpartamptheampproblematicampmomentampbothampexploreamp
Gadamersamp(1996)ampampassertionampthatamptheampotherampmayampnotamponlyamphaveampaamprightampbutampmayamp
actuallyampbeamprightampmayampunderstandampsomethingampbetterampthanampweampdoamp(pamp82)ampampAampcreativelt
listeningampspaceamplivesampinampthisamppossibilityampampamp
amp Lastlyamprelayingampofampappropriateampexpectationsamptoampparticipantsampisampaampnecessaryamp
featureampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampdemandingampampItamp
requiresampparticipantsampwhoampareampawareampofamptheamprisksampandamphardshipsamptoampenterampintoampitampampItamp
isamptheampresponsibilityampofamptheampeducatoramporampgroupampleaderamptoampmakeamptheseampexpectationsamp
knownampasampwellampasamptoampmodelampthisampbehaviorampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionamphermeneuticallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Areampopenamptoamppossibilitiesampandamptoamptheampotherampbull Conceiveampofampthemselvesampasampengagingampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamptheamprisksampinvolvedampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamplimitationsampofamptheirampunderstandingamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 19amp
Dialogic(Practices(-
I-felt-that-everyone-was-open-and-interested-in-what-I-had-to-say---Perhaps-I-felt-this-sense-of-understanding-due-to-the-nature-of-the-discussion((-
it-felt-[like]-more-[of]-a-dialogue-as-opposed-to-a-standard-critique-(Survey-response-MW-age-22)-
(amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampartampeducationampreliesamponampanampopenampdialogueampduringamp
experiencesampwithampartampselfampandampothersampampWhatampIampfoundamplackingampinamphermeneuticsamp
howeverampwasampaampdiscussionampofamptheamphowltlthowampisamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampachievedampandamp
howampdoampindividualsampmeaningfullyampengageampwithampeachampotherampampInampanampeffortamptoampclarifyampthisamp
Iampwillampdiscussampdialogicamppracticesampasamptheyamprelateamptoampmeaningfulampverbalampexchangesampandamp
listeningampencountersampinamptheampclassroomampandampstudioampamongstampstudentsamptheiramppeersampandamp
educatorsamp
amp Communicatingampthroughamplanguageampandampdialogueampisamphowampweampcoltconstructamp
worldsampwithampourselvesampandampothersampnotampjustampthroughampanampactampofamptransmissionampbutamp
becauseampourampcommunicativeampactsampgiveampbirthamptoampworldsamp(Lipariamp2014amppamp507)ampampSableamp
(2014)ampdescribesampdialogueampasampaampgenerativeampinterchangeampbetweenampparticipantsampasamp
opposedamptoampanampexchangeampofampviewsampwhereampindividualsampsimplyampadvocateamptheiramppositionsamp
(pamp8)ampampForampBohmamp(1996)ampitampisampaampstreamampofampmeaningampflowingampamongampandampthroughampusamp
(pamp6)ampampTheampnatureampofampdialogueampandampconversationampisampinherentlyampunplannedampampThisamp
dimensionampofampconversationampisampimportantamptoampGadameramp(2004)ampwhoampfindsampthatamp
participantsampinvolvedampinampconversationampareamplessamptheampleadersampofampitampthanamptheampledamp(pamp
385)ampampSableamp(2014)ampechoesampthisampbyampwritingampthatamptheampmostampimportantamppartsampofampanyamp
conversationampareampthoseampthatampneitheramppartyampcouldamphaveampimaginedampbeforeampstartingamp(pamp
8)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 20amp
amp Theseampareampnotionsampofampdialogueampamongampothersampthatampfindampaampparallelampinamptheamp
creativeampprocessampampFairfieldamp(2011)ampwritesampthatampinampprincipleampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinamp
dialogueamp(pamp83)ampaampsentimentampthatampalignsampwithampaampcommonampissueampencounteredampduringamp
theampcreativeampprocessltltnotampknowingampwhenampaamppieceampisampdoneampampAampquoteampoftenampattributedamp
toampLeonardoampdaampVinciampspeaksamptoampthisampideaampArtampisampneverampfinishedamponlyampabandonedampamp
Snowberamp(2007)ampdrawsampparallelsampbetweenampmentorshipampdialogueampandamptheampcreativeamp
processampfindingampthatampdeepamplisteningamppracticesampconnectampallampthreeampampSheampfindsampthatamptheamp
taskampofamptheampmentorampisamptheampsameampasamptheamptaskampofamptheampartistampthatampisamptoampbringampoutamptheamp
naturalampqualitiesampofamptheampstudentamporamptheampmediumampampSnowberamp(2007)ampcommentsamponampanamp
ideaampwellltknownampamongampartistsampwhichampisampthatampaampworkampofampartamphasampaamplifeampofampitsampownampthisamp
notionampisampreminiscentampofampGadamersampstatementampaboutampbeingampledampbyampconversationamp
ampamp Dialogicamppracticesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampeducationampemphasizeampaamp
phenomenologicalampdimensionamprequiringamptwoampthingsampfromampparticipantsampampFirstlyamp
participantsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampmustampfindampvalueampinamplisteningamptoamptheamp
narrativesampofamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampampTheseampparticipantsampknowampthatampeducationamp
isampforemostampaboutamptestimonyampaboutampsharingamptheampexperienceampofampbeingamphumanampsharingamp
lifeampconvictionsampandampknowledge((Wiercinskiamp2011amppamp109)ampampNarrativesampareamp
conceivedampofampasampaampwayampofamphumanampknowingamp(Vitanovaamp2010amppamp29)ampthatampmakesamptheamp
selfampampSecondlyampwhenamplisteningamptoamptheampnarrativesampofampothersampparticipantsampareampexpectedamp
toampbracketamptheirampownampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsamp(LindsethampampampNorbergamp2004)ampampThisamp
encouragesamplistenersamptoampexperienceampandampfindampmeaningampinamptheampnarrativesampofampothersamp
whileampfreeingamptheampspeakerampfromamptheampfearampofampbeingampjudgedampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 21amp
amp Bracketingampjudgmentampandampconclusionampisampaamppotentialamptoolampwithinamptheampcommonamp
artampeducationamppracticeampofampgroupampcritiquesampampElkinsamp(2001)ampfindsampthatamppeopleampwhoamphaveamp
experienceampinampartampjudgeampveryampquicklyampandampmostampteachersampwillamphaveampaampprovisionalamp
opinionampaboutampaampworkampinamptheampfirstamptenampsecondsamp(pamp121)ampampBracketingampconclusionampandamp
judgmentampisampparticularlyampimportantampforampeducatorsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
whoseampvolumeampofampviewingampexperiencesampcouldampleadamptoampeasyampassumptionsampwhenamp
encounteringampaampnewampworkampampamp
amp Elkinsamp(2001)ampdiscussesampthatampcritiquesampcanampalsoampbeampseenampasampexchangesampofamp
storiesamporampcollaborativeampstorytellingamp(pamp145)ampwhichampisampyetampanotherampwayampofamptalkingamp
aboutamppossibilitiesampforampdialogueampandampnarrativeampwithinampartampeducationampampElkinsamphoweveramp
findsampstorytellingamplimitingamponceamptheampdeeperampnarrativesampareampdiscoveredamp(2001amppamp
145)ampampThisampimpliesampthatampheampfindsamponlyampaampsingularampmeaningampandamponeampthatampisampnotamp
necessarilyampusefulampforampcollaborativeampgroupampcritiquesamp
amp Insteadampparticipantsampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampbringampknowledgeampofamp
polysemyamptoampcollaborativeampcritiqueampexperiencesampasampwellampasamptoampexperiencesampofampmakingamp
artworkampampAccordingamptoampMuldoonamp(2002)amppolysemyampisamptheampqualityampofampaampwordamporampotheramp
languageampunitampthatampcanampbearampmultipleampmeaningsamp(asampcitedampinampWorsleyamp2012amppamp308)ampampamp
Aamptextualampexampleampofampthisampisamptheampmultipleampmeaningsampofamptheampwordampcan-Iampcanampdriveampaampcaramp
Idamplikeampaampcan-ofampsodaampheampwasntampworkingampveryamphardampsoampIamphadamptoampcan-himamp(Munozamp
2014)ampampampButampifampweampconsideramppolysemyampmetaphoricallyamporampvisuallyamptheampideaampthatampaamp
singleampunitampimageamporampintentionampcouldampbearampmultipleampmeaningsampcouldampbeampproductiveampinamp
creatingltlisteningampspacesampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 22amp
amp Thisampunfoldingampofampmeaningampworksampwellampinamptheampcontextampofampcollageampandampdialogueamp
asampwellampasamphermeneuticsampampInampfactamphermeneuticsampimpliesamppolysemyampbecauseampofampitsamp
notionampthatampitampisampalwaysampaamppossibilityampofampmyampunderstandingampthatampisampplayedampoutampwhenampIamp
understandampaamptextamp(Grondinamp2002amppamp38)ampampPolysemyampcouldampbeampconceptualizedampasampanamp
alternativeampexplorationampofampmeaningampthatampfunctionsampcollaborativelyampwithinampcritiquesampamp
Forampexampleampeducatorsampcanampaskampstudentsamptoamprespondamptoampaampworkampthroughampcollageamp
journalampentriesampmusicampfilmampasampindividualsamporampinampgroupsampampKnowledgeampofamppolysemyamp
couldampalsoampbeampusedampasampaamptoolampforampcreatingampimagesampthatamprecognizesampaamprelationshipamp
betweenamptheampvisualamptheamplinguisticampandamptheampmultipleamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionampdialogicallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Placeampvalueamponampexperientialampnarrativesampbull Practiceamplisteningampbyampbracketingampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampbull Embraceamppolysemicampexplorationsampofampmeaningampamp
Contemplative(Practices(
I-knew-I-was-being-heard-because-of-her-mannerisms-and-the-look-on-her-face--She-was-calm-attentive-and-not-trying-to-jump-in-and-offer-any-advice--She-asked-questions-that-pointed-to-things-I-had-not-openly-articulated-because-of-uncertainty--
This-was-one-of-the-ways-I-knew-I-was-being-heard-(Survey-response-LS-age-27)-
(amp Ifamphermeneuticsampandampdialogicamppracticesampgiveampusamptheampbroadampstrokesampofampactivityampinamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampcontemplativeamppracticesampseekamptoamptuneampstudentsampandamp
educatorsampintoampnuanceampdeliberationampandampdeepampexplorationampampThisampisampaampmostlyamp
individualampinternalamppursuitampthatampfocusesamponampformsampofampselfltlisteningampbutampcontemplativeamp
practicesampareampalsoampformedampbyampanampawarenessampofampinterconnectednessamp
amp InamppursuitampofampcriticalampthinkingampSableamp(2014)ampoutlinesampaampsetampofampcontemplativeamp
practicesampforampstudentsampthatampincludeampmindfulampmeditationampstructuredampcontemplationamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 23amp
journalampwritingampmindfulamplisteningampreflectiveampinquiryampandampdialogueamp(pamp4)ampampWhileamp
Sablesamp(2014)ampmethodampforampcontemplativeamppracticesampprovidesampaampconcreteampframeworkamp
withampspecificampstepsampmanyampofamptheseampconceptsampcouldampbeampappliedampwithoutampsuchampaamp
prescribedampstructureampampForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwillampbeamp
primarilyampdiscussingampSablesampconceptsampofampstructuredampcontemplationampreflectiveamp
inquiryampandampjournalampwritingamp
amp ForampSableamp(2014)ampstructuredampcontemplationampisampaampformampofampbeingamppresentampandamp
focusedamponampaampparticularampquestionampstatementamporampimageampampWithinampthisampmodeampofampinquiryamp
participantsampareampexpectedamptoampholdamptheampobjectampofampcontemplationampinamptheirampmindsamp
deepeningampunderstandingampasamptheyampfocusampwithoutampanalyzingampitamporampmanipulatingampitampinamp
anyampwayamp(pamp5)ampampThisamppracticeampdrawsampcomparisonsamptoamptheampbracketingampofampjudgmentsamp
andampconclusionsampsupportedampinamptheamppreviousampsectionampbutampstructuredampcontemplationamp
occursamponampanampindividualamplevelampratherampthanampdialogicallyamp
amp Reflectiveampinquiryampbearsampsomeampsimilaritiesamptoampstructuredampcontemplationampbutamp
Sableamp(2014)amppositionsampitampasampanampactivityampbetweenamptwoampindividualsampaamplistenerampandampaamp
speakerampampTheamplistenerampisampagainampaskedamptoampsuspendampjudgmentampbutampalsoamptoampengageampinampaamp
formampofampcuriosityampinampwhichampinnocentampquestionsampareampaskedampinamporderamptoampgainamp
understandingampampSableamp(2014)ampcontrastsampinnocentampquestionsampwithampleadingampquestionsampamp
ForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwouldampcharacterizeampthisampinnocentamp
questioningampasampaampformampofampopenltendedampquestioningampampSableamp(2014)ampidentifiesampanamp
exampleampofampanampinnocentamp(orampopenltended)ampquestionampWhatampdidampyouampmeanampwhenampyouamp
saidamp________ampConverselyampaampleadingampquestionampisampDidampyouampmeanamptoampsayamp________ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 24amp
amp Sableamp(2014)ampusesampjournalampwritingampasampaamppieceampofamphisamplargerampstructureampofamp
contemplativeamppracticesampbutampjournalampwritingampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampcouldamp
potentiallyampoccupyampaampsignificantamproleampampIampconceiveampofampjournalampwritingampinampmyampownamp
creativeamppracticeampasampaampformampofampdocumentationampthatampmakesampmeampmoreampawareampofampmyamp
creativeampprocessamptheampemotionalamphabitsampthatampsurroundampitampandamptheampthemesampthatamp
structureampmyampworkampampIampconceptualizeampthisampwayampofampwritingampasampaampformampofampselfltlisteningamp
relatedamptoampaampkeyampconceptampofamphermeneuticsampfoundampinampGadamersampassertionampthatampallamp
educationampisampaampformampofampselflteducationamp(Grondinamp2011)ampampamp
amp Germeraadamp(2013)ampusesampjournalampwritingamptoampexploreamptheampemotionalampandamprationalamp
relationshipsamptoamphisampcreativeampprocessampparallelamptoampexecutingampaampnewampbodyampofampworkampampHeamp
findsampthatampwritingampduringamphisampprocessampisampaamptoolamptoampunderstandamp[his]amppsycheamptoampeaseamp
theamppainampthatampanampartisticampprocessampcanampbringampandamptoamprelieveampartisticampblocksamp
(Germeraadamp2013amppamp21)ampultimatelyampdeclaringampthatampitamphelpsamphimamptoampbetterampunderstandamp
hisampworkampampInampaampstyleampofampwritingampthatamposcillatesamparoundampjournalingampdocumentationampandamp
poetryampdeampCossonamp(2002)ampexploresamphisampoverlappingamprolesampasampanampartistampresearcherampandamp
teacherampampOtherampartistsampbluramptheamplineampbetweenampartamppracticeampdocumentationampandamplifeamp
furtherampstillampbyampofferingampdocumentationampasampartamplikeampSophieampCalleamp(Calleamp2011amp2008amp
2005)ampandampMaryampKellyamp(1973lt1979)ampampamp
amp Karpiakamp(2003)ampestablishesampcontemplativeamppracticesampfromamptheampperspectiveampofamp
theampeducatorampaskingampthemamptoampmineamptheampsubtleamp(pamp71)ampusingampattentivenessamp
attunementampamplificationampandampassociationampampTheseampexercisesampinampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampsetamptheamptoneampasampwellampasampprovideampaampmodelampofampbehaviorampforampotherampparticipantsamp
withinamptheampspaceampampKarpiakamp(2003)ampoutlinesampactivitiesampthatampeducatorsampcanampuseamptoampdrawamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 25amp
outampandamputilizeamptheseampsubtleampsensationsampinamptheampserviceampofamptransformativeamplearningamp(pamp
68)ampampamp
amp ForampKarpiakamp(2003)ampattentivenessamprequiresampawarenessamptoampverbalampandamp
nonverbalampcuesampasampwellampasampanampawarenessampofampwhatampisamphappeningampamongampandampwithinamptheamp
studentsampandamptheampeducatorampampAttunementamprequiresampanampeducatoramptoamporientampherselfamptoamptheamp
otherampandamptoampadoptampanampattitudeampofampunhurriednessampofamppatienceampandampofamphumilityamp
concerningampbothamptheampprocessampandamptheampoutcomesampofamptheampteachingamp(Karpiakamp2003amppgamp
72)ampampAmplificationampisampaampprocessampofamphonoringampcommunicationampthatampcentersamponamptheampideaamp
ofamphearingamponeselfampintoampknowingampitampincludesampusingampparaphrasingampandampclarificationamp
activitiesamptoampgainampinsightampintoampmeaningampampLastlyampassociationampentailsampidentifyingamp
patternsampandampweavingampthemamptogetherampwithampstudentampexperienceampclassroomampdiscussionamp
andamptheampideasampofampothersamp
amp TuningampintoampsubtletyampimpliesampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceampampTheampmanifestationsamp
ofampsilenceampinamptheampclassroomampareampendlessampandampitsampvalueampisamptooampgreatamptoampbeampignoredampwhileamp
tooampvastamptoampbeampfullyampabsorbedampampLevinamp(1989)ampremarksampthatampsilenceampisampaampclearingampwhereamp
thereampisampnothingampforamphearingamptoampholdamponamptoampinampwhichampmanyampfindampunbearableampanxietyamp
(pamp79)ampampNearlyampallampofampusamphaveampexperiencedampthisampunbearableampanxietyampaampstrainampofamp
whichampcanampbeampfoundampinampeducationalampcontextsampdueamptoamptheampfactampthatampclassroomsampareamp
oftenampstructuredamparoundampimplicitampandampexplicitamprulesampaboutamptalkampandampsilenceamp(Schultzamp
2010amppamp2848)ampampForampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampanampawarenessampofampsilenceampimplicatesamp
whatampisampleftampunsaidampandampwhatampisampunsayableltltespeciallyampimportantampbecauseampofamptheamp
unsayableampqualityampofampartworksampampForampSchultzamp(2010)ampsilenceampimpliesamppossibilityamp
becauseampitampcanampholdampmultipleampmeaningsampforampindividualsampwithinampandampacrossampracialamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 26amp
ethnicampandampculturalampgroupsamp(pamp2833)ampampLevinamp(1989)ampfindsampthatamptoamplistenamptoamp
somethingampweampmustampfirstampgive-itampourampsilenceamp(pamp232)ampampThisamppracticeampofampgivingampsilenceamp
isampparticularlyamphelpfulampinamptermsampofampviewingamporamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartamp
amp Gradleamp(2011)ampoutlinesampaamppracticalampvisionampforampviewingampartampthatamprequiresamp
silenceampandampdeliberationampampForamptheamppurposesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampwouldamp
reconceptualizeampthisampasampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampampGradleamp(2011)ampinstructedamp
herampstudentsamptoampspendamptimeampwithampaampworkampofampartampoutsideampofamptheirampeverydayampworldviewamp
attentivelyampviewingampitampforampaboutamptenampminutesampeverydayampforampaampweekampampAfterampeachampviewingamp
experienceamptheampstudentsampwroteampinamptheirampjournalsampampTheampresultsampindicatedampthatampthisamp
processampofampsustainedampsilentampdeliberationampcoupledampwithampanampengagementampofamptheiramp
intuitiveampperceptionsampaboutampartworkampleftampstudentsampfeelingampempoweredamptoampengageampinamp
discussionampandampappreciateampunfamiliarampartampformsampampThisampactivityampisampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoamp
aampworkampofampartampthatampincorporatesampSablesamp(2014)ampconceptampofampstructuredampcontemplationampamp
Weavingampaamprelationshipampbetweenampsilenceampcontemplationampandampattentivenessampisampaamp
significantampendeavorampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
Contemplativeamppracticesampfunctionampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Engageampinampformsampofampviewingampwritingampandampexperiencingampthatamphonorampselfltlisteningamp
bull Attuneamptoampsubtletyampandampnuanceampbull Listenampandampviewampdeliberatelyampbull Cultivateampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceamp(
The(Felt(Sense(
When-someone-understands-what-I-am-talking-about-when-I-talk-about-art-I-am-delighted--Art-is-my-everything--Its-my-passion--When-someone-understands-that-I-
am-instantly-filled-with-joy--That-tells-me-someone-gets-it-(Survey-response-CTF-age-16)-
(
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 7amp
matterampinformationamporamptheamproleampofamptheampeducatorampatamptheampcenterampofamptheseampexperiencesampIamp
proposeampthatampactsampofamplisteningampbeampembeddedampinampmakingampandampviewingampartampampTheamptermamp
creativeltlisteningampspaceamprefersamptoamptheampfluidampandampflexibleampspaceampinampwhichamplisteningamp
practicesampareampanampintegratedampessentialamppartampofampviewingampdiscussingampandampproducingamp
creativeampworksampampArtistsampviewersampstudentsampandampeducatorsampcanamptransformampartamp
classroomsampstudiosampandampsitesampofampviewingampartampintoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhichampareamp
notampdefinedampbyampphysicalampformamporampstructuralampboundariesampampRatheramptheyampareampdefinedampbyamp
specificamppracticesampthatampoccurampamongstampindividualsampandampgroupsampinamptheampcontextampofampartamp
educationampamp
Research(Issue(
amp Theampoverarchingampconcernampinampthisampresearchampisamptheamppotentialampoutcomeampforampusingamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampwithinampartampeducationampampTheamppracticesampIampdiscussamphereamphaveampinamp
commonampaampdistinctiveampflexibilityampandampmalleabilityampampTheyampmayampbeampadaptedamptoampvariousamp
ageampgroupsampeducationalampsitesampandampcontextsampampWhileampIampofferampsuggestionsampIampexpectampthatamp
theamppractitionersampwhoampwishamptoampuseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwillampdeviseamptheirampownamp
methodsampofampimplementationampbasedamponamptheirampspecificampneedsampandampcontextsampampThoughamptheamp
ideaampofampcreativeamplisteningampspacesampemergedampwithinampanampartsampeducationampcontextampampthisamp
conceptampmayampholdampvalueampforampotherampdisciplinesamp
Boundaries(and(Limitations(of(the(Research(
( Iampundertookampthisampresearchampinampfulfillmentampofampaampmastersampdegreeampinampartampeducationamp
atamptheampUniversityampofampCincinnatisampCollegeampofampDesignampArtampArchitectureampandampPlanningamp
(DAAP)ampampTheampresponsesampexperiencesampandampartworkampgeneratedampduringamptheampcourseampofamp
thisampprojectamphaveampoftenampcenteredamparoundampthatampinstitutionampwhichamphousesampaampprimarilyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 8amp
whiteampmiddleltamptoampupperltclassampstudentamppopulationamponampanampurbanampcampusampampIampamampaampwhiteamp
femaleamppursuingamphigherampeducationampampIampwantamptoampacknowledgeampthisamppositionalityampalongamp
withamptheamppersonalampbiasesampaamplifetimeampofampexperiencesamphasampaffordedamptoampmeampampOneampinternalamp
goalampthatampdevelopedampoveramptheampcourseampofampthisampworkampwasampaampcontinuedampconsistentampeffortamp
toampuncoverampandampinterrogateampmyampownampbiasesampasamptheyampmanifestedampampThoughampweampcanampneveramp
beampfreeamporamppureampofamptheseampbiasesampconstantampexaminationampofampthemamphasampbeenampmyampchosenamp
routeamptoampcounteringamptheiramppowerampandampinfluenceampamp
Iampamamppassionateampaboutamptheampmeaningfulamppossibilitiesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampInamprespectampofampmyampownamplimitationsampandampthoseampofampthisampworkamphoweverampIampwillampnotamp
claimampthatampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampareampfeasibleampwithinamptheampcontextampofampeveryamp
educationalampsettingampnorampthatampthisampwayampofampviewingampmakingampandampexperiencingampworksampofamp
artampisampmoreamporamplessampvalidampthanampothersampampRatherampIampsuggestamptheamppossibilityampofamplivingampinamp
possibilitiesampasampaampwayamptoampcultivateampmeaningfulampencountersampwithinampartampandampartamp
educationamp
Data(
amp ForampthisampresearchampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponampthreeampformsampofampdataamp
participantampsurveysampcaseampstudiesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampandampreflectiveamppracticeamp
formsampofampartmakingampallampcollectedampduringampaampfourltmonthampperiodampampToampgatherampparticipantamp
responsesampfromamptheampsurveysampandampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampreliedamponampaampmultitudeampofamp
friendsamppeersampandampcolleaguesampampIampconnectedampwithamptheampmajorityampofamptheseampindividualsamp
duringamporampasampaampresultampofampmyampexperiencesampatampDAAPampampampIampusedamp37ampsurveyampresponsesampaboutamp
listeningampexperiencesampwithampaampparticipantampageamprangeampofamp14amptoamp47ampampParticipantsamp
educationalamplevelsampspannedamphighampschoolamptoampgraduateampschoolampampIamppersonallyampsolicitedamptheamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 9amp
majorityampofamptheamplisteningampsurveysampatamptheampcollegeamplevelampandampaboveampampTheampbulkampofamptheamphighamp
schoolltagedampresponsesampwereampsolicitedampbyampmyampcolleagueampaampphotographyampteacherampatampaamp
Cincinnatiltareaamphighampschoolamp
amp Iampconductedampfiveampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampexperiencesampwithampsixampindividualsampasamp
partampofampthisampresearchampagainampusingampmanyampofamptheamppersonalampandampprofessionalampconnectionsamp
cultivatedampthroughamptheampDAAPampprogramampampIampdeliberatelyampchoseamppeopleampwithampwhomampIamphadamp
variousamplevelsampandamptypesampofamprelationshipsampampIampwillampspeakampmoreampinltdepthampaboutamptheseamp
experiencesampasampwellampasampexploreamptheampsurveyampresponsesampinamptheampResearchampMethodologyamp
andampMethodsampsectionamp
amp Lastlyamptheampdevelopmentampofampanampartmakingamppracticeampwasampessentialamptoampmyampownamp
personalampunderstandingampofamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatampcomposedampmyampresearchamp
ReadersampwillampnoticeampthatampimagesampareampembeddedampinampthisamptextampampTheseampareampimagesampofamptheamp
resultingampproductsampofampaamppracticeampofampunderstandingampthroughampmakingampampIampwillampdiscussamp
themampthroughoutampvariousampsectionsampofampthisamppaperampampamp
Dear(Reader(The(Structure(of(this(Research(Paper(
DearampReader(s)amp
amp Letampmeampbreakampforampaampmomentampfromampstandardampacademicamprhetoricampbeforeampthisamp
paperampreallyampgetsampstartedampampIampknowampwhatampyoureampthinkingltltnineamppagesampinampandampthisamppaperamp
hasntampevenampstartedampyetampampAlasampthisampsectionampisampmyamponeampofampmyampfavoriteampandampmostampoftlt
skimmedamppassagesampofampanampacademicamppaperamptheampstructureampofamptheamppaperampampThisampisamptheamppartamp
whereamptheampwriterampsaysampwhatampshesampaboutamptoampsayampbeforeampsheampsaysampitampampampItsampanamp
organizationalampstrategyampandampitsampthrillingampampLuckilyampforampyouampniceamppersonampwhoampisamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 10amp
readingampthisamppaperampIamphaveampprovidedampaamptranslationampfromampthisamptextsamporiginalampAcademiaamp
intoampnormalltpeopleltlanguageamp
amp Theampstructureampofampthisamppaperampisampasampfollowsampamp(Im-about-to-tell-you-whats-in-this-
long-ass-paper)ampampFirstlyamppleaseampnoteampthatampIampuseamptheamptermampthreadampinamplieuampofampchapteramp
asampanamporganizationalampstructureampIamppreferamptheampformerampbecauseampofamphowampitsampconceptualamp
qualitiesamprelateamptoampmyampworkampamp(Thread-is-awesome-and-you-can-do-tons-of-stuff-with-it-
like-sew-knot-tie-weave-etc--Chapters-are-not-nearly-as-exciting)--Iampwillampfirstampshareamp
myampresearchersampreflexiveampnarrativeampamp(I-made-up-a-cool-story-about-this-project-to-
describe-where-it-all-came-from)ampampThenampIampshallampofferampaampdescriptionampofamptheampqualitiesampofampaamp
creativeltlisteningampspaceampamp(Yes-I-shall)ampampIampwillampdiscussamptheampliteratureampthatampinformsamptheamp
backboneampofampmyampresearchampGadamersamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamp
practicesampandampGendlinsamptheampfeltampsenseampamp(Like-a-typical-graduate-student-I-have-done-
an-insane-amount-of-reading-during-the-past-two-academic-years--A-significant-
portion-of-this-reading-has-been-dedicated-to-those-topics--Dont-ask-me-to-type-them-
out-again-because-Im-seriously-done)ampampTheseampsectionsampbeginampwithampaamppassageampderivedamp
fromampsurveyampresponsesampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampamp(I-got-a-bunch-of-people-to-fill-
out-surveys-for-this-research-and-then-I-put-those-responses-in-my-paper)ampampTheseamp
experiencesampwithamplisteningampwereampprovidedampbyampresearchampparticipantsampamp(Super-nice-
people-I-know-and-some-I-dont-helped-me-out)ampampTheyampareampthereamptoampgroundamptheamp
conceptualampframeworksampinamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampamp(This-basically-means-
none-of-this-research-is-worth-shit-unless-it-can-be-used-in-the-real-world((I-hope-youll-
agree)ampampIampwillampthenampshareampmyampresearchampmethodologyampandampmethodsampamp(Im-going-to-tell-
you-about-how-and-why-I-did-this-project-in-using-big-smart(sounding-words)ampampLastlyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 11amp
Iampwillampconcludeampwithamppossibilitiesampforampthisampresearchampamp(Ill-figure-out-what-I-learned-and-
share-it-with-you-my-new-best-friend-who-made-it-all-the-way-to-the-conclusions-
section)ampampInampthisamppaperampreadersampwillampnoticeamptransparentampimagesampinteractingampwithamptheamp
textampamp(Its-my-art-on-transparent-sheets-in-this-very-paper)ampampTheseampareampworksampofampartamp
thatampIampcreatedamptoampgroundamptheampresearchampinampaamppracticeampofampmakingamptheyampareamptheampphysicalamp
embodimentampofampconceptualampideasampandamptheyampareampalwaysamppresentamptoamptheampresearchampamp
(Research-papers-with-pictures-are-much-more-tolerable-am-I-right)amp
amp Hereampweampgoamp
amp
thread2(
Collaging(Experience1(
amp ImagineampthatampyouampareampanampartistampseatedampatampyourampstudioamptableampampYouamphaveamp
everythingampyouampneedampampTheamproomampisampquietampsaveampforamptheampmuffledampsoundsampofampaampdistantamp
outsideampworldampampYouampsurveyamptheampcollectionampofampimagesampyouamphaveampgatheredamparoundampyouampamp
OnampyouramprightampisampaampraggedamppageampfromampanampoldampsketchbookampampGlossyampjewellttonedampswatchesamp
fromampaampdiscardedampfashionampmagazineampareampstackedampupampglisteningampinamptheamplightampampMonthsamp
agoampyouamppickedampupampaamphandfulampofampblackampandampwhiteampphotosampfromampaampsecondhandampstoreamp
todayamppastyampfacesampofamptheampunknownampsubjectsampstareampthroughampyouampblanklyampampAamppaleampyellowamp
scrapampofampleftoverampfabricampisampdrapedampoveramplastampweeksamppleatedamptoltdoamplistampampTheseampandamptwoamp
dozenampotherampscrapsamppiecesamppilesampandampcrumbsampareampyouramptoolsamptodayampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampamp1ampThisampsectionampisampsupposedamptoampbeampmyampresearchersampreflexiveampnarrativeampaamppassageampaboutampwhereampmyampresearchampideasampcameampfromltltandampinampfactampcollageampisampactuallyampwhereampthisampideaampcomesampfromampampOneampofamptheampfirstampresearchampinterestsampIampdiscussedampwithampmyampprofessorampDrampKristopherampHollandampwasamplayersampbothampphysicalampandampconceptualampampHeampwasamplikeampOhampampYoureamptalkingampaboutamphermeneuticsampSoampinampaampwayampthisampresearchampprojectampbothampbeganampandampconcludedamp(moreamponampthatamplater)ampwithampideasampofamplayeringampandampcollageampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 12amp
amp TheampresidueampthatampclingsamptoamptheseampscrapsampisampexperienceampampTheampoldampsketchbookamp
pageampisampanampimageampofampaampwomansamplegamprenderedampwithampchunkyamppencilampstrokesampampYouampmadeampitamp
whenampyouampwereamplivingampinampyourampoldampapartmentampoverlookingamptheampsquareampampItsampaampwomansamp
footampbutampitampremindsampyouampofamphavingampaamproommateampandampaampgrayampfutonampandampaampsummerampthatamp
wasampdesperatelyamphotampampItampisamponlyamppencilamponamppaperampbutampitampremindsampyouampofamptheampgreenamp
grassyampcenterampinamptheampmedianampofamptheampstreetampampOneamppencilampdrawingampofampaampwomansamplegamp
remindsampyouampofampthatampoldamplifeampandamptheampversionampofampyourselfampyouampwereampthenampitampisamptheampfirstamp
dominoampinampaampseriesampofampcascadingampdetailsampandampmemoriesampamp
amp EachampfragmentampsittingamponampyourampstudioamptableamphasampaampstoryampampEachampcameampfromampaamp
placeampandampwasamptouchedampbyampanotheramphumanampampEachampisampembeddedampwithampexperienceampcoloramp
memoryamptextureampandampinfiniteampdetailampbyamptheampmereampfactampofampitsampownampexistenceampamp
amp YouampbeginamptoamppickampapartamptheampephemeraampampYouampalternateampbeingampcarefulampandamp
carelessamp
amp Cuttingamptearingampburningampstretchingampfoldingampwhitewashingamprippingampcreasingamp
sewingampwritingamppaintingampencasingampfasteningampfillingampsoakingampdyeingampwashingamp
dryingampbitingampscratchingamppryingampyankingampsmoothingampsandingamppokingampstabbingamp
stretchingampfryingampheatingampdustingampcleaningampsculptingampslicingampdicingamppunchingamp
floatingamptwistingampflippingampdrippingampstaplingampstrippingampstripingamppatterningamp
designingampdrawingampsketchingampliftingampcollectingamptapingampgluingampbuttoningampknottingamp
weavingampknittingamp
amp YouampdoampallampofamptheseampthingsampandampprobablyampmanyampotherampthingsampampTheampfragmentsamponamp
youramptableampchangeampshapeampandampgetampsmallerampampFromamptheseamppiecesampyouampbeginamptoampbuildamp
somethingampampThisampsomethingampisampbothampnewampandampoldampampJuxtapositionsampbloomampnewamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 13amp
connectionsampareampfusedampbyamptheampweightampofamppreviousampexperienceampampPastampandamppresentamp
liquefyampintoampendlesslyampcirculatingamppossibilitiesampampYouampcouldamptheoreticallyampcontinueampthisamp
processampofamplayeringampandampreconstructionampforeverampamptheamponlyamplimitsampareampyourampownamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 14amp
thread3(
what(is(a(creative=listening(space(
ampampampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeamplisteningampspaceampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampwhatampdoesampitampsoundampsmellamptasteampfeelamplikeampampampampampampampwhatampampisampamptheampamptextureampampofampampthisampampamp
spaceampampampanswerampmoreampquestionsampampamp specificsampandampgeneralizationsampareampbothampimpossibleampampmaybeampaampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampgoodampstartampwouldampbeampthisampampamp amp amp amp amp safeampampampamp amp amp amp amp foldedampampamp amp amp amp amp amp embodiedampamp layeredampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampconnectedampampampamp amp ampamp
(it-might--be-like-gently-holding-on-to--
a-knot-of-questions)-amp
ampampampampampampampampampamp
(possible)ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 15amp
thread4amp(
Review(of(Literature((
( AnampexplorationampofampGadamerrsquosamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampeducationalampcontextsampandampGendlinrsquosamptheoryampofampfeltampsenseampwereampintegralamptoamp
theampcreationampofamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampWhileampcompellingampconstructsamponamp
theirampownampwhenampdrawnamptogetheramptheseampphilosophicalampperspectivesampvibrateamp
holisticallyamptoampsuggestampintriguingamppossibilitiesampforamptheampuseampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
inampartsampeducationampampInampthisampsectionampIampreviewamptheampliteratureampandampconnectamptheampvariousamp
pointsampofampstudyampampamp
Hermeneutics(amp(the(Fusion(of(Horizons((
It-actually-feels-really-great-knowing-that-other-people-will-enjoy-the-art-you-created-and-knowing-they-know-your-reasoning-and-story-behind-it--Honestly-you-cant-know-if-your-words-are-getting-through-to-them-but-the-cool-thing-about-art-is-that-it-can-be-
interpreted-in-so-many-different-ways---(Survey-response-EK-age-15)-
ampamp Hermeneuticsampwhichamphasampitsamprootsampinamptextualampinterpretationampcanampbeampdefinedampasamp
aamptraditionampofampthinkingamporampofampphilosophicalampreflectionampthatamptriesamptoampclarifyamptheampconceptamp
ofampverstehenampthatampisampunderstandingamp(Brunsamp1992)ampampRicoeuramp(19691974)ampexplainsamp
thatamptheampkeyamphypothesisampofamphermeneuticampphilosophyampisampthatampinterpretationampisampanampopenamp
processampwhichampnoampsingleampvisionampcanampconcludeamp(pamp109)ampampWithampthisampinampmindampIampwillamp
exploreamphermeneuticsampasampitampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp HansltGeorgampGadameramp(1900lt2002)ampinvestigatesampaampmoderateampformampofamp
hermeneuticsampthatampisampparticularlyamprelevantampinampserviceamptoampartampeducationampampGadameramp
breaksampwithamphermeneuticamptraditionampbyampproposingampthatampthereampisampnoampabsolutelyampobjectiveamp
interpretationampreadersampareampnotampableamptoampescapeamptheampprejudicesampofamptheiramptimeamp(Gallagheramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 16amp
1992)ampampThisamphoweverampbecomesampanampopportunityampforamptheampcreationampofampmeaningampInampaamp
passageampthatampechoesamptheampendlesslyampunfoldingampnatureampofampcollageampCaputoamp(2000)amprefersamp
toampanampexchangeampbetweenamppastampandamppresentampinamptheampcreativeamppossibilitiesampofamphermeneuticamp
interpretationamp
amp Thereampisampaamprichnessampinamphistoricalampeventsampthatampjustampkeepsampunfoldingampwhichampisamp
amp certainlyampnotampgraspedampbyamptheamporiginalampprotagonistsampwhichampgraduallyampunfoldsamp
amp overamptheampcourseampofamptimeampandampwhichampisampinampprincipleampneverampfullyampunfoldedampItampisamp
amp anampexcessampwhichampkeepsampspillingampoveramp(pamp47)amp
amp Gadamersampphilosophyampofamphermeneuticampunderstandingampisampformedampthroughamphisamp
notionsampaboutamplanguageampdialogueampandampconversationamp(Caputoamp2000ampSeebohmamp2004)ampamp
InampadditionamptoampGadamersampimplicitamprelianceamponamplisteningampasampheampdiscussesampdialogueamphisamp
workampcapitalizesamponamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampinamplanguageamp(Heelanamp1985)ampmakingamphisamp
formampofamphermeneuticsampparticularlyampapplicableamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp Gadamersamptermampfusion-of-horizonsamprefersamptoamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampwithinampaamp
varietyampofampencountersampampAampfusionampofamphorizonsampcanampbeampdescribedampasampaampdialogicamp
conversationampbetweenampreaderampandamptextamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampWithinamptheamptextualamp
paradigmampGadamerampbelievesampthatampaampwrittenamptextampisampopenamptoampanampinvisibleampandampindefiniteamp
readerampwhoampentersampintoampanampunknownampadventureampofamptheamptextamp(Ricoeuramp2013amppamp13)ampamp
Theamphorizonampitselfampisamptheamprangeampofampvisionampthatampincludesampeverythingampthatampcanampbeampseenamp
fromampaampparticularampvantageamppointamp(Gadameramp2004amppamp301)ampampLikeampcollageamptheampfusionampofamp
horizonsampisampaampprocessampcomposedampofamppastampandamppresentampwhichampareampopenamptoampandampinfinitelyamp
effectedampbyampeachampotheramp(Bourgeoisamp2007)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 17amp
amp Similarampconnectionsampcanampbeampdrawnampwhenampviewerampandampartworkampareampsubstitutedamp
forampreaderampandamptextampampInterpretationampandampunderstandingampbecomeampanampentwinedamp
creativeampendeavorampinampwhichamptheampviewerampparticipatesampasampmuchampasamptheampcreatorampbyamp
constructingampmeaningamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampPalmeramp(1969)ampalludesamptoamptheamppluralityampofamp
meaningampinampstatingampthatamptoampfocusamppurelyamponamptheamppositivityampofampwhatampaamptextampexplicitlyamp
saysampisamptoampdoampanampinjusticeamptoamptheamphermeneuticalamptaskamp(pamp234)ampampToampfocusamponampwhatampisamp
explicitampinampaampcollageampworkampwouldampbeamptoampdisregardamptheampconnectionsampandampcontradictionsamp
ofamptheampwholeampinampfavorampofampaampdirectampreadingampofamptheampindividualamppartsampthusampmissingampoutamponamp
otheramppossibleampdimensionsampofampmeaningamp
amp Theampkeyamptoamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampeducationampinamptextampandampbetweenamp
individualsampisamptheampabilityamptoamplistenampwithampopennessampampDefensiveamplisteningampisampaampwayampofamp
listeningampwithoutampopennessampitampisampaampwayampofampprotectingampourampsmallampversionampofamptheampworldamp
andampavoidingampmoralampclaimsamponampourselvesamp(Levinamp1989amppamp79)ampampLevinamp(1989)amp
discussesampplayfulamplisteningamp(pamp233)ampasampaampwayampofampcounteractingampdefensiveamplisteningampampamp
Bohmamp(1996)ampdiscussesampsuspendingampassumptionsampaampprocessampofampattendingamptoamp
assumptionsampratherampthanamprepressingampthemamporampcarryingampthemampoutampampNicholamp(1996)amp
explainsampaampcircumstanceampinampwhichampyouampencounterampaamppersonampyouampfeelampisampanampidiotampampampYouamp
wouldamprefrainampfromampsayingampsoampoutamploudampbutampyouampwouldampalsoamprefrainampfromampscoldingamp
yourselfampforampthisampthoughtampratherampyouampwouldampseeampthisampreactionampwithoutampfullyampengagingamp
withampitampampSimilarampsuggestionsamplikeampbracketingampofampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampareamp
discussedampinamptheampfollowingampsectionampamp
amp Gadamerampbelievesamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampwhatampallowsamptheampselfamptoampapproachamp
theampotherampitampisampaampprocessampinampwhichamptheampideasampofamptheampotherampbecomeamponesampownamp(Caputoamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 18amp
2000)ampampThisampisamphardlyampanampuncommonampexperienceampampInampfactampweampregularlyampencounteramptheamp
fusionampofamphorizonsampbyampintegratingamppastampunderstandingsampwithampcurrentampexperiencesampaamp
processampundoubtedlyampcomparableamptoampeducationamp(Zuckertamp2002)ampamp
amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsamplikeampeducationampcanampbeampfrustratingampandampemotionalamp
becauseampeachamphighlight[s]amptheampfinitudeampofamptheampinterpreterampandamptheamplimitationsampofamphisamp
understandingamp(Bourgeoisamp2007amppamp79)ampampTheamptermampsharesampsimilaritiesampwithamptheamp
problematic-momentampaamppedagogicalamptermampreferringamptoampaampbreachampinampaampdominantampgroupsamp
discourseampduringampwhichampsomethingamprepressedamparisesamp(KentampampampCummingamp2008)ampampKentamp
andampCummingamp(2008)ampexploreamptheampproblematicampmomentampasampaampdiscursiveampsiteampforamp
examiningampprejudiceampwithinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampandampitsamp
moreamppoliticallyampchargedampcounterpartamptheampproblematicampmomentampbothampexploreamp
Gadamersamp(1996)ampampassertionampthatamptheampotherampmayampnotamponlyamphaveampaamprightampbutampmayamp
actuallyampbeamprightampmayampunderstandampsomethingampbetterampthanampweampdoamp(pamp82)ampampAampcreativelt
listeningampspaceamplivesampinampthisamppossibilityampampamp
amp Lastlyamprelayingampofampappropriateampexpectationsamptoampparticipantsampisampaampnecessaryamp
featureampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampdemandingampampItamp
requiresampparticipantsampwhoampareampawareampofamptheamprisksampandamphardshipsamptoampenterampintoampitampampItamp
isamptheampresponsibilityampofamptheampeducatoramporampgroupampleaderamptoampmakeamptheseampexpectationsamp
knownampasampwellampasamptoampmodelampthisampbehaviorampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionamphermeneuticallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Areampopenamptoamppossibilitiesampandamptoamptheampotherampbull Conceiveampofampthemselvesampasampengagingampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamptheamprisksampinvolvedampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamplimitationsampofamptheirampunderstandingamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 19amp
Dialogic(Practices(-
I-felt-that-everyone-was-open-and-interested-in-what-I-had-to-say---Perhaps-I-felt-this-sense-of-understanding-due-to-the-nature-of-the-discussion((-
it-felt-[like]-more-[of]-a-dialogue-as-opposed-to-a-standard-critique-(Survey-response-MW-age-22)-
(amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampartampeducationampreliesamponampanampopenampdialogueampduringamp
experiencesampwithampartampselfampandampothersampampWhatampIampfoundamplackingampinamphermeneuticsamp
howeverampwasampaampdiscussionampofamptheamphowltlthowampisamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampachievedampandamp
howampdoampindividualsampmeaningfullyampengageampwithampeachampotherampampInampanampeffortamptoampclarifyampthisamp
Iampwillampdiscussampdialogicamppracticesampasamptheyamprelateamptoampmeaningfulampverbalampexchangesampandamp
listeningampencountersampinamptheampclassroomampandampstudioampamongstampstudentsamptheiramppeersampandamp
educatorsamp
amp Communicatingampthroughamplanguageampandampdialogueampisamphowampweampcoltconstructamp
worldsampwithampourselvesampandampothersampnotampjustampthroughampanampactampofamptransmissionampbutamp
becauseampourampcommunicativeampactsampgiveampbirthamptoampworldsamp(Lipariamp2014amppamp507)ampampSableamp
(2014)ampdescribesampdialogueampasampaampgenerativeampinterchangeampbetweenampparticipantsampasamp
opposedamptoampanampexchangeampofampviewsampwhereampindividualsampsimplyampadvocateamptheiramppositionsamp
(pamp8)ampampForampBohmamp(1996)ampitampisampaampstreamampofampmeaningampflowingampamongampandampthroughampusamp
(pamp6)ampampTheampnatureampofampdialogueampandampconversationampisampinherentlyampunplannedampampThisamp
dimensionampofampconversationampisampimportantamptoampGadameramp(2004)ampwhoampfindsampthatamp
participantsampinvolvedampinampconversationampareamplessamptheampleadersampofampitampthanamptheampledamp(pamp
385)ampampSableamp(2014)ampechoesampthisampbyampwritingampthatamptheampmostampimportantamppartsampofampanyamp
conversationampareampthoseampthatampneitheramppartyampcouldamphaveampimaginedampbeforeampstartingamp(pamp
8)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 20amp
amp Theseampareampnotionsampofampdialogueampamongampothersampthatampfindampaampparallelampinamptheamp
creativeampprocessampampFairfieldamp(2011)ampwritesampthatampinampprincipleampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinamp
dialogueamp(pamp83)ampaampsentimentampthatampalignsampwithampaampcommonampissueampencounteredampduringamp
theampcreativeampprocessltltnotampknowingampwhenampaamppieceampisampdoneampampAampquoteampoftenampattributedamp
toampLeonardoampdaampVinciampspeaksamptoampthisampideaampArtampisampneverampfinishedamponlyampabandonedampamp
Snowberamp(2007)ampdrawsampparallelsampbetweenampmentorshipampdialogueampandamptheampcreativeamp
processampfindingampthatampdeepamplisteningamppracticesampconnectampallampthreeampampSheampfindsampthatamptheamp
taskampofamptheampmentorampisamptheampsameampasamptheamptaskampofamptheampartistampthatampisamptoampbringampoutamptheamp
naturalampqualitiesampofamptheampstudentamporamptheampmediumampampSnowberamp(2007)ampcommentsamponampanamp
ideaampwellltknownampamongampartistsampwhichampisampthatampaampworkampofampartamphasampaamplifeampofampitsampownampthisamp
notionampisampreminiscentampofampGadamersampstatementampaboutampbeingampledampbyampconversationamp
ampamp Dialogicamppracticesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampeducationampemphasizeampaamp
phenomenologicalampdimensionamprequiringamptwoampthingsampfromampparticipantsampampFirstlyamp
participantsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampmustampfindampvalueampinamplisteningamptoamptheamp
narrativesampofamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampampTheseampparticipantsampknowampthatampeducationamp
isampforemostampaboutamptestimonyampaboutampsharingamptheampexperienceampofampbeingamphumanampsharingamp
lifeampconvictionsampandampknowledge((Wiercinskiamp2011amppamp109)ampampNarrativesampareamp
conceivedampofampasampaampwayampofamphumanampknowingamp(Vitanovaamp2010amppamp29)ampthatampmakesamptheamp
selfampampSecondlyampwhenamplisteningamptoamptheampnarrativesampofampothersampparticipantsampareampexpectedamp
toampbracketamptheirampownampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsamp(LindsethampampampNorbergamp2004)ampampThisamp
encouragesamplistenersamptoampexperienceampandampfindampmeaningampinamptheampnarrativesampofampothersamp
whileampfreeingamptheampspeakerampfromamptheampfearampofampbeingampjudgedampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 21amp
amp Bracketingampjudgmentampandampconclusionampisampaamppotentialamptoolampwithinamptheampcommonamp
artampeducationamppracticeampofampgroupampcritiquesampampElkinsamp(2001)ampfindsampthatamppeopleampwhoamphaveamp
experienceampinampartampjudgeampveryampquicklyampandampmostampteachersampwillamphaveampaampprovisionalamp
opinionampaboutampaampworkampinamptheampfirstamptenampsecondsamp(pamp121)ampampBracketingampconclusionampandamp
judgmentampisampparticularlyampimportantampforampeducatorsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
whoseampvolumeampofampviewingampexperiencesampcouldampleadamptoampeasyampassumptionsampwhenamp
encounteringampaampnewampworkampampamp
amp Elkinsamp(2001)ampdiscussesampthatampcritiquesampcanampalsoampbeampseenampasampexchangesampofamp
storiesamporampcollaborativeampstorytellingamp(pamp145)ampwhichampisampyetampanotherampwayampofamptalkingamp
aboutamppossibilitiesampforampdialogueampandampnarrativeampwithinampartampeducationampampElkinsamphoweveramp
findsampstorytellingamplimitingamponceamptheampdeeperampnarrativesampareampdiscoveredamp(2001amppamp
145)ampampThisampimpliesampthatampheampfindsamponlyampaampsingularampmeaningampandamponeampthatampisampnotamp
necessarilyampusefulampforampcollaborativeampgroupampcritiquesamp
amp Insteadampparticipantsampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampbringampknowledgeampofamp
polysemyamptoampcollaborativeampcritiqueampexperiencesampasampwellampasamptoampexperiencesampofampmakingamp
artworkampampAccordingamptoampMuldoonamp(2002)amppolysemyampisamptheampqualityampofampaampwordamporampotheramp
languageampunitampthatampcanampbearampmultipleampmeaningsamp(asampcitedampinampWorsleyamp2012amppamp308)ampampamp
Aamptextualampexampleampofampthisampisamptheampmultipleampmeaningsampofamptheampwordampcan-Iampcanampdriveampaampcaramp
Idamplikeampaampcan-ofampsodaampheampwasntampworkingampveryamphardampsoampIamphadamptoampcan-himamp(Munozamp
2014)ampampampButampifampweampconsideramppolysemyampmetaphoricallyamporampvisuallyamptheampideaampthatampaamp
singleampunitampimageamporampintentionampcouldampbearampmultipleampmeaningsampcouldampbeampproductiveampinamp
creatingltlisteningampspacesampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 22amp
amp Thisampunfoldingampofampmeaningampworksampwellampinamptheampcontextampofampcollageampandampdialogueamp
asampwellampasamphermeneuticsampampInampfactamphermeneuticsampimpliesamppolysemyampbecauseampofampitsamp
notionampthatampitampisampalwaysampaamppossibilityampofampmyampunderstandingampthatampisampplayedampoutampwhenampIamp
understandampaamptextamp(Grondinamp2002amppamp38)ampampPolysemyampcouldampbeampconceptualizedampasampanamp
alternativeampexplorationampofampmeaningampthatampfunctionsampcollaborativelyampwithinampcritiquesampamp
Forampexampleampeducatorsampcanampaskampstudentsamptoamprespondamptoampaampworkampthroughampcollageamp
journalampentriesampmusicampfilmampasampindividualsamporampinampgroupsampampKnowledgeampofamppolysemyamp
couldampalsoampbeampusedampasampaamptoolampforampcreatingampimagesampthatamprecognizesampaamprelationshipamp
betweenamptheampvisualamptheamplinguisticampandamptheampmultipleamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionampdialogicallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Placeampvalueamponampexperientialampnarrativesampbull Practiceamplisteningampbyampbracketingampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampbull Embraceamppolysemicampexplorationsampofampmeaningampamp
Contemplative(Practices(
I-knew-I-was-being-heard-because-of-her-mannerisms-and-the-look-on-her-face--She-was-calm-attentive-and-not-trying-to-jump-in-and-offer-any-advice--She-asked-questions-that-pointed-to-things-I-had-not-openly-articulated-because-of-uncertainty--
This-was-one-of-the-ways-I-knew-I-was-being-heard-(Survey-response-LS-age-27)-
(amp Ifamphermeneuticsampandampdialogicamppracticesampgiveampusamptheampbroadampstrokesampofampactivityampinamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampcontemplativeamppracticesampseekamptoamptuneampstudentsampandamp
educatorsampintoampnuanceampdeliberationampandampdeepampexplorationampampThisampisampaampmostlyamp
individualampinternalamppursuitampthatampfocusesamponampformsampofampselfltlisteningampbutampcontemplativeamp
practicesampareampalsoampformedampbyampanampawarenessampofampinterconnectednessamp
amp InamppursuitampofampcriticalampthinkingampSableamp(2014)ampoutlinesampaampsetampofampcontemplativeamp
practicesampforampstudentsampthatampincludeampmindfulampmeditationampstructuredampcontemplationamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 23amp
journalampwritingampmindfulamplisteningampreflectiveampinquiryampandampdialogueamp(pamp4)ampampWhileamp
Sablesamp(2014)ampmethodampforampcontemplativeamppracticesampprovidesampaampconcreteampframeworkamp
withampspecificampstepsampmanyampofamptheseampconceptsampcouldampbeampappliedampwithoutampsuchampaamp
prescribedampstructureampampForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwillampbeamp
primarilyampdiscussingampSablesampconceptsampofampstructuredampcontemplationampreflectiveamp
inquiryampandampjournalampwritingamp
amp ForampSableamp(2014)ampstructuredampcontemplationampisampaampformampofampbeingamppresentampandamp
focusedamponampaampparticularampquestionampstatementamporampimageampampWithinampthisampmodeampofampinquiryamp
participantsampareampexpectedamptoampholdamptheampobjectampofampcontemplationampinamptheirampmindsamp
deepeningampunderstandingampasamptheyampfocusampwithoutampanalyzingampitamporampmanipulatingampitampinamp
anyampwayamp(pamp5)ampampThisamppracticeampdrawsampcomparisonsamptoamptheampbracketingampofampjudgmentsamp
andampconclusionsampsupportedampinamptheamppreviousampsectionampbutampstructuredampcontemplationamp
occursamponampanampindividualamplevelampratherampthanampdialogicallyamp
amp Reflectiveampinquiryampbearsampsomeampsimilaritiesamptoampstructuredampcontemplationampbutamp
Sableamp(2014)amppositionsampitampasampanampactivityampbetweenamptwoampindividualsampaamplistenerampandampaamp
speakerampampTheamplistenerampisampagainampaskedamptoampsuspendampjudgmentampbutampalsoamptoampengageampinampaamp
formampofampcuriosityampinampwhichampinnocentampquestionsampareampaskedampinamporderamptoampgainamp
understandingampampSableamp(2014)ampcontrastsampinnocentampquestionsampwithampleadingampquestionsampamp
ForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwouldampcharacterizeampthisampinnocentamp
questioningampasampaampformampofampopenltendedampquestioningampampSableamp(2014)ampidentifiesampanamp
exampleampofampanampinnocentamp(orampopenltended)ampquestionampWhatampdidampyouampmeanampwhenampyouamp
saidamp________ampConverselyampaampleadingampquestionampisampDidampyouampmeanamptoampsayamp________ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 24amp
amp Sableamp(2014)ampusesampjournalampwritingampasampaamppieceampofamphisamplargerampstructureampofamp
contemplativeamppracticesampbutampjournalampwritingampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampcouldamp
potentiallyampoccupyampaampsignificantamproleampampIampconceiveampofampjournalampwritingampinampmyampownamp
creativeamppracticeampasampaampformampofampdocumentationampthatampmakesampmeampmoreampawareampofampmyamp
creativeampprocessamptheampemotionalamphabitsampthatampsurroundampitampandamptheampthemesampthatamp
structureampmyampworkampampIampconceptualizeampthisampwayampofampwritingampasampaampformampofampselfltlisteningamp
relatedamptoampaampkeyampconceptampofamphermeneuticsampfoundampinampGadamersampassertionampthatampallamp
educationampisampaampformampofampselflteducationamp(Grondinamp2011)ampampamp
amp Germeraadamp(2013)ampusesampjournalampwritingamptoampexploreamptheampemotionalampandamprationalamp
relationshipsamptoamphisampcreativeampprocessampparallelamptoampexecutingampaampnewampbodyampofampworkampampHeamp
findsampthatampwritingampduringamphisampprocessampisampaamptoolamptoampunderstandamp[his]amppsycheamptoampeaseamp
theamppainampthatampanampartisticampprocessampcanampbringampandamptoamprelieveampartisticampblocksamp
(Germeraadamp2013amppamp21)ampultimatelyampdeclaringampthatampitamphelpsamphimamptoampbetterampunderstandamp
hisampworkampampInampaampstyleampofampwritingampthatamposcillatesamparoundampjournalingampdocumentationampandamp
poetryampdeampCossonamp(2002)ampexploresamphisampoverlappingamprolesampasampanampartistampresearcherampandamp
teacherampampOtherampartistsampbluramptheamplineampbetweenampartamppracticeampdocumentationampandamplifeamp
furtherampstillampbyampofferingampdocumentationampasampartamplikeampSophieampCalleamp(Calleamp2011amp2008amp
2005)ampandampMaryampKellyamp(1973lt1979)ampampamp
amp Karpiakamp(2003)ampestablishesampcontemplativeamppracticesampfromamptheampperspectiveampofamp
theampeducatorampaskingampthemamptoampmineamptheampsubtleamp(pamp71)ampusingampattentivenessamp
attunementampamplificationampandampassociationampampTheseampexercisesampinampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampsetamptheamptoneampasampwellampasampprovideampaampmodelampofampbehaviorampforampotherampparticipantsamp
withinamptheampspaceampampKarpiakamp(2003)ampoutlinesampactivitiesampthatampeducatorsampcanampuseamptoampdrawamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 25amp
outampandamputilizeamptheseampsubtleampsensationsampinamptheampserviceampofamptransformativeamplearningamp(pamp
68)ampampamp
amp ForampKarpiakamp(2003)ampattentivenessamprequiresampawarenessamptoampverbalampandamp
nonverbalampcuesampasampwellampasampanampawarenessampofampwhatampisamphappeningampamongampandampwithinamptheamp
studentsampandamptheampeducatorampampAttunementamprequiresampanampeducatoramptoamporientampherselfamptoamptheamp
otherampandamptoampadoptampanampattitudeampofampunhurriednessampofamppatienceampandampofamphumilityamp
concerningampbothamptheampprocessampandamptheampoutcomesampofamptheampteachingamp(Karpiakamp2003amppgamp
72)ampampAmplificationampisampaampprocessampofamphonoringampcommunicationampthatampcentersamponamptheampideaamp
ofamphearingamponeselfampintoampknowingampitampincludesampusingampparaphrasingampandampclarificationamp
activitiesamptoampgainampinsightampintoampmeaningampampLastlyampassociationampentailsampidentifyingamp
patternsampandampweavingampthemamptogetherampwithampstudentampexperienceampclassroomampdiscussionamp
andamptheampideasampofampothersamp
amp TuningampintoampsubtletyampimpliesampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceampampTheampmanifestationsamp
ofampsilenceampinamptheampclassroomampareampendlessampandampitsampvalueampisamptooampgreatamptoampbeampignoredampwhileamp
tooampvastamptoampbeampfullyampabsorbedampampLevinamp(1989)ampremarksampthatampsilenceampisampaampclearingampwhereamp
thereampisampnothingampforamphearingamptoampholdamponamptoampinampwhichampmanyampfindampunbearableampanxietyamp
(pamp79)ampampNearlyampallampofampusamphaveampexperiencedampthisampunbearableampanxietyampaampstrainampofamp
whichampcanampbeampfoundampinampeducationalampcontextsampdueamptoamptheampfactampthatampclassroomsampareamp
oftenampstructuredamparoundampimplicitampandampexplicitamprulesampaboutamptalkampandampsilenceamp(Schultzamp
2010amppamp2848)ampampForampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampanampawarenessampofampsilenceampimplicatesamp
whatampisampleftampunsaidampandampwhatampisampunsayableltltespeciallyampimportantampbecauseampofamptheamp
unsayableampqualityampofampartworksampampForampSchultzamp(2010)ampsilenceampimpliesamppossibilityamp
becauseampitampcanampholdampmultipleampmeaningsampforampindividualsampwithinampandampacrossampracialamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 26amp
ethnicampandampculturalampgroupsamp(pamp2833)ampampLevinamp(1989)ampfindsampthatamptoamplistenamptoamp
somethingampweampmustampfirstampgive-itampourampsilenceamp(pamp232)ampampThisamppracticeampofampgivingampsilenceamp
isampparticularlyamphelpfulampinamptermsampofampviewingamporamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartamp
amp Gradleamp(2011)ampoutlinesampaamppracticalampvisionampforampviewingampartampthatamprequiresamp
silenceampandampdeliberationampampForamptheamppurposesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampwouldamp
reconceptualizeampthisampasampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampampGradleamp(2011)ampinstructedamp
herampstudentsamptoampspendamptimeampwithampaampworkampofampartampoutsideampofamptheirampeverydayampworldviewamp
attentivelyampviewingampitampforampaboutamptenampminutesampeverydayampforampaampweekampampAfterampeachampviewingamp
experienceamptheampstudentsampwroteampinamptheirampjournalsampampTheampresultsampindicatedampthatampthisamp
processampofampsustainedampsilentampdeliberationampcoupledampwithampanampengagementampofamptheiramp
intuitiveampperceptionsampaboutampartworkampleftampstudentsampfeelingampempoweredamptoampengageampinamp
discussionampandampappreciateampunfamiliarampartampformsampampThisampactivityampisampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoamp
aampworkampofampartampthatampincorporatesampSablesamp(2014)ampconceptampofampstructuredampcontemplationampamp
Weavingampaamprelationshipampbetweenampsilenceampcontemplationampandampattentivenessampisampaamp
significantampendeavorampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
Contemplativeamppracticesampfunctionampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Engageampinampformsampofampviewingampwritingampandampexperiencingampthatamphonorampselfltlisteningamp
bull Attuneamptoampsubtletyampandampnuanceampbull Listenampandampviewampdeliberatelyampbull Cultivateampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceamp(
The(Felt(Sense(
When-someone-understands-what-I-am-talking-about-when-I-talk-about-art-I-am-delighted--Art-is-my-everything--Its-my-passion--When-someone-understands-that-I-
am-instantly-filled-with-joy--That-tells-me-someone-gets-it-(Survey-response-CTF-age-16)-
(
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 8amp
whiteampmiddleltamptoampupperltclassampstudentamppopulationamponampanampurbanampcampusampampIampamampaampwhiteamp
femaleamppursuingamphigherampeducationampampIampwantamptoampacknowledgeampthisamppositionalityampalongamp
withamptheamppersonalampbiasesampaamplifetimeampofampexperiencesamphasampaffordedamptoampmeampampOneampinternalamp
goalampthatampdevelopedampoveramptheampcourseampofampthisampworkampwasampaampcontinuedampconsistentampeffortamp
toampuncoverampandampinterrogateampmyampownampbiasesampasamptheyampmanifestedampampThoughampweampcanampneveramp
beampfreeamporamppureampofamptheseampbiasesampconstantampexaminationampofampthemamphasampbeenampmyampchosenamp
routeamptoampcounteringamptheiramppowerampandampinfluenceampamp
Iampamamppassionateampaboutamptheampmeaningfulamppossibilitiesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampInamprespectampofampmyampownamplimitationsampandampthoseampofampthisampworkamphoweverampIampwillampnotamp
claimampthatampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampareampfeasibleampwithinamptheampcontextampofampeveryamp
educationalampsettingampnorampthatampthisampwayampofampviewingampmakingampandampexperiencingampworksampofamp
artampisampmoreamporamplessampvalidampthanampothersampampRatherampIampsuggestamptheamppossibilityampofamplivingampinamp
possibilitiesampasampaampwayamptoampcultivateampmeaningfulampencountersampwithinampartampandampartamp
educationamp
Data(
amp ForampthisampresearchampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponampthreeampformsampofampdataamp
participantampsurveysampcaseampstudiesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampandampreflectiveamppracticeamp
formsampofampartmakingampallampcollectedampduringampaampfourltmonthampperiodampampToampgatherampparticipantamp
responsesampfromamptheampsurveysampandampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampreliedamponampaampmultitudeampofamp
friendsamppeersampandampcolleaguesampampIampconnectedampwithamptheampmajorityampofamptheseampindividualsamp
duringamporampasampaampresultampofampmyampexperiencesampatampDAAPampampampIampusedamp37ampsurveyampresponsesampaboutamp
listeningampexperiencesampwithampaampparticipantampageamprangeampofamp14amptoamp47ampampParticipantsamp
educationalamplevelsampspannedamphighampschoolamptoampgraduateampschoolampampIamppersonallyampsolicitedamptheamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 9amp
majorityampofamptheamplisteningampsurveysampatamptheampcollegeamplevelampandampaboveampampTheampbulkampofamptheamphighamp
schoolltagedampresponsesampwereampsolicitedampbyampmyampcolleagueampaampphotographyampteacherampatampaamp
Cincinnatiltareaamphighampschoolamp
amp Iampconductedampfiveampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampexperiencesampwithampsixampindividualsampasamp
partampofampthisampresearchampagainampusingampmanyampofamptheamppersonalampandampprofessionalampconnectionsamp
cultivatedampthroughamptheampDAAPampprogramampampIampdeliberatelyampchoseamppeopleampwithampwhomampIamphadamp
variousamplevelsampandamptypesampofamprelationshipsampampIampwillampspeakampmoreampinltdepthampaboutamptheseamp
experiencesampasampwellampasampexploreamptheampsurveyampresponsesampinamptheampResearchampMethodologyamp
andampMethodsampsectionamp
amp Lastlyamptheampdevelopmentampofampanampartmakingamppracticeampwasampessentialamptoampmyampownamp
personalampunderstandingampofamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatampcomposedampmyampresearchamp
ReadersampwillampnoticeampthatampimagesampareampembeddedampinampthisamptextampampTheseampareampimagesampofamptheamp
resultingampproductsampofampaamppracticeampofampunderstandingampthroughampmakingampampIampwillampdiscussamp
themampthroughoutampvariousampsectionsampofampthisamppaperampampamp
Dear(Reader(The(Structure(of(this(Research(Paper(
DearampReader(s)amp
amp Letampmeampbreakampforampaampmomentampfromampstandardampacademicamprhetoricampbeforeampthisamp
paperampreallyampgetsampstartedampampIampknowampwhatampyoureampthinkingltltnineamppagesampinampandampthisamppaperamp
hasntampevenampstartedampyetampampAlasampthisampsectionampisampmyamponeampofampmyampfavoriteampandampmostampoftlt
skimmedamppassagesampofampanampacademicamppaperamptheampstructureampofamptheamppaperampampThisampisamptheamppartamp
whereamptheampwriterampsaysampwhatampshesampaboutamptoampsayampbeforeampsheampsaysampitampampampItsampanamp
organizationalampstrategyampandampitsampthrillingampampLuckilyampforampyouampniceamppersonampwhoampisamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 10amp
readingampthisamppaperampIamphaveampprovidedampaamptranslationampfromampthisamptextsamporiginalampAcademiaamp
intoampnormalltpeopleltlanguageamp
amp Theampstructureampofampthisamppaperampisampasampfollowsampamp(Im-about-to-tell-you-whats-in-this-
long-ass-paper)ampampFirstlyamppleaseampnoteampthatampIampuseamptheamptermampthreadampinamplieuampofampchapteramp
asampanamporganizationalampstructureampIamppreferamptheampformerampbecauseampofamphowampitsampconceptualamp
qualitiesamprelateamptoampmyampworkampamp(Thread-is-awesome-and-you-can-do-tons-of-stuff-with-it-
like-sew-knot-tie-weave-etc--Chapters-are-not-nearly-as-exciting)--Iampwillampfirstampshareamp
myampresearchersampreflexiveampnarrativeampamp(I-made-up-a-cool-story-about-this-project-to-
describe-where-it-all-came-from)ampampThenampIampshallampofferampaampdescriptionampofamptheampqualitiesampofampaamp
creativeltlisteningampspaceampamp(Yes-I-shall)ampampIampwillampdiscussamptheampliteratureampthatampinformsamptheamp
backboneampofampmyampresearchampGadamersamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamp
practicesampandampGendlinsamptheampfeltampsenseampamp(Like-a-typical-graduate-student-I-have-done-
an-insane-amount-of-reading-during-the-past-two-academic-years--A-significant-
portion-of-this-reading-has-been-dedicated-to-those-topics--Dont-ask-me-to-type-them-
out-again-because-Im-seriously-done)ampampTheseampsectionsampbeginampwithampaamppassageampderivedamp
fromampsurveyampresponsesampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampamp(I-got-a-bunch-of-people-to-fill-
out-surveys-for-this-research-and-then-I-put-those-responses-in-my-paper)ampampTheseamp
experiencesampwithamplisteningampwereampprovidedampbyampresearchampparticipantsampamp(Super-nice-
people-I-know-and-some-I-dont-helped-me-out)ampampTheyampareampthereamptoampgroundamptheamp
conceptualampframeworksampinamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampamp(This-basically-means-
none-of-this-research-is-worth-shit-unless-it-can-be-used-in-the-real-world((I-hope-youll-
agree)ampampIampwillampthenampshareampmyampresearchampmethodologyampandampmethodsampamp(Im-going-to-tell-
you-about-how-and-why-I-did-this-project-in-using-big-smart(sounding-words)ampampLastlyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 11amp
Iampwillampconcludeampwithamppossibilitiesampforampthisampresearchampamp(Ill-figure-out-what-I-learned-and-
share-it-with-you-my-new-best-friend-who-made-it-all-the-way-to-the-conclusions-
section)ampampInampthisamppaperampreadersampwillampnoticeamptransparentampimagesampinteractingampwithamptheamp
textampamp(Its-my-art-on-transparent-sheets-in-this-very-paper)ampampTheseampareampworksampofampartamp
thatampIampcreatedamptoampgroundamptheampresearchampinampaamppracticeampofampmakingamptheyampareamptheampphysicalamp
embodimentampofampconceptualampideasampandamptheyampareampalwaysamppresentamptoamptheampresearchampamp
(Research-papers-with-pictures-are-much-more-tolerable-am-I-right)amp
amp Hereampweampgoamp
amp
thread2(
Collaging(Experience1(
amp ImagineampthatampyouampareampanampartistampseatedampatampyourampstudioamptableampampYouamphaveamp
everythingampyouampneedampampTheamproomampisampquietampsaveampforamptheampmuffledampsoundsampofampaampdistantamp
outsideampworldampampYouampsurveyamptheampcollectionampofampimagesampyouamphaveampgatheredamparoundampyouampamp
OnampyouramprightampisampaampraggedamppageampfromampanampoldampsketchbookampampGlossyampjewellttonedampswatchesamp
fromampaampdiscardedampfashionampmagazineampareampstackedampupampglisteningampinamptheamplightampampMonthsamp
agoampyouamppickedampupampaamphandfulampofampblackampandampwhiteampphotosampfromampaampsecondhandampstoreamp
todayamppastyampfacesampofamptheampunknownampsubjectsampstareampthroughampyouampblanklyampampAamppaleampyellowamp
scrapampofampleftoverampfabricampisampdrapedampoveramplastampweeksamppleatedamptoltdoamplistampampTheseampandamptwoamp
dozenampotherampscrapsamppiecesamppilesampandampcrumbsampareampyouramptoolsamptodayampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampamp1ampThisampsectionampisampsupposedamptoampbeampmyampresearchersampreflexiveampnarrativeampaamppassageampaboutampwhereampmyampresearchampideasampcameampfromltltandampinampfactampcollageampisampactuallyampwhereampthisampideaampcomesampfromampampOneampofamptheampfirstampresearchampinterestsampIampdiscussedampwithampmyampprofessorampDrampKristopherampHollandampwasamplayersampbothampphysicalampandampconceptualampampHeampwasamplikeampOhampampYoureamptalkingampaboutamphermeneuticsampSoampinampaampwayampthisampresearchampprojectampbothampbeganampandampconcludedamp(moreamponampthatamplater)ampwithampideasampofamplayeringampandampcollageampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 12amp
amp TheampresidueampthatampclingsamptoamptheseampscrapsampisampexperienceampampTheampoldampsketchbookamp
pageampisampanampimageampofampaampwomansamplegamprenderedampwithampchunkyamppencilampstrokesampampYouampmadeampitamp
whenampyouampwereamplivingampinampyourampoldampapartmentampoverlookingamptheampsquareampampItsampaampwomansamp
footampbutampitampremindsampyouampofamphavingampaamproommateampandampaampgrayampfutonampandampaampsummerampthatamp
wasampdesperatelyamphotampampItampisamponlyamppencilamponamppaperampbutampitampremindsampyouampofamptheampgreenamp
grassyampcenterampinamptheampmedianampofamptheampstreetampampOneamppencilampdrawingampofampaampwomansamplegamp
remindsampyouampofampthatampoldamplifeampandamptheampversionampofampyourselfampyouampwereampthenampitampisamptheampfirstamp
dominoampinampaampseriesampofampcascadingampdetailsampandampmemoriesampamp
amp EachampfragmentampsittingamponampyourampstudioamptableamphasampaampstoryampampEachampcameampfromampaamp
placeampandampwasamptouchedampbyampanotheramphumanampampEachampisampembeddedampwithampexperienceampcoloramp
memoryamptextureampandampinfiniteampdetailampbyamptheampmereampfactampofampitsampownampexistenceampamp
amp YouampbeginamptoamppickampapartamptheampephemeraampampYouampalternateampbeingampcarefulampandamp
carelessamp
amp Cuttingamptearingampburningampstretchingampfoldingampwhitewashingamprippingampcreasingamp
sewingampwritingamppaintingampencasingampfasteningampfillingampsoakingampdyeingampwashingamp
dryingampbitingampscratchingamppryingampyankingampsmoothingampsandingamppokingampstabbingamp
stretchingampfryingampheatingampdustingampcleaningampsculptingampslicingampdicingamppunchingamp
floatingamptwistingampflippingampdrippingampstaplingampstrippingampstripingamppatterningamp
designingampdrawingampsketchingampliftingampcollectingamptapingampgluingampbuttoningampknottingamp
weavingampknittingamp
amp YouampdoampallampofamptheseampthingsampandampprobablyampmanyampotherampthingsampampTheampfragmentsamponamp
youramptableampchangeampshapeampandampgetampsmallerampampFromamptheseamppiecesampyouampbeginamptoampbuildamp
somethingampampThisampsomethingampisampbothampnewampandampoldampampJuxtapositionsampbloomampnewamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 13amp
connectionsampareampfusedampbyamptheampweightampofamppreviousampexperienceampampPastampandamppresentamp
liquefyampintoampendlesslyampcirculatingamppossibilitiesampampYouampcouldamptheoreticallyampcontinueampthisamp
processampofamplayeringampandampreconstructionampforeverampamptheamponlyamplimitsampareampyourampownamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 14amp
thread3(
what(is(a(creative=listening(space(
ampampampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeamplisteningampspaceampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampwhatampdoesampitampsoundampsmellamptasteampfeelamplikeampampampampampampampwhatampampisampamptheampamptextureampampofampampthisampampamp
spaceampampampanswerampmoreampquestionsampampamp specificsampandampgeneralizationsampareampbothampimpossibleampampmaybeampaampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampgoodampstartampwouldampbeampthisampampamp amp amp amp amp safeampampampamp amp amp amp amp foldedampampamp amp amp amp amp amp embodiedampamp layeredampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampconnectedampampampamp amp ampamp
(it-might--be-like-gently-holding-on-to--
a-knot-of-questions)-amp
ampampampampampampampampampamp
(possible)ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 15amp
thread4amp(
Review(of(Literature((
( AnampexplorationampofampGadamerrsquosamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampeducationalampcontextsampandampGendlinrsquosamptheoryampofampfeltampsenseampwereampintegralamptoamp
theampcreationampofamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampWhileampcompellingampconstructsamponamp
theirampownampwhenampdrawnamptogetheramptheseampphilosophicalampperspectivesampvibrateamp
holisticallyamptoampsuggestampintriguingamppossibilitiesampforamptheampuseampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
inampartsampeducationampampInampthisampsectionampIampreviewamptheampliteratureampandampconnectamptheampvariousamp
pointsampofampstudyampampamp
Hermeneutics(amp(the(Fusion(of(Horizons((
It-actually-feels-really-great-knowing-that-other-people-will-enjoy-the-art-you-created-and-knowing-they-know-your-reasoning-and-story-behind-it--Honestly-you-cant-know-if-your-words-are-getting-through-to-them-but-the-cool-thing-about-art-is-that-it-can-be-
interpreted-in-so-many-different-ways---(Survey-response-EK-age-15)-
ampamp Hermeneuticsampwhichamphasampitsamprootsampinamptextualampinterpretationampcanampbeampdefinedampasamp
aamptraditionampofampthinkingamporampofampphilosophicalampreflectionampthatamptriesamptoampclarifyamptheampconceptamp
ofampverstehenampthatampisampunderstandingamp(Brunsamp1992)ampampRicoeuramp(19691974)ampexplainsamp
thatamptheampkeyamphypothesisampofamphermeneuticampphilosophyampisampthatampinterpretationampisampanampopenamp
processampwhichampnoampsingleampvisionampcanampconcludeamp(pamp109)ampampWithampthisampinampmindampIampwillamp
exploreamphermeneuticsampasampitampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp HansltGeorgampGadameramp(1900lt2002)ampinvestigatesampaampmoderateampformampofamp
hermeneuticsampthatampisampparticularlyamprelevantampinampserviceamptoampartampeducationampampGadameramp
breaksampwithamphermeneuticamptraditionampbyampproposingampthatampthereampisampnoampabsolutelyampobjectiveamp
interpretationampreadersampareampnotampableamptoampescapeamptheampprejudicesampofamptheiramptimeamp(Gallagheramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 16amp
1992)ampampThisamphoweverampbecomesampanampopportunityampforamptheampcreationampofampmeaningampInampaamp
passageampthatampechoesamptheampendlesslyampunfoldingampnatureampofampcollageampCaputoamp(2000)amprefersamp
toampanampexchangeampbetweenamppastampandamppresentampinamptheampcreativeamppossibilitiesampofamphermeneuticamp
interpretationamp
amp Thereampisampaamprichnessampinamphistoricalampeventsampthatampjustampkeepsampunfoldingampwhichampisamp
amp certainlyampnotampgraspedampbyamptheamporiginalampprotagonistsampwhichampgraduallyampunfoldsamp
amp overamptheampcourseampofamptimeampandampwhichampisampinampprincipleampneverampfullyampunfoldedampItampisamp
amp anampexcessampwhichampkeepsampspillingampoveramp(pamp47)amp
amp Gadamersampphilosophyampofamphermeneuticampunderstandingampisampformedampthroughamphisamp
notionsampaboutamplanguageampdialogueampandampconversationamp(Caputoamp2000ampSeebohmamp2004)ampamp
InampadditionamptoampGadamersampimplicitamprelianceamponamplisteningampasampheampdiscussesampdialogueamphisamp
workampcapitalizesamponamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampinamplanguageamp(Heelanamp1985)ampmakingamphisamp
formampofamphermeneuticsampparticularlyampapplicableamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp Gadamersamptermampfusion-of-horizonsamprefersamptoamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampwithinampaamp
varietyampofampencountersampampAampfusionampofamphorizonsampcanampbeampdescribedampasampaampdialogicamp
conversationampbetweenampreaderampandamptextamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampWithinamptheamptextualamp
paradigmampGadamerampbelievesampthatampaampwrittenamptextampisampopenamptoampanampinvisibleampandampindefiniteamp
readerampwhoampentersampintoampanampunknownampadventureampofamptheamptextamp(Ricoeuramp2013amppamp13)ampamp
Theamphorizonampitselfampisamptheamprangeampofampvisionampthatampincludesampeverythingampthatampcanampbeampseenamp
fromampaampparticularampvantageamppointamp(Gadameramp2004amppamp301)ampampLikeampcollageamptheampfusionampofamp
horizonsampisampaampprocessampcomposedampofamppastampandamppresentampwhichampareampopenamptoampandampinfinitelyamp
effectedampbyampeachampotheramp(Bourgeoisamp2007)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 17amp
amp Similarampconnectionsampcanampbeampdrawnampwhenampviewerampandampartworkampareampsubstitutedamp
forampreaderampandamptextampampInterpretationampandampunderstandingampbecomeampanampentwinedamp
creativeampendeavorampinampwhichamptheampviewerampparticipatesampasampmuchampasamptheampcreatorampbyamp
constructingampmeaningamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampPalmeramp(1969)ampalludesamptoamptheamppluralityampofamp
meaningampinampstatingampthatamptoampfocusamppurelyamponamptheamppositivityampofampwhatampaamptextampexplicitlyamp
saysampisamptoampdoampanampinjusticeamptoamptheamphermeneuticalamptaskamp(pamp234)ampampToampfocusamponampwhatampisamp
explicitampinampaampcollageampworkampwouldampbeamptoampdisregardamptheampconnectionsampandampcontradictionsamp
ofamptheampwholeampinampfavorampofampaampdirectampreadingampofamptheampindividualamppartsampthusampmissingampoutamponamp
otheramppossibleampdimensionsampofampmeaningamp
amp Theampkeyamptoamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampeducationampinamptextampandampbetweenamp
individualsampisamptheampabilityamptoamplistenampwithampopennessampampDefensiveamplisteningampisampaampwayampofamp
listeningampwithoutampopennessampitampisampaampwayampofampprotectingampourampsmallampversionampofamptheampworldamp
andampavoidingampmoralampclaimsamponampourselvesamp(Levinamp1989amppamp79)ampampLevinamp(1989)amp
discussesampplayfulamplisteningamp(pamp233)ampasampaampwayampofampcounteractingampdefensiveamplisteningampampamp
Bohmamp(1996)ampdiscussesampsuspendingampassumptionsampaampprocessampofampattendingamptoamp
assumptionsampratherampthanamprepressingampthemamporampcarryingampthemampoutampampNicholamp(1996)amp
explainsampaampcircumstanceampinampwhichampyouampencounterampaamppersonampyouampfeelampisampanampidiotampampampYouamp
wouldamprefrainampfromampsayingampsoampoutamploudampbutampyouampwouldampalsoamprefrainampfromampscoldingamp
yourselfampforampthisampthoughtampratherampyouampwouldampseeampthisampreactionampwithoutampfullyampengagingamp
withampitampampSimilarampsuggestionsamplikeampbracketingampofampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampareamp
discussedampinamptheampfollowingampsectionampamp
amp Gadamerampbelievesamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampwhatampallowsamptheampselfamptoampapproachamp
theampotherampitampisampaampprocessampinampwhichamptheampideasampofamptheampotherampbecomeamponesampownamp(Caputoamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 18amp
2000)ampampThisampisamphardlyampanampuncommonampexperienceampampInampfactampweampregularlyampencounteramptheamp
fusionampofamphorizonsampbyampintegratingamppastampunderstandingsampwithampcurrentampexperiencesampaamp
processampundoubtedlyampcomparableamptoampeducationamp(Zuckertamp2002)ampamp
amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsamplikeampeducationampcanampbeampfrustratingampandampemotionalamp
becauseampeachamphighlight[s]amptheampfinitudeampofamptheampinterpreterampandamptheamplimitationsampofamphisamp
understandingamp(Bourgeoisamp2007amppamp79)ampampTheamptermampsharesampsimilaritiesampwithamptheamp
problematic-momentampaamppedagogicalamptermampreferringamptoampaampbreachampinampaampdominantampgroupsamp
discourseampduringampwhichampsomethingamprepressedamparisesamp(KentampampampCummingamp2008)ampampKentamp
andampCummingamp(2008)ampexploreamptheampproblematicampmomentampasampaampdiscursiveampsiteampforamp
examiningampprejudiceampwithinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampandampitsamp
moreamppoliticallyampchargedampcounterpartamptheampproblematicampmomentampbothampexploreamp
Gadamersamp(1996)ampampassertionampthatamptheampotherampmayampnotamponlyamphaveampaamprightampbutampmayamp
actuallyampbeamprightampmayampunderstandampsomethingampbetterampthanampweampdoamp(pamp82)ampampAampcreativelt
listeningampspaceamplivesampinampthisamppossibilityampampamp
amp Lastlyamprelayingampofampappropriateampexpectationsamptoampparticipantsampisampaampnecessaryamp
featureampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampdemandingampampItamp
requiresampparticipantsampwhoampareampawareampofamptheamprisksampandamphardshipsamptoampenterampintoampitampampItamp
isamptheampresponsibilityampofamptheampeducatoramporampgroupampleaderamptoampmakeamptheseampexpectationsamp
knownampasampwellampasamptoampmodelampthisampbehaviorampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionamphermeneuticallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Areampopenamptoamppossibilitiesampandamptoamptheampotherampbull Conceiveampofampthemselvesampasampengagingampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamptheamprisksampinvolvedampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamplimitationsampofamptheirampunderstandingamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 19amp
Dialogic(Practices(-
I-felt-that-everyone-was-open-and-interested-in-what-I-had-to-say---Perhaps-I-felt-this-sense-of-understanding-due-to-the-nature-of-the-discussion((-
it-felt-[like]-more-[of]-a-dialogue-as-opposed-to-a-standard-critique-(Survey-response-MW-age-22)-
(amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampartampeducationampreliesamponampanampopenampdialogueampduringamp
experiencesampwithampartampselfampandampothersampampWhatampIampfoundamplackingampinamphermeneuticsamp
howeverampwasampaampdiscussionampofamptheamphowltlthowampisamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampachievedampandamp
howampdoampindividualsampmeaningfullyampengageampwithampeachampotherampampInampanampeffortamptoampclarifyampthisamp
Iampwillampdiscussampdialogicamppracticesampasamptheyamprelateamptoampmeaningfulampverbalampexchangesampandamp
listeningampencountersampinamptheampclassroomampandampstudioampamongstampstudentsamptheiramppeersampandamp
educatorsamp
amp Communicatingampthroughamplanguageampandampdialogueampisamphowampweampcoltconstructamp
worldsampwithampourselvesampandampothersampnotampjustampthroughampanampactampofamptransmissionampbutamp
becauseampourampcommunicativeampactsampgiveampbirthamptoampworldsamp(Lipariamp2014amppamp507)ampampSableamp
(2014)ampdescribesampdialogueampasampaampgenerativeampinterchangeampbetweenampparticipantsampasamp
opposedamptoampanampexchangeampofampviewsampwhereampindividualsampsimplyampadvocateamptheiramppositionsamp
(pamp8)ampampForampBohmamp(1996)ampitampisampaampstreamampofampmeaningampflowingampamongampandampthroughampusamp
(pamp6)ampampTheampnatureampofampdialogueampandampconversationampisampinherentlyampunplannedampampThisamp
dimensionampofampconversationampisampimportantamptoampGadameramp(2004)ampwhoampfindsampthatamp
participantsampinvolvedampinampconversationampareamplessamptheampleadersampofampitampthanamptheampledamp(pamp
385)ampampSableamp(2014)ampechoesampthisampbyampwritingampthatamptheampmostampimportantamppartsampofampanyamp
conversationampareampthoseampthatampneitheramppartyampcouldamphaveampimaginedampbeforeampstartingamp(pamp
8)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 20amp
amp Theseampareampnotionsampofampdialogueampamongampothersampthatampfindampaampparallelampinamptheamp
creativeampprocessampampFairfieldamp(2011)ampwritesampthatampinampprincipleampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinamp
dialogueamp(pamp83)ampaampsentimentampthatampalignsampwithampaampcommonampissueampencounteredampduringamp
theampcreativeampprocessltltnotampknowingampwhenampaamppieceampisampdoneampampAampquoteampoftenampattributedamp
toampLeonardoampdaampVinciampspeaksamptoampthisampideaampArtampisampneverampfinishedamponlyampabandonedampamp
Snowberamp(2007)ampdrawsampparallelsampbetweenampmentorshipampdialogueampandamptheampcreativeamp
processampfindingampthatampdeepamplisteningamppracticesampconnectampallampthreeampampSheampfindsampthatamptheamp
taskampofamptheampmentorampisamptheampsameampasamptheamptaskampofamptheampartistampthatampisamptoampbringampoutamptheamp
naturalampqualitiesampofamptheampstudentamporamptheampmediumampampSnowberamp(2007)ampcommentsamponampanamp
ideaampwellltknownampamongampartistsampwhichampisampthatampaampworkampofampartamphasampaamplifeampofampitsampownampthisamp
notionampisampreminiscentampofampGadamersampstatementampaboutampbeingampledampbyampconversationamp
ampamp Dialogicamppracticesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampeducationampemphasizeampaamp
phenomenologicalampdimensionamprequiringamptwoampthingsampfromampparticipantsampampFirstlyamp
participantsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampmustampfindampvalueampinamplisteningamptoamptheamp
narrativesampofamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampampTheseampparticipantsampknowampthatampeducationamp
isampforemostampaboutamptestimonyampaboutampsharingamptheampexperienceampofampbeingamphumanampsharingamp
lifeampconvictionsampandampknowledge((Wiercinskiamp2011amppamp109)ampampNarrativesampareamp
conceivedampofampasampaampwayampofamphumanampknowingamp(Vitanovaamp2010amppamp29)ampthatampmakesamptheamp
selfampampSecondlyampwhenamplisteningamptoamptheampnarrativesampofampothersampparticipantsampareampexpectedamp
toampbracketamptheirampownampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsamp(LindsethampampampNorbergamp2004)ampampThisamp
encouragesamplistenersamptoampexperienceampandampfindampmeaningampinamptheampnarrativesampofampothersamp
whileampfreeingamptheampspeakerampfromamptheampfearampofampbeingampjudgedampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 21amp
amp Bracketingampjudgmentampandampconclusionampisampaamppotentialamptoolampwithinamptheampcommonamp
artampeducationamppracticeampofampgroupampcritiquesampampElkinsamp(2001)ampfindsampthatamppeopleampwhoamphaveamp
experienceampinampartampjudgeampveryampquicklyampandampmostampteachersampwillamphaveampaampprovisionalamp
opinionampaboutampaampworkampinamptheampfirstamptenampsecondsamp(pamp121)ampampBracketingampconclusionampandamp
judgmentampisampparticularlyampimportantampforampeducatorsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
whoseampvolumeampofampviewingampexperiencesampcouldampleadamptoampeasyampassumptionsampwhenamp
encounteringampaampnewampworkampampamp
amp Elkinsamp(2001)ampdiscussesampthatampcritiquesampcanampalsoampbeampseenampasampexchangesampofamp
storiesamporampcollaborativeampstorytellingamp(pamp145)ampwhichampisampyetampanotherampwayampofamptalkingamp
aboutamppossibilitiesampforampdialogueampandampnarrativeampwithinampartampeducationampampElkinsamphoweveramp
findsampstorytellingamplimitingamponceamptheampdeeperampnarrativesampareampdiscoveredamp(2001amppamp
145)ampampThisampimpliesampthatampheampfindsamponlyampaampsingularampmeaningampandamponeampthatampisampnotamp
necessarilyampusefulampforampcollaborativeampgroupampcritiquesamp
amp Insteadampparticipantsampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampbringampknowledgeampofamp
polysemyamptoampcollaborativeampcritiqueampexperiencesampasampwellampasamptoampexperiencesampofampmakingamp
artworkampampAccordingamptoampMuldoonamp(2002)amppolysemyampisamptheampqualityampofampaampwordamporampotheramp
languageampunitampthatampcanampbearampmultipleampmeaningsamp(asampcitedampinampWorsleyamp2012amppamp308)ampampamp
Aamptextualampexampleampofampthisampisamptheampmultipleampmeaningsampofamptheampwordampcan-Iampcanampdriveampaampcaramp
Idamplikeampaampcan-ofampsodaampheampwasntampworkingampveryamphardampsoampIamphadamptoampcan-himamp(Munozamp
2014)ampampampButampifampweampconsideramppolysemyampmetaphoricallyamporampvisuallyamptheampideaampthatampaamp
singleampunitampimageamporampintentionampcouldampbearampmultipleampmeaningsampcouldampbeampproductiveampinamp
creatingltlisteningampspacesampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 22amp
amp Thisampunfoldingampofampmeaningampworksampwellampinamptheampcontextampofampcollageampandampdialogueamp
asampwellampasamphermeneuticsampampInampfactamphermeneuticsampimpliesamppolysemyampbecauseampofampitsamp
notionampthatampitampisampalwaysampaamppossibilityampofampmyampunderstandingampthatampisampplayedampoutampwhenampIamp
understandampaamptextamp(Grondinamp2002amppamp38)ampampPolysemyampcouldampbeampconceptualizedampasampanamp
alternativeampexplorationampofampmeaningampthatampfunctionsampcollaborativelyampwithinampcritiquesampamp
Forampexampleampeducatorsampcanampaskampstudentsamptoamprespondamptoampaampworkampthroughampcollageamp
journalampentriesampmusicampfilmampasampindividualsamporampinampgroupsampampKnowledgeampofamppolysemyamp
couldampalsoampbeampusedampasampaamptoolampforampcreatingampimagesampthatamprecognizesampaamprelationshipamp
betweenamptheampvisualamptheamplinguisticampandamptheampmultipleamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionampdialogicallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Placeampvalueamponampexperientialampnarrativesampbull Practiceamplisteningampbyampbracketingampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampbull Embraceamppolysemicampexplorationsampofampmeaningampamp
Contemplative(Practices(
I-knew-I-was-being-heard-because-of-her-mannerisms-and-the-look-on-her-face--She-was-calm-attentive-and-not-trying-to-jump-in-and-offer-any-advice--She-asked-questions-that-pointed-to-things-I-had-not-openly-articulated-because-of-uncertainty--
This-was-one-of-the-ways-I-knew-I-was-being-heard-(Survey-response-LS-age-27)-
(amp Ifamphermeneuticsampandampdialogicamppracticesampgiveampusamptheampbroadampstrokesampofampactivityampinamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampcontemplativeamppracticesampseekamptoamptuneampstudentsampandamp
educatorsampintoampnuanceampdeliberationampandampdeepampexplorationampampThisampisampaampmostlyamp
individualampinternalamppursuitampthatampfocusesamponampformsampofampselfltlisteningampbutampcontemplativeamp
practicesampareampalsoampformedampbyampanampawarenessampofampinterconnectednessamp
amp InamppursuitampofampcriticalampthinkingampSableamp(2014)ampoutlinesampaampsetampofampcontemplativeamp
practicesampforampstudentsampthatampincludeampmindfulampmeditationampstructuredampcontemplationamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 23amp
journalampwritingampmindfulamplisteningampreflectiveampinquiryampandampdialogueamp(pamp4)ampampWhileamp
Sablesamp(2014)ampmethodampforampcontemplativeamppracticesampprovidesampaampconcreteampframeworkamp
withampspecificampstepsampmanyampofamptheseampconceptsampcouldampbeampappliedampwithoutampsuchampaamp
prescribedampstructureampampForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwillampbeamp
primarilyampdiscussingampSablesampconceptsampofampstructuredampcontemplationampreflectiveamp
inquiryampandampjournalampwritingamp
amp ForampSableamp(2014)ampstructuredampcontemplationampisampaampformampofampbeingamppresentampandamp
focusedamponampaampparticularampquestionampstatementamporampimageampampWithinampthisampmodeampofampinquiryamp
participantsampareampexpectedamptoampholdamptheampobjectampofampcontemplationampinamptheirampmindsamp
deepeningampunderstandingampasamptheyampfocusampwithoutampanalyzingampitamporampmanipulatingampitampinamp
anyampwayamp(pamp5)ampampThisamppracticeampdrawsampcomparisonsamptoamptheampbracketingampofampjudgmentsamp
andampconclusionsampsupportedampinamptheamppreviousampsectionampbutampstructuredampcontemplationamp
occursamponampanampindividualamplevelampratherampthanampdialogicallyamp
amp Reflectiveampinquiryampbearsampsomeampsimilaritiesamptoampstructuredampcontemplationampbutamp
Sableamp(2014)amppositionsampitampasampanampactivityampbetweenamptwoampindividualsampaamplistenerampandampaamp
speakerampampTheamplistenerampisampagainampaskedamptoampsuspendampjudgmentampbutampalsoamptoampengageampinampaamp
formampofampcuriosityampinampwhichampinnocentampquestionsampareampaskedampinamporderamptoampgainamp
understandingampampSableamp(2014)ampcontrastsampinnocentampquestionsampwithampleadingampquestionsampamp
ForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwouldampcharacterizeampthisampinnocentamp
questioningampasampaampformampofampopenltendedampquestioningampampSableamp(2014)ampidentifiesampanamp
exampleampofampanampinnocentamp(orampopenltended)ampquestionampWhatampdidampyouampmeanampwhenampyouamp
saidamp________ampConverselyampaampleadingampquestionampisampDidampyouampmeanamptoampsayamp________ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 24amp
amp Sableamp(2014)ampusesampjournalampwritingampasampaamppieceampofamphisamplargerampstructureampofamp
contemplativeamppracticesampbutampjournalampwritingampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampcouldamp
potentiallyampoccupyampaampsignificantamproleampampIampconceiveampofampjournalampwritingampinampmyampownamp
creativeamppracticeampasampaampformampofampdocumentationampthatampmakesampmeampmoreampawareampofampmyamp
creativeampprocessamptheampemotionalamphabitsampthatampsurroundampitampandamptheampthemesampthatamp
structureampmyampworkampampIampconceptualizeampthisampwayampofampwritingampasampaampformampofampselfltlisteningamp
relatedamptoampaampkeyampconceptampofamphermeneuticsampfoundampinampGadamersampassertionampthatampallamp
educationampisampaampformampofampselflteducationamp(Grondinamp2011)ampampamp
amp Germeraadamp(2013)ampusesampjournalampwritingamptoampexploreamptheampemotionalampandamprationalamp
relationshipsamptoamphisampcreativeampprocessampparallelamptoampexecutingampaampnewampbodyampofampworkampampHeamp
findsampthatampwritingampduringamphisampprocessampisampaamptoolamptoampunderstandamp[his]amppsycheamptoampeaseamp
theamppainampthatampanampartisticampprocessampcanampbringampandamptoamprelieveampartisticampblocksamp
(Germeraadamp2013amppamp21)ampultimatelyampdeclaringampthatampitamphelpsamphimamptoampbetterampunderstandamp
hisampworkampampInampaampstyleampofampwritingampthatamposcillatesamparoundampjournalingampdocumentationampandamp
poetryampdeampCossonamp(2002)ampexploresamphisampoverlappingamprolesampasampanampartistampresearcherampandamp
teacherampampOtherampartistsampbluramptheamplineampbetweenampartamppracticeampdocumentationampandamplifeamp
furtherampstillampbyampofferingampdocumentationampasampartamplikeampSophieampCalleamp(Calleamp2011amp2008amp
2005)ampandampMaryampKellyamp(1973lt1979)ampampamp
amp Karpiakamp(2003)ampestablishesampcontemplativeamppracticesampfromamptheampperspectiveampofamp
theampeducatorampaskingampthemamptoampmineamptheampsubtleamp(pamp71)ampusingampattentivenessamp
attunementampamplificationampandampassociationampampTheseampexercisesampinampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampsetamptheamptoneampasampwellampasampprovideampaampmodelampofampbehaviorampforampotherampparticipantsamp
withinamptheampspaceampampKarpiakamp(2003)ampoutlinesampactivitiesampthatampeducatorsampcanampuseamptoampdrawamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 25amp
outampandamputilizeamptheseampsubtleampsensationsampinamptheampserviceampofamptransformativeamplearningamp(pamp
68)ampampamp
amp ForampKarpiakamp(2003)ampattentivenessamprequiresampawarenessamptoampverbalampandamp
nonverbalampcuesampasampwellampasampanampawarenessampofampwhatampisamphappeningampamongampandampwithinamptheamp
studentsampandamptheampeducatorampampAttunementamprequiresampanampeducatoramptoamporientampherselfamptoamptheamp
otherampandamptoampadoptampanampattitudeampofampunhurriednessampofamppatienceampandampofamphumilityamp
concerningampbothamptheampprocessampandamptheampoutcomesampofamptheampteachingamp(Karpiakamp2003amppgamp
72)ampampAmplificationampisampaampprocessampofamphonoringampcommunicationampthatampcentersamponamptheampideaamp
ofamphearingamponeselfampintoampknowingampitampincludesampusingampparaphrasingampandampclarificationamp
activitiesamptoampgainampinsightampintoampmeaningampampLastlyampassociationampentailsampidentifyingamp
patternsampandampweavingampthemamptogetherampwithampstudentampexperienceampclassroomampdiscussionamp
andamptheampideasampofampothersamp
amp TuningampintoampsubtletyampimpliesampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceampampTheampmanifestationsamp
ofampsilenceampinamptheampclassroomampareampendlessampandampitsampvalueampisamptooampgreatamptoampbeampignoredampwhileamp
tooampvastamptoampbeampfullyampabsorbedampampLevinamp(1989)ampremarksampthatampsilenceampisampaampclearingampwhereamp
thereampisampnothingampforamphearingamptoampholdamponamptoampinampwhichampmanyampfindampunbearableampanxietyamp
(pamp79)ampampNearlyampallampofampusamphaveampexperiencedampthisampunbearableampanxietyampaampstrainampofamp
whichampcanampbeampfoundampinampeducationalampcontextsampdueamptoamptheampfactampthatampclassroomsampareamp
oftenampstructuredamparoundampimplicitampandampexplicitamprulesampaboutamptalkampandampsilenceamp(Schultzamp
2010amppamp2848)ampampForampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampanampawarenessampofampsilenceampimplicatesamp
whatampisampleftampunsaidampandampwhatampisampunsayableltltespeciallyampimportantampbecauseampofamptheamp
unsayableampqualityampofampartworksampampForampSchultzamp(2010)ampsilenceampimpliesamppossibilityamp
becauseampitampcanampholdampmultipleampmeaningsampforampindividualsampwithinampandampacrossampracialamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 26amp
ethnicampandampculturalampgroupsamp(pamp2833)ampampLevinamp(1989)ampfindsampthatamptoamplistenamptoamp
somethingampweampmustampfirstampgive-itampourampsilenceamp(pamp232)ampampThisamppracticeampofampgivingampsilenceamp
isampparticularlyamphelpfulampinamptermsampofampviewingamporamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartamp
amp Gradleamp(2011)ampoutlinesampaamppracticalampvisionampforampviewingampartampthatamprequiresamp
silenceampandampdeliberationampampForamptheamppurposesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampwouldamp
reconceptualizeampthisampasampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampampGradleamp(2011)ampinstructedamp
herampstudentsamptoampspendamptimeampwithampaampworkampofampartampoutsideampofamptheirampeverydayampworldviewamp
attentivelyampviewingampitampforampaboutamptenampminutesampeverydayampforampaampweekampampAfterampeachampviewingamp
experienceamptheampstudentsampwroteampinamptheirampjournalsampampTheampresultsampindicatedampthatampthisamp
processampofampsustainedampsilentampdeliberationampcoupledampwithampanampengagementampofamptheiramp
intuitiveampperceptionsampaboutampartworkampleftampstudentsampfeelingampempoweredamptoampengageampinamp
discussionampandampappreciateampunfamiliarampartampformsampampThisampactivityampisampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoamp
aampworkampofampartampthatampincorporatesampSablesamp(2014)ampconceptampofampstructuredampcontemplationampamp
Weavingampaamprelationshipampbetweenampsilenceampcontemplationampandampattentivenessampisampaamp
significantampendeavorampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
Contemplativeamppracticesampfunctionampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Engageampinampformsampofampviewingampwritingampandampexperiencingampthatamphonorampselfltlisteningamp
bull Attuneamptoampsubtletyampandampnuanceampbull Listenampandampviewampdeliberatelyampbull Cultivateampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceamp(
The(Felt(Sense(
When-someone-understands-what-I-am-talking-about-when-I-talk-about-art-I-am-delighted--Art-is-my-everything--Its-my-passion--When-someone-understands-that-I-
am-instantly-filled-with-joy--That-tells-me-someone-gets-it-(Survey-response-CTF-age-16)-
(
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 9amp
majorityampofamptheamplisteningampsurveysampatamptheampcollegeamplevelampandampaboveampampTheampbulkampofamptheamphighamp
schoolltagedampresponsesampwereampsolicitedampbyampmyampcolleagueampaampphotographyampteacherampatampaamp
Cincinnatiltareaamphighampschoolamp
amp Iampconductedampfiveampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampexperiencesampwithampsixampindividualsampasamp
partampofampthisampresearchampagainampusingampmanyampofamptheamppersonalampandampprofessionalampconnectionsamp
cultivatedampthroughamptheampDAAPampprogramampampIampdeliberatelyampchoseamppeopleampwithampwhomampIamphadamp
variousamplevelsampandamptypesampofamprelationshipsampampIampwillampspeakampmoreampinltdepthampaboutamptheseamp
experiencesampasampwellampasampexploreamptheampsurveyampresponsesampinamptheampResearchampMethodologyamp
andampMethodsampsectionamp
amp Lastlyamptheampdevelopmentampofampanampartmakingamppracticeampwasampessentialamptoampmyampownamp
personalampunderstandingampofamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatampcomposedampmyampresearchamp
ReadersampwillampnoticeampthatampimagesampareampembeddedampinampthisamptextampampTheseampareampimagesampofamptheamp
resultingampproductsampofampaamppracticeampofampunderstandingampthroughampmakingampampIampwillampdiscussamp
themampthroughoutampvariousampsectionsampofampthisamppaperampampamp
Dear(Reader(The(Structure(of(this(Research(Paper(
DearampReader(s)amp
amp Letampmeampbreakampforampaampmomentampfromampstandardampacademicamprhetoricampbeforeampthisamp
paperampreallyampgetsampstartedampampIampknowampwhatampyoureampthinkingltltnineamppagesampinampandampthisamppaperamp
hasntampevenampstartedampyetampampAlasampthisampsectionampisampmyamponeampofampmyampfavoriteampandampmostampoftlt
skimmedamppassagesampofampanampacademicamppaperamptheampstructureampofamptheamppaperampampThisampisamptheamppartamp
whereamptheampwriterampsaysampwhatampshesampaboutamptoampsayampbeforeampsheampsaysampitampampampItsampanamp
organizationalampstrategyampandampitsampthrillingampampLuckilyampforampyouampniceamppersonampwhoampisamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 10amp
readingampthisamppaperampIamphaveampprovidedampaamptranslationampfromampthisamptextsamporiginalampAcademiaamp
intoampnormalltpeopleltlanguageamp
amp Theampstructureampofampthisamppaperampisampasampfollowsampamp(Im-about-to-tell-you-whats-in-this-
long-ass-paper)ampampFirstlyamppleaseampnoteampthatampIampuseamptheamptermampthreadampinamplieuampofampchapteramp
asampanamporganizationalampstructureampIamppreferamptheampformerampbecauseampofamphowampitsampconceptualamp
qualitiesamprelateamptoampmyampworkampamp(Thread-is-awesome-and-you-can-do-tons-of-stuff-with-it-
like-sew-knot-tie-weave-etc--Chapters-are-not-nearly-as-exciting)--Iampwillampfirstampshareamp
myampresearchersampreflexiveampnarrativeampamp(I-made-up-a-cool-story-about-this-project-to-
describe-where-it-all-came-from)ampampThenampIampshallampofferampaampdescriptionampofamptheampqualitiesampofampaamp
creativeltlisteningampspaceampamp(Yes-I-shall)ampampIampwillampdiscussamptheampliteratureampthatampinformsamptheamp
backboneampofampmyampresearchampGadamersamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamp
practicesampandampGendlinsamptheampfeltampsenseampamp(Like-a-typical-graduate-student-I-have-done-
an-insane-amount-of-reading-during-the-past-two-academic-years--A-significant-
portion-of-this-reading-has-been-dedicated-to-those-topics--Dont-ask-me-to-type-them-
out-again-because-Im-seriously-done)ampampTheseampsectionsampbeginampwithampaamppassageampderivedamp
fromampsurveyampresponsesampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampamp(I-got-a-bunch-of-people-to-fill-
out-surveys-for-this-research-and-then-I-put-those-responses-in-my-paper)ampampTheseamp
experiencesampwithamplisteningampwereampprovidedampbyampresearchampparticipantsampamp(Super-nice-
people-I-know-and-some-I-dont-helped-me-out)ampampTheyampareampthereamptoampgroundamptheamp
conceptualampframeworksampinamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampamp(This-basically-means-
none-of-this-research-is-worth-shit-unless-it-can-be-used-in-the-real-world((I-hope-youll-
agree)ampampIampwillampthenampshareampmyampresearchampmethodologyampandampmethodsampamp(Im-going-to-tell-
you-about-how-and-why-I-did-this-project-in-using-big-smart(sounding-words)ampampLastlyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 11amp
Iampwillampconcludeampwithamppossibilitiesampforampthisampresearchampamp(Ill-figure-out-what-I-learned-and-
share-it-with-you-my-new-best-friend-who-made-it-all-the-way-to-the-conclusions-
section)ampampInampthisamppaperampreadersampwillampnoticeamptransparentampimagesampinteractingampwithamptheamp
textampamp(Its-my-art-on-transparent-sheets-in-this-very-paper)ampampTheseampareampworksampofampartamp
thatampIampcreatedamptoampgroundamptheampresearchampinampaamppracticeampofampmakingamptheyampareamptheampphysicalamp
embodimentampofampconceptualampideasampandamptheyampareampalwaysamppresentamptoamptheampresearchampamp
(Research-papers-with-pictures-are-much-more-tolerable-am-I-right)amp
amp Hereampweampgoamp
amp
thread2(
Collaging(Experience1(
amp ImagineampthatampyouampareampanampartistampseatedampatampyourampstudioamptableampampYouamphaveamp
everythingampyouampneedampampTheamproomampisampquietampsaveampforamptheampmuffledampsoundsampofampaampdistantamp
outsideampworldampampYouampsurveyamptheampcollectionampofampimagesampyouamphaveampgatheredamparoundampyouampamp
OnampyouramprightampisampaampraggedamppageampfromampanampoldampsketchbookampampGlossyampjewellttonedampswatchesamp
fromampaampdiscardedampfashionampmagazineampareampstackedampupampglisteningampinamptheamplightampampMonthsamp
agoampyouamppickedampupampaamphandfulampofampblackampandampwhiteampphotosampfromampaampsecondhandampstoreamp
todayamppastyampfacesampofamptheampunknownampsubjectsampstareampthroughampyouampblanklyampampAamppaleampyellowamp
scrapampofampleftoverampfabricampisampdrapedampoveramplastampweeksamppleatedamptoltdoamplistampampTheseampandamptwoamp
dozenampotherampscrapsamppiecesamppilesampandampcrumbsampareampyouramptoolsamptodayampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampamp1ampThisampsectionampisampsupposedamptoampbeampmyampresearchersampreflexiveampnarrativeampaamppassageampaboutampwhereampmyampresearchampideasampcameampfromltltandampinampfactampcollageampisampactuallyampwhereampthisampideaampcomesampfromampampOneampofamptheampfirstampresearchampinterestsampIampdiscussedampwithampmyampprofessorampDrampKristopherampHollandampwasamplayersampbothampphysicalampandampconceptualampampHeampwasamplikeampOhampampYoureamptalkingampaboutamphermeneuticsampSoampinampaampwayampthisampresearchampprojectampbothampbeganampandampconcludedamp(moreamponampthatamplater)ampwithampideasampofamplayeringampandampcollageampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 12amp
amp TheampresidueampthatampclingsamptoamptheseampscrapsampisampexperienceampampTheampoldampsketchbookamp
pageampisampanampimageampofampaampwomansamplegamprenderedampwithampchunkyamppencilampstrokesampampYouampmadeampitamp
whenampyouampwereamplivingampinampyourampoldampapartmentampoverlookingamptheampsquareampampItsampaampwomansamp
footampbutampitampremindsampyouampofamphavingampaamproommateampandampaampgrayampfutonampandampaampsummerampthatamp
wasampdesperatelyamphotampampItampisamponlyamppencilamponamppaperampbutampitampremindsampyouampofamptheampgreenamp
grassyampcenterampinamptheampmedianampofamptheampstreetampampOneamppencilampdrawingampofampaampwomansamplegamp
remindsampyouampofampthatampoldamplifeampandamptheampversionampofampyourselfampyouampwereampthenampitampisamptheampfirstamp
dominoampinampaampseriesampofampcascadingampdetailsampandampmemoriesampamp
amp EachampfragmentampsittingamponampyourampstudioamptableamphasampaampstoryampampEachampcameampfromampaamp
placeampandampwasamptouchedampbyampanotheramphumanampampEachampisampembeddedampwithampexperienceampcoloramp
memoryamptextureampandampinfiniteampdetailampbyamptheampmereampfactampofampitsampownampexistenceampamp
amp YouampbeginamptoamppickampapartamptheampephemeraampampYouampalternateampbeingampcarefulampandamp
carelessamp
amp Cuttingamptearingampburningampstretchingampfoldingampwhitewashingamprippingampcreasingamp
sewingampwritingamppaintingampencasingampfasteningampfillingampsoakingampdyeingampwashingamp
dryingampbitingampscratchingamppryingampyankingampsmoothingampsandingamppokingampstabbingamp
stretchingampfryingampheatingampdustingampcleaningampsculptingampslicingampdicingamppunchingamp
floatingamptwistingampflippingampdrippingampstaplingampstrippingampstripingamppatterningamp
designingampdrawingampsketchingampliftingampcollectingamptapingampgluingampbuttoningampknottingamp
weavingampknittingamp
amp YouampdoampallampofamptheseampthingsampandampprobablyampmanyampotherampthingsampampTheampfragmentsamponamp
youramptableampchangeampshapeampandampgetampsmallerampampFromamptheseamppiecesampyouampbeginamptoampbuildamp
somethingampampThisampsomethingampisampbothampnewampandampoldampampJuxtapositionsampbloomampnewamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 13amp
connectionsampareampfusedampbyamptheampweightampofamppreviousampexperienceampampPastampandamppresentamp
liquefyampintoampendlesslyampcirculatingamppossibilitiesampampYouampcouldamptheoreticallyampcontinueampthisamp
processampofamplayeringampandampreconstructionampforeverampamptheamponlyamplimitsampareampyourampownamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 14amp
thread3(
what(is(a(creative=listening(space(
ampampampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeamplisteningampspaceampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampwhatampdoesampitampsoundampsmellamptasteampfeelamplikeampampampampampampampwhatampampisampamptheampamptextureampampofampampthisampampamp
spaceampampampanswerampmoreampquestionsampampamp specificsampandampgeneralizationsampareampbothampimpossibleampampmaybeampaampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampgoodampstartampwouldampbeampthisampampamp amp amp amp amp safeampampampamp amp amp amp amp foldedampampamp amp amp amp amp amp embodiedampamp layeredampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampconnectedampampampamp amp ampamp
(it-might--be-like-gently-holding-on-to--
a-knot-of-questions)-amp
ampampampampampampampampampamp
(possible)ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 15amp
thread4amp(
Review(of(Literature((
( AnampexplorationampofampGadamerrsquosamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampeducationalampcontextsampandampGendlinrsquosamptheoryampofampfeltampsenseampwereampintegralamptoamp
theampcreationampofamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampWhileampcompellingampconstructsamponamp
theirampownampwhenampdrawnamptogetheramptheseampphilosophicalampperspectivesampvibrateamp
holisticallyamptoampsuggestampintriguingamppossibilitiesampforamptheampuseampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
inampartsampeducationampampInampthisampsectionampIampreviewamptheampliteratureampandampconnectamptheampvariousamp
pointsampofampstudyampampamp
Hermeneutics(amp(the(Fusion(of(Horizons((
It-actually-feels-really-great-knowing-that-other-people-will-enjoy-the-art-you-created-and-knowing-they-know-your-reasoning-and-story-behind-it--Honestly-you-cant-know-if-your-words-are-getting-through-to-them-but-the-cool-thing-about-art-is-that-it-can-be-
interpreted-in-so-many-different-ways---(Survey-response-EK-age-15)-
ampamp Hermeneuticsampwhichamphasampitsamprootsampinamptextualampinterpretationampcanampbeampdefinedampasamp
aamptraditionampofampthinkingamporampofampphilosophicalampreflectionampthatamptriesamptoampclarifyamptheampconceptamp
ofampverstehenampthatampisampunderstandingamp(Brunsamp1992)ampampRicoeuramp(19691974)ampexplainsamp
thatamptheampkeyamphypothesisampofamphermeneuticampphilosophyampisampthatampinterpretationampisampanampopenamp
processampwhichampnoampsingleampvisionampcanampconcludeamp(pamp109)ampampWithampthisampinampmindampIampwillamp
exploreamphermeneuticsampasampitampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp HansltGeorgampGadameramp(1900lt2002)ampinvestigatesampaampmoderateampformampofamp
hermeneuticsampthatampisampparticularlyamprelevantampinampserviceamptoampartampeducationampampGadameramp
breaksampwithamphermeneuticamptraditionampbyampproposingampthatampthereampisampnoampabsolutelyampobjectiveamp
interpretationampreadersampareampnotampableamptoampescapeamptheampprejudicesampofamptheiramptimeamp(Gallagheramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 16amp
1992)ampampThisamphoweverampbecomesampanampopportunityampforamptheampcreationampofampmeaningampInampaamp
passageampthatampechoesamptheampendlesslyampunfoldingampnatureampofampcollageampCaputoamp(2000)amprefersamp
toampanampexchangeampbetweenamppastampandamppresentampinamptheampcreativeamppossibilitiesampofamphermeneuticamp
interpretationamp
amp Thereampisampaamprichnessampinamphistoricalampeventsampthatampjustampkeepsampunfoldingampwhichampisamp
amp certainlyampnotampgraspedampbyamptheamporiginalampprotagonistsampwhichampgraduallyampunfoldsamp
amp overamptheampcourseampofamptimeampandampwhichampisampinampprincipleampneverampfullyampunfoldedampItampisamp
amp anampexcessampwhichampkeepsampspillingampoveramp(pamp47)amp
amp Gadamersampphilosophyampofamphermeneuticampunderstandingampisampformedampthroughamphisamp
notionsampaboutamplanguageampdialogueampandampconversationamp(Caputoamp2000ampSeebohmamp2004)ampamp
InampadditionamptoampGadamersampimplicitamprelianceamponamplisteningampasampheampdiscussesampdialogueamphisamp
workampcapitalizesamponamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampinamplanguageamp(Heelanamp1985)ampmakingamphisamp
formampofamphermeneuticsampparticularlyampapplicableamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp Gadamersamptermampfusion-of-horizonsamprefersamptoamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampwithinampaamp
varietyampofampencountersampampAampfusionampofamphorizonsampcanampbeampdescribedampasampaampdialogicamp
conversationampbetweenampreaderampandamptextamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampWithinamptheamptextualamp
paradigmampGadamerampbelievesampthatampaampwrittenamptextampisampopenamptoampanampinvisibleampandampindefiniteamp
readerampwhoampentersampintoampanampunknownampadventureampofamptheamptextamp(Ricoeuramp2013amppamp13)ampamp
Theamphorizonampitselfampisamptheamprangeampofampvisionampthatampincludesampeverythingampthatampcanampbeampseenamp
fromampaampparticularampvantageamppointamp(Gadameramp2004amppamp301)ampampLikeampcollageamptheampfusionampofamp
horizonsampisampaampprocessampcomposedampofamppastampandamppresentampwhichampareampopenamptoampandampinfinitelyamp
effectedampbyampeachampotheramp(Bourgeoisamp2007)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 17amp
amp Similarampconnectionsampcanampbeampdrawnampwhenampviewerampandampartworkampareampsubstitutedamp
forampreaderampandamptextampampInterpretationampandampunderstandingampbecomeampanampentwinedamp
creativeampendeavorampinampwhichamptheampviewerampparticipatesampasampmuchampasamptheampcreatorampbyamp
constructingampmeaningamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampPalmeramp(1969)ampalludesamptoamptheamppluralityampofamp
meaningampinampstatingampthatamptoampfocusamppurelyamponamptheamppositivityampofampwhatampaamptextampexplicitlyamp
saysampisamptoampdoampanampinjusticeamptoamptheamphermeneuticalamptaskamp(pamp234)ampampToampfocusamponampwhatampisamp
explicitampinampaampcollageampworkampwouldampbeamptoampdisregardamptheampconnectionsampandampcontradictionsamp
ofamptheampwholeampinampfavorampofampaampdirectampreadingampofamptheampindividualamppartsampthusampmissingampoutamponamp
otheramppossibleampdimensionsampofampmeaningamp
amp Theampkeyamptoamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampeducationampinamptextampandampbetweenamp
individualsampisamptheampabilityamptoamplistenampwithampopennessampampDefensiveamplisteningampisampaampwayampofamp
listeningampwithoutampopennessampitampisampaampwayampofampprotectingampourampsmallampversionampofamptheampworldamp
andampavoidingampmoralampclaimsamponampourselvesamp(Levinamp1989amppamp79)ampampLevinamp(1989)amp
discussesampplayfulamplisteningamp(pamp233)ampasampaampwayampofampcounteractingampdefensiveamplisteningampampamp
Bohmamp(1996)ampdiscussesampsuspendingampassumptionsampaampprocessampofampattendingamptoamp
assumptionsampratherampthanamprepressingampthemamporampcarryingampthemampoutampampNicholamp(1996)amp
explainsampaampcircumstanceampinampwhichampyouampencounterampaamppersonampyouampfeelampisampanampidiotampampampYouamp
wouldamprefrainampfromampsayingampsoampoutamploudampbutampyouampwouldampalsoamprefrainampfromampscoldingamp
yourselfampforampthisampthoughtampratherampyouampwouldampseeampthisampreactionampwithoutampfullyampengagingamp
withampitampampSimilarampsuggestionsamplikeampbracketingampofampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampareamp
discussedampinamptheampfollowingampsectionampamp
amp Gadamerampbelievesamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampwhatampallowsamptheampselfamptoampapproachamp
theampotherampitampisampaampprocessampinampwhichamptheampideasampofamptheampotherampbecomeamponesampownamp(Caputoamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 18amp
2000)ampampThisampisamphardlyampanampuncommonampexperienceampampInampfactampweampregularlyampencounteramptheamp
fusionampofamphorizonsampbyampintegratingamppastampunderstandingsampwithampcurrentampexperiencesampaamp
processampundoubtedlyampcomparableamptoampeducationamp(Zuckertamp2002)ampamp
amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsamplikeampeducationampcanampbeampfrustratingampandampemotionalamp
becauseampeachamphighlight[s]amptheampfinitudeampofamptheampinterpreterampandamptheamplimitationsampofamphisamp
understandingamp(Bourgeoisamp2007amppamp79)ampampTheamptermampsharesampsimilaritiesampwithamptheamp
problematic-momentampaamppedagogicalamptermampreferringamptoampaampbreachampinampaampdominantampgroupsamp
discourseampduringampwhichampsomethingamprepressedamparisesamp(KentampampampCummingamp2008)ampampKentamp
andampCummingamp(2008)ampexploreamptheampproblematicampmomentampasampaampdiscursiveampsiteampforamp
examiningampprejudiceampwithinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampandampitsamp
moreamppoliticallyampchargedampcounterpartamptheampproblematicampmomentampbothampexploreamp
Gadamersamp(1996)ampampassertionampthatamptheampotherampmayampnotamponlyamphaveampaamprightampbutampmayamp
actuallyampbeamprightampmayampunderstandampsomethingampbetterampthanampweampdoamp(pamp82)ampampAampcreativelt
listeningampspaceamplivesampinampthisamppossibilityampampamp
amp Lastlyamprelayingampofampappropriateampexpectationsamptoampparticipantsampisampaampnecessaryamp
featureampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampdemandingampampItamp
requiresampparticipantsampwhoampareampawareampofamptheamprisksampandamphardshipsamptoampenterampintoampitampampItamp
isamptheampresponsibilityampofamptheampeducatoramporampgroupampleaderamptoampmakeamptheseampexpectationsamp
knownampasampwellampasamptoampmodelampthisampbehaviorampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionamphermeneuticallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Areampopenamptoamppossibilitiesampandamptoamptheampotherampbull Conceiveampofampthemselvesampasampengagingampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamptheamprisksampinvolvedampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamplimitationsampofamptheirampunderstandingamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 19amp
Dialogic(Practices(-
I-felt-that-everyone-was-open-and-interested-in-what-I-had-to-say---Perhaps-I-felt-this-sense-of-understanding-due-to-the-nature-of-the-discussion((-
it-felt-[like]-more-[of]-a-dialogue-as-opposed-to-a-standard-critique-(Survey-response-MW-age-22)-
(amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampartampeducationampreliesamponampanampopenampdialogueampduringamp
experiencesampwithampartampselfampandampothersampampWhatampIampfoundamplackingampinamphermeneuticsamp
howeverampwasampaampdiscussionampofamptheamphowltlthowampisamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampachievedampandamp
howampdoampindividualsampmeaningfullyampengageampwithampeachampotherampampInampanampeffortamptoampclarifyampthisamp
Iampwillampdiscussampdialogicamppracticesampasamptheyamprelateamptoampmeaningfulampverbalampexchangesampandamp
listeningampencountersampinamptheampclassroomampandampstudioampamongstampstudentsamptheiramppeersampandamp
educatorsamp
amp Communicatingampthroughamplanguageampandampdialogueampisamphowampweampcoltconstructamp
worldsampwithampourselvesampandampothersampnotampjustampthroughampanampactampofamptransmissionampbutamp
becauseampourampcommunicativeampactsampgiveampbirthamptoampworldsamp(Lipariamp2014amppamp507)ampampSableamp
(2014)ampdescribesampdialogueampasampaampgenerativeampinterchangeampbetweenampparticipantsampasamp
opposedamptoampanampexchangeampofampviewsampwhereampindividualsampsimplyampadvocateamptheiramppositionsamp
(pamp8)ampampForampBohmamp(1996)ampitampisampaampstreamampofampmeaningampflowingampamongampandampthroughampusamp
(pamp6)ampampTheampnatureampofampdialogueampandampconversationampisampinherentlyampunplannedampampThisamp
dimensionampofampconversationampisampimportantamptoampGadameramp(2004)ampwhoampfindsampthatamp
participantsampinvolvedampinampconversationampareamplessamptheampleadersampofampitampthanamptheampledamp(pamp
385)ampampSableamp(2014)ampechoesampthisampbyampwritingampthatamptheampmostampimportantamppartsampofampanyamp
conversationampareampthoseampthatampneitheramppartyampcouldamphaveampimaginedampbeforeampstartingamp(pamp
8)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 20amp
amp Theseampareampnotionsampofampdialogueampamongampothersampthatampfindampaampparallelampinamptheamp
creativeampprocessampampFairfieldamp(2011)ampwritesampthatampinampprincipleampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinamp
dialogueamp(pamp83)ampaampsentimentampthatampalignsampwithampaampcommonampissueampencounteredampduringamp
theampcreativeampprocessltltnotampknowingampwhenampaamppieceampisampdoneampampAampquoteampoftenampattributedamp
toampLeonardoampdaampVinciampspeaksamptoampthisampideaampArtampisampneverampfinishedamponlyampabandonedampamp
Snowberamp(2007)ampdrawsampparallelsampbetweenampmentorshipampdialogueampandamptheampcreativeamp
processampfindingampthatampdeepamplisteningamppracticesampconnectampallampthreeampampSheampfindsampthatamptheamp
taskampofamptheampmentorampisamptheampsameampasamptheamptaskampofamptheampartistampthatampisamptoampbringampoutamptheamp
naturalampqualitiesampofamptheampstudentamporamptheampmediumampampSnowberamp(2007)ampcommentsamponampanamp
ideaampwellltknownampamongampartistsampwhichampisampthatampaampworkampofampartamphasampaamplifeampofampitsampownampthisamp
notionampisampreminiscentampofampGadamersampstatementampaboutampbeingampledampbyampconversationamp
ampamp Dialogicamppracticesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampeducationampemphasizeampaamp
phenomenologicalampdimensionamprequiringamptwoampthingsampfromampparticipantsampampFirstlyamp
participantsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampmustampfindampvalueampinamplisteningamptoamptheamp
narrativesampofamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampampTheseampparticipantsampknowampthatampeducationamp
isampforemostampaboutamptestimonyampaboutampsharingamptheampexperienceampofampbeingamphumanampsharingamp
lifeampconvictionsampandampknowledge((Wiercinskiamp2011amppamp109)ampampNarrativesampareamp
conceivedampofampasampaampwayampofamphumanampknowingamp(Vitanovaamp2010amppamp29)ampthatampmakesamptheamp
selfampampSecondlyampwhenamplisteningamptoamptheampnarrativesampofampothersampparticipantsampareampexpectedamp
toampbracketamptheirampownampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsamp(LindsethampampampNorbergamp2004)ampampThisamp
encouragesamplistenersamptoampexperienceampandampfindampmeaningampinamptheampnarrativesampofampothersamp
whileampfreeingamptheampspeakerampfromamptheampfearampofampbeingampjudgedampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 21amp
amp Bracketingampjudgmentampandampconclusionampisampaamppotentialamptoolampwithinamptheampcommonamp
artampeducationamppracticeampofampgroupampcritiquesampampElkinsamp(2001)ampfindsampthatamppeopleampwhoamphaveamp
experienceampinampartampjudgeampveryampquicklyampandampmostampteachersampwillamphaveampaampprovisionalamp
opinionampaboutampaampworkampinamptheampfirstamptenampsecondsamp(pamp121)ampampBracketingampconclusionampandamp
judgmentampisampparticularlyampimportantampforampeducatorsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
whoseampvolumeampofampviewingampexperiencesampcouldampleadamptoampeasyampassumptionsampwhenamp
encounteringampaampnewampworkampampamp
amp Elkinsamp(2001)ampdiscussesampthatampcritiquesampcanampalsoampbeampseenampasampexchangesampofamp
storiesamporampcollaborativeampstorytellingamp(pamp145)ampwhichampisampyetampanotherampwayampofamptalkingamp
aboutamppossibilitiesampforampdialogueampandampnarrativeampwithinampartampeducationampampElkinsamphoweveramp
findsampstorytellingamplimitingamponceamptheampdeeperampnarrativesampareampdiscoveredamp(2001amppamp
145)ampampThisampimpliesampthatampheampfindsamponlyampaampsingularampmeaningampandamponeampthatampisampnotamp
necessarilyampusefulampforampcollaborativeampgroupampcritiquesamp
amp Insteadampparticipantsampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampbringampknowledgeampofamp
polysemyamptoampcollaborativeampcritiqueampexperiencesampasampwellampasamptoampexperiencesampofampmakingamp
artworkampampAccordingamptoampMuldoonamp(2002)amppolysemyampisamptheampqualityampofampaampwordamporampotheramp
languageampunitampthatampcanampbearampmultipleampmeaningsamp(asampcitedampinampWorsleyamp2012amppamp308)ampampamp
Aamptextualampexampleampofampthisampisamptheampmultipleampmeaningsampofamptheampwordampcan-Iampcanampdriveampaampcaramp
Idamplikeampaampcan-ofampsodaampheampwasntampworkingampveryamphardampsoampIamphadamptoampcan-himamp(Munozamp
2014)ampampampButampifampweampconsideramppolysemyampmetaphoricallyamporampvisuallyamptheampideaampthatampaamp
singleampunitampimageamporampintentionampcouldampbearampmultipleampmeaningsampcouldampbeampproductiveampinamp
creatingltlisteningampspacesampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 22amp
amp Thisampunfoldingampofampmeaningampworksampwellampinamptheampcontextampofampcollageampandampdialogueamp
asampwellampasamphermeneuticsampampInampfactamphermeneuticsampimpliesamppolysemyampbecauseampofampitsamp
notionampthatampitampisampalwaysampaamppossibilityampofampmyampunderstandingampthatampisampplayedampoutampwhenampIamp
understandampaamptextamp(Grondinamp2002amppamp38)ampampPolysemyampcouldampbeampconceptualizedampasampanamp
alternativeampexplorationampofampmeaningampthatampfunctionsampcollaborativelyampwithinampcritiquesampamp
Forampexampleampeducatorsampcanampaskampstudentsamptoamprespondamptoampaampworkampthroughampcollageamp
journalampentriesampmusicampfilmampasampindividualsamporampinampgroupsampampKnowledgeampofamppolysemyamp
couldampalsoampbeampusedampasampaamptoolampforampcreatingampimagesampthatamprecognizesampaamprelationshipamp
betweenamptheampvisualamptheamplinguisticampandamptheampmultipleamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionampdialogicallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Placeampvalueamponampexperientialampnarrativesampbull Practiceamplisteningampbyampbracketingampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampbull Embraceamppolysemicampexplorationsampofampmeaningampamp
Contemplative(Practices(
I-knew-I-was-being-heard-because-of-her-mannerisms-and-the-look-on-her-face--She-was-calm-attentive-and-not-trying-to-jump-in-and-offer-any-advice--She-asked-questions-that-pointed-to-things-I-had-not-openly-articulated-because-of-uncertainty--
This-was-one-of-the-ways-I-knew-I-was-being-heard-(Survey-response-LS-age-27)-
(amp Ifamphermeneuticsampandampdialogicamppracticesampgiveampusamptheampbroadampstrokesampofampactivityampinamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampcontemplativeamppracticesampseekamptoamptuneampstudentsampandamp
educatorsampintoampnuanceampdeliberationampandampdeepampexplorationampampThisampisampaampmostlyamp
individualampinternalamppursuitampthatampfocusesamponampformsampofampselfltlisteningampbutampcontemplativeamp
practicesampareampalsoampformedampbyampanampawarenessampofampinterconnectednessamp
amp InamppursuitampofampcriticalampthinkingampSableamp(2014)ampoutlinesampaampsetampofampcontemplativeamp
practicesampforampstudentsampthatampincludeampmindfulampmeditationampstructuredampcontemplationamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 23amp
journalampwritingampmindfulamplisteningampreflectiveampinquiryampandampdialogueamp(pamp4)ampampWhileamp
Sablesamp(2014)ampmethodampforampcontemplativeamppracticesampprovidesampaampconcreteampframeworkamp
withampspecificampstepsampmanyampofamptheseampconceptsampcouldampbeampappliedampwithoutampsuchampaamp
prescribedampstructureampampForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwillampbeamp
primarilyampdiscussingampSablesampconceptsampofampstructuredampcontemplationampreflectiveamp
inquiryampandampjournalampwritingamp
amp ForampSableamp(2014)ampstructuredampcontemplationampisampaampformampofampbeingamppresentampandamp
focusedamponampaampparticularampquestionampstatementamporampimageampampWithinampthisampmodeampofampinquiryamp
participantsampareampexpectedamptoampholdamptheampobjectampofampcontemplationampinamptheirampmindsamp
deepeningampunderstandingampasamptheyampfocusampwithoutampanalyzingampitamporampmanipulatingampitampinamp
anyampwayamp(pamp5)ampampThisamppracticeampdrawsampcomparisonsamptoamptheampbracketingampofampjudgmentsamp
andampconclusionsampsupportedampinamptheamppreviousampsectionampbutampstructuredampcontemplationamp
occursamponampanampindividualamplevelampratherampthanampdialogicallyamp
amp Reflectiveampinquiryampbearsampsomeampsimilaritiesamptoampstructuredampcontemplationampbutamp
Sableamp(2014)amppositionsampitampasampanampactivityampbetweenamptwoampindividualsampaamplistenerampandampaamp
speakerampampTheamplistenerampisampagainampaskedamptoampsuspendampjudgmentampbutampalsoamptoampengageampinampaamp
formampofampcuriosityampinampwhichampinnocentampquestionsampareampaskedampinamporderamptoampgainamp
understandingampampSableamp(2014)ampcontrastsampinnocentampquestionsampwithampleadingampquestionsampamp
ForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwouldampcharacterizeampthisampinnocentamp
questioningampasampaampformampofampopenltendedampquestioningampampSableamp(2014)ampidentifiesampanamp
exampleampofampanampinnocentamp(orampopenltended)ampquestionampWhatampdidampyouampmeanampwhenampyouamp
saidamp________ampConverselyampaampleadingampquestionampisampDidampyouampmeanamptoampsayamp________ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 24amp
amp Sableamp(2014)ampusesampjournalampwritingampasampaamppieceampofamphisamplargerampstructureampofamp
contemplativeamppracticesampbutampjournalampwritingampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampcouldamp
potentiallyampoccupyampaampsignificantamproleampampIampconceiveampofampjournalampwritingampinampmyampownamp
creativeamppracticeampasampaampformampofampdocumentationampthatampmakesampmeampmoreampawareampofampmyamp
creativeampprocessamptheampemotionalamphabitsampthatampsurroundampitampandamptheampthemesampthatamp
structureampmyampworkampampIampconceptualizeampthisampwayampofampwritingampasampaampformampofampselfltlisteningamp
relatedamptoampaampkeyampconceptampofamphermeneuticsampfoundampinampGadamersampassertionampthatampallamp
educationampisampaampformampofampselflteducationamp(Grondinamp2011)ampampamp
amp Germeraadamp(2013)ampusesampjournalampwritingamptoampexploreamptheampemotionalampandamprationalamp
relationshipsamptoamphisampcreativeampprocessampparallelamptoampexecutingampaampnewampbodyampofampworkampampHeamp
findsampthatampwritingampduringamphisampprocessampisampaamptoolamptoampunderstandamp[his]amppsycheamptoampeaseamp
theamppainampthatampanampartisticampprocessampcanampbringampandamptoamprelieveampartisticampblocksamp
(Germeraadamp2013amppamp21)ampultimatelyampdeclaringampthatampitamphelpsamphimamptoampbetterampunderstandamp
hisampworkampampInampaampstyleampofampwritingampthatamposcillatesamparoundampjournalingampdocumentationampandamp
poetryampdeampCossonamp(2002)ampexploresamphisampoverlappingamprolesampasampanampartistampresearcherampandamp
teacherampampOtherampartistsampbluramptheamplineampbetweenampartamppracticeampdocumentationampandamplifeamp
furtherampstillampbyampofferingampdocumentationampasampartamplikeampSophieampCalleamp(Calleamp2011amp2008amp
2005)ampandampMaryampKellyamp(1973lt1979)ampampamp
amp Karpiakamp(2003)ampestablishesampcontemplativeamppracticesampfromamptheampperspectiveampofamp
theampeducatorampaskingampthemamptoampmineamptheampsubtleamp(pamp71)ampusingampattentivenessamp
attunementampamplificationampandampassociationampampTheseampexercisesampinampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampsetamptheamptoneampasampwellampasampprovideampaampmodelampofampbehaviorampforampotherampparticipantsamp
withinamptheampspaceampampKarpiakamp(2003)ampoutlinesampactivitiesampthatampeducatorsampcanampuseamptoampdrawamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 25amp
outampandamputilizeamptheseampsubtleampsensationsampinamptheampserviceampofamptransformativeamplearningamp(pamp
68)ampampamp
amp ForampKarpiakamp(2003)ampattentivenessamprequiresampawarenessamptoampverbalampandamp
nonverbalampcuesampasampwellampasampanampawarenessampofampwhatampisamphappeningampamongampandampwithinamptheamp
studentsampandamptheampeducatorampampAttunementamprequiresampanampeducatoramptoamporientampherselfamptoamptheamp
otherampandamptoampadoptampanampattitudeampofampunhurriednessampofamppatienceampandampofamphumilityamp
concerningampbothamptheampprocessampandamptheampoutcomesampofamptheampteachingamp(Karpiakamp2003amppgamp
72)ampampAmplificationampisampaampprocessampofamphonoringampcommunicationampthatampcentersamponamptheampideaamp
ofamphearingamponeselfampintoampknowingampitampincludesampusingampparaphrasingampandampclarificationamp
activitiesamptoampgainampinsightampintoampmeaningampampLastlyampassociationampentailsampidentifyingamp
patternsampandampweavingampthemamptogetherampwithampstudentampexperienceampclassroomampdiscussionamp
andamptheampideasampofampothersamp
amp TuningampintoampsubtletyampimpliesampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceampampTheampmanifestationsamp
ofampsilenceampinamptheampclassroomampareampendlessampandampitsampvalueampisamptooampgreatamptoampbeampignoredampwhileamp
tooampvastamptoampbeampfullyampabsorbedampampLevinamp(1989)ampremarksampthatampsilenceampisampaampclearingampwhereamp
thereampisampnothingampforamphearingamptoampholdamponamptoampinampwhichampmanyampfindampunbearableampanxietyamp
(pamp79)ampampNearlyampallampofampusamphaveampexperiencedampthisampunbearableampanxietyampaampstrainampofamp
whichampcanampbeampfoundampinampeducationalampcontextsampdueamptoamptheampfactampthatampclassroomsampareamp
oftenampstructuredamparoundampimplicitampandampexplicitamprulesampaboutamptalkampandampsilenceamp(Schultzamp
2010amppamp2848)ampampForampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampanampawarenessampofampsilenceampimplicatesamp
whatampisampleftampunsaidampandampwhatampisampunsayableltltespeciallyampimportantampbecauseampofamptheamp
unsayableampqualityampofampartworksampampForampSchultzamp(2010)ampsilenceampimpliesamppossibilityamp
becauseampitampcanampholdampmultipleampmeaningsampforampindividualsampwithinampandampacrossampracialamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 26amp
ethnicampandampculturalampgroupsamp(pamp2833)ampampLevinamp(1989)ampfindsampthatamptoamplistenamptoamp
somethingampweampmustampfirstampgive-itampourampsilenceamp(pamp232)ampampThisamppracticeampofampgivingampsilenceamp
isampparticularlyamphelpfulampinamptermsampofampviewingamporamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartamp
amp Gradleamp(2011)ampoutlinesampaamppracticalampvisionampforampviewingampartampthatamprequiresamp
silenceampandampdeliberationampampForamptheamppurposesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampwouldamp
reconceptualizeampthisampasampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampampGradleamp(2011)ampinstructedamp
herampstudentsamptoampspendamptimeampwithampaampworkampofampartampoutsideampofamptheirampeverydayampworldviewamp
attentivelyampviewingampitampforampaboutamptenampminutesampeverydayampforampaampweekampampAfterampeachampviewingamp
experienceamptheampstudentsampwroteampinamptheirampjournalsampampTheampresultsampindicatedampthatampthisamp
processampofampsustainedampsilentampdeliberationampcoupledampwithampanampengagementampofamptheiramp
intuitiveampperceptionsampaboutampartworkampleftampstudentsampfeelingampempoweredamptoampengageampinamp
discussionampandampappreciateampunfamiliarampartampformsampampThisampactivityampisampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoamp
aampworkampofampartampthatampincorporatesampSablesamp(2014)ampconceptampofampstructuredampcontemplationampamp
Weavingampaamprelationshipampbetweenampsilenceampcontemplationampandampattentivenessampisampaamp
significantampendeavorampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
Contemplativeamppracticesampfunctionampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Engageampinampformsampofampviewingampwritingampandampexperiencingampthatamphonorampselfltlisteningamp
bull Attuneamptoampsubtletyampandampnuanceampbull Listenampandampviewampdeliberatelyampbull Cultivateampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceamp(
The(Felt(Sense(
When-someone-understands-what-I-am-talking-about-when-I-talk-about-art-I-am-delighted--Art-is-my-everything--Its-my-passion--When-someone-understands-that-I-
am-instantly-filled-with-joy--That-tells-me-someone-gets-it-(Survey-response-CTF-age-16)-
(
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 10amp
readingampthisamppaperampIamphaveampprovidedampaamptranslationampfromampthisamptextsamporiginalampAcademiaamp
intoampnormalltpeopleltlanguageamp
amp Theampstructureampofampthisamppaperampisampasampfollowsampamp(Im-about-to-tell-you-whats-in-this-
long-ass-paper)ampampFirstlyamppleaseampnoteampthatampIampuseamptheamptermampthreadampinamplieuampofampchapteramp
asampanamporganizationalampstructureampIamppreferamptheampformerampbecauseampofamphowampitsampconceptualamp
qualitiesamprelateamptoampmyampworkampamp(Thread-is-awesome-and-you-can-do-tons-of-stuff-with-it-
like-sew-knot-tie-weave-etc--Chapters-are-not-nearly-as-exciting)--Iampwillampfirstampshareamp
myampresearchersampreflexiveampnarrativeampamp(I-made-up-a-cool-story-about-this-project-to-
describe-where-it-all-came-from)ampampThenampIampshallampofferampaampdescriptionampofamptheampqualitiesampofampaamp
creativeltlisteningampspaceampamp(Yes-I-shall)ampampIampwillampdiscussamptheampliteratureampthatampinformsamptheamp
backboneampofampmyampresearchampGadamersamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamp
practicesampandampGendlinsamptheampfeltampsenseampamp(Like-a-typical-graduate-student-I-have-done-
an-insane-amount-of-reading-during-the-past-two-academic-years--A-significant-
portion-of-this-reading-has-been-dedicated-to-those-topics--Dont-ask-me-to-type-them-
out-again-because-Im-seriously-done)ampampTheseampsectionsampbeginampwithampaamppassageampderivedamp
fromampsurveyampresponsesampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampamp(I-got-a-bunch-of-people-to-fill-
out-surveys-for-this-research-and-then-I-put-those-responses-in-my-paper)ampampTheseamp
experiencesampwithamplisteningampwereampprovidedampbyampresearchampparticipantsampamp(Super-nice-
people-I-know-and-some-I-dont-helped-me-out)ampampTheyampareampthereamptoampgroundamptheamp
conceptualampframeworksampinamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampamp(This-basically-means-
none-of-this-research-is-worth-shit-unless-it-can-be-used-in-the-real-world((I-hope-youll-
agree)ampampIampwillampthenampshareampmyampresearchampmethodologyampandampmethodsampamp(Im-going-to-tell-
you-about-how-and-why-I-did-this-project-in-using-big-smart(sounding-words)ampampLastlyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 11amp
Iampwillampconcludeampwithamppossibilitiesampforampthisampresearchampamp(Ill-figure-out-what-I-learned-and-
share-it-with-you-my-new-best-friend-who-made-it-all-the-way-to-the-conclusions-
section)ampampInampthisamppaperampreadersampwillampnoticeamptransparentampimagesampinteractingampwithamptheamp
textampamp(Its-my-art-on-transparent-sheets-in-this-very-paper)ampampTheseampareampworksampofampartamp
thatampIampcreatedamptoampgroundamptheampresearchampinampaamppracticeampofampmakingamptheyampareamptheampphysicalamp
embodimentampofampconceptualampideasampandamptheyampareampalwaysamppresentamptoamptheampresearchampamp
(Research-papers-with-pictures-are-much-more-tolerable-am-I-right)amp
amp Hereampweampgoamp
amp
thread2(
Collaging(Experience1(
amp ImagineampthatampyouampareampanampartistampseatedampatampyourampstudioamptableampampYouamphaveamp
everythingampyouampneedampampTheamproomampisampquietampsaveampforamptheampmuffledampsoundsampofampaampdistantamp
outsideampworldampampYouampsurveyamptheampcollectionampofampimagesampyouamphaveampgatheredamparoundampyouampamp
OnampyouramprightampisampaampraggedamppageampfromampanampoldampsketchbookampampGlossyampjewellttonedampswatchesamp
fromampaampdiscardedampfashionampmagazineampareampstackedampupampglisteningampinamptheamplightampampMonthsamp
agoampyouamppickedampupampaamphandfulampofampblackampandampwhiteampphotosampfromampaampsecondhandampstoreamp
todayamppastyampfacesampofamptheampunknownampsubjectsampstareampthroughampyouampblanklyampampAamppaleampyellowamp
scrapampofampleftoverampfabricampisampdrapedampoveramplastampweeksamppleatedamptoltdoamplistampampTheseampandamptwoamp
dozenampotherampscrapsamppiecesamppilesampandampcrumbsampareampyouramptoolsamptodayampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampamp1ampThisampsectionampisampsupposedamptoampbeampmyampresearchersampreflexiveampnarrativeampaamppassageampaboutampwhereampmyampresearchampideasampcameampfromltltandampinampfactampcollageampisampactuallyampwhereampthisampideaampcomesampfromampampOneampofamptheampfirstampresearchampinterestsampIampdiscussedampwithampmyampprofessorampDrampKristopherampHollandampwasamplayersampbothampphysicalampandampconceptualampampHeampwasamplikeampOhampampYoureamptalkingampaboutamphermeneuticsampSoampinampaampwayampthisampresearchampprojectampbothampbeganampandampconcludedamp(moreamponampthatamplater)ampwithampideasampofamplayeringampandampcollageampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 12amp
amp TheampresidueampthatampclingsamptoamptheseampscrapsampisampexperienceampampTheampoldampsketchbookamp
pageampisampanampimageampofampaampwomansamplegamprenderedampwithampchunkyamppencilampstrokesampampYouampmadeampitamp
whenampyouampwereamplivingampinampyourampoldampapartmentampoverlookingamptheampsquareampampItsampaampwomansamp
footampbutampitampremindsampyouampofamphavingampaamproommateampandampaampgrayampfutonampandampaampsummerampthatamp
wasampdesperatelyamphotampampItampisamponlyamppencilamponamppaperampbutampitampremindsampyouampofamptheampgreenamp
grassyampcenterampinamptheampmedianampofamptheampstreetampampOneamppencilampdrawingampofampaampwomansamplegamp
remindsampyouampofampthatampoldamplifeampandamptheampversionampofampyourselfampyouampwereampthenampitampisamptheampfirstamp
dominoampinampaampseriesampofampcascadingampdetailsampandampmemoriesampamp
amp EachampfragmentampsittingamponampyourampstudioamptableamphasampaampstoryampampEachampcameampfromampaamp
placeampandampwasamptouchedampbyampanotheramphumanampampEachampisampembeddedampwithampexperienceampcoloramp
memoryamptextureampandampinfiniteampdetailampbyamptheampmereampfactampofampitsampownampexistenceampamp
amp YouampbeginamptoamppickampapartamptheampephemeraampampYouampalternateampbeingampcarefulampandamp
carelessamp
amp Cuttingamptearingampburningampstretchingampfoldingampwhitewashingamprippingampcreasingamp
sewingampwritingamppaintingampencasingampfasteningampfillingampsoakingampdyeingampwashingamp
dryingampbitingampscratchingamppryingampyankingampsmoothingampsandingamppokingampstabbingamp
stretchingampfryingampheatingampdustingampcleaningampsculptingampslicingampdicingamppunchingamp
floatingamptwistingampflippingampdrippingampstaplingampstrippingampstripingamppatterningamp
designingampdrawingampsketchingampliftingampcollectingamptapingampgluingampbuttoningampknottingamp
weavingampknittingamp
amp YouampdoampallampofamptheseampthingsampandampprobablyampmanyampotherampthingsampampTheampfragmentsamponamp
youramptableampchangeampshapeampandampgetampsmallerampampFromamptheseamppiecesampyouampbeginamptoampbuildamp
somethingampampThisampsomethingampisampbothampnewampandampoldampampJuxtapositionsampbloomampnewamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 13amp
connectionsampareampfusedampbyamptheampweightampofamppreviousampexperienceampampPastampandamppresentamp
liquefyampintoampendlesslyampcirculatingamppossibilitiesampampYouampcouldamptheoreticallyampcontinueampthisamp
processampofamplayeringampandampreconstructionampforeverampamptheamponlyamplimitsampareampyourampownamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 14amp
thread3(
what(is(a(creative=listening(space(
ampampampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeamplisteningampspaceampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampwhatampdoesampitampsoundampsmellamptasteampfeelamplikeampampampampampampampwhatampampisampamptheampamptextureampampofampampthisampampamp
spaceampampampanswerampmoreampquestionsampampamp specificsampandampgeneralizationsampareampbothampimpossibleampampmaybeampaampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampgoodampstartampwouldampbeampthisampampamp amp amp amp amp safeampampampamp amp amp amp amp foldedampampamp amp amp amp amp amp embodiedampamp layeredampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampconnectedampampampamp amp ampamp
(it-might--be-like-gently-holding-on-to--
a-knot-of-questions)-amp
ampampampampampampampampampamp
(possible)ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 15amp
thread4amp(
Review(of(Literature((
( AnampexplorationampofampGadamerrsquosamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampeducationalampcontextsampandampGendlinrsquosamptheoryampofampfeltampsenseampwereampintegralamptoamp
theampcreationampofamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampWhileampcompellingampconstructsamponamp
theirampownampwhenampdrawnamptogetheramptheseampphilosophicalampperspectivesampvibrateamp
holisticallyamptoampsuggestampintriguingamppossibilitiesampforamptheampuseampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
inampartsampeducationampampInampthisampsectionampIampreviewamptheampliteratureampandampconnectamptheampvariousamp
pointsampofampstudyampampamp
Hermeneutics(amp(the(Fusion(of(Horizons((
It-actually-feels-really-great-knowing-that-other-people-will-enjoy-the-art-you-created-and-knowing-they-know-your-reasoning-and-story-behind-it--Honestly-you-cant-know-if-your-words-are-getting-through-to-them-but-the-cool-thing-about-art-is-that-it-can-be-
interpreted-in-so-many-different-ways---(Survey-response-EK-age-15)-
ampamp Hermeneuticsampwhichamphasampitsamprootsampinamptextualampinterpretationampcanampbeampdefinedampasamp
aamptraditionampofampthinkingamporampofampphilosophicalampreflectionampthatamptriesamptoampclarifyamptheampconceptamp
ofampverstehenampthatampisampunderstandingamp(Brunsamp1992)ampampRicoeuramp(19691974)ampexplainsamp
thatamptheampkeyamphypothesisampofamphermeneuticampphilosophyampisampthatampinterpretationampisampanampopenamp
processampwhichampnoampsingleampvisionampcanampconcludeamp(pamp109)ampampWithampthisampinampmindampIampwillamp
exploreamphermeneuticsampasampitampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp HansltGeorgampGadameramp(1900lt2002)ampinvestigatesampaampmoderateampformampofamp
hermeneuticsampthatampisampparticularlyamprelevantampinampserviceamptoampartampeducationampampGadameramp
breaksampwithamphermeneuticamptraditionampbyampproposingampthatampthereampisampnoampabsolutelyampobjectiveamp
interpretationampreadersampareampnotampableamptoampescapeamptheampprejudicesampofamptheiramptimeamp(Gallagheramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 16amp
1992)ampampThisamphoweverampbecomesampanampopportunityampforamptheampcreationampofampmeaningampInampaamp
passageampthatampechoesamptheampendlesslyampunfoldingampnatureampofampcollageampCaputoamp(2000)amprefersamp
toampanampexchangeampbetweenamppastampandamppresentampinamptheampcreativeamppossibilitiesampofamphermeneuticamp
interpretationamp
amp Thereampisampaamprichnessampinamphistoricalampeventsampthatampjustampkeepsampunfoldingampwhichampisamp
amp certainlyampnotampgraspedampbyamptheamporiginalampprotagonistsampwhichampgraduallyampunfoldsamp
amp overamptheampcourseampofamptimeampandampwhichampisampinampprincipleampneverampfullyampunfoldedampItampisamp
amp anampexcessampwhichampkeepsampspillingampoveramp(pamp47)amp
amp Gadamersampphilosophyampofamphermeneuticampunderstandingampisampformedampthroughamphisamp
notionsampaboutamplanguageampdialogueampandampconversationamp(Caputoamp2000ampSeebohmamp2004)ampamp
InampadditionamptoampGadamersampimplicitamprelianceamponamplisteningampasampheampdiscussesampdialogueamphisamp
workampcapitalizesamponamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampinamplanguageamp(Heelanamp1985)ampmakingamphisamp
formampofamphermeneuticsampparticularlyampapplicableamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp Gadamersamptermampfusion-of-horizonsamprefersamptoamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampwithinampaamp
varietyampofampencountersampampAampfusionampofamphorizonsampcanampbeampdescribedampasampaampdialogicamp
conversationampbetweenampreaderampandamptextamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampWithinamptheamptextualamp
paradigmampGadamerampbelievesampthatampaampwrittenamptextampisampopenamptoampanampinvisibleampandampindefiniteamp
readerampwhoampentersampintoampanampunknownampadventureampofamptheamptextamp(Ricoeuramp2013amppamp13)ampamp
Theamphorizonampitselfampisamptheamprangeampofampvisionampthatampincludesampeverythingampthatampcanampbeampseenamp
fromampaampparticularampvantageamppointamp(Gadameramp2004amppamp301)ampampLikeampcollageamptheampfusionampofamp
horizonsampisampaampprocessampcomposedampofamppastampandamppresentampwhichampareampopenamptoampandampinfinitelyamp
effectedampbyampeachampotheramp(Bourgeoisamp2007)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 17amp
amp Similarampconnectionsampcanampbeampdrawnampwhenampviewerampandampartworkampareampsubstitutedamp
forampreaderampandamptextampampInterpretationampandampunderstandingampbecomeampanampentwinedamp
creativeampendeavorampinampwhichamptheampviewerampparticipatesampasampmuchampasamptheampcreatorampbyamp
constructingampmeaningamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampPalmeramp(1969)ampalludesamptoamptheamppluralityampofamp
meaningampinampstatingampthatamptoampfocusamppurelyamponamptheamppositivityampofampwhatampaamptextampexplicitlyamp
saysampisamptoampdoampanampinjusticeamptoamptheamphermeneuticalamptaskamp(pamp234)ampampToampfocusamponampwhatampisamp
explicitampinampaampcollageampworkampwouldampbeamptoampdisregardamptheampconnectionsampandampcontradictionsamp
ofamptheampwholeampinampfavorampofampaampdirectampreadingampofamptheampindividualamppartsampthusampmissingampoutamponamp
otheramppossibleampdimensionsampofampmeaningamp
amp Theampkeyamptoamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampeducationampinamptextampandampbetweenamp
individualsampisamptheampabilityamptoamplistenampwithampopennessampampDefensiveamplisteningampisampaampwayampofamp
listeningampwithoutampopennessampitampisampaampwayampofampprotectingampourampsmallampversionampofamptheampworldamp
andampavoidingampmoralampclaimsamponampourselvesamp(Levinamp1989amppamp79)ampampLevinamp(1989)amp
discussesampplayfulamplisteningamp(pamp233)ampasampaampwayampofampcounteractingampdefensiveamplisteningampampamp
Bohmamp(1996)ampdiscussesampsuspendingampassumptionsampaampprocessampofampattendingamptoamp
assumptionsampratherampthanamprepressingampthemamporampcarryingampthemampoutampampNicholamp(1996)amp
explainsampaampcircumstanceampinampwhichampyouampencounterampaamppersonampyouampfeelampisampanampidiotampampampYouamp
wouldamprefrainampfromampsayingampsoampoutamploudampbutampyouampwouldampalsoamprefrainampfromampscoldingamp
yourselfampforampthisampthoughtampratherampyouampwouldampseeampthisampreactionampwithoutampfullyampengagingamp
withampitampampSimilarampsuggestionsamplikeampbracketingampofampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampareamp
discussedampinamptheampfollowingampsectionampamp
amp Gadamerampbelievesamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampwhatampallowsamptheampselfamptoampapproachamp
theampotherampitampisampaampprocessampinampwhichamptheampideasampofamptheampotherampbecomeamponesampownamp(Caputoamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 18amp
2000)ampampThisampisamphardlyampanampuncommonampexperienceampampInampfactampweampregularlyampencounteramptheamp
fusionampofamphorizonsampbyampintegratingamppastampunderstandingsampwithampcurrentampexperiencesampaamp
processampundoubtedlyampcomparableamptoampeducationamp(Zuckertamp2002)ampamp
amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsamplikeampeducationampcanampbeampfrustratingampandampemotionalamp
becauseampeachamphighlight[s]amptheampfinitudeampofamptheampinterpreterampandamptheamplimitationsampofamphisamp
understandingamp(Bourgeoisamp2007amppamp79)ampampTheamptermampsharesampsimilaritiesampwithamptheamp
problematic-momentampaamppedagogicalamptermampreferringamptoampaampbreachampinampaampdominantampgroupsamp
discourseampduringampwhichampsomethingamprepressedamparisesamp(KentampampampCummingamp2008)ampampKentamp
andampCummingamp(2008)ampexploreamptheampproblematicampmomentampasampaampdiscursiveampsiteampforamp
examiningampprejudiceampwithinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampandampitsamp
moreamppoliticallyampchargedampcounterpartamptheampproblematicampmomentampbothampexploreamp
Gadamersamp(1996)ampampassertionampthatamptheampotherampmayampnotamponlyamphaveampaamprightampbutampmayamp
actuallyampbeamprightampmayampunderstandampsomethingampbetterampthanampweampdoamp(pamp82)ampampAampcreativelt
listeningampspaceamplivesampinampthisamppossibilityampampamp
amp Lastlyamprelayingampofampappropriateampexpectationsamptoampparticipantsampisampaampnecessaryamp
featureampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampdemandingampampItamp
requiresampparticipantsampwhoampareampawareampofamptheamprisksampandamphardshipsamptoampenterampintoampitampampItamp
isamptheampresponsibilityampofamptheampeducatoramporampgroupampleaderamptoampmakeamptheseampexpectationsamp
knownampasampwellampasamptoampmodelampthisampbehaviorampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionamphermeneuticallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Areampopenamptoamppossibilitiesampandamptoamptheampotherampbull Conceiveampofampthemselvesampasampengagingampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamptheamprisksampinvolvedampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamplimitationsampofamptheirampunderstandingamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 19amp
Dialogic(Practices(-
I-felt-that-everyone-was-open-and-interested-in-what-I-had-to-say---Perhaps-I-felt-this-sense-of-understanding-due-to-the-nature-of-the-discussion((-
it-felt-[like]-more-[of]-a-dialogue-as-opposed-to-a-standard-critique-(Survey-response-MW-age-22)-
(amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampartampeducationampreliesamponampanampopenampdialogueampduringamp
experiencesampwithampartampselfampandampothersampampWhatampIampfoundamplackingampinamphermeneuticsamp
howeverampwasampaampdiscussionampofamptheamphowltlthowampisamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampachievedampandamp
howampdoampindividualsampmeaningfullyampengageampwithampeachampotherampampInampanampeffortamptoampclarifyampthisamp
Iampwillampdiscussampdialogicamppracticesampasamptheyamprelateamptoampmeaningfulampverbalampexchangesampandamp
listeningampencountersampinamptheampclassroomampandampstudioampamongstampstudentsamptheiramppeersampandamp
educatorsamp
amp Communicatingampthroughamplanguageampandampdialogueampisamphowampweampcoltconstructamp
worldsampwithampourselvesampandampothersampnotampjustampthroughampanampactampofamptransmissionampbutamp
becauseampourampcommunicativeampactsampgiveampbirthamptoampworldsamp(Lipariamp2014amppamp507)ampampSableamp
(2014)ampdescribesampdialogueampasampaampgenerativeampinterchangeampbetweenampparticipantsampasamp
opposedamptoampanampexchangeampofampviewsampwhereampindividualsampsimplyampadvocateamptheiramppositionsamp
(pamp8)ampampForampBohmamp(1996)ampitampisampaampstreamampofampmeaningampflowingampamongampandampthroughampusamp
(pamp6)ampampTheampnatureampofampdialogueampandampconversationampisampinherentlyampunplannedampampThisamp
dimensionampofampconversationampisampimportantamptoampGadameramp(2004)ampwhoampfindsampthatamp
participantsampinvolvedampinampconversationampareamplessamptheampleadersampofampitampthanamptheampledamp(pamp
385)ampampSableamp(2014)ampechoesampthisampbyampwritingampthatamptheampmostampimportantamppartsampofampanyamp
conversationampareampthoseampthatampneitheramppartyampcouldamphaveampimaginedampbeforeampstartingamp(pamp
8)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 20amp
amp Theseampareampnotionsampofampdialogueampamongampothersampthatampfindampaampparallelampinamptheamp
creativeampprocessampampFairfieldamp(2011)ampwritesampthatampinampprincipleampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinamp
dialogueamp(pamp83)ampaampsentimentampthatampalignsampwithampaampcommonampissueampencounteredampduringamp
theampcreativeampprocessltltnotampknowingampwhenampaamppieceampisampdoneampampAampquoteampoftenampattributedamp
toampLeonardoampdaampVinciampspeaksamptoampthisampideaampArtampisampneverampfinishedamponlyampabandonedampamp
Snowberamp(2007)ampdrawsampparallelsampbetweenampmentorshipampdialogueampandamptheampcreativeamp
processampfindingampthatampdeepamplisteningamppracticesampconnectampallampthreeampampSheampfindsampthatamptheamp
taskampofamptheampmentorampisamptheampsameampasamptheamptaskampofamptheampartistampthatampisamptoampbringampoutamptheamp
naturalampqualitiesampofamptheampstudentamporamptheampmediumampampSnowberamp(2007)ampcommentsamponampanamp
ideaampwellltknownampamongampartistsampwhichampisampthatampaampworkampofampartamphasampaamplifeampofampitsampownampthisamp
notionampisampreminiscentampofampGadamersampstatementampaboutampbeingampledampbyampconversationamp
ampamp Dialogicamppracticesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampeducationampemphasizeampaamp
phenomenologicalampdimensionamprequiringamptwoampthingsampfromampparticipantsampampFirstlyamp
participantsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampmustampfindampvalueampinamplisteningamptoamptheamp
narrativesampofamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampampTheseampparticipantsampknowampthatampeducationamp
isampforemostampaboutamptestimonyampaboutampsharingamptheampexperienceampofampbeingamphumanampsharingamp
lifeampconvictionsampandampknowledge((Wiercinskiamp2011amppamp109)ampampNarrativesampareamp
conceivedampofampasampaampwayampofamphumanampknowingamp(Vitanovaamp2010amppamp29)ampthatampmakesamptheamp
selfampampSecondlyampwhenamplisteningamptoamptheampnarrativesampofampothersampparticipantsampareampexpectedamp
toampbracketamptheirampownampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsamp(LindsethampampampNorbergamp2004)ampampThisamp
encouragesamplistenersamptoampexperienceampandampfindampmeaningampinamptheampnarrativesampofampothersamp
whileampfreeingamptheampspeakerampfromamptheampfearampofampbeingampjudgedampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 21amp
amp Bracketingampjudgmentampandampconclusionampisampaamppotentialamptoolampwithinamptheampcommonamp
artampeducationamppracticeampofampgroupampcritiquesampampElkinsamp(2001)ampfindsampthatamppeopleampwhoamphaveamp
experienceampinampartampjudgeampveryampquicklyampandampmostampteachersampwillamphaveampaampprovisionalamp
opinionampaboutampaampworkampinamptheampfirstamptenampsecondsamp(pamp121)ampampBracketingampconclusionampandamp
judgmentampisampparticularlyampimportantampforampeducatorsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
whoseampvolumeampofampviewingampexperiencesampcouldampleadamptoampeasyampassumptionsampwhenamp
encounteringampaampnewampworkampampamp
amp Elkinsamp(2001)ampdiscussesampthatampcritiquesampcanampalsoampbeampseenampasampexchangesampofamp
storiesamporampcollaborativeampstorytellingamp(pamp145)ampwhichampisampyetampanotherampwayampofamptalkingamp
aboutamppossibilitiesampforampdialogueampandampnarrativeampwithinampartampeducationampampElkinsamphoweveramp
findsampstorytellingamplimitingamponceamptheampdeeperampnarrativesampareampdiscoveredamp(2001amppamp
145)ampampThisampimpliesampthatampheampfindsamponlyampaampsingularampmeaningampandamponeampthatampisampnotamp
necessarilyampusefulampforampcollaborativeampgroupampcritiquesamp
amp Insteadampparticipantsampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampbringampknowledgeampofamp
polysemyamptoampcollaborativeampcritiqueampexperiencesampasampwellampasamptoampexperiencesampofampmakingamp
artworkampampAccordingamptoampMuldoonamp(2002)amppolysemyampisamptheampqualityampofampaampwordamporampotheramp
languageampunitampthatampcanampbearampmultipleampmeaningsamp(asampcitedampinampWorsleyamp2012amppamp308)ampampamp
Aamptextualampexampleampofampthisampisamptheampmultipleampmeaningsampofamptheampwordampcan-Iampcanampdriveampaampcaramp
Idamplikeampaampcan-ofampsodaampheampwasntampworkingampveryamphardampsoampIamphadamptoampcan-himamp(Munozamp
2014)ampampampButampifampweampconsideramppolysemyampmetaphoricallyamporampvisuallyamptheampideaampthatampaamp
singleampunitampimageamporampintentionampcouldampbearampmultipleampmeaningsampcouldampbeampproductiveampinamp
creatingltlisteningampspacesampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 22amp
amp Thisampunfoldingampofampmeaningampworksampwellampinamptheampcontextampofampcollageampandampdialogueamp
asampwellampasamphermeneuticsampampInampfactamphermeneuticsampimpliesamppolysemyampbecauseampofampitsamp
notionampthatampitampisampalwaysampaamppossibilityampofampmyampunderstandingampthatampisampplayedampoutampwhenampIamp
understandampaamptextamp(Grondinamp2002amppamp38)ampampPolysemyampcouldampbeampconceptualizedampasampanamp
alternativeampexplorationampofampmeaningampthatampfunctionsampcollaborativelyampwithinampcritiquesampamp
Forampexampleampeducatorsampcanampaskampstudentsamptoamprespondamptoampaampworkampthroughampcollageamp
journalampentriesampmusicampfilmampasampindividualsamporampinampgroupsampampKnowledgeampofamppolysemyamp
couldampalsoampbeampusedampasampaamptoolampforampcreatingampimagesampthatamprecognizesampaamprelationshipamp
betweenamptheampvisualamptheamplinguisticampandamptheampmultipleamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionampdialogicallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Placeampvalueamponampexperientialampnarrativesampbull Practiceamplisteningampbyampbracketingampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampbull Embraceamppolysemicampexplorationsampofampmeaningampamp
Contemplative(Practices(
I-knew-I-was-being-heard-because-of-her-mannerisms-and-the-look-on-her-face--She-was-calm-attentive-and-not-trying-to-jump-in-and-offer-any-advice--She-asked-questions-that-pointed-to-things-I-had-not-openly-articulated-because-of-uncertainty--
This-was-one-of-the-ways-I-knew-I-was-being-heard-(Survey-response-LS-age-27)-
(amp Ifamphermeneuticsampandampdialogicamppracticesampgiveampusamptheampbroadampstrokesampofampactivityampinamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampcontemplativeamppracticesampseekamptoamptuneampstudentsampandamp
educatorsampintoampnuanceampdeliberationampandampdeepampexplorationampampThisampisampaampmostlyamp
individualampinternalamppursuitampthatampfocusesamponampformsampofampselfltlisteningampbutampcontemplativeamp
practicesampareampalsoampformedampbyampanampawarenessampofampinterconnectednessamp
amp InamppursuitampofampcriticalampthinkingampSableamp(2014)ampoutlinesampaampsetampofampcontemplativeamp
practicesampforampstudentsampthatampincludeampmindfulampmeditationampstructuredampcontemplationamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 23amp
journalampwritingampmindfulamplisteningampreflectiveampinquiryampandampdialogueamp(pamp4)ampampWhileamp
Sablesamp(2014)ampmethodampforampcontemplativeamppracticesampprovidesampaampconcreteampframeworkamp
withampspecificampstepsampmanyampofamptheseampconceptsampcouldampbeampappliedampwithoutampsuchampaamp
prescribedampstructureampampForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwillampbeamp
primarilyampdiscussingampSablesampconceptsampofampstructuredampcontemplationampreflectiveamp
inquiryampandampjournalampwritingamp
amp ForampSableamp(2014)ampstructuredampcontemplationampisampaampformampofampbeingamppresentampandamp
focusedamponampaampparticularampquestionampstatementamporampimageampampWithinampthisampmodeampofampinquiryamp
participantsampareampexpectedamptoampholdamptheampobjectampofampcontemplationampinamptheirampmindsamp
deepeningampunderstandingampasamptheyampfocusampwithoutampanalyzingampitamporampmanipulatingampitampinamp
anyampwayamp(pamp5)ampampThisamppracticeampdrawsampcomparisonsamptoamptheampbracketingampofampjudgmentsamp
andampconclusionsampsupportedampinamptheamppreviousampsectionampbutampstructuredampcontemplationamp
occursamponampanampindividualamplevelampratherampthanampdialogicallyamp
amp Reflectiveampinquiryampbearsampsomeampsimilaritiesamptoampstructuredampcontemplationampbutamp
Sableamp(2014)amppositionsampitampasampanampactivityampbetweenamptwoampindividualsampaamplistenerampandampaamp
speakerampampTheamplistenerampisampagainampaskedamptoampsuspendampjudgmentampbutampalsoamptoampengageampinampaamp
formampofampcuriosityampinampwhichampinnocentampquestionsampareampaskedampinamporderamptoampgainamp
understandingampampSableamp(2014)ampcontrastsampinnocentampquestionsampwithampleadingampquestionsampamp
ForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwouldampcharacterizeampthisampinnocentamp
questioningampasampaampformampofampopenltendedampquestioningampampSableamp(2014)ampidentifiesampanamp
exampleampofampanampinnocentamp(orampopenltended)ampquestionampWhatampdidampyouampmeanampwhenampyouamp
saidamp________ampConverselyampaampleadingampquestionampisampDidampyouampmeanamptoampsayamp________ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 24amp
amp Sableamp(2014)ampusesampjournalampwritingampasampaamppieceampofamphisamplargerampstructureampofamp
contemplativeamppracticesampbutampjournalampwritingampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampcouldamp
potentiallyampoccupyampaampsignificantamproleampampIampconceiveampofampjournalampwritingampinampmyampownamp
creativeamppracticeampasampaampformampofampdocumentationampthatampmakesampmeampmoreampawareampofampmyamp
creativeampprocessamptheampemotionalamphabitsampthatampsurroundampitampandamptheampthemesampthatamp
structureampmyampworkampampIampconceptualizeampthisampwayampofampwritingampasampaampformampofampselfltlisteningamp
relatedamptoampaampkeyampconceptampofamphermeneuticsampfoundampinampGadamersampassertionampthatampallamp
educationampisampaampformampofampselflteducationamp(Grondinamp2011)ampampamp
amp Germeraadamp(2013)ampusesampjournalampwritingamptoampexploreamptheampemotionalampandamprationalamp
relationshipsamptoamphisampcreativeampprocessampparallelamptoampexecutingampaampnewampbodyampofampworkampampHeamp
findsampthatampwritingampduringamphisampprocessampisampaamptoolamptoampunderstandamp[his]amppsycheamptoampeaseamp
theamppainampthatampanampartisticampprocessampcanampbringampandamptoamprelieveampartisticampblocksamp
(Germeraadamp2013amppamp21)ampultimatelyampdeclaringampthatampitamphelpsamphimamptoampbetterampunderstandamp
hisampworkampampInampaampstyleampofampwritingampthatamposcillatesamparoundampjournalingampdocumentationampandamp
poetryampdeampCossonamp(2002)ampexploresamphisampoverlappingamprolesampasampanampartistampresearcherampandamp
teacherampampOtherampartistsampbluramptheamplineampbetweenampartamppracticeampdocumentationampandamplifeamp
furtherampstillampbyampofferingampdocumentationampasampartamplikeampSophieampCalleamp(Calleamp2011amp2008amp
2005)ampandampMaryampKellyamp(1973lt1979)ampampamp
amp Karpiakamp(2003)ampestablishesampcontemplativeamppracticesampfromamptheampperspectiveampofamp
theampeducatorampaskingampthemamptoampmineamptheampsubtleamp(pamp71)ampusingampattentivenessamp
attunementampamplificationampandampassociationampampTheseampexercisesampinampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampsetamptheamptoneampasampwellampasampprovideampaampmodelampofampbehaviorampforampotherampparticipantsamp
withinamptheampspaceampampKarpiakamp(2003)ampoutlinesampactivitiesampthatampeducatorsampcanampuseamptoampdrawamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 25amp
outampandamputilizeamptheseampsubtleampsensationsampinamptheampserviceampofamptransformativeamplearningamp(pamp
68)ampampamp
amp ForampKarpiakamp(2003)ampattentivenessamprequiresampawarenessamptoampverbalampandamp
nonverbalampcuesampasampwellampasampanampawarenessampofampwhatampisamphappeningampamongampandampwithinamptheamp
studentsampandamptheampeducatorampampAttunementamprequiresampanampeducatoramptoamporientampherselfamptoamptheamp
otherampandamptoampadoptampanampattitudeampofampunhurriednessampofamppatienceampandampofamphumilityamp
concerningampbothamptheampprocessampandamptheampoutcomesampofamptheampteachingamp(Karpiakamp2003amppgamp
72)ampampAmplificationampisampaampprocessampofamphonoringampcommunicationampthatampcentersamponamptheampideaamp
ofamphearingamponeselfampintoampknowingampitampincludesampusingampparaphrasingampandampclarificationamp
activitiesamptoampgainampinsightampintoampmeaningampampLastlyampassociationampentailsampidentifyingamp
patternsampandampweavingampthemamptogetherampwithampstudentampexperienceampclassroomampdiscussionamp
andamptheampideasampofampothersamp
amp TuningampintoampsubtletyampimpliesampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceampampTheampmanifestationsamp
ofampsilenceampinamptheampclassroomampareampendlessampandampitsampvalueampisamptooampgreatamptoampbeampignoredampwhileamp
tooampvastamptoampbeampfullyampabsorbedampampLevinamp(1989)ampremarksampthatampsilenceampisampaampclearingampwhereamp
thereampisampnothingampforamphearingamptoampholdamponamptoampinampwhichampmanyampfindampunbearableampanxietyamp
(pamp79)ampampNearlyampallampofampusamphaveampexperiencedampthisampunbearableampanxietyampaampstrainampofamp
whichampcanampbeampfoundampinampeducationalampcontextsampdueamptoamptheampfactampthatampclassroomsampareamp
oftenampstructuredamparoundampimplicitampandampexplicitamprulesampaboutamptalkampandampsilenceamp(Schultzamp
2010amppamp2848)ampampForampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampanampawarenessampofampsilenceampimplicatesamp
whatampisampleftampunsaidampandampwhatampisampunsayableltltespeciallyampimportantampbecauseampofamptheamp
unsayableampqualityampofampartworksampampForampSchultzamp(2010)ampsilenceampimpliesamppossibilityamp
becauseampitampcanampholdampmultipleampmeaningsampforampindividualsampwithinampandampacrossampracialamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 26amp
ethnicampandampculturalampgroupsamp(pamp2833)ampampLevinamp(1989)ampfindsampthatamptoamplistenamptoamp
somethingampweampmustampfirstampgive-itampourampsilenceamp(pamp232)ampampThisamppracticeampofampgivingampsilenceamp
isampparticularlyamphelpfulampinamptermsampofampviewingamporamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartamp
amp Gradleamp(2011)ampoutlinesampaamppracticalampvisionampforampviewingampartampthatamprequiresamp
silenceampandampdeliberationampampForamptheamppurposesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampwouldamp
reconceptualizeampthisampasampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampampGradleamp(2011)ampinstructedamp
herampstudentsamptoampspendamptimeampwithampaampworkampofampartampoutsideampofamptheirampeverydayampworldviewamp
attentivelyampviewingampitampforampaboutamptenampminutesampeverydayampforampaampweekampampAfterampeachampviewingamp
experienceamptheampstudentsampwroteampinamptheirampjournalsampampTheampresultsampindicatedampthatampthisamp
processampofampsustainedampsilentampdeliberationampcoupledampwithampanampengagementampofamptheiramp
intuitiveampperceptionsampaboutampartworkampleftampstudentsampfeelingampempoweredamptoampengageampinamp
discussionampandampappreciateampunfamiliarampartampformsampampThisampactivityampisampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoamp
aampworkampofampartampthatampincorporatesampSablesamp(2014)ampconceptampofampstructuredampcontemplationampamp
Weavingampaamprelationshipampbetweenampsilenceampcontemplationampandampattentivenessampisampaamp
significantampendeavorampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
Contemplativeamppracticesampfunctionampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Engageampinampformsampofampviewingampwritingampandampexperiencingampthatamphonorampselfltlisteningamp
bull Attuneamptoampsubtletyampandampnuanceampbull Listenampandampviewampdeliberatelyampbull Cultivateampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceamp(
The(Felt(Sense(
When-someone-understands-what-I-am-talking-about-when-I-talk-about-art-I-am-delighted--Art-is-my-everything--Its-my-passion--When-someone-understands-that-I-
am-instantly-filled-with-joy--That-tells-me-someone-gets-it-(Survey-response-CTF-age-16)-
(
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 11amp
Iampwillampconcludeampwithamppossibilitiesampforampthisampresearchampamp(Ill-figure-out-what-I-learned-and-
share-it-with-you-my-new-best-friend-who-made-it-all-the-way-to-the-conclusions-
section)ampampInampthisamppaperampreadersampwillampnoticeamptransparentampimagesampinteractingampwithamptheamp
textampamp(Its-my-art-on-transparent-sheets-in-this-very-paper)ampampTheseampareampworksampofampartamp
thatampIampcreatedamptoampgroundamptheampresearchampinampaamppracticeampofampmakingamptheyampareamptheampphysicalamp
embodimentampofampconceptualampideasampandamptheyampareampalwaysamppresentamptoamptheampresearchampamp
(Research-papers-with-pictures-are-much-more-tolerable-am-I-right)amp
amp Hereampweampgoamp
amp
thread2(
Collaging(Experience1(
amp ImagineampthatampyouampareampanampartistampseatedampatampyourampstudioamptableampampYouamphaveamp
everythingampyouampneedampampTheamproomampisampquietampsaveampforamptheampmuffledampsoundsampofampaampdistantamp
outsideampworldampampYouampsurveyamptheampcollectionampofampimagesampyouamphaveampgatheredamparoundampyouampamp
OnampyouramprightampisampaampraggedamppageampfromampanampoldampsketchbookampampGlossyampjewellttonedampswatchesamp
fromampaampdiscardedampfashionampmagazineampareampstackedampupampglisteningampinamptheamplightampampMonthsamp
agoampyouamppickedampupampaamphandfulampofampblackampandampwhiteampphotosampfromampaampsecondhandampstoreamp
todayamppastyampfacesampofamptheampunknownampsubjectsampstareampthroughampyouampblanklyampampAamppaleampyellowamp
scrapampofampleftoverampfabricampisampdrapedampoveramplastampweeksamppleatedamptoltdoamplistampampTheseampandamptwoamp
dozenampotherampscrapsamppiecesamppilesampandampcrumbsampareampyouramptoolsamptodayampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampamp1ampThisampsectionampisampsupposedamptoampbeampmyampresearchersampreflexiveampnarrativeampaamppassageampaboutampwhereampmyampresearchampideasampcameampfromltltandampinampfactampcollageampisampactuallyampwhereampthisampideaampcomesampfromampampOneampofamptheampfirstampresearchampinterestsampIampdiscussedampwithampmyampprofessorampDrampKristopherampHollandampwasamplayersampbothampphysicalampandampconceptualampampHeampwasamplikeampOhampampYoureamptalkingampaboutamphermeneuticsampSoampinampaampwayampthisampresearchampprojectampbothampbeganampandampconcludedamp(moreamponampthatamplater)ampwithampideasampofamplayeringampandampcollageampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 12amp
amp TheampresidueampthatampclingsamptoamptheseampscrapsampisampexperienceampampTheampoldampsketchbookamp
pageampisampanampimageampofampaampwomansamplegamprenderedampwithampchunkyamppencilampstrokesampampYouampmadeampitamp
whenampyouampwereamplivingampinampyourampoldampapartmentampoverlookingamptheampsquareampampItsampaampwomansamp
footampbutampitampremindsampyouampofamphavingampaamproommateampandampaampgrayampfutonampandampaampsummerampthatamp
wasampdesperatelyamphotampampItampisamponlyamppencilamponamppaperampbutampitampremindsampyouampofamptheampgreenamp
grassyampcenterampinamptheampmedianampofamptheampstreetampampOneamppencilampdrawingampofampaampwomansamplegamp
remindsampyouampofampthatampoldamplifeampandamptheampversionampofampyourselfampyouampwereampthenampitampisamptheampfirstamp
dominoampinampaampseriesampofampcascadingampdetailsampandampmemoriesampamp
amp EachampfragmentampsittingamponampyourampstudioamptableamphasampaampstoryampampEachampcameampfromampaamp
placeampandampwasamptouchedampbyampanotheramphumanampampEachampisampembeddedampwithampexperienceampcoloramp
memoryamptextureampandampinfiniteampdetailampbyamptheampmereampfactampofampitsampownampexistenceampamp
amp YouampbeginamptoamppickampapartamptheampephemeraampampYouampalternateampbeingampcarefulampandamp
carelessamp
amp Cuttingamptearingampburningampstretchingampfoldingampwhitewashingamprippingampcreasingamp
sewingampwritingamppaintingampencasingampfasteningampfillingampsoakingampdyeingampwashingamp
dryingampbitingampscratchingamppryingampyankingampsmoothingampsandingamppokingampstabbingamp
stretchingampfryingampheatingampdustingampcleaningampsculptingampslicingampdicingamppunchingamp
floatingamptwistingampflippingampdrippingampstaplingampstrippingampstripingamppatterningamp
designingampdrawingampsketchingampliftingampcollectingamptapingampgluingampbuttoningampknottingamp
weavingampknittingamp
amp YouampdoampallampofamptheseampthingsampandampprobablyampmanyampotherampthingsampampTheampfragmentsamponamp
youramptableampchangeampshapeampandampgetampsmallerampampFromamptheseamppiecesampyouampbeginamptoampbuildamp
somethingampampThisampsomethingampisampbothampnewampandampoldampampJuxtapositionsampbloomampnewamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 13amp
connectionsampareampfusedampbyamptheampweightampofamppreviousampexperienceampampPastampandamppresentamp
liquefyampintoampendlesslyampcirculatingamppossibilitiesampampYouampcouldamptheoreticallyampcontinueampthisamp
processampofamplayeringampandampreconstructionampforeverampamptheamponlyamplimitsampareampyourampownamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 14amp
thread3(
what(is(a(creative=listening(space(
ampampampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeamplisteningampspaceampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampwhatampdoesampitampsoundampsmellamptasteampfeelamplikeampampampampampampampwhatampampisampamptheampamptextureampampofampampthisampampamp
spaceampampampanswerampmoreampquestionsampampamp specificsampandampgeneralizationsampareampbothampimpossibleampampmaybeampaampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampgoodampstartampwouldampbeampthisampampamp amp amp amp amp safeampampampamp amp amp amp amp foldedampampamp amp amp amp amp amp embodiedampamp layeredampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampconnectedampampampamp amp ampamp
(it-might--be-like-gently-holding-on-to--
a-knot-of-questions)-amp
ampampampampampampampampampamp
(possible)ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 15amp
thread4amp(
Review(of(Literature((
( AnampexplorationampofampGadamerrsquosamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampeducationalampcontextsampandampGendlinrsquosamptheoryampofampfeltampsenseampwereampintegralamptoamp
theampcreationampofamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampWhileampcompellingampconstructsamponamp
theirampownampwhenampdrawnamptogetheramptheseampphilosophicalampperspectivesampvibrateamp
holisticallyamptoampsuggestampintriguingamppossibilitiesampforamptheampuseampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
inampartsampeducationampampInampthisampsectionampIampreviewamptheampliteratureampandampconnectamptheampvariousamp
pointsampofampstudyampampamp
Hermeneutics(amp(the(Fusion(of(Horizons((
It-actually-feels-really-great-knowing-that-other-people-will-enjoy-the-art-you-created-and-knowing-they-know-your-reasoning-and-story-behind-it--Honestly-you-cant-know-if-your-words-are-getting-through-to-them-but-the-cool-thing-about-art-is-that-it-can-be-
interpreted-in-so-many-different-ways---(Survey-response-EK-age-15)-
ampamp Hermeneuticsampwhichamphasampitsamprootsampinamptextualampinterpretationampcanampbeampdefinedampasamp
aamptraditionampofampthinkingamporampofampphilosophicalampreflectionampthatamptriesamptoampclarifyamptheampconceptamp
ofampverstehenampthatampisampunderstandingamp(Brunsamp1992)ampampRicoeuramp(19691974)ampexplainsamp
thatamptheampkeyamphypothesisampofamphermeneuticampphilosophyampisampthatampinterpretationampisampanampopenamp
processampwhichampnoampsingleampvisionampcanampconcludeamp(pamp109)ampampWithampthisampinampmindampIampwillamp
exploreamphermeneuticsampasampitampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp HansltGeorgampGadameramp(1900lt2002)ampinvestigatesampaampmoderateampformampofamp
hermeneuticsampthatampisampparticularlyamprelevantampinampserviceamptoampartampeducationampampGadameramp
breaksampwithamphermeneuticamptraditionampbyampproposingampthatampthereampisampnoampabsolutelyampobjectiveamp
interpretationampreadersampareampnotampableamptoampescapeamptheampprejudicesampofamptheiramptimeamp(Gallagheramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 16amp
1992)ampampThisamphoweverampbecomesampanampopportunityampforamptheampcreationampofampmeaningampInampaamp
passageampthatampechoesamptheampendlesslyampunfoldingampnatureampofampcollageampCaputoamp(2000)amprefersamp
toampanampexchangeampbetweenamppastampandamppresentampinamptheampcreativeamppossibilitiesampofamphermeneuticamp
interpretationamp
amp Thereampisampaamprichnessampinamphistoricalampeventsampthatampjustampkeepsampunfoldingampwhichampisamp
amp certainlyampnotampgraspedampbyamptheamporiginalampprotagonistsampwhichampgraduallyampunfoldsamp
amp overamptheampcourseampofamptimeampandampwhichampisampinampprincipleampneverampfullyampunfoldedampItampisamp
amp anampexcessampwhichampkeepsampspillingampoveramp(pamp47)amp
amp Gadamersampphilosophyampofamphermeneuticampunderstandingampisampformedampthroughamphisamp
notionsampaboutamplanguageampdialogueampandampconversationamp(Caputoamp2000ampSeebohmamp2004)ampamp
InampadditionamptoampGadamersampimplicitamprelianceamponamplisteningampasampheampdiscussesampdialogueamphisamp
workampcapitalizesamponamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampinamplanguageamp(Heelanamp1985)ampmakingamphisamp
formampofamphermeneuticsampparticularlyampapplicableamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp Gadamersamptermampfusion-of-horizonsamprefersamptoamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampwithinampaamp
varietyampofampencountersampampAampfusionampofamphorizonsampcanampbeampdescribedampasampaampdialogicamp
conversationampbetweenampreaderampandamptextamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampWithinamptheamptextualamp
paradigmampGadamerampbelievesampthatampaampwrittenamptextampisampopenamptoampanampinvisibleampandampindefiniteamp
readerampwhoampentersampintoampanampunknownampadventureampofamptheamptextamp(Ricoeuramp2013amppamp13)ampamp
Theamphorizonampitselfampisamptheamprangeampofampvisionampthatampincludesampeverythingampthatampcanampbeampseenamp
fromampaampparticularampvantageamppointamp(Gadameramp2004amppamp301)ampampLikeampcollageamptheampfusionampofamp
horizonsampisampaampprocessampcomposedampofamppastampandamppresentampwhichampareampopenamptoampandampinfinitelyamp
effectedampbyampeachampotheramp(Bourgeoisamp2007)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 17amp
amp Similarampconnectionsampcanampbeampdrawnampwhenampviewerampandampartworkampareampsubstitutedamp
forampreaderampandamptextampampInterpretationampandampunderstandingampbecomeampanampentwinedamp
creativeampendeavorampinampwhichamptheampviewerampparticipatesampasampmuchampasamptheampcreatorampbyamp
constructingampmeaningamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampPalmeramp(1969)ampalludesamptoamptheamppluralityampofamp
meaningampinampstatingampthatamptoampfocusamppurelyamponamptheamppositivityampofampwhatampaamptextampexplicitlyamp
saysampisamptoampdoampanampinjusticeamptoamptheamphermeneuticalamptaskamp(pamp234)ampampToampfocusamponampwhatampisamp
explicitampinampaampcollageampworkampwouldampbeamptoampdisregardamptheampconnectionsampandampcontradictionsamp
ofamptheampwholeampinampfavorampofampaampdirectampreadingampofamptheampindividualamppartsampthusampmissingampoutamponamp
otheramppossibleampdimensionsampofampmeaningamp
amp Theampkeyamptoamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampeducationampinamptextampandampbetweenamp
individualsampisamptheampabilityamptoamplistenampwithampopennessampampDefensiveamplisteningampisampaampwayampofamp
listeningampwithoutampopennessampitampisampaampwayampofampprotectingampourampsmallampversionampofamptheampworldamp
andampavoidingampmoralampclaimsamponampourselvesamp(Levinamp1989amppamp79)ampampLevinamp(1989)amp
discussesampplayfulamplisteningamp(pamp233)ampasampaampwayampofampcounteractingampdefensiveamplisteningampampamp
Bohmamp(1996)ampdiscussesampsuspendingampassumptionsampaampprocessampofampattendingamptoamp
assumptionsampratherampthanamprepressingampthemamporampcarryingampthemampoutampampNicholamp(1996)amp
explainsampaampcircumstanceampinampwhichampyouampencounterampaamppersonampyouampfeelampisampanampidiotampampampYouamp
wouldamprefrainampfromampsayingampsoampoutamploudampbutampyouampwouldampalsoamprefrainampfromampscoldingamp
yourselfampforampthisampthoughtampratherampyouampwouldampseeampthisampreactionampwithoutampfullyampengagingamp
withampitampampSimilarampsuggestionsamplikeampbracketingampofampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampareamp
discussedampinamptheampfollowingampsectionampamp
amp Gadamerampbelievesamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampwhatampallowsamptheampselfamptoampapproachamp
theampotherampitampisampaampprocessampinampwhichamptheampideasampofamptheampotherampbecomeamponesampownamp(Caputoamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 18amp
2000)ampampThisampisamphardlyampanampuncommonampexperienceampampInampfactampweampregularlyampencounteramptheamp
fusionampofamphorizonsampbyampintegratingamppastampunderstandingsampwithampcurrentampexperiencesampaamp
processampundoubtedlyampcomparableamptoampeducationamp(Zuckertamp2002)ampamp
amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsamplikeampeducationampcanampbeampfrustratingampandampemotionalamp
becauseampeachamphighlight[s]amptheampfinitudeampofamptheampinterpreterampandamptheamplimitationsampofamphisamp
understandingamp(Bourgeoisamp2007amppamp79)ampampTheamptermampsharesampsimilaritiesampwithamptheamp
problematic-momentampaamppedagogicalamptermampreferringamptoampaampbreachampinampaampdominantampgroupsamp
discourseampduringampwhichampsomethingamprepressedamparisesamp(KentampampampCummingamp2008)ampampKentamp
andampCummingamp(2008)ampexploreamptheampproblematicampmomentampasampaampdiscursiveampsiteampforamp
examiningampprejudiceampwithinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampandampitsamp
moreamppoliticallyampchargedampcounterpartamptheampproblematicampmomentampbothampexploreamp
Gadamersamp(1996)ampampassertionampthatamptheampotherampmayampnotamponlyamphaveampaamprightampbutampmayamp
actuallyampbeamprightampmayampunderstandampsomethingampbetterampthanampweampdoamp(pamp82)ampampAampcreativelt
listeningampspaceamplivesampinampthisamppossibilityampampamp
amp Lastlyamprelayingampofampappropriateampexpectationsamptoampparticipantsampisampaampnecessaryamp
featureampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampdemandingampampItamp
requiresampparticipantsampwhoampareampawareampofamptheamprisksampandamphardshipsamptoampenterampintoampitampampItamp
isamptheampresponsibilityampofamptheampeducatoramporampgroupampleaderamptoampmakeamptheseampexpectationsamp
knownampasampwellampasamptoampmodelampthisampbehaviorampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionamphermeneuticallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Areampopenamptoamppossibilitiesampandamptoamptheampotherampbull Conceiveampofampthemselvesampasampengagingampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamptheamprisksampinvolvedampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamplimitationsampofamptheirampunderstandingamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 19amp
Dialogic(Practices(-
I-felt-that-everyone-was-open-and-interested-in-what-I-had-to-say---Perhaps-I-felt-this-sense-of-understanding-due-to-the-nature-of-the-discussion((-
it-felt-[like]-more-[of]-a-dialogue-as-opposed-to-a-standard-critique-(Survey-response-MW-age-22)-
(amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampartampeducationampreliesamponampanampopenampdialogueampduringamp
experiencesampwithampartampselfampandampothersampampWhatampIampfoundamplackingampinamphermeneuticsamp
howeverampwasampaampdiscussionampofamptheamphowltlthowampisamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampachievedampandamp
howampdoampindividualsampmeaningfullyampengageampwithampeachampotherampampInampanampeffortamptoampclarifyampthisamp
Iampwillampdiscussampdialogicamppracticesampasamptheyamprelateamptoampmeaningfulampverbalampexchangesampandamp
listeningampencountersampinamptheampclassroomampandampstudioampamongstampstudentsamptheiramppeersampandamp
educatorsamp
amp Communicatingampthroughamplanguageampandampdialogueampisamphowampweampcoltconstructamp
worldsampwithampourselvesampandampothersampnotampjustampthroughampanampactampofamptransmissionampbutamp
becauseampourampcommunicativeampactsampgiveampbirthamptoampworldsamp(Lipariamp2014amppamp507)ampampSableamp
(2014)ampdescribesampdialogueampasampaampgenerativeampinterchangeampbetweenampparticipantsampasamp
opposedamptoampanampexchangeampofampviewsampwhereampindividualsampsimplyampadvocateamptheiramppositionsamp
(pamp8)ampampForampBohmamp(1996)ampitampisampaampstreamampofampmeaningampflowingampamongampandampthroughampusamp
(pamp6)ampampTheampnatureampofampdialogueampandampconversationampisampinherentlyampunplannedampampThisamp
dimensionampofampconversationampisampimportantamptoampGadameramp(2004)ampwhoampfindsampthatamp
participantsampinvolvedampinampconversationampareamplessamptheampleadersampofampitampthanamptheampledamp(pamp
385)ampampSableamp(2014)ampechoesampthisampbyampwritingampthatamptheampmostampimportantamppartsampofampanyamp
conversationampareampthoseampthatampneitheramppartyampcouldamphaveampimaginedampbeforeampstartingamp(pamp
8)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 20amp
amp Theseampareampnotionsampofampdialogueampamongampothersampthatampfindampaampparallelampinamptheamp
creativeampprocessampampFairfieldamp(2011)ampwritesampthatampinampprincipleampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinamp
dialogueamp(pamp83)ampaampsentimentampthatampalignsampwithampaampcommonampissueampencounteredampduringamp
theampcreativeampprocessltltnotampknowingampwhenampaamppieceampisampdoneampampAampquoteampoftenampattributedamp
toampLeonardoampdaampVinciampspeaksamptoampthisampideaampArtampisampneverampfinishedamponlyampabandonedampamp
Snowberamp(2007)ampdrawsampparallelsampbetweenampmentorshipampdialogueampandamptheampcreativeamp
processampfindingampthatampdeepamplisteningamppracticesampconnectampallampthreeampampSheampfindsampthatamptheamp
taskampofamptheampmentorampisamptheampsameampasamptheamptaskampofamptheampartistampthatampisamptoampbringampoutamptheamp
naturalampqualitiesampofamptheampstudentamporamptheampmediumampampSnowberamp(2007)ampcommentsamponampanamp
ideaampwellltknownampamongampartistsampwhichampisampthatampaampworkampofampartamphasampaamplifeampofampitsampownampthisamp
notionampisampreminiscentampofampGadamersampstatementampaboutampbeingampledampbyampconversationamp
ampamp Dialogicamppracticesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampeducationampemphasizeampaamp
phenomenologicalampdimensionamprequiringamptwoampthingsampfromampparticipantsampampFirstlyamp
participantsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampmustampfindampvalueampinamplisteningamptoamptheamp
narrativesampofamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampampTheseampparticipantsampknowampthatampeducationamp
isampforemostampaboutamptestimonyampaboutampsharingamptheampexperienceampofampbeingamphumanampsharingamp
lifeampconvictionsampandampknowledge((Wiercinskiamp2011amppamp109)ampampNarrativesampareamp
conceivedampofampasampaampwayampofamphumanampknowingamp(Vitanovaamp2010amppamp29)ampthatampmakesamptheamp
selfampampSecondlyampwhenamplisteningamptoamptheampnarrativesampofampothersampparticipantsampareampexpectedamp
toampbracketamptheirampownampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsamp(LindsethampampampNorbergamp2004)ampampThisamp
encouragesamplistenersamptoampexperienceampandampfindampmeaningampinamptheampnarrativesampofampothersamp
whileampfreeingamptheampspeakerampfromamptheampfearampofampbeingampjudgedampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 21amp
amp Bracketingampjudgmentampandampconclusionampisampaamppotentialamptoolampwithinamptheampcommonamp
artampeducationamppracticeampofampgroupampcritiquesampampElkinsamp(2001)ampfindsampthatamppeopleampwhoamphaveamp
experienceampinampartampjudgeampveryampquicklyampandampmostampteachersampwillamphaveampaampprovisionalamp
opinionampaboutampaampworkampinamptheampfirstamptenampsecondsamp(pamp121)ampampBracketingampconclusionampandamp
judgmentampisampparticularlyampimportantampforampeducatorsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
whoseampvolumeampofampviewingampexperiencesampcouldampleadamptoampeasyampassumptionsampwhenamp
encounteringampaampnewampworkampampamp
amp Elkinsamp(2001)ampdiscussesampthatampcritiquesampcanampalsoampbeampseenampasampexchangesampofamp
storiesamporampcollaborativeampstorytellingamp(pamp145)ampwhichampisampyetampanotherampwayampofamptalkingamp
aboutamppossibilitiesampforampdialogueampandampnarrativeampwithinampartampeducationampampElkinsamphoweveramp
findsampstorytellingamplimitingamponceamptheampdeeperampnarrativesampareampdiscoveredamp(2001amppamp
145)ampampThisampimpliesampthatampheampfindsamponlyampaampsingularampmeaningampandamponeampthatampisampnotamp
necessarilyampusefulampforampcollaborativeampgroupampcritiquesamp
amp Insteadampparticipantsampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampbringampknowledgeampofamp
polysemyamptoampcollaborativeampcritiqueampexperiencesampasampwellampasamptoampexperiencesampofampmakingamp
artworkampampAccordingamptoampMuldoonamp(2002)amppolysemyampisamptheampqualityampofampaampwordamporampotheramp
languageampunitampthatampcanampbearampmultipleampmeaningsamp(asampcitedampinampWorsleyamp2012amppamp308)ampampamp
Aamptextualampexampleampofampthisampisamptheampmultipleampmeaningsampofamptheampwordampcan-Iampcanampdriveampaampcaramp
Idamplikeampaampcan-ofampsodaampheampwasntampworkingampveryamphardampsoampIamphadamptoampcan-himamp(Munozamp
2014)ampampampButampifampweampconsideramppolysemyampmetaphoricallyamporampvisuallyamptheampideaampthatampaamp
singleampunitampimageamporampintentionampcouldampbearampmultipleampmeaningsampcouldampbeampproductiveampinamp
creatingltlisteningampspacesampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 22amp
amp Thisampunfoldingampofampmeaningampworksampwellampinamptheampcontextampofampcollageampandampdialogueamp
asampwellampasamphermeneuticsampampInampfactamphermeneuticsampimpliesamppolysemyampbecauseampofampitsamp
notionampthatampitampisampalwaysampaamppossibilityampofampmyampunderstandingampthatampisampplayedampoutampwhenampIamp
understandampaamptextamp(Grondinamp2002amppamp38)ampampPolysemyampcouldampbeampconceptualizedampasampanamp
alternativeampexplorationampofampmeaningampthatampfunctionsampcollaborativelyampwithinampcritiquesampamp
Forampexampleampeducatorsampcanampaskampstudentsamptoamprespondamptoampaampworkampthroughampcollageamp
journalampentriesampmusicampfilmampasampindividualsamporampinampgroupsampampKnowledgeampofamppolysemyamp
couldampalsoampbeampusedampasampaamptoolampforampcreatingampimagesampthatamprecognizesampaamprelationshipamp
betweenamptheampvisualamptheamplinguisticampandamptheampmultipleamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionampdialogicallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Placeampvalueamponampexperientialampnarrativesampbull Practiceamplisteningampbyampbracketingampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampbull Embraceamppolysemicampexplorationsampofampmeaningampamp
Contemplative(Practices(
I-knew-I-was-being-heard-because-of-her-mannerisms-and-the-look-on-her-face--She-was-calm-attentive-and-not-trying-to-jump-in-and-offer-any-advice--She-asked-questions-that-pointed-to-things-I-had-not-openly-articulated-because-of-uncertainty--
This-was-one-of-the-ways-I-knew-I-was-being-heard-(Survey-response-LS-age-27)-
(amp Ifamphermeneuticsampandampdialogicamppracticesampgiveampusamptheampbroadampstrokesampofampactivityampinamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampcontemplativeamppracticesampseekamptoamptuneampstudentsampandamp
educatorsampintoampnuanceampdeliberationampandampdeepampexplorationampampThisampisampaampmostlyamp
individualampinternalamppursuitampthatampfocusesamponampformsampofampselfltlisteningampbutampcontemplativeamp
practicesampareampalsoampformedampbyampanampawarenessampofampinterconnectednessamp
amp InamppursuitampofampcriticalampthinkingampSableamp(2014)ampoutlinesampaampsetampofampcontemplativeamp
practicesampforampstudentsampthatampincludeampmindfulampmeditationampstructuredampcontemplationamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 23amp
journalampwritingampmindfulamplisteningampreflectiveampinquiryampandampdialogueamp(pamp4)ampampWhileamp
Sablesamp(2014)ampmethodampforampcontemplativeamppracticesampprovidesampaampconcreteampframeworkamp
withampspecificampstepsampmanyampofamptheseampconceptsampcouldampbeampappliedampwithoutampsuchampaamp
prescribedampstructureampampForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwillampbeamp
primarilyampdiscussingampSablesampconceptsampofampstructuredampcontemplationampreflectiveamp
inquiryampandampjournalampwritingamp
amp ForampSableamp(2014)ampstructuredampcontemplationampisampaampformampofampbeingamppresentampandamp
focusedamponampaampparticularampquestionampstatementamporampimageampampWithinampthisampmodeampofampinquiryamp
participantsampareampexpectedamptoampholdamptheampobjectampofampcontemplationampinamptheirampmindsamp
deepeningampunderstandingampasamptheyampfocusampwithoutampanalyzingampitamporampmanipulatingampitampinamp
anyampwayamp(pamp5)ampampThisamppracticeampdrawsampcomparisonsamptoamptheampbracketingampofampjudgmentsamp
andampconclusionsampsupportedampinamptheamppreviousampsectionampbutampstructuredampcontemplationamp
occursamponampanampindividualamplevelampratherampthanampdialogicallyamp
amp Reflectiveampinquiryampbearsampsomeampsimilaritiesamptoampstructuredampcontemplationampbutamp
Sableamp(2014)amppositionsampitampasampanampactivityampbetweenamptwoampindividualsampaamplistenerampandampaamp
speakerampampTheamplistenerampisampagainampaskedamptoampsuspendampjudgmentampbutampalsoamptoampengageampinampaamp
formampofampcuriosityampinampwhichampinnocentampquestionsampareampaskedampinamporderamptoampgainamp
understandingampampSableamp(2014)ampcontrastsampinnocentampquestionsampwithampleadingampquestionsampamp
ForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwouldampcharacterizeampthisampinnocentamp
questioningampasampaampformampofampopenltendedampquestioningampampSableamp(2014)ampidentifiesampanamp
exampleampofampanampinnocentamp(orampopenltended)ampquestionampWhatampdidampyouampmeanampwhenampyouamp
saidamp________ampConverselyampaampleadingampquestionampisampDidampyouampmeanamptoampsayamp________ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 24amp
amp Sableamp(2014)ampusesampjournalampwritingampasampaamppieceampofamphisamplargerampstructureampofamp
contemplativeamppracticesampbutampjournalampwritingampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampcouldamp
potentiallyampoccupyampaampsignificantamproleampampIampconceiveampofampjournalampwritingampinampmyampownamp
creativeamppracticeampasampaampformampofampdocumentationampthatampmakesampmeampmoreampawareampofampmyamp
creativeampprocessamptheampemotionalamphabitsampthatampsurroundampitampandamptheampthemesampthatamp
structureampmyampworkampampIampconceptualizeampthisampwayampofampwritingampasampaampformampofampselfltlisteningamp
relatedamptoampaampkeyampconceptampofamphermeneuticsampfoundampinampGadamersampassertionampthatampallamp
educationampisampaampformampofampselflteducationamp(Grondinamp2011)ampampamp
amp Germeraadamp(2013)ampusesampjournalampwritingamptoampexploreamptheampemotionalampandamprationalamp
relationshipsamptoamphisampcreativeampprocessampparallelamptoampexecutingampaampnewampbodyampofampworkampampHeamp
findsampthatampwritingampduringamphisampprocessampisampaamptoolamptoampunderstandamp[his]amppsycheamptoampeaseamp
theamppainampthatampanampartisticampprocessampcanampbringampandamptoamprelieveampartisticampblocksamp
(Germeraadamp2013amppamp21)ampultimatelyampdeclaringampthatampitamphelpsamphimamptoampbetterampunderstandamp
hisampworkampampInampaampstyleampofampwritingampthatamposcillatesamparoundampjournalingampdocumentationampandamp
poetryampdeampCossonamp(2002)ampexploresamphisampoverlappingamprolesampasampanampartistampresearcherampandamp
teacherampampOtherampartistsampbluramptheamplineampbetweenampartamppracticeampdocumentationampandamplifeamp
furtherampstillampbyampofferingampdocumentationampasampartamplikeampSophieampCalleamp(Calleamp2011amp2008amp
2005)ampandampMaryampKellyamp(1973lt1979)ampampamp
amp Karpiakamp(2003)ampestablishesampcontemplativeamppracticesampfromamptheampperspectiveampofamp
theampeducatorampaskingampthemamptoampmineamptheampsubtleamp(pamp71)ampusingampattentivenessamp
attunementampamplificationampandampassociationampampTheseampexercisesampinampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampsetamptheamptoneampasampwellampasampprovideampaampmodelampofampbehaviorampforampotherampparticipantsamp
withinamptheampspaceampampKarpiakamp(2003)ampoutlinesampactivitiesampthatampeducatorsampcanampuseamptoampdrawamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 25amp
outampandamputilizeamptheseampsubtleampsensationsampinamptheampserviceampofamptransformativeamplearningamp(pamp
68)ampampamp
amp ForampKarpiakamp(2003)ampattentivenessamprequiresampawarenessamptoampverbalampandamp
nonverbalampcuesampasampwellampasampanampawarenessampofampwhatampisamphappeningampamongampandampwithinamptheamp
studentsampandamptheampeducatorampampAttunementamprequiresampanampeducatoramptoamporientampherselfamptoamptheamp
otherampandamptoampadoptampanampattitudeampofampunhurriednessampofamppatienceampandampofamphumilityamp
concerningampbothamptheampprocessampandamptheampoutcomesampofamptheampteachingamp(Karpiakamp2003amppgamp
72)ampampAmplificationampisampaampprocessampofamphonoringampcommunicationampthatampcentersamponamptheampideaamp
ofamphearingamponeselfampintoampknowingampitampincludesampusingampparaphrasingampandampclarificationamp
activitiesamptoampgainampinsightampintoampmeaningampampLastlyampassociationampentailsampidentifyingamp
patternsampandampweavingampthemamptogetherampwithampstudentampexperienceampclassroomampdiscussionamp
andamptheampideasampofampothersamp
amp TuningampintoampsubtletyampimpliesampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceampampTheampmanifestationsamp
ofampsilenceampinamptheampclassroomampareampendlessampandampitsampvalueampisamptooampgreatamptoampbeampignoredampwhileamp
tooampvastamptoampbeampfullyampabsorbedampampLevinamp(1989)ampremarksampthatampsilenceampisampaampclearingampwhereamp
thereampisampnothingampforamphearingamptoampholdamponamptoampinampwhichampmanyampfindampunbearableampanxietyamp
(pamp79)ampampNearlyampallampofampusamphaveampexperiencedampthisampunbearableampanxietyampaampstrainampofamp
whichampcanampbeampfoundampinampeducationalampcontextsampdueamptoamptheampfactampthatampclassroomsampareamp
oftenampstructuredamparoundampimplicitampandampexplicitamprulesampaboutamptalkampandampsilenceamp(Schultzamp
2010amppamp2848)ampampForampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampanampawarenessampofampsilenceampimplicatesamp
whatampisampleftampunsaidampandampwhatampisampunsayableltltespeciallyampimportantampbecauseampofamptheamp
unsayableampqualityampofampartworksampampForampSchultzamp(2010)ampsilenceampimpliesamppossibilityamp
becauseampitampcanampholdampmultipleampmeaningsampforampindividualsampwithinampandampacrossampracialamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 26amp
ethnicampandampculturalampgroupsamp(pamp2833)ampampLevinamp(1989)ampfindsampthatamptoamplistenamptoamp
somethingampweampmustampfirstampgive-itampourampsilenceamp(pamp232)ampampThisamppracticeampofampgivingampsilenceamp
isampparticularlyamphelpfulampinamptermsampofampviewingamporamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartamp
amp Gradleamp(2011)ampoutlinesampaamppracticalampvisionampforampviewingampartampthatamprequiresamp
silenceampandampdeliberationampampForamptheamppurposesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampwouldamp
reconceptualizeampthisampasampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampampGradleamp(2011)ampinstructedamp
herampstudentsamptoampspendamptimeampwithampaampworkampofampartampoutsideampofamptheirampeverydayampworldviewamp
attentivelyampviewingampitampforampaboutamptenampminutesampeverydayampforampaampweekampampAfterampeachampviewingamp
experienceamptheampstudentsampwroteampinamptheirampjournalsampampTheampresultsampindicatedampthatampthisamp
processampofampsustainedampsilentampdeliberationampcoupledampwithampanampengagementampofamptheiramp
intuitiveampperceptionsampaboutampartworkampleftampstudentsampfeelingampempoweredamptoampengageampinamp
discussionampandampappreciateampunfamiliarampartampformsampampThisampactivityampisampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoamp
aampworkampofampartampthatampincorporatesampSablesamp(2014)ampconceptampofampstructuredampcontemplationampamp
Weavingampaamprelationshipampbetweenampsilenceampcontemplationampandampattentivenessampisampaamp
significantampendeavorampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
Contemplativeamppracticesampfunctionampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Engageampinampformsampofampviewingampwritingampandampexperiencingampthatamphonorampselfltlisteningamp
bull Attuneamptoampsubtletyampandampnuanceampbull Listenampandampviewampdeliberatelyampbull Cultivateampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceamp(
The(Felt(Sense(
When-someone-understands-what-I-am-talking-about-when-I-talk-about-art-I-am-delighted--Art-is-my-everything--Its-my-passion--When-someone-understands-that-I-
am-instantly-filled-with-joy--That-tells-me-someone-gets-it-(Survey-response-CTF-age-16)-
(
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 12amp
amp TheampresidueampthatampclingsamptoamptheseampscrapsampisampexperienceampampTheampoldampsketchbookamp
pageampisampanampimageampofampaampwomansamplegamprenderedampwithampchunkyamppencilampstrokesampampYouampmadeampitamp
whenampyouampwereamplivingampinampyourampoldampapartmentampoverlookingamptheampsquareampampItsampaampwomansamp
footampbutampitampremindsampyouampofamphavingampaamproommateampandampaampgrayampfutonampandampaampsummerampthatamp
wasampdesperatelyamphotampampItampisamponlyamppencilamponamppaperampbutampitampremindsampyouampofamptheampgreenamp
grassyampcenterampinamptheampmedianampofamptheampstreetampampOneamppencilampdrawingampofampaampwomansamplegamp
remindsampyouampofampthatampoldamplifeampandamptheampversionampofampyourselfampyouampwereampthenampitampisamptheampfirstamp
dominoampinampaampseriesampofampcascadingampdetailsampandampmemoriesampamp
amp EachampfragmentampsittingamponampyourampstudioamptableamphasampaampstoryampampEachampcameampfromampaamp
placeampandampwasamptouchedampbyampanotheramphumanampampEachampisampembeddedampwithampexperienceampcoloramp
memoryamptextureampandampinfiniteampdetailampbyamptheampmereampfactampofampitsampownampexistenceampamp
amp YouampbeginamptoamppickampapartamptheampephemeraampampYouampalternateampbeingampcarefulampandamp
carelessamp
amp Cuttingamptearingampburningampstretchingampfoldingampwhitewashingamprippingampcreasingamp
sewingampwritingamppaintingampencasingampfasteningampfillingampsoakingampdyeingampwashingamp
dryingampbitingampscratchingamppryingampyankingampsmoothingampsandingamppokingampstabbingamp
stretchingampfryingampheatingampdustingampcleaningampsculptingampslicingampdicingamppunchingamp
floatingamptwistingampflippingampdrippingampstaplingampstrippingampstripingamppatterningamp
designingampdrawingampsketchingampliftingampcollectingamptapingampgluingampbuttoningampknottingamp
weavingampknittingamp
amp YouampdoampallampofamptheseampthingsampandampprobablyampmanyampotherampthingsampampTheampfragmentsamponamp
youramptableampchangeampshapeampandampgetampsmallerampampFromamptheseamppiecesampyouampbeginamptoampbuildamp
somethingampampThisampsomethingampisampbothampnewampandampoldampampJuxtapositionsampbloomampnewamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 13amp
connectionsampareampfusedampbyamptheampweightampofamppreviousampexperienceampampPastampandamppresentamp
liquefyampintoampendlesslyampcirculatingamppossibilitiesampampYouampcouldamptheoreticallyampcontinueampthisamp
processampofamplayeringampandampreconstructionampforeverampamptheamponlyamplimitsampareampyourampownamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 14amp
thread3(
what(is(a(creative=listening(space(
ampampampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeamplisteningampspaceampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampwhatampdoesampitampsoundampsmellamptasteampfeelamplikeampampampampampampampwhatampampisampamptheampamptextureampampofampampthisampampamp
spaceampampampanswerampmoreampquestionsampampamp specificsampandampgeneralizationsampareampbothampimpossibleampampmaybeampaampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampgoodampstartampwouldampbeampthisampampamp amp amp amp amp safeampampampamp amp amp amp amp foldedampampamp amp amp amp amp amp embodiedampamp layeredampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampconnectedampampampamp amp ampamp
(it-might--be-like-gently-holding-on-to--
a-knot-of-questions)-amp
ampampampampampampampampampamp
(possible)ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 15amp
thread4amp(
Review(of(Literature((
( AnampexplorationampofampGadamerrsquosamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampeducationalampcontextsampandampGendlinrsquosamptheoryampofampfeltampsenseampwereampintegralamptoamp
theampcreationampofamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampWhileampcompellingampconstructsamponamp
theirampownampwhenampdrawnamptogetheramptheseampphilosophicalampperspectivesampvibrateamp
holisticallyamptoampsuggestampintriguingamppossibilitiesampforamptheampuseampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
inampartsampeducationampampInampthisampsectionampIampreviewamptheampliteratureampandampconnectamptheampvariousamp
pointsampofampstudyampampamp
Hermeneutics(amp(the(Fusion(of(Horizons((
It-actually-feels-really-great-knowing-that-other-people-will-enjoy-the-art-you-created-and-knowing-they-know-your-reasoning-and-story-behind-it--Honestly-you-cant-know-if-your-words-are-getting-through-to-them-but-the-cool-thing-about-art-is-that-it-can-be-
interpreted-in-so-many-different-ways---(Survey-response-EK-age-15)-
ampamp Hermeneuticsampwhichamphasampitsamprootsampinamptextualampinterpretationampcanampbeampdefinedampasamp
aamptraditionampofampthinkingamporampofampphilosophicalampreflectionampthatamptriesamptoampclarifyamptheampconceptamp
ofampverstehenampthatampisampunderstandingamp(Brunsamp1992)ampampRicoeuramp(19691974)ampexplainsamp
thatamptheampkeyamphypothesisampofamphermeneuticampphilosophyampisampthatampinterpretationampisampanampopenamp
processampwhichampnoampsingleampvisionampcanampconcludeamp(pamp109)ampampWithampthisampinampmindampIampwillamp
exploreamphermeneuticsampasampitampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp HansltGeorgampGadameramp(1900lt2002)ampinvestigatesampaampmoderateampformampofamp
hermeneuticsampthatampisampparticularlyamprelevantampinampserviceamptoampartampeducationampampGadameramp
breaksampwithamphermeneuticamptraditionampbyampproposingampthatampthereampisampnoampabsolutelyampobjectiveamp
interpretationampreadersampareampnotampableamptoampescapeamptheampprejudicesampofamptheiramptimeamp(Gallagheramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 16amp
1992)ampampThisamphoweverampbecomesampanampopportunityampforamptheampcreationampofampmeaningampInampaamp
passageampthatampechoesamptheampendlesslyampunfoldingampnatureampofampcollageampCaputoamp(2000)amprefersamp
toampanampexchangeampbetweenamppastampandamppresentampinamptheampcreativeamppossibilitiesampofamphermeneuticamp
interpretationamp
amp Thereampisampaamprichnessampinamphistoricalampeventsampthatampjustampkeepsampunfoldingampwhichampisamp
amp certainlyampnotampgraspedampbyamptheamporiginalampprotagonistsampwhichampgraduallyampunfoldsamp
amp overamptheampcourseampofamptimeampandampwhichampisampinampprincipleampneverampfullyampunfoldedampItampisamp
amp anampexcessampwhichampkeepsampspillingampoveramp(pamp47)amp
amp Gadamersampphilosophyampofamphermeneuticampunderstandingampisampformedampthroughamphisamp
notionsampaboutamplanguageampdialogueampandampconversationamp(Caputoamp2000ampSeebohmamp2004)ampamp
InampadditionamptoampGadamersampimplicitamprelianceamponamplisteningampasampheampdiscussesampdialogueamphisamp
workampcapitalizesamponamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampinamplanguageamp(Heelanamp1985)ampmakingamphisamp
formampofamphermeneuticsampparticularlyampapplicableamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp Gadamersamptermampfusion-of-horizonsamprefersamptoamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampwithinampaamp
varietyampofampencountersampampAampfusionampofamphorizonsampcanampbeampdescribedampasampaampdialogicamp
conversationampbetweenampreaderampandamptextamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampWithinamptheamptextualamp
paradigmampGadamerampbelievesampthatampaampwrittenamptextampisampopenamptoampanampinvisibleampandampindefiniteamp
readerampwhoampentersampintoampanampunknownampadventureampofamptheamptextamp(Ricoeuramp2013amppamp13)ampamp
Theamphorizonampitselfampisamptheamprangeampofampvisionampthatampincludesampeverythingampthatampcanampbeampseenamp
fromampaampparticularampvantageamppointamp(Gadameramp2004amppamp301)ampampLikeampcollageamptheampfusionampofamp
horizonsampisampaampprocessampcomposedampofamppastampandamppresentampwhichampareampopenamptoampandampinfinitelyamp
effectedampbyampeachampotheramp(Bourgeoisamp2007)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 17amp
amp Similarampconnectionsampcanampbeampdrawnampwhenampviewerampandampartworkampareampsubstitutedamp
forampreaderampandamptextampampInterpretationampandampunderstandingampbecomeampanampentwinedamp
creativeampendeavorampinampwhichamptheampviewerampparticipatesampasampmuchampasamptheampcreatorampbyamp
constructingampmeaningamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampPalmeramp(1969)ampalludesamptoamptheamppluralityampofamp
meaningampinampstatingampthatamptoampfocusamppurelyamponamptheamppositivityampofampwhatampaamptextampexplicitlyamp
saysampisamptoampdoampanampinjusticeamptoamptheamphermeneuticalamptaskamp(pamp234)ampampToampfocusamponampwhatampisamp
explicitampinampaampcollageampworkampwouldampbeamptoampdisregardamptheampconnectionsampandampcontradictionsamp
ofamptheampwholeampinampfavorampofampaampdirectampreadingampofamptheampindividualamppartsampthusampmissingampoutamponamp
otheramppossibleampdimensionsampofampmeaningamp
amp Theampkeyamptoamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampeducationampinamptextampandampbetweenamp
individualsampisamptheampabilityamptoamplistenampwithampopennessampampDefensiveamplisteningampisampaampwayampofamp
listeningampwithoutampopennessampitampisampaampwayampofampprotectingampourampsmallampversionampofamptheampworldamp
andampavoidingampmoralampclaimsamponampourselvesamp(Levinamp1989amppamp79)ampampLevinamp(1989)amp
discussesampplayfulamplisteningamp(pamp233)ampasampaampwayampofampcounteractingampdefensiveamplisteningampampamp
Bohmamp(1996)ampdiscussesampsuspendingampassumptionsampaampprocessampofampattendingamptoamp
assumptionsampratherampthanamprepressingampthemamporampcarryingampthemampoutampampNicholamp(1996)amp
explainsampaampcircumstanceampinampwhichampyouampencounterampaamppersonampyouampfeelampisampanampidiotampampampYouamp
wouldamprefrainampfromampsayingampsoampoutamploudampbutampyouampwouldampalsoamprefrainampfromampscoldingamp
yourselfampforampthisampthoughtampratherampyouampwouldampseeampthisampreactionampwithoutampfullyampengagingamp
withampitampampSimilarampsuggestionsamplikeampbracketingampofampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampareamp
discussedampinamptheampfollowingampsectionampamp
amp Gadamerampbelievesamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampwhatampallowsamptheampselfamptoampapproachamp
theampotherampitampisampaampprocessampinampwhichamptheampideasampofamptheampotherampbecomeamponesampownamp(Caputoamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 18amp
2000)ampampThisampisamphardlyampanampuncommonampexperienceampampInampfactampweampregularlyampencounteramptheamp
fusionampofamphorizonsampbyampintegratingamppastampunderstandingsampwithampcurrentampexperiencesampaamp
processampundoubtedlyampcomparableamptoampeducationamp(Zuckertamp2002)ampamp
amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsamplikeampeducationampcanampbeampfrustratingampandampemotionalamp
becauseampeachamphighlight[s]amptheampfinitudeampofamptheampinterpreterampandamptheamplimitationsampofamphisamp
understandingamp(Bourgeoisamp2007amppamp79)ampampTheamptermampsharesampsimilaritiesampwithamptheamp
problematic-momentampaamppedagogicalamptermampreferringamptoampaampbreachampinampaampdominantampgroupsamp
discourseampduringampwhichampsomethingamprepressedamparisesamp(KentampampampCummingamp2008)ampampKentamp
andampCummingamp(2008)ampexploreamptheampproblematicampmomentampasampaampdiscursiveampsiteampforamp
examiningampprejudiceampwithinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampandampitsamp
moreamppoliticallyampchargedampcounterpartamptheampproblematicampmomentampbothampexploreamp
Gadamersamp(1996)ampampassertionampthatamptheampotherampmayampnotamponlyamphaveampaamprightampbutampmayamp
actuallyampbeamprightampmayampunderstandampsomethingampbetterampthanampweampdoamp(pamp82)ampampAampcreativelt
listeningampspaceamplivesampinampthisamppossibilityampampamp
amp Lastlyamprelayingampofampappropriateampexpectationsamptoampparticipantsampisampaampnecessaryamp
featureampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampdemandingampampItamp
requiresampparticipantsampwhoampareampawareampofamptheamprisksampandamphardshipsamptoampenterampintoampitampampItamp
isamptheampresponsibilityampofamptheampeducatoramporampgroupampleaderamptoampmakeamptheseampexpectationsamp
knownampasampwellampasamptoampmodelampthisampbehaviorampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionamphermeneuticallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Areampopenamptoamppossibilitiesampandamptoamptheampotherampbull Conceiveampofampthemselvesampasampengagingampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamptheamprisksampinvolvedampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamplimitationsampofamptheirampunderstandingamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 19amp
Dialogic(Practices(-
I-felt-that-everyone-was-open-and-interested-in-what-I-had-to-say---Perhaps-I-felt-this-sense-of-understanding-due-to-the-nature-of-the-discussion((-
it-felt-[like]-more-[of]-a-dialogue-as-opposed-to-a-standard-critique-(Survey-response-MW-age-22)-
(amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampartampeducationampreliesamponampanampopenampdialogueampduringamp
experiencesampwithampartampselfampandampothersampampWhatampIampfoundamplackingampinamphermeneuticsamp
howeverampwasampaampdiscussionampofamptheamphowltlthowampisamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampachievedampandamp
howampdoampindividualsampmeaningfullyampengageampwithampeachampotherampampInampanampeffortamptoampclarifyampthisamp
Iampwillampdiscussampdialogicamppracticesampasamptheyamprelateamptoampmeaningfulampverbalampexchangesampandamp
listeningampencountersampinamptheampclassroomampandampstudioampamongstampstudentsamptheiramppeersampandamp
educatorsamp
amp Communicatingampthroughamplanguageampandampdialogueampisamphowampweampcoltconstructamp
worldsampwithampourselvesampandampothersampnotampjustampthroughampanampactampofamptransmissionampbutamp
becauseampourampcommunicativeampactsampgiveampbirthamptoampworldsamp(Lipariamp2014amppamp507)ampampSableamp
(2014)ampdescribesampdialogueampasampaampgenerativeampinterchangeampbetweenampparticipantsampasamp
opposedamptoampanampexchangeampofampviewsampwhereampindividualsampsimplyampadvocateamptheiramppositionsamp
(pamp8)ampampForampBohmamp(1996)ampitampisampaampstreamampofampmeaningampflowingampamongampandampthroughampusamp
(pamp6)ampampTheampnatureampofampdialogueampandampconversationampisampinherentlyampunplannedampampThisamp
dimensionampofampconversationampisampimportantamptoampGadameramp(2004)ampwhoampfindsampthatamp
participantsampinvolvedampinampconversationampareamplessamptheampleadersampofampitampthanamptheampledamp(pamp
385)ampampSableamp(2014)ampechoesampthisampbyampwritingampthatamptheampmostampimportantamppartsampofampanyamp
conversationampareampthoseampthatampneitheramppartyampcouldamphaveampimaginedampbeforeampstartingamp(pamp
8)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 20amp
amp Theseampareampnotionsampofampdialogueampamongampothersampthatampfindampaampparallelampinamptheamp
creativeampprocessampampFairfieldamp(2011)ampwritesampthatampinampprincipleampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinamp
dialogueamp(pamp83)ampaampsentimentampthatampalignsampwithampaampcommonampissueampencounteredampduringamp
theampcreativeampprocessltltnotampknowingampwhenampaamppieceampisampdoneampampAampquoteampoftenampattributedamp
toampLeonardoampdaampVinciampspeaksamptoampthisampideaampArtampisampneverampfinishedamponlyampabandonedampamp
Snowberamp(2007)ampdrawsampparallelsampbetweenampmentorshipampdialogueampandamptheampcreativeamp
processampfindingampthatampdeepamplisteningamppracticesampconnectampallampthreeampampSheampfindsampthatamptheamp
taskampofamptheampmentorampisamptheampsameampasamptheamptaskampofamptheampartistampthatampisamptoampbringampoutamptheamp
naturalampqualitiesampofamptheampstudentamporamptheampmediumampampSnowberamp(2007)ampcommentsamponampanamp
ideaampwellltknownampamongampartistsampwhichampisampthatampaampworkampofampartamphasampaamplifeampofampitsampownampthisamp
notionampisampreminiscentampofampGadamersampstatementampaboutampbeingampledampbyampconversationamp
ampamp Dialogicamppracticesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampeducationampemphasizeampaamp
phenomenologicalampdimensionamprequiringamptwoampthingsampfromampparticipantsampampFirstlyamp
participantsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampmustampfindampvalueampinamplisteningamptoamptheamp
narrativesampofamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampampTheseampparticipantsampknowampthatampeducationamp
isampforemostampaboutamptestimonyampaboutampsharingamptheampexperienceampofampbeingamphumanampsharingamp
lifeampconvictionsampandampknowledge((Wiercinskiamp2011amppamp109)ampampNarrativesampareamp
conceivedampofampasampaampwayampofamphumanampknowingamp(Vitanovaamp2010amppamp29)ampthatampmakesamptheamp
selfampampSecondlyampwhenamplisteningamptoamptheampnarrativesampofampothersampparticipantsampareampexpectedamp
toampbracketamptheirampownampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsamp(LindsethampampampNorbergamp2004)ampampThisamp
encouragesamplistenersamptoampexperienceampandampfindampmeaningampinamptheampnarrativesampofampothersamp
whileampfreeingamptheampspeakerampfromamptheampfearampofampbeingampjudgedampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 21amp
amp Bracketingampjudgmentampandampconclusionampisampaamppotentialamptoolampwithinamptheampcommonamp
artampeducationamppracticeampofampgroupampcritiquesampampElkinsamp(2001)ampfindsampthatamppeopleampwhoamphaveamp
experienceampinampartampjudgeampveryampquicklyampandampmostampteachersampwillamphaveampaampprovisionalamp
opinionampaboutampaampworkampinamptheampfirstamptenampsecondsamp(pamp121)ampampBracketingampconclusionampandamp
judgmentampisampparticularlyampimportantampforampeducatorsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
whoseampvolumeampofampviewingampexperiencesampcouldampleadamptoampeasyampassumptionsampwhenamp
encounteringampaampnewampworkampampamp
amp Elkinsamp(2001)ampdiscussesampthatampcritiquesampcanampalsoampbeampseenampasampexchangesampofamp
storiesamporampcollaborativeampstorytellingamp(pamp145)ampwhichampisampyetampanotherampwayampofamptalkingamp
aboutamppossibilitiesampforampdialogueampandampnarrativeampwithinampartampeducationampampElkinsamphoweveramp
findsampstorytellingamplimitingamponceamptheampdeeperampnarrativesampareampdiscoveredamp(2001amppamp
145)ampampThisampimpliesampthatampheampfindsamponlyampaampsingularampmeaningampandamponeampthatampisampnotamp
necessarilyampusefulampforampcollaborativeampgroupampcritiquesamp
amp Insteadampparticipantsampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampbringampknowledgeampofamp
polysemyamptoampcollaborativeampcritiqueampexperiencesampasampwellampasamptoampexperiencesampofampmakingamp
artworkampampAccordingamptoampMuldoonamp(2002)amppolysemyampisamptheampqualityampofampaampwordamporampotheramp
languageampunitampthatampcanampbearampmultipleampmeaningsamp(asampcitedampinampWorsleyamp2012amppamp308)ampampamp
Aamptextualampexampleampofampthisampisamptheampmultipleampmeaningsampofamptheampwordampcan-Iampcanampdriveampaampcaramp
Idamplikeampaampcan-ofampsodaampheampwasntampworkingampveryamphardampsoampIamphadamptoampcan-himamp(Munozamp
2014)ampampampButampifampweampconsideramppolysemyampmetaphoricallyamporampvisuallyamptheampideaampthatampaamp
singleampunitampimageamporampintentionampcouldampbearampmultipleampmeaningsampcouldampbeampproductiveampinamp
creatingltlisteningampspacesampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 22amp
amp Thisampunfoldingampofampmeaningampworksampwellampinamptheampcontextampofampcollageampandampdialogueamp
asampwellampasamphermeneuticsampampInampfactamphermeneuticsampimpliesamppolysemyampbecauseampofampitsamp
notionampthatampitampisampalwaysampaamppossibilityampofampmyampunderstandingampthatampisampplayedampoutampwhenampIamp
understandampaamptextamp(Grondinamp2002amppamp38)ampampPolysemyampcouldampbeampconceptualizedampasampanamp
alternativeampexplorationampofampmeaningampthatampfunctionsampcollaborativelyampwithinampcritiquesampamp
Forampexampleampeducatorsampcanampaskampstudentsamptoamprespondamptoampaampworkampthroughampcollageamp
journalampentriesampmusicampfilmampasampindividualsamporampinampgroupsampampKnowledgeampofamppolysemyamp
couldampalsoampbeampusedampasampaamptoolampforampcreatingampimagesampthatamprecognizesampaamprelationshipamp
betweenamptheampvisualamptheamplinguisticampandamptheampmultipleamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionampdialogicallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Placeampvalueamponampexperientialampnarrativesampbull Practiceamplisteningampbyampbracketingampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampbull Embraceamppolysemicampexplorationsampofampmeaningampamp
Contemplative(Practices(
I-knew-I-was-being-heard-because-of-her-mannerisms-and-the-look-on-her-face--She-was-calm-attentive-and-not-trying-to-jump-in-and-offer-any-advice--She-asked-questions-that-pointed-to-things-I-had-not-openly-articulated-because-of-uncertainty--
This-was-one-of-the-ways-I-knew-I-was-being-heard-(Survey-response-LS-age-27)-
(amp Ifamphermeneuticsampandampdialogicamppracticesampgiveampusamptheampbroadampstrokesampofampactivityampinamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampcontemplativeamppracticesampseekamptoamptuneampstudentsampandamp
educatorsampintoampnuanceampdeliberationampandampdeepampexplorationampampThisampisampaampmostlyamp
individualampinternalamppursuitampthatampfocusesamponampformsampofampselfltlisteningampbutampcontemplativeamp
practicesampareampalsoampformedampbyampanampawarenessampofampinterconnectednessamp
amp InamppursuitampofampcriticalampthinkingampSableamp(2014)ampoutlinesampaampsetampofampcontemplativeamp
practicesampforampstudentsampthatampincludeampmindfulampmeditationampstructuredampcontemplationamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 23amp
journalampwritingampmindfulamplisteningampreflectiveampinquiryampandampdialogueamp(pamp4)ampampWhileamp
Sablesamp(2014)ampmethodampforampcontemplativeamppracticesampprovidesampaampconcreteampframeworkamp
withampspecificampstepsampmanyampofamptheseampconceptsampcouldampbeampappliedampwithoutampsuchampaamp
prescribedampstructureampampForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwillampbeamp
primarilyampdiscussingampSablesampconceptsampofampstructuredampcontemplationampreflectiveamp
inquiryampandampjournalampwritingamp
amp ForampSableamp(2014)ampstructuredampcontemplationampisampaampformampofampbeingamppresentampandamp
focusedamponampaampparticularampquestionampstatementamporampimageampampWithinampthisampmodeampofampinquiryamp
participantsampareampexpectedamptoampholdamptheampobjectampofampcontemplationampinamptheirampmindsamp
deepeningampunderstandingampasamptheyampfocusampwithoutampanalyzingampitamporampmanipulatingampitampinamp
anyampwayamp(pamp5)ampampThisamppracticeampdrawsampcomparisonsamptoamptheampbracketingampofampjudgmentsamp
andampconclusionsampsupportedampinamptheamppreviousampsectionampbutampstructuredampcontemplationamp
occursamponampanampindividualamplevelampratherampthanampdialogicallyamp
amp Reflectiveampinquiryampbearsampsomeampsimilaritiesamptoampstructuredampcontemplationampbutamp
Sableamp(2014)amppositionsampitampasampanampactivityampbetweenamptwoampindividualsampaamplistenerampandampaamp
speakerampampTheamplistenerampisampagainampaskedamptoampsuspendampjudgmentampbutampalsoamptoampengageampinampaamp
formampofampcuriosityampinampwhichampinnocentampquestionsampareampaskedampinamporderamptoampgainamp
understandingampampSableamp(2014)ampcontrastsampinnocentampquestionsampwithampleadingampquestionsampamp
ForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwouldampcharacterizeampthisampinnocentamp
questioningampasampaampformampofampopenltendedampquestioningampampSableamp(2014)ampidentifiesampanamp
exampleampofampanampinnocentamp(orampopenltended)ampquestionampWhatampdidampyouampmeanampwhenampyouamp
saidamp________ampConverselyampaampleadingampquestionampisampDidampyouampmeanamptoampsayamp________ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 24amp
amp Sableamp(2014)ampusesampjournalampwritingampasampaamppieceampofamphisamplargerampstructureampofamp
contemplativeamppracticesampbutampjournalampwritingampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampcouldamp
potentiallyampoccupyampaampsignificantamproleampampIampconceiveampofampjournalampwritingampinampmyampownamp
creativeamppracticeampasampaampformampofampdocumentationampthatampmakesampmeampmoreampawareampofampmyamp
creativeampprocessamptheampemotionalamphabitsampthatampsurroundampitampandamptheampthemesampthatamp
structureampmyampworkampampIampconceptualizeampthisampwayampofampwritingampasampaampformampofampselfltlisteningamp
relatedamptoampaampkeyampconceptampofamphermeneuticsampfoundampinampGadamersampassertionampthatampallamp
educationampisampaampformampofampselflteducationamp(Grondinamp2011)ampampamp
amp Germeraadamp(2013)ampusesampjournalampwritingamptoampexploreamptheampemotionalampandamprationalamp
relationshipsamptoamphisampcreativeampprocessampparallelamptoampexecutingampaampnewampbodyampofampworkampampHeamp
findsampthatampwritingampduringamphisampprocessampisampaamptoolamptoampunderstandamp[his]amppsycheamptoampeaseamp
theamppainampthatampanampartisticampprocessampcanampbringampandamptoamprelieveampartisticampblocksamp
(Germeraadamp2013amppamp21)ampultimatelyampdeclaringampthatampitamphelpsamphimamptoampbetterampunderstandamp
hisampworkampampInampaampstyleampofampwritingampthatamposcillatesamparoundampjournalingampdocumentationampandamp
poetryampdeampCossonamp(2002)ampexploresamphisampoverlappingamprolesampasampanampartistampresearcherampandamp
teacherampampOtherampartistsampbluramptheamplineampbetweenampartamppracticeampdocumentationampandamplifeamp
furtherampstillampbyampofferingampdocumentationampasampartamplikeampSophieampCalleamp(Calleamp2011amp2008amp
2005)ampandampMaryampKellyamp(1973lt1979)ampampamp
amp Karpiakamp(2003)ampestablishesampcontemplativeamppracticesampfromamptheampperspectiveampofamp
theampeducatorampaskingampthemamptoampmineamptheampsubtleamp(pamp71)ampusingampattentivenessamp
attunementampamplificationampandampassociationampampTheseampexercisesampinampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampsetamptheamptoneampasampwellampasampprovideampaampmodelampofampbehaviorampforampotherampparticipantsamp
withinamptheampspaceampampKarpiakamp(2003)ampoutlinesampactivitiesampthatampeducatorsampcanampuseamptoampdrawamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 25amp
outampandamputilizeamptheseampsubtleampsensationsampinamptheampserviceampofamptransformativeamplearningamp(pamp
68)ampampamp
amp ForampKarpiakamp(2003)ampattentivenessamprequiresampawarenessamptoampverbalampandamp
nonverbalampcuesampasampwellampasampanampawarenessampofampwhatampisamphappeningampamongampandampwithinamptheamp
studentsampandamptheampeducatorampampAttunementamprequiresampanampeducatoramptoamporientampherselfamptoamptheamp
otherampandamptoampadoptampanampattitudeampofampunhurriednessampofamppatienceampandampofamphumilityamp
concerningampbothamptheampprocessampandamptheampoutcomesampofamptheampteachingamp(Karpiakamp2003amppgamp
72)ampampAmplificationampisampaampprocessampofamphonoringampcommunicationampthatampcentersamponamptheampideaamp
ofamphearingamponeselfampintoampknowingampitampincludesampusingampparaphrasingampandampclarificationamp
activitiesamptoampgainampinsightampintoampmeaningampampLastlyampassociationampentailsampidentifyingamp
patternsampandampweavingampthemamptogetherampwithampstudentampexperienceampclassroomampdiscussionamp
andamptheampideasampofampothersamp
amp TuningampintoampsubtletyampimpliesampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceampampTheampmanifestationsamp
ofampsilenceampinamptheampclassroomampareampendlessampandampitsampvalueampisamptooampgreatamptoampbeampignoredampwhileamp
tooampvastamptoampbeampfullyampabsorbedampampLevinamp(1989)ampremarksampthatampsilenceampisampaampclearingampwhereamp
thereampisampnothingampforamphearingamptoampholdamponamptoampinampwhichampmanyampfindampunbearableampanxietyamp
(pamp79)ampampNearlyampallampofampusamphaveampexperiencedampthisampunbearableampanxietyampaampstrainampofamp
whichampcanampbeampfoundampinampeducationalampcontextsampdueamptoamptheampfactampthatampclassroomsampareamp
oftenampstructuredamparoundampimplicitampandampexplicitamprulesampaboutamptalkampandampsilenceamp(Schultzamp
2010amppamp2848)ampampForampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampanampawarenessampofampsilenceampimplicatesamp
whatampisampleftampunsaidampandampwhatampisampunsayableltltespeciallyampimportantampbecauseampofamptheamp
unsayableampqualityampofampartworksampampForampSchultzamp(2010)ampsilenceampimpliesamppossibilityamp
becauseampitampcanampholdampmultipleampmeaningsampforampindividualsampwithinampandampacrossampracialamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 26amp
ethnicampandampculturalampgroupsamp(pamp2833)ampampLevinamp(1989)ampfindsampthatamptoamplistenamptoamp
somethingampweampmustampfirstampgive-itampourampsilenceamp(pamp232)ampampThisamppracticeampofampgivingampsilenceamp
isampparticularlyamphelpfulampinamptermsampofampviewingamporamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartamp
amp Gradleamp(2011)ampoutlinesampaamppracticalampvisionampforampviewingampartampthatamprequiresamp
silenceampandampdeliberationampampForamptheamppurposesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampwouldamp
reconceptualizeampthisampasampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampampGradleamp(2011)ampinstructedamp
herampstudentsamptoampspendamptimeampwithampaampworkampofampartampoutsideampofamptheirampeverydayampworldviewamp
attentivelyampviewingampitampforampaboutamptenampminutesampeverydayampforampaampweekampampAfterampeachampviewingamp
experienceamptheampstudentsampwroteampinamptheirampjournalsampampTheampresultsampindicatedampthatampthisamp
processampofampsustainedampsilentampdeliberationampcoupledampwithampanampengagementampofamptheiramp
intuitiveampperceptionsampaboutampartworkampleftampstudentsampfeelingampempoweredamptoampengageampinamp
discussionampandampappreciateampunfamiliarampartampformsampampThisampactivityampisampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoamp
aampworkampofampartampthatampincorporatesampSablesamp(2014)ampconceptampofampstructuredampcontemplationampamp
Weavingampaamprelationshipampbetweenampsilenceampcontemplationampandampattentivenessampisampaamp
significantampendeavorampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
Contemplativeamppracticesampfunctionampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Engageampinampformsampofampviewingampwritingampandampexperiencingampthatamphonorampselfltlisteningamp
bull Attuneamptoampsubtletyampandampnuanceampbull Listenampandampviewampdeliberatelyampbull Cultivateampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceamp(
The(Felt(Sense(
When-someone-understands-what-I-am-talking-about-when-I-talk-about-art-I-am-delighted--Art-is-my-everything--Its-my-passion--When-someone-understands-that-I-
am-instantly-filled-with-joy--That-tells-me-someone-gets-it-(Survey-response-CTF-age-16)-
(
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 13amp
connectionsampareampfusedampbyamptheampweightampofamppreviousampexperienceampampPastampandamppresentamp
liquefyampintoampendlesslyampcirculatingamppossibilitiesampampYouampcouldamptheoreticallyampcontinueampthisamp
processampofamplayeringampandampreconstructionampforeverampamptheamponlyamplimitsampareampyourampownamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 14amp
thread3(
what(is(a(creative=listening(space(
ampampampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeamplisteningampspaceampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampwhatampdoesampitampsoundampsmellamptasteampfeelamplikeampampampampampampampwhatampampisampamptheampamptextureampampofampampthisampampamp
spaceampampampanswerampmoreampquestionsampampamp specificsampandampgeneralizationsampareampbothampimpossibleampampmaybeampaampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampgoodampstartampwouldampbeampthisampampamp amp amp amp amp safeampampampamp amp amp amp amp foldedampampamp amp amp amp amp amp embodiedampamp layeredampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampconnectedampampampamp amp ampamp
(it-might--be-like-gently-holding-on-to--
a-knot-of-questions)-amp
ampampampampampampampampampamp
(possible)ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 15amp
thread4amp(
Review(of(Literature((
( AnampexplorationampofampGadamerrsquosamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampeducationalampcontextsampandampGendlinrsquosamptheoryampofampfeltampsenseampwereampintegralamptoamp
theampcreationampofamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampWhileampcompellingampconstructsamponamp
theirampownampwhenampdrawnamptogetheramptheseampphilosophicalampperspectivesampvibrateamp
holisticallyamptoampsuggestampintriguingamppossibilitiesampforamptheampuseampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
inampartsampeducationampampInampthisampsectionampIampreviewamptheampliteratureampandampconnectamptheampvariousamp
pointsampofampstudyampampamp
Hermeneutics(amp(the(Fusion(of(Horizons((
It-actually-feels-really-great-knowing-that-other-people-will-enjoy-the-art-you-created-and-knowing-they-know-your-reasoning-and-story-behind-it--Honestly-you-cant-know-if-your-words-are-getting-through-to-them-but-the-cool-thing-about-art-is-that-it-can-be-
interpreted-in-so-many-different-ways---(Survey-response-EK-age-15)-
ampamp Hermeneuticsampwhichamphasampitsamprootsampinamptextualampinterpretationampcanampbeampdefinedampasamp
aamptraditionampofampthinkingamporampofampphilosophicalampreflectionampthatamptriesamptoampclarifyamptheampconceptamp
ofampverstehenampthatampisampunderstandingamp(Brunsamp1992)ampampRicoeuramp(19691974)ampexplainsamp
thatamptheampkeyamphypothesisampofamphermeneuticampphilosophyampisampthatampinterpretationampisampanampopenamp
processampwhichampnoampsingleampvisionampcanampconcludeamp(pamp109)ampampWithampthisampinampmindampIampwillamp
exploreamphermeneuticsampasampitampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp HansltGeorgampGadameramp(1900lt2002)ampinvestigatesampaampmoderateampformampofamp
hermeneuticsampthatampisampparticularlyamprelevantampinampserviceamptoampartampeducationampampGadameramp
breaksampwithamphermeneuticamptraditionampbyampproposingampthatampthereampisampnoampabsolutelyampobjectiveamp
interpretationampreadersampareampnotampableamptoampescapeamptheampprejudicesampofamptheiramptimeamp(Gallagheramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 16amp
1992)ampampThisamphoweverampbecomesampanampopportunityampforamptheampcreationampofampmeaningampInampaamp
passageampthatampechoesamptheampendlesslyampunfoldingampnatureampofampcollageampCaputoamp(2000)amprefersamp
toampanampexchangeampbetweenamppastampandamppresentampinamptheampcreativeamppossibilitiesampofamphermeneuticamp
interpretationamp
amp Thereampisampaamprichnessampinamphistoricalampeventsampthatampjustampkeepsampunfoldingampwhichampisamp
amp certainlyampnotampgraspedampbyamptheamporiginalampprotagonistsampwhichampgraduallyampunfoldsamp
amp overamptheampcourseampofamptimeampandampwhichampisampinampprincipleampneverampfullyampunfoldedampItampisamp
amp anampexcessampwhichampkeepsampspillingampoveramp(pamp47)amp
amp Gadamersampphilosophyampofamphermeneuticampunderstandingampisampformedampthroughamphisamp
notionsampaboutamplanguageampdialogueampandampconversationamp(Caputoamp2000ampSeebohmamp2004)ampamp
InampadditionamptoampGadamersampimplicitamprelianceamponamplisteningampasampheampdiscussesampdialogueamphisamp
workampcapitalizesamponamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampinamplanguageamp(Heelanamp1985)ampmakingamphisamp
formampofamphermeneuticsampparticularlyampapplicableamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp Gadamersamptermampfusion-of-horizonsamprefersamptoamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampwithinampaamp
varietyampofampencountersampampAampfusionampofamphorizonsampcanampbeampdescribedampasampaampdialogicamp
conversationampbetweenampreaderampandamptextamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampWithinamptheamptextualamp
paradigmampGadamerampbelievesampthatampaampwrittenamptextampisampopenamptoampanampinvisibleampandampindefiniteamp
readerampwhoampentersampintoampanampunknownampadventureampofamptheamptextamp(Ricoeuramp2013amppamp13)ampamp
Theamphorizonampitselfampisamptheamprangeampofampvisionampthatampincludesampeverythingampthatampcanampbeampseenamp
fromampaampparticularampvantageamppointamp(Gadameramp2004amppamp301)ampampLikeampcollageamptheampfusionampofamp
horizonsampisampaampprocessampcomposedampofamppastampandamppresentampwhichampareampopenamptoampandampinfinitelyamp
effectedampbyampeachampotheramp(Bourgeoisamp2007)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 17amp
amp Similarampconnectionsampcanampbeampdrawnampwhenampviewerampandampartworkampareampsubstitutedamp
forampreaderampandamptextampampInterpretationampandampunderstandingampbecomeampanampentwinedamp
creativeampendeavorampinampwhichamptheampviewerampparticipatesampasampmuchampasamptheampcreatorampbyamp
constructingampmeaningamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampPalmeramp(1969)ampalludesamptoamptheamppluralityampofamp
meaningampinampstatingampthatamptoampfocusamppurelyamponamptheamppositivityampofampwhatampaamptextampexplicitlyamp
saysampisamptoampdoampanampinjusticeamptoamptheamphermeneuticalamptaskamp(pamp234)ampampToampfocusamponampwhatampisamp
explicitampinampaampcollageampworkampwouldampbeamptoampdisregardamptheampconnectionsampandampcontradictionsamp
ofamptheampwholeampinampfavorampofampaampdirectampreadingampofamptheampindividualamppartsampthusampmissingampoutamponamp
otheramppossibleampdimensionsampofampmeaningamp
amp Theampkeyamptoamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampeducationampinamptextampandampbetweenamp
individualsampisamptheampabilityamptoamplistenampwithampopennessampampDefensiveamplisteningampisampaampwayampofamp
listeningampwithoutampopennessampitampisampaampwayampofampprotectingampourampsmallampversionampofamptheampworldamp
andampavoidingampmoralampclaimsamponampourselvesamp(Levinamp1989amppamp79)ampampLevinamp(1989)amp
discussesampplayfulamplisteningamp(pamp233)ampasampaampwayampofampcounteractingampdefensiveamplisteningampampamp
Bohmamp(1996)ampdiscussesampsuspendingampassumptionsampaampprocessampofampattendingamptoamp
assumptionsampratherampthanamprepressingampthemamporampcarryingampthemampoutampampNicholamp(1996)amp
explainsampaampcircumstanceampinampwhichampyouampencounterampaamppersonampyouampfeelampisampanampidiotampampampYouamp
wouldamprefrainampfromampsayingampsoampoutamploudampbutampyouampwouldampalsoamprefrainampfromampscoldingamp
yourselfampforampthisampthoughtampratherampyouampwouldampseeampthisampreactionampwithoutampfullyampengagingamp
withampitampampSimilarampsuggestionsamplikeampbracketingampofampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampareamp
discussedampinamptheampfollowingampsectionampamp
amp Gadamerampbelievesamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampwhatampallowsamptheampselfamptoampapproachamp
theampotherampitampisampaampprocessampinampwhichamptheampideasampofamptheampotherampbecomeamponesampownamp(Caputoamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 18amp
2000)ampampThisampisamphardlyampanampuncommonampexperienceampampInampfactampweampregularlyampencounteramptheamp
fusionampofamphorizonsampbyampintegratingamppastampunderstandingsampwithampcurrentampexperiencesampaamp
processampundoubtedlyampcomparableamptoampeducationamp(Zuckertamp2002)ampamp
amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsamplikeampeducationampcanampbeampfrustratingampandampemotionalamp
becauseampeachamphighlight[s]amptheampfinitudeampofamptheampinterpreterampandamptheamplimitationsampofamphisamp
understandingamp(Bourgeoisamp2007amppamp79)ampampTheamptermampsharesampsimilaritiesampwithamptheamp
problematic-momentampaamppedagogicalamptermampreferringamptoampaampbreachampinampaampdominantampgroupsamp
discourseampduringampwhichampsomethingamprepressedamparisesamp(KentampampampCummingamp2008)ampampKentamp
andampCummingamp(2008)ampexploreamptheampproblematicampmomentampasampaampdiscursiveampsiteampforamp
examiningampprejudiceampwithinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampandampitsamp
moreamppoliticallyampchargedampcounterpartamptheampproblematicampmomentampbothampexploreamp
Gadamersamp(1996)ampampassertionampthatamptheampotherampmayampnotamponlyamphaveampaamprightampbutampmayamp
actuallyampbeamprightampmayampunderstandampsomethingampbetterampthanampweampdoamp(pamp82)ampampAampcreativelt
listeningampspaceamplivesampinampthisamppossibilityampampamp
amp Lastlyamprelayingampofampappropriateampexpectationsamptoampparticipantsampisampaampnecessaryamp
featureampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampdemandingampampItamp
requiresampparticipantsampwhoampareampawareampofamptheamprisksampandamphardshipsamptoampenterampintoampitampampItamp
isamptheampresponsibilityampofamptheampeducatoramporampgroupampleaderamptoampmakeamptheseampexpectationsamp
knownampasampwellampasamptoampmodelampthisampbehaviorampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionamphermeneuticallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Areampopenamptoamppossibilitiesampandamptoamptheampotherampbull Conceiveampofampthemselvesampasampengagingampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamptheamprisksampinvolvedampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamplimitationsampofamptheirampunderstandingamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 19amp
Dialogic(Practices(-
I-felt-that-everyone-was-open-and-interested-in-what-I-had-to-say---Perhaps-I-felt-this-sense-of-understanding-due-to-the-nature-of-the-discussion((-
it-felt-[like]-more-[of]-a-dialogue-as-opposed-to-a-standard-critique-(Survey-response-MW-age-22)-
(amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampartampeducationampreliesamponampanampopenampdialogueampduringamp
experiencesampwithampartampselfampandampothersampampWhatampIampfoundamplackingampinamphermeneuticsamp
howeverampwasampaampdiscussionampofamptheamphowltlthowampisamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampachievedampandamp
howampdoampindividualsampmeaningfullyampengageampwithampeachampotherampampInampanampeffortamptoampclarifyampthisamp
Iampwillampdiscussampdialogicamppracticesampasamptheyamprelateamptoampmeaningfulampverbalampexchangesampandamp
listeningampencountersampinamptheampclassroomampandampstudioampamongstampstudentsamptheiramppeersampandamp
educatorsamp
amp Communicatingampthroughamplanguageampandampdialogueampisamphowampweampcoltconstructamp
worldsampwithampourselvesampandampothersampnotampjustampthroughampanampactampofamptransmissionampbutamp
becauseampourampcommunicativeampactsampgiveampbirthamptoampworldsamp(Lipariamp2014amppamp507)ampampSableamp
(2014)ampdescribesampdialogueampasampaampgenerativeampinterchangeampbetweenampparticipantsampasamp
opposedamptoampanampexchangeampofampviewsampwhereampindividualsampsimplyampadvocateamptheiramppositionsamp
(pamp8)ampampForampBohmamp(1996)ampitampisampaampstreamampofampmeaningampflowingampamongampandampthroughampusamp
(pamp6)ampampTheampnatureampofampdialogueampandampconversationampisampinherentlyampunplannedampampThisamp
dimensionampofampconversationampisampimportantamptoampGadameramp(2004)ampwhoampfindsampthatamp
participantsampinvolvedampinampconversationampareamplessamptheampleadersampofampitampthanamptheampledamp(pamp
385)ampampSableamp(2014)ampechoesampthisampbyampwritingampthatamptheampmostampimportantamppartsampofampanyamp
conversationampareampthoseampthatampneitheramppartyampcouldamphaveampimaginedampbeforeampstartingamp(pamp
8)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 20amp
amp Theseampareampnotionsampofampdialogueampamongampothersampthatampfindampaampparallelampinamptheamp
creativeampprocessampampFairfieldamp(2011)ampwritesampthatampinampprincipleampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinamp
dialogueamp(pamp83)ampaampsentimentampthatampalignsampwithampaampcommonampissueampencounteredampduringamp
theampcreativeampprocessltltnotampknowingampwhenampaamppieceampisampdoneampampAampquoteampoftenampattributedamp
toampLeonardoampdaampVinciampspeaksamptoampthisampideaampArtampisampneverampfinishedamponlyampabandonedampamp
Snowberamp(2007)ampdrawsampparallelsampbetweenampmentorshipampdialogueampandamptheampcreativeamp
processampfindingampthatampdeepamplisteningamppracticesampconnectampallampthreeampampSheampfindsampthatamptheamp
taskampofamptheampmentorampisamptheampsameampasamptheamptaskampofamptheampartistampthatampisamptoampbringampoutamptheamp
naturalampqualitiesampofamptheampstudentamporamptheampmediumampampSnowberamp(2007)ampcommentsamponampanamp
ideaampwellltknownampamongampartistsampwhichampisampthatampaampworkampofampartamphasampaamplifeampofampitsampownampthisamp
notionampisampreminiscentampofampGadamersampstatementampaboutampbeingampledampbyampconversationamp
ampamp Dialogicamppracticesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampeducationampemphasizeampaamp
phenomenologicalampdimensionamprequiringamptwoampthingsampfromampparticipantsampampFirstlyamp
participantsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampmustampfindampvalueampinamplisteningamptoamptheamp
narrativesampofamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampampTheseampparticipantsampknowampthatampeducationamp
isampforemostampaboutamptestimonyampaboutampsharingamptheampexperienceampofampbeingamphumanampsharingamp
lifeampconvictionsampandampknowledge((Wiercinskiamp2011amppamp109)ampampNarrativesampareamp
conceivedampofampasampaampwayampofamphumanampknowingamp(Vitanovaamp2010amppamp29)ampthatampmakesamptheamp
selfampampSecondlyampwhenamplisteningamptoamptheampnarrativesampofampothersampparticipantsampareampexpectedamp
toampbracketamptheirampownampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsamp(LindsethampampampNorbergamp2004)ampampThisamp
encouragesamplistenersamptoampexperienceampandampfindampmeaningampinamptheampnarrativesampofampothersamp
whileampfreeingamptheampspeakerampfromamptheampfearampofampbeingampjudgedampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 21amp
amp Bracketingampjudgmentampandampconclusionampisampaamppotentialamptoolampwithinamptheampcommonamp
artampeducationamppracticeampofampgroupampcritiquesampampElkinsamp(2001)ampfindsampthatamppeopleampwhoamphaveamp
experienceampinampartampjudgeampveryampquicklyampandampmostampteachersampwillamphaveampaampprovisionalamp
opinionampaboutampaampworkampinamptheampfirstamptenampsecondsamp(pamp121)ampampBracketingampconclusionampandamp
judgmentampisampparticularlyampimportantampforampeducatorsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
whoseampvolumeampofampviewingampexperiencesampcouldampleadamptoampeasyampassumptionsampwhenamp
encounteringampaampnewampworkampampamp
amp Elkinsamp(2001)ampdiscussesampthatampcritiquesampcanampalsoampbeampseenampasampexchangesampofamp
storiesamporampcollaborativeampstorytellingamp(pamp145)ampwhichampisampyetampanotherampwayampofamptalkingamp
aboutamppossibilitiesampforampdialogueampandampnarrativeampwithinampartampeducationampampElkinsamphoweveramp
findsampstorytellingamplimitingamponceamptheampdeeperampnarrativesampareampdiscoveredamp(2001amppamp
145)ampampThisampimpliesampthatampheampfindsamponlyampaampsingularampmeaningampandamponeampthatampisampnotamp
necessarilyampusefulampforampcollaborativeampgroupampcritiquesamp
amp Insteadampparticipantsampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampbringampknowledgeampofamp
polysemyamptoampcollaborativeampcritiqueampexperiencesampasampwellampasamptoampexperiencesampofampmakingamp
artworkampampAccordingamptoampMuldoonamp(2002)amppolysemyampisamptheampqualityampofampaampwordamporampotheramp
languageampunitampthatampcanampbearampmultipleampmeaningsamp(asampcitedampinampWorsleyamp2012amppamp308)ampampamp
Aamptextualampexampleampofampthisampisamptheampmultipleampmeaningsampofamptheampwordampcan-Iampcanampdriveampaampcaramp
Idamplikeampaampcan-ofampsodaampheampwasntampworkingampveryamphardampsoampIamphadamptoampcan-himamp(Munozamp
2014)ampampampButampifampweampconsideramppolysemyampmetaphoricallyamporampvisuallyamptheampideaampthatampaamp
singleampunitampimageamporampintentionampcouldampbearampmultipleampmeaningsampcouldampbeampproductiveampinamp
creatingltlisteningampspacesampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 22amp
amp Thisampunfoldingampofampmeaningampworksampwellampinamptheampcontextampofampcollageampandampdialogueamp
asampwellampasamphermeneuticsampampInampfactamphermeneuticsampimpliesamppolysemyampbecauseampofampitsamp
notionampthatampitampisampalwaysampaamppossibilityampofampmyampunderstandingampthatampisampplayedampoutampwhenampIamp
understandampaamptextamp(Grondinamp2002amppamp38)ampampPolysemyampcouldampbeampconceptualizedampasampanamp
alternativeampexplorationampofampmeaningampthatampfunctionsampcollaborativelyampwithinampcritiquesampamp
Forampexampleampeducatorsampcanampaskampstudentsamptoamprespondamptoampaampworkampthroughampcollageamp
journalampentriesampmusicampfilmampasampindividualsamporampinampgroupsampampKnowledgeampofamppolysemyamp
couldampalsoampbeampusedampasampaamptoolampforampcreatingampimagesampthatamprecognizesampaamprelationshipamp
betweenamptheampvisualamptheamplinguisticampandamptheampmultipleamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionampdialogicallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Placeampvalueamponampexperientialampnarrativesampbull Practiceamplisteningampbyampbracketingampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampbull Embraceamppolysemicampexplorationsampofampmeaningampamp
Contemplative(Practices(
I-knew-I-was-being-heard-because-of-her-mannerisms-and-the-look-on-her-face--She-was-calm-attentive-and-not-trying-to-jump-in-and-offer-any-advice--She-asked-questions-that-pointed-to-things-I-had-not-openly-articulated-because-of-uncertainty--
This-was-one-of-the-ways-I-knew-I-was-being-heard-(Survey-response-LS-age-27)-
(amp Ifamphermeneuticsampandampdialogicamppracticesampgiveampusamptheampbroadampstrokesampofampactivityampinamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampcontemplativeamppracticesampseekamptoamptuneampstudentsampandamp
educatorsampintoampnuanceampdeliberationampandampdeepampexplorationampampThisampisampaampmostlyamp
individualampinternalamppursuitampthatampfocusesamponampformsampofampselfltlisteningampbutampcontemplativeamp
practicesampareampalsoampformedampbyampanampawarenessampofampinterconnectednessamp
amp InamppursuitampofampcriticalampthinkingampSableamp(2014)ampoutlinesampaampsetampofampcontemplativeamp
practicesampforampstudentsampthatampincludeampmindfulampmeditationampstructuredampcontemplationamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 23amp
journalampwritingampmindfulamplisteningampreflectiveampinquiryampandampdialogueamp(pamp4)ampampWhileamp
Sablesamp(2014)ampmethodampforampcontemplativeamppracticesampprovidesampaampconcreteampframeworkamp
withampspecificampstepsampmanyampofamptheseampconceptsampcouldampbeampappliedampwithoutampsuchampaamp
prescribedampstructureampampForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwillampbeamp
primarilyampdiscussingampSablesampconceptsampofampstructuredampcontemplationampreflectiveamp
inquiryampandampjournalampwritingamp
amp ForampSableamp(2014)ampstructuredampcontemplationampisampaampformampofampbeingamppresentampandamp
focusedamponampaampparticularampquestionampstatementamporampimageampampWithinampthisampmodeampofampinquiryamp
participantsampareampexpectedamptoampholdamptheampobjectampofampcontemplationampinamptheirampmindsamp
deepeningampunderstandingampasamptheyampfocusampwithoutampanalyzingampitamporampmanipulatingampitampinamp
anyampwayamp(pamp5)ampampThisamppracticeampdrawsampcomparisonsamptoamptheampbracketingampofampjudgmentsamp
andampconclusionsampsupportedampinamptheamppreviousampsectionampbutampstructuredampcontemplationamp
occursamponampanampindividualamplevelampratherampthanampdialogicallyamp
amp Reflectiveampinquiryampbearsampsomeampsimilaritiesamptoampstructuredampcontemplationampbutamp
Sableamp(2014)amppositionsampitampasampanampactivityampbetweenamptwoampindividualsampaamplistenerampandampaamp
speakerampampTheamplistenerampisampagainampaskedamptoampsuspendampjudgmentampbutampalsoamptoampengageampinampaamp
formampofampcuriosityampinampwhichampinnocentampquestionsampareampaskedampinamporderamptoampgainamp
understandingampampSableamp(2014)ampcontrastsampinnocentampquestionsampwithampleadingampquestionsampamp
ForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwouldampcharacterizeampthisampinnocentamp
questioningampasampaampformampofampopenltendedampquestioningampampSableamp(2014)ampidentifiesampanamp
exampleampofampanampinnocentamp(orampopenltended)ampquestionampWhatampdidampyouampmeanampwhenampyouamp
saidamp________ampConverselyampaampleadingampquestionampisampDidampyouampmeanamptoampsayamp________ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 24amp
amp Sableamp(2014)ampusesampjournalampwritingampasampaamppieceampofamphisamplargerampstructureampofamp
contemplativeamppracticesampbutampjournalampwritingampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampcouldamp
potentiallyampoccupyampaampsignificantamproleampampIampconceiveampofampjournalampwritingampinampmyampownamp
creativeamppracticeampasampaampformampofampdocumentationampthatampmakesampmeampmoreampawareampofampmyamp
creativeampprocessamptheampemotionalamphabitsampthatampsurroundampitampandamptheampthemesampthatamp
structureampmyampworkampampIampconceptualizeampthisampwayampofampwritingampasampaampformampofampselfltlisteningamp
relatedamptoampaampkeyampconceptampofamphermeneuticsampfoundampinampGadamersampassertionampthatampallamp
educationampisampaampformampofampselflteducationamp(Grondinamp2011)ampampamp
amp Germeraadamp(2013)ampusesampjournalampwritingamptoampexploreamptheampemotionalampandamprationalamp
relationshipsamptoamphisampcreativeampprocessampparallelamptoampexecutingampaampnewampbodyampofampworkampampHeamp
findsampthatampwritingampduringamphisampprocessampisampaamptoolamptoampunderstandamp[his]amppsycheamptoampeaseamp
theamppainampthatampanampartisticampprocessampcanampbringampandamptoamprelieveampartisticampblocksamp
(Germeraadamp2013amppamp21)ampultimatelyampdeclaringampthatampitamphelpsamphimamptoampbetterampunderstandamp
hisampworkampampInampaampstyleampofampwritingampthatamposcillatesamparoundampjournalingampdocumentationampandamp
poetryampdeampCossonamp(2002)ampexploresamphisampoverlappingamprolesampasampanampartistampresearcherampandamp
teacherampampOtherampartistsampbluramptheamplineampbetweenampartamppracticeampdocumentationampandamplifeamp
furtherampstillampbyampofferingampdocumentationampasampartamplikeampSophieampCalleamp(Calleamp2011amp2008amp
2005)ampandampMaryampKellyamp(1973lt1979)ampampamp
amp Karpiakamp(2003)ampestablishesampcontemplativeamppracticesampfromamptheampperspectiveampofamp
theampeducatorampaskingampthemamptoampmineamptheampsubtleamp(pamp71)ampusingampattentivenessamp
attunementampamplificationampandampassociationampampTheseampexercisesampinampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampsetamptheamptoneampasampwellampasampprovideampaampmodelampofampbehaviorampforampotherampparticipantsamp
withinamptheampspaceampampKarpiakamp(2003)ampoutlinesampactivitiesampthatampeducatorsampcanampuseamptoampdrawamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 25amp
outampandamputilizeamptheseampsubtleampsensationsampinamptheampserviceampofamptransformativeamplearningamp(pamp
68)ampampamp
amp ForampKarpiakamp(2003)ampattentivenessamprequiresampawarenessamptoampverbalampandamp
nonverbalampcuesampasampwellampasampanampawarenessampofampwhatampisamphappeningampamongampandampwithinamptheamp
studentsampandamptheampeducatorampampAttunementamprequiresampanampeducatoramptoamporientampherselfamptoamptheamp
otherampandamptoampadoptampanampattitudeampofampunhurriednessampofamppatienceampandampofamphumilityamp
concerningampbothamptheampprocessampandamptheampoutcomesampofamptheampteachingamp(Karpiakamp2003amppgamp
72)ampampAmplificationampisampaampprocessampofamphonoringampcommunicationampthatampcentersamponamptheampideaamp
ofamphearingamponeselfampintoampknowingampitampincludesampusingampparaphrasingampandampclarificationamp
activitiesamptoampgainampinsightampintoampmeaningampampLastlyampassociationampentailsampidentifyingamp
patternsampandampweavingampthemamptogetherampwithampstudentampexperienceampclassroomampdiscussionamp
andamptheampideasampofampothersamp
amp TuningampintoampsubtletyampimpliesampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceampampTheampmanifestationsamp
ofampsilenceampinamptheampclassroomampareampendlessampandampitsampvalueampisamptooampgreatamptoampbeampignoredampwhileamp
tooampvastamptoampbeampfullyampabsorbedampampLevinamp(1989)ampremarksampthatampsilenceampisampaampclearingampwhereamp
thereampisampnothingampforamphearingamptoampholdamponamptoampinampwhichampmanyampfindampunbearableampanxietyamp
(pamp79)ampampNearlyampallampofampusamphaveampexperiencedampthisampunbearableampanxietyampaampstrainampofamp
whichampcanampbeampfoundampinampeducationalampcontextsampdueamptoamptheampfactampthatampclassroomsampareamp
oftenampstructuredamparoundampimplicitampandampexplicitamprulesampaboutamptalkampandampsilenceamp(Schultzamp
2010amppamp2848)ampampForampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampanampawarenessampofampsilenceampimplicatesamp
whatampisampleftampunsaidampandampwhatampisampunsayableltltespeciallyampimportantampbecauseampofamptheamp
unsayableampqualityampofampartworksampampForampSchultzamp(2010)ampsilenceampimpliesamppossibilityamp
becauseampitampcanampholdampmultipleampmeaningsampforampindividualsampwithinampandampacrossampracialamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 26amp
ethnicampandampculturalampgroupsamp(pamp2833)ampampLevinamp(1989)ampfindsampthatamptoamplistenamptoamp
somethingampweampmustampfirstampgive-itampourampsilenceamp(pamp232)ampampThisamppracticeampofampgivingampsilenceamp
isampparticularlyamphelpfulampinamptermsampofampviewingamporamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartamp
amp Gradleamp(2011)ampoutlinesampaamppracticalampvisionampforampviewingampartampthatamprequiresamp
silenceampandampdeliberationampampForamptheamppurposesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampwouldamp
reconceptualizeampthisampasampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampampGradleamp(2011)ampinstructedamp
herampstudentsamptoampspendamptimeampwithampaampworkampofampartampoutsideampofamptheirampeverydayampworldviewamp
attentivelyampviewingampitampforampaboutamptenampminutesampeverydayampforampaampweekampampAfterampeachampviewingamp
experienceamptheampstudentsampwroteampinamptheirampjournalsampampTheampresultsampindicatedampthatampthisamp
processampofampsustainedampsilentampdeliberationampcoupledampwithampanampengagementampofamptheiramp
intuitiveampperceptionsampaboutampartworkampleftampstudentsampfeelingampempoweredamptoampengageampinamp
discussionampandampappreciateampunfamiliarampartampformsampampThisampactivityampisampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoamp
aampworkampofampartampthatampincorporatesampSablesamp(2014)ampconceptampofampstructuredampcontemplationampamp
Weavingampaamprelationshipampbetweenampsilenceampcontemplationampandampattentivenessampisampaamp
significantampendeavorampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
Contemplativeamppracticesampfunctionampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Engageampinampformsampofampviewingampwritingampandampexperiencingampthatamphonorampselfltlisteningamp
bull Attuneamptoampsubtletyampandampnuanceampbull Listenampandampviewampdeliberatelyampbull Cultivateampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceamp(
The(Felt(Sense(
When-someone-understands-what-I-am-talking-about-when-I-talk-about-art-I-am-delighted--Art-is-my-everything--Its-my-passion--When-someone-understands-that-I-
am-instantly-filled-with-joy--That-tells-me-someone-gets-it-(Survey-response-CTF-age-16)-
(
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 14amp
thread3(
what(is(a(creative=listening(space(
ampampampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampampwhatampisampaampcreativeamplisteningampspaceampwhatampisampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampwhatampdoesampitampsoundampsmellamptasteampfeelamplikeampampampampampampampwhatampampisampamptheampamptextureampampofampampthisampampamp
spaceampampampanswerampmoreampquestionsampampamp specificsampandampgeneralizationsampareampbothampimpossibleampampmaybeampaampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampgoodampstartampwouldampbeampthisampampamp amp amp amp amp safeampampampamp amp amp amp amp foldedampampamp amp amp amp amp amp embodiedampamp layeredampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampampconnectedampampampamp amp ampamp
(it-might--be-like-gently-holding-on-to--
a-knot-of-questions)-amp
ampampampampampampampampampamp
(possible)ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 15amp
thread4amp(
Review(of(Literature((
( AnampexplorationampofampGadamerrsquosamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampeducationalampcontextsampandampGendlinrsquosamptheoryampofampfeltampsenseampwereampintegralamptoamp
theampcreationampofamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampWhileampcompellingampconstructsamponamp
theirampownampwhenampdrawnamptogetheramptheseampphilosophicalampperspectivesampvibrateamp
holisticallyamptoampsuggestampintriguingamppossibilitiesampforamptheampuseampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
inampartsampeducationampampInampthisampsectionampIampreviewamptheampliteratureampandampconnectamptheampvariousamp
pointsampofampstudyampampamp
Hermeneutics(amp(the(Fusion(of(Horizons((
It-actually-feels-really-great-knowing-that-other-people-will-enjoy-the-art-you-created-and-knowing-they-know-your-reasoning-and-story-behind-it--Honestly-you-cant-know-if-your-words-are-getting-through-to-them-but-the-cool-thing-about-art-is-that-it-can-be-
interpreted-in-so-many-different-ways---(Survey-response-EK-age-15)-
ampamp Hermeneuticsampwhichamphasampitsamprootsampinamptextualampinterpretationampcanampbeampdefinedampasamp
aamptraditionampofampthinkingamporampofampphilosophicalampreflectionampthatamptriesamptoampclarifyamptheampconceptamp
ofampverstehenampthatampisampunderstandingamp(Brunsamp1992)ampampRicoeuramp(19691974)ampexplainsamp
thatamptheampkeyamphypothesisampofamphermeneuticampphilosophyampisampthatampinterpretationampisampanampopenamp
processampwhichampnoampsingleampvisionampcanampconcludeamp(pamp109)ampampWithampthisampinampmindampIampwillamp
exploreamphermeneuticsampasampitampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp HansltGeorgampGadameramp(1900lt2002)ampinvestigatesampaampmoderateampformampofamp
hermeneuticsampthatampisampparticularlyamprelevantampinampserviceamptoampartampeducationampampGadameramp
breaksampwithamphermeneuticamptraditionampbyampproposingampthatampthereampisampnoampabsolutelyampobjectiveamp
interpretationampreadersampareampnotampableamptoampescapeamptheampprejudicesampofamptheiramptimeamp(Gallagheramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 16amp
1992)ampampThisamphoweverampbecomesampanampopportunityampforamptheampcreationampofampmeaningampInampaamp
passageampthatampechoesamptheampendlesslyampunfoldingampnatureampofampcollageampCaputoamp(2000)amprefersamp
toampanampexchangeampbetweenamppastampandamppresentampinamptheampcreativeamppossibilitiesampofamphermeneuticamp
interpretationamp
amp Thereampisampaamprichnessampinamphistoricalampeventsampthatampjustampkeepsampunfoldingampwhichampisamp
amp certainlyampnotampgraspedampbyamptheamporiginalampprotagonistsampwhichampgraduallyampunfoldsamp
amp overamptheampcourseampofamptimeampandampwhichampisampinampprincipleampneverampfullyampunfoldedampItampisamp
amp anampexcessampwhichampkeepsampspillingampoveramp(pamp47)amp
amp Gadamersampphilosophyampofamphermeneuticampunderstandingampisampformedampthroughamphisamp
notionsampaboutamplanguageampdialogueampandampconversationamp(Caputoamp2000ampSeebohmamp2004)ampamp
InampadditionamptoampGadamersampimplicitamprelianceamponamplisteningampasampheampdiscussesampdialogueamphisamp
workampcapitalizesamponamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampinamplanguageamp(Heelanamp1985)ampmakingamphisamp
formampofamphermeneuticsampparticularlyampapplicableamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp Gadamersamptermampfusion-of-horizonsamprefersamptoamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampwithinampaamp
varietyampofampencountersampampAampfusionampofamphorizonsampcanampbeampdescribedampasampaampdialogicamp
conversationampbetweenampreaderampandamptextamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampWithinamptheamptextualamp
paradigmampGadamerampbelievesampthatampaampwrittenamptextampisampopenamptoampanampinvisibleampandampindefiniteamp
readerampwhoampentersampintoampanampunknownampadventureampofamptheamptextamp(Ricoeuramp2013amppamp13)ampamp
Theamphorizonampitselfampisamptheamprangeampofampvisionampthatampincludesampeverythingampthatampcanampbeampseenamp
fromampaampparticularampvantageamppointamp(Gadameramp2004amppamp301)ampampLikeampcollageamptheampfusionampofamp
horizonsampisampaampprocessampcomposedampofamppastampandamppresentampwhichampareampopenamptoampandampinfinitelyamp
effectedampbyampeachampotheramp(Bourgeoisamp2007)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 17amp
amp Similarampconnectionsampcanampbeampdrawnampwhenampviewerampandampartworkampareampsubstitutedamp
forampreaderampandamptextampampInterpretationampandampunderstandingampbecomeampanampentwinedamp
creativeampendeavorampinampwhichamptheampviewerampparticipatesampasampmuchampasamptheampcreatorampbyamp
constructingampmeaningamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampPalmeramp(1969)ampalludesamptoamptheamppluralityampofamp
meaningampinampstatingampthatamptoampfocusamppurelyamponamptheamppositivityampofampwhatampaamptextampexplicitlyamp
saysampisamptoampdoampanampinjusticeamptoamptheamphermeneuticalamptaskamp(pamp234)ampampToampfocusamponampwhatampisamp
explicitampinampaampcollageampworkampwouldampbeamptoampdisregardamptheampconnectionsampandampcontradictionsamp
ofamptheampwholeampinampfavorampofampaampdirectampreadingampofamptheampindividualamppartsampthusampmissingampoutamponamp
otheramppossibleampdimensionsampofampmeaningamp
amp Theampkeyamptoamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampeducationampinamptextampandampbetweenamp
individualsampisamptheampabilityamptoamplistenampwithampopennessampampDefensiveamplisteningampisampaampwayampofamp
listeningampwithoutampopennessampitampisampaampwayampofampprotectingampourampsmallampversionampofamptheampworldamp
andampavoidingampmoralampclaimsamponampourselvesamp(Levinamp1989amppamp79)ampampLevinamp(1989)amp
discussesampplayfulamplisteningamp(pamp233)ampasampaampwayampofampcounteractingampdefensiveamplisteningampampamp
Bohmamp(1996)ampdiscussesampsuspendingampassumptionsampaampprocessampofampattendingamptoamp
assumptionsampratherampthanamprepressingampthemamporampcarryingampthemampoutampampNicholamp(1996)amp
explainsampaampcircumstanceampinampwhichampyouampencounterampaamppersonampyouampfeelampisampanampidiotampampampYouamp
wouldamprefrainampfromampsayingampsoampoutamploudampbutampyouampwouldampalsoamprefrainampfromampscoldingamp
yourselfampforampthisampthoughtampratherampyouampwouldampseeampthisampreactionampwithoutampfullyampengagingamp
withampitampampSimilarampsuggestionsamplikeampbracketingampofampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampareamp
discussedampinamptheampfollowingampsectionampamp
amp Gadamerampbelievesamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampwhatampallowsamptheampselfamptoampapproachamp
theampotherampitampisampaampprocessampinampwhichamptheampideasampofamptheampotherampbecomeamponesampownamp(Caputoamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 18amp
2000)ampampThisampisamphardlyampanampuncommonampexperienceampampInampfactampweampregularlyampencounteramptheamp
fusionampofamphorizonsampbyampintegratingamppastampunderstandingsampwithampcurrentampexperiencesampaamp
processampundoubtedlyampcomparableamptoampeducationamp(Zuckertamp2002)ampamp
amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsamplikeampeducationampcanampbeampfrustratingampandampemotionalamp
becauseampeachamphighlight[s]amptheampfinitudeampofamptheampinterpreterampandamptheamplimitationsampofamphisamp
understandingamp(Bourgeoisamp2007amppamp79)ampampTheamptermampsharesampsimilaritiesampwithamptheamp
problematic-momentampaamppedagogicalamptermampreferringamptoampaampbreachampinampaampdominantampgroupsamp
discourseampduringampwhichampsomethingamprepressedamparisesamp(KentampampampCummingamp2008)ampampKentamp
andampCummingamp(2008)ampexploreamptheampproblematicampmomentampasampaampdiscursiveampsiteampforamp
examiningampprejudiceampwithinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampandampitsamp
moreamppoliticallyampchargedampcounterpartamptheampproblematicampmomentampbothampexploreamp
Gadamersamp(1996)ampampassertionampthatamptheampotherampmayampnotamponlyamphaveampaamprightampbutampmayamp
actuallyampbeamprightampmayampunderstandampsomethingampbetterampthanampweampdoamp(pamp82)ampampAampcreativelt
listeningampspaceamplivesampinampthisamppossibilityampampamp
amp Lastlyamprelayingampofampappropriateampexpectationsamptoampparticipantsampisampaampnecessaryamp
featureampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampdemandingampampItamp
requiresampparticipantsampwhoampareampawareampofamptheamprisksampandamphardshipsamptoampenterampintoampitampampItamp
isamptheampresponsibilityampofamptheampeducatoramporampgroupampleaderamptoampmakeamptheseampexpectationsamp
knownampasampwellampasamptoampmodelampthisampbehaviorampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionamphermeneuticallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Areampopenamptoamppossibilitiesampandamptoamptheampotherampbull Conceiveampofampthemselvesampasampengagingampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamptheamprisksampinvolvedampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamplimitationsampofamptheirampunderstandingamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 19amp
Dialogic(Practices(-
I-felt-that-everyone-was-open-and-interested-in-what-I-had-to-say---Perhaps-I-felt-this-sense-of-understanding-due-to-the-nature-of-the-discussion((-
it-felt-[like]-more-[of]-a-dialogue-as-opposed-to-a-standard-critique-(Survey-response-MW-age-22)-
(amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampartampeducationampreliesamponampanampopenampdialogueampduringamp
experiencesampwithampartampselfampandampothersampampWhatampIampfoundamplackingampinamphermeneuticsamp
howeverampwasampaampdiscussionampofamptheamphowltlthowampisamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampachievedampandamp
howampdoampindividualsampmeaningfullyampengageampwithampeachampotherampampInampanampeffortamptoampclarifyampthisamp
Iampwillampdiscussampdialogicamppracticesampasamptheyamprelateamptoampmeaningfulampverbalampexchangesampandamp
listeningampencountersampinamptheampclassroomampandampstudioampamongstampstudentsamptheiramppeersampandamp
educatorsamp
amp Communicatingampthroughamplanguageampandampdialogueampisamphowampweampcoltconstructamp
worldsampwithampourselvesampandampothersampnotampjustampthroughampanampactampofamptransmissionampbutamp
becauseampourampcommunicativeampactsampgiveampbirthamptoampworldsamp(Lipariamp2014amppamp507)ampampSableamp
(2014)ampdescribesampdialogueampasampaampgenerativeampinterchangeampbetweenampparticipantsampasamp
opposedamptoampanampexchangeampofampviewsampwhereampindividualsampsimplyampadvocateamptheiramppositionsamp
(pamp8)ampampForampBohmamp(1996)ampitampisampaampstreamampofampmeaningampflowingampamongampandampthroughampusamp
(pamp6)ampampTheampnatureampofampdialogueampandampconversationampisampinherentlyampunplannedampampThisamp
dimensionampofampconversationampisampimportantamptoampGadameramp(2004)ampwhoampfindsampthatamp
participantsampinvolvedampinampconversationampareamplessamptheampleadersampofampitampthanamptheampledamp(pamp
385)ampampSableamp(2014)ampechoesampthisampbyampwritingampthatamptheampmostampimportantamppartsampofampanyamp
conversationampareampthoseampthatampneitheramppartyampcouldamphaveampimaginedampbeforeampstartingamp(pamp
8)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 20amp
amp Theseampareampnotionsampofampdialogueampamongampothersampthatampfindampaampparallelampinamptheamp
creativeampprocessampampFairfieldamp(2011)ampwritesampthatampinampprincipleampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinamp
dialogueamp(pamp83)ampaampsentimentampthatampalignsampwithampaampcommonampissueampencounteredampduringamp
theampcreativeampprocessltltnotampknowingampwhenampaamppieceampisampdoneampampAampquoteampoftenampattributedamp
toampLeonardoampdaampVinciampspeaksamptoampthisampideaampArtampisampneverampfinishedamponlyampabandonedampamp
Snowberamp(2007)ampdrawsampparallelsampbetweenampmentorshipampdialogueampandamptheampcreativeamp
processampfindingampthatampdeepamplisteningamppracticesampconnectampallampthreeampampSheampfindsampthatamptheamp
taskampofamptheampmentorampisamptheampsameampasamptheamptaskampofamptheampartistampthatampisamptoampbringampoutamptheamp
naturalampqualitiesampofamptheampstudentamporamptheampmediumampampSnowberamp(2007)ampcommentsamponampanamp
ideaampwellltknownampamongampartistsampwhichampisampthatampaampworkampofampartamphasampaamplifeampofampitsampownampthisamp
notionampisampreminiscentampofampGadamersampstatementampaboutampbeingampledampbyampconversationamp
ampamp Dialogicamppracticesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampeducationampemphasizeampaamp
phenomenologicalampdimensionamprequiringamptwoampthingsampfromampparticipantsampampFirstlyamp
participantsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampmustampfindampvalueampinamplisteningamptoamptheamp
narrativesampofamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampampTheseampparticipantsampknowampthatampeducationamp
isampforemostampaboutamptestimonyampaboutampsharingamptheampexperienceampofampbeingamphumanampsharingamp
lifeampconvictionsampandampknowledge((Wiercinskiamp2011amppamp109)ampampNarrativesampareamp
conceivedampofampasampaampwayampofamphumanampknowingamp(Vitanovaamp2010amppamp29)ampthatampmakesamptheamp
selfampampSecondlyampwhenamplisteningamptoamptheampnarrativesampofampothersampparticipantsampareampexpectedamp
toampbracketamptheirampownampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsamp(LindsethampampampNorbergamp2004)ampampThisamp
encouragesamplistenersamptoampexperienceampandampfindampmeaningampinamptheampnarrativesampofampothersamp
whileampfreeingamptheampspeakerampfromamptheampfearampofampbeingampjudgedampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 21amp
amp Bracketingampjudgmentampandampconclusionampisampaamppotentialamptoolampwithinamptheampcommonamp
artampeducationamppracticeampofampgroupampcritiquesampampElkinsamp(2001)ampfindsampthatamppeopleampwhoamphaveamp
experienceampinampartampjudgeampveryampquicklyampandampmostampteachersampwillamphaveampaampprovisionalamp
opinionampaboutampaampworkampinamptheampfirstamptenampsecondsamp(pamp121)ampampBracketingampconclusionampandamp
judgmentampisampparticularlyampimportantampforampeducatorsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
whoseampvolumeampofampviewingampexperiencesampcouldampleadamptoampeasyampassumptionsampwhenamp
encounteringampaampnewampworkampampamp
amp Elkinsamp(2001)ampdiscussesampthatampcritiquesampcanampalsoampbeampseenampasampexchangesampofamp
storiesamporampcollaborativeampstorytellingamp(pamp145)ampwhichampisampyetampanotherampwayampofamptalkingamp
aboutamppossibilitiesampforampdialogueampandampnarrativeampwithinampartampeducationampampElkinsamphoweveramp
findsampstorytellingamplimitingamponceamptheampdeeperampnarrativesampareampdiscoveredamp(2001amppamp
145)ampampThisampimpliesampthatampheampfindsamponlyampaampsingularampmeaningampandamponeampthatampisampnotamp
necessarilyampusefulampforampcollaborativeampgroupampcritiquesamp
amp Insteadampparticipantsampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampbringampknowledgeampofamp
polysemyamptoampcollaborativeampcritiqueampexperiencesampasampwellampasamptoampexperiencesampofampmakingamp
artworkampampAccordingamptoampMuldoonamp(2002)amppolysemyampisamptheampqualityampofampaampwordamporampotheramp
languageampunitampthatampcanampbearampmultipleampmeaningsamp(asampcitedampinampWorsleyamp2012amppamp308)ampampamp
Aamptextualampexampleampofampthisampisamptheampmultipleampmeaningsampofamptheampwordampcan-Iampcanampdriveampaampcaramp
Idamplikeampaampcan-ofampsodaampheampwasntampworkingampveryamphardampsoampIamphadamptoampcan-himamp(Munozamp
2014)ampampampButampifampweampconsideramppolysemyampmetaphoricallyamporampvisuallyamptheampideaampthatampaamp
singleampunitampimageamporampintentionampcouldampbearampmultipleampmeaningsampcouldampbeampproductiveampinamp
creatingltlisteningampspacesampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 22amp
amp Thisampunfoldingampofampmeaningampworksampwellampinamptheampcontextampofampcollageampandampdialogueamp
asampwellampasamphermeneuticsampampInampfactamphermeneuticsampimpliesamppolysemyampbecauseampofampitsamp
notionampthatampitampisampalwaysampaamppossibilityampofampmyampunderstandingampthatampisampplayedampoutampwhenampIamp
understandampaamptextamp(Grondinamp2002amppamp38)ampampPolysemyampcouldampbeampconceptualizedampasampanamp
alternativeampexplorationampofampmeaningampthatampfunctionsampcollaborativelyampwithinampcritiquesampamp
Forampexampleampeducatorsampcanampaskampstudentsamptoamprespondamptoampaampworkampthroughampcollageamp
journalampentriesampmusicampfilmampasampindividualsamporampinampgroupsampampKnowledgeampofamppolysemyamp
couldampalsoampbeampusedampasampaamptoolampforampcreatingampimagesampthatamprecognizesampaamprelationshipamp
betweenamptheampvisualamptheamplinguisticampandamptheampmultipleamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionampdialogicallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Placeampvalueamponampexperientialampnarrativesampbull Practiceamplisteningampbyampbracketingampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampbull Embraceamppolysemicampexplorationsampofampmeaningampamp
Contemplative(Practices(
I-knew-I-was-being-heard-because-of-her-mannerisms-and-the-look-on-her-face--She-was-calm-attentive-and-not-trying-to-jump-in-and-offer-any-advice--She-asked-questions-that-pointed-to-things-I-had-not-openly-articulated-because-of-uncertainty--
This-was-one-of-the-ways-I-knew-I-was-being-heard-(Survey-response-LS-age-27)-
(amp Ifamphermeneuticsampandampdialogicamppracticesampgiveampusamptheampbroadampstrokesampofampactivityampinamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampcontemplativeamppracticesampseekamptoamptuneampstudentsampandamp
educatorsampintoampnuanceampdeliberationampandampdeepampexplorationampampThisampisampaampmostlyamp
individualampinternalamppursuitampthatampfocusesamponampformsampofampselfltlisteningampbutampcontemplativeamp
practicesampareampalsoampformedampbyampanampawarenessampofampinterconnectednessamp
amp InamppursuitampofampcriticalampthinkingampSableamp(2014)ampoutlinesampaampsetampofampcontemplativeamp
practicesampforampstudentsampthatampincludeampmindfulampmeditationampstructuredampcontemplationamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 23amp
journalampwritingampmindfulamplisteningampreflectiveampinquiryampandampdialogueamp(pamp4)ampampWhileamp
Sablesamp(2014)ampmethodampforampcontemplativeamppracticesampprovidesampaampconcreteampframeworkamp
withampspecificampstepsampmanyampofamptheseampconceptsampcouldampbeampappliedampwithoutampsuchampaamp
prescribedampstructureampampForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwillampbeamp
primarilyampdiscussingampSablesampconceptsampofampstructuredampcontemplationampreflectiveamp
inquiryampandampjournalampwritingamp
amp ForampSableamp(2014)ampstructuredampcontemplationampisampaampformampofampbeingamppresentampandamp
focusedamponampaampparticularampquestionampstatementamporampimageampampWithinampthisampmodeampofampinquiryamp
participantsampareampexpectedamptoampholdamptheampobjectampofampcontemplationampinamptheirampmindsamp
deepeningampunderstandingampasamptheyampfocusampwithoutampanalyzingampitamporampmanipulatingampitampinamp
anyampwayamp(pamp5)ampampThisamppracticeampdrawsampcomparisonsamptoamptheampbracketingampofampjudgmentsamp
andampconclusionsampsupportedampinamptheamppreviousampsectionampbutampstructuredampcontemplationamp
occursamponampanampindividualamplevelampratherampthanampdialogicallyamp
amp Reflectiveampinquiryampbearsampsomeampsimilaritiesamptoampstructuredampcontemplationampbutamp
Sableamp(2014)amppositionsampitampasampanampactivityampbetweenamptwoampindividualsampaamplistenerampandampaamp
speakerampampTheamplistenerampisampagainampaskedamptoampsuspendampjudgmentampbutampalsoamptoampengageampinampaamp
formampofampcuriosityampinampwhichampinnocentampquestionsampareampaskedampinamporderamptoampgainamp
understandingampampSableamp(2014)ampcontrastsampinnocentampquestionsampwithampleadingampquestionsampamp
ForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwouldampcharacterizeampthisampinnocentamp
questioningampasampaampformampofampopenltendedampquestioningampampSableamp(2014)ampidentifiesampanamp
exampleampofampanampinnocentamp(orampopenltended)ampquestionampWhatampdidampyouampmeanampwhenampyouamp
saidamp________ampConverselyampaampleadingampquestionampisampDidampyouampmeanamptoampsayamp________ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 24amp
amp Sableamp(2014)ampusesampjournalampwritingampasampaamppieceampofamphisamplargerampstructureampofamp
contemplativeamppracticesampbutampjournalampwritingampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampcouldamp
potentiallyampoccupyampaampsignificantamproleampampIampconceiveampofampjournalampwritingampinampmyampownamp
creativeamppracticeampasampaampformampofampdocumentationampthatampmakesampmeampmoreampawareampofampmyamp
creativeampprocessamptheampemotionalamphabitsampthatampsurroundampitampandamptheampthemesampthatamp
structureampmyampworkampampIampconceptualizeampthisampwayampofampwritingampasampaampformampofampselfltlisteningamp
relatedamptoampaampkeyampconceptampofamphermeneuticsampfoundampinampGadamersampassertionampthatampallamp
educationampisampaampformampofampselflteducationamp(Grondinamp2011)ampampamp
amp Germeraadamp(2013)ampusesampjournalampwritingamptoampexploreamptheampemotionalampandamprationalamp
relationshipsamptoamphisampcreativeampprocessampparallelamptoampexecutingampaampnewampbodyampofampworkampampHeamp
findsampthatampwritingampduringamphisampprocessampisampaamptoolamptoampunderstandamp[his]amppsycheamptoampeaseamp
theamppainampthatampanampartisticampprocessampcanampbringampandamptoamprelieveampartisticampblocksamp
(Germeraadamp2013amppamp21)ampultimatelyampdeclaringampthatampitamphelpsamphimamptoampbetterampunderstandamp
hisampworkampampInampaampstyleampofampwritingampthatamposcillatesamparoundampjournalingampdocumentationampandamp
poetryampdeampCossonamp(2002)ampexploresamphisampoverlappingamprolesampasampanampartistampresearcherampandamp
teacherampampOtherampartistsampbluramptheamplineampbetweenampartamppracticeampdocumentationampandamplifeamp
furtherampstillampbyampofferingampdocumentationampasampartamplikeampSophieampCalleamp(Calleamp2011amp2008amp
2005)ampandampMaryampKellyamp(1973lt1979)ampampamp
amp Karpiakamp(2003)ampestablishesampcontemplativeamppracticesampfromamptheampperspectiveampofamp
theampeducatorampaskingampthemamptoampmineamptheampsubtleamp(pamp71)ampusingampattentivenessamp
attunementampamplificationampandampassociationampampTheseampexercisesampinampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampsetamptheamptoneampasampwellampasampprovideampaampmodelampofampbehaviorampforampotherampparticipantsamp
withinamptheampspaceampampKarpiakamp(2003)ampoutlinesampactivitiesampthatampeducatorsampcanampuseamptoampdrawamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 25amp
outampandamputilizeamptheseampsubtleampsensationsampinamptheampserviceampofamptransformativeamplearningamp(pamp
68)ampampamp
amp ForampKarpiakamp(2003)ampattentivenessamprequiresampawarenessamptoampverbalampandamp
nonverbalampcuesampasampwellampasampanampawarenessampofampwhatampisamphappeningampamongampandampwithinamptheamp
studentsampandamptheampeducatorampampAttunementamprequiresampanampeducatoramptoamporientampherselfamptoamptheamp
otherampandamptoampadoptampanampattitudeampofampunhurriednessampofamppatienceampandampofamphumilityamp
concerningampbothamptheampprocessampandamptheampoutcomesampofamptheampteachingamp(Karpiakamp2003amppgamp
72)ampampAmplificationampisampaampprocessampofamphonoringampcommunicationampthatampcentersamponamptheampideaamp
ofamphearingamponeselfampintoampknowingampitampincludesampusingampparaphrasingampandampclarificationamp
activitiesamptoampgainampinsightampintoampmeaningampampLastlyampassociationampentailsampidentifyingamp
patternsampandampweavingampthemamptogetherampwithampstudentampexperienceampclassroomampdiscussionamp
andamptheampideasampofampothersamp
amp TuningampintoampsubtletyampimpliesampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceampampTheampmanifestationsamp
ofampsilenceampinamptheampclassroomampareampendlessampandampitsampvalueampisamptooampgreatamptoampbeampignoredampwhileamp
tooampvastamptoampbeampfullyampabsorbedampampLevinamp(1989)ampremarksampthatampsilenceampisampaampclearingampwhereamp
thereampisampnothingampforamphearingamptoampholdamponamptoampinampwhichampmanyampfindampunbearableampanxietyamp
(pamp79)ampampNearlyampallampofampusamphaveampexperiencedampthisampunbearableampanxietyampaampstrainampofamp
whichampcanampbeampfoundampinampeducationalampcontextsampdueamptoamptheampfactampthatampclassroomsampareamp
oftenampstructuredamparoundampimplicitampandampexplicitamprulesampaboutamptalkampandampsilenceamp(Schultzamp
2010amppamp2848)ampampForampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampanampawarenessampofampsilenceampimplicatesamp
whatampisampleftampunsaidampandampwhatampisampunsayableltltespeciallyampimportantampbecauseampofamptheamp
unsayableampqualityampofampartworksampampForampSchultzamp(2010)ampsilenceampimpliesamppossibilityamp
becauseampitampcanampholdampmultipleampmeaningsampforampindividualsampwithinampandampacrossampracialamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 26amp
ethnicampandampculturalampgroupsamp(pamp2833)ampampLevinamp(1989)ampfindsampthatamptoamplistenamptoamp
somethingampweampmustampfirstampgive-itampourampsilenceamp(pamp232)ampampThisamppracticeampofampgivingampsilenceamp
isampparticularlyamphelpfulampinamptermsampofampviewingamporamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartamp
amp Gradleamp(2011)ampoutlinesampaamppracticalampvisionampforampviewingampartampthatamprequiresamp
silenceampandampdeliberationampampForamptheamppurposesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampwouldamp
reconceptualizeampthisampasampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampampGradleamp(2011)ampinstructedamp
herampstudentsamptoampspendamptimeampwithampaampworkampofampartampoutsideampofamptheirampeverydayampworldviewamp
attentivelyampviewingampitampforampaboutamptenampminutesampeverydayampforampaampweekampampAfterampeachampviewingamp
experienceamptheampstudentsampwroteampinamptheirampjournalsampampTheampresultsampindicatedampthatampthisamp
processampofampsustainedampsilentampdeliberationampcoupledampwithampanampengagementampofamptheiramp
intuitiveampperceptionsampaboutampartworkampleftampstudentsampfeelingampempoweredamptoampengageampinamp
discussionampandampappreciateampunfamiliarampartampformsampampThisampactivityampisampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoamp
aampworkampofampartampthatampincorporatesampSablesamp(2014)ampconceptampofampstructuredampcontemplationampamp
Weavingampaamprelationshipampbetweenampsilenceampcontemplationampandampattentivenessampisampaamp
significantampendeavorampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
Contemplativeamppracticesampfunctionampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Engageampinampformsampofampviewingampwritingampandampexperiencingampthatamphonorampselfltlisteningamp
bull Attuneamptoampsubtletyampandampnuanceampbull Listenampandampviewampdeliberatelyampbull Cultivateampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceamp(
The(Felt(Sense(
When-someone-understands-what-I-am-talking-about-when-I-talk-about-art-I-am-delighted--Art-is-my-everything--Its-my-passion--When-someone-understands-that-I-
am-instantly-filled-with-joy--That-tells-me-someone-gets-it-(Survey-response-CTF-age-16)-
(
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 15amp
thread4amp(
Review(of(Literature((
( AnampexplorationampofampGadamerrsquosamphermeneuticsampdialogicampandampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampeducationalampcontextsampandampGendlinrsquosamptheoryampofampfeltampsenseampwereampintegralamptoamp
theampcreationampofamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampWhileampcompellingampconstructsamponamp
theirampownampwhenampdrawnamptogetheramptheseampphilosophicalampperspectivesampvibrateamp
holisticallyamptoampsuggestampintriguingamppossibilitiesampforamptheampuseampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
inampartsampeducationampampInampthisampsectionampIampreviewamptheampliteratureampandampconnectamptheampvariousamp
pointsampofampstudyampampamp
Hermeneutics(amp(the(Fusion(of(Horizons((
It-actually-feels-really-great-knowing-that-other-people-will-enjoy-the-art-you-created-and-knowing-they-know-your-reasoning-and-story-behind-it--Honestly-you-cant-know-if-your-words-are-getting-through-to-them-but-the-cool-thing-about-art-is-that-it-can-be-
interpreted-in-so-many-different-ways---(Survey-response-EK-age-15)-
ampamp Hermeneuticsampwhichamphasampitsamprootsampinamptextualampinterpretationampcanampbeampdefinedampasamp
aamptraditionampofampthinkingamporampofampphilosophicalampreflectionampthatamptriesamptoampclarifyamptheampconceptamp
ofampverstehenampthatampisampunderstandingamp(Brunsamp1992)ampampRicoeuramp(19691974)ampexplainsamp
thatamptheampkeyamphypothesisampofamphermeneuticampphilosophyampisampthatampinterpretationampisampanampopenamp
processampwhichampnoampsingleampvisionampcanampconcludeamp(pamp109)ampampWithampthisampinampmindampIampwillamp
exploreamphermeneuticsampasampitampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp HansltGeorgampGadameramp(1900lt2002)ampinvestigatesampaampmoderateampformampofamp
hermeneuticsampthatampisampparticularlyamprelevantampinampserviceamptoampartampeducationampampGadameramp
breaksampwithamphermeneuticamptraditionampbyampproposingampthatampthereampisampnoampabsolutelyampobjectiveamp
interpretationampreadersampareampnotampableamptoampescapeamptheampprejudicesampofamptheiramptimeamp(Gallagheramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 16amp
1992)ampampThisamphoweverampbecomesampanampopportunityampforamptheampcreationampofampmeaningampInampaamp
passageampthatampechoesamptheampendlesslyampunfoldingampnatureampofampcollageampCaputoamp(2000)amprefersamp
toampanampexchangeampbetweenamppastampandamppresentampinamptheampcreativeamppossibilitiesampofamphermeneuticamp
interpretationamp
amp Thereampisampaamprichnessampinamphistoricalampeventsampthatampjustampkeepsampunfoldingampwhichampisamp
amp certainlyampnotampgraspedampbyamptheamporiginalampprotagonistsampwhichampgraduallyampunfoldsamp
amp overamptheampcourseampofamptimeampandampwhichampisampinampprincipleampneverampfullyampunfoldedampItampisamp
amp anampexcessampwhichampkeepsampspillingampoveramp(pamp47)amp
amp Gadamersampphilosophyampofamphermeneuticampunderstandingampisampformedampthroughamphisamp
notionsampaboutamplanguageampdialogueampandampconversationamp(Caputoamp2000ampSeebohmamp2004)ampamp
InampadditionamptoampGadamersampimplicitamprelianceamponamplisteningampasampheampdiscussesampdialogueamphisamp
workampcapitalizesamponamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampinamplanguageamp(Heelanamp1985)ampmakingamphisamp
formampofamphermeneuticsampparticularlyampapplicableamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp Gadamersamptermampfusion-of-horizonsamprefersamptoamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampwithinampaamp
varietyampofampencountersampampAampfusionampofamphorizonsampcanampbeampdescribedampasampaampdialogicamp
conversationampbetweenampreaderampandamptextamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampWithinamptheamptextualamp
paradigmampGadamerampbelievesampthatampaampwrittenamptextampisampopenamptoampanampinvisibleampandampindefiniteamp
readerampwhoampentersampintoampanampunknownampadventureampofamptheamptextamp(Ricoeuramp2013amppamp13)ampamp
Theamphorizonampitselfampisamptheamprangeampofampvisionampthatampincludesampeverythingampthatampcanampbeampseenamp
fromampaampparticularampvantageamppointamp(Gadameramp2004amppamp301)ampampLikeampcollageamptheampfusionampofamp
horizonsampisampaampprocessampcomposedampofamppastampandamppresentampwhichampareampopenamptoampandampinfinitelyamp
effectedampbyampeachampotheramp(Bourgeoisamp2007)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 17amp
amp Similarampconnectionsampcanampbeampdrawnampwhenampviewerampandampartworkampareampsubstitutedamp
forampreaderampandamptextampampInterpretationampandampunderstandingampbecomeampanampentwinedamp
creativeampendeavorampinampwhichamptheampviewerampparticipatesampasampmuchampasamptheampcreatorampbyamp
constructingampmeaningamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampPalmeramp(1969)ampalludesamptoamptheamppluralityampofamp
meaningampinampstatingampthatamptoampfocusamppurelyamponamptheamppositivityampofampwhatampaamptextampexplicitlyamp
saysampisamptoampdoampanampinjusticeamptoamptheamphermeneuticalamptaskamp(pamp234)ampampToampfocusamponampwhatampisamp
explicitampinampaampcollageampworkampwouldampbeamptoampdisregardamptheampconnectionsampandampcontradictionsamp
ofamptheampwholeampinampfavorampofampaampdirectampreadingampofamptheampindividualamppartsampthusampmissingampoutamponamp
otheramppossibleampdimensionsampofampmeaningamp
amp Theampkeyamptoamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampeducationampinamptextampandampbetweenamp
individualsampisamptheampabilityamptoamplistenampwithampopennessampampDefensiveamplisteningampisampaampwayampofamp
listeningampwithoutampopennessampitampisampaampwayampofampprotectingampourampsmallampversionampofamptheampworldamp
andampavoidingampmoralampclaimsamponampourselvesamp(Levinamp1989amppamp79)ampampLevinamp(1989)amp
discussesampplayfulamplisteningamp(pamp233)ampasampaampwayampofampcounteractingampdefensiveamplisteningampampamp
Bohmamp(1996)ampdiscussesampsuspendingampassumptionsampaampprocessampofampattendingamptoamp
assumptionsampratherampthanamprepressingampthemamporampcarryingampthemampoutampampNicholamp(1996)amp
explainsampaampcircumstanceampinampwhichampyouampencounterampaamppersonampyouampfeelampisampanampidiotampampampYouamp
wouldamprefrainampfromampsayingampsoampoutamploudampbutampyouampwouldampalsoamprefrainampfromampscoldingamp
yourselfampforampthisampthoughtampratherampyouampwouldampseeampthisampreactionampwithoutampfullyampengagingamp
withampitampampSimilarampsuggestionsamplikeampbracketingampofampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampareamp
discussedampinamptheampfollowingampsectionampamp
amp Gadamerampbelievesamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampwhatampallowsamptheampselfamptoampapproachamp
theampotherampitampisampaampprocessampinampwhichamptheampideasampofamptheampotherampbecomeamponesampownamp(Caputoamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 18amp
2000)ampampThisampisamphardlyampanampuncommonampexperienceampampInampfactampweampregularlyampencounteramptheamp
fusionampofamphorizonsampbyampintegratingamppastampunderstandingsampwithampcurrentampexperiencesampaamp
processampundoubtedlyampcomparableamptoampeducationamp(Zuckertamp2002)ampamp
amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsamplikeampeducationampcanampbeampfrustratingampandampemotionalamp
becauseampeachamphighlight[s]amptheampfinitudeampofamptheampinterpreterampandamptheamplimitationsampofamphisamp
understandingamp(Bourgeoisamp2007amppamp79)ampampTheamptermampsharesampsimilaritiesampwithamptheamp
problematic-momentampaamppedagogicalamptermampreferringamptoampaampbreachampinampaampdominantampgroupsamp
discourseampduringampwhichampsomethingamprepressedamparisesamp(KentampampampCummingamp2008)ampampKentamp
andampCummingamp(2008)ampexploreamptheampproblematicampmomentampasampaampdiscursiveampsiteampforamp
examiningampprejudiceampwithinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampandampitsamp
moreamppoliticallyampchargedampcounterpartamptheampproblematicampmomentampbothampexploreamp
Gadamersamp(1996)ampampassertionampthatamptheampotherampmayampnotamponlyamphaveampaamprightampbutampmayamp
actuallyampbeamprightampmayampunderstandampsomethingampbetterampthanampweampdoamp(pamp82)ampampAampcreativelt
listeningampspaceamplivesampinampthisamppossibilityampampamp
amp Lastlyamprelayingampofampappropriateampexpectationsamptoampparticipantsampisampaampnecessaryamp
featureampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampdemandingampampItamp
requiresampparticipantsampwhoampareampawareampofamptheamprisksampandamphardshipsamptoampenterampintoampitampampItamp
isamptheampresponsibilityampofamptheampeducatoramporampgroupampleaderamptoampmakeamptheseampexpectationsamp
knownampasampwellampasamptoampmodelampthisampbehaviorampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionamphermeneuticallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Areampopenamptoamppossibilitiesampandamptoamptheampotherampbull Conceiveampofampthemselvesampasampengagingampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamptheamprisksampinvolvedampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamplimitationsampofamptheirampunderstandingamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 19amp
Dialogic(Practices(-
I-felt-that-everyone-was-open-and-interested-in-what-I-had-to-say---Perhaps-I-felt-this-sense-of-understanding-due-to-the-nature-of-the-discussion((-
it-felt-[like]-more-[of]-a-dialogue-as-opposed-to-a-standard-critique-(Survey-response-MW-age-22)-
(amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampartampeducationampreliesamponampanampopenampdialogueampduringamp
experiencesampwithampartampselfampandampothersampampWhatampIampfoundamplackingampinamphermeneuticsamp
howeverampwasampaampdiscussionampofamptheamphowltlthowampisamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampachievedampandamp
howampdoampindividualsampmeaningfullyampengageampwithampeachampotherampampInampanampeffortamptoampclarifyampthisamp
Iampwillampdiscussampdialogicamppracticesampasamptheyamprelateamptoampmeaningfulampverbalampexchangesampandamp
listeningampencountersampinamptheampclassroomampandampstudioampamongstampstudentsamptheiramppeersampandamp
educatorsamp
amp Communicatingampthroughamplanguageampandampdialogueampisamphowampweampcoltconstructamp
worldsampwithampourselvesampandampothersampnotampjustampthroughampanampactampofamptransmissionampbutamp
becauseampourampcommunicativeampactsampgiveampbirthamptoampworldsamp(Lipariamp2014amppamp507)ampampSableamp
(2014)ampdescribesampdialogueampasampaampgenerativeampinterchangeampbetweenampparticipantsampasamp
opposedamptoampanampexchangeampofampviewsampwhereampindividualsampsimplyampadvocateamptheiramppositionsamp
(pamp8)ampampForampBohmamp(1996)ampitampisampaampstreamampofampmeaningampflowingampamongampandampthroughampusamp
(pamp6)ampampTheampnatureampofampdialogueampandampconversationampisampinherentlyampunplannedampampThisamp
dimensionampofampconversationampisampimportantamptoampGadameramp(2004)ampwhoampfindsampthatamp
participantsampinvolvedampinampconversationampareamplessamptheampleadersampofampitampthanamptheampledamp(pamp
385)ampampSableamp(2014)ampechoesampthisampbyampwritingampthatamptheampmostampimportantamppartsampofampanyamp
conversationampareampthoseampthatampneitheramppartyampcouldamphaveampimaginedampbeforeampstartingamp(pamp
8)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 20amp
amp Theseampareampnotionsampofampdialogueampamongampothersampthatampfindampaampparallelampinamptheamp
creativeampprocessampampFairfieldamp(2011)ampwritesampthatampinampprincipleampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinamp
dialogueamp(pamp83)ampaampsentimentampthatampalignsampwithampaampcommonampissueampencounteredampduringamp
theampcreativeampprocessltltnotampknowingampwhenampaamppieceampisampdoneampampAampquoteampoftenampattributedamp
toampLeonardoampdaampVinciampspeaksamptoampthisampideaampArtampisampneverampfinishedamponlyampabandonedampamp
Snowberamp(2007)ampdrawsampparallelsampbetweenampmentorshipampdialogueampandamptheampcreativeamp
processampfindingampthatampdeepamplisteningamppracticesampconnectampallampthreeampampSheampfindsampthatamptheamp
taskampofamptheampmentorampisamptheampsameampasamptheamptaskampofamptheampartistampthatampisamptoampbringampoutamptheamp
naturalampqualitiesampofamptheampstudentamporamptheampmediumampampSnowberamp(2007)ampcommentsamponampanamp
ideaampwellltknownampamongampartistsampwhichampisampthatampaampworkampofampartamphasampaamplifeampofampitsampownampthisamp
notionampisampreminiscentampofampGadamersampstatementampaboutampbeingampledampbyampconversationamp
ampamp Dialogicamppracticesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampeducationampemphasizeampaamp
phenomenologicalampdimensionamprequiringamptwoampthingsampfromampparticipantsampampFirstlyamp
participantsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampmustampfindampvalueampinamplisteningamptoamptheamp
narrativesampofamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampampTheseampparticipantsampknowampthatampeducationamp
isampforemostampaboutamptestimonyampaboutampsharingamptheampexperienceampofampbeingamphumanampsharingamp
lifeampconvictionsampandampknowledge((Wiercinskiamp2011amppamp109)ampampNarrativesampareamp
conceivedampofampasampaampwayampofamphumanampknowingamp(Vitanovaamp2010amppamp29)ampthatampmakesamptheamp
selfampampSecondlyampwhenamplisteningamptoamptheampnarrativesampofampothersampparticipantsampareampexpectedamp
toampbracketamptheirampownampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsamp(LindsethampampampNorbergamp2004)ampampThisamp
encouragesamplistenersamptoampexperienceampandampfindampmeaningampinamptheampnarrativesampofampothersamp
whileampfreeingamptheampspeakerampfromamptheampfearampofampbeingampjudgedampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 21amp
amp Bracketingampjudgmentampandampconclusionampisampaamppotentialamptoolampwithinamptheampcommonamp
artampeducationamppracticeampofampgroupampcritiquesampampElkinsamp(2001)ampfindsampthatamppeopleampwhoamphaveamp
experienceampinampartampjudgeampveryampquicklyampandampmostampteachersampwillamphaveampaampprovisionalamp
opinionampaboutampaampworkampinamptheampfirstamptenampsecondsamp(pamp121)ampampBracketingampconclusionampandamp
judgmentampisampparticularlyampimportantampforampeducatorsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
whoseampvolumeampofampviewingampexperiencesampcouldampleadamptoampeasyampassumptionsampwhenamp
encounteringampaampnewampworkampampamp
amp Elkinsamp(2001)ampdiscussesampthatampcritiquesampcanampalsoampbeampseenampasampexchangesampofamp
storiesamporampcollaborativeampstorytellingamp(pamp145)ampwhichampisampyetampanotherampwayampofamptalkingamp
aboutamppossibilitiesampforampdialogueampandampnarrativeampwithinampartampeducationampampElkinsamphoweveramp
findsampstorytellingamplimitingamponceamptheampdeeperampnarrativesampareampdiscoveredamp(2001amppamp
145)ampampThisampimpliesampthatampheampfindsamponlyampaampsingularampmeaningampandamponeampthatampisampnotamp
necessarilyampusefulampforampcollaborativeampgroupampcritiquesamp
amp Insteadampparticipantsampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampbringampknowledgeampofamp
polysemyamptoampcollaborativeampcritiqueampexperiencesampasampwellampasamptoampexperiencesampofampmakingamp
artworkampampAccordingamptoampMuldoonamp(2002)amppolysemyampisamptheampqualityampofampaampwordamporampotheramp
languageampunitampthatampcanampbearampmultipleampmeaningsamp(asampcitedampinampWorsleyamp2012amppamp308)ampampamp
Aamptextualampexampleampofampthisampisamptheampmultipleampmeaningsampofamptheampwordampcan-Iampcanampdriveampaampcaramp
Idamplikeampaampcan-ofampsodaampheampwasntampworkingampveryamphardampsoampIamphadamptoampcan-himamp(Munozamp
2014)ampampampButampifampweampconsideramppolysemyampmetaphoricallyamporampvisuallyamptheampideaampthatampaamp
singleampunitampimageamporampintentionampcouldampbearampmultipleampmeaningsampcouldampbeampproductiveampinamp
creatingltlisteningampspacesampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 22amp
amp Thisampunfoldingampofampmeaningampworksampwellampinamptheampcontextampofampcollageampandampdialogueamp
asampwellampasamphermeneuticsampampInampfactamphermeneuticsampimpliesamppolysemyampbecauseampofampitsamp
notionampthatampitampisampalwaysampaamppossibilityampofampmyampunderstandingampthatampisampplayedampoutampwhenampIamp
understandampaamptextamp(Grondinamp2002amppamp38)ampampPolysemyampcouldampbeampconceptualizedampasampanamp
alternativeampexplorationampofampmeaningampthatampfunctionsampcollaborativelyampwithinampcritiquesampamp
Forampexampleampeducatorsampcanampaskampstudentsamptoamprespondamptoampaampworkampthroughampcollageamp
journalampentriesampmusicampfilmampasampindividualsamporampinampgroupsampampKnowledgeampofamppolysemyamp
couldampalsoampbeampusedampasampaamptoolampforampcreatingampimagesampthatamprecognizesampaamprelationshipamp
betweenamptheampvisualamptheamplinguisticampandamptheampmultipleamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionampdialogicallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Placeampvalueamponampexperientialampnarrativesampbull Practiceamplisteningampbyampbracketingampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampbull Embraceamppolysemicampexplorationsampofampmeaningampamp
Contemplative(Practices(
I-knew-I-was-being-heard-because-of-her-mannerisms-and-the-look-on-her-face--She-was-calm-attentive-and-not-trying-to-jump-in-and-offer-any-advice--She-asked-questions-that-pointed-to-things-I-had-not-openly-articulated-because-of-uncertainty--
This-was-one-of-the-ways-I-knew-I-was-being-heard-(Survey-response-LS-age-27)-
(amp Ifamphermeneuticsampandampdialogicamppracticesampgiveampusamptheampbroadampstrokesampofampactivityampinamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampcontemplativeamppracticesampseekamptoamptuneampstudentsampandamp
educatorsampintoampnuanceampdeliberationampandampdeepampexplorationampampThisampisampaampmostlyamp
individualampinternalamppursuitampthatampfocusesamponampformsampofampselfltlisteningampbutampcontemplativeamp
practicesampareampalsoampformedampbyampanampawarenessampofampinterconnectednessamp
amp InamppursuitampofampcriticalampthinkingampSableamp(2014)ampoutlinesampaampsetampofampcontemplativeamp
practicesampforampstudentsampthatampincludeampmindfulampmeditationampstructuredampcontemplationamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 23amp
journalampwritingampmindfulamplisteningampreflectiveampinquiryampandampdialogueamp(pamp4)ampampWhileamp
Sablesamp(2014)ampmethodampforampcontemplativeamppracticesampprovidesampaampconcreteampframeworkamp
withampspecificampstepsampmanyampofamptheseampconceptsampcouldampbeampappliedampwithoutampsuchampaamp
prescribedampstructureampampForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwillampbeamp
primarilyampdiscussingampSablesampconceptsampofampstructuredampcontemplationampreflectiveamp
inquiryampandampjournalampwritingamp
amp ForampSableamp(2014)ampstructuredampcontemplationampisampaampformampofampbeingamppresentampandamp
focusedamponampaampparticularampquestionampstatementamporampimageampampWithinampthisampmodeampofampinquiryamp
participantsampareampexpectedamptoampholdamptheampobjectampofampcontemplationampinamptheirampmindsamp
deepeningampunderstandingampasamptheyampfocusampwithoutampanalyzingampitamporampmanipulatingampitampinamp
anyampwayamp(pamp5)ampampThisamppracticeampdrawsampcomparisonsamptoamptheampbracketingampofampjudgmentsamp
andampconclusionsampsupportedampinamptheamppreviousampsectionampbutampstructuredampcontemplationamp
occursamponampanampindividualamplevelampratherampthanampdialogicallyamp
amp Reflectiveampinquiryampbearsampsomeampsimilaritiesamptoampstructuredampcontemplationampbutamp
Sableamp(2014)amppositionsampitampasampanampactivityampbetweenamptwoampindividualsampaamplistenerampandampaamp
speakerampampTheamplistenerampisampagainampaskedamptoampsuspendampjudgmentampbutampalsoamptoampengageampinampaamp
formampofampcuriosityampinampwhichampinnocentampquestionsampareampaskedampinamporderamptoampgainamp
understandingampampSableamp(2014)ampcontrastsampinnocentampquestionsampwithampleadingampquestionsampamp
ForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwouldampcharacterizeampthisampinnocentamp
questioningampasampaampformampofampopenltendedampquestioningampampSableamp(2014)ampidentifiesampanamp
exampleampofampanampinnocentamp(orampopenltended)ampquestionampWhatampdidampyouampmeanampwhenampyouamp
saidamp________ampConverselyampaampleadingampquestionampisampDidampyouampmeanamptoampsayamp________ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 24amp
amp Sableamp(2014)ampusesampjournalampwritingampasampaamppieceampofamphisamplargerampstructureampofamp
contemplativeamppracticesampbutampjournalampwritingampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampcouldamp
potentiallyampoccupyampaampsignificantamproleampampIampconceiveampofampjournalampwritingampinampmyampownamp
creativeamppracticeampasampaampformampofampdocumentationampthatampmakesampmeampmoreampawareampofampmyamp
creativeampprocessamptheampemotionalamphabitsampthatampsurroundampitampandamptheampthemesampthatamp
structureampmyampworkampampIampconceptualizeampthisampwayampofampwritingampasampaampformampofampselfltlisteningamp
relatedamptoampaampkeyampconceptampofamphermeneuticsampfoundampinampGadamersampassertionampthatampallamp
educationampisampaampformampofampselflteducationamp(Grondinamp2011)ampampamp
amp Germeraadamp(2013)ampusesampjournalampwritingamptoampexploreamptheampemotionalampandamprationalamp
relationshipsamptoamphisampcreativeampprocessampparallelamptoampexecutingampaampnewampbodyampofampworkampampHeamp
findsampthatampwritingampduringamphisampprocessampisampaamptoolamptoampunderstandamp[his]amppsycheamptoampeaseamp
theamppainampthatampanampartisticampprocessampcanampbringampandamptoamprelieveampartisticampblocksamp
(Germeraadamp2013amppamp21)ampultimatelyampdeclaringampthatampitamphelpsamphimamptoampbetterampunderstandamp
hisampworkampampInampaampstyleampofampwritingampthatamposcillatesamparoundampjournalingampdocumentationampandamp
poetryampdeampCossonamp(2002)ampexploresamphisampoverlappingamprolesampasampanampartistampresearcherampandamp
teacherampampOtherampartistsampbluramptheamplineampbetweenampartamppracticeampdocumentationampandamplifeamp
furtherampstillampbyampofferingampdocumentationampasampartamplikeampSophieampCalleamp(Calleamp2011amp2008amp
2005)ampandampMaryampKellyamp(1973lt1979)ampampamp
amp Karpiakamp(2003)ampestablishesampcontemplativeamppracticesampfromamptheampperspectiveampofamp
theampeducatorampaskingampthemamptoampmineamptheampsubtleamp(pamp71)ampusingampattentivenessamp
attunementampamplificationampandampassociationampampTheseampexercisesampinampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampsetamptheamptoneampasampwellampasampprovideampaampmodelampofampbehaviorampforampotherampparticipantsamp
withinamptheampspaceampampKarpiakamp(2003)ampoutlinesampactivitiesampthatampeducatorsampcanampuseamptoampdrawamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 25amp
outampandamputilizeamptheseampsubtleampsensationsampinamptheampserviceampofamptransformativeamplearningamp(pamp
68)ampampamp
amp ForampKarpiakamp(2003)ampattentivenessamprequiresampawarenessamptoampverbalampandamp
nonverbalampcuesampasampwellampasampanampawarenessampofampwhatampisamphappeningampamongampandampwithinamptheamp
studentsampandamptheampeducatorampampAttunementamprequiresampanampeducatoramptoamporientampherselfamptoamptheamp
otherampandamptoampadoptampanampattitudeampofampunhurriednessampofamppatienceampandampofamphumilityamp
concerningampbothamptheampprocessampandamptheampoutcomesampofamptheampteachingamp(Karpiakamp2003amppgamp
72)ampampAmplificationampisampaampprocessampofamphonoringampcommunicationampthatampcentersamponamptheampideaamp
ofamphearingamponeselfampintoampknowingampitampincludesampusingampparaphrasingampandampclarificationamp
activitiesamptoampgainampinsightampintoampmeaningampampLastlyampassociationampentailsampidentifyingamp
patternsampandampweavingampthemamptogetherampwithampstudentampexperienceampclassroomampdiscussionamp
andamptheampideasampofampothersamp
amp TuningampintoampsubtletyampimpliesampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceampampTheampmanifestationsamp
ofampsilenceampinamptheampclassroomampareampendlessampandampitsampvalueampisamptooampgreatamptoampbeampignoredampwhileamp
tooampvastamptoampbeampfullyampabsorbedampampLevinamp(1989)ampremarksampthatampsilenceampisampaampclearingampwhereamp
thereampisampnothingampforamphearingamptoampholdamponamptoampinampwhichampmanyampfindampunbearableampanxietyamp
(pamp79)ampampNearlyampallampofampusamphaveampexperiencedampthisampunbearableampanxietyampaampstrainampofamp
whichampcanampbeampfoundampinampeducationalampcontextsampdueamptoamptheampfactampthatampclassroomsampareamp
oftenampstructuredamparoundampimplicitampandampexplicitamprulesampaboutamptalkampandampsilenceamp(Schultzamp
2010amppamp2848)ampampForampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampanampawarenessampofampsilenceampimplicatesamp
whatampisampleftampunsaidampandampwhatampisampunsayableltltespeciallyampimportantampbecauseampofamptheamp
unsayableampqualityampofampartworksampampForampSchultzamp(2010)ampsilenceampimpliesamppossibilityamp
becauseampitampcanampholdampmultipleampmeaningsampforampindividualsampwithinampandampacrossampracialamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 26amp
ethnicampandampculturalampgroupsamp(pamp2833)ampampLevinamp(1989)ampfindsampthatamptoamplistenamptoamp
somethingampweampmustampfirstampgive-itampourampsilenceamp(pamp232)ampampThisamppracticeampofampgivingampsilenceamp
isampparticularlyamphelpfulampinamptermsampofampviewingamporamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartamp
amp Gradleamp(2011)ampoutlinesampaamppracticalampvisionampforampviewingampartampthatamprequiresamp
silenceampandampdeliberationampampForamptheamppurposesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampwouldamp
reconceptualizeampthisampasampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampampGradleamp(2011)ampinstructedamp
herampstudentsamptoampspendamptimeampwithampaampworkampofampartampoutsideampofamptheirampeverydayampworldviewamp
attentivelyampviewingampitampforampaboutamptenampminutesampeverydayampforampaampweekampampAfterampeachampviewingamp
experienceamptheampstudentsampwroteampinamptheirampjournalsampampTheampresultsampindicatedampthatampthisamp
processampofampsustainedampsilentampdeliberationampcoupledampwithampanampengagementampofamptheiramp
intuitiveampperceptionsampaboutampartworkampleftampstudentsampfeelingampempoweredamptoampengageampinamp
discussionampandampappreciateampunfamiliarampartampformsampampThisampactivityampisampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoamp
aampworkampofampartampthatampincorporatesampSablesamp(2014)ampconceptampofampstructuredampcontemplationampamp
Weavingampaamprelationshipampbetweenampsilenceampcontemplationampandampattentivenessampisampaamp
significantampendeavorampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
Contemplativeamppracticesampfunctionampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Engageampinampformsampofampviewingampwritingampandampexperiencingampthatamphonorampselfltlisteningamp
bull Attuneamptoampsubtletyampandampnuanceampbull Listenampandampviewampdeliberatelyampbull Cultivateampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceamp(
The(Felt(Sense(
When-someone-understands-what-I-am-talking-about-when-I-talk-about-art-I-am-delighted--Art-is-my-everything--Its-my-passion--When-someone-understands-that-I-
am-instantly-filled-with-joy--That-tells-me-someone-gets-it-(Survey-response-CTF-age-16)-
(
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 16amp
1992)ampampThisamphoweverampbecomesampanampopportunityampforamptheampcreationampofampmeaningampInampaamp
passageampthatampechoesamptheampendlesslyampunfoldingampnatureampofampcollageampCaputoamp(2000)amprefersamp
toampanampexchangeampbetweenamppastampandamppresentampinamptheampcreativeamppossibilitiesampofamphermeneuticamp
interpretationamp
amp Thereampisampaamprichnessampinamphistoricalampeventsampthatampjustampkeepsampunfoldingampwhichampisamp
amp certainlyampnotampgraspedampbyamptheamporiginalampprotagonistsampwhichampgraduallyampunfoldsamp
amp overamptheampcourseampofamptimeampandampwhichampisampinampprincipleampneverampfullyampunfoldedampItampisamp
amp anampexcessampwhichampkeepsampspillingampoveramp(pamp47)amp
amp Gadamersampphilosophyampofamphermeneuticampunderstandingampisampformedampthroughamphisamp
notionsampaboutamplanguageampdialogueampandampconversationamp(Caputoamp2000ampSeebohmamp2004)ampamp
InampadditionamptoampGadamersampimplicitamprelianceamponamplisteningampasampheampdiscussesampdialogueamphisamp
workampcapitalizesamponamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampinamplanguageamp(Heelanamp1985)ampmakingamphisamp
formampofamphermeneuticsampparticularlyampapplicableamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
amp Gadamersamptermampfusion-of-horizonsamprefersamptoamptheamppluralityampofampmeaningampwithinampaamp
varietyampofampencountersampampAampfusionampofamphorizonsampcanampbeampdescribedampasampaampdialogicamp
conversationampbetweenampreaderampandamptextamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampWithinamptheamptextualamp
paradigmampGadamerampbelievesampthatampaampwrittenamptextampisampopenamptoampanampinvisibleampandampindefiniteamp
readerampwhoampentersampintoampanampunknownampadventureampofamptheamptextamp(Ricoeuramp2013amppamp13)ampamp
Theamphorizonampitselfampisamptheamprangeampofampvisionampthatampincludesampeverythingampthatampcanampbeampseenamp
fromampaampparticularampvantageamppointamp(Gadameramp2004amppamp301)ampampLikeampcollageamptheampfusionampofamp
horizonsampisampaampprocessampcomposedampofamppastampandamppresentampwhichampareampopenamptoampandampinfinitelyamp
effectedampbyampeachampotheramp(Bourgeoisamp2007)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 17amp
amp Similarampconnectionsampcanampbeampdrawnampwhenampviewerampandampartworkampareampsubstitutedamp
forampreaderampandamptextampampInterpretationampandampunderstandingampbecomeampanampentwinedamp
creativeampendeavorampinampwhichamptheampviewerampparticipatesampasampmuchampasamptheampcreatorampbyamp
constructingampmeaningamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampPalmeramp(1969)ampalludesamptoamptheamppluralityampofamp
meaningampinampstatingampthatamptoampfocusamppurelyamponamptheamppositivityampofampwhatampaamptextampexplicitlyamp
saysampisamptoampdoampanampinjusticeamptoamptheamphermeneuticalamptaskamp(pamp234)ampampToampfocusamponampwhatampisamp
explicitampinampaampcollageampworkampwouldampbeamptoampdisregardamptheampconnectionsampandampcontradictionsamp
ofamptheampwholeampinampfavorampofampaampdirectampreadingampofamptheampindividualamppartsampthusampmissingampoutamponamp
otheramppossibleampdimensionsampofampmeaningamp
amp Theampkeyamptoamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampeducationampinamptextampandampbetweenamp
individualsampisamptheampabilityamptoamplistenampwithampopennessampampDefensiveamplisteningampisampaampwayampofamp
listeningampwithoutampopennessampitampisampaampwayampofampprotectingampourampsmallampversionampofamptheampworldamp
andampavoidingampmoralampclaimsamponampourselvesamp(Levinamp1989amppamp79)ampampLevinamp(1989)amp
discussesampplayfulamplisteningamp(pamp233)ampasampaampwayampofampcounteractingampdefensiveamplisteningampampamp
Bohmamp(1996)ampdiscussesampsuspendingampassumptionsampaampprocessampofampattendingamptoamp
assumptionsampratherampthanamprepressingampthemamporampcarryingampthemampoutampampNicholamp(1996)amp
explainsampaampcircumstanceampinampwhichampyouampencounterampaamppersonampyouampfeelampisampanampidiotampampampYouamp
wouldamprefrainampfromampsayingampsoampoutamploudampbutampyouampwouldampalsoamprefrainampfromampscoldingamp
yourselfampforampthisampthoughtampratherampyouampwouldampseeampthisampreactionampwithoutampfullyampengagingamp
withampitampampSimilarampsuggestionsamplikeampbracketingampofampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampareamp
discussedampinamptheampfollowingampsectionampamp
amp Gadamerampbelievesamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampwhatampallowsamptheampselfamptoampapproachamp
theampotherampitampisampaampprocessampinampwhichamptheampideasampofamptheampotherampbecomeamponesampownamp(Caputoamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 18amp
2000)ampampThisampisamphardlyampanampuncommonampexperienceampampInampfactampweampregularlyampencounteramptheamp
fusionampofamphorizonsampbyampintegratingamppastampunderstandingsampwithampcurrentampexperiencesampaamp
processampundoubtedlyampcomparableamptoampeducationamp(Zuckertamp2002)ampamp
amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsamplikeampeducationampcanampbeampfrustratingampandampemotionalamp
becauseampeachamphighlight[s]amptheampfinitudeampofamptheampinterpreterampandamptheamplimitationsampofamphisamp
understandingamp(Bourgeoisamp2007amppamp79)ampampTheamptermampsharesampsimilaritiesampwithamptheamp
problematic-momentampaamppedagogicalamptermampreferringamptoampaampbreachampinampaampdominantampgroupsamp
discourseampduringampwhichampsomethingamprepressedamparisesamp(KentampampampCummingamp2008)ampampKentamp
andampCummingamp(2008)ampexploreamptheampproblematicampmomentampasampaampdiscursiveampsiteampforamp
examiningampprejudiceampwithinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampandampitsamp
moreamppoliticallyampchargedampcounterpartamptheampproblematicampmomentampbothampexploreamp
Gadamersamp(1996)ampampassertionampthatamptheampotherampmayampnotamponlyamphaveampaamprightampbutampmayamp
actuallyampbeamprightampmayampunderstandampsomethingampbetterampthanampweampdoamp(pamp82)ampampAampcreativelt
listeningampspaceamplivesampinampthisamppossibilityampampamp
amp Lastlyamprelayingampofampappropriateampexpectationsamptoampparticipantsampisampaampnecessaryamp
featureampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampdemandingampampItamp
requiresampparticipantsampwhoampareampawareampofamptheamprisksampandamphardshipsamptoampenterampintoampitampampItamp
isamptheampresponsibilityampofamptheampeducatoramporampgroupampleaderamptoampmakeamptheseampexpectationsamp
knownampasampwellampasamptoampmodelampthisampbehaviorampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionamphermeneuticallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Areampopenamptoamppossibilitiesampandamptoamptheampotherampbull Conceiveampofampthemselvesampasampengagingampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamptheamprisksampinvolvedampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamplimitationsampofamptheirampunderstandingamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 19amp
Dialogic(Practices(-
I-felt-that-everyone-was-open-and-interested-in-what-I-had-to-say---Perhaps-I-felt-this-sense-of-understanding-due-to-the-nature-of-the-discussion((-
it-felt-[like]-more-[of]-a-dialogue-as-opposed-to-a-standard-critique-(Survey-response-MW-age-22)-
(amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampartampeducationampreliesamponampanampopenampdialogueampduringamp
experiencesampwithampartampselfampandampothersampampWhatampIampfoundamplackingampinamphermeneuticsamp
howeverampwasampaampdiscussionampofamptheamphowltlthowampisamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampachievedampandamp
howampdoampindividualsampmeaningfullyampengageampwithampeachampotherampampInampanampeffortamptoampclarifyampthisamp
Iampwillampdiscussampdialogicamppracticesampasamptheyamprelateamptoampmeaningfulampverbalampexchangesampandamp
listeningampencountersampinamptheampclassroomampandampstudioampamongstampstudentsamptheiramppeersampandamp
educatorsamp
amp Communicatingampthroughamplanguageampandampdialogueampisamphowampweampcoltconstructamp
worldsampwithampourselvesampandampothersampnotampjustampthroughampanampactampofamptransmissionampbutamp
becauseampourampcommunicativeampactsampgiveampbirthamptoampworldsamp(Lipariamp2014amppamp507)ampampSableamp
(2014)ampdescribesampdialogueampasampaampgenerativeampinterchangeampbetweenampparticipantsampasamp
opposedamptoampanampexchangeampofampviewsampwhereampindividualsampsimplyampadvocateamptheiramppositionsamp
(pamp8)ampampForampBohmamp(1996)ampitampisampaampstreamampofampmeaningampflowingampamongampandampthroughampusamp
(pamp6)ampampTheampnatureampofampdialogueampandampconversationampisampinherentlyampunplannedampampThisamp
dimensionampofampconversationampisampimportantamptoampGadameramp(2004)ampwhoampfindsampthatamp
participantsampinvolvedampinampconversationampareamplessamptheampleadersampofampitampthanamptheampledamp(pamp
385)ampampSableamp(2014)ampechoesampthisampbyampwritingampthatamptheampmostampimportantamppartsampofampanyamp
conversationampareampthoseampthatampneitheramppartyampcouldamphaveampimaginedampbeforeampstartingamp(pamp
8)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 20amp
amp Theseampareampnotionsampofampdialogueampamongampothersampthatampfindampaampparallelampinamptheamp
creativeampprocessampampFairfieldamp(2011)ampwritesampthatampinampprincipleampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinamp
dialogueamp(pamp83)ampaampsentimentampthatampalignsampwithampaampcommonampissueampencounteredampduringamp
theampcreativeampprocessltltnotampknowingampwhenampaamppieceampisampdoneampampAampquoteampoftenampattributedamp
toampLeonardoampdaampVinciampspeaksamptoampthisampideaampArtampisampneverampfinishedamponlyampabandonedampamp
Snowberamp(2007)ampdrawsampparallelsampbetweenampmentorshipampdialogueampandamptheampcreativeamp
processampfindingampthatampdeepamplisteningamppracticesampconnectampallampthreeampampSheampfindsampthatamptheamp
taskampofamptheampmentorampisamptheampsameampasamptheamptaskampofamptheampartistampthatampisamptoampbringampoutamptheamp
naturalampqualitiesampofamptheampstudentamporamptheampmediumampampSnowberamp(2007)ampcommentsamponampanamp
ideaampwellltknownampamongampartistsampwhichampisampthatampaampworkampofampartamphasampaamplifeampofampitsampownampthisamp
notionampisampreminiscentampofampGadamersampstatementampaboutampbeingampledampbyampconversationamp
ampamp Dialogicamppracticesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampeducationampemphasizeampaamp
phenomenologicalampdimensionamprequiringamptwoampthingsampfromampparticipantsampampFirstlyamp
participantsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampmustampfindampvalueampinamplisteningamptoamptheamp
narrativesampofamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampampTheseampparticipantsampknowampthatampeducationamp
isampforemostampaboutamptestimonyampaboutampsharingamptheampexperienceampofampbeingamphumanampsharingamp
lifeampconvictionsampandampknowledge((Wiercinskiamp2011amppamp109)ampampNarrativesampareamp
conceivedampofampasampaampwayampofamphumanampknowingamp(Vitanovaamp2010amppamp29)ampthatampmakesamptheamp
selfampampSecondlyampwhenamplisteningamptoamptheampnarrativesampofampothersampparticipantsampareampexpectedamp
toampbracketamptheirampownampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsamp(LindsethampampampNorbergamp2004)ampampThisamp
encouragesamplistenersamptoampexperienceampandampfindampmeaningampinamptheampnarrativesampofampothersamp
whileampfreeingamptheampspeakerampfromamptheampfearampofampbeingampjudgedampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 21amp
amp Bracketingampjudgmentampandampconclusionampisampaamppotentialamptoolampwithinamptheampcommonamp
artampeducationamppracticeampofampgroupampcritiquesampampElkinsamp(2001)ampfindsampthatamppeopleampwhoamphaveamp
experienceampinampartampjudgeampveryampquicklyampandampmostampteachersampwillamphaveampaampprovisionalamp
opinionampaboutampaampworkampinamptheampfirstamptenampsecondsamp(pamp121)ampampBracketingampconclusionampandamp
judgmentampisampparticularlyampimportantampforampeducatorsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
whoseampvolumeampofampviewingampexperiencesampcouldampleadamptoampeasyampassumptionsampwhenamp
encounteringampaampnewampworkampampamp
amp Elkinsamp(2001)ampdiscussesampthatampcritiquesampcanampalsoampbeampseenampasampexchangesampofamp
storiesamporampcollaborativeampstorytellingamp(pamp145)ampwhichampisampyetampanotherampwayampofamptalkingamp
aboutamppossibilitiesampforampdialogueampandampnarrativeampwithinampartampeducationampampElkinsamphoweveramp
findsampstorytellingamplimitingamponceamptheampdeeperampnarrativesampareampdiscoveredamp(2001amppamp
145)ampampThisampimpliesampthatampheampfindsamponlyampaampsingularampmeaningampandamponeampthatampisampnotamp
necessarilyampusefulampforampcollaborativeampgroupampcritiquesamp
amp Insteadampparticipantsampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampbringampknowledgeampofamp
polysemyamptoampcollaborativeampcritiqueampexperiencesampasampwellampasamptoampexperiencesampofampmakingamp
artworkampampAccordingamptoampMuldoonamp(2002)amppolysemyampisamptheampqualityampofampaampwordamporampotheramp
languageampunitampthatampcanampbearampmultipleampmeaningsamp(asampcitedampinampWorsleyamp2012amppamp308)ampampamp
Aamptextualampexampleampofampthisampisamptheampmultipleampmeaningsampofamptheampwordampcan-Iampcanampdriveampaampcaramp
Idamplikeampaampcan-ofampsodaampheampwasntampworkingampveryamphardampsoampIamphadamptoampcan-himamp(Munozamp
2014)ampampampButampifampweampconsideramppolysemyampmetaphoricallyamporampvisuallyamptheampideaampthatampaamp
singleampunitampimageamporampintentionampcouldampbearampmultipleampmeaningsampcouldampbeampproductiveampinamp
creatingltlisteningampspacesampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 22amp
amp Thisampunfoldingampofampmeaningampworksampwellampinamptheampcontextampofampcollageampandampdialogueamp
asampwellampasamphermeneuticsampampInampfactamphermeneuticsampimpliesamppolysemyampbecauseampofampitsamp
notionampthatampitampisampalwaysampaamppossibilityampofampmyampunderstandingampthatampisampplayedampoutampwhenampIamp
understandampaamptextamp(Grondinamp2002amppamp38)ampampPolysemyampcouldampbeampconceptualizedampasampanamp
alternativeampexplorationampofampmeaningampthatampfunctionsampcollaborativelyampwithinampcritiquesampamp
Forampexampleampeducatorsampcanampaskampstudentsamptoamprespondamptoampaampworkampthroughampcollageamp
journalampentriesampmusicampfilmampasampindividualsamporampinampgroupsampampKnowledgeampofamppolysemyamp
couldampalsoampbeampusedampasampaamptoolampforampcreatingampimagesampthatamprecognizesampaamprelationshipamp
betweenamptheampvisualamptheamplinguisticampandamptheampmultipleamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionampdialogicallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Placeampvalueamponampexperientialampnarrativesampbull Practiceamplisteningampbyampbracketingampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampbull Embraceamppolysemicampexplorationsampofampmeaningampamp
Contemplative(Practices(
I-knew-I-was-being-heard-because-of-her-mannerisms-and-the-look-on-her-face--She-was-calm-attentive-and-not-trying-to-jump-in-and-offer-any-advice--She-asked-questions-that-pointed-to-things-I-had-not-openly-articulated-because-of-uncertainty--
This-was-one-of-the-ways-I-knew-I-was-being-heard-(Survey-response-LS-age-27)-
(amp Ifamphermeneuticsampandampdialogicamppracticesampgiveampusamptheampbroadampstrokesampofampactivityampinamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampcontemplativeamppracticesampseekamptoamptuneampstudentsampandamp
educatorsampintoampnuanceampdeliberationampandampdeepampexplorationampampThisampisampaampmostlyamp
individualampinternalamppursuitampthatampfocusesamponampformsampofampselfltlisteningampbutampcontemplativeamp
practicesampareampalsoampformedampbyampanampawarenessampofampinterconnectednessamp
amp InamppursuitampofampcriticalampthinkingampSableamp(2014)ampoutlinesampaampsetampofampcontemplativeamp
practicesampforampstudentsampthatampincludeampmindfulampmeditationampstructuredampcontemplationamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 23amp
journalampwritingampmindfulamplisteningampreflectiveampinquiryampandampdialogueamp(pamp4)ampampWhileamp
Sablesamp(2014)ampmethodampforampcontemplativeamppracticesampprovidesampaampconcreteampframeworkamp
withampspecificampstepsampmanyampofamptheseampconceptsampcouldampbeampappliedampwithoutampsuchampaamp
prescribedampstructureampampForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwillampbeamp
primarilyampdiscussingampSablesampconceptsampofampstructuredampcontemplationampreflectiveamp
inquiryampandampjournalampwritingamp
amp ForampSableamp(2014)ampstructuredampcontemplationampisampaampformampofampbeingamppresentampandamp
focusedamponampaampparticularampquestionampstatementamporampimageampampWithinampthisampmodeampofampinquiryamp
participantsampareampexpectedamptoampholdamptheampobjectampofampcontemplationampinamptheirampmindsamp
deepeningampunderstandingampasamptheyampfocusampwithoutampanalyzingampitamporampmanipulatingampitampinamp
anyampwayamp(pamp5)ampampThisamppracticeampdrawsampcomparisonsamptoamptheampbracketingampofampjudgmentsamp
andampconclusionsampsupportedampinamptheamppreviousampsectionampbutampstructuredampcontemplationamp
occursamponampanampindividualamplevelampratherampthanampdialogicallyamp
amp Reflectiveampinquiryampbearsampsomeampsimilaritiesamptoampstructuredampcontemplationampbutamp
Sableamp(2014)amppositionsampitampasampanampactivityampbetweenamptwoampindividualsampaamplistenerampandampaamp
speakerampampTheamplistenerampisampagainampaskedamptoampsuspendampjudgmentampbutampalsoamptoampengageampinampaamp
formampofampcuriosityampinampwhichampinnocentampquestionsampareampaskedampinamporderamptoampgainamp
understandingampampSableamp(2014)ampcontrastsampinnocentampquestionsampwithampleadingampquestionsampamp
ForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwouldampcharacterizeampthisampinnocentamp
questioningampasampaampformampofampopenltendedampquestioningampampSableamp(2014)ampidentifiesampanamp
exampleampofampanampinnocentamp(orampopenltended)ampquestionampWhatampdidampyouampmeanampwhenampyouamp
saidamp________ampConverselyampaampleadingampquestionampisampDidampyouampmeanamptoampsayamp________ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 24amp
amp Sableamp(2014)ampusesampjournalampwritingampasampaamppieceampofamphisamplargerampstructureampofamp
contemplativeamppracticesampbutampjournalampwritingampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampcouldamp
potentiallyampoccupyampaampsignificantamproleampampIampconceiveampofampjournalampwritingampinampmyampownamp
creativeamppracticeampasampaampformampofampdocumentationampthatampmakesampmeampmoreampawareampofampmyamp
creativeampprocessamptheampemotionalamphabitsampthatampsurroundampitampandamptheampthemesampthatamp
structureampmyampworkampampIampconceptualizeampthisampwayampofampwritingampasampaampformampofampselfltlisteningamp
relatedamptoampaampkeyampconceptampofamphermeneuticsampfoundampinampGadamersampassertionampthatampallamp
educationampisampaampformampofampselflteducationamp(Grondinamp2011)ampampamp
amp Germeraadamp(2013)ampusesampjournalampwritingamptoampexploreamptheampemotionalampandamprationalamp
relationshipsamptoamphisampcreativeampprocessampparallelamptoampexecutingampaampnewampbodyampofampworkampampHeamp
findsampthatampwritingampduringamphisampprocessampisampaamptoolamptoampunderstandamp[his]amppsycheamptoampeaseamp
theamppainampthatampanampartisticampprocessampcanampbringampandamptoamprelieveampartisticampblocksamp
(Germeraadamp2013amppamp21)ampultimatelyampdeclaringampthatampitamphelpsamphimamptoampbetterampunderstandamp
hisampworkampampInampaampstyleampofampwritingampthatamposcillatesamparoundampjournalingampdocumentationampandamp
poetryampdeampCossonamp(2002)ampexploresamphisampoverlappingamprolesampasampanampartistampresearcherampandamp
teacherampampOtherampartistsampbluramptheamplineampbetweenampartamppracticeampdocumentationampandamplifeamp
furtherampstillampbyampofferingampdocumentationampasampartamplikeampSophieampCalleamp(Calleamp2011amp2008amp
2005)ampandampMaryampKellyamp(1973lt1979)ampampamp
amp Karpiakamp(2003)ampestablishesampcontemplativeamppracticesampfromamptheampperspectiveampofamp
theampeducatorampaskingampthemamptoampmineamptheampsubtleamp(pamp71)ampusingampattentivenessamp
attunementampamplificationampandampassociationampampTheseampexercisesampinampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampsetamptheamptoneampasampwellampasampprovideampaampmodelampofampbehaviorampforampotherampparticipantsamp
withinamptheampspaceampampKarpiakamp(2003)ampoutlinesampactivitiesampthatampeducatorsampcanampuseamptoampdrawamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 25amp
outampandamputilizeamptheseampsubtleampsensationsampinamptheampserviceampofamptransformativeamplearningamp(pamp
68)ampampamp
amp ForampKarpiakamp(2003)ampattentivenessamprequiresampawarenessamptoampverbalampandamp
nonverbalampcuesampasampwellampasampanampawarenessampofampwhatampisamphappeningampamongampandampwithinamptheamp
studentsampandamptheampeducatorampampAttunementamprequiresampanampeducatoramptoamporientampherselfamptoamptheamp
otherampandamptoampadoptampanampattitudeampofampunhurriednessampofamppatienceampandampofamphumilityamp
concerningampbothamptheampprocessampandamptheampoutcomesampofamptheampteachingamp(Karpiakamp2003amppgamp
72)ampampAmplificationampisampaampprocessampofamphonoringampcommunicationampthatampcentersamponamptheampideaamp
ofamphearingamponeselfampintoampknowingampitampincludesampusingampparaphrasingampandampclarificationamp
activitiesamptoampgainampinsightampintoampmeaningampampLastlyampassociationampentailsampidentifyingamp
patternsampandampweavingampthemamptogetherampwithampstudentampexperienceampclassroomampdiscussionamp
andamptheampideasampofampothersamp
amp TuningampintoampsubtletyampimpliesampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceampampTheampmanifestationsamp
ofampsilenceampinamptheampclassroomampareampendlessampandampitsampvalueampisamptooampgreatamptoampbeampignoredampwhileamp
tooampvastamptoampbeampfullyampabsorbedampampLevinamp(1989)ampremarksampthatampsilenceampisampaampclearingampwhereamp
thereampisampnothingampforamphearingamptoampholdamponamptoampinampwhichampmanyampfindampunbearableampanxietyamp
(pamp79)ampampNearlyampallampofampusamphaveampexperiencedampthisampunbearableampanxietyampaampstrainampofamp
whichampcanampbeampfoundampinampeducationalampcontextsampdueamptoamptheampfactampthatampclassroomsampareamp
oftenampstructuredamparoundampimplicitampandampexplicitamprulesampaboutamptalkampandampsilenceamp(Schultzamp
2010amppamp2848)ampampForampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampanampawarenessampofampsilenceampimplicatesamp
whatampisampleftampunsaidampandampwhatampisampunsayableltltespeciallyampimportantampbecauseampofamptheamp
unsayableampqualityampofampartworksampampForampSchultzamp(2010)ampsilenceampimpliesamppossibilityamp
becauseampitampcanampholdampmultipleampmeaningsampforampindividualsampwithinampandampacrossampracialamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 26amp
ethnicampandampculturalampgroupsamp(pamp2833)ampampLevinamp(1989)ampfindsampthatamptoamplistenamptoamp
somethingampweampmustampfirstampgive-itampourampsilenceamp(pamp232)ampampThisamppracticeampofampgivingampsilenceamp
isampparticularlyamphelpfulampinamptermsampofampviewingamporamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartamp
amp Gradleamp(2011)ampoutlinesampaamppracticalampvisionampforampviewingampartampthatamprequiresamp
silenceampandampdeliberationampampForamptheamppurposesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampwouldamp
reconceptualizeampthisampasampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampampGradleamp(2011)ampinstructedamp
herampstudentsamptoampspendamptimeampwithampaampworkampofampartampoutsideampofamptheirampeverydayampworldviewamp
attentivelyampviewingampitampforampaboutamptenampminutesampeverydayampforampaampweekampampAfterampeachampviewingamp
experienceamptheampstudentsampwroteampinamptheirampjournalsampampTheampresultsampindicatedampthatampthisamp
processampofampsustainedampsilentampdeliberationampcoupledampwithampanampengagementampofamptheiramp
intuitiveampperceptionsampaboutampartworkampleftampstudentsampfeelingampempoweredamptoampengageampinamp
discussionampandampappreciateampunfamiliarampartampformsampampThisampactivityampisampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoamp
aampworkampofampartampthatampincorporatesampSablesamp(2014)ampconceptampofampstructuredampcontemplationampamp
Weavingampaamprelationshipampbetweenampsilenceampcontemplationampandampattentivenessampisampaamp
significantampendeavorampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
Contemplativeamppracticesampfunctionampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Engageampinampformsampofampviewingampwritingampandampexperiencingampthatamphonorampselfltlisteningamp
bull Attuneamptoampsubtletyampandampnuanceampbull Listenampandampviewampdeliberatelyampbull Cultivateampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceamp(
The(Felt(Sense(
When-someone-understands-what-I-am-talking-about-when-I-talk-about-art-I-am-delighted--Art-is-my-everything--Its-my-passion--When-someone-understands-that-I-
am-instantly-filled-with-joy--That-tells-me-someone-gets-it-(Survey-response-CTF-age-16)-
(
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 17amp
amp Similarampconnectionsampcanampbeampdrawnampwhenampviewerampandampartworkampareampsubstitutedamp
forampreaderampandamptextampampInterpretationampandampunderstandingampbecomeampanampentwinedamp
creativeampendeavorampinampwhichamptheampviewerampparticipatesampasampmuchampasamptheampcreatorampbyamp
constructingampmeaningamp(Gallagheramp1992)ampampPalmeramp(1969)ampalludesamptoamptheamppluralityampofamp
meaningampinampstatingampthatamptoampfocusamppurelyamponamptheamppositivityampofampwhatampaamptextampexplicitlyamp
saysampisamptoampdoampanampinjusticeamptoamptheamphermeneuticalamptaskamp(pamp234)ampampToampfocusamponampwhatampisamp
explicitampinampaampcollageampworkampwouldampbeamptoampdisregardamptheampconnectionsampandampcontradictionsamp
ofamptheampwholeampinampfavorampofampaampdirectampreadingampofamptheampindividualamppartsampthusampmissingampoutamponamp
otheramppossibleampdimensionsampofampmeaningamp
amp Theampkeyamptoamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampeducationampinamptextampandampbetweenamp
individualsampisamptheampabilityamptoamplistenampwithampopennessampampDefensiveamplisteningampisampaampwayampofamp
listeningampwithoutampopennessampitampisampaampwayampofampprotectingampourampsmallampversionampofamptheampworldamp
andampavoidingampmoralampclaimsamponampourselvesamp(Levinamp1989amppamp79)ampampLevinamp(1989)amp
discussesampplayfulamplisteningamp(pamp233)ampasampaampwayampofampcounteractingampdefensiveamplisteningampampamp
Bohmamp(1996)ampdiscussesampsuspendingampassumptionsampaampprocessampofampattendingamptoamp
assumptionsampratherampthanamprepressingampthemamporampcarryingampthemampoutampampNicholamp(1996)amp
explainsampaampcircumstanceampinampwhichampyouampencounterampaamppersonampyouampfeelampisampanampidiotampampampYouamp
wouldamprefrainampfromampsayingampsoampoutamploudampbutampyouampwouldampalsoamprefrainampfromampscoldingamp
yourselfampforampthisampthoughtampratherampyouampwouldampseeampthisampreactionampwithoutampfullyampengagingamp
withampitampampSimilarampsuggestionsamplikeampbracketingampofampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampareamp
discussedampinamptheampfollowingampsectionampamp
amp Gadamerampbelievesamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampwhatampallowsamptheampselfamptoampapproachamp
theampotherampitampisampaampprocessampinampwhichamptheampideasampofamptheampotherampbecomeamponesampownamp(Caputoamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 18amp
2000)ampampThisampisamphardlyampanampuncommonampexperienceampampInampfactampweampregularlyampencounteramptheamp
fusionampofamphorizonsampbyampintegratingamppastampunderstandingsampwithampcurrentampexperiencesampaamp
processampundoubtedlyampcomparableamptoampeducationamp(Zuckertamp2002)ampamp
amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsamplikeampeducationampcanampbeampfrustratingampandampemotionalamp
becauseampeachamphighlight[s]amptheampfinitudeampofamptheampinterpreterampandamptheamplimitationsampofamphisamp
understandingamp(Bourgeoisamp2007amppamp79)ampampTheamptermampsharesampsimilaritiesampwithamptheamp
problematic-momentampaamppedagogicalamptermampreferringamptoampaampbreachampinampaampdominantampgroupsamp
discourseampduringampwhichampsomethingamprepressedamparisesamp(KentampampampCummingamp2008)ampampKentamp
andampCummingamp(2008)ampexploreamptheampproblematicampmomentampasampaampdiscursiveampsiteampforamp
examiningampprejudiceampwithinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampandampitsamp
moreamppoliticallyampchargedampcounterpartamptheampproblematicampmomentampbothampexploreamp
Gadamersamp(1996)ampampassertionampthatamptheampotherampmayampnotamponlyamphaveampaamprightampbutampmayamp
actuallyampbeamprightampmayampunderstandampsomethingampbetterampthanampweampdoamp(pamp82)ampampAampcreativelt
listeningampspaceamplivesampinampthisamppossibilityampampamp
amp Lastlyamprelayingampofampappropriateampexpectationsamptoampparticipantsampisampaampnecessaryamp
featureampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampdemandingampampItamp
requiresampparticipantsampwhoampareampawareampofamptheamprisksampandamphardshipsamptoampenterampintoampitampampItamp
isamptheampresponsibilityampofamptheampeducatoramporampgroupampleaderamptoampmakeamptheseampexpectationsamp
knownampasampwellampasamptoampmodelampthisampbehaviorampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionamphermeneuticallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Areampopenamptoamppossibilitiesampandamptoamptheampotherampbull Conceiveampofampthemselvesampasampengagingampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamptheamprisksampinvolvedampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamplimitationsampofamptheirampunderstandingamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 19amp
Dialogic(Practices(-
I-felt-that-everyone-was-open-and-interested-in-what-I-had-to-say---Perhaps-I-felt-this-sense-of-understanding-due-to-the-nature-of-the-discussion((-
it-felt-[like]-more-[of]-a-dialogue-as-opposed-to-a-standard-critique-(Survey-response-MW-age-22)-
(amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampartampeducationampreliesamponampanampopenampdialogueampduringamp
experiencesampwithampartampselfampandampothersampampWhatampIampfoundamplackingampinamphermeneuticsamp
howeverampwasampaampdiscussionampofamptheamphowltlthowampisamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampachievedampandamp
howampdoampindividualsampmeaningfullyampengageampwithampeachampotherampampInampanampeffortamptoampclarifyampthisamp
Iampwillampdiscussampdialogicamppracticesampasamptheyamprelateamptoampmeaningfulampverbalampexchangesampandamp
listeningampencountersampinamptheampclassroomampandampstudioampamongstampstudentsamptheiramppeersampandamp
educatorsamp
amp Communicatingampthroughamplanguageampandampdialogueampisamphowampweampcoltconstructamp
worldsampwithampourselvesampandampothersampnotampjustampthroughampanampactampofamptransmissionampbutamp
becauseampourampcommunicativeampactsampgiveampbirthamptoampworldsamp(Lipariamp2014amppamp507)ampampSableamp
(2014)ampdescribesampdialogueampasampaampgenerativeampinterchangeampbetweenampparticipantsampasamp
opposedamptoampanampexchangeampofampviewsampwhereampindividualsampsimplyampadvocateamptheiramppositionsamp
(pamp8)ampampForampBohmamp(1996)ampitampisampaampstreamampofampmeaningampflowingampamongampandampthroughampusamp
(pamp6)ampampTheampnatureampofampdialogueampandampconversationampisampinherentlyampunplannedampampThisamp
dimensionampofampconversationampisampimportantamptoampGadameramp(2004)ampwhoampfindsampthatamp
participantsampinvolvedampinampconversationampareamplessamptheampleadersampofampitampthanamptheampledamp(pamp
385)ampampSableamp(2014)ampechoesampthisampbyampwritingampthatamptheampmostampimportantamppartsampofampanyamp
conversationampareampthoseampthatampneitheramppartyampcouldamphaveampimaginedampbeforeampstartingamp(pamp
8)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 20amp
amp Theseampareampnotionsampofampdialogueampamongampothersampthatampfindampaampparallelampinamptheamp
creativeampprocessampampFairfieldamp(2011)ampwritesampthatampinampprincipleampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinamp
dialogueamp(pamp83)ampaampsentimentampthatampalignsampwithampaampcommonampissueampencounteredampduringamp
theampcreativeampprocessltltnotampknowingampwhenampaamppieceampisampdoneampampAampquoteampoftenampattributedamp
toampLeonardoampdaampVinciampspeaksamptoampthisampideaampArtampisampneverampfinishedamponlyampabandonedampamp
Snowberamp(2007)ampdrawsampparallelsampbetweenampmentorshipampdialogueampandamptheampcreativeamp
processampfindingampthatampdeepamplisteningamppracticesampconnectampallampthreeampampSheampfindsampthatamptheamp
taskampofamptheampmentorampisamptheampsameampasamptheamptaskampofamptheampartistampthatampisamptoampbringampoutamptheamp
naturalampqualitiesampofamptheampstudentamporamptheampmediumampampSnowberamp(2007)ampcommentsamponampanamp
ideaampwellltknownampamongampartistsampwhichampisampthatampaampworkampofampartamphasampaamplifeampofampitsampownampthisamp
notionampisampreminiscentampofampGadamersampstatementampaboutampbeingampledampbyampconversationamp
ampamp Dialogicamppracticesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampeducationampemphasizeampaamp
phenomenologicalampdimensionamprequiringamptwoampthingsampfromampparticipantsampampFirstlyamp
participantsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampmustampfindampvalueampinamplisteningamptoamptheamp
narrativesampofamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampampTheseampparticipantsampknowampthatampeducationamp
isampforemostampaboutamptestimonyampaboutampsharingamptheampexperienceampofampbeingamphumanampsharingamp
lifeampconvictionsampandampknowledge((Wiercinskiamp2011amppamp109)ampampNarrativesampareamp
conceivedampofampasampaampwayampofamphumanampknowingamp(Vitanovaamp2010amppamp29)ampthatampmakesamptheamp
selfampampSecondlyampwhenamplisteningamptoamptheampnarrativesampofampothersampparticipantsampareampexpectedamp
toampbracketamptheirampownampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsamp(LindsethampampampNorbergamp2004)ampampThisamp
encouragesamplistenersamptoampexperienceampandampfindampmeaningampinamptheampnarrativesampofampothersamp
whileampfreeingamptheampspeakerampfromamptheampfearampofampbeingampjudgedampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 21amp
amp Bracketingampjudgmentampandampconclusionampisampaamppotentialamptoolampwithinamptheampcommonamp
artampeducationamppracticeampofampgroupampcritiquesampampElkinsamp(2001)ampfindsampthatamppeopleampwhoamphaveamp
experienceampinampartampjudgeampveryampquicklyampandampmostampteachersampwillamphaveampaampprovisionalamp
opinionampaboutampaampworkampinamptheampfirstamptenampsecondsamp(pamp121)ampampBracketingampconclusionampandamp
judgmentampisampparticularlyampimportantampforampeducatorsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
whoseampvolumeampofampviewingampexperiencesampcouldampleadamptoampeasyampassumptionsampwhenamp
encounteringampaampnewampworkampampamp
amp Elkinsamp(2001)ampdiscussesampthatampcritiquesampcanampalsoampbeampseenampasampexchangesampofamp
storiesamporampcollaborativeampstorytellingamp(pamp145)ampwhichampisampyetampanotherampwayampofamptalkingamp
aboutamppossibilitiesampforampdialogueampandampnarrativeampwithinampartampeducationampampElkinsamphoweveramp
findsampstorytellingamplimitingamponceamptheampdeeperampnarrativesampareampdiscoveredamp(2001amppamp
145)ampampThisampimpliesampthatampheampfindsamponlyampaampsingularampmeaningampandamponeampthatampisampnotamp
necessarilyampusefulampforampcollaborativeampgroupampcritiquesamp
amp Insteadampparticipantsampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampbringampknowledgeampofamp
polysemyamptoampcollaborativeampcritiqueampexperiencesampasampwellampasamptoampexperiencesampofampmakingamp
artworkampampAccordingamptoampMuldoonamp(2002)amppolysemyampisamptheampqualityampofampaampwordamporampotheramp
languageampunitampthatampcanampbearampmultipleampmeaningsamp(asampcitedampinampWorsleyamp2012amppamp308)ampampamp
Aamptextualampexampleampofampthisampisamptheampmultipleampmeaningsampofamptheampwordampcan-Iampcanampdriveampaampcaramp
Idamplikeampaampcan-ofampsodaampheampwasntampworkingampveryamphardampsoampIamphadamptoampcan-himamp(Munozamp
2014)ampampampButampifampweampconsideramppolysemyampmetaphoricallyamporampvisuallyamptheampideaampthatampaamp
singleampunitampimageamporampintentionampcouldampbearampmultipleampmeaningsampcouldampbeampproductiveampinamp
creatingltlisteningampspacesampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 22amp
amp Thisampunfoldingampofampmeaningampworksampwellampinamptheampcontextampofampcollageampandampdialogueamp
asampwellampasamphermeneuticsampampInampfactamphermeneuticsampimpliesamppolysemyampbecauseampofampitsamp
notionampthatampitampisampalwaysampaamppossibilityampofampmyampunderstandingampthatampisampplayedampoutampwhenampIamp
understandampaamptextamp(Grondinamp2002amppamp38)ampampPolysemyampcouldampbeampconceptualizedampasampanamp
alternativeampexplorationampofampmeaningampthatampfunctionsampcollaborativelyampwithinampcritiquesampamp
Forampexampleampeducatorsampcanampaskampstudentsamptoamprespondamptoampaampworkampthroughampcollageamp
journalampentriesampmusicampfilmampasampindividualsamporampinampgroupsampampKnowledgeampofamppolysemyamp
couldampalsoampbeampusedampasampaamptoolampforampcreatingampimagesampthatamprecognizesampaamprelationshipamp
betweenamptheampvisualamptheamplinguisticampandamptheampmultipleamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionampdialogicallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Placeampvalueamponampexperientialampnarrativesampbull Practiceamplisteningampbyampbracketingampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampbull Embraceamppolysemicampexplorationsampofampmeaningampamp
Contemplative(Practices(
I-knew-I-was-being-heard-because-of-her-mannerisms-and-the-look-on-her-face--She-was-calm-attentive-and-not-trying-to-jump-in-and-offer-any-advice--She-asked-questions-that-pointed-to-things-I-had-not-openly-articulated-because-of-uncertainty--
This-was-one-of-the-ways-I-knew-I-was-being-heard-(Survey-response-LS-age-27)-
(amp Ifamphermeneuticsampandampdialogicamppracticesampgiveampusamptheampbroadampstrokesampofampactivityampinamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampcontemplativeamppracticesampseekamptoamptuneampstudentsampandamp
educatorsampintoampnuanceampdeliberationampandampdeepampexplorationampampThisampisampaampmostlyamp
individualampinternalamppursuitampthatampfocusesamponampformsampofampselfltlisteningampbutampcontemplativeamp
practicesampareampalsoampformedampbyampanampawarenessampofampinterconnectednessamp
amp InamppursuitampofampcriticalampthinkingampSableamp(2014)ampoutlinesampaampsetampofampcontemplativeamp
practicesampforampstudentsampthatampincludeampmindfulampmeditationampstructuredampcontemplationamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 23amp
journalampwritingampmindfulamplisteningampreflectiveampinquiryampandampdialogueamp(pamp4)ampampWhileamp
Sablesamp(2014)ampmethodampforampcontemplativeamppracticesampprovidesampaampconcreteampframeworkamp
withampspecificampstepsampmanyampofamptheseampconceptsampcouldampbeampappliedampwithoutampsuchampaamp
prescribedampstructureampampForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwillampbeamp
primarilyampdiscussingampSablesampconceptsampofampstructuredampcontemplationampreflectiveamp
inquiryampandampjournalampwritingamp
amp ForampSableamp(2014)ampstructuredampcontemplationampisampaampformampofampbeingamppresentampandamp
focusedamponampaampparticularampquestionampstatementamporampimageampampWithinampthisampmodeampofampinquiryamp
participantsampareampexpectedamptoampholdamptheampobjectampofampcontemplationampinamptheirampmindsamp
deepeningampunderstandingampasamptheyampfocusampwithoutampanalyzingampitamporampmanipulatingampitampinamp
anyampwayamp(pamp5)ampampThisamppracticeampdrawsampcomparisonsamptoamptheampbracketingampofampjudgmentsamp
andampconclusionsampsupportedampinamptheamppreviousampsectionampbutampstructuredampcontemplationamp
occursamponampanampindividualamplevelampratherampthanampdialogicallyamp
amp Reflectiveampinquiryampbearsampsomeampsimilaritiesamptoampstructuredampcontemplationampbutamp
Sableamp(2014)amppositionsampitampasampanampactivityampbetweenamptwoampindividualsampaamplistenerampandampaamp
speakerampampTheamplistenerampisampagainampaskedamptoampsuspendampjudgmentampbutampalsoamptoampengageampinampaamp
formampofampcuriosityampinampwhichampinnocentampquestionsampareampaskedampinamporderamptoampgainamp
understandingampampSableamp(2014)ampcontrastsampinnocentampquestionsampwithampleadingampquestionsampamp
ForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwouldampcharacterizeampthisampinnocentamp
questioningampasampaampformampofampopenltendedampquestioningampampSableamp(2014)ampidentifiesampanamp
exampleampofampanampinnocentamp(orampopenltended)ampquestionampWhatampdidampyouampmeanampwhenampyouamp
saidamp________ampConverselyampaampleadingampquestionampisampDidampyouampmeanamptoampsayamp________ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 24amp
amp Sableamp(2014)ampusesampjournalampwritingampasampaamppieceampofamphisamplargerampstructureampofamp
contemplativeamppracticesampbutampjournalampwritingampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampcouldamp
potentiallyampoccupyampaampsignificantamproleampampIampconceiveampofampjournalampwritingampinampmyampownamp
creativeamppracticeampasampaampformampofampdocumentationampthatampmakesampmeampmoreampawareampofampmyamp
creativeampprocessamptheampemotionalamphabitsampthatampsurroundampitampandamptheampthemesampthatamp
structureampmyampworkampampIampconceptualizeampthisampwayampofampwritingampasampaampformampofampselfltlisteningamp
relatedamptoampaampkeyampconceptampofamphermeneuticsampfoundampinampGadamersampassertionampthatampallamp
educationampisampaampformampofampselflteducationamp(Grondinamp2011)ampampamp
amp Germeraadamp(2013)ampusesampjournalampwritingamptoampexploreamptheampemotionalampandamprationalamp
relationshipsamptoamphisampcreativeampprocessampparallelamptoampexecutingampaampnewampbodyampofampworkampampHeamp
findsampthatampwritingampduringamphisampprocessampisampaamptoolamptoampunderstandamp[his]amppsycheamptoampeaseamp
theamppainampthatampanampartisticampprocessampcanampbringampandamptoamprelieveampartisticampblocksamp
(Germeraadamp2013amppamp21)ampultimatelyampdeclaringampthatampitamphelpsamphimamptoampbetterampunderstandamp
hisampworkampampInampaampstyleampofampwritingampthatamposcillatesamparoundampjournalingampdocumentationampandamp
poetryampdeampCossonamp(2002)ampexploresamphisampoverlappingamprolesampasampanampartistampresearcherampandamp
teacherampampOtherampartistsampbluramptheamplineampbetweenampartamppracticeampdocumentationampandamplifeamp
furtherampstillampbyampofferingampdocumentationampasampartamplikeampSophieampCalleamp(Calleamp2011amp2008amp
2005)ampandampMaryampKellyamp(1973lt1979)ampampamp
amp Karpiakamp(2003)ampestablishesampcontemplativeamppracticesampfromamptheampperspectiveampofamp
theampeducatorampaskingampthemamptoampmineamptheampsubtleamp(pamp71)ampusingampattentivenessamp
attunementampamplificationampandampassociationampampTheseampexercisesampinampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampsetamptheamptoneampasampwellampasampprovideampaampmodelampofampbehaviorampforampotherampparticipantsamp
withinamptheampspaceampampKarpiakamp(2003)ampoutlinesampactivitiesampthatampeducatorsampcanampuseamptoampdrawamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 25amp
outampandamputilizeamptheseampsubtleampsensationsampinamptheampserviceampofamptransformativeamplearningamp(pamp
68)ampampamp
amp ForampKarpiakamp(2003)ampattentivenessamprequiresampawarenessamptoampverbalampandamp
nonverbalampcuesampasampwellampasampanampawarenessampofampwhatampisamphappeningampamongampandampwithinamptheamp
studentsampandamptheampeducatorampampAttunementamprequiresampanampeducatoramptoamporientampherselfamptoamptheamp
otherampandamptoampadoptampanampattitudeampofampunhurriednessampofamppatienceampandampofamphumilityamp
concerningampbothamptheampprocessampandamptheampoutcomesampofamptheampteachingamp(Karpiakamp2003amppgamp
72)ampampAmplificationampisampaampprocessampofamphonoringampcommunicationampthatampcentersamponamptheampideaamp
ofamphearingamponeselfampintoampknowingampitampincludesampusingampparaphrasingampandampclarificationamp
activitiesamptoampgainampinsightampintoampmeaningampampLastlyampassociationampentailsampidentifyingamp
patternsampandampweavingampthemamptogetherampwithampstudentampexperienceampclassroomampdiscussionamp
andamptheampideasampofampothersamp
amp TuningampintoampsubtletyampimpliesampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceampampTheampmanifestationsamp
ofampsilenceampinamptheampclassroomampareampendlessampandampitsampvalueampisamptooampgreatamptoampbeampignoredampwhileamp
tooampvastamptoampbeampfullyampabsorbedampampLevinamp(1989)ampremarksampthatampsilenceampisampaampclearingampwhereamp
thereampisampnothingampforamphearingamptoampholdamponamptoampinampwhichampmanyampfindampunbearableampanxietyamp
(pamp79)ampampNearlyampallampofampusamphaveampexperiencedampthisampunbearableampanxietyampaampstrainampofamp
whichampcanampbeampfoundampinampeducationalampcontextsampdueamptoamptheampfactampthatampclassroomsampareamp
oftenampstructuredamparoundampimplicitampandampexplicitamprulesampaboutamptalkampandampsilenceamp(Schultzamp
2010amppamp2848)ampampForampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampanampawarenessampofampsilenceampimplicatesamp
whatampisampleftampunsaidampandampwhatampisampunsayableltltespeciallyampimportantampbecauseampofamptheamp
unsayableampqualityampofampartworksampampForampSchultzamp(2010)ampsilenceampimpliesamppossibilityamp
becauseampitampcanampholdampmultipleampmeaningsampforampindividualsampwithinampandampacrossampracialamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 26amp
ethnicampandampculturalampgroupsamp(pamp2833)ampampLevinamp(1989)ampfindsampthatamptoamplistenamptoamp
somethingampweampmustampfirstampgive-itampourampsilenceamp(pamp232)ampampThisamppracticeampofampgivingampsilenceamp
isampparticularlyamphelpfulampinamptermsampofampviewingamporamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartamp
amp Gradleamp(2011)ampoutlinesampaamppracticalampvisionampforampviewingampartampthatamprequiresamp
silenceampandampdeliberationampampForamptheamppurposesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampwouldamp
reconceptualizeampthisampasampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampampGradleamp(2011)ampinstructedamp
herampstudentsamptoampspendamptimeampwithampaampworkampofampartampoutsideampofamptheirampeverydayampworldviewamp
attentivelyampviewingampitampforampaboutamptenampminutesampeverydayampforampaampweekampampAfterampeachampviewingamp
experienceamptheampstudentsampwroteampinamptheirampjournalsampampTheampresultsampindicatedampthatampthisamp
processampofampsustainedampsilentampdeliberationampcoupledampwithampanampengagementampofamptheiramp
intuitiveampperceptionsampaboutampartworkampleftampstudentsampfeelingampempoweredamptoampengageampinamp
discussionampandampappreciateampunfamiliarampartampformsampampThisampactivityampisampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoamp
aampworkampofampartampthatampincorporatesampSablesamp(2014)ampconceptampofampstructuredampcontemplationampamp
Weavingampaamprelationshipampbetweenampsilenceampcontemplationampandampattentivenessampisampaamp
significantampendeavorampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
Contemplativeamppracticesampfunctionampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Engageampinampformsampofampviewingampwritingampandampexperiencingampthatamphonorampselfltlisteningamp
bull Attuneamptoampsubtletyampandampnuanceampbull Listenampandampviewampdeliberatelyampbull Cultivateampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceamp(
The(Felt(Sense(
When-someone-understands-what-I-am-talking-about-when-I-talk-about-art-I-am-delighted--Art-is-my-everything--Its-my-passion--When-someone-understands-that-I-
am-instantly-filled-with-joy--That-tells-me-someone-gets-it-(Survey-response-CTF-age-16)-
(
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 18amp
2000)ampampThisampisamphardlyampanampuncommonampexperienceampampInampfactampweampregularlyampencounteramptheamp
fusionampofamphorizonsampbyampintegratingamppastampunderstandingsampwithampcurrentampexperiencesampaamp
processampundoubtedlyampcomparableamptoampeducationamp(Zuckertamp2002)ampamp
amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsamplikeampeducationampcanampbeampfrustratingampandampemotionalamp
becauseampeachamphighlight[s]amptheampfinitudeampofamptheampinterpreterampandamptheamplimitationsampofamphisamp
understandingamp(Bourgeoisamp2007amppamp79)ampampTheamptermampsharesampsimilaritiesampwithamptheamp
problematic-momentampaamppedagogicalamptermampreferringamptoampaampbreachampinampaampdominantampgroupsamp
discourseampduringampwhichampsomethingamprepressedamparisesamp(KentampampampCummingamp2008)ampampKentamp
andampCummingamp(2008)ampexploreamptheampproblematicampmomentampasampaampdiscursiveampsiteampforamp
examiningampprejudiceampwithinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampandampitsamp
moreamppoliticallyampchargedampcounterpartamptheampproblematicampmomentampbothampexploreamp
Gadamersamp(1996)ampampassertionampthatamptheampotherampmayampnotamponlyamphaveampaamprightampbutampmayamp
actuallyampbeamprightampmayampunderstandampsomethingampbetterampthanampweampdoamp(pamp82)ampampAampcreativelt
listeningampspaceamplivesampinampthisamppossibilityampampamp
amp Lastlyamprelayingampofampappropriateampexpectationsamptoampparticipantsampisampaampnecessaryamp
featureampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampTheampfusionampofamphorizonsampisampdemandingampampItamp
requiresampparticipantsampwhoampareampawareampofamptheamprisksampandamphardshipsamptoampenterampintoampitampampItamp
isamptheampresponsibilityampofamptheampeducatoramporampgroupampleaderamptoampmakeamptheseampexpectationsamp
knownampasampwellampasamptoampmodelampthisampbehaviorampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionamphermeneuticallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Areampopenamptoamppossibilitiesampandamptoamptheampotherampbull Conceiveampofampthemselvesampasampengagingampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamptheamprisksampinvolvedampinamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampbull Acknowledgeamplimitationsampofamptheirampunderstandingamp
amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 19amp
Dialogic(Practices(-
I-felt-that-everyone-was-open-and-interested-in-what-I-had-to-say---Perhaps-I-felt-this-sense-of-understanding-due-to-the-nature-of-the-discussion((-
it-felt-[like]-more-[of]-a-dialogue-as-opposed-to-a-standard-critique-(Survey-response-MW-age-22)-
(amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampartampeducationampreliesamponampanampopenampdialogueampduringamp
experiencesampwithampartampselfampandampothersampampWhatampIampfoundamplackingampinamphermeneuticsamp
howeverampwasampaampdiscussionampofamptheamphowltlthowampisamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampachievedampandamp
howampdoampindividualsampmeaningfullyampengageampwithampeachampotherampampInampanampeffortamptoampclarifyampthisamp
Iampwillampdiscussampdialogicamppracticesampasamptheyamprelateamptoampmeaningfulampverbalampexchangesampandamp
listeningampencountersampinamptheampclassroomampandampstudioampamongstampstudentsamptheiramppeersampandamp
educatorsamp
amp Communicatingampthroughamplanguageampandampdialogueampisamphowampweampcoltconstructamp
worldsampwithampourselvesampandampothersampnotampjustampthroughampanampactampofamptransmissionampbutamp
becauseampourampcommunicativeampactsampgiveampbirthamptoampworldsamp(Lipariamp2014amppamp507)ampampSableamp
(2014)ampdescribesampdialogueampasampaampgenerativeampinterchangeampbetweenampparticipantsampasamp
opposedamptoampanampexchangeampofampviewsampwhereampindividualsampsimplyampadvocateamptheiramppositionsamp
(pamp8)ampampForampBohmamp(1996)ampitampisampaampstreamampofampmeaningampflowingampamongampandampthroughampusamp
(pamp6)ampampTheampnatureampofampdialogueampandampconversationampisampinherentlyampunplannedampampThisamp
dimensionampofampconversationampisampimportantamptoampGadameramp(2004)ampwhoampfindsampthatamp
participantsampinvolvedampinampconversationampareamplessamptheampleadersampofampitampthanamptheampledamp(pamp
385)ampampSableamp(2014)ampechoesampthisampbyampwritingampthatamptheampmostampimportantamppartsampofampanyamp
conversationampareampthoseampthatampneitheramppartyampcouldamphaveampimaginedampbeforeampstartingamp(pamp
8)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 20amp
amp Theseampareampnotionsampofampdialogueampamongampothersampthatampfindampaampparallelampinamptheamp
creativeampprocessampampFairfieldamp(2011)ampwritesampthatampinampprincipleampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinamp
dialogueamp(pamp83)ampaampsentimentampthatampalignsampwithampaampcommonampissueampencounteredampduringamp
theampcreativeampprocessltltnotampknowingampwhenampaamppieceampisampdoneampampAampquoteampoftenampattributedamp
toampLeonardoampdaampVinciampspeaksamptoampthisampideaampArtampisampneverampfinishedamponlyampabandonedampamp
Snowberamp(2007)ampdrawsampparallelsampbetweenampmentorshipampdialogueampandamptheampcreativeamp
processampfindingampthatampdeepamplisteningamppracticesampconnectampallampthreeampampSheampfindsampthatamptheamp
taskampofamptheampmentorampisamptheampsameampasamptheamptaskampofamptheampartistampthatampisamptoampbringampoutamptheamp
naturalampqualitiesampofamptheampstudentamporamptheampmediumampampSnowberamp(2007)ampcommentsamponampanamp
ideaampwellltknownampamongampartistsampwhichampisampthatampaampworkampofampartamphasampaamplifeampofampitsampownampthisamp
notionampisampreminiscentampofampGadamersampstatementampaboutampbeingampledampbyampconversationamp
ampamp Dialogicamppracticesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampeducationampemphasizeampaamp
phenomenologicalampdimensionamprequiringamptwoampthingsampfromampparticipantsampampFirstlyamp
participantsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampmustampfindampvalueampinamplisteningamptoamptheamp
narrativesampofamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampampTheseampparticipantsampknowampthatampeducationamp
isampforemostampaboutamptestimonyampaboutampsharingamptheampexperienceampofampbeingamphumanampsharingamp
lifeampconvictionsampandampknowledge((Wiercinskiamp2011amppamp109)ampampNarrativesampareamp
conceivedampofampasampaampwayampofamphumanampknowingamp(Vitanovaamp2010amppamp29)ampthatampmakesamptheamp
selfampampSecondlyampwhenamplisteningamptoamptheampnarrativesampofampothersampparticipantsampareampexpectedamp
toampbracketamptheirampownampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsamp(LindsethampampampNorbergamp2004)ampampThisamp
encouragesamplistenersamptoampexperienceampandampfindampmeaningampinamptheampnarrativesampofampothersamp
whileampfreeingamptheampspeakerampfromamptheampfearampofampbeingampjudgedampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 21amp
amp Bracketingampjudgmentampandampconclusionampisampaamppotentialamptoolampwithinamptheampcommonamp
artampeducationamppracticeampofampgroupampcritiquesampampElkinsamp(2001)ampfindsampthatamppeopleampwhoamphaveamp
experienceampinampartampjudgeampveryampquicklyampandampmostampteachersampwillamphaveampaampprovisionalamp
opinionampaboutampaampworkampinamptheampfirstamptenampsecondsamp(pamp121)ampampBracketingampconclusionampandamp
judgmentampisampparticularlyampimportantampforampeducatorsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
whoseampvolumeampofampviewingampexperiencesampcouldampleadamptoampeasyampassumptionsampwhenamp
encounteringampaampnewampworkampampamp
amp Elkinsamp(2001)ampdiscussesampthatampcritiquesampcanampalsoampbeampseenampasampexchangesampofamp
storiesamporampcollaborativeampstorytellingamp(pamp145)ampwhichampisampyetampanotherampwayampofamptalkingamp
aboutamppossibilitiesampforampdialogueampandampnarrativeampwithinampartampeducationampampElkinsamphoweveramp
findsampstorytellingamplimitingamponceamptheampdeeperampnarrativesampareampdiscoveredamp(2001amppamp
145)ampampThisampimpliesampthatampheampfindsamponlyampaampsingularampmeaningampandamponeampthatampisampnotamp
necessarilyampusefulampforampcollaborativeampgroupampcritiquesamp
amp Insteadampparticipantsampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampbringampknowledgeampofamp
polysemyamptoampcollaborativeampcritiqueampexperiencesampasampwellampasamptoampexperiencesampofampmakingamp
artworkampampAccordingamptoampMuldoonamp(2002)amppolysemyampisamptheampqualityampofampaampwordamporampotheramp
languageampunitampthatampcanampbearampmultipleampmeaningsamp(asampcitedampinampWorsleyamp2012amppamp308)ampampamp
Aamptextualampexampleampofampthisampisamptheampmultipleampmeaningsampofamptheampwordampcan-Iampcanampdriveampaampcaramp
Idamplikeampaampcan-ofampsodaampheampwasntampworkingampveryamphardampsoampIamphadamptoampcan-himamp(Munozamp
2014)ampampampButampifampweampconsideramppolysemyampmetaphoricallyamporampvisuallyamptheampideaampthatampaamp
singleampunitampimageamporampintentionampcouldampbearampmultipleampmeaningsampcouldampbeampproductiveampinamp
creatingltlisteningampspacesampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 22amp
amp Thisampunfoldingampofampmeaningampworksampwellampinamptheampcontextampofampcollageampandampdialogueamp
asampwellampasamphermeneuticsampampInampfactamphermeneuticsampimpliesamppolysemyampbecauseampofampitsamp
notionampthatampitampisampalwaysampaamppossibilityampofampmyampunderstandingampthatampisampplayedampoutampwhenampIamp
understandampaamptextamp(Grondinamp2002amppamp38)ampampPolysemyampcouldampbeampconceptualizedampasampanamp
alternativeampexplorationampofampmeaningampthatampfunctionsampcollaborativelyampwithinampcritiquesampamp
Forampexampleampeducatorsampcanampaskampstudentsamptoamprespondamptoampaampworkampthroughampcollageamp
journalampentriesampmusicampfilmampasampindividualsamporampinampgroupsampampKnowledgeampofamppolysemyamp
couldampalsoampbeampusedampasampaamptoolampforampcreatingampimagesampthatamprecognizesampaamprelationshipamp
betweenamptheampvisualamptheamplinguisticampandamptheampmultipleamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionampdialogicallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Placeampvalueamponampexperientialampnarrativesampbull Practiceamplisteningampbyampbracketingampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampbull Embraceamppolysemicampexplorationsampofampmeaningampamp
Contemplative(Practices(
I-knew-I-was-being-heard-because-of-her-mannerisms-and-the-look-on-her-face--She-was-calm-attentive-and-not-trying-to-jump-in-and-offer-any-advice--She-asked-questions-that-pointed-to-things-I-had-not-openly-articulated-because-of-uncertainty--
This-was-one-of-the-ways-I-knew-I-was-being-heard-(Survey-response-LS-age-27)-
(amp Ifamphermeneuticsampandampdialogicamppracticesampgiveampusamptheampbroadampstrokesampofampactivityampinamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampcontemplativeamppracticesampseekamptoamptuneampstudentsampandamp
educatorsampintoampnuanceampdeliberationampandampdeepampexplorationampampThisampisampaampmostlyamp
individualampinternalamppursuitampthatampfocusesamponampformsampofampselfltlisteningampbutampcontemplativeamp
practicesampareampalsoampformedampbyampanampawarenessampofampinterconnectednessamp
amp InamppursuitampofampcriticalampthinkingampSableamp(2014)ampoutlinesampaampsetampofampcontemplativeamp
practicesampforampstudentsampthatampincludeampmindfulampmeditationampstructuredampcontemplationamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 23amp
journalampwritingampmindfulamplisteningampreflectiveampinquiryampandampdialogueamp(pamp4)ampampWhileamp
Sablesamp(2014)ampmethodampforampcontemplativeamppracticesampprovidesampaampconcreteampframeworkamp
withampspecificampstepsampmanyampofamptheseampconceptsampcouldampbeampappliedampwithoutampsuchampaamp
prescribedampstructureampampForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwillampbeamp
primarilyampdiscussingampSablesampconceptsampofampstructuredampcontemplationampreflectiveamp
inquiryampandampjournalampwritingamp
amp ForampSableamp(2014)ampstructuredampcontemplationampisampaampformampofampbeingamppresentampandamp
focusedamponampaampparticularampquestionampstatementamporampimageampampWithinampthisampmodeampofampinquiryamp
participantsampareampexpectedamptoampholdamptheampobjectampofampcontemplationampinamptheirampmindsamp
deepeningampunderstandingampasamptheyampfocusampwithoutampanalyzingampitamporampmanipulatingampitampinamp
anyampwayamp(pamp5)ampampThisamppracticeampdrawsampcomparisonsamptoamptheampbracketingampofampjudgmentsamp
andampconclusionsampsupportedampinamptheamppreviousampsectionampbutampstructuredampcontemplationamp
occursamponampanampindividualamplevelampratherampthanampdialogicallyamp
amp Reflectiveampinquiryampbearsampsomeampsimilaritiesamptoampstructuredampcontemplationampbutamp
Sableamp(2014)amppositionsampitampasampanampactivityampbetweenamptwoampindividualsampaamplistenerampandampaamp
speakerampampTheamplistenerampisampagainampaskedamptoampsuspendampjudgmentampbutampalsoamptoampengageampinampaamp
formampofampcuriosityampinampwhichampinnocentampquestionsampareampaskedampinamporderamptoampgainamp
understandingampampSableamp(2014)ampcontrastsampinnocentampquestionsampwithampleadingampquestionsampamp
ForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwouldampcharacterizeampthisampinnocentamp
questioningampasampaampformampofampopenltendedampquestioningampampSableamp(2014)ampidentifiesampanamp
exampleampofampanampinnocentamp(orampopenltended)ampquestionampWhatampdidampyouampmeanampwhenampyouamp
saidamp________ampConverselyampaampleadingampquestionampisampDidampyouampmeanamptoampsayamp________ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 24amp
amp Sableamp(2014)ampusesampjournalampwritingampasampaamppieceampofamphisamplargerampstructureampofamp
contemplativeamppracticesampbutampjournalampwritingampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampcouldamp
potentiallyampoccupyampaampsignificantamproleampampIampconceiveampofampjournalampwritingampinampmyampownamp
creativeamppracticeampasampaampformampofampdocumentationampthatampmakesampmeampmoreampawareampofampmyamp
creativeampprocessamptheampemotionalamphabitsampthatampsurroundampitampandamptheampthemesampthatamp
structureampmyampworkampampIampconceptualizeampthisampwayampofampwritingampasampaampformampofampselfltlisteningamp
relatedamptoampaampkeyampconceptampofamphermeneuticsampfoundampinampGadamersampassertionampthatampallamp
educationampisampaampformampofampselflteducationamp(Grondinamp2011)ampampamp
amp Germeraadamp(2013)ampusesampjournalampwritingamptoampexploreamptheampemotionalampandamprationalamp
relationshipsamptoamphisampcreativeampprocessampparallelamptoampexecutingampaampnewampbodyampofampworkampampHeamp
findsampthatampwritingampduringamphisampprocessampisampaamptoolamptoampunderstandamp[his]amppsycheamptoampeaseamp
theamppainampthatampanampartisticampprocessampcanampbringampandamptoamprelieveampartisticampblocksamp
(Germeraadamp2013amppamp21)ampultimatelyampdeclaringampthatampitamphelpsamphimamptoampbetterampunderstandamp
hisampworkampampInampaampstyleampofampwritingampthatamposcillatesamparoundampjournalingampdocumentationampandamp
poetryampdeampCossonamp(2002)ampexploresamphisampoverlappingamprolesampasampanampartistampresearcherampandamp
teacherampampOtherampartistsampbluramptheamplineampbetweenampartamppracticeampdocumentationampandamplifeamp
furtherampstillampbyampofferingampdocumentationampasampartamplikeampSophieampCalleamp(Calleamp2011amp2008amp
2005)ampandampMaryampKellyamp(1973lt1979)ampampamp
amp Karpiakamp(2003)ampestablishesampcontemplativeamppracticesampfromamptheampperspectiveampofamp
theampeducatorampaskingampthemamptoampmineamptheampsubtleamp(pamp71)ampusingampattentivenessamp
attunementampamplificationampandampassociationampampTheseampexercisesampinampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampsetamptheamptoneampasampwellampasampprovideampaampmodelampofampbehaviorampforampotherampparticipantsamp
withinamptheampspaceampampKarpiakamp(2003)ampoutlinesampactivitiesampthatampeducatorsampcanampuseamptoampdrawamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 25amp
outampandamputilizeamptheseampsubtleampsensationsampinamptheampserviceampofamptransformativeamplearningamp(pamp
68)ampampamp
amp ForampKarpiakamp(2003)ampattentivenessamprequiresampawarenessamptoampverbalampandamp
nonverbalampcuesampasampwellampasampanampawarenessampofampwhatampisamphappeningampamongampandampwithinamptheamp
studentsampandamptheampeducatorampampAttunementamprequiresampanampeducatoramptoamporientampherselfamptoamptheamp
otherampandamptoampadoptampanampattitudeampofampunhurriednessampofamppatienceampandampofamphumilityamp
concerningampbothamptheampprocessampandamptheampoutcomesampofamptheampteachingamp(Karpiakamp2003amppgamp
72)ampampAmplificationampisampaampprocessampofamphonoringampcommunicationampthatampcentersamponamptheampideaamp
ofamphearingamponeselfampintoampknowingampitampincludesampusingampparaphrasingampandampclarificationamp
activitiesamptoampgainampinsightampintoampmeaningampampLastlyampassociationampentailsampidentifyingamp
patternsampandampweavingampthemamptogetherampwithampstudentampexperienceampclassroomampdiscussionamp
andamptheampideasampofampothersamp
amp TuningampintoampsubtletyampimpliesampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceampampTheampmanifestationsamp
ofampsilenceampinamptheampclassroomampareampendlessampandampitsampvalueampisamptooampgreatamptoampbeampignoredampwhileamp
tooampvastamptoampbeampfullyampabsorbedampampLevinamp(1989)ampremarksampthatampsilenceampisampaampclearingampwhereamp
thereampisampnothingampforamphearingamptoampholdamponamptoampinampwhichampmanyampfindampunbearableampanxietyamp
(pamp79)ampampNearlyampallampofampusamphaveampexperiencedampthisampunbearableampanxietyampaampstrainampofamp
whichampcanampbeampfoundampinampeducationalampcontextsampdueamptoamptheampfactampthatampclassroomsampareamp
oftenampstructuredamparoundampimplicitampandampexplicitamprulesampaboutamptalkampandampsilenceamp(Schultzamp
2010amppamp2848)ampampForampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampanampawarenessampofampsilenceampimplicatesamp
whatampisampleftampunsaidampandampwhatampisampunsayableltltespeciallyampimportantampbecauseampofamptheamp
unsayableampqualityampofampartworksampampForampSchultzamp(2010)ampsilenceampimpliesamppossibilityamp
becauseampitampcanampholdampmultipleampmeaningsampforampindividualsampwithinampandampacrossampracialamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 26amp
ethnicampandampculturalampgroupsamp(pamp2833)ampampLevinamp(1989)ampfindsampthatamptoamplistenamptoamp
somethingampweampmustampfirstampgive-itampourampsilenceamp(pamp232)ampampThisamppracticeampofampgivingampsilenceamp
isampparticularlyamphelpfulampinamptermsampofampviewingamporamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartamp
amp Gradleamp(2011)ampoutlinesampaamppracticalampvisionampforampviewingampartampthatamprequiresamp
silenceampandampdeliberationampampForamptheamppurposesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampwouldamp
reconceptualizeampthisampasampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampampGradleamp(2011)ampinstructedamp
herampstudentsamptoampspendamptimeampwithampaampworkampofampartampoutsideampofamptheirampeverydayampworldviewamp
attentivelyampviewingampitampforampaboutamptenampminutesampeverydayampforampaampweekampampAfterampeachampviewingamp
experienceamptheampstudentsampwroteampinamptheirampjournalsampampTheampresultsampindicatedampthatampthisamp
processampofampsustainedampsilentampdeliberationampcoupledampwithampanampengagementampofamptheiramp
intuitiveampperceptionsampaboutampartworkampleftampstudentsampfeelingampempoweredamptoampengageampinamp
discussionampandampappreciateampunfamiliarampartampformsampampThisampactivityampisampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoamp
aampworkampofampartampthatampincorporatesampSablesamp(2014)ampconceptampofampstructuredampcontemplationampamp
Weavingampaamprelationshipampbetweenampsilenceampcontemplationampandampattentivenessampisampaamp
significantampendeavorampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
Contemplativeamppracticesampfunctionampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Engageampinampformsampofampviewingampwritingampandampexperiencingampthatamphonorampselfltlisteningamp
bull Attuneamptoampsubtletyampandampnuanceampbull Listenampandampviewampdeliberatelyampbull Cultivateampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceamp(
The(Felt(Sense(
When-someone-understands-what-I-am-talking-about-when-I-talk-about-art-I-am-delighted--Art-is-my-everything--Its-my-passion--When-someone-understands-that-I-
am-instantly-filled-with-joy--That-tells-me-someone-gets-it-(Survey-response-CTF-age-16)-
(
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 19amp
Dialogic(Practices(-
I-felt-that-everyone-was-open-and-interested-in-what-I-had-to-say---Perhaps-I-felt-this-sense-of-understanding-due-to-the-nature-of-the-discussion((-
it-felt-[like]-more-[of]-a-dialogue-as-opposed-to-a-standard-critique-(Survey-response-MW-age-22)-
(amp Theampfusionampofamphorizonsampinampartampeducationampreliesamponampanampopenampdialogueampduringamp
experiencesampwithampartampselfampandampothersampampWhatampIampfoundamplackingampinamphermeneuticsamp
howeverampwasampaampdiscussionampofamptheamphowltlthowampisamptheampfusionampofamphorizonsampachievedampandamp
howampdoampindividualsampmeaningfullyampengageampwithampeachampotherampampInampanampeffortamptoampclarifyampthisamp
Iampwillampdiscussampdialogicamppracticesampasamptheyamprelateamptoampmeaningfulampverbalampexchangesampandamp
listeningampencountersampinamptheampclassroomampandampstudioampamongstampstudentsamptheiramppeersampandamp
educatorsamp
amp Communicatingampthroughamplanguageampandampdialogueampisamphowampweampcoltconstructamp
worldsampwithampourselvesampandampothersampnotampjustampthroughampanampactampofamptransmissionampbutamp
becauseampourampcommunicativeampactsampgiveampbirthamptoampworldsamp(Lipariamp2014amppamp507)ampampSableamp
(2014)ampdescribesampdialogueampasampaampgenerativeampinterchangeampbetweenampparticipantsampasamp
opposedamptoampanampexchangeampofampviewsampwhereampindividualsampsimplyampadvocateamptheiramppositionsamp
(pamp8)ampampForampBohmamp(1996)ampitampisampaampstreamampofampmeaningampflowingampamongampandampthroughampusamp
(pamp6)ampampTheampnatureampofampdialogueampandampconversationampisampinherentlyampunplannedampampThisamp
dimensionampofampconversationampisampimportantamptoampGadameramp(2004)ampwhoampfindsampthatamp
participantsampinvolvedampinampconversationampareamplessamptheampleadersampofampitampthanamptheampledamp(pamp
385)ampampSableamp(2014)ampechoesampthisampbyampwritingampthatamptheampmostampimportantamppartsampofampanyamp
conversationampareampthoseampthatampneitheramppartyampcouldamphaveampimaginedampbeforeampstartingamp(pamp
8)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 20amp
amp Theseampareampnotionsampofampdialogueampamongampothersampthatampfindampaampparallelampinamptheamp
creativeampprocessampampFairfieldamp(2011)ampwritesampthatampinampprincipleampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinamp
dialogueamp(pamp83)ampaampsentimentampthatampalignsampwithampaampcommonampissueampencounteredampduringamp
theampcreativeampprocessltltnotampknowingampwhenampaamppieceampisampdoneampampAampquoteampoftenampattributedamp
toampLeonardoampdaampVinciampspeaksamptoampthisampideaampArtampisampneverampfinishedamponlyampabandonedampamp
Snowberamp(2007)ampdrawsampparallelsampbetweenampmentorshipampdialogueampandamptheampcreativeamp
processampfindingampthatampdeepamplisteningamppracticesampconnectampallampthreeampampSheampfindsampthatamptheamp
taskampofamptheampmentorampisamptheampsameampasamptheamptaskampofamptheampartistampthatampisamptoampbringampoutamptheamp
naturalampqualitiesampofamptheampstudentamporamptheampmediumampampSnowberamp(2007)ampcommentsamponampanamp
ideaampwellltknownampamongampartistsampwhichampisampthatampaampworkampofampartamphasampaamplifeampofampitsampownampthisamp
notionampisampreminiscentampofampGadamersampstatementampaboutampbeingampledampbyampconversationamp
ampamp Dialogicamppracticesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampeducationampemphasizeampaamp
phenomenologicalampdimensionamprequiringamptwoampthingsampfromampparticipantsampampFirstlyamp
participantsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampmustampfindampvalueampinamplisteningamptoamptheamp
narrativesampofamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampampTheseampparticipantsampknowampthatampeducationamp
isampforemostampaboutamptestimonyampaboutampsharingamptheampexperienceampofampbeingamphumanampsharingamp
lifeampconvictionsampandampknowledge((Wiercinskiamp2011amppamp109)ampampNarrativesampareamp
conceivedampofampasampaampwayampofamphumanampknowingamp(Vitanovaamp2010amppamp29)ampthatampmakesamptheamp
selfampampSecondlyampwhenamplisteningamptoamptheampnarrativesampofampothersampparticipantsampareampexpectedamp
toampbracketamptheirampownampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsamp(LindsethampampampNorbergamp2004)ampampThisamp
encouragesamplistenersamptoampexperienceampandampfindampmeaningampinamptheampnarrativesampofampothersamp
whileampfreeingamptheampspeakerampfromamptheampfearampofampbeingampjudgedampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 21amp
amp Bracketingampjudgmentampandampconclusionampisampaamppotentialamptoolampwithinamptheampcommonamp
artampeducationamppracticeampofampgroupampcritiquesampampElkinsamp(2001)ampfindsampthatamppeopleampwhoamphaveamp
experienceampinampartampjudgeampveryampquicklyampandampmostampteachersampwillamphaveampaampprovisionalamp
opinionampaboutampaampworkampinamptheampfirstamptenampsecondsamp(pamp121)ampampBracketingampconclusionampandamp
judgmentampisampparticularlyampimportantampforampeducatorsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
whoseampvolumeampofampviewingampexperiencesampcouldampleadamptoampeasyampassumptionsampwhenamp
encounteringampaampnewampworkampampamp
amp Elkinsamp(2001)ampdiscussesampthatampcritiquesampcanampalsoampbeampseenampasampexchangesampofamp
storiesamporampcollaborativeampstorytellingamp(pamp145)ampwhichampisampyetampanotherampwayampofamptalkingamp
aboutamppossibilitiesampforampdialogueampandampnarrativeampwithinampartampeducationampampElkinsamphoweveramp
findsampstorytellingamplimitingamponceamptheampdeeperampnarrativesampareampdiscoveredamp(2001amppamp
145)ampampThisampimpliesampthatampheampfindsamponlyampaampsingularampmeaningampandamponeampthatampisampnotamp
necessarilyampusefulampforampcollaborativeampgroupampcritiquesamp
amp Insteadampparticipantsampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampbringampknowledgeampofamp
polysemyamptoampcollaborativeampcritiqueampexperiencesampasampwellampasamptoampexperiencesampofampmakingamp
artworkampampAccordingamptoampMuldoonamp(2002)amppolysemyampisamptheampqualityampofampaampwordamporampotheramp
languageampunitampthatampcanampbearampmultipleampmeaningsamp(asampcitedampinampWorsleyamp2012amppamp308)ampampamp
Aamptextualampexampleampofampthisampisamptheampmultipleampmeaningsampofamptheampwordampcan-Iampcanampdriveampaampcaramp
Idamplikeampaampcan-ofampsodaampheampwasntampworkingampveryamphardampsoampIamphadamptoampcan-himamp(Munozamp
2014)ampampampButampifampweampconsideramppolysemyampmetaphoricallyamporampvisuallyamptheampideaampthatampaamp
singleampunitampimageamporampintentionampcouldampbearampmultipleampmeaningsampcouldampbeampproductiveampinamp
creatingltlisteningampspacesampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 22amp
amp Thisampunfoldingampofampmeaningampworksampwellampinamptheampcontextampofampcollageampandampdialogueamp
asampwellampasamphermeneuticsampampInampfactamphermeneuticsampimpliesamppolysemyampbecauseampofampitsamp
notionampthatampitampisampalwaysampaamppossibilityampofampmyampunderstandingampthatampisampplayedampoutampwhenampIamp
understandampaamptextamp(Grondinamp2002amppamp38)ampampPolysemyampcouldampbeampconceptualizedampasampanamp
alternativeampexplorationampofampmeaningampthatampfunctionsampcollaborativelyampwithinampcritiquesampamp
Forampexampleampeducatorsampcanampaskampstudentsamptoamprespondamptoampaampworkampthroughampcollageamp
journalampentriesampmusicampfilmampasampindividualsamporampinampgroupsampampKnowledgeampofamppolysemyamp
couldampalsoampbeampusedampasampaamptoolampforampcreatingampimagesampthatamprecognizesampaamprelationshipamp
betweenamptheampvisualamptheamplinguisticampandamptheampmultipleamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionampdialogicallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Placeampvalueamponampexperientialampnarrativesampbull Practiceamplisteningampbyampbracketingampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampbull Embraceamppolysemicampexplorationsampofampmeaningampamp
Contemplative(Practices(
I-knew-I-was-being-heard-because-of-her-mannerisms-and-the-look-on-her-face--She-was-calm-attentive-and-not-trying-to-jump-in-and-offer-any-advice--She-asked-questions-that-pointed-to-things-I-had-not-openly-articulated-because-of-uncertainty--
This-was-one-of-the-ways-I-knew-I-was-being-heard-(Survey-response-LS-age-27)-
(amp Ifamphermeneuticsampandampdialogicamppracticesampgiveampusamptheampbroadampstrokesampofampactivityampinamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampcontemplativeamppracticesampseekamptoamptuneampstudentsampandamp
educatorsampintoampnuanceampdeliberationampandampdeepampexplorationampampThisampisampaampmostlyamp
individualampinternalamppursuitampthatampfocusesamponampformsampofampselfltlisteningampbutampcontemplativeamp
practicesampareampalsoampformedampbyampanampawarenessampofampinterconnectednessamp
amp InamppursuitampofampcriticalampthinkingampSableamp(2014)ampoutlinesampaampsetampofampcontemplativeamp
practicesampforampstudentsampthatampincludeampmindfulampmeditationampstructuredampcontemplationamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 23amp
journalampwritingampmindfulamplisteningampreflectiveampinquiryampandampdialogueamp(pamp4)ampampWhileamp
Sablesamp(2014)ampmethodampforampcontemplativeamppracticesampprovidesampaampconcreteampframeworkamp
withampspecificampstepsampmanyampofamptheseampconceptsampcouldampbeampappliedampwithoutampsuchampaamp
prescribedampstructureampampForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwillampbeamp
primarilyampdiscussingampSablesampconceptsampofampstructuredampcontemplationampreflectiveamp
inquiryampandampjournalampwritingamp
amp ForampSableamp(2014)ampstructuredampcontemplationampisampaampformampofampbeingamppresentampandamp
focusedamponampaampparticularampquestionampstatementamporampimageampampWithinampthisampmodeampofampinquiryamp
participantsampareampexpectedamptoampholdamptheampobjectampofampcontemplationampinamptheirampmindsamp
deepeningampunderstandingampasamptheyampfocusampwithoutampanalyzingampitamporampmanipulatingampitampinamp
anyampwayamp(pamp5)ampampThisamppracticeampdrawsampcomparisonsamptoamptheampbracketingampofampjudgmentsamp
andampconclusionsampsupportedampinamptheamppreviousampsectionampbutampstructuredampcontemplationamp
occursamponampanampindividualamplevelampratherampthanampdialogicallyamp
amp Reflectiveampinquiryampbearsampsomeampsimilaritiesamptoampstructuredampcontemplationampbutamp
Sableamp(2014)amppositionsampitampasampanampactivityampbetweenamptwoampindividualsampaamplistenerampandampaamp
speakerampampTheamplistenerampisampagainampaskedamptoampsuspendampjudgmentampbutampalsoamptoampengageampinampaamp
formampofampcuriosityampinampwhichampinnocentampquestionsampareampaskedampinamporderamptoampgainamp
understandingampampSableamp(2014)ampcontrastsampinnocentampquestionsampwithampleadingampquestionsampamp
ForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwouldampcharacterizeampthisampinnocentamp
questioningampasampaampformampofampopenltendedampquestioningampampSableamp(2014)ampidentifiesampanamp
exampleampofampanampinnocentamp(orampopenltended)ampquestionampWhatampdidampyouampmeanampwhenampyouamp
saidamp________ampConverselyampaampleadingampquestionampisampDidampyouampmeanamptoampsayamp________ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 24amp
amp Sableamp(2014)ampusesampjournalampwritingampasampaamppieceampofamphisamplargerampstructureampofamp
contemplativeamppracticesampbutampjournalampwritingampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampcouldamp
potentiallyampoccupyampaampsignificantamproleampampIampconceiveampofampjournalampwritingampinampmyampownamp
creativeamppracticeampasampaampformampofampdocumentationampthatampmakesampmeampmoreampawareampofampmyamp
creativeampprocessamptheampemotionalamphabitsampthatampsurroundampitampandamptheampthemesampthatamp
structureampmyampworkampampIampconceptualizeampthisampwayampofampwritingampasampaampformampofampselfltlisteningamp
relatedamptoampaampkeyampconceptampofamphermeneuticsampfoundampinampGadamersampassertionampthatampallamp
educationampisampaampformampofampselflteducationamp(Grondinamp2011)ampampamp
amp Germeraadamp(2013)ampusesampjournalampwritingamptoampexploreamptheampemotionalampandamprationalamp
relationshipsamptoamphisampcreativeampprocessampparallelamptoampexecutingampaampnewampbodyampofampworkampampHeamp
findsampthatampwritingampduringamphisampprocessampisampaamptoolamptoampunderstandamp[his]amppsycheamptoampeaseamp
theamppainampthatampanampartisticampprocessampcanampbringampandamptoamprelieveampartisticampblocksamp
(Germeraadamp2013amppamp21)ampultimatelyampdeclaringampthatampitamphelpsamphimamptoampbetterampunderstandamp
hisampworkampampInampaampstyleampofampwritingampthatamposcillatesamparoundampjournalingampdocumentationampandamp
poetryampdeampCossonamp(2002)ampexploresamphisampoverlappingamprolesampasampanampartistampresearcherampandamp
teacherampampOtherampartistsampbluramptheamplineampbetweenampartamppracticeampdocumentationampandamplifeamp
furtherampstillampbyampofferingampdocumentationampasampartamplikeampSophieampCalleamp(Calleamp2011amp2008amp
2005)ampandampMaryampKellyamp(1973lt1979)ampampamp
amp Karpiakamp(2003)ampestablishesampcontemplativeamppracticesampfromamptheampperspectiveampofamp
theampeducatorampaskingampthemamptoampmineamptheampsubtleamp(pamp71)ampusingampattentivenessamp
attunementampamplificationampandampassociationampampTheseampexercisesampinampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampsetamptheamptoneampasampwellampasampprovideampaampmodelampofampbehaviorampforampotherampparticipantsamp
withinamptheampspaceampampKarpiakamp(2003)ampoutlinesampactivitiesampthatampeducatorsampcanampuseamptoampdrawamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 25amp
outampandamputilizeamptheseampsubtleampsensationsampinamptheampserviceampofamptransformativeamplearningamp(pamp
68)ampampamp
amp ForampKarpiakamp(2003)ampattentivenessamprequiresampawarenessamptoampverbalampandamp
nonverbalampcuesampasampwellampasampanampawarenessampofampwhatampisamphappeningampamongampandampwithinamptheamp
studentsampandamptheampeducatorampampAttunementamprequiresampanampeducatoramptoamporientampherselfamptoamptheamp
otherampandamptoampadoptampanampattitudeampofampunhurriednessampofamppatienceampandampofamphumilityamp
concerningampbothamptheampprocessampandamptheampoutcomesampofamptheampteachingamp(Karpiakamp2003amppgamp
72)ampampAmplificationampisampaampprocessampofamphonoringampcommunicationampthatampcentersamponamptheampideaamp
ofamphearingamponeselfampintoampknowingampitampincludesampusingampparaphrasingampandampclarificationamp
activitiesamptoampgainampinsightampintoampmeaningampampLastlyampassociationampentailsampidentifyingamp
patternsampandampweavingampthemamptogetherampwithampstudentampexperienceampclassroomampdiscussionamp
andamptheampideasampofampothersamp
amp TuningampintoampsubtletyampimpliesampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceampampTheampmanifestationsamp
ofampsilenceampinamptheampclassroomampareampendlessampandampitsampvalueampisamptooampgreatamptoampbeampignoredampwhileamp
tooampvastamptoampbeampfullyampabsorbedampampLevinamp(1989)ampremarksampthatampsilenceampisampaampclearingampwhereamp
thereampisampnothingampforamphearingamptoampholdamponamptoampinampwhichampmanyampfindampunbearableampanxietyamp
(pamp79)ampampNearlyampallampofampusamphaveampexperiencedampthisampunbearableampanxietyampaampstrainampofamp
whichampcanampbeampfoundampinampeducationalampcontextsampdueamptoamptheampfactampthatampclassroomsampareamp
oftenampstructuredamparoundampimplicitampandampexplicitamprulesampaboutamptalkampandampsilenceamp(Schultzamp
2010amppamp2848)ampampForampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampanampawarenessampofampsilenceampimplicatesamp
whatampisampleftampunsaidampandampwhatampisampunsayableltltespeciallyampimportantampbecauseampofamptheamp
unsayableampqualityampofampartworksampampForampSchultzamp(2010)ampsilenceampimpliesamppossibilityamp
becauseampitampcanampholdampmultipleampmeaningsampforampindividualsampwithinampandampacrossampracialamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 26amp
ethnicampandampculturalampgroupsamp(pamp2833)ampampLevinamp(1989)ampfindsampthatamptoamplistenamptoamp
somethingampweampmustampfirstampgive-itampourampsilenceamp(pamp232)ampampThisamppracticeampofampgivingampsilenceamp
isampparticularlyamphelpfulampinamptermsampofampviewingamporamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartamp
amp Gradleamp(2011)ampoutlinesampaamppracticalampvisionampforampviewingampartampthatamprequiresamp
silenceampandampdeliberationampampForamptheamppurposesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampwouldamp
reconceptualizeampthisampasampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampampGradleamp(2011)ampinstructedamp
herampstudentsamptoampspendamptimeampwithampaampworkampofampartampoutsideampofamptheirampeverydayampworldviewamp
attentivelyampviewingampitampforampaboutamptenampminutesampeverydayampforampaampweekampampAfterampeachampviewingamp
experienceamptheampstudentsampwroteampinamptheirampjournalsampampTheampresultsampindicatedampthatampthisamp
processampofampsustainedampsilentampdeliberationampcoupledampwithampanampengagementampofamptheiramp
intuitiveampperceptionsampaboutampartworkampleftampstudentsampfeelingampempoweredamptoampengageampinamp
discussionampandampappreciateampunfamiliarampartampformsampampThisampactivityampisampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoamp
aampworkampofampartampthatampincorporatesampSablesamp(2014)ampconceptampofampstructuredampcontemplationampamp
Weavingampaamprelationshipampbetweenampsilenceampcontemplationampandampattentivenessampisampaamp
significantampendeavorampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
Contemplativeamppracticesampfunctionampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Engageampinampformsampofampviewingampwritingampandampexperiencingampthatamphonorampselfltlisteningamp
bull Attuneamptoampsubtletyampandampnuanceampbull Listenampandampviewampdeliberatelyampbull Cultivateampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceamp(
The(Felt(Sense(
When-someone-understands-what-I-am-talking-about-when-I-talk-about-art-I-am-delighted--Art-is-my-everything--Its-my-passion--When-someone-understands-that-I-
am-instantly-filled-with-joy--That-tells-me-someone-gets-it-(Survey-response-CTF-age-16)-
(
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 20amp
amp Theseampareampnotionsampofampdialogueampamongampothersampthatampfindampaampparallelampinamptheamp
creativeampprocessampampFairfieldamp(2011)ampwritesampthatampinampprincipleampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinamp
dialogueamp(pamp83)ampaampsentimentampthatampalignsampwithampaampcommonampissueampencounteredampduringamp
theampcreativeampprocessltltnotampknowingampwhenampaamppieceampisampdoneampampAampquoteampoftenampattributedamp
toampLeonardoampdaampVinciampspeaksamptoampthisampideaampArtampisampneverampfinishedamponlyampabandonedampamp
Snowberamp(2007)ampdrawsampparallelsampbetweenampmentorshipampdialogueampandamptheampcreativeamp
processampfindingampthatampdeepamplisteningamppracticesampconnectampallampthreeampampSheampfindsampthatamptheamp
taskampofamptheampmentorampisamptheampsameampasamptheamptaskampofamptheampartistampthatampisamptoampbringampoutamptheamp
naturalampqualitiesampofamptheampstudentamporamptheampmediumampampSnowberamp(2007)ampcommentsamponampanamp
ideaampwellltknownampamongampartistsampwhichampisampthatampaampworkampofampartamphasampaamplifeampofampitsampownampthisamp
notionampisampreminiscentampofampGadamersampstatementampaboutampbeingampledampbyampconversationamp
ampamp Dialogicamppracticesampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampeducationampemphasizeampaamp
phenomenologicalampdimensionamprequiringamptwoampthingsampfromampparticipantsampampFirstlyamp
participantsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampmustampfindampvalueampinamplisteningamptoamptheamp
narrativesampofamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampampTheseampparticipantsampknowampthatampeducationamp
isampforemostampaboutamptestimonyampaboutampsharingamptheampexperienceampofampbeingamphumanampsharingamp
lifeampconvictionsampandampknowledge((Wiercinskiamp2011amppamp109)ampampNarrativesampareamp
conceivedampofampasampaampwayampofamphumanampknowingamp(Vitanovaamp2010amppamp29)ampthatampmakesamptheamp
selfampampSecondlyampwhenamplisteningamptoamptheampnarrativesampofampothersampparticipantsampareampexpectedamp
toampbracketamptheirampownampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsamp(LindsethampampampNorbergamp2004)ampampThisamp
encouragesamplistenersamptoampexperienceampandampfindampmeaningampinamptheampnarrativesampofampothersamp
whileampfreeingamptheampspeakerampfromamptheampfearampofampbeingampjudgedampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 21amp
amp Bracketingampjudgmentampandampconclusionampisampaamppotentialamptoolampwithinamptheampcommonamp
artampeducationamppracticeampofampgroupampcritiquesampampElkinsamp(2001)ampfindsampthatamppeopleampwhoamphaveamp
experienceampinampartampjudgeampveryampquicklyampandampmostampteachersampwillamphaveampaampprovisionalamp
opinionampaboutampaampworkampinamptheampfirstamptenampsecondsamp(pamp121)ampampBracketingampconclusionampandamp
judgmentampisampparticularlyampimportantampforampeducatorsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
whoseampvolumeampofampviewingampexperiencesampcouldampleadamptoampeasyampassumptionsampwhenamp
encounteringampaampnewampworkampampamp
amp Elkinsamp(2001)ampdiscussesampthatampcritiquesampcanampalsoampbeampseenampasampexchangesampofamp
storiesamporampcollaborativeampstorytellingamp(pamp145)ampwhichampisampyetampanotherampwayampofamptalkingamp
aboutamppossibilitiesampforampdialogueampandampnarrativeampwithinampartampeducationampampElkinsamphoweveramp
findsampstorytellingamplimitingamponceamptheampdeeperampnarrativesampareampdiscoveredamp(2001amppamp
145)ampampThisampimpliesampthatampheampfindsamponlyampaampsingularampmeaningampandamponeampthatampisampnotamp
necessarilyampusefulampforampcollaborativeampgroupampcritiquesamp
amp Insteadampparticipantsampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampbringampknowledgeampofamp
polysemyamptoampcollaborativeampcritiqueampexperiencesampasampwellampasamptoampexperiencesampofampmakingamp
artworkampampAccordingamptoampMuldoonamp(2002)amppolysemyampisamptheampqualityampofampaampwordamporampotheramp
languageampunitampthatampcanampbearampmultipleampmeaningsamp(asampcitedampinampWorsleyamp2012amppamp308)ampampamp
Aamptextualampexampleampofampthisampisamptheampmultipleampmeaningsampofamptheampwordampcan-Iampcanampdriveampaampcaramp
Idamplikeampaampcan-ofampsodaampheampwasntampworkingampveryamphardampsoampIamphadamptoampcan-himamp(Munozamp
2014)ampampampButampifampweampconsideramppolysemyampmetaphoricallyamporampvisuallyamptheampideaampthatampaamp
singleampunitampimageamporampintentionampcouldampbearampmultipleampmeaningsampcouldampbeampproductiveampinamp
creatingltlisteningampspacesampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 22amp
amp Thisampunfoldingampofampmeaningampworksampwellampinamptheampcontextampofampcollageampandampdialogueamp
asampwellampasamphermeneuticsampampInampfactamphermeneuticsampimpliesamppolysemyampbecauseampofampitsamp
notionampthatampitampisampalwaysampaamppossibilityampofampmyampunderstandingampthatampisampplayedampoutampwhenampIamp
understandampaamptextamp(Grondinamp2002amppamp38)ampampPolysemyampcouldampbeampconceptualizedampasampanamp
alternativeampexplorationampofampmeaningampthatampfunctionsampcollaborativelyampwithinampcritiquesampamp
Forampexampleampeducatorsampcanampaskampstudentsamptoamprespondamptoampaampworkampthroughampcollageamp
journalampentriesampmusicampfilmampasampindividualsamporampinampgroupsampampKnowledgeampofamppolysemyamp
couldampalsoampbeampusedampasampaamptoolampforampcreatingampimagesampthatamprecognizesampaamprelationshipamp
betweenamptheampvisualamptheamplinguisticampandamptheampmultipleamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionampdialogicallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Placeampvalueamponampexperientialampnarrativesampbull Practiceamplisteningampbyampbracketingampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampbull Embraceamppolysemicampexplorationsampofampmeaningampamp
Contemplative(Practices(
I-knew-I-was-being-heard-because-of-her-mannerisms-and-the-look-on-her-face--She-was-calm-attentive-and-not-trying-to-jump-in-and-offer-any-advice--She-asked-questions-that-pointed-to-things-I-had-not-openly-articulated-because-of-uncertainty--
This-was-one-of-the-ways-I-knew-I-was-being-heard-(Survey-response-LS-age-27)-
(amp Ifamphermeneuticsampandampdialogicamppracticesampgiveampusamptheampbroadampstrokesampofampactivityampinamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampcontemplativeamppracticesampseekamptoamptuneampstudentsampandamp
educatorsampintoampnuanceampdeliberationampandampdeepampexplorationampampThisampisampaampmostlyamp
individualampinternalamppursuitampthatampfocusesamponampformsampofampselfltlisteningampbutampcontemplativeamp
practicesampareampalsoampformedampbyampanampawarenessampofampinterconnectednessamp
amp InamppursuitampofampcriticalampthinkingampSableamp(2014)ampoutlinesampaampsetampofampcontemplativeamp
practicesampforampstudentsampthatampincludeampmindfulampmeditationampstructuredampcontemplationamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 23amp
journalampwritingampmindfulamplisteningampreflectiveampinquiryampandampdialogueamp(pamp4)ampampWhileamp
Sablesamp(2014)ampmethodampforampcontemplativeamppracticesampprovidesampaampconcreteampframeworkamp
withampspecificampstepsampmanyampofamptheseampconceptsampcouldampbeampappliedampwithoutampsuchampaamp
prescribedampstructureampampForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwillampbeamp
primarilyampdiscussingampSablesampconceptsampofampstructuredampcontemplationampreflectiveamp
inquiryampandampjournalampwritingamp
amp ForampSableamp(2014)ampstructuredampcontemplationampisampaampformampofampbeingamppresentampandamp
focusedamponampaampparticularampquestionampstatementamporampimageampampWithinampthisampmodeampofampinquiryamp
participantsampareampexpectedamptoampholdamptheampobjectampofampcontemplationampinamptheirampmindsamp
deepeningampunderstandingampasamptheyampfocusampwithoutampanalyzingampitamporampmanipulatingampitampinamp
anyampwayamp(pamp5)ampampThisamppracticeampdrawsampcomparisonsamptoamptheampbracketingampofampjudgmentsamp
andampconclusionsampsupportedampinamptheamppreviousampsectionampbutampstructuredampcontemplationamp
occursamponampanampindividualamplevelampratherampthanampdialogicallyamp
amp Reflectiveampinquiryampbearsampsomeampsimilaritiesamptoampstructuredampcontemplationampbutamp
Sableamp(2014)amppositionsampitampasampanampactivityampbetweenamptwoampindividualsampaamplistenerampandampaamp
speakerampampTheamplistenerampisampagainampaskedamptoampsuspendampjudgmentampbutampalsoamptoampengageampinampaamp
formampofampcuriosityampinampwhichampinnocentampquestionsampareampaskedampinamporderamptoampgainamp
understandingampampSableamp(2014)ampcontrastsampinnocentampquestionsampwithampleadingampquestionsampamp
ForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwouldampcharacterizeampthisampinnocentamp
questioningampasampaampformampofampopenltendedampquestioningampampSableamp(2014)ampidentifiesampanamp
exampleampofampanampinnocentamp(orampopenltended)ampquestionampWhatampdidampyouampmeanampwhenampyouamp
saidamp________ampConverselyampaampleadingampquestionampisampDidampyouampmeanamptoampsayamp________ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 24amp
amp Sableamp(2014)ampusesampjournalampwritingampasampaamppieceampofamphisamplargerampstructureampofamp
contemplativeamppracticesampbutampjournalampwritingampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampcouldamp
potentiallyampoccupyampaampsignificantamproleampampIampconceiveampofampjournalampwritingampinampmyampownamp
creativeamppracticeampasampaampformampofampdocumentationampthatampmakesampmeampmoreampawareampofampmyamp
creativeampprocessamptheampemotionalamphabitsampthatampsurroundampitampandamptheampthemesampthatamp
structureampmyampworkampampIampconceptualizeampthisampwayampofampwritingampasampaampformampofampselfltlisteningamp
relatedamptoampaampkeyampconceptampofamphermeneuticsampfoundampinampGadamersampassertionampthatampallamp
educationampisampaampformampofampselflteducationamp(Grondinamp2011)ampampamp
amp Germeraadamp(2013)ampusesampjournalampwritingamptoampexploreamptheampemotionalampandamprationalamp
relationshipsamptoamphisampcreativeampprocessampparallelamptoampexecutingampaampnewampbodyampofampworkampampHeamp
findsampthatampwritingampduringamphisampprocessampisampaamptoolamptoampunderstandamp[his]amppsycheamptoampeaseamp
theamppainampthatampanampartisticampprocessampcanampbringampandamptoamprelieveampartisticampblocksamp
(Germeraadamp2013amppamp21)ampultimatelyampdeclaringampthatampitamphelpsamphimamptoampbetterampunderstandamp
hisampworkampampInampaampstyleampofampwritingampthatamposcillatesamparoundampjournalingampdocumentationampandamp
poetryampdeampCossonamp(2002)ampexploresamphisampoverlappingamprolesampasampanampartistampresearcherampandamp
teacherampampOtherampartistsampbluramptheamplineampbetweenampartamppracticeampdocumentationampandamplifeamp
furtherampstillampbyampofferingampdocumentationampasampartamplikeampSophieampCalleamp(Calleamp2011amp2008amp
2005)ampandampMaryampKellyamp(1973lt1979)ampampamp
amp Karpiakamp(2003)ampestablishesampcontemplativeamppracticesampfromamptheampperspectiveampofamp
theampeducatorampaskingampthemamptoampmineamptheampsubtleamp(pamp71)ampusingampattentivenessamp
attunementampamplificationampandampassociationampampTheseampexercisesampinampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampsetamptheamptoneampasampwellampasampprovideampaampmodelampofampbehaviorampforampotherampparticipantsamp
withinamptheampspaceampampKarpiakamp(2003)ampoutlinesampactivitiesampthatampeducatorsampcanampuseamptoampdrawamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 25amp
outampandamputilizeamptheseampsubtleampsensationsampinamptheampserviceampofamptransformativeamplearningamp(pamp
68)ampampamp
amp ForampKarpiakamp(2003)ampattentivenessamprequiresampawarenessamptoampverbalampandamp
nonverbalampcuesampasampwellampasampanampawarenessampofampwhatampisamphappeningampamongampandampwithinamptheamp
studentsampandamptheampeducatorampampAttunementamprequiresampanampeducatoramptoamporientampherselfamptoamptheamp
otherampandamptoampadoptampanampattitudeampofampunhurriednessampofamppatienceampandampofamphumilityamp
concerningampbothamptheampprocessampandamptheampoutcomesampofamptheampteachingamp(Karpiakamp2003amppgamp
72)ampampAmplificationampisampaampprocessampofamphonoringampcommunicationampthatampcentersamponamptheampideaamp
ofamphearingamponeselfampintoampknowingampitampincludesampusingampparaphrasingampandampclarificationamp
activitiesamptoampgainampinsightampintoampmeaningampampLastlyampassociationampentailsampidentifyingamp
patternsampandampweavingampthemamptogetherampwithampstudentampexperienceampclassroomampdiscussionamp
andamptheampideasampofampothersamp
amp TuningampintoampsubtletyampimpliesampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceampampTheampmanifestationsamp
ofampsilenceampinamptheampclassroomampareampendlessampandampitsampvalueampisamptooampgreatamptoampbeampignoredampwhileamp
tooampvastamptoampbeampfullyampabsorbedampampLevinamp(1989)ampremarksampthatampsilenceampisampaampclearingampwhereamp
thereampisampnothingampforamphearingamptoampholdamponamptoampinampwhichampmanyampfindampunbearableampanxietyamp
(pamp79)ampampNearlyampallampofampusamphaveampexperiencedampthisampunbearableampanxietyampaampstrainampofamp
whichampcanampbeampfoundampinampeducationalampcontextsampdueamptoamptheampfactampthatampclassroomsampareamp
oftenampstructuredamparoundampimplicitampandampexplicitamprulesampaboutamptalkampandampsilenceamp(Schultzamp
2010amppamp2848)ampampForampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampanampawarenessampofampsilenceampimplicatesamp
whatampisampleftampunsaidampandampwhatampisampunsayableltltespeciallyampimportantampbecauseampofamptheamp
unsayableampqualityampofampartworksampampForampSchultzamp(2010)ampsilenceampimpliesamppossibilityamp
becauseampitampcanampholdampmultipleampmeaningsampforampindividualsampwithinampandampacrossampracialamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 26amp
ethnicampandampculturalampgroupsamp(pamp2833)ampampLevinamp(1989)ampfindsampthatamptoamplistenamptoamp
somethingampweampmustampfirstampgive-itampourampsilenceamp(pamp232)ampampThisamppracticeampofampgivingampsilenceamp
isampparticularlyamphelpfulampinamptermsampofampviewingamporamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartamp
amp Gradleamp(2011)ampoutlinesampaamppracticalampvisionampforampviewingampartampthatamprequiresamp
silenceampandampdeliberationampampForamptheamppurposesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampwouldamp
reconceptualizeampthisampasampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampampGradleamp(2011)ampinstructedamp
herampstudentsamptoampspendamptimeampwithampaampworkampofampartampoutsideampofamptheirampeverydayampworldviewamp
attentivelyampviewingampitampforampaboutamptenampminutesampeverydayampforampaampweekampampAfterampeachampviewingamp
experienceamptheampstudentsampwroteampinamptheirampjournalsampampTheampresultsampindicatedampthatampthisamp
processampofampsustainedampsilentampdeliberationampcoupledampwithampanampengagementampofamptheiramp
intuitiveampperceptionsampaboutampartworkampleftampstudentsampfeelingampempoweredamptoampengageampinamp
discussionampandampappreciateampunfamiliarampartampformsampampThisampactivityampisampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoamp
aampworkampofampartampthatampincorporatesampSablesamp(2014)ampconceptampofampstructuredampcontemplationampamp
Weavingampaamprelationshipampbetweenampsilenceampcontemplationampandampattentivenessampisampaamp
significantampendeavorampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
Contemplativeamppracticesampfunctionampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Engageampinampformsampofampviewingampwritingampandampexperiencingampthatamphonorampselfltlisteningamp
bull Attuneamptoampsubtletyampandampnuanceampbull Listenampandampviewampdeliberatelyampbull Cultivateampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceamp(
The(Felt(Sense(
When-someone-understands-what-I-am-talking-about-when-I-talk-about-art-I-am-delighted--Art-is-my-everything--Its-my-passion--When-someone-understands-that-I-
am-instantly-filled-with-joy--That-tells-me-someone-gets-it-(Survey-response-CTF-age-16)-
(
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 21amp
amp Bracketingampjudgmentampandampconclusionampisampaamppotentialamptoolampwithinamptheampcommonamp
artampeducationamppracticeampofampgroupampcritiquesampampElkinsamp(2001)ampfindsampthatamppeopleampwhoamphaveamp
experienceampinampartampjudgeampveryampquicklyampandampmostampteachersampwillamphaveampaampprovisionalamp
opinionampaboutampaampworkampinamptheampfirstamptenampsecondsamp(pamp121)ampampBracketingampconclusionampandamp
judgmentampisampparticularlyampimportantampforampeducatorsampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
whoseampvolumeampofampviewingampexperiencesampcouldampleadamptoampeasyampassumptionsampwhenamp
encounteringampaampnewampworkampampamp
amp Elkinsamp(2001)ampdiscussesampthatampcritiquesampcanampalsoampbeampseenampasampexchangesampofamp
storiesamporampcollaborativeampstorytellingamp(pamp145)ampwhichampisampyetampanotherampwayampofamptalkingamp
aboutamppossibilitiesampforampdialogueampandampnarrativeampwithinampartampeducationampampElkinsamphoweveramp
findsampstorytellingamplimitingamponceamptheampdeeperampnarrativesampareampdiscoveredamp(2001amppamp
145)ampampThisampimpliesampthatampheampfindsamponlyampaampsingularampmeaningampandamponeampthatampisampnotamp
necessarilyampusefulampforampcollaborativeampgroupampcritiquesamp
amp Insteadampparticipantsampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampbringampknowledgeampofamp
polysemyamptoampcollaborativeampcritiqueampexperiencesampasampwellampasamptoampexperiencesampofampmakingamp
artworkampampAccordingamptoampMuldoonamp(2002)amppolysemyampisamptheampqualityampofampaampwordamporampotheramp
languageampunitampthatampcanampbearampmultipleampmeaningsamp(asampcitedampinampWorsleyamp2012amppamp308)ampampamp
Aamptextualampexampleampofampthisampisamptheampmultipleampmeaningsampofamptheampwordampcan-Iampcanampdriveampaampcaramp
Idamplikeampaampcan-ofampsodaampheampwasntampworkingampveryamphardampsoampIamphadamptoampcan-himamp(Munozamp
2014)ampampampButampifampweampconsideramppolysemyampmetaphoricallyamporampvisuallyamptheampideaampthatampaamp
singleampunitampimageamporampintentionampcouldampbearampmultipleampmeaningsampcouldampbeampproductiveampinamp
creatingltlisteningampspacesampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 22amp
amp Thisampunfoldingampofampmeaningampworksampwellampinamptheampcontextampofampcollageampandampdialogueamp
asampwellampasamphermeneuticsampampInampfactamphermeneuticsampimpliesamppolysemyampbecauseampofampitsamp
notionampthatampitampisampalwaysampaamppossibilityampofampmyampunderstandingampthatampisampplayedampoutampwhenampIamp
understandampaamptextamp(Grondinamp2002amppamp38)ampampPolysemyampcouldampbeampconceptualizedampasampanamp
alternativeampexplorationampofampmeaningampthatampfunctionsampcollaborativelyampwithinampcritiquesampamp
Forampexampleampeducatorsampcanampaskampstudentsamptoamprespondamptoampaampworkampthroughampcollageamp
journalampentriesampmusicampfilmampasampindividualsamporampinampgroupsampampKnowledgeampofamppolysemyamp
couldampalsoampbeampusedampasampaamptoolampforampcreatingampimagesampthatamprecognizesampaamprelationshipamp
betweenamptheampvisualamptheamplinguisticampandamptheampmultipleamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionampdialogicallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Placeampvalueamponampexperientialampnarrativesampbull Practiceamplisteningampbyampbracketingampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampbull Embraceamppolysemicampexplorationsampofampmeaningampamp
Contemplative(Practices(
I-knew-I-was-being-heard-because-of-her-mannerisms-and-the-look-on-her-face--She-was-calm-attentive-and-not-trying-to-jump-in-and-offer-any-advice--She-asked-questions-that-pointed-to-things-I-had-not-openly-articulated-because-of-uncertainty--
This-was-one-of-the-ways-I-knew-I-was-being-heard-(Survey-response-LS-age-27)-
(amp Ifamphermeneuticsampandampdialogicamppracticesampgiveampusamptheampbroadampstrokesampofampactivityampinamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampcontemplativeamppracticesampseekamptoamptuneampstudentsampandamp
educatorsampintoampnuanceampdeliberationampandampdeepampexplorationampampThisampisampaampmostlyamp
individualampinternalamppursuitampthatampfocusesamponampformsampofampselfltlisteningampbutampcontemplativeamp
practicesampareampalsoampformedampbyampanampawarenessampofampinterconnectednessamp
amp InamppursuitampofampcriticalampthinkingampSableamp(2014)ampoutlinesampaampsetampofampcontemplativeamp
practicesampforampstudentsampthatampincludeampmindfulampmeditationampstructuredampcontemplationamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 23amp
journalampwritingampmindfulamplisteningampreflectiveampinquiryampandampdialogueamp(pamp4)ampampWhileamp
Sablesamp(2014)ampmethodampforampcontemplativeamppracticesampprovidesampaampconcreteampframeworkamp
withampspecificampstepsampmanyampofamptheseampconceptsampcouldampbeampappliedampwithoutampsuchampaamp
prescribedampstructureampampForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwillampbeamp
primarilyampdiscussingampSablesampconceptsampofampstructuredampcontemplationampreflectiveamp
inquiryampandampjournalampwritingamp
amp ForampSableamp(2014)ampstructuredampcontemplationampisampaampformampofampbeingamppresentampandamp
focusedamponampaampparticularampquestionampstatementamporampimageampampWithinampthisampmodeampofampinquiryamp
participantsampareampexpectedamptoampholdamptheampobjectampofampcontemplationampinamptheirampmindsamp
deepeningampunderstandingampasamptheyampfocusampwithoutampanalyzingampitamporampmanipulatingampitampinamp
anyampwayamp(pamp5)ampampThisamppracticeampdrawsampcomparisonsamptoamptheampbracketingampofampjudgmentsamp
andampconclusionsampsupportedampinamptheamppreviousampsectionampbutampstructuredampcontemplationamp
occursamponampanampindividualamplevelampratherampthanampdialogicallyamp
amp Reflectiveampinquiryampbearsampsomeampsimilaritiesamptoampstructuredampcontemplationampbutamp
Sableamp(2014)amppositionsampitampasampanampactivityampbetweenamptwoampindividualsampaamplistenerampandampaamp
speakerampampTheamplistenerampisampagainampaskedamptoampsuspendampjudgmentampbutampalsoamptoampengageampinampaamp
formampofampcuriosityampinampwhichampinnocentampquestionsampareampaskedampinamporderamptoampgainamp
understandingampampSableamp(2014)ampcontrastsampinnocentampquestionsampwithampleadingampquestionsampamp
ForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwouldampcharacterizeampthisampinnocentamp
questioningampasampaampformampofampopenltendedampquestioningampampSableamp(2014)ampidentifiesampanamp
exampleampofampanampinnocentamp(orampopenltended)ampquestionampWhatampdidampyouampmeanampwhenampyouamp
saidamp________ampConverselyampaampleadingampquestionampisampDidampyouampmeanamptoampsayamp________ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 24amp
amp Sableamp(2014)ampusesampjournalampwritingampasampaamppieceampofamphisamplargerampstructureampofamp
contemplativeamppracticesampbutampjournalampwritingampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampcouldamp
potentiallyampoccupyampaampsignificantamproleampampIampconceiveampofampjournalampwritingampinampmyampownamp
creativeamppracticeampasampaampformampofampdocumentationampthatampmakesampmeampmoreampawareampofampmyamp
creativeampprocessamptheampemotionalamphabitsampthatampsurroundampitampandamptheampthemesampthatamp
structureampmyampworkampampIampconceptualizeampthisampwayampofampwritingampasampaampformampofampselfltlisteningamp
relatedamptoampaampkeyampconceptampofamphermeneuticsampfoundampinampGadamersampassertionampthatampallamp
educationampisampaampformampofampselflteducationamp(Grondinamp2011)ampampamp
amp Germeraadamp(2013)ampusesampjournalampwritingamptoampexploreamptheampemotionalampandamprationalamp
relationshipsamptoamphisampcreativeampprocessampparallelamptoampexecutingampaampnewampbodyampofampworkampampHeamp
findsampthatampwritingampduringamphisampprocessampisampaamptoolamptoampunderstandamp[his]amppsycheamptoampeaseamp
theamppainampthatampanampartisticampprocessampcanampbringampandamptoamprelieveampartisticampblocksamp
(Germeraadamp2013amppamp21)ampultimatelyampdeclaringampthatampitamphelpsamphimamptoampbetterampunderstandamp
hisampworkampampInampaampstyleampofampwritingampthatamposcillatesamparoundampjournalingampdocumentationampandamp
poetryampdeampCossonamp(2002)ampexploresamphisampoverlappingamprolesampasampanampartistampresearcherampandamp
teacherampampOtherampartistsampbluramptheamplineampbetweenampartamppracticeampdocumentationampandamplifeamp
furtherampstillampbyampofferingampdocumentationampasampartamplikeampSophieampCalleamp(Calleamp2011amp2008amp
2005)ampandampMaryampKellyamp(1973lt1979)ampampamp
amp Karpiakamp(2003)ampestablishesampcontemplativeamppracticesampfromamptheampperspectiveampofamp
theampeducatorampaskingampthemamptoampmineamptheampsubtleamp(pamp71)ampusingampattentivenessamp
attunementampamplificationampandampassociationampampTheseampexercisesampinampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampsetamptheamptoneampasampwellampasampprovideampaampmodelampofampbehaviorampforampotherampparticipantsamp
withinamptheampspaceampampKarpiakamp(2003)ampoutlinesampactivitiesampthatampeducatorsampcanampuseamptoampdrawamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 25amp
outampandamputilizeamptheseampsubtleampsensationsampinamptheampserviceampofamptransformativeamplearningamp(pamp
68)ampampamp
amp ForampKarpiakamp(2003)ampattentivenessamprequiresampawarenessamptoampverbalampandamp
nonverbalampcuesampasampwellampasampanampawarenessampofampwhatampisamphappeningampamongampandampwithinamptheamp
studentsampandamptheampeducatorampampAttunementamprequiresampanampeducatoramptoamporientampherselfamptoamptheamp
otherampandamptoampadoptampanampattitudeampofampunhurriednessampofamppatienceampandampofamphumilityamp
concerningampbothamptheampprocessampandamptheampoutcomesampofamptheampteachingamp(Karpiakamp2003amppgamp
72)ampampAmplificationampisampaampprocessampofamphonoringampcommunicationampthatampcentersamponamptheampideaamp
ofamphearingamponeselfampintoampknowingampitampincludesampusingampparaphrasingampandampclarificationamp
activitiesamptoampgainampinsightampintoampmeaningampampLastlyampassociationampentailsampidentifyingamp
patternsampandampweavingampthemamptogetherampwithampstudentampexperienceampclassroomampdiscussionamp
andamptheampideasampofampothersamp
amp TuningampintoampsubtletyampimpliesampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceampampTheampmanifestationsamp
ofampsilenceampinamptheampclassroomampareampendlessampandampitsampvalueampisamptooampgreatamptoampbeampignoredampwhileamp
tooampvastamptoampbeampfullyampabsorbedampampLevinamp(1989)ampremarksampthatampsilenceampisampaampclearingampwhereamp
thereampisampnothingampforamphearingamptoampholdamponamptoampinampwhichampmanyampfindampunbearableampanxietyamp
(pamp79)ampampNearlyampallampofampusamphaveampexperiencedampthisampunbearableampanxietyampaampstrainampofamp
whichampcanampbeampfoundampinampeducationalampcontextsampdueamptoamptheampfactampthatampclassroomsampareamp
oftenampstructuredamparoundampimplicitampandampexplicitamprulesampaboutamptalkampandampsilenceamp(Schultzamp
2010amppamp2848)ampampForampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampanampawarenessampofampsilenceampimplicatesamp
whatampisampleftampunsaidampandampwhatampisampunsayableltltespeciallyampimportantampbecauseampofamptheamp
unsayableampqualityampofampartworksampampForampSchultzamp(2010)ampsilenceampimpliesamppossibilityamp
becauseampitampcanampholdampmultipleampmeaningsampforampindividualsampwithinampandampacrossampracialamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 26amp
ethnicampandampculturalampgroupsamp(pamp2833)ampampLevinamp(1989)ampfindsampthatamptoamplistenamptoamp
somethingampweampmustampfirstampgive-itampourampsilenceamp(pamp232)ampampThisamppracticeampofampgivingampsilenceamp
isampparticularlyamphelpfulampinamptermsampofampviewingamporamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartamp
amp Gradleamp(2011)ampoutlinesampaamppracticalampvisionampforampviewingampartampthatamprequiresamp
silenceampandampdeliberationampampForamptheamppurposesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampwouldamp
reconceptualizeampthisampasampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampampGradleamp(2011)ampinstructedamp
herampstudentsamptoampspendamptimeampwithampaampworkampofampartampoutsideampofamptheirampeverydayampworldviewamp
attentivelyampviewingampitampforampaboutamptenampminutesampeverydayampforampaampweekampampAfterampeachampviewingamp
experienceamptheampstudentsampwroteampinamptheirampjournalsampampTheampresultsampindicatedampthatampthisamp
processampofampsustainedampsilentampdeliberationampcoupledampwithampanampengagementampofamptheiramp
intuitiveampperceptionsampaboutampartworkampleftampstudentsampfeelingampempoweredamptoampengageampinamp
discussionampandampappreciateampunfamiliarampartampformsampampThisampactivityampisampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoamp
aampworkampofampartampthatampincorporatesampSablesamp(2014)ampconceptampofampstructuredampcontemplationampamp
Weavingampaamprelationshipampbetweenampsilenceampcontemplationampandampattentivenessampisampaamp
significantampendeavorampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
Contemplativeamppracticesampfunctionampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Engageampinampformsampofampviewingampwritingampandampexperiencingampthatamphonorampselfltlisteningamp
bull Attuneamptoampsubtletyampandampnuanceampbull Listenampandampviewampdeliberatelyampbull Cultivateampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceamp(
The(Felt(Sense(
When-someone-understands-what-I-am-talking-about-when-I-talk-about-art-I-am-delighted--Art-is-my-everything--Its-my-passion--When-someone-understands-that-I-
am-instantly-filled-with-joy--That-tells-me-someone-gets-it-(Survey-response-CTF-age-16)-
(
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 22amp
amp Thisampunfoldingampofampmeaningampworksampwellampinamptheampcontextampofampcollageampandampdialogueamp
asampwellampasamphermeneuticsampampInampfactamphermeneuticsampimpliesamppolysemyampbecauseampofampitsamp
notionampthatampitampisampalwaysampaamppossibilityampofampmyampunderstandingampthatampisampplayedampoutampwhenampIamp
understandampaamptextamp(Grondinamp2002amppamp38)ampampPolysemyampcouldampbeampconceptualizedampasampanamp
alternativeampexplorationampofampmeaningampthatampfunctionsampcollaborativelyampwithinampcritiquesampamp
Forampexampleampeducatorsampcanampaskampstudentsamptoamprespondamptoampaampworkampthroughampcollageamp
journalampentriesampmusicampfilmampasampindividualsamporampinampgroupsampampKnowledgeampofamppolysemyamp
couldampalsoampbeampusedampasampaamptoolampforampcreatingampimagesampthatamprecognizesampaamprelationshipamp
betweenamptheampvisualamptheamplinguisticampandamptheampmultipleamp
Creativeltlisteningampspacesampfunctionampdialogicallyampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Placeampvalueamponampexperientialampnarrativesampbull Practiceamplisteningampbyampbracketingampjudgmentsampandampconclusionsampbull Embraceamppolysemicampexplorationsampofampmeaningampamp
Contemplative(Practices(
I-knew-I-was-being-heard-because-of-her-mannerisms-and-the-look-on-her-face--She-was-calm-attentive-and-not-trying-to-jump-in-and-offer-any-advice--She-asked-questions-that-pointed-to-things-I-had-not-openly-articulated-because-of-uncertainty--
This-was-one-of-the-ways-I-knew-I-was-being-heard-(Survey-response-LS-age-27)-
(amp Ifamphermeneuticsampandampdialogicamppracticesampgiveampusamptheampbroadampstrokesampofampactivityampinamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampcontemplativeamppracticesampseekamptoamptuneampstudentsampandamp
educatorsampintoampnuanceampdeliberationampandampdeepampexplorationampampThisampisampaampmostlyamp
individualampinternalamppursuitampthatampfocusesamponampformsampofampselfltlisteningampbutampcontemplativeamp
practicesampareampalsoampformedampbyampanampawarenessampofampinterconnectednessamp
amp InamppursuitampofampcriticalampthinkingampSableamp(2014)ampoutlinesampaampsetampofampcontemplativeamp
practicesampforampstudentsampthatampincludeampmindfulampmeditationampstructuredampcontemplationamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 23amp
journalampwritingampmindfulamplisteningampreflectiveampinquiryampandampdialogueamp(pamp4)ampampWhileamp
Sablesamp(2014)ampmethodampforampcontemplativeamppracticesampprovidesampaampconcreteampframeworkamp
withampspecificampstepsampmanyampofamptheseampconceptsampcouldampbeampappliedampwithoutampsuchampaamp
prescribedampstructureampampForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwillampbeamp
primarilyampdiscussingampSablesampconceptsampofampstructuredampcontemplationampreflectiveamp
inquiryampandampjournalampwritingamp
amp ForampSableamp(2014)ampstructuredampcontemplationampisampaampformampofampbeingamppresentampandamp
focusedamponampaampparticularampquestionampstatementamporampimageampampWithinampthisampmodeampofampinquiryamp
participantsampareampexpectedamptoampholdamptheampobjectampofampcontemplationampinamptheirampmindsamp
deepeningampunderstandingampasamptheyampfocusampwithoutampanalyzingampitamporampmanipulatingampitampinamp
anyampwayamp(pamp5)ampampThisamppracticeampdrawsampcomparisonsamptoamptheampbracketingampofampjudgmentsamp
andampconclusionsampsupportedampinamptheamppreviousampsectionampbutampstructuredampcontemplationamp
occursamponampanampindividualamplevelampratherampthanampdialogicallyamp
amp Reflectiveampinquiryampbearsampsomeampsimilaritiesamptoampstructuredampcontemplationampbutamp
Sableamp(2014)amppositionsampitampasampanampactivityampbetweenamptwoampindividualsampaamplistenerampandampaamp
speakerampampTheamplistenerampisampagainampaskedamptoampsuspendampjudgmentampbutampalsoamptoampengageampinampaamp
formampofampcuriosityampinampwhichampinnocentampquestionsampareampaskedampinamporderamptoampgainamp
understandingampampSableamp(2014)ampcontrastsampinnocentampquestionsampwithampleadingampquestionsampamp
ForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwouldampcharacterizeampthisampinnocentamp
questioningampasampaampformampofampopenltendedampquestioningampampSableamp(2014)ampidentifiesampanamp
exampleampofampanampinnocentamp(orampopenltended)ampquestionampWhatampdidampyouampmeanampwhenampyouamp
saidamp________ampConverselyampaampleadingampquestionampisampDidampyouampmeanamptoampsayamp________ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 24amp
amp Sableamp(2014)ampusesampjournalampwritingampasampaamppieceampofamphisamplargerampstructureampofamp
contemplativeamppracticesampbutampjournalampwritingampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampcouldamp
potentiallyampoccupyampaampsignificantamproleampampIampconceiveampofampjournalampwritingampinampmyampownamp
creativeamppracticeampasampaampformampofampdocumentationampthatampmakesampmeampmoreampawareampofampmyamp
creativeampprocessamptheampemotionalamphabitsampthatampsurroundampitampandamptheampthemesampthatamp
structureampmyampworkampampIampconceptualizeampthisampwayampofampwritingampasampaampformampofampselfltlisteningamp
relatedamptoampaampkeyampconceptampofamphermeneuticsampfoundampinampGadamersampassertionampthatampallamp
educationampisampaampformampofampselflteducationamp(Grondinamp2011)ampampamp
amp Germeraadamp(2013)ampusesampjournalampwritingamptoampexploreamptheampemotionalampandamprationalamp
relationshipsamptoamphisampcreativeampprocessampparallelamptoampexecutingampaampnewampbodyampofampworkampampHeamp
findsampthatampwritingampduringamphisampprocessampisampaamptoolamptoampunderstandamp[his]amppsycheamptoampeaseamp
theamppainampthatampanampartisticampprocessampcanampbringampandamptoamprelieveampartisticampblocksamp
(Germeraadamp2013amppamp21)ampultimatelyampdeclaringampthatampitamphelpsamphimamptoampbetterampunderstandamp
hisampworkampampInampaampstyleampofampwritingampthatamposcillatesamparoundampjournalingampdocumentationampandamp
poetryampdeampCossonamp(2002)ampexploresamphisampoverlappingamprolesampasampanampartistampresearcherampandamp
teacherampampOtherampartistsampbluramptheamplineampbetweenampartamppracticeampdocumentationampandamplifeamp
furtherampstillampbyampofferingampdocumentationampasampartamplikeampSophieampCalleamp(Calleamp2011amp2008amp
2005)ampandampMaryampKellyamp(1973lt1979)ampampamp
amp Karpiakamp(2003)ampestablishesampcontemplativeamppracticesampfromamptheampperspectiveampofamp
theampeducatorampaskingampthemamptoampmineamptheampsubtleamp(pamp71)ampusingampattentivenessamp
attunementampamplificationampandampassociationampampTheseampexercisesampinampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampsetamptheamptoneampasampwellampasampprovideampaampmodelampofampbehaviorampforampotherampparticipantsamp
withinamptheampspaceampampKarpiakamp(2003)ampoutlinesampactivitiesampthatampeducatorsampcanampuseamptoampdrawamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 25amp
outampandamputilizeamptheseampsubtleampsensationsampinamptheampserviceampofamptransformativeamplearningamp(pamp
68)ampampamp
amp ForampKarpiakamp(2003)ampattentivenessamprequiresampawarenessamptoampverbalampandamp
nonverbalampcuesampasampwellampasampanampawarenessampofampwhatampisamphappeningampamongampandampwithinamptheamp
studentsampandamptheampeducatorampampAttunementamprequiresampanampeducatoramptoamporientampherselfamptoamptheamp
otherampandamptoampadoptampanampattitudeampofampunhurriednessampofamppatienceampandampofamphumilityamp
concerningampbothamptheampprocessampandamptheampoutcomesampofamptheampteachingamp(Karpiakamp2003amppgamp
72)ampampAmplificationampisampaampprocessampofamphonoringampcommunicationampthatampcentersamponamptheampideaamp
ofamphearingamponeselfampintoampknowingampitampincludesampusingampparaphrasingampandampclarificationamp
activitiesamptoampgainampinsightampintoampmeaningampampLastlyampassociationampentailsampidentifyingamp
patternsampandampweavingampthemamptogetherampwithampstudentampexperienceampclassroomampdiscussionamp
andamptheampideasampofampothersamp
amp TuningampintoampsubtletyampimpliesampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceampampTheampmanifestationsamp
ofampsilenceampinamptheampclassroomampareampendlessampandampitsampvalueampisamptooampgreatamptoampbeampignoredampwhileamp
tooampvastamptoampbeampfullyampabsorbedampampLevinamp(1989)ampremarksampthatampsilenceampisampaampclearingampwhereamp
thereampisampnothingampforamphearingamptoampholdamponamptoampinampwhichampmanyampfindampunbearableampanxietyamp
(pamp79)ampampNearlyampallampofampusamphaveampexperiencedampthisampunbearableampanxietyampaampstrainampofamp
whichampcanampbeampfoundampinampeducationalampcontextsampdueamptoamptheampfactampthatampclassroomsampareamp
oftenampstructuredamparoundampimplicitampandampexplicitamprulesampaboutamptalkampandampsilenceamp(Schultzamp
2010amppamp2848)ampampForampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampanampawarenessampofampsilenceampimplicatesamp
whatampisampleftampunsaidampandampwhatampisampunsayableltltespeciallyampimportantampbecauseampofamptheamp
unsayableampqualityampofampartworksampampForampSchultzamp(2010)ampsilenceampimpliesamppossibilityamp
becauseampitampcanampholdampmultipleampmeaningsampforampindividualsampwithinampandampacrossampracialamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 26amp
ethnicampandampculturalampgroupsamp(pamp2833)ampampLevinamp(1989)ampfindsampthatamptoamplistenamptoamp
somethingampweampmustampfirstampgive-itampourampsilenceamp(pamp232)ampampThisamppracticeampofampgivingampsilenceamp
isampparticularlyamphelpfulampinamptermsampofampviewingamporamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartamp
amp Gradleamp(2011)ampoutlinesampaamppracticalampvisionampforampviewingampartampthatamprequiresamp
silenceampandampdeliberationampampForamptheamppurposesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampwouldamp
reconceptualizeampthisampasampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampampGradleamp(2011)ampinstructedamp
herampstudentsamptoampspendamptimeampwithampaampworkampofampartampoutsideampofamptheirampeverydayampworldviewamp
attentivelyampviewingampitampforampaboutamptenampminutesampeverydayampforampaampweekampampAfterampeachampviewingamp
experienceamptheampstudentsampwroteampinamptheirampjournalsampampTheampresultsampindicatedampthatampthisamp
processampofampsustainedampsilentampdeliberationampcoupledampwithampanampengagementampofamptheiramp
intuitiveampperceptionsampaboutampartworkampleftampstudentsampfeelingampempoweredamptoampengageampinamp
discussionampandampappreciateampunfamiliarampartampformsampampThisampactivityampisampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoamp
aampworkampofampartampthatampincorporatesampSablesamp(2014)ampconceptampofampstructuredampcontemplationampamp
Weavingampaamprelationshipampbetweenampsilenceampcontemplationampandampattentivenessampisampaamp
significantampendeavorampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
Contemplativeamppracticesampfunctionampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Engageampinampformsampofampviewingampwritingampandampexperiencingampthatamphonorampselfltlisteningamp
bull Attuneamptoampsubtletyampandampnuanceampbull Listenampandampviewampdeliberatelyampbull Cultivateampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceamp(
The(Felt(Sense(
When-someone-understands-what-I-am-talking-about-when-I-talk-about-art-I-am-delighted--Art-is-my-everything--Its-my-passion--When-someone-understands-that-I-
am-instantly-filled-with-joy--That-tells-me-someone-gets-it-(Survey-response-CTF-age-16)-
(
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 23amp
journalampwritingampmindfulamplisteningampreflectiveampinquiryampandampdialogueamp(pamp4)ampampWhileamp
Sablesamp(2014)ampmethodampforampcontemplativeamppracticesampprovidesampaampconcreteampframeworkamp
withampspecificampstepsampmanyampofamptheseampconceptsampcouldampbeampappliedampwithoutampsuchampaamp
prescribedampstructureampampForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwillampbeamp
primarilyampdiscussingampSablesampconceptsampofampstructuredampcontemplationampreflectiveamp
inquiryampandampjournalampwritingamp
amp ForampSableamp(2014)ampstructuredampcontemplationampisampaampformampofampbeingamppresentampandamp
focusedamponampaampparticularampquestionampstatementamporampimageampampWithinampthisampmodeampofampinquiryamp
participantsampareampexpectedamptoampholdamptheampobjectampofampcontemplationampinamptheirampmindsamp
deepeningampunderstandingampasamptheyampfocusampwithoutampanalyzingampitamporampmanipulatingampitampinamp
anyampwayamp(pamp5)ampampThisamppracticeampdrawsampcomparisonsamptoamptheampbracketingampofampjudgmentsamp
andampconclusionsampsupportedampinamptheamppreviousampsectionampbutampstructuredampcontemplationamp
occursamponampanampindividualamplevelampratherampthanampdialogicallyamp
amp Reflectiveampinquiryampbearsampsomeampsimilaritiesamptoampstructuredampcontemplationampbutamp
Sableamp(2014)amppositionsampitampasampanampactivityampbetweenamptwoampindividualsampaamplistenerampandampaamp
speakerampampTheamplistenerampisampagainampaskedamptoampsuspendampjudgmentampbutampalsoamptoampengageampinampaamp
formampofampcuriosityampinampwhichampinnocentampquestionsampareampaskedampinamporderamptoampgainamp
understandingampampSableamp(2014)ampcontrastsampinnocentampquestionsampwithampleadingampquestionsampamp
ForamptheamppurposesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampIampwouldampcharacterizeampthisampinnocentamp
questioningampasampaampformampofampopenltendedampquestioningampampSableamp(2014)ampidentifiesampanamp
exampleampofampanampinnocentamp(orampopenltended)ampquestionampWhatampdidampyouampmeanampwhenampyouamp
saidamp________ampConverselyampaampleadingampquestionampisampDidampyouampmeanamptoampsayamp________ampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 24amp
amp Sableamp(2014)ampusesampjournalampwritingampasampaamppieceampofamphisamplargerampstructureampofamp
contemplativeamppracticesampbutampjournalampwritingampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampcouldamp
potentiallyampoccupyampaampsignificantamproleampampIampconceiveampofampjournalampwritingampinampmyampownamp
creativeamppracticeampasampaampformampofampdocumentationampthatampmakesampmeampmoreampawareampofampmyamp
creativeampprocessamptheampemotionalamphabitsampthatampsurroundampitampandamptheampthemesampthatamp
structureampmyampworkampampIampconceptualizeampthisampwayampofampwritingampasampaampformampofampselfltlisteningamp
relatedamptoampaampkeyampconceptampofamphermeneuticsampfoundampinampGadamersampassertionampthatampallamp
educationampisampaampformampofampselflteducationamp(Grondinamp2011)ampampamp
amp Germeraadamp(2013)ampusesampjournalampwritingamptoampexploreamptheampemotionalampandamprationalamp
relationshipsamptoamphisampcreativeampprocessampparallelamptoampexecutingampaampnewampbodyampofampworkampampHeamp
findsampthatampwritingampduringamphisampprocessampisampaamptoolamptoampunderstandamp[his]amppsycheamptoampeaseamp
theamppainampthatampanampartisticampprocessampcanampbringampandamptoamprelieveampartisticampblocksamp
(Germeraadamp2013amppamp21)ampultimatelyampdeclaringampthatampitamphelpsamphimamptoampbetterampunderstandamp
hisampworkampampInampaampstyleampofampwritingampthatamposcillatesamparoundampjournalingampdocumentationampandamp
poetryampdeampCossonamp(2002)ampexploresamphisampoverlappingamprolesampasampanampartistampresearcherampandamp
teacherampampOtherampartistsampbluramptheamplineampbetweenampartamppracticeampdocumentationampandamplifeamp
furtherampstillampbyampofferingampdocumentationampasampartamplikeampSophieampCalleamp(Calleamp2011amp2008amp
2005)ampandampMaryampKellyamp(1973lt1979)ampampamp
amp Karpiakamp(2003)ampestablishesampcontemplativeamppracticesampfromamptheampperspectiveampofamp
theampeducatorampaskingampthemamptoampmineamptheampsubtleamp(pamp71)ampusingampattentivenessamp
attunementampamplificationampandampassociationampampTheseampexercisesampinampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampsetamptheamptoneampasampwellampasampprovideampaampmodelampofampbehaviorampforampotherampparticipantsamp
withinamptheampspaceampampKarpiakamp(2003)ampoutlinesampactivitiesampthatampeducatorsampcanampuseamptoampdrawamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 25amp
outampandamputilizeamptheseampsubtleampsensationsampinamptheampserviceampofamptransformativeamplearningamp(pamp
68)ampampamp
amp ForampKarpiakamp(2003)ampattentivenessamprequiresampawarenessamptoampverbalampandamp
nonverbalampcuesampasampwellampasampanampawarenessampofampwhatampisamphappeningampamongampandampwithinamptheamp
studentsampandamptheampeducatorampampAttunementamprequiresampanampeducatoramptoamporientampherselfamptoamptheamp
otherampandamptoampadoptampanampattitudeampofampunhurriednessampofamppatienceampandampofamphumilityamp
concerningampbothamptheampprocessampandamptheampoutcomesampofamptheampteachingamp(Karpiakamp2003amppgamp
72)ampampAmplificationampisampaampprocessampofamphonoringampcommunicationampthatampcentersamponamptheampideaamp
ofamphearingamponeselfampintoampknowingampitampincludesampusingampparaphrasingampandampclarificationamp
activitiesamptoampgainampinsightampintoampmeaningampampLastlyampassociationampentailsampidentifyingamp
patternsampandampweavingampthemamptogetherampwithampstudentampexperienceampclassroomampdiscussionamp
andamptheampideasampofampothersamp
amp TuningampintoampsubtletyampimpliesampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceampampTheampmanifestationsamp
ofampsilenceampinamptheampclassroomampareampendlessampandampitsampvalueampisamptooampgreatamptoampbeampignoredampwhileamp
tooampvastamptoampbeampfullyampabsorbedampampLevinamp(1989)ampremarksampthatampsilenceampisampaampclearingampwhereamp
thereampisampnothingampforamphearingamptoampholdamponamptoampinampwhichampmanyampfindampunbearableampanxietyamp
(pamp79)ampampNearlyampallampofampusamphaveampexperiencedampthisampunbearableampanxietyampaampstrainampofamp
whichampcanampbeampfoundampinampeducationalampcontextsampdueamptoamptheampfactampthatampclassroomsampareamp
oftenampstructuredamparoundampimplicitampandampexplicitamprulesampaboutamptalkampandampsilenceamp(Schultzamp
2010amppamp2848)ampampForampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampanampawarenessampofampsilenceampimplicatesamp
whatampisampleftampunsaidampandampwhatampisampunsayableltltespeciallyampimportantampbecauseampofamptheamp
unsayableampqualityampofampartworksampampForampSchultzamp(2010)ampsilenceampimpliesamppossibilityamp
becauseampitampcanampholdampmultipleampmeaningsampforampindividualsampwithinampandampacrossampracialamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 26amp
ethnicampandampculturalampgroupsamp(pamp2833)ampampLevinamp(1989)ampfindsampthatamptoamplistenamptoamp
somethingampweampmustampfirstampgive-itampourampsilenceamp(pamp232)ampampThisamppracticeampofampgivingampsilenceamp
isampparticularlyamphelpfulampinamptermsampofampviewingamporamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartamp
amp Gradleamp(2011)ampoutlinesampaamppracticalampvisionampforampviewingampartampthatamprequiresamp
silenceampandampdeliberationampampForamptheamppurposesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampwouldamp
reconceptualizeampthisampasampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampampGradleamp(2011)ampinstructedamp
herampstudentsamptoampspendamptimeampwithampaampworkampofampartampoutsideampofamptheirampeverydayampworldviewamp
attentivelyampviewingampitampforampaboutamptenampminutesampeverydayampforampaampweekampampAfterampeachampviewingamp
experienceamptheampstudentsampwroteampinamptheirampjournalsampampTheampresultsampindicatedampthatampthisamp
processampofampsustainedampsilentampdeliberationampcoupledampwithampanampengagementampofamptheiramp
intuitiveampperceptionsampaboutampartworkampleftampstudentsampfeelingampempoweredamptoampengageampinamp
discussionampandampappreciateampunfamiliarampartampformsampampThisampactivityampisampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoamp
aampworkampofampartampthatampincorporatesampSablesamp(2014)ampconceptampofampstructuredampcontemplationampamp
Weavingampaamprelationshipampbetweenampsilenceampcontemplationampandampattentivenessampisampaamp
significantampendeavorampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
Contemplativeamppracticesampfunctionampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Engageampinampformsampofampviewingampwritingampandampexperiencingampthatamphonorampselfltlisteningamp
bull Attuneamptoampsubtletyampandampnuanceampbull Listenampandampviewampdeliberatelyampbull Cultivateampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceamp(
The(Felt(Sense(
When-someone-understands-what-I-am-talking-about-when-I-talk-about-art-I-am-delighted--Art-is-my-everything--Its-my-passion--When-someone-understands-that-I-
am-instantly-filled-with-joy--That-tells-me-someone-gets-it-(Survey-response-CTF-age-16)-
(
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 24amp
amp Sableamp(2014)ampusesampjournalampwritingampasampaamppieceampofamphisamplargerampstructureampofamp
contemplativeamppracticesampbutampjournalampwritingampwithinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampcouldamp
potentiallyampoccupyampaampsignificantamproleampampIampconceiveampofampjournalampwritingampinampmyampownamp
creativeamppracticeampasampaampformampofampdocumentationampthatampmakesampmeampmoreampawareampofampmyamp
creativeampprocessamptheampemotionalamphabitsampthatampsurroundampitampandamptheampthemesampthatamp
structureampmyampworkampampIampconceptualizeampthisampwayampofampwritingampasampaampformampofampselfltlisteningamp
relatedamptoampaampkeyampconceptampofamphermeneuticsampfoundampinampGadamersampassertionampthatampallamp
educationampisampaampformampofampselflteducationamp(Grondinamp2011)ampampamp
amp Germeraadamp(2013)ampusesampjournalampwritingamptoampexploreamptheampemotionalampandamprationalamp
relationshipsamptoamphisampcreativeampprocessampparallelamptoampexecutingampaampnewampbodyampofampworkampampHeamp
findsampthatampwritingampduringamphisampprocessampisampaamptoolamptoampunderstandamp[his]amppsycheamptoampeaseamp
theamppainampthatampanampartisticampprocessampcanampbringampandamptoamprelieveampartisticampblocksamp
(Germeraadamp2013amppamp21)ampultimatelyampdeclaringampthatampitamphelpsamphimamptoampbetterampunderstandamp
hisampworkampampInampaampstyleampofampwritingampthatamposcillatesamparoundampjournalingampdocumentationampandamp
poetryampdeampCossonamp(2002)ampexploresamphisampoverlappingamprolesampasampanampartistampresearcherampandamp
teacherampampOtherampartistsampbluramptheamplineampbetweenampartamppracticeampdocumentationampandamplifeamp
furtherampstillampbyampofferingampdocumentationampasampartamplikeampSophieampCalleamp(Calleamp2011amp2008amp
2005)ampandampMaryampKellyamp(1973lt1979)ampampamp
amp Karpiakamp(2003)ampestablishesampcontemplativeamppracticesampfromamptheampperspectiveampofamp
theampeducatorampaskingampthemamptoampmineamptheampsubtleamp(pamp71)ampusingampattentivenessamp
attunementampamplificationampandampassociationampampTheseampexercisesampinampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampsetamptheamptoneampasampwellampasampprovideampaampmodelampofampbehaviorampforampotherampparticipantsamp
withinamptheampspaceampampKarpiakamp(2003)ampoutlinesampactivitiesampthatampeducatorsampcanampuseamptoampdrawamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 25amp
outampandamputilizeamptheseampsubtleampsensationsampinamptheampserviceampofamptransformativeamplearningamp(pamp
68)ampampamp
amp ForampKarpiakamp(2003)ampattentivenessamprequiresampawarenessamptoampverbalampandamp
nonverbalampcuesampasampwellampasampanampawarenessampofampwhatampisamphappeningampamongampandampwithinamptheamp
studentsampandamptheampeducatorampampAttunementamprequiresampanampeducatoramptoamporientampherselfamptoamptheamp
otherampandamptoampadoptampanampattitudeampofampunhurriednessampofamppatienceampandampofamphumilityamp
concerningampbothamptheampprocessampandamptheampoutcomesampofamptheampteachingamp(Karpiakamp2003amppgamp
72)ampampAmplificationampisampaampprocessampofamphonoringampcommunicationampthatampcentersamponamptheampideaamp
ofamphearingamponeselfampintoampknowingampitampincludesampusingampparaphrasingampandampclarificationamp
activitiesamptoampgainampinsightampintoampmeaningampampLastlyampassociationampentailsampidentifyingamp
patternsampandampweavingampthemamptogetherampwithampstudentampexperienceampclassroomampdiscussionamp
andamptheampideasampofampothersamp
amp TuningampintoampsubtletyampimpliesampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceampampTheampmanifestationsamp
ofampsilenceampinamptheampclassroomampareampendlessampandampitsampvalueampisamptooampgreatamptoampbeampignoredampwhileamp
tooampvastamptoampbeampfullyampabsorbedampampLevinamp(1989)ampremarksampthatampsilenceampisampaampclearingampwhereamp
thereampisampnothingampforamphearingamptoampholdamponamptoampinampwhichampmanyampfindampunbearableampanxietyamp
(pamp79)ampampNearlyampallampofampusamphaveampexperiencedampthisampunbearableampanxietyampaampstrainampofamp
whichampcanampbeampfoundampinampeducationalampcontextsampdueamptoamptheampfactampthatampclassroomsampareamp
oftenampstructuredamparoundampimplicitampandampexplicitamprulesampaboutamptalkampandampsilenceamp(Schultzamp
2010amppamp2848)ampampForampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampanampawarenessampofampsilenceampimplicatesamp
whatampisampleftampunsaidampandampwhatampisampunsayableltltespeciallyampimportantampbecauseampofamptheamp
unsayableampqualityampofampartworksampampForampSchultzamp(2010)ampsilenceampimpliesamppossibilityamp
becauseampitampcanampholdampmultipleampmeaningsampforampindividualsampwithinampandampacrossampracialamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 26amp
ethnicampandampculturalampgroupsamp(pamp2833)ampampLevinamp(1989)ampfindsampthatamptoamplistenamptoamp
somethingampweampmustampfirstampgive-itampourampsilenceamp(pamp232)ampampThisamppracticeampofampgivingampsilenceamp
isampparticularlyamphelpfulampinamptermsampofampviewingamporamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartamp
amp Gradleamp(2011)ampoutlinesampaamppracticalampvisionampforampviewingampartampthatamprequiresamp
silenceampandampdeliberationampampForamptheamppurposesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampwouldamp
reconceptualizeampthisampasampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampampGradleamp(2011)ampinstructedamp
herampstudentsamptoampspendamptimeampwithampaampworkampofampartampoutsideampofamptheirampeverydayampworldviewamp
attentivelyampviewingampitampforampaboutamptenampminutesampeverydayampforampaampweekampampAfterampeachampviewingamp
experienceamptheampstudentsampwroteampinamptheirampjournalsampampTheampresultsampindicatedampthatampthisamp
processampofampsustainedampsilentampdeliberationampcoupledampwithampanampengagementampofamptheiramp
intuitiveampperceptionsampaboutampartworkampleftampstudentsampfeelingampempoweredamptoampengageampinamp
discussionampandampappreciateampunfamiliarampartampformsampampThisampactivityampisampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoamp
aampworkampofampartampthatampincorporatesampSablesamp(2014)ampconceptampofampstructuredampcontemplationampamp
Weavingampaamprelationshipampbetweenampsilenceampcontemplationampandampattentivenessampisampaamp
significantampendeavorampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
Contemplativeamppracticesampfunctionampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Engageampinampformsampofampviewingampwritingampandampexperiencingampthatamphonorampselfltlisteningamp
bull Attuneamptoampsubtletyampandampnuanceampbull Listenampandampviewampdeliberatelyampbull Cultivateampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceamp(
The(Felt(Sense(
When-someone-understands-what-I-am-talking-about-when-I-talk-about-art-I-am-delighted--Art-is-my-everything--Its-my-passion--When-someone-understands-that-I-
am-instantly-filled-with-joy--That-tells-me-someone-gets-it-(Survey-response-CTF-age-16)-
(
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 25amp
outampandamputilizeamptheseampsubtleampsensationsampinamptheampserviceampofamptransformativeamplearningamp(pamp
68)ampampamp
amp ForampKarpiakamp(2003)ampattentivenessamprequiresampawarenessamptoampverbalampandamp
nonverbalampcuesampasampwellampasampanampawarenessampofampwhatampisamphappeningampamongampandampwithinamptheamp
studentsampandamptheampeducatorampampAttunementamprequiresampanampeducatoramptoamporientampherselfamptoamptheamp
otherampandamptoampadoptampanampattitudeampofampunhurriednessampofamppatienceampandampofamphumilityamp
concerningampbothamptheampprocessampandamptheampoutcomesampofamptheampteachingamp(Karpiakamp2003amppgamp
72)ampampAmplificationampisampaampprocessampofamphonoringampcommunicationampthatampcentersamponamptheampideaamp
ofamphearingamponeselfampintoampknowingampitampincludesampusingampparaphrasingampandampclarificationamp
activitiesamptoampgainampinsightampintoampmeaningampampLastlyampassociationampentailsampidentifyingamp
patternsampandampweavingampthemamptogetherampwithampstudentampexperienceampclassroomampdiscussionamp
andamptheampideasampofampothersamp
amp TuningampintoampsubtletyampimpliesampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceampampTheampmanifestationsamp
ofampsilenceampinamptheampclassroomampareampendlessampandampitsampvalueampisamptooampgreatamptoampbeampignoredampwhileamp
tooampvastamptoampbeampfullyampabsorbedampampLevinamp(1989)ampremarksampthatampsilenceampisampaampclearingampwhereamp
thereampisampnothingampforamphearingamptoampholdamponamptoampinampwhichampmanyampfindampunbearableampanxietyamp
(pamp79)ampampNearlyampallampofampusamphaveampexperiencedampthisampunbearableampanxietyampaampstrainampofamp
whichampcanampbeampfoundampinampeducationalampcontextsampdueamptoamptheampfactampthatampclassroomsampareamp
oftenampstructuredamparoundampimplicitampandampexplicitamprulesampaboutamptalkampandampsilenceamp(Schultzamp
2010amppamp2848)ampampForampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampanampawarenessampofampsilenceampimplicatesamp
whatampisampleftampunsaidampandampwhatampisampunsayableltltespeciallyampimportantampbecauseampofamptheamp
unsayableampqualityampofampartworksampampForampSchultzamp(2010)ampsilenceampimpliesamppossibilityamp
becauseampitampcanampholdampmultipleampmeaningsampforampindividualsampwithinampandampacrossampracialamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 26amp
ethnicampandampculturalampgroupsamp(pamp2833)ampampLevinamp(1989)ampfindsampthatamptoamplistenamptoamp
somethingampweampmustampfirstampgive-itampourampsilenceamp(pamp232)ampampThisamppracticeampofampgivingampsilenceamp
isampparticularlyamphelpfulampinamptermsampofampviewingamporamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartamp
amp Gradleamp(2011)ampoutlinesampaamppracticalampvisionampforampviewingampartampthatamprequiresamp
silenceampandampdeliberationampampForamptheamppurposesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampwouldamp
reconceptualizeampthisampasampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampampGradleamp(2011)ampinstructedamp
herampstudentsamptoampspendamptimeampwithampaampworkampofampartampoutsideampofamptheirampeverydayampworldviewamp
attentivelyampviewingampitampforampaboutamptenampminutesampeverydayampforampaampweekampampAfterampeachampviewingamp
experienceamptheampstudentsampwroteampinamptheirampjournalsampampTheampresultsampindicatedampthatampthisamp
processampofampsustainedampsilentampdeliberationampcoupledampwithampanampengagementampofamptheiramp
intuitiveampperceptionsampaboutampartworkampleftampstudentsampfeelingampempoweredamptoampengageampinamp
discussionampandampappreciateampunfamiliarampartampformsampampThisampactivityampisampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoamp
aampworkampofampartampthatampincorporatesampSablesamp(2014)ampconceptampofampstructuredampcontemplationampamp
Weavingampaamprelationshipampbetweenampsilenceampcontemplationampandampattentivenessampisampaamp
significantampendeavorampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
Contemplativeamppracticesampfunctionampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Engageampinampformsampofampviewingampwritingampandampexperiencingampthatamphonorampselfltlisteningamp
bull Attuneamptoampsubtletyampandampnuanceampbull Listenampandampviewampdeliberatelyampbull Cultivateampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceamp(
The(Felt(Sense(
When-someone-understands-what-I-am-talking-about-when-I-talk-about-art-I-am-delighted--Art-is-my-everything--Its-my-passion--When-someone-understands-that-I-
am-instantly-filled-with-joy--That-tells-me-someone-gets-it-(Survey-response-CTF-age-16)-
(
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 26amp
ethnicampandampculturalampgroupsamp(pamp2833)ampampLevinamp(1989)ampfindsampthatamptoamplistenamptoamp
somethingampweampmustampfirstampgive-itampourampsilenceamp(pamp232)ampampThisamppracticeampofampgivingampsilenceamp
isampparticularlyamphelpfulampinamptermsampofampviewingamporamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartamp
amp Gradleamp(2011)ampoutlinesampaamppracticalampvisionampforampviewingampartampthatamprequiresamp
silenceampandampdeliberationampampForamptheamppurposesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampwouldamp
reconceptualizeampthisampasampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampampGradleamp(2011)ampinstructedamp
herampstudentsamptoampspendamptimeampwithampaampworkampofampartampoutsideampofamptheirampeverydayampworldviewamp
attentivelyampviewingampitampforampaboutamptenampminutesampeverydayampforampaampweekampampAfterampeachampviewingamp
experienceamptheampstudentsampwroteampinamptheirampjournalsampampTheampresultsampindicatedampthatampthisamp
processampofampsustainedampsilentampdeliberationampcoupledampwithampanampengagementampofamptheiramp
intuitiveampperceptionsampaboutampartworkampleftampstudentsampfeelingampempoweredamptoampengageampinamp
discussionampandampappreciateampunfamiliarampartampformsampampThisampactivityampisampaampwayampofamplisteningamptoamp
aampworkampofampartampthatampincorporatesampSablesamp(2014)ampconceptampofampstructuredampcontemplationampamp
Weavingampaamprelationshipampbetweenampsilenceampcontemplationampandampattentivenessampisampaamp
significantampendeavorampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamp
Contemplativeamppracticesampfunctionampinampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwhenampparticipantsampamp
bull Engageampinampformsampofampviewingampwritingampandampexperiencingampthatamphonorampselfltlisteningamp
bull Attuneamptoampsubtletyampandampnuanceampbull Listenampandampviewampdeliberatelyampbull Cultivateampaamprelationshipampwithampsilenceamp(
The(Felt(Sense(
When-someone-understands-what-I-am-talking-about-when-I-talk-about-art-I-am-delighted--Art-is-my-everything--Its-my-passion--When-someone-understands-that-I-
am-instantly-filled-with-joy--That-tells-me-someone-gets-it-(Survey-response-CTF-age-16)-
(
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 27amp
amp Relatedamptoampcontemplativeamppracticesampisamptheampdevelopmentampofampaamprelationshipampwithamp
onesampfeltampsenseampampEugeneampGendlinamp(1926ltpresent)ampisampcreditedampwithamptheampdevelopmentampofamp
thisamptermampwhichamprefersamptoampaamppreconceptualamppartlyampunformedampstreamampofampfeelingampthatamp
weamphaveampeveryampmomentamp(Gendlinamp1962amppamp3)ampampGendlinamp(1962)ampfindsampthatampthisamp
dimensionampofampexperiencingampisampaampconstantampeveramppresentampunderlyingampphenomenonampofamp
inwardlyampsentientamplivingampandampthereforeampthereampisampanampexperientialampsideampofampanythingamp(pgamp
11)ampampThisampisampaampsenseampsoampfundamentalampandampavailableamptoampallamppeopleampthatampitampoftenampgoesamp
unrecognizedampitampisamptheampphysicalampplaceampwhereampweamplocateampwhatamptheampbodyampknowsamp(Perlamp
2004amppamp4)ampampGendlinsamp(1997)ampfeltampsenseampalsoampconnectsampbackamptoamplanguageamp
hermeneuticsampandampexperienceampinampthatampnoampexhaustiveampexaminationampofampexperienceampisamp
possibleampsinceampitampisampneverampcompletelyampinampviewamp[and]ampwhatampwordsampmeanampisampnotamp
presentedampbeforeampusampeitheramp(pamp4)amp
amp TheampfeltampsenseampappliesamptoampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampampInamp
particularampdescriptionsampaboutampandampgesturesamptowardsamptheampfeltampsenseampwereampwovenamp
throughoutamptheampsurveyampresponsesampcollectedampasamppartampofampthisampresearchampampampInampansweringamp
theampquestionampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingamplistenedamptoampandampunderstoodamp[asampyouamp
spokeampaboutampyourampart]amptheampsurveyampresponsesampdidampnotampcatalogampandampquantifyampbodyamp
languageampverbalampresponsesampandampeyeampcontactampampWhileamptheseampandampotherampfeaturesampofamp
conversationampregularlyampinformamptheampfeelingampofampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodamptheampwholeamp
isampgreaterampthanamptheampsumampofampitsamppartsampampTheseampfeaturesampofampdialogueampasampwellampasampothersamp
composeampaampfeelingampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareampbeingampheardampampSimilaramptoamptheampfeelingampofamp
describingampaamppowerfulampviewingampexperienceampwordsampsometimesampfailampusltltweampfeelamp
connectedampbutampdontampknowampexactlyampwhyamporamphowampitamphappenedampampAsamponeampsurveyamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 28amp
participantampwroteampsomeoneampgetsampitamp(SurveyampresponseampCTFampageamp16)ampampThatampitampisamp
heavyampwithampcomplexityampwhileampsimultaneouslyampweightlessampitampisamptheampfeelingampofampbeingamp
understoodamp
amp Artistsampandampmakersampalsoamprelyamponamptheampfeltampsenseampduringamptheampcreativeampprocessamp
usuallyampwithoutampidentifyingampitampasampsuchampampPerlamp(2004)ampexemplifiesampthisampinamptheampfollowingamp
passageamponampcomposingampaamptextamp
amp YouampareampdraftingampaamppaperampampAfterampanampinitialampstruggleamptryingampthisamptryingampthatampyouamp amp
amp hitampyourampstrideampampTheampwordsampareampcomingampquicklyampYourampbodyamptinglesampYouampjiggleamp
amp youramplegamporamptapamponamptheamptableampYouamploveampwhatampisamphappeningamp[But]ampyouampareamp
amp afraidamptoampsayampmuchampaboutampwhatampisampgoingamponampbecauseampyouampdontampwantamptoampjinxamptheamp
amp creativeampprocessamp(pamp3)ampamp
amp Perlamp(2004)ampdemonstratesampaampconnectionampbetweenampmindampandampbodyampanamp
alignmentampthatampletsampusampknowampweampareamponamptheamprightamptrackampampConverselyamptheampfeltampsenseampalsoamp
operatesamptoampletampusampknowampwhenampthingsampareampnotampgoingampwellampampForampGendlinamp(1962)amp
nothingampisampasampdebilitatingampasampaampconfusedamporampdistantampfunctioningamp(pamp15)ampofamptheampfeltamp
senseampampampamp
amp ThisampsenseampofampdebilitationampcomesampupampinamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampOneampparticipantamp
wroteamppassionatelyampaboutampbeingampjudgedampduringampaampformalampcritiqueampAfterampputtingampsoamp
muchamptimeampeffortampandampstressampintoampsomethingampitampwasampsoampdisappointingamptoampfeelamp
insignificantamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)ampampHereampweampcanampseeamphowamptheampwriteramp
equatesampherampartworkampwithampherampsenseampofampselfampfeelingampthatampsheampwasampputampinampaampsituationamp
whereampasampsheampwritesampIampwasampunprotectedampandampvulnerableampIampfeltampasampthoughampIampwasamp
almostampcondemnedampampAamppervasiveampdogmaampofampcritiqueampisampthatampitampshouldampnotampbeamptakenamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 29amp
personallyampandampmostampcritiquesampmaintainamptheampstrangeampfictionampthatamptheampworkampcanampbeamp
consideredampentirelyampapartampfromamptheamppersonampwhoampmadeampitamp(Elkinsamp2001amppamp132)ampamp
Artistsamproutinelyampputampthemselvesampintoamptheirampartampamptheampworkampisamptheampphysicalampandamp
conceptualampmanifestationampofamptheampselfampofampwaysampofampbeingampandampofamppersonalampbeliefsampampYetamp
whenampitampcomesamptimeamptoampcritiqueampartistsampmustampputampthemselvesampasideampinampaampwayampthatamp
recallsampaampCartesianampmindltbodyampdualismamp(BakerampampampMorrisamp2002)ampampWorksampofampartampwhichamp
comeampfromamptheampinteriorampselfampandampareampproducedampbyampaampphysicalampbodyampareampcritiquedampasampifamp
theyampareampseparateampfromamptheirampexperiencesampofampbeingampmadeampandampseparateampfromamptheamp
experiencesampthatampmadeampitamppossibleampforamptheampartistamptoampmakeampthemampampInampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceamphoweverampthereampisampanampinfiniteamploopampbetweenamptheampartisticampproductamptheampexperienceamp
ofampmakingampthisampproductampandamptheampselfampampCritiqueampexperiencesampareampaampholisticampencounteramp
withampallampofamptheseampideasamp
amp BelenkyampClinchyampGoldbergerampandampTaruleamp(1997)ampimplyamptheampfeltampsenseampasamptheyamp
discussampsubjectiveampknowingampaampconceptionampofampunderstandingampthatampisamppersonalampprivateamp
andampsubjectivelyampknownamporampintuitedamp(pamp54)ampampThoughamptheyamppositampthisampasampmentalamp
activityampitamphasampaampphysicalampcomponentampasampwellamponeampofamptheirampstudyampparticipantsamp
describesamplisteningamptoampherampgutampasampaampwayampofampmakingampdecisionsamp(pamp53)ampampItampisampalsoamp
sometimesampcharacterizedampasampanampinnerampvoiceampampItampseemsampthatampwhenampweampdiscussamptheampideaamp
ofampintuitiveampknowingampthisampintuitionampcouldampmanifestampitselfampinampaampnumberampofampwaysltltaamp
voiceampaampphysicalampsenseampaampgutampreactionamporampaampsensationamponlyamprecognizableamptoamponeselfampampAamp
challengeampofamplisteningamptoamponeselfampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampisampinamptheampidentificationamp
ofamptheampwayampinampwhichampaampsenseampofampintuitionampcomesamptoampusampandamphowampweamprespondampwhenampitamp
doesampampBecauseamptheampcreationampofampartworkampreliesampheavilyamponampaampbalanceampbetweenampintuitionamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 30amp
andampcognitionampandampbothampmustampbeamptrustedampingredientsampinamptheampcreativeampprocessamp(Watsonamp
2013)amp
Aampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamphonorsamptheampfeltampsenseampwhenampparticipantsamp
bull Identifyamptheampwaysampinampwhichamptheyampexperienceampaampfeltampsenseamporampintuitionampbull Valueampthisampsenseampasampanampimportantampcomponentamptoampviewingampandampcreatingampworksamp
ofampartampbull Conceiveampofampworksampofampartampasampaampcontinuationampofamptheampselfamp
amp
thread5(
Research(Methodology(and(Methods(
amp Theampresearchampmethodologyampusedampforampthisampprojectampisampintricatelyamplinkedampwithamptheamp
variousampconceptualampframeworksampthatampspawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampamp
Thisampisampanampinterpretiveampfluidampmethodologyampsomethingamplikeampaampmediumampthatampcouldampbeamp
bentampandampfoldedamptoampfitampmyampneedsampampThisampmethodologyampidentifiesampcloselyampwithamp
hermeneuticsampinampitsampinterestampinamplanguageamptheampwrittenampwordampandampconstructionsampofamp
meaningamp(HeelanampampampSchulkinamp2009)ampbutampcollagesamptogetherampelementsampfromamprelatedamp
fieldsampampInampthisampsectionampIampwillampfirstampdiscussamphowampmyampresearchampwasampinfluencedampbyamp
methodologicalampaspectsampofampcaseampstudiesampphenomenologyampandampnarrativeampresearchampamp
ThenampIampwillampexploreamptheampobjectsampIampcreatedampasampconceptualampembodimentsampofampthisampresearchampamp
Case(Studies(
amp BecauseampIampsoughtamptoampgroundampmyampworkampinamprealltlifeamppracticesamptheampuseampofampcaseamp
studiesampwasampanampimportantampfeatureampparticularlyampwithinamptheampcontextampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampampCreswellamp(2013)ampdefinesampaampcaseampstudyampasampaampmethodamporampmethodologyamp
thatampusesampdetailedampinltdepthampdataampcollectionampinvolvingampmultipleampsourcesampofamp
informationampthatampoccursampwithinampaamprealltlifeampcontemporaryampboundedampsystemamp(pamp97)ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 31amp
TheampdataampIampcollectedampwithinamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampincludedamphandoutsampandamp
drawingsampbyampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampasampwellampasampreflexiveampfieldampnotesamponamptheamp
partampofamptheampresearcherampampampIampchoseampnotamptoampemployampaudioamporampvideoamprecordingampcapabilitiesamp
becauseampIampfeltampthatampthoseampmethodsampwouldampalterampsignificantlyamptheampbehaviorampandamp
experiencesampofampbothampresearcherampandampparticipantampampIampchoseamptoampuseampaampcollectiveampcaseamp
studyampinampwhichamptheampissueampofamplisteningampwasampselectedamptoampbeampexploredampandampmultipleampcaseamp
studiesampwereampconductedampunderamptheampumbrellaampofampthisampissueamp(Creswellamp2013)ampampCaseamp
studiesamprelianceamponampbothampnarrativesampandamptheamplivedampexperiencesampofampothersampalsoamphaveampaamp
relationshipampwithamptheampsubsequentampmethodsampinampthisampresearchamp
Phenomenology(
amp Phenomenologyampisamptheampstudyampofampouramplivedampexperiencesampasamphumansampandamphowampweamp
immediatelyampexperienceamp[theampworld]ampratherampthanamphowampweampconceptualizeampcategorizeamp
oramptheorizeampaboutampitamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp37)ampampVanampManenamp(1984amp1990)ampdescribesampaamp
processampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampwhoseampfocusamponamplanguageampwasampparticularlyamp
influentialamptoampmyampprojectampampHisampdiscussionampofampphenomenologicalampwritingampresonatedamp
withampmeampbecauseampofampitsampqualitativeampfocusamponampthoughtfulnessampandampattentivenessamp
connectionsampthatampalignampwithampmanyampsignificantampaimsampofampteachingamplisteningampandampviewingamp
withinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampPhenomenologyampalsoampconnectsamptoampcontemplativeamp
practicesampinampitsampuseampofampbracketingampperceptionsamptoampbeampmoreampopenamporampfaithfulamptoamptheamp
phenomenonamp(AndersonampampampSpenceramp2013amppamp331)ampbeingampinvestigatedampampVanampManenamp
(1984)ampdescribesampphenomenologyampasampaampsearchampforampwhatampitampmeansamptoampbeamphumanampaampgoalamp
simultaneouslyampsimpleampandampoverwhelminglyampcomplexampsimilaramptoamptheampactampofamplisteningamp
andampbeingamplistenedamptoampampPhenomenologicalampresearchampisampparticularlyampappropriateamptoampartlt
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 32amp
makingampbecauseampitampisampconceivedampofampasampaamppoetizingampactivityampthatampseeksamptoamp
authenticallyampspeakamptheampworldamp(vanampManenamp1984amppamp39)ampinampaampfashionampthatampisampsimilaramp
toamptheampwayampsomeampartistsampapproachamptheirampworkampamp
Narrative(Research(
amp Becauseampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamphonoramptheampnarrativesampofampothersampemployingamp
narrativeampresearchampseemedamptoampbeampanampimplicitampbutampimportantamppartampofampthisampprocessampampIamp
reliedamponamptheampstoriesampofampothersamptoampexplainamptheirampexperiencesampwithamplisteningampasampIamp
solicitedampsurveysampasampwellampasampduringamptheampperiodsampinampwhichampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningamp
spacesampampNarrativeampresearchampbearsampsimilaritiesampwithampcollageampandampcollaborationampampTheamp
storiesampofampothersampwhenampgivenamptoampaampresearcherampareampreconstructedampintoampaampcoltcreativeamp
endeavorampinampwhichampaampstoryampemergesampthroughamptheampinteractionamporampdialogueampofamptheamp
researcherampandamptheampparticipant(s)amp(Creswellamp2013amppamp71)ampampThisampwasampespeciallyamptrueamp
duringamptheampcourseampofampmyampprojectampinampwhichamptheampindividualampstoriesampinteractedampwithampeachamp
otheramptoampformamptheirampownampmeaningsampwhichampwereampthenampconstructedampmediatedampandamp
experiencedampbyamptheampresearcherampampampIampalsoampprovidedampmyampownamppersonalampnarrativesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperienceampandamp(In)Conclusionsampsections)ampinampanampeffortamptoampgiveamplifeamptoampmyamp
personalityampandampitsamprelationshipampwithampandampeffectamponampthisampresearchamp
Data(Collection(
amp ForampthisampprojectampIampreliedampprimarilyamponamptwoampformsampofampdataampcollectionampampIampsolicitedamp
surveysampthatampaskedampartistsampaboutamptheiramppositiveampandampnegativeampexperiencesampwithamp
listeningampinamptheampcontextampofampdiscussingamptheirampartworkampampIampwillampelaborateampmoreamponamptheamp
resultsampofamptheseampsurveysampinampanampupcomingampsectionampofampthisamppaperampampAfterampexploringamptheamp
surveyampresponsesampinampaampnumberampofampwaysampIampenactedampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 33amp
participantsampampIampwillampdiscussamptheseampcomponentsampofamptheampdataampfurtherampinamptheampImmersedampinamp
Dataampsectionamp
Methods(
amp Iampchoseamptoampsynthesizeamptheampvariousampdataampdescribedampaboveamp(surveysampandampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampexperiences)ampandamptheampresearchampexploredampthroughoutampthisamppaperamp
(hermeneuticsampdialogicamppracticesampcontemplativeamppracticesampandamptheampfeltampsense)ampintoamp
textltobjectsampampTheampformsampofamptheseampobjectsampechoamptheampconceptualampframeworksampthatamp
spawnedamptheampideaampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampAsampIampcreatedamptheseamptextltobjectsampIamp
soughtamptoampembedamprealltlifeamplisteningampexperiencesampinamptheampphilosophicalampframeworksampIamp
employedampampIampwantedamptheampworksamptoampengageampwithampaampsenseampofamppraxisampthatampisampvitalamptoamp
educationampartltmakingampandamptheamptypesampofamplisteningampIampamampinterestedampinampfosteringamp
amp Theseamptextltobjectsampcanampbeampunderstoodampinampmanyampwaysltltasampphysicalamp
embodimentsamptoampphilosophicalampnotionsampasampaamplibraryampforampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamporamp
asampaampmapampofampinquiryampamongampmanyamppossibilitiesampforamptheirampconceptualizationampampTheseamp
textltobjectsamprequireampactiveampparticipationampfromampanampinquiringampviewerampampManyampofampthemamp
haveampanampinteractiveampqualityampthatampseeksampparticipationampampIampwillampbrieflyampdescribeampsomeampofamp
theampartltmakingampmethodsampIampusedampandampwhyamptheirampqualitiesampareamprelevantamptoampmyampresearch( amp
bull BookmakingampampBecauseampwrittenamptextsampwereampamongamptheampearliestampusesampofamp
hermeneuticsamp(Bleicheramp1980ampHeelanampampampSchulkinamp2003)ampIampfoundamptheampnotionamp
ofampbookmakingampanampimportantamptraditionamptoampadhereamptoampasampwellampasamponeampthatampcouldamp
beampmanipulatedampandampcomplicatedamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 34amp
bull SculptureampampTheampcreationampofampthreeltdimensionalampobjectsampratherampthatampthoseamp
composedampsolelyamponampaamptwoltdimensionalampplaneampwasampmeaningfulampasampaampreflectionamp
ofamptheampspaceampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
bull TextualampmanipulationampandamppolysemyampampTheampuseampofamplanguageampandamptextampareamp
importantampfeaturesamptoampthisampprojectampinampmanyampwaysampsoamptheamppiecesampIampcreatedampareamp
textltheavyampampIampoftenampdissectedampandamppulledampapartamptextsamptoamppurposelyamptroubleamptheiramp
initialampmeaningsamporampofferampanotherampinterpretationampampManyampofamptheamptextltobjectsampareamp
deliberatelyampinteractiveampmoveableampandampchangeableampinamporderamptoampprovokeamptheamp
viewerampintoamptakingampanampactiveamproleampinampinterpretationampampTheseampworksampinampparticularamp
reinforceamppluralityampasampaampfeatureampofampartampinterpretationampandampeducationampasampwellampasamp
theampnecessityampofampanampactiveampdeliberateampattitudeampduringamptheseampprocessesamp
bull CollageampandampLayeringampampTheseampphysicalampmanifestationsampareampintricatelyamplinkedamptoamp
theampideaampofampmeaningampasampaampcollageamporamplayeringampofamppreviousampexperiencesamp(seeamp
CollagingampExperiencesampsection)ampampamp
bull FoldingampampFoldingamprequiresampactiveampparticipationampthatampresultsampinampaamptensionampaamppushamp
andamppullampampToampfoldampaamppieceampofamppaperampisamptoampforeverampmarkampitampwithamptheampcreaseampofampthatamp
experienceampampampMarksamp(2002)ampwordsamponampthisamptopicampofferampanampexplanationampthatampfitsamp
wellampwithinamptheampconceptualampframeworkampofampthisampresearchamp
Oneampofampmyampfavoriteampmetaphorsampfromampquantumampphysicsampisampthatamptheampuniverseampisamp
likeampaampgreatampsurfaceampthatamphasampbeenampinfinitelyampfoldedamptogetherampuntilamppointsampthatamp
wereampunfathomablyampdistantampinampspacelttimeampcomeamptoamptouchampeachampotherampEachamp
timeampweampperceiveampsomethingampweampacknowledgeamptheampcontinuityampbetweenampitsamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 35amp
manyamplayersampampExpressingamptheseampperceptionsampweampactualizeamptheampvirtualampeventsamp
enfoldedampinampthoseamplayersamp(pampxi)amp
bull SewingampampTheampphysicalampthreadampisampaampconceptualampexpressionampampRatherampthanamp
chaptersampthisamppaperampcontainsampthreadsampampLooseampthreadsampareampleftampasampaampnodamptoampwhatamp
isampunfinishedampandampnotampneatlyamptiedampupampotherampthreadsamptightlyampbindampobjectsamp(andamp
ideas)amptogetherampstillampothersamprepresentampaamprecurringampthemeamprunningampthroughampanamp
experienceamp
bull AudioamprecordingampThisampfeatureampofamptheampprojectampdoesampnotampcontinueamptheampphysicalamp
formampofamptheamptextltobjectampthoughamptheamptwoampmayampbearampsomeampconceptualamp
similaritiesampampProvidingampsoundampinamptheampspaceampofampmyampresearchampexhibitionampseemedamp
importantampandampIampwantedamptoamphonoramptheampvariousampvoicesampthatampcontributedamptheiramp
storiesampwithinamptheampsurveysampampToampdoampthisampIampcollagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampofamp
theampsurveysampthatampseemedamptoamprelateamptoampeachampotherampampIampthenamprecordedampmyselfamp
speakingamptheseamppassagesampandampeditedampthemampintoamponeamplayeredampmultiltstoriedamp
trackampampInampthisamptrackamppassagesampswellampinampvolumeamptoamphighlightampthemesamporamp
complicationsampampamp
amp
thread6(
Immersed(in(Data(
amp AsampmentionedampaboveampIamphaveampgatheredampdataampfromampaampnumberampofampsourcesampsuchampasamp
theampsolicitationampofampsurveysampaboutamplisteningampexperiencesampfromampartistsampatampvariousamplevelsampofamp
educationampasampwellampasamptheampenactmentampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampInamptheampfollowingamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 36amp
sectionsampIampwillampdiscussampandampanalyzeamphowamptheseampendeavorsampcontributeamptoampmyamp
understandingampofamplisteningampinampspacesampofampartampeducationamp
Survey(Responses(
amp Participantampsurveysampprovidedampaampwealthampofampknowledgeampaboutampwhatampencouragesamp
andampprohibitsampmeaningfulamplisteningampexperiencesampampIamporganizedamptheampsurveyampintoamptwoamp
questionsamponeampquestionampelicitsampaampgenerallyamppositiveampresponseampwhileamptheampotherampasksamp
participantsamptoamprecallampaampgenerallyampnegativeamplisteningampexperienceampampIampuseamptheamptermamp
positiveampinampreferenceamptoamptheampfirstampquestionampandampnegativeampinampreferenceamptoamptheampsecondampforamp
organizationalampreasonsampampManyampofamptheampresponsesampblurredamplinesampbetweenampwhatampisamp
consideredamppositiveamporampnegativeampaboutampaampspecificampexperienceampbutampmostampmaintainedamptheamp
generalampstructureampampampTheamporganizationampofamptheampsurveysampasamppositiveampandampnegativeampisampnotamp
meantamptoampreinforceampaampbinaryampofamptheseampexperiencesampthoughampthatampmayampbeampaampconsequenceamp
ofampthisampdecisionampampTheampsurveyampquestionsampareamp
1ampDescribeampaamptimeampwhenampyouampfeltampthatampsomeoneamplistened(to(you(and(understood(asampyouampspokeampaboutampyourampartampampUseampspecificampdetailsampaboutamphowampyouampfeltampampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampwereampbeingampheardampandampunderstoodampamp2ampDescribeampaamptimeampwhenampyouampfeltampmisunderstood(not(heard(or(dismissedampasampyouampspokeampaboutampyourampartampampUseampspecificampdetailsampaboutamphowampyouampfeltampampHowampdidampyouampknowampyouampandorampyourampworkampwasampbeingampmisunderstoodampampampamp Iampreceivedamp48amptotalamplisteningampsurveysampampOfamptheseamp48ampsurveysamp11ampwereamp
incompleteamporampnotamprelevantamptoamptheampresearchampampIampfocusedamptheampbulkampofampmyampinquiryamponamptheamp
37ampremainingampsurveysampinampwhichamptheampageamprangeampisampfromamp14amptoamp47ampandamplevelsampofamp
educationamprangeampfromampearlyamphighampschoolamptoampgraduateampschoolampampOfampthoseamp37amponeampsurveyamp
didampnotampexpressamphavingampanyamppositiveamplisteningampexperiencesampandamponeampdidampnotampexpressamp
havingampanyampnegativeamplisteningampexperiencesampampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 37amp
( Survey(themes(
amp Withinamptheamp37ampsurveysampIampuncoveredampeightampcommonampthemesamp(seeampfigamp1)ampthatamp
occurredampinampbothamppositiveampandampnegativeamplisteningampexperiencesampampTheampdiscoveryampofamptheseamp
themesampisamplikelyampinfluencedampbyampmyampownampbiasesampandampIamphaveampundoubtedlyampoverlookedamp
someampqualitiesampofamptheseampexperiencesampampTheampthemesampIamphaveampuncoveredamphoweverampareamp
richampwithampinstructiveamppotentialampforampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampThemesampincludeamp
studentltteacherampinteractionamppeerampinteractionampfamilyampinteractionampreferenceamptoamp
critiqueampexperience(s)ampreferenceamptoampinstitutionalampexperience(s)amporampgradesampreferenceamp
toampideologyampstrongampemotionalampcharacterampandampartampasampcontinuationampofampselfampampIampcountedamp
theampthemesampasampdataamponlyampwhenamptheyampwereampexplicitlyampmentionedampinamptheamptextampampampToamp
exemplifyampthisampIampwillampprovideamptextualampevidenceampofamphowamptheampthemesampmanifestedampinamp
surveyampresponsesamp
bull StudentltteacherampinteractionampInamp7thampgradeampIampcompletedampanampartampprojectampampWhileamp
Iampwasampgoingamptoampwriteampmyampnameampatamptheampcornerampofamptheamppieceampmyampteacherampcameampupamp
behindampmeampandampsaidampWowampthatamplooksampfantasticampampIamplikeamphowampyouampusedampdifferentamp
colorsamptoampshowamptheamptextureampandampcontrastampInampthatampmomentampIampfeltampveryampproudamp
(SurveyampresponseampAFPampageamp14)amp
bull PeerampinteractionampDuringamptheampfirstampcritiqueampIampwasamptalkingamptoampaamppeerampaboutampmyamp
conceptampampWhenampIampwasampexplainingampwhatampIamphaveampinampmindampherampeyesamplitampupampampIampfeelampasamp
thoughampsheampgotampwasampIampwasamptryingamptoampsayampasampopposedamptoamphavingampitampgoampinampthroughamp
oneampearampandampoutamptheampotherampamp(SurveyampresponseampDAampageamp16)amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 38amp
bull FamilyampinteractionampWhenampIampshowampmyampmomampmyampworkampsheampdoesntampunderstandamp
theampcomplexampandampintenseampmeaningsampbehindampthemampampMyampworkampcannotampbeamp
appreciatedampproperlyampbyampherampamp(SurveyampresponseampRMampageamp17)amp
bull ReferenceamptoampcritiqueampexperiencesampAsampifampitampisampnotampunsettlingampenoughamptoamppresentamp
aampyearampofampworkamptoampfourampjudgesampwhomampyouveampneverampconnectedampwithampbeforeamptheamp
structureampofamptheampcritiqueampallowedampforamplittleamptimeamptoampdiscussamptheampworkampinampaamp
relevantampcontextampamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)amp
bull Referenceamptoampinstitutionalampexperience(s)amporampgradesampIampwasampbetterampableamptoamp
conveyampmyampartampamongstampfriendsampandampfamilyampbutampnotampinamptheampartampvernacularampandamp
rhetoricampmyampprofessorsampseemedamptoampcovetampampAtampleastampthatampwasampmyampperceptionampampItamp
wasampalsoampreflectedampinamptheampgradeampIampreceivedamponampmyampthesisamppaperampinampcomparisonamp
toamptheampgradeampreceivedamponamptheampaccompanyingampartworkampasampgivenampbyampdifferingamp
professorsamppaperampC+ampartworkampAltampampGradesamphurtampsometimesamp(Surveyamp
responseampRVTampageamp30)amp
bull Referenceamptoampideologyamp[EstablishedampartistampJoseph]ampMarioniampwasamptheampfirstamp
personampIamphadampexplainedampthisamptoampthatampactuallyampknewampEXACTLYampwhatampIampwasamptalkingamp
aboutampHeampactuallyampsaidamptoampmeampItsampinampyouramppsycheampampThisampresonatedampwithampmeampamp
IampknewamprightampthenampthatampIampwasampnoamplongerampafraidampwhenampsomeoneampaskedampmeampwhyampIamp
chooseampaampparticularampcolorampampIampchooseampcolorampbecauseampIampintuitivelyampknowampthatampcoloramp
isampgivingampsomethingamptoamptheampviewerampMarioniampunderstoodamp(Surveyampresponseamp
RWampageamp26)amp
bull StrongampemotionalampcharacterampThisamppersonampdidntampactuallyampcareampinamptheampfirstamp
placeampsoampIampfeltampthatampeverythingampIampwasampdoingampwasampworthlessampuselessampandampuglyampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 39amp
MyampartamprepresentsampmeampandampmyamppastampsoampIampfeltampworthlessampuselessampandampuglyamp
(SurveyampresponseampAVampageamp17)amp
bull ArtampasampcontinuationampofampselfampIfampIampknowampmeampandampIampcanampspeakampofampmeampthenampmaybeamp
oneampdayampeveryoneampwillampgiveampmeampandampmyampworkampwhichampisampmeampaampchanceamp(Surveyamp
responseampMESampageamp24)amp
Creative=Listening(Space(Case(Studies(
( Iampconductedampfiveampcaseampstudiesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithampsixampindividualsamp
asamppartampofampthisampresearchampdeliberatelyampchoosingamppeopleampwithampwhomampIamphadampvariousamptypesamp
ofamprelationshipsampampampTwoampofamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwereampconductedampwithamp
individualsampwithampwhomampIamphadampnoampprioramprelationshipamponeampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampwasamp
withamptheamp14ampyearltoldampdaughterampofampaampclassmateampandamptheampotherampwasampwithamptwoamp
undergraduateampfineampartampstudentsampinamptheirampfirstampyearampinamptheampUniversityampofampCincinnatisamp
DAAPampprogramampampAnotheramptwoampwereampconductedampwithamphighampschoolltagedampstudentsampIamp
teachampinampanampafterltschoolampartampprogramampampTheampfinalampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampconductedamp
wasampwithampanampundergraduateampartampstudentampwithampwhomampIamphaveampsharedampseveralampclassesampampamp
amp Theampbasicampstructureampofamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampexperiencesampwasampfairlyamp
consistentampthroughoutampthisampprocessampampIampprovidedampparticipantsampwithamptwoamphandoutsamp(seeamp
figamp2ampandamp3)ampampTheampfirstamphandoutampdescribedamptheamppromptampandampbeliefsampofampaampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampampWeampcompletedamptheamppromptamponamptheampbackampofampthisamphandoutampampTheampsecondamp
handoutampoutlinedampwaysampofamplisteningampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampandampwasampusedampforamp
participantsamptoampevaluateamptheampexperienceampampAllampparticipantsampincludingampmyselfamp
interactedampwithamptheseamphandoutsampbyampreadingampthemamp(oftenampaloud)ampandampfillingampthemampoutampatamp
differentamptimesampduringamptheampexperienceampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 40amp
amp Iampbeganamptheampsessionsampbyampinformingamptheampparticipantampthatampbothampofampusampwereampinampaamp
creativeltlisteningampspaceampandampthenampIampbrieflyampdescribedampwhatampthatampmeantampampThisampstepampsetamp
theamptoneampforamptheampencounterampampThenamptheampparticipantampandampIampreadamptheampBeliefsampinampaamp
CreativeltListeningampSpaceampsectionamp(figamp2)ampampIampaskedampifamptheampparticipantamphadampanyamp
questionsamporampcommentsampaboutamptheseamppracticesampampThenampIampshowedamptheampparticipantamptheamp
nextamphandoutamp(figamp3)ampampWeampeachampfilledampoutamptheamphandoutampwritingampourampnamesampinamptheamp
appropriateampspacesampampWeampreadampoveramptheamplistampofampactivitiesamponamptheampleftampsideampofamptheamppaperampampIamp
askedampparticipantsamptoampchooseamponeampqualityamptoampfocusamponampandampweampsharedampwhatamptheampfocusamp
wouldampbeampforampeachampofampusampandampwhyampampThenampIampintroducedamptheamppromptampaampselfltportraitampinamp
threeampminutesampampThisampselfltportraitampwasampcompletelyampopenltendedampinamptermsampofampstyleamp
techniqueampandampsubjectampmatterampampTheampmainampqualificationsampwereampthatampitampfeltamp
representativeampofamptheampartistampinampthatampmomentampampAfterampweamphadampspentampthreeampminutesamponamp
ourampselfampportraitsampweamptalkedampaboutampwhatampweampdrewampandampwhyampampIampgaveampparticipantsamptheamp
opportunityamptoampcontinueamptoampdrawampasampweampspokeampampampWhenampIampfeltampthatamptheampsessionampwasamp
drawingamptoampaampnaturalampcloseampeachampofampusampfilledampoutamptheampevaluationamphandoutamp(figamp3)ampbyamp
circlingampwhatampweampfeltampweamphadampexperiencedampduringamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampamp
amp
thread7(
Responding(to(Response(Layers(of(Listening(Understandingamp
amp Theampamountampofampdataamptheampexperiencesampandamptheampknowledgeampaccruedampoveramptheamp
courseampofampthisampprojectamphasampbeenamptoampsayamptheampleastampoverwhelmingampandamphumblingampamp
WritingampaamppassageampinampresponseamphasampbeenampaampsignificantampchallengeltlthowampshouldampIampdoamp
justiceamptoamptheampindividualsampwhoampsharedamptheirampstoriesampampWhatampisamptheampappropriateampmediumamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 41amp
forampsuchampaampventureampampHowampdoampIampsumampupampwhatampIamphaveamplearnedampfromampthemampandampfromamptheamp
experiencesampgeneratedampwithinampthisampresearchamp
amp InampanampattemptamptoampansweramporampsimplyampliveampinamptheseampquestionsampIampwouldampfirstamplikeamptoamp
discussamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampWhenamptaskedampwithampdescribingampsituationsampofampbeingamp
listenedamptoamporampnotampsurveyampparticipantsamphadampaamplotamptoampsayampampRarelyampdidampindividualsampgiveamp
oneltwordamporampevenamponeltsentenceampanswersampampNearlyampeveryoneamphadampexperiencesamptheyamp
wantedamptoampshareampandamptheseampexperiencesampwereampoftenampdescribedampusingamplanguageampthatamp
carriedampwithampitamptheampweightampofampemotionampandampvulnerabilityampampSomeampofamptheseampresponsesamp
continueamptoampstickamptoampmeampampMyampunderstandingampofampotherampresponsesampevolvedampoveramptheamp
courseampofampmyampinteractionsampwithampthemampampamp
amp Inampgeneralamptheampnegativeamplisteningampsituationsampdescribedampwereampnotampusuallyamp
purposefullyamphurtfulampampMoreampoftenampparticipantsampdescribedampfeelingampdismissedampampThisamp
sometimesampdidntampevenamptranslateampintoampwritingampampParticipantsampwroteampaboutampsituationsampinamp
whichamptheamplanguageampofamptheampencounterampdidntampalwaysampmatchamptheampemotionampfeltampampForamp
exampleamponeampsurveyampparticipantampdescribedampanampexperienceampinampwhichampaampfamilyampmemberamp
saidampWowampIampneverampthoughtampwouldveampthoughtamptoampmakeampaampportraitampthatampwayamp(Surveyamp
responseampLSampageamp27)ampampInampexamplesamplikeampthisampnegativeampinteractionsampwereampfeltampratheramp
thanamparticulatedampdirectlyampampTheseampmomentsampwereampbasedamparoundampintonationampemphasisamp
andamppresumedampsubtextampratherampthanampexplicitamporampdeliberateampwordampchoiceampampamp
amp IampamampundoubtedlyampmakingampsomeampassumptionsampasampIampsayampthisampbutamptheampsurveyamp
responsesampindicatedampthatampitsampeasyamptoampbeampunintentionallyamphurtfulampampItsampmuchampharderamptoamp
handleamptheampwordsampandampcreativeampworkampofampanotherampwithampcareampampInampfactampthisamptakesampconstantamp
questioningampandampreflectionampampTheamppositiveampresponsesampusuallyampindicatedampaampsenseampofamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 42amp
connectionamprestraintampandampgenuineampinterestampampSomeampdescribedampsilenceampasampaampkeyamp
componentampofamplisteningampandampothersampdiscussedamptheampsituationsampinampwhichamptheamplisteneramp
asksampquestionsamporampmake[s]ampcommentsampthatampallowampyouamptoampfeelampjustifiedampinampwhatampyouveamp
saidamp(SurveyampresponseampCHampageamp47)ampampStillampothersampreferredamptoamptheamppowerampofamp
interpretationampandamptheampintentampofamptheampartistampasampaampguideampforampknowingampthatamponesampworkamp
wasampunderstoodamp
amp Asampforamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcaseampstudiesampthisampideaampandamptheampexperiencesamp
thatampbroughtampitamptoampfruitionampareampstillampinamptheirampinfancyampampThisampresearchampprojectampgaveampmeamptheamp
firstampstepsampintoamptheamppossibilitiesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampandampIamplookampforwardamptoamp
understandingampmoreampaboutamphowampitampwouldamplookamptoampimplementampthisampframeworkampintoampaamp
classroomamporampstudioampcontextampampInitiallyampIampthoughtampthatampIampcouldampjustampaskampparticipantsamptoamp
enterampintoampaampstateampofampmindampthatampwouldampbeampconduciveamptoampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampIamp
assumedampthatampitampwasampmoreamplikeampaampshiftampinampattitudeampthanampaamplearnedampbehaviorampampButampIampwasamp
wrongltlttheampshiftampinampattitudeampcomesampfromampgradualamplearningampoveramptimeampampToampachieveampthisamp
thereampneedsamptoampbeampaampsystemampofampscaffoldingampinampplaceampampThisampscaffoldingampcanampincludeamp
specificampwaysampofampinteractingampinampclassroomsampstudiosampandampviewingampspacesampassignmentsamp
andampprojectsampcenteredamparoundampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampexperiencesampinvestigationampofamp
collageampjournalampwritingampexercisesampinamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampsustainedamp
engagementsampinampviewingampworksampofampartampteacherampmodelingampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
behaviorsampandampsoamponampampThisamprealizationampcameamptooamplateampinamptheampresearchamptoampfullyampengageamp
withamppossibleampsolutionsampbutampIamplookampforwardamptoampdevelopingamptheseampoveramptheampcourseampofamp
myampcareeramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 43amp
amp Theamprealizationampthatampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamprequireampmoreampthanampjustampanamp
attitudeampshiftampcameampfromampanotheramponeampofamptheampbiggestampoutcomesampofampthisampresearchampampTheamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampIampenactedamphadampsomethingampofampaampdominoampeffectamponampmyamppracticesamp
withinampthemampampTheampmostampimportantampaspectampofampenactingampthemampwasampbeingampreflexiveamptoamp
whatamphappenedampwithinampthemampampIampwasampconstantlyampaskingampmyselfampwhatampwasampworkingamp
whatampneededamptoampchangeampandampwhatampcouldampmakeampitampbetterampampIampreflectedamponampmyampownampstateamp
ofampmindampandamphowampthatampinformedampmyampexperiencesampandamptheampexperiencesampofampanotherampampIamp
reflectedamponampmyampassumptionsampampIampthoughtampthatampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmightamphaveampaamp
certainampkindampofampfeelingampaamptransformativeampclickampthatampwouldampletampmeampknowampitampwasamp
workingampampButampitsampnotampthatampsimpleampampAampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampmanifestampitselfampinamp
soampmanyampwaysampthatampitsampimpossibleamptoampidentifyampthemampallampampItampcouldampfeelamplikeampaampregularamp
conversationamporampcritiqueampitampcouldampfeelampuncomfortableamporampeasyampampItampcouldamphaveampaampuniqueamp
asltyetltunknownampqualityampampLikeampaampworkampofampartampitampcouldamptakeamponampanyampnumberampofampformsamp
andamppossibilitiesampMyampassumptionampthatampitampwouldamptakeamponamponeampeasylttoltrecognizeamp
manifestationampwasampnotampasampnuancedampasampthisampresearchampindicatesamptheamppossibilitiesampwouldamp
haveamptoampbeampampamp
amp FinallyampinampresponseamptoampresponseampIampcreatedampaamptextltobjectamp(Imagesamp1ampampamp2)ampthatamp
offersamponeamppossibleamparticulationamptoamptheampsurveysampandampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcaseamp
studiesampampIampwouldamplikeamptoampletampthisamponeamppossibilityampserveampasampaampmarkerampforamptheampinfiniteamp
possibilitiesampIampdidampnotampmakeampexploreampexpressamporampundergoampbutampthatampcontinueamptoampexistamp
inamptheamprealmampofampwhatltmightltbeamp
amp ThisamptextltobjectampisampakinamptoampaampmovingamppieceampofamppoetryampampToampcreateamptheamptextampIamp
collagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampfromamptheampsurveyampresponsesampinampanampeffortamptoamphonoramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 44amp
manyampvoicesampampTheamptextampisampopenampandampflowingampwithampnoampclearampbeginningamporampendampampTheamp
concealampandamprevealampaspectampofamptheampworkampcallsamptoampmindamptheampactampofampresearchampandampinquiryampinamp
generalampampTheampthickampblackampscribblesamponamptheampmovingampcirclesampareampderivedampfromamptheampfieldamp
notesampIamptookampduringampmyampexperiencesampwithampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcaseampstudiesampampTheamp
overlappingampdenseampqualityampofampthisamptextampcallsamptoampmindamptheampdensenessampofamptheseamp
experiencesampandamptheampoverwhelmingampimpossibilityampofampabsorbingampeverythingampIampcouldamp
containampamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 47amp
thread8(amp
(In)conclusions(amp
amp InamptheampwordsampofampPaulampFairfieldamp(2011)ampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinampdialogueampnoamp
interpretationampthatampisampuniquelyampandampsupremelyampauthoritativeamp(pamp83)ampampThoughampthisamp
paperampisampendingampthereampisampnoamplastampwordamponamptheampmatterampofamplisteningampforampmeampnorampforamp
studentsampteachersamphumansampworksampofampartamptextsampadampinfinitumampampThisampmyampnotltsolt
conclusiveltconcludingampsectionampstretchesamptheamppossibilityampofampmyampresearchampinampaampmanneramp
thatampdefiesamptheampsupremelyampauthoritativeampstructureampofampanampacademicampresearchamppaperampampamp
amp
Below-is-the-transcript-from-an-episode-dated-April-6-2015-of-the-popular-daytime-
talk-show-Ellen-during-which-the-artistresearcheducator-was-invited-to-discuss-her-
groundbreaking-work-on-listening-
(Camerasamprollampinamp3amp2amp1ampSceneampopensamponamptheampsetampof-EllenampampCameraamppansampinamptoampfocusamp
onampEllenampampSheampisampseatedamponampaamploveseatampwearingampaampcreamltcoloredamppantsuitampwithampaamplightamp
blueampbuttonltupampshirtampampHeramphairampisampperfectlyampcoiffedampampLightsampflashampandamptheampcrowdamp
cheersampampIntroampmusicampswells)-
EllenampDegeneresampampHelloampeveryoneampampWelcomeamptoamptheampshowamptodayampampTheampfirstamponlyampandamp
mostampimportantampguestamponamptodaysampshowampisampSamanthaampMesserampampSamanthaampisampanampartistamp
researcherampandampeducatorampbasedampinampCincinnatiampOhioampwhoseamprecentampresearchampprojectamp
onamplisteningampinampartampeducationamphasamptheamppotentialamptoampchangeamptheampfaceampofampnotamponlyampartamp
educationampbutampalsoamptheampworldampampHereampsheampisampSamanthaampMesseramp
(SamanthaampwalksamponamptheampstageamplookingampsleekampasamphellampwhileampdoingampitampampTheampaudienceamp
cheersampampSamanthaampandampEllenamphugamplikeampoldampfriends)amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 48amp
SamanthaampMesserampampHiampEllenampampItsampsoampgreatamptoampseeampyouampampamp
EDampampNoampSamanthaampitsampgreatamptoampseeampyouampampTellampusampaboutampwhatampbringsampyouamphereamptodayamp
SMampamp(Laughsampfreelyampwithoutampaampcare)ampEllenampyouampareampwhatampbroughtampmeamphereamptoday(
(Audienceamplaughs)amp
EDampampIampappreciateampthatampthankampyouampampButampletsampgetamptoampwhatsamponampAmericasampmindampampYouramp
lifesampworkampampIncredibleampampWhatampexactlyampisampitampandamphowampdidampitampcomeampaboutampampampampamp
SMampampEllenampwhereamptoampbeginampampampTheampideaampinampitsampmostampbasicampformampisampanampartampeducationampbasedamp
aroundamplisteningamppracticesamp
EDampampThatampsoundsampfascinatingampamp
SMampampIampknowampampThankampyouampforampnoticingampitsampsubtleampbrillianceamp
EDampampIampwouldampbeampaampfoolampnotamptoampampTellampusamphowampyouampcameampupampwithampthisampideaamp
SMampampampTheampcentralampcomponentampisampanampideaampcalledampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampwhichampisampaamp
spaceampinampwhichampstudentsampandampparticipantsampmakeampdiscussampandampviewampworksampofampartampwithamp
listeningampatamptheampcenterampofamptheseampactivitiesampandampexperiencesampampThisampideaampcameamptogetheramp
overamptheampcourseampofampmonthsampofampreadingamphundredsampofampdiscussionsampwithamppeersampresearchamp
participantsampandampprofessorsampasampwellampasamptheampwritingampandamprewritingampofampmanyampdraftsampofamp
myampnowampbestltsellingampbookamp
(Audienceampooooooohs)amp
EDampampWowampyouampreallyampputampsomeampthoughtampintoampthisamphuhampampSoamphowampisampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampdifferentampthanampaampregularampclassroomamp
SMampampWellampitampdependsamponamptheampclassroomampampSomeampclassroomsampprobablyampalreadyampareamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampampEssentiallyampitamprequiresampsomethingampofampanampattitudeampshiftampampItamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 49amp
doesntampevenampnecessarilyamphaveamptoampbeampinampaampclassroomamporampanyampspecificampplaceampampItsampmoreampofamp
aampstateampofampmindampandampanampattitudeamp
EDampampCouldampweampbeampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamprightampnowamp
SMampampEllenampnothingampwouldampgiveampmeampmoreamppleasureamp
(Audienceampawwwwws)amp
SMampampButampseriouslyampyesampweampcanampbeampampThoughampitampmightamptakeampmoreampthanampjustampanampattitudeamp
shiftampampWhenampIampinitiallyampbeganampthisampprojectampIampthoughtampthatsampallampitampwouldampbeampampIampassumedamp
thatampifampparticipantsampwereampwillingamptheyampcouldampenterampintoampthisampstateampofampmindampampamp
EDampampButampthatsampnotamptheampcaseamp
SMampampWellampitsampjustampthatampitsampmoreampcomplicatedampthanampthatampampWhatampIampfoundampwereampthatamptheamp
thingsampIampwasampaskingampindividualsamptoampdoampwereampnotampwithinampouramptypicalampculturalampskillampsetampamp
NotamponlyampthisampbutamptheyampareampdifficultampsubtleampandampoftenampinternalamppursuitsampampTheyampareampnotamp
easyamptoampseeampandamptheampresultsampareampnotampinstantaneousampampItsamphardamptoampknowampifampyoureampdoingamp
itamprightamp
EDampSoampwhatampdoesampitampmeanamptoampdoampitamprightamp
SMampampThatsampaampgreatampquestionampEllenampandampthankampyouampforampaskingampitampampIampdontampthinkamptheresamp
justamponeampwayampofampdoingampitamprightampampAndampevenampsometimesampwhenampyoureampdoingampitamprightampitamp
mightampnotampfeelamplikeampanythingampspecialampampItampcouldampjustampfeelamplikeampaampnormalampconversationamp
EDampampSoampthisampisampallampaboutamphavingampaampconversationampampIampdoampthatampfiveampdaysampaampweekamponampthisampsetamp
Samanthaampamp
(Audienceamplaughsamplightheartedly)amp
SMampampEllenampampYoureampcuttingampmeampdeepampamp(laughs)ampYoureamprightampampItsampnotamprevolutionaryampamp
Toamplistenamptoampbeamplistenedamptoamptoampcarryamponampanampopenampandamphonestampconversationampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 50amp
anotheramphumanampTheseampareamphumbleampgoalsampthatampweampcanampcarryampacrossampmanyampcontextsampampIamp
thinkampthereinampliesamptheampbeautyamp
EDampampInterestingampampImampgoingamptoampaskampwhatampImampsureampaamplotampofampteachersamphaveamponamptheiramp
mindsltlthowampdoampweampteachampthisamptoampstudentsamp
SMampampTheampgoalsampandampbeliefsampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmustampbeamplivedampthroughampandamp
undergoneampratherampthanampmerelyampactedampoutamponceamporamptwiceampampItsampaboutampcreatingampaampsystemamp
craftingampassignmentsampandampsettingampaamptoneampthatampallampunderlieamptheseampvaluesampampNotamponlyampthatamp
butamptheampstudentsampandampteachersampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmustampbeampreflectiveamptoamp
theirampexperiencesampampTheseampskillsampneedamptoampbeampbuiltampupampandampaampkeyampcomponentampofampthatampisamp
reflectionamponamppreviousampexperiencesamp
EDampampampIampunderstandampyouampalsoampsolicitedampsurveyampresponsesamptoampdiscussampmomentsampinampwhichamp
individualsampdidamporampdidampnotampfeelamplistenedamptoampasamptheyampspokeampaboutamptheirampartampampCanampyouamptalkamp
aamplittleampbitampaboutampwhatampyouampfoundampinamptheampsurveysamp
SMampampWellampIampcoveredampaamplotampofampthisampinampmyampbookampYoullamphaveamptoampreadampitampampIamphaveampprovidedamp
everyampmemberampofamptheampaudienceamptodayampwithampaampcopyampwhichampyoullampallampfindampunderampyouramp
seatsamp
(AudienceampgoesampwildampwithampexcitementampasamptheyampreachampunderamptheirampseatsampampThereampareamp
intermittentampscreechesampofampjoy)amp
EDampampWowampthankampyouampampTheampgiftampofamplisteningampwhatampaamptreasureampforamptheampaudienceamp
membersamptodayamp
(Audienceampclapsampwholeheartedly)amp
SMampampYoureampwelcomeampampInampgeneralampthoughampwhatampIampfoundampisampaampneedamptoamphandleamptheampwordsamp
andampexperiencesampofampothersampwithampcareampampTheampsurveysampdescribedampsituationsampinampwhichamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 51amp
individualsampfeltamptheyampwereampnotampbeingamplistenedamptoampyetamptheseampmomentsampwereampnotampusuallyamp
profoundlyamporamppurposefullyamphurtfulampampMoreampoftenamptheampsurveysampdescribedampinstancesampinamp
whichamppeopleampfeltampthatampanotheramppersonampwasntamptryingamptoampunderstandampampTheseamp
situationsampwereampmoreamppassiveampandampdismissiveampratherampthanampactivelyamphurtfulampthoughamp
theyampdidampstillamphurtamp
EDampampWellampcouldntampthatampbeampchalkedampupamptoamptheampsensitiveamppersonaampofamptheampartistampampWeampallamp
knowamphowampsensitiveampthoseampartistsampareamp
(Audienceamplaughsamptheyampareampinamponamptheampjoke)amp
SMampamp(chastising)ampEllenampyoureampsmarterampthanampthatampstereotypeampampIampmeanampyouampcouldampsayamp
thatampbutampIampdontampknowampifampthatampwouldampbeampproductiveampampAndampitampwouldntampfitampwithamptheamp
beliefsampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampinampmyampopinionampampDontampweampallampwantamptoampbeamplistenedamp
toampampIsampthatampdesireampexclusiveamptoampsomeampideaampweamphaveampinampourampheadampofampartistsampampIampdontamp
thinkampsoamp
EDampampYoureampsoamprightampSamanthaampampImampsorryampforampgivingampintoampsomeamppervasiveampmodernistamp
nonsenseampaboutampwhatampitampisamptoampbeampanampartistamp
(Audienceampnodsampinampagreement)amp
SMampampItsampokayampEllenampWeampinamptheampartampworldampareampfightingamptheampgoodampfightampWhatampweampdoampisamp
importantampandampwereamptiredampofampbeingampdismissedampbyampsocietyamp
(Audienceampclaps)amp
EDampampSoampwhatampisampyourampnextampstepamp
SMampampWellampIampwasampjustampawardedampaampspecialampmedalampofamphonorampfromampPresidentampObamaampamp
(PhotoampofampSamanthaampshakingamphandsampwithamptheampPresidentampflashesamponamptheampscreenampandamptheamp
audienceampclaps)amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 52amp
EDampampCongratulationsamp
SMampampThankampyouampampWhatampanamphonorampampAlongampwithampthisampcommendationampcameampaampgrantampforamp
meamptoampbeampableamptoamptrainampaampgroupampofamphighlyampspecializedampartistlteducatorsampinamptheseamp
practicesampandampsendampthemampoutamptoampcommunitiesampacrossamptheampcountryamptoamphelpampimplementamp
andampsupportampeffortsamptoampputampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampintoampschoolsampwhoampchooseamptoampbeamp
involvedampnationwideamp
(Aampthunderingampofampclappingampinamptheampaudience)amp
EDampampWhatampdoampyouampseeampareamptheamplonglttermampeffectsampofamptheampimplementationampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampamp
SMampampEllenampImampsureampIampdontamphaveamptoamptellampyouampthatampweampliveampinampaampfastltpacedamp
technologicallyltrevolutionaryampworldampampThereampareamppartsampofampthatampthatampareampwonderfulampandamp
makeampourampworldampanampeasierampplaceamptoampliveampampButampthereamphasamptoampbeamproomampforampusamptoampswitchampoffamp
unplugampandampslowampdownampampIampbelieveampthatamptheampplatformampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
unleashesampsomeamppossibilitiesampofamphumanampconnectionampinampaampveryamprealampauthenticampwayampamp
(Audienceamprisesampfromamptheirampseatsampwithamptearsampinamptheirampeyesampasamptheyampgiveampaampstandingamp
ovation)amp
EDampampAampnobleampgoalampindeedampampThankampyouampSamanthaampforampallampthatampyouampdoampampWhatampaampgamelt
changerampampThatsampallamptheamptimeampweamphaveampforamptodayampampItsampbeenampaamptrueamphonorampampGoodampluckampinamp
allampofampyourampendeavorsampampToampthoseampwatchingampatamphomeampgoamplistenamptoampsomeoneampamp
(SamanthaampEllenampandampaudienceampdanceampasamptheampcreditsamproll)amp
(
ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 53amp
loose(ends((References(
AndersonampEampHampampampSpencerampMampHamp(2013)ampAampPhenomenologicalampStudyampCognitiveamp
amp RepresentationsampofampAIDSampInampJampWampCreswellampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-
- Designamp(ppamp327lt346)ampLosampAngelesampSAGEampPublicationsampIncamp
BakerampGampampampMorrisampKamp(2002)ampDecartes-DualismampLondonampRoutledgeamp
BelenkyampMampFampClinchyampBampMampGoldbergerampNampRampampampTaruleampJampMamp(1997)ampWomens-Ways-
- of-Knowing-The-Development-of-Self-Voice-and-MindampNewampYorkampNYamp
amp BasicBooksamp
BleicherampJamp(1980)ampampContemporary-Hermeneutics-Hermeneutics-as-Method-
- Philosophy-and-Critique--LondonampUKampRoutledgeampampampKeeganampPaulamp
BohmampDamp(1996)ampOn-DialogueampLondonampUKampRoutledgeamp
BourgeoisampJampPamp(2007)ampThe-Aesthetic-Hermeneutics-of-Hans(Georg-Gadamer-and-Hans-
- Urs-von-BalthasarampNewampYorkampNYampPeterampLangampPublishingampIncamp
BrunsampGampLamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-Ancient-and-ModernampNewampHavenampCTampYaleamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
CalleampSamp(2011)ampBlindampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CalleampSamp(2005)ampExisquisite-PainampNewampYorkampThamesampampampHudsonamp
CalleampSamp(2008)ampTake-Care-of-YourselfampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CaputoampJamp(2000)ampMore-Radical-HermeneuticsampBloomingtonampINampIndianaampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
CreswellampJampWamp(2013)ampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-DesignampLosampAngelesampSAGEamp
amp PublicationsampIncamp
deampCossonampAamp(2002)ampTheampHermeneuticampDialogueampFindingampPatternsampamidamptheampAporiaamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 54amp
amp ofamptheampArtistResearcherTeacherampAlberta-Journal-of-Educational-Researchamp-
- 48amp(3)amp1lt20amp
ElkinsampJamp(2001)ampWhy-Art-Cannot-Be-TaughtampChicagoampILampUniversityampofampIllinoisampPressamp
FairfieldampPamp(2011)ampDialogueampinamptheampClassroomampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-
- Dialogue-and-Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp77lt90)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GadamerampHltGamp(1996)ampThe-Engima-of-HealthampStanfordampCAampStanfordampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
GadamerampHltGamp(2004)ampTruth-and-Methodamp(Secondamprevisedamped)amp(JampWeinsheimerampampamp
amp DampGampMarshallampTrans)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GallagherampSamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-and-EducationampAlbanyampNYampStateampUniversityampofamp
amp NewampYorkampPressamp
GendlinampEamp(1962)ampExperiencing-and-the-Creation-of-MeaningampNewampYorkampNYampTheamp
amp FreeampPressampofampGlencoeamp
GendlinampEamp(1997)ampampHowampPhilosophyampCannotampAppealamptoampExperienceampandampHowampItampCanamp
amp InampLanguage-beyond-Postmodernism-Saying-and-Thinking-in-Gendlins-
- Philosophy-(ppamp3lt41)ampEvanstonampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
GermeraadampGamp(2013)ampRationalityampIntuitionampandampEmotionampExploringampanampArtisticamp
amp ProcessampJournal-for-Artistic-Researchamp-3
GradleampSampAamp(2011)ampAampuniversityampcourseampinampmindfulampviewingampUnderstandingampartampandamp
amp selfampthroughampcontemplativeampexperienceampInternational-Journal-of-Education-
- Through-Artamp-7amp(2)amp137lt151amp
GreeneampMamp(2013)ampTheampTurningampofamptheampLeavesampExpandingampOurampVisionampforamptheampArtsampinamp
amp EducationampHarvard-Educational-Reviewamp-83amp(1)amp251lt252amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 55amp
GrondinampJamp(2002)ampGadamersampBasicampUnderstandingampofampUnderstandingampInampThe-
- Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp36lt51)ampCambridgeampUKampCambridgeamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
GrondinampJamp(2011)ampGadamersampExperienceampandampTheoryampofampEducationampLearningampthatamp
amp theampOtherampMayampBeampRightampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp5lt20)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
HeelanampPamp(1985)ampampPerceptionampasampaampHermeneuticalampActampampInampDampIhdeampampampHampSilvermanamp
amp (Eds)ampHermeneutics-amp-Deconstruction-(ppamp43lt54)-AlbanyampSUNYampPressamp
HeelanampPampampampSchulkinampJamp(2003)ampHermeneuticalampPhilosophyampandampPragmatismampAamp
amp PhilosophyampofampScienceampInampRampCampScharffampampampVampDusekamp(Eds)ampPhilosophy-of-
- Technology-The-Technological-Condition-an-Anthology-amp(ppamp138lt153)amp
amp MaldenampMAampBlackwellamp
KarpiakampIampEamp(2003)ampTheampListeningampHeartampTuningampInampForampTransformativeampLearningamp
amp 2003-Complexity-Science-and-Educational-Research-Conferenceamp(ppamp67lt80)amp
amp EdmontonampCanadaamp
KellyampMampPost(Partum-DocumentampInstituteampofampContemporaryampArtsampLondonamp
KentampSampJampampampCummingampJampamp(2008)ampampIampdontampknowampEngagingampwithampproblematicamp
amp momentsampinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampRadical-Pedagogy-2-(9)amp1lt20ampampamp
LevinampDampMamp(1989)ampThe-Listening-Self-Personal-Growth-Social-Change-and-the-
- Closure-of-MetaphysicsampNewampYorkampNYampRoutledgeamp
LindsethampAampampampNorbergampAamp(2004)ampAampphenomenologicalamphermeneuticalampmethodampforamp
amp researchingamplivedampexperienceampNordic-College-of-Caring-Sciencesamp-18amp145lt153amp
LipariampLamp(2014)ampampOnampinterlisteningampandamptheampideaampofampdialogueampampTheory-amp-Psychology-24-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 56amp
- (4)amp504lt523amp
MarksampLamp(2002)ampTouch-Sensuous-Theory-and-Multisensory-MediaampMinneapolisamp
amp UniversityampofampMinnesotaampPressamp
MunozampKampLamp(2014)ampTranscribing-Silence-Culture-Relationship-and-Communicationamp
amp WalnutampCreekampCAampLeftampCoastampPressamp
NicholampLamp(1996)ampForewordampInampDampBohmampOn-Dialogueamp(ppampviiltxvii)ampLondonampUKamp
amp Routledgeamp
PalmerampRamp(1969)ampHermeneutics-Interpretation-Theory-in-Schleiermacher-Dilthey-
- Heidegger-and-GadamerampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
PerlampSamp(2004)ampFelt-Sense-Writing-with-the-BodyampPortsmouthampNHampBoyntonCookamp
RicoeurampPamp(19691974)ampThe-Conflicts-of-Interpretations-Essays-in-Hermeneuticsamp
amp (NorthwesternampUniversityampPressampTrans)ampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
RicoeurampPamp(2013)ampHermeneuticsampCambridgeampUKampPolityampPressamp
SableampDamp(2014)ampReasonampinamptheampServiceampofamptheampHeartampTheampImpactsampofampContemplativeamp
amp PracticesamponampCriticalampThinkingampJournal-of-Contemplative-Inquiryamp-1amp(1)amp1lt22amp
SchultzampKamp(2010)ampAfteramptheampBlackbirdampWhistlesampListeningamptoampSilenceampinampClassroomsamp
amp Teachers-College-Recordamp-112amp(11)amp2833lt2849amp
SeebohmampTampamp(2004)ampampHermeneutics-Method-and-MethodologyampDordrechtamptheamp
amp NetherlandsampKluwerampAcademicampPublishersamp
SnowberampCamp(2005)ampTheampmentorampasampartistampaamppoeticampexplorationampofamplisteningampcreatingamp
amp andampmentoringampMentoring-and-Tutoring-13amp(3)amp345lt353amp
vanampManenampMampamp(1984)ampPracticingampPhenomenologicalampWritingampPhenomenology-+-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 57amp
- Pedagogy-2amp(1)amp36lt68amp
vanampManenampMamp(1990)ampampResearching-Lived-Experience-Human-Science-for-an-Action(
- Sensitive-PedagogyampNewampYorkampSUNYampPressamp
VitanovaampGamp(2010)ampampAuthoring-the-Dialogic-SelfampAmsterdamampJohnampBenjaminsamp
amp PublishingampCoamp
WatsonampJamp(2013)ampampKnowingampthroughamptheampfeltltsenseampaampgestureampofampopennessamptoamptheamp
amp otherampampInternational-Journal-of-Childrens-Spirituality-18amp(1)amp118lt130amp
WiercinskiampAamp(2011)ampHermeneuticampEducationamptoampUnderstandingampSelfltEducationampandamp
amp theampWillingnessamptoampRiskampFailureampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp107lt124)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
WorsleyampRamp(2012)ampNarrativesampandamplivelyampmetaphorsampHermeneuticsampasampaampwayampofamp
amp listeningampPerson(Centered-amp-Experiential-Psychotherapiesamp-11amp(4)amp304lt320amp
ZuckertampCampHamp(2002)ampHermeneuticsampinampPracticeampGadameramponampAncientampPhilosophyampInamp
amp RampJampDostalamp(Ed)ampThe-Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp201lt224)amp
amp CambridgeampUKampCambridgeampUniversityampPressamp
amp
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
- WebsitePaper-20
- WebsitePaper-18
- WebsitePaperpdf
-
- MesserFinalPaper-11
- MesserFinalPaper
-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 37amp
( Survey(themes(
amp Withinamptheamp37ampsurveysampIampuncoveredampeightampcommonampthemesamp(seeampfigamp1)ampthatamp
occurredampinampbothamppositiveampandampnegativeamplisteningampexperiencesampampTheampdiscoveryampofamptheseamp
themesampisamplikelyampinfluencedampbyampmyampownampbiasesampandampIamphaveampundoubtedlyampoverlookedamp
someampqualitiesampofamptheseampexperiencesampampTheampthemesampIamphaveampuncoveredamphoweverampareamp
richampwithampinstructiveamppotentialampforampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampampThemesampincludeamp
studentltteacherampinteractionamppeerampinteractionampfamilyampinteractionampreferenceamptoamp
critiqueampexperience(s)ampreferenceamptoampinstitutionalampexperience(s)amporampgradesampreferenceamp
toampideologyampstrongampemotionalampcharacterampandampartampasampcontinuationampofampselfampampIampcountedamp
theampthemesampasampdataamponlyampwhenamptheyampwereampexplicitlyampmentionedampinamptheamptextampampampToamp
exemplifyampthisampIampwillampprovideamptextualampevidenceampofamphowamptheampthemesampmanifestedampinamp
surveyampresponsesamp
bull StudentltteacherampinteractionampInamp7thampgradeampIampcompletedampanampartampprojectampampWhileamp
Iampwasampgoingamptoampwriteampmyampnameampatamptheampcornerampofamptheamppieceampmyampteacherampcameampupamp
behindampmeampandampsaidampWowampthatamplooksampfantasticampampIamplikeamphowampyouampusedampdifferentamp
colorsamptoampshowamptheamptextureampandampcontrastampInampthatampmomentampIampfeltampveryampproudamp
(SurveyampresponseampAFPampageamp14)amp
bull PeerampinteractionampDuringamptheampfirstampcritiqueampIampwasamptalkingamptoampaamppeerampaboutampmyamp
conceptampampWhenampIampwasampexplainingampwhatampIamphaveampinampmindampherampeyesamplitampupampampIampfeelampasamp
thoughampsheampgotampwasampIampwasamptryingamptoampsayampasampopposedamptoamphavingampitampgoampinampthroughamp
oneampearampandampoutamptheampotherampamp(SurveyampresponseampDAampageamp16)amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 38amp
bull FamilyampinteractionampWhenampIampshowampmyampmomampmyampworkampsheampdoesntampunderstandamp
theampcomplexampandampintenseampmeaningsampbehindampthemampampMyampworkampcannotampbeamp
appreciatedampproperlyampbyampherampamp(SurveyampresponseampRMampageamp17)amp
bull ReferenceamptoampcritiqueampexperiencesampAsampifampitampisampnotampunsettlingampenoughamptoamppresentamp
aampyearampofampworkamptoampfourampjudgesampwhomampyouveampneverampconnectedampwithampbeforeamptheamp
structureampofamptheampcritiqueampallowedampforamplittleamptimeamptoampdiscussamptheampworkampinampaamp
relevantampcontextampamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)amp
bull Referenceamptoampinstitutionalampexperience(s)amporampgradesampIampwasampbetterampableamptoamp
conveyampmyampartampamongstampfriendsampandampfamilyampbutampnotampinamptheampartampvernacularampandamp
rhetoricampmyampprofessorsampseemedamptoampcovetampampAtampleastampthatampwasampmyampperceptionampampItamp
wasampalsoampreflectedampinamptheampgradeampIampreceivedamponampmyampthesisamppaperampinampcomparisonamp
toamptheampgradeampreceivedamponamptheampaccompanyingampartworkampasampgivenampbyampdifferingamp
professorsamppaperampC+ampartworkampAltampampGradesamphurtampsometimesamp(Surveyamp
responseampRVTampageamp30)amp
bull Referenceamptoampideologyamp[EstablishedampartistampJoseph]ampMarioniampwasamptheampfirstamp
personampIamphadampexplainedampthisamptoampthatampactuallyampknewampEXACTLYampwhatampIampwasamptalkingamp
aboutampHeampactuallyampsaidamptoampmeampItsampinampyouramppsycheampampThisampresonatedampwithampmeampamp
IampknewamprightampthenampthatampIampwasampnoamplongerampafraidampwhenampsomeoneampaskedampmeampwhyampIamp
chooseampaampparticularampcolorampampIampchooseampcolorampbecauseampIampintuitivelyampknowampthatampcoloramp
isampgivingampsomethingamptoamptheampviewerampMarioniampunderstoodamp(Surveyampresponseamp
RWampageamp26)amp
bull StrongampemotionalampcharacterampThisamppersonampdidntampactuallyampcareampinamptheampfirstamp
placeampsoampIampfeltampthatampeverythingampIampwasampdoingampwasampworthlessampuselessampandampuglyampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 39amp
MyampartamprepresentsampmeampandampmyamppastampsoampIampfeltampworthlessampuselessampandampuglyamp
(SurveyampresponseampAVampageamp17)amp
bull ArtampasampcontinuationampofampselfampIfampIampknowampmeampandampIampcanampspeakampofampmeampthenampmaybeamp
oneampdayampeveryoneampwillampgiveampmeampandampmyampworkampwhichampisampmeampaampchanceamp(Surveyamp
responseampMESampageamp24)amp
Creative=Listening(Space(Case(Studies(
( Iampconductedampfiveampcaseampstudiesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithampsixampindividualsamp
asamppartampofampthisampresearchampdeliberatelyampchoosingamppeopleampwithampwhomampIamphadampvariousamptypesamp
ofamprelationshipsampampampTwoampofamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwereampconductedampwithamp
individualsampwithampwhomampIamphadampnoampprioramprelationshipamponeampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampwasamp
withamptheamp14ampyearltoldampdaughterampofampaampclassmateampandamptheampotherampwasampwithamptwoamp
undergraduateampfineampartampstudentsampinamptheirampfirstampyearampinamptheampUniversityampofampCincinnatisamp
DAAPampprogramampampAnotheramptwoampwereampconductedampwithamphighampschoolltagedampstudentsampIamp
teachampinampanampafterltschoolampartampprogramampampTheampfinalampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampconductedamp
wasampwithampanampundergraduateampartampstudentampwithampwhomampIamphaveampsharedampseveralampclassesampampamp
amp Theampbasicampstructureampofamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampexperiencesampwasampfairlyamp
consistentampthroughoutampthisampprocessampampIampprovidedampparticipantsampwithamptwoamphandoutsamp(seeamp
figamp2ampandamp3)ampampTheampfirstamphandoutampdescribedamptheamppromptampandampbeliefsampofampaampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampampWeampcompletedamptheamppromptamponamptheampbackampofampthisamphandoutampampTheampsecondamp
handoutampoutlinedampwaysampofamplisteningampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampandampwasampusedampforamp
participantsamptoampevaluateamptheampexperienceampampAllampparticipantsampincludingampmyselfamp
interactedampwithamptheseamphandoutsampbyampreadingampthemamp(oftenampaloud)ampandampfillingampthemampoutampatamp
differentamptimesampduringamptheampexperienceampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 40amp
amp Iampbeganamptheampsessionsampbyampinformingamptheampparticipantampthatampbothampofampusampwereampinampaamp
creativeltlisteningampspaceampandampthenampIampbrieflyampdescribedampwhatampthatampmeantampampThisampstepampsetamp
theamptoneampforamptheampencounterampampThenamptheampparticipantampandampIampreadamptheampBeliefsampinampaamp
CreativeltListeningampSpaceampsectionamp(figamp2)ampampIampaskedampifamptheampparticipantamphadampanyamp
questionsamporampcommentsampaboutamptheseamppracticesampampThenampIampshowedamptheampparticipantamptheamp
nextamphandoutamp(figamp3)ampampWeampeachampfilledampoutamptheamphandoutampwritingampourampnamesampinamptheamp
appropriateampspacesampampWeampreadampoveramptheamplistampofampactivitiesamponamptheampleftampsideampofamptheamppaperampampIamp
askedampparticipantsamptoampchooseamponeampqualityamptoampfocusamponampandampweampsharedampwhatamptheampfocusamp
wouldampbeampforampeachampofampusampandampwhyampampThenampIampintroducedamptheamppromptampaampselfltportraitampinamp
threeampminutesampampThisampselfltportraitampwasampcompletelyampopenltendedampinamptermsampofampstyleamp
techniqueampandampsubjectampmatterampampTheampmainampqualificationsampwereampthatampitampfeltamp
representativeampofamptheampartistampinampthatampmomentampampAfterampweamphadampspentampthreeampminutesamponamp
ourampselfampportraitsampweamptalkedampaboutampwhatampweampdrewampandampwhyampampIampgaveampparticipantsamptheamp
opportunityamptoampcontinueamptoampdrawampasampweampspokeampampampWhenampIampfeltampthatamptheampsessionampwasamp
drawingamptoampaampnaturalampcloseampeachampofampusampfilledampoutamptheampevaluationamphandoutamp(figamp3)ampbyamp
circlingampwhatampweampfeltampweamphadampexperiencedampduringamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampamp
amp
thread7(
Responding(to(Response(Layers(of(Listening(Understandingamp
amp Theampamountampofampdataamptheampexperiencesampandamptheampknowledgeampaccruedampoveramptheamp
courseampofampthisampprojectamphasampbeenamptoampsayamptheampleastampoverwhelmingampandamphumblingampamp
WritingampaamppassageampinampresponseamphasampbeenampaampsignificantampchallengeltlthowampshouldampIampdoamp
justiceamptoamptheampindividualsampwhoampsharedamptheirampstoriesampampWhatampisamptheampappropriateampmediumamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 41amp
forampsuchampaampventureampampHowampdoampIampsumampupampwhatampIamphaveamplearnedampfromampthemampandampfromamptheamp
experiencesampgeneratedampwithinampthisampresearchamp
amp InampanampattemptamptoampansweramporampsimplyampliveampinamptheseampquestionsampIampwouldampfirstamplikeamptoamp
discussamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampWhenamptaskedampwithampdescribingampsituationsampofampbeingamp
listenedamptoamporampnotampsurveyampparticipantsamphadampaamplotamptoampsayampampRarelyampdidampindividualsampgiveamp
oneltwordamporampevenamponeltsentenceampanswersampampNearlyampeveryoneamphadampexperiencesamptheyamp
wantedamptoampshareampandamptheseampexperiencesampwereampoftenampdescribedampusingamplanguageampthatamp
carriedampwithampitamptheampweightampofampemotionampandampvulnerabilityampampSomeampofamptheseampresponsesamp
continueamptoampstickamptoampmeampampMyampunderstandingampofampotherampresponsesampevolvedampoveramptheamp
courseampofampmyampinteractionsampwithampthemampampamp
amp Inampgeneralamptheampnegativeamplisteningampsituationsampdescribedampwereampnotampusuallyamp
purposefullyamphurtfulampampMoreampoftenampparticipantsampdescribedampfeelingampdismissedampampThisamp
sometimesampdidntampevenamptranslateampintoampwritingampampParticipantsampwroteampaboutampsituationsampinamp
whichamptheamplanguageampofamptheampencounterampdidntampalwaysampmatchamptheampemotionampfeltampampForamp
exampleamponeampsurveyampparticipantampdescribedampanampexperienceampinampwhichampaampfamilyampmemberamp
saidampWowampIampneverampthoughtampwouldveampthoughtamptoampmakeampaampportraitampthatampwayamp(Surveyamp
responseampLSampageamp27)ampampInampexamplesamplikeampthisampnegativeampinteractionsampwereampfeltampratheramp
thanamparticulatedampdirectlyampampTheseampmomentsampwereampbasedamparoundampintonationampemphasisamp
andamppresumedampsubtextampratherampthanampexplicitamporampdeliberateampwordampchoiceampampamp
amp IampamampundoubtedlyampmakingampsomeampassumptionsampasampIampsayampthisampbutamptheampsurveyamp
responsesampindicatedampthatampitsampeasyamptoampbeampunintentionallyamphurtfulampampItsampmuchampharderamptoamp
handleamptheampwordsampandampcreativeampworkampofampanotherampwithampcareampampInampfactampthisamptakesampconstantamp
questioningampandampreflectionampampTheamppositiveampresponsesampusuallyampindicatedampaampsenseampofamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 42amp
connectionamprestraintampandampgenuineampinterestampampSomeampdescribedampsilenceampasampaampkeyamp
componentampofamplisteningampandampothersampdiscussedamptheampsituationsampinampwhichamptheamplisteneramp
asksampquestionsamporampmake[s]ampcommentsampthatampallowampyouamptoampfeelampjustifiedampinampwhatampyouveamp
saidamp(SurveyampresponseampCHampageamp47)ampampStillampothersampreferredamptoamptheamppowerampofamp
interpretationampandamptheampintentampofamptheampartistampasampaampguideampforampknowingampthatamponesampworkamp
wasampunderstoodamp
amp Asampforamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcaseampstudiesampthisampideaampandamptheampexperiencesamp
thatampbroughtampitamptoampfruitionampareampstillampinamptheirampinfancyampampThisampresearchampprojectampgaveampmeamptheamp
firstampstepsampintoamptheamppossibilitiesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampandampIamplookampforwardamptoamp
understandingampmoreampaboutamphowampitampwouldamplookamptoampimplementampthisampframeworkampintoampaamp
classroomamporampstudioampcontextampampInitiallyampIampthoughtampthatampIampcouldampjustampaskampparticipantsamptoamp
enterampintoampaampstateampofampmindampthatampwouldampbeampconduciveamptoampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampIamp
assumedampthatampitampwasampmoreamplikeampaampshiftampinampattitudeampthanampaamplearnedampbehaviorampampButampIampwasamp
wrongltlttheampshiftampinampattitudeampcomesampfromampgradualamplearningampoveramptimeampampToampachieveampthisamp
thereampneedsamptoampbeampaampsystemampofampscaffoldingampinampplaceampampThisampscaffoldingampcanampincludeamp
specificampwaysampofampinteractingampinampclassroomsampstudiosampandampviewingampspacesampassignmentsamp
andampprojectsampcenteredamparoundampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampexperiencesampinvestigationampofamp
collageampjournalampwritingampexercisesampinamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampsustainedamp
engagementsampinampviewingampworksampofampartampteacherampmodelingampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
behaviorsampandampsoamponampampThisamprealizationampcameamptooamplateampinamptheampresearchamptoampfullyampengageamp
withamppossibleampsolutionsampbutampIamplookampforwardamptoampdevelopingamptheseampoveramptheampcourseampofamp
myampcareeramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 43amp
amp Theamprealizationampthatampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamprequireampmoreampthanampjustampanamp
attitudeampshiftampcameampfromampanotheramponeampofamptheampbiggestampoutcomesampofampthisampresearchampampTheamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampIampenactedamphadampsomethingampofampaampdominoampeffectamponampmyamppracticesamp
withinampthemampampTheampmostampimportantampaspectampofampenactingampthemampwasampbeingampreflexiveamptoamp
whatamphappenedampwithinampthemampampIampwasampconstantlyampaskingampmyselfampwhatampwasampworkingamp
whatampneededamptoampchangeampandampwhatampcouldampmakeampitampbetterampampIampreflectedamponampmyampownampstateamp
ofampmindampandamphowampthatampinformedampmyampexperiencesampandamptheampexperiencesampofampanotherampampIamp
reflectedamponampmyampassumptionsampampIampthoughtampthatampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmightamphaveampaamp
certainampkindampofampfeelingampaamptransformativeampclickampthatampwouldampletampmeampknowampitampwasamp
workingampampButampitsampnotampthatampsimpleampampAampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampmanifestampitselfampinamp
soampmanyampwaysampthatampitsampimpossibleamptoampidentifyampthemampallampampItampcouldampfeelamplikeampaampregularamp
conversationamporampcritiqueampitampcouldampfeelampuncomfortableamporampeasyampampItampcouldamphaveampaampuniqueamp
asltyetltunknownampqualityampampLikeampaampworkampofampartampitampcouldamptakeamponampanyampnumberampofampformsamp
andamppossibilitiesampMyampassumptionampthatampitampwouldamptakeamponamponeampeasylttoltrecognizeamp
manifestationampwasampnotampasampnuancedampasampthisampresearchampindicatesamptheamppossibilitiesampwouldamp
haveamptoampbeampampamp
amp FinallyampinampresponseamptoampresponseampIampcreatedampaamptextltobjectamp(Imagesamp1ampampamp2)ampthatamp
offersamponeamppossibleamparticulationamptoamptheampsurveysampandampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcaseamp
studiesampampIampwouldamplikeamptoampletampthisamponeamppossibilityampserveampasampaampmarkerampforamptheampinfiniteamp
possibilitiesampIampdidampnotampmakeampexploreampexpressamporampundergoampbutampthatampcontinueamptoampexistamp
inamptheamprealmampofampwhatltmightltbeamp
amp ThisamptextltobjectampisampakinamptoampaampmovingamppieceampofamppoetryampampToampcreateamptheamptextampIamp
collagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampfromamptheampsurveyampresponsesampinampanampeffortamptoamphonoramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 44amp
manyampvoicesampampTheamptextampisampopenampandampflowingampwithampnoampclearampbeginningamporampendampampTheamp
concealampandamprevealampaspectampofamptheampworkampcallsamptoampmindamptheampactampofampresearchampandampinquiryampinamp
generalampampTheampthickampblackampscribblesamponamptheampmovingampcirclesampareampderivedampfromamptheampfieldamp
notesampIamptookampduringampmyampexperiencesampwithampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcaseampstudiesampampTheamp
overlappingampdenseampqualityampofampthisamptextampcallsamptoampmindamptheampdensenessampofamptheseamp
experiencesampandamptheampoverwhelmingampimpossibilityampofampabsorbingampeverythingampIampcouldamp
containampamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 47amp
thread8(amp
(In)conclusions(amp
amp InamptheampwordsampofampPaulampFairfieldamp(2011)ampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinampdialogueampnoamp
interpretationampthatampisampuniquelyampandampsupremelyampauthoritativeamp(pamp83)ampampThoughampthisamp
paperampisampendingampthereampisampnoamplastampwordamponamptheampmatterampofamplisteningampforampmeampnorampforamp
studentsampteachersamphumansampworksampofampartamptextsampadampinfinitumampampThisampmyampnotltsolt
conclusiveltconcludingampsectionampstretchesamptheamppossibilityampofampmyampresearchampinampaampmanneramp
thatampdefiesamptheampsupremelyampauthoritativeampstructureampofampanampacademicampresearchamppaperampampamp
amp
Below-is-the-transcript-from-an-episode-dated-April-6-2015-of-the-popular-daytime-
talk-show-Ellen-during-which-the-artistresearcheducator-was-invited-to-discuss-her-
groundbreaking-work-on-listening-
(Camerasamprollampinamp3amp2amp1ampSceneampopensamponamptheampsetampof-EllenampampCameraamppansampinamptoampfocusamp
onampEllenampampSheampisampseatedamponampaamploveseatampwearingampaampcreamltcoloredamppantsuitampwithampaamplightamp
blueampbuttonltupampshirtampampHeramphairampisampperfectlyampcoiffedampampLightsampflashampandamptheampcrowdamp
cheersampampIntroampmusicampswells)-
EllenampDegeneresampampHelloampeveryoneampampWelcomeamptoamptheampshowamptodayampampTheampfirstamponlyampandamp
mostampimportantampguestamponamptodaysampshowampisampSamanthaampMesserampampSamanthaampisampanampartistamp
researcherampandampeducatorampbasedampinampCincinnatiampOhioampwhoseamprecentampresearchampprojectamp
onamplisteningampinampartampeducationamphasamptheamppotentialamptoampchangeamptheampfaceampofampnotamponlyampartamp
educationampbutampalsoamptheampworldampampHereampsheampisampSamanthaampMesseramp
(SamanthaampwalksamponamptheampstageamplookingampsleekampasamphellampwhileampdoingampitampampTheampaudienceamp
cheersampampSamanthaampandampEllenamphugamplikeampoldampfriends)amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 48amp
SamanthaampMesserampampHiampEllenampampItsampsoampgreatamptoampseeampyouampampamp
EDampampNoampSamanthaampitsampgreatamptoampseeampyouampampTellampusampaboutampwhatampbringsampyouamphereamptodayamp
SMampamp(Laughsampfreelyampwithoutampaampcare)ampEllenampyouampareampwhatampbroughtampmeamphereamptoday(
(Audienceamplaughs)amp
EDampampIampappreciateampthatampthankampyouampampButampletsampgetamptoampwhatsamponampAmericasampmindampampYouramp
lifesampworkampampIncredibleampampWhatampexactlyampisampitampandamphowampdidampitampcomeampaboutampampampampamp
SMampampEllenampwhereamptoampbeginampampampTheampideaampinampitsampmostampbasicampformampisampanampartampeducationampbasedamp
aroundamplisteningamppracticesamp
EDampampThatampsoundsampfascinatingampamp
SMampampIampknowampampThankampyouampforampnoticingampitsampsubtleampbrillianceamp
EDampampIampwouldampbeampaampfoolampnotamptoampampTellampusamphowampyouampcameampupampwithampthisampideaamp
SMampampampTheampcentralampcomponentampisampanampideaampcalledampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampwhichampisampaamp
spaceampinampwhichampstudentsampandampparticipantsampmakeampdiscussampandampviewampworksampofampartampwithamp
listeningampatamptheampcenterampofamptheseampactivitiesampandampexperiencesampampThisampideaampcameamptogetheramp
overamptheampcourseampofampmonthsampofampreadingamphundredsampofampdiscussionsampwithamppeersampresearchamp
participantsampandampprofessorsampasampwellampasamptheampwritingampandamprewritingampofampmanyampdraftsampofamp
myampnowampbestltsellingampbookamp
(Audienceampooooooohs)amp
EDampampWowampyouampreallyampputampsomeampthoughtampintoampthisamphuhampampSoamphowampisampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampdifferentampthanampaampregularampclassroomamp
SMampampWellampitampdependsamponamptheampclassroomampampSomeampclassroomsampprobablyampalreadyampareamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampampEssentiallyampitamprequiresampsomethingampofampanampattitudeampshiftampampItamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 49amp
doesntampevenampnecessarilyamphaveamptoampbeampinampaampclassroomamporampanyampspecificampplaceampampItsampmoreampofamp
aampstateampofampmindampandampanampattitudeamp
EDampampCouldampweampbeampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamprightampnowamp
SMampampEllenampnothingampwouldampgiveampmeampmoreamppleasureamp
(Audienceampawwwwws)amp
SMampampButampseriouslyampyesampweampcanampbeampampThoughampitampmightamptakeampmoreampthanampjustampanampattitudeamp
shiftampampWhenampIampinitiallyampbeganampthisampprojectampIampthoughtampthatsampallampitampwouldampbeampampIampassumedamp
thatampifampparticipantsampwereampwillingamptheyampcouldampenterampintoampthisampstateampofampmindampampamp
EDampampButampthatsampnotamptheampcaseamp
SMampampWellampitsampjustampthatampitsampmoreampcomplicatedampthanampthatampampWhatampIampfoundampwereampthatamptheamp
thingsampIampwasampaskingampindividualsamptoampdoampwereampnotampwithinampouramptypicalampculturalampskillampsetampamp
NotamponlyampthisampbutamptheyampareampdifficultampsubtleampandampoftenampinternalamppursuitsampampTheyampareampnotamp
easyamptoampseeampandamptheampresultsampareampnotampinstantaneousampampItsamphardamptoampknowampifampyoureampdoingamp
itamprightamp
EDampSoampwhatampdoesampitampmeanamptoampdoampitamprightamp
SMampampThatsampaampgreatampquestionampEllenampandampthankampyouampforampaskingampitampampIampdontampthinkamptheresamp
justamponeampwayampofampdoingampitamprightampampAndampevenampsometimesampwhenampyoureampdoingampitamprightampitamp
mightampnotampfeelamplikeampanythingampspecialampampItampcouldampjustampfeelamplikeampaampnormalampconversationamp
EDampampSoampthisampisampallampaboutamphavingampaampconversationampampIampdoampthatampfiveampdaysampaampweekamponampthisampsetamp
Samanthaampamp
(Audienceamplaughsamplightheartedly)amp
SMampampEllenampampYoureampcuttingampmeampdeepampamp(laughs)ampYoureamprightampampItsampnotamprevolutionaryampamp
Toamplistenamptoampbeamplistenedamptoamptoampcarryamponampanampopenampandamphonestampconversationampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 50amp
anotheramphumanampTheseampareamphumbleampgoalsampthatampweampcanampcarryampacrossampmanyampcontextsampampIamp
thinkampthereinampliesamptheampbeautyamp
EDampampInterestingampampImampgoingamptoampaskampwhatampImampsureampaamplotampofampteachersamphaveamponamptheiramp
mindsltlthowampdoampweampteachampthisamptoampstudentsamp
SMampampTheampgoalsampandampbeliefsampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmustampbeamplivedampthroughampandamp
undergoneampratherampthanampmerelyampactedampoutamponceamporamptwiceampampItsampaboutampcreatingampaampsystemamp
craftingampassignmentsampandampsettingampaamptoneampthatampallampunderlieamptheseampvaluesampampNotamponlyampthatamp
butamptheampstudentsampandampteachersampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmustampbeampreflectiveamptoamp
theirampexperiencesampampTheseampskillsampneedamptoampbeampbuiltampupampandampaampkeyampcomponentampofampthatampisamp
reflectionamponamppreviousampexperiencesamp
EDampampampIampunderstandampyouampalsoampsolicitedampsurveyampresponsesamptoampdiscussampmomentsampinampwhichamp
individualsampdidamporampdidampnotampfeelamplistenedamptoampasamptheyampspokeampaboutamptheirampartampampCanampyouamptalkamp
aamplittleampbitampaboutampwhatampyouampfoundampinamptheampsurveysamp
SMampampWellampIampcoveredampaamplotampofampthisampinampmyampbookampYoullamphaveamptoampreadampitampampIamphaveampprovidedamp
everyampmemberampofamptheampaudienceamptodayampwithampaampcopyampwhichampyoullampallampfindampunderampyouramp
seatsamp
(AudienceampgoesampwildampwithampexcitementampasamptheyampreachampunderamptheirampseatsampampThereampareamp
intermittentampscreechesampofampjoy)amp
EDampampWowampthankampyouampampTheampgiftampofamplisteningampwhatampaamptreasureampforamptheampaudienceamp
membersamptodayamp
(Audienceampclapsampwholeheartedly)amp
SMampampYoureampwelcomeampampInampgeneralampthoughampwhatampIampfoundampisampaampneedamptoamphandleamptheampwordsamp
andampexperiencesampofampothersampwithampcareampampTheampsurveysampdescribedampsituationsampinampwhichamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 51amp
individualsampfeltamptheyampwereampnotampbeingamplistenedamptoampyetamptheseampmomentsampwereampnotampusuallyamp
profoundlyamporamppurposefullyamphurtfulampampMoreampoftenamptheampsurveysampdescribedampinstancesampinamp
whichamppeopleampfeltampthatampanotheramppersonampwasntamptryingamptoampunderstandampampTheseamp
situationsampwereampmoreamppassiveampandampdismissiveampratherampthanampactivelyamphurtfulampthoughamp
theyampdidampstillamphurtamp
EDampampWellampcouldntampthatampbeampchalkedampupamptoamptheampsensitiveamppersonaampofamptheampartistampampWeampallamp
knowamphowampsensitiveampthoseampartistsampareamp
(Audienceamplaughsamptheyampareampinamponamptheampjoke)amp
SMampamp(chastising)ampEllenampyoureampsmarterampthanampthatampstereotypeampampIampmeanampyouampcouldampsayamp
thatampbutampIampdontampknowampifampthatampwouldampbeampproductiveampampAndampitampwouldntampfitampwithamptheamp
beliefsampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampinampmyampopinionampampDontampweampallampwantamptoampbeamplistenedamp
toampampIsampthatampdesireampexclusiveamptoampsomeampideaampweamphaveampinampourampheadampofampartistsampampIampdontamp
thinkampsoamp
EDampampYoureampsoamprightampSamanthaampampImampsorryampforampgivingampintoampsomeamppervasiveampmodernistamp
nonsenseampaboutampwhatampitampisamptoampbeampanampartistamp
(Audienceampnodsampinampagreement)amp
SMampampItsampokayampEllenampWeampinamptheampartampworldampareampfightingamptheampgoodampfightampWhatampweampdoampisamp
importantampandampwereamptiredampofampbeingampdismissedampbyampsocietyamp
(Audienceampclaps)amp
EDampampSoampwhatampisampyourampnextampstepamp
SMampampWellampIampwasampjustampawardedampaampspecialampmedalampofamphonorampfromampPresidentampObamaampamp
(PhotoampofampSamanthaampshakingamphandsampwithamptheampPresidentampflashesamponamptheampscreenampandamptheamp
audienceampclaps)amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 52amp
EDampampCongratulationsamp
SMampampThankampyouampampWhatampanamphonorampampAlongampwithampthisampcommendationampcameampaampgrantampforamp
meamptoampbeampableamptoamptrainampaampgroupampofamphighlyampspecializedampartistlteducatorsampinamptheseamp
practicesampandampsendampthemampoutamptoampcommunitiesampacrossamptheampcountryamptoamphelpampimplementamp
andampsupportampeffortsamptoampputampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampintoampschoolsampwhoampchooseamptoampbeamp
involvedampnationwideamp
(Aampthunderingampofampclappingampinamptheampaudience)amp
EDampampWhatampdoampyouampseeampareamptheamplonglttermampeffectsampofamptheampimplementationampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampamp
SMampampEllenampImampsureampIampdontamphaveamptoamptellampyouampthatampweampliveampinampaampfastltpacedamp
technologicallyltrevolutionaryampworldampampThereampareamppartsampofampthatampthatampareampwonderfulampandamp
makeampourampworldampanampeasierampplaceamptoampliveampampButampthereamphasamptoampbeamproomampforampusamptoampswitchampoffamp
unplugampandampslowampdownampampIampbelieveampthatamptheampplatformampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
unleashesampsomeamppossibilitiesampofamphumanampconnectionampinampaampveryamprealampauthenticampwayampamp
(Audienceamprisesampfromamptheirampseatsampwithamptearsampinamptheirampeyesampasamptheyampgiveampaampstandingamp
ovation)amp
EDampampAampnobleampgoalampindeedampampThankampyouampSamanthaampforampallampthatampyouampdoampampWhatampaampgamelt
changerampampThatsampallamptheamptimeampweamphaveampforamptodayampampItsampbeenampaamptrueamphonorampampGoodampluckampinamp
allampofampyourampendeavorsampampToampthoseampwatchingampatamphomeampgoamplistenamptoampsomeoneampamp
(SamanthaampEllenampandampaudienceampdanceampasamptheampcreditsamproll)amp
(
ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 53amp
loose(ends((References(
AndersonampEampHampampampSpencerampMampHamp(2013)ampAampPhenomenologicalampStudyampCognitiveamp
amp RepresentationsampofampAIDSampInampJampWampCreswellampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-
- Designamp(ppamp327lt346)ampLosampAngelesampSAGEampPublicationsampIncamp
BakerampGampampampMorrisampKamp(2002)ampDecartes-DualismampLondonampRoutledgeamp
BelenkyampMampFampClinchyampBampMampGoldbergerampNampRampampampTaruleampJampMamp(1997)ampWomens-Ways-
- of-Knowing-The-Development-of-Self-Voice-and-MindampNewampYorkampNYamp
amp BasicBooksamp
BleicherampJamp(1980)ampampContemporary-Hermeneutics-Hermeneutics-as-Method-
- Philosophy-and-Critique--LondonampUKampRoutledgeampampampKeeganampPaulamp
BohmampDamp(1996)ampOn-DialogueampLondonampUKampRoutledgeamp
BourgeoisampJampPamp(2007)ampThe-Aesthetic-Hermeneutics-of-Hans(Georg-Gadamer-and-Hans-
- Urs-von-BalthasarampNewampYorkampNYampPeterampLangampPublishingampIncamp
BrunsampGampLamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-Ancient-and-ModernampNewampHavenampCTampYaleamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
CalleampSamp(2011)ampBlindampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CalleampSamp(2005)ampExisquisite-PainampNewampYorkampThamesampampampHudsonamp
CalleampSamp(2008)ampTake-Care-of-YourselfampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CaputoampJamp(2000)ampMore-Radical-HermeneuticsampBloomingtonampINampIndianaampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
CreswellampJampWamp(2013)ampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-DesignampLosampAngelesampSAGEamp
amp PublicationsampIncamp
deampCossonampAamp(2002)ampTheampHermeneuticampDialogueampFindingampPatternsampamidamptheampAporiaamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 54amp
amp ofamptheampArtistResearcherTeacherampAlberta-Journal-of-Educational-Researchamp-
- 48amp(3)amp1lt20amp
ElkinsampJamp(2001)ampWhy-Art-Cannot-Be-TaughtampChicagoampILampUniversityampofampIllinoisampPressamp
FairfieldampPamp(2011)ampDialogueampinamptheampClassroomampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-
- Dialogue-and-Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp77lt90)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GadamerampHltGamp(1996)ampThe-Engima-of-HealthampStanfordampCAampStanfordampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
GadamerampHltGamp(2004)ampTruth-and-Methodamp(Secondamprevisedamped)amp(JampWeinsheimerampampamp
amp DampGampMarshallampTrans)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GallagherampSamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-and-EducationampAlbanyampNYampStateampUniversityampofamp
amp NewampYorkampPressamp
GendlinampEamp(1962)ampExperiencing-and-the-Creation-of-MeaningampNewampYorkampNYampTheamp
amp FreeampPressampofampGlencoeamp
GendlinampEamp(1997)ampampHowampPhilosophyampCannotampAppealamptoampExperienceampandampHowampItampCanamp
amp InampLanguage-beyond-Postmodernism-Saying-and-Thinking-in-Gendlins-
- Philosophy-(ppamp3lt41)ampEvanstonampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
GermeraadampGamp(2013)ampRationalityampIntuitionampandampEmotionampExploringampanampArtisticamp
amp ProcessampJournal-for-Artistic-Researchamp-3
GradleampSampAamp(2011)ampAampuniversityampcourseampinampmindfulampviewingampUnderstandingampartampandamp
amp selfampthroughampcontemplativeampexperienceampInternational-Journal-of-Education-
- Through-Artamp-7amp(2)amp137lt151amp
GreeneampMamp(2013)ampTheampTurningampofamptheampLeavesampExpandingampOurampVisionampforamptheampArtsampinamp
amp EducationampHarvard-Educational-Reviewamp-83amp(1)amp251lt252amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 55amp
GrondinampJamp(2002)ampGadamersampBasicampUnderstandingampofampUnderstandingampInampThe-
- Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp36lt51)ampCambridgeampUKampCambridgeamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
GrondinampJamp(2011)ampGadamersampExperienceampandampTheoryampofampEducationampLearningampthatamp
amp theampOtherampMayampBeampRightampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp5lt20)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
HeelanampPamp(1985)ampampPerceptionampasampaampHermeneuticalampActampampInampDampIhdeampampampHampSilvermanamp
amp (Eds)ampHermeneutics-amp-Deconstruction-(ppamp43lt54)-AlbanyampSUNYampPressamp
HeelanampPampampampSchulkinampJamp(2003)ampHermeneuticalampPhilosophyampandampPragmatismampAamp
amp PhilosophyampofampScienceampInampRampCampScharffampampampVampDusekamp(Eds)ampPhilosophy-of-
- Technology-The-Technological-Condition-an-Anthology-amp(ppamp138lt153)amp
amp MaldenampMAampBlackwellamp
KarpiakampIampEamp(2003)ampTheampListeningampHeartampTuningampInampForampTransformativeampLearningamp
amp 2003-Complexity-Science-and-Educational-Research-Conferenceamp(ppamp67lt80)amp
amp EdmontonampCanadaamp
KellyampMampPost(Partum-DocumentampInstituteampofampContemporaryampArtsampLondonamp
KentampSampJampampampCummingampJampamp(2008)ampampIampdontampknowampEngagingampwithampproblematicamp
amp momentsampinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampRadical-Pedagogy-2-(9)amp1lt20ampampamp
LevinampDampMamp(1989)ampThe-Listening-Self-Personal-Growth-Social-Change-and-the-
- Closure-of-MetaphysicsampNewampYorkampNYampRoutledgeamp
LindsethampAampampampNorbergampAamp(2004)ampAampphenomenologicalamphermeneuticalampmethodampforamp
amp researchingamplivedampexperienceampNordic-College-of-Caring-Sciencesamp-18amp145lt153amp
LipariampLamp(2014)ampampOnampinterlisteningampandamptheampideaampofampdialogueampampTheory-amp-Psychology-24-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 56amp
- (4)amp504lt523amp
MarksampLamp(2002)ampTouch-Sensuous-Theory-and-Multisensory-MediaampMinneapolisamp
amp UniversityampofampMinnesotaampPressamp
MunozampKampLamp(2014)ampTranscribing-Silence-Culture-Relationship-and-Communicationamp
amp WalnutampCreekampCAampLeftampCoastampPressamp
NicholampLamp(1996)ampForewordampInampDampBohmampOn-Dialogueamp(ppampviiltxvii)ampLondonampUKamp
amp Routledgeamp
PalmerampRamp(1969)ampHermeneutics-Interpretation-Theory-in-Schleiermacher-Dilthey-
- Heidegger-and-GadamerampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
PerlampSamp(2004)ampFelt-Sense-Writing-with-the-BodyampPortsmouthampNHampBoyntonCookamp
RicoeurampPamp(19691974)ampThe-Conflicts-of-Interpretations-Essays-in-Hermeneuticsamp
amp (NorthwesternampUniversityampPressampTrans)ampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
RicoeurampPamp(2013)ampHermeneuticsampCambridgeampUKampPolityampPressamp
SableampDamp(2014)ampReasonampinamptheampServiceampofamptheampHeartampTheampImpactsampofampContemplativeamp
amp PracticesamponampCriticalampThinkingampJournal-of-Contemplative-Inquiryamp-1amp(1)amp1lt22amp
SchultzampKamp(2010)ampAfteramptheampBlackbirdampWhistlesampListeningamptoampSilenceampinampClassroomsamp
amp Teachers-College-Recordamp-112amp(11)amp2833lt2849amp
SeebohmampTampamp(2004)ampampHermeneutics-Method-and-MethodologyampDordrechtamptheamp
amp NetherlandsampKluwerampAcademicampPublishersamp
SnowberampCamp(2005)ampTheampmentorampasampartistampaamppoeticampexplorationampofamplisteningampcreatingamp
amp andampmentoringampMentoring-and-Tutoring-13amp(3)amp345lt353amp
vanampManenampMampamp(1984)ampPracticingampPhenomenologicalampWritingampPhenomenology-+-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 57amp
- Pedagogy-2amp(1)amp36lt68amp
vanampManenampMamp(1990)ampampResearching-Lived-Experience-Human-Science-for-an-Action(
- Sensitive-PedagogyampNewampYorkampSUNYampPressamp
VitanovaampGamp(2010)ampampAuthoring-the-Dialogic-SelfampAmsterdamampJohnampBenjaminsamp
amp PublishingampCoamp
WatsonampJamp(2013)ampampKnowingampthroughamptheampfeltltsenseampaampgestureampofampopennessamptoamptheamp
amp otherampampInternational-Journal-of-Childrens-Spirituality-18amp(1)amp118lt130amp
WiercinskiampAamp(2011)ampHermeneuticampEducationamptoampUnderstandingampSelfltEducationampandamp
amp theampWillingnessamptoampRiskampFailureampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp107lt124)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
WorsleyampRamp(2012)ampNarrativesampandamplivelyampmetaphorsampHermeneuticsampasampaampwayampofamp
amp listeningampPerson(Centered-amp-Experiential-Psychotherapiesamp-11amp(4)amp304lt320amp
ZuckertampCampHamp(2002)ampHermeneuticsampinampPracticeampGadameramponampAncientampPhilosophyampInamp
amp RampJampDostalamp(Ed)ampThe-Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp201lt224)amp
amp CambridgeampUKampCambridgeampUniversityampPressamp
amp
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
- WebsitePaper-20
- WebsitePaper-18
- WebsitePaperpdf
-
- MesserFinalPaper-11
- MesserFinalPaper
-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 38amp
bull FamilyampinteractionampWhenampIampshowampmyampmomampmyampworkampsheampdoesntampunderstandamp
theampcomplexampandampintenseampmeaningsampbehindampthemampampMyampworkampcannotampbeamp
appreciatedampproperlyampbyampherampamp(SurveyampresponseampRMampageamp17)amp
bull ReferenceamptoampcritiqueampexperiencesampAsampifampitampisampnotampunsettlingampenoughamptoamppresentamp
aampyearampofampworkamptoampfourampjudgesampwhomampyouveampneverampconnectedampwithampbeforeamptheamp
structureampofamptheampcritiqueampallowedampforamplittleamptimeamptoampdiscussamptheampworkampinampaamp
relevantampcontextampamp(SurveyampresponseampMWampageamp22)amp
bull Referenceamptoampinstitutionalampexperience(s)amporampgradesampIampwasampbetterampableamptoamp
conveyampmyampartampamongstampfriendsampandampfamilyampbutampnotampinamptheampartampvernacularampandamp
rhetoricampmyampprofessorsampseemedamptoampcovetampampAtampleastampthatampwasampmyampperceptionampampItamp
wasampalsoampreflectedampinamptheampgradeampIampreceivedamponampmyampthesisamppaperampinampcomparisonamp
toamptheampgradeampreceivedamponamptheampaccompanyingampartworkampasampgivenampbyampdifferingamp
professorsamppaperampC+ampartworkampAltampampGradesamphurtampsometimesamp(Surveyamp
responseampRVTampageamp30)amp
bull Referenceamptoampideologyamp[EstablishedampartistampJoseph]ampMarioniampwasamptheampfirstamp
personampIamphadampexplainedampthisamptoampthatampactuallyampknewampEXACTLYampwhatampIampwasamptalkingamp
aboutampHeampactuallyampsaidamptoampmeampItsampinampyouramppsycheampampThisampresonatedampwithampmeampamp
IampknewamprightampthenampthatampIampwasampnoamplongerampafraidampwhenampsomeoneampaskedampmeampwhyampIamp
chooseampaampparticularampcolorampampIampchooseampcolorampbecauseampIampintuitivelyampknowampthatampcoloramp
isampgivingampsomethingamptoamptheampviewerampMarioniampunderstoodamp(Surveyampresponseamp
RWampageamp26)amp
bull StrongampemotionalampcharacterampThisamppersonampdidntampactuallyampcareampinamptheampfirstamp
placeampsoampIampfeltampthatampeverythingampIampwasampdoingampwasampworthlessampuselessampandampuglyampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 39amp
MyampartamprepresentsampmeampandampmyamppastampsoampIampfeltampworthlessampuselessampandampuglyamp
(SurveyampresponseampAVampageamp17)amp
bull ArtampasampcontinuationampofampselfampIfampIampknowampmeampandampIampcanampspeakampofampmeampthenampmaybeamp
oneampdayampeveryoneampwillampgiveampmeampandampmyampworkampwhichampisampmeampaampchanceamp(Surveyamp
responseampMESampageamp24)amp
Creative=Listening(Space(Case(Studies(
( Iampconductedampfiveampcaseampstudiesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithampsixampindividualsamp
asamppartampofampthisampresearchampdeliberatelyampchoosingamppeopleampwithampwhomampIamphadampvariousamptypesamp
ofamprelationshipsampampampTwoampofamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwereampconductedampwithamp
individualsampwithampwhomampIamphadampnoampprioramprelationshipamponeampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampwasamp
withamptheamp14ampyearltoldampdaughterampofampaampclassmateampandamptheampotherampwasampwithamptwoamp
undergraduateampfineampartampstudentsampinamptheirampfirstampyearampinamptheampUniversityampofampCincinnatisamp
DAAPampprogramampampAnotheramptwoampwereampconductedampwithamphighampschoolltagedampstudentsampIamp
teachampinampanampafterltschoolampartampprogramampampTheampfinalampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampconductedamp
wasampwithampanampundergraduateampartampstudentampwithampwhomampIamphaveampsharedampseveralampclassesampampamp
amp Theampbasicampstructureampofamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampexperiencesampwasampfairlyamp
consistentampthroughoutampthisampprocessampampIampprovidedampparticipantsampwithamptwoamphandoutsamp(seeamp
figamp2ampandamp3)ampampTheampfirstamphandoutampdescribedamptheamppromptampandampbeliefsampofampaampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampampWeampcompletedamptheamppromptamponamptheampbackampofampthisamphandoutampampTheampsecondamp
handoutampoutlinedampwaysampofamplisteningampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampandampwasampusedampforamp
participantsamptoampevaluateamptheampexperienceampampAllampparticipantsampincludingampmyselfamp
interactedampwithamptheseamphandoutsampbyampreadingampthemamp(oftenampaloud)ampandampfillingampthemampoutampatamp
differentamptimesampduringamptheampexperienceampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 40amp
amp Iampbeganamptheampsessionsampbyampinformingamptheampparticipantampthatampbothampofampusampwereampinampaamp
creativeltlisteningampspaceampandampthenampIampbrieflyampdescribedampwhatampthatampmeantampampThisampstepampsetamp
theamptoneampforamptheampencounterampampThenamptheampparticipantampandampIampreadamptheampBeliefsampinampaamp
CreativeltListeningampSpaceampsectionamp(figamp2)ampampIampaskedampifamptheampparticipantamphadampanyamp
questionsamporampcommentsampaboutamptheseamppracticesampampThenampIampshowedamptheampparticipantamptheamp
nextamphandoutamp(figamp3)ampampWeampeachampfilledampoutamptheamphandoutampwritingampourampnamesampinamptheamp
appropriateampspacesampampWeampreadampoveramptheamplistampofampactivitiesamponamptheampleftampsideampofamptheamppaperampampIamp
askedampparticipantsamptoampchooseamponeampqualityamptoampfocusamponampandampweampsharedampwhatamptheampfocusamp
wouldampbeampforampeachampofampusampandampwhyampampThenampIampintroducedamptheamppromptampaampselfltportraitampinamp
threeampminutesampampThisampselfltportraitampwasampcompletelyampopenltendedampinamptermsampofampstyleamp
techniqueampandampsubjectampmatterampampTheampmainampqualificationsampwereampthatampitampfeltamp
representativeampofamptheampartistampinampthatampmomentampampAfterampweamphadampspentampthreeampminutesamponamp
ourampselfampportraitsampweamptalkedampaboutampwhatampweampdrewampandampwhyampampIampgaveampparticipantsamptheamp
opportunityamptoampcontinueamptoampdrawampasampweampspokeampampampWhenampIampfeltampthatamptheampsessionampwasamp
drawingamptoampaampnaturalampcloseampeachampofampusampfilledampoutamptheampevaluationamphandoutamp(figamp3)ampbyamp
circlingampwhatampweampfeltampweamphadampexperiencedampduringamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampamp
amp
thread7(
Responding(to(Response(Layers(of(Listening(Understandingamp
amp Theampamountampofampdataamptheampexperiencesampandamptheampknowledgeampaccruedampoveramptheamp
courseampofampthisampprojectamphasampbeenamptoampsayamptheampleastampoverwhelmingampandamphumblingampamp
WritingampaamppassageampinampresponseamphasampbeenampaampsignificantampchallengeltlthowampshouldampIampdoamp
justiceamptoamptheampindividualsampwhoampsharedamptheirampstoriesampampWhatampisamptheampappropriateampmediumamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 41amp
forampsuchampaampventureampampHowampdoampIampsumampupampwhatampIamphaveamplearnedampfromampthemampandampfromamptheamp
experiencesampgeneratedampwithinampthisampresearchamp
amp InampanampattemptamptoampansweramporampsimplyampliveampinamptheseampquestionsampIampwouldampfirstamplikeamptoamp
discussamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampWhenamptaskedampwithampdescribingampsituationsampofampbeingamp
listenedamptoamporampnotampsurveyampparticipantsamphadampaamplotamptoampsayampampRarelyampdidampindividualsampgiveamp
oneltwordamporampevenamponeltsentenceampanswersampampNearlyampeveryoneamphadampexperiencesamptheyamp
wantedamptoampshareampandamptheseampexperiencesampwereampoftenampdescribedampusingamplanguageampthatamp
carriedampwithampitamptheampweightampofampemotionampandampvulnerabilityampampSomeampofamptheseampresponsesamp
continueamptoampstickamptoampmeampampMyampunderstandingampofampotherampresponsesampevolvedampoveramptheamp
courseampofampmyampinteractionsampwithampthemampampamp
amp Inampgeneralamptheampnegativeamplisteningampsituationsampdescribedampwereampnotampusuallyamp
purposefullyamphurtfulampampMoreampoftenampparticipantsampdescribedampfeelingampdismissedampampThisamp
sometimesampdidntampevenamptranslateampintoampwritingampampParticipantsampwroteampaboutampsituationsampinamp
whichamptheamplanguageampofamptheampencounterampdidntampalwaysampmatchamptheampemotionampfeltampampForamp
exampleamponeampsurveyampparticipantampdescribedampanampexperienceampinampwhichampaampfamilyampmemberamp
saidampWowampIampneverampthoughtampwouldveampthoughtamptoampmakeampaampportraitampthatampwayamp(Surveyamp
responseampLSampageamp27)ampampInampexamplesamplikeampthisampnegativeampinteractionsampwereampfeltampratheramp
thanamparticulatedampdirectlyampampTheseampmomentsampwereampbasedamparoundampintonationampemphasisamp
andamppresumedampsubtextampratherampthanampexplicitamporampdeliberateampwordampchoiceampampamp
amp IampamampundoubtedlyampmakingampsomeampassumptionsampasampIampsayampthisampbutamptheampsurveyamp
responsesampindicatedampthatampitsampeasyamptoampbeampunintentionallyamphurtfulampampItsampmuchampharderamptoamp
handleamptheampwordsampandampcreativeampworkampofampanotherampwithampcareampampInampfactampthisamptakesampconstantamp
questioningampandampreflectionampampTheamppositiveampresponsesampusuallyampindicatedampaampsenseampofamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 42amp
connectionamprestraintampandampgenuineampinterestampampSomeampdescribedampsilenceampasampaampkeyamp
componentampofamplisteningampandampothersampdiscussedamptheampsituationsampinampwhichamptheamplisteneramp
asksampquestionsamporampmake[s]ampcommentsampthatampallowampyouamptoampfeelampjustifiedampinampwhatampyouveamp
saidamp(SurveyampresponseampCHampageamp47)ampampStillampothersampreferredamptoamptheamppowerampofamp
interpretationampandamptheampintentampofamptheampartistampasampaampguideampforampknowingampthatamponesampworkamp
wasampunderstoodamp
amp Asampforamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcaseampstudiesampthisampideaampandamptheampexperiencesamp
thatampbroughtampitamptoampfruitionampareampstillampinamptheirampinfancyampampThisampresearchampprojectampgaveampmeamptheamp
firstampstepsampintoamptheamppossibilitiesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampandampIamplookampforwardamptoamp
understandingampmoreampaboutamphowampitampwouldamplookamptoampimplementampthisampframeworkampintoampaamp
classroomamporampstudioampcontextampampInitiallyampIampthoughtampthatampIampcouldampjustampaskampparticipantsamptoamp
enterampintoampaampstateampofampmindampthatampwouldampbeampconduciveamptoampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampIamp
assumedampthatampitampwasampmoreamplikeampaampshiftampinampattitudeampthanampaamplearnedampbehaviorampampButampIampwasamp
wrongltlttheampshiftampinampattitudeampcomesampfromampgradualamplearningampoveramptimeampampToampachieveampthisamp
thereampneedsamptoampbeampaampsystemampofampscaffoldingampinampplaceampampThisampscaffoldingampcanampincludeamp
specificampwaysampofampinteractingampinampclassroomsampstudiosampandampviewingampspacesampassignmentsamp
andampprojectsampcenteredamparoundampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampexperiencesampinvestigationampofamp
collageampjournalampwritingampexercisesampinamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampsustainedamp
engagementsampinampviewingampworksampofampartampteacherampmodelingampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
behaviorsampandampsoamponampampThisamprealizationampcameamptooamplateampinamptheampresearchamptoampfullyampengageamp
withamppossibleampsolutionsampbutampIamplookampforwardamptoampdevelopingamptheseampoveramptheampcourseampofamp
myampcareeramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 43amp
amp Theamprealizationampthatampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamprequireampmoreampthanampjustampanamp
attitudeampshiftampcameampfromampanotheramponeampofamptheampbiggestampoutcomesampofampthisampresearchampampTheamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampIampenactedamphadampsomethingampofampaampdominoampeffectamponampmyamppracticesamp
withinampthemampampTheampmostampimportantampaspectampofampenactingampthemampwasampbeingampreflexiveamptoamp
whatamphappenedampwithinampthemampampIampwasampconstantlyampaskingampmyselfampwhatampwasampworkingamp
whatampneededamptoampchangeampandampwhatampcouldampmakeampitampbetterampampIampreflectedamponampmyampownampstateamp
ofampmindampandamphowampthatampinformedampmyampexperiencesampandamptheampexperiencesampofampanotherampampIamp
reflectedamponampmyampassumptionsampampIampthoughtampthatampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmightamphaveampaamp
certainampkindampofampfeelingampaamptransformativeampclickampthatampwouldampletampmeampknowampitampwasamp
workingampampButampitsampnotampthatampsimpleampampAampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampmanifestampitselfampinamp
soampmanyampwaysampthatampitsampimpossibleamptoampidentifyampthemampallampampItampcouldampfeelamplikeampaampregularamp
conversationamporampcritiqueampitampcouldampfeelampuncomfortableamporampeasyampampItampcouldamphaveampaampuniqueamp
asltyetltunknownampqualityampampLikeampaampworkampofampartampitampcouldamptakeamponampanyampnumberampofampformsamp
andamppossibilitiesampMyampassumptionampthatampitampwouldamptakeamponamponeampeasylttoltrecognizeamp
manifestationampwasampnotampasampnuancedampasampthisampresearchampindicatesamptheamppossibilitiesampwouldamp
haveamptoampbeampampamp
amp FinallyampinampresponseamptoampresponseampIampcreatedampaamptextltobjectamp(Imagesamp1ampampamp2)ampthatamp
offersamponeamppossibleamparticulationamptoamptheampsurveysampandampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcaseamp
studiesampampIampwouldamplikeamptoampletampthisamponeamppossibilityampserveampasampaampmarkerampforamptheampinfiniteamp
possibilitiesampIampdidampnotampmakeampexploreampexpressamporampundergoampbutampthatampcontinueamptoampexistamp
inamptheamprealmampofampwhatltmightltbeamp
amp ThisamptextltobjectampisampakinamptoampaampmovingamppieceampofamppoetryampampToampcreateamptheamptextampIamp
collagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampfromamptheampsurveyampresponsesampinampanampeffortamptoamphonoramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 44amp
manyampvoicesampampTheamptextampisampopenampandampflowingampwithampnoampclearampbeginningamporampendampampTheamp
concealampandamprevealampaspectampofamptheampworkampcallsamptoampmindamptheampactampofampresearchampandampinquiryampinamp
generalampampTheampthickampblackampscribblesamponamptheampmovingampcirclesampareampderivedampfromamptheampfieldamp
notesampIamptookampduringampmyampexperiencesampwithampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcaseampstudiesampampTheamp
overlappingampdenseampqualityampofampthisamptextampcallsamptoampmindamptheampdensenessampofamptheseamp
experiencesampandamptheampoverwhelmingampimpossibilityampofampabsorbingampeverythingampIampcouldamp
containampamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 47amp
thread8(amp
(In)conclusions(amp
amp InamptheampwordsampofampPaulampFairfieldamp(2011)ampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinampdialogueampnoamp
interpretationampthatampisampuniquelyampandampsupremelyampauthoritativeamp(pamp83)ampampThoughampthisamp
paperampisampendingampthereampisampnoamplastampwordamponamptheampmatterampofamplisteningampforampmeampnorampforamp
studentsampteachersamphumansampworksampofampartamptextsampadampinfinitumampampThisampmyampnotltsolt
conclusiveltconcludingampsectionampstretchesamptheamppossibilityampofampmyampresearchampinampaampmanneramp
thatampdefiesamptheampsupremelyampauthoritativeampstructureampofampanampacademicampresearchamppaperampampamp
amp
Below-is-the-transcript-from-an-episode-dated-April-6-2015-of-the-popular-daytime-
talk-show-Ellen-during-which-the-artistresearcheducator-was-invited-to-discuss-her-
groundbreaking-work-on-listening-
(Camerasamprollampinamp3amp2amp1ampSceneampopensamponamptheampsetampof-EllenampampCameraamppansampinamptoampfocusamp
onampEllenampampSheampisampseatedamponampaamploveseatampwearingampaampcreamltcoloredamppantsuitampwithampaamplightamp
blueampbuttonltupampshirtampampHeramphairampisampperfectlyampcoiffedampampLightsampflashampandamptheampcrowdamp
cheersampampIntroampmusicampswells)-
EllenampDegeneresampampHelloampeveryoneampampWelcomeamptoamptheampshowamptodayampampTheampfirstamponlyampandamp
mostampimportantampguestamponamptodaysampshowampisampSamanthaampMesserampampSamanthaampisampanampartistamp
researcherampandampeducatorampbasedampinampCincinnatiampOhioampwhoseamprecentampresearchampprojectamp
onamplisteningampinampartampeducationamphasamptheamppotentialamptoampchangeamptheampfaceampofampnotamponlyampartamp
educationampbutampalsoamptheampworldampampHereampsheampisampSamanthaampMesseramp
(SamanthaampwalksamponamptheampstageamplookingampsleekampasamphellampwhileampdoingampitampampTheampaudienceamp
cheersampampSamanthaampandampEllenamphugamplikeampoldampfriends)amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 48amp
SamanthaampMesserampampHiampEllenampampItsampsoampgreatamptoampseeampyouampampamp
EDampampNoampSamanthaampitsampgreatamptoampseeampyouampampTellampusampaboutampwhatampbringsampyouamphereamptodayamp
SMampamp(Laughsampfreelyampwithoutampaampcare)ampEllenampyouampareampwhatampbroughtampmeamphereamptoday(
(Audienceamplaughs)amp
EDampampIampappreciateampthatampthankampyouampampButampletsampgetamptoampwhatsamponampAmericasampmindampampYouramp
lifesampworkampampIncredibleampampWhatampexactlyampisampitampandamphowampdidampitampcomeampaboutampampampampamp
SMampampEllenampwhereamptoampbeginampampampTheampideaampinampitsampmostampbasicampformampisampanampartampeducationampbasedamp
aroundamplisteningamppracticesamp
EDampampThatampsoundsampfascinatingampamp
SMampampIampknowampampThankampyouampforampnoticingampitsampsubtleampbrillianceamp
EDampampIampwouldampbeampaampfoolampnotamptoampampTellampusamphowampyouampcameampupampwithampthisampideaamp
SMampampampTheampcentralampcomponentampisampanampideaampcalledampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampwhichampisampaamp
spaceampinampwhichampstudentsampandampparticipantsampmakeampdiscussampandampviewampworksampofampartampwithamp
listeningampatamptheampcenterampofamptheseampactivitiesampandampexperiencesampampThisampideaampcameamptogetheramp
overamptheampcourseampofampmonthsampofampreadingamphundredsampofampdiscussionsampwithamppeersampresearchamp
participantsampandampprofessorsampasampwellampasamptheampwritingampandamprewritingampofampmanyampdraftsampofamp
myampnowampbestltsellingampbookamp
(Audienceampooooooohs)amp
EDampampWowampyouampreallyampputampsomeampthoughtampintoampthisamphuhampampSoamphowampisampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampdifferentampthanampaampregularampclassroomamp
SMampampWellampitampdependsamponamptheampclassroomampampSomeampclassroomsampprobablyampalreadyampareamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampampEssentiallyampitamprequiresampsomethingampofampanampattitudeampshiftampampItamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 49amp
doesntampevenampnecessarilyamphaveamptoampbeampinampaampclassroomamporampanyampspecificampplaceampampItsampmoreampofamp
aampstateampofampmindampandampanampattitudeamp
EDampampCouldampweampbeampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamprightampnowamp
SMampampEllenampnothingampwouldampgiveampmeampmoreamppleasureamp
(Audienceampawwwwws)amp
SMampampButampseriouslyampyesampweampcanampbeampampThoughampitampmightamptakeampmoreampthanampjustampanampattitudeamp
shiftampampWhenampIampinitiallyampbeganampthisampprojectampIampthoughtampthatsampallampitampwouldampbeampampIampassumedamp
thatampifampparticipantsampwereampwillingamptheyampcouldampenterampintoampthisampstateampofampmindampampamp
EDampampButampthatsampnotamptheampcaseamp
SMampampWellampitsampjustampthatampitsampmoreampcomplicatedampthanampthatampampWhatampIampfoundampwereampthatamptheamp
thingsampIampwasampaskingampindividualsamptoampdoampwereampnotampwithinampouramptypicalampculturalampskillampsetampamp
NotamponlyampthisampbutamptheyampareampdifficultampsubtleampandampoftenampinternalamppursuitsampampTheyampareampnotamp
easyamptoampseeampandamptheampresultsampareampnotampinstantaneousampampItsamphardamptoampknowampifampyoureampdoingamp
itamprightamp
EDampSoampwhatampdoesampitampmeanamptoampdoampitamprightamp
SMampampThatsampaampgreatampquestionampEllenampandampthankampyouampforampaskingampitampampIampdontampthinkamptheresamp
justamponeampwayampofampdoingampitamprightampampAndampevenampsometimesampwhenampyoureampdoingampitamprightampitamp
mightampnotampfeelamplikeampanythingampspecialampampItampcouldampjustampfeelamplikeampaampnormalampconversationamp
EDampampSoampthisampisampallampaboutamphavingampaampconversationampampIampdoampthatampfiveampdaysampaampweekamponampthisampsetamp
Samanthaampamp
(Audienceamplaughsamplightheartedly)amp
SMampampEllenampampYoureampcuttingampmeampdeepampamp(laughs)ampYoureamprightampampItsampnotamprevolutionaryampamp
Toamplistenamptoampbeamplistenedamptoamptoampcarryamponampanampopenampandamphonestampconversationampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 50amp
anotheramphumanampTheseampareamphumbleampgoalsampthatampweampcanampcarryampacrossampmanyampcontextsampampIamp
thinkampthereinampliesamptheampbeautyamp
EDampampInterestingampampImampgoingamptoampaskampwhatampImampsureampaamplotampofampteachersamphaveamponamptheiramp
mindsltlthowampdoampweampteachampthisamptoampstudentsamp
SMampampTheampgoalsampandampbeliefsampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmustampbeamplivedampthroughampandamp
undergoneampratherampthanampmerelyampactedampoutamponceamporamptwiceampampItsampaboutampcreatingampaampsystemamp
craftingampassignmentsampandampsettingampaamptoneampthatampallampunderlieamptheseampvaluesampampNotamponlyampthatamp
butamptheampstudentsampandampteachersampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmustampbeampreflectiveamptoamp
theirampexperiencesampampTheseampskillsampneedamptoampbeampbuiltampupampandampaampkeyampcomponentampofampthatampisamp
reflectionamponamppreviousampexperiencesamp
EDampampampIampunderstandampyouampalsoampsolicitedampsurveyampresponsesamptoampdiscussampmomentsampinampwhichamp
individualsampdidamporampdidampnotampfeelamplistenedamptoampasamptheyampspokeampaboutamptheirampartampampCanampyouamptalkamp
aamplittleampbitampaboutampwhatampyouampfoundampinamptheampsurveysamp
SMampampWellampIampcoveredampaamplotampofampthisampinampmyampbookampYoullamphaveamptoampreadampitampampIamphaveampprovidedamp
everyampmemberampofamptheampaudienceamptodayampwithampaampcopyampwhichampyoullampallampfindampunderampyouramp
seatsamp
(AudienceampgoesampwildampwithampexcitementampasamptheyampreachampunderamptheirampseatsampampThereampareamp
intermittentampscreechesampofampjoy)amp
EDampampWowampthankampyouampampTheampgiftampofamplisteningampwhatampaamptreasureampforamptheampaudienceamp
membersamptodayamp
(Audienceampclapsampwholeheartedly)amp
SMampampYoureampwelcomeampampInampgeneralampthoughampwhatampIampfoundampisampaampneedamptoamphandleamptheampwordsamp
andampexperiencesampofampothersampwithampcareampampTheampsurveysampdescribedampsituationsampinampwhichamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 51amp
individualsampfeltamptheyampwereampnotampbeingamplistenedamptoampyetamptheseampmomentsampwereampnotampusuallyamp
profoundlyamporamppurposefullyamphurtfulampampMoreampoftenamptheampsurveysampdescribedampinstancesampinamp
whichamppeopleampfeltampthatampanotheramppersonampwasntamptryingamptoampunderstandampampTheseamp
situationsampwereampmoreamppassiveampandampdismissiveampratherampthanampactivelyamphurtfulampthoughamp
theyampdidampstillamphurtamp
EDampampWellampcouldntampthatampbeampchalkedampupamptoamptheampsensitiveamppersonaampofamptheampartistampampWeampallamp
knowamphowampsensitiveampthoseampartistsampareamp
(Audienceamplaughsamptheyampareampinamponamptheampjoke)amp
SMampamp(chastising)ampEllenampyoureampsmarterampthanampthatampstereotypeampampIampmeanampyouampcouldampsayamp
thatampbutampIampdontampknowampifampthatampwouldampbeampproductiveampampAndampitampwouldntampfitampwithamptheamp
beliefsampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampinampmyampopinionampampDontampweampallampwantamptoampbeamplistenedamp
toampampIsampthatampdesireampexclusiveamptoampsomeampideaampweamphaveampinampourampheadampofampartistsampampIampdontamp
thinkampsoamp
EDampampYoureampsoamprightampSamanthaampampImampsorryampforampgivingampintoampsomeamppervasiveampmodernistamp
nonsenseampaboutampwhatampitampisamptoampbeampanampartistamp
(Audienceampnodsampinampagreement)amp
SMampampItsampokayampEllenampWeampinamptheampartampworldampareampfightingamptheampgoodampfightampWhatampweampdoampisamp
importantampandampwereamptiredampofampbeingampdismissedampbyampsocietyamp
(Audienceampclaps)amp
EDampampSoampwhatampisampyourampnextampstepamp
SMampampWellampIampwasampjustampawardedampaampspecialampmedalampofamphonorampfromampPresidentampObamaampamp
(PhotoampofampSamanthaampshakingamphandsampwithamptheampPresidentampflashesamponamptheampscreenampandamptheamp
audienceampclaps)amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 52amp
EDampampCongratulationsamp
SMampampThankampyouampampWhatampanamphonorampampAlongampwithampthisampcommendationampcameampaampgrantampforamp
meamptoampbeampableamptoamptrainampaampgroupampofamphighlyampspecializedampartistlteducatorsampinamptheseamp
practicesampandampsendampthemampoutamptoampcommunitiesampacrossamptheampcountryamptoamphelpampimplementamp
andampsupportampeffortsamptoampputampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampintoampschoolsampwhoampchooseamptoampbeamp
involvedampnationwideamp
(Aampthunderingampofampclappingampinamptheampaudience)amp
EDampampWhatampdoampyouampseeampareamptheamplonglttermampeffectsampofamptheampimplementationampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampamp
SMampampEllenampImampsureampIampdontamphaveamptoamptellampyouampthatampweampliveampinampaampfastltpacedamp
technologicallyltrevolutionaryampworldampampThereampareamppartsampofampthatampthatampareampwonderfulampandamp
makeampourampworldampanampeasierampplaceamptoampliveampampButampthereamphasamptoampbeamproomampforampusamptoampswitchampoffamp
unplugampandampslowampdownampampIampbelieveampthatamptheampplatformampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
unleashesampsomeamppossibilitiesampofamphumanampconnectionampinampaampveryamprealampauthenticampwayampamp
(Audienceamprisesampfromamptheirampseatsampwithamptearsampinamptheirampeyesampasamptheyampgiveampaampstandingamp
ovation)amp
EDampampAampnobleampgoalampindeedampampThankampyouampSamanthaampforampallampthatampyouampdoampampWhatampaampgamelt
changerampampThatsampallamptheamptimeampweamphaveampforamptodayampampItsampbeenampaamptrueamphonorampampGoodampluckampinamp
allampofampyourampendeavorsampampToampthoseampwatchingampatamphomeampgoamplistenamptoampsomeoneampamp
(SamanthaampEllenampandampaudienceampdanceampasamptheampcreditsamproll)amp
(
ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 53amp
loose(ends((References(
AndersonampEampHampampampSpencerampMampHamp(2013)ampAampPhenomenologicalampStudyampCognitiveamp
amp RepresentationsampofampAIDSampInampJampWampCreswellampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-
- Designamp(ppamp327lt346)ampLosampAngelesampSAGEampPublicationsampIncamp
BakerampGampampampMorrisampKamp(2002)ampDecartes-DualismampLondonampRoutledgeamp
BelenkyampMampFampClinchyampBampMampGoldbergerampNampRampampampTaruleampJampMamp(1997)ampWomens-Ways-
- of-Knowing-The-Development-of-Self-Voice-and-MindampNewampYorkampNYamp
amp BasicBooksamp
BleicherampJamp(1980)ampampContemporary-Hermeneutics-Hermeneutics-as-Method-
- Philosophy-and-Critique--LondonampUKampRoutledgeampampampKeeganampPaulamp
BohmampDamp(1996)ampOn-DialogueampLondonampUKampRoutledgeamp
BourgeoisampJampPamp(2007)ampThe-Aesthetic-Hermeneutics-of-Hans(Georg-Gadamer-and-Hans-
- Urs-von-BalthasarampNewampYorkampNYampPeterampLangampPublishingampIncamp
BrunsampGampLamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-Ancient-and-ModernampNewampHavenampCTampYaleamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
CalleampSamp(2011)ampBlindampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CalleampSamp(2005)ampExisquisite-PainampNewampYorkampThamesampampampHudsonamp
CalleampSamp(2008)ampTake-Care-of-YourselfampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CaputoampJamp(2000)ampMore-Radical-HermeneuticsampBloomingtonampINampIndianaampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
CreswellampJampWamp(2013)ampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-DesignampLosampAngelesampSAGEamp
amp PublicationsampIncamp
deampCossonampAamp(2002)ampTheampHermeneuticampDialogueampFindingampPatternsampamidamptheampAporiaamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 54amp
amp ofamptheampArtistResearcherTeacherampAlberta-Journal-of-Educational-Researchamp-
- 48amp(3)amp1lt20amp
ElkinsampJamp(2001)ampWhy-Art-Cannot-Be-TaughtampChicagoampILampUniversityampofampIllinoisampPressamp
FairfieldampPamp(2011)ampDialogueampinamptheampClassroomampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-
- Dialogue-and-Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp77lt90)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GadamerampHltGamp(1996)ampThe-Engima-of-HealthampStanfordampCAampStanfordampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
GadamerampHltGamp(2004)ampTruth-and-Methodamp(Secondamprevisedamped)amp(JampWeinsheimerampampamp
amp DampGampMarshallampTrans)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GallagherampSamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-and-EducationampAlbanyampNYampStateampUniversityampofamp
amp NewampYorkampPressamp
GendlinampEamp(1962)ampExperiencing-and-the-Creation-of-MeaningampNewampYorkampNYampTheamp
amp FreeampPressampofampGlencoeamp
GendlinampEamp(1997)ampampHowampPhilosophyampCannotampAppealamptoampExperienceampandampHowampItampCanamp
amp InampLanguage-beyond-Postmodernism-Saying-and-Thinking-in-Gendlins-
- Philosophy-(ppamp3lt41)ampEvanstonampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
GermeraadampGamp(2013)ampRationalityampIntuitionampandampEmotionampExploringampanampArtisticamp
amp ProcessampJournal-for-Artistic-Researchamp-3
GradleampSampAamp(2011)ampAampuniversityampcourseampinampmindfulampviewingampUnderstandingampartampandamp
amp selfampthroughampcontemplativeampexperienceampInternational-Journal-of-Education-
- Through-Artamp-7amp(2)amp137lt151amp
GreeneampMamp(2013)ampTheampTurningampofamptheampLeavesampExpandingampOurampVisionampforamptheampArtsampinamp
amp EducationampHarvard-Educational-Reviewamp-83amp(1)amp251lt252amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 55amp
GrondinampJamp(2002)ampGadamersampBasicampUnderstandingampofampUnderstandingampInampThe-
- Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp36lt51)ampCambridgeampUKampCambridgeamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
GrondinampJamp(2011)ampGadamersampExperienceampandampTheoryampofampEducationampLearningampthatamp
amp theampOtherampMayampBeampRightampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp5lt20)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
HeelanampPamp(1985)ampampPerceptionampasampaampHermeneuticalampActampampInampDampIhdeampampampHampSilvermanamp
amp (Eds)ampHermeneutics-amp-Deconstruction-(ppamp43lt54)-AlbanyampSUNYampPressamp
HeelanampPampampampSchulkinampJamp(2003)ampHermeneuticalampPhilosophyampandampPragmatismampAamp
amp PhilosophyampofampScienceampInampRampCampScharffampampampVampDusekamp(Eds)ampPhilosophy-of-
- Technology-The-Technological-Condition-an-Anthology-amp(ppamp138lt153)amp
amp MaldenampMAampBlackwellamp
KarpiakampIampEamp(2003)ampTheampListeningampHeartampTuningampInampForampTransformativeampLearningamp
amp 2003-Complexity-Science-and-Educational-Research-Conferenceamp(ppamp67lt80)amp
amp EdmontonampCanadaamp
KellyampMampPost(Partum-DocumentampInstituteampofampContemporaryampArtsampLondonamp
KentampSampJampampampCummingampJampamp(2008)ampampIampdontampknowampEngagingampwithampproblematicamp
amp momentsampinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampRadical-Pedagogy-2-(9)amp1lt20ampampamp
LevinampDampMamp(1989)ampThe-Listening-Self-Personal-Growth-Social-Change-and-the-
- Closure-of-MetaphysicsampNewampYorkampNYampRoutledgeamp
LindsethampAampampampNorbergampAamp(2004)ampAampphenomenologicalamphermeneuticalampmethodampforamp
amp researchingamplivedampexperienceampNordic-College-of-Caring-Sciencesamp-18amp145lt153amp
LipariampLamp(2014)ampampOnampinterlisteningampandamptheampideaampofampdialogueampampTheory-amp-Psychology-24-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 56amp
- (4)amp504lt523amp
MarksampLamp(2002)ampTouch-Sensuous-Theory-and-Multisensory-MediaampMinneapolisamp
amp UniversityampofampMinnesotaampPressamp
MunozampKampLamp(2014)ampTranscribing-Silence-Culture-Relationship-and-Communicationamp
amp WalnutampCreekampCAampLeftampCoastampPressamp
NicholampLamp(1996)ampForewordampInampDampBohmampOn-Dialogueamp(ppampviiltxvii)ampLondonampUKamp
amp Routledgeamp
PalmerampRamp(1969)ampHermeneutics-Interpretation-Theory-in-Schleiermacher-Dilthey-
- Heidegger-and-GadamerampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
PerlampSamp(2004)ampFelt-Sense-Writing-with-the-BodyampPortsmouthampNHampBoyntonCookamp
RicoeurampPamp(19691974)ampThe-Conflicts-of-Interpretations-Essays-in-Hermeneuticsamp
amp (NorthwesternampUniversityampPressampTrans)ampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
RicoeurampPamp(2013)ampHermeneuticsampCambridgeampUKampPolityampPressamp
SableampDamp(2014)ampReasonampinamptheampServiceampofamptheampHeartampTheampImpactsampofampContemplativeamp
amp PracticesamponampCriticalampThinkingampJournal-of-Contemplative-Inquiryamp-1amp(1)amp1lt22amp
SchultzampKamp(2010)ampAfteramptheampBlackbirdampWhistlesampListeningamptoampSilenceampinampClassroomsamp
amp Teachers-College-Recordamp-112amp(11)amp2833lt2849amp
SeebohmampTampamp(2004)ampampHermeneutics-Method-and-MethodologyampDordrechtamptheamp
amp NetherlandsampKluwerampAcademicampPublishersamp
SnowberampCamp(2005)ampTheampmentorampasampartistampaamppoeticampexplorationampofamplisteningampcreatingamp
amp andampmentoringampMentoring-and-Tutoring-13amp(3)amp345lt353amp
vanampManenampMampamp(1984)ampPracticingampPhenomenologicalampWritingampPhenomenology-+-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 57amp
- Pedagogy-2amp(1)amp36lt68amp
vanampManenampMamp(1990)ampampResearching-Lived-Experience-Human-Science-for-an-Action(
- Sensitive-PedagogyampNewampYorkampSUNYampPressamp
VitanovaampGamp(2010)ampampAuthoring-the-Dialogic-SelfampAmsterdamampJohnampBenjaminsamp
amp PublishingampCoamp
WatsonampJamp(2013)ampampKnowingampthroughamptheampfeltltsenseampaampgestureampofampopennessamptoamptheamp
amp otherampampInternational-Journal-of-Childrens-Spirituality-18amp(1)amp118lt130amp
WiercinskiampAamp(2011)ampHermeneuticampEducationamptoampUnderstandingampSelfltEducationampandamp
amp theampWillingnessamptoampRiskampFailureampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp107lt124)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
WorsleyampRamp(2012)ampNarrativesampandamplivelyampmetaphorsampHermeneuticsampasampaampwayampofamp
amp listeningampPerson(Centered-amp-Experiential-Psychotherapiesamp-11amp(4)amp304lt320amp
ZuckertampCampHamp(2002)ampHermeneuticsampinampPracticeampGadameramponampAncientampPhilosophyampInamp
amp RampJampDostalamp(Ed)ampThe-Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp201lt224)amp
amp CambridgeampUKampCambridgeampUniversityampPressamp
amp
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
- WebsitePaper-20
- WebsitePaper-18
- WebsitePaperpdf
-
- MesserFinalPaper-11
- MesserFinalPaper
-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 39amp
MyampartamprepresentsampmeampandampmyamppastampsoampIampfeltampworthlessampuselessampandampuglyamp
(SurveyampresponseampAVampageamp17)amp
bull ArtampasampcontinuationampofampselfampIfampIampknowampmeampandampIampcanampspeakampofampmeampthenampmaybeamp
oneampdayampeveryoneampwillampgiveampmeampandampmyampworkampwhichampisampmeampaampchanceamp(Surveyamp
responseampMESampageamp24)amp
Creative=Listening(Space(Case(Studies(
( Iampconductedampfiveampcaseampstudiesampofampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwithampsixampindividualsamp
asamppartampofampthisampresearchampdeliberatelyampchoosingamppeopleampwithampwhomampIamphadampvariousamptypesamp
ofamprelationshipsampampampTwoampofamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspacesampwereampconductedampwithamp
individualsampwithampwhomampIamphadampnoampprioramprelationshipamponeampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampwasamp
withamptheamp14ampyearltoldampdaughterampofampaampclassmateampandamptheampotherampwasampwithamptwoamp
undergraduateampfineampartampstudentsampinamptheirampfirstampyearampinamptheampUniversityampofampCincinnatisamp
DAAPampprogramampampAnotheramptwoampwereampconductedampwithamphighampschoolltagedampstudentsampIamp
teachampinampanampafterltschoolampartampprogramampampTheampfinalampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampIampconductedamp
wasampwithampanampundergraduateampartampstudentampwithampwhomampIamphaveampsharedampseveralampclassesampampamp
amp Theampbasicampstructureampofamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampexperiencesampwasampfairlyamp
consistentampthroughoutampthisampprocessampampIampprovidedampparticipantsampwithamptwoamphandoutsamp(seeamp
figamp2ampandamp3)ampampTheampfirstamphandoutampdescribedamptheamppromptampandampbeliefsampofampaampcreativelt
listeningampspaceampampWeampcompletedamptheamppromptamponamptheampbackampofampthisamphandoutampampTheampsecondamp
handoutampoutlinedampwaysampofamplisteningampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampandampwasampusedampforamp
participantsamptoampevaluateamptheampexperienceampampAllampparticipantsampincludingampmyselfamp
interactedampwithamptheseamphandoutsampbyampreadingampthemamp(oftenampaloud)ampandampfillingampthemampoutampatamp
differentamptimesampduringamptheampexperienceampampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 40amp
amp Iampbeganamptheampsessionsampbyampinformingamptheampparticipantampthatampbothampofampusampwereampinampaamp
creativeltlisteningampspaceampandampthenampIampbrieflyampdescribedampwhatampthatampmeantampampThisampstepampsetamp
theamptoneampforamptheampencounterampampThenamptheampparticipantampandampIampreadamptheampBeliefsampinampaamp
CreativeltListeningampSpaceampsectionamp(figamp2)ampampIampaskedampifamptheampparticipantamphadampanyamp
questionsamporampcommentsampaboutamptheseamppracticesampampThenampIampshowedamptheampparticipantamptheamp
nextamphandoutamp(figamp3)ampampWeampeachampfilledampoutamptheamphandoutampwritingampourampnamesampinamptheamp
appropriateampspacesampampWeampreadampoveramptheamplistampofampactivitiesamponamptheampleftampsideampofamptheamppaperampampIamp
askedampparticipantsamptoampchooseamponeampqualityamptoampfocusamponampandampweampsharedampwhatamptheampfocusamp
wouldampbeampforampeachampofampusampandampwhyampampThenampIampintroducedamptheamppromptampaampselfltportraitampinamp
threeampminutesampampThisampselfltportraitampwasampcompletelyampopenltendedampinamptermsampofampstyleamp
techniqueampandampsubjectampmatterampampTheampmainampqualificationsampwereampthatampitampfeltamp
representativeampofamptheampartistampinampthatampmomentampampAfterampweamphadampspentampthreeampminutesamponamp
ourampselfampportraitsampweamptalkedampaboutampwhatampweampdrewampandampwhyampampIampgaveampparticipantsamptheamp
opportunityamptoampcontinueamptoampdrawampasampweampspokeampampampWhenampIampfeltampthatamptheampsessionampwasamp
drawingamptoampaampnaturalampcloseampeachampofampusampfilledampoutamptheampevaluationamphandoutamp(figamp3)ampbyamp
circlingampwhatampweampfeltampweamphadampexperiencedampduringamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampamp
amp
thread7(
Responding(to(Response(Layers(of(Listening(Understandingamp
amp Theampamountampofampdataamptheampexperiencesampandamptheampknowledgeampaccruedampoveramptheamp
courseampofampthisampprojectamphasampbeenamptoampsayamptheampleastampoverwhelmingampandamphumblingampamp
WritingampaamppassageampinampresponseamphasampbeenampaampsignificantampchallengeltlthowampshouldampIampdoamp
justiceamptoamptheampindividualsampwhoampsharedamptheirampstoriesampampWhatampisamptheampappropriateampmediumamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 41amp
forampsuchampaampventureampampHowampdoampIampsumampupampwhatampIamphaveamplearnedampfromampthemampandampfromamptheamp
experiencesampgeneratedampwithinampthisampresearchamp
amp InampanampattemptamptoampansweramporampsimplyampliveampinamptheseampquestionsampIampwouldampfirstamplikeamptoamp
discussamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampWhenamptaskedampwithampdescribingampsituationsampofampbeingamp
listenedamptoamporampnotampsurveyampparticipantsamphadampaamplotamptoampsayampampRarelyampdidampindividualsampgiveamp
oneltwordamporampevenamponeltsentenceampanswersampampNearlyampeveryoneamphadampexperiencesamptheyamp
wantedamptoampshareampandamptheseampexperiencesampwereampoftenampdescribedampusingamplanguageampthatamp
carriedampwithampitamptheampweightampofampemotionampandampvulnerabilityampampSomeampofamptheseampresponsesamp
continueamptoampstickamptoampmeampampMyampunderstandingampofampotherampresponsesampevolvedampoveramptheamp
courseampofampmyampinteractionsampwithampthemampampamp
amp Inampgeneralamptheampnegativeamplisteningampsituationsampdescribedampwereampnotampusuallyamp
purposefullyamphurtfulampampMoreampoftenampparticipantsampdescribedampfeelingampdismissedampampThisamp
sometimesampdidntampevenamptranslateampintoampwritingampampParticipantsampwroteampaboutampsituationsampinamp
whichamptheamplanguageampofamptheampencounterampdidntampalwaysampmatchamptheampemotionampfeltampampForamp
exampleamponeampsurveyampparticipantampdescribedampanampexperienceampinampwhichampaampfamilyampmemberamp
saidampWowampIampneverampthoughtampwouldveampthoughtamptoampmakeampaampportraitampthatampwayamp(Surveyamp
responseampLSampageamp27)ampampInampexamplesamplikeampthisampnegativeampinteractionsampwereampfeltampratheramp
thanamparticulatedampdirectlyampampTheseampmomentsampwereampbasedamparoundampintonationampemphasisamp
andamppresumedampsubtextampratherampthanampexplicitamporampdeliberateampwordampchoiceampampamp
amp IampamampundoubtedlyampmakingampsomeampassumptionsampasampIampsayampthisampbutamptheampsurveyamp
responsesampindicatedampthatampitsampeasyamptoampbeampunintentionallyamphurtfulampampItsampmuchampharderamptoamp
handleamptheampwordsampandampcreativeampworkampofampanotherampwithampcareampampInampfactampthisamptakesampconstantamp
questioningampandampreflectionampampTheamppositiveampresponsesampusuallyampindicatedampaampsenseampofamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 42amp
connectionamprestraintampandampgenuineampinterestampampSomeampdescribedampsilenceampasampaampkeyamp
componentampofamplisteningampandampothersampdiscussedamptheampsituationsampinampwhichamptheamplisteneramp
asksampquestionsamporampmake[s]ampcommentsampthatampallowampyouamptoampfeelampjustifiedampinampwhatampyouveamp
saidamp(SurveyampresponseampCHampageamp47)ampampStillampothersampreferredamptoamptheamppowerampofamp
interpretationampandamptheampintentampofamptheampartistampasampaampguideampforampknowingampthatamponesampworkamp
wasampunderstoodamp
amp Asampforamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcaseampstudiesampthisampideaampandamptheampexperiencesamp
thatampbroughtampitamptoampfruitionampareampstillampinamptheirampinfancyampampThisampresearchampprojectampgaveampmeamptheamp
firstampstepsampintoamptheamppossibilitiesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampandampIamplookampforwardamptoamp
understandingampmoreampaboutamphowampitampwouldamplookamptoampimplementampthisampframeworkampintoampaamp
classroomamporampstudioampcontextampampInitiallyampIampthoughtampthatampIampcouldampjustampaskampparticipantsamptoamp
enterampintoampaampstateampofampmindampthatampwouldampbeampconduciveamptoampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampIamp
assumedampthatampitampwasampmoreamplikeampaampshiftampinampattitudeampthanampaamplearnedampbehaviorampampButampIampwasamp
wrongltlttheampshiftampinampattitudeampcomesampfromampgradualamplearningampoveramptimeampampToampachieveampthisamp
thereampneedsamptoampbeampaampsystemampofampscaffoldingampinampplaceampampThisampscaffoldingampcanampincludeamp
specificampwaysampofampinteractingampinampclassroomsampstudiosampandampviewingampspacesampassignmentsamp
andampprojectsampcenteredamparoundampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampexperiencesampinvestigationampofamp
collageampjournalampwritingampexercisesampinamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampsustainedamp
engagementsampinampviewingampworksampofampartampteacherampmodelingampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
behaviorsampandampsoamponampampThisamprealizationampcameamptooamplateampinamptheampresearchamptoampfullyampengageamp
withamppossibleampsolutionsampbutampIamplookampforwardamptoampdevelopingamptheseampoveramptheampcourseampofamp
myampcareeramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 43amp
amp Theamprealizationampthatampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamprequireampmoreampthanampjustampanamp
attitudeampshiftampcameampfromampanotheramponeampofamptheampbiggestampoutcomesampofampthisampresearchampampTheamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampIampenactedamphadampsomethingampofampaampdominoampeffectamponampmyamppracticesamp
withinampthemampampTheampmostampimportantampaspectampofampenactingampthemampwasampbeingampreflexiveamptoamp
whatamphappenedampwithinampthemampampIampwasampconstantlyampaskingampmyselfampwhatampwasampworkingamp
whatampneededamptoampchangeampandampwhatampcouldampmakeampitampbetterampampIampreflectedamponampmyampownampstateamp
ofampmindampandamphowampthatampinformedampmyampexperiencesampandamptheampexperiencesampofampanotherampampIamp
reflectedamponampmyampassumptionsampampIampthoughtampthatampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmightamphaveampaamp
certainampkindampofampfeelingampaamptransformativeampclickampthatampwouldampletampmeampknowampitampwasamp
workingampampButampitsampnotampthatampsimpleampampAampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampmanifestampitselfampinamp
soampmanyampwaysampthatampitsampimpossibleamptoampidentifyampthemampallampampItampcouldampfeelamplikeampaampregularamp
conversationamporampcritiqueampitampcouldampfeelampuncomfortableamporampeasyampampItampcouldamphaveampaampuniqueamp
asltyetltunknownampqualityampampLikeampaampworkampofampartampitampcouldamptakeamponampanyampnumberampofampformsamp
andamppossibilitiesampMyampassumptionampthatampitampwouldamptakeamponamponeampeasylttoltrecognizeamp
manifestationampwasampnotampasampnuancedampasampthisampresearchampindicatesamptheamppossibilitiesampwouldamp
haveamptoampbeampampamp
amp FinallyampinampresponseamptoampresponseampIampcreatedampaamptextltobjectamp(Imagesamp1ampampamp2)ampthatamp
offersamponeamppossibleamparticulationamptoamptheampsurveysampandampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcaseamp
studiesampampIampwouldamplikeamptoampletampthisamponeamppossibilityampserveampasampaampmarkerampforamptheampinfiniteamp
possibilitiesampIampdidampnotampmakeampexploreampexpressamporampundergoampbutampthatampcontinueamptoampexistamp
inamptheamprealmampofampwhatltmightltbeamp
amp ThisamptextltobjectampisampakinamptoampaampmovingamppieceampofamppoetryampampToampcreateamptheamptextampIamp
collagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampfromamptheampsurveyampresponsesampinampanampeffortamptoamphonoramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 44amp
manyampvoicesampampTheamptextampisampopenampandampflowingampwithampnoampclearampbeginningamporampendampampTheamp
concealampandamprevealampaspectampofamptheampworkampcallsamptoampmindamptheampactampofampresearchampandampinquiryampinamp
generalampampTheampthickampblackampscribblesamponamptheampmovingampcirclesampareampderivedampfromamptheampfieldamp
notesampIamptookampduringampmyampexperiencesampwithampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcaseampstudiesampampTheamp
overlappingampdenseampqualityampofampthisamptextampcallsamptoampmindamptheampdensenessampofamptheseamp
experiencesampandamptheampoverwhelmingampimpossibilityampofampabsorbingampeverythingampIampcouldamp
containampamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 47amp
thread8(amp
(In)conclusions(amp
amp InamptheampwordsampofampPaulampFairfieldamp(2011)ampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinampdialogueampnoamp
interpretationampthatampisampuniquelyampandampsupremelyampauthoritativeamp(pamp83)ampampThoughampthisamp
paperampisampendingampthereampisampnoamplastampwordamponamptheampmatterampofamplisteningampforampmeampnorampforamp
studentsampteachersamphumansampworksampofampartamptextsampadampinfinitumampampThisampmyampnotltsolt
conclusiveltconcludingampsectionampstretchesamptheamppossibilityampofampmyampresearchampinampaampmanneramp
thatampdefiesamptheampsupremelyampauthoritativeampstructureampofampanampacademicampresearchamppaperampampamp
amp
Below-is-the-transcript-from-an-episode-dated-April-6-2015-of-the-popular-daytime-
talk-show-Ellen-during-which-the-artistresearcheducator-was-invited-to-discuss-her-
groundbreaking-work-on-listening-
(Camerasamprollampinamp3amp2amp1ampSceneampopensamponamptheampsetampof-EllenampampCameraamppansampinamptoampfocusamp
onampEllenampampSheampisampseatedamponampaamploveseatampwearingampaampcreamltcoloredamppantsuitampwithampaamplightamp
blueampbuttonltupampshirtampampHeramphairampisampperfectlyampcoiffedampampLightsampflashampandamptheampcrowdamp
cheersampampIntroampmusicampswells)-
EllenampDegeneresampampHelloampeveryoneampampWelcomeamptoamptheampshowamptodayampampTheampfirstamponlyampandamp
mostampimportantampguestamponamptodaysampshowampisampSamanthaampMesserampampSamanthaampisampanampartistamp
researcherampandampeducatorampbasedampinampCincinnatiampOhioampwhoseamprecentampresearchampprojectamp
onamplisteningampinampartampeducationamphasamptheamppotentialamptoampchangeamptheampfaceampofampnotamponlyampartamp
educationampbutampalsoamptheampworldampampHereampsheampisampSamanthaampMesseramp
(SamanthaampwalksamponamptheampstageamplookingampsleekampasamphellampwhileampdoingampitampampTheampaudienceamp
cheersampampSamanthaampandampEllenamphugamplikeampoldampfriends)amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 48amp
SamanthaampMesserampampHiampEllenampampItsampsoampgreatamptoampseeampyouampampamp
EDampampNoampSamanthaampitsampgreatamptoampseeampyouampampTellampusampaboutampwhatampbringsampyouamphereamptodayamp
SMampamp(Laughsampfreelyampwithoutampaampcare)ampEllenampyouampareampwhatampbroughtampmeamphereamptoday(
(Audienceamplaughs)amp
EDampampIampappreciateampthatampthankampyouampampButampletsampgetamptoampwhatsamponampAmericasampmindampampYouramp
lifesampworkampampIncredibleampampWhatampexactlyampisampitampandamphowampdidampitampcomeampaboutampampampampamp
SMampampEllenampwhereamptoampbeginampampampTheampideaampinampitsampmostampbasicampformampisampanampartampeducationampbasedamp
aroundamplisteningamppracticesamp
EDampampThatampsoundsampfascinatingampamp
SMampampIampknowampampThankampyouampforampnoticingampitsampsubtleampbrillianceamp
EDampampIampwouldampbeampaampfoolampnotamptoampampTellampusamphowampyouampcameampupampwithampthisampideaamp
SMampampampTheampcentralampcomponentampisampanampideaampcalledampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampwhichampisampaamp
spaceampinampwhichampstudentsampandampparticipantsampmakeampdiscussampandampviewampworksampofampartampwithamp
listeningampatamptheampcenterampofamptheseampactivitiesampandampexperiencesampampThisampideaampcameamptogetheramp
overamptheampcourseampofampmonthsampofampreadingamphundredsampofampdiscussionsampwithamppeersampresearchamp
participantsampandampprofessorsampasampwellampasamptheampwritingampandamprewritingampofampmanyampdraftsampofamp
myampnowampbestltsellingampbookamp
(Audienceampooooooohs)amp
EDampampWowampyouampreallyampputampsomeampthoughtampintoampthisamphuhampampSoamphowampisampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampdifferentampthanampaampregularampclassroomamp
SMampampWellampitampdependsamponamptheampclassroomampampSomeampclassroomsampprobablyampalreadyampareamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampampEssentiallyampitamprequiresampsomethingampofampanampattitudeampshiftampampItamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 49amp
doesntampevenampnecessarilyamphaveamptoampbeampinampaampclassroomamporampanyampspecificampplaceampampItsampmoreampofamp
aampstateampofampmindampandampanampattitudeamp
EDampampCouldampweampbeampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamprightampnowamp
SMampampEllenampnothingampwouldampgiveampmeampmoreamppleasureamp
(Audienceampawwwwws)amp
SMampampButampseriouslyampyesampweampcanampbeampampThoughampitampmightamptakeampmoreampthanampjustampanampattitudeamp
shiftampampWhenampIampinitiallyampbeganampthisampprojectampIampthoughtampthatsampallampitampwouldampbeampampIampassumedamp
thatampifampparticipantsampwereampwillingamptheyampcouldampenterampintoampthisampstateampofampmindampampamp
EDampampButampthatsampnotamptheampcaseamp
SMampampWellampitsampjustampthatampitsampmoreampcomplicatedampthanampthatampampWhatampIampfoundampwereampthatamptheamp
thingsampIampwasampaskingampindividualsamptoampdoampwereampnotampwithinampouramptypicalampculturalampskillampsetampamp
NotamponlyampthisampbutamptheyampareampdifficultampsubtleampandampoftenampinternalamppursuitsampampTheyampareampnotamp
easyamptoampseeampandamptheampresultsampareampnotampinstantaneousampampItsamphardamptoampknowampifampyoureampdoingamp
itamprightamp
EDampSoampwhatampdoesampitampmeanamptoampdoampitamprightamp
SMampampThatsampaampgreatampquestionampEllenampandampthankampyouampforampaskingampitampampIampdontampthinkamptheresamp
justamponeampwayampofampdoingampitamprightampampAndampevenampsometimesampwhenampyoureampdoingampitamprightampitamp
mightampnotampfeelamplikeampanythingampspecialampampItampcouldampjustampfeelamplikeampaampnormalampconversationamp
EDampampSoampthisampisampallampaboutamphavingampaampconversationampampIampdoampthatampfiveampdaysampaampweekamponampthisampsetamp
Samanthaampamp
(Audienceamplaughsamplightheartedly)amp
SMampampEllenampampYoureampcuttingampmeampdeepampamp(laughs)ampYoureamprightampampItsampnotamprevolutionaryampamp
Toamplistenamptoampbeamplistenedamptoamptoampcarryamponampanampopenampandamphonestampconversationampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 50amp
anotheramphumanampTheseampareamphumbleampgoalsampthatampweampcanampcarryampacrossampmanyampcontextsampampIamp
thinkampthereinampliesamptheampbeautyamp
EDampampInterestingampampImampgoingamptoampaskampwhatampImampsureampaamplotampofampteachersamphaveamponamptheiramp
mindsltlthowampdoampweampteachampthisamptoampstudentsamp
SMampampTheampgoalsampandampbeliefsampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmustampbeamplivedampthroughampandamp
undergoneampratherampthanampmerelyampactedampoutamponceamporamptwiceampampItsampaboutampcreatingampaampsystemamp
craftingampassignmentsampandampsettingampaamptoneampthatampallampunderlieamptheseampvaluesampampNotamponlyampthatamp
butamptheampstudentsampandampteachersampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmustampbeampreflectiveamptoamp
theirampexperiencesampampTheseampskillsampneedamptoampbeampbuiltampupampandampaampkeyampcomponentampofampthatampisamp
reflectionamponamppreviousampexperiencesamp
EDampampampIampunderstandampyouampalsoampsolicitedampsurveyampresponsesamptoampdiscussampmomentsampinampwhichamp
individualsampdidamporampdidampnotampfeelamplistenedamptoampasamptheyampspokeampaboutamptheirampartampampCanampyouamptalkamp
aamplittleampbitampaboutampwhatampyouampfoundampinamptheampsurveysamp
SMampampWellampIampcoveredampaamplotampofampthisampinampmyampbookampYoullamphaveamptoampreadampitampampIamphaveampprovidedamp
everyampmemberampofamptheampaudienceamptodayampwithampaampcopyampwhichampyoullampallampfindampunderampyouramp
seatsamp
(AudienceampgoesampwildampwithampexcitementampasamptheyampreachampunderamptheirampseatsampampThereampareamp
intermittentampscreechesampofampjoy)amp
EDampampWowampthankampyouampampTheampgiftampofamplisteningampwhatampaamptreasureampforamptheampaudienceamp
membersamptodayamp
(Audienceampclapsampwholeheartedly)amp
SMampampYoureampwelcomeampampInampgeneralampthoughampwhatampIampfoundampisampaampneedamptoamphandleamptheampwordsamp
andampexperiencesampofampothersampwithampcareampampTheampsurveysampdescribedampsituationsampinampwhichamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 51amp
individualsampfeltamptheyampwereampnotampbeingamplistenedamptoampyetamptheseampmomentsampwereampnotampusuallyamp
profoundlyamporamppurposefullyamphurtfulampampMoreampoftenamptheampsurveysampdescribedampinstancesampinamp
whichamppeopleampfeltampthatampanotheramppersonampwasntamptryingamptoampunderstandampampTheseamp
situationsampwereampmoreamppassiveampandampdismissiveampratherampthanampactivelyamphurtfulampthoughamp
theyampdidampstillamphurtamp
EDampampWellampcouldntampthatampbeampchalkedampupamptoamptheampsensitiveamppersonaampofamptheampartistampampWeampallamp
knowamphowampsensitiveampthoseampartistsampareamp
(Audienceamplaughsamptheyampareampinamponamptheampjoke)amp
SMampamp(chastising)ampEllenampyoureampsmarterampthanampthatampstereotypeampampIampmeanampyouampcouldampsayamp
thatampbutampIampdontampknowampifampthatampwouldampbeampproductiveampampAndampitampwouldntampfitampwithamptheamp
beliefsampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampinampmyampopinionampampDontampweampallampwantamptoampbeamplistenedamp
toampampIsampthatampdesireampexclusiveamptoampsomeampideaampweamphaveampinampourampheadampofampartistsampampIampdontamp
thinkampsoamp
EDampampYoureampsoamprightampSamanthaampampImampsorryampforampgivingampintoampsomeamppervasiveampmodernistamp
nonsenseampaboutampwhatampitampisamptoampbeampanampartistamp
(Audienceampnodsampinampagreement)amp
SMampampItsampokayampEllenampWeampinamptheampartampworldampareampfightingamptheampgoodampfightampWhatampweampdoampisamp
importantampandampwereamptiredampofampbeingampdismissedampbyampsocietyamp
(Audienceampclaps)amp
EDampampSoampwhatampisampyourampnextampstepamp
SMampampWellampIampwasampjustampawardedampaampspecialampmedalampofamphonorampfromampPresidentampObamaampamp
(PhotoampofampSamanthaampshakingamphandsampwithamptheampPresidentampflashesamponamptheampscreenampandamptheamp
audienceampclaps)amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 52amp
EDampampCongratulationsamp
SMampampThankampyouampampWhatampanamphonorampampAlongampwithampthisampcommendationampcameampaampgrantampforamp
meamptoampbeampableamptoamptrainampaampgroupampofamphighlyampspecializedampartistlteducatorsampinamptheseamp
practicesampandampsendampthemampoutamptoampcommunitiesampacrossamptheampcountryamptoamphelpampimplementamp
andampsupportampeffortsamptoampputampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampintoampschoolsampwhoampchooseamptoampbeamp
involvedampnationwideamp
(Aampthunderingampofampclappingampinamptheampaudience)amp
EDampampWhatampdoampyouampseeampareamptheamplonglttermampeffectsampofamptheampimplementationampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampamp
SMampampEllenampImampsureampIampdontamphaveamptoamptellampyouampthatampweampliveampinampaampfastltpacedamp
technologicallyltrevolutionaryampworldampampThereampareamppartsampofampthatampthatampareampwonderfulampandamp
makeampourampworldampanampeasierampplaceamptoampliveampampButampthereamphasamptoampbeamproomampforampusamptoampswitchampoffamp
unplugampandampslowampdownampampIampbelieveampthatamptheampplatformampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
unleashesampsomeamppossibilitiesampofamphumanampconnectionampinampaampveryamprealampauthenticampwayampamp
(Audienceamprisesampfromamptheirampseatsampwithamptearsampinamptheirampeyesampasamptheyampgiveampaampstandingamp
ovation)amp
EDampampAampnobleampgoalampindeedampampThankampyouampSamanthaampforampallampthatampyouampdoampampWhatampaampgamelt
changerampampThatsampallamptheamptimeampweamphaveampforamptodayampampItsampbeenampaamptrueamphonorampampGoodampluckampinamp
allampofampyourampendeavorsampampToampthoseampwatchingampatamphomeampgoamplistenamptoampsomeoneampamp
(SamanthaampEllenampandampaudienceampdanceampasamptheampcreditsamproll)amp
(
ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 53amp
loose(ends((References(
AndersonampEampHampampampSpencerampMampHamp(2013)ampAampPhenomenologicalampStudyampCognitiveamp
amp RepresentationsampofampAIDSampInampJampWampCreswellampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-
- Designamp(ppamp327lt346)ampLosampAngelesampSAGEampPublicationsampIncamp
BakerampGampampampMorrisampKamp(2002)ampDecartes-DualismampLondonampRoutledgeamp
BelenkyampMampFampClinchyampBampMampGoldbergerampNampRampampampTaruleampJampMamp(1997)ampWomens-Ways-
- of-Knowing-The-Development-of-Self-Voice-and-MindampNewampYorkampNYamp
amp BasicBooksamp
BleicherampJamp(1980)ampampContemporary-Hermeneutics-Hermeneutics-as-Method-
- Philosophy-and-Critique--LondonampUKampRoutledgeampampampKeeganampPaulamp
BohmampDamp(1996)ampOn-DialogueampLondonampUKampRoutledgeamp
BourgeoisampJampPamp(2007)ampThe-Aesthetic-Hermeneutics-of-Hans(Georg-Gadamer-and-Hans-
- Urs-von-BalthasarampNewampYorkampNYampPeterampLangampPublishingampIncamp
BrunsampGampLamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-Ancient-and-ModernampNewampHavenampCTampYaleamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
CalleampSamp(2011)ampBlindampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CalleampSamp(2005)ampExisquisite-PainampNewampYorkampThamesampampampHudsonamp
CalleampSamp(2008)ampTake-Care-of-YourselfampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CaputoampJamp(2000)ampMore-Radical-HermeneuticsampBloomingtonampINampIndianaampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
CreswellampJampWamp(2013)ampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-DesignampLosampAngelesampSAGEamp
amp PublicationsampIncamp
deampCossonampAamp(2002)ampTheampHermeneuticampDialogueampFindingampPatternsampamidamptheampAporiaamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 54amp
amp ofamptheampArtistResearcherTeacherampAlberta-Journal-of-Educational-Researchamp-
- 48amp(3)amp1lt20amp
ElkinsampJamp(2001)ampWhy-Art-Cannot-Be-TaughtampChicagoampILampUniversityampofampIllinoisampPressamp
FairfieldampPamp(2011)ampDialogueampinamptheampClassroomampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-
- Dialogue-and-Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp77lt90)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GadamerampHltGamp(1996)ampThe-Engima-of-HealthampStanfordampCAampStanfordampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
GadamerampHltGamp(2004)ampTruth-and-Methodamp(Secondamprevisedamped)amp(JampWeinsheimerampampamp
amp DampGampMarshallampTrans)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GallagherampSamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-and-EducationampAlbanyampNYampStateampUniversityampofamp
amp NewampYorkampPressamp
GendlinampEamp(1962)ampExperiencing-and-the-Creation-of-MeaningampNewampYorkampNYampTheamp
amp FreeampPressampofampGlencoeamp
GendlinampEamp(1997)ampampHowampPhilosophyampCannotampAppealamptoampExperienceampandampHowampItampCanamp
amp InampLanguage-beyond-Postmodernism-Saying-and-Thinking-in-Gendlins-
- Philosophy-(ppamp3lt41)ampEvanstonampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
GermeraadampGamp(2013)ampRationalityampIntuitionampandampEmotionampExploringampanampArtisticamp
amp ProcessampJournal-for-Artistic-Researchamp-3
GradleampSampAamp(2011)ampAampuniversityampcourseampinampmindfulampviewingampUnderstandingampartampandamp
amp selfampthroughampcontemplativeampexperienceampInternational-Journal-of-Education-
- Through-Artamp-7amp(2)amp137lt151amp
GreeneampMamp(2013)ampTheampTurningampofamptheampLeavesampExpandingampOurampVisionampforamptheampArtsampinamp
amp EducationampHarvard-Educational-Reviewamp-83amp(1)amp251lt252amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 55amp
GrondinampJamp(2002)ampGadamersampBasicampUnderstandingampofampUnderstandingampInampThe-
- Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp36lt51)ampCambridgeampUKampCambridgeamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
GrondinampJamp(2011)ampGadamersampExperienceampandampTheoryampofampEducationampLearningampthatamp
amp theampOtherampMayampBeampRightampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp5lt20)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
HeelanampPamp(1985)ampampPerceptionampasampaampHermeneuticalampActampampInampDampIhdeampampampHampSilvermanamp
amp (Eds)ampHermeneutics-amp-Deconstruction-(ppamp43lt54)-AlbanyampSUNYampPressamp
HeelanampPampampampSchulkinampJamp(2003)ampHermeneuticalampPhilosophyampandampPragmatismampAamp
amp PhilosophyampofampScienceampInampRampCampScharffampampampVampDusekamp(Eds)ampPhilosophy-of-
- Technology-The-Technological-Condition-an-Anthology-amp(ppamp138lt153)amp
amp MaldenampMAampBlackwellamp
KarpiakampIampEamp(2003)ampTheampListeningampHeartampTuningampInampForampTransformativeampLearningamp
amp 2003-Complexity-Science-and-Educational-Research-Conferenceamp(ppamp67lt80)amp
amp EdmontonampCanadaamp
KellyampMampPost(Partum-DocumentampInstituteampofampContemporaryampArtsampLondonamp
KentampSampJampampampCummingampJampamp(2008)ampampIampdontampknowampEngagingampwithampproblematicamp
amp momentsampinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampRadical-Pedagogy-2-(9)amp1lt20ampampamp
LevinampDampMamp(1989)ampThe-Listening-Self-Personal-Growth-Social-Change-and-the-
- Closure-of-MetaphysicsampNewampYorkampNYampRoutledgeamp
LindsethampAampampampNorbergampAamp(2004)ampAampphenomenologicalamphermeneuticalampmethodampforamp
amp researchingamplivedampexperienceampNordic-College-of-Caring-Sciencesamp-18amp145lt153amp
LipariampLamp(2014)ampampOnampinterlisteningampandamptheampideaampofampdialogueampampTheory-amp-Psychology-24-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 56amp
- (4)amp504lt523amp
MarksampLamp(2002)ampTouch-Sensuous-Theory-and-Multisensory-MediaampMinneapolisamp
amp UniversityampofampMinnesotaampPressamp
MunozampKampLamp(2014)ampTranscribing-Silence-Culture-Relationship-and-Communicationamp
amp WalnutampCreekampCAampLeftampCoastampPressamp
NicholampLamp(1996)ampForewordampInampDampBohmampOn-Dialogueamp(ppampviiltxvii)ampLondonampUKamp
amp Routledgeamp
PalmerampRamp(1969)ampHermeneutics-Interpretation-Theory-in-Schleiermacher-Dilthey-
- Heidegger-and-GadamerampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
PerlampSamp(2004)ampFelt-Sense-Writing-with-the-BodyampPortsmouthampNHampBoyntonCookamp
RicoeurampPamp(19691974)ampThe-Conflicts-of-Interpretations-Essays-in-Hermeneuticsamp
amp (NorthwesternampUniversityampPressampTrans)ampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
RicoeurampPamp(2013)ampHermeneuticsampCambridgeampUKampPolityampPressamp
SableampDamp(2014)ampReasonampinamptheampServiceampofamptheampHeartampTheampImpactsampofampContemplativeamp
amp PracticesamponampCriticalampThinkingampJournal-of-Contemplative-Inquiryamp-1amp(1)amp1lt22amp
SchultzampKamp(2010)ampAfteramptheampBlackbirdampWhistlesampListeningamptoampSilenceampinampClassroomsamp
amp Teachers-College-Recordamp-112amp(11)amp2833lt2849amp
SeebohmampTampamp(2004)ampampHermeneutics-Method-and-MethodologyampDordrechtamptheamp
amp NetherlandsampKluwerampAcademicampPublishersamp
SnowberampCamp(2005)ampTheampmentorampasampartistampaamppoeticampexplorationampofamplisteningampcreatingamp
amp andampmentoringampMentoring-and-Tutoring-13amp(3)amp345lt353amp
vanampManenampMampamp(1984)ampPracticingampPhenomenologicalampWritingampPhenomenology-+-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 57amp
- Pedagogy-2amp(1)amp36lt68amp
vanampManenampMamp(1990)ampampResearching-Lived-Experience-Human-Science-for-an-Action(
- Sensitive-PedagogyampNewampYorkampSUNYampPressamp
VitanovaampGamp(2010)ampampAuthoring-the-Dialogic-SelfampAmsterdamampJohnampBenjaminsamp
amp PublishingampCoamp
WatsonampJamp(2013)ampampKnowingampthroughamptheampfeltltsenseampaampgestureampofampopennessamptoamptheamp
amp otherampampInternational-Journal-of-Childrens-Spirituality-18amp(1)amp118lt130amp
WiercinskiampAamp(2011)ampHermeneuticampEducationamptoampUnderstandingampSelfltEducationampandamp
amp theampWillingnessamptoampRiskampFailureampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp107lt124)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
WorsleyampRamp(2012)ampNarrativesampandamplivelyampmetaphorsampHermeneuticsampasampaampwayampofamp
amp listeningampPerson(Centered-amp-Experiential-Psychotherapiesamp-11amp(4)amp304lt320amp
ZuckertampCampHamp(2002)ampHermeneuticsampinampPracticeampGadameramponampAncientampPhilosophyampInamp
amp RampJampDostalamp(Ed)ampThe-Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp201lt224)amp
amp CambridgeampUKampCambridgeampUniversityampPressamp
amp
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
- WebsitePaper-20
- WebsitePaper-18
- WebsitePaperpdf
-
- MesserFinalPaper-11
- MesserFinalPaper
-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 40amp
amp Iampbeganamptheampsessionsampbyampinformingamptheampparticipantampthatampbothampofampusampwereampinampaamp
creativeltlisteningampspaceampandampthenampIampbrieflyampdescribedampwhatampthatampmeantampampThisampstepampsetamp
theamptoneampforamptheampencounterampampThenamptheampparticipantampandampIampreadamptheampBeliefsampinampaamp
CreativeltListeningampSpaceampsectionamp(figamp2)ampampIampaskedampifamptheampparticipantamphadampanyamp
questionsamporampcommentsampaboutamptheseamppracticesampampThenampIampshowedamptheampparticipantamptheamp
nextamphandoutamp(figamp3)ampampWeampeachampfilledampoutamptheamphandoutampwritingampourampnamesampinamptheamp
appropriateampspacesampampWeampreadampoveramptheamplistampofampactivitiesamponamptheampleftampsideampofamptheamppaperampampIamp
askedampparticipantsamptoampchooseamponeampqualityamptoampfocusamponampandampweampsharedampwhatamptheampfocusamp
wouldampbeampforampeachampofampusampandampwhyampampThenampIampintroducedamptheamppromptampaampselfltportraitampinamp
threeampminutesampampThisampselfltportraitampwasampcompletelyampopenltendedampinamptermsampofampstyleamp
techniqueampandampsubjectampmatterampampTheampmainampqualificationsampwereampthatampitampfeltamp
representativeampofamptheampartistampinampthatampmomentampampAfterampweamphadampspentampthreeampminutesamponamp
ourampselfampportraitsampweamptalkedampaboutampwhatampweampdrewampandampwhyampampIampgaveampparticipantsamptheamp
opportunityamptoampcontinueamptoampdrawampasampweampspokeampampampWhenampIampfeltampthatamptheampsessionampwasamp
drawingamptoampaampnaturalampcloseampeachampofampusampfilledampoutamptheampevaluationamphandoutamp(figamp3)ampbyamp
circlingampwhatampweampfeltampweamphadampexperiencedampduringamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampampamp
amp
thread7(
Responding(to(Response(Layers(of(Listening(Understandingamp
amp Theampamountampofampdataamptheampexperiencesampandamptheampknowledgeampaccruedampoveramptheamp
courseampofampthisampprojectamphasampbeenamptoampsayamptheampleastampoverwhelmingampandamphumblingampamp
WritingampaamppassageampinampresponseamphasampbeenampaampsignificantampchallengeltlthowampshouldampIampdoamp
justiceamptoamptheampindividualsampwhoampsharedamptheirampstoriesampampWhatampisamptheampappropriateampmediumamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 41amp
forampsuchampaampventureampampHowampdoampIampsumampupampwhatampIamphaveamplearnedampfromampthemampandampfromamptheamp
experiencesampgeneratedampwithinampthisampresearchamp
amp InampanampattemptamptoampansweramporampsimplyampliveampinamptheseampquestionsampIampwouldampfirstamplikeamptoamp
discussamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampWhenamptaskedampwithampdescribingampsituationsampofampbeingamp
listenedamptoamporampnotampsurveyampparticipantsamphadampaamplotamptoampsayampampRarelyampdidampindividualsampgiveamp
oneltwordamporampevenamponeltsentenceampanswersampampNearlyampeveryoneamphadampexperiencesamptheyamp
wantedamptoampshareampandamptheseampexperiencesampwereampoftenampdescribedampusingamplanguageampthatamp
carriedampwithampitamptheampweightampofampemotionampandampvulnerabilityampampSomeampofamptheseampresponsesamp
continueamptoampstickamptoampmeampampMyampunderstandingampofampotherampresponsesampevolvedampoveramptheamp
courseampofampmyampinteractionsampwithampthemampampamp
amp Inampgeneralamptheampnegativeamplisteningampsituationsampdescribedampwereampnotampusuallyamp
purposefullyamphurtfulampampMoreampoftenampparticipantsampdescribedampfeelingampdismissedampampThisamp
sometimesampdidntampevenamptranslateampintoampwritingampampParticipantsampwroteampaboutampsituationsampinamp
whichamptheamplanguageampofamptheampencounterampdidntampalwaysampmatchamptheampemotionampfeltampampForamp
exampleamponeampsurveyampparticipantampdescribedampanampexperienceampinampwhichampaampfamilyampmemberamp
saidampWowampIampneverampthoughtampwouldveampthoughtamptoampmakeampaampportraitampthatampwayamp(Surveyamp
responseampLSampageamp27)ampampInampexamplesamplikeampthisampnegativeampinteractionsampwereampfeltampratheramp
thanamparticulatedampdirectlyampampTheseampmomentsampwereampbasedamparoundampintonationampemphasisamp
andamppresumedampsubtextampratherampthanampexplicitamporampdeliberateampwordampchoiceampampamp
amp IampamampundoubtedlyampmakingampsomeampassumptionsampasampIampsayampthisampbutamptheampsurveyamp
responsesampindicatedampthatampitsampeasyamptoampbeampunintentionallyamphurtfulampampItsampmuchampharderamptoamp
handleamptheampwordsampandampcreativeampworkampofampanotherampwithampcareampampInampfactampthisamptakesampconstantamp
questioningampandampreflectionampampTheamppositiveampresponsesampusuallyampindicatedampaampsenseampofamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 42amp
connectionamprestraintampandampgenuineampinterestampampSomeampdescribedampsilenceampasampaampkeyamp
componentampofamplisteningampandampothersampdiscussedamptheampsituationsampinampwhichamptheamplisteneramp
asksampquestionsamporampmake[s]ampcommentsampthatampallowampyouamptoampfeelampjustifiedampinampwhatampyouveamp
saidamp(SurveyampresponseampCHampageamp47)ampampStillampothersampreferredamptoamptheamppowerampofamp
interpretationampandamptheampintentampofamptheampartistampasampaampguideampforampknowingampthatamponesampworkamp
wasampunderstoodamp
amp Asampforamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcaseampstudiesampthisampideaampandamptheampexperiencesamp
thatampbroughtampitamptoampfruitionampareampstillampinamptheirampinfancyampampThisampresearchampprojectampgaveampmeamptheamp
firstampstepsampintoamptheamppossibilitiesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampandampIamplookampforwardamptoamp
understandingampmoreampaboutamphowampitampwouldamplookamptoampimplementampthisampframeworkampintoampaamp
classroomamporampstudioampcontextampampInitiallyampIampthoughtampthatampIampcouldampjustampaskampparticipantsamptoamp
enterampintoampaampstateampofampmindampthatampwouldampbeampconduciveamptoampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampIamp
assumedampthatampitampwasampmoreamplikeampaampshiftampinampattitudeampthanampaamplearnedampbehaviorampampButampIampwasamp
wrongltlttheampshiftampinampattitudeampcomesampfromampgradualamplearningampoveramptimeampampToampachieveampthisamp
thereampneedsamptoampbeampaampsystemampofampscaffoldingampinampplaceampampThisampscaffoldingampcanampincludeamp
specificampwaysampofampinteractingampinampclassroomsampstudiosampandampviewingampspacesampassignmentsamp
andampprojectsampcenteredamparoundampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampexperiencesampinvestigationampofamp
collageampjournalampwritingampexercisesampinamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampsustainedamp
engagementsampinampviewingampworksampofampartampteacherampmodelingampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
behaviorsampandampsoamponampampThisamprealizationampcameamptooamplateampinamptheampresearchamptoampfullyampengageamp
withamppossibleampsolutionsampbutampIamplookampforwardamptoampdevelopingamptheseampoveramptheampcourseampofamp
myampcareeramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 43amp
amp Theamprealizationampthatampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamprequireampmoreampthanampjustampanamp
attitudeampshiftampcameampfromampanotheramponeampofamptheampbiggestampoutcomesampofampthisampresearchampampTheamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampIampenactedamphadampsomethingampofampaampdominoampeffectamponampmyamppracticesamp
withinampthemampampTheampmostampimportantampaspectampofampenactingampthemampwasampbeingampreflexiveamptoamp
whatamphappenedampwithinampthemampampIampwasampconstantlyampaskingampmyselfampwhatampwasampworkingamp
whatampneededamptoampchangeampandampwhatampcouldampmakeampitampbetterampampIampreflectedamponampmyampownampstateamp
ofampmindampandamphowampthatampinformedampmyampexperiencesampandamptheampexperiencesampofampanotherampampIamp
reflectedamponampmyampassumptionsampampIampthoughtampthatampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmightamphaveampaamp
certainampkindampofampfeelingampaamptransformativeampclickampthatampwouldampletampmeampknowampitampwasamp
workingampampButampitsampnotampthatampsimpleampampAampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampmanifestampitselfampinamp
soampmanyampwaysampthatampitsampimpossibleamptoampidentifyampthemampallampampItampcouldampfeelamplikeampaampregularamp
conversationamporampcritiqueampitampcouldampfeelampuncomfortableamporampeasyampampItampcouldamphaveampaampuniqueamp
asltyetltunknownampqualityampampLikeampaampworkampofampartampitampcouldamptakeamponampanyampnumberampofampformsamp
andamppossibilitiesampMyampassumptionampthatampitampwouldamptakeamponamponeampeasylttoltrecognizeamp
manifestationampwasampnotampasampnuancedampasampthisampresearchampindicatesamptheamppossibilitiesampwouldamp
haveamptoampbeampampamp
amp FinallyampinampresponseamptoampresponseampIampcreatedampaamptextltobjectamp(Imagesamp1ampampamp2)ampthatamp
offersamponeamppossibleamparticulationamptoamptheampsurveysampandampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcaseamp
studiesampampIampwouldamplikeamptoampletampthisamponeamppossibilityampserveampasampaampmarkerampforamptheampinfiniteamp
possibilitiesampIampdidampnotampmakeampexploreampexpressamporampundergoampbutampthatampcontinueamptoampexistamp
inamptheamprealmampofampwhatltmightltbeamp
amp ThisamptextltobjectampisampakinamptoampaampmovingamppieceampofamppoetryampampToampcreateamptheamptextampIamp
collagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampfromamptheampsurveyampresponsesampinampanampeffortamptoamphonoramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 44amp
manyampvoicesampampTheamptextampisampopenampandampflowingampwithampnoampclearampbeginningamporampendampampTheamp
concealampandamprevealampaspectampofamptheampworkampcallsamptoampmindamptheampactampofampresearchampandampinquiryampinamp
generalampampTheampthickampblackampscribblesamponamptheampmovingampcirclesampareampderivedampfromamptheampfieldamp
notesampIamptookampduringampmyampexperiencesampwithampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcaseampstudiesampampTheamp
overlappingampdenseampqualityampofampthisamptextampcallsamptoampmindamptheampdensenessampofamptheseamp
experiencesampandamptheampoverwhelmingampimpossibilityampofampabsorbingampeverythingampIampcouldamp
containampamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 47amp
thread8(amp
(In)conclusions(amp
amp InamptheampwordsampofampPaulampFairfieldamp(2011)ampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinampdialogueampnoamp
interpretationampthatampisampuniquelyampandampsupremelyampauthoritativeamp(pamp83)ampampThoughampthisamp
paperampisampendingampthereampisampnoamplastampwordamponamptheampmatterampofamplisteningampforampmeampnorampforamp
studentsampteachersamphumansampworksampofampartamptextsampadampinfinitumampampThisampmyampnotltsolt
conclusiveltconcludingampsectionampstretchesamptheamppossibilityampofampmyampresearchampinampaampmanneramp
thatampdefiesamptheampsupremelyampauthoritativeampstructureampofampanampacademicampresearchamppaperampampamp
amp
Below-is-the-transcript-from-an-episode-dated-April-6-2015-of-the-popular-daytime-
talk-show-Ellen-during-which-the-artistresearcheducator-was-invited-to-discuss-her-
groundbreaking-work-on-listening-
(Camerasamprollampinamp3amp2amp1ampSceneampopensamponamptheampsetampof-EllenampampCameraamppansampinamptoampfocusamp
onampEllenampampSheampisampseatedamponampaamploveseatampwearingampaampcreamltcoloredamppantsuitampwithampaamplightamp
blueampbuttonltupampshirtampampHeramphairampisampperfectlyampcoiffedampampLightsampflashampandamptheampcrowdamp
cheersampampIntroampmusicampswells)-
EllenampDegeneresampampHelloampeveryoneampampWelcomeamptoamptheampshowamptodayampampTheampfirstamponlyampandamp
mostampimportantampguestamponamptodaysampshowampisampSamanthaampMesserampampSamanthaampisampanampartistamp
researcherampandampeducatorampbasedampinampCincinnatiampOhioampwhoseamprecentampresearchampprojectamp
onamplisteningampinampartampeducationamphasamptheamppotentialamptoampchangeamptheampfaceampofampnotamponlyampartamp
educationampbutampalsoamptheampworldampampHereampsheampisampSamanthaampMesseramp
(SamanthaampwalksamponamptheampstageamplookingampsleekampasamphellampwhileampdoingampitampampTheampaudienceamp
cheersampampSamanthaampandampEllenamphugamplikeampoldampfriends)amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 48amp
SamanthaampMesserampampHiampEllenampampItsampsoampgreatamptoampseeampyouampampamp
EDampampNoampSamanthaampitsampgreatamptoampseeampyouampampTellampusampaboutampwhatampbringsampyouamphereamptodayamp
SMampamp(Laughsampfreelyampwithoutampaampcare)ampEllenampyouampareampwhatampbroughtampmeamphereamptoday(
(Audienceamplaughs)amp
EDampampIampappreciateampthatampthankampyouampampButampletsampgetamptoampwhatsamponampAmericasampmindampampYouramp
lifesampworkampampIncredibleampampWhatampexactlyampisampitampandamphowampdidampitampcomeampaboutampampampampamp
SMampampEllenampwhereamptoampbeginampampampTheampideaampinampitsampmostampbasicampformampisampanampartampeducationampbasedamp
aroundamplisteningamppracticesamp
EDampampThatampsoundsampfascinatingampamp
SMampampIampknowampampThankampyouampforampnoticingampitsampsubtleampbrillianceamp
EDampampIampwouldampbeampaampfoolampnotamptoampampTellampusamphowampyouampcameampupampwithampthisampideaamp
SMampampampTheampcentralampcomponentampisampanampideaampcalledampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampwhichampisampaamp
spaceampinampwhichampstudentsampandampparticipantsampmakeampdiscussampandampviewampworksampofampartampwithamp
listeningampatamptheampcenterampofamptheseampactivitiesampandampexperiencesampampThisampideaampcameamptogetheramp
overamptheampcourseampofampmonthsampofampreadingamphundredsampofampdiscussionsampwithamppeersampresearchamp
participantsampandampprofessorsampasampwellampasamptheampwritingampandamprewritingampofampmanyampdraftsampofamp
myampnowampbestltsellingampbookamp
(Audienceampooooooohs)amp
EDampampWowampyouampreallyampputampsomeampthoughtampintoampthisamphuhampampSoamphowampisampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampdifferentampthanampaampregularampclassroomamp
SMampampWellampitampdependsamponamptheampclassroomampampSomeampclassroomsampprobablyampalreadyampareamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampampEssentiallyampitamprequiresampsomethingampofampanampattitudeampshiftampampItamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 49amp
doesntampevenampnecessarilyamphaveamptoampbeampinampaampclassroomamporampanyampspecificampplaceampampItsampmoreampofamp
aampstateampofampmindampandampanampattitudeamp
EDampampCouldampweampbeampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamprightampnowamp
SMampampEllenampnothingampwouldampgiveampmeampmoreamppleasureamp
(Audienceampawwwwws)amp
SMampampButampseriouslyampyesampweampcanampbeampampThoughampitampmightamptakeampmoreampthanampjustampanampattitudeamp
shiftampampWhenampIampinitiallyampbeganampthisampprojectampIampthoughtampthatsampallampitampwouldampbeampampIampassumedamp
thatampifampparticipantsampwereampwillingamptheyampcouldampenterampintoampthisampstateampofampmindampampamp
EDampampButampthatsampnotamptheampcaseamp
SMampampWellampitsampjustampthatampitsampmoreampcomplicatedampthanampthatampampWhatampIampfoundampwereampthatamptheamp
thingsampIampwasampaskingampindividualsamptoampdoampwereampnotampwithinampouramptypicalampculturalampskillampsetampamp
NotamponlyampthisampbutamptheyampareampdifficultampsubtleampandampoftenampinternalamppursuitsampampTheyampareampnotamp
easyamptoampseeampandamptheampresultsampareampnotampinstantaneousampampItsamphardamptoampknowampifampyoureampdoingamp
itamprightamp
EDampSoampwhatampdoesampitampmeanamptoampdoampitamprightamp
SMampampThatsampaampgreatampquestionampEllenampandampthankampyouampforampaskingampitampampIampdontampthinkamptheresamp
justamponeampwayampofampdoingampitamprightampampAndampevenampsometimesampwhenampyoureampdoingampitamprightampitamp
mightampnotampfeelamplikeampanythingampspecialampampItampcouldampjustampfeelamplikeampaampnormalampconversationamp
EDampampSoampthisampisampallampaboutamphavingampaampconversationampampIampdoampthatampfiveampdaysampaampweekamponampthisampsetamp
Samanthaampamp
(Audienceamplaughsamplightheartedly)amp
SMampampEllenampampYoureampcuttingampmeampdeepampamp(laughs)ampYoureamprightampampItsampnotamprevolutionaryampamp
Toamplistenamptoampbeamplistenedamptoamptoampcarryamponampanampopenampandamphonestampconversationampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 50amp
anotheramphumanampTheseampareamphumbleampgoalsampthatampweampcanampcarryampacrossampmanyampcontextsampampIamp
thinkampthereinampliesamptheampbeautyamp
EDampampInterestingampampImampgoingamptoampaskampwhatampImampsureampaamplotampofampteachersamphaveamponamptheiramp
mindsltlthowampdoampweampteachampthisamptoampstudentsamp
SMampampTheampgoalsampandampbeliefsampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmustampbeamplivedampthroughampandamp
undergoneampratherampthanampmerelyampactedampoutamponceamporamptwiceampampItsampaboutampcreatingampaampsystemamp
craftingampassignmentsampandampsettingampaamptoneampthatampallampunderlieamptheseampvaluesampampNotamponlyampthatamp
butamptheampstudentsampandampteachersampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmustampbeampreflectiveamptoamp
theirampexperiencesampampTheseampskillsampneedamptoampbeampbuiltampupampandampaampkeyampcomponentampofampthatampisamp
reflectionamponamppreviousampexperiencesamp
EDampampampIampunderstandampyouampalsoampsolicitedampsurveyampresponsesamptoampdiscussampmomentsampinampwhichamp
individualsampdidamporampdidampnotampfeelamplistenedamptoampasamptheyampspokeampaboutamptheirampartampampCanampyouamptalkamp
aamplittleampbitampaboutampwhatampyouampfoundampinamptheampsurveysamp
SMampampWellampIampcoveredampaamplotampofampthisampinampmyampbookampYoullamphaveamptoampreadampitampampIamphaveampprovidedamp
everyampmemberampofamptheampaudienceamptodayampwithampaampcopyampwhichampyoullampallampfindampunderampyouramp
seatsamp
(AudienceampgoesampwildampwithampexcitementampasamptheyampreachampunderamptheirampseatsampampThereampareamp
intermittentampscreechesampofampjoy)amp
EDampampWowampthankampyouampampTheampgiftampofamplisteningampwhatampaamptreasureampforamptheampaudienceamp
membersamptodayamp
(Audienceampclapsampwholeheartedly)amp
SMampampYoureampwelcomeampampInampgeneralampthoughampwhatampIampfoundampisampaampneedamptoamphandleamptheampwordsamp
andampexperiencesampofampothersampwithampcareampampTheampsurveysampdescribedampsituationsampinampwhichamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 51amp
individualsampfeltamptheyampwereampnotampbeingamplistenedamptoampyetamptheseampmomentsampwereampnotampusuallyamp
profoundlyamporamppurposefullyamphurtfulampampMoreampoftenamptheampsurveysampdescribedampinstancesampinamp
whichamppeopleampfeltampthatampanotheramppersonampwasntamptryingamptoampunderstandampampTheseamp
situationsampwereampmoreamppassiveampandampdismissiveampratherampthanampactivelyamphurtfulampthoughamp
theyampdidampstillamphurtamp
EDampampWellampcouldntampthatampbeampchalkedampupamptoamptheampsensitiveamppersonaampofamptheampartistampampWeampallamp
knowamphowampsensitiveampthoseampartistsampareamp
(Audienceamplaughsamptheyampareampinamponamptheampjoke)amp
SMampamp(chastising)ampEllenampyoureampsmarterampthanampthatampstereotypeampampIampmeanampyouampcouldampsayamp
thatampbutampIampdontampknowampifampthatampwouldampbeampproductiveampampAndampitampwouldntampfitampwithamptheamp
beliefsampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampinampmyampopinionampampDontampweampallampwantamptoampbeamplistenedamp
toampampIsampthatampdesireampexclusiveamptoampsomeampideaampweamphaveampinampourampheadampofampartistsampampIampdontamp
thinkampsoamp
EDampampYoureampsoamprightampSamanthaampampImampsorryampforampgivingampintoampsomeamppervasiveampmodernistamp
nonsenseampaboutampwhatampitampisamptoampbeampanampartistamp
(Audienceampnodsampinampagreement)amp
SMampampItsampokayampEllenampWeampinamptheampartampworldampareampfightingamptheampgoodampfightampWhatampweampdoampisamp
importantampandampwereamptiredampofampbeingampdismissedampbyampsocietyamp
(Audienceampclaps)amp
EDampampSoampwhatampisampyourampnextampstepamp
SMampampWellampIampwasampjustampawardedampaampspecialampmedalampofamphonorampfromampPresidentampObamaampamp
(PhotoampofampSamanthaampshakingamphandsampwithamptheampPresidentampflashesamponamptheampscreenampandamptheamp
audienceampclaps)amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 52amp
EDampampCongratulationsamp
SMampampThankampyouampampWhatampanamphonorampampAlongampwithampthisampcommendationampcameampaampgrantampforamp
meamptoampbeampableamptoamptrainampaampgroupampofamphighlyampspecializedampartistlteducatorsampinamptheseamp
practicesampandampsendampthemampoutamptoampcommunitiesampacrossamptheampcountryamptoamphelpampimplementamp
andampsupportampeffortsamptoampputampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampintoampschoolsampwhoampchooseamptoampbeamp
involvedampnationwideamp
(Aampthunderingampofampclappingampinamptheampaudience)amp
EDampampWhatampdoampyouampseeampareamptheamplonglttermampeffectsampofamptheampimplementationampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampamp
SMampampEllenampImampsureampIampdontamphaveamptoamptellampyouampthatampweampliveampinampaampfastltpacedamp
technologicallyltrevolutionaryampworldampampThereampareamppartsampofampthatampthatampareampwonderfulampandamp
makeampourampworldampanampeasierampplaceamptoampliveampampButampthereamphasamptoampbeamproomampforampusamptoampswitchampoffamp
unplugampandampslowampdownampampIampbelieveampthatamptheampplatformampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
unleashesampsomeamppossibilitiesampofamphumanampconnectionampinampaampveryamprealampauthenticampwayampamp
(Audienceamprisesampfromamptheirampseatsampwithamptearsampinamptheirampeyesampasamptheyampgiveampaampstandingamp
ovation)amp
EDampampAampnobleampgoalampindeedampampThankampyouampSamanthaampforampallampthatampyouampdoampampWhatampaampgamelt
changerampampThatsampallamptheamptimeampweamphaveampforamptodayampampItsampbeenampaamptrueamphonorampampGoodampluckampinamp
allampofampyourampendeavorsampampToampthoseampwatchingampatamphomeampgoamplistenamptoampsomeoneampamp
(SamanthaampEllenampandampaudienceampdanceampasamptheampcreditsamproll)amp
(
ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 53amp
loose(ends((References(
AndersonampEampHampampampSpencerampMampHamp(2013)ampAampPhenomenologicalampStudyampCognitiveamp
amp RepresentationsampofampAIDSampInampJampWampCreswellampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-
- Designamp(ppamp327lt346)ampLosampAngelesampSAGEampPublicationsampIncamp
BakerampGampampampMorrisampKamp(2002)ampDecartes-DualismampLondonampRoutledgeamp
BelenkyampMampFampClinchyampBampMampGoldbergerampNampRampampampTaruleampJampMamp(1997)ampWomens-Ways-
- of-Knowing-The-Development-of-Self-Voice-and-MindampNewampYorkampNYamp
amp BasicBooksamp
BleicherampJamp(1980)ampampContemporary-Hermeneutics-Hermeneutics-as-Method-
- Philosophy-and-Critique--LondonampUKampRoutledgeampampampKeeganampPaulamp
BohmampDamp(1996)ampOn-DialogueampLondonampUKampRoutledgeamp
BourgeoisampJampPamp(2007)ampThe-Aesthetic-Hermeneutics-of-Hans(Georg-Gadamer-and-Hans-
- Urs-von-BalthasarampNewampYorkampNYampPeterampLangampPublishingampIncamp
BrunsampGampLamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-Ancient-and-ModernampNewampHavenampCTampYaleamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
CalleampSamp(2011)ampBlindampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CalleampSamp(2005)ampExisquisite-PainampNewampYorkampThamesampampampHudsonamp
CalleampSamp(2008)ampTake-Care-of-YourselfampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CaputoampJamp(2000)ampMore-Radical-HermeneuticsampBloomingtonampINampIndianaampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
CreswellampJampWamp(2013)ampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-DesignampLosampAngelesampSAGEamp
amp PublicationsampIncamp
deampCossonampAamp(2002)ampTheampHermeneuticampDialogueampFindingampPatternsampamidamptheampAporiaamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 54amp
amp ofamptheampArtistResearcherTeacherampAlberta-Journal-of-Educational-Researchamp-
- 48amp(3)amp1lt20amp
ElkinsampJamp(2001)ampWhy-Art-Cannot-Be-TaughtampChicagoampILampUniversityampofampIllinoisampPressamp
FairfieldampPamp(2011)ampDialogueampinamptheampClassroomampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-
- Dialogue-and-Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp77lt90)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GadamerampHltGamp(1996)ampThe-Engima-of-HealthampStanfordampCAampStanfordampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
GadamerampHltGamp(2004)ampTruth-and-Methodamp(Secondamprevisedamped)amp(JampWeinsheimerampampamp
amp DampGampMarshallampTrans)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GallagherampSamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-and-EducationampAlbanyampNYampStateampUniversityampofamp
amp NewampYorkampPressamp
GendlinampEamp(1962)ampExperiencing-and-the-Creation-of-MeaningampNewampYorkampNYampTheamp
amp FreeampPressampofampGlencoeamp
GendlinampEamp(1997)ampampHowampPhilosophyampCannotampAppealamptoampExperienceampandampHowampItampCanamp
amp InampLanguage-beyond-Postmodernism-Saying-and-Thinking-in-Gendlins-
- Philosophy-(ppamp3lt41)ampEvanstonampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
GermeraadampGamp(2013)ampRationalityampIntuitionampandampEmotionampExploringampanampArtisticamp
amp ProcessampJournal-for-Artistic-Researchamp-3
GradleampSampAamp(2011)ampAampuniversityampcourseampinampmindfulampviewingampUnderstandingampartampandamp
amp selfampthroughampcontemplativeampexperienceampInternational-Journal-of-Education-
- Through-Artamp-7amp(2)amp137lt151amp
GreeneampMamp(2013)ampTheampTurningampofamptheampLeavesampExpandingampOurampVisionampforamptheampArtsampinamp
amp EducationampHarvard-Educational-Reviewamp-83amp(1)amp251lt252amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 55amp
GrondinampJamp(2002)ampGadamersampBasicampUnderstandingampofampUnderstandingampInampThe-
- Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp36lt51)ampCambridgeampUKampCambridgeamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
GrondinampJamp(2011)ampGadamersampExperienceampandampTheoryampofampEducationampLearningampthatamp
amp theampOtherampMayampBeampRightampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp5lt20)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
HeelanampPamp(1985)ampampPerceptionampasampaampHermeneuticalampActampampInampDampIhdeampampampHampSilvermanamp
amp (Eds)ampHermeneutics-amp-Deconstruction-(ppamp43lt54)-AlbanyampSUNYampPressamp
HeelanampPampampampSchulkinampJamp(2003)ampHermeneuticalampPhilosophyampandampPragmatismampAamp
amp PhilosophyampofampScienceampInampRampCampScharffampampampVampDusekamp(Eds)ampPhilosophy-of-
- Technology-The-Technological-Condition-an-Anthology-amp(ppamp138lt153)amp
amp MaldenampMAampBlackwellamp
KarpiakampIampEamp(2003)ampTheampListeningampHeartampTuningampInampForampTransformativeampLearningamp
amp 2003-Complexity-Science-and-Educational-Research-Conferenceamp(ppamp67lt80)amp
amp EdmontonampCanadaamp
KellyampMampPost(Partum-DocumentampInstituteampofampContemporaryampArtsampLondonamp
KentampSampJampampampCummingampJampamp(2008)ampampIampdontampknowampEngagingampwithampproblematicamp
amp momentsampinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampRadical-Pedagogy-2-(9)amp1lt20ampampamp
LevinampDampMamp(1989)ampThe-Listening-Self-Personal-Growth-Social-Change-and-the-
- Closure-of-MetaphysicsampNewampYorkampNYampRoutledgeamp
LindsethampAampampampNorbergampAamp(2004)ampAampphenomenologicalamphermeneuticalampmethodampforamp
amp researchingamplivedampexperienceampNordic-College-of-Caring-Sciencesamp-18amp145lt153amp
LipariampLamp(2014)ampampOnampinterlisteningampandamptheampideaampofampdialogueampampTheory-amp-Psychology-24-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 56amp
- (4)amp504lt523amp
MarksampLamp(2002)ampTouch-Sensuous-Theory-and-Multisensory-MediaampMinneapolisamp
amp UniversityampofampMinnesotaampPressamp
MunozampKampLamp(2014)ampTranscribing-Silence-Culture-Relationship-and-Communicationamp
amp WalnutampCreekampCAampLeftampCoastampPressamp
NicholampLamp(1996)ampForewordampInampDampBohmampOn-Dialogueamp(ppampviiltxvii)ampLondonampUKamp
amp Routledgeamp
PalmerampRamp(1969)ampHermeneutics-Interpretation-Theory-in-Schleiermacher-Dilthey-
- Heidegger-and-GadamerampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
PerlampSamp(2004)ampFelt-Sense-Writing-with-the-BodyampPortsmouthampNHampBoyntonCookamp
RicoeurampPamp(19691974)ampThe-Conflicts-of-Interpretations-Essays-in-Hermeneuticsamp
amp (NorthwesternampUniversityampPressampTrans)ampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
RicoeurampPamp(2013)ampHermeneuticsampCambridgeampUKampPolityampPressamp
SableampDamp(2014)ampReasonampinamptheampServiceampofamptheampHeartampTheampImpactsampofampContemplativeamp
amp PracticesamponampCriticalampThinkingampJournal-of-Contemplative-Inquiryamp-1amp(1)amp1lt22amp
SchultzampKamp(2010)ampAfteramptheampBlackbirdampWhistlesampListeningamptoampSilenceampinampClassroomsamp
amp Teachers-College-Recordamp-112amp(11)amp2833lt2849amp
SeebohmampTampamp(2004)ampampHermeneutics-Method-and-MethodologyampDordrechtamptheamp
amp NetherlandsampKluwerampAcademicampPublishersamp
SnowberampCamp(2005)ampTheampmentorampasampartistampaamppoeticampexplorationampofamplisteningampcreatingamp
amp andampmentoringampMentoring-and-Tutoring-13amp(3)amp345lt353amp
vanampManenampMampamp(1984)ampPracticingampPhenomenologicalampWritingampPhenomenology-+-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 57amp
- Pedagogy-2amp(1)amp36lt68amp
vanampManenampMamp(1990)ampampResearching-Lived-Experience-Human-Science-for-an-Action(
- Sensitive-PedagogyampNewampYorkampSUNYampPressamp
VitanovaampGamp(2010)ampampAuthoring-the-Dialogic-SelfampAmsterdamampJohnampBenjaminsamp
amp PublishingampCoamp
WatsonampJamp(2013)ampampKnowingampthroughamptheampfeltltsenseampaampgestureampofampopennessamptoamptheamp
amp otherampampInternational-Journal-of-Childrens-Spirituality-18amp(1)amp118lt130amp
WiercinskiampAamp(2011)ampHermeneuticampEducationamptoampUnderstandingampSelfltEducationampandamp
amp theampWillingnessamptoampRiskampFailureampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp107lt124)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
WorsleyampRamp(2012)ampNarrativesampandamplivelyampmetaphorsampHermeneuticsampasampaampwayampofamp
amp listeningampPerson(Centered-amp-Experiential-Psychotherapiesamp-11amp(4)amp304lt320amp
ZuckertampCampHamp(2002)ampHermeneuticsampinampPracticeampGadameramponampAncientampPhilosophyampInamp
amp RampJampDostalamp(Ed)ampThe-Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp201lt224)amp
amp CambridgeampUKampCambridgeampUniversityampPressamp
amp
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
- WebsitePaper-20
- WebsitePaper-18
- WebsitePaperpdf
-
- MesserFinalPaper-11
- MesserFinalPaper
-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 41amp
forampsuchampaampventureampampHowampdoampIampsumampupampwhatampIamphaveamplearnedampfromampthemampandampfromamptheamp
experiencesampgeneratedampwithinampthisampresearchamp
amp InampanampattemptamptoampansweramporampsimplyampliveampinamptheseampquestionsampIampwouldampfirstamplikeamptoamp
discussamptheampsurveyampresponsesampampWhenamptaskedampwithampdescribingampsituationsampofampbeingamp
listenedamptoamporampnotampsurveyampparticipantsamphadampaamplotamptoampsayampampRarelyampdidampindividualsampgiveamp
oneltwordamporampevenamponeltsentenceampanswersampampNearlyampeveryoneamphadampexperiencesamptheyamp
wantedamptoampshareampandamptheseampexperiencesampwereampoftenampdescribedampusingamplanguageampthatamp
carriedampwithampitamptheampweightampofampemotionampandampvulnerabilityampampSomeampofamptheseampresponsesamp
continueamptoampstickamptoampmeampampMyampunderstandingampofampotherampresponsesampevolvedampoveramptheamp
courseampofampmyampinteractionsampwithampthemampampamp
amp Inampgeneralamptheampnegativeamplisteningampsituationsampdescribedampwereampnotampusuallyamp
purposefullyamphurtfulampampMoreampoftenampparticipantsampdescribedampfeelingampdismissedampampThisamp
sometimesampdidntampevenamptranslateampintoampwritingampampParticipantsampwroteampaboutampsituationsampinamp
whichamptheamplanguageampofamptheampencounterampdidntampalwaysampmatchamptheampemotionampfeltampampForamp
exampleamponeampsurveyampparticipantampdescribedampanampexperienceampinampwhichampaampfamilyampmemberamp
saidampWowampIampneverampthoughtampwouldveampthoughtamptoampmakeampaampportraitampthatampwayamp(Surveyamp
responseampLSampageamp27)ampampInampexamplesamplikeampthisampnegativeampinteractionsampwereampfeltampratheramp
thanamparticulatedampdirectlyampampTheseampmomentsampwereampbasedamparoundampintonationampemphasisamp
andamppresumedampsubtextampratherampthanampexplicitamporampdeliberateampwordampchoiceampampamp
amp IampamampundoubtedlyampmakingampsomeampassumptionsampasampIampsayampthisampbutamptheampsurveyamp
responsesampindicatedampthatampitsampeasyamptoampbeampunintentionallyamphurtfulampampItsampmuchampharderamptoamp
handleamptheampwordsampandampcreativeampworkampofampanotherampwithampcareampampInampfactampthisamptakesampconstantamp
questioningampandampreflectionampampTheamppositiveampresponsesampusuallyampindicatedampaampsenseampofamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 42amp
connectionamprestraintampandampgenuineampinterestampampSomeampdescribedampsilenceampasampaampkeyamp
componentampofamplisteningampandampothersampdiscussedamptheampsituationsampinampwhichamptheamplisteneramp
asksampquestionsamporampmake[s]ampcommentsampthatampallowampyouamptoampfeelampjustifiedampinampwhatampyouveamp
saidamp(SurveyampresponseampCHampageamp47)ampampStillampothersampreferredamptoamptheamppowerampofamp
interpretationampandamptheampintentampofamptheampartistampasampaampguideampforampknowingampthatamponesampworkamp
wasampunderstoodamp
amp Asampforamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcaseampstudiesampthisampideaampandamptheampexperiencesamp
thatampbroughtampitamptoampfruitionampareampstillampinamptheirampinfancyampampThisampresearchampprojectampgaveampmeamptheamp
firstampstepsampintoamptheamppossibilitiesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampandampIamplookampforwardamptoamp
understandingampmoreampaboutamphowampitampwouldamplookamptoampimplementampthisampframeworkampintoampaamp
classroomamporampstudioampcontextampampInitiallyampIampthoughtampthatampIampcouldampjustampaskampparticipantsamptoamp
enterampintoampaampstateampofampmindampthatampwouldampbeampconduciveamptoampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampIamp
assumedampthatampitampwasampmoreamplikeampaampshiftampinampattitudeampthanampaamplearnedampbehaviorampampButampIampwasamp
wrongltlttheampshiftampinampattitudeampcomesampfromampgradualamplearningampoveramptimeampampToampachieveampthisamp
thereampneedsamptoampbeampaampsystemampofampscaffoldingampinampplaceampampThisampscaffoldingampcanampincludeamp
specificampwaysampofampinteractingampinampclassroomsampstudiosampandampviewingampspacesampassignmentsamp
andampprojectsampcenteredamparoundampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampexperiencesampinvestigationampofamp
collageampjournalampwritingampexercisesampinamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampsustainedamp
engagementsampinampviewingampworksampofampartampteacherampmodelingampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
behaviorsampandampsoamponampampThisamprealizationampcameamptooamplateampinamptheampresearchamptoampfullyampengageamp
withamppossibleampsolutionsampbutampIamplookampforwardamptoampdevelopingamptheseampoveramptheampcourseampofamp
myampcareeramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 43amp
amp Theamprealizationampthatampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamprequireampmoreampthanampjustampanamp
attitudeampshiftampcameampfromampanotheramponeampofamptheampbiggestampoutcomesampofampthisampresearchampampTheamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampIampenactedamphadampsomethingampofampaampdominoampeffectamponampmyamppracticesamp
withinampthemampampTheampmostampimportantampaspectampofampenactingampthemampwasampbeingampreflexiveamptoamp
whatamphappenedampwithinampthemampampIampwasampconstantlyampaskingampmyselfampwhatampwasampworkingamp
whatampneededamptoampchangeampandampwhatampcouldampmakeampitampbetterampampIampreflectedamponampmyampownampstateamp
ofampmindampandamphowampthatampinformedampmyampexperiencesampandamptheampexperiencesampofampanotherampampIamp
reflectedamponampmyampassumptionsampampIampthoughtampthatampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmightamphaveampaamp
certainampkindampofampfeelingampaamptransformativeampclickampthatampwouldampletampmeampknowampitampwasamp
workingampampButampitsampnotampthatampsimpleampampAampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampmanifestampitselfampinamp
soampmanyampwaysampthatampitsampimpossibleamptoampidentifyampthemampallampampItampcouldampfeelamplikeampaampregularamp
conversationamporampcritiqueampitampcouldampfeelampuncomfortableamporampeasyampampItampcouldamphaveampaampuniqueamp
asltyetltunknownampqualityampampLikeampaampworkampofampartampitampcouldamptakeamponampanyampnumberampofampformsamp
andamppossibilitiesampMyampassumptionampthatampitampwouldamptakeamponamponeampeasylttoltrecognizeamp
manifestationampwasampnotampasampnuancedampasampthisampresearchampindicatesamptheamppossibilitiesampwouldamp
haveamptoampbeampampamp
amp FinallyampinampresponseamptoampresponseampIampcreatedampaamptextltobjectamp(Imagesamp1ampampamp2)ampthatamp
offersamponeamppossibleamparticulationamptoamptheampsurveysampandampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcaseamp
studiesampampIampwouldamplikeamptoampletampthisamponeamppossibilityampserveampasampaampmarkerampforamptheampinfiniteamp
possibilitiesampIampdidampnotampmakeampexploreampexpressamporampundergoampbutampthatampcontinueamptoampexistamp
inamptheamprealmampofampwhatltmightltbeamp
amp ThisamptextltobjectampisampakinamptoampaampmovingamppieceampofamppoetryampampToampcreateamptheamptextampIamp
collagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampfromamptheampsurveyampresponsesampinampanampeffortamptoamphonoramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 44amp
manyampvoicesampampTheamptextampisampopenampandampflowingampwithampnoampclearampbeginningamporampendampampTheamp
concealampandamprevealampaspectampofamptheampworkampcallsamptoampmindamptheampactampofampresearchampandampinquiryampinamp
generalampampTheampthickampblackampscribblesamponamptheampmovingampcirclesampareampderivedampfromamptheampfieldamp
notesampIamptookampduringampmyampexperiencesampwithampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcaseampstudiesampampTheamp
overlappingampdenseampqualityampofampthisamptextampcallsamptoampmindamptheampdensenessampofamptheseamp
experiencesampandamptheampoverwhelmingampimpossibilityampofampabsorbingampeverythingampIampcouldamp
containampamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 47amp
thread8(amp
(In)conclusions(amp
amp InamptheampwordsampofampPaulampFairfieldamp(2011)ampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinampdialogueampnoamp
interpretationampthatampisampuniquelyampandampsupremelyampauthoritativeamp(pamp83)ampampThoughampthisamp
paperampisampendingampthereampisampnoamplastampwordamponamptheampmatterampofamplisteningampforampmeampnorampforamp
studentsampteachersamphumansampworksampofampartamptextsampadampinfinitumampampThisampmyampnotltsolt
conclusiveltconcludingampsectionampstretchesamptheamppossibilityampofampmyampresearchampinampaampmanneramp
thatampdefiesamptheampsupremelyampauthoritativeampstructureampofampanampacademicampresearchamppaperampampamp
amp
Below-is-the-transcript-from-an-episode-dated-April-6-2015-of-the-popular-daytime-
talk-show-Ellen-during-which-the-artistresearcheducator-was-invited-to-discuss-her-
groundbreaking-work-on-listening-
(Camerasamprollampinamp3amp2amp1ampSceneampopensamponamptheampsetampof-EllenampampCameraamppansampinamptoampfocusamp
onampEllenampampSheampisampseatedamponampaamploveseatampwearingampaampcreamltcoloredamppantsuitampwithampaamplightamp
blueampbuttonltupampshirtampampHeramphairampisampperfectlyampcoiffedampampLightsampflashampandamptheampcrowdamp
cheersampampIntroampmusicampswells)-
EllenampDegeneresampampHelloampeveryoneampampWelcomeamptoamptheampshowamptodayampampTheampfirstamponlyampandamp
mostampimportantampguestamponamptodaysampshowampisampSamanthaampMesserampampSamanthaampisampanampartistamp
researcherampandampeducatorampbasedampinampCincinnatiampOhioampwhoseamprecentampresearchampprojectamp
onamplisteningampinampartampeducationamphasamptheamppotentialamptoampchangeamptheampfaceampofampnotamponlyampartamp
educationampbutampalsoamptheampworldampampHereampsheampisampSamanthaampMesseramp
(SamanthaampwalksamponamptheampstageamplookingampsleekampasamphellampwhileampdoingampitampampTheampaudienceamp
cheersampampSamanthaampandampEllenamphugamplikeampoldampfriends)amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 48amp
SamanthaampMesserampampHiampEllenampampItsampsoampgreatamptoampseeampyouampampamp
EDampampNoampSamanthaampitsampgreatamptoampseeampyouampampTellampusampaboutampwhatampbringsampyouamphereamptodayamp
SMampamp(Laughsampfreelyampwithoutampaampcare)ampEllenampyouampareampwhatampbroughtampmeamphereamptoday(
(Audienceamplaughs)amp
EDampampIampappreciateampthatampthankampyouampampButampletsampgetamptoampwhatsamponampAmericasampmindampampYouramp
lifesampworkampampIncredibleampampWhatampexactlyampisampitampandamphowampdidampitampcomeampaboutampampampampamp
SMampampEllenampwhereamptoampbeginampampampTheampideaampinampitsampmostampbasicampformampisampanampartampeducationampbasedamp
aroundamplisteningamppracticesamp
EDampampThatampsoundsampfascinatingampamp
SMampampIampknowampampThankampyouampforampnoticingampitsampsubtleampbrillianceamp
EDampampIampwouldampbeampaampfoolampnotamptoampampTellampusamphowampyouampcameampupampwithampthisampideaamp
SMampampampTheampcentralampcomponentampisampanampideaampcalledampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampwhichampisampaamp
spaceampinampwhichampstudentsampandampparticipantsampmakeampdiscussampandampviewampworksampofampartampwithamp
listeningampatamptheampcenterampofamptheseampactivitiesampandampexperiencesampampThisampideaampcameamptogetheramp
overamptheampcourseampofampmonthsampofampreadingamphundredsampofampdiscussionsampwithamppeersampresearchamp
participantsampandampprofessorsampasampwellampasamptheampwritingampandamprewritingampofampmanyampdraftsampofamp
myampnowampbestltsellingampbookamp
(Audienceampooooooohs)amp
EDampampWowampyouampreallyampputampsomeampthoughtampintoampthisamphuhampampSoamphowampisampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampdifferentampthanampaampregularampclassroomamp
SMampampWellampitampdependsamponamptheampclassroomampampSomeampclassroomsampprobablyampalreadyampareamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampampEssentiallyampitamprequiresampsomethingampofampanampattitudeampshiftampampItamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 49amp
doesntampevenampnecessarilyamphaveamptoampbeampinampaampclassroomamporampanyampspecificampplaceampampItsampmoreampofamp
aampstateampofampmindampandampanampattitudeamp
EDampampCouldampweampbeampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamprightampnowamp
SMampampEllenampnothingampwouldampgiveampmeampmoreamppleasureamp
(Audienceampawwwwws)amp
SMampampButampseriouslyampyesampweampcanampbeampampThoughampitampmightamptakeampmoreampthanampjustampanampattitudeamp
shiftampampWhenampIampinitiallyampbeganampthisampprojectampIampthoughtampthatsampallampitampwouldampbeampampIampassumedamp
thatampifampparticipantsampwereampwillingamptheyampcouldampenterampintoampthisampstateampofampmindampampamp
EDampampButampthatsampnotamptheampcaseamp
SMampampWellampitsampjustampthatampitsampmoreampcomplicatedampthanampthatampampWhatampIampfoundampwereampthatamptheamp
thingsampIampwasampaskingampindividualsamptoampdoampwereampnotampwithinampouramptypicalampculturalampskillampsetampamp
NotamponlyampthisampbutamptheyampareampdifficultampsubtleampandampoftenampinternalamppursuitsampampTheyampareampnotamp
easyamptoampseeampandamptheampresultsampareampnotampinstantaneousampampItsamphardamptoampknowampifampyoureampdoingamp
itamprightamp
EDampSoampwhatampdoesampitampmeanamptoampdoampitamprightamp
SMampampThatsampaampgreatampquestionampEllenampandampthankampyouampforampaskingampitampampIampdontampthinkamptheresamp
justamponeampwayampofampdoingampitamprightampampAndampevenampsometimesampwhenampyoureampdoingampitamprightampitamp
mightampnotampfeelamplikeampanythingampspecialampampItampcouldampjustampfeelamplikeampaampnormalampconversationamp
EDampampSoampthisampisampallampaboutamphavingampaampconversationampampIampdoampthatampfiveampdaysampaampweekamponampthisampsetamp
Samanthaampamp
(Audienceamplaughsamplightheartedly)amp
SMampampEllenampampYoureampcuttingampmeampdeepampamp(laughs)ampYoureamprightampampItsampnotamprevolutionaryampamp
Toamplistenamptoampbeamplistenedamptoamptoampcarryamponampanampopenampandamphonestampconversationampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 50amp
anotheramphumanampTheseampareamphumbleampgoalsampthatampweampcanampcarryampacrossampmanyampcontextsampampIamp
thinkampthereinampliesamptheampbeautyamp
EDampampInterestingampampImampgoingamptoampaskampwhatampImampsureampaamplotampofampteachersamphaveamponamptheiramp
mindsltlthowampdoampweampteachampthisamptoampstudentsamp
SMampampTheampgoalsampandampbeliefsampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmustampbeamplivedampthroughampandamp
undergoneampratherampthanampmerelyampactedampoutamponceamporamptwiceampampItsampaboutampcreatingampaampsystemamp
craftingampassignmentsampandampsettingampaamptoneampthatampallampunderlieamptheseampvaluesampampNotamponlyampthatamp
butamptheampstudentsampandampteachersampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmustampbeampreflectiveamptoamp
theirampexperiencesampampTheseampskillsampneedamptoampbeampbuiltampupampandampaampkeyampcomponentampofampthatampisamp
reflectionamponamppreviousampexperiencesamp
EDampampampIampunderstandampyouampalsoampsolicitedampsurveyampresponsesamptoampdiscussampmomentsampinampwhichamp
individualsampdidamporampdidampnotampfeelamplistenedamptoampasamptheyampspokeampaboutamptheirampartampampCanampyouamptalkamp
aamplittleampbitampaboutampwhatampyouampfoundampinamptheampsurveysamp
SMampampWellampIampcoveredampaamplotampofampthisampinampmyampbookampYoullamphaveamptoampreadampitampampIamphaveampprovidedamp
everyampmemberampofamptheampaudienceamptodayampwithampaampcopyampwhichampyoullampallampfindampunderampyouramp
seatsamp
(AudienceampgoesampwildampwithampexcitementampasamptheyampreachampunderamptheirampseatsampampThereampareamp
intermittentampscreechesampofampjoy)amp
EDampampWowampthankampyouampampTheampgiftampofamplisteningampwhatampaamptreasureampforamptheampaudienceamp
membersamptodayamp
(Audienceampclapsampwholeheartedly)amp
SMampampYoureampwelcomeampampInampgeneralampthoughampwhatampIampfoundampisampaampneedamptoamphandleamptheampwordsamp
andampexperiencesampofampothersampwithampcareampampTheampsurveysampdescribedampsituationsampinampwhichamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 51amp
individualsampfeltamptheyampwereampnotampbeingamplistenedamptoampyetamptheseampmomentsampwereampnotampusuallyamp
profoundlyamporamppurposefullyamphurtfulampampMoreampoftenamptheampsurveysampdescribedampinstancesampinamp
whichamppeopleampfeltampthatampanotheramppersonampwasntamptryingamptoampunderstandampampTheseamp
situationsampwereampmoreamppassiveampandampdismissiveampratherampthanampactivelyamphurtfulampthoughamp
theyampdidampstillamphurtamp
EDampampWellampcouldntampthatampbeampchalkedampupamptoamptheampsensitiveamppersonaampofamptheampartistampampWeampallamp
knowamphowampsensitiveampthoseampartistsampareamp
(Audienceamplaughsamptheyampareampinamponamptheampjoke)amp
SMampamp(chastising)ampEllenampyoureampsmarterampthanampthatampstereotypeampampIampmeanampyouampcouldampsayamp
thatampbutampIampdontampknowampifampthatampwouldampbeampproductiveampampAndampitampwouldntampfitampwithamptheamp
beliefsampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampinampmyampopinionampampDontampweampallampwantamptoampbeamplistenedamp
toampampIsampthatampdesireampexclusiveamptoampsomeampideaampweamphaveampinampourampheadampofampartistsampampIampdontamp
thinkampsoamp
EDampampYoureampsoamprightampSamanthaampampImampsorryampforampgivingampintoampsomeamppervasiveampmodernistamp
nonsenseampaboutampwhatampitampisamptoampbeampanampartistamp
(Audienceampnodsampinampagreement)amp
SMampampItsampokayampEllenampWeampinamptheampartampworldampareampfightingamptheampgoodampfightampWhatampweampdoampisamp
importantampandampwereamptiredampofampbeingampdismissedampbyampsocietyamp
(Audienceampclaps)amp
EDampampSoampwhatampisampyourampnextampstepamp
SMampampWellampIampwasampjustampawardedampaampspecialampmedalampofamphonorampfromampPresidentampObamaampamp
(PhotoampofampSamanthaampshakingamphandsampwithamptheampPresidentampflashesamponamptheampscreenampandamptheamp
audienceampclaps)amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 52amp
EDampampCongratulationsamp
SMampampThankampyouampampWhatampanamphonorampampAlongampwithampthisampcommendationampcameampaampgrantampforamp
meamptoampbeampableamptoamptrainampaampgroupampofamphighlyampspecializedampartistlteducatorsampinamptheseamp
practicesampandampsendampthemampoutamptoampcommunitiesampacrossamptheampcountryamptoamphelpampimplementamp
andampsupportampeffortsamptoampputampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampintoampschoolsampwhoampchooseamptoampbeamp
involvedampnationwideamp
(Aampthunderingampofampclappingampinamptheampaudience)amp
EDampampWhatampdoampyouampseeampareamptheamplonglttermampeffectsampofamptheampimplementationampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampamp
SMampampEllenampImampsureampIampdontamphaveamptoamptellampyouampthatampweampliveampinampaampfastltpacedamp
technologicallyltrevolutionaryampworldampampThereampareamppartsampofampthatampthatampareampwonderfulampandamp
makeampourampworldampanampeasierampplaceamptoampliveampampButampthereamphasamptoampbeamproomampforampusamptoampswitchampoffamp
unplugampandampslowampdownampampIampbelieveampthatamptheampplatformampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
unleashesampsomeamppossibilitiesampofamphumanampconnectionampinampaampveryamprealampauthenticampwayampamp
(Audienceamprisesampfromamptheirampseatsampwithamptearsampinamptheirampeyesampasamptheyampgiveampaampstandingamp
ovation)amp
EDampampAampnobleampgoalampindeedampampThankampyouampSamanthaampforampallampthatampyouampdoampampWhatampaampgamelt
changerampampThatsampallamptheamptimeampweamphaveampforamptodayampampItsampbeenampaamptrueamphonorampampGoodampluckampinamp
allampofampyourampendeavorsampampToampthoseampwatchingampatamphomeampgoamplistenamptoampsomeoneampamp
(SamanthaampEllenampandampaudienceampdanceampasamptheampcreditsamproll)amp
(
ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 53amp
loose(ends((References(
AndersonampEampHampampampSpencerampMampHamp(2013)ampAampPhenomenologicalampStudyampCognitiveamp
amp RepresentationsampofampAIDSampInampJampWampCreswellampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-
- Designamp(ppamp327lt346)ampLosampAngelesampSAGEampPublicationsampIncamp
BakerampGampampampMorrisampKamp(2002)ampDecartes-DualismampLondonampRoutledgeamp
BelenkyampMampFampClinchyampBampMampGoldbergerampNampRampampampTaruleampJampMamp(1997)ampWomens-Ways-
- of-Knowing-The-Development-of-Self-Voice-and-MindampNewampYorkampNYamp
amp BasicBooksamp
BleicherampJamp(1980)ampampContemporary-Hermeneutics-Hermeneutics-as-Method-
- Philosophy-and-Critique--LondonampUKampRoutledgeampampampKeeganampPaulamp
BohmampDamp(1996)ampOn-DialogueampLondonampUKampRoutledgeamp
BourgeoisampJampPamp(2007)ampThe-Aesthetic-Hermeneutics-of-Hans(Georg-Gadamer-and-Hans-
- Urs-von-BalthasarampNewampYorkampNYampPeterampLangampPublishingampIncamp
BrunsampGampLamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-Ancient-and-ModernampNewampHavenampCTampYaleamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
CalleampSamp(2011)ampBlindampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CalleampSamp(2005)ampExisquisite-PainampNewampYorkampThamesampampampHudsonamp
CalleampSamp(2008)ampTake-Care-of-YourselfampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CaputoampJamp(2000)ampMore-Radical-HermeneuticsampBloomingtonampINampIndianaampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
CreswellampJampWamp(2013)ampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-DesignampLosampAngelesampSAGEamp
amp PublicationsampIncamp
deampCossonampAamp(2002)ampTheampHermeneuticampDialogueampFindingampPatternsampamidamptheampAporiaamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 54amp
amp ofamptheampArtistResearcherTeacherampAlberta-Journal-of-Educational-Researchamp-
- 48amp(3)amp1lt20amp
ElkinsampJamp(2001)ampWhy-Art-Cannot-Be-TaughtampChicagoampILampUniversityampofampIllinoisampPressamp
FairfieldampPamp(2011)ampDialogueampinamptheampClassroomampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-
- Dialogue-and-Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp77lt90)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GadamerampHltGamp(1996)ampThe-Engima-of-HealthampStanfordampCAampStanfordampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
GadamerampHltGamp(2004)ampTruth-and-Methodamp(Secondamprevisedamped)amp(JampWeinsheimerampampamp
amp DampGampMarshallampTrans)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GallagherampSamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-and-EducationampAlbanyampNYampStateampUniversityampofamp
amp NewampYorkampPressamp
GendlinampEamp(1962)ampExperiencing-and-the-Creation-of-MeaningampNewampYorkampNYampTheamp
amp FreeampPressampofampGlencoeamp
GendlinampEamp(1997)ampampHowampPhilosophyampCannotampAppealamptoampExperienceampandampHowampItampCanamp
amp InampLanguage-beyond-Postmodernism-Saying-and-Thinking-in-Gendlins-
- Philosophy-(ppamp3lt41)ampEvanstonampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
GermeraadampGamp(2013)ampRationalityampIntuitionampandampEmotionampExploringampanampArtisticamp
amp ProcessampJournal-for-Artistic-Researchamp-3
GradleampSampAamp(2011)ampAampuniversityampcourseampinampmindfulampviewingampUnderstandingampartampandamp
amp selfampthroughampcontemplativeampexperienceampInternational-Journal-of-Education-
- Through-Artamp-7amp(2)amp137lt151amp
GreeneampMamp(2013)ampTheampTurningampofamptheampLeavesampExpandingampOurampVisionampforamptheampArtsampinamp
amp EducationampHarvard-Educational-Reviewamp-83amp(1)amp251lt252amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 55amp
GrondinampJamp(2002)ampGadamersampBasicampUnderstandingampofampUnderstandingampInampThe-
- Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp36lt51)ampCambridgeampUKampCambridgeamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
GrondinampJamp(2011)ampGadamersampExperienceampandampTheoryampofampEducationampLearningampthatamp
amp theampOtherampMayampBeampRightampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp5lt20)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
HeelanampPamp(1985)ampampPerceptionampasampaampHermeneuticalampActampampInampDampIhdeampampampHampSilvermanamp
amp (Eds)ampHermeneutics-amp-Deconstruction-(ppamp43lt54)-AlbanyampSUNYampPressamp
HeelanampPampampampSchulkinampJamp(2003)ampHermeneuticalampPhilosophyampandampPragmatismampAamp
amp PhilosophyampofampScienceampInampRampCampScharffampampampVampDusekamp(Eds)ampPhilosophy-of-
- Technology-The-Technological-Condition-an-Anthology-amp(ppamp138lt153)amp
amp MaldenampMAampBlackwellamp
KarpiakampIampEamp(2003)ampTheampListeningampHeartampTuningampInampForampTransformativeampLearningamp
amp 2003-Complexity-Science-and-Educational-Research-Conferenceamp(ppamp67lt80)amp
amp EdmontonampCanadaamp
KellyampMampPost(Partum-DocumentampInstituteampofampContemporaryampArtsampLondonamp
KentampSampJampampampCummingampJampamp(2008)ampampIampdontampknowampEngagingampwithampproblematicamp
amp momentsampinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampRadical-Pedagogy-2-(9)amp1lt20ampampamp
LevinampDampMamp(1989)ampThe-Listening-Self-Personal-Growth-Social-Change-and-the-
- Closure-of-MetaphysicsampNewampYorkampNYampRoutledgeamp
LindsethampAampampampNorbergampAamp(2004)ampAampphenomenologicalamphermeneuticalampmethodampforamp
amp researchingamplivedampexperienceampNordic-College-of-Caring-Sciencesamp-18amp145lt153amp
LipariampLamp(2014)ampampOnampinterlisteningampandamptheampideaampofampdialogueampampTheory-amp-Psychology-24-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 56amp
- (4)amp504lt523amp
MarksampLamp(2002)ampTouch-Sensuous-Theory-and-Multisensory-MediaampMinneapolisamp
amp UniversityampofampMinnesotaampPressamp
MunozampKampLamp(2014)ampTranscribing-Silence-Culture-Relationship-and-Communicationamp
amp WalnutampCreekampCAampLeftampCoastampPressamp
NicholampLamp(1996)ampForewordampInampDampBohmampOn-Dialogueamp(ppampviiltxvii)ampLondonampUKamp
amp Routledgeamp
PalmerampRamp(1969)ampHermeneutics-Interpretation-Theory-in-Schleiermacher-Dilthey-
- Heidegger-and-GadamerampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
PerlampSamp(2004)ampFelt-Sense-Writing-with-the-BodyampPortsmouthampNHampBoyntonCookamp
RicoeurampPamp(19691974)ampThe-Conflicts-of-Interpretations-Essays-in-Hermeneuticsamp
amp (NorthwesternampUniversityampPressampTrans)ampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
RicoeurampPamp(2013)ampHermeneuticsampCambridgeampUKampPolityampPressamp
SableampDamp(2014)ampReasonampinamptheampServiceampofamptheampHeartampTheampImpactsampofampContemplativeamp
amp PracticesamponampCriticalampThinkingampJournal-of-Contemplative-Inquiryamp-1amp(1)amp1lt22amp
SchultzampKamp(2010)ampAfteramptheampBlackbirdampWhistlesampListeningamptoampSilenceampinampClassroomsamp
amp Teachers-College-Recordamp-112amp(11)amp2833lt2849amp
SeebohmampTampamp(2004)ampampHermeneutics-Method-and-MethodologyampDordrechtamptheamp
amp NetherlandsampKluwerampAcademicampPublishersamp
SnowberampCamp(2005)ampTheampmentorampasampartistampaamppoeticampexplorationampofamplisteningampcreatingamp
amp andampmentoringampMentoring-and-Tutoring-13amp(3)amp345lt353amp
vanampManenampMampamp(1984)ampPracticingampPhenomenologicalampWritingampPhenomenology-+-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 57amp
- Pedagogy-2amp(1)amp36lt68amp
vanampManenampMamp(1990)ampampResearching-Lived-Experience-Human-Science-for-an-Action(
- Sensitive-PedagogyampNewampYorkampSUNYampPressamp
VitanovaampGamp(2010)ampampAuthoring-the-Dialogic-SelfampAmsterdamampJohnampBenjaminsamp
amp PublishingampCoamp
WatsonampJamp(2013)ampampKnowingampthroughamptheampfeltltsenseampaampgestureampofampopennessamptoamptheamp
amp otherampampInternational-Journal-of-Childrens-Spirituality-18amp(1)amp118lt130amp
WiercinskiampAamp(2011)ampHermeneuticampEducationamptoampUnderstandingampSelfltEducationampandamp
amp theampWillingnessamptoampRiskampFailureampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp107lt124)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
WorsleyampRamp(2012)ampNarrativesampandamplivelyampmetaphorsampHermeneuticsampasampaampwayampofamp
amp listeningampPerson(Centered-amp-Experiential-Psychotherapiesamp-11amp(4)amp304lt320amp
ZuckertampCampHamp(2002)ampHermeneuticsampinampPracticeampGadameramponampAncientampPhilosophyampInamp
amp RampJampDostalamp(Ed)ampThe-Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp201lt224)amp
amp CambridgeampUKampCambridgeampUniversityampPressamp
amp
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
- WebsitePaper-20
- WebsitePaper-18
- WebsitePaperpdf
-
- MesserFinalPaper-11
- MesserFinalPaper
-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 42amp
connectionamprestraintampandampgenuineampinterestampampSomeampdescribedampsilenceampasampaampkeyamp
componentampofamplisteningampandampothersampdiscussedamptheampsituationsampinampwhichamptheamplisteneramp
asksampquestionsamporampmake[s]ampcommentsampthatampallowampyouamptoampfeelampjustifiedampinampwhatampyouveamp
saidamp(SurveyampresponseampCHampageamp47)ampampStillampothersampreferredamptoamptheamppowerampofamp
interpretationampandamptheampintentampofamptheampartistampasampaampguideampforampknowingampthatamponesampworkamp
wasampunderstoodamp
amp Asampforamptheampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcaseampstudiesampthisampideaampandamptheampexperiencesamp
thatampbroughtampitamptoampfruitionampareampstillampinamptheirampinfancyampampThisampresearchampprojectampgaveampmeamptheamp
firstampstepsampintoamptheamppossibilitiesampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampandampIamplookampforwardamptoamp
understandingampmoreampaboutamphowampitampwouldamplookamptoampimplementampthisampframeworkampintoampaamp
classroomamporampstudioampcontextampampInitiallyampIampthoughtampthatampIampcouldampjustampaskampparticipantsamptoamp
enterampintoampaampstateampofampmindampthatampwouldampbeampconduciveamptoampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampampIamp
assumedampthatampitampwasampmoreamplikeampaampshiftampinampattitudeampthanampaamplearnedampbehaviorampampButampIampwasamp
wrongltlttheampshiftampinampattitudeampcomesampfromampgradualamplearningampoveramptimeampampToampachieveampthisamp
thereampneedsamptoampbeampaampsystemampofampscaffoldingampinampplaceampampThisampscaffoldingampcanampincludeamp
specificampwaysampofampinteractingampinampclassroomsampstudiosampandampviewingampspacesampassignmentsamp
andampprojectsampcenteredamparoundampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampexperiencesampinvestigationampofamp
collageampjournalampwritingampexercisesampinamplisteningamptoampaampworkampofampartampsustainedamp
engagementsampinampviewingampworksampofampartampteacherampmodelingampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
behaviorsampandampsoamponampampThisamprealizationampcameamptooamplateampinamptheampresearchamptoampfullyampengageamp
withamppossibleampsolutionsampbutampIamplookampforwardamptoampdevelopingamptheseampoveramptheampcourseampofamp
myampcareeramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 43amp
amp Theamprealizationampthatampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamprequireampmoreampthanampjustampanamp
attitudeampshiftampcameampfromampanotheramponeampofamptheampbiggestampoutcomesampofampthisampresearchampampTheamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampIampenactedamphadampsomethingampofampaampdominoampeffectamponampmyamppracticesamp
withinampthemampampTheampmostampimportantampaspectampofampenactingampthemampwasampbeingampreflexiveamptoamp
whatamphappenedampwithinampthemampampIampwasampconstantlyampaskingampmyselfampwhatampwasampworkingamp
whatampneededamptoampchangeampandampwhatampcouldampmakeampitampbetterampampIampreflectedamponampmyampownampstateamp
ofampmindampandamphowampthatampinformedampmyampexperiencesampandamptheampexperiencesampofampanotherampampIamp
reflectedamponampmyampassumptionsampampIampthoughtampthatampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmightamphaveampaamp
certainampkindampofampfeelingampaamptransformativeampclickampthatampwouldampletampmeampknowampitampwasamp
workingampampButampitsampnotampthatampsimpleampampAampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampmanifestampitselfampinamp
soampmanyampwaysampthatampitsampimpossibleamptoampidentifyampthemampallampampItampcouldampfeelamplikeampaampregularamp
conversationamporampcritiqueampitampcouldampfeelampuncomfortableamporampeasyampampItampcouldamphaveampaampuniqueamp
asltyetltunknownampqualityampampLikeampaampworkampofampartampitampcouldamptakeamponampanyampnumberampofampformsamp
andamppossibilitiesampMyampassumptionampthatampitampwouldamptakeamponamponeampeasylttoltrecognizeamp
manifestationampwasampnotampasampnuancedampasampthisampresearchampindicatesamptheamppossibilitiesampwouldamp
haveamptoampbeampampamp
amp FinallyampinampresponseamptoampresponseampIampcreatedampaamptextltobjectamp(Imagesamp1ampampamp2)ampthatamp
offersamponeamppossibleamparticulationamptoamptheampsurveysampandampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcaseamp
studiesampampIampwouldamplikeamptoampletampthisamponeamppossibilityampserveampasampaampmarkerampforamptheampinfiniteamp
possibilitiesampIampdidampnotampmakeampexploreampexpressamporampundergoampbutampthatampcontinueamptoampexistamp
inamptheamprealmampofampwhatltmightltbeamp
amp ThisamptextltobjectampisampakinamptoampaampmovingamppieceampofamppoetryampampToampcreateamptheamptextampIamp
collagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampfromamptheampsurveyampresponsesampinampanampeffortamptoamphonoramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 44amp
manyampvoicesampampTheamptextampisampopenampandampflowingampwithampnoampclearampbeginningamporampendampampTheamp
concealampandamprevealampaspectampofamptheampworkampcallsamptoampmindamptheampactampofampresearchampandampinquiryampinamp
generalampampTheampthickampblackampscribblesamponamptheampmovingampcirclesampareampderivedampfromamptheampfieldamp
notesampIamptookampduringampmyampexperiencesampwithampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcaseampstudiesampampTheamp
overlappingampdenseampqualityampofampthisamptextampcallsamptoampmindamptheampdensenessampofamptheseamp
experiencesampandamptheampoverwhelmingampimpossibilityampofampabsorbingampeverythingampIampcouldamp
containampamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 47amp
thread8(amp
(In)conclusions(amp
amp InamptheampwordsampofampPaulampFairfieldamp(2011)ampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinampdialogueampnoamp
interpretationampthatampisampuniquelyampandampsupremelyampauthoritativeamp(pamp83)ampampThoughampthisamp
paperampisampendingampthereampisampnoamplastampwordamponamptheampmatterampofamplisteningampforampmeampnorampforamp
studentsampteachersamphumansampworksampofampartamptextsampadampinfinitumampampThisampmyampnotltsolt
conclusiveltconcludingampsectionampstretchesamptheamppossibilityampofampmyampresearchampinampaampmanneramp
thatampdefiesamptheampsupremelyampauthoritativeampstructureampofampanampacademicampresearchamppaperampampamp
amp
Below-is-the-transcript-from-an-episode-dated-April-6-2015-of-the-popular-daytime-
talk-show-Ellen-during-which-the-artistresearcheducator-was-invited-to-discuss-her-
groundbreaking-work-on-listening-
(Camerasamprollampinamp3amp2amp1ampSceneampopensamponamptheampsetampof-EllenampampCameraamppansampinamptoampfocusamp
onampEllenampampSheampisampseatedamponampaamploveseatampwearingampaampcreamltcoloredamppantsuitampwithampaamplightamp
blueampbuttonltupampshirtampampHeramphairampisampperfectlyampcoiffedampampLightsampflashampandamptheampcrowdamp
cheersampampIntroampmusicampswells)-
EllenampDegeneresampampHelloampeveryoneampampWelcomeamptoamptheampshowamptodayampampTheampfirstamponlyampandamp
mostampimportantampguestamponamptodaysampshowampisampSamanthaampMesserampampSamanthaampisampanampartistamp
researcherampandampeducatorampbasedampinampCincinnatiampOhioampwhoseamprecentampresearchampprojectamp
onamplisteningampinampartampeducationamphasamptheamppotentialamptoampchangeamptheampfaceampofampnotamponlyampartamp
educationampbutampalsoamptheampworldampampHereampsheampisampSamanthaampMesseramp
(SamanthaampwalksamponamptheampstageamplookingampsleekampasamphellampwhileampdoingampitampampTheampaudienceamp
cheersampampSamanthaampandampEllenamphugamplikeampoldampfriends)amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 48amp
SamanthaampMesserampampHiampEllenampampItsampsoampgreatamptoampseeampyouampampamp
EDampampNoampSamanthaampitsampgreatamptoampseeampyouampampTellampusampaboutampwhatampbringsampyouamphereamptodayamp
SMampamp(Laughsampfreelyampwithoutampaampcare)ampEllenampyouampareampwhatampbroughtampmeamphereamptoday(
(Audienceamplaughs)amp
EDampampIampappreciateampthatampthankampyouampampButampletsampgetamptoampwhatsamponampAmericasampmindampampYouramp
lifesampworkampampIncredibleampampWhatampexactlyampisampitampandamphowampdidampitampcomeampaboutampampampampamp
SMampampEllenampwhereamptoampbeginampampampTheampideaampinampitsampmostampbasicampformampisampanampartampeducationampbasedamp
aroundamplisteningamppracticesamp
EDampampThatampsoundsampfascinatingampamp
SMampampIampknowampampThankampyouampforampnoticingampitsampsubtleampbrillianceamp
EDampampIampwouldampbeampaampfoolampnotamptoampampTellampusamphowampyouampcameampupampwithampthisampideaamp
SMampampampTheampcentralampcomponentampisampanampideaampcalledampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampwhichampisampaamp
spaceampinampwhichampstudentsampandampparticipantsampmakeampdiscussampandampviewampworksampofampartampwithamp
listeningampatamptheampcenterampofamptheseampactivitiesampandampexperiencesampampThisampideaampcameamptogetheramp
overamptheampcourseampofampmonthsampofampreadingamphundredsampofampdiscussionsampwithamppeersampresearchamp
participantsampandampprofessorsampasampwellampasamptheampwritingampandamprewritingampofampmanyampdraftsampofamp
myampnowampbestltsellingampbookamp
(Audienceampooooooohs)amp
EDampampWowampyouampreallyampputampsomeampthoughtampintoampthisamphuhampampSoamphowampisampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampdifferentampthanampaampregularampclassroomamp
SMampampWellampitampdependsamponamptheampclassroomampampSomeampclassroomsampprobablyampalreadyampareamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampampEssentiallyampitamprequiresampsomethingampofampanampattitudeampshiftampampItamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 49amp
doesntampevenampnecessarilyamphaveamptoampbeampinampaampclassroomamporampanyampspecificampplaceampampItsampmoreampofamp
aampstateampofampmindampandampanampattitudeamp
EDampampCouldampweampbeampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamprightampnowamp
SMampampEllenampnothingampwouldampgiveampmeampmoreamppleasureamp
(Audienceampawwwwws)amp
SMampampButampseriouslyampyesampweampcanampbeampampThoughampitampmightamptakeampmoreampthanampjustampanampattitudeamp
shiftampampWhenampIampinitiallyampbeganampthisampprojectampIampthoughtampthatsampallampitampwouldampbeampampIampassumedamp
thatampifampparticipantsampwereampwillingamptheyampcouldampenterampintoampthisampstateampofampmindampampamp
EDampampButampthatsampnotamptheampcaseamp
SMampampWellampitsampjustampthatampitsampmoreampcomplicatedampthanampthatampampWhatampIampfoundampwereampthatamptheamp
thingsampIampwasampaskingampindividualsamptoampdoampwereampnotampwithinampouramptypicalampculturalampskillampsetampamp
NotamponlyampthisampbutamptheyampareampdifficultampsubtleampandampoftenampinternalamppursuitsampampTheyampareampnotamp
easyamptoampseeampandamptheampresultsampareampnotampinstantaneousampampItsamphardamptoampknowampifampyoureampdoingamp
itamprightamp
EDampSoampwhatampdoesampitampmeanamptoampdoampitamprightamp
SMampampThatsampaampgreatampquestionampEllenampandampthankampyouampforampaskingampitampampIampdontampthinkamptheresamp
justamponeampwayampofampdoingampitamprightampampAndampevenampsometimesampwhenampyoureampdoingampitamprightampitamp
mightampnotampfeelamplikeampanythingampspecialampampItampcouldampjustampfeelamplikeampaampnormalampconversationamp
EDampampSoampthisampisampallampaboutamphavingampaampconversationampampIampdoampthatampfiveampdaysampaampweekamponampthisampsetamp
Samanthaampamp
(Audienceamplaughsamplightheartedly)amp
SMampampEllenampampYoureampcuttingampmeampdeepampamp(laughs)ampYoureamprightampampItsampnotamprevolutionaryampamp
Toamplistenamptoampbeamplistenedamptoamptoampcarryamponampanampopenampandamphonestampconversationampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 50amp
anotheramphumanampTheseampareamphumbleampgoalsampthatampweampcanampcarryampacrossampmanyampcontextsampampIamp
thinkampthereinampliesamptheampbeautyamp
EDampampInterestingampampImampgoingamptoampaskampwhatampImampsureampaamplotampofampteachersamphaveamponamptheiramp
mindsltlthowampdoampweampteachampthisamptoampstudentsamp
SMampampTheampgoalsampandampbeliefsampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmustampbeamplivedampthroughampandamp
undergoneampratherampthanampmerelyampactedampoutamponceamporamptwiceampampItsampaboutampcreatingampaampsystemamp
craftingampassignmentsampandampsettingampaamptoneampthatampallampunderlieamptheseampvaluesampampNotamponlyampthatamp
butamptheampstudentsampandampteachersampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmustampbeampreflectiveamptoamp
theirampexperiencesampampTheseampskillsampneedamptoampbeampbuiltampupampandampaampkeyampcomponentampofampthatampisamp
reflectionamponamppreviousampexperiencesamp
EDampampampIampunderstandampyouampalsoampsolicitedampsurveyampresponsesamptoampdiscussampmomentsampinampwhichamp
individualsampdidamporampdidampnotampfeelamplistenedamptoampasamptheyampspokeampaboutamptheirampartampampCanampyouamptalkamp
aamplittleampbitampaboutampwhatampyouampfoundampinamptheampsurveysamp
SMampampWellampIampcoveredampaamplotampofampthisampinampmyampbookampYoullamphaveamptoampreadampitampampIamphaveampprovidedamp
everyampmemberampofamptheampaudienceamptodayampwithampaampcopyampwhichampyoullampallampfindampunderampyouramp
seatsamp
(AudienceampgoesampwildampwithampexcitementampasamptheyampreachampunderamptheirampseatsampampThereampareamp
intermittentampscreechesampofampjoy)amp
EDampampWowampthankampyouampampTheampgiftampofamplisteningampwhatampaamptreasureampforamptheampaudienceamp
membersamptodayamp
(Audienceampclapsampwholeheartedly)amp
SMampampYoureampwelcomeampampInampgeneralampthoughampwhatampIampfoundampisampaampneedamptoamphandleamptheampwordsamp
andampexperiencesampofampothersampwithampcareampampTheampsurveysampdescribedampsituationsampinampwhichamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 51amp
individualsampfeltamptheyampwereampnotampbeingamplistenedamptoampyetamptheseampmomentsampwereampnotampusuallyamp
profoundlyamporamppurposefullyamphurtfulampampMoreampoftenamptheampsurveysampdescribedampinstancesampinamp
whichamppeopleampfeltampthatampanotheramppersonampwasntamptryingamptoampunderstandampampTheseamp
situationsampwereampmoreamppassiveampandampdismissiveampratherampthanampactivelyamphurtfulampthoughamp
theyampdidampstillamphurtamp
EDampampWellampcouldntampthatampbeampchalkedampupamptoamptheampsensitiveamppersonaampofamptheampartistampampWeampallamp
knowamphowampsensitiveampthoseampartistsampareamp
(Audienceamplaughsamptheyampareampinamponamptheampjoke)amp
SMampamp(chastising)ampEllenampyoureampsmarterampthanampthatampstereotypeampampIampmeanampyouampcouldampsayamp
thatampbutampIampdontampknowampifampthatampwouldampbeampproductiveampampAndampitampwouldntampfitampwithamptheamp
beliefsampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampinampmyampopinionampampDontampweampallampwantamptoampbeamplistenedamp
toampampIsampthatampdesireampexclusiveamptoampsomeampideaampweamphaveampinampourampheadampofampartistsampampIampdontamp
thinkampsoamp
EDampampYoureampsoamprightampSamanthaampampImampsorryampforampgivingampintoampsomeamppervasiveampmodernistamp
nonsenseampaboutampwhatampitampisamptoampbeampanampartistamp
(Audienceampnodsampinampagreement)amp
SMampampItsampokayampEllenampWeampinamptheampartampworldampareampfightingamptheampgoodampfightampWhatampweampdoampisamp
importantampandampwereamptiredampofampbeingampdismissedampbyampsocietyamp
(Audienceampclaps)amp
EDampampSoampwhatampisampyourampnextampstepamp
SMampampWellampIampwasampjustampawardedampaampspecialampmedalampofamphonorampfromampPresidentampObamaampamp
(PhotoampofampSamanthaampshakingamphandsampwithamptheampPresidentampflashesamponamptheampscreenampandamptheamp
audienceampclaps)amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 52amp
EDampampCongratulationsamp
SMampampThankampyouampampWhatampanamphonorampampAlongampwithampthisampcommendationampcameampaampgrantampforamp
meamptoampbeampableamptoamptrainampaampgroupampofamphighlyampspecializedampartistlteducatorsampinamptheseamp
practicesampandampsendampthemampoutamptoampcommunitiesampacrossamptheampcountryamptoamphelpampimplementamp
andampsupportampeffortsamptoampputampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampintoampschoolsampwhoampchooseamptoampbeamp
involvedampnationwideamp
(Aampthunderingampofampclappingampinamptheampaudience)amp
EDampampWhatampdoampyouampseeampareamptheamplonglttermampeffectsampofamptheampimplementationampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampamp
SMampampEllenampImampsureampIampdontamphaveamptoamptellampyouampthatampweampliveampinampaampfastltpacedamp
technologicallyltrevolutionaryampworldampampThereampareamppartsampofampthatampthatampareampwonderfulampandamp
makeampourampworldampanampeasierampplaceamptoampliveampampButampthereamphasamptoampbeamproomampforampusamptoampswitchampoffamp
unplugampandampslowampdownampampIampbelieveampthatamptheampplatformampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
unleashesampsomeamppossibilitiesampofamphumanampconnectionampinampaampveryamprealampauthenticampwayampamp
(Audienceamprisesampfromamptheirampseatsampwithamptearsampinamptheirampeyesampasamptheyampgiveampaampstandingamp
ovation)amp
EDampampAampnobleampgoalampindeedampampThankampyouampSamanthaampforampallampthatampyouampdoampampWhatampaampgamelt
changerampampThatsampallamptheamptimeampweamphaveampforamptodayampampItsampbeenampaamptrueamphonorampampGoodampluckampinamp
allampofampyourampendeavorsampampToampthoseampwatchingampatamphomeampgoamplistenamptoampsomeoneampamp
(SamanthaampEllenampandampaudienceampdanceampasamptheampcreditsamproll)amp
(
ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 53amp
loose(ends((References(
AndersonampEampHampampampSpencerampMampHamp(2013)ampAampPhenomenologicalampStudyampCognitiveamp
amp RepresentationsampofampAIDSampInampJampWampCreswellampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-
- Designamp(ppamp327lt346)ampLosampAngelesampSAGEampPublicationsampIncamp
BakerampGampampampMorrisampKamp(2002)ampDecartes-DualismampLondonampRoutledgeamp
BelenkyampMampFampClinchyampBampMampGoldbergerampNampRampampampTaruleampJampMamp(1997)ampWomens-Ways-
- of-Knowing-The-Development-of-Self-Voice-and-MindampNewampYorkampNYamp
amp BasicBooksamp
BleicherampJamp(1980)ampampContemporary-Hermeneutics-Hermeneutics-as-Method-
- Philosophy-and-Critique--LondonampUKampRoutledgeampampampKeeganampPaulamp
BohmampDamp(1996)ampOn-DialogueampLondonampUKampRoutledgeamp
BourgeoisampJampPamp(2007)ampThe-Aesthetic-Hermeneutics-of-Hans(Georg-Gadamer-and-Hans-
- Urs-von-BalthasarampNewampYorkampNYampPeterampLangampPublishingampIncamp
BrunsampGampLamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-Ancient-and-ModernampNewampHavenampCTampYaleamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
CalleampSamp(2011)ampBlindampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CalleampSamp(2005)ampExisquisite-PainampNewampYorkampThamesampampampHudsonamp
CalleampSamp(2008)ampTake-Care-of-YourselfampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CaputoampJamp(2000)ampMore-Radical-HermeneuticsampBloomingtonampINampIndianaampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
CreswellampJampWamp(2013)ampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-DesignampLosampAngelesampSAGEamp
amp PublicationsampIncamp
deampCossonampAamp(2002)ampTheampHermeneuticampDialogueampFindingampPatternsampamidamptheampAporiaamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 54amp
amp ofamptheampArtistResearcherTeacherampAlberta-Journal-of-Educational-Researchamp-
- 48amp(3)amp1lt20amp
ElkinsampJamp(2001)ampWhy-Art-Cannot-Be-TaughtampChicagoampILampUniversityampofampIllinoisampPressamp
FairfieldampPamp(2011)ampDialogueampinamptheampClassroomampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-
- Dialogue-and-Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp77lt90)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GadamerampHltGamp(1996)ampThe-Engima-of-HealthampStanfordampCAampStanfordampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
GadamerampHltGamp(2004)ampTruth-and-Methodamp(Secondamprevisedamped)amp(JampWeinsheimerampampamp
amp DampGampMarshallampTrans)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GallagherampSamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-and-EducationampAlbanyampNYampStateampUniversityampofamp
amp NewampYorkampPressamp
GendlinampEamp(1962)ampExperiencing-and-the-Creation-of-MeaningampNewampYorkampNYampTheamp
amp FreeampPressampofampGlencoeamp
GendlinampEamp(1997)ampampHowampPhilosophyampCannotampAppealamptoampExperienceampandampHowampItampCanamp
amp InampLanguage-beyond-Postmodernism-Saying-and-Thinking-in-Gendlins-
- Philosophy-(ppamp3lt41)ampEvanstonampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
GermeraadampGamp(2013)ampRationalityampIntuitionampandampEmotionampExploringampanampArtisticamp
amp ProcessampJournal-for-Artistic-Researchamp-3
GradleampSampAamp(2011)ampAampuniversityampcourseampinampmindfulampviewingampUnderstandingampartampandamp
amp selfampthroughampcontemplativeampexperienceampInternational-Journal-of-Education-
- Through-Artamp-7amp(2)amp137lt151amp
GreeneampMamp(2013)ampTheampTurningampofamptheampLeavesampExpandingampOurampVisionampforamptheampArtsampinamp
amp EducationampHarvard-Educational-Reviewamp-83amp(1)amp251lt252amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 55amp
GrondinampJamp(2002)ampGadamersampBasicampUnderstandingampofampUnderstandingampInampThe-
- Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp36lt51)ampCambridgeampUKampCambridgeamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
GrondinampJamp(2011)ampGadamersampExperienceampandampTheoryampofampEducationampLearningampthatamp
amp theampOtherampMayampBeampRightampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp5lt20)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
HeelanampPamp(1985)ampampPerceptionampasampaampHermeneuticalampActampampInampDampIhdeampampampHampSilvermanamp
amp (Eds)ampHermeneutics-amp-Deconstruction-(ppamp43lt54)-AlbanyampSUNYampPressamp
HeelanampPampampampSchulkinampJamp(2003)ampHermeneuticalampPhilosophyampandampPragmatismampAamp
amp PhilosophyampofampScienceampInampRampCampScharffampampampVampDusekamp(Eds)ampPhilosophy-of-
- Technology-The-Technological-Condition-an-Anthology-amp(ppamp138lt153)amp
amp MaldenampMAampBlackwellamp
KarpiakampIampEamp(2003)ampTheampListeningampHeartampTuningampInampForampTransformativeampLearningamp
amp 2003-Complexity-Science-and-Educational-Research-Conferenceamp(ppamp67lt80)amp
amp EdmontonampCanadaamp
KellyampMampPost(Partum-DocumentampInstituteampofampContemporaryampArtsampLondonamp
KentampSampJampampampCummingampJampamp(2008)ampampIampdontampknowampEngagingampwithampproblematicamp
amp momentsampinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampRadical-Pedagogy-2-(9)amp1lt20ampampamp
LevinampDampMamp(1989)ampThe-Listening-Self-Personal-Growth-Social-Change-and-the-
- Closure-of-MetaphysicsampNewampYorkampNYampRoutledgeamp
LindsethampAampampampNorbergampAamp(2004)ampAampphenomenologicalamphermeneuticalampmethodampforamp
amp researchingamplivedampexperienceampNordic-College-of-Caring-Sciencesamp-18amp145lt153amp
LipariampLamp(2014)ampampOnampinterlisteningampandamptheampideaampofampdialogueampampTheory-amp-Psychology-24-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 56amp
- (4)amp504lt523amp
MarksampLamp(2002)ampTouch-Sensuous-Theory-and-Multisensory-MediaampMinneapolisamp
amp UniversityampofampMinnesotaampPressamp
MunozampKampLamp(2014)ampTranscribing-Silence-Culture-Relationship-and-Communicationamp
amp WalnutampCreekampCAampLeftampCoastampPressamp
NicholampLamp(1996)ampForewordampInampDampBohmampOn-Dialogueamp(ppampviiltxvii)ampLondonampUKamp
amp Routledgeamp
PalmerampRamp(1969)ampHermeneutics-Interpretation-Theory-in-Schleiermacher-Dilthey-
- Heidegger-and-GadamerampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
PerlampSamp(2004)ampFelt-Sense-Writing-with-the-BodyampPortsmouthampNHampBoyntonCookamp
RicoeurampPamp(19691974)ampThe-Conflicts-of-Interpretations-Essays-in-Hermeneuticsamp
amp (NorthwesternampUniversityampPressampTrans)ampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
RicoeurampPamp(2013)ampHermeneuticsampCambridgeampUKampPolityampPressamp
SableampDamp(2014)ampReasonampinamptheampServiceampofamptheampHeartampTheampImpactsampofampContemplativeamp
amp PracticesamponampCriticalampThinkingampJournal-of-Contemplative-Inquiryamp-1amp(1)amp1lt22amp
SchultzampKamp(2010)ampAfteramptheampBlackbirdampWhistlesampListeningamptoampSilenceampinampClassroomsamp
amp Teachers-College-Recordamp-112amp(11)amp2833lt2849amp
SeebohmampTampamp(2004)ampampHermeneutics-Method-and-MethodologyampDordrechtamptheamp
amp NetherlandsampKluwerampAcademicampPublishersamp
SnowberampCamp(2005)ampTheampmentorampasampartistampaamppoeticampexplorationampofamplisteningampcreatingamp
amp andampmentoringampMentoring-and-Tutoring-13amp(3)amp345lt353amp
vanampManenampMampamp(1984)ampPracticingampPhenomenologicalampWritingampPhenomenology-+-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 57amp
- Pedagogy-2amp(1)amp36lt68amp
vanampManenampMamp(1990)ampampResearching-Lived-Experience-Human-Science-for-an-Action(
- Sensitive-PedagogyampNewampYorkampSUNYampPressamp
VitanovaampGamp(2010)ampampAuthoring-the-Dialogic-SelfampAmsterdamampJohnampBenjaminsamp
amp PublishingampCoamp
WatsonampJamp(2013)ampampKnowingampthroughamptheampfeltltsenseampaampgestureampofampopennessamptoamptheamp
amp otherampampInternational-Journal-of-Childrens-Spirituality-18amp(1)amp118lt130amp
WiercinskiampAamp(2011)ampHermeneuticampEducationamptoampUnderstandingampSelfltEducationampandamp
amp theampWillingnessamptoampRiskampFailureampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp107lt124)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
WorsleyampRamp(2012)ampNarrativesampandamplivelyampmetaphorsampHermeneuticsampasampaampwayampofamp
amp listeningampPerson(Centered-amp-Experiential-Psychotherapiesamp-11amp(4)amp304lt320amp
ZuckertampCampHamp(2002)ampHermeneuticsampinampPracticeampGadameramponampAncientampPhilosophyampInamp
amp RampJampDostalamp(Ed)ampThe-Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp201lt224)amp
amp CambridgeampUKampCambridgeampUniversityampPressamp
amp
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
- WebsitePaper-20
- WebsitePaper-18
- WebsitePaperpdf
-
- MesserFinalPaper-11
- MesserFinalPaper
-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 43amp
amp Theamprealizationampthatampcreativeltlisteningampspacesamprequireampmoreampthanampjustampanamp
attitudeampshiftampcameampfromampanotheramponeampofamptheampbiggestampoutcomesampofampthisampresearchampampTheamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampIampenactedamphadampsomethingampofampaampdominoampeffectamponampmyamppracticesamp
withinampthemampampTheampmostampimportantampaspectampofampenactingampthemampwasampbeingampreflexiveamptoamp
whatamphappenedampwithinampthemampampIampwasampconstantlyampaskingampmyselfampwhatampwasampworkingamp
whatampneededamptoampchangeampandampwhatampcouldampmakeampitampbetterampampIampreflectedamponampmyampownampstateamp
ofampmindampandamphowampthatampinformedampmyampexperiencesampandamptheampexperiencesampofampanotherampampIamp
reflectedamponampmyampassumptionsampampIampthoughtampthatampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmightamphaveampaamp
certainampkindampofampfeelingampaamptransformativeampclickampthatampwouldampletampmeampknowampitampwasamp
workingampampButampitsampnotampthatampsimpleampampAampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcanampmanifestampitselfampinamp
soampmanyampwaysampthatampitsampimpossibleamptoampidentifyampthemampallampampItampcouldampfeelamplikeampaampregularamp
conversationamporampcritiqueampitampcouldampfeelampuncomfortableamporampeasyampampItampcouldamphaveampaampuniqueamp
asltyetltunknownampqualityampampLikeampaampworkampofampartampitampcouldamptakeamponampanyampnumberampofampformsamp
andamppossibilitiesampMyampassumptionampthatampitampwouldamptakeamponamponeampeasylttoltrecognizeamp
manifestationampwasampnotampasampnuancedampasampthisampresearchampindicatesamptheamppossibilitiesampwouldamp
haveamptoampbeampampamp
amp FinallyampinampresponseamptoampresponseampIampcreatedampaamptextltobjectamp(Imagesamp1ampampamp2)ampthatamp
offersamponeamppossibleamparticulationamptoamptheampsurveysampandampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcaseamp
studiesampampIampwouldamplikeamptoampletampthisamponeamppossibilityampserveampasampaampmarkerampforamptheampinfiniteamp
possibilitiesampIampdidampnotampmakeampexploreampexpressamporampundergoampbutampthatampcontinueamptoampexistamp
inamptheamprealmampofampwhatltmightltbeamp
amp ThisamptextltobjectampisampakinamptoampaampmovingamppieceampofamppoetryampampToampcreateamptheamptextampIamp
collagedamptogetherampvariousamppassagesampfromamptheampsurveyampresponsesampinampanampeffortamptoamphonoramp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 44amp
manyampvoicesampampTheamptextampisampopenampandampflowingampwithampnoampclearampbeginningamporampendampampTheamp
concealampandamprevealampaspectampofamptheampworkampcallsamptoampmindamptheampactampofampresearchampandampinquiryampinamp
generalampampTheampthickampblackampscribblesamponamptheampmovingampcirclesampareampderivedampfromamptheampfieldamp
notesampIamptookampduringampmyampexperiencesampwithampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcaseampstudiesampampTheamp
overlappingampdenseampqualityampofampthisamptextampcallsamptoampmindamptheampdensenessampofamptheseamp
experiencesampandamptheampoverwhelmingampimpossibilityampofampabsorbingampeverythingampIampcouldamp
containampamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 47amp
thread8(amp
(In)conclusions(amp
amp InamptheampwordsampofampPaulampFairfieldamp(2011)ampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinampdialogueampnoamp
interpretationampthatampisampuniquelyampandampsupremelyampauthoritativeamp(pamp83)ampampThoughampthisamp
paperampisampendingampthereampisampnoamplastampwordamponamptheampmatterampofamplisteningampforampmeampnorampforamp
studentsampteachersamphumansampworksampofampartamptextsampadampinfinitumampampThisampmyampnotltsolt
conclusiveltconcludingampsectionampstretchesamptheamppossibilityampofampmyampresearchampinampaampmanneramp
thatampdefiesamptheampsupremelyampauthoritativeampstructureampofampanampacademicampresearchamppaperampampamp
amp
Below-is-the-transcript-from-an-episode-dated-April-6-2015-of-the-popular-daytime-
talk-show-Ellen-during-which-the-artistresearcheducator-was-invited-to-discuss-her-
groundbreaking-work-on-listening-
(Camerasamprollampinamp3amp2amp1ampSceneampopensamponamptheampsetampof-EllenampampCameraamppansampinamptoampfocusamp
onampEllenampampSheampisampseatedamponampaamploveseatampwearingampaampcreamltcoloredamppantsuitampwithampaamplightamp
blueampbuttonltupampshirtampampHeramphairampisampperfectlyampcoiffedampampLightsampflashampandamptheampcrowdamp
cheersampampIntroampmusicampswells)-
EllenampDegeneresampampHelloampeveryoneampampWelcomeamptoamptheampshowamptodayampampTheampfirstamponlyampandamp
mostampimportantampguestamponamptodaysampshowampisampSamanthaampMesserampampSamanthaampisampanampartistamp
researcherampandampeducatorampbasedampinampCincinnatiampOhioampwhoseamprecentampresearchampprojectamp
onamplisteningampinampartampeducationamphasamptheamppotentialamptoampchangeamptheampfaceampofampnotamponlyampartamp
educationampbutampalsoamptheampworldampampHereampsheampisampSamanthaampMesseramp
(SamanthaampwalksamponamptheampstageamplookingampsleekampasamphellampwhileampdoingampitampampTheampaudienceamp
cheersampampSamanthaampandampEllenamphugamplikeampoldampfriends)amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 48amp
SamanthaampMesserampampHiampEllenampampItsampsoampgreatamptoampseeampyouampampamp
EDampampNoampSamanthaampitsampgreatamptoampseeampyouampampTellampusampaboutampwhatampbringsampyouamphereamptodayamp
SMampamp(Laughsampfreelyampwithoutampaampcare)ampEllenampyouampareampwhatampbroughtampmeamphereamptoday(
(Audienceamplaughs)amp
EDampampIampappreciateampthatampthankampyouampampButampletsampgetamptoampwhatsamponampAmericasampmindampampYouramp
lifesampworkampampIncredibleampampWhatampexactlyampisampitampandamphowampdidampitampcomeampaboutampampampampamp
SMampampEllenampwhereamptoampbeginampampampTheampideaampinampitsampmostampbasicampformampisampanampartampeducationampbasedamp
aroundamplisteningamppracticesamp
EDampampThatampsoundsampfascinatingampamp
SMampampIampknowampampThankampyouampforampnoticingampitsampsubtleampbrillianceamp
EDampampIampwouldampbeampaampfoolampnotamptoampampTellampusamphowampyouampcameampupampwithampthisampideaamp
SMampampampTheampcentralampcomponentampisampanampideaampcalledampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampwhichampisampaamp
spaceampinampwhichampstudentsampandampparticipantsampmakeampdiscussampandampviewampworksampofampartampwithamp
listeningampatamptheampcenterampofamptheseampactivitiesampandampexperiencesampampThisampideaampcameamptogetheramp
overamptheampcourseampofampmonthsampofampreadingamphundredsampofampdiscussionsampwithamppeersampresearchamp
participantsampandampprofessorsampasampwellampasamptheampwritingampandamprewritingampofampmanyampdraftsampofamp
myampnowampbestltsellingampbookamp
(Audienceampooooooohs)amp
EDampampWowampyouampreallyampputampsomeampthoughtampintoampthisamphuhampampSoamphowampisampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampdifferentampthanampaampregularampclassroomamp
SMampampWellampitampdependsamponamptheampclassroomampampSomeampclassroomsampprobablyampalreadyampareamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampampEssentiallyampitamprequiresampsomethingampofampanampattitudeampshiftampampItamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 49amp
doesntampevenampnecessarilyamphaveamptoampbeampinampaampclassroomamporampanyampspecificampplaceampampItsampmoreampofamp
aampstateampofampmindampandampanampattitudeamp
EDampampCouldampweampbeampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamprightampnowamp
SMampampEllenampnothingampwouldampgiveampmeampmoreamppleasureamp
(Audienceampawwwwws)amp
SMampampButampseriouslyampyesampweampcanampbeampampThoughampitampmightamptakeampmoreampthanampjustampanampattitudeamp
shiftampampWhenampIampinitiallyampbeganampthisampprojectampIampthoughtampthatsampallampitampwouldampbeampampIampassumedamp
thatampifampparticipantsampwereampwillingamptheyampcouldampenterampintoampthisampstateampofampmindampampamp
EDampampButampthatsampnotamptheampcaseamp
SMampampWellampitsampjustampthatampitsampmoreampcomplicatedampthanampthatampampWhatampIampfoundampwereampthatamptheamp
thingsampIampwasampaskingampindividualsamptoampdoampwereampnotampwithinampouramptypicalampculturalampskillampsetampamp
NotamponlyampthisampbutamptheyampareampdifficultampsubtleampandampoftenampinternalamppursuitsampampTheyampareampnotamp
easyamptoampseeampandamptheampresultsampareampnotampinstantaneousampampItsamphardamptoampknowampifampyoureampdoingamp
itamprightamp
EDampSoampwhatampdoesampitampmeanamptoampdoampitamprightamp
SMampampThatsampaampgreatampquestionampEllenampandampthankampyouampforampaskingampitampampIampdontampthinkamptheresamp
justamponeampwayampofampdoingampitamprightampampAndampevenampsometimesampwhenampyoureampdoingampitamprightampitamp
mightampnotampfeelamplikeampanythingampspecialampampItampcouldampjustampfeelamplikeampaampnormalampconversationamp
EDampampSoampthisampisampallampaboutamphavingampaampconversationampampIampdoampthatampfiveampdaysampaampweekamponampthisampsetamp
Samanthaampamp
(Audienceamplaughsamplightheartedly)amp
SMampampEllenampampYoureampcuttingampmeampdeepampamp(laughs)ampYoureamprightampampItsampnotamprevolutionaryampamp
Toamplistenamptoampbeamplistenedamptoamptoampcarryamponampanampopenampandamphonestampconversationampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 50amp
anotheramphumanampTheseampareamphumbleampgoalsampthatampweampcanampcarryampacrossampmanyampcontextsampampIamp
thinkampthereinampliesamptheampbeautyamp
EDampampInterestingampampImampgoingamptoampaskampwhatampImampsureampaamplotampofampteachersamphaveamponamptheiramp
mindsltlthowampdoampweampteachampthisamptoampstudentsamp
SMampampTheampgoalsampandampbeliefsampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmustampbeamplivedampthroughampandamp
undergoneampratherampthanampmerelyampactedampoutamponceamporamptwiceampampItsampaboutampcreatingampaampsystemamp
craftingampassignmentsampandampsettingampaamptoneampthatampallampunderlieamptheseampvaluesampampNotamponlyampthatamp
butamptheampstudentsampandampteachersampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmustampbeampreflectiveamptoamp
theirampexperiencesampampTheseampskillsampneedamptoampbeampbuiltampupampandampaampkeyampcomponentampofampthatampisamp
reflectionamponamppreviousampexperiencesamp
EDampampampIampunderstandampyouampalsoampsolicitedampsurveyampresponsesamptoampdiscussampmomentsampinampwhichamp
individualsampdidamporampdidampnotampfeelamplistenedamptoampasamptheyampspokeampaboutamptheirampartampampCanampyouamptalkamp
aamplittleampbitampaboutampwhatampyouampfoundampinamptheampsurveysamp
SMampampWellampIampcoveredampaamplotampofampthisampinampmyampbookampYoullamphaveamptoampreadampitampampIamphaveampprovidedamp
everyampmemberampofamptheampaudienceamptodayampwithampaampcopyampwhichampyoullampallampfindampunderampyouramp
seatsamp
(AudienceampgoesampwildampwithampexcitementampasamptheyampreachampunderamptheirampseatsampampThereampareamp
intermittentampscreechesampofampjoy)amp
EDampampWowampthankampyouampampTheampgiftampofamplisteningampwhatampaamptreasureampforamptheampaudienceamp
membersamptodayamp
(Audienceampclapsampwholeheartedly)amp
SMampampYoureampwelcomeampampInampgeneralampthoughampwhatampIampfoundampisampaampneedamptoamphandleamptheampwordsamp
andampexperiencesampofampothersampwithampcareampampTheampsurveysampdescribedampsituationsampinampwhichamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 51amp
individualsampfeltamptheyampwereampnotampbeingamplistenedamptoampyetamptheseampmomentsampwereampnotampusuallyamp
profoundlyamporamppurposefullyamphurtfulampampMoreampoftenamptheampsurveysampdescribedampinstancesampinamp
whichamppeopleampfeltampthatampanotheramppersonampwasntamptryingamptoampunderstandampampTheseamp
situationsampwereampmoreamppassiveampandampdismissiveampratherampthanampactivelyamphurtfulampthoughamp
theyampdidampstillamphurtamp
EDampampWellampcouldntampthatampbeampchalkedampupamptoamptheampsensitiveamppersonaampofamptheampartistampampWeampallamp
knowamphowampsensitiveampthoseampartistsampareamp
(Audienceamplaughsamptheyampareampinamponamptheampjoke)amp
SMampamp(chastising)ampEllenampyoureampsmarterampthanampthatampstereotypeampampIampmeanampyouampcouldampsayamp
thatampbutampIampdontampknowampifampthatampwouldampbeampproductiveampampAndampitampwouldntampfitampwithamptheamp
beliefsampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampinampmyampopinionampampDontampweampallampwantamptoampbeamplistenedamp
toampampIsampthatampdesireampexclusiveamptoampsomeampideaampweamphaveampinampourampheadampofampartistsampampIampdontamp
thinkampsoamp
EDampampYoureampsoamprightampSamanthaampampImampsorryampforampgivingampintoampsomeamppervasiveampmodernistamp
nonsenseampaboutampwhatampitampisamptoampbeampanampartistamp
(Audienceampnodsampinampagreement)amp
SMampampItsampokayampEllenampWeampinamptheampartampworldampareampfightingamptheampgoodampfightampWhatampweampdoampisamp
importantampandampwereamptiredampofampbeingampdismissedampbyampsocietyamp
(Audienceampclaps)amp
EDampampSoampwhatampisampyourampnextampstepamp
SMampampWellampIampwasampjustampawardedampaampspecialampmedalampofamphonorampfromampPresidentampObamaampamp
(PhotoampofampSamanthaampshakingamphandsampwithamptheampPresidentampflashesamponamptheampscreenampandamptheamp
audienceampclaps)amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 52amp
EDampampCongratulationsamp
SMampampThankampyouampampWhatampanamphonorampampAlongampwithampthisampcommendationampcameampaampgrantampforamp
meamptoampbeampableamptoamptrainampaampgroupampofamphighlyampspecializedampartistlteducatorsampinamptheseamp
practicesampandampsendampthemampoutamptoampcommunitiesampacrossamptheampcountryamptoamphelpampimplementamp
andampsupportampeffortsamptoampputampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampintoampschoolsampwhoampchooseamptoampbeamp
involvedampnationwideamp
(Aampthunderingampofampclappingampinamptheampaudience)amp
EDampampWhatampdoampyouampseeampareamptheamplonglttermampeffectsampofamptheampimplementationampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampamp
SMampampEllenampImampsureampIampdontamphaveamptoamptellampyouampthatampweampliveampinampaampfastltpacedamp
technologicallyltrevolutionaryampworldampampThereampareamppartsampofampthatampthatampareampwonderfulampandamp
makeampourampworldampanampeasierampplaceamptoampliveampampButampthereamphasamptoampbeamproomampforampusamptoampswitchampoffamp
unplugampandampslowampdownampampIampbelieveampthatamptheampplatformampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
unleashesampsomeamppossibilitiesampofamphumanampconnectionampinampaampveryamprealampauthenticampwayampamp
(Audienceamprisesampfromamptheirampseatsampwithamptearsampinamptheirampeyesampasamptheyampgiveampaampstandingamp
ovation)amp
EDampampAampnobleampgoalampindeedampampThankampyouampSamanthaampforampallampthatampyouampdoampampWhatampaampgamelt
changerampampThatsampallamptheamptimeampweamphaveampforamptodayampampItsampbeenampaamptrueamphonorampampGoodampluckampinamp
allampofampyourampendeavorsampampToampthoseampwatchingampatamphomeampgoamplistenamptoampsomeoneampamp
(SamanthaampEllenampandampaudienceampdanceampasamptheampcreditsamproll)amp
(
ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 53amp
loose(ends((References(
AndersonampEampHampampampSpencerampMampHamp(2013)ampAampPhenomenologicalampStudyampCognitiveamp
amp RepresentationsampofampAIDSampInampJampWampCreswellampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-
- Designamp(ppamp327lt346)ampLosampAngelesampSAGEampPublicationsampIncamp
BakerampGampampampMorrisampKamp(2002)ampDecartes-DualismampLondonampRoutledgeamp
BelenkyampMampFampClinchyampBampMampGoldbergerampNampRampampampTaruleampJampMamp(1997)ampWomens-Ways-
- of-Knowing-The-Development-of-Self-Voice-and-MindampNewampYorkampNYamp
amp BasicBooksamp
BleicherampJamp(1980)ampampContemporary-Hermeneutics-Hermeneutics-as-Method-
- Philosophy-and-Critique--LondonampUKampRoutledgeampampampKeeganampPaulamp
BohmampDamp(1996)ampOn-DialogueampLondonampUKampRoutledgeamp
BourgeoisampJampPamp(2007)ampThe-Aesthetic-Hermeneutics-of-Hans(Georg-Gadamer-and-Hans-
- Urs-von-BalthasarampNewampYorkampNYampPeterampLangampPublishingampIncamp
BrunsampGampLamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-Ancient-and-ModernampNewampHavenampCTampYaleamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
CalleampSamp(2011)ampBlindampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CalleampSamp(2005)ampExisquisite-PainampNewampYorkampThamesampampampHudsonamp
CalleampSamp(2008)ampTake-Care-of-YourselfampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CaputoampJamp(2000)ampMore-Radical-HermeneuticsampBloomingtonampINampIndianaampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
CreswellampJampWamp(2013)ampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-DesignampLosampAngelesampSAGEamp
amp PublicationsampIncamp
deampCossonampAamp(2002)ampTheampHermeneuticampDialogueampFindingampPatternsampamidamptheampAporiaamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 54amp
amp ofamptheampArtistResearcherTeacherampAlberta-Journal-of-Educational-Researchamp-
- 48amp(3)amp1lt20amp
ElkinsampJamp(2001)ampWhy-Art-Cannot-Be-TaughtampChicagoampILampUniversityampofampIllinoisampPressamp
FairfieldampPamp(2011)ampDialogueampinamptheampClassroomampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-
- Dialogue-and-Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp77lt90)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GadamerampHltGamp(1996)ampThe-Engima-of-HealthampStanfordampCAampStanfordampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
GadamerampHltGamp(2004)ampTruth-and-Methodamp(Secondamprevisedamped)amp(JampWeinsheimerampampamp
amp DampGampMarshallampTrans)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GallagherampSamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-and-EducationampAlbanyampNYampStateampUniversityampofamp
amp NewampYorkampPressamp
GendlinampEamp(1962)ampExperiencing-and-the-Creation-of-MeaningampNewampYorkampNYampTheamp
amp FreeampPressampofampGlencoeamp
GendlinampEamp(1997)ampampHowampPhilosophyampCannotampAppealamptoampExperienceampandampHowampItampCanamp
amp InampLanguage-beyond-Postmodernism-Saying-and-Thinking-in-Gendlins-
- Philosophy-(ppamp3lt41)ampEvanstonampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
GermeraadampGamp(2013)ampRationalityampIntuitionampandampEmotionampExploringampanampArtisticamp
amp ProcessampJournal-for-Artistic-Researchamp-3
GradleampSampAamp(2011)ampAampuniversityampcourseampinampmindfulampviewingampUnderstandingampartampandamp
amp selfampthroughampcontemplativeampexperienceampInternational-Journal-of-Education-
- Through-Artamp-7amp(2)amp137lt151amp
GreeneampMamp(2013)ampTheampTurningampofamptheampLeavesampExpandingampOurampVisionampforamptheampArtsampinamp
amp EducationampHarvard-Educational-Reviewamp-83amp(1)amp251lt252amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 55amp
GrondinampJamp(2002)ampGadamersampBasicampUnderstandingampofampUnderstandingampInampThe-
- Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp36lt51)ampCambridgeampUKampCambridgeamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
GrondinampJamp(2011)ampGadamersampExperienceampandampTheoryampofampEducationampLearningampthatamp
amp theampOtherampMayampBeampRightampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp5lt20)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
HeelanampPamp(1985)ampampPerceptionampasampaampHermeneuticalampActampampInampDampIhdeampampampHampSilvermanamp
amp (Eds)ampHermeneutics-amp-Deconstruction-(ppamp43lt54)-AlbanyampSUNYampPressamp
HeelanampPampampampSchulkinampJamp(2003)ampHermeneuticalampPhilosophyampandampPragmatismampAamp
amp PhilosophyampofampScienceampInampRampCampScharffampampampVampDusekamp(Eds)ampPhilosophy-of-
- Technology-The-Technological-Condition-an-Anthology-amp(ppamp138lt153)amp
amp MaldenampMAampBlackwellamp
KarpiakampIampEamp(2003)ampTheampListeningampHeartampTuningampInampForampTransformativeampLearningamp
amp 2003-Complexity-Science-and-Educational-Research-Conferenceamp(ppamp67lt80)amp
amp EdmontonampCanadaamp
KellyampMampPost(Partum-DocumentampInstituteampofampContemporaryampArtsampLondonamp
KentampSampJampampampCummingampJampamp(2008)ampampIampdontampknowampEngagingampwithampproblematicamp
amp momentsampinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampRadical-Pedagogy-2-(9)amp1lt20ampampamp
LevinampDampMamp(1989)ampThe-Listening-Self-Personal-Growth-Social-Change-and-the-
- Closure-of-MetaphysicsampNewampYorkampNYampRoutledgeamp
LindsethampAampampampNorbergampAamp(2004)ampAampphenomenologicalamphermeneuticalampmethodampforamp
amp researchingamplivedampexperienceampNordic-College-of-Caring-Sciencesamp-18amp145lt153amp
LipariampLamp(2014)ampampOnampinterlisteningampandamptheampideaampofampdialogueampampTheory-amp-Psychology-24-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 56amp
- (4)amp504lt523amp
MarksampLamp(2002)ampTouch-Sensuous-Theory-and-Multisensory-MediaampMinneapolisamp
amp UniversityampofampMinnesotaampPressamp
MunozampKampLamp(2014)ampTranscribing-Silence-Culture-Relationship-and-Communicationamp
amp WalnutampCreekampCAampLeftampCoastampPressamp
NicholampLamp(1996)ampForewordampInampDampBohmampOn-Dialogueamp(ppampviiltxvii)ampLondonampUKamp
amp Routledgeamp
PalmerampRamp(1969)ampHermeneutics-Interpretation-Theory-in-Schleiermacher-Dilthey-
- Heidegger-and-GadamerampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
PerlampSamp(2004)ampFelt-Sense-Writing-with-the-BodyampPortsmouthampNHampBoyntonCookamp
RicoeurampPamp(19691974)ampThe-Conflicts-of-Interpretations-Essays-in-Hermeneuticsamp
amp (NorthwesternampUniversityampPressampTrans)ampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
RicoeurampPamp(2013)ampHermeneuticsampCambridgeampUKampPolityampPressamp
SableampDamp(2014)ampReasonampinamptheampServiceampofamptheampHeartampTheampImpactsampofampContemplativeamp
amp PracticesamponampCriticalampThinkingampJournal-of-Contemplative-Inquiryamp-1amp(1)amp1lt22amp
SchultzampKamp(2010)ampAfteramptheampBlackbirdampWhistlesampListeningamptoampSilenceampinampClassroomsamp
amp Teachers-College-Recordamp-112amp(11)amp2833lt2849amp
SeebohmampTampamp(2004)ampampHermeneutics-Method-and-MethodologyampDordrechtamptheamp
amp NetherlandsampKluwerampAcademicampPublishersamp
SnowberampCamp(2005)ampTheampmentorampasampartistampaamppoeticampexplorationampofamplisteningampcreatingamp
amp andampmentoringampMentoring-and-Tutoring-13amp(3)amp345lt353amp
vanampManenampMampamp(1984)ampPracticingampPhenomenologicalampWritingampPhenomenology-+-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 57amp
- Pedagogy-2amp(1)amp36lt68amp
vanampManenampMamp(1990)ampampResearching-Lived-Experience-Human-Science-for-an-Action(
- Sensitive-PedagogyampNewampYorkampSUNYampPressamp
VitanovaampGamp(2010)ampampAuthoring-the-Dialogic-SelfampAmsterdamampJohnampBenjaminsamp
amp PublishingampCoamp
WatsonampJamp(2013)ampampKnowingampthroughamptheampfeltltsenseampaampgestureampofampopennessamptoamptheamp
amp otherampampInternational-Journal-of-Childrens-Spirituality-18amp(1)amp118lt130amp
WiercinskiampAamp(2011)ampHermeneuticampEducationamptoampUnderstandingampSelfltEducationampandamp
amp theampWillingnessamptoampRiskampFailureampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp107lt124)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
WorsleyampRamp(2012)ampNarrativesampandamplivelyampmetaphorsampHermeneuticsampasampaampwayampofamp
amp listeningampPerson(Centered-amp-Experiential-Psychotherapiesamp-11amp(4)amp304lt320amp
ZuckertampCampHamp(2002)ampHermeneuticsampinampPracticeampGadameramponampAncientampPhilosophyampInamp
amp RampJampDostalamp(Ed)ampThe-Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp201lt224)amp
amp CambridgeampUKampCambridgeampUniversityampPressamp
amp
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
- WebsitePaper-20
- WebsitePaper-18
- WebsitePaperpdf
-
- MesserFinalPaper-11
- MesserFinalPaper
-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 44amp
manyampvoicesampampTheamptextampisampopenampandampflowingampwithampnoampclearampbeginningamporampendampampTheamp
concealampandamprevealampaspectampofamptheampworkampcallsamptoampmindamptheampactampofampresearchampandampinquiryampinamp
generalampampTheampthickampblackampscribblesamponamptheampmovingampcirclesampareampderivedampfromamptheampfieldamp
notesampIamptookampduringampmyampexperiencesampwithampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampcaseampstudiesampampTheamp
overlappingampdenseampqualityampofampthisamptextampcallsamptoampmindamptheampdensenessampofamptheseamp
experiencesampandamptheampoverwhelmingampimpossibilityampofampabsorbingampeverythingampIampcouldamp
containampamp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp
amp amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 47amp
thread8(amp
(In)conclusions(amp
amp InamptheampwordsampofampPaulampFairfieldamp(2011)ampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinampdialogueampnoamp
interpretationampthatampisampuniquelyampandampsupremelyampauthoritativeamp(pamp83)ampampThoughampthisamp
paperampisampendingampthereampisampnoamplastampwordamponamptheampmatterampofamplisteningampforampmeampnorampforamp
studentsampteachersamphumansampworksampofampartamptextsampadampinfinitumampampThisampmyampnotltsolt
conclusiveltconcludingampsectionampstretchesamptheamppossibilityampofampmyampresearchampinampaampmanneramp
thatampdefiesamptheampsupremelyampauthoritativeampstructureampofampanampacademicampresearchamppaperampampamp
amp
Below-is-the-transcript-from-an-episode-dated-April-6-2015-of-the-popular-daytime-
talk-show-Ellen-during-which-the-artistresearcheducator-was-invited-to-discuss-her-
groundbreaking-work-on-listening-
(Camerasamprollampinamp3amp2amp1ampSceneampopensamponamptheampsetampof-EllenampampCameraamppansampinamptoampfocusamp
onampEllenampampSheampisampseatedamponampaamploveseatampwearingampaampcreamltcoloredamppantsuitampwithampaamplightamp
blueampbuttonltupampshirtampampHeramphairampisampperfectlyampcoiffedampampLightsampflashampandamptheampcrowdamp
cheersampampIntroampmusicampswells)-
EllenampDegeneresampampHelloampeveryoneampampWelcomeamptoamptheampshowamptodayampampTheampfirstamponlyampandamp
mostampimportantampguestamponamptodaysampshowampisampSamanthaampMesserampampSamanthaampisampanampartistamp
researcherampandampeducatorampbasedampinampCincinnatiampOhioampwhoseamprecentampresearchampprojectamp
onamplisteningampinampartampeducationamphasamptheamppotentialamptoampchangeamptheampfaceampofampnotamponlyampartamp
educationampbutampalsoamptheampworldampampHereampsheampisampSamanthaampMesseramp
(SamanthaampwalksamponamptheampstageamplookingampsleekampasamphellampwhileampdoingampitampampTheampaudienceamp
cheersampampSamanthaampandampEllenamphugamplikeampoldampfriends)amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 48amp
SamanthaampMesserampampHiampEllenampampItsampsoampgreatamptoampseeampyouampampamp
EDampampNoampSamanthaampitsampgreatamptoampseeampyouampampTellampusampaboutampwhatampbringsampyouamphereamptodayamp
SMampamp(Laughsampfreelyampwithoutampaampcare)ampEllenampyouampareampwhatampbroughtampmeamphereamptoday(
(Audienceamplaughs)amp
EDampampIampappreciateampthatampthankampyouampampButampletsampgetamptoampwhatsamponampAmericasampmindampampYouramp
lifesampworkampampIncredibleampampWhatampexactlyampisampitampandamphowampdidampitampcomeampaboutampampampampamp
SMampampEllenampwhereamptoampbeginampampampTheampideaampinampitsampmostampbasicampformampisampanampartampeducationampbasedamp
aroundamplisteningamppracticesamp
EDampampThatampsoundsampfascinatingampamp
SMampampIampknowampampThankampyouampforampnoticingampitsampsubtleampbrillianceamp
EDampampIampwouldampbeampaampfoolampnotamptoampampTellampusamphowampyouampcameampupampwithampthisampideaamp
SMampampampTheampcentralampcomponentampisampanampideaampcalledampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampwhichampisampaamp
spaceampinampwhichampstudentsampandampparticipantsampmakeampdiscussampandampviewampworksampofampartampwithamp
listeningampatamptheampcenterampofamptheseampactivitiesampandampexperiencesampampThisampideaampcameamptogetheramp
overamptheampcourseampofampmonthsampofampreadingamphundredsampofampdiscussionsampwithamppeersampresearchamp
participantsampandampprofessorsampasampwellampasamptheampwritingampandamprewritingampofampmanyampdraftsampofamp
myampnowampbestltsellingampbookamp
(Audienceampooooooohs)amp
EDampampWowampyouampreallyampputampsomeampthoughtampintoampthisamphuhampampSoamphowampisampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampdifferentampthanampaampregularampclassroomamp
SMampampWellampitampdependsamponamptheampclassroomampampSomeampclassroomsampprobablyampalreadyampareamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampampEssentiallyampitamprequiresampsomethingampofampanampattitudeampshiftampampItamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 49amp
doesntampevenampnecessarilyamphaveamptoampbeampinampaampclassroomamporampanyampspecificampplaceampampItsampmoreampofamp
aampstateampofampmindampandampanampattitudeamp
EDampampCouldampweampbeampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamprightampnowamp
SMampampEllenampnothingampwouldampgiveampmeampmoreamppleasureamp
(Audienceampawwwwws)amp
SMampampButampseriouslyampyesampweampcanampbeampampThoughampitampmightamptakeampmoreampthanampjustampanampattitudeamp
shiftampampWhenampIampinitiallyampbeganampthisampprojectampIampthoughtampthatsampallampitampwouldampbeampampIampassumedamp
thatampifampparticipantsampwereampwillingamptheyampcouldampenterampintoampthisampstateampofampmindampampamp
EDampampButampthatsampnotamptheampcaseamp
SMampampWellampitsampjustampthatampitsampmoreampcomplicatedampthanampthatampampWhatampIampfoundampwereampthatamptheamp
thingsampIampwasampaskingampindividualsamptoampdoampwereampnotampwithinampouramptypicalampculturalampskillampsetampamp
NotamponlyampthisampbutamptheyampareampdifficultampsubtleampandampoftenampinternalamppursuitsampampTheyampareampnotamp
easyamptoampseeampandamptheampresultsampareampnotampinstantaneousampampItsamphardamptoampknowampifampyoureampdoingamp
itamprightamp
EDampSoampwhatampdoesampitampmeanamptoampdoampitamprightamp
SMampampThatsampaampgreatampquestionampEllenampandampthankampyouampforampaskingampitampampIampdontampthinkamptheresamp
justamponeampwayampofampdoingampitamprightampampAndampevenampsometimesampwhenampyoureampdoingampitamprightampitamp
mightampnotampfeelamplikeampanythingampspecialampampItampcouldampjustampfeelamplikeampaampnormalampconversationamp
EDampampSoampthisampisampallampaboutamphavingampaampconversationampampIampdoampthatampfiveampdaysampaampweekamponampthisampsetamp
Samanthaampamp
(Audienceamplaughsamplightheartedly)amp
SMampampEllenampampYoureampcuttingampmeampdeepampamp(laughs)ampYoureamprightampampItsampnotamprevolutionaryampamp
Toamplistenamptoampbeamplistenedamptoamptoampcarryamponampanampopenampandamphonestampconversationampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 50amp
anotheramphumanampTheseampareamphumbleampgoalsampthatampweampcanampcarryampacrossampmanyampcontextsampampIamp
thinkampthereinampliesamptheampbeautyamp
EDampampInterestingampampImampgoingamptoampaskampwhatampImampsureampaamplotampofampteachersamphaveamponamptheiramp
mindsltlthowampdoampweampteachampthisamptoampstudentsamp
SMampampTheampgoalsampandampbeliefsampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmustampbeamplivedampthroughampandamp
undergoneampratherampthanampmerelyampactedampoutamponceamporamptwiceampampItsampaboutampcreatingampaampsystemamp
craftingampassignmentsampandampsettingampaamptoneampthatampallampunderlieamptheseampvaluesampampNotamponlyampthatamp
butamptheampstudentsampandampteachersampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmustampbeampreflectiveamptoamp
theirampexperiencesampampTheseampskillsampneedamptoampbeampbuiltampupampandampaampkeyampcomponentampofampthatampisamp
reflectionamponamppreviousampexperiencesamp
EDampampampIampunderstandampyouampalsoampsolicitedampsurveyampresponsesamptoampdiscussampmomentsampinampwhichamp
individualsampdidamporampdidampnotampfeelamplistenedamptoampasamptheyampspokeampaboutamptheirampartampampCanampyouamptalkamp
aamplittleampbitampaboutampwhatampyouampfoundampinamptheampsurveysamp
SMampampWellampIampcoveredampaamplotampofampthisampinampmyampbookampYoullamphaveamptoampreadampitampampIamphaveampprovidedamp
everyampmemberampofamptheampaudienceamptodayampwithampaampcopyampwhichampyoullampallampfindampunderampyouramp
seatsamp
(AudienceampgoesampwildampwithampexcitementampasamptheyampreachampunderamptheirampseatsampampThereampareamp
intermittentampscreechesampofampjoy)amp
EDampampWowampthankampyouampampTheampgiftampofamplisteningampwhatampaamptreasureampforamptheampaudienceamp
membersamptodayamp
(Audienceampclapsampwholeheartedly)amp
SMampampYoureampwelcomeampampInampgeneralampthoughampwhatampIampfoundampisampaampneedamptoamphandleamptheampwordsamp
andampexperiencesampofampothersampwithampcareampampTheampsurveysampdescribedampsituationsampinampwhichamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 51amp
individualsampfeltamptheyampwereampnotampbeingamplistenedamptoampyetamptheseampmomentsampwereampnotampusuallyamp
profoundlyamporamppurposefullyamphurtfulampampMoreampoftenamptheampsurveysampdescribedampinstancesampinamp
whichamppeopleampfeltampthatampanotheramppersonampwasntamptryingamptoampunderstandampampTheseamp
situationsampwereampmoreamppassiveampandampdismissiveampratherampthanampactivelyamphurtfulampthoughamp
theyampdidampstillamphurtamp
EDampampWellampcouldntampthatampbeampchalkedampupamptoamptheampsensitiveamppersonaampofamptheampartistampampWeampallamp
knowamphowampsensitiveampthoseampartistsampareamp
(Audienceamplaughsamptheyampareampinamponamptheampjoke)amp
SMampamp(chastising)ampEllenampyoureampsmarterampthanampthatampstereotypeampampIampmeanampyouampcouldampsayamp
thatampbutampIampdontampknowampifampthatampwouldampbeampproductiveampampAndampitampwouldntampfitampwithamptheamp
beliefsampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampinampmyampopinionampampDontampweampallampwantamptoampbeamplistenedamp
toampampIsampthatampdesireampexclusiveamptoampsomeampideaampweamphaveampinampourampheadampofampartistsampampIampdontamp
thinkampsoamp
EDampampYoureampsoamprightampSamanthaampampImampsorryampforampgivingampintoampsomeamppervasiveampmodernistamp
nonsenseampaboutampwhatampitampisamptoampbeampanampartistamp
(Audienceampnodsampinampagreement)amp
SMampampItsampokayampEllenampWeampinamptheampartampworldampareampfightingamptheampgoodampfightampWhatampweampdoampisamp
importantampandampwereamptiredampofampbeingampdismissedampbyampsocietyamp
(Audienceampclaps)amp
EDampampSoampwhatampisampyourampnextampstepamp
SMampampWellampIampwasampjustampawardedampaampspecialampmedalampofamphonorampfromampPresidentampObamaampamp
(PhotoampofampSamanthaampshakingamphandsampwithamptheampPresidentampflashesamponamptheampscreenampandamptheamp
audienceampclaps)amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 52amp
EDampampCongratulationsamp
SMampampThankampyouampampWhatampanamphonorampampAlongampwithampthisampcommendationampcameampaampgrantampforamp
meamptoampbeampableamptoamptrainampaampgroupampofamphighlyampspecializedampartistlteducatorsampinamptheseamp
practicesampandampsendampthemampoutamptoampcommunitiesampacrossamptheampcountryamptoamphelpampimplementamp
andampsupportampeffortsamptoampputampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampintoampschoolsampwhoampchooseamptoampbeamp
involvedampnationwideamp
(Aampthunderingampofampclappingampinamptheampaudience)amp
EDampampWhatampdoampyouampseeampareamptheamplonglttermampeffectsampofamptheampimplementationampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampamp
SMampampEllenampImampsureampIampdontamphaveamptoamptellampyouampthatampweampliveampinampaampfastltpacedamp
technologicallyltrevolutionaryampworldampampThereampareamppartsampofampthatampthatampareampwonderfulampandamp
makeampourampworldampanampeasierampplaceamptoampliveampampButampthereamphasamptoampbeamproomampforampusamptoampswitchampoffamp
unplugampandampslowampdownampampIampbelieveampthatamptheampplatformampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
unleashesampsomeamppossibilitiesampofamphumanampconnectionampinampaampveryamprealampauthenticampwayampamp
(Audienceamprisesampfromamptheirampseatsampwithamptearsampinamptheirampeyesampasamptheyampgiveampaampstandingamp
ovation)amp
EDampampAampnobleampgoalampindeedampampThankampyouampSamanthaampforampallampthatampyouampdoampampWhatampaampgamelt
changerampampThatsampallamptheamptimeampweamphaveampforamptodayampampItsampbeenampaamptrueamphonorampampGoodampluckampinamp
allampofampyourampendeavorsampampToampthoseampwatchingampatamphomeampgoamplistenamptoampsomeoneampamp
(SamanthaampEllenampandampaudienceampdanceampasamptheampcreditsamproll)amp
(
ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 53amp
loose(ends((References(
AndersonampEampHampampampSpencerampMampHamp(2013)ampAampPhenomenologicalampStudyampCognitiveamp
amp RepresentationsampofampAIDSampInampJampWampCreswellampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-
- Designamp(ppamp327lt346)ampLosampAngelesampSAGEampPublicationsampIncamp
BakerampGampampampMorrisampKamp(2002)ampDecartes-DualismampLondonampRoutledgeamp
BelenkyampMampFampClinchyampBampMampGoldbergerampNampRampampampTaruleampJampMamp(1997)ampWomens-Ways-
- of-Knowing-The-Development-of-Self-Voice-and-MindampNewampYorkampNYamp
amp BasicBooksamp
BleicherampJamp(1980)ampampContemporary-Hermeneutics-Hermeneutics-as-Method-
- Philosophy-and-Critique--LondonampUKampRoutledgeampampampKeeganampPaulamp
BohmampDamp(1996)ampOn-DialogueampLondonampUKampRoutledgeamp
BourgeoisampJampPamp(2007)ampThe-Aesthetic-Hermeneutics-of-Hans(Georg-Gadamer-and-Hans-
- Urs-von-BalthasarampNewampYorkampNYampPeterampLangampPublishingampIncamp
BrunsampGampLamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-Ancient-and-ModernampNewampHavenampCTampYaleamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
CalleampSamp(2011)ampBlindampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CalleampSamp(2005)ampExisquisite-PainampNewampYorkampThamesampampampHudsonamp
CalleampSamp(2008)ampTake-Care-of-YourselfampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CaputoampJamp(2000)ampMore-Radical-HermeneuticsampBloomingtonampINampIndianaampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
CreswellampJampWamp(2013)ampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-DesignampLosampAngelesampSAGEamp
amp PublicationsampIncamp
deampCossonampAamp(2002)ampTheampHermeneuticampDialogueampFindingampPatternsampamidamptheampAporiaamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 54amp
amp ofamptheampArtistResearcherTeacherampAlberta-Journal-of-Educational-Researchamp-
- 48amp(3)amp1lt20amp
ElkinsampJamp(2001)ampWhy-Art-Cannot-Be-TaughtampChicagoampILampUniversityampofampIllinoisampPressamp
FairfieldampPamp(2011)ampDialogueampinamptheampClassroomampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-
- Dialogue-and-Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp77lt90)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GadamerampHltGamp(1996)ampThe-Engima-of-HealthampStanfordampCAampStanfordampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
GadamerampHltGamp(2004)ampTruth-and-Methodamp(Secondamprevisedamped)amp(JampWeinsheimerampampamp
amp DampGampMarshallampTrans)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GallagherampSamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-and-EducationampAlbanyampNYampStateampUniversityampofamp
amp NewampYorkampPressamp
GendlinampEamp(1962)ampExperiencing-and-the-Creation-of-MeaningampNewampYorkampNYampTheamp
amp FreeampPressampofampGlencoeamp
GendlinampEamp(1997)ampampHowampPhilosophyampCannotampAppealamptoampExperienceampandampHowampItampCanamp
amp InampLanguage-beyond-Postmodernism-Saying-and-Thinking-in-Gendlins-
- Philosophy-(ppamp3lt41)ampEvanstonampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
GermeraadampGamp(2013)ampRationalityampIntuitionampandampEmotionampExploringampanampArtisticamp
amp ProcessampJournal-for-Artistic-Researchamp-3
GradleampSampAamp(2011)ampAampuniversityampcourseampinampmindfulampviewingampUnderstandingampartampandamp
amp selfampthroughampcontemplativeampexperienceampInternational-Journal-of-Education-
- Through-Artamp-7amp(2)amp137lt151amp
GreeneampMamp(2013)ampTheampTurningampofamptheampLeavesampExpandingampOurampVisionampforamptheampArtsampinamp
amp EducationampHarvard-Educational-Reviewamp-83amp(1)amp251lt252amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 55amp
GrondinampJamp(2002)ampGadamersampBasicampUnderstandingampofampUnderstandingampInampThe-
- Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp36lt51)ampCambridgeampUKampCambridgeamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
GrondinampJamp(2011)ampGadamersampExperienceampandampTheoryampofampEducationampLearningampthatamp
amp theampOtherampMayampBeampRightampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp5lt20)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
HeelanampPamp(1985)ampampPerceptionampasampaampHermeneuticalampActampampInampDampIhdeampampampHampSilvermanamp
amp (Eds)ampHermeneutics-amp-Deconstruction-(ppamp43lt54)-AlbanyampSUNYampPressamp
HeelanampPampampampSchulkinampJamp(2003)ampHermeneuticalampPhilosophyampandampPragmatismampAamp
amp PhilosophyampofampScienceampInampRampCampScharffampampampVampDusekamp(Eds)ampPhilosophy-of-
- Technology-The-Technological-Condition-an-Anthology-amp(ppamp138lt153)amp
amp MaldenampMAampBlackwellamp
KarpiakampIampEamp(2003)ampTheampListeningampHeartampTuningampInampForampTransformativeampLearningamp
amp 2003-Complexity-Science-and-Educational-Research-Conferenceamp(ppamp67lt80)amp
amp EdmontonampCanadaamp
KellyampMampPost(Partum-DocumentampInstituteampofampContemporaryampArtsampLondonamp
KentampSampJampampampCummingampJampamp(2008)ampampIampdontampknowampEngagingampwithampproblematicamp
amp momentsampinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampRadical-Pedagogy-2-(9)amp1lt20ampampamp
LevinampDampMamp(1989)ampThe-Listening-Self-Personal-Growth-Social-Change-and-the-
- Closure-of-MetaphysicsampNewampYorkampNYampRoutledgeamp
LindsethampAampampampNorbergampAamp(2004)ampAampphenomenologicalamphermeneuticalampmethodampforamp
amp researchingamplivedampexperienceampNordic-College-of-Caring-Sciencesamp-18amp145lt153amp
LipariampLamp(2014)ampampOnampinterlisteningampandamptheampideaampofampdialogueampampTheory-amp-Psychology-24-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 56amp
- (4)amp504lt523amp
MarksampLamp(2002)ampTouch-Sensuous-Theory-and-Multisensory-MediaampMinneapolisamp
amp UniversityampofampMinnesotaampPressamp
MunozampKampLamp(2014)ampTranscribing-Silence-Culture-Relationship-and-Communicationamp
amp WalnutampCreekampCAampLeftampCoastampPressamp
NicholampLamp(1996)ampForewordampInampDampBohmampOn-Dialogueamp(ppampviiltxvii)ampLondonampUKamp
amp Routledgeamp
PalmerampRamp(1969)ampHermeneutics-Interpretation-Theory-in-Schleiermacher-Dilthey-
- Heidegger-and-GadamerampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
PerlampSamp(2004)ampFelt-Sense-Writing-with-the-BodyampPortsmouthampNHampBoyntonCookamp
RicoeurampPamp(19691974)ampThe-Conflicts-of-Interpretations-Essays-in-Hermeneuticsamp
amp (NorthwesternampUniversityampPressampTrans)ampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
RicoeurampPamp(2013)ampHermeneuticsampCambridgeampUKampPolityampPressamp
SableampDamp(2014)ampReasonampinamptheampServiceampofamptheampHeartampTheampImpactsampofampContemplativeamp
amp PracticesamponampCriticalampThinkingampJournal-of-Contemplative-Inquiryamp-1amp(1)amp1lt22amp
SchultzampKamp(2010)ampAfteramptheampBlackbirdampWhistlesampListeningamptoampSilenceampinampClassroomsamp
amp Teachers-College-Recordamp-112amp(11)amp2833lt2849amp
SeebohmampTampamp(2004)ampampHermeneutics-Method-and-MethodologyampDordrechtamptheamp
amp NetherlandsampKluwerampAcademicampPublishersamp
SnowberampCamp(2005)ampTheampmentorampasampartistampaamppoeticampexplorationampofamplisteningampcreatingamp
amp andampmentoringampMentoring-and-Tutoring-13amp(3)amp345lt353amp
vanampManenampMampamp(1984)ampPracticingampPhenomenologicalampWritingampPhenomenology-+-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 57amp
- Pedagogy-2amp(1)amp36lt68amp
vanampManenampMamp(1990)ampampResearching-Lived-Experience-Human-Science-for-an-Action(
- Sensitive-PedagogyampNewampYorkampSUNYampPressamp
VitanovaampGamp(2010)ampampAuthoring-the-Dialogic-SelfampAmsterdamampJohnampBenjaminsamp
amp PublishingampCoamp
WatsonampJamp(2013)ampampKnowingampthroughamptheampfeltltsenseampaampgestureampofampopennessamptoamptheamp
amp otherampampInternational-Journal-of-Childrens-Spirituality-18amp(1)amp118lt130amp
WiercinskiampAamp(2011)ampHermeneuticampEducationamptoampUnderstandingampSelfltEducationampandamp
amp theampWillingnessamptoampRiskampFailureampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp107lt124)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
WorsleyampRamp(2012)ampNarrativesampandamplivelyampmetaphorsampHermeneuticsampasampaampwayampofamp
amp listeningampPerson(Centered-amp-Experiential-Psychotherapiesamp-11amp(4)amp304lt320amp
ZuckertampCampHamp(2002)ampHermeneuticsampinampPracticeampGadameramponampAncientampPhilosophyampInamp
amp RampJampDostalamp(Ed)ampThe-Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp201lt224)amp
amp CambridgeampUKampCambridgeampUniversityampPressamp
amp
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
- WebsitePaper-20
- WebsitePaper-18
- WebsitePaperpdf
-
- MesserFinalPaper-11
- MesserFinalPaper
-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 47amp
thread8(amp
(In)conclusions(amp
amp InamptheampwordsampofampPaulampFairfieldamp(2011)ampthereampisampnoamplastampwordampinampdialogueampnoamp
interpretationampthatampisampuniquelyampandampsupremelyampauthoritativeamp(pamp83)ampampThoughampthisamp
paperampisampendingampthereampisampnoamplastampwordamponamptheampmatterampofamplisteningampforampmeampnorampforamp
studentsampteachersamphumansampworksampofampartamptextsampadampinfinitumampampThisampmyampnotltsolt
conclusiveltconcludingampsectionampstretchesamptheamppossibilityampofampmyampresearchampinampaampmanneramp
thatampdefiesamptheampsupremelyampauthoritativeampstructureampofampanampacademicampresearchamppaperampampamp
amp
Below-is-the-transcript-from-an-episode-dated-April-6-2015-of-the-popular-daytime-
talk-show-Ellen-during-which-the-artistresearcheducator-was-invited-to-discuss-her-
groundbreaking-work-on-listening-
(Camerasamprollampinamp3amp2amp1ampSceneampopensamponamptheampsetampof-EllenampampCameraamppansampinamptoampfocusamp
onampEllenampampSheampisampseatedamponampaamploveseatampwearingampaampcreamltcoloredamppantsuitampwithampaamplightamp
blueampbuttonltupampshirtampampHeramphairampisampperfectlyampcoiffedampampLightsampflashampandamptheampcrowdamp
cheersampampIntroampmusicampswells)-
EllenampDegeneresampampHelloampeveryoneampampWelcomeamptoamptheampshowamptodayampampTheampfirstamponlyampandamp
mostampimportantampguestamponamptodaysampshowampisampSamanthaampMesserampampSamanthaampisampanampartistamp
researcherampandampeducatorampbasedampinampCincinnatiampOhioampwhoseamprecentampresearchampprojectamp
onamplisteningampinampartampeducationamphasamptheamppotentialamptoampchangeamptheampfaceampofampnotamponlyampartamp
educationampbutampalsoamptheampworldampampHereampsheampisampSamanthaampMesseramp
(SamanthaampwalksamponamptheampstageamplookingampsleekampasamphellampwhileampdoingampitampampTheampaudienceamp
cheersampampSamanthaampandampEllenamphugamplikeampoldampfriends)amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 48amp
SamanthaampMesserampampHiampEllenampampItsampsoampgreatamptoampseeampyouampampamp
EDampampNoampSamanthaampitsampgreatamptoampseeampyouampampTellampusampaboutampwhatampbringsampyouamphereamptodayamp
SMampamp(Laughsampfreelyampwithoutampaampcare)ampEllenampyouampareampwhatampbroughtampmeamphereamptoday(
(Audienceamplaughs)amp
EDampampIampappreciateampthatampthankampyouampampButampletsampgetamptoampwhatsamponampAmericasampmindampampYouramp
lifesampworkampampIncredibleampampWhatampexactlyampisampitampandamphowampdidampitampcomeampaboutampampampampamp
SMampampEllenampwhereamptoampbeginampampampTheampideaampinampitsampmostampbasicampformampisampanampartampeducationampbasedamp
aroundamplisteningamppracticesamp
EDampampThatampsoundsampfascinatingampamp
SMampampIampknowampampThankampyouampforampnoticingampitsampsubtleampbrillianceamp
EDampampIampwouldampbeampaampfoolampnotamptoampampTellampusamphowampyouampcameampupampwithampthisampideaamp
SMampampampTheampcentralampcomponentampisampanampideaampcalledampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampwhichampisampaamp
spaceampinampwhichampstudentsampandampparticipantsampmakeampdiscussampandampviewampworksampofampartampwithamp
listeningampatamptheampcenterampofamptheseampactivitiesampandampexperiencesampampThisampideaampcameamptogetheramp
overamptheampcourseampofampmonthsampofampreadingamphundredsampofampdiscussionsampwithamppeersampresearchamp
participantsampandampprofessorsampasampwellampasamptheampwritingampandamprewritingampofampmanyampdraftsampofamp
myampnowampbestltsellingampbookamp
(Audienceampooooooohs)amp
EDampampWowampyouampreallyampputampsomeampthoughtampintoampthisamphuhampampSoamphowampisampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampdifferentampthanampaampregularampclassroomamp
SMampampWellampitampdependsamponamptheampclassroomampampSomeampclassroomsampprobablyampalreadyampareamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampampEssentiallyampitamprequiresampsomethingampofampanampattitudeampshiftampampItamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 49amp
doesntampevenampnecessarilyamphaveamptoampbeampinampaampclassroomamporampanyampspecificampplaceampampItsampmoreampofamp
aampstateampofampmindampandampanampattitudeamp
EDampampCouldampweampbeampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamprightampnowamp
SMampampEllenampnothingampwouldampgiveampmeampmoreamppleasureamp
(Audienceampawwwwws)amp
SMampampButampseriouslyampyesampweampcanampbeampampThoughampitampmightamptakeampmoreampthanampjustampanampattitudeamp
shiftampampWhenampIampinitiallyampbeganampthisampprojectampIampthoughtampthatsampallampitampwouldampbeampampIampassumedamp
thatampifampparticipantsampwereampwillingamptheyampcouldampenterampintoampthisampstateampofampmindampampamp
EDampampButampthatsampnotamptheampcaseamp
SMampampWellampitsampjustampthatampitsampmoreampcomplicatedampthanampthatampampWhatampIampfoundampwereampthatamptheamp
thingsampIampwasampaskingampindividualsamptoampdoampwereampnotampwithinampouramptypicalampculturalampskillampsetampamp
NotamponlyampthisampbutamptheyampareampdifficultampsubtleampandampoftenampinternalamppursuitsampampTheyampareampnotamp
easyamptoampseeampandamptheampresultsampareampnotampinstantaneousampampItsamphardamptoampknowampifampyoureampdoingamp
itamprightamp
EDampSoampwhatampdoesampitampmeanamptoampdoampitamprightamp
SMampampThatsampaampgreatampquestionampEllenampandampthankampyouampforampaskingampitampampIampdontampthinkamptheresamp
justamponeampwayampofampdoingampitamprightampampAndampevenampsometimesampwhenampyoureampdoingampitamprightampitamp
mightampnotampfeelamplikeampanythingampspecialampampItampcouldampjustampfeelamplikeampaampnormalampconversationamp
EDampampSoampthisampisampallampaboutamphavingampaampconversationampampIampdoampthatampfiveampdaysampaampweekamponampthisampsetamp
Samanthaampamp
(Audienceamplaughsamplightheartedly)amp
SMampampEllenampampYoureampcuttingampmeampdeepampamp(laughs)ampYoureamprightampampItsampnotamprevolutionaryampamp
Toamplistenamptoampbeamplistenedamptoamptoampcarryamponampanampopenampandamphonestampconversationampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 50amp
anotheramphumanampTheseampareamphumbleampgoalsampthatampweampcanampcarryampacrossampmanyampcontextsampampIamp
thinkampthereinampliesamptheampbeautyamp
EDampampInterestingampampImampgoingamptoampaskampwhatampImampsureampaamplotampofampteachersamphaveamponamptheiramp
mindsltlthowampdoampweampteachampthisamptoampstudentsamp
SMampampTheampgoalsampandampbeliefsampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmustampbeamplivedampthroughampandamp
undergoneampratherampthanampmerelyampactedampoutamponceamporamptwiceampampItsampaboutampcreatingampaampsystemamp
craftingampassignmentsampandampsettingampaamptoneampthatampallampunderlieamptheseampvaluesampampNotamponlyampthatamp
butamptheampstudentsampandampteachersampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmustampbeampreflectiveamptoamp
theirampexperiencesampampTheseampskillsampneedamptoampbeampbuiltampupampandampaampkeyampcomponentampofampthatampisamp
reflectionamponamppreviousampexperiencesamp
EDampampampIampunderstandampyouampalsoampsolicitedampsurveyampresponsesamptoampdiscussampmomentsampinampwhichamp
individualsampdidamporampdidampnotampfeelamplistenedamptoampasamptheyampspokeampaboutamptheirampartampampCanampyouamptalkamp
aamplittleampbitampaboutampwhatampyouampfoundampinamptheampsurveysamp
SMampampWellampIampcoveredampaamplotampofampthisampinampmyampbookampYoullamphaveamptoampreadampitampampIamphaveampprovidedamp
everyampmemberampofamptheampaudienceamptodayampwithampaampcopyampwhichampyoullampallampfindampunderampyouramp
seatsamp
(AudienceampgoesampwildampwithampexcitementampasamptheyampreachampunderamptheirampseatsampampThereampareamp
intermittentampscreechesampofampjoy)amp
EDampampWowampthankampyouampampTheampgiftampofamplisteningampwhatampaamptreasureampforamptheampaudienceamp
membersamptodayamp
(Audienceampclapsampwholeheartedly)amp
SMampampYoureampwelcomeampampInampgeneralampthoughampwhatampIampfoundampisampaampneedamptoamphandleamptheampwordsamp
andampexperiencesampofampothersampwithampcareampampTheampsurveysampdescribedampsituationsampinampwhichamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 51amp
individualsampfeltamptheyampwereampnotampbeingamplistenedamptoampyetamptheseampmomentsampwereampnotampusuallyamp
profoundlyamporamppurposefullyamphurtfulampampMoreampoftenamptheampsurveysampdescribedampinstancesampinamp
whichamppeopleampfeltampthatampanotheramppersonampwasntamptryingamptoampunderstandampampTheseamp
situationsampwereampmoreamppassiveampandampdismissiveampratherampthanampactivelyamphurtfulampthoughamp
theyampdidampstillamphurtamp
EDampampWellampcouldntampthatampbeampchalkedampupamptoamptheampsensitiveamppersonaampofamptheampartistampampWeampallamp
knowamphowampsensitiveampthoseampartistsampareamp
(Audienceamplaughsamptheyampareampinamponamptheampjoke)amp
SMampamp(chastising)ampEllenampyoureampsmarterampthanampthatampstereotypeampampIampmeanampyouampcouldampsayamp
thatampbutampIampdontampknowampifampthatampwouldampbeampproductiveampampAndampitampwouldntampfitampwithamptheamp
beliefsampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampinampmyampopinionampampDontampweampallampwantamptoampbeamplistenedamp
toampampIsampthatampdesireampexclusiveamptoampsomeampideaampweamphaveampinampourampheadampofampartistsampampIampdontamp
thinkampsoamp
EDampampYoureampsoamprightampSamanthaampampImampsorryampforampgivingampintoampsomeamppervasiveampmodernistamp
nonsenseampaboutampwhatampitampisamptoampbeampanampartistamp
(Audienceampnodsampinampagreement)amp
SMampampItsampokayampEllenampWeampinamptheampartampworldampareampfightingamptheampgoodampfightampWhatampweampdoampisamp
importantampandampwereamptiredampofampbeingampdismissedampbyampsocietyamp
(Audienceampclaps)amp
EDampampSoampwhatampisampyourampnextampstepamp
SMampampWellampIampwasampjustampawardedampaampspecialampmedalampofamphonorampfromampPresidentampObamaampamp
(PhotoampofampSamanthaampshakingamphandsampwithamptheampPresidentampflashesamponamptheampscreenampandamptheamp
audienceampclaps)amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 52amp
EDampampCongratulationsamp
SMampampThankampyouampampWhatampanamphonorampampAlongampwithampthisampcommendationampcameampaampgrantampforamp
meamptoampbeampableamptoamptrainampaampgroupampofamphighlyampspecializedampartistlteducatorsampinamptheseamp
practicesampandampsendampthemampoutamptoampcommunitiesampacrossamptheampcountryamptoamphelpampimplementamp
andampsupportampeffortsamptoampputampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampintoampschoolsampwhoampchooseamptoampbeamp
involvedampnationwideamp
(Aampthunderingampofampclappingampinamptheampaudience)amp
EDampampWhatampdoampyouampseeampareamptheamplonglttermampeffectsampofamptheampimplementationampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampamp
SMampampEllenampImampsureampIampdontamphaveamptoamptellampyouampthatampweampliveampinampaampfastltpacedamp
technologicallyltrevolutionaryampworldampampThereampareamppartsampofampthatampthatampareampwonderfulampandamp
makeampourampworldampanampeasierampplaceamptoampliveampampButampthereamphasamptoampbeamproomampforampusamptoampswitchampoffamp
unplugampandampslowampdownampampIampbelieveampthatamptheampplatformampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
unleashesampsomeamppossibilitiesampofamphumanampconnectionampinampaampveryamprealampauthenticampwayampamp
(Audienceamprisesampfromamptheirampseatsampwithamptearsampinamptheirampeyesampasamptheyampgiveampaampstandingamp
ovation)amp
EDampampAampnobleampgoalampindeedampampThankampyouampSamanthaampforampallampthatampyouampdoampampWhatampaampgamelt
changerampampThatsampallamptheamptimeampweamphaveampforamptodayampampItsampbeenampaamptrueamphonorampampGoodampluckampinamp
allampofampyourampendeavorsampampToampthoseampwatchingampatamphomeampgoamplistenamptoampsomeoneampamp
(SamanthaampEllenampandampaudienceampdanceampasamptheampcreditsamproll)amp
(
ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 53amp
loose(ends((References(
AndersonampEampHampampampSpencerampMampHamp(2013)ampAampPhenomenologicalampStudyampCognitiveamp
amp RepresentationsampofampAIDSampInampJampWampCreswellampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-
- Designamp(ppamp327lt346)ampLosampAngelesampSAGEampPublicationsampIncamp
BakerampGampampampMorrisampKamp(2002)ampDecartes-DualismampLondonampRoutledgeamp
BelenkyampMampFampClinchyampBampMampGoldbergerampNampRampampampTaruleampJampMamp(1997)ampWomens-Ways-
- of-Knowing-The-Development-of-Self-Voice-and-MindampNewampYorkampNYamp
amp BasicBooksamp
BleicherampJamp(1980)ampampContemporary-Hermeneutics-Hermeneutics-as-Method-
- Philosophy-and-Critique--LondonampUKampRoutledgeampampampKeeganampPaulamp
BohmampDamp(1996)ampOn-DialogueampLondonampUKampRoutledgeamp
BourgeoisampJampPamp(2007)ampThe-Aesthetic-Hermeneutics-of-Hans(Georg-Gadamer-and-Hans-
- Urs-von-BalthasarampNewampYorkampNYampPeterampLangampPublishingampIncamp
BrunsampGampLamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-Ancient-and-ModernampNewampHavenampCTampYaleamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
CalleampSamp(2011)ampBlindampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CalleampSamp(2005)ampExisquisite-PainampNewampYorkampThamesampampampHudsonamp
CalleampSamp(2008)ampTake-Care-of-YourselfampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CaputoampJamp(2000)ampMore-Radical-HermeneuticsampBloomingtonampINampIndianaampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
CreswellampJampWamp(2013)ampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-DesignampLosampAngelesampSAGEamp
amp PublicationsampIncamp
deampCossonampAamp(2002)ampTheampHermeneuticampDialogueampFindingampPatternsampamidamptheampAporiaamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 54amp
amp ofamptheampArtistResearcherTeacherampAlberta-Journal-of-Educational-Researchamp-
- 48amp(3)amp1lt20amp
ElkinsampJamp(2001)ampWhy-Art-Cannot-Be-TaughtampChicagoampILampUniversityampofampIllinoisampPressamp
FairfieldampPamp(2011)ampDialogueampinamptheampClassroomampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-
- Dialogue-and-Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp77lt90)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GadamerampHltGamp(1996)ampThe-Engima-of-HealthampStanfordampCAampStanfordampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
GadamerampHltGamp(2004)ampTruth-and-Methodamp(Secondamprevisedamped)amp(JampWeinsheimerampampamp
amp DampGampMarshallampTrans)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GallagherampSamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-and-EducationampAlbanyampNYampStateampUniversityampofamp
amp NewampYorkampPressamp
GendlinampEamp(1962)ampExperiencing-and-the-Creation-of-MeaningampNewampYorkampNYampTheamp
amp FreeampPressampofampGlencoeamp
GendlinampEamp(1997)ampampHowampPhilosophyampCannotampAppealamptoampExperienceampandampHowampItampCanamp
amp InampLanguage-beyond-Postmodernism-Saying-and-Thinking-in-Gendlins-
- Philosophy-(ppamp3lt41)ampEvanstonampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
GermeraadampGamp(2013)ampRationalityampIntuitionampandampEmotionampExploringampanampArtisticamp
amp ProcessampJournal-for-Artistic-Researchamp-3
GradleampSampAamp(2011)ampAampuniversityampcourseampinampmindfulampviewingampUnderstandingampartampandamp
amp selfampthroughampcontemplativeampexperienceampInternational-Journal-of-Education-
- Through-Artamp-7amp(2)amp137lt151amp
GreeneampMamp(2013)ampTheampTurningampofamptheampLeavesampExpandingampOurampVisionampforamptheampArtsampinamp
amp EducationampHarvard-Educational-Reviewamp-83amp(1)amp251lt252amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 55amp
GrondinampJamp(2002)ampGadamersampBasicampUnderstandingampofampUnderstandingampInampThe-
- Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp36lt51)ampCambridgeampUKampCambridgeamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
GrondinampJamp(2011)ampGadamersampExperienceampandampTheoryampofampEducationampLearningampthatamp
amp theampOtherampMayampBeampRightampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp5lt20)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
HeelanampPamp(1985)ampampPerceptionampasampaampHermeneuticalampActampampInampDampIhdeampampampHampSilvermanamp
amp (Eds)ampHermeneutics-amp-Deconstruction-(ppamp43lt54)-AlbanyampSUNYampPressamp
HeelanampPampampampSchulkinampJamp(2003)ampHermeneuticalampPhilosophyampandampPragmatismampAamp
amp PhilosophyampofampScienceampInampRampCampScharffampampampVampDusekamp(Eds)ampPhilosophy-of-
- Technology-The-Technological-Condition-an-Anthology-amp(ppamp138lt153)amp
amp MaldenampMAampBlackwellamp
KarpiakampIampEamp(2003)ampTheampListeningampHeartampTuningampInampForampTransformativeampLearningamp
amp 2003-Complexity-Science-and-Educational-Research-Conferenceamp(ppamp67lt80)amp
amp EdmontonampCanadaamp
KellyampMampPost(Partum-DocumentampInstituteampofampContemporaryampArtsampLondonamp
KentampSampJampampampCummingampJampamp(2008)ampampIampdontampknowampEngagingampwithampproblematicamp
amp momentsampinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampRadical-Pedagogy-2-(9)amp1lt20ampampamp
LevinampDampMamp(1989)ampThe-Listening-Self-Personal-Growth-Social-Change-and-the-
- Closure-of-MetaphysicsampNewampYorkampNYampRoutledgeamp
LindsethampAampampampNorbergampAamp(2004)ampAampphenomenologicalamphermeneuticalampmethodampforamp
amp researchingamplivedampexperienceampNordic-College-of-Caring-Sciencesamp-18amp145lt153amp
LipariampLamp(2014)ampampOnampinterlisteningampandamptheampideaampofampdialogueampampTheory-amp-Psychology-24-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 56amp
- (4)amp504lt523amp
MarksampLamp(2002)ampTouch-Sensuous-Theory-and-Multisensory-MediaampMinneapolisamp
amp UniversityampofampMinnesotaampPressamp
MunozampKampLamp(2014)ampTranscribing-Silence-Culture-Relationship-and-Communicationamp
amp WalnutampCreekampCAampLeftampCoastampPressamp
NicholampLamp(1996)ampForewordampInampDampBohmampOn-Dialogueamp(ppampviiltxvii)ampLondonampUKamp
amp Routledgeamp
PalmerampRamp(1969)ampHermeneutics-Interpretation-Theory-in-Schleiermacher-Dilthey-
- Heidegger-and-GadamerampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
PerlampSamp(2004)ampFelt-Sense-Writing-with-the-BodyampPortsmouthampNHampBoyntonCookamp
RicoeurampPamp(19691974)ampThe-Conflicts-of-Interpretations-Essays-in-Hermeneuticsamp
amp (NorthwesternampUniversityampPressampTrans)ampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
RicoeurampPamp(2013)ampHermeneuticsampCambridgeampUKampPolityampPressamp
SableampDamp(2014)ampReasonampinamptheampServiceampofamptheampHeartampTheampImpactsampofampContemplativeamp
amp PracticesamponampCriticalampThinkingampJournal-of-Contemplative-Inquiryamp-1amp(1)amp1lt22amp
SchultzampKamp(2010)ampAfteramptheampBlackbirdampWhistlesampListeningamptoampSilenceampinampClassroomsamp
amp Teachers-College-Recordamp-112amp(11)amp2833lt2849amp
SeebohmampTampamp(2004)ampampHermeneutics-Method-and-MethodologyampDordrechtamptheamp
amp NetherlandsampKluwerampAcademicampPublishersamp
SnowberampCamp(2005)ampTheampmentorampasampartistampaamppoeticampexplorationampofamplisteningampcreatingamp
amp andampmentoringampMentoring-and-Tutoring-13amp(3)amp345lt353amp
vanampManenampMampamp(1984)ampPracticingampPhenomenologicalampWritingampPhenomenology-+-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 57amp
- Pedagogy-2amp(1)amp36lt68amp
vanampManenampMamp(1990)ampampResearching-Lived-Experience-Human-Science-for-an-Action(
- Sensitive-PedagogyampNewampYorkampSUNYampPressamp
VitanovaampGamp(2010)ampampAuthoring-the-Dialogic-SelfampAmsterdamampJohnampBenjaminsamp
amp PublishingampCoamp
WatsonampJamp(2013)ampampKnowingampthroughamptheampfeltltsenseampaampgestureampofampopennessamptoamptheamp
amp otherampampInternational-Journal-of-Childrens-Spirituality-18amp(1)amp118lt130amp
WiercinskiampAamp(2011)ampHermeneuticampEducationamptoampUnderstandingampSelfltEducationampandamp
amp theampWillingnessamptoampRiskampFailureampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp107lt124)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
WorsleyampRamp(2012)ampNarrativesampandamplivelyampmetaphorsampHermeneuticsampasampaampwayampofamp
amp listeningampPerson(Centered-amp-Experiential-Psychotherapiesamp-11amp(4)amp304lt320amp
ZuckertampCampHamp(2002)ampHermeneuticsampinampPracticeampGadameramponampAncientampPhilosophyampInamp
amp RampJampDostalamp(Ed)ampThe-Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp201lt224)amp
amp CambridgeampUKampCambridgeampUniversityampPressamp
amp
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
- WebsitePaper-20
- WebsitePaper-18
- WebsitePaperpdf
-
- MesserFinalPaper-11
- MesserFinalPaper
-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 48amp
SamanthaampMesserampampHiampEllenampampItsampsoampgreatamptoampseeampyouampampamp
EDampampNoampSamanthaampitsampgreatamptoampseeampyouampampTellampusampaboutampwhatampbringsampyouamphereamptodayamp
SMampamp(Laughsampfreelyampwithoutampaampcare)ampEllenampyouampareampwhatampbroughtampmeamphereamptoday(
(Audienceamplaughs)amp
EDampampIampappreciateampthatampthankampyouampampButampletsampgetamptoampwhatsamponampAmericasampmindampampYouramp
lifesampworkampampIncredibleampampWhatampexactlyampisampitampandamphowampdidampitampcomeampaboutampampampampamp
SMampampEllenampwhereamptoampbeginampampampTheampideaampinampitsampmostampbasicampformampisampanampartampeducationampbasedamp
aroundamplisteningamppracticesamp
EDampampThatampsoundsampfascinatingampamp
SMampampIampknowampampThankampyouampforampnoticingampitsampsubtleampbrillianceamp
EDampampIampwouldampbeampaampfoolampnotamptoampampTellampusamphowampyouampcameampupampwithampthisampideaamp
SMampampampTheampcentralampcomponentampisampanampideaampcalledampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampwhichampisampaamp
spaceampinampwhichampstudentsampandampparticipantsampmakeampdiscussampandampviewampworksampofampartampwithamp
listeningampatamptheampcenterampofamptheseampactivitiesampandampexperiencesampampThisampideaampcameamptogetheramp
overamptheampcourseampofampmonthsampofampreadingamphundredsampofampdiscussionsampwithamppeersampresearchamp
participantsampandampprofessorsampasampwellampasamptheampwritingampandamprewritingampofampmanyampdraftsampofamp
myampnowampbestltsellingampbookamp
(Audienceampooooooohs)amp
EDampampWowampyouampreallyampputampsomeampthoughtampintoampthisamphuhampampSoamphowampisampaampcreativeltlisteningamp
spaceampdifferentampthanampaampregularampclassroomamp
SMampampWellampitampdependsamponamptheampclassroomampampSomeampclassroomsampprobablyampalreadyampareamp
creativeltlisteningampspacesampampEssentiallyampitamprequiresampsomethingampofampanampattitudeampshiftampampItamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 49amp
doesntampevenampnecessarilyamphaveamptoampbeampinampaampclassroomamporampanyampspecificampplaceampampItsampmoreampofamp
aampstateampofampmindampandampanampattitudeamp
EDampampCouldampweampbeampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamprightampnowamp
SMampampEllenampnothingampwouldampgiveampmeampmoreamppleasureamp
(Audienceampawwwwws)amp
SMampampButampseriouslyampyesampweampcanampbeampampThoughampitampmightamptakeampmoreampthanampjustampanampattitudeamp
shiftampampWhenampIampinitiallyampbeganampthisampprojectampIampthoughtampthatsampallampitampwouldampbeampampIampassumedamp
thatampifampparticipantsampwereampwillingamptheyampcouldampenterampintoampthisampstateampofampmindampampamp
EDampampButampthatsampnotamptheampcaseamp
SMampampWellampitsampjustampthatampitsampmoreampcomplicatedampthanampthatampampWhatampIampfoundampwereampthatamptheamp
thingsampIampwasampaskingampindividualsamptoampdoampwereampnotampwithinampouramptypicalampculturalampskillampsetampamp
NotamponlyampthisampbutamptheyampareampdifficultampsubtleampandampoftenampinternalamppursuitsampampTheyampareampnotamp
easyamptoampseeampandamptheampresultsampareampnotampinstantaneousampampItsamphardamptoampknowampifampyoureampdoingamp
itamprightamp
EDampSoampwhatampdoesampitampmeanamptoampdoampitamprightamp
SMampampThatsampaampgreatampquestionampEllenampandampthankampyouampforampaskingampitampampIampdontampthinkamptheresamp
justamponeampwayampofampdoingampitamprightampampAndampevenampsometimesampwhenampyoureampdoingampitamprightampitamp
mightampnotampfeelamplikeampanythingampspecialampampItampcouldampjustampfeelamplikeampaampnormalampconversationamp
EDampampSoampthisampisampallampaboutamphavingampaampconversationampampIampdoampthatampfiveampdaysampaampweekamponampthisampsetamp
Samanthaampamp
(Audienceamplaughsamplightheartedly)amp
SMampampEllenampampYoureampcuttingampmeampdeepampamp(laughs)ampYoureamprightampampItsampnotamprevolutionaryampamp
Toamplistenamptoampbeamplistenedamptoamptoampcarryamponampanampopenampandamphonestampconversationampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 50amp
anotheramphumanampTheseampareamphumbleampgoalsampthatampweampcanampcarryampacrossampmanyampcontextsampampIamp
thinkampthereinampliesamptheampbeautyamp
EDampampInterestingampampImampgoingamptoampaskampwhatampImampsureampaamplotampofampteachersamphaveamponamptheiramp
mindsltlthowampdoampweampteachampthisamptoampstudentsamp
SMampampTheampgoalsampandampbeliefsampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmustampbeamplivedampthroughampandamp
undergoneampratherampthanampmerelyampactedampoutamponceamporamptwiceampampItsampaboutampcreatingampaampsystemamp
craftingampassignmentsampandampsettingampaamptoneampthatampallampunderlieamptheseampvaluesampampNotamponlyampthatamp
butamptheampstudentsampandampteachersampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmustampbeampreflectiveamptoamp
theirampexperiencesampampTheseampskillsampneedamptoampbeampbuiltampupampandampaampkeyampcomponentampofampthatampisamp
reflectionamponamppreviousampexperiencesamp
EDampampampIampunderstandampyouampalsoampsolicitedampsurveyampresponsesamptoampdiscussampmomentsampinampwhichamp
individualsampdidamporampdidampnotampfeelamplistenedamptoampasamptheyampspokeampaboutamptheirampartampampCanampyouamptalkamp
aamplittleampbitampaboutampwhatampyouampfoundampinamptheampsurveysamp
SMampampWellampIampcoveredampaamplotampofampthisampinampmyampbookampYoullamphaveamptoampreadampitampampIamphaveampprovidedamp
everyampmemberampofamptheampaudienceamptodayampwithampaampcopyampwhichampyoullampallampfindampunderampyouramp
seatsamp
(AudienceampgoesampwildampwithampexcitementampasamptheyampreachampunderamptheirampseatsampampThereampareamp
intermittentampscreechesampofampjoy)amp
EDampampWowampthankampyouampampTheampgiftampofamplisteningampwhatampaamptreasureampforamptheampaudienceamp
membersamptodayamp
(Audienceampclapsampwholeheartedly)amp
SMampampYoureampwelcomeampampInampgeneralampthoughampwhatampIampfoundampisampaampneedamptoamphandleamptheampwordsamp
andampexperiencesampofampothersampwithampcareampampTheampsurveysampdescribedampsituationsampinampwhichamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 51amp
individualsampfeltamptheyampwereampnotampbeingamplistenedamptoampyetamptheseampmomentsampwereampnotampusuallyamp
profoundlyamporamppurposefullyamphurtfulampampMoreampoftenamptheampsurveysampdescribedampinstancesampinamp
whichamppeopleampfeltampthatampanotheramppersonampwasntamptryingamptoampunderstandampampTheseamp
situationsampwereampmoreamppassiveampandampdismissiveampratherampthanampactivelyamphurtfulampthoughamp
theyampdidampstillamphurtamp
EDampampWellampcouldntampthatampbeampchalkedampupamptoamptheampsensitiveamppersonaampofamptheampartistampampWeampallamp
knowamphowampsensitiveampthoseampartistsampareamp
(Audienceamplaughsamptheyampareampinamponamptheampjoke)amp
SMampamp(chastising)ampEllenampyoureampsmarterampthanampthatampstereotypeampampIampmeanampyouampcouldampsayamp
thatampbutampIampdontampknowampifampthatampwouldampbeampproductiveampampAndampitampwouldntampfitampwithamptheamp
beliefsampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampinampmyampopinionampampDontampweampallampwantamptoampbeamplistenedamp
toampampIsampthatampdesireampexclusiveamptoampsomeampideaampweamphaveampinampourampheadampofampartistsampampIampdontamp
thinkampsoamp
EDampampYoureampsoamprightampSamanthaampampImampsorryampforampgivingampintoampsomeamppervasiveampmodernistamp
nonsenseampaboutampwhatampitampisamptoampbeampanampartistamp
(Audienceampnodsampinampagreement)amp
SMampampItsampokayampEllenampWeampinamptheampartampworldampareampfightingamptheampgoodampfightampWhatampweampdoampisamp
importantampandampwereamptiredampofampbeingampdismissedampbyampsocietyamp
(Audienceampclaps)amp
EDampampSoampwhatampisampyourampnextampstepamp
SMampampWellampIampwasampjustampawardedampaampspecialampmedalampofamphonorampfromampPresidentampObamaampamp
(PhotoampofampSamanthaampshakingamphandsampwithamptheampPresidentampflashesamponamptheampscreenampandamptheamp
audienceampclaps)amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 52amp
EDampampCongratulationsamp
SMampampThankampyouampampWhatampanamphonorampampAlongampwithampthisampcommendationampcameampaampgrantampforamp
meamptoampbeampableamptoamptrainampaampgroupampofamphighlyampspecializedampartistlteducatorsampinamptheseamp
practicesampandampsendampthemampoutamptoampcommunitiesampacrossamptheampcountryamptoamphelpampimplementamp
andampsupportampeffortsamptoampputampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampintoampschoolsampwhoampchooseamptoampbeamp
involvedampnationwideamp
(Aampthunderingampofampclappingampinamptheampaudience)amp
EDampampWhatampdoampyouampseeampareamptheamplonglttermampeffectsampofamptheampimplementationampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampamp
SMampampEllenampImampsureampIampdontamphaveamptoamptellampyouampthatampweampliveampinampaampfastltpacedamp
technologicallyltrevolutionaryampworldampampThereampareamppartsampofampthatampthatampareampwonderfulampandamp
makeampourampworldampanampeasierampplaceamptoampliveampampButampthereamphasamptoampbeamproomampforampusamptoampswitchampoffamp
unplugampandampslowampdownampampIampbelieveampthatamptheampplatformampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
unleashesampsomeamppossibilitiesampofamphumanampconnectionampinampaampveryamprealampauthenticampwayampamp
(Audienceamprisesampfromamptheirampseatsampwithamptearsampinamptheirampeyesampasamptheyampgiveampaampstandingamp
ovation)amp
EDampampAampnobleampgoalampindeedampampThankampyouampSamanthaampforampallampthatampyouampdoampampWhatampaampgamelt
changerampampThatsampallamptheamptimeampweamphaveampforamptodayampampItsampbeenampaamptrueamphonorampampGoodampluckampinamp
allampofampyourampendeavorsampampToampthoseampwatchingampatamphomeampgoamplistenamptoampsomeoneampamp
(SamanthaampEllenampandampaudienceampdanceampasamptheampcreditsamproll)amp
(
ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 53amp
loose(ends((References(
AndersonampEampHampampampSpencerampMampHamp(2013)ampAampPhenomenologicalampStudyampCognitiveamp
amp RepresentationsampofampAIDSampInampJampWampCreswellampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-
- Designamp(ppamp327lt346)ampLosampAngelesampSAGEampPublicationsampIncamp
BakerampGampampampMorrisampKamp(2002)ampDecartes-DualismampLondonampRoutledgeamp
BelenkyampMampFampClinchyampBampMampGoldbergerampNampRampampampTaruleampJampMamp(1997)ampWomens-Ways-
- of-Knowing-The-Development-of-Self-Voice-and-MindampNewampYorkampNYamp
amp BasicBooksamp
BleicherampJamp(1980)ampampContemporary-Hermeneutics-Hermeneutics-as-Method-
- Philosophy-and-Critique--LondonampUKampRoutledgeampampampKeeganampPaulamp
BohmampDamp(1996)ampOn-DialogueampLondonampUKampRoutledgeamp
BourgeoisampJampPamp(2007)ampThe-Aesthetic-Hermeneutics-of-Hans(Georg-Gadamer-and-Hans-
- Urs-von-BalthasarampNewampYorkampNYampPeterampLangampPublishingampIncamp
BrunsampGampLamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-Ancient-and-ModernampNewampHavenampCTampYaleamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
CalleampSamp(2011)ampBlindampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CalleampSamp(2005)ampExisquisite-PainampNewampYorkampThamesampampampHudsonamp
CalleampSamp(2008)ampTake-Care-of-YourselfampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CaputoampJamp(2000)ampMore-Radical-HermeneuticsampBloomingtonampINampIndianaampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
CreswellampJampWamp(2013)ampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-DesignampLosampAngelesampSAGEamp
amp PublicationsampIncamp
deampCossonampAamp(2002)ampTheampHermeneuticampDialogueampFindingampPatternsampamidamptheampAporiaamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 54amp
amp ofamptheampArtistResearcherTeacherampAlberta-Journal-of-Educational-Researchamp-
- 48amp(3)amp1lt20amp
ElkinsampJamp(2001)ampWhy-Art-Cannot-Be-TaughtampChicagoampILampUniversityampofampIllinoisampPressamp
FairfieldampPamp(2011)ampDialogueampinamptheampClassroomampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-
- Dialogue-and-Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp77lt90)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GadamerampHltGamp(1996)ampThe-Engima-of-HealthampStanfordampCAampStanfordampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
GadamerampHltGamp(2004)ampTruth-and-Methodamp(Secondamprevisedamped)amp(JampWeinsheimerampampamp
amp DampGampMarshallampTrans)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GallagherampSamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-and-EducationampAlbanyampNYampStateampUniversityampofamp
amp NewampYorkampPressamp
GendlinampEamp(1962)ampExperiencing-and-the-Creation-of-MeaningampNewampYorkampNYampTheamp
amp FreeampPressampofampGlencoeamp
GendlinampEamp(1997)ampampHowampPhilosophyampCannotampAppealamptoampExperienceampandampHowampItampCanamp
amp InampLanguage-beyond-Postmodernism-Saying-and-Thinking-in-Gendlins-
- Philosophy-(ppamp3lt41)ampEvanstonampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
GermeraadampGamp(2013)ampRationalityampIntuitionampandampEmotionampExploringampanampArtisticamp
amp ProcessampJournal-for-Artistic-Researchamp-3
GradleampSampAamp(2011)ampAampuniversityampcourseampinampmindfulampviewingampUnderstandingampartampandamp
amp selfampthroughampcontemplativeampexperienceampInternational-Journal-of-Education-
- Through-Artamp-7amp(2)amp137lt151amp
GreeneampMamp(2013)ampTheampTurningampofamptheampLeavesampExpandingampOurampVisionampforamptheampArtsampinamp
amp EducationampHarvard-Educational-Reviewamp-83amp(1)amp251lt252amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 55amp
GrondinampJamp(2002)ampGadamersampBasicampUnderstandingampofampUnderstandingampInampThe-
- Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp36lt51)ampCambridgeampUKampCambridgeamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
GrondinampJamp(2011)ampGadamersampExperienceampandampTheoryampofampEducationampLearningampthatamp
amp theampOtherampMayampBeampRightampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp5lt20)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
HeelanampPamp(1985)ampampPerceptionampasampaampHermeneuticalampActampampInampDampIhdeampampampHampSilvermanamp
amp (Eds)ampHermeneutics-amp-Deconstruction-(ppamp43lt54)-AlbanyampSUNYampPressamp
HeelanampPampampampSchulkinampJamp(2003)ampHermeneuticalampPhilosophyampandampPragmatismampAamp
amp PhilosophyampofampScienceampInampRampCampScharffampampampVampDusekamp(Eds)ampPhilosophy-of-
- Technology-The-Technological-Condition-an-Anthology-amp(ppamp138lt153)amp
amp MaldenampMAampBlackwellamp
KarpiakampIampEamp(2003)ampTheampListeningampHeartampTuningampInampForampTransformativeampLearningamp
amp 2003-Complexity-Science-and-Educational-Research-Conferenceamp(ppamp67lt80)amp
amp EdmontonampCanadaamp
KellyampMampPost(Partum-DocumentampInstituteampofampContemporaryampArtsampLondonamp
KentampSampJampampampCummingampJampamp(2008)ampampIampdontampknowampEngagingampwithampproblematicamp
amp momentsampinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampRadical-Pedagogy-2-(9)amp1lt20ampampamp
LevinampDampMamp(1989)ampThe-Listening-Self-Personal-Growth-Social-Change-and-the-
- Closure-of-MetaphysicsampNewampYorkampNYampRoutledgeamp
LindsethampAampampampNorbergampAamp(2004)ampAampphenomenologicalamphermeneuticalampmethodampforamp
amp researchingamplivedampexperienceampNordic-College-of-Caring-Sciencesamp-18amp145lt153amp
LipariampLamp(2014)ampampOnampinterlisteningampandamptheampideaampofampdialogueampampTheory-amp-Psychology-24-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 56amp
- (4)amp504lt523amp
MarksampLamp(2002)ampTouch-Sensuous-Theory-and-Multisensory-MediaampMinneapolisamp
amp UniversityampofampMinnesotaampPressamp
MunozampKampLamp(2014)ampTranscribing-Silence-Culture-Relationship-and-Communicationamp
amp WalnutampCreekampCAampLeftampCoastampPressamp
NicholampLamp(1996)ampForewordampInampDampBohmampOn-Dialogueamp(ppampviiltxvii)ampLondonampUKamp
amp Routledgeamp
PalmerampRamp(1969)ampHermeneutics-Interpretation-Theory-in-Schleiermacher-Dilthey-
- Heidegger-and-GadamerampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
PerlampSamp(2004)ampFelt-Sense-Writing-with-the-BodyampPortsmouthampNHampBoyntonCookamp
RicoeurampPamp(19691974)ampThe-Conflicts-of-Interpretations-Essays-in-Hermeneuticsamp
amp (NorthwesternampUniversityampPressampTrans)ampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
RicoeurampPamp(2013)ampHermeneuticsampCambridgeampUKampPolityampPressamp
SableampDamp(2014)ampReasonampinamptheampServiceampofamptheampHeartampTheampImpactsampofampContemplativeamp
amp PracticesamponampCriticalampThinkingampJournal-of-Contemplative-Inquiryamp-1amp(1)amp1lt22amp
SchultzampKamp(2010)ampAfteramptheampBlackbirdampWhistlesampListeningamptoampSilenceampinampClassroomsamp
amp Teachers-College-Recordamp-112amp(11)amp2833lt2849amp
SeebohmampTampamp(2004)ampampHermeneutics-Method-and-MethodologyampDordrechtamptheamp
amp NetherlandsampKluwerampAcademicampPublishersamp
SnowberampCamp(2005)ampTheampmentorampasampartistampaamppoeticampexplorationampofamplisteningampcreatingamp
amp andampmentoringampMentoring-and-Tutoring-13amp(3)amp345lt353amp
vanampManenampMampamp(1984)ampPracticingampPhenomenologicalampWritingampPhenomenology-+-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 57amp
- Pedagogy-2amp(1)amp36lt68amp
vanampManenampMamp(1990)ampampResearching-Lived-Experience-Human-Science-for-an-Action(
- Sensitive-PedagogyampNewampYorkampSUNYampPressamp
VitanovaampGamp(2010)ampampAuthoring-the-Dialogic-SelfampAmsterdamampJohnampBenjaminsamp
amp PublishingampCoamp
WatsonampJamp(2013)ampampKnowingampthroughamptheampfeltltsenseampaampgestureampofampopennessamptoamptheamp
amp otherampampInternational-Journal-of-Childrens-Spirituality-18amp(1)amp118lt130amp
WiercinskiampAamp(2011)ampHermeneuticampEducationamptoampUnderstandingampSelfltEducationampandamp
amp theampWillingnessamptoampRiskampFailureampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp107lt124)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
WorsleyampRamp(2012)ampNarrativesampandamplivelyampmetaphorsampHermeneuticsampasampaampwayampofamp
amp listeningampPerson(Centered-amp-Experiential-Psychotherapiesamp-11amp(4)amp304lt320amp
ZuckertampCampHamp(2002)ampHermeneuticsampinampPracticeampGadameramponampAncientampPhilosophyampInamp
amp RampJampDostalamp(Ed)ampThe-Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp201lt224)amp
amp CambridgeampUKampCambridgeampUniversityampPressamp
amp
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
- WebsitePaper-20
- WebsitePaper-18
- WebsitePaperpdf
-
- MesserFinalPaper-11
- MesserFinalPaper
-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 49amp
doesntampevenampnecessarilyamphaveamptoampbeampinampaampclassroomamporampanyampspecificampplaceampampItsampmoreampofamp
aampstateampofampmindampandampanampattitudeamp
EDampampCouldampweampbeampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamprightampnowamp
SMampampEllenampnothingampwouldampgiveampmeampmoreamppleasureamp
(Audienceampawwwwws)amp
SMampampButampseriouslyampyesampweampcanampbeampampThoughampitampmightamptakeampmoreampthanampjustampanampattitudeamp
shiftampampWhenampIampinitiallyampbeganampthisampprojectampIampthoughtampthatsampallampitampwouldampbeampampIampassumedamp
thatampifampparticipantsampwereampwillingamptheyampcouldampenterampintoampthisampstateampofampmindampampamp
EDampampButampthatsampnotamptheampcaseamp
SMampampWellampitsampjustampthatampitsampmoreampcomplicatedampthanampthatampampWhatampIampfoundampwereampthatamptheamp
thingsampIampwasampaskingampindividualsamptoampdoampwereampnotampwithinampouramptypicalampculturalampskillampsetampamp
NotamponlyampthisampbutamptheyampareampdifficultampsubtleampandampoftenampinternalamppursuitsampampTheyampareampnotamp
easyamptoampseeampandamptheampresultsampareampnotampinstantaneousampampItsamphardamptoampknowampifampyoureampdoingamp
itamprightamp
EDampSoampwhatampdoesampitampmeanamptoampdoampitamprightamp
SMampampThatsampaampgreatampquestionampEllenampandampthankampyouampforampaskingampitampampIampdontampthinkamptheresamp
justamponeampwayampofampdoingampitamprightampampAndampevenampsometimesampwhenampyoureampdoingampitamprightampitamp
mightampnotampfeelamplikeampanythingampspecialampampItampcouldampjustampfeelamplikeampaampnormalampconversationamp
EDampampSoampthisampisampallampaboutamphavingampaampconversationampampIampdoampthatampfiveampdaysampaampweekamponampthisampsetamp
Samanthaampamp
(Audienceamplaughsamplightheartedly)amp
SMampampEllenampampYoureampcuttingampmeampdeepampamp(laughs)ampYoureamprightampampItsampnotamprevolutionaryampamp
Toamplistenamptoampbeamplistenedamptoamptoampcarryamponampanampopenampandamphonestampconversationampwithamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 50amp
anotheramphumanampTheseampareamphumbleampgoalsampthatampweampcanampcarryampacrossampmanyampcontextsampampIamp
thinkampthereinampliesamptheampbeautyamp
EDampampInterestingampampImampgoingamptoampaskampwhatampImampsureampaamplotampofampteachersamphaveamponamptheiramp
mindsltlthowampdoampweampteachampthisamptoampstudentsamp
SMampampTheampgoalsampandampbeliefsampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmustampbeamplivedampthroughampandamp
undergoneampratherampthanampmerelyampactedampoutamponceamporamptwiceampampItsampaboutampcreatingampaampsystemamp
craftingampassignmentsampandampsettingampaamptoneampthatampallampunderlieamptheseampvaluesampampNotamponlyampthatamp
butamptheampstudentsampandampteachersampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmustampbeampreflectiveamptoamp
theirampexperiencesampampTheseampskillsampneedamptoampbeampbuiltampupampandampaampkeyampcomponentampofampthatampisamp
reflectionamponamppreviousampexperiencesamp
EDampampampIampunderstandampyouampalsoampsolicitedampsurveyampresponsesamptoampdiscussampmomentsampinampwhichamp
individualsampdidamporampdidampnotampfeelamplistenedamptoampasamptheyampspokeampaboutamptheirampartampampCanampyouamptalkamp
aamplittleampbitampaboutampwhatampyouampfoundampinamptheampsurveysamp
SMampampWellampIampcoveredampaamplotampofampthisampinampmyampbookampYoullamphaveamptoampreadampitampampIamphaveampprovidedamp
everyampmemberampofamptheampaudienceamptodayampwithampaampcopyampwhichampyoullampallampfindampunderampyouramp
seatsamp
(AudienceampgoesampwildampwithampexcitementampasamptheyampreachampunderamptheirampseatsampampThereampareamp
intermittentampscreechesampofampjoy)amp
EDampampWowampthankampyouampampTheampgiftampofamplisteningampwhatampaamptreasureampforamptheampaudienceamp
membersamptodayamp
(Audienceampclapsampwholeheartedly)amp
SMampampYoureampwelcomeampampInampgeneralampthoughampwhatampIampfoundampisampaampneedamptoamphandleamptheampwordsamp
andampexperiencesampofampothersampwithampcareampampTheampsurveysampdescribedampsituationsampinampwhichamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 51amp
individualsampfeltamptheyampwereampnotampbeingamplistenedamptoampyetamptheseampmomentsampwereampnotampusuallyamp
profoundlyamporamppurposefullyamphurtfulampampMoreampoftenamptheampsurveysampdescribedampinstancesampinamp
whichamppeopleampfeltampthatampanotheramppersonampwasntamptryingamptoampunderstandampampTheseamp
situationsampwereampmoreamppassiveampandampdismissiveampratherampthanampactivelyamphurtfulampthoughamp
theyampdidampstillamphurtamp
EDampampWellampcouldntampthatampbeampchalkedampupamptoamptheampsensitiveamppersonaampofamptheampartistampampWeampallamp
knowamphowampsensitiveampthoseampartistsampareamp
(Audienceamplaughsamptheyampareampinamponamptheampjoke)amp
SMampamp(chastising)ampEllenampyoureampsmarterampthanampthatampstereotypeampampIampmeanampyouampcouldampsayamp
thatampbutampIampdontampknowampifampthatampwouldampbeampproductiveampampAndampitampwouldntampfitampwithamptheamp
beliefsampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampinampmyampopinionampampDontampweampallampwantamptoampbeamplistenedamp
toampampIsampthatampdesireampexclusiveamptoampsomeampideaampweamphaveampinampourampheadampofampartistsampampIampdontamp
thinkampsoamp
EDampampYoureampsoamprightampSamanthaampampImampsorryampforampgivingampintoampsomeamppervasiveampmodernistamp
nonsenseampaboutampwhatampitampisamptoampbeampanampartistamp
(Audienceampnodsampinampagreement)amp
SMampampItsampokayampEllenampWeampinamptheampartampworldampareampfightingamptheampgoodampfightampWhatampweampdoampisamp
importantampandampwereamptiredampofampbeingampdismissedampbyampsocietyamp
(Audienceampclaps)amp
EDampampSoampwhatampisampyourampnextampstepamp
SMampampWellampIampwasampjustampawardedampaampspecialampmedalampofamphonorampfromampPresidentampObamaampamp
(PhotoampofampSamanthaampshakingamphandsampwithamptheampPresidentampflashesamponamptheampscreenampandamptheamp
audienceampclaps)amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 52amp
EDampampCongratulationsamp
SMampampThankampyouampampWhatampanamphonorampampAlongampwithampthisampcommendationampcameampaampgrantampforamp
meamptoampbeampableamptoamptrainampaampgroupampofamphighlyampspecializedampartistlteducatorsampinamptheseamp
practicesampandampsendampthemampoutamptoampcommunitiesampacrossamptheampcountryamptoamphelpampimplementamp
andampsupportampeffortsamptoampputampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampintoampschoolsampwhoampchooseamptoampbeamp
involvedampnationwideamp
(Aampthunderingampofampclappingampinamptheampaudience)amp
EDampampWhatampdoampyouampseeampareamptheamplonglttermampeffectsampofamptheampimplementationampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampamp
SMampampEllenampImampsureampIampdontamphaveamptoamptellampyouampthatampweampliveampinampaampfastltpacedamp
technologicallyltrevolutionaryampworldampampThereampareamppartsampofampthatampthatampareampwonderfulampandamp
makeampourampworldampanampeasierampplaceamptoampliveampampButampthereamphasamptoampbeamproomampforampusamptoampswitchampoffamp
unplugampandampslowampdownampampIampbelieveampthatamptheampplatformampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
unleashesampsomeamppossibilitiesampofamphumanampconnectionampinampaampveryamprealampauthenticampwayampamp
(Audienceamprisesampfromamptheirampseatsampwithamptearsampinamptheirampeyesampasamptheyampgiveampaampstandingamp
ovation)amp
EDampampAampnobleampgoalampindeedampampThankampyouampSamanthaampforampallampthatampyouampdoampampWhatampaampgamelt
changerampampThatsampallamptheamptimeampweamphaveampforamptodayampampItsampbeenampaamptrueamphonorampampGoodampluckampinamp
allampofampyourampendeavorsampampToampthoseampwatchingampatamphomeampgoamplistenamptoampsomeoneampamp
(SamanthaampEllenampandampaudienceampdanceampasamptheampcreditsamproll)amp
(
ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 53amp
loose(ends((References(
AndersonampEampHampampampSpencerampMampHamp(2013)ampAampPhenomenologicalampStudyampCognitiveamp
amp RepresentationsampofampAIDSampInampJampWampCreswellampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-
- Designamp(ppamp327lt346)ampLosampAngelesampSAGEampPublicationsampIncamp
BakerampGampampampMorrisampKamp(2002)ampDecartes-DualismampLondonampRoutledgeamp
BelenkyampMampFampClinchyampBampMampGoldbergerampNampRampampampTaruleampJampMamp(1997)ampWomens-Ways-
- of-Knowing-The-Development-of-Self-Voice-and-MindampNewampYorkampNYamp
amp BasicBooksamp
BleicherampJamp(1980)ampampContemporary-Hermeneutics-Hermeneutics-as-Method-
- Philosophy-and-Critique--LondonampUKampRoutledgeampampampKeeganampPaulamp
BohmampDamp(1996)ampOn-DialogueampLondonampUKampRoutledgeamp
BourgeoisampJampPamp(2007)ampThe-Aesthetic-Hermeneutics-of-Hans(Georg-Gadamer-and-Hans-
- Urs-von-BalthasarampNewampYorkampNYampPeterampLangampPublishingampIncamp
BrunsampGampLamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-Ancient-and-ModernampNewampHavenampCTampYaleamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
CalleampSamp(2011)ampBlindampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CalleampSamp(2005)ampExisquisite-PainampNewampYorkampThamesampampampHudsonamp
CalleampSamp(2008)ampTake-Care-of-YourselfampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CaputoampJamp(2000)ampMore-Radical-HermeneuticsampBloomingtonampINampIndianaampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
CreswellampJampWamp(2013)ampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-DesignampLosampAngelesampSAGEamp
amp PublicationsampIncamp
deampCossonampAamp(2002)ampTheampHermeneuticampDialogueampFindingampPatternsampamidamptheampAporiaamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 54amp
amp ofamptheampArtistResearcherTeacherampAlberta-Journal-of-Educational-Researchamp-
- 48amp(3)amp1lt20amp
ElkinsampJamp(2001)ampWhy-Art-Cannot-Be-TaughtampChicagoampILampUniversityampofampIllinoisampPressamp
FairfieldampPamp(2011)ampDialogueampinamptheampClassroomampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-
- Dialogue-and-Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp77lt90)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GadamerampHltGamp(1996)ampThe-Engima-of-HealthampStanfordampCAampStanfordampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
GadamerampHltGamp(2004)ampTruth-and-Methodamp(Secondamprevisedamped)amp(JampWeinsheimerampampamp
amp DampGampMarshallampTrans)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GallagherampSamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-and-EducationampAlbanyampNYampStateampUniversityampofamp
amp NewampYorkampPressamp
GendlinampEamp(1962)ampExperiencing-and-the-Creation-of-MeaningampNewampYorkampNYampTheamp
amp FreeampPressampofampGlencoeamp
GendlinampEamp(1997)ampampHowampPhilosophyampCannotampAppealamptoampExperienceampandampHowampItampCanamp
amp InampLanguage-beyond-Postmodernism-Saying-and-Thinking-in-Gendlins-
- Philosophy-(ppamp3lt41)ampEvanstonampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
GermeraadampGamp(2013)ampRationalityampIntuitionampandampEmotionampExploringampanampArtisticamp
amp ProcessampJournal-for-Artistic-Researchamp-3
GradleampSampAamp(2011)ampAampuniversityampcourseampinampmindfulampviewingampUnderstandingampartampandamp
amp selfampthroughampcontemplativeampexperienceampInternational-Journal-of-Education-
- Through-Artamp-7amp(2)amp137lt151amp
GreeneampMamp(2013)ampTheampTurningampofamptheampLeavesampExpandingampOurampVisionampforamptheampArtsampinamp
amp EducationampHarvard-Educational-Reviewamp-83amp(1)amp251lt252amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 55amp
GrondinampJamp(2002)ampGadamersampBasicampUnderstandingampofampUnderstandingampInampThe-
- Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp36lt51)ampCambridgeampUKampCambridgeamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
GrondinampJamp(2011)ampGadamersampExperienceampandampTheoryampofampEducationampLearningampthatamp
amp theampOtherampMayampBeampRightampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp5lt20)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
HeelanampPamp(1985)ampampPerceptionampasampaampHermeneuticalampActampampInampDampIhdeampampampHampSilvermanamp
amp (Eds)ampHermeneutics-amp-Deconstruction-(ppamp43lt54)-AlbanyampSUNYampPressamp
HeelanampPampampampSchulkinampJamp(2003)ampHermeneuticalampPhilosophyampandampPragmatismampAamp
amp PhilosophyampofampScienceampInampRampCampScharffampampampVampDusekamp(Eds)ampPhilosophy-of-
- Technology-The-Technological-Condition-an-Anthology-amp(ppamp138lt153)amp
amp MaldenampMAampBlackwellamp
KarpiakampIampEamp(2003)ampTheampListeningampHeartampTuningampInampForampTransformativeampLearningamp
amp 2003-Complexity-Science-and-Educational-Research-Conferenceamp(ppamp67lt80)amp
amp EdmontonampCanadaamp
KellyampMampPost(Partum-DocumentampInstituteampofampContemporaryampArtsampLondonamp
KentampSampJampampampCummingampJampamp(2008)ampampIampdontampknowampEngagingampwithampproblematicamp
amp momentsampinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampRadical-Pedagogy-2-(9)amp1lt20ampampamp
LevinampDampMamp(1989)ampThe-Listening-Self-Personal-Growth-Social-Change-and-the-
- Closure-of-MetaphysicsampNewampYorkampNYampRoutledgeamp
LindsethampAampampampNorbergampAamp(2004)ampAampphenomenologicalamphermeneuticalampmethodampforamp
amp researchingamplivedampexperienceampNordic-College-of-Caring-Sciencesamp-18amp145lt153amp
LipariampLamp(2014)ampampOnampinterlisteningampandamptheampideaampofampdialogueampampTheory-amp-Psychology-24-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 56amp
- (4)amp504lt523amp
MarksampLamp(2002)ampTouch-Sensuous-Theory-and-Multisensory-MediaampMinneapolisamp
amp UniversityampofampMinnesotaampPressamp
MunozampKampLamp(2014)ampTranscribing-Silence-Culture-Relationship-and-Communicationamp
amp WalnutampCreekampCAampLeftampCoastampPressamp
NicholampLamp(1996)ampForewordampInampDampBohmampOn-Dialogueamp(ppampviiltxvii)ampLondonampUKamp
amp Routledgeamp
PalmerampRamp(1969)ampHermeneutics-Interpretation-Theory-in-Schleiermacher-Dilthey-
- Heidegger-and-GadamerampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
PerlampSamp(2004)ampFelt-Sense-Writing-with-the-BodyampPortsmouthampNHampBoyntonCookamp
RicoeurampPamp(19691974)ampThe-Conflicts-of-Interpretations-Essays-in-Hermeneuticsamp
amp (NorthwesternampUniversityampPressampTrans)ampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
RicoeurampPamp(2013)ampHermeneuticsampCambridgeampUKampPolityampPressamp
SableampDamp(2014)ampReasonampinamptheampServiceampofamptheampHeartampTheampImpactsampofampContemplativeamp
amp PracticesamponampCriticalampThinkingampJournal-of-Contemplative-Inquiryamp-1amp(1)amp1lt22amp
SchultzampKamp(2010)ampAfteramptheampBlackbirdampWhistlesampListeningamptoampSilenceampinampClassroomsamp
amp Teachers-College-Recordamp-112amp(11)amp2833lt2849amp
SeebohmampTampamp(2004)ampampHermeneutics-Method-and-MethodologyampDordrechtamptheamp
amp NetherlandsampKluwerampAcademicampPublishersamp
SnowberampCamp(2005)ampTheampmentorampasampartistampaamppoeticampexplorationampofamplisteningampcreatingamp
amp andampmentoringampMentoring-and-Tutoring-13amp(3)amp345lt353amp
vanampManenampMampamp(1984)ampPracticingampPhenomenologicalampWritingampPhenomenology-+-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 57amp
- Pedagogy-2amp(1)amp36lt68amp
vanampManenampMamp(1990)ampampResearching-Lived-Experience-Human-Science-for-an-Action(
- Sensitive-PedagogyampNewampYorkampSUNYampPressamp
VitanovaampGamp(2010)ampampAuthoring-the-Dialogic-SelfampAmsterdamampJohnampBenjaminsamp
amp PublishingampCoamp
WatsonampJamp(2013)ampampKnowingampthroughamptheampfeltltsenseampaampgestureampofampopennessamptoamptheamp
amp otherampampInternational-Journal-of-Childrens-Spirituality-18amp(1)amp118lt130amp
WiercinskiampAamp(2011)ampHermeneuticampEducationamptoampUnderstandingampSelfltEducationampandamp
amp theampWillingnessamptoampRiskampFailureampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp107lt124)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
WorsleyampRamp(2012)ampNarrativesampandamplivelyampmetaphorsampHermeneuticsampasampaampwayampofamp
amp listeningampPerson(Centered-amp-Experiential-Psychotherapiesamp-11amp(4)amp304lt320amp
ZuckertampCampHamp(2002)ampHermeneuticsampinampPracticeampGadameramponampAncientampPhilosophyampInamp
amp RampJampDostalamp(Ed)ampThe-Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp201lt224)amp
amp CambridgeampUKampCambridgeampUniversityampPressamp
amp
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
- WebsitePaper-20
- WebsitePaper-18
- WebsitePaperpdf
-
- MesserFinalPaper-11
- MesserFinalPaper
-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 50amp
anotheramphumanampTheseampareamphumbleampgoalsampthatampweampcanampcarryampacrossampmanyampcontextsampampIamp
thinkampthereinampliesamptheampbeautyamp
EDampampInterestingampampImampgoingamptoampaskampwhatampImampsureampaamplotampofampteachersamphaveamponamptheiramp
mindsltlthowampdoampweampteachampthisamptoampstudentsamp
SMampampTheampgoalsampandampbeliefsampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmustampbeamplivedampthroughampandamp
undergoneampratherampthanampmerelyampactedampoutamponceamporamptwiceampampItsampaboutampcreatingampaampsystemamp
craftingampassignmentsampandampsettingampaamptoneampthatampallampunderlieamptheseampvaluesampampNotamponlyampthatamp
butamptheampstudentsampandampteachersampinampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampmustampbeampreflectiveamptoamp
theirampexperiencesampampTheseampskillsampneedamptoampbeampbuiltampupampandampaampkeyampcomponentampofampthatampisamp
reflectionamponamppreviousampexperiencesamp
EDampampampIampunderstandampyouampalsoampsolicitedampsurveyampresponsesamptoampdiscussampmomentsampinampwhichamp
individualsampdidamporampdidampnotampfeelamplistenedamptoampasamptheyampspokeampaboutamptheirampartampampCanampyouamptalkamp
aamplittleampbitampaboutampwhatampyouampfoundampinamptheampsurveysamp
SMampampWellampIampcoveredampaamplotampofampthisampinampmyampbookampYoullamphaveamptoampreadampitampampIamphaveampprovidedamp
everyampmemberampofamptheampaudienceamptodayampwithampaampcopyampwhichampyoullampallampfindampunderampyouramp
seatsamp
(AudienceampgoesampwildampwithampexcitementampasamptheyampreachampunderamptheirampseatsampampThereampareamp
intermittentampscreechesampofampjoy)amp
EDampampWowampthankampyouampampTheampgiftampofamplisteningampwhatampaamptreasureampforamptheampaudienceamp
membersamptodayamp
(Audienceampclapsampwholeheartedly)amp
SMampampYoureampwelcomeampampInampgeneralampthoughampwhatampIampfoundampisampaampneedamptoamphandleamptheampwordsamp
andampexperiencesampofampothersampwithampcareampampTheampsurveysampdescribedampsituationsampinampwhichamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 51amp
individualsampfeltamptheyampwereampnotampbeingamplistenedamptoampyetamptheseampmomentsampwereampnotampusuallyamp
profoundlyamporamppurposefullyamphurtfulampampMoreampoftenamptheampsurveysampdescribedampinstancesampinamp
whichamppeopleampfeltampthatampanotheramppersonampwasntamptryingamptoampunderstandampampTheseamp
situationsampwereampmoreamppassiveampandampdismissiveampratherampthanampactivelyamphurtfulampthoughamp
theyampdidampstillamphurtamp
EDampampWellampcouldntampthatampbeampchalkedampupamptoamptheampsensitiveamppersonaampofamptheampartistampampWeampallamp
knowamphowampsensitiveampthoseampartistsampareamp
(Audienceamplaughsamptheyampareampinamponamptheampjoke)amp
SMampamp(chastising)ampEllenampyoureampsmarterampthanampthatampstereotypeampampIampmeanampyouampcouldampsayamp
thatampbutampIampdontampknowampifampthatampwouldampbeampproductiveampampAndampitampwouldntampfitampwithamptheamp
beliefsampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampinampmyampopinionampampDontampweampallampwantamptoampbeamplistenedamp
toampampIsampthatampdesireampexclusiveamptoampsomeampideaampweamphaveampinampourampheadampofampartistsampampIampdontamp
thinkampsoamp
EDampampYoureampsoamprightampSamanthaampampImampsorryampforampgivingampintoampsomeamppervasiveampmodernistamp
nonsenseampaboutampwhatampitampisamptoampbeampanampartistamp
(Audienceampnodsampinampagreement)amp
SMampampItsampokayampEllenampWeampinamptheampartampworldampareampfightingamptheampgoodampfightampWhatampweampdoampisamp
importantampandampwereamptiredampofampbeingampdismissedampbyampsocietyamp
(Audienceampclaps)amp
EDampampSoampwhatampisampyourampnextampstepamp
SMampampWellampIampwasampjustampawardedampaampspecialampmedalampofamphonorampfromampPresidentampObamaampamp
(PhotoampofampSamanthaampshakingamphandsampwithamptheampPresidentampflashesamponamptheampscreenampandamptheamp
audienceampclaps)amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 52amp
EDampampCongratulationsamp
SMampampThankampyouampampWhatampanamphonorampampAlongampwithampthisampcommendationampcameampaampgrantampforamp
meamptoampbeampableamptoamptrainampaampgroupampofamphighlyampspecializedampartistlteducatorsampinamptheseamp
practicesampandampsendampthemampoutamptoampcommunitiesampacrossamptheampcountryamptoamphelpampimplementamp
andampsupportampeffortsamptoampputampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampintoampschoolsampwhoampchooseamptoampbeamp
involvedampnationwideamp
(Aampthunderingampofampclappingampinamptheampaudience)amp
EDampampWhatampdoampyouampseeampareamptheamplonglttermampeffectsampofamptheampimplementationampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampamp
SMampampEllenampImampsureampIampdontamphaveamptoamptellampyouampthatampweampliveampinampaampfastltpacedamp
technologicallyltrevolutionaryampworldampampThereampareamppartsampofampthatampthatampareampwonderfulampandamp
makeampourampworldampanampeasierampplaceamptoampliveampampButampthereamphasamptoampbeamproomampforampusamptoampswitchampoffamp
unplugampandampslowampdownampampIampbelieveampthatamptheampplatformampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
unleashesampsomeamppossibilitiesampofamphumanampconnectionampinampaampveryamprealampauthenticampwayampamp
(Audienceamprisesampfromamptheirampseatsampwithamptearsampinamptheirampeyesampasamptheyampgiveampaampstandingamp
ovation)amp
EDampampAampnobleampgoalampindeedampampThankampyouampSamanthaampforampallampthatampyouampdoampampWhatampaampgamelt
changerampampThatsampallamptheamptimeampweamphaveampforamptodayampampItsampbeenampaamptrueamphonorampampGoodampluckampinamp
allampofampyourampendeavorsampampToampthoseampwatchingampatamphomeampgoamplistenamptoampsomeoneampamp
(SamanthaampEllenampandampaudienceampdanceampasamptheampcreditsamproll)amp
(
ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 53amp
loose(ends((References(
AndersonampEampHampampampSpencerampMampHamp(2013)ampAampPhenomenologicalampStudyampCognitiveamp
amp RepresentationsampofampAIDSampInampJampWampCreswellampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-
- Designamp(ppamp327lt346)ampLosampAngelesampSAGEampPublicationsampIncamp
BakerampGampampampMorrisampKamp(2002)ampDecartes-DualismampLondonampRoutledgeamp
BelenkyampMampFampClinchyampBampMampGoldbergerampNampRampampampTaruleampJampMamp(1997)ampWomens-Ways-
- of-Knowing-The-Development-of-Self-Voice-and-MindampNewampYorkampNYamp
amp BasicBooksamp
BleicherampJamp(1980)ampampContemporary-Hermeneutics-Hermeneutics-as-Method-
- Philosophy-and-Critique--LondonampUKampRoutledgeampampampKeeganampPaulamp
BohmampDamp(1996)ampOn-DialogueampLondonampUKampRoutledgeamp
BourgeoisampJampPamp(2007)ampThe-Aesthetic-Hermeneutics-of-Hans(Georg-Gadamer-and-Hans-
- Urs-von-BalthasarampNewampYorkampNYampPeterampLangampPublishingampIncamp
BrunsampGampLamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-Ancient-and-ModernampNewampHavenampCTampYaleamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
CalleampSamp(2011)ampBlindampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CalleampSamp(2005)ampExisquisite-PainampNewampYorkampThamesampampampHudsonamp
CalleampSamp(2008)ampTake-Care-of-YourselfampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CaputoampJamp(2000)ampMore-Radical-HermeneuticsampBloomingtonampINampIndianaampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
CreswellampJampWamp(2013)ampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-DesignampLosampAngelesampSAGEamp
amp PublicationsampIncamp
deampCossonampAamp(2002)ampTheampHermeneuticampDialogueampFindingampPatternsampamidamptheampAporiaamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 54amp
amp ofamptheampArtistResearcherTeacherampAlberta-Journal-of-Educational-Researchamp-
- 48amp(3)amp1lt20amp
ElkinsampJamp(2001)ampWhy-Art-Cannot-Be-TaughtampChicagoampILampUniversityampofampIllinoisampPressamp
FairfieldampPamp(2011)ampDialogueampinamptheampClassroomampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-
- Dialogue-and-Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp77lt90)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GadamerampHltGamp(1996)ampThe-Engima-of-HealthampStanfordampCAampStanfordampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
GadamerampHltGamp(2004)ampTruth-and-Methodamp(Secondamprevisedamped)amp(JampWeinsheimerampampamp
amp DampGampMarshallampTrans)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GallagherampSamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-and-EducationampAlbanyampNYampStateampUniversityampofamp
amp NewampYorkampPressamp
GendlinampEamp(1962)ampExperiencing-and-the-Creation-of-MeaningampNewampYorkampNYampTheamp
amp FreeampPressampofampGlencoeamp
GendlinampEamp(1997)ampampHowampPhilosophyampCannotampAppealamptoampExperienceampandampHowampItampCanamp
amp InampLanguage-beyond-Postmodernism-Saying-and-Thinking-in-Gendlins-
- Philosophy-(ppamp3lt41)ampEvanstonampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
GermeraadampGamp(2013)ampRationalityampIntuitionampandampEmotionampExploringampanampArtisticamp
amp ProcessampJournal-for-Artistic-Researchamp-3
GradleampSampAamp(2011)ampAampuniversityampcourseampinampmindfulampviewingampUnderstandingampartampandamp
amp selfampthroughampcontemplativeampexperienceampInternational-Journal-of-Education-
- Through-Artamp-7amp(2)amp137lt151amp
GreeneampMamp(2013)ampTheampTurningampofamptheampLeavesampExpandingampOurampVisionampforamptheampArtsampinamp
amp EducationampHarvard-Educational-Reviewamp-83amp(1)amp251lt252amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 55amp
GrondinampJamp(2002)ampGadamersampBasicampUnderstandingampofampUnderstandingampInampThe-
- Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp36lt51)ampCambridgeampUKampCambridgeamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
GrondinampJamp(2011)ampGadamersampExperienceampandampTheoryampofampEducationampLearningampthatamp
amp theampOtherampMayampBeampRightampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp5lt20)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
HeelanampPamp(1985)ampampPerceptionampasampaampHermeneuticalampActampampInampDampIhdeampampampHampSilvermanamp
amp (Eds)ampHermeneutics-amp-Deconstruction-(ppamp43lt54)-AlbanyampSUNYampPressamp
HeelanampPampampampSchulkinampJamp(2003)ampHermeneuticalampPhilosophyampandampPragmatismampAamp
amp PhilosophyampofampScienceampInampRampCampScharffampampampVampDusekamp(Eds)ampPhilosophy-of-
- Technology-The-Technological-Condition-an-Anthology-amp(ppamp138lt153)amp
amp MaldenampMAampBlackwellamp
KarpiakampIampEamp(2003)ampTheampListeningampHeartampTuningampInampForampTransformativeampLearningamp
amp 2003-Complexity-Science-and-Educational-Research-Conferenceamp(ppamp67lt80)amp
amp EdmontonampCanadaamp
KellyampMampPost(Partum-DocumentampInstituteampofampContemporaryampArtsampLondonamp
KentampSampJampampampCummingampJampamp(2008)ampampIampdontampknowampEngagingampwithampproblematicamp
amp momentsampinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampRadical-Pedagogy-2-(9)amp1lt20ampampamp
LevinampDampMamp(1989)ampThe-Listening-Self-Personal-Growth-Social-Change-and-the-
- Closure-of-MetaphysicsampNewampYorkampNYampRoutledgeamp
LindsethampAampampampNorbergampAamp(2004)ampAampphenomenologicalamphermeneuticalampmethodampforamp
amp researchingamplivedampexperienceampNordic-College-of-Caring-Sciencesamp-18amp145lt153amp
LipariampLamp(2014)ampampOnampinterlisteningampandamptheampideaampofampdialogueampampTheory-amp-Psychology-24-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 56amp
- (4)amp504lt523amp
MarksampLamp(2002)ampTouch-Sensuous-Theory-and-Multisensory-MediaampMinneapolisamp
amp UniversityampofampMinnesotaampPressamp
MunozampKampLamp(2014)ampTranscribing-Silence-Culture-Relationship-and-Communicationamp
amp WalnutampCreekampCAampLeftampCoastampPressamp
NicholampLamp(1996)ampForewordampInampDampBohmampOn-Dialogueamp(ppampviiltxvii)ampLondonampUKamp
amp Routledgeamp
PalmerampRamp(1969)ampHermeneutics-Interpretation-Theory-in-Schleiermacher-Dilthey-
- Heidegger-and-GadamerampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
PerlampSamp(2004)ampFelt-Sense-Writing-with-the-BodyampPortsmouthampNHampBoyntonCookamp
RicoeurampPamp(19691974)ampThe-Conflicts-of-Interpretations-Essays-in-Hermeneuticsamp
amp (NorthwesternampUniversityampPressampTrans)ampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
RicoeurampPamp(2013)ampHermeneuticsampCambridgeampUKampPolityampPressamp
SableampDamp(2014)ampReasonampinamptheampServiceampofamptheampHeartampTheampImpactsampofampContemplativeamp
amp PracticesamponampCriticalampThinkingampJournal-of-Contemplative-Inquiryamp-1amp(1)amp1lt22amp
SchultzampKamp(2010)ampAfteramptheampBlackbirdampWhistlesampListeningamptoampSilenceampinampClassroomsamp
amp Teachers-College-Recordamp-112amp(11)amp2833lt2849amp
SeebohmampTampamp(2004)ampampHermeneutics-Method-and-MethodologyampDordrechtamptheamp
amp NetherlandsampKluwerampAcademicampPublishersamp
SnowberampCamp(2005)ampTheampmentorampasampartistampaamppoeticampexplorationampofamplisteningampcreatingamp
amp andampmentoringampMentoring-and-Tutoring-13amp(3)amp345lt353amp
vanampManenampMampamp(1984)ampPracticingampPhenomenologicalampWritingampPhenomenology-+-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 57amp
- Pedagogy-2amp(1)amp36lt68amp
vanampManenampMamp(1990)ampampResearching-Lived-Experience-Human-Science-for-an-Action(
- Sensitive-PedagogyampNewampYorkampSUNYampPressamp
VitanovaampGamp(2010)ampampAuthoring-the-Dialogic-SelfampAmsterdamampJohnampBenjaminsamp
amp PublishingampCoamp
WatsonampJamp(2013)ampampKnowingampthroughamptheampfeltltsenseampaampgestureampofampopennessamptoamptheamp
amp otherampampInternational-Journal-of-Childrens-Spirituality-18amp(1)amp118lt130amp
WiercinskiampAamp(2011)ampHermeneuticampEducationamptoampUnderstandingampSelfltEducationampandamp
amp theampWillingnessamptoampRiskampFailureampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp107lt124)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
WorsleyampRamp(2012)ampNarrativesampandamplivelyampmetaphorsampHermeneuticsampasampaampwayampofamp
amp listeningampPerson(Centered-amp-Experiential-Psychotherapiesamp-11amp(4)amp304lt320amp
ZuckertampCampHamp(2002)ampHermeneuticsampinampPracticeampGadameramponampAncientampPhilosophyampInamp
amp RampJampDostalamp(Ed)ampThe-Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp201lt224)amp
amp CambridgeampUKampCambridgeampUniversityampPressamp
amp
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
- WebsitePaper-20
- WebsitePaper-18
- WebsitePaperpdf
-
- MesserFinalPaper-11
- MesserFinalPaper
-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 51amp
individualsampfeltamptheyampwereampnotampbeingamplistenedamptoampyetamptheseampmomentsampwereampnotampusuallyamp
profoundlyamporamppurposefullyamphurtfulampampMoreampoftenamptheampsurveysampdescribedampinstancesampinamp
whichamppeopleampfeltampthatampanotheramppersonampwasntamptryingamptoampunderstandampampTheseamp
situationsampwereampmoreamppassiveampandampdismissiveampratherampthanampactivelyamphurtfulampthoughamp
theyampdidampstillamphurtamp
EDampampWellampcouldntampthatampbeampchalkedampupamptoamptheampsensitiveamppersonaampofamptheampartistampampWeampallamp
knowamphowampsensitiveampthoseampartistsampareamp
(Audienceamplaughsamptheyampareampinamponamptheampjoke)amp
SMampamp(chastising)ampEllenampyoureampsmarterampthanampthatampstereotypeampampIampmeanampyouampcouldampsayamp
thatampbutampIampdontampknowampifampthatampwouldampbeampproductiveampampAndampitampwouldntampfitampwithamptheamp
beliefsampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampinampmyampopinionampampDontampweampallampwantamptoampbeamplistenedamp
toampampIsampthatampdesireampexclusiveamptoampsomeampideaampweamphaveampinampourampheadampofampartistsampampIampdontamp
thinkampsoamp
EDampampYoureampsoamprightampSamanthaampampImampsorryampforampgivingampintoampsomeamppervasiveampmodernistamp
nonsenseampaboutampwhatampitampisamptoampbeampanampartistamp
(Audienceampnodsampinampagreement)amp
SMampampItsampokayampEllenampWeampinamptheampartampworldampareampfightingamptheampgoodampfightampWhatampweampdoampisamp
importantampandampwereamptiredampofampbeingampdismissedampbyampsocietyamp
(Audienceampclaps)amp
EDampampSoampwhatampisampyourampnextampstepamp
SMampampWellampIampwasampjustampawardedampaampspecialampmedalampofamphonorampfromampPresidentampObamaampamp
(PhotoampofampSamanthaampshakingamphandsampwithamptheampPresidentampflashesamponamptheampscreenampandamptheamp
audienceampclaps)amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 52amp
EDampampCongratulationsamp
SMampampThankampyouampampWhatampanamphonorampampAlongampwithampthisampcommendationampcameampaampgrantampforamp
meamptoampbeampableamptoamptrainampaampgroupampofamphighlyampspecializedampartistlteducatorsampinamptheseamp
practicesampandampsendampthemampoutamptoampcommunitiesampacrossamptheampcountryamptoamphelpampimplementamp
andampsupportampeffortsamptoampputampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampintoampschoolsampwhoampchooseamptoampbeamp
involvedampnationwideamp
(Aampthunderingampofampclappingampinamptheampaudience)amp
EDampampWhatampdoampyouampseeampareamptheamplonglttermampeffectsampofamptheampimplementationampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampamp
SMampampEllenampImampsureampIampdontamphaveamptoamptellampyouampthatampweampliveampinampaampfastltpacedamp
technologicallyltrevolutionaryampworldampampThereampareamppartsampofampthatampthatampareampwonderfulampandamp
makeampourampworldampanampeasierampplaceamptoampliveampampButampthereamphasamptoampbeamproomampforampusamptoampswitchampoffamp
unplugampandampslowampdownampampIampbelieveampthatamptheampplatformampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
unleashesampsomeamppossibilitiesampofamphumanampconnectionampinampaampveryamprealampauthenticampwayampamp
(Audienceamprisesampfromamptheirampseatsampwithamptearsampinamptheirampeyesampasamptheyampgiveampaampstandingamp
ovation)amp
EDampampAampnobleampgoalampindeedampampThankampyouampSamanthaampforampallampthatampyouampdoampampWhatampaampgamelt
changerampampThatsampallamptheamptimeampweamphaveampforamptodayampampItsampbeenampaamptrueamphonorampampGoodampluckampinamp
allampofampyourampendeavorsampampToampthoseampwatchingampatamphomeampgoamplistenamptoampsomeoneampamp
(SamanthaampEllenampandampaudienceampdanceampasamptheampcreditsamproll)amp
(
ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 53amp
loose(ends((References(
AndersonampEampHampampampSpencerampMampHamp(2013)ampAampPhenomenologicalampStudyampCognitiveamp
amp RepresentationsampofampAIDSampInampJampWampCreswellampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-
- Designamp(ppamp327lt346)ampLosampAngelesampSAGEampPublicationsampIncamp
BakerampGampampampMorrisampKamp(2002)ampDecartes-DualismampLondonampRoutledgeamp
BelenkyampMampFampClinchyampBampMampGoldbergerampNampRampampampTaruleampJampMamp(1997)ampWomens-Ways-
- of-Knowing-The-Development-of-Self-Voice-and-MindampNewampYorkampNYamp
amp BasicBooksamp
BleicherampJamp(1980)ampampContemporary-Hermeneutics-Hermeneutics-as-Method-
- Philosophy-and-Critique--LondonampUKampRoutledgeampampampKeeganampPaulamp
BohmampDamp(1996)ampOn-DialogueampLondonampUKampRoutledgeamp
BourgeoisampJampPamp(2007)ampThe-Aesthetic-Hermeneutics-of-Hans(Georg-Gadamer-and-Hans-
- Urs-von-BalthasarampNewampYorkampNYampPeterampLangampPublishingampIncamp
BrunsampGampLamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-Ancient-and-ModernampNewampHavenampCTampYaleamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
CalleampSamp(2011)ampBlindampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CalleampSamp(2005)ampExisquisite-PainampNewampYorkampThamesampampampHudsonamp
CalleampSamp(2008)ampTake-Care-of-YourselfampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CaputoampJamp(2000)ampMore-Radical-HermeneuticsampBloomingtonampINampIndianaampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
CreswellampJampWamp(2013)ampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-DesignampLosampAngelesampSAGEamp
amp PublicationsampIncamp
deampCossonampAamp(2002)ampTheampHermeneuticampDialogueampFindingampPatternsampamidamptheampAporiaamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 54amp
amp ofamptheampArtistResearcherTeacherampAlberta-Journal-of-Educational-Researchamp-
- 48amp(3)amp1lt20amp
ElkinsampJamp(2001)ampWhy-Art-Cannot-Be-TaughtampChicagoampILampUniversityampofampIllinoisampPressamp
FairfieldampPamp(2011)ampDialogueampinamptheampClassroomampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-
- Dialogue-and-Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp77lt90)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GadamerampHltGamp(1996)ampThe-Engima-of-HealthampStanfordampCAampStanfordampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
GadamerampHltGamp(2004)ampTruth-and-Methodamp(Secondamprevisedamped)amp(JampWeinsheimerampampamp
amp DampGampMarshallampTrans)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GallagherampSamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-and-EducationampAlbanyampNYampStateampUniversityampofamp
amp NewampYorkampPressamp
GendlinampEamp(1962)ampExperiencing-and-the-Creation-of-MeaningampNewampYorkampNYampTheamp
amp FreeampPressampofampGlencoeamp
GendlinampEamp(1997)ampampHowampPhilosophyampCannotampAppealamptoampExperienceampandampHowampItampCanamp
amp InampLanguage-beyond-Postmodernism-Saying-and-Thinking-in-Gendlins-
- Philosophy-(ppamp3lt41)ampEvanstonampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
GermeraadampGamp(2013)ampRationalityampIntuitionampandampEmotionampExploringampanampArtisticamp
amp ProcessampJournal-for-Artistic-Researchamp-3
GradleampSampAamp(2011)ampAampuniversityampcourseampinampmindfulampviewingampUnderstandingampartampandamp
amp selfampthroughampcontemplativeampexperienceampInternational-Journal-of-Education-
- Through-Artamp-7amp(2)amp137lt151amp
GreeneampMamp(2013)ampTheampTurningampofamptheampLeavesampExpandingampOurampVisionampforamptheampArtsampinamp
amp EducationampHarvard-Educational-Reviewamp-83amp(1)amp251lt252amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 55amp
GrondinampJamp(2002)ampGadamersampBasicampUnderstandingampofampUnderstandingampInampThe-
- Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp36lt51)ampCambridgeampUKampCambridgeamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
GrondinampJamp(2011)ampGadamersampExperienceampandampTheoryampofampEducationampLearningampthatamp
amp theampOtherampMayampBeampRightampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp5lt20)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
HeelanampPamp(1985)ampampPerceptionampasampaampHermeneuticalampActampampInampDampIhdeampampampHampSilvermanamp
amp (Eds)ampHermeneutics-amp-Deconstruction-(ppamp43lt54)-AlbanyampSUNYampPressamp
HeelanampPampampampSchulkinampJamp(2003)ampHermeneuticalampPhilosophyampandampPragmatismampAamp
amp PhilosophyampofampScienceampInampRampCampScharffampampampVampDusekamp(Eds)ampPhilosophy-of-
- Technology-The-Technological-Condition-an-Anthology-amp(ppamp138lt153)amp
amp MaldenampMAampBlackwellamp
KarpiakampIampEamp(2003)ampTheampListeningampHeartampTuningampInampForampTransformativeampLearningamp
amp 2003-Complexity-Science-and-Educational-Research-Conferenceamp(ppamp67lt80)amp
amp EdmontonampCanadaamp
KellyampMampPost(Partum-DocumentampInstituteampofampContemporaryampArtsampLondonamp
KentampSampJampampampCummingampJampamp(2008)ampampIampdontampknowampEngagingampwithampproblematicamp
amp momentsampinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampRadical-Pedagogy-2-(9)amp1lt20ampampamp
LevinampDampMamp(1989)ampThe-Listening-Self-Personal-Growth-Social-Change-and-the-
- Closure-of-MetaphysicsampNewampYorkampNYampRoutledgeamp
LindsethampAampampampNorbergampAamp(2004)ampAampphenomenologicalamphermeneuticalampmethodampforamp
amp researchingamplivedampexperienceampNordic-College-of-Caring-Sciencesamp-18amp145lt153amp
LipariampLamp(2014)ampampOnampinterlisteningampandamptheampideaampofampdialogueampampTheory-amp-Psychology-24-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 56amp
- (4)amp504lt523amp
MarksampLamp(2002)ampTouch-Sensuous-Theory-and-Multisensory-MediaampMinneapolisamp
amp UniversityampofampMinnesotaampPressamp
MunozampKampLamp(2014)ampTranscribing-Silence-Culture-Relationship-and-Communicationamp
amp WalnutampCreekampCAampLeftampCoastampPressamp
NicholampLamp(1996)ampForewordampInampDampBohmampOn-Dialogueamp(ppampviiltxvii)ampLondonampUKamp
amp Routledgeamp
PalmerampRamp(1969)ampHermeneutics-Interpretation-Theory-in-Schleiermacher-Dilthey-
- Heidegger-and-GadamerampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
PerlampSamp(2004)ampFelt-Sense-Writing-with-the-BodyampPortsmouthampNHampBoyntonCookamp
RicoeurampPamp(19691974)ampThe-Conflicts-of-Interpretations-Essays-in-Hermeneuticsamp
amp (NorthwesternampUniversityampPressampTrans)ampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
RicoeurampPamp(2013)ampHermeneuticsampCambridgeampUKampPolityampPressamp
SableampDamp(2014)ampReasonampinamptheampServiceampofamptheampHeartampTheampImpactsampofampContemplativeamp
amp PracticesamponampCriticalampThinkingampJournal-of-Contemplative-Inquiryamp-1amp(1)amp1lt22amp
SchultzampKamp(2010)ampAfteramptheampBlackbirdampWhistlesampListeningamptoampSilenceampinampClassroomsamp
amp Teachers-College-Recordamp-112amp(11)amp2833lt2849amp
SeebohmampTampamp(2004)ampampHermeneutics-Method-and-MethodologyampDordrechtamptheamp
amp NetherlandsampKluwerampAcademicampPublishersamp
SnowberampCamp(2005)ampTheampmentorampasampartistampaamppoeticampexplorationampofamplisteningampcreatingamp
amp andampmentoringampMentoring-and-Tutoring-13amp(3)amp345lt353amp
vanampManenampMampamp(1984)ampPracticingampPhenomenologicalampWritingampPhenomenology-+-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 57amp
- Pedagogy-2amp(1)amp36lt68amp
vanampManenampMamp(1990)ampampResearching-Lived-Experience-Human-Science-for-an-Action(
- Sensitive-PedagogyampNewampYorkampSUNYampPressamp
VitanovaampGamp(2010)ampampAuthoring-the-Dialogic-SelfampAmsterdamampJohnampBenjaminsamp
amp PublishingampCoamp
WatsonampJamp(2013)ampampKnowingampthroughamptheampfeltltsenseampaampgestureampofampopennessamptoamptheamp
amp otherampampInternational-Journal-of-Childrens-Spirituality-18amp(1)amp118lt130amp
WiercinskiampAamp(2011)ampHermeneuticampEducationamptoampUnderstandingampSelfltEducationampandamp
amp theampWillingnessamptoampRiskampFailureampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp107lt124)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
WorsleyampRamp(2012)ampNarrativesampandamplivelyampmetaphorsampHermeneuticsampasampaampwayampofamp
amp listeningampPerson(Centered-amp-Experiential-Psychotherapiesamp-11amp(4)amp304lt320amp
ZuckertampCampHamp(2002)ampHermeneuticsampinampPracticeampGadameramponampAncientampPhilosophyampInamp
amp RampJampDostalamp(Ed)ampThe-Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp201lt224)amp
amp CambridgeampUKampCambridgeampUniversityampPressamp
amp
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
- WebsitePaper-20
- WebsitePaper-18
- WebsitePaperpdf
-
- MesserFinalPaper-11
- MesserFinalPaper
-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 52amp
EDampampCongratulationsamp
SMampampThankampyouampampWhatampanamphonorampampAlongampwithampthisampcommendationampcameampaampgrantampforamp
meamptoampbeampableamptoamptrainampaampgroupampofamphighlyampspecializedampartistlteducatorsampinamptheseamp
practicesampandampsendampthemampoutamptoampcommunitiesampacrossamptheampcountryamptoamphelpampimplementamp
andampsupportampeffortsamptoampputampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceampintoampschoolsampwhoampchooseamptoampbeamp
involvedampnationwideamp
(Aampthunderingampofampclappingampinamptheampaudience)amp
EDampampWhatampdoampyouampseeampareamptheamplonglttermampeffectsampofamptheampimplementationampofampcreativelt
listeningampspacesampamp
SMampampEllenampImampsureampIampdontamphaveamptoamptellampyouampthatampweampliveampinampaampfastltpacedamp
technologicallyltrevolutionaryampworldampampThereampareamppartsampofampthatampthatampareampwonderfulampandamp
makeampourampworldampanampeasierampplaceamptoampliveampampButampthereamphasamptoampbeamproomampforampusamptoampswitchampoffamp
unplugampandampslowampdownampampIampbelieveampthatamptheampplatformampofampaampcreativeltlisteningampspaceamp
unleashesampsomeamppossibilitiesampofamphumanampconnectionampinampaampveryamprealampauthenticampwayampamp
(Audienceamprisesampfromamptheirampseatsampwithamptearsampinamptheirampeyesampasamptheyampgiveampaampstandingamp
ovation)amp
EDampampAampnobleampgoalampindeedampampThankampyouampSamanthaampforampallampthatampyouampdoampampWhatampaampgamelt
changerampampThatsampallamptheamptimeampweamphaveampforamptodayampampItsampbeenampaamptrueamphonorampampGoodampluckampinamp
allampofampyourampendeavorsampampToampthoseampwatchingampatamphomeampgoamplistenamptoampsomeoneampamp
(SamanthaampEllenampandampaudienceampdanceampasamptheampcreditsamproll)amp
(
ampamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 53amp
loose(ends((References(
AndersonampEampHampampampSpencerampMampHamp(2013)ampAampPhenomenologicalampStudyampCognitiveamp
amp RepresentationsampofampAIDSampInampJampWampCreswellampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-
- Designamp(ppamp327lt346)ampLosampAngelesampSAGEampPublicationsampIncamp
BakerampGampampampMorrisampKamp(2002)ampDecartes-DualismampLondonampRoutledgeamp
BelenkyampMampFampClinchyampBampMampGoldbergerampNampRampampampTaruleampJampMamp(1997)ampWomens-Ways-
- of-Knowing-The-Development-of-Self-Voice-and-MindampNewampYorkampNYamp
amp BasicBooksamp
BleicherampJamp(1980)ampampContemporary-Hermeneutics-Hermeneutics-as-Method-
- Philosophy-and-Critique--LondonampUKampRoutledgeampampampKeeganampPaulamp
BohmampDamp(1996)ampOn-DialogueampLondonampUKampRoutledgeamp
BourgeoisampJampPamp(2007)ampThe-Aesthetic-Hermeneutics-of-Hans(Georg-Gadamer-and-Hans-
- Urs-von-BalthasarampNewampYorkampNYampPeterampLangampPublishingampIncamp
BrunsampGampLamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-Ancient-and-ModernampNewampHavenampCTampYaleamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
CalleampSamp(2011)ampBlindampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CalleampSamp(2005)ampExisquisite-PainampNewampYorkampThamesampampampHudsonamp
CalleampSamp(2008)ampTake-Care-of-YourselfampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CaputoampJamp(2000)ampMore-Radical-HermeneuticsampBloomingtonampINampIndianaampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
CreswellampJampWamp(2013)ampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-DesignampLosampAngelesampSAGEamp
amp PublicationsampIncamp
deampCossonampAamp(2002)ampTheampHermeneuticampDialogueampFindingampPatternsampamidamptheampAporiaamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 54amp
amp ofamptheampArtistResearcherTeacherampAlberta-Journal-of-Educational-Researchamp-
- 48amp(3)amp1lt20amp
ElkinsampJamp(2001)ampWhy-Art-Cannot-Be-TaughtampChicagoampILampUniversityampofampIllinoisampPressamp
FairfieldampPamp(2011)ampDialogueampinamptheampClassroomampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-
- Dialogue-and-Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp77lt90)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GadamerampHltGamp(1996)ampThe-Engima-of-HealthampStanfordampCAampStanfordampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
GadamerampHltGamp(2004)ampTruth-and-Methodamp(Secondamprevisedamped)amp(JampWeinsheimerampampamp
amp DampGampMarshallampTrans)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GallagherampSamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-and-EducationampAlbanyampNYampStateampUniversityampofamp
amp NewampYorkampPressamp
GendlinampEamp(1962)ampExperiencing-and-the-Creation-of-MeaningampNewampYorkampNYampTheamp
amp FreeampPressampofampGlencoeamp
GendlinampEamp(1997)ampampHowampPhilosophyampCannotampAppealamptoampExperienceampandampHowampItampCanamp
amp InampLanguage-beyond-Postmodernism-Saying-and-Thinking-in-Gendlins-
- Philosophy-(ppamp3lt41)ampEvanstonampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
GermeraadampGamp(2013)ampRationalityampIntuitionampandampEmotionampExploringampanampArtisticamp
amp ProcessampJournal-for-Artistic-Researchamp-3
GradleampSampAamp(2011)ampAampuniversityampcourseampinampmindfulampviewingampUnderstandingampartampandamp
amp selfampthroughampcontemplativeampexperienceampInternational-Journal-of-Education-
- Through-Artamp-7amp(2)amp137lt151amp
GreeneampMamp(2013)ampTheampTurningampofamptheampLeavesampExpandingampOurampVisionampforamptheampArtsampinamp
amp EducationampHarvard-Educational-Reviewamp-83amp(1)amp251lt252amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 55amp
GrondinampJamp(2002)ampGadamersampBasicampUnderstandingampofampUnderstandingampInampThe-
- Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp36lt51)ampCambridgeampUKampCambridgeamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
GrondinampJamp(2011)ampGadamersampExperienceampandampTheoryampofampEducationampLearningampthatamp
amp theampOtherampMayampBeampRightampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp5lt20)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
HeelanampPamp(1985)ampampPerceptionampasampaampHermeneuticalampActampampInampDampIhdeampampampHampSilvermanamp
amp (Eds)ampHermeneutics-amp-Deconstruction-(ppamp43lt54)-AlbanyampSUNYampPressamp
HeelanampPampampampSchulkinampJamp(2003)ampHermeneuticalampPhilosophyampandampPragmatismampAamp
amp PhilosophyampofampScienceampInampRampCampScharffampampampVampDusekamp(Eds)ampPhilosophy-of-
- Technology-The-Technological-Condition-an-Anthology-amp(ppamp138lt153)amp
amp MaldenampMAampBlackwellamp
KarpiakampIampEamp(2003)ampTheampListeningampHeartampTuningampInampForampTransformativeampLearningamp
amp 2003-Complexity-Science-and-Educational-Research-Conferenceamp(ppamp67lt80)amp
amp EdmontonampCanadaamp
KellyampMampPost(Partum-DocumentampInstituteampofampContemporaryampArtsampLondonamp
KentampSampJampampampCummingampJampamp(2008)ampampIampdontampknowampEngagingampwithampproblematicamp
amp momentsampinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampRadical-Pedagogy-2-(9)amp1lt20ampampamp
LevinampDampMamp(1989)ampThe-Listening-Self-Personal-Growth-Social-Change-and-the-
- Closure-of-MetaphysicsampNewampYorkampNYampRoutledgeamp
LindsethampAampampampNorbergampAamp(2004)ampAampphenomenologicalamphermeneuticalampmethodampforamp
amp researchingamplivedampexperienceampNordic-College-of-Caring-Sciencesamp-18amp145lt153amp
LipariampLamp(2014)ampampOnampinterlisteningampandamptheampideaampofampdialogueampampTheory-amp-Psychology-24-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 56amp
- (4)amp504lt523amp
MarksampLamp(2002)ampTouch-Sensuous-Theory-and-Multisensory-MediaampMinneapolisamp
amp UniversityampofampMinnesotaampPressamp
MunozampKampLamp(2014)ampTranscribing-Silence-Culture-Relationship-and-Communicationamp
amp WalnutampCreekampCAampLeftampCoastampPressamp
NicholampLamp(1996)ampForewordampInampDampBohmampOn-Dialogueamp(ppampviiltxvii)ampLondonampUKamp
amp Routledgeamp
PalmerampRamp(1969)ampHermeneutics-Interpretation-Theory-in-Schleiermacher-Dilthey-
- Heidegger-and-GadamerampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
PerlampSamp(2004)ampFelt-Sense-Writing-with-the-BodyampPortsmouthampNHampBoyntonCookamp
RicoeurampPamp(19691974)ampThe-Conflicts-of-Interpretations-Essays-in-Hermeneuticsamp
amp (NorthwesternampUniversityampPressampTrans)ampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
RicoeurampPamp(2013)ampHermeneuticsampCambridgeampUKampPolityampPressamp
SableampDamp(2014)ampReasonampinamptheampServiceampofamptheampHeartampTheampImpactsampofampContemplativeamp
amp PracticesamponampCriticalampThinkingampJournal-of-Contemplative-Inquiryamp-1amp(1)amp1lt22amp
SchultzampKamp(2010)ampAfteramptheampBlackbirdampWhistlesampListeningamptoampSilenceampinampClassroomsamp
amp Teachers-College-Recordamp-112amp(11)amp2833lt2849amp
SeebohmampTampamp(2004)ampampHermeneutics-Method-and-MethodologyampDordrechtamptheamp
amp NetherlandsampKluwerampAcademicampPublishersamp
SnowberampCamp(2005)ampTheampmentorampasampartistampaamppoeticampexplorationampofamplisteningampcreatingamp
amp andampmentoringampMentoring-and-Tutoring-13amp(3)amp345lt353amp
vanampManenampMampamp(1984)ampPracticingampPhenomenologicalampWritingampPhenomenology-+-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 57amp
- Pedagogy-2amp(1)amp36lt68amp
vanampManenampMamp(1990)ampampResearching-Lived-Experience-Human-Science-for-an-Action(
- Sensitive-PedagogyampNewampYorkampSUNYampPressamp
VitanovaampGamp(2010)ampampAuthoring-the-Dialogic-SelfampAmsterdamampJohnampBenjaminsamp
amp PublishingampCoamp
WatsonampJamp(2013)ampampKnowingampthroughamptheampfeltltsenseampaampgestureampofampopennessamptoamptheamp
amp otherampampInternational-Journal-of-Childrens-Spirituality-18amp(1)amp118lt130amp
WiercinskiampAamp(2011)ampHermeneuticampEducationamptoampUnderstandingampSelfltEducationampandamp
amp theampWillingnessamptoampRiskampFailureampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp107lt124)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
WorsleyampRamp(2012)ampNarrativesampandamplivelyampmetaphorsampHermeneuticsampasampaampwayampofamp
amp listeningampPerson(Centered-amp-Experiential-Psychotherapiesamp-11amp(4)amp304lt320amp
ZuckertampCampHamp(2002)ampHermeneuticsampinampPracticeampGadameramponampAncientampPhilosophyampInamp
amp RampJampDostalamp(Ed)ampThe-Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp201lt224)amp
amp CambridgeampUKampCambridgeampUniversityampPressamp
amp
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
- WebsitePaper-20
- WebsitePaper-18
- WebsitePaperpdf
-
- MesserFinalPaper-11
- MesserFinalPaper
-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 53amp
loose(ends((References(
AndersonampEampHampampampSpencerampMampHamp(2013)ampAampPhenomenologicalampStudyampCognitiveamp
amp RepresentationsampofampAIDSampInampJampWampCreswellampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-
- Designamp(ppamp327lt346)ampLosampAngelesampSAGEampPublicationsampIncamp
BakerampGampampampMorrisampKamp(2002)ampDecartes-DualismampLondonampRoutledgeamp
BelenkyampMampFampClinchyampBampMampGoldbergerampNampRampampampTaruleampJampMamp(1997)ampWomens-Ways-
- of-Knowing-The-Development-of-Self-Voice-and-MindampNewampYorkampNYamp
amp BasicBooksamp
BleicherampJamp(1980)ampampContemporary-Hermeneutics-Hermeneutics-as-Method-
- Philosophy-and-Critique--LondonampUKampRoutledgeampampampKeeganampPaulamp
BohmampDamp(1996)ampOn-DialogueampLondonampUKampRoutledgeamp
BourgeoisampJampPamp(2007)ampThe-Aesthetic-Hermeneutics-of-Hans(Georg-Gadamer-and-Hans-
- Urs-von-BalthasarampNewampYorkampNYampPeterampLangampPublishingampIncamp
BrunsampGampLamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-Ancient-and-ModernampNewampHavenampCTampYaleamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
CalleampSamp(2011)ampBlindampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CalleampSamp(2005)ampExisquisite-PainampNewampYorkampThamesampampampHudsonamp
CalleampSamp(2008)ampTake-Care-of-YourselfampArlesampFranceampActesampSudamp
CaputoampJamp(2000)ampMore-Radical-HermeneuticsampBloomingtonampINampIndianaampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
CreswellampJampWamp(2013)ampQualitative-Inquiry-and-Research-DesignampLosampAngelesampSAGEamp
amp PublicationsampIncamp
deampCossonampAamp(2002)ampTheampHermeneuticampDialogueampFindingampPatternsampamidamptheampAporiaamp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 54amp
amp ofamptheampArtistResearcherTeacherampAlberta-Journal-of-Educational-Researchamp-
- 48amp(3)amp1lt20amp
ElkinsampJamp(2001)ampWhy-Art-Cannot-Be-TaughtampChicagoampILampUniversityampofampIllinoisampPressamp
FairfieldampPamp(2011)ampDialogueampinamptheampClassroomampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-
- Dialogue-and-Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp77lt90)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GadamerampHltGamp(1996)ampThe-Engima-of-HealthampStanfordampCAampStanfordampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
GadamerampHltGamp(2004)ampTruth-and-Methodamp(Secondamprevisedamped)amp(JampWeinsheimerampampamp
amp DampGampMarshallampTrans)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GallagherampSamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-and-EducationampAlbanyampNYampStateampUniversityampofamp
amp NewampYorkampPressamp
GendlinampEamp(1962)ampExperiencing-and-the-Creation-of-MeaningampNewampYorkampNYampTheamp
amp FreeampPressampofampGlencoeamp
GendlinampEamp(1997)ampampHowampPhilosophyampCannotampAppealamptoampExperienceampandampHowampItampCanamp
amp InampLanguage-beyond-Postmodernism-Saying-and-Thinking-in-Gendlins-
- Philosophy-(ppamp3lt41)ampEvanstonampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
GermeraadampGamp(2013)ampRationalityampIntuitionampandampEmotionampExploringampanampArtisticamp
amp ProcessampJournal-for-Artistic-Researchamp-3
GradleampSampAamp(2011)ampAampuniversityampcourseampinampmindfulampviewingampUnderstandingampartampandamp
amp selfampthroughampcontemplativeampexperienceampInternational-Journal-of-Education-
- Through-Artamp-7amp(2)amp137lt151amp
GreeneampMamp(2013)ampTheampTurningampofamptheampLeavesampExpandingampOurampVisionampforamptheampArtsampinamp
amp EducationampHarvard-Educational-Reviewamp-83amp(1)amp251lt252amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 55amp
GrondinampJamp(2002)ampGadamersampBasicampUnderstandingampofampUnderstandingampInampThe-
- Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp36lt51)ampCambridgeampUKampCambridgeamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
GrondinampJamp(2011)ampGadamersampExperienceampandampTheoryampofampEducationampLearningampthatamp
amp theampOtherampMayampBeampRightampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp5lt20)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
HeelanampPamp(1985)ampampPerceptionampasampaampHermeneuticalampActampampInampDampIhdeampampampHampSilvermanamp
amp (Eds)ampHermeneutics-amp-Deconstruction-(ppamp43lt54)-AlbanyampSUNYampPressamp
HeelanampPampampampSchulkinampJamp(2003)ampHermeneuticalampPhilosophyampandampPragmatismampAamp
amp PhilosophyampofampScienceampInampRampCampScharffampampampVampDusekamp(Eds)ampPhilosophy-of-
- Technology-The-Technological-Condition-an-Anthology-amp(ppamp138lt153)amp
amp MaldenampMAampBlackwellamp
KarpiakampIampEamp(2003)ampTheampListeningampHeartampTuningampInampForampTransformativeampLearningamp
amp 2003-Complexity-Science-and-Educational-Research-Conferenceamp(ppamp67lt80)amp
amp EdmontonampCanadaamp
KellyampMampPost(Partum-DocumentampInstituteampofampContemporaryampArtsampLondonamp
KentampSampJampampampCummingampJampamp(2008)ampampIampdontampknowampEngagingampwithampproblematicamp
amp momentsampinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampRadical-Pedagogy-2-(9)amp1lt20ampampamp
LevinampDampMamp(1989)ampThe-Listening-Self-Personal-Growth-Social-Change-and-the-
- Closure-of-MetaphysicsampNewampYorkampNYampRoutledgeamp
LindsethampAampampampNorbergampAamp(2004)ampAampphenomenologicalamphermeneuticalampmethodampforamp
amp researchingamplivedampexperienceampNordic-College-of-Caring-Sciencesamp-18amp145lt153amp
LipariampLamp(2014)ampampOnampinterlisteningampandamptheampideaampofampdialogueampampTheory-amp-Psychology-24-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 56amp
- (4)amp504lt523amp
MarksampLamp(2002)ampTouch-Sensuous-Theory-and-Multisensory-MediaampMinneapolisamp
amp UniversityampofampMinnesotaampPressamp
MunozampKampLamp(2014)ampTranscribing-Silence-Culture-Relationship-and-Communicationamp
amp WalnutampCreekampCAampLeftampCoastampPressamp
NicholampLamp(1996)ampForewordampInampDampBohmampOn-Dialogueamp(ppampviiltxvii)ampLondonampUKamp
amp Routledgeamp
PalmerampRamp(1969)ampHermeneutics-Interpretation-Theory-in-Schleiermacher-Dilthey-
- Heidegger-and-GadamerampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
PerlampSamp(2004)ampFelt-Sense-Writing-with-the-BodyampPortsmouthampNHampBoyntonCookamp
RicoeurampPamp(19691974)ampThe-Conflicts-of-Interpretations-Essays-in-Hermeneuticsamp
amp (NorthwesternampUniversityampPressampTrans)ampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
RicoeurampPamp(2013)ampHermeneuticsampCambridgeampUKampPolityampPressamp
SableampDamp(2014)ampReasonampinamptheampServiceampofamptheampHeartampTheampImpactsampofampContemplativeamp
amp PracticesamponampCriticalampThinkingampJournal-of-Contemplative-Inquiryamp-1amp(1)amp1lt22amp
SchultzampKamp(2010)ampAfteramptheampBlackbirdampWhistlesampListeningamptoampSilenceampinampClassroomsamp
amp Teachers-College-Recordamp-112amp(11)amp2833lt2849amp
SeebohmampTampamp(2004)ampampHermeneutics-Method-and-MethodologyampDordrechtamptheamp
amp NetherlandsampKluwerampAcademicampPublishersamp
SnowberampCamp(2005)ampTheampmentorampasampartistampaamppoeticampexplorationampofamplisteningampcreatingamp
amp andampmentoringampMentoring-and-Tutoring-13amp(3)amp345lt353amp
vanampManenampMampamp(1984)ampPracticingampPhenomenologicalampWritingampPhenomenology-+-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 57amp
- Pedagogy-2amp(1)amp36lt68amp
vanampManenampMamp(1990)ampampResearching-Lived-Experience-Human-Science-for-an-Action(
- Sensitive-PedagogyampNewampYorkampSUNYampPressamp
VitanovaampGamp(2010)ampampAuthoring-the-Dialogic-SelfampAmsterdamampJohnampBenjaminsamp
amp PublishingampCoamp
WatsonampJamp(2013)ampampKnowingampthroughamptheampfeltltsenseampaampgestureampofampopennessamptoamptheamp
amp otherampampInternational-Journal-of-Childrens-Spirituality-18amp(1)amp118lt130amp
WiercinskiampAamp(2011)ampHermeneuticampEducationamptoampUnderstandingampSelfltEducationampandamp
amp theampWillingnessamptoampRiskampFailureampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp107lt124)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
WorsleyampRamp(2012)ampNarrativesampandamplivelyampmetaphorsampHermeneuticsampasampaampwayampofamp
amp listeningampPerson(Centered-amp-Experiential-Psychotherapiesamp-11amp(4)amp304lt320amp
ZuckertampCampHamp(2002)ampHermeneuticsampinampPracticeampGadameramponampAncientampPhilosophyampInamp
amp RampJampDostalamp(Ed)ampThe-Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp201lt224)amp
amp CambridgeampUKampCambridgeampUniversityampPressamp
amp
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
- WebsitePaper-20
- WebsitePaper-18
- WebsitePaperpdf
-
- MesserFinalPaper-11
- MesserFinalPaper
-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 54amp
amp ofamptheampArtistResearcherTeacherampAlberta-Journal-of-Educational-Researchamp-
- 48amp(3)amp1lt20amp
ElkinsampJamp(2001)ampWhy-Art-Cannot-Be-TaughtampChicagoampILampUniversityampofampIllinoisampPressamp
FairfieldampPamp(2011)ampDialogueampinamptheampClassroomampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-
- Dialogue-and-Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp77lt90)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GadamerampHltGamp(1996)ampThe-Engima-of-HealthampStanfordampCAampStanfordampUniversityamp
amp Pressamp
GadamerampHltGamp(2004)ampTruth-and-Methodamp(Secondamprevisedamped)amp(JampWeinsheimerampampamp
amp DampGampMarshallampTrans)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
GallagherampSamp(1992)ampHermeneutics-and-EducationampAlbanyampNYampStateampUniversityampofamp
amp NewampYorkampPressamp
GendlinampEamp(1962)ampExperiencing-and-the-Creation-of-MeaningampNewampYorkampNYampTheamp
amp FreeampPressampofampGlencoeamp
GendlinampEamp(1997)ampampHowampPhilosophyampCannotampAppealamptoampExperienceampandampHowampItampCanamp
amp InampLanguage-beyond-Postmodernism-Saying-and-Thinking-in-Gendlins-
- Philosophy-(ppamp3lt41)ampEvanstonampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
GermeraadampGamp(2013)ampRationalityampIntuitionampandampEmotionampExploringampanampArtisticamp
amp ProcessampJournal-for-Artistic-Researchamp-3
GradleampSampAamp(2011)ampAampuniversityampcourseampinampmindfulampviewingampUnderstandingampartampandamp
amp selfampthroughampcontemplativeampexperienceampInternational-Journal-of-Education-
- Through-Artamp-7amp(2)amp137lt151amp
GreeneampMamp(2013)ampTheampTurningampofamptheampLeavesampExpandingampOurampVisionampforamptheampArtsampinamp
amp EducationampHarvard-Educational-Reviewamp-83amp(1)amp251lt252amp
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 55amp
GrondinampJamp(2002)ampGadamersampBasicampUnderstandingampofampUnderstandingampInampThe-
- Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp36lt51)ampCambridgeampUKampCambridgeamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
GrondinampJamp(2011)ampGadamersampExperienceampandampTheoryampofampEducationampLearningampthatamp
amp theampOtherampMayampBeampRightampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp5lt20)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
HeelanampPamp(1985)ampampPerceptionampasampaampHermeneuticalampActampampInampDampIhdeampampampHampSilvermanamp
amp (Eds)ampHermeneutics-amp-Deconstruction-(ppamp43lt54)-AlbanyampSUNYampPressamp
HeelanampPampampampSchulkinampJamp(2003)ampHermeneuticalampPhilosophyampandampPragmatismampAamp
amp PhilosophyampofampScienceampInampRampCampScharffampampampVampDusekamp(Eds)ampPhilosophy-of-
- Technology-The-Technological-Condition-an-Anthology-amp(ppamp138lt153)amp
amp MaldenampMAampBlackwellamp
KarpiakampIampEamp(2003)ampTheampListeningampHeartampTuningampInampForampTransformativeampLearningamp
amp 2003-Complexity-Science-and-Educational-Research-Conferenceamp(ppamp67lt80)amp
amp EdmontonampCanadaamp
KellyampMampPost(Partum-DocumentampInstituteampofampContemporaryampArtsampLondonamp
KentampSampJampampampCummingampJampamp(2008)ampampIampdontampknowampEngagingampwithampproblematicamp
amp momentsampinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampRadical-Pedagogy-2-(9)amp1lt20ampampamp
LevinampDampMamp(1989)ampThe-Listening-Self-Personal-Growth-Social-Change-and-the-
- Closure-of-MetaphysicsampNewampYorkampNYampRoutledgeamp
LindsethampAampampampNorbergampAamp(2004)ampAampphenomenologicalamphermeneuticalampmethodampforamp
amp researchingamplivedampexperienceampNordic-College-of-Caring-Sciencesamp-18amp145lt153amp
LipariampLamp(2014)ampampOnampinterlisteningampandamptheampideaampofampdialogueampampTheory-amp-Psychology-24-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 56amp
- (4)amp504lt523amp
MarksampLamp(2002)ampTouch-Sensuous-Theory-and-Multisensory-MediaampMinneapolisamp
amp UniversityampofampMinnesotaampPressamp
MunozampKampLamp(2014)ampTranscribing-Silence-Culture-Relationship-and-Communicationamp
amp WalnutampCreekampCAampLeftampCoastampPressamp
NicholampLamp(1996)ampForewordampInampDampBohmampOn-Dialogueamp(ppampviiltxvii)ampLondonampUKamp
amp Routledgeamp
PalmerampRamp(1969)ampHermeneutics-Interpretation-Theory-in-Schleiermacher-Dilthey-
- Heidegger-and-GadamerampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
PerlampSamp(2004)ampFelt-Sense-Writing-with-the-BodyampPortsmouthampNHampBoyntonCookamp
RicoeurampPamp(19691974)ampThe-Conflicts-of-Interpretations-Essays-in-Hermeneuticsamp
amp (NorthwesternampUniversityampPressampTrans)ampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
RicoeurampPamp(2013)ampHermeneuticsampCambridgeampUKampPolityampPressamp
SableampDamp(2014)ampReasonampinamptheampServiceampofamptheampHeartampTheampImpactsampofampContemplativeamp
amp PracticesamponampCriticalampThinkingampJournal-of-Contemplative-Inquiryamp-1amp(1)amp1lt22amp
SchultzampKamp(2010)ampAfteramptheampBlackbirdampWhistlesampListeningamptoampSilenceampinampClassroomsamp
amp Teachers-College-Recordamp-112amp(11)amp2833lt2849amp
SeebohmampTampamp(2004)ampampHermeneutics-Method-and-MethodologyampDordrechtamptheamp
amp NetherlandsampKluwerampAcademicampPublishersamp
SnowberampCamp(2005)ampTheampmentorampasampartistampaamppoeticampexplorationampofamplisteningampcreatingamp
amp andampmentoringampMentoring-and-Tutoring-13amp(3)amp345lt353amp
vanampManenampMampamp(1984)ampPracticingampPhenomenologicalampWritingampPhenomenology-+-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 57amp
- Pedagogy-2amp(1)amp36lt68amp
vanampManenampMamp(1990)ampampResearching-Lived-Experience-Human-Science-for-an-Action(
- Sensitive-PedagogyampNewampYorkampSUNYampPressamp
VitanovaampGamp(2010)ampampAuthoring-the-Dialogic-SelfampAmsterdamampJohnampBenjaminsamp
amp PublishingampCoamp
WatsonampJamp(2013)ampampKnowingampthroughamptheampfeltltsenseampaampgestureampofampopennessamptoamptheamp
amp otherampampInternational-Journal-of-Childrens-Spirituality-18amp(1)amp118lt130amp
WiercinskiampAamp(2011)ampHermeneuticampEducationamptoampUnderstandingampSelfltEducationampandamp
amp theampWillingnessamptoampRiskampFailureampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp107lt124)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
WorsleyampRamp(2012)ampNarrativesampandamplivelyampmetaphorsampHermeneuticsampasampaampwayampofamp
amp listeningampPerson(Centered-amp-Experiential-Psychotherapiesamp-11amp(4)amp304lt320amp
ZuckertampCampHamp(2002)ampHermeneuticsampinampPracticeampGadameramponampAncientampPhilosophyampInamp
amp RampJampDostalamp(Ed)ampThe-Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp201lt224)amp
amp CambridgeampUKampCambridgeampUniversityampPressamp
amp
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
- WebsitePaper-20
- WebsitePaper-18
- WebsitePaperpdf
-
- MesserFinalPaper-11
- MesserFinalPaper
-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 55amp
GrondinampJamp(2002)ampGadamersampBasicampUnderstandingampofampUnderstandingampInampThe-
- Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp36lt51)ampCambridgeampUKampCambridgeamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
GrondinampJamp(2011)ampGadamersampExperienceampandampTheoryampofampEducationampLearningampthatamp
amp theampOtherampMayampBeampRightampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp5lt20)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
HeelanampPamp(1985)ampampPerceptionampasampaampHermeneuticalampActampampInampDampIhdeampampampHampSilvermanamp
amp (Eds)ampHermeneutics-amp-Deconstruction-(ppamp43lt54)-AlbanyampSUNYampPressamp
HeelanampPampampampSchulkinampJamp(2003)ampHermeneuticalampPhilosophyampandampPragmatismampAamp
amp PhilosophyampofampScienceampInampRampCampScharffampampampVampDusekamp(Eds)ampPhilosophy-of-
- Technology-The-Technological-Condition-an-Anthology-amp(ppamp138lt153)amp
amp MaldenampMAampBlackwellamp
KarpiakampIampEamp(2003)ampTheampListeningampHeartampTuningampInampForampTransformativeampLearningamp
amp 2003-Complexity-Science-and-Educational-Research-Conferenceamp(ppamp67lt80)amp
amp EdmontonampCanadaamp
KellyampMampPost(Partum-DocumentampInstituteampofampContemporaryampArtsampLondonamp
KentampSampJampampampCummingampJampamp(2008)ampampIampdontampknowampEngagingampwithampproblematicamp
amp momentsampinampaampmulticulturalampeducationampampRadical-Pedagogy-2-(9)amp1lt20ampampamp
LevinampDampMamp(1989)ampThe-Listening-Self-Personal-Growth-Social-Change-and-the-
- Closure-of-MetaphysicsampNewampYorkampNYampRoutledgeamp
LindsethampAampampampNorbergampAamp(2004)ampAampphenomenologicalamphermeneuticalampmethodampforamp
amp researchingamplivedampexperienceampNordic-College-of-Caring-Sciencesamp-18amp145lt153amp
LipariampLamp(2014)ampampOnampinterlisteningampandamptheampideaampofampdialogueampampTheory-amp-Psychology-24-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 56amp
- (4)amp504lt523amp
MarksampLamp(2002)ampTouch-Sensuous-Theory-and-Multisensory-MediaampMinneapolisamp
amp UniversityampofampMinnesotaampPressamp
MunozampKampLamp(2014)ampTranscribing-Silence-Culture-Relationship-and-Communicationamp
amp WalnutampCreekampCAampLeftampCoastampPressamp
NicholampLamp(1996)ampForewordampInampDampBohmampOn-Dialogueamp(ppampviiltxvii)ampLondonampUKamp
amp Routledgeamp
PalmerampRamp(1969)ampHermeneutics-Interpretation-Theory-in-Schleiermacher-Dilthey-
- Heidegger-and-GadamerampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
PerlampSamp(2004)ampFelt-Sense-Writing-with-the-BodyampPortsmouthampNHampBoyntonCookamp
RicoeurampPamp(19691974)ampThe-Conflicts-of-Interpretations-Essays-in-Hermeneuticsamp
amp (NorthwesternampUniversityampPressampTrans)ampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
RicoeurampPamp(2013)ampHermeneuticsampCambridgeampUKampPolityampPressamp
SableampDamp(2014)ampReasonampinamptheampServiceampofamptheampHeartampTheampImpactsampofampContemplativeamp
amp PracticesamponampCriticalampThinkingampJournal-of-Contemplative-Inquiryamp-1amp(1)amp1lt22amp
SchultzampKamp(2010)ampAfteramptheampBlackbirdampWhistlesampListeningamptoampSilenceampinampClassroomsamp
amp Teachers-College-Recordamp-112amp(11)amp2833lt2849amp
SeebohmampTampamp(2004)ampampHermeneutics-Method-and-MethodologyampDordrechtamptheamp
amp NetherlandsampKluwerampAcademicampPublishersamp
SnowberampCamp(2005)ampTheampmentorampasampartistampaamppoeticampexplorationampofamplisteningampcreatingamp
amp andampmentoringampMentoring-and-Tutoring-13amp(3)amp345lt353amp
vanampManenampMampamp(1984)ampPracticingampPhenomenologicalampWritingampPhenomenology-+-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 57amp
- Pedagogy-2amp(1)amp36lt68amp
vanampManenampMamp(1990)ampampResearching-Lived-Experience-Human-Science-for-an-Action(
- Sensitive-PedagogyampNewampYorkampSUNYampPressamp
VitanovaampGamp(2010)ampampAuthoring-the-Dialogic-SelfampAmsterdamampJohnampBenjaminsamp
amp PublishingampCoamp
WatsonampJamp(2013)ampampKnowingampthroughamptheampfeltltsenseampaampgestureampofampopennessamptoamptheamp
amp otherampampInternational-Journal-of-Childrens-Spirituality-18amp(1)amp118lt130amp
WiercinskiampAamp(2011)ampHermeneuticampEducationamptoampUnderstandingampSelfltEducationampandamp
amp theampWillingnessamptoampRiskampFailureampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp107lt124)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
WorsleyampRamp(2012)ampNarrativesampandamplivelyampmetaphorsampHermeneuticsampasampaampwayampofamp
amp listeningampPerson(Centered-amp-Experiential-Psychotherapiesamp-11amp(4)amp304lt320amp
ZuckertampCampHamp(2002)ampHermeneuticsampinampPracticeampGadameramponampAncientampPhilosophyampInamp
amp RampJampDostalamp(Ed)ampThe-Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp201lt224)amp
amp CambridgeampUKampCambridgeampUniversityampPressamp
amp
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
- WebsitePaper-20
- WebsitePaper-18
- WebsitePaperpdf
-
- MesserFinalPaper-11
- MesserFinalPaper
-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 56amp
- (4)amp504lt523amp
MarksampLamp(2002)ampTouch-Sensuous-Theory-and-Multisensory-MediaampMinneapolisamp
amp UniversityampofampMinnesotaampPressamp
MunozampKampLamp(2014)ampTranscribing-Silence-Culture-Relationship-and-Communicationamp
amp WalnutampCreekampCAampLeftampCoastampPressamp
NicholampLamp(1996)ampForewordampInampDampBohmampOn-Dialogueamp(ppampviiltxvii)ampLondonampUKamp
amp Routledgeamp
PalmerampRamp(1969)ampHermeneutics-Interpretation-Theory-in-Schleiermacher-Dilthey-
- Heidegger-and-GadamerampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternampUniversityampPressamp
PerlampSamp(2004)ampFelt-Sense-Writing-with-the-BodyampPortsmouthampNHampBoyntonCookamp
RicoeurampPamp(19691974)ampThe-Conflicts-of-Interpretations-Essays-in-Hermeneuticsamp
amp (NorthwesternampUniversityampPressampTrans)ampEvanstonampILampNorthwesternamp
amp UniversityampPressamp
RicoeurampPamp(2013)ampHermeneuticsampCambridgeampUKampPolityampPressamp
SableampDamp(2014)ampReasonampinamptheampServiceampofamptheampHeartampTheampImpactsampofampContemplativeamp
amp PracticesamponampCriticalampThinkingampJournal-of-Contemplative-Inquiryamp-1amp(1)amp1lt22amp
SchultzampKamp(2010)ampAfteramptheampBlackbirdampWhistlesampListeningamptoampSilenceampinampClassroomsamp
amp Teachers-College-Recordamp-112amp(11)amp2833lt2849amp
SeebohmampTampamp(2004)ampampHermeneutics-Method-and-MethodologyampDordrechtamptheamp
amp NetherlandsampKluwerampAcademicampPublishersamp
SnowberampCamp(2005)ampTheampmentorampasampartistampaamppoeticampexplorationampofamplisteningampcreatingamp
amp andampmentoringampMentoring-and-Tutoring-13amp(3)amp345lt353amp
vanampManenampMampamp(1984)ampPracticingampPhenomenologicalampWritingampPhenomenology-+-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 57amp
- Pedagogy-2amp(1)amp36lt68amp
vanampManenampMamp(1990)ampampResearching-Lived-Experience-Human-Science-for-an-Action(
- Sensitive-PedagogyampNewampYorkampSUNYampPressamp
VitanovaampGamp(2010)ampampAuthoring-the-Dialogic-SelfampAmsterdamampJohnampBenjaminsamp
amp PublishingampCoamp
WatsonampJamp(2013)ampampKnowingampthroughamptheampfeltltsenseampaampgestureampofampopennessamptoamptheamp
amp otherampampInternational-Journal-of-Childrens-Spirituality-18amp(1)amp118lt130amp
WiercinskiampAamp(2011)ampHermeneuticampEducationamptoampUnderstandingampSelfltEducationampandamp
amp theampWillingnessamptoampRiskampFailureampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp107lt124)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
WorsleyampRamp(2012)ampNarrativesampandamplivelyampmetaphorsampHermeneuticsampasampaampwayampofamp
amp listeningampPerson(Centered-amp-Experiential-Psychotherapiesamp-11amp(4)amp304lt320amp
ZuckertampCampHamp(2002)ampHermeneuticsampinampPracticeampGadameramponampAncientampPhilosophyampInamp
amp RampJampDostalamp(Ed)ampThe-Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp201lt224)amp
amp CambridgeampUKampCambridgeampUniversityampPressamp
amp
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
- WebsitePaper-20
- WebsitePaper-18
- WebsitePaperpdf
-
- MesserFinalPaper-11
- MesserFinalPaper
-
TheampPossibilityampofampPossibilitiesampCreativeltListeningampSpacesampinampArtampEducationamp
amp 57amp
- Pedagogy-2amp(1)amp36lt68amp
vanampManenampMamp(1990)ampampResearching-Lived-Experience-Human-Science-for-an-Action(
- Sensitive-PedagogyampNewampYorkampSUNYampPressamp
VitanovaampGamp(2010)ampampAuthoring-the-Dialogic-SelfampAmsterdamampJohnampBenjaminsamp
amp PublishingampCoamp
WatsonampJamp(2013)ampampKnowingampthroughamptheampfeltltsenseampaampgestureampofampopennessamptoamptheamp
amp otherampampInternational-Journal-of-Childrens-Spirituality-18amp(1)amp118lt130amp
WiercinskiampAamp(2011)ampHermeneuticampEducationamptoampUnderstandingampSelfltEducationampandamp
amp theampWillingnessamptoampRiskampFailureampInampPampFairfieldamp(Ed)ampEducation-Dialogue-and-
- Hermeneuticsamp(ppamp107lt124)ampLondonampUKampContinuumamp
WorsleyampRamp(2012)ampNarrativesampandamplivelyampmetaphorsampHermeneuticsampasampaampwayampofamp
amp listeningampPerson(Centered-amp-Experiential-Psychotherapiesamp-11amp(4)amp304lt320amp
ZuckertampCampHamp(2002)ampHermeneuticsampinampPracticeampGadameramponampAncientampPhilosophyampInamp
amp RampJampDostalamp(Ed)ampThe-Cambridge-Companion-to-Gadameramp(ppamp201lt224)amp
amp CambridgeampUKampCambridgeampUniversityampPressamp
amp
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
- WebsitePaper-20
- WebsitePaper-18
- WebsitePaperpdf
-
- MesserFinalPaper-11
- MesserFinalPaper
-
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
samanthamesser
Typewritten Text
- WebsitePaper-20
- WebsitePaper-18
- WebsitePaperpdf
-
- MesserFinalPaper-11
- MesserFinalPaper
-
- WebsitePaper-20
- WebsitePaper-18
- WebsitePaperpdf
-
- MesserFinalPaper-11
- MesserFinalPaper
-
