The Parminter Cousins

39
A La Ronde performance/walk (2007) Phil Smith (I am dressed in a cream suit, wearing dark glasses, which I remove as the audience approach. I have two suitcases at my feet.) 1/ Well, hello, everyone. My name is Phil Smith and I’m very pleased you can join me on this walk around A La Ronde – this unusual house here, built for – or some people say built, or at least designed, by - Mary and Jane Parminter, two cousins. This house was built not only as their home, but also as a celebration of their European Grand Tour – a ten year long journey they began more than 200 years ago. They had set off in 1784 and made a slow but painstaking progress through France, Italy, Germany, Switzerland and possibly Portugal and Spain. Please note that

description

Phil Smith's text for A La Ronde ~ Performance 2 (2007)

Transcript of The Parminter Cousins

Page 1: The Parminter Cousins

A La Ronde performance/walk (2007)

Phil Smith

(I am dressed in a cream suit, wearing dark glasses, which I remove as the audience approach. I have two suitcases at my feet.)

1/

Well, hello, everyone. My name is Phil Smith and I’m very pleased you can join me on this walk around A La Ronde – this unusual house here, built for – or some people say built, or at least designed, by - Mary and Jane Parminter, two cousins. This house was built not only as their home, but also as a celebration of their European Grand Tour – a ten year long journey they began more than 200 years ago.

They had set off in 1784 and made a slow but painstaking progress through France, Italy, Germany, Switzerland and possibly Portugal and Spain. Please note that “possibly” – because in researching the history of the Parminter cousins and their house here I have probably turned up more “possibly” than anything else.

Now, this tour we are going on today will be something of a celebration of the Parminters’ tour – and at the same time something of a celebration of the most recent leg of my own European Grand Tour. In the last couple of years making these kinds of walks has taken me – sometimes on my own, sometimes with the artists Wrights & Sites – to the Channel Islands, to Munich, to Copenhagen, to Naples, to Zurich and I have just returned from Vienna, a few days ago.

Page 2: The Parminter Cousins

So I’m carrying these cases – you might be able to help me with them in a while – partly to celebrate my coming home. And partly to remember the Tour made by the two cousins who lived here.

(LET PEOPLE TRY THEM OUT.)

If you hold them. You’ll feel that they are quite light, because I didn’t bring many things back with me from Vienna – just a couple of things for my children.

(SHOW TO ANY CHILDREN ON THE WALK.)

Mostly I brought back stories and impressions and ideas and associations. And, perhaps I will have time to share a few of them as we go along.

But when the Parminters came back from their tour they brought back many, many things.

And I want to talk about one of these things – and it’s something which is literally at the very centre of this house.

For those of you who haven’t been inside yet, the central room of the house runs from the upper ground floor all the way up to the roof. And down from the very centre of that roof is hung a long steel wire that reaches down almost to the floor of the central room. Now, there are two things hanging on this wire – I shall come to the very lowest thing a little later. But just above it is a very significant thing.

By the way, “significant” is another of those words you find a lot of when researching the Parminters.

Page 3: The Parminter Cousins

Now, this thing on the wire is a dove – a stuffed dove – and in its beak is an olive branch – a small, leafy twig from an olive tree. The present one is a recent restoration, but we know something very like it was part of the original design of the house because it is described in Mary Parminter’s will. And that will is going to play an important part in this journey.

OK – so at heart of the house is an animal. And a plant.

And what you will find if you look through the house is that so much of it is decorated with exactly that… with feathers and shells and with plants – most strikingly with seaweed.

But for the first part of our walk, we’re going to walk around the perimeter of the Parminters’ garden – just as it’s believed that the cousins themselves would have done each day.

Of course there have been some changes since the Parminters’ time – you will have to imagine the two milk cows and the fourteen sheep that were kept here to create the sense of living in a rural landscape.

And as we go I’d like you to look out for plants and animals, use your eyes like digital cameras – and store as many images in your head as you can. Immerse yourself in the natural part of this garden.

(Then walking anti-clockwise around the perimeter walk.)

2/ View of the house.

Page 4: The Parminter Cousins

OK, well, we’ve arrived at a good place to look back at the A La Ronde house –

… but before I get you to start looking at this place in a slightly different kind of way I’d like to share with you one of my experiences from the Viennese leg of my Grand Tour – now, I was in Vienna to visit and take part in some walks and tours made by Viennese artists inspired by the kind of a tour that we are taking part in today.

And one of these tours began in one of the suburbs of Vienna, called Kagran, and there we were guided by a rather eccentric mountaineer and a young shepherdess into the city’s waste dump – now this is a very unusual waste dump – because where they once filled the ground with waste now they have found a way to compress the waste, so it is solid enough to be built up above the ground – and they have made pyramid, using the same system of ramps as were used by the ancient Egyptians to make their pyramids. On the very top of this pyramid, which takes about an hour to climb, the Viennese sanitary workers have built their own safari-style lodge, an open lodge with views all over the city and the countryside and beside it they have dug a swimming pool. To see all this would be enough, but to top the day, the manager of the site crams me into the back of his tiny jeep and we drive to a place where we enter a scene like that on a mountain top, but constructed out of what look like huge, rather geometrical boulders. These are the remains of the former Reichsbrucke – the old bridge over the Danube that collapsed in the 1970s – and on the top of these remains were a herd of huge mountain goats, twenty three of the last 300 of an endangered species.

(SHOW PICTURES.)

Page 5: The Parminter Cousins

So - nature in a very artificial and constructed space.

And I want to suggest that this space here, at A la Ronde, despite the apparently very natural look, is also very artificial and constructed.

Because where I first asked you to think of the natural elements that make up much of the ornament of the house – symbolised by that dove and olive branch at its very heart – now I want you to think a little bit about the house’s shape – which is what has made A La Ronde famous – and also, something of a puzzle.

I shouldn’t really say “shape”, but “shapes” – because the house is very importantly made up of two key shapes.

The outer walls make up a symmetrical sixteen sided shell – and inside that, something you can’t tell from the outside – is a shape that I think is “possibly” the most “significant” – those words I warned you about! – the central room is eight-sided. Indeed there are many eights in that central room – it has eight doors, for example, and the chairs all have eight-sided seats and eight-sided backs. The octagon seems to have been of great significance to the cousins.

But why? People have had all sorts of theories: that the shape is based on a South Sea Islands hut, a Chinese temple, or more prosaically, on eight-sided summerhouses that were popular in England at the time. But the explanation which seems to have gathered most enthusiasm – perhaps because it is both logical, but also suggestive – is that the cousins were inspired to live in a house built around eight sides by their visit – on their Grand Tour - to the Italian city of Ravenna and specifically to the Cathedral of Saint Vitale.

Page 6: The Parminter Cousins

And here’s a picture of the cathedral at Ravenna…

(TAKE BOOK FROM THE SUITCASE AND SHOW A PICTURE OF THE OUTSIDE OF THE CATHEDRAL AT RAVENNA.) Now, I actually bought this book from a second hand bookshop in Vienna, but I want you to imagine that this is a memory that was brought back here by the cousins.

There are a couple of things to point out here – first the key symmetrical inside shape is not clear from the outside. Just like here. Also, the outer shell is fairly dour – and if we look at how A La Ronde first appeared, before the roof was tiled and the extra windows put in…

(SHOW PHOTO OF THE MODEL OF THE ORIGINAL APPEARANCE OF A LA RONDE)

… it doesn’t really tell you much about the extraordinary geometry of what lies within.

So here is the interior of Saint Vitale.

(SHOW.)

And here is the interior of A La Ronde.

(SHOW.)

And what they have most in common is that that they are constructed around a dome supported on an octagon of walls – significantly, neither of which is photographed here.”

Page 7: The Parminter Cousins

The dome was the key architectural development of Byzantine architecture – and the cathedral at Saint Vitale is a very important example, - begun in 527 and completed in 548 - it is a model, a message to everyone of the superiority of the Christian Byzantine Empire, a message sent from the Byzantine emperor Justinian, telling the world that his empire is here to stay, that his capture of Ravenna from the pagan Ostrogaths has secured for him the centre of the Eastern part of his empire and is now the launch pad for winning back Western Europe for Christianity and wresting it back from the northern European pagans.

There are two things to point out about Saint Vitale at this point – but it will come back later in our journey –

The first thing is the mosaics: the basilica (or dome) and the rest of the interior are covered – just like much of the interior of A La Ronde - in spectacular mosaics.

Here is the baptistery mosaic, for example, and right at the centre of the roof, is our friend the dove. Just like here.

(SHOW THIS IMAGE FROM BOOK.)

Something to note is how many of the mosaics tell stories from the Old Testament history of the Jews – Abraham and the (almost) sacrifice of Isaac, Moses and the Burning Bush, the prophecies of Isaiah, representatives of the twelve tribes of Israel – and just to drive the point home, the roof of the presbytery rises to a crown that encircles Christ portrayed as a lamb – remember the sheep that were once here – and above the arches are two angels holding a single disc or globe, and beside them are two cities – Jerusalem and Bethlehem – the

Page 8: The Parminter Cousins

first representing the Jewish city, the second the Christian city – and the disc representing the utopian coming together at the end of time of these two divided people and two divided religions with their common origin.

Now the second thing to note is the dome itself – it seems to hover…

Now, there are lots of ways that artists and architects can use shapes to create illusions … and I’ve got a book here with a few:

(SHOW SOME EXAMPLES FROM BOOK OF ILLUSIONS.)

Well, it’s the same basic trick at work here – using the mechanics of our brains and eyes to create illusions.

First of all the arches are designed to look as if they could not possibly be holding up the dome. To give the impression that it’s floating in the air. And then to add to this effect the symmetry of the central form of the cathedral is disrupted by building the so-called “narthex” off the axis - which is why the church looks jumbled from the outside.

From the inside this makes the building a mystery. It’s hard to read the way the building works, to see where the load of the dome might be supported – indeed the idea is to suggest that perhaps it is only by the invisible will and action of God that the dome is supported.

And something similar seems to be at work in the house here at A la Ronde – not by placing something off-axis, there is no room for that. But rather in the dome itself – which

Page 9: The Parminter Cousins

incidentally shares with Saint Vitale an ambulatory gallery all around the top – at San Vitale there is a gallery reserved only for women, just as was this house - in the dome here there is something about the shaping of the coving gallery which seems to suck the eyes of the viewer up into its heights –

Here’s a typical description of the house by an online local historian who describes the central room as “sixty feet in height above which is a shell gallery” – so let’s say that makes seventy feet – well, that is in fact double the actual height. Clearly, architects have been at work here to create illusions. Illusions that have a message. About the presence of something invisible – of the work of an invisible God who intervenes in architecture as well as in history. Something bigger than we can touch.

And hovering at the end of a steel wire inside A la Ronde – is a reflective globe. A symmetrical symbol of a world, reflecting light...

So, let’s continue on our tour. But this time as well as noticing the natural world – the animals, the plants – also have in your mind the very unnatural world of geometry and symmetry…

.. or at least we tend to think of it as unnatural – though it comes out of our very natural brains.

And in fact there is plenty of symmetry in nature – just about every animal there is can move, and the best way that nature has found to aid that movement is something called dorsiventrality. Basically if you split us from top to bottom one side looks pretty much like a mirror image of the other. And this really helps with moving – to have our limbs in symmetrically balanced positions to move us around.

Page 10: The Parminter Cousins

(SHOW IMAGE OF A DOVE CUT IN HALF.)

And those mountain goats are the same.

And a lot of leaves are the same. Here.

(TAKE A SYMMETRICAL LEAF AND FOLD IT IN TWO.)

So maybe there isn’t such a strict division between nature and symmetry – after all the Parminters were happy to place a dove and a sphere together.

So, we’re going to walk towards and then away from the house now – we’re going to break up our ‘global’ walk around A la Ronde. After all, the Parminter cousins’ Grand Tour – despite their placing a globe at the centre of their house – was very far from global. Though to them it probably felt as if the had seen the world.

So, then, as we go keep in mind the symmetries you might see in the house, the ones I’ve shown you that are here and the ones in Italy, and also any you may see or remember in nature.

Just as you collected animals and plants - this time see how many symmetrical shapes you can collect in your head.

3/ The big oak

I’m stopping here because of this big oak tree here, because there is an important story about the older oak trees here.

Page 11: The Parminter Cousins

But first I want to tell you about oak trees and my own travelling. Because this Easter, for just over a couple of weeks I followed the route of a walk first made a hundred years ago by a Manchester engineer called Charles Hurst.

Hurst was appalled by the pollution of the industry that he had helped to create and so he set out to wander – with no set destination in mind – carefully planting acorns as he went. Because he was worried that pollution was killing the oaks. He wrote a book about his journey. But the book is completely forgotten – I discovered it entirely by accident in the underground stacks of Exeter Central Library – no one had taken it out for twenty years. But I was able to work out from his story his basic route – sometimes following very closely, sometimes approximately. And as I went along I was looking for the 100 year old oak trees that might have grown from his acorns.

I had many adventures, but almost from the very beginning of my walk – which was about 200 miles from Manchester down to a village in Rutland – many of the things that happened to me seemed to have a symbolic significance. The people I met would tell me stories of extraordinary things – of tunnels and underground ballrooms, of prophesies and approaching deaths, I would be attacked by flocks of birds (twice), I would be attracted by the shape of shadows in cornfields and discover they were traces of the Knights Templar, on Archaeological Way I found endless car wrecks and dumped tyres, as if this was an apocalyptic, post-petroleum landscape … I met, completely by accident, someone I hadn’t seen for more than 30 years, an old school friend… and of course, as I’d been walking across the country many of my thoughts were on travel, and cars, and pollution, and in the hot sun about global

Page 12: The Parminter Cousins

warning - my old friend turned out to be the new civil service head of the Ministry of Transport.

Now someone – travelling in the same kind of symbolic frame of mind as I did while seeking the oak trees – came this way. His name was Lewis Way and he was a very rich man. But being rich was not so important to him. For he had come into his money in a rather odd way. He was given his money by an old man called John Way. Despite their surnames they were not related.

John Way had made his money from land. He was a very devout man and he wished to pass on his wealth so it might be used for religious purposes, but he was not sure if he could trust any of his relatives. Finally, he found a distant relative he thought he could trust and after interviewing the man he was confident that he could trust him to spend the money well. So he suggested to his heir-to-be that they settle their agreement with a small glass of port.

Unfortunately, John Way could not get the cork out of the port bottle. But the heir-to-be leapt to his aid producing a corkscrew from his pocket and successfully opened the bottle of port.

(PRODUCE A CORKSCREW FROM POCKET.)

John Way was pleased and together they toasted the deal.

But later, before John Way had signed the papers, he began to wonder if his money would be so safe with a man who always kept a corkscrew in his pocket and he cancelled the deal.

Page 13: The Parminter Cousins

Eventually, in 1804, he gave his money - 300,000 pounds – many millions in today’s money - to Lewis Way, a barrister – attracted first by their common surname and then by Lewis Way’s devout character.

Lewis did as John hoped and spent his money on various religious and missionary projects.

Some point after 1811 Lewis Way was travelling near Exmouth and was brought by a friend to see this unusual house. The friend told Way of a codicil in the will of Jane Parminter, the older of the two cousins. In this clause it was specified that the oaks in the grounds were to be protected – indeed, that “the hand of man shall not be raised against them, till Israel returns and is restored to the Land of Promise.” Indeed the friend explained that it was the local belief that the oak trees were intended for be used as ships’ timbers – to make the boats in which the dispersed Jewish people, converted to Christianity, would be returned to Israel.

Lewis was inspired by this story and – no doubt, sensing the symbolic importance of his stumbling accidentally upon this story – dedicated the rest of his life, and his fortune, to the conversion of the Jews to Christianity, in preparation for their return to Israel, where, at the end of time – symbolised in many poems and writings by the moment of the conversion of the Jews – the twin cities of Jerusalem, city of the Jews, and Bethlehem, city of the Christians, would be united in a single, shining globe, or disc, the indivisible shape, similar at every point, the symbol of unity – the unity of the universe.

The irony of the story is that –according to the historian Robin Bush, who has studied the original Parminter will – there is no such codicil.

Page 14: The Parminter Cousins

Sometimes symbols don’t need to be accurate to have power…

… two shapes arise from this story, both from nature and from symmetry…

First the corkscrew: this form appears in many sea shells – the key material for the decoration of A la Ronde.

And then the branches of the oak – which might seem to have no symmetry at all, with their wandering – and yet… and this is something pointed out first by Leonardo Da Vinci – if you take a cross section through any part of the tree – bottom of the trunk, first spread into thick boughs, higher up the spread of smaller branches – in each case the total cross-sectional area remains the same. Unity is present symbolically even when not in appearance.

O, and the corkscrew also occurs in the horns of the goats on the Viennese wastedump… and in the ivy that winds its way around the oak’s branches.

Let’s walk now to a secret place – and as we do – think of the roots beneath us.. for they follow the same principles of branching as the oak’s boughs… indeed, the same as lightning forks and river systems.

4/ The secret garden

Well here we are in a part of A la Ronde that is not seem by most visitors. For this is a little secret garden made by the wife of one of the previous National Trust curators of A la Ronde.

Page 15: The Parminter Cousins

And here you will see that the passion for patterns that so informs the house has been an inspiration here too.

I have no idea if there is any story or belief that informs these patterns – so I will leave you to enjoy them for a moment, and maybe find your own meanings …

(ALLOW PEOPLE A FEW MINUTES TO ENJOY THE GARDEN.)

….before we move on I want to point out to you a rather special space here that – for me – seems to float in the same way as the basilica of Saint Vitale:

It is this space here – (SHOW FORMER SPACE OF STUDIO) – where the curator’s wife had a sort of studio-cum-summer house. I saw it before it was knocked down. It was raised up on a sort of raised platform. And, for me, it still seems to hover there now.

For there are other things missing from the story.

Jane Parminter’s diary of the Grand Tour breaks off after only a few weeks, when the party reaches Dijon. Nothing of Ravenna and what it might have meant to the cousins, unfortunately.

But perhaps the most devastating disappearance is that of the Parminter family papers – papers which might have settled many of the mysteries about this place – “who really designed it?” and “what significance its patterns and symbols might have had for the cousins?”

Page 16: The Parminter Cousins

These papers were destroyed by German bombing during the second world war – along with the county records of generations of Devonians. Such records – now online – are used by the Mormon Church as information for services in which dead people who did not have the chance to convert to Mormonism in their lives, are offered the chance in the afterlife. They have already performed this service for many millions of people. But not for Devonians, who must now make up a good percentage of the occupants of Mormon hell.

5/ The feet of the statue

I’ve brought you to these stone feet – all that remains of a statue that was stolen some years ago – not a very significant loss, the statue was a fairly recent and relatively inexpensive (and not particularly appropriate) addition to the garden – but I’ve brought you here to think about walking. And feet.

Jane and Mary, though the longer parts of their Grand Tour were made by coach, would have made far more of the Tour on foot than modern tourists. And from what we have of Jane’s diary we know that they visited many sites in any one day.

So we have a walking tour. Visiting places many had visited before.

And we have my re-walking of a tour of a man planting acorns.

And then there is a different kind of walking – something we have heard a reference to in that mosaic in San Vitale

Page 17: The Parminter Cousins

portraying the miracle of Moses and the Burning Bush. In the story the bush is in flames and yet it does not burn, similar to the architectural illusion of weightlessness in the Basilica.

In the story Moses finds the Bush while tending sheep – bringing us back to the sheep here. God speaks to Moses through the Bush – talking first to Moses about his feet – he tells Moses to remove his sandals, for the place is holy. Nothing man-made must come between the man and the material of the place. And then God tells Moses about another holy place – he offers him a new land for his people, at that time enslaved and in exile in Egypt – and to Moses, God describes this new place as “a land flowing with milk and honey”.

At this point I was going to take from my case a jar of honey and offer you all a spoonful, and then a sip of milk. But as something equivalent I’ve brought you chocolates from Vienna.

(HAND ROUND CHOCOLATES)

So we have another kind of journey – an exodus. Which is both an escape. And a journey to a place we have already been told about.

But rather than learning from a guidebook about somewhere to be visited, this is hearing from God about a place to live forever.

And in some ways, it is possible, “possible” you hear, that this journey – this exodus – is the most significant, “significant” you see, in the design of this house.

Page 18: The Parminter Cousins

So let’s make our own little Exodus – and escape from the house and the gardens – and heading for the Promised Land of our own story – somewhere beyond the hot desert of Summer Lane is Point In View. And when we get there we can maybe find out what is the Point of all this, and why it is In View.

But before we leave on our Exodus, just take a view back to the obelisk – a recent replacement (and re-siting) of an obelisk placed by the Parminters here in the garden. Obelisks seemed to first appear in ancient Egyptian architecture – though I don’t remember any on the waste dump pyramid in Vienna – they symbolised the sun god Ra – and, interestingly, it is possible – “possible”! – that the Pharoah from whose slavery Moses led the Jews was the reforming Pharaoh Akhenaton – who was said to be a petrified ray of the Aten, the sundisc. Of course, what unites Akhenaton and Moses is that both of them sought to convert their people to belief in a single god, rather than many. And how significant it is that the symbol of unity at St Vitale and in the heart of the building here – is a kind of an Aten, a sundisc, I am not sufficiently qualified to say.

But we should notice this – A la Ronde is designed so that the cousins could rise in the morning with the sun streaming into their bedrooms and then follow that sun from room to room, round the house, until it set as they ate in the dining room.

O, and then finally, before we leave look over there where we began. Remember how we stood there some forty minutes ago – can you see our forty minute ghosts? Can you see what tiny changes have already happened to us in that short time? What changes there have been between us?

Page 19: The Parminter Cousins

I say this – because if the guidebooks are right and this house and gardens are inspired by Saint Vitale then it is intended as a generator for changing people.

OK, let us go on our miniature Exodus around the remains of the perimeter walk, walking in the footsteps of Jane and Mary Parminter. Then up Summer Lane and to the Point-In –View.

6/ The Plinth.

I’m afraid I haven’t been able to decipher what appears to be an inscription on this plinth.

So, perhaps you would like to suggest who it would be good to put up a to statue in these gardens?

(LISTEN TO SUGGESTIONS.)

And would you like to model the pose that you would like them take?

(VOLUNTEERS TO MODEL POSES.)

On the Exodus from Egypt, while Moses was on Mount Sinai receiving the tablets of the ten Commandments from God, the Jews constructed a calf from gold and began to worship it – we should be careful about making too much of that “gold” – the calf was a holy animal of El, the god of the local people whose country the Jews were passing through. So this was an alternative religion, rather than wealth, being worshipped.

Page 20: The Parminter Cousins

So maybe we could think of any of our idols – perhaps ones that attract us, maybe ones we have got from other people, but who we are not supposed to worship?

Are there any forbidden idols you would like to put up there on the plinth?

(ACT OUT.)

Well, now I should play Moses and tell you all off and burn your idol and crush it into powder and mix it on water and force you to dink it… but I think we’ll just keep going – heading for the desert of Summer Lane. Just before we go – so we can reach the climax of our story – literally the climax to all our stories – maybe I should tell you one last tale from my own Grand Tour – because it involves a statue. Preparing for one of my walks in Naples and looking up I suddenly realised that I was looking straight into the eyes of the great Neapolitan philosopher Giambattista Vico- who died 50 years before the Parminters began their Grand Tour – although they visited Naples at a time when the memory and influence of Vico would still have been very strong.

Vico had a theory for the beginning of civilisation – and it all began in a great forest that covered the earth – blocking out the sun disc – the Aten – after the great Flood that was escaped by Noah.

I don’t have time to tell you the whole of Vico’s imaginary history of everything, but we will come back to that flood in a minute.

But let’s go now – keep your eyes peeled for the re-emerging of symmetry.

Page 21: The Parminter Cousins

7/ The View

Well here we are – the whole complex around us here – the chapel that we’ll visit in a moment and the little dwellings places around – and the manse over there – this complex was called Point In View – and clearly there is a Point that is In View.

And there it is, the remnants of a 300 million year old desert – the sandy outcrop of Langstone Rock.

(TAKE SOME SAND FROM A CASE.)

And here is some sand from the beach on the bay of Naples – the bay which the Parminter cousins are reported to have said was recalled to them by seeing the very sight you are seeing now.

Sand – along with seaweed, and the shells and feathers – is a key ingredient in the cousins’ decoration of A la Ronde.

For we may be looking at a view which has not changed much from the Parminters’ day, but – thanks to global warming, may be about to change profoundly.

A new flood may be coming.

And is that what the cousins believed too – remember all those shells in the house? Were they imaging it underwater? A world once more underwater? Remember the seaweed in the house?

Page 22: The Parminter Cousins

And that key central room – look at this wallpaper (SHOW PHOTO OF WALLPAPER IN THE CENTRAL ROOM) first installed during the cousins’ time – does it represent, as the official guidebook suggests, an undersea cave covered in seaweed and lit from the shell grotto above?

And what of that dove and olive branch? Isn’t that the dove that brings exactly this evidence of dry land and trees to Noah while at sea in his ark? Trees, that according to Vico, will grow into a huge forest, blotting out the Aten, the sun disc, and destroying the unity of humanity, reducing people to lonely wanderers?

So what flood did the Parminters think was coming?

Perhaps a social flood?

The King Louis and the Marie Antoniette, whom they had observed from a distance in France, had been swept away by revolution. They might have known of Nancy Perriam from Exmouth, a woman who fought in some of the major sea battles against the revolutionary French and who, unlike most of the invisible women of the navy became well known. They would have seen the French prisoners of the war marched along the lanes.

Was it time to prepare for the end of their world?

Surely is too wild and exotic for two spinster cousins, often described in the guidebooks as “eccentric” – but we should beware of stamping them with our own stereotype. In Jane’s diary – that part of it we have – it is the bizarre and exotic that seems to have appealed: the cabinets of curiosities, the rhinoceros and pelicans… and an interesting sensibility, for

Page 23: The Parminter Cousins

while writing appreciatively of formal French gardens, with fountains and cascades, she expresses her preference of a natural landscape… and it is this combination of the natural and the abstract we find in all that the Parminters do.

8/ The Point

Well let’s have a look at the buildings over here – called “Point In View” by the Parminter cousins.

Now, I’ve suggested that the house of A la Ronde might possibly signify a kind of story: that its natural components – sand, seaweed, feathers and shells – and its symmetrical shapes – of octagon and disc – and its orientation to the rise and fall of the sun – that these point to a story of a people – the Old Testament Jews - - portrayed in the mosaics of Ravenna as without a land, and in Jane and Mary Parminters’ time equally in exile.

The cousins – inspired by that image of unity at Ravenna, of the city of Jews and the city of Christians united in a single disc – create here a machine, an architectural, symbolic machine for bringing that into being.

For The Point – which the cousins believed was swinging into “View” – was shortly to come about – and that was the conversion of the Jews to Christianity and their return to a Christian Israel.

Indeed, Ravenna may be even more significant – and sinister – for that figure of Emperor Justinian in the mosaic in the cathedral – it was Justinian who passed the infamous Novella

Page 24: The Parminter Cousins

146 laws, granting Jews the right to read their scriptures, but sentenced to death any Jew found denying the Resurrection or the Coming Judgement. So Ravenna, and perhaps here, celebrates conversion by force.

And these buildings before us, which are like a shell around that small chapel in the centre, were specifically created to house Jewish widows who had converted to Christianity. And for the Christian education of their children… this complex is a generator, a practical thing, for bringing about the final days. The end times.

Now remember these “significances” are only one “possible” interpretation.

And you should ask yourself how much you should accept from me, dressed in this cream suit and shades, looking like a third hand Jonathan Meades?

But, if I’m right, then the Parminters were no alone – for in 1809 a group of prominent of Christians – including William Wilberforce – set up the Anglican Church’s Ministry Among Jewish people. Lewis Way gave huge amounts of money – as a result of the oak trees here – to the London Society For Promoting Christianity Amongst the Jews.

But money does not always talk. And for all the pamphlets and missions conversions were few, rarely significant and sometimes fraudulent.

For a moment, let’s got into the Chapel remembering the text which once used to decorate the door here:

“O Israel, Though Shalt Not Be Forgotten By Me”

Page 25: The Parminter Cousins

But mostly to look at the memorial stone to Jane Parminter, presumably arranged by Mary - for both cousins are buried under the organ in here.

(INTO THE CHAPEL. AT THE MEMORIAL. READS THE INSCRIPTION.)

“Here sleep, no noise shall break thy restTill the last trump proclaim thee wholly blest, Then shall thy former partner claim each dust…”

Does this suggest that Mary expected “the last trump” to be sounded in her lifetime?

“And join in one made perfect join the just.”

And so it is with an image of unity to come that we end.

A unity of what has yet to come. And possibly – only “possibly” – part of a set of images and ideas, which two highly motivated, sophisticated, hard-travelling, hard working, voraciously interested, intelligent and acquisitive cousins MAY have patterned into this complex of house, gardens, chapel, manse, school, almshouse and vista.

Thank you.

Let’s return now to A la Ronde.