The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical Seminar on Innovative Particle and Radiation Detectors (...

35
The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical Seminar on Innovative Particle and Radiation Detectors (IPRD10) 7-10 June 2010, Siena, Italy Jonas Knüsel Albert Einstein Center for Fundamental Physics Laboratory for High Energy Physics University of Berne On behalf of the OPERA collaboration 1 [email protected]

description

The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical Seminar on Innovative Particle and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10 June 2010, Siena, Italy Jonas Knüsel Albert Einstein Center for Fundamental Physics Laboratory for High Energy Physics University of Berne - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Transcript of The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical Seminar on Innovative Particle and Radiation Detectors (...

Page 1: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected]

The OPERA Experiment 12th Topical Seminar on Innovative Particle and Radiation Detectors

(IPRD10)

7-10 June 2010, Siena, Italy

Jonas Knüsel

Albert Einstein Center for Fundamental PhysicsLaboratory for High Energy Physics

University of BerneOn behalf of the OPERA collaboration

Page 2: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected]

The Photographic Emulsion Technology of the OPERA Experiment on its Way to

Find the → Oscillation

OPERAOscillation Project with Emulsion tRacking Apparatus

Page 3: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 3

JINST 4 (2009) P06020

New Journal of Physics (2006) 303a

JINST 4 (2009) P06020

• Introduction

• The OPERA experiment

• The nuclear emulsion technology

• On the way to find the → oscillation

• Conclusion

Page 4: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

4

IntroductionThe OPERA collaboration

LAPP AnnecyIPNL LyonIPHC Strasbourg

INR, LPI, ITEP, SINP MoscowJINR Dubna

IRB Zagreb

BariBologna L’AquilaLNF FrascatiLNGSNapoliPadovaRomaSalerno

BernETH Zurich

ULB Brussels HamburgMünsterRostock

AichiTohoKobeNagoyaUtsunomiya

Technion HaifaMETU Ankara

Jinju

• 33 Institutions

• ~200 physicist

Page 5: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 5

IntroductionPhysics motivation

• Neutrinos as fundamental particles of the SM• Flavour vs. Mass Eigenstates:

– Mixing – Oscillation!

• Oscillation parameters: θ and ∆m2, available in experiment: L, E• Detection of Tau Neutrino from an oscillated muon neutrino via

the tau decay kink.– High target mass to compensate low neutrino cross

section: use LEAD– High granularity and resolution to see the tau kink:

use PHOTGRAPHIC EMULSIONS• Prove neutrino oscillation by observing the Tau appearance.

Page 6: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 6

IntroductionPrinciple of topological detection

Topology Selection

τ-ν

μ, e, h, 3h

h

h

cτ = 87 micron

Tau decay kinkAlso other topologies, according to decay:

ντ

ντ

Page 7: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 7

<Eνm> 17 GeV

L 730 km(νe+νe)/νm CC 0.87%

νm/νm CC 2.1%

ντ prompt negligible

The OPERA experimentFrom CERN to Gran Sasso

CERN

LNGS

730 km

Expected number of interactions in 5 years running:

~23600 νm CC + NC~205 νe + νe CC

~115 ντ CC (Dm2=2.5 x 10-3 eV2)

~ 10 tau decays are expected to be observed, with less than 1

background event

Page 8: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

8

The OPERA experimentThe OPERA detector

Dimension of the detector: 20m x 10m x 10m

Page 9: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 9

The OPERA experimentThe OPERA detector

Brick Wall and Brick Manipulation system.bricks

scintillator

Page 10: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 10

The OPERA experimentThe OPERA basic unit: the „brick“

125mm

100mm

75.4mm

8.3kg10X0

Neutrino

Beam

OPERA emulsion film

Lead plate : 1mm

The Emulsion Cloud Chamber (ECC)

• The OPERA emulsion film plays the main role in this experiment.• These emulsion films are scanned by automatic optical microscopes.• > 200000 m2 of emulsion surface in OPERA

57 emulsion per brick

CSd

Page 11: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 11

The OPERA experimentThe scanning systems

• Scanning speed/system: 75cm2/h• High speed CCD camera (3 kHz) , Piezo-

controlled objective lens• FPGA Hard-coded algorithms• Japan overall capacity: ~ 200 cm2/h

• Scanning speed/system: 20cm2/h • Customized commercial optics and

mechanics• Asynchronous DAQ software• EU overall capacity: ~ 200 cm2/h

JapanEurope

ESS: (European Scanning System) SUTS (Super Ultra Track Selector)

Page 12: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 12

The OPERA experimentThe scanning procedure

1257565554535251504948…21

CSd Scanback• Track follow-up film by film:

• Alignment using cosmic ray tracks

• Definition of the stopping point

Volume-Scan• Volume scanning (2-3 cm2)

around the stopping point

Page 13: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 13

The OPERA experimentThe scanning analysis

JINST 4 (2009) P04018

Different steps of the emulsion data processing

• All base-tracks in the 11 films• Long tracks for the alignment• Tracks belonging to the

vertex≈ 2 mm

Position residuals for the position alignment

Page 14: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 14

The OPERA experimentFrom the m to the mm scale

• Detector• Muon Spectrometer

O (m)

Page 15: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 15

The OPERA experimentFrom the m to the mm scale

• Target Tracker

O (m)O (cm)

Page 16: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 16

The OPERA experimentFrom the m to the mm scale

• The ECC brick

O (m)O (cm)

extraction

Page 17: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 17

The OPERA experimentFrom the m to the mm scale

• The Changeable Sheet (CS)

O (m)O (cm)O (mm)

JINST 3 (2008) P07005

CS:2 emulsion film

located on the brick

Page 18: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 18

The OPERA experimentFrom the m to the mm scale

O (m)O (cm)O (mm)

emulsion film doublets

• CS confirmes prediction by electronic detectors.• Move from cm-range (electronic detector) to mm-range• Bricks are only developed after CS confirmes prediction

Page 19: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 19

The OPERA experimentFrom the m to the mm scale

O (m)O (cm)O (mm)O (mm)

• The emulsion

This is the main part of the OPERA experiment. The essentiall stuff happens here. Vertex finding and topology classification.

1 cm

1 cm

Page 20: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 20

The nuclear emulsion technologyRenaissance

The central part of OPERA happens in emulsion films:• AgBr Crystal, size ~ 0.2 microns• Semiconductor detector technique, band gap ~ 2.6eV• Signal amplified by developing the photographic films.• After developing the „silver grains“ are read out by optical

microscopes

Plastic Base (205micron)

Emulsion Layer

Emulsion Layer (44micron)

Page 21: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 21

The nuclear emulsion technologySub micron resolution 3D tracking

50 micron

Microscopic Image

Recorded as silver grains along the line particle passed through

Resolution of 0.3 micron

cτ of tau:~87 microns

Page 22: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 22

The nuclear emulsion technologyMicroscope images

JINST 4 (2009) 6020

Nuclear emulsion image as seen by the microscope

Peculiar event: neutrino interaction occured inside the emulsion layer

Page 23: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 23

On the way to find the νm→ ντ oscillationFirst OPERA run 2006

• Only electronic detectors, at that time:• No bricks in target, then.

Cosmic muon induced background

Muons from CNGS beam.Angle w.r.t. earth curvature: 3.4 degree.

New Journal of Physics 8 (2006) 303

✔ Neutrino beam✔ Electronic detector

Page 24: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

24

On the way to find the νm→ ντ oscillationνm CC interaction

muon primary vertex 4 tracks with IP < 2 mm

secondary vertex 2 tracks with IP < 4 mm

2.2 cm

7 mm

Page 25: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

25

y

On the way to find the νm→ ντ oscillationνm CC interaction

muon primary vertex 4 tracks with IP < 2 mm

6 Gammas reconstructed4 Gammas from 1ry vtx2 Gammas from 2ry vtx

secondary vertex 2 tracks with IP < 4 mm

2.2 cm

7 mm

Page 26: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 26

On the way to find the νm→ ντ oscillationCharm candidates

• Thetakink: 0.204 rad• Pdaughter: 3.9 (+1.7 -0.9) GeV• PT: 800 MeV

• Flight length: 3247.2 μm • 2 EM-showers point to

vertex

Charm topology analogous to tau (similar lifetime): reference sample for the decay finding efficiency

Page 27: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 27

On the way to find the νm→ ντ oscillationCharm candidates

Event in Europe (D0 4 prong) Event in Japan (kink)

Topology Kink Vee Trident 4Vee

Observed events 5+2N1 5 1+N3 1

Page 28: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 28

On the way to find the νm→ ντ oscillationνe interaction

6 νe interactions found in a subsample of 690 CC located interaction (expected are about 6)

Page 29: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 29

On the way to find the νm→ ντ oscillationsearch for τ

• Search for ντ is ongoing

• Systematic decay studies are performed for all interactions

• About 2 τ are expected from 2008-2009 run

Channel Signal Backgroundτ → m 2.9 0.17τ → e 3.5 0.17τ → h 3.1 0.24τ → 3h 0.9 0.17Total 10.4 0.75

Page 30: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 30

On the way to find the νm→ ντ oscillationwork in progress...

• CNGS run 2010 is going well (started on April 20th 2010)

• Continuous extraction of bricks from triggered events

• About 100 bricks / week are extracted, developed and sent to the labs

• Systematic decay search studies are performed to find all possible decay topologies.

Page 31: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 31

Conclusion

• OPERA, the largest nuclear emulsion experiment is successfully taking data.

• OPERA has collected for 5.3E19 pot in 2008 and 2009.

• The full chain of events handling/analysis is proven.

• Electronic detector performance is reliable and well understood.

• Several charm events are found as expected.

• The first τ event is close...

Page 33: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 33

Additional Information2008 run status (May 5th, 2010)

0mu 1mu All

Events predicted by the electronic detector 406 1292 1698

Found in CS 276 1056 1332

Neutrino interactions in the bricks 155 798 953

Located in dead material 8 40 48

Interaction in the upstream brick 6 35 41

Decay search completed 130 673 803

• Decay search completed for 84.3% of the sample

• 22 observed charm candidates

Page 34: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 34

• Decay search completed for 42.1% of the located event sample• 4 observed charm candidates

0mu 1mu All

Events predicted by the electronic detector 1097 2460 3557

Events with at least 1 brick extracted 1050 2389 3439

CS scanned 826 2143 2969Found in CS 447 1418 1865Neutrino interactions in the bricks 112 550 662Located in dead material 3 15 18Interactions in the upstream brick 4 50 54Decay search completed 53 226 279

Additional Information2009 run status (May 5th, 2010)

Page 35: The OPERA Experiment 12 th Topical  Seminar on Innovative  Particle  and Radiation Detectors ( IPRD10) 7-10  June  2010, Siena,  Italy Jonas  Knüsel

[email protected] 35

Additional InformationDecay search – detect kink topology