THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY What You Dont Know CAN Hurt You Karen L. Hawkins,...

25
THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY What You Don’t Know CAN Hurt You Karen L. Hawkins, Director

Transcript of THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY What You Dont Know CAN Hurt You Karen L. Hawkins,...

Page 1: THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY What You Dont Know CAN Hurt You Karen L. Hawkins, Director.

THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY

What You Don’t Know CAN Hurt You

Karen L. Hawkins, Director

Page 2: THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY What You Dont Know CAN Hurt You Karen L. Hawkins, Director.

The Statute & Regulations

• 31 U.S.C. §330 (1884)• 31 C.F.R. Part 10 (cir. 1886) • Authorizes regulation of

representatives of persons before the Department of the Treasury

Page2

Page 3: THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY What You Dont Know CAN Hurt You Karen L. Hawkins, Director.

“Fitness” to Practice• good character • good reputation • necessary qualifications to enable

the representative to provide valuable service to the client

• competency to advise and assist persons in presenting their cases

Page3

Page 4: THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY What You Dont Know CAN Hurt You Karen L. Hawkins, Director.

Finding It

• Online at www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/pcir230.pdf

• Substantial revisions effective August 2, 2011

• NPRM – Additional Revisions Proposed – Final Regs pending

Page4

Page 5: THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY What You Dont Know CAN Hurt You Karen L. Hawkins, Director.

Calendar Year 2012 Discipline Results

Activity Attorney CPA EA Unenrolled Totals

• Total Receipts 516

• Disbarments (FAD/Consent) - 1 - 1 2• Suspensions (FAD/Consent) 2 2 3 - 7• Expedited Suspensions 29 25 7 - 61• DDA/Other Conditions - 1 2 - 3• Censure 1 2 1 - 4• Reprimands/Soft Letter 150• Cease & Desists 50• CWOS, LOJ , NCOA, CWOA 409 • Reinstatements 25

• Total Dispositions 813

Page5

Page 6: THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY What You Dont Know CAN Hurt You Karen L. Hawkins, Director.

Calendar Year 2013Discipline Results Through Q3

Activity Attorney CPA EA RTRP Unenrolled Totals

• Total Receipts 631• Disbarments (FAD/Consent) - 4 2 - - 6• Suspensions (FAD/Consent) 1 1 1 - - 3• Expedited Suspensions 13 24 4 - 1 42• DDA/Other Conditions 2 4 5 - 1 12• Censure - 2 - 1 - 3• Reprimands/Soft Letters 117• Cease & Desist Letters 22• CWOS, LOJ, CWOA, etc. 470• Reinstatements 11

• Total Dispositions 701

Page 7: THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY What You Dont Know CAN Hurt You Karen L. Hawkins, Director.

JURISDICTION

• 31 USC 330(a)(1); (b); (c); (d)• 10.2(a)(4)• 10.7(c)• 10.8(a)• 10.8(c) (Notice 2011-6)• 10.50(b)/10.60(b)

Page7

Page 8: THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY What You Dont Know CAN Hurt You Karen L. Hawkins, Director.

Key Circular 230 Provisions• Diligence as to Accuracy (10.22)• Due Diligence Standards – Returns/Docs

(10.34)• Competence (Proposed 10.35)• Requirements for Written Advice

(Proposed 10.37)• Ensuring Compliance (Proposed 10.36)• Oral or Written Opinions (10.51(a)(13))

Page8

Page 9: THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY What You Dont Know CAN Hurt You Karen L. Hawkins, Director.

Diligence as to Accuracy (10.22)

• Must exercise Due Diligence in:– Preparing, approving and filing tax

returns, documents, affidavits etc. relating to IRS matters.

– Determining correctness of oral/written representations made to the client or to Treasury personnel.

• Reliance on Another’s Work Product? With Reasonable Care.

Page9

Page 10: THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY What You Dont Know CAN Hurt You Karen L. Hawkins, Director.

Standards for Tax Returns Section 10.34(a)• May not sign a tax return or advise a

position on a tax return, willfully, recklessly, or through gross incompetence if:– Lacks reasonable basis– Unreasonable position (6694(a)(2))–Willful attempt to understate liability

(6694(b)(2)(A))– Reckless, intentional disregard of rules

and regulations (6694(b)(2)(B))• Patterns matter

Page10

Page 11: THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY What You Dont Know CAN Hurt You Karen L. Hawkins, Director.

Standards for Documents and Other Papers- 10.34(b)

• May not advise Taking Positions in Documents that are Frivolous.

• May not advise Making Submissions:– to Delay or Impede Tax

Administration– that are Frivolous–Containing or Omitting Information

that demonstrates an intentional disregard of rules or regulations.

Page11

Page 12: THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY What You Dont Know CAN Hurt You Karen L. Hawkins, Director.

Disclosure re: Unreasonable Positions (10.34(c))

• Advised position?• Prepared or signed return?• Submitting docs/other papers to IRS?• Then-–Must Advise Client of Potential

Penalties and their Avoidance through Disclosure

• Applicable even if no Practitioner Penalty Exposure

Page12

Page 13: THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY What You Dont Know CAN Hurt You Karen L. Hawkins, Director.

Reliance on Client Data- 10.34(d)• Reliance on Client Information in

good faith, without verification, is OK, but…–Cannot ignore implications of other

information furnished –Cannot ignore actual knowledge–Must make reasonable inquiries for

incorrect, inconsistent or incomplete information

• No Willful Blindness• No Don’t Ask Don’t Tell

Page13

Page 14: THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY What You Dont Know CAN Hurt You Karen L. Hawkins, Director.

Proposed §10.35.

• A practitioner must possess the necessary competence to engage in practice before the Internal Revenue Service.

• Competent practice requires the knowledge, skill, thoroughness, and preparation necessary for the matter for which the practitioner is engaged.

• See ABA Model Rule 1.1, “Competence”• AICPA Code of Professional Conduct

Article V, “Due Care”.

Page14

Page 15: THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY What You Dont Know CAN Hurt You Karen L. Hawkins, Director.

Proposed Section 10.36• Any practitioner who has (or practitioners who have or

share) principal authority and responsibility for overseeing a firm’s practice governed by this part must take reasonable steps to ensure that the firm has adequate procedures in effect for all members, associates, and employees for purposes of complying with Circular 230. Any practitioner who has (or practitioners who have or share) this principal authority will be subject to discipline for failing to comply with the requirements of this Section.

Page15

Page 16: THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY What You Dont Know CAN Hurt You Karen L. Hawkins, Director.

Prop. §10.37 Requirements For Written Advice

• Reasonable factual and legal assumptions • Reasonably consider all relevant facts • Reasonable efforts to identify and ascertain

the relevant facts• Not rely upon representations, statements,

findings, or agreements if reliance would be unreasonable

• No audit lottery advice (“odds” for an audit, or that a matter will not be raised on audit).

Page16

Page 17: THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY What You Dont Know CAN Hurt You Karen L. Hawkins, Director.

Prop. 10.37 (cont)

• Reliance on taxpayer is unreasonable if the practitioner knows or should know that one or more representations, or assumptions on which any representation is based, are incorrect, inconsistent or incomplete

• May only rely on the advice of another practitioner if the advice was reasonable and the reliance is in good faith considering all the facts and circumstances .

• May not rely on another practitioner who has a conflict (ref. 10.29); or is incompetent

Page17

Page 18: THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY What You Dont Know CAN Hurt You Karen L. Hawkins, Director.

Oral or Written Opinions – 10.51(a)(13)

• It is Disreputable/Incompetent Conduct to Give:–False opinions-knowingly, recklessly, through gross incompetence; –Intentional or recklessly Misleading Opinions;–Pattern of Incompetent Opinions

Page18

Page 19: THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY What You Dont Know CAN Hurt You Karen L. Hawkins, Director.

10.51(a)(13) (cont)

• False Opinion =–knowing misstatements of fact/law;–assertion of unwarranted positions;–Counseling/assisting conduct known

to be illegal/fraudulent;–concealing matters required by law to

be revealed.

Page19

Page 20: THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY What You Dont Know CAN Hurt You Karen L. Hawkins, Director.

10.51(a)(13) (cont)

• Reckless conduct=– highly unreasonable

omission/misrepresentation involving extreme departure from standards of ordinary care that a practitioner should observe under the circumstances

• Gross Incompetence=– gross indifference, grossly inadequate

preparation, consistent failure to perform obligations to client

• Patterns matter Page20

Page 22: THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY What You Dont Know CAN Hurt You Karen L. Hawkins, Director.

Recent/Relevant Cases• Bohn: http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-utl/Morton

%20Bohn%20SJ%20Order%20-FINAL%20Redacted.pdf

• Gee: http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-utl/opr-_edgar_h__gee_jr__-_final_order.pdf

• Christensen: http://www.irs.gov/file_source/pub/irs-utl/Redacted%20Final%20Order%20Assessing%20Sanction%20-%20IRS%20Christenson.pdf

Page22

Page 23: THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY What You Dont Know CAN Hurt You Karen L. Hawkins, Director.

Recent/Relevant News

• Attorney Censured by the OPR for Mishandling Conflicts of Interest: http://www.irs.gov/file_source/PUP/taxpros/agents/Atty%20Censured%20by%20OPR%20for%20Mishandling%20Conflicts%20of%20Interests.pdf

• Refund Splitting: http://www.irs.gov/file_source/pub/irs-utl/OPR%20Targeting%20Preparers%20Compensated%20Through%20Shared%20Refunds.pdf

Page23

Page 24: THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY What You Dont Know CAN Hurt You Karen L. Hawkins, Director.

Proposed Revisions• 10.1 (OPR Authority)• 10.31 (Electronic refunds)• 10.35 (rescission of covered opinion reg)• 10.35 (competence)• 10.36 (Respondeat Superior)• 10.37 (All Written Tax Advice)• 10.39 (rescission re: Bond Practice)• 10.82 (compliance & procedure)

Page24

Page 25: THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY What You Dont Know CAN Hurt You Karen L. Hawkins, Director.

More Info?• Office of Professional Responsibility

1111 Constitution Ave. N.W.SE:OPR Rm. 7238 Washington, D.C. 20224

• Information on OPR, Circular 230 and Discipline visit:http://www.irs.gov/Tax-Professionals/Circular-230-Tax-Professionals

Page25