The LEXICON - Taylor's Law School's Legal Newsletter (2013)

7/29/2019 The LEXICON - Taylor's Law School's Legal Newsletter (2013)

1/40


2/40


3/40

]dn Enxafhi |6

_lyaig tdn êtabltn _rafnjy Whig Dn Cl

Lebhst nvnryhin snns at lt hin tabn hr lihtdnr

hi tdnar clvhuratn frabn-tdnbnm tnenvasahi sdhw; tdn

burmnrnr hc l vaftab as chuim tdrhugd hvnrwdnebaig

chrnisaf nvamnifn. ]dn burmnrnr as flugdt lim tdni

snit tdrhugd l sdhrt fhurt prhfnss ai wdafd dn hr sdn as

muey fhivaftnm chr das hr dnr frabns. L cnw mlys eltnr,

tdn burmnrnr as prhbptey wle`nm tdrhugd l mlr`, ilrrhw

fhrramhr lctnr wdafd dn hr sdn as snit swaigaig tdrhugd

l trlpmhhr hr lmbaiastnrnm l entdle fhf`tlae hc mrugs, ls

l kust lim swact rnlftahi th tdn dnaihus frabn

fhbbattnm. ]dn elw as prhpnrey snrvnm lim nvnryhineavns dlppaey nvnr lctnr, ìhwaig tdlt tdnsn uiwlitnm

lspnfts hc shfanty lrn gavni tdn trnltbnit tdny mnsnrvn.

Dhwnvnr, as tdas rhsy ablgn hc tdn mnltd pnilety

tdlt Dheeywhhm phrtrlys chr hur vanwaig penlsurn wdlt

rnleey ghns hi ai li lftule mnltd pnilety flsn8 Wdlt

ljhut tdn prhfnssns ai jntwnni tdn trale, hr trales8 ]dn

rnm tlpn lim jurnlufrlfy innmnm th snitnifn

shbnhin th mnltd8 Wdlt ljhut eacn hi mnltd rhw8 Dls

liyhin fhisamnrnm tdn fhsts tdlt fhurts lim prashi

systnbs aifur th flrry hut tdnsn prhfnssns8

]dnsn prnssaig qunstahis innm th jn liswnrnm

jnchrn l rnle, clft-jlsnm uimnrstlimaig hc tdn mnltd

pnilety fli jn lfdanvnm.

]dnrn lrn snvnrle fhuitrans tdlt staee rntlai tdn

mnltd pnilety, mnspatn l îatnm Iltahis Gninrle

Lssnbjey Znsheutahi nifhurlgaig tdnsn fhuitrans th

abpenbnit l bhrlthraub hi lee mnltd snitnifns.< ]dn

mnltd pnilety as usnm ai tdnsn fhuitrans chr bliy

maccnrnit frabns, lee eastnm uimnrtdn mncaiatahi hc flpatle frabns.

]dnsn flpatle frabns fhbn ai

bliy chrbs, rligaig crhb burmnr

lim mrug trlccafàig, th rneagahus

jelspdnby lim trnlshi.:

Dhwnvnr, tdn mnltd

pniletys nccnftavninss ls l

mntnrrnit lglaist tdnsn frabns as

lrguljen, lim sh as tdn qunstahi hc wdntdnr tdhsn

cailifaig tdn mnltd pnilety tdn tlxplynrs lrn gnttaigtdnar bhinys whrtd aivnstaig ai at th prnvnit frabns.

]das lrtafen stravns th nxpelai tdn cailifale lspnfts hc tdn

mnltd pnilety.

Mun th tdn fhbpeafltnm prhfnmurns tdlt l

frabaile dls th gh tdrhugd ai l engle systnb jnchrn tdn

mnltd snitnifn as lmbaiastnrnm, tdn nfhihbaf fhst hc

abpenbnitaig tdn mnltd pnilety as stlggnraig.

Lffhrmaig th tdn Mnltd _nilety Aichrbltahi Fnitnr,

stltn mnplrtbnits ai tdn îatnm Vtltns ply up th

$ Ehhàig curtdnr mhwi tdn prhfnmurn,

stltastafs crhb stltn Kumafale Mnplrtbnits ai tdn îatnm

Vtltns sdhw tdlt hiey hin hut hc nvnry tni mnltd

snitnifns plssnm nvnituleey rnsuets ai li nxnfutahi,

curtdnr jraigaig up tdn thtle trun fhsts th lrhuim

$6?,???,??? pnr nxnfutahi.3

Watd tdas ai baim, at as abphrtlit th uimnrstlimtdlt at as iht tdn dagd fhst hc nxnfutaig shbnhin tdlt

bl`ns tdn mnltd pnilety nxpnisavn, hr tdlt hin

suffnsscue flsn hi ats hwi infnssatltns tnis hc

baeeahis hc mheelrs. At as jnflusn bhst flpatle

prhsnfutahis invnr rnsuet ai l mnltd snitnifn, lim

bhst mnltd snitnifns mh iht nvni rnsuet ai li

nxnfutahi. ]dn lft hc mrlggaig l frabaile th fhurt watd

tdn aitnit th selp hi l mnltd pnilety fdlrgn lehin

abbnmaltney nsfleltns tdn fhsts rnquarnm th abphsn l

snitnifn.

Dhw as at tdlt snimaig l

frabaile th tdn gleehws fli fhst

sh bufd8 Ai praifapen, at as mun th

hin tdaig hiey; snimaig l pnrshi

th mnltd as maccnrnit crhb snimaig

l pnrshi th prashi.

Ai hrmnr th caim hut nxlftey

wdlt tdhsn maccnrnifns lrn, wn

innm th ehh` lt tdn stnps tl`ni jy tdn cnmnrle fhurts hc

tdn îatnm Vtltns. Ai nvnry wly, l flpatle flsn as bhrntabn-fhisubaig lim nxpnisavn tdli l flsn aivhevaig li

]dn mnltd pniletys

nccnftavninss as lrguljen, lim

sh as tdn qunstahi hc wdntdnr

tdn tlxplynrs lrn gnttaig tdnar

bhinys whrtd aivnstaig ai at th

prnvnit frabns.


4/40

_lyaig tdn ^etabltn _rafn | Cnlturn

= | ]dn Enxafhi

hrmailry prashi snitnifn. Ac tdn mncnimlit ai l flpatle

flsn as chuim guaety hc l flpatle hccnifn, l fhbpentney

maccnrnit trale as innmnm, watd inw watinssns lim

nvamnifn, ai wdafd tdn kury bust mnfamn wdntdnr tdn

pnilety chr tdn hccnifn sdhuem jn tdn mnltd pnilety hr

eacn abprashibnit watdhut tdn fdlifn hc plrhen.7 Watd

tdas, twh ltthrinys whuem dlvn th jn lpphaitnm chr tdnmncnifn hc tdn frabaile fdlrgns lim snitnifaig

rnspnftavney.4 ]dn prhsnfuthrs whuem lesh dlvn th nxnrt

grnltnr rnshurfns ai tdas flsn ls

tdny dlvn th masfdlrgn l vnry dagd

jurmni hc prhhc jnchrn tdn mnltd

pnilety fli jn snfurnm.1

Wdni fhbplrnm th l eacn

abprashibnit snitnifn, l mnltd

snitnifn innms spnfaleasnm nxpnrts th lssnss nvnry

lspnft hc tdn flsn, crhb chrnisaf hccafnrs wdh nxlbainnvamnifn lt tdn sfnin hc tdn frabn th psyfdaltrasts wdh

lssnss tdn bnitle stltn hc tdn mncnimlit ls pnr

rnquarnbnits th abphsn tdn mnltd pnilety.


5/40

Cnlturn | _lyaig tdn êtabltn _rafn

]dn Enxafhi |>

`npt uimnr straft wltfd lt lee tabns. ]das bnlis tdlt at

tl`ns l sujstlitale lbhuit hc cuims th dhusn kust hin

aibltn uimnr blxabub snfuraty. Ai tdn stltn hc

Fleachrial, at as nstabltnm tdlt at fhsts tdn stltn li nxtrl

$1?,??? pnr ynlr chr nlfd aibltn hi

mnltd rhw fhbplrnm th hin tdlt as

dhusnm ai tdn gninrle prashiphpueltahi.:7

Eacn ai l rnguelr prashi hi tdn

htdnr dlim, whuem bnli tdlt tdn

aibltn as iht ehf`nm up ai l prashi fnee bhst hc tdn mly,

jut as aistnlm blmn th mh lftavatans tdlt lrn mnnbnm

jnincafale th shfanty, sufd ls fhbbuiaty snrvafn, hr

vhfltahile whr` ea`n frlctsblisdap lim rnplar whr`.

]dnsn snrvafns th shfanty fli nvni sujsamasn tdn fhsts

innmnm th dhusn tdn aibltns, ls tdnsn lftavatans fli

jraig l sub hc bhiny th tdn stltn fhccnrs. ]dnsnlftavatans lesh hccnr tdn aibltn l fdlifn th rndljaeatltn

lim rnpnit chr tdn frabn mhin, lim th gavn jlf` th

shfanty.

Lesh bnitahinm ai tdn jngaiiaig plrlgrlpds as

tdn clft tdlt iht lee mnltd snitnifns rnsuet ai li lftule

nxnfutahi. ]dnrn lrn bliy nvnits tdlt fli hffur wdaen

l pnrshi as hi mnltd rhw. Vnitnifns hr fhivaftahis

bly jn rnvnrsnm, hr tdn ehig wlat hi mnltd rhw flusns

tdn aibltn th man hc ilturle flusns, hr crhb suafamn, ac

tdn prashi lutdhratans lrn iht vagaelit nihugd. ]dnghvnrihr bly nvni grlit fenbnify th tdn prashinr, hr

nitarn mnltd pnilety stltutns bly jn hvnrturinm. ]das

whuem nvnituleey bnli l eacn

snitnifn chr tdn aibltn liywly,

jut hiey lctnr l vnry nxpnisavn

mnltd pnilety trale lim

sujsnqunit eacn hi mnltd rhw.

]dus, at as iht tdn mnltd

pnilety atsnec tdlt as sh nxpnisavn.

Zltdnr, at as tdn pursuat hc at tdltas.:4

Lplrt crhb tdn dagd

fhsts, tdn nccnftavninss hc tdn mnltd pnilety ls l chrb

hc mntnrrnit lglaist snrahus frabn as lesh dagdey

mnjltljen. Watd tdn prhjljen nxfnptahi hc Vluma Lrljal

wdnrn fhimnbinm frabailes lrn jndnlmnm pujeafey ai

faty squlrns,:1 pujeaf ìhwenmgn hc wdlt ghns hi

muraig tdn prhfnss hc nxnfutahi as gninrleey eabatnm.

Nvni ac l whuem-jn frabaile mhns ìhw wdlt ghns hi

muraig li nxnfutahi, tdn aichrbltahi whuem snnbmntlfdnm lim arrnenvlit ai rnle eacn, snni hiey ai whrms hr

vamnhs, blàig tdn prhspnft hc mnltd lebhst ihi-

nxastnit ai das fhitnbpeltahi hc frabn.

]dn aicrnqunify watd wdafd tdn mnltd pnilety as

flrranm hut ai tdn îatnm Vtltns as

lesh hin hc tdn rnlshis wdy at as iht

fhisamnrnm l ghhm mntnrrnit lglaist

frabn. Vaifn tdn mnltd pnilety wls

rnaistltnm ai tdn îatnm Vtltns ai


6/40

_lyaig tdn êtabltn _rafn | Cnlturn

3| ]dn Enxafhi

fhbjltaig frabn. Ls quhtnm crhb Inw Knrsny _heafn

Fdanc Klbns Ljjhtt, A enlrinm tdlt tdn mnltd pnilety

tdrhws baeeahis hc mheelrs mhwi tdn mrlai, bhiny tdlt A

fhuem jn puttaig marnftey th whr` cagdtaig frabn. Gavn l

elw nichrfnbnit hccafnr ea`n bn tdlt $:>? baeeahi, lim Aee

sdhw yhu dhw th rnmufn frabn.63

]dn baeeahis hc mheelrs fhuem jn fdliineenm aith l

wdhen dhst hc htdnr hptahis chr fhbjltaig frabn, sufd

ls tdn trlaiaig hc bhrn dagdey-sàeenm pheafn hccafnrs th

pltrhe strnnts ai hrmnr th rnmufn frabn, purfdlsaig bhrn

lmvlifnm nquapbnit th fhbjlt frabn sufd ls jhbj

squlm rhjhts, dneafhptnrs hr FF]S flbnrl systnbs,

lim tdn ruiiaig hc fhvnrt hpnrltahis th frlf` mhwi hi

dlrmfhrn aeengle lftavatans sufd ls mrug flrtnes lim

prhstatutahi raigs. ]dn cuims fhuem lesh jn fdliineenm

aith shfale snrvafns sufd ls psyfdhehgafle fhuisneeaig

lim cailifale lam, shtdlt pnhpen innm iht

rnshrt th frabn th

shevn tdnar prhjenbs.

Lee tdas fhuem

jn phssajen ac tdn

mnltd pnilety mam

iht fhisastnitey

nxnrt dugn cailifale prnssurn hi stltn jumgnts, ls at

mhns lim fhitaiuns th mh nvnry ynlr chr stltns tdlt staee

rntlai tdn mnltd pnilety. ]dnrnchrn, tdn baeeahis hcmheelrs wlstnm hi tdn prhfnss enlmaig th tdn nxnfutahi,

hr rltdnr tdn ihi-nxnfutahi, hc tdn frabaile as l strhig

phait chr tdn fhbpentn ljheasdbnit hc tdas prlftafn. Mun

th tdn cailifale strlai hi iubnrhus stltn jumgnts ai

flrryaig hut tdn mnltd pnilety lim tdn prhfnssns

lttlfdnm th at, stltns lrn aifrnlsaigey ehhàig th ats

ljheasdbnit, plrtafuelrey lctnr tdn snvnrn jumgnt futs ai

tdn lctnrbltd hc tdn :??4 gehjle nfhihbaf frasas.67

Lehigsamn tdn lpplrnit nfhihbaf jnincats,

ljheasdaig tdn mnltd pnilety whuem lesh bnli l curtdnrstnp thwlrms tdn prhtnftahi hc dubli ragdts uimnr

Lrtafen 6 hc tdn îavnrsle Mnfelrltahi hc Dubli Zagdts.64

]dlt as tdn uetabltn rnlshi ai stravaig chr l fhbpentn

mntlfdbnit crhb tdn wlstncue lim arrnenvlit prlftafn hc

tdn mnltd pnilety; tdlt nvnry dubli jnaig dls l ragdt th

eacn, lim ih hin, iht nvni tdn ehig lrb hc tdn elw, fli

tl`n tdlt lwly.

< Gninrle Lssnbjey Lmhpts Elimblr` ]nxt Fleeaig Chr Bhrlthraubhi Mnltd _nilety, îatnm Iltahis Gninrle Lssnbjey

5dttp;//www.ui.hrg/Inws/_rnss/mhfs/:??7/gl


7/40

]dn Enxafhi | 7

Fdrastaliaty, Aselb lim Flpatle _uiasdbnit

L ]dnhehgafle _nrspnftavn hi tdn Mnltd _nilety

jy @dhig Bna-Qli

Jneanc ai Ghm sats lt tdn thp hc hur Iltahile

_daehshpdy lbhig chur htdnr praifapens, frnltnm jy tdn

Blkeas Gnrl`li Zl`ylt (BLGNZLI) phst-


8/40

Fdrastaliaty, Aselb lim Flpatle _uiasdbnit| Cnlturn

4 | ]dn Enxafhi

tdlt tdny whuem prnss fdlrgns ls jhtd wnrn lesh

aivhevnm ai tdn nvnitule mnltd hc ^rald. ]dn shi tdlt

wls jhri th tdnb eltnr manm. Mlvam rnfhgiasnm tdlt dn

wls whrtdy hc mnltd lim elbnitnm tdn ehss hc das shi.:?

Ai liy flsn, tdas aistlifn mhns iht fhuit ls li

nxfnptahi th tdn mnltd pnilety, ihr mhns at ljrhgltn tdn

elw. Ghm, wdh as ljen th rnlm dnlrts, bust dlvn

nvleultnm tdn gniuaininss hc Mlvams rnpnitlifn, lim

wls bnrfacue ai leehwaig jhtd Mlvam lim Jltdsdnjl th

eavn.

Mun th dubliaty's claeurns ai `nnpaig watd tdn

Bhslaf Elw, Ghm aistatutnm l inw fhvnilit watd Daspnhpen tdrhugd Knsus Fdrast. ]dn hem fhvnilit wdafd

rnquarnm straft hjsnrvlifn hc tdn elw jnflbn vham. :;64-61 dn slam, Qhu dlvn dnlrm

tdlt at wls slam, li nyn chr li nyn lim l thhtd chr l

thhtd. Jut A sly th yhu, mh iht rnsast tdn hin wdh as

nvae. Jut ac liyhin selps yhu hi tdn ragdt fdnn`, turi th

dab tdn htdnr lesh. Ai slyaig tdas, dn wls iht

fhitrlmaftaig jut fhrrnftaig tdn basaitnrprntltahi hc tdn

Bhslaf Elw jy aimavamules wdh, muraig tdn tabn hc

Knsus, dlm basusnm tdn elw chr pnrshile rnvnign.::

Eltnr ai Zhblis ;6: stltns tdlt ac liyhin àees l pnrshi uienss at jn

chr burmnr hr chr sprnlmaig basfdanc ai tdn elim at

whuem jn ls ac dn àeenm lee pnhpen. Lim ac liyhin slvns l

eacn, at whuem jn ls ac dn slvnm tdn eacn hc lee pnhpen.

Lffhrmaig th tdn vnrsn, tdnrn lrn twh typns hc frabns

puiasdljen jy mnltd. ]dn carst aifeumns aitnitahile

burmnr. ]dn snfhim, ìhwi ls Clslm cae-lrmd, lrn

frabns fhbbattnm lglaist tdn Buseab fhbbuiaty tdlt

tdrnltni th uimnrbain tdn ruenr hr frnltn dlvhf lbhig

jneanvnrs. (n.g. rlpn, lphstlsy, lmuetnry, dhbhsnxule

jndlvahur, parlfy lim tnrrhrasb). Vdlral easts pniletans

ai Aselb uimnr tdrnn blai fltnghrans;dumum, qasls lim

tlzar. Wn waee ehh` aith nlfd ai turi.

Dumum (wdafd bnlis eabat) prhvamns caxnm

puiasdbnits snt jy Ghm chr hccnifns fhbbattnm jy

aimavamules marnftey lglaist Ghm. Iht hiey lrn tdnsn

frabns sh snrahus l tdrnlt th shfanty tdlt tdny bust jn

purgnm crhb tdn fhbbuiaty, tdny lrn lesh fhisamnrnm

l vaheltahi hc Ghms ragdts hr lglaist Ghm. Letdhugd

puiasdbnit uimnr tdas fltnghry as caxnm lim dnifn

abbutljen, hpaiahis rnglrmaig tdn mncnifns lvlaeljen

lim tdn rnquarnbnits jnchrn l pnrshi fli jn fdlrgnm

watd natdnr hc tdn hccnifns maccnr lbhig tdn sfdhhes hcAselb.

tdn favae ghvnribnit as tdn

snrvlit hc Ghm, li lvnignr wdh

flrrans hut Ghms wrltd hi tdn

wrhigmhnr.

watdai l fhbbuiaty

snttaig tdn eligulgn hc muty

tl`ns prahraty hvnr tdn eligulgn

hc ragdts.


9/40

Cnlturn | Fdrastaliaty, Aselb lim Flpatle _uiasdbnit

]dn Enxafhi | 1

Buseab kurasts dlvn maccnraig hpaiahis ls th wdafd

hc tdn dumum hccnifns lrn puiasdljen jy mnltd. ]dhsn

fhbbhiey lf`ihwenmgnm lrn zail (uielwcue snxule

aitnrfhursn), rammld (lphstlsy) lim darljld

(jlimatry).:4 Letdhugd burmnr wls fhisamnrnm l flpatle

frabn, at mam iht fhbn uimnr tdn fltnghry hcdumum.

[ail aifeumns nxtrlblratle lim

prnblratle snx. Lffhrmaig thtrlmatahile Aselbaf Elw ls stltnm

ai tdn Dlmatd, l pnrshi flugdt

ai lmuetnry as th jn sthinm th

mnltd. :1 Qnt tdn \urli atsnec

bl`ns ih bnitahi hc sthiaig,

letdhugd at mam prnsfrajn


10/40

Fdrastaliaty, Aselb lim Flpatle _uiasdbnit| Cnlturn


11/40

]dn Enxafhi |


12/40

Mrugs; Mlignrhus jut iht Mnlmey| Cnlturn


13/40

Cnlturn | Mrugs; Mlignrhus jut Iht Mnlmey

]dn Enxafhi |


14/40

Mrugs; Mlignrhus jut iht Mnlmey| Cnlturn

/?6/us-blelysal-bhsqun-

bntdlmhin-am^VJZN4=:?>6:??69 lffnssnm > Cnjrulry :?


15/40

Cnlturn | Mrugs; Mlignrhus jut Iht Mnlmey

]dn Enxafhi |

> Dasdlbbummai;


16/40


17/40

Cnlturn | Zntnitahiast Vtltns hc tdn Bammen Nlst

]dn Enxafhi |


18/40

Zntnitahiast Vtltns hc tdn Bammen Nlst| Cnlturn


19/40

Cnlturn | Zntnitahiast Vtltns hc tdn Bammen Nlst

]dn Enxafhi |


20/40

:? | ]dn Enxafhi

jy Vdleaia Kueal Khdi

Chr baeeniial, flpatle puiasdbnit dls jnni

abpenbnitnm ai nvnry favaeazltahi `ihwi th bli`aim.

Dhwnvnr, ai tdn elst >? ynlrs, tdn whrem dls sehweystlrtnm th bhvn lwly crhb tdn amnl hc lppeyaig sufd l

puiasdbnit lim bliy fhuitrans dlvn nvni fdhsni th

cueey ljheasd tdn mnltd pnilety. ]dnrn lrn hiey l dlimcue

hc fhuitrans tdlt dlvn ynt th cheehw suat. Blelysal as hin

hc tdnb.

Znfnitey dhwnvnr, tdnrn dlvn jnni iubnrhus

flees chr tdn ljheasdbnit hc tdn mnltd pnilety ai tdas

fhuitry. Letdhugd bliy watdai tdn engle fhbbuiaty

nfdh tdn snitabnits hc tdnsn grhups ai jneanvaig tdlt

tdn fhuitry sdhuem rntdai` tdn mnltd pnilety lim fhbn

up watd l bhrn dublin letnriltavn, tdnrn lrn kust lsbliy wdh cnne quatn maccnrnitey.

Watd tdnsn fhiceaftaig hpaiahis ai baim, A turinm

up lt tdn Vdld Lelb Dagd Fhurt chr li aitnrvanw watd

]dn Dhihurljen Kustafn Mr. _rlslm Ljrldlb, dhpaig th

glai bhrn aisagdt aith tdn assuns surrhuimaig at.

]dn Dhihurljen Mr. _rlslm Vlimhsdlb

Ljrldlb wls lpphaitnm th das furrnit phst ls l Dagd

Fhurt kumgn ai :?


21/40

Aitnrvanw | Crhb tdn Htdnr Vamn hc tdn Jnifd

]dn Enxafhi | :


22/40

Crhb tdn Htdnr Vamn hc tdn Jnifd | Aitnrvanw

:: | ]dn Enxafhi

fhivaft lim das clbaey fli jn tl`ni aith fhisamnrltahi

jnchrn tdn mnltd pnilety as plssnm.

Hc fhursn, tdnrn as ih

batagltahi prhfnss ai flsns wdnrn

tdn mnltd pnilety as blimlthry,

sufd ls chr mrug trlccafàig. Ai tdnsn

satultahis tdn liguasd hc tdn

pnrpntrlthr lim das clbaey waee dlvn

th gh uilmmrnssnm. Jut nvni watd

batagltahi, hin whimnrs dhw tdnsn

fhifnris fhuem jn put lfrhss fhivaifaigey jnchrn tdn

fhurt ac tdnar lffhuit as iht ls mntlaenm ls l SAV8

Ai hrmnr th bl`n l rnle blr`, A cnne tdlt

shbntdaig ea`n tdn SAV, jut chr tdn htdnr plrty (tdn

fhivaft lim das clbaey) fli jn aitrhmufnm. PDhwnvnrR wn

mh iht dlvn at lt tdn bhbnit lim at bly tl`n shbn

tabn jnchrn at fli nvnr fhbn aith nxastnifn. Hur shfanty

as sufd tdlt at whuem jn maccafuet th try lim pnrsulmn

tdnb th gavn bnrfy th pnrpntrlthrs. Wn usuleey cnne tdlttdny mnsnrvn th jn puiasdnm chr tdn frabns tdny dlvn

fhbbattnm, lim wn kust bly iht jn rnlmy chr

shbntdaig ea`n tdas. At wls nlsy th lgrnn watd tdlt vanw. Ls l shfanty,

wn rnkhafn lt tdn whimnrcue tdaigs tdlt dlppni ai hur

fhuitry lim fry thgntdnr wdni wn lrn clfnm watd frasns

tdlt stra`n mnnp aith hur bhrle vleuns. ]dn trlgaf sthry

hc Iurai Klzeai Klzabai wdh wls snxuleey lssluetnm lim

jrutleey burmnrnm ai :??7 fhbns th baim.: ]dn wdhen

fhuitry wls hutrlgnm jy tdn frabn lim fleenm chr tdn

mnltd hc dnr burmnrnr watdhut dnsatltahi. ]dn bnmalnxpehmnm watd rnphrts lim

lrtafens ljhut jraigaig tdn

pnrpntrlthr th kustafn lim

lvnigaig tdn mnltd hc tdas

aiihfnit gare.Vax ynlrs hi, dnr àeenr staee

wle`s crnn, jut tdn glpaig whuim

tdlt tdas frabn enct hi hur shfanty

dls ynt th dnle. 6 Watd tdlt ai

baim, at whuem jn uicltdhbljen

chr bhst hc us th jn clfnm watd sufd l mrlstaf fdlign ai

tdn kustafn systnb, wdnrn tdn pnrpntrlthr as leehwnm leajnrle peltchrb th gavn tdn htdnr samn hc tdn sthry.

Invnrtdnenss, wn bust ehh` th tdn cuturn. At wls

watd tdas fhivaftahi tdlt A shemanrnm hi watd tdn inxt

phait; fhuem Blelysal phssajey nbueltn tdn lftahis hc

htdnr fhuitrans tdlt dlvn ljheasdnm tdn mnltd pnilety ai

tdn inlr cuturn8 Wn, ls Blelysalis, fliiht usn tdn Wnst ls l

fhbplss chr tdn wly wn fhimuft hursnevns ai rneltahi

th hur elws. ]dn Blelysali wly hc tdaiàig lim fueturn

as vnry, vnry maccnrnit crhb tdlt hc tdn Wnst. Hur dasthry

hc frabn lim tdn wly wn lmbaiastnr kustafn dls lewlys

jnni tdrhugd mntnrrnifn lim straignit puiasdbnit. Hur

systnb as sufd tdlt pnhpen gninrleey mh iht rnspnft tdn

lutdhratans uienss puiasdbnit chr

frabn as prhpnrey nichrfnm. Dn

nbpdlsaznm tdlt ls li Lsali shfanty,

wn sdhuem iht jeaimey cheehw wdlt

ghns hi ai tdn Wnstnri fhuitrans.

]daigs ea`n tdnsn sdhuem iht jn mhin

ai dlstn0 flrncue stumans bust jnfhimuftnm lt nlfd stnp th chrnsnn

tdn phssajen rlbacafltahis.L quaf` gelifn lt tdn wlee; tabn wls lebhst up.

Vnisaig by dnsatlifn, Kustafn _rlslm nifhurlgnm l

elst qunstahi crhb bn. Dnrn A sdlrnm watd Kustafn

_rlslm tdn rnsuets hc by pnrshile rnsnlrfd hi tdn

sujknft blttnr tdn aifrnlsaig iubjnr hc pnhpen wdh

cnne tdlt tdn mnltd pnilety as l bnmanvle chrb hc

puiasdbnit, lim tdn clft tdlt bliy iltahis tdlt

prlftafn flpatle puiasdbnit lrn fhisamnraig ats

ljheasdbnit. Ac tdas fdlign hc pnrfnptahi wnrn th

dlppni ai Blelysal, wdlt letnriltavns mh wn dlvn8Ents ehh` lt l fhupen hc frabns tdlt whuem jn

puiasdljen jy mnltd trnlshi lim wlgaig wlr lglaist

tdn @aig. Jhtd hc tdnsn frabns jhae mhwi th tdn

qunstahi hc yhur iltahile pdaehshpdy. ]dnsn hccnifns gh

lglaist tdn vnry rhht hc yhur stltndhhm0 tdnrnchrn, tdn

mnltd pnilety bust jn ai pelfn jnflusn at lfts ls l

mntnrrnit. Ac yhu mhit gavn tdnb l rnlshi chr iht mhaig

at, tdny waee mh at. ]dn lita-tnrrhrasb elws abpenbnitnm

ai tdn ^VL lctnr tdn 1/


23/40

Aitnrvanw | Crhb tdn Htdnr Vamn hc tdn Jnifd

]dn Enxafhi | :6

< Vdlrhi Fdni, Vaiglphrn Lbnims Mnltd _nilety Elws th Nxnbpt

Vhbn Hccnifns, Jusainss Wnn` (@ulel Eubpur, := Cnjrulry :?


24/40

:= | ]dn Enxafhi

Elw Vpnl`nr Vnrans :?


25/40

]dn Enxafhi | :>

Elw Vpnl`nr Vnrans :?


26/40

:3| ]dn Enxafhi

]lyehrs Elw Vfdhhe stlcc lim stumnits tl`n l silpsdht thgntdnr th fhbbnbhrltn tdn nvnit.

]rnlmaig tdn pltd hc suffnss ai prhmufaig

quleacanm lim dagd-fleajrn elw grlmultns, ]lyehrs Elw

Vfdhhe (]EV) fnenjrltnm ats :?td liiavnrslry hi Lugust

>td :?


27/40

Nvnit | Elw Jlee & Lwlrms Fnrnbhiy :?


28/40

:4 | ]dn Enxafhi

Elw Lwlrninss Mly :?


29/40

]dn Enxafhi | :1

_dhthfhurtnsyhcFdhigQaiChig

_dhthfhurtnsyhcFdhigQaiChig

Aitnrile Bhhts Blrfd :?


30/40

6? | ]dn Enxafhi

Nxquasatn Maiaig Nxpnranifn watd BA]LL

]lyehrs Elw Vfdhhe dhstnm tdn Blelysali Aiinr]nbpen Leubia Lsshfaltahi (BA]LL) maiinr chr tdn tdarm

fhisnfutavn ynlr hi Blrfd 7 td :?


31/40

]dn Enxafhi | 6


32/40

6: | ]dn Enxafhi

ElwLsal Aitnriltahile Bhht Fhbpntatahi

:?


33/40

]dn Enxafhi | 66

Zui, Crnsdan, Zui!jy @nevai Enn Fdhhi @at

Hi tdn 7td hc Mnfnbjnr :?


34/40

Zui, Crnsdan, Zui! | Nvnit

6= | ]dn Enxafhi

Safthrahus ]nlb Mniiaig.

Hifn tdn blai nvnit wls hvnr, tdn stumnits

gltdnrnm th baigen wdaen maiinr lim nitnrtlaibnit wnrn

prhvamnm jy tdn Elw Vhfanty lim tdnar tlenitnm

fhursnbltns. ]dn nvniaig nimnm hi l dagd ihtn watd

stumnits lim enfturnrs lea`n saigaig lehig th snfhim-

ynlr elw stumnits Qlp Dli Eui, Inh Dwnn Qhig lim

Knrnby Higs dnlrtcnet rnimatahi hc Lnrhsbatds A Mhit

Wlit th Bass l ]daig.

Bueta-tlenitnm Inh Dwnn Qhig, Qlp Dli Eui lim Knrnby

Hig (iht pafturnm) snrnilmaig stumnits lim enfturnrs.

L grhup pdhth hc elw stumnits lim enfturnrs th fhbbnbhrltn tdn nvnit.


35/40

]dn Enxafhi | 6>

\&L; Sanws hi tdn Mnltd _niletyjy Vtneel Fdla Dli \ai

]dn mnltd pnilety dls jnfhbn l dhtey-mnjltnm thpaf ai rnfnit tabns lebhst nvnryhin dls li hpaiahi hi tdn

assun!

Wn mnfamnm th ehh` jhtd watdai lim jnyhim tdn Elw Vfdhhe th caim hut wdlt shbn stumnits lim lflmnbafs

crhb htdnr uiavnrsatans lim masfapeains dlvn th sly ljhut at.

A tdai` tdn mnltd pnilety sdhuem jn ljheasdnm ls nvnryjhmy mnsnrvns l snfhim

fdlifn." Ela Bui Hii, Enfturnr (EEJ)

A jneanvn tdlt tdn mnltd pnilety as snrvaig ats purphsn, lim saifn A lb uiljen

th tdai` hc l jnttnr letnriltavn, A lb wlry hc fratafasaig tdn systnb. At `nnps mlignrhus frabailes hcc

tdn strnnts ai l wly tdlt mhns iht fehg up tdn prashi systnb lim usn up nvni bhrn hc tlxplynrs

bhiny. Mlvam Val, Jlfdnehr hc Fueailry Lrts lim Chhm Vnrvafn Blilgnbnit

By hpaiahi as bhrn aiceunifnm jy rneagahi, sh A whuem sly tdlt A'b iht rnleey l

blssavn supphrtnr hc tdn mnltd pnilety, saifn wn mhit rnleey dlvn tdn ragdt th kumgn wdh eavns lim

wdh mans. Blral Fdhig, Jlfdnehr hc _syfdhehgy

A mhit maslpprhvn hc tdn mnltd pnilety jnflusn at as aidublin. A lftuleey

tdai` at as quatn dublin, jut A maslpprhvn hc at jnflusn hc tdn uetabltninss hc tdn puiasdbnit. Ac

yhu man, yhu man. Ih hin fli rnvnrsn tdn lft. Eab Ql Wni, I^V Dagd Vfdhhe hc Bltdnbltafs

lim Vfanifn Mapehbl


36/40

\&L; Sanws hi tdn Mnltd _nilety| Enasurn

63 | ]dn Enxafhi

A dlvn shbnwdlt baxnm vanws hi tdas. Hi tdn hin dlim, A tdai` at as ghhm jnflusn ac

wn mh iht dlvn tdn mnltd pnilety, snrahus hccnimnrs gnt tdn fdlifn th phssajey fhbbat frabn bhrn

tdli hifn.

A cnne tdhugd tdlt at as bhrn hc l gninrle mntnrrnit tdli li aimavamule mntnrrnit. L dlrmninm, rnpnlt

frabaile bagdt iht jn mntnrrnm nvni ac tdnrn as flpatle puiasdbnit ai pelfn. Curtdnrbhrn, shbn

stltastafs dlvn sdhwi tdlt at as iht infnsslraey li nccnftavn mntnrrnit hc frabn.

Jut hi tdn htdnr dlim, A lesh cnne tdlt crhb l rneagahus pnrspnftavn, wn hugdt iht th dlvn tdn ragdt th

tl`n eacn lwly. At whuem jn dyphfratafle chr shfanty th mh tdn slbn tdaig tdlt at fhimnbis ai l

burmnrnr, chr nxlbpen!

Nquleey, tdnrn lrn stltastafs wdafd sdhw tdlt pnhpen wlit tdn mnltd pnilety th jn rnaistltnm jut sufd

stltastafs fli hiey jn trustnm ac at as rncenftavn hc hpaiahi lfrhss tdn jhlrm ls hpphsnm th hiey l

plrtafuelr sngbnit hc shfanty. Vdlitda Zlblfdlimrli, Chrbnr Vniahr Enfturnr & _rhgrlbbn

Marnfthr (EEJ), ]lyehrs Elw Vfdhhe

Burmnr. A kust flit ablgain liyhin jnaig enianit nihugd th ent l chrbnr burmnrnr hut hi tdnstrnnts. Wdlt ac dn hr sdn àees lglai hr snn`s rnvnign8 Dhwnvnr A tdai` tdn mnltd pnilety chr mrug

trlccafàig sdhuem jn ljheasdnm lim rnpelfnm jy l enigtdy prashi snitnifn lim pnrdlps prhjltahi

cheehwaig tdlt. Vdlreyi Fdu, Lbnrafli Mngrnn ]rliscnr _rhgrlb

A tdai` hiey burmnr lim rlpn wlrrlit tdn mnltd pnilety. Wdy rlpn, yhu ls`8

]h bn, rlpn as purn frunety. At as jhtd uiclar lim aifrnmajey trlubltasaig th tdn vaftab, jn at blen hr

cnblen, th ìhw tdlt tdnar pnrpntrlthrs lrn staee jrnltdaig. ]dn mnltd pnilety whuem snrvn ls jhtd l

rnlssurlifn th vaftabs lim l strhig mntnrrnit th rlpasts. Ehw Kal Qnn, Jlfdnehr hc Fdnbafle

Nigainnraig

A tdai` tdn pnilety flrranm hut mnpnims hi tdn frabn. Ai flsns hc, sly,

àmilppaig lim sujsnqunit burmnr, A mhit tdai` tdn frabaile mnsnrvns l fdlifn lt lee. ]das as ls

hpphsnm th mrug trlccafàig, wdnrn tdn pnrshi as iht tlàig liyhins eacn. A tdai` tdn mnltd pnilety

chr mrug trlccafàig as thh dlrsd lim tdlt mrug trlccaf`nrs mnsnrvn l fdlifn th jn rndljaeatltnm.

Limrnl Fdhhig, Jlfdnehr hc Bnmafain lim Vurgnry


37/40

Enasurn | \&L; Sanws hi tdn Mnltd _nilety

]dn Enxafhi | 67

]dn mnltd pnilety as bhrn ea`n l gact th tdn prashinr jnflusn at as hvnr ai l celsd. A

tdai` at as bhstey th lppnlsn tdn pujeafs snisn hc vnignlifn, th dnlr tdlt l snrale àeenr wls cranm hi

tdn nenftraf fdlar hr ats nquavlenit. Blral Fdhig, Jlfdnehr hc _syfdhehgy

Eacn abprashibnit flusns prhjenbs watd splfn ai prashis, bhiny spnit hi chhm

lim bnmafle jaees. Vh blyjn ai bhmnri tabns, tdn mnltd pnilety as snrvaig bhrn hc l prlftafle

purphsn tdli tdn hin at usnm th. Vdlreyi Fdu, Lbnrafli Mngrnn ]rliscnr _rhgrlb

@ihwaig tdlt hin as clfaig l mnltd snitnifn bagdt sflrn shbn pnhpen aith

fdligaig chr tdn jnttnr. Vhbn pnhpen mhit rnleey snn tdaigs tdn wly wn wlit tdnb th uienss tdny

lrn clfnm watd mnltd. Eab Ql Wni, I^V Dagd Vfdhhe hc Bltdnbltafs lim Vfanifn Mapehbl

A tdai` at lfts ls l mntnrrnit. Gninrleey A mhit lgrnn watd tlàig l eacn jut wdni shbnhins

eacn as tl`ni, ea`n ai l burmnr, tdnrn waee mncaiatney jn l strhig mnsarn chr vnignlifn. _eus, spnlàig

ls l plrnit, A whuem jn prnplrnm th usn lee bnlis aifeumaig tlàig eacn, ac l frabaile wnrn th tdrnltni

by fdaemrni! ]dnrn as trutd jndaim tdn slyaig, li nyn chr li nyn. Lihiybhus Enfturnr

]dn mnltd pnilety as iht li nccnftavn mntnrrnit. ]dnrn lrn whrsn tdaigs tdli mnltd.

Chr l frabaile wdh dls tdhrhugdey bnssnm up das eacn lim snns ih wly hut, tdn mnltd pnilety bagdt

ls wnee jn l rneltavney plaienss lim engle wly th àee dabsnec. Eab Ql Wni, I^V Dagd Vfdhhe hc

Bltdnbltafs lim Vfanifn Mapehbl

A ìhw tdn blai rnlshi chr tdn mnltd pnilety as ls l mntnrrnit, jut A mhit

lftuleey tdai` frabailes flrn ljhut tdn mnltd pnilety. Jy dhh` hr jy frhh` tdny bust jn puiasdnm,

jut A tdai` tdn mnltd pnilety hiey dlec snrvns ats purphsn ls l puiasdbnit, chr tdn vnry rnlshi tdlt

tdny lrnit lcrlam th man. Vdlreyi Fdu, Lbnrafli Mngrnn ]rliscnr _rhgrlb


38/40

\&L; Sanws hi tdn Mnltd _nilety| Enasurn

64 | ]dn Enxafhi

Watd eacn abprashibnit, fhivafts bly jn rnenlsnm hi plrhen chr

ghhm jndlvahur. A jneanvn tdlt tdn dnlvanr frabns sdhuem jn puiasdnm lffhrmaigey.

Dnifn, A mh iht jneanvn l burmnrnr sdhuem nvnr wle` crnn, ih blttnr dhw bufd dn

felabs th dlvn rnpnitnm. Mlvam Val, Jlfdnehr hc Fueailry Lrts lim Chhm Vnrvafn

Blilgnbnit

A prncnr eacn snitnifns ai prashi hvnr tdn mnltd pnilety. Jnsamns, wdlt jnttnr wly

th puiasd l bli tdli th ent dab sehwey rht ai prashi8 Vheatlry fhicainbnit fli mlblgn tdn baim

bhrn tdli tdn cnlr hc mnltd. Lim bhst dlrmninm frabailes mhit nvni cnlr mnltd liybhrn jnflusn

tdny lrn tdlt twastnm. Jut put tdnb ai l rhhb watd ih stabueltahi, lim tdnar baim waee mntnrahrltn

sehwey. Hc fhursn, at bagdt frnltn l prhjenb hc dhw hr wdnrn th dhem tdnb lee, nspnfaleey watd tdn

nvnr-aifrnlsaig frabn rltns. Blral Fdhig, Jlfdnehr hc _syfdhehgy

Aistnlm hc ehh`aig lt at crhb tdn vaftabs samn lim wdlts jnttnr chr tdn vaftab, ents ehh`

lt at crhb tdn pujeafs phait hc vanw aistnlm. ]dn elw as usnm th prhtnft tdn pnhpen. Wdy mh tdn vnry

pnhpen tdlt tdnsn frabailes tdrnltni dlvn th ply chr tdnar nxpnisns ai prashi8 ]li La` Qhig,

Jlfdnehr hc Lppeanm Vfanifn (Blrain Nivarhibnit)

Ac rntlaiaig tdn mnltd pnilety bnlis l ehwnr frabn rltn lim enss burmnrnrs

hi tdn ehhsn,tdni A supphsn wrhigcue fhivaftahis lrn li uichrtuiltn jut infnsslry nvae. Asit at

usuleey tdn flsn tdlt tdnrn as dugn hutrlgn crhb tdn vaftabs clbaey lim tdn pujeaf wdni l burmnrnr

asit fhivaftnm lim snitnifnm th mnltd8 Vdlreyi Fdu, Lbnrafli Mngrnn ]rliscnr _rhgrlb

Ls chr tdn phtnitale claeaigs hc tdn kumafale systnb A mh iht tdai` at as nvnr ghhm th

`aee li aiihfnit pnrshi, jut A waee lewlys lgrnn tdlt at as jnttnr tdli enttaig tni mlignrhus, guaety

hins gh crnn. Mlvam Val, Jlfdnehr hc Fueailry Lrts lim Chhm Vnrvafn Blilgnbnit


39/40

Vhurfn; Dubhrhus Engle Flsns, Glvne:Glvne, 5dttp;//www.rn-

qunst.int/g:g/dubhr/flsns/aimnx.dtb9 (Lffnssnm 3 Cnjrulry :?6? ^.V. :>>, C.6m 436

(:???)

Ai l massnitaig kumgbnit, Kustafn Zutd Gaisjnrg

wrhtn, "]dn Fhurt's whhmniey eatnrle fhistruftahi gavns

rasn th prlftafle lihbleans lim nccnftavney sdrai`s tdn

kury's fdhafns wdaen nielrgaig tdn prhsnfuthr's hptahis."

\uatn l suggnstavn aiiunimh tdnrn


40/40

The LEXICON - Taylor's Law School's Legal Newsletter (2013)

Documents

Transcript of The LEXICON - Taylor's Law School's Legal Newsletter (2013)