The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7...

27
The Haldane Model Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 1 / 12

Transcript of The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7...

Page 1: The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12. Trivial vs Topological 1 Trivial Topological 1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in

The Haldane Model

Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 1 / 12

Page 2: The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12. Trivial vs Topological 1 Trivial Topological 1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in

Why the Haldane Model?

First crystal model describing topological behavior.

Simple and intuitive tight binding model.Helped me understand what topological materials are all about.

Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 2 / 12

Page 3: The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12. Trivial vs Topological 1 Trivial Topological 1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in

Why the Haldane Model?

First crystal model describing topological behavior.Simple and intuitive tight binding model.

Helped me understand what topological materials are all about.

Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 2 / 12

Page 4: The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12. Trivial vs Topological 1 Trivial Topological 1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in

Why the Haldane Model?

First crystal model describing topological behavior.Simple and intuitive tight binding model.Helped me understand what topological materials are all about.

Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 2 / 12

Page 5: The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12. Trivial vs Topological 1 Trivial Topological 1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in

The Model

Spinless model on the Honeycomb lattice (2 sites)

On-site energy

H = ∆∑i

(−)τic†ici + t1∑<ij>

(c†icj + h.c

)+ t2

∑<<ij>>

(ic†icj + h.c

)

Real first neighbor hoppingsImaginary second neighbor hoppings

Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 3 / 12

Page 6: The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12. Trivial vs Topological 1 Trivial Topological 1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in

The Model

Spinless model on the Honeycomb lattice (2 sites)

On-site energy

H = ∆∑i

(−)τic†ici + t1∑<ij>

(c†icj + h.c

)+ t2

∑<<ij>>

(ic†icj + h.c

)

Real first neighbor hoppings

Imaginary second neighbor hoppings

Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 3 / 12

Page 7: The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12. Trivial vs Topological 1 Trivial Topological 1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in

The Model

Spinless model on the Honeycomb lattice (2 sites)

On-site energy

H = ∆∑i

(−)τic†ici + t1∑<ij>

(c†icj + h.c

)+ t2

∑<<ij>>

(ic†icj + h.c

)

Real first neighbor hoppingsImaginary second neighbor hoppingsNicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 3 / 12

Page 8: The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12. Trivial vs Topological 1 Trivial Topological 1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in

Defining non-trivial states

The atomic limit: Strength of hoppings and hybridization is zero i.eflat bands

Figure: ∆ = 0.7, t1 = t2 = 0

Definition: A state is topological when it is impossible to turn offthe interactions (atomic limit) without closing the gap.

Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 4 / 12

Page 9: The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12. Trivial vs Topological 1 Trivial Topological 1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in

Defining non-trivial states

The atomic limit: Strength of hoppings and hybridization is zero i.eflat bands

Figure: ∆ = 0.7, t1 = t2 = 0

Definition: A state is topological when it is impossible to turn offthe interactions (atomic limit) without closing the gap.

Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 4 / 12

Page 10: The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12. Trivial vs Topological 1 Trivial Topological 1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in

Trivial vs Topological

∆ = 0.7, t1 = −1.0, t2 = 0 and t2 = −0.06

1

1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in Electronic StructureNicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 5 / 12

Page 11: The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12. Trivial vs Topological 1 Trivial Topological 1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in

Trivial vs Topological

∆ = 0.7, t1 = −1.0, t2 = 0 and t2 = −0.06

1

1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in Electronic StructureNicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 5 / 12

Page 12: The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12. Trivial vs Topological 1 Trivial Topological 1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in

Trivial vs Topological

∆ = 0.7, t1 = −1.0, t2 = −0.1347 and t2 = −0.24

2

2Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in Electronic StructureNicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 6 / 12

Page 13: The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12. Trivial vs Topological 1 Trivial Topological 1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in

Trivial vs Topological

∆ = 0.7, t1 = −1.0, t2 = −0.1347 and t2 = −0.24

2

2Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in Electronic StructureNicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 6 / 12

Page 14: The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12. Trivial vs Topological 1 Trivial Topological 1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in

What is topological about the topological state?

Hybrid Wannier Representation:

|hnk1l2〉 =1

∫ 2π

0e−ik2l2 |ψnk1k2〉 dk2

State |hnk1l2〉 is localized at the l2/a unit cell in the y direction andextended in x.Well defined expectation value of the y operator.

Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12

Page 15: The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12. Trivial vs Topological 1 Trivial Topological 1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in

What is topological about the topological state?

Hybrid Wannier Representation:

|hnk1l2〉 =1

∫ 2π

0e−ik2l2 |ψnk1k2〉 dk2

State |hnk1l2〉 is localized at the l2/a unit cell in the y direction andextended in x.

Well defined expectation value of the y operator.

Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12

Page 16: The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12. Trivial vs Topological 1 Trivial Topological 1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in

What is topological about the topological state?

Hybrid Wannier Representation:

|hnk1l2〉 =1

∫ 2π

0e−ik2l2 |ψnk1k2〉 dk2

State |hnk1l2〉 is localized at the l2/a unit cell in the y direction andextended in x.Well defined expectation value of the y operator.

Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12

Page 17: The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12. Trivial vs Topological 1 Trivial Topological 1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in

Trivial vs Topological

1

Trivial

Topological

1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in Electronic StructureNicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 8 / 12

Page 18: The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12. Trivial vs Topological 1 Trivial Topological 1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in

Trivial vs Topological

1

Trivial Topological

1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in Electronic StructureNicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 8 / 12

Page 19: The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12. Trivial vs Topological 1 Trivial Topological 1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in

Quantized Hall Conductivity

The semiclassical Boltzmann theory tells as: k̇ = − e~E

An electric field in the x direction will move states in the y direction

σxy = Ce2

hC = Chern number = number of unit cells after adiabatic cycle

Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 9 / 12

Page 20: The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12. Trivial vs Topological 1 Trivial Topological 1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in

Quantized Hall Conductivity

The semiclassical Boltzmann theory tells as: k̇ = − e~E

An electric field in the x direction will move states in the y direction

σxy = Ce2

h

C = Chern number = number of unit cells after adiabatic cycle

Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 9 / 12

Page 21: The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12. Trivial vs Topological 1 Trivial Topological 1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in

Quantized Hall Conductivity

The semiclassical Boltzmann theory tells as: k̇ = − e~E

An electric field in the x direction will move states in the y direction

σxy = Ce2

hC = Chern number = number of unit cells after adiabatic cycle

Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 9 / 12

Page 22: The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12. Trivial vs Topological 1 Trivial Topological 1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in

Bulk-Boundary Correspondence

Charge moving from the bottom to the top surface.

The only way is if the boundary is conducting.

3

3Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in Electronic StructureNicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 10 / 12

Page 23: The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12. Trivial vs Topological 1 Trivial Topological 1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in

Bulk-Boundary Correspondence

Charge moving from the bottom to the top surface.The only way is if the boundary is conducting.

3

3Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in Electronic StructureNicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 10 / 12

Page 24: The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12. Trivial vs Topological 1 Trivial Topological 1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in

Summary

Topological states cannot be connected to the atomic limit withoutclosing the gap.

Global properties are quantized.Weak perturbation will not affect them.

Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 11 / 12

Page 25: The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12. Trivial vs Topological 1 Trivial Topological 1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in

Summary

Topological states cannot be connected to the atomic limit withoutclosing the gap.Global properties are quantized.

Weak perturbation will not affect them.

Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 11 / 12

Page 26: The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12. Trivial vs Topological 1 Trivial Topological 1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in

Summary

Topological states cannot be connected to the atomic limit withoutclosing the gap.Global properties are quantized.Weak perturbation will not affect them.

Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 11 / 12

Page 27: The Haldane Model - physics.rutgers.edu · Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 7 / 12. Trivial vs Topological 1 Trivial Topological 1Vanderbilt. Berry Phases in

Nicodemos Varnava The Haldane Model September 27, 2017 12 / 12