The Evolution of Snare Drum Grip - · PDF fileThe Evolution of Snare Drum Grips BY JAMES A....

9
PERCUSSIVE NOTES 60 JUNE 2002 T he way in which one holds a drum- stick can drastically affect a player’s technique, the pace of development for a young player, and one’s overall atti- tude toward sound production, or tone, on a drum. Although “rules” on how to hold a stick may seem to be steadfast, these rules have evolved through several schools of thought, and even today are still changing. An examination of written explanations and pictorial representa- tions from the past 200 years regarding “gripping” the stick provides keen insight regarding this evolution of the snare drum grip. EARLY INSTRUCTORS Early nineteenth-century “instructors” (i.e., instructional books) deal entirely with military drumming and describe a grip now labeled “traditional.” One of the earliest books to explain this method of holding the sticks is the 1815 British publication by Samuel Potter that was the basis for most American instructors of the same era. His description of the grip includes two analogies often echoed by others at that time: the right-hand grip is compared to holding a sword and the left-hand grip to holding a pen. Potter says: The right Hand stick to be grasp’d with the whole Hand about two inches and a half from the Top (or more if requir’d)—as Drum sticks are not all of the same Weight: similar to grasp- ing a Sword or Stick when going to play Back-sword. The left to be held between the Thumb and Fore Finger of the left Hand close in the hollow, the Top towards the Wrist leaving the Top of the Stick as much out of the Hand as the other—rest- ing it resembling a Pen when going to Write, only with this exception, between the first Joints of the Second and Third Fingers.” Note that Potter states that the “whole hand” is to grasp the right-hand stick. In contrast to this, Ashworth (1812) identi- fies the little finger as the primary finger gripping the right stick, and more clearly specifies where the left stick lies on the third finger: “The upper, or left hand stick…must be firmly held between the The Evolution of Snare Drum Grips BY JAMES A. STRAIN Thumb and two middle fingers, to rest on the third finger a little above the middle joint. The lower, or right hand stick must be held fast with the little finger and be allowed to play with ease through the others, as a man may use a stick in fenc- ing.” LATE NINETEENTH-CENTURY METHODS In 1861, Howe takes the opposite opin- ion regarding the role of each finger for the right hand: “The stick in the right hand should be held naturally; that is, it should pass between the thumb and fin- gers; the little finger should be loosely closed around it, and it should be held firmly with the thumb and fore-finger. “The stick in the left hand should pass between the thumb and two forefingers, and over the third and fourth, the first and second closed round it to the thumb.” Bruce (1862) differs, saying that the left hand “should grasp the stick firmly, but not too tight, between the thumb and first two fingers, passing over the third, and resting a little below the middle (or large) joint; the thumb in the meantime resting on the forefinger.” Note that he specifies the thumb should rest on the first finger, whereas Howe instructed the reader to close two fingers to the thumb. For the right hand, Bruce adopts both the fencing analogy and the little finger as the primary point of contact: “The stick in the right hand should be held be- tween the thumb and fingers lightly, with the little finger pressing it, so as to play through the hand, as a man would use a stick in fencing.” In a British publication, Elliott (1884) introduces two analogies, one similar to a sword, another to a spoon: “One drum- stick should be grasped firmly in the right hand in the same manner as when one is going to strike a blow with an ordi- nary stick, while the other should be held in the left hand somewhat similar to the way in which we should hold a spoon, only the stick should be passed between the middle fingers and allowed to rest upon the second joint of the third finger, the thumb being used to hold the stick with. The drum-sticks should be thus grasped about four inches from the top of each.” By “top,” Elliott is referring to the butt end of the stick, as the sticks hang down- ward to the drum. Other writers mention the distance one should hold the stick from the butt end in various ways. For example, Sousa states: “The right hand should grasp the stick at about two inches from the end, the thumb well un- der; and the left hand should hold the stick lightly, between the thumb and first two fingers, passing over the third, and resting on the first joint, the thumb on the fore-finger.” This “thumb on the fore- finger” for the left hand occurs in many descriptions, including Flockton’s (1898), which states: “Close the thumb against the side of the first finger, and hold the stick only tight enough to handle it.” TURN-OF-THE-CENTURY METHODS Langey (1891) provides one of the clearest early descriptions regarding the distance from the butt end and all four fingers of the left hand: “The right stick is held between the first joint of the middle finger and the inside tip of the thumb at a point about four and one-half inches from the butt end. The remaining fingers curve under the stick and control it without interfering with its free action. The left-hand stick is held between the thumb and fore finger, the butt end lying in the hollow, passed between the second and third fingers, and rests on the first joint of the third finger, the butt end pro- jecting out about the same distance as with the right hand. The tips of the fin- gers are bent towards the palm of the hand.” Flockton (1898) introduces a new anal- ogy for the right hand that recurs well into the twentieth century: “The stick in the right hand should be held very much like a hammer… The little finger should hold the stick the tightest, and each fin- ger looser and looser in succession, the first finger leaving the stick free. The ball of the thumb should rest against the side of the first finger.” De Ville (1905) is also quite explicit re- garding the point one holds the stick:

Transcript of The Evolution of Snare Drum Grip - · PDF fileThe Evolution of Snare Drum Grips BY JAMES A....

Page 1: The Evolution of Snare Drum Grip - · PDF fileThe Evolution of Snare Drum Grips BY JAMES A. STRAIN Thumb and two middle fingers, to rest on ... TURN-OF-THE-CENTURY METHODS Langey (1891)

PERCUSSIVE NOTES 60 JUNE 2002

The way in which one holds a drum-stick can drastically affect a player’stechnique, the pace of development

for a young player, and one’s overall atti-tude toward sound production, or tone,on a drum. Although “rules” on how tohold a stick may seem to be steadfast,these rules have evolved through severalschools of thought, and even today arestill changing. An examination of writtenexplanations and pictorial representa-tions from the past 200 years regarding“gripping” the stick provides keen insightregarding this evolution of the snaredrum grip.

EARLY INSTRUCTORSEarly nineteenth-century “instructors”

(i.e., instructional books) deal entirelywith military drumming and describe agrip now labeled “traditional.” One of theearliest books to explain this method ofholding the sticks is the 1815 Britishpublication by Samuel Potter that wasthe basis for most American instructorsof the same era. His description of thegrip includes two analogies often echoedby others at that time: the right-handgrip is compared to holding a sword andthe left-hand grip to holding a pen.

Potter says: “The right Hand stick tobe grasp’d with the whole Hand abouttwo inches and a half from the Top (ormore if requir’d)—as Drum sticks are notall of the same Weight: similar to grasp-ing a Sword or Stick when going to playBack-sword. The left to be held betweenthe Thumb and Fore Finger of the leftHand close in the hollow, the Top towardsthe Wrist leaving the Top of the Stick asmuch out of the Hand as the other—rest-ing it resembling a Pen when going toWrite, only with this exception, betweenthe first Joints of the Second and ThirdFingers.”

Note that Potter states that the “wholehand” is to grasp the right-hand stick. Incontrast to this, Ashworth (1812) identi-fies the little finger as the primary fingergripping the right stick, and more clearlyspecifies where the left stick lies on thethird finger: “The upper, or left handstick…must be firmly held between the

The Evolution of Snare Drum GripsBY JAMES A. STRAIN

Thumb and two middle fingers, to rest onthe third finger a little above the middlejoint. The lower, or right hand stick mustbe held fast with the little finger and beallowed to play with ease through theothers, as a man may use a stick in fenc-ing.”

LATE NINETEENTH-CENTURY METHODSIn 1861, Howe takes the opposite opin-

ion regarding the role of each finger forthe right hand: “The stick in the righthand should be held naturally; that is, itshould pass between the thumb and fin-gers; the little finger should be looselyclosed around it, and it should be heldfirmly with the thumb and fore-finger.

“The stick in the left hand should passbetween the thumb and two forefingers,and over the third and fourth, the firstand second closed round it to the thumb.”

Bruce (1862) differs, saying that theleft hand “should grasp the stick firmly,but not too tight, between the thumb andfirst two fingers, passing over the third,and resting a little below the middle (orlarge) joint; the thumb in the meantimeresting on the forefinger.” Note that hespecifies the thumb should rest on thefirst finger, whereas Howe instructed thereader to close two fingers to the thumb.

For the right hand, Bruce adopts boththe fencing analogy and the little fingeras the primary point of contact: “Thestick in the right hand should be held be-tween the thumb and fingers lightly, withthe little finger pressing it, so as to playthrough the hand, as a man would use astick in fencing.”

In a British publication, Elliott (1884)introduces two analogies, one similar to asword, another to a spoon: “One drum-stick should be grasped firmly in theright hand in the same manner as whenone is going to strike a blow with an ordi-nary stick, while the other should be heldin the left hand somewhat similar to theway in which we should hold a spoon,only the stick should be passed betweenthe middle fingers and allowed to restupon the second joint of the third finger,the thumb being used to hold the stickwith. The drum-sticks should be thus

grasped about four inches from the top ofeach.”

By “top,” Elliott is referring to the buttend of the stick, as the sticks hang down-ward to the drum. Other writers mentionthe distance one should hold the stickfrom the butt end in various ways. Forexample, Sousa states: “The right handshould grasp the stick at about twoinches from the end, the thumb well un-der; and the left hand should hold thestick lightly, between the thumb and firsttwo fingers, passing over the third, andresting on the first joint, the thumb onthe fore-finger.” This “thumb on the fore-finger” for the left hand occurs in manydescriptions, including Flockton’s (1898),which states: “Close the thumb againstthe side of the first finger, and hold thestick only tight enough to handle it.”

TURN-OF-THE-CENTURY METHODSLangey (1891) provides one of the

clearest early descriptions regarding thedistance from the butt end and all fourfingers of the left hand: “The right stickis held between the first joint of themiddle finger and the inside tip of thethumb at a point about four and one-halfinches from the butt end. The remainingfingers curve under the stick and controlit without interfering with its free action.The left-hand stick is held between thethumb and fore finger, the butt end lyingin the hollow, passed between the secondand third fingers, and rests on the firstjoint of the third finger, the butt end pro-jecting out about the same distance aswith the right hand. The tips of the fin-gers are bent towards the palm of thehand.”

Flockton (1898) introduces a new anal-ogy for the right hand that recurs wellinto the twentieth century: “The stick inthe right hand should be held very muchlike a hammer… The little finger shouldhold the stick the tightest, and each fin-ger looser and looser in succession, thefirst finger leaving the stick free. Theball of the thumb should rest against theside of the first finger.”

De Ville (1905) is also quite explicit re-garding the point one holds the stick:

Page 2: The Evolution of Snare Drum Grip - · PDF fileThe Evolution of Snare Drum Grips BY JAMES A. STRAIN Thumb and two middle fingers, to rest on ... TURN-OF-THE-CENTURY METHODS Langey (1891)

PERCUSSIVE NOTES 61 JUNE 2002

Page 3: The Evolution of Snare Drum Grip - · PDF fileThe Evolution of Snare Drum Grips BY JAMES A. STRAIN Thumb and two middle fingers, to rest on ... TURN-OF-THE-CENTURY METHODS Langey (1891)

PERCUSSIVE NOTES 62 JUNE 2002

“The right-hand stick is grasped with thewhole hand, so that the little finger willbe about three or four inches from thebutt-end. The left-hand stick is held be-tween the thumb and the fore-finger…the butt-end projecting out about thesame distance as with the right hand.”

Bower (1898) in his Imperial Methodincludes an illustration as the primarymeans of explaining the grip with the fol-lowing comments: “The right stick shouldbe grasped about two inches from the endwith the whole hand being about parallelwith the knuckles. The back of the handshould be inward as in cut No. 1. Graspthe left stick the same distance from theend between the thumb and first two fin-gers of the left hand, with the palm of thehand inward, as in cut No. 2.” Note thedirections in which the palm and back ofthe hand should face.

By 1911, however, Bower uses a pic-ture to illustrate the grip, including in-structions for the right hand that state:“The stick being held loosely, principallyby the Thumb and first two Fingers, alsothe other Fingers must touch the Stick(more or less) while drumming.” For theleft, along with the picture he states:“Note the Thumb resting on the first Fin-ger, also the little Finger and one next to

it inclined somewhat towards the centerof the hand.” One notes that within onedecade Bower has changed his right-hand grip from the “whole hand” grip tojust using the thumb and first two fin-gers.

Rollinson (1906) provides quite exten-sive directions for the grip. For the lefthand, he states: “Turn the palm of thehand up. Open the first two fingers, turn

Bower 1911 Bower 1911

Bower 1898

Page 4: The Evolution of Snare Drum Grip - · PDF fileThe Evolution of Snare Drum Grips BY JAMES A. STRAIN Thumb and two middle fingers, to rest on ... TURN-OF-THE-CENTURY METHODS Langey (1891)

PERCUSSIVE NOTES 63 JUNE 2002

the third and fourth down, until theynearly touch the palm. Lay the stick inthe hollow between the thumb and firstfinger; let it cross the third finger be-tween the second and third joints. Thenclose the first and second fingers aroundthe stick, the thumb also closing aroundit and resting on the side of the first fin-ger. The stick should balance on the handin such a way, that when the thumb andfirst two fingers are raised, the small end(tip) of the stick will drop over the thirdfinger. The thumb and first finger shouldhave the firmest grip.”

For the right hand, he says: “Turn thepalm of the hand down. Close the fingersaround the stick, which should be heldnearly parallel with the knuckles. Thethumb should close as in the left hand.Balance the stick so that if the fingerswere opened, the small end would dropover the thumb. The little finger shouldclose around the stick, more firmly thanthe others, and each consecutive fingerwith a consecutively weaker grip. Thiswill give much more power than if thestick is held by the first finger alone.”Note that he continues with the little fin-ger as the primary finger for the grip inthe right hand, and that the stick is par-allel with the knuckles, similar toBower’s early description. He also men-tions that the palm should be down—oneof the first to clearly state this.

EARLY TWENTIETH-CENTURY METHODSDodge (1917) uses numerous pictures

and frames from moving pictures to illus-trate the grip and strokes. Using the“hammer” analogy, he states: “The rightstick is held by the thumb and first twofingers. The other two fingers touch thestick lightly but do not grip the stick, andthe butt (thick end) of the stick restsagainst the heel of the hand. About theway you would hold a light tack ham-mer.”

For the left stick, he says: “Curve thethumb around the stick, gripping it verylightly. The stick rests on the first joint ofthe fourth finger and the little finger sup-ports the fourth finger, but does nottouch the stick. The index and middlefingers do not touch the stick except occa-sionally to keep it from falling out of thethumb hold. Be sure not to cramp thefourth finger.” Note that he is clearlystating that the thumb holds the leftstick, not the thumb and the first and/orsecond fingers.

Gardner (1919), writing a method forconcert—not military—drumming states:“The left stick is held in the crotch of thethumb and forefinger. The first and sec-ond fingers rest above the stick while thethird and fourth fingers rest beneath thestick. Great care should be taken to avoida protruding finger. All the fingers shouldbe wholly relaxed, but with sufficientelasticity to return to position when dis-placed by stick action. The right stick isheld between the inside tip of the thumband the first joint of the middle finger.The three remaining fingers rest uponthe stick in the same relaxed manner asthe fingers in the left hand.” Clear pic-tures are given for several angles of thegrip.

Inside View of Left Hand

Outside View of Right Hand

Of importance for Gardner is a note,clearly acknowledging the military styleof holding the stick. “A right-hand posi-tion common among military drums inthis country consists of holding the sticklike a hammer, grasping it between littlefinger and palm. This position has the ob-vious disadvantage of control on but oneside of the fulcrum and is not to be rec-ommended. Many drummers playing inthis manner, however, have excellenttechnic.”

By acknowledging this second tech-nique, Gardner makes one aware of twoparallel methods of performing, based onstyle of drumming. Bower has hinted atthis, and as the twentieth centuryprogresses, it becomes clear that differ-ent grips are used for different musicalstyles of drumming.

Among those players with excellenttechnique, as mentioned by Gardner, wasSanford A. Moeller, who, in his 1925method takes exactly the opposite pointof view on the right hand by stating: “Theillustrations are so clear that words areunnecessary, but the attention might bedrawn to the fact that the right stick isheld almost entirely with the little fingeras in Plate No. 7. When the stick isplaced on the drum the other fingers areclosed around the stick, but very lightly,if touching it at all. The left stick isgrasped between the thumb and first fin-ger. The pressure on the drum head ismade with the first finger, the second fin-ger acts more as a guide. The third fingeris the one under the stick and is used topick it up.”

He goes on to defend the right hand“little finger” grip by referring to sevenprevious methods (including Flockton,Potter, and Langey) that suggest thisgrip. Note that he also uses the first fin-ger of the left hand as a primary meansof striking the stick to the drumhead, incontrast to using the thumb, as stated byDodge.

Page 5: The Evolution of Snare Drum Grip - · PDF fileThe Evolution of Snare Drum Grips BY JAMES A. STRAIN Thumb and two middle fingers, to rest on ... TURN-OF-THE-CENTURY METHODS Langey (1891)

PERCUSSIVE NOTES 64 JUNE 2002

Page 6: The Evolution of Snare Drum Grip - · PDF fileThe Evolution of Snare Drum Grips BY JAMES A. STRAIN Thumb and two middle fingers, to rest on ... TURN-OF-THE-CENTURY METHODS Langey (1891)

PERCUSSIVE NOTES 65 JUNE 2002

Scott (1930) includes clear photo-graphs with the following directions forthe left hand: “Place drum stick betweenthumb and forefinger, allowing it to restbetween the first and second joint of thethird finger. Close the first and secondfingers over drum stick but add no pres-sure.”

For the right hand, along with photo-graphs, it states: “Close middle finger,not tightly, but merely enough to keepthe stick from falling from the hand.Close remaining fingers, but rememberthat the right stick is controlled mainlyby the middle finger.” Note that Scott’sright full-hand grip, clearly illustrated bya photograph, is identical to Heney’s(1933), both of whom are writing prima-rily for a military style of drumming.

In contrast to the military style, Little(ca. 1930), writing specifically for a“swing” style drummer, states: “Left-hand stick: this rests in the hollow be-tween the thumb and first finger and isheld between the second and third fin-gers, palm upwards. Right-hand stick:this is grasped with the palm downwardsand lightly held between the first fingerand the thumb: the three other fingersmerely assist in controlling the positionof the stick, without in any way grippingit.” His illustration shows the stick posi-tioned in the second knuckle of the righthand, not the first. Of interest is thatLittle discusses the various styles ofdrumming (concert, military, and dance),but makes no distinction regarding thegrip for these styles.

Scott Scott

Page 7: The Evolution of Snare Drum Grip - · PDF fileThe Evolution of Snare Drum Grips BY JAMES A. STRAIN Thumb and two middle fingers, to rest on ... TURN-OF-THE-CENTURY METHODS Langey (1891)

PERCUSSIVE NOTES 66 JUNE 2002

The 1937 Sears Home Study CourseDrum Method (containing the exact, du-plicated material regarding the grip asthe Haskell Harr method, though notcredited to him) includes complete pic-tures and makes a clear distinction be-tween a rudimental right-hand grip anda grip for “light playing.” For the rudi-mental right-hand grip it states: “Gripthe stick firmly with the second finger asshown in figure 1. The other fingers andthe thumb close loosely around the stick,permitting it to hinge on the second fin-ger. Turn the hand over and you willhave the closed hand position for playingas shown in figure 2.”

For light playing, one is directed toFigure 3 and to “hold the hand in thesame position as figure 1, placing thestick so that it will rest across the secondjoint of the first finger, then place thethumb on the stick opposite the secondjoint of the first finger, close the secondfinger as before, and turn the hand overfor playing. The stick will pivot betweenthe thumb and first finger. Retain aslight grip with the second finger.”

Of interest regarding the right-handmilitary style grip is the contrasting gripthat Moore (1937) uses when he states:“The right-hand stick must be heldagainst the first finger with the thumballowing freedom at heel of stick for con-trol. See Fig. B.”

This is a clear shift from the little ormiddle finger as primary point of controlfrom previous military methods, includ-ing the Harr, written in the same year.Also note that the thumb is not parallelto the stick, instead using the side of thethumb to press against the stick.

In contrast to Moore’s “first finger”right-hand grip, Berryman (1940) usesthe “tip” of the thumb and the second fin-ger. For the right hand, he states: “Thestick is held between the tip of the thumband the first joint of the second finger. Inplaying, the other fingers rest lightlyupon the stick.” He further points out,“While drum instructors may disagreeslightly on minor points regarding thecorrect manner of holding the sticks, themethod here described is most successfulfor concert band or orchestras. For drumcorps or dance orchestra some othermethods may be advantageous.”

One such method, written in 1942 withthe dance orchestra drummer in mind, isby Buddy Rich and Henry Adler. For theright-hand grip, Rich and Adler state,“Grasp the stick with the thumb and firstfinger of the right hand, at about two-thirds of the distance from the knob (tip)of the stick (the center of balance). The

second, third and fourth fingers act in anauxiliary capacity as they aid in control-ling the various movements of the stick.The palm of the hand is turned down-ward, upon striking the drum.

“The left hand stick is held at abouttwo-thirds of the distance from the knob(tip) of the stick (the center of balance) inthe crotch formed by the thumb and firstfinger. The second finger, acting as aguide, is placed on top of the stick. Thethird and fourth fingers, placed underthe stick, act in an auxiliary capacity,while controlling the ‘Swing’ of the stick.The palm of the hand is turned towardthe body, upon striking the drum.” Notethat they shift some guidance of the left-hand stick to the middle finger, and thatthey clearly discuss the direction bothpalms face as one strikes the drum.

Of major importance in the Rich-Adlermethod is the inclusion of the comment,“After all of the rudiments and exercisesin this book have been thoroughlylearned, the student may then practicethem by holding the sticks timpani fash-ion as shown.” This is one of the firstmethods to advocate what is to becomethe “matched grip” for general use in per-forming. It should be noted that it was astandard enough practice for drummersto use this “timpani” style by the timethe method was written, that they in-cluded two pictures of the style in thebook.

LATER TWENTIETH-CENTURY METHODSOne other method is necessary to illus-

trate the wide variety of exact position-ing possible for the traditional grip, aswell as an additional analogy. Mott

Figure 1

Figure 2

Figure 3

Page 8: The Evolution of Snare Drum Grip - · PDF fileThe Evolution of Snare Drum Grips BY JAMES A. STRAIN Thumb and two middle fingers, to rest on ... TURN-OF-THE-CENTURY METHODS Langey (1891)

PERCUSSIVE NOTES 67 JUNE 2002

(1956) states: “The right stick is held be-tween the thumb and the second joint ofthe middle finger, palm down with the re-maining fingers curled over the sticklightly but securely. Hold it as you wouldhold a knife to cut a cake. The left stick isheld palm up, in the hollow between thethumb and forefinger, the first two fin-gers curling over the stick. The last twofingers are under the stick, close togetherwith the tips almost straight out, and inposition to lift the stick. If these two fin-gers touch the palm it will cramp yourmuscles. The stick rests on the third fin-ger which acts as a shelf.” Note that Mottspecifically says the second joint of themiddle finger for the right hand, and thatthe left hand’s “last two” fingers shouldbe almost straight out (i.e., not curved to-ward the palm).

By 1964, Leach identifies three gripsrecognized by percussionists. The first isthe “most common field and concert grip.”He states, “The thumb and forefingerform the fulcrum in both the left andright hands. In the right hand, the sec-ond finger is used for additional fine con-trol, but the third and fourth fingersshould not touch the stick at any time.”

The second grip is one “which hasachieved more popularity in the jazz anddance field but has also become acceptedin the classical field because this type ofexecution allows for a finer, more delicatetouch and a greater sensitivity of sound.The thumb and forefingers are the onlygrips on either stick, thus allowing theother fingers to be used in motivatingand controlling the sticks. This is knownas ‘finger technique’.”

The third grip illustrated by Leach isthe “timpani style” or “like-handmethod.” He clearly advocates this stylefor use on drumset when playing addi-tional Latin instruments or a solo on thefloor tom, and mentions that many per-formers use this grip as a supplement totheir traditional method of holding thesticks.

Educationally, this third grip men-tioned by Leach is renamed the “matchedgrip” and assumes a position of impor-tance by the early 1970s. Schinstine andHoey include it as secondary method ofholding the sticks in 1972, and by 1976advocate it as follows in their SnareDrum Primer: “In the opinion of the au-thors, the Matched Grip should be recom-mended for the beginning percussionist.”Supporting this move toward the use of

matched grip, Faulmann (1976) includescomplete directions for matched as wellas traditional, even justifying matchedgrip as compatible for marching due tothe invention of the “High Stepper” car-rier.

Of interest during the last quarter ofthe twentieth century is a move toward amore restricted grip in the right hand,whereby all fingers and thumb grasp thestick. For the right hand, Whaley (1980)states: “The stick is held between thefleshy part of the thumb and the firstjoint of the index finger. The butt of thestick fits naturally in the main crease ofthe palm and the remaining three fingerswrap firmly around the stick. Notice thatthe stick is equally supported by thethumb and index finger and, the lastthree fingers.”

He then reiterates, with illustrationsand captions, that “The stick is held be-tween the fleshy part of the thumb andthe first joint of the index finger. Thisprovides 50% of the grip…The last threefingers wrap firmly around the stick.This provides 50% of the grip.”

For the left hand, in addition to the ac-cepted normal directions, Whaley in-cludes the statement “Note that the wristis cocked in toward the body.” This is oneof the few occurrences where a methodadvocates something other than astraight-wrist approach to the grip.

Wessels (1992) includes almost identi-cal directions as Whaley, echoing the po-sition of the right hand stick as “in themain crease of the palm with the remain-ing three fingers wrapping firmly aroundthe stick.” However, later on the samepage he includes the admonition that“you must be very careful to not squeezethe stick with the back fingers.”

By the end of the twentieth century,the most common method for describingthe right-hand grip might be one similarto that used by Breithaupt (1991), whostates: “Place the stick between the firstjoint of the first finger and the flat, orfleshy part of the thumb, one-third thedistance from the butt-end of the stick.This is the fulcrum point of the snaredrum stick. Position the stick so the palmfaces the floor.” He continues with “bringthe fingers around the stick. The fingerswill not be controlling the stick to a greatextent at this point, but should stay incontact with the stick during all parts ofthe stroke.”

It should be noted that many books

have no directions whatsoever, and thatmethods written for drumset playershave only in recent years begun to illus-trate the various positions the handmight assume (i.e., thumbs up) when per-forming on the ride cymbal, as opposed tothe snare drum. The single picture inAlfred’s Beginning Drumset Method(1990) clearly illustrates a “palm down”position for the ride cymbal. PeterErskine’s Drum Concepts and Techniques(1987) and Drumset Essentials (2002)have photos of the right-hand grip in thepalm-down position, but also show theright hand in thumb-up position, whichhe advocates for ride-cymbal playing.

Also of interest in one publication is anexample of a common practice amongdrumset players when using matchedgrip, that is, the use of a “thumbs up” po-sition as the primary position for bothsticks. In Pearl’s An Introduction to theBasics of Drumming (1998), a bookletthat accompanies new drumsets, thesingle picture for matched grip shows thesticks parallel to each other, with thethumbs on the top of both sticks.

Although there are generally just two“grips” for holding the sticks—matchedand traditional—a survey of knownmethods identifies numerous variationsin the exact way the sticks may be held,not for matched and traditional, but forthe left and the right hand. The grips,both left hand and right hand, continue

Page 9: The Evolution of Snare Drum Grip - · PDF fileThe Evolution of Snare Drum Grips BY JAMES A. STRAIN Thumb and two middle fingers, to rest on ... TURN-OF-THE-CENTURY METHODS Langey (1891)

PERCUSSIVE NOTES 68 JUNE 2002

to evolve even today. A quick search onthe Internet might enlighten one to gen-eral discussion of where the stick lieswhen using a traditional left-hand grip,not in regards to the thumb and first twofingers, but on which knuckle, or eventhe cuticle of the ring finger, the stickshould lie! As an ever-evolving process,the “grip” for the right and left handscontinues to warrant examination andexplanation for any true student orteacher of percussion, based on the usesand styles required for each musical per-formance.

BIBLIOGRAPHYAshworth, Charles Stewart. (1812). A New

Useful and Complete System of Drum Beat-ing. Washington, D.C.

Berryman, Joe. (1940). Carl Fischer BasicMethod for the Drums. New York: CarlFischer

Bower, Harry A. (1911). The Harry A. BowerSystem (in Three Parts) for Drums, Bells,Xylophone, Tympani. Boston: Bower. Re-vised edition (1912). New York: CarlFischer.

Bower, Harry A. (1898). Imperial Method forthe Drum. Philadelphia: John Church.

Breithaupt, Robert B. (1991). The CompletePercussionist, A Guidebook for the MusicEducator. Oskaloosa, IA: C. L. Barnhouse.

Bruce, George B. & Emmett, Daniel. (1862).Drummer’s and Fifer’s Guide: or Self-In-structor. New York.

De Ville, Paul. (1905). The Eclipse Instructor

for the Drum, including Camp Duty andPopular Tunes for Fife and Drum. NewYork: Carl Fischer.

Dodge, Frank. (1917). Drumming SuccessfullyTaught by Mail, Drum Beats Illustratedand Analyzed by Means of Actual MovingPicture Photographs. Boston: InternationalTrumpet School.

Elliott, J. Arthur. (1884). Drums and Fifes;and How to Beat and Play Them. The BoysOwn Paper. London.

Erskine, Peter. (1987). Drum Concepts andTechniques. Milwaukee, WI. 21st Century/Hal Leonard.

Erskine, Peter. (2002). Drumset Essentials.Van Nuys, CA: Alfred.

Feldstein, Sandy & Black, Dave. (1990).Alfred’s Beginning Drumset Method. VanNuys, CA: Alfred.

Flockton, J. M. (1898). Jean Whites’s Editionof Flockton’s New Method for the SideDrum, Xylophone, and Tympani. Boston:Jean White.

Gardner, Carl. (1919). The Gardner ModernMethod for the Instruments of Percussion.Enlarged and revised edition (1945). NewYork: Carl Fischer.

Harr, Haskell W. (1937). Drum Method. Chi-cago: M. M. Cole.

Heney, John J. (1933). The Correct Way toDrum. St. Augustine, FL: Heney.

Howe, Elias. (1861). Howe’s United StatesRegulation Drum and Fife Instructor, forthe Use of the Army and Navy. Boston:Howe.

Langey, Otto. (1891). Carl Fischer’s New and

Revised Edition of Celebrated Tutors for theDrum, Xylophone, Timpanies, and Casta-nets. New York: Carl Fischer.

Leach, Joel. (1964). Percussion Manual forMusic Educators. New York: Henry Adler.Copyright assigned 1966 to Belwin, Inc.,Rockville Centre, NY.

Little, Eric. (n.d., ca. 1930). Premier Tutor forDrums, Cymbals, and Accessories. London:Premier Drum Co., Ltd.

Moeller, Sanford A. (1925). Ludwig Instructorin the Art of Snare Drumming. Chicago:Ludwig & Ludwig.

Moore, J. Burns. (1937). The Art of Drum-ming. Chicago: W.F.L. Drum Co.

Mott, Vincent L. (1956). Evolution of Drum-ming, The Golden Drum Instructor, Text-book of the Snare Drum. Miami: CharlesHansen.

Potter, Samuel. (1815). The Art of Beating theDrum. London: Henry Potter.

Rich, Buddy & Adler, Henry. (1942). BuddyRich’s Modern Interpretation of SnareDrum Rudiments. New York: Embassy Mu-sic Co.

Rollinson, Thomas H. (1906). Modern Schoolfor the Drum, Tympani, Xylophone andGlockenspiel. Boston: Oliver Ditson.

Schinstine, William J. & Hoey, Fred A. (1972).Percussion Method, Basic Drum Book. SanAntonio: Southern Music Co.

Schinstine, William J. & Hoey, Fred A. (1976).Snare Drum Primer. Pacific, MO: Mel Bay.

Scott, Andrew V. (1930). Leedy BeginnersDrum Method. Indianapolis: Leedy Mfg. Co.

Sears Home Study Course Drum Method.(1937). Chicago: M. M. Cole.

Sousa, John P. (1886). Book of Instruction forthe Field-Trumpet and Drum. (Reprint Chi-cago: WFL Drum Co., 1954).Washington,D.C.: Sousa.

Wessels, Mark. (1992). A Fresh Approach tothe Snare Drum for Classroom or Indi-vidual Study. DeSoto, TX: Wessels.

Whaley, Garwood. (1980). Primary Handbookfor Snare Drum. Fort Lauderdale, FL:Meredith Music Publications.

James A. Strain holds a DMA degree inPercussion Performance and Literaturefrom the Eastman School of Music, anM.M. degree in Percussion Performancefrom the University of Cincinnati, and aBME degree from Arkansas State Uni-versity. He teaches percussion and musictheory at Northern Michigan Universityand is Timpanist of the Marquette Sym-phony Orchestra. Strain is Co-Historianfor the PAS and an associate editor forPercussive Notes. PN