The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

248
8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD ﻧﺸﻮء اﻟﺘﻌﺎون روﺑﺮ أﻛﺴﻴﻠﺮودhttp://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 1/248

Transcript of The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

Page 1: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 1/248

Page 2: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 2/248

 

!"#$%&' )*+, 

!"#$%&'( *#+",

 

-.#/0-1#2( 345

6%78/" -9:(#50"8%; <=>1,

 

Page 3: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 3/248

(?@ABCDE(

 

" #$%&'()*FGHI <"=9JB( +(,(-./01(234567896:;<=6>"$%965<?(@6A.B(*BC(D)96E;FG(H-I6(JKL"MNOPQK)8&6RS'()K96/TU)96FR96V(?34W(JX96EHK96G(YMC(2(%Z([0T)8@5<?P0*\K]&BC(D)^9BM_`a&>b(4\@c0Z(Zd6\&R96NB<D8&N.W6GCe`f(g@hW6<i6<Z(*j<kl]a4CMm&G(Q@/&G(nCM

6o6_1MhpJ0?NB<Kqr(JS/s^i/&t*_@uk6_qevp4MOFC_&(J9+_,CGoC_^08*M/gk+N<s,'(D9M'<i(?wE`2V_?M(`01

x@(Zy96zBC(D)=6{"w$?6<96w$?6<,#+6G(g)Z6|/^SR@p*}~&(•(%0Hsq34P0€mi6C\@m06<=6|/4<J)=6}‚%&C>ƒ,()*6RSP0*\K]&W6_%^9(D0„BM6<%  # Hs&…o(H=6/0ZC(D)9634|e•(0?BMC6<]  # ^D&…o(H@BC(D)96\&_†‡9O

 *#+", !"#$%&'K  0 A()iM"<^D96/0i(0896/i(0896C/@(D96>/D@(-|B(ˆ0Q0@<SC:0@V>wt‰(-r(@_YGŠ EH†C$‰6G>/&_aZ/HD^96W(*R96C‹4(JsŒN6"<^4C

W(0?d6/0‰(%qGN60]J)96CŽ(&_96/&_aZC$0%D)96O0D&>BŠ |G<,GŠ >B(ˆ0Q0@O  

Page 4: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 4/248

!" !)*+#,-./0123 7289:';!<=$%&'>

 ?$*'@A&';!B.%5#'$CD!"<EH$I@;HJKG'

LM >!"NO;P"BQ'RSDTF23U56?V$B3;

?$ >23;HWXYRS P.%5#!EMZ$O!"[$)[\']0M ^9%&';]48.)&'

 !"" $%&'() $*)*$+*,-

012 3*01) 4%('

_$5 ;0]0abIDc93 e93!EMZ'

 

f;hijkO@hi;Lblm<%E7@$/nT@F$o#'$%&'T@$p5&TMZ'qW)&';@$SFrV';!6'gOs3At%3 5"6

 j<".%uvAwxnyEABu?$"OF0!EMZ'@$`dG';D@'!o.8&';z{B|#';?$)*+#';!"<.%&'$6G';

DqWK!E0;!}~•MX0€9%u!EMZ$O7$%&' &'q,e93!EMZ'1?$‚MuHJKG!"#$K!ƒ43M3$I;

 !"<EF$60D!"<.KDME@$Bu;„$kO0;!B.%53$")&$O €%) ,e93!EMZ'1xnyEABu…$59&']M`{&'j#$%&''DL-[†5)"&$C$t{=4OWEAOF'Ao5*W&T@F$‡3;'

 ˆK‰$/;G'‰$)[\';7$%&'LM%&'>

"""#$%&'()(*+,))%--(#.)/

/ 60$( /7 ('%) 8//9 302 8* $*6$/,5:*, %1 012 7/

/5( ('* 6$%/$ 6*$3%))%/1 /7 ;%180$0"'5$$%220 <*

Š!‹4{Œe9#!EMZ'>V<)ETF$KŽO@'A=n'RS &']†Om`:23DH$`:G'Vn‰ŽOj8XPo)323 EMd

 

 3mI'yKF'4S;g3

f$   9‡& B&'m‘$*;;'DvA’' BE

?$*'@F;Dm‘$*4&'“@$B.& %&'

]R&' <"S 

$3 /$ 82

3>

 

s"‚ BZ'

Page 5: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 5/248

 "#$%&'()*+, 0

"#$%&' () '*&#+  

,sƒ4u0‰0AI0!<`l;0W30$9)9”]go&'7!o%&D_4*$l2`&;$SDjS7_$56F;M.")6'>Y;Mƒ'>1

–;MO —45* D–@4E4"[ !EV; !%3$I D‰4)34u -E4&>

 ,$[@$`d02K‰;$%5&'hN55*V!&$Œ>>>'RS_$5`&''n$3Y$[0MƒY$9oK45*';Y$9B   o/;‰4`")dc&P"<KM˜G'>1

H$[@4I ™Eš* H;; Dz5)"[@46 H$"['F>

 ,q$t*ns‘'@7!EM›[D‰;$%5&'Aƒ;U5  œ 6_4.*†O';hi;]A".Bu$žm%I_$5`&'!%53“@$B.&>1

™9<".O$* ]@'š"& b<E$u> ,c['_$5`&j9im`ŸOhiDv4&†3V;AO‰0‰4`E'A"{3m`&“M3'y5t3g9O–4.)&'—;$%5&';0c%93>1

™9"<p[$3 A[ b")"&$[' ¡&4O !{"k=

 ,¢".Xb"<5323m".k5&'D]M›9&'m"&A&';D^EM8&'¢<[;Š@$Xv4&†<.&23

£ko&'j<.%&'>>>q$ƒc"d¤^&+#'¥P"o85O!.¦%3zp)&'ˆKs"'43D€5:…@A5u23+/'45&'zO?$6g&'xn§@45&'j`EM3G'7q$95"d>1

H -<"I>-9E$* DA&4i ™['Mi H;@$6; A&4i>

 

Page 6: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 6/248

1 &'()*+, %"#$

 

Page 7: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 7/248

 "#$%&'()*+, 2

A"t¨H;G' ab”'©!3AB3

">‰;$%5&' !.`Ÿ3

 —$|&' ab”'©‰;$%5&' T†Ÿ[#>0Ao3 ª$p[$TAl'4O TAl'4&'%_4*$Z' _$%&0 7&>‰;$%5&' «E@†u 

£&$|&' ab”'©‰;AO ‰;$%5&'Th‡O ;0 !ƒ'A= q$›[$¬"%E –hi fF; ¬K%x;G' !"#$%&' _MZ' 7 H$5B&' ŠF$9X 7

'>!"‘$"l\' !<›[G' 7 ‰;$%5&' @48u¤F q$"&; s3>‰45."3$S¥ 

sO'M&' ab”'©zk.‡#'; z6@$Ÿ  œ <.& !k"‡[ (>mK$d m`ŸO @$5® ^"6)>‰;$%5&' …  ;Mu ^"6 

-3$¯' ab”'©'?$I$595**>V' !"9  œ o&'‰;$%5.& !"KJ5I+>HF$o5&' ![$53 

Pk.#'¤0¥©!&48o&' °‘$5[ Pk.#'¤_¥©!EM›9&' ?$"M{&' ˆK zS'MO@F$‡#'m"&A&'

 

Page 8: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 8/248

3 &'()*+, %"#$

 

Page 9: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 9/248

!"#$&'()*+,!-!./01

!"#$%&' )*+, 

 "#$%&' ()*+,-%./012*3+-%456,-712*3891:;<=>?@A*B*6C$D=E*=F%GHI*J-%GK>3L%M1*NO%4PHF7#A#:,Q12*3+-%9R:;<=RSTR7AD=#UQV%9WC%:-*TUTMX-IWC%7G<NYZ-%9GQ[Y-%G<NYK7\*N]%*^QA4\*N]*_U@9*`_><aUTbM

#:,-%95/@c#$da*@e*6'\*NfM#*,=9>gh i6<8\*N]%GN6Q7b%S-%4M7j*B9DQ7b%k D=l;YQ9l;YQj*<-%7mn=G_*,To*3p-%i+-%*`H*+qr:/sL%PHFm*;Y-%4*6aF79tN6Q7b%kASY6uvB:waxy*z+=t{|3=k:H7GNa*aAG;N}BvB~:+J=m*;+aR%

9i<NYZ-%R7\R*Y=GNu*Cm%•$9\*a*<L%€U+'%7€b*‚*ƒ6-*T„k>3-%vB)*JfDQ>g…%4W=9X-ID}_P?=†&'o*Q%SY-%9Gg:J}L%D,}Q#A‡ˆQm‰#:,Q*YQ>C

%SHD=\:gF%9\k7k:-%PNpw+@9P*f#$jD,Q\b7Š-*T*‹NŒ%k:p;=4†&'i'G-*u>-%i+-%<Y8vB12*3+-%M)*+@o>T7bk7>/NJ@%Wy%>-%4

S;-da*@‡Ž'=GT*+,-†&'G=S;L%GNwZu*`6,-7\b>,+=4i3_>g%7AS;Bo*N6N<YJ-%D=#>;-%DQ[<-%‘9S<To%:6uG/N/CD=[a’*+@17F%€:u:L%2./ 

 3456/ 9„&-%17*68“k*Y=€2*z+-%”ah >@&-%‚[-*T9J3+-%7 (dN;/8vBtf\>–  —GK:Z˜D=j*B™*Nui,Q>=AjD@A95_>BA5}uAšo>T7bk7>/NJ@%4d6/BA†&'

GCb:-%GT:+,L%G-…*TG<T*Z-%DBk:H7›G-:ZT)*<-AGNa7|,-%œ.</-GY<-›G/^<=tƒJ-%œ9\b>,+L%SC7cd`  " H7 "$ž„AGCb:-%ž\:BkG@b*z}/-MGJ_*6L%4i,-7

Page 10: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 10/248

!" 784'9+/ ,:;5

#:@A>?@AGCkž#F7ŸNN}+-%m‰x`=36-.YJ-%„&-%P<H¡=%>T):u*]%RX/+¢\pY-%GNB%:-%žS;-i6+BkGCb:-%xQS;+-¡=*a>TE7|,-%:'7„&-%_*6+Nu

MG-:ZY-%4dNzgD=i6aAjD@ASQbAMmSY-%1*ub$G@b*z=4i6,-7 (dN  " ;/8x<  £ Z-%*=*¢Nfi68:`+u%9\>,3-%d};_G¤*J}TG}  " NC\Sf%7¥7[}/-MX/89G/f>L%#$7

da*@GNY/u*B:a*=4#*@k7>/NJ@%%I*+uA€:/</-9GNu*NJ-%i+;Q>ZT7G*O% (o><Œ

5aˆT¦*+q§$¨#7*<8W=j*BM1*©m*NfF%GQb:Z+-%4 (dY+@5-G-*ubxQS;8§$:N/Tk4k4 9#:+/N=*'„&-% (ª  " H>Q5aAi6Q7b%S-%>?@F%%ŸN¢M9*6/NH–5aA”u«-7N-vBSNC

\*N]%9#…%Nf†*_:8PHF%m% ">HG/¬GNb*@*'k*C§$o*T*–:®a:,-%€*B!"""4MS;B9o*N6N<YJ-%#*@#:+/N=*'ŽN=•k7>/NJ@FMG<=*H#*®NzN=D,-7xJ;T>gh D=9*`=*JCAj7¯><Q*¤SfA>g…%M*`6Nf4~S-7i;/89i+-*ub€*Ck7>/NJ@%

GYK*s}T#:+/N=*'9%b:_*a7*<87vB•*ƒa$wY-%„&-%°Yu%&'9)*+,-%„&-%7€ "S  ( C5/,zTŸH:L%MPp3-%=*O%4SC7P¬wY-%3a#%:6<-%„&-%5/}q%&'

9)*+,-%SC7[  ( aMG/©<=*'+/ >?-4@ A €*B#$%#9•*_7\Ÿy*ƒT.=:@:NažSaŽ3N/@

GN<}ƒ/-GN,Q>=F%>Q:Z+-€:/<-%4o[  ( aG<YZ-%GN,Q>=F%§7F%D=)*+@,:;5 784'9+/ €*B#$%&9*±A>C7b:_

9*'b:`²GuUwT9\SQ%Ÿ+=oAST7³7A*´µUwTd  " =Ÿ+  ( =P@D=5+N;+-%4#*@[email protected]*KD=GY/Kkb:3J@ADQ&-%x`+u "bkMo%:6J-%i+-%d/8[a)*+,-%#A.+,Q

R*;=DB)*+@9k7>/NJ@%%:a*@75a7 "S<QUy%k%Sf%7D=oR*;L%i+-%#:<+}+JQ%?@*`+T*+,T4j[6Q)*+,-%M9*Na*ZQ>TvB7„A91*fG}/,-*_GT:+,L%*'b:`¶PCA?,T

Gab*;=#:QŸ3/+-*T4%&-d6@%b7·=*=S6BE*Bk }QHi b:/Q*8D=iY-%’™€*B#$%'9#:@F*= S;=¡=*a¹-B  C D   E D  F  G 7H-/I=J A K:'7S6+J=P,zTY@vBP}B k7>/NJ@%4*6;/KAvBx/3-%xu%7=(")+/ L8F   01  M#9?-  !"#$ &'() *"+"), *"-). (4

#*@ "nB#A°Za%‡U/@D=WC%:=–9G_:-ˆ=.</}@\>,-€S;-%7AGubS=MG;Z6=GNB*6Mºu%7A*Na*ZQ>T7AD=>Qk>=S=D=#7>;-%lZu:-%7AD=\k*NBxN<Z+-1*<J-%i,QS-%7A€*=A\b:DBrS6gD=rk*6g)>]%GNL*<-%§7F%4 »¼ ½>  ( B

Page 11: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 11/248

 :;5,784'9+/ !!

¡=*a>T7=(")+/ L8F   01  M#9?- MWNTb€*B#$%)i¾f7‚*ƒ6T9„S;avBx–>-%D=5aAj¼><  ( QM*,Q>=AžR7„bkAUN_%I$da*@i+6,-GNa*ZQ¹-%m*`/Y-%i'.YJ-%4U@

i6YJ@A¡=*a¹-%*^QAGa*,=G+C=¿*6}@€*B À/-›ª=*J8œ7›€SBSJ]%œ7›tYNZ-%œž#*@7*^QAGT*?}TÁN/Â*Y  " f>  ( =5TD=nYCI$i6f%bAD=G<}J-%G‹NJ-%

i+-%i6+;]i3:T)% ">B9GNa*aF%*=7X-IR$\k*`ŒGCk*vBr:38#%:6<-%vB

#:}^L%š#«_’*+@#*@P}q#%:6B2./  3456/ 9 (o¹+B%%¿*6=GNa*a«-4*=Ai©*a>T #*,_5}u%7=(")+/ L8F   01  M#9?- 9%&,'7dwYA”7ASNJ-*T”NZ/-%4D,-7„AD=t=*u:-%7ADQm%>KV%jS@ˆ+QRD=1Žg#:}^=9)*+,-%R7¡=*a¹-%

E:QŸ3/+-%4x–b79X-IMWNT*uF%i+-%d/8T9¡=*a¹-% (dN  " ;/8?,-%D=o%:BS-%9m%&®/-Eb*z+u%7#:NB*6p-%#:ƒ+6L%71:fb:=A”Z/-%4Nf€*C>QS=G/J/uoŽÃm*Q•F%\Sy%>-%M*Na*ZQ>T‡:BSTm%&®/-i,-tTA5-~S=”Z-5+@ÄM#:NB

5N3²:=4U@i68&gA*^QA\SNuG-7J=D=G@Äo*Q:/f~¹@m%&®/-MG}`=9G´*z=D,-7#*@*`_S'D=X-I:'#A "tY8#AW_%S-%™*uF%m%b7€*NC*`+@ÄWNYT

.-%:C58R:@:z-%jD,Qi6H9‚*TbF%PT[6-\7Ž]%\k*<J-%7tTµ*6-%49*¤Ž@ SCˆZg%¯SÅ%U@lzgA4

xi6+Bk¹@AG@Ä>8:NY=:,/-Mj*<-%xN¾6+-GYC%>=7GY<-GNƒN8%|u$>}+J8*=:QŽ=*@tTÆ<T9DQ&  " 36L%#*@¯SÅ%*`6=:'x`ZTbx`^<YTM#7*<8„k74x8

xNJ;8DQ&  " 36L%§$ÇŽo*B:}©žm%>}]%m*CbŸ-%7m%ŠO%7žda*@7GY</-%\b*YBDB>Q:ÈGY</-G/^<=tƒJ-%i+-%b7SQ*Å:f%&')*+,-%49”u«-7#É_ºT%>-%

E7*<+-%„&-%#*@¯S'G@[-%jª/3QM&N36+-%žPTPz_vB:wa?=4U@7WC:8

o>T7b9k7>/NJ@%#É_G;N;]%G_7><L%1:fSB:=m*`+a%GY</-%MGB*J-%G<T%>-%S<T >`¾-%SCd/  " ƒBr*3gV*TPy*Å%„&-%°]°Q>3-%>¬F%S{°Q>3-%9rb•F%PYCSB:L%kSwL%\Ä*Y=4#*@7b:<z-%ÊNJ-%„&-%xƒaDB†&'GQ*`6-%9G‹H*3L%S<T€:Q°T*ux<3=*Q%:6-*T9G6J]%*w{%7%SHMGJ/Ë%GN/N/w+-%i+-%d/89ÇS]%i+-%7

9*`  ( +Q>HA#*@7RST#Ab7*z+Q#7&36L%PYCx`B*6C$P}<-*TGQ:u\>=~>gA4

Page 12: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 12/248

!# 784'9+/ ,:;5

  (dw}u€*B#$$%G<YZLG<=*Hkb:3J@Ab%SÉTG<YKGNa*D=2./  3456/ NSC7d6}^8G<YZ-%\SQSË%t/p_DQSQSH%S}+B%vBtT*+,-%DQ&/-%E%b*AGQ*®/-

1Žg€%:BF%i+-%o ">=tTt+<YZ-%4R7GT%>–M#A#:,Q17ADQ&'t/p3-%*{>BP}<-9k7>/NJ@%\>=79~>gA5+N}uA›#:YNZ-%17AD=i`+6Qœ4i6,-7d6@R1%•A><ŒA#ˆT)*+@k7>/NJ@%RST#A>_:+QM„S/T4o&gˆ_€*=•\bk*YL%D=1Žg

)*'&-%§$.+@9DQ:®6NTobÌ7UQAb7Ì*=S6B%:/Y;8i+N:89†[6TE:Bk7 GT*+,-G=S;=x`+<YZ-GNa*ZQ¹-%4#*@7„b7Ì*3B*^=*=S6BE*Bkk7>/NJ@%*NpsŒQSw+-X/8G=S;L%PHFG<YZ-%GN-*]%D=)*+,-%4

i6/<-7R*–A*=S6B1:CA#$)*+@,:;5 784'9+/ 9Mt6R%DQ[B7*=*Bi+-%d/8†[a\>}/-9§7F%SC.ƒaAŽ;f%SQSHŽ=*@M1*©GB*6wY-%4i3_€*B#$%%9€*Ck7>/NJ@%PN=•79>gh 5}u%µŽ–7k9#:Q%kWN}ƒ+T”z@WH%>=‚7[=

o%b:z6}/-GN?wY-%i+-%*`}ÅA)*+@,:;5 784'9+/ 9G;Q>ZT7A~>gˆT4o:+f*_x`+}y*CvB>?@AD=!'" —Ž}Bl+fX-I9t]%M1*©DQ7*6<-%GN-*+-%š›€:/<-%GNu*NJ-%

#:a*;-%7œ7›x/Bk*p+CR%œ7›x/B¥U+HR%iH:-:T7>?aR%7œ7›o*;NYZ+-%GNH:-:NY-%œ7›GQ>¾6-%UT*`N_GQ>¾6-%GNy*;8bR%‘œ7›GQ>¾aG+¢F%€:/B):u*]%‘œ

7›oR:ZT)*<-F%GNa7|,-R%‘œ7›~>gAGC>3+=4œU@€*Ck7>/NJ@%#:Q%k7wYTe|z=>gh [aMG/©€:/<-%•  >?-4@ A S/ƒL%!&!9#$%%o*w3p-% 9#*%'ž#*$"‘dÈ#%:6B›b:Z+-%M*{V%9#7*<+/-œ„&-%7ÁO€S;+-%„&-%PpfM%&'P;]%M

€%:BF%G<TbF%i+-%d/8€*B#$%&4&6=7X-I9¼><-%Í;a%#%S;BD=D=Ÿ-%*=71%•:}a1:;]%GN?wY-%i+-%SC7A%&')*+,-%*±7&H%>}+J=vB€SCr*u74tYQ7

ºZsL%E*NY-%*+-%€*CbAo*u*Y+CR%GQ:6J-%)*+,-k7>/NJ@%Mo*NTkF%9GN}/<-% :'7ª{:QP,zTnHˆ+-%„&-%SCW+}+Q5T)*+@>=Sf%7vBb:Z8P;fD=1:;fG_><L%4ÎfR¥*38bR%k*]%MºO%E*NY-%S<T€*B#$%&9ÏQb*8[a)*+@,:;5 

784'9+/ 4D,}Q#ASƒao%k%S+=%GQ>¾a#7*<+-%M.+@1:fW6=)>]%Ç:'#$%%‘m*;8bR%7iBU+HR%•>3Q%>8#$%'‘#7*<+-%7tTo*a%:N]%D,8*–7k#$$+‘ÏQb*+-%7

Page 13: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 13/248

 :;5,784'9+/ !$

„[Y-%dQ%b!"""‘GQ>¾a7)*<-F%GQb:Z+-%N+N6N–!"""‘o*,YŒ7G;?-%1k*Y+-%7i+-%i6Y8µAb1*L%iBU+HR%#*¢:T!"""‘x/B7k*p+CR%iyŸË%Ÿ-7*T!""&‘1*NO%7

i}/<-%E:?a%#$%)‘Ž^_DB.+@k7>/NJ@%5J3a#$$+7!""#‘4 

D,-7S6BP=ˆ+-%MÐ:_wY-%9SQSË%#:,Qx'A¥*YZa% "„S-:'G/CGH*f¡y*+6-%GNu*uF%M)*+,-%N®+/-4U,_#*@‚ŽL%9xQS;-%d/%7vB~S=t6u¼>_)*+,-%vBGY/Z-%mŽ=Ÿ-%7vB7Mb*<=D=o*CŽ<-%\>T*<-%4S;+B%7°wT#A

*6Y@:@#:,Nu*a*,=P^_A%I$*=†A>C5}`_7WN}Ë%4*=A\k*Cj*<-%.ƒN_#A%:JY  ( qW= %&')*+,-%R7°/ZQx`f%ÌR$S<T58m%>C45aF#:,NuG<+=9xÅSC7&;6QD=i;T*6=D=1ŽgX-I4#$)*+@\ˆza#7*<+-%°w+JQ\b%SƒT#APqPÃ,/I=O 7=-!P 4

Ÿ6N@7%k kb*z+Qb#%>QŸf 9kb:3J@A,:Na:Q!"")

!

"!

#!!

#"!

$!!

$"!

%!!

%"!

&!!

&"!

#'(" #')! #')" #'*! #'*" #''! #''" $!!! $!!" $!#!

    &  -  =   ?  Q    +    /   R    4  @    4  (    9    S    T    /   U   !   V

U8W*"QX/ RWY8I Z49[+ &-=?Q+/ R4@4(9ST/

Page 14: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 14/248

!% 784'9+/ ,:;5

 -.#/0' 

9E:?a%µNT4#$%)

4 \"+=P  ]V  W^6/ 4eb:Q:Naš.+@DQ*+aR*T4 9k7>/NJ@%o>T7b4#$$+4!"_'O 784'9+/ `  abc5 ,HXWd91  ]V  e"d'+/  01 &QE4?f/ 784'9+/8 49#:+J6Q>TG<YZ=G<=*H:Na™H4

9k7>/NJ@%9o>T7bP,Q*=7k4t':@4!""#N,W)"Q+/  ]V !"_'9+/ ` 214gf/ &"d"h?9+/ U8!i*+ &"d*'+/ 4eb:Q:NašG<YZL%\>]%4

9Ÿ-7*TPNy:}4!""&4 \*V U4j9ST/  MkH./ ` Kl=*Q+/ R4Q@mf/  I=)9+/8 4eb:Q:NašGJu=Pu%bÑNuG<YZ=7G<=*H#:+J6Q>T4

9€*68:To>T7bk4!"""4n'*-  o?+=(+/ p!q=+ `  I4"r/  sd9tf/  M[-W16/ uv4'95/8 4eb:Q:Naš#:}Q*u|u:,u74

9•>3Q%>8o>T7b4#$%'4 I=)9+/  MVc9wT/ 4:/6N=eb*Tš*Nab:3N-*@št=*ƒ6NTŸ®6NN=:@4

9D,8*–7k#Rh 4#$$+4784'9+/ 2Y R45/="x/ `  I4h?1  Mk4_OI/ 4eb:Q:Nakb:3J@A7šG<YZ=G<=*Hkb:3J@A4

9dQ%bo>T7b4!"""Ny+/  Wz{ ` C)?1  |jf/ }~(+/ N

eb:Q:Naš#:N?a*T4 9+N6N–o>T'4!"""4 I=)O &-Wh5 &('*+/ ` &1!_1 ,HXWd91  ]V Ry[;f/ •"d?9+  eV4z9+/  Mt"O/€@T/ N#:+J6Q>Tš:Na™H4G<YZ=G<=*H#:+J6Q>T4

9Ç:'17*Te4#$%%4¥k>-%WJ+L%W6=7)>]%4:Na9D3Q*'d,+,Na:@#S6-7šG<YZ=G<=*HPNQ4

Page 15: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 15/248

"#$%&'()*+%,%-.$/01.$2"3')456789:;<=>?@+%A"/A)BC6<567)DE36<F1G>A"A3H</B1IBI"JK1GL>M>BN6O%@L6.+%P7QRST@UV M'89:;<=>W<#XO%A"@L6.<JY@H6O%,BZ[\B$=>W<#]@UV 2FG7BC<TM^+B$M')D_=>()*7`aBbcC7A"Y#d<eB7#UKC<f()*+`aBb@UV gS3<=>Thi[j%

kl`"m#789:;<=>eB<23O%n#o6+%A"DpBCqrBs2%861[3.O%=>F7B1p`t$ML> 8u%#>/ABvB7)3'0LIw3G.O%`&O%xHL<eB<23GOn#o6+%A"F7#R6.q(y6;6OMZ["w3Gz{)BCqxH|x7rBs2%T861[3.O%

wB;'Kd<@}K~1.$•<#d6O%&'(3;O%x7€p%3+%`&O%%^vB7D:.6<Ja3‚ƒ„&'/MvB…+%8')Y%#R6z%(3IcC7x7/†BCO\%8')K:CGO%86O%5L.q‡KGZC7

cˆ.O%na@H6+%‰Š‹lŒL.q„&'K:CGO%c:>iOc;%,3XŽB$=>eB:.6H7KOrB:67x7?%@E/A)BC6O%B‚;HO)ŒL.qBZ<"K1O6B$A"Y3d<#"c:>iO%,i96zB$/@U‘%)"K1O6%A"2A)BC6<`"‚;7Šv)J•’C7€p%3+%J/Pp%3O%A“[c:>iO%”.1O

•#OŒOBX7K–aBC67=>3oI2KI)@7F1[ŠME\)rB_lK1ˆ1q%—zln#1EB‚7%#R6z2JM^7„&'/€p%3+% e3  ™ > ™ršC$?%›œ%JK<@’I†BCO\%•<#d6O7%@$

KO3~$žKGZC7cˆ.O%ŸK1I)—HO2%8')F:S"KO3~:$I@~…O%{)—HO2%ŠABv)@[36<m#OMv7BI@$ ¡iˆzB1¢aBqM>BN6GO`&O%MX&;7K<%#:O%56K’oGO%

/K1OBŽ%Pz3$)D>iO%nrBN6z2%x7%&'Mˆ.O%8¢aB6O%#;>F7B1p‹B£B$e%aB1œ%

Page 16: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 16/248

!" "#$%&'( )*+,

KdGC6+%A)BC6OB$)"Y#>A)BC6O%JKGd;O%K1OBŽ%Še?Bˆ[eBvaB…+%x7šC$`@’;7†BCO\%x7`)‹eB1NGœ%K1LGCO%KNG6R+%Y3GCvrBX6p2%•G>)¤N;O%•G>)(6E2%Y3GCO%)K1zB1.O%eB1–B<@O%)Š•”Lpna%r“$P1¥eiU#+%KC$a\%*>

/B‚G19…q)B‚6GCE)BC1¥MLCqP7B‚ZC$W[)n#>BpK1u%3…>KO3~:$e%‹eB1NXqKG.G.67Kd<@~$`a)#O%ž`"A",¦B;<D>iO%K[Bvc:>iO%x<@U‘%!"#$% !"'($ )Š

86…'#O)/n:HO%ABv7BI›O%Œ$%@O%3'0.$"7%›O%86O%•q/B‚L<#dq2"3') 7BI@$!n#%3O%n#%3$"ŠB7)!n#%3O%n#%3$"2lK1ˆ1q%—zl?#:O%/A)BC6OB$#C$)gO‹YB1dO%M^L$B7MC[D>iO%@U‘%JKGd;O%Kd$B.O%Š

  ”L  ˜ p#C$gO‹@<)#6$/uB6;O%• ”CLˆ6z%eiU#7n#<#EKO3ˆGOK1IB^O%x7KO3~:O%Š”1dGq„&'n@+%AB;%A36z)BvaB…7x7K6zA%#G$ŠABv•’C7cd$B.6+%x7

n%3'/@q31:73HO%/xHO)ABv•‚;1$BZ<"n&qBz"J•G>?B1\%8uBdqa2%?B<y1NO%)Y3G>)/eB:zBŽ%iZ[x>Y3GCO%K.Lœ%86O%”G^§JKO3¨%k)\%Šv)ABv,BŽ%

JKO3¨%/k)\%•q•<#dq7%@$KG  ¡ XN7%#EŠ”IBv)wB;'BZ<" ©K>3Lªx7e2)Bo+%@<3~6O7BI@$*n#%3O%n#%3$+F.NIŠABv)yuBNO%JKO3¨%/k)\%,3qBI"ea3$%ax7KC7BE/36Ia3q3')`&O%Mza"7BI@$!n#%3O%n#%3$"Š#p)¦B[%&'7BI›O%K1IBŠ

 /B;')«#?¬P6|K<B9GOŠ#dO{a)Bz gSAt$e.O%86O%”GCE7BI@$*n#%3O%n#%3$+Œˆ;<=>%&'3o;O%Je23~:O%#pMLCqBZ<"J®B>A3HqF1[

P1¥eB1ˆ1q%—z2%K;H|ŠAlABv@7\%/%&H')#:1zA)BC6O%8;:+%=>,rB:6O%B;H|Š8;HO)era"A"¯@>"°)*O%Kd1p#O%86O%±B6o;zB‚1Ol@<3~6OA)BC6O%JM^7„&'

¯)@’O%Š#p){rBp%&'klaB’;7`a3~q3'4M7t6O%JK1N1vK1IBH7la3‚ƒA)BC6O%c$

²BRS\%c1IBI\%i$)K~GzK<yv@7Š#p)³@}aB’;+%`a3~6O%KiKG´z"ny1|4 /,)\%€1vxHL<K1ˆ1q%—zjK1I)BCqKGL6µA"MXs=>¶}37Y#dO%k)\%JK´1$·KI)BC67=>TDG·\%/{B^O%)B7(3IK1ˆ1q%—zj%86O%xHL<A"@'ryqJK´1$

K>3;67KI3H7x7r%@["x<@UV A3GLC6.<K>3LªK>3;67x7eB1ˆ1q%—zj%Kq)BN6+%JKEarTB'#1dCqB7",%-.O%¸OB^O%3‚[4”sK<"¯)@ƒxHL<M^+„&'K1ˆ1q%—zj%A"

Page 17: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 17/248

 *+,)"#$%&'( !#

Y)Bdq³B16E%eB1ˆ1q%—z2%Mp\%/BI)BCq#C$B‚.1ztqMH…$YBqc$K>3Lªx7ThB;O%

e*  ˜ IuB6IKO3~:O%J-./01  23 4$5(67'( ž8$,9:; <#( =>/?.,:@  

 AB:':CD9 Ÿžr)@G1.v%,-./ž"Ÿ),-./ž†ŸŸ/8')n@[367B;'BZ<"MH…$/Œd;7JMXNO%{B^O%x7B;$B6v%&'ŠB7"uB6;O%K<@’;O%,3K1IBH7l³Bˆ;O%/K1O)\%KIB6+%)

a%@d6z2%)#d[e*IJK<a)r%E(F%&GH?%'-G$/C'(I>DFJK(ž"$>DLJM  8$>&/':N  O7D$G  :/.D9 P žr)@G1.v%,-.,Ÿ/#p)e@[)„&'uB6;O%hBz\%`&O%8;  ˜ $F1G>MXNO%¸OB^O%Š

#C$)HN6O%nt…;$A)BC6O%J¹B1.O%/8>6E2%”var"A"„&ºuB6;O%B‚;17BZ7B»B}B:qa%)a3~6OB$8E3O31:O%Š%&O e#  ™ E ™)A"2²B;7x7A)BC6O%P7®B>8E3O31$3')YB1O)A36G17B'ME\@<3~qc7BZ+%K1E3O31:O%„&ºaBH[\%

K1ˆ1q%—zj%Š#p)6I"%&'A)BC6O%B^o$ ™ ¼*  ˜ IJK<a)rQ:?%'(ž O7D$G P žr)@G1.v% A36G17B'),-.,Ÿ

`&O%)@‚’<BZ<"Fqa3X$Kod;+%JMXNO%¤7Bœ%Š#p)MX¸o:O% =>nyuBED73v31I#IiN1GvK1CLˆGOK1H<@7\%@<3~6OY3GCO%Š #dO8;6CˆS„&'K$Bˆ6z2%K1–@  ˜ +%=>•<#dq„&'aBH[\%MH…$B‚GC_KG‚z

•‚NO%†BC16z2%)¤1O0d[m#O?G  ˜ >?B1\%?G>)(6E2%x7`)‹eB‚E36O%/K1qB1–B<@O%M$a3‚L¨Pz%)•6‚7•‚N$¯)@’O%86O%x7B½tSA"8  ¡ L;qA)BC6O%c$

r%@[\%e’;+%)•7\%)Š#p){rBp%&'„a)#$n#'B…+uB6IgGqaBH[\%J€1}(3;67x7€p%3+%K1qB1Ž%cL^q)K1N1vY%#R6z%„&'uB6;O%#1O36Oc7BZ7)"eBpi>

K1d~;7w3G.GO²Bœ%KzB1.GO)K7BCO%Š

xHO)2#$x7#1vt6O%=>K~dIn#%)¾rB$`‹/?#$2"8')A"„&'Kd<@~O%€G6£x>Kd<@}•G>?B1\%8>6E2%Š•GC[?B1\%8>6E2%#;6.<=>¿%—[2%

At$8%3;O%K7Bº%x7w3G.O%`*:O%KC–BUKa%3GOK1;1¨%ž`l ,B^+% M1:z =>Š)"Š A3.G<),-01ŸŠ$aA3H<gO‹Bo1o]ŠxHO)Kd<@~O%K1OBŽ%8'Kd<@}K1ˆ1q%—zl@^v"

B‚;7K1;1EŠvB½"Y#R6.q%aB’;7B<a3~qA\hB;O%JnrBCO%A3I3H<J€p%37@L6.<

Page 18: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 18/248

!% "#$%&'( )*+,

B‚1[Y%#R6z%eB1ˆ1q%—zj%KG>BNO%/0d[B7"eB1ˆ1q%—z2%·KG>BNO%•61[ ¡ÀR6O%B‚;>ŠA3HqK1GL>aB16U2%nÁB:7JšC$AB1\%43ZC[h@9I3HO%`&O%2yˆ;  ˜ <

`"?¬JM>BN6O%P7Fui7¦¯3zxO@L6.<i<3}JF:X;73ZCvJh@9I3HO%Š{Â<A"†@>"x>{B;67%`@HS)n#>B.LGO86O%B‚61dGqJ56SM%@7r%#>l

%&'Ã()*+%x7A#OABBI3Ea#;1$e@$)a)#<3$A3E)•@$A3E)cO›7B…q

,3E)c'3v3O)”z@<%A3E)A3_[ÄB$)Å6;<@[raBI$)A[)@·8ˆ;1v) 3<B'hi·)r)qrB6.[3'`r3E)A3.vBE—1$)c6…;<yqBvYB1O))Å61vxqaB7)@G.1vyL1E)ÅqaB7#OBI)r)YBvaB7raB…6<a)#IiqB7A3E)@<B7e@$)a)xv)3H;7

`a2)@'37xH;1O)h¦37B<a37)g.6O)%A3E)”1EB$€1E)xI3IB$Æ3G;1$)cG7)a8L<%)@9I#OBzeaB‚;<a)x61G1zA3E)#1N<rGH;1zA3E)eŠyO3Hz±z)a3G<Bqe@$)a)¦N<%@q#1N<r)A23zA3.G<)QU")@v&OB$MH<B7c'3vŠ

r)")A"@HS%Mv²BRS\%x<&O%”GCE•»BvaB…7KO3~:O%K1I)—HO2%/K;H|•'Çz")BC1¥na3v&7JWoG+%ž"ŠŸv2#$ÈA"@HS"AB;67B$eB.z-+%86O%”GCE%&'MLCO%B;H|4#‚C7eBz%arKzB1.O%K7BCO%JKC7BEAB91…17yv@7)eBz%a#O%K7#d6+%JY3GCO%K1v3G.O%K.z-7)•GCO%K1;}3O%KC$B6O%Ko;+•pahŠ`lŠhŠ #./23114Š

 

Page 19: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 19/248

 

!" 

!"#$%& 

Page 20: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 20/248

!" "#$% &'(%)*+,-.%

 

Page 21: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 21/248

*/01+2#3456% !#

 

()*+,-& !./0" 

"#$%&'()*+$,*+-./0123)456'"7,*+89:"; <=7>5?@A"AB"4:";(C,D>EF

GHI/*+JG>KL(M++ NOHC,P+Q%R+S/*+T"U*+VWD*5GI>2XOY/*'Z@['6'\]^_ "UIL&(7A6`4T"U*++2/@*5Gabc#deF'62I@.>f'ghYi'hLjk()UI*d3/DABd3l"m#'_n#'5]*opqA&(7A"r>g6g6'"7,*+stu5c7v6g'"U01"rwG@UY#

Z@I;_5pa*'x@L6'"7,I*6g2.U>8xi+2M+$,*+62a>ha*\(v"3@vnv+\2qAJG@A"AB+

6Fy+2zI*{Q*+Z#tC>hLtw+'"U#|;+Q%R+S/*+}~`0{(%2[|;GC>(X"A}aD0"Uv•0'8"U0"ic;G@;€,[f+G@P"@/*+'G>\"m,if+'n#p>(‚+_€L6g

ƒ"4"[„*$,*+"3#tC>6'(‚+…(4g(~B+|;†t#d%\+t7,P+6'"7,I*"U7#_ "#gy+2‡+(ˆLB+V(3^tCvZ#tiT"#20K42%hYi(ˆLgp#Gb€~c~‰";5  Š‹  N I  N ZUa*'6"L"4+2[€b"Œ,#_@wO%oK42%EFZAghYi\2['5ƒ"#2al+‹A"LG*"w

G7@YH*+G7Ž"V(H@/*\+(vB+?@A"AB+p>Q*++2/v"U0|;74PB+G@P"C*+GIb"C*+6`4V"@l+‘G>\+(DA+V}Cv'G,@C#'GŒw2,#'V}mi'’“K42%"#$"”"%#& 5"''–_p.v

 

Page 22: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 22/248

!! "#$% &'(%)*+,-.%

G3['5—()Afpa.>6'"7,I*6g2.U>6'\GHIP5G>KL(#˜",*"4'6™vG#2al+G>1'š_QU#]*o5?l+Rt‡+'R2w1")UM+dbcM+G#2aqI*+}ˆL"#K  < L(0R2w"#

+oF6"Lj(M+5n@H,/>'gf5n@H,/>6gni2,>123›6'"7,*+8R"œ?7#6F:pa0"U%GHIPOi+(0xi2M+_

h;"D,0d#B+‰2@*+€@v"3U@46't4GHIPG>KL(#_5+Q*6™vƒ"YIH,#123›

6'"7,*+GHY0(#t>t7*"4p#">"rC*+G>KL(M+GP"@/I*G@*'t*+_GIr7#'p#B+$% GIaŒM+(ˆLB+G@žgŸ@w+}ˆL"#7/0d#B+j+1'"3U#g¡;hb"P'\t¢p#gd#B+†(B+_(3)0'—Q%GIaŒM+8£X"UM+$,*+di"D,>"3@vt@7m0ƒ";+•*+G@IqM+

ƒ"i"YP'-  < I/,*+_"#gƒcaŒM+†(B+ƒ+oGic7*+(3),v8ƒ"ic7*+G@*'t*+|;ha^v"U0h+\5ƒ"D*"q,*+ƒ"Ž'"DM+'|;Gv(7,*+5G@L(.‡+ƒ";+•*+'

G@7.,zM+€L2%R"l+8¡i!""_tC*h7[¤"@,[+\"¥f+$,@v2/*+6",/A"¦vB‰";"%(%ƒ">f2*+Vtq,M+‰"#g

GIr7#1"@,+G@[o2.A_+o™v"#ƒ(.,P+ƒ">f2*+Vtq,M+"3X"ŒU4{1"z,*+5\",7M+ nzŒ,@P\"¥f+$,@v2/*+|;O>(§R"a^g†(gp#2I/*+}¨6'"7,M+€@vt74_p#G@w"A5†(g6F{gh@IC0{(%2[86'"7,*+p#OA"[ƒ">f2*+Vtq,M+62a@P

Gv…"œR€,wfs'twha^p#R"a^g5‰"C,Af+{Q*+'£I©@P˜",*"4\1h7v5h4"C#"ªt*2>"H.A"@b+t;f\"Y,#pa.>6g«(¬p;"HAV(H@/*+_U70d)7#ƒf+t‡+

G@IqM+R2wGP"@/*+G@[1"®+ƒcaŒ.4p#+Q%¯2U*+"#"°_2%'(#g5$7@YX6Bƒ+1"@®+GY7±_8V"@l+5G@#2@*+"U@I;6gR`/A"U/DAgdLV(#2;tUP"Uv1"7#EF5j"Œ7*+6F:

+2#2C>d%"U02;t4|;cX²+8h4"CM+_‰2C>twgj+1tM+?>Q@DU,*+8†twF 

“"– ¯cXc*|;ƒ"w"r>FVt@D#—Q³ƒ"C@YH,*+|;GP"@/*+5G@*'t*+()A+1\"mM+G@*",*+Ÿ*/74+  8+$% “v}["%()–593:;  </=56%  >'?#  @A=6% “ƒ12424+1"%#'–5 BC3DE F3G63H56% “1t>"UP

"%("–5F3I#3G+ *CJ456% “KA"D>+"%("–5KL%M6% F3NO6%# PQ,45+ F3R=D(% “(vf"%((–5' >%S6%  T4U5V.% W  XYZ “p>t/#2*"%(*–_ 

Page 23: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 23/248

*/01+2#3456% !$

ƒ€)UM+t>t7*"4p#R"rvB+p#h[g6gCI,>f"rvgh4"CM"4_$Dqm*+'{Q*+CI,>"Y>´0">¡"#"%$H7>G@H¦0G@Dq±Vt@[51tm.I*|;h#gR2ml+|;ƒ"Y>´0

G@IYC,/#†(g_GLµ*+'G>1"z,*+GI#"7*+8R"œfh.70Z@v†2PGL¶Vtw+'†(g‰2C0nv(41"7PB+ni2,0'p#GLµ*+†(B+6g'Q¥"%'Qw"r>gj"C4™4

"%1"7PgG7D0(#·h[B€3@,qIm#G*\"Y,M+|;'y"/w]I3,/M+_

"#gGY/U*"45˜6™vG*"l+G@*"ˆM+123)*6'"7,*+$%12H074¸€AB+G@L2I/*+ 86"@L$7>µ0hˆ#Iœ¹2@Œ*+$a>(#B+_@w6g†t*hL120"U@Pnv+t*+$a*(3)>(3).4(~S#‰"#g5Z@Y"A,w2*6"L(#B+|;y"/w¯+•*+n#j"r;B+

p>(‚+IzM¹2@Œ*+p>Q*+62*'"u123)*+‰"#gd3@Y"A(3).4(~S#"r>g_pa*'+Q%€  < Ii6"L"Di2#-*"m.I*GŽ1"7,M+5"#"°h42%GY7*=0"A{(D±“+,-./012

342,_–|;5a7*+"U%t>t7*+p#(D*+GHŒAº*Gq4(M+5?v(HI*GY/U*"4{Bp>2r;p#j"r;gIzM+_ti'ƒ\"i—Q%GHŒAB+Gq4(M+?v(HI*EF£IG#2)U#

G7P2#p#5t;+2C*+'g5&+(;B+8Iœ¹2@Œ*+_p#'?4d%g—Q%t;+2C*+$% Vt;"iR\"Y,*+·$%'V1"Y;p; »&(  ¼ ;$Y7^p.r,>Vt;"/#h@#K*+p#h[gR2ml+|;GI#"7#hˆM"4cYC,/#_p.r,>'"r>gV1"z,*+5ƒ+2±B"4ZUa*'t,.>h.Œ@*";+2Ag

V\t7,#p#2I/*+{KzM+?v(HI*,wZAg‘@*p#h@YiG¦*"YM+R2C*+6`4R\"Y,*+2%GC>(XV"@w8Iœ¹2@Œ*+_’“…2@~"#"%#% 5"''2½"# ()A+' 5"%($"r>g–_

}¨6gpHU^+':pa0€b+\|;+Q%R"l+_tCv¾wf62Yi+(M+62*'B+6gj"r;gn.,œpHU^+'d%G;2.œp#$.>t;5}.r*+p>Q*+ft.,7  ¼ >5d3@I;

62./,>' ¿*"4‘x>K*+¯+t®+'GA"@®+'’“@.P"%'# 5"%'–_‹  < IaŒ0—Q%GP1€M+8ƒ"U@A€~6(C*+p>µ7*+|;'2qAt@[_,wƒ+}@¦,*+V}Ya*+8Iœ¹2@Œ*+Rcp>tC7*+5?@Ž"M+$,*+'‹A"Lh@°8O*"¦*+2qAt>KM+p#5G>KL(#c*+5¤",DAf+'

t>KM+'p#n>…2,*+R\"7*+5GHI/I*tiƒj"[6't4h@IC,*+p#6`^&(;R\"Y,*+“{\'1' {\2Y@4 5?,ŒA1'+"%((–_€L'5-r,@PZA™v@*p#{1'À*+Á+Wvf+6`4

j"r;gIœ¹2@Œ*+d%(ˆLgG%+KA'g"#(L'g2D0d3w'1G>}%€‡+d3@C4"P8

Page 24: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 24/248

!% "#$% &'(%)*+,-.%

ƒ+2U/*+5G@Ž"M+h[B}/D0G@D@L123›6'"7,*+$UYM+|;5R\"Y,*+Z01ti'|;1+(C,Pf+_pa.>}/D0123›6'"7,*+|;ZAgGz@,A »\2[2*j"r;g8Iœ¹2@Œ*+

627/>xId3l"m#G±"®+_

6F=e+Q%y",a*+2%V1"Y;p; ÂÃC0G@D@a*& <•0\+(vB+p>Q*+627/>j+1'5d3l"m#d~h@I¥ƒ+}~`0+Q%&

 <•,*+|;‰")U*+Z,#(4_V1"Y74'5†(g6™v=3U*+

2%‰"@C*+7Y4ƒ"Ž+Wvf+R2w74nv+'t*+G>\(D*+d~¸"YU,P+=b",U*+2I/*‰")U*+Z,#(4“=U@I@^"%)(–_"#'G*"wIœ¹2@Œ*+$a>(#B+fF »R"ˆ#5t@[pa*'

y2IPgRft,Pf+$CHUM+Z/DApa.>6g£YHU>|;t%"Œ#†(g_

&t½+Q%¯'µM+EF(>2H0G>()A6'"70pa.>"3#+t©,P+&"Œ,Lf"#2%{1'šh7‡6'"7,*+`ŒU>_d3D4'¸'µ*+$,*+-./06'"7,I*5V`ŒU*"4pa.>o"Ä+

}4+t,*+G#…c*+K>K7,*V`ŒA6'"7,*+89xi2#\ <t  ¼ Å_

6FG>()A6'"7,*+$,*+"3#tCA8+Q%y",a*+G@UY#|;ÆC0\+(vB+p>Q*+ 627/>j+1'd3l"m#G±"®+6'\d;\p#G>gGHIPG>KL(#d%¡§|;6'"7,*+n#d3r747Y*+_OY/*+'j+1'Á+Wv+GqImM+G@m©Œ*+2%"eg-./0ÃqD,4G*"l+GY7m*+$,*+ft.,7>"3@v6'"7,*+haŒ4‰"0|;j"U,;f+5p>(‚"4f'|;G@%"v1

G;2.zM+haL_|;'hL5R"wft4p#t@L`,*+|;6g+Q%Á+Wvf+2%8ni+2*+hig+t@@C0"ª'tY>_+o™v‹A"L‹B+G.,3#G@%"v(45"3@g6™vGqImM+G@m©Œ*+‹º*pa.>6g()U  ¼ >"3@*F|;"egp.r,0“p#?4j"@^g†(g–]*o‰€,%f+G@%"v(4"3@g_

fF6g+Q%(#B+f$¦I>V1'À*"4hLƒf€,w+¯+•*+?4"#‹B+¹B+'_|;'DA51+( Ç ¦*+6™vG#B+pa.>6g5&•,0haŒ45$bK[p#£IHU#-*"m#"¢"C>t± p#5d#B+pa*'+Q%£IHUM+f$U7>6g5R't*+,w6F'‹A"L5V\'\'n@H,/0€b+\

6'"7,*+p#h[g"3l"m#G*\"Y,M+_+Q*6™vÁ+Wv+GqImM+G@0+Q*+2%8ni+2*+   »Á+Wv+6`4‰€,%f+p>(‚"4fhuGIaŒM+GCI7,M+‹i2*"4{Q*+6'"7,05Z@v‹i2*+'

{Q*+fh7D0Z@v]*o_

Page 25: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 25/248

*/01+2#3456% !&

p#'GIˆ#B+Vt@‡+|;GIaŒ#6'"7,*+G>(%2‡+$%G*"l+$,*+‰2C0"3@v6",#g6",@;"U±G#"i™4K[+2wG>1"§8£>(Xƒ+1\"± <hL€3U#†(º*_hrDYvtb+2D*+

G*\"Y,M+V1"z,I*5V(l+6"Lpa.>ca*p>tIY*+6g"A2a>hrvgf"w2*:pa0—Q%K[+2l+V\2[2#_pa*'+oF"#‰"i{gp#p>tIY*+G*+…™4—K[+2wp#&(X5tw+'ZA™v

tz@PZ/DA‰"#g9\2U49G>1"§£ Ç qI  ¼ 01À*+—\"m,i"4_8GC@Cw5(#B+€3#h7D>twg

p>Q%5p>tIY*+6™vtIY*+(‚+62a@Phrvgf"wtU;Z›"D,w+—K[+2q4G>1"z,*+_ 5]*Q*6™vGIaŒM+$%6ghLtI4]I,.>+Kv"wÈ"D,wc*K[+2q45G>1"§"ª\2C>EFGz@,Ag2Pg"ª‹A"LR'S,PZ@*FR+2wB+2*6g6+t  N I  N Y*+ti"A'"70€@v€3U@4_

st¥—Q%GIaŒM+G@P"PB+"#tU;{\S>$7PhLtw+'j+1'Z,qIm#G@0+Q*+EFGz@,AG/b"[email protected]*_h[B'…+(wF‰tC08"U.3vx@HI*nP+2*+p#xi+2M+

V\tqM+$,*+]I,°—Q%5G@±"®+ft4p#h@ˆ°"#2%WŒ#?4]I0xi+2M+6'\R"¦ŒAf+h@±"D,*"4$,*+ÃÄhLtw+'"3U#_p/l'5¾l+6™v"#h~€>+Q%xi2M+

(v2,#5"U>t*fg2%'ŸGY7**/74+[V=6%P\]16%_!"" $DvGY7*GIr7#5?z/*+"U%56"Y;f†t*hL€3U#56+1"@"ž't>tq,*"4

“2 _#34  ` Ea'g“b ,  ` ca_|;'hLtw+'6g‰2C>1"@,f"46'\Gv(7#"#{Q*+‰tC  ¼ @PZ@I;O;c*+(‚+_&•4'()U*+ <€;‰2C@PZ45(‚+6™v1t¦*+{\S@PEFƒ+tb";|;g

p#6'"7,*+_GIr7M+'$%ZAg2*1t¨56"U~f+€e™v6"#tC@P Éj+\gg2Pg"ª2*"A"Lti"A'"70_6F—Q%GY7I*+GH@/Y*+‰tC,P"U*"P"Pgh@Iq,I*‰t©,/M+8+Q%y",a*+Z,#(4 _

GC>(H*"v$,*+h.70"Ê—Q%GY7I*+GU@Y#8haŒ*+di1“"–_oF1",¬twg?  N Y;c*+5"  < D±"#F6'"7,*+'g1t¦*+_"#gO;c*+(‚+‰2C@v"@b"CI01"@,"45\2.;"#F6'"7,*+"#F'

1t¦*+_6+Q%'56+1"@®+56"7.,œ6"z,U>Vtw+'p#=b",U*+n41B+GUa.M+GU@YM+'8 Gv2DmM+—"A\g_"#g+oF6'"7056"Y;c*+"žcav‰[email protected]@[hmq@P'"žcL|;“5 –5fg$%'V`v"aM+|;6'"7,*+R\"Y,M+_8'R"ˆM+{\"M+?YM+8haŒ*+di1

 “"– d0¯+W+GY7*GIr7#?z/*+‰";"%$'"Y>(C0|;t>h>}#\2Iv?DI@#'5µ>1\‰"i'{g_

2@I4\_(L20"%(>2H,4haŒ4$.P1t74]*o_ 

Page 26: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 26/248

!' "#$% &'(%)*+,-.%

“"–562a0V`v"aM+V1"Y;p;sc~¸"CA_pa.>'6g62a>+Q%di(*+2%ƒ+tb"7*+“'gƒ";2vtM+–1f't*"45cˆ#$,*+'pa.>6ghmu"3@I;hLO;fp#?Y;c*+j"C*

—Q%Gz@,U*+_"#g+oF6'"70twg?Y;c*+1t¨'O;c*+5(‚+hmq@/vO;c*+1\"¦*+|;&%Jcdb,e6%5€U@4hmuO;c*+6'"7,M+|;F3fgC,+h  i Ge.%jK=0.%kf

l3=mh  i Ge.%()*+,-.( 012344 6_"#g85R"ˆM+6™v?0"%?,z@,U*+"ž$''|;˜+2,*+_

"#g+oF1t¨56"U~f+"žcavhmq@P|;GHCA5Vtw+'$%'*ng-fb,e6%"Q3:5.%o  

pZb h016%j#)a[V=6% */74+

 "#{Q*+ZI7D,P8hˆ#—Q%JGY7I*+1 <2m0]AgO;f <x±5]AF'tC,706gO;f\2.7*+6'"7,@P_+Q%$U7>]Aghmq,P|;Vtw+'p#?,z@,U*+?,U  < @YM+8

\2.7*+R'B+p#haŒ*+di1“"_–‹Ag]I,°51"@®+]A"a#™Yv6'"7,*+"r>gR2mqI*|;¸"CU*+scˆ*+Gmm©M+V`v"a.L|;6'"7,*+R\"Y,M+_'g]Ua.>6g51t¦0hmq,v

Page 27: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 27/248

*/01+2#3456% !5

|;$¸"CAF%,L3f&%Jcq%_+Q*p.v{KzM+6g51t¦06F‹ULtC,706`4O;c*+(‚+6'"7,@P_pa*'6‚+ÁWDU*]A`4tC,706`4O;c*+(‚+1t¦@P_6‚+‹Ag

8\2.7*+Ë"ˆ*+p#haŒ*+di1“"–5]>t*'1"@,+?456'"7,*+{Q*+]I7ÌcD¦#“0178,- –]qU.>''5GHCA'g1t¦*+{Q*+{\S@PEFG42C;G*\"Y,#f]@H70†2P

GHCAVtw+'_+Q*p.v{KzM+6g51t¦06F‹ULtC,706`4O;c*+(‚+1t¦@P_+Q%'

$U7>6gp#hrvB+6g1t¦06F‹ULtC,706`4O;c*+(‚+56'"7,@P€LZAFp# hrvB+6g1t¦06FƒtC,;+6`4(‚+1t¦@P_5+Q*¦Yv()U*+€;ZI7D@PO;c*+5(‚+62a@Pp#{KzM+]*6g1t¦0_

tl56‚+hLjk|;"#‰+(>_pa*'£HUM+Z/DA£YHU>|;O;c*+(‚+"r>g_5]*Q*|;O;c*+(‚+6g1t¦> <¦4()U*+€;ni2,>]U#6gh7D0_+Q*

€a@I;€,Ag6"U~f+6g5+1t¦0pa*'"3U@whmq@PhLtw+'€aU#|;GHCAVtw+'5ÍCv$%'g2Pgp#¸"CAV`v"aM+scˆ*+$,*+6"Lpa.>€a@Ia*R2ml+"3@I;2*€aAg

ti€,A'"70n#€ar74_6FG@AcC7*+G>\(D*+\2C0EFGz@,Ag2Pg"ª2%ni2,#ca*?v(H*+_"U%'p.a0GIr7M+_

"#'GIr7#?z/*+†2Ph@aŒ0\(œ7Y*xi+2M+G7b"Œ*+G7,.M+'5+t[$,*+'\2C>"3@vjÎ*+hrvB+ha*é^|;5\+(DA+EF1t¨5R\"Y,#€U@4pa.>ha*&(X6g62a>hrvgf"wp#Rc6'"7,*+R\"Y,M+_OIH,>x>(70GIr7#?z/*+

j"C4²+|;ƒ"ic;Vt>t;?4xI,Ï=b",U*+n41B+GUa.M+_@w\t¥Gic7*+E'B+‰")Aƒ+tb"7*+G741B+_6Fhrvg"#pa.>O; <c*6gZI7D>2%R2ml+|;“9–52%'

j+(¨F1t¦*+"#tU;6'"7,>O;c*+(‚+_"#gg2Pg"#pa.>O;c*6gZI7D>23vR2ml+|;“:–52%'ƒ";2vt#hD¦M+“0178,-;0 <4=.>> –€U@41t¦>O;c*+(‚+_ †t*'O@0(0?,z@,U*+5?0(B+ ¼Á NWD  ¼ >6g62a0Gz@,U*+“5 –5$%'V`v"aM+|;6'"7,*+5R\"Y,M+hrvgp#Gz@,U*+“?–5$%'G42C;1t¦*+R\"Y,M+_\2C>'+Q%EFO@0(0Ð@rD0ƒ+tb"7I*G741B+p#hrvB+EFg2PB+|;2qU*+˜",*+“ Ÿ9–'“5 –'“:–

'“?_–

Page 28: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 28/248

!6 "#$% &'(%)*+,-.%

"#gjK‡+Ë"ˆ*+p#x>(70GIr7#?z/*+23v6g6"Y;c*+f6"7@H,/>«'(®+p#€3,Ir7#p#Rcy'"U,*+8Rc¦,P+d3r747Y*+_+Q%'Á+Wvf+$U7>6`4

G±(D*+G>'"/,M+Rc¦,Pf(‚+Á <(7,*+'5Rc¦,Pc*‹/@*Gz@,AVt@[O; <c*"e`^6`^6'"7,*+R\"Y,M+_5+Q*ÁWD>6`462a>j+K[6'"7,*+R\"Y,M+¡Lgp#ÍP2,#

j+(¨²+p.ˆ*+'hmq,/M+p#h  < D¦M+“0178,-;0 <4=.>> –_6F+Q%5Á+Wvf++W^f"4

n#d@)U0ƒ">2,/#ƒ+tb"7*+5G741B+2%{Q*+& <(7>GIr7#?z/*+_ 5Z@I;'+oF"#h\6"Y;f6"@A"Ag—QÊ5GY7I*+\(z.Yv6g1",¬"žcL1"@®+h   < rDM+5€½t*fg2%'51t¦*+hmq@PhL€3U#|;hig"ª"A"L6cmq@*Z@I;2*€eg

ti"A'"70_+oF'"#d0j+([FGY7I*++\t;+\tÅp#5ƒ+(M+6™v?Y;c*+6c)@P6't4nv+\6'"7,I*_€L <-m>+Q%(#B+8GICU*+'gGL(l+5V}B+"M"Xp*CY,>"U%

hYC,/#$a*62a>Z*}~`0_"#g8GICU*+"#hYi5V}B+6™v">gp#?Y;c*+p*62a>Z>t*Kv"l+|;56'"7,*+"M"X6"L"žcLni2,>1t¦*+p#&(XO;c*+(‚+tU;

GICU*+V}B+"¢+o_6F—Q%GC>(H*+8Rft,Pf+$CHUM+Rt0|;6gGY7I*+xŒa,PhL£>(H*+f2±'1t¦I*R\"Y,M+8GL(l+E'B+p#G>gV1'\y"7*gƒ+oR2X

&'(7#\tÅ'“5"D>+1' T2*"%$(ƒ"qDm*+ 5%@·"'&–_f'£YHU>+Q%Rft,Pf++oF"#h;"D06"Y;c*+\t7*}¨\ Ñt  ¼ Åp#ƒ+(M+_8d)7#xi+2M+5G@7i+2*+fn@H,/>

62Y;c*+6g+'tL`,>p#‹i2*+{Q*+stq@PZ@v(Ò h;"D0€3U@4_€L'?Y,@P5"Cwfpa.>6'"7,I*6g(3)>8\t;f•wZ*p#ƒc;"D,*+_-Ym,P'G*`/M+"3U@wG*`/#

&"Œ,L+¸'µI*GC@it*+G#…c*+G.bcM+'123)*6'"7,*+_8'+Q%5y",a*+ÓC0`Pƒc;"D,*+?4?Y;f?U~+ÍCv8V(M+Vtw+2*+_

pa.>6gh;"D,>O;c*+tw+2*+n#t>t7*+p#?Y;c*+5p>(‚+pa*'ÁWD>Z46g h;"D,>d37#hLtw+'|;Vtw!""_€LÁWD>O;c*"4"r>g6gK@.>O;c*+5(‚+ 

“"– "#gxi+2M+$,*+p.r,0(ˆLgp#h;"D0$b"U~pa.@v"3I@aŒ0O/wÍ.AGY7*GIr7#?z/*+(ˆLB++t@C70$,*+'./0AB/<,-0.B6“62/*'+"%#@Ô$[_p>\1"%"%)#Ô =U@I@^"%(*Ô>'+\"%)'Ô

1g_6\1"%"%)&–_£@YH,*+'@b(*+2%8}v20nI/*+G#"7*+_€Lpa.>6gt;"/0=b",A Õ

Page 29: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 29/248

*/01+2#3456% !7

6g'(  < LQ,>x@L6"L€3I#"708Ö"M+_—Q%'V1tC*+|;K@@.,*+(LQ,*+'-./06`4Q`0G@z@0+WPFO;c*+×>1"0h;"D,*+'gh#"7,*+£4"/*+?741"Y,;f+_

"_tC*d0\+t;F(>2H0't>t7*+p#(H*+hlGIr7#?z/*+_ƒ2,w+'hLVtw+'"3U#|;¤€/*+7Y4GHŒAB+G@v"Ž²+$,*+ <}¦0h;"D,*+$z@0+WPf+hˆ.4

—Q%5GC>(H*+p#h[g}@¦0G7@YXGIaŒM+haŒ4{(%2[_|;'{g5R"w6™vGIaŒM+

ƒ"‡"7M+ —Q% "3@v (v+2,0 f $,*+ xi+2M+ p# t>t7*+ \2[2* ]*o' 5$% €L CY0 G@I±B+_ 5+Q*d,@Ph#"7,*+n#GIaŒ  ¼ M+"3IaŒ45Ø"PB+6't4]I0ƒ+}@¦,*+_‹/@*"U%G@*Ò V(v2,#?Y;c*d3I7§62#2C>5ƒ+t>t3,4'gƒ"#+K,*+GI4"iQ@DU,I*“=U@I@^"%#'_–

"M"X6"L62Y;c*+}¨p>1\"i|;‰+K,*f+G@z@0+WP™45GU  < @7  ¼ #6™v|;hLtw+'d3U#6gQ`>6"Y/l"4Gv"Lƒ"@z@0+WP²+$,*+pa.> Ñc*O;(‚+6g"3#t©,/>_V\">…

|;5]*o6F?Y;c*+62aI,.>hLƒ"@z@0+WP²+GUa.  ¼ M+Gw",  ¼ M+'d³_&_‹/@*"U%p#GC>(XtL`,I*"ªZI7D@PO;c*+(‚+8G>gGICAGU@7#_

+Q%'ÙC>|;G@A"a#Fh@I¥"#j+1'GY7I*+“\1+'"%"%("

–{Q*+'-./>ƒ+1"@©4hˆ# ‘diDU41"@®+{Q*+‰'(>O;c*+(‚+‰"@C*+Z4_’€L6g+Q%h>K>"r>gG@A"a#FG7./*+GU@±(*+$,*+pa.>6gUY  ¼ 0|;GYi+(#O;c*+(‚+2%'h;"D,>n#&(X

*"~_5+Qa%'6™vG#2I7M+Vt@w2*+Gw",M+?Y;c*R2w"žtwg(‚+$%×>1"0d3I;"D0EF\'tw]I0G)qI*+_*_‹/@*"U%GC>(Xj"rCI*|;O;c*+(‚+'gÃI.,*+p#h;"D,*+_+Q*

6™vhLO;f¾D,uV1tC*"4|;6'"7,*+'g1t¦*+8hLGICA_@

_‹/@*"U%GC>(X}@¦,*ƒ+tb";'gOP"a#O;c*+(‚+_oF6g ƒ+tb"7*+'gOP"aM+p.r,0"DIPhLƒ+1"Y,;f+$,*+"3aI,.>O;c*+GqImMO;c*+(‚+“12I>"0"%(#ƒ"qDm*+ 5#%·(*–_

 Õ ƒc;"D,*+G@b"Uˆ*+8¤+Wi+G@D@L‰"@C*+h@Iq,4£.;gG*"lAB/<,-0.B65"r>g()A+“12I>"0"%(#

ƒ"qDm*+&%·#&–_ 

Page 30: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 30/248

$" "#$% &'(%)*+,-.%

£v'—Q%5¸'µ*+62a0ƒ€Ia*+}¨G;2DŒM+R"7vB"4Gm@1G.>t;'U7M+_cv]I.>62Y;c*+†2Ph;"D,*+n#d3r747Y*+¡;5d3L2IPf'jk†2P

]*o_—Q%'$%GIr7#?z/*+"3IaŒ4Ø"PB+_6F"#h7Ì6'"7,*+paªs'tl+2%GC@Cw6g?Y;c*+ti62C,I>+\tœ_$U70'

—Q%G@A"a#²+6gƒ+1"@®+$,*+Q  N ©  N ,  ¼ 0‰2@*+f\t  ¼ ¥Gz@,U*+V"2,M+p#—Q%GICU*+

5O/qvh4"eFpa.>6g(~S0|;ƒ+1"@®+GIYCM+GY/U*"4?Y;c*_+Q*6™vhYC,/M+ pa.>6g$CI>Z*c)4|;5š"l++QÊ'(~S>|;xi2M+$z@0+WP²+˜"l+_pa*'hYC,/M+higG@žgp#š"l+·]*o'?YY/*Ÿ5€³'g2%6g?Y;c*+

62I@.>2qAd@@C0ƒ+tb"7*+€@@C0hig"#tU;´  N qU>p#…R2ml+"3@I;2qAhYC,/M+_"#gOY/*+5Ë"ˆ*+23v6g"U%€b+\G±(v6`4f$C,I>62Y;c*+G@A"~_@w6gGic7*+

V(.,/M+&2P$3,U0"#tU;hC,U>+Q%O;c*+'g5+o'g}¦>5ZI.;'gƒ2.>'gÁ(7,>Tcv„*_

p>Q³'5?YY/*+6™vƒ+tb"7*+GÚ"U*+p;GICU*+G@*",*+f{(¦0(ˆLgp#ƒ+tb"; GICU*+G@*"l+_GC>(H*+'G@7@YH*+QB]*o86"Y/l+$%dL+(0ƒ+tb"7*+|;1'(#‹i2*+@q462a0GICU*+G#\"C*+{'"/0 ÉjK["U@7#p#GICU*+G@*"l+“]@42^"%('–_

Gic7*+'?46…'“'gG.@i–GICU*+G#\"C*+GY/U*"4GICUI*G@*"l+./,P“C–_$%'hˆ°G[1\dm®+'g¯"HC,Pf+p#ƒ+tb";hLGICAGY/U*"4GICUI*5GC4"/*++Q*$3vG4"ˆ.4

r3R-+pst%DE07.1BF <4-42,F,- _pa.>'‰+t©,P+T"@C#dm®+t>tq,*tb"7*+p#GI/I/*+"3,#(4_Í7U*f"ˆ#

"H@/4Ÿ+ÁWv6ghLGICA$%xmU4G@žgGICU*+5GC4"/*+"ªh7ÌC G &H"_+Q*6™v Í@1t¦*+R\"Y,M+{Q*+{'"/>GHCAVtw+'ha*GICA{'"/@PG.@i“"–8GICU*+E'B+'“&”"–8G@A"ˆ*+'“@”"–8GICU*+5Gˆ*"ˆ*++Qa%']@*+'\_62a,P'G.@C*+

[email protected]+W*+G@*"Ú²+GI/I/I*$%"Û&”"Û@”"Û)”"_"ªh7z@PG.@C*+G@*"Ú²+Õ&

"#"°_|;'5‰2.7*+6™vR2ml+|;GHCAVtw+'8hLGICA{'"/@PŸ"I C I&C I

Page 31: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 31/248

*/01+2#3456% $#

C*  JJ_p#'£b"Cl+Vt@DM+"U%6g¯2.œ—Q%GI/I/*+G@%"U,#c*+{B“C–¡Lgp#(Dm*+hig'p#"$%GX"/Y4"”“"/C_–

Q`U*'G*"w5†(g+oF‹A"LG.@ihLGICA{'"/0%'Gb"M"4p#G.@iGICU*+5GC4"/*+6™vGI/IPƒcCU*+G.@C4“"–ha*"3U#{'"/@PVµ;¸"CAÍCv6B"”“" K

C6 G "”“"/'_%–G "H'_"G "'5|;'DA51+(¦*+"#tU;62a0G.@iC{'"/0%_5

6™vGI/IPGA2a#p#*¸"CAp#ƒÜv"aM+G*\"Y,M+{'"/,PG~c~&"7Žg5+Q%{g*'

GHCA_p7.,U*'6‚+8R"ˆ#?Y;c*6c;"D,>n#€3r74_+ÁWv6g"Y;fnY,>GP"@P

1t¦*+db+t*+“LMM D–5"#gO;c*+(‚+nY,@vGP"@PNVtw+2*+Vtw+249O9 PQ5 

9L9 R_GP"@P'!Vtw+2*+Vtw+24"$%6'"7,*+8GICU*+5E'B+d~‰"@C*+hˆ.4"#h7vO;c*+(‚+8GICU*+GC4"/*+_$U70'—Q%GP"@/*+6gNVtw+2*+Vtw+24"1t¦,PV(#

Vtw+'t74hLG*"w1t¨p#&(XO;c*+(‚+_"#tU;'‰t©,/>O;c*+(‚+

GP"@P“Vtw+2*+Vtw+24–56™vO;c*+{Q*+1t¦> É€b+\R'B+hmq@P|;“9

–8 GICU*+5E'B+'“?–8n@ÚƒcCU*+G@*",*+_"#g*UR-6%j#u*vb,6%a$,*+hmu"3@I;{Q*+‰t©,/>GC>(X“1t¦*+db+t*+–{g“LMM D–"#tU;O7I>n#é^‰t©,/>

GC>(X“Vtw+2*+Vtw+24–62a,/v¯2.œG.@i“9–GICUI*5E'B+'“C?–5G@A"ˆI*'“C

&?–5Gˆ*"ˆI*+Qa%'_!"" 

6F$,C>(X“1t¦*+db+t*+LMM D–'“Vtw+2*+Vtw+24–"ž6",@z@0+WPF_'*RVRE%w;q%“'gP,f3Zb%J-6%–V12m4G#";$%V1"Y;p;t>t¥"#{Q*+OÌZI7v8

{gxi2#tistu_t.,7>'xi2M+Z/DA|;×>1",*+Ö"M+GY7I*_5+Q*6™v

 “"– 6FG.@C*+$,*+d,>R2ml+"3@I;8G*"w1t¦*+(.,/M+"#tU;‰2C>O;c*+(‚+

O7I4!Vtw+2*+Vtw+24"$%S

TALMM DU9P96 G 9 I C? I C&? I C*? JJJ

G 9 I C? I A"I C I C& VJ6

G 9 I C?H A" K C6J

Page 32: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 32/248

$! "#$% &'(%)*+,-.%

G@z@0+WP²+ti6'"7,0t7474¸€AB+5G@I;"D,*+1t¦0't74"3r74(‚+_Gv"Ž²"4EF5]*o6™vG@z@0+WP²+ti‰t©,/05ƒf€,wf+€L8R"ˆ#Vt;"C*+G@b+2Œ7*+"#"°8"3I#"70n#ƒf€,wf+G>'"/,M+6'"7,*+'g1t¦*+8hLGICA_€Lpa.>6g62a0

G@z@0+WP²+VtC7#"#"°8"3#+t©,P+Í.U*=b",U*+GC4"/*+8GY7I*+tl6‚+p#h[gt>t¥"#O[2,>ZI7vcYC,/#_p#'GIˆ#B+|;5]*oGY7I*+$,*+Ý2m02IPO;c*+

5(‚+8hL5GICA‰+t©,P"4=3U#tC7#“[email protected]&2L1"#|;h@YPR"ˆM+–5p#'d~ ‰t©,/0GC>(XG@*"@c*"C,^$b"mw²+“h@Iq,*"LÞ>"Y*+–1"@,f"#'tY>|;ZAghrvgƒ+1"@®+|;†tM+t@7Y*+_'gti62a0"H@I"C@i\p#ƒ"@z@0+WPF†(g_

ti62a>R+S/*+R'B+{Q*+(H¬]*"Y46gZw(H02%Ÿ‘"#$%hrvgJG@z@0+WPF’'gV1"Y745†(g"#$%G@z@0+WP²+$,*+‰tC,PO; <c*|;gG[1\GUaª

p#J¸"CU*++Q%R+SP5Z@['pa*'€L-r,@P5"Cwfft[20"U%Vt;"iGIC,/#p;G@z@0+WP²+$,*+"3#t©,/>O;c*+(‚+_p#'+Q%5£IHUM+6™vGIr7#?z/*+

V1(a,M+GDI,Ï"#"°p;GY7*†(gGY7IL=A(HŒ*+cˆ#_O;cv=A(HŒ*+pa.>6gÁWD>6`4O;c*+(‚+‰2C@PGICU*"4(ˆLB++1Qw_+Q%Á+Wvf+2%{Q*+(v2@P

"P"PgÍ@H©,I*8GY7*GY7IL5=A(HŒ*+@w62a0-*"m#?Y;c*+G>\"7,#"#"°_pa*'xi+2M+$,*+"3# <tC  ¼ 0GY7*GIr7#?z/*+GDI,Ï"#"°_-*"m.v?Y;c*+‹/@*8¯+߉"0_pa.>ca*?Y;c*+6g"#2C>h.74t@[R2ml"4|;V`v"aM+“5 –6'"7,I*

5R\"Y,M+'g6"7@H,/>‰"@C*+h.74x@7Žp#RcR2ml+|;G42C7*+“?–1t¦I*R\"Y,M+_6FÁ+Wvf+6`4O;c*+(‚+‰2C@P|;‰+'t*+GICU4"%"ŒÄ5‹Ag\2C@P

EFni2,*+6`4O;c*+(‚+&2Pp*6'"7,>5"CIH#\2C@P'+Q%—1't4EF51t¦*+"ª

OY/>ƒ"42C;fG>"e"³_5+Q*|7va;GY7*5=A(HŒ*+8GY7*GIr7#?z/*+@* p#],qIm#6gÁWD06`4O;c*+(‚+R"U@P]U#_ 85ni+2*+8GIr7#5?z/*+t.,70G@z@0+WP²+(ˆLB+"w"zA|;

G@z@0+WP²+$,*+"3#t©,/>O;c*+5(‚+haŒ4'5¶"Y#|;'Z['52m®+|;"#+oF‹A"L—Q%G@z@0+WP²+W0f"œ[email protected],*6'"70R\"Y,#‰gf_t.,7>+Q%gtYM+|;

Page 33: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 33/248

*/01+2#3456% $$

G.@iGICU*+G@*",*+GY/U*"4GICUI*5G@*"l+"#'+oF‹A"LGYP"U#€4Z@vG>"Da*+h7z,*hYC,/M+€3#_V1"Y745†(g6FT"@C#dm®+“C–ft4p#6g62a>+}YL€4Z@vG>"Da*+h7z@*hYC,/M+¤2I>haŒ4-Ž+'8ƒ"4"/wƒ+tb"7*+G@*"Ú²+_|;'

5‰2.7*++oF:pa>p#h.,qM+GY/U*"4]*6gZ[+20+Q%éŒ*+G@A"~“8G*2[G@A"~p#GY7I*+–5'g6F‹ULfZ4`0+}ˆLƒ+tb"7*"45G@IYC,/M+]7P2Yv6g1t¦06‚+6'\6g

£IC0+}ˆLR2wƒ"7Y,*+G@IYC,/M+_ "A\2C>'+Q%EFG@Ž(D*[email protected](*+E'B+_ZAFpM5xPSM++oF6"LhYC,/M+5€3#6gf62a0"U%G@z@0+WPFGI#"L|ˆ#_

G@Ž(D*+E'B+Ÿ6F6"LT"@C#dm®+“C–5"7D0(#haŒ45&"L‹/@*"U%G@z@0+WPF|ˆ#GIC,/#p;G@z@0+WP²+$,*+"3#t©,/>O;c*+(‚+_

6"%¡*+'|;]*o@*"Y7±_+ÁWv6gO;c*+(‚+‰t©,/>GH1t¦*+db+t*+/LMM D/_6F:6'"7,>O;c*+(‚+5 É"CIH  ¼ #hrv`v"#n@H,/0‰"@C*+Z42%6g

1t¦0‹Ag"r>g_6‚+'5ÁWv+p#G@w"A5†(g6gO;c*+(‚+nY,>G@z@0+WPF ‘‰"C,Af+db+t*+_’$%'G@z@0+WPF6'"7,*+,w‰"@C*+51t¦*"4"3U@w'62a>1t¦*+|; 92qA(.,/#_8'—Q%5R"l+62a,PG@z@0+WP²+|ˆM+GY/U*"4]*6gf1t¦05"CIH#

GH>¶6gCI,>j+(¨²+1t¦*"48GICU*+E'B+"r>270+}YL+t[Gz@,A1+šº*Vt@74†tM+GÚ"U*+p;‰t;R2ml+|;jk†2PG42C7*+“?–5@*'V`v"aM+“5 –58(b"P

ƒcCU*+G#\"C*+_62a@P+Q%"q@q±€IL6"LT"@C#dm®+“C–+}YL€4Z@vG>"Da*+!""_+Q*6™vG*`/#]A'"70p#Z#t;t.,70|;G@z@0+WP²+G#t©,/M+p#hYi

O;c*+5(‚+QU#'GICU*+E'B+_5Z@I;'6F6"LT"@C#dm®+“C–5+}YLf62a0"U%G@z@0+WPF|ˆ#_

 “"– +oF6"LO;c*+(‚+‰t©,/>G@z@0+WPF‰"C,Af+5(.,/M+]A™v62a,Phrvgf"w"#tU;

6'"7,0"ª62a0Z@I;+oF"#ƒ1t¨"#tU;62a>5HA" KC6 W 9 I C? H A"/C6'gC W A9 K56H

A9 K ?6_

Page 34: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 34/248

$% "#$% &'(%)*+,-.%

"#g8G*"wIœ$7>µ0Iz.L¹2@Œ*+5$a>(#B+6™v+Q%¤WCM+R2C>6F‹A"L"U%G±(vVt@[6`4‰2C>twgj"r;gIzM+6'"7,*"4h;"D,*+'*R?3xn#2r;5(Ò p*62a0"U%G@z@0+WPFVtw+'|ˆ#‰t©,/  ¼ ,*RK7.4p;G@z@0+WP²+

G#t©,/M+p#&(XéŒ*+Ë"ˆ*+_62a@P'p#hrvB+6'"7,*+n#é^h#"7,>hˆM"4 <\(>'+Q%6'"7,*+hˆM"485hYC,/M+@*'n#é^p*(~`,>ZL2IPÐYC,/M+

+}ˆL+Qʯ2U*+p#h;"D,*+“ÐaU@% 5R"ˆM+ h@YP |; 5()A+"%(&

–_6FG@A"a#FR2ml+|; 6'"70R\"Y,#(C,/#t.,70|;t[+20G±(vGU/w1+(.,Pc*5h;"D,*"4O/q4dzwT"@C#dm®+“C–_€L'stu85ni+2*+8G*"w5T(¦A2a*+6™vG±(D*+GqA"/*+?U~fp#j"r;B+‰"@CI*h;"D,4$b"U~(.,/#€3U@4tiƒt>+K0haŒ4}YL"#tU;

ƒ12%t0O/Aƒ"7@YM+G@U@,U/*+“$,*+st¥hL?#"; XE,BBE4Y–p#@'Gb"M"48ƒ+2U/*+?741B+E'B+p#‰"@i5G>123.‡+EF&'Gb"M"4"Y>(C08ƒ+2U/*+V}B+

“àA2>"%## 5Ÿ)(/ %'$Y/*24 Ô"%#)KA2[ Ô"%(( 5Ÿ"$@Ô62P}0"4"%() 5Ÿ"@/*@@–_

|;'hL5R"w6™v"U*2i6`4G±(D*+V(.,/M+h;"D,I*$%jk{1'š(>2H,* 56'"7,*+f$U7>"UAgR2CA"e`4jk&"L_¤"r>²"v‰t74\2['G@z@0+WPFVtw+'|ˆ#W>R+S/*+R2w¸€AB+G@L2I/*+$,*+pa.>ni205"%123›€U@w62a0"U%c7vG@*€,w+G@*";G@v"L1+(.,Pfh;"D,*+?45p>\(D*+ZLW>6'\y+2[&"^_

hYiZ[2,*+2qAGP+1\2I/*+{Q*+ni2,>5—123›1tÌ"U46g$CIAV()AGY>(i|;ƒ+K@M+G@7i+2*+$,*+5pa.>$,*+'f5pa.>1"X²h.;GY7*GIr7#?z/*+6g

Í@u"Ê_p/l'5¾l+6™vGX"/41"XFh.7*+h7§p#pa.M+OU§t>t7*+p#

ƒ"Ž+Wvf+Vt  < @CM+$,*+{\S,P&c©4]*oEFt>t¥h@Iq,*+Ÿ"Jf«",¥ƒ+tb";?Y;c*+EF6g62a0GA1"C#|;cX²+_|;h@YP

5R"ˆM+tihmu$Dq±?7#|;V`v"a#p#RcO>´0GmiG>1"YFG@I+\G>á†(g5Z@*F€U@4hmu$X+(i'}Y*+6'"7,M+|;V`v"a#G±(D4‰"@CI*d>tC,4GŒi"U#R2w†twFƒ"P"@/*+G#"7*+1")U.4'O  < Y  ¼ Å_

Page 35: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 35/248

*/01+2#3456% $&

&JfO[2,>|;ƒ+tb"7*+6g62a0GI~€,#6't4]^_p.vdbcM++t[()U*+EFh;"D,*+|;ZAgâv"a,#"#"°p#1")U#5?Y;c*+pa*'+Q%@*">1'š_f«",u

j(M+EFÁ+Wvf+6`4V`v"a#6'"7,*+5R\"Y,M+|;h@YP5R"ˆM+'g{gp#ƒ+¶SM+G~cˆ*+†(B+5ƒ+tb"7I*n,.,0DU41+tCM+†t*c Ç L?Y;c*+_€L'"A(Lo5"C4"Pf$¦YU>|;j(M+,w6g5ÁWD>2*'\(œ5Á+Wv+"e`4T"C0O/wƒ+tw'GA1"C#_

jÎ*+t@w2*+{Q*+OÌZŽ+Wv+2%5ZAgGY/U*"4ha*5O;fd,>O@0(0ƒ+tb"7*+ n41B+O/w‰")U*+12LQM+8x>(70GIr7#?z/*+_*Jf$¦YU>6gT"C0ƒ+tb";O;c*+ N£v Ç'T"@C#£IH#_h4«",¥EF6g

T"C0GA1"CM"4n#"3r747Y*+_!"" 

@Jf«",u6'"7,*+6B¡,7  ¼ >"YYÅp#G3['()A(b"PT"U*+_"U3vƒ"i'g«",u"3@v\(D*+Gi";²6'"7,*+?4?Y;c*+5Z7U#'@*'Ç—K>K7,*_6Fƒ"P1"ªR€;B+

G>1"z,*+G>(#Ü,*+Vt@[GY/U*"4n>1"Œ.I*G>1"z,*+ƒ+o5Gic7*+"3Ua*'‹/@*Vt@[€4

Z@vG>"Da*+GY/U*"4(b"/*n.,zM+_85ni+2*+6Fd)7#R"a^g\"/D*+$%GIˆ#gG@Y@w(0 |;6'"7,*+GY/U*"45?LWŒ.I*"#gGY/U*"4d%+2/*$3v}¨Ow(#"Ê_5+Q*$Dv745ƒ"YP"UM+d,>‰+t©,P+G>()U*+haŒ4T2a7#h[B6"@4G@D@LnU#56'"7,*+ft4p#

Z7@zŒ0_$Jft[20G["wÁ+Wvc*6`4?Y;c*+562@AcC;@Ivp#V1'À*+6g

+2[",uEF$7/*+V\">K*d¢`v"a#EFtl+ÓiB+_ti'a70d¢"@z@0+WP+GX"/Y4ƒ+j+([Fh.7*+5G>1"@7M+'gƒ"P1€M+5G#"7*+'g5Kb+(¦*+'gt@IC,*+“62.>"P"%$$ƒ(>"P Ô

 ã01"#'"%#*–_

 “"– +Q%'$U7>6gnv"UM+«",¥ÍCv6gT"C0£v'T"@C#h±"D*+$U#K*+_‰+t©,P+'T"@C#

h±"D*+$U#K*+$U7>6gh@ˆ°ƒ";2vtM+pa.>6g}¦,>n#{gR <2¥$Hä"Ì+n#']*oCY>€L52%€L2%R"wG[1\V1+(l+$,*+CY0"3/DAj+2Pd0"3P"@iO/wT"@CM+{2åM+'g

T"@C#‹>"%"A(3v_

Page 36: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 36/248

$' "#$% &'(%)*+,-.%

#J6FR"7vB+$,*+‰2C>"Ê62Y;c*+‹/@*V1'À*"4ƒ+1"@G@;+'G>'"/,#_éŒ*"v{Q*+ <\(>|;n@Um*+t@‡+8746"@wB+5hˆM"4f'‰2C>]*Q4

86"@wg5†(gtif(aD>G@z@0+WP²"4G7Y,M+8ZU@w_@*"U%p#¯+\Á+Wvc*\2[241"@,f+{tmC*+|;cX²+_!""

 

6F1"XFh.7*+nP+'€4$Da>GX"w„*@*ÍCv5T"U*"4h4d#B"4">WaY*+'

|;twj+2P_d#B"v6'\]^Q©,0f"7vgpa.>"%}/D0hˆ#ƒ+1"@®+8GIr7# 5?z/*+€L2%R"l+8R"ˆ#nv1Gv(7,*+G@L(.‡+'g"3rD_€LZAg@*p#{1'À*+Á+Wvf+6`4R"7vB+$%R"7vg5G@AcC;'g"egGz@,Ah.;O;f'ghˆª

tw+'7/>2qA&t%?7#_|;5a7*+"e™vpa.>6g62a0Gz@,Aƒ"P"@/*G@X+(i'}4VtC7#haŒ42D>512m,*+h.,Œ0|;ƒ"#2I7#VtC7#=*"70ƒ"D*"q,*+

G@P"@/*+"%}¦0'“62/@*+"%("–_|;'DA51+( Ç ¦*+|;'&(H*+(‚+p#5G@rC*+f«",¥ƒ"Ub"a*+G@l+EF

Ý"#\$a*O7I0GY7*_5">WaY*"v|;h@YP5R"ˆM+Vt>t^G4"z,Pf+7Y*$w+2U*+ V"C,UM+p#"3,å@4G@b"@.@a*+_]*Q*$3vn@H,/0G4"z,Pf+|;2qAxI,Ï"MZI7D0ƒ"Ub"a*+G@l+5†(B+—Q%'ƒ"@z@0+WP²+G@L2I/*+5G@Xµ*+pa.>6gs <120_

Gv"ŽFEF5]*o6™v2IP">WaY*+pa.>6g(~S>|;G.bc#'gGi"@*ƒ"Ub"a*+G@l+†(B+5"³2w€Iˆ#pa.>2I/*ƒ"Ub"a*+G@l+†(B+6g(~S>|;Gi"@*">WaY*+_

"UUa*'"A(\+ƒ"C@YH,*+G@[2*2@Y*+hmDI*#"®+_"#g56‚+ æOmUPh["U#€,%+|;T"U*+ƒ"/PSM+'_5]*Q*p#t@DM+6g&(7A

ZAgp#h[[email protected],*+@*p#V1'À*+6"a.46gÁWDA}ˆa*+R2wG[1\G>tmC*+•Y,*+'†t*T"U*+_f'6g5ÁWDA€Lh7D>j€I  ¼ ;5j"@wB+6`4$w+2U*+G#"³+p#

2IP6"/A²+nrÄV\"@C*Z0"U@[_GC>(H*"v"U%G@z@0+WPF(ˆLg"3U#G@U@[_

 “"– t>K.I*p#ƒ"#2I7M+R2w?#"r#‰t;GY*"HM+1"@,f"4t.7,M+8Í.U*+{12H,*+}¦,I*

5{\"m,if+“()A+62/I@AWU>''"%)&–_

Page 37: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 37/248

*/01+2#3456% $5

5nYH*"4'6™vh@aŒ,*+\ <(  N z  ¼ M+GIaŒM6'"7,*+GIr7.L?zP$  < qU  ¼ 0t>t7*+p#ƒ"Dm*+G>2@l+$,*+h7§{gh;"D0$C@Cw"å@^5+t>(v"37r0'"YA"[_€L6gGIˆ#B+

$,*+ <|Ä"3U;t>(z,*+ÐaŒ*+p.r,08"¢"@XG@A"a#Fh±+2,*+5{2¦I*+}~`,*+'¶"YM+&(H*5*"~ƒcaŒ#'Q@DU051"@,f+‰t;'pC@,*+"ªZI7vO;c*+8GICU*+

GC4"/*+_8'hmD*+5p#"ˆ*+‹D@Žg74—Q%ß"U7*+VtC7M+«o2.UI*Ø"PB+_p#

-Ž+2*+ZAgpa.>[email protected]"iß"U7*+GI.,qM+ƒ+o5GIm*+$,*+'d05"3L(0|;'  92qA$%"U,  ¼ #f_5nYH*"4'@*"U%p#hi";‰2C>[email protected]"@,+G#"%6'\G*'"ÅQghˆ#—Q%h#+27*+VtC7M+()U41"Y,;f+_oF6gG.@ih@Iq,*+"e't4p.a08"3U  < a°p#

Vt;"/M+|;¤"r>F74p#ƒ"D±h;"D,*+G,4"ˆ*+·ƒ"Dm*+$,*+pa.>8&c]*o6gn@r08G%",#ƒ+t@C70&'()*+G±"®+5+t[$,*+'OÌ"3@v‰"@C*+7Y4

ƒ+1"@®+G@C@Cl+_6F+Q%t@C7,*+{Q*+p.@½|;ni+2*+2%{Q*+h7Ìh;"D,*+{t>(z,*++t@D#+t[GI@P2LVt;"/#d3DI*_

xŒa,/>hmD*+‰\"C*+123›6'"7,*+p#RcGP+1\"#{Q*+pa.>6g Z#t©,/0G@z@0+WP²+Vt@‡++oF"#‹3[+'"Di2#xi2.LGIr7#?z/*+_ti'{([g+Q%&"Œa,Pf+GC>(H45 ŠG; Nt,Y  ¼ #$%8ni+2*+G*2H4y"7*g5G@A'Wa*+@w$; ¼\

74{()U#y"7*B+?vWqM+d>tC,*d3,@z@0+WPF5GIrDM+ti'd06+(iFhLVtw+'p#t;+2io"Ä+1+(C*+n#hLVt;"i5†(gGv(7M=#"A¡*+{Q*+h.7@PhaŒ4hrvgp#?4n@.‡+_p#'}ˆM+5y+(¦,Pc*6gG@z@0+WP²+Gq4+(*+‹A"L$%Í/4B+p#?4n@Úƒ"@z@0+WP²+G#tCM+_‹A"L'—Q%G@z@0+WP²+$%G@z@0+WPF!Vtw+2*+

Vtw+24"5$%'G@z@0+WP²+$,*+6'"7,08GICU*+E'B+p#'d~‰2C0hˆ.4"#h  N 7  N v

O;c*+(‚+8GICU*+GC4"/*+_d~‹>([gG*2[G@A"~p#5G*2HY*+d0"3@vR"\Ft>KM+ p#ƒctM+p#hYiV+2³+?vWqM+'|;tw5j+2P6"L'hLd3U#&(7>=b",AG*2‡+E'B+_‹A"L'Gz@,U*+$%…2v(Ò G@z@0+WP²!Vtw+2*+Vtw+24"çti'xŒLh@I¥ƒ"A"@4—Q%G*2HY*+p;n41gƒ€Ph@°2qAh7[=#"A¡*+5"q["A$%'ŸOU§

¯+•*+}¨{1'À*+p#Rc6'"7,*+"M"X6"LO;c*+(‚+h7D>Ô]*o

Page 38: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 38/248

$6 "#$% &'(%)*+,-.%

V1"ˆ,Pf+'“'gG@I4"C*+G>…+KD,Pf+–tU;Á <(7,*+ƒ"YP"UM1t¦*+}¨V1¡M+p#&(XO;c*+Ô(‚+-#"/,*+'t74G4"z,Pf+Ô…+KD,Pc*¤2Ž2*+'82I/*+$a*n@H,/>O;c*+(‚+6gx@a,>n#Í.Ah7D*+{Q*+‰2C0Z4_

?Y0'=b",U*+V"C,/M+p#—Q%y"7*B+ZAg8h›&'()*+5GYP"U  ¼ M+pa.>6'"7,I*6g(3)>c7v8:";p#5G@A"AB+?4¸"P'g5?@A"AB+6'\G["l+EFGHIPG>KL(#_

h[B'Gv(7#†t#G@I4"i—Q%=b",U*+|;5£@YH,*+d0$UY0 É"z  N e">()A8hmD*+ *"ˆ*+_ti'‹°GU%(4GI/IPp#ƒ"Ž+Wvf+$,*+f <?Y0ƒ"YIH,#123›6'"7,*+5O/qvh4‰ <tC0GmiV`ŒA6'"7,*+haŒ4h/I/,#_"%'2%Rt‡+haŒ4•,ÏŸ

OIH,0V`ŒA6'"7,*+6gn,.,>\+(vB+G±(D4G7P+'G@v"L'j"CI*V(#†(g$a*62a,>d½t*‰€,%+d¢c#"7,4G@IYC,/M+_6F6"L]*o5"q@q±6™v6'"7,*+pa.>6g12H,>

|;sc~hw+(#Ÿ"_6FG>+t4GmC*+$%6g6'"7,*+pa.>6ggtY>,w8:";p#1t¦*+}¨

¸'µM+_oF6g12H,*+y80Uz6gstu+oF"#R'"w\+(vg6'(ˆ7Y#"U%5"U%'‹/@* d½t*G>gG±(vh;"D,I*n#d3r7457Y*+6g+2#2C>Z4_|;'hL5R"wpa.>6'"7,I*6g12H,>p#ƒ"7.§V}¦±p#\+(vB+p>Q*+62UY>de'"70|;T"Pg5˜\"Y0

$a*+2Imu|;jK[}¦±p#d3I;"D0n#d3r747Y*+_&_"#gxm,U#5GmC*+$3v6gG@z@0+WP²+G@UYM+|;R\"Y,*+pa.>6gã7,U0

8:";d,>Z@vO>(§t>t7*+p#¯+2Agƒ"@z@0+WP²+GDI,©M+_*_"#gG>"eGmC*+$3v6g56'"7,*+\(z.4Z/@P`0|;T"Pg5R\"Y,*+pa.>

6g$.uZ/DAtŽ¤"@,[f+‰\"C*+p#ƒ"@z@0+WPf+hiB+"A'"70_5+Q*6™vƒcz; hCAGL(l+812H,*+$;€,[f+]I,°hDi6"#g“-4F7Z,F_–Q©,>6cmD*+n4+(*+#"®+'ƒ"@DIG>\"#6"@Y*†t#G@I4"i—Q%=b",U*+

£@YH,I*_tCvT è(LhmD*+n4+(*+G*"qI*G4+Q‡+$,*+h.70‰")U4‘ã;¯\'}¨ã@7>’5$,*+'ƒ(3›8\"U®+G@*",C*+8y(l+G@M"7*+E'B+_ÍP2v¯+•*+5(>(M+

Page 39: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 39/248

*/01+2#3456% $7

6"L\2U[¸2H®+G@#"#B+62vK7>p;cXF"±(*+G  < @U4h,C*+·GH>¶6gh  N 4"C  ¼ >d3v'K;+Q%5hˆM"4h#"7,>'&(H*+(‚+d37#DU4y2IPB+_6F"#h7[+Q%&'K7*+R\"Y,M+"Uaª2%G*"l+G,4"ˆ*+V(C,/M+'\"U®5R",C*+$,*+'Š‹3[+'"3@v+\t;

p#ƒ+tw2*+V}¦m*+"3r747Y*+ƒ+WD*GI>2Xp#p#K*+_tC*]3,A+\2U[—Q%ƒ+tw2*+V}¦m*+V(w"U,M+(#+'B+V1\"m*+p;d¢\"ip#h[g£@C¥6'"70(  N .r  ¼ #n#

d3r747Y*+_6FV()AGImD#+Q³G*"l+?Y0"U*ZAg"#tU;(v2,0&'()*+Vt;"/M+ |;123›56'"7,*+ZA™v·{g6'"7,*+·pa.>6g5gtY>p%¡>'|;—1+(C,P+8xi+2M+$,*+'tY08&c]*o}¨G7zŒ#|;cX²+_6F‰")A‘ã;¯\'}¨ã@7>’5|;Z['52m®+ <?Y>6gGi+tm*+€  < Ii62a0G>1'šh[B(>2H06'"7,*+_$Dvh›

&'()*+5V(C,/M+pa.>6'"7,I*$UYM+|;T"PgR\"Y,*+6g12H,>,w?4‰2m®+_

"#ghmD*+5#"®+{Q*+'ZY,L:";j"@wB+‰"@*'\_562,I@#"% <?Y@v6g6'"7,*+pa.>6g(3)>,w6't4V}m4'g&+µ,P+hYC,/.I*_stu'+Q%p#Rc

-@Ž2,*+6`4G>()A6'"7,*+pa.>6g < D  ¼ 0¸€AB+G@L2I/*+Vt[+2,M+8"HAnP+' p#G.)AB+5G@[2*2@Y*+p#">WaY*+EF12@H*+_pa.>6gstu6'"7,*+8G.)AB+G@[2*2@Y*+,w"#tU;f62a0"U%Gic;?45?L1"ŒM+h4,w"#tU;fn@H,/>62L1"ŒM+d@@C0ƒ"7Y,*+GY0WM+|;d3L2IP_6F"#h7Ì+Q%"Uaª$%ƒ"@*‚+

G>12H,*+5ƒ"U@zI*gtY#'j"CY*+†2iº*_\(D*"v1\"C*+|;R2ml+|;G4"z,P+G7v"Ap#\(v(Ò 62a,PZ>t*G±(v¡LgR2mqI*|;h/Apa.>6g$CY>|;5Z,*cP

]*o'h7z@PÍ.U*+5$L2I/*+{Q*+…"w|;G4"z,P+G7v"Ap#5p>(‚++(.,/#_5+Q*$Dvh›&'()*+5GYP"UM+‹Yˆ>6'"7,*+$UYM+|;G./*+G@*\"Y,*+—1+(C,P+8:"7*+

$b"@wB+_p#'ƒ"C@YH,*+GUa.M++Q³(#B+]I0$,*+-r,08¯"v\74ƒ"Ub"a*+p; "%\'tw5G@.@Ii²+8'"3['+K0"3Ž(#'_G±c®+'$%6gt@L`06'1+\|;Vtb"D*+G>\(D*+5pa.>85ni+2*+6g´D>\2[''"7,*+6?4\+(vB+p#DAT"U[B+

5G@[2*2@Y*+h4,w?4GDI,©M+"3U#_oF"M"X‹A"L"U%&'(›5G.bc#pa.>6'"7,I*6g5gtY>ã7,U>'p#'d~(C,/>_

Page 40: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 40/248

%" "#$% &'(%)*+,-.%

€U@4f¡,70V}mY*+"å@^">1'šV`ŒU*56'"7,*+"3Ua.>6g62a0c#";+t;"/#ha4t@L`0_5]*Q*"UP(L?ImD*+T\"/*+n4"/*+'d>tC,*-mU*+?L1"Œ.I*

5?qImM+'|;˜+2,*+_hmD*"vT\"/*+-Ž2>?#"r#G>()A6'"7,*+ha*p#2%8xi2#GIr7#?z/*+_p.vG3['()A51"ŒM+6F&t³+2%‰"@C*+hrv`4jk5paª&•4()U*+p;†t#p/wj+\gO;c*+(‚+_\€,;f"4'|;=b",A5G*2HY*+"U#ti

G741gƒ"wWC#GH@/41"@,f\+(vB+Ÿfpa0+\2/w¤"zU*O;c*+Ô(‚+fpa0 R'gp#Ô1t¦>Z[+'hLp#6'"7,*+1t¦*+'ÔhˆM"4f'L+Q,0'gpa0"@Lo(ˆLgp#‰…c*+_

pa.>d3D*G3['()A1"ŒM+6g(v2>"P"PgG>é(*"#pa.>ZI7vh[Bh@3/02.A6'"7,*+?4?@A"AB+—12H0'_5+Q*6™vhmD*+n4"/*+Q`>1")UM+$YM'B+twB

?qImM+p>Q*++'\+1g}@¦0¸'¶ƒc;"D,*+"3/DAh[Bn@P20123›6'"7,*+_d,vQgt>t7*+p#(H*+?7451"Y,;f+hˆ#h7[ƒc;"D,*+?4?Y;c*+R2Xg8"¢+Wv

G@U#K*+(ˆLg'(a05+1+'gd@I70?L1"ŒM+x@L62.,½5d3r7Y4d3.@I70'G@D@L+1\FG.@iG@±"®+G@*\"Y,*+_(v2>'1")U#- Ç Im  ¼ M++Q%+•Y0+Qv"A8t>t7*+p#5n@Ž+2M+p#V2i5G@X+(i'}Y*+EFO;"mM+$,*+"33[+2>5(z¦*+p#'ƒ"@icgNVtw+2*+Vtw+24R

EFpvG4",Lƒ+t%"7M+_+Q%n  < P2>'hmD*+p#"ˆ*+p#?#"r#G>()A6'"7,*+8ƒf"œVt>t[_@w

   <?Y>x@L(~S0xI,ÏUY*+G@;€,[f+8GC>(H*+$,*+pa.>6g12H,>"3@v6'"7,*+_|7vh@YP5R"ˆM+pa.>T"UI*¸"Y01f+d3r7Y47Y*+(H4GDI,Ï(~`,0ƒ€/*"4

5V12)UM+hˆ#U‡+(.7*+'62*'VµY*+GC>(X'YIM+_pa.>'—Q³ƒ"q.I*+'g

ƒ+1"^²+6g\2C0EFU4G@;€,[+G@UY#|;Í@.U,*+“'g1+(a0¸€AB+–ƒ"Y0+W*+' G@#(³+_R"ˆ.L'|;UY*+5G@;€,[f+‹°GP+1\1'\G7./*+ƒQg'?741"Y,;f+_oF6g¯+•*+{Q*+Z*QY>j(M+p#h[g@P`0Z,7.PÈ"Dl+'"3@I;pa.>6g62a>GD±

G@P"Pgp#ƒ"D±ƒ";+•*+GDˆaM+_|7vh@YP5R"ˆM+6™vt@7m0G#2al+G@a>(#B+y(qI*8‰"U,@v‰";"%#$†K7>G[1t*"4E'B+EF"3,Y¨18¯\1ƒ">tq,*+†(B+

Page 41: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 41/248

*/01+2#3456% %#

$,*+Z[+20"3l"m#p#Rc"3›"Dw|;"3,7.P8Gw"/*+G@M"7*+_€LR'"U,>+Q%hmD*+"r>g&'"ÏG#2al+GCI7,M+È"Dl"4|;"3,7.P‰"#g"3@UX+2#_p.vh[g6g

62a0G#2al+5GI;"v@*"37P246gÁ(D0G>g}>"7#p#"%1"@,+5$%h4"3@I;6ghmq,/0G;"H*+'g‰+K,*f+p#hYiG@YI¨g?UX+2M+p>Q*+d3.a¥_p#'h[g‰"@C*+

5]*Q4O[2,>nŽ't;+2C*+$a*t§—Q%G@YI¨B+6gp#"3,qIm#6gn@H0G#2al+

8d)7#ƒ"i'B+_6F?#"r#—Q%GC>(H*+G@P"PgGY/U*"4R"¦,^fGHI/*+5"3,@I;"v' €L"egt§hrvgR"ˆ#$q@Ž20"³8s2I,*+5$;"Um*+]*QL'8&+¶²+|;hwƒ";+KAcH*+_

R2Iq4'hmD*+5}B+ƒ12H0GŒi"UM+p#GP+1\123)*12H,*+?4?@A"AB+6'\GHIP5G>KL(#EFh@I¥"Mstq@P"#tU;(uT"U*+A4C|;d3r7457Y*+"#'{Q*+stq@P2*‹A"L"U%GHIPG>KL(#_pa*'GC>(H*+G@P"PB+CY0€L$%|;‰+'t*+ŸG)wc#x@L6gh.;\+(vB+O/wd3l"m#G±"®+a7>"#stu

G;2.z.I*"3I#"a4_6F—Q%GC>(H*+-./0(ˆL`4p#\(œd3vG3[2*()Atwg?Y;c*+_oF"eg(v20 É"r>g€@@C0"M«",¥Z@*FG*`/#d;\1+(C,P+6'"7,*+R\"Y,M+8

G@DIV\tÅ_pa*'«",U,Pf+t;+2*+G>"¦I*2%ZAg+oF‹A"L£b"CwG>()A6'"7,*+Gv'(7#†t*?L1"ŒM+{'o(b"mY*+5VQv"U*+ZA™vpa.>n>´0V`ŒA6'"7,*+_

 

Page 42: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 42/248

%! "#$% &'(%)*+,-.%

 

Page 43: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 43/248

 

!"#$%&' )*    ,

 

Page 44: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 44/248

!! "#$%&'()%*+,'-.)% /012

 

Page 45: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 45/248

 3456 7'829/4:%;< /4:%;)%=>;?'@% >'-)3 A !"

 

-./0 1#2"

).3'45 ).3'4&'#

 

647#8' 6#$&- 9  

$%$&'($)*+,-./0123*-4$567)89:; <=3>[email protected]$CD-23*EFGH23I?J;B$CD-238*E2;>23KLME:A.NO;P23KQRS-($.LT7,UQR VWX$Y-:L@Z$E[23\@$.>Y]KLM(67^.3_T`aL23bc];7)8d$JKeU*EaSU7Ff23g@$123 V/hX

\(Q'1E2i$YT*E0EX3j:kl>J3;c^.$m.>G?1Y2bnEJKQ=o237,Up3>q?-r7MH@s4tuc]$.7q?  v wKQ\+-frx]D23Syz3b*U$ak{k8|2}KeU$.7q?  v wKQ

ZL[r\@x]D23Syz3>C>q?-rc]$.`CL?  ~ rBC6|2}x]D23KQ7-fXb•;SG+2;A.3_T8|@$H?23AMqrn€h23A]l>]$1%3]‚E?fXn€h23N_23

NSuQ$[h1.ƒ@g+-?r*+,-q@/0123dLF€+2c]*€EF(l>Ef.bA1„;8…„3KeU †^M23A.n€h23>CNSuQ63_Td$0%3b>[2>u;=ƒ+]‡fY23Ar_23KL.>G?1r`Ea3L%3*EhrS0?238\(Q6*+,-.

/01238lOSM?%3>q?-rO3>[.K;$-?237F€?1  v %3ˆ|2_);9qY23‰>€%36*EfE)dLF„3\E+]ˆc]Š$‹(ŒLY?.`:3;;A.7.3L-23*[+-?%3Š$E1@8*h-+23B$f;

 

Page 46: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 46/248

!# "#$%&'()%*+,'-.)% /012

8/h]D23c];*CD-23/@/h]D23bƒ@;KQiL+1236*h-+23‡M-r>r>-23A.7.3L-23*qm%3dLJ8Ž$Y23>[UhQ3_TiL+123*[rS&*rO$E-.R$HM?:‘-@74$1%36’+]‡fY238s]ƒ?u3A.B3†“”XS–236$E[rSUQI‹:L23—’EmE+^E@"#$%˜

{k‰Lu;—;QZ>]‰Lu;˜*E(3;>-23™>2=$1Y23B3;}\uL?23sYm%3—Sš†@; sM1fE@"#$&˜8{kB$-h?23*rtEEq?23ŠS‹2†Mf?23‰ VS0%37@$[.†Mf?23ŽLq+%3—†š>r$("#$&˜b

6;Z3L]p3*1q›3œ]8l†yp3'($)i$YTB$.B$[%3dLJ*+,-./0123 *1h?[%36*+žD'EFG;);EH'?  I.J%KL<% bƒ)'€hQ*+,-./01237^.$r†?M@KL2L[23*h1Y2$@’+-2‡fY23s]ƒ?u3b

ƒ)KQ*EŸQZ3>G?:3*+,-./0123c]$TO$h?]3SrO$h?y37[X$(”5A]$m?EŸQŽ$:”)sqET$f.•}ƒY2A.B$E+q-23*E]ƒ?u3*.$¡3b•}LqYUKL:‰O$H?rOŠ$h12+1?23>q?-rc]7]$f?23N_23LT6Ž$:p3*+,-  v .8/0:$mYM2;x-+  v X

lS.6*Y123B$(¢3L%$@;*E2$%3d;>+2*1U$Y?%3—KL:‰O$?HrO"#'(tEYr¢ £"#$'B$€fF23 8¤))(ˆ)&(˜bƒ)KQ*1U$Y%3*rO$M?J3AMqrKQ`h?X•}Lq(*+,-./0123—KL1+rL.$:

"#$)B$€fF23 8%()ˆ%(%˜b$.QBDMH.7q-23s]ƒ¥3¦S–2•$?(k†›3s]ƒ¥3l‰LuL%3;67)K$M.AMqEU$m+E+§*+,-  v q)/0:$,rQAM2;*)O$Hq@/h]S^)

—• bK‰O$T"#*+˜b7@I?J*,r$[  v %3B3Lp$@’X$m+EMHX$m?u_q(;c]$¨Q*+,-  v ./0:—t.3S@; SMr3O"#$)˜b6;*[E[„3Kk>r>-23A.•}ƒY23S^)p33OL‹XB$E+q-+2

*E:$E123*E]ƒ?u3;*r‰$F?C3;>CB_©3*+,-./0123$:$:Q$¡bƒ)KQi$YT$@‰Q$^2$“dLJ*+,-.8/0123¢;$0?r*+:p3*r?G%3*EhrS0?238*-&$[23;Qª$-238s[E[„3Z>G?1r;>@A]|2}*h-2l‰Sž7E+€?2Bƒ:‘-@

$r$,[23*E0EX3j:«38*E:$:p3IY-q)*E(D[-23—$fr3O; ŽL2"#$)˜8B3O$E›3;s?23 S“¬Xc]Ž$Y23ArSyz3—YE+E5"#$)˜8K;$-?23;s]L‹23ˆD@®3S)k—OL+r$X"#$'˜b=L12;8…„3$.A.>J3;A./@Œ;SU®_TB$E@‰p3*“D^23¯HMr†^M23dLJ

*EfE)x-2*h-+23c]L€(A1  ~ Jb†šKQB$E@‰p3*EhrS0?23Z>[Xl>]$1.8l†h)$¨p*EYh.7MH@Z$Xc]7E+§B3O$E›3s?23ZL[r$°KLh]D23Ar_23KL@ VS±*h-+23

Page 47: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 47/248

 3456 7'829/4:%;< /4:%;)%=>;?'@% >'-)3 A !$

*Eq:S23lSq+2{;p3bAM2;²$Y.A.KQ’mqEE[Xg4$C>23*E0EX3j:«3KLME:ƒEE[X3‰;>³bc];’šS23A.KQ`Ea3L%3*EhrS0?23>CI´§†^[email protected]$0?23A.

dDyŒLCL23s.LE23*+,-%8/0123kKQ$µO>Cc]O$)_?:3®_T*@S0?236*rQ*Ef+y*Eq:O>CKLMXl‰;>³b>[2'¶*:3O‰B3O$EyxGY23*r‰$F?C3*E:$E123;

*Uj€%36¯C3L%3*r‰$E?]36‘[email protected]$E@‰p3*E[Eh‹?23*+,-%8/0123AM2;

ƒ  V +CK$)K$T+2l>4$U8S)_  v X|2};*0E?(*]·+2*E‹h23$Eh1(’´-%BD]$f?23*E2$-23 8™L?1%3*@L-;lS‹E123c]R;S´23l†–?%3bAM2;B3O$E›3s?23’X$mfrS-X$m+E+§;®_°*[rS‹23*-q?žª¸+hX™L:3‰>]DE+Cb83†yQ;KeUB$E@‰p3l‰S0%37]$f?+2s0EX3j:«3l‰$]$.Ž vO>  ~ X743>@*+,-./0123lOSM?%3s?23'  ~ qq  v =$,[+2c]*+,-  v %3$m1f(]’r>[X‘-@B3†E–?2368*h-+23¹ƒ12$)‘-h@

B3O$E›3*+[?1%3—‰O3;$T"#''BOL@L@3O £"#$'˜8;Q¦SU*hrºc]O>–23—iL2LX; K$.>r$X"#$'iOD) £"#*(˜b

 7up;’+-X>rt%3A]*EfE)Z$E[23B3O$EG@*+]$U6*+,-./01238lOSM?%3•$?€({k  ~ ¨>r>ubxuL?E:;c]3_TmY23KQ>q?-rc]Ž$Y23Ar_23KLM+?qr

ƒmU3†h)Bƒ?JD2*E0EX3j:«3*+”?%36¯C3L.X$Y23NSfD23—,-,./01-.

234˜8LT;¯CL.gU3L?X\EU2$F./)O$H%37MH@8s4tu¦O$-?X;7MH@s4tu$,rQb>@A._yQ/?[E[J/?qm.dLJ¯C3L.X$Y23NSfD23/-@O$h?]3b

8{;p3KQ¹j[.7Ff23g@$123 V/@KQ$.LT7]$US“¬.;>q?-rc]»4$Fy*E0EX3j:k8$mYE-@7@>q?-r$,rQc]B$E0EX3j:«3™Syp3s?23x±$mE+]KQ

7]$f?X$m-.b$.Q*‹[Y238*E($^23`hY?UA.{;p37MH@¼$h.¤x±KQKLMX

*E0EX3j:«3*+]$f238lO‰$C>Y]*rQ*‹[(8'($)c]KQ_y”XK$h1„$@½rO$X7]$f?23 ƒ)OL‹XI?J|+X*´€+23bKkZ3>G?:3*h-2*E@L:$J*:3O>2B3O$E›3*+]$f236*+,-./0123lOSM?%3

s  V h+X®_TB$u$„3bsfU*2L‹h238*E(;jM2«3ZL[r7)iO$H.*@$?M@.$(S@>1±l>]$C}$©O$EyK;$-?.;Q†šK;$-?.67)*+[(b`?q?r;3_T.$(23SUL?@½rO$X

Page 48: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 48/248

!% "#$%&'()%*+,'-.)% /012

*h-+23I?J|+X8*´€+23AMqr;\2Z3>G?:33_T½rO$?23>Y]Z$E[23O$E?y$@b3}kK$)KL)O$H%3>C’X’TO$E?y3A./@=¬TAr_23KLUS-r*+,-.8/0123AMqEUArO$h?q+2KQ3;>)”?rA.KQ’µ>]$C6O$E?y3\u3L?:>]3LCArO$h?%3/-+‹%3ArSyz3bƒ)KQ7^.3_T=$[?(3²$G5¾2/)O$H%3Aq,E:KQI´§*2$JAf236

*h-+237E^q?@>Eub

xh1@;s?hšO6*US-.$.8¿>€E: vBL] ~‰NS  V ´Y.$-2Q/Uj³sM23L+:Sr ’µ$)O$H.7^%®_T*2L‹h23*E(;jM2«39[Ub>C;À'  ~ q Á q  v c]7M5B$EfFXNO;>23*+1+1?%3s?23\u3Lr$mEUx]D23>J3L23`EÂ/h]D23ArSyz3—5-3,6 1-78,˜8

IY-q@KQ7)7y>.A.BDy>%3Kj[E:7M@7y>.Syàbƒ); v'Y+]Q6Ä;¼8*2L‹h23K$)7)Å7  ~ y>  v .$(j[.\.QL?@ @;.$( —s43LH-2359:;<=˜8LT;.$(S@

K;$-?rO>–r;lOLF@*E43LH]*E2ƒ?J$@;*r;$1?.bNL?§;7)*h-2c]s?4$.*+[(9h,2$@b!"#'($);*ULfF%3*E($Eh237M2*+[(sT|+Xs?23’X$mf;67Ff23d;p3b'($);Y¶)Ä$[(K;$-?+28d‰$h?%3*‹[(;l>J3;O>–+2d‰$h?%3b$.Q3}kO>š>JQ

/h]D23ƒYE@K;$-Xx]D238Syz37F€E1Ux]D23O‰$–23c]%Ä$[(ƒYE@7Fwx]D23K;$-?%3c]Sf*‹[(b

ª;’?rK$.SJNQ*+y>  v .A.*h-+23s]3>@¢;$Æ'CL23b6;8*[E[„3KeU*2L‹@B$EfFX VNO;>23*+1+1?%3—5-3,6 1-78,˜$m+.$M@>C’X$TO3SMX‡q›B3S.*E–@dLF„3c]/q^X;Q’EE[XS^)Q3O3S[?:3B$uO>27)•;¢A./h]D23bK$);7qž

‰>]BD[Y23LT"+(b(((8*+[(BL?J3c]+&(b(((O$E?y37FfY.bB=$u;`@Op3lœ]*)O$H.*.>[%3*2L‹h+2A.*1ÇB$ž*EUS-.*f+?È

sT¤’+]8‡fY23’+];‰$F?C3ZL+-23;*E:$E123B$Ea$rS23;’+];Œƒ?u3b/hr;g€+%3—Q˜’43LC=ƒ:”@Ar_233L.>C®_TBDy>%3B$mu;8’°$1?(3ƒ)/hrg€+%3*hXS%3*uO>23;s?23$m?[[J’µDy>.b

 —"˜ 3'.>G?:»Y23 6  v'f; ƒ); 8*h-+2 3†–?. L& *E($^23 *2L¥3b

Page 49: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 49/248

 3456 7'829/4:%;< /4:%;)%=>;?'@% >'-)3 A !&

A.;sJ3LY23ltEq?%3*h-+2sT$¨Q'($)q1XŽ$Y+2c]RD?y3’m];SU*EUS-%37]$f?2$@`.’m,-@‘-h23Aqa*–E*–2;/?)jH.b>C;†?y3’´-.

/)O$H%3A./@=¬TAr_233;œ(B$[.dLJ*rS´(*h-+237MH@8Z$];QdLJ*+,-./01237MH@²$yb

¢$U.$(S@>l>J3L23l>J3L@?N_23Z>[X\@OL1U;23dLX$(QBOL@L@3OA.

*-.$uL?(OLX*2L‹h2$@bK$);3_T.$(23LT91@p3A./@`EÂ.323*.>[?%36 8\XSMUAM2; V/hX\(Q7,Up3A.$mYE@$-EÂ@

Q>hr.$(S@>l>J3L23l>J3L@?8`h‹[email protected]$E?y38K;$-?.A.;’“7-fr$.\+-frx]D23Syz36*+[Y23*[@$123bKkl>]$CO$E?y3—;Q*E0EX3j:«3˜®_TsT`:;p33O$H?(3SU;p3;$´JB$HC$Y%$@6*:O$É*h-2*+,-./0123bƒ)$¨Q.$(S@7m:

’mf237m:;*ž23bƒ)RS-  v r$mY]$¨Qs[?1X*uO‰l>EuA.K;$-?23$.>Y]Ž ~O$  v ¶`.œh23—x.$M:;3"#$"KL1+r; LE+@‰ £"#$"˜b$.Q7y>q)iO$H.6*2L‹@8*E(;jM2kKeU

3_T.$(23`?q?r»4$FG@*h  V h  v ³sT;\(Q‡E2D@$C3>u8dD–?:D2\(Q;7q-rc]L€(>Eu`.\.QLX;Q\fr‰Ob†š\(QÊ$-rA.*‹[(*Eh+:8l>J3;sT;\(Q’rS)3>u`.

.$(23s43LH-2359:;<=8sT;*f*U;S-.\Y]™>2 %3 H /)O$ `.t%3’¡$y‰k6l3O$h%3b

*U$a«$@{k8|2}RS-  v rA].$(S@>l>J3L23l>J3L@!\(Q‡U$Y?.NLCbsfU*2L‹h238*r>Emq?23 ~¢ ~SJQ.$(S@"l>J3L23l>J3L@!*hXS%38*E($^23$.Q6™>JkB$]SfX*2L‹h238*r>Emq?23>[U ~¢ ~SJQ.$(S@"l>J3L23l>J3L@!*hXS%3{;p3b'($)`E®_Tg4$[„3*U;S-.™>2’´-.Ž$Y23Ar_233Lqq.323*2L‹h2*+,-./0123

8*E(;jM2«3Kp$G1  v (A.¯;*2L‹h23*r>Emq?23'($)>C'+:OQ’mE2kbª;AMr A.†^%33S–?:D2KQ’mq´-.>CZ>G?:3Q>h.>l>J3L23l>J3L@?d;$J;=3Suk‘-@B$YE1€?23\E+]b

$.Q*[E[„3*–.3>23smUZ>]A  V M  ~ ~ ¶.323S^)p33>E[-Xs?23'. V>C*)O$Hq+2A.’r>[X=3‰Q™L?1q@=3‰Q.$(S@"l>J3L23l>J3L@!9E1h237Ep3;b

Page 50: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 50/248

"' "#$%&'()%*+,'-.)% /012

‘C$Y?X®_T*0E?Y23`.BL‹@8(S‹H23nEJKLMX*u$„3{k>E[-?23*€+.7MH@a3;bc-U7Eh:8d$^%36*2L‹@(S‹H23*E(;jM23*E%$-238*E($^23=$u

.$(237Cp33>E[-X*hXS%$@l†yp3—t–YYEu"#$*˜8nEJ\.>CK$TLuŽLuA.>m-.‚E:LYE±Ã sY[?23A.ËOLr¢8*r·rL123N_23;Z V>C*)O$H.$,rQ6*[@$1.*h-2

*+,-./0123*E(;jM23b'($);\?)O$H.6*[@$1.*+,-./0123lO$h]A]

SrL§9E1@Q>h%>

l>J3L23l>J3L@?

bAM2;®SrL§83_T\(”5K”58ArSyz3’m:Q6 7E+[X™L?1.=3‰Ql>]$C}$©3O3S[23bSmÌQ7E+§4$?Y23\(Qd$0%36S-%38¯2¬q+2;W  v C.$(23®¢$±k;ˆ;

M);NˆArO‰$[@c]†1fX¹$0Y23sh1Y23l>]$[+2—NQl>]$C}$©3O3S[23b˜AqUN_23`E‹?1rÍ <3}k

7EhC*@$u«3A]3_T8d3¬123|2$YT*´JD.>@$mY.dLJ†1fXB$uO>23*EqCS23bsfUÅ*h-2Å*f2¬.A.+((8*+[(KLME:O$E-%3>Ef%3=3‰¾2>E¥3LT'((8*‹[(

sT;*r;$1.*uO>+2s?23$T¢Swx]D23$.>Y]KLMrK$h]D23/(;$-?.`.ƒm,-@ c]Z3;>23b$.QO$E-%3`U$Y236*2$J=3‰p3¯E-,233>uLmU+((8*‹[(sT;*r;$1.*uO>+2s?237Fw$mE+]x]D23$.>Y]K;$-?rK$US‹23`.ƒm,-@3>@Qb•O>?X;

’´-.B$uO>23/@+((;'((8*‹[(c]’šS23A.KQB$uO>23$./@SfF23;"(((

*‹[(*YMÉ$,rQb$.Q.$(238t4$f23LT;.$(S@"l>J3L23l>J3L@!>[U70:9:L?.%(&6*h-+23l>J3L23b

A.;†^%38*HT>+2KQ|2$YT Î*f  Á l>J3;t  V E¶B$) ~O$H  v %3s?23'+0:B$uO>23*E2$-23$Eh1(A]B$)O$H%3B3}B$uO>23*&3L238$Eh1(QsT;*E$yOPQ)%8

s?23;dL[X¤AMXd;QA.O>–r— bA.;7uQ7E+§®_T8l3O$h%3KLME:¯rS-Xl>]$C ¯‹+23$(S.3>u7qHE2>]3L[23s?23KL  v MXd;QA.O>–r7hCBD[Y23*+E+[238l†yp37[Y27hC*+[Y23’CO"##˜b

?-X`EÂB$) ~O$H  v %3*E(ƒ^23s?23B¢SJQxX3S%3*E(ƒ^23{;p3B$) ~O$H  v .*fE‹2b$.QB$)O$H%3™Syp3’+UAMX|2_)b7@KQi$YTlL0Ul†h)6B>-.B$uO>23

Page 51: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 51/248

 3456 7'829/4:%;< /4:%;)%=>;?'@% >'-)3 A "(

/@/)O$H%3/fE‹+23/@;ArSyz3b>[UI[+XKL)O$H%3KLfE‹+23B>-.Ä$[(/@&$+;%(&*‹[(68*2L‹h23ƒYE@ª¢Sw7,UQ/)O$H%3ArSyz3†š/fE‹+23™L:&("*‹[(9[Ub83_2KkZ>]$¨L)d;QA.8O>–rc]7Cp37EhC*r$¨8*h-+23sT*q123s?23'+FU.323S^)p3$J$0(A].3237Cp3$J$0(6®_T*2L‹h23¤*2L‹@

*+,-./0123*E(;jM23b

>[27FJ7)>J3;A..323*fE‹+23c]Ï3LJ'((*‹[(`.7)A..323 *-h1238*E[h?%3`.;®†´(;Q\.QLX$,rQb™t-r;|2}{k\(Q$.>Y]x-+rK$)O$H%3*h-+23 *r$¨ I?J; 8Syz3 `. $Ÿ>JQ K;$-X A. Ar>)”?. $(LMr 8ƒm,-@ `. K$fE‹+23b6;

Ar$h?23 A. †^M23 ·fX ª *h-+23 *r$¨ B$ME?MX 6 *rL($^23 B$]LY?23 Kk 8`C3L23B$uO>23 6bƒ@;KQ.323B3}>]3L[23*fE‹+23$m-Eª¢S§™L:7E+[23A.Ä$[Y23 

 Ð23'((8>Y]$mh-2`.$m,-@8‘-h23K$)=o23N_23t  V E.xEXj23sh1Y23/@.323*fE‹+23LT$µ$uO‰*(O$[.B$uO>2$@s?23$m?[[J.323†š*fE‹+23bK$);3_T

—†^M23˜$€a3;bAM2;$.ªAMr$€a3;LTKQxEXj23sh1Y23.3+2*E(ƒ^23{;p3K$)83‰>³{3;>J8†h)A.7hC/Y“39[UA..323*-h123™Syp3bK3_T;

K$ž$(23$ŸR'  S C   T UV;QW%ƒ¨pK3>E±7-U†^M238ƒm1f(pƒmYM2;K3‰>wxEXj23;Q71+1?23/@/1U$Y?%3743;p3b

 >q?]3.$(S@X2'UV;QW%S^)p3*EŸQc]Q>h."gE[§>„3ÑCp364$?Y23#N_23;>]QDQKLME23†1fX$%\+-frŽ$Y236?ÈO$Æ*+,-./0123—¸YE(;‰

"#$%˜b3_T;8.$(23Iq1%3—¸YE(;‰;-A,8,B˜8LT.$(S@`?É7MH@²$y>€@8\X3}g€?1r;*:3O>23\fL@$^.c]l>]$CO$E?y3*EYh%3c]lSMUl>[-.$.$¶b‡M-@;

’´-..3238™Syp3KeU\[‹Y.Ò$:p3‡E2‰SžŒLYXKL($[2.$(S@"l>J3L23 l>J3L@[email protected]]*2;$³*r>FC’mf2x]D238Syz3A.;’“Z$E[23O$E?y$@N_23Z V>[r*uO>237,Up3c]™>%3>E-h23‰ƒ?]$@c]|2}’mf23blSMf23;sT\(Q

3}kª;>hrx]D23Syz3$hE0?1.$%\+-fr¸YE(;‰;-A,8,B8\(eUˆNQ¸YE(;‰;-A,8,Bˆd;$€E:KQ'+frK;‰$[]7M@$.`E‹?1rA.dDyO>–23bA.*EJ$(

Page 52: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 52/248

") "#$%&'()%*+,'-.)% /012

8™SyQ3}k3>@x]D23Syz38$hE0?1.KeU¸YE(;‰K;$-?E:b7up;’M„3c]*@$0?:38Syz3ZL[r¸YE(;‰/qG?@*E($M.kK;$-Xx]D23Syz3>-@KQ8K;$-?rƒ)

_y”rK$h1„$@$,rQ*E($M.kKQK;$-?rx]D23Syz3>-@KQO>–rb7M2;8*+[(ZL[rnr>€?@B$YEq©/X$T/?E($M.«3’“O$?ÓO$E?y33N_2>rtE:\X3>4$]*+rL&>.p3

{k>„3ÑCp367̦3jU374$[23\(”@>C7  V M5x]D23Syz3;Q\š$7MH@

E€b$.Q3}k'($)™>2/?E($M.«3/?E&œ23 Î’EC8*°$H?.$mYEJ‰>w¸YE(;‰KQ O>–23KLME:8$r>ž$%$&K$)x]D23Syz3c]$.8;>hr7-fr=o238\1f(=3L:K;$-X¸YE(;‰ZQb87@$[%$@;3}k$.K$)x]D23Syz37Eqr{kK;$-?23>-@K;$-X

8¸YE(;‰AM2;‡E2>-@8®O>š <3}kx]D2$USyz3;>hr8$hE0?1.x1€E:;¸YE(;‰KQ7,UQ=Ô\+-fr`.x]D23xE0?1%3LTK;$-?23b6;7Ì‘-@R;S´238*YE-%3OS[E:¸YE(;‰KQ*E0EX3j:«37,Up3sT;$Y?23/@$.K;$-?23O>–23;b

>Y]*r3>@8*h-+23RS-r¸YE(;‰*qEC®_T3B$E2ƒ?J*&;œ%3™>2/h]D23ArSyz3b¦jfEUƒ¨QK$r;$1r(b%8\YM2;’E[r$(¢;3_¡/qG?23$.>Y]KLMX*.L+-%3>CB=$u=$Y“Q†:*h-+23b

Kk3_T.$(23>[-.7MH@Ž”@8\@AM2;®_EfYXÊ$-rA.”‹y>J3;9[Ub¦3jU$@;KQx]D23Syz3†š8;$0?.’?€?rc]¸YE(;‰KQO>–r6/?+[Y23/X†yp3b>[U™‰QK3_TK3O>–23K$E2;p3>r>-2$@A.*q´(p3™Syp3{k*hC$-.

8¸YE(;‰$É7-±=$E5p3dtYX{k™L?1.*r3>@=ÒbAM2;3_TLTxh123gEC>23=3O;7-uZ$´(¸YE(;‰0Yr$J$0(3†h)*fL@X2'UV;Q6b>[2$0?:37)A..$(S@

"l>J3L23l>J3L@!N_237J*hXS%$@8{;p3.$(S@;K$.>EXN¢;†HX;C8064D, D,6

EF8013//8N_23¢SJQ*hXS%38*E($^23*[rS‹@'+-u¸YE(;‰RS-r¯E)`CL?rKQO>–23 N>±8$-f(7@KQK;$-?23LTN_237-fr|2}b$.QS4$:.323*fE‹+23™Syp3>[UBOLT>X`.¸YE(;‰b

>[2'[[J.323*fE‹+233¢$0(33>Eu6*2L‹h23$¨p>C8'.$C{k;>J8†h)=3‰”@>Eu`.$m,-@8‘-h23$,rQ;Kpi$YT‰>]†h)$mY.sfMrZ$E[+2`US@d>-.

Page 53: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 53/248

 3456 7'829/4:%;< /4:%;)%=>;?'@% >'-)3 A "*

B$uO‰$m,-@‘-h237MH@NSTLub$%$&KQx]D23Syz3ª8O>–rKeU7).323*fE‹+23'($)l>)”?.A.O3Sq?:3K;$-?23I?J*r$¨*h-+23bAM2;3}$.¿>€E:L2K$)

i$YTÍO>š>[2'@$0?:3.323*f+?G%3xE2$:”@*f+?È8$.$¶>C;'($)’m?@$0?:3*qm.6>r>§’mJ$0(7MH@Z$]bKkZLmf..$1Xl>]$CO$E?y3LT>JQ’ET$f%3

*E1E4S23$YTb}kKQY6'LZ.$(23AMqrKQ¯Lr7MH@†šsq:Oc]\(Q7E.L€(

K;$-?236BD[Y23s?23`h?XO>šx]D23Syz3!"#

b A.;/@`EÂ.3238*fE‹+237  V 0:.$(237Cp3$³$1X*uO>237Cp36*2L‹h23bK$);|2}LT.$(S@K$.>rSUG5HI;=9:8LT;.$(S@†š.$1?.c]

ŠD&«3sYh.c]*[rS&Z$[?(3’43>23b†š\(Q‡E2d;QA.8O>–rAM2;$.KQQ>hrRS‹23Syz3O>–2$@L2;lS%8l>J3;ZL[rK$.>rSUO>–2$@_Y.|+X*´€+23I?J;*r$mY23bc];‡M-23A.8|2}K$).$(S@"l>J3L23l>J3L@?8@3S2368*[@$1%3

.$1?rc]™L?1.*+[Y238l>J3L23AM2;>-@|2}®>0(.$1?.$.$¶`.O>–23b>-@;*@L[]l>J3;8†šijrÕ$%3Õƒ+2I1Yr;S.p3b

A.;/@$h:p3*1E4S23s?23'+-u.323†š*fE‹+23gf©6gE[§4$?(l>Eu6*2L‹h23sTKQ’´-./(3LC.323*)O$H%3'($)†š*³$1?.bKLME:;A.

N>0%3$YTKQ>mH?1(d$^q@s€EaLXŽLq+.;bS´(36*2$J.$(S@—ŽLuJ<KK˜8LT;lO$h]A].$(S@ZL[rc]KL($C‘E–@»@j.ZL[rO>–@>J3;6*+fš

A.A.t23d;$w;KQL0Yr\?+-f@bKk.$(S@O$E?y33_TLTlO$h]A]7M5Syà.$(2"l>J3L23l>J3L@!bLmUO>–r>-@O>šx]D23Syz38l¼$h.7^..$(S@

"l>J3L23l>J3L@!8AM2;>@A.K;$-?23’43>23>-@K;$-XRS‹238Syz3®3S(O>–r

*h1Y@"(ÖA.K$EJp3s?23KLMr$mEUx]D23Syz3$(;$-?.b3_°;LmUd;$w»@j23 *Sf@dD–?:x]D23Syz3b

 —"˜ Kk®$.$HX; BOL@O;3O \.>G?:3 N_23 ¯rS-?23 A. `:;Q .$1?+2 ¯rS-?23 3_T—"#'%² 8¤$+ˆ

$)˜7f–%3 A. Aq^23 s[+X ×X s?23 *+[Y23 6 K;$-?23 *E2ƒ?J3 LT N_23—Kb˜

Page 54: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 54/248

"! "#$%&'()%*+,'-.)% /012

;>hr;.$(S@O$E?y33_T\h5QSrL€?@†–.$(2"l>J3L23l>J3L@!8AM2;®Ø3‰Q7MH@Z$]QL:Q8†^M@A.;†^%3Zƒ?TD2KQRS-(xh123gEC>23=3O;3_Tb/hr

d;>¥3’CO—"˜½rO$X7  V Ff.BD[Y+26*h-2/@—ŽLuJ<KK˜.$(S@;>l>J3L23l>J3L@!b6Ù‰[email protected];$-X7)A.8/h]D23AM2;>Y]*+[Y238*:‰$123O$?y3

—ŽLuJ<KK˜l>J3;A.\X3O>š*+q?€%3b6;*+[Y238*E2$?23O‰$@—ŽLuJ<KK˜

8K;$-?2$@AM2;.$(S@>l>J3L23l>J3L@?O>š®_TlS%3*@$0?:3O>–+2g@$123N_23Z$C \@d;p3bƒUK$)\Y.ÚNQŽLuJ<KKÛkKQO>š*@$0?:3O>–2"l>J3L23l>J3L@?b8Ï$?2$@;g+yO>–23>EJL23N_23Z$C\@—ŽLuJ<KK˜6*+[Y23*:‰$123[4U\,3

%]^3_ <$@$T} <$@$rk;/@.$(S@—ŽLuJ<KK˜;"l>J3L23l>J3L@!b>C;’0(A]3_TS“p3 ÎO>šA.x($u—ŽLuJ<KK˜6`EÂBD[Y23B3}Z$COp38*Eu;t23ƒ)xh1X

6O>š"l>J3L23l>J3L@!6`EÂBD[Y23*E2$?23B3}Z$COp3*r‰Sf23b

 `ab D,4$%(

 c6'2]< d< eFfFg;Z e5-)!

/4:%;< /4:%;)%"

c6'2]<,!

h;G"

+)+)+ )+)+) +)+)+ """"" .+("   BD[Y23

&&&&& &&&&& &&&&& )+) +"&(.   BD[Y23

&&&&& &&&&& &&&&& &&&&& &"'(.   BD[Y23

&&&&& &&&&& &&&&& &&&&& '"*(.   BD[Y23

&&&&& &&&&& &&&&& &&&&& *" "((.   BD[Y23

&&&&& &&&&& &&&&& &&&&& "(" "+(.   BD[Y23

&&&&& &&&&& &&&&& &&&&& "+" L "&(   BD[Y23&&&&& &&&&& &&&&& &&&&& "&". "'(   BD[Y23

&&&&& &&&&& &&&&& &&&&& "'". "*(   BD[Y23

&&&&& &&&&& &&&&& &&&&& "*". +((   BD[Y23

*h-+23 ®_T 6 B$uO>23¤.$(S@"l>J3L@ l>J3L23!¤+)'ŽLu .$(S@; 8¤+&"b

Page 55: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 55/248

 3456 7'829/4:%;< /4:%;)%=>;?'@% >'-)3 A ""

7ij'fQPk6lE1)%*

"MK$US‹23 K;$-X+M.$(S@ K;$-X>l>J3L@ l>J3L23?9[U)M9[U ŽLu .$(S@ K;$-X&M>J3 K;$-?r ªb

6;*+[Y23*1.$›38Arœ-23;O$?y3ŽLul>J3;A.\X3O>š*+q?€%3b`h‹2$@;8KeU.$(S@"l>J3L23l>J3L@!>CO>šLT8Syz36*+[Y23*E2$?23Q>@;Ž$M-(3™>F2Syàb3_T;™>F237-uŽLuO>–r6BD[Y23B3}Z$COp3*r‰Sf23b>C;'hh1X®_T

8=3>p38*-q?žZ$E[@D)/h]D23O>–2$@67)*+[(>-@*+[Y23*1.$›3Arœ-23;bƒ)KQ3_T9›3Sq?1%3A.O>–23d‰$h?%3sY-rƒ¨QªDFwc]S^)QA.*‹[(l>J3;67)8*2LuI?J;=$m?(3*h-+23b'($);Ä$[Y23*E4$mY23®_¡*h-+23sT+)'.$(2

>l>J3L23l>J3L@?;+&"ŽL¥b…J\(QƒYE@g[JŽLu$&$[(c]Q7E+[@A..$(S@>

l>J3L23l>J3L@?

8>0(KQ=3‰Q/Y“3K$)$fE-ab!"#

  '($)*+MH%3*h)S.A.O>–23Üu$f%3ŽL¥>-@KQK;$-XRS‹238Syz3$(j[.»[Y@†FC>.p36.$1?23A.7hC/US‹23bl-23;KQ7)>J3;A./US‹23

L2K$)>C’[?(3*[rS‹2$@s?23$m-hX3ŽLu;"l>J3L23l>J3L@!8‡E+UA.N>0%3KQhFr=S%3$-Huƒ+^.K$)ŽLub

A.;Ž;O>23*1E4S23s?23$m.>[X®_T*2L‹h23*E(;jM2«3sT*EŸQ7E+[XB3†“”X=3>p3—INF- 0OO0NP2˜6*[email protected][23*2‰$h?%3bnEJAMqr*)S„O>š

l>J3;KQQ>hX*[email protected]$.$µ3B$.$µ3;8l‰$,%3*0E?Y23;sTB$($-  v .D Á

 ) /US‹23bsM2;ZL[rNQ7E+§>[-.$1€@®_T8B3†“”?23>@\2A.KQxT_r{kgq]*“D“B$rL?1.b™L?1%3d;p3A.7E+€?23LT†“”?23¼$h%3O$E?yD2b3_T;=Ô

 —"˜ 6B$rO$h%3‡q›3s?23BSu8ƒmYE@K$)d>-.Ä$[Y23s?23’X$m+E01XLT++%*h1Y2$@

.$(2>l>J3L23l>J3L@?;+)(*h1Y2$@ Ð2"ŽLu?b

Page 56: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 56/248

"# "#$%&'()%*+,'-.)% /012

87m:$%$&KQO>–23x1ME:S^)QA.K;$-?23b$.Q™L?1%3Ê$^23g+-?EUB3†“”?2$@†š8l¼$h%3Ar_yà/-@O$h?]3KQRS‹23Syz3>C8xC$-  v r>C;8xC$-  v rc]O>–23b

>[2s[23_TO>[23A.7E+€?23$hEJSX$YEq^X;A.7hC/)O$H%3D@|5b†šKQ™L?1%3n2$^237šLr6\[q-X_y”r;6K$h1„3*[E[J\(Q>Y]3*@$0?:B3O>–2RS‹238Syz3AMqr=Sq+2KQ8>E-rƒ@O;’  V G,  v rO$E›3ÏD–?:3b3_2KeUO>–23

>J3L23AMqrKQKLMr$€u$(ƒYEJ’?r7E+§\X3†“”X8l¼$h%37@I?J\X3†“”X*rL($^23 AMqrKQ_y¬X/-@O$h?]3bAM2;¯E2$M?23*E[E[„3AMqrKQKLMX6B3†“”X*uO>23*^2$^23$.>Y]dL€?XB3O>š=S%3*CSf?%3{kB$E+q]*+3L?.A.B$.$µ3*2‰$h?%3bsm?Yr;R$‹%3>r>-2$@A.®_T*q´(p3;Q8.323>-@$maS-X8¢3tf?:D2{k*hC$-.8$m1f(K;‰KQiO>X|2}bZ$E[@;x]D23Syz3*E2Ý@7Eu”X*@L[-23]‰>]

7E+CA.8BD[Y23KeU®_T*EJ$Y23A.*hC$-.B3_23ª`h  Þ ?  v XA.7hC>r>-23A./(3LC}$©3O3S[23b

c]’šS23A.KQNQA.B;$€%36/(3LC}$©3O3S[23l>[-%37MH@;QSyÝ@ªAMX <$YE1§.$(2>l>J3L23l>J3L@?8k\(QA.*2Lm123K$Mq@KQ>0(>r>-23A.

.323s?23AMqr$¡KQN‰¬X <=3‰Q7,UQA..$(S@>l>J3L23l>J3L@?69E³*2L‹h23b>@‰LuL2®_T/(3L[23KQKLMr3Sr_§>a‰$[?]3s€‹123K”@Q>h.

/-23/-2$@LTlO;P2$@*E0EX3j:«3c^%3b|2$YTc]7Cp3*“D“.3S@AMqrKQ@SX*[@$1%3L2KQ3>JQK$)>C$m. V>C*)O$Hq+2b

K$)AMq  v r.$(+2*Y  V E-23N_23’X\2$:OkArO$h?  v q+2/+q?€%3sM2 V/hr’¡¯E)AMqr’r>[X8*)O$H.K$)AMqrKQ@Sr*[@$1%3L2KQ3>JQ$.>C v\  ~ [  ~ UOQ v® ~O ÞLJ;@

AM2;¯:¾2ª v\+:S  v r>JQbZL[r;.$(S@*YE-233_TO>–2$@9[UƒYEJO>–rx]D23 Syz36/?+[Y23/?[@$123b$¨k*G1(S^)Q <$³$1XA..$(S@"l>J3L23l>J3L@!A.nEJ$¨QxC$-Xc]B3O>–23*C VSf?  v %3bKk=3‰p3`43S23KL($[2"l>J3L23/?Y“$@CHC

G<5 CQ< C9CK?>)¬rc]KQ”‹›3`4$H23/@/[@$1?%3LT’¨Q3L($)KL-CL?rKQx:$M%3AMqrKQg[€?XA.dDy’¨L)7CQ$³$1X$Eh1(A."l>J3L23l>J3L@!8

Page 57: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 57/248

 3456 7'829/4:%;< /4:%;)%=>;?'@% >'-)3 A "$

AM2;68`C3L23'($)i$YTx:$M.l†h)AMqr$m[E[§A.dDy’¨L)S^)Q$³$1XbKk/.$,.3_T•$?Y?:3*+T_.8$[J$%$&'($)¹j[XKQI?J=3yB$E0EX3j:«3ª3LY1w’EE[X.$1?23\?EŸQ;b

A.;.323™Syp3s?23K$)$m-:L@¢Lf23*2L‹h2$@sT|+Xs?23'($)lSUL?.’´-%/[@$1?%3bK$);3_T.$(23LTN_23¢$U6*2L‹h238*E2;p3N_23;

Z>G?:3SrS[X\Y]67E01X/[@$1?%3’TO$E?y3;bK$)3_T8.$(23N_23;g+‹r \E+]’:3>S´(Q|.$.QR<<S 9TI9; ?8>C ~’ Á m+  v ?:3A.B$EY[X*.>G?1.6.3S@=$)_23s]$Y‹3x-+2(S‹H23bA.;`?q%3KQB$EY[X=$)_23s]$Y‹3AMqr$¡

KQ’m+  v X$ž$(S@K$)6`C3L237,UQA.`EÂ.323s?23$mqq;S  V ´Y.$-2p3*+,-%/01237MH@²$yb

$.Q.$(23n2$^23N_23K$)AMqrKQ¢Lfr*[@$1%$@LmUlO$h]A]SrL§¯Ef&.$(2>¸Y(;‰?bL+UK$).$(S@>¸Y(;‰?>CQ>@B$a3jU$@*E2;QK”@/h]D23ArSyz3

KL(LME:/hE0?1.S^)QA.’¨L)†š8/hE0?1.K$M2>C¢$ULT$,rQÅ

ŠO$f@†h)b K$)AMqr`($F2iL+%3KQKLMr$M+.bB$a3jU$U>¸Y(;‰?*E43>?@3A]/h]D23ArSyz3'($)*q4$H?.3>ub>C;/hXKQdØ$f?23A1€@’m?@$0?:3ªAMrS^)Q*C‰A.ZØ$H?238x1€U7@K$)AMqrKQN‰¬r{k=3‰QS^)Q$J$0(bK$)AMqrdØ$f?+2KQ

N‰¬r{k*hXS%3{;p3>@A.l¼$-23b!"# >[2B¢t]4$?(®_T.323*E+EqM?23 <lSMU— <*qE“˜ <*EX”?.A.7E+§BDy>.

*[@$1%3;QB$)O$H%3$m1f(¤>[U'($)®_TBDy>%3*E1U$YX3>uA.7uQ$m„$F.*$›3b8;Q>[2Z$C>r>-23$mY.O>–2$@SMh%36*h-+23K;‰NQ¦S-X8¢3tf?:D2

sT;*q:*f+M.3>uc]™>%3>E-h23b8$E($“K$)O3>[%3Ï$^%3.$1?+2)Q$Eh1($É 

—"˜ 6*Eh23*‹E€%3.32$@*1q›3œ]*)O$H%368*2L‹h23K$)d>-..$(S@>¸YE(;‰[Y%3?

LT%&+*‹[(bAMqr;\?(O$[.`..$(S@>l>J3L23l>J3L@?N_23¢$U Ð@%(&*‹[(b¢SJQ.$(S@>l>J3L23l>J3L@? %)+*‹[(6‡f(8*Eh23ƒYE@¢$J.$(S@>S´(Q|.$.Q?c]%+(

*‹[(b

Page 58: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 58/248

"% "#$%&'()%*+,'-.)% /012

BSmÌQ*rQ*)O$H.A.B$)O$H%3—ƒ@O=$Y^?:$@"¸Y(;‰!b˜8$^2$“s[@7y>  v %3S^)p3$UD?y3A]BDy>%3™Syp38$-EÂLT;.$(S@"¸Y(;‰!89hG?r6\.Ø$HXN_23K$)

6†š\+³ƒEUg+-?r*@$0?:$@*E2;p3A.7hCArSyz3b¼¬r;7E+§4$?(*2L‹h23*E(;jM2«3KQi$YT†^M23\q+-?Y2dLJ¯EM?236

*[email protected][23*2‰$h?%3bI?J=3yB$E0EX3j:3A.ZL+-238*E:$E123’+];8Œƒ?u3

ZL+];8‰$F?C3’+];8‡fY23B$Ea$rS23;3L-C;6=$‹yQ*q  V ´Y.A.dDy’m&3SUk 6‡U$Y?23A.7uQ’m„$F.8*EX3_23Z>];’m³$1Xƒ@\EU8*r$fM23’¨L);/q4$H?.3>uƒEU»Ó*@$0?:3RS‹23Syz3b

>q?-X*E+]$U*E0EX3j:k*YE-.c]$µƒ:*$›389[U7@>q?-X$,rQc]*-Eh&B$E0EX3j:3™Syp3s?23xuL?r$mE+]KQ7]$f?X$m-.b3_¡;8xh123KeU

*q:$J; *[EC‰ '1E2 *2L‹h+2 l>J3; *2Lu 4$?(b*2L‹h23 A. *E($“ *2Lu 'rSuQ 8|2_2b$.Q4$?(*2L¥3*E($^23smUSULX$1:Q7,UQA.nEJ$TSTLu7up7.”?236

gq]*-Eh&O$E?y3S“¬%36*+,-./0123bxh123;6|2}LTKQ/)O$H%36 *2L¥3*E($^23$-EÂ>C3L  V [+X7E+€?237Ff%34$?Y2*2L¥3{;p38\+.$M@ƒ@6|2}*HC$Y./(3L[+2*E+EqM?23s?23K$)$mYMqrKQZL[X7q-@>Eu69E³*2L¥3{;p3b3_2

3L($)/)O>.‡E29[U4$?Y2*2L¥38{;p37@’ET$fq+2s?23À'  ~ . Á>G  v ?:37E+€?28¹$0Y23S&$G%3;*E0EX3j:«3s?23’X$mU$H?)3b*U$ak{k8|2}KeU7)>J3;’mY.

RS]KQArSyz3>C3LUS]$,rQ`E®_T=$E5p3b8|2_2KeU*2L¥3*E($^23>C8BQ>@ƒ)LT8¦jf.™L?1q@A.>E[-?23c]Q†^M@A.*2L¥38{;p33_2KeU$m04$?(K$)

AMqr`CL?23K”@KLMXS^)Q*-fY.*qEC;$mfL@3>5S.O$E?yD27]$f236*+,-.

/0123bƒ)KQ*2L¥3*E($^23'($)$,rQ3OL‹X$E.3O‰$ÌL€+.c]*2L¥3{;p3A.nEJ

’0„3×M23*2L‹h+2b}k'($)*@$0?:3)Q†^M@$ÉK$)$-CL?.bK$)i$YT$.  v\]LqžK$?Y“3KL?:;*)O$H.A.*?:K3>+@b>C;’X7E01X/1U$Y?%3A.dDy

B$(D]k6¯€F23s.>G?1%ltmuQL:$„3*EFGH23l†–F23bƒ)'¶lL]‰

Page 59: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 59/248

 3456 7'829/4:%;< /4:%;)%=>;?'@% >'-)3 A "&

NS  V ´Y.*h-+23Ar_233L)O$56*2L¥3{;p3A.8*2L‹h233L2;$€E2lS.*E($“b•  VO>X;KL1U$Y?%3A.l3LTltmupL:$„3Sq-@œ]/Y:{kl_X$:QZL+-28B$h:$„38=$rtEf23;’+];8‡fY238B$Ea$rS23;’+]8Œƒ?u3ZL+-23;8*E:$E123’+];=$EJp3s4$[XO3b$.QK3>+h23*+^  ~ q  v %36*2L‹h23smUB$rL238l>€?%383>Y);$E($‹rS@;8Iq´-238r;SY23;83·rL:;l>Y2¢LE(;b

>[2'.>C*2L¥3*E($^23*SUO$h?y*€O$MUp3*1E4S23—BƒE^23˜s?23’X $TSrL‹X67E+§*2L¥38{;p3g[€?23;8$mY.SrL‹?2;’ET$f.l>r>u†1f?2B$J$0Y238B$C$fy«3;c]>J=3L:bƒ)KQ/)O$H%3>C3LF+G?:3Ž;O>23-23;

A.*@SÆ*2L¥3{;p3bAM2;RD?y3²$G5p3™‰Q{k=$[?:3Ž;O‰*f+?ÈbAM2;$.K$) <$€a3;6*2L¥3*E($^23LT*[rS&7]$fXBDy>%3*EYh%3c]Ž;O‰*f+?Èb

K$).$(S@>l>J3L23l>J3L@[email protected]?23'. V>  v C6*2L¥38{;p3>C;¢$U*2L¥$@{;p3bƒ)'($)91@Q*)O$H.’X$mqr>[X6*2L¥38*E($^23>C;¢$U

*2L¥$@*E($^23$,rQbc];’šS23A.KQ`EÂ/)O$H%36*2L¥3*E($^233LUS]KQ.$(S@"l>J3L23l>J3L@!>C¢$U*2L¥$@8{;p3$.K$)>JQ’mY.3O‰$Cc]’EqFX7y>.;Q

*)O$H.']$‹?:3KQZ>[X™L?1.7,UQb

'($)l>]$C}$©3O3S[23®_T*U;S-.™>2`EÂ/)O$H%36*2L¥3*E($^23’¨p$-EÂ3L[+X3SrS[XA]*2L¥38{;p3LT; V/@KQ.$(S@>l>J3L23l>J3L@?K$).$(23

S^)p3$J$0(>„Kz3bƒ)’¨Q>C3;ØSCß$[ Á Y23dLJ¯E)KQ3_T.$(23K$)$U;S-.\XO>[@c]gE[§*uO‰l>EuA.K;$-?23$.>Y]’?r\h-2`.8œh23¯E);\(Q

‡E27m:8dD–?:3¯E);\(QZ$C=3‰”@>Eu6l3O$h%38*r>Emq?23¯E);\(Q¢$U*2L¥$@{;p3bƒ)KQSrS[?23dLJ*2L¥3{;p3>Ca;Q$,rQ‘-@$h:Q\J$0(

—NQ¹$0(.$(S@>l>J3L23l>J3L@?˜83†H.7MH@²$y{k\?fltEq%36\(L)A2KLMrd;QA.O>–r"¯‹  v +23#8\+E.;L€(K;$-?23>-@KQO>–rx]D23Syz3

—".$1?23#=$Y^?:$@*@L[]l>J3;9[UAMqrKQZ>[  v r$mE+]˜b

Page 60: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 60/248

#' "#$%&'()%*+,'-.)% /012

c]’šS23A.KQKL($C*2L‹h23K$) <$€a3;LT;¹ƒ  ~ 1237M2Åg@$1?.’r>[?@NQ Å.3S@8K$)I?JKk;K$) <$f2¬.A.7hCÅ»G58SyàKeU3>JQªZ V>[  v r.$(S@>l>J3L23

l>J3L@?™L:»G5>J3;89[ULT;dLX$(3BOL@L@3ON_23\. V>C6lS%3{;p3b'rSu vQ*2L¥3*E($^23A.*2L‹h23‡fY@L+:p3N_23'rSuQ\@*2L¥38{;p3

=$Y^?:$@=$–2k‘-@B3†“”X*+JS%3*E4$mY23bƒ);'Y+]Q8>]3L[23KeUdL&$-2p3>C

8‰>§7MH@;8Õ3jU3 Ð@(b(()&'*SU=$m?(D2;QŠDš«3`.7)*+[(!"#

b3_T; ÜU$M.`aL2U A(b##'%&bƒ@;KQ3>JQªAMrRS-rI?.à”?:*+[Y238l†yp3KeUB3†“”X*+JS%3*E4$mY23*h-+2>C’X$mhYƹ$0Y@6*2L¥3*E($^23b

lS.8™SyQª9hXSX*rQ*q:A.Bƒ123*EFGH23/[@$1?q+27MH@†h)`.=3‰Q.323bl_X$:p$UKLE-.$¥3ª3L.L[r=3‰”@7,UQA.8ArSyz3;/EMrS.p3>C

3L+-U|2}bƒ)KQ=¬TAr_233Lh?)*–+@—K3SXLUG<5C9:˜>@A.*–2itr$@V9KHEª3L.L[r=3‰”@7,UQc]8ŠD&«3I?JKk;K$)Z3>G?:3K3SXLU G<5C9:

  Vd>rc]™L?1.)QA.>„3I(‰p3A.*US-%3ltmu”@L:$„3*EFGH23l†–F23b 6;g€+%3—Q˜8Sm´X=ƒ:Q/[@$1?%3x1€@xEXSX¹$0Y23N_23®;¢SJQ*U$ak{k‘-@B$.L+-%3’mY]A];’mž3S@b

A.nEJ8d>-%3ª’[X.323l†F[23=3‰”@7,UQA..323*+rL‹237MH@8áL€+.c]’šS23A.O$F?(3.$(S@"l>J3L23l>J3L@!bAM2;A.*EJ$Y238™Syp3ª

’[X.323*+rL‹23—`.$T>E[-X†hM23˜=3‰”@7,UQA.=3‰Q.3238l†F[23$,rQb

 

—"˜ >[2’XO$E?y3®_T*E2ƒ?J36=$¨k*h-+23>Y]*rQ*+[(A.7uQKQKLMrd>-.dL&*h-+23LT+((*+[(b6;*:Oƒ%38*E+q-23I[?237)•;¢A./h]D23‡Ç8B3S.$.QdL&®_T

B$rO$h%3‡q›3>[U’X®>r>§lS.l>J3;9[UA.dDyx€:*YE]*E43LH]b$.Q*YE-23*E43LH-23l}Ly”%3A.`r¢L?23sYq,23>[UB‰>JKQKLMXB$rO$h%3‡q›37M2•;¢A./h]D23d3L&”@')8$$8"%"8"%'8;)(*BD[(b3_MT;>[U V/hXKQd>-.dL&*h-+23

WCQ$]L($.A.BD[Y23*-CL?%3¸2$h23$T‰>]"%"b

Page 61: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 61/248

 3456 7'829/4:%;< /4:%;)%=>;?'@% >'-)3 A #(

Kk>r>§$.·fr¹$0Y236*2L¥3*E($^23‡E23S.QDm:|2};‰LuL2)#'#

*[rS&AMqr$mEU*.QLX.323*“D^23/?123;—ƒ@$mEU.$(S@s43LH-2359:;<=˜c]7M5B$E4$Y“6B$EfFX VNO;>23*+1+1?%35-3,6 1-78,b>C;’X¹$,rk

*ULfF.B$uO‰®_T*2L‹h23l†hM233>u6g€+%3—Q˜*U$a«$@{kB$.L+-.A]/)O$H%3’mž3S@;b7MH@;8Ï$Âk'($)i$YTS^)QA.KLE+.*+[(6*2L¥3*E($^23b

ƒ);LTd$„36*2L¥38{;p3KeU¯‹+23I[+E:l”U$M.bƒ)KQ|(L)d;QA. O>–r$h2$š$.K$)¯  V +Mr3†^)bS^)QA.¯F(BDy>%3*)O$H%3'($)¯F?X8¯‹+2$@3_2A.a3L23KQ’´-./[@$1?%3>C3L[+X*2$:O*2L¥3{;p3s?23>EfXK”@

‡E2A.N>0%3KQKLMXd;QA.8O>–r3L)O‰Q;$T3t–.b6;*2L¥38*E($^23K$)i$YTÄ$hXO3gE“;$,rQ/@™>.¯‹2.$(23™L?1.;

\43‰QbnEJ'($)`EÂ.323*1q›3œ]{;p3*fE‹2=$Y^?:$@>J3;9[U—>C;¢SJQ3_T.$(23*hXS%3*Y.$^23b˜$.Q.323*1q›3œ]8l†yp3$m-Eq0UªAMX

*fE‹2$.3>] <$ž$(S@ <3>J3;$,rQb$.QÏ$ÂkÄ$hXO3/@™>.¯‹2.$(23\?uO‰;6 *2L‹h23K$MU(b%*bKk*q123s?23tE  V ¶7MH@>Eu$./@.323*fE‹+23$m1f(sT™>.*]·23

*EC3>F%3;s?23xE0?1X.323$°B$r>€?+2s?23ZL[r$°x]D23Syz3bAMqr;KQIq1r.$(23"'F6'm.2%#KkZ$CO>–2$@OLU¿;>J*2$JO>š"†š`CL?.#A.7hC

RS‹23Syz3b$.Q$.\EY-( Ð@"†š`CL?%3#9h,2$@’+U‰>  v w7MH@gEC‰bc];7)8d$JKeU*‹[Y23sT\(Q$.ªtf  ~ ?1  ~ rx]D23Syz3*E0EX3j:«3$ma VSw;c]*@$0?:3

8*rOLUKeUx]D23Syz37F€E:c]l>4$UlOSM?.A.7^.®_T*E0EX3j:«3*(S%3b

6*2L¥3*E($^23A.8*2L‹h23K$)i$YT‰>]A..323s?23'.>G?:37MH@;>q-?.3‰>]A.B$JO>–23sM2™SX$.N_23AMqrKQ•S©\@b$.;K$)‰>wxEXSX

.323*fE‹+23;k{>J>E-@LT™>.$mYM¶A.¯EM?23`.=¬TAr>€?%3b$.QK$r>€?%3K3_+23$($)/qm.63_T‰>F23ƒmEq:”1U—»J$f23CIKCI5 ˜;—A  V M  ~ 1  v %3

C59:WXHRHYI5 b˜

Page 62: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 62/248

#) "#$%&'()%*+,'-.)% /012

Z>[X>Efr‰/?:‰Dš.$(@—»J$f23CIKCI5 ˜8>C;g[J*hXS%3*:‰$123/-@Op3;6*2L‹h23b>[2’q  v 3_T.$(23n€h+2A]=$f-,23;Q8/Ef&$-23\YM2;

>-?1.$€1(D23}k$.SmÌQx]D23Syz3\(Q†š7@$CdD–?:D2bKk3_T.$(23†šN‰$E?]3A.nEJ\(QO>–r6*+[Y23{;p3A.7uQKQ?Ól‰O7-Ux]D23

Syz3b3}eU$.O>šx]D238Syz3O_?-E:A.dDyK;$-?23x-+23;gU;Q>h.

l>J3L23l>J3L@$%I[hXA.*h-+23bƒEU3>]8|2}\(eUK;$-?r6/?+[Y23*E($^238*^2$^23; \YM2;O>–r6`EÂBD[Y23*[JD23b>[2Z$C—»J$f23CIKCI5 ˜7q-@>Eu6dD–?:3>r>-23A..323*E+EqM?23s?23K$)AMqr$¡KQZL[X=3‰”@>Eu69E³

*2L¥3{;p3A.l3O$h%3—L2'($)>C')j53$mEUb˜c];7Eh:8d$^%3KeU.$(S@"l>J3L23/?Y“$@? CHC G<C CQ< C9CKO>–rk>-@KQO>–rx]D23Syz36

/?+[Y23/?[@$123bAM2;—»J$f23CIKCI5 ˜O>–r/X VS%c]Ï3L?23b3_2KeU.$(S@"l>J3L23/?Y“$@? CHC G<C CQ< C9CKl‰$]$.K;$-?r`..$(S@—»J$f23

CIKCI5 ˜87–?1  v r;`H@QdD–?:3*0E?(\.SM2b…JKQ.$(S@—»J$f23CIKCI5 

˜ª’[r=3‰”@>Eu7MH@²$y6*2L‹h23bc];7)8d$J\(eUZ V>CB$uO‰ *&3;‘-h2A..323*(S%3*+m123;bd$^q);Syàc]*EfE)x  v h1X—»J$f23CIKCI5 ˜BDMHq@‘-h2.323

™Syp3s?23'.$C=3‰”@>Eu6*2L¥38{;p37  V .”XB$-rLY?23*“D^23Q>h%×1E2¸YE(;‰6gE[§*0E?Y23™LF[23b'($)i$YTK$?)O$H.K$?+FfY..$(2¸YE(;‰  ~ [  ~ Y  v %3

5IZHKI; ;<Q:H:[8sYh%3c].$(S@>¸YE(;‰?N_233>@ <3>]3; <3>u6*2L¥3{;p3b>C;$X=$uA.Ï$Y?:Rb7rL)×1E2;¸YE(;‰\1f(bƒ)B=$u*G1(lO VL³7MH@¯Ef&A.Åg@$1?.8$5¸+hrA.Sq-23>JQœ]$.$]I]>r;¯E?:K$.LE(b

c];7)8d$JKeU—»J$f23CIKCI5 ˜>C7–?:3`EÂ.3238*“D^23$%$&KQ’m-EÂ3Lh1JKQ7,UQ$.’mYMqr\+-U`..$(23N_23K;$-?rS^)QA.¯F('CL23>-@K;$-XNQ>J3;8’mY.LTKQ3;Sq?1r6K;$-?23b6;8`C3L23K$)’m-:L@

$-EÂKQ3L(LMr7,UQ$JL2’¨Q>C3L+-U$.\+-U.$(S@"l>J3L23l>J3L@!>r>-23;A..323™Syp3B3}xX3S%38*E2$-23NQO>–236*+[Y23*E($^23l¼$h.*@$0?:3O>–2

Page 63: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 63/248

 3456 7'829/4:%;< /4:%;)%=>;?'@% >'-)3 A #*

—»J$f23CIKCI5 ˜6*+[Y23{;p3bK$)AMqr3_¡7-f23KQŒt?Yr33O3_?]A.—»J$f23CIKCI5 ˜$ÉAMqrKQ7-±OL.p3†1Xc]$.Z3SrA.>-@|2}b

$.Q.$(S@—A  V M  ~ 1  v %3C59:WXHRHYI5 ˜LmU   V aLr*[rS&S^)Q <*C‰ <*]3S@;6dD–?:3>r>-23A.8.323LT;|2_@/hr <$r>§S^)Q*C‰bLmU6d;QS.p3I-1r{k

‡E:”XÅ*CD]Å*U$M.*E2‰$hX`.x]D238Syz3$mYEJ9[Ud;$wO_€@KQ™SrKkK$)

\($M.e@KQ@Sr$E5L0Yr;\1fY@bZ V>[X¸rS)¢O_EU.$(@—A  V M1%3C59:WXHRHYI5 ˜*[@$1q+2>C;=$u3_T.$(236*hXS%3*-@$123Arœ-23;6

*2L‹h23bƒ)KQ3_T.$(23 ÎK;$-?.68l‰$-23\YM2;>-?1.O>–+23}k$.O>šx]D23Syz37MH@OSM?.b3_2KeU3_T.$(237Eqr{kK;$-?2363s?Y“lœ]*+[(;Q`@Op3Arœ];*+[(8{;p33}kK$)x]D23Syz3$(;$-?.b$mYEJ9[UZL[r=$[2e@O>š

†št  ~ f  ~ ?1  v .bA.;dDyO$´?(3I?J’?rSrL‹X9q(A.K;$-?238d‰$h?%3d;$w3_T.$(23KQQ>âx]D23Syz3\Y  V M1  v r;7upKQKLMr$³$1?.`.B3O>–23*CSf?%3b

3}eUSq?:3x]D23Syz368K;$-?23$mYEJhF?:B3O>–23S^)Q <3O3SMXbAM2;$%$&K$)—A  V M1%3C59:WXHRHYI5 ˜ <$´U$³c]d>-.ÅB$]LU>.¸+hr+b+%*‹[(c]

7Cp36*)S„38l>J3L23\(eUA2O>–r/XS.c]8Ï3L?23;O>–rS^)pA.`@O'CL23×M23bƒ)\(Qd;$wKQxY0?r9–,23c]\´J3†^)b

Kk$.•$?w\E2k=S%3Z$E[+2=3‰”@>Eu6N>§.3S@sž$()—»J$f23CIKCI5 ˜;—A  V M1%3C59:WXHRHYI5 ˜LT‰3>-?:3Z$[?(D2>-@¿;>JO>š

"†š`CL?.#A.7hCRS‹23Syz3b3_2ƒ+^.KLMr¯‹+23$rtžKeUA.Nt0%3$,rQKQKLMX$E.$[?(3bKk.$(S@>l>J3L23l>J3L@?`q±/@/X$T/?q123/?hh€%3bLmU

8¯E‹28.$1?.;s.$[?(3;$,rQbƒ)\(QA2KLMrd;QA.O>–r£3>@Q.$1?r;`. O>–237FfY%3>-@*@$0?:3£l‰SfY.\YM2; vt  ~ f?1  v rƒ43‰O>–2$@ V‘–@S´Y23A]™>.A1J†:7]$f?23N_23¿>JI?J$mYEJb

>[2BS  V “QŽ;O‰*2L¥3{;p3A.*2L‹h23c]9E€%3sEh23*2L0+28*E($^23|2}; ÞKp/1U$Y?%33L($)c]’+]4$?Y2$@b?Y?:3;SrS[?23dLJ4$?(*2L¥3{;p3

Page 64: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 64/248

#! "#$%&'()%*+,'-.)% /012

A.*2L‹@*+,-./0123$-2pL:$„3—‰;S+E1)Q"#*(Q˜K”@A.Nt0%3‡E26KQKLMX$fE‹28x1€U7@$³$1?.;$,rQbƒ) ~RS  ~ ]/1U$Y?%36*2L¥3*E($^23K”@‘-@>]3LC}$©3O3S[23*³$1?%3.$(Ð)>l>J3L23/?Y“$@?.$(S@;>¸YE(;‰  V [Y%3!K$)AMqrKQZL[X=3‰”@7,UQA..$(S@"l>J3L23l>J3L@!69E³*2L¥3{;p3b

K$)>r>-23A.8/1U$Y?%36*2L¥38*E($^23KLYq?rKQ V7´X|+XB$u$?Y?:3

  <*+]$UB3};*+bAqU/@B$)O$H%3/?Y“38/?123;'q1X3`1XKL“D“;*)O$H. 8¯‹+2$@'($);$m+)$hrS[X*³$1?.$]L(8$.c]7CQSr>[Xb>[2’X’r>[X.$(S@>l>J3L238/?Y“[email protected]‰O$Yr$.LT;ª$]=$EJQ*E4$[XO3A.*M+q%3l>€?%3b

\YM2;=$u*hXS%$@*-@3S23Arœ-23;bƒ);8$Yf+:QKeU.$(S@"¸YE(;‰[Y%3!>CZ V>  v C/XS.b\YM2;6lS%3*E($^23K$)6¯FY23†yp3A.*2L‹h23b

;>hrKQ$.K$)>C¿>JLT Î7]$fX†^  v ./@Ž$Y23Ar_233L[?:3 <$:O‰ <$YE-.Ar_23;3L[?:3$:O‰SyàA.*2L¥3{;p3bK$MUŽO>23d;p3¤"A  v )$fE‹2$³$1?.;b#

$.QŽO>23Ê$^23K$MUS^)Q*E2D–?:3¤"KkK$)K;Syz3/fE‹28/³$1?.;KLME:A. N>0%3*2;$³’¡D–?:3l‰$f?:3;’mY.b#AM2;Ar_233Lh]L?:3ŽO>23d;p33L($]A.Ar_233Lh]L?:3ŽO>238Ê$^236*2L¥3*E($^23A.*2L‹h23bK$);$ž$(S@—»J$f23

CIKCI5 ˜;—A  V M1%3C59:WXHRHYI5 ˜8ArS“¬./+]$U;6dD–?:3.323s?23’1?X*(;S%$@l†hM23bAM2;Ar_233Lq+-XŽO>23Ê$^23ª3L.L[r=3‰”@>Euc]

ŠD&«3bxh123;LT\(Q>Y]’m?2;$³dD–?:3.323™Syp383†^)$.3L($)KL[+?r6SyàR$‹%3$@$[]$EU$)7-¥*h-+23$m?.S@7CQl”U$M.DM2/h]D23$ÉAMqrKQ

KLMr\E+]d$„367ÌK;$-?23d‰$h?%3»2$›3bc]7Eh:8d$^%3>[2¢SJQ.$(S@

—A  V M1%3C59:WXHRHYI5 ˜*hXS%3*-@$1238Arœ-23;ƒYE@¢SJQ.$(S@—»J$f23CIKCI5 ˜*hXS%3*:‰$123/-@Op3;bƒ)KQ7)>J3;ƒmY.Š$U*uO>23s?23$m[[J

.$(S@"l>J3L23l>J3L@!7C”@A.n+“.323bAM2;ª¢S§*rQ*)O$H.A.B$)O$H%38™Syp3s?23'2;$JgEh‹X•$?Y?:3ÏD–?:3ŽO>+28Ê$^23*hXS.

*hrSCA.*q[23b

Page 65: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 65/248

 3456 7'829/4:%;< /4:%;)%=>;?'@% >'-)3 A #"

ƒYE@;K$)Z3>G?:3ŽO>23Ê$^237EqrL€(d$‹@kdL-f.ŽO>238d;p3ª`‹?1rNQA./)O$H%3l‰$f?:3S^)QA.lO$1›3s?23sY  v .$°68*2L‹h23=3Su

’m?2;$³dD–?:>]3L[23*(S%3;Q*+T$1?%3b'($);B$)O$H%3S^)p3$J$0(7E¶KpKLMX‰SžB$-rLYXl†–$Eh1(.$(2>l>J3L23l>J3L@?>C;'qq  v sM2t  V E  v ¶

x€1Y  ~ X;`.x]D23a3L23.$(2"s43LH-23#> 59:;<=?8;QNQx]Syà

†šK;$-?.lS%$@bAM2;_EfYX®_TO$MUp3ª’[rN”@=3‰Q7,UQA.7MH23‘€%3 .$(2"l>J3L23l>J3L@!b3_2KeU"l>J3L23l>J3L@!8N_23’01(3`.8`Eq¥3>C¢$U*2L¥$@*E($^23A.*2L‹h23ƒ)¢$U*2L¥$@{;p3b

7mU'($)4$?(*2L¥3*E($^23KLM?2*f+?ÈL2K$)`r¢LXB$)O$H%3>C¯+?y37MH@ÍNSTLu;Q-Y2A]|2}L+:”@8Syà7TZL[?:l>]$C"l>J3L23l>J3L@!

=3‰”@7,UQ6ŒLYX`:;QA.B$Ef+›3Í*EEh238IY-q@7T$¨QeCF.6 Í8*Ea3jU3 BL‹h23 A. *+1+: =$Y@ 6 d3¬123 3_T »  V €f?2 l>E¥3 *[rS‹23 AqMX

NL?§7)l>J3;$mY.c]`r¢LX¯+?ÈŒ3L(p.323*)O$H%3b$.Q*[rS&=$Y@®_T BL‹h23*2 V>-  v %37MH@†h)smU Î*YEh.6g€+%3—Qb˜'($MU4$?Y23sT¢LU.$(S@>l>J3L23l>J3L@?*[email protected]$]LY?23*?1238*2L‹h+2ƒ)¢SJQ*hXS%3*E($^236lO;>23

*:‰$123b.$(S@ ¹$0( *($O; *($?. ™L?1% NLC O$h?y3 k 3_T $.;>l>J3L@ l>J3L23?b$.Q*[rS‹23™Syp3g[€?+2A.*($O4$?Y23smU=$H(k*+1+:*+.$)A.BL¥3*Ea3jU3*E+h[?1%3*2L‹h+2b‘[email protected]—;Q>]3LCO$E?y3˜'[fyQ

7MH@†h)nE€@ªAMrA.7q?€%3KQ’?r$mhrSÆ6BL‹h238*E+h[?1%36/JKQ‘-h23Syz3K$)$€u$(ƒ@\EU*r$fM23nE€@KQO3Sq?:3’TOL,J6BL‹h23

*[J VD23KLME:Dq?³b3_¡;8xh123KLME:A.>Ef%3KQ7+€($.¿>€E:c]™>.*+1+:A.BL‹h233}k$.'€hQ.323S^)p3$J$0( <=tu)QA.*Eh23*‹E€%3

7M28.$(S@$.Q.3237Cp38$J$0(DE+[U$.À'+@LCbKLME:3_T7E+€?233O$h?y3$rLC3>u™L?1%=3‰Q8.$(23Kp¹$0Y23’43>23x+‹?E: <$ž$(S@\-:L@Z$E[237q-@>Eu`..323*€u$Y23™Syp3b

Page 66: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 66/248

## "#$%&'()%*+,'-.)% /012

Z V>[r’+]=$EJ«3s4$[XO3*[rS&l>Ef.†Mf?+2®_°*+MH%3*EME.$Yr>23—¢Sfr3SX"#$"tYE);3‰ £"#$'B$€fF23 8¤"$#ˆ+(+¤nEq: ‰O$Yr$."#$*˜b7E©KQi$YT>r>-23A.

B$(3LE„3s?23sq?YX{k*+EFU8l>J3;sT;l‰$]$.7]$f?X`.$m,-@b¦jU3KQ®_TBD]$f?23_y”X7M5*+,-./0123b$.>Y]s[?+r8K$(3LEJƒmYMqrKQ$(;$-?r`.

$Ÿ>JQ8Syz3;QKQ8$(;$-?r;QKQ$Ÿ>JQAMqrKQ V7–?1rSyz3b¦jUQ$,rQKQ

7)K3LEJAMqrKQtEqr‰3SUp3Ar_23gh:KQ;7]$fX8’m-.\YMqr;$,rQKQS)_?r x(3L¥3l¢O$h23A.8’m+]$fXc]7Eh:d$^%37TK$)Syz3$(;$-?.6l‰$-23ZQb3_MT;KeU*2L¥36*2L‹h23AMqrKQ V>-  v Xl$)$³7E¥>J3;7^%®_T8B$(3LE„3`.*E($M.kZ3>G?:37)l>]$C}$©O3S[23A.7hC‰>]†h)A.‰3SUp3bA.;/.$,%3*h:$Y%33_¡†1f?23LTKQK3LE„3 V/-%3AMqrKQ7]$f?r`.K3LEJSyàZ3>G?:$@\X>]$C*$›368O$E?y3$.$¶7^.$.\-:L@KQZ>‹FrK3LE„$@Syz38\:jfr;

Z3>G?:$@l>]$CO$E?y3™SyQbKk*qEC3_T\@$H?23AqMX6\(Qq1rl$)$€q@d$Eup3*E+h[?1%3A.*2L‹@$.b

lSMf23;sTKQBDy>%3S^)p3$J$0(>0?:$SU)Q$mqr>[?26*2L¥38*.‰$[23$.QBDy>%37Cp3$J$0(KLM?1U$mEU Î²SU7CQ6’r>[?23lS.™SyQb7up;

8*C>23$YYMqrdL[23K”@‰>]½1Y23—;Q8=$Y@p3;Q*rO_23˜A.Å7y>  v ./-.x:$Y?E:`.*uO‰|2}7  ~ y>  v %36*2L‹h23b$YE+]KQ V·f(9:L?.@S23N_23®$[+?r‰Sf23c]\(Q

x:$Y?.`.‰>-23`CL?%3=$Y@p‰Sf23—;Q\?rO}b˜c]7Eh:8d$^%33}k$.7FJ.$(S@—;Ql>]$CO$E?y3˜c]*uO‰*E2$]6*2L¥3{;p3A.*2L‹h23d‰$-Xsf-a*uO>23

s?23$m[[w.$(S@8Syà <3}kKeU v\SU67E^q?236*2L¥3*.‰$[23KLM?:™L?1q@

/f-,23$,rQb!"#

83_2KeU.$(S@—s43LH-2359:;<=

˜8c]7Eh:8d$^%3KLME:

 —"˜ Kk7) $T¢Sw s?23 B$uO>23 d V>-. \EU KLMr *2L‹h23 A. $E($“ 3t  V f³ DEu g+© ®_T •$?(«3 *E+q]

d V>-%3 LT .$(S@h'mW%nEJ 8.323 A. .$(S@ 7) `. \4$[+@ $mE+] 7FJ s?23 *uO>+2™Syp3 .323 ¹$0( `. *h:$Y?. KLMX6d;p3 7E¥3b

Page 67: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 67/248

 3456 7'829/4:%;< /4:%;)%=>;?'@% >'-)3 A #$

7CQ*EŸQ67E¥38Ê$^23ƒYE@KLME:.$(S@"l>J3L23l>J3L@!®†š;A..323B3}B$uO>238*E2$-23 Î7^ÉDE^¶7,UQb

x1J;’ET$f%38*E($1(«3KeU.$(23N_23701r*uO‰*E2$]>CKLMr7CQƒ?J36OLm´2367h[?1%3>r>-+2A.$h:p3*f+?G%3b™>JkBƒ?J3sTKQ

x]D23 VS0E:B$E0EX3j:3*f+?ÈO;Sq@8'CL23A.;’“|1q?rs?2$@7q-Xc]

7q)Q\u;b$.Qdƒ?J3Syz3LmUKQ»GH23N_23Z>G?1r$ž$(S@™SrKQ B$E0EX3j:3™Syp3S^)Q$J$0(d VL€?EU{kl>J3;A.®_TB$E0EX3j:3bi$YT;dƒ?J3SyàK”@»GH23N_237–Hr3O;‰8 <$E:$:QL,-)6ŽS–(LM23;QSr>.

Œ;œ.8NO$Æ>C¦S-?r=$FCã23}k$./hXKQ*E0EX3j:«3s?23$m-hX3'1E2*€u$(3>ub83_28’+-?2$U8>E+[?23;O$E?y3;AMqrKQK;$-?X$-EÂ6K;¬H23

*E($1(«3A.7uQ•$?(k*E+q]A.$¨”5KQ7-ÆB$E0EX3j:3†š*€u$Y23$Eh1(7CQƒ?J36OLm´23ƒEU>-@b

Kkl$)$³®_T*E+q-23*2L‹h2*+,-./0123sT6`C3L23l$)$³*wä l¼$h.;b V/hX;*ULfF.*2L‹h23*uO>23s?237F§$mE+]7)*E0EX3j:k*(O$[%$@`.7)A.B$E0EX3j:3™Syp3b$.>Y-UQ>hX—*ULfF%3˜x1Y2$@s?237FJ$mE+]7)ŒL(67Eu8$.AqUNO;P23$1Jx1Y23s?23KLM?:l‰LuL.67E¥3Z‰$[239[U!"# bƒ+MUK$)=3‰Q*E0EX3j:«387,UQƒ+)‰3‰¢3Lq($m+E^¶b

'. V>C4$?Y23*FCl†^  v .bd;”U=Ô7FJLT`u3SXB$)O$H%3™>J«3lœ]s?23B¢SJQ”&;QxX3S%3{k¯F($mq0JÏ;p3™>27E¥3‡.$›3ƒYE@'($)

 

—"˜ >[2'¶®_Tl$)$€%3BL0+2*E+h[?1%3A.*2L‹h23$1€@9:L?.*qECÄ$[Y23s?23$T¢SJQ.$(S@/-.`.S4$:.3238™Syp3nEJKLMX’E[23*:$[%3sTZ$COQ.$(23

l‰LuL%367E¥3Ï$„3b$.QZ$COQ.$(S@$.67E¥3Z‰$[23>[U ~> Á [  v ?] vQ$¨”@*h:$Y?.`.$m0?Y.A.Z$COp367E¥3Ï$„3$m&$[(;67E¥3Ï$„3b{L?r;3_T=3Su«3$:$EC$E1E4O*ULfF%

B3>4$-23bLT;d$^%3>EJL2363_T$?M23N_23'E‹]Q\EUZ$COQB3>4$-233†1fX8$E:$:Q>@A.†1f?23NLf23‰S0%3b

Page 68: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 68/248

#% "#$%&'()%*+,'-.)% /012

B$)O$H%3B3}xX3S%3*‹:L?%37E¶{k*´U$€%3c]8$m-C3L.$.QB$)O$H%3s?236*q[23smU9[Us?23'E[@$m.$0JQLqYX=9h@bdL+€@;7E¥38‡.$›3'f?y3.323s?23'($)$mhX3S.6n+^23†yp3A.*2L‹h238$.$¶ƒYE@BQ>@xX3S%3I‹:L23

»+[?2$@8߃M(3;$.Q.323s?236n+^23c]p3>[UBSq?:36LqY23—S´(37MH23+b˜

 `ab lE1)%)

*b%]m)% n'o% d2%;a /'J'f  T W pqF5)% 7'8C)%

 

Page 69: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 69/248

 3456 7'829/4:%;< /4:%;)%=>;?'@% >'-)3 A #&

s)$   v §®_T*E+q-23Q>h.=$[h23™LC¾2bKk.$(23N_230Yr7MH@9:L?.`.`r¢L?23Ï$„3>]3L[+2c]/)O$H  v %3hFE: <=tu)QA.*Eh23*‹E€%3>]3L[2$@

™Syp367E¥3Z‰$[23b68*r3>h23œ?YXl>]$[23s?230YX`.`EÂŒ3L(Q8>]3L[23AM2;=$f?y$@>]3L[23*€u$Y23ƒEU8>-@KeU¹$0Y23RL:x+‹?r=3‰Q3>Eu`.>]3L[23

*€u$Y23™Syp3b

SULX®_Tl$)$€%3 <3OL´Y. <$EE@\(pª’?r’r>[X>]3LC*E)L+:l>r>ubsT; ¯+?©A]OL´Y%3s4$[XO3;QNOL‹?23N_23q1rBL€?2$@’r>[?2B$E0EX3j:3l>r>u6*Eh23b6OL´Y%38sEh23i$YT`r¢LX†–?.Œ3L(p*YE-.A.>]3L[23bhF?U

>]3L[237Cp3$J$0(7CQ8$]LE5ƒYE@œ?YX>]3L[23S^)p3$J$0(bKk`r¢L?23s4$FJ«3Œ3L(p‰3SUp3†–?r67)7EuA.8d$Eup33_T; V†–r*Eh23s?23xuL?r

c]7)ŒL(A.‰3SUp37.$-?23$m-.b>[2’X7E^¶.323l>E¥3.323;*fE-,23x1Y@*r;$1?.6*r3>h23bAM2;

O;Sq@8'CL23Q>hX.323*fE-,23`u3j2$@8N;$m?23;ƒYE@‚-?YX.323l>E¥3b ¹$0Y23>2Lr>rt%3A.8¹$0Y23ļKQ v>q  ~ ?1  v r¹$0Y23A.7]$fX.323*€u$Y23™Syp3bA.*EJ$Y238™Syp33}k$.I[?:3¹$0(l>]$C*YE-.A.$µO>Cc]dD–?:3>]3L[238™Syp38$mYEJ$.>Y]BL¶|+X>]3L[23s?23'aS-X8dD–?:D2hFX

$[23l>]s?23>q?-r$mE+]7  å –  ~ ?1  v %3*+)Ý?.\u3LE:;3†F.$°$H.bA.*+^.p3l>E¥3c]¦3S[(3sEh23LT|2}N_23\.>[r$Y2.$(S@KL?–YrO$T

T955H:[C<:8.$(23†š¯E‹+23>EJL23A./@*1q›3œ]$ž$(S@s?23'+;{ks4$mY236*2L¥3*E($^23b6s?4$%37Eu{;p3;Q$.8O$[rA.*2L‹h23

8*EEh23K$).$(S@KL?–YrO$TT955H:[C<:>rtrA.\?h1(8*rL%3ƒ)LTd$„3`..$(S@"l>J3L23l>J3L@!®†š;A..323*fE‹+23*€u$Y23™Syp3s?23>rtXA.x1Y23*rL%3‰>-2/)O$H  v %3$mEUb`uSr;|2}*E0EX3j:ã2*E2D–?:3.$(2

KL?–YrO$TT955H:[C<:b>Y];7E¥3/?4$%3;Q$.8O$[rBQ>@=$E5p3I€YX$€Y.$f+?È$ÌL€+.b'($).3237Cp3$J$0(8¦S[YXƒ@sY-rKQ‰>]‡43Sf23

Page 70: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 70/248

$' "#$%&'()%*+,'-.)% /012

*E[h?%3.$(2KL?–YrO$TT955H:[C<:_yQ»C$Y?rS^)QS^)”Ub‰S0q@;KQhFr.$(S@KL?–YrO$TT955H:[C<:8$aS[Y.dL+€@;7E¥38¯2p3hFr3_T

.$(23 <$aS[Y.\+^.7^..323™Syp3*+@$[238dD–?:D2s?23;Z$C$m:3jU$@b   V/hr7E+€?23sEh23KQ=3‰p3>E¥3`..323s?23sT$m1f(701XB$uO‰

*E2$]LT6*+F€%3*E+q]*qrtT*EX3}bƒ@O;>hrZ>]¯‹+23$E53>]3;6d;Q

8R$‹%3\YM2;c]™>%3>E-h23AMqrKQS.>rI?J*Eh23s?23•$?w$mE2k¦S–2 \J$0(b'. V>C4$?Y233O$F?(33Syà.$(2"l>J3L23l>J3L@!bƒ)K$)3_¡.$(23

$.>[X$fEf&6*2L‹h238*E+p3†š\(Qª>[fr\.>[X6d$Eup3s?23’X$µ$)$  v ³bdL+€@;7E¥38¯2p3K$).$(S@"l>J3L23l>J3L@!KL($[23S^)p38$J$0(;d3tr

LqYrd>-q@ŒQA.NQKL($CSyàb .$(2 Z$-23 70123 Kk"l>J3L@ l>J3L23!3>u `43O 70:bKeU 8O$F?y$@;

 .$(S@"/?Y“3 B$)O$H%3 /@ c]p3 d>-%3 *E($^23 *2L¥3 6 g[J l>J3L@ l>J3L23*2L‹h23 6 /?123;b*Ea3jU3 BL‹h23 A. ‡Ç 6 *uO‰ c]Q $,rQ ¢SJQ \(Q ƒ)  *2L¥3 A. .323 Œ3L(Q ¯+?È B3†“”X ’EG,X dDy A. $TØ$H(k ’X s?23 '123

*E($^23b3jU3 *2L‹h23 6 $.Q*E($^23 *hXS%$@ =$u >[U *:‰$123 *EabKeU 83†yQ; .$(S@"l>J3L@ l>J3L23!*E+h[?1%3 d$Eup3 l$)$³ 6 {;p3 *hXS%3 6 \?($M. >[fr ª

*2L‹h23 A.b6 >E¥3 \43‰Q; 8*2L‹h23 A. {;p3 *2L¥3 6 ®¢LU {k *U$a«$hU 'h“Q 8œh23 `. *r?G%3 O$0?23>L@ l>J3L23l>J3!*E0EX3j:k \(Q 8¹La; 7M@; 8

3>u *€u$(bdL[X*EaSf23{;p3KQ'1E2i$YTl>]$Cc^.7MH@g+‹.dt-q@A]*Eh23*‹E€%3b$.AMqrKQd$[  v rA]¹$0Y23shrS0?23.$(2"l>J3L23l>J3L@!LT\(Q.$(S@/?.¤nEJZ$C=3‰”@>Eu6Š$‹(`:3;A.B$Eh23*f+?G%3bAMqr;KQ`uSr

=tuA.\J$0({kKQ>]3L[23™Syp3>CB”hYX8®OL,€@>C;'  ~ q  å q  v Z$E[+2=3‰”@

Page 71: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 71/248

 3456 7'829/4:%;< /4:%;)%=>;?'@% >'-)3 A $(

>Eu\-.bx+‹?rZ$E[23=3‰”@>Eu`..$(S@"l>J3L23l>J3L@!K;$-?238\-.3_T;®O;>@>]$1r.$(S@"l>J3L23l>J3L@?bI?J.323s?23’X$mqEqFX‰$E‹D26

=$%38SM-23»@jXN”@=Ô®_y”XL0YX;8$m?+-f@.$()—»J$f23CIKCI5 ˜8K$]$.O_?-X.$(2"l>J3L23l>J3L@!b7);.$(S@d;$wdD–?:3.$(S@

"l>J3L23l>J3L@!ƒ(kZ>[E:c]=3_rk\1f(7M@*&$1@b>Ef?1r.$(S@"l>J3L23

l>J3L@!

A.\?-Eh&†š*E2D–?:3|2};=$frã2¿D^@Ä;¼¤"bKk*E($M.k*mu3L..$(S@"l>J3L23l>J3L@!l¢O$@3>u*+q?³;b

+bOLU*mu3L..$(S@"l>J3L23l>J3L@!8KeUA.7m1233>uRS-?23\E+]b

)bOLUR VS-?23c].$(S@"l>J3L23l>J3L@!8KeUZ>]\?E+@$CdD–?:D2KLM?:*+m:’EE[?23b

3_2KeU.$(S@"l>J3L23l>J3L@!>Ef?1rA.7;g;)%N_23`?q?r\@b

  .$(S@ Kk 8™Syp3 *EJ$Y23 A.>l>J3L@ l>J3L23?dD–?:3 *E($M.k A] cG?r™Syp3 .323 ;Q /(3L[23bBDMH%3 KeU 83Sq^. dD–?:3 3_T KLMr $. 3O‰$( ƒYE@;

  l‰>-?. BDMH. sT B$Eh23 A. `:3; Š$‹( 6 ArSyz3 dD–?:3 *2;$³ `.d$M5p3bL0Yr; \h1Mr KQ Œ$‹?:3 N_23 $. ™Sr KQ 7up .$(23 O>š $. 3}k 8;Q

 fY@tf?1  v X KQ AMqr s?23 .323 7hC A. Z$[?(D2 ¦S-?2$@ S&$GE: \(eU 8\1 b$. 8$E($“$mY] dt-q@ =$[h23 x-F23 A. KLME: 8*2‰$h?%3 B$.$µ3 Q>hX Kkb*2;$³ KeU 83†yQ;

 *hE0?1%3 †š .323 A] ×G?23 ’“ A.; 8>r>§—s43LH-23 .$()59:;<=;Q

 %3 †š ™Syp3 .323ŠD&«3 c] *(;$-? ˜Ž”E23 {k ÄL+–. L€( c] N‰¬X $. l‰$] .$() OLh .$(S@ 7hC A. }$[(«3 *YMÉ `C3L23 6 '($) s?23 .323 A."l>J3L23

l>J3L@!bsT *E2$] *f+MX `U‰ K;‰ dD–?:D2 7@$C LT $. dD–?:3 c] lO>[23 Kk NQ 7hC A. $m[E[§ K$M.«$@ AMr ª *  V q  ~ m  ~ .*E($^23 *2L¥3 6 ')O$5 s?23 BDy>%3 A.

*2L‹h23 A.b

Page 72: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 72/248

$) "#$%&'()%*+,'-.)% /012

Kk$. V·fr¹$0Y23ST$h23N_23\[[J.$(S@>l>J3L23l>J3L@?LTrt. Vx)S.A.8\f‹2\J;O;8*E.$[?(38\³$1X;\JLa;;b\f‹+U\-YqrA.dLy>236

BDMH%3†š*rO;P23b\J;O;*E.$[?(39h^XArSyz3A.O3ä«3$.>Y]’?rxrSÆO>–23b$.Q\³$1X>]$1EUc]l‰$-?:3K;$-?23d‰$h?%3bƒYE@\+-±¹LaL237m:’mf23*h1Y2$@/h]D28ArSyz3$ÉN‰¬r{kd$F€?:3K;$-?237rL‹23>.p3b

 

Page 73: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 73/248

 

!"#$%&' )*+#,  

"#$%&'()*$+,-$./0$.1234567'.89:;$.<=2>$.?+@$.AB2CDEFGHI

J"K2C"3BL+#GMBNO6C9B2;7$2=PCQ"BO-BNDG5RS 2C"T7>CQ"U.VDC *&WEXY*6'.VDCZ2W[WY.\'].*;&7T^._`a2bV(c273$.def2[3$.5e2-$.(C2ag$!Q"U.+$.Q"U.+="_*h24ijikl$mHnh9W&o7$.dpW-$./0$.qb2UZN+r.*W&-#7>^.

DC*$+,-$.*WaV\E$N."sf\s.HI(C2a5=!Q"U.+$.Q"U.+="t+'5F7>G8?2#-$.ku2evwN.VxaIV8*&:o^.DEyL."T7'N.DC9-sPWFr.9EX=z6h_

2C/0$.J"oW'"3B{l$m.|\hHIPWFr..+B}8L."T7'.*W[WY.\'].2~.m_9•hH+EW'€23e/IM-'+B"G?5^.L."T7'N*W[WY.\'i5RIk*;&7‚LIHi

*W[WY.\'].*6c2X$.q#-7'P4+Cu2W7R.{PWFr. "#$u ƒ+„H+…vu23G2Ck†WF'+eV‡2B?2WUˆ$k*Wc2#YuN. ‰2[) ‰26h2a ƒ."…*=2…Š$AB.0e‹.Œ>$.!"#$V!"#%_Ž9  ƒ WT7GV.0e(•3$.v+…VPF2E'DCv.5h‘.DG0$.H+C"T7>G*W[WY.\'ik*3W6C’3W=L"T7>G"UIv.5h‘.O$+o7^./I

O3[•^.8“•7-Wb5Y*W”.u+$.Ž*W[WY.\'i5RI_‹2#   GHi*W[WY.\'].*3[•^.L"#   7'

Page 74: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 74/248

!" "#$%& '()&*+,#-.%& /012

ABf2W7….PF[7$.2E>$..mi2C–2,7'.v5;$.‹ ƒ+o7^.‹+:—.ABZ."c2BABIDCl&Yd7$.9:K2•W&B5c2'?2@BIH2E>$._Qu2-6=k5RIDEFG9W˜HIPW™v.5hI

PF[7$.2E>$.H+C"T7>G*W[WY.\'ikQ"U.V’3W=“•WYšG"UIv.5h‘.*W[WY.\'n=Q"G"…_DE$V.0eLv2#$."G"r.t+'D$9B2;7GNiPCv.5h‘.DG0$.H+C"T7>G

*W[WY.\'].*W&›‘._Qv2GwABkl$mHnhD„.+^.z›‘.t+'k9B2;7GABV+oa

"bŒCk2-G5#YPCO3„.+^.kDG5Rœ.2^2„HILv2#$."G"r.W$+' ‰?ž… ‰ŸF•CDC H2E>$._.0$‹2#GHi*W[WY.\'].Q"G"r."s34#.5&*W[WY.\'].k*W&›‘..mi2C9:ULv2#$.k"G"r."3Bx&C26YPCD„.+^.kz›‘.AB*…uvABIDCl&Yd7$.9:K2•W&BD„.+^.2C"3B9C267GPCD„.+C5RS DC;aH2E>$._’=VHIH2E>$.

OW&›‘.“eDG0$.H+&EXGPF[7$.2E>$.kx7C5=HnhL+•;Cf2W7…N.+e¡a¢h2ECv5;&$D  ƒ [•^./0$.–2,7'.L2W#$.?.vš=9@hIDC%'+7C?.vIH2E>$._2av+#G

.0ek5C‘.9EX=Vk}2-CjiL+•;C*#G5,$.*Gu+,7$.£2'‘._H+EY*W[WY.\']./67.89 ‰2WB2™.mi‡DEF7Y*GI*W[WY.\'i5RIDC2•U2W7…._"!# 

"37>GžW;o7$.dc2WU].10¤*#G5,$.AB>;YZ2B+h"^.AB¥2'I*FcŸ^.VI*s2W&$.?2#-$.v"BVv.5hI9>3$._ŽHiPW™ZN+o7$.*Wc2WU‘.k*3Ey.miV–2,7'./I

 !Ž ?NŒe*G5¡a “We2;C AB H+6&,^.¦26$‘.H+h\6W' ‰2WB2™ Q5#7>^. *W[WY.\'Š$ §G567$. .0¨

8 *GV2>7C H+EY *W[WY.\'i 2)I ABHw.+Y©2a '()* +,-./.01.-22•>;a PC_ª2;G56Y 2CI †WF' vu23G2C Z2;G56Y DB ŸW&s *;&7‚ d•h d6Fr. u.5#7'N.V f2W7…Ÿ$!"#$Žf2W7…Ÿ$

/u+,7$. u.5#7'N.V_x….+G /0$. "G"r. "h.+$. x= L+#G /0$. f2W7…Ÿ$ x;G56Y «F>G †WUAB 9:K Hš= k2W&›I 23„.+C:;2x7•….+C "3B z›‘. D„.+^. 2•W&B 9:K d7$. *…u"$.

+$. DC 9@hI ?.vš= "G"r. "h.+$. x….+G /0$. z›‘. D„.+^. L+#G HI ¬} k5RS 23„.+C"h. 5RS ."h.V x….+G /0$._5;$. f2@G]V Oe.g$. %W>-Y 9…‘ Q"G"… Z2;G56Y `C"T7'. "#$O3[•^. DC Q®› *B+F¯ ”šY VI O3[•^. "UI Z.”šY O=_HI9EX= Q5#7>C Q"B2s *GI

Q5#7>C Q"B2s 2@GI de /u+,Y ‰2WB2™_*;W,&$. Q"B2#&$ *->3$2=VH+EY N d7$. Q"B2#$. /I‹VIŸ„]. AB DGuv2®$.Ž ‰2GV2>C §G567$. H+EG k_Z2W45;$. PW™ Hid7$.8°3$.q#-7'

 ‹."-7'. “Y 2C .mi *oWo›±/u+,7$. u.5#7'N.² ³=±u.5#7'N.dB’r.²§W3:7$. *G5¡a ?23´7'2= <o&^. 8 d7$.¦Ž.Œ;b "6G ‡ x3E$V k ‰2GuVµ §W3:7$. H+EG †WU k_

Page 75: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 75/248

 <=>9 ?#@2A/=4&BC /=4&B%&D  EBF#G& E#-%< H!#

2•3CHIf27¶26F ‰2Wa2E'k ‰23W6CHnh.0e‹+o7$.dc2WU‘.q¡oW'*›5;=L2W#&$kl$0=’b+e|\;C_.0¤VkM->$.Hnh*W[WY.\'].Q5#7>^. ‰2WB2™de%#hd7$.Ps+7G2•3CHIDEF7YDC?2#=i2•>;a8Hw.+YAB"^."W6-$.2•;›+=*W[WY.\'].

d7$.2•C"T7>GPWFr._ªš3'VAB*Xs23C·6=Z2#W-,7$.].*Wc2WU89:;$.kC2¸.DE$V237,#aHœ.deHIZ2W[WY.\'N.Q5#7>^. ‰2WB2™deZ2W[WY.\'.

*F•C2)‘Q"WU+$.d7$.PW,7>YZ26F[7$.*Wa2E>$.2•&C2E=HI¹h2º2•W&BAB"^. "W6-$.DC"G"~/Iv5hD  ƒ [•C9F  » 7   ¼_Hižh2U<W-,Yu.5#7'N.d6Fr.AB9W&º€+&>$./½-$.+et2X7b./I

–.+aIZ2W[WY.\'].ded7$.DEFG*B+F[F&$HI¹h2º2•W&Bx…+=*GI*W[WY.\'i*&G"=_.mi2CZ"…V*W[WY.\'i*&G"=k*o…2aDEFWhv5;&$±D  ƒ [•^.²HI2e"¶DC

‹ŸRš7$.kdB.+$.VIDC‹ŸR*= 5[7$.kš,¸.VVI’=uDC‹ŸR¹—.v5[^._.miH2bPWFr.H+C"T7>G*W[WY.\'ik*3W6CH2bVP'+=*W[WY.\'i5RIHIL+#Y?.vš=

9@hIDF4*pW-$.*W$2—.kH2E>&$P'+-h?5^.HIDF@G“)IH+;X7EW'10e*W[WY.\'].k9@h‘.Ÿ…2BLIŸ…S _.0$Hnh*W[WY.\'].Q"WU+$.d7$.NDEFG

2•U2W7….ded7$.DEFGHId#-Y2•>;a*W[WY.\'].*&@;^."$PWFr._DE$Vl$23e5G0ºN"=x3C‹+U.0e§G567$.*W[WY.\'Š$Q5#7>^. ‰2WB2™_

+•h|\;GHš=v.5h‘.DG0$.H+=5¶Z2W[WY.\'].Q"G"r.NH+&B2;7G.´bPC“•@6=·6-$._"!#’bV¹UŸ3'’Whk"6=2)I.mi2C`&B2;YAB9E¾kZ2B+F¯Hnhl$23e*Wa2ECiu+•¡$"Gž^.DCZ.u+,7$.Q"G"r.*C2¤.V."…_

DCVZ2=+6:$.d7$.x….+7'.0eL+•;^."3Bx#W-,YAB*-6$*&@6CO[>$.Qu5E7^.dexaIH+EW'DCM6:$.."…"G"ºZ2W[WY.\'N.d7$.xE&7¿ #/IL+•;C

 !Ž DEFG>;Y.u.5#7'Nd6Fr. ‰2@GI ‰2#hVL.ž7$Ÿ$DCt5„MBNk"U.VW$V2#hV

–+F[F&$2E>$.1Àš=_“”D$PW,7>GMBN5RS HIL+#G?.vš=9@hIDCL."T7'.10e*W[WY.\'].2•>;a.mi%#hV.mi`a2b*W[WY.\'].Q5#7>C ‰2WB2™_

Page 76: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 76/248

!$ "#$%& '()&*+,#-.%& /012

u.5#7'N.d6Fr.ÁZ2W[WY.\'].Vd7$.NxE&7¿_"#$9C26YHV5Rœ.PC10e*=+6:$.DC‹ŸRÂU9W&o7$.1u2:7s.VAB§s.+^.d7$.H+EY2•WhZ2W[WY.\'].

*,W>=9EX=kÃ2RVIDC‹ŸR5¡3$.8·6=Z2B+F¯Z2W[WY.\'N.d7$.“Y2e"G"ºAB+oadc.+XB"!# _"#$“Y9U*&EX^.kHœ.2y96…DCDEF^.°WTXY

IJKZ2W[WY.\'N.Q5#7>^.2WB2™*-6&$*&@6CO[>$.Qu5E7^._"sV“Y5bm

°WTX7$.u+b0^.8<o&^.¦_Ž DE$VW$DC/uVÄ$.*->3$2=234.5Å‘*W$2—.HI¬ Æ5;   a8Z’WF67$._DC“cŸ^.HI0Rša*W[WY.\'i*3W6C53$`º*GItV5Ç2•3EFGHILV2#Yf2W7…N./0$.DEFGHIL+#Yx=*GI*W[WY.\'i5RI_DCVZ2W[WY.\'N.d7$.<o7>Y°o;$.de

!Q"U.+$.Q"U.+=3_*W[WY.\'nh4Q"U.+$.Q"U.+="HV267Y8*&#3$.kjV‘.DCV“”L+#Y9´F=2CL+#Gx=MBŸ$.5Rœ.8*&#3$.*#=2>$._.0$Hnh*B+F¯O-B ƒŸ$.DG0$.

H+C"T7>G*W[WY.\'i4Q"U.+$.Q"U.+=3H+aV267W'PC“•@6=k·6-$.9:oW'V9b"U.V“•3CABQšh2E^.5 Ž9E$*&#a_.miV2C`C2s*W[WY.\'i5RIf2W7…2=.0e

PF[7$.k2E>$.M[Wh2•W&BHIw5º*FWs*6s+7CABIDC10e_’hde*W[WY.\'].d7$.DEFGHI9:ºAB2C+e5´bIDCl$m"3BM6&$.PCMBNL"T7>G*W[WY.\'i

!Q"U.+$.Q"U.+="{‹VI2CDEFGHI‹2#G+eHI*W[WY.\'i10•bM¶HIu"®Y8*,#ak*3W6C2^2„

2)I8tŸRl$m9:o7'ABQšh2EC5 Ž%#hAB9bkx&#a2)š¾8l$mHš¾DG5Rœ._2C"3BVu"®YQ5F&$kjV‘.9:o7'AB?.5Å].6Žk+eV9EXGABI

Z2B+h"^.*3EF^._DE$V"6=kl$mL+#7'*W[WY.\'i!Q"U.+$.Q"U.+="u"®$2=de

5R‘._kÈ27$2=VHnh!Q"U.+$.Q"U.+="2•3EFGHIM3[7Yf2W7…N.DC9-s 

!Ž `a2b2•C"T7'. d7$. §s+^. "G"º *#G5„*B+37^. ¦26$‘. DC "G"6$. 8 H+7&WC2e!"7#Žk G.5=V †WF' vu23G2C 2•C"T7'. d7$. Z2W[WY.\']. "G"º *#G5„V!"#8Ž†WF' vu23G2C k

!"#%Žu+&G2YV k!"#7_Ž€+&>&$ 9F7o^. DC2E$. u.5#7'N2= *,-Y5^. (c273$. AB –Ÿ„Š$V 2;GuV ¥+$ 5¡aI kV267$.!"9#Ã k!:;Žkwu+b!"##Ž;W&¾5G2eV k!"#%_Ž

Page 77: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 77/248

 <=>9 ?#@2A/=4&BC /=4&B%&D  EBF#G& E#-%< H!!

Z2W[WY.\'i10•b¬}HI5F7>Y*-6&$.Q\h*&G+„’=d;EG2•3WEF7$DCL2#7aN.v5$.VAB?.5Åiu"®$._8kPs.+$.2CDC*W[WY.\'iDEFGHIf27!Q"U.+$.Q"U.+="

.mi2CH2bL#J79MNO&<Ž26'.V’=xWh*G2;E$._2CI*#G5„«W4+Yl$m“77hgB*#W#—.d7$."W;YHš=!Q"U.+$.Q"U.+="P7F7Y

Q5b.0=2e"CI*&#3$.QR‘.%#h_kl$0$P'+=/"o7^.9B2;$.HI5”š7>GÉsš=Q"c2h

*3Ey2•3CDB<G5„u.5EY/IP=27YZ.u2W¸HV267$.u"®$.VAB+oa"W…_M->=V Âs"CQ5b.m4Q"U.+$.Q"U.+=3kHnhP=277$.u+b0^.v.5^.1u.5EYM¶HINLV"G5´b‘DCO7&#a_.0EeVHnh5´bIZ2G"o7$.*W&B2hdeZ26=277$.Qu5E7^.DCHV267$.

u"®$.V/I=>ŽV>>Žd7$.Vd36Yu"®$.“c."$.?@@ >Ž_.miV‡DEF7Y*GIQ"U.VDCOY2eO7W[WY.\'].DCf2W7….4Q"U.+$.Q"U.+="kD$DEF7Y ‰.mi*GI*W[WY.\'i

5RIDCL2W#$.kl$0=HiV*W[WY.\'i!Q"U.+$.Q"U.+="Q5#7>C ‰2WB2™_HiŸbDG0eOGu2-7   ^.O&F7o   ^.H26W,7>GL2W#$.’=+e9@hIDCQšh2E^.5 Ž8

*&#3$.kjV‘.2CV+eI+'IDCQšh2E^.5 

Ž8*&#3$.*Wa2´$._.0$’•hH."W;7>GDC Z2W;&¸.d7$.NH+EG9-#7>^.2•Wh’•C."…*au2#Cµ2—2=_ABV9bk‹2U.mi2CH2b¥2W#C“:¸.<Ž.-b’=xWhk*G2;E$.HnhN*W[WY.\'iu"®$.“c."$.?@@ >ŽNV¦V23Yu"®$.kHV267$.V/I>ŽV=Žuv2#=ABf2W7….*W[WY.\'i4Q"U.+$.

Q"U.+=3_.miV‡DEF7Y*GIQ"U.VDCOY2eO7W[WY.\'].DCf2W7….4Q"U.+$.Q"U.+="kHnh*GI*W[WY.\'i5RID$DEF7YDCl$m_.0eV2C23W,6G*W45;$.*Wa2´$._

2CIH2eg$.d;h<o&^.¦_ŽPJQ6;%&%*

Hi*W[WY.\'i4

Q"U.+$.Q"U.+="

Q5#7>C ‰2WB2™.mi%#hV.miH2b ¥2W#C“:¸.AŽ.-b’=xWh*G2;E$._Hi10e*FW#$.*…5—.¥2W#^“:¸.AŽde*;WÇVWG2#CZ2B+h"^.k*6=u‘.6ŽV5 ŽVBŽVC_Ž"!# 

!Ž NVk’W'HI*FW#$.*…5—.¥2W#^“:¸.DAE*W[WY.\'i 96r!Q"U.+= Q"U.+$."Q5#7>CDC gb‘. de 2W6™6F BÊŽ6 F 5 ŽV5F CÊŽ6 F 5 Žk‹V‘. 9:;$. 8 2#=2' 23GIu ’bV Ë

Page 78: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 78/248

!& "#$%& '()&*+,#-.%& /012

DFEYV*WÌI10e*W45;$.8xaI.miH2b9bDC8PF7[^.2E>$. ‰2aV267   CPCDG5Rœ.H‘PWFr.H+C"T7>G*W[WY.\'i4Q"U.+$.Q"U.+="kxanhD$PW,7>G ‰2GI“•3C

DC“G"#Y?.vI9@hIL."T7'2=*GI*W[WY.\'iPRSTHIL+#G9-#7>^.?2#$n=‹ŸÇQ-b*6'.VVABµ2—._Qu2-6=k5RIHi2C96¶*W&FBf2W7….*W[WY.\'i

!Q"U.+$.Q"U.+=".5CIŸWo7>C+eHIH+EG¥2W#C“:¸.<ŽkP;Y5C’=xWh*G2;E$.

*->3$2=jiZ2-&,7^.d7$.2~v"UWG2#CZ2B+h"^.*6=u‘.ÁQu+b0^.1ŸBI_A6h 9W-'k‹2´^.|\h.HI6 G 9 V5 G 8VB G !VC G :’b8*h+;:CZ2B+h"^.*3W-^.89EX$.“su!_ ‰.mi*W[WY.\'nh4Q"U.+$.Q"U.+=3Q5#7>C ‰2WB2™.mi`a2b*&#3$.

*Cv2#$.Z.m*FWs/V2>Yd´&”*FWs*&#3$.*W$2—._89ÇtV5Çk10•b.miH2bPW™DG5Rœ.H+C"T7>G4Q"U.+$.Q"U.+=3kW$ »l6'+=NiHI96;Y;ak?Í$.HIV

HV267Y“•6C_DC*WU23$.k5R‘..mi2C·;Ta.¥2W#C“:¸.AŽji2CHVv10e*FW#$.k*…5—.H2bVPW™DG5Rœ.H+C"T7>G4Q"U.+$.Q"U.+=3kH+EW'DC/"[^.

HIu"®Y8ZŸ#a*=V237C_2CI.miH2b¥2W#C“:¸.AŽ9sIDCk§:3$.H+EW'DC

/"[^.HIu"®YABL.V"$._Hi"UiOC2@^.*›2¸.dexaI.miH2bDCÅ9F7o^.HIH+EGMBŸ$.

5Rœ.."….+7C8*-6&$.kŸG+„l$mV*[W7ax;6@$k«4.+$. ‰.mi*FW#$2h*bu"   ^.¥2W#^“:¸.AŽ"s`@;Ta.‡V"6Y*F>$.*W$v2-7$.*W[WY.\']4Q"U.+$.Q"U.+=3

Q5#7>C_23G"$23e>;Y¥+W$+GÂWs¦2-'ˆ$d7$.`&6…?2;&UxF:RH+;EGDBHV267$.PCl$m“:¸.α"#$.V"…VHIN9CIxG"$H":#GVxF:Rd-C+=IxaIV

 

Ë *…uv Hnh*W[WY.\'iu"®$.“c."$.D?@@ >E

"3BM6&$.PC*W[WY.\'i4

Q"U.+$.Q"U.+=3

de 6 J AB J A;B KG 6 JABLD!FAEMM ³$ H2E>$. –+F¯ %'+7C DC 9@hI .0e H+EG D$V5LD!FAE“:¸. ¥2W#C H+EG 2C"3BA N D6F5ELD6FBŽ_

 ABVu"®$. ¦V23Y VI ‹v2-Y Hnh k‹.+3^. ;a>HV267$.V="3BM6$*W[WY.\'i4Q"U.+$.Q"U.+=39:oW'AB6 J AC J A;6 J A8CMMM G D6 J ACED! J A; J A$ M M E G D6 J

ACELD! O A;E%'+7C DC 9@hI .0e H+EG D$V–+F¯ ³$ H2E>$.5LD!FAEH+EG 2C"3B“:¸. ¥2W#CA N D6F5ELD5 O CEM¦ <o&^. 5¡aI kx&C2E= H2eg$. AB –Ÿ„Š$V_

Page 79: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 79/248

 <=>9 ?#@2A/=4&BC /=4&B%&D  EBF#G& E#-%< H!'

À2RNk*$2¼.+hÂ7h2#hVQ"B2#&$*C26$.d7$.«-:G2•Wh?2s"›I?5^.?."BIx$8?.Ä$._ÏPau.V *GžW&[aŠ$ 2•™5Y!"7:Ã k8;%Ð_

DCV*&´C‘.5R‘.de*$2—.d7$.H+EG2•Wh–V½^./u2[7$.AB*h2Uk¥Ÿh].PW-WhxY2=2>U2ym*&=2s9#3&$°TX$kd…u2RVI*•…k*W…u2R<&,G2•W&B

“'.9Wb+$./u2[7$.Q(RST1 Ž_“7GV.0ePW-$.“:T=-b."…xa‘2CHII"-GP  ƒ 3  » :   ^.

u."oaN2=ku+e"7$.V·h'q7U9@hIx3c2=wPh"$.9…‘kx7B2@=O[[o7C v+…+=Ñ9&R8kQv+r.VI2•&Xh8*#=2,CkZ2;›.+^.VI9W›+7$.k?d,-$.VI9b2C5,Ò8l$2=_Hiw ƒž6   ^.-E$.Z2WsŸRˆ$8Qu2[7$.+e*sŸ6$.kQ5F7>^.v2#7BN.V

Hš=AB?5^.HIL+#G·6-=9F6$./u2[7$.PC.0ekH+=ž$.VI.0ekž  ƒ •[^.2C"3BV"#;Y*b½$.*&¾2;$..0ew ƒž6   ^.kdEWY2C+YV‘.q7U9Wb+$./u2[7$./"G"—./I/+#$.

."…ŽD$H+EG.uv2sABv2¶i9G"-$._k5G2C!"#$Ã kÎ;%:Ž

ABV;aku.5®$.Hnh/I+@B8¥5®a+E$.P  » s+7   GxaILž•   W'8Z2=2T7aN.

*Cv2#$."s26GDC·6=Z2=+6:$.8L2W#$.·6-=‹’B‘.*W6G½7$.PCxcŸCwAB ¥2'‘./v2W7BN.*#´&$*6F>$.V*-W,$."!#_’bHI€23e"G"6$.DC*&´C‘.5R‘.d7$.O-Y*WÌI9B2;7$.9G+,$."C‘.8

u.5#7'.HV267$._DC9•>$.."…HI¹h2ºAB"B.+s‹v2-7$.8u2„i*3G"^.Q®:$.VI<„23^.*W3E>$.Q ƒ5#7>   ^.d7$.2•3,#G?23=I5B"U.V_ABV+oak¥+E6CHnhDC

9F7o^.."…HIq#&Gm27'‘.5c.ž$.*&C26C*;W64DCH"$*W#=?2@BI*pW¤.*W>Gu"7$.8k*W&E$.*au2#^2=PC*#G5„9C26Y?NŒePC“•@6=VIPC“•cŸCwOF¡73^._

DCVZN2—.Q´^.*6c.5$.Vd7$.A[7G2•Whu+,YHV267$.AB¥2'I9B2;7$. 5F7>^.2CJ"U8v23R‹27#$.8¦5—.*W^26$.jV‘._d;h“   ƒ @R10e¦5—.

 !Ž DCVde *Gw.+^. Z.u2-7BN.Mc23$. HId6G½7$. &[^. +@B VIŽ*&EXC DC 26G /0$.

 ¦2T7a. Qv2Bi Ã5h Qv2Gw 8 H+-Å5G DG0$. DGvVv+$. ?ŸCž$. ·6= DC Q"B2>C q#&7G HI DEFG*#” 9¼V ‰.5”ŒCV k ‰2aV267C xaI Ó2^. 8 `-”I °T¾_

Page 80: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 80/248

&( "#$%& '()&*+,#-.%& /012

*W[F¤.k¥VÄ$.šXa8v23¸.2CO=‹2…5$.DG0$.x….+G“•@6=2@6=2C<&„ IxW&B’Wh"6=±L2¡aÔ Æ B–vV€ÅÔW6G_²`a2bZ.+#$.Q"67>C*™2•^2•@6=

·6-$.2C"3Bq#&7Yk5C.V‘.DE$V89›.+;$.d7$.J"ºO=€u26^.kgE$.H2b9bDCOh5,$.M3[7G2—im‘.t5,&$5Rœ.Á¬}HIHV267Gt5,$.5Rœ.

9C267GV9´^2=_‡DEY10e*W[WY.\'].QuVÄ$2=!Q"U.VQ"U.+="_9=`a2b8·6=

kH2WU‘.H273”.Q"U.+=_’bM7b%=242,G5=8xY.5b0C‹+UxF  ƒ &>YP„2#$Z2W&FB "G"…DCOW>a5;$.Î`a2b*'u’^.*W>a5;$.deHI±–v¦ŸE$.*Fc23$.*Fc2a²Á/I–v*37;$.*Fc2a

NV2•¡s+YÁ2C"3BH+EGP„2#$.k2cv2ef2@GiVl$m9EX=L2YDC‹ŸRv5$.Q"X="3B|567$./"o7&$_8V"UIZ26,#$.d7$.2e23F&7'.k“•3C.+o4VI ƒÈi“)š=8

Ps.+$.H+E&7FGQ5;¾2•F•;G?."B‘.9EX=k"W…deVΓ)IH+#&,GO7›2›u.vuAB9b*›2›u<&,3Yk“•W&B“•3E$VD$.VI"-GŸ„iÃ2›5$.ABŸ„].zWb

!"8:Ã kÎ!%Ž_

`a2b9´C10eZ2'u’^.*WaV267$.Q5F@   ^.VÅ*Wa+a2sQ5^2=Á2•3E$V`a2b*3„+7>C2@GI_u ƒ+„.0eL2¡3$. x>;aP  ƒ '+YVQ"6$Z.+3'“Å5$2=DC5B2XC¦5—.

9@hIVv+•r.d7$.2¤0-GZN.53r.*&›.+^*'2W't.ž37'N.*7=2´$._Hi10e*:#$.*W3Å."…82•&W›2;Y*WU+^.Q"W;^.V†Wo=HI9:;$.Lv2#$.x7C5="s¥ ƒ5   b2¤_

q7UVHV"=|+¸.8"Gž^.DC9W›2;Y*G2EUv23¸.*W$27#$.k10eHnhu+•Ç*W[WY.\'iQ"U.+$.O73”2=f\#GHš=AB?5^.HIqR+7Gu0—."3B?2#7'.Z2…2737'N.

DCžWb\$.<W@$.AB*W[WY.\'i!Q"U.+$.Q"U.+="*:$2¸._DE$Vji/I"C<-,3G

|.\hN.‹+U!

Q"U.+$.Q"U.+="

9c2#$.2)š=*W[WY.\'iQ5#7>C ‰2WB2™.mi%#hV.mi H2b9-#7>C9B2;7$. ƒ’•   C9EX={M'23C’3W=‹+#Y*W45;$.*Cv2#$.Hi10e*[W73$.de*[W7a*C2B8kPs.+$.<-,3YVŸ6hAB*GI*W[WY.\'iDEFGHIH+EY‹VIDCHV267G_

.PJQ6;%)UHi*GI*W[WY.\'iDEFGHIH+EY‹VIDCkHV267G2)2ECn=HI5#7>Y  ‰2WB2™%#h2C"3BH+EG¥2W#C“:¸.AŽ.-b9EX=M'23C_

Page 81: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 81/248

 <=>9 ?#@2A/=4&BC /=4&B%&D  EBF#G& E#-%< H&*

M->$.V?.uVl$m+exaIDC9…IHIH+EY*W[WY.\'].Q5#7>Ck ‰2WB2™N"=2¤DCHIdFº2•>;aDC5,Rf2W7…N.DC9-s/IÑ"o7CkH2b’=“•Wh*W[WY.\'].

d7$.u"®Y’c.v_.mi9:UHIV`aV26Y*W[WY.\'].*W&o^.k*W&›‘.Hnh*W[WY.\'iu"®$.“c."$.?@@ >Ž9:o7'AB?.5Åiu"®$.6Ž8l&Y*&#3$._DC*WU23$.

k5R‘.Hi%'+7CH2E>$.2CO=O3„.+^.OW&›‘.NDEFGHIH+EGgbIDC

Qšh2E^.5 

Ž9E$*&#a_k.0$DFh9…IHINH+EG%'+7CH2E>$.9sIDC*…u"$.d7$. 2•##º*W[WY.\'iu"®$.“c."$.?@@ >ŽkN"=HI5F7>G9B2;7$.Q\;$*&G+„’=xWh*G2;E$.?2®$]M'2E^.*WYš7^.DC?.5Å].8ZŸ#3$.*Cv2#$._.0e+e5e+…k*W@#$.

DE$V5¡aI<o&^.¦Ž–Ÿ„Š$ABOe.g$.*WF'5$._Hid7W[WY.\'i!Q"U.+$.Q"U.+="V!Q"U.+$.O73”2="2ÌŸbH2Y"B2s+#.;JR%

m2˜Nu.5#$.DC†WU’)INHS"-Gu"®$.2#&,C_HiQ"c2h(C2ag$.§W,&$.8*CV2#Cf2W7…N.dexaIw5KABI*…uv*3Ey8–+F[^.2E>$.H+E7^.DC–+a"U.VDC

Z2W[WY.\']._L+#GVl$0=DC‹ŸR‹+:—.ABQšh2ECHV267$.€\X^.89bk*&#aPCMBN5RS L"T7>G*W[WY.\'].2~.m_

€\XY27W[WY.\'i4Q"U.+$.Q"U.+=3V!Q"U.+$.O73”2=3?Í=5RS 2@GI_2ÌŸEh“#73G"6=HIu"®GMBŸ$.5Rœ._v+#YV10e*¡UŸ^.jiI"-CkL2B2^2„HI*GI

*W[WY.\'i*-Å.u8HV267$.M¶HI96DCÅ/"[^.ÅVPh23$.*->3$2=/"o7F&$HI‹V2K2¤Ÿ®7'._I"-^.VL26$..0e+eHI(C2ag$.§W,&$.M¶HIU#$.8S‹Vš=*$2U

u"ÅL+#G2¨MBŸ$.k5Rœ..0eVd36GxaI8·6=ZŸ#3$.QR‘.M¶AB*W[WY.\'].HIl&7¿*›5hQv"¼*=2[7'Ÿ$u"®=DC2•-a2…2@GI"!#_

 !Ž "$2´7'N. *W&=2#= 2#&67C 2C+•;C HI `-” k*$+,-$. (c27a 9W&º ‰."… "W;C Qu_Q"B2s de 10eV

 u"®= 5Rœ. MBŸ$. L2Ws u+h u"®Y d7$. Q"B2#$. "G"o7$2= deV k*WC2#7a.±Ps+7C Ų_L+•;C Hi*Gu+h *=2[7'. M&,7G N ’b k*=2[7'N. "WbšY M&,7G N Qu2´7'N. *W&=2s_L+•;C M&,7G ’3W=

’•W&b *WC2#7aN. Q"B2#$._

Page 82: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 82/248

&% "#$%& '()&*+,#-.%& /012

PJQ6;%&"+DC9…IHIH+EY*W[WY.\'].*;W,&$.Q5#7>Ck ‰2WB2™N"=HIu2´7>   YDC‹ŸR‹VIu"ÅL+#Gx=MBŸ$.5Rœ._

M->$.V?.uVl$m%W>=."…_.mi‡u2´7>Y*W[WY.\'].*;W,&$.ž  » ;  » 7>   YVDC‹ŸRu"®$./0$./5¶8*&#3$.VŽkt+'D$H+EYQ5#7>C ‰2WB2™2)‘DEFGHI

|567Yf2W7…NDC9-s(C2ag$./0$.u »"  » Å8*&#3$.VŽ%#h_

"#$`3W=H27W45;$.H2YR‘.HI(C2ag$.§W,&$.DEFGHIH+EG ‰.5#7>C  ‰2WB2™.miH2b9-#7>^.d#&G‹Ÿ¡=k*Wh2bH2bV(C2ag$.x>;a9=2sQu2´7'Ÿ$_DE$V€23e*W[WY.\'iQ"U.V%#hQ5#7>C ‰2WB2™VWX&,=%&k·  ƒ ®=5¡3$.DB*FWs¥2W#C

“:¸.AŽkVIWG2#CkZ2B+h"^.6ŽV5 ŽVBŽVCŽ_10eV*W[WY.\'].deu"®$.“c."$.?@@ >Žk(C2ag$./0$.u"®GtÂ=5¡3$.DB/I?Õ_

PJQ6;%&#U*W[WY.\'iu"®$.“c."$.?@@ >Žde*W[WY.\'iQ5#7>C ‰2WB2™_

.mi`3b ‰."bš7CDCHIMBŸ$.5Rœ.ku "®W'ŸhV"  » …DClaV26Y ‰."=I_9:oW'V9bMBN8*B+F¯O-BŸ$.DG0$.H+C"T7>G*W[WY.\'iu"®$.“c."$.

?@@ >ŽABBŽ*&#3&$Q"U.+$._W$V€23eDC9W-'H‘DEF7GMBŸ$.DCL2W#$./š[email protected]‡HV267G/Iv5h5RS ABŸ„]._8k*G2•3$.Hnh/I

u2W7R.HV267Ct+'L ƒ"#GZ2B+h"C9;®^.C-RW+1X) Y(ZT[[ CŽk%#hHV"=*GI*›5h‹+:o&$ABÑ·G+6Yz-#7>C_

l&7¿10e*W45;$.·6=OC2@^.*C2¤.u+,7$HV267$._.mi2C9  ƒ W˜?5^.2C2¡aI"-GPCv.5h‘.DG0$.NDEFG“eÖ.5ÅikHV267&$Hnhu.5#7'N.dB’r.*W[WY.\']

u"®$.“c."$.?@@ >Ž‹"GABxaI2CDCv5hDEFGHI9CšGL2W#$./š=?.vI9@hIDC ×^.2C"   su.5F7'N.V8L"BxaV26Y+e2@GI_Hi ‰2^2BDCv2ÅV‘.ŽDEFGHILV2#Gf2W7…N./0$.L"#GxW&B/Iv5hL"T7>G*GI*W[WY.\'i5RIÁ¬}HI9:GH+Cv2#$.v"r."U.+$.+&Yk5Rœ.9b"U.VAB1"U_*&EX^.VdeHILv2#$."G"r.8

9´C.0e‡26$.!PW4+$."t+'D$"¶/Iv5hDEFGHI‹v2-7G/IkHV26Y9C267GVx6C

Page 83: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 83/248

 <=>9 ?#@2A/=4&BC /=4&B%&D  EBF#G& E#-%< H&)

9´^2=_ABV9bk‹2U.mi2C9RvLv2#$."G"r.jiZ26FkQ®›“)nh"sH+¡K*›5;=?"-$HV267$._

9…‘V*h56C*W;Wb‹+:Uk.0e9CšYN2´C ‰2WFsu ‰2,W>=*h+;:F=Z2B+h"Cl&7b*3W-^.89EX$.“su!89:;$.‹V‘._v ƒ"Ul$m‹2´^.?.5Åi‹Ÿ®7'N.*FW#= 

6 G 9kQšh2ECVHV267$.‹v2-7^.*FW#=5 G 8k*=+#BVu"®$.‹v2-7^.*FW#=B G !k2CI

Z2B+h"C9;®^.d•hC G :_"6=kl$mØ|\h.HI*W$’7U.?2#7$.O-BŸ$.*Wa2”de A G :M"_k2e"6=l$0=9:oW'9b"U.VDC*B+F¯v2ÅV‘.d7$.L"T7>Y

*W[WY.\'iu"®$.“c."$.?@@ >ŽABZ2B+h"CB89bk*&#a*…u"$V2•B+F¯!:

¬2#a_Hœ.V|\h.HI€23e"G"6$.DCO-BŸ$.DG0$.H+C"T7>G*W[WY.\'i

!Q"U.+$.Q"U.+="_2C"3B9C267Y*W[WY.\'i!Q"U.+$.Q"U.+="PC*W[WY.\'iu"®$.“c."$.?@@ >ŽkHnh4Q"U.+$.Q"U.+=3|5677'‹Ÿ®7'Ÿ$8*&#3$.kjV‘.DCV"6=

l$mD$HV267YPCuv2®$.4

PW4+$.3

.0eVd,6W':

Ž8*&#3$.kjV‘.V!

Ž8ZŸ#3$. k*W$27$.*…u"$V*WFb.5Y2•B+F¯"¬2#a%#h_"!#10eV*…u"$.de9sI9W&#=DC¬2#3$.½6$.d7$.9:K2•W&B!v2ÅV‘."HVuv2®$."3B9C267$.PC“•@6=·6-$._ABV9bk‹2U.mi2C`&B2;Y*W[WY.\'i!Q"U.VQ"U.+="PC*W[WY.\'i4Q"U.VQ"U.+="

k5RI’)nhHŸ:oW'ABHV26Y€\XC03C*G."-$.9:KV2ÌŸbAB8¬2#a89b*&#a2yÙ&-GxB+F¯8:*,#a_10eV*…u"$.9@hI´E=DC¬2#3$.½6$.d7$.9:K

2•W&B!v2ÅV‘."k"3B“•&C26YPC“•@6=·6-$._

Hœ..mi2CH2bH+Cv2#$.v"r.OC"T7>^.*W[WY.\']4

Q"U.+$.Q"U.+=3

*->a Q®›DCkH2E>$.Hnh4v2ÅV‘.3H+&C267W'9EX=5F7>C ‰2-G5#YPC4v2ÅVI3kDG5RS H+&:oW'VAB!:¬2#a%#h_xW&BVHnhH2b+-BN*W[WY.\'i4Q"U.+$.Q"U.+=3

 !Ž 9:º*W[WY.\'i4.Q"U.+$Q"U.+=3"3BM6&$.PC*W[WY.\'iu"®$.“c."$.D?@@ >EABC

J AB J A;B M MMd7$.VdeU C J ABLD!FAE G : J D:M" \ !ELM"DC¬2#3$._

Page 84: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 84/248

&" "#$%& '()&*+,#-.%& /012

DGuv2sAB9C267$.PC“•@6=·6-$.9EX=kt2bH+EW'’•6'+=‹+:—.AB‹"6CABIDCZ2…u"$.DC10e¬2#3$.½6$._“•3EFGV96hl$mDC‹ŸR“•bŸ7C.

Ã5;&$*Wh2E$.9W[>7$8:*,#aPCv5;$./0$.‹v2-7W'HV267$.“•6C9C267GVk9´^2=N"=DC¬2#3$.P>7$.d7$.H+&:K2•W&BDC9C267$.PC°T¾N“¤v2-GHV267$._“b

0Rš7'*W[WY.\'i4Q"U.+$.Q"U.+="{.mi2C`a2b10e*W[WY.\'].2Ú"$*->a*3W6C

 Y

ŽDCZŸC267$.PCO-BNDG5RS H+6-  ƒ 7G*W[WY.\'i!

Q"U.+$.Q"U.+="

k2@GI 9:o7>hAB! O YPCXv2ÅV‘.X_.0$Hnh‹"6C2•7…uvH+E7'8: Y J " D!FYE_.miV`a2b10e*…u"$.ABIDC!:k¬2#aDFh/"[^. ‰.miL."T7'.*W[WY.\'i4Q"U.+$.

Q"U.+=3N"=DC‹+o7$.ji"ÅV9´C5c2'?2@BI*B+F[^._<-,3W'V.0eq7UHiV`a2b*->a9]%#hDCZŸC26Yd-BN*W[WY.\'i4Q"U.+$.Q"U.+=3"s`”"UPC

O-BŸ$.DG5Rœ.DG0$.H+6-7G;a*W[WY.\']."!# _kxW&BVq7UPF[7$.®:$.DCd-BN*W[WY.\'i!Q"U.+$.Q"U.+="H+&:oW'AB‹"6CZ2…uvABIDC*W-$2Å

H2E>$.!v2ÅV‘."d7$.H+&R"G2•W$i_H‘Vd-BN!Q"U.+$.Q"U.+="H+C+#G?.vš=9@hI2C"3BH+•….+G“•@6=k·6-$.W&h“•W&BHI.+•….+G“•@6=·6-$..´b

9EX=Vu5E7CdE$.+&6¶DC“•7W[WY.\'i9@hI*W[WY.\'iDEFG2•C."T7'._10¨Vk*#G5,$.Hnh26FDCdC"T7>C*W[WY.\'i4Q"U.+$.Q"U.+=3DEFGHI

f27‡2B4kv2ÅV‘.9=2)IV96;7'l$m*$+•>=_9…‘Vf2@Gi10ek*,#3$.Ø|\h.HI ‰.m27'I8*W&bQu.vi‹’B‘."s“  ƒ &Bx7-&„HI.Vuv2-GL2W#&$€+&>=V26Y8

Z2b½$.d7$.H+#o7&Gk2¨HIV.+&C267G9´^2=PCZ2b½$.5R‘.d7$.HV267Y“•6C_.mi2C9FB*-&,$.10¨k*oW:3$.‡V.V5´6-7G9EX=P'.V."…dE$H+EY*->a

Q"W…DC“~ŸB2;YPC?2@BIDG5RS DC;a*p;$.Žk2•3WU"[W'*-&,$.Hš=“•'uv 

!Ž Hid-BN*W[WY.\'i4Q"U.+$.Q"U.+=39EX=PFH+C+#W'?.vš=9@hIDCv2ÅV‘..miH2bU

8: Y J "D! O YE ^ !:VI;! Y J " ^ !:VI;!Y ^ !:VIB ^ !L;!_Hi9FÚ ¦2>—. .0e  DG"h.+$. DC ®› PF u+@— *[W7a d…m+F3$. z›‘. D„.+^. *…uv 8 *,W>-$. Qv2Gž$.

v"r._<o&^. 5¡aI 9W›2;7$. DC "GžF&$VI_Ž

Page 85: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 85/248

 <=>9 ?#@2A/=4&BC /=4&B%&D  EBF#G& E#-%< H&#

H2b ‰2G"¯_8‹2´^.dFs5$./0$.123Xs2ak+7&$Û27o7'*b½$.d7$.‹+o7Y+oa*W[WY.\'i4Q"U.+$.Q"U.+=3ji*->a9*c2^2=%#hDC2~ŸC26YPC*b}5RI*¨2XC

dE$H.56XYQv26>$2=’)‘Ÿ:UAB*›5hHV267&$_q7UZ26F[7$.9s‘.’[UH+EY*GuVµ2C"3BPs+7GHI5®7>YZŸC267$.

27sVk‹+„IVI2C"3BNH+EG9C2B“:¸.d3Cž$.6.2+ _.)RT-VS [(RST1 .-b."…_

L."T7'2=V>;Y¥2W#C“:¸.AŽABu"s<&6Y5C‘.1"W>[7=Ã5;$?2#&$.k*Wa2” |\h.HI%'+7C‹+„*-6&$.+ed7c2C*&#a*#=2,7CPCA G M""79$Ž_810ek*$2—.q7U9B2;7$."U.+$.DCO=k§$IPCL"T7>C*W[WY.\']4Q"U.+$.Q"U.+=3x$V;a

E;7$.VIk*W&#6$.H+EW'2Wh2b*W[WY.\'Š$dE$L+#Yf2W7…2=‡2BDC–2-YIu"®$.“c."$.?@@ >_q7UV%'+7F=‹+„*-6$Z.mO7&#a%#hG A:_9ŽkHnh/I?Õ

"GžGAB   ÜZŸB2;7$.d7$.L+#G2¨+-BN!Q"U.+$.Q"U.+="PC–.+a‘.Z.mE;7$.kx=2X^.H+EW'2Wh2bf2[3$kf2W7…N.u+•ÇVHV267$._

HiL+•;Cf2W7…N.AB"GÑP  ƒ FDEFGHIt ƒ56   G9EX=k<Wsv<  ƒ -,   GVAB*GI *W[WY.\'i_|\h.HI€23e ‰*W[WY.\'i ‰*W&›IL+#GPWFr.2-G5#Yk2•C."T7'2=“”`&›V*B+F¯Q®›DCv.5h‘.DG0$.H+C"T7>G*W[WY.\'ikQ"G"…`&B2;YVPC

9bDCDG"h.+$.v"r.kDG5Rœ.O3„.+^.VOW&›‘._Hi*->a9B2;7$./0$.L+#Gx=v5hL"T7>G*W[WY.\'iQ"G"…PCv5h5RS L"T7>G*W[WY.\'].Q"G"r.2@GIde

 YŽ_ABV|.\h.HIOCv2#$.v"r.“ekQu"3$.*au2#CPCH2E>$.kOW&›‘.HnhPW™ZŸB2;YH2E>$.OW&›‘.2-G5#YH+E7'PC“•W3„.+CDCH2E>$.OW&›‘.DG5Rœ._

Hi%'+7C*…uvLv2#$."G"r.de‹"6CZ2…u"$.*'2#^.2^9:KxW&B.0eLv2#$.

"G"r.DCx&B2;YPCLv2s"G"…k5RS 2CV9:KxW&BLv2#$."G"r.DC9B2;7$.PC"UI H2E>$.OW&›‘._WG2#^.Vdeu.5EYDG0ekO”"—./I YŽV!F YŽABx…V"G"o7$._DC*WU23$.k5R‘.Hnh%'+7C*…uvD„.+^.z›‘.*#=2,7C ‰2-G5#YPC2C

9:KxW&BD„.+^.DC9B2;7$.PCD„.+Ck5RS ’=HIDG"h.+$.HVuv2a."…_«F>GV.0e‹N"7'N.Ý2>—.?5F&$Hš=(737>GHIPFDG"h.+$.v"r.DEFGHIf27¶

Page 86: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 86/248

&$ "#$%& '()&*+,#-.%& /012

H2E>$.kOW&›‘..mi2CL2s?NŒeHV"h.+$.?.vš="W…PCDG"h.VkDG5RS .miV2Cq#7$.HV"h.+$.v"r.“•@6-=·6-$.9EX=u5E7C"!#_

¹UNHI.0e|\;GHš=H.\sN.dc23´$.8ZŸB2;7$.W$2Wc.+XB_d;hH.\sN.kdc.+X6$.DCuv23$.HId#7&G"h.+$."G"r.."h.V5RS _N"=VDCkl$mHnh

L+•;CPF[7$.9C26G*$2—.d7$.H+EG2•WhHV"h.+$.v"r.*->a*,W>=DC%W¼

H2E>$.kOW&›‘.W$V*->a*,W>=DC%W¼DG"h.+$.v"r.“•>;aI_O-YV*[W73$.*W$27$.HIZ2W[WY.\'].de5´b‘.Q?2;b8f2W7….*W[WY.\'i

u"®$.“c."$.?@@ >Ž9sš=u"sDEyDCZ26F[7$._l&YdeZ2W[WY.\'].5´b‘.Qu"sABžWWF7$.O=2•>;aO=Vu"®$.“c."$.?@@ >Ž_H+EY*W[WY.\'].PS(JJYZ[

\]<P5U^.mi2C`C2s85RS t2,^.HV267$2=q7U+$‡HV267Gt5,$.5Rœ."—kHœ.2CVHIkHV267Y2)nhD$HV267Y*Wa2”PC*W[WY.\'iu"®$.“c."$.?@@ >Žk

2•3E$VHV2677'’c.vPCMBN5RS L"T7>G;a*W[WY.\'].d7$.2•C"T7>Y_

PJQ6;%&$

ÎHiZ2W[WY.\'].d7$.PW,7>Yf2W7….*W[WY.\'iu"®$.“c."$. ?@@ >ŽAB9E¾kPF9sš=V*FWs*3Ey ³$ YŽkdel&Y*GžWWF7$.jiÉsIk*…uv*W[WY.\'nb4Q"U.+$.Q"U.+=3_

DC9•>$.HI5aHI4Q"U.+$.Q"U.+=3de*W[WY.\'i*GžWW¿jiÉsI*…uv_d•hHV267Y8*&#3$.jV‘.k2C2¿DE$V2CHIHV267YPC*W[WY.\'iu"®$.“c."$.?@@

>Žk2)nhD$HV267Y2•6CQ5C5RIABŸ„]._DC*WU23$.k5R‘.H+EW'2¤%R5F7>CÅVP,#3CDCHV267$.PCMBN5RS L"T7>G*W[WY.\'i4Q"U.+$.Q"U.+=3_

.0$Hnh4

Q"U.+$.Q"U.+=3

Q"W…."…8*W&FBžWWF7$.O=2•CI+YO=V*W[WY.\'iu"®$. “c."$.?@@ >Žk«F>YV10e*W›2¸.2¤f2W7…2=‡2B!v2ÅV‘."9sš=PFDEy2•3C_

 !Ž "GžF&$<o&^. 5¡aI 9W›2;7$. DC¦_Ž

Page 87: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 87/248

 <=>9 ?#@2A/=4&BC /=4&B%&D  EBF#G& E#-%< H&!

’3W=f\#GPF[7$.*W$S ?"-$HV267$.8‡2BDC!v2ÅV‘."k+ef5,Gl$0b‹.Œ'2C.miH2bE6$.2oWo›VI23Ey"6=HI«-:Y*W[WY.\'i ³b!Q"U.+$.Q"U.+="*7=2”

*>'ŒCV2~.0=_8kPs.+$."…+G23eÛm+FaÔe"C(•-CV."…DCL"B5Ç237$._9…‘Vkx7h56C5b07'.§G56Y*W[WY.\'].P;JR_%&2•;›+=l&Yd7$.NH+EY‹VI

  *W[WY.\'nb kDGuv2®$.!Q"U.+= Q"U.+$."_H27W[WY.\']. 9B2;7Y 2C"3B xaI «4.+$. DC

kH27;W,&$.’)nhHŸ:ºABQšh2E^.5 

Ž89bk*&#adeVABI*…uv*,'+7CDEFG HI9:K2•W&B?5^.2C"3B9B2;7GPCv5h5RS L"T7>G*W[WY.\'].2~.m_.0eV23W,6G*W45;$.*W$27$._

PJQ6;%&!+.mi‡DEGDCDEF^.v5;&$"U.+$.HIf27¶*W[WY.\'].k*;W,&$.NPW,7>Gq7UPF[7$.HI96;Gl$m_

Hi*…u"$.d7$.9:º2•W&B*W[WY.\'].d7$.0RšY9E¾PF[7$.de‹"6^.¥2#^.O3”NDC9C.+6$.*a+E^.2ÌVÎ*W;Wb9FB10e*W[WY.\'].2•c.vIVPC

DG5Rœ.DG0$.H+6-7G;ak*W[WY.\'].*W;WbV2•c.vIPC*W[WY.\'].*3FW•^._Ÿb DG0eO&C26$.H2a ƒ+EG9sIDC*…u"$.d7$.9:º2•W&B*W[WY.\'].*;W,&$.k*3FW•^.VIOGV2>C2¤_k.0$.mi‡DEG23Eyv5;&$"U.+$.HIf27¶*W[WY.\'].*;W,&$.

k*3FW•^.DFhÅDEF^.q7UZ26F[7&$HI2•U27_  15•¡   Y /0$. zEW¤. §6    @$. AB /+7º N *;W,&$. "B.+#$. HI Û2737'N. .0e d36GV

*W[WY.\'iu"®$.“c."$.?@@ >Ž_DEFGV*W[WY.\']u"®$.“c."$.?@@ >ŽHILV2#Yf2W7…N./0$.L+#Yx=*GI*W[WY.\'i2^2„H2bH+-BŸ$.DG0$.H+C"T7>G

Z2W[WY.\'i5RIH+pW¶kv.5h."U.V89bQ5C_DE$V.mi2C.V?2…AB9E¾ Z26FQ®› Z26F `a2b +$ q7UŽk“c."$. u"®$. *W[WY.\'i Hnh?@@ >ŽDEFGHI|567Yf2W7…Ÿ$_2CIPC"B.+#$.k*;W,&$.HnhP4+$.§&7‚_.mi`a2bQ"B2#$.*;W,&$.PW,7>Y*CV2#Cf2W7…N./0$.x  ƒ 3XY"B.+s*;W,$5RIªšYkv.5hQ"U.+$.+&Y

k5R‘. ‰.mi2•6'+=HILV2#Yf2W7…N./0$.L+#Yx=kZ26F[7$.tÂ=5¡3$.DBx7C2>…_.0$"B.+#$2h*;W,&$.DEFGHIdFº2•>;aI*#G5,=Nu"#G2•W&Bv2ÅV‘._

Page 88: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 88/248

&& "#$%& '()&*+,#-.%& /012

“cŸ7YV10e(c273$.PC2•@6=d,67$Qu+›*&>&>7C*6=277CQšX3$HV267$.1u ƒ+,YV_8V*$2U‹2´^.doW4+7$.DB&¯kÞ+WX$.Ø 3  ƒ W=*W45;$.*>C2¸.xaIHV"=

Z26FVI·6=Z2W$œ.*W->3$.ŽkHnh%F3$.z›‘.±*a2WT&$²*$v2-7^.NDEFGM&®7$.xW&B_’=uH+EY10eZ26F[7$.*G"#3$.Q5E-^.*W3-CVIQ"37>CABZ2B+F¯Q®›DCO&´F^.DG0$.H+XW6G26C8L2>sI*W&R.vDE>&$8*F›26$.Q"G"r.

‹ŸRÂBH+'5;W…Ùa+G!"77Ž

_VI’=uH+EYv+hVZ2GN+$.v+hVV¦.žUI*GN+$. 5´bI.v2#7a.$u2CV ß+=!"#9Ž_«4+Y*W45;$.*6=2>$.xaI2CHI“7GW'šYHV267$.d3-^.ABk‹v2-7$.xa2ECn-hHIq#-G27=2”q7U+$HI26FDCDG"h.+$.v"r.‡L\K.0e

t56$./u+Y23W>$._v5[F=VHI'š7G%F3$.kÈv2-7$.HnhO7W45;$.*Wa2´$.*´$2´$.VH23W-YxaI5#7>Ck ‰2WB2™2^2„HI‹"6CÈ2™i*b5—./0$./5¶9bOC2B6*+ 0.+VV.(/

S-1VT`+1 W$.-b."…_.0$HnhHV267$.DEFGHI5•¡Gq7U8‡2BDCu"®$.ŬV½^._NDEFG

*WF37&$HIJ"º.mi2C‹V2U·6=v.5h‘.DG5´6-^.23e€23eVL2W#$.k2¨DG0$.V`>W$

“•C2CI*GI*›5h9B2;7&$PC“•@6=·6-$._DE$VDEFGHV267&$HI5•¡GDC Z26FQ®›DCv.5h‘.DG0$.kHVžW  ƒ F   G2^2„H2b"$?NŒev.5h‘.+$V*->aQ®›DC.0e9B2;7$.PC“•@6=·6-$._*h24]2=jikl$m.mi2CL2sPWFr.2-G5#Yd3-7=

Z2W[WY.\'].*;W,&$.l&Yd7$.NH+EY‹VIDCu"®G."=IŽk.miHnh?NŒev.5h‘.DEFGHI.+a+EG?2C5b89C267$.PC/Iv5h5RS _DCV‹ŸR9C267$.9EX=D>UPC

“•@6=k·6-$.DEFGPF7[F&$2E>$.H ƒ+E^.DC"B.+#$.*;W,&$.HIdFKx>;a"4Z26Fv.5h‘.DG0$.H+C"T7>G*GI*W[WY.\'i5RI2^2„H2bx6'+=HIdFKx>;a

"4v.5h‘.v2Uœ.Os5;7^._DE$VDC9…IHIH+EY*W[WY.\'].*;W,&$.Q5#7>C

q36^2=kd6Fr.N"=DCHIH+EY*&=2sQu2´7'Ÿ$_.0$HnhHV267$.‹v2-7^.DEFGHI 5•¡G8‡2BDCOWa2a‘.HV"=Q5,W'k*Gžb5CDC‹ŸR?"-$.PF[7=DCv.5h‘.DG0$.HV"F76GAB‹v2-7$._

*GÖ5$V"C*6'V<W-,Y10ek(c273$.§XEW'23$HŸ:;$.H2Cv2#$.DB·6=ZN2—.d7$.u+,YHV267$.2•Wh9EX=z6h_*$2—.jV‘.d7$.u ƒ+,Y2•WhHV267$.de8

Page 89: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 89/248

 <=>9 ?#@2A/=4&BC /=4&B%&D  EBF#G& E#-%< H&'

DCwk¦5—.“Å5$2=DC?."6$.5G5^.O=O-BŸ$._2CI*$2—.*Wa2´$./+,37hAB*F¡aI*Wc2WUIH+EY2•WhZ2a.+W—.qav‘.ÅQuv2sABOF´YZ26-Y2~.u2W7R._ ƒO-YV10e

ZN2—.xaI2C"3BH+EYtV5¡$.*oWo›k*WY.+CVDEFGHV267&$HIu+,7G+F3GVHVv*…2—.ji*s.":$.VIÂ-7$.9-#7>^2=_

 

Page 90: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 90/248

'( "#$%& '()&*+,#-.%& /012

 

Page 91: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 91/248

 

!  "#$% "  

+,-% #.&'()*

  0*$1

Page 92: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 92/248

!" "#$%&'()'%*+,-. /0 12%34 5/3. 5/(67'%

 

Page 93: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 93/248

8(9:;<=6> ?,@ AB/ <CDEF/G% 1=H(6'% IJK% E L(7M'% NB(OP !#

 

2&34"56'7 8,9 :;# 5<#=;&>? @ 

A#B* /6C&')* DEF* @ G&(H)* 

$%&'()*+,-./0+1(*234.52367+89,':3;<=> ? @AB$C.D2E*+-.FG)4.HI*JD%KL.D21$M-.*3NOPQ*+EDR S)$OTOUV;Q*,O;DW2W8TOXQ4.<TY-)Z1[W\FPQ*+E.U1],3F*^>_/0+1TJ*O4.`$_4.aR=9bcd.ef-.

gWK'7-9bDhijk l>2O/*jI$AF*Y2mW1)no*R*O(*Jo9pVq.:R4.(9rQi' l*O.s,-.  l69t+O<:tAu36c1*v(*JQ;w*x'$1/D-9Vy*8*z/{o*p_=*,t-.7I;|

U} ~•D&3>Eo9pL.(*E4.€})(9-9m,'Tv`:O‚O$-.ƒW_{o*p_ €%,%KV<.:1)aR*p-*VQ€„;….9%K,p'[-f-<†Q$tA/e S‡(;ˆW@,ITO.f}‰9p-.TOq*2Š4.*O:pR€  S Wj,I‹Œ89E.•6Žij-.U‘1’f}q*2Š4.<q6“%A

Fy9t-.iJF):K'6(9W+'(;[-*p}B$3n$,jO<(*J>JZA$x-.iJ):K'(*pO“'Dr*2j1!” ? R‰o)P–”2+'<"—U':–)o"#$%˜ F<#&™<

 

Page 94: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 94/248

!$ "#$%&'()'%*+,-. /0 12%34 5/3. 5/(67'%

…TY'.f} l6*‘O l>š›pO<:tA(*Jy*&I!” ? R‰o)P–”2+'" l*pb9,jO/{o*p_=*,t-.<:8).$}oœaR€–$-.TOUA;o9%L.‚,-.*^f1Q*KJž*K-.7A*t'Ÿ

D-9W2C.)F7I)oaR)€–$-.TOƒb.9+-.‚,-.*}‘'F=*,t-.€–$-*1)TOxpE.e$Yj+-.ef-.=9t'|"U,8;);U  ¡ ,t  ~ \#FaR)€–$-.TOD-9%j-.‚,-.TR*%t'$bHI*J

no*2t-.Œ2x,j\(;Œt\D';o9%VD2W¢Ž2\£W-DI:  ~ ^n¤*KO<

(’f}‚}D-*3TO()*+,-.ef-.†$%¥aR€–$-.TOD2h.:+-.*OZ1ZKR>-.< aR).f}F9¦p-.‚%Ay S:t\*':§2Kx,-€2}*›E.D'$&p-.)‚,-.€\*}$'9x\/=9š›-.D¨>‘-.Dt1*j-.<(©:^.ª2h$-.9}y.:@,r.D'$&p-.j›,-*O«'aR)7V)

˜9šd.|"<ƒ2JHI*JD'.:1y*&I'” ? R‰o)P–”2+'"¬%<ƒ2JH7,O.o®*›C.)¬72WR$<.•*EQ*„..f}y*&p-.*O:pR†o*JB$C.(;Œ\¬*}Q.œ);&<.•*E(*J.f}y*&p-.DrB$C{o*pd./B$C.D2E*+-.FG)4.()o(;

$%&'6 l>2W8/‘Y-.TOB)$C.¬`$_4.*O;©:^.w*‘-.9%Ay.:@,r.D-*C.D2¯Q°,-..£86D2›2Jy*2t-.Œ2r9,1€2}*›E.D'$&p-.)D2W±4.<

TjC)FuC.(²ADr.QoD‘':3€m¦1B*,JUO*JTRy*&I!” ? R‰o)P–”2+'"n$A9,O l*2-*3<:,+').f}U+-.Œh.$-.…*+-‰i,V6.w*x'³-.w9\´Q9Šµ 

—"#()™aRUh*rQ†.$JfOFD2O9'†*'$J•)TRZW\*tE./{o*pd.<iJH+  ~ ¶o.9E. TOUJ{$›-.D2I*x'³-.ŒKj-.Zjk)F l*K'$t\=:+1*O:'s'aR$‘J;TOD¨>¨Qo*šOTOUJD8$A<iJFH+  ~ ¶TY-)`:1FU8;0+1o.9E.TOQo*šOD2I*E;D2jI$A)*';

€\)·*p¸,r6.*z<HI*J)Dm2,p-.DO9&pOD2p–TOQ9š-.D2¦2v9,-.‚,-.€\*%W2W§nQ*%1nKJA9,-nQ9±DWO*ŠQ9x,-=*,8{o*pd.7\ir)/D%KL.D21$M-./B$C.

Page 95: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 95/248

8(9:;<=6> ?,@ AB/ <CDEF/G% 1=H(6'% IJK% E L(7M'% NB(OP !%

D2E*+-.G)4.<:,+')*pWšA.f}aRB*,J´Q9Šµ €  S 2t-.TO523†*r*K,86.D2¦2v9,-.j›,-.)‚¯Q*,-.<

ip21)… S³+'´Q9Šµ TR$O4.’fzFDt'$x-.(²Aƒ89E.‚¯Q*,-.†*R*xtW-Dho*^.aR=9bD%KL.D21$M-.(*JDW+OZmrnQ$Y,O</Q*bŒ89E./.$ML.

Fo:¦E.TY'Q*K,R.ZKR>-.Z\:3)Z,'$YjR7V.9\*¹.:3`$_4.</)e;H8)

TOF†*8)4.(9Y'(.Q*2d.(*3*,E.*¹|Wb;Q*p-.FU,t,-);Wb;Q*p-.UYº1Žpm,' {*C`•4.UYº1):  S +,  ~ O<DKjp-*1)FZA$xW-(9Y'©*+v):+-.D28D%O7I4‚  S p2rq*tK-..•*O†Q:±$O.);Tº1 lDJ$+O lDj2hQ/‰*xt-.<[-f-FŽKj-.(9Y'TO

UA4.aR`:E.Ž'$t-.y*2t-.{*C²1Q»-.(¼.q.9r(*J):+-.o$'aR{>bQ*p-.y;6<=:')[-•aR(;Q:M-.=o*K,E.(9Y'U   S A;TOu›¦,-.eo*34.ŽI*L.

—*+,™F(;)u›¦,-.eo*34.ŽI*L.TO©$x-.$_¼.9}UA;],3TO()*+,-.=o*K,E.—-+. ™<DA*vGF[-•(²An°A*YO:  S 2t,-.=o*K,E.DW   S ›O`:-†.:39-.D2W¦E.

aR½h*,IB*t+-.=o*K,E.—. + *™F*E*b(*JB*t+-.=o*K,E.T,'n*I*+OUJTOZ\:39-.TOUV;ŽjYOU2W8F.:V:8)6ŽjY\ l*¸2ŠaR{>bŸ.<.•)*O*If_;

$O4.F l*+,¾7I²Aªr“'DO9&pE.D2r*r4.y:+-n.)*jE.— |-+.+*+,<™DA*vGF[-•U   S ›  ~ 2r> ? J(*A$x-.u›¦,-.=o*K,E.B)*p,W-‚h.9º+-.=iR¿-D2h.:+-.no*L.F

*ÀU+—- / ,0%+ . ™<.f-ƒ89E*A1*x'©)$¥DW+OZmj-.Z1Z\:39-.Z,'$Yj+-.Z\Mš-.Z,W-.(*%V.9\*¹.:3`$_4./`:3Œb.9t-.D,1*‘-.<

HI*J(*\:39-.(*,'$Yj+-.(*\Mš-.(*,W-.(*%V.9\*¹.:3`$_4.³RDA*jO).£\Z1Dh*OGDhi+1Q;noQ*'TOXQ4.y.$C.*¹ZKR>-./n:3.)TO

†>+OZmj-.DpO*Y-.D,2E.)</Œv9-.FÁ*‘E.TY'Q*K,R.n:39-.D2r*r4. DK2,JDI9YOTOÁ.93ƒ-;FUVQ€%›šIaRž9xd.D2O*O4./e;D&CTOTOs-.<:t-HK+-DK2,Y-..Q)o.KJ/n*23e:pVn*ºE.<‚%A…€&p\*}q*R;UV4=*,t-.

FŽj¦AU1F€%,+b;H+Ao)€^FŽ\.)$-.€%,jJ)Fª1>E*1>ATR€2&p\:2R.9O€Â.œ*V<Œ2¶ž*K-.€&+O)o9pL.T'$_¼./DK2,Y-.(9A$+'€%+1

Page 96: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 96/248

!& "#$%&'()'%*+,-. /0 12%34 5/3. 5/(67'%

0+K-.UYº-*1<*p\*'*M-)FD2-*C.P*p}(>O*R(*2r*r;(>+DK2,Y-. l*KR6 l*2V•9I<TAFD23*IHI*JDK2,Y-.nKJi172AD'*›Y-.U,¦,- l*+b*8 lih>OTOD%KL.³,+,-

"D-)“jO#TR=iR4.D2h.:+-.DOo*t-.TO*%,txpO<TO)D23*p-.F`$_4.HI*JnM±i1‚›Y'(9Y,-nQo*8aRn$x2j-.aRP9Wj-.eo$›-.F*^*V$-TO=>_:':+-.TO

FUh*r9-. r$-.D2 *%pO–)D2r$-.<

TY'DK2,YW-aR:3;ZKI*L.(;(9Y\/D%V.9Oq.sV;TODK2,JFn:3.)); FZ,p¨.);D¨>¨TOŽI*L.$_¼.<.f-(²AUJŽR6TY'(;ž$@p'UYº1‚pO.s\/:':+-.TO†>R*›,-.<aR)Q.:OD%KL.FD21$M-.HI*J†*¸E.TO’f}†*%V.9E.´:§

Z1ZC.$_¼.)<:t-HI*J†.:39-.D'$Yj+-.nMš-.ctA‚}DbQ9,E.†>+1Zmj-.

nQ9JfE.<*O;†.o*2t-.*2W  ~ +-.TOZKI*L.€WAP£º\D%V91$&IDO*Ro9pL.T'f-..9-*8|(ŽKj-.‚t2tC.q.Q)q):}0+1q.sV;c_D%KL.‚} ~7I;…[W,'e;TO

ZA$x-.D2IŒr9,-./[W\DtxpE.†.f-*1<<<.•ŠQ(92I*x'³-.(*E4.F˜*±$-*1oQ F(*E4.(*J)Q»-.*')*j,O|.•)ƒš8(*E4.D+x8DO:t,OTO{:pd.HW,8)DjkF=*VQoQ(92I*x'³-.U1.91TO˜*±$-..9W,8)Djk(*E;<—B9J (9,W21"#"1˜ F2&™

 (*JqÃ-.€}4.DKjp-*1†.$tEno*28”2L.9}$'9x\)$-.D2O9m^.Z1©9›±”2L.<:t-ŒK\.Fq*›WC.aR7V)F˜9šd.D2m2\.£r©.sp,r6.523(;$h*jd.D')*j,E./.)Q4.TOZKI*L.‚p+\ l*KjYO l*2A*±Fq*›W¦W-(4n98(*E4.[%p  ~ ,r l>V*Ry; l>Vµ <F.f-a+A:2+š-.F‚pb9-.H1Q*8B$C.D2E*+-.G)4.TODK+-

½\*p-.e$›š-.‚,-.U‘*%2A$h*j_©$x-.=)4.Žr*YO©$x-.w*‘-.<TY-)aR :2+š-.F«¦E.aR=9bž9xd.FD2O*O4.(*Ju›¦,-.=o*K,E.]tW' l>2›\$‘J;TOB*t+-.=o*K,E.<

.f}HW±.9\)DW+  ~ E.aR:2+š-.«¦E.|‚›AD';D&CDp2+O(*JTODYC.{>bQ*p-.:št1FU,t-.q.9rU+A©$x-.$_¼.[-•y;…U+›'<TY-)*OU+V=*,8

Page 97: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 97/248

8(9:;<=6> ?,@ AB/ <CDEF/G% 1=H(6'% IJK% E L(7M'% NB(OP !'

{o*pd. l*›W,ÄUYº1KJTRPQ*+E.`$_4.9}(;†.:39-.nMš-.*%j›I:8H%V.)*%+10+K-./†*+x8–DWtp,O†.£›-D-9xOTOTOs-.<:t-†   S–’f}

Dt2tC.DK+W-.TODW+OZmj-.†.•DWtp-.n:3.9-.‚,-.(9Y'*%2AQ:M-.9}Q*2d.FT2%E.GDW+OZmrnQ$Y,O(9Y\†*2m2\.£rŸ.Db)ÅE.DpYÀ*%2A<:t-HtA.9\Dm2,p-.ŒO†*+89\D'$&p-.|o9V91UR*›,-.F€':,jE.TY'(;(9Y\Dm2,p-.

D,1*‘-.‚}()*+,-.=o*K,E.‚pKE.aRDj-.D2-o*K,-.<aR)7V)F˜9šd.(²A>J ZA$x-.:8*+K\.†*2m2\.£r6TY'(;(9Y\=);TOFQ:M'*%pY-) Æs›  ¡ ,j  ~ ,r.•*OQ:–©$x-.$_¼.<

UK8:'sE.TOT  S +,-./†*K¨F()*+,-.TO‘E.(;u3>Iƒ2JHI*JD'.:1()*+,-./=);©*xE.<HI*JDW3$E.G)4.TOFB$C.‚,-.)†;:1/$%Š

Bµ Çªxj– ~;TOy*R"#"&F€j,\n$‘Y1F=*t,I6.iJHI*JD'9OoD'*MW-<TY-)*O(;†$t,r.ž9xd.FD2-*,t-.$%¥(.):R>-.Z1o.$A;†.9t-.aR9¦I‚h*tW\/:':+-.

TODpYO4.aR=9bž9xd.D2O*O4.<:8)HI£8.DW‘O4.G)4.ŒO†*KV)y*+x-. ‚,-.HI*Jy È:t  ~ \/ª›I†*8)4.aR‚KI*VXQ4.y.$C.</)T'Å\w*‘-.—³A9I™y*R"#"&Fu36c1*v–X S9›OHI*J7\:3)/{o*pd.D+K-y*';7I;|

=)“jO o*,R.(“E. ŽW (; aR DŠ*RŸ.<<<HI*J ‹y>&-. =9W3 :+1 DW2- UJ*}f_4 D2O*O4. ž9xd. TO q‚mE. aR †o*,R. :8 †*RiL. HI*J) *VQ*_ $x  ~ \<

 ); DR*j-. [W\ / Dho*} Q9O4. HI*J .f- ‹qÃ-. ª›p1 .9WMºI. :8 q.:R4. (; :t,R.$A H¦K±; €¨ TO) FZ,W2W- TOs-. TO Z,R*j-.D¨£YO – D2p'9,-. ˆšC. {

€%+2O*¾ G €Âo9R '$b / (9WY,') (9Y¦' .9I*J U1 F7KKj1<—(QRJC S7'% IJK% 

+(TH% "#$(˜|#%™<

=9W¦1)o*2R;Fo>2E.HI*JP*p}D-*3TOq*_Ÿ.Fƒ2‘Y-.‚})DrQ*ÀHK–;†.$tOno*2t-.</)Q9%º-.FDt3>-.HI*J0+1†*I:^.n¤*KE.€  S &p  ~ \†*¦2š-*1);

†.Q*ŠŸ*1<:8)u36:}*Š(*2R7I;|

Page 98: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 98/248

!( "#$%&'()'%*+,-. /0 12%34 5/3. 5/(67'%

/:3;y*j84.HI*JDR*j-.Z1*ODpO*‘-.D+r*,-.)*3*K±³,+\DššÄ"Q9O¿-D±*d.#FHI*J)0+1b*pE.n¤“E.€W+1³,+\ÉQ*_{*xIy.s,-6.`:-

Z±*pt-.TOZA$x-.<—(*–Q9O"#"1˜ F|%2) #%2"™<TY-)(*R‡*OHI*JX$+,\†*I:^.n¤*KE.ŒtW-<$O.)4*AnQo*š-.U+Ê

TOËv.9-.(;o9pL.:8.)q*V"G*jI$AF=*,tW-ª2-)‚_Ì,W-ŒOq.:R4.#—1U=7V'% 

5(=:/,W(V'% 1XW(Y% "#$1˜ F|%™<$‘J4.)D8>R[-f19}(;:':+-.TOo9pL.:8.9J93 F*'$YjRiJHK89RŽh*,J*%WO*Y1<(*R‡)*OËK±;*¦v.)(;†*K2\£-.D'9›º-.:8ÍH  ¡ + ?   ~ 8D-9%j1Dxr.91†.o*2t-.*2W  ~ +-.H¦K±°AU‘O’f}†*K2\£-.nQo*I´):C.<

TO){$x-.`$_4.‚,-.;:1TO*^>_u›¦,-.F= ¡o*K,  ~ E.‚}[W\‚,-.H¨:3H§¨°\ªtbª2+\<*O:pRHI*JQ*xO4.D¸2rUYº16F{*x'(*JTOU2¦,jE.

  l*K'$t\y*2t-.e°1UR‚h.:R<HI*JDI:^.D2-*ÊQ6.$%&\UYº1‚h*tW\ l*I*23;[-•)ŽKj1ªtx-.FÎ2j-.>Ay9t'o9pL.*%2A{>b²1Q*p-.aR€%+10+K-.<*O:pR)

Tj¦,'F9L.(*JcIu  S ›¦,-.=o*K,E.$,j'Db*jK1< .f-(²A†*8*›\6.D'9›º-.HI*Jn$¨“O/=9šC.aRD'.:1()*+,W-/:':+-.TO†*Kr*pE./H8)$YKO=>_FB$C.TY-)‚_Ì,-.¤*KE..‘J*O(*JŒt  ~ '

D-9%j1<aR)`:E.F:2+K-.HI*JP*p}:':+-.TO{$x-.DR9p,E.$‘J4. l.¨°\‚,-.)H¦rZA$xW-2jp,1i^*+A;()oq9mW-.G†iWY-.<(*J)UO*+-.ª2h$-.9}

P.Qo7I;.•y*8:3;ZA$x-.DrQi1 l*R9I l*p2+OTOFu›¦,-.*%p23:8UO*+,'©$x-.$_¼.U‘E*1<(7V);7Kº-./†*V*C.†*b*ºp-.)D2r*r4.HW+Vo9pL.(9p¯(;

©$x-.$_¼.i1Q6ŒK,'D2m2\.£rQ:M-.–ž)ÅE.<a+AU2KrF=*‘E./ƒ2±

y*R"#"3F`;Qe:pV(;):+-.U,  ~ Ï(;UO*+,'U‘E*1=o*K,')()*+,-.‚pKE.aR DK–$-.=9šC*1aRˆš3DI)“E.DVœ*x-.<(9Y2r>R l*2-9›b l*ºh*b(;Š$\˜*±$-*1'$x-.Œ8.9-.ƒW_{o*p_

Fq.:R4.ef-.)6:1(;(9Y'*ÐosO†>m+1{.œQ;o9pL.†*1$R)F’*2E./D'³-.DV»E.q*O:-*1<<<TY-)UYº1Fy*R[-*p}H±</)D'*„F©*xE..•*O ¡H+  ¡ p  ¡ O

Page 99: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 99/248

8(9:;<=6> ?,@ AB/ <CDEF/G% 1=H(6'% IJK% E L(7M'% NB(OP !!

P):RTOŽWV7,I)“OF78.œQ;)(9Y2jA7V>R>%r|•[+p2rTO=9šC.aR[šš3TODI)“E. l*';<—e*}"#"1˜ F|%%&Ñ%%3™<*O(;:K\D2m2\.£rŸ.D2pKE.aRF=o*K,-.*„²AÅ,p,r{$x1no:+,O<(u›¦,-.

f  S @,E./†*R*rDp2+OTY'(;:,'G†*R*r=9b;<o9t2r)‰9IZ+OTO†*&›¦,-.GŽ'$ʉ.9I4.`$_4.<€}4.)TO[-•F7WJ(;y:t,-.smpE./‰*x8

M±aRD%KL.TY'(;:  S Wt  ~ 'TOUK8†.:39-.`$_4./†*R*xt-.nQ)*mE.<HI*J)©)$&-.‚,-.H¦rDO.o²1()*+,-.ª›p1D2¹;7->%,r.<HI*J

†*2m2\.£rŸ.‚,-.TY'(;€':\()*+,-.=o*K,E.‚}†*2m2\.£rŸ.DW1*t-.œ.s›,r>-<=>@A†.£Au›¦,-.F=o*K,E.U§:pVq.:R4.DtºO*'Dt2t3€„;(9+2x,j'y*t,I6.(ŽV9,r.$O4.<a+AU2KrF=*‘E.$%¥;(9±*pt-.(*E4.€ÂQ*%O

D2-*+-.Z2I*x'³W-TO=>_:':j,-.aR0+1ž*tp-.aR(.Q:VÒ.9J4.Ž'9š,-.)‚O$-.)*%2WR],3(9J£'*19t¨/(*YE.—+(TH% (QRJC S7'% IJK% "#$(˜ F|#(™<aR)ª›I

FQ.$ ? M-.(*Jo9pVD2+A:E.no*R*O(9p2K'†*8>b²1DW2W8no:jOD8:1Dth*A7I;€%pY' .)o.Q; *O .• Q»-. TO :'sE. {*C<D2O*t,I6. †.Q:tW- †*v.$+,r6. ’f} †:R*r :8)aRDK8.$Oy*&p-.TO=>_Q*%¥(;u›¦,-.ª2- l*¶*ITRFƒ+v(;)Q:M-.o9t2rGU  ¡ º  ¡ ›-.Ó.f-.<

*O:pR) ¡Œ  ¡ 8)Q:M-.FU+ ? ›-*1.‘J*O(*Jy*t,I6.³J;*À9}Œ89,OTOUK8D2m2\.£r'n:3.9-.n:3.914<•HI*Jn:3.9-.FZ,p¨*1);n:3.9-.F´>‘1‚}D1*m,r6.D+h*º-.U+›W-ef-.]x@,'o):3*O(*J³,+' l69KtO<

*pJÉ$@I>2-y*O;{o*pd.<<<HI*J)Œ2O*¾(*E4.DWO*+-./ÉQ*d.F*';.f- …TY':+'TOD8*2W-.—H2Y\Ÿ.™(;WxIQ*p-.<(q*2Š4.nQft-. l>+A‚}U1*pt-.‚,-.*%Aft\D28:pK-.<<<•*%pY'(;U,t\D2Ii¨);nÅRo9pV.•*OH+8)U_.o{:pd.<<<*ppY-)…y:@,jI*pW1*p8.:1;*O…ËKš'(*E4.ZK_*±UYº1F˜*_Žj¦1)€%O*&I

/Fo$-.]tW,I€%pO´>¨U1*p8TRUJDWKp8*%tWxIT¦I<—U'9p'$–"#2%˜ F|"1 #"2™<

Page 100: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 100/248

)** "#$%&'()'%*+,-. /0 12%34 5/3. 5/(67'%

TOU,¦E.7I;HI*JP*p}D2WRc2K‘\FDW±°,Ono*R)*OHI*JŒp†*O*t,I6.TO(;eo9\GQ.$Y\–U1*8n$x2jW-TO†*O*Â6.no*E.<TO)TYE.(;u3>'

©$x-.ef-.U+Š;U2,AU+›-.D1*m,r6.:R*š,E.>A=)*Ï(;:2+'*%,›R*OGZ›+-.);D¨>¨©*+v;<o$m1)(;6{*jp':2+š,-.F.:2+17I²ATOU,¦E.(;

U2'G=>¦v6.<*E*b7I;Hj2-UJD8>b);DWKp8);D›'f8HtWb;UYº1:+,O

Ž2š,rF*%A:}(9Y2rP*p}U2OU±°,O9¦Iy:R:2+š,-.< TO)†>YºE.`$_4.‚,-.H%V.)®*›C.aRQ.$t,r.()*+,-.‚}DWYºO$'):\†.9t-.<‚›AUJD2Ii¨y*';F*K'$t\y9t\DK2,J*O2M,1*%+8.9OŒODK2,J`$_;

Œv9,\*%›W_<aR)†.£AF=9b;y9t\†.:39-.nKY-.2M,1TJ*O4.<(*O ¡Ër()*+,W-(°1]tK' l.$t,jO9}D2WRƒ-Ì,-.‚,-.*%O:t\n:39-.nQo*ME.n:39W-DOo*t-.<

€,2AË2v9\U2±*›\€}*›,-.$  ~ E.ŒO):+-.<–7I;/0+1(*234.(*JTO€h>E.  l.:VDKjp-*1q*O:tW-(;.)³¯ZOo*t-.o:L.(°1":2j-.Ãr91Ô‚})nQ*KRDp2%  ~ O

HI*Jy:@,j  ~ \nQ*ŠÕ-G(*E4./B$C.D2E*+-.G)4.Öª2- l>2Oœ l*¸2r<.•²A7,J$\7I°Š)[J£2r[I°Š)#—˜ F(9W2–|22™<:t-Ër.f}ƒ-Ì,-.‚Ri,V6.n:39W-

D'$Yj+-.(;ƒtW,\DK+W-.*%W±.9\)TOi‘23*%J$\$_¼.<TO†>YºE.`$_4.‚,-.7V.9\DO.oQ.$t,r.()*+,-.‚}Dt2t3(;o9pV

D2+A:E..9I*JU8; lDv$  ~ Ry*t,I6):+-.TOo9pVn*ºE.<F[-f-(²AD2+A:W-Dš3U8;/y*&I'”R‰o)P–”2+'4<Dm2,I)F[-f-U2'n*ºE.G(;.9I9Y'$‘J; l*jV9\

*tW8)TOo9pV:±$-.ZO:t,E.TOD2+A:E.<iJu36:3;=*VQD2+A:E.(*E4.TRn*ºE.7I;".•HI*J€×:-D';D+b;D2%ŠFn:h.œ€„²A(9O:t'*p-D':}F*%pOŽKj-.)

/[-•o9+'UYº1‚hsVG€}Q9+Š*pI°1TOy9t'€%,'i¦1#—”\*1s-9r"#2$˜ F2"™< (*J©:^.TO[-•9}Œ2mº\o9pVD2+A:E.aRP$\B>Y-.Dh*p-.Dh*I<(*J)e:pV:±$-.‚+A:E.:':L. l.‘J*OUKt  ¡ ,j  ~ 'ŽWx-*1Á*,-.|"UO°I[I;T-(9Y\=);

TO;:K'nQ*¨²1DWYºE.<#(*J)B.9L.Á*‘E.9}|"F>J*O….9K–$\Z7:0[-f1#—´Q9Šµ "#()˜ F|"1#™<ªY+').f}Q):-.É)osE.=*V$-D2+A:E./DO.ou  S ›¦,-.=o*K,E.ŒO

Page 101: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 101/248

8(9:;<=6> ?,@ AB/ <CDEF/G% 1=H(6'% IJK% E L(7M'% NB(OP )*)

q.:R4.|"D2KWj-.#*O:pR6(9v$+,'Fœ.s›,r>-)"o$-.‚O*t,I6.Œ'N-.#*O:pRy9t'):+-.P*%,I*1€Wj-.<

HI*J†.o*2t-.*2W  ~ +-.Ø92mW-D2I*x'³-.D2jI$›-.)D2I*E4.)*%+2¶‚MK\:C.TO’f}†*I:^.n$  ~ E.‹*%h*„)€%+2mA.9I*J(9º¯TO0'9t\)$-.D'9p+E.

`:-F€^*VQ€%+2¶).9I*J():t,+'7I;=>_B$C.(9Y\Dr*2j-.D2O9m^.

DKv*M-.n$,jE.‚}Dt'$x-.n:239-.2t¦,-Ùp-.<(*JŒr91†.$tOFno*2t-..:R*O 0+1†.q*p‘,r6.FDW2Wt-.(;X$›\D';$O.);*%pY'©.¤Ÿ.*%2WRUYº1¤*KO<F.f-HI*J†.$tE.nQo*8aRq.$VPQ*+OnKJTO=>_q*xR$O.)4.=*V$W-(°1

.9J£'€%8o*p_n$b*@E.)€Â*2¦1³RD¶*%OŒ8.9Oq.:R4.<TY-)Z1PQ*+E.FnKY-.…TY'€}Q):t1DK8.$O$O.)4.*%,+1*,O)TOUV;DW±.9OcM-.!""<aR)

UJF=*3(*JTOŽ+š-..:VaRe;Úc1*vy:8;(;o:Ïe:pL.ef-.(*J‚O$':št1FU,t-.TO)ef-.‚O$'9})ˆ'$3UJ˜$C.aReo*›\y*t,I6.<ËK±;o9pL.q.³_/ŽWM,-.aRy*&IFDK8.$E.iJ9}=*C.ŒOn:39-.‚,-.HI*Ju›,§D›W1

TOP>r;F):+-.Ur$\)D+x87pOG$tOno*2t-.iWJHKWbn_4.>2-oHK‘'€„;.9O*8†*'Q):1‰>x,r./XQ4.y.$C.<

(*O$  S Ooy*&I!”R‰o)P–”2+'"/D'*%p-.9}Djr“OTO‰9I(.):+-.F$,jE.‚,-.)(*JTOU%j-.aR†.$tOno*2t-.*%,K8.$O<HI*J’f}Djr“E.‚}

FnQ*M-.‚})y9m} S:+O UYº128oaR{o*p_q.:R4.T,'TOnÅR=*VQG‚,h*O>VQ<HI*J)$O.)4.n*x+E.T'MW-‚}(;.9W,t');.)‡°'):+-./$tR

’Q.o<.•HI*JnQ*M-.FD¦V*I€,'f_;‹`‡4.*O;.•*OF   ÍHW ? ºA(9Y,jA†*1*±Ÿ.

TO]3$Va,8)‚}U2-:-.aR€%O*28D-)*¦E*1<…TY\P*p}Dt'$bDWR*Aq*RoÕ-(°1

 —"™ T  S k´Q9Šµ —"#()˜ F|"2" #"23™y*&I (!”2+' P ~– ‰   ¡o) ”  ¡ R"5W¨ Á.93 / 7t2Kx\ €\ :8

D2I*x'³-. {$›-. *z HO*8 ‚,-. {o*pd. †69V<

Page 102: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 102/248

)*" "#$%&'()'%*+,-. /0 12%34 5/3. 5/(67'%

nQ*M-.:8†smI;ip21…´:Ï[-•/XQ;Œ8.9-.<iJ…TY\P*p}DW2r)DWR*A()*+,W-ŒOq.:R4./nQ*M-.5236o9pL.q*234.6)5‘Va,t-.TY'*^o*K\<

…Œx,j'y*&I!”R‰o)P–”2+'"(;]Ši,'ŒOÛ9›-.ef-. ~7,K  S Kr†*¸E.nMš-. †.Q*M-. TO< l*t36 ´:¦2r *O Œ89\ aR l.Qo*8 ZA$x-. TO e; TY' … FnQ*M-. :+1)<

©$x-*Aef-.Q*–;(*JŒ89,'Fy*t,I6.7pY-)…TY'7+r91(;©$+'],O);T';);

ƒ2J<*O;©$x-.ef-.X$+\nQ*MW-(*YA l.$\9,OF*';…)©$+'*O.•HI*JnQ*M-. †im^. TO DWjWr / G)4. ‚} y; Uš›pO y9m} TR nQ*KR<†.Q*M-. (; i1 F[-• G DA*vTY'(;Q:š\*}$O.);Œ  ¡ 1*,  ~ \)TOUK8$tOFno*2t-.(²A{*xInQ*M-.D2O*t,I6.TY'

n$x2j-.72WRF*';*À=9Ï()oq*„D2W+-.<HI*JŽh*,Y-. ¡³   ~ ÊaRy*2t-.†imzn$x2j-. {*xI TR É$Ü D2W+-. HI*J) Fo*kÕ- l>1*8 o$-. TY' …) Fq.:R4. aR D2t2t3<

FD8Q*›W-)*O:pRH-9\no*2t-.D2I*x'³-.*2W+-.7,r*2rDtW+,E.F†.Q*M-*1‚%A…€t\[-f1TOUV;q*„y*&I'”R‰o)P–”2+'4<U1(*%A:}Á)4.(*J*A:}

F*2r*2r9})F:':¦,-*1(;.9p2K  ~ '€%h*›WCZ2jI$›-.€„;(9O9t'€}Q):1/Dt'*  ~ O q.:R4.<(€}Q9š\Q*¨Ý-n¤*KE.†.Q*MW-‚}*„;:8†o.œTO†*'9p+O€}o9pVTO=>_no*+,r.)$-.D2h.:+-.‚,-.HV S)Q©.sp,r6):+-.TO=>_{*C

†*1*±71/†.Q*M-.$‘J;TO†*1*±Ÿ.‚,-.w*+'*%pO()ME.€%j›I;<H2t1)D-°jO*O.•HI*J[W\†.¨°,-.aR†*'9p+E.aR)Žj ? I†*1*±Ÿ.:8Htt§y;F6H2t1Œv9O=:VfpO[-•ZC.<TY-)*O9}Ëv.)/n$J.f-.9}(;¨°,-.–

¤*KE.†.Q*MW-(*J$O:\©)$&-.‚,-.É*,Ï*%2-Q.$t,r.†*&›¦,-.n$  ~ E.‚,-.HI*J· ¡Q*aRD%KL.FD21$M-.UYº1Œr.)<TO)iI)oPQ:\no*2t-.*2W+-.*OHI*J

7W+›\FcK-*1*„²AH8aRy*&I'

”R‰o)P–”2+'4

TO=>_ŒpO*%Kh*,JTO DrQ*À*Â*2m2\.£rD±*d./()*+,-.‚pKE.aRD2-o*K,-.<(€':t\†.Q*M-.:8UJ;n$h.oQ9x\y*&I'”R‰o)P–”2+'4<()*+,-*A

ef-.Uš3aRÎb9Oy:8=>_=iR4.D2R>x,r6.aR`9,jE.F«¦E.(*J.Qo*8aR®*›C.aR7j›IŽKj1n£AP*Y,36.Z1†.:39-.nMš-.‚,-.7V.9\*%+1

Page 103: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 103/248

8(9:;<=6> ?,@ AB/ <CDEF/G% 1=H(6'% IJK% E L(7M'% NB(OP )*#

F*+1€¨€\q*t-.72WR/D'*„©*xE.*O:pR†:tA[W\†.:39-.nMš-.*%,'$3/© SÙ,-.<:t-HO:@,r.†.:39-.FnMš-.FŽh*,Y-*J*Â*2m2\.£r/UO*+,-.ŒO

†.:3)):+-.‚,-..9I*J*„9%V.9'<$%¥()*+,-.n$W-G)4.UYº1‚h*tW\/:':+-.TOF†*8*2j-.u›¦,-*J/D¶*%OŒ'œ9\):+-.7ššCTOF{.œQ4.€¨D›8)=>_

:2Ro>2E.=)4./F{o*pd.€¨DW±.9E.D¸2xK-.=*,tW-:+1=.934.D'9L.D¸2j-.

HW+V=*,t-.y.:,jE.U2¦,jO l*K'$t\<:t-†Q9x\’f}†*&›¦,-.UYº1Œ'‡ËKš,-   l*biI; lD¦v.)TOP9Wj-.DO9%›O`:-FZA$x-.y*t,I*Jn:3.9-.Z,p¨*1);n:3.9-.´>‘1=iR¿-‚,-.HI*J³,+\–D-9KtO<6:1(;†*2-µ Q9x\’f}†*2m2\.£rŸ.HI*J³RD1$m,-.°xd.):2Wt\)†.:39-.nQ)*mE.<

 …T,\†*2-µ Q9x,-.6= S9¦,-.]R4.6);:KOq*tK-.ËW±¿-<a+A02tp-.TO= S9¦,-.F]R4.(*Jo9pL.(9%›'€%›89O(9-)*Ï)ž*ºp1(;7I9WM,j'UA°1*O(9+2x,j'<.9I*J(9%›'†*+K,-.–n¤*KE.€^*+A4iJ†:jÊi2A7,2r;;:KOn*J*¦E.—);;:KOD1*m,r6.5678 9:;<6;9=>|™"(ŽKj,-.y:+1*2\Q6.

$_Ý-iI9}ŽKj\y:+1*2\Q6.†.fW-#—ÁQ9r"#"#˜ F<%($™<HI*J†*2m2\.£rŸ. D2pKOaRQ*YA4.DA*vGn³d.<:t-€  S W+\o9pL.7I;TOUV;DO.ou  S ›¦,-.=o*K,E.ŒOF€%h.:R;€%2WR(;.9pK'[-•:  S 2t,-.aRnQ:tE.DK–$-.)Z,p}³E.aR€%,2W1*8

œ.s›,r>-<:t-.9W+\(;()*+,-.6:1(;]pK  ~ 'aRD2-o*K,-.<F.f-(*JQ9x\†*2m2\.£rŸ.‚pKOaRƒ2Y,-.e:št-.ª2-)aRƒ2Y,-.]R4.<iJ(;Q9x,-.…

T   S ,';:KOq*tK-.`98¿-<ip21)HI*JD2m2\.£rŸ.–DWR*›-.‚p+,r:'sE.TO†*1*±Ÿ.Fn:39W-(*JU':K,-.‚p+'aR9¦IÁ*‘O(;†.:39-.*%j›I9mp,r<(U±;y*&I!”R‰o)P–”2+'"/{o*pd.FD2-*,t-.7,O.o)’O:\)*%WJ

DtA.9,OŒOD'$&In°ºI()*+,-.<DA*vŸ*1GF[-•[-*p}(.Q9x\(.‘OTvy*&I'”R‰o)P–”2+'4F*I*J(.:':VDKjp-*1D'$&pW-<(.f})(.Q9x,-.(*2A*vŸ.*¹|

Q9%¥F†*28>_4.Q9%¥)·9tx-.<†*28>_4*A‚,-.†Q S9x\:8€\*%3*'/’f}D¨o*C.DtW+,E.c1*1w*x'$1

$Jf,j'7,1$Ê*O:pR(*J7V.9' ln:3)D2I9jYrTO”2L.w*E4.<

Page 104: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 104/248

)*$ "#$%&'()'%*+,-. /0 12%34 5/3. 5/(67'%

HpJ=)*p\;e*º-.ŒOU2š›-.—;™*O:pRH+r‘Y-.TOFÒ.Ù-.*pK}fAÞt,I$O4.<*I:V)(;*p-*VQ(*E4.)(9›t'/€%j'Q*,O<n°mA)HW±)D›'f8*%pY-)…¦W\Q»-.<TO)€¨=sI(*A$x-.UYº1‚+2KbF€%+8.9Ef_;)*p-*VQ

(9,º'F(*E4.*}:pRUYº1)ÎV*›OÉ$_w*E;‰*mŠTO7+v9O*±)|"T¦I(9›rµ ‹.f^]p,I(;.:3;…X$+,'`•¿-<ª2-.f}F*I°x_U1°x_[W\D2+A:E.

D2r)³-.Dp2+W-.<—\)Q"#$&

˜ F|%#

™< (Q.f,R6.w9jYj-.{9›'/7\69-:Oo$¾:%V=*  S +AŒpEy*t,I6.<9%AªY+' l*O:I l*28>_;y*2tW-P*%,I*1ƒ89OTOƒ8.9OFDt‘-.ZK')*';Wt-.TO(;  l*š@Š*O:8X S$+\`•¿-<

«+A UYº1 UR*›,-. D+2Kb =o*K,E. u  S ›¦,W- D2I)*+,-. †6o*K,-. †– :t-<$_¼. *¹:3; DO>j1 (i,× ZA$x-. U+V G U2 HI*YA<2M,-. .f} j›\ TY')

 :¦1 DO.:,jE. =o*K,E. ()*+,-. D1$Ê (°1 =9t-. =>_ TO Zmj-. DW+O ßo*KO A)

 R>-. †*R9A:O †   S– :8 *Â.•/ (*J *À D28 $‘J; =o*K,E. ()*+,-. U+V *À FZK  1*j-.<iJ(*JªY+-.*¦2¦±*';<*O:p+AQ9}:\()*+,-.=o*K,E.Dm2,I†.Q*MW-FD2O.s-Ÿ.€\œ.s›,r.D28>_;y*t,I6.D'9t-.<’f})D28>_4.Hj2-D-°jO‰*K\

D2m2\.£rD2pKOaRF=o*K,-.aR)9¦Ißo*}<U1‚}D-°jOy*2t-.i1(*J):K'.$O;  l*28>_; l*Kr*pO)UV4f2›p\y.s,-.q$E.’*Ê2AQ73>r=9,tE.<y*t,I6.):  S -9' l*O*t,I.<.fY})(²AUJTO()*+,-.y*t,I6.)*I*J(.œs+,'*2\.•<(s's+,-.Ó.f-.[W,-žiI4.

D2J9Wj-.D-o*K,E.…TY'A)D2m2\.£rUR*›\FZKR>-.TY-)*';A)€Â.Q9š\ w*+E½h*,p-.<TO)D23*p-.Fno$mE.D-°jE*AHj2-/(9J†>2›,-.$¨“\aRP9Wj-.½h*,p-.)FŽj¦AU1/(;P9Wj-.½h*,p-.)(.$¨“'aR†>2›,-.*';<

*O;DA*vŸ.`$_4.GD'$&p-.‚,-.)*%,3£8.D28=*,8{o*pd.‚%AQ9x\·9tx-.<y.:@,r6.) FD›2›d. D¦Wr¿- ‚p2\)$-. y.:@,r6. UYŠ ·9tx-. †fÜ. :t-

Page 105: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 105/248

8(9:;<=6> ?,@ AB/ <CDEF/G% 1=H(6'% IJK% E L(7M'% NB(OP )*%

–e•“E.:+,E.D2+A:W-<aRU2KrF=*‘E.`$V;(*E4./:3;TJ*O4."€Â*2WRFZ2r)³-. à$' (*J ef-.) FÎ2j-. Ž'9š,-.) $,jE. ‚O$-. TO ‰Q*1 ½'s1 D2O9m^.

7pY-)/H89-.7\.•…ŽKj,'D'°1†*t'*O·*O9,-ªp2Y\µ #—e*}"#"1˜ F<%)1™<(*J)$O4.$‘J4.nQ*¨.s  S 2)9}y.:@,r6.Œ89,E.D2+A:W-ef-.´:3/

:':+-.TO†*R*xt-.<

:t-.9I*JÔe;(*E4.ÖZ&,pO.:V/€Â.Q*2,_.F©.:}¿-†*,289\)Fƒšt-.o:R)ƒh.ft-.‚,-.F*„9tWx'52¦1(;:2t+-.FsI9V:+1’o9V)/c_=*,t-.y92-);

FZO9'ƒº,J.F€%O*&I],37I;(*J©$+'aR7V)D8:-.T';ctj,rD›'ft-.D2-*,-.<HI*J7\*1*j3Dt28oFD'*MW-(*J) l.Qo*8aRy*2t-.i1.:1.$x_.KJDKjp-*1ž*K-

(*JQ4.–FZr$,E.7,A$+E(;ƒšt-.ƒ89,2rUK87-9±)G(*YE.ef-.€\7›š8<—sW2}"#"#˜ F<#1™

:8)U+AŽI*L.$_¼.qÃ-.F7j›IiJ$J•e:pVw*E;/X$+O7t2W+\aR

"D›'f8q*jE.#‚,-.(*J(92I*x'³-.*„9tWx'<HI*JÓ°\/DR*j-.D+1*j-.ÑUYº1€&,pO.:V52¦1Œ2x,j\(;cK\

[,R*r*%2WR<<<HI*J©:%,j\ih.o©:^.F7j›I(*J*}.:OF l*t28o…)©$¦p\UYº1‚KI*V);]x@,\GFq.Q9-.);ctj\y*O;DO>+-.<<<],3(*JP*p}0+1Z2-9›-.T'f-..9›3œ*VQ*_<<<UK8D+1*j-.†*&¦W1*„):}*º2-‚})$m›p\<—Z19J"#$"˜ F|

"$3"$1?™

:t-HWrQ;[W\·9tx-./{>bQ*p-.‚p2\)$-.D-*rQDV)osO<:tAHW±);

Gno*2t-.*2W+-.€%O*28=iR4*1FD2h.:+-.ip21HW±);):+W-D-*rQy>r<:tA€Rœ =*V$-.€„;()f›p'Dr*2rFD2h.:R€%pY-)….9I9Y'(9W+›'[-•>+A<:8)Ëv);´Q9Šµ 7j›I(;[W\=*+A4.DxpE.HI*J$‘J;TODt'$bŽ  S pm,-o$-.‚O*t,I6.<

/{o*pd.FD2-*,t-.HI*JD2p1(.):+-.átx-.6*›,3.PQ*º'72Ay9šd.—o.:I4.™Š.£1€&,pO=o*K,O)F†*A)ftE*1e;â'Q.9š-*1FU1*pt-.)F˜*±$-.)*O)

Page 106: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 106/248

)*& "#$%&'()'%*+,-. /0 12%34 5/3. 5/(67'%

GF[-•*À(*JsO$'Fœs+')/)H8)F:3.)>JTOƒb.9R·*j3Ÿ.€%8*A$1/F>j-.o*t,R6.)(°1q.:R4.€}*'; ã{*AQ€^/n*I*+E.<—´Q9Šµ "#()˜ F"&&™<

.fY}):tA†:R*r[W\·9tx-.aRs's+\‰o.)$-.D28>_4.‚,-.†œsR·*r4.‚h*t\Q6.y*&p-!”  ¡ R‰   ¡o)P ~–”2+'4<

(y*&I!”  ¡ R‰   ¡o)P

 ~–”2+'"ef-.$%¥/{o*p_=*,t-.$'$E./B$C.

D2E*+-.G)4.T}³'aR(;D8.:š-.i  S W8(9Y\D'Q)äq:K-()*+,-.‚pKE.aRDj-.D2-o*K,-.<‚›AU¥©)$&-.FDh>E.TY'()*+,W-(;Q9x,'],3Z1y9šd.<

P*p}$O;:3.)(*JŽš'/Ë-*±o9pL./{o*p_F=*,t-.9})€%›-.Ëv.9-.  l*O*Q):-=o*K,-./DO.o()*+,-.<y:@,j2r)Uš›-.Á*,-.0+1DW‘O4.D2h*234.

Dp}³W-aR(;U‘O.f}€%›-.TO(:-ZJQ*ºE.ª2-*'Q)ä>+AQ9%&-()*+,-.’Q.$t,r.)<

 

Page 107: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 107/248

 

"#$ %&'#()*+ ,-#./ 

012'134+ 05674+! #$%&' () *+,-.$/01234%)$5

 

"#$%"&'( )*"+,-./ 0"123/ 45% 67 418"9:/ 67 $;$<(/ "#=<'>/ ?@+A"&(/ BCD9(/ EF%G15H-CIJKL"<'(/MAN"O(/PEL"O5DQ?/R8S=O>G1TU/PV"W"'O'>."Q

@;=XO(/L)'(/4,"8=;CY,4I9(N"O(/Z  [ \Y  ] '>K^/EG15HKL"<'(/E-CY'(/)*"123/P67LV"W"'O'>./@7"_/)'(/4,"8`"+'>/67/R8ab\(/)8KcdeD\(/fLcBCg

=XO(/hi1(0j("Ak-Ll(/-CY'(KL"<'(/P $T'<,@;=X#-CY'(/)*"123/F%m/n(/67GWc?0"+\(/0"+\(/LoCpq(Pr7/R8KL"<'("Qr*"sMA0"t%cN"OW3/?d$2/C(/u'2LMA0"t%cN"OW3/@95'v:/P

G1\+Qw"%!"#$? x"\;=+,y5zc=;-"+,@15T<(/?@;-CY'(/{|$2?$1<Ad=8"X(/@1#L"<'(/"I9}CA.~5Y', x"7•'8/ x"}"€P$pL0"W/R80"Dp/@‚1'#d0/=p@ƒg"€?@;=XO5(

Page 108: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 108/248

!"# 6&$7&+ 89:+;<=>/ '? @A+BC 1'B/ 1'$D3&+

V„%4X<7V."2…1†'(/{|0"+'#./f‡"v'#./hF%oC'&7V"<T'‚:/@1#"†&(/LciOU/ˆ'7=AP@‚1'#LG‰:ŠR8d0/=+(/?@ƒg"‹/dS"%"7K"ŒKL"<'(/'<; x"  [ 19  [ 1†  Ž ,PF%L

GŒ?B"2KQV"<W/=:/de€3/@15T<5(@;-CY'(/= ‘ IX  ] ,@;ci>c@T15>=XO5({|‡"v'#./ˆ9}CA x"1O\7F%@<9O7r17"‚:/"I'  [ 7=APGAF%i†<(/67’(“ x"7"”PF<Q

$1<}iOW?M<7Lc@%CT@1#"†>?@O1<7y#"ŒV"15T%‡"v'#./@91<–P•O1AK"Œ

$1Œ—'(/˜/S=9(/™}3/@;=XO(KL-/S=‰Œc"p$}P!!"

  e&9'(LSCWC(/k=8"X(/KL"<'5(šC5&(/L)%•U/k“?@p›<(/-"‰;"Œœ  [ 9b'(/LE?@&Q"O:/y5D2@;=XO(/@1*"+,-./ x/=€7F%M%C#67V/S/$'7./P

ŠR8LV/S/$'7./?)8G†žA?w"%@;=X#@A/=+(/@1O1U/@;=X#LBS"\'(/P4,L0/=W|4X<  ] 7V"1("<9(/de€3/EB"@A/=+(/EGŒ67GT<(/˜/$1:/V/-CY'(/Lo=€3/

@;=XO5(P"7cŸ=Y(/@15†ž(/$+Q?yO;"\,6†(L@;=X#@A/=+(/$p?  VR¡/G†žAL?$;/„'7d=X#@1O1W‡"v'#›()<1\Y(/f„O1ŒL/S!"%#hP?MU"QE?rp/C(/=XO;{|"70/-Lˆ57"2

?˜"9(/{|@7CXO:/d$("‹/@O†T:/67‘ ‘ v  Ž

 &  ] #‘@(C+O:/‘dSCWC:/ES/=Q3/6;=€^/67kL“@p›<(/P/“QK"ŒKC\%›(/MY\,=74It<\A¢<\(/G†žA?M'76†T;-"‰;£(Kcr9O;=¤"†,?@7CXO:/F%4¥=(/67=*"&‹/)'(/$puOT;"¦S=9(/4&':/-"‰;"AP

~&bALV"<pC,ŠR8?@;=XO(/KQr1§V."2-"‰;/? x"\;=+,4X<7LV."2KL"<'(/)'(/y”"I'X2›7¨/$1<A6%"8-CIJEN"OW3/@;©\(/ !ª$H6T–V"p"1>

«"\,-./r1Q=(/?kC+(/ x"}CD€LMA0"t%c@5*"<(/d$2/C(/MYA/¬:/G†žA"\7P-CY'Q@<&5(/@1ŒCž(/@;-"b'#./)'(/wC+,"¦@57"%@15€GbO(/6†T;KcR€,B"‰TŒ

/R_®‹/67@;=XO(/fKC'517"8!"%&hP!&" 

f!h m›g£(=X#c KL-/S @;=XO( kS=9(/ $1Œ—'(/ ¯CDvA $;„:/ F%°„7"1(Lf!"##hKC'517"8L ?f!"%(Ph-"‰;/L ?V"%•U/ oC'&7 F% =  [ ¤:/ 0"+'#›( @‰;$±/ V."±/ GtQc F% m›g£(L

=X#c ?‡-"p3/ e¥ 67 M\%›( )O1U/ «"\,-./ F% )O\:/°kSPNPKC&5;Lf!"%"Phf&h BC2@;=X#KC'517"8 =X#c ?@A/=+(/f!"#)Ph²=9;/=, =X#c ?@1(S"\'(/ @;=XO(/ BC2Lf!"%!h?

 „;"ž,f!"*$hM¥"Q ?f!"*$hy191(L K"7-CAL ?f!"*$Ph

Page 109: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 109/248

@%E$%FG+ @HIJG+ K 1'$D3&+ L2MN !"$

•Œª$H@5‰7cd=;„¥@b–/LL67KL"<'(/f4¥=("A67"³cF%~5¥3/.4&',@1bt'("AV/R("AF%Ÿ›g/ha12KC†,@5}uA=+(/@91<–Lc@7L$<7Pw$+;L"O(

´;"<'(/fLcGQ"†'(/hL“@<9O:/@(S"\':/@5‰7cd„1T'7d$;=QLG‰7°=Y9(/~5bY(/L)'(/K [C†,@Os3/fLc²/ [„2=vD(/hµGTO(/=‚sL"1>"Œ3/f=‚s®  [ T&(/Lc¶TD(/·=<(/h?a12kL,d=‚ž(/GTO(/?ˆT<Y,L•O1AwC+;?GTO(/?Š-L$A@;•bAd=‚ž(/

f6;„#"W!"##

h°eA"ASLM'(/-"‚scL?M'(/a12Kc?eA"A$(/)'(/)8"t;cV"1519g ¸"'<,F%-"8²c?M'(/)8@51>C(/d$12C(/¹1+5'(d=‚ž(/@7CXO7L"8-LRAfi1\;L!"%#6;„#"W µ!"%"hPdS"%"7KC†;e>KL"<'(/EG‰7ŠR8@5‰73/67´;"<'(/fGQ"†'(/h

  x"&5>? x"Y1&AL6†(LE¢<AK"123/ ]= ‘ IX  ] ;V"7›%?0/$<(/"7|G†žA?)*"+5,Lcˆ#c-"‰  ] ;%m/C#c@O1<767@57"<:/fke(L"Œ!"(&hP!!" 4¥=("A67Kc@5}@A/=+(/$p?G€$',•Œ´p"OO>•1Q?$<AKQ´;"<'(/fLcGQ"†'(/h [M\;">">cr>C'(/e€3/@;=XO5(

@;-CY'(/ !@;=X#BS"\'(/PK|KL"<'(/ˆ&9# Žœº.|G15+("A67w•'8./67»=g0•5%0"123/RO7=;=+'(/

$*/=(/kR(/ˆ7 [$p²eQ/=,f!"%!hµ6†(L@1tpV/“?@5}Z5<',œ9b'("AE…p/C7?m/n(/$p4,"8=;CY, x";=X#PEL/R8?S$D(/4,=;CY,wCI97$;$W¨C8LwCI97

@1‚1,/¬>/d=+'&:/ x";-CY,¨G†žA)T>-fi;/=AL a1T> S-"O;"7!"%+a1T> S-"O;"7 µ  =Œ-"AL!"%#„O1ŒL/S µ!"%#=Œ-"A µ!"%*hP•O1A)+AKL"<'(/uO<:"AkS"1'%./@T5†5(ˆ55X,¢<A?~%"D:/"}CD€L’5,@+5<':/0$\AKL"<'(/67@("2@+A">e¥@1%•'W/

fe'&5;|!"%"h?ˆ'7/S|Ld=+'&:/-CQˆ&1>—,Pš"O8@W"2d$;/„'7@;=XO(@1T>-KL"<'5(P$+(„  [ Œ-$1Œ—'(/S$‚':/F%@1#/S=9(/F%@(CI>´¼(/d-=†':/PK|G‰7/R8´¼(/G<½

-/=+'>./EV"ƒ1A´;"<'(/fGQ"†'(/hV/“@<9O:/@(S"\':/L$\,r–C7šC†sd$;/„'7 "¾y#"Œˆ15%EGJd=XO(/@T;$+(/…  [ 1†'5(GW3@<9O7iOU/PELypC(/?ˆ&9#KQV."±/o=€3/)'(/V=IJV/“d [=7EB"@;=X#@A/=+(/$pVc$AK^/…ž†,Kc

 f!h w$+; Œke(L" ,!"(&-MAL ?=Y9(/L ~5b&(/ MA @1ž;"<'(/ V"p›<(/ E @1*/$<(/ F% @5‰7c

@Os3/P-CA$(/ MA ´;"<'(/ BC2 $;„T5(LKC'517"8 =X#c GTO(/Lf!"%&Ph

Page 110: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 110/248

!!" 6&$7&+ 89:+;<=>/ '? @A+BC 1'B/ 1'$D3&+

M\%›(//C&1(MY\,=7G†žAM'7•Aˆ1Q@;"9†(/)†(rpC'#$;„:/67-"‰;/)O\:/F%@5}uA=+(/PZ\YO;L/R8F%GŒ67=¤"†'(/˜L"<'(/o$(-C1Y(/fMT5;|!"%*¿"'> µ!"%"h?F%LB"<Q3/@1#L"<'(/G†žAw"%EV"%CT¢<AV"#/C1±/@#C\5(/fV-CŒ-"8!"%*=Œ-"A µ!$%*w"I¼#/- µ!"%"hP"7cKc=8"X7KL"<'(/@%S"€¨)IQV."267-"‰;/

Š"\sc‡-"p3/´¼(/L)*„U/¨LcKc/0„WŒc67šC5&(/ ÀL„<7{|BS"\'(/=+'&:/P

6†(L=;-"+'(/@+A"&(/)'(/y7"p x"+\&7-"tb'>"ABS"\'(/LcS"Iž'>./?ˆA$py7"p G15+'("A67$1Œ—'(/F%@7/ÁˆQL=JfKC¼1(L KC¼1(!"%*hPK|w"I>|/R8GD9(/E45%0"123/C8w"I>|$;$WŸ=YAª›¤°!PEŸ"1&(/?)*"123//R8“CTO(/~;=¥Eˆ'57"<7@5T'b:/@1#"†7Kc4';G%"9'(/MAMO¤/67S/=Q3/d=7@1#"¤P¹T&;L/R8®15&'A0Ct(/F%¢<AV"15T<(/

@1*"123/@€Cv1ž("Œ@1+g"O:/LfkcK"Y1'>/V"O*"†(/@1±/E@+YO7@O1<7SLR(/L"IO%Ph

&PK|G15H-CY,KL"<'(/.=XO;®+Q{|-/=+'>./)*"IO(/@1‚1,/¬>?@O1<7 GAR€—;M<A-"\'%./ x"t;c@15A"pÃ"‚O(/@1(L3/@1‚1,/¬>£(E@ƒ1A6T1  ] Ä"I15%S/=Q3/e¥?M#L"<':/@Q"–|{|@#"'7@1‚1,/¬>/E@ƒ1\(/@%CO:/@9(:/67S/=Q3/

6;=€^/6;R(/KC7$v'&; x"%CO,67V"1‚1,/¬>/d$+<:/G†žALc=€ÅAP¹T&;L/R8ÆIO(/4I9AuO¥crA"''5()O7„(/G7"†(/@15T<(-CY,KL"<'(/"¾ˆ15%B"±/r7"7K"Œ x"O†¾EZA"&(/P

+P6Tt',V"+1\Y'(/›%"9,"1ŒC5>F%oC'&:/·L=†1:/P"#SC+;L/R8{|

¢<AV"2/¬p./@1OI†'(/i>q(@1+YO:/d-S"+(/F%e&9,SCWLGŒ67M'52=:/ @O7„:/dS"±/LE$;$<(/67?Ç/=73/e&9,L x"t<A67‡C1<(/?@1O1U/)'(/"I''\¤c@7²›'7KL-/SP

K|$;$<(/67rQ"O:/)'(/u<&,"I1(|V"O*"†(/@1±/d=QC'7G†žA)\>"O,@#L"<':/ V"%CT‚T5(P"b5YD7 ˆ1O<; •1Q de\Œ V"Q›'€/ š"O8 •O1\QÈrQ"O7ÉLÈu<&,É

Page 111: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 111/248

@%E$%FG+ @HIJG+ K 1'$D3&+ L2MN !!!

E"O'5§?ŠR8"³Q¨kc@5TU/¨":"gy#"Œ?@b1b})IQrt, x">">c x";=8CWd"1b5(@1%•'W./P@5†ž:/L)8•O1Ar1Y'&;S=9(/dS"9'>./67KL"<'(/?BS"\':/6†T;G†(

$2/L x"t;cKcwC+;0/S—AGtQc67B›€B›¼'>/SCIW6;=€^/@1#L"<'(/PB/CYQd¬Q67?67„(/6†T;S/=Qq(4I&9#cKc/C5%"9';?@1#"¤•A¹T&;«•#q(d$+<:/67

V›%"9'(/@1‚1,/¬>/-CIX("AP•ŒLyO1ABCD9(/?@+A"&(/KQ@5t<7M‚&(/

¹T&,G1†ž'AV"1#"†7/@1‚1,/¬>/@5}—':/EG‰7ŠR8…p/C:/!!"

P /$1<AL6%KCŒ-$¼(/ [›2E@;=X#?@\<5(/KQ-$¼(/E@IW/C:/dS=9:/KC†;  [›2E-CY'(/)*"123/ x"t;c!&"Pˆ#|@‚1'#’("&T5(fLcBC1:/h@;-CY'(/@1T'±/B›€

B [Cb'(/‡"v'#./L)<1\Y(/°/“Qy#"ŒV"%CQ$:/~&bA?@p"15(/y#"ŒLV›%"9'(/)'(/ª$HMAÂ/L²c67S/=Q3/4',d-CDA@1*/Cž%.L?-=†', x/“|KQkcmCT

˜"†>’5'T; x"Y15€67V"1‚1,/¬>/@¤L-C:/-CY'1>{|@("2KC†;"I1Qr1§S/=Q3/6;-S"¥P@Q"–|{|?’(“.r1Y'&,@;c@1‚1,/¬>|@( [Cb'7fLc@O  [ ‚I7h@95'ÊKc

wC+,0/S—AGtQc676;=€^/"7$O%wC+;mCT‚:/˜"†&(/w/$v'>"AŠR8@1‚1,/¬>/P"7$O<Q.)+'5;KC\%›(/ x/S$? x"1*"³KQ@1‚1,/¬>|-$¼(/)8@1‚1,/¬>/d=+'&:/d$12C(/P

E$;$<(/67V"195‹/@1ƒ1\(/?@1*"123/6†T;6;S=95(•I&9#Kc"1+'5;=‰Œc67d=7P/“|m"Y'>/S=9(/Kc„  [ 1T;S=9(/kR(/ug"<,ˆ<7E?ZA"&(/=  [ ŒR';L¢<AˆWLc

Æ*"'O(/?@+A"&(//“|¹\D;…pC:/)‚1,/¬>/@5t<7M‚>?d-=†'7@%CT‚TAuO¥c67V.•'2./P6†T;@1‚1,/¬>£(Kcw$v'&,Ë;-",G%"9'(/)†(S$H@1(•'2/

"³L"<,Lc"8-$¥E@5+O(/@1("±/P?6†(L•Œ"Ob–LcE?ZA"&(//“|K"Œš"O8S$%

 f!h ’("O8$;$<(/67«•#3/o=€3/67G%"9'(/@Q"–"A{|@5t<7M‚&(/)'(/¹T&,

BCD±"AF%~>"†:/67KL"<'(/P=X#cF%G1\>?B"‰:/“CT#@Œ=<:/MA0"t%c@(›&(/d$2/C(/LciOU/$2/C(/EfS-"O;"7a1T>i;/=AL!"%+hP

f&h $;„T5(67V"7C5<:/BC2-$¼(/E?-CY'(/=X#cKC'517"8,!"%!-.M\;LM¥"Q,!"*$-

¢<A«LV"IW/C:/dS=9O:/)'(/.KC†;-$¼(/"I1QC8G±/~>"O:/P

Page 112: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 112/248

!!% 6&$7&+ 89:+;<=>/ '? @A+BC 1'B/ 1'$D3&+

»L=<767V›%"9'(/MAÂL²67?S/=Q3/KQ-$¼(/=T'&:/.B/„; x/=+'&767@12"O(/?@;-CY'(/.LB/„;C8@1‚1,/¬>/d$12C(/d=QC':/P~\&(/L0/-L’(“C8Kc

-$¼(/EG%"9'(/ZA"&(/KC†1> x/-$¥ x"1("‰7›†(?MQ=Y(/Ì"'("ALKQ-$¼(/EG%"9'(/"7G\pe€3/KC†1>?’(RŒ/R†8L x.C}L{|G%"9'(/BL3/P

K|“CTO(/- [CY:/EGD9(/BL3/ À)O\7F%Ç/¬Q./=‰Œ3/@1<p/LK—AS$%

V›%"9'(/i1( x"'A"¤ x/S$ÍL x"+\&7PGA’("O8¢<A@1(•'2./f/hˆ#c$<AG%"9'(/ ?Ì"±/)+'51>K/S=9(/•I&9#@1#"¤!!"PK|G7/C<(/@1*"123/)'(/=¤,F%o$7@<>LŠR8@1(•'2./0"+5(@1#"¤6Tt',®>C'7=T%?S=9(/@15A"pL@Œ=±/@1\&O(/?ˆ;$(

ˆ'b}LP@\&O("A@;3@T1p Î(f/h?KC†'>@1‚1,/¬>|-$¼(/4*/$(/e¥L«L©:/f011 2hd=+'&7µ•*/S/“|K"Œr1TU/KC7$v'&;ŠR8?@1‚1,/¬>/.r1Y'&,@;c

@1‚1,/¬>|@(Cb'7fLc@O‚I7hKc¹‚O,EÃ"1'W/rT‚'(/˜"†&(/Pe\<'5(LG†žA?)T>-@1‚1,/¬>"Qd=+'&767@12"O(/@;-CY'(//“|"7- [R<,

Ã"1'W/S/=QcmCT‚:/˜"†&(/6;R(/KC7$v'&;ŠR8@1‚1,/¬>/67G\pkcS=Q   [BCb'7Lc6  [ ‚I7uO\';@1‚1,/¬>|@95'Ê!&"P$pKC†;š"O8$;$<(/67V"1‚1,/¬>/d=+'&:/67@12"O(/@;-CY'(/PE?rp/C(/K|@1–=9(/{L3/67GD9(/BL3/$pyO  [ 1A

ˆ#c"7$O%KC†,@T1pN"1+74D‹/f/hde\Œ•Aˆ1Q?@;"9†(/.KC†,š"O8@1‚1,/¬>|d$2/L?F‰7 [¢¼A=XO(/6%šC5>6;=€^/EmCT‚:/˜"†&(/Pˆ#3Ly&1(š"O8

@1‚1,/¬>|d$2/L?F‰7KQ’(“.)O<;KcG15b'(/0ÏNCƒ17ˆO7PF%?i†<(/$+Q Ž [MAK›D9(/˜"‰(/a("‰(/LKc676†T:/G15Hi1(®+Q-/=+'>/@1‚1,/¬>|

?@O1<7GA"I'#"'7"I'15A"pL@1+1\Y'(/@1(L3/ x"t;cP

 f!h Kc7,/-E "Ob–Lc •Œ ?V›%"9'(/ MA 4D‹/ B$<7 -"\'%./ M<A R€—; Kc "t;c 6†T;

BL3/ GD9(/Pf&h K|/R8…;=<'(/@1‚1,/¬>£(d=+'&:/67@12"O(/@;-CY'(/,344-a1T> S-"O;"7 67 “C€—7

  i;/=ALf!"%+Ph…;=<'(/ /R¦  x"+1¤L  x"g"\,-/ ®\,=:/ )%•U/ -/=+'>./ wCI97 F% m›g£(L 4p- ´7"_/ •1> .L ?a("‰(/ GD9(/ =X#c!P

Page 113: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 113/248

@%E$%FG+ @HIJG+ K 1'$D3&+ L2MN !!&

67Le‰:/@ž8$5(Kcš"O8Ÿ"Y#r>/L67@1<p/C(/@1*"123/)'(/®1H"¦ŠR8@+;=Y(/@;=XO(/@\<  [ 5(PÐS"ALk“?0$AK|V"O*"†(/@;Ct<(/.Â"'H{|G+%)†(

w$v'&,@1‚1,/¬>|P?";e'†\("QF%G1\>?B"‰:/’5'”d-$p@1>">c~<5(?‡"<(3/67a12ˆ#cf °!h";e'†\(/@1("%@A"‚'>./¢<\(~#/CU/d"+'O:/67?"I'ƒ1AÑ€3"AL

"I'ƒ1A *•1†(/µ@1 f&hB$;/R8F%"³c6†T;Kc~1‚'&,G†žA)%/=;"7wC+,ˆA

V"O*"†(/@1±/)'(/µ"_C2f+

h6†T;KcKC†,’5,V"1‚1,/¬>/@1ŒC5&(/@1g©(/ $1Œ—'("A?@¤L-C7Lf)hK|šC5>";¬†\(/d$2/C(/6†T;Kc=¤;F%@p"1(@T*›7LV"O*"†(/@1±/o=€3/)'(/?"_C2•5‰76†T;šC5&(V"O*"†(/@1±/o=€3/Kc=¤;

@p"1(";¬†\(/d$2/C(/"I'T*›7LPM\,L@(S3/@‰;$±/Kcu'2NL=;"9(/6†T;Kcw$v'&;@1‚1,/¬>|@1gfCA"AL KC&#CW ?Ms"'A!"*&hP

•O1AL6†T;V"1‚1,/¬>£(Kc6Tt',@(CI&A@A"‚'>/@;„11”@1%/=7V/e¼'5( ±/@‰;$ E?@ƒ1\(/LcV.$<T5(@1TŒ/¬(/-L=TA?67„(/KC†;Ÿ"Y#"I'A"‚'>//SL$ÍE

Ÿ=Y(/o=€3/P";¬†\("Q.r1Y'&,Kc5=ŒR',6Lc5

 [Ò9  ] ,6@5&5>d$+< 

 ] 767V/e¼'(/

)'(/y  Ž 5  Ž D  Ž 2E?Ó":/•A-L."IO†T;Kc„  [ 1”BC}3/@5;$\(/V/e¼'5(d-"t(/Lc@<Q"O(/P¢<\Qm/C#c?";¬†\(/F%G1\>?B"‰:/Æ'O,V/S"t:/@;C1±/@}"‹/?"¦)'(/LuT&,5M>C;¬†A6PŠR8LV/S"t:/e¥d-"–";e'†\5()'(/)867i9#?@(›&(/

"IO†(Ld=7$7@\&O("A6;=€Ô(P6†T;L";e'†\5(d$2/C(/KcG<Õ"IW"'#|"8S"t:¯"‹/67"M>C;¬†\(/#/$T'<7F%"IŒ/-S|SCWC(V"‚'O7@1*/$%E"IY1Í?)ƒ1\(/

6†(L."IO†T;Kc»$I'&,"I  Ö T  ] &AkcÐ$'\7d0">"AP"7$O%LG+'O;0=:/{|F%c4  [ 5&(/k-CY'(/E$1+<'(/?)\D<(/¹\D;šC5>

~<(‡"<(3/=‰Œc x0/=¤PK|0"Œ“?V"1;$‰(/•A"I1Q?K"&#/¹T&;S$<A67V"O1&b'(/ V/“@p›<(/°d=Œ/R("Œ=‰Œ3/? x/$1+<,@U"<:/L=‰Œ3/ x/$1+<,V"7C5<T5(67GWc$;$HG<9(/Ì"'(/@91JCŒ67…*"JLG%"9'(/u'2?ˆO12=;$+'(/LGtQ3/@1(•'2.G%"9'(/

S/=Q3/ …5'Ê MA „11T'(/ F% GtQ3/ d-$+(/L ?ˆ&9# S=9(/ r7 ™\+'&:/P„11” K|6;=€^/6†T;KcKC†;67V/-$+(/=‰Œ3/@1zcˆ#3¹T&;S=95(K—A=;$;G%"9'(/r7$;$<(/

Page 114: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 114/248

!!' 6&$7&+ 89:+;<=>/ '? @A+BC 1'B/ 1'$D3&+

67S/=Q3/KLSKc~WC';ˆ15%4I'57"<7"<1§@57"<7d$2/LF%$2?0/C>/R¦LG<½676†T:/d—Q"†7KL"<'(/67»=g$2c?S/=Q3/@\p"<7L-$¼(/67»=g=€^/P

K|“CT#@5t<7M‚&(/d-=†':/C8Erp/C(/Gpc/$  [ 1+,"¾L$\;@58C5({L3/P“|.Z\YO;F%V›%"9'(/MAM%C#67?";e'†\(/LcF%V›%"9'(/MAM%C#67

V"1;$‰(/?~&bQGA6†T;"t;cKcZ\YO;fkc®T#@5t<7M‚&(/hF%V›%"9'(/

MAd=T<'&767";e'†\(/r76*"Œ);$¤GT<;@9DA6–"±/Pi1(š"O8Ç/¬Q/K—A V"%CQ$7MQ=Y(/@5A"p@#-"+T5(PKC†'>Æ*"'#G15b'(/@5A"p?Z1\Y'5(«KcKC†,V"%CQ$:/67›ŒMQ=Y(/@1s•'7r7V."2w$%d/L"&:/)'(/4  [ &',"¦@5t<7

?M‚&(/•ŒS-LEGD9(/BL3/PǬ9;“CTO(/KcV/-"1‹/$pV ŽR ‘ ] ¡/G†žA67/„'7ELG}/CQ@1O7²@5D9O7

dS$ÍP@\&O("AL4X<:V";"¼(/?@1515b'(/KC†;/R8 x";L"&7G%"9'5(=T'&:/-L=TA?67„(/r7ZQ/C,BCgd¬9(/@1O7„(/)'(/GD9,MA@5+#o=€cLr7$±/u#S3/67

d¬9(/@1O7„(/MAe¼'(/)ŒC5&(/67K$($2c»/=g3/@A"‚'>/L»=Y(/=€^/P•O1AL G7"<;“CTO(/V/-"1‹/F%"³c?@O7/„'7»C>6(KC†;š"O8 ÀŸ=Qe\Œ/“|"7y”"I'57"<7fkcV/-"1‹/hF%"³c@<A"''7!!"P

mCW=("AL{|-CY,?@;=XO(/6†T;4IQ-CY,KL"<'(/ZQLª›¤G*"&7@5D9O7°!P@J$3O+°"7mC#@1‚1,/¬>/)'(/6†T;Kc=8S„,E@ƒ1\(/@%CO':/@9(:/L67

S/=Qc6;=€× KC7$v'&; x"%CO, x/e\Œ67V"1‚1,/¬>/d$+<:/G†žALcØ=€ÅA

 

f!h 0/C>K"Œ-"1'€./ x"1O7/„,Lc 1<A"',? x" KQKL"<'(/F%N">cd$2/C(/d$2/CA=+'&767@12"O(/@;-CY'(//“|®+QL/“|y#"Œ@T1p,/-@1("%•Aˆ1Q@;"9†(/PEL@("2V›+O(/?@<A"''://ǬQ

Kc’("O8@}=Q@'A"¤,7-K—A x"\%. x"O1<767ÂL„(/KC†1>˜"‰(/Eˆ'W"2d$%"&T5(P6†T;Kc=IX,@T1+(/@W=±/ Î(f/h67 MQ=Y(/ @T1+( u#S3/ $±/ "³c F%087 ,0 9 :-a12Kc

,0-)8@95†,4;$+,d$%"&:/Lf:h"I1+5, 4'; "7$O% d$%"&:/ d$*"Q )8P@5‰7c F% m›g£(LBC2KC&\7C, =X#c d$%"&:/ ŠR8f!"*$Ph

Page 115: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 115/248

@%E$%FG+ @HIJG+ K 1'$D3&+ L2MN !!(

&P.+L+PQ3R°yH@;c»L=J6†T;G‰:ŠR8?@1‚1,/¬>/"7$<A4';"I&1>—,G†žA?w",KcwL"+,Ã"1'W./67»=gV"1‚1,/¬>/@(Cb':/f@O‚I:/hØ+P@%4/$AS$TU&+@%&'G+°u'2C(y#"Œ@1‚1,/¬>/@O1'7?d=+'&7L…1Œ

"IO†T;KcGDHF%ÙgC7w$pE@ƒ1\(/)'(/6T1Ú"I15%@T>w$%ØKL"<'(/$+(yO  [ 1A@(CYA‡"<(c‡C>"±/)'(/y9  ‘ } ]LEGD9(/˜"‰(/Kc@1‚1,/¬>|

5d$2/C(/d$2/CA6EKL"<'(/@1O\:/LF%?BS"\'(/y#"Œ@O1'7@;"¼5(P$+QV²"QŠR8@1‚1,/¬>/@Y1&\(/)'(C‚A?@(CY\(/@&ÛL67G}c@'>V"%=9,67@(CU/@1#"‰(/P

$pL$WLG15b'(/)ƒ1\(/ˆ#c•O1Ay”@2/²|$%/C+(/Gp3/? x"2"‚#y1+A@1‚1,/¬>|5d$2/C(/d$2/CA6kS, x0/Sc x/$1Wr7V"1‚1,/¬>/)'(/kS, x0/Sc x"1(Lc x/$1WP/R¦L

KQKL"<'(/)O\:/F%BS"\'(/6†T;Kc=8S„;E@ƒ1\(/@% [CO':/P"7Kc4';)O\,@1‚1,/¬>|67G\prT‚'(/˜"†&(/?ˆ57"†AG7"<''>@1tp

-/=+'>./k-CY'(/r7"7/“|K"Œ/R8rT‚'(/r1Y'&;k$D'(/Ã"1'W›(kR(/6†T;Kc

wC+,ˆA@1‚1,/¬>|@( [Cb'7fLc@O‚I7Ph$+(yb–LcÆ*"'O(/@1A"&±/GD95(a("‰(/ Kc@1‚1,/¬>|"d$2/C(/d$2/CA#d=+'&7 x";-CY,/“|®+QL/“|K"Œo$(V›%"9'(/MAS/=Q3/@1(•'2/de\Œ-/=T'>›(P

K|@1‚1,/¬>|5d$2/C(/d$2/CA6y&1(d$12C(/)'(/6†T;KcKC†,d=+'&7  x";-CY,PE?@+1+±/KQ@1‚1,/¬>|"-$¼(/4*/$(/#d=+'&7 x";-CY, [¢¼A=XO(/6%

@1(•'2/-/=T'>/G%"9'(/P/R8LÃ=Y;@5†ž7@191Œ6  [ †  Ž Ž ”ˆWC'(/k-CY'(/šC5&5(˜L"<'(/670$\(/EBLc=73/P

ì+,@;=X#@A/=+(/@1O1U/ x"A=I7 x.C+<767K²/C,@1‚1,/¬>|-$¼(/4*/$(/PK| @p›%uA=+(/@O1':/MAM\%›(/¹T&,-"‰;"A)+1+±/¨@1bt,@p"15(/67G\pS=Q   [M<767GWc@b5D7S=Q=€× PK|-"‰;/)+1+±/6†T;Kc-CY';"7$O%w [$+,»L=J

@95†'(/d$*"9(/L@A/=+(/L~>"†7@1Q"}V"O1‚5(@\\&:/?-"‰;£()'(/L$WC,G€/SS/=Q3/‡-"p3/f©1Q!"+$6;$("8 µ!"((°KC'517"8!"#+hPK|w$%-$¼(/E@5t<7M‚>

Page 116: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 116/248

!!) 6&$7&+ 89:+;<=>/ '? @A+BC 1'B/ 1'$D3&+

@#C†'767@5+#d$2/L)8-"‰;|67mC#"7fS=9("QFv';6%V/S/=;|6†T;KcKC†,$py  Ž \&  ] 'Œ/hµ/R(KQ/R8mCO(/67šC5&(/6†T;Kc-CY';/“|"7K"ŒK"\%›(/MY\,=7r7•It<A@5DA@A/=p@O1'7fKC'517"8!"%!6;$;=AL $;/L µ!"*$hPE?rp/C(/K|dS"%|

V"A"&±/6†T;"8`/=W|@+;=YAa1bAKC†;S=95(w•'8/Lc@b5D7E~&†7ˆ†;fkcd-C,"QÃ"A-3/"+QL":uT&;@p"15("A@57"ž(/PhK|dS"%|V"A"&±/ŠR86†T;E

dS"<(/Kc$H67V."2d/L"&7›(/; < = 

L> < 4

?ELŠR8?B"±/KC†;KL"<'(/ ›   [ t97F%Cb#e¥«L©7P/R(KQ676†T:/G  [ 1¡$*/CQKL"<'(/E…p/C:/)'(/ˆ\ž,@5t<7M‚&(/)'(/6†T;Kc"I1OÕV"%CT‚:/@#C†:/67S/=Qc4IYA=,V›}@A/=p@O1'7P67L?¹–/C(/•1QÑÜÂ/L²3/?@1*"O‰(/d$(/C("Œ?"8$1(LLLck—ŒMO¤/

67?0"+s3/6†T;Kc/C#C†;6;$%/LG†žA¯"€E?4³L"<,EL@+1+±/š"O8$;$<(/67@5‰73/@QL=<:/F%KL"<'(/Lcœ9b'(/EG‰7ŠR8Â/L²3/P

S=‚TAKc$W/C',V"O1W?KL"<'(/KQ0"+'#./)  [ TO  ] 1>V"1‚1,/¬>/)'(/)O\,

šC5&(/˜L"<'(/F%¢<AV/-"s/@1ƒ1\(/f²e9;/=,!"%!

hPK|¢<AG7/C<(/dCA3"Œ @Y5'v:/f-PSP-$#"&†1(/!"%)hª/$23/L)'(/r+,F%´7/C8V"%CT‚:/e¥?@Q [=<:/SC+'> x•*/S{|@p›%e¥d$Œ7MAM\%›(/M5T'b:/PK|„11”@;cV›7"<7«"\,-/

?d-CY'7w/$v'>/L’5,V/-"s/$;$b'(šC5&(/˜L"<'(/¹T&'>•*/S-CY'("Ar>C'(/LE@p"15(/@57"ž(/P"7$O%4';“"¡/-"1€?˜L"<,KQ@+1+2@T&(/@1(S"\'(/KL"<'5()8o$2|V/-"s/@(/$(/F%«"\,-./Lc@p›<(/P?/R(KQV"Q [=<7šC5&(/

=‰Œ3/@1#"#c$<A@A"‚'>./@1\5&(/)'(/wC+;"¦»=Y(/=€^/KC†'>d$197•5Œy#"Œ@W-S«"\,-./@t9vO7LcšC†ž7"¦PF%L?/R8$+Q Ý4,‡"&'Œ/d-$+(/F%G<W

šC5>S=9(/"gL©7šC5&AS=9(/?=€^/’(RAL6†T1>KL"<'5(Kc©'O;E»L=X(/V/“®A/¬(/Gp3/P?/e€cL"7$O%KC†,@1(•'2/0"+'(/MO¤/67S/=Q3/d=7o=€c

? x›\+'&7@1(•'2/@1("%•Aˆ1Q?@;"9†(/6†T;KL"<'5()O\:/F%@T&(/@1(S"\'(/Kc?´<'O;KC†;L x/=+'&767@12"O(/@;-CY'(/EmCT‚:/˜"†&(/kR(/i1(ˆ1QV›}

uA=pF%Ÿ›g/P

Page 117: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 117/248

@%E$%FG+ @HIJG+ K 1'$D3&+ L2MN !!*

 4, $+(?{L3/ @(S3/ E Gp3/ F% ?C;-"O1&(/ /R8 ~>"O, KL"<'(/ 67 @("2 »"ž'Œ/EV"p›%V"15T%r–L¢1\(/o$(š•>cNL-"+(/fÑ\ž(/hf©'1Q!"*$ˆ1( ?!"%%hP

ŠRIQš•>3/"Ä$(0"t%c@15>"O,o$("8-CŒ“"I¤"#|LP)8LG  [ †ž, x"W/L²c6†T;LKcB"+;6%GŒÂL²"IO7G†žAw"%•³cK.S"\';-/LS3/E•³CŒ’;-•‰'>/r9,=7

@T1+(/fr–L¢1\(/h’;L-•‰'>/¢9vO7@T1+(/feQC,V"#/C1±/@;CO:/¹1+5'(

ÇC1\(/Ph@5+(/ oC>  ]=Q ÝC, . "³c e¥ ?$2/C(/ wC1(/ E ¢1\(/ r–C( V"15T% ©% ª$HLd=7 GŒ E ¢1\(/ 67P| K"WL„(/ G1T; a12@>-•:/ S$% 6  ] †; "7 @1&OU/ @p›<(/ 0"³| {@1&OU/ x•  [ &+  ] 7kL"&'("APL$\;w"XO(/ˆ#—ŒL¹T&;CTOAe‰†(/67$1s¬(/E4‚2?Þ‹/6†(L©'1Qf!"*$h$pìpcKc«Þ‹/6†T;KcKC†;$p- [CY,"7$O%

y#"Œ@(›&(/@51ƒ–@("17LCb#=¤"†'(/PK|=¤"†'(/ [B$1>F%®A/¬(/MAÂ/L²3//R8L$pKC†;$%">BLc=73/E=;CY,KL"<'(/KLS@W"±/{|$;„:/67«"\,-./P

$+("Ob–LcEGD9(/a("‰(/@1(^/o=€3/)'(/67"³—sKcG<ÕKL"<'(/c$\;

"7$O%w$v'&;r1TU/"\;=+,@1‚1,/¬>|-$¼(/4*/$(/f011 2h?.c)8L@1(× rT‚'(/ f?@ABCDEFGH-PǬQ/Kc@%CTde¼}67S/=Q3/w$v'&,@1‚1,/¬>|@1‚1,/¬>Œ5d$2/C(/d$2/CA6?KcLš"O8@\&#@O1<7f Ih67V›%"9,0"t%c/R8rT‚'(/k=Õr7

0"t%c6;=€× ErT‚'(/ˆ&9#P/“|w"p0"t%crT‚'(/4;$+'A@\&#de¼}67V›%"9'(/0"t%q(?6;=€^/ x/“|@W-$("Q@5Db'&:/67G\p6;R(/KC7$v'&;@1‚1,/¬>|-$¼(/4*/$(/f011 2hy(/²"7@;L"&7"\;=+,@AC+<5(f>h?EGŒ@5+#P

?"IO12•ŒL"  [ O1AEGD9(/?a("‰(//“|y#"Œ)'T1pf IhLf/hde\Œ•Aˆ1Q?@;"9†(/KQ

rTÕS/=Qc@1‚1,/¬>|5

d$2/C(/d$2/CA6

6†T;Kc/Cb\D;M5%"Q6;-S"pLF%Ã"‚O(/ E@ƒ1\(/@#C†:/67e‰†(/67-$¼(/4*/$(/f011 2hP

dS"%"7K¬+; ]r  [ T‚'(/?@A/=+("AK","8LK"'1(^/K"<1Y'&,„;„<,"z/$2|o=€3/Er1>C,@15A"+(/@1(L3/F%Ã"‚#KL"<'(/BS"\':/PF%LGŒ?B"26TQ6†T:/

rT‚'5(KcKC†; x›%"Q67KLS@A/=+(/P

Page 118: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 118/248

!!# 6&$7&+ 89:+;<=>/ '? @A+BC 1'B/ 1'$D3&+

u'2LKL$A@5}?@A/=+(/6†T;@1‚1,/¬>5d$2/C(/d$2/CA6Kc?G9Y',G†žAL?r  [ TÕF%mCT˜"†>67-$¼(/4*/$(/f011 2h?u'2K|LK"Œ-$¼(/

4*/$(/f011 2h=+'&767@12"O(/@;-CY'(/PK|/R8=73/"O†¾K3 x"<TÕ67"d$2/C(/d$2/CA#6†T;Kc)Y<;G†(Ct%@1#"†7|.K"I'&;"¦E0"+'(./S=9A=€×  À$<'&7

BS"\'(KL"<'(/P•O1ALì+;/R8@1(× 0$\(?KL"<'(/CIQÃ=Y;"t;c x./>•%/“|K"Œ

i†<(/6†¾ªL$±/?"t;c"7$<AwC+,@1‚1,/¬>|G‰7"

d$2/C(/d$2/CA#

i1>—'A "I&9#PErp/C(/ [M\  ] ,@1–=9(/@<A"&(/EGD9(/a("‰(/SCWL@("2de‰767›(/=J"O,"O8°@5‚<Qe1¼,V"%Ò(/E-CY'(/)%•'W./’5'” x"W.„7Lc@g"  [ +>K"7q(P

K|@D+(/@<A"'':/)'(/=IX,67/R8G15b'(/)8"7™;°K|-$¼(/4*/$(/f011

2hC8@("±/?@1*/$\(/C8L=+'&767@12"O(/@;-CY'(/P6†(L6†T;KL"<'5()O\:/F%BS"\'(/Kc~&†;ÙgC7w$p67B›€M'1(× P?{L3/)8@1#"†7|SCWL@5}@A/=pMA

V"1‚1,/¬>/@(Cb':/f@O‚I:/h?"¾)Y<;V"O1UMO  [ ‚I:/¢<A@D±/@1,—':/67Ã"‚#4It<A?¢<\(/’(RALe¼',V"%CQ$7G%"9'(/"7$O%=  Ž XO  ] ;ˆ1(|67@IWL=X#

MU/i1(L67@IWL=X#S=9(/P"7c@1(^/@1#"‰(/~5¼'5(F%-$¼(/w"'(/@\&O("A V"1‚1,/¬>£(@O  [ ‚I:/)IQBC}C(/F%G†sV"<TÕ)†(=QC,@\&#.N—A"¦67V›%"9'(/)'(/"I†5'”GŒd$2/L?"IO7u'2K|Ly#"Œ=¼}c67Kcw [$+,@\&#@;C#"¤

67V›%"9'(/)'(/"I†5'T;S/=Qc@1‚1,/¬>|-$¼(/4*/$(/f011 2hP x/“|@+;=YQ@(CY\(/)'(/4,"I2EGD9(/˜"‰(/M\,ˆ#c"7Kc=QC',@%CT@%CO'767

?V"1‚1,/¬>/KC†,@1‚1,/¬>|5d$2/C(/d$2/CA6@O1'7@;"¼5(P)IQwC+,0/S—A$1WEŸ"Y#r>/L67»L=X(/ [GHLÆ;-$'("AGÍV"1‚1,/¬>/o=€3/Ed"Œ"Í@1ƒ1A

kC'HF%mCO,e\Œ67$%/Cp“"¡/-/=+(/d$+<:/G†žALc=€ÅAP/“|y#"Œ@1(•'2/KcKL"<'(/MAMO¤/67S/=Q3/=T'&1>)8@1(•'2/de\Œ•Aˆ1Q?@;"9†(/ x/“|@1‚1,/¬>Q

5d$2/C(/d$2/CA6"I&9#)8@1‚1,/¬>|d=+'&767@12"O(/@;-CY'(/P@Q"–|{|?’(“KQ"Ú"\¤67× G†žA?¯"€"³3r1Y'&,@7L"+7G  [ 9Y,rTÕG7"Œ67V"1‚1,/¬>/

@(Cb':/fLc@O‚I:/Ph?/R(KL"<'("Q)O\:/F%BS"\'(/6†T;Kcc$\;E"<(/kR(/u¼Y,ˆ15%@T>w$%?KL"<'(/6†T;LKc)Tº?ˆ&9#S=‚TAKc4';ˆ&1>—,G†žAw",P

Page 119: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 119/248

@%E$%FG+ @HIJG+ K 1'$D3&+ L2MN !!$

r\O,$;$<(/67V"+1\Y'(/@1*"123/@%CO'://R_ÆIO(/67M\5Y'7MO¤/d—žO(KL"<'(/Pd=†9(/L@&1*=(/)8KcS=9(/~½Kc.KC†; x/-S"pF%Kc-$¼;C‚O;Lˆ'5<9A

KLSKcKC†;S/=Q3/6;=€^/6;-S"pF%w"+'#./ˆO7S=(/LF%ßCb#B"  [ <QP~5Y',@A"‚'>./Kc.r1t;S=9(/-S"¼(/Eß=bA67S/=Q3/6;=€^/M(CI‚:/@\&O("Aˆ(P

~O‚',LV"O*"†(/up-3/ŠR8@5†ž:/67B›€"Ú-$pd-CY':/F%„11”$;$<(/67

S/=Q3/M95'v:/6%?"I'(›>e¥ˆ#c$T'<,V"O*"†(/u#S3/F%V"1(^/)'(/S$   ] H G†žAe\ŒS$%S/=Q3/?M95'v:/LcV/=T<'&:/?@95'v:/)'(/r1Y'&,KcG%"9',"I<7F%ßCb#B"  [ <QP"7c~5Y':/4I:/˜"‰(/G<Uw"+'#./ x."  [ <QCIQKc@1(•'2./f/hd=QC':/w"7ci9#6;S=9(/M\%›(/0"+'(›(@1#"¤.$AKcKC†,@<9,=7G†žA»"ŒP

"7$O%.KC†;6*"†(/ x/-S"pF%„11”S=9(/kR(/K"Œˆ;$(G%"9,ZA">?ˆ<7KQ@1(^/@5;$\(/)8$Œ—'(/67Kcr1§ˆ,›%"9,)8r7~%›(/ˆ&9#P6†T;LG<Q’(“

67B›€@7CT;Sš"†'2./=T'&:/r7=€^/PZ\YO,LŠR8@+;=Y(/E4X<7…p/C:/

?@1#L"<'(/)8L…p/C7«"\,-./Z1¤C(/rQ"OT5(@(S"\':/MA0"t%cN"OW3/@95'v:/P 6Tt',L@5‰73/K"gÒ(/’>"O(/LcrpC+':/JkR(/GTº@<pCp@¥-"QF%Š=IJˆ';•±KDELFC MENO-hr7ˆ†;K/C126T1#3/k=b\(/fBDNJNGDLPGDhµd©2L„Î;„(/r7$;$<(/67V/=T<'&:/@95'v:/67V"O*"†(/@;=I‚:/@+1p$(/)'(/"ÄL,E

µ"8$&Wd=‚ž(/Lr7"Ú";=YQ)'(/¸"'<,"I15%P

67LV"1(^/o=€3/~O‚'(@W"±/{|„11T'(/)8K•–S [=9,G1†ž'(/)*"O‰(/M\%›(67B›€w/$v'>/K"†7yA"¤S$ÍLm•'W›(PG7—,F%G1\>B"‰:/E

V"p›<(/@1#L"<'(/@1O\:/F%…1XO'(/)'(/wC+,"I1Q@†T>de¼}Lc$2cV";©+(/ @(/²AV"1519Y(/"I5ŒcL674&W@†T>ŒcfLcu'267G€/S"ITQh?6†T;KcKC†,@>¬97"_PK|ŠR8V"15T<(/@1(S"\'(/@191XO'(/@1*":/ª$HE…p/C:/@152"&(/EL

»L=U/@;=vD(/a12´1<,V"#/C1±/6T–Zg"O7@1ƒ1A@'A"¤f²=9;/=,!"%!hPL$\,LŠR8«•#3/@1ŒC5&(/e¥dS-/LE»L=X(/@Y5'v:/@2C'9:/LEŸ•%c-"b\(/P

Page 120: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 120/248

!%" 6&$7&+ 89:+;<=>/ '? @A+BC 1'B/ 1'$D3&+

"7cV."2KL"<'(/@1(S"\'(/o=€3/)IQ@T>d„1¾…p/CT5()'(/KC†;«"\,-./=T'&:/"I1Q? x/S-/LdS"%L"76Tt',0"+'(/)*"O¤ˆ\s=T'&7?S/=Qq(Lc

V.›&5(@15€/SS›1'>./LcV.›&(/?@1&OW›(/LcS/=Qq(67ßV.›>ŠRIŒfKC'517"8!"%&L!"%*hP?GA"+:"ALKQ»L=J«›'€./?=±/»L=JL0"+'(./)*"O‰(/

?yp:/a12KC†;„11T'(/?›1b'&7GT'  ] º/$WKc4‚O;"IO%B›¼'>./¨?G9Y'("Œ

?Ç=:/L"7L{|’(“P?/R(•O1\Q48"&,V/=T<'&7GTO(/E$;$<(/67V."2 ?GQ"†'(/$T'<,L"I15%G†žAe\ŒE¢<A?K"123/KQV/=T<'&7Gb#G&<(/ ¨)'(/)8Gpc x","\¤E6Œ"7c"I¤C†7¨y&1("Ä$(V"O*"Œ@QL=<7´;"<',?"I<7GA

"Ä$($;$<(/67V"1519Y(/fk|PLcPKC&5;L!"%!K•&;=, µ!"*$hPK|K/C1±f+LBV$5'L24WX%YVBV=Z+,-.-,/0.1 34.40455461 he¼D(/kR(/´1<;EŠ"1:/?@AR<(/«"\,-/

yA"¤4*/SLr7~("bY(/0/l‹/)'(/$W/C', x•*/SEˆ'‚&#c)'(/L~<D; x/$W"I'(/²|PE/R8mCO(/Lc?@(›&(/G+'O;~("bY(/{|B"1W3/d$;$U/%ÇC1\(/P•Œ

Kc/-$;"_/f[VL$\&$Z]N?'$N+2%U%N+7/0.1 389:1.45 1;0 7< =>>?;81>1h®\,=,

  x"t;c?~("bY("A"IO†(L.’5'” x."+'#/6%Z;=gÇC1\(/PEŠR8?V.›&(/B"+;Kc ÈoL$<(/KC†,@pC\&7»"<–AV"#/C1b5(@ACbD7L¢<\AÇ/=%3/@1–=:/)'(/B$,F%SCWL@("2dS$Í67G9Y'(/67G\p@'\O(/Éf¶#C;!"+)¯ ?!!" !+hPd=7L?o=€c=IJKc@T&(/@'p:/«"\,-›(G1”{|@%„%²´;"<'(/P

"7cEN"OW3/V/“d-$+(/dSL$b:/F%„11T'(/MA0"t%3/6;=€^/670"OAciOU/?ˆ&9#6†T;KL"<'5(BS"\':/KcKC†; x"'A"¤d$%"&TA@1(^/)'(/G5+,674‚2„11T'(/w²›(/P6†T;@1+g"OT5(Kcw$¡/R8Ç=¼(/PK|d-"\%ÈZg"O:/d=+'&:/É)O<,

Kcš"O8K"%C#K"95'Ê67G%"9'(/°r70.86;R(/KCT'O;{|Zg"O:/d-L"‚:/a12 KC†,@1#"†7|G%"9'(/?@1("%r7L0"A=¼(/6;R(/KC†,@1(•'2/4³L"<,™\+'&:/@t9vO7P ]w Ž$v  Ž '&  ] ,˜"¥3/E@("2-CŒR(/67-C1Y(/@1+g"O:/Õ&5(K/e‚5(„11T'A

4It<A¢<\(/P x"1s"”Lr7ŠR8?@;=XO(/KQ-CŒ“G‰7ŠR8-C1Y(/@1+g"O:/k$\,SLS- 

f!h w [$+;¶#C;f!"+)h/ F% o=€c @5‰7c (V";=+Q   [› @15‹/ @;S"23/ ~("bY(/ r7P

Page 121: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 121/248

@%E$%FG+ @HIJG+ K 1'$D3&+ L2MN !%!

B"<Qc@1*/$%"7$O%-$D,@1O¥cß=ŒR(e¥»C(—7=‰Œc"IO7C(y#"Œ@1O¥3/=ŒR(67K/eU/fk|PLcPKC5&;L!"%(¯ ?&%+hP

6†T;KcKC†;KL"<'(/BS"\':/ x/=+'&7r7SCWLŸ"Y#r>/L67S/=Q3//“|K"Œ„11T'(/ x/-S"pF%@1Y¼,mCO,r>/L676;=€^/67kL“S•'%./Gp3/F%V"b1T5'(/

@151T†'(/d$%"&:/rpC:"ŒP$O%)OA?©\(/KC†,ŠR8d-$+(/d-CY'7? x/$W)8L$T'<,

{|$2$1<AF%„11”ŠCWC(/P"7co$7ÑD¡ŠR8@91JC(/…ž'†1QE‡/=Y–./ )¥"7$(/kR(/uT&;f"1>COŒ"AC>L=AhàLcw$%d-$  ] +(/F%» [=<'(/F%S/=Q3/674I8CWLáPÑvž("Q)<1\Y(/ˆO†T;Kc)T&; x"Dvs x"O1<767B›€V•>ˆWC(/?"8$2C(u'2K|LVe¼,V•&(/G†žAe\Œ-L=TAMO&(/P"7c¯"vs3/MA"D:/

›Q"1>COŒ"AC>L("AKC<1Y'&;w"1+(/G‰TA/R8?®A=(/6†(L4Ä$(¢<AÇ/=%3/@1\D<(/o=€3/@Q"–"A{|K/$+Q0„W67B"‚:/kn\(/PGDºo“3/BL&:/

6%‡/=Y–./E0„W» [=<767â"7$(/°E~#"U/™9&(/67›ŒMD9(/?M195‹/  x.C}Lw"7q(Cb#¹Y&(/™€/$(/¯CD95(@'p:/PK|r–C”~\&(/?/R8$;$HL

?@‚1'O(/K [.$;F%Kc„11”ŠCWLS/=Q3/K"Œ@  [ T  Ž I  Ž 7@¼("A@1z3/•Aˆ1Q@;"9†(/a1bAKc@\&#de\Œ67S-/C7â"7$(/@> [=†7"_f$#Cž1¥!"%"hP

•ŒLKcd-$+(/F%„11”~%›(/=€^/)8d-$p@¼("A@1z3/Er1>C,Ÿ"Y#KL"<'(/?=+'&:/KQd-$+(/F%@\p/=7V/-"s/@+5<':/@1(•'2"AªL$2G%"9'(/=T'&:/)8d-$p@<Q"#d$%"&7L"I9}CAd-"s|{|ypC(/kR(/KC†;ˆ1QKL"<'(/BS"\':/? x/=+'&7u'7L.KC†; x/=+'&7PF%LˆWL?@p$(/"7$O%®+&,@1z3/@1\&O(/

V›%"9'5(@15\+'&:/f/h{|"7KLS$2?-/=+'>./»C>6($<;67k$‚:/G7"<'(/

G‰:"Ar7KL"<,=€^/!!"

PK|Ç=7$2cM†;©(/kR(/SC+;{|G15+,¯=Q@15A"p Ã"‚O(/KC†1>o$2|V/-"s/)'(/6†T;"I<\',)'(/LB$,F%-C8$,V›%"9'(/@15\+'&:/f/hP4¤K|›ŒM#/C1±/E=g@Œ/©(/rpC'1>•IO7Kc"#C†;Gpc x"#L"<,P•Œ

 f!h •Œ"#S$2E@1–=9(/@1#"‰(/67GD9(/?a("‰(/KQ$2-/=+'>/@1‚1,/¬>|5d$2/C(/d$2/CA6

)8@T1+(/oCD+(/ Î(,;J>-8,; J =-L,=J4-8,; J =-P

Page 122: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 122/248

!%% 6&$7&+ 89:+;<=>/ '? @A+BC 1'B/ 1'$D3&+

Kc@€Cv1s$2cM†;©(/KC†'>ˆ\scÇ=:"AE/R8?¯CD‹/a124‚O;"IO%a%"AF%-$¼(/GW3Kc²C9;~&†TAd=7d$2/L"7$O%KC†,¯=QG%"9'(/

@15\+'&:/@515p•Aˆ1Q@;"9†(/P6†T;KcG¼'ž,ŠR8V"1(^/u'2F%oC'&7V"AL=†;":/P•ŒKckcK/C12

´;"<'7.B/„;’5'T;@}=Q-"ž'#›({|M91t76;=€× 67B›€¢<AV"15T%

oL$<(/rpC'1>ˆO7KcBCb';67@1(S"\'(/{|G9Y'(/"7$O% [G  ] +  Ž ,V.•'2/G%"9'(/ =T'&:/r7…1t:/?™}3/Ñp"O',LP)9Q@52=:/=‰Œ3/ x›9Y,fkc=‰Œ3//S•'%/F%G9Y'(/h?ˆO†T;¨kc’;©(/E@15T%´;"<'(/¨KcG  [ ¼'&;…1t:/G†žAu&pc67B›€Â"'#|$;„:/67B"†s3/)'(/"I<>CAj9'(/G+#LoL$<(/PrpC'  ] ;LªL$2ŠR8

@52=:/"7$O%Ç=<';…1t:/{|-ã?e\Œ~Y+'&;L x"%C# x"1519g x"7"”67oL$<(/)'(/S$Ú?VC:"ALc"7$O%L$\,ˆ15%¢<AV"7›%@€Cv1ž(/PE?@+1+±/K|";¬†\(/

@;S"1'%./)'(/LL$\, x";=8"J@T;$%?o“3/GAu'2@<Q"#E?0"ž23/6†T;Kc$‚#

"³c48"&,E4T&,4&U/"7$O%4';Ÿ/¬€/0"ž23/Lc?"I\+¤"¾B$;F%Ã=W$;$s fÂ"Q">!"%%hP"7c";¬†\(/)'(/6gC'&,¹Y>4&U/f$V,^_WPH`3&+h6†T1QKcKC†,@1*/$%deY€L/$WF%¯"vs3/ä=:/Lc-"\Œ6&(/P

676†T:/ x"t;cKcGTº/R8B$U/¢<A@p›<(/‡"\>—A?K"gÒ(/":"g=IJˆ#c4W"#6%V">L=;"Q@O7"ŒEV"O1U/@  Ž ¤ [-C:/f¶O1#"7!"%(»C(-Lc µ!"%%hPG1”

Ç/=73/@1#"gÒ(/{|0$\(/E-•%3/)'(/KC†,"I1Q¯=QB"+'#/K"gÒ(/67G1W{|ßG1W=€× ˆ15;EÑp"O,r;åfKC'517"8!"##hP•ŒKc$2cV">L=;"9(/)'(/~\&,

?w/-L3/C8LNL=;"Qy1Œ-CAw/-L3S$¼(/?@;L"9T5(/6†T;KcKC†,ˆ(G*/$AV/“Â"'#|r;åLc0)YAG2/=T5(@;$<:/P=IX;G†ž(/0)Y\(/F%G†sÇ=7m"9,-/

";›‹/@;L"9T5(/?67„:/"7cG†ž(/r;Ò(/=IX1QÇ=TŒm"9,-/";›‹/@;L"9T5(/?S"±/Lcw-CŒES$¼(/@;L"9T5(/fy1O1(L ™O18 ?™O18!"%"hP@Y+O(/L@7"_/E/R8S$D(/

)8Kcw-LS$¼(/?@;L"9T5(/•ŒLì+,?@(S3/6†T;KcZ5YO;67";-›7…1t:/@Tp"9':/P6†(w-LS$¼(/@;L"9T5(/CTO;@%ÒA@+*"Q x/$W/R(ˆO†T;KciQ"O';r7

Page 123: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 123/248

@%E$%FG+ @HIJG+ K 1'$D3&+ L2MN !%&

";-›:/EB"+'#./f•A-@Y>/CAÇC<\(/hG\pKc4‚O;ˆO%VC:/P$O%LG7—'(/E¢<AV."±/o=€3/67oL$<(/@O7/„':/@Y>/CAMO¤/Lc=‰Œc67N"OW3/)'(/~\&,?Ç=:/Lc@Y>/CAM'(›>67i9#?iOU/KQ@;=XO(/@1("±/6†T;KcKC†,

V/“@5}G†žAw"%•1QC(K"ŒÇ=:/r\'1>-"&7B›¼'>/0)YAš¬ž7LfÈ67„7É@\&O("A…1tT5(hLcB›¼'>/r;åN"pLfÈS"2É@\&O("A…1tT5(Phr7LoL$<(/

?dS=9:/KC†;-"&:/0)Y\(/ x"<pC'7P"7cr7oL$<(/?@WLS„:/KQB›¼'>./)7S"D'(/ $pc$\;F%-C9(/¨•Œˆ15”…*"JLV"%CQ$:/@1OTt(/¨?LcKcc$\;•1Q$<AE@52=7@T*›767G2/=:/@;=T<(/!!"P

6†T;“CTO(@5t<7M‚&(/d-=†':/KcZ\YO; x"t;cG†žALÌLcF%dS";„(/r7=T<(/)7C73/¢<\(m/C#c‡C1<(/@1O1U/fKe'>!"%+hPSC+;L/R8e¤—'(/{|$;$<(/67»L=X(/@95'v:/67V/S.C(/Lc0"OA3/Mp"<:/G†žAN"p?/$W"7LÇ=7

"1(C¼O:/fkR(/ˆ\\&,@v&#d$*/²67wC>C7L=†(/&!hoC>B"‰7r*"sG‰:/R8ŸC<(/P$T'<;/R8=73/G†žAw", x"\;=+,F%GžQGD9(/kS"1'%./MA

V"7C>C7L=†(/@WL/„':/E$&W?dc=://R8Lì+;@p›<(/@O†T:/r7@;=XO(/PK|w"&+#/";›‹/0"O¤c6;C†,@t;C\(/f6†(Li1(6T1±/dS"%hC8w"&+#/e¥G¤•'7F%

Cb#?„1¾r7¢Q-V"7C>C7L=†5(f"7uT&;‡"Y+'>."ALc6;—'(/h)'(/~8R,{|~Y+(/e¥æCXb:/67@15‹/PL$\;L676†T:/?ˆ#c•O1A…+,V"7C>C7L=†(/

@¦"ž':/Lc@+>"O':/G†žAw"%GW3Kc~&†,67B›€KL"<'(/a1‰±/E";›‹/@1±/@b+5:/M'%CT‚TAM,=J"O'767?V"7C>C7L=†(/KQ…pC:/KC†;@5t<7

M‚&(/°wC>C7L=†("QkR(/KC†;ÈBLc67-$¼;É6†T;Kcrt;ˆ&9#Ed/C#@t1\(/

i1(LE$&U/)\Y+(/P6†T;L0=T5(KcǬ9;K—AG‰7/R8G<9(/Z5Y;V.L"Í @¦"ž'767G\p@TX#cd=J"O'76†(L@95'ÊE?"I9*"JLEw"&pc?@<A"''7"7$O%LBL"º

 f!h =X#cG1ž;c "t;cf!"%%hV"O1U/ dS$<':/ oL$<5( @p›<(/ V/“ @O†T:/ M7"t:/ F% m›g£(P

=X#c @1g©(/ @1‚1,/¬>/ w/$v'>/ F% NL=;"9(/ d-$p F% @(S3/ ª$2c F% m›g£(L° CA"AL KC&#CW ?Ms"'Af!"*&Ph

Page 124: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 124/248

!%' 6&$7&+ 89:+;<=>/ '? @A+BC 1'B/ 1'$D3&+

/Ct%w"XO(/=J"O':/ŠR¦@(L"b:/EypL?$2/LKQ x"7C>C7L=Œ x"1Q"–|EG&O(/6†T;KcKC†;@‚1'#@1–=%PK|@p"1(™7"2V"7C>C7=†(/@1Q"–/dS"%"7KC†,

@t9vO7@;"¼5(G†žA?w"%6†(LwC>C7L=†(/kR(/š¬;ˆ&9# ŽG  Ž >   ]e({|$&U/)\Y+(/²=º x"7"I>|E@p"15(/oC'&TA=9D(/P/R(KQf>h)8Œc67f4hP67LGWc

KcGT<;“CTO(/?¹‚O;LKQ@¤S"2Èß-$¥ÉEo$2|V"t1\(/@17"O(/6†T;Kc"IŒ-$,

V"t1\(/)'(/.B/„,=X'O,PK|B•'2/mCpLG<QŸ›g//R8C8S=MT¡i1(?.| •ŒC8B"2@1#"†7|@T*›7LšC5>=;CY,V/R(/kR(/wC+,ˆAV"7C>C7L=†(/0"O¤cG‰7/R8w"&+#./E@15‹/P6†(LV/e¤—'(/.L$\,Â-"€Ÿ"Y#- [CD'(/°?";e'†\("QF%GŒ?B"2"I7C>C7=†A?$12C(/"IO†T;KcG<9,0"1sc@1gd [$+<7PSCWCALG‰7ŠR8?V/e¤—'(/KQ“CTO(/¹–C1>@¤S"±/Œ3/dS";„(wC>C7L=†(/“"ž(/E

ÇC1\(/fi1(LE67"1±/h•5ŒS/S²/=T<(/P4,E/R8GD9(/G1†ž,$1Œ—,KL-/SF%@b5D:/@;S=9(/ZQLSCOA@;=X#

@\<5(/Pi  [

 >;L/R8G1†ž'(/«L©(/)'(/6†T;E"I5JKL"<'5(E@TX#3/?@1WC(C1\(/)O\:/LF%@T&(/?@1(S"\'(/Kc-CY';KLS@W"±/{|n\'(/™\+'&:/67

»=gMŒ-"ž:/ P 

Page 125: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 125/248

 

"#$%"  

"   '() *+,-.

 (-/01

Page 126: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 126/248

!"# "#$%&'%()%*+,-./%0 +12345-) 6,7.8

 

Page 127: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 127/248

9:3; 9<4' 23=> ?71 !"$

 

234&5 $%67 8,# 

39%:  

"#$%& '()  * + *()  * %,-#./ 01+234567#.8931):./&;<=>?@AB+9?9CA+ 0DE1F  0/(F1GEH8;.I.9JK1#LMK/INOMP./3QR1S./91T ',AEU+(S:.VM#./WX217BL.

WY Z LM  * BL.3[F\/C:./HQ '(S+/INOMP./]Y$M#./@^(_=GP>`abCE]Lc)EWdG./H@E]ef3

,-#./8]+R,P./9gh(i/CNj/,kgOcK?]f2R]#AlmDn]LGLT@EoDF1P:./pEqF&,nr m31sCN1c+?9?j,s]f2R5($fH"%39?]t)L./uN]Lc)E8WdG./

9CA$Tv(.qFD./wK1kxMb(Ey/82(zL.=#A.3@AB+9?QCS+{/R6%($f[Fv(^/($)t./@EmDn,+C|}~B>@E931):./mR1t:^/pE,n•/H,  ' KC  * +3O$L€].C|t./

8]$>3A.‚/DcK@Fƒ„1:>…1Y%y/o1S$SY:./3]+,-#./†)%o1ECL)^/]B  ' $S./mCko1$d$}/T‚/u:./@E1‡6<9?OB)}`OˆaL:‰8h3,-./qtG./3{/23;.ŠH9gh(i/@E/INOMP./CN]‹,}ŒINo1f1:#:T&/gV„1M>p$B  ' ŽWtFD./H

 

Page 128: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 128/248

!"% "#$%&'%()%*+,-./%0 +12345-) 6,7.8

In6}3V„1M#./OA<])%2?o1k/b/]|$G%mCk]$P$XQ1$S./{/R6%($f`]Lc)EWdG./52,A:^/

"H&@A}/RCGkH#H&@A}m3?@E2(z+H$

HOE1)}O^1%`931):./2(z./3[F(k{/CTH %H&‘X/I:}H

"!"#$%& ()* +

R1:F/’1#./[FxAP:./oDF1P:%ƒ}1#./“,PM./H`;L}8ab/C^/9CA+OX1E,n•/ ”7L. 521Gn CN 8W)E ”< =tGA+H].C|% uN ;.Š [F 5($Ž/ ]LEy/ @E3

ƒ>,|7./HqFD./ @E OcK? OA7% OB)+ 9? “21t:^/ [F q_ 8($f {/R? U+(S} Of? @E

,n•/`]t)L./U-)E–bC./H9gjCK†$%y/CN523—.1%521Gn]tG#.1%RCT˜.H @A.3]$t.1™51$š/–G$.oDF1P}ƒ}1#%“,P›H8 01ECBF@AB+WK,|L.9?1E '(S  * +{/R?/8 0/($f3?"e#AB+9?91ECS+OB)%a$)œH"X9?931):./mR1t:^/@Al`

85R1)./=#A.3&wd#  * +3?SY:+[FQ/3(./H/IiqtG./9CA}]Lc)EWdG./uN;.ŠžŠCB#./($P^/`Ÿ1|>pT/3@Eab/CE51$š/]$EC$./H

`hCPM./u:./QCb?81eG+2(:%/xX1EO)f? 01f/3j?@Eu:tL9Ct)L+]Lc)EWdG./o/¡).@EoDS#./HUN¢n?96%h(i/CN9?U:+O$dG}£1S#./OA7%($f

8"e$LA."XC."‡?9DMY$T[F/2&3ROA.]|S>H"XUN¢n?1c+?=>?q_9?& 9CA+@EUe^/]tG#.1%"i9?D  ' dG+[FCY>OcK?O$LS%3??CT?O$LS%@E1¤(k?8,n•/1^191X"e)TC%9?1)B_,X?R(F@Al@E¥o/2&3(./¦"eGP#.H

9gŒIN8o/R1<2‚/8]1Gt%[email protected])}H]tL|.1K9CYt+@F21$)E]>21SBL.]+§,.1E/Šg/C>1X9CECS+OB)%($fQ?&H821$)^/3“I./,KC:+Ui].CeG%CN]>21SE

Page 129: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 129/248

9:3; 9<4' 23=> ?71 !"&

Ue1S>u:./1NCLdTpE£1S>qFD./,n•/HDf1F3Q?8Dfr QCS+(k?]tL|./2(z.1% vx. Oby/ [F 3? 8]E '(S^/ ` VtM+ uA.…(Y$T “I./ 1EHqFD./ 91X 1E 5R1F3,n•/

QCS+2(z.1%uA.&VtM+`5,  ' n¨^/H@E3U©2CN(:+abC^/]d$:>o1E1ªD.5R1c^/].R1t:^/H91F«31E¬2(+91tFD./"‡?&91ECS+{/R6%($f"Xuzt#+9?8D)P+

m31Y$K1¤(k?9?($):G+931):./mR1t:^/[email protected],n•/$./(X6:E@E9?/IN"%2

9CA+]L$k@AB+9?“R¨}g=.Dz:T/]$>1©R,dB%9??(t+931):./5,E]$>1©H O$B+’1#./5R1Fg{CdL./g21$)E]>21S^/“I./,KC:+U®(.¯5R1F31E9CA+/IN21$)^/CN]>21SE°1d>qFD./,n•/]tG#.1%Uek1d#.UN!""H“R¨+/IN21$)^/g

(Gš/H(Gš/3RCS+go&31±O+()}]+?5(„1KOMk1e$LFqFD./,n•/H`/IN²C#./@E]Lc)E8WdG./&@AB+O+()}(„/CP./u:./OMk1e$LF,n•/&g@EmDn2(z./[email protected](z./“R¨+g(+w^/@E2(z./g3³1S)./mR1t:^/H/I.9JK(Gš/,E(+

o/I./H

9gm/¨G./@Fv(E@Gk¬{/R?]>21SE@GY%{/R?qFD./,n•/$.21$)^1% ($Ž/1E´@A+;K(NCNxE(}qFD./,n•/H`U-)E8ab/C^/9CA+OE/INh(i/O$Y:GE8j1d>‚/@E3OB:Y^/9?RCS+g²/µa Z LA  * E(b9CA+@E,|¶/

  0/(f=:)%1:E2/,B:T&/3=$KH1E(#F&9CA} 01$F1TgxE(}qFD./8,n•/9JK]>21SE;1S>pE£1S>,n•/9CA:T]1Gt%]Kj1·@AB+9?2C|:}VtM:K 0/(Gk 0/,E(Eo/IL.H9g21$)^/OcKy/]>21SBL.CNv(E@Gk;„/R?]>21S^1%pE1E@AB+9?=L)P+

”<,nr C.91X`;>1AEH;:K,)B%3]$d$}/TgqFD./8,n•/ON–>?QCS}

 ¸"¹ Q(:T/,e$%&"'(")/IN21$)^/5R1F‚³1Gk£1S>].CŽ/3y/@E].C|%]Lc)EWdG./

]$>3A.‚/H(SK21<?g=>?`†)%ab/C^/‘)G+9CtFD./gmC›C./UetT1AB%8]$tG#./$.38]SL|^/g(š/ºby/H@. »()}]t)L./]Lc)EWdT`Oˆ/IN8xGP:./[FOX8m1k

O%9CA:T]t).ƒ}1>“,P›VtM}3]$d$}/Tg2(z./U„/(./&*++ ,)uN]$d$}/T‚/]#B$e^/5($kC./31e$K]+y]B$b ¼L.¸-H¹

Page 130: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 130/248

!'( "#$%&'%()%*+,-./%0 +12345-) 6,7.8

OcK6%1E½@AB+p$|:G+?”<,nr C.91X;>1AE9?QCS+{/R6%OcK?@E/IN8{/Ry/pE/INqFD./½,n•//INCN21t:n&/qT1#^/{/R˜.Vf1#./!""H

(S.oj1K]$d$}/Tg!5(k/C./5(k/C%"`].C|t./1‡y–E1b{/R6%($f`1ªDF1P}pE¾a$pT/3@Eo1$d$}/T‚/v,ny/H@BK¿$k8m()^/–E1b{/R6%

OcK?@E]+?5(F1bv,n?pEo1$d$}/T‚/v,ny/`].C|t./HpE8;.Š9JK!

5(k/C./5(k/C%"

´OdG}£1S>OcK?@EqFD./,n•/`]+?]t).–>1XÀ`8]S$Sš/ uN&p$|:G};.ŠHueK¬}qFD./,n•/2(z+8 0&3?&32(z},X?@ER(Fo/,^/u:./2(™1e$KqFD./,n•/[FŸD‚/H8;.I.9JK!5(k/C./5(k/C%.1Eg9?S€

P>£1S#./u:./1Nj,sqFD./8,n•/3?Ob?O$LS%H(S.oj1K]$d$}/Tg!5(k/C./5(k/C%"8].C|t.1%$.@EmDnŸ1šg]B+wi/qFD.1%8,n•/O%@EmDn£1t#:T/¬CLT@EqFD./,n•/VBT"e$LA.9?1ECS+{/R6%($fH–>1X]$d$}/Tg!5(k/C./

5(k/C%"]:%1©`£1t#:T/ƒ„1:#./]+wd^/8WK,|L.¿$Y%1‡?–LMk[F]f2R]$.1‹g[F?@E]+?]$d$}/Tgv,n?H

`´1)./“I./$.1^1Fƒ}1#%“,P›$.;$LF9?QCS}{/R6%OcK?@EqFD./,n•/@EOf?9?Q(S};GP#./j1d>gOcK?HVM+3/INmCS./OA7%Á1n

 ¸"¹ @AB+xt):./@F@+IN@+21$)^/]>21S^qFD./o/21t)%]$BT23?]$LA<Q/(:T1%xt):.//

&* 0 1)O$B:.]B$S./])  ' bC:^/]$d$}/TÂ.&*)1E(#FOF1P:}pE]$d$}/T‚/&1)29g6|¶/p„17./“I./pS+=$K’1#./CN]>21SE/ &* 0 1)pE/ &1 0 *¹8@E3U©].31±(X6:./@EU‡?

9CECS+OB)%OcK?@EqFD./,n•/H9gh(i/u)$t|./@E8]t)L./"X=GA)}]$#%8].C|t./CN$S€[F?]f2R]#AlŸCKp$‹;}DF1P}]PL:^/H/IN3u#)+mC›C./m()B%/ &* 0 1)

g[F?(k@AlŸCKp$‹U$b ¼./¸1

¹u:./@AB+9?1eef/C}H1E(#F3O%1S} 01tF&Q(:G+ ]$d$}/Tg]#$)E¸1¹9CA$T21$)^/($Ž/]>21SBL.CN1E/Šg91X;$LF9?QCS}OcK6%1E;#AB+=L)K/Šg1E–K,F96%qFD./,n•/Q(:G+]$d$}/T‚/&1)29g1Eq_;$LF=:>21SEpE{/R?;:$d$}/Tg¸*¹CN{/R?]$d$}/Tg*38v,n?1E(#FQCS}ŒIN5xny/q)L.1%pE]$d$}/Tg&1)1eGP>H/IN3u#)+]>21SE/ &* 0 1)pE/ &*3 0 1)281ECBF9g1E

Œ(+,}CN]$d$}/T‚/u:./QCS}OcK6%{/R?`m '()^/pEp$‹o1$d$}/Tg¸1¹v,ny/u:./QCS:T1e:ef/CB%H

Page 131: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 131/248

9:3; 9<4' 23=> ?71 !'!

1E(#FQCS}OF1P:.1%pER(F@EWtFD./WPL:^/H/ŠJK–YBT“yqF&Ue#EQCS+P#%vC:GE8;„/R?3?OcK? 0D$Lb@E8;„/R?CN{Ã8($f1^1–#X;GP> 0&1$EQ1$SL.{/R6%($fH$.¬1#N@E¾²/R9y9CA} 0/RCGk°1d#.qFD./8,n•/1^191X

(E?°1d>qFD./,n•/`]Lc)EWdG./52,A:^/CNqL|:E“2343?£Ä&‘#™=#F;E1$S.–>?{/R6%($f;GP#.H

,  ' KC+3’,z>CA./&1E/($fH{1cF6K’,z>CA./Ue#AB+931):./pEUec)% †)t./93RU+(S}o/(+(ªabC^UN(k?,n•/`@C./H$.(+(e:./$„,./²   '¡BL.CN°1d#./utG#./“I./=SSs²   '¡^/,n•/QR1S./@E{wf,nr @E8(Lt./O%

Å6+(+(e:./@E”7./“I./@AB+9?OA7+ 01+(€`=},„/R]$%1:>&/H/I.$.¬1#NxA./@Ev3(Ž/`(GkO$Ej²   '¡E[F°1d#./“I./Å6+@E931):./mR1t:^/H

;.IX3CNm1š/`m"Fy/]+21d:./¿$k@AB+]X¡L.u:./“7}@Ew  ' e·W)E9?pbC:}9?]bD)./]Yf1#./@AB+9?1eL)ÆqGA} 01k1%2?w  ' edBL.“7BL.3

[F¾(k{/CTH$.¬1#N@E¾²/R(  Ç G  Ç š°1%2?w  ' ed^/H9g]+?].31±O$LS:.=k1%2?@E mDn†)%o1T2"^/x™8]>31):^/OEQ(FpKR;B„/Cb`–bC./R(Y^/8 0DEp  ' d7:Tw  ' ed^/[FŠ1È/O)KuE1S:>/H@AB+39?In6+O)P./uE1S:>&/(+()./@E

8m1A<y/5R1F93R]$BG}]sµ]Yœ/33O)PL.[F=>?³1SFH@BK@AB^/9?9CA+/INQ1S:>&/($F/CE5,n6:E 0D$Lb`U$LG:./3?vC:GE 01cP#E@E5,|$G./]$FC#./3?

o1efC}]$LtS:GEOb?CY>U+(S}UM¶/[F8o1$BA./3?Q(FU+(S}21tn?]+2CK@Fo1tLS:./])bC:^/`h3,ˆŸCG./¸\31X1E"'4$¹H@AB+O)PL.uE1S:>&/9?O)_(Gš/

  01$.1™ 0/(fH&(tK@ELS./967%°1%2y/]$tG#./u:./1eSSs8p„1t./[F“7^/9?OE6:+

"$K/Šg–>1X]+?]$d$}/Tgv,n?{/¡L.9CA:TOcK?H#!  ,-./ (0 123 ()* + 

9g 0DX@E].C|t./ƒ„1:#./3]+,-#./91#  ' $t+9?931):./ 01+(·1^191XqFD./,n•/ 01>31):EH

Page 132: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 132/248

!'" "#$%&'%()%*+,-./%0 +12345-) 6,7.8

9gƒ„1:>].C|t./@EOMP./É1./]LNIE 0/(fHxn3@E6t#:+v(B%5RCf{/R?5(F1b21$:n/]#$)ECN1E/Šg–>1X]P$|.Q?8&“?1E/Šg–>1Xm3?@E2(z+Q?&H`].CŽ/83y/–>1XOX5(k/3@E(F/CS./3?o1$d$}/T‚/9"./3y/8]P$|.´3

@A}]+?5(k/3@Eo1$d$}/T‚/ptG./u:./(fC}`,nr ]B„1S./]P$|.H`3].CŽ/8]$>1./–>1Xp$‹o1$d$}/T‚/]GB¶/5¡Fu:./`8]BS./1E/(F5(k/38~SK

]P$|.¸(b3oj,k?;L}]$d$}/T‚/]t},^/]#E1./H¹1E?o1$d$}/T‚/]GB¶/¡F 5xny/u:./o{1f`8xny/ >1AK– 81e)$‹1E/(F85(k/3x™]P$|.H–E1b†)%(F/CS./u:./´@A}]P$|.q+,d:%Ÿ,5(S)E 01E1Ê]+§,.1E“I./

1e#AB+9?ŒIn6}–LP}3=%H[FO$tT8m1^/–.31k]$d$}/Tg5”k1P./678679 .

Q1$S./2(z%\3?@E3U©pf/./OA7%p+«/Šg1EQ1bqFD./,n•/Q1S:>&1%Hm1BX38,nr –>1X]$d$}/Tg!@  ' AG^/69*:;<=+=>79.O$Êg21-:>&/,Xy@E

5¡F3?@+¡F]LS>Otb9?2(z}v,}31E/Šg91XqFD./,n•/¬$T=GP>pcË]„(e:L.uA. 'Oz  Ç :G 

 * +W%Wk,nr3H/ŠJK1E91X,Ey/8;.IXQCS+!@  ' AG^/

69*:;<=+=>79.{1S.J%†)%o&1k2(z./]L$LS./v,ny/O›/CP%,X?8 0/2/,A}‘:k¢  * _[Fpf/./@EOtb]%1d:T/qFD./,n•/[email protected]´ÌUS} 01+?@EW}1N

W:$d$}/T‚/W:L./1:.31k9?1>CA}m3?@E82(z+´US}{/R6%($fOA7%Á1nH91X3¬1#N(+()./@EWtFD./@+,n•/@+I./´/C>CA+WL%1bmDz:TD. 0/R1#:T/g

Ue:t™2UNR/():T/3Q1S:>D.H–>1X3o1F/Í./]Æ1#./]PLAE 0/(f`†)%91$ky/H‘:k38{/¢¶/´@A+(+()./Ue#E@  ' B+]B$bq#Æ(+()./@Eo1F/Í./x™

]+23—./@EmDnÎY:./a|L.1%HuPK].CŽ/83y/´@A}aM>o1X217^/u:./

Q(S}1Ï3,-#E³1).y/1t+,S}]P$|.H`3].CŽ/8]$>1./u:./3V$}?1i9?In6}W)% 21t:F&/ƒ„1:#./]Yœ/C./ 0/(f].CdL.83y/–% ',f\/Ck¿L©o1X217^/²1t}go1$d$}/Tgx™]P$|.H1e#A.3´@A}o/I%v3(fH

,  ' KC}ƒ„1:#./]+,-#./OMPL.¿.1./]S+,v,n?,-#L.³1tT˜.u:./O)Æ(F/CS./]P$|L./QCS}{/R6%($f 0/(fH9gpBd:./É1AG./9 'CA^/@E(F/CS./]P$|L./CN

Page 133: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 133/248

9:3; 9<4' 23=> ?71 !''

1ec)% pE /(f ($f {/R6% QCS} ]P$|L./ (F/CS./ 9y 81ek1$:f/ @AB+ u:./ ²/C>y/ q)›?†)t./H 0]K1œgg8;.Š9JKpBd:./É1AG./ ' A^/9C @E(F/CS./]P$|L./“I./@AB+9?

Q31S+3w™5(F1S./]#  ' de^/85R,P^/=#AB+]E31SE“?pBÆ@E(F/CS./v,ny/H,  ' KC}ƒ„1:#./]+,-#./ 0DN¨E 01E1No/j1$:E&Q/(:T/]$d$}/Tg]P$|.H1E(#F3

&9CA+OtS:GEOF1P:./ 0"eE"%=$K]+1PA./]tG>go1tG:A^/]+2CP./]$}6:^/@E82(z./

1e#$k&9CA}5,AK21-:>/,n•/‘:k2(z+5,AP.1%5(+(G./H@EUe^/9?,  ' XI:>9?]$d$}/Tg!5(k/C./5(k/C%"uN]$d$}/Tg5,S:GE~SK1E(#F9CA+’1$SEUM¶/

¸-¹ 01$.1F"%=$K]+1PA./]>21SE$+1SB%o1FCK(^/9 38363?H 'Wt}]$œ,P./]$>1./[F=f3ÁCM¶/=>?/Šg´@A+’1$SEUM¶/ 01)P},E"%=$K]+1PA./91X3qFD./

,n•/Q(:G+]$d$}/Tg!5(k/C./5(k/C%"89JKqFD./9CA$TOcK? 0&1k1E(#FQCS+Q/(:T1%2(z./931):./3OA7%8³31#:E3?‘:k1E(#F2(z+[FQ/3(./H8;.I.

/Šg91X@EpbC:^/Q(F]+§2qFD./,n•/8]$>1©9CA$T2(z./I#E8]+/(t./OA7%3

8Ä1tEOcK?@E9?9CA} 01P$|.H9gŒIi]S$Sš/o1$F/(}]PT¨Eo1FCBdBL.u:./h,)  * +1e#F1‡?OS:#}@E

91AEg,nr H(f3(k?{"LF2 'C|}’1#fy/]+¡t./Ð1$fC.C%3,>y/Ñ9?“,dz./1E(#F³S+@Ex™“,dz./pbC:+…3(k8qF1:^/"X9?x™“,dz./³S+@E

“,dz./52CM%8]t+,E=>ypbC:+=#E²/(¶/H

[FO$tT8m1^/U}{1F(:T/1t$t521+w.OP†+,E/(f@EÒ,dz./´3@A+CNq$t|./m3y/“I./U}8Œ§1F(:T/O%91Xq$t|./m3y/q™/,./`³1NI./HŒ1#SK/2

g]K,™QC#./8]$PL¶/=#A.3abC}D$Lb(#F]t:F³1%]K,™†+,^/Hm1SK 01t.1|E¥ŒIN521+w./a  ' LA:T]GÓ¡F8 0/2&3RU:>?3W#+(E\]GB%o/2&3R@E521+w./

]S%1G./H/C)KR?\@+¡F 0/2&3ROtb9?”YK?†+,^/H¦OTC:K=%,dz./WL„1b¥8 01#Gk8 01#GkOMY:T1e$LF¯~SK,->?gOP|./9•/H¦–©(k3o&Cfv,n?

@EÔ1S#./Otb9?O  ' n(}?H/C)œ3`Œ(+5¡Fo/2&3RK/CKq$t|./[F”YK

Page 134: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 134/248

!') "#$%&'%()%*+,-./%0 +12345-) 6,7.8

†+,^/H()%38521+w./–P7:X/9?8,dz./ 01E1S:>/@E8q$t|./´/C>CA+Wt™/2`pKR5¡)./o/2&3Rv,ny/q$t|L.H¸x%3,™"'@Ao1YPM./ 8"B4 C "B@¹H

`pB:·81$>2CP$.1X(f *39?,dz./&9C)K(+OXx}/CK8q$t|./Ue#A.3@AB;CDo1E/,™]+(Lt./]FÕ%¸(>&2C©CT"'@AÁ 8@B¹H5R1F31E–>1XŒINo1E/,z./Ö,P  * }Ue$LFqtG%mDn‚/x%/(:%uE2]E"S./H91X3/IN…(sW%£1T3?]FCB·

@E,dz./@+I.//C>1X93RC)+gP>]#+(^/OX{1:<H@E8ÖP^/9?,dz.//CK,F 9?U®(.]bDF5,B:GEpE]E(np‹o1+1P#./`;L}8]#+(^/´3@A+UN23(SB%9?/3(_]E(n]+(L%v,n?H[F3A)./@E8;.Š91X¬1#N[FQ/3(./R(F¾h1X@E

{1ty/`8]S|#^/UeLX°1:EQ1E?,dz./uA./C#AB:+@Ep|bUª1bDFq$t|%/CGT¨$.]bDFv,n?pEq$t,nr 1E(#F9CA+;.Š1+234!"" H

–G$.oDF1P:./5xMS./uN£¡./($kC./“I./O)_@E“(d^/9?9CA}m3?@E2(z+H]$.":k&1Kv,ny/uN9?931):./]1Gt%[email protected]+ 0&R1t:EH/Šg

91XOXR,K,nr OB):G+]$d$}/Tg2(z./8U„/(./1e#$k&@AB+R,PL.(k/C./9? OB)+ 01×$<OcK?@EQ/(:T/ŒIN]$d$}/T‚/1eGP>[email protected]"X1#Yœ3?`OMP./8¿.1./‘:kC.–>1X]tG>5xz›@EoDF1P}R,P./(b–©(kpE@+,n•/@+I./

9CE(:G+]$d$}/Tg]t$d:GE]$d$}/TJX55(k/C./5(k/C%.81e#$k9CA$T@E“(d^/Q/(:T/]$d$}/Tg55(k/C./5(k/C%.&(%@E2(z./m/C–bC./"XO)P+

U-)E{&¨N@+I./`²CB·91AG./H`m1^/uBb,./“I./U}=B+(S}¬1#N¸“?`OMP./¿.1./¹8/ Çž1:k,Ey/g]tG>]GÓ]„1^1%@EoDF1P}R,P./U:}pEWtF&

9CAL:B+ 0/xAP} 01Ï17E 01efC}3CY>Q/(:T/]$d$}/Tg55(k/C./5(k/C%.uA.O)_

{1cF?/INpBd:./~$Gt./9CECS+{/R6%OcK?@ECc)./`/IN²CBd^/É1AG./ “I./2(z+2/,B:T1%!#"H 

¸"¹ (+wBL.@E”MS./mCk]bD)./W%,dz./x™38,dz./,->?1c+?;+,#$X9CGXC%3¸"'@#¹81>1:#+CX(+CLK3¸"'@#¹89C:Xr ¸"'@%¹8“/CT3¸"'(BH¹

¸#¹ (B:)+/INm1^/]$LF1P.]$LBFp  ' Bd:./[FU$S./]$.1:./D - E 2'36 E A39 E $3? E "38 E BH

Page 135: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 135/248

9:3; 9<4' 23=> ?71 !'*

ON9CA$T¬1#N“?R,K,nr OE1):+O^1%mR1t:+3pE931):./\3y/2R1M./@E½R,P./`†)%8h3,-./9CA$T@Eq)M./ t#:./¨ tG^//IÏ,Ey/[email protected]

¬1#N–b3h1Xq+,d:.(+()./@Eo1$d$}/T‚/8]PL:^/²C$7.3†)%Ÿ,|./O)Žo1$d$}/T‚/,Xy/8 01k1d>1e#$k@AB+{,BL.9?9CA+ 01S©/3OA7%($f@E

=>?9CA$T¬1#N†)%R/,Ky/@+I./9CLE1):$TO^1%pE931):./HqtG./3{/23;.Š

CN=>?‘:kpBd:./xzM./ 01$tG>@E(F/CS./]+w$$B:./]P$|L./=#AB+9?°1:_ 01FCB·   01$>1AT@E8R1™3y/@E3U©@AB:+/INpBd:./@Ep:B:./£1S#.1%]$.1)./pEUec)%†)t./H1E39?OM€(F/CS./]P$|L./[FØCE8Q(b@AB::T@E]+1Ù1eGP>@E

,|n°1$:f&/[F(+R1™3y/H8pt|.1%3@AB+{,BL.9?m31s¥9?1et)L+OA7%V$Y›@Er3¦@EmDnQ1$S./

2(z.1%‘:k931):+qFD./8,n•/1e#$k3~SK?(t+CN931):.1%H[F3OX8m1kWt}ƒ„1:>].C|t./9?ŒIN]$d$}/T‚/uN`pb/C./]$d$}/Tg5x|n/(fHqtG./3CN9?

¬2(™\3y/OB:s9??(t+]$LBFQ1S:>/@Eh,qFD./,n•/H/IN3"A)c$T":>?91#©&/`pœ3q)›`].31±”$LÈ"A$GP>@E~B#./\3y/mDz:TD.3?2(z./mR1t:^/H/Šg1E Ç–tb1FQ1S:>&/“I./QCS+=%8,n•/9JK]LA7^/@AB+9?A)#}[F

OtS:G^/H/Šg31E–±1T8,n•/hCGK,1È2Ce-.1%,e-B%”7./O%1S./D.mDz:TH‘:k9g3–#X/2R1b[Fq#ÆŒINoDA7^/]L+C|./8(Ey/9JK]$.":k/

Q1S:>&/p+Õ./(œ¬2(™\3y/(b;L)_‘#B:}C.;>?(b–#Xa$|.I#E]+/(t./Ha7XO$LY:./u×$t./].C|tL. 01ttT 0/,nr  'Wt  * +52C|n9CX{,^/m3?@E2(z+H9g

5(F1S./5($kC./u:./´@A}8]P$|.u:./3oj,k?]t},E@Bœ]GB¶/5¡F5(F1b

3y/`].CŽ/]$>1./@E].C|t./o{1f3]t},^1%8]#E1./uN5(F1b!9C:z#+21NF*99=:G6H:.H(b3–E1bŒIN5(F1S./{/R6%($f1‡yoj,k? 011S>5($fpE

o1X217^/o/ŠwX/,^/]$>(:^/`].C|t./H`o&CŽ/]$œ/K&/]$LtS:G^/8].C|tL.–Yt›?o1X217^/o/ŠwX/,^/]$>(:^/O  ' A7}]tG>,z›?,z›?3@E91AG./H`3]+1‡8h1|^/Vt›?v(.5(F1S./x™]P$|L./u:./oj,k?`O›y//wX,E8/($fVt›?

Page 136: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 136/248

!'# "#$%&'%()%*+,-./%0 +12345-) 6,7.8

1®(.O$LS./@Eo1$d$}/T‚/u:./1e#AB+9?QCS}1e)E{/R6%($fH@E3U©–>1FŒIN5(F1S./1c+?U©–}1EH/I.9JKO$LY:./u×$t./Wt+9?Q1$S./{/R6%($fpE(F/CS./u:./

uN1eGP>´S€ƒ„1:>5($f9CA$T`,nr ,Ey/]$LBFQwNÅ/ŠH5¢)./31#NuN9?Q(F9CX]$d$}/T‚/]P$|.(b3(t+ 01×$< 0/(F/3`8]+/(t./@A.3[Fv(^/8($)t./

@AB+9?“R¨+gxE(}]×$t./1eGP>u:./3ž1:€1e$.g]$d$}/T‚/Ofy1ek1d>H

$!-& 456 ,-.7"2 829:;7" < =>?9@ A=B 09:*C"$D

9g°1d#./x™u)$t|./]$d$}/T‚55(k/C./5(k/C%.1>RCS}g]Y$M#./]|$Gt./]+CS./3]$.1:./Ì’ Z21EmR1t:./H()%931):./`5,^/83y/QCS}]$d$}/Tg

!5(k/C./5(k/C%"R,.1%O^1%[FOX1EQCS+=%qFD./,n•/`]LS#./]S%1G./H9gŒIN5(F1S./]|$Gt./uN5(F1b]#$:E[FCY>ÚN(EH(S.oj1K`].CŽ/3y/@E].C|t./

]$>3A.&/]t)L.]Lc)EWdG./@EmDnmCMš/[F~TC:E£1S>[F?@E“? ¾On(  * E@EoDn(^/u:./1eE '(b“,  ' -#E³1).y/WKY^/Hoj1K3]$d$}/Tg

!5(k/C./5(k/C%"5,Ev,n?1E(#Fo¡  * >ŒINƒ„1:#./–Fj33[FWGK1#:^/`].CŽ/ ]$>1./H91X/IN21M:>&/ 056f1PE8 0]Yœ/31^191Xp$BŽ/@+2R1b[F1eB+(S}]X217BL.`].CŽ/]$>1./()%]+§21ek1d>`].CŽ/3y/[email protected]@EVœ/C./9?

’1#.//C>1X9C#B:+9?Ue)TC%9?/CECS+{/R6%OcK?¯Ue#A.3/C>1XW×|‰H´wP}]$d$}/Tg!5(k/C./5(k/C%"`].C|t./8qGYKO%1‡g–E1b{/R6%OcK?

@E]+?5(F1bv,n?`o&CŽ/]$œ/K&/]$LtS:G^/Hm(+3/IN[F9?]$d$}/Tg!5(k/C./5(k/C%"&US}~SKOB)%($fpE²C#:./xtA./@E(F/CS./8]$L›y/O%Q '(S  * }

  0{/R? 0/($f 01c+?pE(F/CS./]Yf1#./u:./OB:  * s9?,e-}qG#%¢X?`OtS:G^/HueK´ ,  ' E(}’1T?1ek1d>Á1¶/H[F8A)./ueK,NRw}@EmDnoDF1P:./pE(F/CS./]Yf1#./v,ny/H

9g]BG./]$.R1t:./u:./o(GÆ`]$d$}/Tg55(k/C./5(k/C%.uN]BT5($f5($PE3³1tTy]+,-> 01c+?H1E(#F9CA+OtS:G^/ 0"eE"%=$K]+1PA./]>21SE841š1%

Page 137: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 137/248

9:3; 9<4' 23=> ?71 !'$

(d>9?55(k/C./5(k/C%.5,S:GE 01$F1‹H/IN3u#)+=>?/Šg91XOX”<Q(:G+55(k/C./5(k/C%.8–G$.¬1#N]Y$M>@AB+1eB+(S}qFD.W)EOcK?@E=YM>

96%Q(:G+55(k/C./5(k/C%.CN,n•/H3? '¢)#.@F,Ey/]z$M%8v,n?/Šg1E–#X/(X6:E@E9?qFD./,n•/Q(:G+]$d$}/Tg!5(k/C./5(k/C%"89?3OF1P:./hCT,B:G+–bC.8h1X 0/Šg;)TC%–>? 01c+?9?OB)}P>{Û./[email protected]‹]BG./

]$.R1t:./v(.!

5(k/C./5(k/C%"

@BA}`1‡CX5($f`Ÿ1|>pT/3@Eh3,-./H `8]S$Sš/9g55(k/C./5(k/C%.5($f 0/(f`w$$B:./W%(F/CS./u:./($):T1‡31)}\3y/R,}3O^1%¯“?9?931):}uNv,ny/¯(F/CS./3u:./@.O)P};.ŠH

‘:k1‡?]+w$$Ê]+1zL.qGkQCeP^/“I./Œ1#E(b`OMP./¿.1./H/IN3VBG+1i°1$:f1%´1F@ER1™3y/,z›6%pBÆ8@Al"X31#Yœ3?`]$œ,P./]TR1G./H]K1œg

g8;.Š1‡JKO%1S:TO^1%1E=L)P+,n•/@E¾2(™¾931)}3[F¾(k8{/CT1l1eL)_]L%1bj/wP:TD.HVœC}3]$œ,P./])%/,./9?1‡CX]L%1bj/wP:TD.CN`pb/3m1š/

qL|:E“234]tG#.1%o1$d$}/TÂ.]P$|L./ ¼X!

5(k/C./5(k/C%"

uA.@AB:}@E ]E31SE,|nÖ,):./°1$:fD.Hv(.]%1d:T&/2(z.@Eq>1fqFD./8,n•/OÊ55(k/C./5(k/C%.]>j/CE

W%]tb1)^/VE1G:./3H]$d$}/TJK55(k/C./5(k/C%.QCS}5R1F2(z.1%5,^5(k/3~SK()%OX].1k2(™QCS+1Ï8,n•/–>1X355(k/C./5(k/C%.]Yf1>/(f`].C|t./H

°S+3/IN].6GE1E/Šg91XQ1$S./OB%1EO)P+,n•/8~tc.1%5(k/385(k/C%CN9/w$^/,Xy/]$LF1KH@Eq)M./–t.//IÏ,Ey/9yo1$d$}/T‚/o/Šo1>j/C^/

]PL:^/ 0D$Lb´U:+1eB+(S}][email protected]œ/39?²/w:>/,X?@E52(™

5(k/3OA.52(™@Eh,|./,n•/hj1d$TÖ ',):.1%($)M:L.H@E]$k1#./8v,ny/ 9g²/w:>/1ECNOb?@E5(k/35(k/C.hj1d$TÖ ',):.1%mDz:TD.H1E?]$d$}/Tg!5(k/C./W:#©1%"ueK;L}u:./&2(z}&g1E()%2(z+qFD./

,n•/`OX@EW:LS#./W:S%1G./H8/I.ueK($)}5(k/C./W:#©1%H–>1XŒIN5(F1S./]±1G:^/ 01$tG>52R1S./[FjCP./`].CŽ/3y/@E].C|t./]$>3A.&/]Lc)^WdG./

Page 138: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 138/248

!'% "#$%&'%()%*+,-./%0 +12345-) 6,7.8

C.9?/(k?(bQ(S}1Ï]X217BL.H91X@AB+9?QCS}{/R6%($f1‡y–>1XvR1P::.o1E1ª&/5R1c^/].R1t:^/pE†)%@E(F/CS./v,ny/u:./–ttG}OX17^1%‘:k

]$d$}/T‚!5(k/C./5(k/C%"HpE8;.ŠuPK].CŽ/]$>1./@E8].C|t./1E(#FU} 0D)KU+(S}!5(k/C./W:#©1%"8´p|:G}j/,kg“?wX,E‘:kW%wX/,E¿L./[Fy/H

qtG./3`;.ŠCN9?].CŽ/]$>1./(boC:k/[F†)%(F/CS./u:./91X1‡1AEJ%

mDz:T/1e:t™2`]±1GEo/2(z./5R,P#^/H 9g’2(./ubDny/“I./Œ(B:G>@EŒIN]MS./CN9gvC:G^/$b(./@EVE1G:./“I./3CN\1E(B:)+[F]×$t./]|$Y^/H[F3=f38ÁCM¶//Šg91X,|¶/$„,./CNo1E1ª&/].R1t:^/u:./&]+1‡81i 0/Šg9CA$TvC:G^/U+,A./@EVE1G:./

  01×$< 0"„[email protected]/Šg91X,|¶/$„,./Å6+@Eo1$d$}/T‚/u:./9CA}5($f`mDz:T/(F/CS./]>,^/8]±1G:^/3 0/Šg9CA$T£/,K‚/`VE1G:./ 01PLAEH"#$%39CA$T

9j/C:./$b(./ 01×$<q)›(+(Y:./`]×$t./8]#$)^/9JK91N,%].C|t./°S+9?{Û./“I./³S+@E]%1d:T/5(k/C./5(k/C.82(zL."%29CA+ 0/,©¨E 0/(f`Ÿ1|>pT/3

@Eab/C^/o1$PL¶/3H8;.I.9JK]Y$M#./]B$S./qFD.uN9?mR1t:+2(z./"LEmR1t:+931):./H

%!4E"F;* +

Wt}ƒ„1:>].C|t./=>?`abCE]Lc)E8WdG./@EOeG./9?9CA}1$XŠ 0/(fH9g(F/CS./5(S)^/´US}{/R6%OcK?@E(F/CS./]|Gt^/H`8]S$Sš/9g1E‘BG+

(F/CS%(š/[Fy/ 0/xX1E–>1X“R¨} 0{/R?1P$)œ1‡y–>1X~SG}`q|E2(z./

mR1t:^/H9g]LA7^/]E1)./pEŒIN(F/CS./uN1‡?Q(:G} 01b,5(S)EQ1$SL. o1f1:#:T&1%mCkqFD./,n•/¯–>1X3ŒINo1f1:#:T&/]×1nH91X{wf@EqFD./ 9? [F  'm(+ =>? [F ,n•/ qFD./ Otb @E ut+,d:./ 2(z./ xGP} CN ]LA7^/ ŒIN

,n•/&@AB+=%IfCY>931):./[email protected]  * ›²CœC^/CN9?(F/Cb(š/[Fy/ŒIN´In6}91tGš1%9?1eXCLTÁ1¶/CN“I./RCS$TqFD./,n•/gx$z:./H

Page 139: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 139/248

9:3; 9<4' 23=> ?71 !'&

1E(#F2,S>1E/Šg1#XOBY#T8]  ' L-E$.1#$LF9?LS>@E9?QC$z./In6:T1#XCLT/INW)%21t:F&/H1#)TC%9?QCS>†)t%o1$LB)./]$%1Gš/]K,)^]›,K~b1G},|^/R1#:T&1%g³21d:./]S%1G./H[F3P>82/,z./`]t).ƒ}1>“,P›

¸]t)L./u:./9CA+1e$KqGAEm3y/521GnÉ1L.¹8]t)LX8ƒ>,|7./1##AB+9?Q(:G>Ö/K&/O„1S./96%qFD./,n•/I:$T]LS#./,Xy/52C|nu:./@AB+9?

8,KC:}1#)TC%39?hÍ:>1SK3;.I.H8/I.9CA$T@E“(d^/]tG#.1%1#.9?9CA> @+(  ' S)E@+2 'C|:E3`1#L$L€2(S%²1|:G  * ^/[email protected]³1).y/u:./–G$.o/I%ƒ}1>8“,P›]Lc)BXWdG./–G$./IANH

[)K†$S>8QC$z./@AB+qFD.,n•/9?q$d:G+;}/21$¶H[F3hDn]t).8ƒ>,|7./q_9?&¢:)+qFD./,n•/`]Lc)EWdG./1M<m31sŸ1šg

]B+wi/;%H9CA$TqFD./,n•/qb/,+;XCLTpt::$.†)%o/21<‚/mCk1E/Šg–#XmR1t::T931):./R,}3=$LFO^1%Q?8&/IAN39JK;XCLT@AB+9?A)#+]$>1©;$.gH

9g(F/CS./u:./m31€mC›C./g(š/ºby/`R(F1e1S>"#$%OE1)}qFD./,n•/[F=>?{wf–%1©@E]×$t./">guNOPz}ŒIN]$k1#./@E8OF1P:./ '†z%

,-#./@Fv(E1e„1XŠ`o1%1Gš/`Oˆ1ª1œ/K/5R(Y^/H8;.I.$.@E“(d^/9?9CA} 01$XŠ`~$B#}qFD./,n•/=L$A7}3/Šg–#X¬}]$LB)./]$T1A)>&/u:./

QCS+1e$KqFD./,n•/a$A:.1%8;)E–>?3QCS}a$A:.1%pE8,n•/@E3U©QCS+,n•/a$A:.1%pE;}1P$A}ULN3v,fH9g/IN+,|./ Ü+,|  Ç . Üq)›=F1t}g(+wB%@EOEy/@E?Of°1d#./H8($X6:.1%3´Ì–t  * }“?5(F1b@EW%(F/CS./5(S)^/OA7%3?

8,nÝ%u:./3U}1eB+(S}`“?@E8W:.CŽ/1‡?5($f 0/(f`/INm1d^/H @EŸ,|./v,ny/u:./m(}[F{1XI./xA./uNQ/(:T/]$d$}/Tg!Q1S:>&/U„/(./"HŒIN3uN]$d$}/Tg8931):./1^191XqFD./,n•/8 01>31):[email protected]&

931):} 01SL|E5,Ev,n?()%²Cb3m3?2(™@Eh,qFD./,n•/H"%39?ŒIN]$d$}/T‚/uN]$d$}/Tg8]P$|.1‡JKQCS}{/R6%($fpE(F/CS./]P$|L./H"X1‡?

Page 140: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 140/248

!)( "#$%&'%()%*+,-./%0 +12345-) 6,7.8

“R¨}{/R?/($fpE(F/CS./u:./´@A}]t$d:GE8 0/(f5(F1S.1X]$„/C7)./ 01E1ÊH1e#A.3–>1XQCS}{/R6%a$)œpE(+()./@E(F/CS./v,ny/1‡yULG:G}]FÕ%pE

(F/CS./u:./m31€Q1$S./2(z%8Þ Ç,  Ç F1e#A.35():GEpf/L.2CK1e:tb1)EH(b3(t}]$d$}/TgQ1S:>&/U„/(./]$XŠ1‡y,KC}[F?wK1k@Alq#d:.2(z./H1e#A.3]$T1b

/(f@EOf?1e:YLMEH

1E–./j¬1#N 01c+?]S+,].1©9CA}1e$K†)%(F/CS./]X217^/`].C|t./]$XŠ 8/(fuN31‡?pt  ' :}]$d$}/Tg8]$.":k/9CA}[F]f2R@E($S):./¿$Y%&@AB+o1$d$}/TÂ.v,ny/9?1Nw  ' $Ê@Fo/21$¶/]$„/C7)./]M.1¶/H521t)%8v,n?9g

($S):./£,P^/@AB+9?,e-+=>6X3ßCK]E1}H/ŠJK–#XQ(:G} 0]$d$}/Tg3(t}1‡6X38]$„/C7F *,e-:T 01c+?;>6¼X3x™³31d:EpEqFD./,n•/H/Šg3–#Xx™

8³31d:  * E 0/Š[email protected]}v(.qFD./,n•/]+?pK/3R931):L.;)EH/I.;>CAK,X?/($S)}@E9?;tFC:G+93,n•/CN{Ãx|n/(fH

8pt|.1%3=>JK`(+()./@Eab/C^/]$>1G>‚/@AB+{,BL.“I./Q(:G+5(F1b 5(S)E9?V   ' œC+³1tTy/{/23OX21$:n/qFD.,n•/HpE38;.Š,e-:T]LA7^/1eGP>H(b9CA+qFD./,n•/ 01%1},  * E@E³1tTy/u:./U:+1eB+(S}1E(#F9CA}5(S)E

  0/(f¿$Y%3(t};L}³1tTy/1‡6X3]F‰ 01M$Mn;L:.]tT1#^/H`OEŒIN8h3,-./(b;A7+qFD./,n•/`RCf3]+?]%1d:T/Y:G}]+1F,./H/I.9JK

qFD./,n•/(b¢:)+5(F1S./u:./3(t}x™8])bC:E1N¢:)+x™]L%1b°D›Â.HRCS$T3/INž1:#:T&/g2(z./52CM%]$)$tH

9gv(kgŸ,|./u:./ 'ÕP}°1d#./xtA./]$d$}/T‚!5(k/C./5(k/C%"`

].C|t./uN1‡?p:B:}°CœC%xtXueK]Yœ/3@Al1Ï1)$:T/OA7%xtX@EOtbqFD./,n•/H1E(#FQ(:G}]$d$}/Tg!5(k/C./5(k/C%"8,KC::TqFD.,n•/

  0]›,K 05j1:lUeP.1EQCS}=%H;:%1d:T1K5(k/C.1%¯5(k/C.{/jg“?2(™uN~B>OeTU$$S:./H9CA$T3;XCLTÎtS:G^/1e#$kOeTpbC:./H2CK3…3(k8/IN@AB+

qFD.,n•/9?v,+].CeG%9?]S+,|./OcKy/OE1):L.pE]$d$}/Tg!5(k/C./

Page 141: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 141/248

9:3; 9<4' 23=> ?71 !)!

5(k/C%"uN931):./1e)EH/Šg31#œK/96%]t)L./,B:G:T]LS#.]$K1œg5(k/3~SK[F8Oby/[email protected]}¬1#N]|n1E(#F=f/C}]$d$}/Tg!5(k/C./5(k/C%"

OcK?@E9?931):}9•/@EOf?9?‘SL:}931):./`]LS#./]ER1S./H5 ',E8v,n?;.1#N†b1#}UeEW%]t).ƒ}1#./8“,PM./8ƒ>,|7.1X]t)L./3u:./

–G$.ƒ}1#%8“,P›]t)LX]Lc)EWdG./52,A:^/H`8ƒ>,|7./@E($P^/9?O)Æ

qFD./,n•/ 0/2R1b[FWBȬ1+/C>H"LAKoR/Rj/¬CA<qFD./8,n•/"LX–>1X =:$d$}/TgOb?5{1PXH"X9?{1Png1+/C>{,^/($PE`o1$PLn]t).ƒ}1#./“,PM./¿$k9?OXŸ1Png`¬CLTqFD./,n•/u#)$T 01Y%23? 01tGAE]tG#.1%;[email protected]

`abCE]t)L./u:./uN–G$.o/Šƒ}1>“,P›[email protected]+,Ey/ 01+(·[FQ/3(.//Šg1E–Yt›? 01$XŠ 0/(fH–>?($P:G}@E931)}qFD./,n•/`]Lc)EWdG./

52,A:^/H]L$š/3uN9?p  ' d7}[F…3(k;.Š931):./HOcK?3]S+,Q1$SL.;.I%uN9?Vœ 'C};>?():GE931):L.OE1):./3O^1%H@AB+39?9CA}o"LA./1#No/Š

85(„[email protected]"Xh,)+8p$BŽ/m1)Ky/ULA:}OA7%àL%?@Eo"LA./H/IiqtG./9CA}m1)Ky/]LeG./UeP./]$d$}/T‚!5(k/C./5(k/C%"]z.1%x©6:./H

 

Page 142: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 142/248

!)" "#$%&'%()%*+,-./%0 +12345-) 6,7.8

 

Page 143: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 143/248

 

"#$%&'()*+ ,&-. 

"#$%&'()*+,-'./0#1234+5'6789:;&<=>?@A=,4B'A=C=D'EFG'HI;,JKLM&?@9 N/3%DK1*O@P&QE-'?QHR%4-STJQ2U2$VW-'6(  N X@*+,-'YUH;-'"3#1 ZH,4%[6\]^_JH>A4L`5'aH#)<=>b+#Jcd,-'e(-'?H>fg=hij=U N2R16

'78H1_3MFA=,4B'A=C=D'EFG'kWVH,%-HUA4&/l-'mUn=^A&H,L-'2Uoc'd^p'?q^r0R1bsH+#-'k.Ht@u8vH$Fp'i%-'<]Dw'.Q?/>cd,-'xHJp' ZH$y'.f?QHR%-'

"%z?8Q?H>aH#){^Hz|+}\1p'~C`&•V€\V?QHR%-'6KL-Q'78KL&*VH,%-'*&/‚o\1p'HI#=z?/L=FxHJp'*ƒ^@ Z„HzfiR;-'<4…\s'/,-'†|+]-'o\1p'

€/]&Q.\‡-HU6m>?@'()o*+,-'K1A=zHJoˆd…@„*1HR%&~1A=,4B'A=C=D'EFG' d1:>~}'Q6*U9wH;%&<=>KLM&wdM4-?@‰  NQd&?QHR%4-ST#&QK19W…*&/ŠA=,4B'A=C=D'EFG'H‹'7 !•V*=$Fo9HŒ5'K19W…~=F/D**$]%;5'6

†cHVH1\]%R&wd5'?@?QHR%-'wŽ\=O6S()Qi)A]&dl-'A=R=$l-'H1\#V"  N #$%&wd5'./0#12$VW-'rI;,J@6•VQ*>o9Hz?q^?QHR%-'9cH$%5'\=OA$;#-HUWL-

Page 144: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 144/248

!"" "#$%&$ '()$*+,-./$0 +12345-& 6,7.8

2$VW-'fA4ƒR12C;-'6'(-   ‘ %L   =F'()*+,-'K1AIOQd0JA=,=>P&QE-'?QHR%4-nR=F/DQ6~1o’-7m>H#zE}'o ZH]UHFaH#)<}'/1\&d&HI=^wd5'?@*R,&“LR-' ZH1H”6KM^*O@~#1~&.H`5'A&.HC%-'K1\&\Šo.HRFp'K1Q*O@~#1w'\Vp'

24M%35'K1Y=;#DormV@\&|Fwd5'?@4]&A]&dl-' ZH1H”*R,&Q“LVwH=tp'i%-'K1H–:t?@‰  NQdD?QHR%4-6

\]-_=  N M   FA4ƒR12C;-''(—rF„'$;U<}/1'(I>678eQdDA+]-' A=4˜p'?@2L&™fAM&dOrDmH]%V'm—'/C%F'Q*L`Uo*+,#1e@ š*>•VS\z6~=l%;&*>\z'QmI#1?@.\‡&d…›HUK19W…œ'EV„' ZW1@9/+HU•VrLz

<,[6KL-Q'78œEV'o?H#ž„'?q^m‹H^'EV'K-?/LDk'(UAM=}6K1A=zH#-'oˆd…p''78H1HJQHRD~1HŸ\z@od…›'K19W…mIƒ^.oœ'EVW-K4^~=l%;&

iV\5'€HR-'fA]l#5'?@mI#&\&„8AMI%UA&/JHž6'78H1H#E^'?@„\z@K12  ‘ $VW-'n&\-“O'/)A=}W…@Q@A=`…K1n1H=}oAJH=BHU?q^FHL5'*L`%FHI#=zA4ƒR1

2CF¡H^H&.Q ¢/-!"#$£ o¤"%¥"#¦6K1AIOQd0Jo~M%C5'nJ8w§-\=O?@€H1@2L&T-'A=-m%z'A,=Rf?@"]4   &¨$]-'mI=4Vf“,J<}/5'oA=JHž•Vˆ\5'

&d]-'•Vo*}p'?p'()/)g$ƒ-HU$;-'e(-'*R©K1A34+1*>\z'QmI#1?@?/ªd…›'6

H5H‚?@*VH,%-'“=-o'.dL%1?/L=F?QHR%-' ZH$R˜ Z'\O6'()/)$;-'e(-'*ROr)@A]&d‚P&QE4-?QHR%4-nR=F/DQ/)€H=]-'=DE-HU*R«“,J2+¬`-'

?H=]%4&mIƒR$U†d1oˆd…@?@QHJ/L&K&.cH}•V{==”mIƒRUK1AUdC%-'oA=H5'?@Qd>(%&*>\z'QmI#1<=>œ NDd…›'nR1"%zS()A034-'6?8'()?QHR%-'

*˜'/%5'/)e(-'*R©K1KLM5'A$;#-HU?QHR%4-i#$5'•V9cH$%-'?@?/L& Z'd]%;16®:DQA3=+#-'i%-'*1HR%D~1A=,=>P&QdD'()?QHR%-'9cH$%5'STJQfAžWž

€H;}@¤*RO*$]%;5'dŒ>@A=Ÿ@AJ.H]1¯HHU|=‡DQFHL12$VW-'A=D:%5'K1PsH%#-'~U.p'A#LM5'*L-A4]Jr=4RDQ2$VW-'r=]-HUYsH]'Qk'.HI5'Qi%-'‰  NQEF

?QHR%-'ST#DQ6

Page 145: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 145/248

 971:03;<-& =0%> !"#

!"""" #$%&'() *+, -. /0 

KLM&?QHR%4-9cH$%5'?@?/L&'d]%;1'78H1?H>*$]%;5' ZmI1*L`UœH> ZH=$;JAJ.H]5HU~1¯H'6~Od&Q'()u8?@2$VW-'?/R=l%;&b&/4%-'\&\I%-HU€H]%J„HU

\.\yd…›'¥'78H1dM%F'*VH,%-'†E,-A4&/‚mUn=^A&H,L-'°=3UKLM&?@*R©\&\I%-''dž±16?8†\)H`1A=,=>*MV'()d1p'f9HŒ1iM}.bM;=FK&/L%U²dl-'

A4&\$-'i%-'KLM&?@~  N F/DK19W*$]%;5'6m>QfoYUH;-'³E^'?@FHL5'i%-'KLM&HI=]4DfA4]#-'A1cH]-'„eQH;D

ˆ/FA$;JA%UHžK1“,JFHL5'i%-'KLM&HI=]4DfA4]#-'A=-H'6d  N >(D?@¢H=]1r+B''()¡&¦“LR&2$$Fw'.Q?/>*$]%;5'*}@A=Ÿ@K1¯H'6o„Q@\}„dM%;&*VH,%-'6\]^k/M&'()VW-'Q@a'7Q@“4,   &Q@*]%#&u8?HL1d…´ Q@?@

A}WR-'\}iI%#Dep$Fd…´ 6mUQnJ@„KLM&±$#%-'S(—*1'/R-'*L`UY=}co\>±1Q?q^A4]#-'A1cH]-'_;=-A=Ÿ:UA4]#-'A=-H'6\]^„?/LDaH#)A4]JA1cH}6H1@

$;-'xHŒ-'w'.Q?/>*$]%;5'*}@A=Ÿ@K1¯H'/I^?@c'd^p'†cHVH1?/4   N ƒ,& 9/+'•V;L12R1o€/=-' Z„\UK1.H0%J„'K1*O@“,J;L5'"%z€/&\y6~M%©QW>K&|ž:%-'WRC=-A4]#-'A1cH]-'*}@A=Ÿ@K1A4]#-'A=-H'6

?89HŒ5'iM}d-'/)9HŒ5'œ/-:5'A4ƒR52C;-'†.dL%5'k'7FHL5'A=-H%-'¤w'dy8.\‡-'wH#ž@?QHRDœdl-'d…›'€ N\]&' ) #†:^HL1Q?QHR%-'9cH$%5'i)* ) +o

H1@AU/]V.\‡-'9cH$%5'iI^, ) !oH1@FHL1*  N ,‡5'?QHR%4-H1\#V.\‡&œdl-'d…›'¡e@kHV/^\1*  N ,‡5'¦iI^- ) .6³E^'A034-†\z'Q?@A4]#-'A=-H%-'eQH;D

".AsH5HUK1AM=}A4]#-'oA=-H'Hµ*R©AM=}¢H=]1r+B'& ) ./"6 Z'78/-?H> VW-'d…›'€\¬%;&A=C=D'EF8"†\z'/-'†\z'/U#K-?/L&.\‡-' ZH&\¶A$;#-HU’-6~$#&Q'()†™H$1K1A=d,-'oA=JHŒ-'i%-'HJ·X"%1?/LDA=C=D'EF8"†\z'/-'

†\z'/U#†d]%;1oH=VH¸KL-QKLM&†cHV8~M«'A^dR5A=,=>HI4MV6?8€\V.\‡-'\#VAIO'/1A=C=D'EF8"†\z'/-'†\z'/U#ilR=FAl]JAM=]U* f*>A4]J6\RUQ(…@

Page 146: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 146/248

!"$ "#$%&$ '()$*+,-./$0 +12345-& 6,7.8

9\R1r+B'o?H$;HU?q^'()~MC%&fAO.cA=-H¸8AR}/%1 ¹4-*0&*0&1* 666i%-'Q* 23!4&56'78_JH>*)+ Q& ) ./"?/L=Fº/MC5'+.Al]J6

“=-’RF/U?@€/]D*ƒ^:UK1’-76'78_M}.\‡-HUodM%;5'*+3%F•VFHL1ow'dyG'' ) #ofA4]#-'ouQp'’#L-Q\RU’-7*+3%F•VAU/]V.\‡-'o9cH$%5', ) !6'()Q*+=Fu8H1nV/M¶!%Al]J!!"6º/M¶Q!%Al]Ji)WU’t

“=-†\=Oº/MCM>2žWŒ-'Al]Ji%-'KLM&?@*+ŠHI=4VK19W…?QHR%-'6 ’#LM& ZHƒ&@?@v Nd»vQH#%-'2U.\‡-'o?QHR%-'Q¨&dRDQA=C=D'EF8"†\z'/-'†\z'/U6o9W‡%FW-?/LDQA,4L%-'?@³dR%D9W‡%FW-_J@’;,JfkW]#-'AUQH#%5'¡e@2UA4]Jˆd…@Q6¦’3#M=FQ'()H1nV/M¶176+Al]J!1"6'()Qr}d-'WU

’t/)*ƒ^@K1¼H]#-'ARU.p'TVA=D:%5'K1.\‡-'odM%;5'n#L-Q“=-*ƒ^:UK12žWŒ-'Al]JA=D:%5'K1?QHR%-'rs'\-'~1A=C=D'EF8"†\z'/-'†\z'/U#6K1Q21Hƒ1

A=d,-'A=JHŒ-'i)nJ@'78KLD2DH)2%=C=D'EFG'*ƒ^@o Z„Hz~1A=C=D'EF8"

†\z'/-'†\z'/U6

oK1?QHR%-'o9cH$%5'?q^A&@A=C=D'EF8ˆd…@K-~=l%;D?@?/LD *ƒ^@o Z„Hz•V²W‚G'6H1\#Vi]4&*$]%;5'n-W0Uo†|$L-'m>“LR#&’-7f¢H=]1r+B'½HR-'

¾-H$-'".oAsH5HU Z'78?/L=FK1e\C5'?@?QHR%D~1¿¬`-'e(-'€\¬%;&A=C=D'EF8"†\z'/-'o†\z'/U6'(Qo$;-'?/L=FK1e\C5'€'\¬%F'A=C=D'EF8

"†\z'/-'†\z'/U#6o'(L)Qc/O/$^*Œ1S()9W0-'A=4$]%;5'†|$L-'†H]45'•Vo¯H'?/L&?QHR%-'i#$5'•V9cH$%-' Z'd]%;16

 

¡!¦ ?8AO.c.\‡-'rs'\-'3899 :5~1 R4& H1\#VA=C=D'EF8;†\z'/U †\z'/-'#i)'0 &, 0

&1, ///i) i%-'Q' 0 &,3! 0 & 0 <5i%-'Qi)' 0&,23! = &5K1Q°=zo€H}.p''()eQH;&>#0 ./" ? !2./! ) !%

¡1¦ ilR&vQH#Dd…›' VW-' €\¬%;& H1\#V ?QHR%-'Q .\‡-'A=C=D'EF8;†\z'/U †\z'/-'6AO.c' 0 &- 0 &1' 0 &+-<i%-'QKLM&?@g  N ;$DK19W…'()3'0&-523!4&15Q@

3#0/.523!4/" ?/"5 ) 17/+6

Page 147: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 147/248

 971:03;<-& =0%> !"%

|‡%&Q<}/5'H1\#V„?/LD9W*$]%;5'†|$>'\O6A&Àd-Q'()od1p'³E^'?@¢H=]1r+B'\}¨,¬J'K1".AsH5HUu8+.AsH5HU6KLM&?@ˆ{R   &'()

³H,¬J„'u8A=-m%z„'†|$L-'?:U?QHR%-'iI%#=Fo ZH$&d}Q@u8*=ƒ,%-'·>p';LM4-™H$5'•VwH.G'Q@ºH$tG'o*O±5'Q@u8e@A$=>dDK1K&()241HR-'6

 A=C=D'EF8 €\¬%;& d…›' VW-' ?@ ³E^' oˆd…@ †d1"†\z'/U †\z'/-'#6_JQHRD '78

nR1*+3%;^•V†:^HL5' * 

 L-* oA4]Jm>fYUH;-'6?/L%FQ’%O.cAR}/%5'i)* 2

3! = &5m>foYUH;-'KL-QS()AM=]-'?›'„eQH;DdŒ>@K1%6+K1¼H]#-'AC=%JAM=]4-Aƒ,¬#5' ¹4-¡&¦6*)’JHL1qU?@*R,DH1/)Á*ƒ^@'78H1_M}.\‡-HU•V

o€'Q\-'*+3%;^•V' ) #fA4]#-'ouQp'\RUQ’-7*+3%F•V, ) !6'()Q~M©H1S.'\]1#6%oAl]Ji)Q*ƒ^@Hµ’#LM&?@n$;LDK19W…acm%V'<l4-'f

?QHR%-'6H1@vQH#%-'2U.\‡-'?QHR%-'Q€/]=;^w'c:U*ƒ^@K1o'()H]]h761Al]J6K1Q*O@?@?/L& Â**$]%;5'*}@ Z'./ƒzd‡˜@Qo ZmCznJq^<}/&ˆQ\O’JQHRD

~1VW-'d…›'¥"%z?8Q?H>VW-'d…›'?QHR%=F~1’JQHRD6

?8KL&K1e\C5'A$;#-HU’-?@o?QHR%Dœ/FK-?/L&d1p' ZH&\¶A$;#-HU VW-d…›'?@?QHR%&/)d…›'6'(-H1\#V„?/L&¢H=]1r+B' ZHR,Dd1mUn=^oA&H,L-'KM^*M%35'?@?/L&?QHR%-' Z'c/],1*L`U€HDQ@ ZH=,%[*L`U~&Ã6?8'()

‰H%#%F„'„\M%R&•V€'\¬%F'A=C=D'EF8"†\z'/-'†\z'/U#o?pA=d,-'AŒ-HŒ-'K1*+,-'°-HŒ-'_#  N =U?@A&@A=C=D'EF8?/LD9Q@K1?QHR%&?/L%F†d]%;1g]^'78

?H>¢H=]1r+B' ZHR,Dd1mUn=^ÄA&H,L-''()Qi#R&nJ@“=-aH#) ZWLt Z'd]%;1K19HLt@?QHR%-'H1\#V„?/L&?QHR%-'mI1mUn=^A&H,L-'AJ.H]1¯HHU6

\>±&Q'()‰H%#%F„'•VA=Ÿ@A]&dl-'uQp'fP&QdD?QHR%-'¤~=F/D9W *$]%;5'S|ž:DQ6aH#)Q?H%]&d‚€H=]4-'(—d1p'¤K19W…*ROkWVH,%-'A#=%1dM%;DQ†E,-A=#1Åo9/‚@K1Q9W…HI4ROdŒ>@ Z'.'dLD6

?8A]&dl-'dŒ>p'†™H$1~=C`%-?QHR%-'i)*ROkWVH,%-'dŒ>@AJH%1'.'dM%F'Q6•V*=$Fo9HŒ5'?8*,zœH^{-'/)*R^€HVr  N M   ˜wH,%zW-P&QE-'QAJH%5

Page 148: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 148/248

!"& "#$%&$ '()$*+,-./$0 +12345-& 6,7.8

A}WVA#=R16KLM&?@\VH;   DAJH%1*VH,%-'“=-g]^oA$zp'*Uw'\Vp' ZHƒ&@69HŒ5'QÅdUp'b=/%-S()Al]#-'?H>f€H0J;ÆVºcQa|yÆ=R&6e(-'rDSd&/lDf

²cH#B'A=-H%]-'?HU8vd'A=5HR-'ouQp'e(-'Q Nd1Sd>76m>QH#0z„f*+,-'o~U'd-'H1?H>|yecH=%V'9/z9H%}²cH#B'/)?@k'\z/-'A&dL;R-'HI;,J_JH>

faHL%z'~1HIƒRUo¨R$-'dM%F'k'E,-A=#1ÅA4&/‚6\}Q'/^dV?@r‹WVH,D

dM%;%FnJpKL&e@\z'QrI#1)(&u8e@?HL1d…´ 6H1@fvQd'oA4]#%5' KLM&†\z/4-A&dL;R-'†|‡+-'?@nO'/D†\zQA&dL;VA,4%[K1Q\R-'f*>†d1?/L&HI=^oaH$%t'o½H%-HUQœ/FK-?/L&K1e\C5'?@@\$D?QHR%-'•V*1@?@cd&cd,-'d…›'Q@†\z/-'†|‡+-'ˆd…p'o*Œ5HU?QHR%&Q¥Q@?QHR%D¥m=^\RU6KL-Qf

A>dR5'oA%UHŒ-'?/L&*VH,%-'2Uk'\z/-'A&dL;R-'†|‡+-'„ N/l1†E,-K1K1{-'6bM;&Q'()*VH,%-'9 N/l5'¼mJp?QHR%-'A=#$5'•V9cH$%-'?:U?/LD†d&\OoA-QH35HUbM;DQH?:U“F:%D6

A]&dl-'Qˆd…p'~=F/%-./ƒz*$]%;5'i)*ROkWVH,%-'dŒ>@ Z'.'dLD6f*Œ1S()o9H'?HVÃH1~]&*VH,%-'od…›''(—Q?q^A4]#-'A1cH]-'Ç/4%FfY^p'·>@HµKLM&fœW…’-76“LR#=F'()9\R5'\&'{%5'K1kWVH,%-'f†cH&ÅfAM=}¡&¦oi)QAM=}A4]#-'A1cH]-'AJ.H]5HU~1A4]#-'A=-H'6

K1rI5'?@KM  N  X?@¢H=]1or+B'&oi#$1•VA=Ÿp'A=$;#-'A4]#-A#=R1†\z'QAJ.H]1~1A4]#-'A1cH]-'i%-'oHI=4D“=-Q†E,-A=#1ÅA#=R1i%-'QHI=4D6o’-(-

'78H1·%V'?/$VW-'?@ ZH$;L1Q@ ZH3U.H1œ/Fr%&\RU2%#FK1?›'•VnJ@eQH;&g]^<+JH1eQH;&;L5'Q@bUd-'e(-'r%&o€/=-'?q^A]&d‚P&QdD?QHR%-'

?/L%Ff*ROr‹WVH,DdŒ>@ Z'.'dLD6K1Q²dl-'†\=«'†cH&{-.'dLDkWVH,%-'2UK&cd^2#  N =R1i)?@\ È R$   D£H¬tp'K&d…›'6•R^*=$Fo9HŒ5'H1\#V“F±&?H#ž'K1./=l-'A]l#1A=M=4}8

'(I^i#R&nJ@?/L=FmÉ\-c\V*=4}g]^K1?'|«'6'()QS.Q\Ui#R&m–@?H=03=FkWVH,%U†.dL%1 ZH=$;J~1c'd^p'K&(-'f.'/«'6KLM&Q?@Y$l#&w§-'n;,J•V

Page 149: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 149/248

 971:03;<-& =0%> !"'

A>T-'A&.HC%-'i%-'HÉ\-†\VH}A=M=4}8fA]l#1oA#=R1i%-'Q€/]D~=$-HUw'T-'Qg]^~1kH>T-'A4=4]-'†\O'/%   5'fHI%]l#1A=M=4}G'6•VQ/3JonUH`1?q^e@º/JK1

¿+¬%-'e(-'*=M&u8\&\ŠkWVH,%-'H)zQc\RU*=4}K1K&d…›'º{#=F/3J*ROS()kWVH,%-'~1’-7c\R-'*=4]-'dŒ>@ Z'.'dLD6'()$F\z'Qg]^w'.Q

./I?QHR%-'A-/I;UdŒ>@f?\5'†|‡+-'n#1f?\5'ˆ·L-'6m>nJ@$;-'n=O/-'

w'.QA-QHh¨RUkH>T-'i%-'¢.H”AVH#˜A;JHC%1cHRU8kH>T-'†\&\«'i%-' KLM&?@ N ]  ‘ DHIRCƒ1Y È 4]   DQc/=]-'AÊd5'AQd,5'•VoA;^H#5'i%-'Q_1H#D_M}H,DQfAVH#+-'†\  N =]5'6o'|…@Q?q^~sH$-'9 N/C%5'Q@*1HR-'e(-'*MR&dO:U

i1/&?HR%M%=FkH}WRUoA=JQHRDA=1H#%1~1oK1{-'~1KsHU{-''78H1?H>KsHU{-'?Qd&*1HR-'Q@dOH%-'•V¢[email protected]%#1*IF@Hµ?/L=Fn=4V9H'/-HŸQ\)Htfk'E^A=#1ņ\VH$%1|yQAR  N }/%16'()@\$5'/)n;,J•V€'Q\-'¤kWVH,%-'†.dL%5'\VH;D•VP&QdD?QHR%-'d]%;5'6

~%M%&*;4;%-'i1d'r=0#%-'QA=Ÿ:UA=4VH^Q2D|$>*L`U£H…f{=>dDkWVH,%-'2Uc'd^p'2#  N =R5'6°=z*L`%DA-HzA=‚'d}Q|U*R»¢H#-'o?/++¬%&

~C`DQ¢H#-'K&(-'?/4MR&•V€HI1AlU'E1•V?@'/4  N %L%&A&/F6\&{DQS()AF.m5'A=M=0#%-'K1.'dLDokWVH,%-'Hµ*R©d1p'*IF@•V9mR-''Q. N/l=-kH}WV

A=JQHRD†d]%;16A^H8u8o’-7H1\#V4l%DA-:;1A#=R1Y=;#%-'2UºQd,-'A,4%¬5'K1oAM0#5'bM;&*;4;%-'i1d'A-:;M4-?:U9H    Šu8ºH  N #   ˜AFH=;-'fkH&/%;5'

H=4R-'K&(-' Z'|Œ>H1?/41HR%&~1rIƒRU¨R$-'£/+¬U*Œ1S()*sH;5'6K1Q9W…¼H$D.'¢H#-'~1rIƒRUfA$R-A4&/‚o\1p'†c\R%1kH&/%;5'o*z'd5'Q€/]D

S()km0#5'†cH&{Uc\VkWVH,%-'A=4$]%;5'oHI%=Ÿ@Q’-(UQ‰  NQdDº   NËDQ./I ?QHR%-'2UkHV/MC5'†|$L-' Z'\O°=3U„~=l%;D*VH,%-'•V/3Jecd^6'()QS.Q\Uc/]&u8. N/lDkm0#5'KLM%%-K1*1HR%-'~1*sH;5'·>p'dŒ>p'Q Z'\=]RD6

A^HGHUQu8*RO?QHR%-'dŒ>@o Z'.'d]%F'?q^{=>dDkWVH,%-'°=3Ui]%4&*>cd^c\RUcQ\hK1K&d…›'n-†\sH^ˆd…@6/I^\VH;&•V.'dM%F'?QHR%-' ZHƒ&@6

Page 150: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 150/248

!#( "#$%&$ '()$*+,-./$0 +12345-& 6,7.8

m>QHJd>7fA`}H#1Ì~MC%-'Íf*+,-'o°-HŒ-'?q^"%z~MC%-'|‡+-'K1c'd^p'n#LM&ÇH=%O'º/M¶xHLF|$>K1cHyQp'6„\U?@~%M%&wHƒV@~MC%-'A$;#U„

¢:UH—K1kWVH,%-'m=^orI#=U"%z?8Q_JH>r0R1r‹WVH,D~1€/MV?HL;-'6\}Q N2U9HŒ5'iM}d-'ˆ\1A-/IFd1p'A$;#-HU~MC%4-|‡+-'K1i$V„A=C=D'EF8

;†\z'/-'†\z'/U6€H=]4-ÇH=%OHUº/M¶xHLFK12$VW-'K&(-'?Q.\‡&•V€'Q\-'6

c/O/UQr  ‘ =}FHL5'A=3=/%-'A&.H=R5'A=-H%-'¡ ¤' ) #@ * ) +@ , ) !@ - ) .

¦ ¢H=]1Qr+…9\%R1AM=]U¡& ) ./"¦o‰H%z'wHƒV@~MC%-'u8?@?/LDA$;J#

AsH5HUg]^K1r‹WVH,D~1wHƒV@K&d…´ K1~MC%-'K1*O@?@'/4R©?QHR%-'@\$&fHVcHyQp'6

?8{=>dDkWVH,%-'i)ˆ\z8²dl-'*R«2#ž'K1c'd^p'?H=]%4&*L`U.dL%16f²H=FoA1QH;5'?/LDA]&dl-'ˆd…p'*R«r‹WVH,DdŒ>@ Z'.'dLDi)As{»

H&Hƒ]-'u8~l}†|‡˜6†dl=;-H^•V.H`%J'oA34Fp'Q@A=}H,D'º{#-oÇW;-'•V

*=$Fo9HŒ5'KLM&HI%s{»u8†\V*z'd16'()Qœ/FbM;&2^dl4-€H=]-'\&\R-HU K1kW]#-'†|‡+-' ZH=$;J Z„\UK1A4]J†|$>†\z'QQ@2%#ž'6?8€H=]-''(—d1p'*R©AM;-'A=-cH$%-'dŒ>@A=4VH^6'78QH1œdVW>2^dl-'?@A4]#-'|yAMsW5'i%-'€/]&H—

œdl-'d…›'KLM&?@n  ‘ O'/   D.\‡U9cH$%1fA4zd5'oA=JHŒ-'HI#=z?/L=F?H#ž„'   ‘2]ž'QK1?@A=4MR-'*MR%Fm>/)~}/%1HI#16o~$l-HUQ?q^9'±;-'“=sd-'f

†dl=;-'•VA34Fp'/)H1'78?H>*>œd‚K12^dl-'~=l%;&f~}'Q9H'?@œdR&H1\}n4R^œdl-'d…›'fA4]#-'A=H5'¥H1'78?H>?Qd…›'\}'/JQHRDK19W…wH,&G'or‹H1'{%-HU€@K19W….\‡-'AR&\B'Q6KL-QA$;#-HUA&pAO.cA#=R1

K1A]Œ-'f†.\}*>œd‚K1œ'd‚p'•V NÎ]DoƇ-'?q^c/OQ\&\R-'K1 k'/lB'†|‡+-'\VH;=FfP&QdD?QHR%-'oSTJQAJ.H]1c/O/Uk'/l…†|$>KL-QA4=4}6?8’=L,D*VH,%-'‰  NQd&?QHR%4-dM%;   5'K19W…*ROFHL5'i%-'

®:DK1Ƈ-'fA4]#-'A=-H'*}@A=Ÿ@|ŒLUAJ.H]5HU~1FHL5'A=D:%5'K1?QHR%-'9cH$%5'KLM5'fkW]#-'A=-H%-'6

Page 151: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 151/248

 971:03;<-& =0%> !#!

?8@\$1’=L,%-'/)@\$1ÏMV'\O6\]-  N D.ed#)dC#=;=>vH3;J„*=s'Ã8K1wH#=F\RUvdz€HV!"$+w\$4-f*z'd5'i%-'rDHI]=;#D~1kW]J

2&5'i%-'QkcH}u8kH}WVA=R=$‚~12=4=s'ÃG'6*   N ƒ  ‘ ,   D9mVp'A&.HC%-'A$-Hl5'~^\-HUkH=$4l4-†|$L-'•V*Lto*z'd1\#VkH=4MVor=4;%-'„\UK1.H0%J'¾4$5'fH+-'½H¸G'fA&HI#-'6?8\>:%-'K1?@.\‡-'fA4]#-'A=-H'“=- ZH&d‡1

  Z'\OAJ.H]5HU~1.H;5'Ï$]%;5'n%1dU/)A]&d‚†\=OT#-?QHR%-'6KL-QA]&dl-' ˆd…p'i)|=‡DFHL5'Q@kH$;%L5'HI;,J6)"""" 1/23() 4567 

?8c.*R,-'~sH`-'\#V¿¬`-'e(-'~]&fa'™A4ƒR12C;-'/)nJ@Ì„\U?@?/L&aH#)?/JH}\'()º/#-'K1wH=tp'6Ífo~}'/-'?8‰QdB'K1A4ƒR1

2C;-'/)\z@<sH/-'A=FHFp'A1/L34-¤?@\>:%DK1nJ@H1\#V„?/L&ˆ\-c'd^p'{^'/zA˜H…o?QHR%4-O/%=FrI=4V•VA&@9Hz?@'/4R,&w§-'\=,5'K1

A=zH#-'A=Vm%O„'6 ÂK;   D2J'/]-'*RC%-¢H#-'?/R^\&os'Ð-'rI4RC%-Q?/$#C%& oA}Ë-'?/1EÊQc/]R-'A1·5'~1wHUd‡-'6KLM&?@\  ‘ R   D*>†\z'QK1S()kH=-HR,-'A$R-A4ƒR12CF†|$>c\RUQ|$>K12$VW-'6„\&d&\z@?@~^\&s'Ð-'’-7Q?pkH$;%L5'A}d,%1 Z'\OH1@<=-HL%-'†™H$M^ Z'\O6KLM&?@?/L&~=M«'*ƒ^@

  Z„Hz'78?H>•V*>¿¬t?@~^\&K1*O@?@~=l%;&~=M«'?@'/>E`&f~^H#1¢.'\5'kH}dl-'Q~^H#5'QA=Vm«'ˆd…p'¡P#=4=t!"$+¦6'()Q/)w{O|$>HµSH#V

?HOaHO/FQ.H1\#V9H}?8.QcA1/L'/)\>:%-'K1?@*>K‚'/1Ì ‘·C   =F•V?@?/L& Z' NdzÍ¡/FQ.!$71Ñ!"#.£ o!A¦6

?8H1n4R,DA1/L'/)|=‡DFHL5'†dž±5'6'7q^H1_$  N #»~^co’$s'¯ ’=4V?@nO'/DA=-m%z'?@r%&aH;1G'’U‰{-'Q’UfKC;-'6?8S()k„m%z„'*R»K1.\‡-' ZHj=t*}@A=U7HO6"%zSH$t@kH1/L'HI#LM&?@*  N R,   DHI#=J'/}K1

9W…|=‡DFHL5'i%-'HIIO'/&?/$VW-'6•V*=$Fo9HŒ5'fA+]-'A=4˜p'A4ƒR5o2C;-'?H>aH#)?H#ž'K1n$%`5'r—K&(-'rDmH]%V'm—'/C%F'Q*L`U*+,#16

Page 152: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 152/248

!#) "#$%&$ '()$*+,-./$0 +12345-& 6,7.8

'78H1HJH>?H=M%#&u8AUH+VoAM0#1mI#LM&~  N }/D³dR%-'vH]R4-•VAJH=B'6KLM&Q?@*4]&'()K1FHL5'A$DE5'•VAJH=…œdl-'d…›'u8\z\=RU°=3U„\z@

mI#1€\]   =F•Vœ'EV„'¥?W+3=FQA&/F•VrL'<,¬5' ZH=$;JPDH#-'KV?QHR%-'aE`5'fmI1'{%-'_M+-'6

?8k'|=‡%-'ARF'/-'fkHJ/L1FHL5'KLM&?@9 N/   Š*VH,%-'°=3U„\   RD

A-:;5'A4ƒR12CF•V²W‚G'6'78_JH>AU/]V.\‡-'†|$>'\O°=3U?/L& ?QHR%-'/).H=B'*ƒ^p'•Vˆ\5'o&d]-'œUd0#-' NmV*R,&VW-'od…›'HI#=z„?/LDaH#)A&@A4ƒR16?89 N/ŠFHL5'„©?@?/L&H1.H˜S(—AO.\-'

iL-?/L&'dž±16"%z9 N/3%-'|‡+-' ZH=$;JfFHL5'KLM&?@\VH;   &•V*RO?QHR%-'i#$5'•V9cH$%-'o Z'd]%;1•Vryd-'K1A]=]z?@*VH,%-'„9'{&A4ƒR12CF6$;-'Qf’-7/)?@¼Q™.'d]%F'?QHR%-'\}_;LRJ'fA}WR-'2U¢H=]1or+B'&oFHL1QPsH%#-'ARU.p'¤'Q* Q-Q,6!!"*>QH1‰H%Ên=-8d1p'

/)?@?/L&¢H=]1r+B'&'|$>mUn=^A&H,L-'AJ.H]1S(—kH$;%L5'6'78H1k  N|‡D

oFHL5'KLM&?@|‡%&<}/5'K1€\V.'d]%F'f?QHR%-'u8<}/1?/L&n=^?QHR%-'’-(>6o’-(-K1*O@P&QdD?QHR%-'STJQK19W…*&\RDokH$;%L5'

“=-K1e.QÐ-'?@)(Ju8'()\'K1*O@wHƒ]-'•VdD/%-'2U°V'/$-'†|+]-'ˆ\5'/3Jo.\‡-'{^'/'QA4&/l-'ˆ\5'Y=]3%-?QHR%-'aE`5'6KL-QK1

e.QÐ-'?@*RCJ{^'/'A4&/l-'ˆ\5'?QHR%4-9cH$%5'·>@K1{^'/'†|+]-'ˆ\5'.\‡4-6

 

¡!¦ ilRDA=d,-'A=JHŒ-'A}WR-'2Uk'™±5'i%-'Qi)A&.Q¯.'d]%FW-6A]&dl-'QA,4%¬5'i)*=4]Dº'Òb-H+5'fA^/,+1kHV/^\5'HI;,J6€H=]4-Qo'(—?/L=Fœ\'/)*=4]D'Q,

†cH&ÅQ* Q-¡k./U/U'.SH1H`DQ!"7#okH3,+-'+#¥+AÄcQd4=;>@!"$.okH3,+-'7#¥$.¦6

Page 153: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 153/248

Page 154: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 154/248

!#" "#$%&$ '()$*+,-./$0 +12345-& 6,7.8

kHRM%C5'A&\=4]%-'AŒ&\'Q•VÖ\zw'/F6KLM&?@?/L&~^'\-'/)Y4B€'{%-'dŒ>@K1nJ/>£d'•Vd&/lDA=)H^.i]4%5'A&\I4-¡QWU!"7A¦6

KLM&A1'c8.HŒ&G'2Uv.H}p'’-7QK1AIOQd0Jr4VAž'.Q./l%-'isH=zp'6€pH^i%-'d‚HXH‹H=3UK1*O@7H]J8\&\R-'K1HIsH#U@KLM&?@\&{DK1

k„m%z'†HCJ¨RU×;#-'K1H‹H#=O6'()Q/)¢HF@A&d0JAU'd]-'oA=#=«'m>

H)H#`}HJf*+,-'“1HB'6KLM&?@r%&ØH,'•V.HŒ&G'K19W…~=$l%-'iVm%O„'¡BCDEFGEHFIECJ¦6

KL-QaH#)A4L`1A&\O6KLM&cd,4-xHJp'?@"]4%&FHL5'K1.HŒ&8¿¬td…´ „Q~^\&*UH]5HU<=-HLDA=)H^d-'K19W…nJ/>m&d>/)d…›'6\]-H#4UH} ZHR=¸¨RU

£H¬tp'o24-\5'¢HJ@?/R}/%&K1K&d…›'?@'/J/L&2V'd1r2M&d>orIR1rI#L-Q„?QdL,&kHOH3Ue@¿¬td…´ ˆ/FrI;,J@6‰H%Ê*Œ1w„±)¢H#-'?@'/41HR   &*L`U<4%[KV¢H#-'K&(-'?/V'd&oK&d…›'Wj-?/1/]&H#-W‡%FHU6

ÇE]&Q'()9„\%F„'nJ@KLM&†dl=;-'•V<=-HLD.HŒ&G'K19W…Ï3%-'A,+U .HŒ&G'~1~=M«'foA&'\$-'KL-Q\RUo’-7%]&HJ.HŒ&8g]^•VK&(-'?Q\$&dVH`1A—H`16KL-Q'()d1p'?HVÃH1HJ\=R&u8AM;-'A=-cH$%-'HI,˜/U ZHFHF@?QHR%4-6

""""" J5@K2$&@) L>. MDK 

KLM&?@?/LDA=C=D'EF8;†\z'/-'†\z'/U6A=C=D'EF8†dž±1A$;#-HUxHJÙ-iL-oHI1\¬%;&KL-Q*)i)A=C=D'EF8A=}W…@HIR$  N %=-¿¬`-'Q@Á\4$-'\M%R&

v'/«'•V'()o9'±;-'?Qco’t•V.H=R1cd,-'²W…Ù-6mU.?/L&.H=R5'

i}W…p'dŒ>p' Z„/$}/)†\VH]-'A=$)(-'¤*1HV¢H#-'m>Š?@a/41HR&6Q\$%F S()†\VH]-'A=$)(-'f²H=FA4ƒR12C;-'H–:>Q N9\D•V?@?QHR%D_J@•Vo€'Q\-'H5H‚?H>?QHR%-'/)*>H1\&dDK1VW-'d…›'6ÇE]&'()|;,%-'?@

*ƒ^@A=C=D'EF8K1AIOQd0J²W…p'i)A=C=D'EF8?QHR%-'|y¼QT5'_;=-QA=C=D'EF8;†\z'/-'†\z'/U66

Page 155: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 155/248

 971:03;<-& =0%> !##

?8A4L`1AIOQd0#-'S()i)?@r&\]Da N\…d…›'d  N ^/=F Z'{^Hzˆ\-VW-'d…›'iL-’  N 4‡%;&6?QHR%-H^|y¼QT5'“=-K1nJ:t?@Y34&.Ð-'’Uo;3^

*UnJ@KLM&?@ NÐ&2Od,%5HUwH&dUp'K&(-'*VH,%=F?/  N 4‡%;5'?/3OH#-'rIR1m=^\RU6*=M&?QHR%-'|y¼QT5'/3JcH;^8VW-'Äd…›'aE&Q ZHj$V•V*)H>A=]U

~M%C5'fÇW˜8VW-'o\FH,-'HµÇE]&?@AM;-'A=-cH$%-'i)¢HF@*ƒ^@

²W…Ù-K1?QHR%-'|y¼QT5'6?8†\VH]-'A=$)(-'?.@<A?QHR%-HU|yo¼QT5' H5H‚?@H1 N*ƒ,D?@€/]&nUVW-'d…›'/)?@’V\&_4,D’%4R,U\RU?@€/]D¨R$Uk'.\‡-'6

~1o’-7?8“=F:DA=C=D'EFG'•V9cH$%-'„Q\$&"MF@wŽf²W…p'/)d…›'¥•V*}p'“=-K1./0#1H#DH=É\UA=1/=-'6?8A=-cH$%-'i)\=>:%-HU_;=-  ZHFHF@ Z'\=OA=}W…pÇ/Ml-'Q@~  N 4l%-'6~1Q'()iI^dŒ>@K1cd¶A=}W…@A=JHJ@6

iI^f~}'/-'„\VH;Dwd5'o;3^*U\VH;DK&d…›' ZHƒ&@6H–8\VH;DK&d…›'K1H$R˜ Hj=t A=-W‡%F„' kH=C=D'EFG' .H)cÅ' *RO 9W…6og]^ K&d…›' \VH;D „ i)*U

H–8„4lDHI;,#-dŒ>@Hµi)†\R%;1nM&\]%-K&d…Ú-6KLM&A=C=D'EFÕ-A=#$5'•V9cH$%-'?@bM;DVW-d…›'?@*+Ê•V†:^HL1K1?QHR%-'o9cH$%5'i)Q

“,J;L5'e(-'*+Šn=4VHI;,#-H1\#V€/]D?H%=C=D'EFG'*R,U*ƒ^@H1mIRF/U6

?8.'ÒG'•V†'QH;5'„QwŽdŒ>@K1†'QH;5'/)A,˜A=FHF@\&\R4-K1\V'/]-'A=#$5'•V9cH$%-'6KLM&QHI%&À.bQ:UH‹H=4»fw'c@A=C=D'EF8;†\z'/-'†\z'/U6fA-/lUA4ƒR12C;-'6\]-kÅH^A=C=D'EF8;†\z'/-'†\z'/U6i%-/CU

oA-/l$-'HI#L-QY4%D ZH‚H]JfA&@A$R-dŒ>@HµSÅdz@VW-'d…›'KfQoA]=]'„ HI#LM&*=C;D¼H]JdŒ>@Hµn4C;&VW-'d…›'fA&@A$R-H–p Zms'caEDVW-'d…›'.\‡&o Z„Q@m>H–@K-.\‡Dc\RUK1k'd5'·>@Hµ€/]&nUVW-'d…›'6\]-

okÅH^“=-K19W…€H=]-'w'c:U*ƒ^@K1VW-'od…›'*UK19W…¼H$#%F'?QHR%-'K1VW-'d…›'6S(—QoA]&dl-'_1H}A=C=D'EF8;†\z'/-'†\z'/U6w'c:U

Page 156: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 156/248

!#$ "#$%&$ '()$*+,-./$0 +12345-& 6,7.8

\=OK19W…P&QdDA34+5'A-cH$%5'“=-QK19W…9W‡%F'<RVW-'d…›'6¿¬`-'i}W…p'„~=l%;&€H=]-'*ƒ^:UK1’-76?8H1"lV@A=C=D'EF8;†\z'/-'†\z'/U6'()rRl-'SQdL5' ZW=4}/)H).'Ò8

•V@\$12R-'2R-HU6S()Qi)A-'\R-'A#`B' ZH]z6KL-QA-:;5'A=]=]'i)H1'78_JH>aH#)A&@*s'\U*ƒ^@6\O/DQaH#)*s'\Uf<}'/5'i%-'KLM&?@\M%R&HI=^

¢H#-'•VAl4FA&{>d1*=  N R,%-|&HR1~M%C5'6mU.?/LDAU/]R-'A$FH#%1~1AM&d«' ?Qc?@?/LDA5±1*ŒMUH1_JH>n=4VAM&d«'6H1\#V„?/LDaH#)Al4FA&{>d1€/]%-o*=R,%-HU©•V2$VW-'?@'Q\M%R&•VrI;,J@wHlVGrIƒRU¨R$-'

{^'/'A&.QÐ-'¼H$#%F„?QHR%-'„\UK1.\‡-'6f*Œ1S()oA-H'?/L&9'±;-'i]=]'¤H1/)*L`-'e(-'©?@S(¬%&'()Áw'dyG'

?8A4L`5'~1A=C=D'EF8;†\z'/-'†\z'/U6i)H1?@@\$&ow'\R-'nJq^dM%;=Fu8H1„A&H–6fQoA]=]'?8\&\R-'K1k'Q'\R-'Q\$DH–:>Q<+%DS(—AM;-'6•R^

*=$Fo9HŒ5'dM%;&w'\R-'2UkWsHR-'fH=JH$-@²T-'QgFQp'f¨RU?H=zp'c/]R-K1oK1{-'H1\#Vr%&cd-'•Vˆ7p'ˆ7:Ud…´ 6*>QA=4MV€H]%J'?/L%FAŠH^ A]4A1cH}6KLM&[email protected]%D9mV@<#R-'ˆ7p'Q ZHUH)7 ZHUH&8Q"%z~=ƒ&aHI%J„'

o9Qp'Q@$FœWB'Ϙp'fkH=‚ÛH5'\=R$-'¡aWU = c/L&H1!"$#¦6S()Qi)A4L`1A&\OfA=C=D'EF8;†\z'/-'†\z'/U66mU.?/LDA=C=D'EFG'*ƒ^p'i)ºHO.8AR;D.H`V@†\z'/-'*UH]1†\z'/-'6\VH;=F'()fg=$ŒDw'\˜@º'-'d^/&Q

  ZHƒ&@ Z'{^HzVW-d…›'i>„v Nd©e@.\y„.·1n-6?/L%FA=C=D'EF8A=#$1•Vo9cH$%-'HI#L-Q?/L%FdŒ>@ ZHhH;D ZW=4}K1A=C=D'EF8;†\z'/-'†\z'/U66i)Q„

9'{DA-'\VoA#`…KL-QfHVK12=JHJp'vH=‡UQAl4;-'oA&{>d5'H–q^~%M%D ZWR^A4=ƒ,UP&QE-'“=-g]^HI%=)H^d-oA=D'(-'*UA=)H^d-K&d…›' &@ ZHƒ 6

KLM&~M%CM4-e(-'€\¬%;&kH=C=D'EFG'A=#$5'•V9cH$%-'f~}'/-'?@}'d&n;,J6KM^9W…?mA$}HR1e@cd^9QHÊ?@?/L&*}@o ZHJQHRDKLM&?@*RCJA=C=D'EFG'A^d3#5'AM&\V†\sH,-'•V²W‚G'6o'(-K-KLM%&œd3#5'K1owH]$-'K-Q?/L& ZHO7/MJˆ(%ÊnU?Qd…›'6

Page 157: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 157/248

 971:03;<-& =0%> !#%

?8A,˜A$}'d5'A=D'(-'S()’=lRD Z'{^Hz ZH=^H8 ZH˜H…iL-nF N.\   DK&d…Ú-¥"%zw„±K&(-'K-*VH,%DrIR16K1A=zH#-'oA=R=$l-'_J@\&dD?@¢ N.\   D9cH$%-'

w„±K&(-'œ/F*1HR%DorIR1*Op?@KLM%DK1wH#UA}WVA&{¶2^dl4-6’#L-Q’4%” ZHƒ&@AR,#1K1¿¬`-'d…›'e(-'€\¬%;&oA=-cH$%-'"%z/-KL&

’&\-e@*VH,D~1’-7¿¬`-'¤?8AM;-'A=-cH$%-'\VH;D•VA$}'d1~M%C5'n%1dU

K19W…A$}HR1’j-Q@K&(-'?/-QHÊ?@'/J/L&2=-W‡%F' Z'\O6'()Q*4]&K1c\V c'd^p'|y2JQHR%5'K&(-'O/%&’=4V*1HR%-'rIR1f*$]%;5'6’-(-?q^r=4RD€'\¬%F'kH=C=D'EFG'A,=l4-'A=#$5'•VA=-cH$%-'\VH;&

o(=M4%-'\VH;&Qo~M%C5'KLM&Q?@\VH;&r4R5'•VÖ/3J|y™H$16„QAU'dy?@\z@wm4V“,#-'2&/UE-'ÜQ@“&.\%UAM;-'A=-cH$%-'f¢.'\5'’-7Q\#VnVmF

KFH3MUA=C=D'EF8;†\z'/-'†\z'/U6¡i,-H>!"A!£ o¤+A¦6#"""" J;N559&@) O)MP%@) M. 8Q 

?8†.\]-'•V{==”VW-'d…›'K19W…kWVH,%-'oA]UH;-'d  N >(DQkm;-' k'7A}WR-'’4%-okWVH,%-'i)\=>:%-HUwŽe.Q¯ØH,34-•V?QHR%-'6?Q\$^’4Dok'.\]-'„~=l%;&VW-'?@€\¬%;&e@*LtK19HLt@9cH$%-''(—Q„

~=l%;&?@~  N C`   &VW-'d…›'•V?QHR%-'6foA]=]'\M%R&ˆ\1?QHR%-'e(-'KLM&ØH,'n=4V•V’4Dk'.\]-'6?8

'()cm%V„'bƒ%& ZH=4Of²HlJA4Œ1p'A=3=/%-'A=sH=zG'i%-'_zd   ‚f*+,-'“1HB'6oH&|%L$-H^•V*=$Fo9HŒ5'i)vd}@u8dR}r4;-'oe./l%-'i)Q’4%”

†.\}†cQ\h Z'\Of{==”kH#sHL-'A='ˆd…p'6'(-©HI=4V?@€\¬%;D ZH]&d‚  Z'%[{==M%4-¤A}WVA&z~1V„od…´  Z'\z'Qg]^¡<=ƒ5'¦f†d5'†\z'/-'6 S(—QoA]&dl-'e@Ö N|‡DfAj=UH&|%L$-'KLM&?@ˆ{R&u8 N|‡D\z@2$VW-'!!"6H1@

 ¡!¦ •VQ“,Jo.'d È ‡-'„KLM&H&|%L$4-?@u/%D¨RU9mVp'†\]R5'A«HR5kH1/4R5'9/z

×&.HDA$R4-'"%zS()oA034-'HI#L-QKLM& ZH=d^?@?/LDHÉ\-†c.*R^•V¨RUkm;-'Al=;$-'oÛm4-*Œ1m=^'78_JH>Aj=$-'Al=35'A$$h†\=ÝQ Z'd…±1*L`UQ@d…ÞU6

Page 158: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 158/248

!#& "#$%&$ '()$*+,-./$0 +12345-& 6,7.8

o./=l-'iI^dŒ>@ Z'{==”¥78HI#LM&?@{  N =”K12Uc\VK1c'd^@./=l-'†.QHC5'·VH‹'/˜@Q@H‹H=#y@6S()Q†.\]-'•V{==M%-'bM;DHd&/l%U¨RUkH}WR-'A=JQHR%-'

 ¥Q@•V*}p'bM;DH#C%UkH}WR-'A=^WB'¥~1\&\R-'K1./=l-'ˆd…p'6m>QH#`}HJf*+,-'o“1HB'\]- N/‚.T$-'r‹'.\}A&{==M%-'u8\z?@rÉ\-'w{OK1ßH1\-'eT$-'¿+¬%1{==M%US/O/-'6?8†.\]-'AR  N F/5'•V{==”c'd^p'K&(-'

Y$FwdM4-?@*1HRDrIR1bM;DT$4-?:U'Q./l&A1/0#1K1kH}WR-'A=JQHR%-' "#y@K1’4Di%-'ˆ\-./=l-'6~1o’-7"%zf?Q±`-'oA&T$-'†cHVH1?/LDk'c\35'AQd,5'•V²HlJ

?QHR%-'A¸HJKV€\V†.\]-'•V{==”A&/)2$VW-'K&d…›'Q@rHR^@6?/LDQS()A4L`5'†cHz*L`U£H…f9H¶Y=]Š†dl=FA=5HVA-H  N R^•VA34Fp'A&Q/#-'6

AU/R+-'QH#)i)Y]3%-'¤A^dR1A&@†/l…\}€H}H—VW-'d…›' ZWR^AO.\UQA=^H>K1A]Œ-'6•VQ*=$Fo9HŒ5'\]-à_  ‘ R È #   1A=}H,D'd0A^H>v.H»A34Fp'A&Q/#-'"%zQ

_}Q&d}$;UAU/R+-'A=#]%-'f{==M%-'2Uk'.HC,JG'9Å„{-'Q¥i)QAU/R˜\}rD?›'H)ÅQH» ZH$&d]D¡K&c|,&8Q “&HLF!"A1¦6

_;=-†.\]-'•V{==”.\‡-'H1\#VÔ\Êi)4l%5'\=z/-'./I0-?QHR%-'obOH#-'HI#L-QWU’t4l%1rI16o’-(-KLM&?@~F/%&²HlJ?QHR%-'e(-'

KLM&ØH,'on=4VK19W…A&@k'd&/lDf†.\}2$VW-'•V{==”rIƒRU¨R$-'K1oÛH5'?@Q'/J/L&K&\>:%1?:`U9HR^p'A]UH;-'i%-'rDH)7HX' ZWR^6\]-Q N2U'()*+,-'?@?QHR%-'2U¢H#-'KLM&?@~F/%&‰  NQd&Qn-·V\&\R-'K1kH=#]%-'

ˆd…p'o ZHƒ&@mUHI=^~=F/D./ƒz*$]%;5'|=‡DQFHL5'r=4RDQ¢H#-'?@'/˜dÊ

•VA=)H^.K&d…›'r=4RDQAM;-'A=-cH$%-'6?8P&QE-'PsH%#4-†\=«'_;=-A-:;1wH]-8 k'¯Hh•V2$VW-'9/zA]=]z?@aH#)\&{5'n$;L-K1?QHR%-'9cH$%5'HµKLM&n$;>K1.\‡-'9cH$%5'6*UnJ@ ZHƒ&@A-:;1*=L`DkH,˜*VH,%-'°=3UKLM&?@?/L&aH#) Z'./lD Z'd]%;1?QHR%4-•VQˆ\5'\=R$-'6

 

Page 159: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 159/248

 

!"#"$%$   '

Page 160: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 160/248

!"# "#$%&'()%*+(,(-.-/%

 

Page 161: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 161/248

Page 162: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 162/248

!"$ "#$%&'()%*+(,(-.-/%

†•yAe'(il,  Š U  < ‹(+019M'(ƒ$n'Œ#9.73'8iŽ@'(†0'(8STUC9{0&bnYSYJ@`ƒ$n'(%‚(FSTUC},#K0o'7=0#  < C E9$(3R=i%m0eYSY‘,U#0'(yneoe0'(8+,Y%’(+R9TUo'F9Y=+:UXƒ$n'(†{a+:  t ,“”58)*Z3;3'(9Y"#$73TCk"'ƒ$n'(%‚(

>:1y9Y3o:‹(+,f,5(gX(†0'(9{Y"d0X(ƒ$n'(€8\(zY–@$n'(SC%‚(F7*+:Ue'(ƒ@e05I23{„"C":'(SY6%•(3&'(A19{,ala(3—(N$Œ,X5+:UXZ%-o'

N$OR=6™šla(3—(8N$z#YSC%‚(SY7=(3G@KC–XšF9Y=u,&#0'(3{a +`n$–1+Y3T—(–Y3TG‹(8FBz,40e5y9Y3T—(7=uT›SY€n‚z#‹(6‘maJ1ƒœ9{,o$ EB"1SY'j7=žm› E9Y(l0'( E9,$3“k"'+,@o[=–Y3TG‹(F6(]'7hau,&#0'(

ƒ@e0CI23{„ynT~Yž  t o:05k"U1+Y(Ÿ"$(3m'(y(/(%;*89{m,@45F6 E(w‚=8%{&5+,m“9#  Š ‹(9Y"#$J$9-0C73@$n'(zYu(w; EB"1SYJ$9-0'(zYs=¡dp79.F

STUC8(]’%Y\(7=ƒ@e0CI23{„¢AR=+~•"YSY£3oe'(9Y"#$Ž0#5y9,f,5(gX(I+$3Uf‹(F

!"#$%&' !)*+,- ./0&01'-2 3#45-2 .#6)781'- iZ9$9Y‘@5%C™9#'(u{|:@1>:@'(¤%41%¥05y9-K'91†0'(STUC9{0&bnY

Œ#9.%U:'(873'8iŽ@'(¦3oX=8Œ@  t o'(F§Ue5¨]•y(29p(ƒ$n  t '71="@CJ$9-0'91zYƒC%^'(z  t `3017=© tª0C(]•ƒC%^'(A.SC%‚(SC]'(73.g~CŒ-#1

o5¡_9KQ(+o19m'(+&bnUo'F6 E(j*SYL,b6="@‹(STUCo0'¡_9KQ(7=§Ue5ƒ$n'71©%:C E9«,p E(",-YS$+,f,5(gX*ƒ$n'(%‚(J@`7=="@CJ$9-0'(F(]•8

%Y\(¬"7\yAe'(†0'(u59{0&bnY§Ue5SC%‚®'71(3-  t #K  < CZ%-'(N$OR=

3|$I+$9¯z0U05yAe1+°9~YF§UeC8(]•},#K0'(¨28"1Jx30'91)* y9;90#0X(€3b},.73T,X© tª5'jZ%-'(FB±90›y9:`30'(+4@5%‹(},#K01 t–:  < Y)*7=9{Uo:0RSY+1%f0'(+,Kd~'(F

¨]{ay9:`30'(STUC7=JT~059|C=SY€n‚¦29f0'(w[iš9@‹(²$+,oU$£29~0'(y9C9T—91FSTUC8y(we-0o'†0'(?4:  < 5y(29p³'7=JT~05?0b²  $uo$

Page 163: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 163/248

  01(2-34 5678-,9% 56.:4%!"%

+¥(23'(¦9d0RB(86†:,@4'(A.3•€9—(9Y"#$73T5i9-Goe'(i2Z9`N$l,,µŒ#;i9-Goe'(k%‚\(ƒ,f0e58 E9ma8']'F

STUC7=© t%:  < C},#K0'(ˆ%&'()‰N$OR=+UX+019¥ƒ$n'–:YSTUC9{0&bnYSYJ@`SC%‚(9Y"#$="@CJ$9-0'(!+"F9Y"#$73T5£9#•6y9-,#K5STUC

+,f,5(gX³'7=Z"   < ›29,Q( E(/9#1Œ,'‘maN$¶C25J$9-0'(?0b¨]•6+&Go'(ST'8

N$},#K0'(Z"G‹(ƒ$   tn'%‚( E9|C=F7*k"b*y9:@0'(%M.\( Ei29¥* E9;9$·*8y9-,#K0o'†•9=STUC7=Z3m5)*

¢AR\(i".¸‹( E9,5(jFJ;\8+a%:Y},.STUC7=¬"(]•6%Y\(¹ga(7=J.Z%ao0UC9Y=+Yn$},#K5/9`2·8=/(º‚F+a9H*)*6'j¹ga(7=J.+$3UWSY

–0$3Uf‹(+-,4'zY/9|$=9{0$3UW6+x9Q(+:,H88zY/9|$=+$3Uf‹(k%‚\(FSY8J;=",ef0'(6sZ9‹(¹ga(7=/9|$=n.–0$3Uf‹(73Y"d0eC+,f,5(gX*

"i"b(3'(i"b(31#zYu{|:16>:@'(782"^C8 EA_(ZzY/9|$=+$3Uf‹(k%‚\(F

¹ga(87=™9,mYuKQ(,

z-5%YA1O,a+C9-T'(J:f,'"

i"b(3'(i"b(31#

+,f,5(gX* i%m0eY9,$9¯ˆƒeG1+,H%-'(+M'9M'(SYJK-'(L'9M'(F‰9{#,bBz,40eCs=Z%a6"b(8/(3X79. E9`2·=8=6 E(º‚=7=c3mC/(Z1J|a=SYs]'(Oo:-C6z,U(7=873TC E9-,4'zY/9#1=O0$3UWˆ8=O$3R‰6 E9:,H88zY/9#1=+$3Uf‹(k%‚\(ˆ8=…3#'(%‚(F‰

†#:C(]•la9—(7=¢AR\(STUC7=73T56+019¥?0b9Y"#$B73T5+,#@YN$+C=y9an0‚(+,$3H3YF"m0:C¤2l'(7=ºQ(6 E(Z9[8=Ao.8(3o19`6 E(º‚=".0C

u•"#$(]•Z9m0$B(F"m0:C8ºQ(7=ºQ(SC%‚(‘mau•SC]'(73'Z9@0,X6789:0'(73o:f,X8u»(Z9m0$(¨]•".05 E9|C=F(j*9Y Š¼'89b7=¦%{05SY(]•

6c9&#'("f0X7=@X9TY+x9Q(6¡`9#057=859:o45u4G05F6']'(j*¼G@x=6 E9m~#YSYJU0G‹(7=Z3:56;(2Z= En;9$c=6 En;½ 3GR28"'(z  t `30‹(#YF(j*79.

 ˆ+‰ ža8y9Go4KYy(29p*6¤3e'((]•89Y?Ue  < Cš¸‹91ˆŒ#,@X+-./F‰

Page 164: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 164/248

!"& "#$%&'()%*+(,(-.-/%

-,#K5€3mCR=6º‚=oY9:,X78%‚(6º‚.9‹9“879.SYs"f‹(+@e#'91'7=©ª05A.© tª0C6ºQ(Rha".¸0Xy9:`35z,U(F

7*(]’…3#'(SY‘,U#0'(–0f,0R–0-X¸Y‡9¾("b*+GH(8A#,1k%‚\(%M.=  E9H3U[ E9  t ,-¿8F9Y=+f,0#'(+GH(3'(†{a7=z,U(73o:-C=3X=9ÀcloC7\789:0'(€Z9@0‹(–1–0$3Uf‹(79.STUC7=za%CSY¢9mRz,U(F9Y=+f,0#'(%M.\(9  t ,-¿”0a

SYs=y89-5IZ"$¤2l'(6ºQ(89ÀžoÁ+,@o[=+,o`=8FI¨]•6+'9—(A#,1Â9:5 790$3Uf‹(SY29m0aB()*789:0'(6€Z9@0‹(7ha/9|$=+$3UW+,o`\(Â9:0X%M.=FB+1(%[ E(j*SY7=y9,o`\(iZ9$9Y?:e5)*+'l:'(+,$9a"'(F

+a%:‹8ƒ@e'(/(286'j¹ga(7=£9#•73RA¥SYºQ(78Ž$8SY¤2l'(I+#C"Y6+#,:YJ.8"b(8u{#YJ$9-0CzYJ.Z%a%‚½ i%Yi"b(8I…3@X\(F

6£(]#,b+@e#'916ºdo'u&:Yu»n$9-5¬"›J‚(Zu{0$3UW†•8']1sZ¸5)*789:0'(6€Z9@0‹(ST'8+@e#'916¤2lo'73T5u&:Yu»n$9-5zY+$3Uf‹(k%‚\(

ˆs=zYºQ(‰6†•8']1sZ¸5)*+@`9:Y2"^'(€Z9@0‹(F6(]'7ha‘X30Y¢9m#'( +@e#'91+,o`Ã'/9`2l'(73T,XJ`=SY‘X30Y¢9m#'(+@e#'91+,@o[Ã'/(ºQ(F%U0e,X8(]•w¥0'(?0b9Y"#$73TC£9#• ÄJ,Yk"'J.+$3UWI7=‘@5%5zY/9#1=9{0$3UWˆ8=9{$3RF‰7*(]•w¥0'(%U0e,XOR\(j*79.£9#•Z"$–:YSYy(%‹(

†0'(†m0o59{,a+,o`\(/9`2l'(+,@o[\916/(ºQ(7ha(]•J  t MU,X+KbSYÅ9¯*yn$9-5+,o`\(².=SY+  t KbÅ9¯*yn$9-5+,@o[\(ˆ79[23Y8 9#,0C2+-01‰F+f,0#'(8

†•OR=STUCy9-,#K0o'7=u$"5¢AR\(†0'(Â9:Cz,U(69{@@e1+,o`\(8Â9:0X%M.=SY–`9@'(F

STUC7=Z3m5y9-,#K0'()*w¥5%‚½  E9|C=Fj*9{#TUC7=u$"5yneoe0'(+,Y%’(+R9TUo'FN$J,@X6€9M‹(¹ga(7=z,U(73To0UC+UX6+#,:Y€34'9.8=

i3m'(8=iŽ@'(8=i²#'(6+,53K'(STUC9{0&bnY6+'3{e1§Ue58+R29m‹91–1–#¥(SY™9#'(FJ;\86+“9e@'(¹ga(OR=B";35£9#•u,`6‘12L,G1OR=(j*9Y?m0'(

679Kdp73T,XSY§H(3'(Av=o0UC"Cl‹(SYo56+Ue'(Av=8o0UCJ,om'(

Page 165: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 165/248

  01(2-34 5678-,9% 56.:4%!"'

9{#YF7(8¹ga(7=z,U(}K0C+X(Ž'91€9,b/B¸•?RZ\(k30eY6u{#Y+$(Z3'918}4o'(8€9,b/B¸•N$\(u{#YFSTUC=7=73TC'jÆ(%m0eY

6u:R9#•8€9MY†G,H35F¹ga(7=z,U(73Y"d0eC+,f,5(gX(+,'90'(9Y"#$73m0oC¡d~1?RZ=u{#Y‡¦89#5I2"^'(789:0'(89YÇ2"^Cƒ$n'(%‚(

3'8i%‹6i"b(8I8o56+'9—(S'(3R89:0C+,R9¥N$¤n“(F7*(]•%Y\(™šSY

L,bR=iZ9$9Y62"^5#T'8S'§Y9e05zY2"^'((j*/9;SYƒ$n'(%‚(F ¹ga(87=z,U(73Y"d0eC+,f,5(gX(+,'90'(9Y"#$73m0oC¡d~1N$=u{#Y‡  Ä789:59YÇ2"^C%‚(–5%YN$6Å(30'((j*89Y62"[Soa(3R89:0Ci%Yk%‚=F7*(]•%Y\(},4'SYL,bR=JUG05R3. En  t -^YIynm#'(6+189#0‹(#T'8 E9|C=

JUG05·(l-0XB(SYL,bR=BJUG05%M.=SY2("mY t–:YSY€n^0XB(F7*(]•‘U#'(SY£3oe'(ŒX¸C Eneoe5 E9,Y%•+R9TUo' E9,#@YN$+UXSTUC9{0&bnYFc3m,a™9#'(–@C%m'(SY+  t U`c%’(/(Z1",;u\73:,40eC© tª0'(

+,`3-1/n:0X(8zYz,U(9@C%m5F6J19m‹9187ha™9#'(–@C%m'(SY…9m'(73Y3mC/(Z1 /Èu\–-,4'zYz,U( E9@C%m5FSY8J{e'(+a%:Yƒ@e'(/(28iZ9:X¡d~'(ƒC%m'(SY+Um'(¨9H28S$+,#@'(6+,$A0;B(ST'8J•£9#•/Éz,40eC¡d~'(ƒC%m'(SY…9m'(7=Oo:-C€9,b'jƨZ%-U1

Iz`(3'(Œ,'£9#•/ÉFƒ@e'(83•OR=9Y"#$73TC™9,mYuKQ( E9,'9$A1O,a6+C9-T'(73T,XSYJ|a\(7=]‚C/%‹(O59“3›–1+omRk%‚=8SY¡d~'(

6™Ž'(SY7=2"^CO;(3C8":1'j+13m$B+C99’!+"F6']'7ha¡d~'(s]'(

 

ˆ+‰ 7*R3. E9:CZ8G#UC2 3 ,4 3 ,12 3 ,54 666 7 823,49:8+;,199Y=(j*9Y6y tZ%µ"mac3m5 E9|C=2"^'91N$6c(8"'(9À,4:C< 3 ,< 3 ,1< 3,5< 666 7 8< 3 ,<9:8+;,196(]'Œ,'£9#•s=la9bN$Z%U0'(AM,b79.=

 2 3 ,4 > < 3 ,<FFF8=, >8< $ 29:84;<96(]'9Y"#$73T5+U,`,[email protected],a6+C9-T'(S'73TC£9#•L$91N$Z%U0'(F+@e#'918u,mo'+,G,H30'( Êo'2 7 ?6< 7 +684 7 56S'73TCZ%U0'( E9C"W9Y"#$73TC,².(SY+:16

Page 166: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 166/248

!"" "#$%&'()%*+(,(-.-/%

I…9`+,#@'(+,$A0;B(z`(8I¶-'(F3{ac3mC/(Z16},:HST'8c3m,XA13•=3X=SY€n‚O0'89Ë+H29:‹c9&#'(F

7*c"$k8";i23M'(+oK-#‹(9{Um$8†•+f,0RSY_90Ry9@¥y9,f,5(gX*–@$n'(SC%‚(F7*Z%µƒ$n'(8j+R9T‹(+|-d#‹(žGo,X2º'(nT1–a%4'(

JT~1Ì:aF9Y=(j*c9`73@$n'(SYs8j+R9T‹(+,`(%'(w,^01u{.3oX6¨(%.91ORha

ƒœ7=]‚¸5¨]•+m,m—(%&#129@0$B(SYJ@`–@$n'(SYs8j+R9T‹(+|-d#‹( SC]'(78%T-CZ t%U0'91FST'8(]•29@0$B(Z3mC†@$B+R9T‹(+,'9:'()*P%—(N$u{0:UXu»%{p8y9@M'91FJ;\8+X(2Z(]•…3#'(SY6%•(3&'(±90/%‹()*%&#'(

Iy9,'½ ˆ+,T,Y9#CZ‰+:U  < e'(F

9:+'-2 !;%< 0'- 

"ef05+:UXƒ$n'(Iy("m0:YSC%‚(7~1+,f,5(gX(†0'(©3X9{Y"d0eCƒ$n'( 'jFƒ$n'( 'j €9:a= +&bnY €n‚ SY E9,;j3UR +:U 

 < e'( JT~05

9Y"#$J$9-0CzY–@$n'(SC%‚(FN:aJ,@X6€9M‹(y· tl:5+:UX9,R94C%193T1+#TÀ·(l-0XB(9•2(%m1iZ9:0X(2l;"Rn.3-'(I+19f0X(8l^o'†#,0#;2\(FSTUC

uYÃ'k%‚\(7=Íbn5y(2(%`9,R94C%1SYJ;=€3x3'()*>:1y9;90#0XB( +x9Q( u’9:a= N$ 9{o:a Z2 O,o$ 73T,X 9Y €3bˆk%‚\( uY\( €9:a= s=‰J@m0e‹( IF

73T0X8y9;90#0XB(+,R9@X(7~1c(l0'B(Â94C²'(J@f16¤29“y9;90#0XB(8+,#,K'(7~1c(l0'B(Â94C²'(ÎR3°6ÎR3.73T0X9{:,¯y(j+ox(]°%Y\(F9Y=

+'eY9Y(j*¼R9.¨]•y9;90#0XB(+G,Gxc=B†{aLG1%‚½ F+4m#'(89#•†•OR=

9Y"#$73T5£9#•©(%“=+M'9¥ƒ`(%56"•9~587hay9R9•2}`3‹(Å9—("0U0XSY /B¸•–o‚"0‹(JT~16š9@YJU~0'w¥529,Q(Å9—(N$+:UX–@$n'(F §Ue5'+a%:Y+:UX™9#'(71©%:5 E9«,p9YS$+,f,5(gX(†0'(

93Y"d0eC?0bJ@`7=ƒ;30C,o$7=c3m5£29,d1€8\(FVgm58¨]•+,R9TY(k"Y+U,`0a%:Yi".¸‹(+,f,5(gX³'†0'(p3Cƒ$n'(%‚(7=9{Y"d0eC

Page 167: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 167/248

  01(2-34 5678-,9% 56.:4%!"(

:YF7*k"b*¤%“™9,`+U,`+C=+Y3o:Y†•²$¦9eb)*s=k"YSTUC7=S  t eG0C£r(Z=Z3;316+Y3o:‹(9À73T,XO,o$€9—(98"1ˆ9-C(2+-@0‰F6(]'Ao.79.

£r(Z=J|a=78"16y9Y3o:‹(Ao.¼  t o`0;9b)*6y9Y3o:‹(Ao.8¼  t o`9{0U,`FIn.†0'3;+'341+o|:Y6–fe'(N$J,@X6€9M‹(¼mmb+,f,5(gX*"i"b(3'(

i"b(31# E/(Z= E(",;78Z+a%:Y+,f,5(gX(†0'(c8%Cƒ$n'(%‚(9{Y("d0X(F¼R9.

+a%:Y+,f,5(gX*%‚(§Ue0Xƒ$n'7=c3mC/(Z1J|a=9X9X=IyB9b+o,o` ‘maFN$J,@X6€9M‹((j*¼R9.+,f,5(gX*ƒ$n'(%‚("`¼a%  < $N$9="i"b(3'(–0#¥91#ˆs=†0'(B2"^59YÇumC%‚(2"^'91I–0om#'(–0,H9‹(‰679T'SYSTU‹(c9,m'(/(Z1J|a=SYs]'(O0mmb+,f,5(gX*"i"b(3'(i"b(31#SY€n‚¦89#52"^'(

789:0'(8FST'8¼e,'£9#•y9,f,5(gX*iwM.+o19`€n^0Xn'Is=SY–0'3(I6+'34@'((]'7ha+a%:Y+,f,5(gX*%‚(JT~1ž@eYS'£"$9eC En:aIc9,m'(A13•

J|a=SY+,f,5(gX*"i"b(3'(i"b(31#iZ":0‹(¹(%[\(FI6+m,m—(7*%^xufbƒeT‹(”(SY+a%:Y+,f,5(gX*%‚(3•Z%W™9,mY%‚½ +R90‹+,f,5(gX*

"i"b(3'(i"b(31#F7*€(¸e'(S$+U,`y9Y3o:‹(STUC E9|C=7=ƒom  < C E9X=2N$ƒm$‡9Y†•+U,`

ˆ8=+-o.‰Z3;8–@$BSC%‚½ 73a%:CÆ0,f,5(gX*6¦(3(86z@4'91"U0:CN$+C=+,f,5(gX*‘@|'91¼R=c"d0e5F(jha¼#.c"d0e5+,f,5(gX*+o19`6€n^0Xn'JMY+,f,5(gX*"i"b(3'(–0#¥91#STUC7=73T5+-oT0'([email protected]+,b9#'(6k%‚\((j*

¼#.c"d0e5+,f,5(gX*STUC7=O;(35N$J|a=i23x789:0'916JY9T'( E(j*A12":e0XJ:0,f,5(gX*+a8%:Yk"'ƒ$n'(%‚(FN$8J,@X6€9M‹((j*¼#.

c"d0e5+,f,5(gX*"i"b(3'(i"b(31#673T0X E(",:XJ:ƒ$n'(%‚(S  t UMC¨]• +m,m—(},T0C869{:Yz@4'918+4Cš7=†moCJ@m0e‹(€n&[email protected],a+C9-T'(L,G173T5J|a=y919f0XB(†•+,f,5(gX(+-,4o'(FI6+m,m—(A.9#o`6 E9-R½ 7*

 +,f,5(gX* y(·9,0Y( k"b*"i"b(31 i"b(3'(#9•l,,µ u0C 7= 9’ +@e#'91 J{e'( SY OR= †•/9#¥=wX+@:o'(?0b7*879.ƒ$n'(s]'(9{Y"d0eCÇŒX¸C+:UX"—7(F

Page 168: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 168/248

!") "#$%&'()%*+(,(-.-/%

7*£n0Y(+:UXi",“8c("d0XB+,f,5(gX*"i"b(3'(i"b(31#3•/É",-Y6ƒ$   tn' {#T'89 ¼e,'J|a=+:UXSTUC9{.n0Y(Iz`(8%Y\(F7*J|a=+:UX

STUC9{.n0Y(†•+:Ue'(+X ´ ŠŽ'(FJ|a=8…(3R=–XŽ'(3•£(js]'(OC"'+:UXc9,m'(Pnd0X91².=/ÉSTÀSYƒ$n'(6%‚(I–bOR=B§Y9e0CzYs=2"[679.SYƒ$n'(%‚(F7*+mC%“Pnd0X(².=/ÉO#Y3•7=2"^5(wM.L,G17=

ƒ$n'(%‚(J   t |-  < ,X789:0'(€(3“¼`3'(N$2"^'(€(3“¼`3'(FJ|a=8+mC%“ z,f~0'789:0'(O'9KG0X(8SY%‚(†•7=© Š%:  < C#$R= Ä¡dpB789:0Ci%Yk%‚=N$¤n“((j*9Yc9`%‚(2"^'913'8i%Yi"b(8F

Se—86Í—(Œ,'SYJ{e'(Œ,X5+:UX+X(šFSUaJ;=7=©%:  < C#$R=6   Ä™š,o$7=2"^56 E(wM.(]•8†#:CR=SYJU0G‹(7= tl-  Š 0e5ƒ$n'(%‚(2M,'um0#C8F?0bŒX050:UXN$3GR6",; <J  Š U0  < 7=J  < ‚"  Š 5I"C":'(SY

y9ea9#‹(w[+Clf‹(y(Z(2³'FN$J,@X6€9M‹((j*9Y2"[ƒ$n'(%‚(3'8i%Y6i"b(873T0ea E9`lÀ–1©ª0'(+R3~Q91†0'(9{@o40CŒ,X5+:Ue'(†0'(ƒ[%5

69°–18+'89ËiZ9:0X(y9`n:'(+CZ3'(IJ$9-0'(Å9—(F7*9YJ:œi23K'(%M.=+Y90`3•7=ƒ$n'(%‚("`73TC9|C=?:eC)*

Œ,X56+:UX(]’8ƒ@e'("`73TCw[§Y9e0Y3•%‚(zYyB9b2"^'(†0'(9{Y"d0e56¼R= EB89ËSY9’n‚Œ,X50:UXF9Y"#$€89J."b(8SY Š–@$n'(

Œ,X5O0:UXJ;\9{Y("d0X("H–@$n'(SC%‚(I¦9:'\(6+,o@m0e‹(73T,XSYJ{e'(+Cr27=u»n$9-5STUC7=2"G#5)*J-X\(I+oeoX+oC3“SY

y913m:'(+'Z9@0‹(F

o0UCJ.©%“SY©(%“\(la9—(3GR/9$Z(OR1BÍbnC9Y€89©%4'( %‚(Oo:aF"C%  < CJ.SY–a%4'(7=%{&CN$OR=ƒ:xZ9,mRB(†T'}TC©%4'(%‚(S$yB89Ëu{-C3d0'%U#0'(8u{,o$F

Vgm5+'341+o|:Y–fe'(7=SY¤%4'(i",(+@e#'91ƒ$n'†T'%{&Cƒ:xZ9,mRB(†•7=c"d0eCƒ$n'(+,f,5(gX*"i"b(3'(i"b(31#F7*+“9e@'(

Page 169: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 169/248

  01(2-34 5678-,9% 56.:4%!"*

+mo4‹(+,f,5(gX³'9{o:œ+o{X",.0'(9{-x31 E94UR E9019¥SY£3oe'(FA.7=+'3{Xl,,U0'(J:ÏSYƒ:K'(+@e#'91–@$n'SC%‚(7=(3ox(3C9’9-[*F7*+,f,5(gX*

"i"b(3'(i"b(31#†•+mC%“+o$9ay9@Mo'J:;8ƒ$n'(%‚(c3mC}  t ,T0'91F†{a>a%57=¹%:05+X(Žo'6%U#0'(89{#T'8 E9|C=Bc3m5s1…3RSY+X(Ž'(N$

SC%‚(F(j*9Y}  t ,.ƒ$n'(%‚(Oe-R69{:Y73T0X+f,0#'(†•789:0'(€Z9@0‹(F

"`8ž  t mG0C…Z%'(I+m,m—(SY€n‚Œ,X5+:UX+#,:YF 7*k"b*y9C9[£n0Y(+:UX+#,:Y†•#,TU0'SYž,m›…Z%'(SY€n‚"C"»€3m:YF¼R=€89›7=clo  < 5e-R+19f0X91¼R=Iz`(3'(B"C%59•j9¿(3'

¼G#X+x%-'( En:aF"m'¼$Z2y9CB3'(i"G0‹(Z9›(†0,a3e'(O0:#Y8SY€n0b(–'%1+,1%^'(SY€n‚"C"{0'(S~1¦%b™8D E(Z2N$JMY(]•¦9K0[B(F

J:8(]•"C"{0'(6 EB3m:Y¼:Xy9CB3'(i"G0‹()*Œ,X5+:UX9’9{-x31 E("o1c3mC En:a],-#01JMY¨]•6y9RA|'(N$u[%'(SY+-oT0'(iwKm'("Y\(F

A.79.c9#0,-'Œ-R?#:‹( E9Y9µ+@e#'91+Y3TGo'+,TC%Y\(9Y"#$u5j9¿(2(%m'( €9‚Zh1y(3`+C%[email protected]$+-@AF7*+#U,•+@[%'(IÐ9-—(N$+:UX+#,:Y"`u5w@:0'(9{#$Ii%.]Y+CÑ)*%C·8…9a"'(†TC%Y\(y%1826(2A#.9YSY73;

67353R¨"$9eY78¸~'SY\(6Å8"'( E9:a("YS$©("•=y9CB3'(i"G0‹(+,TC%Y\(I¦3#;c9#0,a‡

#$=+*> ?-@A>B 

.?+_9‹91Òƒ#f0'+UCl•+,TC%Y=/(%TR+Clqˆ9#0:Ue'9#-x31 En,-.F‰1?

+_9‹91Òc9#0,a ¦3#; Ó(2= /9m1*ˆ9’ +Ô90‹( Ó(2\(8‰+,#,K'( i%4,e'( ±29‚F+?+_9‹91ÒVAe'(ƒ:~'¦3#;c9#0,az0U0'91¤%41Õ,$%M.=+C%bFˆS$ Œ@0mY

 †¥283#,.8 79{,p+-.+P 6‡/51‰

7*+Y(Z*…Z%'(SY€n‚ž,m›+:UX+1nK'91†•%Y= Äc9•Œ,'‘maN$",:x+X9,e'(6+,'8"'(J1I"C":'(SY}_9„3'(+,oG‹(+,Y3T—( E9|C=FA#,18 <l  t .%C(]•

Page 170: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 170/248

!(# "#$%&'()%*+(,(-.-/%

¦90T'(JT~1È9X=N$}`(3‹(†0'(Œ,'9{,a+4oX6+Cl.%Y7ha29“*JU:'(ž@4#C  E9|C=N$"C":'(SY}`(3‹(†0'(SU|05 E9$3RSY+4oe'(+Cl.%‹(Fƒ@e'(83•OR=?0b

y9Y3T—(%M.\(+,o$9aBz,40e57=]‚5c(l0'(9{,#“(3YJT~16†v"18=O  Š #  Š U   Ö |  Š 5F  EB"18SY6'jk"'+Y3T—(yn$9-5+,f,5(gX*zY6–Y3TG‹(¨]•8yn$9-0'(  E(wM.9Y]d05JTp+o|:Y–fe'(i2%T0‹(F

CD*D$E-2 !*D$F- 

ƒœN$+Y3T—(7=…Z%59{,#“(3YSY£9{0R(73R9m'(FN:aJ,@X6€9M‹(SYJ;=+C9@;ƒ_(º'(JT~16J$9aN$+Y3T—(7=Ía9›N$9{0:UX93.Ó9m5SY

¦ t%{0CSYƒ_(º'(FiZ9$9Yž-#5+Y3T—(N$y9m,mG0'(yA.9G‹(8–1%{0Uo'SYƒ_(º'(%M.=9ÀJK›O,o$SYy913m:'(+H8%-‹(u{,o$F7*©"•+Y3T—(3•

z@4'91/9m1(N$9{0:UX£9eY91–1 t%{0  < ‹91u{0U.9Ë8SYJ;=…Z2J.SY€3  t e  < 5O'Oe-R7=¦%{0CSYƒ_(º'( [email protected]=9Yž@4#CN$z¯ƒ_(º'(ž@4#C E9|C=

N$"C":'(SY€9Tp=+@`(%‹(‡7*J|a=+o,X8+Y(Z£3oe'(z,4‹(SY©%“–#“(3‹( 3•7=?m@5+Y3T—(i2Z9`+@[(28IŒC%T5Z2(3‹(JT~1":1=wMT1SYƒe#'(+KKd‹(¡K—78¸~'(6+,'9—(SYJ;=/9m1(N$9{0:UX9•29{0p(8+1nK'91FI+'9b+Y3T—(6–#“(3‹(8o0µ+,#@'(+,$A0;B( EnMÀˆ E9@$B‰ E9Cl.%Y E("b(8+a9H91)*"C":'(SY–@$n'(–C3R9M'(F";358+,#1+,$A0;(+°9~YI%  T  Š 0G  < ‹(s]'(

€89…Z2–o‚("'()*O`3XFSY8+oMY\(k%‚\(3•€9MY+C23“(²Y(†0'(€89›…Z2y(23¥y9&a9G‹(+:190'(9’FIJ.+'9bSY6–0'9—(73T5+oT~‹(†•z#Y

y9C"G0'(SY€n‚Ð9-—(N$+:UX+019¥IJY9:0'(u{:YFSY8J;=Ð9-—(N$ ¨]•+:Ue'("`ƒo40C%Y\(+{;(3Y"›–:Y+1nK1i3`8±%¿S$+a9.Œ,C9m‹(ƒe#'(8+o‚("'(Io5+,|m'(y(]'91F

B8z,40e5?0b+Y3T—(%M.\(i3`J,:-5+C=i"$9`9•290¿†•FN$+Y3T—(7=…l0#5c(l0'B(SY+,@'9[–Y3TG‹(SYJ;=7=73T5i%¥¸YFƒo40C8c9,m'(']1

Page 171: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 171/248

  01(2-34 5678-,9% 56.:4%!(!

zH8J,:-58"$(3`L,G173TCSYs"f‹(+@e#'91+,@'9^'–Y3TG‹(7=9•3:,4Cu&:Yy9`8\(FSY8+oMY\(N$¨]•+oT~‹(+,X9X\('j€9M‹(s]'(¬ <"  Š Iu,&#5

¬ t3o0'(†$9#K'(FA.89{o  t Tpl'3TXˆ+-05‰67ha+'9.8u,&#0'(†Y3T—(+.Ž'(8+:H9Q(

u,&#0o'9¾I+o|:Y–fXzYA{|:1>:@'(Fy(29,da+.Ž'(I+C=+4mRSY

¢9m#'(ƒœ7=ža(305JT~1†$3“zY6"$(3m'(8=7=¡oU059{#YF9Y=y(29,‚ +'9.3'(†{a7=?#@05 E94UR E9C],-#5IJY9:0'(zYo5+.Ž'(6y(]'91(]•8‘U#'(9Y=7=73TC E9R%Y8= E9C×`F

J. ",-0e,X 9{#,b 6"$(3m'91 +.Ž'( ¼Yl0'(8 +R8%U1 ],-#0'91 +'9.3'( ¼Y9` 9Y  E(j*€Z9@0‹( 789:0'( SY +.Ž'(8 +'9.3'( SYF '( SY ",-0e5 +'9.3'9a",-0e5 +.Ž'(8 6+.Ž'( c(l0 

SY+R8%Y+'9.3'(Fƒ  t #f0C8n.–a%4'(},'9T0'(+&•9@'(y(/(%;],-#0'(i9H9m‹(8FZ9K0`B( N$ J`= +-oT018 c90'( c(l0'B( N$ +@5g‹( "_(3-'( E9|C= ƒeT,X zU0f‹( 7= A.F

ST'8(j*9Y¼K  t oµ+.Ž'(¼Y9`8+'9.3'(c("d0X91],-#0'(6s×m'(Â9:,X79a%4'( SY},'9T5y913m:'(+`n:o'+,_9|m'(+Ï9#'(SY'jFA.7=+.Ž'(O;(35 E9|C=  E(/(%[*3GR¡oU0'((j*¼R9.+'9.3'(c"d0e5+X9,X],-#5+R%YBJU  Š 0  < 7=ƒ`9:5

¡oU0'(FA.7=+'9.3'(¦]f#0X3GRc("d0X(‘URc29x™9`8zY+.Ž'(+$894  < ‹(SYJ;=€3K—(N$"_(3a],-#5J,:-58"$(3m'(+&•9@'(SUM'(JT~1w[€3m:YF

STUC+'9.3o'7=?#@05+,f,5(gX*""b(3'(ii"b(31#†0'(8†4:0X+.Ž'(  E(la9bc(l0'n'6†$34'(']18ƒ#f05c9m0RB(JMU0‹(+X9,e1],-#0'(s×m'(FIJ„

¢8Ž'(+U_n‹(ƒX9TUo'8=y9$3a"‹(™9,mY86uKQ(STUC+`n:o'–1+{(

+U&#‹(+{(8+:H9Q(u,&#0o'7=73T5+`n$+:a9R9,$A0;(SYc(l0'B(†$34'( ],-#0'(87%‹(7(2%T0‹(F+-K'(8i"C"(†0'(9{Y t"`±j3UR"l'3TX2BCD)E#J$9-0o'–1+Y3T—(

–Y3TG‹(8†•29,Q(I9H(s]'(OTo0µ+Y3T—(A1ž  t o:0C+Y(ª1wC9:‹(FzH3a29,:Y¬ t3o56c29xN$J,@X6€9M‹(J:f,X/(%[(¡  t oU0o'(w@. E(";FSY+,b9#'(

Page 172: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 172/248

!($ "#$%&'()%*+(,(-.-/%

6k%‚\(7*zH8 E(29,:Y En•9e0Y E(";†#:,X E9¥ t3o56 E9b3UeY']18JomCƒeT‹(”0‹(SY789:0'(€Z9@0‹(s]'(O@eT0X+'9.3'(SY€n‚c(l0'B(†$34'(F+$"Q(8

†•"C"›+Y(Ÿ29,:‹(JT~1z-5%YA1O,a+C9-T'(€3KGo'N$u&:Yza9#‹(+,$A0;B(6u,&#0o'ST'8¼e,'+:-5%Y E(";L,G1z#µ2 t345‘UR¼19¥SYc(l0'B(

†$34'(SYJ@`z,¯y9.Ž'( E9@C%m5F

+a9H918)*z#xwC9:‹(69{m,@458iZ9$9Yc3m5+Y3T—(>-1y9anQ(–1 ©(%“\(+x9Q(FJ|a=8€9MY3•+,|`¤n4'(†0'(c3m5+UTG‹(9{,a§#U1+C9x3'("b\6SC31\(¹%-58y9@o40Yy9$3a"Yu$ZJ-4'(N$%‚(F7*JMY¨]•€3o—(+«,X¼,K'(ƒ@e1c"$+,`("KYy9$3a"Yu$"'(6+mbn'(c"$89{0,`3¥3YF(]’8

6ƒ@e'("m'u5V(g`B(71?4:5yn$9-0'(+,o@m0e‹(–1SC31\(+:,@“+,'Z9@5SY€n‚VAe'(s]o'c3mC+C9x3'91ƒGe1y(·9,0Y(i29Cl'((j*9Y tª`%‚(I

y9$3a"Yu$"'(ˆwX898%.8 S.83#Y+-.-‰F7*(]•Vgm‹(Z9TCJKC)*zH8SC31\(I}`3Y+o|:Y–fe'(6i2%T0‹(A{.gC8791 t%œy9,f,5(gX*+,#@YN$789:0'(F

SY8JY¸‹(7=73T5+f,0#'(i",-YJ-4o'SY€n‚C8%5‘UR¼19¥SY789:0'(–1 SC31\(+,#@YN$€Z9@0'(s]'(%;90Cy9$3a"U1u$Z+`3¥3YJ19mYy(·9,0Y(i29Cl'(FB‘@5%5y9Y3T—(9{,#“(3U16‘ma9{#T'8‘@5%5y9Y3TG1k%‚='].FI

>:16y9`9,e'(STUCJT'+Y3Tb7=J$9-05zY+C=+Y3Tbk%‚=JT~1†_9#¥F€9M‹(8N$'j3•i%4,Xi29f0'(+,‹9:'(†0'(z,40eC"o@'(9{,a7=¹%-CZ3,m'(N$

y(Z2(3'(SY"o16%‚½ N$J,@X€9M‹(+^,K1Z2†Y9m0R("Hy9X2A‹(+C29f0'(w[+'Z9:'(FST'8+Ue'(iwM‹(k"'y9Y3T—(†0'(8Çu0C9•]‚=79@e—91"—7(†•

9=+,#@YN$¹(2=+,U,o`*iZ"ËFI8c9&#'(†m“9#‹(6¡'9Q(73TCk"'J.ƒ$BZ"$J,o`‘maSY67(w(B8J$9-0CB*zY/B¸•7(w(F7*yAe'(+,'((]’…3#'(SY?#@'(+,$A0;B(†•…3H3YLG@‹(cZ9m'(F

!G )HI#7J K- Ö"  Š :  < 5uY\(zC29~‹(8+C29f0'(J_9@m'(823,4'(8+oMY=N$–@$n'(SC]'(iZ9$9Y

73o^0~CSUHZ8"b+,U,o`*+#,:YFu  < {a73o$9-0CzYu(w;%M.=wMT1SYu{o$9-5

Page 173: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 173/248

  01(2-34 5678-,9% 56.:4%!(%

zYSC",:@'(F6']187hau{b9fR"U0:[email protected]$k"YSebu{_(Z=Iu»n$9-5zYu(w;FSTUC87=73T57(wfo'+-,„8k%‚= E9|C=FSTUC29fo'7=

%  t a3CB9MYk]0  < O1F(j*79.29(c3mC/(Z16",;7haO.3oXSTUC7="  t om  < CF¨]°8+mC%4'(STUCy9,f,5(gX³'+G;9#'(7=Ž0#5–1c3U$679Te'(SY29;29F

STUC%&#'()*u,'9`\(–0mC%41–0-o0q E9Y9µF+mC%4'()8\(†•ža8+,a(%^(

/9|-'(8sZ9‹(FN$J,@X6€9M‹(A1273TCc9&R"Õ  $…   ŠZ8£w[Õ,:C#I¤Z9#‚ €90m'("`Ž0R(SY/l;w^xSY+{@;€90m'()*ž“9#‹(i289f‹(F9Y=+mC%4'(+,R9M'(%&#o')*u,'9`\(†{aƒeG1/9|-'(Z%f‹(¡_9Kdo'FN$J,@X6€9M‹(STUC

+.Ž'+C29Ï7=¤ t3e5 E918ŽYw[Å3G.2("mU1 t–:YSY%  t Te'(2("mY8 t–:YSY–,a9T'(F7*7(w;(]•¦8Ž‹(w[Å3GT'(†•y918Ž‹(k%‚\( 0'(† I¤3e'(

2("mU1J`=8=%M.=SY%  t Te'(FN$8Œ-R62(%^'(A12]d0C Ä§  t p%YÈ9,X E9:`3Y E9#,:YN$",:x":  < @'(Å(²,o'(ØÍa9G‹( E9:`3Y8I":  < @'(†‹9:'(ØÅ(l:RB(F(j*79.£9#•

"C":'(SY–G  t p%‹(–ea9#0‹(zYu{|:16>:@'(7haÙ7(w;Ú§  t p%‹(u• '8=« SC]'(Iz`(3Y+°9~YF(]T•87hau,'9`\(STUC7=73T5y(/9|aiZ%W+a9H*)*93.y(/9|a+,a(%^;F

%  t a3C82A:0XB(+,'½ k%‚=+a9H91)*",om0'(8=i9.9G‹(†0'(STUCSY9’n‚y9,f,5(gX³'7=Jm0#5SY79TY)*79TY%‚½ FSTUC7=¬"2A:0XB((j*9Y79.

z`3Y+,f,5(gX(J`\( E9b9fR"`u5O'n0b(SYJ@`JeR29(%M.\( E9b9fRFST'8/(3X¼R9.y9,f,5(gX("`yŽ0R(²$",om0'(8=62A:0XB(i%T-'9a†•9{e-R‡7*

7(w(673o$9-0C+,f,5(gX(8%M.\( E9b9fRŽ0#5)*z`(3‹(+Ô90‹(F?m@C7(w(

–019¥I6u{:`(3YST'8y9,f,5(gXB(9  Š {  < #  TU  < ,  Š a29~0RB(FJ:8¨]•+,oU:'(+o19`6J,oG0o'B"1SY9•"C"›SY+,b9#'(+,oT~'(F

¹(%[Ã'86+,G,H30'(JY5I+,#1+4,e1u,'9`Ã'†0'(73T59{,az,¯Ó(2\(+U  t emYL,G17=J.ƒ$BOC"'+:12=67(w;"b(8SY€A~'("b(88SY¤Ž'("b(88SY¦3#(%‚½8SY¦%^'(FJKJ.ƒ$BIJ.ÙJ,;ÚN$+;2ZV9fR

Page 174: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 174/248

Page 175: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 175/248

  01(2-34 5678-,9% 56.:4%!('

+,f,5(gX(†UG0'9{e-RSYi%4,Xi(l^'(¼e,' E9“8š"p=+Y(ŸIc9&#'(†U,o`(9{#YIc9&#'(†$A0;B(L,b73TCJ.Z%a+H%$7\†m0oCJ.Z%a%‚½ F

56KGL4%5.'(M4%‡(j*¼R9.i"$9m'(ˆ8=+,f,5(gX(‰i%m0eY69,$9¯†{ai%m0eY9,U,o`*F

‘oeC879•²'(N$¨]•+,H%-'(>:1/3|'(N$y9,'½ +U&R\(+,U,o`(F¹ga(7=£9#• E9Y9&R E9,U,o`*c"d0eCO,az,U(+,f,5(gX*+,oË+,ox=73T5i%m0eY6 E9,$9¯("$9Y¡dp"b(8c"d0eC+,f,5(gX*i"C";F–@0C8(]•}`3‹(IJT~'(

u`25F7(8JY5A,a(j*79.k"'29(cZ9m'("C"(s=ƒ@X€3G0o')*+,f,5(gX*'jcZ9m'("C"(FA17=+,f,5(gX(+,ox\(i%m0eY6 E9,$9¯7hacZ9m'("C"(B

STUC7=c3mCJ,fe01¢9mRi",;9Y"#$73TC E9“9Ë–#“(3‹916–,ox\(Œ-#1+mC%4'(†0'(Jfe  < C9°S“(3‹(Ìx\(¢9G‹(–#“(3‹91–,ox\(FST'8J.29;SY

7(w;cZ9m'("C"(o0UCIz`(3'( E(29;3•S“(3YÌx=6 E9|C=3•8¢9ËJT~1c95–#“(3‹91SC%‚( E9|C=F6']'©3XS'"œs=29;SY7(w;cZ9m'("C"(7=

w‚\(3•29(%M.\( E9b9fR†T'(3Y3mC¨",om01F(]'7haJ.7(w;cZ9m'("C"(73m@,XN$u»9,f,5(gX*6+,ox\(8=9Y€Z9:C/Û'(6Oe-Rs=7=(3'3G0C)*

+,f,5(gX*"b=u(w;SY–#“(3‹(–,ox\(F6']'BSTUC+,f,5(gX³'i"C"(7=Ž0#5I¢9X8=79Te'(+-'¸‹(SYy9,f,5(gX*i%m0eY6 E9,$9¯6Å90'9187ha

+,f,5(gX(i%m0e‹( E9,$9¯†•+,f,5(gX*i%m0eY E9,U,o`*F NDO PQR4%%*56C63DE 5678-,% 56.= S' "#,TU%1 V W?@-' +%X

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y YY Y  Z Y YY Y Y Y YY Y Y Y Y

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Page 176: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 176/248

!(" "#$%&'()%*+(,(-.-/%

   t–@  < 5+,H%-'(+o_9m'(71+,f,5(gX(i%m0e‹( E9,$9¯†•i%m0eY E9,U,o`*7=+CA—(SY%4‚V9,0;B(†•+o{XN$J`\(Ic9&#'(†U,o`(A.†•+o{XIc9&#'(

%  < b¢n0‚B(Fk"b*–Y9|‹(†•7=789:0'(€Z9@0‹(STUCÐ9-—(O,o$Ic9&#'(†U,o`(SYJ@`i"$9m'(6+-,4o'(78Zƒo40YIufb™9,mYuKQ(+R29mY

y(š¸U1ƒX9T‹(².=9Àƒo40C%Y\(J:i"$9m'(+-,4o'(i%m0eY E9,$9¯F

Œ,'i28º'917=73T5i"$9m'(+-,4o'(i"$9`6+#Y½ ?0bi"$9eU1+,#@'( +,$A0;B(+,U,o`(Ð9-Go'N$2(%m0XB(F(j*¼R9.€n„J@m0e‹(+-,:HJT~16w@. E(j*Bz,40e5+C=+,f,5(gX*+-,4'7=c89m5V9,0;B(?0bi"$9eU1+m4#‹(

+,U,o`(FI+'9b6¨]{.STUCy9,'+,oU$V9,0;B(7=73T5i"m:Y6 E(";+1(];8  E(";"#$%&#'(9{,'*F–@C8JT~'(u`2/B9MYN$JMY(]•‘U#'(":m‹(FJ  t MUC8(]•

JT~'(}`3Yƒ$B"b(8iZ9$9Y62"^C3•8V90œ E9$3UW E9,R9TX E9,U,o`*9R3TYSYZ(%a=73Y"d0eC+,f,5(gX*"i"b(3'(i"b(31#FI¨]•6+'9—(u5J:;J„J@m0e‹(8=

¨23|b -,:H E9 6 E(";A.ŒT:#C'jIu,m'(+|-d#‹(™9,m‹6uKQ(, 7 5:+F"m'u529,0‚(y(š¸Yy("_9:'(+:12\(%  t a30' E9G,H35k"‹y(",m:0'(+#TU‹(FI8¨]•

6+'9—(F7A@8471-8<7@827?F!+"¨]°86u,m'(–@CJT~'(u`2/9Y¬"":1J,;"b(8+:@X8€9,;=+:12=8Ž$ En,;+:e58Ž$ En,;F"m' Š%U:0X(Z9[8\(

79TX"i"b(3'(i"b(31#6–oT~Y E94UR E(j9‚=SYZ8"—(+oC34'((8·89Ï82l;–R89:0‹(F

 

ˆ+‰ Z3;31¨]•u,m'(73.8, 7 +:567hac9&#'(†U,o`(†4:CGH > FH $ + > GH $ +6/9#M0X91G5 > F/6L,b7=GH9#•†•+;2Z2"^'(u_("'(I%% GzY7(w;!i"b(3'(i"b(31"68FH

†•+;2Z+,f,5(gX*!i"b(3'(i"b(31"zYH66666s=7(w;!i"b(3'(i"b(31"N$J,@X6€9M‹(G/ 7 Jˆ2"^'(u_("'(Ki"b(3'(i"b(31‰7 F 3 ,< : 8+;,9 7 A@ 3 8+:59 8@981:59 7

A-F

Page 177: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 177/248

  01(2-34 5678-,9% 5 !((

FTU%?= FTU%?4% F

a1`% bK?4%

 

 .:4%

 NDO PQ &*  T7(D 0?/O8[ 0(Q/ S' 57?C\ ] (_1`% O(R-A%

 b=(I4% P6$% V1`% P6$% 

c7 b=%G4% P6$%

  4%

 

Page 178: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 178/248

 

Ü  tA$JK9Y"#$ 8=%‚Ý1FSY8¤%4'(

¬–0e'(8i%a30‹(SY+ ž“9#Y+,U,o`*§UeC

 &'()%*+(,(-.-/%

c7 b/(-4% P6$%‡L 7u_(Z 2"[I)) G

 Þ(%a7i"b(31 i"b(3'(

+mC% k%‚\(%&#o')*y(w¥0'(+,U,o`(†• 573@$ E9$3#5 E9:X(8SYy9,f,5(gX(i"m:‹( T~1

c9 ']1†•c("d0X("$(3m'(ˆy9,f,5(gX(‰ M'(+ SY+'34@'(+,R8gT'(F7*"C"›J.i"$9` 121

!() #$%

90-‹( 

 '(8c"d0eC '(+U_n‹( mo'+'3( R9M'(

Page 179: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 179/248

  01(2-34 5678-,9% 56.:4%!(*

Z":'–@$n'(§,GK'( E9Y9µ7=ÃUCÞ(%-'(s]'(Îo@CO$9-52(+/+,o‚OH%$8+0+,o‚‘maF7A|'7=J."b(8B€(lCo0UC+:12=7(w;6‘maSTUC%&#'()*Z8"b

Þ(%-'(N$9=}0o5N$9{e-R=FN$J,@X6€9M‹(z1%‹(s]'(Iß`=–U,'(o0UCz1%‹(ž194‹(s]'(Iß`=29e,'(N$OR= E(29;O'F

¹%^'8+Cr29Y¬"G,X9Y"#$c3mC73@$n'(c("d0X91JMY(]•…3#0'(zX(3'(SY"$(3`j9¿(2(%m'(i"m:‹(JT~18=6%‚Ý1SYs28º'(‘ma7=l  t -GR+,oU:'(J,"b(8Ii%‹(i"b(3'(F%a358_90R+'34@'(y9Y3o:Y+C28D€3b¢9m#'(

†0'(JK›9{,o$J.i"$9`SY"$(3m'(zYs=29;79.SY7(w(SC]'(98289œF73T0X+;2Zu,o`( E(j*†•‘X30YO“9mRzY"$(3m'(z12\(†0'(¨289ÏF9Y87=u0CŒ,X5+;2ZJ.u,o`*SY6u,'9`\(?0b="@5+,oU$€ t3G0'(FJTau,o`*o0UC E(29;

%M.= E9b9fR€ t3G0,X+“9e@1)*i"$9m'(%M.\( E9b9fR†0'(k"'OR(w;F

J;\8".0'(SY7=_90#'(¼e,'+X9eb E(";¨9Ïy9@;(3'(+,_(3~:'(†0'(y="16+,oU:'(¼µiZ9$*+,oU$i9.9G‹(Ž$y(%YZ3;31y9@;(8+,_(3~$+-o0qI

J.i t%YFu58/(%;*J.+,oU$i9.9ËSYy9,oU:'( En,;":1J,;?0bÇ":5£9#•+C=yB t3›+,a9H*STUC9{¥8"bF"`8¤%^0X((]•%Y\(SY"b=Ž$ En,;)*+:12=

SCŽ$8 En,;F¼-`35+,oU:'(S$2340'(IJ.+'9bSYyB9—(9Y"#$u5/9|m'(N$+a9."$(3m'(†0'(ÇST5+-,4'FZ3;318"$(3m'(+-,4o'(6‘ma79.z,U( E9R89:0Y  EA_(ZzYSC%‚(+a9.Ç8¬"›+C=yB3›+,a9H*F

%{&C8‘U#'(†_9{#'(59#'(IJT~'(u`2AF'9#•Z"$SYyAe'(+o•]‹(I

(]•‘U#'(%m0e‹(SYy9,f,5(gX(F6B8=7*y9,f,5(gX(+,;9#'(J0T05zY9{|:1  E9Y3U$Iu,'9`=+-o0qc9fb\(F7*29~0RB(†_(3~:'(s]'(="1+$3UW79Te'("`

§ea€9f‹( E(wM.c9Y=u,'9`\(y(jy9,f,5(gX(+°9~0‹(†0'(Ž0#5I>:179,b\([email protected]'j'9#• E9|C=u,'9`=+o,o`iw^x86 E(";J1?0b

ž“9#YiZ%-#Y+“9Ë–#¥918=+¥n¥SYu,'9`\(+-o0d‹(F

Page 180: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 180/248

!)# "#$%&'()%*+(,(-.-/%

 PQR4%'*BHd(.e% f(g.4% ] h(QI4% i?Cje% >7 V(M'@ @ @ + // // // // // @ @ . . @ . @ @ @

@ + 5+ + + // // // + 5 @ 5 @ @ @ @ @ @

@ @ 5+ 5+ + + + + 5+ + 5 5 5 A1 A1 @ @ @

@ + 5+ 5+ 5+ 5+ 5+ 5+ 5+ 5+ 5+ 5 5 @ @ @ @ @

@ - 5+ 5+ 5+ 5+ 5+ 5+ 5+ 5+ 5+ 5+ 5 @ @ @ @ @

@ 5+ 5+ 5+ 5+ 5+ 5+ 5+ @ 5+ 5+ 5+ 5+ @ @ @ @ @

@ 5+ 5+ @ @ - 5+ 5+ @ - /+ 5+ 5+ @ @ 5+ 5+ @

@ 5+ 5+ @ @ - - - @ /+ /+ 5+ / 5+ 5+ 5+ 5+ @

@ 5+ 5+ - - - - - @ /+ /+ /+ /+ 5+ 5+ 5+ 5+ 5+

@ 5+ @ - - - @ @ @ /+ /+ /+ +. 5+ 5+ 5+ 5+ 5+

@ @ - - - - @ @ @ /+ /+ /+ /+ 5+ 5+ 5+ 5+ .

@ @ . . . @ @ @ - /+ /+ . . . . . . @

@ @ . . . @ @ @ @ /+ . . . . . . . @

@ @ . @ @ @ // @ @ @ . . . . . @ @ @

 +(Uklm9%*56A1nQ49% ojI4% 53p2' 54?l= S' 56A(M4% 54?$% ] +(6j6q %n/k4 #r%Ge% PI3Iq >7 VTq bD?' Pr ] B-4% f(DO`%s t4(Me% P6:/ >7!u1 FTU%?= TU%?4%%!uv_T[(As

 

J,µy9,f,5(gX(†0'(¼fR¼,m18)*93.y9,f,5(gX*Jfe5y9;2Z+,'9$I+'34@'(FN$J,@X6€9M‹(¼o  t MY"i"b(3'(i"b(31# Y€ t": z@XiŽ$i%YI

…3Uf‹(Â9Te'(6†_9{#'(":17=y="1+:121¶  Š e  < R E9Y9µIJ.+'3;FST'8¼R9.£9#•   E9|C=ŒÔy9,f,5(gX*k%‚=79.9’J,MµJ|a=I…3Uf‹(Â9Te'(†_9{#'(F¼R9.8J|a=¨]•y9,f,5(gX(†•o5†0'(9{Y t"`sZ82w["C9R†0'(8y·%b=+@5%‹(

+CZ9—(–¥nM'(8SY–1y9,f,5(gX(¬nM'(–0e'(8+.29~‹(I+'341s28"'(Jeoe0‹(F¼{0R(¨]•+,f,5(gX(Ic9&#'(†U,o`(€ t":U1–:12= E9:195F6(]'

Page 181: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 181/248

  01(2-34 5678-,9% 56.:4%!)!

+,f,5(gX9a+G,GK'(I}K0#Y2(3~Yy9C30eY+'341s28"'(Jeoe0‹(¼R9.†•+,f,5(gX(%M.\( E9b9fRIc9&#'(†U,o`(†_9#M'(Z9:1\(F},Ta¬"bÆ'j

7*+,f,5(gX*i"$9m'(9{e-R+@:xJ,oG0'(9\+,#@YN$‘4q+m194Y€8("(s]'(c"d0eC_90#'(¬nM'(+m19e'(2%m,'9YƒœOo:aA,a":1F <O#T'8STUCJ,o›

/(Z=i"$9m'(ƒeG1+mC%“9{_(Z=zYJ.i"$9`SY"$(3m'(†0'(STUC7=9{{;(35FA.8

3•€9—(zY"$(3m'(k%‚\(†0'(6¼fRÇSTCv_T[(A€8=SY2"^CFST'89Y3•   ÄZ%-0Y€3b¨]•+,f,5(gX(3•OR=9Y"#$c3mCƒ$n'(%‚(2"^'916 EB8=¼R9.+,f,5(gX*v_T[(AI>:179,b\(i2Z9`N$Oo:;Ù2]0:CÚi2(l^1L,G17=+,f,5(gX*v_T[(AIz`(3'(†{0#C9°©94‹(+ofeY+;2ZN$=9À3'79.£9#• E9R89:5

  EBZ9@0YF¬"8(]•zYŒÔSY"$(3m'(z12\(SCŽ$8†0'(ÇST5+-,4'FI+'341s28"'(6+oeoe0‹(ÇSTC'j9,a9.sZ¸0' E/(Z=(",; E("; E9‹9“¼R9.v_T[(AiZ9$9Y

J‚"5IynT~YzY"$(3m'(k%‚\(†0'(ÇST5+-,4'F

]‚523Y\( E?G#Y E(%‚½ I+U&R\(+,m“9#‹(FST'8SY€n‚J:;ŒÔSY "$(3m'(†0'(ÇST5+-,4'62]0:5·3-5v_T[(A"C":'91SY–  t '3G0‹(SY9(w;F9Y"#$73TC("b(8SY/B¸•SC2]0:‹(9@C%`SYv_T[(A79.87(w(+¥nM'(SC%‚(SY

"$(3m'(6+-,4o'(JU07=c3m5v_T[(A/(Z1J|a=SYs=SY9(w;z12\(8=?0bs=SYu(w;u•F¨]°8+mC%4'(9{#TUC7=€ t3›Œ,'‘ma62]0:‹(ST'8>:18=

z,¯9(w;SC%‚( E9|C=F6']'Ic9&#'(†$A0;B(†#@‹(N$29~0RB(²$6",om0'('9#•il,[email protected].(2Z9`N$€3K—(N$V9fR6l,U0Y?0b7(879.'j

†#:C7=‘X30Yk30eYV9f#'(Œ,' E(l,U0YFƒ@e'(8/(28'j3•7=y9@X9#Y

V9f#'(l,U0‹(·3-5wMT'91SY–'3G0‹(F7*+m,mb7=v_T[(A†•+,f,5(gX*+-,4' †#:59=ƒ#f05…(ª'(w[6s28º'(Jx(3589{Teµ9{e-#19Y"#$u0C/9|m'(N$"$(3m'(w[+-,4o'(F7*il,‹(†0'(JK›9{,o$+,f,5(gX*v_T[(A+,#@YN$+m,mbOR=

A#,173T5y9,f,5(gX(ŒUQ(i2]0:Y9{,'*N$3GR6€ t]Y9YSY+,f,5(gX*+-,4'k%‚=…l0#5JMY¨]•y(2(]0$B(SY%M.=SY–5"$9`–5%‚=F

Page 182: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 182/248

!)$ "#$%&'()%*+(,(-.-/%

   t–@Cc9&#'(†m“9#‹(JT~18§H(8(";7=+mC%4'(†0'(J$9-0C9°73@$n'(zYu{|:1>:@'(STUC7=%¥¸5N$29eY+,oU:'(+  t C2340'(F"m'u5J,o›"C":'(SY?#@'(ƒeG1u,•9-‹(+C2340'("—67(N$u[%'(SY7="C":'(SYy9,R9TY(iwM‹(9Y

¼'(·%&0#5J,oG0'(!+"FJ.i"b(8SY¨]•?#@'(ŒUQ(†0'(u59{KG-5I(]•¦90T'( <}~T5S$O;8=+-o0q2 t340'789:0'(‡

 ˆ+‰ A,aÌC–@R>:1yBA0bB(+#TU‹(†0'(9Y¼'(·+;9G1)*9{KG-5žmG0'(8SY9{0Gx=

+FSTUC+C9{#'J$9-0'(7="U0:5N$¶C25J$9-0'(FN$J,@X6€9M‹(STUC7="U0:5N$k"YSeb/(Z=–@$n'(Fƒ$n'9aw[§;9#'(73T5yBA0b(O53Y8=OXna*8=OMG1

S$Cš%‚½ yBA0b([email protected]+'B"'(89#•†•OR="`B73TCSYs"f‹(7=J^0e5  E9@$BS'c3mCc9m0RB91S'8z,40eCc9,m'(O1Fƒ@e'(8/(28'j3•OR=B†^@#C,o$7=J0m5+;9;"'(†0'(>,@5 E9@•jF

1FB±90›+@:o'(7\73T5+o|:Y–fXi2%T0YFN$J,@X6€9M‹(STUC7=73T5+@:'±9;Zi2%T0Y=3X=+f,0R9{,a†•2"^'(6€Z9@0‹(A.I+'9b¹89-0'(7~1+Y·=6+#,:Y

8=¦(D*€A:'(ˆŒ,aw;+-.0‰F…n“³'8N$_90R2 t345789:0'(I¨]•6+@:o'(%&R= Z29#C9YL,UXˆ+-01‰67A@,'8ˆ+-05F‰SY8yBA0bB(iZ2(3'(k%‚\(†•7=l_(3(STUC7=…3#05SY+omRk%‚\ˆZ8%o,e.½ +-.-‰FSY8yBA0bB(k%‚\(7=%a(305k"'

–@$n'(y(29,‚².=SYZ%Ws29,‚+,_9#¥2"^'(8=789:0'(F5FSTUC7=u|CJ$9-0'(%M.=SY–  Š @$B–#¥(Ii%‹(i"b(3'(F7*wa35"_(3-'(+,$A(

%  t a3C+'9b+,;j3UR+o|:‹–fe'(+x9Q(¡d~'91289f‹(H;M(N*DHˆ73e'8=+-@A‰FSU|058y9m,@40'( E9$3#5 E9:X(8SYynT~‹(†0'(73TC9{,ak"'J.£29~Y E(la9b

†T'73TC E9@.(2 E9,R9WN$¦9ebSC%‚(FSU|058+oMY\(+,oU$u,&#5y9,'9:-'(6+4[9|'(y9¾9e‹(8ISY\(†$A(FA.829p=ŒC8(Zˆ+-0?‰67ha+'9b¡d~'(

289f‹(H;M(N*DH

}o0¿JT~1†$3RS$+,|`–Kd~'(SY+¥n¥ƒR(3;FB8=‡7* 2º'(s]'(ƒ@e0CO,a2"^'(…   t·30CN$"C":'(SY–@$n'(B"1SY¨l,.%5N$¡dp"b(8F9,R9¥‡"`73TC£3oe'( EB3{WI¦9:'=¡d~'(289f‹( 

H;M(N*DH6 E9M'9¥=Œ,'k"'J.ƒ$BSY–@$n'(i%4,X+C],-#5+Y95N$z,¯–@$n'(SC%‚(A17=ƒX9T‹(iZ"ËA1c3mCO173@$n'(73-o0d‹(F7*y9,1Z\(+130T‹((]°

7~'([email protected] E(";ST'8J|a=9YSTUC¨%.j9#•†•ƒ0.73e'8=ˆ+-@A‰6± FSCZ29•ˆ+-@0‰6#,o,pˆ+-.5‰623oC95ˆ+-.@‰6ŒC8(Zˆ+-0?‰628FSCZ29•ˆ+-01F‰ à

Page 183: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 183/248

  01(2-34 5678-,9% 56.:4%!)%

+Fc"d  < 0X=¢n0‚B(†_(3~:'(O-x31 E9$3R E9,X9X=SY?#@'(F"`8y%{„=+'341s28"'(6Jeoe0‹(y9,H%-'(8+C%&#'(},.7=789:0'(†#@‹(N$+Ue'(+,'Z9@0'(STUC7=9,?0bI}`(3‹(†0'(%a305N$"b?RZ=SY+,#@'(+,$A0;B(F

1F¼µ+X(2Zy9:UÏSY–@$n'(+Cr%'},.STUC2340'789:0'(7=="@CI€8=%Y\(F§Ue5y9:Uf0'(cZ9mo'"C"(71JKN$J`\(N$+x%aiw^x

+{;(3‹cZ9`"C";6%‚½ ?0b7*879.73YZ9m'(Z"(u{e-R= E(/l; E(w^x E9C3R9¥SY ‘,G‹(ÌT'(–#“(3Uo'–,ox\(F?0b7*8¼R9.u&:Yyn$9-5–YZ9m'(Z"(†•zY–#“(3‹(–,ox\(w[6–R89:0‹(7ha E9:UÏ E(w^xSY–YZ9m'(Z"(SC]'(

73Y"d0eC+,'Z9@0'(STUC7=V90œ E9$3UW E9,R9TXSYZ9[8\(F5F79.l,,µ…3Uf‹(Â9Te'("` t–@5OR=¬"9Y"#$73T5k"'–@$n'(

y9Y3o:YS$u{|:1>:@'(%M.=9À3•%a30YI¶C295u»n$9-5+x9Q(F(j*¼R9.k"'–@$n'(y9-,#K5 t€"5N$u{0C3|$+$3UfU16+#,:Y8=N$>:1yAe'(

6+,Kd~'(7ha‘,U#0'(Jeoe0'(8†Y%’(+R9TUo'STUC7=7(2340CF(j*…940X( 73@$n'(+&bnYA{|:1>:@'(3•873o$9-0CzY–@$B6SC%‚½ 78234,ea+:UX

 /F"`}  t oT5J.i2"`SYy(2"`ƒ$n'(N$l,,U0'(c9m0RB(89«,p9YF6']'(j*79.J.

SC%‚(73Y"d0eCy9,f,5(gX*6+-,4'A1273TCSYs"f‹(7=Nd0RS$y(2"m'(N$l,,U0'(c9m0RB(8FA12"$9eC'jN$23U|'(†0`3'(y(2"mo'+,Y9m0RB(F6(]'

9{:X317=%  t a35+mC%“+X(2"'+,oU$i%4,e'(N$6§  t oe0'(…lR86Vne'(i"#0eYN$áZ9@‹(6+,_9m52B(Œ,'8N$y("•9:‹(+,UX%'(+,oT~'(F

 "`B73TCƒ$n'( E(".0YSY29,Q(s]'(¨]¿(ƒ$n'(%‚(JT~1Ì:aI+om#'(+m19e'(F"`8uf#5J.9~Y/9H3|'(+,_(3~:'(8=/3X€9@m0X(c9&#'(ˆŒ,aw;+-.@‰F+X(2"'8(]•

6%Y\(y",$=+'3()8\(SY+'34@'(+x%-1"b(8+_9‹91/3e'€9@m0X(+om#'(iw‚\(†0'(c9`9°ƒ$n'(%‚(F"`8ufR(]•S$ªR%‚½  E9|C=+,f,5(gX!i"b(3'(i"b(31"F€"58¨]•

+f,0#'(N$7=!i"b(3'(i"b(31"†•+,f,5(gX*+#,0Y E9,@eRIJ„©%„4Q(€"0:‹(I€9@m0XB(F

à

Page 184: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 184/248

!)& "#$%&'()%*+(,(-.-/%

âu’Z3;88+:Ue'(STUC7=sZ¸C)*Ç9$ue0CZ3{91+,Y(%'(…Z%'–XŽ'(SC%U#0‹(F/FÖy Š" ´ ;8y9Y3T—(73T0'9v"'9»nT~Y+,f,5(gX(+x9Q(SYL,b

ž,m›c(l0'B(SY©%“u&:Y–#“(3‹(F¨]•8¼e,'+oT~Y29,0‚(+,f,5(gX*+o$9a¹%^'9{Y("d0X(I+'9b+#,:Y6ƒeGaJ1†• E9|C=+'eY+,-,.zH8wC9:YL,G1

73TCc(l0'B( E(%Y= E9C%^Y–#“(3Uo' E(",-Y8zU0fUo'N$"b/(3XFAFu5+X(2Z+U&R\(+,U,o`(+Cr%'9Ys]'(¬"G,X(j*J$9-573@$n'(zYu(w;6‘ma(3Y9`8",om0129(s]'(79.%M.=9b9fRu{#YF";887=yn$9-0'(zY7(w(ƒ@e05I23{„>:1¢AR\(i"  t m:‹(I29~0R(>:1y9,f,5(gX(6+#,:‹(

C t8%583URo5y9,f,5(gX(†0'(¼o  t fX¢9mRi",;N$3GRw[sZ9,0$(I>:1}`(3‹(?0b7*8¼R9."`yZ= E/(Z= E9-,:HI}`(3Yk%‚=F

 

Page 185: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 185/248

 

!"#$%&' )*#%+ 

"#$%&'()*+,-./012+345"6789:; <+"=>[email protected]=.DEF#&G5H+HI&JK1A(L1MF$&NO?6/$:P+QEF#&G5RA)$0S.9*T+Q,UVW&MX)*+W9-./012+W9F9YZF*+

JW9)&N1+"*+W9*T+,B[./$D2+\].^$D2+_,%96`*+"#  a $%  b P+34[./6*+cd.U$*+Me.F$*+NQ.75OJfMgDAF*+EF#9VG5GAF0W9*T+,BhH.&ijMU*+OhH.4k].^$D2+W6:)*.;

[.l4m*no4.U*+OpAqr+34S.%&s$*+S.7"t+N[.);uvBM-+NHW9;.^$D2+QONw.4px4u+JW&1.y$*+EF#&G5GAF0W9*T+,Bz.9{W@s*+W|;+M*+}  ~ )y$;fZV•+Q

EF*N2€.$W9*T+W&1 ~A`$*+GuGAF0W*‚:7h.9ƒN5SA7QHA=A;n64Z*+J[.9@„u+

EF#&W9y90+…Y†*W|=.)*+G5M(X0?F‡;Mˆ@5+1+MF0O?6/$:P+Gun64Z*+ E&M‰T+GA* ~A|$9Y.(9*kQEF#&G5"#$%&p ~A|$*+34"9o/0,-+A‡4Š#45RA);N5M‰‹;n64Z*Jn|=.)*+N5EF#&G5"#$%034W9o#4v  ~ o%0W%o  ~ `  b 7?F‡;N5M‰‹;Q

€.$W9o#%*+W&1 ~A`$*+\W9-./012+_.PABMˆ@5E7A#)*+cd.U$*+C=.)o*QE#V?=5G5M#$:0?q0NŒkS.&"7J"%;5€.$KBW9o#%*+Œk1"q7RA)$o*Ž}&My$*

Page 186: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 186/248

Page 187: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 187/248

23(4-5% 67(-' !"$

J[.9u+v0z+"^$Y+W/&M«W*A`6*+QW*A`6*+N.(:UD"{Ÿ&M=5‘9y‡$*1AlƒS.9y90+…Y2+Jh"/%P+,$*+v0pAqr+.(9o4OW*A+ŒNu+E7pZ‰.²+$=+

.(6o«NE7³%;›M  ~ X)7].%*u+nV…|P+Qx@ŸªWo™+A7n:S.9y90+…Y•+OW*A+W9D.ˆ*+E7pZ‰?%=n@1.‡P+H"+34W&+1H'-.$);W*A+ŒNu+Q+²NEF#&

h"&"= v9B.U#@ N5 JW#&"/*+ 1.FVm* S.)9:|$@ .7k W*A`6o* h"&"= 1.FV5 ?‰"0 G5 <.7.ª.P

EF#&G5zA/&[+H‚;"9=QveGk?9o.7"{CyD <Z%V?#4N?F‡;"9=OKBW¢96*+ JW4A)$P+"{.D’‰5¬ˆF*.;G‚‡;›5RADE7S.9y90+…Y•+EF#&G5 <.9´MBHI&NQx;G5W9o#49Y‚$*+z.$*+?#$  b ´G5‰‚0+1+"/7+¬6@E7JŸ{A*+v0z+"^$Y+

  <RADM‰µ E7S.9)/$*+WY+1"*S.%  ~ {A$*+W6o/$P+S.9y90+…Y†*.7")4 ~¬g$0W¢96*+W94x$=2+QŸD.@NKBW9)/$*+,BW9)/0?9o|$*+J,¢96*+›*+z.{].:|;.7›*+

EF#&G5±"´+„k.7G.@"*?@?9=E7p.9=u+S.9y90+…YkH+HI0O.B1+MF0}Y.)$*.;‘7.(ƒ.yDO?9+¶;.:*+QG.@+B?9o,¢9;˜Duwz ~"/&W&5W9y90+…Yk

Jh"&"=˜)F*N2";E7·*„H"ƒS.%6$*+34"7S.¢7p.9=u+E7o$žS.9y90+…Y•+,$*+v0.(o9ˆª./6:7OW*A`6*+Q"{NC#Y·*„?9o|$;.7+„kŸ[email protected]+…Y•+,$*+Ÿ|yDOW&+"6*+Š/6$YW|=.D"%;G58{.:$&GA64Z*+[.U%l*+Q

EF#&MX)*+ŒkA#DS.9y90+…Y•+W|=.)*+O?@?9=E7p.9=u+34.¥5W%=+1Œk[./;,7"^$:7·o0W9y90+…Y•+JvBMe.F0NN5ŒkW™MU*+’@u+OW9D.F7k.B"9o/0E7?6{E&M‰T+Q

G.@?9o|$*+,/«.)P+ <.`60M7?9o|$*.;,¢96*+.P± b"|9Y+„k.7Ÿ[email protected]+…Y•+±Zˆ*+n$:*+NW@1.‡P+OW*A+W9D.ˆ*+E7W*A`6*+"{SMˆ%60OW9)6*+

JW9#9o{•+‘7z.9{}4Z*+"ƒ+A*+O?@‘{A7E7‘{+AP+?4.U$*.;‘7G+¬+W%;1u+ ·**‘{AP+QGAF&"&".7ABC=.D <+M75 <.9o¸Oz.X)*+,/«.)P+Q?FV‘{A7·o$#&  <+1.=Mˆ@5 <.ƒ.yDŠ  ~ )6$9YW9y90+…Yk1.+Mˆ@u+ <.ƒ.yDE7‘9#+n;˜D+¬=Qx@NO

h.@.|P+JW9¢96*+EF#&G5NI%D+BA#)*+Mˆ@m* <.ƒ.yD.7kŒk[./6*+Me.F$*+NJ?lVu+N5ŒkW™MU*+’@u+OG5zA/&GNM‰T+K"9o/$;Q

Page 188: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 188/248

!"" "#$%&'()%*+(,(-.-/%

?=uNz+"^$Y+?-.YN?9o|$*+›1A`$*+JKB€.$|DŒkW/&M«"&"|$*W9U9@[+H5W&5W9y90+…Yk‘7W&5W9y90+…YkM‰5QOS2.r+JW`9:6*+EF#&z.9/*++²

].:r+?F‡;J›’[email protected]+"*"&"W9U9@[+H5W9y90+…Yk(h"ƒ+A*+h"ƒ+A;)

.7")4˜=+A0 <.642v-+H1"g*+QON r+S2. Mˆ@u+J <+"9/%0EF#&z.9/*+].:r.;E7pZ‰h.@.  b ¸JSZ4.U$*+‘©N}Y.FP+JWoq|$:[email protected]+O—AoYW*A`;

Wol%7ny:*+W9DN…F*2+Q"/*v0'7H1.FV5vqt+,)7I*+W&.()*+N¬h"@°P+ SZ4.U$o*OW*A`6*+E7pZ‰‘&A)0S+…U*+W9)7I*+?F*W6%*Q.75'-.$DW9%96`*+Wo#$|P+³%6*S.9y90+…Y•+"/Vv0?7.%$*+.(%7E7pZ‰‘dN"&"%*+E7

S+1+MF$*+SZ4.U$o*n;UDn$9y90+…Y•+QEF#&S+NHu?9o|$*+›1 ~A`$*+KBG5z a"^  a $:  b 0‘7W&5W9Uo‰W94x$=+Qv0N

.(/96`0O.);.$@+B34RADn%7E7{+AP+JW94x$=2+{+AP+,$*+·:ªWol%P.;W&MBA+GN.%$o*Q¶ˆ6)&‘V+"*+E7.F*+GN.%$o*.7")4EF#$&?@}42E7h"4.:7

M‰T+Q‚‡)0NWol%P+.7")4GAF&v&"/0KBh"4.:P+[¹oF7QM(X0W™MV}:FP+pH.6$P+E7GN.%$*+?‰"9YOW6%o*+.7")4GAF0}Y.FP+W90‚$P+E7GN.%0}4Z*+M‰T+’@5E7o  b @GN.%0[MP+QONKBJW*.r+GAF&GN.%$*+pH.6$P+ <Z   ~ lU7

E7?6{nVM`*+34z"4GN.%$*+pH.6$P+\N5.7Š#:&1"g*.;Q_EF*NpAqr+34.7?   ~ lU09*M7u.;¬:9*+Q·*„Nn66:*>J2N5·9o4G5?%º}4Z*+M‰T+"4.:  b & * 

Š$ƒGkNG.@}4Z*+M‰T+?lV5 <2.ƒ34"P+¬q/*+E7pZ‰z"4h"4.:P+QJ.9D.ev$9Y—¯+MkpAq|o*34W&5h"4.:7‘9`$:0GNHG5z ~"/0W&5h"4.:7WUoF7

·:U);!+"Q

 

\+_ »"  a %  b 0Wol%7ny:*+Mˆ@5 <x9#%0 <Z9o{.œ˜ƒ…/0KBW‡{.)P+QGkE&AF0Wol%7ny:*+2£…U&G5WUo@h"4.:P+,BUDWUoF*+[+AYGN.%0}4Z*+M‰T+z52QJ+*,(Vz"^$:0

£+…V2+O.d•+G‚;Z@n64Z*+GZlU&h"4.:P+W*H.6$P+34W™MU*+W&N.:P+OpZg$Y+M‰T+£M%$*+NpZg$YZ* <.l&5Q

Page 189: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 189/248

23(4-5% 67(-' !"%

.75'-.$)*+W9/6$P+W&MX)*GN.%$*+,(VW%  ~ y‡7Q,(V ~n60G5GN.%$*+EF#&G55"6&Š$ƒ34"&‘#º89:;E7H+MVu+n¢9(P+GN.%$o*JpH.6$P+Š$ƒOw.4E*GN.%$&˜9V

›5¦^M‰µ Qx@ ~n6&?9o|$*+ <.l&5G5n6o`$P+n9Y.Yu+[./6*GN.%$*+JK1.BHi+N.¼N2N5>G5Š)6  b &GN.%$*+34JpH.6$*+®.ˆ*+NABG5GAF&1Alƒ?6/$:P+˜oLN <+¬6@

  <x(7Nx;˜9VW&.UF*+?%y9*+BpH.6$*+ <+M/$:7QEF*N.7G5v$&9Y‚0GN.%$*+,)6P+

34W#:*+W9*H.6$*+ORA#¡J®.FYEF#$9YE7W&.½˜:UDE7¾.9$=+S.9y90+…Y•+ ¬WDN.%$P+QE7‘  ~ y‡P+G5MDG5GN.%$*+EF#&G5J5"6&‘9`$:&NWo™+AP+[./6*+NOW¢96*+

JW4A)$P+EF#&NG5,#´˜:UD1AV˜:9Y‚0QEF*N.7ABMˆ@5h1.ekABW  ~ o{?&A%$*+34H+MVu+N5S.9Uot+W94x$=2+O9Y‚0KB'-.$)*+Q9*34H+MVu+G5+ADAF&

n9DZ/4>C#:0W9o#%*+W&1A`$*+S.9y90+…Y†*W|=.)*+G‚;J¿%$)0Š$ƒA*G.@n64Z*+2GAVM%&+„.PN59@Qx@˜D59*34n64Z*+G5+A*H.6&?-.YM*+N5

S.7+I$*2+>v¥k2GA=.$´ŒkJSxoF*+Guv¨.%V5voF$0W;.9)*.;v()4QW/&M`*.;NJ.(:UDŸ:9*—.)BW=.ƒ£+…V2W/ˆ*+n; an64Z*+>EF#&G5GAF&z+"^$Y+pH.6$*+

  <.9V.@?%1"g*+¬ <.y$)7Qx@G51.ˆ&•+2W=.ƒ˜*ABM‰T+>EF#&S.9y90+…Y†*W|=.)*+G5€M^$:0GN.%$*+Š$ƒE7¦^‡*+®.Du+QJ+¬‰5NŸ:9*—.)BW=.ƒW`o:o*W&I@MP+>EF#&GN.%$o*,)6P+34pH.6$*+G5GAF&À+„W6{+MP+Q

Gk1A(LGN.%$*+KA#DN˜$7+HkN[.95}o`$0³%;S.d+…V2+pAƒH+MVu+ S.9Uot+NW94x$=2+Q›*+ M‰T+ }4Z*+ I99ª 34 +1H.{ GAF& G5 HMU*+ E7 }o`$0 ,(V

v0?7.%$*+˜%7O¶;.:*+Qx@˜D5}o`$&G5GAF&Á&1.$*+¶;.:*+SZ4.U$o*‘7+B

}4Z*+EFœJM@ ~$*+E7?=5G5GAF&}4Z*+ <.69y$:7QOJ‘{+A*+GkKBS.6o`$P+ I99#$o*M  ~ @$*+NŸ:9*U);A$:P+›*+N"60˜9o4QEF#&Š$ƒ.&¬$F6o*G5Iy)0KBS.6o`$P+E7pZ‰?4.U$*+‘7RAD"ƒ+NE7S.)-.F*+W9r+z+"^$Y.;W9y90+…Yk

\W9y90+…YÂ@(h"ƒ+A*+h"ƒ+A;)_}9y$:0—Ao:o*¬‰u+8/V›*+1"6&E7}4Z*+M‰T+Q+„kŸ4.`$Y+.&¬$F6*+G5}%o0J].%*u+·*@‘9`$:9Yf.)*+v7u+NQ

Page 190: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 190/248

!%& "#$%&'()%*+(,(-.-/%

E7?=5G5Ÿ6ˆ&GN.%$*+JK1+M/$Y+2";E7G5,/o&?6/$:P+pZX;hM7.h¬6@NQ,)%&N+BG5W9¼5[./o*+zH./*+n;E&HMU*+x(:UD2";E7G5GAF0h¬6@x;

˜9VW&.UF*+?%y$*E71"g*+W9y90+…Yk¬Jh"9U7.7")4GAF&}4Z*+M‰T+ <Z;.{i+IU$YZ*Q2";E7G5GAF&"*n64Z*+W™MVh¬6@x;˜9VW&.UF*+[./$*Z*JW9D.e

G5N2+Aoo/&E7W9¼5v(-./*zH./*+Œk"ƒ"9%;Q34?96YJp.ˆP+Gk.7?%=GN.%$*+

  <.)FœOÃH.)‰p.$/*+O]Mr+W9P.%*+W9D.ˆ*+ABW/9/ƒG5S+"ƒA*+W&MF:%*+h¬gq*+ J.(:UDE7OM«Wƒ.YJW@M%P+N5£1u+Jz+Mr+GAF$YO—.F$ƒ+‘7.(l%;S+…U*NWo&A«E7JE7I*++*+„k.7Ä@"ƒ5nVM`*+vB.U$*+J,)#l*+.()9ƒGAF9Y

"*§M`*+M‰T+¶r+OHM*+34UDh"ƒA*+,$*+Ÿ{M‰·*„vB.U$*+QJ+¬‰5N}o`$&A#DGN.%$*+K1A`0NG5GAF&1N"/#;S.9y90+…Y•+W|=.)*+

G5A#)0JMBHI0NG5NGAF&—.)B1"q7RA)$o*OS.9y90+…Y•+W7"^$:P+QEF#&K¨S.9*T+G5GAF0.œ}B„˜9*kGN1+HO[./6*+Co™m*pA|$*+NJ,e+1A*+EF*N

EF#& <.l&5G5E#l$0³%;S.9o#%*+¶#4u+WY+1Hh.@.|#@ÅxDu+W9@Ao:*+JW|=.)*+v9#q0N³%;1.FVu+W9y90+…Y•+h"&"+34A|DÆ*.;[.@*+Q

E7N?=5G5EF#$&GN.%$*+E7G5‚‡)&OpN5JM7u+2";E7HA=NÅÇM‰µ QOw.4E71"g*+¬JÅNsP+E#F0WoF‡P+OG5 <+HMV <+"ƒ+NE7E&*+GAdM%&

GN.%$*+2‘9`$:&1.BHi2+.7wv/&GNM‰T+E&*+GA`9´˜;?7.%$*.;˜%7?ˆP.;GA*H.6$&NGN.%$*+˜%7QE7W9ƒ.)*+JM‰u+EF#&GN.%$o*G5M(X&E7S.%#ºh¬g™

E7H+MVu+E&1H./*+34I99#$*+.P.«G.@[2°BH+MVu+GA%$#$&A*NW6:);h¬g™E7SZ4.U$*+‘7v(l%;³%6*+Q+*2";E7HA=N³%;S.%#y$*+E7H+MVu+E&*+

GA7"^$:&S.9y90+…Y•+,$*+v:$0n$9™.^;>GAF0S.9y90+…Y•+pN5E7 JGN.%$  a &zA/0NI99#$*.;n;[2°BE&*++A;.y$Y+GN.%$o*E&*+Nw+A69y$:&Q.D’–ÅNÇ1A(LGN.%$*+x;ABJ›1NÈ.()F*N2J.D’–J.BHMU#;E4

S.9y90+…Y•+,$*+EF#&G5GAF0Mˆ@u+ <.ƒ.yDQW6:)*.6V+¨JM7u+Ÿ7 ~"{.)*W/&M«W*A`6*+ <Z9*H <.%«.{C*.q*¾.y)*+n™M*+¶-.U*+NW9y90+…Y†*Mˆ@u+W«.:;n;

Page 191: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 191/248

23(4-5% 67(-' !%!

JS.9y90+…Y•+25,BN>(h"ƒ+A*+h"ƒ+A;Q)E#VpZ‰GN.%$*+OWo/)*+JŒNu+E7Nvez.9/*+?ˆ#;.7˜o%V}4Z*+M‰T+ <.7.ªOWo/)*+Jh¬‰u+Ÿ)FªW9y90+…Yk(h"ƒ+A*+h"ƒ+A;)E7z.9/*+[+H‚;"9=‘7"4+A{„.–+1+M/*+h"/%P+?F‡;N5M‰‹;QvoV

}:F0KBW9y90+…Y•+W*A+ŒNu+E7W*A`;Wol%7Jny:*+"*.($(=+A7S.@1.‡P+,$*+.(7 ~"{NM  ~ X)7JW6%o*+J}:|V?;.¥kSi.VW*A.;W9D.ˆ*+J.l&5,BN

W*A+,$*+Ÿ)#l0Mˆ@5E7n$YW@1.‡7.(##™f.D5Ÿ|)Yv¨W™MU*+‰u '-.$DW*A+ŒNu+G.6:r.;Qx@ŸD.@,BW9y90+…Y•+hI-.U*+OW:ÉE7?™5W$YS.%&A)0W*Ayo*W9D.ˆ*+\SiMƒ5NW60MP+W9D.ˆ*+ORA)$*+fH.:*+Q_Mˆ@u+Nh1.ekE7

J·*„Gk.(ƒ.yDwEF& <.9)678/V34.Ê1"{34z.9/*+[+H‚;"9=‘7S.9y90+…Y•+M‰u+,$*+Ÿo  ~ yY <.«./DWU9%d.(:U)*Q"{Nv0G.9;·*„O?9o,¢9;S2AW9o6/$:7W9d+…V+E7KBW*A`6*+QONKBh.@.|P+,$*+Ÿ&M=5S.¢PS2A+E7

 W9y90+…Yk ŸD.@ JW*A`6*+(h"ƒ+A; h"ƒ+A*+)J <.ƒ.yD Mˆ@u+ W9y90+…Y•+ ,B M‰5 hM7.œp"&34G5.(%YA;G5zA/0[+H‚;"9=‘7"4+A/*+h"9+W¢9:*+N34"ƒ[+AYQ

I%&¾.yDW9y90+…Yk(h"ƒ+A*+h"ƒ+A;)n$P+Œk.¥A@W9y90+…YkWU9`*Wo;.{Ni+IU$YZ*W¸.:$7NW|d+NNQ,)%&.(U`*.¥5E*GAF0pN5E71"g&34

JÃZ«•+KBNW#:*+.(%)ªE7pA‰"*+O?@.‡7,BOŠ).()4Qx@G5§At+E7.(7./$D+2‘  ~ y‡&§M`*+M‰T+341+M#$Y2+Š$7.7pN.ƒz.9/*+1"g*.;Q.75.(¸.:0"4.:9V34hH.%$Y+GN.%$*+pH.6$P+Qx)9;?%¤.(ƒAdNE7W*A(:*+G.F#;I99ª.(`#D

J,@Ao:*+.7NG5v$&JKI99ª?(:9Y—+1H•+G‚;W/&M`*+3ˆP+?7.%$o*‘7W9y90+…Yk(h"ƒ+A*+h"ƒ+A;),BGN.%$*+.(%7Q34vM*+E7.(ƒ.yDJn$P+9*.)%YA;G5

,#:DW9y90+…Yk(h"ƒ+A*+h"ƒ+A;)W9y90+…Y•+ P+3ˆ ,$*+EF#&.(6%*OWol%7 ny:*+h1MF$P+QI%&N·*„Œk}6YJ"ƒ+NABG5W9y90+…Yk(h"ƒ+A*+h"ƒ+A;)J"4+A/*+NWU9`o*+M‰u+}o`$0G5,/o&?6/$:P+pZX;h¬6@34È.r+?=uG5

GAF0Wo4.VQEF*NŠ$ƒ·*„nr+wEF0—.)BW9y90+…Yk3ˆ7GAF0Wo/$:7 4E S.9y90+…Y•+,$*+.(%6  ~ $&GNM‰T+QO³%;S.¢96*+WVM`$P+zA/$YŠ$ƒW9y90+…Yk

Page 192: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 192/248

Page 193: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 193/248

23(4-5% 67(-' !%(

GA;F&34v(l%;Q‘7·*„1NM#;NJn):*+S5";³%;ÅxDu+W9@Ao:*+W9DN.%$*+1A(X*.;Ÿ$6e5N.B1+M/$Y+QŸD.@KBÅxDu+W9)6734¬&.%7W#:*+W9*H.6$*+Q

x@G5"&"%*+E7S.:Y°P+"{S1 ~A« <.«xD5W$;.eE7GN.%$*+,)6P+34³%;¬&.%P+W².‡P+QM($‡0Ã+AY5Jf.P+34?96YJp.ˆP+W/&M`*.;,$*+zA/&.(/VN[.l45

S.|V.q7N W&AU HA4N pZ‰ E7 S+12N"*+ n&Z7 W#9/; ‘-.l; pH.6$; Ã+AYu+ KB

W&N"&Q?7.%*+N9-M*+.)BABG5n@1.‡P+GAVM%&v¥5GAo7.%$9Y‘7v(l%;³%6*+   <+H"¡?F‡;N1MF$7Q+*GÂV›5W*N.¸pZg$Y2{AP+§AYE*GAF0W&"  b ¡?F;W«.:;Q

E7NWoˆ7u+W%-+M*+34+B5"6P+.7M@ b„[email protected]*ABNvFƒW6%o*hM  b @h"4./*+\pA6:96*+_JŠD.4O³%;G.9ƒu+E7“z.&5W¢9YQ”

"%;1NM7h…VE7JE7I*+Ÿ#o%0G5¶e5³%6;n64Z*+nFY.P+hM  b Fo*Œk"ƒ"9%;Ì9|;Ÿ|#Yv¨Z%Vv9F|$*.;2";,)4Oz.&u+W¢9:*+Qz.&u+NW¢9:*+hH.4.7

ŸD.@c0Ë.9o*+[Z9o*+QQQO?ˆ7·o0z.&u+wEF&,%YA;?%V[¹AYpN.)0 ÍM{E&’Y5G5N?o{5E7¾.9q*+ŒkŠDH51"{EFœQQQ+„kG.@›*+zA/&—.:7•.;¦^¶e5J˜;Ÿ)@pA{5v¨>“+NMXD+˜DkzA&[ÎQE7?lVu+G5+Ao#,)4QGk

ŸD.@JW971+NMX$D++A/;5N34vF0+i.U{WXrW9V.dkQGkNŸD.@JhM@+N"94‚V.(971W4Ä;Q2NJ+A‰Ï0.U`*Q”

G.@+BHx$42+34·Y.P+ <Z4.VGuAD.9YA*A*G.@"{·˜D‚;‘lÐJpZg$YZ*GAF$Y˜&"*"&"%*+E7jMU*+z./$DZ*Q

w¶6:&G5Nz.{›5"ƒ5Ÿo#4˜%7pZg$Y.;+BJ{AP+wNEF&M`ÐOp.;

›5Ñz+1E7h.7M*+.7Ÿ)@?%V5QS+„JhM7.7")4z.{HkG.7¬BÒ+Ï*.;34Jh.7M*+ ŠF$+"ƒ5h.7M*+E7W‰Ó.(/o«5vB"ƒ5QJŸ#:$;+ÔŸF|dNEF*Nw?{5W#o@Q"/VJŸy4ID+Ÿy4ID+Ÿ6lNZ%VQ\s9VN AD.9YA*+-./j J>+00_

Gkpx4u+W&1.y$*+W&H.9$42+W9)67 <.l&534hMFU*+Wo-./*+G‚;W{Z%*+hM#$:P+C#:0GN.%$o*G‚;1A`$&GNHv4HE7W&5W`oYW&I@M7Q34vM*+E7G5v@.|P+

Page 194: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 194/248

!%) "#$%&'()%*+(,(-.-/%

zA/0 <Z%V¬VA$;W`oYW&I@M7³U*S.4+I)*+JW&1.y$*+2kG5KBW`o:*+2v$&.B¯.4"$Y+OhH.%*+Q"{N ~’4"ƒ5[Z@N[+s*+E4K.º+?#%*+›1.y$*+‘-.‡*+˜*A/;>

“+„k.7"y$Y+[¹J.7·%YA;G5?q$0?=M*.;M‰T+’40.¨+?7.%$0N‘7WoF‡P+Q+„kN.7v0H15?7.%$*+‘7vFl%;³%6*+J <+H"¡vF9o4G52+N5M/0S+M/V‘&s$*+®AD./*+W/o%$P+HA/%*.;W&1.y$*+”\Ë[email protected]+-01j JQ0+_QGk+BK.º2+n™1

E:ƒN9Y‚$*+Ì9|;˜D5.7")4Ÿ7.{W@Çh¬6@‘9)q$*H+A79og$*+¦|U$; J.ÊZyYS"=N.¥5"{Ÿ/U‰5O¶o‰HA/4W7Io  b 7E7W9ƒ.)*+W9DAD./*+O,ˆoeS.6o`*+,$*+z ~"/0.².()-.;i\Ë[email protected]+-01_QGkW*+"4S./Uq*+.($V.XDN2.(oUF&"&"($*+[Ayo*.;ŒkJv@.|P+?;.(oUF&‘  ~ {A0z.9/*+S./Uq;W&I¡nVM`o*?F‡;pH.6$7O?6/$:P+Q

2Nv$&[.4"$Y+W`oYW9=1.‰2k.7")4‘`/)&‘  ~ {A0?4.U$*+c6/$:P+ <.7.ªQ}:|;NJË[email protected]ÂVRA)*+Mˆ@u+ <.4A9E7.&.l{HA/%*+W&1.y$*+›*+‰‚&˜/&M«

OS.ƒ.Y[.l/*+Š$ƒ?q&Œkv@.¸§.)¢$Y2+ABRA)*+¶  ~ o%$P+N.4";[.g*•+

Õ«.t+S2.@Ao*W&1.y$*+›*+NzA/0˜;W@s*+WF*.P+QN"6&+BRA)*+E7S.4+I)*+   <.9/`)7.7")4GAF0W*.@A*+"{JŸ($D+wN"%0—.)B ÖjMV±N"r"&IP+E7S./Uq*+W|;MP+n;].|™5S2.@A*+W&1.y$*+W@s*+NWF*.P+Q,($)&JGN.%$*+hH.4N.7GAF0Wy9$)*+—1.%7W9-.l{WUoF7 <+"=Q

ONS.{.9:*+JM‰u+C6q0S.{Z%*+W&IyP+nVM`o*W%-.W*$67N+"=Ì9|;EF#&G5× ~A‡0S.D.9F*+WoqU)P+W@…‡P+OSZ7.%$*+Q34?96YJp.ˆP+S5";W@Ç\"&A*G")*_W4A#y#@h¬g™E7hØxYn7‚$*+n  ~ o/$:  b P+Qx;NG5n7‚$*+

34W)9UY‘7.($4.l;W  ~ #  a (  a 7h¬6@ <+"=34M=.0J"ƒ+NG.@"&"%*+E7hØx:*+ <+¬ˆ@

.7GA7A/&pH.6$*.;‘7v(l%;W¼.:#o*OÃN")™n7‚$*34vBM«.žQG.@N1+MF0 vÊZ7.%0 <+¬6@ <+"=Ì9|;G5[2°Bn)  ~ 7°P++A|6™5'&1"$*.;W#X)7W&H.+·o$ªW9);W9oF9BW™.‰.²Q

GkW9¼5SZ7.%$*+W9o6/$:P+EF#&G5M  ~ VA0+"M7 ~p"&34v9#q0S.:Y°P+QE7N?=5h"4.:P+34'&NM0GN.%$*+n;[.l45W#X)7JW)9%7}¤G5Š)60S.{Z%*+

Page 195: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 195/248

23(4-5% 67(-' !%*

?F‡;C9$&.¨G5M  ~ VA0³%;SZ7.%$*+h1MF$P+W)9$P+N.7n;³%;H+MVu+n)  ~ 9%  b P+Q+¬ˆ@N.7GAF0S.:Y°P+W&1.y$*+S.9«+M{N¬6*+NW9)6734+BJA|)*+x@.)UoY5O

?qU*+E7.ˆ*+QE#F0WoF‡P+O³%;G.9ƒu+OW{.4kGN.%$*+2";E7˜¤NM0KsDNQE7N

Woˆ7u+34J·*„‘)7S.Y1.œpx4u+W&1.y$*+W&M7‹$*+E7pZ‰})º?@§NMX*+

,$*+E7.¥‚G5,  ~ #)0GN.%$*+€NM0N˜*Q[A:*NJÙr+GÂVW*A(:*+,$*+EF#&.² GN.%$o*G51 ~A`$&Š$ƒn;n9D.Du+ ~p"034G5‘)7M7‹$*+9*W#(P.;Wo(:*+Q2·G5GN.%$*+2}  ~ o`$&S.9{.U0+W9#Y1N5Š$ƒS.dN.U7JhÇ.67.(=N˜=A*QGk

W/9/ƒG5GN.%$*+,)6P+34W#:*+W9*H.6$*+EF#&G5M(X&G5NŸ6ˆ&K1+M/$Y+¾…/0G534S.9*.%V‘)7S+1.F$ƒ2+\2'#%#3"4# $5#%6%#%74_G5ËA0"&IP+E7K.6$D2+Œk‘)7

§NMX*+,$*+,  ~ #)0M7‹$*+Mˆ@5E7H ~M¡Ì|6*+E4S+[./o*+W& ~Ä*+n;[+1"P+n&9U)$*+S.@so*W:V.)$P+Q

MXD5Zˆ7ŒkWY1.œW7AFr+O1.9$‰+n$@ÇHA/%o*W&M&A`$*+W9:V.)$*+E7 ?=5[.);hM-.«W&MF:4h"&"=Qx;G5S.@Çp.yP+›A+,-.lU*+N¦$–Œk"ƒ.7OS+M-.`*+W™.t+.7khA/*.;W&A+N5JW&M|6*+·*.)B Ö?97"*S.@s*+S+„

¦q^$*+"ƒ+A*+OG5˜=+A0.(l%; <.l%;OW:V.)P+W9-.()*+\S1µ +-0._QGk1+MF0SZ7.%$*+n;n$@Çn$)9%7?%¤M7‹$*+,)#l*+?(Y5 <.96:DO˜/9/QE7N?=5

?%=M7‹$*+,)#l*+Mˆ@5JW;A%™34W7AFr+G5Ì|60E4³%;?6:*+Wo9UF*+?9o/$;¦q^$*+N5³&A%$*+E4K1.eµ Q+*GÂV€NiS.@s*+,$*+—…‡0O.(qq–

‘{A$$YG5±"´.()9;?7.%01+MF$;?{5OW:V.)P+W9-.()*+Q+BN.7?%y9YSZ7.%$*+

W9*.$*+x9V.()9;?{5W#9{J <.96:D.œ?o/&E7pZL?6/$:P+K1.eµNQ.75+„kG.@?7.%$*+ ‘{A$P+zH./*+ <+"9%;J <+"=GÂVGN.%$*+pH.6$P+O?F°«+A$*+,)#l*+§AYE*¶6&+";5WY.9YW$;.ehM/$:7Q

[email protected]+34GN.%$*+E7GNHS.9{.U0+JW9#Y1.¨.(6D+A=W{sP+OS.{.9YM‰5·*@Q,(VJ,)%034?96YJp.ˆP+G5GN.%$*+Op.¡hM`9:*+34

Page 196: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 196/248

Page 197: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 197/248

23(4-5% 67(-' !%$

E7pZ‰"9o/0n64Z*+Jn|=.)*+N5Š$ƒE7pZ‰W9o#4[./$D2+,-+A‡%*+S.9y90+…Y†*Mˆ@u+J <.ƒ.yD‘7¦o^$*+E7S.9y90+…Y•+?{u+ <.ƒ.yD.(-.q{kNQ

GkW*‚:7HA=NW/ˆ*+n;n64Z*+E7.(7"4,BW*‚:7?{5W9¼534"P+"9%6*+.œ+„kŸD.@§NMX*+W#-Z7[.)6*8#DM/$:7E7GN.%$*+x9VJv()9;z52Q

x@NG5?6/$:P+v(79Y‚$*§NMX*+W#-ZP+JGN.%$o*GÂVÝ.P+ <.l&5}%o&+1NH <+¬6@OW6{+M7—Ao:*+c%U*+QE#VW9¼u+G.F#;G5EF#$&GA64Z*+E7W6{+M7

S+1.9‰v(l%;³%6*+,$*+JŸ/6YW;.y$Y2+N./VN.¨QGN"6VKBh1"/*+34z+"^$Y+JÝ.P+2EF#&W6{.%7S2.ƒJ1"g*+.75IV.ƒGN.%$*+,U$^9:V <.7.ªQ

E:rNJÙr+GÂVh1"/*+34W6{+M7—Ao:*+¶;.:*+}4Z*M‰T+2,g6)&˜*G5GAF& <.9*.ˆ7QGkW*A`;Wol%7ny:*+W9DN…F*2+£…U0WVM%7W7.0W9*.ˆ7NS+1.9t

}4Z*+W/;.:*+QEF*NO"&"%*+E7J{+AP+EF#&G5[Þ&}4Z*+v(V1.9t+›*+z.{˜;}4Z*+M‰T+Q"/VM#&1"g*+xDNHJ}9{1N5"{[.:&v(VGN.%$*+34˜D51"Q

‡Fo*NE4S.94+"0[AYJv(U*+v0[+M=kW*A+ŒNu+E7W*A`6*+hM7M‰5‘7?&"%09U«Ì9|;‘$ª[email protected]$‰+W™MU;\+_W-.P.;OG5[.:&˜#(VE7§M«

}4Z*+M‰T+Qx@NG.@J <.%{A$7Ÿ#yDE4S2.ƒ[AYv(U*+KBW4A#¡h¬6@E7S2.ƒ1"g*+x9Vn;n64Z*+QŸD.@Nh‚=.UP+,B[./;W9y90+…Yk(h"ƒ+A*+h"ƒ+A;)

?lV5h"4.{„.–21+M/*+Q34vM*+E7.¥5Ÿ%{NO"&"%*+E7SZF‡P+.7")4H.{[AYv(V"ƒ+NŒk8‰?&A«E7S2.ƒz./$D2+pH.6$P+J]N.)$P++¬ˆ@.7G.@.(%YA;

G5,()  b 0+B8t+W*.|;[AYv(VM‰5QŸD.@"&"%*+E7"4+A/*+M‰u+?{5J <.¸.:0

+*xVG5‘/0OJWoF‡7 <+1H.D.7ŸD.@EF#$0E7€NMt+.()7QŸ7.{W9y90+…Yk (h"ƒ+A*+h"ƒ+A;)?#%;"9=O˜=N[AYv(VÝ.P+.¥uŸD.@h"%$:7JC7.:$o*+²NŸD.@.Ü"*W™MVhH.4k9Y‚0GN.%$*+pH.6$P+Q

‘$#$&1NH1AX)P+,)7I*+³%6;n7.lP+W7.¨+x9V¶o%$&v9#q$;S.:Y°P+Q,UVSxX)P+Jh¬6F*+S.:Y°#@px4u+W&1.y$*+S.9«+M{N¬6*+NJW97AFr+G.@

Page 198: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 198/248

!%" "#$%&'()%*+(,(-.-/%

[+1"P+GA&9U)$*+hH.4.7GA*A|$&E7}q)7Œk}q)7M‰µ [email protected]&M/0!+"Q.œŠ`45[+1"P+n&9U)$*+IV.r+34z.9/*+?lV‚;.7GA%9`$:&34"P+J}&M/*+ ~³g;MX)*+E4S.%60·*„M7u+34SxX)P+34"P+"9%6*+Q+AD.FVGAVM%&v¥5G.4Ø

 9*N JM‰µ }q)7 Œk GAo/)  b 9Y .7¶;.:*+ }q)P+ O v¨x45 S.%60 }:)  b 0 G5 ?#$|P+ E7v(9*k"%;G5+A@M0v(6™.)7Q+BM7u+,`%&›un)e5E7[+1"P+n&9U)$*+ <+IV.ƒ

  <2H.6$7A|D1"g*+.7")4GAF0h…V[./;›5"ƒ+Nx()7O}q)P+·A034[.($D2+Q ·**GÂVWy9$Dv9o:$*+‘&Ä*+}q)#o*EF#&G5GAF& <Z9o/0GN.%$o*?‰+HW#X)[email protected]Ç5O?qU*+JÌ*.ˆ*+GÂVWoF‡7W².‡7K¨±".7")4Cl$&W6:)*.;

"-./o*Î.9:*+G5˜™MVOhH.4k].^$D2+Wo9o{N5˜6W7N"%7QC6q0NWoF‡P+Mˆ@5h"ƒ‘7\W`6*+[.=M%*+_›5pN°:P+W9($)P+˜$&2N˜)F*N2p+I&zA/&&Ï$;px4u+

W&1+H•+QE#VW(=NMXDJ1A(#+EF#&G5GAF&Î.9:*+›*+˜=+A&W&.¥˜  ~ oyY,)(P++M`‰Wy9$D˜dM%$*[+M†*"&+I$P+,%:o*[+1N˜V+"B5JW™.t+2";E7Û.Ur+

348#DE7GN.%$*+‘7n6‰.)*+pAq|o*34§+"B5W&I¡nVM`o*Qx;NG5pN+"$*+,#o:*+W`o:o*AB Ö[I=›1NÈE7vFr+J,«+M/#&"*+ZV";

E7?ƒWoF‡P+W/&M`;M‰5Q.)BNGAF0]+Iƒu+W9Y.9:*+h"9U7„kEF#&.(o9#JW9*N°:P+z.75J¬Bx+E4p.%Vu+,$*+zA/&.².B¯.l45n6^$)P+QGkn6‰.)*+

]+Iƒu+NW9Y.9:*+G.VM«OW{Z4Wo&A«J"7u++BN,`%&]+Iƒm*W9Y.9:*+‘V+"*+1.9$‰2n|MP+E&*+2GA¢9:&z+"^$Y+vÊ.9*N°:7Q+„ÂV.7"=NGA6‰.)*+

G5 <+"-.{.)9%7"{].y$Y+JS+[+M†*v(%YA6VG5+N‰‚&·*„G.6:r.;")4v(#99/0n|M#o*E&M‰T+E7UD]Ir+OS.;.^$D2+W7H./*+QW6{.%#Vn6‰.)*+]I|o*

›1A(#+"%;W9l{\Ÿ9M0NN_"{Ÿ$6e5 <Z%VG5]+Iƒu+"%  b 0W*N°:7E4]A94 .ÊH.{Q

 

\+_ 9*E7W;+Mg*+5G[+1"P+n&9U)$*+n|=.)*+OE`)+N"{+A#o%0Hx$42+34pH.6$*+O“W7AFƒ[.;Mg*+”KB\AFo9B+-88JS.|Uq*+>+9:Ž/1:_Q

Page 199: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 199/248

23(4-5% 67(-' !%%

EF*NpAor+W&1A$Y"*+pN+"$*W`o:*+€.$ <.7A#4Œkp.‰HkW9*N°:P+W9DAD./*+Œk.7[+1Nh…U*+,$*+.(7"ÐHMU*+O"ƒ5}™.)P+Q,UV{+AP+W9#9X)$*+N5

JW&1.y$*+GAF0?lV5W/&M«Gxl*KBW9*N°:P+W9DAD./*+,B‘6$0¾.yD¦^‡*+O·*„J}q)P+9*·*„8/V?;W*.r+N,$*+—M  b 0.(9V}q)P+Œk¦^‡*+Ë.$*+›*+

§AY˜og‡&Q3%V?96YJp.ˆP++„k.7Š%Y"ƒ5[+1"P+n&9U)$*+[+1N¶9/}:F7

‘&ØE7pZ‰WD.9‰"ƒ5˜-Z7i?6{G5?  a /)  b &Œk‘)q7JM‰µ ZV";E7‰5KB W%{+A*+n%;1.6$42+")4v99/0[+H5·*„¦^‡*+Q

·o$ªW&MXDGN.%$*+³%;n7.lP+S.94+"$*+NW/o%$P+1.9$‰2.;›HMU*+ <ZlVE4·o0W/o%$P+v9#q$;S.:Y°P+Q34N"9%q*+Jß^‡*+ŸD.@"ƒkS‹=.UP+

’F*+W6:)*.;Ë[.)e5c#4O+BRNsP+,BW#9{W9o;./*+W&i+IU$Y2+Q"/VŸ¢=Œk+BRNsP++"/$%7G5[MP+2";G52GAF&‘&Ø}lg*+Q"{NŸ)  ~ 9;'-.$DW*A`;

Wol%7ny:*+W9DN…F*2+˜D5E7?lVu+ <Z%VG5}9y$:0?F‡;‘&Øi+IU$YZ*Q"{N

 ~n60˜D5+„k.7MX$D+[MP+Ì&M0NO˜$;.y$Y+1"go*¬J‘{A$P+—.)(VW#eM`‰

p.Y1kh1.kW¢«.‰QxoFVŸ*.«h…V¾x:*+S2.r1"g*+G5 ~MªGNHJ}9:ƒxo@H+i·*„E7S2x$ƒ+G5'$)$:&}4Z*+M‰T+G‚;1"g*+EF#&G5GAF& <.&"¡Qxo@N

Y‚0+B8#)*+hA/;JMˆ@5xo@SH+Hi+W;A%™KÄ@Qp"&N+B34G5E7?lVu+G5GAF0?(Yi+IU$Y2+JGT+E7G5IU$:  b 0x9V"%;QC   ~ dA&¾.yDW9y90+…Yk(h"ƒ+A*+

h"ƒ+A;)KBW`/)*+Z;N·QE#VpZ‰W;.y$Y2+JW&1AU*+,`%0KBW9y90+…Y•+RØ5Wy9$DW)FœG‚;1"g*+E*›"¤ <.%UDQ

n60NW;.y$Y2+S.@.($DZ*W)F#P+S+"B.%P"r+E7W|oYu+KBW`/)*+Q"/Vz.{H.•+,$9VA:*+n;nr+M‰T+N„.–.;³%;S+A`t+,$*+N"60O.BMB.L

W##q7’:*1+A5HN"ƒ˜0.9{.U0+‘7S.&2A*+h"|$P+Qxo@NŸ4Ø5S.&2A*+h"|$P+Oß/0KBS.  ~ :yP+.(%6$0NW;.y$Y2+NJ.¨xo@G.@·*„?lV5Q1.X$D.V

S2N.¸=³6)*+KBŠ$ƒv@+…0§i.y9YW6g#;W=.r+ŒkW;.y$Y+h¬6@+"="{›H°0Œk"&IP+E7SZF‡P+Q

Page 200: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 200/248

'&& "#$%&'()%*+(,(-.-/%

+B"#$%0NW4ØW;.y$Y2+34Ÿ{A*+ziZ*+W6:)*.;}4Z*M‰T+,F*   ~à/$& <+1.9‰ <.)  ~ 9%7Qx  ~ o@NG.@+BŸ{A*+J <+¬q{xo@EF75GN.%$o*G5GAF&Mˆ@5 <.0.6eQ

x@G5ß/$*+‘&Ä*+,)%&G5Wo/)*+W9*.$*+O?7.%$*+À‚$Y34A|DJ‘&Ø·*;NH+HI&1AlƒpZL?6/$:P+x@n6$&E7pZ‰Ç°7f.9/7vqt+;Q+¨N}6:*+

GÂVS.9{.U02+h"9ƒA*+"|o*E71.‡$D+W|oYu+,$*+EF#&G5‘$#$01+M/$Y2.;,B

·o0S.9{.U02+,$*+EF#&n%;.$#o*ß/0.Ê.@.($D+W4Ä;W9V.@Q}o`$P+NMˆ@u+ W9¼5.)BABW9D.F7kß/0·o0S.@.($D2+?6{G5v@+…0Œk"ƒ¬6@Ì9|;C6q  b 0h1"{W9|l*+34„.–+W&5hA`‰?;./P.;¬[email protected].$;‘)P›"|$P+E7pAqr+34IV.ƒA|D1"g*+Q

"/*v0pxF$Y+'-.$DW*A`6*+W/o%$P+W#9/;W9o;./*+W&i+IU$Y2+E7pZ‰?9o|$*+›MX)*+.P˜=.$h"4./*+WU9`o*+,F*GAF0hM/$:7 <.94.©QE7N?=5G5

GAF0h"4./*+WU9`o*+h1H.{34W7N./7J¾.9$=2+2";G5GAF0KBh"4./*+Wo;.{i+IU$YZ*)7pN5W9o#41"zA/&.²}4Z*+M‰T+\W9dMU*+W%;+M*+E7?qU*+

Ì*.ˆ*+Q_2€.$JW;.y$Y2+E7W9ƒ.)*+JW&MX)*+ŒkG5À‚034J1AU*+EF*N2";G5‘$#$0W9D.F7Â;W9/9/ƒ[,y#o*OM‰µ §.`P+Q[š*+Nz.¨+.)BABG5}4Z*+M‰T+

E*,($)&˜;M7u+ABN·o$#& <+IV.ƒA|D1"g*+Q2·G5h1.ˆ$YZ*.BM«.žQE#F&NM`t+O b D5A*pN.ƒ}4   ~Z*+M‰T+

J1"g*+GÂVHM*+,7./$D2+HA/9YŒkH1,7./$D+JM‰µ pA|$9YNR+Ï*+Œk8‰2W&.¥˜*E71"g*+pH.6$P+QE7"@°P+G5›H°&+BM7u+ŒkWoF‡7W&"=Q3%V?96YJp.ˆP+

EF#&S.4+Ïo*W&A7"*+n;J?-.6/*+O"&"%*+E7JS+1.lr+G5M#$:0Z;hH+AB

S+A):*JWo&A«2?;p.9=u\—Z;ŽHN.‡$97+-89_Q‘=M&+B1+M#$Y2+OR+Ï*+Œk¬e‚0"q*+>Ì9ƒG5?@§M«E7nVM`*+

}9y$:&M‰TW*.ƒ1"S1"™E4}4Z*+M‰T+1"g;?;./7E7˜D"*ABQE7NpAor+W)F#P+,BH.¤kW`oYW&I@M7}{+M0nVM`*+£MU0Nx(9o4vFƒGAD./*+QEF*N[A:*Ùr+GÂV+B?r+9*MVA$7OhH.%*+QŠ$ƒNOW*.ƒHA=NvFƒ

Page 201: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 201/248

Page 202: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 202/248

'&' "#$%&'()%*+(,(-.-/%

xDk[.=W;.y$Y+v(7.9/*s);S+A/*+J <[+"$;+2NEF#&G5’$%  b &·*„ <+"&"Êv¨Q‘6`*.;NGÂVŸ9VA:*+2GN6´MX)*+W*‚:#o*34+BJA|)*+Š$ƒGkNŸD.@W;.y$Y+

A0.)*+?{5E7G5}Y.)$0‘7sDS+A/*+W9$9VA:*+Q <.l&5N+„kŸD.@W;.y$Y+Ÿ9VA:*+?{5 <.4AD.7E7sDS+A{oƒJA0.)*+GÂV"9%q0S+H+"%$Y2+EF#&G5C6q&

J <+M/$:7x;1NGAF& <.9:F4Ì9|;}%q&˜4.=1kŒk‘dA*+,%96`*+Q

E:rNJÙr+GÂVW{+"q*+Ÿ:9* <.6o`$7 <.&1NÈA#)*GN.%$*+Qx@NC   ~ dA&p.ˆ7 ÃH.)t+W9*.$/*+›*+ ~M7JKM@„Š$ƒzAqt+GA)F#$&E7WVM%7W9U9@v(7.9{M&A`$;W*.ƒE7GN.%$*+,)6P+34W#:*+W9*H.6$*+QGk}o`$7W{Z%*+9*JW{+"q*+?;WD.$P+Q

 "9#r+ [š*+N.¥5 E7 "@‚$0 G5 EF#& ’F*+ A/*+ G5 ,B W9*N"*+ S.{Z%*.; ¶o%$& x9V?7.%$$Y‘7.(l%;³%6*+W)Y"%;M‰5QJ+*GÂV?7.%0z.%*+zH./*+2";G5,/o&

˜*ZX;34S+1.9‰+BJz.%*+Ë.$*.;NGAF9Y"*GN.%$*+W™MVh"9=1A`$o*A#)*+NQx@G5Ï6$*+?6/$:P.;9* <.&1NÈJ <.l&5x@C   ~ dA0Woˆ7u+W9-.9ƒu+QEF*N

W9o#%*+W9-./012+‰‚$Y <.${N <Z&A« <+"=].9g;+B ~Ï6$*+QE:rNJÙr+GÂVs6*+ GAFo$#&h¬q6*+GA%9`$:&N.(7+"^$Y+‘&Ä$*W9o#41 ~A`$*+,$*+GAF$YO§Z‰·*„W9o#4W9-+A‡4[.9#4QG.@Np.ˆP+Mˆ@u+.ƒAdNO+BjAqt+ABÃMU*+n;

n$*A+ŒNu+W9D.ˆ*+NE7W*A`;Wol%7ny:*+W9DN…F*2+Q,UVW*A+ŒNu+G.@n:V.)$P+h1.64E4W4A#¡E7›M  ~ X)7].%*u+nV…|P+E&*++A  ~ oˆ7W*.r+W9)U*+O

v([email protected]/*+[+H‚;"9=OWol%7ny:*+Q.7")4Nv0v9:/0vB"4+A{J <.=+Ni5ŸD.@Wy9$)*+,B8YA$7W=1H/Q+<E7Å./)*+?F*JWo/D.7N,B2k?lV5 <Z9o{E7

q$)7E7=>+\,BNW;A/%*+341"g*+pH.6$P+_Œk?>1\,BNh‚V.FP+34GN.%$*+

pH.6$P+Q_.75n64Z*+OW*A+W9D.ˆ*+"/V+A7.{[+H‚;?lV5J¬ˆF;noy:7/Q0<J,BN W=1H?lV5 <Z9o{E7WeZeR.;15¶&M`*+n;W;A/%*+W*H.6$P+Œkh‚V.FP+W*H.6$P+!+"Q 

\+_ E#l$0Å./)*+W`YA$P+S.@1.‡#o*‘9©S.9y90+…Y•+[.)ˆ$Y.;h"4.{!,-+A‡%*+?2@AB!)‰‚0Nn%;1.6$42+G5W*A+ŒNu+"{SA$ƒ+/<<Wo/DÅA‡o*J"ƒ+A*+x)9;

SA$ƒ+W*A+W9D.ˆ*+34p+A«5W)&.6$7G.@.(`YA$7AB+9+Wo/DÅA‡o*"ƒ+A*+Q

Page 203: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 203/248

23(4-5% 67(-' '&(

+²N"/VG.@1N"/#;n64Z*+G5+A7"^$:&'-.$DW*A+JŒNu+x;O·*„W#9{pH.6$*+JW9*H.6$*+?=u°6)$*+W9*T.;,$*+EF#&G5›H°0Œkz.9/*+[+H‚;"9=OW*A+W9D.ˆ*+QŸD.@NKBh¬q6*+W&"  b ¡‘7pAqr+34Å./D345 <.96:DQ

ŸD.@NWy9$)*+,BG5W*A+W9D.ˆ*+ŸD.@Mˆ@5+"9/%0E7ŒNu+QG.@NGN.%$*+,)6P+34pH.6$*+Y°734A|Dn$7QŸD.@N‘9©S2N.|P+W)&.6$P+pZg$Y2

SZ‰"P+¬h"/%P+OW*A+ŒNu+"{S[.;?‡U*.;OW*A+JW9D.ˆ*+.œ ~n6&G5W#:*+W9*H.6$*+,$*+‘$#$0.²W9y90+…YkW9y90+…YÂ@(h"ƒ+A*+h"ƒ+A;),BW#YW)9$7?F‡;¬›H.9$4+Qx;1N2GAF&E7].;Å+MV•+Op¯.U$*+G5?7‚DG5EF#$&f.)*+

E7z+"^$Y+W;My$*+Wo&"6*+Woˆ#$P+OW*A`6*+W9DN…F*2+v  ~ o%$*W#9{pH.6$*+OvÊZ4.U0O1.«kW6%*Wol%7ny:*+Q

.7G5§ aM%  b 0W/9/ƒG5pH.6$*+À‚&Jh"-.U*.;Š$ƒ»z á"/  b &‘9#+34z.9/*+˜;˜4.60kNQ+„kNŸ)@MX$)0E7E&M‰T+G5+Ao7.%$&·%7J?ˆP.;GNHM&N34—1"

·DN.%0NJ?ˆP.;3|$$YW#Fr.;W9V.F*+})y$0N["6*+W&‚;SZF‡7Q <hNZ434J·*„GAF$Y <x9Fƒ <.l&51"g$VŸD5M‰T+.7")4zA/&vB"ƒ5J1"g*.; <+M á (X  b 7·*;

·D5¬?;.{pZg$YZ*Q+²NGAF$Y <x9Fƒ—1.9$‰.;R.  ~ 60kW9y90+…YkW#-.{34pH.6$*+Q+BN.7z"/9Y˜9o4‘9#+Q34N+BJA|)*+C6q9Yn#ˆ0W#9{W#:*+

W9*H.6$*+.(7+…ƒ+N+M75À+„I&I%$*+QHMy#;NG55"6&+BJM7u+H+HI9YhA{ <.¢9 <.¢9‡VQ

+BNO‘{+A*+ABMBA=¬e‚0W«.  ~ /:*+\N5WFY.P+_›*+v0˜:9Y‚0O?qU*+Ì*.ˆ*+>.7G5Y‚$&GN.%$*+v-./*+34W#:*+W9*H.6$*+8YNRA#¡®.FYJn%72

EF#&›u‘#ºE7H+MVu+E&*+GA%:&ŒkpZg$Y+E&M‰T+}  ~ og$*+˜9o4QEF#& 9Y‚$*GN.%$*+M/$:P+G5ÃMg$:& <.${NJ <Z&A«+„kG.@ <x-.{34A{Ñ1 ~A`0W9-+A‡4J[.9#4N5EF#&G5v$&?F‡;RØ5+„k.7z.{GA64Z*+[.9@„u+n#ˆ$;W9o#4˜*.g$+QEF#&'-.$)o*W&MX)*+W96&My$*+N+¨].$F*+G5"4.:0f.)*+34W&¯1jMVGN.%$*+

pH.6$P+W)7.F*+OJv(P.434A|DMˆ@5 <.ƒAdNQGkWVM%7v9B.UP+,$*+ ~ÄU0'-.$D

Page 204: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 204/248

'&) "#$%&'()%*+(,(-.-/%

,$*A=W*A`;Wol%7ny:*+JW9DN…F*2+WVM%7N].6Y5ÅNÇN¾.yDJpH.6$*+"{G+MVA&³%; ~Ï6$*+O.d•+Q

x;1MD¾AdA;¬6@G5—.)B Öf1H¦o^$:  b 7E7W/9/ƒG5W9y90+…Yk(h"ƒ+A*+h"ƒ+A;)"{Ÿ|yDGNH.(7.9{[+H‚;?lV5E7›5HMVM‰µ "{Ÿo7.%0˜%7Q

"/*Ÿ|yDE7pZ‰R+I$D+GN.%$*+E7JE&M‰T+9*NE7pZ‰Ã.rkW#&I¨+v²

}og$*+Nv(9o4Q"/*.D"$4+34¬FU$*+S.:V.)P.;,$*+9*.(9VAYC;+1J"ƒ+N S.:V.)7W6%o@hM@z"/*+N5'DM`‡*+QEF*N+1H.D.7GAF&w.%*++FBQ,UVÃ.`)*+‘Y+A*+E7J{+AP+EF#&GN.%$o*pH.6$P+G5GAF&W6:)*.;ZF*nVM`*+?lV5E7

1"g*+pH.6$P+QÌ9ƒ2E#F&¾.$U7z.9/*+[+H‚;"9=O}og$*+34JE&M‰T+?;OpAqr+34v¥N.%0Q

.75O.)7A&J+BGÂVSZF‡P+vBu+,$*+˜=+A0W&s6*+,B·o0,$*+34Wƒ.YS.{Z%*+JW9*N"*+Ì9ƒzA/0³%;v7u+W9D.Du+hHMU)P+W(=+A#;.(l%;

³%6*+OW*.ƒ]M{5âAUo*Q^$0N"&"%*+E7·o0SZF‡P+?FWol%7ny:*+ h1MF$P+QEF#&NG5?#‡0Woˆ7u+³%;S.{.6YC  ~ o:$*+1.‡$D2+N›NA)*+£N.U$*+NG‚‡;S.7iu+"9%q$*+N›MF:%*+Q2N·˜D5";2v(Uo*,%{+A*+·o$*SZF‡  b P+

G5‰‚&n%;1.6$42+"&"%*+E7?7+A%*+¬hMV+A$P+OWol%7Jny:*+.9=A*A&"&•[email protected]:*+NJW9«+M{N¬6*+S.7+I$*2+S.U*.|$*+NS.«.YA*+N

hH.9/*+NQv1J—+„.)%YA;G5z"^$:[email protected].)90N5E7h¬q;§+s$Y+NQ1.5SM;N1n6o9\+-.+j J/<9_Œk˜D5)7[.7"{¶&M•+Š$ƒNhH.9/*+

JhÓ.%P+ŸD.@W&MX)*+W9Y.9:*+.($  ~ 7M;1A|#$034p+°:*+›MBA+Ë.$*+>“9@

‘9`$:&)+›s6*+G5v(U&A{Á&1‚$*+,$*+N"60J[.9#4G5NM`9:&J.(9o4[+AY G.@·*„S.&.g*W9q^W9D.D5N5S.&.g*Wo96DãW7.4N”"/*C6™5+Bp+°:*+O.)P.4Ó.%P+ <.  ~ |o7 <+"=·*„N}6:;1 ~A`0W|oYu+W&NA)*+Q

EF#&G5GAF0W|9q)*+,$*+ ~M7.BM@„O?qU*+J‘Y.$*+W(  ~ =AP+NŒkn64Z*+OWol%7Jny:*+S+„‘UD.)BhH./*v7u+.l&5>2+ADAF0E&HA:ƒ2N+ADAF0pN5

Page 205: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 205/248

23(4-5% 67(-' '&*

E71"g&+Ao7.%0N?ˆP.;‘7GN.%$*+‘7N1"g*+34"ƒ[+AY2N+A@+$0Q34NA|DJ˜;.‡7GÂVS.9)/$*+,$*+Ÿ‡{ADO?qU*+‘;.:*+?=u'&NM0GN.%$*+OWol%7

ny:*+EF#& <.l&5G5GAF0S+„h"-.VO'&NM0GN.%$*+OÅ.YN5WY.9:*+W9*N"*+QGkMBA=WoF‡7W9U9@pAqr+34h‚V.F7E7GN.%$*+,BG5W9o#4v  ~ o%$*+E4

¶&M«W;My$*+‚`t+N,BW9o#4W¢9`;WP°7NQx;1GAF0§NMX*+W#-Z7S+1A`$o*

Wo&A`*+J"7u+.))F*N"{2·o#DŸ{A*+O.F*+1.X$D2S.9o#%*+W9-+A‡%*+[.9#%*+ Š$ƒ.)o/)0[86;]A™S.9y90+…Y•+W&IyP+nVM`o*W#-./*+N34pH.6$*+Qx;1+„k.7.)#(VW9o#%*+?F‡;J?lV51.™.)%YA;z+"^$Y+.)0¬q;‘&Ä$*W9o#41A`0GN.%$*+Q

Page 206: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 206/248

'&# "#$%&'()%*+(,(-.-/%

 

Page 207: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 207/248

!"#$ 

&'()*'+ ,-./0 

"  # $%&'() *+,-.' /"012'3452'6789:;<=>?&@.'67A47=-B.'6CDE2=FG2=HIG-JB7KLM2'GNOPQ%2R'ST #?U  * &'()+,-.'A47=-B76CV4W2'6&(2''=-:X

G2=HY2'6CPA9:?  * .'Z[\A4]^4_.'`4aM1O6CPb?76Mcd'X\"]G]^4_767A4]^4_.'?WC4aEUI4H7e74aJBIfBY2'Sg]h,1E&4J&\47[(2'i4]6%$&i\

j?k6$lGEmA';nE7opG2=HY2'6&q<=7r2(I?&@.'67K)'s2'tCGO4E7u4LOGNLN>'Qmv!w?c'=2'w?c'=I"S

xW  # $J>G2=y'zP{'67G2=HY2'eI^\w|CG]^4_7G<4l}4IzvGNLN>'Qmv!D~'=_B2'#$%&'()S #KY&P8P?y'•€^Z*`dgm\pKUI4ME.'4UW2'PDE2'4‚ƒqc\

•)?C'=€o„4…'^'qU2'Sg]x†GUI4H7"]‡Pƒ67?C'=U2'oˆ‰Š4B2\Z'=‹\` GO=%767DE~47G-UO"%2w?c'P4aW7Sg]i\4UOG2=HY2'"%2w?C4€67?C'=U2'ŒJE>o8P?y'•€^Z+S`g]i\PŽP"]GNLN>'Qmv67A4NLN>'Qm}'q<=E7o

XPq-NM] Z,-./\`p=)P 4J&\q&qUE2'[(2'•>‘;<=>eN$yK]^4_.'oG2=y'GNO452'67G2=HY2'S

Page 208: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 208/248

!"#  " #$%&

 '() *+,-./!0 1+)2345./167)285.09+:. ;<6-. =

 >?%?4<.

/;[email protected]'BC.DE%F<. GHI4<.

/127 1J2KF&2L0M&2NO<. *6PD4<. Q2RS<.

2TUAV",A^=I=I'^ 8=>4O'ˆ1W2' •-C01/0S1

*

i47?&4> VR=%NO2

[ƒP;_> RP4IX40E€R'0,

1//S0+;’?&4O [XP^ˆ1W2' •-C*+0.1S1

0ig<Pq’ X^4O;IGNm4NM2' T=-B2'.0.,S-

1rNI=‹ 6>^47X40E€R',30./S4

3KEm T4N2P2A^=I=I'^ i=W7 ˆ1O •-CA4Nl4&q2'

1/044S.

4=N-IX $NFSi47?&q<X40E€R',+04+S0

.ˆ1&'X i=>^=7A4Nl4&q2'304,S.

-“74%m'q’ ˆ$NF3+0//S4,/”WNOP'X MN2ˆ1W2' •-C+++-/S3

,,?-N< A=%m–gEFR' •-C3+*4S3

,*V=F i4)=FA4Nl4&q2'1+/0S0

,+—=2=> iPX^=’X40E€R',.+//S1

,0ZŠ=L˜ •m'`44*.*S*

,1D~'=_B2'#$%&'(1*43S+

 47\i=]Q_.'oG2=y'GNO452'•a<i=F^?7oG$~4€o8P?y'•€^Z0`G<4lvzvfBIA47=-B.'8=c•a™'qIS?€P•>eš"]‡Pƒ67?C'=U2'oˆ‰Š4B2\

Z'=‹\`GW&4YE7op4›'=œ\6%2Pm=E7X?CA9UW2'4aN<=),1,"%2w?c'PS—Q‹'oG2=y'j9ži=EmP4]^4_7G<4lvzvŸ74OqI!D~'=_B2'#$%&'("p'(2

Page 209: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 209/248

;<6W3<. MX24N !"$

xO4]G<=107G2=HY2'G2=L-2GNO452'G<=107G$l'?F ¡I3+6 3+S4¢vtCGF^X67•L£';Y%2'¤N,I“  # F=>tC8P?y'•€^Z1`i\4aWNY&"%_I=nJ7Zq¥O\

8P?y'•€^1S`g]i\m=E74UW2'DE2'4‚ƒqc\"]w?C4€e7"]w?C4€bq:\Œ   # JE&o•€^?c'P“M,Iwq1_2'GN24E2'¦

,7"€\67,//GHUO*7 ,// 8 ,--9-GHUOZ,1,GHUO^?n-28X4YE.'"74%2'`+7 *// 8 *--9-GHUO07 +// 8 +--9-GHUO17 0// 8 0--9-GHUO37 01+YJ24IZD)P4UOiP4BE2'8X4YE.'`47 01+9, 8 0--9-GHUO.7 1// 8 1--9-GHUO-7 3//GHUOP\q5]\

 

Page 210: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 210/248

 

 "

'() *+,-./%0;<6W3<. Q2RNY9+:. ;<6-.

!&"  $%&

Page 211: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 211/248

;<6W3<. MX24N !&&

 '() *+,-./'0

 1+)2345./167)285.0;KN2Z<. ;<6-. =

 

>?%?4<./;[email protected]

'BC.,%3<./[\] ^ 1J _2]C6<. [&

`,$45.

 GHI4<. DE%F<./127 1J

2KF&2L0

M&2NO<. ;a<

/b?Kc d" 1.A@)6e0

)*+,+-./ *01-2340

 Q2RS<. D4<.

2TUAV"

,A^=I=I'^ 8=>4O''?W]ˆ1W2' •-C:1

*i=NY74_> § 3'X:,3

+KM<P^=I =>P\Ÿ&PqW2':44

0N] ŠP^:*/

1@7X T4N2P;**

3“74%m'q’ •NF2

6&@>4] K]

 :*+

4qW&P Š^4):+,

.X 8P4ISi=EnW&^4):,,*

-ASVR=%NOi47?N>2¨S

[ƒP;_>

 X40E€R' •-C:+.

,/"N1Y&=-] 8^4_>;1-

,,q-m@EN’ T4)'qI':-

,*

ƒ'q1N2 V=%O'q<'©&=m;*-

,+X^'PXv6IR' px&'P:,3

,0ªq5&\ T4)'q’'?W]:,*

,1[v 8P4IS—9I:**

,3X^=<=) X^4_E&^:01

Page 212: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 212/248

Page 213: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 213/248

;<6W3<. MX24N !&%

 >?%?4<./;[email protected]

'BC.,%3<./[\] ^ 1J _2]C6<. [&

`,$45.

 GHI4<. DE%F<./127 1J

2KF&2L0

M&2NO<. ;a<

/b?Kc d" 1.A@)6e0)*+,+-./ *0

1-2340

 Q2RS<. D4<.

2TUAV"

+4;N1N2 ‡^=F;,/

+.¬\ O4EmS&=]:00

+-^\S[XSi=m^?O':00

0/”WNOP'X MN2ˆ1W2' •-C:++

0,i47q$&ƒ ‡^=F:+3

0*i47=NO NEm:1,

0+@O=F K>^47‘?W2ƒ=NO;,1*

00[vS[vS>\Si47^=‹

 ;+*

01

;_>4Ym=O [qW):1*

03KE‹X9’ ?N1&X:*.

04¬ —^47S"NENI:+/

0.[\ ?N1&XS¤N$m;*+

0-?O9N2 AqIP^‘?W2ƒ=NO;1*

1/¬\ "%&47S6&^=n]47

 :4.

1,

^ X^P4)Sq&?OR=):,3

1*=N-IX ˆ$NFi47?&q<

 X40E€R' •-C:-

1+X^=<=) ‡^=F:0,

10[X=$m rM&^:3

Page 214: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 214/248

!&'  " #$%&

 >?%?4<./;[email protected]

'BC.,%3<./[\] ^ 1J _2]C6<. [&

`,$45.

 GHI4<. DE%F<./127 1J

2KF&2L0

M&2NO<. ;a<

/b?Kc d" 1.A@)6e0)*+,+-./ *0

1-2340

 Q2RS<. D4<.

2TUAV"

11?-N< A=%m–gEFR' •-C:1/

13V'q’X=Wm DWNF:-/

14igM&PX ‡^=F;3

1.=N-IXS>\Si=M>qIP^

 :10

1-¨'^ ?2P^4):1*

3/[v ˆ$NFS84):+,

3,?OR?&q< X^'PXv:.0

3*D~'=_B2'#$%&'(

 :Z0`

3+@>=) qFP^;,0

!1.A@)6e ;I?S< ;K%f.,<. _2N2K3<. g,h iL6Ec *6W<. A7j '@)*+,+-/M&2NO<. [&k'@ ,(+9+:. ;<6-. A]AR@ = l.,V.+ l2N2Kc mN" nh i?4V. ,( 127 mN" 'o) p2ST qN2Kc mN" nh DPr<. A&:. s2?4V.k

 

gWNI6%$&8P?L-2•€^Z1`i\4WNHB&wq%<6C“YM2'd'^P8=0cG&\w?C4€GWNB7tC4UW2'DE2'p4‚ƒqc\Rvi\^'?U ® 7"NŽ41E2'•N¥CSpr2(2ƒs>GF4£'zv

GU&qœq5]\ 9IeNHEMW2•a<Ÿ~4EW2'S6M£Pp¯£'i°<eF'Q2'w=H:w=H:q<=&‘()GU&qH2'S?U< #KY>i\GM‰U<67KI?C'=U2'D)DE2'6%$&i\T?EM  * > #©1E2

"%_I?NF '?Fb?76Mcd'X\w?C4€GWNB7e7GC=$L.'GO=%.'673+w?C4€"74%24ISr2(26%$&q¥W2'zv‘()?C'=U2'ˆ$±'tC4¢\G-5²GC=$L$-24aE7qI67

¤Nci\4UW2'DE2'4‚ƒqc\w?C4€GWNB76%$&i\T?EM>³YWE-28?B$I4UW2'DE2'"0´4aN-Cw?C4U2'oGC=$L.'G-74%2'S

Page 215: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 215/248

;<6W3<. MX24N !&5

 *+,-.5

;<6W3<. Q2RNY;KN2Z<. ;<6-.

 

Page 216: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 216/248

!&6  " #$%&

 

Page 217: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 217/248

;<6W3<. MX24N !&7

`At8<.Y,7"€\67,//GHUO*7 ,// 8 ,--9-GHUOZ,1,GHUO^?n-28X4YE.'"74%2'`+7 *// 8 *--9-GHUO07 +// 8 +--9-GHUO17 0// 8 0--9-GHUO37 01+YJ24IZD)P4UOiP4BE2'8X4YE.'`47 01+9, 8 0--9-GHUO.7 1// 8 1--9-GHUO-7 3//GHUOP\q5]\

47\G2X4B74UOG2=HY2'GB€=E.'Da<¦< = ,*/9/ > ?9*/*)@3 > ?9,-.)@+/ > ?9,,/)@+1 > ?9/4*)@03 > ?9/.3)@*4

¤Nci\<D)GHUW2'GB€=E.'DE2'4)ƒq´w?C4€pGWNB747\@AD)GHUW2'DE2'4)ƒq´r->w?C4U2'67?C'=U2'bq:{'S

?€PY>^''()K$E2'4UW2G2=HY2'e74UW2'GNUNU£'DE2'•>4)ƒ'qcvoG2=HY2'b?2B = 9-4-/pPB 

* = 9-3/S'()PDWB&i\-3G~4.4I676&4YE2'o4UOG2=HY2'

ŒJE>6789:G<qB7d'X\w?C4U2'e7K-5$.'GM$±'U<S?U2A   #©<4UW2'w?Ny'DE2'4‚ƒqc\GNLN>'Qmv!w?c'=2'w?c'=I"e7eNš

dR³)K-5$.'pGM$±'A   #©<4)ƒ=<oG2=HY2'Sq  # ](>i\4UW2' ¡2'01+D)47•>‘ƒ'qcv6789:iP4BE2'8X4YE.';’PDaEW.'S?U2Aƒ4cGNLN>'Qmv!w?c'=2'w?c'=I"tC4UW2'pGN24E2'e7K-5$.'GM$±'¦@ 3 = 01+µ@ +/ = 01+µ@+1 = 01+µ

@ 03 = 01*P@ *4 = 003ST'?Em4IP'()^4NB.'opGO^4U.'em=Idq.'i\bq&N]i4]d'X\?C'=U2'P\A4NLN>'Qm}'bq:{'opG2=HY2'6789:q¥W2'zvb?7d=m

ZP\6M  * c`47x74€¶I67d'X\e7K-5$.'GM$±'GO^4U7GN1N%Id'X\GNLN>'Qmv!w?c'=2'w?c'=I"•aB7Sq<=E&P'()·qB2'o8P?y'•€^3pg]¶O\q  # <=Nm4m4m\4.

DUI67"N-´‘(›G2=y'Zq¥O\8P?y'S`

Page 218: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 218/248

!&#  " #$%&

 '() *+,-./60,h.6R<. u.g"Y;KN2Z<. ;<6-.

q%ZE  v 5. w& u.g:./;[email protected] ;N)2R52c `{2|. Q2RS<.8`,V.6c `,V.6<.90

 

Page 219: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 219/248

;<6W3<. MX24N !&$

 

Page 220: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 220/248

!!"  " #$%&

 

Page 221: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 221/248

;<6W3<. MX24N !!&

G<4l}4Izv47pT #?U>i°<8P?y'•€^Z3`"$E_&tC4UW2'GN-B12'pG2=HY-2"%2Pw?C4€67p?C'=U2'G-J12'PGNUYE.'DE2'PD)oe€'=2'^'?U7¸^412'KIGHUW2'

GNUNU£'GHUW2'PGB  # €=E.'oG2=HY2'S¯cR¶O\gWNIDHn>4UOG2=HY2'R4™4O #=%767w?CA4¹767p4UW2'?LOi\G-J12'"€\67,/4UOpU<4²8?&w #q7bq:\tC

b?76Mc;M1>K-5$.'GM$±'d'X{?C'=U2'"%_IT4CS67PAgM2'bq:{'

wq&?y'TgE)R4Ib?2G-J12'GNUYE.'D)i\?C'=U2'DE2'Aƒqc\“>'q.'G7?UE.'"N† zv—9E7's]\G-J<GNI4ºv4² #8?&tC4¢\T=U>d'X»I"J<\67•¥B7?C'=U2'ofBIDc'=W2'wXP?,.'67G2=HY2'DE2'¼4)   #©1&i=-5$.'GM$±'S

6%$&i½'T'?Em'K-5$.'w?C4M$-2tCGI4F}'tCG-¹m{'G&^=,.'8=c47i4] 4B<4O47P¼6%&r2(]S

   #KY&8P?y'•€^3"%_IPRˆY2¶N<$O4UW2'wƒq,.'e7K-5$.'GM$±'SivK-5$.'Gž952'"~'P{'•aM1O\i=$ME&H-24IS?U2x-0cG<4]?C'=U2'G1NH-2'

tC01+

GHUOe7"]"5²67dR³)K-5$.'pGž952''(2¼?U1>?C'=U2'G1NH-2'G&\GHUO GO^4U7e7GN1N]d'X\GNLN>'Qmv!w?c'=2'w?c'=I"DE2'Aƒqc\GY>q.'pzP{'•aB7S47\?C'=U2'DE2'¼6%>G1NH2"%_IpT4C•-<•U>"5$I47¶E-B<GNLN>'Qmv!w?c'=2'w?c'=I"e7dR³)K-5$.'Gž952'p"~'P{'g]qa¥&oGW$N)T4€^{'GYF=.'tCT4€^{'GY24M2'or->w?$C{'Gž952'DE2'qa¥>o8P?y'•€^3S

"F{PX4a_EmR'845$I8=c'()pq7{'i°<"J<\?C'=U2'DE2'¼•ME>H-24ID)r->DE2'T #?U>4¾8P4Ipi=EnW&^4)DE2'PAƒqc\GY>q.'GW7452'SxO4]‘()w?C4U2'w^4YC6Ce&=W>P\q&=´GNLN>'Qm}!w?c'=2'w?c'=I"p?€PxO4]4›GY€'q7

tCD~'=_B2'Z#$%&'(`pGU&qœPh  # -$E-267AR4c^?n2'ŠP4WE.'Z;ž»>b?02'`p9J<6CGU&qœG&¿q2476%$&i\‘(:»>x-1>P¶I67Š4UB2'SxO4]‘()w?C4U2'^?n>g~'X?WCG-UW2'GBI4M2'pKž952'PGN2gEc4IPw?&'@E7?BI‘()pG-UW2'47¼

•U&“C92'q:½'^?n24I[^=12'?BIw?c'P67A   #R'X^?n2'p‘()oPr->p84£'%Em‘()w?C4U2'6C^?n2'D~'=_B2'S;’4¢\¼T #?U>47=)"J<\67d'X\

Page 222: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 222/248

!!!  " #$%&

GNLN>'Qmv!w?c'=2'w?c'=I"e7[\67K-5$.'pGM$±'4aW%2PxO4C';5]67"5$.'3452'S?U<x-0c‘()w?C4U2'b?24aEaF'=7G]^4_7'()"5$.'tC47=)ÀOX\67

GNLN>'Qmv!w?c'=2'w?c'=I"¸^41I+4S*GHUOSiv'()"5$.'3452'=)47À$M&G24£4¡IGN24UEOR'G,UW.'#CDE@C& @<$<C <#$%@E<E'%p=)Pw^4YC6Cw?C4€

G2 #?B767w?C4U2'GN-N$%E2'G2=L-2pzP{'?€P4a7 #?€i4ž4O=F%WNIG2=L-2GNO452'S

eYE>‘()w?C4U2'“C92'q:½'"B1>P"57¶-B<GN-$B]?N-U>D~'=_CpeHUE7w=H: pw=HItC=,O¶Y‹\GN-$BI!¬=]^47"ST=UE<4‚'^4NE:4I67"F\8=Ž=2'zv?£'Á€{'674aYm4%7w?NBY2'?7{'tC·'Q<'i\'()‡„=$W2'=)‡„=$OŒN,ŽS

gWNIPxO4]w?C4€i=EnW&^4)^?n> '^'q7p '^'q%>PxO4]w?C4€G24£'GN24UEOR'G,  # UW.'DUY>tCK$…q$EM7GN2gEcRi\T=U&“C92'q:½'iP4BE24I?BI"]GLNEO67

Ÿ~4EW2'GBI^{'GW%$.'SoPG&4¢p¬4H.'A^q€¶O\ˆN267[?L.'i\iP4BE>?BIi\4a  # -nEm'¬qH2'pq:½'?BIPr2„wÂ4Y7A^q€ 4J&\¶O\4¢P4B>ˆN2 4&?™ÀEc?BIiP4BE2'8X4YE.'!,"S

'(2ÀEc=2xO4]w?C4U2'bq:{'w?BEM7"YUE2fBIAR4cp^?n2'XqL$Ii\+NJ>4C^„”-Y&P4a˜4M>p¶>P^„i=%Nm67;MB2''?F4aC4W€vi»I¸qœdq.'?€

A   #;n>SgWNIPxW%†fBI?C'=U2'bq:{'DE2'¼6%>pG1NH2oe€'Ppq7{'67T4NU2'd'X»I"J<\67d'X\GNLN>'Qmv!w?c'=2'w?c'=I"e7w?C4€G24£'GN24UEOR'G,UW.'

#CDE@C& @<$<C <#$%@E<E'%pRvi\‘()?C'=U2'xO4]G24  # N7=,OT4NU2'd'X»I\=m\;5%Ie7fBI67K-5$.'6&q:½'S

6%$&T'?Em'K-5$.'GM$±'ˆN2U<"N-,E2Ÿ~4EOG2=y'GNO452'67pG2=HY2'

"Id4_O}A4B&=W>GNl'Q<'G2=HY-2S•E&P'()6789:?&?´G$N€G1-EÃ4NYMO"%2 –=O67?C'=U2'G]^4_.'S6%$&Pq¥W2'zv"]"5²67K-5$.'GM$±'¶1Ž=Ir-E$& 

Z,` 6  # $J>Ÿ74OqIGNLN>'QmvGN24UEOR' G24£'G,UW.'#CDE@C& @<$<C <#$%@E<E'%p»H:T'P?2' tC "B1& i\ ¶2 ?&^\ 47 "B1& 6%& ¼ ¶O°< ª4E24IPSGNLN>'Qmv ¶E10I ?NF "$BI T4€ ¶W%2P

G]^4_.' bq:{' A9:?$-2 ;57 Ä?´ •&?U> 89: 67 G-5²S

Page 223: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 223/248

Page 224: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 224/248

!!'  " #$%&

i4] 41-Eà474†4²i4]¶N-Coe€'=2'S'(2i°<Ÿ~4EW2'G  # N-%2'G2=L-2GNO452'xO4]eE$E>GO4E$IGN24CS

6%2P84UEOR4I67G2=HY2'4aE7qI=,OG&=)p@~412'6%$&dq$-2i\8»M& 4J&\N]i4]d'X\GNLN>'Qmv!w?c'=2'w?c'=I"or->AR=HY2'GNl'Q<R'xM2'S

Š'=y'P=)4¢\¼8@>oGY>q.'zP{'oˆ‰67AR=HY2'GNl'Q<R'xM2'Siv

‘()GLNEW2G&=€'?FKY>i\!w?c'=2'w?c'=I"¼8@>"J<\w?C4€67KIr->?C'=U2' DE2'•>4a$&?U>tC"%‹8 #?B767KI?&?B2'67A4B&=WE2'oG¹NY2'GHN,.'DE2'R?I4›674aEaF'=7S

6%2Pd4W5EmR'?Nc=2'u4LW2GNLN>'Qmv!w?c'=2'w?c'=I"oAR=HY2'GNl'Q<R'=)8457;57TgE)92S=2xO4]wq~'X^=ašGNLN>'QmvG24£'GN24UEOR'

G,UW.'#CDE@C& @<$<C <#$%@E<E'%s]\ˆ‰A'q74²xO4]¶N-Coe€'Pp84£'xO4%2GNLN>'Qmv!w?c'=2'w?c'=I"?€x  # -coGY>q.'GNO452'SxO4%2PGY>q.'

zP{'?€xY)„zvw?C4U2'DE2'Aƒqc\GY>q.'GBm4E2'KBI^{'PoG2=HY2'GNUNU£'S ?€PT #?U>‘(¾w?C4U2'AqIP^?O9N267?O9]P\ow?W2ƒ=NOSi4]4aB<'X¶Y_&zv?c47e<'XGNLN>'Qmv!6  # %M  * .'#$%JKELEMC#"67¤Nc4¢\\?Y>tC=,OiP4BE7

p'?F4aW%2Pi4CÇ47q¥W>zv474aW%$&i\‘(:»>=LW>P4aE-B1ISg]P6%$&i\¯c9O678P?y'•€^Z3`pi°<w?C4€?O9N2?€Ad4FoGY>q.'GBm4E2'KBI^{'P

4¢{x74€d'X»Id§'?Fe7"5$.'p¤2452'e7P!6  # %M  * .'#$%JKELEMC#"S4aW%2Px74€ƒ'qc°I-/GHUO"J<\4²¶>ƒqc\GNLN>'Qmv!w?c'=2'w?c'=I"o4aEaF'=7

}GNLN>'QmG24£'GN24UEOR'G,UW.'#CDE@C& @<$<C <#$%@E<E'%p4.4œi\r->w?C4U2'xO4]?€xNU2 R4YUEm'4WMcGLNEO4¢P4BE2oG&'?Y2'S=2Pi4]^=aš"5²

GNLN>'QmvG24£'GN24UEOR'G,UW.'#CDE@C& @<$<C<#$%@E<E'%s]\ˆ‰A'q74²i4]¶N-Cope€'=2'xO4%2w?C4€?O9N2?€x74€d'X»I"J<\ 9B<67d'X\

GNLN>'Qmv!w?c'=2'w?c'=I"P\G&\w?C4€bq:\•>4a$&?U>G]^4_$-2oG2=HY2'4aE7qIS

Page 225: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 225/248

;<6W3<. MX24N !!5

ivGUNU£'DE2'?N1>i»IGNLN>'Qmv!w?c'=2'w?c'=I"?€x,I^GM‰"~'?I67"Ž\GEm67pG2=HY2'?€PAd4FGY>q.4IGNO452'o"&?Y2'VX4M2' #KY>i\ƒ=<!w?c'=2'

w?c'=I"i4] 'ƒ=< 4WNE7 'q)4IP 4UcS 

Page 226: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 226/248

!!6  " #$%&

 

Page 227: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 227/248

!"#$ 

&'()*+,- .#/ 01-*2 

34*56,- 

" #$%&'()*+,-'./01'23./4526,78&29:7'" #$%&;<)'=7'87>?';@3AB7'C>2&/)2DEFG/BH7'IJD" #$%&KL/B:7'8&29:7'AB7'MNBO/PQ4R./4S4O'TUV'

W2%BN-'/4XJB1'IY #20O8Z078,[03<SN7'\X/]^8Z07_T`&/a4bc/ZXde4fcgH&QUgh

iD$f';Ja:3c^c;/0B&j!k;^c^l$m&j"kI'En;c;/0Ooc/:pd'cqr+4Nb\X

Wsb/H-'j# kI/3^'En/3l$to/uqD/uqHbir+4U\XG/%07'j$kI@H7;'En/3 c;/0O/u$f^ vl$t;o2wx'ir+4Nby;?'\X./Xgb$3oi  # 6m-'z^j%koJ:4hir{|/}7'\X8~4•€'2tV'j&kIOTO;./Xgb$-'\Xg+:7'‚/B7'& ( # ( $ ( %o

ƒZrBU;# ) *& + %,-.IF;iH`7'M•lj/k@3ir67'y;?'ƒ[BO8bg6r38Z0,7'iH`h„1Q3M4%7'8,}~-'IiD8,%…F8Z078,[03<SN7'Wl2HB-'z;/NOi•^@3

Page 228: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 228/248

!!" "#$%&

8,%:7'AB7'o/aB%ZU=Xi3/Xy$03Mr†'0oe4f1( 0 ( /I'(7c‡biˆ/fQ~‰'A~D'T7'./Xgb$~,7F8Z0,7'Wl2HB-'z?Xd@3<ZXq7'@&(,7'c/…;/0B&J4b

Ja:4hcgH4U# + 0# + 0.# 222 3 #-*/40,I84S4O'TUV'A)864Šg7'W$~BN-'@3‹&l/O8Z0,7'Œ,3/HhJ4b*,0B&847JBf/h

847/' 8,%:7' F c;/0B7'IA) 841Eg~:7' 84S4O'TUV';5W$f'gh W$f'g7'6/];/0O cgH& AB7'

8%h/N7' 8,%:7' F 2wx' Xq7' i06& /3 i06O Mp @3; oŽ;?' 8,%:7' F '$D3Io"/X iH`h; c‡b8~4•j;^ %…8 k84S4O'TUV'7$:X/a,3/0OQ384S4O'TUV'8i}~BO\Xg+:7'‚/B7'‘9*7-8,I84S4O'TUV' c^ y/%&;7<ZXd @3 c #gHB-' |/HN7' Q~BS-' ’f/B1' $•

cg3$“BN&84S4O'TUV'8'Enc/D9*7-8,) 9*8-8,I'En;C2bgBO8&^84S4O'TUn/a:H~&c^”/B84S4O'TUV'8o/a:4f@H~&yg%7'csh8W2%BN3iH`hAX/RI

" #$%O845267'Ž;?'€/Z…?'8–4N7'AB7'$46OŒ…sh'Enc/DiZ%BN-'Ja3JhŒ4bo8&/6H7'’N47_/:)84S4O'TUnW$f';\}3F8Z078,[03<SN7'Wl2HB-'I

'()*+,-#

:'Enc/D—3Mr†'0/06O23JhŒ4bo8&/6H7'’N47_/:) 84S4O'TUnW$f';\}38,%BN3@X84S4O'TUV'AB7'/a3$“BN&Xq7'2wx'I$•;’4X^<)'=7'\X˜7EFir67'y;?'I

/3^845267'84…/}7'yg%BbŒ…^'Enc/DQ4~‰'cg3$“BN&84S4O'TUn5W$f'g7'W$f'gh6oc/D;iZ%BN-'Ja3JhŒ4bo8&/6H7'/a:4fdQ4BN&$f^"/4%7'zsh€'>^i[b^

@3yqwy #g+B7'Žn84S4O'TUn™2w^I'()*+,-!$cn84S4O'TUn5W$f'g7'W$f'gh6W2%BN3/4X/R'En;š%b'Enc/D

›/4%3Mr†'j0k\Xi•?'oMS+h;^=D^@3-*& ; #,*& ; # k;j& ; #,-*# ; %Ik./01,-‘Fo8&'$Z7'.2aŠœ()845267'8&;/N3yg%,7csh84S4O'TUn5W$f'g7'

W$f'gh6W2%BN3/4XJB1''Enš%b;'En’…/Dt8,h/•”/4B1q7d@3iZ•84S4O'TUnl$m7'ML'$7'7<< "d;@3iZ•8&^84S4O'TUn™2w^"$“BNOl$m7'c;/0B7';iH`h

G;/:B3I$0h;./Zpnb/HO<Bm4r7'MB&./Zpn<3/[38m4r7'84…/}7'I

Page 229: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 229/248

'2*34,- 5/()*+,- 67 80-*9 !!%

cn/:7g•csh84S4O'TUnl$m7'ML'$7'dQ4BNO”/4B1'84S4O'TUn5W$f'g7'W$f'gh6A:0&c^9*7<< "=&>&, ? 9*&>&=&>&I k/3$:XŒ1'gO84S4O'TUnl$m7'

ML'$7'7<< "84S4O'TUn5W$f'g7'W$f'gh6o/]‡bir+BUF8,%:7'Ž;?'\X&

$0h;˜7E@7irž\X€Ÿ™gU$Bf8&/]o8Z0,7'/¡i0¢‘9*7<< "=&>&, 3

&+ 0$-*/40,IJh;c^584S4O'TUnW$f'g7'W$f'gh6c;/0BOJL'>Q3o/£'9…c‡b9*&>&=&>&,3#+0#+0.#2 2 23#-*/40,

I'(H);c‡b84S4O'TUnl$m7'ML'$7'd Q4BNOc^”/B84S4O'TUn5W$f'g7'W$f'gh6/3$:XcgH&‘ &+0$-*/40,?#-*/40k;^&*/40,+0$?# o;^& ; # ? 0 *& ; $ko;^ j& ; #,-*& ; $, 0 @I\X;¤6…ol'2 ¥ m7'c‡byg%7'csh'()G;/:B7'l$m,7

c;/0B7';d@H~&c^”/B¢84S4O'TUn5W$f'g7'W$f'gh6A:0&c^ j&+ 0% , - */4 0., ? # - */40ko;^j&4 #,-*#4%,? 0I'(7c‡b 

0 @ *& ; #,-*&4$k;0 @ *& ; #,-*#4%kz¦'g&/:7g•csh84S4O'TUn5W$f'g7'

W$f'gh6

t8:H¡”/4B1d'd@3iZ•84S4O'TUn5

l$m7'ML'$7'6

  7<< "od;@3iZ•84S4O'TUV'AB7'QZBO8U/4UG;/:B7'Fl$m7'c;/0B7';I'();   #<Z&c^<Bm4r7'c/B–b/HB3I

cx';MBBU8:)2hiD$f';@3<3/[38m4r7';^87>/0-'84…/}7'I$fsb<3/[-'$•¤UsO@3yqw89fq-'84NZ7'csh84S4O'TUn5W$f'g7'W$f'gh6A)84S4O'TUn

W2%BN3o/4X/R‚/B7/h;dQ4BNO8&^W$X/•o/af/4B1'Œ4,X;c‡b<O$X/%7'<O>$+-'dc/04BNO˜7E/[&^I/3^cg~[-'2wx'z(7'd$h@3ŒB:)2hgab‘'EnCQBNO

84S4O'TUnl$m7'ML'$7'7<< "od;84S4O'TUnG;/:B7'<hl$m7'c;/0B7';c^”/B84S4O'TUn5W$f'g7'W$f'gh6o §'En@7Q4BNO8&^84S4O'TUn™2w^c^i06O˜7EIcn

™$784S4O'TUn5W$f'g7'W$f'gh6<B7/foš%b>/:BUd/h\X/3i0bXq7'2wx'F8,%:7'8%h/N7'jA6b8,%:7'oŽ;?'¨T6Oœ()84S4O'TUV'c^Xq7'2wx'$•

c;/0B&Iko˜7(7'En’…/D84S4O'TUV'j^ki3/0BOQ384S4O'TUn5W$f'g7'W$f'gh6c‡bi[b^/3@H~&c^"g%OŒhj^k;^8&^84S4O'TUn™2w^$0hl/4Bw'l$m7'g)c^l/B©<h

Page 230: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 230/248

!&' "#$%&

l$m7'";^c;/0B7'!I\X;¤6…oiH`7'c‡bi[b^/3@H~&c^"g%OŒh84S4O'TUnj^k$0hl/4Bw'l$m7'g)c^l/B©<hc;/0B7'!;^l$m7'"I_T&;'()23?'

84S4O'TUV'j^k"/3^80hl^.dJBf'@H~&c^/a,06OQ384S4O'TUn5W$f'g7'W$f'gh6‘./0h/BB7'Wl2HB-'c;/0B,7ªc;/0B7'j!!ko;^c;/0B7'ªl$m7'j!"ko;^

l$m7'-c;/0B7'j"!ko;^l$m7'-l$m7'j""kIŽ;?';"g%Oi}~h/3Œ,06O5W$f'g7'

W$f'gh6

Q3W$X/•™2w^QZBO5

W$f'g7'W$f'gh6

/[&^I@H7;84…/}7'C@H~BO@3"/4%7' €'>shi[b^@3iD@3Ž;?'8}7/}7';I'();y$&\XŒ…^'En/3’…/D<B47JBfd'8}7/}7'80h'27';t<Ol>/•\X”/4B1'84S4O'TUn5W$f'g7'W$f'gh6o/a:4f@7@H~BO8&^

84S4O'TUn™2w^@3˜7E\X«q¬V'I<O/);<B4…/H3V'<B&¦'g384S4O'TUVG;/:Ol$m7'oc;/0B7';84S4O'TUn;l$m7'ML'$7'\X‚'gB7'Io˜7(7'EnC@H~BO8&^W$f';@3<O/)<B4S4O'TUV'@3”/4B1'84S4O'TUn5W$f'g7'W$f'gh6o@,b@H~BO

8&^84S4O'TUn™2w^@3"/4%7'o˜7(h˜7(h;cgHO84S4O'TUn5W$f'g7'W$f'gh6

W2%BN3/4X/RI'();i~H&c/)=7'I

 $0h/:O/Zpn’•g7'z(7'cgHOŒ4b84S4O'TUn5W$f'g7'W$f'gh6W2%BN3o/4X/Rc‡bWg†'WZH7'847/B7'A)4:rOQ4R./4S4O'TUV'W2%BN-'/4X/RI®HO2&;'()

4:rB7'8b/H7./4S4O'TUV'W2%BN-'/4X/R\XW2H67'AB7'™2OŒ…sh@H~&Q:3”/4B1d''En/3’,01W$X/%7'ML/%7'”/4B1d/h^gU^d/f'En/3Q  # ZO'W$X/%7'83/07'

N+bI@H~&84S4O'TU¯7jGkc^Q:°”/4B1d'z(7'"g%OŒh84S4O'TUV'j^k'En/3.$DsO84S4O'TUV'jGk@3Œ…^Y±h29:7' #JX"g%OŒh84S4O'TUnj^kJ4bo$0h

c‡bjGki0SBU²g~³´/%…j^k/[6“:3JhŒ4b8&/6H7'I'();>g%&Žn&20B7'$46-'

‚/B7'‘QB~BOjGk\Xj^k8,%:7' F @3µ Q5ghjA

ko/a4,& /3;9*7-8,?9*8=8

k¨'Tb' \X c^84S4O'TUV'jGk8l$mBU@38,%:7'jAk/3;/a4,&Bf8&/a:7'I¨'Tb/h;c^8~4•9Ai}°²g~S-'A~D'T7'´/%:7j^kF.q%:7'8%h/N7'8,%:,7AI/a:4fcgHO8%&27'

84…/}7'yg%7c^84S4O'TUV'jGk8®4~BO\Xj^kQ5gh@3µ F8,%:7'AA)JD„&‘9 A *7=8, + 0 A4/$- */40, ? 9 *8=8k

Page 231: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 231/248

'2*34,- 5/()*+,- 67 80-*9 !&#

Jhc^i[b^/3Q4BNO84S4O'TUnj^kc^Œ,06O(:38,%:7'A/3;/a4,&'En/3.l$t84S4O'TUV'jGkA)ygr'\X8hg%07'j$kFiDW23I

$N;8&29:7'AB7'„O˜7E8+4r:7'AB7'$46O˜…sh'En.>l^c^"$“BNO84S4O'TUnW2%BN3o/4X/RJb˜4,X™gUc^c;/0BO/3$:XQ4BNOc^i~+BOyqmBUd'\X$&Y27'2wx'’:D;dy'®OQ4BNO¶/6'\X˜05;@3x'I

'2*3:;(<=>,-?cgHO84S4O'TUV'jGk84S4O'TUnW2%BN3/4X/R'Enš%b;'En’3/•jGkl$m7/hF8,%:7'AJ,Dc/D²g~³´/%…Xq7'2wx''ZD'$1Bf

oŒ:4fd;J4U/3$:XcgH&‘9A *7=8, ) 9 *8=8, ; 0 A ; / B& + 0$- */40,C

$•;>l;c/)=7'\X˜7EFG/BD>;2,4ND^j/DE/Ikcn8&29…·4“`B7'¸8%4p;8,r7'@3e4f8U/4N7'83/07'¹F/a3ga63> #2S-'

e4f/]^>$ž84S4O'TUV'AB7'¢\XjGk/a3'$“BU'™$78%…84:3¦8:403

864ŠgD@3L/Š;‹&l/Oi3/0B7'*h/N7'@3i1^c^ƒZrOjGk84S4O'TUnW2%BN3 /4X/R!/"IŒ…n º·4“`O º"/Oc?'(),B-'g) º  # ,B3zl;»g);´—MLq384S4O'TU¯7jGkAH7cgHOW2%BN3/4X/RI

JD@H~&@3œ()8&29:7'845/&27'89fq3<B:p'@3./0ZB7'8%,0B-'./4S4O'TUV/hW2%BN-'/4X/RIod;^/-/¬c^Xq7'2wx'CQ~¢JD'2O'ZD@3

o´/%:7'c‡b84S4O'TUV'QB~BO€¼h@38…;2-'Fl/4Bwd'<hc^c;/0BO;^c^l$mO%ZO;W2%BN3/4X/RIœ();8…;2-'A)AB7' #½6OZN7'€'l;>g1;$&$07'@3

./4S4O'TUV'AB7'MNBO/a04R./Z}7/hAXJ‰'I/3^8S4B:7'84…/}7'Aabc^W$X/%7' 864,7'jW$X/%7'AB7'dcgHOy;^@3l$m&kQB~BOl$%7/h=D?'@3e4f8…;2-'/-/¬/]^˜,B°\X^81l>8:H¡@3´/%:7'/3$:X0,OQ3W$X/•8%h/3IWl/Z0ho™2w^cn

 j/k AH7$&$ž MB& c^ $h d o<%4•> cgH…9*8=8,/%ZN3IW$X/%7' ’…/D 'En oy/}-' i4ZU \XjGk

 ol$m& @3 y;^ A) ¤479*8=8,3#-*/40,2

Page 232: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 232/248

!&! "#$%&

$X'g%7'864,7'@H~&c^i~Bžc^cgHO2}D^/32D@3$X'g%7'™2w?'F/a,3/0OQ3W'®m7'<,~B+-'c?$X'g%7'864,7'"g%O€'>sh$41Q3/a[0h¾0Z7'I

’:  # 4h845267'.c^84S4O'TUn5W$f'g7'W$f'gh6’…/DW2%BN3/4X/Rš%b/3$:Xc/DiZ%BN-'Ja3JhŒ4b8&/6H7'I/3^845267'84…/}7'"$“BNBb8&29…·4“`B7';^

i4}~B7'AB7' #<ZOc^'()¿/B:BUd'g)FQ•';y/'"/XQU';;'$1IŒ…nF8%4%'

*Z:&\X8&^84S4O'TUn@H~&c^cgHOy;^@3c;/0B&I '()*+,-&:cn8&^84S4O'TUnjGkcgHOy;^@3c;/0B&/a:H~&c^ƒZrOW2%BN3/4X/Rš%b/3$:XcgH&›/4%3Mr†'0'ZDJhŒ4b8&/6H7'I

./@@@@@@@@@@@@@@01,-‘'En’ÀÀÀÀÀÀÀÀÀÀÀÀÀÀ…;/0OjGkF8ÀÀÀÀÀÀÀÀÀÀÀÀÀÀ,%:7'oŽ;?' 9*7<<"=8,@ &+ 0$-*/40,I@H7;8ZN:7/h8&?o84S4O'TUnjGkocgH&#-*/40,@

9*8=8k/-/¬c/D# g)i[b^/3@H~&84S4O'TU¯7jGkc^"g%OŒÀhQÀ3./À5'Tb'8,[03<SN7'csh# ) $;# ) *% + &,-.IŒ4,X;c‡Àb9*7<<"=8,)9*8=8kcgÀH&

'(H)J,Dc/D& + 0$-*/40,) #-*/40,

I'();y$&\ÀXc^84S4O'TÀUnl$Àm7'ML'$À7' 7<< "”/BSBUjGkAB7'c;/0BOF87g‰'Ž;?'J,Dc/D 0(*& ;#,-*&4$,I'Enc/D™$7jGk8ˆ2b84h/¢nc;/0B,7F87g‰'oŽ;?' §'Enc‡bNH39*7<< "=8kœ¦gÀb;\X9/*8=8kd@H~&c^m,  Á &dn'Enc/D›/4%3Mr†'0'ZDJhŒ4b8&/6H7'I\ÀX;

g+…oip/¡'En’…/DjGk’N47A)y;^@À3c;/À0B&ÀBf8À,%:7'Ao/Àa:4fcgH4ÀU9A*7<< "=8,3 9A*8=8ko/À3^ÀNH39 A +/ *7<< "=8k@À39 A +/ *8=8kqÀb

@H~&œÂ/m7ndn'Enc/D›/4%3Mr†'0'ZDJhŒ4b8&/6H7'IJD;/:9fdo/%h/Uc‡b/3OT&\X8&29…·4“`B7'A)c^W$X/%7'864,7'

QB~BOl'$%~h=D^@38…;2-'Itc^8…;23W$X/%7'864,7'’N478%,3d;>;$f/ÃJDƒ[B&@38&29:7'

847/B7'IFo8%4%'¢¦'®6BU'W$X/%7'864,7'@3yqw87/fl$m7'Ž;?'AB7'l$rO@3Xq7'o2wx'z^c^W$X/%7'd$h@3c^iržF8,%…847/O\X8ˆ2bW>;$Ä

"/%B…q7>27';i}-/hF87/fl$t8,4}3I

Page 233: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 233/248

'2*34,- 5/()*+,- 67 80-*9 !&&

'()*+,-($@3i1^c^cgHO84S4O'TUV'864,7'W2%BN3o/4X/Rd$h@3c^®6  v BN  Á O@3yqwy;^87/fl$t"g%&/PXq7'2wx'I

./01,-?'EnC®6  v BN  Á OW$X/%7'864,7'F8,%:7'Ao/a:4fYgU@7cgHOW2%BN3/4X/R/]?@H~&c^¨20BO”/4B1q7@3iZ•W$X/%7'AB7'.l$tF8,%:7'Aš%bI

˜7/:)W$X/•W$f';QB~BOJL'>l'2%BUd/hoAXJ‰'z^ #¾mh29:7'@X8~4•0

;^¤4&/%3./Xgb$-'&;# ;$;%oA);W$X/•l$m7'ML'$7'7<< "oW$X/%7'AB7'l$mOJL'>Ja3’…/DY;297'I

'()*+,-):cnW$X/•l$m7'ML'$7' 7<< "W2%BN3/4X/R\X"';$7'I./01,-‘cnW$X/•l$m7'ML'$7' 7<< "W2%BN3/4X/R\X"';$7'/]?l$mO

oJL'>˜7(h;Aabl$mOJ,Dc/D˜7E/hg,3@3yqw´—8&29…·4“`B7'Iyg%&;'()´Å7'c^/-/X/… #gH3@3¸>/t;?'¹Œ:H~&c^";/%&”/4B1d'z(7'

"g%&Œhz^>2b"$“BN&8&^84S4O'TUn™2w^Æ´—c^ir&cg3>/%7'>$‰'$f'g7' g,Oo2wx'z^iH`h>26:3¤47;iH`hAX/RI'(7@~bi1^c^2~BN&oc;/0B7'd$hc^ir&cg3>/%7'>$‰'\XiHÇ./0~I\X;¨'Tb'c^<3>/%7'>$‰'7M)Wl$…

8…l/%-/hQ3./4S4O'TUV'jGk8o@~byqwQ~<3>/%7'>$‰'7@H~&M&$%O€®1ZD@38–4h/a[0ho¾0Z7'Œ:H7;%Z&€®1š4Nh@38–4hjGk8I'(7/::H~&

yg%7'c^Q~SB7' F@3<3>/%7'>$‰'7”/B¢8'Enc/D‘  F9*7=7,+*/4F,9*8=8,)9*8=8ko

e4fc^ F

A)8ZN….qX/6B7'AB7'"g%&/PXq7'z(7'"$“BN&84S4O'TUV' 7Q3Xd2wµ "$“BN&¤6…84S4O'TUV'I"/4%7/h; #i+h Foc‡b'()A:0&c^”/4B1d'@H¡'En/3"/•cg3>/%7'>$‰'iX/6B7/hJ4bMa:4hiH`hY/DI

Èfdc^˜7E¨T6&c^M4N%B7'AL/:}7'F.q3/0B7'¤47/4L'g`XIA6bM4N%B7'AL'g`07'o¿';¦É7cgH4U@3l>/:7'c^A%B,O84S4O'TUV'j^k84S4O'TU‡h

Page 234: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 234/248

!&( "#$%&

j^k™2w^Id$h;@3o˜7Ec‡b"ga63Q~SB7'i3/0&87/'AB7'cgHO/a4b./4S4O'TUnj^k §€®1/4Nh@38–4Z7'AB7'$1'gBO/a4b./4S4O'TUnjGko/a:H7;

c #gHO€®1dc/aBN  Á &Œh@38–4Z7'AB7'$1'gBO/a4b./4S4O'TUnj^k™2w?'I$%7" #$•ir67'e7/}7'¾0h8,}3?'84~•27'AB7' #<ZOc^”/4B1d'z(7'"g%OŒh./0~SB7'@H~&c^cgH&qaUŽn$f}&o8`)$7'FQ•';23?'I\Xi4ZUoy/}-'

/3$:XcgHOM4%7'8&l/40-'\Xg+:7'‚/B7'‘& 3 Go# 3 Ho$ 3 /o;% 3 1ocgH&; ›/4%3Mr†'08~4%h1IDoc‡b/0~@3A3$“BN384S4O'TUn5W$f'g7'W$f'gh6

Œ:H~&c^”/B¢/0~/4…/HU@3>/t;?'Bfg7’…/D8ZN…G8L/-/hš%b@3M£q3/0OA)AB7'MBOQ3€/[X^Q~SB7'@&2wx'I

$•y€/NB&€2-'/[&^ #JX@H~&c^Ê${/3$:X$&'®B&>$X<3>/%7'>$‰'Žn81l>WZDe4+hC$0&/a~Sf §€®1/4Nh@38–4hc/HN7'<4,ˆ?'I/3c^g~:O8ZN…

<3>/%7'>$‰'o$&'®BO; #i%OMaB1/f  # :SB7´qBwd'AL'g`07'I\X;¨'Tb'´qBwd'AL'g`07'/3/°Q38ZN…I@3<3>/%7'o>$‰'c‡b€d)<3>/%7'>$‰'cg3g%4U€'>shi[b^@3€'>^c/HN7'<4,ˆ?'/3$:XcgH&‘

I9 *7=7, + */ ; I, 9 *7=8, ) I9 *8=7, + */4I, 9 *8=8k"'$“BU/b87/f5W$f'g7'W$f'gh6A);"g%O”/4B1/h84S4O'TUnl$m7'ML'$7' 

7<< "o"'$“BU';M4%7'8&l/40-'o./Xgb$~,7c/404U8S4B:7/h  # ,B-'y$B0-'z(7'g)I ) /-/JI'(7c‡b<3>/%7'>$‰'cg04BN&”/S:7'l/)>¦d';F´qBwd'

AL'g`07'>2S~hc^'g+Zr&8ZN…8,4–5@3²g~S-'|/HN7'ŒB32hI^$ZO8r%7'8,N,NB-'Q~SBhdiH`&dn8ZN…8,4–5@3²g~S-'|/HN7'I

@H~BOœ()8ZN:7'@3¤4UsO/aN6…8&—c^˜,B~&/)Â/[X^8ˆ2bg7;oWmˆ Fo€/%B7q7Ma[0Zh¾0Z7'I$0ho˜7E/3c^2)>®O84S4O'TUV'oW$&$‰'ƒZrOœ()

8ZN:7'i•^'>JBX'\X´qBwd'AL'g`07'IF;8&/]oY/-'/3$:XƒZr&/)Â/[X^g7;8ZN…Wmˆ@3²g~³oc/HN7'/a:H~&c^iˆ'gO2)>®O;BfQ3´qBwd'

AL'g`07'"/B7'I

Page 235: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 235/248

'2*34,- 5/()*+,- 67 80-*9 !&)

<ZO;8S4B:7'847/B7'./4S4O'TUV'2}D?'8~Lq3”/4B1d84S4O'TUnl$m7'ML'$7'7<< "i•shMSf@H¡@3Q~SB7'Iœ();./4S4O'TUV'A)˜,O2}D?'Wl$•

\X®44~B7'<h/aN6…^<h;84S4O'TUnl$m7'ML'$7'I Ë$  v 0  Á O'(A(B-CDE- FG HI J (KLMNOP'QRS'En/3’…;/0OBf/3$:XCM%&Y27'2wx'c;/0B7/hBfocx'/3;c^"g%O

oc;/0B7/h/]‡b@7 v"$%  Á O'$h^\Xc;/0B7'84…/pQ384S4O'TUnl$m7'ML'$7'7<< "o

/a:H7;c;/0BBU\X"';$7'Q3Xq7'2wx'z(7'"$“BN&¤6…84S4O'TUV'I '()*+,-*:cn./4S4O'TUV'AB7'/a:H~&c^”/B84S4O'TUnl$m7'ML'$7'7<< "\XiHÇQ~2mˆsh8~4•8:H¡ À,7 FA)˜,OAB7'rBOÌ•sh81l>8:H¡

@3o®44~B7'84S4O'TU‡D5W$f'g7'W$f'ghI6./01,-?AH7cgHOW$X/%7'Wl>/•\X”/4B1'84S4O'TUnl$m7'ML'$7'7<< "o

d$h/Ãd;^@3_qB3'8ˆ2b84h/¢'c;/0B,7Icnc;/0B7'AL'g`07'¤47'$41JDg)y/fc;/0B7'>$+-'Y;20-';Q3Xd2wµ "$“BN&W$X/%7'/aN6…/-/¬c/Dc;/0B7'

AL'g`07'" #$%&¤6…847JBfd'M4%7%

;&

o;-.(#*%+&

kF8,[03<SN7'Io˜7(7 c‡b84S4O'TUV'AB7'Q4BNOo”/4B1d'2mˆsh;8~4•8:H¡ À,7 Fod$h/Ãc^c;/0BOd;^F¾0h.q%:7'jAkBfg7c^Xq7'2wx'CM%&zshc;/0O$cx'Icn

8b203/3Œ1/B{23?'8ZN:7/hQ~SB7@3./4S4O'TUV'j^ki1?”/4B1'84S4O'TUV'jGky #$&/:~5\Xc^$X'g%7'AB7'”/BjGkÍl$m7'ML'$7'7<< "i•sh8~4•8:H¡

 À,7j FkA)˜,OAB7'˜,B°i•^8~4•8:H¡ À,7j FKke4fc^‘$K3 B9*8=8, ; 9*7=8,C - B9*7=8,C

cn8~4• FK #i%OŽn…>^™gBN3/3$:XcgHOM4•9*7=7k;9*7=8k$•’,ˆ;

Žn/£/&gBN3/4,07'jA);805/w/[&^$4%,7i}~B-'cshc;/0B&j^k;^7

W2~,7Ž;?'F 8,%:7'Ak/-/¬c^‘ 9*7=7, ) 9*8=8, ) 9 *7=8,IJDc^9*7=7k;9*7=8kc/…gH4U<0h/O@&ZD'(Ã$4%7''Enš%b;'En’…/DW$X/%7'j7kW$X/•W®4¡ŽnÌ•^$f@H¡j I@3;

8b>/r-'Œ…^/3$:X^$ZOW$X/%7'7c;/0B7/hc‡b8~4%7'/4…$7' À,7j Fk@7cgHO8~a3Ik

Page 236: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 236/248

!&* "#$%&

cgHO84S4O'TUn5W$f'g7'W$f'gh6\X'()g+:7'/]?W>/X/3c;/0BOi1?A 3 /ot/]^dc;/0BOQ384S4O'TUnl$m7'ML'$7'™gUW23W$f';oš%b/a:H7;c;/0BO\X

"';$7'Q384S4O'TUn5W$f'g7'W$f'gh6™2w?'I<ZO845267'847/B7'c^$X'g%7'864,7'jz^˜,OAB7'@7cgHOy;^@3l$m&\X

«q¬V'kA)FQ•';23?'2}D^Wl$•@3$X'g%7'™2w?'\X8&/Î/aN6…^@3

”/4B1d'\X$&./0~>'2b?'I'()*+,-+:'EnC@H&@3@H~-'”/4B1'84S4O'TUn8:403@3iZ•>2bo$f';

¤4,b@3@H~-'c^/af/B¢z^Q~c/D@3>'2b?'I./01,-‘@3i1^c^@H~B&Q  # ~W$X/%,77j^k@3”/4B1'²g~³|/HU

W$X/%,78jGkod$hc^cgH& F @ /e4+hc^ F9*7=7, + */ ; F, 9 *7=8, ) 9

*8=8,I@H7;'En’…/DW$X/%7'8jGkW$X/•o8647 §'En9 *7=7, ? 9 *8=8,I$•;ƒZˆ^23?'\X'()g+:7'c?9*8=8,3#-*/40koA);\X^8~4•@H~&ygr'

/a4,X/3$:X"g%&Xq7'2wx'"'$“BU/h84S4O'TUV'/aN6…I/]n8~4%7'=D?' \X?';/-/¬c^# ) *% + &,-.IJhc^9*7=7,? 9*8=8ko@H~& À7j^k7c^”/B\XiHÇQ~š%b'Enc/D9*7=8, ) 9*8=8,I@H7;'()/&;/N384S4O'TU¯7j^k7

A);"g%Oi06h”/4B1d'o/)>26~hz^JDg7/]^/)$fg7Ii3/0BOKL/B:7'84L/a:7'Q3"/9…A%¬/:3iX/6B&Œ4bcgZXq7'Q3M]'1š%bIF

iDi41@3oy/41?'%,B&iDXd81l>”/S…A)FQ•'g7'y #$03™gBN3ŒL'>^Q3Œ…'1IMp'EnƒZˆ^™$7Xq7' ºl/1;^<:p'@¡M)2}D^o/f/S…y #g+B4U

Xq7'g+…84S4O'TUV'2}D?'/f/S…™$7c'‰'j;^l/BÏ'l/4Bw'/4L'g`X@3<h i[b^./4S4O'TUV'Fy/f>g1;šh'l<hc'‰'2}D?'/f/S…IkJD$B°M4)/63”/4B1d'l'2%BUd';i~`B78~9…?'84%¬/:-'\Xg+:7'‚/B7'‘

¨Tb'c^'>2b'$f';"$“BN&84S4O'TUV'j^k;^7$•iw>F$f';@3Q•'g-'"g%&iD>2bŒ4b"'$“BU/h84S4O'TUV'jGk8I@H~&€2~,7c^yg%&c^84S4O'TUV'j^k

Page 237: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 237/248

'2*34,- 5/()*+,- 67 80-*9 !&+

$•’f/B1'84S4O'TUV'jGk'En/3y #gžiDQ•g3FM4,•V'g+…84S4O'TUV'j^kF8&/]Y/-'I‚/B7/h;@H~&€2~,7c^yg%&c^84S4O'TUV'jGkW2%BN3/4~4,•n'EnC

@H~BO8&^84S4O'TUn@3/);®t/af/4B1';/4~4,•nI'();/…>g%&Žn8S4B…8&g•A)‘

'()*+,-":'En’…/DW$X/%7'W2%BN3o/4X/RAab‚/B7/hW2%BN3/4~4,•nI$•;AX Ác/)=7'\X'()23?'Fir67'@3/}7'F8~9…?'84%¬/:-'84:Z-'\X

$X'g%7'8,4BN-'Ic/XÐ;/3M  # ~0  Á &c/)=7'*Z:47\XQ4R8~9…?'84%¬/:-'AB7'dQB~BO™gBN~hy/X@3˜UJB7'„w'$7'IŒ:H7;*Z:&iH`hÑ/w\Xz^"/9…®4~B&

84ˆ/“h8:403e4+hŒ…^iH7o8%…$1g&_/:) ºl/1l/‰2wµ dcgH&/Ò/B38%:,784,ˆ?'I

ƒ   # 5g&;˜7Ec^8&J'@32w”/4B1d'A)\Xi•?'8,aUF"/9:7'A%¬/:-'i}~h/aB7gaUFM,9…´qBwd'2'I@H~&;yg%7'csh@3<3/[-'8~a-'/:)A)c^

c;/0B7'y>/ZB-'@H~&c^2~BN&"'$BN&;F"/9:7'84%¬/:-'jz(7'dMNB&™gBN~hy/X @3šh'T7'kiH`hiaUA)/[&87gaUœl'2~BU'Œ3';>;F"/9…´qBwd'2'I 

Page 238: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 238/248

!&" "#$%&

 

Page 239: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 239/248

 !"#$%&

 

!"#$%&' ()&*+,"!"#$! #$%&'() *+&,)- ./+,) 01231 4 01231- 0356() 23'7,-89() :7;< =>-.,) 03>7? @A 09:7&B3C,) 03DEFG) H> I3J2;9K,) ./+,) IL M+N,) ")-./0123'456&7 )$82+4"

%"9'5$% (5-:$;</,"!"#!" O-.B3P) 0Q3R,) ST$ "=5&>&2:0?>,4"&"@ @5$A*>5 (5-:$;</,"!"#$"BCDE*FG, =&3;/, 5&H'4 IJA:"K0Q3R,) STU, 0975V,) 0U').P) 

03>2W5,)- '( &%'*+&"$"L M$N,OP ()&;2/,"!"#!" :).X,) .Y7' "9*Q&70)4,O7 (R*2/"'"S LO745 (L5,"!",+" Z[) \) ] :).? 4  ^3_)- ):2>25B> ")&*Q&70)4,O7 (R*2/","T&' (U54&V,"!"+-"`ab25c) d.D !"!# !"#$"% e2WJ &  ^3U9 f*g hb- ^$ ! "=5&>&2:0

O>$%4 WX&N"#"LO745 (@4O32;+,"!"#-"0123V,) i 2j2X3R;<- 0N?25&P) \)8Yk) 09.WJ `l,2mP) h)n "

&P$<2V0M$+5$%"+" ........... / !"#""BYZF$[\3/ T]^_/, `2a&*/,"K03P2U,) 0123V,) &!( %%+*$,""" ........... / !"+-bc"dBef;/, Y3g_% h 6$_[/, 5$2*iG,"K0To p2$)q5,) rD %$( &*

%'"!-" ........... / !"+-j"Bef;/, Y3g_% h Y2/$_k Ol+c 5$2*i,"K0To p2$)q5,) rD 

%$(&#"*$-&"!!" ........... / !"+!"Be2:$:m, e7 )4$_*/, 5&no"K 73C9: Z5921 s2B3&3,7L t2B9.>u  

#'(&-,*!+"!%"@ M$2/44 (LO745 (@4O32;+,")&*32%$N"!"+!"B)4$_*/, IJA:"K0  v To Z5921 %!!( !&"-*","!&"#4 (j (C<;[>$7"p"OPq7"!"#$"BL,4r s$;./, -.D Y2:,4-_/,4 )4$_*/,4 L,t/$7 Y2ug*/,

v.w, 54@ 6&x Y[3*yX, L$nF&*/,"K #$%&'() ZC5,) ST$- 03mwx,) yzJ !( %",*"+"!$"# p5$P (O<27"!"#,"BY2.2w, Ya$23/,4 Y2:$:m,4 5$l>z,0s$2xm, {3D4 @$|*aG, {3D

CDE*FG,"K{b2m&?() dbk) 0To !$( +!#*%,"

Page 240: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 240/248

$#% :b2mP)

!'"6 p45 (On27"!"+!"B,Oi} )&n.> )&~2H/, •$yVm, 0 $:$2xc"Kp2$)q5,) rD 0To %'(

%+"*&--"!,"S (j&+ )&*327"!"!," |EVT, 23Y ")-./0€$+4 )&'5,@ (O:@5$P W3>4"!#"@ ({n3*27"4"!"#'"B‚HQ&/, $2^>Okƒ h T4$_*/, =&3;/, „D …>O8*/, q†J'"K ZC5,) ST$ 0To 

03,-8,) !-( %!"*%$"!+"= @5$A*>5 (W*27"!"+%"}g2RP) e7/~) 4  #$2•8,) M3;w&,) i €-:b "‡ p@ (9H.V,40

W8.2+4O7 -n_%" !""=]7*j&<>$F (@&A2%"!"#'"0XFE&P) y7X,) 4 az,)- M17&P) .R,) 0X;5> i ‚)8U,) M1-k) "@5&[;+4,0R>&+]7 R>ˆ$7"

%-"M ‰27 (4]7"!",+"BRD$[*/,0CDE*FG, 6@$~*/,"Kh03$%&'() e7TUT, 03P2U,) 0$717P) ( -3fX,#L$u[|/, ($'%*'#"=5&> &2:0v>O7 pOk4 )]2\+$%"

%!"S )G, (Š&7"$%4 (q/5$% 6&7 =5"!"#'"B#$./,4 ‹&[/, 6&x0`>&|'4 ?i,-/, 9<;/, (#O8:&</,!+%!Œ!+$%"K03123V,) e7TUT, 03B9.>k) 0T/P) !"( '",*,!%"

%%"5 6&74 (L&<Q ()$%5&7"`2[2/"!"+-" :2ƒ9G) 06):- ST$ "=5&>&2:0v>O7 2\>@$+,"%&"S W.[2*Q (W%,O7"(!"#'"B /, Y3g_%4 …%&+&2: Y3<A%ef; "K0To p2$)q5,) rD !"( '",*

,!%

"%$"j (O.V&7"!",'"09.„/P) 03<2R5,) p23NU&P) …> p2J)73†) ^92U< "=5&>&2:0v.>$Q‰:,"%'"LO745 (C[/$+"!"+!"BY2\23_*/, YQ5EX,4 hO_X, v[./, {3D"K@ h"#"O.2/q7bŽ^d(

{7L‡,) ˆR,) 0U').> (&*#&"‡ p@ (9H.V,40p&7‰/, u~3/ Y2<>O%m, Y2_\w,"%,"M (pq/4$+"!"'%" ^92U&,)- rC;&,) ")-./0)&;+$F4 >&82Q"%#"@ )$[>, (W>$A'"!"+-"BL$:,&2‘, -.D T4$_' ]/,4 T4$_*/, =&3;/,"K #B9.>k) 0U3R;,) ‰2$ 

!!'( +%#*'#"%+" ’N @5,4@, (=5]+"!"+-"0>2U,) …Š2NR,) *•7<- ‹T;,) H$ ŒxB,) " +#$% (S->“%$ 0"

O8.2/$7"

%""M @5$A*>5 (LO>$Q"S W\2F4 ("”'5$%"!",&"0[zT, 03[7TV,) 09.W5,) "(v[3+ @4&38:,)"S 0"v*.>O7*6&N"

&-"M e745 (ˆ4,@"!"+-"BY2DE*FG, Y3g_X,"K ZC5,) STU, 0975V,) 0U').P) &!( !,"*"&"&!"@5$A*>5 (W.+4,@"!"#," 2Jk) I_) "@5&[;+4,0@5&[;+c Y_%$F Y_~H%"&%"6 ?;2/ (.:4,@"!"#'"BL]<AX, R‘ ION$–+ ef;/, Y3g_% Y~_/0{yg' Yf2*:

q;[*/,"Kd2U,k)- y2[2P) ,&,,*"!"

Page 241: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 241/248

:b2mP) $#!

&&"S (R>,-P,@"!"&%"{)K>2[- f:2>.+J( "I-u*X, Y<3\X, (pq7ˆ40)&Q -:, :-3>,4"&$")&F (‰;3>,"!"#""`.R,) p29:7D- Z3V3,79 03JEX$E,)- 03JEXU,) i p21):b "

S->“%$+0S->“%$+ Y_%$F Y_~H%"&'"L 9[2*Q ()E3>,"!"#+"B5&2H/, e7 Y2:4$_*/, Y27‰/, IJA:"KS h"5"j #G&<2:4 v7O+"

 ()$^^ (W2[>,@ #[7TV,) 0Q3R,) ST$ 4  #Š2X<:) Ž„5> (%$'*+!"@5&[;+4,0R>&+]7"&,"c (R2A>,"!"##"B, q†J*/,Y>5$l>G, LE;/, s$^'5,4 vQ—X 0 CZ27 1n.%ŒC.2F"K‚23Dk) ST$ 

{.W5,) 2BV,) !!( $!-*%$

" &#"4 )&F (W:$[>,"!"#!"03B9.>k) y:2/&,) 01231 i {8353[ 0,7' "#$% (S->“%$+0"Y_~H%@5$k5$N Y_%$F"

&+"M LO745 (9P$k"!"+-"B{˜E‘, O%™*' $%-.D0h IO%-X, qP Y2/$*^/, L$<2*<*/, s$^'5,4 IJA:Y2˜,&A_/, qP YnF,&X, pr L$:,&2‘, š,› Sr&\:"K #B9.>k) 0U3R;,) ‰2$ !!'( +'+*,""

&""t73J-.>2B,) 0V>2c) 0R3&B,) "!"&,"&<Q]P0&+4 )&;+$F"$-"c •>5, (œ2k "!"+-"BS4,W*/, M$–: e7 Ya]_/,(Y2:$FOX, …_A/, \Q -.D Y.%,W*X, Y._/,4

 qJ2B9.+3J e)‡B3TL7R3Y bp,-2:,qQ"dK T,&2‘, =&3;/, %+( ,%-*&&"$!" 5 (œ2k "c"!"&-" #U3R;,) d2w&JE, 0353_) 09.W5,) "@5&[;+4,0@5&[;+4, Y_%$F Y_~H%"$%

"@ #4O7 (-/,qFW*2k "!"#'

"B5$l>z, 4c Y2',t/, Yu3|X,"K) rD 0To p2$)q5, !"( $,%*#"

bL$u[|/, (”23N4Ok )$%5&: 9% @5 %$+-Œ+&"d$&" 4 W\2F ()$%->Ok "!"#!"BY^˜$[/, j$_/ž/ T4$_' qP )ˆ,&'"K09b2m&?() p21):8,) 0U').> 

&+( !*!%"$$")$%5&: (-.>&A2P "!"#" "B pœ~/, R^_/, L$||Ÿ "K  #TU,) #B9.>k) %$!b@-_/,&0d

!+-Œ"""$'"()&32P#">5$' )4-7"0?.C,) 0m?  H9zU,)- 0U12&,) ")-./0W:$Q4 )&;32:"$,"LO745 (e~32P"!"+!"03,-8,) 0123V,) i *+&,)- d.†) "S->“%$+0S->“%$+ Y_%$F Y_~H%"$#"S (R>&.>OP"€"!"#%"d:2 …3‘: ")-./0e/ )G,"

$+"$.>5 (O74OP"!"#'"0598P) i ./g 4 03•2Xƒ,) ’%Jk) y23†) 83? “$ ‚2XR,)- ") ()&*;.>O7"S 0")&*;.>O7 Y_%$F Y_~H%"

$""S (),-/$N"j"#"!"''"B)$<;/, Y†,54 {3D"K898_) y23†) ST$ !+( &$*'!"'-"@ M$23>4 ()&*32%$N"!",&"Bp5$l>G, =&3;/, IJA:"K #B9.>k) 0U3R;,) ‰2$ "#( &'$*',"'!" ........../ !",$"B 3;3/ C.2w, 5&H*/,CDE*FG, =& "K{.W5,) y23†) ST$ 0To #( !*!,

4!#*&%"

Page 242: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 242/248

Page 243: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 243/248

:b2mP) $#&

,+"#$%&' (W7&N"!,'!"t26292C3, "=5&>&2:0(v+&7 q/&+ Y_~ª!",$",""5 #]P4@ (O'$*;k&N"!"+&"BOu;/, s,54 $% LE2†0j$_/ž/ ef;/, Y3g_% LG&H7

 Y2:4‰</G,)4$_*/, JA.> «2+ ¬‰^'"Kt2B9.>u C&5921 %$+b@-_/,'0d!, 0 %,"#-"4qn2V ($>&Q&N"!",+"BYD@,O/, YQ$2;/, h L$7$;‘, s&Q0(Y2<>O%m, Y2:$7$2/, L$a]_/,

!"&+Œ!"$!"K eEV,) ›2Lu 0To %( "#*!!'"#!"Rf2: (@54$N"!",,"Bj$_/m, s,54 $% L$2$>5"K0>2U,) 0WJk) !!b@-_/,'0d!+#Œ%--"#%

" ........ / !"#!

"03JEXU,) p2N?25< 4  œ23V,) f7TV,)- d2U,k) ‚):- 2> 09.WJ "(S@“%$+ #$%0"M, Y_~H%"pc"®"#&"Ž^ ($+$'&7&: (>,"!",#! e2U, 0123V,) p).ž> pE/1 `d.†) s7Ÿb t2L23,) :).? 

!"#! "$2:5&[2/$+ (@5&[:$*Q0Y_%$F Y_~H%$2:5&[2/$+"#$" ’N 6$2:,@ (9>W:$F"!",,"B$<>O%c h $2Q$+G, IOfV4 R\./, e7 Y2/@$~*/, h =‰AX, s$^'5G,

‚HQ&/,"K‚2X<:()- yx5,) %-( %$"*#'"#'" ........ / !"#""Be' IO\† )&<' «2+"K03W5,)- 0Q3R,) STU, 0975V,) 0U').P) !-( !&*'%"#,"j (W8..2F"5"!"#+"B V 6$H7cT$l/, ¯$_/, h j&Q$‘, 1:OH "K}92L &bO>$.>d( !-+*!+"##"LO745 (vkqF"!"#,"03,-8,) 0123V,) i f):bG) ‚71- f):bG) ") ()&*;.>O7"S 0"Y_~H%

)&*;.>O7 Y_%$F"#+" ........ / !"#+"B9%m, Y3g_% Ro h )4$_*/,"K03P2U,) 0123V,) &-( !,#*%!$"#""4 W/5$A' (W:&F"!"##"B°#O8:&</, ¬]±z, q82Q RNK# v:5&/ h"c #4O74 @4@"

)$^^ (O\>$n.74," €.+J7B,) i .W5,) yb2$A "=5&>&2:0O²,O7"+-"@ (?2+"¢"!"&-"&" ).„– ")-./0e7 `;:5,"+!"9;+&7 )&',OP4 (-/$:4@ (>O.2+"!"#%!I3L:-k) ./+,) :8? "=5&>&2:0v+&7 ;>$7"+%"p (e7&+"!"&!" “$k) .>k) ")-./0“>$k -:, “>$k"+&"p$+@5&% (ˆ5&+"!"##"Bp5$l>G, )ˆ,&*/,"K()$^^ ()&;32: @5$A*>54 $Q]27 ]27 h :7;&,) 

0>2U,) 0123V,)- `03mwx,) S3X,)- `{b2m&?() (!##*%--"M,@‰;%c0-:G&N U5&:"

+$"M M$2/4 (ˆ-:G"c @5$A*>54 ("O.Q&7"!"#+c"Bh 5$l>z,@$|*aG,4 )&:$^/,"Kb2m&?() 0U').>   #B9.>k) ,+( $!#*%!"+'" ....... / !"#+j"B)4Oi} )4t^.%4 ()&~2H/, )&>O%$;/, ()4-F,&/, ()&|3yX,0YQ,5@

5$l>z, )&:$^/ Y>@$|*a,"K03J7J2X,) p21):8,) 0To #( +&*!%+"+,"R<>$% (OkG"!"##"B³;~% Sr&\: (C´m, )4$_*/, 6&x L$%&<‘, e7 Y+‰AX, YQ$2;/,

Y2~>µ/, Yg>$^\3/"K03123V,) ›2L¡, 03L-:-k) 0T/P) '( &,&*+-"

Page 244: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 244/248

Page 245: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 245/248

:b2mP) $#'

!-,"5 @5$A*>5 ()&;32:"S T-2Q ("‰.>4"!"+%"{b2m&?() *+&T, ‚2X<:)- yxJ 09.WJ "(S@“%$+#$%0"@5$k5$N Y_%$F Y_~H%"

!-#"¢ p@45 (qP->$:"!"#+"B®,t/, ¼yA/, ·2\3*/, Ok&'4 L$%&3_X, Yw$_% h -2^_*/, q†J'YFW*\X, k,4-/, L,r Y~_3/, h Cf2',‰Qz, …_3/, „D"Kš&~H% qP"

!-+" ...... / !"#$"Bh -2^_*/,…_3/, =&3Q4 L$%&3_X, Yw$_%0ef;/, Y3g_%"K STU,)  #[7TV,) !"( %-$*!-"

!-"

"97G, 5&|.% ()&;/4,"!",'

" #U_) rUC,) ¥;5> "#$% (S@“%$+0"@5$k5$N Y_%$F Y_~H%" !!-"M (¢&/54,"S "!"##"B)$ª½/,4 j5$am, s$^*:,"K0To {.W5,) y23†) ST$ ,'( ,-'*#"!!!"()$%5&: (9>$*;2:54,6 LO745"4 -2[>@4 (p@&~27"@45"!"##"Bq8*X, ¾&2A/, v3¿09%

9>œ_/, )O^/, h L$2.2_~;/, ¦ƒ L$2.2;\º,"K# v:5&/ h"c #4O74 @4@"(O\>$n.74, ()$^^ €.+J7B,) i .W5,) yb2$A "=5&>&2:0O²,O7"

!!%"L5,&2*Q (…%$<Q4,"!"#!"Bef;/, Y3g_% h )4$_*/, „D Y¿“X, L$2f2',‰Qz, L,q†J'YH3*yX, k,4-/, L,r ¨Oic j$_/,4"K0To p2$)q5,) rD !'( %%'*%""

!!&" ’N (`Q$+Ok4,"=&/&' )@5&P4 (9>4@,"!"#!"BI5O<*X, ef;/, Y3g_X ?$[' 1n.%!™

 :).X,)- 09.W5,) !( &'-*'+"!!$

"S (O+5$7"c"!"#+

"B 2w,=&3;/, «22<'4 (Y2˜$^'5G, L$.2w, (Y2:$:m, L$. "K0  v To

0U3R;,) %#$( +$"*''"

!!'"R>&2%$Q ()&QO'$7"!"#+"BR^*;X, ¤~V #O8:&</,"K(Ž^ (.+ T&l:c h œ23V,) e2W5,) 898_) #B9.>k) "‡ p@ (9H.V,40C<>O%m, š4œX, -n_%"

!!,")&;32: (C~;/&7"!",+"B ./, v3¿ Y2'$;Q—%C<>O%m, j,& "K œ23V,) STU,) 0U').>  #B9.>k) ,%( !$$*,+"

!!#"@ 5-:$;<2/,4 (=5$% (C.V$*7"4 65$+4 ()&;:&F"&7$7"!"+%"B#4qk h C.2F R>&¥pq*<7"K˜C&5921 t2[*>u  %$#b@-_/,'0d!%+Œ$-"

!!+"j $†q7 ($:$*.>&+"->&3k p,OP v>&/4 ("!"#%"{./+,) ˜,¦ '23J2R1) d75' i ./+,) "

=5&>&2:0)&*;.>44 L5$n.>,5 (`/&N"!!""@5,4$N ($[>,5"!",+" :).X,) r3T§ "#$% (.>->50")&;>@,*¶W>4"!%-"6&'$:, (L5&7&7,5"!",-!p(2/1- `d2U,)- `p2$)n "O7, ),0)$8A*2% Y_%$F Y_~H%"!%!" ...... / !",#"B¡a$.*/, 9% j4O§,"K˜C&5921 t2[*>u  %!#b&2/&>0d'-Œ',"!%%"M L“/,4 (6&'$:, (L5&7&7,5"€$%$A'"!",'"I/V,) 0TNU> "O75, )} 0Y_%$F Y_~H%

)$82A*2%"

Page 246: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 246/248

$#( :b2mP)

!%&"¢ v>&2/ ()&Q@5$A*>5"!",-" H>k) t)8X•- |EV,) "&P$<2V0R8:,5@,&+"!%$"S «2*Q4 (M$2/4 (O<>5"W%,O7"!"#&"BY27$y*:G, L,&±m, s, ¡a$.'"K STU,) 0U').> 

 œ23V,)  #B9.>k) ,#( !%&'*$#"!%'"=$F )$F (&Q45"!#,%" #$%&'() 8XU,) "=5&>&2:0pc Y_~ª"À"()&',@!"'-"!%,"Ž^ (9>4, (O',5"!"&$"Y_7$;/, Y~2*</, >5$' b L$%-º, d  #BTP) ZB121 ”7• !"!# !

"#"#")-./0YD$~H3/ W\>$' Y+"!%#

"6 -2[>@4 («2*Q ($.2*>5")$P5&%"!"+%

"BY2DE*FG, L$a]_/, j$;x {3D0«.|/, Ri,-' Y<~A/,4"K h%&'() STU, 03B9.>k) 0T/P) ++( ++*!!&"!%+"c 6&7 (9;/&2%$Q"!"#&"b2m&?() ST$ "=5&> &2:04O8+$%*R2N"!%""@ (12k$Q"#"!"##"B¤'$74O<2%4 «2gX, e7 L]D$['"K5 h"L"S "L4 =5]+"

 ()$^^ (j&V&70Q3R,) ST$ ‚2U>¡, O-.B3P) (%##*&!-"=5&> &2:02\>@$+, Y_~H%"!&-"# #$%&' (.232V"!",-" h)¤,) 03/3<)‡1A "#$% (S@“%$+0"@5$k5$N Y_%$F Y_~H%"!&!" ...... / !"#&"B5$n./, s& qk&'4 (IJ~yX, Yu3Qm,4 (C+&§, r&i0L,5$2*iG, h YQ,5@

Y2F5$º, L,q†J*/, L,r Y2˜$.l/,"K0To p2$)q5,) rD !#(&+!*$%+"!&%" ...... / !"#+"BON$–/, =&3;/,4 ,-F Iq8|/, k,4-/,"KŽ^ (.232V #$%&' h` …•)-8,) 

 .Y2W,) f7TV,)- )8' y*+m,) ("*$&

"=5&>&2:0)&'5&:"!&&"L )&F (W/&V"!"+&"B5$~Fz, Y3g_%4 (Y2\2–.*/, YD$H/,4 ()4$_*/,"Kh Y%-^% Ya54

 “\*~Q (Y2Q$2;/, M&3_3/ Y2<>O%m, Y2_\f3/ p&.;/, šE*FG,!*$&P$<2V ("!&$" ’N M&/$V (W'5,&V"!"##"B5$l>z, „D Y>5$2_X, L,q†J*/,"K(Ž^ (W*k&+q7 @5$:&2/ h

 ./&,) #$%&'() ZC5,) ST$ i p):7;<  ~>  C (!-( %%!*#""!&'" ’N R2: ()$n2V"p4 ("4")$^^ (C†O>&.2+"!"#!"t7g2&5R,) a):-u  "=5&> &2:0v+&7 W\>$'"!&,"9'5$% (27&V"!"'""a7V,) 035L- 03/3<)‡1G) "=5&>&2:0?>,4"!&#" ....... / !"#-"Bef;/, Y3g_% ¡a$.'4 (=&3;/,4 (Y~_3/, Y>O–:06&3x Y†]†"K0To  rD 

p2$)q5,) !$( !+!*"$"

!&+"c LO7qN ()&\>$Q"!"''"BT]^_/, 5$2*i]/ C+&3Q Sr&\:"K STU, 03TmC,) 0T/P)  b2m&?() ,"( ""*!!+"!&""@5$>$7 `>OP5$% (2\Q"!"-,! H;5–)- …&/P @-k) t7UL:k) p)75V,) "=5&>&2:0

ˆO.~>O<Q"!$-" ’N e3P (5->$.Q"!"#!"3 1ef;/, Y3g_%2SrE:41YF$F-/,2Y2/4-/, YQ$2;/, h"K0T/P) 

03,-8,) p21):8,) 03TmC,) !'( ,,*!-&"

Page 247: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 247/248

:b2mP) $#)

!$!"W/5$A' (¶5&Q"!"!""¨:71 q,:2x< rŠ21: "S@“%$+0S@“%$+ Y_%$F Y_~H%"!$%"c R<>$% (v.~Q"!"#$"a7V,) p):2–A "#$% (S->“%$+0"@5$k5$N Y_%$F Y_~H%"!$&"j (¸>$*Q"j"!"#""B(¸.w, 6$|'G,4 (Y7,O^/,5$[x 5&2ª -.D Y2DE*FG, YZA.*/,4

Á&3~/, OfV"K #$%&'() ‚23DG) ST$- #[7TV,) 0Q3R,) ST$ ,( '&*,,"!$$"Lq+ ()q*Q"!"#&"09zR,) 06):7,) ©b2R> "&<;2;:,Ok )$Q09%ˆO>$k"!$'" ’N (=$7W/&Q"!"#&"03J2Pk) ab25R,) …> ")-./0O7&+&2/"!$,

")} (-:G5t†$Q"!"#'

"`./+,) t73Cc) t73B9.>k) "=5&>&2:0v>O7 pOk" !$#"e/5$% (p,&Q"!"+-"BOf8/,4 …>O83/ R\2Q M&n[%"K #$%&'() STU,) p2>7TU> !+( $!*

'-"!$+"5 e/ (v<>$Q"¢ =$F4 ("9>@Ok,"!"+%"BR%$V p4&: 5$~*i, O–x L$~†c"K #B9.>k) 

 #TU,) %$#b@-_/,$d( $#*'-"!$""R<>$% (O3>$'"!"#," ª7C,) t-2U&,)- "=5&>&2:0?>,4"!'-"@5$A*>5 …232k ()&;~%&†"!"+-"B1°p5$F &N 9%42Y2˜$^'5G, Y†,5&/, 9% j,&F"K

 #$%&'() STU,) p2>7TU> !"( &$!*'$"!'!"L ()$%->$'"=&/&' )@5&P4 (#G&<2:"!"#,"BL,5$2º, r$Ÿ$7 M$2^3/ Y2a,54 I->-F Y23\D

Y2DE*FG,"Kb2m&?() 0C3F  œ23V,) +$

0!!$' 0 +$

"!'%"M @5$A*>5 (#E*2'"!"#!"098~) 0?E$ 4 03$%&'() 0123V,) @A {zR,) e8,) H> "=5&>&2:0

#4$N M4-:,5"!'&"6$A2% ()$%W>O'"!"+-"B5&2H/, T$Pc L$f§ U4-‘ 5$~*iG, ¬4 h L$7&_|/, ¡_7"K

 )73†) f7TV,) %+( &!!*!%"!'$"6 LO745 (ˆO[>,O'"!"#!"B6@$~*X, 5$l>z, s$^'5,4 IJA:"Ky23†) STU, 03TmC,) 0U').P) $,(

&'*'#"!''"5 v>&/ (O+$'"!"#+"BYZ2~/$7 {*nX, 9ª,&X,0L$:,‰aG, ¡_7"Kf7TV,)- 0Q3R,) !-( &+"*

$!+"

!',"# (v2:$kG$k"!"'+"Bk$.X, RD$[*' $%-.D š,W./, Rx"Kp2$)q5,) rD 0To %( %',*,""!'#"R<>$% (->,4S ")->O7 v<232k4 ("!"+-"BT$:m, =&3;/,4 ”8/, IJA:"K #[7TV,) 0Q3R,) ST$ 

 #$%&'() y23†) ST$- #( !,#*#%"!'+"y2xP) 2„•.$ #&,) d.†) "!"&+")-./0j"#".+"!'""{F‰% (v<>5 (O:5,4"!",-"03L.†) ¤3? p2X3TU< "=5&>&2:0I->-w, Y2<>O%m, Y~*<X,"!,-"S (W~>4"L"!"#,"B5&7-/,4 e*/, h u~3/ q|a >5$'"K q59b:2g 0To bI5&k$8.Q0d%-#Œ&%"

Page 248: The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

8/13/2019 The Evolution of Cooperation BY ROBERT AXELROD نشوء التعاون روبر أكسيلرود

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-evolution-of-cooperation-by-robert-axelrod- 248/248

$#* :b2mP)

!,!"# S5&F (W%$2/4"!",," #U3R;,) ‚2X&J()- Œ3B&,) ") ()&*;.>O7"S 0"Y_%$F Y_~H%