The Ethical and Lawful Board of Trustees California ...The Ethical and Lawful Board of Trustees...
Transcript of The Ethical and Lawful Board of Trustees California ...The Ethical and Lawful Board of Trustees...
TheEthicalandLawfulBoardofTrusteesCaliforniaCommunityColleges
Contents Chapter1 OverviewofEthicsandLawsChapter2 CodeofEthicsChapter3 HandlingLegalandEthicalViolationsChapter4 ResourcesandReferencesCompiledbyDr.CindraSmithusingresourcespreviouslypublishedbytheCommunityCollegeLeague.Chapter1and2areadaptedfromChapter7intheLeague’sTrusteeHandbook.Chapter3isadaptedfromBoardFocus,Winter2006.
CommunityCollegeLeagueofCalifornia2017OStreet,Sacramento,CA95811www.ccleague.org2016
TheEthicalandLawfulBoardofTrustees CommunityCollegeLeagueofCaliforniaCaliforniaCommunityColleges 2
Chapter 1. Overview of Ethics and Laws Thetitleof“trustee”assumesamoral,ethical,andlegalobligationtofulfilladutytoprotectthecommunitycollegedistrictandservethepublicgood.Thepublicandthecollegemustbeabletotrustthemembersofthegoverningboardtodowhatislegalandethicaltoensurethesuccessoftheinstitutioninmeetingtheneedsofstudentsandthecommunity.Beinglegalmeanscomplyingwiththelawsandregulationsthatapplytocollegeboardsandelectedofficials.Ethicsreferstomoralresponsibilitiesandmaygobeyondlegalconsiderations.Ethicsarestandardsofrightandwrong,goodandbad.Ethicsaddresswhatoneoughttodotofulfillone’smoralduty.Beingethicalandlegalinvolvesmorethanunderstandingwhattherightthingistodo;itmeansthatonemustperforminethicalandlegalways–onemustactively“walkthetalk.”First,onedetermineswhatisrightorwrong,goodorbad.Then,onedoeswhatislegal,right,good.
Ethical Values TheethicalvaluesdescribedbelowarefromtheJosephsonInstitute,andarecalledthe“SixPillarsofCharacter”(seewww.josephsoninstitute.org).Thepillarsaretrustworthiness,respect,responsibility,fairness,caringandcitizenship.Trustworthiness.Whenwearetrustworthy,peoplebelieveinus.Beingtrustworthyrequireshonesty,integrity,reliability,andloyalty.Beinghonestmeanswearesincere,truthful,straightforward,andthatweavoiddeception.Itmeansnotviolatingconfidentiality,beinguncivil,ormakingpromisesthatonemightnotbeabletokeep.Integrityrefersto“wholeness.”Apersonwhohasintegrityisconsistentindecision-makingandbehavior,andbaseshisorherbehavioronacoresetofethicsorvalues.Reliabilitymeanswekeepourpromises.Ifwecommittoatask,wefollowthrough.Ethicaltrusteesspendthehourseachweekthatarerequiredtoperformthejobwell.Loyaltymeansprotectingandpromotingtheinterestsofpeople,agroupororganization.Asatrustee,theprimaryloyaltyistothecollegeandthepublicgood—loyaltytofriendsandinterestgroupsissubordinateregardingcollegebusiness.Respect.Thesecond“pillarofcharacter”isrespect.Itincludescivility,courtesy,decency,autonomy,andtolerance.Civilityandcourtesyareparticularlyimportantwhenengagingindiscussionswithotherswithwhomwedisagree.Autonomymeansthatwedonottrytoliveothers’livesforthem. Tolerancemeanswe
FourQuestions
Tohelpdetermineethicalbehavior,ask:
AmIdoingtootherswhatIwouldwantdonetome?WouldImindseeingwhatIamdoingonthefrontpageofanewspaper?AmIcomfortablewithmembersofmyfamilyknowingwhatIamdoing?DoIwantmybehaviortobeamodelforemployeesandstudents?
TheEthicalandLawfulBoardofTrustees CommunityCollegeLeagueofCaliforniaCaliforniaCommunityColleges 3
acceptothers’perspectivesandjudgeothersonlyontheircoreethicalvalues.Responsibility.Responsibilitymeansbeingwillingtomakedecisionsandchoicesandtobeaccountablefortheiractionsandwords.Responsiblepeopledonotshifttheblametoothers.Responsibilitymeansdoingthebestonecan,andbeingdiligent,careful,prepared,andinformed.Itmeanspersevering,followingthrough,andfinishingtasksthatonehaspromisedtodo.Responsibilityalsoinvolvesself-restraint,prudence,andrecognizingtheimportancetosetagoodexample.Responsibletrusteesrecognizethattherearesomelimitsonsayingordoingwhateveronewantsto,becausepeoplelooktothemasrepresentativesofthecollege.Fairness.Thefourthpillar,fairness,involvesequality,impartiality,opennessandusingdueprocess.Exhibitingfairnessinvolvesusingopenandimpartialprocessesforgatheringandevaluatinginformation,sothateventhosewhodisagreewithadecisioncanunderstandhowitwasmade.Itmeansseekingequityandavoidingfavoritismorprejudice.Caring.Caringmeansthatwearegenuinelyconcernedaboutthewelfareofothers.Aspublicofficials,wecareaboutthecommongoodandwelfareofthecommunity.Publiceducationisabenevolentactandexpressescaringforthepublicwell-being.Trusteesareoftenaskedtocareaboutmanydifferentpeople–communitymembers,students,faculty,andothers.Benevolenceasatrusteeinvolvesseekingthewell-beingoftheentirecommunity.Challengesarisewhendecisionsmustbemadeforthebenefitofthepublicwelfarethatmaynotmeettheneedsofspecificgroups.Caringtrusteesunderstandthosechallenges,andrealizethattheirrolerequiresfocusingonthepublicgood.Becausewecareaboutotherpeople,wecareaboutbeingethical,aboutbeingrespectful,responsible,andtrustworthy.Beingunethicaliseasierifwedonotcareaboutothers.Citizenship.Thefinal“pillar”iscitizenship,whichinvolveshowwebehaveaspartofacommunity.Ethicalcitizensobeylaws,contributetothecommunitythroughserviceandleadership,andprotecttheenvironment.Citizenshipisconcernedwiththefuturehealthandwelfareofsociety.Trusteeshipisanexpressionofcivicleadership,andtheethicsoftrusteeshipreflectgoodcitizenshippractices.Codes of Ethics VirtuallyallboardsoftrusteesinCaliforniaCommunityCollegeshavehadacodeofethics(orstandardofpractice)aspolicy.Theserulesofconductorstandardsofpracticearebasedonaboveethicalvalues.Havingandlivingbysuchacodeisgoodpractice,andhasbeenastandardoftheAccreditingCommissionforCommunityandJuniorCollegessincetheearly1990’s.Chapter2inthisresourceguidecoversmoreondevelopingandmaintainingauseful,effectiveethicalcodeforboards.
TheEthicalandLawfulBoardofTrustees CommunityCollegeLeagueofCaliforniaCaliforniaCommunityColleges 4
Legal Responsibilities Therearemanylawsandregulationsthataffectwhattheboarddoesandhowitconductsitself.Thestatutesthatdesignateboardresponsibilitiesarecoveredinchapter7oftheLeague’sTrusteeHandbook;otherchaptersrefertomanyrelevantlawsandregulations.Threemajorsetsoflawsthataffecttrusteesdirectlyarehighlightedbelow:conflictsofinterest,openandpublicmeetings,andpersonaluseofpublicresources.Conflicts of Interest Californiahastwosetsoflawsgoverningconflictsofinterestofpublicofficersandemployees.Thefirst,mostrestrictivestatutes,areinGovernmentCodesections1090,etseq.ThesecondisfoundinthePoliticalReformAct,atGovernmentCodesections81000,etseq.Thebasicintentofbothsetsofstatutesistoavoideventheappearanceofimpropriety.Thestatutesaddresspersonalintereststhatmaybeaffectedbythetrustee'sexerciseofhisorherofficialduties,includingpersonalinvestmentsandbusinesses,andtheemploymentoftrusteesandfamilymembersascollegeemployees.Inadditiontothelaws,trusteesshouldbeawareofactivitiesthatcreatetheperceptionoffavoritismorpersonalgain.Examplesofpotentialproblemareasarepreferentialtreatmentofothertrusteesorcollegestaff,selectivelysharinginformationwithonlycertainpeople,orinformallysteeringbusinesstoorseekingtohavefriendshired.Publicperceptionsthatboardmembersarefurtheringtheirowninterestsratherthanthoseofthedistrictharmthecollege.Beingsensitivetosituationsforpotentialconflicts,andseekinglegaladvicewhennecessarywillhelpavoidproblems.Itisimportantthatallpublicofficersandemployeesbeawareoftheselawsandtheirimplications,whichincludecriminalprosecutionsandbarsfromholdingfurtherpublicoffice.Conflictofinteresttraining(ethicstraining)isrequiredeverytwoyearsformanylocallyelectedofficials.ThetrainingisavailableonlineattheFPPCsitehttps://oag.ca.gov/ethics/courseandtheInstituteforLocalGovernmentsitehttp://www.ca-ilg.org/post/institutes-self-study-program-and-fppc-online-alternative.InpersontrainingisofferedbytheCommunityCollegeLeagueatthe:EffectiveTrusteeshipWorkshop,AnnualTrusteesConferenceandAnnualConventioneveryyear.FurtherinformationonconflictofinterestlawsispublishedinEthicsLawPrinciplesforPublicServants:KeyThingstoKnow,availablefromtheInstituteforLocalGovernment.Open and Public Meetings Statelawrequiresthatpublicboardsdotheirworkinpublic.Publicservicerequiresthatissuesaffectingthepublicaresharedanddebatedopenly.Doingsopromotestrustworthinessandreliability.TheBrownActcreatedtheprimarysetofstatutes(GovernmentCode54950-54961)thatgovernsthelegislativebodiesoflocalagencies.Communitycollegegoverningboards,academicsenates,andassociatedstudentgoverningbodiesareamongthegroupstowhomtheActapplies.Thelawscoverboardmeetingsandagendas,publicparticipation,andlimitsonhowboardsmaymeet.Theyprovideforholdingexecutiveorclosedsessionsonanumberofmatters,includingpersonnel,contractnegotiations,andlawsuits.Closedsessionsprotecttherightsofpersonnelandthecollege,anditisunlawfultorevealinformationdiscussedinthesesessions.
TheEthicalandLawfulBoardofTrustees CommunityCollegeLeagueofCaliforniaCaliforniaCommunityColleges 5
DetailsonBrownActprovisionsarecoveredinOpenandPublicIV,availablefromtheLeagueofCaliforniaCities.Use of Public Resources Boththelawandethicalconsiderationsprohibittheuseofpublicresourcesforpersonalbenefitandpoliticalactivity.Therefore,boardsusuallyhaveclearpolicieson,andtrusteesadheretotravelbudgetsandexpensereimbursementprovisions,andtheprohibitiononusingcollegeequipment,e-mailnetworks,supplies,andotherresourcesforpersonalreasons.LegalreferencesincludeEducationCode7054,7056,72423;GovernmentCode8314,andPenalCode424.Other Laws Therearemanyothercomplexlawsandregulationsthataffectthedistrictandboardresponsibilities.Keyareasinclude:
• electionsandcampaigns,• lawsuits,• auxiliaryorganizations,• fiscalmanagement,• confidentialityofrecords,• bondsandconstruction,and• personnel.
BoardsandCEOsshouldseeklegaladvicewhentheyhavequestions.Legal Advice Whileafewdistrictshaveanattorneyonstaff,mostdistrictsrelyoncountycounselorretainalawfirmorattorneytobeavailabletoanswerquestions.Nomatterwhethertheyareonstafforoncontract,collegeattorneysaretheretoadvisethedistrict.Heorsheisaresourcethatprovidesvaluableinformation,butisnotthedecision-maker.Attorneysareoftenpresentinclosedsessionsoftheboard,andshouldalwaysbetherewhendiscussingissueswithlegalimplications.Attorneysarenottheretoserveindividualtrustees.TrusteeswhohavelegalquestionsshouldworkthroughtheCEOand/orboardchairinseekingananswer.Whenboardsseeklegaladvice,theyshould:
• Planahead:giveattorneyssufficientleadtimetoprovideadviceonaquestion.• Askaboutlegalimplicationspriortomakingcertaindecisions:itiseasiertoprevent
problemsthansolvethem.• Beopenaboutallofthefactsofasituation,bothgoodandbad.• Acceptandexpectrealisticassessmentsofthelegalposition,includingoptionsandtherisk
involvedinvariousalternatives.• Understandthatlegaladvicetopublicinstitutionsisusuallyconservative,inordertoprotect
thepublictrust.• Getlegaladviceinwritingtoavoidmisunderstandings.• Avoidenteringintoadversarialsituations,ifpossible:lookforlong-termsolutionsto
problems.
TheEthicalandLawfulBoardofTrustees CommunityCollegeLeagueofCaliforniaCaliforniaCommunityColleges 6
Summary Toprotectthedistrictandfulfillthetrust,boardsmustfirstensurethattrusteesandthecollegeareawareofandadheretolawsandregulations.Threemajorlegalconcernsfortrusteesareconflictsofinterest,openandpublicmeetings,andpersonaluseofpublicresources.Legaladvicemaybenecessaryfromtimetotimeinordertoensurecompliancewithamyriadoflawsandregulations.Ethicalpublicserviceisbasedonadesiretodogoodforthecommunity.Ethicalbehaviorbytrusteesenhancesthevalueofthecollegeandsetsahighstandardfortherestofthecollege.Ethicalleadershipbytrusteesmakesitmorelikelythatthecollegewillfulfillitsmissiontothecommunity.Codesofethicsdefineinmoredetailforboardmembershowpublicserviceisbestexpressed,andarecoveredinthenextchapter.
TheEthicalandLawfulBoardofTrustees CommunityCollegeLeagueofCaliforniaCaliforniaCommunityColleges 7
Chapter 2. Codes of Ethics Trusteeshipbringswithitcertainresponsibilitiesandexpectations,manyofwhicharerelatedtobeinganelectedpublicofficial.Thepublicexpectsanddeservesthatitsrepresentativesstrivetoupholdhighstandardsintheperformanceoftheirduties.Codesofethics(or“standardsofpractice”astheyaresometimescalled)definespecificexpectationsforboardmembers.Itisimportantforboardstoclarifyforthemselves,thecollege,andthecommunity,whatbehaviortheythinkisappropriate.Itisnotenoughtoassumethatbecausesomethingislegal,thatitisethical.Norcananyoneassumethattrusteesknowhowtheyaresupposedtoactasboardmemberstheminutetheyareelectedorappointedtotheposition.Codesofethicsputinwritingwhatthe“oughts”areoftrusteeship.Theyaddressboardrolesandresponsibilities,andtrusteeconduct.Codesofethicsarepoliciesthatstatehowboardsandtrusteesshouldperformtheirresponsibilities.Theyareusedasreferenceswhentherearequestionsaboutspecificsituationsorbehaviors.Theyareusefultoolstoorientnewtrusteestotheirresponsibilities.Thepoliciesandpracticesinacodemayalsobeusedascriteriaforboardself-evaluations.AccreditationStandardIV.C.11states,inpart:“Thegoverningboardupholdsacodeofethicsandconflictofinterestpolicy,andindividualboardmembersadheretothecode.Theboardhasaclearlydefinedpolicyfordealingwithbehaviorthatviolatesitscodeandimplementsitwhennecessary.”Codes of Ethics Address Board Roles Ataminimum,codesofethicsaddressthefollowing:Representcommongood.Trusteeshipisanexpressionofcivicleadershipandcitizenship.Governingboardsderivetheirauthorityfromandareaccountabletothecommunityasawhole.Aspublicofficials,trusteesfulfillthecorevalueofresponsibilitytosocietybyactingonbehalfoftheentirecommunity.Theyexpressthevalueofbenevolencebyseekingthewell-beingoftheentirecommunity.Theyrepresenttheinterestsofthelargercommunityintheirboarddecisions.Studentsuccess.Thecollege’spurposeistoeducatestudentsanddoeverythingpossibletoensuretheymeettheirgoals.Boardsshouldexpecttheirmemberstoupholdthewelfareandsuccessofstudentsasaprimaryconcern.Theyshouldhaveasthehighestprioritypromotingthemissionandgoalsofthecollegeastheypertaintostudentsuccessandthecollege’sbenefittothecommunity.Boardasaunit.Oneofthemostbasictenetsofeffectivetrusteeshipistherecognitionthatgoverningauthorityrestswiththeentireboard,notwithanyindividualtrustee.Asindividuals,trusteeshavenoauthoritytodirectstaff,determineprogramsandprocedures,orrepresentthecollege,andethicaltrusteesdonottrytodoso.Theboard’svoiceisexpressedthroughthepoliciesandactionsittakesinitsofficialmeetings.Oncetheboardhasdecidedonapolicyorposition,atrusteemustbepreparedtosupportitpublicly.Itisunethicaltotrytouseauthorityindependentlyfromtheboard,tospeakoutagainst,ortotrytosabotageaboarddecision.
TheEthicalandLawfulBoardofTrustees CommunityCollegeLeagueofCaliforniaCaliforniaCommunityColleges 8
Makingdecisions.Makingethicaldecisionsmeansapplyingdefiningandapplyingcorepolicyvalues.Itmeansstudyingandaskingquestionstoclarifyboardagendamaterials.Makinggooddecisionsmeansaskingforandusingdataandconsideringallavailablefactsandperspectives.Boardsareethicalwhentheymodelaspiritofinquiryandvalueacultureofevidencefordecision-making.Beingethicalandresponsibletothepublicmeansnotmakinganypromisesabouthowonewillvotepriortodiscussionsatopenmeetings.BoardandCEORelations.TheChiefExecutiveOfficer(ChancellororSuperintendent/President)istheonlyemployeetheboardhas.Tobeethicalandeffective,boardspromoteahealthyworkingrelationshipwiththeCEOthroughsettingexpectations,clearlydelegatingauthority,ensuringopenandhonestcommunication,providingongoingandpublicsupport,andconductingregularevaluationsinaprofessionalmanner.Respect,reliability,trustworthinessandjusticeareallkeyvaluesintheboard/CEOrelationship.Specificethicalconceptsincludecommittingtothoughtful,thoroughCEOsearchprocesses;fairandattractivecontracts;“nosurprises,”andcleardifferentiationofroles.Specialinterests.Singleandspecialinterestgroupsplayanimportantpartinrepresentingvarioussegmentsofourdiversesociety,suchaspoliticalparties,racialandethnicgroups,employeeassociations,religiousgroups,neighborhoodassociations,andtaxpayergroups.Whilealloftheseinterestsareimportant,trusteesmustrememberthatthefirstandforemostobligationofeverytrusteeistorepresentthegeneralinterestsofthecollege’sservicearea.Ethicalbehaviorinvolvesbeingawareofawidevarietyofpublicandcommunityneeds,andintegratingthemintotheinterestsofthewhole.Policy-making.Boardresponsibilitiesincludeestablishingpoliciesthatdirecttheoperationsofthecollegeandassuringthatthecollegeperformsaccordingtopolicies.Ethicaltrusteesengagewiselyinpolicymakingandrespectthedelegationofauthoritytothechiefexecutivetoadministerthecollege.Problemsoccurwhenboardsandtrusteesbecomeinvolvedintheday-to-dayoperationsandtrytosecondguessordirectstaffactivities.Althoughoftenwellintentioned,theseactsaredisrespectfulofthecollegeandchiefexecutive.ContinuousImprovement.Ethicalandeffectiveboardsarededicatedtocontinuousimprovementoftheirperformance.Theyengageinregularself-evaluation,andsupporttrusteeorientationandon-goingeducation.Codes of Ethics Address Trustee Conduct Commitment.Ethicaltrusteesarecommittedtodoingthejobwell.Theyspendthetimeneededtoensuretheyarewell-informed,attendcollegeevents,andrepresentthedistrictinthecommunityandinadvocacyroles.Theyaligntheirbehaviorwiththeneedsofthecollege,andarecommittedtodoingwhatisneededtoprotectthedistrict’sreputation.Civility,decorum,andconsiderationforothers.Remainingcourteousandopen-mindedandtreatingotherswithhonesty,decency,andrespectarecharacteristicofethicaltrustees.Ethicaltrusteespracticeresponsibleself-restraintandsetagoodexampleforothersbycommunicatingthoughtfully.Theyavoidattacksandusecourteous,non-inflammatorylanguageatboardmeetings.
TheEthicalandLawfulBoardofTrustees CommunityCollegeLeagueofCaliforniaCaliforniaCommunityColleges 9
Considerationforothersmeansspeakingwellofothersinpublic.Criticizingorbelittlingothertrustees,collegestaff,orcommunitymembershurtsthereputationoftheentireboard.Board/CEOrelationship.EthicalbehaviorincludeshonoringtheCEO’sroleastheleaderoftheinstitution,andnotundermininghisorherleadershipandauthority.EthicaltrusteessupporttheCEOpubliclyandraiseanyconcernsprivatelydirectlytotheCEOorthroughtheCEOevaluationprocess.Theyhonorboard-establishedprotocolsforcommunicationandseekinginformationfromcollegestaff.Opencommunication.Allboardmembers,aswellastheCEO,areresponsibleformaintaininganopen,cooperativeenvironmentandpromotingafreeexchangeofinformationattheboardmeetings.Trusteedeliberationsshouldbecharacterizedbyfairness,andopenandimpartialprocessesforgatheringandevaluatinginformation.Trusteesarehonestandstraightforwardincivilandrespectfulways.Communicatingwithstaffandstudents.TheboardandCEOshoulddiscussandreachagreementonprotocolsfortrusteecontactwithothercollegeadministrators,faculty,andclassifiedstaffmembers.EthicaltrusteessupporttheauthorityoftheCEOpositionandrespectestablishedlinesofcommunication.Studentandemployeecomplaintstotrusteesshouldbereferreddirectlythroughappropriatechannelsortothechiefexecutiveofficer.Everycommunitycollegehas,orshouldhave,policiesandproceduresthatprovideforfairandethicaltreatmentofstudentsandemployees.Communicatingwithcommunitymembersandmedia.Acodeofethicsmayincludestatementsaboutprotocolsforcommunicatingwithcommunitymembersandmediapersonnel.Theprotocolsusuallystatethatindividualtrusteesdonotspeakfortheboardunlessspecificallydelegatedtodoso,andreferand/orfollowupwithcommunitymembersthroughappropriatechannels,almostalwaysthroughtheCEO’soffice.Theseprotocolsensurereliabilityofinformation,andrespecttheboardasaunitandtherolesofthosedesignatedasspokespeopleforthecollege.Functionasateammember.Beingagoodboardmemberrequirestheabilitytofunctionaspartofateam.Boardmembersdifferinpersonality,motivation,knowledge,attitude,experience,background,communitystature,andcapability.Differingpointsofviewhelpdevelopalternatives,stimulatetheimagination,andleadtocreativesolutions.Beingopentoandrespectfulofothermembers'viewpointsareskillsthatarenecessarytoreachconsensus.Trusteesoftenbringspecializedknowledgetotheboardbyvirtueoftheirbackgroundsandprofessions.However,trusteesarenotontheboardtobe"experts"intheirfields–theyaretheretorepresentbroadcommunityinterests.Maintainingconfidentiality.Whilemostofwhattheboarddoesispublic,animportantaspectoftrusteeethicsismaintainingconfidentialityaboutissuesdiscussedinclosedsession.Violatingconfidentialityoccurswhenindividualsshareclosedsessioninformation,suchasinformingtheunionofthecollectivebargainingpositions,leakinginformationtothemedia,ordiscussingprivatepersonnelinformation.Compensationandexpenses.Trusteesshouldfollowlawsandlocalproceduresaboutreceivingcompensationofanykind.Boardsandcollegesshouldhavereimbursementcriteriaandprocedures
TheEthicalandLawfulBoardofTrustees CommunityCollegeLeagueofCaliforniaCaliforniaCommunityColleges 10
thatdefinefairreimbursementfortrusteeexpenses.Ethicaltrusteesaccuratelyaccountfortheirexpenses,andalwaysaskthemselvesiftheirexpensesareauthorized,legitimate,andreasonable.Reviewing and Updating Codes of Ethics Sincetheearly1990’s,virtuallyallboardshaveadoptedacodeofethicsorstandardsofpracticeasaboardpolicy.DevelopingsuchadocumentideallyengagedalltrusteesandtheCEOindiscussionsofethicalvaluesastheysoughtconsensusaboutwhatshouldbeintheirpolicy.Sincethattime,goodpracticehasmeantthatboardsperiodicallyreviewandaffirmtheircodeofethics.Bestpracticeisthattheboardperiodicallyengagesinadeepdiscussionabouteachofthestatementsinthecode.Thediscussionhelpsclarifythevaluesinherentinthecodeandexplorestrustees’interpretationofthestandards.Itmayresultinrevisionsandadditionstothecodeofethics,therebyensuringthatthepolicyiscurrent,useful,andrelevanttotheboard.Suchareviewmightincludecomparingtheboard’scurrentethicspolicytotheboardrolesandtrusteeconductdefinedabove.Doesthecodesufficientlyaddressalltheissues?Aretrusteesclearabouttheexpectationsfortheirrole?Inadditiontotheperiodicreview,discussionofthecodeofconductshouldbeanintegralpartofnewtrustees’orientationtotheirrole.Itisextremelyhelpfulfornewtrusteestounderstandwhattheexpectationsareforlegalandethicalperformanceasamemberoftheboard.Sample Codes TheAssociationofCommunityCollegeTrusteeshaspublishedamodelcodeofethics,includedbelow.Boardsmayalsocollectexamplesfromothercolleges,usuallybygoingtotheboardpoliciespostedoncommunitycollegedistrictwebsites.However,muchofthebenefitofacodederivesfromthediscussioninvolvedthatfitstheboard.Therefore,effectiveboardsengageindiscussionsaboutethicalpracticesforthemselves,insteadofsimplyadoptingasamplestatement.Thediscussionusuallytakesplaceinaretreatformatallowingforopendiscussionofethicalvaluesanddifferentscenarios.Association of Community College Trustees Model Code of Ethics Asagoverningboardmember,Iamresponsibleto:§ devotetime,thought,andstudytothedutiesandresponsibilitiesofacommunitycollege
boardmembersothatImayrendereffectiveandcreditableservice;§ workwithmyfellowboardmembersinaspiritofharmonyandcooperationinspiteof
differencesofopinionthatariseduringvigorousdebatesofpointsofissue;§ basemypersonaldecisionuponallavailablefactsineachsituation;votemyhonestconviction
ineverycase,unswayedbypartisanbiasofanykind,andtoabidebyandupholdthefinalmajoritydecisiontotheboard;
§ rememberatalltimesthatasanindividualIhavenolegalauthorityoutsidethemeetingsof
theboard,andtoconductmyrelationshipswiththecommunitycollegestaff,thelocal
TheEthicalandLawfulBoardofTrustees CommunityCollegeLeagueofCaliforniaCaliforniaCommunityColleges 11
citizenry,andallmediaofthecommunityonthebasisofthisfact;§ resisteverytemptationandoutsidepressuretousemypositionasacommunitycollegeboard
membertobenefitmyselforanyotherindividualoragencyapartfromthetotalinterestofthecommunitycollegedistrict;
§ recognizethatitisasimportantfortheboardtounderstandandevaluatetheeducational
programofthecommunitycollegeasitistoplanforthebusinessofcollegeoperation;§ welcomeandencourageactivecooperationbycitizens,organizations,andthemediaof
communicationinthedistrictwithrespecttoestablishingpolicyoncurrentcollegeoperationsandproposedfuturedevelopments;
§ Speakwithonevoiceasaboardmemberonceaboarddecisionismade.§ Supportthestateandnationalcommunitycollegetrustees’associations;§ Strivestepbysteptowardidealconditionsforthemosteffectivecommunitycollegeboard
servicetomycommunity,inaspiritofteamworkanddevotiontopubliceducationasthegreatestinstrumentforthepreservationandtheperpetuationofourrepresentativedemocracy.
TheEthicalandLawfulBoardofTrustees CommunityCollegeLeagueofCaliforniaCaliforniaCommunityColleges 12
Chapter 3 Upholding Board Ethics “Icareabout,serve,andrespectthecommunity,thecollegeanditsemployees,andourstudents.”“Iamlaw-abiding,trustworthy,andfair.”Virtuallyallcommunitycollegetrusteesbelievetheseimportantethicalvalues.Thepublicandcollegeemployeesexpectcommunitycollegetrusteestoupholdthesehighstandardsintheperformanceoftheirduties.Governingboards,whichservethepublicandprovideleadershipforthecampuscommunity,mustliveuptotheseexpectations.Ethicalbehaviorfostersconfidenceinthecollegesanditsgoverningboardandpromotesthepublicgood.Beingethicalmeansupholdingthevaluesoftrustworthiness,respect,responsibility,fairness,caring,andcitizenship.However,livingbyethicalstandardsisnotalwayseasy.Boardsmayfaceethicaldilemmas,whenhonoringoneethicalvaluemaymeanviolatinganother.Inaddition,peoplefacechallengestoupholdethicalvalueswhentheyconflictwithself-interest,thedesiretopromotesingleinterestsorapersonalagenda,andthedifficultyoffullyrespectingthosewithwhomonedisagrees.Whenethicaldilemmasoccur,oneethicalcourseofactionmaymeanthatanothervalueisviolated.Makingadecisiontodowhatisrightforthecollegemayresultinsignificantpersonalcosttotrustees,tootherpersons,ortoagroupofconstituents.Inothercases,makingadecisionthatupholdsoneethicalsetofvaluesmaybeatoddswithanother.Forinstance,supportingaregionalorstateinitiativethatbenefitscommunitycollegesasawholemaymeanthatalocalneedmightnotbemetasfully.Resolvingethicaldilemmasrequiresboardmemberstoengageinoftenverydifficultdiscussionstodeterminewhichethicalvaluesaremostimportantinaspecificsituation.Thecriteriafordecision-makingincludewhatupholdsthepublicgoodandwhatisbestforthecommunityandcollegeasawhole.Unethicaltrusteebehavioroftenoccurswhenpersonalinterestsoverridetrusteeresponsibilities;examplesincludeindependentlypursuingpetprojects,breakingconfidentiality,ornotdevotingtimetotherole.Theseactivitieshurtthecollege.Unethicaltrusteebehaviorcanleadtolossofpublicsupportfortheentireinstitution.Ithascausedproblemsinthere-accreditationprocess.Communitymembersandlegislatorslosefaithinthecollege,andmaybemorereluctanttosupportfundingfortheinstitution.Trusteeswhoactunethicallyfailtofulfilltheirfiduciaryresponsibilitytoprotectthevalueofthecollege.Ethical Violations Cause Harm Trusteeswhoviolatetheboard’scodeofethicsharmtheboardandthecollegeinanumberofways.Violatingethicslawsmaysubjecttheboardandcollegetolegalaction,whichcaninvolvepenaltiesandsignificantcosts.Notaddressingethicalandlegalviolationsmaycausethepublicandcollegeemployeestoloserespectforandtrustintheboard,whichmayleadtolossoftrustinthecollegeanddistrict.Unethicalbehaviormayreducesupportforcommunitycollegeissuesfromcommunityleadersandthestatelegislature.Bondissuesarelesslikelytopass.Collectivebargainingprocessesaremoredifficult.Significantviolationshavecausedcollegestorisktheiraccreditationstatus.
TheEthicalandLawfulBoardofTrustees CommunityCollegeLeagueofCaliforniaCaliforniaCommunityColleges 13
Boardscannotaffordtoignore“badbehavior”andviolationsofthecodeofethics.Itisdifficulttoapproachafellowtrusteeaboutperceivedviolations,butitmustbedoneforthesakeofthecollegeanditsstudents.Thestrategyaboardusestoaddressethicalbreachesdependsonwhetherthebehaviorviolatesrelatedlawsortheboard’sowncodeofethics.Types of Violations ViolatingEthicalLawsTherearethreemajorcategoriesoflawsthataddressethicalbehaviorbypublicofficials.Allboardsshouldhavepoliciesthataddresstheissuesintheselaws.FinancialInterests.Conflictsofinterestlawsprohibittrusteesfromfinanciallybenefitingfromboarddecisions,oractingonmattersthatbenefitfamilymembers.FairandOpenDecision-Making.California’sopenandpublicmeetingslaws(theBrownAct)requirethatthepublic’sbusinessbedoneinpublic.Examplesofviolationsincludemakingdecisionsinprivatethatshouldbemadeinpublicmeetings,discussingitemsthathavenotbeennoticedtothepublic,andviolatingprovisionsthatclosedsessioninformationbekeptconfidential.UseofPublicFunds.Itisafelonytomisusepublicfunds.Examplesincludeclaimingexpensesthattheydidnotincurandusingcollegeresourcesforpersonalorpoliticalpurposes.Furtherinformationonethicslaw,stepstotake,andtheconsequencesofviolatingthemisinWalkingtheLine:WhattoDoWhenYouSuspectanEthicsProblem,bytheInstituteforLocalGovernment(2005).Seewww.ca-ilg.org/ethics-and-public-confidence.Actualorperceivedviolationsofthelawmustbedealtwithexpeditiouslyandlegaladviceshouldbesought.Astudysessionorworkshopmaybeappropriatefortheentireboardifitappearsthattrusteesmaybeunawareofthelaw.Upholding Ethics Preventionisthebestcureinpromotingethicalbehavior.Thebestpreventionconsistsofadoptingacodeofethicsandconflictofinterestpolicy,educatingboardmembersaboutlawsandethicalexpectations,andmakinganongoingandpubliccommitmenttobehavinglegallyandethically.Effectiveboardsperiodicallyreviewtheirpoliciesonethicsandconflictsofinteresttobesuretheycontinuetobeeffectiveguidesforboardbehavior.Theyfosterawarenessofethicalexpectationsby:
• Ensuringthatalltrusteesareawareoftheboard’sethicalexpectationsbyprovidingittoalltrusteesandhavingitavailableatboardmeetings.
• IncludingthecodeofethicsandconflictsofinterestwhenorientingnewtrusteesandCEOs.
• Usingthestandardsinthecodeascriteriaintheboardself-evaluationprocess.• Identifyingconsequencesforviolationsofthecodeofethics,sinceviolationsnegatively
impacttheboardandthecollege.Policy on Ethical Violations AccreditationStandardIV.C.11statesthatboardsmusthaveapolicythataddressesviolationsofthecodeofethics.Thestatementshouldaddressstepstoaddresspotentialoractualviolationsofethics
TheEthicalandLawfulBoardofTrustees CommunityCollegeLeagueofCaliforniaCaliforniaCommunityColleges 14
laws(openmeetings,conflictofinterestanduseofpublicresources),aswellastheboard’sownexpectationsforbehavior.Followingarethreestatementsfoundinmanycodesofethicsandexamplesofbehaviorsthatviolatethestatement.• “Werecognizethatatrusteeisamemberofalegalentityandshallabidebymajority
decisionsoftheboard.Weworkwithfellowboardmembersinaspiritofharmonywhilerespectingdifferencesofopinion.”Examplesofviolationsincludeattackingothertrusteesorthepresidentinpublic,publiclyadvocatingagainstboarddecisionsaftertheyaremade,orsabotagingtheworkoftheboard.Trusteesmustfindethicalwaystoexpresstheirindividualopinionsthatdon’tviolatetheall-importantprinciplethattheboardisaunit.
• “WeclearlydelegatetoandsupporttheCEOintheperformanceofhisorherresponsibilities.”
Examplesofviolationsincludeongoingandsubstantialattemptsbytrusteestoadminister,ratherthangovernthecollege,whichviolatetheseparationofCEOandboardroles.Examplesincludeignoringlocaldecision-makingprocessandcommunicationprotocolsbyworkingdirectlywithstaffmembers,tellingcollegestaffwhomtheyshouldhire,andattemptingtodirecttheday-to-daydutiesofstaffmembers.
• “WerepresenttheDistrictasawhole,butrecognizetheuniqueneedsoftheindividual
collegesandlocalcommunities.Wearenotadvocatesforspecialinterestgroups.”Trusteeswhopersistentlyadvocateasingleinterestinsteadofthecommonpublicgoodmaybeviolatingthisstatement.Examplesincludetrusteeswhoignorethebroadrangeofpublicneedsincommunitycollegeeducationintheirdecision-makingandappeartobeagentsofaunion,aspecificcommunitygroup,orabusinessinterest.Allinterestsareimportantandshouldbeconsidered;butsolelyrepresentingsingleinterestsdoesnotservethegreatergoodforthecollegeandcommunity.
Steps in Addressing Legal and Ethical Violations Theboardoftrusteeshasresponsibilityformonitoringitself,andthechairplaysakeyroleinensuringthatlawsandcodesofethicsarefollowed.WhileCEOshelpensuretheboardisknowledgeablebyprovidinginformationaboutethicslawsandtheboard’scodeofethics,theyshouldnotbeputinthepositionofenforcingtrustees’ethicalbehavior.BoardsandCEOsshouldseekadvicefromlegalcounselregardingviolationsthatmayhavelegalramifications.Apresentationbyanattorneyaboutlegalconstraintsandstandardsexpectationsmaybeallthatisneededtopreventfurtherviolationsoflawandregulations.TheCEOcanbeveryhelpfulinensuringthatboardmembers(particularlynewones)havetheinformationtheyneedtobeawareoflegalexpectationsandalertingtheboardtoitslegalresponsibilities.Ethicaldilemmasarenotuncommon,wherepeoplearefacedwithdecisionswheretheymustbalancetwoconflictingethicalvalues,orwheredoingtheethicalthingcomesatgreatpersonalcost.Goodpeoplemaydisagreeonwhetherornotcertainbehaviorisunethical.Therefore,afirststepinaddressingaperceivedviolationofanethicalcodeorlawistoexaminethevariousperspectivesaboutandinterpretationsofthebehavior.Lookbothattheintentionandmotivesofthetrusteeinquestionandthosemakingthecharge.Wastheactionordecisionbased
TheEthicalandLawfulBoardofTrustees CommunityCollegeLeagueofCaliforniaCaliforniaCommunityColleges 15
onanethicaldilemma?Isthedecisionopentointerpretation?Doestheperceivedviolationbetraythepublictrust?Dothoseexpressingtheconcernhaveaparticularinterestthatmayinfluencetheirperception?Accusationsofunethicalbehaviorcandoasmuchharmtoaninstitutionasthebehaviorunderquestion—caremustbetakenthatmisguidedrighteousnessdoesnotdomoreharmthangood.Unfortunately,someaccusationsmaybebasedonretribution,personalbenefitorthedesiretoembarrasssomeone.Therefore,whenconsideringchargesthatanethicalcodehasbeenviolated,oneshouldtakeintoaccountthemotivesofthepartiesinvolved.Aretheytobenefitthecollegeanditsmission,aretheytobenefitorprotectacertaingroupofpeopleorthetrustee,orarethereotherpossiblemotives?Alsothinkaboutwhetheraddressingthebehaviorwillfosterconfidenceinthedistrictanditsgoverningboard.Takeintoaccountwhatwillhappenifthisissueisnotaddressed.Whenconsideringpossibleresponses,choosetheone(s)thataremostlikelytoupholdthepublictrustandthatmostcloselyreflectethicalvalues.Addressingethicalissuesistheresponsibilityoftheboardchairorothertrusteesidentifiedbytheboard.Followingaresomepossiblecoursesofaction:• Theboardchairordesigneetalkstothepersonabouttheimplicationsoftheperceived
violation,includingthenegativeimpactthebehaviorwillhaveonthecollege,theboard,andtheindividualtrustee.Anopportunityshouldbeprovidedforthepersontoexplainhisorherperspectiveandmotivesandtosetmattersstraight.Goodhumanrelationsandcommunicationskillsarehelpfulinhandlingthesedifficultsituations—chargingsomeonewithunethicalbehavioroftenleadstodefensiveness.
• Anadhoccommitteemaybeappointedtolookintotheallegationsandmakearecommendationtotheboardchairortheboardasawhole.BeawareoftheimplicationsoftheBrownActwhenestablishingacommittee.
• Theboardmayholdaworkshoporretreatoncodesofethicsandtheimportanceof
upholdingthem.Alltrusteesdiscussinterpretationsofthecodeandreinforceexpectedbehavior.
• Theboardmay,inameeting,makeapublicstatementofexpectedboardbehavior,adopta
boardresolutionaboutwhatexpectedbehavioris,and/orpubliclyreaffirmtheethicspolicy.Thiscourseofactionalertsthepublicthatindividualviolationsarenotcondonedbytheboard.
• Theboardmayissueapublicstatementinwhichitexpressesconcernwithanindividual
trustee’sbehavior.Thestatementwouldbemadeataboardmeeting.• Alastresortisaboardvotetocensurethetrustee’sbehavior.Censuredistancestheboard
fromtheunethicalbehaviorofoneofitsmembersandisaclear,publicstatementthatunethicalbehaviorisnotcondonedortolerated.However,censureofficiallydividestheboard,whichmayleadtoadditionalproblems.
Ifillegalorunethicalbehavioroccursduringaboardmeeting,thechaircanstatewhattheexpectationsandstandardsareofboardbehavior,recessthemeeting,and/orstatethatthe
TheEthicalandLawfulBoardofTrustees CommunityCollegeLeagueofCaliforniaCaliforniaCommunityColleges 16
behaviorisnotthepolicyandpracticeoftheboard.Examplesofpossibleethicalviolationsincludethetrusteeremainingattheboardtablewhenheorshehasaconflictofinterest,engagingindebateordiscussionwithaudiencemembersontopicsnotontheagenda,attackingaspeaker,ornotfollowingtheboard’smeetingprocedures.Policy Statements Effectiveboardshaveaprocesstodealwithviolationsoftheboardcodeofethics.In2002,theAccreditingCommissionforCommunityandJuniorCollegesadoptedstandardsthatrequirethattheboard’scodeofethicsincludea“clearlydefinedpolicyfordealingwithbehaviorthatviolatesitscode.”Conceptsthatmaybeaddressedinsuchapolicyincludewhoontheboardisresponsibletoaddresschargesorperceptionsofviolations,whatstepswillbetakentoexamineandaddressbothlegalandethicalviolations,andpossibleconsequencesofviolations.Thefollowingsamplestatementsareprovidedasstartingplacesforboarddiscussion.Boardsshouldchange,deleteoraddadditionaldetailtothesuggestedlanguagetoreflecttheirownprocedures.
Sample1TheCEOandboardchairareauthorizedtoconsultwithlegalcounselwhentheybecomeawareoforareinformedaboutactualorperceivedviolationsofpertinentlawsandregulations,includingbutnotlimitedtoconflictofinterest,openandpublicmeetings,confidentialityofclosedsessioninformation,anduseofpublicresources.ViolationsoflawmaybereferredtotheDistrictAttorneyorAttorneyGeneralasprovidedforinlaw.Violationsoftheboard’spolicycodeofethicswillbeaddressedbythepresidentoftheboard,whowillfirstdiscusstheviolationwiththetrusteetoreacharesolution.Ifresolutionisnotachievedandfurtheractionisdeemednecessary,thepresidentmayappointanadhoccommitteetoexaminethematterandrecommendfurthercoursesofactiontotheboard.Sanctionswillbedeterminedbytheboardofficers[orcommittee]andmayincludearecommendationtotheboardtocensureofthetrustee.Ifthepresidentoftheboardisperceivedtohaveviolatedthecode,thevicepresidentoftheboardisauthorizedtopursueresolution.
Sample2Chargesbyanypersonthataboardmemberhasviolatedlawsandregulationsgoverningboardbehaviorortheboard’scodeofethicsshallbedirectedtotheboardpresidentortheboardoftrustees.Theboardchairmayestablishanadhoccommitteetoexaminethechargesandrecommendfurthercoursesofactiontotheboard.Possiblecoursesofactioninclude:
• Ifallegedbehaviorviolateslawsgoverningboardbehavior,legalcounselmaybesoughtandtheviolationsreferredtotheDistrictAttorneyorAttorneyGeneralasprovidedforinlaw.
• Iftheallegedbehaviorviolatesboardpolicyonethicalconduct,thechairoftheboardshallalerttheboardmemberinquestionregardingtheviolationofpolicy,theboardmaydiscusstheviolationataboardmeetingandaffirmitspolicy
TheEthicalandLawfulBoardofTrustees CommunityCollegeLeagueofCaliforniaCaliforniaCommunityColleges 17
expectation,and/ortheboardmaymovetocensurethetrustee.
Sample3AllboardmembersareexpectedtomaintainthehigheststandardsofconductandethicalbehaviorandtoadheretotheBoardCodeofEthics.Theboardwillbepreparedtoinvestigatethefactualbasisbehindanychargeorcomplaintoftrusteemisconduct.Aboardmembermaybesubjecttoaresolutionofcensurebythegoverningboardshoulditbedeterminedthattrusteemisconducthasoccurred.Censureisanofficialexpressionofdisapprovalpassedbythegoverningboard.Acomplaintoftrusteemisconductwillbereferredtoanadhoccommitteecomposedoftwotrusteesnotsubjecttothecomplaint.Inamannerdeemedappropriatebythecommittee,afact-findingprocessshallbeinitiatedandcompletedwithinareasonableperiodoftimetodeterminethevalidityofthecomplaint.ThecommitteeshallbeguidedinitsinquirybythestandardssetforthintheCodeofEthicsasdefinedinpolicy.Thetrusteesubjecttothechargeofmisconductshallnotbeprecludedfrompresentinginformationtothecommittee.Thecommitteeshall,withinareasonableperiodoftime,makeareportofitsfindingstothegoverningboardforaction.
Summary Itisnotenoughtohavepoliciesoncodeofethicsandconflictofinterests.Effectiveboardsunderstandandabidebytheconceptsinthesepolicies,andarewillingtoaddressviolationsofthesepolicies.Suchboardsgoalongwayofjustifyingthetrustthepublichasplacedinthemtoprotecttheircommunitycolleges.
TheEthicalandLawfulBoardofTrustees CommunityCollegeLeagueofCaliforniaCaliforniaCommunityColleges 18
Chapter 4: Resources and References CommunityCollegeLeagueofCaliforniaTheLeaguehelpsallnewtrusteeslearnabouttheirrolesandresponsibilitiesbyprovidingeachnewtrusteewithTrusteeHandbook,EthicsLawPrinciplesforPublicServants:KeyThingstoKnow(publishedbytheInstituteforLocalGovernment)andOpenandPublicIV,AUser’sGuidetotheRalphM.BrownAct.ThesematerialsandothersaredistributedattheannualEffectiveTrusteeshipWorkshop,designedfornewtrusteesandothersinterestedinimprovingboardeffectiveness.InstituteforLocalGovernmentTheInstituteisthenonprofitresearcharmoftheLeagueofCaliforniaCities,isanoutstandingsourceofresearchandinformationforCalifornia'slocalofficials.TheInstitutehasextensiveresourcesonethicsforlocalofficials,mostofwhichareavailableontheweb,www.ca-ilg.org.
Otheroutstandingresourcesformaterialsandtrainingonethicsare:
• JosephsonInstituteofEthics,LosAngeles,http://www.josephsoninstitute.org.• MarkkulaCenterforAppliedEthicsatSantaClaraUniversity,http://www.scu.edu/ethics.• InternationalCity/CountyManagementAssociation,www.icma.org.
References • AccreditingCommissionforCommunityandJuniorColleges.HandbookofAccreditationand
PolicyManual,2014
• AssociationofCommunityCollegesTrustees,www.acct.org.• CommunityCollegeLeagueofCalifornia,TrusteeHandbook,Sacramento,CA2015• CommunityCollegeLeagueofCalifornia,“UpholdingBoardEthics”,BoardFocus,Winter2006
• Open&PublicIV:User'sGuidetotheRalphM.BrownAct.Sacramento,CA:LeagueofCalifornia
Citiesandothers,2010.• Houle,CyrilO.GoverningBoards.SanFrancisco:JosseyBass,1989• InstituteforLocalGovernment.WalkingtheLine:WhattoDoWhenYouSuspectanEthics
Problem,Sacramento,CA,2005.• InstituteforLocalGovernment.EthicsLawPrinciplesforPublicServants:KeyThingstoKnow.
Sacramento,CA2015-2016.• Josephson,Michael.MakingEthicalDecisions.www.josephsoninstitute.org.