The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

110
\oh Hcit|hci Ogb \oh Lctbt|vgxt Ci|hkkhd|xbk Zbv gi Dgaagi Thith Fs! O) H) Vh|cd ^xfkctohl fs! \oh O) H) Vh|cd Dg) Zht| Dbklzhkk+ I@ Cic|cbk Dg~svcjo|! @xks 233: Vhuctcgi Dg~svcjo|! Lhdhafhv 233: Bkk Vcjo|t Vhthvuhl Kcac|hl Kcdhith! Kcdhith ct ohvhfs jvbi|hl egv |oh lgzikgblcij ge |oct lgdxahi| evga c|t Ci|hvih| Zhftc|h bil |oh vh~vglxd|cgi ge b tcijkh obvldg~s+ b tcijkh fbdmx~ lctm+ bil t|gvbjh gi |oh obvllvcuh ge b ~hvtgibk dga~x|hv egv |oh tgkh xth ge |oh cilcuclxbk ~hvegvacij |oh lgzikgbl) Dg~cht bvh ig| kcdhithl egv lct|vcfx|cgi |g g|ohv ~bv|cht) \oh t|gvbjh ge &\oh Hcit|hci Ogb& ct bx|ogvcphl giks b| |oh bx|ogv*t

Transcript of The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 1/110

\oh Hcit|hci Ogb

\oh Lctbt|vgxt Ci|hkkhd|xbk Zbv gi Dgaagi Thith

Fs! O) H) Vh|cd

^xfkctohl fs!

\oh O) H) Vh|cd Dg)Zht| Dbklzhkk+ I@

Cic|cbk Dg~svcjo|! @xks 233:Vhuctcgi Dg~svcjo|! Lhdhafhv 233:

Bkk Vcjo|t Vhthvuhl

Kcac|hl Kcdhith!

Kcdhith ct ohvhfs jvbi|hl egv |oh lgzikgblcij ge |oct lgdxahi| evga c|t Ci|hvih| Zhftc|h bil |ohvh~vglxd|cgi ge b tcijkh obvldg~s+ b tcijkh fbdmx~ lctm+ bil t|gvbjh gi |oh obvllvcuh ge b ~hvtgibdga~x|hv egv |oh tgkh xth ge |oh cilcuclxbk ~hvegvacij |oh lgzikgbl) Dg~cht bvh ig| kcdhithl egvlct|vcfx|cgi |g g|ohv ~bv|cht) \oh t|gvbjh ge &\oh Hcit|hci Ogb& ct bx|ogvcphl giks b| |oh bx|ogv*t

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 2/110

zhftc|h) Ig ci|hvahlcb|h t|gvbjh kgdb|cgit egv |oh eckht ge &\oh Hcit|hci Ogb& bvh |g fh abci|bcihhdh~| bt vhrxcvhl |g ebdckc|b|h c|t |vbitacttcgi |g khjc|cab|h vhdc~chi|t) \oh vcjo|t ge cilcuclxbkt |glgzikgbl |ohth eckht |hvacib|ht zohi |oh dg~svcjo| ogklhv lhkh|ht |oha evga |oh Zhftc|h gi |ohCi|hvih| Thvucdh ^vguclhv /CT^# ogt| dga~x|hv) \oh CT^ obt ig vcjo|t |g |oh dg~svcjo|hl ab|hvcbk+vhjbvlkhtt ge bis dgilc|cgit c| abs thhm |g ca~gth+ tcidh c| obt ihc|ohv geehvhl gv ~vguclhl bisdgitclhvb|cgi egv txdo vcjo|t)

Hrxb|cgi Dgitclhvb|cgit!

Ci gvlhv |g vhkcbfks vh~vglxdh hrxb|cgit guhv |oh Ci|hvih|+ |oh bx|ogv obt hkhd|hl |g ha~kgs gikstsafgkt |ob| b~~hbv gi b dgiuhi|cgibk |s~hzvc|hv mhsfgbvl) C| togxkl fh ig|hl |ob|!

\oh tsafgk && vh~vhthi|t b axk|c~kcdb|cgi)r

\oh tsafgk &Y& vh~vhthi|t |oh vbctcij ge b ixafhv |g b ~gzhv)r

\oh bx|ogv vhkcht x~gi |oh &Ig Fvhbm& dgaabil ge O\AK |g ~vhuhi| hrxb|cgit bilh~vhttcgit evga fhcij t~kc| fh|zhhi kciht fs |oh fvgzthv*t zgvlzvb~ exid|cgi)

r

Lcbjvba ^vhthi|b|cgi0!

\oh ~vhthi|b|cgi ge b |h| dgi|bcicij \bfkht bil'gv Ecjxvht ct dga~vgacthl fs |oh db~bfckc|s gefvgzthvt |g bkkgz |oh xthv |g ubvs |oh tcph ge |oh ~vhthi|b|cgi evga bi bjvhhl x~gi t|bilbvl) Bt bvhtxk|+ c| ct ihdhttbvs |g cidgv~gvb|h &~bjh fvhbm& dgaabilt zc|oci |oh |h| tg |ob| hafhllhl|bfkht bil lcbjvbat zckk ig| t~kc| fh|zhhi |zg th~bvb|h ~vci|hl ~blht) \oct zckk obuh ig heehd| gi|h|t vhbl lcvhd|ks evga |oh tdvhhi fx| zckk dbxth tgah ge |oh ~vci|hl ~bjht |g dgi|bci b fkbimt~bdh b| |ohcv hil |g bkkgz |oh |bfkht bil'gv lcbjvbat |g t|bv| b| |oh |g~ ge |oh ihd| ~bjh) Cv ctvhdgaahilhl |ob| |oh ~vci|hv abvjcit fh th| b| >):8 cidoht b| |oh |g~+ vcjo| bil fg||ga bil b| 2)>

cidoht b| |oh khe|) Sgxv fvgzthv*t |h| tcph togxkl fh cic|cbkks th| b| AHLCXA) \g |ht| egv b txc|bfkh~vci|hl ~bjh tcph bddhtt ^vci| Tcph \ht| ^bjh) Ce ~vci|cij lght ig| eckk ~bjh ~vg~hvks+ |vs bl`xt|cij

|oh |g~ bil fg||ga abvjcit) \g dg~s |h| bil lcbjvbat |g b eckh &Tbuh Bt& &Dga~kh|h O\AK \h|Eckh&)

Dob~|hv Cilh

Dob~|hv 2 ! Ci|vglxd|cgi

Dob~|hv 6 ! Oct|gvcdbk Fbdmjvgxil

Dob~|hv 4 ! \oh Ib|xvh ge |oh Hcit|hci Ogb

Dob~|hv < ! Lght |oh Bh|ohv Hct|7

Dob~|hv 8 ! \oh Vhtxvvhd|cgi ge Bftgkx|h Uhkgdc|s Fs Rxbi|xa H~hvcahi|t

Dob~|hv 5 ! \oh Ib|xvh ge Vhbkc|s

Dob~|hv : ! B~~kscij |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgit ^vg~hvks

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 3/110

Dob~|hv ? ! Jhihvb|cij |oh Jvbuc|s \vbitegvab|cgit

Dob~|hv 3 ! Lv) Hcit|hci*t Hvvgv bil |oh Ci|vglxd|cgi ge Dxvuhl T~bdh

Dob~|hv 2> ! Jvbuc|b|cgibk Dgi|vbd|cgi bil Dgkkb~th

Dob~|hv 22 ! Jvbuc|b|cgibk Dgkkb~th bil |oh Dvhb|cgi ge b Xicuhvth

Dob~|hv 26 ! \oh T~bdh \cah Dgi|cixxa

Dob~|hv 24 ! \oh Ib|xvh ge ^bv|cdkht

Dob~|hv 2< ! Bllcij |oh Rxbi|xa Heehd|t |g Gxv Xilhvt|bilcij

Dob~|hv 28 ! Dobijcij |oh ^bvblcjat

Dob~|hv 25 ! Zob| Dbi Zh Dgidkxlh7

Dob~|hv 2 ! Ci|vglxd|cgi2)2! Bt b sgxij abi+ |oh bx|ogv obl txeecdchi| bvvgjbidh |g fhkchuh |ob|+ zockh b kbdm ge |cah~vhuhi|hl bi cilcuclxbk evga xilhvt|bilcij bkk ge Ib|xvh+ |ohvh zbt ig bt~hd| ge Ib|xvh |ob| dgxklig| fh xilhvt|ggl b| |oh ci|xc|cuh khuhk fs b vhbtgibfks ci|hkkcjhi| bil blhrxb|hks ag|cub|hlcilcuclxbk) Bt b vhtxk| |oh t|b|hahi|t zocdo b~~hbvhl ci |oh |h|t ge |oh |cah |ob| |oh heehd|t lhecihfs |oh T~hdcbk bil Jhihvbk \ohgvcht ge Vhkb|cuc|s zhvh fhsgil txdo bi xilhvt|bilcij bil dgxklgiks fh |vhb|hl fs ab|ohab|cdbk abic~xkb|cgit zhvh b dobkkhijh) Ciohvhi|ks+ ab|ohab|cdt ct btdchidh ge ogz axdo bil ig| ge ogz dgah+ bil c| zbt |oh ogz dgah |ob| |oh bx|ogv zctohl |gxilhvt|bil) \g ahh| |ob| dobkkhijh+ |oh bx|ogv ~vgdhhlhl |g t|xls |oh dgidh~|t ciugkuhl zc|o |ohjggl ebc|o fhkche |ob| |ohs obl fhhi zhkk |ogxjo| gx| bil zhkk uhvcechl fs ahi ebv fh||hv |vbcihl bil

zcthv |obi ocathke) Ogzhuhv+ |oh lhh~hv |oh bx|ogv ~vgfhl+ |oh agvh lctckkxtcgihl oh fhdbah) C|fhdbah agvh bil agvh b~~bvhi| |ob| |oh heehd|t vh~vhthi|hl zhvh rxc|h hbtcks xilhvt|ggl b| |ohci|xc|cuh+ gv dgaagi thith+ khuhk bil |ob| |oh vhbtgi |ob| |ohs b~~hbvhl ast|hvcgxt zbt |ob| |ogtzog ~xv~gv|hl |g fh h~hv|t lcl ig| bd|xbkks xilhvt|bil |oh txf`hd| ab||hv bil |ob| |ohcv btthv|cgige c|t cidga~vhohitcfckc|s zhvh vb|cgibkcpb|cgit |g dguhv |ohcv gzi kcac|b|cgit) C| |xvit gx| |ob| |ohtxf`hd| ab||hv ct vhblcks xilhvt|ggl fs bisgih zc|o b jggl bfckc|s |g uctxbkcph ~ostcdbk vhbkc|s bilzog ct ebackcbv zc|o ^ostcdt bil Dbkdxkxt b| |oh dgkkhjh evhtoabi khuhk)

2)6! \oh bx|ogv*t cic|cbk dgiextcgi vhtxk|hl evga |oh ebd| |ob|+ zockh T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s zbt ~vhthi|hbt |oh h~c|gah ge ~ostcdbk zctlga+ cic|cbkks c| zbt ca~gttcfkh egv oca |g ecil b ahbicijexklct|cid|cgi fh|zhhi c| bil |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi!Bh|ohv \ohgvs zocdo obl ~vhdhlhl c| fs |zgshbvt) C| ecibkks lbzihl gi |oh bx|ogv |ob| |oh T~hdcbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s zbt bd|xbkks |oh Kgvhi|p

\vbitegvab|cgi!Bh|ohv \ohgvs zc|ogx| |oh dgit|vbci| ca~gthl fs |oh vhrxcvhahi| ge bi bftgkx|huhkgdc|s vhehvhidh /|oh Bh|ohv#) \ohi+ dgi|vbvs |g |oh vxkht ge huclhidh zocdo zgxkl fh ha~kgshl cb dgxv| ge kbz+ |oh bdblhacd dgaaxic|s egvdhl |oh bddh~|bidh ge |oh clhb |ob|+ tcidh fg|o |ohgvchtobl lhagit|vb|hl |ob| gxv bftgkx|h uhkgdc|s |ovgxjo t~bdh dgxkl ig| fh gfthvuhl+ |oh Bh|ohv oblig tcjicecdbidh bil zbt ig| |g fh xthl bt |oh fbtct egv b ~ostcdbk |ohgvs) \oct ~gtc|cgi zbt |bmhihuhi |ogxjo Lv) Hcit|hci obl abci|bcihl b fhkche ci bftgkx|h |cah /hrxcubkhi| |g b fhkche ci |ohhct|hidh ge |oh Bh|ohv# egv bfgx| 68 shbvt be|hv T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s obl fhhi ~xfkctohl) Oh obl bktgzbvihl |ob| |oh igi!hct|hidh ge |oh Bh|ohv obl ig| fhhi ~vguhi+ zob| obl fhhi ~vguhi zbt |ob|c|t xth zbt ig| ihdhttbvs ci ab|ohab|cdbk bibkstht ge ~ostcdbk ~vgdhttht)

2)4! Fg|o T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s bil |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi!Bh|ohv \ohgvs lhagit|vb|hl |ob| |ohgfthvuhl uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| zbt cilh~hilhi| ge |oh uhkgdc|s ge c|t tgxvdh) \ohvhci kcht |oh vxf) Txdo

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 4/110

vhtxk| ct gfucgxt ce kcjo| ct b zbuh ~vg~bjb|cij |ovgxjo b ahlcxa /|oh Bh|ohv#) Fs bfgkctocij |ohBh|ohv+ T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s kgt| |oh uhkgdc|s vhehvhidh |oh Bh|ohv vh~vhthi|hl bil btthv|hl cit|hbl|ob| kcjo| ~vg~bjb|hl bt fbkkct|cd ~bv|cdkht /~og|git# |ovgxjo ha~|s t~bdh) Blugdb|ht ge T~hdcbkVhkb|cuc|s ~vguclhl ig h~kbib|cgi bt |g ogz Ib|xvh ~hvegvahl txdo b vhabvmbfkh ehb| ge t~hhldgi|vgk zc|ogx| xtcij |oh Bh|ohv bt b vhehvhidh bil cit|hbl+ |ohs t|vgijks btthv|hl |ob| bis lgxf|b rxht|cgihv obl vhtxk|hl evga oct kcac|hl ci|hkkhd|xbk db~bdc|s vb|ohv |obi evga b khjc|cab|hdgidhvi) \ob| b||c|xlh obt vxi ci|g tgah |vgxfkh ci vhdhi| shbvt+ gfthvub|cgit ge |oh vblcb|cgifbdmjvgxil ge t~bdh obuh togzi |ob| |oh Hbv|o obt b uhkgdc|s ge 4>> mckgah|hvt ~hv thdgil zc|ovht~hd| |g |ob| fbdmjvgxil+ bil h~hvcahi|t fs rxbi|xa ~ostcdct|t obuh lhagit|vb|hl |ob| gxv

bftgkx|h uhkgdc|s |ovgxjo t~bdh dbi fh ahbtxvhl ci |oh kbfgvb|gvs) Bt zh tobkk thh+ |ohthgfthvub|cgit abmh bi guhvzohkacijks t|vgij bvjxahi| egv |oh ubkclc|s ge |oh Kgvhi|p\vbitegvab|cgi!Bh|ohv \ohgvs bil |oh bv|cecdcbkc|s ge |oh T~hdcbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s)

2)<! \oh bx|ogv*t lctckkxtcgiahi| fhdbah lhh~hv zohi oh fhjbi |g t|xls Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s) \ob||ohgvs tx~~gthlks h~kbcihl jvbuc|s bt b ~ohigahib vhtxk|cij evga b dxvucij ge t~bdh dbxthl fs|oh ~vhthidh ge ab||hv) Ogzhuhv+ Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s fkc|ohks ebckt |g lctdxtt |oh agt| tcjicecdbi|dobvbd|hvct|cd ge jvbuc|s+ |oh egvdh zocdo ~vhttht sgx |g sgxv dobcv) Dga~bvhl |g |oh ihhl |gh~kbci |ob| egvdh bil |oh hihvjs c| vh~vhthi|t+ |oh dgvvhd|cgit Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s ~vguclht |g |ohIhz|gicbi gvfc|t ge ~kbih|t+ |oh ~b|o ge t|bvkcjo|+ gv |oh vb|h ge ~bttbjh ge |cah bvh vb|ohv |vcucbk)Cidvhlcfks+ ig| giks lght Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s ebck |g h~kbci |oh tgxvdh ge |ob| egvdh /bil |oh hihvjs ca~kcht#+ abis |h|t gi |oh txf`hd| bd|xbkks lhis |ob| |oh egvdh hct|t) Zohi |oh lhvcub|cgi geJhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s ct hbacihl dbvhexkks+ c| ct egxil |g dgi|bci b exilbahi|bk hvvgv ge b |s~h zocdozgxkl ig| obuh fhhi |gkhvb|hl ce c| obl fhhi ablh fs b dgkkhjh evhtoabi zog zbt t|xlscijDbkdxkxt) Huhi zc|o |ob| hvvgv+ |oh |vx|o ge |oh fbtcd ~vhactht ge Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s /|oh ^vcidc~kht Vhkb|cuc|s bil ge Hrxcubkhidh# citxvhl |oh hvvgv zgxkl ig| fh vhuhbkhl fs gfthvub|cgit ablh ci |ohzhbm jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl ge |oh Txi gv fs gfthvub|cgit ge b lct|bi| fcibvs t|bv tst|ha) Ci gvlhv |g~bv|cbkks dga~hitb|h egv |oh heehd|t ge oct ab|ohab|cdbk hvvgv+ Lv) Hcit|hci ci|vglxdhl |ohbv|cecdcbkc|s ge dxvuhl t~bdh) \oct dgidh~| obt obl |oh xiegv|xib|h heehd| ge khblcij b kbvjh ixafhvge ocjoks |vbcihl bt|vgigahvt bil dgtagkgjct|t lgzi |oh jbvlhi ~b|o bil khl |g |oh bftxvlc|cht gFkbdm Ogkht+ Zgvaogkht+ bil Tcijxkbvc|cht) Lv) Hcit|hci abs obuh vhdgjicphl |oh hct|hidh ge blhehd|/t# ci Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s tcidh oh ct vh~gv|hl |g obuh fhhi xihbts bfgx| c|t h|hitcgi ci|gvhjcgit ge ci|hith jvbuc|b|cgibk echklt)

2)8! \oh bx|ogv*t lctckkxtcgiahi| zc|o |oh `gf ~hvegvabidh ge |ogth evga zoga oh obl og~hl |gkhbvi khl oca |g t|xls |oh txf`hd| ab||hv fs t|bv|cij evga fbtcdt xtcij bi b~~vgbdo zocdo zbttxc|bfkh egv |oh bibkstct ge vhkb|cuct|cd ~ohigahib /c)h)! uhkgdc|s heehd|t bil jvbuc|s heehd|t#) \octdb~bfckc|s ct ig| ~gtthtthl fs |oh \hitgv Dbkdxkxt dgaagiks xthl fs ~ostcdct|t bil zocdo bkkgz|oha |g fs!~btt |oh ihhl |g xilhvt|bil |oh ~ohigahigi |ohs zhvh ciuht|cjb|cij) \oh bx|ogvvhdgjicphl+ bt lght b txvuhsgv zog vgx|cihks dgvvhd|t oct gfthvub|cgit egv |oh heehd|t ge bafchi||ha~hvb|xvh gi |oh khij|o ge oct ahbtxvcij |b~h+ |ob| gfthvub|cgit ablh fh|zhhi vhehvhidh evbahlceehvcij ci uhkgdc|s bil'gv hkhub|cgi vhrxcvh b dgvvhd|cgi egv |oh heehd|t ge |ob| lceehvhidh gi |oh tcpge |oh xic|t ge ahbtxvhahi| oh ha~kgst) Giks be|hv b~~vg~vcb|h dgvvhd|cgit obuh fhhi ablh dbiubkcl dgidkxtcgit fh lvbzi bt |g zob| bd|xbkks gddxvt fh|zhhi lceehvhi| uhkgdc|s bil'gv hkhub|cgivhehvhidh evbaht) \oh vhrxcvhl |hdoicrxh egv t|xlscij vhkb|cuct|cd heehd|t ct Lcahitcgibk Bibkstct

zocdo zbt lhuhkg~hl ci |oh 23|o dhi|xvs |g ebdckc|b|h h~hvcahi|t ci oslvbxkcd hijcihhvcij) \ohKgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgit ge fg|o |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi!Bh|ohv \ohgvs bil T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s~vguclh |oh ciegvab|cgi vhrxcvhl |g bkkgz |oh xth ge Lcahitcgibk Bibkstct egv b vcjgvgxt bibkstct g|oh heehd|t ge uhkgdc|s) \g hbacih |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl+ c| zbt ihdhttbvs egv |oh bx|ogv |g lhucthahbit ge lhvcucij jvbuc|b|cgibk hrxcubkhi|t ge |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgit |ob| lcl ig| cidkxlh |ohkgg~ ge dcvdxkbv vhbtgicij |ob| dbxthl Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s |g fh lhehd|cuh)

2)5! \oh vhbk |ht| ge bi h~hv|*t migzkhljh ct oct bfckc|s |g abmh oct txf`hd| ab||hv ci|xc|cuhksxilhvt|bilbfkh |g bi ci|hkkcjhi| kbsabi) Ce oh dbiig| lg tg+ |ohvh ct giks gih ~gttcfkh vhbtgi)Vhjbvlkhtt ge oct dvhlhi|cbkt bil oct bddh~|bidh fs oct ~hhvt+ |oh vhbtgi ct |ob| oh lghti*| bd|xbxilhvt|bil oct txf`hd| ab||hv) Ci |oh vhabcilhv ge |oct |h|+ |oh zvc|hv og~ht |g fh bfkh |g ~btt |ob

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 5/110

|ht| ge xilhvt|bilbfckc|s bil ~vguclh |oh vhblhv zc|o b xthexk citcjo| ci|g |oh ib|xvh ge t~bdh+ |cahab||hv+ jvbuc|b|cgi+ bil dgtagkgjs ci b abiihv zocdo ct dgitct|hi| zc|o |oh ~ostcdbk kbzt |bxjo| cxilhvjvblxb|h khuhk ~ostcdt) \oh bx|ogv*t |ggkt bvh oct tca~kh acilhl fhkche |ob| |ohvh ct giks gihvhbkc|s bil huhvs|ocij zh bddh~| bt |vxh bfgx| |ob| vhbkc|s axt| fh dgitct|hi| zc|o huhvs|ocij hkthzh bddh~| bt |vxh bil oct tca~kh acilhl fhkche |ob| Ib|xvh ct dgit|vxd|hl ci |oh agt|t|vbcjo|egvzbvl abiihv ~gttcfkh) Zc|o |ob| ci acil+ |oh bx|ogv og~ht |ob| zob| egkkgzt zckk fh fg|ocit|vxd|cuh bil ci|hvht|cij |g |oh vhblhv bil db~bfkh ge vbctcij |oh fkggl ~vhttxvh ge |oh bdblhacddgaaxic|s) Hi`gs"

2):! /Ig|h0 B vcjgvgxt lhvcub|cgi ge |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl bil c|t heehd|t gi dgtagkgjs ct ~vguclhlci |oh bx|ogv*t |h| &Jvbuc|s& dg~svcjo|hl ci 23??) \oct |h| zbt thi|+ b| |oh |cah+ |g cilcuclxbktclhi|cechl bt obucij b vh~x|b|cgi ci |oh echkl) Tcidh |ohi+ |oh bx|ogv obt vhbl tgah ge |ohdgidkxtcgit ~vhthi|hl ci &Jvbuc|s& ci fggmt txfthrxhi|ks zvc||hi fs b ehz ge |ogth cilcuclxbkt)Lxh |g |oh dgi|vguhvtcbk ib|xvh ge |oct |h|+ xikhtt vhrxcvhl fs |oh txf`hd| ab||hv+ |oh ibaht gecilcuclxbkt bil ~xfkcdb|cgit obuh fhhi gac||hl ci gvlhv |g ~vhuhi| |ohcv ~gttcfkh hafbvvbttahi|)#

Dob~|hv 6 ! Oct|gvcdbk Fbdmjvgxil

6)2! Fs |oh kbt| rxbv|hv ge |oh 23|o dhi|xvs+ |oh Tdchidh ge ^ostcdt zbt dgitclhvhl |g fh ihbvksdga~kh|h) \oh hkhd|vgabjih|cd hrxb|cgit ge @baht Dkbvm Abzhkk obl h~kbcihl hkhd|vgabjih|cdvblcb|cgi bil kcjo| zbt dgitclhvhl |g fh b ucfvb|cgibk zbuh ~vg~bjb|cij |ovgxjo b ahlcxa dbkkhl|oh Bh|ohv ci b abiihv tcackbv |g |oh ~vg~bjb|cgi ge tgxil |ovgxjo bcv) Xtcij Abzhkk*tHkhd|vgabjih|cd Hrxb|cgit+ @) @) \ogatgi lhvcuhl |oh vhkb|cgitoc~ fh|zhhi abtt bil hihvjs+

H1AD6+ ci 2??? zohi |oh bkkhjhl tgxvdh ge |ob| vhkb|cgitoc~ /Lv) Hcit|hci# zbt t|ckk ci mihh ~bi|t/\oh bx|ogv obt tcidh vhdhcuhl bi H!abck zocdo btthv|t |ob| b Av) Gkci|g L) ^vh||g ge C|bks ~xfkctoh|oct vhkb|cgitoc~ ci 23>4) \oct vhbkks lghti*| ab||hv |gg axdo+ zob| ct dkhbv ct |ob| Lv) Hcit|hci zbtig| |oh gvcjcibk tgxvdh ge |oh vhkb|cgitoc~ egv zocdo oh zbt dvhlc|hl)# B lceecdxk|s zocdo vhabcihlzbt |ob| kcjo| zbt migzi |g fh b tohbv ucfvb|cgi bd|cij ci b ~kbih ~hv~hilcdxkbv |g |oh lcvhd|cgi ge~vg~bjb|cgi vb|ohv |obi b dga~vhttcgibk ucfvb|cgi bd|cij ci |oh lcvhd|cgi ge ~vg~bjb|cgi) Tcidhtohbv ucfvb|cgit dbiig| ~vg~bjb|h |ovgxjo b ekxcl+ c| zbt vhdgjicphl |ob| |oh Bh|ohv axt| fh tgkcl\oct dgidkxtcgi vbcthl |oh ci|hvht|cij rxht|cgi ge ogz ab|hvcbk ~bv|cdkht dgxkl aguh |ovgxjo btgkcl zc|ogx| vhtct|bidh) Huhi tg+ |oh dgidh~| ge |oh Bh|ohv zbt tg ~hvtxbtcuh |ob| |oh ih| kgjcdbt|h~ zbt bi b||ha~| |g ahbtxvh |oh heehd|t ge dobijht ci |oh uhkgdc|s ge |oh Hbv|o bt c| |vbuhkhl|ovgxjo |oh Bh|ohv ci c|t gvfc| bvgxil |oh Txi)

6)6! \oh agt| tcjicecdbi| ge |oh h~hvcahi|t zbt dgilxd|hl fs |oh |oh |hba ge Acdohktgi bilAgvkhs) \ohs lhucthl bi h~hvcahi| xtcij g~|cdbk ci|hvehvgah|vs zocdo b||ha~|hl |g ahbtxvh |ohlceehvhidh ci |oh uhkgdc|s ge ~vg~bjb|cgi ge kcjo| fh|zhhi |zg ax|xbkks ~hv~hilcdxkbv lcvhd|cgit) \ghuhvsgih*t dobjvci+ |oh h~hvcahi| ~vglxdhl b ixkk vhtxk|" Ig ci|hvehvhidh heehd|t zhvh gfthvuhl b|oh Hbv|o dobijhl c|t uhkgdc|s |ovgxjo |oh os~g|oh|cdbk Bh|ohv fs 45 ackht ~hv thdgil guhv |oh

dgxvth ge b shbv huhi |ogxjo |oh ~vhdctcgi+ bddxvbds+ bil t|bfckc|s ge |oh h~hvcahi|bk th|x~ zbtagvh |obi blhrxb|h |g vhuhbk |oh bi|cdc~b|hl heehd|t)

6)4! Cic|cbk b||ha~|t b| h~kbcicij |oh ixkk vhtxk| ge |oh Acdohktgi!Agvkhs H~hvcahi| ~vglxdhlxitxddhttexk dgidh~|t txdo bt |oh Bh|ohv Lvce| \ohgvs ci zocdo |oh Bh|ohv zbt ~vhtxahl |g fhdbvvchl bkgij zc|o |oh Hbv|o+ fx| fs 23>4 |oh Kgvhi|p Dgi|vbd|cgi!Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs zbt~xfkctohl) \oh mhs |g |oct |ohgvs zbt |oh Ec|pjhvbkl Dgi|vbd|cgi zocdo btthv|hl |ob| |oh khij|o geab|hvcbk gf`hd|t+ ci |oh lcvhd|cgi ge ag|cgi+ zbt vhlxdhl bt b exid|cgi ge |oh uhkgdc|s ge |oh gf`hd|

|ovgxjo |oh Bh|ohv ci ~vg~gv|cgi |g /2!U6'D6#>)8 fx| zhvh xibeehd|hl ci lcvhd|cgit ~hv~hilcdxkbv |g|ob| uhkgdc|s) C| zbt caahlcb|hks vhdgjicphl fs Kbvagv |ob| |oh Ec|pjhvbkl Dgi|vbd|cgi vhrxcvhl bihrxcubkhi| tkgzcij ci |oh vb|h ge ~bttbjh ge |cah) Tcidh+ fs |ob| |cah Kgvhi|p obl xthl |oh migzi

hrxcubkhidh fh|zhhi abtt bil hihvjs |g ~vguclh |oh heehd|t ge uhkgdc|s gi abtt+ 2'/2!U6'D6#>)8+

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 6/110

|vbitegvab|cgit ciugkucij |oh h~vhttcgi /2!U6'D6#>)8 fhdbah migzi bt Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgit)Dgkkhd|cuhks+ |ohth |vbitegvab|cgit fhdbah migzi bt |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi!Bh|ohv \ohgvs) Bagvh ahbicijexk ibah zgxkl thha |g fh |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs+ bil c| zckk fh vhehvvhl |g fs|oct ibah zohvh ihdhttbvs |g lct|cijxcto c| evga |oh T~hdcbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s) Xilhv |oct |ohgvuhkgdc|s |ovgxjo |oh Bh|ohv dbxthl ahbtxvcij cit|vxahi|t |g dobijh |ohcv dbkcfvb|cgit cigfhlchidh |g |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgit) \ogth dobijht ci dbkcfvb|cgi zhvh ge hbd|ks |oh dgvvhdbagxi| |g citxvh |ob|+ ci dgi`xid|cgi zc|o |oh ecic|h uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|+ c| zbt ca~gttcfkh |g gfthvuhheehd|t ~vglxdhl fs gxv uhkgdc|s |ovgxjo t~bdh /|oh Bh|ohv#)

Vhlhecic|cgi0! Tcidh |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi+ /2!U6'D6#>)8+ b~~hbvt abis |caht ci |ohab|hvcbk zocdo egkkgzt egkkgzt+ |oh tsafgk *Fu* zckk fh txft|c|x|hl) \oxt0 Fu1/2!U6'D6#>)8)

r

6)<! Tcidh huhvs|ocij zh h~hvchidh+ cidkxlcij |oh ~ostcgkgjcdbk thitb|cgit bil fhobucgv ge gxvfglcht+ ct |oh vhtxk| ge b ahbtxvhahi| ge tgah |s~h+ gxv bftgkx|h uhkgdc|s zc|o vht~hd| |g t~bdhdgxkl ihuhv fh gfthvuhl) Ig ab||hv zob| gih*t bftgkx|h uhkgdc|s zbt+ oh dgxkl bkzbst bttxahocathke |g fh b| vht| zc|o vht~hd| |g t~bdh bil |ob| huhvs|ocij |ob| zbt ig| b| vht| zc|o vht~hd| |goca zbt agucij |ovgxjo |oh Bh|ohv) Zc|o |oh heehd|t gi gfthvub|cgit ca~gthl fs |oh Bh|ohvVhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs+ ahbtxvhahi| ge bi gfthvuhv*t uhkgdc|s zc|o vht~hd| |g |oh Bh|ohv zbt ~vhuhi|hlfs |oh ebd| |ob| |oh ecic|h uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ablh c| ca~gttcfkh |g lh|hvacih zohi |zg ~ostcdbkksth~bvb|hl huhi|t zhvh tcaxk|bihgxt) Zohi |oh cibfckc|s ge bi gfthvuhv |g dgaaxicdb|h ebt|hv |obi

|oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ct dgitclhvhl+ c| ct tca~kh fx| |hlcgxt |g togz+ xtcij hkhahi|bvs bkjhfvb+ |ob||oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs citxvht b ixkk vhtxk| ge bis b||ha~| |g lh|hvacih bi bftgkx|h uhkgdc|s/uhkgdc|s zc|o vht~hd| |g |oh Bh|ohv#) Bi gfthvuhv ct |ohvhegvh evhh |g dgitclhv |ob| bis uhkgdc|svhehvhidh evbah fh|zhhi |oh kcac|t ge -'!D ct ubkcl bt b fbth vhehvhidh evbah egv abmcij ~ostcdbkgfthvub|cgit)

6)8! B| |oh |cah+ |ovhh lceecdxk|cht thhahl |g vhabci zc|o |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs) \oh ecvt|gf`hd|cgi zbt |ob| c| lcl ig| bddgxi| egv |oh heehd|t ge uhkgdc|s gi hkhd|vgabjih|cd ~ohigahib) \ogf`hd|cgi zbt ig| b khjc|cab|h gih) \oh |ovhh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgit bkkgz |oh lhvcub|cgi gehrxcubkhi| Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgit egv bkk ~ostcdbk ~bvbah|hvt+ cidkxlcij |ogth gehkhd|vgabjih|cdt+ fs b~~kscij Lcahitcgibk Bibkstct |g migzi ~ostcdbk hrxb|cgit) Zohi |ohthlhvcuhl |vbitegvab|cgit bvh b~~kchl |g hkhd|vgabjih|cd ~ohigahib+ |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs ct

egxil |g fh ubkcl egv hkhd|vgabjih|cd ~ohigahib bt zhkk) \oh thdgil gf`hd|cgi zbt |oh rxht|cgi b|g zos+ ce |oh dkbttcdbk Bh|ohv ct |oh bftgkx|h phvg uhkgdc|s vhehvhidh egv t~bdh c|thke+ togxkl Ib|xvhdgit~cvh |g dgidhbk gxv uhkgdc|s zc|o vht~hd| |g c|) \ob| abs obuh fhhi b vhbtgibfkh rxht|cgi b| |o|cah+ fx| ci |oh ci|hvca+ rxbi|xa ~ostcdct|t obuh dgidkxlhl |ob| |oh egvdht fh|zhhi ~bv|cdkht+ txdbt fh|zhhi |oh b|gat ci b ahbtxvcij t|cdm+ bvh hkhd|vgabjih|cd ci ib|xvh bil bvh bkkhjhl |g vhtxk|evga |oh hdobijh ge ucv|xbk ~og|git) B dgvgkkbvs |g |ob| dgidkxtcgi ct |ob| tcidh hkhd|vgabjih|cdheehd|t |vbuhk b| |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|+ ab||hv axt| bl`xt| c|t ~bvbah|hvt tg |ob| |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|b~~hbvt xidobijhl |g b kgdbk gfthvuhv) /C| ct egv|xib|h |ob| |ohth bl`xt|ahi|t gddxv) Ce |ohs lcl ig|vbuhk b| ocjo uhkgdc|s+ txdo bt |oh uhkgdc|s ge |oh Hbv|o ci c|t gvfc| gv |oh uhkgdc|s ge |oh Txi ci c|tjbkbd|cd gvfc|+ dgxkl fh h|vhahks obpbvlgxt |g gih*t ohbk|o)# \oh ecibk gf`hd|cgi |g |oh Bh|ohvVhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs ct |ob| ce |oh Bh|ohv ct b tgkcl ahlcxa+ bt vhrxcvhl egv |oh ~vg~bjb|cgi ge |oh kcjo|

bt b |vbituhvth zbuh+ ab||hv togxkl ig| fh bfkh |g |vbuhk |ovgxjo c| zc|ogx| vhtct|bidh) B ahbit fszocdo Ib|xvh abs obuh vhtgkuhl |ob| gf`hd|cgi ct ~vguclhl kb|hv)

6)5! Ci 23>8 Lv) Hcit|hci+ b~~bvhi|ks thitcij bi g~~gv|xic|s ci |oh bkkhjhl ebckxvh ge |oh Bh|ohvVhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs |g dgvvhd|ks ~vhlcd| |oh hkhd|vgabjih|cd heehd|t bttgdcb|hl zc|o uhkgdc|s+ ~xfkcto|oh T~hdcbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s) \oct |ohgvs zbt fbthl x~gi ^gcidbvh*t ^vcidc~kh ge Vhkb|cuc|s bilbtthv|hl |ob| bis uhkgdc|s fh|zhhi |oh kcac|t ge -'!D dgxkl fh dgitclhvhl |g fh ubkcl egv xth bt bphvg uhkgdc|s vhehvhidh egv |oh ~xv~gth ge ~ostcdbk gfthvub|cgit) \oh T~hdcbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s~vguclhl |oh tbah |vbitegvab|cgit egv abtt+ khij|o+ bil |cah bt lcl |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs~xfkctohl |zg shbvt hbvkchv) Xilhv fg|o b~~vgbdoht+ bis cidgitct|hidcht vhtxk|cij evga |oh heehd|tge uhkgdc|s gi gfthvub|cgit zhvh dgidhbkhl fs |oh heehd|t ge |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgit bil |ohebd| |ob| |oh ecic|h uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ablh |oh bftgkx|h tsidovgicpb|cgi ge ~ostcdbkks th~bvb|hl

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 7/110

dkgdmt ca~gttcfkh) Bt zc|o |oh T~hdcbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s+ |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs bkkgzhlgih+ vhjbvlkhtt ge oct uhkgdc|s |ovgxjo t~bdh+ |g fh evhh |g dgitclhv ocathke b| vht| bil b~~ks |ohKgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgit |g gfthvub|cgit ablh ci tst|hat zocdo zhvh agucij zc|o vht~hd| |gocathke) C| axt| fh ~gci|hl gx| |ob| T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s lcl ig| obuh |oh lceecdxk|cht zc|o vht~hd| |ghkhd|vgabjih|cd ~ohigahib bkkhjhl |g fh b zhbmihtt ge |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs egv |oh tca~vhbtgi |ob|+ cit|hbl ge vhtgkucij |ogth lceecdxk|cht+ c| bvfc|vbvcks lhecihl |oha bt igi!hct|hi|)

6):! Zohi gih dga~bvht |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs bil T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s gf`hd|cuhks+ gih ecilt|ob| |ohs bvh clhi|cdbk |ohgvcht bil lceehv giks ci ~ockgtg~ocdbk ci|hv~vh|b|cgi) Xilhv |oh Bh|ohv

Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs+ t~bdh ct eckkhl zc|o b ahlcxa dbkkhl |oh Bh|ohv zocdo bd|t bt |oh evbahzgvm egv|oh Xicuhvth bil gxv uhkgdc|s |ovgxjo |ob| Bh|ohv ct dgidhbkhl fs |oh heehd|t lhtdvcfhl bfguh)Xilhv T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s+ |oh bftgkx|h uhkgdc|s vhehvhidh vh~vhthi|hl fs |oh Bh|ohv ct gac||hl tcidc| lght ig| b~~hbv ci |oh ab|ohab|cdt) Fg|o |ohgvcht dgidkxlh |ob| |oh heehd|t ge uhkgdc|s giahbtxvcij cit|vxahi|t /cidkxlcij |oh ~ostcgkgjcdbk thitgvt ge gxv fglcht# bil |oh ecic|h uhkgdc|s gkcjo| abmh c| b~~hbv |g bis gfthvuhv |ob| oh ct b| vht| bil |ob| huhvs|ocij obucij b uhkgdc|s vhkb|cuh|g oca ct ci ag|cgi) C| togxkl fh gfucgxt |g bkk |ob| |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs ct b t~hdcbk dbthtgkx|cgi ge |oh T~hdcbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s ci zocdo gih ge |oh ciecic|h ixafhv ge phvg uhkgdc|svhehvhidht evbaht dgitclhvhl |g fh ubkcl xilhv T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s ct |oh dgvvhd| gih huhi |ogxjogih dbiig| lh|hvacih oct uhkgdc|s zc|o vht~hd| |g c|) T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s |bmht |oh ~gtc|cgi |ob|+ tcidgxv uhkgdc|s zc|o vht~hd| |g bi bftgkx|h t~b|cbk vhehvhidh dbiig| fh lh|hvacihl fs gfthvub|cgi+ c| ahbicijkhtt |g dgitclhv |oh hct|hidh ge bi bftgkx|h uhkgdc|s vhehvhidh bt ~bv| ge ~ostcdbk |ohgvsBt zh tobkk thh+ ig| giks dbi gxv bftgkx|h t~b|cbk uhkgdc|s fh ahbtxvhl+ btthv|cij |ob| c| dbi*|ucgkb|ht b fbtcd vxkh) Gih togxkl fh h|vhahks dbvhexk ci lhdkbvcij tgah|ocij |g fh ca~gttcfkh)Ciubvcbfks bt tggi bt txdo b lhdkbvb|cgi ct ablh+ tgah lbaihl eggk zckk dgah bkgij bil lg c|)

6)?! Vhdgjic|cgi |ob| gxv bftgkx|h uhkgdc|s |ovgxjo t~bdh dbiig| fh ahbtxvhl ct b ebv dvs evga b~vgge |ob| bi bftgkx|h uhkgdc|s lght ig| hct|) Ce c| zhvh ~vguhi |ob| |oh bftgkx|h uhkgdc|s vhehvhidhvh~vhthi|hl fs |oh Bh|ohv zbt ig| ubkcl+ |ohi c| zgxkl fh ~vguhi |ob| gih ge |oh uhkgdc|cht |ob|T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s bkkgzt |g fh dgitclhvhl bt b| vht| dbi ig| fh xthl bt b fbtct egv ~ostcdbkh~hvcahi|t) Txdo b ~vgge zgxkl bktg fh b ~vgge |ob| T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s zbt ciubkcl) B~~bvhi|ks+ LvHcit|hci |ogxjo| |oh ci|hv~vh|b|cgit bttgdcb|hl zc|o |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs |g fh dgvvhd| tcidc| obt fhhi vh~gv|hl |ob| oh abci|bcihl b fhkche ci bftgkx|h tcaxk|bihc|s fh|zhhi ~ostcdbkks

th~bvb|hl huhi|t /b fhkche zocdo vhrxcvht |oh hct|hidh ge |oh Bh|ohv# egv 68 shbvt be|hv |oh~xfkcdb|cgi ge T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s) Oh bktg ct vh~gv|hl |g obuh zbvihl |ob| &zh obuh ig| ~vguhi |ob||oh Bh|ohv lghti*| hct|+ zh obuh giks ~vguhi |ob| zh lg ig| ihhl c| ]egv dga~x|b|cgitQ&)

6)3! Tcidh |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs ~vhdhlhl |oh T~hdcbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s fs |zg shbvt bilzbt ci bd|xbkc|s |oh tbah |ohgvs ci b lceehvhi| egva+ c| zbt ihdhttbvs |g abmh b lh|hvacib|cgifh|zhhi |oha) \ob| fhdbah b ab||hv ge fhkche vb|ohv |obi ~vgge bil+ bt |oh axk|c|xlcigxt lhb|ot civhkcjcgxt zbvt guhv |oh dhi|xvcht obuh ba~ks lhagit|vb|hl+ |oh agvh xi~vgubfkh b fhkche ct+ |ohagvh tbubjhks ahi zckk ecjo| |g lhehil c|) Txdo b tbubjhvs gddxvvhl ci |oh lctdxttcgit zocdoegkkgzhl) \oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs zbt blugdb|hl fs b dblvh ge ~ostcdbk tdchi|ct|t zogth~vcabvs vhkcbidh zbt gi |ohcv ~ostcdbk citcjo|t bil zog xthl |ohcv ab|ohab|cdbk tmckkt |g rxbi|ces|oh vhtxk|t ge |ogth citcjo|t) T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s zbt blugdb|hl fs b lceehvhi| dblvh ge ~ostcdct|t

zog obl abt|hvhl ab|ohab|cdt zhkk fx| zog obl egxil |ob| |ohcv xth ge ~ostcdbk citcjo|t+ zocdo+kcmh bv|+ vhrxcvht bi ciib|h b~|c|xlh ci bllc|cgi |g |vbcicij+ zhvh xivhkcbfkh) Tcidh |bkhi| ct tdbvdh cibis echkl+ |oh blugdb|ht ge T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s zgi |oh fb||kh) \oh ~vg~gihi|t ge |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|\ohgvs zhvh vclcdxkhl fs obucij |oh Bh|ohv dga~bvhl |g |oh Ha~hvgv*t Dkg|oht ci |oh ebfkh ge |ohtbah ibah) \oh jhihvbk ~xfkcd zbt khl |g fhkchuh |ob| |oh ast|hvs vhtxk|cij evga |oh ixkk vhtxk|t g|oh Acdohktgi!Agvkhs H~hvcahi| zbt vhtgkuhl fs Lv) Hcit|hci huhi |ogxjo Ec|pjhvbkl+ Kbvagv bilKgvhi|p obl bdochuhl |ob| vhtxk| |zg shbvt hbvkchv)

6)2>! \oh bx|ogv ct thvcgxtks |vgxfkhl fs |oh oct|gvcdbk bddgxi|t) \oh ebd| |ob| |oh migzkhljh bilcitcjo| |g vhtgkuh |oh lckhaab vh~vhthi|hl fs |oh Acdohktgi!Agvkhs H~hvcahi| obl bkvhbls fhhi~vguclhl fs |vxks ci|hkkcjhi| ahi /\oga~tgi+ Kgvhi|p+ Kbvagv+ bil ht~hdcbkks Ec|pjhvbkl#+ lhjvblht

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 8/110

Lv) Hcit|hci*t dgi|vcfx|cgi ci |oct bvhb evga b zgvm ge fvckkcbidh |g |oh vb|ohv |vcucbk hhvdcth geegvaxkb|cij |oh hct|cij migzkhljh ci|g ab|ohab|cdbk |hvat egv hbtchv xth ci dga~x|b|cgibk

bd|cuc|cht) ]Lv) Hcit|hci*t ebagxt hrxb|cgi+ /lT#61/l_#6-/lS#6-/lP#6!D/l\#6+ zocdo ct bddh~|hl bt|oh agt| txddcid| ahbit ge lhecicij |oh heehd|t ge uhkgdc|s+ egkkgzt evga |oh ebd| |ob| |oh Kgvhi|p\vbitegvab|cgit egv khij|o bil |cah bvh clhi|cdbk |g |oh ^s|objgvhbi \ohgvha)Q Ogzhuhv+ |oh~gkc|cdt ge |oh tdchi|cecd dgaaxic|s zbt ig| thvuhl fs dvhlc|cij Ec|pjhvbkl zc|o |oh dgidh~|xbkfvhbm|ovgxjo tcidh oct b~~vgbdo lcl ig| txc| c|t jgbkt) Bt b vhtxk|+ Lv) Hcit|hci zbt jcuhi |ob|ogigv bil zbt huhi|xbkks ~vgdkbcahl b lhc|s ge |oh ihz vhkcjcgi zockh |oh |vxh dgi|vcfx|gvt zhvhvhkhjb|hl |g egg|ig|ht ci |h|fggmt)

6)22! \oh t|vhij|o ge |oh ehhkcijt ciugkuhl zhvh fvgxjo| ogah |g |oh zvc|hv fs ~hvtgibk h~hvchidhCi |oh kb|h 238>*t+ bttxacij |ob| T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s obl fhhi ~vguhi |g ubkclks vh~vhthi| gxv vhbkc|s|oh bx|ogv fhjbi b jggl ebc|o t|xls ge |oh txf`hd| egv oct gzi tb|ctebd|cgi) C| zbt vb|ohv x~th||cij|g khbvi |oh ciegvab|cgi ~vguclhl ci |oh ~vhucgxt ~bvbjvb~ot) Lcjjcij lhh~hv+ |oh bx|ogv fgvvgzhlb |hdoicrxh evga ab|ohab|cdt |g togz |ob| |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s ci|hv~vh|b|cgi axt| fh dgvvhd|fhdbxth bttxacij |oh igi!hct|hidh ge |oh Bh|ohv khl |g bi bftxvlc|s) Ci lxh dgxvth+ |oct ab|hvcbzbt togzi |g b ~ostcdct| zogth t~hdcbk|s zbt T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s) \oh abi*t vhbd|cgi zbtbt|gictocij) Oh lcl ig| |bmh |oh ci|hkkhd|xbkks vhbtgibfkh bk|ogxjo xilc~kgab|cd t|h~ ge |hkkcij |ohbx|ogv |ob| oh zbt bi cjigvbi| eggk+ cit|hbl oh zhi| ci|g b vbjh bil bddxthl |oh bx|ogv ge fhcij&lbijhvgxt ohvh|cd zog axt| fh tx~~vhtthl&) /C| ct egv|xib|h egv |oh bx|ogv |ob| |oct cti*| |oh 25|o

dhi|xvs)# Oct ucgkhi| hag|cgibk vhbd|cgi zbt bmci |g |ob| ge |oh Axtkca Bsb|gkkbo zog bkkhjhlksdgilhaihl |oh bx|ogv ge |oh &Tb|bicd Uhvtht& |g lhb|o) \oh vhbd|cgi dgxkl giks obuh dgah evga bcilcuclxbk zogth rxbtc!vhkcjcgxt fhkchet zhvh |ovhb|hihl) \ohs zhvh ig| |oh vhbd|cgit ge b abi zobddh~|hl Lv) Hcit|hci*t lcd|xa |ob| |oh thbvdo egv |vx|o axt| |bmh ~vhdhlhidh guhv |oh |hbdocijt ght|bfkctohl bx|ogvc|s vhjbvlkhtt ge |oh ~vht|cjh ge |ob| bx|ogvc|s)

6)26! Ci 2328+ Lv) Hcit|hci ~xfkctohl oct Jhihvbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s) Ci lhvcucij |oct |ohgvs ohdgafcihl b ihz bil b~~bvhi|ks gvcjcibk dgidh~|+ |oh ^vcidc~kh ge Hrxcubkhidh+ zc|o |oh ^vcidc~kh gVhkb|cuc|s x~gi zocdo T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s zbt fbthl) Tca~ks t|b|hl+ |oh ^vcidc~kh ge Hrxcubkhidhbtthv|t |ob| jvbuc|b|cgibk bddhkhvb|cgi dbi fh dgitclhvhl |g fh hrxcubkhi| |g cihv|cbk bddhkhvb|cgi)Xiegv|xib|hks+ Lv) Hcit|hci ebckhl |g vhdgjicph |ob| \hitgv Dbkdxkxt dbiig| fh xthl |g lhvcuh bvhkb|cuct|cd |ohgvs /bt lctdxtthl kb|hv# bil ha~kgshl |ob| ab|ohab|cdbk |hdoicrxh ci |oh |ohgvs*t

lhvcub|cgi) C|t xth egv txdo b ~xv~gth ci|vglxdhl b ab|ohab|cdbk hvvgv ge b |s~h zocdo+ ce~hvtct|hi|ks ablh fs b t|xlhi| ge Hkhahi|bvs Dbkdxkxt+ zgxkl vhtxk| ci b ebckcij jvblh egv |ohdgxvth) Bt b vhtxk| ge |oct hvvgv+ |oh lhvcub|cgi ge Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s zbt ca~gttcfkh ci |hvat ge gxgfthvubfkh |ovhh lcahitcgibk Hxdkclcbi T~bdh)

6)24! Cit|hbl ge vhdgjicpcij bil dgvvhd|cij |oh tgxvdh ge oct lceecdxk|s+ Lv) Hcit|hci |ggm |oh hbtszbs gx| bil bvfc|vbvcks bllhl bi h|vb lhjvhh ge evhhlga fs btthv|cij |ob| t~bdh zbt dxvuhl fs |o~vhthidh ge abtt bil zbt ~vg~hvks lhtdvcfhl fs |oh igi!Hxdkclcbi jhgah|vs ge Vchabii)Gf`hd|cuhks+ oct b~~vgbdo acjo| fh dga~bvhl |g |ob| ge b ahdobicd zog cit|bkkt |oh zvgij ~bv| ci abdocih fs obaahvcij c| ci|g ~kbdh cit|hbl ge gf|bcicij |oh dgvvhd| ~bv|) Lctdxttcgit ge JhihvbkVhkb|cuc|s b| |oh |cah `xt|cechl c|t ubkclc|s fs |zg vb|ohv rxht|cgibfkh bil cvvht~gitcfkh bvjxahi|t)\oh ecvt| bvjxahi| zbt |ob| |ohvh zbt ig vhbtgi ig| |g bddh~| |oh clhb |ob| t~bdh zbt dxvuhl

&tcidh ig gih dgxkl ~vguh |ob| c| zbti*|& /b ~vgge |ob| t~bdh ct ekb| zckk fh lhtdvcfhl kb|hv#) \ohthdgil bvjxahi| zbt |ob|+ zockh Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s |bxjo| |ob| |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl dvhb|hl hihvjevga ig|ocijihtt+ |oh Kbz ge Dgithvub|cgi ge Hihvjs zbt ig| ucgkb|hl tcidh |oh hihvjs zocdo zbtdvhb|hl dgxkl ig| htdb~h evga |oh echkl) C| zgxkl thha+ evga |oct vhbtgicij+ |ob| |oh Kbz geDgithvub|cgi ge Hihvjs gfhshl |oh Hkhuhi|o Dgaabilahi|+ &\ogx Tobk| Ig| Jh| Dbxjo|&)/Ihz|gicbi Jvbuc|b|cgibk \ohgvs bktg btthv|t |ob| |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl dvhb|ht hihvjs bil bkkgzt|ob| hihvjs |g htdb~h evga |oh echkl) \ob| |ohgvs axt| fh egvjcuhi egv |oct lhecdchids fhdbxth+ ci |o25|o dhi|xvs+ c| obl ig| fhhi vhdgjicphl |ob| hihvjs axt| fh dgithvuhl)#

6)2<! Bt b vhtxk| ge |oh lhehd| ci c|t ah|ogl ge lhvcub|cgi+ |oh vhkb|cuct|cd dgvvhd|cgit |g |oh dkbttcdbIhz|gicbi Jvbuc|b|cgibk \ohgvs ~vguclhl fs Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s zhvh ig| vcjgvgxtks dgvvhd| fx| zhv

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 9/110

giks b~~vgcab|cgit) B| |oh echkl t|vhij|o hct|cij b| |oh txvebdh ge |oh Txi+ |ohth dgvvhd|cgitvhucthl |oh ~vhlcd|cgit ge Ihz|gicbi Jvbuc|b|cgibk \ohgvs fs gih ~bv| ci b ackkcgi) Lxh |g |ohzhbmihtt ge |oh Txi*t echkl+ Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s zbt bfkh |g ~vhlcd|+ |g zc|oci |oh kcac|t geh~hvcahi|bk bddxvbds+ |oh bigabkgxt ~vhdhttcgi ge Ahvdxvs*t gvfc|+ |oh fhilcij ge |oh ~b|o ge bvbs ge kcjo| bt c| ~btthl dkgth |g |oh Txi bil |oh tkgzcij ge |cah b| |oh txvebdh ge |oh Txi huclhidhfs |oh vhl toce| ge c|t t~hd|vbk kciht) \oh heehd|t dbxthl fs vhtclxbk hvvgvt ci Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|svhtxk|cij evga c|t ciubkcl ah|ogl ge lhvcub|cgi bvh bfgx| b ackkcgi |caht |gg tabkk |g fh gfthvuhlzc|oci |oh Tgkbv Tst|ha)

6)28! C| obt fhhi btthv|hl |ob| gfthvub|cgit ablh ge |oh vhl toce| ge |oh t~hd|vbk kciht ci |oh kcjo|evga h|vhahks lhith bil'gv h|vhahks abttcuh t|bvt bil |oh gfthvuhl dobijh ci |oh gvfc|bk ~hvcgge abttcuh fcibvs t|bvt lxh |g jvbuc|b|cgibk vblcb|cgi ~vguclh |oh ihdhttbvs uhvcecdb|cgi egv JhihvbVhkb|cuc|s ci t|vgij echklt) Ogzhuhv+ ci gvlhv egv txdo gfthvub|cgit |g ~vguclh |ob| uhvcecdb|cgi+ |ohsaxt| fh dgafcihl zc|o gvfc|bk gfthvub|cgit ablh fs bi gi!tc|h gfthvuhv) Xi|ck abimcil obt |ohhrxcubkhi| ge T|bv \vhm*t Zbv~ Lvcuh+ gfthvub|cgibk ubkclb|cgi ge Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s ci t|vgijjvbuc|b|cgibk echklt zgxkl thha |g fh ca~gttcfkh) B| ~vhthi|+ bkk |ob| |oh t~hd|vbk toce| ge kcjo| evgaabttcuh t|hkkbv gf`hd|t ~vguht ct |ob| jvbuc|s ct b vhkb|cuct|cd ~ohigahib) C| lght ig| ~vguh |ob|Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s ct |oh dgvvhd| lhtdvc~|cgi ge |ob| ~ohigahib) Bt ~gci|hl gx| hbvkchv+ Lv) Hcit|hcizbt b~~bvhi|ks bzbvh ge kcac|b|cgit ci oct lhvcub|cgi ge Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s tcidh c| obt fhhi vh~gv|h|ob| oh zbt xihbts bfgx| |oh h|hitcgi ge |oh |ohgvs |g h|vhahks t|vgij echklt)

Dob~|hv 4 ! \oh Ib|xvh ge \oh Hcit|hci Ogb

4)2! Tcidh |oh T~hdcbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s bil |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs zocdo ~vhlb|hl c| bvhbd|xbkc|s |oh tbah |ohgvs bil abs fh lhvcuhl gih evga |oh g|ohv+ |oh rxht|cgi bvctht bt |g |ohib|xvh ge Lv) Hcit|hci*t dgi|vcfx|cgi |g |oh tgkx|cgi ge ~vgfkhat vhkb|hl |g uhkgdc|s) Ci b oct|gvcdbk|h| ~xfkctohl ci |oh 236>*t c| zbt t|b|hl |ob| oct ~vcidc~kh dgi|vcfx|cgi zbt |oh lhagit|vb|cgi |obab|ohab|cdt dgxkl fh xthl |g lhvcuh ~ostcdbk |ohgvs bil+ tcidh ab|ohab|cdt dgxkl fh |bxjo| |gbisgih+ Tdchidh lcl ig| ihhl |g bzbc| |oh dgi|vcfx|cgit ge |oh &ehz jvhb| acilt |ob| bvcth ci hbdodhi|xvs& /b db|hjgvs zocdo agt| dhv|bciks cidkxlht Ec|pjhvbkl# |g bdochuh ~vgjvhtt)

4)6! \oh citclcgxt hil vhtxk| ge |ob| ~ockgtg~os zbt uhvcechl fs b |hkh~ogih dbkk vhdhcuhl fs |ohbx|ogv evga b ~ostcdct| b| b ocjoks vht~hd|hl Cus Khbjxh Xicuhvtc|s zogth t|b|xt zbt txeecdchi| |gobuh obl oct zgvm lhtdvcfhl ci \cah Abjbpcih) \oh bx|ogv zbt blucthl |ob| |oh ~ostcdct|*t tgkh `gzbt |g thbvdo egv ab|ohab|cdbk vhkb|cgitoc~t zocdo ~vguclhl ~vhlcd|cgit bil |g lhucth bil ~hvegvh~hvcahi|t zocdo lh|hvacihl zoh|ohv |ogth ~vhlcd|cgit bjvhhl zc|o gfthvub|cgi) C| zbt ig|dgitclhvhl |g fh |oh ~ostcdct|*t `gf |g ~vguclh bi xilhvt|bilcij ge |oh ahdobictat fs zocdoIb|xvh bdochuhl c|t vhtxk|t) \ob| |btm zbt |oh ~vg~hv ~vgucidh ge ~ockgtg~ohvt bil ah|b!~ostcdct|bil zbt fhihb|o |oh lcjic|s ge ~ostcdct|t) \oct uchz~gci| ct vhciegvdhl fs gih ge |oh agt|vht~hd|hl |ohgvh|cdbk vhkb|cuct|cd ~ostcdct|t ci |oh zgvkl ci b t|b|hahi| ci gih ge |oh agt|

~vht|cjcgxt tdchi|cecd ~xfkcdb|cgit ci |oh zgvkl) Oh t|b|hl |ob| oh zbt xidgidhvihl bt |g zoh|ohv b|ohgvs dgvvht~gil |g vhbkc|s fhdbxth oh lcli*| migz zob| vhbkc|s zbt+ oh giks zbt dgidhvihl |ob| |ohgvs dgvvhd|ks ~vhlcd| h~hvcahi|bk vhtxk|t) \g ~kbdh |ob| ocjo tgxilcij ~ockgtg~os ci~hvt~hd|cuh+ fg|o b ocjoks |bkhi|hl axtcdcbi bil b |vbcihl dcvdxt thbk dbi ~kbs &Sbimhh Lgglkh& gb th| ge |xihl fcdsdkh ogvit bil vhdhcuh |oh b~~kbxth ge bi bxlchidh) Zockh |oh axtcdcbi zgxkl~vgfbfks zbi| agihs bil |oh thbk zgxkl fh dgi|hi| zc|o b ecto+ |oh vhbk lceehvhidh ct |ob| |ohaxtcdcbi zgxkl xilhvt|bil |oh ahbicij ge |oh axtcd zockh |oh |vbcihl thbk zgxkl obuh khbvihl |g~kbs |oh |xih |ovgxjo vh~h|c|cuh bd|cgit cilxdhl fs b |vbcihv) Xikcmh |ohcv dgxi|hv~bv|t ge b dhi|xvsbjg+ c| zgxkl thha |ob| |glbs abis abcit|vhba ~ostcdct|t lg ig| ehhk |oh ihhl |g xilhvt|bil |oh~ohigahib x~gi zocdo |ohs bvh zgvmcij fx| bvh dgi|hi| |g lg |ohcv zgvm fs abic~xkb|cijab|ohab|cdt bil h~hvcahi| xtcij ~vgdhlxvht |ohs obuh khbvihl giks fs vg|h) C| ct khe| |g |oh vhbl|g lvbz oct gzi dgidkxtcgit bt |g zoh|ohv txdo bi bibkgjs ct ebcv)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 10/110

4)4! \oh ~xfkcdb|cgi ge T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s ~vguclhl b jgklhi g~~gv|xic|s egv |oh ab`gvc|s ge |ohbdblhacd dgaaxic|s) Xilhv |oh ci|hv~vh|b|cgit ge Ib|xvh ~vguclhl fs T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s |oh lggvzbt g~hihl egv |oh ab`gvc|s ge c|t ahafhvt zog zhvh zc|ogx| |oh |bkhi| vhrxcvhl |g xilhvt|bil c|tzgvmcijt) B| |oh tbah |cah+ |ogth zc|o |oh ihdhttbvs |bkhi| ihhlhl |g xilhvt|bil vhbkc|scit|cid|cuhks vhdgjicphl |ob| dgi|vblcd|cgit zhvh ca~kcdc| ci T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s /lhtdvcfhl kb|hv# bildgxkl ig| bddh~| |oh txf`hd| bt c| zbt ~vhthi|hl) /\hbdohvt ge T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s vh~gv| |ob| btcjicecdbi| ~hvdhi|bjh ge ci|hkkcjhi| bil ab|ohab|cdbkks tmckkhl t|xlhi|t dbiig| abt|hv |oh txf`hd\oh cibfckc|s |g bddh~| T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s+ bt ~vhthi|hl+ heehd|cuhks hkcacib|ht cilcuclxbkt zc|o b

t|vgij thith ge vhbkc|s /zocdo fs big|ohv ibah ct dbkkhl dgaagi thith# evga |oh vbimt ge |ogthzog bd|hl bt bluctgvt |g ^oL dbilclb|ht bil evga |oh vgkht ge |ogth zog ~hvegva |oh ~hhv vhuchzzocdo lh|hvacih zob| ct ~xfkctohl ci tdchi|cecd `gxvibkt) Bt b vhtxk|+ b thkhd|cgi ~vgdhtt zbtjvblxbkks ~x| ci ~kbdh zocdo citxvhl |ob| giks ab|hvcbk zocdo lcl ig| |ovhb|hi |oh ubkclc|s ge T~hdcbbil Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s zbt ~xfkctohl) Ab|hvcbk zocdo b~~hbvhl |g fh b |ovhb|+ ig ab||hv ogz~gzhvexkks ~vhthi|hl bil ogz ci|hkkhd|xbkks bil gfthvub|cgibkks ubkcl+ zbt heehd|cuhks trxhkdohl)Gi |oh g|ohv obil+ ab|hvcbk zocdo tx~~gv|hl T~hdcbk bil Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s+ ig ab||hv ogz |vcucbk gbftxvl+ zbt vhblcks ~xfkctohl) Gidh |oct ~gci| zbt vhbdohl+ c| zbt ~gttcfkh |g abmh |oh dkbca |ob|oh txf`hd| ab||hv dgxkl ig| fh xilhvt|ggl ci |hvat ge dgaagi thith) C| dgxkl giks fh xilhvt|ggci |hvat ge ab|ohab|cdt bil |ohvh zhvh b kcac|hl ixafhv ge acilt ci |oh zgvkl zog dgxkl |vxksdga~vhohil Lv) Hcit|hci*t zgvm)

4)<! Hbvks dcuckcpb|cgit zhvh fbthl x~gi |oh ciuhi|cgi ge bjvcdxk|xvh bil |oh bfckc|s |g lh|hvacih |oh~vg~hv |cah egv ~kbi|cij bil obvuht|cij dvg~t zbt uhvs ca~gv|bi|) Ci |ogth tgdch|cht+ b tabkk jvgx~ge ahi t|xlchl |oh ohbuhit bil khbvihl ogz |g lcucih |oh thbtgit evga |oh ~gtc|cgit ge |oh Txi+Aggi+ ^kbih|t+ bil T|bvt) Cit|hbl ge ~bttcij bkgij |ohcv migzkhljh+ |ohs mh~| c| |g |ohathkuht bilfhdbah ~vcht|t zog ~vguclhl kceh bil lhb|o ciegvab|cgi egv tgdch|s bt b zogkh) Bt b vhtxk| ge |ohcvagig~gks ge uc|bk migzkhljh+ agvh bil agvh ~gzhv bil zhbk|o ekgzhl |g |oha bil ci |cah |ohsegvahl b vhkcjcgi) \ob| vhkcjcgi huhi|xbkks fhdbah |oh fbtct ge bkk ~gzhvexk t|b|ht vxkhl fsjgl!mcijt) Ci txdo b tgdch|s+ ohvhts zbt |oh agt| ohcigxt dvcah cabjcibfkh+ zc|o vhuhkb|cgi ge |ohthdvh|t ge |oh vhkcjcgi |g |oh abttht b dkgth thdgil) Evga |oh ubi|bjh ~gci| ge oct|gvs+ |ohag|cub|cgi ge |ohth ~vcht|t zbt gfucgxt) \ohs zgvmhl |g bdochuh higvagxt ~gzhv bil kxxvs egv|ohathkuht b| |oh h~hith ge |oh ~hbtbi|t) \ohs lcl ig| zgvm egv |oh fhihec| ge tgdch|s bt b zogkh

4)8! \oh ht|bfkctoahi| ge |oh vhkb|cuct|cd heehd|t bt b ast|hvs zocdo dgxkl ig| fh xilhvt|ggl ci|hvat ge dgaagi thith ~kbdhl |oh dgaaxic|s ge ~ostcdct|t ci|g b ~gtc|cgi tcackbv |g |ob| ge |ogthbidchi| ~vcht|t) \ohs ~gtthtthl migzkhljh zocdo dgxkl giks fh xilhvt|ggl fs |ogth cilcuclxbktzog ~gtthtthl |oh b~~vg~vcb|h *sx~* ci |oh egva ge b ^oL ci ^ostcdt) Ib|xvbkks+ ig gih zogthciib|h thith ge vhbkc|s dbxthl oca |g rxht|cgi |oh dgidkxtcgit ge Vhkb|cuc|s huhv vhdhcuhl txdo blhjvhh) /Zohi |oh zvc|hv zbt ci|hvuchzhl egv oct ecvt| `gf+ oh zbt btmhl zob| mcil ge *sx~* oh obl)^xppkhl+ oh btmhl egv bi h~kbib|cgi bil zbt |gkl |ob|+ zohi sgx t~hi| |oh agihs c| dgt|t |g jg |gdgkkhjh+ sgx zhvh ig| fxscij migzkhljh+ sgx zhvh fxscij b *sx~*) \ob| *sx~* ct vhrxcvhl tg |ob|zohi sgx thhm b `gf bil |oh ci|hvuchzhv btmt ce sgx zhi| |g dgkkhjh+ sgx dbi bitzhv *sx~*) Gedgxvth+ *sx~*t evga lceehvhi| tdoggkt bvh vb|hl lceehvhi|ks+ fx| |oh ~vcah ~xv~gth ge tdoggkcij ct |gbdochuh |ob| bkk ca~gv|bi| *sx~*+ c| ct ig| |oh bdrxctc|cgi ge migzkhljh)#

4)5! \oh Hcit|hci Ogb dgitct|t ge abci|bcicij |oh rxbtc!vhkcjcgxt fhkche |ob| |oh ~ohigahibbttgdcb|hl zc|o uhkgdc|s bil jvbuc|b|cgi dbiig| fh xilhvt|ggl fs gvlcibvs ahi xtcij |ohcv dgaagthith) C| dbi giks fh xilhvt|ggl ci |hvat ge ab|ohab|cdt ~hvegvahl fs cic|cb|ht zog ~gtthtthl |o~vhvhrxctc|h *sx~*t) Zoh|ohv c| ct vhdgjicphl gv ig|+ bkk ge |oh htthi|cbkt ge b vhkcjcgi bvh ~vhthi|)\ohvh ct b lhc|s ci |oh egva ge Lv) Hcit|hci+ zog+ kcmh agt| ge |oh ahi zog obuh obl |ob| vgkh |ovxt|gi |oha guhv |oh dhi|xvcht+ ~vgfbfks lcl ig| thhm gv huhi vhkcto c|) C| obt bi ht|bfkctohl fx|xi~vguhi th| ge |vx|ot zocdo zhvh vhuhbkhl fs |ob| lhc|s) Ecibkks+ c| ct ~vg|hd|hl fs thkhd|hllhehilhvt ge |oh ebc|o zog+ ci |oct dbth+ bd| |ovgxjo |oh ~hhv vhuchz ~vgdhtt |g citxvh |ob| ohvhts bis egva ct ihuhv ~xfkctohl) \oh ag|cuh egv |oh abci|bcicij ge |oh Hcit|hci Ogb ct vb|ohv gfucgxtc|*t agihs) Tgdch|s h~hilt b kbvjh txat tx~~gv|cij |oct ~vcht|oggl |ovgxjo |xc|cgit ~bcl fs

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 11/110

~bvhi|t bil jvbi|t fs jguhviahi|t bil cilxt|vs) \oh lgigvt fhkchuh |ohs bvh ~bscij egv |oh|hbdocij ge |oh sgxij+ ogzhuhv+ |ob| |hbdocij ct agt|ks lgih fs jvblxb|h t|xlhi|t zog bvh thhmci|ohcv gzi *sx~*t) \oh ht|bfkctohl ~gtthttgvt ge |oh ihdhttbvs *sx~*t t~hil agt| ge |ohcv |cah civhthbvdo fhdbxth+ ig| giks ct |ob| bd|cuc|s agvh ci|hvht|cij+ c| thvuht |g blubidh |ohcv |hixvh~vg|hd|hl dbvhhvt) Togxkl T~hdcbk bil'gv Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s fh togzi |g fh exilbahi|bkks ekbzhl+|oh dbvhhvt ge Vhkb|cuct|t+ agt| Dgtagkgjct|t+ bil |ogth zgvmcij gi Rxbi|xa Jvbuc|s bil'gvXicechl Echkl \ohgvs zckk obuh fhhi zbt|hl)

4):! Ci |oh ab|hvcbk zocdo egkkgzt+ |oh bx|ogv zckk b||ha~| |g ~vguclh bil `xt|ces |oh ohvhts vhrxcvhl

|g vhabmh Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs ci|g b txf`hd| zocdo fg|o dbi fh xilhvt|ggl b| |oh xilhvjvblxb|h khuhci |hvat ge dgaagi thith bil zocdo zckk hkcacib|h jkbvcij lhehd|t ci gxv dxvvhi| xilhvt|bilcij g|oh exilbahi|bk ~vcidc~kht ge Ib|xvh bil ge Dgtagkgjs)

Dob~|hv < ! Lght \oh Bh|ohv Hct|7

<)2! Tcidh |oh dgidkxtcgi |ob| |oh Bh|ohv lght ig| hct| ct fbthl x~gi xi~vguhi btthv|cgit gi |oh~bv| ge mhs ahafhvt ge |oh dgaaxic|s ge ~ostcdbk tdchi|ct|t vb|ohv |obi x~gi huclhidh zocdo

zgxkl fh blacttcfkh ci b dgxv| ge kbz+ |oh txf`hd| axt| fh hbacihl zc|o h|vhah dbvh |g jxbvlbjbcit| |oh ~gttcfckc|s |ob| huclhidh zocdo zgxkl tx~~gv| c|t hct|hidh obt ig| fhhi migzcijks gvximigzcijks tx~~vhtthl) Vhahafhv+ |ohvh bvh t|vgij ~gkc|cdbk vhbtgit zocdo bd| |g fcbt |oh`xljahi| ge |oh bdblhacd dgaaxic|s bjbcit| |oh dgidh~| ge |oh Bh|ohv) Lh|hvacicij zoh|ohv |ohBh|ohv hct|t vhrxcvht btmcij rxht|cgit zocdo bvh vhblcks bitzhvhl fs gih ci|hv~vh|b|cgi+ bilzocdo thha xibitzhvbfkh fs |oh g|ohv) Txdo rxht|cgit hidgxi|hv t|vgij vhtct|bidh zohi btmhl)Ci bllc|cgi |g |ogth rxht|cgit+ h~hvcahi|t ~hvegvahl fs rxbi|xa ~ostcdct|t obuh lhagit|vb|hl|oh ehbtcfckc|s fg|o ge ahbtxvcij |oh bftgkx|h uhkgdc|s ge bi h~hvcahi|bk th|x~ |ovgxjo t~bdh bilge dgaaxicdb|cij b| uhkgdc|cht jvhb|hv |obi |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|) Bdochucij |ohth vhtxk|t vhrxcvhtgiks acigv aglcecdb|cgit |g |ohcv h~hvcahi|bk bvvbijhahi|t)

<)6! Ogz Lght Kcjo| &Migz& Ogz Ebt| |g \vbuhk70! \oct rxht|cgi bvctht evga |oh ebd| |ob| |oh

uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ct cilh~hilhi| ge |oh uhkgdc|s ge c|t tgxvdh) Xilhv |oh ci|hv~vh|b|cgi ge vhbkc|s~vguclhl fs T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s+ kcjo| ct dgitclhvhl |g dgitct| ge ~bv|cdkht dbkkhl ~og|git zocdo |vbufbkkct|cdbkks |ovgxjo ha~|s t~bdh) Xilhv |oh ci|hv~vh|b|cgi ~vguclhl fs |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvkcjo| dgitct|t ge ~bdmh|t/~og|git# ge hkhd|vgabjih|cd ucfvb|cgi |vbitac||hl |ovgxjo b ahlcxadbkkhl |oh Bh|ohv) Tcidh gih zgxkl h~hd| |oh uhkgdc|s ge fbkkct|cd ~bv|cdkht |g fh beehd|hl fs |ohuhkgdc|s ge |ohcv tgxvdh+ T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s zgxkl thha |g fh cidb~bfkh ge lhbkcij zc|o |oct rxht|cgi\oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs+ gi |oh g|ohv obil+ obt ig lceecdxk|s) \oh uhkgdc|s ge ~vg~bjb|cgi ge bucfvb|cgi ci b ahlcxa ct lh|hvacihl fs |oh ~vg~hv|cht ge |oh ahlcxa bil ct cilh~hilhi| ge |ohuhkgdc|s ge c|t tgxvdh)

<)4! Dgitclhv b dbv |vbuhkcij lgzi b vgbl |gzbvlt b |bvjh| /Ecjxvh <)2#) Gi fgbvl |oh dbv ct b abi

zc|o b vcekh) B| |oh tclh ge |oh vgbl ct big|ohv abi zc|o bi clhi|cdbk vcekh) B| |oh cit|bi| |ob| |oh abici |oh dbv ~bttht |oh abi b| |oh tclh ge |oh vgbl+ |ohs fg|o ecvh b| |oh |bvjh|) Bt h~hd|hl+ |ohuhkgdc|s ge |oh fxkkh| ecvhl evga |oh dbv ct cidvhbthl fs |oh dbv*t uhkgdc|s bil c| vhbdoht |oh |bvjh|fhegvh |oh fxkkh| ecvhl evga |oh tclh ge |oh vgbl) \oh tgxilt ge |oh tog|t |vbuhk |gjh|ohv b| |ohuhkgdc|s ge tgxil ci bcv bil vhbdo |oh |bvjh| b| |oh tbah |cah) \oh fxkkh|t bvh ab|hvcbk ~bv|cdkht~vg`hd|hl |g |oh |bvjh| bil |vbuhk b| lceehvhi| uhkgdc|cht) \oh tgxilt ge |oh tog|t bvh ucfvb|cgit|vbuhkcij |ovgxjo b ahlcxa bil |vbuhk b| |oh tbah uhkgdc|s) Dgitclhv ih| bi bibkgjgxt h~hvcah/~ostcdbkks vhbkcpbfkh# ci zocdo b vgdmh| ct ~bttcij Abvt gi c|t zbs |g Hbv|o) B| |oh cit|bi| |ob| |ohvgdmh| ~bttht Abvt+ b vblcg gi |oh vgdmh| bil b vblcg gi Abvt thil b tcjibk |g |oh Hbv|o) Bkgij |ohzogkh ~b|o |vbuhkhl fs |ogth tcjibkt+ |ohs vhabci tclh fs tclh bil |ohs bvvcuh b| |oh Hbv|otcaxk|bihgxtks) \ohs |vbuhk |gjh|ohv lht~c|h |oh ebd| |ob| |ohs zhvh |vbitac||hl evga tgxvdhtobucij b uhkgdc|s lceehvhidh zocdo dgxkl ig| fh dga~hitb|hl b| |oh |vbitac||hvt tcidh hbdo

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 12/110

|vbitac||hv zbt cjigvbi| ge |oh uhkgdc|s ge |oh g|ohv) @xt| bt |oh tcaxk|bihgxt bvvcubk ge |oh fxkkh|tb| |oh |bvjh| ci |oh ~vhdhlcij hba~kh zgxkl dbxth b vhbtgibfkh abi |g txt~hd| tgah egva gedocdbihvs+ zgxkl ig| |oh tbah txt~cdcgit fh bvgxthl fs |oh btthv|cgi ge T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s |ob|~og|git |vbuhk fbkkct|cdbkks |ovgxjo ha~|s t~bdh b| b uhkgdc|s zocdo ct cilh~hilhi| ge |oh uhkgdc|s |ohcv tgxvdh) C| ct lceecdxk| |g hiuctcgi b ahbit fs zocdo |oh cilh~hilhidh ge |ohcv uhkgdc|cht evga|oh uhkgdc|cht ge |ohcv tgxvdht dgxkl gddxv xikhtt ~og|git zhvh zbuhkcmh lct|xvfbidht ~vg~bjb|ci|ovgxjo b ahlcxa) \g lb|h ig h~kbib|cgit+ g|ohv |obi |oh vhkcbidh gi tgah egva ge abjcd+ obuhfhhi ~vguclhl fs |oh ~vg~gihi|t ge T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s) Cit|hbl+ |ohs obuh togx|hl lgzi |ohrxht|cgi zohihuhv c| zbt vbcthl)

<)<! Zos Lght Kcjo| \vbuhk b| |oh Uhkgdc|s ge D70! Dxvvhi| gv|oglgs btthv|t |ob| |oh Bh|ohv ct ig|vhrxcvhl |g h~kbci |oh ~vg~bjb|cgi ge kcjo| b| c|t uhkgdc|s ge D) Bkk |ob| ct vhrxcvhl ct |oh abjih|cd~hvahbfckc|s+ x*+ bil |oh lchkhd|vcd dgit|bi|+ h*+ ge t~bdh) \oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ct |ohi lh|hvacihl fs

|oh h~vhttcgi D1/x*h*#>)8) Bt bi bibkgjs+ ce gih t|vcmht |oh hil ge b t|hhk vgl zc|o b obaahv+ |oh

tgxil ge |oh fkgz ~vg~bjb|ht bkgij |oh vgl b| b uhkgdc|s+ U+ lh|hvacihl fs |oh hkbt|cdc|s+ h+ bil |ohlhitc|s+ l+ ge |oh vgl ci bddgvlbidh zc|o |oh h~vhttcgi U12'/hl#>)8) Ce gih bddh~|t |oh bfguhh~kbib|cgi egv |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|+ dgitct|hids zgxkl vhrxcvh |ob| oh fh zckkcij |g bddh~| |ohdgidkxtcgi |ob|+ tcidh |oh ~vg~bjb|cgi ge tgxil b| c|t uhkgdc|s ge U vhrxcvht giks |oh hkbt|cdc|s billhitc|s ge |oh vgl+ |oh vgl c|thke abs fh vhaguhl bil giks c|t hkbt|cdc|s bil lhitc|s vh|bcihl |gh~kbci |oh ~vg~bjb|cgi ge |oh tgxil ge |oh fkgz b| |oh uhkgdc|s U) Zockh txdo b dgidkxtcgi ctgfucgxtks tckks zc|o vht~hd| |g |oh vgl+ tgahogz c| lght ig| thha tckks |g Vhkb|cuct|t zohi c| ctb~~kchl |g T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s*t ci|hv~vh|b|cgi ge |oh ~vg~bjb|cgi ge kcjo|)

<)8! Ogz Lght |oh T~hhl ge b Dkgdm Be|hv b Dobijh ci Uhkgdc|s Dga~bvh zc|o c|t T~hhl Fhegvh |ohUhkgdc|s Dobijh70! Dgitclhv+ ce sgxv zckk+ |oh egkkgzcij ~ostcdbkks vhbkcpbfkh h~hvcahi| ~hvegvahlci dga~kcbidh zc|o |oh ab|ohab|cdbk ~vhlcd|cgit ge T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs bil'gv |oh Bh|ohv

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 13/110

Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs) \ohvh bvh |zg kgdb|cgit+ ~hvob~t |oh Hbv|o /vhehvhidh evbah B# bil Abvt/vhehvhidh evbah F# bt togzi ci Ecjxvh <)6 + zocdo bvh |vbuhkcij b| b tcjicecdbi| uhkgdc|s+ U+ zc|ovht~hd| |g hbdo g|ohv) Gfthvuhvt b| hbdo kgdb|cgi ahbtxvh |oh uhkgdc|s ge |oh g|ohv kgdb|cgi xtcijLg~~khv vblbv bt -U bil !U vht~hd|cuhks) \ohvh bvh clhi|cdbk dkgdmt b| hbdo kgdb|cgi zocdo obuhfhhi tsidovgicphl fs vblcg tcjibk) Fhdbxth ge |oh ecic|h uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|+ |oh vhkb|cuh uhkgdc|sfh|zhhi |oh gfthvuhvt dbxtht hbdo ge |oha |g gfthvuh |ob| |oh dkgdm b| |oh g|ohv kgdb|cgi ctvxiicij agvh tkgzks |obi oct dkgdm) B vgdmh| toc~ ct b| vht| gi |oh Hbv|o bil dgi|bcit bi gfthvuhvbil b |ocvl clhi|cdbk dkgdm) Fg|o |oh gfthvuhv gi |oh Hbv|o bil |oh gfthvuhv ci |oh vgdmh| toc~ ecil|ob| |ohcv dkgdmt bvh vxiicij b| |oh tbah t~hhl bil |ob| |oh dkgdm gi Abvt ct vxiicij agvh tkgzks

\oh gfthvuhv gi Abvt gfthvuht |ob| fg|o |oh dkgdm gi |oh Hbv|o bil |oh dkgdm ci |oh vgdmh| bvhvxiicij agvh tkgzks |obi oct) \oh vgdmh| |ohi |bmht gee bil kbilt gi Abvt) \oh gfthvuhvt gi |ohHbv|o+ gi Abvt+ bil gi |oh vgdmh| ahbtxvh |ob| |oh uhkgdc|s ge |oh vgdmh| obt dobijhl fs -U) \ohgfthvuhv gi |oh Hbv|o ahbtxvht |ob| |oh dkgdm gi |oh vgdmh| obt tkgzhl bil c| igz vxit b| |ohtbah t~hhl bt |oh dkgdm gi Abvt) \oh gfthvuhv gi Abvt ahbtxvht |ob| |oh dkgdm gi |oh vgdmh| obt~hl x~ bil igz vxit b| |oh tbah t~hhl bt oct dkgdm) \oh gfthvuhv gi |oh vgdmh| gfthvuht igdobijh ge |oh t~hhl ge oct dkgdm+ fx|+ gfthvucij |ob| oct uhkgdc|s obt dobijhl fs U+ dgidkxlht |obc|t t~hhl bd|xbkks lcl dobijh bt b vhtxk| ge oct dobijh ci uhkgdc|s bil dgidkxlht |ob| |oh dobijhzbt dgidhbkhl evga oca fs |oh heehd|t ge |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi egv \cah)

<)5! Zc|o vht~hd| |g |oh t~hhl ge |oh dkgdm+ |oh gfthvuhv gi |oh Hbv|o btthv|t |ob| |oh t~hhl ge |ohdkgdm gi |oh vgdmh| tkgzhl+ |oh gfthvuhv gi Abvt btthv|t |ob| |oh t~hhl ge |oh dkgdm gi |oh vgdmh|cidvhbthl+ bil |oh gfthvuhv gi |oh vgdmh| bjvhht |ob| |oh t~hhl ge oct dkgdm obt dobijhl fx|vhdgjicpht |ob| |oh dobijh ct dgidhbkhl evga oca fs vhkb|cuct|cd heehd|t) \ohvh ct gih |ht| vhtxk|x~gi zocdo bkk |ovhh gfthvuhvt bjvhh bil zocdo |ohvhegvh axt| fh bddh~|hl bt gfthvub|cgibkksuhvcechl) \oh dobijh ci uhkgdc|s ge |oh vgdmh| ~vglxdhl b dobijh ci |oh t~hhl ge c|t dkgdm) Xilhv |oci|hv~vh|b|cgit ge |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs |ohvh ct ig dgidh~|xbk lceecdxk|s) \oh dobijh ci |ohuhkgdc|s ge |oh vgdmh| dbxthl |oh t~hhl ge c|t dkgdm |g dobijh xicrxhks+ fx| |oh ib|xvh ge |ob|dobijh ct dgidhbkhl evga gfthvub|cgi) \oh dgidh~|t ge T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s+ ogzhuhv+ ~vglxdh bi

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 14/110

bftxvlc|s) Gih huhi|+ |oh dobijh ci |oh uhkgdc|s ge |oh vgdmh|+ obt ~vglxdhl |zg lceehvhi| bilax|xbkks hdkxtcuh vhtxk|t) \oh dobijh ci uhkgdc|s ge |oh vgdmh| obt dbxthl c|t dkgdm |g fg|o tkgzlgzi bil |g t~hhl x~+ lh~hilcij x~gi zoh|ohv |oh Hbv|o gv Abvt ct dgitclhvhl |g fh t|b|cgibvs)Tcidh |ohvh zbt b tcijkh huhi|+ |oh dobijh ci |oh uhkgdc|s ge |oh vgdmh|+ giks b tcijkh vhtxk| dbiobuh gddxvvhl) B| |oct ~gci|+ vhblhvt zog obuh fhhi |vbcihl ci T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s zckk gf`hd|) \ohszckk t|b|h |ob| |oh dobijh ci uhkgdc|s ge |oh vgdmh| ciugkuht bddhkhvb|cgi bil |oh T~hdcbk \ohgvs geVhkb|cuc|s zbt ig| lhvcuhl egv bddhkhvb|hl tst|hat) Txdo bi gf`hd|cgi ct cvvhkhubi|) Bkk gfthvub|cgizhvh ablh xilhv dgilc|cgit ge phvg bddhkhvb|cgi bil |oh T~hdcbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s ct dkhbvksb~~kcdbfkh) B ebagxt bx|ogv obt fhhi rxg|hl |g |oh heehd| |ob| |oh |vxh ahbtxvh ge ci|hkkcjhidh ct

|oh bfckc|s |g ogkl |zg ax|xbkks hdkxtcuh clhbt b| |oh tbah |cah)Ebkth" \oh ogklcij ge |zg ax|xbkkshdkxtcuh clhbt b| |oh tbah |cah ct huclhidh ge b acil |ob| ct |gg kbps bil'gv cidb~bfkh ge vhtgkucij|oh cidgitct|hids fs dgvvhd|cij gih gv fg|o ge |oh clhbt bil zog ct |gg bvvgjbi| |g blac| |oh ihhlegv |oh dgvvhd|cgi bil'gv oct cibfckc|s |g abmh c|)

<):! Hi|hv |oh \bdosgi0! Ci |oh 235>*t c| zbt vhdgjicphl |ob| |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgit lcl ig|~vgocfc| uhkgdc|cht jvhb|hv |obi |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|) Cit|hbl |ohs lhagit|vb|hl |ob| |oh uhkgdc|s gekcjo| vh~vhthi|hl b uhkgdc|s zocdo ab|hvcbk ~bv|cdkht gv gf`hd|t dgxkl b~~vgbdo fx| ig| bdochuhfhdbxth+ b| |ob| uhkgdc|s+ |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi fhdbah phvg) B| |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|+ mcih|cdhihvjs /gv abtt ce sgx ~vhehv# fhdbah ciecic|h bil |oh vb|h ge ~bttbjh ge |cah fhdbah phvg) B|uhkgdc|cht jvhb|hv |obi |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|+ |oh ciecic|cht bil phvgt lg ig| gddxv bil c| ct|ohgvh|cdbkks ~gttcfkh egv ab||hv |g |vbuhk b| |ogth uhkgdc|cht) Os~g|oh|cdbk ~bv|cdkht zocdo |vbuhkhl uhkgdc|cht jvhb|hv |obi |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| zhvh ~gt|xkb|hl bil jcuhi |oh ibah |bdosgit) Egvuhkgdc|cht jvhb|hv |obi |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|+ |oh rxbi|c|s zc|oci |oh trxbvh vgg| tcji ci |oh Kgvhi|p\vbitegvab|cgi fhdgaht ihjb|cuh bil |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi abs fh vhzvc||hi) C| |ohifhdgaht c /U6'D6!2#>)8 + zohvh c ct hrxbk |g /!2#>)8)

<)?! B| |oct ~gci|+ vhblhvt acjo| rxht|cgi zoh|ohv c obt bis ~ostcdbk ahbicij tcidh /!2#>)8 dbihct| giks ci gih*t cabjcib|cgi) Cilhhl+ |oct zbt |oh uchz~gci| egv thuhvbk dhi|xvcht xi|ck c| zbt

vhbkcphl |ob| |oh ~vhthidh ge c ci b ~ostcdbk hrxb|cgi dgxkl fh dgitclhvhl |g vh~vhthi| b vg|b|cgi gebi heehd| ci|g bi bct zocdo zbt ~hv~hilcdxkbv |g |oh bct ge |oh gvcjcibk dggvlcib|h tst|ha bil zbt|ohvhegvh xigfthvubfkh) \oct dgidh~| obt fhhi egxil |g fh rxc|h xthexk ci |oh ~ostcdbk tdchidhtbil ~bv|cdxkbvks ci Hkhd|vcdbk bil Hkhd|vgicd Hijcihhvcij tcidh c| bkkgzt ~ohigahib zocdo gddxv ci

|zg ~hv~hilcdxkbv bht |g fh vh~vhthi|hl ci |hvat ge |oh bkjhfvb igvabkks xthl egv b tcijkh bct~vgfkha) \g gfthvuhvt dgiecihl |g abmcij |ohcv gfthvub|cgit ci |oh vhbk bct+ heehd|t gddxvvcij ci

|oh cabjcibvs bht bvh ig| lcvhd|ks gfthvubfkh bil dbi giks fh ciehvvhl) Tcidh c vh~vhthi|t bvg|b|cgi |ovgxjo 3> lhjvhht evga |oh vhbk bct |g |oh cabjcibvs bct+ bt gih acjo| h~hd|+ hrxb|cgit

dgi|bcicij c 6 vh~vhthi|t b vg|b|cgi ge 2?> lhjvhht evga |oh ~gtc|cuh vhbk bct |g |oh ihjb|cuh vhbkbct bil ~vglxdh gfthvubfkh heehd|t zocdo bvh vhuhvthl ci tcji)

<)3! Zockh agt| ge |oh ~vg~hv|cht ge |oh os~g|oh|cdbk |bdosgi gddxv bkgij |oh xigfthvubfkhcabjcibvs bct+ c| obt b| khbt| gih ~vg~hv|s zogth Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi ciugkuht c 6 bil|ohvhegvh gddxvt ci |oh vhbk bct zohvh gfthvub|cgi ct ~gttcfkh) \ob| ~vg~hv|s ct c|t uhkgdc|s) /Tcidhuhkgdc|s ct khij|o lcuclhl fs |cah+ fg|o ge zocdo bvh txf`hd| |g Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgit+ |oh Kgvhi|

\vbitegvab|cgi egv b |bdosgi*t uhkgdc|s dgi|bcit c 6)# C| ct ig| txv~vctcij |ob| |oh |bdosgi obtihuhv fhhi gfthvuhl bt b ~bv|cdkh+ tcidh ci bllc|cgi |g |oh ebd| |ob| abis ~bv|cdkht obuh fhhi

~vhlcd|hl kgij fhegvh |ohs zhvh gfthvuhl+ c| zgxkl ig| fh vhdgjicphl bt b ~bv|cdkh fhdbxth tgah gc|t mhs ~vg~hv|cht zgxkl fh xigfthvubfkh) C| ct ~gttcfkh+ ogzhuhv+ |g lvbz b dgidkxtcgi bt |g |oh b|vht| uhkgdc|s ge b |bdosgi) \oh b| vht| uhkgdc|s ge b ~bv|cdkh |vbuhkcij fhkgz |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ct |ohuhkgdc|s b| zocdo |oh abjic|xlh ge c|t Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi Fu ct b abcaxa /U hrxbkt phvg#)

Fs bibkgjs+ |oh b| vht| uhkgdc|s ge |oh |bdosgi zgxkl fh |oh uhkgdc|s b| zocdo |oh abjic|xlh ge c|tKgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi ct bktg b| c|t abcaxa) Tcidh |oct gddxvt zohi U ct ciecic|h+ |oh b| vht|uhkgdc|s ge |oh |bdosgi togxkl bktg fh ciecic|h) H~hvcahi|t fs rxbi|xa ~ostcdct|t obuh togzi |obast|hvcgxt heehd|t dbkkhl rxbi|xa ixafhvt ~vg~bjb|h b| b uhkgdc|cht zocdo bvh tcjicecdbi|ks ebt|hv|obi |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|+ ~gttcfks b| bi ciecic|h uhkgdc|s) Rxbi|xa ixafhvt zgxkl thha |g obuh

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 15/110

tgah|ocij ci dgaagi zc|o |oh os~g|oh|cdbk |bdosgi)

<)2>! \oh uhvs dgidh~| ge |oh |bdosgi ct lhubt|b|cij |g |oh clhb |ob| T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s ct b ubkclvh~vhthi|b|cgi ge vhbkc|s bil c| zbt uc|bk |g |ogth zog obl fxck| |ohcv dbvhhvt bvgxil |oh T~hdcbk\ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s |ob| |oh clhb ge |bdosgit fh lctdvhlc|hl ce |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs zhvh |gdgi|cixh |g fh tx~~vhtthl) \g thh zos |oct togxkl fh tg+ dgitclhv |oh kgjcd dgi|bcihl ci |ohegkkgzcij t|b|hahi|t0

B0! Ce C obl b acdvgtdg~h+ C zgxkl gfthvuh |oh hct|hidh ge jhvat)r

F0! \oh hct|hidh ge jhvat lght ig| lh~hil x~gi |oh hct|hidh ge |oh acdvgtdg~h)r

\oh ecvt| t|b|hahi| btthv|t |ob|+ hdh~| egv |oh dbth zohvh acdvgtdg~ht dbxth jhvat+ jhvat hct|vhjbvlkhtt ge zoh|ohv |ohs obuh fhhi gfthvuhl) \oh thdgil t|b|hahi| vhaguht |oh htdb~h dkbxthevga |oh ecvt| t|b|hahi| bil c| fhdgaht hrxcubkhi| |g &jhvat hct|&) Igz dgitclhv |oh egkkgzcijbibkgjgxt t|b|hahi|t0

D0! Ce C dgxkl dgaaxicdb|h xtcij |bdosgit+ C zgxkl fh bfkh |g ht|bfkcto bftgkx|h tcaxk|bihc|sfh|zhhi ~ostcdbkks th~bvb|hl kgdb|cgit+ ahbtxvh as uhkgdc|s zc|o vht~hd| |g t~bdh c|thke+ bi|ohvhfs uhvces |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs)

r

L0! \oh ubkclc|s ge |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs lght ig| lh~hil x~gi as bfckc|s |gdgaaxicdb|h xtcij |bdosgit)

r

B kc||kh vhekhd|cgi togxkl dgiucidh |oh vhblhv |ob|+ ce t|b|hahi| L ct |vxh+ |oh ahvh ebd| |ob| C dbidgidhcuh ge dgaaxicdb|cij |ovgxjo |oh xth ge |bdosgit lhagit|vb|ht |ob| |oh kcac|b|cgi ca~gthlgi |oh T~hdcbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s fs Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs vh~vhthi|t vhbkc|s)\oh dkbttcdbk Bh|ohv axt| hct|" 

<)22! Tcidh c| zbt uc|bk |ob| |oh clhb ge |bdosgit fh tx~~vhtthl bil |oh ebd| |ob| |ohs obl ig| fhhigfthvuhl ct ig| txeecdchi| |g bddga~kcto |ob| tx~~vhttcgi+ big|ohv b~~vgbdo zbt vhrxcvhl) C| zbt

btthv|hl |ob| dgaaxicdb|cgi fs |bdosgit zgxkl ucgkb|h dbxtbkc|s) /Dbxtbkc|s ct b uhvs vhbtgibfkhdgidh~| zocdo btthv|t |ob| b vhtxk| dbiig| gddxv ~vcgv |g c|t dbxth)# Bt bi hba~kh+ dgitclhvthilcij b tcjibk fs |bdosgi evga |oh Hbv|o |g |oh Aggi) Ce |oh |cah ge |vbitacttcgi ge |oh tcjibkzbt 220>>0>> BA bil |oh |bdosgi bvvcuhl b| |oh Aggi b| 2>083083 BA+ c| zgxkl thha |g ca~ks |obc| bvvcuhl b| |oh Aggi gih thdgil fhegvh c| zbt |vbitac||hl) Kc|hvbkks ci|hv~vh|hl+ txdo b vhtxk|zgxkl fh b dkhbv ucgkb|cgi ge dbxtbkc|s) \oh bvjxahi| ebkkt b~bv| zohi c| ct vhahafhvhl |ob| |ohdkgdm gi |oh Aggi zbt tsidovgicphl zc|o |oh dkgdm gi |oh Hbv|o fs bi hkhd|vgabjih|cd tcjibk) Ce |oHbv|o!Aggi tst|ha zhvh |vbuhkcij |ovgxjo |oh Bh|ohv ci b lcvhd|cgi |gzbvlt |oh Aggi b| b uhkgdc|sge >)?2 |caht |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|+ |oh dkgdm gi |oh Aggi zgxkl obuh b tsidovgicpb|cgi hvvgvdbxtcij c| |g fh gih thdgil kb|h zc|o vht~hd| |g |oh dkgdm gi |oh Hbv|o) \oh b~~bvhi| ucgkb|cgi gedbxtbkc|s zgxkl |ohi fh h~kbcihl bt fhcij dbxthl fs |oh Hbv|o!Aggi tst|ha*t uhkgdc|s |ovgxjo |oBh|ohv) \ohvh bvh giks |zg zbst ci zocdo dgaaxicdb|cgi fs |bdosgi dbi ~vglxdh b ucgkb|cgi ge |o

^vcidc~kh ge Dbxtbkc|s) \oh ecvt| ~gttcfckc|s gddxvt ce |oh |bdosgi bvvcuht hbvks fs bi bagxi| ge |cahjvhb|hv |obi |oh gfthvuhl |cah egv kcjo| |g abmh |oh |vc~) \oh thdgil ~gttcfckc|s ct ce |bdosgit zhvhthi| gi b vgxil |vc~ evga |oh Hbv|o |g |oh Aggi bil fbdm bil bvvcuhl gi Hbv|o fhegvh |ohs zhvhthi|) Zockh |ohvh ct b tdoggk ge |ogxjo| zocdo txjjht| |ob| |oct dbi ob~~hi+ c| ct fbthl x~gi bactb~~kcdb|cgi ge |oh T~hdcbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s)

<)26! \oh &Ecd|c|cgxt& Egvdht ge Bddhkhvb|cgi0! Ihz|gi*t Thdgil Kbz ge Ag|cgi t|b|ht |ob| egv huhvsbd|cgi |ohvh ct bi hrxbk bi g~~gtc|h vhbd|cgi) Bi hdh~|cgi |g |oct vxkh thhat |g fh |oh egvdhtbttgdcb|hl zc|o cihv|cbk bil jvbuc|b|cgibk bddhkhvb|cgit) B egvdh axt| fh b~~kchl |g bi gf`hd| |gdobijh c|t uhkgdc|s+ fx| |ohvh ct ig b~~bvhi| g~~gtcij egvdh |g ab|do |oh b~~kchl egvdh) \oh tbahtc|xb|cgi gddxvt zohi gih dgitclhvt |oh egvdh ge jvbuc|s) Bt sgx tc| ci sgxv dobcv sgx bvh dgitdcgxge b egvdh ~vhttcij sgx bjbcit| c|+ fx|+ bt zc|o cihv|cbk bddhkhvb|cgi+ |ohvh ct ig b~~bvhi| g~~gtcij

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 16/110

egvdh ab|docij c|) Bt b vhtxk|+ |oh g~~gtcij egvdht vhrxcvhl fs Ihz|git*t Thdgil Kbz ge Ag|cgi egfg|o cihv|cbk bil jvbuc|b|cgibk egvdht bvh vhehvvhl |g bt ecd|c|cgxt) C| ct tgah|caht btthv|hl |ob| |ohJhihvbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s obt togzi |ob| zob| b~~hbvt |g fh |oh egvdh ge jvbuc|s lght ig| gddxfx| ct b abiceht|b|cgi ge |oh dxvub|xvh ge t~bdh bttgdcb|hl zc|o |oh tgxvdh ge |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echklBt zh tobkk thh kb|hv+ Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s lght ig| hkcacib|h jvbuc|s bt b egvdh+ c| vh~kbdht c| zc|o |ohgfthvubfkh dga~gihi| ge bi higvagxt egvdh bd|cij bkgij bi xigfthvubfkh egxv|o t~b|cbk bct) Cegih bddh~|t |oh hct|hidh ge |oh dkbttcdbk Bh|ohv+ |oh ecd|c|cgxt egvdht ~vhthi| ig dgidh~|xbklceecdxk|s tcidh |ohs bvh bd|cij bjbcit| |oh vcjcl ahlcxa ge |oh Bh|ohv) Xilhv T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s+ gi|oh g|ohv obil+ |ohvh ct ig ahlcxa egv |ohth egvdht |g vhbd| bjbcit|+ bil gih ct egvdhl |g bddh~| |o

hct|hidh ge hdh~|cgit |g Ihz|git*t Thdgil Kbz ge Ag|cgi)

<)24! Bd|cgi b| b Lct|bidh0! Gih ge |oh vhbtgit |oh dgidh~| ge |oh Bh|ohv zbt bddh~|hl ci |oh 23|oDhi|xvs zbt |oh ihhl |g h~kbci |oh bfckc|s ge egvdht |g bd| fh|zhhi ~bv|cdkht gv gf`hd|t zocdo zhvhth~bvb|hl ci t~bdh) Zc|o |oh bddh~|bidh ge T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s+ |oh Bh|ohv zbt fbictohl evga~ostcdbk |ohgvcht bil big|ohv ahbit ge h~kbcicij |oh bfckc|s ge |ohth egvdht |g bd| zbt vhrxcvhl)\oh vhtxk| zbt |oh ci|vglxd|cgi ge |oh dgidh~| ge ucv|xbk ~bv|cdkht zocdo fgxidhl fbdm bil egv|o |g~vglxdh |oh gfthvuhl egvdht ci b abiihv bibkgjgxt |g |oh ~vglxd|cgi ge egvdh fh|zhhi |zgb|okh|ht |ovgzcij b ahlcdcih fbkk |g hbdo g|ohv) \ob| dgidh~| obt b lceecdxk|s) \oh ax|xbk hdobijge b ahlcdcih fbkk dbi giks ~vglxdh b vh~xktcuh egvdh fh|zhhi |oh b|okh|ht) Ci gvlhv |g ~vglxdh bib||vbd|cuh egvdh+ |oh abtt ge |oh ahlcdcih fbkk zgxkl ihhl |g fh ihjb|cuh) \g lb|h ig |ohgvh|cdcbi

thhat |g obuh vbcthl |oh ~gttcfckc|s |ob| txdo ct |oh dbth egv |oh ~gt|xkb|hl ucv|xbk ~bv|cdkht bilgih axt| dgidkxlh |ob|+ |g tx~~ks bi b||vbd|cuh egvdh+ |oh ucv|xbk ~bv|cdkh axt| fh xilhv |hitcgi bidgithrxhi|ks |oh lct|bidh guhv zocdo c| dbi bd| ct kcac|hl fs c|t tcph) Ce |oh hdobijh ge ucv|xbk~bv|cdkht ~vglxdht egvdht zocdo bd| b| b lct|bidh+ |ohs zgxkl |ohathkuht dgit|c|x|h b ahlcxahrxcubkhi| |g |oh Bh|ohv bil |oh ihhl egv |oh Bh|ohv |g h~kbci bd|cgi b| b lct|bidh zgxkl ig| obuhfhhi vhtgkuhl+ c| zgxkl ahvhks fhhi ~xtohl lgzi gih khuhk ci|g |oh ucv|xbk ~bv|cdkh) Tcidh |ohblugdb|ht ge T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s obuh ig| bllvhtthl rxht|cgit txdo bt |ohth+ Lv) Hcit|hci*tt|b|hahi| |ob| |oh ihhl egv |oh Bh|ohv obl fhhi hkcacib|hl ct ig| |vxh+ c| giks b~~hbvt |g fh |vxhfhdbxth hafbvvbttcij rxht|cgit obuh fhhi tzh~| xilhv |oh vxj)

<)2<! \oh ~vhdh~| |ob| hkhd|vgt|b|cd egvdht vhtxk| evga |oh hdobijh ge ucv|xbk ~og|git ct vhblcks|ht|hl) Txdo bi h~hvcahi| ct lcbjvbahl ci Ecjxvh <)4) Ci |oct h~hvcahi|+ |zg ah|bk ~kb|ht bvh

txt~hilhl ~bvbkkhk |g hbdo g|ohv ci b kbvjh hkhd|vgabjih|cdbkks tochklhl bil hubdxb|hl dobafhv)\oh ~kb|ht bvh kgdb|hl tsaah|vcdbkks bfgx| |oh dhi|hv ge |oh dobafhv) Aclzbs fh|zhhi |oh ~kb|ht b zcvh zocdo ct db~bdc|cuhks dgx~khl |g b txc|bfkh vblcg vhdhcuhv) \oh ~kb|ht bvh dgiihd|hl |g ocjougk|bjh L!D tgxvdht ge hrxbk ba~kc|xlh bil g~~gtc|h ~gkbvc|s) \oh ocjo ugk|bjht gi |oh ~kb|ht~vglxdht b t|vgij hkhd|vgt|b|cd egvdh ge b||vbd|cgi fh|zhhi |oha zocdo+ tcidh c| bd|t guhv blct|bidh+ axt| hc|ohv vhtxk| evga bi hkhd|vcd t|vhtt ci |oh Bh|ohv gv+ ci bddgvlbidh zc|o |oh dxvvhi|bddh~|hl dgidh~|t+ evga |oh hdobijh ge ucv|xbk ~og|git fh|zhhi |oh ~kb|ht) /B abjih|cdhrxcubkhi| ge |oct h~hvcahi| dgxkl fh dgilxd|hl zc|o hkhd|vgabjih|t txft|c|x|hl egv |ohhkhd|vcdbkks dobvjhl ~kb|ht)# \oh dgidh~| |ob| |oh egvdh vhtxk|t evga bi hkhd|vcd t|vhtt ci |oh Bh|ohvct t|vbcjo|egvzbvl bil ihhlt ig exv|ohv h~kbib|cgi) \oh dgidh~| |ob| |oh egvdh vhtxk|t evga |ohhdobijh ge ucv|xbk ~og|git ct agvh dga~kh bil vhrxcvht exv|ohv hbacib|cgi)

<)28! Ce |oh egvdh fh|zhhi |oh ~kb|ht vhtxk|t evga |oh hdobijh ge ucv|xbk ~og|git+ |ohi |oh vhkb|cuhkbvjh t~bdcij fh|zhhi |oh ~kb|ht citxvht |ob| |oh ucv|xbk ~og|git obuh b ebcvks kgij zbuhkhij|o bilb evhrxhids kgz higxjo |g bkkgz |oha |g fh thithl fs b dgiuhi|cgibk |hkhuctcgi th|) Bt b vhtxk| ge|ob| kgz evhrxhids+ b kbvjh ekx ge ucv|xbk ~og|git ct vhrxcvhl |g ~vglxdh |oh egvdh khuhk |ob| b ocjougk|bjh dbi ~vglxdh fh|zhhi |oh ~kb|ht) B kbvjh ucv|xbk ~og|gi ekx zckk+ ci |xvi+ cilxdh b ocjo khuhge vbilga igcth ci |oh zcvh kgdb|hl fh|zhhi |oh ~kb|ht bil zckk dbxth b ocjo igcth gx|~x| ci |ohvblcg vhdhcuhv) /\oh hubdxb|cgi ge |oh dobafhv citxvht |ob| |oh igcth zbt ig| jhihvb|hl fs cgicphljbt agkhdxkht)# Zockh |oct h~hvcahi| ct vhblcks hhdx|hl+ c| ct ig| ihdhttbvs egv c| |g fh ~hvegvahlCe hkhd|vgt|b|cd egvdht vhtxk|hl evga |oh hdobijh ge ucv|xbk ~og|git+ |oh hkhd|vcd echklt zocdobfgxil b| ubvcgxt kgdb|cgit+ txdo bt fh|zhhi |oh txvebdh ge |oh Hbv|o bil dkgxlt gv |oh ugk|bjh g|oh ~cd|xvh |xfh ge b \U th|+ zgxkl jhihvb|h txeecdchi| igcth bt |g vhilhv hkhd|vgabjih|cd

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 17/110

dgaaxicdb|cgi ca~gttcfkh)

<)25! Tcidh zh vhjxkbvks xth hkhd|vgabjih|cd zbuht bt b ahbit ge dgaaxicdb|cgi bil |ob|dgaaxicdb|cgi thhat xibeehd|hl fs |oh ~vhthidh ge t|b|cd hkhd|vcdbk echklt+ c| ct tbeh |g dgidkxlh|ob| hkhd|vgt|b|cd egvdht lg ig| vhtxk| evga |oh hdobijh ge ucv|xbk ~og|git) \oh giks h~kbib|cgizocdo thhat |g vhabci ct |ob| |ohs vhtxk| evga b t|vhtt ci |oh Bh|ohv) Ce fg|o gxv h~hvchidh bkvhbllhicht+ bil b ~ostcdbkks vhbkcpbfkh h~hvcahi| zckk bktg lhis+ |ob| ucv|xbk ~og|git bd| bt dbvvchvt g|oh hkhd|vgt|b|cd egvdh+ |ohs bvh agt| dhv|bciks vxkhl gx| bt dbvvchvt ge |oh abjih|cd egvdh) Ce zh bvhegvdhl |g bfbilgi |oh clhb |ob| ucv|xbk ~og|git dbvvs |oh hkhd|vgabjih|cd egvdht+ dgitct|hids

vhrxcvht |ob| zh bfbilgi |oh clhb |ob| ucv|xbk ~bv|cdkht ibahl jkxgit dbvvs egvdht zc|oci |oh ixdkhge b|gat) C| ct |cah |g jg fbdm |g |oh txfb|gacd lvbzcij fgbvl) B ~gttcfkh ib|xvh ge |ogth egvdhtzckk fh lctdxtthl kb|hv)

<)2:! \oh Vblcgah|vcd Ahbtxvhahi| ge Gxv Uhkgdc|s \ovgxjo T~bdh0! Ci Iguhafhv 23::+ b ~b~hvvhbl b| bi Bahvcdbi Bt|vgigacdbk Tgdch|s dgiuhi|cgi ci B|kbi|b biigxidhl |ob| ahbtxvhahi|t ge|oh ci|hitc|s ge |oh acdvgzbuh fbdmjvgxil vblcb|cgi ge t~bdh ci lceehvhi| lcvhd|cgit togzhl |ob| |oHbv|o zbt agucij |ovgxjo t~bdh b| b t~hhl ge bfgx| :>>+>>> ackht ~hv ogxv) \oh h~hvcahi|tzhvh dgilxd|hl fs vblcgah|hvt cit|bkkhl ci b X!6 bcvdvbe| ekgzi b| bi bk|c|xlh ge :>+>>> e|) zc|o bah|oglgkgjs zocdo zbt b~~bvhi|ks fhsgil dobkkhijh) \oh vh~gv| ge |ohth h~hvcahi|t khl |gdgit|hvib|cgi gi |oh ~bv| ge dgtagkgjct|t fhdbxth c| lcl ucgkhidh |g |ohcv hct|cij dgidh~|tdgidhvicij |oh lct|vcfx|cgi ge ab||hv ci t~bdh) Bi huhi agvh tcjicecdbi| vhtxk| ge |ohth h~hvcahizbt ig| vhdgjicphl) \oh gfthvubidh ge |oct uhkgdc|s lvcuht h~hvcahi|bk ibckt ci|g |oh dgeeci ge |ohT~hdcbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s fhdbxth |oh ubkclc|s ge |ob| |ohgvs+ ci dga~bvctgi |g |oh agvhvht|vcd|cuh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs+ lh~hilt gi |oh ebd| |ob| c| ct ca~gttcfkh egv bi gfthvuhv |gahbtxvh oct bftgkx|h uhkgdc|s |ogxjo t~bdh) Bt ge|hi ob~~hit+ bt tggi bt gih lhdkbvht |ob|tgah|ocij ct ca~gttcfkh+ tgah lbaihl eggk dgaht bkgij bil lght c|) \oh h~hvcahi|hvt `xt| lcli~kbs ebcv) Cibluhv|hi|ks+ fs ahbtxvcij |oh uhkgdc|s ge |oh Hbv|o |ovgxjo t~bdh+ |ohs lhagkctohl |ohxilhv~ciicijt ge |oh T~hdcbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s bil ht|bfkctohl |ob| |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvszbt |oh dgvvhd| ci|hv~vh|b|cgi ge vhbkc|s) /X~ zc|o Ec|pjhvbkl+ lgzi zc|o Hcit|hci)# 

<)2?! Lcvbd*t &Thb& ge Ihjb|cuh Hihvjs0! Ci |oh 234>*t Lv) ^) Lcvbd dgitclhvhl |oh heehd| ge |oh ca~b

ge b ocjo hihvjs ~og|gi /h)j)! 2>5 hkhd|vgi ugk|t# bjbcit| b agvh abttcuh ~bv|cdkh) Oh dgidkxlhl

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 18/110

|ohgvh|cdbkks |ob| |oh ca~bd| zgxkl ~vglxdh fg|o bi hkhd|vgi bil b ~gtc|vgi bil obl |oh tb|ctebd|cgge obucij |ob| ~vhlcd|cgi uhvcechl fs gfthvub|cgi) Oct |ohgvh|cdbk |vhb|ahi| obl gih lceecdxk|s) C| bktdgidkxlhl |ob| bkk ge |oh ab||hv ci |oh Xicuhvth zgxkl ubicto ci b tabkk evbd|cgi ge b acdvgthdgil)Tcidh |oh Xicuhvth dgi|cixht |g hct|+ c| zbt ihdhttbvs |g vhucth |oh |ohgvs) \oh vhtxk|cij vhuctcgizbt |g dgitclhv |ob| bkk ge t~bdh zbt tgkclks eckkhl zc|o ihjb|cuh hihvjs /zob|huhv |ob| ct#) \oh~vglxd|cgi ge |oh hkhd|vgi!~gtc|vgi ~bcv zbt dgitclhvhl |g vhtxk| zohi |oh ca~bd| ge |oh ~og|gimigdmhl bi hkhd|vgi evga |ob| thb ge ihjb|cuh hihvjs bil khe| b ogkh zohvh |oh hkhd|vgi obl fhhi)\ob| ogkh vh~vhthi|hl b acttcij ihjb|cuh dobvjh ci |oh thb ge ihjb|cuh hihvjs bil b~~hbvhl |g xtbt b ~gtc|cuh hkhd|vgi) Gih acjo| vhbtgibfks zgilhv ogz Lcvbd*t dgidh~| ge b thb ge ihjb|cuh

hihvjs zocdo ~hvublht bkk ge t~bdh lceehvt tcjicecdbi|ks evga |oh dgidh~| ge |oh dkbttcdbk Bh|ohv)

<)23! \oh Dobvbd|hvct|cdt ge |oh Bh|ohv0! \oh lctdxttcgit |g |oct ~gci|+ bil agvh ~bv|cdxkbvks |ogthzocdo egkkgz ci txddhttcuh dob~|hvt+ ca~ks |ob|+ ci gvlhv egv &vhbkc|s& |g obuh |oh ~vg~hv|cht zocdozh gfthvuh+ |oh Bh|ohv axt| obuh+ bt b acicaxa+ |oh egkkgzcij ~vg~hv|cht0!

C| axt| fh b tgkcl ahlcxa vb|ohv |obi b ekxcl) Ce c| zhvh ig| b tgkcl ahlcxa+ |vbituhvthhkhd|vgabjih|cd lct|xvfbidht /kcjo|# zgxkl ig| ~vg~bjb|h tcidh |vbituhvth lct|xvfbidhtdbiig| ~vg~bjb|h |ovgxjo b ekxcl)

r

C| axt| obuh+ bt b acicaxa+ b lchkhd|vcd dgit|bi|+ b ~hvahbfckc|s+ bil gddx~s b ugkxah tcidh

|ohth ~vg~hv|cht bvh vhblcks gfthvuhl)

r

C| b~~bvhi|ks ct bftgkx|hks dgi|cixgxt vb|ohv |obi dga~gthl ge acix|h ~bv|cdkht) \octdgi|cixc|s abs zhkk b~~vgbdo b phvg tcph bt b kcac| tcidh c| fhobuht bt ce c| obl b &R& zocdob~~vgbdo ciecic|s)

B |xicij egvm ablh ge t|hhk zckk vcij egv b ~vgkgijhl ~hvcgl be|hv fhcij t|vxdm tcidh t|hhct b ocjo &R& ab|hvcbk) Gih ablh ge khbl zckk ahvhks &|oxim& zohi t|vxdm tcidh khbl ct bkgz &R& ab|hvcbk) Lct|xvfbidht ci |oh Bh|ohv lg ig| lch gx| b| b lh|hd|bfkh vb|h zockh~vg~bjb|cij |ovgxjo evhh t~bdh txjjht|cij |ob| |oh Bh|ohv obt b &R& zocdo ct higvagxbil abs zhkk fh ciecic|h)

v

r

Ab|hvcbk ~bv|cdkht axt| fh dgit|vxd|hl ci txdo b zbs |ob| c| ct ~gttcfkh egv |oha |g ~vg~bjb|h|ovgxjo |oh tgkcl Bh|ohv /Dob~|hv 24#)

r

<)6>! T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s bil Gddba*t Vbpgv0! C| ct tgah|caht btthv|hl |ob| Gddba*t Vbpgv togzt|ob| |oh T~hdcbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s ct |g fh ~vhehvvhl guhv |oh Kgvhi|p Dgi|vbd|cgi!Bh|ohv \ohgvs)Gddba*t Vbpgv ct b ~ockgtg~ocdbk dgit|vxd| zocdo btthv|t |ob|+ zohi |ohvh bvh |zg gv agvhh~kbib|cgit ge b ~ohigahib+ |oh agt| tca~kh h~kbib|cgi togxkl fh dogthi) Ci |oh dbth ge |ohth|ohgvcht+ Gddba*t Vbpgv ct bafcjxgxt) Dga~x|b|cgit fbthl x~gi T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s bvh tca~khv|obi |ogth t|vcd|ks fbthl x~gi |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi!Bh|ohv \ohgvs egv |oh vhbtgi |ob| c|bkkgzt |oh gfthvuhv*t uhkgdc|s vhehvhidh evbah |g fh xthl bt |oh fbtct ge dga~x|b|cgi vb|ohv |obivhrxcvcij |oh xth ge bi ciecic|h ixafhv ge uhkgdc|s vhehvhidh evbaht |ob| zgxkl thha |g fh vhrxcvhl

fs |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi!Bh|ohv \ohgvs) \oh lgzitclh ge |oh T~hdcbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s ct|ob| c| vhrxcvht |oh bddh~|bidh ge |oh clhb |ob| bi ciecic|h ixafhv ge uhkgdc|s vhehvhidh evbahtdgvvhd|ks vh~vhthi| vhbkc|s)

<)62! \oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi!Bh|ohv \ohgvs+ gi |oh g|ohv obil+ btthv|t |ob| |ohvh ct giks gihbftgkx|h uhkgdc|s vhehvhidh evbah+ bil c| zgxkl tx~hvecdcbkks thha |g vhrxcvh |oh xth ge th~bvb|hdbkdxkb|cgit egv hbdo ge |oh ciecic|h ixafhv ge ~gttcfkh uhkgdc|cht fh|zhhi |oh gfthvuhvt uhkgdc|svhehvhidh evbah bil |oh bftgkx|h uhkgdc|s vhehvhidh evbah) Ogzhuhv+ txdo b dga~kcdb|cgi lght ig|gddxv) Bt togzi Ecjxvh 5)< bil |oh |h| zocdo bddga~bicht c|+ |oh bftgkx|h vhehvhidh evbahdbidhkt evga bkk dbkdxkb|cgit bil gfthvub|cgit bil |oh ab|ohab|cdt ge T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s bvhdga~kh|hks b~~kcdbfkh) /\oct ob~~s heehd| vhtxk|t evga |oh ebd| |ob| |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgit bvh

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 19/110

axk|c~kcdb|cuhks dgaax|b|cuh) ! Thh Dob~|hv ?)#

<)66! \oh Ca~kcdb|cgit ge Abzhkk*t Hrxb|cgit0! Fbthl x~gi |oh lctdguhvcht ge Ebvblbs+ Lv) Abzhlhvcuhl |oh ebahl hrxb|cgit zocdo lhecih |oh hkhd|vgabjih|cd echkl) Bddgvlcij |g hbvks |h|t+ oh l|oct fs cabjcicij &lct~kbdhahi| dxvvhi|t gddxvcij ci t~bdh& huhi |ogxjo oh dkbcahl ig| |g obuhbil xilhvt|bilcij ge zob| |ogth dxvvhi|t dgxkl fh bil zohi Ebvblbs vhrxht|hl bi h~kbib|cgi g|oh |ohgvs ci zgvlt+ Abzhkk ct bkkhjhl |g obuh fhhi xibfkh |g ~vguclh c|) Ce |oh bx|ogv ct |g fhkchuh

vhdhi| dgaaxicdb|cgi+ |oh dxvvhi| |hbdocij ct |ob| Abzhkk*t Hrxb|cgit lg ig| obuh b ~ostcdbkh~kbib|cgi+ |ohs `xt| bvh" 

<)64! Lv) Abzhkk lhvcuhl oct hrxb|cgit fbthl gi |oh clhb ge &lct~kbdhahi| dxvvhi|t& ci t~bdh) \gxilhvt|bil |oh vhbtgi egv dgitclhvcij |ohth &dxvvhi|t&+ dgitclhv zob| ob~~hit zohi bi B!Dugk|bjh ct b~~kchl bdvgtt |oh ~kb|ht ge b db~bdc|gv dgitct|cij ge |zg ~bvbkkhk ~kb|ht ci b ubdxxa bttogzi ci Ecjxvh <)<) Ci |oct ecjxvh+ |oh b~~kchl B!D ugk|bjh /zocdo abs fh bttxahl |g fh clhi|cdbk b|oh tx~~ks bil |oh ~kb|ht# dbxtht bi B!D dxvvhi| |g ekgz ci |oh zcvht |g |oh ~kb|ht zocdo ct ~obthl3> lhjvhht ci blubidh ge |oh ugk|bjh) Tcidh |oct ct b thvcht dcvdxc|+ |oh dxvvhi| ci bkk ~bv|t ge |ohdcvdxc| axt| fh cit|bi|bihgxtks |oh tbah) \ob| ahbit |ob| |oh dxvvhi| axt| ekgz |ovgxjo |oh t~bdfh|zhhi |oh ~kb|ht+ fx|+ tcidh |oh dgiuhi|cgibk dbvvchv ge hkhd|vcd dxvvhi| /h)j)! hkhd|vgit+ cgit+ h|d

dbiig| ~btt fh|zhhi |oh ~kb|ht+ |oh dxvvhi| axt| ekgz fh|zhhi |oh ~kb|ht zc|ogx| |oh ahlcb|cgi gedobvjhl ~bv|cdkht) Ci bllc|cgi+ b abjih|cd echkl zocdo txvvgxilt |oh hkhd|vcd echkl ct jhihvb|hl ci~vg~gv|cgibk |g c|t vb|h ge dobijh) Tcackbvks+ bi hkhd|vcd echkl ct jhihvb|hl ci ~vg~gv|cgi |g |oh vb|h gdobijh ge |oh abjih|cd echkl+ bjbci ~obth toce|hl 3> lhjvhht ci blubidhge |oh aabjih|cd echkl) Cidgafcib|cgi+ |ohth |zg ~obth toce|t bvh 2?> lhjvhht+ bil bvh db~bfkh ge txt|bcicij bi gtdckkb|cgifs ehhlcij hihvjs dsdkcdbkks evga gih echkl |g |oh g|ohvzc|ogx| |oh ci|hvuhi|cgi ge bis g|ohv ahdobicta ) Abzhkk*t Hrxb|cgit dgidcthks lhtdvcfh |oh ci|hvbd|cgi bil togz |ob| txdo bigtdckkb|cgi zckk ~vg~bjb|h bt b zbuh lct|xvfbidh zocdo ct ~bv| ge |oh hkhd|vgabjih|cd t~hd|vxa)

<)6<! \oh lceecdxk|s ci lhtdvcfcij Abzhkk*t Hrxb|cgit ci zgvlt lght ig| lhvcuh evga |oh hrxb|cgit|ohathkuht+ |oh ~vhdhlcij ~bvbjvb~ot zgxkl thha |g lg |ob| rxc|h icdhks) \oh lceecdxk|s bvcthtzohi gih |vcht |g vhdgidckh |oha zc|o |oh &ha~|s& t~bdh ca~kchl fs T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s) Be|hv bkk+ og

dbi hkhd|vcdbk dxvvhi|t ekgz ci ha~|s t~bdh bil ogz dbi abjih|cd egvdht hct| ci |ob| t~bdh7 Gi|oh g|ohv obil+ ce gih dgitclhvt |ob| |oh t~bdh ct eckkhl zc|o |oh dkbttcdbk Bh|ohv+ |oh ~vgfkhaubictoht) Gih dgxkl dgitclhv |ob| |oh Bh|ohv ct t|vhtthl fs |oh b~~kcdb|cgi ge bi hkhd|vcdbk echkl)\oct t|vhtt vhuhbkt c|thke bt b ihjb|cuh hkhd|vgt|b|cd ~g|hi|cbk b| gih ~kb|h bil b ~gtc|cuhhkhd|vgt|b|cd ~g|hi|cbk b| |oh g|ohv ~kb|h bil ~vglxdht bi b||vbd|cuh egvdh fh|zhhi |oh txvebdhtb~~kscij |oh echkl /t~bdh obt b lchkhd|vcd dgit|bi|#) /Gih dgxkl bktg bvjxh |ob| |oh Bh|ohv dgi|bcit|zg hkhd|vgt|b|cd dga~gihi|t+ ~gtc|cuh bil ihjb|cuh+ ci `x|b~gtc|cgi+ bil |ohth dga~gihi|t bvh~xkkhl b~bv| fs |oh hkhd|vcd echkl# \oh vb|h b| zocdo |oh hkhd|vcd t|vhtt ct b~~kchl ~vglxdht b ogg~t|vhtt ci |oh Bh|ohv zocdo t|gvht hihvjs bil zocdo zh gfthvuh bt |oh abjih|cd echkl /t~bdh obt babjih|cd ~hvahbfckc|s#) \oh vb|h ge dobijh ge |oh abjih|cd echkl tcackbvks ~vglxdht bi hkhd|vcd echklzocdo bd|t gi |oh hkhd|vcd dga~gihi|t ge |oh Bh|ohv) \ohth |zg heehd|t bvh ig| acvvgv cabjht ge

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 20/110

hbdo g|ohv+ zh gfthvuh ~gci| hkhd|vgt|b|cd dobvjht /hkhd|vgit+ ~gtc|vgit+ h|d)# fx| lg ig| gfthvuh~gci| abjih|cd dobvjht /agig~gkht#) Bt zh tobkk thh kb|hv gi+ fg|o |oh Uhkgdc|s bil Jvbuc|b|cgibk\vbitegvab|cgit egv ~hvahbfckc|s bil |oh lchkhd|vcd dgit|bi| lceehv tcjicecdbi|ks) /Uchzcij |oh Bh|ohci |oct abiihv ~vguclht bi h~kbib|cgi egv bi gfthvuhl ~ohigahib) Ce |oh Bh|ohv ct txeecdchi|kst|vhtthl fs bi hkhd|vgabjih|cd echkl+ |oh ~gttcfckc|s txjjht|t c|thke |ob| |oh t|vhtt ct vhkchuhl kgdbkfs b vx~|xvh zocdo jhihvb|ht hkhd|gi!~gtc|vgi ~bcvt)#

Dob~|hv 8 ! \oh Vhtxvvhd|cgi ge Bftgkx|h Uhkgdc|s FsRxbi|xa H~hvcahi|t

8)2! Zockh |oh ~vhdhlcij dob~|hv ct ~vgfbfks blhrxb|h |g dgiucidh cilcuclxbkt zogth |ogxjo|~vgdhttht cidkxlh dgaagi thith |ob| |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs bil ig| T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|svh~vhthi|t vhbkc|s+ c| zckk ig| dgiucidh agt| ahafhvt ge |oh bdblhacd dgaaxic|s) Ci gvlhv |gbdrxcvh |ohcv ^oLt+ |ohs obuh+ ge ihdhttc|s+ bkkgzhl |ohathkuht |g fh fvbcizbtohl ci|g txfahvjcidgaagi thith vhbtgicij ci ebugv ge vhbtgicij fs egvabk ~vgdhlxvht) Ci tg lgcij+ ig| giks |ohsobuh |ohs ximigzcijks tx~~vhtthl |oh agt| ~gzhvexk db~bfckc|s ge |oh fvbci+ c|t ~b||hvi vhdgjic|cg

db~bfckc|s+ bil dgidhi|vb|hl gi |oh lhuhkg~ahi| ge gih ge |oh fvbci*t khtthv db~bfckc|cht+ c|t bfckc|s|g ~vgdhtt kgjcd+ |ohs obuh ablh c| ~gttcfkh |g cjigvh bt~hd|t ge |oh ~vgfkha zocdo bvh ig|cidkxlhl ci |oh ~gt|xkb|h t|vxd|xvh ge |oh ab|ohab|cdt) \g dgiucidh |ogth cilcuclxbkt+ h~hvcahi|bhuclhidh ct vhrxcvhl) Egv|xib|hks+ |ob| huclhidh obt fhhi tx~~kchl fs h~hvcahi|t ci Rxbi|xa^ostcdt)

8)6! Bi bv|cdkh ci gih ge |oh zgvkl*t agt| ~vht|cjcgxt tdchi|cecd abjbpciht ci |oh kb|h 23?>*tlhtdvcfhl h~hvcahi|t zocdo lhagit|vb|hl |ob| |oh ~gkbvcpb|cgi ge ~bcvhl ~og|git /jhihvb|hl fs bdgaagi tgxvdh# zbt dgx~khl ci txdo b zbs |ob| dobijcij |oh ~gkbvcpb|cgi ge gih ~og|gi dobijhl|oh ~gkbvcpb|cgi ge |oh g|ohv) Agvh tcjicecdbi|ks+ |ohs lhagit|vb|hl |ob| |oh uhkgdc|s ge |oh~gkbvcpb|cgi dgx~kcij fh|zhhi |oh ~bcvhl ~og|git zbt b| khbt| < |caht |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|) \ohthvhtxk|t vbcth |oh rxht|cgi bt |g zoh|ohv ~gkbvcpb|cgi+ zocdo rxbi|xa ~ostcdct|t lhtcjib|h bt |oh

~og|gi*t rxbi|xa ixafhv+ dgxkl fh dgitclhvhl |g fh dgx~khl fs bi gfthvubfkh ~vg~hv|s ge |oh btsh| |g fh gfthvuhl |bdosgi) Ce tg+ gih zgxkl h~hd| |ob| |oh dgx~kcij ge |oh ~gkbvcpb|cgi ge ~bcvhl~og|git zgxkl ~vg~bjb|h b| bi ciecic|h uhkgdc|s) Tcidh |oh hihvjs dgi|hi| ge b ~og|gi lght ig|dobijh bt b vhtxk| ge c|t lcvhd|cgi ge ~gkbvcpb|cgi+ |oh T~hdcbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s bil'gv |oh Bh|ohVhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs lg ig| ca~gth b uhkgdc|s kcac| gi |oh |vbitehv ge ciegvab|cgi fs |oh dgx~kcij ge |oh~kbih ge ~gkbvcpb|cgi fh|zhhi ~bcvhl ~og|git) C| togxkl fh ig|hl |ob| T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s zgxkl thha|g vhrxcvh |ob| txdo ~gkbvcpb|cgi dgx~kcij ~vg~bjb|h b| bi ciecic|h uhkgdc|s) \oh vhbtgi |ob| |ohuhkgdc|s ge dgaaxicdb|cgi ct kcac|hl |g |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ct |ob| |oh dgaaxicdb|cgi ct ciubvcbfks

hidglhl ci |oh egva ge hihvjs bil |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi egv hihvjs ct 2'/2!U6'D6#>)8 zocdofhdgaht ciecic|h b| |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| bil cabjcibvs bfguh |ob| uhkgdc|s) \oh tc|xb|cgi dobijhtzohi zh hbacih ~gkbvcpb|cgi bijkh) \oh bijkh ge ~gkbvcpb|cgi ge b ~og|gi ct ahbtxvhl ci vblcbit+

zocdo ct b khij|o bkgij bi bvd lcuclhl fs |oh vblcxt ge |oh bvd) Bt txdo+ ~gkbvcpb|cgi bijkh ct bkhij|o lcuclhl fs b khij|o bil ct |ohvhegvh lcahitcgikhtt) \oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi egv bijkh ctxic|s egv bkk uhkgdc|cht fh|zhhi -'! ciecic|s) C| ct hbtcks togzi |ob| |oct dgidkxtcgi ogklt |vxh huhi b|oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| zohvh |oh lh|hvacib|cgi ge |oh |vbitegvab|cgi ciugkuht axk|c~kscij phvg |cahtciecic|s) Ce ~gkbvcpb|cgi dgx~kcij fh|zhhi &~bcvhl ~og|git& lght gddxv+ T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s zgxklbtthv| |ob| c| axt| gddxv b| bi ciecic|h uhkgdc|s ci bddgvlbidh huhi bt |oh agvh vb|cgibk ge |oh |zgci|hv~vh|b|cgit ge Rxbi|xa \ohgvs btthv|t |ob| c| lght) Bk|ogxjo |oh bx|ogvt ge |oh bv|cdkh ablh igtxdo dkbca+ ~hvob~t fhdbxth |ohs zctohl |ohcv zgvm |g fh ~xfkctohl+ |oh h~hvcahi|t lhtdvcfhl ci|oh bv|cdkh lhagit|vb|hl fg|o |ob| gxv bftgkx|h uhkgdc|s |ovgxjo t~bdh dgxkl fh ahbtxvhl/ubkclb|cij |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs guhv |oh T~hdcbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s# bil |ob|dgaaxicdb|cgi b| uhkgdc|cht jvhb|hv |obi |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| zbt ehbtcfkh zc|o acigv aglcecdb|cgi|g |oh hrxc~ahi|)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 21/110

8)4! Ci |oh bv|cdkh c| zbt t|b|hl |ob| b||ha~|t |g xth |oh b~~bvb|xt |g dgaaxicdb|h b| uhkgdc|chtjvhb|hv |obi |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| vhtxk|hl ci |oh |vbitacttcgi ge igcth cit|hbl ge ciegvab|cgi) \ohcvebckxvh |g bdochuh dgaaxicdb|cgi vhtxk|hl evga |oh ebd| |ob|+ zockh |ohs zhvh gfucgxtks jggl

rxbi|xa ~ostcdct|t+ |ohs zhvh ig| jggl dgaaxicdb|cgi hijcihhvt) Ci bibkgjgxt hkhd|vgicd |hvat+|ohs zhvh b||ha~|cij |g dgaaxicdb|h fs ~obth aglxkb|cij b vbilgaks ~obthl dbvvchv) Ci txdo bibvvbijhahi|+ |oh vbilgaks ~obthl dbvvchv ci`hd|t zoc|h igcth |ob| ~vhuhi|t |oh ciegvab|cgi+ zocdoct bd|xbkks ~vhthi| ci |oh vhdhcuhl tcjibk+ evga fhcij lhdglhl) \oh h~hvcahi| lcl lhagit|vb|h|ob|+ ce |oh dbvvchv obl fhhi dgohvhi|+ |oh lhtcvhl ~vg~bjb|cgi ge ciegvab|cgi b| |vbitkcjo| uhkgdc|szgxkl obuh fhhi bdochuhl)

8)<! \oh h~hvcahi|bk th|x~ ct lcbjvbahl ci Ecjxvh 8)2) B ~og|gi tgxvdh ct ~vguclhl zocdo dgi|bcihdc|hl b|gat ge b |s~h zocdo hac| b ~bcv ge ~og|git ge |oh tbah ~gkbvcpb|cgi ci g~~gtc|h lcvhd|cgizohihuhv gih ge |oha vhuhv|t |g c|t xihdc|hl t|b|h) Hbdo ge |oh ~og|git ge b ~bcv /khe| bil vcjo|# bthi| |g bi g~|cdbk tzc|do zocdo thilt c|t ~og|git ci gih ge |zg lcvhd|cgit ci vht~gith |g b

dgaabil tcjibk) Lh~hilcij x~gi |oh th||cij ge |oh tzc|do+ hbdo ~og|gi ~bttht |ovgxjo bogvcpgi|bkks gv uhv|cdbkks gvchi|hl ~gkbvcphv bil ct vhdhcuhl fs gih ge |zg ~og|gi lh|hd|gvt) /\zg~og|gi lh|hd|gvt bvh b| hbdo hil ge |oh b~~bvb|xt)# \oh gx|~x|t ge |oh egxv lh|hd|gvt zhvhdga~bvhl ci b dgcidclhidh lh|hd|gv) \oh ~xv~gth ge |oh dgcidclhidh lh|hd|gv ct |zgegkl) C| citxvht|ob| |oh giks lh|hd|cgit zocdo bvh vhdgvlhl bvh |ogth zocdo gddxv bt tcaxk|bihgxt ~bcvt b|g~~gtc|h hil ge |oh b~~bvb|xt bil |ohvhegvh vhtxk| evga ~og|gi ~bcvt bil ig| evga t~xvcgxt~og|git) C| bktg bkkgzt |oh ab|docij lh|hd|cgit |g fh tgv|hl ci|g egxv db|hjgvcht+ogvcpgi|bk'ogvcpgi|bk+ uhv|cdbk'uhv|cdbk+ ogvcpgi|bk'uhv|cdbk+ bil uhv|cdbk'ogvcpgi|bk) \oh khij|ot ge |ohvcjo| bil khe| obkuht ge |oh h~hvcahi|bk th|x~ bvh dbvhexkks ab|dohl |g dbidhk |oh heehd|t ge |oh|vbitc| |cah ge |oh ~og|git+ |oh ~vg~bjb|cgi |caht ge |oh lvcuh tcjibkt |g |oh tzc|doht+ bil |oh~vg~bjb|cgi |caht ge |oh tcjibkt evga |oh lh|hd|gvt |g |oh dgcidclhidh lh|hd|gvt)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 22/110

8)8! \oh vhtxk|cij lh|hd|cgit zhvh rxc|h vhuhbkcij) Bi guhvzohkacij ~vh~gilhvbidh ge |ohadgitct|hl ge ogvcpgi|bk'ogvcpgi|bk bil uhv|cdbk'uhv|cdbk huhi|t+ zc|o b axdo tabkkhv ixafhv geogvcpgi|bk'uhv|cdbk bil uhv|cdbk'ogvcpgi|bk huhi|t) Tcidh |oh vht~gith |cah ge |oh g~|cdbk tzc|dohtzocdo dobijhl |oh ~gkbvcpb|cgi ge gih ge |oh ~og|git zbt gi |oh gvlhv ge 2> ibigthdgilt bil |oh|cah vhrxcvhl egv kcjo| |g |vbuhk |oh khij|o ge |oh h~hvcahi|bk th|x~ zbt <> ibigthdgilt+ txdo bvhtxk| dgxkl giks obuh gddxvvhl ce |oh ~gkbvcpb|cgi dgx~kcij fh|zhhi |oh ~bcvhl ~og|git ~vg~bjb|hb| b uhkgdc|s zocdo zbt tcjicecdbi|ks kbvjhv |obi < |caht |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|) \oh bddxvbds ge |octlh|hvacib|cgi ct kcac|hl fs |oh t~hhl ge |oh tzc|doht bil fs |oh khij|o ge |oh th|x~) Zockh c| ct~vgfbfks rxc|h lceecdxk| |g ca~vguh |oh tzc|doht+ |oh khij|o ge |oh th|x~ ct+ ci ~vcidc~kh+ kcac|hl fs

|oh tcph ge |oh Hbv|o) C| ct ig| lceecdxk| |g hiuctcgi bi h~hvcahi|bk bvvbijhahi| zocdo zgxkllhagit|vb|h b ~vg~bjb|cgi uhkgdc|s egv ~gkbvcpb|cgi dgx~kcij fh|zhhi ~bcvhl ~og|git jvhb|hv |obiackkcgi |caht |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|)

8)5! Dgitclhv b aglcecdb|cgi |g |oh h~hvcahi|bk th|x~+ bt togzi ci Ecjxvh 8)6) Ci |oh h~hvcahi|vh~vhthi|hl fs Ecjxvh 8)2+ dbvh zbt |bmhi |g citxvh |ob| |oh ~b|o khij|ot |vbuhkhl fs hbdo ge |oh~bcvhl ~og|git bil |oh khij|o ge |oh tcjibk ~b|ot evga |oh g~|cdbk lh|hd|gvt |g |oh dgcidclhidhlh|hd|gvt zhvh hrxbk) \oct zbt lgih |g citxvh |ob| |oh heehd| ge bis uhkgdc|s |ob| |oh kbfgvb|gvsacjo| obuh zc|o vht~hd| |g t~bdh gi |oh |vbitc| |caht ge |oh ~og|git evga |oh tgxvdh |g |ohcvvht~hd|cuh ~og|gi lh|hd|gvt zbt dbidhkhl fs |oh heehd| ge |ob| tbah uhkgdc|s gi |oh ~vg~bjb|cgi|caht ge |oh tcjibkt evga |oh ~og|gi lh|hd|gvt |g |oh dgcidclhidh lh|hd|gvt) Bt b vhtxk|+ |ohh~hvcahi| zbt xibeehd|hl fs |oh uhkgdc|s ge |oh kbfgvb|gvs zc|o vht~hd| |g bis uhkgdc|s vhehvhidhevbah bvfc|vbvcks dogthi |g fh b| vht|) Ci |oh ~vg~gthl aglcecdb|cgi ge |oh h~hvcahi|+ |ohcilh~hilhidh ge |oh vhtxk|t gi |oh uhkgdc|s ge |oh kbfgvb|gvs |ovgxjo t~bdh ct hkcacib|hl fs aguci|oh dgcidclhidh lh|hd|gv |g |oh khe| tclh ge |oh th|x~ bil txft|c|x|cij bl`xt|bfkh lhkbs kciht ci |ohtcjibk ~b|ot fh|zhhi |oh khe| tclh ~og|gi lh|hd|gvt bil |oh dgcidclhidh lh|hd|gvt) \oh bl`xt|bfkhlhkbs kciht dga~hitb|h egv |oh ~vg~bjb|cgi lhkbs ge |oh tcjibkt fh|zhhi |oh vcjo| tclh ~og|gilh|hd|gvt bil |oh dgcidclhidh lh|hd|gvt bil bvh bl`xt|hl |g ~vguclh |oh abcaxa khuhk geogvcpgi|bk'ogvcpgi|bk bil uhv|cdbk'uhv|cdbk lh|hd|cgit) \oh th||cijt ge |oh lhkbs kciht zocdo vhtxk|evga |ob| bl`xt|ahi| ~vguclht |oh gx|~x| lb|b egv |oh h~hvcahi|)

8):! Tcidh |oct h~hvcahi| lceehvt evga |oh ~vhdhlcij gih giks ci |oh kgdb|cgi ge |oh dgcidclhidhlh|hd|gvt bil lght ig| lceehv ci |oh |vhb|ahi| ge |oh ~bcvhl ~og|git+ c| zckk bktg fh db~bfkh ge

lhagit|vb|cij |oh os~hvkcjo| uhkgdc|s ge dgx~kcij ge ~bcvhl ~og|git b| |oh gx|~x| ge c|t dgcidclhidlh|hd|gv) Egv |ob| dgcidclhidh |g fh gfthvuhl |oh ~vg~bjb|cgi lhkbs ge |oh lhkbs kciht axt| fhbl`xt|hl |g fh hrxbk |g |oh ~vg~bjb|cgi lhkbs ge |oh tcjibk ci |oh dbfkh zocdo dgx~kht |oh ~og|gilh|hd|gvt b| |oh vcjo| tclh |g |oh dgcidclhidh lh|hd|gvt) \oh buhvbjh ge |oh th||cijt ge |oh lhkbskciht ~vguclht |oh gx|~x| lb|b ge |oh h~hvcahi|) Ce gih bvfc|vbvcks bttcjit b uhkgdc|s ge -U |gvh~vhthi| |oh bftgkx|h uhkgdc|s ge |oh kbfgvb|gvs |ovgxjo t~bdh ci b lcvhd|cgi |g |oh vcjo|+ c| togxklfh ~gttcfkh |g lh|hvacih |ob| uhkgdc|s evga |oh buhvbjh lhkbs+ \bu+ th| ci|g |oh lhkbs kciht) Bt

gfthvuhl ci b uhkgdc|s vhehvhidh evbah zocdo ct b| vht|+ |oh uhkgdc|s ge ~vg~bjb|cgi ge |oh tcjibk|ovgxjo |oh dbfkh ct cidvhbthl fs U bil fhdgaht D-U+ bil |oh th||cij ge |oh lhkbs kcih axt| fhdobijhl evga c|t igacibk ubkxh ge \bu1D'K |g dga~hitb|h) \oh uhkgdc|s ge |oh kbfgvb|gvs |ovgxjo

t~bdh ct |ohi jcuhi fs U1D!\buD6'K)

8)?! Tcidh |oh ubkxh ge U ct b ixafhv zocdo abs fh fvgbldbt|+ |oh ahbtxvhl uhkgdc|s ge |ohkbfgvb|gvs abs fh |vbitac||hl |g b thvcht ge gfthvuhvt obucij uhkgdc|cht lceehvhi| evga |ob| ge |ohkbfgvb|gvs bil lceehvhi| evga hbdo g|ohv) Ce |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs dgvvhd|ks vh~vhthi|t vhbkc|s|oh tbah ixafhv zckk fh vhdhcuhl fs bkk ge |oh agucij gfthvuhvt bil zckk vh~vhthi| |oh bftgkx|huhkgdc|s ge |oh kbfgvb|gvs |ovgxjo t~bdh) Ce |oh T~hdcbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s dgvvhd|ks vh~vhthi|tvhbkc|s+ |oh ixafhv zocdo ct fvgbldbt| evga |oh kbfgvb|gvs zckk hrxbk phvg zockh |oh ixafhv vhdhcuhfs hbdo ge |oh g|ohv gfthvuhvt zckk fh hrxbk |g |oh uhkgdc|s ge |oh kbfgvb|gvs zc|o vht~hd| |g ocathkBkk ge |ogth gfthvuhvt zgxkl vhdhcuh b lceehvhi| ixafhv" /Ce bis vhblhv bddh~|t txdo b vhtxk| bt~gttcfkh+ |oh bx|ogv zgxkl kcmh |g ahh| oca) \ohvh ct b fvcljh guhv Ihz Sgvm Dc|s*t Hbt| Vcuhv |ob|oh obt fhhi |vscij |g thkk egv tgah |cah)# \oh txddhtt ge |oh ~bcvhl ~og|gi h~hvcahi| ge Ecjxvh 8citxvht |oh ca~gttcfckc|s ge b vhtxk| ci zocdo |oh lhkbs kcih th||cijt zgxkl vhabci xidobijhl b|

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 23/110

\bu1D'K bt |oh Hbv|o vg|b|hl gi c|t bct bil aguhl ci c|t gvfc|)

8)3! \oh h~hvcahi| ge Ecjxvh 8)2 dbi fh aglcechl |g hkcacib|h c|t togv|dgacijt bt b dgaaxicdb|cgtst|ha fs ~vguclcij b ~obth dgohvhi| dbvvchv egv |oh ciegvab|cgi |g fh |vbitac||hl fs |oh ~bcvhl~og|git) Ecjxvh 8)4 togzt b ahbit ge ~vguclcij ~obth dgohvhids ge |oh ~bcvhl ~og|git fscithv|cij bllc|cgibk ~gkbvcphvt b| |oh ~og|gi tgxvdh zocdo bvh gvchi|hl ~bvbkkhk |g hbdo g|ohv bil b

bi bijkh ge <8 lhjvhht |g |oh ogvcpgi|bk bil uhv|cdbk ~gkbvcphvt bkvhbls lhtdvcfhl) Tcidh |oh~xv~gth ge |oct h~hvcahi| ct |g lhagit|vb|h ebt|hv |obi kcjo| dgaaxicdb|cgi evga vcjo| |g khe|+ |ohtzc|do ct hkcacib|hl evga |oh khe| tclh ge |oh th|x~ bil |oh lh|hd|gvt b| |oh vcjo| tclh ge |oh th|x~bvh vh~kbdhl fs ~og|gi bftgvfhvt) Lb|b ct ci~x||hl |g |oh tst|ha |ovgxjo |oh tzc|do b| |oh vcjo|tclh ge |oh th|x~) Ci ~kbdh ge |oh tzc|do b| |oh khe| tclh+ b dvst|bk ct ~vguclhl zocdo lcuclht |ohcidclhi| kcjo| ci|g |zg ~gkbvcphl fhbat zogth bht bvh ~hv~hilcdxkbv) \oh gvchi|b|cgi ge |oh~gkbvcpcij dvst|bk ct dogthi txdo |ob| gih ge |oh fhbat ct uhv|cdbkks ~gkbvcphl bil |oh g|ohv fhba ogvcpgi|bkks ~gkbvcphl) Hbdo ge |ohth fhbat ct thithl fs b ~og|gi lh|hd|gv bil |oh gx|~x| ge |ogtlh|hd|gvt ct lhdglhl |g ~vguclh |oh vhdhcuhl tcjibk)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 24/110

8)2>! Bttxacij |ob| |oh bllc|cgi ge |oh dgohvhids ~vglxdcij ~gkbvcphvt lght ig| ci|hvehvh zc|o |oh~gkbvcpb|cgi dgx~kcij ge |oh ~bcvhl ~og|git gfthvuhl ci |oh h~hvcahi| ge Ecjxvh 8)2 /sh| |g fhuhvcechl h~hvcahi|bkks#+ |oh gx|~x|t ge |oh lhdglhv b| |oh khe| tclh ge |oh th|x~ zckk dgi|bci b tcjibclhi|cdbk |g |oh tcjibk cithv|hl ci|g |oh tzc|do gi |oh vcjo| tclh ge |oh th|x~) B dga~x|hv tcaxkb|cgi|g lh|hvacih |oh khuhk ge |oh tcjibk vhdhcuhl b| hbdo lh|hd|gv togzt c| |g fh agvh |obi blhrxb|h |glctdvcacib|h bjbcit| igcth) Bt ci |oh bvvbijhahi| ge Ecjxvh 8)2+ 8>( ge |oh ~og|git jhihvb|hl fs

|oh ~og|gi tgxvdh zckk fh vhdhcuhl /bttxacij ig t~xvcgxt kgttht#) Ge |ohth ~og|git+ :8( zckk fhlcvhd|hl |g |oh lh|hd|gv zocdo zbt thkhd|hl fs |oh |vbitac||cij tzc|do bil 68( zckk fh lcvhd|hl |g|oh g|ohv lh|hd|gv) \oh vhtxk|cij lhdglhv gx|~x| zgxkl |ohi fh h~hd|hl |g obuh b ~hbm |g ~hbmba~kc|xlh /clhbk dbth# hrxbk |g 8>( ge |oh ~og|gi gx|~x| ge gih tclh ge |oh ~bcvhl ~og|gi tgxvdh) Czgxkl fh ci|hvht|cij |g obuh txdo bi h~hvcahi| ~hvegvahl)

8)22! \oh ^bcvhl ^og|gi H~hvcahi| lhtdvcfhl ci Ecjxvh 8)2 dkhbvks ht|bfkctoht |ob| |oh T~hdcbk\ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s giks txvucuhl fhdbxth |oh ihdhttbvs h~hvcahi|t |g ubkclb|h c|t t~hdcbk dbthtgkx|cgi+ |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs+ zhvh fhsgil |oh t|b|h ge |oh bv| xi|ck thuhvbk jhihvb|cgit ge~ostcdct|t obl fhhi fvbcizbtohl ci|g cjigvcij |oh ebd| |ob|+ xikcmh |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs+ c|dgi|vblcd|hl dgaagi thith) \oh clhb |ob| rxbi|xa ixafhvt+ txdo bt ~gkbvcpb|cgi+ dbi ~vg~bjb|hb| bi ciecic|h uhkgdc|s bil hocfc| abis /ce ig| bkk# ge |oh ~vg~hv|cht ge |bdosgit lght ig| ucgkb|h |ohdgidh~| |ob| hihvjs dbiig| fh |vbitac||hl ebt|hv |obi uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|) \oh |vbitacttcgi geciegvab|cgi lght ig| ihdhttbvcks vhrxcvh |oh |vbitacttcgi ge hihvjs) Tcidh |oh hihvjs ge b ~og|gilght ig| dobijh bt b vhtxk| ge b dobijh ci c|t lcvhd|cgi ge ~gkbvcpb|cgi+ |ohvh ct ig ~vgocfc|cgi+ huhici T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s+ bjbcit| ciegvab|cgi vh~vhthi|hl fs |oh lcvhd|cgi ge ~gkbvcpb|cgi ge ~bcvhl~og|git ~vg~bjb|cij b| bi ciecic|h uhkgdc|s) T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s obt fhhi h~hvcahi|bkkslhagit|vb|hl |g fh cidga~kh|h) C|t t~hdcbk dbth tgkx|cgi+ |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs ct |oh dgvvhdci|hv~vh|b|cgi ge vhbkc|s+ bil+ egv |oh vhabcilhv ge |oct |h|+ c|t txf`hd| ab||hv zckk fh vhehvvhl |g btUhkgdc|s Vhkb|cuc|s |g lct|cijxcto c| evga |oh vhkb|cuct|cd |vhb|ahi| ge jvbuc|b|cgi zocdo zckk fhlhtcjib|hl bt Jvbuc|s Vhkb|cuc|s) \oh Ha~hvgv lght obuh dkg|oht be|hv bkk" 

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 25/110

Dob~|hv 5 ! \oh Ib|xvh ge Vhbkc|s

5)2! Lg \oh Heehd|t Gfthvuhl Fh|zhhi Uhkgdc|s bil'gv Hkhub|cgi Vhehvhidh Evbaht Gddxv Fhdbxthge b Dobijh ci Vhbkc|s gv Fhdbxth ge b Dobijh ci |oh Xic|t ge Ahbtxvhahi| Fs Zocdo \ob| Vhbkc|sct Gfthvuhl70! Ci |oh 23|o dhi|xvs+ c| zbt xicuhvtbkks bttxahl |ob| |ohvh zbt bi xilhvkscij vhbkc|szocdo hct|hl cilh~hilhi|ks ge |oh ahbit fs zocdo c| zbt ahbtxvhl) \oh Kgvhi|p

Dgi|vbd|cgi!Bh|ohv \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s bddh~|hl |oct uchz~gci|+ fx|+ xilhv |oh T~hdcbk |ohgvs geVhkb|cuc|s+ |oh ahbtxvhahi| c|thke fhdbah |oh vhbkc|s bil |oh vhbkc|s fhihb|o |oh ahbtxvhahi|fhdbah ahbicijkhtt) \g hbacih |oh lceehvhidh fh|zhhi |ohth ~ockgtg~ocdbk b~~vgbdoht+ kh| xtdgitclhv |oh ca~kcdb|cgit ge b tca~kh |ogxjo| h~hvcahi| bt togzi ci Ecjxvh 5)2B) Ci |octh~hvcahi|+ |ohvh bvh |zg vggat hbdo dgi|bcicij clhi|cdbk dkgdmt zocdo abs fh ci|hvdobijhlzc|ogx| beehd|cij |oh vhtxk|t) Bktg ci |ohth vggat bvh hkhd|vcdbkks g~hvb|hl fxpphvt bd|cub|hl fs bdgaagi tcjibk) Bi h~hvcahi|hv ~vhttht b fx||gi |g tgxil |oh fxpphvt bil gfthvuhvt ci hbdovgga ig|h |oh |cah b| zocdo |oh fxpphv tgxilt) Bi ogxv kb|hv+ |oh h~hvcahi|hv bjbci tgxilt |ohfxpphv+ bil |oh gfthvuhvt ci hbdo vgga bjbci ig|h |oh |cah) Ci vgga B+ |oh gfthvuhv vh~gv|t |ob|gih ogxv obt ~btthl fh|zhhi |oh tgxilcijt ge |oh fxpphv) Ci vgga F+ |oh gfthvuhv vh~gv|t |ob| 8>acix|ht obuh hkb~thl) Tcidh |oh dkgdmt bvh clhi|cdbk+ |oh ~ockgtg~os bttgdcb|hl zc|o T~hdcbk bilJhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s btthv|t |ob| |oh gfthvub|cgit togz |ob| |cah ~bttht agvh tkgzks ci vgga F |obi

c| lght ci vgga B) \ohvh ct+ ge dgxvth+ b ~vgfkha zc|o |oct btthv|cgi+ |oh lxvb|cgi ge |cah fh|zhhi|oh tgxilcijt ge |oh fxpphvt zbt |oh tbah ci fg|o vggat tcidh |ohs zhvh bd|cub|hl fs |oh tbahtcjibk bil |oh ~vg~bjb|cgi |cah egv |ob| tcjibk fh|zhhi |oh vggat ct axdo tabkkhv |obi |ohlceehvhidh ci vhblcijt ge |oh dkgdmt) Vh~hb|cij |oh h~hvcahi| zc|o |oh dkgdmt ci|hvdobijhlfh|zhhi vggat schklt |oh tbah vhtxk| bil togzt |ob| b lceehvhidh fh|zhhi |oh dkgdmt zbt ig| |ohdbxth ge |oh lceehvhidh ci |oh gfthvuhl lxvb|cgit)

5)6! \oh h~hvcahi|bk vhtxk|t b~~hbv bftxvl xi|ck c| ct khbvihl |ob| |oh dkgdmt bvh ge |oh gklebtocgihl |s~h lvcuhi fs tsidovgigxt hkhd|vcd ag|gvt evga bi h|hvibk B!D ~gzhv tgxvdh) Zob| |oh~hvcahi| bd|xbkks vhuhbkt ct |ob| |oh dkgdm ci vgga B ct g~hvb|hl evga b 5> Op) ~gzhv tgxvdh+ bt dgiuhi|cgibk ci |oh XTB+ bil |oh dkgdm ci vgga F ct g~hvb|hl evga b 8> Op) ~gzhv tgxvdh+ bt ctdgiuhi|cgibk ci Hxvg~h) \oh ~bttbjh ge |cah vh~gv|hl fs hbdo dkgdm zbt lh|hvacihl fs |oh vgga zocdo c| zbt ~kbdhl bt zhkk bt fs |oh bd|xbk ~bttbjh ge |cah) \g ahbtxvh |oh bd|xbk ~bttbjh ge |ca

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 26/110

ci hbdo vgga+ c| ct ihdhttbvs |g lh|hvacih |oh heehd| ge |ob| vgga gi |oh t~hhl ge c|t dkgdm bil |gdgvvhd| hbdo gfthvub|cgi egv |ob| heehd| zc|o vht~hd| |g bi bjvhhl x~gi xicuhvtbk t|bilbvl) Zc|ogxtxdo b dgvvhd|cgi+ |oh |hva JCJG b~~kcht |g |oh h~hvcahi|) /JCJG ct bi h~vhttcgi egvaxkb|hl ci|oh hbvks lbst ge |oh dga~x|hv) C| ahbit jbvfbjh ci 1 jbvfbjh gx|)#

5)4! \oh ~vhdhlcij vb|ohv eb|xgxt lhtdvc~|cgi zbt ~vguclhl |g togz |oh ihhl egv vhdgjicpcij |ob|+zohi b rxbi|c|s ct gfthvuhl xtcij clhbk cit|vxahi|t ci vhehvhidh evbaht zocdo lceehv ci uhkgdc|sbil'gv hkhub|cgi+ c| ct ihdhttbvs |g lct|cijxcto fh|zhhi |zg heehd|t) \oh heehd| ge ci|hvht| gddxvt btb vhtxk| ge b dobijh ge |oh rxbi|c|s c|thke) Gfthvub|cgi ge |ob| heehd| abs fh dgvvx~|hl fs b dobijh

ci |oh dbkcfvb|cgi /tcph ge |oh xic|t ge ahbtxvhahi|# ge |oh ahbtxvcij cit|vxahi|/t# zocdo gddxvtfh|zhhi |oh vhehvhidh evbaht) \oh ~vhlcd|cgit ge Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s dbxthl ahbtxvhahi|t |g fhablh zocdo lhagit|vb|hl |ob| |oh vb|h ge ~bttbjh ge |cah tkgzt bt |oh hkhub|cgi ci b jvbuc|b|cgibkechkl ct vhlxdhl) \g fh gf`hd|cuh+ gih axt| lh|hvacih zoh|ohv |oh vb|h ge ~bttbjh ge |cah bd|xbkkslhdvhbtht gv zoh|ohv dkgdmt vxi agvh tkgzks /xic|t ge ahbtxvhahi| egv |cah bvh kbvjhv# b| |oh kgzhkhub|cgi gv zoh|ohv fg|o heehd|t gddxv ci dgafcib|cgi) Egv|xib|hks+ b ~ostcdbkks vhbkcpbfkh |ogxjoh~hvcahi| dbi ~vguclh |oh bitzhv)

5)<! Dgitclhv ih| bi h~hvcahi|bk th|x~ ci b uhv|cdbk tobe| lvckkhl ci|g b agxi|bci+ bt togzi ciEcjxvh 5)2F) B ~bcv ge clhi|cdbk b|gacd dkgdmt bvh agxi|hl b| |oh |g~ bil fg||ga ge |oh tobe|) \ohohcjo| ge |oh tobe| ct txeecdchi|+ ~hvob~t 2>+>>> ehh|+ tg |ob| |oh dkgdmt dbi bddxvb|hks ahbtxvh |ohjvbuc|b|cgibkks cilxdhl lceehvhidh ci |oh vb|h ge ~bttbjh ge |cah fh|zhhi |oh |g~ bil |oh fg||ga ge|oh tobe|) B| |oh t|bv| ge |oh h~hvcahi|+ b tcjibk ct thi| evga |oh fg||ga ge |oh tobe| |g |oh |g~ bil|oh dkgdmt bvh tsidovgicphl) B| |oh hil ge |oh h~hvcahi|+ b thdgil tcjibk ct thi| evga |oh fg||ga|g |oh |g~ ge |oh tobe| bil |oh hkb~thl |cah ct vhbl gi fg|o dkgdmt) Tcidh |oh lxvb|cgi ge |ohh~hvcahi| zckk fh beehd|hl fs bis uhkgdc|s cilxdhl lceehvhidh ci |oh ~vg~bjb|cgi |cah ge |oh t|bv|bil t|g~ tcjibkt fh|zhhi |oh hkhub|cgit+ |oh heehd| ge ~vg~bjb|cgi |cah hvvgv ct acicacphl fsabmcij |oh lxvb|cgi ge |oh h~hvcahi| hrxbk |g egxv shbvt) \oct |cah t~bi citxvht |ob| |oh dobijh uhkgdc|s ge |oh tobe| |ovgxjo t~bdh bt b vhtxk| ge |oh gvfc|bk ag|cgi ge |oh Hbv|o bil ge c|t vg|b|cgi cacicacphl) Zc|o |oct ~vhdbx|cgi+ |oh lceehvhidh ci |oh lxvb|cgi ge |oh h~hvcahi| fh|zhhi hkhub|cgi

dbi fh vhlxdhl |g khtt |obi gih ~cdgthdgil) Tcidh egxv shbvt ct 2)682>? thdgilt+ |oh lxvb|cgi g

|oh h~hvcahi| ct |oh tbah b| fg|o hkhub|cgit |g bi bddxvbds ge fh||hv |obi gih ~bv| ci 2>6>) \ohtkgzcij ge |cah+ bt ahbtxvhl fs |oh lceehvhidh ci vhblcijt ge |ohth dkgdmt+ guhv |oh hkhub|cgi

lceehvhidh ge 2>+>>> ehh| ct bfgx| ge gih ~bv| ci 42>24) \g bi bddxvbds ge fh||hv |obi 2 ~bv| ci backkcgi+ |oh lceehvhidh zocdo zckk fh gfthvuhl ci |oh lxvb|cgi ge |oh h~hvcahi| fh|zhhi |oh x~~hvbil kgzhv hkhub|cgi vhtxk|t evga b lceehvhidh ci |oh t~hhl ge |oh dkgdmt bil ig| evga b dobijh ci|oh vb|h ge ~bttbjh ge |cah) Zh abs dgidkxlh |ohvhegvh |ob| |oh vb|h ge ~bttbjh ge |cah ct bibftgkx|h zocdo ct cilh~hilhi| ge zoh|ohv b ahbtxvhahi| obt fhhi ablh bil cilh~hilhi| ge |ohdobvbd|hvct|cdt ge bis cit|vxahi|t acjo| obuh fhhi xthl |g abmh txdo b ahbtxvhahi|)

5)8! \oh ~vhdhlcij ~bvbjvb~o khblt |g |oh dgidkxtcgi |ob| b dobijh ge vhehvhidh evbah /hkhub|cgi guhkgdc|s # dbxtht b dobijh ci |oh tcph ge |oh xic|t ge ahbtxvhahi| egv |cah /lxvb|cgi ge |cahfh|zhhi |oh |cdmt ge |oh dkgdm# fs zocdo |oh dkgdm jbxjht |oh ~bttbjh ge |cah zockh |oh vb|h ge~bttbjh ge |cah c|thke ct xidobijhl) Ce txdo b dgidkxtcgi b~~kcht |g |cah ci b jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl+dgitct|hids vhrxcvht |ob| c| b~~ks |g bkk g|ohv ahbtxvhahi|t /egvdh+ abtt+ khij|o+ h|d)# ci zocdovhkb|cuct|cd heehd|t bvh ciugkuhl) \oh vhkb|cuct|cd |ohgvcht axt| |ohi bd|xbkks fh b ahbit ge mhh~cij|vbdm ge |oh dgithrxhidht ge dobijht ci tcph ge |oh ubvcgxt xic|t ge ahbtxvhahi| zocdo gddxv bt vhtxk| ge b dobijh ci uhkgdc|s gv hkhub|cgi) \ohs lg ig| ciugkuh |oh tcph ge |ogth rxbi|c|cht ci |ohbftgkx|h thith)

5)5! \oh Ib|xvh ge Abtt0! \ovgxjogx| |oh tdchidh ge ~ostcdt+ |oh dgidh~| ge abtt ~kbst bica~gv|bi| vgkh) Txf`hd|cuhks+ |oh ahbicij ge abtt zbt fvgxjo| ogah |g |oh zvc|hv rxc|h ucuclksshbvt bjg bt oh t|ggl gi b lgdm zockh b kbvjh evhcjo|hv zbt fhcij aggvhl) B~~bvhi|ks |oh db~|bcige |oh toc~ bil'gv |oh |xjfgb| dvhz zhvh ig| txeecdchi|ks tmckkhl+ bil |oh toc~ zbt ~xtohl |gzbvl|oh lgdm b| b t~hhl hrxcubkhi| |g |oh dvbzk ge b tkhh~s |xv|kh) \oh toc~ dgi|bd|hl |oh jvgx~ ge ~chvtx~~gv|t+ hbdo dga~gthl bfgx| b lgphi 26 cido lcbah|hv zgglhi ~ckcijt+ bil mh~| vcjo| gi

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 27/110

agucij) Lht~c|h c|t h|vhahks tkgz t~hhl+ fhegvh |oh toc~ dbah |g vht| c| obl ~xtohl |oh abttcuh~chv tx~~gv|t bfgx| egxv ehh| tclhzbst bil ablh ihdhttbvs b tcjicecdbi| lhjvhh ge lgdm vh~bcv) Gigiks ihhl |g gfthvuh txdo bi gddxvvhidh |g b~~vhdcb|h |oh tcjicecdbidh ge |oh toc~*t cihv|cbk abtt

5):! Ci |oh bfguh h~hvchidh+ |oh bx|ogv lcl ig| bd|xbkks gfthvuh |oh abtt ge |oh toc~+ oh gfthvuhl|oh heehd|t ge |oh egvdh zocdo vhtxk|hl zohi |oh ~chv tx~~gv|t b||ha~|hl |g khtthi |oh toc~*tuhkgdc|s) Gfthvub|cgi ge txdo b egvdh ct |oh giks abiihv ci zocdo gih dbi ahbtxvh |oh cihv|cbk abtge bis gf`hd| gv ~bv|cdkh) Cihv|cbk abtt dbiig| fh gfthvuhl lcvhd|ks) C| dbi giks fh gfthvuhl bt |ohcidvhahi|bk ca~xkth /egvdh!|cah ~vglxd|# vhrxcvhl |g ~vglxdh bi cidvhahi|bk dobijh ci uhkgdc|s

/khij|o'|cah rxg|chi|# bil ct agvh ~vg~hvks lhecihl ci |hvat ge egvdh+ khij|o bil |cah) Tcackbvks+jvbuc|b|cgibk abtt ct gfthvubfkh giks ci |hvat ge egvdh+ khij|o+ bil big|ohv migzi jvbuc|b|cgibkabtt ci bddgvlbidh zc|o Ihz|gi*t Kbz ge Jvbuc|b|cgi) Ecibkks+ ce gih dgitclhvt |oh hrxcubkhidh

fh|zhhi abtt bil hihvjs+ \ogatgi*t H1AD6+ gih ig|ht |ob| giks |zg ge |oh |ovhh |hvat ci |ob|hrxb|cgi bvh cilh~hilhi|) Tcidh+ xikcmh abtt+ fg|o |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| bil hihvjs bvh lcvhd|ksgfthvubfkh+ abtt axt| fh b lh~hilhi| ubvcbfkh zc|ogx| hct|hidh bt bi hi|c|s ci c|t gzi vcjo|)

5)?! \oh actb~~kcdb|cgi ge |oh dgidh~| ge abtt obt khl ~ostcdct|t |g tgah zhcvl dgidkxtcgit) Egvhba~kh+ |oh ~og|gi bil |oh ihx|vcig bvh dgitclhvhl |g fh abttkhtt ~bv|cdkht lht~c|h |oh ebd| |ob||ohs vh~vhthi| |oh ~vhthidh ge hihvjs bil obuh cihv|cbk bil jvbuc|b|cgibk ~vg~hv|cht dgitct|hi| zc||oh khuhk ge |ob| hihvjs) /Ci |oh bx|ogv*t |h| &Jvbuc|s&+ c| ct togzi |ob| |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk abttvh~vhthi|hl fs |oh hihvjs ge b ~og|gi gv ihx|vcig ct |zcdh |ob| ge |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk abtt ge |ohtbah rxbi|c|s ge hihvjs ci b |oh egva ge b ab|hvcbk ~bv|cdkh)# \oh vhbtgi |ob| ~og|git bil ihx|vcigbvh dbkkhl &abttkhtt& ~bv|cdkht ct |ob| |ohs lg ig| ~gtthtt abtt zohi |ohs bvh b| vht|) Tcidh |oht~bv|cdkht giks hct| zohi |ohs |vbuhk b| |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|+ |ohcv lhtcjib|cgi bt &abttkhtt&~bv|cdkht zgxkl thha |g fh vb|ohv evcugkgxt) Agvh lbabjcij+ |oh lhtcjib|cgi ge |ohth ~bv|cdkht btabttkhtt gftdxvht |oh ebd| |ob| |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk abtt ge |oh fbdmjvgxil vblcb|cgi ci gxv xicuhvthhdhhlt |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk abtt ge c|t ab||hv fs b zclh abvjci) \oct ebxk|s lhecic|cgi obt dbxthlbt|vgigahvt bil dgtagkgjct|t |g t~hil b jvhb| lhbk ge heegv| ci thbvdocij egv |oh lbvm ab||hvihhlhl |g bddgxi| egv jvbuc|b|cgibkks cilxdhl fhobucgv gfthvuhl |ovgxjogx| |oh Xicuhvth) B vgxjodbkdxkb|cgi togzt |oh tg dbkkhl &abttkhtt& ~bv|cdkht hbtcks dgi|bci higxjo jvbuc|b|cgibk abtt |gbddgxi| egv |ob| fhobucgv) \oh cihv|cbk abtt ge |oh tg dbkkhl &abttkhtt& ~bv|cdkht bktg ~vguclhttxeecdchi| vblcb|cgi ~vhttxvh |g ~vhuhi| |oh Xicuhvth evga dgi|vbd|cij lxh |g jvbuc|b|cgibk

bvv|bd|cgi)

5)3! \oh dkbttcdbk dgidh~| ge cihv|cbk abtt ct |oh cidvhahi|bk dobijh ge |g|bk hihvjs+ /lH#+ vhtxk|cij

evga bi cidvhahi|bk dobijh ci uhkgdc|s+ /lU#) Fhdbxth H1AD6+ c| egkkgzt |ob| /lA#1/lH#'D6+ bil+ci |hvat ge |ob| lhecic|cgi ge abtt+ |oh heehd| ge abtt ct agvh ~vg~hvks ~vguclhl fs |oh lhvcub|cuh g|oh dgiuhi|cgibk Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi egv Abtt zc|o vht~hd| |g uhkgdc|s+ |oh Kgvhi|p\vbitegvab|cgi egv Cidvhahi|bk Abtt) \oh dxvuht ge Ecjxvh 5)6 ~vguclh |oh vhkb|cgitoc~ fh|zhhi |ofg|o |oh abtt bil |oh cidvhahi|bk abtt ge bi gf`hd| bt b exid|cgi ge c|t uhkgdc|s) C| zckk fh ig|hl|ob| |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi egv Cidvhahi|bk Abtt ct |oh tkg~h /ecvt| lhvcub|cuh# ge |oh dxvuh egv|oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi egv Abtt) Zohi |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi egv Cidvhahi|bk Abtt ctha~kgshl ci |oh tgkx|cgi ge vhkb|cuct|cd ~vgfkhat+ abtt obt |oh dgvvhd| lcahitcgibk dgi|hi| bil |olctdvh~bids fh|zhhi c|t xth ci dkbttcdbk ~vgfkhat bil c|t xth ci vhkb|cuct|cd ~vgfkhat ubictoht)

T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s*t bv|cecdcbkc|s ge txft|c|x|cij agahi|xa egv abtt ct ig kgijhv vhrxcvhl)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 28/110

5)2>! \oh xth ge |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi egv Abtt cit|hbl ge |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi egvCidvhahi|bk Abtt khl |g |oh ebkth dgidkxtcgi |ob|+ tcidh T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s zbt lhvcuhl egv vhehvhidevbaht obucij vhkb|cuh uhkgdc|s+ c| dgxkl ig| fh b~~kchl |g bddhkhvb|hl vhehvhidh evbaht) \ob|dgidkxtcgi ct cidgvvhd|) Fg|o T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s bil |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs ~vguclh|vbitegvab|cgit egv fg|o khij|o bil |cah) Tcidh uhkgdc|s ct |oh ecvt| lhvcub|cuh ge khij|o zc|o vht~hd|g |cah bil bddhkhvb|cgi ct |oh thdgil lhvcub|cuh ge khij|o zc|o vht~hd| |g |cah+ ce T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|sbil'gv Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s dbi lhbk dgvvhd|ks zc|o |oh heehd|t ge uhkgdc|s+ |ohs axt| bktg fh bfkh |g lh

dgvvhd|ks zc|o |oh heehd|t ge bddhkhvb|cgi) Dgi|vbvs |g lgjab+ Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s ct ig| vhrxcvhl egv|ob| ~xv~gth)

5)22! \oh Ahdobicta Fhocil |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgit0! \oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgit ~vguclh blhtdvc~|cgi ge ogz ab||hv fhobuht zohi c|t uhkgdc|s ct dobijhl tg |ob| |oh ^vcidc~kh ge Vhkb|cuc|s ctb|ctechl bil gfthvuhvt agucij zc|o |ob| ab||hv dbi bkzbst dgitclhv |ohathkuht |g fh b| vht|) C| ctlhtcvbfkh |g lhtdvcfh ogz |ohth |vbitegvab|cgit dgah bfgx| ci b abiihv zocdo ct dgitct|hi| zc|odgaagi thith tg |ob| |oh heehd| dbi fh vhblcks xilhvt|ggl bil ct ig| fhdkgxlhl fs ab|ohab|cdbkgfextdb|cgi) Ci gvlhv |g ahbtxvh b khij|o+ gih acjo| xth b sbvlt|cdm /gv ah|hvt|cdm ce sgx ~vhehv# b|oh xic| ge ahbtxvhahi|) Ci |oh clhbk dbth+ |oh khij|o ge |oct sbvlt|cdm ct dga~gthl ge b dobci geb|gat zogth guhvbkk khij|o ct lh|hvacihl fs |oh ixafhv ge b|gat ci |oh dobci bil |oh lct|bidhfh|zhhi |oha) Ce |oh uhkgdc|s ge |oh sbvlt|cdm ct dobijhl+ |oh t~bdcij fh|zhhi |oh b|gat ci |oh

dobci abs dobijh+ fx| |oh ixafhv ge b|gat ci |oh dobci zckk ig|) \oh ~vgfkha ge lh|hvacicijkhij|ot |ohi fgckt lgzi |g lh|hvacicij ogz b|gat dgi|vgk |ohcv t~bdcij) Egv hba~kh+ |oh |zg

b|gat ci b oslvgjhi agkhdxkh abci|bci b th~bvb|cgi ge tkcjo|ks guhv 2>!2> ah|hvt bil t|vgijksvhtct| bis gx|tclh egvdht b||ha~|cij |g dobijh |ob| t~bdcij) Tcidh |oh t~bdcij fh|zhhi |oh b|gat

vh~vhthi|t b lct|bidh ge 2>8 |caht |oh lcbah|hv ge |oh ~vg|gi ci zocdo 33)38( ge |oh abtt ge |ohb|ga vhtclht+ c| ct gfucgxt |ob| |oh b|gat obuh tgah ahbit ge ahbtxvcij |ohcv th~bvb|cgi bilb~~kscij |oh egvdht ihhlhl |g abci|bci |ob| th~bvb|cgi guhv zob|+ |g |oh b|ga+ ct bi higvagxtlct|bidh)

5)26! Ci |oh abdvgtdg~cd zgvkl+ |ohvh bvh |ovhh ahbit fs zocdo lct|bidht dbi fh ahbtxvhl fshkhd|vgabjih|cd ahbit) \ohs bvh |vcbijxkb|cgi+ |oh vblbv ~vcidc~kh+ bil dga~bvctgi ge |oh |cah

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 29/110

lceehvhidh fh|zhhi |zg tcjibkt zocdo ~vg~bjb|h b| lceehvhi| uhkgdc|cht /h)j)! |oh lceehvhidh ci |cahfh|zhhi |oh gfthvub|cgi ge b kcjo|icij ekbto |oh gfhvub|cgi ge |oh tgxil ge |oh ekbto#) \vcbijxkb|cgiogzhuhv+ vhrxcvht |oh ~vh!hct|hidh ge b fbthkcih ge b migzi khij|o+ bil+ zockh c| acjo| thha |gbitzhv |oh rxht|cgi ge ogz |zg oslvgjhi b|gat acjo| ahbtxvh bil abci|bci |ohcv th~bvb|cgi+ c| ctig| b ucbfkh h~kbib|cgi fhdbxth c| vhrxcvht |ob| |ohvh fh bi cilh~hilhi| ahbit ge lhecicij |ohfbthkcih) \vcbijxkb|cgi lght ig| vhtgkuh |oh ~vgfkha+ c| ahvhks aguht c| |g big|ohv kgdb|cgi) \ohvblbv ~vcidc~kh lght ig| txeehv evga |oct kcac|b|cgi bil zgxkl thha |g fh b vhbtgibfkh dbilclb|h)\oh vhdgjic|cgi+ ogzhuhv+ |ob| Fhkk*t Cihrxbkc|s togzt |ob| rxbi|xa heehd|t ~vg~bjb|h b| bi ciecic|huhkgdc|s txjjht|t |ob| |oh dga~bvctgi ge |cah lceehvhidh /|oh tgxil ge |oxilhv bil |oh ekbto ge

kcjo|icij# ct b agvh ~vgfbfkh ahdobicta /dcvdb 6>>4#) /\oh zvc|hv vh`hd|t bt eggkctoihtt |oh clhb g^bvbkkhk Xicuhvtht)# \oct ahdobicta vhrxcvht |oh hct|hidh ge bi hi|c|s hct|t zocdo ~vg~bjb|ht bb echl uhkgdc|s |ovgxjo |oh b~~bvhi|ks ha~|s t~bdh fh|zhhi |oh b|gat) Hkhd|vgabjih|cd vblcb|cgi~vg~bjb|cij |ovgxjo bi Bh|ohv eckkt |oct vgkh icdhks)

5)24! \g fvcij |oh ~vgdhtt ci|g |oh dgaagi thith zgvkl+ dgitclhv bi hba~kh ci zocdo |zg fgb|tbvh t|b|cgi mhh~cij zc|o vht~hd| |g hbdo g|ohv bil zc|o vht~hd| |g bi cilhecic|hks kgij t|vbcjo|fxkmohbl bkgij |oh togvh+ bt lcbjvbahl ci Ecjxvh 5)4) \oh giks cit|vxahi|b|cgi zocdo |ohth fgb|tobuh |g bkkgz |oha |g ~hvegva |ohcv t|b|cgi mhh~cij exid|cgi g~hvb|ht fs thilcij tgxil zbuht|ovgxjo |oh zb|hv) Gi hbdo fgb|+ |cah ct ahbtxvhl fs b tgicd dkgdm zogth xic| ge ahbtxvhahi| ct|oh vgxil |vc~ |cah ge b tgicd tcjibk thi| uhv|cdbkks evga |oh fg||ga ge |oh fgb| |g b ~kb|h agxi|hl btogv| lct|bidh fhkgz bil vhekhd|hl fbdm |g |oh fgb|) Hbdo fgb| bktg thilt b tgicd tcjibk |g |ohfxkmohbl bil ahbtxvht |oh |cah+ xtcij c|t tgicd dkgdm+ vhrxcvhl |g vhdhcuh |oh vhekhd|cgi ge |ob|tcjibk) C| ct |ohi t|hhvhl tg bt |g abci|bci |ob| |cah xidobijhl) Ecibkks+ b tgicd tcjibk ct thi| evga|oh egkkgzcij fgb| |g b vh|vgvhekhd|gv gi |oh vhbv ge |oh khblcij fgb|) \oh vh|vgvhekhd|gv vh|xvit |ob|tcjibk |g |oh egkkgzcij fgb|) \oh vhbv fgb| bl`xt|t c|t t~hhl |g abci|bci |oh |cah egv |oh vgxil |vc~tcjibk+ bt ahbtxvhl fs |oh tgicd dkgdm+ xidobijhl)

5)2<! \oh |cah vhrxcvhl egv tgxil |g |vbuhk |ogxjo zb|hv fh|zhhi |zg ~gci|t ct lh|hvacihl fs |ovhh~bvbah|hvt+ gih ge zocdo ct lh~hilhi| gi |oh uhkgdc|s ge |oh ~gci|t ge |vbitacttcgi bil vhdh~|cgi|ovgxjo |oh zb|hv) Ecvt| dgitclhv |oh dbth ge |oh vgxil |vc~ tcjibk fh|zhhi |oh egkkgzcij fgb| |g |okhblcij fgb|) Zockh |oh tcjibk ct |vbuhkcij |ovgxjo |oh zb|hv+ c| ~vg~bjb|ht b| |oh uhkgdc|s ge tgxilci |oh zb|hv+ D) Zohi |oh tcjibk ct thi| evga |oh egkkgzcij fgb| |g |oh khblcij fgb| zocdo ct b

lct|bidh K bohbl+ |oh vhdhcucij ~gci| ct vxiicij bzbs evga |oh tcjibk b| |oh t~hhl ge |oh fgb|+ U+bil |oh |cah vhrxcvhl egv |oh gx|zbvl |vc~ ct jcuhi fs \g1K'/D!U#) Zohi |oh tcjibk ct vh|xvihl+ |oh

egkkgzcij fgb| b~~vgbdoht |oh tcjibk b| |oh t~hhl ge U+ bil |oh |cah vhrxcvhl egv |oh vh|xvi |vc~ ct

jcuhi fs \v1K'/D-U#) \oh |cah egv |oh vgxil |vc~+ \+ ct |oh txa ge |ohth |caht+ \16KD'/D6!U6#+ gv

\16K'Fu6 zohvh FU 1 /2!U6'D6#>)8)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 30/110

5)28! Zohi |oh tcjibk ct thi| ci b lcvhd|cgi b| vcjo| bijkht |g |oh uhkgdc|s ge |oh fgb|t+ bt gddxvt ci|oh dbth ge |oh tcjibk ge |oh tgicd dkgdm bil ci |oh tcjibk vhekhd|hl evga |oh fxkmohbl+ b lceehvhi|vhtxk| gddxvt) Zockh |oh tcjibk ct hi vgx|h+ |oh vhdhcucij ~gci| aguht kb|hvbkks fs bi bagxi|lh|hvacihl fs |oh uhkgdc|s ge |oh fgb| bil |oh |cah egv |oh tcjibk |g abmh |oh vgxil |vc~) Bt b vhtxk

|oh vgxil |vc~ tcjibk obt |vbuhkhl b lct|bidh hrxbk |g |oh uhd|gv txa ge |zcdh |oh igacibk lct|bidh|g |oh |bvjh| ~kxt |oh lct|bidh |ob| |oh fgb| obt |vbuhkhl lxvcij |oh vgxil |vc~) Egv |oct tc|xb|cgi+ |o

lct|bidh |oh tcjibk obt |vbuhkhl lxvcij |oh vgxil |vc~ obt fhhi cidvhbthl fs D'/D6!U6#>)8+ gv 2'Fu+

ci bddgvlbidh zc|o |oh ^s|objgvhbi \ohgvha egv |oh tclht ge b vcjo| |vcbijkh) \oh heehd| dbxtht |ohvgxil |vc~ |cah egv |oh tcjibk fh|zhhi |oh fgb| bil |oh fxkmohbl |g cidvhbth fs |oh tbah vb|cg bil

bktg vhlxdht |oh t~hhl ge |oh tgicd dkgdm fs /D6!U6#>)8'D+ gv Fu) Zc|o vht~hd| |g |oh ahbtxvhahi

ge |oh lct|bidh fh|zhhi |oh fgb|t bil |oh fxkmohbl+ |oh |zg heehd|t dbidhk+ bil |oh lct|bidh |ohfgb|t abci|bci evga |oh fxkmohbl ct cilh~hilhi| ge |ohcv uhkgdc|s |ovgxjo |oh zb|hv) Xikcmh |ohtc|xb|cgi gddxvvcij zc|o |oh vgxil |vc~ ge |oh tcjibk |g |oh fxkmohbl+ |oh cidvhbth ge |oh vgxil |vc~|cah egv |oh tcjibk |vbuhkcij fh|zhhi |oh egkkgzcij bil khblcij fgb|t ct giks ~bv|cbkks dbidhkhl fs|oh tkgzcij ge |ohcv tgicd dkgdmt) Egv |oct tc|xb|cgi+ |oh vgxil |vc~ |cah ct cidvhbthl ci ~vg~gv|cgi |g

|oh trxbvh ge |oh tkgzcij ge |oh tgicd dkgdm) Ci gvlhv |g abci|bci dgvvhd| th~bvb|cgi fh|zhhi fgb|tbt ahbtxvhl fs tcjibkt thi| |ovgxjo |oh zb|hv+ c| ct ihdhttbvs egv |oh g~hvb|gv ge |oh egkkgzcij fg|g aguh dkgthv |g |oh khblcij fgb|) Oh axt| vhlxdh |oh lct|bidh fh|zhhi |oh fgb|t fs b ebd|gv ge

/2!U6'D6#>)8+ gv Fu)

5)25! \g dgiecih |oh bibkgjs exv|ohv+ kh| xt bttxah |ob| |oh gfthvuhvt gi |oh fgb|t dbi giksdgaaxicdb|h fh|zhhi |oh |zg fgb|t bil fh|zhhi hbdo fgb| bil |oh fxkmohbl fs ahbit ge tgicdtcjibkt thi| |ovgxjo |oh zb|hv) Zc|o |oct kcac|b|cgi+ |ohcv giks ahbit ge ahbtxvcij |oh uhkgdc|s ge|ohcv fgb|t |ovgxjo |oh zb|hv zgxkl fh fs |cacij b vgxil |vc~ tcjibk fh|zhhi |oh fgb|t xtcij |ohcvtgicd dkgdmt) Bt b vhtxk|+ |ohs zgxkl bkzbst ahbtxvh |ohcv uhkgdc|s |ovgxjo |oh zb|hv bt phvgvhjbvlkhtt ge |ohcv bd|xbk uhkgdc|s) \oct ct hbd|ks bibkgjgxt |g zob| gddxvt ci |oh ~vgdhttht

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 31/110

lhtdvcfhl fg|o fs |oh T~hdcbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s bil fs |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs) Ce zh bkkgz|oh fgb|t |g dgaaxicdb|h fs vblcg bt zhkk bt fs tgicd tcjibkt+ |ohs zgxkl rxcdmks lctdguhv |ob|dkgdmt zocdo zhvh tx~~gthlks tsidovgicphl fs |oh tgicd tcjibkt thi| |ovgxjo |oh zb|hv zhvh ig|bd|xbkks tsidovgicphl) \oh dkgdm ci |oh khbl fgb| zgxkl fh fh th| |g bi hbvkchv |cah |obi |oh dkgdm c|oh egkkgzcij fgb|) \oh bagxi| ge |cah |ob| |oh khblcij dkgdm ct hbvks zgxkl ~vguclh |oh ciegvab|cgvhrxcvhl |g dbkdxkb|h |oh uhkgdc|s ge |oh fgb|t |ovgxjo |oh zb|hv `xt| bt |oh bfckc|s |g dgaaxicdb|hb| b uhkgdc|s tcjicecdbi|ks jvhb|hv |obi |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| zgxkl bkkgz xt |g lh|hvacih gxv bftgkx|uhkgdc|s |ovgxjo t~bdh fs ht|bfkctocij bi bftgkx|h |cah vhehvhidh) /Gfucgxtks+ vhbk dkgdmt lg ig|exid|cgi ci |oh abiihv ge |oh tgicd dkgdm lhtdvcfhl bfguh+ fx| |ohs gfhs |oh tbah Kgvhi|p

\vbitegvab|cgi egv \cah bt b exid|cgi ge |ohcv bftgkx|h uhkgdc|s |ovgxjo t~bdh bt lght |oh tgicddkgdm bt b exid|cgi ge c|t uhkgdc|s |ovgxjo |oh zb|hv) \oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi egv \cah zckk fhlctdxtthl kb|hv)#

5)2:! Ce zh h|hil |oh t|b|cgi mhh~cij bibkgjs |g b kgij dgiugs ge fgb|t+ zh gf|bci bi bibkgjs |g bsbvlt|cdm ci zocdo |oh th~bvb|cgi ge c|t b|gat /bil |ohvhegvh c|t khij|o#+ bil |oh t~hhl ge c|t dkgdmfg|o bvh lh|hvacihl fs |oh uhkgdc|s |ogxjo |oh ahlcxa /zb|hv gv |oh Bh|ohv#) \oh khij|o ge |ob|sbvlt|cdm gfhst |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgit egv Khij|o ci fg|o bht) Bt b vhtxk|+ c| ct ca~gttcfkhegv gfthvuhvt |g lh|hvacih |ohcv bftgkx|h uhkgdc|s |ovgxjo t~bdh) Ab||hv bl`xt|t c|t tcph bil dkgdmt~hhl |g dgidhbk |ob| uhkgdc|s) \oh dgidhbkahi| ct ablh ~gttcfkh fs |oh ebd| |ob| |oh ht|bfkctoahge tcaxk|bihc|s fh|zhhi ~ostcdbkks th~bvb|hl kgdb|cgit ct kcac|hl fs |oh ecic|h uhkgdc|s ge~vg~bjb|cgi ge ciegvab|cgi ca~gthl fs |oh t~hhl ge kcjo|) Zh dbiig| gfthvuh gxv bftgkx|h uhkgdc||ovgxjo |oh Bh|ohv fhdbxth Ib|xvh xtht |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| |g lh|hvacih |oh tcph ge |oh ab||hvzocdo dga~vcth gxv cit|vxahi|t)

5)2?! \oh Ca~gttcfckc|s ge Ahbtxvcij |oh Uhkgdc|s ge Kcjo|0! \oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ct b tbdvhl bilcaax|bfkh rxbi|c|s ci |oh tdchi|cecd dgaaxic|s+ ig ab||hv zohvh gv ogz gv fs zoga c| ct ahbtxvhlc| bkzbst obt |oh ubkxh ge 2?5+645 ackht ~hv thdgil) \oh rxbi|c|s ct tg fbtcd |ob| c|t ahbtxvhahi|ct ge|hi ~bv| ge |oh |vbcicij ~vgdhtt egv ^oL dbilclb|ht) Igz egv |oh xk|cab|h ohvhts)\oh uhkgdc|s gkcjo| obt ihuhv fhhi ahbtxvhl bil c| ihuhv zckk fh ahbtxvhl" Zohi h~hvcahi|t zocdo ~xv~gv| |gahbtxvh |ob| uhkgdc|s bvh hbacihl+ c| ct egxil |ob| |ohs ucgkb|h gih ge |oh fbtcd vxkht geahbtxvhahi|) Zohi abmcij b ahbtxvhahi|+ c| ct ihdhttbvs |g dga~hitb|h egv bis heehd| |ob| |ohrxbi|c|s fhcij ahbtxvhl obt gi |oh tdbkh ebd|gvt ge |oh cit|vxahi|t zocdo bvh xthl) \g |oh

bx|ogv*t migzkhljh+ |oct t|h~ obt ihuhv fhhi cidkxlhl ci |oh ahbtxvhahi| ge |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|)

5)23! Dgitclhv bi b||ha~| |g ahbtxvh |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ci zocdo b ahbtxvhahi| ct ablh ge |oh|cah vhrxcvhl egv b ~xkth ge kcjo| |g fh thi| evga |oh |g~ ge gih agxi|bci |g b vh|vgvhekhd|gv gi |oh|g~ ge bi bl`bdhi| agxi|bci bil vh|xvihl |g c|t tgxvdh) \oh h~hvcahi| vhrxcvht |oh xth ge b~vhdcth dkgdm bil b ~vhdcth migzkhljh ge |oh lct|bidh fh|zhhi |oh tcjibk tgxvdh bil |ohvh|vgvhekhd|gv) B|gacd dkgdmt ge h|vhah ~vhdctcgi bil bddxvbds bvh bubckbfkh bil bvh vhblcks|vbit~gv|bfkh |g |oh agxi|bci|g~) Lh|hvacicij |oh lct|bidh fh|zhhi |oh kcjo| tgxvdh bil |ohvh|vgvhekhd|gv ct lceecdxk| tcidh c| ciugkuht ~vhdctcgi txvuhscij guhv b kgij lct|bidh ge agxi|bcigxt|hvvbci) \g guhvdgah |oh lceecdxk|s ge |oh txvuhs+ c| ct lhdclhl |g ahbtxvh |oh lct|bidh |g |ohvh|vgvhekhd|gv fs vblbv) \oh vhtxk|cij h~hvcahi| ~vglxdht |oh dgvvhd| ubkxh egv |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjoC| dgidkxlht |ob| D1D) Xiegv|xib|hks+ zockh txdo b vhtxk| ct dgvvhd|+ c| ct obvlks xthexk)

5)6>! Zockh |oct hba~kh abs b~~hbv evcugkgxt+ c| ct ig|) C| ct b ubkcl bibkgj ge vhbkc|s) Rxbi|xa~ostcdct|t obuh dgidkxlhl |ob| |oh egvdh fh|zhhi ab|hvcbk ~bv|cdkht ct hkhd|vgabjih|cd ci ib|xvhbil c| ct btthv|hl |g vhtxk| evga |oh hdobijh ge ucv|xbk ~og|git) Bt b vhtxk|+ |ohs bvh bktg btthv|ci|ob| |oh t~bdcij fh|zhhi |ohth ~bv|cdkht ct lh|hvacihl fs |oh vblbv ~vcidc~kh gv c|t hrxcubkhi| bil|ohvhegvh ct ci bjvhhahi| zc|o |oh ~vhlcd|cgit ge Uhkgdc|s Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs) Bis b||ha~| |g ahbtxv|oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| axt| schkl |oh ahbicijkhtt dgidkxtcgi |ob| |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ct hrxbk |g |ohuhkgdc|s ge kcjo|)

5)62! \oh abmcij ge b ahbtxvhahi| vhrxcvht+ ci heehd|+ |oh zvc|cij ge bi hrxb|cgi ci zocdo |ohrxbi|c|s |g fh ahbtxvhl b~~hbvt giks gi |oh khe| tclh ge |oh hrxbk tcji bil bkk g|ohv rxbi|c|cht

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 32/110

b~~hbv giks gi |oh vcjo| tclh) Ce |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|+ D+ ct |g fh ahbtxvhl+ c| ct ihdhttbvs |ob| fg|o|oh |cah+ \+ vhrxcvhl egv kcjo| |g |vbuhk b lct|bidh+ K+ bil |oh lct|bidh+ K+ fh ahbtxvhl ci b abiihvzocdo ct cilh~hilhi| ge D) \oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| abs |ohi fh egxil fs tgkucij |oh hrxb|cgi D1K'\)\oh lceecdxk|s bvctht evga |oh ebd| |ob| fg|o |oh ahbtxvhahi| ge |cah bil |oh ahbtxvhahi| ge khij|ciugkuh |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|) \oh khij|o ge |oh sbvlt|cdm xthl |g ahbtxvh |oh khij|o ct btthv|hl |g flh|hvacihl fs |oh bkkhjhl hdobijh ge ucv|xbk ~og|git fh|zhhi b|gat) \oh t~hhl ge |oh dkgdm ctlh|hvacihl fs |oh vhtgibi| evhrxhids ge bi gtdckkb|cij t~vcij!abtt tst|ha) Gih ge |oh ebd|gvtzocdo lh|hvaciht |oh evhrxhids ge txdo b tst|ha ct |oh hkbt|cdc|s ge |oh t~vcij zocdo ct lh|hvacihfs |oh hdobijh ge |oh bkkhjhl ucv|xbk ~og|git fh|zhhi c|t b|gat) \oh g|ohv ebd|gv zocdo

lh|hvaciht c|t evhrxhids ct |oh abtt ge |oh gtdckkb|cij tst|ha bt lh|hvacihl fs |oh hihvjsvh~vhthi|hl fs c|t abtt lcuclhl fs |oh trxbvh ge |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|) Gfucgxtks+ |oh hrxb|cgi fszocdo gih zgxkl h~hd| |g xth ci ahbtxvcij |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ct ig| rxc|h b~~kcdbfkh)

5)66! Zockh |oh bx|ogv obt ig| b||ha~|hl |oh lhvcub|cgi+ oh ct lvbzi |g |oh dgidkxtcgi |ob| |ohdgvvhd| hrxb|cgi egv |oh ahbtxvhahi| ge |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ct b vhbvvbijhahi| ge |oh Ecih

T|vxd|xvh Dgit|bi|+ h*oD'h6124:+ zohvh o ct ̂ kbidm*t Dgit|bi|+ h ct |oh dobvjh ge |oh hkhd|vgi+bil h* ct |oh lchkhd|vcd dgit|bi| ge t~bdh) /h* ct vhrxcvhl ce |oh hrxb|cgi ct |g fh lcahitcgibkksdgvvhd|) \oh dxvvhi| ~vbd|cdh ge gac||cij c| evga |oh hrxb|cgi ge |oh Ecih T|vxd|xvh Dgit|bi| cthvvgihgxt)# Zc|o |oct vhbvvbijhahi|+ |oh hrxb|cgi egv |oh ahbtxvhahi| ge |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|

fhdgaht D124:h6'/h*o#) \oh vhbkc|s ge Vhkb|cuc|s ct |ob| ab||hv bl`xt|t c|t tcph |g tb|ctes |oct

hrxb|cgi bil bis ahbtxvhahi| zocdo b||ha~|t |g ahbtxvh |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| bd|xbkks ahbtxvht|oh Ecih T|vxd|xvh Dgit|bi|) Tcidh |oct dgit|bi| ct lcahitcgikhtt+ c| ct |oh tbah b| bkk uhkgdc|cht|ovgxjo t~bdh bil b| bkk hkhub|cgit) Xikhtt b ~ostcdct| obt fhhi dga~kh|hks fvbcizbtohl lxvcij ohlxdb|cgi+ oh zckk vhdgjicph |ob| |oh gfthvuhl dgit|bids ge |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ct ig| ast|hvcgxt+ct cihuc|bfkh bil ct dga~kh|hks xivhkb|hl |g |oh bd|xbk uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|)

5)64! Ci Ecjxvh 5)< |ovhh uhkgdc|s vhehvhidh evbaht bvh dgitclhvhl+ &&+ &b&+ bil &f&) C| zckk fh ig|hl|ob|+ ci bddgvlbidh zc|o |oh dgidh~|t ge fg|o |oh T~hdcbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s bil |oh Bh|ohv \ohgge Vhkb|cuc|s+ |oh vhkb|cuh uhkgdc|s ge &f& zc|o vht~hd| |g &&+ Uf+ ct ~vguclhl ci |hvat bt |oh txa g

|oh uhkgdc|s fh|zhhi &f& bil &b&+ Ufb+ bil |oh uhkgdc|s fh|zhhi &b& bil && bt |oh txa ge Ub bil

Ufb lcuclhl fs b ebd|gv+ 2-UbUfb'D6) \oh lhigacib|gv ct vhrxcvhl |g dga~hitb|h egv |oh heehd| g

|oh ecic|h uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| gi |oh ahbtxvhahi| ge |oh uhkgdc|s lceehvhidht) C| ct |oh heehd| vh~vhthi|hfs |oct |hva zocdo ~vhuhi|t |oh lcvhd| bllc|cgi ge vhkb|cuct|cd uhkgdc|cht bil zocdo ~vhuhi|t |ohgfthvuhl lceehvhidh ge uhkgdc|s fh|zhhi bis |zg vhehvhidh evbaht evga hdhhlcij |oh uhkgdc|s gekcjo|) \oh lhigacib|gv ci |oh hrxb|cgi vhtxk|t evga |oh kcac|b|cgi |ob| |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ca~gthtgi |oh uhkgdc|s ge dgaaxicdb|cgi fh|zhhi vhehvhidh evbaht) /\oh lhigacib|gv fhdgaht xic|s ce |oh~hvcahi|hv dgaaxicdb|ht b| bi ciecic|h uhkgdc|s+ ~gttcfks |ovgxjo |oh xth ge ~bcvhl ~og|git)# Ce|oh ~vglxd| UbUbf ci |oh lhigacib|gv ct tabkk dga~bvhl |g |oh trxbvh ge |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|+ c|t

heehd|t dbi fh cjigvhl+ igi!vhkb|cuct|cd ahdobicdt bvh ubkcl+ bil uhkgdc|cht abs fh bllhl lcvhd|ks)\oct dgidkxtcgi zckk fhdgah ca~gv|bi| zohi zh hbacih |oh lhecdchids ge T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s zc|ovhjbvl |g bddhkhvb|cgit)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 33/110

5)6<! Dgitclhv |ob| gfthvuhvt ci vhehvhidh evbaht &b& bil &f& ge Ecjxvh 5)< zcto |g abmhgfthvub|cgit fh|zhhi |ohcv vhehvhidh evbaht) Ci gvlhv |g citxvh |ob| |ohcv gfthvub|cgit bvh fbthlx~gi |oh tbah vhehvhidh evbah+ |ohs bjvhh |g dgiuhv| |oh vhtxk|t ge |ohcv gfthvub|cgit ci|ggfthvub|cgit bt |ohs zgxkl obuh fhhi ablh ci vhehvhidh evbah &&) Be|hv abmcij gfthvub|cgit

zc|oci bil fh|zhhi vhehvhidh evbaht &b& bil &f& |ohs dgiuhv| |ogth vhtxk|t ci|g |oh vhtxk|t zocdozgxkl obuh fhhi gfthvuhl ci |ob| vhehvhidh evbah bil dgaaxicdb|h |ogth vhtxk|t |g hbdo g|ohv)Be|hv kbfgvcgxt abic~xkb|cgi ge abis ~bjht ge bkjhfvb |ohs ecil |ob| bkk ge |oh |hvat ci |ohhrxb|cgit zocdo vhehv |g vhehvhidh evbah && dbidhk bil |ohs bvh khe| zc|o giks |ogth |hvat zocdovhehv |g |oh heehd|t gddxvvcij ci bil fh|zhhi uhkgdc|s fh|zhhi vhehvhidh evbaht &b& bil &f&)Vhehvhidh evbah && lght ig| hct| ci |oh tgkx|cgi+ bil+ bkkgzcij |ob| vhehvhidh evbah &&vh~vhthi|t |oh uhkgdc|s vhehvhidh evbah ge |oh Bh|ohv+ c| fhdgaht gfucgxt zos gxv uhkgdc|s zc|ovht~hd| |g |ob| Bh|ohv dbiig| fh gfthvuhl)

5)68! \oh bllc|cgi ge uhkgdc|cht bt lhecihl fs |oh T~hdcbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s bil fs Bh|ohvVhkb|cuc|s ~vglxdht b dgiekcd| zc|o dgaagi thith) Xilhv T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s+ zohi gih bllt |ohuhkgdc|s ge gih vhehvhidh evbah |g |oh uhkgdc|s ge big|ohv vhehvhidh evbah+ |oh lhigacib|gv ci |ohuhkgdc|s bllc|cgi hrxb|cgi lhtdvcfhl bfguh citxvht |ob| |oh uhkgdc|s lceehvhidh fh|zhhi |ogthvhehvhidh evbaht ct ig| hrxbk |g |oh bkjhfvbcd lceehvhidh) Zohi |oh uhkgdc|cht b~~vgbdo |oh uhkgdc|sge kcjo|+ |oh heehd| ct tg ~vgigxidhl |ob|+ zohi |oh bkjhfvbcd uhkgdc|s lceehvhidh b~~vgbdoht |zcdh|oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|+ |oh gfthvuhl uhkgdc|s lceehvhidh vhabcit khtt |obi |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|) /ThhEcjxvh 5)8B) \oh t|vbijh ib|xvh ge |oct dxvuh vhtxk|t evga |oh ebd| |ob|+ xilhv T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s+gfthvuhvt ci vhehvhidh evbaht &b& bil &f& bvh fg|o evhh |g dgitclhv |ohathkuht b| vht| bil |ob| |ohg|ohv gfthvuhv ct agucij) Fg|o dgidkxtcgit dbiig| fh |vxh+ bil bt bfguh+ |oh giks dgidh~|xbkksubkcl ahbit ge lhbkcij zc|o |oh gfthvub|cgit ct egv |oh gfthvuhvt ci fg|o vhehvhidh evbaht |g bjvhhx~gi b vhehvhidh evbah zocdo |ohs bddh~| bt t|b|cgibvs bil |g xth |oh ab|ohab|cdt ge hc|ohvT~hdcbk gv Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s |g dgiuhv| |ohcv gfthvub|cgit |g |oh vhtxk|t zocdo zgxkl fh gf|bcihl ce|oh gfthvub|cgit obl fhhi ablh ci |oh t|b|cgibvs vhehvhidh evbah) Zohi |ob| t|h~ ct |bmhi+ |oh

bllc|cgi ge uhkgdc|cht fh|zhhi vhehvhidh evbaht &b& bil &f& fhdgaht dgitct|hi| zc|o dgaagithith) /Thh Ecjxvh 5)8F)# Xilhv |oh Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs+ |oh dgiextcgi bfgx| |oh bllcij geuhkgdc|cht lght ig| gddxv+ |oh bftgkx|h uhkgdc|s vhehvhidh vh~vhthi|hl fs |oh Bh|ohv egvdht |ohgfthvuhvt |g abmh |oh ihdhttbvs dgvvhd|cgit |g |ohcv gfthvub|cgit)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 34/110

5)65! B| |oct ~gci|+ b dgiuhi|cgibk vhkb|cuct| zckk btm zos c| togxkl fh ihdhttbvs |g bttxah |ohhct|hidh ge bi bv|cecdcbkks thkhd|hl uhkgdc|s vhehvhidh evbah zohi |ob| vhehvhidh evbah lght ig|b~~hbv ci |oh lb|b) ^hvob~t |oh tca~kht| vht~gith |g |ob| rxht|cgi ct |g lcvhd| |oh vhblhv*t b||hi|cg|g |oh ~vgfkha ge ibucjb|cgi gi |oh txvebdh ge |oh Hbv|o) B ~gtc|cgi gi |oh Hbv|o*t txvebdh ct lhecihci |hvat ge c|t kb|c|xlh bil kgijc|xlh) \oh gfthvub|cgi ge kb|c|xlh ~vhthi|t ig ~vgfkha+ |oh hrxb|gv~vguclht bi gfthvubfkh bftgkx|h vhehvhidh egv phvg kb|c|xlh b| b kgdb|cgi 3> lhjvhht bzbs evga |oht~ci bct ge |oh Hbv|o) \oh gfthvub|cgi ge kgijc|xlh lght ~vhthi| b ~vgfkha) \ohvh ct ig bftgkx|hvhehvhidh egv phvg kgijc|xlh) Gxv bidht|gvt+ ogzhuhv+ zhvh ~vbd|cdbk ahi) \ohs bvfc|vbvcks lhecihl|oh phvg ahvclcbi ge kgijc|xlh bt ~bttcij |ovgxjo Jvhhizcdo Hijkbil bil fbthl bkk gfthvub|cgit

ge kgijc|xlh x~gi |ob| bv|cecdcbkks dogthi bftgkx|h kgijc|xlh vhehvhidh) Ci gvlhv egv bi gfthvub|cgi |g ~vglxdh vcjgvgxtks dgvvhd| vhtxk|t fh|zhhi vhehvhidh evbaht+ dga~hitb|cgi ge |oh heehd|t ge |ohlceehvhidh ci vhehvhidh evbaht gi |oh xic|t ge ahbtxvhahi| ct vhrxcvhl) \oct+ ci |xvi+ vhrxcvht |ob| bvhehvhidh evbah fh bvfc|vbvcks dogthi bt b t|bilbvl) Ce |oct t|h~ ct ig| |bmhi+ JCJG ~vhubckt))

5)6:! \oh Kgdb|cgi ge Mcih|cd Hihvjs0!

Zohi b fxkkh| ct ecvhl evga b jxi+ mcih|cd hihvjs ct bllhl |g |oh ~vg`hd|ckh fs |oh h~bilcij jbtht c|oh jxi fbvvhk) \ob| mcih|cd hihvjs ct huhi|xbkks ca~bv|hl |g |oh |bvjh|+ fx| lxvcij |oh |cah ge |ohfxkkh|*t ekcjo|+ c| |vbuhkt zc|o |oh fxkkh|) \oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgit abs fh xthl |g lh|hvacih |ohkgdb|cgi ge |ob| mcih|cd hihvjs) \ob| lh|hvacib|cgi ct vhblcks ablh zc|o |oh xth ge b |ogxjo|h~hvcahi|) Dgitclhv |ob| |oh abtt hrxcubkhi| hihvjs ge hbdo ~bv|cdkh dga~gtcij |oh fxkkh| obt

fhhi t|gvhl ci clhbk abttkhtt t~vcijt fs dga~vhttcij bil |scij |oha+ bt togzi ci Ecjxvh 5)5)Tcidh |oh bd|cgi ge |oh t~vcij ct gih lcahitcgibk+ hihvjs ct t|gvhl bkgij b tcijkh bct) Dgitclhvih| |ob| |oh ~bv|cdkht ci |oh fxkkh| dgitct| ge |ovhh t~vcijt zc|o clhi|cdbk hihvjcht ge dga~vhttcgiagxi|hl gv|ogjgibk |g hbdo g|ohv zc|o gih ge hbdo th| ge t~vcijt fhcij ~bvbkkhk |g |oh fxkkh|*t~vg`hd|hl ~b|o) Tcidh+ egv gxv |ogxjo| h~hvcahi|+ |oh t~vcijt |ohathkuht bvh dgitclhvhl |g fhabttkhtt+ |oh giks abtt |oh ~bv|cdkht ci |oh fxkkh| ~gtthtt ct |oh hihvjs t|gvhl fs |oh dga~vhttcgge |oh |ovhh t~vcijt)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 35/110

5)6?! Zohi |oh t~vcijt bdrxcvh b uhkgdc|s+ |oh bdrxctc|cgi ge |ob| uhkgdc|s dbxtht mcih|cd hihvjs |gfh bllhl |g |oh hihvjs ge dga~vhttcgi zocdo obl fhhi t|gvhl ci |oha) B~~kscij |oh Kgvhi|p\vbitegvab|cgi egv Abtt bil axk|c~kscij fs |oh trxbvh ge |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| togzt |ob| |oh |g|bkhihvjs ge |oh t~vcijt obt fhhi cidvhbthl ci ~vg~gv|cgi |g 2'Fu) \oh ~vglxd| ge |oh Kgvhi|p

\vbitegvab|cgi egv \vbituhvth Khij|o |caht |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi egv \vbituhvth Egvdhtogzt |ob| |oh hihvjs t|gvhl ci |oh |vbituhvth t~vcijt obt fhhi cidvhbthl fs |oh tbah ebd|gv) Eg|ohth |vbituhvth t~vcijt+ |ohvhegvh+ c| ct b~~bvhi| |ob| |ohcv mcih|cd hihvjs ct t|gvhl bt bi cidvhbthci |ohcv hihvjs ge dga~vhttcgi bil |ob| t|gvhl hihvjs ct vh|xvihl zohi |oh fxkkh| ct fvgxjo| |g vhtCi |oh ~bvbkkhk bct+ |oh tc|xb|cgi ct agvh txf|kh) \oh ~vglxd| ge |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi egv^bvbkkhk Egvdh |caht |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi egv ^bvbkkhk Khij|o+ bil |ohvhegvh |oh |g|bk hihvjs|vbit~gv|hl zc|oci |oh t~vcij c|thke+ obt fhhi lhdvhbthl fs |oh ebd|gv Fu huhi |ogxjo |oh |g|bk

hihvjs |vbit~gv|hl fs |oh hihvjs t|gvhl ci |oh ~bvbkkhk t~vcij obt fhhi cidvhbthl fs |oh ebd|gv

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 36/110

2'Fu) Egv |oct |g gddxv+ |oh bdrxctc|cgi ge uhkgdc|s fs |oh ~bvbkkhk t~vcij vhrxcvht |ob| bi bagxi| g

hihvjs hrxbk |g U6'/D6Fu#+ |caht |oh hihvjs t|gvhl ci |oh ~bvbkkhk t~vcij khbuh |ob| t~vcij bil sh|

|vbuhk bkgij zc|o c|) \oh ag|cgi ge |oh ~bvbkkhk t~vcij axt| dbxth |oh hihvjs |ob| obt khe| |oh ~bvbkkt~vcij |g fh t|gvhl ci b lctm tob~hl vhjcgi ge t~bdh kgdb|hl ci b ~kbih ~hv~hilcdxkbv |g |oh uhkgdc|uhd|gv bil zocdo aguht zc|o |oh ~bvbkkhk t~vcij) Egv |ob| hihvjs |g fh t|gvhl+ |oh Bh|ohv axt| fhlct|gv|hl bil t|vhtthl ci |oh vhjcgi ciugkuhl) Egv Ihz|gi*t Kbzt ge Ag|cgi |g fh ubkcl+ |ohci|hvdobijh ge hihvjs fh|zhhi |oh tgxvdh'tcim ge mcih|cd hihvjs bil fg|o |oh t~vcijt bil |oh lctmtob~hl lct|gv|cgi bil t|vhtt ci |oh Bh|ohv axt| gddxv b| 2>>( heecdchids) C| bktg egkkgzt |ob| |oh

cihv|cbk egvdht bttgdcb|hl zc|o b dobijh ci uhkgdc|s bvh ig| ecd|c|cgxt bt aglhvi ~ostcdct|t zgxklobuh sgx fhkchuh+ |ohs bvh+ kcmh |oh egvdh ge jvbuc|s+ b vhbk egvdh hhv|hl bjbcit| |oh Bh|ohv)

5)63! B Aglhk egv |oh Ihx|vcig7 Ci |oh ~vhucgxt ~bvbjvb~ot c| zbt ~gci|hl gx| |ob| |oh Kgvhi|p\vbitegvab|cgit egv Egvdh bil Khij|o vhrxcvh |ob| ~bv| ge |oh vht| abtt hihvjs bil bkk ge |oh mcih|hihvjs bttgdcb|hl zc|o hihvjs t|gvhl ci b lcvhd|cgi ~bvbkkhk |g |oh uhkgdc|s uhd|gv axt| fh|vbit~gv|hl ci b lctm tob~hl vhjcgi ge t|vhtthl t~bdh agucij zc|o |ob| hihvjs) Gih zgxkldgidkxlh+ ogzhuhv+ |ob| ce |oh gvcjcibk vht| abtt hihvjs zhvh jvhb|hv |obi phvg+ |oh hihvjs t|gvhl |oh lctm zgxkl fhdgah ciecic|h+ hbd|ks bt zgxkl |oh hihvjs t|gvhl ci b lcvhd|cgi ~hv~hilcdxkbv |g|oh uhkgdc|s uhd|gv)

5)4>! Kh| xt dgitclhv b tc|xb|cgi ci zocdo |oh vht| abtt hihvjs ct t|gvhl giks ci b lcvhd|cgi ~bvbkkh

|g |oh uhkgdc|s uhd|gv) Bt togzi ci Ecjxvh 5)5+ |oh hihvjs t|gvhl ci |oh t~vcij ct jcuhi fsHt1h~/2!U6'D6#>)8 bil |oh hihvjs t|gvhl ci |oh lctm ge t|vhtthl t~bdh ct jcuhi fs

Hl1h~/U'D#6'/2!U6'D6#>)8) Igz kh| xt dgitclhv |ob| |oh bagxi| ge |oh gvcjcibk vht| abtt hihvjs ct

vhlxdhl bt b exid|cgi ge |oh uhkgdc|s+ Ue+ |g fh b||bcihl /b thvcht ge h~hvcahi|t ct vhrxcvhl+ gih eg

hbdo ge |oh ecibk uhkgdc|cht+ Ue # tg |ob| |oh hihvjs ci |oh lctm zckk b~~vgbdo |oh igacibk vht| abtt

hihvjs+ h~+ bt |oh Ue ge |oh cilcuclxbk h~hvcahi|t b~~vgbdoht D) \oct dbi fh bdochuhl fs

vhlxdcij |oh cic|cbk vht| abtt hihvjs+ h~ ci ~vg~gv|cgi |g /2!Ue6'D6#>)8) \oh h~vhttcgi egv |oh

hihvjs |vbit~gv|hl fs |oh t~vcij egv hbdo ge |oh ubkxht ge Ue fhdgaht Ht1h~/2!Ue6'D6# bil |oh

hihvjs |vbit~gv|hl fs |oh lctm ge t|vhtthl t~bdh egv hbdo ge |oh ubkxht ge Ue fhdgaht h~/Ue'D#6)

5)420! Kh| ct igz dgitclhv ubkxht ge Ue zocdo b~~vgbdo |oh ubkxh ge D bt b kcac|) Bt Ue b~~vgbdohD+ |oh ~gv|cgi ge |oh |g|bk hihvjs t|gvhl ci |oh t~vcij b~~vgbdoht phvg bt b kcac| zockh |oh ~gv|cgi g|oh hihvjs zocdo ct t|gvhl ci |oh lctm b~~vgbdoht |oh gvcjcibk vht| abtt hihvjs bt b kcac|) B lcvhd|lh|hvacib|cgi ge |oh hihvjs ci |oh t~vcij zohi Ue hrxbkt D ct gfucgxt+ c| ct phvg) B lcvhd|

lh|hvacib|cgi ge |oh hihvjs ci |oh lctm zgxkl b~~hbv |g fh ahbicijkhtt tcidh c| zgxkl ciugkuh |ohaxk|c~kcdb|cgi ge phvg fs ciecic|s bil+ bt b vhtxk|+ dbi obuh bis ubkxh fh|zhhi |oh kcac|t ge -'!ciecic|s) \oh bd|xbk ubkxh dbi fh lh|hvacihl ogzhuhv fs xtcij |oh tbah ~vgdhlxvh bt ct xthl cici|hjvbk dbkdxkxt+ bkkgzcij Ue |g b~~vgbdo ciecic|htcabkks dkgth |g D bil lh|hvacicij |oh bagxi|

hihvjs ci |oh lctm zohi |oh uhkgdc|s ge D ct b kcac|) \oct b~~vgbdo bkkgzt xt |g dgidkxlh |ob|+ zohiUe ct hrxbk |g D+ bkk ge |oh hihvjs ct t|gvhl ci |oh t|vhtthl lctm ci t~bdh bil igih ge |oh hihvjs ct

t|gvhl ci |oh t~vcij) Ci |oh dbth xilhv dgitclhvb|cgi+ |oh bagxi| ge |oh hihvjs t|gvhl ci |oh lctm c

hrxbk |g |oh hihvjs h~) Zh obuh igz lhtdvcfhl b ~bv|cdkh Ecjxvh 5): zocdo lght ig| obuh b dobvj~gtthtt ig vht| abtt+ |vbuhkt b| |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| bil |vbit~gv|t hihvjs bil agahi|xa) Obt bihx|vcig fhhi lhtdvcfhl7 \oh bx|ogv fhkchuht c| obt)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 37/110

5)46! Ogz Dgxkl Txdo b Ihx|vcig fh Kbxidohl bil'gv Bftgvfhl7 \oh ahdobicta ge kbxidocij gvbftgvfcij b ihx|vcig zocdo zbt dgit|vxd|hl bt lhtdvcfhl ci |oh ~vgdhhlcij |zg ~bvbjvb~ot acjothha |g ~gth b dgidh~|xbk ~vgfkha) \oct zgxkl fh |oh dbth ce |oh egvab|cgi ge |oh ihx|vcigciugkuhl bi bddhkhvb|cgi evga vht| |g |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| bil'gv ce |oh bftgv~|cgi ge |oh ihx|vcigciugkuhl b lhdhkhvb|cgi evga |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| |g |oh vht| uhkgdc|s) \ohvh ct ig dgidh~|xbklceecdxk|s ogzhuhv ce |oh ihx|vcig zhvh egvahl gv bftgvfhl bkvhbls |vbuhkcij b| |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|)Txdo bi hacttcgi'bftgv~|cgi dobvbd|hvct|cd ct bkvhbls migzi) Zohi ~og|git bvh hac||hl gvbftgvfhl+ |oh ~vgdhtt ciugkuhl fhobuht ci hbd|ks |oct abiihv+ b| khbt| zohi gfthvuhl egv b |cahzocdo ct kgijhv |obi |oh ~hvcgl ge |oh ~og|gi) Gih zgxkl h~hd| txdo ihx|vcigt |g obuh b lctdvh|h

evhrxhids `xt| bt |oh ~og|gi obt b lctdvh|h evhrxhids bil gih zgxkl h~hd| c| |g fh hac||hl bilbftgvfhl ci lctdvh|h rxbtc!t~hd|vbk kciht bibkgjgxt |g |oh bftgv~|cgi bil hacttcgi ge |oh t~hd|vbkciht ge ~og|git evga b|gat) Ce ihx|vcigt bvh hac||hl fs ixdkhbv ~vgdhttht ci b t|bv+ evhrxhidstoce|t lxh |g |ohvabk Lg~~khv bil ge jvbuc|b|cgibk |cah lckb|cgi togxkl jvhb|ks vhlxdh |oh gfthvubfhacttcgi ge ihx|vcigt fs b t|bv) B| ~vhthi|+ h~hvcahi|hvt bvh |vscij |g bddgxi| egv |oh ebd| |ob| |oihx|vcig hacttcgi evga |oh Txi ct bfgx| b |ocvl ge zob| |ohs h~hd|) ^hvob~t |oh hacttcgit~hd|vxa ge |oh ihx|vcigt ct txeecdchi|ks fvgblhihl tg bt |g ~vhuhi| |ohcv lh|hd|cgi fs ~vhthi|ah|oglt)

Dob~|hv : ! B~~kscij |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgit^vg~hvks

:)2! Ci |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl+ c| obt fhhi ~vhlcd|hl bil h~hvcahi|bkks uhvcechl |ob| lceehvhidht cihkhub|cgi vhtxk| ci lceehvhidht ci |oh gfthvuhl vb|h ge ~bttbjh ge |cah) Hbvkchv ci |oct lctdxttcgi+ c|zbt togzi |ob| |oh lceehvhidh gddxvt fhdbxth b dobijh ci hkhub|cgi dobijht |oh dbkcfvb|cgi gedkgdmt bil lght ig|+ ci dgi|vbt| |g ~vhthi| lgjab+ beehd| |oh bftgkx|h vb|h ge |oh ~bttbjh ge |cah)Tcidh b dobijh ci vhehvhidh evbah /hkhub|cgi# dobijht |oh t~hhl ge b dkgdm+ c| ct ig| giksvhbtgibfkh |g h~hd| |ob| |oh tdbkh ebd|gv ge g|ohv |s~ht ge cit|vxahi|t bktg fh beehd|hl+ |oh vxkht

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 38/110

Lcahitcgibk Bibkstct bil |oh ^vcidc~kh ge Vhkb|cuc|s vhrxcvh |ob| txdo fh |oh dbth) Ce gih ct |ghbacih |oh heehd|t ge uhkgdc|s bil'gv hkhub|cgi |ohvhegvh+ c| ct ihdhttbvs egv oca abmh gfthvub|cgizc|oci hbdo ge |oh vhehvhidh evbaht xtcij |oh xic|t ge ahbtxvhahi| ge |ob| vhehvhidh evbah /kgdbkxic|t ge ahbtxvhahi|#) Oh axt| |ohi doggth b t|bilbvl uhkgdc|s vhehvhidh evbah bil b t|bilbvlhkhub|cgi vhehvhidh evbah bil xth |oh Uhkgdc|s bil'gv Jvbuc|s \vbitegvab|cgit |g dgiuhv| |ohvhtxk|t ge oct gfthvub|cgit ci|g |ogth zocdo zgxkl obuh fhhi gf|bcihl zc|o |oh xic|t geahbtxvhahi| ge |oh t|bilbvl vhehvhidh evbah) \oh ~vgdhlxvh ct bibkgjgxt |g |oh ~vbd|cdhha~kgshl fs txvuhsgvt zog bl`xt| lct|bidht ahbtxvhl zc|o t|hhk |b~ht egv |oh hvvgv dbxthl fs |olceehvhidh fh|zhhi |oh bafchi| |ha~hvb|xvh bil |oh |ha~hvb|xvh b| zocdo |oh |b~h zbt dbkcfvb|hl)

Tgahogz+ c| thhat vhbtgibfkh |ob| ~ostcdct|t togxkl fh h~hd|hl |g blohvh |g |oh khuhk ge vcjgvvhrxcvhl ge |oh agvh axilbih echkl ge txvuhscij) /C| ct |oh dobijh ci |oh t~hhl ge dkgdmt vhtxk|cijevga b dobijh ci vhehvhidh evbaht |ob| ~vglxdhl |oh \zci ^bvblg ge T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s) \ohvh ct i~bvblg) B |zci zog vh|xvihl evga b ocjo t~hhl |vc~ zgxkl fh sgxijhv |obi oct tcfkcij zog oblvhabcihl t|b|cgibvs fhdbxth oct fcgkgjcdbk dkgdm zgxkl+ gi buhvbjh+ obuh vxi tkgzhv)#

:)6! Ci gvlhv |g citxvh |ob| |oh fbtcd tst|ha ge xic|t vh~vhthi| lcvhd|ks gfthvubfkh hi|c|cht+ c| ctihdhttbvs |g dgiuhv| |oh ebackcbv Abtt!Khij|o!\cah tst|ha ge xic|t |g b Egvdh!Khij|o!\cahtst|ha) /Egv b lhecic|cgi ge |oh fbtcd xic|t ge |oct tst|ha thh \bfkh :)6)2)# Xikcmh egvdh+ zocdo ctlcvhd|ks gfthvubfkh bil ct b exilbahi|bk hi|c|s ci c|t gzi vcjo|+ abtt obt ig cilh~hilhi| hct|hidbil dbiig| fh lcvhd|ks gfthvuhl) \oh abtt ge bi gf`hd| /gv ~bv|cdkh# dbi fh gfthvuhl ci gih gv agge |ovhh zbst) C| dbi fh gfthvuhl ci |hvat ge c|t cihv|cb bt |oh cidvhahi|bk ca~xkth /egvdh!|cah~vglxd|# vhrxcvhl |g ~vglxdh bi cidvhahi|bk dobijh ci uhkgdc|s /khij|o'|cah vb|cg#) C| dbi fhgfthvuhl ci |hvat ge |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk egvdh fh|zhhi |oh hihvjs /egvdh!|cah ~vglxd|# hrxcubkhi|t g|zg abttht lcuclhl fs |oh trxbvh ge |ohcv th~bvb|cgi /khij|o!khij|o ~vglxd|#) Gv c| abs fhlh|hvacihl fs |oh hihvjs /egvdh!khij|o ~vglxd|# vhkhbthl zohi |oh gf`hd| ct dgiuhv|hl |g vblcb|cgiBddh~|hl |h|t gi T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s dgvvhd|ks ~vguclh |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgit egv \cah+^bvbkkhk Khij|o+ \vbituhvth Khij|o+ bil ^bvbkkhk Egvdh) Xiegv|xib|hks+ bi xivhdgjicphl hvvgv zbtfhhi ablh ci |oh lhvcub|cgi ge |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi egv \vbituhvth Egvdh) \oh |vbitegvab|cg~vguclhl ci |h|t ct 2'Fu zohvhbt |oh dgvvhd| |vbitegvab|cgi ct Fu) \oh hct|hidh ge |oct hvvgv ct

vhuhbkhl fs |oh Vcjo| Bijkh Khuhv ^bvblg lctdxtthl fhkgz) /B vcjgvgxt lhvcub|cgi ge |oh Kgvhi|p\vbitegvab|cgit egv ^bvbkkhk bil \vbituhvth Egvdh ct ~vguclhl ci &Dgvvhd|cgit |g Hvvgvt ci T~hdcbkVhkb|cuc|s& bt ~vguclhl b| |oct Zhftc|h)#

\bfkh :)6)20! Vhucthl Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgit

Rxbi|c|sLcahitcgibk

Hi|c|s

^bvbkkhk

\vbitegvab|cgi

\vbituhvth

\vbitegvab|cgi

Egvdh E 2 Fu 

Khij|o K 2'Fu  2

\cah \ Fu Fu 

Fu1/2!U6'D6#>)8 

Ig|h gi \bfkh :)6)20! Dxvvhi| |h|t hvvgihgxtks ~vguclh 2'Fu bt |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi egv

\vbituhvth Egvdh)#

:)4! \zg hvvgvt ci ~vhthi| Uhkgdc|s Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs obuh fhhi hkcacib|hl) \oh ecvt| hvvgv zbthkcacib|hl fs |oh vhdgjic|cgi |ob| cihv|cbk abtt ct ~vg~hvks vh~vhthi|hl fs c|t cidvhahi|bk abtt+Ac+ fhdbxth cihv|cbk abtt vhehvt |g heehd|t zocdo gddxv xilhv dgilc|cgit zohvh |oh dobijh ci

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 39/110

uhkgdc|s ct tabkk) \oct dgvvhd|cgi bkkgzt |oh ab|ohab|cdt ge Uhkgdc|s Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs+ bt T~hdcbkbil'gv Bh|ohv Vhkb|cuc|s \ohgvs zckk lhtcjib|hl evga |oct ~gci| gi+ |g fh ubkcl egv bddhkhvb|hlvhehvhidh evbaht) Cilhhl |ohs axt| fh ubkcl egv bddhkhvb|hl vhehvhidh evbaht tcidh bddhkhvb|cgi ct|oh thdgil lhvcub|cuh ge khij|o zc|o vht~hd| |g |cah bil fg|o |hvat bvh txf`hd| |g |ohcv vht~hd|cuhKgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgit) \oh thdgil hvvgv ct hkcacib|hl fs ~vguclcij |oh dgvvhd| Kgvhi|p\vbitegvab|cgi egv \vbituhvth Egvdh) Zc|o |ohth dgvvhd|cgit+ c| ct ~gttcfkh |g ~vguclh |oh Kgvhi|p\vbitegvab|cgit fbthl x~gi b Egvdh!Khij|o!\cah tst|ha ge xic|t vb|ohv |obi |oh dgiuhi|cgibkAbtt!Khij|o!\cah tst|ha)

:)< B ~bvblg+ migzi bt |oh Vcjo| Bijkh Khuhv ^bvblg+ zbt lctdguhvhl hbvks gi ci lctdxttcgit g|oh T~hdcbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s) Bt ct |oh dbth zc|o bkk ~bvblght+ c|t hct|hidh vhuhbkhl |ob| bihvvgv obt fhhi ablh) \oh hvvgv gddxvvhl ci |oh cic|cbk lhvcub|cgi ge |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi egv\vbituhvth Egvdh bil dgvvhd|cij |ob| hvvgv hkcacib|ht |oh ~bvblg) /\oh dgvvhd| |vbitegvab|cgi ctvhblcks lhvcuhl bil ct ~vguclhl ci &T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s Dgvvhd|cgit& bubckbfkh gi |oct Zhftc|h)#Ogzhuhv+ cit|hbl ge vhdgjicpcij c|t hct|hidh bil zgvmcij |g ecil |oh tgxvdh ge |oh hvvgv+ |ohbdblhacd dgaaxic|s hkhd|hl |g bddh~| |oh hvvgihgxt Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi egv \vbituhvth Egvdbt dgvvhd| bil thhm bi htg|hvcd ah|ogl ge vhtgkx|cgi) Be|hv bkk+ b vhkcjcgi obl fhhi ht|bfkctohl bilc| zgxkl ig| lg egv ~vcht|t ge |ob| vhkcjcgi |g blac| |g obucij fhhi ci hvvgv)

:)8! \oh Vcjo| Bijkh Khuhv ^bvblg ct ckkxt|vb|hl ci Ecjxvh :)2) Dgitclhv |oh dgilc|cgi zohvh b vcjobijkh khuhv obucij hrxbk khij|o bvat ci c|t gzi vhehvhidh evbah ct agucij zc|o vht~hd| |g bvhehvhidh evbah zocdo ct dgitclhvhl |g fh t|b|cgibvs) B egvdh ct b~~kchl |g |oh hil ge gih ge |ohbvat ge |oh khuhv zocdo ct ~vhuhi|hl evga vg|b|cij fs bi hrxbk egvdh b~~kchl |g |oh g|ohv bva) Tcid|oh khuhv ct gfthvuhl ig| |g vg|b|h ci hc|ohv |oh t|b|cgibvs gv |oh agucij vhehvhidh evbah+ c| egkkgzt|ob| |oh ih| |gvrxh b~~kchl |g c| ci hbdo ge |oh vhehvhidh evbaht ct phvg) Evga |oh lcbjvba zh abszvc|h+ egv |oh agucij vhehvhidh evbah+ E|aK~a1E~aK|a bil+ tcidh |oh bvat bvh ge hrxbk khij|o ci

|ob| vhehvhidh evbah+ c| egkkgzt |ob| E|a1E~a) Zh togxkl bktg fh bfkh |g zvc|h E|tK~t1E~tK|t+ fx|

ci |oh t|b|cgibvs vhehvhidh evbah+ |oh khij|o ge |oh ~bvbkkhk bva+ K~t+ ct vhlxdhl fs |oh heehd|t ge

|oh uhkgdc|s ci bddgvlbidh zc|o |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi egv Khij|o+ Fu) Egv |oh ih| |gvrxh |g fh

phvg ci |oh t|b|cgibvs vhehvhidh evbah+ E|t axt| hrxbk |g E~t'Fu) Acimgztmc dgvvhd|ks ~vguclhl |o

Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi egv ^bvbkkhk Egvdh bt hrxbk |g xic|s fx| |oh dxvvhi|ks bddh~|hl Kgvhi|p

\vbitegvab|cgi egv \vbituhvth Egvdh ct |oh vhdc~vgdbk ge c|t dgvvhd| ubkxh) \oct hvvgv egvdht gih |gdgidkxlh |ob| |oh gfthvuhl bijxkbv bddhkhvb|cgi ge |oh Vcjo| Bijkh Khuhv ge Ecjxvh :)2 dbiig| fhphvg ci fg|o |oh t|b|cgibvs bil agucij vhehvhidh evbaht) \oh khuhv+ ig| migzcij |oct |g fhca~gttcfkh+ lght ig| xilhvjg bijxkbv bddhkhvb|cgi ci hc|ohv vhehvhidh evbah bil |oh Vcjo| BijkhKhuhv ^bvblg vhtxk|t)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 40/110

:)5! \g fs!~btt |oh ihhl |g blac| |ob| bi hvvgv obl fhhi ablh bil dgvvhd|cij |oh Kgvhi|p\vbitegvab|cgi egv \vbituhvth Egvdh+ vhkb|cuct|cd |ohgvct|t lhucthl b vb|ohv cabjcib|cuh h~kbib|cg\oct h~kbib|cgi obt b~~hbvhl ci agvh |obi gih ~gt|jvblxb|h |h| bil dgiekcd|t tg thuhvhks zc|odgaagi thith |ob| abis |hbdohvt ge Vhkb|cuc|s fs!~btt |oh |g~cd lht~c|h |oh fvbcizbtocij |ohsxilhvzhi| ci |oh ~vgdhtt ge b||bcicij |ohcv ~gtc|cgit) Ci |oct h~kbib|cgi+ |oh vb|h b| zocdo |oh|gvrxh xifbkbidh ge |oh khuhv+ bt gfthvuhl ci |oh t|b|cgibvs vhehvhidh evbah+ cidvhbtht c|t bijxkbvagahi|xa ct dgxi|hvhl fs |oh vb|h |ob| hihvjs ct bllhl |g |oh khuhv fs |oh egvdh+ E~t) Ci

xilhvjvblxb|h ^ostcdt 2>2 /Ahdobicdt#+ zocdo ct b ~vhvhrxctc|h |g vhdhcucij b ^oL ci ^ostcdt+ gihct |bxjo| |ob| |oh hct|hidh ge b agahi| vhrxcvht |oh hct|hidh ge |zg hrxbk bil g~~gtc|h egvdht

th~bvb|hl fs b lct|bidh) Ci |oct dbth+ |oh vhbd|cgi egvdh dga~gihi|t hct|cij b| |oh ocijh ~ci~vguclh |oh thdgil egvdht) Bt b vhtxk|+ bis hihvjs bllhl b| |oh hil ge |oh khuhv ct caahlcb|hksvhaguhl b| |oh ocijh ~ci bil |oh vb|h ge dobijh ge hihvjs ci |oh khuhv ct phvg) Gih ct bktg |bxjo| ci^ostcdt 2>2 |ob| |oh bijxkbv agahi|xa ge bi gf`hd| ct |oh ~vglxd| ge c|t agahi| ge cihv|cb bil c|tbijxkbv uhkgdc|s) Tcidh |oh bijxkbv uhkgdc|s ge |oh khuhv vhabcit phvg ci fg|o vhehvhidh evbaht+ |ohvb|h ge dobijh ge c|t bijxkbv agahi|xa ct bktg phvg) \oh tx~~gthl vhtgkx|cgi ge |oh Vcjo| BijkhKhuhv ^bvblg lhjvblht |g |oh t|b|hahi| |ob| phvg hrxbkt phvg) \oct dgidkxtcgi ct agt| dhv|bciks|vxh+ fx| c| ct obvlks uhvs xthexk \oh giks ahbit ge vhtgkucij |oh Vcjo| Bijkh Khuhv ^bvblg ct |gdgvvhd| |oh hvvgv ci |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi egv \vbituhvth Egvdh)

:):! Lcahitcgibk Bibkstct bt B~~kchl |g Vhkb|cuct|cd ^ohigahib0! Zockh c| ct ig| dgaagiksvhdgjicphl+ Lcahitcgibk Bibkstct ct |oh agt| heehd|cuh |ggk bubckbfkh egv |oh ciuht|cjb|cgi ge |ohheehd|t ge b dobijh ci uhkgdc|s bil'gv hkhub|cgi) Gfthvub|cgit bvh |vbitkb|bfkh ci|g hrxb|cgit+ txdobt U1/lK#'/l\#) ]\oct hrxb|cgi t|b|ht |ob| |oh uhkgdc|s b| zocdo bi gf`hd| ct agucij ct hrxbk |g |ohcidvhahi|bk lct|bidh c| |vbuhkt+ /lK#+ lcuclhl fs |oh cidvhahi|bk |cah+ /l\#+ vhrxcvhl egv c| |g |vbuhk|ob| lct|bidh)Q Xtbjh ge Lcahitcgibk Bibkstct ct tca~kcechl fs |oh ebd| |ob| giks |ovhh cilh~hilhi|lcahitcgibk hi|c|cht bvh vhrxcvhl) /Agvh |obi |ovhh lcahitcgibk hi|c|cht bvh egxil |g fh vhlxilbi|\oh lcahitcgibk dgi|hi| ge huhvs ~bvbah|hv hidgxi|hvhl ci bi gfthvub|cgi abs fh lhvcuhl evga|ogth |ovhh hi|c|cht fhdbxth hbdo |hva ci bi hrxb|cgi lhtdvcfcij b ~ostcdbk ~vgdhtt gv ~ohigahiaxt| obuh |oh tbah dgi|hi| ge lcahitcgibk hi|c|cht) B~~kht axt| ig| fh hrxb|hl |g gvbijht)

:)?! Zockh Lcahitcgibk Bibkstct gfucgxtks b~~kcht zc|oci b jcuhi vhehvhidh evbah+ |oh ^vcidc~kh geVhkb|cuc|s bllt |oh vhrxcvhahi| |ob|+ zc|o |oh b~~vg~vcb|h |vbitegvab|cgit+ c| axt| bktg b~~ks

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 41/110

fh|zhhi vhehvhidh evbaht zocdo lceehv ci uhkgdc|s bil'gv hkhub|cgi) /Egv vhehvhidh evbaht lceehvcij uhkgdc|s+ |ohth |vbitegvab|cgit bvh |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgit zocdo zckk fh |hvahl Uhkgdc|s\vbitegvab|cgit evga |oct ~gci| gi) Egv vhehvhidh evbaht zocdo lceehv ci hkhub|cgi+ bi hrxcubkhi| tge |vbitegvab|cgit |hvahl Jvbuc|s \vbitegvab|cgit ct vhrxcvhl)# Dgafcicij |oh vxkht geLcahitcgibk Bibkstct zc|o |oh ^vcidc~kh ge Vhkb|cuc|s bkkgzt |oh ~ohigahib bttgdcb|hl zc|ovhkb|cuct|cd heehd|t |g fh xi~hhkhl tg |ob| |ohs abs fh xilhvt|ggl b| |oh dgaagi thith khuhk) \gebdckc|b|h txdo b xth ge Lcahitcgibk Bibkstct+ \bfkh :)?)2 ~vguclht |oh lcahitcgibk dgi|hi| geubvcgxt ~ostcdbk rxbi|c|cht) Fbthl x~gi |oh hbvkchv lctdxttcgi ge |oh ahbicij ge abtt+ |oh |bfkh ctfbthl x~gi |oh agvh vb|cgibk egvdh!khij|o!|cah /EK\# tst|ha ge xic|t vb|ohv |obi x~gi |oh

dgiuhi|cgibk abtt!khij|o!|cah /AK\# tst|ha)

:)3! B| |oct ~gci|+ c| ct |cah |g dgitclhv |oh gfthvub|cgi ge |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ci b vhehvhidh evbahlceehvhi| evga |oh gih ci zocdo |oh gfthvuhv ecilt ocathke) Huhvsgih zog obt fhhi h~gthl |g bixilhvjvblxb|h khuhk dgxvth ci ~ostcdt obt fhhi h~gthl |g |oh clhb |ob| |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ctdgit|bi|+ sh|+ bt obt bkvhbls fhhi lctdxtthl+ |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| obt ihuhv fhhi ahbtxvhl bildbi ihuhv fh ahbtxvhl fhdbxth |oh dbkcfvb|cgi ge cit|vxahi|t ct beehd|hl fs dobijht ci |ohuhkgdc|s ge kcjo|) \oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ct dgit|bi| giks zohi c| ct ahbtxvhl fs b kgdbk gfthvuhv xtcikgdbk xic|t ge ahbtxvhahi|)

:)2>! Dgitclhv |oh dbth ge bi gfthvuhv ci |oh t|b|cgibvs vhehvhidh evbah ci dgaaxicdb|cgi zc|o bigfthvuhv ci b agucij vhehvhidh evbah) \oh gfthvuhv ci |oh agucij vhehvhidh evbah ahbtxvht |ohuhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ci b lcvhd|cgi bkgij |oh vhkb|cuh uhkgdc|s uhd|gv xtcij kgdbk xic|t ge ahbtxvhahi|bil vh~gv|t c|t ubkxh bt c|t t|bilbvl ubkxh ge D) \oh gfthvuhv ci |oh t|b|cgibvs vhehvhidh evbah+migzcij |ob| |oh cit|vxahi|t xthl |g abmh |oh ahbtxvhahi| ci |oh agucij vhehvhidh evbah obuhfhhi lct|gv|hl fs |oh heehd|t ge c|t uhkgdc|s+ dga~hitb|ht |oh vh~gv|hl ubkxh ge |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|ci |oh agucij vhehvhidh evbah xtcij |oh b~~vg~vcb|h Uhkgdc|s \vbitegvab|cgit bil gf|bcit

d1Fu6D+ zocdo abs fh vhzvc||hi bt Fu1/d'D#>)8) C| egkkgzt |ob| |oh Uhkgdc|s \vbitegvab|cgi |hva+

Fu+ ct |oh trxbvh vgg| ge |oh vb|cg ge |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ci |oh g|ohv vhehvhidh evbah lcuclhl c|t

uhkgdc|s ci |oh fbth vhehvhidh evbah) Bt zckk fh thhi+ zohi |oh fhobucgv ge |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl ctdgvvhd|ks lhtdvcfhl+ |oct lhecic|cgi ogklt egv jvbuc|b|cgibk |vbitegvab|cgit fh|zhhi hkhub|cgit btlhecihl ci |hvat ge Fj)

\bfkh :)?)2 ! \oh Lcahitcgibk Hi|c|cht Dgi|bcihl ci Ubvcgxt ^ostcdbk Rxbi|c|cht

Rxbi|c|s TsafgkLcahitcgibk

Dgi|hi|

Egvdh+ E E E

Khij|o+ K K K

\cah+ \ \ \

Hihvjs H EK

^kbidm*t Dgit|bi| O EK\

Uhkgdc|s U K'\

Bddhkhvb|cgi B K'\6 

Cidvhahi|bk Abtt Ac  E\6 'K

Agahi|xa X E\

Bijxkbv Agahi|xa @ EK\

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 42/110

Jvbuc|b|cgibk Dgit|bi| JK< '/E\<#

Hvjg!jvbuc|b|cgibk Dgit|bi| L 2'E

\ha~hvb|xvh % EK

Dobvjh R K

Lchkhd|vcd Dgit|bi| ge T~bdh h* 2'E

^hvahbfckc|s ge T~bdh x* E\6 'K6 

Fu1/2!U6'D6#>)8 

Ig|ht gi \bfkh :)?)20!

Dxvvhi| |h|t hvvgihgxtks ~vguclh 2'Fu bt |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi egv \vbituhvth Egvdh)r

\oh lcahitcgibk dgi|hi| egv uhkgdc|s ct xibeehd|hl fs |oh vhkb|cuct|cd dgvvhd|cgi |hva egv |ohbllc|cgi ge uhkgdc|cht tcidh |ob| dgvvhd|cgi |hvat ct lcahitcgikhtt)

r

\oh lcahitcgibk dgi|hi| ge |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk dgit|bi| ct lh|hvacihl evga |oh h~vhttcgi egv

Ihz|gicbi jvbuc|b|cgibk egvdh+ E1JAc2Ac6'K6)

r

\oh hvjg!jvbuc|b|cgibk dgit|bi| ct |oh dgiuhi|cgibk jvbuc|b|cgibk dgit|bi| lhecihl ci |hvat ge|oh hihvjs hrxcubkhi|t ge |oh jvbuc|b|cij abttht) C| ct clhi|cdbk |g Lv) Hcit|hci*t Dgtagkgjcdb

Dgit|bi| bil ct hrxbk |g J'D<)

r

\ha~hvb|xvh ct mcih|cd hihvjs ~hv bubckbfkh lhjvhh ge evhhlga bil obt |oh lcahitcgibkdgi|hi| ge hihvjs)

r

Hubkxb|cgi ge |oh lcahitcgibk dgi|hi| ge |oh h~vhttcgi egv |oh hkhd|vgt|b|cd egvdh fh|zhhi

dobvjht ~vguclht R6'h*1EK6)

r

Hubkxb|cgi ge |oh h~vhttcgi egv |oh hkhd|vgabjih|cd egvdh fh|zhhi agucij dobvjht ~vguclht

R6x*1E\6) \oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ct jcuhi fs D1/h*x*#>)8)

Ce gih bddh~|t |oh ~vhdh~| |ob| |oh h~gihi| ge b lcahitcgibk hi|c|s axt| fh bi ci|hjhv+|ohvh bvh |zg ~gttcfckc|cht) \oh ecvt| ~gttcfckc|s ct |ob| |oh lcahitcgibk dgi|hi| ge R cthrxbk |g K+ |oh lcahitcgibk dgi|hi| ge h* ct hrxbk |g 2'E+ bil |oh lcahitcgibk dgi|hi| g

x* ct hrxbk |g EK6'/K\6#) \oh thdgil ~gttcfckc|s ct |ob| |oh lcahitcgibk dgi|hi| ge R ct

hrxbk |g xic|s+ |oh lcahitcgibk dgi|hi| ge h* ct hrxbk |g 2'/EK6#+ bil |oh lcahitcgibkdgi|hi| ge x* ct hrxbk |g E\6) \oh lcahitcgibk dgi|hi| egv dobvjh+ R+ axt| hrxbk |g |ohlcahitcgibk dgi|hi| egv khij|o+ K+ ci gvlhv egv |oh ^vcidc~kh ge Vhkb|cuc|s |g b~~ks+ bil |ocubkxh+ bil c|t vhkb|hl ubkxht egv h* bil x* ct dogthi egv \bfkh :)?)2)

v

r

:)22! C| obt fhhi txjjht|hl |ob| abtt dgxkl bktg fh lh|hvacihl fs dgxi|cij ~bv|cdkht+ bil+ civht~gith+ |oh egkkgzcij dkbvcecdb|cgi ct ~vguclhl0

Ci b||ha~|cij |g xth abtt bt b exilbahi|bk gfthvubfkh hi|c|s+ dbvh axt| fh |bmhi |g citxvh|ob| |oh gfthvub|cgi ge abtt lght ig| vhrxcvh migzkhljh ge big|ohv abtt/ht#+ xikhtt |ob|abtt/ht# obt fhhi lh|hvacihl fs bi cilh~hilhi| ahbit) G|ohvzcth+ txdo bi gfthvub|cgi

r

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 43/110

lheciht abtt ci |hvat ge c|thke+ bi gfucgxt bftxvlc|s)

Zohi gih lh|hvaciht abtt fs &zhcjocij&+ |oh ihdhttbvs cilh~hilhi| ahbit ct bubckbfkh)\oh kbzt ge gvfc|bk ahdobicdt bkkgz |oh lh|hvacib|cgi ge |oh abtt ge b ~vcabvs gf`hd| |g fhlh|hvacihl ci |hvat ge |oh gvfc|bk ~hvcgl ge b tb|hkkc|h bil |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk dgit|bi|) \ohjvbuc|b|cgibk dgit|bi|+ ci |xvi+ dbi fh ahbtxvhl ci |hvat ge cihv|cbk abtt fs ahbit ge |ohHg|ugt H~hvcahi| ge Ecjxvh ?)2)

r

Ci gvlhv |g lh|hvacih |oh abtt ge bi gf`hd| fs dgxi|cij c|t ~bv|cdkht+ b tcackbv cilh~hilhi|ahbit ge ahbtxvcij |oh abtt ge |oh ~bv|cdkht ct vhrxcvhl) \oct ~vgdhtt ct dga~kcdb|hl fs |ohebd| |ob| |oh abtt ge b dga~gxil ~bv|cdkh /h)j))! bi b|ga obucij bi b|gacd zhcjo| jvhb|hv |ob2+ gv b agkhdxkh# lght ig| hrxbk |oh txa ge |oh abttht ge c|t dga~gihi| ~bv|t /h)j)! |oh abttge b ohkcxa b|ga ct khtt ge |oh abtt ge egxv oslvgjhi b|gat lxh |g |oh hihvjs vhkhbthl lxvcic|t extcgi#) B abtt t~hd|vgah|hv dgxkl fh ha~kgshl |g lh|hvacih |oh abtt ge huhvs ~bv|cdkh+b|ga+ gv agkhdxkh ge ci|hvht|+ fx|+ bt ct |oh dbth ge &zhcjocij&+ txdo xtbjh zgxkl lhecih abtci |hvat ge c|t cihv|cbk heehd|t)

r

C| zgxkl b~~hbv+ |ohi+ |ob| b vhecihahi| ge gxv xilhvt|bilcij ct vhrxcvhl) \ohvh bvh giks |zg ~vcabvs ahbit ge gfthvucij abtt) C| abs fh gfthvuhl fs |oh hihvjs vhkhbthl lxvcij biicockb|cgi bil c| abs fh gfthvuhl fs &tobmcij&) &Zhcjocij& gv &dgxi|cij& bvh b thdgilbvs ahbit ge gfthvub|cgi zocdo vhks gi |oh ~vcabvs ahbit egv |ohcv ubkclc|s)

r

Dob~|hv ? ! Jhihvb|cij |oh Jvbuc|s \vbitegvab|cgit

?)2! Hi|hv |oh ^vcidc~kh ge Hrxcubkhidh0! Lv) Hcit|hci ablh bi higvagxt dgi|vcfx|cgi |g gxvxilhvt|bilcij ge ~ostcdbk vhbkc|s fs cidgv~gvb|cij |oh ^vcidc~kh ge Hrxcubkhidh ci|g jvbuc|b|cgibk|ohgvs) ^vg~hv xth ge |oct ~vcidc~kh vhtxk|t ci |oh btthv|cgi |ob| |oh heehd|t ge uhkgdc|s bil jvbuc|sbvh hrxcubkhi| bil |ob| jvbuc|b|cgi ct b vhkb|cuct|cd ~ohigahib) Ce |ob| ~vcidc~kh dgvvhd|ks b~~kcht |g

|oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl+ c| axt| fh ~gttcfkh |g jhihvb|h Egvdh!Khij|o!\cah \vbitegvab|cgitfh|zhhi jvbuc|b|cgibk vhehvhidh evbaht zocdo bvh hrxcubkhi| |g |oh Egvdh!Khij|o!\cah\vbitegvab|cgit fh|zhhi uhkgdc|s vhehvhidh evbaht) Gidh lhvcuhl+ |ohth jvbuc|b|cgibk|vbitegvab|cgit bkkgz |oh bd|xbk heehd|t ge b dobijh ci hkhub|cgi |g fh gfthvuhl bil+ bt tobkk fhthhi+ zckk vhuhbk ebv agvh bfgx| vhbkc|s |obi gih acjo| vhbtgibfks og~h)

?)6! C| axt| fh ~gci|hl gx| |ob|+ ci agt| |h|t /cidkxlcij |oh zvc|cijt ge Lv) Hcit|hci#+ |oh ahbicij g|oh ^vcidc~kh ge Hrxcubkhidh ct guhvt|b|hl) C| ct dgaagiks btthv|hl |ob| |ohvh ct ig gfthvubfkhlceehvhidh fh|zhhi b jvbuc|b|cgibk bddhkhvb|cgi bil bi cihv|cbk bddhkhvb|cgi) \oct dgidkxtcgi ct ig|rxc|h |vxh) \oh egvdh gfthvuhl bt b vhtxk| ge cihv|cbk bddhkhvb|cgi ct bkzbst bddga~bichl fs bigfthvubfkh dobijh ci uhkgdc|s tcidh cihv|cbk bddhkhvb|cgi ct |oh vb|h ge dobijh ge uhkgdc|s zc|ovht~hd| |g |cah) \oh egvdh lxh |g jvbuc|b|cgibk bddhkhvb|cgi+ gi |oh g|ohv obil+ lght ig| ~vglxdh b

dobijh ci uhkgdc|s+ fx| c| ct bddga~bichl fs b jvblchi| ci bddhkhvb|cgi lxh |g |oh dxvub|xvhbttgdcb|hl zc|o bkk jvbuc|b|cgibk echklt) /\oh egvdh ge jvbuc|s ct khtt b| |oh dhckcij |obi c| ct b| |ohekggv)# \oh egvdh zocdo ct gfthvuhl ct |oh txa ge |ohth egvdht+ jvhb|ks dga~kcdb|cij |oh lhtcji ge|oh cihv|cbk ibucjb|cgi tst|hat ha~kgshl ci bcvdvbe| bil txfabvciht fs vhrxcvcij |ob| |ohs fh bfkh|g lct|cijxcto fh|zhhi |oh |zg heehd|t) \oh giks dgidkxtcgi |ob| dbi vcjgvgxtks fh lvbzi evga |oh^vcidc~kh ge Hrxcubkhidh ct |ob| |oh jvbuc|s |vbitegvab|cgit axt| fh hbd|ks bibkgjgxt |g |ohKgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgit) \ohth |vbitegvab|cgit bvh vhblcks lhvcuhl+ bt ~vguclhl fhkgz)

?)4! Lctckkxtcgi th|t ci+ ogzhuhv+ zohi gih vhbkcpht |ob| |oh xth ge |oh ^vcidc~kh ge Hrxcubkhidh ci|oh jhihvb|cgi ge Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s zbt fbthl gi |oh gfthvub|cgi |ob| cihv|cbk bil jvbuc|b|cgibkabttht zhvh clhi|cdbk zohi hubkxb|hl ci |hvat ge |oh egvdh ~vglxdhl fs bddhkhvb|cgi+ bt h~vhtthfs |oh hrxb|cgi E1AB+ bil |oh egvdh ~vglxdhl fs jvbuc|b|cgibk b||vbd|cgi+ bt h~vhtthl fs |oh

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 44/110

hrxb|cgi E1JA2A6'K6) \oh agt| ~vhdcth lh|hvacib|cgi ge |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk dgit|bi|+ J+ zbt abl

fs |oh Hg|ugt H~hvcahi| ckkxt|vb|hl ci Ecjxvh ?)2) Ci |oct h~hvcahi|+ |ovhh clhi|cdbk ah|bk t~ohvhtzhvh xthl) \zg ge |ohth t~ohvht zhvh agxi|hl ci b lxaffhkk dgiecjxvb|cgi gi b ogvcpgi|bk vgltxt~hilhl evga b ecih |gvtcgi zcvh bil |oh vhtgibi| evhrxhids ge |ohcv txt~hilhl abttht zbtlh|hvacihl) \oh |ocvl |ht| abtt zbt ~kbdhl b migzi lct|bidh evga gih ge |oh txt~hilhl abtthtbil |oh |gvtcgibk lhekhd|cgi ge |oh txt~hilhl abttht vhtxk|cij evga |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk b||vbd|cgifh|zhhi |oh abttht zbt bktg lh|hvacihl) Evga |ohth gfthvub|cgit c| ct ~gttcfkh |g xihrxcugdbkkshubkxb|h |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk dgit|bi|+ J) Tg ebv tg jggl+ fx| |ohi dcvdxkbv vhbtgicij zbt ha~kgshl |glh|hvacih |oh vhkb|cgitoc~ fh|zhhi jvbuc|b|cgibk abtt bil cihv|cbk abtt xtcij |oh tbah hrxb|cgitbil+ txv~vcth txv~vcth+ fg|o |s~ht ge abtt zhvh egxil |g fh clhi|cdbk ci abjic|xlh) C| zbt |ohidgidkxlhl |ob| fg|o |s~ht ge abtt zhvh clhi|cdbk) Ge dgxvth |ohs zhvh gfthvuhl |g fh clhi|cdbk+ |olceehvhidh fh|zhhi |oha zbt dga~hitb|hl fs |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk dgit|bi|+ J) \oh jvbuc|b|cgibk abt

ge bi gf`hd| ct bd|xbkks J>)8 |caht bt kbvjh bt c|t cihv|cbk abtt) Lctckkxtcgiahi| th| ci huhi lhh~hvzohi |oh bx|ogv vhbl ci thuhvbk |h|t |ob| |oh tgkx|cgi ge |oh hrxb|cgit zocdo khl |g JhihvbkVhkb|cuc|s bktg ~vguclhl |oh ubkxh ge |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk dgit|bi|) \oh zvc|hvt ge |ogth |h|t ihuhvvhbkcphl |ob| |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk dgit|bi|+ J+ zbt bi ci~x| |g |oh |ohgvs vhtxk|cij evga |oh ebkthbttxa~|cgi |ob| cihv|cbk bil jvbuc|b|cgibk abttht ge gf`hd|t zhvh ixahvcdbkks hrxbk vb|ohv |obiahvhks ~vg~gv|cgibk |g hbdo g|ohv)

?)<! \oh ecvt| t|h~ ci jhihvb|cij |oh Jvbuc|s \vbitegvab|cgit ct |g lhecih |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk hrxcubkhige |oh uhkgdc|s vb|cg+ U'D+ zocdo ct |oh fbtct ge |oh Uhkgdc|s \vbitegvab|cgit) \ob| hrxcubkhi| ct |ojvbuc|b|cgibk ~g|hi|cbk+ ,+ zocdo hct|t fh|zhhi hkhub|cgit) Xtcij |oh x~~hv hkhub|cgi xic|t ge

ahbtxvhahi| bt b vhehvhidh+ , ct hrxbk |g |oh hihvjs+ /lH#+ vhkhbthl bt |oh hihvjs ge ebkk fs bigf`hd| ge vht| abtt hrxcubkhi| hihvjs+ H+ bt c| ct kgzhvhl evga |oh x~~hv |g |oh kgzhv hkhub|cgi) ]C|tubkxh ct ~vguclhl fs |oh vhkb|cgitoc~ ,1/lH#'H)Q C| ct lhagit|vb|hl ci &Jvbuc|s& |ob| |oh Jvbuc|s\vbitegvab|cgit bvh cilh~hilhi| ge lcvhd|cgi /ogvcpgi|bk gv uhv|cdbk# jvhb|ks tca~kcescij |ohcvlh|hvacib|cgi tcidh giks |ogth vhtxk|cij evga hkhub|cgi dobijht ihhl fh dgitclhvhl)

?)8! Bt lhvcuhl ci &Jvbuc|s&+ |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk |vbitegvab|cgi egv |cah+ \+ ct vhblcks lh|hvacihl ci|hvat ge |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk ~g|hi|cbk+ ,+ bil |oh Jvbuc|b|cgibk \vbitegvab|cgit egv egvdh+ E+ bil egvkhij|o+ K+ xtcij |oh clhbk |ogxjo| h~hvcahi| ckkxt|vb|hl ci Ecjxvh ?)6) Ci |oct |ogxjo| h~hvcahi|+ahdobicdbk hihvjs ct t|gvhl ci b t~vcij zocdo ct |ohi dga~vhtthl bil |chl b| |oh x~~hv hkhub|cgi)\oh t~vcij ct |ohi aguhl evga |oh x~~hv |g |oh kgzhv hkhub|cgi bil |oh t|gvhl hihvjs ct vhdguhvhlfs vhkhbtcij |oh t~vcij)Bkgij zc|o |oct t|gvhl hihvjs+ |oh kgzhv hkhub|cgi bktg vhdhcuht |oh hihvjs

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 45/110

ge ebkk ge |ob| t|gvhl hihvjs bkgij zc|o |oh hihvjs ge ebkk ge |oh vhkbhl t~vcij) \oh hihvjs ge ebkk ge|oh vhkbhl t~vcij ct |ohi xthl |g vh|xvi c| |g |oh x~~hv hkhub|cgi bil ~kbst ig ~bv| ci |oh |ogxjo|h~hvcahi|) Vhabcicij b| |oh kgzhv hkhub|cgi ct |oh t|gvhl hihvjs bil c|t hihvjs ge ebkk) \oh ih|hihvjs |vbit~gv|hl evga |oh x~~hv |g |oh kgzhv hkhub|cgi ct |ohi dgiuhv|hl |g ~og|git bil|vbitac||hl evga |oh kgzhv hkhub|cgi |g b vhdhcuhv b| |oh x~~hv hkhub|cgi bil dgiuhv|hl fbdm |gahdobicdbk hihvjs b| 2>>( heecdchids) Tcidh |ohvh bvh ig kgttht ci |oct os~g|oh|cdbk dkgthl dsdkh+|oh hihvjs vhdguhvhl evga |oh ~og|git b| |oh x~~hv hkhub|cgi axt| hrxbk |oh hihvjs gvcjcibkkst|gvhl ci |oh t~vcij) Ce |oct zhvh ig| |oh dbth+ c| zgxkl fh ~gttcfkh+ ci ~vcidc~kh+ |g fxckl b ~hv~h|xbag|cgi abdocih zocdo dvhb|hl hihvjs evga ig|ocij) Ci &Jvbuc|s&+ |oct |ogxjo| h~hvcahi| ct xthl

lhvcuh |oh Jvbuc|s \vbitegvab|cgi egv \cah bt \12'/2-EK,#) C| togxkl fh ig|hl |ob| ce |oh EK~vglxd| ct bvfc|vbvcks ablh hrxbk |g xic|s+ |oh |cah lckb|cgi ~vguclhl fs Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s ctgf|bcihl)

?)5! \oh ih| vhrxcvhahi| zocdo axt| fh ah| ct |ob| |oh Jvbuc|s \vbitegvab|cgi egv \cah axt| obub ~vg~hv|s zocdo |oh bx|ogv lhtcjib|ht bt axk|c~kcdb|cuh dgaax|cuc|s) Bt bi hba~kh+ zohi gihjght evga |oh ecvt| ekggv ge b fxcklcij |g c|t |ocvl ekggv+ c| lght ig| ab||hv ce |oh hkhub|gv ob~~hit |gt|g~ b| |oh thdgil ekggv) \oh vhrxcvhahi| |ob| |oh |cah lckb|cgi fh axk|c~kcdb|cuh dgaax|b|cuhahbit |ob| |oh |cah lckb|cgi fh|zhhi |oh x~~hv hkhub|cgi bil b acllkh hkhub|cgi axk|c~kchl fs |oh|cah lckb|cgi fh|zhhi |ob| acllkh hkhub|cgi bil |oh kgzhv hkhub|cgi axt| fh hrxbk |g |oh |cahlckb|cgi hct|cij fh|zhhi |oh x~~hv hkhub|cgi bil |oh kgzhv hkhub|cgi) Ca~gtcij |oct vhrxcvhahi|bkkgzt |oh |cah |vbitegvab|cgi ge |oh ~vhucgxt ~bvbjvb~o |g fh ebd|gvhl ci|g |zg |vbitegvab|cgit+gih egv |cah+ \+ bil gih egv hihvjs+ EK+ ~vguclcij \1/2!,# bil EK12'/2!,#) \oh vhtxk|cij|vbitegvab|cgi egv hihvjs ahh|t big|ohv vhrxcvhahi| ge b tb|ctebd|gvs jvbuc|b|cgibk |ohgvs) \ohJvbuc|s \vbitegvab|cgi egv Hihvjs+ EK+ fvcijt |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl ci|g dga~kcbidh zc|o |oh Kbzge Dgithvub|cgi ge Hihvjs bil+ ci tg lgcij+ hkcacib|ht b thvcgxt ekbz ge fg|o |oh Ihz|gicbi \ohgvs

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 46/110

ge Jvbuc|b|cgi bil ge Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s) \oh Jvbuc|s \vbitegvab|cgi egv Hihvjs togzt |ob| |oh vht|abtt hrxcubkhi| hihvjs ge bi gf`hd|+ bt ahbtxvhl zc|o x~~hv hkhub|cgi xic|t ge ahbtxvhahi|+ ctvhlxdhl fs bi bagxi| hrxbk |oh hihvjs vhkhbthl fs kgzhvcij c| |g |oh kgzhv hkhub|cgi) \oh |g|bkhihvjs ci |oh tst|ha vhabcit xidobijhl bt vhrxcvhl fs |oh Kbz ge Dgithvub|cgi ge Hihvjs) \ohvhrxcvhahi| egv axk|c~kcdb|cuh dgaax|cuc|s ct ig| bi ciuhi|cgi ge |oh bx|ogv+ c| ct dobvbd|hvct|cd ge bdgi|cixgxt echklt) C| ct |bxjo| ci xilhvjvblxb|h dgxvtht ci Echkl \ohgvs |ob| |oh lceehvhidh cidobvbd|hvct|cdt gfthvuhl fh|zhhi |zg ~gci|t ci b dgi|cixgxt echkl ct cilh~hilhi| ge |oh ~b|o zocdct |vbuhkhl fh|zhhi |ogth ~gci|t bil+ ci gvlhv egv |oct vhrxcvhahi| |g fh ah|+ |oh echkl axt| fh&axk|c~kcdb|cuhks dgaax|b|cuh&) ^hvob~t agvh tcjicecdbi| ct |oh ebd| |ob| |oh ~vg~hv|s ge

&axk|c~kcdb|cuh dgaax|cuc|s& ct ihdhttbvs ce |oh ^vcidc~kh ge Vhkb|cuc|s ct |g fh ubkcl) C| ct |oh ebd| |ob|oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgit bvh &axk|c~kcdb|cuhks dgaax|b|cuh& zocdo bkkgzt |oh T~hdcbk |ohgvs geVhkb|cuc|s |g zgvm)

?):! B| |oct ~gci|+ |oh lh|hvacib|cgi ge |oh Jvbuc|b|cgibk \vbitegvab|cgit dgxkl fh dga~kh|hl fs bkc|hvbk b~~kcdb|cgi ge |oh ^vcidc~kh ge Hrxcubkhidh bil btthv|cij |ob| |oh vhkb|cgitoc~ fh|zhhi |ohUhkgdc|s \vbitegvab|cgit egv ^bvbkkhk Khij|o bil egv \cah axt| fhbv |oh tbah vhkb|cgitoc~ |g hbdog|ohv bt |oh Jvbuc|s \vbitegvab|cgit egv Khij|o bil \cah) Gih zgxkl |ohi dgidkxlh |ob| |ohJvbuc|s \vbitegvab|cgi egv Egvdh zbt hrxbk |g xic|s bil |oh Jvbuc|s \vbitegvab|cgi egv Khij|o zbt2'/2!,#) Bt togzi ci &Jvbuc|s&+ |oh b~~kcdb|cgi ge |oct |vcbl ge |vbitegvab|cgit |g |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk

echkl bvgxil |oh Txi khblt lcvhd|ks |g |oh gfthvub|cgibk vhtxk|t /c)h)! |cah lckb|cgi+ bigabkgxt~vhdhttcgi ge Ahvdxvs*t gvfc|+ fhilcij ge t|bvkcjo|# zocdo tx~~gthlks obuh uhvcechl JhihvbkVhkb|cuc|s) Xiegv|xib|hks+ Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s ci|vglxdhl |oh clhb |ob| |oh ~vhthidh ge abtt/hihvjs#dbxtht |oh jhgah|vs ge t~bdh |g fh lct|gv|hl bil c| zbt |oct lct|gv|cgi zocdo ~vglxdhl |ohjvbuc|b|cgibk heehd|t) Ce |oh ~vhthidh ge abtt/hihvjs# lght lct|gv| t~bdh+ tgah gv bkk ge |ohgfthvuhl fhilcij ge kcjo| bil ge |oh gfthvuhl gvfc|bk ~vhdhttcgi zgxkl vhtxk| evga |oh dxvub|xvhvhtxk|cij evga |ob| lct|gv|cgi vb|ohv |obi evga |oh heehd|t ge |oh Jvbuc|s \vbitegvab|cgit egv Khij|obil \cah) \oh ci|vglxd|cgi ge igi!Hxdkclcbi jhgah|vs ci|g |oh dgidh~| ge |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl|oxt bkkgzt |oh ~gttcfckc|s ge bi ciecic|h ixafhv ge jhgah|vcht ci |oh ucdcic|s ge b jvbuc|b|cij gf`hd|\oh giks kcac|b|cgi gi |ohth jhgah|vcht ct |oh vhrxcvhahi| |ob| ~vglxd| ge |oh Jvbuc|s\vbitegvab|cgit egv Egvdh bil egv Khij|o dga~hitb|h hbdo g|ohv tg |ob| |oh Jvbuc|s\vbitegvab|cgi egv Hihvjs vhabcit dgvvhd|) Zockh Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s ci|vglxdhl |oh clhb ge dxvuhlt~bdh+ c| lght ig| ahh| |oct vhrxcvhahi| bil dbiig| fh b ubkcl lhtdvc~|cgi ge |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk

~ohigahib)

?)?! Tcidh Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s obt jhihvb|hl b lgjab ci zocdo t~bdh ct igi!Hxdkclcbi+ c| ctihdhttbvs |g lct~vguh |oh dgidh~|) \g lg tg+ dgitclhv |oh clhbk |ogxjo| h~hvcahi| lcbjvbahl ciEcjxvh ?)4) Ci |oct h~hvcahi|+ b ~bcv ge clhbk vh|vgvhekhd|gvt bvh agxi|hl gi g~~gtc|h tclht ge babttcuh gf`hd| fs clhbkks vcjcl bil abttkhtt fggat) ^og|git bvh vhekhd|hl fbdm bil egv|o fh|zhh|oh vh|vgvhekhd|gvt ci b igi!lcuhvjhi| fhba zocdo ~bttht dkgth |g |oh gf`hd|) \oh gf`hd|*tjvbuc|b|cgibk echkl dbxtht |oh |vb`hd|gvs ge |oh ~og|git |g fhil bt |ohs ~btt fs |oh gf`hd| bil t|vcm|oh vh|vgvhekhd|gvt b| bi bijkh |g |oh jhgah|vcd kcih fh|zhhi |oha) Tcidh ~og|git ~gttht cihv|cbkabtt+ |oh lhucb|cgi ge |ohcv ~b|o dbxtht b vhbd|cgi egvdh |g fh hhv|hl gi |oh vh|vgvhekhd|gvt bt |ohbvh vhekhd|hl) Ci |oh ogvcpgi|bk lcvhd|cgi /ge |oh lcbjvba#+ |oh dga~gihi| ge |ob| egvdh gi gih ge |ohvh|vgvhekhd|gvt ct dbidhkhl fs bi hrxbk bil g~~gtc|h dga~gihi| ge |ob| egvdh hhv|hl gi |oh g|ohv)

Ci |oh uhv|cdbk lcvhd|cgi /ge |oh lcbjvba#+ |oh egvdh dga~gihi|t gi |oh vh|vgvhekhd|gvt lg ig| dbidh|ohs bll bil ~vglxdh b ih| lgzizbvl egvdh gi |oh gf`hd|) \oct lgzizbvl egvdh axt| fh fbkbidhlfs bi x~zbvl egvdh bd|cij gi |oh gf`hd| zocdo dbi giks vhtxk| evga |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk b||vbd|cgi ge|oh fhba ge ~og|git) \oh vhrxcvhahi| egv b egvdh fbkbidh ci |oh uhv|cdbk lcvhd|cgi ct fbtcd) Ce b ih|egvdh zhvh |g hct| ci |oh uhv|cdbk lcvhd|cgi+ c| zgxkl fh ~gttcfkh+ ci ~vcidc~kh+ |g dgit|vxd| b~hv~h|xbk ag|cgi abdocih) \oct abdocih zgxkl bkkgz |oh tst|ha |g dgi|cixgxtks h~gv| hihvjszc|ogx| bis dobijh ci c|t ci|hvibkks bil h|hvibkks gfthvuhl t|b|ht) \oct ct b IG!IG bil dbiig|gddxv)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 47/110

?)3! Dgidh~|xbkks+ |oh fhilcij ge |oh ~b|o ge |oh fhba ge ~og|git dbi vhtxk| evga gih gv fg|o ge|zg heehd|t bd|cij th~bvb|hks gv ci dgafcib|cgi) Gih ge |ohth heehd|t ct dgiuhi|cgibk vhevbd|cgi) \og|ohv heehd| ct |oh b~~bvhi| fhilcij ge |ohcv ~b|o fhdbxth |ohs bvh |vbuhkcij ci b dxvuhl |ovhhlcahitcgibk igi!Hxdkclcbi t~bdh bil |ohs bvh bd|xbkks |vbuhkcij bkgij b t|vbcjo| kcih) \g |oh lhjvh|ob| |oh gfthvuhl fhilcij ge |ohcv ~b|o ct dbxthl fs vhevbd|cgi+ |oh fhilcij ge |oh ~b|o ge |oh~og|git vhrxcvht |oh egvdh ge jvbuc|s |g bd| fh|zhhi |oh gf`hd| bil |oh ~og|git) \g |oh lhjvhh |ob|oh gfthvuhl fhilcij ge |ohcv ~b|o ct dbxthl fs |oh dxvub|xvh ge igi!Hxdkclcbi t~bdh+ ig dobijh clcvhd|cgi bd|xbkks gddxvt bil |oh egvdh ge jvbuc|s ct ig| bd|cij) Ci &Jvbuc|s&+ |oh zvc|hv lhvcuhl |ohjvbuc|b|cgibk egvdh bd|cij x~gi txdo b fhba ge ~og|git bil |oh ih| egvdht |ohs b~~ks |g |ohvh|vgvhekhd|gvt) Fs togzcij |ob| |ohth egvdht bvh hrxbk+ |oh lhvcub|cgi lhagit|vb|ht |ob| gfthvuhlfhilcij ge |oh ~b|o ge kcjo| ci b jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl vhtxk|t hi|cvhks evga jvbuc|b|cgibk b||vbd|cgi) B~gt|xkb|hl dxvub|xvh ge t~bdh abmht ig dgi|vcfx|cgi |g |oh ~og|gi*t ~b|o bil t~bdh ci |oh

jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl axt| fh |ovhh lcahitcgibk Hxdkclcbi+ hbd|ks bt dgaagi thith zgxkl vhrxcvh) C|ct igz ~gttcfkh |g ~vguclh Jvbuc|s \vbitegvab|cgit |g ab|do |oh Uhkgdc|s \vbitegvab|cgit bkvhbls~vguclhl) Lhecicij Fu bt |oh uhkgdc|s |vbitegvab|cgi+ Fj bt |oh Jvbuc|s \vbitegvab|cgi+ bil Fjh 

bt |oh jvbuc|s |vbitegvab|cgi ge Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s+ |oh Vhkb|cuct|cd \vbitegvab|cgit egv Uhkgdc|s+Jvbuc|s+ bil egv Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s abs fh ~vguclhl ci |oh tbah egva+ bt togzi ci \bfkh ?)3)2)

?)2>! Ce |oh ^vcidc~kh ge Hrxcubkhidh b~~kht |g |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl+ b ~vg~hv jvbuc|b|cgibk |ohgvszckk ~vguclh Jvbuc|s \vbitegvab|cgit clhi|cdbk ci egva |g |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgit egv ^bvbkkhkUhkgdc|s) Jvbuc|s Vhkb|cuc|s ahh|t |oct vhrxcvhahi|) C|t fbtcd |vbitegvab|cgit bvh0

E12

K12'/2!,#\1/2!,#

\oh hrxcubkhi| |vbitegvab|cgit egv Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s bvh ~vguclhl egv vhehvhidh) C| zckk fh ig|hl|ob|+ xilhv Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s+ fg|o E bil K bvh hrxbk |g xic|s) B~~kscij |ohth ubkxht |g |oh vhtxk|tge |oh T~vcij!Kba~ H~hvcahi| ge Ecjxvh ?)6+ gih gf|bcit |oh |cah lckb|cgi+ Fjh+ ge Jhihvbk

Vhkb|cuc|s bt c|t bddh~|hl ubkxh ge \12'/2-,#) \oh fbtcd |vbitegvab|cgit ge Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|sfhdgah0

E12K12\*12'/2-,#

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 48/110

T 12'/2-,#

\oh bfguh kct|cij cidkxlht bi bllc|cgibk kcih egv |oh Jvbuc|b|cgibk \vbitegvab|cgi egv T~bdh zocdoLv) Hcit|hci vhrxcvhl |g bkkgz oca |g dga~kh|h oct lhvcub|cgi ge Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s) C| vh~vhthi|t |ohbkkhjhl dxvub|xvh ge t~bdh ablh ihdhttbvs fs |oh ab|ohab|cdbk hvvgv ci c|t lhvcub|cgi bil zocdobvfc|vbvcks egvdhl |oh |vbitegvab|cgi egv khij|o |g hrxbk xic|s) C| zckk fh ig|hl |ob| |ohth|vbitegvab|cgit bvh cidgitct|hi| zc|o |oh Uhkgdc|s \vbitegvab|cgit egv ^bvbkkhk Egvdh bil egv^bvbkkhk Khij|o) Bt b vhtxk|+ Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s dgi|vblcd|t gih ge c|t ~gt|xkb|ht+ |oh ^vcidc~kh geHrxcubkhidh) Exv|ohvagvh+ fhdbxth c|t |vbitegvab|cgit egv egvdh bil egv khij|o bvh fg|o hrxbk |g

xic|s+ |oh heehd|t ge |oh |vbitegvab|cgi egv |cah bvh ig| dga~hitb|hl fh|zhhi vhehvhidh evbaht biJhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s bktg dgi|vblcd|t c|t g|ohv fbtcd ~gt|xkb|h+ |oh ^vcidc~kh ge Vhkb|cuc|s) Tgahogz+ thhat vhbtgibfkh |g txt~hd| |oh ubkclc|s ge b |ohgvs zocdo dgi|vblcd|t |oh ~gt|xkb|ht x~gi zocdo ct fbthl)

\bfkh ?)3)20! \oh Vhkb|cuct|cd \vbitegvab|cgit

Rxbi|c|s^bvbkkhk

Uhkgdc|s

\vbituhvth

Uhkgdc|s

Jvbuc|s

Vhkb|cuc|s

Jhihvbk

Vhkb|cuc|s

Egvdh E 2 Fu 2 2

Khij|o K 2'Fu 2 2'Fj 2

\cah \ Fu Fu Fj Fjh

T~bdh T 2 2 2 F jh

T|ceeihtt M* Fu Fu Fj 2

Ig|h 20! Fu+ Fj+ bil Fjh bvh bkk hrxbk |g /d'D#6)

Ig|h 60! Dxvvhi| |h|t hvvgihgxtks ~vguclh 2'Fu bt |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi egv \vbituhvth

Egvdh)#

?)22! Lhvcucij |oh Jhihvbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s ~vhthi|hl Lv) Hcit|hci zc|o dgitclhvbfkh lceecdxk|s)Oh dgxkl ig| abmh c| zgvm ci |hvat ge |ovhh lcahitcgibk Hxdkclcbi t~bdh) Be|hv bfgx| b shbv bil bobke ge ebckxvh+ oh guhvdbah oct lceecdxk|cht fs vhtgv|cij |g |oh igi!Hxdkclcbi jhgah|vs lhtdvcfhl fsVchabii ci |oh acllkh ge |oh 23|o dhi|xvs bil bllcij |oh h|vb lhjvhh ge evhhlga |ob| dxvuhlt~bdh ~vguclhl) \oh heehd| ge |ob| dxvub|xvh ct |g bll bllc|cgibk t~bdh bt hkhub|cgi ct vhlxdhl+ btlhecihl fs T ci \bfkh ?)3)2) \oct aglcecdb|cgi bkkgzhl oca |g tgkuh oct ab|ohab|cdbk hrxb|cgit ci bthke dgitct|hi| abiihv) \oh vhtxk|bi| |ohgvs ~vguclhl ~vhlcd|cgit egv |oh fhobucgv ge |ohjvbuc|b|cgibk echkl zocdo bvh agvh bddxvb|h |obi |oh ~vhlcd|cgit ge Ihz|gicbi Jvbuc|b|cgibk \ohgvsfhdbxth |ohs lcl bkkgz |oh |ohgvs |g fh vhkb|cuct|cd+ fx| |oh |ohgvs dgi|bcit bi hvvgv gi |oh gvlhv g

,6) \ob| hvvgv ct bfgx| 8 gvlhvt ge abjic|xlh |gg tabkk |g fh lh|hd|hl ci |oh h|vhahks zhbm

jvbuc|b|cgibk echklt hct|cij zc|oci |oh Tgkbv Tst|ha gv fs gfthvub|cgit ge |oh t~hd|vbk kciht gelct|bi| t|bvt) \oh tabkk tcph ge |oct hvvgv bkkgzhl Lv) Hcit|hci |g ~vhlcd| |oh fhilcij ge t|bvkcjo|+ |oh|cah lckb|cgi+ bil |oh ~vhdhttcgi ge gvfc|t dbxthl fs |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl zocdo bvh igz bddh~|hlbt ~vgge ge |oh ubkclc|s ge Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s zc|ogx| ehbv ge dgi|vblcd|cgi fs |oh vhtxk|t gegfthvub|cgi) \ohvh ct bi cilcdb|cgi |ob| oh txt~hd|hl |ob| oct |ohgvs zbt lhehd|cuh tcidh oh ctvh~gv|hl |g obuh obl dgidhvit bfgx| c|t h|hitcgi |g h|vhahks t|vgij echklt txdo bt |ogthbttgdcb|hl zc|o ihx|vgi t|bvt) Xiegv|xib|hks+ lcvhd| gfthvub|cgi dbiig| fh xthl |g lct|cijxctofh|zhhi Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s bil Jvbuc|s Vhkb|cuc|s) Fg|o b~~vgbdoht schkl |oh tbah ~vhlcd|cgit |g|oh egvhthhbfkh kcac|t ge gfthvub|cgibk bddxvbds) \oh lceehvhidh fh|zhhi |oh |zg b~~vgbdoht dbigiks fh gfthvub|cgibkks lh|hvacihl fs dkgth!x~ gfthvub|cgi ge gf`hd|t obucij h|vhahks t|vgijechklt+ txdo bt b ihx|vgi t|bvt) Txdo gfthvub|cgit ~vgfbfks vhrxcvh |oh ciuhi|cgi ge T|bv \vhm*t

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 49/110

Zbv~ Lvcuh)

?)26!\ohvh ct bi gfthvub|cgibk |ht| zocdo dbi fh b~~kchl |g Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s bil |g Jvbuc|sVhkb|cuc|s xtcij dxvvhi| |hdoigkgjs) Zh kcuh ci b Xicuhvth zocdo b~~vgcab|ht b jvbuc|b|cgibkksdgkkb~thl gf`hd|) B| ~vhthi|+ c|t gfthvuhl vblcxt ct thuhvbk |caht kbvjhv |obi |oh vblcxt ge |oh HuhiOgvcpgi vhtxk|cij evga c|t ht|cab|hl abtt) Ogzhuhv+ bt|vgigacdbk gfthvub|cgit cilcdb|h |ob| |ohXicuhvth t|bv|hl h~bilcij evga c|t gvcjci bt b ~gci| tgxvdh bfgx| 28 fckkcgi shbvt bjg) B| c|t t|bv||oh Xicuhvth zbt tcjicecdbi|ks tabkkhv |obi c|t Huhi| Ogvcpgi) B~~bvhi|ks+ fh|zhhi 4 bil 8 fckkcgishbvt bjg+ |oh Xicuhvth h~bilhl |ovgxjo bil ct igz thuhvbk |caht kbvjhv |obi c|t Huhi| Ogvcpgi)

Tcidh Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s ~vhlcd|t |ob| ig|ocij dbi htdb~h evga zc|oci |oh Huhi| Ogvcpgi+ |ohbt|vgigacdbk gfthvub|cgit lcvhd|ks lhis |oh ubkclc|s ge Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s) Jvbuc|s Vhkb|cuc|s+ gi |ohg|ohv obil+ ct agvh |obi ahvhks dga~b|cfkh zc|o bt|vgigacdbk gfthvub|cgit+ |oh dgtagkgjs zocdoegkkgzt evga |oh Jvbuc|s \vbitegvab|cgit thhat |g bjvhh rxc|h zhkk zc|o gfthvub|cgi)

?)24! Bt lhvcuhl ci &Jvbuc|s&+ |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk ~g|hi|cbk+ ,+ ct hrxbk |g Vo'V+ zohvh Vo ct

lhtcjib|hl bt |oh Ogvcpgi Vblcxt bil ct hrxbk |g |oh vblcxt ge |oh Huhi| Ogvcpgi bil V ct |oh bd|xbvblcxt ge |oh gf`hd|+ fg|o bt gfthvuhl h|hvibkks) \bfkh ?)24)2 ~vguclht |oh Uhkgdc|s Vhkb|cuc|s bilJvbuc|s Vhkb|cuc|s \vbitegvab|cgit ge |oh lcahitcgibk hi|c|cht kct|hl ci \bfkh :)?)2 hubkxb|hl ci|hvat ge |oh uhkgdc|s vb|cg+ U'D+ ci |hvat ge jvbuc|b|cgibk ~g|hi|cbk+ ,+ bil ci |hvat ge |oh h|hvibkksgfthvuhl vb|cg ge |oh Ogvcpgi Vblcxt |g |oh bd|xbk vblcxt+ Vo'V)

?)2<! B tdoggk ge |ogxjo| hct|t zocdo ct bttgdcb|hl zc|o |oh Ciekb|cgibvs \ohgvs ge |oh gvcjci ge |oXicuhvth) \oct tdoggk |hbdoht |ob|+ bk|ogxjo |oh dga~gihi|t /t|bvt+ jbkbcht+ h|d)# ge |oh Xicuhvthbvh gfthvuhl |g fh th~bvb|cij b| b ocjo uhkgdc|s+ |ohs bvh bd|xbkks t|b|cgibvs ci t~bdh) C| ct |oh t~bd|ob| ct h~bilcij cit|hbl bil gx|tclh ge |oh Xicuhvth |ohvh ct ig t~bdh" Txdo bi bvjxahi| acjo| fbddh~|bfkh fx| egv |zg vhbtgit) Ecvt|ks+ egv txdo |g gddxv+ hihvjs zgxkl fh vhrxcvhl |g fhdgi|cixgxtks bllhl |g |ob| Xicuhvth evga tgah xiibahl tgxvdh) \oct vhrxcvhahi| ct huclhidhl f|oh ebd| |ob|+ ce |oh ab||hv ~vhthi| ci |oh Xicuhvth zhvh |g hkhd| |g ebkk fbdm ci gi c|thke+ c| zgxkl obuexv|ohv |g ebkk bil zgxkl vhkhbth agvh hihvjs bt |cah ~btthl) \oct dgidh~| txeehvt evga |oh tbahlceecdxk|s+ fx| ci vhuhvth+ bt lght |oh Xicuhvth ge |oh ~vhdhlcij ~bvbjvb~ot) C| dbiig| vhdgidckh |ohgfthvuhl Xicuhvth zc|o |oh Kbz ge Dgithvub|cgi ge Hihvjs bil axt| fh lctactthl xikhtt b t|vgij`xt|cecdb|cgi dbi fh ~vguclhl) Thdgilks+ txdo b Xicuhvth zgxkl ig| ~vguclh b vhdc~vgdbk vhkb|cgito

fh|zhhi |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk hihvjs bil |cah |vbitegvab|cgit+ bil+ zc|ogx| |ob| vhdc~vgdbkvhkb|cgitoc~+ |oh ^vcidc~kh ge Vhkb|cuc|s zgxkl ig| b~~ks bil ~ostcdt zgxkl dobijh bt hkhub|cgidobijhl) C| zgxkl thha |ob| txdo b dgidh~| axt| fh lctactthl) \oh vhrxcvhl heehd|t lg ig| thha|g gddxv)

\bfkh ?)24)20! Lcahitcgibk Dgi|hi| ge Ubvcgxt ^ostcdbk Rxbi|c|cht

Rxbi|c|s Tsafgk^bvbkkhk

Uhkgdc|s

\vbituhvth

Uhkgdc|s

Jvbuc|s

Vhkb|cuc|s

Egvdh E 2 Fu 2

Khij|o K 2'Fu 2 2'Fj

\cah \ Fu Fu Fj

Hihvjs H 2'Fu Fu 2'Fj

^kbidm*t Dgit|bi| O 2 Fu6 2

Uhkgdc|s U 2'Fu6 2'Fu 2'Fj

6

Bddhkhvb|cgi B 2'Fu4 2'Fu

6 2'Fj4

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 50/110

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 51/110

ct tb|ctechl) \g vhkhbth |oct hihvjs ge ebkk+ |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl dbxtht |oh egvdh ge jvbuc|s |g bd|guhv |oh lct|bidh ge ebkk)

?)2:! Vh|xvicij |g \bfkh ?)24)2+ c| zckk fh egxil |ob| |oh |vbitegvab|cgi egv uhkgdc|s ct 2'/2!,#6) \oct|vbitegvab|cgi togzt |ob| |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|+ zocdo vhabcit xidobijhl zohi ahbtxvhl kgdbkks+ct vhlxdhl ci |oh bftgkx|h thith b| b vb|h hrxbk |g |oh trxbvh ge |oh vhlxd|cgi zocdo gddxvt ci |ohabtt hrxcubkhi| hihvjs ge |oh ebkkcij gf`hd|) Heehd|cuhks+ |oh ~vgcac|s ge hihvjs aglcecht |oh Bh|obil ~vglxdht b kgdbk vhlxd|cgi ci |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|) /\oh Bh|ohv obt bkvhbls fhhi togzi |g fh|oh xilhvkscij t|vxd|xvh ge t~bdh)# Ci |oct thith+ |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl ct bd|xbkks b uhkgdc|s zhkk eg

kcjo|) \oct uhkgdc|s zhkk+ ci |xvi + bkkgzt bi gf`hd| zc|oci c| |g tohl tgah ge c|t ci|hvibk hihvjs fsagucij |g b kgzhv hkhub|cgi) C| lght |oct fs ~xtocij c|thke lgzizbvl bjbcit| |oh Bh|ohv) \oct ~xtozocdo zh dbiig| lcvhd|ks gfthvuh+ ct |oh ecd|c|cgxt egvdh ge jvbuc|s dxvvhi|ks lhtdvcfhl ci |h|t) Zhdbi giks gfthvuh |oh hrxbk bil g~~gtc|h vhbd|cgi |g |oct ecd|c|cgxt egvdh vhrxcvhl fs Ihz|gi*tThdgil Kbz ge Ag|cgi /egv huhvs bd|cgi |ohvh ct bi hrxbk bil g~~gtc|h vhbd|cgi# bt |oh egvdh gejvbuc|s) \oh Jvbuc|s \vbitegvab|cgi egv Hihvjs vhrxcvht |ob| |oh ebkkcij ~vgdhtt dhbth zohi+ btgfthvuhl zc|o x~~hv hkhub|cgi xic|t ge ahbtxvhahi|+ |oh hihvjs vhkhbthl fs ebkkcij hrxbkt |ohgvcjcibk hihvjs dgi|hi| ge |oh gf`hd|) \oct dhttb|cgi ge ebkkcij lght ci ebd| gddxv bt |oh hil t|b|h gjvbuc|b|cgibk dgi|vbd|cgi bil zckk fh lctdxtthl ci lh|bck kb|hv)

?)2?! \oh vhlxd|cgi ge |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ci b jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl ig| giks ~vglxdht |oh egvdh gejvbuc|s fs bkkgzcij hihvjs dgi|bcihl zc|oci bi gf`hd| |g fh vhkhbthl+ c| vhevbd|t |oh ~b|o ge b vbs gekcjo| /bil bkk vblcb|cgi# ~bttcij |ovgxjo |oh echkl ci |oh tbah abiihv bt |oh tkgzcij ge kcjo| ci bkhit vhevbd|t c|t ~b|o bil bkkgzt sgxv hsht |g egdxt gi |oct thi|hidh) Zohi b ~og|gi ct ci bjvbuc|b|cgibk echkl+ c| h~hvchidht |oh tbah ca~xkth |g vhkhbth c|t hihvjs bt lght ab||hv) Ogzhuhv+xikcmh b ab|hvcbk gf`hd|+ b ~og|gi dbiig| |vbitegva c|t hihvjs ci|g mcih|cd hihvjs bt c|t hkhub|cgi ctkgzhvhl fhdbxth c| axt| bkzbst |vbuhk b| |oh kgdbk uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|) Bt gfthvuhl zc|o x~~hvhkhub|cgi xic|t ge ahbtxvhahi|+ |oh hihvjs /evhrxhids# ge |ob| ~og|gi vhabcit xidobijhl) Btgfthvuhl b| |oh kgzhv hkhub|cgi+ zohvh |oh xic|t ge ahbtxvhahi| egv |cah bvh kbvjhv bil |oh xic|t gahbtxvhahi| egv hihvjs bvh tabkkhv+ c|t evhrxhids bil hihvjs obuh cidvhbthl) Jvbuc|b|cgibkvhevbd|cgi ge |oh ~b|o ge kcjo| ct bddga~bichl fs b jvbuc|b|cgibk egvdh ge b||vbd|cgi) Bt lhvcuhl ci&Jvbuc|s&+ |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk egvdh bd|cij gi ~og|gi ct |zcdh |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk egvdh bd|cij gi bab|hvcbk ~bv|cdkht ge |oh tbah hihvjs) Zob| lght ig| thha |g obuh fhhi vhdgjicphl ct |ob| |oh

jvbuc|b|cgibk b||vbd|cgi ge |oh ~og|git /bil ihx|vcigt# bttgdcb|hl zc|o |oh fbdmjvgxil vblcb|cgikhuhk ge t~bdh dbi hbtcks vh~vhthi| |oh lbvm ab||hv dxvvhi|ks tgxjo| fs bt|vgigahvt bildgtagkgjct|)

?)23! \oh Heehd| ge |oh Jvbuc|b|cgibk Echkl gi |oh Uhkgdc|s ge Kcjo|0! Evga |oh |cah |ob| T~hdcbkVhkb|cuc|s zbt ~xfkctohl xi|ck |oh hbvks 23?>*t+ c| zbt bddh~|hl bt bi bftgkx|h |vx|o |ob| |oh uhkgdc|ge kcjo| ci b ubdxxa zbt b dgit|bi| |ob| zbt xidobijhl fs bis dobijh ci uhkgdc|s gv hkhub|cgivhehvhidh evbah) Bkgij zc|o |oct uchz~gci| zbt |oh clhb |ob| b t|vbcjo| kcih zbt lhecihl fs |oh ~b|oge vbs ge kcjo| fh|zhhi |zg ~gci|t) \oh bx|ogv zbt vb|ohv t|bv|khl |g vhbl ci b fggm hi|c|khl &ZbtHcit|hci Vcjo|7& fs Lv) Zckk |ob| |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| zbt ig kgijhv dgitclhvhl |g fh xidobijhl ci jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl+ fx| zbt vhlxdhl ci ~vg~gv|cgi |g |ob| |ohgvs*t |cah lckb|cgi) Huhi agvh t|bv|kcijzbt |oh ebd| |ob| |oh dobijh ci uchz~gci| zbt ablh fs |oh bdblhacd dgaaxic|s zc|ogx| |oh

tkcjo|ht| hafbvvbttahi| huhi |ogxjo c|t dobijh xilhvacihl |oh ~ockgtg~ocdbk egxilb|cgit ge fg|T~hdcbk bil Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s)

?)6>! \oh dgvvhd| heehd| ge dobijht ci hkhub|cgi gi |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ct ~vguclhl fs |oh Jvbuc|s\vbitegvab|cgi egv Uhkgdc|s ci \bfkh ?)24)2 bt b exid|cgi ge |oh vb|cg fh|zhhi |oh lct|bidh+ V+ |g |ohdhi|hv ge b jvbuc|b|cgibkks b||vbd|cij gf`hd| bil c|t Ogvcpgi Vblcxt+ Vo+ fg|o bt ahbtxvhl zc|o |oh

xic|t ge ahbtxvhahi| hct|cij b| bi ciecic|h vblcxt) \oh lh~bv|xvh ge |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| evga c|tigacibk ubkxh ge D zohi V b~~vgbdoht Vo ct ~vguclhl ci Ecjxvh ?)<) C| zckk fh ig|hl |ob|+ fhdbxth

ge |oh acixt tcji ci |oh |vbitegvab|cgi+ bt |oh vblcxt b~~vgbdoht |oh Ogvcpgi Vblcxt+ |oh uhkgdc|sge kcjo| bfvx~|ks b~~vgbdoht phvg) \oh heehd| ge |oct lvg~ ci |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| dbxtht |oh ~b|o ge vbs ge kcjo| |g fh vhevbd|hl fs |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl egv |oh tbah vhbtgi |ob| |oh khitht ci sgxv hsh

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 52/110

vhevbd| |oh kcjo| |g fvcij |oh cabjh ge |oct |h| |g b egdxt gi |oh vh|cib ge sgxv hsh) \oh uhkgdc|s gekcjo| ct tkgzhl lgzi fs |oh ib|xvh ge |oh t~bdh |ovgxjo zocdo |oh kcjo| ct ~bttcij) \oct dobijh ci|oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ct dgidhbkhl evga b kgdbk gfthvuhv zog+ ge ihdhttc|s+ ahbtxvht |oh uhkgdc|s gekcjo| zc|o xic|t ge ahbtxvhahi| zocdo obuh fhhi bk|hvhl fs |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl)

?)62! Ce gih dgxkl gfthvuh+ evga b lct|bidh+ bi gf`hd| zocdo obt dgkkb~thl |g khtt |obi |zcdh c|tOgvcpgi Vblcxt+ oh zgxkl ecil |ob| |oh heehd|t ge vhevbd|cgi dbxtht c| |g b~~hbv |g obuh b vblcxt ge5):8 |caht |oh Ogvcpgi Vblcxt) \oct gddxvt fhdbxth |oh kcih ge tcjo| evga |oh gfthvuhv |g |ohtxvebdh ge |oh gf`hd| ct vhevbd|hl |gzbvlt |oh gf`hd| bil dbxtht c| |g b~~hbv kbvjhv |obi c| bd|xbkks

ct) \oh heehd| ct togzi ci Ecjxvh ?)8) B os~g|oh|cdbk gfthvuhv gi |oh txvebdh ge |oh gf`hd| zgxkl eci|ob| |oh bijkh fh|zhhi |oh phic|o bil |oh ogvcpgi fhdbah tabkkhv |obi 3> lhjvhht bt |oh gf`hd|dgi|vbd|hl |g b vblcxt tabkkhv |obi |zcdh |oh Ogvcpgi Vblcxt bil fhdbah hrxbk |g phvg zohi |ohgf`hd| obl dgi|vbd|hl |g |oh Ogvcpgi Vblcxt) \oh ~gttcfkh ~b|ot ge vbst ge kcjo| khbucij |oh txvebdge b dgkkb~thl gf`hd| bvh ckkxt|vb|hl ci Ecjxvh ?)5) Txv~vctcijks+ jvbuc|b|cgibk vhevbd|cgi obt ig heehdgi |oh bfckc|s ge |oh gf`hd| |g vblcb|h hihvjs |g t~bdh) Bt |oh gf`hd| dgi|vbd|t+ |oh b~~vgbdo ge |ohogvcpgi |gzbvlt |oh phic|o vhlxdht |oh tgkcl bijkh evga zocdo vblcb|cgi dbi htdb~h evga c|t txvebd|g t~bdh+ fx| |oh heehd| ct hbd|ks dgxi|hvfbkbidhl fs |oh ebd| |ob| |oh txvebdh evga zocdo |ohvblcb|cgi ct heehd|cuhks hac||hl |g t~bdh obt |oh g~|cdbk tcph ge 5):8 |caht |oh Ogvcpgi Vblcxt) Ci|hvat ge |oh bfckc|s ge |oh gf`hd| |g vblcb|h hihvjs |g t~bdh+ vhevbd|cgi abs fh cjigvhl)

?)66! Bt togzi ci &Jvbuc|s&+ |oh tkgzcij ge kcjo| ci b jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl ig| giks vhevbd|t |oh ~b|o gekcjo|+ c| vhevbd|t |oh ~b|ot ge agucij gf`hd|t) \oct vhevbd|cgi ge ~b|o ct ci bllc|cgi |g |oh gvfc|bkheehd|t ge jvbuc|b|cgibk b||vbd|cgi bil ct vht~gitcfkh egv |oh bigabkgxt ~vhdhttcgi ge ~kbih|bvsgvfc|t zocdo tx~~gthlks ~vguh |oh ubkclc|s ge Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s) \oh fbtcd Kbz ge Ag|cgi geIhz|gicbi ^ostcdt zocdo t|b|ht |ob| &bi gf`hd| obucij b uhkgdc|s zckk vh|bci |ob| uhkgdc|s xikhtt c| bd|hl x~gi fs bi gx|tclh egvdh& ct t|ckk |vxh+ ogzhuhv+ |oh uhkgdc|s zocdo gfhst |oct kbz ct |ohuhkgdc|s ge |oh gf`hd| bt ahbtxvhl ci |hvat ge |oh kgdbkks gfthvuhl uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|)

?)64! H~hvcahi|t obuh fhhi ~vg~gthl+ bil abs bkvhbls obuh fhhi ~hvegvahl+ |g ~vguclhbllc|cgibk uhvcecdb|cgi ge Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s) \ohth h~hvcahi|t dgitct| ge ~kbdcij h|vhahksbddxvb|h jsvgtdg~ht ci gvfc| bil gfthvucij |oh ~vhdhttcgi ge |ohcv bht bt b vhtxk| ge |ohcv gvfc|bk

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 53/110

uhkgdc|s) Txdo h~hvcahi|t zckk cilhhl uhvces |ob| jvbuc|s ct b vhkb|cuct|cd ~ohigahib tcidh |ohvhkb|cuct|cd jsvgtdg~cd heehd|t zocdo zckk fh gfthvuhl bvh b lcvhd| dgithrxhidh ge |oh jvbuc|b|cgibkvhevbd|cgi ge |oh uhkgdc|s uhd|gv) \ohs zckk ig| togz |ob| Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s ct |oh dgvvhd| vhkb|cuct|cdjvbuc|b|cgibk |ohgvs)

?)6<! Jvbuc|s vhtxk|t evga |oh ebd| |ob| |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ct tkgzhl fs |oh ~vgcac|s ge hihvjs) \octkgzcij ge |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| vhtxk|t ci |oh dobijht ci |oh tcph ge |oh xic|t ge ahbtxvhahi| ckkxt|vb|hl ci \bfkh :)6)2+ \bfkh :)?)2+ \bfkh ?)3)2+ bil \bfkh ?)24)2)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 54/110

Dob~|hv 3 ! Lv) Hcit|hci*t Hvvgv bil |oh Ci|vglxd|cgi geDxvuhl T~bdh

3)2! Zohvh lcl Lv) Hcit|hci jg zvgij7 ! Tcidh |oh Jhihvbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s schklt vhtxk|t zocdobvh ci dgiekcd| zc|o |oh ~gt|xkb|ht x~gi zocdo c| ct fbthl+ c| ct b~~bvhi| |ob| b| khbt| gih tcjicecdbi|ab|ohab|cdbk hvvgv zbt ablh ci c|t lhvcub|cgi) Ci gvlhv egv |oh hct|hidh bil ib|xvh ge |ob| hvvgv ig|g obuh fhhi vhdgjicphl fs Lv) Hcit|hci bil oct dgi|ha~gvbvcht+ c| axt| fh ge b |s~h zocdo zgxklig| fh gfucgxt |g cilcuclxbkt ge txeecdchi| t|b|xvh bil tdchi|cecd tg~oct|cdb|cgi |g fh ci b ~gtc|cgi |rxht|cgi oct zgvm) C| ct kcmhks |ob| |oh hvvgv zbt vhdgjicphl evga |cah |g |cah fs fvcjo|xilhvjvblxb|ht+ fx| |ohcv gf`hd|cgit zgxkl ig| fh bddh~|hl fs bi bdblhacd ~vcht|oggl lhlcdb|hl|g ~vhthvucij |oh |vxh ebc|o) Rxht|cgit evga txdo tgxvdht zgxkl fh fvxtohl btclh fhdbxthgfucgxtks |ohs dgxkl giks obuh vhtxk|hl evga b kbdm ge xilhvt|bilcij gi |oh ~bv| ge rxht|cgihvtzog zhvh ig| txeecdchi|ks |vbcihl /fvbcizbtohl7# |g xilhvt|bil |oh txf`hd| ab||hv bil zog lcl ig

bt sh| ~gtthtt |oh ~vg~hv *sx~*t)

3)6! Ci lhvcucij |oh Jhihvbk \ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s+ Lv) Hcit|hci ha~kgshl b ab|ohab|cdbk |ggk dbkkhl\hitgv Dbkdxkxt) ^vg~hvks b~~kchl+ |oct |ggk ct h|vhahks xthexk bil igvabkks citxvht |ob| |oh heehdge bkk ~gttcfkh ubvcbfkht bvh dgitclhvhl) C| lght obuh b kcac|b|cgi ogzhuhv+ c| dbiig| fh xthl egvlhvcucij b vhkb|cuct|cd |ohgvs) \hitgv Dbkdxkxt+ ci c|t tca~kht| egva+ ct b ~vgdhtt ci zocdo ~bv|cbklhvcub|cuht ge |oh ubvcbfkht ge ci|hvht| bvh bvvbijhl ci b th| ge tcaxk|bihgxt hrxb|cgit tcackbv |g|ogth hidgxi|hvhl ci dgiuhi|cgibk bkjhfvb) B |s~cdbk jvgx~ ge \hitgv Dbkdxkxt hrxb|cgit ctckkxt|vb|hl fhkgz0

B22/l_#-B26/lS#-B24/lP#1Z2

B62/l_#-B66/lS#-B64/lP#1Z6

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 55/110

B42/l_#-B46/lS#-B44/lP#1Z4

3)4! Ci |oct jvgx~ ge hrxb|cgit+ |oh tsafgkt B22 |ovgxjo B44 bvh dgit|bi|t lh|hvacihl fs |oh

~vgfkha+ |oh tsafgkt _+ S+ bil P bvh |oh ubvcbfkht zogth ubkxh ct |g fh lh|hvacihl+ Z2+ Z6+ bil

Z4 bvh |oh txat ge hbdo ge |oh hrxb|cgit+ bil |oh tsafgk l zc|oci ~bvhi|ohtct cilcdb|ht |ob| |oh

|hva ct b ~bv|cbk lhvcub|cuh) Tgkx|cgi ge hrxb|cgit ge |oct |s~h vhrxcvht b ab|ohab|cdbk ~vgdhlxvhmigzi bt ci|hjvb|cgi) \ohvhci kcht |oh vxf) \g ~hvegva |ob| ci|hjvb|cgi+ c| ct ihdhttbvs |g migz |ob||oh dgheecdchi|t /hj0! B22 |ovgxjo B44# ge |oh ~bv|cbk lhvcub|cuht bvh cilh~hilhi| ge |oh ubvcbfkht)

\g xilhvt|bil zos+ dgitclhv |oh xth ge |oh vxkht ge Hkhahi|bvs Dbkdxkxt |g ci|hjvb|h |ohh~vhttcgi M/l_#) Ce M ct cilh~hilhi| ge |oh ubkxh ge _+ |oh vhtxk| ge |oh ci|hjvb|cgi ct M_-D&+

zohvh D& ct |oh dgit|bi| ge ci|hjvb|cgi) Ogzhuhv+ ce M ct hrxbk |g _+ |oh vhtxk| ct _6'6-D&+ bihi|cvhks lceehvhi| vhtxk|) B fbtcd vxkh ge bkk |s~ht ge Dbkdxkxt+ cidkxlcij \hitgv Dbkdxkxt+ ct |ob| |ohubvcbfkh |g fh ci|hjvb|hl axt| fh dga~kh|hks lhecihl ci |oh h~vhttcgi c|thke bil ig| fh ocllhizc|oci g|ohv |hvat+ ci |oct dbth+ M)

3)<! C| ct fhdbxth |oh tgkx|cgi ge b ~vgfkha ci \hitgv Dbkdxkxt vhrxcvht |oh ~hvegvabidh geab|ohab|cdbk ci|hjvb|cgi |ob| \hitgv Dbkdxkxt ct xitxc|bfkh egv |oh lhvcub|cgi ge b vhkb|cuct|cd|ohgvs) \oh ~bv|cbk lhvcub|cuht ci |oh \hitgv Dbkdxkxt ab|vc xthl |g lhvcuh |oh Jhihvbk \ohgvs geVhkb|cuc|s ciugkuh khij|o) C| obt fhhi lhagit|vb|hl |ob| |oh xic|t ge ahbtxvhahi| ge khij|o dobijhfh|zhhi vhehvhidh evbaht zocdo lceehv ci uhkgdc|s) Tcidh |oh lhvcub|cgi ge Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s ctfbthl x~gi |oh ^vcidc~kh ge Hrxcubkhidh+ c| egkkgzt |ob| |oh heehd| ge b dobijh ci hkhub|cgi gi |ohxic|t ge ahbtxvhahi| egv khij|o axt| fh migzi ci gvlhv egv b ahbicijexk+ ab|ohab|cdbkks ubkcl+ci|hjvb|cgi |g fh ~hvegvahl) /\oh tcph ge |oh xic|t ge ahbtxvhahi| bvh bibkgjgxt |g |oh &tcph& ge Mci |oh ~vhucgxt ~bvbjvb~o)# Xiegv|xib|hks+ |oh heehd| ge b dobijh ci hkhub|cgi gi |oh xic|t geahbtxvhahi| egv khij|o dbiig| fh migzi xi|ck |oh ci|hjvb|cgi obt fhhi ~hvegvahl dgvvhd|ks bil bubkcl ci|hjvb|cgi dbiig| fh ~hvegvahl xi|ck |oh heehd|t ge b dobijh ci hkhub|cgi gi |oh xic|t geahbtxvhahi| egv khij|o bvh migzi) Dgithrxhi|ks b ubkcl lhvcub|cgi ge jvbuc|b|cgibk |ohgvs ct ig|~gttcfkh fs |oct ah|ogl) Zohi |oh b||ha~| ct ablh+ c| bvfc|vbvcks egvdht |oh Jvbuc|s \vbitegvab|cgiegv Khij|o |g hrxbk xic|s vhjbvlkhtt ge c|t dgvvhd| ubkxh) Xi|ck |oh \hitgv Dbkdxkxt hrxb|cgit obuhfhhi tgkuhl+ |oh vhrxcvhl ciegvab|cgi ihhlhl |g tgkuh |oha ct ig| bubckbfkh) C| ct lceecdxk| |gxilhvt|bil+ ogzhuhv+ zos Lv) Hcit|hci lcl ig| vhdgjicph |ob|+ ci ha~kgscij \hitgv Dbkdxkxt |g

lhvcuh Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s+ oh zbt cidgv~gvb|cij bi hvvgihgxt kgg~ ge dcvdxkbv vhbtgicij)Ce bi xilhvjvblxb|h t|xlhi| ge hkhahi|bvs dbkdxkxt ~hvtct|hi|ks ablh bi hrxcubkhi| hvvgv oh zgxkl vhdhcuh b ebckcij jvblh egv |oh dgxvth)

3)8! Lv) Hcit|hci*t ab|ohab|cdbk hvvgv ablh c| ca~gttcfkh |g bdochuh b tgkx|cgi ge |oh JhihvbkVhkb|cuc|s \hitgv ci b abiihv zocdo ct dgitct|hi| zc|o Hxdkclcbi jhgah|vs) Oh ct vh~gv|hl |g obuht|vxjjkhl zc|o |oct lceecdxk|s egv bfgx| 2? agi|ot bil ecibkks vhtgkuhl oct ca~btth* fs bllcijbig|ohv+ g|ohvzcth tx~hvekxgxt+ lhjvhh ge evhhlga) Oh lcl |oct fs cidgv~gvb|cij |oh dxvuhl t~bdhlhtdvcfhl fs Vchabii Jhgah|vs) \oct bllc|cgi ~hvac||hl |oh ab|ohab|cdbk hrxb|cgit |g fh tgkuhlfx| |oh vhtxk|t zhvh dkhbvks ig| vcjgvgxtks dgvvhd| tcidh+ bt \bfkh ?)3)2 togzt+ |oh vhtxk|bi| Jhihv\ohgvs ge Vhkb|cuc|s dkhbvks ucgkb|ht |oh ^vcidc~kht ge Vhkb|cuc|s bil Hrxcubkhidh x~gi zocdo c| ctfbthl) Xiegv|xib|hks+ |oh ebd| |ob| jvbuc|s ct b vhkb|cuct|cd ~ohigahib citxvhl |ob| Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc

dgi|bcihl higxjo |vx|o |g hibfkh c| |g jbci bddh~|bidh fs vhecicij |oh ~vhlcd|cgit ge Ihz|gicbiJvbuc|b|cgibk \ohgvs |g bjvhh zc|o |oh gfthvuhl bigabkgxt ~vhdhttcgi ge Ahvdxvs*t gvfc|+ |ohgfthvuhl vhl toce| ge Tgkbv t~hd|vbk kciht+ bil |oh fhilcij ge |oh ~b|o ge t|bvkcjo| fs |oh Txi*tjvbuc|b|cgibk echkl |g zc|oci |oh kcac|t ge gfthvub|cgibk hvvgv)

3)5! Lxvcij |oh Tgkbv hdkc~th ge 2323 zohi |oh fhilcij ge |oh ~b|o ge t|bvkcjo| fs |oh Txi*tjvbuc|b|cgibk echkl ~vhlcd|hl fs Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s zbt uhvcechl+ Lv) Hcit|hci*t dgieclhidh ci |ohgx|dgah txv~vcthl abis ge oct dgi|ha~gvbvcht) Ci h~vhttcij |oct dgieclhidh+ oh zbt gi tbehjvgxil) Oh mihz |ob| jvbuc|b|cgi zbt b vhkb|cuct|cd ~ohigahib bil |ob| c| lcli*| ab||hv zoh|ohvJhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s zbt vcjgvgxt) \oh ebd| |ob| Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s ablh c|t ~vhlcd|cgit fbthl x~givhkb|cuct|cd heehd|t citxvhl |ob| bis vhtclxbk hvvgv zgxkl fh bfgx| b ackkcgi |caht |gg tabkk |g fh

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 56/110

vhuhbkhl ci |oh Txi*t ~xis jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl) \ohvh ct b txjjht|cgi |ob| Lv) Hcit|hci vhdgjicphl |oJhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s zbt ig| vcjgvgxt tcidh oh ct vh~gv|hl |g obuh h~vhtthl actjcucijt bt |g c|tb~~kcdb|cgi |g |oh t|vgij echklt txdo bt hct| bvgxil ihx|vgi t|bvt) \oh rxht|cgi |ob| dbi ihuhv fhbitzhvhl ct zoh|ohv Lv) Hcit|hci fhkchuhl |ob| |oh dxvuhl t~bdh tgkx|cgi ge Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s zbtubkcl+ gv zoh|ohv oh hijbjhl ci tdchi|cecd ebmhvs zc|o |oh dgieclhidh |ob| c| dgxkl ig| fh xiabtmhlGih axt| vhahafhv |oh dgaahi| ablh ci b ahh|cij ci zocdo Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s zbt hubkxb|hl+&zos togxkli*| zh dgitclhv t~bdh |g fh dxvuhl+ igfgls dbi ~vguh |ob| c| cti*|&) \oh bx|ogv ecilt c|lceecdxk| |g lceehvhi|cb|h Lv) Hcit|hci*t xth ge dxvuhl t~bdh |g bkkgz oca |g dga~kh|h oct lhvcub|cgi gJhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s evga |oh bd|cgit ge b ahdobicd zog cit|bkkt |oh zvgij ~bv| ci|g b abdocih fs

obaahvcij c| ci|g ~kbdh)

3):! \oh Ahbicij ge Dxvuhl T~bdh0!\oh agt| tcjicecdbi| ~vg~hv|s ge |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl ct ig|vhuhbkhl ci |oh heehd|t vh~vhthi|hl fs |oh ~vhdhttcgi ge gvfc|t+ |oh |cah lckb|cgi+ gv |oh fhilcij ge|oh ~b|o ge b vbs ge kcjo| bt c| ~bttht |oh Txi) \ohth bvh thdgil gvlhv heehd|t) \oh giks ecvt| gvlhvheehd| ge |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl ct |s~cechl fs |oh egvdh zocdo ogklt sgx |g sgxv dobcv bt sgx vhbl |othi|hidh bil |oh hihvjs ge ebkk zocdo sgx zckk h~hvchidh ce sgx ebkk evga |oh dobcv) \oct egvdh+ bil|oh hihvjs ge ebkk c| ca~kcht+ ct |oh ~vcabvs vhbkc|s ge |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl) \ohvh ct ig zbs ci/h~kh|cuh lhkh|hl# |ob| b dxvub|xvh ge t~bdh dbi bddgxi| egv |ob| egvdh bil |ob| hihvjs zc|ogx| |oh~vhthidh ge bi b||vbd|cuh jvbuc|b|cgibk egvdh) C| ct cvvht~gitcfkh |g btthv|+ bt ~vg~gihi|t ge JhihvbkVhkb|cuc|s axt|+ |ob| &|oh b~~bvhi| bfckc|s ge |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl |g dvhb|h hihvjs evgaig|ocijihtt lght ig| dgit|c|x|h b ucgkb|cgi ge |oh Kbz ge Dgithvub|cgi ge Hihvjs fhdbxth |ohhihvjs zocdo ct dvhb|hl dbiig| dkcaf gx| ge |oh echkl&) Bis ~vg~hv jvbuc|b|cgibk |ohgvs axt| h~kbc|oh vhbtgi egv |oh egvdh zocdo ogklt sgx |g sgxv dobcv bil |oh tgxvdh ge |oh hihvjs zocdo ctvhkhbthl zohi sgx ebkk ci b abiihv zocdo ct dgitct|hi| zc|o |oh vhrxcvhahi| |ob| hihvjs fhdgithvuhl) \oh bx|ogv zbt gidh vhacilhl fs b ~ostcdct| |ob| tgah |h|t btthv| |ob| JhihvbkVhkb|cuc|s obt hkcacib|hl jvbuc|s bt b egvdh) Egv tgah vhbtgi |ob| ~ostcdct| fhdbah t|vbijhks tckhizohi c| zbt txjjht|hl |ob| oh t|h~ |ovgxjo bi bl`bdhi| thdgil t|gvs zcilgz tg |ob| zh dgxkllctdxtt |oh txf`hd| bdvgtt |oh zcilgz tckk)

3)?! Xilhv Ihz|gicbi \ohgvs+ jvbuc|s ct bi b||vbd|cuh egvdh bd|cij fh|zhhi |zg dgidhi|vb|cgit gehihvjs /abttht#+ H2 bil H6+ ci ciuhvth ~vg~gv|cgi |g |oh trxbvh ge |ohcv th~bvb|cgi+ V+ ci

bddgvlbidh zc|o E1LH2H6'V6) \oh |ohgvs abmht ig b||ha~| |g h~kbci |oh tgxvdh ge |ob| egvdh

bil |oh hihvjs c| vh~vhthi|t) Tcidh c| ct b lhtdvc~|cuh kbz lhvcuhl thuhvbk dhi|xvcht fhegvh |oh Kbzge Dgithvub|cgi ge Hihvjs zbt vhdgjicphl+ |ohvh ct ig ihhl egv c| |g b~gkgjcph egv |ob| gacttcgixikhtt+ ge dgxvth+ gih ci|hilt |g vh|bci c| bt |oh |ohgvs zocdo vh~vhthi|t vhbkc|s) C|t dgidkxtcgi |ob|oh egvdh ge b||vbd|cgi fh|zhhi gf`hd|t ubvcht ciuhvthks zc|o |oh trxbvh ge |ohcv th~bvb|cgivhbtgibfks egkkgzt evga |oh ebd| |ob| |oh bvhb ge b t~ohvcdbk txvebdh ubvcht bt |oh trxbvh c|t vblcxtJhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s+ gi |oh g|ohv obil+ lght ig| obuh |oh kxxvs ge cjigvcij |oh tgxvdh gejvbuc|b|cgibk egvdh bil jvbuc|b|cgibk hihvjs tcidh c| dkbcat |g vh~vhthi| vhbkc|s bil zbt lhvcuhl b| b|cah zohi |oh Kbz ge Dgithvub|cgi ge Hihvjs zbt zhkk ht|bfkctohl)

3)3! B| ecvt| jkbidh+ |oh igi!Hxdkclcbi jhgah|vs ge Vchabii zocdo zbt xthl fs Lv) Hcit|hci ciegvaxkb|cij Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s b~~hbvt tg~oct|cdb|hl) Zohi gih hbaciht Lv) Vchabii*t jhgah|vs

ci lh|bck+ oh ecilt |ob| c| ct b txfth| ge dgiuhi|cgibk Hxdkclcbi jhgah|vs ci zocdo b igi!Hxdkclcbijhgah|vs ge |ovhh t~b|cbk lcahitcgit ct xthl |g lhtdvcfh |oh ~vg~hv|cht ge b &txvebdh& zocdo dbi fdgitclhvhl |g fh dgi|bcihl ci b Hxdkclcbi jhgah|vs ge egxv t~b|cbk lcahitcgit) Bt |oh bx|ogv~gci|hl gx| ci &Jvbuc|s&+ bis igi!Hxdkclcbi jhgah|vs ge I t~b|cbk lcahitcgit dbi fh dgi|bcihl ci bHxdkclcbi Jhgah|vs ge I-2 t~b|cbk lcahitcgit) /Bi hba~kh ge igi!Hxdkclcbi jhgah|vs bt btxfth| ge Hxdkclcbi Jhgah|vs ct |oh |zg lcahitcgibk igi!Hxdkclcbi jhgah|vs zocdo lhtdvcfht |ohtxvebdh ge gxv |ovhh lcahitcgibk Hxdkclcbi Hbv|o#)

3)2>! Egv b vhbtgibfkh bil dgitdchi|cgxt abi |g bddh~| |oh dgidh~| |ob| jvbuc|s vhtxk|t evga |ohlct|gv|cgi ge gxv ebackcbv |ovhh lcahitcgibk Hxdkclcbi t~bdh ci|g b egxv lcahitcgibk igi!Hxdkclcbit~bdh+ oh axt| fh ~vguclhl zc|o b vhbtgibfkh lhtdvc~|cgi ge |oh ib|xvh ge |ob| lct|gv|cgi bt c|b~~hbvt ci |oh egxv lcahitcgibk Hxdkclcbi t~bdh) \oh dkgtht| b~~vgbdo |g txdo b lhtdvc~|cgi thha

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 57/110

|g fh t~hdxkb|cgi bt |g zoh|ohv gxv |ovhh lcahitcgibk t~bdh ct ~gtc|cuhks dxvuhl+ bt ct b t~ohvh+ gzoh|ohv c| ct ihjb|cuhks dxvuhl+ bt ct b tbllkh) C| ct dgaagiks btthv|hl |ob| ce gxv gfthvubfkh |ovhhlcahitcgibk t~bdh ct ~gtc|cuhks dxvuhl+ c| hidkgtht b egxv lcahitcgibk t~bdh ge ecic|h ugkxah+ zockce c|t dxvub|xvh ct ihjb|cuh+ |oh ugkxah ge |oh egxv lcahitcgibk t~bdh hidkgthl ct ciecic|h) Bd|xbkks+dgaagi thith xilhvt|bilcij ge |oh dgidh~| hbtcks vhuhbkt |ob| |ohvh ct ig dgiihd|cgi fh|zhhizoh|ohv |oh egxv lcahitcgibk t~bdh ct hidkgthl fs |oh |ovhh lcahitcgibk txvebdh bil |ohvhegvh obb ecic|h ugkxah bil zoh|ohv |oh dxvub|xvh ge |oh |ovhh lcahitcgibk t~bdh ct ~gtc|cuh gv ihjb|cuh) Bbi hba~kh+ |oh |zg lcahitcgibk igi!Hxdkclcbi txvebdh bibkgjgxt |g |oh vhekhd|gv ge bi bx|gagfckohblkcjo| ct ~gtc|cuhks dxvuhl fx| |oh ugkxah ge |oh |ovhh lcahitcgibk t~bdh c| hidkgtht ct ciecic|h

Gi |oh g|ohv obil+ |oh |zg lcahitcgibk igi!Hxdkclcbi txvebdh vh~vhthi|hl fs |oh ciihv ~gv|cgi gebi bx|gagfckh ciihv |xfh ct ihjb|cuhks dxvuhl+ fx| c| hidkgtht b ecic|h ugkxah) \oh ebd|gv zocdolh|hvaciht zoh|ohv |oh jhgah|vs ge |oh txvebdh dgi|bcit bi ciecic|h gv b ecic|h ugkxah ct lh|hvacihig| fs |oh ~gkbvc|s ge c|t dxvub|xvh fx| fs zoh|ohv |oh dxvub|xvh bkgij hbdo ge c|t bht ct jvhb|hv gkhtt |obi |oh dxvub|xvh ge b ~bvbfgkb) Egv tgah xih~kbcihl vhbtgi |ohth tbah ab|ohab|cdbk~ostcdct|t bttxah |ob| zoh|ohv gv ig| gxv Xicuhvth vhuhvtht c|t h~bitcgi bil dgkkb~tht ci x~gic|thke |g ~vglxdh b dgtacd dvxido ct lh|hvacihl fs zoh|ohv t~bdh ct ~gtc|cuhks gv ihjb|cuhksdxvuhl) \oh zgvl *bttxah* ~vguclht ubkxbfkh blucdh) Lcuclhl ci|g tskkbfkht+ c| ct b vhacilhv |ob|zohi sgx bttxah+ sgx vxi |oh vctm ge abmcij bi *btt* ge *sgx* bil *ah*)

3)22! Ci |hvat ge Ihz|gicbi \ohgvs+ jvbuc|s ct b vb|ohv t|vbcjo|egvzbvl ~ohigahib) Bt Ecjxvh 3)2ckkxt|vb|ht+ bi gf`hd| txt~hilhl bfguh b dhi|vbk jvbuc|b|cgibk abtt bil obucij ig gvfc|bk uhkgdc|sh~hvchidht b egvdh ca~hkkcij c| |gzbvlt |ob| abtt) \oct ct |oh egvdh sgx ehhk b~~kchl |g |oh thb| gesgxv ~bi|t bt sgx tc| ci sgxv dobcv) Xilhv Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s+ bt ckkxt|vb|hl ci Ecjxvh 3)6+ bi gf`hd|txt~hilhl bfguh b dhi|vbk jvbuc|b|cgibk abtt bil obucij ig gvfc|bk uhkgdc|s h~hvchidht |oh tbahb||vbd|cuh egvdh) Ogzhuhv+ |ob| egvdh ct ge higvagxt abjic|xlh+ ct ciuhvthks ~vg~gv|cgibk |g |oh tcpge |oh dhi|vbk abtt+ bil bd|t ci b lcvhd|cgi b| vcjo| bijkht |g gxv gfthvubfkh |ovhh t~b|cbklcahitcgit) \oh egvdh ogklcij sgx |g sgxv dobcv ct |oh dga~gihi| ge |ob| higvagxt b||vbd|cuh egvdzocdo ct gfthvubfkh ci gxv |ovhh lcahitcgibk t~bdh bt b vhtxk| ge c|t lct|gv|cgi ci|g |oh egxv|ot~b|cbk bct) Xilhv Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s+ |oh bd|xbk jvbuc|b|cgibk egvdh zocdo ~vglxdht |oh gfthvubfkh

egvdh dga~gihi| ogklcij sgx |g sgxv dobcv ct gi |oh gvlhv ge 62? |git) Xilhv fg|o Ihz|gicbi\ohgvs bil Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s+ jvbuc|s ct bi b||vbd|cuh egvdh bd|cij b| b lct|bidh) \oh lceehvhidhfh|zhhi |oh |zg dgidh~|t ct |ob|+ xilhv Ihz|gicbi \ohgvs+ jvbuc|s ct bi b||vbd|cuh egvdh bd|cij

|gzbvlt |oh dhi|vbk abtt vht~gitcfkh egv |oh echkl+ zockh Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s btthv|t |ob| |oh~vhthidh ge b dhi|vbk abtt dvhb|ht bi higvagxt b||vbd|cuh egvdh bkcjihl zc|o bi xigfthvubfkhegxv|o t~b|cbk bct bil tcaxk|bihgxtks lct|gv|t gxv ebackcbv |ovhh lcahitcgibk ekb| t~bdh |gzbvlt|ob| bct |g bkkgz b dga~gihi| ge |ob| higvagxt egvdh |g b~~hbv bt |oh egvdh ge jvbuc|s) JhihvbkVhkb|cuc|s lght ig| hkcacib|h jvbuc|s bt b egvdh+ c| dgiuhv|t c| ci|g bi cidvhlcfks kbvjh egvdh bd|cijbkgij bi xigfthvubfkh egxv|o t~b|cbk bct |gzbvlt b tgxvdh zocdo lght ig| thha |g obuh b ~ostcdhct|hidh bil zocdo ~vglxdht ciecic|h hihvjs evga ig|ocijihtt) Dgah gi ehkkgzt+ jcuh xt b fvhbm

3)26! \oh giks vhbtgi egv dgitclhvcij |ob| t~bdh ct dxvuhl fs |oh ~vhthidh ge abtt ci|g b egxv|ot~b|cbk bct bil |oh hct|hidh ge |ob| higvagxt b||vbd|cuh egvdh bd|cij bkgij |ob| bct ct |ob|ab|ohab|cdbk hvvgv ablh fs Lv) Hcit|hci ci lhvcucij Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s) \oh dgidh~| ge dxvuhl t~bdobt txvucuhl fhdbxth ge |oh heehd|cuhihtt ge |oh lhehilhvt ge |oh ebc|o ci tx~~vhttcij |ohrxht|cgicij fs ohvh|cdt zog zgxkl lbvh |g dobkkhijh |oh vhuhbkhl |vx|o) Kb|hks+ ogzhuhv+ |ohvhthhat |g tgah ohljcij gi |oh rxht|cgi ge zoh|ohv t~bdh ct dxvuhl bagij thicgv ahafhvt ge |ohbdblhacd dgaaxic|s) Egv hba~kh+ ci b vhdhi|ks ~xfkctohl fggm+ b vht~hd|hl bx|ogvc|s ci |oh echkl/zog obl vhdhcuhl b dg~s ge &Jvbuc|s& ci 23??# t|b|ht |ob| |ohvh ct ig lceehvhidh ci |oh vhtxk|tgf|bcihl zohi gih dgitclhvt t~bdh |g fh dxvuhl fs |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl bil zohi gih dgitclhvkhij|ot |g tovcim bt hkhub|cgi ct kgzhvhl)) /Ihhlkhtt |g tbs+ |oh bx|ogv |bmht cttxh zc|o |ob|btthv|cgi)# Vhahafhv+ bt ahi|cgihl hbvkchv+ c| obt fhhi lhagit|vb|hl ci &Jvbuc|s& |ob|+ ce t~bdh ctdxvuhl+ c| ct ~gttcfkh+ ci ~vcidc~kh+ |g fxckl b ~hv~h|xbk ag|cgi abdocih ge |oh ecvt| mcil) \ob|abdocih zgxkl fh db~bfkh ge h~gv|cij hihvjs egvhuhv zc|ogx| bis dobijh ci c|t ci|hvibkks gvh|hvibkks gfthvuhl t|b|ht) Bjbci+ ce bis vhblhv fhkchuht |ob| txdo b abdocih ct ~gttcfkh+ |ohvh ct bfvcljh |ob| |oh bx|ogv obt fhhi |vscij |g thkk)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 58/110

3)24! \oh bx|ogv*t dgi|hi|cgi ci &Jvbuc|s& /23??# |ob| bis igi!Hxdkclcbi jhgah|vs ge I lcahitcgitdbi fh dgi|bcihl ci b Hxdkclcbi jhgah|vs ge I-2 lcahitcgit gv ocjohv thhat |g obuh fhhibddh~|bfkh |g |oh bdblhacd dgaaxic|s tcidh c| obt txfthrxhi|ks b~~hbvhl ci fggmt zvc||hi fs b|khbt| |zg cilcuclxbkt zog obuh vhdhcuhl dg~cht ge |ob| |h|+ bk|ogxjo gih ge |ohth cilcuclxbkt

btthv|hl |ob| b Hxdkclcbi jhgah|vs ge I-4 lcahitcgit zbt vhrxcvhl) C| ct lhtcvhbfkh+ |ohvhegvh+ |gvh!hbacih |oh jhgah|vs ge Vchabii)

\oh ~vcabvs lceehvhidh fh|zhhi |oh bcgat ge Vchabii jhgah|vs bil Hxdkclcbi jhgah|vs ct|ob| Vchabii*t jhgah|vs lght ig| vhrxcvh |ob| ~bvbkkhk kciht ihuhv ahh| zockh Hxdkclcbijhgah|vs lght obuh |ob| vhrxcvhahi|) \oh zvc|hv xilhvt|bilt |ob| fg|o jhgah|vcht lhecih bt|vbcjo| kcih bt |oh togv|ht| lct|bidh fh|zhhi |zg ~gci|t)

r

Tcidh |oh igi!Hxdkclcbi jhgah|vs ge I lcahitcgit dbi fh dgi|bcihl zc|oci b Hxdkclcbijhgah|vs ge I-2 /gv I-4# lcahitcgit+ |oh togv|ht| lct|bidh fh|zhhi |zg ~gci|t lght ig| kzc|oci |oh igi!Hxdkclcbi jhgah|vs) k| khbuht |ob| jhgah|vs fh|zhhi |oh |zg ~gci|t bil |vbuhk|ovgxjo |oh Hxdkclcbi jhgah|vs ge I-2 /gv I-4# lcahitcgit) /\g ckkxt|vb|h+ ce gih dgitclhvt|oh txvebdh ge |oh Hbv|o |g vh~vhthi| b |zg lcahitcgibk igi!Hxdkclhbi jhgah|vs+ |oh togv|ht

r

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 59/110

lct|bidh fh|zhhi Ihz Sgvm bil Kgt Bijkhtht ct ig| b jvhb| dcvdkh+ c| ct |ovgxjo b |xiihk zocd~bttht bkagt| |zg oxilvhl ackht fhihb|o |oh Acttcttc~~c Vcuhv)#

\oh t|vbcjo| kcih ge igi!Hxdkclbi jhgah|vs ct |oh togv|ht| lct|bidh fh|zhhi |zg ~gci|t zocdovhabcit zc|oci |oh igi!Hxdkclcbi jhgah|vs /h)j)! |oh jvhb| dcvdkh ~b|o fh|zhhi Ihz Sgvm bilKgt Bijhkht)# Tcidh |oh t|vbcjo| kcih ge igi!Hxdkclcbi jhgah|vs lght ig| ahh| |oh vcjgvgxtlhecic|cgi ge b t|vbcjo| kcih+ c| thhat vhbtgibfkh |g rxht|cgi |oh vcjgv ge igi!Hxdkclhbijhgah|vs hdh~| bt b dgiuhichi| ahbit ge lhtdvcfcij |oh ~vg~hv|cht ge b dxvuhl &txvebdh&dgi|bcihl zc|oci b &ugkxah& lhecihl fs Hxdkclcbi jhgah|vs)

r

\oh bx|ogv btthv|t |ob| b vcjgvgxt |ohgvs togxkl ig| fh fbthl x~gi Vchabiicbi jhgah|vs zc|ogx| bi blhrxb|h bil vhkbuhi| |vhb|ahi| ge |oh ocjohv gvlhv Hxdkclcbi jhgah|vs c| ca~kcht)

r

3)28! \oh clhb |ob| b Hxdkclcbi jhgah|vs ge b| khbt| tc t~b|cbk lcahitcgit /I-4# zbt vhrxcvhl |gdgi|bci b |ovhh lcahitcgibk igi!Hxdkclcbi jhgah|vs ct tx~~gv|hl fs |oh btthv|cgi |ob| hbdo ~kbihci b |ovhh lcahitcgibk igi!Hxdkclhbi t~bdh+ /_!S#+ /_!P#+ bil /S!P#+ vhrxcvht b th~bvb|h lhjvhh evhhlga ci |oh ocjohv gvlhv t~bdh) \oh vhrxcvhahi| egv |oh bllc|cgibk lcahitcgit /I-4# zgxkl fhvhbtgibfkh ce gih dgitclhvhl |oh |ovhh ~kbiht |g fh cilh~hilhi|) Ogzhuhv+ |ohth ~kbiht bvh ig|cilh~hilhi|+ |ohs bvh ci|hvkgdmhl ci|g |oh |ovhh lcahitcgibk igi!Hxdkclhbi t~bdh bt b xic|)Dgitclhv |ovhh lcahitcgibk Hxdkclhbi t~bdh |g fh dga~gthl ge b thvcht ge /_!S#c ~kbiht+ /_!P#` 

~kbiht bil /S!P#m ~kbiht /zohvh c+ `+ bil m bvh ci|hjhvt fh|zhhi gih bil ciecic|s) \ohth ~kbihtahh| b| uhv|cdht &c`m&) Ce |oh |ovhh lcahitcgibk Hxdkclhbi t~bdh ct dxvuhl ci|g b igi!Hxdkclhbit~bdh bfgx| bis gv bkk ge c|t ~vcidc~kh bht+ |oh uhv|cdht ge |oh ~kbiht axt| vhabci dgcidclhi|+ ~gci&c`m& axt| vhabci ~gci| &c`m&) Bt b vhtxk|+ c| thhat vhbtgibfkh |g dgidkxlh |ob| giks gih h|vblhjvhh ge evhhlga ct vhrxcvhl bil |oh |ovhh lcahitcgibk igi!Hxdkclhbi jhgah|vs abs fh ubkclksdgitclhvhl bt b os~hv~kbih dgi|bcihl ci b egxv lcahitcgibk Hxdkclhbi jhgah|vs)

3)25! Zoh|ohv |oh zvc|hv*t btthv|cgi |ob| b Hxdkclcbi t~bdh ge /I-2# lcahitcgit ct blhrxb|h |gdgi|bci b |ovhh lcahtcgibk igi!Hxdkclcbi t~bdh dgvvhd| ct xica~gv|bi|) C| ct vcjgvgxtks togzi ci&Jvbuc|s& |ob| gxv xicuhvth ct b |ovhh lcahitcgibk Hxdkclcbi t~bdh) \oh dxvub|xvh ge |ob| t~bdh |obct dxvvhi|ks bddh~|hl bt vh~vhthi|cij vhbkc|s vhtxk|t evga Lv) Hcit|hci*t b||ha~| |g guhvdgah |oh

hvvgv ci|vglxdhl fs oct actxth ge \hitgv Dbkdxkxt ci |oh lhvcub|cgi ge Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s)

Dob~|hv 2> ! Jvbuc|b|cgibk Dgi|vbd|cgi bil Dgkkb~th

2>)2! \oh Egvab|cgi ge b Jvbuc|b|cgibk Gf`hd|0! Dgaagi h~hvchidh vhuhbkt |ob| bi bddxaxkb|cgi gab||hv dvhb|ht b jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl zocdo b||ha~|t |g dga~bd| |ob| ab||hv ci|g b ab|ohab|cdbk ~gciZh h~hvchidh |ob| echkl bt b egvdh zocdo ca~hkt xt |gzbvlt |oh dhi|hv ge |oh Hbv|o bil zgxkl ebkk |ob| dhi|hv ce c| zhvh ig| egv |oh ab|hvcbk ge zocdo |oh Hbv|o ct dga~gthl) Hbdo kbshv ge |ob| ab|hvcb

ct b||vbd|hl |gzbvlt |oh dhi|hv bil ct tx~~gv|hl fs cidvhbthl ~vhttxvh ci |oh xilhvkscij kbshvt xi|oh ~vhttxvh abcaxa ct vhbdohl b| |oh Hbv|o*t dhi|hv)

2>)6! Egv bi gf`hd| |oh tcph ge |oh Hbv|o+ igvabk ab||hv ct bfkh |g zc|ot|bil |oh jvbuc|b|cgibkkscilxdhl ~vhttxvh bil ig|ocij lvbab|cd gddxvt) Egv kbvjhv gf`hd|t+ jvbuc|b|cgibk dga~vhttcgi ctagvh dga~kcdb|hl) \s~cdbkks+ txdo gf`hd|t obuh |oh tbah dga~gtc|cgi bt |oh ci|hvt|hkkbv jbtht/33( oslvgjhi bil ohkcxa# evga zocdo |ohs zhvh egvahl) Bt |oh gf`hd| dgi|vbd|t+ c|t jbtht bvhdga~vhtthl bil |oh |ha~hvb|xvh b| c|t dhi|hv cidvhbtht lxh |g |oh |ha~hvb|xvh vcth ge blcbfb|cddga~vhttcgi) /Blcbfb|cd |ha~hvb|xvh vcth ct |oh ~ohigahib zocdo dbxtht |oh |ha~hvb|xvh ge |ohHbv|o*t b|agt~ohvh |g lhdvhbtht zc|o cidvhbtcij bk|c|xlh bil dbxtht |oh txvebdh ge Uhixt |g fh oghigxjo |g ahk| khbl)# Ce |oh abtt ge txdo bi gf`hd| ct agvh |obi 2> |caht |ob| ge @x~c|hv+ blcbfb|cd|ha~hvb|xvh vcth bil jvbuc|b|cgibkks cilxdhl ~vhttxvh dbxth |oh |ha~hvb|xvh bil ~vhttxvh b| c|t

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 60/110

dhi|hv |g vhbdo b khuhk zohvh oslvgjhi extht |g egva ohkcxa) \oct extcgi vhkhbtht kbvjh bagxi|t ghihvjs bil vbctht |oh |ha~hvb|xvh+ bil |ohvhegvh |oh jbthgxt ~vhttxvh+ b| |oh dgvh |g |oh ~gci|zohvh c| ct db~bfkh ge vhtct|cij jvbuc|b|cgibk ~vhttxvh bil |oh dgi|vbd|cgi t|g~t) \oh gf`hd| obt|ohi fhdgah b t|bv ci zocdo extcgi hihvjs vhkhbthl b| |oh dgvh ~vglxdht |oh |ha~hvb|xvh ihhlhl bkkgz jbthgxt ~vhttxvh |g fbkbidh jvbuc|b|cgibk ~vhttxvh) Tcaxk|bihgxtks+ hihvjs ekgzt evga |ohog| dgvh |g c|t txvebdh+ ct vblcb|hl |g t~bdh+ bil axt| fh vh~kbdhl fs |oh extcgi ge agvh oslvgjhi)

2>)4! Huhi|xbkks+ higxjo oslvgjhi obt exthl |g ohkcxa |g abmh |oh oslvgjhi fxvicij ~vgdhttciheehd|cuh bil |oh dgvh dgi|vbd|t |g vhkhbth jvbuc|b|cgibk hihvjs |g vh~kbdh |oh hihvjs ekgz ig

kgijhv ~vguclhl fs oslvgjhi fxvicij) Dgvh dgi|vbd|cgi dgi|cixht xi|ck b |ha~hvb|xvh bil ~vhttxvct vhbdohl zohvh ohkcxa dbi exth ci|g t|ckk ohbuchv hkhahi|t bil bjbci tx~~ks |oh hihvjs ekgzihhlhl |g vhtct| jvbuc|b|cgibk ~vhttxvh) \oct t|bjh ci b t|bv*t hugkx|cgi ct lvbab|cd) \oh tzc|do evgaoslvgjhi fxvicij |g ohkcxa fxvicij vhrxcvht b kbvjh cidvhbth ci |oh |ha~hvb|xvh ge |oh dgvh bil~vglxdht b dgvvht~gilcijks kbvjh cidvhbth ci |oh vb|h ge ohb| ekgz |g |oh txvebdh) \g vblcb|h |ob|kbvjhv vb|h ge ohb| ekgz+ |oh t|bv vhrxcvht b axdo kbvjhv txvebdh bvhb bil c| h~bilt |g fhdgah b vhjcbi|) /Ci bfgx| ecuh fckkcgi shbvt+ gxv Txi zckk vhbdo |oct t|bjh bil c|t txvebdh zckk hidga~btt |ohgvfc| ge Abvt)# Zohi |oh ohkcxa exhk ct hobxt|hl+ |oh txddhttcuhks ohbuchv hkhahi|t zocdo bvh |ohbtoht ge |oh kcjo|hv hkhahi|t bkvhbls fxvihl bvh |ohathkuht fxvihl ci|g huhi ohbuchv hkhahi|t)\ohcv fxvicij+ ogzhuhv+ lght ig| cilxdh b tcjicecdbi| cidvhbth ge dgvh |ha~hvb|xvh bil fxvicij vbbil |oh t|bv dgi|vbd|t evga c|t vhl jcbi| t|b|h |g b~~vgcab|hks c|t gvcjcibk tcph) \oh jhihvb|cgi gehihvjs ci |oh dgvh fs |oh extcgi ge ~vgjvhttcuhks ohbuchv hkhahi|t dhbtht zohi |oh dgvh obt fhhifxvihl |g cvgi fhdbxth |oh egvab|cgi ge hkhahi|t ohbuchv |obi cvgi bftgvft hihvjs cit|hbl gevhkhbtcij c|) \oh ex|xvh ge |oh t|bv evga |oct ~gci| gi lh~hilt x~gi c|t abtt)

2>)<! Ce |oh t|bv ct tabkkhv |obi bfgx| 2)< tgkbv abttht+ |oh ab||hv ci c|t dgvh ct db~bfkh ge vhtct|cij|oh ~vhttxvh hhv|hl fs |oh guhvkscij ab|hvcbk bil c| huhi|xbkks dggkt |g |oh |ha~hvb|xvh ge t~bdh)|oh t|bv ct kbvjhv+ igvabk ab||hv ci |oh dgvh ct ig| db~bfkh ge vhtct|cij jvbuc|b|cgibk ~vhttxvh bilb|gacd hkhd|vgit bvh trxhhphl ci|g |oh b|gacd ixdkhc |g egva ihx|vgit) Tcidh ihx|vgit lg ig| vh~hhbdo g|ohv+ |oh dgvh dgkkb~tht bkagt| cit|bi|bihgxtks evga |oh lhitc|s ge dga~vhtthl b|gat |g |olhitc|s ge ihx|vgit) \oct dgkkb~th ~vglxdht b togdm zbuh zocdo vbctht b tcjicecdbi| ~gv|cgi ge |ohoslvgjhi guhvfxvlhi |g extcgi dgilc|cgit bil |oh t|bv h~kglht) Ce |oh t|bv ct tabkkhv |obi bfgx| 4tgkbv abttht+ |oh jbthgxt guhvfxvlhi ct ig| bfkh |g dgi|bci |oh h~kgtcgi bil b tx~hvigub vhtxk|

\oh vhaibi|t ge txdo bi h~kgtcgi bvh b ihx|vgi t|bv b| |oh dhi|hv ge bi h~bilcij tohkk ge jbt) Ce|oh t|bv ct fh|zhhi 4 bil <)8 tgkbv abttht+ |oh guhvfxvlhi ct txeecdchi| |g kcac| |oh h~kgtcgi bil|oh gf`hd| tohlt b ~gv|cgi ge c|t jbthgxt hiuhkg~h) \ob| h~kgtcgi+ migzi bt b igub+ ct axdo khttthuhvh+ bil abs gddxv thuhvbk |caht bt |oh t|bv vhlxdht c|t abtt |g |oh ~gci| zohvh c|t ihx|vgidgvh dbi tx~~gv| |oh guhvfxvlhi ge t|hkkbv jbttht)

2>)8! Jvbuc|b|cgibk dgkkb~th gddxvt zohi |oh tcph ge |oh dgkkb~tcij t|bv hdhhlt <)8 tgkbv abttht)Txdo t|bvt bvh ig| db~bfkh ge vhlxdcij |ohcv abtt fs h~kglcij) \oh jbthgxt guhvfxvlhi ct |ggjvhb| bil b dgkkb~th ge |oh t|bv zocdo vhtxk|t evga |oh cibfckc|s ge |oh ihx|vgit ci c|t dgvh |g vhtct|jvbuc|b|cgibk ~vhttxvh jght |g dga~kh|cgi) Xilhv fg|o Ihz|gicbi Jvbuc|b|cgibk \ohgvs bil JhihvbVhkb|cuc|s+ txdo bi gf`hd| obt ig dogcdh fx| |g dgkkb~th bkagt| cit|bi|bihgxtks |g b ab|ohab|cdbk~gci| dbkkhl b Tcijxkbvc|s) /Vhdhi|ks b txjjht|cgi zbt ablh |ob| hkhd|vgit zckk dgkkb~th |g egva

mbgit xilhv txeecdchi| ~vhttxvh) Huhi |ogxjo mbgit+ kcmh ~og|git bil ihx|vcigt+ dga~vhtt vb|ohv|obi dgkkb~th xilhv ~vhttxvh+ |oh ab|ohab|cdt bttgdcb|hl zc|o fg|o |ohgvcht togz |ob| mbgit bvhig| db~bfkh ge ~vhuhi|cij |oh ecibk jvbuc|b|cgibk dgkkb~th)#

2>)5! \oh ebd| |ob| fg|o Ihz|gicbi Jvbuc|b|cgibk \ohgvs bil Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s ~vhlcd| |ob| kbvjhgf`hd|t huhi|xbkks dgi|vbd| |g b ab|ohab|cdbk ~gci| b| b uhkgdc|s jvhb|hv |obi |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| |gegva Fkbdm Ogkht+ Tcijxkbvc|cht bil Zgvaogkht togxkl obuh khl |g |oh dgidkxtcgi |ob| |oh |ohgvchtzhvh lhehd|cuh bil'gv cidga~kh|h) Xiegv|xib|hks+ ci |oct bvhb b| khbt|+ tdchidh obt fhhi dgiuhv|hlci|g b vhkcjcgi) Bt b vhtxk|+ ~ostcdct|t bvh ~vhuhi|hl evga vbctcij hafbvvbttcij rxht|cgit hc|ohvfhdbxth ge |oh khaacij heehd| dobvbd|hvct|cd ge bkk vhkcjcgit gv fhdbxth dobkkhijcij |oh |vxh ebc|ozgxkl hil |ohcv dbvhhvt) Tcidh |oh bx|ogv ct ihc|ohv b khaacij igv ct oh lh~hilhi| x~gi |oh

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 61/110

jgglzckk ge |oh lhehilhvt ge |oh |vxh ebc|o+ oh ct evhh |g dobkkhijh |ob| ebc|o bil btthv| |ob| b ~vg~hjvbuc|b|cgibk |ohgvs axt| schkl |oh egkkgzcij vhtxk|t0

C| zckk ~vhlcd| |oh dhttb|cgi ge dgi|vbd|cgi b| |oh vblcxt zohvh |oh uhkgdc|s ge ebkk evga biciecic|h lct|bidh ct hrxbk |g |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|)

r

C| zckk fh dgitct|hi|+ ci |oh bftgkx|h thith+ zc|o |oh Kbz ge Dgithvub|cgi ge Hihvjs)r

C| zckk fh dgitct|hi| zc|o |oh ^vcidc~kh ge Vhkb|cuc|s)r

C| zckk fh dgitct|hi| zc|o |oh ^vcidc~kh ge Hrxcubkhidh)r

C| zckk schkl ~vhlcd|cgit zocdo bvh dgitct|hi| zc|o gfthvub|cgi)r

Ge |oh bfguh+ Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s giks tb|ctecht giks |oh kbt| vhrxcvhahi| bil |ob| tb|ctebd|cgi cttx~hvecdcbk) Jvbuc|s Vhkb|cuc|s+ gi |oh g|ohv obil+ ahh|t bkk ge |oh vhrxcvhahi|t)

2>):! Aglhkcij |oh Jvbuc|b|cgibk Gf`hd|0! Ci &Jvbuc|s&+ |oh bx|ogv obt hbacihl jvbuc|b|cgibk

dgkkb~th fs bttxacij b ocjoks bv|cecdcbk aglhk ge |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl |g bkkgz c|t ciohvhi|dobvbd|hvct|cdt |g fh hbacihl zockh vh|bcicij txeecdchi| tca~kcdc|s |g bkkgz hbts tgkx|cgi) \octaglhk ct lcbjvbahl ci Ecjxvh 2>)2) \oh bttxa~|cgit zocdo zhvh ablh bvh |bfxkb|hl fhkgz0

\oh abtt ge |oh gf`hd| ct dgi|bcihl ci bi ciecic|htcabkks |oci tohkk zocdo ct b| b dgit|bi|vblcxt evga |oh dhi|hv) Bkk ge c|t jvbuc|b|cgibk abtt bil c|t hi|cvh ci|hvibk ugkxah ct b| |ohtbah jvbuc|b|cgibk ~g|hi|cbk)

\oct aglhk ct t|vxd|xvbkks xit|bfkh bil zckk dgkkb~th ci vht~gith |g |oh tkcjo|ht|lhegvab|cgi+ `xt| bt b ~kbt|cd tge| lvcim fg||kh zckk dgkkb~th xilhv b tkcjo| h|hvibk~vhttxvh huhi |ogxjo c| dbi zc|ot|bil dgitclhvbfkh ci|hvibk ~vhttxvh) \oct cit|bfckc|s

lght ig| kcac| c|t xthexkihtt ci bibkspcij |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl)

v

r

Zohvh c| ct ihdhttbvs ci |oh lctdxttcgi |g hkcacib|h |oh heehd|t ge hihvjs kgtt fs vblcb|cgi+ |otxvebdh ge |oh gf`hd| ct dgitclhvhl |g obuh phvg hacttcuc|s)

r

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 62/110

2>)?! \ohth tca~kcecdb|cgit bkkgz |oh gf`hd| |g fh |vhb|hl bt ce c| obl b tcijkh vblcxt+ V+ cit|hbl gevhrxcvcij c| |g fh bi ciecic|h thvcht ge iht|hl tohkkt ge lhdvhbtcij vblcc zocdo bvh b| bi cidvhbtcijjvbuc|b|cgibk ~g|hi|cbk+ lhitc|s+ |ha~hvb|xvh bil ~vhttxvh bt |oh dhi|hv ge |oh gf`hd| ct b~~vgbdohl\oh tca~kcechl aglhk lght ig| bddxvb|hks vh~vhthi| |oh ci|hvcgv dgilc|cgit ge b jvbuc|b|cgibkksdgi|vbd|hl gf`hd|+ fx| c| ct vcjgvgxt gx|tclh ge |oh gf`hd|) Zockh dgidkxtcgit fbthl x~gi txdo b

aglhk zckk rxbi|c|b|cuhks lceehv evga zob| bd|xbkks gddxvt+ |ohs zckk fh b vhbtgibfkh b~~vgcab|cgi)Ci &Jvbuc|s&+ |oct aglhk ct tgkuhl egv |oh |zg hil kcac| dbtht) Gih dbth vhtxk|t zohi igih ge |ohhihvjs vhkhbthl fs jvbuc|b|cgi ct vblcb|hl |g t~bdh) \oh g|ohv vhtxk|t zohi bkk ge |oh hihvjsvhkhbthl fs jvbuc|b|cgi ct vblcb|hl |g t~bdh) /Bd|xbk jvbuc|b|cgibk dgi|vbd|cgi egkkgzt b ~b|o fh|zhh|ohth hil kcac| dbtht bil ct lh|hvacihl fs |oh ~gv|cgi ge |oh cic|cbk |g|bk hihvjs zocdo obt fhhivblcb|hl |g t~bdh)# \g ~vguclh dkbvc|s |g |oh lctdxttcgi+ gfthvub|cgit ablh zc|o |oh xic|t geahbtxvhahi| hct|cij b| b rxbtc!ciecic|h lct|bidh evga |oh gf`hd| bvh lhtdvcfhl bt &bd|xbk& gv&bd|xbkks gfthvuhl&) Tcackbvks+ gfthvub|cgit ablh zc|o |oh xic|t ge ahbtxvhahi|t hct|cij ihbv gvzc|oci |oh gf`hd| bvh lhtdvcfhl bt &kgdbk& gv &kgdbkks gfthvuhl&) C| axt| fh vhc|hvb|hl |ob| |oh&bd|xbk& xic|t ge ahbtxvhahi| vhabci xidobijhl bt b vhtxk| ge b dobijh ge hkhub|cgi zockh |oh&kgdbk& xic|t ge ahbtxvhahi| dobijh ci b abiihv zocdo tb|ctecht |oh ^vcidc~kh ge Vhkb|cuc|s fg|o

zc|oci bil fh|zhhi hkhub|cgit+ bt ~vguclhl fs |oh Jvbuc|s \vbitegvab|cgit ge \bfkh ?)24)2)

2>)3! Ci &Jvbuc|s& c| ct togzi |ob| |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk ~g|hi|cbk+ ,+ abs fh lh|hvacihl evga |oh bd|xbkvblcxt+ V bil |oh Ogvcpgi Vblcxt /lhtcjib|hl bt |oh Tdozbvpdockl Vblcxt ci &Jvbuc|s&#+ Vo+ xtcij

|oh h~vhttcgi ,1Vo'V) /\g ~vguclh b vhehvhidh egv |oh vhblhv+ |oh Ogvcpgi Vblcxt egv bi gf`hd| |o

abtt ge |oh Txi ct bfgx| 2)4? mckgah|hvt)# Txft|c|x|cij |oct h~vhttcgi ci|g |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk|vbitegvab|cgi /2!,# ~vguclht |oh fbtcd jvbuc|b|cgibk |vbitegvab|cgi bt bktg fhcij hrxbk |g/V!Vo#'V) \oh Ogvcpgi Vblcxt ct lh|hvacihl+ ci |xvi+ fs |oh |g|bk hihvjs dgi|hi|+ H|+ ge |oh

jvbuc|b|cij gf`hd|+ |oh Hvjg!jvbuc|b|cgibk Dgit|bi|+ L+ bil |oh ~gv|cgi+ $+ /|oh vbijh ge $ ct > |g 2# ge|oh |g|bk hihvjs dgi|hi| zocdo ct ci |oh egva ge vblcb|cgi) C|t ubkxh ct lhecihl fs |oh hrxb|cgi0

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 63/110

Vo1/2-$#LH| 

\oh |hva+ $+ ct bllhl |g |oh h~vhttcgi egv |oh Ogvcpgi Vblcxt lhvcuhl ci &Jvbuc|s& fhdbxth+ bt |ob|h| togzt+ hihvjs ci |oh egva ge vblcb|cgi jvbuc|b|ht b| |zcdh |oh vb|h bt hihvjs ci |oh egva geab||hv) \oh ~gv|cgi+ $+ ge |oh |g|bk hihvjs ge b dgi|vbd|cij gf`hd| zocdo ct ci |oh egva ge vblcb|cgidobijht bt |oh gf`hd| dgi|vbd|t lxh |g |oh vhkhbth ge jvbuc|b|cgibk hihvjs bt vblcb|cgi gv |ohdgiuhvtcgi ge vblcb|cgi ci|g ab||hv) \oh ab|hvcbk zocdo egkkgzt obt fhhi tca~kcechl fs igvabkcpcij|oh vblcxt ge |oh gf`hd| ci |hvat ge V'Vo)

2>)2>! Tcidh |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl vhtxk|t evga b vhlxd|cgi ci |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ci |oh Bh|ohvdbxthl fs |oh ~vgcac|s ge hihvjs+ |oh ecvt| heehd| |g fh dgitclhvhl ct |oh heehd| ge jvbuc|b|cgibk~g|hi|cbk gi |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|) \ob| heehd| ct togzi ci Ecjxvh ?)<) Xikhtt |oh bd|xbk vblcxt+ V'Vo+

ct khtt |obi bfgx| 2>+ |oh bd|xbk uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|+ ct htthi|cbkks xidobijhl evga c|t t|bilbvl ubkxh D) Bt |oh vblcxt+ V'Vo+ b~~vgbdoht xic|s+ |oh bd|xbk uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| vb~clks b~~vgbdoht phvg) Bt

gfthvuhl kgdbkks+ ge dgxvth+ |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| vhabcit xidobijhl b| c|t igacibk ubkxh ge D)

2>)22! \oh Bd|xbk bil Kgdbkks Gfthvuhl Tcph ge b Jvbuc|b|cgibkks Dgkkb~tcij Gf`hd|0! Tcidh ab||hvdgi|vgkt c|t tcph bil c|t th~bvb|cgi evga g|ohv ab||hv fs b ah|ogl bmci |g ahbtxvcij |oh kgdbkuhkgdc|s ge kcjo|+ |oh vhlxd|cgi ge |ob| uhkgdc|s fs |oh ~vhthidh ge |oh hihvjs vh~vhthi|hl fs bjvbuc|b|cij gf`hd| vhlxdht |oh tcph ge bkk ge |oh xic|t ge ahbtxvhahi| fs zocdo lct|bidht bvh

gfthvuhl) B| ecvt|+ bt bi gf`hd| dgi|vbd|t evga b kbvjh vblcxt+ |oh dgi|vbd|cgi+ bt fg|o bd|xbk bilkgdbkks gfthvuhl+ ~vgdhhlt ci |oh abiihv gih zgxkl bi|cdc~b|h evga dkbttcdbk ~ostcdt) Bt |oh bd|xvblcxt+ V'Vo+ b~~vgbdoht xic|s+ |oh acixt tcji ci |oh fbtcd Jvbuc|s \vbitegvab|cgi dbxtht |oh

kgdbk xic|t ge ahbtxvhahi| egv khij|o |g tovcim agvh vb~clks |obi |oh bd|xbk gfthvuhl vblcxt) \g bci|hvibk gfthvuhv+ |oh heehd| dbxtht |oh uhkgdc|s ge dgi|vbd|cgi |g tkgz |g phvg zohi |oh kgdbkksgfthvuhl vblcxt+ V'Vo+ obt ebkkhi |g <) /\oh bd|xbk ubkxh ge V'Vo ct 6 b| |oct ~gci|)# Bt |oh bd|xbk

ubkxh ge V'Vo ge |ob| gf`hd| dgi|vbd|t evga 6 |gzbvlt c|t kcac|cij ubkxh ge 2+ |oh vhtxk|bi| vhlxd|cgi

ci tcph ge |oh xic| ge ahbtxvhahi| egv khij|o dbxtht |oh kgdbkks gfthvuhl ubkxh ge V'Vo |g

b~~vgbdo ciecic|s) \oh heehd|t bvh togzi ci Ecjxvh 2>)6)

2>)26! \oh tca~kcechl aglhk ge |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl lhtdvcfhl bfguh bil ckkxt|vb|hl ci Ecjxvh 2>)2ct xthexk ci ~vguclcij citcjo| ci|g |oh ib|xvh ge jvbuc|b|cgibk dgkkb~th) Egv |oct ~xv~gth+ |oh bx|ogvobt zvc||hi b ~vgjvba egv xth gi b ^D |g bkkgz oca |g b~~vgcab|h |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk dgi|vbd|cgi gebi gf`hd| obucij b thkhd|hl abtt+ bt h~vhtthl ci xic|t hrxbk |g |oh Tgkbv Abtt+ fh|zhhi |oh vblc

ge 2>2> bil 2-2>!2> |caht c|t Ogvcpgi Vblcxt)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 64/110

Bt |oh gf`hd| dgi|vbd|t+ |oh uhkgdc|s /bt b evbd|cgi ge |oh kgdbk uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|# bil |oh mcih|cdhihvjs ge b ~bv|cdkh ebkkcij |g |oh gf`hd| evga bi ciecic|h vblcxt cidvhbtht)

r

\oh cidvhbth ge mcih|cd hihvjs ge |oh ebkkcij ~bv|cdkh vbctht c|t |ha~hvb|xvh xi|ck c|t mcih|cdhihvjs fhdgaht hrxbk |g c|t vht| abtt hihvjs) B| |ob| ~gci|+ c|t |ha~hvb|xvh ig kgijhv vcthtfhdbxth |oh dvhb|cgi ge bllc|cgibk ab||hv ct b ocjohv hi|vg~s ~b|o egv |oh bftgv~|cgi ge |ohhihvjs ge ebkk |obi ct bi cidvhbth ci |oh |ha~hvb|xvh ge hct|cij ab||hv) \oh kgdbkks gfthvuhl|ha~hvb|xvh |ohi vhabcit dgit|bi| b| bfgx| <)68 |vckkcgi Mhkucit xi|ck |oh ecibk ~gv|cgi ge |oh

kgdbkks gfthvuhl h~bitcgi ~obth)

\oh tcaxkb|cgi bttxaht |ob| gidh |oh ab||hv dvhb|cgi t|bjh ct vhbdohl+ ci|hvibk~vhttxvht fbkbidh jvbuc|b|cgibk ~vhttxvht bil |oh uhkgdc|s ge ebkk ig kgijhv cidvhbtht)\oh tcaxkb|cgi zbt bktg vxi zc|ogx| bkkgzcij |oh dvhb|cgi ge bllc|cgibk ab||hv fsbkkgzcij |oh bd|xbk dgi|vbd|cgi uhkgdc|s |g cidvhbth |g |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|) \oh gikslceehvhidh ci |oh vhtxk|t gf|bcihl zbt b vhlxd|cgi ge khtt |obi gih thdgil ci |oh |cah eg|oh ~vgdhtt |g jg |g dga~kh|cgi) C| thhat vhbtgibfkh+ |ohvhegvh+ |g bddh~| |ob| bisheehd|t vhtxk|cij evga obucij hvvgihgxtks bttxahl |ob| |oh uhkgdc|s ge dgkkb~th ct kcac|hfs ab||hv dvhb|cgi abs fh cjigvhl)

v

r

\oh kgdbkks gfthvuhl uhkgdc|s ge |oh h~bitcgi t|bjh ct kcac|hl |g |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|)

\oct kcac|b|cgi ct ig| ca~gthl fs Uhkgdc|s Vhkb|cuc|s fhdbxth |oh kgdbkks gfthvuhlh~bitcgi ct ig| dbxthl fs uhkgdc|s) \oh ~bv|cdkht zocdo bvh gfthvuhl |g fh th~bvb|cijevga hbdo g|ohv bvh htthi|cbkks t|b|cgibvs) C| ct |oh vhlxd|cgi ci |oh bd|xbk uhkgdc|s ge kcjzocdo abmht |oha b~~hbv |g fh th~bvb|cij b| b ocjo uhkgdc|s)

v

\oct kcac|b|cgi zgxkl vhtxk| ce |oh ~vg~bjb|cgi uhkgdc|s ge jvbuc|b|cgibk heehd|t ct kcac|hl |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|) Tcidh |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk egvdh ~vglxdcij dgkkb~th ~vg~bjb|ht |ovgxj|oh ci|hvcgv ge |oh gf`hd|+ |oh egvdh dbxtcij |oh dgkkb~th zgxkl |ohi dhbth |g bd| gidh |okgdbkks gfthvuhl h~bitcgi uhkgdc|s fhdbah hrxbk |g D)

Tcidh jvbuc|b|cgibk hihvjs ct vhkhbthl evga |oh hihvjs dgi|bcihl ci |oh ab||hv bilvblcb|cgi zc|oci |oh echkl vb|ohv |obi evga |oh echkl c|thke+ |ohvh ct ig vhbtgi |gfhkchuh |ob| |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl c|thke dgi|bcit hihvjs ci bis egva) Uhkgdc|sVhkb|cuc|s |ohi lght ig| ca~gth c|t uhkgdc|s kcac|t ge -'!D gi |oh ~vg~bjb|cgiuhkgdc|s ge b jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl) \g |oh bx|ogv*t migzkhljh+ |ohvh obt fhhi igh~hvcahi|bk lh|hvacib|cgi ge |oh uhkgdc|s ge ~vg~bjb|cgi ge jvbuc|b|cgibk heehd|t)

t

v

\oh dga~x|hv tcaxkb|cgi zbt vxi fg|o zc|o bil zc|ogx| b kcac|b|cgi gi |oh uhkgdc|s ge~vg~bjb|cgi ge jvbuc|b|cgibk heehd|t) \oh giks tcjicecdbi| lceehvhidh zbt+ |ob| zc|ogx| |ocvht|vcd|cgi+ |oh h~bitcgi ~obth+ bt kgdbkks gfthvuhl+ ct tg vb~cl |ob| ixdkhgit fhjcivhdhlcij evga hbdo g|ohv b| ebt|hv |obi kcjo| uhkgdc|cht zc|oci b thdgil be|hv |oh

h~bitcgi ~obth t|bv|t) Tcidh gxv Xicuhvth ct agt| dhv|bciks bi bidchi| jvbuc|b|cgibkgf`hd| zocdo ct h~bilcij bil zocdo dgi|bcit b kbvjh ixafhv ge gfthvubfkh ixdkhgit+|oh bx|ogv bddh~|t |ob| jvbuc|b|cgibk heehd|t ~vg~bjb|h b| |oh kgdbk uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|)

v

r

2>)24! \oh Bd|xbk bil Kgdbkks Gfthvuhl Vb|h ge Dgi|vbd|cgi ge b Evhhks Dgi|vbd|cij Jvbuc|b|cgibkGf`hd|0! \oh ecvt| vhtxk| ge ci|hvht| ~vguclhl fs |oct tcaxkb|cgi ct |oh bd|xbk uhkgdc|s ge dgi|vbd|cgi |oh gf`hd| bt b exid|cgi ge |oh vb|cg fh|zhhi c|t bd|xbk vblcxt bil c|t Ogvcpgi Vblcxt+ V'Vo+ bt

togzi ci Ecjxvh 2>)4B) Bt |oh gf`hd| dgi|vbd|t evga b kbvjh vblcxt /V'Vo12>2>#+ |oh uhkgdc|s ge

dgi|vbd|cgi cidvhbtht |g tkcjo|ks khtt |obi |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| bil vhabcit b| |ob| khuhk bt |ohhihvjs ge ebkk fhjcit |g dvhb|h bllc|cgibk ab||hv cit|hbl ge cidvhbtcij |oh |ha~hvb|xvh ge |oh ab||h|ob| bkvhbls hct|t) Fhsgil |oct ~gci| |oh heehd|t ge |oh jvbuc|b|cgibkks cilxdhl vhlxd|cgi ci |oh

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 65/110

bd|xbk uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| fhjci |g fhdgah tcjicecdbi|) \oh bd|xbk uhkgdc|s ge dgi|vbd|cgi vhlxdhtbfvx~|ks zohi |oh bd|xbk vblcxt ebkkt fhkgz <V'Vo bil vxit ci|g b ecjxvb|cuh &fvcdm zbkk& zohi |oh

bd|xbk vblcxt+ V+ obt ebkkhi h|vhahks dkgth |g Vo fhdbxth+ b| |ob| vblcxt+ |oh bd|xbk uhkgdc|s ge kcj

obt fhdgah uhvs dkgth |g phvg) \oh kgdbkks gfthvuhl uhkgdc|s ge dgi|vbd|cgi fhobuht lceehvhi|ks bt|oh bd|xbk vblcxt+ V+ b~~vgbdoht Vo+ bt togzi ci Ecjxvh 2>)4F) B| kbvjh vblcc+ |oh kgdbkks gfthvuhl

bil bd|xbk uhkgdc|cht bvh ihbvks clhi|cdbk+ fx| b| bi bd|xbk vb|cg+ V'Vo+ ge bfgx| 8+ |oh kgdbkks

gfthvuhl uhkgdc|s ge dgi|vbd|cgi fhjcit |g lhdvhbth evga c|t ubkxh ihbv !D /dgi|vbd|cgi#+ dgaht |vht| b| bi bd|xbk vblcxt vb|cg+ V'Vo+ ge 6+ bil cidvhbtht |g c|t abcaxa ubkxh ge -D /h~bitcgi# b

bi bd|xbk vblcxt vb|cg ge bfgx| 2)8) C| abci|bcit |oh kgdbkks gfthvuhl h~bitcgi uhkgdc|s ge -Dcilhecic|hks bt |oh bd|xbk vblcxt+ V+ b~~vgbdoht |oh Ogvcpgi Vblcxt+ Vo+ bil |oh kgdbkks gfthvuhl

vblcxt b~~vgbdoht ciecic|s)

2>)2<! \oh Heehd| ge Jvbuc|b|cgibk Dgkkb~th gi |oh Gfthvuhl Vb|h ge ^bttbjh ge \cah0! \oh ih|vhtxk| ~vguclhl fs |oh dga~x|hv tcaxkb|cgi ct |oh vhkb|cgitoc~ fh|zhhi |oh kgdbkks gfthvuhl bilbd|xbk |cah egv |oh gf`hd| |g dgkkb~th+ bt togzi ci Ecjxvh 2>)<) Tcidh |oh abtt ge |oh gf`hd| beehd|t|oh |cah vhrxcvhl fs |oh dgkkb~tcij ~vgdhtt+ |oh vhtxk|t bvh ~vguclhl egv |oh tabkkht| gf`hd| zocdobt|vg~ostcdct|t ~vhlcd| bt fhcij txf`hd| |g dgkkb~th+ <)8 tgkbv abttht) /\oh ~kg| t|bv|t gihacdvgthdgil be|hv |oh t|bv| ge |oh h~bitcgi ~obth ci gvlhv |g ~hvac| |oh xth ge bi h~gihi|cbktdbkh)# C| zckk fh ig|hl |ob| |oh ~bttbjh ge |cah+ bt gfthvuhl zc|o kgdbk dkgdmt+ cidvhbtht ci

~vg~gv|cgi |g |oh trxbvh vgg| ge |oh ~bttbjh ge |cah bt gfthvuhl zc|o h|hvibk dkgdmt) \oxt+ |oh~bttbjh ge gih shbv citclh |oh gf`hd| vhrxcvht b ~bttbjh ge |cah gx|tclh ge |oh gf`hd| zocdo ctjvhb|hv |obi |oh bjh ge gxv Xicuhvth) C| axt| fh ha~obtcphl |ob| |oh lceehvhidh ci |oh gfthvuhl~bttbjh ge |cah lght ig| vhtxk| evga b dobijh ci |oh bd|xbk vb|h ge ~bttbjh ge |cah+ c| vhtxk|t evga|oh tkgzcij ge &dkgdmt& zc|oci |oh gf`hd|)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 66/110

2>)28! \oh Bd|xbk bil Kgdbkks Gfthvuhl Hihvjs ge b Ixdkhgi Lxvcij Jvbuc|b|cgibk Dgkkb~th0! \oh

bd|xbk tkgzcij ge |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| |g phvg b| |oh Ogvcpgi Vblcxt citxvht |ob| jvbuc|b|cgibkdgkkb~th zckk ig| bkkgz |oh vblcxt ge bi gf`hd| |g lhdvhbth |g khtt |obi Vo ci b ecic|h |cah) Gih

zgxkl og~h+ ogzhuhv+ |ob| Ib|xvh obl b khtt ibafs!~bafs ahbit ge |hvacib|cij |oh ~vgdhtt+ bilcilhhl c| lght) \oh |hvacib|cgi ge jvbuc|b|cgibk dgkkb~th gddxvt fhdbxth+ bt |oh bd|xbk vblcxtb~~vgbdoht |oh Ogvcpgi Vblcxt+ |oh vblcb|cgi ~vhttxvh ge ~og|git bil ihx|vcigt cidvhbthttxeecdchi|ks |g fbkbidh jvbuc|b|cgibk ~vhttxvh) Bt |oh gf`hd| dgi|vbd|t+ c|t kgdbkks gfthvuhl vblcxt+ lcbjvbahl ci Ecjxvh 2>)6F+ lhdvhbtht evga |oh vblcxt ge |oh t|bv evga zocdo c| zbt egvahl |g bacicaxa ge egxv |caht |oh c|t Ogvcpgi Vblcxt) Evga |ob| ~gci| gi+ |oh kgdbkks gfthvuhl xic| geahbtxvhahi| egv khij|o lhdvhbtht agvh vb~clks |obi |oh bd|xbk vblcxt ge |oh gf`hd|) \oct dbxtht|oh gf`hd|+ bt kgdbkks gfthvuhl+ |g h~bil vb|ohv |obi dgi|vbd|+ zc|o |oh kgdbkks gfthvuhl vblcxtb~~vgbdocij ciecic|s bt |oh bd|xbk vblcxt b~~vgbdoht Vo) Lxvcij |oh kgdbkks gfthvuhl dgi|vbd|cgi+

|oh hihvjs lhitc|s /agt|ks ci |oh egva ge ab||hv# ge |oh gf`hd| cidvhbtht evga |ob| ge igvabk ab||hv|g |ob| ge ihx|vgit bil ecibkks |g bi hihvjs lhitc|s zocdo+ ce |oh gf`hd| ct ig| |gg kbvjh+ ebv hdhhlt|oh hihvjs lhitc|s ge ixdkhgit) Zohi |oh ciekhd|cgi ~gci| togzi ci Ecjxvh 2>)6F obt fhhi ~btthl+|oh kgdbkks gfthvuhl hihvjs lhitc|s ge |oh gf`hd| fhjcit |g lhdvhbth fhdbxth ge |oh kgdbkksgfthvuhl cidvhbth ci ugkxah bil huhi|xbkks ebkkt |g |oh hihvjs lhitc|s ge b ixdkhgi) Lxvcij |oct~gv|cgi ge |oh h~bitcgi ~vgdhtt+ |oh hihvjs zocdo obl fhhi t|gvhl bt b vhtxk| ge |oh dga~vhttcgge |oh gvcjcibk ixdkhgit ct vhkhbthl fs |oh h~bitcgi |g egva bllc|cgibk ixdkhgit b| bi ci|hvibkksgfthvuhl |ha~hvb|xvh ge <)68 |vckkcgi Mhkucit) \oh ~vgdhtt jhihvb|ht b kbvjh cidvhbth ci |oh kgdbkksgfthvuhl hihvjs dgi|hi| ge |oh gf`hd|+ fg|o ci |hvat ge |oh ixafhv ge ixdkhgit ~vhthi| bil c|tvblcb|cgibk hihvjs+ bt togzi ci Ecjxvh 2>)8B) /\oh vhlxd|cgi ge |oh bd|xbk hihvjs ~vhthi| ciixdkhgit ct togzi ci Ecjxvh 2>)8F)# Bt |oh kgdbkks gfthvuhl h~bitcgi dgi|cixht+ |oh gf`hd|fhdgaht igvabk ab||hv zocdo |ohi h~bilt |g fhdgah b jbt) \oh h~bitcgi bttgdcb|hl zc|o |oct

~obth bd|t |g vhlxdh |oh |ha~hvb|xvh ge |oh gf`hd|)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 67/110

2>)25! Bt |oh ci|hvibkks gfthvuhl h~bitcgi ~obth ~vgdhhlt bil |oh |ha~hvb|xvh lvg~t fhkgz c|tkcac| ge <)68 |vckkcgi Mhkucit+ ab||hv dbi ig kgijhv vhlxdh |oh bftgkx|h hihvjs vh~vhthi|hl fscilcuclxbk ~bv|cdkht ge ab||hv+ bt vhrxcvhl fs |oh ^vcidc~kh ge Vhkb|cuc|s+ fs dvhb|cij bllc|cgibkab||hv) Be|hv |oct ~gci| obt fhhi vhbdohl+ ab||hv obt ig dogcdh fx| |g vhkhbth hihvjs ci |oh egva gvblcb|cgi) Egv |oh tabkk ~gv|cgi ge c|t hihvjs zocdo ct hkhd|vgabjih|cd ci ib|xvh/hkhd|vgit'~gtc|vgit+ dobvjh ge ~vg|git'bi|c~vg|git+ bil |oh hkhd|vgabjih|cd hihvjs bttgdcb|hlzc|o |oh gvfc|cij ge hkhd|vgit'~gtc|vgit# |ohvh ct ig ~vgfkha) \oh vhtxk|cij vblcb|cgi dgitct|t ge~og|git bil bllt |g |oh gfthvuhl fbdmjvgxil hkhd|vgabjih|cd vblcb|cgi ge t~bdh gv+ ce |oh ab||hvct dgi|bcihl zc|oci bi gf`hd| txdo bt b ~kbih| gv t|bv+ thvuht |g zbva |ob| gf`hd|) /^kbih|t+ egvhba~kh+ bvh gfthvuhl |g vblcb|h agvh hihvjs |obi |ohs vhdhcuh evga |oh Txi)# \oh 33)38( ge |oh

hihvjs dgi|hi| ge ab||hv |ob| ct dgi|bcihl zc|oci b|gacd ixdkhc ct b lceehvhi| ab||hv) Fbthl x~gi |obvjxahi|t ~vguclhl ci Dob~|hv 24+ c| zgxkl thha |ob| |oh vhrxcvhl tohllcij ge hihvjs axt| fhbddga~kctohl fs fvgbl t~hd|vxa vblcb|cgi ge ihx|vcigt tcackbv |g |oh fkbdm fgls vblcb|cgi gehkhd|vgabjih|cd hihvjs) Txdo b fvgbl t~hd|vxa vblcb|cgi ge ihx|vcigt+ ogzhuhv+ ct ig| lcvhd|ksgfthvubfkh zc|oci |oh dxvvhi| t|b|h ge |oh bv| bil+ cilhhl+ abs ihuhv fh gfthvubfkh) Ihx|vcigt bvhdxvvhi|ks lh|hd|bfkh giks fs |ohcv bftgv~|cgi fs b|gacd ixdkhc) Tcidh |ob| ci|hvbd|cgi gddxvt b|tobv~ks lhecihl evhrxhidcht+ bibkgjgxt |g |oh hkhd|vgabjih|cd t~hd|vbk bftgv~|cgi kciht ge b|gat+giks b tabkk ~hvdhi|bjh ge |oh hac||hl ihx|vcig vblcb|cgi |vbuhvtcij t~bdh dbi fh lh|hd|hl)/Jvbuc|b|cgibkks cilxdhl |cah lckb|cgi fh|zhhi |oh dhi|hv ge |oh Txi bil |oh Hbv|o dbi hbtcks~vguclh higxjo evhrxhids toce| |g bddgxi| egv |oh ebckxvh ge h~hvcahi|t lhtcjihl |g lh|hd| |ohh~hd|hl hacttcgi khuhk ge ihx|vcigt ~vglxdhl ci Txi)# Xikcmh ~og|git+ ihx|vcigt bvh ig| |vb~~hlfs ab||hv bil |ohs htdb~h lcvhd|ks |g t~bdh zc|ogx| ohb|cij |oh gf`hd| |ovgxjo zocdo |ohs bvh

~bttcij) C| thhat vhbtgibfkh |g h~hd| |ob| |oh lct|vcfx|cgi ge hihvjs fh|zhhi ~og|git bilihx|vcigt ci |oh fbdmjvgxil vblcb|cgi ge t~bdh zgxkl dkgthks ab|do |oh vb|cg ge hkhd|vgi abtt |gixdkhgi abtt ge b|gat) Ce |oct ct |oh dbth+ 33)38( ge |oh fbdmjvgxil vblcb|cgi khuhk ge t~bdh zgxkdgitct| ge xilh|hd|bfkh ihx|vcigt) Zockh |oct dgidkxtcgi abs thha h|vhah+ ci |hvat gefbdmjvgxil vblcb|cgi |ha~hvb|xvh c| ct ig| obvl |g bddh~|) Tcidh |oh hihvjs ge vblcb|cgi ubvcht bt|oh <|o ~gzhv ge bftgkx|h |ha~hvb|xvh+ |oh vhrxcvhl hihvjs vb|cg ct bdochuhl ce b uhvs vhbtgibfkhfbdmjvgxil ihx|vcig vblcb|cgi |ha~hvb|xvh ge 66)4M dghct|hl zc|o gxv Xicuhvth*t fbdmjvgxilhkhd|vgabjih|cd fbdmjvgxil |ha~hvb|xvh ge 4)8M)

2>)2:! \oh Hil~gci| ge Jvbuc|b|cgibk Dgkkb~th0! &Jvbuc|s&+ xtcij |oh bfguh aglhk+ ~vguclht |ohjvbuc|b|cgibkks cilxdhl ~vhttxvh bil |oh hihvjs lhitc|s ge bi gf`hd| obucij b |g|bk hihvjs ge H|+ b

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 68/110

gfthvuhl zc|o bd|xbk xic|t ge ahbtxvhahi| bil ci |hvat ge |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk ~g|hi|cbk+ ,/bk|hvib|cuhks h~vhtthl bt Vo'V#) \oh lhvcub|cgi ge |ohth h~vhttcgit lcl ig| dgitclhv |ob| hihvj

ci |oh egva ge vblcb|cgi jvbuc|b|ht b| |zcdh |oh vb|h ge hihvjs ci |oh egva ge ab||hv) Zohi |oct heehd|ct dgitclhvhl fs |oh cidkxtcgi ge |oh ebd|gv $+ |ohth h~vhttcgit+ zc|o ig hihvjs vblcb|hl |g t~bdhfhdgah0

Jvbuc|b|cgibk ^vhttxvh 1 Vo<']</^C#L4/2-$#6V<H|

6Q

Vblcb|cgi Hihvjs Lhitc|s 1 4Vo4

']</^C#L4

$6

V4

H|6

Q

Bil+ tcidh vblcb|cgi ~vhttxvh ct ~vg~gv|cgibk |g |oh hihvjs lhitc|s ge |oh vblcb|cgi+ |oh vblcb|cgi~vhttxvh+ ^v+ ct jcuhi fs0

Vblcb|cgi ^vhttxvh 1 4Vo4']</^C#L4$6V4H|

6Q

Hrxb|cij |oh h~vhttcgit egv |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk ~vhttxvh bil |oh vblcb|cgibk ~vhttxvh hibfkht |ohvhkb|cgitoc~ fh|zhhi |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk ~g|hi|cbk+ Vo'V+ bil |oh ~gv|cgi+ $+ ge |oh gf`hd|*t |g|bk

hihvjs zocdo ct ci |oh egva ge vblcb|cgi hibfkht |oh ubkxh ge $ b| zocdo b ~vhttxvh fbkbidht gddxv|g fh lh|hvacihl) \oh vhtxk| ct ~kg||hl ci Ecjxvh 2>)5 bt b exid|cgi ge |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk ~g|hi|cbk) \o

dxvuh obt fhhi bl`xt|hl |g cidkxlh |oh heehd|t vhtxk|cij evga |oh ebd| |ob| hihvjs ci |oh egva gevblcb|cgi jvbuc|b|ht b| |zcdh |oh vb|h ge hihvjs ci |oh egva ge ab||hv)

2>)2?! Bt b vhtxk| ge vblcb|cgi ~vhttxvh+ bd|xbk jvbuc|b|cgibk dgi|vbd|cgi dgaht |g b obk| b| b vblcxtV+ zocdo ct dkgth |g |oh Huhi| Ogvcpgi vblcxt+ Vo+ fhdbxth exv|ohv bd|xbk dgi|vbd|cgi cidvhbtht |o

kgdbkks gfthvuhl vblcb|cgi ~vhttxvh) Bd|xbk dgi|vbd|cgi evga |oct ~gci| gi dbi giks dgi|cixh bt bvhtxk| ge |oh vblcb|cgi ge hihvjs |g t~bdh) Egv |oct |g gddxv+ |oh bd|xbk |ha~hvb|xvh ge |oh gf`hd|axt| fh zbvahv |obi |oh t~bdh ci zocdo hct|t) Bt ~vguclhl ci &Jvbuc|s&+ |oh jvbuc|b|cgibkhrxckcfvcxa |ha~hvb|xvh fh|zhhi t~bdh bil |oh dgkkb~thl gf`hd| ca~gthl fs |oh Jvbuc|b|cgibk\vbitegvab|cgi+ /2!Vo'V#+ ci |hvat ge |oh |ha~hvb|xvh ge |oh h|hvibk t~bdh+ %+ ci Mhkucit+ ct jcuhi

fs0

/2!Vo'V#1<)?8%>)82>!:

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 69/110

\oh dobvbd|hvct|cdt ge b dgkkb~thl gf`hd| ci zocdo bkk ge c|t hihvjs obt fhhi vblcb|hl |g t~bdh obtbktg fhhi lhvcuhl ci &Jvbuc|s&) Bd|xbkks+ |oh gf`hd| obt tovxim |g |oh tcph ge b ab|ohab|cdbk ~gci|zocdo dgi|bcit phvg hihvjs) Bt gfthvuhl kgdbkks+ |oh gf`hd| obt tovxim |g |oh vblcxt ge c|t gvcjcibHuhi| Ogvcpgi bil dgi|bcit bi bagxi| ge hihvjs zocdo ct hrxbk |g |oh hihvjs gvcjcibkks dgi|bcihlci |oh ab||hv evga zocdo c| zbt egvahl) \oct hihvjs+ ogzhuhv+ zckk fh hi|cvhks ci |oh egva gevblcb|cgi) Jvbuc|b|cgibk dgkkb~th ge bi gf`hd| zckk ig| jg |g dga~kh|cgi bt kgij bt |oh |ha~hvb|xvh g|oh t~bdh txvvgxilcij |oh gf`hd| hdhhlt bftgkx|h phvg)

2>)23! \oh Dgithvub|cgi ge Bijxkbv Agahi|xa Lxvcij Jvbuc|b|cgibk Dgi|vbd|cgi0!Zohi b ecjxvhtmb|hv ct t~ciicij gi |oh |gh ge b tmb|h+ ohv vb|h ge t~ci ct cidvhbthl lvbab|cdbkks fs |oh tca~kh bdge fvcijcij ohv h|hilhl bvat |g ohv tclh) \oh heehd| ct gih ge |oh agt| ebackcbv hba~kht ge |ohKbz ge Dgithvub|cgi ge Bijxkbv Agahi|xa bil vhtxk|t evga |zg heehd|t) Ci vh|vbd|cij ohv bvat+ |otmb|hv cidvhbtht |oh mcih|cd hihvjs ge ohv bvat fs lgcij zgvm bjbcit| |oh dhi|vcexjbk egvdh ge |oht~ci) \oct hihvjs+ bkgij zc|o |oh gvcjcibk mcih|cd hihvjs t|gvhl ci ohv bvat axt| fh dgithvuhl bilci gvlhv egv |oct vhrxcvhahi| |g fh ah|+ ohv bijxkbv uhkgdc|s axt| cidvhbth) \oh heehd| gfhst |oh Kbge Dgithvub|cgi ge Bijxkbv Agahi|xa zocdo t|b|ht+ |ob| ci |oh bfthidh ge h|hvibk |gvrxht+ |oh~vglxd| ge bi gf`hd|*t agahi| ge cihv|cb bil c|t bijxkbv uhkgdc|s axt| vhabci dgit|bi|) Fszc|olvbzcij ohv bvat+ |oh tmb|hv vhlxdht |oh agahi| ge cihv|cb ge ohv fgls bil ohv bijxkbvuhkgdc|s cidvhbtht bddgvlcijks)

2>)6>! \oh heehd| bktg b~~kcht |g vg|b|cij gf`hd|t xilhvjgcij jvbuc|b|cgibk dgkkb~th) B| bkk ~gci|t ci|oh ~vgdhtt+ bijxkbv agahi|xa axt| fh dgithvuhl+ fg|o bd|xbkks bil bt kgdbkks gfthvuhl)Obilfggmt ~vguclh |oh agahi| ge cihv|cb ge b t~ohvh ci |hvat ge c|t abtt+ A+ bil c|t vblcxt+ V+ bt

>)<AV6) Tcidh fg|o ge |ohth rxbi|c|cht+ bil |oh ahbtxvhl vb|h ge |oh ~bttbjh ge |cah bvh txf`hd|g |oh Jvbuc|s \vbitegvab|cgit ge \bfkh ?)24)2+ |oh vhkb|cuh dobijh ci |oh bijxkbv uhkgdc|s ge bdgkkb~tcij gf`hd| bt b exid|cgi ge c|t kgdbkks gfthvuhl vblcxt ct vhblcks lh|hvacihl) Bt togzi ciEcjxvh 2>):F+ |oh vhkb|cgitoc~ fh|zhhi |oh kgdbkks gfthvuhl bijxkbv uhkgdc|s bil |oh kgdbkksgfthvuhl vblcxt ge |oh gf`hd| lxvcij |oh dgi|vbd|cgi ~obth ct dgiuhi|cgibk) C|t bijxkbv uhkgdc|scidvhbtht ci ciuhvth ~vg~gv|cgi |g |oh trxbvh ge c|t vblcxt) Lxvcij |oh h~bitcgi ~obth+ ogzhuhv+|oh kgdbkks gfthvuhl bijxkbv uhkgdc|s lhdvhbtht ci ciuhvth ~vg~gv|cgi |g |oh dxfh ge c|t kgdbkksgfthvuhl vblcxt) \oh vhbtgi egv |oh lceehvhidh ci fhobucgv fh|zhhi |oh kgdbkks gfthvuhl h~bitcgi

bil dgi|vbd|cgi ~obtht ct |ob| |oh kgdbkks gfthvuhl vhkhbth ge jvbuc|b|cgibk hihvjs cidvhbtht |ohgf`hd|*t kgdbkks gfthvuhl abtt) B| |oh kbvjh kgdbkks gfthvuhl vblcxt hct|cij kb|h ci |oh h~bitcgit|bjh+ |oh ci|hvibkks gfthvuhl bijxkbv uhkgdc|s ct cilct|cijxctobfkh evga phvg)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 70/110

2>)62! Bd|xbkks |oh bijxkbv uhkgdc|s ge b dgkkb~tcij gf`hd| egkkgzt b lceehvhi| ~b|o) Egv |oh dbthzohvh ig hihvjs ct kgt| fs |oh dgkkb~tcij gf`hd| fs vblcb|cgi |g t~bdh+ |oh abtt ge |oh gf`hd| ubvch

ciuhvthks zc|o |oh trxbvh ge |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ci bddgvlbidh zc|o \ogatgi*t H1AD6 bil ct

~vg~gv|cgibk |g 2'/2!Vo'V#<) Ecjxvh 2>):B togzt |ob| |oh heehd| ge |oh abtt cidvhbth ct tabkk egv

vblcc zocdo bvh kbvjh dga~bvhl |g |oh Ogvcpgi Vblcxt bil |oh gf`hd| gfhst |oh dgiuhi|cgibk Kbz gDgithvub|cgi ge Bijxkbv Agahi|xa bt c| dgi|vbd|t) Zohi |oh vblcxt b~~vgbdoht |oh OgvcpgiVblcxt+ |oh heehd|t ge |oh cidvhbthl abtt ~vhlgacib|h bil |oh vg|b|cgi ge |oh gf`hd| dgaht |g btdvhhdocij obk|) \oh bfvx~|ihtt ge |oh t|g~~bjh ct ckkxt|vb|hl fs Ecjxvh 2>)?)

2>)66! Zohi gih vhdgjicpht |ob| gxv Xicuhvth ct c|thke b jvbuc|b|cgibk gf`hd| ge b vblcxt htthi|cbkkshrxbk |g c|t Ogvcpgi Vblcxt+ bt lh|hvacihl fs |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk abtt ge |oh ab||hv bil |oh vblcb|cg

c| dgi|bcit+ c| ct gfucgxt |ob| |oh ih| bijxkbv uhkgdc|s vh~vhthi|hl fs |ob| ab||hv bil vblcb|cgi axtfh ubictocijks dkgth |g phvg) \oh jsvgtdg~cdbkks gfthvuhl phvg bijxkbv uhkgdc|s ge gxv Xicuhvth ctdbxthl fs |oh Kbz ge Dgithvub|cgi ge Bijxkbv Agahi|xa g~hvb|cij ci bi *h~bilcij* Xicuhvth) C|ct ig| |oh vhtxk| ge |oh ih| bijxkbv uhkgdc|s ge bkk ge |oh ab||hv ci |oh Xicuhvth bt Lvt) Hcit|hci bilAbdo btthv|hl zc|ogx| obucij ~vhthi|hl bis cilcdb|cgi bt |g ogz txdo b acvbdxkgxt heehd| acjo|dgah bfgx|) Aglhvi Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuct|t btthv| |ob| bt b vg|b|cij gf`hd| egvat b Fkbdm Ogkh+ c| lvbjt~bdh bkgij zc|o c| bil c|t vg|b|cgi dgaht |g vht| zc|o vht~hd| |g |ob| t~bdh) Ce bis vhblhv fhkchuhthc|ohv ge |ohth btthv|cgit+ |oh bx|ogv zgxkl kcmh |g ohbv evga oca) \ob| fvcljh guhv |oh Hbt| Vcuhv ct|ckk egv tbkh)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 71/110

2>)64! Jvbuc|b|cgibk Zbuht bil Jvbuc|git0! Tcidh huhvs bddxaxkb|cgi ge hihvjs jhihvb|ht b

jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl+ c| egkkgzt |ob| |oh hihvjs dga~vctcij huhvs gf`hd| zocdo ct xilhvjgcij t~b|cbkbddhkhvb|cgi+ txdo bt |oh Aggi ci c|t gvfc| bvgxil |oh Hbv|o+ hac|t jvbuc|b|cgibk lct|xvfbidht) Ce |ohbddhkhvb|cgi ct dsdkcdbk+ |oh lct|xvfbidht bvh ci |oh egva ge zbuht zocdo ~vg~bjb|h |ovgxjogx|t~bdh bil bvh txeecdchi|ks t|vgij |g bkkgz |ohcv lh|hd|cgi+ b| khbt| ci ~vcidc~kh+ b| h|vhah lct|bidhtBt ct |oh dbth egv bkk |s~ht ge vblcb|cgi+ |oh zbuhkhij|o ge txdo b jvbuc|b|cgibk zbuh ct lh|hvacihlfg|o fs |oh evhrxhids ge |oh dsdkcdbk ag|cgi jhihvb|cij c| bil |oh uhkgdc|s ge |oh zbuh*t~vg~bjb|cgi) /Ce gih bttxaht |ob| |oh uhkgdc|s ge ~vg~bjb|cgi ge b jvbuc|b|cgibk heehd| ct ciecic|h+jvbuc|b|cgibk zbuht dbi fh dgitclhvhl |g fh b zbuht ge ciecic|h zbuhkhij|o)# Jvbuc|b|cgibk zbuht bca~kcdc| ci fg|o Ihz|gi*t bil Hcit|hci*t dgidh~|t ge jvbuc|b|cgi bt zhkk bt ci Jvbuc|s Vhkb|cuc|s)Tcidh c| obt obl |g fh gfucgxt |g bisgih zog obt |ogxjo| bfgx| |oh txf`hd| lxvcij |oh ci|hvuhicijshbvt tcidh Ihz|gi |ob| jvbuc|b|cgibk zbuht ~vg~bjb|h |ovgxjogx| |oh Xicuhvth+ |oh ~vbd|cdh ge

dvhlc|cij Lv) Hcit|hci zc|o ~vhlcd|cij |ohcv hct|hidh thhat |g fh tgahzob| ge b vhbdo)2>)6<! B jvbuc|s zbuh ct hac||hl fs bi bddhkhvb|hl tgxvdh+ txdo bt bi gf`hd| ci gvfc| bfgx| big|ohgf`hd|) Ihz|gi*t Thdgil Kbz ge Ag|cgi vhrxcvht |ob| ci|hvbd|cij gf`hd|t abci|bci b dgaagi dhi|hge jvbuc|s zocdo vhabcit t|b|cgibvs) Bt bi hba~kh+ |oh Aggi lght ig| gvfc| |oh dhi|hv ge |oh Hbv|\oh egdxt ge |oh gvfc|t ge fg|o |oh Hbv|o bil |oh Aggi ct b| |ohcv dgaagi dhi|hv ge jvbuc|s+ bfgx|2>>> ackht fhkgz |oh Hbv|o*t txvebdh gi |oh tclh ihbvhv |g |oh Aggi) Bt |ohs aguh ci |ohcvvht~hd|cuh gvfc|t bfgx| |oct egdxt+ fg|o |oh Hbv|o bil |oh Aggi vblcb|h jvbuc|b|cgibk zbuht) \octvblcb|cgi dbi fh gfthvuhl ci |oh ihbv echkl bt th~bvb|h jvbuc|b|cgibk zbuht ~vglxdhl fs |oh gvfc|bkag|cgit ge |oh Hbv|o bil ge |oh Aggi) C| dbiig| fh gfthvuhl ci |oh ebv echkl fhdbxth lh|hd|gvt ci |oebv echkl kbdm txeecdchi| bijxkbv vhtgkx|cgi |g lct|cijxcto |oh Hbv|o bil |oh Aggi bt th~bvb|htgxvdht ge jvbuc|b|cgibk vblcb|cgi bil thith giks |oh ih| jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl evga |ohcv t|b|cgibvs

dhi|hv ge jvbuc|s) Ci |oh ebv echkl+ |oh jvbuc|s zbuh evga |oh Hbv|o ct dbidhkhl fs |oh jvbuc|s zbuhevga |oh Aggi)

2>)68! \oh ahbicij ge ihbv echkl bil ebv echkl lh|hd|cgi ge vblcb|cgi dbi fh xilhvt|ggl fsdgitclhvcij |oh gfthvub|cgi ge b ~gkcdh dbv b~~vgbdocij b| icjo| bkgij b t|vbcjo| lhthv| vgbl zc|oc|t ohblkcjo|t ekbtocij bk|hvib|hks) Zockh hbdo ohblkcjo| ct bk|hvib|hks |xvihl gi bil gee+ |oh |g|bkkcjo| hac||hl evga |oh dbv vhabcit dgit|bi| zc|o c|t tgxvdh agucij evga gih tclh ge |oh dbv |g |ohg|ohv) Zohi |oh dbv ct 8 ackht bzbs+ |oh kcac|hl vhtgkx|cgi ge |oh gfthvuhv*t hsht ~vhuhi|t oca evgathhcij |oh ohblkcjo|t bt cilcuclxbk kcjo| tgxvdht+ oh thht |oha ci |oh ebv echkl bt b tcijkh tgxvdh gedgit|bi| ci|hitc|s) Zohi |oh dbv b~~vgbdoht |g zc|oci 2 gv 6 ackht+ ihbv echkl lh|hd|cgi fhjcitfhdbxth |oh gfthvuhv*t hsht bvh db~bfkh ge vhtgkucij |oh |zg ohblkcjo|t bt th~bvb|h tgxvdht) Oh|ohi gfthvuht |oh dsdkcdbk ekbtocij ge hbdo ohblkcjo|+ bil |oh kcjo| tgxvdh ct thhi |g aguh evga

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 72/110

tclh |g tclh)

2>)65! Ihbv echkl gfthvub|cgi ge |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk zbuht ge |oh Hbv|o!Aggi tst|ha obt fhhi b ebd| gkceh |ovgxjogx| oct|gvs) Zh kcuh ci ~vgcac|s |g b ocjoks heehd|cuh ihbv echkl jvbuc|b|cgibk zbuhlh|hd|gv+ |oh gdhbi) \oh gx|~x| ge |oct ihbv echkl lh|hd|gv ct |oh lbcks dobijh ge |oh |cah ge ocjo |clOgzhuhv+ zohi c| dgaht |g |oh lh|hd|cgi ge jvbuc|b|cgibk zbuht evga+ egv hba~kh+ dkgthks t~bdhlfcibvs t|bvt+ bis lh|hd|gv zocdo dbi fh fxck| gi Hbv|o zckk fh b ebv echkl lh|hd|gv) C|t bijxkbvvhtgkx|cgi ct kcac|hl fs |oh tcph ge |oh Hbv|o bil zckk fh abis gvlhvt ge abjic|xlh |gg dgbvth |gbkkgz c| |g vhtgkuh |oh jvbuc|s zbuh dga~gihi|t ge bis ~gttcfkh tgxvdh) \oh jvbuc|s zbuht zckk fh

|ohvh+ fx| |oh lh|hd|gv zckk fh xibfkh |g ecil |oha) B||ha~|t |g lh|hd| jvbuc|b|cgibk zbuht bvhlggahl |g ebckxvh bil dgithrxhi|ks bvh b zbt|h ge |cah+ agihs+ bil huhi agvh tcjicecdbi|ks+ubkxbfkh |bkhi|) \oh giks huclhidh zh thh+ gv ~vgfbfks huhv zckk thh+ ge jvbuc|b|cgibk vblcb|cgi evgalct|bi| gvfc|cij gf`hd|t ct |oh lhdbs ge |ohcv gvfc|t vhtxk|cij evga |oh kgtt ge hihvjs |ob| txdovblcb|cgi ca~kcht) \oh Xicuhvth dga~kh|hks txvvgxilt bis tgxvdh ge jvbuc|b|cgibk vblcb|cgi bildgithrxhi|ks fhobuht bt b ihbv echkl bftgvfhv ge c|t hihvjs)

2>)6:! \ohvh bvh ixahvgxt ahi|cgit ci |oh kc|hvb|xvh ge bt sh| xigfthvuhl ~bv|cdkht ibahljvbuc|git bt fhcij |oh dbvvchvt ge jvbuc|b|cgibk egvdh) \oh dgidh~| ge jvbuc|git bvctht bt bi bibkgj|g |oh ucv|xbk ~og|git zocdo bkkhjhlks ~vglxdh |oh hkhd|vgabjih|cd egvdht) Btclh evga zoh|ohv gvig| ucv|xbk ~og|git hct|+ |ohvh ct ig vhrxcvhahi| egv jvbuc|git |g fh bis agvh |obi b ecjahi| ge |oab|ohab|cdbk ~ostcdct|*t cabjcib|cgi bil bvh jhihvb|hl fs oct ihhl |g h~kbci jvbuc|s*t bfckc|s |gbd| b| b lct|bidh zc|ogx| bddh~|cij |oh hct|hidh ge |oh Bh|ohv) Tcidh |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl lght idgi|bci hihvjs c|thke+ fx| giks aglxkb|ht |oh fhobucgv ge |oh hihvjs zocdo ct bkvhbls ~vhthi|+ |ohvct ig |ohgvh|cdbk vhrxcvhahi| egv c| |g fh rxbi|cdcphl) Xikhtt |ohs bvh gfthvuhl gv bvh togzi |g fhvhrxcvhl+ c| thhat vhbtgibfkh |g |bmh |oh ~gtc|cgi |ob| |ohs bvh b ecd|cgi)

Dob~|hv 22 ! Jvbuc|b|cgibk Dgkkb~th bil |oh Dvhb|cgi ge bXicuhvth

22)2! Ce gih hbaciht |oh ca~kcdb|cgit ge Ecjxvh 2>)6+ c| ct b~~bvhi| |ob| huhvs gf`hd| zocdoxilhvjght jvbuc|b|cgibk dgkkb~th dvhb|ht big|ohv xicuhvth zc|oci b t~ohvh obucij bi bd|xbk vblcxttkcjo|ks ci hdhtt c|t Ogvcpgi Vblcxt) Bt zh obuh thhi+ bt |oh gf`hd|*t bd|xbk vblcxt dgi|vbd|t|gzbvlt |oh Ogvcpgi Vblcxt+ c|t kgdbkks gfthvuhl vblcxt cic|cbkks dgi|vbd|t bil |ohi h~bilt) Evga|oct ~gci| gi+ jvbuc|b|cgibk dgi|vbd|cgi dbxtht |oh gf`hd|*t kgdbkks gfthvuhl vblcxt |g cidvhbth bilb~~vgbdo ciecic|s) \oh ebd| |ob| |oh Jvbuc|s \vbitegvab|cgit egv Khij|o bil egv Hihvjs bvh clhi|cdbdbxtht fg|o |oh kgdbkks gfthvuhl hihvjs dgi|hi| ge |oh gf`hd| bil c|t kgdbkks gfthvuhl vblcxt |gb~~vgbdo ciecic|s b| |oh tbah vb|h) Tcidh |oh ugkxah ge b t~ohvh ubvcht ci ~vg~gv|cgi |g |oh dxfh gc|t vblcxt+ gidh |oh kgdbkks gfthvuhl h~bitcgi ~obth fhjcit+ |oh kgdbkks gfthvuhl hihvjs lhitc|sge |oh gf`hd| lhdvhbtht ci ~vg~gv|cgi |g |oh trxbvh ge c|t kgdbkks gfthvuhl vblcxt) /\oh dgafcihlheehd|t ge |oh Jvbuc|s \vbitegvab|cgit gi |oh xic|t ge ahbtxvhahi| ge fg|o khij|o bil hihvjsdbxth |oh ~gci| ge abcaxa kgdbkks gfthvuhl hihvjs lhitc|s |g toce| evga c|t igacibk ubkxh ge<Vo |g <)2Vo)#

22)6! Bt togzi ci Ecjxvh 22)2B+ dga~x|hv tcaxkb|cgi vhuhbkt |ob| |oh abcaxa kgdbkks gfthvuhlhihvjs lhitc|s ge |oh dgkkb~tcij gf`hd|+ h~vhtthl ci |hvat ge ixdkhgi hihvjs ~hv gvcjcibk ixdkhgiubvcht ciuhvthks zc|o |oh trxbvh ge |oh |oh bd|xbk hihvjs dgi|hi| ge |oh gf`hd|) B| |oh ~gci| geabcaxa kgdbkks gfthvuhl lhitc|s+ |oh ixdkhgit ge gf`hd|t tabkkhv |obi 2?8 bd|xbk tgkbv abtthtbvh dga~vhtthl bil hihvjs ct t|gvhl zc|oci |oha) Bt |oh txfthrxhi| kgdbkks gfthvuhl h~bitcgi~obth ~vgdhhlt+ |oh hdhtt kgdbkks gfthvuhl hihvjs t|gvhl zc|oci |oh dga~vhtthl ixdkhgit ctvhkhbthl ci b abiihv zocdo egkkgzt |oh ocjoht| hi|vg~s ~b|o) Bt b vhtxk|+ |oh bllc|cgibk ixdkhgittogzi ci Ecjxvh 22)2F bvh dvhb|hl zockh |oh kgdbkks gfthvuhl |ha~hvb|xvh ge <)68 |vckkcgi Mhkucit

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 73/110

jhihvb|hl lxvcij |oh dgi|vbd|cgi ~obth vhabcit xidobijhl) Kgdbk gfthvub|cgit ablh kb|h ci |ohh~bitcgi ~obth bil h|vb~gkb|hl fbdmzbvlt ci |cah |g |oh fhjciicij zgxkl khbl |g |oh dgidkxtcg|ob| ab||hv fgckhl ci|g fhcij evga ig|ocijihtt bil |ohi h~bilhl |g fhdgah igvabk ab||hvhafhllhl ci b thb ge ci|hith vblcb|cgi) \oh gf`hd|+ bt kgdbkks gfthvuhl+ |ohi dgi|cixht |g h~bilbil dggk bt b jbt bil+ bt |oh kgdbkks gfthvuhl h~bitcgi ~vgdhhlt+ bllc|cgibk hihvjs ct vhkhbthlevga ab||hv |g vh|bvl fx| ig| t|g~ |oh dggkcij ~vgdhtt) Huhi|xbkks |oh gf`hd|+ bt kgdbkks gfthvuhl+fhdgaht t~bvthks ~g~xkb|hl zc|o ab||hv bil |oh fxkm ge c|t hihvjs dgi|hi| ct ci |oh egva gevblcb|cgi) \oh bd|xbk dgi|vbd|cgi bil |oh dgvvht~gilcij kgdbkks gfthvuhl h~bitcgi+ bvh ecibkkskcac|hl fs b fbkbidh fh|zhhi jvbuc|b|cgibk bil vblcb|cgibk ~vhttxvh bt b exid|cgi ge |oh ebd|gv $+ bt

togzi ci Ecjxvh 2>)5) \oh dgkkb~th ge gf`hd|t agvh abttcuh |obi 2?8 tgkbv abttht lght ig| dbxthdga~vhttcgi ge ixdkhgit fhdbxth |oh ugkxah ge txdo gf`hd|t b| V16Vo ct txeecdchi| |g ~vhuhi|

ixdkhgi dga~vhttcgi) Egv txdo gf`hd|t+ |oh hihvjs ge ebkk evga bi ciecic|h lct|bidh dbxtht bicidvhbth ci |oh ixafhv ixdkhgit fs b ebd|gv ge <)83)

22)4! Tcidh bt|vg~ostcdct|t |hbdo |ob| giks gf`hd|t obucij bi h|hvibkks gfthvuhl tcph kbvjhv |obi<)8 Tgkbv Abttht zckk xilhvjg jvbuc|b|cgibk dgkkb~th+ c| ct vhbtgibfkh |g xth |oh Jvbuc|b|cgibk\vbitegvab|cgit |g hbacih |oh ci|hvcgv ge txdo gf`hd|t be|hv |ohs obuh xilhvjgih |ob| dgkkb~th fobuh ig| vblcb|hl hihvjs |g h|hvibk t~bdh) Kb|h ci c|t kgdbkks gfthvuhl h~bitcgi t|bjh zh zgxklecil |ob|0

\oh gf`hd| dgitct|t ge agt|ks ha~|s t~bdh eckkhl zc|o vblcb|cgi)r

Ixdkhgit zc|oci |oh gf`hd| bvh gvjbicphl ci t|vcijt ge ubvscij khij|ot x~ |g b tcjicecdbi|~gv|cgi ge |oh tcph ge |oh gf`hd|) Ce |oh gf`hd| ct txeecdchi|ks kbvjh+ |ohth t|vcijt huhi|xbkksdgi|bci t|bvt bil jbkbcht)

Zgvmhvt ci |oh echkl ge ~kbtab ~ostcdt obuh togzi |ob| hkhd|vcd bil abjih|cd echklt cit~bdh bvh db~bfkh ge gvjbicpcij ab||hv ci |oct abiihv) /&\oh Fcj Fbij Ihuhv Ob~~hihlfs Hvcd Khvihv+ \caht Fggmt)#

v

r

\oh gf`hd| zckk fh gfthvuhl |g fh h~bilcij |gzbvlt bi ciecic|h vblcxt zc|o |oh evbd|cgi ge c|t

|g|bk hihvjs zocdo ct ci |oh egva ge vblcb|cgi+ $+ b~~vgbdocij xic|s)

r

H|vb~gkb|cgi ge gfthvub|cgit ge |oh h~bitcgi ~vgdhtt fbdmzbvlt ci |cah zckk khbl |g |ohdgidkxtcgi |ob| |oh gf`hd| fhjbi zc|o bi hvx~|cgi ge ab||hv ci|g hct|hidh) Tca~kct|cdbkks+ c|zgxkl fh dgidkxlhl |ob| |oh ab||hv zbt dvhb|hl evga ig|ocijihtt b| b tcijkh ~gci| ci t~bdh)

r

\oh vblcxt ge |oh gf`hd| zckk b~~hbv |g fh cidvhbtcij b| |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|)r

\oh gf`hd| zckk fh dga~gthl hi|cvhks ge igvabk ab||hv gv ge bi|c!ab||hv fx| c| zckk ig| dgi|bcifg|o |s~ht)

Ax|xbk biicockb|cgi zckk dbxth ab||hv bil bi|c!ab||hv ci |oh gvcjcibk dkgxl |g biicockb|hhbdo g|ohv xi|ck giks |oh ~vhlgacibi| |s~h ge ab||hv vhabcit)

v

r

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 74/110

\oct lhtdvc~|cgi acjo| zhkk b~~ks |g gxv gzi Xicuhvth ce c| zhvh ig| egv gih lceecdxk|s) Gxv Xicuhvth

dgi|bcit 2>?> ixdkhgit) Bt togzi ci Ecjxvh 22)6B+ |oh ixdkhgi dgi|hi| ge b dgkkb~thl gf`hd| ct

lh|hvacihl fs c|t bd|xbkks gfthvuhl tcph bil+ egv |oh dgkkb~thl gf`hd| |g dgi|bci 2>?> ixdkhgit+ |o

bd|xbkks gfthvuhl tcph ge |oh dgkkb~tcij gf`hd| zgxkl obuh |g fh gi |oh gvlhv ge 62>26 mckgjvbat/b~~vgcab|hks |ob| ge b vgdm obucij b lcbah|hv ge b mckgah|hv#+ bt togzi ci Ecjxvh 22)6F) Tcidhjvbuc|b|cgibk dgkkb~th lght ig| gddxv ci gf`hd|t tabkkhv |obi <)8 bd|xbk tgkbv abttht+ gxv Xicuhvthdgxkl ig| fh egvahl ci |oct abiihv xikhtt bi bllc|cgibk ebd|gv zbt ~vhthi|)

22)<! Zockh c| acjo| fh rxht|cgihl bt |g zoh|ohv |oh ~vgdhtt ge jvbuc|b|cgibk dgkkb~th rxbkcecht bt|oh dvhb|cgi ge b xicuhvth+ txdo bi gf`hd|cgi ct jvgxilkhtt) Cic|cbkks |oh gf`hd| ct dgkkb~tcij ci bi

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 75/110

hct|cij xicuhvth) Bt gfthvuhl ci |ob| xicuhvth+ |oh gf`hd| dgkkb~tht |g b tabkk xk|vb lhith bil xk|og| t~ohvh dgi|bcicij b jvhb|ks cidvhbthl ixafhv ge dgkkb~thl ixdkhgit zocdo tovcim ci tcph xi|ck|oh gf`hd| b~~hbvt |g fh ucv|xbkks lhugcl ge ab||hv bil ct eckkhl bkagt| hi|cvhks zc|o vblcb|cgi) Btgfthvuhl zc|oci |oh gf`hd|+ |oh lhtdvc~|cgi ge |oh cic|cbk t|bjht bvh ucv|xbkks clhi|cdbk xi|ck be|hv |oh~gci| ge abcaxa hihvjs lhitc|s obt fhhi vhbdohl) Evga |ob| ~gci| gi+ bllc|cgibk ab||hv fgckt ci|hct|hidh evga zob| thhat |g fh ig|ocijihtt bil |oh gf`hd| |ohi h~bilt bil dggkt xi|ck c|fhdgaht bi h|vhahks kbvjh gf`hd| h~bilcij b| |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|) B| |ob| ~gci|) |oh lhitc|s geab||hv obt fhdgah kgz bil |oh gf`hd| dgitct|t ~vcabvcks ge vblcb|cgi) \oh kbvjh kgdbkks gfthvuhltcph bil hihvjs dgi|hi| ge zob| ct bd|xbkks bi h|vhahks tabkk gf`hd| dgi|bcicij bkagt| ig hihvjs

vhtxk|t evga |oh jvbuc|b|cgibkks cilxdhl dobijh ci |oh tcph ge |oh xic|t ge ahbtxvhahi| bd|cij cidgidhv| zc|o |oh ^vcidc~kh ge Vhkb|cuc|s) Huhi |ogxjo |oh fgxilbvcht ge |oh gf`hd| bvh ig kgijhv og|gv lhith+ |ohvh ct ig ~gttcfkh htdb~h evga |oh xicuhvth vh~vhthi|hl fs |oh ci|hvcgv ge |oh dgkkb~thgf`hd| |g |oh xicuhvth ci zocdo c| vhtclht) \oh hihvjs vhrxcvhl egv b ixdkhgi |g htdb~h evga |ohgf`hd| ct |gg jvhb|) C| zgxkl fh obvl |g cabjcih bis|ocij zocdo ct agvh rxbkcechl |g fh dkbttcechl btxicuhvth bt |oh dgkkb~thl gf`hd|)

22)8! C| vhabcit |g fh h~kbcihl ogz b xicuhvth |oh tcph ge |oh gih ci zocdo zh kcuh acjo| fh egvahfs jvbuc|b|cgibk dgkkb~th ce dgkkb~th lght ig| gddxv ci gf`hd|t tabkkhv |obi <)8 tgkbv abttht) \gckkxt|vb|h ogz |oh bx|ogv fhkchuht gxv Xicuhvth zbt egvahl+ |oh vblcc vb|cgt+ V'Vo+ zohvh |oh

jvbuc|b|cgibk trxbtocij ge ixdkhgit gddxv+ bvh ~kg||hl ci Ecjxvh 22)4B) Ci gvlhv |g abjices |oh

heehd|t ge ci|hvht|+ |oh uhv|cdbk tdbkh ct ~kg||hl ci |hvat ge /V'Vo!2# vb|ohv |obi V'Vo) /C| ct |oh acixttcji ci |oh Jvbuc|b|cgibk \vbitegvab|cgi zocdo ~vglxdht |oh heehd| ge |oh echkl)# Bt bi hba~kh+ |ohjvbuc|b|cgibk dgkkb~th ge bi gf`hd| ge <)8 tgkbv abttht ct togzi gi |oct ~kg| xilhv dgilc|cgit zohvig hihvjs ct kgt| fs vblcb|cgi) /Ci vhbkc|s+ hihvjs ct bkzbst vblcb|hl)# \g togz ogz |oh kgtt ge hihvj|g t~bdh fs vblcb|cgi bkkgzt |oh dvhb|cgi ge bi h|vhahks kbvjh xicuhvth+ |oh vhjcgi ge trxbtohlihx|vgit ct vh~kg||hl ci Ecjxvh 22)4F zc|o |oh uhv|cdbk bct togzi ci |hvat ge bd|xbk ah|hvt) \oct~kg| togzt |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk dgkkb~th ge bi gf`hd| ge <)8 tgkbv abttht zc|o |oh heehd|t ge vblcb|cgibohb| kgtt cidkxlhl) /Zc|o |oh ~kg| tdbkh ha~kgshl+ |oh vhjcgi ge kgdbkks gfthvuhl h~bitcgi cttxeecdchi|ks ibvvgz |g fh dgi|bcihl zc|oci |oh zcl|o ge |oh kgzhv kcih)# Bt |oh gf`hd| dgkkb~tht+ c|vblcb|ht hihvjs |g t~bdh) \ob| hihvjs kgtt aguht c| |g |oh khe| ci Ecjxvh 22)4F+ bt |s~cechl fs |ohbvvgz evga ~gci| *2* |g ~gci| *6*) \oh aguhahi| |g |oh khe|+ ci |xvi+ ahbit |ob| ci |hvat ge c|t OgvcpgiVblcxt+ c| ct igz |gg kbvjh bil axt| dgi|vbd| exv|ohv+ bt |s~cechl fs |oh bvvgz evga ~gci| *6* |g ~gci|*4*+ |g bjbci dgcidclh zc|o |oh kgzhv kcih+ jhihvb|cij agvh ixdkhgit ci |oh ~vgdhtt) \oh ~vgdhtt ctdgi|cixgxt bil |oh kgtt ge hihvjs |g t~bdh fs vblcb|cgi dbxtht |oh gf`hd| |g aguh |g |oh khe| bkgij|oh kgzhv fgxilbvs kcih) Huhi|xbkks |oh gf`hd| bdochuht b |ohvabk fbkbidh zc|o |oh h|hvibk t~bdhbil+ evga |ob| ~gci| gi+ |oh gf`hd| vhabcit gi |oh kgzhv kcih ge |oh dxvuh zc|o b $ ebd|gv ucv|xbkkshrxbk |g xic|s) Exv|ohv bd|xbk dgkkb~th bil kgdbkks gfthvuhl h~bitcgi dbi giks vhtxk| evga bvhlxd|cgi ge |oh |ha~hvb|xvh ge |oh t~bdh txvvgxilcij |oh gf`hd|) /\ob| t~bdh ct dgklhv |obi |ohkgzht| |ha~hvb|xvh bdochuhl gv kcmhks |g fh bdochuhl ci b kbfgvb|gvs)# C| ct ci|hvht|cij |g ig|h |ob|Ecjxvh 22)4F cilcdb|ht |ob| |oh bd|xbk vblcxt ge b xicuhvth obucij |oh kgdbkks gfthvuhl tcph ge gxvgzi ct bfgx| 2'2>>> ge |oh tcph ge |oh ihx|vgi" \bkm bfgx| abmcij agvh bil agvh evga khtt bilkhtt)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 76/110

22)5! \oh hbacib|cgi ge jvbuc|b|cgibk dgkkb~th lght+ ogzhuhv+ bitzhv |oh rxht|cgi bt |g |oh ecibkeb|h ge gxv Xicuhvth) Ci &Jvbuc|s&+ |oh ~bvbah|hvt ge b jvbuc|b|cgibkks dgkkb~thl gf`hd| zocdo oblvblcb|hl bkk ge c|t hihvjs |g |oh h|hvibk t~bdh bvh ~vguclhl) Txdo bi gf`hd| obt bd|xbkks vhbdohl bphvg vblcxt bil phvg hihvjs dgi|hi| bil dgithrxhi|ks obt dhbthl |g hct|) \g |oh kgdbk gfthvuhv+

|oh vblcxt ge |oh gf`hd| bil c|t Ogvcpgi Vblcxt obuh fhdgah ciecic|h) \oh dgtacd dvxido zocdo obtfhhi ~gt|xkb|hl bt |oh ~gttcfkh hil ge gxv Xicuhvth zckk ig| gddxv) \oh Xicuhvth+ bt kgdbkksgfthvuhl+ zckk h~bil bil dggk egvhuhv bt c| tovcimt |g bi bd|xbk ab|ohab|cdbk ~gci|)

22):! \oh ~vgdhtt ge jvbuc|b|cgibk dgkkb~th ca~kcdc| ci |oh Jvbuc|s \vbitegvab|cgit txjjht|t bici|hvht|cij tdhibvcg) Cic|cbkks+ b tcijkh xicuhvth dgi|bcit ~bv|cdkht ge ab||hv bil bi|c!ab||hv zocdobiicockb|h hbdo g|ohv bil vhkhbth vblcb|cgi zohi |ohs ahh|) Ci |xvi+ vblcb|cgi ge txeecdchi| hihvjs+be|hv b |cah+ vhdvhb|ht ~bv|cdkht ge ab||hv |g vh~kbdh |oh ab||hv zocdo obt fhhi biicockb|hl)Huhi|xbkks |oh ~vgdhtt dbxtht ab||hv bil bi|c!ab||hv |g tgv| |ohathkuht ci|g th~bvb|h jvgx~t evgazocdo jvbuc|b|cgibk gf`hd|t dga~gthl ge hc|ohv igvabk ab||hv gv bi|c!ab||hv dbi egva) Bis txdogf`hd|t obucij b tcph ge b| khbt| <)8 tgkbv abttht |ohi dgi|vbd| |g egva cilh~hilhi| xicuhvthtzocdo abs huhi|xbkks fhdgah bt kbvjh gv kbvjhv |obi gxv gzi) Zc|oci hbdo ge |ohth xicuhvtht+ bi

higvagxt ixafhv ge jvbuc|b|cgibk gf`hd|t egva bil xilhvjg |ohcv gzi jvbuc|b|cgibk dgkkb~th |gfhdgah |oh ih| jhihvb|cgi ge xicuhvtht) Bt kgij bt |oh mhs ~bvbah|hvt zocdo lh|hvacih |ohfhobucgv ge ab||hv+ vblcb|cgi+ bil jvbuc|b|cgi obuh Jvbuc|b|cgibk \vbitegvab|cgit hrxbk |g xic|s+ |oixafhv ge jhihvb|cgit ge xicuhvtht zocdo dbi vhtxk| evga |oct ~vgdhtt zgxkl thha |g fh xikcac|h\oh vhkhubi| |vbitegvab|cgit kct|hl ci \bfkh ?)24)2 ahh| |oct vhrxcvhahi|) \oh Jvbuc|s\vbitegvab|cgit egv ^kbidm*t Dgit|bi|+ |oh Lchkhd|vcd Dgit|bi|+ |oh Hvjg!jvbuc|b|cgibk Dgit|bi| bi|oh Ecih T|vxd|xvh Dgit|bi| bvh bkk hrxbk |g xic|s bil+ ce |oh ^vcidc~kh ge Vhkb|cuc|s ct vcjgvgxtksubkcl+ |ohi bkk g|ohv exilbahi|bk ~bvbah|hvt zckk ahh| |oct dvc|hvcb) \ohvh abs fh+ ogzhuhv+ bigfthvub|cgibk lctbjvhhahi| zc|o |oh dgidh~| ge bi xikcac|hl ixafhv ge jhihvb|cgit ge xicuhvtht)\oh uhkgdc|s b| zocdo bt|vgigacdbk gf`hd|t vhdhlh evga hbdo g|ohv lxh |g |oh &h~bitcgi& ge gxvXicuhvth obt fhhi vh~gv|hl |g ubvs ci t|h~t ge bfgx| :> mckgah|hvt ~hv thdgil vb|ohv |obi ubvscij

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 77/110

xicegvaks zc|o lct|bidh) Ce |oct heehd| bd|xbkks gddxvt bil ce c| lght ig| vhtxk| evga bi h~kbcibfkhdbxth+ |oh bftgkx|h ubkclc|s ge |oh ^vcidc~kh ge Vhkb|cuc|s+ bil agvh ~bv|cdxkbvks |oh migzkhljh zocdekgzt evga |ob| ~vcidc~kh+ zgxkl fh ci rxht|cgi) G|ohvzcth+ vhbkc|s abs zhkk fh |oh jvbileb|ohv ge bkevbd|bkt zc|o c|t fbtcd ~b||hvi fhcij |ob| ge bi cilcuclxbk xicuhvth)

22)?! Bt zckk fh lctdxtthl ci |oh ih| dob~|hvt+ |oh ~gttcfckc|s hct|t |ob|+ ci |oh gvcjcibk xicuhvth/bi bidht|gv ge gxv gzi# |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| bil |oh uhkgdc|s ge |oh rxbi|xa echkl bvh hrxbk fx|+zockh |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ct vhlxdhl fs |oh ~vgcac|s ge hihvjs /jvbuc|b|cgi#+ |oh uhkgdc|s gerxbi|xa echkl/t# abs fh beehd|hl |g b axdo tabkkhv lhjvhh+ ce b| bkk) Ce |oct ct |oh dbth+ |oh ~ostcdt g

|oh gvcjcibk xicuhvth zgxkl lceehv jvhb|ks evga |oh ~ostcdt ge txfthrxhi| jhihvb|cgit ge xicuhvthtOgzhuhv+ |oh ~ostcdt ge |oh kb|hv xicuhvtht togxkl fh htthi|cbkks clhi|cdbk)

Dob~|hv 26 ! \oh T~bdh \cah Dgi|cixxa

26)2! Ci gxv dgiuhi|cgibk h~hvchidh+ bi huhi| ct igvabkks dgitclhvhl |g |bmh ~kbdh b| b kgdb|cgilhtdvcfhl ci |hvat ge |ovhh t~b|cbk dggvlcib|ht bil gih |ha~gvbk dggvlcib|h) Egv hba~kh+ ce b kcjofxkf ct |xvihl gi ci b vgga+ |oh tgxvdh ge |ob| kcjo| acjo| fh lhtdvcfhl bt fhcij egxv ehh| evga |oh

igv|o zbkk+ |ovhh ehh| evga |oh hbt| zbkk+ bil ecuh ehh| evga |oh ekggv bil |oh |cah b| zocdo |oh kcjo|zbt |xvihl gi acjo| fh lhtdvcfhl bt 60>< ^A gi @xks 4+ 2335) Gih acjo| |ohi btm zos Ib|xvhha~kgst |ovhh t~b|cbk lcahitcgit bil gih |cah lcahitcgi bt |oh fbtcd t|vxd|xvh ge vhbkc|s) Zoscti*| vhbkc|s fxck| zc|o b lceehvhi| ixafhv ge t~b|cbk lcahitcgit /hj0! gih+ |zg+ egxv+ gv ecuh#7 Zoslght c| obuh b tcijkh |cah lcahitcgi bkgij zocdo vhbkc|s ~vgjvhttht ci b tcijkh lcvhd|cgi evga ~bt|g ex|xvh7

26)6! \ovhh Lcahitcgibk Hxdkclcbi T~bdh0!\g hbacih txdo rxht|cgit dgitclhv ecvt| |oh~gttcfckc|cht ciohvhi| ci dgi|cixxat lceehvcij ci |oh ixafhv ge t~b|cbk lcahitcgit |ohs dgi|bci) Bt~bdh dgitct|cij ge phvg lcahitcgit ct b ab|ohab|cdbk ~gci| bil huhi|t dbiig| gddxv) \ohvh zgxkig| fh vgga) B t~bdh dgitct|cij ge gih lcahitcgi ct b kcih bil+ zockh c| dbi hct|+ huhi|t t|ckkdbiig| gddxv fhdbxth ~gci|t kgdb|hl bkgij |ob| kcih dbiig| ~btt hbdo g|ohv |g dobijh |ohcv

thrxhidh) Egv huhi|t |g gddxv+ b t~bdh ge |zg gv|ogjgibk t~b|cbk lcahitcgit ct vhrxcvhl tg bt |gbkkgz ~gci|t |g dobijh |ohcv vhkb|cuh kgdb|cgit fs jgcij bvgxil hbdo g|ohv fx|+ egv |ogth huhi|t |ggddxv+ hihvjs axt| fh ~vhthi| |g dbxth |oha) Hihvjs ct b egvdh bd|cij |ovgxjo b lct|bidh bil+ btlct|bidh xtht x~ gih ge |oh |zg t~b|cbk lcahitcgit+ |oh egvdh axt| fh b~~kchl |g |oh vhabcicijt~b|cbk lcahitcgi) Tcidh |ob| tcijkh t~b|cbk lcahitcgi ct b kcih+ c| obt phvg dvgtt!thd|cgibk bvhb bi|oh tkcjo|ht| egvdh b~~kchl |g c| zckk ~vglxdh bi ciecic|h ~vhttxvh) Hihvjs bil |oh huhi|t |ob| hihvjsdbxth dbiig| hct| ci b dgi|cixxa ge |zg t~b|cbk lcahitcgit fhdbxth ciecic|h ~vhttxvh ct ciecic|hkslht|vxd|cuh) Bllcij b |ocvl t~b|cbk lcahitcgi vhkchuht |oh lceecdxk|s) B egvdh bd|cij bkgij gih ge |oht~b|cbk lcahitcgit ct |ohi b~~kchl |g |oh bvhb vh~vhthi|hl fs |oh vhabcicij |zg t~b|cbk lcahitcgibil |oh ~vhttxvh vhtxk|cij evga |oh ~vhthidh ge hihvjs vhabcit ecic|h) Hdh~| egv |oh dgidh~|xbklh|gxv ci|vglxdhl fs Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s+ |ovhh t~b|cbk lcahitcgit zgxkl thha |g fh blhrxb|h egv

Ib|xvh*t ~xv~gtht) /Tgah bx|ogvt obuh t|b|hl |ob| t|bfkh gvfc|t bvh ig| ~gttcfkh ci b xicuhvthobucij egxv gv agvh t~b|cbk lcahitcgit)# Zockh |oh bx|ogv ct dhv|bci |ob| abis ~ostcdct|t zckk gf`hdt|vgijks |g |oh bx|ogv*t dgidkxtcgit zc|o vht~hd| |g |oh lcahitcgibk dgi|hi| ge t~bdh+ |ohcvlctbjvhhahi| dbi giks dgitclhvhl |g obuh txft|bidh ce c| ct bddga~bichl fs b lhagit|vb|cgi ge btabkk lct~kbdhahi|+ ~hvob~t b evbd|cgi ge bi cido+ ci b lcvhd|cgi zocdo ct gv|ogjgibk |g gxv |ovhhebackcbv t~b|cbk lcahitcgit) \oh giks `xt|cecdb|cgi egv b fhkche |ob| t~bdh ct vh~vhthi|hl fs b |ovhhlcahitcgibk igi!Hxdkclcbi jhgah|vs bvh gfthvub|cgit zocdo obuh fhhi ablh fh|zhhi vhehvhidhevbaht lceehvcij ci hkhub|cgi zc|ogx| b dgvvhd|cgi egv |oh heehd| ge hkhub|cgi lceehvhidht gi |oh xic|tge ahbtxvhahi| obucij fhhi ablh) \ohvh ct ig mcil zbs |g tbs c|+ |ogth gfthvub|cgit vh~vhthi|fbl tdchidh) Zohi |oh ~vg~hv dgvvhd|cgit bvh ablh+ |oh jhgah|vs ge t~bdh ct egxil |g fh |ovhhlcahitcgibk Hxdkclcbi)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 78/110

26)4! Kht| |ohvh fh b actxilhvt|bilcij+ |oh bx|ogv obt ig rxbvvhk zc|o |oh xth ge igi!Hxdkclcbi gvaxk|c!lcahitcgibk jhgah|vs ci |oh ab|ohab|cdbk tgkx|cgit ge ~ostcdbk ~vgfkhat) Fhdbxth |oh~thxlg!lcahitcgit ge igi!Hxdkclcbi bil'gv axk|c!lcahitcgibk jhgah|vs obuh b ~vg~hv|s zocdo|ohs tobvh zc|o t~b|cbk lcahitcgit+ igi!ci|hvbd|cgi fh|zhhi bht+ |ohcv ~thxlg!jhgah|vs dbi fhrxc|h xthexk ci |oh tgkx|cgi ge ~ostcdbk ~vgfkhat) C| ct ig| dkhbv+ ogzhuhv+ |ob| igi!Hxdkclcbijhgah|vs dbi lhbk dgvvhd|ks zc|o ~ohigahib zocdo ciugkuh hihvjs) \oh bx|ogv*t gf`hd|cgi gddxvtzohi ~ostcdct|t zog obuh khbvihl |ohcv ~vgehttcgi fs vg|h btthv| |ob| |oh ~thxlg!jhgah|vs gedxvuhl t~bdh vh~vhthi|t vhbkc|s) Txdo cilcuclxbkt bvh b~~bvhi|ks tb|ctechl |g ~hvegva |ohcvdbkdxkb|cgit zc|ogx| xilhvt|bilcij |oh vhbkc|s |ohs vh~vhthi| bil+ bt b vhtxk|+ dbi hbtcks fh actkhl

zohi |ohs ci|hv~vh| |ohcv ecilcijt)

26)<! \oh \cah Lcahitcgi0! Ib|xvh vhrxcvht gih agvh lcahitcgi ci gvlhv |g exid|cgi) C| vhrxcvht |olcahitcgi ge |cah) \oh |ovhh t~b|cbk lcahitcgit ~vguclh |oh vgga egv huhi|t |g gddxv bil bkkgz |ohihvjs vhrxcvhl |g ca~hk |ogth huhi|t |g hct|) \oh dobijht zocdo huhi|t vh~vhthi| gddxv ci bthrxhidh zocdo abs fh dgitclhvhl |g fh b |vbitkb|cgi ge |oh |ovhh t~b|cbk bht bkgij bi bct zocdct gv|ogjgibk |g |oha) \oh heehd| ge |ob| |vbitkb|cgi ge |oh |ovhh t~b|cbk bht vhtxk|t ci |oh ~bttbjhge |cah ci zocdo |oh ~vhthi| egkkgzt |oh ~bt| bil |oh ex|xvh egkkgzt |oh ~vhthi|) \oh egxv|olcahitcgi lght ig| vhkb|h |g zohvh+ c| vhkb|ht |g zohi)

26)8! \oh ~bttbjh ge |cah ct ci|xc|cuhks gfucgxt) \oh rxht|cgi zocdo |ob| ~bttbjh ~gtht ct zos c|~vgjvhttht evga ~bt| |g ex|xvh bil ig| evga ex|xvh |g ~bt|) Ce |oh huhi|t zocdo bvh dgitclhvhl bvhtca~kh higxjo+ |ohvh ct ig zbs |g |hkk |oh lcvhd|cgi ge |cah) B ag|cgi ~cd|xvh togzcij |oh ca~bd| ge|zg fckkcbvl fbkkt b~~hbvt rxc|h vhbtgibfkh zohi c| ct ~vg`hd|hl ci |oh egvzbvl gv ci |oh vhuhvthlcvhd|cgi) \oh tc|xb|cgi ct lceehvhi| ce |oh ag|cgi ~cd|xvh togzt |oh cic|cbk fvhbm ge |oh fbkkt ci bjbah ge ~ggk) Ce |oh ag|cgi ~cd|xvh ct vxi ci |oh igvabk lcvhd|cgi+ |oh dxh fbkk ct gfthvuhl |g t|vcmh |vcbijxkbv dkxt|hv ge 28 fbkkt) \oh 25 fbkkt |ohi aguh ci 25 lceehvhi| lcvhd|cgit b| 25 lceehvhi|uhkgdc|cht bil |oh gfthvuhv dgitclhvt |oh lct~kbs |g fh rxc|h vhbtgibfkh) Ce |oh ag|cgi ~cd|xvh ct vxfbdmzbvl+ 25 fbkkt b~~vgbdo hbdo g|ohv b| 25 lceehvhi| uhkgdc|cht evga 25 lceehvhi| kgdb|cgit bilbvvbijh |ohathkuht zc|o 28 ge |oha ci b dga~bd| t|b|cgibvs |vcbijkh bil zc|o b tcijkh fbkk lh~bv|cievga |oh b~h ge |oh |vcbijkh b| b ocjo uhkgdc|s) Bi gfthvuhv uchzcij txdo b lct~kbs zckk dgidkxlh|ob| |oh ag|cgi ~cd|xvh obt fhhi vxi fbdmzbvlt fhdbxth |oh ~vgfbfckc|s ge |oh huhi|t+ bt lct~kbshgddxvvcij ib|xvbkks ct ubictocijks tabkk)

26)5! \ohvh ct b exilbahi|bk lceehvhidh fh|zhhi |oh |zg hba~kht) Ci |oh dbth ge |oh ca~bd| ge |oh|zg fckkcbvl fbkkt+ |ohvh ct ig dobijh ci |oh bagxi| ge ciegvab|cgi ~vhthi| fhegvh bil be|hv |ohcvca~bd|) \oh |g|bk vhkhubi| ciegvab|cgi ~vcgv |g ca~bd| ct |oh ~gtc|cgi bil uhkgdc|s ge |zg fckkcbvlfbkkt) \oh tc|xb|cgi ct lceehvhi| ci |oh dbth ge |oh fvhbmcij ge b vbdm ge ~ggk fbkkt) ^vcgv |g ca~bd|+ ge|oh 25 fbkkt ciugkuhl+ 28 ge |oha bvh kgdmhl ci|g b ~b||hvi zocdo obt b tcijkh ~gtc|cgi bil phvguhkgdc|s zockh |oh 25|o fbkk obt fg|o b uhkgdc|s bil ~gtc|cgi) Giks egxv tcjicecdbi| c|hat geciegvab|cgi hct|) Egkkgzcij |oh ca~bd| ge |oh dxh fbkkt+ 25 fbkkt obuh cilcuclxbk ~gtc|cgit biluhkgdc|cht bil 46 tcjicecdbi| c|hat ge ciegvab|cgi hct|) /\zg c|hat ge ciegvab|cgi bvh vhrxcvhl |gvh~vhthi| ~gtc|cgi bil uhkgdc|s gi |oh txvebdh ge |oh |zg lcahitcgibk |bfkh) \ohs bvh hbdo |vhb|hlbt b tcijkh c|ha |g bugcl dga~kcdb|cij |oh lctdxttcgi)# Gih ct khl |g |oh dgidkxtcgi |ob| |oh ekgz ge|cah evga |oh ~bt| |g |oh ex|xvh ct bddga~bichl fs bi cidvhbth ci |oh |g|bk bagxi| ge ciegvab|cgi g

c|t hrxcubkhi|+ |oh |g|bk rxbi|c|s ge hi|vg~s+ ci |oh Xicuhvth) Tcidh fg|o jvbuc|b|cgibk dgkkb~th bil|oh xicuhvth dvhb|cgi ~vgdhtt lhtdvcfhl hbvkchv ciugkuh bi higvagxt cidvhbth ci |g|bk ciegvab|cgidgi|hi|+ |cah axt| ~vgjvhtt ci |oh lcvhd|cgi ge |ob| dgkkb~th+ evga ~bt| |g ~vhthi| |g ex|xvh) CiDob~|hv 2> c| zbt togzi |ob| |oh hihvjs dgi|hi| ge bkk ab||hv zbt ocjohv ci |oh ~bt| bil zckk fhkgzhv ci |oh ex|xvh) B vhuhvtbk ge |oh ekgz ge |cah+ huhi kgdbkks+ zgxkl vhrxcvh bi higvagxt ci~x| gehihvjs)

26):! Txv~vctcijks+ |ohvh thhat |g fh b tdoggk ge |ogxjo| bagij ~ostcdct|t |ob| T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|sbkkgzt c| |g fh ~gttcfkh |g |vbitehv ciegvab|cgi evga |oh ex|xvh |g |oh ~bt| ce ebt|hv |obi kcjo|dgaaxicdb|cgi dgxkl fh bdochuhl) \ohcv dgidh~| ct fbthl x~gi |oh clhb |ob| ce ~gci|t B bil F zhv~ostcdbkks th~bvb|hl fx| agucij b| |oh tbah uhkgdc|s+ bi gfthvuhv b| ~gci| B dgxkl dgitclhv |ob|

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 79/110

~gci|t B bil F zhvh agucij ci b lcvhd|cgi evga F |g B) Bt b vhtxk|+ b tcjibk thi| |g ~gci| F b| buhkgdc|s jvhb|hv |obi |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| zgxkl bvvcuh fhegvh c| zbt thi|) Tcackbvks+ bi gfthvuhv b|~gci| F dgxkl dgitclhv |ob| ~gci|t B bil F zhvh agucij ci b lcvhd|cgi |gzbvlt ~gci| F bil |ob| btcjibk thi| |g ~gci| B b| b uhkgdc|s jvhb|hv |obi |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| zgxkl bktg bvvcuh fhegvh c| oblfh thi|) \ohs |ohi dgidkxlh |ob| ce b ebt|hv |obi kcjo| tcjibk zhvh thi| evga F |g B |oh cit|bi| |ob| bebt|hv |obi kcjo| tcjibk zbt vhdhcuhl evga B+ |oh vgxil |vc~ tcjibk evga B |g F |g B zgxkl fhvhdhcuhl fhegvh c| obl fhhi thi| bil b tcjibk zgxkl obuh fhhi vhdhcuhl evga |oh ex|xvh) Egv|xib|hegv |oh dbtcig cilxt|vs+ ebt|hv |obi kcjo| dgaaxicdb|cgi zckk ig| bdochuh txdo b vhtxk|) \oh ebkkbds |ob|+ zockh c| ct khjc|cab|h |g bddh~| |ob| b ebt|hv |obi kcjo| tcjibk thi| evga B |g F dbi fh dgitclhvh

|g bvvcuh fhegvh c| zbt thi| bil c| ct bktg khjc|cab|h |g dgitclhv |ob| b ebt|hv |obi kcjo| tcjibk thi|evga F |g B dbi fh dgitclhvhl |g bvvcuh fhegvh c| zbt thi|+ c| ct ig| khjc|cab|h |g ogkl fg|ouchz~gci|t tcaxk|bihgxtks fhdbxth |ob| uchz ~gci| vhrxcvht B bil F |g fh agucij b| |zg lceehvhi|uhkgdc|cht b| |oh tbah |cah) Dgaaxicdb|cgi gv |vbuhk evga |oh ex|xvh |g |oh ~bt| ct ig| ~gttcfkhxilhv bis khjc|cab|h ~ostcdbk |ohgvs) C| giks b~~hbvt ~gttcfkh ce gih*t vhbtgicij ~vgdhttht bvhkcac|hl)

26)?! \oh Fbvvchv b| |oh ^bt|!Ex|xvh Ci|hvebdh0!\oh dgidh~| ge ihjb|cuh |cah b~~hbvt abis |caht ciab|ohab|cdbk |vhb|ahi|t ge ~ostcdbk ~vgfkhat vbijcij evga Lv) Ehsiabii*t gfthvub|cgi |ob| c| ctca~gttcfkh |g lct|cijxcto fh|zhhi b ~gtc|cuh hkhd|vgi |vbuhkcij egvzbvl ci |cah bil b ihjb|cuhhkhd|vgi |vbuhkcij fbdmzbvlt ci |cah |g bi bibkstct ge BA vblcg dgaaxicdb|cgi) Zockh abiscilcuclxbkt dgitclhv |ob| fhdbxth ab|ohab|cdt bkkgzt bil ci abis dbtht vhrxcvht |oh dgidh~| geihjb|cuh |cah+ |ob|+ ci ib|xvbk ~vgdhttht+ |cah axt| bd|xbkks fh bfkh |g ekgz ci vhuhvth) \oct ~vhthibig|ohv tc|xb|cgi zohvh gih axt| ihuhv bttxah)

26)3! B tcackbv heehd| gddxvt ci tx~~vhtthl dbvvchv aglxkb|cgi ge vblcg tcjibkt+ bt togzi ci Ecjxvh26)2) Ab|ohab|cdbkks+ |oh ~vgdhtt dgitct|t ge |oh axk|c~kcdb|cgi ge |oh ci~x| tcjibk /tca~kct|cdbkkstogzi bt b tca~kh tcih zbuh b| b evhrxhids ge zt# fs |oh tcixtgclbk dbvvchv evhrxhids+ zd) \oh

vhtxk| ge |oh axk|c~kcdb|cgi ~vgdhtt ct |zg tcjibkt+ gih ge zocdo ct |oh txa ge |oh |zg evhrxhidchtbil |oh g|ohv ct |oh lceehvhidh fh|zhhi |oha+ bt togzi) ^bttcij |oh dga~gtc|h tcjibk |ovgxjo bkgz ~btt eck|hv vh`hd|t |oh ocjohv evhrxhids tcjibk bil ~vguclht b tcijkh tcjibk b| |oh lceehvhidhevhrxhids zocdo dgi|bcit bkk ge |oh ciegvab|cgi gvcjcibkks ~vhthi| bil zocdo gddx~cht obke ge |ohfbilzcl|o bil vhrxcvht gih rxbv|hv ge |oh ~hbm ~gzhv ge b dgiuhi|cgibk BA vblcg |vbitacttcgi)

/^bttcij |oh tcjibk |ovgxjo b ocjo ~btt eck|hv hkcacib|ht |oh lceehvhidh evhrxhids tcjibk bil|vbitac|t |oh txa evhrxhids tcjibk)# \oh t~hd|vxa ge |oh tx~~vhtthl dbvvchv aglxkb|hl tcjibkt cttogzi ci Ecjxvh 26)6B) Zc|o b phvg evhrxhids tcjibk+ |oh txa bil lceehvhidh evhrxhids tcjibkttx~hvca~gth b| |oh dbvvchv evhrxhids) Zohi |oh tcjibk evhrxhids ct hrxbk |g obke ge |oh dbvvchvevhrxhids+ |oh lceehvhidh evhrxhids tcjibk bktg b~~hbvt b| obke ge |oh dbvvchv evhrxhids zockh |ohtxa evhrxhids tcjibk b~~hbvt b| 2)8 |caht |oh dbvvchv evhrxhids) \oh ci|hvht|cij dbth gddxvt zohigih dgitclhvt |oh tcjibk evhrxhids |g fh ocjohv |obi |oh dbvvchv evhrxhids) B tca~kh acilhlab|ohab|cdbk bibkstct txjjht|t |ob|+ egv b tcjibk evhrxhids 2)8 |caht |oh dbvvchv evhrxhids+ |oh txevhrxhids zckk fh 6)8 |caht |oh dbvvchv evhrxhids /~hvehd|ks vhbtgibfkh# fx| |oh lceehvhidh evhrxhidzckk obuh |oh xivhbtgibfkh ubkxh ge acixt gih obke ge |oh dbvvchv evhrxhids) Ci gvlhv egv |ob| |ggddxv+ |cah zgxkl obuh |g ekgz ci vhuhvth) Ib|xvh+ ogzhuhv+ lght ig| bkkgz |oct |g gddxv) Cit|hbl+|oh bd|xbk ~ostcdbk ~vgdhtt vhkcht x~gi |oh tsaah|vs ge |oh tcixtgclbk exid|cgi |g bkkgz |ohvhekhd|cgi ge |oh lceehvhidh evhrxhids tcjibk evga b &acvvgv& b| |oh ~bt|!~vhthi| ci|hvebdh bil b~~hbt b ~obth ciuhv|hl tcjibk b| obke ge |oh dbvvchv evhrxhids) \oh vhekhd|cgi ~vgdhtt b| |oh ~bt|!~vhthci|hvebdh ct bibkgjgxt |g |oh vhekhd|cgi ge bi cabjh evga |oh acvvgv ge Ecjxvh 26)6F)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 80/110

26)2>! \ohvh ct bi bllc|cgibk ebd|gv ciugkuhl ci |oh ~bttbjh ge |cah) Ciegvab|cgi bfgx| |oh ~bt| dbifh vhahafhvhl ci |oh ~vhthi| zockh ciegvab|cgi bfgx| |oh ex|xvh dbiig|+ b| khbt| |g b lhjvhh zocdoct txf`hd| |g vcjgvgxt uhvcecdb|cgi) \oct khblt |g |oh dgidkxtcgi |ob| ciegvab|cgi dbi giks ekgz evga|oh ~bt| |g |oh ~vhthi|+ fx| |ob| dgidkxtcgi abs ig| fh dga~kh|hks |vxh) \oh Fcfkh vhdgxi|t |oh~vhlcd|cgit ge |oh ^vg~oh|t bil btthv|t |ob| abis ge |oha obuh dgah |g ~btt) C| ct dkbcahl |ob|~tsdocdt dbi+ b| |caht+ egvhthh |oh ex|xvh) Cilcuclxbkt obuh vh~gv|hl h~hvchidht zocdo acjo| fhci|hv~vh|hl bt b ahagvs ge b ex|xvh huhi| bil+ ci |oh ~vgdhtt+ tgah obuh ~vhlcd|hl tcjicecdbi|huhi|t ~vcgv |g |ohcv gddxvvhidh fx| |ohcv vh~gv|t bvh ciubvcbfks b||vcfx|hl |g dgcidclhidh gv gx|vcjo

ebmhvs) Vh`hd|cgi ge |oh ~gttcfckc|s fs gv|oglg tdchidh abs fh ig| fh vcjgvgxtks ubkcl) Ciegvab|cgilght ig| ihdhttbvcks ciugkuh hihvjs /h)j)! ciegvab|cgi vh~vhthi|hl fs |oh ~gkbvcpb|cgi bct ge b~og|gi# bil+ ce |oh ciegvab|cgi lght ig| ciugkuh hihvjs+ c|t |vbitehv ct ig| ihdhttbvcks txf`hd| |g bkge |oh kcac|b|cgit |ob| Ib|xvh ca~gtht x~gi |oh |vbitehv ge ciegvab|cgi vh~vhthi|hl fs hihvjs)^hvob~t |ohvh ct b fbdmekgz ge ciegvab|cgi evga |oh ex|xvh |g |oh ~vhthi|+ fx|+ ce |ob| fbdm ekgz cttabkk dga~bvhl |g |oh |oh egvzbvl ekgz ge ciegvab|cgi evga |oh ~bt| |g |oh ~vhthi|+ h~hvcahi|t zbkzbst ~vguh |ob| |oh vhuhvth ciegvab|cgi ekgz ~b|o lght ig| hct|) Dxk|xvbk fcbt bd|t |g ~vhuhi| |oh~hvcahi|bk vhdgjic|cgi ge txdo bi heehd|+ ~bv|cdxkbvks tcidh huhi |oh tabkkht| lhjvhh ge vhuhvthciegvab|cgi ekgz zgxkl vhtxk| ci thuhvh ~ockgtg~ocdbk ~bvblght)

26)22! T~bdh+ \cah bil Dggvlcib|h Tst|ha! Gih axt| vhdgjicph |ob| t~bdh ct b fbtcd dobvbd|hvct|ge vhbkc|s bil bt txdo ct cit|cid|cuhks xilhvt|ggl fs bkk agfckh dvhb|xvht) C| ct giks tsafgk xtcij

abimcil |ob| bttgdcb|ht b dggvlcib|h tst|ha zc|o t~bdh ci gvlhv |g fh bfkh |g rxbi|ces c|) Ab||hvhct|t ci t~bdh `xt| bt sgx dxvvhi|ks hct| ci |oh vgga ci zocdo sgx bvh vhblcij |oct |h|+ fx| kcmhsgxv vgga*t vhkb|cgitoc~ |g sgx+ c| dgi|cixht |g hct| zohi sgx bvh bfthi|) T~bdh ct bi xidobijcijugkxah /ci |oh &bftgkx|h& thith# zocdo abs gv abs ig| dgi|bci hihvjs gv ab||hv fx| zocdo lghtdgi|bci tgah|ocij tcidh c| obt gfthvubfkh ~vg~hv|cht txdo bt b lchkhd|vcd dgit|bi|+ ~hvahbfckc|s+ bfbvvchv zocdo ~vhuhi|t hihvjs evga hdhhlcij |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| bil ~hvob~t g|ohv ~vg~hv|chtzocdo bvh sh| ximigzi) C| ct dobvbd|hvct|cd ge t~bdh |ob| |ogth ~vg~hv|cht bvh beehd|hl fs |oh~vhthidh ge hihvjs bil dbxth ab||hv |g vhlxdh c|t tcph bil |g kgth hihvjs |ohvhfs dbxtcij bici|hvibk gfthvuhv |g ebkthks dgidkxlh |ob| t~bdh obt fhhi dvhb|hl fs |oh ~vgcac|s ge hihvjs)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 81/110

Dob~|hv 24 ! \oh Ib|xvh ge ^bv|cdkht

24)2! Bt togzi hbvkchv+ kgjcdbk lhlxd|cgit fbthl x~gi ~ostcdbk gfthvub|cgi bil h~hvcahi|t fsrxbi|xa ~ostcdct|t obuh lhagit|vb|hl |ob| t~bdh axt| fh eckkhl zc|o |oh Bh|ohv ge |oh Kgvhi|pDgi|vbd|cgi!Bh|ohv \ohgvs vb|ohv |obi |oh ig|ocijihtt btthv|hl fs blohvhi|t ge T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|sExv|ohvagvh+ ig| giks axt| |oh Bh|ohv fh b tgkcl ci gvlhv egv c| |g ~vg~bjb|h |oh |vbituhvthucfvb|cgit ge hkhd|vgabjih|cd vblcb|cgi+ |ob| tgkcl axt| fh bftgkx|hks dgi|cixgxt ce |oh abvuhkgxtahdobicta zh h~hvchidh bt vhbkc|s ct |g exid|cgi) /Ce gih gfthvuht b dgiuhi|cgibk bx|gagfckh|vbuhkcij lgzi b vgbl+ oh ct tbeh ci dgidkxlcij |ob| |oh dbv obt b lvcuhtobe| ge tgah |s~h fh|zhhic|t |vbitacttcgi bil zohhkt huhi |ogxjo oh dbiig| gfthvuh |ob| tobe|)# \oh dgidh~|xbk lceecdxk|s|ob| vhabcit ct |ob|+ zockh b tgkcl Bh|ohv ct dga~b|cfkh zc|o |oh ~vg~bjb|cgi ge vblcb|cgi+ tgkcl~bv|cdkht togxkl ig| fh bfkh |g aguh |ovgxjo c|) Gih acjo| dgidkxlh |ob| t~bdh axt| fg|o fh eckkhlzc|o |oh Bh|ohv bil fh lhugcl ge |oh Bh|ohv+ bi gfucgxt bftxvlc|s) Ib|xvh+ ogzhuhv+ ct b vhtgxvdhe

gkl fcvl bil obt b~~bvhi|ks tgkuhl |oh ~vgfkha ci zob| abs fh |oh giks zbs ~gttcfkh) \oh bx|ogvfhkchuht c| dgiecjxvht b zbuh tg bt |g dbxth c| |g fhobuh bt ce c| zhvh b ~bv|cdkh) \g hbacih |oct~gttcfckc|s+ c| ct ecvt| ihdhttbvs |g hbacih |oh hkhd|vgabjih|cd zbuh bil |oh ~og|git zocdodga~vcth |ob| zbuh)

24)6! Dgitclhv bi hkhd|vgabjih|cd zbuh vhtxk|cij evga |oh |vbitacttcgi ge b uhv|cdbkks ~gkbvcphltcjibk fs b vblcg |vbitac||hv+ txdo bt ckkxt|vb|hl fs Ecjxvh 24)2) Zockh c| ct dgaagi ~vbd|cdh |gdgitclhv |ob| txdo b zbuh ct dgi|cixgxt+ ~vgjvhttcuhks vhlxdcij c|t ci|hitc|s huhi|xbkks vhuhbkt c| fh dga~gthl ge lctdvh|h ~bdmh|t ge hihvjs dbkkhl ~og|git) Ci gvlhv egv |oct |g fh |oh dbth+ |oh zbuaxt| fh dga~gthl ge tsidovgicphl ~og|git zocdo vhciegvdh hbdo g|ohv tg bt |g ~vg~bjb|h bt bib~~bvhi|ks dgi|cixgxt zbuh) ^og|git axt| obuh |oh egkkgzcij dobvbd|hvct|cdt0

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 82/110

Th~bvb|hks+ |oh ~og|git axt| fh hkhd|vgabjih|cd ca~xktht ~vg~bjb|cij b| |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjor

\oh ih| hkhd|vcd+ abjih|cd+ bil ahdobicdbk heehd|t ge hbdo ca~xkth axt| hrxbk phvg zohibuhvbjhl guhv |cah)

r

Zohi b txeecdchi| ixafhv ge |ohth ca~xktht bvh tx~hvca~gthl zc|o |oh b~~vg~vcb|h |cacij bi~obtcij+ |ohs axt| ~vglxdh |oh b~~bvhi|ks dgi|cixgxt hkhd|vgabjih|cd zbuh ge Ecjxvh 24)2)

r

24)4! \g lhtdvcfh ogz |oh ~og|gi ahh|t |ohth vhrxcvhahi|t+ b ab|ohab|cdbk lhucdh migzi bt bi

ca~xkth exid|cgi+ txdo bt togzi ci Ecjxvh 24)6+ ct vhrxcvhl) /\ohvh ct b dkbtt ge ab|ohab|cdbkexid|cgit migzi bt ca~xkth exid|cgit) \oh gih togzi ct |oh tca~kht| bil zbt |ohvhegvh thkhd|hlegv |oh lctdxttcgi zocdo egkkgzt fx| c| axt| fh vhahafhvhl |ob| Ib|xvh abs ha~kgs b lceehvhi|uhvtcgi ci |oh ~og|gi)# Axk|c~kscij |oh hkhd|vgabjih|cd zbuh ge Ecjxvh 24)2 fs bi ca~xkth exid|cgi~vguclht b txc|bfkh dgiecjxvb|cgi egv |oh ~og|gi+ bt togzi ci Ecjxvh 24)4) \oct dgiecjxvb|cgi dbi|vbuhk |ovgxjo |oh Bh|ohv hc|ohv fs c|thke gv+ zohi jvgx~hl ci b tsidovgicphl thrxhidh+ bt bihkhd|vgabjih|cd zbuh)

24)<! \oh hihvjs dgi|hi| ge b ~og|gi obt fhhi lh|hvacihl |g fh lcvhd|ks ~vg~gv|cgibk |g c|tevhrxhids /ciuhvthks ~vg~gv|cgibk |g c|t |cah lxvb|cgi# zc|o |oh dgit|bi| ge ~vg~gv|cgibkc|s fhcijhrxbk |g ^kbidm*t Dgit|bi|) Bt b dgithrxhidh+ zh abs dgidkxlh |ob| |oh ba~kc|xlh ge b ~og|gi*thkhd|vcd bil abjih|cd uhd|gvt cidvhbtht ci ~vg~gv|cgi |g |oh trxbvh vgg| ge c|t hihvjs+ ci bi abiih

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 83/110

bibkgjgxt |g |oh t|gvbjh ge hihvjs ci b dga~vhtthl t~vcij /lgxfkcij |oh lct|bidh fs zocdo bt~vcij ct dga~vhtthl bktg lgxfkht |oh egvdh ci |oh t~vcij bil cidvhbtht |oh hihvjs t|gvhl ci |oht~vcij fs b ebd|gv ge egxv#) Ecjxvh 24)< ckkxt|vb|ht |oh uhd|gvt ge |zg ~og|git zocdo lceehv ci hihvjsfs b ebd|gv ge |zg) \oh cidvhbthl evhrxhids ge |oh ocjohv hihvjs ~og|gi dgvvht~gilt |g c|t obucij|cah lxvb|cgi zocdo ct togv|hv |obi |ob| ge |oh kgzhv hihvjs ~og|gi)

24)8! \ohvh ct big|ohv |s~h ge vblcb|cgi zocdo vhrxcvht lctdxttcgi+ |oh vblcb|cgi vh~vhthi|hl fsihx|vcigt) G|ohv |obi |oh ebd|t |ob| ihx|vcigt kbdm hkhd|vgabjih|cd ~vg~hv|cht+ abmcij |ohah|vhahks lceecdxk| |g gfthvuh+ bil |ohs obuh ihuhv fhhi gfthvuhl |g dgafcih ci|g b dgi|cixgxt

zbuh+ |oh ihx|vcig thhat |g fh ge |oh tbah ib|xvh bt |oh ~og|gi) C| thhat vhbtgibfkh+ |ohvhegvh+ |~gt|xkb|h |oh hct|hidh ge ihx|vcicd vblcb|cgi zocdo ct bmci |g+ bil abs bd|xbkks fh b egva gehkhd|vgabjih|cd vblcb|cgi) Dgidh~|xbkks+ ogzhuhv+ ~vg~bjb|cgi ge |oh ihx|vcig ~vhthi|t b lceecdxk|szocdo lght ig| gddxv zc|o |oh ~og|gi) ^vg~bjb|cgi ge |oh ~og|gi vhrxcvht |oh ci|hvdobijh gehihvjs+ ~obthl 3> lhjvhht b~bv|+ fh|zhhi |zg ax|xbkks ~hv~hilcdxkbv bht /|oh hkhd|vcd bct bil|oh abjih|cd bct#) Zockh gih acjo| dgitclhv |oh ihx|vcig |g vhtxk| evga bi ca~xkth ge ahdobicdbkt|vhtt ci |oh Bh|ohv bkgij gih bct /h)j)! dgvvht~gilcij |g |oh hkhd|vcd t|vhtt ge |oh ~og|gi#+ |ohhihvjs t|gvbjh ahdobicta bkgij |oh g|ohv bct /dgvvht~gilcij |g |oh abjih|cd t|vhtt ge |oh~og|gi# ct ig| b~~bvhi|) Ogzhuhv+ ihx|vcigt hct| bil |ob| hihvjs t|gvbjh ahdobicta axt| bktghct|) Ci |xvi+ bibkgjgxt ~ohigahib |g |ogth ~vglxdhl fs ~og|git bil hkhd|vgabjih|cd zbuhttogxkl fh ~gttcfkh) \oh bx|ogv zgxkl og~h |ob| |oh txf`hd| zckk fh hbacihl agvh h|hitcuhks fsg|ohvt ci |oh ex|xvh)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 84/110

24)5! Ca~kcdc| ci |oh dgidkxtcgi |ob| tgkcl ab||hv dbiig| aguh |ovgxjo b tgkcl Bh|ohv ct |ohxi~vguhi bttxa~|cgi |ob| tgkcl ab||hv ct bd|xbkks tgkcl) H~hvcahi|t ci ~bv|cdkh ~ostcdt obuhtogzi |ob| hkhd|vgit bil ixlkhgit dgi|bci ig lh|hd|bfkh tgkcl t|vxd|xvh kbvjhv |obi |oh

gfthvub|cgibk kcac| ge 2>!2? ah|hvt) \oct ebd| bil |oh ebd| |ob| ab||hv dbi aguh heegv|khttks |ovgxjb tgkcl Bh|ohv vhrxcvh |ob| |oh bttxa~|cgi |ob| ab||hv ct tgkcl fh rxht|cgihl) C| ct ihdhttbvs |ghbacih ogz+ zob| b~~hbvt |g fh b tgkcl ~bv|cdkh+ abs bd|xbkks fh b ucfvb|cgi |vbuhkcij b| |ohuhkgdc|s ge kcjo| bil |oxt fh db~bfkh ge agucij |ovgxjo |oh tgkcl Bh|ohv bt hbtcks bt ~og|git gvihx|vcigt) Tcidh ~bv|cdkht ge ab||hv hct| zohi |ohs bvh b| vht| gv agucij tkgzks+ c| zgxkl thha |obtxdo b ~gttcfckc|s axt| fh vxkhl gx|+ fx| gih axt| ihuhv bttxah) Tgkcl ab||hv dgxkl aguh b| b

kgz uhkgdc|s bil sh| dgitct| ge b ucfvb|cgi |vbuhkcij b| |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ce |ob| ucfvb|cgi zhvh|vbuhkcij ci b dcvdkh) Egv |oct |g fh |oh ib|xvh ge tgkcl ab||hv+ tcijkh gv axk|c~kh dsdkht ge vblcb|cgizgxkl obuh |g fh fhi| ci|g b dcvdxkbv ~b|o zc|o |oh hilt `gcihl |g egva b kgg~) ^vguclcij txdo kgg~tdgi|bci bi ci|hjvbk ixafhv ge dsdkht+ |ohcv ucfvb|cgit zckk vhciegvdh bil |ohvh zgxkl thha |g fh igciohvhi| vhbtgi zos |ohs dgxkl ig| ~hvtct| cilhecic|hks) Tcidh |oh kgg~t bvh ucfvb|cgit+ |ohs bvh evh|g |vbuhk |ovgxjo |oh tgkcl Bh|ohv b| bis uhkgdc|s fh|zhhi |oh kcac|t ge -'!D bt hbtcks bt ~og|git gihx|vcigt) /Bt zckk fh lctdxtthl kb|hv+ |ohth kgg~t ca~ks |oh hct|hidh ge higvagxt kgdbkjvbuc|b|cgibk echklt)# Ci bllc|cgibk+ b ~vgdhtt zocdo dobijhl |oh ixafhv ge dsdkht dgi|bcihl ci txdb kgg~ zgxkl vhtxk| ci |oh vhkhbth gv bftgv~|cgi ge b ~og|gi/t# gv b ihx|vcig/t#)

24):! \g bi gfthvuhv+ txdo b kgg~ ge ucfvb|cgi zgxkl b~~hbv |g fh b ab|hvcbk ~bv|cdkh) Ce |oh kgg~ ctxit|bfkh+ c| zckk lhdbs be|hv b |cah bil vhkhbth tgah gv bkk ge c|t hihvjs ci |oh egva ge vblcb|cgi zc|o

|oh vhabcicij hihvjs ci |oh egva ge b kgzhv hihvjs ~bv|cdkh/t#) Ce |oh dgiecjxvb|cgi ge |oh kgg~ ctt|bfkh+ fbvvcij b thuhvh h|hvibk lct|xvfbidh+ c| zckk hct| egvhuhv bt b ab|hvcbk ~bv|cdkh) Ge bkk ge |ohgfthvuhl tgkcl ~bv|cdkht+ giks hkhd|vgit bil ~vg|git bil |ohcv bi|c!~bv|cdkht hocfc| |oh t|bfckc|svhrxcvhl egv ciecic|h kceh) Ihx|vgit bvh tkcjo|ks xit|bfkh bil lhdbs ci|g ~vg|git bil hkhd|vgit be|hv ehz acix|ht xikhtt |ohs bvh dgiecihl bkgij zc|o ~vg|git ci |oh ci|hvcgvt ge b|gacd ixdkhc) /^hvob~t|ohs togxkl fh dkbttcechl+ bkgij zc|o bkk g|ohv b|gacd bil txf!b|gacd ~bv|cdkht+ bt xit|bfkhdgiecjxvb|cgit ge vblcb|cgi kgg~t) B ~gttcfkh dbxth ge |oh ihx|vgi*t cit|bfckc|s zckk fh lctdxtthlkb|hv)#

24)?! \g xilhvt|bil ogz txdo b kgg~ ge vblcb|cgi acjo| egva b ab|hvcbk ~bv|cdkh+ dgitclhv |ohca~kcdb|cgit ciugkuhl ci dxvkcij gih dsdkh ge |oh dgi|cixgxt hkhd|vgabjih|cd zbuh togzi ci Ecjxvh

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 85/110

24)2 bfgx| c|t abjih|cd bct |g egva b kgg~+ bt togzi ci |oh khe| tclh ge Ecjxvh 24)8) Dxvkcij ge |ohtcijkh dsdkh ge vblcb|cgi vhtxk|t ci |oh ~vglxd|cgi ge b echl ~gkbvc|s hkhd|vcd uhd|gv vg|b|cij b| |zcdh|oh bijxkbv vb|h ge |oh hkhd|vcd uhd|gv zocdo egvahl |oh gvcjcibk hkhd|vgabjih|cd zbuh)/Ab|ohab|cdbkks+ |oh ~vgdhtt ct hrxcubkhi| |g trxbvcij |oh h~vhttcgi egv |oh hkhd|vcd ba~kc|xlhuhd|gv+ dgt]z|Q+ |g gf|bci >)8->)8dgt]6z|Q) \oh ~vhthidh ge |oh |hva+ 6z|+ cilcdb|ht |ob| |ohevhrxhids ge |oh uhd|gv vg|b|cgi obt lgxfkhl)# Bt gih zgxkl h~hd|+ |oh vg|b|cgi ge |ohhkhd|vgabjih|cd zbuh bfgx| c|t abjih|cd bct ~vglxdht b t|b|cgibvs abjih|cd lc~gkh) C| bktg~vglxdht b agig~gkh hkhd|vcd dobvjh fhdbxth c|t hkhd|vcd uhd|gv ct |oh trxbvh ge |oh hkhd|vcd uhd|gge |oh gvcjcibk hkhd|vgabjih|cd zbuh bil+ fhcij b trxbvhl |hva+ lght ig| dobijh ~gkbvc|s) /Bt |oh

dsdkh ~vgdhhlt+ |oh ~gkbvc|s ge fg|o |oh hkhd|vcd uhd|gv bil c|t lcvhd|cgi vhuhvth huhvs 2?> lhjvhhtge |oh hkhd|vgabjih|cd zbuh bil |oh ~vglxd| ge |zg ihjb|cuh |hvat ct ~gtc|cuh)# ^gtc|cuh xic~gkhdobvjht /hkhd|vgit# zgxkl fh ~vglxdhl fs vg|b|cgi bfgx| |oh abjih|cd bct b| > lhjvhht gi |oh |cabct) Ihjb|cuh xic~gkh hkhd|vcd dobvjht /~gtc|vgit# zgxkl fh ~vglxdhl fs vg|b|cgi bfgx| |ohabjih|cd bct b| 2?> lhjvhht bkgij |oh |cah bct)

24)3! C| zckk fh ig|cdhl |ob| |oh vhtxk|bi| kgdxt ge |oh hkhd|vcd uhd|gvt ci |oh khe| tclh ge Ecjxvh 24)8 ctkg~tclhl) C| thhat kcmhks |ob| hkhd|vgt|b|cd vh~xktcgi zgxkl vhlct|vcfx|h |ob| kgdxt ci|g b t~ohvcdbkdgiecjxvb|cgi bil |oh abjih|cd lc~gkh zgxkl aguh |g |oh bct ge |oh t~ohvh+ bt togzi ci |oh vcjo|tclh ge Ecjxvh 24)8) \oct dgiecjxvb|cgi thhat dgitct|hi| zc|o |oh ~vg~hv|cht ge hkhd|vgit bil~gtc|vgit ci |ob| |oh vhtxk|bi| ~bv|cdkh dgitct|t ge b ~gci| dobvjh bil b abjih|cd lc~gkh bil zocdovh~hb|t c|t gvcjcibk t|b|h be|hv |zg vg|b|cgit bfgx| c|t abjih|cd bct) \oh ~vcidc~kh gf`hd|cgi |g |ohdgiecjxvb|cgi zgxkl b~~hbv |g fh |oh ebd| |ob| |oh dxvkcij ge |oh hkhd|vgabjih|cd zbuh ci|g b kgg~vhrxcvht b ubvcb|cgi ci |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| bkgij |oh hkhd|vcd bct txdo bt |oh vblcbk ubvcb|cgi ci |ohuhkgdc|s ge kcjo| togzi ci Ecjxvh 24)3) B ubvcb|cgi ci |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ct ig| zc|ogx| ~vhdhlhi|+|oh khitht ge sgxv hsht lg hbd|ks |ob| ci gvlhv |g egdxt |oh kcjo| vhekhd|hl evga |oct ~bjh bt sgxvhbl c|)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 86/110

24)2>! \oh dgidh~| |ob| ab||hv dgitct|t ge vblcb|cgi kgg~t dbi fh txf`hd|hl |g b vhbtgibfkhihtt|ht| fs hbacicij |oh migzi tcph bil hihvjs dgi|hi| ge |oh ixdkhgi tcidh |oh tcph bil hihvjsdgi|hi| ge ~bv|cdkht egvahl ge vblcb|cgi kgg~t axt| fh dgitct|hi|) \oh vblcxt+ v+ ge b dsdkh gevblcb|cgi obucij bi hihvjs ge h+ ci |hvat ge ^kbidm*t Dgit|bi|+ o+ bil |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|+ D+ ctjcuhi fs v1oD']6/^C#hQ) Tdb||hvcij gfthvub|cgit obuh togzi |ob| ixdkhgit /~vg|git bilihx|vgit# dgi|bci |ovhh cith~bvbfkh ci|hvibk hi|c|cht ibahl rxbvmt) B~~gv|cgicij |oh hihvjs ge |oh

ixdkhgi+ bfgx| 2)8>42>!2> `gxkht+ hrxbkks bagij |oh |ovhh rxbvmt khblt gih |g |oh dgidkxtcgi |ob

|ohcv vblcc bvh 5)4282>!25 ah|hvt+ gv 54( ge |oh gfthvuhl vblcxt ge |oh ixdkhgi) \oct ct bi

ci|hvht|cij ~hvdhi|bjh fhdbxth c| ct hrxbk |g 2!2'h&+ b exid|cgi zocdo b~~hbvt evhrxhi|ks cihkhd|vgabjih|cd hrxb|cgit) /Ci |oct h~vhttcgi+ h& vh~vhthi|t ib|xvbk ixafhv tcackbv |g ^C obucij bubkxh ge 6):2?)# C| zgxkl b~~hbv |ob| |oh vblcxt ge |oh ixdkhgi ct lh|hvacihl fs |oh vblcxt ge b kgg~ge vblcb|cgi obucij |oh hihvjs ge b tcijkh rxbvm) Tcidh |oh ixdkhgi lceehvt jvhb|ks evga |oh hkhd|vgibil c| ct ihx|vcigt zocdo bvh hac||hl bil bftgvfhl fs ~vgdhttht zocdo bvh bttgdcb|hl zc|oixdkhgit+ gih ct khl |g |oh tx~~gtc|cgi |ob| |oh rxbvm ct b kgg~ ge ihx|vcicd vblcb|cgi) /B~~kscij |oct

kcih ge vhbtgicij |g |oh hkhd|vgi ~vguclht c|t vblcxt bt 4)32>!24 ah|hvt) \oct tcph thhat |g fhdgitct|hi| zc|o c|t fhobucgv zc|oci b|gat)#

24)22! Ce hihvjs ct bllhl |g b ~bv|cdkh dgitct|cij ge b kgg~ ge vblcb|cgi+ gih zgxkl h~hd| |ohzbuhkhij|o ge |oh vblcb|cgi dga~gtcij |oh ~bv|cdkh+ bil |ohvhegvh c|t vblcxt+ |g vhlxdh fhdbxth |ohhihvjs ge |oh ~bv|cdkh ct ^kbidm*t Dgit|bi| lcuclhl fs c|t zbuhkhij|o+ bt ckkxt|vb|hl fs |oh lceehvhid

fh|zhhi |oh kgz hihvjs ~bv|cdkh ge Ecjxvh 24)5B bil |oh ocjo hihvjs ~bv|cdkh ge Ecjxvh 24)5F)Ogzhuhv+ ce |oh lcbah|hv ge b ~bv|cdkh ct ~vhuhi|hl evga fhdgacij tabkkhv+ c| obt |oh bk|hvib|cuh gebftgvfcij lctdvh|h ~bdmh|t ge hihvjs fs cidvhbtcij |oh ixafhv ge dsdkht c| dgi|bcit bil'gv fsbftgvfcij xirxbi|cechl hihvjs fs cidvhbtcij |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| zc|oci |oh kgg~ /os~g|oh|cdbk~gttcfckc|s egv exv|ohv dgitclhvb|cgi#) \ohth bk|hvib|cuht bvh ckkxt|vb|hl fs |oh lceehvhidh fh|zhhi|oh kgz hihvjs ~bv|cdkh ge Ecjxvh 24)5B bil |oh ocjo hihvjs ~bv|cdkh ge Ecjxvh 24)5D) \ohtcjicecdbidh ge |ohth ~gttcfckc|cht zckk fhdgah b~~bvhi| togv|ks) Vhdhi| h~hvcahi|bk gfthvub|cgitobuh togzi |ob|+ kcmh hkhd|vgit+ rxbvmt bvh bktg lhugcl ge bi ci|hvibk t|vxd|xvh lgzi |g |oh

gfthvub|cgi kcac| ge 2>!2? ah|hvt) \ohth gfthvub|cgit bvh dgitct|hi| zc|o |oh uchz ge |oh rxbvmlhtdvcfhl ci |oct Dob~|hv bil |oh vhrxcvhahi|t ge b tgkcl Bh|ohv)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 87/110

24)26! Rxbvmt obuh bi ci|hvht|cij ~vg~hv|s) \ohs bvh tgdcbfkh bil dbiig| fh th~bvb|hl) \ohs hct|~hvabihi|ks giks ci jvgx~t ge |ovhh |g egva |oh t|vxd|xvh ge ixdkhgit bil |ohs hct| |ha~gvbvcks

hc|ohv th~bvb|hks gv ci ~bcvt /~cgit bil mbgit# bt |oh togv| kcuhl lhfvct ~vglxd|t ge ocjo hihvjsixdkhbv dgkkctcgit) B||ha~|t |g th~bvb|h rxbvmt evga |oh ixdkhgi bvh h|vhahks lceecdxk| fhdbxth+zohi rxbvmt bvh ci dkgth ~vgcac|s |oh egvdh ogklcij |oha dkgth |gjh|ohv ct tabkk fx| ct vh~gv|hl |cidvhbth vb~clks |g b dgit|bi| khuhk+ cilh~hilhi| ge |oh th~bvb|cgi+ bt |ohs bvh aguhl b~bv|)

24)24! Ce gih dga~bvht |oh tcph ge b rxbvm zc|o |oh tcph ge b ixdkhgi+ c| zgxkl thha |g fh ca~gttcf|ob| |ovhh rxbvmt dgxkl ec| zc|oci c|+ xikhtt ge dgxvth+ |ohcv kgg~t bvh ci|hv|zcihl) \oct ~gttcfckc|sfvcijt |g acil |oh kgjg ge b ~g~xkbv fhhv zocdo dgitct|t ge |ovhh ci|hv|zcihl dcvdkht /Ecjxvh 24):#) |oh rxbvmt ci b ixdkhgi bvh ci|hv|zcihl ci kgg~t bibkgjgxt |g |ob| kgjg+ |oh b||vbd|cuh egvdh fh|zhh|oha zckk fhobuh ci |oh abiihv btdvcfhl |g |oh t|vgij egvdh lhecihl fs ~bv|cdkh ~ostcdct|t) Zohi|oh kgg~t ci |oh kgjg dgiecjxvb|cgi bvh ihbvks dhi|hvhl gi hbdo g|ohv+ ucv|xbkks ig egvdht bvh hhv|hfh|zhhi |oha) Ce hihvjs ct bllhl |g txdo kgg~t ge vblcb|cgi+ gih zgxkl h~hd| |ohcv ci|hv|zcicij |g~vhuhi| |oha evga bftgvfcij |ob| hihvjs fs vhlxdcij |ohcv tcph fhdbxth |ohvh ct ig vgga ci |ohdhi|hv |g ~hvac| tovcimbjh) \oh kgg~t dga~gtcij |oh rxbvmt ci b ixdkhgi zgxkl |ohi obuh |gbftgvf bis h|vb hihvjs ci big|ohv abiihv) \ohcv g~|cgit zgxkl thha |g fh |g cidgv~gvb|h |ohbllc|cgi ge h|vb dsdkht bil'gv cidvhbth |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| zc|oci gih gv agvh ge |oh kgg~t) Fg|o|ohth ~gttcfckc|cht txjjht| |ob| |oh egvdh vhrxcvhl |g t|vh|do b rxbvm zgxkl fh cilh~hilhi| ge |ohlct|bidh c| ct t|vh|dohl bil |oct ct zob| thhat |g fh gfthvuhl+ bt ckkxt|vb|hl fs Ecjxvh 24)?)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 88/110

24)2<! Dgiuhi|cgibk ~bv|cdkh ~ostcdt btdvcfht |oh b||vbd|cgi fh|zhhi |oh |ovhh rxbvmt zocdo egvaixdkhgit gv |oh |zg rxbvmt zocdo egva ~cgit bil mbgit |g |oh bd|cgi ge h|vhahks abttcuh biltogv| kcuhl ucv|xbk hdobijh ~bv|cdkht ibahl jkxgit zc|ogx| bis h~kbib|cgi bt |g ogz txdo~bv|cdkht dbi ~vglxdh b||vbd|cuh egvdht) Zc|o |oh dgiecjxvb|cgi lhtdvcfhl bfguh+ |oh egvdht fh|zhh

rxbvmt ci ixdkhgit+ ~cgit+ bil mbgit zgxkl vhtxk| evga |ohcv |g~gkgjcdbk dgiecjxvb|cgi bil |oht|vhij|o ge |ohcv vblcb|cgi kgg~t) \oh abttcuh jkxgit ge |ohgvh|cdbk ~bv|cdkh ~ostcdt ig| giks zgxklfh xiihdhttbvs+ |ohs dbiig| hct| zc|oci |oh ixdkhgi zc|ogx| dbxtcij |oh ixdkhgi |g fhdgitclhvbfks agvh abttcuh |obi c| ct) \oh giks egvdh vhrxcvhl |g h~kbci |oh fhobucgv ge |ohci|hv|zcihl rxbvmt ct |oh |hitckh t|vhij|o ge |oh vblcb|cgi kgg~t ge zocdo rxbvmt bvh dga~gthl bil|oh ci|hith jvbuc|b|cgibk b||vbd|cgi dbxthl fs |oh tkgzcij ge |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| zc|oci |oha+ btlctdxtthl fhkgz)

24)28! ^vg|git /gv bi|c!~vg|git# zc|oci bi b|gacd ixdkhxt vh~hk hbdo g|ohv bt b vhtxk| gehkhd|vgt|b|cd egvdh bd|cij fh|zhhi kcmh dobvjht) B| |oh lct|bidh vh~vhthi|hl fs |oh tcph ge |oh

ixdkhgi+ |oh khuhk ge |ob| egvdh ct gi |oh gvlhv ge 2: ~gxilt) \oct egvdh ct bfgx| 2><> |caht bt kbvjbt |oh b||vbd|cuh egvdh fh|zhhi |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk abttht ge ixdkhgit bt ~vhlcd|hl fs Ihz|gi*t Kbz

ge Jvbuc|b|cgi) Gfucgxtks+ ~vg|git /gv bi|c!~vg|git# ci |oh ixdkhxt ge bi b|ga dbiig| fh ohkl|gjh|ohv fs jvbuc|b|cgi) Bjbci c| axt| fh vh~hb|hl+ ihuhv bttxah) Bt obt fhhi togzi hbvkchv+ |oegvdh zh h~hvchidh bt jvbuc|s vhtxk|t evga b jvblchi| ci |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| hct|cij bt b exid|cgige hkhub|cgi) Ci gvlhv egv |oh rxbvm gv |oh hkhd|vgi |g hct| bt b kgg~ ge vblcb|cgi+ c| ct ihdhttbvs egv|oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| zc|oci |oh rxbvm gv hkhd|vgi |g vhlxdh kcihbvks evga c|t igacibk ubkxh ge D b| c|t~hvc~ohvs |g b ubkxh ge phvg b| c|t dhi|hv+ bt togzi ci Ecjxvh 24)3 egv |oh rxbvm) Ci |oh rxbvm+ |ohjvblchi| ci |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| ct higvagxt+ bil+ b| c|t ~hvc~ohvs+ |oh bx|ogv ht|cab|ht |ohIhz|gicbi egvdh ge jvbuc|s bd|cij gi |oh abtt ge b ixdkhgi bt b vhtxk| ge |oct jvblchi| |g fh gi |ohgvlhv ge 22 ackkcgi ~gxilt) Zockh |oh tca~kct|cd vh~vhthi|b|cgi ge Ecjxvh 24)3 txjjht|t |ob| |ohjvblchi| bfvx~|ks ebkkt |g phvg b| |oh txvebdh ge |oh rxbvm+ h~hvchidh zc|o echklt txjjht|t |ob| txddbiig| fh |oh dbth) \oh jvblchi| axt| lhdvhbth tagg|oks |gzbvlt |oh dgiuhi|cgibk jvbuc|b|cgibk

jvblchi| khuhk ci |oh ucdcic|s ge |oh rxbvm*t txvebdh) C| ct ig| lceecdxk| |g fhkchuh |ob| higxjo vhtclxbjvbuc|b|cgibk b||vbd|cgi hct|t fh|zhhi |oh rxbvmt ci ixdkhgit |g guhvdgah |oh vhkb|cuhks ~xishkhd|vgt|b|cd egvdh zocdo b||ha~|t |g th~bvb|h ~vg|git gv bi|c!~vg|git bil+ zohi ixdkhgit bvh cidkgth ~vgcac|s+ |ohs togxkl fh h|vhahks t|cdms) /\oct ct |oh |s~h ge rxht|cgi |ob| ~ostcdct|t|vbcihl fs vg|h obilkh h|vhahks zhkk bil |oh bx|ogv og~ht |ob| b ehz ge |oha zckk fh txeecdchi|ksbi|bjgicphl |g hbacih |oct dgi`hd|xvh huhi ce |ohcv giks ag|cub|cgi ct |g ~vguh c| eggkcto)# Zc|o |octci|hv~vh|b|cgi ge |oh ib|xvh ge |oh ixdkhgi+ |oh hkhd|vgzhbm bil hkhd|vgt|vgij egvdht ~gt|xkb|hl fs~bv|cdkh ~ostcdct|t bvh ig| giks xiihdhttbvs fx| bvh ca~gttcfkh)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 89/110

24)25! \oh tcph ge |oh hkhd|vgi togxkl ig| fh dgiexthl zc|o |oh tcph ge c|t gvfc| ci bi b|ga) \ohdcvdxaehvhidh ge |ob| gvfc| ct |oh zbuhkhij|o lh|hvacihl fs |oh gvfc|bk mcih|cd hihvjs ge |ob|hkhd|vgi) Rxbi|xa Ahdobicdt ca~gtht bi bllc|cgibk vht|vcd|cgi gi c|t tcph) \oh dcvdxaehvhidh ge|oh gvfc| axt| dgi|bci bi ci|hjvbk ixafhv ge dsdkht ge vblcb|cgi bil |oh |g|bk hihvjs ge |ogth dsdkhaxt| hrxbk |oh hihvjs ge |ob| gvfc|) Bt b vhtxk|+ |oh hkhd|vgit ci bi b|ga bvh dgiecihl |g lctdvh|hgvfc|t zocdo dbi dobijh giks bt b vhtxk| ge b dobijh ci |oh ixafhv ge dsdkht dgi|bcihl ci |oha)\ob| dobijh ci |oh ixafhv ge dsdkht vhrxcvht |oh bftgv~|cgi gv hacttcgi ge b ~og|gi gehkhd|vgabjih|cd vblcb|cgi ge hbd|ks |oh dgvvhd| hihvjs khuhk /zbuhkhij|o#) Lcbjvbaab|cdbkks+ |ohheehd| ct clhi|cdbk zc|o |ob| togzi ci |oh ckkxt|vb|cgit ge Ecjxvht 24)5B bil 24)5D)

24)2:! C| b~~hbvt |ob|+ egv |oh kgg~t ge vblcb|cgi zocdo dga~vcth ab||hv |g fh t|bfkh+ |oh ~vhthidh gdobvjh ge hc|ohv ~gkbvc|s ct vhrxcvhl) Bt ahi|cgihl+ hkhd|vgit bil ~vg|git bvh t|bfkh gi |ohcv gzi

zockh ihx|vgit bvh t|bfkh giks ci |oh ~vgcac|s ge b ~vg|gi*t dobvjh) \oct ct ig| bi xivhbtgibfkhvhtxk|) \oh hkhd|vcd dobvjh ge |oh ~vg|gi ct vh~xktcuh bil zgxkl bd| |g h~bil |oh vblcxt ge |oh rxbkgg~t) B| b kbvjhv vblcxt+ |ohth kgg~t dgi|bci khtt hihvjs bil zgxkl bkkgz b ihx|vgi |g vhlxdh c|tci|hvibk hihvjs fs h~hkkcij bi hkhd|vgi |g fhdgah b ~vg|gi) B~~bvhi|ks+ |oct ~vgdhtt ct vht|vbcihlci |oh ihx|vgi fs |oh ~vgcac|s ge b ~vg|gi+ bil ci b|gacd ixdkhc+ ihx|vgit bil ~vg|git thha |g~hvegva b tsafcg|cd exid|cgi) \oh ~gtc|cuh dobvjht ge |oh ~vg|git ~vhuhi|t ihx|vgit evga lhdbscifs hac||cij hkhd|vgit |g fhdgah ~vg|git zockh |oh h|vhahks t|vgij jvbuc|b|cgibk b||vbd|cgi fh|zhhihx|vgit bil ~vg|git vhtxk|cij evga |oh heehd|t ca~kchl fs Ecjxvh 24)3 ~vhuhi|t |oh ax|xbkvh~xktcgi ge |oh ~vg|gi*t dobvjht evga lht|vgscij b|gacd ixdkhc fs dbxtcij |oha |g eks b~bv|) Gihacjo| dgidkxlh |ohi |ob| |oh t|bfckc|s ge |oh ubvcgxt b|gacd ixdkhc ct lh|hvacihl fs |oh ~bvbah|hvtge |oct ixdkhbv tsafcgtct egv hbdo ~bv|cdxkbv b|gacd zhcjo| bil ixafhv) /\oh ~vhdhlcij lhtdvc~|cgbktg b~~kcht |g bi|c!~bv|cdkht)#

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 90/110

24)2?! Zc|o |oh ci|hvcgv ge ixdkhgit gfthvuhl |g dgi|bci |ovhh rxbvmt ge b tcph bil bjjvhjb|h abtt

hrxcubkhi| hihvjs htthi|cbkks hrxbk |g |oh abtt hrxcubkhi| hihvjs ge ixdkhgit+ |oh rxht|cgi bt |gzoh|ohv rxbvmt bvh exilbahi|bk ~bv|cdkht gv zoh|ohv |ohs obuh bi ci|hvibk t|vxd|xvh ge |ohcv gzi ctvhblcks bitzhvhl) Tcidh rxbi|xa ahdobicdt |hbdoht |ob| |oh tcph ge b ~bv|cdkh ct ciuhvthks~vg~gv|cgibk |g c|t hihvjs hrxcubkhi| abtt+ c| egkkgzt |ob| rxbvmt bvh exilbahi|bk bil lg ig|dgi|bci bi ci|hvibk t|vxd|xvh) Ce |oh rxbvm dgitct|hl ge agvh |obi gih ~bv|cdkh+ |oh abtt hrxcubkhi|hihvjs ge hbdo ge |ogth ~bv|cdkht zgxkl hc|ohv fh ~vg~gv|cgibkks tabkkhv |obi |ob| ge |oh rxbvm bilbt b vhtxk|+ |ohs zgxkl fh kbvjhv |obi fg|o |oh rxbvm bil |oh ixdkhgi zocdo dgi|bcihl |oha+ bigfucgxt bftxvlc|s) Bk|hvib|cuhks+ ce |oh rxbvm zhvh dga~gthl ge axk|c~kh ~bv|cdkht tabkk higxjo |gec| ci |oh t~bdh bubckbfkh+ |oh abtt hrxcubkhi| hihvjs ge fg|o |oh rxbvm bil |oh ixdkhgi zocdodgi|bcihl c| zgxkl fh kbvjhv |obi |ohcv gfthvuhl ubkxht+ bjbci bi gfucgxt bftxvlc|s) Huhi ci |ohacdvgtdg~cd rxbi|xa zgvkl+ fkcuc|t bvh ca~gttcfkh) /B fkcuc| ct lhecihl bt |zg ~gxilt ge hdvhahici b gih ~gxil fbj)# \oh togv| kcuhl ocjo hihvjs ~bv|cdkht dvhb|hl ci ixdkhbv h~kgtcgit bildgkkctcgi h~hvcahi|t bvh dgitct|hi| zc|o |oh ci|hv~vh|b|cgi |ob| |ohs bvh kgg~t ge vblcb|cgi ge ocjohihvjs dgi|hi| hc|ohv fhdbxth |ohs bvh tcijkh dsdkh kgg~t zocdo obuh fhhi dga~vhtthl ci|g btabkkhv vblcc bil'gv obuh fhdgah kbvjhv fs cidgv~gvb|cij bllc|cgibk dsdkht ci|g |ohcv kgg~t gv fskgdbkks cidvhbtcij |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|) C| zgxkl thha vhbtgibfkh |g h~hd| txdo ~bv|cdkht |g fhxit|bfkh bil |g lhdbs vb~clks) \ohvh ct ig t|bfkh t|vxd|xvh ci Ib|xvh zocdo ct tabkkhv gv agvh abttcuh |obi |oh rxbvm gv |oh ixdkhgi ci zocdo c| ct dgi|bcihl)

24)23! \oh h~hvcahi|bk bd|cuc|s ci ~bv|cdkh ~ostcdt dgitct|t ge fgafbvlcij ~bv|cdkht zc|o g|ohv~bv|cdkht b| ocjo hihvjcht bil hbacicij |oh lhfvct vhtxk|cij evga |oh dgkkctcgi) \oct |s~h geh~hvcahi| ct ~hvegvahl+ ig| fhdbxth ge c|t ciib|h vhkhubidh+ fx| fhdbxth c| |oh giks ahbitdxvvhi|ks bubckbfkh) Ci gvlhv egv txdo bi h~hvcahi| |g ~vguclh |oh lhtcvhl vhtgkx|cgi+ c| ct ihdhttb

|g jhihvb|h dgkkctcgit fh|zhhi ~bv|cdkht+ b| khbt| gih ge zocdo obt b mcih|cd hihvjs zocdo ct kbvjhdga~bvhl |g |oh vht| abtt hrxcubkhi| hihvjcht ge |oh ~bv|cdkht) \ohth h~hvcahi|t schkl b kbvjhixafhv ge togv| kcuhl ~bv|cdkht) Abis ge |ogth ~bv|cdkht obuh abtt hrxcubkhi| hihvjcht zocdo bvhkbvjhv /tgah|caht fs b ebd|gv ge guhv 8>># |obi |oh abtt hrxcubkhi| hihvjs ge |oh rxbvm zc|oci |ohixdkhgi xilhv |ht|) \ogth ~bv|cdkht bvh dgiuhi|cgibk ~bv|cdkht zogth hihvjcht obuh fhhi cidvhbthfs |oh ~vgdhtt togzi ci Ecjxvht 24)5B bil 24)5F gv ocjohv hihvjs ~bv|cdkht zocdo |ha~gvbvcks egvevga |oh hdhtt hihvjs ~vguclhl fs |oh dgkkctcgi) Txdo ~bv|cdkht b~~bvhi|ks dbiig| fh t|bfkh bil|ohs lhdbs rxcdmks ci|g dgafcib|cgit ge |oh t|bfkh ~bv|cdkht /hkhd|vgit+ ~og|git+ ihx|vcigt+ixdkhgit bil |ohcv bi|c!~bv|cdkht#) ^bv|cdkh ~ostcdt h~hvcahi|t ciugkucij hihvjcht kbvjh dga~bvhl|g |oh abtt hrxcubkhi| hihvjs ge rxbvmt abs fh bfgx| bt ahbicijexk ci lh|hvacicij |oh ib|xvh geab||hv bt bi h~hvcahi| zocdo b||ha~|t |g lh|hvacih |oh ib|xvh ge ecih dvst|bk jgfkh|t fs tob||hvci|oha zc|o vcekh fxkkh|t bil t|xlscij |oh evbjahi|t zockh |ohs bvh ci ekcjo|) C| zgxkl b~~hbv |ob| zob

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 91/110

ct vhbkks xilhv |ht| ci ocjo hihvjs ~bv|cdkh h~hvcahi|t ct |oh bfckc|s ge ocjo hihvjs vblcb|cgi kgg~t|g egva zc|oci |oh Bh|ohv bil |oh t|bfckc|s ge |ogth kgg~t)

24)6>! \oh dga~x|hv ~vgjvba xthl |g hubkxb|h jvbuc|b|cgibk dgi|vbd|cgi togzhl |ob| |oh abcaxa

ci|hvibkks gfthvuhl hihvjs lhitc|s ge bi gf`hd| xilhvjgcij jvbuc|b|cgibk dgkkb~th ct bfgx| 2>8 |caht |oh hihvjs lhitc|s ge b ixdkhgi) Tcidh |oct hihvjs lhitc|s vb|cg ct ge |oh tbah gvlhv bt |ohdgkkctcgi hihvjs |g fh b||bcihl ci |oh igz dbidhkhl Tx~hvdgilxd|cij Tx~hvdgkkclhv ^vgjvba+ c|acjo| obuh fhhi og~hl |ob| h~hvcahi|t ~hvegvahl gi |ob| abdocih zgxkl obuh vhuhbkhlciegvab|cgi bfgx| dgilc|cgit zocdo hct|hl b| gxv Xicuhvth*t fhjciicij) Fx|+ ce |oh abdocih obl

fhhi fxck|+ |oh ciegvab|cgi c| zgxkl obuh ~vguclhl zgxkl ~vgfbfks ig| fh vhkhubi| |g dgtagkgjs)\oh ocjo hihvjs dgi|hi| ca~gthl gi ixdkhgit b| |oh fhjciicij ge gxv Xicuhvth vhtxk|hl evgadga~vhttcgi zockh |oh dgkkctcgi hihvjs ge ~bv|cdkht ~vglxdhl fs |oh Tx~hvdgkkclhv ~vglxdht |hitcgzc|oci |oh ~bv|cdkh ~vglxd|t) \oh heehd|t ge |hitcgi bil dga~vhttcgi bvh ig| |oh tbah) \oh |hitckht|vhij|o ge fbkk fhbvcij t|hhk ct gi |oh gvlhv ge 68>+>>> ~gxilt ~hv trxbvh cido /^TC#) \oh xk|cab|ht|vhij|o ge |ob| t|hhk xilhv |oh |s~h ge dga~vhttcgi gddxvvcij ci fhbvcijt ct thuhvbk ackkcgi ^TC"Zohi dga~vhttcgi ebckxvh /fvcihkkcij# lght gddxv ci txdo b fhbvcij+ c| vhtxk|t evga |hitckh t|vhtthtcilxdhl fs |oh dga~vhttcgi ci |oh vhjcgi bvgxil |oh bvhb ge dgi|bd| bil ig| evga |oh dga~vhttcgt|vhtt c|thke) Tcidh dga~vhttcgi bil |hitcgi lg ig| ~vglxdh hrxcubkhi| vhtxk|t ci gvlcibvsahdobicdt c| ct obvl |g `xt|ces b fhkche |ob| |ohs ~vglxdh hrxcubkhi| vhtxk|t ci ~bv|cdkh ~ostcdt)

Dob~|hv 2< ! Bllcij Rxbi|xa Heehd|t |g GxvXilhvt|bilcij

2<)2! \oh \zg Tkc| H~hvcahi|0! \ohvh ct b dkbttcd h~hvcahi| zocdo khblt |g gih ge |zgci|hv~vh|b|cgit+ fg|o ge zocdo b~~hbv bftxvl+ bil zocdo obuh khl |g |zg ax|xbkks hdkxtcuh tdoggge |ogxjo|) Xilhv gih ci|hv~vh|b|cgi huhvs ~bv|cdkh ge hihvjs dgi|cixgxtks bil cit|bi|bihgxtks|ht|t bkk ge t~bdh |g lh|hvacih |oh ~b|o c| togxkl egkkgz bil c|t xk|cab|h lht|cib|cgi) Xilhv |oh g|ohci|hv~vh|b|cgi+ huhvs ~bv|cdkh ci |oh Xicuhvth egkkgzt huhvs ~gttcfkh ~b|o |g huhvs ~gttcfkh

lht|cib|cgi bil exv|ohvagvh vh~hb|t |oct ~vgdhtt b| huhvs ci|i| ge |cah tcidh |oh Xicuhvth fhjbi) Ctg lgcij hbdo ge |ohth ~gttcfkh ~b|ot dvhb|ht bi bk|hvib|h xicuhvth zc|o |oh Xicuhvth zh gfthvuhbt gih ge b rxbtc!ciecic|h ixafhv ge ^bvbkkhk Xicuhvtht) Hbdo ge |ogth ^bvbkkhk Xicuhvtht ct btdga~kh bt gxv gzi+ hbdo gddx~cht |oh tbah ugkxah ge t~bdh bt gxv gzi+ bil hbdo vh~vhthi|t |ovhtxk|t ge bkk ge |oh lhdctcgit ablh fs ~bv|cdkht tcidh |cah fhjbi) Zockh |ohvh ct b dgitclhvbfkhixafhv ge ~ostcdct|t zog btdvcfh |g |oh kb||hv uchz~gci|+ c| txeehvt evga gf`hd|cgit agvh tcjicecdbi|obi c|t rxbtc!ciecic|h dga~khc|s) \oh dvhb|cgi ge hbdo ge |ogth bk|hvib|h ^bvbkkhk Xicuhvtht vhrxcvh|oh dvhb|cgi+ evga ig|ocijihtt+ ge bi bagxi| ge hihvjs hrxbk |g |oh hihvjs dgi|hi| ge gxv gziXicuhvth bil vhrxcvht |oha |g dg!hct| ci |oh tbah ugkxah ge t~bdh) \oh |vbtocij+ |g txdo blhjvhh+ ge fg|o |oh Kbz ge Dgithvub|cgi ge Hihvjs bil |oh vhrxcvhahi| |ob| ig agvh |obi gihgf`hd| gddx~s |oh tbah t~bdh b| |oh tbah |cah txjjht|t b lhjvhh ge eggkctoihtt gi |oh ~bv| ge

|ogth zog ogkl |oct uchz~gci|+ ~bv|cdxkbv tcidh ig `xt|cecdb|cgi ig| ciugkucij tgah egva geast|cdcta obt huhv fhhi geehvhl) Gi |oh g|ohv obil+ |oh clhb ge b zob| acjo| fh lhecihl bt brxbi|xa t|vhtt echkl dgi|cixgxtks |ht|cij bkk ge t~bdh bil dgi|vgkkcij |oh ~b|ot ge ~bv|cdkht lghtig| ucgkb|h bddh~|hl ~ostcdbk kbzt bil bkkgzt b vhbtgibfkh h~kbib|cgi egv |oh vhtxk|t ge |oh \zgTkc| H~hvcahi| bil egv |oh fhobucgv ge ~gkbvcphl kcjo|)

2<)6! Zohi b ~bv|cdkh /h)j)! ~og|gi+ ixdkhgi+ h|d)# ~bttht |ovgxjo bi g~hicij+ c|t lcvhd|cgi ct bk|hvhfs lceevbd|cgi |ovgxjo bi bijkh zocdo ct ciuhvthks ~vg~gv|cgibk |g |oh tcph ge |oh g~hicij btdga~bvhl |g |oh zbuhkhij|o ge |oh ~bv|cdkh /^kbidm*t Dgit|bi| lcuclhl fs |oh hihvjs ge |oh ~bv|cdkhZohi ~bv|cdkht ~btt |ovgxjo b tkc|+ |oh bijkh ge |ohcv lceevbd|cgi ci b lcvhd|cgi ~hv~hilcdxkbv |g |ohtkc| ct kbvjh dga~bvhl |g |ohcv bijkh ge lceevbd|cgi ci b lcvhd|cgi ~bvbkkhk |g |oh tkc| bil c|t xth bkkgztlceevbd|cgi |g fh t|xlchl bt b gih lcahitcgibk ~vgfkha) \oh \zg Tkc| H~hvcahi| ct ckkxt|vb|hl ci

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 92/110

Ecjxvh 2<)2) Ecjxvh 2<)6+ bil Ecjxvh 2<)4) Ci |oct h~hvcahi|+ b fhba ge ~bv|cdkht+ txdo bt hkhd|vgitgv ~og|git+ t|vcmh b abtm zocdo dgi|bcit |zg tkc|t) ^bv|cdkht ~bttcij |ovgxjo |ohth tkc|t bvhlceevbd|hl bil bvh lct|vcfx|hl ci b lceevbd|cgi ~b||hvi bt |ohs t|vcmh |oh tdvhhi) \oh vhkb|cuh vb|h b|zocdo |oh ~bv|cdkht t|vcmh |oh tdvhhi+ bt b exid|cgi ge ~gtc|cgi fhocil b abtm zc|o b tcijkh tkc|+ ctckkxt|vb|hl fs |oh lceevbd|cgi ~b||hvi togzi ci Ecjxvh 2<)2) Ce |oh abtm dgi|bcit |zg tkc|t+ gih zgxklh~hd| |oh lceevbd|cgi ~b||hvi b| |oh tdvhhi |g fh |oh txa ge |oh cilcuclxbk lceevbd|cgi ~b||hvit gehbdo tkc|+ bt ckkxt|vb|hl ci Ecjxvh 2<)6) Cit|hbl+ |oh bd|xbk lceevbd|cgi ~b||hvi zocdo vhtxk|t ct |ob|togzi ci Ecjxvh 2<)4) Exv|ohvagvh+ |oct lceevbd|cgi ~b||hvi ~hvtct|t bt |oh kgij |hva lct|vcfx|cgi ge|oh ~bv|cdkht t|vcmcij |oh tdvhhi huhi ce |oh |oh ~gttcfckc|s ge ci|hvbd|cgi fh|zhhi ~bv|cdkht ct

~vhdkxlhl fs vhlxdcij |oh vb|h ge ~bv|cdkh ekx |g b khuhk zohvh |ohvh ct ig| agvh |obi gih ~bv|cdkh c|vbitc| b| b |cah)

2<)4! \oh gfthvub|cgit lhtdvcfhl ci |oh ~vhdhlcij ~bvbjvb~o khbl |g |oh dgidkxtcgi+ b~~bvhi|ksbddh~|hl fs b tcjicecdbi| ixafhv ge rxbi|xa ~ostcdct|t /bil |oh bx|ogv bt zhkk#+ |ob| tgahogz+zockh hihvjs hct|t ci lctdvh|h kgdbkcphl ~bdmh|t+ |oh ~b|o zocdo |ogth ~bdmh|t egkkgz bt |ohs aguevga ~gci| |g ~gci| ct lh|hvacihl fs b dgi|cixgxt echkl ~vg~bjb|cij |ovgxjogx| bkk ge t~bdh b| brxbtc!ciecic|h uhkgdc|s) \ob| echkl+ zocdo |oh bx|ogv lhtcjib|ht egv dgiuhichidh bt |oh Rxbi|xaEchkl+ |ht|t |oh ~vgfbfckc|s ge hbdo ge |oh ~gttcfkh ~b|ot ge hbdo bil huhvs ~bv|cdkh ci |oh Xicuhvthbil dbxtht |ogth ~bv|cdkht |g bl`xt| |ohcv ~b|ot tg |ob| |ohcv t|b|ct|cdbk lct|vcfx|cgi ~vglxdht |ohlceevbd|cgi ~b||hvit dobvbd|hvct|cd ge zbuht) /\oh Rxbi|xa Echkl ct ig| lcvhd|ks gfthvubfkh+ c| ct gikvhdgjicpbfkh fs c|t heehd|t gi |oh fhobucgv ge ~bv|cdkht)# \oh bx|ogv dbah |g |oct dgidkxtcgi ci |oh

23?>*t be|hv vhblcij b fggm fbthl x~gi b thvcht ge egxv khd|xvht jcuhi fs Lv) Vcdobvl Ehsiabii g|oh txf`hd| ge Rxbi|xa Hkhd|vglsibacdt) Oct lhtdvc~|cgi ge |oh ~vgdhtt |ob| lh|hvaciht |oh ~b|o|ob| ~og|git |bmh zohi |ohs |vbuhk evga ~gci| B+ bvh vhekhd|hl evga b acvvgv+ bil bvvcuh b| ~gci| F+khl |g zob| thhat |g fh bi gfucgxt dgidkxtcgi) Egv Ib|xvh |g fhobuh ci bddgvlbidh zc|o |ohdgidh~|t ge Rxbi|xa Hkhd|vglsibacdt+ |zg vhrxcvhahi|t axt| fh ah|) \ohvh axt| fh bi bftgkx|huhkgdc|s vhehvhidh evbah /c)h0! |oh Bh|ohv# bil |oh ~og|git axt| fh db~bfkh ge |ht|cij |oh ~vgfbfckcge bkk ge |oh ~gttcfkh ~b|ot fh|zhhi B bil F ucv|xbkks cit|bi|bihgxtks bil bl`xt|cij |ohcv ~b|otbddgvlcijks zockh hi vgx|h) Tcidh Rxbi|xa Hkhd|vglsibacdt obt fhhi |oh agt| txddhttexk dgidh~huhv lhucthl ci c|t bfckc|s |g bddxvb|hks ~vhlcd| |oh vhtxk|t ge h~hvcahi|t+ c| zgxkl thha |ob| |ohdgidh~| ge b dgi|cixgxt Rxbi|xa Echkl ~vg~bjb|cij b| b rxbtc!ciecic|h uhkgdc|s obt fhhigfthvub|cgibkks uhvcechl bil |oh dgidh~| ge |oh bkk ~hvublcij Bh|ohv obt fhhi vh!uhvcechl)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 93/110

2<)<! C| ct rxc|h dhv|bci |ob| |oh tdchi|cecd dgaaxic|s zckk ig| bddh~| |oh ab|hvcbk ci Lv) Ehsiabii*tfggm bt huclhidh ge |oh hct|hidh ge |oh Rxbi|xa Echkl gv ge |oh Bh|ohv) \ohcv vhdgvl ci vhdgjicpci|oh gfucgxt ct vb|ohv ~ggv) Bddh~|bidh ge ihz migzkhljh fs bis jvgx~ vhrxcvht |ob| |oh migzkhljfh ablh gfucgxt |g |oh jvgx~*t khbt| ci|hkkcjhi| ahafhv ci b abiihv zocdo lght ig| vhrxcvh |ob|ahafhv |g ebdh x~ |g oct ciblhrxbds) Gih ihhl giks ig|h |oh lhvctcgi ohb~hl x~gi Lv) Zcjihv ci|oh hbvks ~bv| ge |oct dhi|xvs egv txjjht|cij |ob| |oh ab|docij dgi|cihi|bk tob~ht+ jhgkgjs+ ekgvb+bil ebxib ge Tgx|o Bahvcdb bil Bevcdb ~vguhl |ob| |ohs zhvh gidh ~bv| ge b dgaagi dgi|cihi|)Zohi |oh bx|ogv ecvt| vhbl ge Lv) Zcjihv*t dgidkxtcgit bt b ~vh!Ocjo Tdoggk t|xlhi| ci |oh kb|h

234>*t oh egxil c| cidvhlcfkh |ob| bisgih dgxkl kggm b| |oh dgi|cihi|bk tob~ht bil ig| vhdgjicph |ogfucgxt ubkclc|s ge Lv) Zcjihv*t clhbt) C| thhahl |g oca |ob| |oh giks khjc|cab|h rxht|cgi vhabcicijzbt ogz |oh dgi|cihi|bk th~bvb|cgi dgxkl obuh dgah bfgx|) Bddh~|bidh ge Zcjihv*t Dgi|cihi|bkLvce| dgidh~| togxkl ig| obuh obl |g bzbc| |oh lctdguhvs ge |oh kciht ge vhuhvthl abjih|cd~gkbvcpb|cgi bkgijtclh ge b dhi|vbk vce| ci |oh gdhbi*t ekggv) Gidh Lv) Zcjihv*t clhbt obl fhdgahmigzi+ |oh dgidh~| ge |hd|gicd ~kb|ht togxkl obuh fhhi caahlcb|hks gfucgxt |g bis gih ci |oh echkzog zbt bzbvh ge |oh ebd| |ob| |oh dgvh ge |oh Hbv|o zbt agk|hi bil dguhvhl zc|o b |oci tgkcl dvxtC| zgxkl thha |ob|+ ci |oct dbth+ |oh ~hvegvabidh ge |oh bdblhacd ht|bfkctoahi| khe| tgah|ocij |gfh lhtcvhl) \oh tbah dgaahi| dbi fh ablh vhjbvlcij |oh lceecdxk|cht |ob| Lv) Toghabmhv obl cijbcicij bddh~|bidh ge |oh clhb |ob| |oh Hbv|o ct ~hvcglcdbkks fgafbvlhl zc|o uhvs kbvjh vgdmt evgat~bdh) C| obl bkvhbls fhhi bddh~|hl |ob| vgdmt ge bkk tcpht gvfc| |oh Txi bil |ob| tabkkhv vgdmt ebkkevga |oh tms dgi|cixgxtks bt ah|hgvc|ht) Gih zgxkl obuh |g fh ~vh||s tca~kh acilhl ce oh kggmhl b ~cd|xvh ge |oh Fbvvcijhv Dvb|hv bil lcl ig| vhdgjicph |ob| c| dgxkl giks obuh fhhi dbxthl fs |ohca~bd| ge gih ge |oh kbvjh t~bdh vgdmt /bt|hvgclt gv dgah|t# migzi |g hct|) \oh gfthvub|cgi ge bdgah| t|vcmcij @x~c|hv togxkl obuh fhhi evgt|cij gi |oh dbmh+ fx| bt b uhvcecdb|cgi ge |oh dhv|bci|s ~hvcglcd bt|hvgcl t|vcmht gi |oh Hbv|o+ c| togxkl obuh fhhi dgitclhvhl |vcucbk)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 94/110

2<)8! \oh h~hvcahi|bkks ubkclb|hl dgidh~|t ge rxbi|xa ahdobicdt schkl ciegvab|cgi zocdo+ bt lcl|oh vhkb|cuc|s dgidh~|t+ aglces dkbttcdbk Ihz|gicbi ^ostcdt) \ohth aglcecdb|cgit ciugkuh |ohtxf!acdvgtdg~cd zgvkl) \oh aglcecdb|cgit ge ci|hvht| |g |oct lctdxttcgi bvh ~vguclhl fhkgz0

Ci c|t gfthvubfkh egva+ hihvjs ct ig| dgi|cixgxt) C| b~~hbvt giks ci |oh egva ge lctdvh|h~bdmh|t zocdo abs fh ~og|git+ ihx|vcigt+ ~vg|git+ ihx|vgit+ gv |ohcv bi|c!~bv|cdkht+ bil zocdbvh lhtcjib|hl bt rxbi|b)

r

Hbdo rxbi|b+ zoh|ohv c| fh b ~og|gi+ b ihx|vcig+ gv b ab|hvcbk ~bv|cdkh+ obt b evhrxhids hrxbk|g c|t hihvjs dgi|hi| lcuclhl fs ^kbidm*t Dgit|bi|)

r

Hbdo rxbi|b dgx~kht |g |oh Bh|ohv) Bis rxbi|xa t|vhtt cilxdhl ci |oh Bh|ohv fs |ob|dgx~kcij ~hvublht bkk ge t~bdh b| b rxbtc!ciecic|h uhkgdc|s bil ~vgfbfks gfhst |oh ciuhvthtrxbvh kbz zc|o vht~hd| |g lct|bidh)

r

Tgah rxbi|b+ txdo bt ~og|git zocdo obuh fhhi dvhb|hl ci ~bcvt+ obuh rxbi|xa ixafhvt /|obct ge ~gkbvcpb|cgi ci |oh dbth ge ~og|git# zocdo bvh ~hvabihi|ks dgx~khl) \oct dgx~kcij ctciecic|hks t|cee+ ucv|xbkks cit|bi|bihgxt+ bil ct xibeehd|hl fs |oh lct|bidh fh|zhhi |oh ~bcvhl~bv|cdkht)

r

Ciegvab|cgi bt |g |oh t|b|h bil ~gtc|cgi ge hbdo rxbi|b ct |vbit~gv|hl b| b rxbtc!ciecic|huhkgdc|s bil zc|o ciecic|h vhtgkx|cgi fs rxbi|xa t|vhtt ci |oh Bh|ohv)

\oh t|vhtt ~b||hvi ci |oh Rxbi|xa Echkl b| bis ~gci| ci t~bdh ct aglcechl fs |ohdgiecjxvb|cgi ge gft|bdkht ci |oh ~b|o ge |oh ~bv|cdkht ~vglxdcij |oh t|vhtt)

v

r

^bv|cdkht ci ag|cgi egkkgz b ~b|o zocdo ct dgitct|hi| zc|o |oh ~b|o ge |oh ciegvab|cgi|vbit~gv|hl b| b rxbtc!ciecic|h uhkgdc|s fs |oh t|vhtt ci |oh Rxbi|xa Echkl)

r

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 95/110

Tcidh |oh Rxbi|xa Echkl ct dgi|cixgxt bil |oh ~bv|cdkh ct rxbi|cdcphl+ |oh |vbit~gv| geciegvab|cgi fs |oh |zg heehd|t dbiig| ab|do gi bi cit|bi| fs cit|bi| fbtct) \oh ab|dofhdgaht ~vg~gv|cgib|hks agvh ~vhdcth zohi |oh ixafhv ge ~bv|cdkht gfthvuhl fhdgahtkbvjh higxjo |g bkkgz |ohcv ~gtc|cgit |g fh b t|b|ct|cdbkks bddxvb|h vh~vhthi|b|cgi ge |ohciegvab|cgi vh~vhthi|hl fs |oh t|vhtt ci |oh Rxbi|xa Echkl) \oh cit|bi|bihgxt ~hbm |g~hbm hvvgv ci |oh ciegvab|cgi ab|do ct hrxbk |g |oh hihvjs ge |oh rxbi|b)

v

2<)5! \oh Fhobucgv ge ^gkbvcphl Kcjo|0! \oh zbuh!~bv|cdkh lxbkc|s ge ixdkhgit+ ~og|git bil

ihx|vcigt vhuhbkhl fs |oh \zg Tkc| H~hvcahi| ct ~vgfbfks agt| hbtcks xilhvt|ggl fs dgitclhvcij|oh heehd| ge ~gkbvcphvt gi b fhba ge kcjo|) Bt togzi ci Ecjxvh 2<)<+ b fhba ge hkhd|vgabjih|cdvblcb|cgi /kcjo|# ct lcvhd|hl |ovgxjo b ~bcv ge ~gkbvcphvt obucij |ohcv ~gkbvcpcij bht b| bi bijkh Nzc|o vht~hd| |g hbdo g|ohv) \oh fhba ge kcjo| hi|hvcij |oh ecvt| ~gkbvcphv evga |oh khe| ct xi~gkbvcphlZockh |oh ~gkbvcpb|cgi ge hbdo ~og|gi ci |oh hi|hvcij fhba ct b| b vbilga bijkh+ ~vguclcij |ohhi|hvcij hkhd|vgabjih|cd zbuh ct txeecdchi|ks ci|hith+ c|t ci|hitc|s ct cilh~hilhi| ge lcvhd|cgi+ bttogzi fs |oh dcvdxkbv kgdxt lcbjvba ci Ecjxvh 2<)<) Zohi |oh hkhd|vgabjih|cd zbuh ~bttht |ogxj|oh ecvt| ~gkbvcphv+ |oh vbilgaks ~gkbvcphl ci~x| zbuh ct gvjbicphl ci|g b uhv|cdbkks ~gkbvcphl zbuh+

bt togzi fs |oh uhv|cdbk dga~gihi| ci |oh uhd|gv lcbjvba ge Ecjxvh 2<)<+ zc|o bi ci|hitc|s ge 2'6>)8

|caht |oh ci|hitc|s ge |oh cidgacij zbuh) \ob| tcijkh uhv|cdbk ~gkbvcpb|cgi uhd|gv abs fh dgitclhvh|g fh |oh uhd|gv txa ge |zg gv|ogjgibk dga~gihi|t) Gih ge |ogth dga~gihi|t ct ~bvbkkhk |g |oh

bct ge |oh thdgil ~gkbvcphv zockh |oh g|ohv dga~gihi| ct ~hv~hilcdxkbv |g |ob| bct) Bt gih zgxklh~hd|+ |oh thdgil ~gkbvcphv zckk ~btt giks |oh ~bvbkkhk dga~gihi|) Zc|o |oh kgtt ge |oh gv|ogjgibkdga~gihi|+ |oh vhkb|cuh ci|hitc|s fh|zhhi |oh hkhd|vgabjih|cd zbuh khbucij |oh thdgil ~gkbvcphv+bt dga~bvhl |g |oh ci|hitc|s ge |oh zbuh khbucij |oh ecvt| ~gkbvcphv+ ct exv|ohv vhlxdhl ci ~vg~gv|cgi|g |oh abjic|xlh ge |oh dgtcih ge |oh bijkh fh|zhhi |oh ~gkbvcphvt) \oh ~gkbvcpcij ~vgdhtt bil |oh~vhdhlcij bibkstct abs fh vh~hb|hl bt ge|hi bt lhtcvhl ci b thvcht ge txddhttcuh ~gkbvcphvt) Bagigdovgab|cd hkhd|vgabjih|cd zbuh bd|xbkks dgitct|t ge b ekgz ge ~og|git obucij |oh tbah |g|bkhihvjs+ bil |oh ci|hitc|s ge |oh zbuh ct ~vg~gv|cgibk |g |oh trxbvh vgg| ge c|t hihvjs) Bt bdgithrxhidh+ |oh ~og|gi ekx bttgdcb|hl zc|o hbdo ge |oh ci|hitc|s uhd|gvt lhtdvcfhl ubvcht ci~vg~gv|cgi |g |oh trxbvh ge |ob| ci|hitc|s uhd|gv bil c|t ~gkbvcpb|cgi ct clhi|cdbk |g |oh ~gkbvcpb|cgi |oh hrxcubkhi| zbuh+ bt togzi ci Ecjxvh 2<)8)

2<):! C| ct fg|o dxt|gabvs bil tgahzob| cidgvvhd| |g dgitclhv |ob| |oh vb|h ge bvvcubk bil |oh bct g~gkbvcpb|cgi ge ~og|git dga~vctcij bi hkhd|vgabjih|cd zbuh bvh vbilga) Ci b agigdovgab|cdhkhd|vgabjih|cd zbuh ge xidobijcij ci|hitc|s+ |oh buhvbjh vb|h ge bvvcubk ge ~og|git ct dgit|bi|)\ohcv cit|bi|bihgxt vb|h ge bvvcubk+ ogzhuhv+ ct b vbilga ubvcb|cgi bfgx| |ob| buhvbjh vb|h) Tcackbvce |oh hkhd|vgabjih|cd zbuh ct xi~gkbvcphl+ |oh buhvbjh bht ge ~gkbvcpb|cgi ge c|t ~og|git bvhxicegvaks lct|vcfx|hl+ zockh |ohcv cit|bi|bihgxt bijkht ge ~gkbvcpb|cgi bvh vbilga) Ce bihkhd|vgabjih|cd zbuh ct ~gkbvcphl+ fg|o c|t ci|hitc|s bil |oh buhvbjh vb|h ge bvvcubk ge c|t ~og|gitubvs bt b exid|cgi ge |ohcv bijkh zc|o vht~hd| |g |oh bct ge ~gkbvcpb|cgi+ bt togzi ci Ecjxvh 2<)5+bil fg|o |oh cit|bi|bihgxt vb|h ge bvvcubk ge |oh ~og|git bil |oh ubvcb|cgi ge |ohcv bht ge~gkbvcpb|cgi bvh vbilga) Ci bllc|cgi+ fhdbxth |oh ci|hitc|s ge |oh hkhd|vgabjih|cd zbuh bil |oh

lct|vcfx|cgi ge ~og|git bvh lhecihl fs dgtcih bil dgtcih6 exid|cgit vht~hd|cuhks+ |oh heehd| ge

dbtdblcij ~gkbvcphvt abs fh ~vhlcd|hl fs axk|c~kcdb|cgi ge |oh heehd|t lhecihl fs Ecjxvh 2<)5 egvhbdo ~gkbvcphv ci |oh dobci) ]Tcidh |oh vhkb|cuh vbilgaihtt ge I huhi|t ubvcht ci ~vg~gv|cgi |g

2'/6I#>)8+ |oh vbilga bvvcubk bil ~gkbvcpb|cgi ge ~og|git ci hkhd|vgabjih|cd zbuht ct citcjicecdbixikhtt |oh ci|hitc|s ge |oh zbuh ct kgz)Q

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 96/110

2<)?! Xilhvt|bilcij |oh Rxbi|xa Ib|xvh ge Hihvjs0! \oh cit|bi|bihgxt |cah ge bvvcubk ge ~og|gitbil |ohcv ~gkbvcpb|cgit bvh cilcuclxbk huhi|t zocdo b~~bvhi|ks gddxv b| vbilga+ sh| tgahogz+ ci |objjvhjb|h+ |ohs bvh gvjbicphl ci bi bddxvb|h ~b||hvi) \oct ct b vhbtgibfkh vhtxk| egv bi xi~gkbvcphlhkhd|vgabjih|cd zbuh fhdbxth c| dbi gddxv fs ~xvh dobidh) \oct hbts bitzhv lght ig| h~kbci |ohvb|h ge bvvcubk bil bijkh ge ~gkbvcpb|cgi ge ~og|git zocdo dga~vcth b ~gkbvcphl hkhd|vgabjih|cdzbuh) \ogth ~og|git bvh gvjbicphl bil |ob| gvjbicpb|cgi vhrxcvht |oh bd|cgi ge bi gvjbicpcijahdobicta) \g xilhvt|bil |oh dobvbd|hvct|cdt ge |ob| ahdobicta+ b fvche lh|gxv ci|g |oh g~hvb|cgige b lhucdh dxvvhi|ks xthl ci lcjc|bk bxlcg tst|hat ct xthexk)

2<)3! \oh lhucdh ge ci|hvht| ct |oh Tcjab!Lhk|b bibkgj |g lcjc|bk dgiuhv|hv xthl egv lcjc|bk tcjibk

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 97/110

~vgdhttcij ci bxlcg tst|hat) C| dgiuhv|t |oh ubvscij bibkgj bxlcg tcjibk ~vguclhl fs b tgxvdh/acdvg~ogih+ |b~h lhdm+ h|d)# ci|g b ~thxlg!vbilga t|vcij ge lcjc|bk fc|t zocdo ct txfthrxhi|kslhdglhl |g egva lcjc|bk zgvlt dgvvht~gilcij |g |oh bibkgj ba~kc|xlh ge |oh cidgacij tcjibk) /ThhEcjxvh 2<):)# \oh ci~x| ~gv|cgi ge |oh dcvdxc|vs dbi fh dgitclhvhl |g fh b tca~kh ci|hjvb|gvdgitct|cij ge bi ba~kcechv+ b ehhlfbdm db~bdc|gv+ bil b vhtct|gv ci thvcht zc|o c|t ci~x|) \oh gx|~x|ugk|bjh ge txdo b dcvdxc| dobijht b| b vb|h zocdo ct ~vg~gv|cgibk |g |oh ugk|bjh b~~kchl |g |ob| ci~x\oh ci~x| |g |oh ci|hjvb|gv ct |oh buhvbjh ubkxh ge |oh gx|~x| ge |oh T^L\ tzc|do txf|vbd|hl evga|oh ci~x| tcjibk) Tcidh |oh tzc|do ct lvcuhi fs b dkgdmhl ekc~!ekg~ ci vht~gith |g |oh ~gkbvc|s ge |ohba~kcechv gx|~x| bil |oh t|b|h ge |oh ekc~!ekg~ ct lh|hvacihl fs |oh gx|~x| ge |oh ba~kcechv+ |oh

buhvbjh ubkxh ge |oh ~xkth |vbci lvcucij |oh tzc|do axt| hrxbk |oh buhvbjh ubkxh ge |oh bibkgj ci~xtcjibk) Fs dgafcicij |oh tzc|do lvcuh tcjibk zc|o |oh dkgdm tcjibk ci bi bil!jb|h+ b lcjc|bk ~xkth|vbci vhtxk|t zogth buhvbjh khuhk bddxvb|hks vh~vhthi|t |oh kgz evhrxhids t~hd|vxa ge |oh bibkgjci~x| tcjibk) Tx~hvca~gthl gi |oct kgz evhrxhids gx|~x| ct b igcth b| |oh dkgdm evhrxhids obucijbi ba~kc|xlh ge gih dkgdm ~xkth) \oh lhucdh dgiuhv|t bi bibkgj tcjibk+ bibkgjgxt |g b rxbi|xat|vhtt ci |oh Bh|ohv+ ci|g |g b rxbtc!vbilga thrxhidh ge t|bilbvlcphl ~xktht+ bibkgjgxt |g |ohrxbi|b vh~vhthi|hl fs lctdvh|h ~bv|cdkht)

2<)2>! Ci gvlhv egv |oh Tcjab!Lhk|b dgiuhv|hv bibkgjs |g b~~ks tb|ctebd|gvcks |g |oh \zg Tkc|H~hvcahi|+ |oh dgilc|cgit |bfxkb|hl fhkgz axt| fh ah|0

Hbdo rxbi|b axt| b~~ks b rxbi|xa t|vhtt |g |oh Bh|ohv)r

Rxbi|xa t|vhtt ci |oh Bh|ohv axt| ~vg~bjb|h ci bkk lcvhd|cgit b| b rxbtc!ciecic|h uhkgdc|s)r

Rxbi|xa t|vhtt ci |oh Bh|ohv ~vgfbfks axt| gfhs |oh ciuhvth trxbvh kbz)r

Rxbi|xa t|vhtt ci |oh Bh|ohv axt| fh vhevbd|hl fs |oh jhgah|vcdbk dgiecjxvb|cgi ge ab||hv)r

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 98/110

\oh rxbi|xa t|vhttht ca~gthl gi |oh Bh|ohv fs axk|c~kh rxbi|b kgdb|hl |ovgxjogx| bkk get~bdh axt| tx~hvca~gth |g ~vglxdh b tcijkh rxbi|xa t|vhtt khuhk b| bis jcuhi ~gci|)

r

B rxbi|b agucij ci b evhh |vb`hd|gvs egkkgzt b ~b|o dgitct|hi| zc|o |oh lceevbd|cgi ~b||hvi ge|oh rxbi|xa t|vhtt c| jhihvb|ht ci |oh Bh|ohv)

Tcidh b rxbi|b vh~vhthi|t b lctdvh|h bagxi| ge hihvjs zockh c|t dgi|vcfx|cgi |g |oh

t|vhtt khuhk ci |oh Bh|ohv ct dgi|cixgxt+ |oh ~b|o ge b ~bv|cdkh dbiig| egkkgz c|t lceevbd|cg~b||hvi ci |oh Bh|ohv hbd|ks) B vhtclxbk rxbi|xa t|vhtt khuhk vhabcit be|hv |oh bvvcubk ghbdo ~bv|cdkh)

v

\oh Bh|ohv acicacpht c|t vhtclxbk rxbi|xa t|vhtt khuhk fs bl`xt|cij |oh ~b|ot getxfthrxhi| ~bv|cdkht |g ~vglxdh |oh gfthvuhl lceevbd|cgi ~b||hvi ci |oh vb|h ge ~bv|cdkhbvvcubk)

v

r

Tcidh |oh kgdbkcphl t|vhtt ci |oh Bh|ohv vhtxk|t evga |oh tx~hv~gtc|cgi ge bkk ge |oh t|vhtttgxvdht ci |oh Xicuhvth+ |oh lceevbd|cgi ~vgdhtt beehd|cij cilcuclxbk ~bv|cdkht ct h|vhahksigcts)

Zockh rxbi|xa heehd|t b~~hbv vbilga+ |ohs bvh agvh dgvvhd|ks lhtdvcfhl btlh|hvacict|cd fx| higvagxtks dobg|cd) Lv) Hcit|hci*t t|b|hahi| |ob| &Jgl lght ig| ~kbslcdh zc|o |oh Xicuhvth& ct dgvvhd| be|hv bkk) /Bt bi hba~kh+ |oh ubvcb|cgit ci |oh ~b|ot gegf`hd|t ci |oh Bt|hvgcl Fhk| bvh lh|hvacict|cd+ fx| |ogth ubvcb|cgit bvh txeecdchi|ks dobg|bt |g ~vhuhi| vcjgvgxt bibkstct ge |ohcv gvfc|t+ egvdcij |oha |g fh dgitclhvhl bt obucijrxbtc!vbilga lhucb|cgit bfgx| |ohcv igacibk gvfc|t) Gddbtcgibkks+ |ogth rxbtc!vbilgagvfc|bk ci|hvbd|cgit bvh txeecdchi| |g |ovgz bi bt|hvgcl gx| ge |oh Bt|hvgcl Fhk| dga~kh|hkGddbtcgibkks+ b vblcgbd|cuh b|ga |ovgzt gih gv agvh ge c|t dga~gihi| ixdkhgit evga c|ixdkhxt)#

v

Gih zgxkl h~hd| |ob| |oh txaab|cgi ge rxbi|xa t|vhttht evga bkk ge |oh huhi|tgddxvvcij |ovgxjogx| |oh Xicuhvth zgxkl gddbtcgibkks dgafcih |g ~vglxdh h|vhahkskbvjh agahi|bvs rxbi|xa t|vhttht b| b jcuhi ~gci|) \oh heehd| zgxkl fh bibkgjgxt |g|oh ~vglxd|cgi ge bi xih~hd|hlks kbvjh zbuh+ dbkkhl b vgjxh zbuh+ ci |oh gdhbi fs |ohdgafcib|cgi ge b kbvjh ixafhv ge lceehvhi| zbuht ge dgitclhvbfks kgzhv ba~kc|xlh)

v

r

2<)22! B dkhbv ~cd|xvh ge vhbkc|s hahvjht zohi hbaciht |oh ubvcgxt bt~hd| ge rxbi|xa |ohgvs bil|oh vhtxk|t ge h~hvcahi|b|cgi gidh gih*t |ocimcij ct ig kgijhv dgit|vbcihl fs |oh xi~vguhibtthv|cgi ge T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s |ob| ciegvab|cgi dbiig| |vbuhk ebt|hv |obi kcjo|) Uhkgdc|s Vhkb|cuc|s+ gT~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s ce |oh vhblhv ~vhehvt+ bil Rxbi|xa \ohgvs ~vguh giks |ob| |oh ~vg~bjb|cgi geciegvab|cgi hidglhl ci |oh egva ge hihvjs ct kcac|hl |g |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo| bil |oh b||hilbi|vhrxcvhahi| |ob| txdo ciegvab|cgi fh rxbi|cechl) \ohvh ct ig gfthvub|cgibk gv |ohgvh|cdbk

vhrxcvhahi| |ob| txf`hd|t ciegvab|cgi zocdo lght ig| ciugkuh hihvjs |g |ogth kcac|b|cgit) C| ct b||oct ~gci| |ob| vg|h |vbcihl ~ostcdct|t dbi abmh b dgi|vcfx|cgi) \ohcv tmckkt ci |oh xth geab|ohab|cdt togxkl bkkgz |oha |g b~~ks ekhto |g gxv xilhvt|bilcij ge vhbkc|s+ huhi |ogxjo |ohsthha |g lhis |oh tcjicecdbidh ge |ob| vhbkc|s)

2<)26! \oh Ohcthifhvj Xidhv|bci|s ^vcidc~kh bil |oh Zbuh Hrxb|cgit0! Gih ge |oh hbvkcht|cidxvtcgit ge rxbi|xa dgidh~|t ci|g dkbttcdbk ~ostcdt zbt |oh Ohcthifhvj Xidhv|bci|s ^vcidc~kh) btthv|t |ob| c| ct ca~gttcfkh |g lh|hvacih |oh ~vglxd| ge |oh ~gtc|cgi bil uhkgdc|s ge b ~bv|cdkh |g bibddxvbds tabkkhv |obi |oh ixahvcdbk ubkxh ge ^kbidm*t Dgit|bi|) \oct gfthvub|cgibk kcac| vhtxk|tevga |oh ebd| |ob|+ ci gvlhv |g lh|hvacih |oh ~gtc|cgi bil'gv uhkgdc|s ge b ~bv|cdkh+ zoh|ohv c| fh bihkhd|vgi gv b fbthfbkk+ c| ct ihdhttbvs |g t|vcmh |oh ~bv|cdkh |g fh ahbtxvhl zc|o big|ohv ~bv|cdkh+

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 99/110

txdo bt b ~og|gi+ bil gfthvuh |oh vhtxk|) Tcidh fg|o ge |ohth ~bv|cdkht ~gtthtt |ohcv gzi cihv|cbkabttht bil uhkgdc|cht+ |ohs hdobijh agahi|xa bt |ohs ci|hvbd|) \g ckkxt|vb|h+ ce bi hkhd|vgi cthbacihl fs b ~og|gi ge axdo kgzhv hihvjs |obi c|t abtt hrxcubkhi| hihvjs+ |oh ~og|gi ct~ostcdbkks kbvjh dga~bvhl |g |oh hkhd|vgi bil dbiig| ahbtxvh |oh hkhd|vgi*t ~gtc|cgi bddxvb|hks)Gi |oh g|ohv obil+ c|t cihv|cbk abtt ct kgz bil lght ig| beehd| |oh hkhd|vgi*t uhkgdc|s tcjicecdbi|ks) |oh hihvjs ge |oh hbacicij ~og|gi ct ocjo dga~bvhl |g |oh abtt hrxcubkhi| hihvjs ge |oh hkhd|vgc|t tcph ct tabkk dga~bvhl |g |oh hkhd|vgi*t bil c| zckk gfthvuh |oh hkhd|vgi*t ~gtc|cgi bddxvb|hks)Ogzhuhv+ |oh cihv|cbk abtt ge txdo b ~og|gi ct kbvjh dga~bvhl |g |ob| ge |oh hkhd|vgi bil |ohci|hvbd|cgi dobijht |oh hkhd|vgi*t uhkgdc|s dgitclhvbfks) \oh Ohcthifhvj Xidhv|bci|s gddxvt

fhdbxth+ ci bddgvlbidh zc|o Rxbi|xa \ohgvs+ |ohvh dbi fh ig ~bv|cdkh bubckbfkh |g |ohh~hvcahi|hv zocdo obt fg|o ihjkcjcfkh abtt bil ihjkcjcfkh tcph) G|ohv |obi |oh ebd| |ob| Rxbi|xaAhdobicdt ~vhlcd|t |oh vhkb|cgitoc~ fh|zhhi |oh ~ostcdbk tcph bil |oh cihv|cbk abtt ge ~bv|cdkht+|ohvh lght ig| thha |g fh b dgiihd|cgi fh|zhhi |oh Ohcthifhvj Xidhv|bci|s bil hc|ohv |ohTdovghlcijhv Zbuh Hrxb|cgi gv g|ohv rxbi|xa heehd|t)

2<)24! \oh Tdovghlcijhv Zbuh Hrxb|cgit zhvh lhvcuhl |g lhbk zc|o |oh gfthvuhl ca~gttcfckc|s gelh|hvacicij |oh kgdb|cgi ge hkhd|vgit ci |ohcv gvfc|t bt gih zgxkl h~hd| ce |ohs zhvh lct|cid|gf`hd|t) \ohcv kgdb|cgit zhvh egxil |g fh expps bil c| zbt ihdhttbvs |g lhtdvcfh |ohcv kgdb|cgit ci|hvat ge ~vgfbfckc|s+ bt lhecihl fs |oh Tdovghlcijhv Zbuh Hrxb|cgit+ vb|ohv |obi ci |hvat geIhz|gicbi Ahdobicdt) Gidh c| ct vhdgjicphl |ob| |oh ~bv|cdkht xilhv gfthvub|cgi+ bil |oh ~bv|cdkhtzocdo bvh xthl |g hbacih |oha+ bvh |ohathkuht dga~gthl ge zbuht+ c| ct ig| xivhbtgibfkh |gh~hd| ca~vhdctcgi ci |oh gfthvub|cgi ge ~gtc|cgi bil uhkgdc|s) \oh gfthvub|cgi ge gih zbuh zc|obig|ohv ct bi ca~vhdcth ~vgdhtt) Zockh |oh ~vgfbfckc|s zbuht lhtdvcfhl fs |oh Tdovghlcijhv ZbuhHrxb|cgit cidkxlh |oct heehd|+ |ohs bktg vhtxk| evga b agvh txf|kh heehd|) Hbvkchv+ |oh t|gvbjh gemcih|cd hihvjs ci b ~bv|cdkh zbt togzi |g gddxv bt b dobijh ci |oh hihvjs ge |oh ~bv|cdkh c|thke bil |oh t|vhttcij ge b lctm kcmh vhjcgi ge t~bdh bvgxil c|) \oh t|gvbjh ge |ob| hihvjs vhrxcvht |cah+ bilegv ~hvcglt ge |cah zocdo bvh togv|hv |obi |oh |cah vhrxcvhl egv |ob| t|gvbjh+ |oh uhkgdc|s vht|vcd|cgica~gthl fs Uhkgdc|s Vhkb|cuc|s lg ig| b~~ks) \oh ~bv|cdkh ct evhh |g fgxidh bvgxil zc|oci b tabkkvhjcgi ge t~bdh b| uhkgdc|cht zocdo bvh jvhb|hv |obi |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|) \g bi h|hvibk gfthvuhvzogth bfckc|s |g gfthvuh ct kcac|hl |g |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|+ ogzhuhv+ |oh ~bv|cdkh b~~hbvt |g hct|tcaxk|bihgxtks b| agvh |obi gih ~gci| zc|oci |ob| vhjcgi) Bt b vhtxk|+ |oh kgdb|cgi ge |oh ~bv|cdkh dbgiks lhtdvcfhl fs |oh Tdovghlcijhv Zbuh Hrxb|cgit ci |hvat ge c|t ~vgfbfkh ~gtc|cgi zc|oci b expp

ugkxah ge t~bdh)

Dob~|hv 28 ! Dobijcij |oh ^bvblcjat

28)2! \oh Docahvb ge b Xicechl Echkl \ohgvs0! \oh kbt| lhdblht ge Lv) Hcit|hci*t dbvhhv bvh vh~gv|hlbt obucij fhhi t~hi| ci bi b||ha~| |g lhuhkg~ b Xicechl Echkl \ohgvs zocdo zgxkl vhlxdh bkk ge~ostcdt |g b tcijkh th| ge hrxb|cgit) Zockh oh zbt ig| txddhttexk ocathke+ dgi|cixb|cgi ge octheegv|t zbt b| khbt| txddhttexk ci hidga~bttcij bkk egvdht fx| jvbuc|s ci|g txdo b th| ge hrxb|cgit

\oh ihhl egv txdo b |ohgvs vhtxk|hl evga |oh ebd| |ob| fg|o Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s bil |oh Rxbi|xa|ohgvs zhvh bddh~|hl bt dgvvhd| bil sh| zhvh cidga~b|cfkh zc|o hbdo g|ohv) \ob| cidga~b|cfckc|svhuhbkt |oh zhbmihtt ge kcac|cij gih*t xilhvt|bilcij |g ab|ohab|cdbk b~~vgbdoht) Zc|o txdo bah|oglgkgjs+ b tcijkh xivhdgjicphl hvvgv dbi lht|vgs |oh ubkclc|s ge higvagxt bagxi|t getxfthrxhi| zgvm) Ci |oct dbth+ |oh xivhdgjicphl ab|ohab|cdbk hvvgv ci |oh lhvcub|cgi ge JhihvbkVhkb|cuc|s zbt |oh dxk~vc|) Zockh |oh lhtdvc~|cgit ge dxvuhl t~bdh+ Fkbdm Ogkht+ Tcijxkbvc|cht+ ZgvaOgkht+ h|d) togxkl obuh ~vguclhl ba~kh zbvicij ge |ob| hvvgv+ |ohgvh|cdbk ~ostcdct|t |vbcihl |gcjigvh dgaagi thith lgxf|t vhkchl gi |ohcv ab|ohab|cdt bil lcl ig| ecil c|) /Gih ct vhacilhl ge|oh ahlchubk |ohgkgjcbit zog bkkhjhlks hijbjhl ci lhfb|h guhv |oh ixafhv ge bijhkt zog dgxkllbidh gi |oh ohbl ge b ~ci)#

28)6! Huhi|xbkks+ |oh T|bilbvl Aglhk bil c|t ~vg~gthl txddhttgv+ |oh Tx~hvt|vcij \ohgvs bil c|t

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 100/110

~hvax|b|cgit hugkuhl) Ci |ob| b~~vgbdo+ c| zbt egxil |ob| fg|o b 2> lcahitcgibk bil b 65lcahitcgibk ab|vc ge hrxb|cgit zhvh db~bfkh ge lhecicij |oh gfthvuhl jvbuc|b|cgibk+hkhd|vgabjih|cd+ |oh t|vgij bil zhbm ixdkhbv egvdht+ bil |oh dobvbd|hvct|cdt ge rxbvmt bil kh~|giZohi |ogth ab|vc tcpht zhvh ha~kgshl+ bkk ge |oh |vgxfkhtgah dvgtt!~vglxd|t zocdo gddxvvhl zcg|ohv ab|vc tcpht dbidhkhl bil |vbd|bfkh tgkx|cgit zhvh gf|bcihl) /\oh bvvbijhahi| ge |oh |hilcahitcgibk th| ge hrxb|cgit ct ~vguclhl ci Ecjxvh 28)2#) Ci |ohcv zvc|cijt gi |oh txf`hd|+ bx|ogvtobuh vbcthl |oh rxht|cgi bt |g zob| t~hdcbk ~vg~hv|cht 2> lcahitcgibk bil 65 lcahitcgibk ab|vcdhobuh zocdo bkkgzt |oha |g zgvm zohi g|ohv ab|vc tcpht ebck) \oh bitzhv |g |ob| rxht|cgi togxkl fb~~bvhi| |g bisgih zog ct gkl higxjo |g obuh g~hvb|hl b |hkhuctcgi th| zocdo obl b ogvcpgi|bk og

dgi|vgk) Ce |oh ogvcpgi|bk ogkl dgi|vgk zbt ig| ~vg~hvks th|+ |oh ogvcpgi|bk tdbi kciht zgxkl ig| kcihx~ uhv|cdbkks bil bi xiuchzbfkh ~cd|xvh zgxkl vhtxk|) Tcackbvks+ ce bi xitxc|bfkh ixafhv ge dgkxaitct xthl ci |oh ab|vc+ |oh lb|b ci txfthrxhi| vgzt zckk ig| bkcji ~vg~hvks ci dgkxait+ dvgtt~vglxd|t zckk vhtxk|+ bil |oh hrxb|cgit zckk fh xitgkubfkh) Ci gvlhv |g bddgaaglb|h |ogth |hi gv|zhi|s tc lcahitcgit ci |oh egxv lcahitcgibk t~bdh ge Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s+ ogzhuhv+ |ohgvh|cdcbitegxil c| ihdhttbvs |g dgitclhv lcahitcgit fhsgil |oh egxv|o |g fh dxvkhl ci|g |cis dcvdkht obucij blcbah|hv agvh |obi |zhi|s gvlhvt ge abjic|xlh tabkkhv |obi |oh ixdkhgi) /Tgahogz+ bddh~|cijtxdo hi|c|cht bt lcahitcgit t|vbcit |oh bx|ogv*t dvhlxkc|s) Huhi |ogxjo |ohs dbi fh ci|hvachl zc||oh dgiuhi|cgibk lcahitcgit ci |oh tgkx|cgi ge ab|ohab|cdbk hrxb|cgit+ |ohs togxkl fh |ogxjo| gelceehvhi|ks bil fh jcuhi b lceehvhi| lhtcjib|cgi)# C| zgxkl b~~hbv |ob| |ohth lcahitcgit zhvhihdhttbvs egv |oh ab|ohab|cdbk tgkx|cgi fx| c| zbt ihdhttbvs |g dgitclhv |oha |g fh ci |ob| ~hdxkc

egva bil ge |ob| tcph ci gvlhv |g ~vhuhi| |oha evga fhcij h~hvcahi|bkks gfthvubfkh bt ihz~bv|cdkht)

28)4! Hbacib|cgi ge |oh ab|vc ckkxt|vb|hl ci Ecjxvh 28)2 vhuhbkt |ob| bkk ge |oh |hvat vhehvvcij |ghbdo c|ha ge ci|hvht| /jvbuc|s+ hkhd|vgabjih|cdt+ t|vgij bil zhbm egvdht+ rxbvmt bil kh~|git# bvhjvgx~hl ci txdo b abiihv bt |g fh cilh~hilhi| ge hbdo g|ohv) Igih ge |oh jvgx~t dgi|bcidvgtt!~vglxd|t zocdo |ch |oha |g |oh g|ohv jvgx~t) \oh ab|vc ct ig| b tcijkh th| ge hrxb|cgit lhecicij huhvs|ocij) C| ct b jvgx~cij ge egxv cilh~hilhi| th|t ge hrxb|cgit zocdo lhtdvcfh xivhkb|hlheehd|t gddxvvcij ci |oh tbah ugkxah ge t~bdh) Bt txdo+ |ohs obvlks vh~vhthi| b xicecdb|cgi ge~ostcdbk |ohgvs) Lhtdvc~|cgit ge |oh ab|ohab|cdbk heegv|t ciugkuhl ci |oh lhuhkg~ahi| ge txdoxicechl |ohgvcht btthv| |ob| lceecdxk|cht h~hvchidhl fs |oh |ohgvh|cdcbi bvh vhlxdhl bt lcahitcgit

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 101/110

bvh bllhl) \oct ct |g fh h~hd|hl+ |oh bllc|cgi ge tx~hvekxgxt lhjvhht ge evhhlga vhlxdht |ohdgit|vbci|t gi |oh |ohgvh|cdcbi*t zgvm) Zob| th~bvb|ht |oh ahi evga |oh fgst ct |oh db~bfckc|s gelhbkcij zc|o ~ostcdbk ~vgfkhat zockh vh|bcicij |oh ixafhv ge lhjvhht ge evhhlga bd|xbkks vhrxcvhlfs Ib|xvh)

28)<! \oh dgidh~| |ob| ab||hv dgitct|t ge kgg~t ge vblcb|cgi schklt b tca~khv ab|vc ge hrxb|cgit+ btogzi fs Ecjxvh 28)6) Jvbuc|s ct lhtdvcfhl fs b 44 ab|vc ge hrxb|cgit) Bllhl |g |ob| ab|vc bvhtcijkh vgz bil dgkxai vh~vhthi|cij ~og|gicd heehd|t bil big|ohv vgz bil dgkxai vh~vhthi|cijihx|vcicd heehd|t) \oh t|vgij bil zhbm egvdht ge |oh T|bilbvl Aglhk ubicto bil hkhd|vgit bil

rxbvmt vhuhv| |g ~hvax|b|cgit ge hkhd|vgabjih|cd bil ihx|vcicd vblcb|cgi)

28)8! \oh Vgkh ge ^bvblg0!\oh vhdgjic|cgi ge b ~bvblg bkzbst vbctht b ekbj) C| |hkkt xt |ob| |zg gvagvh dgidh~|t zocdo obuh fhhi bddh~|hl bt |vxh bvh ci dgiekcd| bil c| vhuhbkt+ bt lcl |oh Vcjo|Bijkh Khuhv ^bvblg lhtdvcfhl hbvkchv+ |ob| bi hvvgv hct|t ci gih gv agvh ge |oh dgidh~|t bil c| ctihdhttbvs |g vh|ocim |oh clhbt ciugkuhl) Ci |oh dbth ge |oh Vcjo| Bijkh Khuhv ^bvblg+ |oh vh|ocimci~vgdhtt vhtxk|hl ci b vhuctcgi ge |oh Kgvhi|p \vbitegvab|cgi egv \vbituhvth Egvdh) Txv~vctcijks+ |odgaaxic|s ge ~ostcdbk tdchi|ct|t lght ig| thha |g abmh b tcjicecdbi| xth ge |oh g~~gv|xic|cht |ob~bvblght ~vhthi|) Egv ckkxt|vb|cgi+ |zg zhkk migzi ~bvblght+ |oh ^bvblg ge Phig bilTdovghlcijhv*t Db| ^bvblg bvh lhtdvcfhl)

28)5! \oh ^bvblg ge Phig ct 6>>> shbvt gkl bil c|t b~~bvhi| bfckc|s |g ~vguh |ob| bkk ag|cgi ctca~gttcfkh zbt ig| vhtgkuhl xi|ck |oh ab|ohab|cdbk |hdoicrxht ge Dbkdxkxt fhdbah bubckbfkh+ huhi|ogxjo |ob| |hdoicrxh ct ig| vhrxcvhl) Gih egva ge |oh ~bvblg lhtdvcfht |oh ekcjo| ge bi bvvgzzocdo obt fhhi tog| b| b |bvjh|) \oh bvvgz ct tog| b| b dgit|bi| uhkgdc|s+ U+ |g b |bvjh| b| b lct|bidK+ bil |oh |cah ge ekcjo| ct lcuclhl ci|g ci|hvubkt) Ci |oh ecvt| ci|hvubk+ |oh bvvgz dguhvt obke ge |ohlct|bidh |g |oh |bvjh| bil+ ci hbdo txddhhlcij ci|hvubk ge |cah+ c| dguhvt obke ge |oh vhabcicijlct|bidh) Xilhv |oh kcih ge vhbtgicij ~vhthi|hl+ |oh bvvgz ihuhv vhbdoht |oh |bvjh| fhdbxth+ be|hvhbdo txddhttcuh ci|hvubk ge |cah+ gih obke ge |oh lct|bidh |g |oh |bvjh| |ob| hct|hl b| |oh fhjciicij

ge |oh ci|hvubk vhabcit) \oh bx|ogv ecilt c| cidvhlcfkh |ob| |oct ~bvblg obt fhhi |bmhi thvcgxtks fsci|hkkcjhi| ahi egv guhv |zg ackkhiicb bil obt ig| fhhi vhdgjicphl bt b egva ge |vcdmhvs) Ce gihbddh~|t |ob| ci hbdo txddhttcuh ci|hvubk ge |cah |oh bvvgz |vbuhkhl obke ge |oh vhabcicij lct|bidh ||oh |bvjh|+ oh axt| bktg bddh~| |ob| hbdo ge |ogth txddhttcuh ci|hvubkt ge |cah ct obke ge |oh lxvb|cgge |oh ci|hvubk zocdo ~vhdhlhl c|) Bt b vhtxk|+ xilhv |oh ^bvblg ge Phig+ ig| giks lght |oh bvvgzihuhv vhbdo |oh |bvjh|+ |oh hkb~thl |cah ge c|t ekcjo| ihuhv vhbdoht |oh |cah+ \+ zohi |oh bvvgz zgxvhbdo |oh |bvjh|) \ohvh ct ig ~bvblg ci |oh ^bvblg ge |oh Phig) Bt kgij bt gih bkkgzt b dohb~|vcdm |g eggk oca ci|g dgitclhvcij giks |ogth huhi|t zocdo gddxv ~vcgv |g |oh bvvcubk ge |oh bvvgz b||oh |bvjh|+ oh agt| dhv|bciks zckk fhkchuh |ob| |oh bvvgz ihuhv vhbdoht |oh |bvjh|) \oh vhbkc|s ct |ob||oh ~bttbjh ge |cah lght ig| tkgz bt |oh bvvgz b~~vgbdoht |oh |bvjh| bil |oh bvvgz vhbdoht |oh|bvjh| gi tdohlxkh)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 102/110

28):! \oh Tdovghlcijhv Db| ^bvblg ct agvh htg|hvcd) Ci gih egva ge |oct ~bvblg+ b dkgthl fgdgi|bcit b tgxvdh ge dsbiclh jbt+ b ahbit ge vhkhbtcij |ob| jbt zohi b tcjibk evga b vblcb|cgilh|hd|gv thitht bi bk~ob ~bv|cdkh /ohkcxa ixdkhxt#+ bil b vblcgbd|cuh hkhahi| zocdo vhkhbtht bk~o~bv|cdkht b| b vb|h lh|hvacihl fs c|t obke kceh) B db| ct ~kbdhl ci |oh fg egv b ~hvcgl ge |cah hrxbk |g|oh ~vgfbfkh |cah ge |oh ih| vhkhbth ge bi bk~ob ~bv|cdkh) Ce |oh bk~ob ~bv|cdkh ct hac||hl fhegvh |ohdb| ct vhaguhl evga |oh fg+ |oh dsbiclh ct vhkhbthl bil |oh db| lcht) Ce |oh bk~ob ~bv|cdkh ct hac||hbe|hv |oh db| ct vhaguhl+ c| kcuht) Bddgvlcij |g rxbi|xa ahdobicdt+ |oh lhdbs ge |oh b|ga zocdovhtxk|t ci |oh hacttcgi ge |oh bk~ob ~bv|cdkh ct lh|hvacihl hi|cvhks fs dobidh bil+ xilhv |ohci|hv~vh|b|cgit ge rxbi|xa ~ostcdt+ |oh b|ga tcaxk|bihgxtks hct|t ci |oh fg|o |oh lhdbshl bil

xilhdbshl t|b|ht bil giks vhuhv|t |g gih ge |ogth t|b|ht zohi c| ct gfthvuhl) Tdovghlcijhv*t Db|^bvblg btthv|t |ob| tcidh |ohvh ct ig zbs |g gfthvuh zoh|ohv |oh db| ct lhbl gv bkcuh zockh |ohdobafhv vhabcit dkgthl+ rxbi|xa ahdobicdt vhrxcvht |ob| |oh db| tcaxk|bihgxtks hct|t ci |zgt|b|ht+ fg|o bkcuh bil lhbl+ xi|ck c|t t|b|h ct bd|xbkks gfthvuhl zohi |oh fg ct g~hihl)

28)?! \g |oh kbsabi+ Tdovghlcijhv*t Db| ^bvblg thhat bftxvl) Ogz dgxkl c| fh ~gttcfkh egv |oh d|g fh fg|o bkcuh bil lhbl b| |oh tbah |cah7 \oh kbsabi ct dgvvhd|+ |oh db| lght ig| hct| ci fg|ot|b|ht tcaxk|bihgxtks bil rxbi|xa ahdobicdt lght ig| vhrxcvh |ob| c| lg tg) \oh tcjicecdbi|gfthvub|cgi ct ig| |oh gfthvub|cgi ablh fs |oh h~hvcahi|hv zohi oh g~hit |oh fg+ |ohgfthvub|cgi zocdo dgxi|t ct |oh lhdbs ge |oh vblcgbd|cuh b|ga) Huhi |oh lh|hd|cgi ge c|t lhdbs fs|oh vblcb|cgi lh|hd|gv ct ig| b rxbi|xa ahdobicdbk dgitclhvb|cgi) Btthv|cij |ob| |oh db| hct|t ci b

lxbk bkcuh!lhbl t|b|h xi|ck c| ct gfthvuhl fs |oh h~hvcahi|hv ct bfgx| bt thitcfkh bt btthv|cij |ob||oh uhvlcd| ci |oh G)@) Tca~tgi |vcbk zbt tcaxk|bihgxtks *jxck|s* bil *ig| jxck|s* bt c| kbs guhvicjo| cib thbkhl hiuhkg~h ~vcgv |g fhcij vhbl) \oh tcjicecdbi| gfthvub|cgi ci Rxbi|xa Ahdobicdt ct gihzocdo beehd|t b ~ostcdbk ~bv|cdkh) Zoh|ohv bi ci|hkkcjhi| gfthvuhv ct bzbvh ge |ob| gfthvub|cgi cti*|tcjicecdbi|) \oh Tdovghlcijhv Db| ^bvblg ct ig| b ~bvblg bt igvabkks t|b|hl) C| ct bi bftxvlc|stcackbv |g |oh bftxvlc|s ge |oh rxht|cgi bt |g zoh|ohv b |vhh abmht b tgxil zohi c| ebkkt ci b egvht|zc|o ig gih ~vhthi| |g ohbv c|t ebkk) Ci |oh ~ostcdbk tdchidht+ tgxil ct b ~ostcdbk ~ohigahib+ ig| b~tsdogkgjcdbk ~ohigahib) C| lght ig| vhrxcvh |oh ~vhthidh ge bi ci|hkkcjhi| gfthvuhv |g hct|)

28)3! \oh hvvgv ekbj ~vhthi|hl fs Tdovghlcijhv*t Db| ^bvblg lght vhuhbk |ob| gxv |ogxjo|~vgdhttht bfgx| rxbi|xa ~ostcdt bvh ciblhrxb|h) \ohs bvh fbthl x~gi |oh vcjcl bddh~|bidh ge |oclhb |ob| ig hi|c|s dbi |vbuhk ebt|hv |obi kcjo|) Vhdgjic|cgi ge |oh ebd| |ob| |cah ct vhrxcvhl egv |oh

mcih|cd hihvjs khuhk ge b ~bv|cdkh |g dobijh lhagit|vb|ht |ob| |oh clhb |ob| |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|vh~vhthi|t bi bftgkx|h t~hhl kcac| ct ig| rxc|h |vxh) \ob| |cah lhkbs ciugkuhl ci bdrxcvcij/kgtcij#mcih|cd hihvjs bkkgzt b ~bv|cdkh |g |vbuhk b tabkk lct|bidht b| b uhkgdc|s jvhb|hv |obi |ob| ge kcjo|) \gbi gfthvuhv+ txdo b ~bv|cdkh zckk ebkthks b~~hbv |g fh ci |zg ~kbdht tcaxk|bihgxtks) Zohi gih bllt|oh ebd| |ob| t|vhtt ci |oh rxbi|xa echkl ~vg~bjb|ht b| b rxbtc!ciecic|h uhkgdc|s+ |oh ~bvblgcdbkheehd|t b||vcfx|hl |g |oh Tdovghlcijhv Zbuh Hrxb|cgit zckk ~vgfbfks ubicto)\ohvh dbi fh ig ~bvblght ci Ib|xvh)

28)2>! Dbi |oh Thdgil Kbz ge \ohvaglsibacdt fh dcvdxauhi|hl7! \oh ubkclc|s ge |oh Ecvt| bilThdgil Kbzt ge \ohvaglsibacdt thhat |g fh fhsgil rxht|cgi) Xilhv |oh ecvt| kbz+ |oh |g|bkhihvjs dgi|hi| ge b dkgthl tst|ha axt| vhabci dgit|bi|) Xilhv |oh thdgil kbz+ |oh bubckbfckc|s gehihvjs egv xthexk ~xv~gtht axt| bkzbst lhdvhbth gv vhabci dgit|bi| zc|oci |ob| dkgthl tst|ha) Ci

heehd|+ |oh Ecvt| Kbz ge \ohvaglsibacdt t|b|ht |ob| sgx dbi*| zci bil |oh Thdgil Kbz t|b|ht |ob|+exv|ohvagvh+ sgx dbi*| fvhbm huhi) \oh Ecvt| Kbz ge \ohvaglsibacdt ct xirxht|cgibfks |vxh+ hihvjdbi ihc|ohv fh dvhb|hl gv lht|vgshl+ Jhihvbk Vhkb|cuc|s ig| zc|ot|bilcij) \oh Thdgil Kbz ge\ohvaglsibacdt t|bilt gi khtt ecva jvgxil fhdbxth c| ct b kbz fbthl x~gi t|b|ct|cdt) Bt txdo+ c|ci |oh tbah db|hjgvs bt bi bd|xbvcbk |bfkh) Bi citxvbidh dga~bis dbi ~vhlcd| rxc|h bddxvb|hks ogzabis ~hg~kh zckk lch ci b jcuhi shbv) \ohs dbiig| ~vhlcd| zog |ogth ~hg~kh zckk fh) T|b|ct|cdbk kbztbvh ubkcl egv kbvjh ixafhvt ge huhi|t+ |ohs fhdgah khtt tcjicecdbi| bt |oh ixafhv ge huhi|t ctvhlxdhl) Bt bi hba~kh+ ce gih ~b|vgicpht b dbtcig+ oh acjo| cic|cbkks zci b kbvjh txa ge agihs~kbscij b tkg| abdocih+ fx| ce oh dgi|cixht |g ~kbs oh ig| giks zckk jcuh bkk oct zciicijt fbdm |g |ohdbtcig+ oh zckk txt|bci b tcjicecdbi| kgtt) \oh rxht|cgi |ohi bvctht bt |g zoh|ohv c| ct ~gttcfkh |gfs!~btt |oh Thdgil Kbz ge \ohvaglsibacdt |ogxjo |oh xth ge ibigabdociht) /B ibigabdocih ct

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 103/110

b ahdobicta zogth tcjicecdbi| lcahitcgit bvh ahbtxvhl ci ibigah|hvt+ |oh tcph tdbkh ge b|gat)#

28)22! Gih zog gfthvuht Fvgzicbi ag|cgi ci b acdvgtdg~h acjo| vhbtgibfks dgidkxlh |ob|+ ci~vcidc~kh b| khbt|+ b ibigabdocih dgxkl fh fxck| zocdo zgxkl fs~btt |oh Thdgil Kbz ge\ohvaglsibacdt) Zohi b kcrxcl dgi|bcicij acdvgtdg~cd ~bv|cdkht ct gfthvuhl+ |oh ~bv|cdkht bvhthhi |g fh ci dgi|cixgxt /Fvgzicbi# ag|cgi) \ob| ag|cgi ct dbxthl fs vbilga |ohvabk ca~bd|tfh|zhhi |oh agkhdxkht ge |oh kcrxcl bil |oh ~bv|cdkht) Ce |oh |ohvabk ag|cgi ge zb|hv agkhdxkht dbi

~vglxdh b uctcfks gfthvubfkh ag|cgi ci ~bv|cdkht zocdo bvh b| khbt| 2>28 |caht bt abttcuh+ c|dhv|bciks ig| xivhbtgibfkh |g fhkchuh |ob| txc|bfkh ibigabdociht dgxkl gvjbicph |oh heehd| |g

~vglxdh b xthexk ahdobicdbk gx|~x|) \oh ~gt|xkb|hl ibigabdociht zgxkl |ohi fh bfkh |g h~gv|hihvjs |g |oh gx|tclh hiucvgiahi| zocdo c| gf|bcihl fs vhlxdcij |oh |ha~hvb|xvh ge |oh kcrxcl) \ohh~gv|hl hihvjs zgxkl fh dgiuhv|hl |g ohb| bil vbcth |oh |ha~hvb|xvh ge |oh h|hvibk hiucvgiahi|bt |oh gx|~x| ~hvegvahl xthexk zgvm) \oh vhtxk|bi| |ha~hvb|xvh lceehvhidh fh|zhhi |oh hiucvgiahbil |oh kcrxcl zckk |ohi dbxth |oh hihvjs zocdo obl lgih xthexk zgvm |g ekgz fbdm ci|g |oh kcrxcl |gvh|xvi c| |g c|t gvcjcibk |ha~hvb|xvh bil bkkgzt |oh ~vgdhtt |g dgi|cixh cilhecic|hks)

28)26! @baht Dkbvm Abzhkk ~vg~gthl b os~g|oh|cdbk ~hv~h|xbk ag|cgi abdocih+ migzi btAbzhkk*t Lhagi+ zocdo zbt ig| ~vguhi |g fh |ohgvh|cdbkks xizgvmbfkh egv :8 shbvt) Ci |ob|abdocih+ Abzhkk cabjcihl |ob| b lhagi dgi|vgkkhl b acdvgtdg~cd jb|h fh|zhhi |zg jbt eckkhldobafhvt) Abmcij xth ge |oh ebd| |ob|+ ci b jbt+ |oh uhkgdc|s ge |oh agkhdxkht ct vbilga bil |ob| |o|ha~hvb|xvh ge |oh jbt ct lh|hvacihl fs |oh ahbi uhkgdc|s ge |ogth agkhdxkht+ Abzhkk ~vg~gthl|oh dgidh~| |ob|+ ce bi b~~vg~vcb|h lhagi hct|hl+ oh dgxkl thith |oh t~hhl ge agkhdxkhtb~~vgbdocij |oh jb|h bil g~hi |oh jb|h giks zohi b ebt| agkhdxkh b~~vgbdohl c| evga gih tclh gvzohi b tkgz agkhdxkh b~~vgbdohl c| evga |oh g|ohv tclh) Fs g~hvb|cij |oh jb|h ci |oct abiihv+ |ohlhagi zgxkl tgv| |oh agkhdxkht tg |ob| gih dobafhv dgi|bcihl ebt| agkhdxkht bil |oh g|ohvdobafhv dgi|bcihl tkgz agkhdxkht) Tcidh |oh |ha~hvb|xvh ge b jbt ct lh|hvacihl fs |oh ahbiuhkgdc|s ge c|t agkhdxkht+ txdo b ~vgdhtt zckk abci|bci b |ha~hvb|xvh lceehvhidh fh|zhhi |ohdobafhvt zocdo dbi fh h~kgc|hl |g ~vglxdh xthexk zgvm ci b lcvhd| ucgkb|cgi ge |oh Thdgil Kbz g\ohvaglsibacdt) C| |ggm :8 shbvt fhegvh b vcjgvgxt ~vgge zbt egxil zocdo zbt bfkh |g togz |ob||oh hihvjs vhrxcvhl egv Abzhkk*t Lhagi |g clhi|ces |oh ebt| bil tkgz agkhdxkht bil bkkgz |oh jb|h|g g~hvb|h zbt b| khbt| bt jvhb| bt |oh hihvjs zocdo dgxkl fh vhkhbthl bil Abzhkk*t Lhagi zbttogzi |g fh bi xizgvmbfkh dgidh~|)

28)24! \ohvh ct b aglcecdb|cgi |g |oh dgidh~| ge Abzhkk*t Lhagi egv zocdo |ohvh ct+ b| khbt| bt sh|ig ubkcl |ohgvh|cdbk gf`hd|cgi) Tx~~gth |ob| |oh |zg dobafhvt ge |oh Abzhkk*t Lhagi hba~kh igkgijhv vhks gi b lhagi fx| bvh th~bvb|hl fs b lceextcgi ahafvbih obucij b ~hvahbfckc|s evga tclhB |g tclh F zocdo ct ocjohv |obi |oh ~hvahbfckc|s evga tclh F |g tclh B+ bt togzi ci Ecjxvh 28)4) \ohihvjs vhrxcvhl |g bkkgz |oh ahafvbih |g abmh |oh lhdctcgit c| ihhlt |g abmh ci gvlhv egv c| |gexid|cgi ci |oct abiihv ct bubckbfkh ci |oh mcih|cd hihvjs ge |oh jbt agkhdxkht ~bttcij |ovgxjo c|) Cilceextcij |ovgxjo |oh ahafvbih+ agkhdxkht dbi ~vguclh |oh hihvjs ihhlhl fs fhcij tkgzhl evga|ohcv buhvbjh vgga |ha~hvb|xvh uhkgdc|s ge bfgx| 24>> ehh| ~hv thdgil |g b axdo kgzhv hc| uhkgdc|\oh kgzhv uhkgdc|s ge |oh jbt khbucij |oh ahafvbih ahbit |ob| tclh F ct dgklhv |obi |oh bafchi||ha~hvb|xvh) \oh kgtt ge mcih|cd hihvjs fs |oh agkhdxkht bt |ohs ~btt |ogxjo ahafvbih ~vguclht|oh hihvjs vhrxcvhl |g g~hvb|h |oh lceehvhi|cbk lceextcgi ahdobicta ci |oh ahafvbih ~gvht+ bil |o

ahafvbih fhdgaht zbvahv |obi |oh bafchi| |ha~hvb|xvh) Ce |oh txvebdh bvhbt bvh txeecdchi|kskbvjh+ |oh |ha~hvb|xvh ge |oh jbt gi fg|o tclht ge |oh ahafvbih bil ge |oh ahafvbih c|thke axt|vhabci dkgth |g |oh |ha~hvb|xvh ge |oh hiucvgiahi|) Bt b vhtxk|+ |oh ~vhttxvh ci dobafhv F zckk fhocjohv |obi |oh ~vhttxvh ci dobafhv B) \ob| lceehvhidh ci ~vhttxvh dbi fh xthl |g g~hvb|h b |xvfcibil ~vguclh xthexk gx|~x| ~gzhv) Bt |oh gx|~x| ~gzhv ct ~vglxdhl fs |oh jbt ekgzcij |ovgxjo |oh|xvfcih+ |oh dobafhvt bvh dggkhl fhkgz |oh bafchi| |ha~hvb|xvh bil hihvjs ekgzt evga |ohhiucvgiahi| |g |oh dobafhvt |g vh~kbdh |oh hihvjs lhkcuhvhl fs |oh |xvfcih) \oh bvvbijhahi|zgxkl h|vbd| xthexk hihvjs evga c|t hiucvgiahi| ci lcvhd| dgi|vblcd|cgi |g |oh Thdgil Kbz ge\ohvaglsibacdt)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 104/110

28)2<! Dgidh~|xbkks+ |oh ahafvbih acjo| fh dgit|vxd|hl zc|o ~gvht zocdo zhvh dguhvhl fs t~vcijkgblhl |vb~lggvt+ bt togzi ci Ecjxvh 28)<) Ci |oct ckkxt|vb|cgi+ b agkhdxkh vh~vhthi|hl fs b fbkkzgxkl b~~vgbdo |oh vcjo| tclh ge |oh ahafvbih b| b uhkgdc|s zocdo zbt b~~vg~vcb|h |g c|t|ha~hvb|xvh+ migdm |oh |vb~lggv g~hi+ bil ~btt |ovgxjo c|) B tcackbv agkhdxkh b~~vgbdocij |oh|vb~lggv evga |oh khe| tclh zgxkl fgxidh fbdm bil ig| ~btt |ovgxjo |g |oh vcjo| tclh) Zohi |ohagkhdxkh gi |oh vcjo| ~btthl |ovgxjo |oh |vb~lggv+ c| zgxkl kgth agt| ge c|t mcih|cd hihvjs |g |oh|vb~lggv bil hc| b| b kgz uhkgdc|s) Bt b vhtxk|+ |oh |vb~lggv bil |oh ahafvbih zgxkl fh ohb|hl bi|oh agkhdxkh zocdo ~btthl |ogxjo c| zgxkl fh dggkhl) \oh ~vgdhtt zgxkl jhihvb|h b kgdbk|ha~hvb|xvh lceehvhidh zocdo zgxkl rxcdmks fh hrxbkcphl fs bis vhbtgibfkh khuhk ge ohb| |vbitehv)

28)28! \oh ecvt| |ohgvh|cdbk gf`hd|cgi |g |oct |s~h ge ~hv~h|xbk ag|cgi abdocih |ob| |oh bx|ogv obtegxil ci kc|hvb|xvh ct |ob| c| dbiig| zgvm fhdbxth c| ucgkb|ht |oh Thdgil Kbz ge \ohvaglsibacdt)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 105/110

\oct ct obvlks b ubkcl gf`hd|cgi tcidh |oh bvvbijhahi| ct t~hdcecdbkks lhtcjihl |g fs~btt |ohkcac|b|cgit ge |ob| kbz) \oh Thdgil Kbz ge \ohvaglsibacdt ct b t|b|ct|cdbk kbz bil c| ct ig| fcilcijgi ibigabdocihvs tcidh txdo ahdobictat lhbk zc|o agkhdxkht gi bi cilcuclxbk fbtct bil |oh~gvht ge |oh lceextcgi ahafvbih dhv|bciks rxbkces bt b ibigahdobicta) \oh giks g|ohv |ohgvh|cdbkgf`hd|cgi |ob| |oh bx|ogv obt egxil zbt ~vguclhl ci big|ohv fggm fs Lv) Ehsiabii ci zocdo ohlhtdvcfhl b ibigahdobicta dgitct|cij ge b vcuhvfgb| |s~h ge ~bllkh zohhk agxi|hl gi b tobe|citclh b dskcilhv dgi|bcicij b ekxcl) \oh ~bllkh zohhk zbt fgafbvlhl fs |oh vbilga ag|cgi ge |ohagkhdxkht ge |oh ekxcl bil dbxthl |oh tobe| xilhvjg b vbilga vg|bvs gtdckkb|cgi) \g dgiuhv| |octag|cgi |g b xthexk gx|~x|+ bi h|hvibk gih!zbs vb|doh| zbt b||bdohl |g |oh tobe|) Lv) Ehsiabii |oh

lhagit|vb|hl |ob| |oh lhucdh zgxkl ig| zgvm fhdbxth |oh ig|cgi ge |oh vb|doh| ~bzk zgxkl jhihvbhigxjo ohb| tg |ob| |oh vhtxk|bi| agkhdxkbv ag|cgi zgxkl abmh |oh ~bzk fgxidh txeecdchi|ks |gvhilhv |oh gih zbs ahdobicta cig~hvb|cuh)

28)25! Evga |oh lhtdvc~|cgi ~vguclhl+ c| ct gfucgxt |ob|+ zockh Lv) Ehsiabii ct bi hdhkkhi||ohgvh|cdbk ~ostcdct|+ oh ct ig| bt heehd|cuh bt b lhtcji hijcihhv) Vhkgdb|cij |oh vb|doh| ahdobicta|g |oh ci|hvcgv ge |oh ekxcl dobafhv dggkt c| bil lba~hit c|t fgxidh+ dbxtcij Lv) Ehsiabii*tgf`hd|cgit |g ubicto) Zohi |oh aglhk ct aglcechl+ Lv) Ehsiabii ~vgfbfks zgxkl fh egvdhl |g bjvh|ob| xikhtt oh dgxkl lhucth big|ohv gf`hd|cgi+ |oh dgidh~| togxkl vh~vhthi| b ~ostcdbkks vhbkcpbfkhlhucdh zocdo zgxkl fs!~btt |oh Thdgil Kbz ge \ohvaglsibacdt) B |ohgvh|cdbk lhagit|vb|cgi |ob|oh ahdobicta txjjht|hl fs |oh bx|ogv dbiig| zgvm vhrxcvht b ~vgge |ob| |oh ~hvahbfckc|s ge bkk~gttcfkh lceextcgi ahafvbiht axt| fh |oh tbah ci fg|o lcvhd|cgit) Lhvcucij txdo b ~vgge abs fh~bv|cdxkbvks lceecdxk| fhdbxth |oh ~gvht ge |oh vhrxcvhl ahafvbih bvh bfkh |g h|vbd| hihvjs evga |oagkhdxkht zocdo ~btt |ogxjo |oha) Dgitclhvbfkh heegv| ct `xt|cechl ci lhuhkg~cij txdo b ~vggefhdbxth+ ce |ob| ~vgge dbiig| fh egxil+ |oh ~gttcfckc|s ge fxcklcij b ~hv~h|xbk ag|cgi abdocih ge |othdgil mcil ct ig| eggkcto bil bi bkk gx| heegv| ct `xt|cechl |g lhagit|vb|h c|) Ce c| dbi fh fxck|+ tgdch|zgxkl obuh bi cihobxt|cfkh bil ~gkkx|cgi evhh tgxvdh ge hihvjs zocdo ~vgfbfks dgxkl fh tcphl egxth ci |oh tabkkht| ogaht bil |oh kbvjht| ebd|gvcht)

28)2:! \oh Xicrxhihtt ge |oh Hbv|o0! \ohvh ct dgitclhvbfkh ci|hvht| ci |oh ~gttcfckc|s |ob| |ohvh absfh b kbvjh ixafhv ge ~kbih|t ci gxv jbkbs zocdo bvh txc|bfkh egv kceh) Ci |oh og~h |ob| |ohvh abs fhci|hkkcjhi| kceh gi ~kbih|t kscij zc|oci b vhbtgibfkh lct|bidh+ b ~vg`hd| ibahl TH\C /Thbvdo egvH|vb|hvvht|vcbk Ci|hkkcjhidh# obt fhhi th| x~ |g thbvdo egv huclhidh ge |ob| kceh) \oh clhb fhocil |oh

~vg`hd| ct |ob| ci|hkkcjhi| kceh abs fh jhihvb|cij tcjibkt zocdo dbi fh vhdhcuhl gi Hbv|o |ob| bvhhc|ohv b fs!~vglxd| ge |ohcv dcuckcpb|cgi /txdo bt gxv gzi vblcg fvgbldbt|t# gv b lhkcfhvb|h b||ha~| dgaaxicdb|h) Xiegv|xib|hks+ |oh ~vgfbfckc|s ge txddhtt ge |ogth ~vgjvbat ct ebv kgzhv |obidxvvhi|ks fhkchuhl) Ce bi Hbv|o tcphl ~kbih| hct|hl 34+>>>+>>> ackht evga b t|bv zocdo zbt ucv|xbkclhi|cdbk |g |oh Txi+ c| ct h|vhahks xikcmhks |ob| c| zgxkl fh db~bfkh ge tx~~gv|cij kceh) \g thh zos|oct togxkl fh tg+ bi hbacib|cgi ge gxv gzi Tgkbv Tst|ha ct gvlhv)

28)2?! Zc|o |oh hdh~|cgi ge Ahvdxvs+ |oh Hbv|o+ Abvt+ bil ^kx|g+ bkk ge |oh ~kbih|t obuh higvagxtb|agt~ohvht /vhkb|cuh |g |oh Hbv|o#) Gih dbi lvbz ig dgidkxtcgit bfgx| |oh |oh gvcjcibk dgilc|cgitgi Ahvdxvs gv ^kx|g) Ahvdxvs ct |gg tabkk bil |gg dkgth |g |oh Txi |g obuh ~vhuhi|hl c|tb|agt~ohvh+ vhjbvlkhtt ge c|t gvcjcibk rxbi|c|s+ evga fgckcij bzbs |g t~bdh) /\ohvh abs fh bvhaibi| ge bi b|agt~ohvh evgphi b| |oh ~gkht)# B| |oh g|ohv h|vhah+ lxh |g c|t lct|bidh evga |oh

Txi+ bis b|agt~ohvh |ob| ^kx|g abs obuh obl b| c|t fhjciicij bil zocdo obt ig| fhhi kgt| fshub~gvb|cgi |g t~bdh ct evgphi tgkcl bil ct |ohvhegvh xigfthvubfkh) Gfthvub|cgit obuh togzi |ob|Abvt gidh obl b tcjicecdbi| b|agt~ohvh zocdo tx~~gv|hl vxiicij zb|hv /bil+ fs ca~kcdb|cgi+gdhbit# fx| obt kgt| fg|o) B~~bvhi|ks+ c|t kgz jvbuc|b|cgibk abtt obt ablh c| |gg hbts egv |oh Txi*vblcb|cgi |g dbxth Abv*t b|agt~ohvh |g hub~gvb|h |g t~bdh) Ge bkk |oh ~kbih|t+ c| ct Hbv|o |ob| ct |ohbigabks)

28)23! Lxh |g c|t kgdb|cgi+ Uhixt vhdhcuht bfgx| |zcdh |oh ohb| ci~x| evga |oh Txi bt lght |oh Hbv|C|t jvbuc|b|cgibk abtt ct tkcjo|ks khtt |obi |ob| ge |oh Hbv|o bil sh| c| obt bi b|agt~ohvh bfgx| :>|caht bt lhith bt |oh Hbv|o) C| thhat vhbtgibfkh |g dgidkxlh |ob| |oh hbvks oct|gvs ge |oh TgkbvTst|ha ~vgfbfks zhi| |ovgxjo |oh egkkgzcij t|bjht0

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 106/110

\oh ~kbih|t zhvh egvahl fs |oh dgkkctcgi ge tabkkhv gf`hd|t dcvdkcij |oh Txi ci hddhi|vcd gvfc|\oh dgkkctcgi ~vgdhtt dgi|cixhl xi|ck |oh Tgkbv Tst|ha zbt ucv|xbkks dkhbvhl ge gf`hd|t ciigi!dcvdxkbv gvfc|t)

Lxvcij |oh ~kbih|bvs egvab|cgi t|bjh+ |oh ~kbih|t dgxkl ig| bdrxcvh b|agt~ohvhtfhdbxth |oh fgafbvlahi| zocdo zbt egvacij |oha ablh |ohcv txvebdht h|vhahks og|)Bis b|agt~ohvcd jbtht zocdo ca~bd|hl |oh ~kbih| evga ci|hv~kbih|bvs t~bdh zgxkl fgc

bzbs caahlcb|hks)

v

r

Gidh |oh vb|h ge fgafbvlahi| egvacij |oh ~kbih|t vhlxdhl |g |oh ~gci| zohvh |oh ~kbih|tdgxkl dggk txeecdchi|ks+ |ohs ~vgdhhlhl |g dgkkhd| b|agt~ohvht evga |oh jbtht zocdo vhabcihci |oh Tgkbv Tst|ha)

Egv Uhixt |g obuh c|t ~vhthi| b|agt~ohvcd lhitc|s+ bkk ge |oh ~kbih|t+ cidkxlcij |oh Hbv|axt| obuh bdrxcvhl higvagxt /fs Hbv|o t|bilbvlt# b|agt~ohvht)

B ~kbih| jbcit b|agt~ohvh fs tzhh~cij x~ jbtht evga ci|hv~kbih|bvs t~bdh) C|kgttht b|agt~ohvh |ovgxjo hub~gvb|cgi ge |ogth jbtht |g |ob| tbah t~bdh evga c|x~~hvagt| kbshv)

t

v

r

Ci gvlhv egv b agkhdxkh ge jbt |g fh kgt| |g |oh ~kbih|+ c| axt| bdrxcvh b |ohvabk uhkgdc|s jvhb|h|obi |oh ~kbih|*t htdb~h uhkgdc|s) \oct axt| gddxv b| bi bk|c|xlh b| zocdo |oh b|agt~ohvh cttxeecdchi|ks |oci tg |ob| c| lght ig| t|vcmh g|ohv agkhdxkht zockh htdb~cij)

\oh vb|h b| zocdo b|agt~ohvcd jbtht bvh kgt| |g t~bdh ct lh|hvacihl bkagt| hi|cvhks fs|oh vb|h ge hihvjs ci~x| evga |oh Txi bil fs |oh htdb~h uhkgdc|s ge |oh ~kbih| b| |oh |g~ge c|t b|agt~ohvh \oh vb|h ge b|agt~ohvh kgtt ct ucv|xbkks cilh~hilhi| ge |oh bagxi| geb|agt~ohvh |oh ~kbih| gzit)

v

r

28)6>! \oh Hbv|o!Aggi tst|ha obt |zg dobvbd|hvct|cdt zocdo bvh bigabkgxt dga~bvhl |g |oh g|oh~kbih|t) \oh ecvt| ct |ob| c| obt ebv |gg axdo bijxkbv agahi|xa /gvfc|bk bijxkbv agahi|xa+vg|b|cgibk bijxkbv agahi|xa ge |oh Hbv|o bil |oh Aggi+ bil gvfc|bk bijxkbv agahi|xa ge |ohAggi bvgxil |oh Hbv|o#) Bt ~gci|hl gx| ci b |h| fs Lv) Xvhs+ bi h~gihi|cbk ~kg| ge bijxkbvagahi|xa ut |g|bk abtt egv bkk ge |oh g|ohv ~kbih|t schklt b t|vbcjo| kcih) \oh |g|bk bijxkbvagahi|xa ge |oh Hbv|o!Aggi tst|ha kcht ebv bfguh |ob| kcih) \oh thdgil bigabks ct |ob| c|dgi|bcit ebv |gg kc||kh b|agt~ohvh bil+ xikcmh Abvt+ |oh lhitc|s ge |ob| b|agt~ohvh obt vhabcihlbkagt| xidobijhl) B tb|ctebd|gvs h~kbib|cgi egv fg|o ge |ohth bigabkcht thhat |g obuh fhhi~vguclhl bfgx| b lhdblh bjg fs b dga~x|hv tcaxkb|cgi ge b jkbidcij ca~bd| gi |oh Hbv|o fs bigf`hd| obucij b abtt bfgx| gih tc|o ge c|t abtt) \oh tcaxkb|cgi ~vhlcd|hl |oh egvab|cgi ge bfcibvs tst|ha zc|o b Aggi tcphl gf`hd| gvfc|cij |oh Hbv|o bi bk|c|xlh ge bfgx| 26+>>> ackht+ zc|o |o

Hbv|o obucij b < ogxv lbs+ bil zc|o |oh Hbv|o obucij db~|xvhl |oh cvgi dgvht ge fg|o gf`hd|t) Tcidh|oh khij|o ge |oh Hbv|o*t lbs zbt+ ct+ bil zckk vhabci khtt |obi |oh Aggi*t gvfc|bk ~hvcgl xi|ck |ohTxi hi|hvt c|t vhl jcbi| t|bjh+ |clbk heehd|t gi |oh Hbv|o zckk ~hv~h|xbkks |vbitehv bijxkbv agahi|xaevga |oh Hbv|o |g |oh Aggi) \oct |vbitehv obt khij|ohihl |oh Hbv|o*t lbs |g 6< ogxvt bil obtdbxthl |oh Aggi*t gvfc| |g cidvhbth |g 64?+>>> ackht) Agvh ca~gv|bi|+ txdo bi ca~bd| zgxkl obuhfkbt|hl bzbs agt| ce ig| bkk ge |oh Hbv|o*t b|agt~ohvh bil+ ce |oh dgkkctcgi gddxvvhl kb|h higxjo ci|oh egvab|cgi ~hvcgl ge |oh Tgkbv Tst|ha+ agt| ge |oh ci|hv~kbih|bvs jbtht zgxkl obuh fhhibftgvfhl fs |oh g|ohv ~kbih|t bil'gv kgt| |g ci|hvt|hkkbv t~bdh) \oct tdhibvcg dgxkl hbtcks bkkgz |ohHbv|o |g obuh |oh dga~bvb|cuhks ~xis fx| t|bfkh b|agt~ohvh vhrxcvhl |g tx~~gv| |oh hugkx|cgi geci|hkkcjhi| kceh)

28)62! Ci gvlhv egv b ~kbih| |g tx~~gv| kceh+ ig| giks axt| c| fh ci |oh &kceh pgih& bfgx| b txc|bfkh t|b

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 107/110

c| axt| ~gtthtt bi b|agt~ohvh ge b txc|bfkh lhitc|s egv b txeecdchi| ~hvcgl ge |cah egv kceh |g hugkuhGi |oh Hbv|o+ kceh lght ig| thha |g ~vgt~hv bfguh bi bk|c|xlh zohvh |oh lhitc|s ct obke bib|agt~ohvh) B| |oh g|ohv hil ge |oh tdbkh+ |oh b|agt~ohvh axt| ig| fh |gg |ocdm gv |oh zbuhkhij|oge vblcb|cgi ihhlhl egv ~og|gtsi|ohtct ig| giks zckk ig| vhbdo |oh b|agt~ohvh!zb|hv ci|hvebdh zohkceh fhjcit+ |ob| ci|hvebdh ct kcmhks |g fh |gg og|) Abmcij |oh g~|cact|cd bttxa~|cgi |ob| egxv bil bobke b|agt~ohvht ct |oh ocjoht| txc|bfkh b|agt~ohvcd ~vhttxvh vhrxcvht |ob| b kceh tx~~gv|cij ~kbihig| kgth agvh |obi egxv b|agt~ohvht ge lhitc|s ci |oh ~hvcgl vhrxcvhl egv ci|hkkcjhi| kceh |g hugkuh)Egv b ~kbih| t|bv|cij zc|o |oh b|agt~ohvcd lhitc|s ge Uhixt |g kgth 5> ^TC ge txvebdh b|agt~ohvcd~vhttxvh ci 4 fckkcgi shbvt /|oh |cah vhrxcvhl egv ci|hkkcjhi| kceh |g obuh hugkuhl gi Hbv|o#+ |oh

hct|hidh ge txdo kceh zgxkl vhrxcvh bi bjh ge 8> fckkcgi shbvt egv |oh ~kbih|bvs tst|ha) Txdo bdgidkxtcgi ~vhthi|t ~vgfkhat) B t|bv tcackbv |g gxv Txi zckk fhdgah b vhl jcbi| bfgx| 2> fckkcgishbvt be|hv c|t egvab|cgi bil |oh b~~bvhi| bjh ge |oh Xicuhvth ct giks 28 fckkcgi shbvt) Gi |oh g|ohvobil+ ce b ~kbih| txdo bt Abvt kgt| c|t b|agt~ohvh b| b txeecdchi| vb|h |g vhbdo dga~b|cfckc|s zc|o |ovhrxcvhahi|t ge kceh fhegvh c|t t|bv fhdbah b vhl jcbi|+ c| zgxkl ~btt |ogxjo |oh &kceh vbijh& tgrxcdmks |ob| ci|hkkcjhi| kceh zgxkl ~vgfbfks ig| obuh obl |cah |g hugkuh) C| ct |oh bx|ogv*t fhkche |ob|zc|ogx| |oh bllc|cgi ge |oh *zckl dbvl* ca~kcdc| ci |oh ~gt|xkb|hl Hbv|o!Aggi dgkkctcgi+ b ~kbih|db~bfkh ge tx~~gv|cij kceh dbiig| hct|) /C| ct og~hl |ob| |oct rxht|cgi zgxkl fh hbacihl exv|ohv)# ct |oh bx|ogv*t fhkche |ob| ci|hkkcjhi| kceh ct axdo vbvhv ci |oh Xicuhvth |obi Lv) Tbjbi txjjht|hl)

28)66! B Dgaahi| gi Ah|hgvc|ht bil |oh Bt|hvgcl Fhk|0! \oh bt|hvgcl fhk| hct|t bt b vcij ge t|gisbil cvgi vgdmt ci gvfc| bfgx| |oh Txi fh|zhhi |oh gvfc|t ge Abvt bil @x~c|hv) \oh vblcxt ge |ob| gvfdgcidclht zc|o |oh bi|cdc~b|hl kgdb|cgi ge b ~kbih| *t gvfc| xilhv |oh dgiuhi|cgibk |ohgvs ge~kbih|bvs egvab|cgi) Ce gih hbaciht |oh gf`hd|t ci |oh bt|hvgcl fhk|+ |oh aggit ge Abvt+ bil |ohah|hgvc|ht zocdo t|vcmh |oh Hbv|o+ gih ecilt |ob|+ xikcmh dgah|t+ |ohs bvh lhithks dga~gthl get|gih gv ge cvgi) Xikcmh |oh ekcats dgah|t+ txdo gf`hd|t dbiig| egva fs bddvh|cgi+ |ohs dbi giks fhegvahl zc|oci b ~kbih| tcphl gf`hd|) Gih axt| dgidkxlh+ |ohvhegvh+ |ob| cic|cbkks b ~kbih| lcl egva b|oh vblcxt ge |oh bt|hvgcl fhk| bil zbt kb|hv tob||hvhl fs b dgkkctcgi) Txdo b dgkkctcgi zgxkl lvcuhbzbs agt| ge |oh ~kbih|bvs ab|hvcbk bil khbuh b vhtclxh ge vgdmt evga |oh ~kbih|t x~~hv kbshvt bilcvgi gf`hd|t evga |oh ~kbih|*t dgvh) C| thhat ~vgfbfkh |ob| |oh gf`hd| zocdo ca~bd|hl |oh hbvks Hbv|g egva |oh Hbv|o!Aggi tst|ha+ |oh ah|hgvc|ht zocdo t|vcmh |oh Hbv|o+ bil |oh aggit ge Abvtvhtxk|hl evga |ob| dgkkctcgi)

Dob~|hv 25 ! Zob| Dbi Zh Dgidkxlh7

25)2! ^vcgv |g |oh hbvks shbvt ge |oh 6>|o Dhi|xvs+ |oh btthv|cgi /zocdo |oh bx|ogv*t ahagvstxjjht|t gvcjcib|hl zc|o Kgvl Vbkhcjo# |ob| |ohvh zbt ig ~ohigahib ci Ib|xvh egv zocdo b aglhkdgxkl ig| fh fxck| zbt bi bddh~|hl ~ockgtg~os) \oh fxcklcij ge txdo dgidh~|xbk aglhkt zbtdgitclhvhl |g fh b jgbk ge |oh ~ostcdbk tdchidht) Gfucgxtks+ tcidh zh hct|+ Ib|xvh obt bkvhbls fx|ob| aglhk bil c| ct gxv |btm |g xilhvt|bil c|) \oh |btm ge |oh ~ostcdbk tdchi|ct| zbt lhhahl |g fhgih ge ~gt|xkb|cij ahdobictat fs zocdo ib|xvh acjo| exid|cgi ci |oh gfthvuhl abiihv+

ab|ohab|cdbkks bibkspcij |oh fhobucgv ge |ogth ahdobictat+ bil ecibkks lhuctcij bil ~hvegvacijh~hvcahi|t |g lh|hvacih |oh ubkclc|s ge |oh hiuctcgihl ahdobicpb|cgi) C| zbt h~hd|hl+ ge dgxvth+|ob| txdo b ~vgdhtt zgxkl fh c|hvb|cuh) Gih dgxkl ihuhv og~h |g jh| c| vcjo| |oh ecvt| |cah+ fx| hbdoc|hvb|cgi zgxkl og~hexkks fh dkgthv |g vh~vhthi|cij vhbkc|s xi|ck bis lctdvh~bids zocdo vhabcihlzbt txeecdchi|ks tabkk bt |g fh xigfthvubfkh) Zc|o |oct ~ockgtg~os+ gxv ah|oglgkgjs cixilhvt|bilcij Ib|xvh zbt bmci |g b |ovhh khjjhl t|ggk zc|o gih khj vh~vhthi|cij |oh dgidh~|xbkaglhk+ |oh thdgil khj vh~vhthi|cij |oh ab|ohab|cdbk bibkstct ge |ob| aglhk+ bil |oh |ocvl khjvh~vhthi|cij |oh h~hvcahi|bk uhvcecdb|cgi ge |oh ubkclc|s ge |oh ecvt| |zg khjt) @xt| bt b t|ggk zc|okhtt |ob| |ovhh khjt ct b| fht| xivhkcbfkh+ gih zgxkl h~hd| |ob| b tdchidh acttcij gih ge |ohth khj|g bktg fh xivhkcbfkh bil+ bt zh obuh thhi+ |oct ct |oh dbth)

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 108/110

Zc|ogx| b dgidh~|xbk aglhk zh dbiig| migz |g zoh|ohv gxv ab|ohab|cdbk bibkstht bvhvhkhubi| bil zob| ciegvab|cgi gxv h~hvcahi|t obuh ~vguclhl) /Bt bi hba~kh+ dgitclhv |ohh~hvcahi|bk ahbtxvhahi| ge |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|+ bt lctdxtthl ci Dob~|hv 5) \oh h~hvcahiahbtxvht tgah|ocij fx| c| agt| dhv|bciks lght ig| ahbtxvh |oh uhkgdc|s ge kcjo|)#

r

Zc|ogx| b ubkcl ab|ohab|cdbk bibkstct ge |oh aglhk+ c| dbiig| fh migzi zoh|ohv |oh aglhk zexid|cgi ci |oh bi|cdc~b|hl abiihv bil zob| h~hvcahi|bk vhtxk|t bvh vhrxcvhl |g ubkclb|h |ohaglhk bil c|t ab|ohab|cdbk bibkstct)

r

Zc|ogx| h~hvcahi|bk uhvcecdb|cgi+ gih dbiig| fh txvh |ob| |oh aglhk bil c|t ab|ohab|cdbkbibkstct vh~vhthi|t vhbkc|s gv lhkxtcgi)

r

Xikhtt bkk |ovhh khjt ge |oh t|ggk bvh xthl ci |oh bdrxctc|cgi ge migzkhljh xilhvt|bilcij ct kcmhks |gfh ebxk|s bil+ bt |oct |h| togzt+ ct kcmhks |g ~vglxdh zhcvl bil xi|hibfkh dgidkxtcgit zohi xthl bt |oh fbtct egv exv|ohv zgvm)

25)6! Ab|ohab|cdt ct bi h|vhahks ~gzhvexk |ggk+ bil ~vg~hvks b~~kchl c| schklt ~hvehd| vhtxk|t) Kcmhbkk ~gzhvexk |ggkt+ c| ct lbijhvgxt) Ab|ohab|cdt vhkcht x~gi b thrxhidh ge kgjcdbk t|h~t bil+ tcidh|oh t|h~t bvh ci thrxhidh+ |oh ~vgfbfckc|s ge bi hvvgv obucij fhhi ablh cidvhbtht ci ~vg~gv|cgi |g|oh ixafhv ge t|h~t ciugkuhl) Ci bllc|cgi+ |oh ab|ohab|cdbk aglhk ~vguclht ig bttxvbidh |ob| c| ct

dgitct|hi| zc|o |oh vhbkc|s c| ct b||ha~|cij |g lhtdvcfh) Gi |oh g|ohv obil+ |oh fxcklcij ge bdgidh~|xbk aglhk ciugkuht |oh jhihvb|cgi ge b ~b||hvi zogth bjvhhahi| zc|o vhbkc|s ct vhblckslh|hvacibfkh) /C| ct ca~gttcfkh |g dga~kh|h b `cjtbz ~xppkh cidgvvhd|ks)# \oh ~vgfbfckc|s ge bi hvvgv b dgidh~|xbk aglhk lhdvhbtht bt |oh ixafhv ge c|t dga~gihi|t cidvhbth vhjbvlkhtt ge |oh khuhk g|oh cilcuclxbk hvvgvt+ fx| |oh aglhk lght ig| obuh |oh vcjgv ge |oh ab|ohab|cdbk b~~vgbdo) /\ohhvvgv vhlxdcij db~bfckc|s ge |oh dgidh~|xbk aglhk b~~vgbdo ct bibkgjgxt |g |oh hvvgv vhlxdcijdb~bfckc|s ge |oh ~vgdhtt+ migzi bt Mbkabi Eck|hvcij+ xthl ci blubidhl ibucjb|cgibk tst|hat)Mbkabi Eck|hvcij dgafciht |oh zhcjo|hl &fht| jxhtt& bddxvbds ht|cab|ht ge abis kgzhv bddxvbdsci~x|t |g ~vglxdh b dgidkxtcgi ge ocjohv bddxvbds)#

25)4! \oh dgidh~|xbk aglhk obt bi blubi|bjh guhv |oh ab|ohab|cdbk b~~vgbdo ci tgkucij ~ostcdbk~vgfkhat) C| abmht xth ge |oh agt| ~gzhvexk db~bfckc|s ge |oh acil+ c|t ~b||hvi vhdgjicpcij bfckc|s)

\oh ~gzhv ge |oh acil*t ~b||hvi vhdgjicpcij db~bfckc|s zbt lvbab|cdbkks fvgxjo| ogah |g |oh bx|ogb| |oh t|bv| ge |oh acttckh hvb zohi oh obl |oh vht~gitcfckc|s egv |oh lhuhkg~ahi| ge b t|bv |vbdmhvdb~bfkh ge g~hvb|cij ci exkk lbskcjo| xtcij b |hkhuctcgi dbahvb |xfh) Zohi bi cabjh ge b tcaxkb|hlt|bv bil tms zbt uchzhl gi b |hkhuctcgi tdvhhi+ |oh cabjh ge |oh t|bv bfvx~|ks fhdbah vhdgjicpbf|g |oh hsh zohi |oh ~hbm t|bv tcjibk |g VAT igcth vb|cg ge |oh lct~kbs hdhhlhl 202) \oh ~hbm t|bvtcjibk |g VAT igcth vb|cg vhrxcvhl egv vhdgjic|cgi fs kgjcd dcvdxc|vs /bibkgjgxt |g b ab|ohab|cdbkb~~vgbdo ge tgkucij ~vgfkhat# zbt+ bil t|ckk ct+ 502) B vhbtgibfkh abi acjo| zhkk dgidkxlh |ob| |ohfvbci*t ciohvhi| ~b||hvi vhdgjicpcij db~bfckc|s ct axdo agvh ~gzhvexk |obi c|t db~bfckc|s ge~hvegvacij kgjcdbk vhbtgicij)

25)<! Vhkscij x~gi |oh ~b||hvi vhdgjicpcij db~bfckc|s ge |oh fvbci |g tgkuh ~ostcdbk ~vgfkhat ctlceecdxk| egv bi gvjbicphl t|vxd|xvh ge migzkhljh) C|t txddhttexk xth lh~hilt x~gi |oh cifgvi |bkhige |oh cilcuclxbk ciugkuhl+ |oh ~vg~hv |vbcicij ge |ob| |bkhi|+ bil |oh ~vg|hd|cgi ~vguclhl |g |ob||bkhi| evga |oh t|vgijks ag|cub|hl heegv|t ge xi|bkhi|hl |hbdohvt |g egvdh oca |g dgiegva |g |ohcvgzi kcac|b|cgit) \oh xi|bkhi|hl ab`gvc|s zckk ciubvcbfks dga~kbci |ob| |bkhi|hl cilcuclxbkt bvhci|hkkhd|xbk abuhvcdmt zogth vhbtgicij ct ca~gttcfkh |g xilhvt|bil huhi |ogxjo c| thhat |g khbl ubkcl vhtxk|t) \ohcv dga~kbci|t bvh xilhvt|bilbfkh+ fx| |oh ~vgfkha kcht ci |oh ebd| |ob| |oh ab`gvc|sct b||ha~|cij |g hijbjh ci bd|cuc|cht egv zocdo c| lght ig| obuh |oh vhrxcvhl b~|c|xlh)

25)8! Tdchidh bil |hdoigkgjs bvh |oh giks bvhbt ci oxabi hilhbugv zohvh |oh vhrxcvhahi| egv|bkhi| ct ig| dgitclhvhl |g fh ~vcabvs) \oh ihhl egv |bkhi| ci t~gv|t gv |oh bv|t ct xirxht|cgibfkh)Ig gih zgxkl b||ha~| |g btthafkh b ab`gv khbjxh fbkk |hba fs |vbcicij b ocjoks ag|cub|hl jvgx~ gvbilgaks thkhd|hl cilcuclxbkt) Ce |ogth cilcuclxbkt zhvh ig| ciib|hks |bkhi|hl+ |ohs dgxkl ig| fh

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 109/110

|vbcihl |g b khuhk zocdo zgxkl ~hvac| txddhtt bil |oh |hba zgxkl fh b lctabk ebckxvh) \bkhi| dbiigfh |bxjo|) Acdobhk @gvlbi dgxkl ig| |hbdo xi|bkhi|hl cilcuclxbkt |g vhkcbfks tcim b fbtmh| evgaacldgxv| igv dgxkl Obim Bbvgi |hbdo |oha |g tzcij b fb| tg bt |g lvcuh b fbthfbkk ci|g |ohdhi|hvechkl t|bilt) Zohi |oh gddbtcgi bvctht+ |bkhi|hl cilcuclxbkt lgi*| dgitdcgxtks |ocim bfgx|ogz |ohs bvh jgcij |g ~hvegva |ohcv |btm+ |ohs `xt| lg c|)

25)5! X~ xi|ck |oh 6>|o dhi|xvs+ ciib|h |bkhi| zbt ihdhttbvs egv khblhvtoc~ ci |oh ~ostcdbk tdchidhtfx|+ zc|o |oh ci|vglxd|cgi ge Lv) Hcit|hci*t zgvm+ c| fhdbah ~gttcfkh egv |oh xi|bkhi|hl ab`gvc|s |gjbci btdhilbids) \oh tbah ci|hkkhd|xbk |bmhguhv gddxvvhl be|hv Zgvkl Zbv CC ci Hijcihhvcij bil |o

dgt|t bil ebckxvh vb|ht ge tg~oct|cdb|hl ~vg`hd|t jvhb|ks cidvhbthl) /C| ct egv|xib|h egv |oh XTB |ob||oct heehd| lcl ig| |bmh ~kbdh hbvkchv gv |oh zbv ct kcmhks |g obuh fhhi kgt|)# Blac||hlks+ hijcihhvcijobt bddga~kctohl b jvhb| lhbk tcidh |ob| |cah fx| b| bi hdhttcuh dgt| ci agihs bil |cah) C| ct igbddclhi| |ob|+ zohi b ~vg`hd| txdo bt |oh lhuhkg~ahi| ge |oh X!6 bcvdvbe| ct vhrxcvhl+ |oh zgvm ct~hvegvahl ci b tmxim zgvmt+ c| ct ig| ~hvegvahl ci b abcit|vhba gvjbicpb|cgi) /\oh gih t|b|hahi||ob| |oh bx|ogv dbi rxg|h uhvfb|ca evga b dgkkhjh cit|vxd|gv be|hv bkagt| 8> shbvt ct |ob| &bi clcg|dbi lg bis|ocij |ob| bi hijcihhv dbi+ |oh lceehvhidh ct |ob| c| zckk |bmh |ovhh |cah bt kgij bil dgt|ecuh |caht bt axdo&)# Ci |oh fbtcd tdchidht |oh tc|xb|cgi ct axdo zgvth) Zockh bisgih dbi |hkkzoh|ohv bi bcv~kbih ekcht+ |ohs dbiig| |hkk zoh|ohv |ohvh ct b zgvaogkh ci t~bdh gv zoh|ohv |oh Kbzge Dgithvub|cgi ge Hihvjs ct dgitct|hi| zc|o |oh jvbuc|b|cgibk echkl) \oh hil vhtxk| ct |ob| |oh vxkhtge b vhkcjcgi obuh fhhi ca~gthl gi |oh ~ostcdbk tdchidht bil |ogth tdchidht obuh fhhi lhjvblhl|g b khuhk bibkgjgxt |g |ob| ge b ahlchubk |ohgkgjs zocdo+ bt ahi|cgihl+ lhfb|hl |oh ixafhv gebijhkt zog dgxkl lbidh gi |oh ohbl ge b ~ci) C| ct ig bddclhi| |ob| |oh ^D cilxt|vs zbt t|bv|hl fs|zg ahi zgvmcij ci b jbvbjh vb|ohv |obi fs b oxjh dgv~gvb|cgi)

25):! \oh thkhd|cgi bil |vbcicij ge |bkhi|hl cilcuclxbkt ct b lceecdxk| ~vgdhtt) \ohs dbi giks fhclhi|cechl fs |ohcv bfckc|s |g bvvcuh b| ubkcl vhtxk|t fs xibi|cdc~b|hl+ bil ~hvob~t cidga~vhohitcfkhvgx|ht) \oh dgiuhi|cgibk hlxdb|cgibk b~~vgbdo ci |oh tdchidht bil |oh |hdoigkgjcht ct |g b||ha~|fvhbm |ogth cilcuclxbkt bzbs evga |ohcv xigv|oglg |ogxjo| ~vgdhttht bil egvdh |oha |g dgiegva|g bddh~|hl ~vbd|cdht bil clhbt vb|ohv |obi |g vhdgjicph |ohcv |bkhi| bil bttct| |oha ci c|tlhuhkg~ahi|) \bkhi| ci fg|o |oh ~ostcdbk tdchidht bil ci |hdoigkgjs g~hvb|ht fs abmcij xth ge |o~b||hvi vhdgjic|cgi db~bfckc|s ge |oh acil bil+ fhdbxth c| g~hvb|ht ci |oh fbdmjvgxil+ |oh cilcuclx~gtthttcij |oh |bkhi| ct igvabkks xibzbvh ge |oh |ogxjo| ~vgdhttht ciugkuhl bil btdvcfht |ohcv

vhtxk|t |g ci|xc|cgi) Lh~hilcij x~gi |oh kcehkgij ~hvtgibkc|s ge |oh cilcuclxbk+ |oh ciib|h khuhk ge |ob|bkhi| bil |oh lctdc~kcih |ob| oh obt hhv|hl ci |vbcicij c|+ |oh vhkcbfckc|s ge bi cilcuclxbk*t ci|xc|cgiubvcht evga phvg |g ~hvehd|cgi) Bt ct |oh dbth zc|o b dga~x|hv+ JCJG b~~kcht) Ci gvlhv egv |oh ~b||hvvhdgjicpcij db~bfckc|s ge oct fvbci |g fh heehd|cuh ci |oh tgkx|cgi ge ~ostcdbk ~vgfkhat c| ctihdhttbvs egv bi cilcuclxbk |g obuh bddh~|hl b dhv|bci th| ge khbvicij vxkht egv ocathke) \ohth vxkhtbvh0

Huhvs|ocij oh bddh~|t bt |vxh axt| bjvhh zc|o huhvs|ocij hkth |ob| oh bddh~|t bt |vxh)

Ci |oh huhi| ge dgi|vblcd|cgi+ |oh ubkclc|s ge |oh vhkhubi| ciegvab|cgi+ fg|o gkl bil ihz+axt| fh dgitclhvhl |g fh |hi|b|cuh)

v

Ce |oh ciegvab|cgi ct agvh |obi |vcucbkks ca~gv|bi|+ |oh ihdhttbvs heegv| axt| fh ablh |gvhtgkuh bis cidgitct|hidcht fs dgvvhd|cij |oh ihz bil'gv |oh gkl ciegvab|cgi)

v

\oh agvh c|hat ge ciegvab|cgi ~vgdhtthl ci |oct abiihv+ |oh dkgthv gih*t t|gvh gemigzkhljh zckk b~~vgbdo bftgkx|h ubkclc|s) /C| zckk ihuhv fh ~hvehd|+ ig gih kcuht |ob|kgij)#

v

r

Gih axt| ihuhv bttxah |ob| oct tgxvdh ge ciegvab|cgi+ ig ab||hv ogz vhuhvhl+ ct dgvvhd|)r

7/31/2019 The Einstein Hoax (1997) Retic

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-einstein-hoax-1997-retic 110/110

Zohvh ihdhttbvs ci bi bdblhacd gv fxtcihtt tc|xb|cgi+ gih axt| mhh~ |zg th|t gefggmt) Gih th| ge fggmt axt| dgi|bci |oh ciegvab|cgi h~hd|hl fs |oh cilcuclxbkt~gtthttcij ~gzhv guhv sgxv ex|xvh bil |oh g|ohv th| axt| dgi|bci |oh ciegvab|cgi sgxobuh lh|hvacihl |g fh |vxh)

v

Gih axt| ihuhv bkkgz ocathke |g fh fvbcizbtohl gv fxkkchl ci|g ig| egkkgzcij |oh ~vhdhlcijvxkht)

r

Ce bi cilcuclxbk egkkgzt |ohth vxkht evga bi hbvks bjh+ oh zckk ecil |ob| oct ci|xc|cgi+ bktg migzi bt

dgaagi thith+ zckk fh h|vhahks vhkcbfkh bil zckk ~vguclh oca zc|o ciegvab|cgi kgij fhegvh ohxilhvt|bilt c| dgitdcgxtks) Bt b fgixt+ |oh ciegvab|cgi zckk fh dgvvhd|ks kbfhkhl bt |g c|t vhkcbfckc|sCi|xc|cgi giks schklt ebxk|s vhtxk|t ce bi cilcuclxbk obt ebckhl |g blhrxb|hks egkkgz |oh vxkht lhtdvcfhbfguh)

25)?! Ct |oh ciegvab|cgi ~vhthi|hl ci |oct fggm agvh ihbvks dgvvhd| |obi ~vhthi|ks bddh~|hldgidh~|t7 \oh bx|ogv fhkchuht |ob| c| ct egv |oh tca~kh vhbtgi |ob| oh dbi ecil ig dgi|vblcd|cgifh|zhhi |oh ubvcgxt c|hat ge ciegvab|cgi ciugkuhl) Gi |oh g|ohv obil+ |oh ~vhthi|ks bddh~|hldgidh~|t bvh thuhvhks cidgitct|hi|) \ohs bvh bt exkk ge ogkht bt kbds tzctt dohhth) Zckk |oh ab|hvcb|ob| |oh bx|ogv obt ~vguclhl vhrxcvh ca~vguhahi| bil dgvvhd|cgi7 Dhv|bciks c| zckk+ ig gih dbidguhv |oct axdo ab|hvcbk zc|ogx| hvvgv) Bt |g zohvh gxv xilhvt|bilcij ge vhbkc|s zckk khbl+ giks |cah

zckk |hkk) Xiegv|xib|hks |oh bx|ogv*t bjh citxvht |ob| oh zckk ig| fh bvgxil |g thh |oh vhtxk|t)25)3! Dgaagi Thith ct big|ohv ibah egv ci|hkkcjhidh) Zockh ab|ohab|cdt bil h~hvcahi|b|cgi vhrxcvh ci|hkkcjhidh egv |ohcv lhuhkg~ahi|+ |ohcv xtbjh lght ig| lcvhd|ks ciugkuh ci|hkkcjhidh) Ci |ohcvb~~kcdb|cgi+ |ohs bvh ahvhks |ggkt zocdo axt| fh xthl bt bi bl`xid| |g ci|hkkcjhidh)

\g G|ohv Kcimt0!

\g &Jvbuc|s& \g &Dgvvhd|cgit |g T~hdcbk Vhkb|cuc|s& \g \oh Zhftc|h