THE EFFECTS OFOOFFOF INFLATION GAS ON TIRE …...The Effects of Inflation Gas on Tire Laboratory...

28
THE HE HE HE INTERNATIONAL NTERNATIONAL NTERNATIONAL NTERNATIONAL TIRE IRE IRE IRE EXHIBITION XHIBITION XHIBITION XHIBITION & CONFERENCE ONFERENCE ONFERENCE ONFERENCE 1725 MERRIMAN ROAD AKRON OHIO 44313-9006 PHONE: 330-836-9180 FAX: 330-836-1005 WWW.RUBBERNEWS.COM THE THE THE THE EFFECTS EFFECTS EFFECTS EFFECTS OF OF OF OF INFLATION INFLATION INFLATION INFLATION GAS GAS GAS GAS ON ON ON ON TIRE TIRE TIRE TIRE LABORATORY LABORATORY LABORATORY LABORATORY TEST TEST TEST TEST PERFORMANCE PERFORMANCE PERFORMANCE PERFORMANCE AUTHOR UTHOR UTHOR UTHOR: JAMES AMES AMES AMES MAC AC AC ACISAAC SAAC SAAC SAAC DOT DOT DOT DOT - NHTSA NHTSA NHTSA NHTSA CO-AUTHOR UTHOR UTHOR UTHORS: LARRY ARRY ARRY ARRY EVANS VANS VANS VANS JOHN OHN OHN OHN HARRIS ARRIS ARRIS ARRIS TRANSPORTATION RANSPORTATION RANSPORTATION RANSPORTATION RESEARCH ESEARCH ESEARCH ESEARCH INSTITUTE NSTITUTE NSTITUTE NSTITUTE ED D D D TERRILL ERRILL ERRILL ERRILL, PH.D. D. D. D. AKRON KRON KRON KRON RUBBER UBBER UBBER UBBER DEVELOPMENT EVELOPMENT EVELOPMENT EVELOPMENT LABORATORY ABORATORY ABORATORY ABORATORY, INC NC NC NC. ITEC ITEC ITEC ITEC 2008 2008 2008 2008 PAPER APER APER APER 18C 8C 8C 8C-1 All papers owned and copyrighted by Rubber & Plastics News, a Crain Communications publication. Reprint only with permission of Rubber & Plastics News.

Transcript of THE EFFECTS OFOOFFOF INFLATION GAS ON TIRE …...The Effects of Inflation Gas on Tire Laboratory...

TTTTHE HE HE HE IIIINTERNATIONAL NTERNATIONAL NTERNATIONAL NTERNATIONAL TTTTIRE IRE IRE IRE EEEEXHIBITION XHIBITION XHIBITION XHIBITION &&&& CCCCONFERENCEONFERENCEONFERENCEONFERENCE

1725 MERRIMAN ROAD ● AKRON OHIO 44313-9006

PHONE: 330-836-9180 ● FAX: 330-836-1005 ● WWW.RUBBERNEWS.COM

THETHETHETHE EFFECTSEFFECTSEFFECTSEFFECTS OFOFOFOF INFLATIONINFLATIONINFLATIONINFLATION GASGASGASGAS ONONONON TIRETIRETIRETIRE

LABORATORYLABORATORYLABORATORYLABORATORY TESTTESTTESTTEST PERFORMANCEPERFORMANCEPERFORMANCEPERFORMANCE

AAAAUTHORUTHORUTHORUTHOR:::: JJJJAMES AMES AMES AMES MMMMACACACACIIIISAACSAACSAACSAAC

DOTDOTDOTDOT ---- NHTSANHTSANHTSANHTSA

CCCCOOOO----AAAAUTHORUTHORUTHORUTHORSSSS::::

LLLLARRY ARRY ARRY ARRY EEEEVANSVANSVANSVANS

JJJJOHN OHN OHN OHN HHHHARRISARRISARRISARRIS

TTTTRANSPORTATION RANSPORTATION RANSPORTATION RANSPORTATION RRRRESEARCH ESEARCH ESEARCH ESEARCH IIIINSTITUTENSTITUTENSTITUTENSTITUTE

EEEED D D D TTTTERRILLERRILLERRILLERRILL,,,, PPPPHHHH....D.D.D.D.

AAAAKRON KRON KRON KRON RRRRUBBER UBBER UBBER UBBER DDDDEVELOPMENT EVELOPMENT EVELOPMENT EVELOPMENT LLLLABORATORYABORATORYABORATORYABORATORY,,,, IIIINCNCNCNC....

ITECITECITECITEC 2008200820082008

PPPPAPER APER APER APER 11118C8C8C8C----1111

All papers owned and copyrighted by Rubber & Plastics News, a Crain Communications publication.

Reprint only with permission of Rubber & Plastics News.

The

Effe

cts

of In

flatio

n G

as

on T

ire L

abor

ator

y T

est

Per

form

ance

Jam

es D

. Mac

Isaa

c Jr

., U

SD

OT

-N

HT

SA

Larr

y E

vans

& J

ohn

Har

ris, T

rans

port

atio

n R

esea

rch

Cen

ter,

Inc.

Ed

Ter

rill,

Ph.

D.,

Akr

on R

ubbe

r D

evel

opm

ent L

abor

ator

y, In

c.

Pre

sent

ed a

t IT

EC

200

8A

kron

, OH

Sep

tem

ber

17, 2

008

Nitr

ogen

Infla

tion

of

Pne

umat

ic T

ires

�In

flatio

n of

tire

s w

ith N

2ga

s is

pre

sum

ed to

be

bene

ficia

l. H

owev

er, t

here

are

a w

ide

varie

ty o

f cl

aim

s an

d co

unte

r-cl

aim

s:•

Bet

ter

infla

tion

pres

sure

ret

entio

n•

Low

er r

ollin

g re

sist

ance

•B

ette

r tr

eadw

ear

•Lo

wer

run

ning

tem

pera

ture

s•

Bet

ter

tire

dura

bilit

y•

Less

moi

stur

e•

Etc

.

Nat

iona

l Hig

hway

Tra

ffic

Saf

ety

Adm

inis

trat

ion

�N

HT

SA

Tra

ffic

Saf

ety

Fac

ts, 2

006*

•In

200

6, th

ere

wer

e an

est

imat

ed 5

,973

,000

pol

ice-

repo

rted

traf

fic c

rash

es, i

n w

hich

:–

42,6

42 p

eopl

e w

ere

kille

d–

2,57

5,00

0 pe

ople

wer

e in

jure

d–

4,18

9,00

0 cr

ashe

s in

volv

ed p

rope

rty

dam

age

only

•A

n av

erag

e of

117

peo

ple

died

eac

h da

y in

mot

or

vehi

cle

cras

hes

in 2

006

—on

e ev

ery

12 m

inut

es•

Mot

or v

ehic

le c

rash

es a

re th

e le

adin

g ca

use

of d

eath

for

ever

y ag

e fr

om a

ges

2 th

roug

h 34

•F

rom

199

4 to

200

4, N

HT

SA

est

imat

es th

at a

bout

400

fa

talit

ies,

ann

ually

(~

1% o

f tot

al m

otor

veh

icle

fata

litie

s),

may

be

attr

ibut

ed to

tire

failu

res

of a

ll ty

pes

*NH

TS

A T

raffi

c S

afet

y F

acts

, 200

6 D

ata,

DO

T H

S 8

10 8

09, N

HT

SA

’s N

atio

nal C

ente

r fo

r S

tatis

tics

and

Ana

lysi

s, U

pdat

ed M

arch

200

8

NH

TS

A T

estin

g of

Tire

s w

ith

Nitr

ogen

Infla

tion

�N

HT

SA

re-

dire

cted

tire

s fr

om o

ther

tire

pr

ogra

ms

to a

ddre

ss fo

ur b

asic

que

stio

ns:

•Is

ther

e a

syst

emat

ic a

nd q

uant

ifiab

le d

iffer

ence

in th

e in

flatio

n pr

essu

re lo

ss r

ate

(IP

LR)

of ti

res

whe

n in

flate

d w

ith g

ases

of v

aryi

ng n

itrog

en to

oxy

gen

ratio

s?•

Are

any

obs

erve

d di

ffere

nces

in IP

LR u

nifo

rm a

mon

g tir

es, o

r ar

e th

ey r

elat

ed to

var

iabl

es s

uch

as in

itial

in

flatio

n pr

essu

re, o

r tir

e de

sign

and

com

posi

tion?

•A

re th

ere

dire

ct e

ffect

s of

infla

tion

gas

com

posi

tion

on

the

rolli

ng r

esis

tanc

e of

tire

s?•

Are

ther

e di

ffere

nces

in ti

re d

urab

ility

per

form

ance

afte

r ac

cele

rate

d ag

ing

rela

ted

to th

e ni

trog

en-t

o-ox

ygen

ra

tio?

Tes

ting

�T

wen

ty-f

ive

pass

enge

r or

ligh

t tru

ck ti

re

mod

els

wer

e in

flate

d w

ith:

•S

hop

air

with

air

line

drye

r•

Dry

N2

gas

from

94

to 9

9% p

urity

–In

itial

pur

ge a

nd r

efill

use

d

•G

as c

ompo

sitio

n m

easu

red

at th

e be

ginn

ing

and

end

of te

st

�T

ires

wer

e te

sted

for:

•In

flatio

n pr

essu

re lo

ss r

ate

•La

bora

tory

rol

ling

resi

stan

ce•

Roa

dwhe

el e

ndur

ance

afte

r ov

en a

ging

•M

ater

ial p

rope

rtie

s

Tire

Infla

tion

Pre

ssur

e Lo

ss

�U

nder

-infla

ted

tires

are

a s

igni

fican

t pr

oble

m•

Acc

ordi

ng to

a N

HT

SA

stu

dy, 2

7% o

f pas

seng

er

cars

and

32%

of l

ight

truc

ks h

ave

at le

ast o

ne

tire

that

is s

ubst

antia

lly u

nder

infla

ted*

–“O

pera

ting

a ve

hicl

e w

ith s

ubst

antia

lly u

nder

-infla

ted

tires

can

res

ult i

n a

prem

atur

e tir

e fa

ilure

, suc

h as

in

stan

ces

of tr

ead

sepa

ratio

n an

d bl

owou

ts, w

ith th

e po

tent

ial f

or a

loss

of c

ontr

ol o

f the

veh

icle

. U

nder

-in

flate

d tir

es a

lso

shor

ten

tire

life

and

incr

ease

fuel

co

nsum

ptio

n.”

**

*Tir

e P

ress

ure

Spec

ial S

tudy

@ h

ttp:/

/ww

w.n

htsa

.dot

.gov

/peo

ple/

ncsa

/

**U

.S. T

rans

port

atio

n Se

cret

ary

Nor

man

Y. M

inet

a@

htt

p://

ww

w.d

ot.g

ov/a

ffai

rs/n

htsa

4601

.htm

Tire

Infla

tion

Pre

ssur

e Lo

ss

�T

ires

lose

infla

tion

gase

s co

ntin

uous

ly, s

ince

ru

bber

com

poun

ds a

re p

erm

eabl

e to

gas

m

olec

ules

and

loss

es e

xist

thro

ugh

tire/

whe

el/v

alve

inte

rfac

es�

Tub

eles

s tir

es r

equi

re a

n in

nerli

ner

com

poun

d w

ith lo

w p

erm

eabi

lity

to li

mit

the

loss

of

infla

tion

�T

he A

ST

M F

1112

-06

test

mea

sure

s th

e st

atic

lo

ss o

f inf

latio

n ga

s fr

om a

tire

ove

r tim

e•

Dat

a is

rep

orte

d as

% lo

ss /

mon

th

AS

TM

F11

12-0

6 In

flatio

n P

ress

ure

Loss

Rat

e (I

PLR

)�

Min

imum

sam

ple

of 2

tire

s pe

r m

odel

�C

lean

pai

nted

ste

el (

pref

erre

d) w

heel

or

othe

r m

ater

ial t

hat h

as b

een

leak

che

cked

�R

im s

ize

per

Tire

& R

im A

ssoc

iatio

n or

oth

er

stan

dard

s or

gani

zatio

n (p

refe

r m

easu

ring

rim)

�R

im s

eat d

iam

eter

mus

t be

with

in to

lera

nces

fr

om s

tand

ards

(co

nfirm

ed w

ith b

all t

ape)

�P

ress

ure

tran

sduc

er o

r ga

uge

�T

wo

met

al v

alve

s or

“T

”va

lve

+ m

etal

val

ve

AS

TM

F11

12-0

6 In

flatio

n P

ress

ure

Loss

Rat

e (I

PLR

)

�T

est R

oom

•M

ean

tem

pera

ture

s of

21,

24,

30

or 3

8°C

(n

orm

al te

st is

21°

C)

±0.6

°C (

±1°F

)•

For

cibl

y ci

rcul

ated

air

cont

rolle

d at

±3°

C (

±5°F

)

�G

auge

s or

Pre

ssur

e T

rans

duce

rs

•R

esol

utio

n 2

kPa

(0.2

5 ps

i) ac

cura

te to

±1%

of

mea

sure

d va

lue

(ope

ratin

g w

ithin

40

to 9

0% o

f fu

ll sc

ale)

�D

ata

Acq

uisi

tion

•R

ecor

d da

ta o

nce

per

day

for

180

days

or

com

pute

r da

ta a

cqui

sitio

n of

mor

e da

ta p

oint

s pe

r da

y fo

r a

shor

ter

dura

tion

test

�B

arom

eter

(H

igh

Acc

urac

y)

AS

TM

F11

12-0

6 In

flatio

n P

ress

ure

Loss

Rat

e (I

PLR

)

�T

ires

are

infla

ted

to a

spe

cifie

d pr

essu

re a

nd s

it st

atic

an

d un

load

ed in

a c

ontr

olle

d en

viro

nmen

t•

NH

TS

A te

stin

g us

ed F

MV

SS

No.

139

Hig

h S

peed

test

pre

ssur

es

•N

HT

SA

test

ing

was

con

duct

ed a

t 21º

C ±

3ºC

�T

he p

ress

ure

and

cond

ition

s ar

e m

onito

red

over

tim

e•

NH

TS

A te

stin

g us

ed 9

0 da

ys w

ith c

ontin

uous

mon

itorin

g of

the

pres

sure

via

com

pute

r in

terf

ace

–P

er th

e st

anda

rd th

e fir

st 3

0 da

ys d

ata

was

dis

card

ed

�D

ata

is th

en c

orre

cted

to a

sta

ndar

d te

mpe

ratu

re a

nd

baro

met

ric p

ress

ure

•21

ºC a

nd 1

01.3

kP

a

Exa

mpl

e D

ata

Out

put

30 -

90 d

ay d

ata

is u

sed

to c

alcu

late

In

flatio

n P

ress

ure

Loss

Rat

e (I

PLR

)

Rat

e st

abili

zes

afte

r in

itial

30

days

:0

to 1

5 da

y =

3.30

%/m

onth

y =

-0.0

011x

+ 5

.406

3R

2 =

0.9

788

0 to

30

day

= 3

.0 %

/mon

thy

= -0

.001

x +

5.4

053

R2

= 0.

991 30

to 9

0 da

y =

2.40

%/m

onth

y =

-0.0

008x

+ 5

.401

R2

= 0.

9989

60 to

90

day

=2.4

0%/m

onth

y =

-0.0

008x

+ 5

.400

2

R2 =

0.9

972

5.30

5.32

5.34

5.36

5.38

5.40

5.42

5.44

0.0

10.0

20.0

30.0

40.0

50.0

60.0

70.0

80.0

90.0

Day

s

LnP

Is th

ere

a di

ffere

nce

in (

IPLR

) w

hen

vary

ing

N2/

O2

ratio

?

�O

ne-w

ay A

NO

VA

ana

lysi

s of

IPLR

:

Infla

tion

Gas

and

Tire

Typ

e ar

e S

igni

fican

t Var

iabl

es

Dep

ende

nt V

aria

ble:

IPLR

, Rat

e @

90

Day

s, %

/mon

thS

um o

f

Sou

rce

DF

Squ

ares

M

ean

Squ

are

F V

alue

P

r >

F

R-S

quar

eM

odel

2

7

56.4

1

2

.089

22.5

6

<.

0001

0.9

02E

rror

66

6

.11

0.

092

Cor

rect

ed T

otal

93

62.

52

Sou

rce

DF

T

ype

III S

S

Mea

n S

quar

eF

Val

ue

Pr

> F

Infla

tion

Gas

1

6

.842

6

.842

73.9

0

<.

0001

Tes

t Lab

1

0

.017

0

.017

0.19

0.

6668

Tire

Typ

e

25

4

0.53

1

.621

17.5

1

<.

0001

IPLR

with

Air

vs. N

2 In

flatio

n

17 D

iffer

ent

Mod

els

of

Tire

s

Ave

rage

IP

LR fo

r N

2w

as 6

6% o

f A

ir

IPLR

, In

flatio

n w

ith A

ir o

r N

2 g

as

0

0.51

1.52

2.53

3.54

4.5

B1

B7

B8

B9

C7

C8

D6

G1

M1

M3

N2

O4

P3

S1

T2

U2

Y2

Tir

e T

yp

e

IPLR, 90-day

0%

10

%

20

%

30

%

40

%

50

%

60

%

70

%

80

%

90

%

10

0%

IPLR N2 / IPLR Air

Air

N2

%

Tire

Par

amet

ers

�A

ppro

xim

ate

inne

rline

r va

riatio

ns:

•P

olym

er:

100%

IIR

�80

/20

NR

/SB

R•

Car

bon

blac

k: 5

3 �

76 p

hr

•N

on-b

lack

fille

r: 0

�22

phr

•T

otal

fille

r: 6

7 �

105

phr

•V

olat

iles:

13 �

26 p

hr

•T

hick

ness

0.6

7 �

1.85

mm

�In

itial

Infla

tion

Pre

ssur

e: 2

20

� ���52

1 kP

a

IPLR

Ver

sus

Tire

C

onst

ruct

ion

�O

f the

var

iabl

es s

tudi

ed, i

nner

liner

com

posi

tion

and

min

imum

thic

knes

s ha

d m

ost s

igni

fican

t ef

fect

on

IPLR

•F

iller

and

vol

atile

s ha

d si

gnifi

cant

, but

less

er e

ffect

s

�A

naly

sis

of d

iffer

ence

in IP

LRbe

twee

n ai

r an

d N

2 (I

PLR

air

–IP

LRni

trog

en)

by ti

re ty

pe•

No

sign

ifica

nt e

ffect

of a

ny c

onst

ruct

ion

para

met

er•

No

sign

ifica

nt e

ffect

of i

nitia

l inf

latio

n pr

essu

re–

Pas

seng

er /

LT ti

res

Ben

efits

of N

itrog

en In

flatio

n on

IPLR

A

ppea

r to

be

App

licab

le to

All

Tire

Typ

es

Nitr

ogen

Infla

tion

& O

xyge

n C

once

ntra

tion

Equ

ipm

ent

Bal

ston

®72

-730

O

xyge

n A

naly

zer

Acc

urat

e to

<0

.1%

O2

O2

Mig

ratio

n D

urin

g T

est

Change in

Perc

ent

Oxy

gen C

once

ntr

atio

n D

uring

IP

L T

est

Vers

us

Sta

rtin

g O

xygen C

once

ntr

atio

n

y =

-0

.00

16x

2 - 0

.05

19x

+ 0

.216

6R

2 = 0

.91

56

-7-6-5-4-3-2-101

02

46

81

012

141

61

82

02

22

426

283

03

23

43

63

840

424

44

64

85

052

% In

itial O

2

%O2 Loss During Test (90 days)

Cha

nge

in O

2Le

vels

�F

aste

r m

igra

tion

of O

2ch

ange

s m

ixtu

re o

f ga

s du

ring

90-d

ay te

st•

Tire

s in

flate

d w

ith a

ir lo

stav

erag

e of

1.5

% O

2

•T

ires

infla

ted

with

N2

lost

or

gain

ed O

2to

ap

proa

ch e

quili

briu

m p

artia

l pre

ssur

e

�O

2le

vels

wer

e m

easu

red

for

76 ti

res

that

w

ere

in-s

ervi

ce (

19 v

ehic

les)

in A

kron

, OH

•T

ires

wer

e or

igin

ally

infla

ted

with

sho

p ai

r at

va

rious

loca

tions

, no

spec

ial p

roce

dure

s

O2

Con

tent

Ver

sus

Infla

tion

Pre

ssur

eIn

-Ser

vice

Tire

s

79111315171921

1015

2025

3035

40

Infla

tion

Pre

ssur

e, p

si

% O2No

Cor

rela

tion

Bet

wee

n In

flatio

n P

ress

ure

and

% O

2

Dur

ing

serv

ice

with

top-

offs

of

norm

al a

ir, th

e ox

ygen

pe

rmea

tes

out

at a

fast

er r

ate

than

the

nitr

ogen

.

Thi

s ca

n re

sult

in a

>50

%

redu

ctio

n in

ne

t oxy

gen

leve

ls in

the

tire

infla

tion

gas

durin

g no

rmal

ser

vice

.

O2

Leve

l Sig

nific

antly

R

educ

ed In

-Ser

vice

Oxy

gen

Ran

ge

(% o

f in

flat

ion

gas)

N

umbe

r of

Tir

es

9 � ���

11

4 11

.1 � ���

13

18

13.1

� ��� 1

5 18

15

.1 � ���

17

17

17.1

� ��� 1

9 14

19

.1 � ���

20.

0 5

15.0

2 A

vera

ge

2.79

S

tan

dard

Dev

iati

on

Indi

cate

s R

educ

ed P

oten

tial B

enef

its

for

N2

Infla

tion

in N

orm

al T

ire S

ervi

ce

IPLR

Adv

anta

ge fo

r N

2In

Ser

vice

The

oret

ical

Dis

trib

utio

n of

IP

LR

Nor

mal

ized

to

Air

Rat

e =

100

for

Tir

e T

ype.

Nor

mal

ized

Dis

trib

utio

n of

:__

___

Air

wit

h 20

.9%

O2

____

_--

----

----

----

Nit

roge

n -

----

----

----

--__

-A

ir, D

eple

ted

of O

2 in

Ser

vice

__-

IPL

Rav

g=2.

1

IPL

Rav

g=1.

4IP

LR

avg=

1.8

Dyn

amic

Infla

tion

Pre

ssur

e Lo

ss –

Roa

dwhe

el T

estin

g

Infla

tion

Pre

ssur

e Lo

ss D

urin

g R

oadw

heel

T

estin

g W

as 3

7% L

ess

for

Tire

s In

flate

d w

ith N

2vs

. Tire

s In

flate

d w

ith A

ir

Cha

nge

in %

O2

Dur

ing

Dyn

amic

Loa

ded

Ope

ratio

n

Hig

her

%O

2G

as D

iffus

es M

ore

Rap

idly

D

urin

g D

ynam

ic R

oadw

heel

Tes

ting

Doe

s N

2H

ave

a D

irect

Effe

ct

on R

ollin

g R

esis

tanc

e?

�24

Tire

s w

ere

com

pare

d fo

r R

ollin

g R

esis

tanc

e, e

ither

in

flate

d w

ith N

2 or

Air

•S

AE

J12

69 S

ingl

e-P

oint

Tes

t�

Ave

rage

Rol

ling

Res

ista

nce

•A

ir =

12.

80 p

ound

s ±0

.38

•N

2=

12.

65 p

ound

s ±0

.44

�N

o D

irect

Effe

ct O

bser

ved

for

N2

Infla

tion

on T

ire

Rol

ling

Res

ista

nce

�T

he O

nly

Sig

nific

ant E

ffect

on

Tire

Rol

ling

Res

ista

nce

may

be

Indi

rect

: •

Due

to B

ette

r R

eten

tion

of In

flatio

n P

ress

ure

over

Tim

e

Effe

cts

on T

ire D

urab

ility

�T

he b

enef

its o

f N2

infla

tion

on o

ven-

aged

tir

es h

as b

een

show

n*

�T

he ti

res

wer

e fil

led

with

50

/50

N2/

O2,

air

or N

2an

d ov

en-a

ged

for

5 w

eeks

@

65ºC

�T

hey

wer

e th

en te

sted

ac

cord

ing

to th

e F

MV

SS

13

9 E

ndur

ance

and

Low

P

ress

ure

Tes

t (to

failu

re

or 3

5.5

hour

s st

op-f

inis

h)

�50

/50

N2/

O2

had

a si

gnifi

cant

del

eter

ious

ef

fect

. T

ires

aged

with

N2

or a

ir in

flatio

n al

l pas

sed

test

@ 3

5.5

hrs

*N

. Tok

ita, W

.D. S

igw

orth

, G.H

. Nyb

akka

n, G

.B. O

uyan

g, “

Long

-Ter

m D

urab

ility

of T

ires,

”P

aper

18

D17

, Pro

ceed

ings

of t

he In

tern

atio

nal R

ubbe

r C

onfe

renc

e, K

yoto

, 198

5, p

. 672

-679

.

J. M

. Bal

dwin

, D.R

. Bau

er, a

nd K

.R. E

llwoo

d, “

Effe

cts

of N

itrog

en In

flatio

n on

Tire

Agi

ng a

nd

Per

form

ance

,”P

aper

2, p

rese

nted

at R

ubbe

r D

ivis

ion,

AC

S, G

rand

Rap

ids,

MI,

May

17-

19, 2

004.

U. K

arm

akar

, “E

ffect

of N

itrog

en P

urity

on

the

Oxi

datio

n of

Bel

t Coa

t Com

poun

d,”

pres

ente

d at

th

e In

tern

atio

nal T

ire E

xpos

ition

and

Con

fere

nce,

Akr

on, O

H, S

epte

mbe

r, 2

006.

Con

clus

ion

(I)

�In

labo

rato

ry te

stin

g, ti

res

infla

ted

with

94-

99%

N

2sh

owed

a 3

4% r

educ

tion

in p

ress

ure

loss

ve

rsus

tire

s in

flate

d w

ith a

ir (7

8% N

2)•

Bas

ed o

n re

duce

d O

2ob

serv

ed fo

r in

-ser

vice

tire

s, th

e be

nefit

s of

N2

in s

ervi

ce w

ould

be

sign

ifica

ntly

red

uced

•T

ires

infla

ted

with

N2

abov

e 97

% p

urity

sho

wed

di

ffusi

on o

f O2

into

the

tire

at 9

0 da

ys�

Sim

ilar

redu

ctio

n in

IPLR

for

tires

infla

ted

with

N

2du

ring

800-

hour

dyn

amic

, loa

ded

road

whe

el

test

�In

nerli

ner

com

posi

tion

and

initi

al in

flatio

n pr

essu

re h

ad n

o si

gnifi

cant

effe

ct o

n re

duct

ion

of IP

LR fo

r N

2ve

rsus

air

Con

clus

ions

(I

I)

�T

ire in

flatio

n w

ith N

2ve

rsus

air

had

no

sign

ifica

nt e

ffect

on

rolli

ng r

esis

tanc

e•

Ben

efits

of N

2w

ill li

kely

be

indi

rect

from

impr

oved

re

tent

ion

of in

flatio

n pr

essu

re o

ver

time

�La

bora

tory

tire

end

uran

ce a

fter

oven

agi

ng w

as

redu

ced

by h

igh

O2

cont

ent i

n in

flatio

n ga

s du

ring

oven

agi

ng

•T

ires

infla

ted

with

air

or N

2du

ring

agin

g co

mpl

eted

the

post

-ove

n 35

.5 h

our

test

with

no

failu

res

•P

revi

ous

stud

ies

have

sho

wn

bene

fits

for

tire

road

whe

el

endu

ranc

e w

hen

tires

infla

ted

with

N2

durin

g ag

ing