The Dr Paul Broughton Collection of English Hammered Gold Coins - 16014
-
Upload
spink-and-son -
Category
Documents
-
view
230 -
download
3
description
Transcript of The Dr Paul Broughton Collection of English Hammered Gold Coins - 16014
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION
OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
22 MARCH 2016
LONDON
© C
op
yri
ght
2016
2
35
TH
E D
R P
AU
L B
RO
UG
HT
ON
CO
LL
EC
TIO
N O
F E
NG
LIS
H H
AM
ME
RE
D G
OL
D C
OIN
S
22
MA
RC
H 2
01
6
LO
ND
ON
STAMPS COINS BANKNOTES MEDALS BONDS & SHARES AUTOGRAPHS BOOKS WINES
69 Southampton Row, Bloomsbury, London WC1B 4ETwww.spink.com
£25
Spink 16014 Coins cover.qxp_Layout 1 17/02/2016 18:30 Page 1
GROUP CHAIRMAN AND CEO
Olivier D. Stocker
YOUR SPECIALISTS
STAMPS
UK - Tim Hirsch FRPSL Guy Croton David Parsons Nick Startup Neill GrangerPaul Mathews Dominic Savastano Tom Smith George James Ian Shapiro (Consultant)
USA - George Eveleth Richard DebneyEUROPE - Guido Craveri Fernando MartínezCHINA - Doris Lo George Yue (Consultant)
COINS
UK - Richard Bishop Tim Robson Malene Wagner Lawrence Sinclair Barbara Mears John PettUSA - Greg Cole Muriel Eymery Stephen Gol dsmith (Special Consultant)
CHINA - Kin Choi Cheung Paul Pei Po ChowBANKNOTES
UK - Barnaby Faull Andrew Pattison Monica Kruber Thomasina SmithUSA - Greg Cole Stephen Goldsmith (Special Consultant)
CHINA - Kelvin Cheung Paul Pei Po ChowORDERS, DECORATIONS, MEDALS & MILITARIA
UK - Mark Quayle Oliver Pepys John Hayward (Consultant)BONDS & SHARES
UK - Mike Veissid (Consultant) Andrew Pattison Thomasina SmithUSA - Greg Cole
EUROPE - Peter ChristenCHINA - Kelvin Cheung
BOOKS
UK - Philip Skingley Michael Hyman Nik von UexkullAUTOGRAPHS
USA - Greg Cole Stephen Goldsmith (Special Consultant)WINES
CHINA - Guillaume Willk-Fabia Angie Ihlo Fung
YOUR EUROPE TEAM (LONDON - LUGANO)
DirectorsTim Hirsch Anthony Spink
Auction & Client Management TeamMira Adusei-Poku Rita Ariete Grace Hawkins Dora Szigeti Tatyana Boyadzhieva Nik von Uexkull
John Winchcombe Maurizio ScheniniFinance
Alison Bennet Marco Fiori Mina Bhagat Dennis Muriu Hemel Thakore Veronica MorrisIT & Administration
Berdia Qamarauli Michael Addo Liz Cones Curlene SpencerTom Robinson Cristina Dugoni Giacomo Canzi
YOUR AMERICA TEAM (NEW YORK)
Managing DirectorCharles Blane
Auction Administration and Marketing & DesignPolona Hribovsek
Finance & AdministrationAmit Ramprashad
AuctioneerStephen Goldsmith (Special Consultant)
YOUR ASIA TEAM (HONG KONG - SINGAPORE)
AdministrationAngie Ihlo Fung Newton Tsang Sue Pui Arthur Chan Doris Lo Gary Tan
Ken Imase [email protected]
BANKNOTES
7 April The Numismatic Collector’s Series Sale Hong Kong CSS2112 April The Bruce Smart Collection of Middle East and North Africa London 1603712/13/14 April World Banknotes London 1600822/23 June The Numismatic Collector’s Series Sale New York 3245 July World Banknotes London 1600925 August The Numismatic Collector’s Series Sale Hong Kong CSS23
SALE CALENDAR 2016
The above sale dates are subject to change
Spink offers the following services:– VALUATIONS FOR INSURANCE AND PROBATE FOR INDIVIDUAL ITEMS OR WHOLE COLLECTIONS –
– SALES ON A COMMISSION BASIS EITHER OF INDIVIDUAL PIECES OR WHOLE COLLECTIONS –
STAMPS
23 February The Drs. Joanne and Edward Dauer Collection of Australian States and Commonwealth London 1603823 February The “Britannia” Collection of Barbados London 1602424 February India, The De La Rue Issues London 1602327-28 April The Philatelic Collector’s Series Sale London 16027May The Pre-New York 2016 Collector’s Series Sale New York 154June The Jose Castillejo Collection of Guatemala, 1871-86 New York 15511 June The Philatelic Collector’s Series Sale Hong Kong CSS1822 June Great Britain Stamps and Postal History London 160296-7 July The Philatelic Collector’s Series Sale London 1603013 July Autographs, Historical Documents, Ephemera and Postal History London 16043
COINS
22 March The Academic Collection of Lord Stewartby: English Coins part 1, Anglo-Saxon and Norman Coins London 16019
22 March The Dr Paul Broughton Collection of English Hammered Gold Coins London 1601422/23 March Ancient, British & Foreign Coins and Commemorative Medals London 160047 April The Numismatic Collector’s Series Sale Hong Kong CSS2112 May Ancient and World Coins including European Coins from the Peter Woodhead Collection London 1604222/23 June The Numismatic Collector’s Series Sale New York 32429 June The Academic Collection of Lord Stewartby: English coins part 2, Plantagenet,
Lancastrian and Yorkist Coins London 1602029/30 June Ancient, British & Foreign Coins and Commemorative Medals London 1600525 August The Numismatic Collector’s Series Sale Hong Kong CSS23
MEDALS
21 April Orders, Decorations, Campaign Medals & Militaria London 1600121 July Orders, Decorations, Campaign Medals & Militaria London 16002
BONDS & SHARES
7 April The Numismatic Collector’s Series Sale Hong Kong CSS2120 May Bonds & Share Certificates of the World London 1601722/23 June The Numismatic Collector’s Series Sale New York 32425 August The Numismatic Collector’s Series Sale Hong Kong CSS23
AUTOGRAPHS
22/23 June The Numismatic Collector’s Series Sale New York 32413 July Autographs, Historical Documents, Ephemera and Postal History London 16043
WINES
8 April An Evening of Great Whiskies and Spirits Hong Kong SFW1923 June An Evening of Great Whiskies and Spirits Hong Kong SFW20
Spink 16014 Coins cover.qxp_Layout 1 17/02/2016 18:30 Page 2
Front Cover Illustration: 453 Back Cover Illustrations: 464, 465
To purchase a catalogue:
email: [email protected]
tel: +44 (0)20 7563 4005 fax: +44 (0)20 7563 4037
For more information about Spink services, forthcoming
sales and sales results visit the Spink Website
www.spink.com
SPINK ON SOCIAL MEDIA
Please use the QR code to visit our website, view our catalogues and otherpublications and place commission bids. You can download the QR CodeReader for iPhone, Blackberry and Android from App Store on yoursmartphone.
Dora [email protected]+44 (0)20 7563 4005fax +44 (0)20 7563 4037
FOR YOUR BIDS
John [email protected]
+44 (0)20 7563 4101
FOR YOUR VAT ENQUIRIES
*Spink is pleased to continue to offer our brand new on-line bidding platformSpink Live for no charge through www.spink.com. Please note that bidderswho acquire lots on the-saleroom.com will have a fee of 3% on the hammerprice added to their invoice for using this facility.
The Spink Environment Commitment:Paper from Sustainable Forests and Clean InkSpink has a long history of preserving not only collectables but our planet, too. We are proud to ensure thatour policy of sustainability and conservation keeps up with Spink’s growth, helping improve the environmentfor new generations of collectors.
We insist that our printers source all paper used in the production of Spink catalogues from FSC and/or PEFCsuppliers and use non-hazardous inks. We also ask they hold the environmental standard ISO 14001.
Spink recycle all ecological material used on our premises and we encourage you to recycle your catalogueonce you have finished with it.
Berdia [email protected]+44 (0)20 7563 4089on auction day only:+44 (0)20 7193 8608+44 (0)20 7193 8342
FOR YOUR INTERNET BIDDING
Veronica [email protected]+44 (0)20 7563 4018
Hemel [email protected]+44 (0)20 7563 4023
FOR YOUR PAYMENT
TWITTER: @SpinkandSon
INSTAGRAM: Spink_auctions
FACEBOOK: Spink Auctions
YOUTUBE: Spinkauctions
SALE DETAILS
Tuesday 22 March 2016 at 2.00 p.m.
In sending commission bids or making enquiries,
this sale should be referred to as BROUGHTON - 16014
Richard [email protected]+44 (0)20 7563 4053
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTIONOF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
SALE LOCATION
SPINK LONDON
69 Southampton Row, Bloomsbury
London WC1B 4ET
tel +44 (0)20 7563 4000 fax +44 (0)20 7563 4066
Vat No: GB 791627108
22 March 2016 in London and on
and/or *
YOUR SPINK TEAM FOR THIS SALE
FOR YOUR QUESTIONS ABOUT THE SALE LOTS
VIEWING OF LOTS
At Spink London
Friday 18 March 2016 10.00 a.m. - 5.00 p.m.
Monday 21 March 2016 10.00 a.m. - 5.00 p.m.
Private viewing by appointment only
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 1
TUESDAY 22 MARCH 2016
Commencing at 2.00 p.m
Lots
EDWARD III (1327-77) 401-407
RICHARD II (1377-99) 408-410
HENRY V (1413-22) 411-412
HENRY VI (FIRST REIGN 1422-61) 413-419
EDWARD IV (FIRST REIGN 1461-70) 420-422
HENRY VI (SECOND REIGN 1470-71) 423-424
RICHARD III (1483-85) 425
HENRY VII (1485-1509) 426-427
HENRY VIII (1509-47) 428-432
EDWARD VI (1547-53) 433-435
MARY (1553-54) 436
PHILIP AND MARY (1554-58) 437
ELIZABETH I (1558-1603) 438-444
JAMES I (1603-25) 445-458
CHARLES I (1625-49) 459-466
COMMONWEALTH (1649-60) 467-473
CHARLES II (1660-85) 474
END OF SALE
Order of Sale
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
WWW.SPINK.COM
Page 2
436429 441
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 2
x401 Edward III (1327-1377), third coinage, third period, 1346-51, Quarter-Noble, 2.04g,+ EDWAR R ANGL Z FRANC D HYB, shield in tressure of six arcs, rev. + EXALBITVR IN GLORIA,cross fleury in tressure of eight arcs, E in centre (Schneider 7; N.1112; S.1483), aboutextremely fine, scarce £600-800
PROVENANCE:Bonham’s, London, 20 April 2006, lot 358
TUESDAY 22 MARCH 2016
Commencing at 2.00 p.m
All lots are subject to Terms and Conditions for Buyers printed at the back of this catalogue
EstimatesThe estimated selling price of each lot is printed below the lot description and does not include the Buyer’s Premium.
Bidders should bear in mind that estimates are prepared well in advance of the sale and are not definitive.They are subject to revision.
Please note that bidders who acquire lots on the-saleroom.com will have a fee of 3% on the hammer price added to their invoice for using this facility. Spink is pleased to continue to offer our brand new on-line bidding platform
Spink Live for no charge through www.spink.com.
3
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
x402 Edward III (1327-1377), fourth coinage, pre-Treaty period (1351-61), Noble, 7.59g,London, class C/E, mule, m.m. cross 2 EDWARD DEI GRA REX ANGL Z FRANC D HYB, kingstanding facing in ship, holding sword and shield, rev. + IHC AVTEM TRAIICIEIIS P MEDIVMILLORVM IBAT, floriate cross with lis at ends, E in centre (Schneider 21; N.1144/60;S.1486/1488), better than very fine, extremely rare £3,000-4,000
PROVENANCE:Doubleday collection, Glendining, 7 June 1972, lot 48St. James’s auction, 27 September 2006, lot 163
401
401 (x1.5)
402
402 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 3
x403 Edward III (1327-1377), pre-Treaty period (1356-1361), Noble, 7.68g, series F/Gb orGc, mule, London, m.m. cross pattée, EDWARD DEI GRA REX ANGL Z FRANC D HYB, kingstanding facing in ship, holding sword and shield.; ornaments -11-11-, ropes 3/3,quatrefoils 3/4. lis 3; E’s broken in legend, saltire stops, double A in FRANC, rev. + IHTAVTEM TRAIICIEIIS P MEDIVM ILLORVM IBAT, floriate cross with lis at ends and small E incentre, crowned lions in quarters, all within tressure of eight arches, small annulet stops,unbroken C and E, small lis by lion in second quarter (Lawrence dies AQ/7-8; Schneider37-38 var. (Gg reverse; same obverse die); N.1173/1183; S.1489/1490), nearlyextremely fine, a few minor marks on edge, well struck, very rare £3,000-4,000
PROVENANCE:Marshall Faintich collectionClassical Numismatic Group, auction 73, 13 September 2006, lot 1245
Note: the series F obverse die used for this coin was muled with both Gb-Gc and Gg reverses
Page 4
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
403
403 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 4
x404 Edward III (1327-1377), fourth coinage, Treaty period, Noble, 7.33g, London, m.m.cross potent, EDWARD DEI GRA REX ANGL DNS HYB Z AQT, king standing facing in ship,holding sword and shield, rev. + IHC AVTEM TRANSIENS PER MEDIV ILLORVM IBAT, floriatecross with lis at ends, E in centre (cf. Schneider 75-76, both with saltire before EDWARD;N. -; S.1502; L. A. Lawrence: 1933 Numismatic Chronicle, pp. 15-79 , plate XV11:4),good very fine, an extremely rare variety £3,000-4,000
This obverse die is described by Lawrence (pl. XVII:4 [same obverse die]) as being from GroupC, with annulet before Edward and a crescent on the forecastle, but it clearly does not haveeither of these features.
The obverse die in question was mis-described by Lawrence. He stated that it had an annuletbefore EDWARD and a crescent on the forecastle which it does not. Therefore, although the coinis from the same die as the coin illustrated by Lawrence, it does not match Lawrence’sdescription in the text. This coin is not the coin illustrated by Lawrence, as although theobverses are from the same die, the reverses are from different dies. When North was preparinghis book he presumably just went by the text in Lawrence and failed to notice the discrepancybetween the description and the coin illustrated. This variety is not listed by North asaccording to his listing, all Treaty period nobles of London (North 1231-1233) have either asaltire or an annulet before EDWARD (L. A. Lawrence: 1933 Numismatic Chronicle, pp. 15-79, plate XV11:4)
PROVENANCEBaldwin’s auction 43, London, 11 October 2005, lot 2254
5
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
404
404 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 5
x405 Edward III (1327-1377), fourth coinage, Treaty period 1361-69, Noble, 7.71g,London, series B, m.m. cross pattée, EDWARD DEI GRA REX ANGL D HYB Z AQT, kingstanding facing in ship, holding sword and shield, annulet before Edward, rev. + IHCAVTEM TRANSIENS PER MEDIV ILLORVM IBAT, floriate cross with lis at ends, large E in centre,double saltire stops (cf. Schneider 87; N.1232; S.1503), extremely fine £3,000-4,000
PROVENANCE:Clarendon collection, Bonham’s, London, 28 March 2006, lot 342
Page 6
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
x406 Edward III (1327-1377), fourth coinage, treaty period 1361-69, Noble, 7.65g, Calais,EDWARD DEI GRA REX ANGL DNS HYB Z AQT, voided quatrefoil before EDWARD and saltireseither side of Z, king standing facing in ship, holding sword and shield, flag at stern, rev.+ IHC AVTEM TRANSIENS PER MEDIV ILLORVM IBAT, floriate cross with lis at ends, E in centre(cf. Schneider 102; N.1236; S.1504), a delightful coin, well centred with a superb portrait,lustrous extremely fine £6,000-8,000
PROVENANCE:Goldberg auction 44, 13 February 2008, lot 3972
405
405 (x1.5)
406
406 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 6
x407 Edward III (1327-1377), post-Treaty 1369-77, Noble, 7.66g, group III, London, m.m.cross potent, EDWARD DI GRA REX ANGL Z FRANC DNS HIB Z AQ, king standing facing inship, holding sword and shield, ornaments 1-1-1-1, ropes 3/1, quatrefoils 4/4, lis 4,saltire stops, annulet above sail, rev. + IHC AVTEM TRANSIENS PER MEDIVM ILLORVM IBAT,floriate cross with lis at ends and small E and pellet in centre; crowned lions in quarters,chevron barred A in IBAT (Lawrence 1; Schneider 112/114 (obv./rev.); N.1278; S.1518),nearly extremely fine, struck from fresh dies £3,000-4,000
PROVENANCE:Classical Numismatic Group, Triton X, 8 January 2007, lot 1321
7
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
x408 Richard II (1377-1399), Noble, 7.80g, London, Series IIA, crude style, m.m. crosspattée, RICARD DEI GRA REX ANGL DNS HIB Z AQT, king standing facing in ship, holdingsword and shield, saltire over sail, without French title, rev. + IHC AVTEM TRANSIENS PERMEDIV ILLORV IBAT, floriate cross with lis at ends, R in centre, double saltire stops(Schneider 146 same dies; N.1304 (2); S.1655), a clean example with strong detailthroughout, almost extremely fine £4,000-5,000
PROVENANCE:Glendining, 3 October 1963, lot 23Glendining, 4 March 1981, lot 13Clarendon collection, Bonham’s, London, 28 March 2006, lot 433
407
407 (x1.5)
408
408 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 7
x409 Richard II (1377-1399), Noble, 7.68g, series IIIA, fine style, London, m.m crosspotent, RICARD DI GRA REX ANGL Z FRANC DNS HI Z AQ, king standing facing in ship,holding sword and shield, French title resumed, rev. + IHC AVTEM TRANSIENS PER MEDIVILLORVM IBAT, floriate cross with lis at ends, R in centre (Schneider 159 same obverse die;N.1303 (1); S.1656), struck on a broad flan, minor scrape centre of obverse, crisp strikeoverall, the face of the king well detailed, good extremely fine, rare £4,000-5,000
PROVENANCE:R C Lockett, Glendining, 11 October 1956, lot 1330St James’s auction 7, 8 February 2008, lot 67
Page 8
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
x410 Richard II (1377-1399), Noble, 7.72g, Calais, Series IIIC with French title resumed,m.m. cross pattée RICARD DEI GRA REX ANGL D HIB Z AQT, king standing facing in ship,holding sword and shield, flag at stern, lion on rudder, pellet above and below the shield,rev. + IHC AVTEM TRANSIENS PER MEDIVM ILLORVM IBAT, floriate cross with lis at ends, R incentre, double saltire stops (N.1307 (2); S.1663), double struck on reverse, good very fine £5,000-6,000
PROVENANCE:Clarendon collection, Bonham’s, London, 28 March 2006, lot 435
409
409 (x1.5)
410
410 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 8
x411 Henry V (1413-1422), Noble, 6.95g, type E, London, HENRIC DI GRA REX ANGL Z FRANCDNS HYB, king standing facing in ship, holding sword and shield, pellet at sword point,mullet and annulet by sword arm, trefoil by shield, annulet on ship, rev. + IHC AVTEMTRANSIENS PER MEDIV ILLORV IBA, floriate cross with lis at ends, H in centre, extra pellet inone quarter and saltire in another (cf. Schneider 251; N.1373; S.1744), about extremelyfine with good portrait £4,000-5,000
PROVENANCE:St James’s auction 6, 8 June 2007, lot 60
9
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
x412 Henry V (1413-1422), Quarter-Noble, 1.75g, type C, London, m.m. pierced cross, +HENRIC DI GRA REX ANG Z F, quartered shield of arms with lis above, quatrefoil and annuletat sides, trefoils at points of tressure of eight arcs, rev. + EXALTABITVR IN GLORIA, initialmark pierced cross, lis at centre, stars in angles of centre panel (Schneider 213; N.1381/1;S.1754), neatly struck on a broad flan, very fine £2,000-2,500
PROVENANCE:Baldwin’s auction 62-63, 29 September 2009, lot 219
411
411 (x1.5)
412
412 (x2)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 9
x413 Henry VI (first reign, 1422-1461), Noble, 7.66g, annulet issue, London, mule withobverse of Henry V, class F, m.m. lis on reverse only, HENRIC DI GRA REX ANGL Z FRANCDNS HYB, king standing facing in ship, holding sword and shield, mullet and annulet bysword arm, trefoil by shield and on ship’s side, quatrefoil over sail, rev. IHC AVT TRANSIENSPER MEDIVM ILLORV IBAT, floriate cross with lis at ends, H in centre, annulet in firstspandrel (Whitton mule (a); cf. Schneider 268; N.1374/1414; S.1746/1799), anextremely rare and interesting mule, very fine and clear, a pleasing coin £4,000-5,000
PROVENANCE:Spink auction 169, 15 July 2004, lot 231
Nobles were struck muling observe dies of each the last three classes (E, F, and G) of Henry Vwith annulet reverse dies of Henry VI. All such mules are extremely rare, and the only otherF/annulet mule offered at auction in the last 40 years was a coin from the Pulham hoardstruck from the same dies as this piece (Christie’s, May 28, 1985, lot 32)
Page 10
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
413
413 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 10
11
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
x414 Henry VI (first reign, 1422-1461), Noble, 6.95g, annulet issue, London, mule withobverse of Henry V, class G, m.m. lis on reverse only, HENRIC DI GRA REX ANGL Z FRANCDNS HYB, king standing facing in ship, holding sword and shield, mullet after HENRICstruck over an annulet, rev. IHC AVT TRANSIENS PER MEDIVM ILLORV IBAT, floriate crosswith lis at ends, H in centre, mullet after IHC, annulet in one spandrel (cf. Whitton p. 79(b); Schneider 269; N.1375/1414; S.1800), an attractive coin, extremely fine, very rare £5,000-6,000
PROVENANCE:Brokes Road, Reigate, Surrey, Hoard (1990)Glendining, 8 December 1992, lot 42DNW, Coinex auction, 24 September 2008, lot 3867
There were three examples in the Fishpool Hoard (1996), and one in the Pulham Hoard(1985)
414
414 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 11
x415 Henry VI (first reign, 1422-1461), Noble, 6.95g, annulet issue, London, m.m. lis,HENRIC (lis) DI GRA REX ANGL Z FRANC DNS HYB, king standing facing in ship, holdingsword and shield, annulet at sword arm, rev. IHC AVT TRANSIENS PER MEDIVM ILLORV IBAT,floriate cross with lis at ends, H in centre, annulet in first spandrel (Whitton 7(d); cf.Schneider 285; N.1414; S.1799), an attractive and full round coin, mint state as struck,extremely fine £5,000-6,000
PROVENANCE:Marshall collection, Spink auction 167, 31 March 2004, lot 4
Page 12
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
415
415 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 12
13
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
x416 Henry VI (first reign, 1422-1461), Noble, 6.91g, annulet issue, Calais, m.m. lis onreverse only, HENRIS (lis) DI GRA REX ANGL Z FRANC DNS HYB, lis and trefoil stops, kingstanding facing in ship, holding sword and shield, annulet by wrist, flag at stern, rev. IHCAVT TRANSIENS PER MEDIVM ILLORV IBAT, floriate cross with lis at ends, H in centre, annuletin first spandrel of second quarter, annulet stops (Whitton 5; cf. Schneider 299-300;N.1415; S.1803), nearly extremely fine £5,000-6,000
PROVENANCE:DNW, 13 December 2006, lot 87
416
416 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 13
x417 Henry VI (first reign, 1422-1461), Half-Noble, annulet issue, London, m.m. lis onreverse, HENRIC DI GRA REX ANGL Z FRANC, king standing facing in ship, holding swordand shield, rev. DOMINE NE IN FVRORE TVO ARGVAS ME, floriate cross with lis at ends, H incentre (N.1417; S.1805), the Half-Noble is rarer in high grade than the Noble, anexceptionally round and well-struck example, NGC graded MS-64 £2,500-3,000
PROVENANCE:Spink auction 161, 14 November 2002, lot 101Cheshire collection, Goldberg auction 31, 30 May 2005, lot 2089Dr Robert D. Hesselgesser collection, Goldberg auction 42, 26 September 2007, lot 794
418
Page 14
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
x418 Henry VI (first reign, 1422-1461), Half-Noble, 3.46g, annulet issue, London, mule,obverse of Henry V, class G, mm. lis on reverse, HENRIC DI GRA REX ANGL Z FR, mulletafter HENRIC, king standing facing in ship, holding sword and shield, quatrefoil over sail,rev. DOMINE NE IN FVRORE TUO ARGVAS ME, floriate cross with lis at ends, H in centre,mullet after DOMINE, annulet in one spandrel (cf. Whitton p. 82 (a); Schneider 272-273same obverse die; N.1380/1417; S.1806), slightly creased, otherwise very fine or better, veryrare £3,000-4,000
PROVENANCE:Brokes Road, Reigate, Surrey, Hoard (1990)Glendining, 8 December 1992, lot 63DNW, Coinex auction, 24 September 2008, lot 3868
418 (x1.5)
417
417 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 14
x419 Henry VI (first reign, 1422-1461), Noble, rosette-mascle issue 1427-30, London, m.m.lis on reverse, HENRIC DI GRA REX ANGL FRANC DNS HYB, king standing facing in ship,holding sword and shield, lis by sword arm, rev. IHC AVT TRANSIENS PER MEDIVM ILLORVIBAT, floreate cross, H at centre, stops, rosettes and mascles (N.1439; S.1817), mint statewith a superb portrait, NGC graded MS-63, very rare £6,000-8,000
PROVENANCE:Baldwin’s auction 24, 9 October 2000, lot 988Cheshire collection, Goldberg auction 31, 30 May 2005, lot 2099Dr. Robert D. Hesselgesser collection, Goldberg auction 42, 26 September 2007, lot793
419 (x1.5)
15
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
419
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 15
x420 Edward IV (first reign, 1461-1470), light coinage 1466-67, Ryal or Rose Noble, 7.63g,London, m.m. crown on reverse, EDWARD DI GRA REX ANGL Z FRANC DNS HI, king standingfacing in ship, carrying sword and shield, rose on side and flag with E, rev. IHC AVTTRANSIENS PER MEDIVM ILLORVM IBAT, rose over sun with fleurs in spandrels (Schneider363; N.1549; S. 1950), very fine, wavy flan £2,000-2,500
PROVENANCE:Classical Numismatic Group, auction 158, 14 February 2007, lot 297
Page 16
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
420
420 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 16
17
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
x421 Edward IV (first reign, 1461-1470), light coinage 1464-70, Ryal, 7.61g, Bristol mint,m.m. crown on reverse, EDWARD DI GRA REX ANGL Z FRANC DNS I B, king standing facingin ship, holding sword and shield, B in waves below, rev. IHC AVTEM TRANSIENS PERMEDIVM ILLORVM IBAT, crowned sunburst, rose in centre, small trefoils in spandrels(Schneider 419; N.1550; S.1954), lustrous with crisp strike on a round flan, not quite full,legends and the king’s facial features especially well detailed, about extremely fine, rare,NGC graded MS-63 £5,000-7,000
PROVENANCE:Spink auction 32, 30 November 1983, lot 281Dr Jacob Y. Terner collectionGoldberg ‘Millennia’ collection, 26 May 2008, lot 281
421 (x1.5)
421
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 17
x422 Edward IV (first reign, 1461-1470), light coinage 1464-70, Half-Ryal, 3.98g, Bristolmint, m.m. crown on reverse, EDWARD DI GRA REX ANGL Z FRANC, king standing facing inship, holding sword and shield, B in waves below, rev. DOMINE NE IN FVRORE TVO ARGVASME, crowned sunburst, rose in centre (Schneider 420; N.1555; S.1960), very rare, typeVII, minted July 1466 to July 1467 only, a superb, lustrous example, crisp strike, slightly shortof flan, about extremely fine with a good portrait, NGC graded MS-65 £5,000-7,000
PROVENANCE:Lockett, Glendining, 27 April 1960, lot 4021Norweb, Spink auction 45, 13 June 1985, lot 193Dr Jacob Y. Terner collectionGoldberg ‘Millennia’ collection, 26 May 2008, lot 282
422
Page 18
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
422 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 18
x423 Henry VI (second reign, 1470-1471), Half-Angel, 2.54g, London, m.m./cross pattéeon reverse, HENRIC DI GRA REX.ANGL Z FR/A, St Michael vanquishing Satan, trefoil stops,rev. + O:/CRVX. AVE. SPES: V. NICA, cross dividing h and lis above shield within ship, trefoilstops (Schneider 444 - same dies; N.1615; S.2080), slight crease, almost very fine,extremely rare £15,000-20,000
PROVENANCE:A metal detector find 10 miles north of Shrewsbury, ShropshireSpink auction auction 201, 26 November 2009, lot 180
Extremely rare, only a few extant. This was the second sale of this coin type since the sale bySpink in 1985 of the Norweb collection. The other was an inferior example with crackedcentre (Spink auction 199, 25 June 2009, lot 485)
19
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
423
423 (x2)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 19
x424 Edward IV (second reign, 1471-1483), Angel, 5.18g, m.m. cinquefoil, EDWARD DEI GRAREX ANGL Z FRANC, St Michael vanquishing Satan, rev. PER CRVCEM TVA SALVA NOS XPEREDEMPT, cross dividing E and rose above shield within ship (B&W XXI; cf. Schneider466; N.1626; S.2091), nearly extremely fine £1,500-2,000
PROVENANCE:DNW, 13 December 2006, lot 95
Page 20
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
x425 Richard III (1483-1485), Angel, 5.04g, type 2B/1 mule, m.m. boar’s head no. 1 (oversun and rose no. 1) on obverse, halved sun and rose no. 1 on reverse, RICARD DI GRA REXANGL Z FRANC, St Michael vanquishing Satan, rev. PER CRVCEM TVA SALVA NOS XPCREDEMPT, cross dividing H and rose above shield within ship, R over E (Schneider 484,same obv die; N.1676; S.2151), good very fine, very rare £12,000-15,000
PROVENANCE:DNW, 22 February 1995, lot 136DNW, Coinex auction, 24 September 2008, lot 3878
424
424 (x2)
425
425 (x2)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 20
x426 Henry VII (1485-1509), Angel, 5.18g, class V, m.m. cross crosslet, HENRIC DI GRA REXAGLIE Z FRA, St. Michael vanquishing Satan, both feet on dragon, cross crosslet spear shaft,one saltire by halo, rev. PER CRVCEM TVA SALVA NOS XPE RED, cross dividing H and roseabove shield within ship, double saltire/rosette stops, double rosette after PER (cf.Schneider 536 (obv.); PW class II(b), 2 var.; N.1698; S.2186), a full round crisply struckcoin, almost extremely fine, this reverse die, with a double rosette stop after PER, is apparentlyunpublished, very rare £3,500-4,500
PROVENANCE:Spink Numismatic Circular, August-September 1942, item 15770Marshall collection, Spink auction 167, 31 March 2004, lot 9
21
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
x427 Henry VII (1485-1509), Half-Angel, 2.54g, type III, m.m. pansy, HENRIC DI GRA REXANGLI, St Michael vanquishing Satan, rev. O CRVX AVE SPES VNICA, cross dividing H androse above shield within ship (N.1700; S.2189), abrasion in waves otherwise a superb piece,almost extremely fine £2,500-3,500
PROVENANCE:Maj. W.S. Thorburn, Sotheby, 6-8 July 1887, lot 64, £1.9/- to SpinkSir A. Prevost, Glendining, 22 January 1919, lot 43Lockett, Glendining, 4 November 1958, lot 3192Lockett collectionSt James’s auction 7, 8 February 2008, lot 83
426
426 (x1.5)
427
427 (x2)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 21
Page 22
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
x428 Henry VIII (1509-1547), first coinage, Angel, m.m castle with pellet before, HENRIC VIIIDI GRA REX AGL Z FR, St. Michael vanquishing Satan, both feet on dragon, rev. PER CRVCETVA SALVA NOS REDE, cross dividing H and rose above shield within ship (Schneider 557;N.1760; S.2265), lustrous surfaces, almost fully struck on a broad flan with bold legendscomplete to the outer rim beads, with a wonderfully detailed face of St Michael, die-linesvisible in the fields, uncirculated £2,500-3,000
PROVENANCE:Heritage auction 458, 7 January 2008, lot 51164
428 (x1.5)
428
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 22
x429 Henry VIII (1509-1547), second coinage, Sovereign, 15.31g, , m.m. lis (over sunburston obverse) HENRICVS DEI GRACIA REX ANGLIE ET FRANC DNS HIB, king enthroned holdingorb and sceptre, portcullis at feet, rev. IHESVS AVTEM TRANSIENS PER MEDIVM ILLORVMIBAT, square-topped shield on Tudor rose, within double tressure, double saltire stops(Whitton O1d/R4; Schneider 570/1 (same obv./rev. dies); N.1782; S.2267), struck ona small flan, very fine scratches in field, very fine or better, rare £25,000-30,000
PROVENANCE:R Huth, Sotheby, 4 April 1927, lot 34Glendining, 19 June 1974, lot 8Spink auction 166, 12 November 2003, lot 11
23
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
429
429 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 23
x430 Henry VIII (1509-1547), second coinage, Angel, 5.11g, m.m. lis, HENRIC VIII DI GRAREX AGL Z FRA, St. Michael vanquishing Satan, rev. PER CRVCE TVA SALVE NOS XPE REDETO,cross dividing H and rose above shield within ship, double saltire stops (cf. Schneider 574;N.1783; S.2268), faint scratch in obverse field, a clear and evenly toned coin, very fine, veryrare £3,500-4,500
PROVENANCE:Spink auction 172, 31 March 2005, lot 232
The very rare second coinage Angel of Henry VIII is distinguished from the normal thirdcoinage piece by reading HENRIC VIII, rather than HENRIC 8
Page 24
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
x431 Henry VIII ( 1509-1547), third coinage, Half-Sovereign, 6.20g, Southwark, S HENRIC 8D G AGL FRANCI Z HIB REX, king enthroned facing, holding orb but no sceptre, rose below,rev. S IHS AVTE TRANSIENS PER MEDIVM ILLOR IBAT, crowned shield with lion and griffinsupporters, E below (Schneider -; N.1828; S.2297), about extremely fine on a full flan withgood portrait of king, rare variety without the sceptre £6,000-8,000
PROVENANCE:Major David Poll collection, St James’s auction 12, 6 November 2009, lot 1149
430
430 (x1.5)
431
431 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 24
x432 Henry VIII (1509-1547), third coinage, Angel, 5.13g, m.m. lis, HENRIC 8 D G AGL FRAZ HIB REX, St Michael vanquishing Satan, annulet to left of nimbus, rev. PER CRVCE TVASALVA NOS XPE REDE, cross dividing H and rose above shield within ship, anulet on side ofship (cf. Schneider 624; N.1830; S.2299), good very fine £1,500-2,000
PROVENANCE:DNW, 28 September 2006, lot 567
25
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
x433 Edward VI (1547-1553), first period, Half-Sovereign, 5.88g, Southwark, m.m. E overarrow/E, EDWARD 6 D G AGL FRAN ZHIB REX, king enthroned facing, holding orb andsceptre, rose below, rev. IHS AVTEM TRANSIENS PER MEDI ILLOR IBAT, crowned shield withlion and griffin supporters, reversed E below (Schneider 665 same obverse die; N.1893,S.2430), good very fine to almost extremely fine with unusually well-struck portrait £3,500-4,500
PROVENANCE:St James’s auction 6, 8 June 2007, lot 75
432
432 (x1.5)
433
433 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 25
x434 Edward VI (1547-1553), third coinage, Sovereign of Twenty Shillings, 11.16g, m.m. y,EDWARD VI D G AGL FRA Z HIB REX, crowned half-length figure of king right, holding orband sword, rev. IHS AVTE TRANCI PER MEDIV ILLOR IBAT, crowned shield with lion andgriffin supporters, ER below (cf. Schneider 690; N.1927; S.2450), creased, otherwise veryfine, lightly toned, rare £15,000-20,000
PROVENANCE:C H B Morton, Earl of Ducie, Glendining, 5 October 1949, lot 16Glendining, 17 July 1962, lot 20Glendining, 6 June 1991, lot 841 Spink auction 181, 30 March 2006, lot 1028
There are two mint marks for the third coinage gold issued at the Tower, tun, and letter Y.The letter Y probably refers to the Under Teasurer Sir John Yorke (just as the ostrich headmark used at Southwark is regarded as a punning allusion to the treasurer Sir EdmundPeckham). Of the two marks, the letter Y is much rarer that the tun.
Page 26
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
434
434 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 26
x435 Edward VI (1547-1553), third coinage, Half-Sovereign, 5.51g, m.m. y, EDWARD VI D GAGL FRA Z HIB, crowned half-length figure of king right, holding sword and orb, rev. IHSAVTE TRANCI PERMED ILLO IBA, crowned square topped shield, E-R at sides (Schneider 693same obverse die; N.1928; S.2451), two small flan cracks on edge, bold strike, almostextremely fine £8,000-10,000
PROVENANCE:Künker auction 121, 13 March 2007, lot 2086
27
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
435
435 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 27
x436 Mary (1553-1554), Sovereign, 15.32g, 1553, m.m. pomegranate, MARIA D G ANG FRA ZHIB REGINA MDLIII, queen enthroned holding orb and sceptre, portcullis at feet, rev. A DNOFACTV EST ISTV Z EST MIRA IN OCVL NRIS, square-topped shield in centre of Tudor rose,within double tressure, double annulet stops, single annulet after NRIS (Schneider 704same obverse die; N.1956; S.2488), very slightly creased, a small scratch to right of shield,otherwise a sharply struck coin with excellent portrait, and original bright underlying lustre,almost extremely fine, rare £20,000-25,000
PROVENANCE:Glendining, 18 November 1930, lot 172Spink auction 63, 28 March 1988, lot 173Spink auction 161, 14 November 2002, lot 118Samuel King collection, Spink auction 173, 5 May 2005, lot 41
Page 28
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
436
436 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 28
x437 Philip and Mary (1554-1558), Angel, 5.15g, m.m lis, PHILIP’. Z: MARIA: D’. G’. REX. Z.REGINA. A’, St Michael of old style with small wings, vanquishing Satan, rev. A. DNO’.FACTVM: EST. ISTVD: Z: EST: MIRAB’, cross dividing P-M above shield on rudderless ship,wire line inner circles both sides (Schneider 727 same obverse die; N.1965; S.2496), goodvery fine on a full round flan, rare £15,000-20,000
PROVENANCE:Major W.S. Thorburn, Sotheby, 6-8 July 1887, lot 90J.G. Murdoch, part 1, 31 March - 4 April 1903, lot 550H.P. Hall, Glendining, 26-27 July 1950, lot 80, collection bought en bloc by Spinkprior to the saleR.D. Beresford-Jones, Spink auction 29, 2 June 1983, lot 63
29
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
437
437 (x2)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 29
x438 Elizabeth I (1558-1603), second issue 1560-61, Angel, 5.02g, m.m. cross crosslet,ELIZABETH D G ANG FR ET HIB REGINA, St. Michael standing vanquishing Satan, rev. A DNOFACTVM EST ISTVD ET EST MIRABI, cross dividing E (over rose) and rose (over E), aboveshield within large ship with upturned castles sailing right, E (over rose) and rose (over E)at sides, beaded inner circles, pellet stops (Schneider 733 (same dies); N.1979; S.2514),a pleasing coin, unusually full and round, very fine or better, rare £2,000-2,500
PROVENANCE:Spink auction 171, 25 November 2004, lot 15
Page 30
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
x439 Elizabeth I (1558-1603), third issue 1573-78, Half Angel, 2.61g, m.m. eglantine,ELIZABETH D G ANG FR ET HI REGINA, St. Michael standing vanquishing Satan, rev. A DNOFACTVM EST ISTVD ET EST MIRA, cross dividing E and rose above shield within ship, crescentor double crescent stops (Schneider 771 same dies; N.1992/1; S.2517), an excellent coin,unusually fine and crisp on a full round flan, extremely fine, very rare thus £4,000-5,000
PROVENANCE:Sir Kenyon Vaughan Morgan, Sotheby, 17 June 1935, lot 59Spink Numismatic Circular, June 1943, no 20475, £15Marshall collection, Spink auction 167, 31 March 2004, lot 15
438
438 (x1.5)
439
439 (x2)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 30
x440 Elizabeth I (1558-1603), Half-Pound, m.m. cross crosslet, ELIZABETH D G ANG FR ET HIREGINA, crowned bust left, rev. SCVTVM FIDEI PROTEGET EAM, crowned shield (Schneider738; N.1982; S.2520), sharp lettering and detail preserved, especially within the reverseshield. NGC graded AU-50 £5,000-6,000
PROVENANCE:Goldberg auction 41, 30 May 2007, lot 4474
31
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
440 (x1.5)
440
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 31
x441 Elizabeth I (1558-1603), sixth issue 1583-1600, Sovereign, 15.37g, m.m. tun,ELIZABETH D G ANG FRA ET HIB REGINA, queen enthroned holding orb and sceptre,portcullis at feet, tressure unbroken by throne, back of throne and uprights decoratedwith pellets, rev. A DNO FACTV EST ISTVD ET EST MIRAB IN OCVL NRS, square-topped shieldon Tudor rose, pellet stops (Brown & Comber A26; Schneider 783 (same dies); N.2003;S.2529), tiny dig in field above portcullis, otherwise a pleasing full round specimen withgolden/red toning, almost extremely fine, rare £20,000-25,000
PROVENANCE:Spink Numismatic Circular, July 1942, no. 15355, £22.10/-Marshall collection, Spink auction 167, 31 March 2004, lot 16
Page 32
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
441
441 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 32
x442 Elizabeth I (1558-1603), sixth issue 1583-1600, Pound of Twenty-Shillings, 11.11g,bust 7A, m.m. tun, ELIZABETH D G ANG FRA ET HIB REGINA, crowned bust left with longhair and richly ornamented dress, rev. SCVTVM FIDEI PROTEGET EAM, crowned square-topped shield with E R at sides, colon/double annulet stops (Brown & Comber F4;Schneider 798 (same dies); N.2008; S.2534), very slightly double struck on obverse, the diesof exceptionally fine workmanship, extremely fine, very rare thus, probably the finest knownexample £15,000-20,000
PROVENANCE:Spink Numismatic Circular, May 1942, no. 14270 (‘almost perfect’)Marshall collection, Spink auction 167, 31 March 2004, lot 17
Brown and Comber suggest that Seaby Coin and Medal Bulletin, April 1973 (G2378), a dieduplicate of this coin, may have a lion erased from the obverse die above the crown, but thereis no trace of an erasure on this finer example.
33
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
442
442 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 33
x443 Elizabeth I (1558-1603), sixth issue 1583-1600, Half-Pound, m.m. tun, ELIZAB D G ANGFRA ET HIB REGIN, bust of queen facing left, wearing elaborate dress, rev. SCVTVM FIDEIPROTEGET EAM, crowned shield dividing E-R (N.2009; S.2535), this very ornate type ofElizabethan Half-Pound is considerably rarer than the plainer style Half-Pound, andprobably much rarer than the Pound piece in the top grades, extremely fine, proof-like fields,an abundance of original luster and very sharply struck on a larger than average flan, NGCgraded AU-55 £8,000-10,000
PROVENANCE:Goldberg auction 41, 30 May 2007, lot 4477
Page 34
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
443 (x1.5)
443
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 34
x444 Elizabeth I (1558-1603), sixth issue 1583-1600, Halfcrown, 1.31g, m.m. woolpack,ELIZAB D G ANG FR ET HIB REGI, crowned bust left in ornate jewelled dress, rev. SCVTVMFIDEI PROTEGET EAM, crowned shield, ER at sides (Schneider - (cf.818-821); N.2011;S.2537), well centred with a good portrait and sharp details all around, flan slightly ragged,choice very fine £4,000-5,000
PROVENANCE:St James’s auction 7, 8 February 2008, lot 107
35
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
x445 James I (1603-1625), first coinage, Sovereign, 11.07g, m.m. thistle, IACOBVS D G ANGSCO FRAN ET HIB REX, first bust crowned right, holding orb and shouldering sceptre,wearing plain armour, rev. EXVRGAT DEVS DISIPENTVR INIMICI, crowned shield, IR at sides(Schneider 1; N.2066; S.2608), very fine, reverse good very fine £12,000-15,000
PROVENANCE:Glendining, 28 November 1980, lot 29St James’s auction 5St James’s auction, 27 September 2006, lot 307
444
444 (x2)
445
445 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 35
x446 James I (1603-1625), second coinage 1604-19, Rose Ryal of 30-Shillings, m.m. rose,IACOBVS D G MAG BRIT FRAN ET HIBER REX, king enthroned facing, portcullis at feet, throneback with scrolling, rev. A DNO FACTVM EST ISTVD ET EST MIRAB IN OCVLIS NRIS, shield onrose (Schneider 6 same dies; N.2079; S.2613), on a full, broad flan, with a crisp strikeshowing the tiniest details exquisitely, the important centres (normally weak even on the finestpieces) being sharply defined, rare, more so in this remarkable quality, NGC graded MS-64 £20,000-25,000
PROVENANCE:J G Murdoch, Sotheby, 31 March - 4 April 1903, lot 678J Haswell, Sotheby, 12 July 1926, lot 96H M Lingford, Glendining, 20-21 June 1951, lot 880Dr. Jacob Y. Terner collectionGoldberg ‘Millennia’ collection, 26 May 2008, lot 297
Page 36
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
446
446 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 36
37
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
x447 James I (1603-1625), second coinage, Spur Ryal, 6.89g, m.m. escallop (over rose onrev.), IACOBVS D G MAG BRIT FRAN ET HIB REX, king holding sword and shield, standing inship, I on flag at stern, rose on side of ship, rev. A DNO FACTVM EST ISTVD ET EST MIRABILE,rose on spur rowel at centre, lis and crowned lions around (cf. Schneider 11-13; N.2080;S.2614), extremely fine, very rare £25,000-30,000
PROVENANCE:Cdr. J B Spurgin, Glendining, 14 January 1944, lot 10, bought by SpinkDNW, 28 September 2006, lot 580
Illustrated on the back cover and in The Art of Coins and their Photography by GeraldHoberman.
447
447 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 37
x448 James I (1603-1625), second coinage, Angel, 4.65g, m.m. cinquefoil, IACOBVS D G MABRI FR ET HI REX, St Michael vanquishing Satan, rev. A DNO FACTVM EST ISTVD, I and roseabove shield within ship (N.2081; S.2615), slightly double struck on obverse and a lightscratch on the reverse, well struck and about extremely fine £5,000-6,000
PROVENANCE:R C Lockett, Glendining, 11 October 1956, lot 2080Sotheby, 19 April 1993, lot 44St James’s auction 7, 8 February 2008, lot 120
Page 38
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
448
448 (x2)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:22 Page 38
x449 James I (1603-1625), second coinage 1604-05, Unite, 10.12g, m.m lis, IACOBVS D GMAG BRIT FRAN ET HIB REX, half-length crowned bust right, wearing decorated armour,holding orb and shouldering sceptre, rev. FACIAM EOS IN GENTEM VNAM crowned shielddividing I-R (Schneider 22; N.2083, S.2618), extremely fine £3,000-4,000
PROVENANCE:St James’s auction 12, 5 November 2009, lot 422
39
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
449
449 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:23 Page 39
x450 James I (1603-1625), second coinage, Unite, 9.94g, m.m. rose, IACOBVS D G MAG BRITFRAN ET HIB REX, fourth bust crowned right, wearing plain armour, holding orb andshouldering sceptre, rev. FACIAM EOS IN GENTEM VNAM, crowned shield dividing I-R(N.2084; S.2619), extremely fine £2,500-3,000
PROVENANCE:Clarendon collection, Bonham’s, 29 March 2006, lot 1124St James’s auction 6, 8 June 2007, lot 118
Page 40
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
450
450 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:23 Page 40
x451 James I (1603-1625), third coinage, Rose Ryal, 12.48g, m.m. spur rowel, IACOBVS D GMA BRI FR ET HIB REX, king enthroned holding orb and sceptre, back of throne garnishedwith semée of thistles, portcullis at feet, rich pattern of roses and lis in field, rev. A DNOFACTVM EST ISTVD ET EST MIRAB IN OC NRI, shield over cross fleury, value XXX above, withincircle decorated with lis, lions and roses (Schneider 77, same dies; N.2108; S.2632), tinyscratches above shield on reverse under a deep reddish/gold tone, with strong and detailedportrait, a very handsome example of this splendid work of art, almost extremely fine, rare £20,000-25,000
PROVENANCE:Stack’s, 30 January 1958, lot 218H J Bareford, Stack’s, 22 October 1981, lot 497Spink auction 107, 22 November 1994, lot 55Samuel King, Spink auction 167, 5 May 2005, lot 65. Noted as ‘superb’ in post-salecommentary
41
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
451
451 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:23 Page 41
Page 42
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
x452 James I (1603-1625), third coinage 1619-25, Rose Ryal of Thirty Shillings, m.m. trefoil,IACOBVS D G MA BRI FR ET HI REX, king enthroned facing, plain back to throne, rev. A DNOFACTVM EST ISTVD ET EST MIRA IN OC NRIS, shield on rose (Schneider 78 same dies;N.2108; S.2633), lustrous, on a full flan with complete legends, and lovely original colour,sharply detailed on the king’s face, rare in this condition. NGC graded MS-63 £20,000-25,000
PROVENANCE:Beresford Jones, Spink auction 29, 2 June 1983, lot 93Dr Jacob Y. Terner collectionGoldberg ‘Millennia’ collection, 26 May 2008, lot 299
452
452 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:23 Page 42
x453 James I (1603-1625), third coinage, Spur Ryal, 6.23g, m.m. spur rowel, IACOBVS D GMAG BRIT FRA ET HI REX, crowned lion facing, supporting shield and holding scepter, withvalue X-V at sides, rev. A DNO FACTVM EST ISTVD ET EST MIRABI, rose on spur rowel in centreof royal cross, crowned lions in angles (Schneider 79 (same dies); N.2109; S.2634), verylightly creased, small scratch on lion’s crown, otherwise almost extremely fine, extremely wellstruck, very rare £30,000-40,000
PROVENANCE:H P Hall, Glendining, 26-27 July 1950, lot 106, collection purchased en bloc by Spinkprior to the saleSpink Numismatic Circular, January 1974, no. 184Spink auction 176, 30 November 2005, lot 467
The Spur Ryals tend to come in nice condition but are often very creased. This coin isexceptional as it is only slightly creased. It is graded as being almost extremely fine astechnically it does exhibit some wear in parts. However, in other parts it is extremely wellstruck, such as on the lion and particularly on the paw, which is one of the highest points onthe coin. There are only four ‘true’ extremely fine coins extant, or at least on the market inthe last 40 years, whereas the others tend to be almost extremely fine at best and very creased
43
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
453
453 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:23 Page 43
x454 James I (1603-1625), third coinage, Laurel, 8.82g, m.m. spur rowel both sides, IACOBVSD G MA BRI FRAN ET HIBER REX, first, laureate bust left, rev. FACIAM EOS IN GENTEM VNAM,crowned shield over long cross fleury, m.m. to left of crown (Schneider 82; N.2111;S.2637), a full round specimen, very fine, rare £2,000-2,500
PROVENANCE:Spink auction 181, 30 March 2006, lot 1030
Page 44
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
x455 James I (1603-1625), third coinage, Laurel, 8.95g, m.m. spur rowel, IACOBVS D G MAGBRI FRAN ET HIB REX, second laureate bust left, mark of value behind, rev. FACIAM EOS INGENTEM VNAM, crowned shield on long cross fleury, m.m. to left of crown (Schneider 83;N.2112; S.2638), extremely fine with superb portrait £3,000-4,000
PROVENANCE:St James’s auction 6, 8 June 2007, lot 124
454
454 (x1.5)
455
455 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:23 Page 44
x456 James I (1603-1625), third coinage, Laurel, 9.14g, m.m. lis, IACOBVS D G MAG BRI FRANET HIB REX, fourth laureate bust left, rev. FACIAM EOS IN GENTEM VNAM, crowned shieldon long cross fleury, m.m. to left of crown (Schneider 86; N.2114; S.2638C), lovely oldgold colour, lustre subdued but distinct, pleasing portrait, better than most of this issue,slightly short of flan, but with legends nearly complete to the outer ends of the lettering,extremely fine £1,500-2,000
PROVENANCE:St James’s auction 7, 8 February 2008, lot 126
45
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
x457 James I (1603-1625), third coinage, Half-Laurel, m.m. spur rowel, IACOBVS D G MAGBRIT FRA ET HIBER REX, laureate armored bust left, value X behind, rev. HENRICVS ROSASREGNA IACOBVS, crowned shield on long cross fleury (N.2116; S.2640), crisp portrait,NGC graded MS-61 £1,500-2,000
PROVENANCE:Cheshire collection, Goldberg auction 31, 30 May 2005, lot 2143Goldberg auction 41, 30 May 2007, lot 4489
456
456 (x1.5)
457
457 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:23 Page 45
x459 Charles I (1625-1649), Unite, Tower mint, Group C, m.m. plume, CAROLVS D G MAGBRIT FR ET HIB REX, third high-crowned bust left, rev. FLORENT CONCORDIA REGNA,crowned and garnished oval shield dividing C-R (N.2150; S.2690), lustrous, a splendidexample, unusually round, full flan, the legends all sharp, with full outer beading, welldetailed on portrait, reddish gold surfaces, NGC graded AU-58 £5,000-6,000
PROVENANCE:Glendinings, 24 November 1976, lot 159Dr Jacob Y. Terner collectionGoldberg ‘Millennia’ collection, 26 May 2008, lot 302
Page 46
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
x458 James I (1603-1625), third coinage 1621-23, Gold Crown or Quarter-Laurel, 2.26g,m.m. thistle, IACOBVS D G MAG BRI FR ET HI REX, second laureate bust left, mark of valuebehind, rev. HENRICVS ROSAS REGNA IACOBVS, shield on long cross fleury, m.m. after REGNA(Schneider 95-96; N.2118; S.2642), extremely fine, rare £800-1,000
PROVENANCE:St James’s auction 12, 5 November 2009, lot 430
459
459 (x1.5)
458
458 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:23 Page 46
x460 Charles I (1625-1649), Unite, 9.17g, Tower mint, group C, class IIa, Unite, m.m. rose(over plume on obv.), CAROLVS D G MAG BRIT FR ET HIB REX, crowned bust left, wearingarmour and ruff, rev. FLORENT CONCORDIA REGNA, crowned oval shield dividing C-R(Schneider 140; Brooker 71, this coin; N.2150; S.2690), legends weak in places, otherwisegood very fine with an exceptionally well struck portrait £3,000-4,000
PROVENANCE:V J E Ryan, Glendining, 28-30 June 1950, lot 447J.A.M. Patrick collection, collection purchased by Spink 1954J.G. Brooker collection, collection purchased by Spink 1986DNW, 29 September 2006, lot 588
47
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
x461 Charles I (1625-1649), Unite, 8.95g, Tower mint, group D, class IIa/IIb, Unite, m.m.bell (large on obv., small on rev.), CAROLVS D G MA BR FR ET HI REX, crowned bust leftwering falling lace collar, value XX behind, rev. FLORENT CONCORDIA REGNA, crowned ovalshield dividing crowned C-R (Schneider 151; SCBI Brooker 89, this coin; N.2153; S. 2692), extremely fine £3,500-4,000
PROVENANCE:Helen Farquhar, Glendining, 25 April 1955, lot 10J.G. Brooker collection, collection purchased by Spink 1986DNW, 28 September 2006, lot 590
460
460 (x1.5)
461
461 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:23 Page 47
x462 Charles I (1625-1649), Unite, 8.99g, Tower mint, group D, class IIa/IIb, m.m. (p),CAROLVS D G MAG BRI FRA ET HIB REX, crowned bust left wearing falling lace collar, rev.FLORENT CONCORDIA REGNA, crowned oval shield dividing crowned C-R (Schneider 160;SCBI Brooker 117, this coin; N.2153; S.2693), double-struck, otherwise very fine, very rare £3,500-4,500
PROVENANCE:Glendining, 15 October 1985, lot 308Glendining, 19-20 June 1990, lot 876DNW, 29 September 2006, lot 591
Page 48
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
x463 Charles I (1625-1649), Unite, 8.96g, Tower mint, m.m. bell, CAROLVS D G MA BR FR ETHIB REX, fourth crowned bust left, wearing lace collar, mark of value behind, rev. FLORENTCONCORDIA REGNA, crowned, oval, garnished shield, dividing crowned C-R (Schneider151; N.2153; S.2692), almost extremely fine with an excellent portrait £1,800-2,200
PROVENANCE:St. James’s auction 4, 8 May 2006, lot 338
462
462 (x1.5)
463
463 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 10:23 Page 48
x464 Charles I (1625-1649), Oxford, Triple Unite, 26.96g, 1642, on a larger module flan,m.m. Oxford plume, CAROLVS: D:G: MAG: BRIT: FRAN: ET: HI: REX, improvised ‘Shrewsbury’crowned half-length bust of king left, in armour, holding sword and olive branch, plumesbehind, rev. .EXVRGAT: DEVS: DISSIPENTVR: INIMICI, declaration RELIG: PROT LEGI: ANGLIBER: PAR in three lines on continuous scroll, value and three plumes above, date below(B-J dies III/L1; cf. Schneider 287 (same obv. die); N.2382; S.2724), an imposing andmost handsome coin, on a full round flan, with attractive golden tone, and a strong portrait,almost extremely fine, very rare with declaration on continuous scroll £50,000-70,000
PROVENANCE:Glendining, 19 May 1964, lot 314, described as ‘in beautiful state’R Strauss, Sotheby, 26 May 1994, lot 101Samuel King, Spink auction 173, 5 May 2005 lot 76. Noted as ‘magnificent’ in post-sale commentary
49
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
464
464 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 11:50 Page 49
CHARLES I OXFORD TRIPLE UNITE 1643
An exceptional coin of great rarity and with a British Royal provenance
Page 50
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
465
465 (x1.5)
x465 Charles I (1625-1649), Oxford, Triple Unite, 27.09g, 1643, m.m. Oxford plume,CAROLVS: D:G: MAG: BRIT: FRAN: ET: HI: REX, improvised ‘Shrewsbury’ crowned half-lengthbust of king left, in armour, holding sword and olive branch, plumes behind, rev..EXVRGAT: DEVS: DISSIPENTVR: INIMICI, declaration RELIG: PROT LEG: ANG LIBER: PAR inthree lines on continuous scroll, value and three plumes above, date below (B-J III/L2;Schneider 288 (plate 23); Brooker 834A (plate CXXVI); N.2382; S. 2725), a well struckobverse with a crisp and detailed portrait, good extremely fine, extremely rare, one of onlythree known examples, and an exceptionally rare example of a coin in a private collectionwith a British Royal provenance £80,000-100,000PROVENANCE:Property of King Edward VIIGiven by the King to Dr Sir Maurice Holzmann, GCVO, CB (1835-1909),Comptroller of the Duchy of Cornwall and Personal Private Secretary to H.M. the KingSir Maurice Holzmann in London, Sammlung von neuren Goldmünzen und Thalern,Adolf Hess, Frankfurt am Main, 31 January 1910, lot 760 (illustrated) (purchased byHess for H Vogel)Geheimrat Hermann Vogel, Adolf Hess, Frankfurt am Main, 16 April 1928, lot 4907(purchased by Spink for Lt Col Taylor)Lt Col Taylor collection purchased by Spink 1936V J E Ryan, Glendining, 28 June 1950, lot 516. The provenance cited in Ryan salecatalogue. At that time there was no other example known of this early bust with the1643 date. The coin fetched £250, in contrast to the common types in the samecondition at £80-100 in same sale.Privately acquired by Dr Broughton, 1 July 2008
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 11:50 Page 50
51
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
There are only four known Triple Unites with the obverse used for the 1642 coinage combinedwith a reverse dated 1643 (Schneider 288, 289). Of these, three have the L2 reverse, and onehas the L3 reverse. This coin is one of three exceedingly rare examples with the L2 reverse. Theother two known examples with the L2 reverse are the Schneider example, formerly in theBrooker collection (Schneider 288), and the example in the British Museum. The fourth coindated 1643, with the L3 reverse, also resides in the Schneider collection (Schneider 289), andis unique. The 2009 edition of the Standard Catalogue was the first to differentiate betweenthe 1642 (S.2724) and 1643 dates (S.2725). Formerly both were designated S.2725. This isthe type coin for the catalogue differentiation.
The Royal Provenance is fascinating. Sir Maurice Holzmann was known to be a keennumismatist, and also in his sale (lot 732) was a box of three gold coins presented to him bythe staff of the Duchy of Cornwall. The catalogue description of lot 732 is as follows:
Pol. Kästchen mit Dedication vom ‘Staff of the Duchy of Cornwall’ enthaltend: A) Edward. Royal d’or von BordeauxB) Richard II. NobleC) Heinrich V. Noble.Schön
The three coins are illustrated on plate II (one of only four plates produced to illustrate theimpressive 4,480 lot sale) immediately above the 1643 Triple Unite. The lot was purchased bySpink for 300 Marks. It is not unreasonable to assume that the occasion for the presentationof this numismatic gift to Sir Maurice by the Staff of the Duchy of Cornwall may also havebeen the occasion for the Royal Gift.
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 11:50 Page 51
Page 52
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
x466 Charles I (1625-1649), Oxford, Unite, 1644, m.m. Oxford plume, CAROLVS D G MAG BRIFR ET HIB REX, short and wide crowned bust left, holding sword and branch, rev. EXVRGATDEVS DISSIPENTVR INIMICI, declaration RELIG: PROT: LEG: ANG: LIBER: PAR. in three lines oncontinuous scroll, three plumes above, date and OX below (Schneider 326 same dies;N.2389; S.2735), lustrous and choice, well-detailed example for issue, with reddish goldtoning, very rare in this grade, NGC graded AU-58 £10,000-12,000
PROVENANCE:Herman Selig, Spink auction 70, 31 May 1989, lot 149Dr Jacob Y. Terner collectionGoldberg ‘Millennia’ collection, 26 May 2008, lot 308
466
466 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 11:50 Page 52
53
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
x467 Commonwealth (1649-1660), Unite, 9.08g, 1651, m.m. sun, THE COMMONWEALTH OFENGLAND, shield of St. George within a wreath formed of a palm and laurel branch, rev.GOD WITH VS, conjoined shields of St. George and Ireland, XX above (cf. Schneider 341;N.2715; S.3208), extremely fine £8,000-10,000
PROVENANCE:Purchased from Spink, 14 February 2007
467
467 (x1)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 11:50 Page 53
Page 54
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
x468 Commonwealth (1649-1660), Unite, 9.01g, 1652, m.m. sun, THE COMMONWEALTH OFENGLAND, shield of St. George within a wreath formed of a palm and laurel branch, rev.GOD WITH VS, conjoined shields of St. George and Ireland, XX above (cf. Schneider 341;N.2715; S.3208), extremely fine, scarce date £10,000-12,000
POVENANCE:Spink auction 107, 22 November 1994, lot 84St James’s auction 12, 5 November 2009, lot 451
468
468 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 11:50 Page 54
55
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
x469 Commonwealth (1649-1660), Unite, 9.16g, 1653, m.m. sun, THE COMMONWEALTH OFENGLAND, shield of St. George within a wreath formed of a palm and laurel branch, rev.GOD WITH VS, conjoined shields of St. George and Ireland, XX above (cf. Schneider 341;N.2715; S.3208), a pleasing coin, with hints of red lustre, almost extremely fine £5,000-6,000
PROVENANCE:November 1942: Spink Numismatic Circular, November 1942, no.16791Marshall collection, Spink auction 167, 31 March 2004, lot 27
469
469 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 11:50 Page 55
Page 56
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
x470 Commonwealth (1649-1660), Unite, 8.98g, 1654, m.m. sun, THE COMMONWEALTH OFENGLAND, shield of St. George within a wreath formed of a palm and laurel branch, rev.GOD WITH VS, conjoined shields of St. George and Ireland, XX above (cf. Schneider 341;N.2715; S.3208), almost extremely fine £6,000-8,000
PROVENANCE:St James’s auction 7, 8 February 2008, lot 170
470
470 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 11:50 Page 56
57
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
x471 Commonwealth (1649-1660), Unite, 9.02g, 1660, m.m. anchor, THE COMMONWEALTHOF ENGLAND, shield of St. George within a wreath formed of a palm and laurel branch,rev. GOD WITH VS, conjoined shields of St. George and Ireland, XX above (cf. Schneider347; N.2716, S. 3209), usual slightly irregular flan, slightly double struck in places, anexceptional example, superb extremely fine, extremely rare £30,000-40,000
PROVENANCE:H C Dangar, Glendining, 15 April 1953, lot 132Sotheby, 24 March 1988, lot 722Spink auction 190, 27 September 2007, lot 594
471
471 (x2)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 11:50 Page 57
Page 58
WWW.SPINK.COM
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
x472 Commonwealth (1649-1660), Double-Crown of 10 Shillings, 4.55g, 1650, m.m. sun,THE COMMONWEALTH OF ENGLAND, shield of St. George within wreath, rev. GOD WITH VS,conjoined shields of England and Ireland, X above (Schneider 349; N.217; S.3210), choiceextremely fine and about uncirculated, wholly round and totally lustrous, precisely struck anddetailed, a beautiful specimen, in mint state, rare in this condition £15,000-20,000
PROVENANCE:H Montagu, Sotheby, 13 November 1896, lot 669 (illustrated)B Roth, Sotheby, 19 July 1917, lot 334R C Lockett, Glendining, 11 October 1956, lot 2596George Gund III, Stack’s, New York, 15 January 2007, lot 3614
472
472 (x2)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 11:50 Page 58
59
March 22, 2016 - LONDON
x473 Commonwealth (1649-1660), Gold Crown, 2.21g, 1652/0, m.m. sun, THECOMMONWEALTH OF ENGLAN, shield of St. George within a wreath formed of a palm andlaurel branch, rev. GOD WITH VS, conjoined shields of St. George and Ireland, V above(Schneider 360; N.2719, S.3212), extremely fine or better on a perfectly round flan £8,000-10,000
PROVENANCE: Bridgewater House, Sotheby, 15-16 June 1972, lot 120Clarendon collection, Bonham’s, 17 October 2006, lot 1519St James’s auction 6, 8 June 2007, lot 167
x474 Charles II (1660-1685), first issue, Unite, 8.96g, m.m. crown on obverse, CAROLVS II DG MAG BRIT FRAN ET HIB REX, laureate and draped bust left, rev. FLORENT CONCORDIAREGNA, crowned oval shield dividing C-R (Schneider 371 dies O3/R4; N.2753; S.3301),good very fine, a full round coin with attractive reddish tone, rare £6,000-8,000
PROVENANCE:Spink auction 54, 20 June 1986, lot 615DNW, 14 March 2007, lot 1569
END OF THE SALE
473
473 (x2)
474
474 (x1.5)
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 11:50 Page 59
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 11:50 Page 60
TEL. HOME ______________________________________________ TEL. OFFICE ____________________________________________
FAX ____________________________________________________ E-MAIL ________________________________________________
SIGNATURE _______________________________________________ VAT NUMBER ___________________________________________
Please indicate the type of card: VISA VISA DEBIT MASTERCARD SWITCH AMERICAN EXPRESS
PAYMENTS MADE BY MASTERCARD OR VISA ARE SUBJECT TO A 2% FEE, AMERICAN EXPRESS 4% AND UK DEBIT CARD £3
CARD NO: START DATE: ISSUE NO: SECURITY CODE:
SIGNATURE EXPIRY DATE NAME (ON CREDIT CARD)
Please charge all purchases to my card
Do not charge my card. I will arrange to send payment. (Spink will only charge your card should you default on the payment terms agreed)
Please hold my purchased lots for collectionContinued ...
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– #
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
– –
SALE TITLE DATE CODE NAME SALE NO.
The Dr Paul Broughton Collection Tuesday 22 March 2016 BROUGHTON 16014of English Hammered Gold Coins at 2.00 p.m.
I request Spink, without legal obligations of any kind on its part, to bid on the following Lots up to the price given below. I understand that if my bid is successful the Purchase Price will be the sum of the final bid and Buyer’s premium as a percentage of the final bid, any VAT chargeable, also a fee for bidding on the-saleroom.com onlyand fee for paying by card. The Rate of Premium is 20% of the final hammer price of each lot. I understand Spink will pursue me for payment for any successful bid. In addition, I understand and consent that Spink may share my personal details relating to the default with other auction houses and live bidding platforms to protectthemselves from such defaults.
All bids shall be treated as offers made on the Terms and Conditions for Buyers printed in the catalogue. I also understand that Spink provides the service of executingbids on behalf of clients for the convenience of clients and that Spink will not be held responsible for failing to execute bids. If identical commission bids are received forthe same Lot, the commission bid received first by Spink will take precedence. Please note that you will not be notified if there are higher written bids received.
PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY IN BLOCK LETTERS AND ENSURE THAT BIDS ARE IN STERLING
Lot Number(in numerical order)
Price Bid £(excluding Buyer’s Premium)
Lot Number(in numerical order)
Price Bid £(excluding Buyer’s Premium)
Lot Number(in numerical order)
Price Bid £(excluding Buyer’s Premium)
69 Southampton Row, Bloomsbury,London WC1B 4ETtel: +44 (0)20 7563 4005fax: +44 (0)20 7563 4037email: [email protected]
YOU CAN ALSO BID IN REAL TIME ON SPINK LIVE. JUST VISIT WWW.SPINK.COM, REGISTER AND LOG
INTO THE SALE.
WRITTEN BIDS FORM
This form should be sent or faxed to theSpink auction office in advance of the sale.References for new clients should besupplied in good time to be taken upbefore the sale. Bids received later thanone hour before the start of the sale maynot be processed.
NAME ______________________________________________________
ADDRESS ____________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________
POSTCODE ___________________________________________________
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 11:50 Page 61
PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY IN BLOCK LETTERS AND ENSURE THAT BIDS ARE IN STERLING
REFERENCES REQUIRED FOR CLIENTS NOT YET KNOWN TO SPINK
TRADE REFERENCES ________________________________________________________________________________________
BANK REFERENCES _____________________________________________________________________________________________________
Lot Number(in numerical order)
Price Bid £(excluding Buyer’s Premium)
Lot Number(in numerical order)
Price Bid £(excluding Buyer’s Premium)
Lot Number(in numerical order)
Price Bid £(excluding Buyer’s Premium)
DATE SALE NO.
Tuesday 22 March 2016 16014at 2.00 p.m.
VAT is chargeable on the Hammer price andthe Buyer’s premium of daggered (†) and (Ω)lots at the standard rate (currently 20%), andon lots marked (x) at the reduced rate(currently 5% on the Hammer price and 20%on the Buyer’s premium). VAT on MarginScheme lots (identified by the absence of anyVAT symbol next to the lot number) ispayable at 20% on the Buyer’s premium only.
BIDDING INCREMENTSBidding generally opens below the low estimate and advances in the following orderalthough the auctioneer may vary the bidding increments during the course of theauction. The normal bidding increments are:
Up to £100 by £5£100 to £300 by £10£300 to £600 £320-£350-£380-£400 etc.£600 to £1,000 by £50
£1,000 to £3,000 by £100£3,000 to £6,000 £3,200-£3,500-£3,800-£4,000 etc.£6,000 to £20,000 by £500£20,000 and up Auctioneer’s discretion
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 11:50 Page 62
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 11:50 Page 63
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 11:50 Page 64
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 11:50 Page 65
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 11:50 Page 66
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 11:50 Page 67
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 11:50 Page 68
TERMS AND CONDITIONS FOR BUYERSThese conditions set out the terms on which we (Spink and Son Limited of 69 Southampton Row, Bloomsbury London WC1B 4ET (company no. 04369748)) contractwith you (Buyer) either as agent on behalf of the Seller or as principal if we are the Seller. You should read these conditions carefully.
January/16
1 DEFINITIONS The following definitions apply in these conditions:Auctioneers’ Margin Scheme means a VAT margin scheme as defined by HM Revenue & Customs;Buyer’s Premium means the charge payable by you as a percentage of the Hammer Price, at the rates set out in clause 5.1 below; Certificate of Authenticity means a certificate issued by an Expert Committee confirming the authenticity of a Lot; Expert Committee means a committee of experts to whom a Lot may be sent for an extension in accordance with clause 3.4.3; Forgery means a Lot constituting an imitation originally conceived and executed as a whole with a fraudulent intention to deceive as to
authorship, origin, age, period, culture or source where the correct description as to such matters is not reflected by the descriptionin the catalogue and which at the date of the auction had a value materially less than it would have had if it had been in accordancewith the description in the catalogue. Accordingly, no Lot shall be capable of being a Forgery by reason of any damage and/orrestoration work of any kind (including re-enamelling);
Hammer Price means the amount of the highest bid accepted by the auctioneer in relation to a Lot;Lot means any item deposited with us for sale at auction and, in particular, the item or items described against any Lot number in any
catalogue;Reserve the amount below which we agree with the Seller that the Lot cannot be sold;Seller means the owner of the Lot being sold by us; Spink Group Spink and Son Limited, our subsidiaries and associated companies.VAT value added tax chargeable under VAT and any similar replacement or additional tax; andVAT Symbols means the symbols detailing the VAT status of the Lot details of which are set out at the back of the catalogue.
2 SPINK’S ROLE AS AGENT
2.1 All sales undertaken by us either at auction or privately are undertakeneither as agent on behalf of the Seller or from time to time, as principalif we are the owner of the Lot. Please note that even if we are acting asagent on behalf of the Seller rather than as principal, we may have afinancial interest in the Lot.
2.2 The contract for the sale of the Lot will be between you and the Seller.
3 BEFORE THE SALE3.1 Examination of goods
You are strongly advised to examine personally any goods in which youare interested, before the auction takes place. Condition reports areusually available on request. We provide no guarantee to you otherthan in relation to Forgeries, as set out in clause 5.13 of these Termsand Conditions.
3.2 Catalogue descriptions3.2.1 Statements by us in the catalogue or condition report, or made
orally or in writing elsewhere, regarding the authorship, origin,date, age, size, medium, attribution, genuineness, provenance,condition or estimated selling price of any Lot are merelystatements of opinion, and are not to be relied on as statements ofdefinitive fact. Catalogue and web illustrations are for guidanceonly, and should not be relied on either to determine the tone orcolour of any item. No lot shall be rejected on the grounds ofinaccurate reproduction. No lot illustrated in the catalogue andonline shall be rejected on the grounds of cancellation, centring,margins, perforation or other characteristics apparent from theillustration. Estimates of the selling price should not be relied on asa statement that this price is either the price at which the Lot willsell or its value for any other purpose.
3.2.2 Many items are of an age or nature which precludes their beingin perfect condition and some descriptions in the catalogue or givenby way of condition report make reference to damage and/orrestoration. We provide this information for guidance only and theabsence of such a reference does not imply that an item is free fromdefects or restoration nor does a reference to particular defectsimply the absence of any others.
3.2.3 Other than as set out in clause 5.13, and in the absence of fraud,neither the Seller nor we, nor any of our employees or agents, areresponsible for the correctness of any statement as to theauthorship, origin, date, age, attribution, genuineness orprovenance of any Lot nor for any other errors of description or forany faults or defects in any Lot. Every person interested shouldexercise and rely on his own judgment as to such matters.
3.3 Your ResponsibilityYou are responsible for satisfying yourself as to the condition of thegoods and the matters referred to in the catalogue description.
3.4 Extensions – Stamps only3.4.1 If you wish to obtain an expert opinion or Certificate of
Authenticity on any Lot (other than a mixed Lot or Lot containingundescribed stamps) you must notify us in writing not less thanforty-eight hours before the time fixed for the commencement ofthe first session of the sale. If accepted by us, such request shall havethe same effect as notice of an intention to question thegenuineness or description of the Lot for the purposes of clause5.13 (Refund in the case of Forgery) of these Terms andConditions and the provisions of clause 5.13 (Refund in the case ofForgery) shall apply accordingly.
3.4.2 Notice of a request for an expert opinion or Certificate ofAuthenticity must give the reason why such opinion is required andspecify the identity of your proposed expert which will be subjectto agreement by us. We reserve the right, at our discretion, torefuse a request for an expert opinion or Certificate of Authenticityincluding (without limitation) where the proposed expert is notknown to us.
3.4.3 If we accept a request for an expert opinion or Certificate ofAuthenticity we will submit the Lot to the Expert Committee. Youacknowledge and accept that the length of time taken by an ExpertCommittee to reach an opinion will vary depending on thecircumstances and in any event is beyond our control.
3.4.4 We will not accept a request for an extension on account ofcondition. Any Lot described in the catalogue as having faults ordefects may not be returned even if an expert opinion or Certificateof Authenticity cites other faults or defects not included in thecatalogue description, other than in the case of a Forgery.
3.4.5 Should Spink accept a request for an extension under theforegoing provisions of this paragraph, the fact may be stated by theAuctioneer from the rostrum prior to the sale of the Lot.
3.4.6 It should be noted that any stamp accompanied by a Certificateof Authenticity is sold on the basis of that Certificate only and noton the basis of any other description or warranty as to authenticity.No request for an extension will be accepted on such a stamp andthe return of such a stamp will not be accepted.
3.4.7 If you receive any correspondence from the Expert Committeein relation to the Lot, including but not limited to a Certificate ofAuthenticity, you must provide us with copies of suchcorrespondence no later than 7 days after you receive suchcorrespondence.
4 AT THE SALE4.1 Refusal of admission
Our sales usually take place on our own premises or premises overwhich we have control for the sale, and we have the right, exercisableat our complete discretion, to refuse admission to the premises orattendance at an auction.
4.2 Registration before biddingYou must complete and sign a registration form and provideidentification before making a bid at auction. Please be aware that weusually require buyers to undergo a credit check.If you have not bid successfully with Spink in the past, or you areregistering with us for the first time, we reserve the right to require adeposit of up to 50% of the amount you intend to spend. Such depositwill be deducted from your invoice should you be successful. If you areunsuccessful at auction, your deposit will be returned by the samemeans it was paid to Spink.Some lots may be designated, prior to the auction, as “Premium Lots”,which means a deposit may be required before placing a bid on theitem for sale. Information will be posted on our website in such anevent.
4.3 Bidding as PrincipalWhen making a bid (whether such bids are made in person or byway of telephone bids operated by Spink, commission or online oremail bids), you will be deemed to be acting as principal and will beaccepting personal liability, unless it has been agreed in writing, at thetime of registration, that you are acting as agent on behalf of a thirdparty buyer acceptable to us.
4.4 Commission BidsIf you give us instructions to bid on your behalf, by using the formprovided in our catalogues or via our website, we shall use reasonableendeavours to do so, provided these instructions are received not laterthan 24 hours before the auction. If we receive commission bids on aparticular Lot for identical amounts, and at auction these bids are thehighest bids for the Lot, it will be sold to the person whose bid wasreceived first. Commission bids are undertaken subject to othercommitments at the time of the sale, and the conduct of the auctionmay be such that we are unable to bid as requested. Since this isundertaken as a free service to prospective buyers on the terms stated,we cannot accept liability for failure to make a commission bid. Youshould therefore always attend personally if you wish to be certain ofbidding.
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 11:50 Page 69
January/16
4.5 On-line BiddingWe offer internet services as a convenience to our clients. We will notbe responsible for errors or failures to execute bids placed on theinternet, including, without limitation, errors or failures caused by (i) aloss of internet connection by either party for whatever reason; (ii) abreakdown or problems with the online bidding software and/or (iii)a breakdown or problems with your internet connection, computer orsystem. Execution of on-line internet bids on www.spink.com andSpink Live is a free service undertaken subject to other commitments atthe time of the auction and we do not accept liability for failing toexecute an online internet bid or for errors or omissions in connectionwith this activity. Buyers who acquire lots on the-saleroom.com willhave a fee of 3% on the hammer price added to their invoice for usingthis facility.
4.6 Telephone BidsIf you make arrangements with us not less than 24 hours before thesale, we shall use reasonable endeavours to contact you to enable youto participate in bidding by telephone, but in no circumstances will webe liable to either the Seller or you as a result of failure to do so.
4.7 Currency ConverterAt some auctions, a currency converter will be operated, based on theone month forward rates of exchange quoted to us by Barclays BankPlc or any other appropriate rate determined by us, at opening on thedate of the auction. Bidding will take place in a currency determined byus, which is usually sterling for auctions held in London. The currencyconverter is not always reliable, and errors may occur beyond ourcontrol either in the accuracy of the Lot number displayed on theconverter, or the foreign currency equivalent of sterling bids. We shallnot be liable to you for any loss suffered as a result of you following thecurrency converter.
4.8 Video imagesAt some auctions there will be a video screen. Mistakes may occur in itsoperation, and we cannot be liable to you regarding either thecorrespondence of the image to the Lot being sold or the quality of theimage as a reproduction of the original.
4.9 Bidding IncrementsBidding generally opens below the low estimate and advances in thefollowing order although the auctioneer may vary the biddingincrements during the course of the auction. The normal biddingincrements are:
Up to £100 by £5£100 to £300 by £10£300 to £600 £320-£350-£380-£400 etc.£600 to £1,000 by £50£1,000 to £3,000 by £100£3,000 to £6,000 £3,200-£3,500-£3,800-£4,000 etc.£6,000 to £20,000 by £500£20,000 and up Auctioneer’s discretion
4.10 Bidding by Spink4.10.1 We reserve the right to bid on Lots on the Seller’s behalf up to
the amount of the Reserve (if any), which will never be above thelow estimate printed in the auction catalogue.
4.10.2 The Spink Group reserves the right to bid on and purchaseLots as principal.
4.11 The Auctioneer’s DiscretionThe auctioneer has the right at his absolute discretion to refuse any bidto advance the bidding in such manner as he may decide to withdrawor divide any Lot, to combine any two or more Lots and, in the case oferror or dispute, to put an item up for bidding again.
4.12 Successful BidSubject to the auctioneer’s discretion, the striking of his hammer marksthe acceptance of the highest bid, provided always that such bid ishigher than the Reserve (where applicable), and the conclusion of acontract for sale between you and the Seller.
4.13 After Sale Arrangements If you enter into any private sale agreements for any Lot with the Sellerwithin 60 days of the auction, we, as exclusive agents of the Sellerreserve the right to charge you the applicable Buyer’s Premium inaccordance with these Terms and Conditions, and the Seller acommission in accordance with the terms of the Seller’s agreement.
4.14 Return of Lot4.14.1 Once your bid has been accepted for a Lot then you are liable
to pay for that Lot in accordance with these Terms and Conditions.If there are any problems with a Lot then you must notify us within7 days of receipt of the Lot, specifying the nature of the problem.We may then request that the Lot is returned to us for inspection.Save as set out in clause 5.13, the cancellation of the sale of any Lotand the refund of the corresponding purchase price is entirely atour sole discretion. We will not normally exercise that discretion ifthe Lot is not received by us in the same condition that it was in atthe auction date.
4.14.2 No lot may be returned on account of condition if thecondition was stated by a third party grading company (including,but not limited to PCGS, NGC, ANACS, ICG, PMG, WBG).
5 AFTER THE AUCTION5.1 Buyer’s Premium and other charges
In addition to the Hammer Price, you must pay us the Buyer’sPremium at a rate of 20% of the final Hammer price of each lot, a feeof 3% on the hammer price total for using the-saleroom.com and a feefor paying by card.
5.2 Value Added TaxOther than in respect of Zero-rated Lots (o) VAT is chargeable on theHammer price and the Buyer’s premium of daggered (†) and (Ω) lotsat the standard rate (currently 20%), and on lots marked (x) at thereduced rate (currently 5% on the Hammer price and 20% on theBuyer’s premium). VAT on Margin scheme lots (identified by theabsence of any VAT symbol next to the lot number) is payable at 20%on the Buyer’s premium only.
5.3 VAT RefundsGeneral5.3.1 As we remain liable to account for VAT on all Lots unless they
have been exported outside the EU within 3 months of the date ofsale, you will generally be asked to deposit all amounts of VATinvoiced. However, if a Spink nominated shipper is instructed, thenany refundable VAT will not be collected. In all other cases creditswill be made when proof of export is provided. If you export theLot yourself you must obtain shipping documents from theShipping Department for which a charge of £50 will be made.
5.3.2 If you export the Lot you must return the valid proof of exportcertificate to us within 3 months of the date of sale. If you fail toreturn the proof of export certificate to us within such period andyou have not already accounted to us for the VAT, you will beliable to us for the full amount of the VAT due on such Lot and weshall be entitled to invoice you for this sum.
5.3.3 To apply for a refund of any VAT paid, the proof of exportcertificate must be sent to our Shipping Department clearly marked‘VAT Refund’ within 3 months of the date of sale. No payment willbe made where the total amount of VAT refundable is less than £50and Spink will charge £50 for each refund processed.
VAT Refunds - Buyers from within the EU5.3.4 VAT refunds are available on the Hammer Price and Buyer’s
Premium of Daggered (†) and Investment Gold (g) Lots. You mustcertify that you are registered for VAT in another EU country andthat the Lot is to be removed from the United Kingdom within 3months of the date of sale.
5.3.5 Where an EU buyer purchases a Lot on which import VAT hasbeen charged, no refund of VAT is available from us. It may bepossible to apply directly for a refund on form VAT 65 toHM Revenue & Customs Overeseas Repayment Section,Londonderry.
VAT Refunds – Buyers from outside the EU5.3.6 Where a Lot is included within the Auctioneers’ Margin Scheme
and evidence of export from the EU is produced within 3 monthsof the date of sale, the VAT on Buyer’s Premium may be refunded.
5.3.7 Where the Lot is marked as a Daggered (†) or Investment Gold(g) Lot the VAT charged on the Hammer Price may be refundedwhere evidence of export from the EU is produced within 3months of the date of sale. A refund of VAT charged on the Buyer’sPremium can also be made on receipt of proof of business as acollectibles dealer.
5.3.8 Where the Lot is marked as an Omega (Ω) Lot or an ImportVAT (x) Lot and evidence of export from the EU is producedwithin 3 months of the date of sale, the VAT charged on both theHammer Price and Buyer’s Premium may be refunded. Whererequired, we can advise you on how to export such Lots as a specificform of export evidence is required. Where we advise you on theexport of the Lots, please be aware that the ultimate responsibilityin respect of obtaining a valid proof of export certificate will lie withyou and we will not be responsible for your failure to obtain suchcertificate.
5.4 Payment5.4.1 You must provide us with your full name and permanent address
and, if so requested, details of the bank from which any paymentsto us will be made. You must pay the full amount due (comprisingthe Hammer Price, the Buyer’s Premium and any applicable VAT)within seven days after the date of the sale. This applies even if youwish to export the Lot and an export licence is (or may be)required.
5.4.2 You will not acquire title to the Lot until all amounts due have been paid in full. This includes instances where specialarrangements were made for release of Lot prior to full settlement.
5.4.3 Payment should be made in sterling by one of the followingmethods:II(i) Direct bank transfer to our account details of which are set
out on the invoice. All bank charges shall be met by you.Please ensure that your client number is noted on thetransfer.
i(ii) By cheque or bank draft made payable to Spink and Son Ltdand sent to Spink at 69 Southampton Row, Bloomsbury,London WC1B 4ET. Please note that the processing chargesfor payments made by cheques or bank drafts drawn on anon-U.K bank shall be met by you. Please ensure that theremittance slip printed at the bottom of the invoice isenclosed with your payment.
(iii) By Visa, Mastercard or American Express. Payments made byUK issued personal debit cards are subject to a £3 fee.Payments made by American Express are subject to a 4% fee.All other credit and debit card payments are subject to a feeof 2%. For all card payments there are limits to the amountswe will accept depending on the type of card being used andwhether or not the cardholder is present.
5.4.4 Payments should be made by the registered buyer and not bythird parties, unless it has been agreed at the time of registrationthat you are acting as an agent on behalf of a third party.
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 11:50 Page 70
5.5 InvoicesInvoices may consist of one or more pages and will show: Zero ratedLots (o); no symbol Lots sold under the Auctioneers’ Margin Scheme;Lots marked (g) special scheme Investment Gold; Daggered Lots (†),imported Lots marked (x) and (Ω), (e) Lots with Zero rated hammerfor EU VAT registered buyers.
5.6 Collection of Purchases5.6.1 Unless specifically agreed to the contrary, we shall retain lots
purchased until all amounts due to us, or to the Spink Group, havebeen paid in full. Buyers will be required to pay for their lots whenthey wish to take possession of the same, which must be within 7days of the date of the sale, unless prior arrangements have beenmade with Spink. Without prior agreement, lots will not be releaseduntil cleared funds are received with regard to payments made bycheque.
5.6.2 Unless we notify you to the contrary, items retained by us willbe covered in accordance with our policy which is available forinspection at our offices from the date of sale for a period of sevendays or until the time of collection, whichever is sooner. After sevendays or from the time of collection, whichever is the earlier, the Lotwill be entirely at your risk.
5.6.3 Our policy will not cover and we are unable to acceptresponsibility for damage caused by woodworm, changes inatmospheric conditions or acts of terrorism.
5.7 NotificationWe are not able to notify successful bidders by telephone. WhileInvoices are sent out by mail after the auction we do not acceptresponsibility for notifying you of the result of your bid. You arerequested to contact us by telephone or in person as soon as possibleafter the auction to obtain details of the outcome of your bids to avoidincurring charges for late payment.
5.8 Packing and handling5.8.1 We shall use all reasonable endeavours to take care when
handling and packing a purchased Lot but remind you that afterseven days or from the time of collection, whichever is sooner, theLot is entirely at your risk. Our postage charges are set out at theback of the catalogue.
5.8.2 It is the responsibility of the Buyer to be aware of any ImportDuties that may be incurred upon importation to the finaldestination. Spink will not accept return of any package in order toavoid these duties. The onus is also on the Buyer to be aware of anyCustoms import restrictions that prohibit the importation ofcertain collectibles. Spink will not accept return of the Lot(s) underthese circumstances. Spink will not accept responsibility for Lot(s)seized or destroyed by Customs.
5.8.3 If the Buyer requires delivery of the Lot to an address other thanthe invoice address this will be carried out at the discretion ofSpink.
5.9 Recommended packers and shippersIf required our shipping department may arrange shipment as youragent. Although we may suggest carriers if specifically requested, oursuggestions are made on the basis of our general experience of suchparties in the past and we are not responsible to any person to whomwe have made a recommendation for the acts or omissions of the thirdparties concerned.
5.10 Remedies for non-payment or failure to collect purchases5.10.1 If you fail to make payment within seven days of your stipulated
payment date set out in your invoice, we shall be entitled to exerciseone or more of the following rights or remedies:5.10.1.1 to charge interest at the rate of 2% per month compound
interest, calculated on a daily basis, from the date the fullamount is due;
5.10.1.2 to set off against any amounts which the Spink Group mayowe you in any other transaction the outstanding amountremaining unpaid by you;
5.10.1.3 we may keep hold of all or some of your Lots or otherproperty in the possession of the Spink Group until you havepaid all the amounts you owe us or the Spink Group, even if theunpaid amounts do not relate to those Lots or other property.Following fourteen days’ notice to you of the amountoutstanding and remaining unpaid, the Spink Group shall havethe right to arrange the sale of such Lots or other property. Weshall apply the proceeds in discharge of the amount outstandingto us or the Spink Group, and pay any balance to you;
5.10.1.4 where several amounts are owed by you to the SpinkGroup in respect of different transactions, to apply any amountpaid to discharge any amount owed in respect of any particulartransaction, whether or not you so direct;
5.10.1.5 to reject at any future auction any bids made by you or onyour behalf or obtain a deposit from you before accepting anybids.
5.10.2 If you fail to make payment within thirty-five days, we shall inaddition be entitled:
5.10.2.1 to cancel the sale of the Lot or any other item sold to youat the same or any other auction;
5.10.2.2 to arrange a resale of the Lot, publicly or privately, and, ifthis results in a lower price being obtained, claim the balancefrom you together with all reasonable costs including a 20%seller’s commission, expenses, damages, legal fees, commissionsand premiums of whatever kind associated with both sales orotherwise, incurred in connection with your failure to makepayment;
5.10.2.3 when reselling the Lot, place a notice in our cataloguestating that you successfully purchased the Lot at auction buthave subsequently failed to pay the Hammer Price of the Lot; or
5.10.2.4 take any other appropriate action as we deem fit.5.10.3 If you fail to collect within fourteen days after the sale, whether
or not payment has been made, you will be required5.10.3.1 to pay a storage charge of £2 per item per day plus any
additional handling cost that may apply. 5.10.3.2 you will not be entitled to collect the Lot until all
outstanding charges are met, together with payment of all otheramounts due to us.
5.11 Uses of default informationIf you fail to make payment for a Lot in accordance with these Terms andConditions:5.11.1 We reserve the right to refuse you the right to make bids for any
future auction irrespective of whether previous defaults havebeen settled; and
5.11.2 You consent to us disclosing details of such default to otherauctioneers and live bidding platforms, which will include yourname, address, nature of the default and the date of the default.
Auctioneers or live bidding platforms who receive details of the defaultmay rely on such information when deciding whether to enter into atransaction with you in the future.
5.12 Export Licence5.12.1 If required we can, at our discretion, advise you on the detailed
provisions of the export licensing regulations. Where we advise youin relation to export licensing regulations the ultimate responsibilityin respect of any export will lie with you and we will not beresponsible for your failure to apply for any necessary licences.
5.12.2 If the Lot is going to be hand carried by you, you may berequired to produce a valid export licence to us or sign a waiverdocument stating that a licence will be applied for.
5.12.3 You should always check whether an export licence is requiredbefore exporting. Export licences are usually obtained within twoor three weeks but delays can occur.
5.12.4 Unless otherwise agreed by us in writing, the fact that you wishto apply for an export licence does not affect your obligation tomake payment within seven days nor our right to charge interest onlate payment.
5.12.5 If you request that we apply for an export licence on yourbehalf, we shall be entitled to recover from you our disbursementsand out of pocket expenses in relation to such application, togetherwith any relevant VAT.
5.12.6 We will not be obliged to rescind a sale nor to refund anyinterest or other expenses incurred by you where payment is madeby you despite the fact that an export licence is required.
5.13 Refund in the case of Forgery5.13.1 A sale will be cancelled, and the amount paid refunded to you
if a Lot (other than a miscellaneous item not described in thecatalogue) sold by us proves to have been a Forgery. We shall nothowever be obliged to refund any amounts if either (a) thecatalogue description or saleroom notice at the auction datecorresponded to the generally accepted opinion of scholars orexperts at that time, or fairly indicated that there was a conflict ofopinions, or (b) it can be demonstrated that the Lot is a Forgeryonly by means of either a scientific process not generally acceptedfor use until after publication of the catalogue or a process which atthe date of the auction was unreasonably expensive or impracticableor likely to have caused damage to the Lot. Furthermore, youshould note that this refund can be obtained only if the followingconditions are met:5.13.1.1 you must notify us in writing, within seven days of the
receipt of the Lot(s), that in your view the Lot concerned is aForgery;
5.13.1.2 you must then return the item to us within fourteen daysfrom receipt of the Lot(s), in the same condition as at theauction date; and
5.13.1.3 as soon as possible following return of the Lot, you mustproduce evidence satisfactory to us that the Lot is a Forgery andthat you are able to transfer good title to us, free from any thirdparty claims.
5.13.1.4 you must provide to us all evidence obtained by you thata Lot is a Forgery no later than 7 days after you receive suchevidence.
5.13.2 In no circumstances shall we be required to pay you any morethan the amount paid by you for the Lot concerned and you shallhave no claim for interest.
5.13.3 The benefit of this guarantee is not capable of beingtransferred, and is solely for the benefit of the person to whom theoriginal invoice was made out by us in respect of the Lot when soldand who, since the sale, has remained the owner of the Lot withoutdisposing of any interest in it to any third party.
5.13.4 We shall be entitled to rely on any scientific or other process toestablish that the Lot is not a Forgery, whether or not such processwas used or in use at the date of the auction.
6 LIABILITY Nothing in these Terms and Conditions limits or excludes our liability for:6.1 death or personal injury resulting from negligence; or 6.2 any damage or liability incurred by you as a result of our fraud or
fraudulent misrepresentation.
January/16
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 11:50 Page 71
January/16
7 USE OF YOUR PERSONAL INFORMATION7.1 We will use the personal information you provide to us to:
7.1.1 process the bids you make on Lots (whether successful orotherwise) and other auction related services we provide;
7.1.2 process your payment relating to a successful purchase of a Lot;7.1.3 arrange for delivery of any Lot you purchase, which will include
passing your details to shipping providers and, on overseasdeliveries, to customs where they make enquiries regarding the Lot;
7.1.4 inform you about similar products or services that we provide,but you may stop receiving these at any time by contacting us.
7.2 In accordance with clause 4.2, you agree that we may pass yourinformation to credit reference agencies and that they may keep a recordof any search that they do.
7.3 In accordance with clause 5.11, you agree that where you default onmaking payment for a Lot in accordance with these terms and conditionswe may disclose details of such default to other auctioneers and livebidding platforms.
7.4 We are also working closely with third parties (including, for example,other auctioneers and live bidding platforms) and may receiveinformation about you from them.
8 COPYRIGHT 8.1 We shall have the right (on a non-exclusive basis) to photograph, video
or otherwise produce an image of the Lot. All rights in such an imagewill belong to us, and we shall have the right to use it in whatever waywe see fit.
8.2 The copyright in all images, illustrations and written material relatingto a Lot is and shall remain at all times our property and we shall havethe right to use it in whatever way we see fit. You shall not use or allowanyone else to use such images, illustrations or written material withoutour prior written consent.
9 VATYou shall give us all relevant information about your VAT status and that ofthe Lot to ensure that the correct information is printed in the catalogues.Once printed, the information cannot be changed. If we incur any unforeseencost or expense as a result of the information being incorrect, you willreimburse to us on demand the full amount incurred.
10 NOTICESAll notices given under these Terms and Conditions may be served personally,sent by 1st class post, or faxed to the address given to the sender by the otherparty. Any notice sent by post will be deemed to have been received on thesecond working day after posting or, if the addressee is overseas, on the fifthworking day after posting. Any notice sent by fax or served personally will bedeemed to be delivered on the first working day following despatch.
11 ADDITIONAL PROVISIONSThe following provisions of this clause 10 shall apply only if you are acting forthe purposes of your business. 11.1 Limitation of Liability
Subject to clause 6, we shall not be liable, whether in tort (includingfor negligence) or breach of statutory duty, contract, misrepresentationor otherwise for any:11.1.1 loss of profits, loss of business, depletion of goodwill and/or
similar losses, loss of anticipated savings, loss of goods, loss ofcontract, loss of use, loss of corruption of data or information; or
11.1.2 any special, indirect, consequential or pure economic loss,costs, damages, charges or expenses.
11.2 SeverabilityIf any part of these Terms and Condition is found by any court to beinvalid, illegal or unenforceable, that part may be discounted and therest of the conditions shall continue to be valid and enforceable to thefullest extent permitted by law.
11.3 Force majeureWe shall have no liability to you if we are prevented from, or delayedin performing, our obligations under these Terms and Conditions orfrom carrying on our business by acts, events, omissions or accidentsbeyond our reasonable control, including (without limitation) strikes,lock-outs or other industrial disputes (whether involving our workforceor the workforce of any other party), failure of a utility service ortransport network, act of God, war, riot, civil commotion, maliciousdamage, compliance with any law or governmental order, rule,regulation or direction, accident, breakdown of plant or machinery,fire, flood, storm or default of suppliers or subcontractors.
11.4 Waiver11.4.1 A waiver of any right under these Terms and Conditions is only
effective if it is in writing and it applies only to the circumstancesfor which it is given. No failure or delay by a party in exercising anyright or remedy under these Terms and Conditions or by law shallconstitute a waiver of that (or any other) right or remedy, norpreclude or restrict its further exercise. No single or partial exerciseof such right or remedy shall preclude or restrict the further exerciseof that (or any other) right or remedy.
11.4.2 Unless specifically provided otherwise, rights arising underthese Terms and Conditions are cumulative and do not excluderights provided by law.
11.5 Law and Jurisdiction11.5.1 These Terms and Conditions and any dispute or claim arising
out of or in connection with them or their subject matter, shall begoverned by, and construed in accordance with, the law of Englandand Wales.
11.5.2 The parties irrevocably agree that the courts of England andWales shall have exclusive jurisdiction to settle any dispute orclaim that arises out of, or in connection with, Terms andConditions or their subject matter.
Postal ChargesPrices for books(items sent by this method are not covered by insurance)
Prices for all other items including postage and packaging
Shipments of more than 2kg or volumetric measurement of more than 2kg have tobe sent by courier. Certain countries may incur extra charge when courier servicesare required by our insurance policy. For lots sent by courier please [email protected] for calculation of any further relevant cost in addition tothe above charges.
Value Added Tax (VAT)
Charging of (VAT) at AuctionThe information shown on this page sets out the way in which Spink intends toaccount for VAT.
i. Auctioneers’ Margin Scheme1. Where possible, we will offer Lots for sale under the Auctioneers’
Margin Scheme. Such Lots can be identified by the absence of anyVAT symbol next to the Lot number in the catalogue and will not besubject to VAT on the Hammer Price.
2. Where Lots are sold using the Auctioneers’ Margin Scheme to UKVAT–registered businesses, the VAT on Buyers’ Premium is notrecoverable as input tax. Upon request on sale day, we will issueinvoices that show VAT separately on both the Hammer Price andthe Buyer’s Premium. This will enable VAT-registered businesses torecover the VAT charged as input tax, subject to the normal rules forrecovering input tax.
ii. Zero-Rated LotsLimited Categories of goods, such as books, are Zero-rated (o) for VAT inthe United Kingdom. Such Lots are offered under the Auctioneers’ MarginScheme. In these circumstances no VAT will be added to the Buyer’spremium.
iii. Daggered LotsLots which are Daggered (†) in the catalogue are subject to VAT at 20%on both the Hammer Price and the Buyer’s Premium.
iv. Imported and Omega LotsLots which are marked (x) in the catalogue are subject to VAT at 5% onthe Hammer price plus 20% on the Buyer’s premium. Lots which bear theOmega symbol (Ω) are subject to VAT at 20% on the Hammer Price andon the Buyer’s Premium. This VAT is payable on items imported fromoutside the EU. In these cases we have used a temporary importationprocedure, which in effect means that the point of importation is deferreduntil the Lot has been sold. At this point the Buyer is treated as theimporter and is liable to pay the import VAT due. We will collect the VATfrom you and pay it to HM Customs and Excise on your behalf.
v. Investment Gold LotsLots marked (g) in the catalogue are exempt from VAT on the HammerPrice and are subject to VAT at 20% on the Buyer’s Premium. A refund ofVAT charged on the Buyer’s Premium can also be made on receipt of proofof business as a collectibles dealer outside of the EU.
Invoice Value UK EU Rest of the WorldUp to £1,500 £10 £15 £20
Up to £10,000 £20 £30 £40
Above £10,001 £20 £50 £60
Weight UK EU Rest of the WorldUp to 1kg £8 for any weight £12 £15
Up to 2kg £8 for any weight £18 £25
Spink 16014 Coin pages.qxp_Layout 1 18/02/2016 11:50 Page 72
GROUP CHAIRMAN AND CEO
Olivier D. Stocker
YOUR SPECIALISTS
STAMPS
UK - Tim Hirsch FRPSL Guy Croton David Parsons Nick Startup Neill GrangerPaul Mathews Dominic Savastano Tom Smith George James Ian Shapiro (Consultant)
USA - George Eveleth Richard DebneyEUROPE - Guido Craveri Fernando MartínezCHINA - Doris Lo George Yue (Consultant)
COINS
UK - Richard Bishop Tim Robson Malene Wagner Lawrence Sinclair Barbara Mears John PettUSA - Greg Cole Muriel Eymery Stephen Gol dsmith (Special Consultant)
CHINA - Kin Choi Cheung Paul Pei Po ChowBANKNOTES
UK - Barnaby Faull Andrew Pattison Monica Kruber Thomasina SmithUSA - Greg Cole Stephen Goldsmith (Special Consultant)
CHINA - Kelvin Cheung Paul Pei Po ChowORDERS, DECORATIONS, MEDALS & MILITARIA
UK - Mark Quayle Oliver Pepys John Hayward (Consultant)BONDS & SHARES
UK - Mike Veissid (Consultant) Andrew Pattison Thomasina SmithUSA - Greg Cole
EUROPE - Peter ChristenCHINA - Kelvin Cheung
BOOKS
UK - Philip Skingley Michael Hyman Nik von UexkullAUTOGRAPHS
USA - Greg Cole Stephen Goldsmith (Special Consultant)WINES
CHINA - Guillaume Willk-Fabia Angie Ihlo Fung
YOUR EUROPE TEAM (LONDON - LUGANO)
DirectorsTim Hirsch Anthony Spink
Auction & Client Management TeamMira Adusei-Poku Rita Ariete Grace Hawkins Dora Szigeti Tatyana Boyadzhieva Nik von Uexkull
John Winchcombe Maurizio ScheniniFinance
Alison Bennet Marco Fiori Mina Bhagat Dennis Muriu Hemel Thakore Veronica MorrisIT & Administration
Berdia Qamarauli Michael Addo Liz Cones Curlene SpencerTom Robinson Cristina Dugoni Giacomo Canzi
YOUR AMERICA TEAM (NEW YORK)
Managing DirectorCharles Blane
Auction Administration and Marketing & DesignPolona Hribovsek
Finance & AdministrationAmit Ramprashad
AuctioneerStephen Goldsmith (Special Consultant)
YOUR ASIA TEAM (HONG KONG - SINGAPORE)
AdministrationAngie Ihlo Fung Newton Tsang Sue Pui Arthur Chan Doris Lo Gary Tan
Ken Imase [email protected]
BANKNOTES
7 April The Numismatic Collector’s Series Sale Hong Kong CSS2112 April The Bruce Smart Collection of Middle East and North Africa London 1603712/13/14 April World Banknotes London 1600822/23 June The Numismatic Collector’s Series Sale New York 3245 July World Banknotes London 1600925 August The Numismatic Collector’s Series Sale Hong Kong CSS23
SALE CALENDAR 2016
The above sale dates are subject to change
Spink offers the following services:– VALUATIONS FOR INSURANCE AND PROBATE FOR INDIVIDUAL ITEMS OR WHOLE COLLECTIONS –
– SALES ON A COMMISSION BASIS EITHER OF INDIVIDUAL PIECES OR WHOLE COLLECTIONS –
STAMPS
23 February The Drs. Joanne and Edward Dauer Collection of Australian States and Commonwealth London 1603823 February The “Britannia” Collection of Barbados London 1602424 February India, The De La Rue Issues London 1602327-28 April The Philatelic Collector’s Series Sale London 16027May The Pre-New York 2016 Collector’s Series Sale New York 154June The Jose Castillejo Collection of Guatemala, 1871-86 New York 15511 June The Philatelic Collector’s Series Sale Hong Kong CSS1822 June Great Britain Stamps and Postal History London 160296-7 July The Philatelic Collector’s Series Sale London 1603013 July Autographs, Historical Documents, Ephemera and Postal History London 16043
COINS
22 March The Academic Collection of Lord Stewartby: English Coins part 1, Anglo-Saxon and Norman Coins London 16019
22 March The Dr Paul Broughton Collection of English Hammered Gold Coins London 1601422/23 March Ancient, British & Foreign Coins and Commemorative Medals London 160047 April The Numismatic Collector’s Series Sale Hong Kong CSS2112 May Ancient and World Coins including European Coins from the Peter Woodhead Collection London 1604222/23 June The Numismatic Collector’s Series Sale New York 32429 June The Academic Collection of Lord Stewartby: English coins part 2, Plantagenet,
Lancastrian and Yorkist Coins London 1602029/30 June Ancient, British & Foreign Coins and Commemorative Medals London 1600525 August The Numismatic Collector’s Series Sale Hong Kong CSS23
MEDALS
21 April Orders, Decorations, Campaign Medals & Militaria London 1600121 July Orders, Decorations, Campaign Medals & Militaria London 16002
BONDS & SHARES
7 April The Numismatic Collector’s Series Sale Hong Kong CSS2120 May Bonds & Share Certificates of the World London 1601722/23 June The Numismatic Collector’s Series Sale New York 32425 August The Numismatic Collector’s Series Sale Hong Kong CSS23
AUTOGRAPHS
22/23 June The Numismatic Collector’s Series Sale New York 32413 July Autographs, Historical Documents, Ephemera and Postal History London 16043
WINES
8 April An Evening of Great Whiskies and Spirits Hong Kong SFW1923 June An Evening of Great Whiskies and Spirits Hong Kong SFW20
Spink 16014 Coins cover.qxp_Layout 1 17/02/2016 18:30 Page 2
THE DR PAUL BROUGHTON COLLECTION
OF ENGLISH HAMMERED GOLD COINS
22 MARCH 2016
LONDON
© C
op
yri
ght
2016
2
35
TH
E D
R P
AU
L B
RO
UG
HT
ON
CO
LL
EC
TIO
N O
F E
NG
LIS
H H
AM
ME
RE
D G
OL
D C
OIN
S
22
MA
RC
H 2
01
6
LO
ND
ON
STAMPS COINS BANKNOTES MEDALS BONDS & SHARES AUTOGRAPHS BOOKS WINES
69 Southampton Row, Bloomsbury, London WC1B 4ETwww.spink.com
£25
Spink 16014 Coins cover.qxp_Layout 1 17/02/2016 18:30 Page 1