The Diffrent Bettween Aldarorah and Alhajah

download The Diffrent Bettween Aldarorah and Alhajah

of 54

description

بحث دقيق حول الفرق بين الضرورة والحاجة الشرعيتين

Transcript of The Diffrent Bettween Aldarorah and Alhajah

  • Gd H GdhQI hGdLJk Y H

    GC MG GC b Gd

    Gd Y Gd H Hq Y Gd GC hQhH dE aA hGd

  • H Gd GdM GdMGd d hGdI hGd Y Sf e hY GB d hU.

    ee``GE GE Y GdL a GC M GC U e Gd Gd j c e GdS,

    GC V GE d Pd GC GC c Gdj Gd GdUI SGAk J Gd hb Gd a eW Gde GC h J Gd JG eQI GC ee JL GE d GE Td Jj GdL

    hJj Gd Gd jC Y: g J HdhQI a M GC h J H?SGAk cf bj W J H Gd ek GC h GE LV, GC h bj GbOj

    J HdO GdjI e GE jQ j Hd GC h JC e HC fGY, GC h GC MGdc hGC S hYO GdQj hGdh GdGF GdaI Y GdaA H

    Gd. e j GC Jj Yb GdL HdhQI GC U eMk C b eGde Gd a Gd Gdj.

    hSC Mh GB - YOGk Y HA - GC GC f cf gG GdV C Y YGf hGC ZQa GC ZGQg hGC U a bf )hc Hd e e he(. hPd M Gd

    Gdd:1. Jj GdhQI:

    - d hGUMk : e fU Gdj hfU GC Ud hGdA.- GC U ehY GdhQI.

    2. Jj GdL:- d hGUMk : e fU Gdj hfU GC Ud hGdA e

    GC e a JR Gd H hH GdhQI.- GC U ehY GdL.

    121

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • 3. f Gdj: GdH Gd hGdGN Gd hGC Ud, eC GTGGC h Gd.

    4. Gd PG Gdb HV GdhQI hGdL.5. GE L Gdh H GdhQI hGdL HAk Y e Pcf e GdA

    hGC Ud hGdj.6. hGC NGk J eUI e bGQG Gd GC hQH dE aA he Gd

    GE Se HI e Gd Y g GdGQG.7. NJ J fF Gd.

    Jj GdhQI dk hGUMk :GdhQI a GU d KK em : Gd Gd GdU Gd j Gd

    hGd GSd GdS hg j GdL, hGd GC Ud.

    GdhQI d:b e Gdj GdhR GC HO a GdeS ehLk HM: )hGVGQ GM

    GE d GdA( hb )GV GE d( GC e )GC ML hGC dC aVo . H GdA( HhD GaL GdA WA C GdA d j d e GdO )hGS GdI( Hd. b

    OQj H Gd:hJ e VI Gd ebk hW Gdi OQ Y e

    GC JC dD Y. ha Mj Y QV Gd Y Qa GC f f Y H Gd. bGH GC K: hgG j e hL GC Mg GC j GE d Gd e Wj GE cG

    Y, b: "hgG H aS j, hGdf GC j GE d Gd dj Qc GC h eD fJg a e a j Hdc dhQI, hgG S a M Gdj hGdhAI GC

    jj Y gG GdL hd jo hjo V GE d GdI GC h Jo i S H aE

    122

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • Y Gd e GdhQI Y gG GdL U hd j e cGg GC g Gd d".he Gd gG GdGA GC h Gdj GC h b Gd.

    hbd Ys hLs : }a GVo s Z Hm h YOm | GC a GC o dA GE d GC c Gd heM hVq Y GC e Hd hGC U e GdQ hg Gd.

    )hGdhQI GdL( hj Y GdhQG )cdQhQI hGdQhQ hGdQhQGA(GC NG f GdZJ hGC f a Gd Y GdQhQI:

    GC K GC N VQhQI GC U Gdi Y hb a Gdj GC hGUhb Gd: GdhQI GS dQ GVGQ, J M GdhQI Y cG

    hcG.b: a gG GdhQI hGdI cg GS a GC hd GC j Gd

    cdI hGdhQI K j hg GC jk GdL Gd c j.ha Mj SI j e GdQhQI U GC h Z. GC GE f j d e

    Gd GC jC c e e j Gde e ZGA GC h YA hd d GC j H.)hGdQ( ec )Gd( j e Ph VQ GC Ph V. )J GdhS:

    3/943(.hGE f Pc gG Gd Y Wd d GdQiA Gd Gdj Gd cf hHh

    T Yek e YGe Jh GC bG GdA a e GdhQI. hb j eGd GC jq GE d H GC d Gd hQO a gG Gd dj GdhQI hg

    GM hGdL hGE dA hGd he j MaGk d e Oj jc Gd GC heD f Jg GC h GE cG j GC h L jD GC h GC YGA j Y c g Gdf

    Gd GC TQ GE d GC g Gd hg em J GE d GdI hGd hg Gd Of MdGdA c Si.

    123

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • GdhQI GUMk :hGdhQI a GU a hJ GE Wb GC Mg: VhQI bi J

    Gdq Si e GSo . hGdf: VhQI Oh Pd hg Gdq Y HdL GE qGC f j Y GdhQI a GS JSk , hZ Gd hJo VhQI

    GC Ud hg: GdhQI Gde Hd, hd GE e Gde e GC h e Gf GE d PdM b a Gdg: "GE GdhQI Y GC b, a J GdhQI fYk jg

    b c Pcf. hb J GdhQI GdA hd J Mk cq k a Gd,H j J a c T cC c Gd hW Gd )hg g GdhQI Gd

    J HdhQI Gd Hd GC N(. hGd Gdd e jJ a GC UHdhQI hd j Gd a GBMO hGC TU hgG cd he a e

    )Gdg: U 249(.hdGC a Jj GC b GdhQI:

    1- GdhQI Gd Hd GC N:Yq a GdW Hd: )adhQI HZ Mq Gk GE d jh Gd g GC h bQ

    hgG j Jh GdG( )GC T hGdF: U16(. hg g GdhQI Gd bY GE e Gde GC f J Mk ck a Gd H j J a c

    T cC c Gd hW Gd c GC S.b a e Gd hg "Ta": )e N e Y GC c Y f eJk GC h

    eVk eak GC h RjOJ GC h W eJ GC h GfY Y Qa GC h N V e GC hQc hd j Mk jC c hhL MGek de GC c(. Gde: GdQOj a Gd Gd

    "ed": )GdhQI g M GdS e Gd GC h TI GdQ( )GdQOj: 2/381(.haq GdQbf a TM GdhQI bFk : )hg N Gd Y Gd Yk GC h

    Xk ( GE q GC f H Pd f Y GdF Y GdSd bd: "hg M GVGQ N

    124

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • Gd GC h N GdV, b dd hGda". )GdQbf: 3/8(.Yq a GdU )M(: "g N GdQ GC h Gd Y Gd GC h H

    GC YA H GC c" )GC M GdGB: 1/591(.b GdW: GVGQ j GC j HE cG e Xd GC h H e e

    hGd Y GdQ e GdA hGdA a e GBj g e U Gd hGdhg Gd GE d Pd, hb e GC c hZ Y GC c g Gdq e. )GdW:

    2/522(.2- GdhQI Hd GSd Gd GdS hGd J GdL:

    b N: "hU b )GC Hh Gd( e GC U GC h GC d H GC h Y T b GE f hGV GC GM c a GdV Y Gd H Gd Gd j e

    GNQ". )GdQbf: 5/781(.he GS GdhQI hjo GO H GdL b GdRQ a Th GZQ GdQ

    Gd: b GH Ya: "RGO GdRQ c e Gd Z eO hVhQI GQJH,hbQ Hd e H GC L hLGR H Gd Gd bQ Mg Gd H

    hM hLGR GdGA d e GM f hJe hLGR ON Gd e bQeA GdS hd a hGd e Gdb GE LYk , a Gd Od Y GE dA e g

    j OY GdhQI d". GH Y Gd a RjOI GdRQ GE T hQO gG"GE T" GH Ya )Gdq G a Gd hGE c He Gd 4/563(. H

    Yq N HdL a g GdC d M b: "hGZ ZQ j dL d j")f GdL hGd(.

    hb fs Gdf a MT Y YQI GdRQ bFk : "hdG Yq GdRQ Y bGdL HdhQI hg GC N e GdL d Gd S" )MT Gdf Y

    GdQbf: 5/08(.

    125

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • he GS` H GdL e Gda UM fj Gd bFk : "fGC hd H e RGO Y e a Y cj heD f S hj e Y RGF Y Pd

    a Re GdhQI. hY e JQ GNU Jj GMQ HC bG" )2/74(.adhQI g GdL, C GVGQ GE PG J d j dd cj S M

    YQI GC H GdA GdGe a GdT Y f Gd.

    3- Gd GC Ud dhQI:dhQI e Kd g Gd GC Ud hfs Y GE e Gde a Gdg a

    Gd Gdd, hb Pcf. hb RGO GC e hVMk Ye b: hg j Gd eGdhQ hj H )GdhQ( J Gd aE GdS d d jOdG e HC jj

    dq Pd VhQI XgI a Gd GE PG GB GE d GdhQI GdGL GE d Gd hGdK b J a Gdj GC GC U GE PG K bGYg a f GE d W J a

    GBMO Gd. )U 329he Hg(.hb GC hV GdW HC f GE Mi Gd Gd Gd JL GE d eU Gdj

    M j: "aC e GdhQj ag GC f H e a b ed Gdj hGdfH GE PG a d J ed Gdf Y GSe H Y aO hJQ ha

    MI ha GC Ni a GdI hGd hGdL HdG Gd" hJ GdWY eGYI GdhQI e Lf GdLO heGYJ e Lf Gd hes dd

    HC U GdOG hGde )aGL: 2/89(.hgG g Gd Gdq Y HdhQ C f e VhQG SS Gdd hHF hGf

    GC MGd M YQI Gda )3/902(.hjq Y HdhQI Hd GE d Gd GdGb a e, a Pd b GdGd

    eKk Y Gd GdS: "hGE hb a eb GdhQI LR GC jD Oi GE dGLO e H GC J b c" )Gda: 3/112(. he b

    126

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • Gdcf: "GC f GE cf J Gd VhQj b c cf eI aE aGC M g GdK d J, hGdGO HdhQj GC J e GdhQj Gd

    hHd GC J L Gd, d cf d GdS Oh H GC h a MdeU Oh Md". )Gdcf: GE QTO Gd: U 242(.

    hb GdW: "e GdhQj N hg M Gdj hGd hGdhGd hGd" )GdGa: 3/01(.

    hGC e dPG So HdhQI? GE e C f VhQI f MI GdS c J, GC h C GYQg "Gd GE d e Y HdhQI cf eOI d Hd hGM

    H HC Od NQL Y Gd" )GE QTO Gd: U 242(.hb J GC c GC Ud Y GdhQI hGdhQ a GdV GdS GdS

    E K M Hd GdI GE d e Z GYQ GdS HhW, hGC MGd J Y GdF H, cd, GC M eI hg jC J Gd H GE q Y

    Z Gd.hb J GSA e Y c j Y GSO Gdd:

    b GdL: "hGN b ed a GdL jC J OGQ Gd aa GE d a hRfkhjC N e hRfk OQGg hj GC LI Gd. a eI: GC QL GC j Nk .

    hPc GH GdGR hQhG Y Y GH GdS he Pd Y H OjQ hM GHM Y LY e GC U ed, hH b GC H M hGda. hL QhGj

    GdGR Y GdGg e GM H e VhQI GdS GE d GdQGg hJQ Gd GE q aPd GdV e ML GdS GE d GS hGfR Gda dhQ e GC UH

    hNa Y f a GfGO hj GE Z Y Pg GC j hj HhGdhQI Gde J GdQ. GC e Gd a UQ Gd H H hGJ GC e a

    jR hhL QhGj Gd GC f j GC j Hk GC h GE LQI, aE c Hk a

    127

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • GdV a Gdg, hGE c GE LQI a GE LQI hS hPd Z LF aGdL" )Gd: 4/952(.

    b: hVhQI GdS GdcQI g hcd GdhQI Gde GE f g H GdLGde hd j e c GC H Gdd GC e c gG S e GE K GC M e

    GC L GdhQI Gde HLO jh HhG GdV Gd GC Oi GE d hd c GdHH GdQ.

    hY GS GdhQI a e GdL Hd GC Ud b ed a eC d GdOY GdQg )e eF Gd( ; b ed: c f hjd GC g GdG K

    GC Lf dhQI GdS hC f jh H Uak .a S GH SG QM Gd j: QL ed a GdO Y GdQg d Z

    e GC L GdhQI. )Gdq G: 4/103(.hH Gdj HdhQI d hHdhQI a GU GdA hGC Ud fM GC

    GdhQI GC e jQ Vk he GE q GC gG Gd jh a TJ adhQI eH Gd Gd Y GdW hg c b GC N a TM d

    )Gd( a Gd hGE GN a HdI hGd S ck ek cdVaE s e a GdQ GC bi e e a Gd ek . hgG H GdGWA hg

    Gd GJ e a GC aGO cE f. )jo GL T Gd Y bd(:hf GC d` df N GC b H f`

    JGWD Jc Jd` hGTG Y GdGOhGC Qi GC Gd Y GdhQI hGd hGdL KK e H Gd Gd

    b j eMk d GN YQG Gdj hGdA, adhQI j GC Jo a M GdI Gdi c j GC Jo a M Oh Pd hHdd JJ

    GC M e Y Pd c QGC j.

    128

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • GC U ehY M GdhQI:a b Gd Jd: }hb as d e Mo u Y GE s e GVo QJ GE d| )SQI

    GC f 911(b GdU: Pc Gd Jd GdhQI a g GBj hGC W GE HM a H

    dLO GdhQI e Z T h U hg bd Jd: }hb as d e Mo u Y GE s e GVo QJ GE d| )SQI GC f 911( ab Pd hLO GE HM

    HLO GdhQI a c M ho L a. )GC M GdGB dU: 1/741(.hb Jd: }a GV Z Hm h YOm a GE K Y| )GdI 371(. b GH

    Y: "he GV Y" hZ, gG g Gd Gd Y LQ GdAhGdA. hb: e GC c hZ Y GC c g Gde )GdQ GdL H

    Y: 2/17(. hGdU cI HG Gd.hHdb Y bd Jd: }hb as d e Mo u Y GE s e GVo QJ

    GE d|, j GdA e: Gd Gd Pc GdU hg hLO GE HM MhL GdhQI. he GBN hg GE f aq e Gde J GE q GdhQI.

    hgG e j GE d Gd a GSA Y e Y j GC j e Hd GC GdL GE f JN Gd h JN a Gd hGd GC Y.

    Jj GdL:a b GdhR GC HO ehLk HQM:

    )hGdL( GdC QH )( GC eha, hbd Jd: }hdG Y MLk aUhQc| )Za08(. b K: j GC SQ. hY T: hb GC GdL

    Jo Y f GaQ hY GdA Gd j GE d, hb Gd GC H gGd a ahb: GdL GdQ Y Gd Gd, jo Gd j GE d

    Nb hGd N Gd hGd H Gd hGdL GC Gd S hGd

    129

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • j GE d f hGd GC Y e Sd a Gd hZ, K b: bhZ a HC GdL GC Y e Gd hH Hd hGdU GdL hH J

    GC Y GdL Y Gd g J GC h Y GC Y GC h GC N GC h Z PdaC e. b: Uj c T GC GdL e Y Gd hd cd H

    bd hGdL c e eGC hN bd eh c g Xg a j GE de Pc e GdL )cdLA( Hd hGd )h( b )J( GE PG )W( GC

    GdL H GdL hN j j e jL e e, ha GdJ GE d GdA GM GE d hGC QGO ) M( b GdY:

    hGC QV ML H GC Ni cG Gd JV HdGC e GdL a GU a VH: ML Ye b J ed GdhQI hg

    g GdL GC Ud hb Sq g H HdhQI Gde c GC S, hML aNU M eD b J JSk d GdhQI.

    GC hk : GdL Gde )GC Ud(b GE e Gde a Gd GC h: "hGd Gdf e j HdL Gde h

    j GE d M GdhQI, he gG J GE LQI aE f e Y GdL GE dGdc, e GdQ Y J, hV ec H Y S GdQj a ML

    XgI Z Hd e GdhQI GdhV a Gd hZ hd ML Gd b Je GdhQI Gd GdGM e M GE Gda d eG Y J GdL a

    Gd d GBMO Gd VGQ ed J e GdhQI a M GdGM, hbjj GC K Pd a GdQ GdGL GE d Gd Y e j GBMO Hd GE d Gd,

    hgG e j HC M GE jd hGd Pcf eGQ ZV GB". )Gdg 429(.hb GC jk : "hf fi GC fq b J Gd a Y GC e hg GC GE LQI LR

    NQL Y GC b Gd Sg LF a Gd GC h aE eH GdV GdLO

    130

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • HdV Gdh NQ Y GdS GdY a GdhV aE bS GC jHGE q eLOG hd GM Pd a GE LQI d GdL hb Pcf GC GdL

    Gde J ed GdhQI GdU a M GBMO GC TU". )Gdg 139(.hS J GC H Me GdGd e a cH "TA Gd a H Gd

    hGd hed Gd" M b a eV ce Y GdhQI Gd SO GE da e e gG Gd: "hGdL Gde a M ca Gd J ed GdhQI

    GdU a M Gd GdGM" )U 642(.hGE d Lf gG Gd fi GdGd f Ye j Y Gd j "GE f

    hGE hb a eV GdL GC h Gd d J hGE hb a eV GdhQI LRGC jD O GE d GLO e H GC J b c c GC S".

    hb Y GC K J GC H H H GdH Gdd M b a cH Gd)GdYI GdH(: "GYQ GdL a Jj Gd cYQ GdhQI a J

    Gdq " hH GC V ek dd HSA GdV Gd j d GC L Y ede H Gdg Hdg GE d GC L, GC V: "he Pd Mj GdGj hH Gd a

    Y QhD hS Gd Hd GdV Y GC QV ha e GdH KK GC hL: HGdW HdH hGd HdR hGd a Jj Gdd GdHj hJC N GdH

    GE b GC f j d GE PG M LGP Gd" )Gd: 2/097-197(.GE q GC H GdA cH f hGdW fG GdL e ee GC Ud GE d

    GdGY Gd Oh Jj VGH e GC hg H GdM GdUj GC f cM dGF e GC h YV ML j GE HM hcC f j GE d bYI b

    J Y Gd H hGS TC GdhQI Gd Hg GC N a H.hdG aV f GdYI Y GdW d eNk E HGA Gdh GdI H

    GdhQI hGdL.

    131

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • b GdW )GdYI Gde(: GdL J ed GdhQI Ye cf GC hNU. )e GC hd( ehY GE LQI hGdd hGdGd hfg LR Y

    N GdS d a GC hd e hQhO Gd Y ea ehe, ha Gdf eGdd ha Gdd e H Gdj Hdj d GdL GE d Pd. hGdL GE PG Yq

    cf cdhQI he V GdQ LR Y N GdS GE P GdF GE PG H ef d e GC N` e Gd Ojk Y M j` d` M` GdS GE d

    ee` e ja h jD e Nh Gd ek , he e Gd hGE HMGd de hfg hZ Pd. e Gdf J GE fA Hd hjR dL

    h j Gd Y Z Gd C f j GC U GE fA e Gdj bk H GdGOGC ZGV Gd Hd SGA Gdj cE U eV Gd hGd GdK

    he GC c e Gd a OGQ Gd LF dL h j dC c GC j eZ. )GC T hGdF: U 2636(.

    aFI: c GdS e GdW GC jj b Gd a g GdYI hcC f dI eON a d jOg hd GC M GE KJ aC e.

    hYQI GdQc QM Gd Jd: GdL Gde J ed GdhQI GdU aM GBMO GdS, K b: GdL GdU J GdQG. Gf. he PcJ

    GC b GE d GSd GC c, GC GdL J e GdhQI aC e. )GdgHe GC T hGdF: U 121-221(.

    hg GdL Gd Pcg GdW hGH f g ML GC Ud Hd HA MhGSGQ Hh ML d a GBMO GC aGOg hg GdL Y GC Ud

    Gd J Y M b GdW GdL: e j GE d e M GdS hQaGd GdD O a Gdd GE d Gd hGd GdM H Gd hGE PG d JG

    ON Y Gd - Y Gd - Gd hGd hd j GdO Gdba Gdd Gde hg LQj a GdOG hGdOG hGde hGdj

    )GdGa: 2/01-11(.

    132

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • eb Jj GdL ed GdhQI:b GE GdL j GYQg bF e GdhQI H e a GE HM

    Gdq , H GE GC U GC GdhQI hMg J Gdq hGC gG Gd jY GdL c b Gda: "hd j HdL eq GE q a GdhQG"

    )GC : 3/82(. hb Gda: "GdL J C M GC jC N e Z" )fGdL: U77(.

    hGdW f Uq Hd: "GC c Ge a Md GdhQI j Y GC N eGd" )GC T hGdF: U26(; Pd GC GC c Gd a M Gd Jd a hGC N

    e Gd he GdH a M Gd Jd hM GBOe. b GdGa: "hb jL MGd Jd hg ed d GE SW hj e M Gd cj Jd dO GdH

    hGdQ hGd". )Gdh: 1/041-141(. a GdO eq e d Gd hMGdO a j Jj GdL a ed GdhQI HE W.

    hGC c GdA QGC hG GC Gd GdL jJ Y M. b Gda a TMd GdhV: " jR d GC f c d e J GC h ML GYg

    hQJq Y GC M M j YQg TgGk e L" )Gda: 3/702(.hb GH bGe a GdhV a S Mj Y Gdd GdS Gd d j d

    Gd HE H h HYQ e, hgG Y KK Vh: GC Mg ej a eJGdL )hV d GC e(. Gd Gdf e j a eb Gd )hPc d

    GC e( K b: "aG GdH f Nak a GC f jR Gd H e ZGC U aE f d LR Pd c hVk d HdGC hd GM GE d H GdS"

    )QhV GdX: 1/314he Hg(.he b HC K Gd a e GdL T GC J LQj Y GC U Gd

    hbGY e e eOF heU H Ja GC Uk e GC Ud h Odk eGC Od. )GdW "GY": 2/921(; C Gd Gd GE f GC J a

    133

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • Hd eGk H g LQ Y GC Ud, hd Jk dN h GNQ GC bGHd HH e GC Ud. )GdGa dW: 4/541(.

    GC e e d b c h a eV GdhQG aE f e f Gdd Gd bY GdGd GC jk : "a e JL GE d M eO a e Gd hGdq

    hGE L hcf e Gdd Gdj Gd JF Ja GdQ a HWhehM he UQ GE d a T" GC MG J GdL Y Gd H GE

    eGJ GC M ehJ hGC Yg Gd heGJ Gd YjI hGC Yg GdG hGdGeGJ. hE j e fj fQO c GdGa GBJ a ahb: )Gd GdO

    hGdK H Gf e Gde GE d GE HM j a GC Y GdJ hH bYIe GE HM GE d Gde j d GC j GC S(. )Gdh dGa: 3/372(

    hV GC e e GdeGd J GE q HC T Gdh hGC Y GdJ, hGdLd e GC Y GdJ, he GC Gd Y j GLH H Gd hGdq ,

    hjO dj a GC Z GC M he Gdj j Y e Gd Zdkhg bGY eha.

    GE q GC Gd GC fG, a Gd dU cd hGd hd Gdj, he GdGd: cdC NP Zk GC h Y aS hgG Gd H J. )Gdhi:

    92/023(.hGd d eh ; a e Jj GdU ; he Gd Jj

    GdSF hGdQGF. aC h GC T e Gdf.hGdH GC T ee GdO, hM GdH C f e d, aE f GC N a H

    eH, hJj GdH GC T e Jj Gd )GH J(. hb GC jk : "GE Jj GdHGC T e Jj GdQ C f X e".

    hGdH eh: aH Gd jh QH GdA, aE Jj gG e Jj

    134

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • GdU, hJj GBN Jj GdSF hS GdQGF, hdG d j TA e QHGd. )GH Gd "GC Y Gdb": 2/701(.

    hdV e Pc GH Gd fc b GdGa: "GC M Y b: eU hgGd dd hGdS a GC f, hhSF: hg Gd Gd GE d

    hM M e GC a GE d e Jj hJ Z GC f GC N QJ e GdU")Gdh: 2/33(.

    e Pd fQ Jh eGJ Gd hGC GdL JN a f e eJ Y..HE Va GE d GC e bd GH Gd j GC jq H GBN Z Gdj H GdU

    hGdSF H GE GdL JD K M jL f Ha c b GH f:"Gd GC h Gd GE f j a eV f a hGC e e Gd Ha a jR

    Gd Hd, hdG b GC H M he QM Gd He QY MGd Gd hb GE q GC PN". )GC T hGdF: 1/711(. heO ce GC Gd

    jQV GE q HdhQI C f e H GdN hPd a GBN H GdL GdehGdhQI.

    GE GdL Gde JN a Gd GdU dN C GC Kg e hGE cfJN e a GSA e GC U c adN g e T dQ e bS Gdd

    Gdq d GdQ.hb f GdW Y Pd a H a GdN GE P b: "hGC e GdN a T

    dQ T, GSA e GC U c j Gd e GbQ Y eGV GdLa".

    haq GdI GC NI Hd: hcf eGk H Y eV GdL NU e NGUGdN GC jk H e hg GdU H e T e GdL Gdq he T e

    GdN aE TY GdN LF j a Y eV GdL. aE Gdq GE PG

    135

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • Gf S hL Y GdL GE d GC U e GE J GdI hGE dG Gd.hGdj GE PG bQ Y Gd a GdI d ju bYGk hGE PG bQ Y e GdA d

    j.hcd SF GdN H GdV hGdGV hGdbI,hf Pd e g j

    GdN aE f d HN a M GU C f eh GC jk hGE RG GdQ.aR dE f GC jV hGE d j H ML GE d GbGV hGC jb MF hGE

    c bOQGk Y Y H GC h HSQ Y hGC jQV Hd hGE c bOQGk YGdQI a H GC h HSQ hcd e T. hGdU GC Gdj QGL GE d

    GC U c GHGF. hGdN QGL GE d LF e Y Pd GC U Gd.)GdGa dW: 1/003-303(.

    hGE PG c c GE e Gde hJe je GE d J fU TY -ZGLOj- HdL aE Gdd JSG a HA Gdh GLOj Y GdL

    Gd.b GdG H GC Pc GC fGYk e YO GE LQI Gd jg ed: "hc S

    GH SG QM Gd a g LQ Y gG j H GHGA, h j YeJ aQi GC e eJ GC f JQ dQ. he Gd a T M a h

    S GE OY dd ML. he GC U ed GC f jGY GdL c jGYGdhQj aC LR GdO Y GdQg e cf j e YI e H GdH hGC LR

    JC N Gd a GdGA Gd. GE d GC b: hjo GdQ Gd H H GdH.hPc e GC LH C U H e: b hcd e j GE d GdL jC L GC L

    j d GdQ hd H, b j GE d GC e GE PG GVhG GE d a H d e hjh Gd GE q H aC QL GC q j H HC S GE PG Y e H Pd e jL a GE d

    GC Y GdS h jh Y Hq Gk e cGA Gd a M Gd. hSo S GHSG QM Gd: g JR GdQc a Gda GC j GdQ Y hGM hY

    136

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • GBN Gde hJ GdQj H Y f Gd Gd Y? aC L: b GC LRe Pc H GdA, a Y Hd Y GdL GdcQ dhQI hJq Q GdL

    GBN aL GC jR GE TA Gd. hQGC j d a GC Ni b a: hj Pd Ye b ed a GE LRI GC e Gd GdL ".

    hS Y Gd)1(d je HA e Z, b g GE LQI ed hcda GC aG hGdM. hGE f jR Pd Y e j GdS Y GdbI

    hGdGV hM gG Y GH Sj hLY, hY j Gd Y GdS eGC LI Gd dL GdS GE d hY Gd d GC ef hcI Gdf c GYQ

    ed H gG a GE HM JC N GC LI a GdGA Gd a Wj Gd C GC cjA QH ja, a ed gG VhQI GE HM Gdj Hdj adS eh

    dG hGd Gd )Gdq G: 5/093(.hbj e gG Gd e Pg GE d H GC M a eF GE LQI M bdG:

    "hLR GE LQI GdI hGd e GdA, H f d Gdi eG" )GdQGdQ(. Yq GH YHj Hd: bd )e GdA( GC Jk b a c Gd e

    GdGQj d J GE LQI Gd db GE LQI Y GS Gd eO GE q GE PG GC LGC h H e GC QV am jR Jk .

    hGC V GH YHj )J( b a GdJ Nf ha Gd hGdQ j GC LGd he JGVG Y GC a c YI Off cG aG GdG. ha Gdh S

    e GH e Y GC LI GdQ a GC QL GC f HC S H hGE c a GC UaSGk dI Gde hc e gG Z LF aR dL dL GdS GE d

    cN Gd. hY b: QGC j GH Gd` jW` fLk j d c S.)GdT: 5/83(. ha GdQ GdQ: )hj Gd H "GE LQI" d GdGB

    hGd hGE ee hGC PG hj GdC L Y Oa e b(.

    )1( Gd: Nj Gd - b a Gd: g eGV Gd a Gd ha J )GdQ(.

    137

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • Yq GH YHj Hd: "b a GdGj: hH ej QM Gd JdGSG GSQ Y J GdGB Gd dQ GdGf a GC eQ Gdj a

    Ge J M GdGB hY Gdi".hPc e e GC a H GdC Nh e ej hg Gd Y N a

    H ed e Pg GE d GE e hUM )MT GH YHj: 5/43-53(.hgG fi GdC Nj e GC J GE ee ed hGC H M jS a Gde e

    GdL GC Mfk e ed eU GE e HAk Y e a e bGY GE ee.hb GM Gd J Gdj H J H Y a eC d GE LQI GC QV hGd

    Hd: aE b GE GH Y LR GE LQI GC QV hGd Lk C L GdL hGC fS e ed d edk GY Gd a Gd hGH Y Y aE GdL

    OGY GE d GE LQI GC QV GdA Gd a T hGE aGOg Y HE LQI eQ GC he d a e GdQ aR ONd a GE LQI c LR Gda ON GC QV

    e Gd Jk a GdbI )Gdhi: 03/132(.ha eg Gda e M UM Gd Y f Gda QM Gd GC

    GC QRG Gd jL Gd dS jR H b b. hH Pc da g GdC d, b Gdh: "hOd e bd GC h hg GC U GC gG GdQ e

    Gdd dYI GM d hGda Hd d GdL" )Gd:9/862(.

    hb GC U GC H GE S GdW gG Gd GdL hGVk GE j a GE WQ GC UdbFk : "he j Y gG GC U bYI GS". hg a eg ed

    GC N H LF a eH Od c. he GdL GE d Jj GSGdS Y GdS, aE e GS d jL GE d eO Phb hJ, hGE f QL

    GE d e Y e b GdQ a Gd a GC e J GC TA GdhV cdF

    138

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • Gd j GdS a GC eGk GE q GC q Pd GC e jD O GE d aG Gd e LGC Ni GC h L eI cd. hcGk e j gG a GC U GdhQ e

    GdL, hGdL e Gd, a GE LGA GdS ek a GdhQ jD OGE d M he a H eGQO a eV Gd hcd a GdL e

    Gd, GC h GdhQ e Gd hg Xg.hd a Gd GC e cI cdV ek aE f QH a GC U C f GdQg HdQg GE d

    GC L, hd GC H d a e Gda hGdS Y GdL, H d H YGC U Gd d a Pd V Y Gd. he H Gdj HU JGk aE f

    H GdW HdH, d GC H d a e Gda hQa Gd Hd GE d Gdp hGdo n i hd Ge ek d hS d GE YGA, c GC QH Gd d Ge a

    GdV e GC U Gda e gG GdL he Gd H Gd hGdA dhL Gda, hb GdI, hGd a Gd Gdj, hUI Gd, hSF

    GdN Gd Y gG Gd, aE M JL GE d GYQ GdB a JGdd GC h OQA GdS Y GdU, M c Gdd Gd j e Pd

    C f d H e GC U gG Gdd Gd C Oi GE d Qa e Gb Pd Gdd eGd, a e GdGL QY Pd GdB GE d GC b he GW Y

    GdQG a GdGh hGdV hGdbI hGE c Gdd Gd j Gd hGC TAe gG Gd cI.

    gG f e GC Od GdGd Y U Gd H GdYI hY H edhGC UH.

    hb b GH GdH a J GS HC f GE jQ J e Gdd Y WjGSA hGdN, dQV e jQV H a H eJ. K L GC bek :

    a J Gdd d cO GC j GE d Gd, hJc GE d Gd cGC L Gd, GC h Jc dE L cE j Gd Y e b Pf H GdV,

    139

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • hJc a Gd dg da Gd hGE jQ GdS Y Gd cE LRI GdVGd a GdGW GdI hGE LRI H hU a Gd. hb a GC M GdGB:

    GS Yf hY Gd g Gd HC bi Gdd, ad GE PG GShGdS GE PG GC WO aE edk hGC H M jj J Gd HC Od c e

    Xg GC h e. hj ed GC j Hd, hj GC H M GC j H GdGM e GdH GdGQO H GdS, hjj ek J

    GdS hf Gd. h ji Gda d Gd GE PG K Jk . hgG Gdb g f a eB GC M e Z GbQ Y e Gdd Gd hGdS

    Gd. )GdGa dW: 4/502-902(.hf d J e c GdW a JN GdL a J Y ha

    Gdd j Yek Vk .he Gd GC J GdF GdGQO Y Gd e fGOQ GdQ hj

    a ONd a M Gd. b a eGb GdO:g fOQ a P Gd jN he GC h N j

    hj HdOQ e j Zdk H Gd dQI hbY hdG b H: JRGdH Y Gd hLRg H. hGC U a Pd S GE q a N..

    b Rcj: hL Ye GC f fI hGb a GE K hGC f a M Gd e GE PGdj GE q GE c a N. hGdI a S Gd J. )QGL f GdO:

    1/802he Hg(.hGC LR ed JhI GdF dGB M J hg e d e GdhI

    d.hGE PG b c J GdL hg d e Gd Gd e fU

    hXGg Gd hGdq hZg cE L hGd HY hGdS?

    140

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • b: GE f ji Gd dS GC h GS Gd j Y GdLhPd GC e eh a Gdg Gd hGdd c J Y GdW.

    hGE Gd j Gd Y GC g GdF Gd GC LRg e GC LRg dL aE fhGE cf Jk e Gd a Gd Y bGAI Gd dGB hGd Y bV

    j fk hGd Y H b Gd, aE f Y V a GdF GdUC Mj Gd LA a eV LH Z GdF hg Mj Y, a

    Gd Hd GdQI GdOQI Hd dGh Gdj.hcd aE GSA Gd hg e J Y RjOI e GdQ GdOQI

    Hd d aE f Ye j Y L Gd aE f j HC Ud GdjOI GC h GdjGC h f Pd hY gG fq GH bGe e W N Ye b GE f f a

    Jj GC HU.hb e Pd a eC d GC QRG he GC fGOQ GdQ e a ONd a

    Gd c GC S.

    Kf - GdL GdGd HdhQI Gd hg e H GdS a e GdhQI hGVGQ, GE P

    GdhQI d e, hg c j e GC T a H GC aGO e H, aJS GC W Y Gd GdS )GdL( he d jS Gb Y Gd GC Y:

    GdhQI. hd gG e H GdS hGE f g e H GC Od Gd.hg GdL Gd J GC KGk eGk h Mk OGFk H g cdhQI Jq Q

    HQg hb Pcf ek dd f HNQ g eC d H GdI b Hh UMhTh GSA e Gd, M b N )hU b( GC Hh UM e GC U

    GC h GC d H GC h Y b hGV GC GM c a GdV )d( e Gdj GC hGC Mg c j J J e HF d )GdQbf(.

    141

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • hg ML a C f J Mk a a e GM hg T HGC f JR d Gd h JhR e. hgG e j GdL Gd Y

    GdL GC Ud Gd J Mk eGk h j J a GBMO GC aGOg.ad jR d hZ Gd c be, hcd b N a eC d J

    Gd: "hLR d Y S GC e GC N e GE d". he GC e c HGk YGdj jR d GTGA ej GE d e Gd b hUd Gd. b Gd Y

    GH QT: "hGC e GE e H Gd Y bj Y GC e e GdVI aR d GC j e j GE d dQI, d GdV Y GE d GdVI". )Gd:

    4/083(.g g GdL Gd hJ JSk a e GdhQI aq Q HQg hg ML

    T.gG g Gd H GdL GC Ud Gde Gd J H GC M Hd GC h

    GS hGS hH GdL Gd GdU Gd J JSk aGdhQI ; hg e LGk a J GdL hJJ GC M Y.

    hHd fQ hLO fY e GdL GC Mg ML Ye hGC Ni ML NUT.

    hM GE GdL Gd e HdhQI a jo a H Gdh g Ja GdhQI Gdi GC h GdL?

    a eC d GE j H GC bG Y e g Y hb GdA j a GdhQIGd JL Pd. a GdW GE f j Gd GE N H GE J Gd )GC

    GdhQI( aE e GdL hd j Gd GdcQ H Ohf hL Y GH QT)GdQbf: 5/4(.

    142

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • aH QT GC d GdL g HdhQI GE q GC GdhQI Gd J GdL b je H j Pd c a QhGj GH GdS a a Gdj a ea jC N b

    e Gdj. b a GE q Y GdhQI Gd J GC c Gd e GC j a UGAH j cGA hj Y f Gd GE d jC N e OGH j Y,

    hGC T j GC jC N e OGH d H d hGE d J d VhQI )Gd:4/863(.

    Gd PG Gdb:Gd:

    eQ e e U j H Y Gd hVq a GdV hGdQ, hgV GdI hGd V GdO hGC U L e GC h Oa eI. b

    Gdcf: "b GdGQRe: hGdGO Hd Gda Y eO Gd HaGdS Y Gd" )GE QTO Gd: U 242(.

    hH Gd hGdL Y hL, a Jo Gd Y GdL hZg,hcd GdL b J a e Gdd hGS Gd H

    GdLGde a b Gd H Y Gd )C Gd Gde cdhQI GdU()bGY GC M: U 623(.

    hb GH bGe a Gd H GC Pc Gd a M b: "hb fq GC MY GC e T GC j H S d j he GTG GdA a H GBN.

    hQhi Y LGRg cf e d Lk " hH GC Pc GC bG GdjhGdf b: "hGd LGR C f e d e Z VQ dGM e.

    hGd jO Hj Gdd Gd eq I a H HhY hC gG dHU Y Jj h a e GdU aL GE HhD Y GE HM"

    )Gd: 6/634-734(.

    143

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • Y Gdi:hg Gdd GC h GdOK Gd J cGk e GdS hjq Q GMGR e )GH YHj:

    GdT 1/013( GC h e J GdL GE d a Y GC MG )c GC SGQ: 3/61(cS Gd hGd J Hdd hGE c QWk Y b GC H jS hg GC U

    Gd H d Gdi )GH YHj: 1/903-013(.hY Gdi cdL ja fk . b GH f: GYQ Y GC H M Hdi

    a eV Gd c a H GBOe aE Gdi a GC Y )GC T hGdF U 48(.Gd:

    Gd J ed GdhQI ha GE aOI GE HM. GC Ji GC GC SG Gd JY Gdq . )GdGF: 6/03(

    Y GMGR:heg UH Gd Y GC e hg a GdOG hZg. b GdSf: c a

    eh a Gd QH SGA c Gd e M GdG GC h e M GC hU GE q e j GdR Y Oak d )HGF GdF: 5/781(.

    hYq Y GdGa HdQ M b: "GdQ j GYQ hGd ja Gd" )Gdh: 3/891(.

    hGC e N a b: " GE Y GMGR e" )GdQbf: 1/71(.hY Y j c e )GC Y j Gf Y H hLO S hg

    Gd( )GdQbf hHT Gdf 1/14(.c e j GMGR e e Y )GH J Gdhi1/295( hY GMGR g

    YQI Y Gd GdM a GdOI GC h Gde.

    144

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • Gd:Gd J H GdL g GdGb a eJ eS. hE j Pd f c

    GdGa a Gdh Y GC b Gd M j ehLk HH Gd HNQe H Y H M Gdd a Jj Gdh e j: )Gd GdGH Y

    H bYJ Gd Gd dOI hGd Gd J(:GY GC Gd GE dG Gd Y GdW j e GSS e OhGY f

    g GC e f eLO a L GC Me M GE HM. K j Z GE HM HHf H GC Y e H. ad H GE hb e je e Gd YOI GC h a

    Gdd GC h a GdOQ cdVA hGd a GdO hGd a GdQ Gdj hGdWIHd a GdO hf Pd, d jD K e je a GdOI HE S h H

    C a Pd f Gd GE d j Gd H je e Gd c GdY KK GC b:

    GC h: e Y GYQ a GE S GC h Gd cd Y GdS GC h GC YAhGda C M g GC eQ g S ed Gdf hGBNI a M g

    GdOI e Gd Y e Pc dGH C Oi dg GC ed.Gdf: e Y Y GYQ a Pd cC Of hL a GC U C J g

    GdOI GC hd e OQA g Gd d GdOI hN Gd.Gdd: e a a j a Gd e GT e hGE H GdGQ

    e N e hg Gdg e eg ed. a Gd e Gd aGdI Y K GdV c e j GdR e c GdGZ hj GdVA a

    Hd dI Y GdA hGdL GE d hGd Y GSd. hH j aGd TjI Gd hN.

    g GC b GdK JO a L GC HG Gd a hL Gd GdK a

    145

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • GdVA, cd fg a GdI hGd hGC e Hdh hGd Y GdhJb GdF hGd Y MQ GdI hGdC P Hdj GdQOI a Gd GdA

    hGd a GdM hZ Gd hLY Gdf e GSA Gd hZ Pd.hcd GdQ a Gd KK GC b hgG a c GC HG Gd )1/131-231(.

    hH GC d YOI eJ. b: hcd e Gde d e eJ.

    e JN a GdL:GdL hGdQ:

    e GC g Gd Gd JN GdL YO GdQ hJe H GdU GdJ Y GZQ j GdQ dL.

    hfj GC fc GB e g GdQ? hGC U Gd Y hei JC K GdL a GE dAM.

    hGdQ Yq a GdGa HC f: GdA Gd jQ g j GC h . hYq GddHC f: e Yo hLO hLo U.

    hYq GdLf GdQ HC f: e j e Gdb jQ GC j GC h )Gdj(.

    hb: e c d Xg j Gd hHW e. b GC Rg: hjN a HGdQ Gd Gdd Gd j H Gdj )Gd: 3/344(.

    hH GdQ e TYk H Gd dd Jd: }h JC cG GC eGd HHdW| )GdI 2/88(.

    heq HU Gdq . a U e e Mj GC H gjI GC Gd fY H GdI hY H GdQ )T e dh: 11/651(. hGC NL ed a

    146

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • GdWC eSk Y GC H MR H OjQ Y S H Gd GC Gd f YH GdQ )Gd dL 5/14(.

    Yq GdL Hd "f Y H GdQ j aO he H GdQ hGd GC Ye c a GdQ hZ Y M UQ Gd jU H GdQ aG Gd N

    a Gd e".hGC e j GdQ aE f jD K a aO Y H aE f jO j e Y. hGE f

    j GdA a aO GC Y GdO Na a a e GdQ g g e MGd Gd j Gd GC h e M Gd Gd j, adQ j Hd e

    KK GC hL: e L Gd, hGdV, hGC L )Gd 5/14(. b: hL e PcGdL hZ GC eO hLO GdQ d ek d M j Zdk fTk Y c

    GE Va Gd GE d GdQ g e GE Va GdU GE d Gd. hhU GH ed aGd gG Gd e GE Va HC f e T Gd he d H Gde C

    Gd g Gde hPd U he gG GC Gd hGQO Y H ZQ hd YH a ZQ hGd jQc Gd HGQO GC d.

    hb GdGa: "bYI: GdQ KK GC b: e Y e a Gd cd a GdGAhe Y LGR cC SS GdGQ he a g j Hd GC h d GC h

    Hd Gdf d GC h dhQI GE d c GdF Y Gd hGdfe hfg?a gJ GdYJ j Gd a GdGAI. a` )( ji GE c Gd e

    GC hU M d aR d Gd a hGE SW Hd, hZ jG M GdJd hGC f M Y YO a GdhV Y Gd. h)( ji GC ZQ Gd

    a T GdGAI e GdQ Gd dhQI GdF da Gde Y f hZ jGe GdQ Gd C f b jC J Y GC c U Gd, aC e g GdGQ a

    e GLO hGf GC j GC b dO Gd hbGY aY Y hGd gGdO GE d S GdTO )GdNI dGa: 5/39(.

    147

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • hj Gdh: )a( GC U GC H GdQ HW dG Gdj hGdGO e c aZQ Xg j GMGR e )aC e( e JY GE d GdL h j GMGR Y

    cC SS GdGQ hTGA Gde e GM GC Gd hGM GC h GC c hPc GC h GC f hceGC YA GC h fb hcGA GdI a VY d hf Pd aG j H

    HE L.hf GdA GE L GC jk a GC TA ZQg M )e( GC GC eq GC L Y

    U H Gd GdI hGE d j Mg hd H Mg eOGk d j,hGC LG Y LGR GE LQI GdGQ hZg TGk e GC f b j KK jek hb j

    J hYj, hGC LG Y LGR ON Gd HC LI hY LGR Gd e eAGdA HV e GN GC MG GdS a GS GdA GC h e a Gd.

    b GdA eGQ Gd H GdQ hGd e hLO Y e Pcf hg GC f GE PGOY GdL GE d GQJ GdQ h j GMGR Y GE q H GC h c GdQ

    MGk LR Gd hGE q a. hb j GdA a H GdF c Gd GdFhH Gd a S hj GNa ek Y g GdYI, a ji GdQ

    jGk jD K, hH jG eD KGk hGd Sf hJd GC Y )Gd dh:9/852(.

    GC e Gd J Gdj H J aE f bq GdL Hdq I Ye b a Mj YGdGF: "hGdL GdjI ja H GdQ Gd hGdj e Y GC GdI

    Gd dj GE PG YQV e QGL GC H Gdq a GE PG cfGdI e" )Gdhi(.

    GdQ Gd:hGY Gdd GC GdQ GE PG c eak C U LF j dL H e d c

    GdQ GC Uk a Gd a Gd. b GdG: he Gdhf e H GC e hd QVM hT Y QVY hf S ad LF GE PG c GE e Gd GC QVG d

    148

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • GBN.. )GH jf( hGd H gG hH Gd jR GC j GE e Gd GC jD J H, GC eC d GC e GdQ a J C f Gf GE d GC U LF. c ed

    a H d TI LGak TGk GC f jR hGC LR cGA fb TGk hGT MH, GC ULGR GTG Gd KGk d jD H - Gf H gG Y bd - hN Gd. hb

    GC T GE GC f Y bd j GdLO M Gdh cdQ hGdd a GdO GE PGb hY GMGR Y f GC SS GdGQ hb Gd hQOGAI HW GdGc hO

    GdGZ hfS K GdV. hGf Hd dH jR e b h c d a H Gd -e GH jf- )GdG MT Y eGg Gd:

    4/563(.hgG Gd hGV a GC ej GC Mg GC GdQ b jR Jk dL hjR e

    Gd hGC GdH jR e b h c.hg fU J MhO JC K GdL a Gd hPd H eJ Gd a

    c a eJ hS cdQ JD K a Hh he c a eJ Y jC K H.he gG Gd JC K GdL eI Y GT Gd Y e Gda hGdh

    a j Gd a GC U MGek hd j dL HAk Y e Y e GdGdQ dh hGda.

    he Pd GC f GC LRhG GE LQI J a W Gda GdC L Y h GdGGdC LI hPd a U Ya Y Gdd H` "GC Y He C Y He".

    hJQ g GdC d e e N ehLk HQM GdQbf: "hLR GC YHe Y MK hf C Y He. GC QGO GC h f Y MK GC h Z. hdG

    M e M c Pd, GE LQI YQj, C f H YV hgG HV,J Gd GC , Jhi Re GC h GN, JK Gd H dBN GC , c

    hHA hZ hKQ a j GJO Gd h Y Gd(. hg GE LQI,

    149

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • he GC GE LQI cd. GC Qcf, hGdc Gdf - GC L- g cd j cfehak bQGk hU " gG c GH Ya )GdG5:/983(.

    hg Gd Gd GY J Y L bQ GC LI hU ; C f b JKQGk a eH Z, hb J MKk a eH GdA C GE Yf eh M

    YQI GdQbf )f GdL(.b GH TS d b GC Y He jek hGC Y He jek a HQj H JL

    GE d M GE LQI d GC LR GH GdS hQGB e Gda )GdG 5/962(.hS Gdj HC S GC j GdL Gde d GC Y N GC j hGC Y N

    GC j a MO RQY hOQS hY )GH QT( C f e Gda a Pd VhQIJ Pd hGE f jR Pd a b hb e GC j hGE GN GC Y )GdG:

    4/814(.b: bd a Pd VhQI GE d GBN eg g GdL c be. hcd fq G

    Y GC )bd Gd J GE PG L Mk hMGek eU HdhVGdd Hd hGdGA( )a GdQbf: 7/97(. bd a eV Gd Y H

    YO Gdb Gd J Mk hMGek , hee GC GdY J Hd HGd hGdG H j a GdA Gd J H Gde hj Z hPd

    C YO Gdh hGda je a fGk d GdQ Gd a GE jY e je a Zg hj a e Gd Gd JY GE d GdL e j a YO

    Gdj Gd.he gG Gd e Pc GH jf a Le hg j H YO Gd: "Gf

    g Gd GC f GE PG bhG GE bd LR C f eh, hGE PG bhG Gdj d j C fej. a Y gG GE PG GH M HGR aC Y fbk hQO Y e Gd,

    GE bhG Gdj d j hd bhG GE bd a Gd hb hL OjQ j

    150

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • SSk GC b HG Gd e SS Gd hN GdjQ Gdb dR" )cGd e GH jf(.

    a g Gd HR GE Y GdL d N e d hd eYk aJ N j H GE Qa heh.

    GdL JL Gd a H GdA:hb fs Gdd Y LGR Gd Hd HK Th: GC JA GE d GdhQI,

    hGC j V TjGk LGk , hGC J f GE d bF jo i H Yk hhQYk .Pc Gdf a MT Y GdQbf Y Gdh )5/421(.

    hf S Y Gd a eGb GdO M b:hPc e V d d GE P PG Y hab b Gf

    H db a eGQ Gd` hd GdQ e d GY`hdGYI Gd Gd` GC h GdGY`I d e S```````

    hcf j GE d Gd```````Q GE c d j a Gd`````QK Gd`h hb J```````` VGk e Gd` H J```````````

    GC U ehY GdL Qa Gd hGd a J e GdhQI a eC d QaGd hg e Y Gd hGd hGdS.

    b GdW )GdC d GdOS(: aE GdQ d j GE d Gd HdhGE Y a hGdd Y Pd GC eQ:

    GC Mg: GdU GdGd Y Pd cd Jd: }hj Y GE Ug hGC ZGd cf Y| )GC YG: 751(. hbd: }QHq h J Y GE UGk c

    M Y Gdj e b| )GdI: 682(. ha Gdj: "b Gd Jd ba" )Mj Qb 081GC NL e Y GH YS, H GE j(. hb LA:

    151

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • } jq Gd fk GE q hS| )GdI 682(. h}jj Gd H Gd h jjH Gd|)GdI 581(. h}he L Y a Gdj e M| )Gd

    87(. h}jj Gd GC j Y hNo GE f V| )GdA 82(. h}ejj Gd d Y e M hd jj do c| )GdFI 6(. ha

    Gdj: "Ho p o Hd Gd" )Gdj GC NL GE e GC M Y GC H GC eeQV Gd Y, Mj Qb 06212Hb e GC fQ(, hMj: "e No u n QS

    Gd H GC ej GE q GNQ GC jg e d j GE Kk " )Gdj GC NL GE e GC MY YF QV Gd Y, Mj Qb 20732Hb e GC fQ(. hGE f b:

    "e d j GE Kk " C J GE K eq a e M c eO J GE d GC T Pde a gG Gd. hd c bUGk d d c ejGk d h Gd

    hd ejGk d hGd hPd HW.hGdf: e K GC jk e ehY GdN hg GC e e H he Y e Oj

    GC e VhQI cN Gd hGd hGd hJh Gde a GVGQ, aE gG f j bk Y e Qa Gd hGdq , hcd eLA e Gd Y

    Gd hGd hGd a Gf Y OhG GC Y. hd c GdQ bUGkd a Gd d c K JN h J )GdGa 2/121-221(.

    adU Gdd Gdc Ye a Gdq HY Gdj hGdS, hGE PG aV GC Qa Gd eO a U Y aE f f e fGR eOI NU e

    Gd e a GC U Qa Gd c GE PG hLf Gd T Y e WGdA hGdI bYGk Y e W Gd, hGd hGd a Gd, hGd H

    GdJ a Gd hGdV hGd, hGd H Gd Y e Gd.hGC W Gd )GE d LF cI LGk j e eY b da Gd aE f

    f H Qa Gd a GC HG c Yk HSGA(. )GdGa:2/992(

    152

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • GE L Gdh H GdhQI hGdL:H gG GdV j GC Gd H GdhQI hGdL jL GE d:

    1- Gdj a GC GdhQI a eg Gd GC N TI hV a GdJGdi J Gdq , ha eg GC Ud c j GC M Gd H bG

    GC Oj hGC HG.hGdL e a eJ hS a eg Gd J HdhQI Gd a GE HM

    e V Od hJf eJ a S Gd ha e GC Ud c GC hQY GYQ e hMLk de hGC Oi GYQ GE d Sd hj a GC Uk dO

    eU MO Y bS GC h NL Y bYI c GC h GC Oi GE d GLO eGSMk GC h GSfk .

    2- GC U GdhY a GC GdU Gd HdhQI fU hGV eOIJ Ha M hTI e f NU.

    hGdU Gd JL ehY GdL GE d J Ha Gd H Ye GC Y eJ Gd b hGC b JjGk .

    hgG Gdb H GdhQI hH GdL KH a GdhQI Hd GC Ud)GdhQ( he e, GC GC Gd Gd e GC L Y N GdS

    e HA Y Od GS GC h Gd GdS ha GdhQI HdGd he eb e H GdN Hd GC N hg J M dQ e

    Y Gd GC U.ha GdL H GdL hg Gd GC Ud he e GC GC Gd

    KH H e SGA c eUk ek H cd hGE LQI... GE d GBN, GC heHk GE d GSfk cS dL hGde GC h GSMk cGR JhI

    GdF Y ed.

    153

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • hGdL H GdL j a GC J Ye hGC e GdL Gd hgcdhQI Gd C f e H hJS dg hg Ja Gd eD bk H

    GdhQI Hg Gd aE f J e bS Gd Gdf Ujk a JL aaa eD bk hJQc GdL Gd a Gdb d J e a eJ

    Od Gd Gd Ja, aC hd Ja Mk Od b cd Hd GdghGbA hGE TQI hGd hGdS.

    GC e Gdf aE f Ja Mk Od X c Gd hHU Gd Gd a fGOQGdQ c GC S hgG GN a W Gdd Gd JGL c e fTA

    Y GN Gd adq a e GdhQI g eq ci H Gdq ae GdL g eq hS.

    GC e GdhQI H GdhQ Y GC Ud aE f J JC Uk C M eUe GdQ GC h e a Y Wj Gd GdS.

    j Gd H GdhQ hGdL a GC e c e b GdhQj a GC QaeJ e c e b GdL JC Uk hJk , a c e GdhQj e

    M f hOj hf he hY j a GdJ Gd e Gdd GdY hdGaE f e a Z Gdg GdU Y e j Hdd GdS hg ed

    QM Gd Jd hd j e j H cdGd a Gd Hh hGHbGe a GdhV.

    GC e GdL af eJ aE GS a e f c e GdAcdGd a Gd hGH bGe a GdhV.

    hc g Gdh JY GE d GdC e a g GdYI hGE YOI Gd a eb, hGdfG GC f bYI GC Ud hd a hGC GdO hGdh Gd J Y eQI

    Hd acg GE PGk e H Gd hGdC U hd eOI hdG Yq H H

    154

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • Gd hGC GC hd GC Jc e GdhQI GC Ud C f J Mk OGFk hg eGd Gd jb Y J a c aO e GC aGO H j H Hd

    a Gd.hGC Y GC gG Gd g Gd Gf GE e Gde M J Y GdhQI

    GC Ud a Gd Gdd hL e Gd K J Y GE d GdL H aGdJ Gd J hhV H GE LQI hJ Je.

    hgG a QGC g Gd Gd hGE hV bYI a GC M GQJck Y c eGdM M GC HMG HdL Oh GS hOh Gd a Th GS

    hGS, hd jG GE d GC GdL JD K a K Gd Y HC Od bjH J a eJ bj e eGJ Gd a JD K a Jj Gd hGd hGd.

    H GE f JD K a Y V c GC aGO hJhd Gd hGE f JD K a eJGd JU HC f a GC Y OQL Gd a Gd GC eq e

    GdU d cq e GdSF hGdQGF hg ah Ob JR HG Ob.aC hd J GE q GdhQI GdU H JC K GC NI HdL ed ed

    GdhQI hJD K GdL a H Gde hH Gd GC b bI HjM Gd GC GdQ d jO a a Me GdH ce GdQ hGd

    hGdQ adH GC T e g c j GH J.K GE GdL j GC J Gd H GC f j J V GdL GC

    f GC GdQ c GC U LFGk GC h GC H e d Y GC U LFGk , H GE GdLJe e LF a e g Gde C Gd f a j Y GC b

    aE dhD j GE dA d.hGE PG cf GdOG d Y hRG hGM c j GdW ad Gde

    d Y hRG hGM.

    155

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • hHNQ aE Gd H GdhQI hH GdL j a K eGJ: eJGdq heJ Gd heJ Gdd. aE GdhQI a GdJ Gdi e Gdq GC h

    e GC g hGdL a eJ eS. hGd Gd J GdhQI Ha g fb j a GC Y OQL Gd C eJ bj GC h C f j GdI a f

    GdU H JGL GdL fk GC Of eJ e Pd C f b j f GdSF.GC e eJ Gdd aE Gdd Gd Ja M GdhQI b j fk Ujk e

    c GC h Sq GC h SGg. GC e Gdd Gd J GE d GdL a a Gdd YV j, GC h bS jO a e GdL, GC h bYI j e.

    e N Gde e g GdGJ Gd j a GdA ha GC PcA aGd H GdhQI H Gd hGC Ud hGdL H GC Ud

    hGd.hY VA gG j GE Y GdL a GdO GdOI j GC j Gd

    c ek Y GdO H j GdO Mk H GC hL Gd c bdG a HGdaA. adO j H GC hL Oh H. hPd GE f j a Y eO h

    j a YI YO GC h ee H aS hH U, a j JGdS HA Y U Gd. hgG e GC S e N Y H GdA

    aG Md GdO GdM HA e Gd hGd j L GE PG c ZQGk jGkek eak GE d GC U LF, WG Pd Gd Y YO eOI H e Y

    H hH e hH LF HYi Gd GdI. hgG c g hGVZ U, h j bd e N eGE GdL H e GC MG.

    156

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • J eUI:a j H Gd GdUI dGE GdL:

    1- ai Gd GC hQhH HC TGA H Gd a OjQ Z Gd:fGC g Gd Hi GC KQ Lk a GdM Gd hg ai Gd

    GC hQhH dE aA hGd Gd HGQ GE HM TGA H Gd a OjQ ZGd JLk dg GC H M he b Hd Gfbk e eGE GdL.

    f Gd a Gd Gd Y H Gdi a GC hQhH ha HO Gd c,hg b GdR Gd Ji HV QH HGS Gd Gdj.

    hb be GE d Gd YI GC hQG a GdV e H eD j heQV bo F YGd, K fb L GC YA eb e, Gf Hg HC Z GC YF

    GE d e j:1. jD c Gd Y e GC L Y GC e e Me GdH hGC f e Gd

    GdH, he GdF Gd JD P H e Gd hQSd, hjD c e bQJ GdeGd GE Se e GC aGF Gd g GdH GdG.

    2. jT Gd GC HA Gd a Gd GC jhG a GE jO GdGF GdYGd T a, e GSYG GE d Pd Sk e )H GdGH( Gd Je

    Gd GE Se, he JC S Tc GE Se JA e g Gd HheI ehQI dQ Gd, hZ Pd.

    3. c jY Gd GE S`e a GC hQhH GC JhV Gd GC hQhH Gdjdj g Gde GE d U ed TYk , e )H Gd( Gd jGO a Gd

    eH GdjOI a GC L, aE gG S d YOGk cGk e Gd jee Y GC SS g Gdj, hg e j H Gd a H GC bQ GC hQhH,

    157

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • hb QGC j YOGk e Gd GdH Gdi J ahY d a HOf GdH Jeha Gdj GE Se, c a Gdj hZg. hj d GC jY a

    Pd HE QS fGA GE d g Gd dj Sc e Gd.4. hGE PG d j gG h PG eGk a Gdb GdV, aE Gd a VA GC Od

    hGdGY hGYQG GdY, ji HC Sk e GdA GE d g GdS hg GdVGdH dGA H j GE d Gd d g hGC SJ, H GC j dj H

    GBN j, hGC j g e GC SS, hGC j Y e aF Gd ej e TGF H g GdS, hb GY d a aG Y eJj

    GC SS:

    GdJ GC h:bYI )GdhQG J GdQG( hg bYI e Y eC NPI e fU

    GdGB a N eGV, e bd Jd a SQI GC f: }hb aq d eMq Y GE q e GVQJ GE d| )GBj 911(. he bd Jd a f GdQI

    H Pc eq e GC W: }a GVo s Z Hm h YOm aE QHs ZQ QM|)GBj 541(. he bQ GdA g GC GdL b J ed GdhQI, NU cf

    GC h Ye.hGdL g Gd GE PG d J j Gd a M hGE c j GC j

    H GdhQI Gd j GC j Hhf, hGd Jd Qa Gd Y gGC e HU GdGB c a bd Jd a SQI Gd: }he L Y a

    Gdj e M|)GBj 87(, ha SQI GdFI: }e jj Gd d Y eM|)GBj 6(. hGd Gd ja Y Gd Gd g Gd GdS

    d a eb ha S ha eGa H j Sk Mk .hGE PG c Gd b GY Y bYI GdhQI GC h GdL Gd J ed

    158

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • GdhQI, aE f d j GdYI GC Ni GdH hGd d, hg GC e GC HdhQI jq Q HQg, a j Jq Gd dQI hfg.

    hGd h T VhQI dO Gd hdC SI Gd, hb Ge Gd HdY YO M b: }hGd L d e HJ Sk | )Gd 08(, hL

    Gd Gd GdGS YGk e YU GdOI GC QH GC h GdK hGdGdC L j c ML Gd, h j HC e, hGE c j Gd

    cGk H ja d Gd hj SG ja GC LJ h j e MGk hGMGk ,he gG j Gd YV dO e gG Gd GE PG c Yd GC h c Va, c

    GC f GE PG c S GC h bq ON GC h Gf YV C jo e H a Gdj.hJ Gd j Gd gG Gd, c GC f j GC jQ Gd bjk e

    Gd hGdc GE Se hGdQS GE Se, hjA aU dYGd GC JQ a ec Y GC JA d ek GE Sek UGk OGN

    Gd Gd, aQ a GC HhD g, hJi QhGH, hjhf Y Gd aX eg GE S hb Gd.

    c GC gG j Gd e GE YGO H hJJ H j ML Gdj hGLYeOG eck d.

    hg GE d Lf g GdL GdOj d e GdL Gde dY GdGdj j GC b NQ OGQ GE S, hg J a J GC MGd Gd,

    M jJ eGg, hjfG GC gk dfA GE d N GC e GC o NL dS, hjhGUQI eb dE S GC e Z Gd, c J a GC jQhG e Gd

    GbOj Y, deG HGL GdYI hjgG a HA Gd Gd, hgGj GC q j Gd j W Y e GC L Oa b GE jQ H hf Y,

    h j aU de e GC h f OYJ.

    159

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • GdJ Gdf: )hg e dJ GC h GC SS(g e Pg GE d GC H M hUM e H Gd Gdf - hg Gd H a

    Gdg Gd - hcd S GdQ hGE HGg Gd, hg QhGj Y GC MH M, hQL GH J - a Pc H GdH - e LGR Gde HdH

    - hZ e GdO GdSI - H Gd hZg a Z OGQ GE S.hjL GC N HG Gdg g YI GYQG, e:

    1. GC Gd Z e TYk GC j GC M Gd Gdf hGdd hGdShfg e j Hd Gd a e jD e HE S, C gG d a

    hS, h j Gd fk GE q hS, hJj GdH g e g GC M Gd JHj Gd ha Gdhd hGJg GLY hGbO. hGE f jd

    Gd HE be GC M Gd J aOGk e GC M GdOG hGC M GdehGdhH hGdS he j HdhG hGd hGdL hGdI hGdG

    hZg e GC MG Gd, H d V Y a g GC eQ hd jH GE be Oj a dL Y GC jL GE d GC QV Gd GdGS e hL GE d Pd

    Sk .2. GC Gd GE PG d je H GdO GdSI - he Y GdH - a OGQ Gd,

    SD O Pd Hd GE d GC j GdGe HE S Sk d GbOjk hNQJedk , hGdhV GC GE S jq Gd h j, hjj h j, hj

    h jq , hb GM H YA Gd Y LGR JQj Gd e Z GdHj: "GE S jj h j" GC jj Gd h j, he: "GE S j

    j", hg GE PG d je H GdO Gd jGVf H S GE d GC je j e h jC N eH, a j g GdGf hGdO a j Y e

    eQ h jg a j d e ef, a Gd OGFk hd d Gd, hHGj Gd GC HGk eek edk H GdGe HE S, hGE S j GC HGk GE d GC

    160

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • j Gd HdGe H, hGC jc - a Z OGQ GE S - d Gd jhj e, a M j Y Gd GC j e ee Z Gd a GdH

    a VA GdO GdFI hGd H Yg.he jo e GC eg Gd GE f j Gde HdH a Md GC N GE YA

    C f aFI d a GE YA hg jh Gde HdO GdSI GE qHW GC h: GC j a e d, hGdf: GC j a ZQ h Nf

    d Gd, hg d J Gd d.adG: GC gG Z es , c j Y b e H Gd Gdf a

    Gd Gd, hGE W Gde e YA Gdg, c GC Gd hGE c jGdFI g a Gd GE P H j Gd a Gdj.

    hb GC cq Gd Gdj j a g GdjQ Hd GdT e hHdGS:GC GC b Gd jaf d HQ GC LI Gd jaf dd, H GC Mfk J

    GC b, he gG GC f GE PG Mq e Gde g HdFI e Gd Me Gd e Gee d hC SJ, hg e GdL GC U dE f c jq GdA, hQH

    j Yj S GC h GC c ja GE jQGk Tjk GC h Sjk h j Tk Y M cj a N Yj S - hQH GC b - GC j Gd.

    a d j gG Gde LFGk Y eg GC H M he hGa d LFGk YGd dL Gd J GC Mfk ed GdhQI a GE HM GdQ H.

    h S GC Gd g GE f jD c GdH h jC c, GC g j GdFI h jC NghGC U a Gdj e Y )GC c GdH( c f H GBj GdGB, hGE f M

    GE j SGk dQj c Me GdH d hGdOI Y a e H JjGdSF Jj GdU.

    he Gd GC GC c GdH Gdq jR H, GC e GE jd - H GE YA GdFI- aR dL, hb fq Y Pd GdA hGC LRhG GSGV HdH dL GE PG

    161

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • S a hL GC HG Gd. he GdGY` Gd`I g: GC e M` dGJ jGE q dhQI, he M d GdQj j dL, hGd Gda.

    hJ Y gG GdGQ: f Y HNQ GE f j Gde HE W HdH a OjQZ Gd c g e eg GC H M he b Hd d j a Md

    GdL Gd Gd JhR e a JL e HdL Wk dhGdL HdL Gd fg Y ed. hGE c GJ e UZ H GdG

    hHU a j Hd GC GdL hMg J a GE HM gG Gde.hGd GC GdL J a GE HM GdH hGE f J Gdi Y b GdA

    GdF HG eLk HC U Y T Gd HYQ hg GdL hGd.

    2- bGQ e Gd GE Se: 36)1/7( HC TGA GC S a Tc JeGC Mfk HdH:

    a j H GdO Gd hQO HGQ e Gd GE Se a j HGGdV:

    GE e e Gd GE Se Gd a OhQI eD J GdH HI a GdGdH GdOj e 7-21P GdI 2141g` GdGa 941ej 2991.

    H GE WY Y Gd GdGQOI GE d Gd HU eV "GC SG Gdd"GC S, GNQG, Gd, Hb GF, hH GSY GE d Gdb Gd

    OGQ Md, bQ e j:

    GC hk ` GC S:1- GE S a Gdc:

    GC ( H GC GC U a Gde Gd aE JC S Tc eg PG GC ZGVhGC f ehY GC e LF.

    162

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • ( N a Me GE S a Tc ZV GC SS eq , cdeHdH GC h GE f Gdq e GC h GdLI H.

    ( GC U Me GE S a Tc Je GC Mfk Hdq e cdH hfHdZ e GC GC f GC SS ehY.

    2- Jj eD hd Gdc Gdg GdhOI: ef TYk e GE fA Tc eg PG eD hd ehOI HGC S ed, C Pd

    e de e Gdc hH Gd j GdQ Y je e Gdc.

    Kfk ` Gde Hd hGd hGdD TG a GC SG Gd:1- Gd`: j Gde Hd a GC SG Gd HE Mi GC QH W g:

    Gdj GC hd: GC j Gd M J Gd hJ Gd a Gd e hLOGd GC h GE j e d a e GdF hb. hgG Gd LF TYk Hh

    Gd Gdha.Gdj Gdf: GC j Gd M J Gd hJ Gd a Gd e

    GE ef H g Gd. hgG Gd LF TYk Hh Gd Gdha.Gdj Gdd: GC j Gd Y J S eUa a Gde a eY GC L

    hOa Gd Y Gd hGC j TWk j GC j ak Hd hGd,hgG Gd Z LF dC L Gdd, hj GC jq da Th Gd

    Gdha, aE PG GSa Th Gd LR. hcd jR H Gd GdGI Skb b.

    Gdj GdGH: GC j Gd Y J S eUa a Gdeq a eY GC LhOa Gd Y Gd Oh GC j Gd TWk j GC j Hd

    hGd Gd, H j J H ec. hgG g Gd GC c TYk a

    163

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • GC SG Gd, hgG Gd Z LF GC Uk .hJ Y gG GdGQ Gd HC SG Gdd fi GC Gd JQI d j

    GdL d YQV e Gdd Gd j GYQg e hJQI GYg. a SGd:

    1- GdI )(: GC U Me GE S a Tc Je GC Mfk Hdq e cdHhf HdZ e GC GC f GC SS ehY.

    hHG ji Gd GC GdH J GdL h YI H Hd C Y GdchGC f HYQ Pd hUk WOjk hGd a Pd c ek c GE UH C

    GdH c GC S a eJ e Gd J GE q GdhQI.hc HO GC Jo c )GC U( Gd GC U Gd jQq H E HM GTG

    a g Gdc HYi Gd, hb Hq NC Pd a H GBN.2- bQ Gd GC ef TYk e GE fA Tc eg PG eD hd eOI

    HGC S ed.hGd JhR Y e Gdj Gd Y Gdc aE GC UH hGE cfG

    j GC f eJ HGC S e Gdc aE f e Pd GE f JbhG e GC QH GdchgG GdGQ a Y GYG Hd Gdj hGC U a Gdj GYQ Gdeq

    Gd hGd bQ Pd dL.3- a GdI GC NI e Gdj Gdd bQ Gd GC f ) jR H Gd

    GdGI Sk b b( hd j GdL e GC eg ed hGC hRGY LGRPd e d J Gd Wek .

    g GdGQG J Y Je MQ e eGC GdL, hd H gG j aGE j ej Gde e GdL.

    164

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • HE Va GE d e J a e Gd YO GdQj a bGQG SH hGC cq gGGd a OhQJ GC NI HdjV HQj 52LOi Gdf 1241g,` eYG e j

    e HS HAk Y JC L GdV.hGd j d GC YO GdQj e Gd Gd JN a GdL d hLO

    f a hb GC LR ed JC L GdV a Gd H dK hGE d Zj GC LGd H T Gd hGC LR a GSGQ a GdGA e OGF Gd cdR.

    hGC LR a GC cjA Gd hg cGA e JC L a GdV HL GdS GE d Pdhb f c GH SG Y GdG ha GC ed )GC LR JC N Gd a GdGA

    Gd( )Gd hGE c 5/093(.b N: )GC h a ef d j a GE q cGA M ad( hc ed ji GC

    H GC j K GdGA a Gdf GE d GC L, K QL hb: "b Gb GC cjAGC eG GdS a HC S GC jD Nhg Hd hjHf GdjQ hT" )Gd hGE c:

    5/9393(.b: bd )hjHf( GC : jf YHfk .

    c GC L GS dL hb GC b Gd LGR e GC LGR JC L GdVeg GH Gd QV Gd Y.

    hGC f GC Qi GE Y GdL a e g GdO e d jO a f GE PG K GdLGdI Gd jD O Y GQJH GE d e hM j Gde H Gd Y

    J Pd a GBMO UQg hb TM QGC j a JC L Gdd a H aGdQU Gd GE d Gd GC hQhH dE aA.

    165

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • fF Gd:a gG Gd GdS Ya GdhQI d HC f Gd hGdI hGdL hGC f

    GUMk "GC e GE PG d jJ Gd g GC h bQ Gd" a eg GC NhGC f J Y GdL. hGC f GC Udk Gd Gd j Gda Y VhQG

    GdI Gd e L GdLO he L Gd. hHq GC U ehY GdhQI.hYq a GdL d HC f GaQ GE d GdA hPd g GdC QH hGdC QH g GdL.

    hYq ag GUMk HC f e f Y GdhQI H jD O a GE d e hbhMd GE d S hJ.

    K GE GdL e e g ML Ye Hj hg J Mk eGk hg eH Gd Gd j J a GBMO UQI a GC SSk dS

    hGS.hML NU a J JSk dhQI J M hJQ HQg hGC f

    QN Hd GC N, hPcf GC e dd hfb hV bYI Jj GdL edGdhQI a GdGY Gd hGC NL GC U GC Ud ek e Gdj GE d

    Je.c GC hV GC bYI Jj GdL ed GdhQI d Y GE Wb hGE GdL

    j GC j fGk dhQI Gd hGC GC e Gd Pchg e - hg GC Z- eU a Gd a e c GdL J ed GdhQI a GE q GC f GSA

    e GC U j Gdj c GdhQI GSA e fU J Hdj.he YG g GdQf GdF a jh Jj ed GdhQI eOGk M j bYI

    a b Hq GC f J e c Gd a bjk ce GdU a J edGdhQI a.

    166

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • hGC Tf GE d Jh OQL Gd a Gd hHq GC f JGL fk Hda h JaYeq k a c edd H Ja LF e LFJ hg a Gdd LF J GE d Gd

    H hJ f d j Y GdM hb GC jfg HSGA.c GC Hj GC hLk GC Ni JN a GdL M j Gd a Gd eOGk

    GC h M j GdV e Gd ehak GC h a TF Gdh hGQJ GC h jGd JHk hd eYk , GC h JN GdL eGb Gd d eLk d

    eL Y bF hK Yh.hGC L Gdh Gdgj a GdGJ Gd: eJ Gdq , heJ Gd, heJ

    Gdd.hgG GJ Gd Gdb d H GdhQI hGdL Gd ag a

    GdF Gd.hPcf H Gd e bGQG e Gd GE Se HI JGhM H

    GE bG hGE M Wk dj Gd hGdL hGdJk a Gdd GE d hLO fjC f H GC h GC U j Y. H GC Pcf bGQGk hGMGk d GC hQhH dE aA

    hGd, hY Y g GdGQG Jk eLGk Oh eb b J hJLY S Gd a gG Gd hGC Hj hL ff GdU Gd JGa bGQG

    Gd GC h Jd hJj GdGQG hHU a eC d JC L Gdd. c PdHNQ JQI HdQI Gdj GC h HE TQI Gdj Gd j GC g GNU.

    Gdh:1. e M Gdj: GdhQI TI hV heq J Gdq cd hGd

    hd Gdj he Gd, hGdL: GaQ hf a GC Y e GdhQI.2. GdhQI: GC Od fU hGV, hGdL: GC Od Ye.

    167

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • 3. GdhQI Gd: J GE d f a c Md J a H GE GE P H YSi e GS C Od GC Ni hbGF. hGdL: J GE d f E K GYQg hGC c

    GC e GdcQI cE LQI hGdGV hGdbI eU.4. GdhQI: Ja Gd hZ, hGdL ed g J Gd Y e jGg

    hHU ec Jhd Hd Vk , hb Jd bSk hJ e bYI.5. GdhQI: GC Kg eD b ehO H hGdL Gde GC Kg e.

    6. GdhQI T j H Z Gd hGdL j a JGM a GBMO GC aGOg.

    7. GdhQI QN Hd GC N hGdL Gde d QN HdGC N.

    8. GdhQI Ja fk a eJ Y e S Gd c Ja Z. hGdL Ja fk a eJ Y e eGJ Gd H JN eq e GdSF Oh ee

    GdU.9. GdhQI J GdO Gd j Gd a GC Uk GC h JHk hGdL J Gd

    Gd j a Gd JHk heak .01. GdhQI J Gd hGd hGdL J Gd Gd.

    11. GdhQI J Gd GdO hZ, hGdL J Zdk Gd Z GdOa Gd.

    21. GdhQI J H Oh GBN, hGdL J Gd GC Mfk a SGE Qa heh Oh b Gdj.

    168

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • 31. GdhQI J GE d N, hGdL JL Gd a e GNHh.

    hGC NGk d H Gdh Gd J C h eI H Gdj GC S a J gGdC d GC h Y GC b Hq GdL Gd Gd j Y GdM GC jD eq g

    hGdd Gd j dGQS GC jg. hfb eb Z eb bYIJj GdL ed GdhQI a GdGY Gd e GC f fY GS M

    GE GdOI L a eG Gd GdQI GC J eI Z eI.hGd Sf hJd hd Gda hg GdO H GE d SGA Gd.

    169

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • eGL Gd- GH J, GC H GdS J Gdj GC M H Y Gd, 827g,` e Gdhi, OGQ Gda dY

    hGd, Hh 7931g` ` 8791g.`- GH QT, GC H Gdd e H GC M H e GdW, 595g,` Gd hGd, GE OGQI GE MA GdG

    GE Se, b.- GH Y Gd, Y Gdj Y Gdj, bGY GC M, OGQ Gd, Hh 0041g.`

    - GH YHj, e GC e, 8521g,` MT QO GdQ Y GdQ GdQ, e GdH, GdgI6831g.`

    - GH GdH, GC H H e H Y Gd Gda GC fd, 245g,` Gd, Tc Y Gd,GdgI 6731g.`

    - GH Y, GC H e Y Gd GdQH GdfW, 145g,` Gd GdL, eD S OGQ Gd,GdgI.

    - GH bGe, ea Gdj GC H e Y Gd H GC M H e, 026g,` Gd, e GdgI, GdgI9831g.`

    - GH b GdRj, T Gdj GC H Y Gd e H GC H H, 157g,` GE Y Gdb Y QGdd, e Gd GC Rgj,GdgI 8831g.`

    - GE e Gde, GC H Gdd Y Gd H GC H Y Gd Gdj, Gdg, OGQ GC fQ, GdgI 0041g.`- GdL, GC H Gdd H S H N, 494g,` Gd T eWC GE e ed, OGQ Gd GdH,

    Hh 2331g.`- Gd, GC H Y Gd e H e H Y GdM GdY GdH, 459g,` eGg Gd

    Y e N, OGQ Gd, Hh.- GdQOj, GC H Gdc GC M H e H GC M, 1021g,` Gd Gd Y GC b Gdd GE d

    eg GE e ed, e Gdg GC Rgj, GdgI 6831g.`- Gde, T Gdj e H GC H GdS GC M H MI, 4001g,` fj Gd GE d T

    Gd, e GdH Gd, GdgI 6831g.`- GdQbf, Y Gdb, T Y Gd, OGQ Gd, Hh 8931g.`

    - GdW, L Gdj YGdM H GC H H, 119g,` GC T hGdF a bGY hah aGda, e GdH Gd, GdgI 8731g.`

    - GdW, GC H GE S GE HGg, GdGa, OGQ Gda, Hh.- GdW, GC HGE S GE HGg, GY, OGQ Gd Gd, Hh 8891.

    170

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • - Gdcf, e H Y H e, 0521g,` GE QTO Gd, OGQ Gd GdH, Hh 9141g.`- Gda, f Gdj, T e GdhV, eD S GdSd, GdgI.

    - Gd, S Y Gd, f GdO Y eGb GdO, Uh GE MA GdG, GdgI.- GdGd, GC H Me e H GC M, 505g,` TA Gd, J: M Gd, e GE QTO,

    HGO 6131g.`- GdGa, T Gdj GC H GdS GC M H GE OQj, 486g,` GdNI, OGQ Gd GE Se, Hh.

    - GdGa, T Gdj GC H GdS GC M H GE OQj, 486g,` Gdh, OGQ GE MA Gd GdH, GdgI4431g.`

    - GdW, GC H Y Gd e H GC M GC fQ, 176g,` Gde C M GdGB, OGQ Gd, GdgI6831g.`

    - GdSf, YA Gdj GC H H H eO, 785g,` HGF GdF a JJ GdGF, OGQ GdGdH, GdgI.

    - GdG, GC H Y Gd e H jS H GC H GdS GdQ, 798g,` Gd hGE c MT YGd, OGQ Gd, Hh 2991.

    - Gdh, GC H Rcj e Gdj H T Gda, 676g,` Gd T Gd, OGQ Gd,Hh.

    171

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq