The Corporation Code Reviewer
Transcript of The Corporation Code Reviewer
-
7/28/2019 The Corporation Code Reviewer
1/28
THE CORPORATION CODE
A. CORPORATIONDefinition
An artificial being created by operation of law, having the
right of succession and the powers, attributes and properties
expressly authorized by law or incident to its existence. (Sec.
2)
Attributes of a Corporation
i. An Artificial Being (Capacity to Contract andTransact Business)
A corporation exists by fiction of law. Hence, it canact only through its directors, officers, and
employees.
ii. Created by Operation of Law (Creature of theLaw)
Mere consent of the parties is not sufficient. The
State must give its consent either through a special
law (in case of government corporations) or a
general law (i.e., Corporation Code in case of
private corporations).
iii. Has the Right of Succession (Strong JuridicalPersonality)A corporation has the capacity for continuous
existence despite changes instockholders/members or by any transfer of shares
by a stockholder to a 3rd person.
iv. Has the Powers, Attributes, and PropertiesExpressly Authorized by Law or Incident to Its
Existence (A Creature of Limited Powers)
As a mere creature of law, it can exercise only such
powers as the law may choose to grant it, either
expressly or impliedly.
Corporate Fiction: A corporation has a personality separate
and distinct from the persons composing it. (Art. 44-47 of
the Civil Code; PNB vs. Andrada Electric Engineering Co.,
381 SCRA 244 (2002).B. CLASSES OF CORPORATION
IN RELATION TO STATE:a. Public Corporations
Formed or organized for the government of theportion of the state (e.g., barangay, municipality,
city, and province).
Created for political purposes connected with thepublic good in the administration of the civil
government.
Note: Ownership of the government of the majority of
the shares of a corporation does not qualify such entity
as a public corporation (National Coal Co., vs. CIR, 46
Phil 583, 1924).
b. Private by private persons alone or with the State. A corporation is created by operation of law under
the Corporation Code.
Mainly governed by the Corporation Code. A government-owned or controlled corporation
when organized under the Corporation Code is still
a private corporation. But being a government-
owned or controlled corporation makes it liable
for laws and provisions applicable to the
Government of its entities and subject to the
control of the Government(Cervantes vs. Auditor
General, 91 Phil 359, 1952).
c. On GOCCs
i. Created under a special law or charter
ii. Treated as private corporations not as pcorporations
Test to Determine Whether a Corporation is Govern
Owned or Controlled or Private in Nature:
Is it created by its own charter for the exercise of a p
function, or by incorporation under the general corpor
law?
d. Quasi-Public Corporations
A cross between private corporations and pcorporations.
Usually cover school districts, water districtsthe like (Villanueva, p. 75).AS TO PLACE OF INCORPORATION:a. Domestic
One formed, organized, or existing under the laws o
Philippines.
b. Foreign
One formed, organized or existing under any law other
those of the Philippines
- Whose laws allow Filipino citizens and corporatiodo business in its own country or State (princip
reciprocity).
- Licensed by SEC to do business in the Philippinessecuring a certificate of authority from the Boa
Investments and after complying with the conditionissuance of license on application forms, struc
organizations and capitalization.
AS TO GOVERNING LAW:a. PublicSpecial Laws and Local Government Codeb. Private Corporation Codec. Quasi-Public Corporations seems to be a
between private corporations and public corporatio
AS TO LEGAL STATUS:a. De Jure Corporation
A corporation organized in accordance with
requirements of law.
Every corporation is deemed de jure until potherwise.b. De Facto Corporation (Sec. 20)
- A corporation claiming in good faith to corporation under the Corporation Code.
- Corporation where there exists a flaw iincorporation, it falls short of the requiremen
law.
- It is the result of an attempt to incorporate uan existing law coupled with the exercis
corporate powers.
- Under the Sec. 66 of the Rules of Court, inmust be done by the Solicitor General in a
warranto proceeding - the main issue is the ri
exist as a corporation.
- A de facto corporation will incur the obligation, have the same powers and rights a
jure corporation.
Elements:1. A valid law under which incorporated;2. Attempt in good faith to incorporat
colorable compliance;3. Assumption of corporate powers; and4. Issuance of certificate of incorpor
(Arnold Hall vs. Piccio, 86 Phil 634, 195
A corporation which has failed to file its by-laws withi
prescribed period does not ipso facto lose its powers as
(Sawadjaan vs. CA, 459 SCRA 516, 2004).
-
7/28/2019 The Corporation Code Reviewer
2/28
DE JURE DE FACTO
Created in strict or
substantial conformity with
the statutory requirements
for incorporation
Actually exists for all
practical purposes as a
corporation but which has
no legal right to corporate
existence as against the
State
Right to exist cannot be
successfully attacked even ina direct proceeding by the
State
Right to exercise powers
cannot be inquired intocollaterally in any private
suit. But such inquiry may
be made by the State in a
proper court proceeding.
c. Corporation by Estoppel
- All persons who assume to act as a corporationknowing it to be without authority to do so shall be
liable as general partners for all debts, liabilities
and damages incurred or arising as a result thereof.
- Where a group of persons misrepresent themselvesas a corporation (ostensible corporation), they are
subsequently estopped from claiming lack of
corporate life in order to avoid liability.- A third party who assumes an obligation to an
ostensible corporation cannot resist performance
by alleging the ostensible corporations lack ofpersonality.
-DE FACTO BY ESTOPPEL
Existence in Law Yes None
Dealings among
parties on a
corporate basis
Not required Required
Effect of lack of
requisites
Could be a
corporation by
estoppel
Not a corporation
in any shape or
form
d. Corporation by Prescription
- The Roman Catholic Church is a corporation byprescription, with acknowledged juridical personality
inasmuch as it is an institution which antedated by
almost a thousand years any other personality in
Europe (Barlin vs. Ramirez, 7 Phil. 41, 1906).
AS TO EXISTENCE OF STOCKS:a. Stock Corporation
- One which has a capital stock divided into shares andis authorized to distribute to the holders such
shares, dividends or allotments of the surplus profits
(i.e., retained earnings on the basis of the shares held
(Sec. 3)
- It is organized for profit.- The governing body is usually the Board of Directors
(except in certain instances, e.g. close corporations)
- Even if there is a statement of capital stock, thecorporation is still NOT a stock corporation if
dividends are not supposed to be declared, that is,
there is no distribution of retained earnings (CIR vs.
Club Filipino de Cebu, 1962).
b. Non-Stock Corporation (See Sec. 87-88)- A corporation where no part of its income is
distributable as dividends to members, trustees or
officers.
- Corporation that does not issue stocks and does notdistribute dividends to their members.
- Not organized for profit.- Profit obtained as incident to operation had
used for the furtherance of the purpose/s for w
the corporation was organized.
- The governing body is usually the Board of TrusAS TO RELATIONSHIP OF MANAGEMENT AND CONTR
a. Holding Company one that controls another subsidiary or affiliate by the power to elec
management; one which holds in other companie
the purpose of control rather than for mere investm
b. Affiliate Company one that is subject to comcontrol to a mother or holding company and operatpart of a system.
c. Parent and Subsidiary Companies whecorporation has a controlling financial interest in o
more corporations, the one having in control is k
as the parent company and the others are know
subsidiary companies.
- A subsidiary of a specified person affiliate controlled by such person, direc
indirectly, though one or more intermedia
AS TO FUNCTIONS:a. Public government of a portion of the State; andb. Private - usually for profit-making functions.
AS TO PURPOSE OF INCORPORATION:a. Municipal Corporationb. Religious Corporationc. Educational Corporationd. Charitable, Scientific or Vocational Corporatione. Business Corporation
AS TO NUMBER OF MEMBERS:a. Aggregate a corporation which consists of
persons united to form a body politic and corp
(Quimson, p. 156)
b. Corporation Sole may be formed by the archbishop, bishop, minister, rabbi, or other pres
elder of any religious denomination, sect or church.
-Purpose: formed for the purposadministering and managing, as trustee
affairs, properties, and temporalities o
religious denomination to which the hold
the office belongs and also to transmi
same to his successor in office (Sec. 110).
Director of Land vs. IAC, 146 SCRA 509 (1986) held
corporation sole has no nationality, overturned the pre
doctrine (Republic vs. Villanueva, 114 SCRA 875 [1
and Republic vs. Iglesia ni Cristo, 127 SCRA 687 [1that a corporation sole is disqualified to acquire or
alienable lands of the public domain, because of
constitutional prohibition qualifying only individua
acquire land of the public domain and the provision u
the Public Land Act which applied only to Filipino citize
natural persons. {Republic vs. Iglesia ni Cristo, 127
687 (1984); Republic vs. IAC, 168 SCRA 165 (1988)}.
OTHER CLASSIFICATION:
a. Close Corporation the issued stock of all classesbe held of record by not more than twenty persons;
not list in any stock exchange or make any p
offering any of its stocks.
- Any corporation may be incorporated close corporation, except mining o
companies, stock exchanges, banks, insu
companies, public utilities, educa
institutions and corporations declared
vested with public interest (Sec. 96).
-
7/28/2019 The Corporation Code Reviewer
3/28
b. Eleemosynary Corporation one organized forcharitable purposes.
C. NATIONALITY OF CORPORATIONSServes as a legal basis for subjecting the enterprise or its
activities to the laws, the economic and fiscal powers, and
various social and financial policies of the state to which it is
supposed to belong.
Tests:
1. Place of Incorporation- Principal doctrine on the test of the nationality
of a corporate identity in the Philippines- A corporation is a national of the country
under whose laws has been organized and
registered
2. Control TestA corporation shall be considered a Filipino corporation
if the Filipino ownership of its capital stock is at least
60%, and where the 60-40 Filipino-Alien equity
ownership is NOT in doubt (SEC opinion dated 6
November 1989; DOJ Opinion No. 18, s. 1989).
Therefore, its shareholdings in another corporation
shall be considered to be Filipino nationality when
computing the percentage of Filipino equity of the
second corporation (SEC Opinion dated 23 November
1993).
Control test is applied in the following:
Exploitation of natural resourcesOnly Filipinocitizens or corporations whose capital stock are at
least 60% owned by Filipinos can qualify to exploit
natural resources. (Sec. 2, Art. XII, Conti.)
Public Utilities xxx no franchise, certificate orany other form of authorization for the operation of
a public utility shall be granted except to citizens of
the Philippines or corporations organized under
the laws of the Philippines at least 60% of whose
capital is owned by such citizens. (Sec. 11, Art. XII,Consti.)
Mass Media Ownership of mass media shall belimited to the citizens of the Philippines, or tocorporations, cooperatives, or associations, wholly-
owned and managed by such citizens (100%Filipino management of the entity)[Sec 11, Art. XVI,
Consti.]
Cable Industry CATV as a form of mass mediawhich must, therefore, be owned and managed by
Filipino citizens, or corporations, cooperatives, or
associations, wholly-owned and managed by such
citizens pursuant to the mandate of the
Constitution. (DOJ Opinion No. 95, s. 1999)
Advertising Industry xxx only Filipino citizensor corporations or associations at least 70% of
whose capital is owned by such citizens is allowed
to engage in the advertising agency. (Sec 11, Art.
XVI, Constitution)
3. Grandfather RuleIt is a method of determining the nationality of a
corporation which in turn is owned in part by another
corporation by breaking down the equity structure of
the shareholder corporation.
It involves the computation of Filipino ownership of a
corporation in which another corporation of partly
Filipino and partly foreign equity owns capital stock.
The percentage of shares held by the second
corporation in the first is multiplied by the latters own
Filipino equity, and the product of these percentages is
determined to be the ultimate Filipino ownership o
subsidiary corporation (SEC Opinion re: Silahis)
Ex. MV Corporation and AC Corporation have
interest in XYZ Corporation. MV Corporation is
owned by Filipinos while AC Corporation is 50% o
by Filipinos. By the grandfather rule, MV Corpor
would have a 30% Filipino interest in XYZ Com
(60% 0f 50%), while AC Corporation would have a
Filipino interest in XYZ Company (50% of 50%). H
the total Filipino interest is only 55%.
Note: the application of the test is limited to the iof investment. Only when the corporation is less
60% owned shall the grandfather rule be applied.
D. CORPORATE JURIDICAL PERSONALITY1. Doctrine of Separate Juridical Personality
A corporation has personality separate and disfrom that of its stockholders and members and i
affected by the personal rights, obligations,
transactions of the latter.
The property of the corporation is not the property
stockholders or members and may not be sold by
without express authorization from the Boar
Directors (Woodchild Holdings, Inc. vs. R
Electric and Construction Co. 436 SCRA 235, 200
Stockholders have no claim on corporate proper
owners, but mere expectancy or inchoate right t
same upon dissolution of the corporation afte
corporate creditors have been paid. Such right is lim
only to their equity interest (doctrine of limited liab
Although a stockholders interest in the corporationbe attached by his personal creditor, corporate pro
cannot be used to satisfy his claim (Wise & Co. vs
Sun Lung, 1940)
a. Liability for TortsAs a separate juridical personality, a corpor
can be held liable for torts committed by its of
for corporate purpose (PNB vs. CA, 1978).
Corporate tort consists in the violation of agiven or the omission of a duty imposed by l
breach of legal duty.
The failure of the corporate employer to co
with the law-imposed duty under the Labor Co
grant separation pay to employees in ca
cessation of operations constitutes tort an
stockholder who was actively engaged in
management or operation of the business shou
personally liable. (Sergio F. Naguiat vs. NLRC
SCRA 564, 1997)
b. Liability for CrimesSince a corporation is a mere legal fiction, it c
be proceeded against criminally because it c
commit a crime in which personal violencmalicious intent is required. Criminal acti
limited to the corporate agents guilty of a
amounting to a crime and never against
corporation itself (West Coast Life Insuranc
vs. Hurd [1914], Time Inc. vs. Reyes [1971])
General Rule: Corporations cannot co
felonies punishable under the RPC for
incapable of the requisite intent to commit
crimes. Also, crimes are personal in n
requiring personal performance of overt
Finally, a corporation cannot be arrested
imprisoned; hence, cannot be penalized for a
punishable by imprisonment.
-
7/28/2019 The Corporation Code Reviewer
4/28
Exceptions:
If the crime is committed by a corporation, the
directors, officers, employees or other officers
thereof responsible for the offense shall be charged
and penalized for the crime, precisely because of
the nature of the crime and the penalty therefore. A
corporation cannot be arrested and imprisoned;
hence, cannot be penalized for a crime punishable
by imprisonment. However a corporation may be
charged and prosecuted for a crime if the
imposable penalty is fine (Ching vs. Secretary ofJustice, GR NO. 164317, February 6, 2006)
When express provisions of law are enacted
specifically providing that a corporation may be
proceeded against criminally, it is the responsible
officer who will be held personally liable for the
crimes committed by the corporation. (Sia vs. CA ,
GR No 111809, May 5, 1997)
Under the Anti-Money Laundering Act, juridical
persons are also defined as offenders of criminal
acts.
c. Recovery of Moral DamagesGeneral Rule:
Moral damages cannot be awarded in favor of
corporations because they do not have feelings and
mental state. They may not even claim moraldamages for besmirched reputation (NAPOCOR vs.
Philipp Brothers Oceanic, G.R. No. 126204.
November 20, 2001).
Exceptions:
A corporation can recover moral damages under
Art. 2219 (7) if it was the victim of defamation
(Filipinas Broadcasting Network vs. Ago
Medical and Educational Center 448 SCRA 413,
2005)A corporation with a good reputation, if
besmirched, is allowed to recover moral damages
upon proof of existence of factual basis of damage
(actual injury) and its causal relation (Crystal vs.
BPI, 2008).
2. Doctrine of Piercing the Corporate VeilThis doctrine means that the court may disregard the
separate and distinct personality of the corporation
from its members or stockholders and treat the
corporation as a mere collection of individuals or an
aggregation of persons undertaking business as a group
especially when the corporate legal entity is used as a
cloak for fraud or illegality. (Kukan Internatl. Vs.
Reyes, September 29, 2010).
It is merely an equitable remedy, and may be granted
only in cases when the corporate fiction is used to defeat
public convenience, justify a wrong, protect fraud
defend crime or where the corporation is a mere alter
ego of business conduit of a person.
a. Grounds for Application of Doctrinei. If done to defraud the government of
taxes due it.
ii. If done to evade payment of civil liability.iii. If done by a corporation which is merely a
conduit or alter ego of another
corporation.
iv. If done to evade compliance withcontractual obligations.
v. If done to evade compliance with financialobligation to its employees.
b. Test in Determining ApplicabilityGeneral Rule: The mere fact that a corporation
owns all or substantially all of the stocks of another
corporation is NOT sufficient to justify their
treated as one entity.
Exception: The subsidiary is a instrumentalityof the parent corporation.
Circumstances rendering subsidiary
instrumentality (PNB vs. Ritratto Group, 200
i. The parent corporation owns all or mthe capitalof the subsidiary.
ii. The parent and subsidiary corporahave common directors and officers.
iii. The parent company finances subsidiary.
iv. The parent company subscribed to acapital stock of the subsidiaryor othe
causes its incorporation.
v. The subsidiary has grossly inadecapital.
vi. The parent corporation pays the saand other expenses or losses of
subsidiary.
vii. The subsidiary has substantiallybusiness except with the p
corporation or no assets except
conveyed to or by the parent corpora
viii. The papers of the parent corporationthe statements of its officers, is subsdescribed as a department or subdivis
the parent corporation, or its busine
financial responsibility is referred
the parent corporations own.
ix. The parent corporation uses the proof the subsidiary as its own.
x. The directors or executives ofsubsidiary do not act independently i
interest of the subsidiary but take
orders from the parent corporation.
xi. The formal and legal requirements osubsidiary are not observed.
E. INCORPORATION AND ORGANIZATION
1. PromoterPromoters are persons who, acting alone or with o
take the initiative in founding and organizing
business or enterprise of the issuer and rec
consideration therefore (RA 8799, Securities Regu
Code).
a. Liability of PromoterGeneral Rule: The promoter binds hi
personally and assumes the responsibilit
looking to the proposed corporation
reimbursement.
Exception:
Any express or implied agreement to the conor novation of the contract.
The court ruled in Caram Jr. vs. CA thainvestors who were not the moving spirit bthe organization of the corporation, but who
merely convinced to invest in the prop
corporate venture on the basis of the feas
study undertaken, are NOT liable personally
the corporation for the cost of such feasibility
(Caram Jr. vs. CA 151 SCRA 372, 1987) .
Exception to Exception: Where was a showing that the corporation
fictitious and did not have a sep
juridical personality, to justify the m
the principal stockholders th
responsible for its stockholders.
b. Liability of Corporation for PromoContracts
-
7/28/2019 The Corporation Code Reviewer
5/28
General Rule: A corporation is not bound by the
contract. Since the corporation did not yet exist at
the time of the contract, it could not have an agent
who could legally bind it.
Exceptions: A corporation may be bound by the
contract if it makes the contract its own by:
Adoption of ratification of the entire contract afterincorporation.
Acceptance of benefits under the contract withknowledge of the terms thereof.
Performance of its obligation under the contract.2. Number and Qualifications of Incorporators
Incorporators are stockholders or members mentionedin the articles originally forming and composing the
corporation and who are signatories thereof.
Natural persons Of legal age Must own or subscribe at least one share of stock of
the corporation (Genuine interest)
5 to 15 incorporators who must sign the articles ofincorporation (AOI)
Majority of the incorporators must be residents ofthe Philippines
3. Corporate Name Limitations on Use of CorporateName
Must not be identical or deceptively or confusinglysimilar to that of any existing corporation including
internationally known foreign corporation though
not used in the Philippines;
Any other name already protected by law; Name that is patently defective, confusing or
contrary to existing laws, morals or public policy
(Sec. 18).
Must include the word Corporation/Corp.orIncorporated/Inc.
Change of Corporate Name
Requires amendment of the AOI: majority vote of the
board and the vote or written assent of stockholders
holding 2/3 of the outstanding capital stock (Sec 16).
Doctrines Pertaining to Corporate Name
A corporation may change its name by the amendment
of AOI, but the same is not effective until approved by
the SEC (Philippine First Insurance Co. vs. Hartigan34 SCRA 252, 1970).
A change in the corporate name does not make a new
corporation, and whether affected by a special act or
under a general law, has no effect on the identity of the
corporation, or on its property, rights, or liabilities.
Consequently, the new corporation is still liable for the
debts and obligations of the old corporation(Republic
Planters Bank vs. CA 216 SCRA 738, 1992).
Similarity on corporate names between two
corporations would cause confusion to the public
especially when the purposes stated in their charter are
also the same type of business (Universal Mills Corp.vs. Universal Textile Mills Inc. 78 SCRA 62, 1977).
A corporation has no right to intervene in a suit using a
name other than its registered name; if a corporation
legally and truly wants to intervene, it should have used
its corporate name as the law requires and not another
name which it had not registered (LaureanoInvestment and Development Corp. vs. CA 272 SCRA
253, 1997).
There would be no denial of due process wh
corporation is sued and judgment is rendered agai
in its unregistered trade name, holding th
corporation may be sued under the name by wh
makes itself known to its workers (Pison-A
Agricultural Development Corp. vs. NLRC 279
312, 1997).
4. Corporate TermNot more than 50 years from date of incorpor
subject to extension for periods not exceeding 50
per extension unless:
Sooner dissolved, or Extended
Extensions:
Not earlier than 5 years prior to expiry Unless earlier extension is for justi
reasons as determined by SEC.
How to extend amend the AOI during the lthe corporation before the expiry of its term. Any dissenting stockholder may exercise
appraisal right (Sec. 37).
5. Minimum Capital Stock and SubscriRequirementsAt the time of incorporation:
At least25% of authorized capital stockas sin the AOI must be subscribed
At least 25% of the total subscription mupaid upon subscription, the balance to be pa
on a date or dates fixed in the contra
subscription without need of call, or in the ab
of a fixed date or dates, upon call for payme
the BOD.
Call term used when the Board forasks for payment of the balance o
subscription or a part thereof.
No minimum authorized capital stock is required eif required by special laws (Sec. 12 and 13)
Minimum paid-up capital is not less than P5,000.6. Articles of Incorporation
a. Nature and Function of Articles
The AOI is a basic contract documenCorporation Law that defines the charter of
corporation. Section 14 of the Corporation
provides that the AOI do not become binding a
charter of the corporation unless they have ben
with the SEC.
b. Contentsi. Name of corporation;
ii. Purpose/s, indicating the primary secondary purposes;
iii. Place of principal office;iv. Term which shall not be more than 50 yeav. Names, citizenship and residences
incorporators;vi. Number, names, citizenships and residendirectors;
vii. If stock corporation, amount of authocapital stock, number of shares;
viii. In par value stock corporations, the par of each share;
ix. Number of shares and amounts of subscriof subscribers which shall not be less
25% of authorized capital stock;
x. Amount paid by each subscriber on subscription, which shall not be less than
of subscribed capital and shall not be less
P5,000.00;
xi. Name of treasurer elected by subscribers;xii. If the corporation engages in a nationa
-
7/28/2019 The Corporation Code Reviewer
6/28
industry, a statement that no transfer of stock
will be allowed if it will reduce the stock
ownership of Filipinos to a percentage below
the required legal minimum.
c. Amendment
Requirements:i. A legitimate purpose for the amendment;
ii. by a majority vote of the board of directors ortrustees;
iii. by a vote or written assent of the stockholdersrepresenting at least two thirds (2/3) of the
outstanding capital stock, without prejudice tothe appraisal right of dissenting stockholders
in accordance with the provisions of the
Corporation Code;
iv. by a vote or written assent of at least twothirds (2/3) of the members if it be a non-stock
corporation.
v. The original and amended articles, together,shall contain all provisions required by law to
be set out in the articles of incorporation. Such
articles, as amended, shall be indicated by
underscoring the change or changes made, and
a copy thereof duly certified under oath by the
corporate secretary and a majority of the
directors or trustees stating the fact that the
said amendment or amendments have beenduly approved by the required vote of
stockholders or members, shall be submitted
to the Securities and Exchange Commission
(SEC).When the SEC is satisfied that theamendment should be allowed, the SEC will
issue a certificate indicating its approval. The
amendments shall take effect upon approval
by the SEC, or from the date of filing with the
SEC if not acted upon within six (6) months
from the date of filing for a cause not
attributable to the corporation.
d. Non-amendable Items
i. Names of incorporatorsii. Names of incorporating directors/trusteesiii. Names of original subscribers to capital stock
and subscribed and paid- up capital
iv. Treasurer-in-trust elected by originalsubscribers
v. Members who contributed to the initial capitalof non-stock corporation
vi. Place and date of executionvii. Witnesses and acknowledgments (De Leon,
2010)
7. Registration and Issuance of Certificate ofIncorporation
Documents to be filed with the SEC:i. Articles of Incorporation
ii. Treasurers affidavit certifying that 25% of thetotal authorized capital stock has been
subscribed and at least 25% of such has been
fully paid in cash or property
iii. Bank certificate showing the paid-up capitaliv. Letter authority authorizing the SEC to
examine the bank deposit and other corporate
books and records to determine the existence
of paid-up capital.
v. Undertaking to change the corporate name incase there is another person or entity with
same or similar name that was previously
registered.
vi. Certificate of authority from pgovernment agency whenever appropriat
BSP for banks and Insurance Commissio
insurance corporation (Sundiang and Aqu
Issuance of Certificate of Incorporation by SECThe SEC shall give the incorporators reasonable ti
correct or modify the objectionable portions o
articles or amendments (Sec. 17).
Grounds for Disapproving AOI:i. AOI does not substantially comply wit
form prescribedii. Purpose is patently unconstitutional, ilimmoral, contrary to government rules
regulations
iii. Treasurers Affidavit concerning the amof capital subscribed and or paid is false
iv. Required percentage of ownership of Filcitizens has not been complied with.
Remedy in case of rejection of AOI pe
for review in accordance with the Rul
Court (Sec. 6, last par., PD 902-A).
Commencement of corporate existence
juridical personality upon issuanc
certificate of incorporation (Sec. 19)
Revocation of certificate of incorporatio
the incorporators are guilty of frauprocuring the same after due notice
hearing (Sec. 6(i), PD 902-A).
8. Adoption of By-Laws (Sec. 46)After Incorporation within one month after rece
official notice of the issuance of its certificat
incorporation by the SEC.
Before Incorporation approved and signed by a
incorporators and submitted to SEC together with A
a) Nature and FunctionsBy-laws are mere internal rules a
stockholders and cannot affect or prejudice
persons who deal with the corporation unlesshave knowledge of the same (China Ban
Corporation vs. CA, 1997).
Regulations, ordinances, rules or laws adopt
an association or corporation or the like fo
internal governance, including rules for ro
matters such as calling meetings and the like
Vs. Mandaue Packing Products Plants U
FFW, 467 SCRA 107, 2005).
b) Requisites of Valid By-Laws (Sec. 46)i. Must be approved by the affirmative
of the stockholders representing
majority of the outstanding capital
or majority of members (if filed pri
incorporation, approved and signed
incorporators).
ii. Must be kept in the principal office ocorporation; subject to inspectio
stockholders or members during
hours (Sec. 64).
iii. It must be consistent with the CorporCode, other pertinent laws
regulations.
iv. It must be consistent with the AOI.v. It must be reasonable and not arbitra
oppressive.
vi. It must not disturb vested rights, imcontracts or property rights
-
7/28/2019 The Corporation Code Reviewer
7/28
stockholders or members or create
obligations unknown to law.
c) Binding EffectsOnlyfrom the issuance of SEC certification that by-
laws are not inconsistent with the Code.
Cannot bind stockholders or corporation pending
approval.
As to the Corporation and its Components- Binding not only upon the corporation but also on
its stockholders, members and those having
direction, management and control of its affairs.
They have the force of contract betweenstockholders/members.
As to Third Persons
- Not binding unless there is actual knowledge.Third persons are not even bound to investigate the
content because they are not bound to know the by-
laws which are merely provisions for the
government of a corporation and notice to them
will not be presumed (China Banking
Corporation vs. CA, 1997).
d) Amendment or Revision (Sec. 48)Majority vote of the members of the Board and
majority vote of the owners of OCS or members, in
a meeting duly called for the purpose; or
Delegation to the BOD of power to amend or repeal
by-laws by vote of stockholders representing 2/3 of
OCS or 2/3 of the members.
Such delegated power is considered revoked by
majority vote only of stockholders representing 2/3
of OCS or 2/3 of the members.
. CORPORATE POWERS
. GENERAL POWERSEvery corporation has the power and capacity:
i. To sue and be sued in its corporate name;In the absence of a special authority from the Board of Directors
to institute a derivative suit, the President or Managing Director
is disqualified by law to sue in her own name or on behalf of the
corporation. The power to sue and be sued in any court by a
corporation even as a stockholder is lodged in the Board of
Directors that exercises corporate powers and not in the
President. (Bitong v. CA, 292 SCRA 304)
ii. Of succession by its corporate ;A corporation has a capacity of continuous existence irrespective
of the death, withdrawal, insolvency, or incapacity of the
individual stockholders or members and regardless of the
transfer of their interest or shares of stock.
iii. To adopt and use a corporate seal;However, a corporation may exist without a seal.
iv. To amend its articles of incorporation;v. To adopt by-laws, not contrary to law, morals, or public
policy, and to amend or repeal the same;
vi. In case of stock corporations, to issue or sell stocks tosubscribers and to sell treasury stocks, or admit members to
the corporation if it be non-stock corporation;
vii. Purchase, receive, take or grant, hold, convey, sell, lease,pledge, mortgage and otherwise deal with such real and
personal property, including securities and bonds of
corporations;
While a corporation may appoint agents to negotiate fo
purchase of real property needed by the corporation, the fina
will have to be with the Board of Directors whose approva
finalize the transaction. (Firme v. Bukal Enterprises, 414
190)
viii. To enter into merger or consolidation with corporations;
ix. To make reasonable donations, provided, that no corporshall give donations in aid of any political party or candor for purposes of partisan political activity;
x. To establish pension, retirement, and other plans fobenefit of its directors, trustees, officers and employees;
xi. To exercise other powers as may be essential or necessacarry out its purpose or purposes stated in the articl
incorporation.
2. SPECIFIC POWERSi. Power to Extend or Shorten Corporate Terms
Requirements:
- Majority vote of the Board of Directors or Trustees
- Ratification at a meeting by 2/3 of the outstancapital stock or members
An extension of corporate term allows a dissenting stockhold
exercise his appraisal right.
ii. Power to Increase or Decrease Capital Stock or ICreate, Increase Bonded Indebtedness
Requirements:
- Majority vote of the board of directors- Favored by 2/3 of the outstanding capital stock
Ways to increase or decrease capital stock:
i. By increasing/decreasing the number of sauthorized to be issued without increasing/decrethe par value thereof;
ii. By increasing/decreasing the par value of each without increasing/decreasing the number thereof
iii. By increasing/decreasing both the number of sauthorized to be issued and the par value thereof.
A corporate bond is an obligation to pay a definite sum of m
at a future time at fixed rate of interest.
A business corporation may borrow money whenever
necessity of its business so requires and issue securit
customary evidence of debt such as notes, bonds or mortg
This includes non-stock corporations as well.
iii. Power to deny pre-emptive rightWhenever the capital stock of a corporation is increasedand
shares of stock are issued, the new issue must be offered fi
the stockholders who are such at the time the increase was
in proportion to their existing shareholdings and on equal t
with other holders of the original stocks before subscription
received from the general public. This is called a Pre-em
right .
The pre-emptive right of stockholders of a stock corporati
subscribe to all issues or disposition of shares of any cla
proportion to their respective shareholdings may be denie
the articles of incorporation.
-
7/28/2019 The Corporation Code Reviewer
8/28
EXCEPTIONS:
i. Stocks issued in compliance with laws requiringstock offerings or minimum stock ownership by the
public
ii. Stocks issued in good faith with approval ofstockholders representing 2/3 of the OSC:
-In exchange for property needed for corporate purposes
-in payment of a previously contracted debt.
iv. Power to Sell or Dispose All or Substantially All of theCorporate Assets
Requirements:- Majority vote of its board of directors- Authorization by 2/3 of stockholders of the OSC or
members. Provided, that in non-stock corporations,
where there are no members with voting rights, the vote
of at least a majority of the trustees will be sufficient for
authorization.
- Authorization must be done at a stockholders ormembers meeting duly called for that purpose after
written notice.
Any dissenting stockholder may exercise his appraisal rights.
A sale or disposition shall be deemed to cover substantially
all the corporate property and assets if thereby the
corporation would be rendered incapable of continuing thebusiness or accomplishing the purpose for which it was
incorporated.
If the corporation can sell, it can also abandon the
transaction through the board without further action or
approval by the stockholders or members but subject to
rights of third parties under any contract relating thereto.
v. Power to Acquire Its Own SharesA stock corporation shall have the power to purchase or
acquire its own shares for a legitimate corporate purpose,
provided that the corporation has unrestricted retained
earnings. It includes the following cases:
i. To eliminate fractional shares arising out of stockdividends;
ii. To collect or compromise an indebtedness to thecorporation, arising out of unpaid subscription, in a
delinquency sale, and to purchase delinquent
shares sold during said sale;
iii. To pay dissenting or withdrawing stockholdersentitled to payment for their shares. (Sec. 41,
Corporation Code)
Conditions for the exercise of the power:
i. The capital is not impaired;ii. For a legitimate and proper corporate purpose;iii. There is unrestricted retained earnings to purchase
the same;
iv. The corporation acts in good faith withoutprejudicing the rights of creditors and
stockholders;
v. The conditions of corporate affairs warrant it;(De Leon, Corporation Code of the Philippines, 2010)
vi. Power to Invest Corporate Funds in Another Corporationor Business
A private corporation may invest its funds in any other
corporation or business or for any purpose other than the
primary purpose for which it was organized.
Requirements:
- Majority vote of board of directors or trustees- Ratification by the 2/3 stockholders representin
OSC or members. However, if the investme
reasonably necessary to accomplish the corpora
primary purpose, the approval of the stockholde
members shall not be necessary.
Any dissenting stockholder may exercise his appraisal r
The other purposes for which the funds may be invested wi
amending the articles of incorporation must be those enume
in the articles of incorporation. In order to engage in any secondary purposes, the corporation must comply with the a
requirement. A corporation is not allowed to engage
business distinct from those enumerated in the articl
incorporation without amending the purpose clause of
articles to include the desired business activity amon
secondary purpose. (De Leon, Corporation Code of
Philippines, 2010)
vii. Power to Declare DividendsThe board of directors of a stock corporation may de
dividends out of the unrestricted retained earnings which sh
payable in cash, in property, or in stock to all stockholders o
basis of outstanding stock held by them;
Provided, that any cash dividends due on delinquent stock
first be applied to the unpaid balance on the subscription
costs and expenses, while stock dividends shall be withheld
the delinquent stock holder until his unpaid subscription is
paid; (Sec. 43)
Requirement:
- Approval of stockholders representing not less thaof the OSC
- In a regular or special meeting duly called fopurpose
- Existence of unrestricted retained earningsA stock corporation is prohibited from retaining suprofit in excess of 100% of their paid-in capital stock, ex
- When justified by definite corporate expansion pror programs approved by the board of directors;
- When prohibited under any loan agreement withfinancial institution or creditor without their hi
consent;
- That such retention is necessary under spcircumstances obtaining in the corporation, suc
when there is a need for special reserve for pro
contingencies. (Sec. 43, par 2)
Dividend, is that part or portion of the profits
corporation set aside, declared and ordered by the dire
to be paid ratably to the stockholders on demand or
fixed time.
Stock Dividends, these dividends are payable in uni
additional shares of the corporation instead of cas
property out of the unrestricted retained earnings. T
are issued by a resolution of the board and approv
stockholders. It must also require to have unissueds
for distribution to stockholders, otherwise, it must inc
its capital stock to the extent of corporate earnings
declared.
Cash Dividends,these are dividend payable in cash. Tcan be declared by mere board resolution from unrest
retained earnings.
-
7/28/2019 The Corporation Code Reviewer
9/28
Property Dividends,these are dividends distributed to the
stockholders in the form of property, real or personal, such
as warehouse receipts, or shares of stock of another
corporation. This is actually cash dividend since the
stockholder may sell the property received and realize cash.
These must be properties no longer intended to be used by
the corporation for its business. However, no actual
distribution of property dividend shall be made without
approval by the Commission.
The participation of each stockholder in the earnings of the
corporation is based on his total subscription and not on the
amount paid by him in account thereof. Ex. A subscribes to1,000 shares of the par value P10.00 per share and has paid
P5,000 on his subscription, he will participate in dividends
on the basis of 1,000 shares, not 500 shares. (De Leon,
Corporation Code of the Philippines, 2010)
Dividends are usually declared generally quarterly. But the
directors may declare dividends in advance for succeeding
quarters when the business is in good shape and abundant
with revenues.
viii. Power to enter into Management ContractA management contract is one whereby the corporation
undertakes to manage or operate all or substantially all of
the business of another corporation. A managementcontracts must not be longer than 5 years for any one term.
However, service contracts which relate to the exploitation,
development, exploration or utilization of natural resources
may be entered into for such periods provided by law or
regulation. (De Leon, 2010)
Requirements:
- Resolution of a quorum of the Board ofDirectors/Trustees; and
- Ratified by a majority vote by the stockholdersrepresenting the outstanding capital stock or members,
as the case may be, in a meeting called for the purpose;
- In both cases, such votes must be made by both themanaging and managed corporation.
EXCEPT: That 2/3 votes shall be necessary if:
- Stockholder who represents the interest of bothcorporations owns 1/3 of the outstanding capital stock
of the managing corporation.
- Majority of the members of the Board of the managingcorporation compose also majority of the members of
the board of the managed corporation.
(Villanueva, Commercial Law Reviewer, 2009)
ix. Ultra Vires ActsThese are acts not within the express, implied, and incidental
powers of the corporation conferred by the Corporation Code orits articles of incorporation.
There are three types ofultra vires acts:
1. Those outside the express, implied or incidental powersof the corporation;
2. Those which are effected by corporate representativeswho act without authority;
3. Those which are contrary to laws or public policy. Applicability of Ultra Vires ActsThe term ultra vires is distinguished from an illegal act since
the former is merely voidable which may be enforced by
performance, ratification, or estoppels, while the latt
void and cannot be validated.
When a contract or act is illegal per se , it is wholly vo
inexistent. But when a contract is not illegal per s
merely beyond thepower of a corporation, the sam
merely voidable and may be enforced by perform
ratification, or estoppels or on equitable ground.
Consequences of Ultra Vires Acts- If executor on both sides, it cannot be enforced by e
party thereto.
-
If fully performed on both sides, neither partymaintain an action to set aside the transaction
recover what he has parted with.
- If performed on one side and the other has recbenefits by reason of such performance, recove
permitted on the ground that it would be unju
sanction retention of benefits coupled with refu
perform (De Leon, 2010)
3. HOW THESE POWERS ARE EXERCISEDa. StockholdersStockholders have residual power of fundamental corp
changes in the exercise of their right to vote.
b. Board of DirectorsGenerally, the Board of Directors alone exercises the powe
the corporation. The board exercises their power through b
meetings.
c. OfficersCorporate officers may exercise corporate powers via auth
from:
1. Law2. Corporate By-laws3. Authorization from the board, either expressly or imp
by habit, custom or acquiescence in the general courbusiness.
4. TRUST FUND DOCTRINEThe assets of a corporation of the corporation as represent
its capital stock are trust funds to be maintained unimpand to be used to pay corporate creditors in the sense that
can be no distribution of such assets among the stockho
without provision being first made for the payment o
corporate debts and that any such disposition of it is a frau
the creditors of a corporation who extend credit on good fa
its outstanding capital stock and, therefore, void. (Philip
Trust Co. v. Rivera, 144 Phil 469)
Under the trust fund doctrine, the capital stock, property
other assets of a corporation are regarded as equity in tru
the payment of the corporate creditors. (CIR v. CA, 301 152)
G. BOARD OF DIRECTORS AND TRUSTEES
1. DOCTRINE OF CENTRALIZED MANAGEMENTUnless otherwise provided in the Corporation Code
corporate powers of all corporations shall be exercise
business conducted and all property of such corpora
controlled and held by the board of directors or trustees
-
7/28/2019 The Corporation Code Reviewer
10/28
elected from among the holders of stocks, or where there is
no stock, from among the members of the corporations, who
shall hold office for one (1) year and until their successors
are elected and qualified. (Sec. 23, Corporation Code)
A corporations Board of Directors is understood to be thatbody which:
a. Exercises all powers provided for under the CorporationCode;
b. Conducts all business of the corporation; andc. Controls and holds all property of the corporation.(Hornilla v. Salunat, 405 SCRA 220)
2. BUSINESS JUDGMENT RULEThe courts cannot undertake to control the discretion of the
board of directors about administrative matters as to which
they have legitimate power of action, and contracts intra
vires entered into by the board of directors are binding upon
the corporation and courts will not interfere unless such
contracts are so unconscionable and oppressive as to amount
to a wanton destruction of the rights of the minority.
Exceptions:
a. When otherwise provided by the Corporation Codeb. When the Directors or officers acted with fraud, gross
negligence or in bad faith; and
c. When directors or officers act against the corporation inconflict of interest situation.
3. Tenure, Qualifications and Disqualifications ofDirectors or Trustees
Tenure: Under section 23, the board of directors and
trustees shall hold office for one (1) year and until their
successors are elected and qualified. As a general rule, the
directors or trustees of a corporation shall serve for a term
as fixed in the by-laws.
Hold-over:Upon failure of a quorum at any meeting of the
stockholders or members called for an election, the
directorate naturally holds over and continues to functionuntil another directorate is chosen and qualified.
Qualifications:Stock Corporations:
a. Own at least one (1) share;b. Share of stock must be registered in his name;c. Must continually own such share during his term;
otherwise he automatically ceases to be a director;
d. Majority must be residents of the Philippines;Non-stock Corporation:
a. He must be a member in good standing thereof;b. a majority of them must be residents of the Philippines;Only a natural person may be elected as directors or trustees.However, a corporation which owns shares of stocks or is a
member in another corporation can designate by board
resolution its officer or representative to sit in the lattersboard and thus qualifying him to be elected as director or
trustee. (De Leon, 2010)
A trustee in a voting trust may be elected as director/trustee.
(Villanueva, 2009)
Disqualifications:No stockholder or member can be elected as director or
trustee if he has been convicted by final judgment of an
offense carrying an imprisonment exceeding 6 years, or an
offense constituting a violation of the Code, 5 years pr
his election or appointment.
Every Director requires at least one share of stock
elected. If he transfers all his shares during his tenu
automatically ceases to be a director. This applies
Director who transfers all his shares to a trustee un
Voting Trust Agreement. (Lee v. CA, 205 SCRA 752)
4. ELECTIONSIn order for the election of the Directors or Trustees to
place, the presence of a majority of the capital stomembers, either personally or by written proxy is requi
Elections must be held by secret ballot if requested b
voting stockholder or member, otherwise, it may be he
any form.
a. CUMULATIVE VOTING AND STRAIGHT VOTINGExample: A owns 100 shares of stock in a corporation a
directors are to be elected. A is entitled to 500 votes
shares x 5 directors)
Straight Voting - every stockholder may vote such nu
of shares for as many persons as there are directors
elected. In this case, A may distribute equally 100 shaeach of the 5 directors without preference. The same
applies to elections of the board of trustees, whereby A
vote for each trustee to be elected.
Cumulative Voting for one Candidate a stockhold
allowed to concentrate his votes and give one candidamany votes as the number of directors to be el
multiplied by the number of his shares shall equal. Incase, A may vote all his 500 shares to a single director
elected.
Cumulative Voting by Distribution By this meth
stockholder may cumulate his shares by multiplying als
number of his shares by the number of directors telected and distribute the same among as many candi
as he shall see fit. Here, A may distribute his votes as he
desire among the directors to be elected, i.e., 200 shar
Director 1, 100 shares to director 2, and 200 shar
director 3, giving no favorable vote to Directors 4 and 5.
However, the Corporation Code states that the total nu
of votes cast by a stockholder shall not exceed the numb
shares owned by him. Lastly, no delinquent stock shal
or be voted.
b. QUORUMA majority of the number of directors or trustees as fix
the articles of incorporation shall constitute a quorum fotransaction of corporate business. Except, when
otherwise provided in the articles of incorporation or th
laws that a greater majority is required. (Sec. 25, Corpor
Code)
Note: There is a difference between requiring A mavote of the directors or trustees and A vote of majorthe directors or trustees constituting a quorum. Iformer, you require a vote of majority plus one of a
directors. In contrast, the latter requires a majority plu
vote of directors enough to constitute a quorum (majori
-
7/28/2019 The Corporation Code Reviewer
11/28
5. REMOVALAny director or trustee of a corporation may be removed
from office:
a. By a vote of the stockholders representing 2/3 of theoutstanding capital stock, or 2/3 vote of the members.
b. At a regular meeting of the corporation or at a specialmeeting called for such purpose,
c. Previous notice to stockholders or membersd. May be without just cause, except when it operates to
deprive minority stockholders or members the right of
representation (requires just cause).
The board of directors has no power to remove one of its
members as director or trustee.
6. FILLING OF VACANCIESGenerally, if still constituting a quorum, at least a majority of
the members are empowered to fill any vacancy occurring in
the board other than by removal by the stockholders or
members or by expiration of term.
Stockholders or members may fill the vacancy in the
following cases:
a. Vacancy results from removal by the stockholders ormembers, or the expiration of term;
b. Vacancy occurs other than by removal or expiration ofterm, such as death, resignation, abandonment, or
disqualification; provided that the remaining directors
do not constitute a quorum;
c. When the board refers the matter to the stockholders;d. Increase in the number of the board;A director or trustee so elected to fill a vacancy shall only be
for the unexpired term of his predecessor in office.
7. COMPENSATIONGenerally, the by-laws of a corporation fixes the
compensation of the directors. However, if no compensation
is provided for therein, then directors shall receive onlyreasonable per diems. Per diems are paid per attendance in
board meetings.
The amount of compensation may also be fixed in a
resolution of the stockholders by a majority vote
representing the outstanding capital stock. Notwithstanding,
the stockholders cannot delegate to the board of directors
the authority to fix the amount of their own compensation.
Where the compensation is granted either in the by-laws or
by the vote of stockholders, the total yearly compensation of
directors or trustees shall in no case exceed 10% of the net
income before income tax of the compensation during the
preceding year.
8. FIDUCIARIES DUTIES AND LIABILITY RULESA director is a fiduciary. Their powers are powers in trust.He who is in such fiduciary position cannot serve himself
first and his cestuis second. He cannot manipulate the affairs
of his corporation to their detriment and in disregard of the
standards of common decency. He cannot by the
intervention of a corporate entity violate the ancient precept
against serving two masters. (De Leon, The CorporationCode of the Philippines, 2010)
Duty of Obedience The directors or trustees and officers to
be elected shall perform the duties enjoined on them by law
and by the by-laws of the corporation. Any director, tr
or officer violating this duty is liable for ultra vires acts.
Duty of Diligence Directors or trustees who (1) willfull
knowingly vote for, or assent to patently unlawful acts
corporation, (2) or who are guilty of gross negligence o
faith in directing the affairs of the corporation, shall be
jointly and severally for all the damages resulting there
suffered by the corporation, its stockholders or member
other persons. (Sec. 31, Corporation Code)
Personal Liability of corporate director, trustee or o
shall attach only when:a. He affirms an unlawful act, or acts with bad faigross negligence in directing its affairs, or for conf
interest resulting in damage to the corpor
stockholders or other persons;
b. He consents to the issuance of watered stocks ornot file with the secretary his written objection the
c. He agrees to hold himself personally and soliliable with the corporation;
d. Law makes him personally liable for his corpaction. (Tramat Mercantile v. Court of AppealsSCRA 14)
Duty of LoyaltyWhen a director, trustee or officer atte
to acquire or acquires, in violation of his duty, any int
adverse to the corporation with respect to any matter whas been reposed in him in confidence, as to which e
imposes a disability upon him to deal in his own beha
shall be liable as a trustee for the corporation and
account for the profits which otherwise would have ac
to the corporation. (Sec. 31, Corporation Code)
This liability shall attach despite the fact that the dir
risked his own funds in the venture. However, violati
this duty may be ratified by a vote of the stockho
owning or representing at least 2/3 of the outsta
capital stock. (Sec. 34, Corporation Code)
These two provisions are contained in the doctrin
corporate opportunity, which states that a corpdirector cannot take advantage for his personal ben
business opportunity which has an inherent aptitud
being integrated into the existing business of
corporation.
9. RESPONSIBILITY FOR CRIMESSince a corporation is a mere legal fiction, it cannot be
liable for a crime committed by its officers, since it doe
have the essential element of malice; in such case
responsible officers would be criminally liable.
The performance of the act is an obligation directly imp
by the law on the corporation. Since it is a responsible o
or officers of the corporation who actually perform thfor the corporation, they must of necessity be the on
assume the criminal liability (People v. Tan Boon Kon
Phil 607)
10. INSIDE INFORMATIONThe fiduciary position of insiders, directors, and of
prohibits them from using confidential information re
to the business of the corporation to benefit themselv
any competitor corporation in which they may have a
substantial interest.
-
7/28/2019 The Corporation Code Reviewer
12/28
Since loss and prejudice to the corporation is not a
requirement for liability, the corporation has a cause
of action as long as there is unfair use of inside information.
It is inside information if it is not generally available to
others and is acquired because of the close relationship of
the director or officer of the corporation. (Sec. 3.8, 27
Securities Regulation Code)
11. CONTRACTSa. By Self-Dealing Directors with the CorporationA contract of the corporation with one ore more of its
directors or trustees or officers is voidable, at the option of
such corporation, unless the following conditions are
present:
i. The presence of such director or trustee in the board
meeting in which the contract was approved is not necessary
to constitute a quorum for such meeting;
ii. The vote of such director or trustee was not
necessary for the approval of the contract;
iii. That the contract is fair and reasonable under thecircumstances;
iv. (In the case of an officer) The contract with theofficer has been previously authorized by the board
of directors.
In the absence of the first two conditions, a ratification may
be made by a vote of the stockholders representing at least
2/3 of the outstanding capital stock or at least 2/3 vote of
the members in a meeting called for the purpose. Full
disclosure of the adverse interest of the directors or trustees
must be made at such meeting. (Sec. 32, Corporation Code)
b. Between Corporations with Inter-locking DirectorsGeneral Rule: A contract between two or more corporations
having interlocking directors shall not be invalidated on that
ground alone.
Exceptions: (1) There is Fraud and (2) The contract is notfair and reasonable under the circumstances.
Rule when the directors interest is nominal in onecorporation and substantial in the other: The
requirements under Section 32, as stated above, must be
complied with to make the contract between the corporation
and interlocking directors valid.
Stockholdings exceeding 20% of the outstanding capital
stock shall be considered substantial for the purposes of
interlocking directors.
The By-Laws may prohibit a director of a corporation from
serving at the same time a director of a competing
corporation. (Gokongwei, Jr. v. SEC, 89 SCRA 336)
c. Management ContractsPreviously tackled under Corporate Powers.
A management contract cannot delegate entire supervision
and control over the officers and business of a corporation to
another as this will contravene the fundamental rule that the
corporate powers of all corporations shall be exercised by
the board. The board cannot surrender its power and duty of
supervision and control for otherwise, it becomes a mere
instrumentality of the managing company.
Where majority of the members of the members of the b
of the managing corporation also constitute a majority
members of the board of directors of the man
corporation, the management contract must be approv
the stockholders of the MANAGED Corporation owning
of the total outstanding stock or members.
Illustration: If A, B, C, D, and E constitute the majority
members of the board of directors of X corporation and
of Y corporation, the bigger 2/3 vote by the stockholder
corporation is necessary. This is a case of a contract bet
two corporations with interlocking directorates. (De
2010)
16. EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
The by-laws of a corporation may create an exec
committee composed of not less than three members o
board to be appointed by the Board. Said committee ma
by majority vote of all its members, on such specific m
within the competence of the board, as may be delegat
in the by-laws, or on a majority vote of the board.
The purpose of the Executive Committee is to take off p
the work from the Board during the periods when the B
does not meet.
Matters they cannot act on:a. Approval of any action for which shareholders app
is also required;
b. Filling of vacancies in the board;c. Amendment or repeal of any resolution of the B
which by its express terms is not so amendab
repeatable;
d. Distribution of cash dividends.17. MEETINGS
a. Regular or Special MeetingsRegular meetings of directors or trustees are those held b
board monthly, unless the by-laws provide otherwise.
Special meetings of directors or trustees are those held b
board at any time upon the call of the president
provided in the by-laws.
These meetings maybe held anywhere in or outsid
Philippines, unless provided otherwise in the by
Notice must be sent to every director or trustee at least
prior to the scheduled meeting.
b. Who PresidesSection 54 provides, the president shall preside a
meetings of the directors or trustees as well as o
stockholders or members, unless the by-laws protherwise.
The by-laws may provide that the chairman, instead o
president, shall preside at board meetings. Where ther
vice-chairman provided in the by-laws, he presides i
absence of the chairman.
Where the officer entitled to preside is not present a
time of the meeting, a stockholder or member who take
floor may temporarily preside at the meeting pendin
selection of the presiding officer.
c. Quorum
-
7/28/2019 The Corporation Code Reviewer
13/28
Under Sec. 52, Unless otherwise provided for in this Code or
in the by-laws, a quorum shall consist of the stockholders
representing a majority of the outstanding capital stock or a
majority of the members in the case of nonstick corporations.
d. Rule on AbstentionWhen time comes for directors to vote on an issue, a director
may vote "yes" or "no." If a director abstains from voting,
that means the director has not voted. An abstention is a
non-vote, a decision not to make a decision. When the chair
calls for a vote, abstentions are not called for, only the yeasand nays.
Whenever a director believes he/she has a conflict of
interest, the director should abstain from voting on the issue
and make sure his/her abstention is noted in the minutes.
The other reason a director might abstain is that he/she
believes there was insufficient information for making a
decision. Otherwise, directors should cast votes on all issues
put before them. Failure to do so could be deemed a breach
of their fiduciary duties.
. STOCKHOLDERS AND MEMBERS
1. RIGHTS OF A STOCKHOLDER OR MEMBERS
Direct or indirect participation in management Voting Rights Right to remove directors Proprietary Rights Right to Inspect books and records Right to be furnished with the most recent financial
statements/reports
Right to recover stocks unlawfully sold for delinquentpayment of subscription
Right to file individual suit, representative suit and derivativesuits.
a. Doctrine of Equality of SharesEach share shall be EQUAL in ALL respects to every other
share, except as otherwise provided in the Articles ofIncorporation and stated in the certificate of stock.
2. PARTICIPATION IN MANAGEMENT
a. PROXY - Stockholders and members may vote in person or byproxy in all meetings of stockholders or members.
- A written authorization given by one person to another sothat the second person can act for the first.
- A proxy is a special form of agency. The proxy holder is inthe eye of the law an agent and as such a fiduciary.
(Ballantine, p. 412)
Requirements for Validity: (Sec. 58)
i. Unless otherwise provided in the proxy, it shall be validonly for the meeting which it was intended.
ii. It shall be signed by the stockholder or memberconcerned;
iii. Proxies shall be in writing;iv. It shall be filed before the scheduled meeting with the
corporate secretary;
v. No proxy shall be valid and effective for a period longerthan 5 years at any one time.
b. VOTING TRUST - An arrangement created by one or morestockholders for the purpose of conferring upon a trustee or
trustees the right to vote and other rights pertaining to the
shares for a period not exceeding five (5) years at any time.
The trustee can also be voted as director.
If the voting trust was a requirement for a loan agree
period may exceed 5 years but shall automatically expire
full payment of the loan. (Sec. 59, Corporation Code).
c. CASES WHEN STOCKHOLDERS ACTION IS REQUIREDi. By a Majority Vote (of the outstanding capital stoc
entitled to vote)
Fixing of the issue value of no par value shares barticles may fix the issue price or may authorize the B
of Directors to fix said issue value (Sec. 62);
Adoption or amendments to the By-Laws (Sec. 48 Execution of Management Contracts, unless in cinterlocking shareholders of more than one-third (1
the managing corporation or interlocking majori
directors in both managed and managing corpor
(Sec. 44);
Revocation of delegation to the Board of Directothe amendment of By-Laws (Sec. 48);
Calling a meeting to remove directors (Sec. 26); a Payment of compensation for directors unless alfixed in the By-Laws.
ii. By a Two-Thirds Vote Declaration of bond or stock dividends (Sec. 43); Investment in other corporations or for pur
other than those provided in the Article
Incorporation (Sec. 42);
Certain amendments to the Articles of Incorpo(Sec. 16; Sec. 37);
Delegation to the Board of Directors to amend thLaws (Sec. 48);
Sale, lease, exchange, mortgage, pledge or disposition of all or substantially of the corp
assets, but stockholders action is not requir
corporations business is not substantially limite
the proceeds are used to continue the rema
business (Sec. 40);
Removal of a director (Sec. 28); Ratification of voidable contracts in certain
between a corporation and its director or trustee32);
Voluntary dissolution of the corporation (Sec.118 Execution of management contracts in case
interlocking stockholders or directors (Sec.44);
Increase or decrease of capital stock and creatiincrease of bonded indebtedness (Sec. 38);
Extending or shortening corporate term (Sec. 37) Issuance of shares not subject to pre-emptive
(Sec. 39);
iii. By Cumulative VotingCumulative voting is allowed election of directors or trustees (Sec. 24).
- A stockholder may vote such number of shares f
many persons as there are directors to be elected may cumulate said shares and give one candidate as
votes as the number of directors to be elected mult
by the number of his shares shall equal, or he
distribute them on the same principle among as
candidates as he shall see fit (Sec. 24).
Provided that the total number of votes cast by him
not exceed the number of shares owned by him as s
in the books of the corporation multiplied by the w
number of directors to be elected.
-
7/28/2019 The Corporation Code Reviewer
14/28
3. PROPRIETARY RIGHTS
The proprietary rights of shareholders consist principally in their
right to dividends and to liquidation of assets.
While a share of stock represents a proportionate or aliquotinterest
in the property of the corporation, it however, does not vest the
owner thereof with any legal right or title to any of the assets, his
interest in the corporate property being equitable or beneficial in
nature. Shareholders are in no legal sense the owners of corporate
property, which is owned by the corporation as a distinct legal
person.
a. RIGHT TO DIVIDENDSRight to dividends vests upon lawful declaration by the Board of
Directors. From that time, dividends become a debt owing to the
stockholder. No revocation can be made except if NOT yet
announced or communicated to the stockholders.
Stock corporations are prohibited from retaining surplus profits in
the excess of 100% of their paid-in capital stock,
EXCEPT:
i. When justified by definite corporate expansion projects orprograms approved by the board of directors;
ii. When the corporation is prohibited under any loanagreement with any financial institution or creditor, whether
local or foreign, from declaring dividends without its/his
consent, and such consent has not yet been secured; or
iii. When it can be clearly shown that such retention is necessaryunder special circumstances obtaining in the corporation,
such as when there is a need for special reserve for probable
contingencies.
Forms of Dividends: Cash, Property or Stock.
NOTE: Right to dividends vests upon declaration so whoever owns
the stock at such time also owns the dividends. Subsequent transfer
of stock would not carry with it right to dividends UNLESS agreed
upon by the parties.
b. RIGHT OF APPRAISAL
Right to demand payment of the fair value of his shares, after
dissenting from a proposed corporate action involving a fundamental
change in the corporation in the cases provided by law.
When Right of Appraisal May be Exercised:
i. Extend or shorten corporate term;ii. Restriction of rights or privileges of shares through the
amendment of the articles of incorporation;
iii. Sale of all or substantially all corporate assets;iv. Equity investment in non-primary purpose business enterprise;v. Merger or consolidation
OTE: (a) All the above instances require the 2/3 votes of the
outstanding capital stock;
(b) The appraisal right pertains only to stockholders who have
actually dissented from the above-enumerated transactions.
c. RIGHT TO INSPECT
Under Section 74 of the Corporation Code, the stockholder has a
right to examine the books of the corporation. That it be done during
business hours on a business day in the place where the corporation
keeps all its records; the stockholders has not improperly used any
information he secured through any previous examination; demand
is made in good faith or for a legitimate purpose.
If the director or officer unjustly refuses to allow stockholder to
inspect the corporate books, he can be held liable for damages and
for criminal offense punished under Sec. 144 of the Corporation
Code.
A stockholders right of inspection is based on his ownership of
the assets and property of the corporation. Therefore, it is an
incident of ownership of the corporate property, whethe
ownership or interest is termed an equitable ownersh
beneficial ownership, or quasi-ownership. Such rig
predicated upon the necessity of self-protection. (Goko
Jr. Vs. SEC, 1979).
d. PRE-EMPTIVE RIGHT
Right to subscribe to all issues or disposition of shares o
class in proportion to his present stockholdings, the pu
being to enable the shareholder to retain his proportio
control in the corporation and to retain his equity in
retained earnings, and also in the net assets in the eve
dissolution.Sec. 39 has widened the coverage of pre-emptive right w
now includes re-issuance of treasury shares because of th
of the words disposition of shares, which would cove
following instances:
i. Increase in the Authorized Capital Stock;ii. Opening for subscription the unissued portion of ex
capital stock; and
iii. Disposition of treasury shares.Pre-emptive right not available in the following instances:
i. Shares to be issued to comply with laws requiring offering or minimum stock ownership by the public;
ii. Shares issued in good faith in exchange for proneeded for corporate purposes;
iii. Shares issued in payment of previously contracted deiv. In case the right is denied in the articles of incorpor
(Sec. 39)
e. RIGHT TO VOTE
A stockholder is given the right to participate in the corp
affairs by giving him the right to attend meetings afte
notice and the right to vote thereat in person or throu
proxy or trustee.
- Non-voting shares are not entitled to vote exceprovided for in the last paragraph of Sec. 6 o
Corporation Code.
- Preferred or redeemable shares may be deprived oright to vote.
- Fractional shares of stock cannot be voted.- Treasury shares have no voting rights as long as
remain in the treasury.
- No delinquent stock shall be voted. (Sec. 71)- A transferee of stock cannot vote if his transfer
registered in the stock and transfer book o
corporation.
f. RIGHT OF FIRST REFUSAL
Except in the case of close corporations where the right o
refusal is required to be a feature to be found in the artic
incorporation, the right of first refusal can only ari
Corporate Law by means of a contractual stipulation, or w
is provided in the articles of incorporation. The nature
purpose of by-laws would not allow rights of first refusal
found in its provisions.
4. REMEDIAL RIGHTS
a. Individual Suit A suit instituted by a shareholder for his
behalf against the corporation.
b. Representative Suit A suit filed by a shareholder in his b
and in behalf likewise of other stockholders similarly situate
with a common cause against the corporation (Pascual vs. D
Orozco, 19 Phil. 82).
-
7/28/2019 The Corporation Code Reviewer
15/28
Derivative Suit A suit filed in behalf of the corporation by its
hareholders (not creditors whose remedies are merely subsidiary such as
accion subrogatoria or in accion pauliana) upon a cause of action
elonging to the corporation, but not duly pursued by it, against any
erson or against the directors, officers and/or controlling shareholders
f the corporation. If the suit is filed against a third person, the case is not
fra-corporated in nature. A derivative suit is a remedy designed by
quity and has been the principal defense of the minority stockholders
gainst abuses by the majority. The real party-in-interest in a derivative
ction is the corporation itself, not the shareholders who have actually
stituted it. (Gilda Lim vs. Patricia Lim-Yu, 352 Scra 216)
Requisites of a derivative suit
i. Cause of action is in favor of the corporation, such asthose arising from fraudulent conveyances, breach of
trust (but not error of judgment) on the part of the
board of directors, ultra vires acts and similar others;
ii. There is refusal on the part of the corporation to sueafter the corporation is advised to take appropriate
remedies but the exhaustion of intra-corporate
remedies may be dispensed with if that recourse would
be a futile exercise, such as when it is under the
complete control of the defendants (Everest vs. Asia
Banking Corporation, 49 Phil. 512).
iii. There would be injury to the corporation if the action isnot taken; and
iv. The action is brought by a shareholder or group ofshareholders in the name of the corporation.
5. OBLIGATION OF A STOCKHOLDER
i. Liability to the corporation for unpaid subscription (Sec. 67-
70, CCP);
ii. Liability to the corporation for interest on unpaid subscription
if so required by the by-laws (Sec. 66);
iii. Liability to the creditors of the corporation for unpaid
subscription (Sec. 60);
iv. Liability for watered stock (Sec. 65);
v. Liability for dividends unlawfully paid (Sec. 43);
vi. Liability for failure to create corporation (Sec. 10).
6. MEETINGS
a. REGULAR OR SPECIAL
i. WHEN AND WHERE
WHEN:
Regular meetings of stockholders or members shall be held
annually on a date fixed in the by-laws, or if not so fixed, on any
date in April of every year as determined by the board of
directors or trustees. (Sec. 50).
WHERE:
Stock Corporations: City or municipality where the principal
office of the corporation is located, or, if practicable, in the
principal office of the corporation; Provided, Metro Manila shall
be considered a city or municipality. (Sec. 51).
Exception: Such meeting shall be valid even if not held in the
proper place when all the stockholders or members of the
corporation are present or duly represented at the meeting.
Failure to comply with the mandatory provisions of Section 51
would render the meeting illegal.
ii. NOTICE
Regular Meeting written notice sent to tall stockholders or
members at least (2) weeks prior to the meeting, unless a
different period is required by the by-laws.
Special Meeting written notice sent at least 1 week prior to
the meeting, unless otherwise provided in the by-laws.
Subject to waiver, expressly or impliedly.
Failure to give notice would render a meeting VOIDABLE
instance of an absent stockholder, who was not notified o
meeting. (Board vs. Tan, 1959).
b. WHO CALLS THE MEETINGS
i. The President, unless the by-laws provide otherwise
54).
ii. The person or persons designated in the by-laws hav
authority to call stockholders or members meeting.
iii. In the absence of such provision in the by-laws
meeting may be called by a director or trustee or b
officer entrusted with the management of the corpo
unless otherwise provided by law.iv. Whenever for any cause there is no person authoriz
call a meeting, SEC upon petition of a stockholder/mem
and on the showing of good cause therefore, may iss
order to petitioner to call a meeting by giving proper n
with the petitioner presiding thereat until at least a ma
of stockholders/members present have chosen a pre
officer. (Sec. 50)
Pursuant to the powers granted to the SEC under Secti
of the Corporation Code, and Section 6(f) of Pres. D
902-A, the SEC has opined that when there is no p
authorized in the by-laws to call a meeting or in the
the person authorized in the by-laws to call a meetin
or refuses to call for a meeting, any interested stockh
may petition the SEC to authorize him to call a meeti
compel the officers of the corporation to call a meeting
c. QUORUM
Under Section 52 of the Corporation Code, unless othe
provided for in the Code itself or in the by-laws, a quorum
consist of the stockholders representing a majority o
outstanding capital stock or a majority of the members in
of non-stock corporations.
In those cases in which the law determines the numb
shareholders or members whose concurring votes are nece
to make their action binding on the corporation, no less
such number is necessary to constitute a quorum at a me
called to transact such business. In such cases, the by-laws
provide for a greater quorum.
In other cases, the by-laws may provide for the holdi
meetings with the presence of any number of stockholde
members, even less than a majority, provided there are at
two. It is customary however, to provide in the by-laws tha
presence of the registered holders of a majority o
outstanding shares is necessary to constitute a quorum
that a smaller number may meet and adjourn to a later
and that at such adjourned meeting, the shareholders atte
shall constitute a quorum.
The SEC has opined that where a corporation encou
several unsuccessful attempts or if it would be impossib
the corporation to get the required quorum of
stockholders/members necessary to transact business, it
pursuant to the provisions of Pres. Decree 902-A, petitio
SEC for the appointment of a management committe
undertake the management thereof.
Where quorum is present at the start of a lawful me
stockholders present cannot without justifiable cause brea
quorum by walking out from said meeting so as to defea
validity of any act proposed and approved by
majority.(Johnston vs. Johnston, 1965 CA decision)
-
7/28/2019 The Corporation Code Reviewer
16/28
d. MINUTES OF THE MEETINGS
Under Section 74 of the Corporation Code, the corporation
shall, at its principal office, keep and carefully preserve a record
of all minutes of all meetings of stockholders and members, in
which it shall be set forth in detail the time and place of holding
the meeting; the notice given; whether regular or special; if
special, its object, those present and absent; and every act done
or ordered done at the meeting.
Upon the demand of any director, trustee, shareholder or
member, the time when any director, trustee, shareholder or
member entered or left the meeting must be noted in theminutes; and on a similar demand, the yeas and nays must be
taken on any motion