The Copying & Content of the Canon Orthodox teaching claims only the original manuscripts are...

15
The Copying & Content of the Canon Orthodox teaching claims only the original manuscripts are inerrant. Why then even discuss this? What of the originals is lost?

Transcript of The Copying & Content of the Canon Orthodox teaching claims only the original manuscripts are...

Page 1: The Copying & Content of the Canon Orthodox teaching claims only the original manuscripts are inerrant. Why then even discuss this? What of the originals.

The Copying & Content of the Canon

Orthodox teaching claims only the original manuscripts are inerrant.

Why then even discuss this?What of the originals is lost?

Page 2: The Copying & Content of the Canon Orthodox teaching claims only the original manuscripts are inerrant. Why then even discuss this? What of the originals.

The Copying & Content of the Canon

We investigate…

To gain confidencein the text we have.

Because an intellectual faithis more robust than a blind faith.

Page 3: The Copying & Content of the Canon Orthodox teaching claims only the original manuscripts are inerrant. Why then even discuss this? What of the originals.

The Copying & Content of the Canon

We are going to discuss…

Copying: how the text came to us throughout the ages.

Content: what books of the Bible are considered normative for God’s people – what can be called “Sacred Scripture.”

Page 4: The Copying & Content of the Canon Orthodox teaching claims only the original manuscripts are inerrant. Why then even discuss this? What of the originals.

The Copying & Content of the Canon

*The faith of the Patriarchs

existed apart from a

written text for

Centuries.

*Sacred Literature began1st with God and then withMoses and the Pentateuch. *

Old Testament

Page 5: The Copying & Content of the Canon Orthodox teaching claims only the original manuscripts are inerrant. Why then even discuss this? What of the originals.

The Copying & Content of the Canon

“Then Moses turned and went down from the mountain with the two tabletsof the testimony in his hand,tablets that were written onboth sides; on the front andon the back they were written.The tablets were the work ofGod, and the writing was thewriting of God engraved onthe tablets.” Exodus 32:15,16

Old Testament

Page 6: The Copying & Content of the Canon Orthodox teaching claims only the original manuscripts are inerrant. Why then even discuss this? What of the originals.

The Copying & Content of the Canon

Oops!

“And as soon as he camenear the camp and saw thecalf and the dancing, Moses’anger burned hot, and hethrew the tablets out of hishand and broke them at thefoot of the mountain.” Exodus 32:19

Old Testament

Page 7: The Copying & Content of the Canon Orthodox teaching claims only the original manuscripts are inerrant. Why then even discuss this? What of the originals.

The Copying & Content of the Canon

Oops Recovered…

“The LORD said to Moses, ‘Cut for yourself two tabletsof stone like the first, and Iwill write on the tablets thewords that were on the firsttablets, which you broke.’” Exodus 34:1

Old Testament

Page 8: The Copying & Content of the Canon Orthodox teaching claims only the original manuscripts are inerrant. Why then even discuss this? What of the originals.

The Copying & Content of the CanonOld Testament

A Journeyof ~1000 Years

Moses:circa 1400 BC

Malachi:circa 450BC

Via theProphetic

Voice

Page 9: The Copying & Content of the Canon Orthodox teaching claims only the original manuscripts are inerrant. Why then even discuss this? What of the originals.

The Copying & Content of the Canon

Final Collection: the Tanakh – KntTorah – Navi’im – Ketuvim

arqm/Miqra “that which is read”

No one ever disputed the Torah/Pentateuch.The Prophets (Navi’im) may have been

opposed in their ministries, but their writings were accepted.

Some of the Writings (Ketuvim) were disputed, but one Jewish tradition holds that the Great Assembly (~450 BC) settled on 24 books.

Old Testament

Page 10: The Copying & Content of the Canon Orthodox teaching claims only the original manuscripts are inerrant. Why then even discuss this? What of the originals.

The Copying & Content of the Canon

Final Collection: the Tanakh – KntTorah – Navi’im – Ketuvim

arqm/Miqra “that which is read”

Getting our 39 OT books out of the Hebrew 24:

They Have One Minor Prophet; We have 12Samuel, Kings, Chronicles, & Ezra Each are 1

Book

NB: There are Many DifferentOrderings of the OT.

Old Testament

Page 11: The Copying & Content of the Canon Orthodox teaching claims only the original manuscripts are inerrant. Why then even discuss this? What of the originals.

The Copying & Content of the Canon

Evidence of Internal Witness: Jeremiah’s (627-586 BC) life is “saved” by

Micah (8th century BC), Jer. 26:7-19. Use of the Old Testament in the Old

Testament, Psalm 95:7-11 references Exodus 17:1-7 & Numbers 20:2-13.

The Prophet’s continually make reference to the Torah, esp. Deuteronomy. See Isaiah 24:1-5; Jer. 31:31-34; Ezek. 16:59-63.

Old Testament

Page 12: The Copying & Content of the Canon Orthodox teaching claims only the original manuscripts are inerrant. Why then even discuss this? What of the originals.

The Copying & Content of the Canon

Evidence of a Scribal Hand& External Resources:

book of the wars of the LORD, Num. 21:14; book of Jasher, Josh. 10:13; book of the Acts of Solomon, 1 Kgs. 11:41; book of Samuel…Nathan…Gad the seer, 1 Chr. 29:29; et al.

“The prayers of David, the son of Jesse, are ended,” Y72:20, and yet Y86, 101, 103, 108-110, 122, 124, 131, 133, 138-145. Also see Y90:0.

Do you think Moses wrote Deut. 34:1-12?

Old Testament

Page 13: The Copying & Content of the Canon Orthodox teaching claims only the original manuscripts are inerrant. Why then even discuss this? What of the originals.

The Copying & Content of the CanonOld Testament

Amos 8:11-12Zech. 1:5,6

Traditional JewishThought

Moses:circa 1400 BC

Malachi:circa 450BC

Closing theProphetic

Voice

Page 14: The Copying & Content of the Canon Orthodox teaching claims only the original manuscripts are inerrant. Why then even discuss this? What of the originals.

The Copying & Content of the CanonOld Testament

Why Did theProphetic Voice Close?

Every Answer is only Speculation

Sin: Malachi refers to the “blind and lame” sacrifices of those who returned. Many Jewish men intermarried upon returning to the land.

Failure to Return: A large number of the Jews chose to stay in Babylon/Persia.

Messianic Expectation: A lack of prophecy leaves a “God is not here” feeling in the community.

Page 15: The Copying & Content of the Canon Orthodox teaching claims only the original manuscripts are inerrant. Why then even discuss this? What of the originals.

The Copying & Content of the Canon

New Testament Evidence for the Old:The Tanakh (Knt) is referred to in Luke

24:44 by Jesus Jesus makes reference to “the blood of Abel

to Zechariah,” Luke 11:51. Genesis 3 – 2 Chronicles 24:20-22.

The numerous references throughout the gospels to the text as God’s word: “it is written,” Matt. 4; “God commanded,” Matt. 15:3; Jesus calls God’s word “truth,” John 17:17.

Old Testament