The CompactLight Project (XLS)
Transcript of The CompactLight Project (XLS)
1
Funded by theEuropean Union
Towards an Ultra-Compact X-ray Free-Electron Laser, UCLA January 22-25, 2019 G. D’Auria
The CompactLight Project (XLS)Gerardo D’Auria (Elettra-ST)
on behalf of the CompactLight Collaboration
[email protected] www.CompactLight.eu
Towards an Ultra-Compact X-ray Free-Electron Laser
UCLA Luskin Conference Center
January 22-25, 2019
2
Funded by theEuropean Union
Towards an Ultra-Compact X-ray Free-Electron Laser, UCLA January 22-25, 2019 G. D’Auria
Context
• The XLS Collaboration
• The CompactLight Project
• Aims & Motivations
Timeline
Deliverables
Work Packages
• Objectives
• Expected performance
• Ongoing activities
Outline
3
Funded by theEuropean Union
Towards an Ultra-Compact X-ray Free-Electron Laser, UCLA January 22-25, 2019 G. D’Auria
The XLS Collaboration
The XLS Collaboration is an initiative among several Intern. Labs aimed at promoting the construction
of the next generation FEL based photon sources with innovative accelerator technologies
4
Funded by theEuropean Union
Towards an Ultra-Compact X-ray Free-Electron Laser, UCLA January 22-25, 2019 G. D’Auria
List of Participants
Participant Organisation Name Country1 ST (Coord.) Elettra – Sincrotrone Trieste S.C.p.A. Italy2 CERN CERN - European Organization for Nuclear Research International3 STFC Science and Technology Facilities Council – Daresbury Laboratory United Kingdom4 SINAP Shanghai Inst. of Applied Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences China5 IASA Institute of Accelerating Systems and Applications Greece6 UU Uppsala Universitet Sweden7 UoM The University of Melbourne Australia8 ANSTO Australian Nuclear Science and Tecnology Organisation Australia9 UA-IAT Ankara University Institute of Accelerator Technologies Turkey
10 ULANC Lancaster University United Kingdom11 VDL ETG VDL Enabling Technology Group Eindhoven BV Netherlands12 TU/e Technische Universiteit Eindhoven Netherlands13 INFN Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Italy14 Kyma Kyma S.r.l. Italy15 SAPIENZA University of Rome "La Sapienza" Italy
16 ENEA Agenzia Naz. per le Nuove Tecnologie, l'Energia e lo Sviluppo Economico Sostenibile Italy
17 ALBA-CELLS Consorcio para la Construccion Equipamiento y Explotacion del Lab. de Luz Sincrotron Spain
18 CNRS Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique CNRS France19 KIT Karlsruher Instritut für Technologie Germany20 PSI Paul Scherrer Institut PSI Switzerland21 CSIC Agencia Estatal Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicias Spain22 UH/HIP University of Helsinki - Helsinki Institute of Physics Finland23 VU VU University Amsterdam Netherlands24 USTR University of Strathclyde United Kingdom
Third Parties Organisation Name CountryAP1 OSLO Universitetet i Oslo - University of Oslo NorwayAP2 ARCNL Advanced Research Center for Nanolithography NetherlandsAP3 NTUA National Technical University of Athens GreeceAP4 AUEB Athens University Economics & Business Greece
Italy 5Neth. 3+1UK 3Spain 2Australia 2China 1Greece 1+2Sweden 1Turkey 1France 1Germany 1Switz. 1Finland 1Norway 0+1Internat. 1
5
Funded by theEuropean Union
Towards an Ultra-Compact X-ray Free-Electron Laser, UCLA January 22-25, 2019 G. D’Auria
The CompactLight Project (XLS)
Horizon2020 - Work Programme 2016 – 2017
Research & Innovation INFRADEV-1-2017 Design Studies
Starting date: 01-01-2018
Duration: 36 months
Grant amount: 3 M€
http://CompactLight.eu
6
Funded by theEuropean Union
Towards an Ultra-Compact X-ray Free-Electron Laser, UCLA January 22-25, 2019 G. D’Auria
Objectives
Our aim is to facilitate the widespread development of X-ray FEL facilities
across Europe and beyond, by making them more affordable to construct
and operate through an optimum combination of emerging and
innovative accelerator technologies.
We plan to design a Hard X-ray Facility using the very latest concepts for:
High brightness electron photoinjectors
Very high gradient accelerating structures
Novel short period undulators
7
Funded by theEuropean Union
Towards an Ultra-Compact X-ray Free-Electron Laser, UCLA January 22-25, 2019 G. D’Auria
Work PackageLead
ParticipantPerson Months
Start Month
End month
WP1Project management and
Technical CoordinationElettra - ST 32 1 36
WP2FEL Science Requirements and
Facility DesignSTFC 68 2 36
WP3 Gun and Injector INFN 76 2 36
WP4 RF systems CERN 78 2 36
WP5Undulators andLight production
ENEA 81 2 36
WP6Beam dynamics and
Start to End ModellingUA-IAT 78 2 36
WP7Global Integration with
New Research Infrastructures Elettra - ST 27 6 36
Total Person Months 440
XLS Work Packages
8
Funded by theEuropean Union
Towards an Ultra-Compact X-ray Free-Electron Laser, UCLA January 22-25, 2019 G. D’Auria
WP3Gun & Inj.
WP4RF Systems
WP5Und. & LP
Pre-Selection:risk-drivenphysics-driven
Filter:Beam quality, FEL specs
Filter:Self-consistency
Evaluation:FeasibilityCost
WP1Manag. & Coord.
WP6BD & S2E Simul.
WP2FEL Sc. & Fac. Des.
WP7Integrat. in Res. Infr.
Courtesy of S. Di Mitri
Process and WPs relations
9
Funded by theEuropean Union
Towards an Ultra-Compact X-ray Free-Electron Laser, UCLA January 22-25, 2019 G. D’Auria
Time plan, Milestones and Deliverables
MD
Kick-offMeeting
PublicWEB site
II MidtermRev. Meet.
I MidtermRev. Meet.
I Annual Meet.
User Meet. & Req. Rep
10
Funded by theEuropean Union
Towards an Ultra-Compact X-ray Free-Electron Laser, UCLA January 22-25, 2019 G. D’Auria
Deliv. Deliverable nameWP
Lead part.
Type
Del. date
D1.1 CompactLight Public Website. WP1-ST DEC-PU-M3
D1.2 Data Management Plan WP1-ST ORDP-PU-M6
D2.1 Report providing users requirements and FEL performance specification. WP2-STFC R-PU-M12
D3.1 Evaluation report of the optimum e-gun and injector solution for the XLS CDR. WP3-INFN R-PU-M18
D3.2 A review report on the bunch compression techniques and phase space linearization WP3-INFN R-PU-M18
D4.1 Computer code report for RF power unit design and cost optimization. WP4-CERN R-PU-M18
D5.1 A review report comparing the different technologies for the CompactLight undulator. WP5-ENEA R-PU-M18
D6.1 Review report on the most advanced computer codes for the facility design WP6-UAIAT R-PU-M18
D2.2 Report summarizing the FEL design with accelerator and undulator requirements. WP2-STFC R-PU-M24
D7.1 Mid-term report with CompactLight global integration and cost analysis WP7-ST R-PU-M24
D3.3 Design report of the injector diagnostics/beam manipulations based on a X-band cavities WP3-INFN R-PU-M36
D3.4 E-gun and injector Design Report with diagnostics and phase space linearizer WP3-INFN R-PU-M36
D4.2 Design report of the optimized RF unit WP4-CERN R-PU-M36
D4.3 Report on RF unit design and fabrication procedure WP4-CERN R-PU-M36
D5.2 Conceptual Design Report of the undulator WP5-ENEA R-PU-M36
D6.2 Final report with start to end facility simulations WP6-UAIAT R-PU-M36
D7.2 Final report with CompactLight global integration analysis, services and cost. WP7-ST R-PU-M36
D2.3 Hard X-ray FEL Conceptual Design Report. WP2-STFC R-PU-M36
D1.2 Production of a short monograph summarizing the Conceptual Design Report. WP1-ST R-PU-M36
2
0
1
8
2
0
1
9
2
0
2
0
List of Deliverables
Coming6 months!
11
Funded by theEuropean Union
Towards an Ultra-Compact X-ray Free-Electron Laser, UCLA January 22-25, 2019 G. D’Auria
Work Packages:
Objectives
Ongoing Activities
12
Funded by theEuropean Union
Towards an Ultra-Compact X-ray Free-Electron Laser, UCLA January 22-25, 2019 G. D’Auria
WP7: Global integration with new Research Infrastructures (R. Rochow,
Elettra-ST)
WP7 will address strategic issues related to the objectives of XLS, namely
the impact and benefits for the user community, in both the public and
private sectors, at the scientific and technical level. The results of this work
package will be a series of reports which target funding agencies and
policy makers in the decision making process for the approval of new
research infrastructures or the upgrade of existing Facilities.
WP1: Project management and Technical Coordination (G. D’Auria,
Elettra – ST).
WP1 carries the overall management of the XLS Design Study to ensure
timely achievement of project results through technical and
administrative management.
WP1 and WP7 Objectives
13
Funded by theEuropean Union
Towards an Ultra-Compact X-ray Free-Electron Laser, UCLA January 22-25, 2019 G. D’Auria
WP2: FEL science requirements and facility design (J. Clarke STFC -
Daresbury)
The objective of WP2 is to provide the overall design of the FEL. It will
determine performance specification for the Facility “based on user-driven
scientific requirements”. It will identify and choose the most appropriate
technical solutions considering cost, technical risk and performance.
Survey with a specially developed questionnaire sent to over 50
European experts (October-November 2018).
CompactLight User Meeting: CERN, November 27th – 28th, 2018
WP2
D 2.1: Science Requirements and Performance Specification for
the CompactLight X-Ray Free-Electron LaserCourtesy of J. Clarke
14
Funded by theEuropean Union
Towards an Ultra-Compact X-ray Free-Electron Laser, UCLA January 22-25, 2019 G. D’Auria
Parameter Unit Soft x-ray FEL Hard x-ray FEL
Photon energy KeV 0.25 - 2.0 2.0 - 16.0
Wavelength nm 5.0 - 0.6 0.6 - 0.08
Repetition rate Hz 100 to 1000* 100
Pulse duration fs
Pulse energy mJ
Polarization
Two-pulse delay fs
Two-colour separation % 20 10
Synchronization fs
Variable - Selectable
< 10
± 100
0.1 - 50
< 0.3
*A repetition rate of 1000 Hz would be a unique and desirable feature of our design. Werecognise that this is a very challenging target that we may have to reduce during the study.
Preliminary Parameters of the CompactLight FEL
XLS FEL Parameters
15
Funded by theEuropean Union
Towards an Ultra-Compact X-ray Free-Electron Laser, UCLA January 22-25, 2019 G. D’Auria
INJ
BC1 BC2
SX
HX
50 pC160 MeV0.2 um emit60 A
4.3 - 4.8 GeV0.2 um6 kA5 fs fwhm
0.005% - 0.01% rms slice e.spr.
6.5 – 7.5 GeV0.2 um6 kA5 fs fwhm0.003% - 0.01% rms slice e.spr.
XLS FEL possible configuration
Courtesy of N. Thompson, D. Dunning, S. Di Mitri
16
Funded by theEuropean Union
Towards an Ultra-Compact X-ray Free-Electron Laser, UCLA January 22-25, 2019 G. D’Auria
WP3: Gun and injector (M. Ferrario, INFN - Frascati) The objective of WP3 is to provide the technical specification and the optimum design of the Linace-gun and injector. Options considered:
• High-gradient injectors at existing gun frequencies, S and C bands (towards lower emittance).• A full-X-band solution, inclusive of higher-harmonic linearization in K band.• DC Gun• Injector diagnostics & beam manipulations based on X-band technology. Bunch compression
techniques (compact magnetic chicanes, velocity bunching).
Gun design (RF, Solenoid, Cathode, Laser, Diagnostics)• S-Band Gun RF Design (CNRS + IASA+UAIAT-INFN+ALBA)• C-Band Gun RF Design (INFN +IASA+Sapienza)• X-Band Gun RF Design (CSIC-IFIC + UAIAT+ Sapienza)• DC Gun Design (TU/e)• Laser/Photocathode (IASA+CNRS+INFN)
Compressor Design (Velocity Bunching, Magnetic Chicane)• S-Band Velocity Bunching (TU/e + IASA+ALBA) • C-Band Velocity Bunching (INFN +IASA+TU/e ) • X-Band Velocity Bunching (Sapienza+CERN+IASA+INFN)• Magnetic Compressor (ST + CERN+INFN+CNRS)
X-Band Diagnostics (Transverse RF Deflector)
• Transverse RF Deflector (Sapienza + IASA)
Linearizer Design (RF and passive linearizers)• X-Band RF Linearizer (Sapienza) • K-Band RF Linearizer (ULANC + Sapienza )• Passive linearizers (CNRS)
WP3
Main Tasks
Courtesy of M. Ferrario
17
Funded by theEuropean Union
Towards an Ultra-Compact X-ray Free-Electron Laser, UCLA January 22-25, 2019 G. D’Auria
WP3 - C-Band Ultra-Fast GUN Design (prel.)
The C-band injector is based on an ultra-high gradient C-bandgun (1.6 cells) operating at 240 MV/m cathode peak field
We proposed to adopt an ultra-fast gun (rf pulses <150 ns)keeping under control all quantities that drive the breakdownphenomena (Modified Poynting vector, surface electric field, etc.)
The design of the overall system is based on commerciallyavailable components (klystrons, circulators, pulse compressors,ect…)
We have optimized the 2D profile of the cells and the inputcoupler exploring different solutions. An input coupler workingon the TM020 mode on the full cell seems to be the bestsolution
Parameter
fres 5.712 GHz
≈ 80 MHz
Q0 14347
β 3
QL 3623
τF 201 ns
Ecath [MV/m] 240
Esurf/Ecath (on the coupler) 0.91
Hsurf [kA/m] (on the coupler) 357 KA/m
Tpulsed (square pulse)
@ 100 ns
@ 200 ns
12.2°C17.3°C
4
56.4
100 ns, 85 MW
KLY
1-1.5 s, 40 MW
P.C.X2.1
GUN
=3Circ.
Circ.
Courtesy of M. Croia
18
Funded by theEuropean Union
Towards an Ultra-Compact X-ray Free-Electron Laser, UCLA January 22-25, 2019 G. D’Auria
WP4
Task 1: Layout and optimization of the linac RF system A. Gallo INFN-LNF, CERN, SINAP
Task 2: Industrialization X. Janssen VDL
Task 3: Modulator technology M. Jacewicz UU
Task 4: Power sources for higher-harmonic systems A. Cross USTR
Task 5: Integration M. Aicheler UH-HIP
Courtesy of W. Wuensch
WP4: RF systems (W. Wuensch, CERN)
The primary objective of WP4 is to define the RF system for the linac in the main and sub-design
variants (specialized hardware for an eventual 36 GHz lineariser system, deflectors for profile
measurement systems,…).
A key goal will be “to define a standardized RF unit”:
• Simplify the preparation of future construction projects.
• Cost savings (industrialization of linac hardware).
19
Funded by theEuropean Union
Towards an Ultra-Compact X-ray Free-Electron Laser, UCLA January 22-25, 2019 G. D’Auria
• Baseline accelerating gradient: 65 MV/m
• RF system and pulse compressor characteristics
• Average iris radius: 3.5 mm
• Electromagnetic parametric study of the TW cell
• Effective shunt impedance optimization by a 2D scan of the total length and the iris tapering
• Check of modified Poynting vector values @ nominal gradient
• Design a realistic RF module including power distribution network
• Finalize the electromagnetic (input and output couplers) and mechanical design
Trade-off between machine compactness and RF power requirements
50 MW, 1.5 µs
Beam dynamics requirements (BBU threshold)
WP4 - X-band Accel. Struct. Design & Optim.
Courtesy of A. Gallo
20
Funded by theEuropean Union
Towards an Ultra-Compact X-ray Free-Electron Laser, UCLA January 22-25, 2019 G. D’Auria
Freq. of 2π/3 mode [GHz] 11.9942
Average iris radius <a> [mm] 3.5
Total length of the TW structure Ls [m] 0.9
RF pulse [µs] 1.5
Average gradient <G> [MV/m] 65
Linac Energy gain Egain [GeV] 4.5
Linac active length Lact [m] 69.2
Unloaded SLED Q-factor Q0 180.000
External SLED Q-factor QE 21400
Iris radius a [mm] 4.3-2.7
Group velocity vg [%] 4.5-1.0
Effective shunt Imp. Rs [M/m] 389
Filling time tf [ns] 140
Input power per structure Pk_s [MW] 9.8
Structures per module Nm
(input power per module Pk_m [MW])4 (39)
Total number of structures Ntot 80
Total number of klystrons Nk 20
Compact Light optimum
EuSPARC optimum
EuSPARC working point(optimization of RF power splitting)
Best effective shunt impedance
WP4 – RF structure Preliminary Parameters
Courtesy of A. Gallo
21
Funded by theEuropean Union
Towards an Ultra-Compact X-ray Free-Electron Laser, UCLA January 22-25, 2019 G. D’Auria
WP5: Undulators and light production (F. Nguyen, ENEA - Frascati)The primary objective of WP5 is to determine the undulator design for XLS. It will start byinvestigating state of art undulators and then consider on-going developments. “Ambitiousundulators” will be compared with the boundary conditions of technologies available on 4-5 yearstime scale. These will include:
• Novel short period undulators
• Superconducting undulator• RF-microwave undulators.
Particip. N. C. Undulators S.C. UndulatorsBeam Dynamics
(Opt. & Match.)
Exotic Undulators
(MW, ...)
Magn. Measur.
Facilities
ENEA
KYMA R. Geometrante
CERN
USTR
STFC
KIT A. Bernhard
PSI T. Schmidt
ANSTO D. Zhu
Au-IAT Z. Negriz
ALBA
Task Leaders
Different undulator solutions subject to the following investigations:
a. Shortest possible wavelength for a given beam energy.
b. Highest possible FEL performance (shortest gain length, highest saturation power) for a given target wavelength.
c. Highest possible undulator performance (shortest longitudinal space per undulator module, shortest undulator gap
width) for a given focusing scheme.
WP5
Courtesy of F. Nguyen
22
Funded by theEuropean Union
Towards an Ultra-Compact X-ray Free-Electron Laser, UCLA January 22-25, 2019 G. D’Auria
WP6: Beam dynamics and start-to-end modelling (A. Aksoy, UA IAT - Ankara)The main objective of WP6 is to provide key parameters and performance estimates of the Facility. Consistent tools for modelling the machine, as the basis for the integrated performance studies, will be developed.
• S2E simulations from the cathode to the undulator exit.• Tolerance studies will be also performed. • Beam-based alignment and tuning methods that can relax the tolerances.
WP6
Courtesy of A. Aksoy
23
Funded by theEuropean Union
Towards an Ultra-Compact X-ray Free-Electron Laser, UCLA January 22-25, 2019 G. D’Auria
CompactLight is funded by the European Union’s Horizon2020 Research and Innovation programme under Grant Agreement No. 777431