The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory...

60
The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church Building in Europe

Transcript of The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory...

Page 1: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church Building in Europe

Page 2: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

The patrimony of the church:accumulationof land and housesover the centuriesMortmain =Ecclesiasticalproperty cannot be sold or alienated

Properties belonging to the abbey of St.-Denis

Page 3: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

The Commercial Revolution – RobertLopez, 1971

Page 4: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early
Page 5: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

RomanEmpire

the High MiddleAges

Page 6: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early
Page 7: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early
Page 8: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

Population:England in 1086: 1,100,000

c. 1346: 3,700,000

Florence: c. 1300 120,000 by 1427 this declines to 36.909

Siena, 52,000Pisa, 40,000; by 1315 up to 50,000,

but by ca. 1350 declines to 8000, in 1427 is 7, 106

Perugia, 28,000; Arezzo, 20,000; Asissi, 1232, 12,397

most Italian cities did not recoup their pre-plague pop until late 19th

century

Page 9: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

New developments in agriculture

Changes in diet: legumes in addition to grains –more protein= greater fertility and longevity

Page 10: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

The heavy plow forheavy northernsoils; also:

1. Crop rotation

2. The horse collar

3. The horseshoe

4. Horses instead of oxen

5. Land clearance

Page 11: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

The horse collar, stirrups, and rotating axle

Page 12: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

The Bayeux Tapestry: a Norman warrior riding with stirrups

Page 13: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

At the same time, the increasing monetizationof the medieval economy - in effect the

origins of the modern commercial economy in which merchants became immensely wealthy

But wealth was complicated in the medievalchurch:

1. trade looked down upon2. money lending/borrowing for interest

a sin

Page 14: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

The importanceof Islam in establishing a model of effectivelong-distancetrade

Page 15: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early
Page 16: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early
Page 17: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

A Roman road in S. Italy (Apulia) – still an essential network in the Middle Ages

Page 18: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early
Page 19: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

Islam believed that the good, honest merchant was a valuable member of society; that trade was essential for well-being

Page 20: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early
Page 21: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

Medieval trade by theHigh Middle Ages

Page 22: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early
Page 23: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early
Page 24: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early
Page 25: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early
Page 26: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

The annualfair as anessentialform of trade andexchange

Page 27: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early
Page 28: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early
Page 29: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early
Page 30: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

Krakow, the market square and the cloth hall

Page 31: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early
Page 32: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early
Page 33: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early
Page 34: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early
Page 35: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early
Page 36: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early
Page 37: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early
Page 38: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early
Page 39: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

Also rivers:The RhoneThe RhineThe VistulaThe Po

Page 40: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early
Page 41: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

Technology: lifting wheels, waterwheels, windmills

Page 42: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early
Page 43: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early
Page 44: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

fulling

Page 45: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

The fate of the soul after Death mediated by thechurch

Intercessory prayerCommemorative masses

Salvation becomes a commodity

Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory

double entry bookeeping----------

Page 46: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early 11th century

Page 47: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

Modena Cathedral

Page 48: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

Parma Cathedral

Page 49: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

Parma Cathedral

Page 50: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

Pisa: the Cathedral Complex

baptistery

cathedral

tower

Page 51: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early
Page 52: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early
Page 53: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

Florence, the Baptistery and the Cathedral

Page 54: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

Ferrara: the Loggia of the Mercanti(merchant’s lodge)

Lay patronage

Page 55: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

Aquileia: the Early Christian Cathedral

Page 56: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

The pavement of Aquileia Cathedral

Page 57: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

Donor from Aquileia

Page 58: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

The new “incentive system” for pious donations: the doctrine ofPURGATORY

Page 59: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early

The fate of the soul after deathas mediated by the church

Intercessory prayerCommemorative masses

Salvation becomes a commodity

Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory

(double entry bookeepinginvented by Fibonacci, inPisa, early 13th century? )

Page 60: The Commercial Revolution and the Revival of Church ... · Jacques Le Goff: The Birth of Purgatory double entry bookeeping-----Italian City-States and their Cathedrals, starting early