The Al Qaeda Connection

download The Al Qaeda Connection

of 23

Transcript of The Al Qaeda Connection

  • 8/6/2019 The Al Qaeda Connection

    1/23

    The Al Qaeda Connection

    Al Qaeda, Bin Laden and the New Terrorism of the 21st Century

    A seminar paper submitted toDR. CLARITA R. CARLOS

    and the Department of Political ScienceUniversity of the Philippines, Diliman

    In partial fulfillment of the requirements for

    INTERNATIONAL STUDIES 203(GEOGRAPHICAL CONTEXT OF INTERNATIONAL AFFAIRS)

    By

    TAN, AVEMAR T.

    MA International Studies Program 2002-056959 October 2009

  • 8/6/2019 The Al Qaeda Connection

    2/23

    TAN, AVEMAR T. 2002-05695 THE AL QAEDA CONNECTI ON Page | 2

    Introduction to the Study:

    The high-jacking incidents that climaxed into successive and deliberate attacks

    against the World Trade Center in New York and the Pentagon in Arlington, Virginia, which

    took place in the morning of 11 September 2001, have no doubt been the subject of a

    number of articles, news reports and researches. It has sparked the resurgence of public

    interest on the phenomena of terrorism that has otherwise vacillated throughout history,

    between highs and lows, usually corresponding to when the acts of violence occur.

    The perceived severity of the 9/11 Attacks has, however, ignited a greater sense of

    fear and anger particularly among the American population and has since spread across the

    region through the Bush-driven Global War on Terrorism (GWoT). In turn, this aggression

    against Afghanistan, believed to be the stronghold of Osama bin Laden s AlQaeda, and the

    subsequent War launched in Iraq, has prejudiced against the Islamic faith, it being

    identified as the religious foundation of those who perpetrated the 9/11 and a number of

    other similar attacks. Far from being a religion of peace, some critics allege, Islam preaches

    violence against non-believers. Criticisms such as these have profound impacts on

    international response to terrorism as Muslims have now acquired a rather negative

    connotation and their images are often demonized. The demonization of the enemy and the

    absolute polarization of the conflict in turn triggers a sense of deep hostility and mutual

    hatred, robbing the situation of any neutral ground (Smelser, 2007; Primakov, 2004). Since

    it is in the interest of many to maintain relative peace, the polarization of conflicts along the

  • 8/6/2019 The Al Qaeda Connection

    3/23

    TAN, AVEMAR T. 2002-05695 THE AL QAEDA CONNECTI ON Page | 3

    lines of matters such as religion or culture may prove to be damaging and should be

    avoided (Primakov, 2004).

    As such, there is a need to explore this new wave of terrorism that was said to

    have been brought about by Al Qaeda under the leadership of Osama bin Laden, through

    the September 11 Attacks, to determine whether there is indeed novelty in the terrorism

    experienced during this 21stCentury.

    The alleged network of operations of Al Qaeda also need to be explored and the

    implications of its existence on international response toward the threat of terrorism,

    analyzed.

    Hypothesis:

    Osama bin Ladens Al Qaeda, unleashed a new and novel form of terrorism in the

    international arena during this Century through its vast network of operations.

    Objectives of the Study:

    1. Present historical manifestations of terrorism, its motivations and the usual tacticsit employs so as to be able to compare whether or not there is novelty in the Al

    Qaedas motivations and tactics;

  • 8/6/2019 The Al Qaeda Connection

    4/23

    TAN, AVEMAR T. 2002-05695 THE AL QAEDA CONNECTI ON Page | 4

    2. Discuss how the Islamic faith has been reinterpreted to justify the perpetration ofterrorist attacks

    3. Based on previous studies conducted, present the extent of the scope of bin Ladensnetwork and to present evidence that disputes the existence of the Al Qaeda

    Tackling the Definitional Abyss:

    While much debate has surrounded the establishment of a general and widely

    acceptable definition of the term terrorism, this has not prevented it from becoming the

    subject of academic inquiry. Most, if not all, of the works written on terrorism have

    however acknowledged the existence of a definitional abyss (Weinberg, White; Lutz and

    Lutz; Enders and Sandler, Singh; Laqueur; Smelser). This abyss is attributable to the fact

    that the term itself is not value neutral to begin with.1 The term terrorism and its root

    word terror connote negativity, that the person terrorizing is committing some form of

    socially unacceptable conduct (White, 2002;Lutz and Lutz, 2004).

    Academicians and state institutions have since floated several definitions. The US,

    which has adopted the frontline in the Post 9/11 Global War on Terror (GWoT), defines

    terrorism, through its State Department as premeditated, politically motivated violence

    1This is discussed in detail by the following authors in their works:

    White, Jonathan R. (2002) Terrorism: An Introduction. 3rd

    Ed. Canada: Wadsworth Group; Lutz, James M. and

    Brenda J. Lutz (2004) Global Terrorism. New York: Routledge; Laqueur, Walter (2004) No End to War: Terrorism in

    the 21st

    Century. New York: Continuum International Publishing Group Inc; Weinberg, Leonard. (2005) Global

    Terrorism: A Beginners Guide. Oxford: Oneworld Publications; Singh, Bilveer (2007) The Talibanization of

    Southeast Asia: Losing the War on Terror to Islamist Extremists. Connecticut: Praeger Security International;

    Smelser, Neil J. (2007) The Faces of Terrorism: Social and Psychological Dimensions.

  • 8/6/2019 The Al Qaeda Connection

    5/23

    TAN, AVEMAR T. 2002-05695 THE AL QAEDA CONNECTI ON Page | 5

    perpetuated against noncombatant targets by sub national groups or clandestine agents

    usually intended to influence and audience (Weinberg, 2005; Whittaker, 2007).

    The United Kingdom, a staunch ally of the US has its own definition of terrorism:

    the use of violence for political ends and included any use of violence for the purpose of

    putting the public or any section of the public in fear (Weinberg, 2005).

    A number of academics, including Walter Laqueur, Walter Enders, Todd Sandler,

    and Neil Smelser, have likewise offered their own working definitions, which have four

    common elements namely:

    (1) a psychological aspect, that terrorism is meant to have a psychological effect onits audience;

    (2) political aspect, that terrorism involves power relationships;(3) irregularity as a tactic, that terrorism is an asymmetric form of warfare, and(4) an aspect of violence

    One of the most comprehensive definitions proposed for the use of academicians

    was offered by James and Brenda Lutz in their work entitled Global Terrorism:

    Terrorism involves political aims and motives. It is violent or threatens

    violence. It is designed to generate fear in a target audience that extends

    beyond the immediate victims of the violence. The violence is conducted by an

    identifiable organization. The violence involves a non-state actor or actors as

    either the perpetrator, the victim of the violence or both. Finally, the acts of

    violence are designed to create power in situations in which power previously

    had been lacking.

    Despite the definitional conundrum that has plagued its study, it is erroneous to

    conclude that terrorism is a recent phenomenon. Academics note that the word terrorism

    first entered the vocabulary through the French language between 1793-94 during the

  • 8/6/2019 The Al Qaeda Connection

    6/23

    TAN, AVEMAR T. 2002-05695 THE AL QAEDA CONNECTI ON Page | 6

    regime de la terreur or the Reign of Terror under the post-revolutionary government of

    Robespierre (Weinberg, 2005; Enders and Sandler, 2006; White, 2003). The execution of

    thousands of those who opposed the transformation of the French Society characterized

    this period in French history (Enders and Sandler, 2006; Lutz and Lutz, 2004).

    Although the term itself emerged only in the 18th Century, there has been record of

    terrorist attacks perpetrated in as early as the first century A. D. with the group Zealots

    Sicarri who sought to provoke a Jewish uprising against the Romans (Laqueur, 1978;

    Weinberg, 2005; Enders and Sandler, 2006). The group went about stabbing to death

    Jewish leaders who were seen as collaborators with the Romans (Laqueur, 1978, Weinberg,

    2005). The murders were perpetrated in broad daylight, often in public places during

    feasts or when people filled the market so as the attack would have a large audience

    (Weinberg, 2005).

    Since then, acts which may be characterized as terrorist it nature have been carried

    out in various instances, such as during the Russian Revolution (Enders and Sandler, 2006).

    Weinberg and Rapoports Waves of Terrorism

    Leonard Weinberg (2005) and David Rapoport (1984) categorize modern terrorism

    as occurring in four separate waves: the first between the period of 1880 to the onset of

    World War II which occurred mostly within or involving the Russian Empire; the second

    wave which covers the post World War II terrorist tactics used by nationalist, communist

  • 8/6/2019 The Al Qaeda Connection

    7/23

    TAN, AVEMAR T. 2002-05695 THE AL QAEDA CONNECTI ON Page | 7

    and ethnic separatist insurgents; the third during the decade of 1970 to 1980 wherein the

    threat of terrorism had increased dramatically and the fourth, which has been

    characterized as being far more menacing than any point in its modern history and

    had manifested beginning this 21stCentury (Weinberg, 2005).

    According to Weinberg and Rapoport, modern terrorisms first wave emerged

    within the context of a political arena that was still largely dominated by the aristocracy

    and the Empire, more specifically during the turning point when revolutionary ideals such

    as those which spawned the French Revolution were spreading across the European region

    (Rapoport, 1984; Weinberg, 2005; Enders and Sandler, 2006).

    In Russia for instance, the tide of nationalism, and combined with the yearning of

    groups such as the Russian Peoples Will to establish a liberal constitutional regime that

    was to usher in socialism became the fuel which fed the peoples conviction in launching

    assassinations against the aristocrats, such as Czar Alexander II in 1881 (Primakov, 2004;

    White, 2003; Enders and Sandler, 2006; Weinberg 2005). These acts were greatly

    influenced by the philosophies of anarchist terrorism of Mikhail Bakunin and Sergey

    Nechev, who, writing with the hopes of igniting a democratic revolution, were able to spark

    instead, a radical one (White, 2002). Severe repression, wherein the entire executive

    committee of the Peoples Will was eliminated, met the path to radical revolution (Enders

    and Sandler, 2006; White, 2002).

  • 8/6/2019 The Al Qaeda Connection

    8/23

    TAN, AVEMAR T. 2002-05695 THE AL QAEDA CONNECTI ON Page | 8

    Later, more violent groups such as the Socialist Revolutionaries emerged in the

    beginning of the 20th Century (Weinberg 2005). The Bolsheviks under Vladimir Lenin who

    initially opposed these kinds of tactics, eventually, when they found it convenient, engaged

    in terrorist acts such as politically motivated bank robberies that funded their cause

    (Weinberg, 2005). Other groups such as the anarchists also undertook such politically

    motivated Spanish Foreign Minister and the King of Italy among others (Weinberg, 2005).

    Groups, which sought independence for their people such as Ustascha who wanted

    to create an independent Croatia, also began to employ terrorist tactics culminating in the

    assassination of the Yugoslav king, Alexander and the French foreign minister in 1934

    (White, 2002; Weinberg, 2005).

    The Second Wave of Terrorism, as conceptualized by Weinberg (2005) and

    Rapoport (1984), saw the increased diversity in the goals pursued by terrorist groups. A

    number of groups sought independence from their colonizers others, usually ethnic

    minorities, sought separation, while others, such as the communists desired change and

    freedom from what they felt was an oppressive state.

    Taking place just after the Second World War which had destroyed the trappings of

    aristocratic power and which had effectively changed the power relationships in the

    international arena, colonies of former empires found the grip of their European

    motherland weakening (Weinberg 2005; White, 2002). In areas where the colonial power

    sought to maintain its dominant posture, such as in Indonesia and French Indochina and

  • 8/6/2019 The Al Qaeda Connection

    9/23

    TAN, AVEMAR T. 2002-05695 THE AL QAEDA CONNECTI ON Page | 9

    British Malaya, armed struggles, which on occasion employed terrorist tactics, were

    frequent (Weinberg 2005).

    Terrorist tactics perpetrated by nationalist groups was not limited to Asia. In

    countries such as Yemen, Cyprus, Kenya, Palestine and Algeria, terrorism was also a

    dominant method employed to counter colonial rule (Enders and Sandler, 2006). In Algeria

    for instance, the Front de Liberation Nationale (FLN) who allegedly employed tactics that

    were previously used by Jewish terrorists led the revolt against the French rule. (Enders

    and Sandler, 2006). The use of terrorist tactics was however, more common in areas where

    there were marked ethnic divides or where communist insurgents sought dominance

    (Weinberg, 2005). Pockets of conflict such as those in Vietnam, Western Europe and Latin

    America with their varied causes likewise showed increased propensity to use terrorism as

    a tactic (Weinberg, 2005).

    It was during this period that marked improvements in modern communication

    such as television broadcasting occurred. This enabled terrorists to generate a wider

    viewership (Kiras, n.d.). In addition to this, other technological advancements, particularly

    those that involved transportation increased the frequency and volume of travelers (Kiras,

    n. d.; Weinberg, 2005; Lutz and Lutz, 2004). This also opened a new avenue for terrorists

    and high-jacking became one of the means through which they could air their demands

    (Primakov, 2004).

  • 8/6/2019 The Al Qaeda Connection

    10/23

    TAN, AVEMAR T. 2002-05695 TH E AL QA EDA CONN ECTI ON Page | 10

    According to Weinberg, by the 1970s, the use of terrorism to further political ends

    had become widespread and the threat had evolved into an international problem

    (Weinberg, 2005). For instance, terrorist activity perpetrated by guerillas in the Latin

    America continued within the context of a socialist revolt. These were opposed, with

    varying degrees of success, through equally varied degrees of repression (Weinberg, 2005).

    In West Asia, the Palestinian Liberation Organization, which had earlier launched a

    massive campaign against Israel, had changed its strategy, adopting what was essentially a

    terrorist campaign against Israel and the states that supported the latter (Lutz and Lutz,

    2004; Enders and Sandler, 2006). In the summer of 1970, members of the PLO, under the

    tutelage of Yasser Arafat, high jacked four commercial planes using their hostages as

    leverage for their demands (Lutz and Lutz, 2004; White, 2002). While negotiations had

    succeeded in releasing the hostages, the PLO ended up blowing up the planes, an act that

    reverberated throughout the world (Weinberg, 2005). Jordan, one of the states from which

    the PLO operated responded to this event with a massive campaign to disarm the group,

    expelling them (White, 2002). Known as the Black September, the Jordanian move

    crippled PLO and it was thus forced to migrate to Lebanon where it later reestablished its

    headquarters (White, 2002). Over the next few years, the PLO continued to launch massive

    terrorist attacks including the one perpetrated against the Israeli athletes who were

    supposed to participate in the 1972 Olympic Games (Lutz and Lutz, 2004).

    The wave of terror that spread during this decade did not confine itself to the

    Latin American and the West Asian region. As the United States continued its increasingly

  • 8/6/2019 The Al Qaeda Connection

    11/23

    TAN, AVEMAR T. 2002-05695 TH E AL QA EDA CONN ECTI ON Page | 11

    unpopular war in Vietnam, protests from left-wing groups gained media attention after

    employing terrorist acts (Weinberg, 2005). It must also be noted that terrorism

    orchestrated by racist and right wing groups such as the 1995 bombing of the Murrah

    Building in Oklahoma City, have generally been more prevalent (Lutz and Lutz, 2004;

    Weinberg, 2005).

    The violence of what has since been popularly referred to as the Oklahoma City

    bombing was however eclipsed, rather permanently, by the horror witnessed on that

    fateful day of September the 11th, a single incident that has brought, by far, the largest

    number of casualties, not to mention the lives lost as a result of the wars waged in its wake

    (Pettiford and Harding, 2003; Singh, 2007; Weinberg 2005; Primakov, 2004). It is this latter

    incident, which Weinberg eventually identifies as having ushered in the new wave of

    terrorism, characterized as far more menacing (Weinberg, 2005).

    Two questions, however, beg for answers. First of all, is there really something new

    in this new wave of terrorism? Second, could the Al Qaeda really be credited for ushering

    in this new wave?

    Al Qaeda, Bin Laden and the Infamous Network:

    Al Qaeda, the terrorist organization allegedly run by Osama Bin Laden took the

    center stage when, in the aftermath of 9/11, the responsibility for the attacks were

    constantly and consistently attributed to the organization as Bin Ladens handiwork

  • 8/6/2019 The Al Qaeda Connection

    12/23

    TAN, AVEMAR T. 2002-05695 TH E AL QA EDA CONN ECTI ON Page | 12

    (Chandler and Gunaratna, 2007;Primakov, 2004). Bin Laden and Al Qaeda gave a face, a

    leader and a name who can be blamed for the tragic events of 9/11.

    According to most accounts, conceived in the 1980s, the Al Qaeda (translated

    simply as the Base) was the successor of the Maktab-al Khidamat(MAK) or the Afghan

    Service Bureau, which Bin Laden and Sheik Abdullah Azzam created in 1984, to recruit

    young Muslims for the war against the Soviet Red Armys invasion of Afghanistan (Singh,

    2007; Weinberg, 2005; Pettiford and Harding, 2003). Due in part to the funding and

    support extended by the United States in its attempt to undermine Moscow and the spread

    of Communism, training camps were set up and Bin Laden was able to train the mujahidins

    who were instrumental in warding off the Soviets (Singh, 2007, Pettiford and Harding,

    2003; Primakov, 2004; Chandler and Gunaratna, 2007).

    After the latters defeat and the triumph of the MAK, the group metamorphosed

    (Pettiford and Harding, 2003). Not only was the name changed to Al Qaeda, according to

    Weinberg but its objective also changed (Weinberg, 2005). In addition to aiding other

    Muslims who were struggling against oppression, the group now desired to establish a pan-

    Islamic state that would unite all Muslims (Pettiford and Harding, 2003; White, 2002). This

    was consistent with Bin Ladens desire to cure the conflict that pitted the Sunni Muslims

    against the Shiites (White, 2002).

    Inspired by the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood and influenced by Islamic thinkers

    such as Hassan al Banna, Sayyid Qutb and Mawlana Mawdudi during his early years at the

  • 8/6/2019 The Al Qaeda Connection

    13/23

    TAN, AVEMAR T. 2002-05695 TH E AL QA EDA CONN ECTI ON Page | 13

    University, Bin Laden grew to adopt these writers radical rejection of Western

    civilization and their Islamic revivalist and reformist teachings (Singh, 2007). This,

    combined with the influential and rising tide of pan-Islamist thinking and Bin Laden s

    adherence to the purist form of Islam called Wahhabism that has since evolved and has

    been adopted by Saudi Arabia as its state religion, became the ideological foundations of his

    subsequent movements to unite the Muslim world and reestablish the Caliphate (Jacquard,

    2002; White, 2002, Singh 2007; Weinberg, 200; Primakov, 2004; Chandler and Gunaratna,

    2007).

    The immediate trigger of Bin Ladens anger particularly against the United States

    was, the refusal of the King of Saudi the use of his mujahidin as defense against the

    perceived threat emanating from Iraq following the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait (Weinberg,

    2005). Refusing, the Saudis turned instead to the United States for help, a decision that

    infuriated Bin Laden and drove him to condemn the Saudis openly (Weinberg, 2005). In

    response, Bin Laden was stripped of his Saudi citizenship and, fearing reprisal, he and his

    mujahidin fled to Pakistan and then to Sudan where they were invited by Hassan al Turabi,

    the latters spiritual leader (Institute for Counterterrorism, 2006; Weinberg, 2005; Abuzza,

    2002).

    For two years, between 1994 and 1996 Bin Laden set up businesses and

    infrastructure projects in Sudan from where he also controlled Al Qaeda operations

    (Institute for Counterterrorism, 2006; Rabasa, 2008). Due to pressure from the United

    States however, Sudanese government was forced to ask Bin Laden to leave (Institute for

  • 8/6/2019 The Al Qaeda Connection

    14/23

    TAN, AVEMAR T. 2002-05695 TH E AL QA EDA CONN ECTI ON Page | 14

    Counterterrorism, 2006; Rabasa, 2008; Weinberg, 2005; Jacquard, 2002). He left and set up

    camp in Afghanistan that was by then under the Taliban regime (Institute for

    Counterterrorism, 2006; Chandle and Gunaratna 2007; Jacquard, 2002). It was from his

    stronghold in Afghanistan that in 1998, he and Al Zawahiri created the umbrella

    organization called theAl-Jabhah al Islamiyya al-Alamiyyah li-Qital al-Yahud Wal Salibiyyin

    or the Islamic World Front for the Struggle against the Jews and the Crusaders (Institute for

    Counterterrorism, 2006) .

    Beginning in the 1990s, a number of terrorist attacks have been attributed to Bin

    Laden and his network. These included the bombings in Riyadh in November 1995,

    Dhahran in June 1996, Yemen in December 1992 and the World Trade Center in February

    1993 (Institute for Counterterrorism, 2006). It was only after the capture of Mohammed

    Sadiq Odeh, one of the suspects in the WTC bombing that the extent of the Al Qaedas

    network was discovered (Institute for Counterterrorism, 2006).

    Organizationally, the al Qaeda may be divided into two, the center, headed by the

    Emir General and the periphery that forms his international network (Weinberg, 2005).

    Some claim that the said network spans over 70 countries but this is yet to be confirmed

    (Weinberg, 2005).

    The Al Qaeda whose center of operations is assumed to be within the Taliban

    controlled Afghanistan, by virtue of its geographical proximity and religious affinity, has

    been linked with the Chechen nationalist groups operating within the Ichkerian Republic of

  • 8/6/2019 The Al Qaeda Connection

    15/23

    TAN, AVEMAR T. 2002-05695 TH E AL QA EDA CONN ECTI ON Page | 15

    Chechnya (Kramer, n. d.; Swart, 2004; Darling, 2004; Williams, 2004; Brownfield, 2003). It

    was said that Bin Laden had even thought of transferring headquarters to Chechnya

    (Brownfield, 2003).

    Figure 1. Map showing Chechnya and Afghanistan

    Source: http://www.umt.edu/cali/MapCentralAsia.jpg

    Since it first infiltrated the region, it was alleged that the Chechens had begun to

    employ terrorist tactics such as the attack in the Moscow theater in the fall of 2002

    (Williams, 2004). Suicide bombings have also begun to be adopted by the nationalist

    separatist group in their undertakings (Brownfield, 2003). It has also been reported that

    Islamic extremist groups such as the Al Qaeda have provided approximately $100 Million in

  • 8/6/2019 The Al Qaeda Connection

    16/23

    TAN, AVEMAR T. 2002-05695 TH E AL QA EDA CONN ECTI ON Page | 16

    aid to rebels since 1996 (Brownfield, 2003; Williams, 2004). In addition, despite originally

    being of moderate orientation the Chechens, through their frequent contact with the

    Islamic mujahidins who were of the radicalized Wahhabi Islamic faith, are feared to have

    undergone radicalization of their own (Brownfield, 2003). As such, the conflict shall cease

    to be secular and shall be subsumed into the wider Islam against the West umbrella.

    Southeast Asia, which has one of the highest concentrations of Muslim population in

    Asia has also been linked with the Al Qaeda network. Groups operating within the region

    such as the Jemaah al Islamiah and the Abu Sayyaf have metamorphosed from separatist

    groups into terrorist organizations, which form part of the periphery of Bin Ladens

    massive network. Through the former mujahidin who trained in Afghanistan and who, after

    their victory, returned to their respective countries, domestic struggles were linked with

    the international network, radicalizing them also in the process (Abuza, 2002). While in

    Afghanistan, these men were exposed to the works of al Banna, Madudi and Qutb that

    advocated for the reconstruction of Islam to achieve political goals (Singh, 2007). Due in

    part to the regions porous borders, relatively large Muslim population and the long history

    of insurgency and Muslim separatism in the region, Southeast Asia has become the second

    front in the Global War on Terror (Singh, 2007).

    Similarly, East Africas porous borders combined with the environment of weak

    governance and collapsed states, made the region conducive to the presence of Islamist

    extremists (Rabasa, 2008). In addition, its geographical proximity and social, cultural and

    religious affinities with the Arabian Peninsula make it all the more vulnerable and

  • 8/6/2019 The Al Qaeda Connection

    17/23

    TAN, AVEMAR T. 2002-05695 TH E AL QA EDA CONN ECTI ON Page | 17

    susceptible to Al Qaeda influence and radicalization (Rabasa, 2008). As such, East Africa,

    where Sudan, a state from which Bin Laden once had exercised his influence, remains a

    priority area in al Qaedas global strategy (Rabasa, 2008). Within the East African region, al

    Qaeda successfully carried out the bombings of US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania in

    1998 (Shinn, n. d.). Since then, the authorities have foiled a number of plots, which had

    been spearheaded by domestic insurgent groups linked with the al Qaeda (Shinn, n. d.).

    Figure 2. Map of East Africa

    Source: http://www.africa-adventure.com/images/east_africa_map.jpg

  • 8/6/2019 The Al Qaeda Connection

    18/23

    TAN, AVEMAR T. 2002-05695 TH E AL QA EDA CONN ECTI ON Page | 18

    There are those, however, who challenge the existence of this Al Qaeda. According

    to author Jason Burke, al Qaeda does not exist (Burke, 2008). While noting that the term

    al Qaeda, from the Arabic root word qaf-ayn-dalhas been used since the mid-1980s by

    radical Muslim groups, the same, had in fact, multiple meanings ranging from: a base, as in

    a camp or a home, a foundation, such is what is beneath a house or a pedestal that supports

    a column; the lowest, broadest layer of a large cumulonimbus-type cloud and, also, it

    could mean a precept, rule, principle, maxim, formula, method, model or pattern (Burke,

    2008). The term was also used by Abdullah Azzam, who had been identified in other books

    as the founder of the Maktab-al Khidamat (MAK/Afghan Service Bureau) when in 1987 he

    was quoted as writing:

    Every principle needs a vanguard to carry it forward and (to) put

    up with heavy tasks and enormous sacrifices. There is no ideology, neither

    earthly nor heavenly that does not require a vanguard that giveseverything it possesses in order to achieve victory It carries the flag all

    along the sheer endless and difficult path until it reaches its destination inthe reality of life, since Allah has destined that it should make it and

    manifest itself. This vanguard constitutes the strong foundation (al-qaeda

    al sulbah) for the expected society.

    According to Burke, some analysts had misinterpreted this to mean that a group

    with the name al-qaeda al sulbahhad been established in that year (Burke, 2008). From

    Burkes analysis, he concludes that Azzams writing, with its reference to vanguards,

    which is a term that is also replete in Islamic writings, was talking of al-qaeda al sulbah

    not as an organization but rather as a mode of activism, a tactic. Even in the bookAn

    Encyclopedia of Jihad, put together between 1991 to 1993 in Pakistan, the al Qaeda

    organization is notably absent according to Burke. It was in 1996 when the CIA, through

    one of its reports, first used the term: by 1985 bin Laden had organized an Islamic

  • 8/6/2019 The Al Qaeda Connection

    19/23

    TAN, AVEMAR T. 2002-05695 TH E AL QA EDA CONN ECTI ON Page | 19

    Salvation Front, or al-Qaeda, to support mujahideen in Afghanistan. Burke however

    mentions that it is unclear whether the term al-Qaeda was made in reference to an existing

    organization considering the fact that throughout the entire CIA report, the said term was

    never mentioned again. It was in the following year that the US State Department used the

    same term for the first time but used it to refer to an operational hub, predominantly for

    like-minded Sunni extremists. In that sense, it was not an organization to begin with.

    Analysis and Conclusion:

    Despite conflicting evidence as to the existence of al Qaeda, one thing is certain, a

    militant extremist group had been established at some point during the 1980s under the

    auspices of Osama Bin Laden and whether or not it is called the Al Qaeda, and whether or

    not it has adopted such a resilient organizational structure would be of secondary

    importance in light of evidence which links local radical Islamic groups in Russia, Southeast

    Asia, and East Africa among others, to the network ofmujahidin created by Bin Laden in

    Afghanistan where Wahhabism, Qutbs teachings and an ideology of pan-Islamism had

    taken strong root. Whether or not an organization called al Qaeda exists or did exist in the

    1980s, of more concern to policy makers, state decision makers and counterterrorism

    operatives, is the existence of real links between radical Muslim groups in the world. This,

    coupled with the strength of their adherence to their Islamic roots, and their selective and

    radical interpretations of the Quranic text, their religious motivation and justification

    which makes it to a certain extentbeyond reason (Harris, 2006).

  • 8/6/2019 The Al Qaeda Connection

    20/23

    TAN, AVEMAR T. 2002-05695 TH E AL QA EDA CONN ECTI ON Page | 20

    In determining the novelty of this new wave of terrorism it is made apparent from

    historic accounts that terrorism perpetrated in the name of religion is not unique to the

    21st Century nor is it unique to Islam. The Sacarri, during the 1st Century A.D. undertook

    their assassinations with the justification that it would usher in the end of days (Lutz and

    Lutz, 2004). The trend of reinterpreting religious text to justify otherwise socially

    unacceptable acts is therefore nothing novel. Suicide bombing, a tactic that has recently

    been on the rise, and is what has often been used in attacks linked to Islamic extremist

    groups is equally not a new phenomena, in fact, according to Robert Pape, it has been a

    tactic employed by separatist groups such as the Tamil Tigers (Pape, 2006). Even the

    transnational character of its operations is nothing new considering the extent of

    operations carried out by the Palestinian Liberation Organization in the 1970s to the

    1980s.

    Where does the novelty lie then? It is concluded that terrorism in the 21st Century,

    differs very little from its past manifestations. In fact, its motivations, tactics and methods

    are similar to terrorist attacks occurring in other decades and in other locations. What may

    be regarded as the novelty of the Osama Bin Laden brand of terrorism as opposed to

    others before it and other groups of different ideological or religious orientation lies in the

    scope of its network, whether it be al-Qaeda, or under the guise of another organization

    altogether. In addition, there is novelty in Osama Bin Laden s ability to bring together

    Islamic groups of various nationalities, with numerous and varied grievances under the

    single and potent banner of Pan-Islamism.

  • 8/6/2019 The Al Qaeda Connection

    21/23

    TAN, AVEMAR T. 2002-05695 TH E AL QA EDA CONN ECTI ON Page | 21

    References:

    1. Abuza, Zachary. Tentacles of Terror: Al Qaedas Southeast Asian Network,Contemporary Southeast Asia. 24:3 (December 2002).

    2. Brownfield, Peter. The Afghanistan of Chechnya, The International Spectator.March 2003.

    3. Burke, Jason. Al Qaeda: The True Story of Radical Islam. New York: I. B. Tauris,2008.

    4. Chandler Michael and Rohan Gunaratna. Countering terrorism: Can we meet thethreat of global violence? London : Reaktion, 2007

    5. Darling, Dan. Special Analysis: Al Qaeda in Chechnya,Winds of Change Website.Accessed through: http//www.windsofchange.net/archives/004893.html.

    Retrieved on 8 August 2009.

    6. Enders, Walter and Todd Sandler (2006) The Political Economy of Terrorism.New York: Cambridge University Press.

    7. Harris, Sam The End of Faith: Religion, Terror and the Future of Reason. GreatBritain: The Free Press, 2005.

    8. Institute for Counter-Terrorism. Background, Al Qaeda: An Organization to beReckoned With. Edited by: Lawrence J. Bevy. New York: Novinka Books, 2006.

    9. Jacquard, Roland. In the Name of Osama Bin Laden: Global Terrorism and theBin Laden Brotherhood. North Carolona: Duke University Press

    10.Kiras, James. Terrorism and Globalization. PDF File Format. Oxford UniversityPress Website. Accessed through:

  • 8/6/2019 The Al Qaeda Connection

    22/23

    TAN, AVEMAR T. 2002-05695 TH E AL QA EDA CONN ECTI ON Page | 22

    www.oup.com/uk/orc/bin/9780199271184/ch21.pdf Retrieved on: 30 September

    2009.

    11.Kramer, Mark. The Domestic Political Context of Russias War in Chechnya. OhioState University Website. Accessed through:

    https://kb.osu.edu/dspace/bitstream/1811/30222/.../KramerPaper.pdf Retrieved

    on: 9 August 2009

    12.Laqueur, Walter. The Age of Terrorism Little Brown Press, 1987.13.Laqueur, Walter. No End to War: Terrorism in the Twenty-first Century. New

    York: Continuum. 2004.

    14.Laqueur, Walter (ed.) The Terrorism Reader: A Historical Anthology. New York:Meridian, 1978.

    15.Lutz, James M. and Brenda J. Lutz. Global Terrorism. New York: Routledge, Taylorand Francis Group, 2004.

    16.Margulies, Philip. Al Qaeda: Osama Bin Ladens Army of Terrorists. New York:The Rosen Publishing Group Inc., 2003.

    17.Pape, Robert A. Dying to Win: The Strategic Logic of Suicide Terrorism. NewYork: Random House, 2005.

    18.Pettiford, Lloyd and David Harding. Terrorism: The New World War. London:Arcturus Publishing Ltd., 2003

    19.Primakov, Yevgeny M. A World Challenged: Fighting Terrorism in the 21stCentury. Washington: The Nixon Center, 2004.

    20.Rabasa, Angel. Radical Islam in East Africa. Sta. Moncia, CA: Rand Corporation,2009.

  • 8/6/2019 The Al Qaeda Connection

    23/23