The ABC’s for ABD’s: Tips for Working Your Way through Dissertation to Ph.D.
description
Transcript of The ABC’s for ABD’s: Tips for Working Your Way through Dissertation to Ph.D.
1 ABC’s for ABD’s BoF
The ABC’s for ABD’s: Tips for Working Your Way
through Dissertation to Ph.D.
Shannon Duvall Elon University
Katarzyna Wac University of Geneva
Thursday, October 2nd 2008, 5:25 - 6:25 p.m.Torreys Peak III
Shannon I Steinfadt Kent State University
Anne Weinberger BracyIntel Corporation
2 ABC’s for ABD’s BoF
Agenda
• Welcome
• Introduction to Who We Are
• Our ABC’s for ABD’s
• Recommended Resources
• Your Experiences
3 ABC’s for ABD’s BoF
Piled Higher and Deeper by Jorge Cham
What’s ABD?
4 ABC’s for ABD’s BoF
Shannon I Steinfadt
• ABD at Kent State trying to finish up this academic year
• Had a long master’s degree that impacted the first year and half of her doctoral work
5 ABC’s for ABD’s BoF
Shannon Duvall
• Graduated 2006 from Duke
• Now teach at Elon (up for tenure this year)
• Had hard, hard, hard ABD road
• Now maintains gradMentalMakeover.com
6 ABC’s for ABD’s BoF
Anne Weinberger Bracy
• 2001: started PhD• 2003: went ABD• 2005: 6-month internship at Intel• 2006: got married, then proposed• 2007: began working full time• 2008: defended, had a baby, will
graduate
All-But-Dissertation All-Plus-Dissertation!
(Now is probably not the best time to ask me if it was worth it or if I would do it all over again if I had the choice….)
7 ABC’s for ABD’s BoF
Katarzyna Wac
• Did BSc-MSc in Poland, then MSc in Holland
• Started PhD in 2004 trying to finish up this academic year
• Dissertation: just a scientist-license?• ABD is more for you than for others!• First draft & communication• Emotions management along the way
8 ABC’s for ABD’s BoF
Our ABC’s for ABD’s
• Working with your advisor• 3 Fs of Research• Time Management• The Balancing Act• Emotional Management• Stress Management• Building a Support Network
9 ABC’s for ABD’s BoF
Working with your advisor
• Choose your advisor carefully– Hands on or hands off?– Do your expectations match your
advisor’s? (Is a dissertation a stapled document or a perfect work of art?)
• Be professional – not emotional– take notes, make goals– communicate clearly
10 ABC’s for ABD’s BoF
3 Fs of Research
• Focus: like your topic: what’s hot now may not be when you finish
• Feasibility: find a small sub-problem (i.e., don’t try to prove P=NP)
• Feedback: let your research, reading, advisors, and mentors lead you to (or keep you from!) additional sub-topics
11 ABC’s for ABD’s BoF
Time Management
• Be honest about how much time you spend on your dissertation
• Marathon vs. Sprint– Will you ever finish at your
current pace?– Will you survive at your
current pace?
12 ABC’s for ABD’s BoF
The Balancing Act (1)
Deadlines Accountability Feedback# of
Tasks
Work constant othersmuch,
immediategreat
variety
Relation-ships
events
+ noneothers
varies greatly
great variety
Childrendaily
mustsdependent
othersinstant +
hard-to-see∞
PhD rolling selflittle,
delayedONE
It’s not looking good for the PhD!
13 ABC’s for ABD’s BoF
The Balancing Act (2)• Dissertation
– Make your own deadlines, accountability• Work
– Must reign in, without neglecting– Coordinate with your employer– Utilize your income: housekeeping, take-
out, grocery delivery—whatever gives you more time to write!
• Relationships– Do not take for granted or take advantage– Neglect during the sprint, not the marathon!
• Children– Prioritize (all parents do this!)– Trust your instincts, relax and enjoy
14 ABC’s for ABD’s BoF
What is Important? Urgent?
Urgent, Not Important
Urgent, Important
Not Urgent, Important
Not Urgent, Not Important
Importance
Urg
ency
low high
low
high
Where will you place:• answering emails• having kids• building relationships• spiritual practice• reading papers• writing up status report• attending a wedding• playtime with your kids• food shopping• backing up your thesis• cleaning house• social engagements• debugging code• watching Heroes• celebrating anniversary• writing chapter 3• attending Grace Hopper• running experiments• exercise• writing thank you notes?
15 ABC’s for ABD’s BoF
Emotional Management
• Make decisions that take emotions into account
• No negative talk!
• Let go of guilt – it is not helpful
16 ABC’s for ABD’s BoF
Stress Management
• Take breaks (real ones)
• Change your work routine now and then
• Surround yourself with relaxing things
• Reward yourself
• Physical health– Take care of yourself– BSR: breathe, smile, relax :)
17 ABC’s for ABD’s BoF
Building a Support Network
• Family, friends, fellow grad students, mentors, partners, collaborators– How to take care of them? – How they take care of me?
Examples: weekly girls’ brunch/support group, regular meetings with mentor (not your advisor!), accept favors from family members
18 ABC’s for ABD’s BoF
Web Resources (1)
Web pages that helped us… • Mental health tips:
www.gradmentalmakeover.com• Time management: www.tickspot.com • Reference management:
– EndNote http://www.endnote.com – RefWorks http://www.refworks.com
• Mind mapping: freemind.sourceforge.net• Local school library and resource pages
– All sorts of journals, papers, and software may be *FREELY* available from your institutions
• Ph.D. Comics http://www.phdcomics.com
19 ABC’s for ABD’s BoF
Web Resources (2)
Web pages that helped us… • portals
– IEEE Xplore http://ieeexplore.ieee.org– ACM http://portal.acm.org– Google Scholar http://scholar.google.com– CiteSeer.IST http://citeseer.ist.psu.edu– DBLP Bibliography
http://www.informatik.uni-trier.de/~ley/db – Consider IEEE/ACM membership and special interest
groups (SIGs) that are relevant to your research area
• Wiki Page for this Bird of a Feather Discussion http://community.anitaborg.org/wiki/index.php/The_ABCs_for_ABDs:_Tips_for_Working_Your_Way_through_Dissertation_to_PhD
20 ABC’s for ABD’s BoF
Print Resources
Books that helped us… • Hamming, R. (1986). You and your research.
Unpublished manuscript, Morristown, NJ, USA. • Kelley, R. (1999). How to be a star engineer. IEEE
Spectrum, 51-58.• Rugg, G., & Petre, M. (2004). The unwritten rules of
PhD research. Open University Press. • Bolker, Joan (1998). Writing Your Dissertation in Fifteen
Minutes a Day. Holt and Co.• Zobel, J. (2004). Writing for Computer Science.
Springer.• Covey, S. (1989). The 7 Habits of Highly Effective
People. Free Press.• Goleman, D. (1995). Emotional Intelligence: Why it can
matter more than IQ. New York: Bantam.
21 ABC’s for ABD’s BoF
Questions ?
Comments ?
« Insert Your Experiences Here »
22 ABC’s for ABD’s BoF
Backup Slides
↓
23 ABC’s for ABD’s BoF
What’s Next?
• Academia or business?
• When? Where? With Whom?