The 1997/98 ENSO event

Multivariate ENSO Index

http://www.esrl.noaa.gov/psd/people/klaus.wolter/MEI/

Index is based on 6 parameters relevant to phase of ENSO:

sea level pressure zonal and meridional wind at surfacesea surface temperature air temperaturecloudiness

• A weakening and reversal of trade winds in Western and central Pacific led to anomalous warm SSTs east of date line in early 1997

• Warm waters (> 29C migrated eastwards, collapse of cold tongue in east, which failed to develop.

• El Nino developed so rapidly that each month between June-Dec 1997set a new monthly record high was set for SST in eastern equatorial Pacific.

• Development of El Nino in equatorial Pacific was significantly modulated by higher frequency variability.

• Weakening and reversal of trades was punctuated by a number of westerly wind bursts of increasing intensity along the equator (linked to several MJOs)

• Ocean currents forced by these WWBs, advected warm water eastwards.

• Also, WWBs forced downwelling K-waves (thermocline depth decreased by 90m in eastern Pacific by end of 97) – opposite anomaly in western Pacific.

• Rossby waves excited by the initial weakening of the trades propagated westwards towards.

•Net result was a flattening of the thermocline and disapperance of “normal” east-west gradient across the equator, resulting in a weakening of the trades etc etc etc (Bjerknes Feedback).

•

• Note anomalous SSTs in early 1998, SST anomalies superimposed on seasonal warming.

• Cooling did not take place until winds returned close to normal (easterly) in the middle of 1998. Very abrupt change associated with upwelling due to “normal” easterly wind strength. Change to La Nina.

The delayed oscillator theory and the 1997/98 El Nino

• Evolution of equatorial Pacific on interannual timescales is governed by interplay between large-scale equatorial wave processes and atmosphere-ocean feedbacks.

• Strictly the DO requires no new forcing and downwelling Kelvin waves should result from a reflection of a downwelling Rossby wave at the Western boundary.

• In reality, the only downwelling Kelvin waves seen in 1997/98 were associated with a succession of MJOs.

• DO theory predicts demise of El Nino to be associated with reflected upwelling Rossby waves at the western boundary – which was seen to occur after the onset of the El Nino.

• In addition there was direct wind-forcing of upwelling Kelvin waves associated with appearance of easterly wind anomalies in the West Pacific in late 1997 early 1998; so the demise was likely associated with upwelling Kelvin waves due to two different processes.

Implications for predictability (some final thoughts)

• Predictability arises from large-scale wave dynamics

• Skill of models limited by: model inadequacies, errors in initial conditions and tendencies towards chaos in the climate system.

• Forecast skill depends on season and decade.

• Models failed to capture rapid growth of 97/98 El Nino.

Models do not represent MJOs well.

Statistical models do not represent intraseasonal variability

Statistical models not good at extreme events

Implications for predictability (some final thoughts)

Some issues:

• Is variability of El Ninos (amplitude, phase, length) due to interaction between intraseasonal variability and the large-scale wave dynamics?

• What caused the trades to abruptly intensify at the end?

• What is the role of the Pacific Decadal Oscillation (PDO)? (warm phase since 1970)

• MJOs have been more active since the 1970’s due to a warmer Indian ocean – is this consistent with the higher frequency of El Ninos than La Ninas in this period?

• 1997 and 1998 at the time were the warmest years on record , continuing a global warming trend in the 20th century. Are the recent more frequent El Ninos associated with this warming?

http://eol.jsc.nasa.gov/newsletter/DynamicEarth/Chapter5/Cp5.htm

http://www.cdc.noaa.gov/ncep_reanalysis

http://iri.columbia.edu/climate/ENSO/globalimpact/temp_precip/index.html#events

http://www.pmel.noaa.gov/tao/jsdisplay/

ENSO Summary

•Introduction & Observations

•Theory

Bjerknes Feedback

Delayed Oscillator

Recharge-Discharge Theory

•Impacts

Observations

Teleconnections (Zonal and Meridional)

• 1997-1998 El Nino event