Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon OCB 2019 ...€¦ · 2 Buried Carbon Particulate...

24
Amelie Berger, Peter Berg, Karen McGlathery, Lillian Aoki, Matthew Oreska, Marie Lise Delgard Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon sequestration [email protected] OCB 2019 Summer Workshop

Transcript of Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon OCB 2019 ...€¦ · 2 Buried Carbon Particulate...

Page 1: Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon OCB 2019 ...€¦ · 2 Buried Carbon Particulate Organic C Greiner et al. 2013, Greiner et al. 2016, Oreskaet al. 2017a,b t Mature meadow

Amelie Berger, Peter Berg, Karen McGlathery, Lillian Aoki,

Matthew Oreska, Marie Lise Delgard

Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon

sequestration

[email protected]

OCB 2019 Summer

Workshop

Page 2: Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon OCB 2019 ...€¦ · 2 Buried Carbon Particulate Organic C Greiner et al. 2013, Greiner et al. 2016, Oreskaet al. 2017a,b t Mature meadow

Slime moldwasting disease

VCR loss due to pandemic wasting disease and “Great

Storm” of 1933CheapeakeBay

VCR

Atlantic Ocean

OCB 2019 Summer

Workshop

Page 3: Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon OCB 2019 ...€¦ · 2 Buried Carbon Particulate Organic C Greiner et al. 2013, Greiner et al. 2016, Oreskaet al. 2017a,b t Mature meadow

Landscape-scale restorationseeds

Orth Lab, VIMS; The Nature Conservancy

500 acres seeded70 million seeds6200 acres meadow

= 25 km2

OCB 2019 Summer

Workshop

Page 4: Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon OCB 2019 ...€¦ · 2 Buried Carbon Particulate Organic C Greiner et al. 2013, Greiner et al. 2016, Oreskaet al. 2017a,b t Mature meadow

South BaySouth Bay0.5 – 1 acre plots100k seeds acre-1

http://web.vims.edu/bio/sav/

Landscape-scale restoration

OCB 2019 Summer

Workshop

Page 5: Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon OCB 2019 ...€¦ · 2 Buried Carbon Particulate Organic C Greiner et al. 2013, Greiner et al. 2016, Oreskaet al. 2017a,b t Mature meadow

Long-term seagrass study

2014

2015

2017

2016

High temperatures in June 2015 caused large-scale die-off

Meadow development

Mature meadow

Die-off Parti

al re

cove

ry

OCB 2019 Summer

Workshop

Page 6: Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon OCB 2019 ...€¦ · 2 Buried Carbon Particulate Organic C Greiner et al. 2013, Greiner et al. 2016, Oreskaet al. 2017a,b t Mature meadow

VCR

Atlantic Ocean

Photo: AWI Sea Ice Physics group

Aquatic eddy covariance technique

OCB 2019 Summer

Workshop

Page 7: Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon OCB 2019 ...€¦ · 2 Buried Carbon Particulate Organic C Greiner et al. 2013, Greiner et al. 2016, Oreskaet al. 2017a,b t Mature meadow

Aquatic eddy covariance technique

Berger et al. (in review)

OCB 2019 Summer

Workshop

Page 8: Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon OCB 2019 ...€¦ · 2 Buried Carbon Particulate Organic C Greiner et al. 2013, Greiner et al. 2016, Oreskaet al. 2017a,b t Mature meadow

Aquatic eddy covariance technique

24 hours

Berger et al. (in review)

• R = !"# ∑ flux%&'( + ∑flux*+,-

h*+,- h./012

• GPP = !"# ∑ flux./012 +

∑flux*+,-h*+,- h./012

Hume et al. (2011) L&O

• R = !"# ∑ flux%&'( + ∑flux*+,-

h*+,-h./012

• GPP = !"# ∑ flux./012 +

∑flux*+,-h*+,- h./012

OCB 2019 Summer

Workshop

Page 9: Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon OCB 2019 ...€¦ · 2 Buried Carbon Particulate Organic C Greiner et al. 2013, Greiner et al. 2016, Oreskaet al. 2017a,b t Mature meadow

2015

2014

Highly dynamic, but overall balanced seagrass metabolism

Berger et al. (in review)

heterotrophic

autotrophic

OCB 2019 Summer

Workshop

Page 10: Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon OCB 2019 ...€¦ · 2 Buried Carbon Particulate Organic C Greiner et al. 2013, Greiner et al. 2016, Oreskaet al. 2017a,b t Mature meadow

Long-term record of seagrass metabolism

2015

2014

Berger et al. (in review)Hume et al. 2011 Rheuban et al. 2014

OCB 2019 Summer

Workshop

Page 11: Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon OCB 2019 ...€¦ · 2 Buried Carbon Particulate Organic C Greiner et al. 2013, Greiner et al. 2016, Oreskaet al. 2017a,b t Mature meadow

2015

2014 NEM = 1.0 mmol O2 m-2 d-1

Highly dynamic, but overall balanced seagrass metabolism

Berger et al. (in review)

OCB 2019 Summer

Workshop

Page 12: Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon OCB 2019 ...€¦ · 2 Buried Carbon Particulate Organic C Greiner et al. 2013, Greiner et al. 2016, Oreskaet al. 2017a,b t Mature meadow

Annual carbon budget

Berger et al. (in review)

OCB 2019 Summer

Workshop

Page 13: Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon OCB 2019 ...€¦ · 2 Buried Carbon Particulate Organic C Greiner et al. 2013, Greiner et al. 2016, Oreskaet al. 2017a,b t Mature meadow

Restoration reinstates C storage in sediments

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14

Density

(sho

otsm

-2)

MeadowAge(yr)

• Within 12 years, C burial within range of natural systems

• ~half seagrass C; half algal C produced in situ

CO2

Buried Carbon

ParticulateOrganic C

Greiner et al. 2013, Greiner et al. 2016, Oreska et al. 2017a,b

Meadow development

Mature meadow

050100150200250300350400450500

0 9-14 15 16 17

BulkC(gm

-2)

Meadowage(y)

050

100150200250300350400450500

0 9-14 15 16 17

BulkC(gm

-2)

Meadowage(y)

Page 14: Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon OCB 2019 ...€¦ · 2 Buried Carbon Particulate Organic C Greiner et al. 2013, Greiner et al. 2016, Oreskaet al. 2017a,b t Mature meadow

Restoration reinstates C sequestration in plant biomass

Berger et al. (in review)

OCB 2019 Summer

Workshop

Page 15: Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon OCB 2019 ...€¦ · 2 Buried Carbon Particulate Organic C Greiner et al. 2013, Greiner et al. 2016, Oreskaet al. 2017a,b t Mature meadow

Disturbance caused a shift in trophic status

Berger et al. (in review)

Trophic status: balanced

2014

OCB 2019 Summer

Workshop

Page 16: Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon OCB 2019 ...€¦ · 2 Buried Carbon Particulate Organic C Greiner et al. 2013, Greiner et al. 2016, Oreskaet al. 2017a,b t Mature meadow

Disturbance caused a shift in trophic status

Berger et al. (in review)

2014

2015

Trophic status: heterotrophic

OCB 2019 Summer

Workshop

Page 17: Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon OCB 2019 ...€¦ · 2 Buried Carbon Particulate Organic C Greiner et al. 2013, Greiner et al. 2016, Oreskaet al. 2017a,b t Mature meadow

Disturbance caused a shift in trophic status

Berger et al. (in review)2017

2016

2014

2015

Trophic status: autotrophic

OCB 2019 Summer

Workshop

Page 18: Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon OCB 2019 ...€¦ · 2 Buried Carbon Particulate Organic C Greiner et al. 2013, Greiner et al. 2016, Oreskaet al. 2017a,b t Mature meadow

050

100150200250300350400450500

0 9-14 15 16 17

Carbon

storage(gm

-2)

Meadowage(y)

Seagrass loss affects C storage

Nice to meet you. I’m a Zostera.Nice to meet you. I’m a Zostera.Nice to meet you. I’m a Zostera.Nice to meet you. I’m a Zostera.

Restor

ation Loss

Nice to meet you. I’m a Zostera.

Nice to meet you. I’m a Zostera.Nice to meet you. I’m a Zostera.

Nice to meet you. I’m a Zostera.Nice to meet you. I’m a Zostera.Nice to meet you. I’m a Zostera.

Recovery

OCB 2019 Summer

Workshop

Page 19: Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon OCB 2019 ...€¦ · 2 Buried Carbon Particulate Organic C Greiner et al. 2013, Greiner et al. 2016, Oreskaet al. 2017a,b t Mature meadow

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

NearInlet Mid-meadow

Carbon

storage(gm

-2)

2013

2017

2018

2017

Landscape-scale variation affects C loss

No carbon loss near inlet

Near Inlet

Mid-meadow

Page 20: Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon OCB 2019 ...€¦ · 2 Buried Carbon Particulate Organic C Greiner et al. 2013, Greiner et al. 2016, Oreskaet al. 2017a,b t Mature meadow

Link to exposure to temperature stress

High flushing,Short

residence time

Higher resilience

+

Berger et al. (in prep)

OCB 2019 Summer

Workshop

Page 21: Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon OCB 2019 ...€¦ · 2 Buried Carbon Particulate Organic C Greiner et al. 2013, Greiner et al. 2016, Oreskaet al. 2017a,b t Mature meadow

bathymetry

Limitation by low CO2 or high O2?

Berg et al. (2019) L&O

OCB 2019 Summer

Workshop

Page 22: Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon OCB 2019 ...€¦ · 2 Buried Carbon Particulate Organic C Greiner et al. 2013, Greiner et al. 2016, Oreskaet al. 2017a,b t Mature meadow

bathymetry

No limitation by low CO2 or high O2

Berg et al. (2019) L&O

OCB 2019 Summer

Workshop

Page 23: Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon OCB 2019 ...€¦ · 2 Buried Carbon Particulate Organic C Greiner et al. 2013, Greiner et al. 2016, Oreskaet al. 2017a,b t Mature meadow

• Restoration reinstates C storage and sequestration

• Sediment C stocks are vulnerable to shoot losses fromtemperature stress

• Seagrass loss and recovery causes shifts in trophicstatus, but the meadow is metabolically balanced overallà most C retention = in sediment

• Meadows are resilient at the landscape scale

• No stimulation of photosynthesis at high CO2concentrations

Conclusions

OCB 2019 Summer

Workshop

Page 24: Temperate seagrass bed metabolism and carbon OCB 2019 ...€¦ · 2 Buried Carbon Particulate Organic C Greiner et al. 2013, Greiner et al. 2016, Oreskaet al. 2017a,b t Mature meadow

Dieback and C loss is patchy at plot scale

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

Seagrass Bare

C (g

/m2)

OCB 2019 Summer

Workshop