Technology Assessment Report Side-by-side comparison of the next software: AutoCAD MicroStation...

22
Technology Assessment Report Side-by-side comparison of the next software: AutoCAD MicroStation GeoMedia Presented by: Ovidiu Sipos

Transcript of Technology Assessment Report Side-by-side comparison of the next software: AutoCAD MicroStation...

Page 1: Technology Assessment Report Side-by-side comparison of the next software: AutoCAD MicroStation GeoMedia Presented by: Ovidiu Sipos.

Technology Assessment Report

Side-by-side comparison of the next software:

AutoCAD

MicroStation

GeoMedia

Presented by: Ovidiu Sipos

Page 2: Technology Assessment Report Side-by-side comparison of the next software: AutoCAD MicroStation GeoMedia Presented by: Ovidiu Sipos.

Specific Software Assessed

AutoDesk Bentley Intergraph

AutoDesk Mapguide

AutoCAD Map 2000i

AutoDesk Powerline

Vision Enterprise

Vision Objects

Vision Framework Continuum

MicroStation Geographic

MicroStation GeoOutlook

ModelSever Discovery

GeoMedia

GeoMedia Professional

GeoMedia Web Map

Page 3: Technology Assessment Report Side-by-side comparison of the next software: AutoCAD MicroStation GeoMedia Presented by: Ovidiu Sipos.

Assessment Method

1. Tools for entering and manipulating geographic information

2. Expandability3. Tools that create intelligent digital maps you can analyze,

query or print4. A database management system5. Market share6. Hardware requirement7. Learning curve8. Cost

Page 4: Technology Assessment Report Side-by-side comparison of the next software: AutoCAD MicroStation GeoMedia Presented by: Ovidiu Sipos.

Board Digitizing Precision Entry Data entry Heads-up Digitizing Vectorization Map Rectification Graphic error Field d.e

AUTODESK

AutoDesk Mapguide x v v v x x x v

AutoCAD map 2000i v v Through DXF

v v v

AutoDesk Powerline x v v v x x x v

Vision enterprise

Vision objects v v v v v

Vision framework

BENTLEY

MicroStation geographics v v v x

MicroStation Geooutlook v x x x x x x v

ModelServer discovery

Modelserver continum

INTERGRAPH

GeoMedia x x Via 3rd party v x x x v

GeoMedia Professional v v v v v v

GeoMedia Web Map v v

ESRI

ArcInfo 8.0.2 v v v v v v v v

ArcView GIS 3.2a v v v v v v v v

MapObjects 2.0a Can be done Can be done Can be done v x x x v

ArcIM s 3 x x x v x x x v

1.Entering and Manipulation of Geographic Data

Page 5: Technology Assessment Report Side-by-side comparison of the next software: AutoCAD MicroStation GeoMedia Presented by: Ovidiu Sipos.

Operating System/Network Support Compatible Applications Applications Dev. Language

Network

Client-Server Support

Server Operating System

Client Operating

System

Internet

Server

Enabled

Third Party

Applications

Compatibility

Total

Solution

Packages

Proprietary

Application Dev.

Language

Industry

Standard programming

Environment

AUTODESK

AutoDesk Mapguide

v W in NT W in

995/98/NT

v x x v

AutoCAD map 2000i

v x W in

95/98/NT

v v v VBA, C++

AutoDesk Powerline

v W in NT W in

95/98/NT

v x v

Vision enterprise SQL SQL

Vision objects ActiveX

Vision framework

ActiveX

2.Expandability

Page 6: Technology Assessment Report Side-by-side comparison of the next software: AutoCAD MicroStation GeoMedia Presented by: Ovidiu Sipos.

Operating System/Network Support Compatible Applications Applications Dev. Language

Network

Client-Server

Support

Server Operating System

Client Operating

System

Internet

Server

Enabled

Third Party

Applications

Compatibility

Total

Solution

Packages

Proprietary

Application Dev.

Language

Industry

Standard programming

Environment

BENTLEY

MicroStation Geographic

v MicroStation

Basic

C++, Java, VBA

MicroStation GeoOutlook

MicroStation

Basic

C++, Java, VBA

ModelServer Discovery

v v MicroStation

Basic

C++, Java, VBA

Model Server Continuum

v v MicroStation

Basic

C++, Java, VBA

INTERGRAPH

GeoMedia v v v VBA, Power Builder,VC++

GeoMedia Professional

v v v

GeoMedia Web Map

v v v

Expandability(cont.)

Page 7: Technology Assessment Report Side-by-side comparison of the next software: AutoCAD MicroStation GeoMedia Presented by: Ovidiu Sipos.

Operating System/Network Support Compatible Applications Applications Dev. Language

Network

Client-Server

Support

Server Operating System

Client Operating

System

Internet

Server

Enabled

Third Party

Applications

Compatibility

Total

Solution

Packages

Proprietary

Application Dev.

Language

Industry

Standard programming

Environment

ESRI

ArcInfo 8.0.2 v v AML VBA, Visual C++,

Delphi,ActiveX

ArcView GIS 3.2a

v Avenue VBA,Visual C++,Delphi

MapObjects 2.0a

v x 32-bit ActiveX Ebv.

ArcIM S .3 v v x VBA & Java script

Expandability(cont.)

Page 8: Technology Assessment Report Side-by-side comparison of the next software: AutoCAD MicroStation GeoMedia Presented by: Ovidiu Sipos.

3.Ability to Create Intelligent Maps That Can Be Analyzed and Queried

Map design and composition Geographic query and analysis Terrain data processing and analysis Raster image capabilities

Page 9: Technology Assessment Report Side-by-side comparison of the next software: AutoCAD MicroStation GeoMedia Presented by: Ovidiu Sipos.

Map design & Composition

Interactive Map

Composition

Annotation From

Attributes

Global Symbol Change

Thematic

Mapping

AutoDesk

AutoDesk Mapguide v v v v

AutoCAD Map 2000i v v v v

AutoDesk Powerline v v v v

Vision Enterprise SQL Dynamic

Vision Objects

Vision Framework v v v

Bentley

MicroStation Geographic

v v v v

MicroStation Geooutlook

v v v v

ModelServer Discovery

ModelServer Continuum

Map design & Composition

Interactive Map

Composition

Annotation From

Attributes

Global Symbol Change

Thematic

Mapping

Intergraph

GeoMedia v v v v

GeoMedia Professionl v v v v

GeoMedia Web Map v v

ESRI

ArcInfo 8.0.2 v v v v

ArcView GIS 3.2a v v v v

MapObjects 2.0a v v v v

ArcIM S 3 v v v v

3.1 Map Design and Composition

Page 10: Technology Assessment Report Side-by-side comparison of the next software: AutoCAD MicroStation GeoMedia Presented by: Ovidiu Sipos.

Geographic Query & Analysis

Attribute

Query &

Selection

Map

Meas.

Address

Matching

Buffer

Generation

Point/line

In Polygon

Analysis

Polygon

overlay

Network

analysis

Raster

Document

Query&

access

Direct

Access to

Other GIS formats

AutoDesk

AutoDesk Mapguide v v v v v x x x Oracle 8i

AutoCAD Map 2000i v v x v v v v x x

AutoDesk Powerline v v v v v x v x Oracle 8i

Vision Enterprise SQL v v v v v v

Vision Objects SQL v v v v v v

Vision Framework SQL v v v v v v

Bentley

MicroStation Geographic v v GeoAddress v v v v v v

MicroStation Geooutlook v v x v v v x v x

ModelServer Discovery v

ModelServer Continuum v

3.2 Geographic Query & Analysis

Page 11: Technology Assessment Report Side-by-side comparison of the next software: AutoCAD MicroStation GeoMedia Presented by: Ovidiu Sipos.

Geographic Query & Analysis

Attribute

Query &

Selection

Map

Meas.

Address

Matching

Buffer

Generation

Point/line

In Polygon

Analysis

Polygon

overlay

Network

analysis

Raster

Document

Query&

access

Direct

Access to

Other GIS formats

Intergraph

GeoMedia v v v v v v x v v

GeoMedia Professionl v v v v v v x v v

GeoMedia Web Map v v v v v v v v v

ESRI

ArcInfo 8.0.2 v v v v v v v v v

ArcView GIS 3.2a v v v v v v v v v

MapObjects 2.0a v v v v v v x v v

ArcIM S 3 v v v x v x v v x

3.2 Geographic Query & Analysis

Page 12: Technology Assessment Report Side-by-side comparison of the next software: AutoCAD MicroStation GeoMedia Presented by: Ovidiu Sipos.

3.4 Terrain Data Processing & Analysis

Terrain Data Processing & Analysis

DEM

Generat.

Contour

Map

Generation

3-D

Display/profile

Generation

Map

drapping

Slope/Aspect

Analysis

AutoDesk

AutoDesk Mapguide

x x x x x

AutoCAD Map 2000i

v v v x x

AutoDesk Powerline

x x x x x

Vision Enterprise

v

Vision Objects

Vision Framework

Bentley

MicroStation Geographic

Geo terrain

Geo terrain Geo terrain Geo terrain

Geo terrain

MicroStation Geooutlook

x x x x x

ModelServer Discovery

ModelServer Continuum

v

Terrain Data Processing & Analysis

DEM

Generat.

Contour

Map

Generation

3-D

Display/profile

Generation

Map

drapping

Slope/Aspect

Analysis

Intergraph

GeoMedia Via3 rd party

Via3 rd party

x x Via3 rd party

GeoMedia Professionl

Via3 rd party

Via3 rd party

x x Via3 rd party

GeoMedia Web Map

x x x x

ESRI

ArcInfo 8.0.2 v v v v v

ArcView GIS 3.2a

v v v v v

MapObjects 2.0a

x x x x x

ArcIM S 3 x x x x x

Page 13: Technology Assessment Report Side-by-side comparison of the next software: AutoCAD MicroStation GeoMedia Presented by: Ovidiu Sipos.

3.5 Raster Image Capabilities

Raster Image Capabilities

Geometric Rectification

Ortho Image

generation

Image

Enhancement

Spectro

Clasification

AutoDesk

AutoDesk Mapguide

x x x x

AutoCAD Map 2000i

v v v x

AutoDesk Powerline

x x x x

Vision Enterprise

v

Vision Objects

Vision Framework

Bentley

MicroStation Geographic

Decartes Decartes Decartes Decartes

MicroStation Geooutlook

x x x x

ModelServer Discovery

ModelServer Continuum

Raster Image Capabilities

Geometric Rectification

Ortho Image

generation

Image

Enhancement

Spectro

Clasification

Intergraph

GeoMedia x x x x

GeoMedia Professionl

v x x x

GeoMedia Web Map

x x x x

ESRI

ArcInfo 8.0.2 v x v v

ArcView GIS 3.2a

v v v v

MapObjects 2.0a

x x x x

ArcIM S 3 x x x x

Page 14: Technology Assessment Report Side-by-side comparison of the next software: AutoCAD MicroStation GeoMedia Presented by: Ovidiu Sipos.

4.Database Management System

Database administration Database management Native graphic data structure and format Import/export utilities

Page 15: Technology Assessment Report Side-by-side comparison of the next software: AutoCAD MicroStation GeoMedia Presented by: Ovidiu Sipos.

Database Administration Database Management

Multi-user Edit Locking Versioning Metadata Administration Proprietary DBMS RDBMS RDBMS Spatial Data Warehouse

AutoDesk

AutoDesk Mapguide x x x v v v

AutoCAD Map 2000i x x x x v v

AutoDesk Powerline x x v v v v

Vision Enterprise Directly on Oracle Dir. On Or.envi Rational Rose,Oracle x Oracle8.8i Oracle 8i

Vision Objects

Vision Framework

Bentley

MicroStation Geographic v v v VSQL v v

MicroStation Geooutlook v v v VSQL v v

ModelServer Discovery v v v v v

ModelServer Continuum v v v Oracle v

Intergraph

GeoMedia x x Via 3 rd party x v v

GeoMedia Professionl x x Via 3 rd party x v v

GeoMedia Web Map x v v

ESRI

ArcInfo 8.0.2 v v v x v v

ArcView GIS 3.2a v v x x v v

MapObjects 2.0a v ESRI SDE x x v Via ESRI SDE software

ArcIM S 3 v v x x v Via ESRI SDE software

Database Management System

Page 16: Technology Assessment Report Side-by-side comparison of the next software: AutoCAD MicroStation GeoMedia Presented by: Ovidiu Sipos.

Native Graphic Data Structure and Format

Vector Spaghetti Vector-Topologic Parametric 3-D TIN Grid

AutoDesk

AutoDesk Mapguide v v x x x x

AutoCAD Map 2000i v v v v v x

AutoDesk Powerline v v x x x x

Vision Enterprise Stored in Oracle not Blobs Stored in Oracle not Blobs Stored in Oracle not Blobs Stored in Oracle not Blobs x Seamless db

Vision Objects

Vision Framework v

Bentley

MicroStation Geographic x v v GeoTerrain

MicroStation Geooutlook x v v x

ModelServer Discovery x

ModelServer Continuum x

Intergraph

GeoMedia x v v x x Via 3 rd party

GeoMedia Professionl x v v x x Via 3 rd party

GeoMedia Web Map x v v x x

ESRI

ArcInfo 8.0.2 v v v v v v

ArcView GIS 3.2a v v v v v v

MapObjects 2.0a v v v v x x

ArcIM S 3 v v x x x x

Database Management System(cont.)

Page 17: Technology Assessment Report Side-by-side comparison of the next software: AutoCAD MicroStation GeoMedia Presented by: Ovidiu Sipos.

Import/Export Utilities

Raster Image Direct Import Formats Direct Export Formats

AutoDesk

AutoDesk Mapguide v v SDF

AutoCAD Map 2000i v v v

AutoDesk Powerline v v SDF

Vision Enterprise JPEG, 8-Bit

Vision Objects TIFF, JPEG, 8

Vision Framework JPEG, 8-Bit

Bentley

MicroStation Geographic v v v

MicroStation Geooutlook v v v

ModelServer Discovery v

ModelServer Continuum

Intergraph

GeoMedia v v x

GeoMedia Professionl v v v

GeoMedia Web Map v v v

ESRI

ArcInfo 8.0.2 v v v

ArcView GIS 3.2a v v v

MapObjects 2.0a v

ArcIM S 3 v

Database Management System(cont.)

Page 18: Technology Assessment Report Side-by-side comparison of the next software: AutoCAD MicroStation GeoMedia Presented by: Ovidiu Sipos.

5.Market Share

Will it be around in the future?

Experienced workers available

3-rd party services:add-ons,training,consultants

Page 19: Technology Assessment Report Side-by-side comparison of the next software: AutoCAD MicroStation GeoMedia Presented by: Ovidiu Sipos.

Market Share

Market Share

35.10%28.30%

4.70%ESRI

Intergraph

AutoDesk

Page 20: Technology Assessment Report Side-by-side comparison of the next software: AutoCAD MicroStation GeoMedia Presented by: Ovidiu Sipos.

6.Hardware Requirement

Workstation Plotters Digitizers Printers Scanners Alphanumerical terminals

Page 21: Technology Assessment Report Side-by-side comparison of the next software: AutoCAD MicroStation GeoMedia Presented by: Ovidiu Sipos.

7.Learning Curves

Simplicity of use for limited functions products Consistency of interface for multi-functions

products

Page 22: Technology Assessment Report Side-by-side comparison of the next software: AutoCAD MicroStation GeoMedia Presented by: Ovidiu Sipos.

8.Cost

Company Software Price

AUTODESK AutoDesk Mapguide $9,900

AutoCAD Map 2000i $4,250

Vision Objects $2,000

Vision Framework $2,500

BENTLEY MicroStation Geographic Contact vendor

MicroStation GeoOutlook “

ModelServer Discovery “

ModelServer Continuum “

INTERGRAPH GeoMedia $1,500

GeoMedia Professional $7,500

GeoMedia Web Map $10,000

ESRI ArcInfo $10,000

ArcView $1,195