Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways• Flash butt welding • Manual metal arc (MMA)...

24
Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways Stephen Lewis Consultant, Rail Technologies – British Steel

Transcript of Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways• Flash butt welding • Manual metal arc (MMA)...

Page 1: Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways• Flash butt welding • Manual metal arc (MMA) welding • Weld approvals and failures 1 Light rail / Tramway • Corrugation •

Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways Stephen Lewis Consultant, Rail Technologies – British Steel

Page 2: Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways• Flash butt welding • Manual metal arc (MMA) welding • Weld approvals and failures 1 Light rail / Tramway • Corrugation •

Technical expertise for building stronger railways

Dr. Stephen Lewis

Page 3: Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways• Flash butt welding • Manual metal arc (MMA) welding • Weld approvals and failures 1 Light rail / Tramway • Corrugation •

Contents

Technical expertise for building stronger railways 3

Introduction to Rail Technologies

Rail welding •  Gauge corner restoration (GCR) •  Flash butt welding •  Manual metal arc (MMA) welding •  Weld approvals and failures

1

Light rail / Tramway •  Corrugation •  Intelligent maintenance

2

3

4 Questions

Page 4: Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways• Flash butt welding • Manual metal arc (MMA) welding • Weld approvals and failures 1 Light rail / Tramway • Corrugation •

Introduction to Rail Technologies

Technical expertise for building stronger railways 4

Lindsey Smith

Consultant Wheel Rail Interface Specialist

Sean Gleeson

Consultant Welding Specialist

Rob Lambert

Rail Technologies Manager

Brindusa Mironov

Consultant

Sandra Fretwell-Smith

Consultant

Arvid Cedervall

Consultant

Stephen Lewis

Consultant Wheel Rail Tribologist

Page 5: Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways• Flash butt welding • Manual metal arc (MMA) welding • Weld approvals and failures 1 Light rail / Tramway • Corrugation •

Team expertise in: •  Materials testing •  Materials technology •  Welding technology •  Track monitoring / surveying •  Asset management

What we do

Technical expertise for building stronger railways 5

Page 6: Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways• Flash butt welding • Manual metal arc (MMA) welding • Weld approvals and failures 1 Light rail / Tramway • Corrugation •

Rail Welding

Technical expertise for building stronger railways 6

Page 7: Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways• Flash butt welding • Manual metal arc (MMA) welding • Weld approvals and failures 1 Light rail / Tramway • Corrugation •

Martensite – 101

Technical expertise for building stronger railways 7

Heat affected zone (HAZ)

Weld deposit

Pearlitic parent rail

Pearlite

Martensite

Page 8: Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways• Flash butt welding • Manual metal arc (MMA) welding • Weld approvals and failures 1 Light rail / Tramway • Corrugation •

Gauge corner restoration (GCR)

Technical expertise for building stronger railways 8

Traditional GCR solutions •  Can result in untempered martensite •  Deliver poor weld integrity (spalling)

Page 9: Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways• Flash butt welding • Manual metal arc (MMA) welding • Weld approvals and failures 1 Light rail / Tramway • Corrugation •

•  British Steel patented an improved process of robustly weld-repairing worn grooved rail

•  Eliminates high temperature pre-heat which would damage the polymer surrounding embedded rail

•  Suitable for in-track repair of embedded track to extend rail life

Gauge corner restoration

Technical expertise for building stronger railways 9

Page 10: Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways• Flash butt welding • Manual metal arc (MMA) welding • Weld approvals and failures 1 Light rail / Tramway • Corrugation •

Gauge corner restoration

Technical expertise for building stronger railways 10

Page 11: Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways• Flash butt welding • Manual metal arc (MMA) welding • Weld approvals and failures 1 Light rail / Tramway • Corrugation •

Gauge corner restoration

Technical expertise for building stronger railways 11

Page 12: Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways• Flash butt welding • Manual metal arc (MMA) welding • Weld approvals and failures 1 Light rail / Tramway • Corrugation •

The flash butt welding process is sub-divided into: •  Initial flashing •  Pre-heating •  Final flashing •  Upsetting / Forging •  Post weld heat treatment (optional)

Many different varieties of welding machine •  AC / DC •  Fixed / mobile / semi-fixed •  Continuous flashing / pulsed flashing

Flash butt welding

Technical expertise for building stronger railways

‘Heating two rail ends electrically and forging them together to form a welded

joint’

12

Page 13: Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways• Flash butt welding • Manual metal arc (MMA) welding • Weld approvals and failures 1 Light rail / Tramway • Corrugation •

•  They may be manufactured by the same company, built by the same engineering team, be the same make and model, made on the same production line but ……

Flash butt welding

Technical expertise for building stronger railways 13

No two flash butt welders are completely identical

Page 14: Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways• Flash butt welding • Manual metal arc (MMA) welding • Weld approvals and failures 1 Light rail / Tramway • Corrugation •

What weld properties do we have to achieve?

Technical expertise for building stronger railways 14

On-site macros HAZ and Hardness values

Page 15: Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways• Flash butt welding • Manual metal arc (MMA) welding • Weld approvals and failures 1 Light rail / Tramway • Corrugation •

Approval Procedure: 1.  Weld process parameters 2.  External inspection of welded joint 3.  Slow bend tests 4.  Macro examination of longitudinal -

vertical sections 5.  Hardness measurements 6.  Fatigue testing

Weld approvals

Technical expertise for building stronger railways 15

Page 16: Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways• Flash butt welding • Manual metal arc (MMA) welding • Weld approvals and failures 1 Light rail / Tramway • Corrugation •

Repair of a damaged section of rail head by: Excavating damaged area à weld filling the excavation à grinding back to profile •  A multi-layer weld completed as per BS EN 15594:2009 •  Excavation is filled with a minimum of 5 layers. •  Inspection and testing

Manual Metal Arc (MMA)

Technical expertise for building stronger railways 16

Page 17: Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways• Flash butt welding • Manual metal arc (MMA) welding • Weld approvals and failures 1 Light rail / Tramway • Corrugation •

•  No cracks •  No untempered martensite and •  Compatible hardness to parent

What are we looking for?

Technical expertise for building stronger railways 17

Microstructure at HAZ through transverse section

Page 18: Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways• Flash butt welding • Manual metal arc (MMA) welding • Weld approvals and failures 1 Light rail / Tramway • Corrugation •

Weld failure investigations

Technical expertise for building stronger railways

Lots of reasons welds can fail: •  Weld process failure •  Weld defects •  Rail defects •  Track conditions •  Residual stresses

18

Page 19: Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways• Flash butt welding • Manual metal arc (MMA) welding • Weld approvals and failures 1 Light rail / Tramway • Corrugation •

Weld failure investigation example

Technical expertise for building stronger railways 19

Broken rail found Sample received Hardness testing

Fracture face Section area of interest Microscope analysis

Page 20: Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways• Flash butt welding • Manual metal arc (MMA) welding • Weld approvals and failures 1 Light rail / Tramway • Corrugation •

Light Rail

Technical expertise for building stronger railways 20

Page 21: Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways• Flash butt welding • Manual metal arc (MMA) welding • Weld approvals and failures 1 Light rail / Tramway • Corrugation •

Light rail – Corrugation and wear surveying

Technical expertise for building stronger railways 21

•  Tramways often suffer from rail corrugation •  Usually mitigated by rail grinding •  Some networks use subjective assessment •  Some use a more scientific approach

•  Rail Technologies used specialist equipment to survey network •  Assess extent of corrugation •  Analyse and visualise data •  Define grinding priorities

•  Implemented a planned corrugation maintenance program •  Manage maintenance more cost effectively •  Targeting grinding in the short, medium and long term.

Page 22: Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways• Flash butt welding • Manual metal arc (MMA) welding • Weld approvals and failures 1 Light rail / Tramway • Corrugation •

Shifting railways/tramways from a ‘find and fix’ philosophy towards one of ‘predict and prevent’ Corrugation Maps:

•  Mapping part or whole networks •  Maintenance and renewal strategies developed for the highest priority sections

Intelligent maintenance

Technical expertise for building stronger railways 22

Not drawn to scale

98

72

55 36

9 3 1193

5

3

Station B

10

23 12 6

70 6

159

11 50

26 91

11 24 36 86

4

42

8

162

Station C Station D Station E Station A Station F

440

11 4 4 5 5 340

4

Station 4 Station 2 Station 3 Station 1

505

5 15 4 5 8 507

41

640

7 450

45 595

120

56 109

598

34 13 8 9 26 15

10

10

10

Light

Corrugation Measurements

Moderate

Severe

Figures are distance in metres

Page 23: Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways• Flash butt welding • Manual metal arc (MMA) welding • Weld approvals and failures 1 Light rail / Tramway • Corrugation •

Any questions?

Technical expertise for building stronger railways 23

Page 24: Technical Expertise for Building Stronger Railways• Flash butt welding • Manual metal arc (MMA) welding • Weld approvals and failures 1 Light rail / Tramway • Corrugation •