Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

download Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

of 28

Transcript of Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    1/28

    !!!!Switzerland:

    A Neutral Country

    Date: To Be Determined Grade: 10-12

    Teacher Name: Subject: Economics

    1. Topic-

    The economic makeup of Switzerland and its history and reasoning for neutrality

    2. Content-

    A discussion of Switzerlands current economic condition and the political implications and influences of

    its famously neutral standing in international relations.

    3. Goals: Aims/Outcomes-

    1. Apply economic concepts to a real-world example

    2. Understand the political-economic connection of decision making at the national level

    3. Students will begin to understand the effects of Switzerlands neutral status.

    4. Objectives-

    1.Introduce Switzerlands economic condition and current political administration. Work through modulepresentation.

    2.Read and conduct discussion of Swiss Neutrality Found in Appendix or athttp://www.eda.admin.ch/etc/medialib/downloads/edazen/doc/publi.Par.0016.File.tmp/Swiss%20neutral

    ity.pdf

    3.Research and defend/contest the case for neutrality5. Materials and Aids-

    Computer, projector, pens/pencils, paper, chalkboard/white board, board writing utensil

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    2/28

    6. Procedures/Methods-

    A. Introduction-

    !The day before the less, begin by asking what they think of when they hear Switzerland. Spend 3-5minutes collecting their responses. If youd like, show them something like the YouTube video Magic

    Switzerland, which contains many of the typical, beautiful Swiss images. (Found at

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YTQr4M_OdNc ). Then ask what the students know about

    Switzerland politically. Most likely, neutrality will be one of their responses. Ask class to read the

    Swiss Neutrality article for the next class period

    B. Development-

    1. Work through the PowerPoint, introducing Switzerland's economic situation and the political nature of

    its economic choices

    2. Focus on discussing the economic concepts taught3. Conduct discussion of the Swiss Neutrality

    4. Assign persuasive paper that defends or contradicts Switzerlands neutral position

    C. Practice-

    1.After finishing the PowerPoint, review the major elements of Switzerland's economy and what that

    means both at the national and individual levels.

    2. As a class, discuss the article Swiss Neutrality focusing on the following questions:

    a) Why would Geneva be an ideal location for international organizations?b) What political implications have there been for Switzerland itself and the countries with which it

    interacts?

    c) What alternatives does Switzerland have to neutrality?d) What historical precedents have caused Switzerland to be neutral?e) Where else in Swiss society do we see evidence of neutrality?f) The article read was written by the Swiss government. What, if any, arguments do they make for

    neutrality?

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    3/28

    7. Evaluation/Assessment

    After the discussion, explain to the students that just as the Swiss government defends it neutrality, so too

    each student must also decide whether they agree or disagree with Switzerlands philosophy of neutrality

    and defend it. Answer theTheir arguments will be presented in a 2-3 page paper that clearly outlines theirarguments and disputes counter-arguments. Attached by a possible grading rubric.

    8. Appendix-

    Attached please find Persuasive Writing Scoring Guide.

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    4/28

    Persu

    asiveWritingSc

    oringGuide

    COMPONENT

    6

    5

    4

    3

    2

    1

    Focus

    Takesaclear

    positionand

    supportsit

    consistentlywith

    well-chosen

    reasonsand/or

    examples;mayuse

    persuasivestrategy

    toconveyan

    argument.

    Takesaclear

    positionand

    supportsitw

    ith

    relevantreas

    ons

    and/orexam

    ples

    throughmuc

    hof

    theessay.

    Takesaclear

    positionand

    supportsitwith

    somerelevant

    reasonsand/or

    examples;thereis

    somedevelopment

    oftheessay.

    Takesaposition

    and

    provides

    unevensupport;

    may

    lack

    developmentin

    partsorbe

    repe

    titiveORessay

    isnomorethana

    well-written

    beginning.

    Takesaposition,

    butessayis

    underdeveloped.

    Attemptstotakea

    position(addresses

    topic),butposition

    isveryunclearOR

    takesaposition,

    butprovides

    minimalorno

    support;mayonly

    paraphrasethe

    prompt.

    Organization

    Isfocusedandwell

    organized,with

    effectiveuseof

    transitions.

    Iswellorgan

    ized,

    butmaylack

    some

    transitions.

    Isgenerally

    organized,buthas

    few

    orno

    transitionsamong

    sections.

    Iso

    rganizedin

    partsoftheessay;

    othe

    rpartsare

    disjointedand/or

    lack

    transitions.

    Isdisorganizedor

    unfocusedinmuc

    h

    oftheessayORis

    clear,buttoobrief.

    Exhibitslittleorno

    apparent

    organization.

    Sentence

    Fluencyand

    WordChoice

    Consistently

    exhibitsvarietyin

    sentencestructure

    andwordchoice.

    Exhibitssome

    varietyinsentence

    structureand

    uses

    goodwordchoice;

    occasionally,

    words

    maybeused

    inaccurately.

    Mostsentencesare

    wellconstructed

    buthavesimilar

    structure;word

    choicelacksvariety

    orflair.

    Sen

    tencestructure

    may

    besimpleand

    unvaried;word

    choiceismostly

    accurate.

    Sentenceslack

    formalstructure;

    wordchoicemay

    oftenbe

    inaccurate.

    Sentencesrun-on

    andappear

    incompleteor

    rambling;word

    choicemaybe

    inaccurateinmuch

    ortheentireessay.

    Conventions

    Errorsingrammar,

    spelling,and

    punctuationare

    few

    anddonot

    interferewith

    understanding.

    Errorsingrammar,

    spelling,and

    punctuationdonot

    interferewith

    understandin

    g.

    Morefrequent

    errorsingrammar,

    spelling,and

    punctuation,but

    theydonot

    interferewith

    understanding.

    Erro

    rsingrammar,

    spelling,and

    pun

    ctuation

    som

    etimes

    inte

    rferewith

    und

    erstanding.

    Errorsingramma

    r,

    spelling,and

    punctuation

    interferewith

    understandingin

    muchoftheessa

    y.

    Errorsingrammar,

    spelling,and

    punctuation

    preventreader

    fromfully

    understanding

    essay.

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    5/28

    -7-- 1/,/9

    SWISS NEUTRALITY

    {ii`i`

    LViLi`Lii`i>i>iviviVi]*iV>`-*-VVii`i>i>ivi}vv>

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    6/28

    -7-- 1/,/9

    %,%-%.43/&.%542!,)49

    The decisive factors governing our policy of neutrality are the national interest, the body

    of law on neutrality, the international situation as well as our tradition and history.

    /iV`iVv

    iiV>iL>i`

    ii]

    >`>`

    /i>vi>

    `iwii}>`

    `iv>i>>i

    i>V>vi

    }>`iivviVi

    i>`Vi`Lv

    i>L>i`

    >]iii

    viV]i

    i>>>]

    >`>`

    >`

    /ii>>>

    >>yiVi

    i>VVi

    v>V-i>`

    Vi>}i>

    iVi``}i

    -iV`7`7>]v

    i>i

    The term neutral is derived from the Latin: ne uter neither one nor the other.

    A power is neutral when it does not take sides in a war. Switzerlands neutrality is self-

    determined, permanent and armed.

    i

    s

    s

    s

    s

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    7/28

    -7-- 1/,/9

    42!$)4)/.

    -Vi\

    >iV`iL

    i->i}i>i

    i`i>iv/iV}

    ViVi>iwiLiii>

    >`i-V>-7--"9

    -i>`]>Vii>Vi]

    >}>}i>`i}]i>>>>>ii`}>>iii>ViiiLi

    Vivi>>>>i`VyV

    ivi`i>

    v>>vi>>>Vivi}

    ViVii}VyV]vi

    >i]`>ii`Li>>Lii

    i>`Vii]`}i>

    >Vi`>iiV>i`ivi`i>

    >>>V

    7ii>i>]i>Vi`

    Li>Li

    -Lv>>>

    >`\-i>vi

    i>>ii

    vi,i`,

    ii>

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    70

    80

    90

    100%

    1993 94 95 96 97 98 99 00 01 02 03 04

    -i>``i>i>

    -i>``>i>Vi>>`vi

    `iiiV>VyV>L>`L

    i>i>>VyV

    -i>``>i>Vi>>`vi

    `iii>VyV>L>`

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    8/28

    -7-- 1/,/9

    ()34/29

    Originally neutrality was a kind of emergency stop-gap. However, over the course of

    history, it brought clear advantages and is therefore firmly rooted in Switzerlands self-

    perception.

    In the Federal Agreement of 1815 and in the constitutions of 1848, 1874 and 1999,neutrality became a foreign policy norm for the authorities.

    This maxim was always flexibly adapted to the circumstances and applied according

    to the interests of the country.

    >iv>}>

    Vvi`i>i>v]iiVii`i

    >vvi`i>iV>iL>iv

    >}>>Vv>ViVV`i`>>`>

    i>ViiVii`x/i>Vivi`

    iV>V>L>v-i>`iViVi

    vi}VvVii1vi}V

    >i>Liii`v`i>

    >i>>

    -i>`>>L>iwi`

    /i>i>iw}}>V

    vii>i-i>`LiVi>

    i>iv>

    /iiVViiV>v>L`iL

    >i`iL>VLi`vi

    iiV`>ivi-i>`/i,>>`i

    i>`i-vVi`i>i-i>`

    >*>}i]*>i>`->i}/iV>

    >vvi}i>>`i`L`iv

    >>iiii/iiViviiiV,iL

    V`i>`v>Viii>v-

    i>iV>i>ivi`

    ->i>`*>

    >ivii>

    viiiVVivn]ii>

    i>v-i>`vi>vi>Vi

    VViv,>V>>}n]i-

    >`iViiii>vii>`iv>

    i>`iji>ii>

    iiViv>i>ii>

    iVVV>

    >viiVvVi>Vn

    >Vii>>>>ViiiiV

    ,iLViiLi>>Li>L>`i`

    /iv>}iv

    iiV>

    v-i>`

    iiL`i

    iViLi

    >>n

    >Vn

    x>Vn

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    9/28

    -7-- 1/,/9

    /i->}>>i

    -vVi>i>iw}>}>>i

    ]V`}ii}iv}ii>i

    vw>>i>v-vVi>L>`]

    ii*>iV}i-i>`i>

    ii>>`}>>iii>i}

    />}iL>

    -`iviL>>i>iV>ivL-

    `i

    i>V*>7>]-i>``iV>i

    }iiii>>iL>

    `ivi>i`iVi>i>]i-i

    >`Vi`Li>V>v>i`i>>`

    i->iv`}vi,i`

    ni>``ii>`i>>iV}

    vi>

    /i>}ii

    -i>`}i>}ii,}

    >`ivi>->ii>ViVviiVi

    /i>}iii>}i

    -i>``}i7`7>

    -`iiiVi`}7`7>

    vix]-i>`Vii`i`L

    >/i>}>i>iVVi`>-

    i>`i>iy>}>iiL

    >viiiVii}i

    /iiiviiiV-i>>`

    -i>`L`i/i>Viv`iviVii

    L>>ii`6i`v

    Vi`Li>>>Vi``}i

    7`7>

    V>L>`

    }\->iVvvi,>

    V7>>

    i`iVvi-iVi>

    >v}`i}ii>ii

    /``Vi-i>>i

    iVii`i`i>}iiiv>i

    }iiVVii`

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    10/28

    -7-- 1/,/9

    i}>i>

    /ii>}iv>VViv>V

    >}>>V>i-i>`>L>``vvii

    >i>v>vi}>i>]>

    >iv>v}iVV>V

    >L>`

    x]i>}iiiv>>i]-

    Lii>iiii>V>ii>

    /ivviVi>iLi}}v>Vii>

    1iii`>]-i>`>Lii

    i`>>ivi>Viii}>L>`

    -i>`>vi{x

    i>>``>\i`i>V>*iiiViivv-vi}

    i>i>i`iiiLii>L

    i}i>iiV}vi>

    />iV}i``>Vi}>}ii>`

    Vi]-i>`>ViiiV

    iV}vi}v>ii>i

    i>Vvi-x]i-Li

    Vii"-V>V>ii>Viii}

    i>iq>-i>`

    -q>V

    -i>`i`ii>}iv>>`ii>

    LiV>iii>vii>}i-i>

    iV}i`-i>`}iV

    V>Vi`Lii>}i

    vvii>i>

    `>Vii`i>Vi>>>VVi

    LiV`ii`]v-i>`>Li

    i>i}i>ii>

    /ii`i>iVii-i>`VVii

    1]>`>iiiv->VVi

    i1]ii`i>V}i>i>i

    iiVVw}>-i>`i>

    i>i>`>i`i>

    n]>>vxvi-iii`

    >}>}i1

    ,ivii`-i>`>VVii1

    i}}vi-iV`7`7>

    iLi}}vi-iV`7`7>]i

    i`i>VVw-i>`i>>`

    iV}i`LiLi}ii-i>`

    LivVi>i`ii`iVi>`

    i>

    ii>>i>}Liviii`i>

    iL}

    ()34/29

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    11/28

    -7-- 1/,/9

    VV>V

    v7>

    vii>>v>]i1-iV

    Vi`>V>/ii`i>

    V`iV>i`>ii>v

    iVV>VLiV>Lii>

    />>}>>`vvii>i>>

    >`}i]>}i}i

    >i`-i>```>V>i>

    >V-Lii]ii]-i>```

    >`i>Vi}>}>L>]>>`

    9}>>

    i>i

    i>i]ii`i>Vi

    i`i>ii>`ii

    V>}i`}iV>>VV`}i

    i]i>>iV>iVV

    >}>i`>}iV>i]}>i`

    Vi>``iVviii-i

    >`]iivi]L}i`ii`vi}>`

    iVVV}i>

    -i>`iiVii>>>>

    >>iiiVi>>iV>

    v`iviVi]>iiVii>

    ii`}ii>]V`>i>i

    >>Vi>ii>>v`ivii

    i>in

    >

    }i>9}>>]-i>`>

    i>v>ii>`iiLi

    }}ii>>i>VivVi",-",

    L`v>>`ii}>/i

    >-i>`ii

    >VLi>>>>``i]V

    iV>Lii>>V

    i`L>1-iVV>`>i

    -/}iVL>>V>v`iwi>iV>",>

    >iii

    *>iv*i>Vi*v*

    *v*>/">i>Vi`{-i>`

    >Lii>V>}}>iVi

    *v*iiiviVV>`>

    Vi>i-i>`>V>

    *v*V>Lii>>ii

    iiiv/"iLi>`L}>

    `i>iiiv>i`

    VyV/iivi]iv}>>i`

    -i>`ii>`Vivi

    Li\-i>`Vi`i>i

    >`>i`i>`ii`>L>`

    i>`i/"

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    12/28

    -7-- 1/,/9

    -iV*V,i

    -iV*V,iii`i>V

    >i\

    ivi>>i>`i

    LiVi>L>Vii}iVi

    `i}i>V>vi>>]i

    >iV`i>LiViVLii`i

    >i>iiiv>>V>ivi}

    >`iVV{

    i}*V,i

    `ii>]>``>}iV>v}i>i

    i>>Vi>\i>iV

    }Vi>viivvii

    -iVV>}>L>V`>

    ii`i>VVi`ii>i}

    >i>`iii`ii>i>`

    i>vwi`i-iV*V,i>V

    iivi>Vi`iVi

    iv>Viv>V>i>>ii>v

    >}>ivVLiV>`i>Vi

    i`

    vii>]>i>>i>Viii}vVi

    >>i >L>i`

    >1>`>i-i>`ii`i>v

    >}`v",>`>V>i`",>V}iv>>ii

    -7--"9

    >>>>

    vVii>-"i>

    `}i

    >

    i}>,i

    +ivii`i>Vi}>i\

    "ViLivii>1

    V>Lii>>}>i1

    >>>Vin

    ()34/29

    }iV]-i>`iiVi`/"

    iiv>iy}>`i>v

    >}`}i/"

    >i>>Vi>1>`>i]i

    >vi>>`LiLii`iii

    i>i>>i]-i> >>`i i

    >>Vvi1>`i1>}>

    9}>>/ii>V`>ii>v

    i>i>ii]-i>``i`

    >>>>i>vi/i-

    Vi>i`iv}ii]`i`>`iiv

    }`L>>"i>Li>vvi

    1,>`i- >iiivV

    *>>ivi->V

    "-iiLivi>ii>]i>>i

    vi>V>VVii`LiLViii

    vVi/iii`>Vi}>i->V

    >i>Vii>vi1>`i

    "->``iiL>v>}-i>Vi

    vVi>L>`viviV-i

    >`iiV>Lii>

    >>`-i>`Vvi>i`i>

    V`>Vi>}i>>iv

    i->V]{nx->V>

    VL>i>vi>ViivVii]

    ii]iV`i`Li>V

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    13/28

    -7-- 1/,/9

    -i>`>VVii1

    ">V]x{vi-iii`v

    -i>`>VVii1V>i>Vi

    >VV`}-iiLi-i>`iw

    ViiLivi1>`iV`i`

    `iVLii>VVi>ii

    -i>`>vw\-i>`>i>>i

    i>L>i`i>>>i

    >>iLivi1]-i>`i>i

    >-i>`V>i`>V>i1

    iVV>V>`>LV>

    >V`iV`i`Li1-iVV-

    i>`vii`iV`iii>`>ii

    >`ii1iVi>`vVi

    viiVi>>>>`>i>

    -i>`>`i1ii>iLiVi\

    i>`}>>iii>Vi>`iVi

    `iiviVii

    i1}Vv>Vii>>`

    >VV>`>

    >Vi1-

    Viii>`>iV>i>Vi]Li>

    Vi>`i>Vi>ivvii`>iiiiL>V

    `i}}>V>Vv>iiiii]ii

    >i>iiViLiiii`i>*i

    `iiiLi}i`iviii

    >>ViV>v-iiLi

    "iL>]ii`i>Vi

    i>vi>>V>Vi`

    iii>iVVVi\/i>`v

    iL>VViv-iVV]iV

    }Vi>vi}>`i>i

    >`>i`i>]>LiiVwi`Lii

    ii\/iiiV>>ii

    >}i>>L`i>`i>iV>

    iVi}i>>Vi>

    i9>vii>>V\`>

    /i>V`Vi`L>V>i`Li1-

    >}>i->``>ii}i>L>i`

    >1>`>i/iivi]iV>Vvvi

    >vi>>>V>Liv-i>`/i

    i`i>VViiLi`iy}

    >V-iiiViv>

    >>>`i`V>i>V>y}ii]

    ii`i>V>`iiiv>>i>

    i>}>iLiV>>>

    iii

    7ii>>i]i>vi>>

    }i>V>Li/ii>i>i`}i

    VyViiLiivi`

    ->``>i>vi>i

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    14/28

    -7-- 1/,/9

    i`i>>``ii`iVi

    4(%,!7/&.%542!,)49

    The law of neutrality forms part of international law. The essential rights and duties of a

    neutral state are laid down in the Hague Conventions of 1907.

    At national level, neutrality is cited in the Federal Constitution as an instrument for safe-

    guarding independence.

    {\>Li}

    >i`i}v

    >}i`>vi}>`}

    i>

    7{i{n\

    yiVi`Li/9i>7>]i}i}>

    v7`iV`iVi>i>vi`i>>

    >vi}>`-i>

    {n]>,`v7ii>v>i

    >ViiiV}>L>`v-i>``i

    i`iVii7i>>vi

    i>iViii>>iV}

    nx\,iii>ivi>ii`>iV>

    >vi

    6i>>`*>nx\i>iV}i`

    `ii>>>

    i*>}iiiviLinx]i>

    i>iiV}i-i>`i>

    ii>>`}>>iii>i}

    i`i>\i>>>i

    *}>vi

    i`i>vn{n

    in{n\i>>i`iv

    i>vii`i>]i>

    >i>v>vi}>`}`ii`iVi

    >iiviV`i`iV>Vi

    vi>Viii]ii`i>V

    >`i`i>iLV>Vi

    >`Li>Vivi>

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    15/28

    -7-- 1/,/9

    /i>vi>>``

    /i>}i\/i>}ii/i}>``ivi>>i>i>i

    >``viwi}/i>}i

    ivn"VLi

    /i>L}>>i\

    U>V>>

    U-iv`iviVi

    U>>>`Li}ii

    VViiiv>>i>

    UiVi>ivLi}ii

    Ui>viLi}ii

    /i>}>vi>>

    L

    /i>vi>v>i/i>

    `>]ii]V>>Vii`>Li

    >VyV/i>vi>>V>Li

    iiV>i

    /i,>>V>

    }>iiwiv

    /i>}iviiVi

    -i>>>`i

    6i>xx\-i>`>i>i

    >iiivi->i/i>]>`i

    V>i}iiiVii>ii>

    >>Vi`L-i>`

    xx\/iiiv6i>ViiL>ii

    ->i/i>

    ii`i>

    i\i>>`ivi

    i>i>>vviVi`Li>i`iv

    ii`i>`iV`i`Liii

    Livi]ii`i>V>`i`i>iL>i

    iLiv>vi}>`}i>>Vi

    >`nx

    /ii`i>

    >i`i`*>>i

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    16/28

    -7-- 1/,/9

    4(%,!7/&.%542!,)49

    What forms of security policy involvement are compatible with the law of neutrality?

    The law provides neutral states with a good deal of scope in peacetime. Measures aimed at

    peace promotion give no cause for concern and military cooperation with foreign partners

    is possible.The limit of what is legally permissible is exceeded when the neutral state undertakes to

    provide assistance for another in the event of war.

    ->viVV>Vi

    VV>V

    ii>viV

    V>Vi`

    Li1

    *>V>iVV

    >Vi`L

    ii>>>V

    i}1

    ii>VV`}i>vi>

    >Lii>vi>V>iLii

    `iV`i`Li1-iVV

    >Lii>LiV>iiVV>V

    >iVii`Li>vi>iVi

    \>>i>

    >}v>}

    vi>Vii>

    *>V>i>Vi

    i>

    *>V>i>Vi

    ivViii>

    >i>

    *i>Vi ii>VV`}i>vi>

    >Lii>vi>>iL>i`

    >>`>ivi1-iVV>iV>i`

    iViviVyV}>i

    >Lii>vi>>iL>i`

    >>`>ivi1-iVV>iV>i`

    iViviVyV}>i

    VV`}ii>ivii`i>

    V]V>Lii>vi

    i>V>i`iL>v>>`>iv

    i1-iVV>`ii>>V

    >V>>>}>i>

    Li>i/i>V]ii]i>V

    >i>ViivViiVL>i>

    i>>Vi> ii>VV`}i>vi>

    />}Vi>

    vi}>i

    >iVi>

    vi}>i

    >Lii>>}>>>Vi

    L}>i>i`iiiv>

    >Lii>>}>>>Vi

    L}>i>i`iiiv>iii

    v>]i>vi>ii>Li}ii

    >ii>i`i>

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    17/28

    -7-- 1/,/9

    *>V>i>>}>i

    iLivi>>}>>

    *>V>i

    *>iv*i>Vi

    }>iiLi

    vi>V

    *>iV

    iLivi>

    >}>>V

    >i"-]iV

    vi

    iLivi

    1i`>1

    ii>VV`}i>vi>

    >Lii>LiV>ii*v*>i

    i>ii/"iLi>>

    >ViL}>

    >Lii>LiV>iii>

    >ViL}>iiiv>

    >Lii>LiV>iL}>

    iii`>VV>iv

    i>

    i>11

    iLi

    /"iLi

    >Lii>>}>i1>

    L`}>>>>ViL}>v>

    iLi

    V>Lii>LiV>i/"iLi

    V`iiL}>`i>>

    >Viiiiv>

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    18/28

    -7-- 1/,/9

    3)45!4)/.

    The world is changing. Our policy of neutrality changes with it. New situations call for

    new answers. In every age, neutrality had its specific significance.

    The following maps reveal how the power situation around Switzerland has changed.

    nx\/i>vi>i`>>i}iv

    6i>-i>`i>iViivi>iwi`

    vi/iiiV}i-i> i>ii>

    {\iiiivi7`7>

    -i>`iiii`i`ivVyVLiii>Vi

    >`i>

    {\iii>>>Vi-i1

    -i>``i`Liii`>i`L

    i>>`>

    x\/i`7>->i}V>i>}]ivi

    ivVyVLiii`i}V>i`>>Vi\

    i>>>Viv/">`i7>>*>V-i>`

    i>Vi`>>>`iviVi

    *

    i>vi`i>

    ">i

    1

    ,>

    -

    *

    >

    >

    *

    i>i

    1

    ,>

    -

    >}>

    i

    i}

    }>>

    ,>>-

    iL>

    *

    i>ii>i

    1

    1--,

    -

    }>>

    ,>>

    }>-

    >>

    ,

    *

    1

    1--,

    -

    }>>

    ,>>

    }>

    ,

    ,

    , *>`

    9}>>

    >>`>]1-

    >>`>]1-

    *

    1

    -

    }>>

    ,>>

    }>

    ,

    *>`

    ,>-,>i`i>

    >

    >>

    >>

    i>

    1>i

    `>-

    >>

    iV,i

    >>

    >

    -iL

    >>`

    i

    i}

    >V

    -

    i>

    L>>

    /"Vi

    7>>*>V

    i>>`>}i`>i

    {\1``i`i/i1>`/"ii>i

    }iiiV>V>`iiv>>i}>}`

    -i>`Viv}i>Vi

    /"Vi

    i>>`>}i`>i "i

    --,

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    19/28

    -7-- 1/,/9

    i>>`>}i`>ii

    Apart from Switzerland, Ireland, Sweden, Finland and Austria are regarded as neutral or

    non-aligned states. A comparison of the models:

    >V`>> vi> iLi *Li

    `iii

    *>V>

    i>>

    i>

    >\`{

    i>Vi

    nxx

    ,i>\i}>i

    iiiVi

    vi-i`

    iV

    -i`iii

    iv>

    >}i`

    i>1

    1]>V

    >*v*]

    "-]1]

    Vvi

    /"iLi

    Li

    iiVi`i

    i>vi

    -i]i

    V`}

    ]}]

    ``i>]

    v}>>]

    i>>

    i>Vi

    xx

    ,i>\}i

    V>>

    -Vix]

    >`i}>`

    iv>

    >}i`>Vi

    }i>>i

    >

    `iviiV>>

    L

    i>1

    1]>V

    >*v*]

    "-]1]

    Vvi

    /"iLi

    Li

    iiVi`i

    i>vi

    -i]i

    V`}

    ]i>

    >]

    v}>>]

    ``i>

    i>Vi

    xx

    ,i>\->i

    /i>

    i>

    >VV`}i

    -`i

    1`i`>

    >}i`

    Vi

    i>1

    1]>V

    >*v*]

    "-]1]

    Vvi

    /"iLi

    V

    Vi>Lii

    i`i

    -i]i

    V`}

    ]``i

    >]>

    ii}>]

    i>Vi

    n

    ,i>\/

    `>ViLi

    iiiv>`

    i}L

    -iv`iii`

    i>>

    ii>

    >>

    Viv>V

    i>1

    1]>V

    >*v*]

    "-]1]

    Vvi

    iii

    /"iLi

    ii}

    i

    -ini

    V`}

    Li>]]

    >ii

    }>]

    ``i>]

    v}>>

    i>Vi

    x]iV}i`

    `ii>

    >>Vi

    nx

    ,i>\vi}

    V

    iv>>

    >i>>

    Vi

    -iv`iii`

    i>i>`

    >i`i>

    /]>V

    >*v*]

    "-]1]

    Vvi

    -i>``i

    ii/"

    iLi

    -ixi

    V`}

    ]

    >`-i>]

    v}>>]

    i}>]

    ``i>

    -i`i

    >`

    >

    i>`

    -i>`

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    20/28

    -7-- 1/,/9

    3)45!4)/.

    Changing forms of conflict during the 20th century:

    Until the beginning of this century, war was considered to be a legitimate means of pursu-

    ing national interests. With the founding of the League of Nations and the United Nations

    (UN), war was outlawed.Today, many conflicts are no longer between states, but primarily occur within them. The

    law of neutrality is not applicable in such cases. However, the situation may constantly

    change with the emergence and disappearance of states. Furthermore, conflicts are becom-

    ing increasingly complex and unpredictable through the participation of both non-state and

    state actors with a background of extremism, terrorism or organised crime and through the

    collapse of state power. Asymmetrical forms of power are often predominant.

    iL>>

    i>qiL>>

    >>`ii}>q

    vi9}>>

    >>q-iL>

    i}>

    >Vi`>

    `>>

    ,>vi`i>

    -iL>q/"

    ->>i*Vi

    /i

    1i`}`i

    i>`

    /i>VyVvx

    /iv}i>ivVyV>}i`/i>VyVLiii

    >i>i>i`L`

    >v}>>

    >}>`i

    >L`>

    >

    >/

    `>

    `>q*>>

    `i>

    >q1-

    >iqiL>

    >i*>ii

    >

    iL>

    >>

    i>

    iV>L>

    V>`q*i

    >i>>

    >

    iV

    *i

    6iii>

    vV>}i>

    }>

    `

    i>vV>

    ,iLV

    >`

    }>>i

    ,}

    }

    >qi>

    i>>

    >

    Li>

    >`>}>V>

    VV

    >Li

    }i>

    ,i`

    -ii}>

    -i>ii

    ->>-`>

    1}>`>

    i>q-i>

    *>>ii>

    /i*i

    /i->`

    ->>

    />>

    1Li>

    9ii

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    21/28

    -7-- 1/,/9

    "}>>vi}VyV

    Since the Second World War, various organisations and cooperation forums have been set

    up, which as far as possible, help to prevent conflicts and secure peace. Some neutral states

    are also represented in these organisations and play an active role in resolving conflicts.

    1/i1ii>>V>

    v>iv>vi}>`}`

    i>Vi

    /i1-iVVV>ii

    >iLvi}

    i>Vi>`iV>i`i

    1>i]`iV`ii>i

    vi}Vi

    /iiV`ii>iV>i`

    i>}iiiviVyV

    }>iL>ViViiV

    V>`>i>i

    "-/i"}>>v-iV>`

    i>iii

    iiV>`i>Vi]

    >}>``iV>V>i

    >Vi>i}

    iii`>Vi

    }>>V>

    i>ViLi}/i"-

    ii>Vi>V>}

    >i>vV>`L

    V`V}>`i}iiV

    /"/`iviVi>>ViVv

    i>>`i

    V>>i/">i>i`

    }>i>v`ivi`}

    iLi>i>}>>

    >>V>i>i`

    `ivVii>Vi>

    i>Li`iivi

    >Vi

    *v**/">Vi`i*>i

    v*i>Vi*v*}>i{

    `ivii>Vi}

    }i>iVi>

    /"Vi>``i

    /"iLi>i]i

    i>>iV`}-

    i>`>V>i/i>i>

    iLivi>V*>

    iV*v`i`

    ]V>V>>iVV

    v

    1/ii>11>

    v`i`>>iVV}>>

    ]LVLi`V`i>L

    i}i`i>`}>`

    i>VivxiLi>i/i

    1iii>L>V

    vi}>`iVV

    Vvi/iVvi>}>

    >v{xi>>i

    V-i>`>Li}

    >>>i\iV>

    }]iiv>>``iV

    >V

    -ivi1-iVV

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    22/28

    -7-- 1/,/9

    `i>

    ->ii

    -i>`>v>Vi`>i>}i>i

    >`iviVi>`iiiVV>ii`Liii

    {>`{{]iV>`i`Li`>i`L

    iiq,i>

    /i>vi>/ii>>i>i}i>>L>`]>i

    >ii]L}i`>vi}>`i>i}

    ]-i>`v>`iV>i`i>>VV`>Vi

    i>}ii/`iV>i`i>>>}iiiVi`

    LiLi}ii

    />`

    /ii>`ivi}ii>v]i>iii`Lii

    ViiV>viVvi7`7>>`vi

    >V*>7>vn

    7`7>

    /i}i>i>i>`>iiLi`v-i>`

    i}L>`iiViviVii>vi

    L{/ii>>iv`>i>}i`i>

    Vi}-i>`

    v7>

    ]>>`i`>/i1-iVVi`

    iVV>V>`>i`>i>>V>i`Li

    1i`->i>iViVi>>V>}>>]->`

    >L>`iviViiiivVi`>`>>Li>i`

    `i>

    ->ii

    -i>`>V>i`>`i1iVV>V

    >}>>

    /iii>>>`i}>iy}}i1-i`

    V>vVi

    /i>vi>ivi>>]ii}ii>Vv

    >V>}iVV>V/i>i>i>i>

    iviy}}v>>>ii>ii]

    ii`i>V`i>`ii>>viV>L

    vi>>i>`v1>>V

    i-i>`>i>`>Vi``vvii>i>

    }i`iVV>Vi]``>V>i

    vii>ivii>}iv>

    />`

    />`>]-i>`>}i}ii>>>

    >`iiV>`i>Vi

    iV

    i`Vvi>

    />ii>Vi`Li]-i>`Li {x]

    i>`iv>>iVi>>`iiviVVi>

    >ii`Li>`i>Vi>v>i}ii

    iVLvViiiV]-i>`iv}iiV`

    >iLiii}ii

    iV

    i`Vvi>

    -i>`>`i`iVV>V>}>>*iv

    iy}>}>i`w}iv>/iV>]

    ii]>>i`yi-i>`>>>

    0/,)#9/&.%542!,)49

    Political tact is called for:

    The Federal Council applies the law of neutrality and takes into account neutrality policy

    considerations in reaching its decisions. Decision-making always requires an assessment of

    the current situation.The following four case studies aim to briefly illustrate what considerations led to what

    decisions.

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    23/28

    -7-- 1/,/9

    `i>

    ->ii-i>`]i>}>>i>VVi

    >LiiVLiV}i>VvVViv

    iv}iiii}>-i>`>>}i>ii>i

    V`Li}i>Li`>iv}ii>i>Li

    iiV

    /i>vi>

    >}>}vVL>i>>vii

    LiV>i/">`iV1>`>ivV>Vi

    ii>i>-i>``>V>i

    >>>i>>`i>>iVV>Vvi

    i>]>}V`Li}>i`LiV>ii`iivi

    ",i>Viii}vVi>L>i`>1>`>i>`>`Lii

    >i`L9}>>->V>",>iivi

    V>Lii>

    -i>`ii>`>`i

    iV-i>`vw}i>L}>>`

    >}ivVi>Vi>Vi`>

    />`

    i>>iiiii`-i>`v}>`V>}

    iiVv>}

    7>

    }]iVyVLiii-iL>`L>>

    iV>>i``i`v>`iivVi`yii]>L>>>>Viii`/"iii`>1

    -iVV>`>i`ii`i>}>L

    vViii`v>]>V>>}iii>>Vii`

    v>i>i`>>v9}>>,iv}iiii`i1`i

    1>`>i]i",i>>i>Viii}vVi>i`

    iV

    i`Vvi>

    -i>`i`i>>>>i]"1-]

    9}>>>``i>>>>>Viiv}ii

    L>>>`>Vi`>/ii`i>Vivi`}i

    /">}vVL>i>i`i>

    >V>}>9}>>vi>1-iVV>`>i>>i`]-i>`>",>`}>i`>}

    `i>

    ->iiiiVii`i>iL]i`i>*i`i*>V>

    ViLii\iV>`i>i>i>`ii

    V>ivL>ivi>ViiiLivi

    }i>i}iii>i`>`iiiLi>Vivi>>

    >>`>}>

    /i>vi>

    /iV>i`Li1->Vi>>V>}>>>

    1>`>i-i>`iivi>iLV

    i>i>ii]i*i`ivivi`i>

    >>i>>``>>i`Li\v>i`

    VyVLiii>i>iiLi>]-i>`

    L}i`>VV`>ViiviVi]-i>`

    `>V>iiiLi>vi]iV

    V]iii>Li>Vi>`w}iV>iviVi

    /i}i>i1>>Vivi}>V`ii>

    >>Vi`-i>`vwV>>>i`iii`

    ii>x>`V>V`>i``}i

    >`-i>`>VVii1i`>

    />`

    i>Li>i>iV}vii`viiV/i

    *i`ivivi`i>>Vi>`i}iL>v

    ->``>ii}i\nn]iVi`>}v`viVi>`}>i`>`

    7>>

    >V]>V>vVii`Li1->Vi>>>V

    >}>>">Vi1-*i`i]i}i7]`iV>i\/iiivi1i`->i>`vi`>`>i

    `i`L>i}i>i>iii>Vi

    i>v>`iVii>>i`vi>>V

    >i>i>i}ii>`>>Li>i`>

    `i`iV>Vi``i>/iV>VVi`

    iV>`->``>iii>i>

    >Li>`V>>Vii`LiVi

    iV

    i`Vvi>

    -i>`i`>iv`i`i>>>i>

    `i>i>>vv>>>ii`

    iy}iv>>>>`i`V>i>V>y}

    ii]ii`i>V>`i>iiVi

    V`V}i>LiVi>vi>ii>}i

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    24/28

    -7-- 1/,/9

    .%542!,)4935--!29

    I fear that a fair neutrality will prove to be a bitter pill for our friends, though necessary

    to keep us from the calamities of war.

    />ivvi{qn]`*i`ivi1i`->iviV>

    3%6%.+%90/).43

    i

    i>>VViviv-

    vi}>`iVV>i`

    `>

    >V}

    i>i}i>>}i

    >"iiVii>>`i>

    }wV>VLii}iV

    }iii>>vi>`]

    >`iviVivV>`

    Vi

    -iV

    i>ii>i`>LiL}i

    iV>}}iVV>

    L>`}i>`Li>i

    viLiiwv>ivviVii

    }i>i>ivi`

    i>>>>`Vi>v>

    Vvi>VVi>>

    >>ViLi

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    25/28

    -7-- 1/,/9

    -Vi

    >}ii>]i>>`i`>

    }``i>vVi-Vixviii>]vi>i"v>V>

    i>>iVV>V"

    v>V>i*>iv*i>Vi

    }>i"vi>}v`iv

    iv`iviVi>L>`">>1iLi

    iiVi

    "iviViiVivi>vi

    }}`iviVi>>>Vi"ii>`]

    iiVvLi}`>

    vi}VyV

    >ii>

    i>>Vi`>Vi]`>

    >`>>i>>ii>

    >>`i`>`iiVi`

    >

    -Vi

    `i

    /i>

    i>>iv>ii>

    V>}i`ii>i``}iVi

    i>V>vi>i

    n

    x

    x

    i`-iViVi>

    v}`}i>ii

    vvii>i>\-i>`ii>}iv>

    1VViv>VLii>}iv>>}>>V>i

    -i>`i>Vvi}>i>

    7`7>\/ii`i>

    V>vw-i>`i>>`Lii>i`vVi

    7>>\

    1>`>i>vi>>V>Li-i>`iVV>V>}>>>``i>>>>>ViviVi}

    -i>`i`>Liii`i>V>ii>

    -i>`i>>vVvi}>i>iVV>V>}>>

    7>>\-i>`}>>

    }",-",>`i`i>Viii}vVi>

    7>\-i>`>>>>V>}>9}>>`ii/">}vii>]-i>`>V>ii",i>VivVi

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    26/28

    -7-- 1/,/9

    i

    *Li\ V>*-]i`i>*>>Vi>7}]i

    \ -iv>iV>]>iVi]>>>]i>i]1L>>v>]->>}i]

    >i i]>V"> ] ,i`*]>,V]*>-i}i]}->iL}]/>-i>]

    />>]->\ V>]-i`i>>Vii

    " i\ -i>LVi]"`ixi{xnnx{

    >>LiviivV>}iv\*LV>->i]i `i}

    ii`i\LL>`VL`iL>i

    *-{ii`i`

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    27/28

    -7-- 1/,/9

    -}}i]Vi

    7i>iiii`vi-i>

    LVi

    *i>iV>V>\

    V>*-]i`i>*>>Vi>7}]i

  • 7/29/2019 Switzerland Lesson Plan Neutrality

    28/28