Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing...

61
Susan J. Leat, PhD, FCOptom, FAAO Professor School of Optometry and Vision Science, University of Waterloo Rhiannon Verran, BSc, OC(C), COMT Low Vision Specialist, Vision Loss Rehabilitation Nova Scotia Niki Harper CVRT Independent Living Skills/Low Vision, Vision Loss Rehabilitation Manitoba ©Copyright: Susan Leat, Rhiannon Verron, Niki Harper

Transcript of Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing...

Page 1: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Susan J. Leat, PhD, FCOptom, FAAO

ProfessorSchool of Optometry and Vision Science, University of Waterloo

Rhiannon Verran, BSc, OC(C), COMT

Low Vision Specialist,Vision Loss Rehabilitation Nova Scotia

Niki Harper CVRT

Independent Living Skills/Low Vision,Vision Loss Rehabilitation Manitoba

©Copyright: Susan Leat, Rhiannon Verron, Niki Harper

Page 2: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Outline

• EV• Training with optical devices▫ Near▫ Distance• Electronic devices and training

Page 3: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Eccentric viewing training – for central scotomas

Eccentric viewing : the use of a retinal locus other than the fovea for fixation (preferred retinal locus= PRL).

After training = TRLEccentric viewing : the Pt is conscious of

looking “to the side”Eccentric fixation : the Pt is not conscious of

looking off centre. The visual system has become re-referenced.

Page 4: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

scotomas come in all shapes and sizesPRLs develop naturally with time (within

6 months)>50% not aware of using it>50% change their PRL during 6 months

but reading speed not affectedNaturally, PRL is more often below the

scotomaPRL more often to the left of the scotomaMultiple PRLs are common

Crossland et al. Ophthalmology 2005;112(9):1579–1585.

Page 5: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Purpose of eccentric viewing training?? To make patient aware of their scotoma to develop consistent and efficient use of a

PRL to speed up the process of developing a PRL to optimise PRL position

Page 6: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

When does a patient need EV training?

• Central scotoma in both eyes ▫ AMD▫ Macular scar▫ Macular edema• Inconsistent fixation• Poor response to magnification

• Established “rightward” eccentric viewing• Established “downward” eccentric viewing

Page 7: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

• When VA measurements indicate

Page 8: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified
Page 9: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Or with near charts

Page 10: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

• SK Read

• Or poor response to magnification

Available from Precision Vision

Page 11: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Determining the direction of EV

• Clock Face Method

Page 12: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

• Steps:▫ Have patient look at the clock▫ Ask them if they can see the picture in the center

Page 13: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

▫ Some may say the star is clear, but some of the numbers are blurry or have disappeared

Page 14: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

▫ If client reports this, walk them around to clock to see in which position the star becomes visible

▫ This will establish the eccentric viewing position

Page 15: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

• Face Method▫ Once a PRL is determined, have the patient look

at your face▫ Ask if parts of the face are missing or blurry▫ Have them apply what they’ve learned with the

clock, to looking at your face

Page 16: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Measuring the visual fieldA protocol for eccentric viewing training

1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified Amsler Tangent screen or Modified tangent screen Humphrey Microperimeter

Want fixation to be central during field testing - plot blind spot to check fixation

Page 17: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified
Page 18: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified
Page 19: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

• Mr M. field

Page 20: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Amsler

Page 21: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Markowitz, S, (2015) Ophthalmology Management, : 19: 48-50, 76

Page 22: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

If symmetrical scotoma, move fixation upwards ie. orthogonal to direction of text If scotoma not symmetrical, choose area of best horizontal

field extending to the right which is nearest to fovea Pt must move fixation in the direction of the scotoma

A A

Page 23: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Teach EV

• Awareness training • Identify best EV location (I use the clock)• Practice fixating on new PRL and scroll print

into that fixation point, ▫ Do not add magnifier until they’ve shown success• After client has demonstrated success, give

homework to client and book follow up before they leave. • Depending on client’s performance, follow ups

required

Page 24: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Teaching eccentric viewing

can begin with Amsler chart use isolated letters then small words to teach EMs to

eccentric location

Page 25: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Quillmans (or similar) exercise

Page 26: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified
Page 27: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified
Page 28: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Pt moves eyes in appropriate direction until letters are legible.

Page 29: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

EV video

Page 30: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

4. Home training training sheets with range of print sizesmust have a helper if word reading acuity is poor loan a 16-20D

magnifier.

Page 31: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

After 2 weeks teach steady eye strategy (scrolling)

had one red two my dog tree for ten blue

had one red two my dog tree for ten blue

Page 32: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

After 2 more weeks reassess word reading acuity and magnification prescribe LVA

If no success see Pt again after 6 months

Page 33: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

• Questions about EVT Where? Effectivity? Few RCTs of effectivity, especially compared to

other TxWould people develop just as good PRL

themselves? How many hours? Technique? Monocular versus binocular viewing Is the increase in reading speed enough?

Gaffney et al (2014). How effective is eccentric viewing training? A systematic literature review. Ophthal Physiol Opt 34, 427-437, Stelmack et al (2004) JVIB, 41, 729-738.

Page 34: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

• What about microperimetry with biofeedback?▫ Verdina et al; trial of microperimetry with audible

feedback = 1 line improvement in VA in Stargardt’s But no evidence of randomization

▫ Vingolo et al (2007): Cohort study, audio biofeedback in AMD RS improved from 25 to 45 wpm character size decreased 36 to 12 point print

▫ Vingolo et al (2013) Compared two types of feedback. Improvement in reading speed and VA with luminance

feedback RS improved from 46-54 wpm

Verdina et al (2013) Eur J Ophthalmol. 23: 723–731., Vingolo et al (2007) Appl. Psychophysiol Biofeedback 32:185–189. Vingolo et al. (2013) Appl Psychophysiol Biofeedback 38: 11–16. .

Page 35: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

▫ Limitations RS still slow Quantitative differences between fovea and peripheral

retina▫ Why? Oculomotor control? Crowding Decreased visual span Slower temporal processing Slower speed of information transfer - bottleneck

Cheong et al (2008) Vis Res 48, 577–588

Page 36: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

• RCT comparing stand CCTV and EVT▫ Patients with AMD▫ With appropriate spectacle Rx and optical mag▫ 2 sessions of EV training vs desk mounted CCTV

(22” Clearview, Optelec)▫ Significant improvement in reading speed and

decrease in time taken to read utility bill for CCTV, but not EVT

▫ Significant improvement in near VA with own glasses with EVT (but VA still 20/400)

▫ Concluded that CCVT more effective for reading but EVT still important for low VA tasks e.gshopping, O&M, grooming etc,

Leat, Si, Gold, Pickering, Gordon, Hodge Accepted for publication in JVIB.

Page 37: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Near optical devices• Optical considerations for hand magnifiers

▫ Hold close to the eye to get the best FOV

▫ If using without a reading addition, distance makes no difference to magnification (EVP)

▫ If using with a reading addition, hold CLOSER to the eye get more magnification (EVP) AND hold the magnifier as far as possible from the page.

▫ Single and double aspheric lenses

Page 38: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

• Optical considerations for stand magnifiers

▫ Distance from the eye is more restricted – depends on reading addition

▫ Ideally prescribe by the MT ≠ Manufacturer’s mag.

▫ If patient pulls the SM away from the page, add is too low or EVP is too low Change to a stronger SM

L

Object

L’

1’

Image

Fm

''LFLM m

T

Page 39: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

• Optical considerations for microscopes

▫ Object at focal length of MS (for a presbyopicemmetrope) Closer for an uncorrected myope Further for an uncorrected hyperope

▫ So not much opportunity to vary the distance

Page 40: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Near Optical Device Training

• Working distance; The closer the magnifier is held to the eye the better the field of view (do they have a near prescription?)• Positioning (parallel to plane of paper)• Changing batteries and bulbs• Lighting; ask about the conditions of where they

read at home

Page 41: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

▫ How to prescribe lighting?

▫ As for tints, use subjective assessment for type and colour temperature and type, and quantity of lighting

▫ Measure illuminance in lux, convert to lumens

Page 42: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Inches from page

cms from page15 20 25 30 35 41 45 50 56 61 66 71 76 81

Light bulb calculator (lumens according to lux required and distance)

Red indicates when more than one bulb may be needed

Page 43: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified
Page 44: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Scrolling and Page navigation

• Scrolling; reading material is moved from right to left in a smooth continual motion. This allows for the patient to keep fixated on their PRL• Client must have good hand motor control• General tips: ▫ Start with easier material ▫ When you get to end of line trace the same line

back before moving down.▫ You can use your thumb to keep track of your line

Page 45: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

-Practical application: Have client bring in a bill for follow up appointment to try applying their skills to something they are familiar with.

-Practice finding top of bill, scanning to right side (to where the amounts are shown) and then scanning down. Look for landmarks or use your finger to mark locations-Using a clipboard for reading tasks allows the client to have more control

Page 46: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Telescope training

• Localizing and Spotting; Have the client find something big enough they can see unaided. Fixate on this and position telescope to see the details • Focusing• Localising• Scanning; Find a light pole and have the client

trace the pole with telescope to find the street sign

Page 47: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Electronic devices

• Electronic Magnification▫ Desktop CCTV models▫ Portable electronic magnifiers▫ Handheld video magnifiers• iOS devices

Page 48: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

• Tabletop CCTV systems

Page 49: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

• Portable electronic magnifiers

Page 50: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

• Handheld video magnifiers

Page 51: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

• iOS Devices▫ iPhones/iPads have given

independence to blind and partially sighted individuals

▫ Basic features can be turned into low vision devices Users can take a picture

using the camera and then zoom in to see more clearly

The flashlight can be used in low light to help with contrast

Page 52: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Accessibility features for iOS devices include:• Siri• Magnifier• Font Adjustment• Invert Colors and Grayscale• Zoom• Dictation• Speak Screen

• Voiceover

Page 53: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Siri

• Siri is a hands-free assistant who can help users send messages, place phone calls or even flip a coin.

• To activate, press and hold the “Home” button. Once you hear two quick beeps, Siri is ready, and you can ask her to do a task.

Page 54: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Magnifier

• Once activated, once the home button is hit three times, the magnifier app appears

• It turns the phone’s camera into an electronic magnifier with options for turning on the flash, changing the colors, zooming in and out and taking a snapshot

Page 55: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Font Adjustments

• Font can be adjusted in the following ways:▫ Larger text▫ Bold text▫ Increase contrast

Page 56: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Invert Colors and Grayscale

• Inverting colors and using grayscale can help to improve contrast

Page 57: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Zoom

• Zoom magnifies the entire screen• Once activated, you need

to double tap with 3 fingers to zoom• To navigate the screen,

you must drag with three fingers

Page 58: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Dictation

• When you press the microphone button on the keyboard, you can dictate and the words will be automatically typed into the field

• Siri must be activated for dictation to work

Page 59: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Speak Screen

• Speak screen will read text on your device in email, iMessages, web pages and books

• Once activated, you need to swipe down from the top of the page with two fingers, or tell Siri to Speak Screen

Page 60: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Voiceover

• VoiceOver is a gesture-based screen reader that allows an individual to use iOS even if they cannot see the screen • When activated, VoiceOver

describes everything happening on the screen• Simple gestures allow the

user to navigate the device• Dragging your finger on the

screen tells you what is there• Tap to hear descriptions• Double tap to activate

Page 61: Susan J. Leat, Rhiannon Niki Harper PhD, FCOptom, FAAO ... · A protocol for eccentric viewing training 1. Determine size, position and shape of central scotoma Amsler or Modified

Apps

• iBooks/eReader apps▫ iPads/iPhones can be used as an eReader▫ Font sizes can be enlarged and brightness can be

adjusted