2 7 7 " I cRKNAL

RLED IN THE / NOV 2 0 2tJi

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES J

- PETITIONER (Your Name)

vs.

RESPONDENT(S)

ON PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO

3TZO STA (*S o €SS J\k cSCQv (NAME OF COURT THAT LAST RULED ON MERITS OF YOUR CASE)

PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI

0 (Your Name)

(p%: L5v 3'AO cc.9o.)(DZ5

(Address)

3 \i\\ 1S Q Ot)OS (City, State, Zip Code)

N 1pk (Phone Number)

QUESTION(S) PRESENTED

. cic T cv 9\c3cV \$

vo s- pv (

TO Lc r\çç ) \\ \*\ O

33- SC\ X\VL ç \ \

LE T\-L

cc*5' SS\)3 vc( r\ GUT CNN c

cyL Cc5

c\

4'

3r cic 'IW -c3 v\\ccv

9Th\- t9\SE _Q- T

co ccu \-\Lc S

LIST OF PARTIES

All parties appear in the caption of the case on the cover page.

[ ] All parties do not appear in the caption of the case on the cover page. A list of all parties to the proceeding in the court whose judgment is the subject of this petition is as follows:

cw\\ cr

TABLE OF CONTENTS

OPINIONS BELOW . 1

JURISDICTION...................................................................................................................

CONSTITUTIONAL AND STATUTORY PROVISIONS INVOLVED .................................3 STATEMENT OF THE CASE ........................................................................................... co

REASONS FOR GRANTING THE WRIT......................................................................... AA

CONCLUSION...................................................................................................................39

INDEX TO APPENDICES

!APPENDIX A o c v\à S?S Lik -

4o . APPENDIX B0,. 43

jAPPENDIX c

IAPPENDIX 0

VQ

tvv vt \Q9 QoL Av3 °

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES CITED

CASES PAGE NUMBER

\rs SPIN 5, (\c g))

\J. SC\\Sk3.S 303 ç\ccç

OU3C\V \J.\JCj\

'.i. 5kv, 3 \S 33,3°\ \L -\5 3c\

vi

'J Q3QV\ (c3d1\ C\r. lmo) STATUTES AND RULES

,~,S U. 3 - C- . ~, AS 'A (A) (L) ~ (PL)

OTHER

\/

v XLV cv S

V.

3

3

L oe&S*c\o.c&5) 35 t.\\

Lcjc V vrc53 3(o03) tWw Q-5, r)S

35

- L)V 3C 3 EA. 5c3 (\s%)

3T \J \\ c\\ \C\\

(\5v C 3") \),

. , 3 cç)

5\s jcc

3\\35 (0)

IN THE

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI

Petitioner respectfully prays that a writ of certiorari issue to review the judgment below.

OPINIONS BELOW

[ ] For cases from federal courts:

The opinion of the United States court of appeals appears at Appendix to the petition and is

[II reported at ; or, [ ] has been designated for publication but is not yet reported; or,

is unpublished.

The opinion of the United States district court appears at Appendix - C_. to

the petition and is

[ ] reported at ; or, [ ] has been designated for publication but is not yet reported; or, M is unpublished.

[ ] For cases from state courts:

The opinion of the highest state court to review the merits appears at Appendix to the petition and is

[ ] reported at ; or, [ ] has been designated for publication but is not yet reported; or, [ ] is unpublished.

The opinion of the _______________________________________________ court appears at Appendix to the petition and is

[ ] reported at ; or, [ ] has been designated for publication but is not yet reported; or, [ ] is unpublished.

1.

JURISDICTION

[ ] For cases from federal courts:

The date on which the United States Court of Appeals decided my case was

[] No petition for rehearing was timely filed in my case.

J A timely petition for rehearing was denied by the United States Court of Appeals on the following date: vvirk, , and a copy of the order denying rehearing appears at Appendix

] An extension of time to file the petition for a writ of certiorari was granted to and including (date) on _____________________ (date) in Application No. A______

The jurisdiction of this Court is invoked under 28 U. S. C. § 1254(1).

[ ] For cases from state courts:

The date on which the highest state court decided my case was A copy of that decision appears at Appendix

[ ] A timely petition for rehearing was thereafter denied on the following date: and a copy of the order denying rehearing

appears at Appendix .

[ ] An extension of time to file the petition for a writ of certiorari was granted to and including (date) on (date) in Application No. A_______

The jurisdiction of this Court is invoked under 28 U. S. C. § 1257(a).

CONSTITUTIONAL AND STATUTORY PROVISIONS INVOLVED

T'Q \Wc\ ko kA

Qzvlvs~ (Qc \\A v\vç

"o QJ5f\ \I\c\\ d \\oQ- (

L Ccwk4 'I

co

tV\ \\ 4 o ko \cSI - \t cr \j

Vi

T\AQ vo

ks r

\I\ o?c 'I S\c\ \c?c JQ

rc\cz

'I MQ -k'R_1S

ç

3

ç%y Cc vov cz j Sov k '

COv\S W'kc i—.,

V\ S\f\ (?—

T \ 5tNJ (I\5

\ \vcL G çç \ 1\

\j c \f5

Co

°'ô s 10c ; c w

5¼Jckv kc o \

A 5c c cv\j Q\o\v J\C~ 5

vc35 cI\ O SQ

( \ °

\o\ cv'

c

4

Vii

r3

Sç \ z Cc

ç- Cç

O3C. 5'-

5

STATEMENT OF THE CASE

5c V\v\ V e?fMov '.icts v\—

'!3 '- ° 3

C3 V-\ 3v \"\ or (\')

\v\c\ çjc\ f\& Ac\ c 2) c \Qw ccc cw (3) s cW \v-

i

o 3'Vc c

V,P

1v\t.r s5

Lc voM otr Q cu c Ov cj k\ov\Sf \oj t. 5 JcA v)ce\\ro cr ç&Q JQ5 -

\c3 35\¼ 9\Qf

XA 34p v~ i Acte V3S Z5)

(o3c\ 5v\cQ A& VO LR '

' v•s.3:v

G

)c\ co ?c o \tvV\ çs\\ vV\ 53

Sr\r k k\ cq3

Qot 3V'ç

\Jcg 5eJ c o

oj- ç \gc

*

Sc\ c\\ 5Q t OA

S

toç

v\cs

çç OVA 3* \'\Ck\J\ 5V\ Q¼AS Z$ t2\ O\(

Mc çr 5-00v ko\. O

\cov Sv

"I

S r ocsv eis *v?v

COtJç \w?v Q\<, - Q 5 TL)3 SV\

V\ \c

Mrt W'cS \p c ¼3 kc \'

C>kv

Qt\p#A t\ \¼J\ Q

'\It Co3\ \ \V QC3

SS \ 3cS 3 ko W'\\ c

" QV1* 34 Cccy\ VO

oI-\

C) v\jJ c

\ q,3 V\ ? kV

\'3 Mo cS Yvc?is >vA -

r. \ocv • sc?c S rjcv

_v )\v

O

ø# AP, \A¼ 1'\c>ç \v4\ Z5cw5 C\c\)ç 5Ove$'

3c J-:~ VA5

M~V 9At? J\

cç y\c 3 kc c- krc V\Q

c'

CACJv\vv

5cwes co-e- !( (\S jtss cç4"

T\/\ C OJ'4J CV9 '1\Y

Ct \cO 5\Jy Qo'Jc\

¼1 O\ P\JL)

3:- VO \\ Su Cc/o\\./\c\ cJ1 ?

CI' Ccvr

mN

C\ c

W\\55Ov ¼I\

k'

Q er \v

°

çç oc'3 c \r Tov- c

q, k vi\ç o

A

(o vc1 3 c3 V'\QcS

V\ qy Sc CcI\

'of \o Z:QF S

ccj Ocvo

1'\ 5V Qok Ov\ f

) ~10

& OS

kc \3\os \tr cr—

A\ c iv\35 sc~

\v \vc

SCjQ~ '\ \v\c:\ Cook v-- \

Ot\ sOA VN

r\s cs s\s

fz~ kc\ CZ3,\S6 e

\O-

AA)èc

po cs 5 V¼OV\S

4 > cc

Lv\ c\))

C\\ '

Ofr\ VI\

ck3 v\c

°'.'

c-

\cj

c L9cv \ \

\\\cW\-

Q

\s< \\ ckv 3ç

s Q\' CèV \(\QJ\ A J3

\O\\ cI\

3v'\S5c\, (çcE)

ix\ o

\L CDc'V

Ov\ cz or

"\S. 1\SCJV% I~) G\

c rcA Sczo'\ -

j\- 3vjcp QA\-

IVJI

A3cA 't SM cscX \kc& 'OvA3 C \c

c13(\ct i) CtD

V-k

/

çQc CcX)-

\ A1 kv\ C5vSc\ w \3 CQQ M-

Q fSç\r c\ çn\ s03 \c

\v —

C'I\

cj

OV*(\ T$kcT

cj o

o 'AJ-

cç cVcM\ >c c

cv\s 5i\ SS1

\ct (JC L}JV\OV

Ov\ '3 vVQf ~Ov

O VO 3 J9) V\ \

- S\' -' rcSc- ç(V\ç Qç

Q çcf CWWr O(jo

\Vs \A\S \r\

cj' vc

k \vS3 -YV\cSS

c?c LS9

\S

3p\r—

cj- co oc?I \O \ $A$ OJVS 5

cc\

OL)V 3 SMc OV\

N-

9J\ c%o¼I\ Oc(3 cNbJ3 çs

AY V\\ \3S-}j cv c\JT33i If\

\I\c O0c\ Xv\

i j vvv

0 0 3 0\() vV~ Y5

\S3\ 5\ft 5Q 3Q \A q S&

tc C\A

> \ vç CV\ 1'-

j) \AV'\. '"L3 S"\

Noco c3v

iJc ¼N'¼M 9A13

\3

yr &c43

V\O' Q cx) J Qoc

oV v<r 3vv\ \OU\V5 J

C\

cc V\O

0 V\

cr3 QP\ \ J UX\ (:A VY, p\vr. C 07s t\ )

OV Pj

j\\ , r \ O\

çv\ç\ç\9 \(

5L\ () 3s OH,5 \\c S

JJ 3> \

\V\ QcV\ s - AccS

M\ ()V &\\ & c SQ(?c o

\c

&t -

(CL) $k \ J\ C S \

Of Vo\)~A--~ q'\ v

C\Qc ç\y\ç Qi\

Qo¼3 C '1

AV v:oc-

\t

&Vi \'-\ kA(sQ 5kcv cA iO

As "A

rl\A ço—

vk LC5OV\\ ~\\cv oc \csf\ c5ç

\r 335cD\c4 Q5 c-

GV\ ( çy Tç

t1\& c?ç cS 3

Loy d. 3iS3

Ic\\ 51

ck\ASi >'s\ ii\ ç04 3 (SV-

kz Qv\V, k'i5 orc ccc -

\

cej3 ¼)tJ\3 OSR Of3 V' c4 Ac\ oJ'

c\\ v\

&3QS c v\O& )Q—

\ atç ss1k O\\\W

ck \&r ç\cv

OCi'Y%\ c cx Sv'\

c3cck 1\c V\v r c2v V)i c C vvi?s

V'O W

c\oc ko cv

)f 5yv, I'd ul-

i\L5 k\ Cc ço ie\

Qoo\f L\

I

\o-

\j)

cJ'1?f3 O (kv\c& itQ ef\ 'v.

&

OV\ (v\)3 YV ¼\J''\ cy\?j Sk4 ~ T

L) j)

SUcv?\ o\cçcLt '

33 t. c

cr

k\\c cc ç\c

\v' çw\oc O%J3\ k cc

Tc.iq\ I\3Q?:\ i •

c \ c \c1

Qf

Q

cj '\c IL4 cs

RL)J- . kc

v\ck O'J\f Q LSJ

s c S czv 3.

i\Oc CV\

-

rV V\C V Oj

kc cSt-

I\oc Vq

OVN

AQ )3à "A3 v5Qf \f\ \

\p

kc cc?Lrvv9

Q\/Jç$ sv\r'5 çc x/V\

ç'v's

3vc cciv' c\v

C\sJ5 c\3ck\\i'\

CCA SW Ic\ v5 c r5

C Y\cr\V5.

D3 SNj \\V\\c Jj\v

CJ

k \ cAc c

v iS 133 o% QQ v\-

° Q'1O35 \ 'WJ\QSS (VVJ v

i. ew,,4.

y\o\

q O C\i \ Srt3k'r 2 A qS c\

o ss Mcc

O L55 czç V\)v\55 \\$

c °c t

'-s

Jc ç\

\c' t

\

t èp\ 5>cç

kc,r \s &\s A's pk

(3\ çcy

oc:v csL

OJ\ c\¼ S Sc3 Ait

'D 5(\oi c\

ov\3rk\ C\ \ eS5 o C\ \\ \

V\

yc\

' Qc\\ sk1 i1

c'&

ci 'cç

9V 3 V\0T,

',\ vvy vpQ

\r ;}cj\? \)C\J•Q 'oc?V\ OS1\Q AA

V S\v\c3 OV

.S\\—

\ '

t cci\ cc3

IV

J. 35r) 393 ç \c\\) \Qc

OQ¼3cr\ kv 3J

isi '

j\ v\

V 3

(e3

9L-I\S~

\ 3 VIC c c\\ooJV \cc 3c3vc \rj cc\j3 "vo \\zc

S \4QJ' V\IV\

3I\ Mov\c V kV\t

•c\ W\S I PAjV\

>czz ccvc \t\J V\O¼\5 C\3cks.A3k

T cc\\ \c\ 55c3 \k O\kAQf è?çc' ckA OCW—

'S ctv

èSc- OSE

C/\ '\c~ - cLe Co &jc. ccs

Jc v

S)ff4 -

53'o

c J \v\ I\ cc

00

\ $ -

\\ovu' SS VVV\~ C Y.

9 ii?c s vs

ç Sç

'svc3 c.

Qo\k v\ Q\ ss J\\oc/3 Jct\

\.

vv rV\1\ ccM çr

9~1.

*vc

c R'

5\ içç iL'rn

c\rq cqj5 TS .ve\p; (-

vVr v-

T

kww o S oci \k5

Scc) r

Cccv &k

3 %') c c o

s"Q

\\t \CTcv cv\ \cS 3

c

REASONS FOR GRANTING THE PETITION

.-c c-cE vc -cEc) 1 _s çyc ?OCSS S 1-No -\ }3\\_ \ TO

\?o LO\E %'( 1cc\

5-TL iot

èw Q ?c\cv\cr

QQ'w>k

CVAvvz, '$ \&\Q )Jk \e \c

Cc:I\ cA \C\3 3'c'i't

cüi k cp çv \?v

.L k

•k'

v\(vc\\\3

-\ VSe \cr c

3

-k

5 gvk

\c Ao

ç cec CWj

\t5s viçv 'c

I ok \SAo ) sJ\? VIA V\\ \\ O\)V \\c\ j

'tw vocn 5'33 'ks yiv

'*r3 " \'c~ ç-w ON y v s'1-\ J) \V\

\__ s ko CyJW\v tj C

s3 Q OS¼d\Q \tilSCV5 - cf ii' \vc

\a J fcci ci\rj cV\\(

3 v\ocS \\r '-

t 3 4ocj\ 3ov'.5 cv9 c\\c X12 . 3SS€.

VIAP, $oJ

c3 \V?j

30

\r CocV \.3Nv A3 \?sk&' c\\vc SA'S

ss ko cv vc?v cwj VVi- V

cws

L ccse c3 \\r

ccvViY j\c rov

k

\ >\* tv \v tr \

•k * c Sc'ZkS \v

Ckv Cv\3 -co %

to?r \*r jc5

coc 5uw wv \<\V\QVS \vt

Cov?v.j S0\0'5 V/\ c\)5

kL kL kr\c\ c\ CQc\(

cAs covs cç jv

c\ \c\ev'Q, c çJV&

vockss

3'

3 WE \ ciEs5 X9Z v scvcc E oo €S\TL

To \SvK\c\r .

c rIw

"k'v *v\ SS* cv kv cj\ kc CJ\ CQL¼)5 V--S

Vccs tceSS czY\k i S

O 5 ,\3)3

>\ k. 5c\o S)c vt '5 2

• kv& ((J5e Ss

Q\ %ilc SS

esiz &cv 5 c)\

cc?v 3\Ø3 ')\SO• 'kj; ¶5

occoc

Ccr ' AV'4t

3'

\cc-

c \k\ e:ckj t CoJ5c

'\\ic~c cQ CJQ \kA Mv U\\3 r C\v\ 3c

\ic

V\ S S5 \í — v5 AQ 3\V\Q c

CJ) ccv yR-t

k jv3 S\\c, 35 ¼r\S Jc >Vc O t v ov

cWc A kcw\3 °V > 'Q

J 'i A *ck SwkZ3

pwclst ) 3tCkv'

kc 'w

fl5 fl 1\ c\rc\-c 3ou.RV iç

os 3Qw3 -

cyr' jc3

'\s 3

33

èWRSV op \or ko A 35

\ c C\or

Qvt5 \v\?3 >\Zi c5

V\ r\v\3 Qv\èwr, AFAVyf

51

cAç vcJ

y&k D\5Q5 4\J\(&S cf e4

3\

cc: c k

c\v) )t \ 3\

VAc c xj q\

/ Q\Qc iç

Svv\ \c "SV\ cQ

\ S5

( (v ?coJ

3

'se

V\55 Ck5

\t 'v

k\,cA9 )c5

vvo4

\\ Q\ \! c3\ c\v\ ¼Ac

v.

3. T Sc\- (OZS

NO v'\VV QZSL \Io)T Is TO cj\ W)&

5çc (ov-

ko 'J..

3Qcs.

34k (\cg5).

<PV\t q3V ikr P3 v?

c:\

C\s Cc\ cjy)

35

C?v Sec\ s\w p

J A S\ fj t~i \ct sqw

\ \J JLV v \s5

3T3f'(\c5)

C

c

°5

t1\C DO

VA- iciç C06\4 3o\\\\\ t

o cJc? S CoA/iej.

R

\ 5 "

r)

3'

9 r IIAM FO6T\\V V?Th\ QO)SL S Y'

s c S3

p" ryv\K Tv SV\ cti\ Cw\'s 4S "CoW'v't\j c\A c\cw\ oc

5'v 'k \ w1Mov t v) w\ o 9 c V.

vytf o-5

&

3r)3C\

'fl\ v\\ (\Fflo)

°- Yçv L S.

ccX,- "

3)

r Ac:~c v'k CA c

\\c kv\ Ccut\ kQ-\ jQv\c5 C\

S\v- 0 z 4J\J -

Ell

CONCLUSION

The petition for a writ of certiorari should be granted. w'

cv

Respectfully submitted, >k< v c\

V/1#5rVAVAWZ =0 _0

Date:

3O