Summary€¦ · Web view146 264 Binnu ASWN 289 136 Calingiri ASWN-119-69-39 79 Fortune...

Agzone 4 (north and eastern wheatbelt) - variety performance in Western Australia (2009-13)

SummaryReview production value graphs for wheat varieties to support you with variety selection.

You can get an indication of how much more a variety is likely to yield in kilograms per hectare (kg/ha) compared to other varieties in that environment.

It also provides an indication of the stability of the variety over a number of locations and years within an agzone or region.

The analysis is based on Grains Research Development Corporation’s (GRDC’s) National Variety Trials (NVT) from 2009–13. It is recommended you consider a number of locations and years.

NVT locations included in this report are:

Binnu, Buntine, Cadoux, Mullewa and Pithara in the northern districts of agzone 4 Kellerberrin, Merredin, Mukinbudin, Narembeen and Wyalkatchem in the eastern districts of agzone 4

Table 1 Location details for NVT’s at Binnu in 2009, 2010 and 2011

Location details Binnu in 2009 Binnu in 2010 Yuna in 2011

Sowing Date 27/05/2009 11/06/2010 29/05/2011

GSR (May – Oct) mm 368 160 344

pH CaCl2 at 10cm 5.7 5 5.7

pH CaCl2 at 60cm 4.7 4.7 5

Previous Crop Lupin Lupin Long fallow

Site Correlation 0.62 0.81 0.70

Table 2 Production value (kg/ha) of wheat varieties and their classification at Binnu in 2009, 2010 and 2011

Variety Classifications: AH = Australian Hard, APW = Australian Premium White, APW-imi = Australian Premium White Imidazolinone tolerant, ASFT = Australian Soft and ASWN = Australian Noodle.

Variety Classification

Production value at Binnu 2009



Carnamah AH -12 -55 235Cascades AH -264 -246Cobra AH 9 438EGA Bonnie Rock AH 109 79 46Emu Rock AH 214 50King Rock AH 108 83 31Mace AH 302 222 186Tammarin Rock AH 141 106Yitpi AH -129 -39AGT Katana APW 111 115 36Corack APW 293 508Correll APW -124Envoy APW 12 -429





Espada APW 81 46 152Estoc APW -20 -263Fang APW -307Gladius APW -60 3Harper APWMagenta APW 43 -53 334Scout APW -128 -501Trojan APWWestonia APW 181 106 282Wyalkatchem APW 197 139 90Young APW 72 113Zippy APW 75 227 -401Clearfield STL APW-imi -174 -201Grenade CL Plus APW-imi -270Impose CL Plus APW-imi 68 79 -289Justica CL Plus APW-imi -70 -247Bullaring ASFT 374Kunjin ASFT -169Wedin ASFTArrino ASWN 154 120 147Binnu ASWN 181 127Calingiri ASWN -64 -94 63Fortune ASWN -42 -46 35Yandanooka ASWN -94 -95 11

Table 3 Location details for NVT’s at Buntine between 2009–13

Location details Buntine in 2009 Buntine in 2010 Buntine in 2011 Buntine in 2012 Buntine in 2013

Sowing Date 4/06/2009 4/06/2010 25/05/2011 6/06/2012 24/05/2013GSR (May – Oct) mm 200 154.3 276 NA 226.2pH CaCl2 at 10cm 5.1 4.8 4.9 5.3 4.5pH CaCl2 at 60cm 4.8 4.5 4.8 4.4 4.6Previous crop Lupin Canola Lupin Lupin LupinSite Correlation 0.76 0.66 0.6 0.67 0.56

Table 4 Production value (kg/ha) of wheat varieties and their classification at Buntine between 2009–13



Production value at Buntine in

2009


2010


2011


2012


2013Carnamah AH 148 -17 211 8Cascades AH -283 -363Cobra AH 35 383 206EGA Bonnie Rock AH 126 56 86 67 92Emu Rock AH 324 176 91 38King Rock AH 122 46 59 52Mace AH 351 348 349 286 350Tammarin Rock AH -32 156Yitpi AH -274 -84 -147 -172AGT Katana APW 166 189 111 51Corack APW 453 656 324 331Correll APW -297Envoy APW -209 7 -461 -130Espada APW 168 111 188 82 77Estoc APW -40 -297 -105Fang APW -526



2009


2010


2011


2012


2013Gladius APW -85 5Harper APW -77Magenta APW 173 30 326 154 202Scout APW -378 -584 -216 -248Trojan APW -193Westonia APW 337 194 344 160 166Wyalkatchem APW 191 196 206 202 268Young APW 124 149Zippy APW 54 114 -342Clearfield STL APW-imi -241 -276 -110Grenade CL Plus APW-imi -234 -97 -118Impose CL Plus APW-imi -131 -35 -108 49Justica CL Plus APW-imi -94 -262 -91 -89Bullaring ASFT -18 55Kunjin ASFT 389 255 425 149 109Wedin ASFT -171 -240 -57 -10Arrino ASWN 286 136 215 58Binnu ASWN 334 80Calingiri ASWN -82 -79 46 42 85Fortune ASWN -50 49 72 52 58Yandanooka ASWN -99 -53 46 -1 -7

Table 5 Location details for NVT’s at Cadoux in 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012 and 2013

Location details Cadoux in 2009 Cadoux in 2010 Cadoux in 2011 Cadoux in 2012 Cadoux in 2013Sowing Date 2/06/2009 11/06/2010 23/05/2011 11/06/2012 27/05/2013

GSR (May – Oct) mm 301 128 275 168 180

pH CaCl2 at 10cm 5.1 4.7 4.5 5.1 4.9

pH CaCl2 at 60cm 4.6 4.2 4.4 4.4 4.8

Previous Crop Lupin Lupin Lupin Lupin Canola

Site Correlation 0.71 0.67 0.74 0.73 0.38

Table 6 Production value (kg/ha) of wheat varieties and their classification at Cadoux between 2009–13



Production value at Cadoux

in 2009Production value at Cadoux 2010

Production value at Cadoux 2011



Carnamah AH -65 -77 -39 -72Cascades AH -334 -235Cobra AH -38 141 120EGA Bonnie Rock AH 102 39 62 -29 11Emu Rock AH 174 57 151 -44King Rock AH 97 34 71 -51Mace AH 417 226 159 205 134Tammarin Rock AH 247 185Yitpi AH -125 -10 26 -9AGT Katana APW 110 98 21 98Corack APW 199 214 74 63Correll APW -79Envoy APW 37 87 -7


Production value at Cadoux

in 2009Production value at Cadoux 2010




Espada APW 96 41 29 44 11Estoc APW 21 -25 64Fang APW -310Gladius APW -130 -3Harper APWMagenta APW 108 -20 42 15 97Scout APW -84 13 47 64Trojan APW -240Westonia APW 202 75 85 37 32Wyalkatchem APW 280 147 108 128 102Young APW 30 66Zippy APW -156 57 -57Clearfield STL APW-imi -101 -93 -16Grenade CL Plus APW-imi -144 130 -79Impose CL Plus APW-imi 9 66 -63 52Justica CL Plus APW-imi -11 -73 69 2Bullaring ASFT 107 53Kunjin ASFT 178 73 50 94 9Wedin ASFT -51 -65 84 110Arrino ASWN 83 40 34 -42Binnu ASWN 119 4Calingiri ASWN -19 -40 -24 22 56Fortune ASWN 17 31 -53 153 25Yandanooka ASWN -106 -39 -119 75 -71

Table 7 Location details for NVT’s at Kellerberrin in 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012 and 2013

Location details Kellerberrin in 2009

Kellerberrin in 2010

Kellerberrin in 2011 Kellerberrin in 2012

Kellerberrin in 2013

Sowing Date 23/06/2009 19/05/2010 18/05/2011 4/06/2012 13/05/2013

GSR (May – Oct) mm 232 98 NA 135 257

pH CaCl2 at 10cm 6.1 4.8 5.4 0.61 5.1

pH CaCl2 at 60cm 7.7 6.9 5.3 4.4 5.4

Previous Crop Lupin Legume pasture Canola Canola Pasture spray topped

Site Correlation 0.72 0.67 0.72 0.74 0.49

Table 8 Production value (kg/ha) of wheat varieties and their classification at Kellerberrin between 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012 and 2013



Production value at Kellerberrin

2009


2010Production value at

Kellerberrin 2011Production value

at Kellerberrin 2012


2013Carnamah AH 10 24 -49 -115Cascades AH -274 -281Cobra AH -163 190 165EGA Bonnie Rock AH 75 -24 158 32 129Emu Rock AH 320 113 190 216King Rock AH 78 -46 182 19Mace AH 217 183 196 257 268Tammarin Rock AH 4 124Yitpi AH -69 -9 16 -50AGT Katana APW 169 203 39 110Corack APW 238 357 147 423



2009


2010Production value at

Kellerberrin 2011Production value

at Kellerberrin 2012


2013Correll APW -68Envoy APW 61 179 99Espada APW 79 88 22 33 45Estoc APW 7 -93 50Fang APW -276Gladius APW 47 152Harper APWMagenta APW -54 -44 -37 -45 -51Scout APW -31 -30 71 119Trojan APW -218Westonia APW 157 106 123 50 146Wyalkatchem APW 108 71 148 177 167Young APW 189 185Zippy APW 363 260 228Clearfield STL APW-imi -165 -201 -69Grenade CL Plus APW-imi -251 77 -253Impose CL Plus APW-imi -2 7 105 172Justica CL Plus APW-imi -7 -159 38 -141Bullaring ASFT 8 -42Kunjin ASFT 187 234 -1 41 81Wedin ASFT -116 -262 -7 -235Arrino ASWN 195 111 168 16Binnu ASWN 184 -75Calingiri ASWN -137 -77 -110 -27 -140Fortune ASWN -53 122 -195 74 -157Yandanooka ASWN -94 80 -213 5 -261

Table 9 Location details for NVT’s at Merredin in 2009, 2011, 2012 and 2013

Location details Merredin in 2009 Merredin in 2011 Merredin in 2012 Merredin in 2013

Sowing Date 16/06/2009 18/05/2011 7/06/2012 15/05/2013

GSR (May – Oct) mm 195 255 137 189

pH CaCl2 at 10cm 4.9 4.5 5.4 4.7

pH CaCl2 at 60cm 5.4 4 4 4.2

Previous Crop Lupin Lupin Grassy pasture Pasture spray topped

Site Correlation 0.80 0.69 0.69 0.52

Table 10 Production value (kg/ha) of wheat varieties and their classification at Merredin between 2009, 2011, 2012 and 2013



Production value at Merredin 2009



Production value at

Merredin 2013Carnamah AH -24 -98 -96Cascades AH -219Cobra AH 235 119EGA Bonnie Rock

AH 81 95 3 2

Emu Rock AH 104 144 93King Rock AH 88 103 -6Mace AH 203 353 172 115Tammarin Rock

AH 35

Yitpi AH -59 42 -59AGT Katana APW 108 41 85





Production value at

Merredin 2013Corack APW 378 71 214Correll APW -76Envoy APW 95 136 99Espada APW 53 63 20 63Estoc APW -21 69Fang APW -238Gladius APW -11Harper APWMagenta APW -31 117 -47 87Scout APW -5 29 109 -54Trojan APW -139Westonia APW 123 158 19 106Wyalkatchem

APW 120 244 112 48

Young APW 116Zippy APW 220 -258Clearfield STL

APW-imi -136 -35

Grenade CL Plus

APW-imi -219 79 -91

Impose CL Plus

APW-imi 17 -111 82

Justica CL Plus

APW-imi -98 51 -69

Bullaring ASFT 38Kunjin ASFT 109 105 30 167Wedin ASFT -38 26 -47Arrino ASWN 135 10 -13Binnu ASWN 169Calingiri ASWN -97 -3 -22 -8Fortune ASWN -64 -29 69 28





Production value at

Merredin 2013Yandanooka ASWN -111 -181 4 -36

Table 11 Location details for NVT’s at Mukinbudin in 2009, 2010, 2011 and 2013

Location details Mukinbudin in 2009 Mukinbudin in 2011 Mukinbudin in 2012

Mukinbudin in 2013

Sowing Date 1/06/2009 20/05/2011 5/06/2012 15/05/2013

GSR (May – Oct) mm 184 261 135 186

pH CaCl2 at 10cm 6.1 4.7 5.5 4.7

pH CaCl2 at 60cm 7.3 5.5 4.3 5.6

Previous Crop Wheat Wheat Canola Wheat


Table 12 Production value (kg/ha) of wheat varieties and their classification at Mukinbudin in 2009, 2011, 2012 and 2013



Production value at

Mukinbudin 2009

Production value at Mukinbudin

2011


2012


2013

Carnamah AH 0 -118 -133Cascades AH -235Cobra AH 169 125EGA Bonnie Rock AH 49 154 22 -49Emu Rock AH 175 106 69King Rock AH 51 176 12Mace AH 165 314 179 54Tammarin Rock AH 0Yitpi AH -31 48 -28AGT Katana APW 152 73 60Corack APW 408 15 157


Production value at

Mukinbudin 2009


2011


2012


2013

Correll APW -20Envoy APW 70 267 124Espada APW 61 35 -3 65Estoc APW -35 72Fang APW -197Gladius APW 67Harper APWMagenta APW -72 -31 -67 112Scout APW 13 75 106 -4Trojan APW -178Westonia APW 114 140 -11 89Wyalkatchem APW 75 223 141 -12Young APW 177Zippy APW 351 151

Clearfield STL APW-imi -212 2

Grenade CL Plus APW-imi -242 108 -78

Impose CL Plus APW-imi -2 59 218

Justica CL Plus APW-imi -131 74 -48

Bullaring ASFT 7Kunjin ASFT 151 27 -49 206Wedin ASFT -207 47 17Arrino ASWN 155 123 -27Binnu ASWN 126Calingiri ASWN -123 -108 -7 9Fortune ASWN -33 -153 60 64Yandanooka ASWN -69 -245 16 -26

Table 13 Location details for NVT’s at Mullewa in 2009, 2010, 2011 and 2013

Location details Mullewa in 2009 Mullewa in 2010 Mullewa in 2011 Mullewa in 2013

Sowing Date 27/05/2009 26/05/2010 27/05/2011 17/05/2013

GSR (May – Oct) mm 183 187 225 171

pH CaCl2 at 10cm 6.8 NA 6.3 5.3

pH CaCl2 at 60cm 5.2 NA 5.2 5.9

Previous Crop Other Grassy pasture Long fallow Pasture spray topped


Table 14 Production value (kg/ha) of wheat varieties and their classification at Mullewa in 2009, 2011, 2012 and 2013



Production value at Mullewa 2009




Carnamah AH 16 -3 187Cascades AH -299 -172Cobra AH 37 386 84EGA Bonnie Rock AH 156 89 128 14Emu Rock AH 156 142 -63King Rock AH 159 88 126Mace AH 319 173 221 104Tammarin Rock AH 118 114Yitpi AH -173 -86 -51AGT Katana APW 145 84 77Corack APW 270 593 36Correll APW -200Envoy APW 7 -278






Espada APW 93 43 132 14Estoc APW -82 -282Fang APW -407Gladius APW -32 6Harper APWMagenta APW 6 -22 197 110Scout APW -200 -462 -84Trojan APWWestonia APW 221 106 286 31Wyalkatchem APW 207 118 127 93Young APW 121 66Zippy APW 272 191 -30Clearfield STL APW-imi -157 -293Grenade CL Plus APW-imi -309 -22Impose CL Plus APW-imi 151 158 -74Justica CL Plus APW-imi -91 -287 -1Bullaring ASFT -36 -46Kunjin ASFT 171 68 296 4Wedin ASFT -193 -344 84Arrino ASWN 258 146 264Binnu ASWN 289 136Calingiri ASWN -119 -69 -39 79Fortune ASWN -106 -54 -87 49Yandanooka ASWN -119 -46 -69 20

Table 15 Location details for NVT’s at Narembeen in 2009, 2010, 2011 and 2013

Location details Narembeen in 2009 Narembeen in 2010 Narembeen in 2011 Narembeen in 2013Sowing Date 31/05/2009 7/05/2011 22/05/2012 10/05/2013

GSR (May – Oct) mm 228.7 268.9 141.7 276.1

pH CaCl2 at 10cm 4.3 5.5 5 5.3

pH CaCl2 at 60cm 5 4.4 4.5 4.1

Previous Crop Pasture spray topped Pasture spray topped Canola Pasture spray topped


Table 16 Production value (kg/ha) of wheat varieties and their classification at Narembeen in 2009, 2011, 2012 and 2013



Production value at Narembeen 2009




Carnamah AH -103 -24 -192Cascades AH -177Cobra AH 155 242EGA Bonnie Rock AH 99 144 89 -100Emu Rock AH 118 210 -158King Rock AH 113 152 84Mace AH 175 228 327 66Tammarin Rock AH 105Yitpi AH -11 24 -4AGT Katana APW 49 50 110Corack APW 352 180 -15Correll APW -53Envoy APW 214 59 232Espada APW 1 40 12 41






Estoc APW -118 60Fang APW -167Gladius APW -43Harper APW 83Magenta APW -79 8 -107 278Scout APW 91 -134 131 57Trojan APW -210Westonia APW 50 137 43 38Wyalkatchem APW 133 173 247 24Young APW 57Zippy APW 193 126Clearfield STL APW-imi -182 -90Grenade CL Plus APW-imi -184 50 -87Impose CL Plus APW-imi 133 176 321Justica CL Plus APW-imi -142 35 29Bullaring ASFT 61Kunjin ASFT -41 34 -45 139Wedin ASFT -231 -51 317Arrino ASWN 77 163 39Binnu ASWN 151Calingiri ASWN -83 -68 -60 168Fortune ASWN -103 -123 11 154Yandanooka ASWN -142 -125 -59 -19

Table 17 Location details for NVT’s at Pithara between 2009, 2011, 2012 and 2013

Location details Pithara in 2009 Pithara in 2011 Pithara 2012 Pithara in 2013Sowing Date 30/05/2009 22/05/2011 7/06/2012 25/05/2013

GSR (May – Oct) mm NA NA NA 260.7

pH CaCl2 at 10cm 6.4 6.1 5.4 7.2

pH CaCl2 at 60cm 7.7 7.3 6.7 7.7

Previous Crop NA NA NA Pasture cut for hay/silage


Table 18 Production value (kg/ha) of wheat varieties and their classification at Pithara between 2009, 2011, 2012 and 2013



Production value at Pithara 2009




Carnamah AH 10 -44 -156Cascades AH -181Cobra AH 66 60EGA Bonnie Rock AH 53 121 -28 54Emu Rock AH 129 208 49King Rock AH 59 129 -47Mace AH 144 192 223 86Tammarin Rock AH -45Yitpi AH -47 104 -41AGT Katana APW 111 59 128Corack APW 272 6 135Correll APW -66Envoy APW 60 91 141






Espada APW 55 24 17 13Estoc APW -77 142Fang APW -210Gladius APW 16Harper APWMagenta APW -31 -41 -94 -4Scout APW -4 -71 201 -25Trojan APW -257Westonia APW 114 97 -14 50Wyalkatchem APW 67 147 145 63Young APW 136Zippy APW 246 198Clearfield STL APW-imi -154 -4Grenade CL Plus APW-imi -118 205 -77Impose CL Plus APW-imi -54 206 156Justica CL Plus APW-imi -99 130 -53Bullaring ASFT 29Kunjin ASFT 137 4 21 12Wedin ASFT -202 98 -88Arrino ASWN 133 143 -57Binnu ASWN 155Calingiri ASWN -100 -77 -18 -33Fortune ASWN -52 -105 149 -53Yandanooka ASWN -92 -100 59 -62

Table 19 Location details for NVT’s at Wyalkatchem between 2009, 2010, 2011 and 2013

Location details Wyalkatchem in 2009

Wyalkatchem in 2010

Wyalkatchem 2011 Wyalkatchem in 2012

Sowing Date 2/06/2009 2/06/2010 21/05/2011 9/06/2012

GSR (May – Oct) mm 247 107 234 152

pH CaCl2 at 10cm 5.3 4.8 5.2 5

pH CaCl2 at 60cm 7.1 5.8 5.5 5

Previous Crop Pasture spray topped Grassy pasture Pasture cut for hay/silage

Grassy pasture


Table 20 Production value (kg/ha) of wheat varieties and their classification at Wyalkatchem between 2009, 2010, 2011 and 2013


Variety Classification Production value at Wyalkatchem 2009

Production value at Wyalkatchem 2010



Carnamah AH 0 -20 -16 -42Cascades AH -124 -178Cobra AH -51 204EGA Bonnie Rock AH 49 34 141 7

Emu Rock AH 169 134 122King Rock AH 59 28 158 5Mace AH 145 147 214 130Tammarin Rock AH -60 116Yitpi AH -58 -25 10AGT Katana APW 53 99 56 70Corack APW 178 394 127Correll APW -97

Variety Classification Production value at Wyalkatchem 2009




Envoy APW 57 104 68Espada APW 48 40 45 31Estoc APW -15 -109 32Fang APW -204Gladius APW -71 45Harper APWMagenta APW 40 -37 5 -10Scout APW -1 -82 70Trojan APW -37Westonia APW 109 69 151 49Wyalkatchem APW 79 87 149 72Young APW 61 84Zippy APW 21 163 167Clearfield STL APW-imi -111 -213 -68Grenade CL Plus APW-imi -242 -8Impose CL Plus APW-imi -136 88 53 -47Justica CL Plus APW-imi -28 -167 -4Bullaring ASFT 87 -17Kunjin ASFT 114 81 65 75Wedin ASFT -104 -255 -20Arrino ASWN 67 85 170 13Binnu ASWN 153 26Calingiri ASWN -48 -55 -94 -32Fortune ASWN -50 14 -154 28Yandanooka ASWN -117 -5 -180 -37

AcknowledgementsWe acknowledge GRDC funded ‘Statistics for the Australian Grains Industry’s (SAGI’s) contribution in the presentation of results in this report. In addition appreciation of the GRDC for their financial support of the Department of Agriculture and Food, Western Australia’s wheat agronomy project DAW00218 which has enabled the collaboration with SAGI.

Further informationWhen using PVs for variety selection decisions it is recommended that you consider not just a single environment, but a number of environments, both in terms of location (trial site) and season (trial year). This gives an indication of the stability of a varieties performance over a range of condition

The locations displayed are based on the agzone however additional sites may have been included as they will have relevance from a regional or district perspective.

To identify the type of environment experienced at that site and year, additional information for each NVT site has been provided. At present the trial sowing date, growing season rainfall, previous crop history and soil pH are reported.

Site correlation is a relativity measure that is included in the reporting. It indicates how the variety ranking of the trial resembles neighbouring trial result rankings within the current region and year.

Important disclaimerThe Chief Executive Officer of the Department of Agriculture and Food and the State of Western Australia accept no liability whatsoever by reason of negligence or otherwise arising from the use or release of this information or any part of it.

Copyright © Western Australian Agriculture Authority, 2014

Summary€¦ · Web view146 264 Binnu ASWN 289 136 Calingiri ASWN-119-69-39 79 Fortune...

Documents

Transcript of Summary€¦ · Web view146 264 Binnu ASWN 289 136 Calingiri ASWN-119-69-39 79 Fortune...