Summary of Amendments to National Food Security Bill Proposed by the political parties

7/30/2019 Summary of Amendments to National Food Security Bill Proposed by the political parties

1/5

Summary of amendments to

National Food Security Bill,

proposed by the differentpolitical parties


2/5

Coverage under PDS1. Shri S. Semmalai-

AIADMK/Tamilnadu(Salem)

2. Dr. M. Thambidurai-AIADMK/Tamilnadu(Karur)

3. Dr. MurliManohar Joshi-BJP/UP-(Varanasi)

. the entire population

4.Adv. A Sampath CPI-M/Kerala(Attingal)

5.Prof. Sk. SaidulHaque CPI-M/West

Bengal(Bardhaman-Durgapur)

6.Shri P.Karunakaran CPI-M(Kerala-

Kasaragod)

... to the entire population with the exception of

income taxpayees

1. ShriGurudasDasgupta(CPI/WestBengal(Ghatal)

1. ShriPrabodh Panda CPI(WestBengal-Medinipur)

2. ShriHarinPathak(Gujarat-Ahmedabad-East)

3. Shri M.B. Rajesh CPI-M(Kerala-Palkadd)

4.

to every resident of India

5. Shri T.R. Baalu-DMK/Tamilnadu(Sriperambudur)

Provided that allocation of foodgrains to states

with Universal PDS shall continue.

6. Dr.Ramachandra Dome-CPI-M/West Bengal(Bolpur)

Automatic inclusion in priority/AAY for SC,

ST, tribals, social and educationally backward

classes, landless/migrant/unorganised sector

labourers.

Automatic exclusion for constitutional posts,

Government/PSU/Armed forces, agricultural

holdings and plantations and annual family

income of more than 4.5 lakhs.7. Prof. Saugata Roy-Trinamool

Congress/ West Bengal(Dum-dum)

upto 90% of rural and 75% of urban

population

8. ShriShailendra Kumar-SamajwadiParty/ UP(Kausambhi)

upto 80% of rural and 75% of urban

population

9. ShriBhartruhariMahtab-Biju JantaDal/ Odisha(Katak)

to all priority households (no percentage

caps)

11.Smt. SushmaSwaraj-BJP/ MP-

(Vidisha)

to all priority households (no percentage

caps)

Automatic inclusion of all SC/ST persons.

Dal-tel-35 kilo

Adv. A Sampath-CPI-M/ CPI-

M/Kerala(Attingal)

Prof. Sk. SaidulHaque-CPI-M/ West

Bengal(Bardhaman-Durgapur)

seven kilo per person or 35 kilo per

household whichever is higher, and adequate

quantities of sugar, pulses and cooking oil

2. ShriPrasanta Kumar five kg cereals, two kg pulses and one liter


3/5

Majumdar(Revolutionary Socialist

Party/West Bengal(Balurghat)

of oil to BPL/priority

35kg cereals, five kg pulses and two liters

oil to AAY

3. Prof. Saugata Roy(TrinamoolCongress/West Bengal(Dum-dum)

seven kg foodgrains, two kg pulses and one

kg cooking oil

4. ShriGurudasDasgupta(CPI/WestBengal(Ghatal)

5. ShriPrabodh Panda35 kg foodgrains per family, one and half kg

pulses and 800 gms of cookin oil per person

per month

6. ShriShailendra Kumar-SP/UP(Kausambhi)

eight kg foodgrains and adequate quantity of

sugar, pulses and edible oil per person per

monthfree of costto priority households

fifty kg to AAY

7. Smt. HarsimratKaurBadal-AkaliDal/Punjab(Bathinda)

five kg (as earlier) andone kg pulses per

person..

8. Dr. MurliManohar Joshi-BJP/UP-(Varanasi)

ten kg of foodgrains, two and half kg pulses

and 900 gms of cooking oil

No cash transfer

4. Adv. A Sampath-CPI-M/Kerala(Attingal)

5. Prof. Sk. SaidulHaque-CPI-M/WestBengal(Bardhaman-Durgapur)

6. ShriGurudasDasgupta/CPI(WestBengal-Ghatal)

7. ShriPrabodh Panda/CPI(WestBengal-Medinipur)

8. Smt. SushmaSwaraj-BJP/MP-(Vidisha)9. Shri P. Karunakaran/CPI-M(Kerala-Kasaragod)

Delete reforms on aadhaar and cash transfer.

10.ShriHarinPathak/BJP(Gujarat-Ahmedabad-East)

11.Shri M.B. Rajesh/CPI-M(Kerala-Palkadd)

12.Smt. SushmaSwaraj BJP(MP-Vidisha)

13.Dr. MurliManohar Joshi-BJP/UP-(Varanasi)

Delete definition of food security allowance

14.Smt. HarsimratKaurBadal- AkaliDal/Punjab(Bathinda)

Delete cash transfer, food coupons fromreforms.

Destitute-homeless-starvation

15.Adv. A Sampath- CPI-M/Kerala(Attingal)

16.Prof. Sk. SaidulHaque- CPI-M/West Bengal(Bardhaman-

Durgapur)

17.Shri P. Karunakaran- CPI-M(Kerala-Kasaragod)

Central Government to fund scheme to provide

one free meal every day to destitute

1. Shri Sanjay Dhotre-BJP/Maharashtra(Akola)

Two free meals to destitute and affordable

meals to homeless

2. ShriBhartruhariMahtab- - Two free meals to destitute


4/5

BJD/Odisha(Katak) - Affordable meals at communitykitchens to homeless

- Minimum 20 kg foodgrains tohouseholds with senior citizens

- Minimum 15 kg per person to AAYhouseholds and SC/ST hostels

- Two free meals upto three months inemergency or disaster situations

18.ShriHarinPathak- BJP(Gujarat-Ahmedabad-East)

19.Shri M. B. Rajesh- CPI-M(Kerala-Palkadd)

Same as the Campaign draft

ICDS


21.Prof. Sk. SaidulHaque- CPI-M/West Bengal(Bardhaman-Durgapur)

22.Smt. SushmaSwaraj- BJP/MP-(Vidisha)

23.Dr. MurliManohar Joshi- BJP/UP-(Varanasi)

24.Shri P. Karunakaran- CPI-M/Kerala-(Kasaragod)

Delete ready to eat meal from Schedule II

(THR and note 1, note 2 and N.B. remain)

25.ShriGurudasDasgupta- CPI(WestBengal-Ghatal)26.ShriPrabodh Panda- CPI(WestBengal-Medinipur)

- All six ICDS services-

No private contractor shall beengaged

- Preference shall be given to womensSHGs etc.

- Sections on malnourished children fromthe NAC draft


28.Shri M.B. Rajesh- CPI-M(Kerala-Palkadd)

- All six ICDS services- No private contractor shall be

engaged

- Preference shall be given to womensSHGs etc.

- Sections on malnourished children fromthe NAC draft- Provisions for out of school children

no child shall be denied.

- Delete Note 1, Note 2 and N.B. fromschedule II

MSP for farmers


30.Prof. Sk. SaidulHaque- CPI-M/West Bengal(Bardhaman-

Durgapur)

Definition of MSP as 1.5 times cost of

production


5/5

31.ShriGurudasDasgupta- CPI(WestBengal-Ghatal)

32.ShriPrabodh Panda- CPI(WestBengal-Medinipur)

33.Shri P. Karunakaran- CPI-M(Kerala-Kasaragod)


35.Shri M.B. Rajesh- CPI-M(Kerala-Palkadd)

- Definition of MSP as 1.5 times cost ofproduction

- Central Government shall buy at MSPat procurement centers at every for

every 10 kms radius area.

Summary of Amendments to National Food Security Bill Proposed by the political parties

Documents

Transcript of Summary of Amendments to National Food Security Bill Proposed by the political parties