7/31/2019 Suggestions for Ammendments in New CCIM Gazette

1/3

Dr. Chaudhari M anojkumar Vitthalrao,

Asst. Professor, Dept. of Sanskrit Sam hita Siddhanta,

Ashtang Ayurved College, 2062, Sadashiv Peth,

Pune 411 030 (M aharashtra)

Date: 18thM ay 2012

To,

Hon. Vd. P.R. Sharma

The Secretary,

Central Council of Indian M edicine,

New Delhi

Email: indiaccim@ gm ail.com

Subject: Request to change the pattern of marks for Theory/Practical of

Dept. of Sanskrit Sam hita Siddhanta

Ref.: The Gazette of India: Extraordinary, Part III Section 4, Regd. No.

D.L.-33004/99, No. 108, Published on 26thApril 2012.

Respected Sir,

Our esteem Institute CCIM , Delhi is continuously working for progress of

Ayurveda. As per above m entioned Subject & reference, I want to focus

your kind attention on following facts & hence want to suggest major

changes about Dept. of Sanskrit Samhita Siddhantas pattern of marks for

Theory/Practical -

1. Our aims & Objects are to provide The Bachelor of Ayurved

education, having profound knowledge of Ashtang Ayurved. Dept. of

Sanskrit Sam hita Siddhanta is the basic foundation of all other

Departments. But in new Gazette, the potential of Dept. of Sanskrit

Sam hita Siddhanta is under estimated. Because, the Practical/Oralexam . of only this Dept. are omitted. W hy not for other Dept.?

2. Charak Samhita, Sushrut Samhita, Ashtang Sangraha & Hridaya

Samhita are main texts of Ayurveda. The accurate knowledge of these

texts can not be gain without the knowledge of Sanskrit language. If

we are not going to assess the student partly by theory & partly by

7/31/2019 Suggestions for Ammendments in New CCIM Gazette

2/3

Oral; the future students will be poor in the knowledge of original

Samhitas. There will be no recitation of Shlokas & ourselves we will

kill the roots of Ayurved.

3. Ayurveda needs to achieve its full potential both in India and globally.

This requires imparting to its students full appreciation of Ayurveda's

power and strength, particularly proper understanding of the

advantages of applying it to treat chronic and acute diseases. To this

end, we explain the necessity of learning Sanskrit and the advantages

of learning the Texts in the traditional way, rather than relying on

translations with all the loss of meaning and precision, which that

entails.

4. Oral examination is an exam ination conducted by spoken

communication. There are a variety of circumstances where the vivavoce exam ination is used as a form of assessment. Generally, use of

the viva voce can be considered under two categories, as under noted:

(i) Oral Examination might form part of the validated assessment for a

course, For exam ple, extended pieces of work such as

dissertations/projects/theses m ay be partly assessed by an oral

exam ination. In these situations, the viva voce is a useful tool to assist

in authenticating that the work is that of the student. External

Examiners are sometimes involved in these planned viva voce

exam inations.

(ii) Oral exam inations have been used to help determine difficult or

borderline cases; the outcomes should be discussed at the relevant

Assessment Panel.

Hence, we request to am end the following changes in the gazette about the

pattern of marks for Theory/Practical of Dept. of Sanskrit Sam hita Siddhanta

1. 1stProfessional Year

a) Padarth Vigyan evam Ayurved ka Itihas Practical of 50 marksshould be included.

b) Sanskrit Practical of 50 m arks should be included

c) M aulik Siddhant evam Ashtang Hridaya (Sutrasthana) Practical

of 50 marks should be included.

2. 2ndProfessional Year

7/31/2019 Suggestions for Ammendments in New CCIM Gazette

3/3

Charak Samhita (Puravardha) Practical of 50 marks should be

included.

3. 3rdProfessional Year

Charak Samhita (Uttarardha) - Practical of 50 marks should be

included.

Yours sincerely,

Dr. Chaudhari M anojkumar Vitthalrao

Copy to

1. Smt. Pratibha Devisingh Patil, President of India, Rashtrapati Bhavan,

New Delhi - Your Request/Grievance has been registered vide

Registration number PRSEC/E/2012/07287.

2. Vaidya Raghunandan Sharma,

President, C.C.I.M ., Jawahar Lal Nehru Bhartiya Chikitsa Avam

Homoeopathy Anusandhan Bhawan,

61-65, Institutional Area, Janakpuri,

New Delhi-110058

Email : ccimpresident@ gm ail.com

3. Dr. M anoj Nesari, Joint Adviser (Ay) DEPARTM ENT OF AYUSH,

M inistry of Health & Family W elfare

IRCS BUILDINGS (M AIN & ANNEXE)

RED CROSS ROAD, NEW DELHI 110001

Email - ayushdept@ gm ail.com

4. Dr. Arun Jamkar, Hon. Vice-Chancellor, M aharashtra University of

Health Sciences, Nashik

Email -vc@ muhsnashik.com

5. Dr. Sunil Fugare, Dy. Registrar, Academ ic Council, M aharashtraUniversity of Health Sciences, Nashik

Eamil -academic@ muhsnashik.com

6. Dr. Adinath N. Suryakar, Registrar, M aharashtra University of Health

Sciences, Nashik

Eamil -registrar@ muhsnashik.com