Submission

doc.: IEEE 11-13/0789r0July 2013

Jon Rosdahl, CSR Technology Inc.Slide 1

802.11 Review of March 2013 Proposed Pars

Date: 2013-03-18

Name Affiliations Address Phone email Jon Rosdahl CSR

Technology Inc. 10871 N 5750 W Highland, UT

801-492-4023 jrosdahl@ieee.rog

Bruce Kraemer Marvell

Authors:

Submission

doc.: IEEE 11-13/0789r0July 2013

Jon Rosdahl, CSR Technology Inc.Slide 2

Abstract

Review of 802 WG PARS submitted for review during the July 2013 Session.

Submission

doc.: IEEE 11-13/0789r0July 2013

Jon Rosdahl, CSR Technology Inc.Slide 3

PARs under considerationJuly 1x-1x, 2013, Geneva, Switzerland802.1Qcc - amendment for Stream Reservation Protocol

(SRP), PAR and 5C 802.1Qcd - amendment for Application Virtual Local Area

Networks (VLAN) Type, Length, Value (TLV), PAR and 5C

802.3br - amendment for Specification and Management Parameters for Interspersing Express Traffic, PAR and 5C

802.15.10 - recommended practice on Layer 2 Routing, PAR and 5C

P802.19.1 - PAR Extension

Submission

doc.: IEEE 11-13/0789r0

Jon Rosdahl, CSR Technology Inc.

802.1QccPARIn general the PAR is written by and for a community already knowledgeable in 802.1Q. One of the

purposes of a PAR is to advertise the start of a new project to a broad community.802.11 members can not read the PAR and determine the scope.Configuration stream wording is confusingWhat is the current stream limit. What will the new limit be?What types of layer three support do you plan to offerDo you plan to issue a press release if the project is approved. How would you describe the project

in a press release?8.1 is empty. Could some of the 5C material be used to further explain the project?

5CTechnical feasibilityWhat is the Avnu Alliance and what is its relationship to 802.1Q?Did Avnu supply use cases or requirements that could be refernced/made available?What does C mean?What assumptions are being made of 802.11 and its ability to participate in SRP?

Slide 4

July 2013

Submission

doc.: IEEE 11-13/0789r0

Jon Rosdahl, CSR Technology Inc.

802.1QcdPARDoes IETF provide any similar VLAN tag?How does VLAN tag simplify mamnagemnt?

5CSlide 6 Please define the scope of “end stations” or provide some examples.The 5C alternately claims that Qcd will simplify network managemment and

end station managem,ennt – which is it?

Slide 5

July 2013

Submission

doc.: IEEE 11-13/0789r0

Jon Rosdahl, CSR Technology Inc.

802.15.10

PARSection 5.4What L3 mechanisms are to be considered?

Section 8.1 Clarify the relationship between 15.4e and 15.10. Are there any new functions being added by 15.10? Does 15.10 use only features previously defined by 15.4e?

Is 15.10 for use only with 15.4 based networks?Should the project be called 802.15.10 or 802.15.4.1?

5C

Slide 6

July 2013

Submission

doc.: IEEE 11-13/0789r0

Jon Rosdahl, CSR Technology Inc.

802.3brPARIs there any dependency between 802.1Qbu and 802.3br?Please explain what “interspersed express traffic” is.

5CDistict Identity (slide 5) What does close to zero delay on converged networks mean?

Slide 7

July 2013

Submission

doc.: IEEE 11-13/0789r0

Jon Rosdahl, CSR Technology Inc.

802.19.1 extensionPARWhy is 802.11af not mentioned?

5C

Slide 8

July 2013