Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge...

27
Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Transcript of Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge...

Page 1: Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy

Project

Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory)

Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Page 2: Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Briefing Outline

A brief history of spectroscopy of pulsating variables

The present knowledge of pulsating variables Earlier Work Present Activities Future Work How You Can Help Q & A

Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory)

Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Page 3: Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

A brief history of spectroscopy of pulsating variables cont. The H-R Diagram - Refresher

Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory)

Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Page 4: Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

A brief history of spectroscopy of pulsating variables cont. Early Oxygen I Studies

a) ε Aur Ia

b) α Leo Ib

c) ζ Leo III

d) γ Vir V

ApJ, 111, 1, 1-10 (1950)

Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory)

Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Page 5: Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

A brief history of spectroscopy of pulsating variables cont.

Partially Resolved O I Triplet in a Supergiant Ia Star

Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory)

Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Page 6: Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

A brief history of spectroscopy of pulsating variables Variables defined mostly from brightness Cycles. Pulsating variables cycle also in temperature /

spectral type. An O I triplet feature noted by Merrill (1934) and

Keenan and Hynek (1950) as unusually strong and dependent on temp/spectral type and luminosity class.

Cepheids and RR Lyrae are in the zones of interest. Keenan suggested study of O I triplet (λ7771-7775) in

testing of S-1 image tubes in 1962. Osmer and Parsons explore detection of A-F

supergiants and Cepheids in nearby galaxies with λ7774 features (1964-1972).

Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory)

Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Page 7: Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

A brief history of spectroscopy of pulsating variables (cont.)

O I Luminosity Effects - Epoch (1950)W

Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory)

Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Page 8: Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

A brief history of spectroscopy of pulsating variables (cont.)

Early 1N film and S-1 image tube data (1960s)

Page 9: Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

A brief history of spectroscopy of pulsating variables (cont.)

O I Energy Levels Producing λ7774 Triplet

Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory)

Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Page 10: Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

A brief history of spectroscopy of pulsating variables (cont.)

Cosmological Occurrence of Pulsation Instability Zones

Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory)

Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Page 11: Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

A brief history of spectroscopy of pulsating variables (cont.)

Cepheid and RR Lyrae Pulsation Zones

Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory)

Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Page 12: Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

A brief history of spectroscopy of pulsating variables (cont.)

Changes of the Oxygen Triplet Vs. Temperature/Spectral Type

Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory)

Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Page 13: Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

The present knowledge of pulsating variables

Pulsation parameters Brightness Vs. phase Temperature Vs. phase Radial velocity Vs. phase Stellar radius Vs. phase

Yet-to-be established parameters O I Triplet strength Vs. phase Spectral-type Vs. phase

Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory)

Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Page 14: Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Earlier Work

Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory)

Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Page 15: Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Present Activities

1960 – 1980 Film and Image Tube work required use of 1.5 – 3.5 meter telescopes to exploit the λ7774 feature. This required good justifications for durations of telescope time needed.

21st century – CCD detectors – most sensitive of these wavelengths will allow use of advanced amateur facilities.

2006 – Began augmentations of Dark Ridge Observatory equipped with an SBIG SGS spectrograph for detailed study of bright Cepheids.

2007 – Initial spectra collected at Dark Ridge Observatory, California site, prior to relocation to New Mexico.

Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory)

Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Page 16: Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Present Activities (Cont.)

Luminosity Effects Using Different MeasuresW

Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory)

Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Page 17: Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Present Activities (Cont.)

Current: initial complications are being worked to resolve best resolution and wavelength calibration issues.

2007 through 2008: Seek to define temperature/feature strength trajectories on HR diagram.

Seek to add O I Triplet feature-strength plot (W versus phase) to existing Cepheid pulsation plots.

Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory)

Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Page 18: Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Present Activities (Cont.)

Early SGS Activation/Testing

Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory)

Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Page 19: Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Future Work (Part 1)

Luminosity Effects: Standard + Variables

Cep

T Mon

Aqlζ Gem

FF Aql

Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory)

Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Page 20: Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Future Work (Part 2)

Enhanced Cepheid pulsation plots

0 0.5 1.0

O I

Eq

. W

Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory)

Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Page 21: Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Future Work (Part 3)

O I Triplet Velocity Vs. Photosphere Velocity

A new challenge that must be explored.

Should permit atmospheric pulsation models to identify the height in the stellar atmosphere of the Oxygen that is producing the triplet.

It is unknown if amateur equipment and capabilities are capable of providing the required data. This requires the ability to measure the Doppler shift of the O I Triplet.

Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory)

Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Page 22: Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Dark Ridge Observatory (DRO)

Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory)

Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Page 23: Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

DRO Cont.

Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory)

Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Page 24: Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

DRO Cont.

Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory)

Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Page 25: Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

How You Can Help

Contribute spectral observations if equipped with high-resolution grating system

( Cephei and others)

Monitor V, Rc, Ic photometry to assure the zero point of the phase.

Contribute spectral observations at lower resolutions along with standard star spectra to determine spectral-types during the cycle.

Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory)

Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Page 26: Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Target List

TABLE I. Cepheid Characteristics for Candidate Program StarsMagnitude

TABLE I. Cepheid Characteristics for Candidate Program Stars

Name Right Ascension Declination Magnitude Epoch Period Spectral Type h m s ° ‘ “ max min (2400000+) d======= ============= =========== ========= ========== ====== =============T Mon 06 25 37.3 +07 04 52 5.58 6.62 43784.615 27.025 F7Iab-KIIabRT Aur 06 29 03.0 +30 29 16 5.00 5.82 42361.155 3.728 F4Ib-G1I Gem 07 04 33.2 +20 33 31 3.62 4.18 43805.927 10.151 F7Ib-G3Ib-G1IbX Sgr 17 48 02.0 -29 49 59 4.20 4.90 40741.70 7.013 F5-G2IIW Sgr 18 05 30.0 -29 34 45 4.29 5.14 43374.77 7.595 F4-G2IbY Sgr 18 21 49.5 -18 51 22 5.25 6.24 40762.38 5.773 F5-G0Ib -IIFF Aql 18 58 34.8 +17 22 17 5.18 5.68 41576.428 4.471 F5Ia-F8Ia Aql 19 52 51.3 +01 01 31 3.48 4.39 36084.656 7.177 F6Ib-G4IbS Sge 19 56 21.7 +16 39 18 5.24 6.04 42678.792 8.382 F6Ib-G5IbX Cyg 20 43 41.8 +35 36 54 5.85 6.91 43830.387 16.386 F7Ib-G8IbT Vul 20 51 47.4 +28 16 44 5.41 6.09 41705.121 4.435 F5Ib-G0IbCep 22 29 27.1 +58 27 13 3.48 4.37 36075.445 5.366 F5Ib-G1Ib

======= ============= ========== ========= ========== ====== =============RR Lyr 19 25 42.3 +42 47 57 7.06 8.12 50238.499 0.567 A5.0-F7.0

Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory)

Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Page 27: Study of Cepheid Variables as a Joint Near IR Spectroscopy Project Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory) Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)

Q & A

Don’t Be Shy!

For information regarding how you can assist in this rediscovered project:

http://www.darkridgeobservatory.org

Thomas C. Smith (Dark Ridge Observatory)

Kenneth E. Kissell (Kissell Consultants)