Stripe Rust Epidemics and Control in
Click here to load reader
-
Upload
harding-mercer -
Category
Documents
-
view
50 -
download
0
description
Transcript of Stripe Rust Epidemics and Control in
Stripe Rust Epidemics and Control inStripe Rust Epidemics and Control in
XIANMING CHEN, David Wood, Laura Penman, Peng Ling and Meinan Wang 1USDA-ARS Wheat Genetics, Quality, Physiology and Disease Research Unit and 2Department of Plant
Pathology, Washington State University, Pullman, WA 99164-6430 ([email protected])
Barley Stripe Rust(Puccinia striiformis f. sp. hordei)
WA
OR ID
MT
NV
WY
UT
AZ NM
OK
KS
SD WI
IA
MO
AR
LA
IL IN
MI
OH
KY
TN
MS AL GA
SC
VA
NC
WV
PA
NY
MDDE
NJ
ME
NHVT
MACT
NC
ND
MN
TX
NE
CO
2000
WA
OR
CA
ID
MT
NV
WY
UT
AZ NM
OK
KS
SD WI
IA
MO
AR
LA
IL IN
MI
OH
KY
TN
MS AL GA
FL
SC
VA
NC
WV
PA
NY
MDDE
NJ
ME
NHVT
MACT
NC
ND
MN
TX
NE
CO
2001FL
WA
OR
CA
ID
MT
NV
WY
UT
AZ NM
OK
KS
SD WI
IA
MO
AR
LA
IL IN
MI
OH
KY
TN
MS AL GA
FL
SC
VA
NC
WV
PA
NY
MDDE
NJ
ME
NHVT
MACT
NC
ND
MN
TX
NE
CO
2002
Barley Stripe Rust
1991
19921992
1992
1993
1993
1993
19941994
1995
1995
Spread in 1991-95 Distributions in 2000-2005
FLWA
OR
CA
ID
MT
NV
WY
UT
AZ NM
OK
KS
SD WI
IA
MO
AR
LA
IL IN
MI
OH
KY
TN
MS AL GA
FL
SC
VA
NC
WV
PA
NY
MDDE
NJ
ME
NHVT
MACT
NC
ND
MN
TX
NE
CO
2003 - 2005
Trace –20%
Severe (>20%)
Wheat Stripe Rust Epidemics
WA
OR
CA
ID
MT
NV
WY
UT
AZ
CO
NM
TX
OK
KS
NE
SD
NDMN
WI
IA
MO
AR
LA
IL IN
MI
OH
KYTN
MSAL GA
FL
SC
VAWV
PANY
MDDENJ
MENH
VT
MACT
NC
2000
WA
OR
CA
ID
MT
NV
WY
UT
AZ
CO
NM
TX
OK
KS
NE
SD
NDMN
WI
IA
MO
AR
LA
IL IN
MI
OH
KYTN
MSAL GA
FL
SC
VAWV
PANY
MDDENJ
MENH
VT
MACT
NC
2002
WA
CA
MT
NV
WY
UT
AZ NMOK
KS
NE
SD
IA
MO
AR
LA
ILIN
MI
OH
KYTN
MSALGA
FL
SC
VA
NC
WV
PANY
VT
MA
NC
NDMN
TX
SD
NE
CO KS
OK AR
MO
IA
LAMSAL
TNKY
IL
ID
2001
ORWI
MD NJDE
CT
ME
NH
2003WA
CA
MT
NV
WY
UT
AZ NM NC
PANY
VT
MA
CO
IDOR
MD NJDE
CT
ME
NHMI
NC
VA
FL
SC
WVIN
KSOH
KYTN
AL GA
OK
TX
AR
LA
MO
MS
SD
NDMN
WI
NE IAIL
Trace (1-20%)Severe (>20%)
Germplasm EvaluationIn every year, more than 13,000 wheat and 5,000 barley entries were evaluated in the fields and/or greenhousefor rust resistance. The data were used to determine
provided to breeders for developing resistant cultivars.genetics of and mapping genes for resistance and were
• Germplasm nurseries• Regional nurseries• Individual breeder’s nurseries• Genetic populations
• Germplasm nurseries• Regional nurseries• Individual breeder’s nurseries• Genetic populations
Wheat Stripe RustPuccinia striiformis f. sp. tritici
Wheat Stripe Rust Epidemic in 2005
Places fromwhich striperust werecollected.
Stripe rustoccurredwithin theregion.
Wheat Stripe Rust Epidemic in 2004
WA
CA
MT
NV
WY
UT
AZNM
NC
PA
NY
VT
MA
CO
IDOR
MD NJ
DE
CT
ME
NH
NC
VA
SC
WV
ND
MN
KS
OK
TX
AR
LA
MO
MS
SD
NEIA
FL
KY
GA
IN
TN
AL
IL
WI
MI
OH
Trace (1-20%)Severe (>20%)
1,3PST-31964
1,3,11PST-381987
1,3,12 PST-221981
1,3,11,12PST-421990
PST-591998 1,3,11,12,16
1,3,8,11,12,16,17,18,19,20 PST-802000
PST-972002
1,3,10,11,12,16,17,18,19,20
PST-982002
1,3,8,10,11,12,16,17,18,19,20
2003
1,3,8,9,10,11,12,14,16,17,18,19,201,3,8,9,10,11,12,14,16,17,18,19,20
PST-782000 1,3,11,12,16,17,18,19,20
1,3,9,11,12,16,17,18,19,20 PST-992002
PST-100PST-101 1,2,3,8,9,10,11,12,16,17,18,19,20
PST-102
2003
PST-1141,3,5,8,9,10,11,12,14,16,17,18,19,20
PST-113
1,3,4,8,9,10,11,12,14,16,17,18,19,20
1,3,8,9,10,11,12,16,17,18,19,20
1,3,5,8,9,10,11,12,16,17,18,19,20 PST-1111,2,3,8,9,10,11,12,14,16,17,18,19,201,2,3,8,9,10,11,12,14,16,17,18,19,20
PST-115
2003
2004
2004
2004
2004
PST-116 1,3,4,5,8,9,10,11,12,14,16,17,18,19,202005
12345678
LemhiChinese 166Heines VIIMoroPahaDruchamp
Produra9
10YamhillStephens
Yr5
1112131415
Lee Fielder TyeeTresHyak
16 Express 17 Yr818 Yr919 Clement 20 Compair
Wheat DifferentialsEvolutionary relationshipsof new racesof the wheatstripe rustpathogen
the United States From 2000 to 2004the United States From 2000 to 2004
Puccinia striiformis f. sp. tritici cDNA Library and Gene IdentificationPuccinia striiformis f. sp. tritici cDNA Library and Gene Identification
1.0E-09NeurosporacrassaRelated to stress response protein rds1pgi1837631360I14
1.0E-100Cryptococcus neoformansTransaldolasegi5722999130K8
1.0E-102NeurosporacrassaATP synthasealpha chain gbEAA36409.155E23
1.0E-124Cryptococcus neoformansH3/H4 histoneacetyltransferasegi57228180 65I3
1.0E-13SchizosaccharomycespombeTransthyretingi358190480G10
1.0E-134Aspergillus fumigatusCalnexingi45551624 60J23
1.0E-137Cryptococcus neoformansSuccinatedehydrogenaseflavoproteingi57228890 30N15
1.0E-143AlternariaalternataEnolasegi601509490H16
1.0E-149Cryptococcus neoformansUDP-glucose dehydrogenasegi4256371765M2
1.0E-160Cryptococcus neoformansGlycinehydroxymethyltransferase,gi5722934765N4
1.0E-22Cryptococcus neoformansSpermidinesynthasegi5722802258D15
1.0E-57Cryptococcus neoformansdiphosphatekinasegi57227197 65M20
1E-040Ustilagomaydisthreoninekinasereceptor EAK84204.170E5
2.0E-07Saccharomyces cerevisiaeGPI transamidasecomponentgi731758 60N1
3.0E-29UstilagomaydisRac1 GTP binding proteingi2166751680F12
3.0E-33Cryptococcus neoformansgi50255528 65G21
3.0E-35Schizosaccharomycespombegi1911577155N13
3.0E-85PneumocystiscariniiTATA binding proteingbAAA79367.158E6
3.80E-01DebaryomyceshanseniiSerine/threonine-protein kinaseCBK1gi5278270390O18
4.0E-04BlumeriagraminisgEgh7gi72715790B8
4.0E-28Aspergillusnidulanspalmitoyltransferasesubunitgi31323646 10D13
5.0E-39Cryptococcus neoformansembCAD10036.1 40F18
5.0E-51Tuber magnatumgi588195090M15
5.0E-61UstilagomaydisGlyoxaloxidase3embCAD79490.2 55J22
5E-068Uromyces Viciae-fabaeBeta-tubulinCAC83953.158H22
6.0E-35DavidiellatassianaHydrophobingi2279615335N24
6.0E-72MortierellaramannianaDiacylglycerolacyltransferasegi1509996165D3
8.0E-12Uromyces appendiculatusDifferentiation-related proteingi505941030M9
8E-056Cryptococcus neoformansAAQ98966.140H12
9.0E-53MagnaporthegriseaChainB, ApoSaccharopineReductasegi12084779 58D15
9.0E-72Cryptococcus neoformansMAPKgbAA061669.155B10
0.0E+00PucciniagraminisElongation factorgi397949 80N15
E-ValueFungal speciesGene descriptionGenBankaccession #
1.0E-09gi1837631360I14
1.0E-100gi5722999130K8
1.0E-102ATP synthasealpha chain gbEAA36409.155E23
1.0E-124H3/H4 histoneacetyltransferasegi57228180 65I3
1.0E-13gi358190480G10
1.0E-134gi45551624 60J23
1.0E-137gi57228890 30N15
1.0E-143Enolasegi601509490H16
1.0E-149UDP-glucose dehydrogenasegi4256371765M2
1.0E-160,gi5722934765N4
1.0E-22gi5722802258D15
1.0E-57Nucleoside-gi57227197 65M20
1E-040Serine/EAK84204.170E5
2.0E-07GPI transamidasecomponentgi731758 60N1
3.0E-29Rac1 GTP binding proteingi2166751680F12
3.0E-33Oxidoreductasegi50255528 65G21
3.0E-35Ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme e2-16 kdgi1911577155N13
3.0E-85TATA binding proteingbAAA79367.158E6
3.80E-01Serine/threonine-protein kinaseCBK1gi5278270390O18
4.0E-04gEgh7gi72715790B8
4.0E-28Serine palmitoyltransferasesubunitgi31323646 10D13
5.0E-39DeacetylaseembCAD10036.1 40F18
5.0E-51Mitochondrial phosphate carrier proteingi588195090M15
5.0E-61Glyoxaloxidase3embCAD79490.2 55J22
5E-068CAC83953.158H22
6.0E-35gi2279615335N24
6.0E-72gi1509996165D3
8.0E-12gi505941030M9
8E-056AAQ98966.140H12
9.0E-53ChainB, ApoSaccharopineReductasegi12084779 58D15
9.0E-72MAPKgbAA061669.155B10
0.0E+00gi397949 80N15
Clone ID
Iron-sulfur cluster isul-like protein
1.0E-09NeurosporacrassaRelated to stress response protein rds1pgi1837631360I14
1.0E-100Cryptococcus neoformansTransaldolasegi5722999130K8
1.0E-102NeurosporacrassaATP synthasealpha chain gbEAA36409.155E23
1.0E-124Cryptococcus neoformansH3/H4 histoneacetyltransferasegi57228180 65I3
1.0E-13SchizosaccharomycespombeTransthyretingi358190480G10
1.0E-134Aspergillus fumigatusCalnexingi45551624 60J23
1.0E-137Cryptococcus neoformansSuccinatedehydrogenaseflavoproteingi57228890 30N15
1.0E-143AlternariaalternataEnolasegi601509490H16
1.0E-149Cryptococcus neoformansUDP-glucose dehydrogenasegi4256371765M2
1.0E-160Cryptococcus neoformansGlycinehydroxymethyltransferase,gi5722934765N4
1.0E-22Cryptococcus neoformansSpermidinesynthasegi5722802258D15
1.0E-57Cryptococcus neoformansdiphosphatekinasegi57227197 65M20
1E-040Ustilagomaydisthreoninekinasereceptor EAK84204.170E5
2.0E-07Saccharomyces cerevisiaeGPI transamidasecomponentgi731758 60N1
3.0E-29UstilagomaydisRac1 GTP binding proteingi2166751680F12
3.0E-33Cryptococcus neoformansgi50255528 65G21
3.0E-35Schizosaccharomycespombegi1911577155N13
3.0E-85PneumocystiscariniiTATA binding proteingbAAA79367.158E6
3.80E-01DebaryomyceshanseniiSerine/threonine-protein kinaseCBK1gi5278270390O18
4.0E-04BlumeriagraminisgEgh7gi72715790B8
4.0E-28Aspergillusnidulanspalmitoyltransferasesubunitgi31323646 10D13
5.0E-39Cryptococcus neoformansembCAD10036.1 40F18
5.0E-51Tuber magnatumgi588195090M15
5.0E-61UstilagomaydisGlyoxaloxidase3embCAD79490.2 55J22
5E-068Uromyces Viciae-fabaeBeta-tubulinCAC83953.158H22
6.0E-35DavidiellatassianaHydrophobingi2279615335N24
6.0E-72MortierellaramannianaDiacylglycerolacyltransferasegi1509996165D3
8.0E-12Uromyces appendiculatusDifferentiation-related proteingi505941030M9
8E-056Cryptococcus neoformansAAQ98966.140H12
9.0E-53MagnaporthegriseaChainB, ApoSaccharopineReductasegi12084779 58D15
9.0E-72Cryptococcus neoformansMAPKgbAA061669.155B10
0.0E+00PucciniagraminisElongation factorgi397949 80N15
E-ValueFungal speciesGene descriptionGenBankaccession #
1.0E-09gi1837631360I14
1.0E-100gi5722999130K8
1.0E-102ATP synthasealpha chain gbEAA36409.155E23
1.0E-124H3/H4 histoneacetyltransferasegi57228180 65I3
1.0E-13gi358190480G10
1.0E-134gi45551624 60J23
1.0E-137gi57228890 30N15
1.0E-143Enolasegi601509490H16
1.0E-149UDP-glucose dehydrogenasegi4256371765M2
1.0E-160,gi5722934765N4
1.0E-22gi5722802258D15
1.0E-57Nucleoside-gi57227197 65M20
1E-040Serine/EAK84204.170E5
2.0E-07GPI transamidasecomponentgi731758 60N1
3.0E-29Rac1 GTP binding proteingi2166751680F12
3.0E-33Oxidoreductasegi50255528 65G21
3.0E-35Ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme e2-16 kdgi1911577155N13
3.0E-85TATA binding proteingbAAA79367.158E6
3.80E-01Serine/threonine-protein kinaseCBK1gi5278270390O18
4.0E-04gEgh7gi72715790B8
4.0E-28Serine palmitoyltransferasesubunitgi31323646 10D13
5.0E-39DeacetylaseembCAD10036.1 40F18
5.0E-51Mitochondrial phosphate carrier proteingi588195090M15
5.0E-61Glyoxaloxidase3embCAD79490.2 55J22
5E-068CAC83953.158H22
6.0E-35gi2279615335N24
6.0E-72gi1509996165D3
8.0E-12gi505941030M9
8E-056AAQ98966.140H12
9.0E-53ChainB, ApoSaccharopineReductasegi12084779 58D15
9.0E-72MAPKgbAA061669.155B10
0.0E+00gi397949 80N15
Clone ID
Iron-sulfur cluster isul-like protein
• 40,000 clones• 1.5 -2.0 kb
• Urediniospores• HindIII digestion
• 95% clones arefull length
M 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 M
33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 M
1 2 3 4 M
M 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 1 12 13 14 15 16 MPGT PST PT PH PSH
PSTc30M9: Differentiation-Related Protein
M 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 1516 17 1819 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 M
PST PSH PSP
PSTc10C13: Deacetylase
Inserts of Puccinia striiformis f. sp. tritici BAC Clones
98kb48kb
Vector
Individual BAC clones
98kb
48kb
Vector
M M
Size Frequencies of Puccinia striiformis f. sp. tritici BAC Clones
0
10
20
30
40
50
15-20 21-30 31-60 61-85 86-125
Insert Size (kb)
Nu
mb
er
of
Clo
ne
Puccinia striiformis f. sp. tritici BAC Library
•24,000 clones
•60 kb/clone in average
•Hind III digest
•17X genome coverage
Resistance Resistance
Yr18 Yr18
AlpowaAlpowa
High-TemperatureAdult-Plant
(HTAP)Resistance
Chromosomal Location of Yr Genes
12345
6
7
A B DYr3a Yr9 Yr15 Yr24 Yr3c Yr10 Yr21 Yr29YrDa1
Yr1 Yr17 Yr32
YrTr2YrHVIIYrMin YrND
YrDru YrH46
Yr5 YrSte2 Yr27 Yr7 YrV23 Yr31YrSte Yr30YrCle YrYamYrMorYr19 YrDru2
Yr4a Yr4b
Yr2 Yr6
Yr8 Yr16
Yr22 Yr28
YrDa2Yr20 YrTr1Yr23 YrTyeYr18 Yr33
Yr25
Yr26
Yr34
One gene after anotherGene rotationGene deployment
Gene pyramiding
Cultivar mixtureMultiline cultivars
All-Stage Resistance
52-513-532-4Adult
888788SeedlingWA7939
2-32-42-312Adult
888588SeedlingWA7936
1009897584337TestLine
Infection types produced by PST races
Evaluation of WA7936 and WA7939 for Resistance to Stripe Rust in the Greenhouse
WA7936 and WA7939 have HTAP resistance.
Constructing BAC Library for Cloning Yr genesConstructing BAC Library for Cloning Yr genes
0.1 0.2 0.4 0.5MHind III unit
350 kb
•410,000 clones in 1,100 384-well plates•130 kb/clone in average
•Hind III digest
•3.4X genome coverage•Primary and super pools weremade for efficient screening
P31
D6
P32
D3
P33
D8
Yr5
NIL
500 bp
E.c
oliD
NA
Y
r5 N
ILP
25
3 p
late
Pools of P253 Rows
L M N OA B C D E F G H I J K P C-1
C-3
C-2
Pools of P253 Columns
C-5
C-1
9C
-20
Yr5
NIL
C-4
C-6
C-7
C-8
C-9
C-1
0C
-11
C-1
2C
-13
C-1
4C
-15
C-1
6C
-17
C-1
8
C-2
1C
-22
C-2
3C
-24
Identification of Yr5-Marker Positive BAC Clones
L5
M5
N5
O5
5
L1
9M
19
O1
9N
19
L2
0M
20
N2
0O
20
M M M M
Disease Epidemiology and Pathogen Races Host Resistance Resistance Gene Cloning
Pathogen Genomics
Disease MonitoringDisease Monitoring
Fungicide Treatments, Hatton, Pullman, 2004
58.559.059.560.060.561.061.562.062.563.063.5
Quilt 7+14
Quilt 14
Stratego10
Tilt 4 Headline9
Headline6
No-fungicide
Test weight (1b/bu)
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
Quilt 7+14 Quilt 14 Stratego10
Tilt 4 Headline9
Headline6
No-fungicide
Yield (bu/A)58.0 57.1 53.8 52.4 51.7 50.1
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
Quilt 7+14 Quilt 14 Stratego 10 Tilt 4 Headline 9 Headline 6 No-fungicide
6/14(B-H) 6/18(M) 7/12(SD)
Str
ipe
ru
st
severi
ty (
%)
Sprayed on 6/9 (boot), 6/16 (heading)
Fungicide TestingFungicide Treatments, Hatton, Pullman, 2004
58.559.059.560.060.561.061.562.062.563.063.5
Quilt 7+14
Quilt 14
Stratego10
Tilt 4 Headline9
Headline6
No-fungicide
Test weight (1b/bu)
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
Quilt 7+14 Quilt 14 Stratego10
Tilt 4 Headline9
Headline6
No-fungicide
Yield (bu/A)58.0 57.1 53.8 52.4 51.7 50.1
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
Quilt 7+14 Quilt 14 Stratego 10 Tilt 4 Headline 9 Headline 6 No-fungicide
6/14(B-H) 6/18(M) 7/12(SD)
Str
ipe
ru
st
severi
ty (
%)
Sprayed on 6/9 (boot), 6/16 (heading)
Fungicide Testing
0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500
PS 279Hatton
BuchananWPB 470
LewjainBoundary
Rely
EdwinFinleyTubbs
EltanWA7939
Brundage 96WA7936LambertMasami
RodCashup
CodaStephens
Madsen
ChukarFinch
Bruehl
Non-spraySprayed
Stripe rustStripe rust
Stripe rust severity (AUDPC)
Winter Wheat (2004)
-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
PS 279Hatton
BuchananWPB 470
Lewjain
BoundaryRely
EdwinFinleyTubbs
Eltan
WA7939Brundage 96
WA7936LambertMasami
RodCashup
CodaStephens
MadsenChukar
FinchBruehl
LossIncrease
Yield loss/increase
Yield loss/increase
Yield (%)
Cultivar Response
0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500
PS 279Hatton
BuchananWPB 470
LewjainBoundary
Rely
EdwinFinleyTubbs
EltanWA7939
Brundage 96WA7936LambertMasami
RodCashup
CodaStephens
Madsen
ChukarFinch
Bruehl
Non-spraySprayed
Stripe rustStripe rust
Stripe rust severity (AUDPC)
Winter Wheat (2004)
-10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
PS 279Hatton
BuchananWPB 470
Lewjain
BoundaryRely
EdwinFinleyTubbs
Eltan
WA7939Brundage 96
WA7936LambertMasami
RodCashup
CodaStephens
MadsenChukar
FinchBruehl
LossIncrease
Yield loss/increase
Yield loss/increase
Yield (%)
Cultivar Response
• Rust alerts and real-time situations were sent to growersfor preparing and implementing fungicide control throughe-mails and news releases.
• Advises and recommendations were provided to growers onwhether to use fungicide on certain cultivars, which one touse, and when to use fungicides.
Implementation of Fungicide Control
Losses of multimillion dollars were prevented.
Integrated Disease Management
40 104
35 9530 86
25 77
20 68
15 5910 50
5 41
0 32
-5 23-10 14
-15 5
-20 -4
Mean (29.6 oF)
Normal (1949 -2004)
Mean max. (35 oF)
Mean min. (24 oF)
Recorded low ( -29 oF)
Recorded high (57 oF)
2005
Mean (33.7 oF)Mean max. (39.6 oF)
Mean min. (27.7 oF)
Highest (56 oF)
Lowest (56 oF)
January Weather Comparison
Disease forecasting
40 104
35 9530 86
25 77
20 68
15 5910 50
5 41
0 32
-5 23-10 14
-15 5
-20 -4
Mean (29.6 oF)
Normal (1949 -2004)
Mean max. (35 oF)
Mean min. (24 oF)
Recorded low ( -29 oF)
Recorded high (57 oF)
2005
Mean (33.7 oF)Mean max. (39.6 oF)
Mean min. (27.7 oF)
Highest (56 oF)
Lowest (7 oF)
January Weather Comparison
Disease forecasting
AcknowledgementsThis rust research program is supported byUSDA-ARS, Washington Wheat Commission,Washington Barley Commission, Idaho WheatCommission, and Vogel Foundation. We thankmany working study students and part -timeworkers for their assistance. The collaborationsby many regional, national, and internationalscientists are highly appreciated.
40 104
35 95
30 86
25 77
20 68
15 59
10 50
5 41
0 32
-5 23
-10 14
-15 5
-20 -4
Spores germinate
Disease developsmost rapidly at
Sporulation
Lethal(10 days)
daily max.daily Avg.
Temperature Effecton Stripe Rust
Parameters in Models for Stripe Rust Forecasting
1. Negative Degree Days (NDD):Accumulated daily temperatureslower than 7oC from December1 to January 31.
2. Positive Degree Days (PDD):Accumulated daily temperatureshigher than 7oC from April 1 toJune 30.
3. Julian Day of Spring (JDS):The date when positive 40oC orhigher during the following 14days.
Eq. 1: DIi=ai–biNDDZ+ciJDSEq. 2: DIi=ai–biNDDZ+ciJDS–diPDDEq. 3: DIi=ai–biNDDZ
(Coakley et al. 1982, Phytopathology 72:1539-42)(Coakley et al. 1983, Phytopathology 73:1382-85)
Epidemic Models