Strengthening Fisheries Management in ACP...
Transcript of Strengthening Fisheries Management in ACP...
"Strengthening Fisheries Management in ACP Countries"
Project Funded by the European Union. “This publication has been produced with the assistance of the European Union. The contents of this
publication are the sole responsibility of ”PBLH International Consulting SPRL” and can in no way be taken to reflect the views of the European Union.” “The content of this document does not necessarily reflect the views of the concerned governments.”
Final Technical Report
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the
Caribbean region
Project ref. N° CAR-5.1-B20 Region: Caribbean
May 13th 2013
A project implemented by:
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 2 of 40
Table of contents
TABLE OF CONTENTS ....................................................................................................................... 2
LIST OF TABLES, FIGURES AND PHOTOGRAPHS ..................................................................... 3
LIST OF ANNEXES .............................................................................................................................. 3
ABBREVIATIONS AND ACRONYMS ............................................................................................... 5
1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ............................................................................................................ 6
2 BACKGROUND ............................................................................................................................ 7
2.1 ABOUT THE CRFM ................................................................................................................... 7 2.2 ABOUT THE PROJECT ................................................................................................................ 7
3 APPROACH TO THE ASSIGNMENT ....................................................................................... 8
3.1 PHASE 1: INCEPTION PHASE: CONSULTATIONS AND ANALYSIS ................................................. 8 3.2 DESK WORK .............................................................................................................................. 9 3.3 REGIONAL TECHNICAL CONSULTATION ................................................................................... 9 3.4 DRAFT INTERIM TECHNICAL REPORT ..................................................................................... 10 3.5 PHASE 2: IMPLEMENTATION PHASE AND TRAINING PREPARATION .......................................... 11 3.6 PHASE 3: TRAINING PHASE: TRAINING WORKSHOPS AND FINAL REPORTS ............................... 13
3.6.1 On-job trainings in St Vincent and Belize................................................................ 13 3.6.2 Finalizing the website and tools development ......................................................... 13 3.6.3 Regional Training Workshop (St Vincent and the Grenadines) ............................... 14 3.6.4 User manuals ........................................................................................................... 15
4 COMMENTS ON TERMS OF REFERENCES ....................................................................... 16
5 ORGANISATION AND METHODOLOGY .............................................................................. 16
5.1 DELIVERY OF TERMS OF REFERENCE ...................................................................................... 16 5.2 CONDUCT AND DETAILS OF THE ASSIGNMENT INCLUDING VISIBILITY ACTIVITIES .................. 17
6 CONCLUSIONS .......................................................................................................................... 18
7 RECOMMENDATIONS .............................................................................................................. 18
8 ANNEXES .................................................................................................................................... 20
ANNEX 1 – TERMS OF REFERENCE ..................................................................................... 20 ANNEX 3 – INSTITUTIONS AND INDIVIDUALS CONSULTED ........................................... 37 ANNEX 4 – CD/DVD .................................................................................................................... 40 ANNEX 5 – USERS GUIDE ........................................................................................................ 40 ANNEX 6 – USERS MANUAL .................................................................................................... 40 ANNEX 7 – ADMINISTRATORS MANUAL .............................................................................. 40
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 3 of 40
List of tables, figures and photographs Table1 – Tools Developed – p.14 Table 2 – Activities Delivery – p.17
List of annexes ANNEX 1 – Terms of Reference ANNEX 2 – Itinerary ANNEX 3 – Institutions and individuals consulted ANNEX 4 – CD/DVD including the following documents:
0. Inception Report with annexes 1. ICT Communication Strategy 2. Plan for Website Upgrade 3. Revised 2010 Draft Communication Strategy 4. OJT Programme and Training presentations 5. Workshops programmes, lists of participants and presentations 6. Communication and visibility supports and analysis 7. Photographs
ANNEX 5 – Users Guide ANNEX 6 – Users Manual ANNEX 7 – Administrators Manual
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 4 of 40
Acknowledgements The Project Team wishes to thank all those who helped us during field missions in setting up interviews and collecting and analysing information.
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 5 of 40
Abbreviations and acronyms
ACS Association of Caribbean States
ACP African Caribbean Pacific
CLME Caribbean Large Marine Ecosystem
CARICOM Caribbean Community
CARIFIS Caribbean Fisheries Information System
CARIFORUM Caribbean Forum of African, Caribbean and Pacific States
CERMES Centre for Resources Management and Environmental Studies
CRFM Caribbean Regional Fisheries Mechanism
CSME CARICOM Single Market and Economy
CU Coordination Unit
EC European Commission
EDF European Development Fund
ESDU Environment and Sustainable Development Unit
FAO Food and Agriculture Organisation
FIS Fisheries Management Information System
GDP Gross Domestic Product
ICCAT International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas
ICT Information and Communication Technologies
ICT4D Information and Communication Technologies for Development
IT Information Technologies
OECS Organisation of Eastern Caribbean States
RFU Regional Facilitation Unit
UNEP United Nations Environment Programme
UNESCO United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation
UWI University of the West Indies
USD United States Dollar
WECAFC Western Central Atlantic Fishery Commission
WSIS World Summit on the Information Society
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 6 of 40
1 Executive summary "Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region" is an EU-funded technical assistance project within the ACP Fish II Programme, that was designed to:
- Contribute to the sustainable and equitable management of fisheries in ACP regions, thus leading to poverty alleviation and improving food security in ACP States
- Strengthen the capacity of the Caribbean Regional Fisheries Mechanism (CRFM) and fisheries administrations of CARIFORUM States in fisheries information and knowledge sharing.
The project had the following expected results that have now all been achieved:
- The Draft Communication Strategy and Plan for the CRFM has been reviewed and finalised (focusing on ICT component) with the stakeholders;
- The CRFM website is updated, expanded and operational, in line with the agreed Strategy and supported by relevant manuals and training;
- National representatives of CARIFORUM states have been trained in using new CRFM website and online interactive tools.
Together with the revisited strategy and new ICT strategy, a complete set of ICT tools and website have been set up. Before the end of the project, CRFM staff and partners already actively use the new website, the intranet and tools such as the CRFM dgroups.org communities. This is an indicator that the project has been quite successful thanks to:
- a correct assessment of the CFRM needs and existing capacities in house and among stakeholders
- the participation of the beneficiary and its stakeholders during the assessment and strategy definition as well as the implementation, content dissemination and training
- an adequate choice of tools and applications carefully considering the existing capacity to maintain and sustain them within the CRFM
- the maximum automation of tasks required to maintain and manage the updated CRFM website in order to allow CRFM staff to focus on content development and publication
- the organisation of a smooth and seamless transition (as for new CRFM emails and web domain), and the focus, when training or choosing tools, on concrete uses, applications and support to enhance exiting collaboration and communications processes (instead of the technology for itself). Training in skills related to e-communications or managing virtual groups was more important than focusing on the software used for it.
The key functionalities of the new collaboration tools are
- On-line discussion board
- e-groups (technical e-group, fisherfolk e-group, management e-groups)
- Video conferencing for presentations delivery, training and discussions
- Possibility to create and access depository of fisheries data and information
- CRFM pages on the major social networks sites (Facebook, Twitter, Youtube, SlideShare)
- On-line documents storage, sharing and real time on-line editing tools New functionalities of the upgraded website
- User access management allowing drafting and editing of content from the frontend
- Events management with attachments, invitation and registration functionalities
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 7 of 40
- Ability to upload library documents to the website and facilitate download by target readership
- Ability to execute extended website searches
- Links to all FAs, regional organizations, and other national departments with interest in fisheries; regional and international legal fisheries instruments
- Possibility to post comments to published news and documents
- Introduced a tagging system for published documents and articles
- Integrated electronic newsletter functionality
- Syndicated fisheries news reader
- Integrated project management module However, there is now an immediate need for the CRFM executive staff to encourage all users and partners to invest some time to explore and use all the tools made available for concrete tasks, until the learning curve is passed. It is recommended to hire a resource person to increase CRFM knowledge management and communication facilitation capacity to make the most out of these new tools, developing and disseminating content, facilitating and organising a growing sustainable flow of communications as well as helping catalyse online collaboration with partners and stakeholders.
2 Background
2.1 About the CRFM
The Caribbean Regional Fisheries Mechanism (CRFM) was officially inaugurated on 27
March 2003, following the signing of the “Agreement Establishing the CRFM” on February
4, 2002. The goal of this inter-governmental organization is “To promote and facilitate the
responsible utilization of the region's fisheries and other aquatic resources for the economic
and social benefits of the current and future population of the region”. The CRFM consists of
three bodies – the Ministerial Council; the Caribbean Fisheries Forum; and the CRFM
Secretariat. Its mission is to promote and facilitate the responsible utilisation of the region’s
fisheries and other aquatic resources for the economic and social benefits of the current and future population of the region.
The CRFM had two offices (Belize and St Vincent) and staff are split between them. There
is just IT resource person in Belize, and an external consultant for PR. Tasks related to web
content management are performed by Belize staff and publications and library maintenance
from St Vincent office.
2.2 About the project
According to the ToRs, the overall objective and the purpose of this project are:
- To contribute to the sustainable and equitable management of fisheries in ACP regions, thus leading to poverty alleviation and improving food security in ACP States
- To strengthen the capacity of the Caribbean Regional Fisheries Mechanism (CRFM) and fisheries administrations of CARIFORUM States in fisheries information and knowledge sharing.
In line with the ToRs, the expected results are:
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 8 of 40
- Draft Communication Strategy and Plan for CRFM reviewed and finalised (focusing on ICT component);
- CRFM website updated, expanded and operational, in line with the agreed Strategy and supported by relevant manuals and training;
- National representatives of CARIFORUM states trained in using new CRFM website and online interactive tools.
3 Approach to the assignment
3.1 Phase 1: Inception phase: Consultations and analysis
The first inception / field mission included:
- The kick-off meeting at the CRFM office in Belize
- The revision of documents and the CRFM website
- National consultations in Belize, Trinidad and Tobago, Barbados, Saint Vincent and Grenadines to asses and evaluate the ICT subsector opportunities and current state of affairs
- Drafting the inception report To start the 1st field mission, the key experts held a kick-off meeting at the CRFM office in Belize with the participation of CRFM top management and technical staff as well as the ACP FISH II staff. At the kick-off meeting, the list of key stakeholders to be interviewed during the first field mission was revised and agreed on, namely the fisheries administration (Belize, Trinidad and Tobago, Barbados, Saint Vincent & the Grenadines), scientific and/or research organisations related to fisheries, national fisher folk organisations, the EU Delegation in Barbados, and the CRFM Eastern Caribbean Office in Saint Vincent and the Grenadines. Annex 3 indicates the contacts made on the spot. The itinerary of the experts can be found in Annex 2. During the national consultations the experts identified the following key documents that were collected and reviewed during the first mission:
- Draft CRFM Communication Strategy, 2010
- Agreement establishing the Caribbean Community Common Fisheries Policy
- CRFM administrative Report Annual work plan and budget (1st April 2012 to 31st March 2013)
- Caribbean Network of Fisherfolk Organisations (CNFO) Communication strategy, October 2012
- Overview of the Status of Performance of CARIFIS in CRFM Member States, and Options for the Way Forward. CRFM Technical & Advisory Document – Number 2012/4
- CRFM Secretariat Operations Manual, 2010
- Different leaflets and promotional materials prepared by CRFM Secretariat
- Training materials for CARIFIS The national consultations enabled the experts to assess the following points:
- Collaboration and communication processes between stakeholders
- Needs assessment of the beneficiaries and CRFM stakeholders
- Information sharing and communications tools used by stakeholders
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 9 of 40
- Data collection and reporting tools used
3.2 Desk work
After this first field mission, the experts carried out home-based work to:
- Review different documents collected during field meetings and consultations
- Followed up on additional contacts indicated by stakeholders (calls, mail)
- Analyse different web-based resources identified during consultations
- Assessed CRFM needs for upgrading of website hosting plan, increase of bandwidth
- Identified international best practices of using information and communication technologies in international organisations similar to CRFM
- Reviewed ICT components and interactive tools used by CRFM and their benchmarking with best international practices to guide implementation
- Selected the Content Management System to use
- Identified technical solutions to index the CRFM materials (pdfs in particular)
- Revised the Draft CRFM Communication Strategy, in light of all the findings and identified needs
- Prepared the validation workshop
In parallel, PBLH logistics expert prepared all logistics to organize the technical regional validation workshop. The Inception Report submitted can be found in Annex 4. Two weeks afters inception report was approved, the experts finalised and submitted to the CRFM and the PMU
- The draft updated communication strategy (that was proposed to be validated at the Regional Technical Consultation in Belize). The ICT communication strategy can be found Annex 4.
- A plan for the upgrading of website, the hosting plan, and increase of bandwidth (Annex 4)
3.3 Regional Technical Consultation
The first phase was completed with the Regional Technical Consultation held in St Vincent the 28th – 29th January 2013. The objective of the Regional Technical Consultation was to review and endorse the CRFM Communication Strategy as improved by the Consultants. The revised Strategy presented addressed issues described in the ToRs such as the assessment of the current situation facing information exchange in the region, update of the stakeholder's matrix and specific communication/collaboration objectives for each targeted audience. The consultation workshop included the following sessions: Session 1: Review of communication objectives at the light of CRFM strategic plans - The framework: CRFM Strategic plans / CCFP implementation, to Communication strategy to ICT in communication and collaboration - Embedding ICTs into CRFM operations: - Proposed aim and objectives of the ICT component of the communication strategy - Prioritising activities of the ICT action plan and evaluation of results
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 10 of 40
Session 2: Review of the stakeholder matrix - Review stakeholder list: add /merge or delete stakeholders. Why? - Review the desired support from stakeholders and actions towards them. Are the proposed Information and Communication actions relevant and sufficient to attain these? - Are all theses communication tools relevant and needed? Session 3: Drafting the data sharing policies and protocols - What has to be shared electronically (data, reports etc) - Information meta-sharing - By whom is it produced, formatted, validated and published? - By whom it has to be accessed and what for - Formats, licences and rights of use or re-use Session 4: CRFM website upgrading and communication tools - Review of the required changes to the website - Proposed website structure and content - Selection of required communication tools - Validation of the CRM ICT communication framework Session 5: From information sharing to collaborative work: how each stakeholder will organize resources and put into practice - Web roles and profiles - Current sharing and collaboration modalities and results - Limitations and constraint to enhanced regional collaboration - Selection of required collaboration and data sharing tools - Roles and responsibilities of CRFM and the partner institutions Session 6: Capacity building plan (March 2013) - Training needs assessment - Who should attend training and why - Review and validation of training program The programme and list of participants can be found in Annex 4. The participants of the technical consultation workshop validated the presented assessment of CRFM needs regarding implementation of the revised Communication Strategy, reviewing of the stakeholders’ matrix, the proposed ICT strategy, identified key aspects of data sharing policy, CRFM website upgrading plan, communication, collaboration and data sharing tools proposed for implementation, and validating and preparing the training plan, that was later implemented. Within this demand driven process leading to the development of the upgraded website and implementation of new ICT tools, the stakeholders agreed with the proposals made by consultants and suggested several adjustments which were discussed and integrated into the updated Implementation Plan.
3.4 Draft Interim Technical Report
The Draft Interim Technical Report was produced after the validation workshop (St Vincent January 2013) and prior to the final end-user workshop of March 2013.
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 11 of 40
It is important to note that, during inception phase, after having assessed the needs, the experts reviewed the exiting Draft Communication Strategy (Haynes, 2010) to integrate the finding and ICT component in it. Given the complexity of documenting the ICT strategy within the framework existing Communication Strategy which holds its own logic and elements and the experts deemed to develop a new document named "ICT component strategy and action plan for the implementation of the CRFM Communication strategy (2013)". This document was used as the basis for the validation workshop held in St Vincent on January 28th - 29th, 2013 and was completed thereafter integrating all stakeholders' comments and inputs. During a meeting held with CRFM director and ACP Fish II advisor, at the end of the January 2013 validation workshop, the experts proposed to consider this ICT Strategy as a stand-alone document and to append it to the existing 2010 Draft Communication Strategy – rev 2013, which was also reviewed with stakeholders during the validation workshop. This proposal was validated. The Draft Interim Technical Report was prepared to wrap 3 attachments, in accordance with the recommendations of the ACP Fish II Regional Facilitation Unit that requested that "The
documents (...) should be included in one document clearly presented as the ITR with the contents list
including all documents. The main narrative of the ITR would be very simple perhaps 2 or 3 pages
but will put the three attached documents in context and allow cross-reference. (..) The Draft
Communications Strategy (originally by C Haynes) has been revised and the Communications
Strategy (Focusing on ICT component) prepared by the KEs (..) will be an Annex to that document.
The Detailed Plan for the CRFM website upgrade can then be included into this structure":
1. The revised CRFM Draft Communication Strategy (originally 2010 - now revision
2013)1. The main update in this document is the addition of a specific objective related to the ICT strategy, and an in-depth revision of the stakeholders' matrix (that includes definition of what and how to interact with the different stakeholders).
2. The "ICT component of the CRFM Communication Strategy and the action plan for the implementation (2013)"2, updated after the January validation workshop and completed after the March end users workshop.
3. The Detailed Plan for the CRFM website upgrading3
3.5 Phase 2: Implementation phase and training preparation
After the validation workshop, the experts started the implementation phase with the following activities:
- website upgrading (redesign of the website structure, implementation of new Content Management System, design of the website layout, transfer of existing documents, creating of new modules) , procurement of ICT tools (trial subscription to communication and collaboration tools provided in “software as a service” model), and negotiation for increase of Internet access bandwidth by Internet service providers for both CRFM offices according to the proposals and budget estimates made in the Interim Technical Report;
- on the job and training workshop-related materials and drafting the manuals (for webmaster and content managers and for end users), and
- workshops logistics.
1 See Annex 4
2 Ibid
3 Ibid
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 12 of 40
As result, the following improvements have been made:
- Internet bandwidth increased in CRFM Belize office from 2 Mbps up to 8 Mbps and in CRFM Saint-Vincent office from 4 Mbps up to 8 Mbps using ADSL technology. In addition, experts initiated negotiation with BTL to allow CRFM Belize office to benefit from a dedicated line for Internet access which allows usage of Voice-over-IP communication technologies;
- The upgraded CRFM website has integrated the following new functionalities: Open Source Content Management System, access level system to the website content and functionalities customised to CRFM types of stakeholders, predefined forms for publishing of website content, tagging system for content and documents, website version for smart phones and tablets, integrated electronic newsletter facility, calendar of CRFM and other events, extended website search, syndicated fisheries news reader, integrated visitors analytics dashboard, module for management of CRFM and other training events, register of international and regional events, directory of related technical assistance projects, directory of websites of National Fisheries Authorities, directory of e-mailing lists, facility to manage extended personal profiles, automated sharing of content on CRFM social networks, automated translation of the website content into French, Spanish and Dutch, RSS (really simple syndication) mechanism to share information from the CRFM website on the CNFO website, mechanism to automatic gathering of information about scientific publications, mushups of bibliographical resources from different websites, integrated project management facility;
- New communication and collaboration tools implemented: directory of electronic forums and virtual groups (DGroups), virtual working group on CARIFIS software and others, CRFM pages on the major social networks (Facebook, Twitter, SlideShare, YouTube, Vimeo), CRFM on-line documents depository (GoogleDisk), corporate real time on-line documents editing tools (GoogleDocs), crfm.net e-mail addresses and possibility to use Google Mail interface for e-mails management, on-line communication tool (GoToMeeting), web conferencing tools (MConf, GoToWebinar), directory of resources to manage depositories of fisheries statistical data, directory of Open Data resources.
The draft of upgraded CRFM website was proposed to revision of CRFM secretariat employees during the On-the-Job trainings in Belize and in Saint Vincent. After this, the participants of the Regional Training seminar in Saint Vincent also contributed to reviewing the draft website. In conclusion, a validation meeting was hold with the CRFM Directors and the Secretariat employees after the completion of this training. A list of 34 requirements for improvement of the website was drafted and agreed. During the On-the-Job training, the upgraded website was reviewed by the CRFM staff and the functionalities were checked and amendments made before the Regional training. The OTJ training was used to populate the upgraded website with test content. Staff of the CRFM secretariat was directly involved in reviewing the style, format and the content of the upgraded website. As the result of several iterations of the website improvements, CRFM Secretariat agreed with the changes being made.
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 13 of 40
3.6 Phase 3: Training phase: Training workshops and final reports
3.6.1 On-job trainings in St Vincent and Belize
The experts carried out the third field mission starting with the on the job trainings, delivered in the CRFM St Vincent office from March 18th to 22nd by the Team Leader and in the CRFM Belize office from March 12th to 20th by the Key Expert 2. The final days of training in Belize on March 21st and 22nd were delivered by both experts together. The focus of the OJT was on the management of the web site and tools and the definition of the processes (to produce and publish content, manage the web site and the other tools administration, moderation and facilitation of virtual communities etc). It became processes were at the same time, web site tools and content organisation were fine tuned, responsibilities over content, communication and tools management were defined, and CFRM staff in both locations trained to manage and administer all the tools. The regional training for the end users was then for the stakeholders to learn how to use all these tools, including web site content upload, and the national fisheries page, publications, data sharing and e-group management (in case some of the would manage virtual communities) The programme included the following modules:
- Website content administration
- Website maintenance
- Communication tools
- Collaboration tools
- Data sharing tools Working sessions with the CRFM Director and CRFM Secretariat senior staff allowed to adjust the structure of the updated CRFM website and to define roles of key people of the CRFM Secretariat. All the roles and responsibilities are detailed in the manual for maintenance and management, sections 6 and 7, as well as each virtual group community and tools moderator/administrator. The team leader interactions were centred in defining responsibilities, back office processes (who manages content, how etc.), content and configuration of the online tools to be presented the following week to the end users. (Annex 4 - CD - Slides of the detailed on the job training programme for CRFM administrators )
3.6.2 Finalizing the website and tools development
During the last days of the on job training, the Key Expert 2 finalized the website and the interactive tools required according to the observations and feedback made during the trainings sessions.
All these tools should all be operational and have been tested by the CRFM or partners.(click
on the links or the tool logo to access the services) Table 1 – Tools developed
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 14 of 40
A Comprehensive CRFM website, that includes CRFM documents and reports (including all those from the old site that have been linked. Scientific Publications and statistics Events agenda and organiser, project management tool, Fisheries Newsfeeds Newsletters, Etc.
http://www.crfm.net/
A complete Intranet system for CRFM staff using Google Apps for Business, ready to share documents drive, agenda, contacts, mails, internal groups, etc.
http://google.com/a/crfm.net
15 CRFM virtual Communities on dgroups.org for Scientific and technical working groups CARIFIS user help community, executive board and forum (private spaces) Carifis software users, etc. have been set up
http://dgroups.org/cta/crfm
3 accounts for CRFM Video conferencing, - MCONF free tool for videoconferencing and
webinars tools, - GotoWebinar for webinars and virtual education - Gotomeeting for videoconferencing
https://mconf.org/spaces/crfm/
Accounts or pages on the main social networks namely Twitter, Facebook, Youtube and Slideshare
https://twitter.com/CaribFisheries
https://www.facebook.com/CarFisheries
http://www.youtube.com/user/TheCRFM
http://www.slideshare.net/CRFM/ The selected following data sharing tools - Open Refine to clean data files - Google Fusion table to share, merge and
compare table and data bases and - To Create visualisations with IBM Many Eyes
3.6.3 Regional Training Workshop (St Vincent and the Grenadines)
The Regional Training Workshop was successfully held in Saint Vincent and the Grenadines from March 25th to March 27th. The workshop practical learning objectives were defined as to have participants learn to
- Search, access and comment articles and publications on the CRFM website
- Draft content for publication and/or collaborate in editing CRFM content
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 15 of 40
- Share or disseminate content (with CRFM, or from CRFM to others) over social networks
- Organize or promote events online
- Maintain their country profiles pages
- Get or provide online training
- Get updates, alerts news and newsletters from CRFM
- Participate in task forces, working groups, scientific committees or communities (discussions or exchanges, collaborative drafting, or articulation, data sharing)
- Use the tools to facilitate collaborative projects management
- Share and manipulate data
- Get support and exchange good practices using CARIFIS software A participatory approach was implemented to ensure the stakeholders' appropriation of the outcomes and their ownership of the tools developed, and although according to the feedback, the follow use and end of workshop survey this was achieved, follow up will be needed to ensure continuous use of the web and tools by stakeholders. This workshop targeted concepts of e-knowledge management, online collaboration and on the techniques to facilitate collaboration, online discussion, and technical groups. Hands – on activities were conducted on live ICT tools The training included the following sessions4
- Session 1: ICT systems overview
- Session 2 Hands on training on the web site
- Session 3: Hands on training: Projects and events
- Session 4: Online synchronic exchanges
- Session 5 Data sharing
- Session 6: Carifis support group
- Session 7: online collaboration According to the participants' evaluations and the CRFM staff feedback, the workshop fully fulfilled the objectives and expectations. The workshop's programme and participants list can be found Annex 4. Following the Regional Training Workshop, a session with senior CRFM secretariat officers was organised to discuss findings and wishes for adjustment of the CRFM website and the ICT tools. The required adjustments were implemented after return of Key Experts from the last workshop and field mission Upon request of the CRFM Secretariat staff and CRFM stakeholders, the Key Experts have provided technical assistance and backup on the usage of the upgraded CRFM website in
the weeks following the workshop, a mentoring support to the CRFM staff.
3.6.4 User manuals
After the Workshop the consultants finalised the (1) end user and (2) web administration manual, and added a (3) user guide/map to the CRFM tools. Those outputs can be found in - Annex 5 – Users Guide of the CRFM ICT tools - Annex 6 – End users manual
4 See Annex 8 – Slides of the users' training Programme
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 16 of 40
- Annex 7 Administrators manual According to the ToRs and the Inception Report, after comments from the CRFM and the CU/RFU were provided, the end user manuals were translated into Spanish and French.
4 Comments on Terms of References The terms of reference were reviewed during the kick-off meeting at CRFM headquarters in Belize on Nov. 19th 2012, and some clarifications were made. No major issue was raised on the interpretation of the ToRs. It was agreed that the project would be implemented over 5 months with a start on November 19th, 2012, divided into three main phases and that the expert team will pursue three field missions in the Caribbean. Key deadlines and dates and workshop sites were agreed during the kick-off. The proposed amendments to the ToRs were: (a) a change of the date of delivery of the Inception report, (b) to use 2 of 5-day on-job training (Belize and St Vincent) for data/documents migration tasks executed together by CRFM web/data managers and KEs, and (c) to translate only the end users manuals out of the two manuals, as all software and applications to be used by the administrators are English-speaking only.
5 Organisation and Methodology
5.1 Delivery of Terms of Reference
Table 2 – Activities delivery
1 Be briefed by ACP Fish II programme and CRFM staff and officers;
The inception meeting was held in Belize Nov 19th
2013 with CRFM key staff and ACP fish II PMU. ToRs were reviewed in detail, key stakeholders and documents identified, workshops and field missions planned for. Details can be found in the inception report.
2 Conduct background literature review and consultations and analysis to enable an assessment of the information sharing activities and communication of CRFM and a critical review of the 2009 Communication Strategy for CRFM;
Regional field mission was conducted with key stakeholders in Belize, Trinidad and Tobago, Barbados, and St Vincent and the grenadines, during months of November and December 2012 Documents were reviewed short after, Results ate in the inception report and the technical reports (new ICT strategy and web plan) delivered mid January 2013
3 Prepare a revised draft Communications Strategy for CRFM (focusing on ICT communications and the website component);
These were delivered before workshop of January, and finalised after SVG workshop, integrating the stakeholders' inputs.
4 Organise and facilitate one Regional Technical Consultation in Belize (20 people, 2 days) of key fisheries and IT stakeholders to review and endorse the CRFM Communication Strategy as improved by the Consultant;
The regional. Workshop held in St Vincent end of January 2013 with the participation of 20 key fisheries and IT stakeholders to review and endorse the new ICT strategy and the revise the CRFM Communication Strategy
5 Upgrade CRFM website using CMS software to include, inter alia, the tools
The new web site was developed, reviewed and finalised. It is fully operational and visible online at
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 17 of 40
identified in the agreed Communication Strategy. A number of these tools are noted in section 4.1.1 The cost of software, licenses and improved bandwidth can be procured using the incidental budget;
the URL www.crfm.net All required communication and collaboration tools have been procured and made available to the CRFM Secretariat and stakeholders in Intranet mode.
6 Prepare one manual for maintenance and management of the new website (for webmaster & administrators at CRFM) and one manual for users of the website produced;
Both manual were prepared and submitted for validation to the CRFM secretariat and PMU staff
7 Develop training outline and deliver OJT training (up to 5 days) to webmasters, administrators and technical staff at CRFM Secretariat in Belize and Saint Vincent and the Grenadines
The experts carried out the third field mission starting with the on the job trainings, the Team Leader delivered in St Vincent March 18
th to 22
th
and Key Expert 2 in Belize from March 12th to 20
th,
and both together in Belize March 21 and 22nd
.
8 Training workshop – train participants in using the new CRFM website; where comments are provided by countries, update website and finalize the design of the website. Participants - CARIFORUM states and other resource institutions using the new CRFM website; participants should be one Senior Fisheries Officer and one Technical staff member responsible for the actual implementation (e.g. Communications officer or Data Manager) of information exchange activities within the FA. The training workshop for 3 days with 35 participants from CARIFORUM states, CRFM, CNFO, UWI-CERMES will take place in Saint Vincent and the Grenadines;
The Regional Training Workshop was successfully held in Saint Vincent and the Grenadines from March 26
th to 28
th 2013 with the participation of 33+
35 participants from CARIFORUM states. The training included the following session
- Session 1: ICT systems overview
- Session 2 Hands on training on the web site
- Session 3: Hands on training: Projects and events
- Session 4: Online synchronic exchanges
- Session 5 Data sharing
- Session 6: Carifis support group
- Session 7: online collaboration
9 Prepare Training Report including all materials prepared and used;
The reports have been prepared and are presented as annexes to this documents
10 Prepare Final Technical Reports as required.
This document is the Final Technical Reports
11 The draft Communication strategy (focusing on IT) will be translated into French and Spanish. The User Manuals for the regional training will be available in French and Spanish.
Pending
5.2 Conduct and details of the assignment including visibility activities
The following communication and visibility activities were carried out in close collaboration with the CRFM and the consultant: - Press Releases dissemination to national and regional stakeholders
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 18 of 40
- Press Conferences at the beginning of each workshop involving fisheries officials The Press Releases along with two reports describing the communication results can be found Annex 4 in the folder 6. 6 Conclusions Before the end of the project CRFM staff and partners are already actively using the web site, the intranet and tools as the CRFM dgroups.org communities.
The following measures and approaches have been taken to try to ensure the success of the
assignment to
- a correct assessment of the CFRM needs and existing capacities in house and among stakeholders
- the participation of the beneficiary and its stakeholders during the assessment and strategy definition as well as the implementation, content dissemination and training
- choosing tools and applications considering carefully the existing capacity to maintain and sustain them within CRFM
- the organisation of a smooth and seamless transition (as for new CRFM emails and web domain, old documents were kept in the old site and linked from the new one), and
- the focus, when training or choosing tools, on concrete uses, applications and support to enhance exiting collaboration and communications processes (instead of the technology for itself). Training in skills related to e-communications or managing virtual groups was more important than focusing on the software used for it.
To fully measure of the success of the initiative , CRFM needs to monitor the use of its Intranet (mail, documents sharing, use of calendar and else) the web site (visits, uploads, events. Fisheries pages updated by stakeholders and new content created) and the working groups dgroups communities activity, over a few months period.
- The initiative raised interest among the CRFM stakeholders on the tools and uses of modern ICTs to manage knowledge sharing, collaboration among partners and selected audience communications, but also that capacity and know how in the region Fisheries Department is low. The project has set up the structures and the facilities and provided the functionalities – but it is only the users it the CFRM staff and the Officers in the Caribbean get gradually empowered and use that can a success of the results.
7 Recommendations There is an immediate need for CFRM executive staff to encourage all users and partners to invest some time to explore and use all the tools made available for concrete tasks, until the learning curve is passed. An additional recommendation is to hire a permanent "CRFM knowledge manager", who can manage the virtual communities, the website content, and moderate and animate forums, blogs, and social networks. That person should be a proficient or expert user of the ICT tools and the website administrator manager, but not necessarily an IT person. Rather someone knowledgeable of the issues, shareholders and work of CRFM, and who can work on developing and disseminating data and content, facilitate and organise sustainable flow of communications as well as help catalyse online collaboration .
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 19 of 40
The integrated visitors’ statistics allow monitoring and evaluation of the upgraded CRFM website by different groups of stakeholders. Also, another measure of results achieved through the usage of the new ICT tools will be number of people subscribed at different CRFM virtual groups, participating in activities of on-line scientific and working groups, visiting and liking CRFM social networks pages. As the overall result of this project will be increased efficiency and productivity of collaboration between CRFM stakeholders, increased visibility on the Web of CRFM activities in the region. CRFM secretariat should undertake an internal evaluation of the usage of the new tools after the initial period of 6 months. This timeframe is sufficient to estimate the uptake both by CRFM collaborators and users.
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 20 of 40
8 ANNEXES
ANNEX 1 – TERMS OF REFERENCE
ACP Fish II – Strengthening fisheries management in ACP states
9 ACP RPF 128 Accounting No. RPR/006/07 – EDF IX
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing
on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region
(CAR-5.1-B20)
TERMS OF REFERENCE
1. BACKGROUND INFORMATION ............................................................................................ 21
1.1 BENEFICIARY COUNTRY ......................................................................................................... 21 1.2 CONTRACTING AUTHORITY .................................................................................................... 21 1.3 RELEVANT COUNTRY BACKGROUND ...................................................................................... 21 1.4 CURRENT STATE OF AFFAIRS IN THE RELEVANT SECTOR ......................................................... 22 1.5 RELATED PROGRAMMES AND OTHER DONOR ACTIVITIES ........................................................ 22
2. OBJECTIVE, PURPOSE & EXPECTED RESULTS .............................................................. 25
2.1 OVERALL OBJECTIVE .............................................................................................................. 25 2.2 PURPOSE ................................................................................................................................. 25 2.3 RESULTS TO BE ACHIEVED BY THE CONSULTANT ................................................................... 25
3. ASSUMPTIONS & RISKS .......................................................................................................... 25
3.1 ASSUMPTIONS UNDERLYING THE PROJECT INTERVENTION ..................................................... 25 3.2 RISKS ...................................................................................................................................... 25
4. SCOPE OF THE WORK ............................................................................................................ 26
4.1 GENERAL ................................................................................................................................ 26 4.2 SPECIFIC ACTIVITIES ............................................................................................................... 27
5. LOGISTICS AND TIMING ........................................................................................................ 29
5.1 LOCATION .............................................................................................................................. 29 5.2 COMMENCEMENT DATE & PERIOD OF IMPLEMENTATION ....................................................... 29
6. REQUIREMENTS ....................................................................................................................... 29
6.1 PERSONNEL ............................................................................................................................ 29 6.2 OFFICE ACCOMMODATION ...................................................................................................... 32 6.3 FACILITIES TO BE PROVIDED BY THE CONSULTANT ................................................................ 32 6.4 EQUIPMENT ............................................................................................................................ 32 6.5 INCIDENTAL EXPENDITURE ..................................................................................................... 32 6.6 EXPENDITURE VERIFICATION .................................................................................................. 33
7. REPORTS ..................................................................................................................................... 34
7.1 REPORTING REQUIREMENTS ................................................................................................... 34 7.2 SUBMISSION & APPROVAL OF REPORTS .................................................................................. 35
8. MONITORING AND EVALUATION ....................................................................................... 35
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 21 of 40
8.1 DEFINITION OF INDICATORS .................................................................................................... 35 8.2 SPECIAL REQUIREMENTS ........................................................................................................ 35
1. BACKGROUND INFORMATION
1.1 Beneficiary countries
The beneficiary countries for this contract are: CARIFORUM countries and the CRFM Secretariat.
1.2 Contracting Authority
ACP Fish II Coordination Unit
36/21 Av. de Tervuren
5th Floor
Brussels 1040, Belgium
Tel.: +32 (0)2.7390060
Fax: +32 (0)2.7390068
1.3 Relevant country background
The CARIFORUM group of countries includes 14 CARICOM member states (Antigua and Barbuda,
The Bahamas, Barbados, Belize, Dominica, Grenada, Guyana, Haiti, Jamaica, St. Kitts and Nevis,
Saint Lucia, St. Vincent and the Grenadines, Suriname, and Trinidad and Tobago) and the Dominican
Republic. The group was established, in July 1973, through the signing of the Treaty of Chaguaramas.
The group was based around two concepts: the Caribbean Community and the Common Market. The
Community was a system to enhance the development and implementation of national policies by
ensuring they were set in a regional framework. There was no supranational authority of the
community which enabled relatively straightforward passage through the national institutions. The
second component was the Common market involving trade and investment integration which had to
be very loosely phrased to ensure the membership of a highly diverse group of states. A smaller group
of the smaller island nations (Antigua and Barbuda, Dominica, Grenada, St. Kitts and Nevis, Saint
Lucia, St. Vincent and the Grenadines, Montserrat and Turks and Caicos and British Virgin islands)
established the Organization of the Eastern Caribbean States (OECS) in 1981 to follow an even deeper
integration programme. In 2001, through the signing of the Revised Treaty of Chaguaramas (the
Revised Treaty) CARICOM members formally agreed and adopted the Caribbean Single Market and
Economy (CSME). Integration in the Caribbean context has remained a challenge and the external
environment has been particularly unforgiving in the period since the revised treaty of 2001.
The 12 island states and 3 larger coastal nations (Belize, Guyana and Suriname) are positioned around
the Caribbean Sea with USA to the north, the Atlantic Ocean to the east, Central and South America to
the west and south. Although there are many similarities in the grouping around culture and history,
their geography may be very different and the present-day social and economic indicators such as
population, per capita income, life expectancy etc. vary enormously, so much so that a distinction is
drawn in membership, identifying less developed countries (LDCs) for special treatment. This
situation of geography and history is a constant challenge to the CARICOM group. Economic
performance within the group also varies, with 2010 seeing strong growth for Suriname (3.8%) and
Guyana (3.6%), contrasting with negative growth recorded for Haiti (-5.1%) and an average of the
non-south American members of 2% for the year5.
5 Caribbean Centre for Money and Finance, June 2011 Newsletter.
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 22 of 40
There are 48 potential maritime boundaries by CARICOM Member States, which enter into 8
maritime boundary delimitation treaties with some boundaries demarcated in both the Caribbean Sea
and the Atlantic Ocean. Guyana and Barbados established a zone of cooperation in the overlapping
outer limits of their jurisdiction. The EEZs of many islands are not fully delimited owing to the close
proximity of neighboring states.
1.4 Current state of affairs in the relevant sector
CARIFORUM states recognize CARICOM as the main vehicle for economic integration in the region,
established in 1973 the founding treaty of Chaguaramas and revised in 2001 to reflect new situations
and objectives. In March 2003, the regional economic integration was given a fisheries component as
CARICOM established the Caribbean Regional Fisheries Mechanism (CRFM) to promote and
facilitate the responsible utilization of the region’s fisheries and other aquatic resources for the
economic and social benefits of the current and future population of the region. The objectives of the
CRFM are: (a) the efficient management and sustainable development of marine and other aquatic
resources within the jurisdiction of Member States; (b) the promotion and establishment of
cooperative arrangements among interested States for the efficient management of shared, straddling
or highly migratory marine and other aquatic resources; and (c) the provision of technical advisory and
consultative services to fisheries divisions of Member States in the development, management and
conservation of their marine and other aquatic resources.
Whilst CRFM may support and bring together a large proportion of the countries in the region, it does
not include all countries in the Caribbean region in its membership. The lack of a unified fisheries (or
other natural resources) management authority in this part of the world is also noted and reflects some
of the issues in broader economic integration. There are a range of bodies responsible to some extent
(spatial or species specific) for fisheries management (e.g. ICCAT, OECS/ESDU, and WECAFC).
There is also the support of development partners (e.g. UN and EU, bilateral partners) to various
economic groupings or fisheries bodies or groups of states.
The institutional environment in the region is no more complex that the ocean environment in the
region including the Caribbean Sea (2.6 million km2) and the central Atlantic region off the coasts of
Latin America, from Suriname to Trinidad and Tobago (310,000 km2). The living resources in the
Caribbean Sea include queen conch, spiny lobster, crabs, mollusks, penaeid shrimps, turtles, marine
mammals, and a variety of fish species such as reef fish, small and medium sized coastal pelagic
species, large migratory pelagic species, and deep slope snapper and groupers. The nature of fisheries
in this region, which stretches from Suriname to Belize and The Bahamas, is varied. It ranges from
pelagic stocks off Trinidad and Tobago, shrimp and ground fish off Guyana and Suriname, reef
species of the Eastern Caribbean, and conch and lobster stocks of Jamaica, The Bahamas, and Belize.
Fish production in CARIFORUM countries was approximately 170,000 MT (average 2001-2006) with
an estimated value of over USD 450 million. The per capita consumption of fish in the region is
between 23-25 kg.
The structure of the sector is characterized by a large artisanal fishery where fishers operate on a
small-scale basis utilizing small boats and limited gear technology (traps, cast nets, and hook and line).
Countries like Barbados, Guyana, Suriname and Trinidad and Tobago have industrial fleets of large,
modern, capital-intensive vessels which operate mainly in offshore areas and targets lobster, conch,
shrimp, tuna, and flying fish. Artisanal catches are sold mainly on the domestic market, while
industrial catches are processed and exported. The recreational fishery includes domestic and
international sport fishing.
The fisheries sector is important for the Caribbean Forum of ACP States (CARIFORUM) as it
provides employment, contributes to food security and export earnings. The sector employs over
182,000 persons, directly and indirectly, mostly from rural villages which lack other income earning
opportunities. The sector earns over USD 150 million per year from exports and saves the region three
times in foreign exchange since the volume of production is four times the volume of export. It
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 23 of 40
accounts for up to 8% of some member state's GDP. The fisheries sector is a major source of protein in
rural communities which have a higher percentage of poverty than the national average. Fishing in the
region complements tourism by providing alternative livelihood options such as tour guiding and
fishing tournaments.
The Caribbean is experiencing enormous challenges in the management of the fisheries resources,
namely: the inadequate capacity to formulate and implement fisheries policies, development and
management strategies; insufficient institutional capacity and resources to support effective
stakeholder participation in fisheries management; insufficient data and manpower for research and
management; and the continued rise in illegal, unreported, and unregulated fishing, both by local and
external vessels that threatens stock sustainability, with the countries having inadequate essential
resources to police their territorial waters. In a region with the geography and history as described
above, and fisheries problems becoming increasingly acute, extra commitment is required if future
resource degradation is to be avoided.
The Agreement establishing the Caribbean Community Common Fisheries Policy (CRFM, 2011) was
recently approved at the 4th CRFM Ministerial Council and identifies a range of key actions through
which member states may ensure sustainable fisheries. Under Article 11, Statistics and Research, some
of the information – related to challenges facing the region and the Competent Agency - is clear and
the relevant parties are required to:
“(a) collect and compile fisheries catch and fishing effort, registration and licensing data as well as
biological, ecological, economic, social, aquaculture and any other relevant data;
(b) conduct research in order to:
i) ascertain the status of fish stocks;
ii) determine the effects of environmental changes on fisheries and aquatic ecosystems;
iii) analyse the effectiveness of management and conservation measures;
iv) evaluate the social and economic performance of fisheries and aquaculture;
v) determine the development potential of underutilised and unutilised fisheries resources; and
vi) otherwise contribute to the fulfilment of an objective of this Agreement;
(c) Develop and maintain national and regional databases relating to (a) and (b) and develop and
adopt appropriate standards for data and information sharing; and
(d) Analyse data and information collected and, subject to any confidentiality requirements, to
disseminate it periodically to Participating Parties and the Competent Agency
(CRFM, 2011)6”
Article 16, Dissemination of Information, deals with aspects of information management related to
sharing of statistical data on fisheries, management programmes, national and regional activities and
involves participation not just by the member states to the Agreement but also by NGOs and other
stakeholders. Clearly the recent adoption of the Agreement recognises the importance of information
of the future management of fisheries resources in the region and envisages a strong role for the
regional fisheries body. Furthermore, Participating States have undertaken to prepare a Protocol on
Data and Information Sharing as part of this agreement (page 13).
The CRFM Secretariat, supporting seventeen member states, is heavily and increasingly dependent on
ICT for effective information sharing and communication. In 2009 the CRFM Secretariat initiated the
preparation of an Information and Communication Strategy and Plan as an overarching framework
document to guide the orderly development of its knowledge exchange and sharing functions. A draft
Communication Strategy was prepared in 2010.
6 Agreement establishing the Caribbean Community Common Fisheries Policy, CRFM, 2011, p8.
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 24 of 40
However, as ICTs develop and new regional agreements are made, the CRFM must ensure its own
operational documents and standard procedures are in line with regional perspectives and to this end
the Communication Strategy requires updating, with specific focus on the IT component. Similarly, as
technologies and platforms develop there is a need to continually update systems and content to
facilitate exchanges between group members and the CRFM website, which will be updated in line
with the identified objectives in the Strategy.
1.5 Related programmes and other donor activities
A number of fisheries-related regional and international agencies operate in the Caribbean region.
They include:
The main regional body, CRFM, is an inter-governmental organization to promote and facilitate
management, conservation and responsible utilization of the region’s fisheries and other aquatic
resources for the economic and social benefits of the current and future population of the region;
The Organization of Eastern Caribbean States/Environment and Sustainable Development Unit
(OECS-ESDU) – assists member states in the sustainable use of natural resources to ensure the
sustainability of the livelihoods of the people of the OECS, including biodiversity management,
protected areas, and environmental management and planning;
Western Central Atlantic Fishery Commission (WECAFC) of the Food and Agriculture
Organization (FAO) – contributes to improved governance through institutional arrangements, and
collects, exchanges, and disseminates statistical, biological, environmental, and socio-economic
data;
Association of Caribbean States (ACS);
United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) and United Nations
Environment Programme (UNEP) – currently implementing the project “Strengthening
Management of the Shared Living Marine Resources of the Caribbean Large Marine Ecosystem
(CLME) and Adjacent Regions. The project aims to assist Caribbean countries improve
management of shared living marine resources through an ecosystem level approach;
The International Commission on Conservation of Atlantic Tuna (ICCAT) - plays an important
role in managing tuna and tuna-like species in the region.
In the conduct of the assignment, the consultant is expected to liaise with the mentioned programmes
or institutions, when appropriate, in order to gather relevant information, to ensure cooperation with
the projects/programmes and to avoid overlapping of activities.
International assistance specifically to the information sub-sector has been limited but there are a
number of key initiatives and the implementation of this task must complement these ongoing
activities. Such initiatives include:
CARIFIS is the Caribbean Fisheries Information System and is a fisheries database currently
being used in the member states of the Caribbean Regional Fisheries Mechanism (CRFM).
The CARIFIS database is used to store information on fishers, fishing vessels, fish catch, and
data collected through biological research programmes;
The GEF funded Caribbean Large Marine Ecosystem project which aims to develop a
comprehensive governance framework for Caribbean living marine resources focusing on
spiny lobster, reef fish, large pelagic, flyingfish, and shrimp and groundfish. The countries are
participating in the implementation of the shrimp and groundfish fishery and the flyingfish
and large pelagic fisheries case study;
ICT4D: A programme in the Directorate of Trade and Economic Integration (TEI) within the
CARICOM Secretariat. The goal of its work programme is to advance the development of the
people of the Caribbean Community using Information and Communication Technologies
(ICT) as a catalyst for the transformation of the Community into a knowledge-based society
and to this end they have completed a strategy7 to achieve these objectives.
7 The Regional Information and Communication Technology (ICT) for Development Strategy, CARICOM
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 25 of 40
2. OBJECTIVE, PURPOSE & EXPECTED RESULTS
2.1 Overall objective
The overall objective of the ACP Fish II Programme is to contribute to the sustainable and equitable
management of fisheries in ACP regions, thus leading to poverty alleviation and improving food
security in ACP States.
2.2 Purpose
The purpose of this contract is to strengthen the capacity of CRFM and fisheries administrations of
CARIFORUM States in fisheries information and knowledge sharing.
2.3 Results to be achieved by the Consultant
The Consultant will achieve the following results as part of this assignment:
1. draft Communication Strategy and Plan for CRFM reviewed and finalised (focusing on ICT
component);
2. CRFM website updated, expanded and operational, in line with the agreed Strategy and
supported by relevant manuals and training;
3. National representatives of CARIFORUM states trained in using new CRFM website and
online interactive tools.
3. ASSUMPTIONS & RISKS
3.1 Assumptions underlying the project intervention
The need for improvements of fisheries information systems of the CRFM has been expressed by the
ACP Fish II Focal Point for CRFM at different stages: initially in the Regional Needs Assessment
Workshops in 2009 and then at different stages as the implementation modalities for Component 5
have been formulated. The CRFM representatives were actively involved in studies and assessments in
the first part of the implementation phase for Component 5 and were part of the assessment visits
made during the second assessment phase.
The assumption is that the beneficiary states in CARIFORUM and the CRFM Secretariat itself, are
well aware of the intervention and are prepared to allocate official hours to its implementation.
National fisheries administrations are expected to enable the identified participants to attend the
training event. Although use of the features in the upgraded website does not require internet access in
the offices, as they can be used outside of the place of work, for maximum utility there should be
connectivity in all FA in member states.
3.2 Risks
Since ACP Fish II is a demand-driven Programme, it is expected that counterpart institutions take all
the necessary measures to ensure the fulfilment of their obligations and responsibilities as set forth
under this project. Failure to meet that requirement is likely to result in the project not achieving the
expected results.
Risks for implementation of this contract are minimised, since the intervention has been indentified in
cooperation with and endorsed by the CRFM on a number of occasions. However, a sudden change in
the political will of FA and/or Government might negatively affect the assignment implementation,
limiting its impact. To prevent such a risk the participatory planning approach adopted in the
development of this intervention will continue throughout the implementation of the assignment, to
ensure the full ownership by local stakeholders and the development of activities and methodology
always coinciding with the FA’s approach.
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 26 of 40
4. SCOPE OF THE WORK
4.1 General
4.1.1 Project description
This assignment will provide focused support to the CRFM Secretariat and Member States to agree
and document goals and targets for the IT component of its Communication Strategy and then, deliver
technical assistance to upgrade and maintain a website whilst providing training to fisheries officers in
an effort to maximise the use of the new found facility and tools. The support from ACP Fish II to the
CRFM will contribute to the achievement of the management goals stated in the recently adopted
Agreement establishing a Common Fisheries Policy8.
The revision and development of the draft Communication Strategy9 is expected to provide clear
objectives in terms of information sharing and communication and a clear identification of target
groups and their information needs. It is anticipated that the revision of the Communication Strategy
should build on the current draft document but will target particularly the ICT component, elucidate
strategies to be followed and include steps to be taken to maximise the opportunities presented in the
ICT sub-sector. The revision will focus on the ICT component and clearly set out how, in the next 3 –
5 years, the CRFM Secretariat will utilise the opportunities presented by the IT sub-sector to better
deliver services to the member states and carry out the mandate provided in the CRFM agreement and
the Common Fisheries Policy document. The KE team will consult with the Fisheries Administration
in Trinidad and Tobago (as host of the Fisheries Management Information System – FISMIS10
) and
the UWI/CERMES in Barbados as part of this review process. As part of the consultation process with
the CRFM, the KE team will visit the CRFM Eastern Caribbean Office in Saint Vincent and the
Grenadines. This Communication Strategy will clearly set out the current situation facing information
exchange in the region (e.g. in existing region-wide initiatives such as CARIFIS, CLME and others),
the required changes in the website, the target audience for the changes and the objectives of making
the changes. Capacity building requirements, to be partially implemented in this assignment, will also
be addressed in this strategy. The Communication Strategy will be prepared in line with international
best practice and will be completed during the first phase of the assignment. The first phase will be
completed with a Regional Technical Consultation in Belize at which the draft strategy is reviewed by
Technical Officers.
The second phase of the assignment will involve the upgrade of the CRFM website using CMS
software and development of associated systems in line with the direction agreed in the
Communication Strategy. Whilst the detail of the website upgrade remains to be elucidated by the
revised ICT/Communication Strategy, it is expected that the Consultant should consider adding the
following tools to the system:
a. The ability to upload all library documents to the website and facilitate download by target
readership;
b. The ability to facilitate website searches;
c. The ability to offer translation of text on website pages into French, Spanish, and Dutch
(not text of documents);
d. Online discussion (discussion board) and the ability to share and edit documents;
e. Video conferencing (similar to MSN chat) for presentations delivery of training and
discussion;
f. Blog to post comments and possible e-groups (e.g., technical e-group, fisherfolk e-group,
management e-group);
g. The ability to access depository of fisheries data and information;
8 Agreement Establishing the Caribbean Common Fisheries Policy, CRFM, 2011 9 Draft CRFM Communication Strategy, Carmel Haynes, 2010 10 FISMIS: a database system comprising a series of bibliographic databases and references and is art of the CRFM “system”
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 27 of 40
h. Links to all FAs, regional organizations, and other national departments with interest in
fisheries; regional and international legal fisheries instruments; and any other based on the
advice of the experts;
i. Profile page for different topics/issues/working groups where registered users can join
different groups and share data and documents, and discuss/collaborate on key topics.
The training component for key system managers and users in the region will develop capacity in the
use of the updated CRFM website and various website tools to facilitate improved knowledge
exchange at the regional level. As an additional benefit, the training will develop the capacity of
participants to refine their own websites (which can be linked to the CRFM Secretariat’s site) for FAs.
A user manual will be prepared for staff of the FAs of the CARIFORUM states using the CRFM
website for regional information sharing.
As such the training component will be conducted in two parts:
Firstly, on-the-job training will be provided (to CRFM Secretariat staff including the webmaster) to
ensure the capacity to manage and maintain the revised website exists within the CRFM team. The
staff will be trained in management and user tasks such as how to develop simple YouTube type video
and slide presentations for uploading and display on the website. This on-the-job training will be
conducted at the CRFM Secretariat offices in Belize and St. Vincent and the Grenadines providing an
opportunity for the system to be tested at both sites.
Secondly, key users and managers from the member states will be trained in using the revised website,
particularly the use of online interaction tools, to ensure that opportunities for information and
knowledge exchange are maximised. One Senior Fisheries Officer and one Data
Manager/Communications Officer from each country will participate in the training. The training will
be based on the manual prepared.
The Key Expert team will be supported by another expert tasked to organise, execute and report the
implementation of the Regional Technical Consultation and the Regional Training.
4.1.2 Geographical area to be covered
The project will cover Antigua and Barbuda, Barbados, The Bahamas, Belize, Dominica, Dominican
Republic, Grenada, Guyana, Haiti, Jamaica, St. Kitts and Nevis, Saint Lucia, St. Vincent and the
Grenadines, Suriname, and Trinidad and Tobago as members of CARIFORUM.
4.1.3 Target groups
Target groups for this project are officers of the CRFM Secretariat in Belize and Saint Vincent and the
Grenadines, representatives of national fisheries management institutions with a direct role and
responsibility in information management.
4.2 Specific activities
4.2.1. Specific activities
The Consultant will undertake the following activities:
1. Be briefed by ACP Fish II programme and CRFM staff and officers;
2. Conduct background literature review and consultations (with visits to regional and national
databanks such as UWI – CERMES (Barbados) and FISMIS (Trinidad and Tobago)) and
analysis to enable an assessment of the information sharing activities and communication of
CRFM and a critical review of the 2009 Communication Strategy for CRFM;
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 28 of 40
3. Prepare a revised draft Communications Strategy for CRFM (focusing on ICT
communications and the website component);
4. Organise and facilitate one Regional Technical Consultation in Belize (20 people, 2 days) of
key fisheries and IT stakeholders to review and endorse the CRFM Communication Strategy
as improved by the Consultant;
5. Upgrade CRFM website using CMS software to include, inter alia, the tools identified in the
agreed Communication Strategy. A number of these tools are noted in section 4.1.1 The cost
of software, licenses and improved bandwidth can be procured using the incidental budget;
6. Prepare one manual for maintenance and management of the new website (for webmaster &
administrators at CRFM) and one manual for users of the website produced;
7. Develop training outline and deliver OJT training (up to 5 days) to webmaster, administrators
and technical staff at CRFM Secretariat in Belize and Saint Vincent and the Grenadines;;
8. Training workshop – train participants in using the new CRFM website; where comments are
provided by countries, update website and finalize the design of the website. Participants -
CARIFORUM states and other resource institutions using the new CRFM website;
participants should be one Senior Fisheries Officer and one Technical staff member
responsible for the actual implementation (e.g. Communications officer or Data Manager) of
information exchange activities within the FA. The training workshop for 3 days with 35
participants from CARIFORUM states, CRFM, CNFO, UWI-CERMES will take place in
Saint Vincent and the Grenadines;
9. Prepare Training Report including all materials prepared and used;
10. Prepare Final Technical Reports as required.
The draft Communication strategy (focusing on IT) will be translated into French and Spanish. The
User Manuals for the regional training will be available in French and Spanish.
4.2.2. Communication and project visibility
a) ACP Fish II projects should follow the EU requirements and guidelines for communication
and visibility available on the Programme website at http://acpfish2-
eu.org/index.php?page=templates&hl=en. The CU will provide ACP Fish II templates for
various communication products.
b) When validation workshops (where technical documents are presented to stakeholders for
validation) are needed, given their importance for disseminating the results of the Project and
ACP Fish II Programme the following activities will be requested:
1) The Consultant will provide all necessary information in press-release style
(“information note”) on the project objectives and results, the activities to undertake,
the main axes or strategic goals proposed and the future role of the beneficiaries;
2) The RFB will receive the information note at least 3 days before the workshop,
through their Government communication/press bodies or officials, in order to
mobilise local media and to assure full coverage of the event. Financial support to
media coverage is included in the “Incidental Expenditure”. Receipt(s) of the incurred
cost for media coverage will be required to verify the costs incurred.
c) The consultant will provide photographic record of the workshop activities.
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 29 of 40
4.3 Project management
4.3.1 Responsible body
The Coordination Unit (CU) of the ACP Fish II Programme, based in Brussels, on behalf of the ACP
Secretariat is responsible for managing the implementation of this assignment.
4.3.2 Management structure
The ACP Fish II Programme is implemented through the CU in Brussels and six Regional Facilitation
Units (RFUs) across the ACP States. The RFU in Belize City, Belize, covering ACP Member States in
the Caribbean region will closely supervise the implementation of this intervention and equally
monitor its execution pursuant to these Terms of Reference. For the purposes of this assignment, the
ACP Fish II Programme Coordinator will act as the Project Manager.
All contractual communications including requests for contract modifications or changes to the Terms
of Reference during the execution period of the contract must be addressed with a formal request to
the CU and copied to the RFU. Beneficiaries’ support for these changes is required.
4.3.3 Facilities to be provided by the Contracting Authority and/or other parties
Not applicable
5. LOGISTICS AND TIMING
5.1 Location
The place of posting will be Belize City, Belize. Missions are expected to be carried out to CRFM
Eastern Caribbean Office in Saint Vincent and the Grenadines (two visits), UWI/CERMES (Barbados)
and the Fisheries Division (Trinidad and Tobago). The Regional Technical Consultation will be held
in Belize City and the Training Workshop will be carried out in Saint Vincent and the Grenadines.
5.2 Commencement date & Period of implementation
The intended commencement date of this assignment is 21 August 2012 and the period of
implementation of field activities will be five (5) months from the date of signature of the contract.
Please refer to Articles 4 and 5 of the Special Conditions for the actual commencement date and period
of implementation.
6. REQUIREMENTS
6.1 Personnel
6.1.1 Key experts
All experts who have a crucial role in implementing this assignment are referred to as key experts. The
profiles of the key experts for this contract are as follows:
Key Expert 1: Communication Specialist and Team leader
Qualifications and skills
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 30 of 40
Degree, or equivalent experience in communications, communications management,
marketing strategies, or a field directly related to the assignment;
The expert should have a high level of proficiency in written and spoken English.
Preferably experience as a Team Leader.
General professional experience
Minimum of 8 years of international experience in communications planning and
management;
Demonstrated communication, report writing and project management skills.
Specific professional experience
Previous experience (minimum 3 assignments) in strategic planning in information
management and communication and/or involvement in developing fisheries information
systems and strategies and/or websites with online interaction tools;
Experience working in the Caribbean and completion of assignments in the fisheries or natural
resources sector will be an advantage;
Experience in carrying out consultancy assignments for the EU or other equivalent
international development organisations (minimum 3 assignments).
The indicative number of missions, requiring overnights, for this expert will be 3. There will be in-
country field visits outside the normal place of posting not requiring overnights for this expert.
Key Expert 2: Information Technology Specialist
Qualifications and skills
A degree or equivalent practical experience, in Information Technology and/or Information
Management Communications or New Media;
The expert should have a high level of proficiency in written and spoken English.
General professional experience
Minimum 5 years of international experience in web design, development and maintenance;
Excellent communication, report-writing.
Specific professional experience
Minimum 3 years of international experience in web design, development and maintenance,
with track record of successful web design activities;
Preferably previous experience in the Caribbean region and experience in fisheries and/or
natural resource management projects.
The indicative number of missions, requiring overnights, for this expert will be 3. There will be in-
country field visits outside the normal place of posting not requiring overnights for this expert.
Indicative number of working days by expert and task
No. Indicative Task
Key Expert
1 (Days) Key Expert 2
(Days)
1.1 Briefing by ACP Fish II and preparatory activities, reviews 2 2
1.2 Consultations for update of Communication strategy (IT
focused) 9 5
1.3 Regional Technical Workshop 3 2
1.4 Provision of advice 3 3
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 31 of 40
1.5 Upgrading of website 0 13
1.6 Preparation of users manuals and on the job training 5 10
1.7 Training preparation, delivery and reporting 10 7
1.8 Team Leader tasks 5 0
1.9 Project technical reporting 5 2
Total 42 44
Additional information
a) Key Experts are expected to spend at least 60% of the total indicative number of working days
in the countries covered by this assignment;
b) Note that civil servants and other staff of the public administration of the beneficiary country
cannot be recruited as experts, unless prior written approval has been obtained from the
European Commission;
c) The Consultant must complete a timesheet using the ACP Fish II template provided by the CU
at the start of the implementation period. The Consultant is entitled to work a maximum of 6
days per week. Mobilisation and demobilisation days will not be considered as working days.
6.1.2 Other experts
The Consultant may hire, for a period not exceeding 10 days, the services of a specialist Event Co-
ordinator to organise the events required for the successful completion of this assignment. More so
than in other ACP Regions the degree of organisation and co-ordination required to arrange, execute
and report regional meetings and trainings involving inter-island travel in the Caribbean region,
demands that specific local expertise be mobilised to ensure that these tasks do not reduce the
effectiveness of the technical inputs from the Key Experts.
The expert will have the following profile:
Qualifications and skills
High School diploma in Administration or equivalent;
Fluency in spoken and written English
General professional experience
At least three years of experience in event management and coordination.
Specific professional experience
Experience in the Caribbean region;
Expertise in event communication is an advantage.
The indicative number of missions outside the normal place of posting requiring overnights for this
expert is 1. There will be in-country field visits outside the normal place of posting that do not require
overnights for this expert.
CVs for experts other than the KE are not examined prior to the signature of the contract. They should
not have been included in tenders. The Consultant shall select and hire other experts as required
according to the profile identified in these Terms of Reference. They must indicate clearly which
profile they have so it is clear which fee rate in the budget breakdown will apply. All experts must be
independent and free from conflicts of interest in the responsibilities accorded to them.
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 32 of 40
The selection procedures used by the Consultant to select these other experts shall be transparent, and
shall be based on pre-defined criteria, including professional qualifications, language skills and work
experience. The findings of the selection panel shall be recorded. The selected experts shall be subject
to approval by the Contracting Authority.
Note that civil servants and other staff of the public administration of the beneficiary country cannot
be recruited as experts, unless prior written approval has been obtained from the European
Commission.
6.1.3 Support staff & backstopping
Backstopping costs are considered to be included in the fee rates of the experts.
6.2 Office accommodation
Office accommodation of a reasonable standard will be provided by the CRFM in Belize.
6.3 Facilities to be provided by the Consultant
The Consultant shall ensure that experts are adequately supported and equipped (transport, laptop,
printing services, internet and appropriate communication tools). In particular it shall ensure that there
is sufficient administrative, secretarial and interpreting provision to enable experts to concentrate on
their primary responsibilities. It must also transfer funds as necessary to support its activities under the
assignment and to ensure that its employees are paid regularly and in a timely fashion.
If the Consultant is a consortium, the arrangements should allow for the maximum flexibility in
project implementation. Arrangements offering each consortium member a fixed percentage of the
work to be undertaken under the contract should be avoided.
6.4 Equipment
No equipment is to be purchased on behalf of the Contracting Authority or beneficiary country as part
of this service contract or transferred to the Contracting Authority or beneficiary country at the end of
the contract. Any equipment related to this contract which is to be acquired by the beneficiary country
must be purchased by means of a separate supply tender procedure.
6.5 Incidental expenditure
The Provision for incidental expenditure covers the ancillary and exceptional eligible expenditure
incurred under this contract. It cannot be used for costs which should be covered by the Consultant as
part of its fee rates, as specified above. Its use is governed by the provisions in the General Conditions
and the notes in Annex V of the contract. It covers:
a) KEY EXPERTS
Travel costs and subsistence allowances for missions, outside the normal place of posting and
requiring overnights, to be undertaken as part of this contract;
Travel costs for field visits for the Key Experts (car or boat rental, fuel and domestic flights or
other appropriate means of transport).
b) WORKSHOP/TRAINING/CONSULTATIONS ORGANISATION
The cost of organisation of the Regional Technical Consultation Training Workshop including
cost for venue, communication and media activities, transport (domestic travel or car or boat
rental to/from);
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 33 of 40
The payment of a lump-sum to participants requiring an overnight stay to cover accommodation
and meals. This lump-sum payment will be up to 150 EUR and must not exceed the published
EU per diem rate for the country;
The payment of a lump sum, up to 20% of the published EU per diem rate for the country, to all
participants not requiring an overnight stay, to cover the cost of transport and meals;
In the two cases above, an attendance list signed by each participant and a separate list stating that
the lump-sum was received (with an indication of the amount) shall be used to justify the
expenditure.
c) FUNDING OF NATIONAL ADMINISTRATION/REGIONAL FISHERIES BODIES
OFFICERS ACCOMPANYING KEY EXPERTS ON MISSIONS
Exceptionally, the cost of flights, accommodation and meals for the representatives of
fisheries administrations or regional fisheries bodies who may accompany the Key Experts on
regional or national missions under the following conditions:
i) Request of a prior approval to the CU, attaching to this request the declaration issued
by fisheries administrations or regional fisheries bodies stating that the cost of this
extra activity for their officers cannot be covered given the internal budget
restrictions. The CRFM should acknowledge, despite this, the need of the attendance
of its officer for effective project implementation; ii) The total cost for accommodation and meals based on actual cost (invoices to be
provided) cannot exceed the EU per diem rate for the country;
iii) If private or administration’s means of transport are used by the representatives of the
fisheries administrations or regional fisheries bodies accompanying the Key Experts on
national missions, fuel cost will be reimbursed upon receipt of the officer’s
reimbursement request based on distance travelled and local price for fuel per unit.
d) TRANSLATION
Interpretation and translation services for French and Spanish participants in the training;
Translation of the draft Communications Strategy (focusing on ICT) to French and Spanish;
Translation of website user and training manuals to French and Spanish.
e) OTHER
The cost of software, licenses and improved bandwidth (for up to 24 months) necessary to
achieve the immediate project results and purpose;
The costs of instructional materials (e.g. prepared manuals) and tools as an integral component
for the training event;
The cost of producing communication items, printing charts, maps and other technical
documents outside normal editing formats to be used in Consultation and Training;
The cost of producing up to fifteen extra copies of the Final Technical Report, to be presented
to the Regional Fisheries Body.
The Provision for incidental expenditure for this contract is EUR 102.698,00 This amount must be
included without modification in the Budget breakdown.
8.1 6.6 Expenditure verification
The Provision for expenditure verification relates to the fees of the auditor who has been charged with
the expenditure verification of this contract in order to proceed with the payment of further pre-
financing instalments if any and/or interim payments if any.
The Provision for expenditure verification for this contract is 1.500,00 EUR. This amount must be
included without modification in the Budget breakdown. This provision cannot be decreased but can
be increased during the execution of the contract.
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 34 of 40
7. REPORTS
7.1 Reporting requirements
Please refer to Article 26 of the General Conditions. There must be a final report, a final invoice and
the financial report accompanied by an expenditure verification report at the end of the period of
implementation of the tasks. The approved Final Technical Report (FTR) must be annexed to the Final
Report (FR). The final report must be submitted to the CU after receiving the approval of the Final
Technical Report (FTR). Note that this final report is additional to any required in Section 4.2 of these
Terms of Reference.
The Final Report (FR) shall consist of a narrative section and a financial section. The financial section
must contain details of the time inputs of the experts, of the incidental expenditure and of the provision
for expenditure verification.
To summarise, the Consultant shall provide the following reports:
Name of report Content Time of submission
Inception Report Maximum of 10 pages in
length including an analysis of
existing situation and
workplan for the project.
No later than 10 days after
the first Expert arriving in
the place of posting for the
first time to the CRFM, RFU
and CU. Comments, if any,
on the IR must be provided
within 5 days from receipt;
Interim Technical Report
(ITR)
To include agreed
Communication Strategy
(focusing on ICT) and detailed
plans for the website upgrade.
No later than 10 days after
the Regional Technical
Consultation to the CRFM,
RFU and CU. Comments, if
any, on the IR must be
provided within 5 days from
receipt.
Draft Final Technical
Report
Description of achievements,
problems encountered,
recommendations and
technical proposals suggested
by the consultant and all
technical deliverables.
Within one week of the
experts leaving the country
on conclusion of the
assignment. to the CRFM,
RFU and CU. Comments on
the draft FTR, if any, must
be provided by the RFU, CU
and CRFM within 14 days
Final Technical Report Draft FTR, taking into account
changes and comments from
the RFU, CU and CRFM.
Within 10 days after
receiving comments on the
DFTR. If no comments on
the report are given within
the time limit of 14 days, the
DFTR shall be considered as
the FTR.
Final Report Short description of
achievements including
Within 1 month of receiving
the approval of the FTR.
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 35 of 40
problems encountered and
recommendations and
suggestions; together with the
Final Technical Report and a
final invoice and the financial
report accompanied by the
expenditure verification
report.
The formats of technical reports are available on the ACP Fish II web site at http://acpfish2-
eu.org/index.php?page=templates&hl=en. All technical reports must follow the requested templates.
7.2 Submission & approval of reports
One electronic copy of the reports referred to above must be submitted to the Project Manager
identified in the contract. Two hard copies of the approved Final Technical Report (FTR) must be
submitted to the Project Manager identified in the contract (CU), one hard copy to the RFU and two
hard copies to the CRFM. The original and a hard copy of the Final Report (FR) must be submitted to
the CU together with its annexes and supporting documents. All Reports must be written in English.
The Project Manager is responsible for approving the reports. The cost of producing such material will
be included in the fees.
8. MONITORING AND EVALUATION
8.1 Definition of indicators
The results to be achieved by the Consultant are included in Section 2.3 above. Progress to achieving
these results will be measured through the following indicators:
i. Quality of experts (in terms of demonstrated skills and experience) fielded
ii. Speed of mobilisation to the beneficiary country will indicate a positive start of the
assignment;
iii. Identification of methodology, issues and problems as recorded in the Inception Report;
iv. Reported involvement and degree of satisfaction of the stakeholders in conduct of activities;
v. Level of attendance at the technical consultation and regional training session;
vi. Nature and quality of training evaluation reports from participants;
vii. Technical quality and functionality of the website;
viii. Number and nature of comments received on the Draft Final Technical Report;
The Consultant may suggest additional monitoring tools for the contract duration.
8.2 Special requirements
Not applicable.
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 36 of 40
ANNEX 2 – ITINERARY
Inception Phase
Both Experts followed the same schedule for their first mission on the field that enabled them
to carry out the necessary consultations and data and documentation revision.
Date Activity
19/11/2012 Communication Strategy and website revision – Belize
20/11/2012 Kick-off meeting in Belize
21/11/2012 Travel to Trinidad and Tobago and preparation of Inception Report
22/11/2012 Meetings with Stakeholders – Trinidad and Tobago
23/11/2012 Meetings with Stakeholders – Trinidad and Tobago
24/11/2012 Communication Strategy and website revision – Trinidad and Tobago
25/11/2013 Travel to Barbados
26/11/2012 Meetings with Stakeholders - Barbados
27/11/2012 Meetings with Stakeholders - Barbados
28/11/2012 Travel to Saint Vincent and preparation of Inception Report
29/11/2012 Meetings with Stakeholders – Saint Vincent and the Grenadines
30/11/2012 Meetings with Stakeholders – Saint Vincent and the Grenadines
Flight home KE2
01/12/2012 Communication strategy revision – Saint Vincent and the Grenadines,
Flight home TL 9
Implementation Phase
The implementation phase was carried out first separately and then jointly by the two key
experts. The division of the technical team between Belize and Saint Vincent allowed an on-
job training for both CRFM offices as well as a common tools revision and finalization before
training users during the Regional workshop in Saint Vincent and the Grenadines.
Date Activity
10/03/2013 Arrival in Belize – KE2
12/03/2013 Finalize website and tools development – Belize (KE2)
13/03/2013 On-job training – Belize (KE2)
14/03/2013 On-job training – Belize (KE2)
15/03/2013 On-job training – Belize (KE2)
18/03/2013 On-job training – Belize (KE2) and Saint Vincent (TL)
19/03/2013 On-job training – Belize (KE2) and Saint Vincent (TL)
20/03/2013 On-job training – Saint Vincent (TL) and travel to Belize – (KE2)
21/03/2013 On-job training – Saint Vincent (TL and KE2), finalize website (KE2)
22/13/2013 On-job training – Saint Vincent (TL and KE2), finalize website (KE2)
23/11/2012 Prepare technical aspects of Regional Training Workshop – Saint Vincent
(TL and KE2)
25/03/2013 Cariforum Regional Training Workshop – Belize (TL and KE2)
26/03/2013 Cariforum Regional Training Workshop – Belize (TL and KE2)
27/03/2013 Cariforum Regional Training Workshop – Belize (TL and KE2)
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 37 of 40
ANNEX 3 – INSTITUTIONS AND INDIVIDUALS CONSULTED
BELIZE: Nov 19-21 Date, Organization Persons
CRFM
November 20, 2012, 9h00 Princess Margaret Drive, P.O. Box 642 Belize City, Belize, Central America Tel: 501-223-4443
Mr Milton Haughton, Executive Director [email protected] Mr Delmar Lanza, Finance and Administration Manager [email protected] Ms Sherlene E. Audinett Senior Secretary [email protected] November 20, 15h30 Mr Lorne Solis, Web designer [email protected]
ACP Fish II RTU
November 19, 2012, 9h00 Fisheries Compound, P.O. Box 1944, Princess Margaret drive Belize City, Belize, Central America Tel: 501-223-2974
Ms Sandra Grant, Regional Manager Caribbean Office [email protected] Mr John Purvis, Fisheries Policy Expert [email protected]
Belize Fisheries Authorities
November 20, 2012, 14h00 Fisheries Compound Princess Margaret Drive, Belize city, Belize
Mr. George Myvett, aquaculture coordinator, Senior fisheries officer [email protected]
CNFO
November 20, 2012, 15h00 Executive Secretary of the Belize Fishermen Cooperative Association Regional coordination of the Caribbean Network of Fisherfolks Organisation (CNFO)
Ms Nadine NEMHARD
Regional Administrator of the CNFO [email protected]
Belize Telemedia Limited
November 21, 2012, 9h45 Corporate headquarters St. Thomas street P.P. Box 603, Belize City, Belize Tel: (+501) –223 8162
Mrs Zoila Casanova Hope, Sales Manager [email protected] Mrs Tiffany Wagner, Sales Representative [email protected]
TRINIDAD: Nov 22-23
Trinidad and Tobago Fisheries Division
November 22, 2012, 9h00 Fisheries Extension Office 35 Cipriani Boulevard Newtown Port of Spain Trinidad, West Indies Tel. (868) 623-8525/6028
Mrs Chan Anshin, Director Ms. Lara Ferreira, Fisheries Officer [email protected] Ms. Elizabeth Mohammed, Senior Fisheries Officer, [email protected]
Research Unit of Fisheries Division
November 22, 2012, 12h00 FISMIS, Chagaram, Trinidad
Ms Aisha, FISMIS Library Manager Mrs, Fisheries Data Entry person
CANARI Communication by e-mail and phone (no face to face meeting)
Mrs Keisha Sandy, Technical Officer - [email protected] Mrs Celeste Chariandy, Senior
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 38 of 40
Building 7, Unit 8, Fernandes Industrial Centre Eastern Main Road, Laventille, Trinidad, West Indies Phone: 1-868-626-6062 Fax: 1-868-626-1788 http://www.canari.org E-mail: [email protected]
Technical Officer - [email protected] Nicole Leotaud, Executive Director - [email protected]
CNFO-CU and TTUFF
November 23, 2012, 10h00 Caribbean Network of Fisherfolk Organizations / Trinidad and Tobago Address: Upper Village, Blanchisseuse, Trinidad Tel: 868 374 7520
Mr Joslyn Lee Quay, CNFO-CU Deputy [email protected]
UWI /CIRP
November 23, 2012, 15h00 University of West Indies
Dr Kim Mallalieu [email protected]
BARBADOS Nov 26-27
Barbados Fisheries Division
November 26, 2012, 9h30 Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development, Fisheries Division, Princess Alice Highway, Bridgetown, Barbados Tel: (246) 427 8480
Mr Stephen Willoughby, Executive Director, [email protected] Mrs Joyce Leslie, [email protected] Mr Adriel Jackman, Fisheries Assistant, [email protected] Mr Chris Parker, Fisheries Officer
FAO
November 27, 2012, 9h00 FAO Subregional Office for the Caribbean United Nations house / FAOSLC, Marine Gardens, Hastings, Chris Church, BB11000, Barbados (1 + 246) 426 7111/426 7110
Raymon VanAnrooy, Fisheries and Aquaculture Officer, [email protected]
BANUFO fisherfolks
November 28, 2012, 11h00 Barbados National Union of Fisherfolk Organizations, c/o Fisheries Division, Princess Alice Highwayg, St. Michael, Bridge Town, Barbados, Tel: 246 268 7168, 246 433 BARNUFO 246 426 5189
Mrs Vernel Nicholls, President, [email protected]
EU Delegation
November 29, 2012, 15h15 EU Delegation Barbados Hastings Main Road, Christ Church, Barbados, West Indies Tel (1-246) 434 8501
Mr Koen Rossel-Cambier, Project Officer, [email protected] Mr. Zissimos Vergos, Head of Social Development Section [email protected]
UWI CERMES
November 29, 2012, 13h00 Centre for Resource Management and Environmental Studies (CERMES), University of the West Indies, Cave Hill Campus, St Michael, Barbados, W.I, BB11000 Telephone: (246) 417-4316, Fax: (246) 424-4204 E-mail: [email protected]
Mrs. Hazel Oxenford, Professor [email protected] ; Patrick McConney, Professor [email protected]
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 39 of 40
ST VINCENT: Nov 29 to Dec 3
CRFM
Thursday 29, 2012, 9h00, 14h00
CRFM Secretariat Kingstown, St. Vincent and the Grenadines Halifax Street, Kingstown, St Vincent and the Grenadines Tel: +1-784-457-3475
Dr. Susan Singh-Renton, Deputy Executive Director, [email protected]
Mrs. June Masters, Statistics and Information Analyst, [email protected] Mr Turd Philips, Fisheries Management Mrs Pam Guibson, Executive Secretary
Fisheries Division of Saint Vincent and the Grenadines
Thursday 29, 2012, 11h30 Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries Kingstown, St. Vincent and the Grenadines Tel: (784) 456 2738
Mrs Jennifer Cruickshan-Howard, acting Chief Fisheries Officer Mrs Raymond Ryan, Executive Director Mrs Sharine-Jadine Jackson, Senior Fisheries Assistant on Data [email protected]
Fisher folks Association:
Thursday 29, 2012, 15h30 Kingstown Fish Market
Mr Eocen Victory, President, cell: 784 529 2127 [email protected] , [email protected]
Strengthening the capacity of CRFM and its member states for information and knowledge sharing on sustainable management of fisheries in the Caribbean region. Final Technical Report by PBLH International Consulting SPRL 40 of 40
ANNEX 4 – CD/DVD
The following documents can be found on the CD:
0. Inception Report with annexes
1. The final ICT Communication Strategy
2. Plan for Website Upgrade
3. Revised 2010 Draft Communication Strategy
4. OJT Programme and Training presentations
5. Workshops programmes, lists of participants and presentations
6. Communication and Visibility Reports and Supports
7. Photos
ANNEX 5 – USERS GUIDE
The Users guide can be found as a separate document (Document 1).
ANNEX 6 – USERS MANUAL
The Website end users manual can be found as a separate document (Document 2).
ANNEX 7 – ADMINISTRATORS MANUAL
The Administrators manual can be found as a separate document (Document 3).