Story Construction in the Blind Assassin
-
Upload
maielgebali -
Category
Documents
-
view
219 -
download
0
Transcript of Story Construction in the Blind Assassin
-
8/10/2019 Story Construction in the Blind Assassin
1/21
Barbara Dancygier
The University of British Colum bia
Narrative Anchors and
the Processes of Story Construction:
The C ase of Margaret Atw oo d s The Blind Assassin
Linguistic theory has often prompted new ways of addressing some of the central
questions of stylistic analysis (to mention only the emergence of discourse analysis
or pragm atics). The issues of correlations between form and function, which have
been crucial to analyses of
style,
have recently been given a new form through the
cogn itive linguists focus on the mechanisms ofmeaning construction.The term
was coinedtorepresent the fact that describing the senses of simple linguistic forms
cannot fully account for the resulting interpretation of complex expression w hich
contains them. Instead, words and other linguistic forms can be treated as prompts
for the construction of meaning, and the analys t s task is both to identify the
meaning chunks the expressions prompt, and, perhaps more importantly, to
describe the processes which explain the construction of the higher levels of
meaning.
Recent proposals have also extended stylistic analysis in ways which give
more focus to cognitive considerations (cf. Semino and Culpeper, Stockwell),
enriching our understanding of how vocabulary and sentence structure choices
reflect conceptual constructs (consider the work on metaphor and blending,
schem as, poetic forms, or speech and though t represen tation). It appears, then, that
cognitive considerations are enhancing our understanding of both specific
linguistic choices and general conceptual strategies involved in the construction of
meaning.
In retrospect, the definitive works on stylistic analysis, such as Leech and
Short s Style in Fiction were the first to talk in clear theoretical terms about
mean ing construction in a literary text. And indeed, literary discou rse is a perfect
exam ple of
n
expression mode where the emerging interpretation relies on the use
of specific expressions, but cannot be fully explained through those expressions
-
8/10/2019 Story Construction in the Blind Assassin
2/21
134 Barbara Dancygier
available can be naturally applied to narrative discourse. However, two
interlocking frameworks which have emerged in the last twenty years, mental
spaces and blending theories, show significant promise in this respect (see, for
exam ple, Sanders and Redeker; Oakley; Turner Doub le-scope Stories; Semino
A Cognitive Stylistic Ap proach, Blending and Charac ters, Text wo rlds,
Dancygier Identity and Perspective, Visual View point, Blending and
Narrative ).
In this paper, I extend the basic concepts of mental spaces theory to identify
some of the aspects of meaning construction in fragmented narratives. Using
Margaret Atwood's The Blind ssassinas an example, I introduce the concept of
narrative anchors to describe some of the mechanisms which underlie the
construction of a cohe rent story out of several substories and explain som e of the
sources of various understandings of the text individual readers may arrive at.
1.
Story Structure
The authorial choices in sequencing the presentation of the story may rely on
different organizational principles. While time seems to be invariably important in
those choices, other factors often disturb the temporal sequence. In fact,
contem porary fiction often experim ents with the presentation of the story in ways
which deliberately make the reader's task harder. Disruptions affect all areas of
story construction temporal organization, continued identity of characters,
boundaries between fact and im agination, etc. And yet, in spite of llthe intricacy,
most readers have no difficulty in understanding the underlying story, and often
enjoy solving the puzzles presented by the text.
The disrupted form of many contemporary narratives and the resulting
challenges to narrative comprehension call for an elaboration of one oftheprimary
categories of classical narratology the distinction between thestoryon the one
hand and textanddiscourseon the other.'
W hile the various aspects ofthe textual surface have been discussed in much
detail, the story remains an under-defined concept, in spite of emerg ing research
in cognitive narratology where the underlying nature of story-telling is in focus.
Recen t work by Herm an ( Stories as a To ol ), for exam ple, discusses stori es as
tools supporting important aspects of conceptualizing experience. The narrative
form, in Herman's discussion, prompts for structuring experiences in specific
ways,such as distinguishing parts, or chunks, seeking causal explanations and
-
8/10/2019 Story Construction in the Blind Assassin
3/21
Narrative Anchors 135
In classical na rratology, for com parison, a story is a largely intuitive concep t,
defined primarily by a sequence of events (Chatman
S tory and
Discourse;
Coming
to Terms .
The sequentiality of the story as a concept builds on the most basic
unde rstanding of narrativity as temporal series of connected events, leading from
some initial state to the final one. What is not discussed too often, though, is the
very complexity of the mental leap from such a sequence to the story as it is told in
the text, with its coheren ce and causal organization. Furtherm ore, the very concept
of what constitutes a
narrative event
is an important issue, in view of significant
differences among agentive acts, mental states, experiential events, etc. What
emerges from the discussions is the ambiguity of the term story , between the
characteristics of
story as a conceptualization device in Herman's sense, and the
specific story as it emerges from the text telling it. I will refer to the former generic
concep t as story-G, and to the narrative construct em erging from a specific text as
story-S,
and attempt to clarify the processes which yield story-S from the
interaction of the text and the principles of story-G.
There are num erous questions regarding the cognitive aspects of story-S. T he
primary one is what we might metaphorically refer to as the loca tion ofthestory.
It can reside only in two place s : the text or the rea de r's mind . The text seems to
be the assumed default choice, very much in the same way as folk semantics has
meaning residing in the words. The words as containers for me aning idea is
central to what is now known as the Conduit Metaphor (cf. Reddy, Lakoff and
Johnson), whereby speakers package the intended meaning into language
express ions for hearers to receive. If, alternately, we claim that the story resides in
the reader's mind, then how did it get there? The text (or texts) should be
responsible for its construction, though there is no one-to-one correspondence
between textual fragments and story elemen ts. As an exam ple, consider
The Great
Gatsbys
crucial event M yrtle W ilson's death. The story -S makes Daisy
responsible for it, since she drove the car that hit Myrtle, but the text does not
describe her doing it. The re is clearly enough in the text to let the reader figure it
out, but it is not part of what is commu nicated. Th e story is thus richer than the
text.
The specific processes which guide the reader in creating the story-S are not
very well investigated, with notable exceptions of the discussion of contextual
frames in Em m ott's
Narrative Comprehension,
and He rm an's general framework
-
8/10/2019 Story Construction in the Blind Assassin
4/21
136
Barbara Dancygier
mental spaces as cognitive domains activated or set up by the use of linguistic
forms for the purposes of on-line m eaning construction; they are further described
as not being a part of language
itself
or a hidden level of representation, but as
having an indispensab le role in the construction of meaning. The role of linguistic
expressions is thus seen not as con tainers for meaning, but as prom pts which
guide its construction. Ifw assume, somewhat loosely, I admit, that the story -S
is the meaning of the text, then we might learn more about the nature of the story
by looking at the role specific textual choices play in its emergence.
The concept of emergent meaning is most transparently described in terms of
theblending of mental spaces, or conceptual integration (Fauconnier and Turner
Blending as a Central Process, Conceptual Integration, Principles, The
Way we Thin k, Coulson). For example, when the author Jonathan Raban recalls
his childhood experience of Twain's
Huckleberry Finn,
he describes it as
living
inside the book and goes on to elaborate on the fantasy world thus set up. The
expression cannot be understood literally (the narrator lived in an English village)
and is not conventiona l, so we can assume that the reader has to undertake mental
work to arrive at its meaning. A skeletal description of the blending processes is
given in Figure 1.
Childhood
Book
English v illage-4-
boy
stream -4
no adventure
Input 1
^Amer ica
Huck Finn
>-the Mississippi River
adventure
-America
-Huck Finn
-theMississippi^iver
-adventure
Input 2
Blend
ig 1
There are two input spaces,that of Jonathan Raban's childhood (with its temporal
-
8/10/2019 Story Construction in the Blind Assassin
5/21
Narrative Anchors 137
spaces are linked viacross-mappings which reveal and/or construct counterpart
elements in the inputs (e.g., the stream in the village and the Mississippi river).
Blending these inputs selectively projects Raban's childhood persona into the
temporal and spatial setting of
th
novel. Theemergent
stru ture
of
th
blend is not
simply a combination of these elements, but an emergent mental space where a
child living in 20th century England can experience adventure on the Mississippi.
The blend thus creates its own topology and yields meanings not available in the
inputs. At the same tim e, the blend may inform its inputs, viabackward projection
so that we can understand the ways in which reading made the boy's village
experience richer.
The analysis of this example applies to a narrative fragment, but the
mechanisms underlying its comprehension seem to work in similar ways when a
broader narrative context is considered . The novel as a whole can be talked about
in term sof narrative spaces which can be defined as cognitive dom ains activated
or set up in the reader 's m ind by the use of linguistic form s, for the purposes of on-
line story construction . A narrative space, once set
up,
is maintained through out the
story and serves as input to blends which will be constructed . The final sto ry-S
(with its event structure, sequential organization, cause-effect organization, and
other generic story-like features, and also its text-induced specificity) results from
subsequen t blend ing of lower level narrative spaces, and can be referred to as the
emergent
story.
As a blended construct, it relies on selective projection from lower
level spaces, but creates narrative structure of its own (roughly equivalent to an
idealized read er's version of what happened ) . Like other blended constructs, it
also projects new structure back to its input narrative spaces, thus enriching their
content with new topology (especially, new cause-effect relations).
The specific aspect of story-S construction which I elaborate here is the
privileged status of selected linguistic forms in the setting up and m aintenance of
narrative spaces, and in prom pting cross-space mappings further used in the blends
leading to the emergent story. Such expressions will be referred to as narrative
anchors.
2.Narrative Spaces and Narrative Anchors
An example of the scope of meaning cons truc t ion s imple express ions can
accomp lish is the f irst sentence of M argare t A tw oo d 's nove l . The Blind Assassin
given in (1) below.
-
8/10/2019 Story Construction in the Blind Assassin
6/21
138 Barbara Dancygier
The sentence seems to be a straightforward description of a tragic event, reported
by La ura's sister. Iris. The highly specific description of
the
time of Laura's death,
however, suggests that it is not simply an instance of temporal framing.
Furtherm ore, the choice of the verbdriveimplies agenthood, and, consequently,
intentional behavior, so that it is unlikely that Laura's death was a result of an
accident. The policeman's report in the next paragraph also mentions two
witnesses who testified that Laura had turned the car sharply and delibe rately. In
the third paragrap h. Iris herself comments: It wasn't the brakes, I though t. She had
her reasons.
The novel is a fragmented narrative, with Iris's pseudo-autobiographical
confession as its central element. Itisthe core of
he
Blind Assassinnarrative (I will
refertoit sBA and is the fram ing story of all the remaining narrative fragments.
She starts her writing as an old woman, describing her daily tasks and walks, and
using them as prompts for reminiscing about her earlier life thus the actual
autobiography proceeds chrono logically from her childhood to old age. The initial
paragraphs, w here Lau ra's death is described in the terms quoted above, how ever,
are taken out of the temporal sequence of the memoirs. The viewpoint of this
section (called The bridge is unclear it is a part of the autobiog raphy, but Iris is
also announcing herself
s
the primary narrator. The doub le role is reflected in the
discourse. For exam ple. Iris introduces Laura s her sister while disregarding any
description of other characters mentioned her husband Richard or her caregiver,
Reenie. And yet, the fragment's main role is not to start Iris's narrative, but to set
up the space of the focal event of Laura's death, while breaking the temporal
sequence and further suggesting that it was suicide. The fact that The bridge
violates temporal order is not remarkable in itself given that many texts do just
that, but it does pose a question with regard to the role of temporal seq uence in the
coherence of the story.
The primary role of The bridgeis to set the theme of the novel as a whole
what Laura really did and why, and the even t's role in the sequence is significantly
less relevant. W e should probably note that among all the patterns of presenta tion
mentioned in Leech and Short, the chronological may be the most obvious, but
neither the most common nor the most interesting stylistically. Classical
narratological accounts (e.g., Genette, Bal, Toolan) argue further that a
chronological presentation is never really just chronological, given that there are
-
8/10/2019 Story Construction in the Blind Assassin
7/21
Narrative Anchors 139
what makes chronological disruptions interesting is not that they occur, but how
they affect the understanding of the story. A flashback does not just break the
sequence, but breaks it so that important aspects of story construction are
highlighted such as the character's current psychological state or the way in
which past actions affect future choices.
Assuming thatB starts the way it does in order to establish the main them e of
the novel allows us to also see how the m ain narrative spaces are initially setup.We
have already looked at the way in which the text signals the suic ide space, along
with its twin, the accident space. Later, towards the end of the section Iris refers
to notebooks which Laura left for her to read:
(2).
. .the stack of cheap school exercise books that she must have hidden that very
morning .. .. knowing would be the onetofind them.
The reader can assume that the notebooks contain information explaining Laura's
decision to killherself which only Iris, the narrator, can have access to. Another
space is thus set-up, the no tebo oks space, subordinate to the suicide -spa ce. It
is structured similarly to the boo k space in theH uck Finnexample above in
both spaces the written text contains information (fictional story, letter, testimony ,
etc.) which may be available to a person if the physical object containing the
information can be accessed. The novel makes it clear that the content of the
notebooks -space is now known to Iris and that it may explain Laura's reasons.
But the space, similarly to the suicide -space, is merely signaled, and is expected
to be elaborated throughout the narrative. In spite of their skeletal topology, the
spaces will continue to structure the reader's understanding of the unfolding text,
as new information is added.
The acciden t -space, which is initially introduced in The bridge is further
elaborated on the next page, in a clipping from The Toronto Star which describes
Laura's death as an accident. Many of such clippings are spread throughout the
text, creating a running com mentary on the events narrated by Iris, presented from
the official or public point of view (which the reader will gradually learn to
associate with Ir is's husband, Richard Griffen). Together, the clippings structure a
shared v iewpoint space, where no new information is added, bu t the story told by
Iris is given its public dimension. Just as an exam ple, the first fragment talks about
accidental deathofMiss Laura C haseand adds thath er car swerved. The choice
of words here avoids attributing any intention to Laura, in contrast to The bridge
-
8/10/2019 Story Construction in the Blind Assassin
8/21
140 Barbara Dancygier
The expressions such asdrove, the carswerved orexercise booksfunction as
narrative place-ho lders for mental spaces which can only be signaled at this point
in the narrative. They are expected to be expanded in the ensuing narrative and are
presented scontributing to the topology or framing of other narrative spaces. Such
place-ho lder or portal expressions can be calledn arrative anchors,since they
open access to spaces which are only partially set up. As further exam ples will
show , narrative ancho rs may not only set up spaces to be elaborated later, but they
also build cross-mappings that link different narrative spaces, add structure to
them, and prompt projections which set up subsequent levels of narrative blends.
They are, then, expressions w hich con tribute in specific ways to the construction of
constituen t spaces and the resulting network. As I will argue , any story relies on a
number of narrative spaces and, while it may eventually yield a chronological
understanding of the events, it develops its structure on the basis of developing
links and cross-m appings. The setting up ofthe specific input narrative spaces and
the overall organization of the network constructed through the text depend in a
crucial way on narrative anchors.
The concept of conceptual anchors emerges first
in
Hu tchins' discussion ofthe
role m aterial objects may play in blending . In order to play a role, they have to be
perceived, but, as Hutchins suggests, (selectively) perceiving objects is a step
which does not need to be treated separately from (also selectively) projec ting them
into blends. Hutchins comments further that material objects as anchors have the
stability required to serve in further computations, since they are capable of
h old ing conceptual elements in place. The discussion of material anchors such
as clocks or calendars makes it clear that anchors do not have any intrinsic qua lity,
but rather have to be used in a certain way, so that material elements are used as
proxies for conceptual elements.
Narrative anchors, as I discuss them here, share some features with material
anch ors. They have a m aterial form in some sense, since they are written
expressions in the text. They are used in connecting or representing conceptual
elements (narrative spaces and aspects of their structure) and they are not
inherently predestined to play the role of anchors, but narrative structure may select
them to ho ld parts of narrative structure and cross-space links in place. In other
words, they participate in blending processes in ways somewhat similar to their
material counterparts.
-
8/10/2019 Story Construction in the Blind Assassin
9/21
Narrative Anchors 141
The novella (which will be termed fiA7-space, as a sub-pace of the overall BA
story) is much more elaborate than other spaces in the network it is an
independent text but its links to the rest of
the
text ofBAare not obvious. There
are numerous aspects of
the
BAJwording which give
it a
special place in the overall
narrative.
First, there are no proper names in the text. There are two characters, referred
to throughout via third person pronou ns heandshe.Personal pronouns may play
very significant roles in texts
see
Em mott, Constructing Social Space ), and there
are some narratives where pronouns are the only referring expressions. But in the
case of BAl which is situated within the context of the rest of the novel,
establishing the referents of the pronouns is a necessary part of understanding the
whole
story.
The question of howcloselyBA
needs to be blended into the n etwork
starts with these pronouns.
It
is
possible to assume that the text constructing theBA l narrative space could
be just what it ostensibly is a post-modern romance, and any resemblance
between the characters inBAl to other characters inBAcounts merely as playfully
teasing the reader. On closer inspection, though, the links between BAl and other
narrative spaces are most certainly meaningful. The logical chain which starts with
discovering the identities of the lovers referred to as he and sh e leads to the
discovery of crucial aspects ofthe story
as
a whole, such
as
the identity ofthe author
of the novella constituting the BAl space, and, perhaps most importantly, the
explanation of La ura 's reaso ns. In other words, the final story cannot be
constructed without incorporating the structure of theB i/-spac e. At the end of her
autobiograph ical narrative. Iris explicitly fills some (but not all) gaps , but she also
adds that the reader could have discovered the untold facts without her help.
Indeed, the reader
can
only do this by recognizing the anchors that linkBA to other
spaces, and it is unlikely that all these links were purely coincidental.
As I will show below, approaching the text as a network of interconnected
narrative spaces reveals unexpected richness of meaning, while at the same time
giving coherence to various narrative devices which could otherw ise be construed
as impediments.
The text ofBAl starts with aPrologue:
(3) She has a single photograph of him. She tucked i t into a brown e nve lope . . . between
the pages of Perennials for the Rock Garden where no one else would ever look the
-
8/10/2019 Story Construction in the Blind Assassin
10/21
142 Barbara Dan cygier
In reality, pho tographs, like books, are material anchors for representation spaces.
The image in a photograph is like a timeless window to the specific time and space
represented, whether identifiable or not. In the novel space, the photo plays a
similar role for the characters, but its description also works as a narrative anchor
for readers. The pho tograph is in fact the most am biguous of the anchors inBA,for
a num ber of reasons. First, it is the only record of her and him together, but
there is the han d of yet another, anonym ous, person. So the story involves three
participan ts, not just two the han d is an anchor to the construction of another
participant in the story. Also , the photograph is hidden in another book so that
by discovering the owner of the book the reader can work out who sh e is.
In fact, the Prologue to BAJ mimics the role The bridge plays in BA it
prov ides the narrative anchors needed. But there is an important difference. W hile
The bridge sets up the narrative spaces the novel as a whole will elaborate and
explore, thePrologueopens up spaces needed to fill in the narrative structure ofits
higher narrative, the BA, notBAJ space. Everything captured in the photo - the
picnic, the man w ith a cigarette, or the hand cut off
by
the margin belongs in the
structureof
BA,
but the woman inBAJholding the photograph is the link between
the two sp aces. In spite of ostensibly writing theB story as an autobiography . Iris
does not tell the reader all that she knows, so the rest is said through BAJ.
A
reader w ho exploresThebridgeand theProloguecarefully enough will then
receive plenty of opportunities to understand the role BAJplays in the story as a
wh ole. Just as an example, the identity of the man inB AJis easily established by
cross-links such as the following description of the events at the Button Factory
picnic:
4)Thenhe took apicture forthe paper with hiscamera....AlexThomas raisedhis hand
as iftofend him off. BA)
TheBAJanchor of the photograph, representing the picnic and the man's gesture,
now links the man to a character in BA. The story-structuring power of such
anchors is quite substantial. Once the reader recognizes the man in the picture as
Alex , all that is known about both Alex and him begins to characterize Alex and
his participation in the
events.
The story being told
in B is
not coherent without the
added inputs, though it remains very traditionally chronological, and in order to
construct the complete story the reader has to incorporate information from BAJ
intoBA.Since this is a pattern affecting most of the events that can explain La ura's
-
8/10/2019 Story Construction in the Blind Assassin
11/21
Narrative Anchors 143
causal links and deeper understanding of the characters and their motivations
not a surprising observation at all, but often back-grounded in narratological
discussions of the story .
Another anchor of crucial importance is the identity of the woman in BA/.
Here the narrative prompts are significantly more misleading, as they point
alternately to Laura and to Iris. Indeed, they are intentionally misleading. The
interesting question here is why the reader follows the promp ts and assumes one or
the other oft he women to be the she character in BAl without explicitly being
asked to do so. The text, in whichever sense, does not require such a conscious
enquiry, and, as the comments by some critics suggest (cf. Roy),BAl could be
treated as an independent story, simply elaborating some of the themes. Without
the narrative structuring work that the reader does, however, the novel would be
rather incoherent. Narrative anchors are story-level devices relying on the reade r's
search for coherence the descriptions of identical gestures in identical situations
have to be considered relevant when the identity of one of the (gesturing)
characters is unclear, or the whole text becomes mess of conflicting story snippets
and no coherence is possible. The cross-space links established and the plot
elements read into narrative spaces establish narrative coherence across
different spaces, which, as the goal of story-construction, leads to narrative
comprehension.
Though literary critics writing about The Blind Assassin have much to say
about the significance of, let 's say, use of color or the recurring them e of violated
women's bodies (Perrakis, Roy) in search for the more abstract levels of
interpretation, narrative structure is not included in these consid erations. The
fragmentation and deliberate deception are treated as com ponents of post-
modern style, while they are, in this case, features of narration. They require that
the participating narrative spaces be integrated, via narrative anchors and cross-
space projection, into the final emergent story. The emergent blend is not
dependent on any of the individual spaces alone, but on the story-construction
mechanisms.
The last ofth e major narrative spaces inThe Blind Assassinis another piece of
fiction, embedded inBAl. It is a pulp science-fiction story, composed during the
secret meetings ofthelovers. As the reader can conclude, the man, who is in hiding
through most of the story, makes a living publishing such popular fiction. Not
-
8/10/2019 Story Construction in the Blind Assassin
12/21
Barbara Dancygier
to the genre , is murky. The only obvious indication of the link with the main story
world is the character of a blind assassin I will refer to it, then, asBA2.
The story told in theBA2-space,which is in fact never finished, takes place on
the planet of Zycron, where blinded children weave carpets and young women,
with their tongues cut out, are sacrificed on the ceremonial altar, after being raped
by the lord of the underworld. With its style, themes, and genre the story
constituting theBA2space seems ou t of place in the novel as a whole. W hile critics
carefully pick out some of the themes (blindness, rape, practices equivalent to
sacrificing young women by marrying them off to rich but cruel husbands, etc.),
they do not mention any of the important narrative contributions the fiy42-space
makes by filling in the gaps in the main story line.
According to the mental spaces analysis proposed by Schnepf BA2 sets up a
set ofroles,to be matched with valuesin other spaces. Role-value links are among
the most salient mechanisms of mental space networks. In the most standard case,
the frame of the US political system profiles the role of the President, (with its
attendant duties and privileges), but also demands that a specific individual (the
value) is determined by elections every four years. The role-value link, once
established, allows speakers to access the value-individual through the role, and
vice versa. If
speaker saysG eorge Bush wasth governor of Texas,she might be
referring to the role (the current president held a different political office before),
or the value (the man called George Bush held a political office before). The roles
are typically established within an appropriate frame, and the frame may be
constructed in spontaneous discourse, supported by an understanding of what
lexical items mean (the buyer and seller roles in the scenario evoked by the verb
sell , or determined socially (the President). Proper names typically represent
values, rather than roles, while specific phrases designate roles rather than values.
Establishing the role-value links across spaces thus gives mental access from
one space to the other. If the roles designated by the story inBA2(the king, the m ute
girl to be sacrificed, the blind assassin, the lord ofthe underw orld) are matched with
the names of characters in BA, the cross-space links thus set up are of the most
com mo n and inconsp icuous kind, but there is a significant narrative gain, as access
across narrative spaces fills more gaps in Iris s story. Let us consider jus t o ne
example, as discussed bySchnepf.In BA2,the lord ofth e underworld plots against
the king. He hires a professional (blind) assassin to kill the king, and also gives a
-
8/10/2019 Story Construction in the Blind Assassin
13/21
Narrative Anchors 145
mute girl, and that the lord of the underworld is Iris's husband, Richard, and,
finally, that the blind assassin is Alex. The events leading to Iris's encounter with
Alex and to her marriage to Richard now become known. It is clear that it was
Richard w ho hired Alex to set Iris's father's factory on fire, and that Iris was forced
to marry Richard in exchange for financial help for the family. Most importantly,
we could not find out about Richard's role in the fire and the resulting damage to
the Chase family from Iris alone. She does not know about all this. But w hen it is
framed into the story that Alex tells her (under the pretence of 6/42), overall
coherence is preserved, since he is the only person who knows what really
happened then. Consequently, the gaps in the plot of
BA
could not be filled in any
other way.
At the same time we should note that coding the real story into what Alex
writes is not as artificial a narrative device at it might seem Alex could not
simply tell Iris about
is
role in the fire and thus adm it to have ruined her family and
her own life in the process. Instead, Alex makes this convoluted confession as if he
were inviting Iris to do what the reader does blend the narrative spaces into a
coherent story.
This aspect of story construction is also particularly interesting from the
linguistic and stylistic point of
view.
The main charactersofB A Alex and Iris, are
referred to in different narrative spaces via different referring expressions: proper
names inB A pronouns inBAl and role descriptors in BA2.Since there are hardly
any other ways to refer to people, the BAl and BA2 narratives exhaust all the
available options of identifying a character, without coming up with other proper
names. The linguistic construction is dauntingly simple, but the results spread
through the entire story.
Most surprisingly, the critical work on the novel that I have seen does not
acknowledge the role
ofBA
as a story-constructing factor, instead focusing on the
aspects of the character's construction (such as blindness or mutilation) which do
not quite work w ithout the rest of what
BA
contributes (cf. Perrakis, Roy, W ilson).
For exam ple, when these critics notice that Iris describes the marks of violence on
her body and that the sacrificial virgin in BA2is also mutilated and is meant to be
raped, they use these observations to talk about the treatmen t of w om en 's bod ies as
one of the themes ofth e novel. The critics' focus on such them es effectively allows
them to ignore narrative structure. But the links between the roles inBA2and the
-
8/10/2019 Story Construction in the Blind Assassin
14/21
146 Barbara Dancyg ier
not know (though perhaps guesses) that, even more ironically, her lover's leftist
views have destroyed her father, a fair employer, only to supplant him with a
ruthless business magnate. The inclusion of BA2 is also crucial with respect to
viewpoint managem ent. Given thatB and B Al are told from Iris 's viewpoint,BA2
is the only part of the narrative that can provide parts of the story not available to
her, and so Atwood creates a masterly construction where Alex's viewpoint is
blended into the rest of the text. Again, the major contribution a narrative space
makes to the story is not related to its temporal sequen ce, but to its coherence and
focus on character motivation.
The links among the major spaces prompt an explanation of the title The
Blind Assassin. The phrase, while ostensibly coined to refer to the group of
professional killers in BA2 acquires a specific m etaphorical m eaning on the basis
of the KNOWING IS SEEING mapping, whereby expressions such as unclear
transparent vision being in the dark being illuminated etc. are used to describe
epistemic states. It is also metaphorically conventional to call a personblindwhen
they lack understanding. Building on this easily accessible mapping, many critics
assume that the blind assassin in the title is Iris (cf. Wilson, Bouson) she
unknowingly causes her sister's death, by casually informing her that the man
Laura loved died, and thus rem oving her reason for living. But it is possible to use
the same metaphorical argument in combination with the actual narrative, and then
Alex emerges as an even better candidate for the role. Like the blind assassin in
BA2
he is paid to commit a crim e, and he does what he is paid for, but then falls in
love and steals the precious bride from his employer. But he is also metaphorically
blind, for he could not foresee that the knowledge of his affair with Iris will kill
Laura in the end.
Furthermore, in the story in BA2both lovers are mutilated he is blind, but
she is mute. As Schnepf shows in detail, being a sacrificial bride and being made
unable to talk app lies to Iris in a straightforward way. Iris matches the description
of the girl in B A2as swollen with words and describes her own forced silence in
similar term s. In BAshe is telling her story for the first time, and still hides much
ofit even though she
s
the framing narrator. The role ofthe blind assassin
s
thus
ambiguous, but the interpretation suggested in BA2 seems better supported.
4.
Conclusion
As was noted in the introduction, cognitive approaches to the narrative are
-
8/10/2019 Story Construction in the Blind Assassin
15/21
Narrative Anchors
understanding of how stories create their own logic, and how that logic is then
extended over other mental dom ains. What I have argued in this article, though, is
that the search for cognitive underpinnings of the narrative can and indeed should
include renewed focus on the text.
As the discussion above suggests, linguistically relevant choices of referential
expressions, verbs, or mental space builders can influence the understanding of the
narrative in ways which affect both the very interpretation of events and cha racte rs'
minds, and the narrative structure as such. These choices matter for specific
elements of the story-S the text tells, the identity of the characters, and the very
understanding of its main them es. They do not do so, however, by directly adding
information in the way we expect all texts to do , but by prom pting meaning
construction beyond the text as such through setting up n arrative spaces and links
across those spaces. In other words, mental space structure mediates between the
meaning contributed directly by the text and the meaning emerging from generic
principles of narrative construction as such.
The questions regarding the mental status of story-S which I posed at the
beginn ing cannot yet be answered in full, but the concepts introduced here answ er
some of
them.
The story em erging from any particular text is the intermediate level
of m eaning, with its own charac teristics. On the one hand, the con struct builds on
the more specific mean ing contributions of textual dev ices, while being framed on
the other hand by the general narrative concepts such as chunking or search for
causation. W hile the text prompts a myriad of mental spaces, it also uses narrative
anchors to privilege those which participate in story construction I called them
narrative spaces. The readers' search for overall story coherence helps in
recognizing the signals given textually, hence some (often significant) differences
in the readers' responses.
The sequential nature of the story (traditionally treated as its defining
characteristic) is a result, not the constitutive feature. Furthermore, events do not
form a linear chronological sequence instead, they cluster together to form
larger and larger hierarchically organized blended structures. The resulting story is
therefore a multi-layered network of narrative spaces which yields a sequence,
even if only a roughly conceived one, as a consequence of its organization.
The final narrative structure of
heBlind ssassin
can be roughly represented
in Figure 2, with the emergent story being the final product of the integrated
network of spaces set up in the course of the text. Som e of its spaces (like the
-
8/10/2019 Story Construction in the Blind Assassin
16/21
148
Barbara Dancygier
v-point: Iris
notebooks
v-point: Laura
Iris remembers
BA
v-point: Iris
BAI
v-point: Iris
BA2
v-point: Alex
accident
v-point: Iris
Emergent Story
Fig 2.
comparison, the spaces participating in the central blend BA, BAI and BA2) are
effectively telling the same story and they do so by prompting for cross-space
connectio ns, for identity blends (Iris is she and the mute girl) and for the overall
integration of various aspects ofthestory presented in the input spaces in the guise
of independent narratives. BA remains the main narrative space which projects
most of its structure into the emergent blend (as indicated, among others, by its
reliance on proper names), in contrast toB AJandBA2,which contribute plot and
characterization pieces to fill in the gaps inB A.It might not be accurate, how ever,
to callBAa framing narrative (for exam ple in the sense described by Herm an in
Genette meets Vygotsky ). The relationship among the various spaces is much
less that of embedding, and is more appropriately described as integration, which
poses a further question of the cogn itive benefit of such stories (in contrast to
framed stories, which Herman discusses in terms of distributed cognition).
The B lind Assassinis a thought-provoking laboratory experiment in narrative
spaces construction and blending , but the process is, I argue, the same in fictional
narratives of
ll
kinds, even though they m ay be ostensibly less fragmented. In the
analysis above, I have focused on selected aspects of story-construction, and the
role of narrative anchors in the emergence of stories as blends of participant
narrative spaces. Numerous questions, however, are still not formulated, let alone
answered. How do narratives distinguish various kinds of narrative space
interactions? How is viewpoint established and maintained? H ow are the different
spatial and temporal features of the inputs reconciled in the blend? How is
-
8/10/2019 Story Construction in the Blind Assassin
17/21
Narrative Anchors ' ^
conceptualization device are numerous and intricate. It seems, however, that
conceptual integration offers tools which might help us propose more and more
accurate answ ers.
Note
' Narratologists use a number of two-fold or three-fold distinctions here
(fabula / sjuzhet, story / text, story / text / narration, etc). Because the focus of my
discussion is on the tension between the story and everything else, I will stick to the
'story' versus 'text,' while elaborating the concept of 'story-S.'
Works Cited
Atwood, Margaret.
The Blind Assassin.
Toronto: Seal Books, 2000.
Bal, Mieke.Narratology: Introduction to the Th eory of Narrative.Trans. C hristine
van Boheemen. Toronto: U of Toronto P, 1985.
Bouso n, J. Brook s. A Comm emoration of W ounds Endured and Resented.
Critique44.3 (2003): 25 1-7 0.
Chatman, Seymour.
S tory and Discourse: N arrative Structure in Fiction and Film.
Ithaca: Cornell UP, 1978.
.C oming to Terms:
th
Rhetoric of Narrative F iction and
Film.
Ithaca: Cornell
UP, 1990.
Coulson, Seana.
Semantic Leaps: Frame-shifting and Conceptual Blending in
Meaning Construction.Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 20 01.
Dancygier, Barbara. Blending and narrative viewpoint: Jonathan Rab an's travels
through Mental Spaces.
Language and Literature
14.2 (2005): 99-127.
, Identity and Perspec tive: the Jekyll-and -Hyde Effect in Na rrative
Discourse.
Language Culture and
Mind
Ed. Michel Achard and Suzanne
Kemmer. Stanford: CSLI Publications, 2004. 363-76.
Visual Viewpoint, Narrative Viewpoint, and Mental Spaces in Narrative
Discourse. Linguagem Cultura e Cognigao: Estudos de Linguistica
Cognitiva.Ed. A. Soares da Silva, A. Torres, and M . Gonalves, 2004. Vol. 2.
347-62.
E m m ot t, Catherine. Constructing Social Space: Socio-Cognitive Factors in the
Interpretation of Character Relations.
Narrative Theory and the Cognitive
-
8/10/2019 Story Construction in the Blind Assassin
18/21
Barbara Dancygier
Fauconnier, Gilles. 1985.
Mental Spaces.
2nd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge UP
1994.
.
Mappings in Thought and Language.
Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1997.
Fauconn ier, Gilles, .and Eve Sweetser, eds.
Spaces, Worlds, and Grammars.
Chicago: U of Chicago P, 1996.
Fauconnier, G illes, and Mark Turner. Blending as a Central Process of
Grammar. Conceptual Structure, Discourse, and Language. Ed. A.
Goldberg. Stanford: CSLI Publications, 1996. 113-30.
. Conceptual Integration Netw orks. Cogni'fi've Sd enc e 22 2(1 99 8)- 13 3 -
87.
. Princip les of Conceptual Integra tion. Discourse and Cognition.Ed. J.P.
Koenig et al. Stanford: C SLI Publications, 1998. 26 9- 83 .
.
The Way We Think: Conceptual Blending a nd the Mind s Hidden
Complexities.
New York: Basic Books, 2002.
Genette, Gerard. Narrative Discourse: An Essay in Method Trans. J.E. Lewin.
Ithaca: Cornell UP, 1980.
Herm an, David. Genette meets Vygotsky: narrative embedding and distributed
intelligence.
Language and Literature
15.4 (2006): 357-80.
. Ed.N arrativeTheoryandthe ognitiveSciences.Stanford, California: C SLI
Publications,
2003.
. Ed. Stories as a Tool for Th inkin g. Narrative Theory and the Cognitive
Sciences.
2003.
163-93.
.Story Logic: P roblems and Possibilities of Narrative.Lincoln and London:
U of Nebraska P, 2002.
Hutchins, Edw in. M aterial Anchors for Conceptual Blen ds.
Journal of
Pragmatics 37 (2005): 1555-77.
akoff George, and Mark Johnson.
Metaphors we Live by.
Chicago: The U of
Chicago P, 1980.
Leech, Geoffrey N. and Michael H. Short, Style in Fiction: A Linguistic
Introduction to English F ictional Prose.London: Longman, 1981.
-
8/10/2019 Story Construction in the Blind Assassin
19/21
Narrative Anchors 51
Oakley, Todd. Conceptual Blending, Narrative Discourse, and Rhetoric.
Cogn itive Linguistics9.4 (1998): 321-36 0.
Perrakis, Phyllis. Negotiating with the Looking G lass: Atwood, her Protagonists,
and the Journey to the Dead . Ed. M oss and Kozakiewich 200 6. 349 -5 9.
Raban, Jonathan.
Old Glory.
New York: Vintage Books, 1998.
Reddy , M ichael. The conduit metaphor a case of frame conflict in our language
about language. Metaphor and Thought. Ed. Andrew Ortony. Cambridge:
Cambridge UP, 1979. 284-97.
Roy, W endy. The body of/as evidence: M argaret Atwood, The Blind Assassin,
and the Feminist Literary M ystery. Ed. M oss and Kozakiewich. 2006. 3 6 1 -
71.
Sanders, Jose and Gisela Redeker. Perspective and the Representation of Speech
and Though t in Narrative Discourse. Ed. G. Fauconnier and E. Sweetser.
2006 .290-317 .
Sawyer, R. Keith.Social Emergence: Societies as Complex Systems. Cambridge:
Cambridge U P, 2005.
chnepf Jennifer. Role-Value M appings and Narrative Structure in Atw ood 's
The Blind Assassin. Paper presented the Literature and Cognitive Science
Conference. Storrs, CT, April 6-9, 2006.
Sem ino, Elena. Blending and Characters: Mental Functioning in Virginia W oo lf s
Lappin and Lapinova. Languag e and Literature
15.1 (2006):
55-73.
. A Cognitive Stylistic Approach to Mind Style in Narra tive Fiction. Ed .
Semino and Culpeper. 2002. 95 -12 2.
. Text wo rlds.
Cognitive Poetics.
Ed. Geert Brone and Joeren Vandaele.
Berlin/New York: Mouton de Gruyter, forthcoming.
Semino, Elena and Jonathan Culpeper, eds.
Cognitive Stylistics: Language and
Cognition in
ext
Ana lysis.Philadelphia: John Benjamins, 2002.
Stockwell, Peter. Cogn itive Poetics.New York: Routledge, 2002.
Tooian, Michael.Narrative: A Critical Linguistic Introduction. 2nd ed. London:
Routledge, 2001 .
-
8/10/2019 Story Construction in the Blind Assassin
20/21
]52 Barbara Dancygier
W ilson, Sharon. Blindness and Survival in M argaret Atw ood 's Major Nove ls.
The Cambridge Companion to Margaret Atwood Ed. C. A. Howells.
Cam bridge: Cam bridge UP, 2006.
176-91.
-
8/10/2019 Story Construction in the Blind Assassin
21/21