Stokes Jolly Ltd Behavioural Realities of the Boardroom Jon Stokes.
-
Upload
shon-miller -
Category
Documents
-
view
222 -
download
0
Transcript of Stokes Jolly Ltd Behavioural Realities of the Boardroom Jon Stokes.
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Behavioural Realities of the Boardroom
Jon Stokes
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Behavioural Realities of the Top Team
• Group Behaviour – Groups & Teams• Personality• Emotional Intelligence• Leadership styles• Organisational Culture• Evolutionary psychology• Implications for Top Teams and
Boards
Stokes Jolly Ltd
4 Fundamental Tasks of the Board
• Accountability• Policy Formulation and Foresight• Strategic Thinking• Supervising Management
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Different Board Styles
Country-Clubboard
Professional
board
Rubber-stampboard
RepresentativeboardC
on
cern
for
board
re
lati
on
ship
s
Concern for board tasks
High
LowLow High
Stokes Jolly Ltd
The Working Board Model : responsibilities
The Thinking
Board
Accountability• To owners• To regulators & legislators• To other stakeholders• Ensuring directorial audits
Policy Formulation• Stating purpose• Creating vision &values• Developing corporate climate• Monitoring external environments
Supervising Management• Overseeing management performance• Monitoring budgetary control• Reviewing key business results•Competencies of employees
Strategic Thinking• Positioning in changing markets• Setting corporate direction• Reviewing & deciding key resources• Deciding implementation process
EXTERNAL
INTERNAL
SHORT TERMBOARD PERFORMANCE
LONG TERMBOARD PERFORMANCE
CONFORMANCE PERFORMANCE
Chairman & Board
Chief Exec. & Management
Stokes Jolly Ltd
A board should be selected, trained, developed and
appraised on their directorial abilities to:• formulate policy and so give foresight
• think strategically• collect accurate external and internal data• generate imaginative ideas• be capable of open questioning and critical review• be rigorous in risk assessments• be collegial in strategic decision-making• learn systematically from their directorial
strengths and weaknesses• ensure organisational capabilities for successful
strategic implementation• ensure rapid feedback for honest information on
the implementation of the strategy
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Unique Issues in
Executive Teams
Bloated Membership
Blind Ambition
Executive Moose
Centrifugal Force
Ambiguous Roles
Dancing Bears
Potential Actions to Deal with the Unique Issues
Design TeamsCreatively
Manage SuccessionDynamics
Create Conditions thatPromote Openness
Reinforce TeamIdentity
Clarify Team Roles andProcesses
Leverage theAgenda
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Work
• What it is you are accountable for• The What by When• Work starts with something that is missing• Work evokes emotion and anxiety• Work needs to engage us emotionally to be meaningful
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Working assumptions
• All organisations now work in an environment of continuous and turbulent change
• How organisational leadership responds to this is a central determining factor of organisational effectiveness and success.
• Pressure for companies to deliver short-term has resulted in a lack of commitment from employees and the overuse of financial reward as the primary motivator.
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Complexity a common factor- dealing with multiple
constituencies
• Shareholders • Customers • Employees • Communities • Society
Stokes Jolly Ltd
3 Fundamentals of Leadership
Awareness of the Whole • To be effective in organisational settings, people need an
awareness of the whole, and to see reality from as many points of view as possible; they need to have information available which disturbs and refines their perception of reality and to be able to express reality as they see it.
Connectedness • Secondly, people need connectedness to others they are engaged
in a common endeavour with, at the level of the heart, of the intellect and the spirit. The quality of relationship between human beings largely determines their ability to work together.
Alignment • Thirdly, human beings need alignment around a common purpose,
strategy, plan of action, set of values and approach to working together to make the best of their combined energy and capabilities.
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Psychological characteristics of the board and top team
• Emphasis on performance, conformance and competition
• Results oriented - wanting right answers quickly • Fear of looking incompetent or foolish, fear of
mistakes - fear of not knowing• Atmosphere of mistrust, competitiveness, being too
open - makes you vulnerable to the predatory ambitions of others (colleagues, owners, subordinates)
All can mitigate against effective decision-making and judgment which requires a combination of cognitive and emotional intelligence.
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Typical Leadership Competencies at Different Career Stages
First First Supervisory Supervisory
LevelLevel
Mid-Mid-Management Management
LevelLevel
analysis and planninganalysis and planning organising and decision-makingorganising and decision-making
influencing and networkinginfluencing and networking achievement and driveachievement and drive
politics & teambuildingpolitics & teambuilding
Executive Executive LevelLevel
inside-outside visioninside-outside vision strategic thinkingstrategic thinking
empoweringempowering coaching & mentoringcoaching & mentoring
conceptual and technical skillsconceptual and technical skills
collaborative skillscollaborative skills energy and ambitionenergy and ambition
self-presentationself-presentation
making decisions without full informationmaking decisions without full information
implementation skillsimplementation skills
Stokes Jolly Ltd
ROLE
PERSON TASK
ORGANISATION
Person - Role - Task - Organisation
•Accountability•Authority•Resources
•Output•Processes•Rewards
•Purpose•Strategy•Structure•Culture
•Capability•Life/Career Stage•Motivation & Values•Personality
E n v
i r
o n
m e
E n v
i r
o n
m e
n t
n t
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Stokes Jolly Ltd
The Visible and the Invisible Group
Visible• Individuals• Words• Behaviours• Conscious
Invisible• Group-as-a-
Whole• Feelings• Meanings• Unconscious
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Group dynamics are the result of many factors
• Competing interests• Difficulties and frustrations in the way of
progress• The pressures of the external environment• Different personalities different needs• Fear of ‘destructive’ differences• Fears of loss of individuality and ‘merger’
and more………..• So, effectiveness is a balancing act
Stokes Jolly Ltd
The Tensions between the Individual and the Group
The Group needs from the
Individual: • Commitment• Acceptance of
norms• Role behaviour• Acceptance of
authority structure
The Individual needs from the
Group: • Belonging • Influence • Achievement • Containment
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Life in a group is a balancing act
• Individual vs. Role• Task/Output vs. Process/Getting
there• Being an Individual vs Merging into
the Group• Sub-groups vs. Whole group• Internal Environment vs. External
Context
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Group Dynamics – Some Themes
• Inclusion vs Exclusion• Conformity vs Diversity• Individuality vs. Merger• Dependency Cycle:Dependence-Counterdependence-Independence-
Interdependence• Intimacy vs Distance: Over-personal vs. counter-
personal • Safety vs Risk• Competition vs. Collaboration• Leadership vs. Followership
Stokes Jolly Ltd
In every group ‘two’ groups are present - the Work Group and the
Basic Assumption groupWork Group
• aim is to complete a specified task
• purpose is explicit• structure and roles are
there to further the task, individuals judged on their competence at the task
• leader is not the only one who has skills and leads as long as his/her leadership serves the task of the group
• members operate as separate and discreet individuals
Basic Assumption Group• aim is to preserve itself and
alleviate the anxieties/satisfy the needs of its members
• purpose is tacit, operates on an ‘as if’ basis
• individual judged not by skill but by willingness/competence to enter into the b.a.
• leader is subservient to the group’s needs, constantly seduced by group away from its task
• individuals regress, relinquish independence and freedom of thought/action
Stokes Jolly Ltd
The Work Group and Basic Assumptions
Work• Atmosphere of ‘industry’; Group
constantly tests itself in a scientific spirit.
• Orientation is external and reality guides
• Learns from experience/ mistakes
• Members belong by conscious choice and work to the agreed purpose of the group
• Its seeks for knowledge, learns from experience, and constantly questions how it may best to achieve its goal. It is conscious of the passage of time and of the processes of learning and development.
Basic Assumption Group• Atmosphere of vague unease,
individual feels in danger of either being swallowed up, victimised, expelled but can’t identify why.
• Orientation is internal Individual who challenges will be scapegoated
• Do not learn from experience• Members belong to alleviate
anxieties, gain security and have needs met
• Fantasy drives and impulses are acted out
• Memory poor, time disorientation, language of reminiscence, cliché, loose generalisation
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Basic Assumptions – Wilfred Bion
3 Fundamental States of Mind
• Dependency
• Fight-flight
• Hope (Pairing)
Stokes Jolly Ltd
DependencyGroup behaves as if its primary task is solely to provide for the needs and wishes of its members.The leader’s task is to look after, protect and sustainthe members, not to face them with the demands ofreality.The leader may be absent or even dead provided theillusion that he/she contains the solution can bemaintained. Debates are about what the leader wouldhave said.Atmosphere: passivityEmotions: Reverence, envy, guilt, depression.
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Fight-Flight
Group behaves as if its primary task is action to deal with an
enemy either internal or external. However it is prepared to
do either indifferently.The leader’s task is merely to devise courses of action, leadeither attack or flight, the group’s task is merely to follow.Both do so without recourse to practicality or effectiveness.Atmosphere: paranoiaEmotions: Anger, fear, hate
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Hope (Pairing)
Group behaves as if its primary task is to create a better future
to give birth to a solution which will save it from its current
difficulties.The leader is unborn The group’s task is to watch and wait.Atmosphere: hopefulnessEmotions: Hope, enthusiasm, despair,
disillusion
Stokes Jolly Ltd
The Work Group and Basic Assumptions
“The individual is a group animal at war not simply with the group, but with himself for being a group animal and with those aspect of his personality that constitute his 'groupishness'.”
Experiences in Groups Wilfred Bion (1961)
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Leader’s Task
Fundamental
Behaviour and
Emotion
Institution
ProfessionCommerc
e
Aberrant Forms
Dependency
Identify and
provide for needs
of members
FeedingChurchDoctorsAirlines
Counter-Dependen
cy
Fight-Flight
Identify the enemy
and attack or
flee
Fighting
ArmySocial
Worker Investmen
t Banks
Paranoia
Hope
Unborn Messiah
or Utopian
Idea
Pairing
Marriage Therapist
s Advertisin
g PR
Collusion
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Basic Assumptions in Commerce
• Dependency – we will take you there – Airline
• Fight-flight – we will make you lots of money but don’t expect us to tell you how – Investment Banks
• Hope – we will make you successful and help you to believe in yourself – Public Relations
Stokes Jolly Ltd
GroupthinkGroupthink• A mode of thinking whereby pressures for unanimity overwhelm the
member motivation to appraise realistically the alternative courses of action
• Group pressure lead to carelessness, poor decisions and low quality actions• Group pressures result in irrational thinking and action
• Collective Rationalization – members discount warnings that their thinking is irrational
• Stereotyping the Adversary – painting an unappealing, inaccurate, self-serving picture of the adversary
• Self-Censorship – members censor thoughts that are opposed to group ideas
• Pressure on Dissenters – dissenters within the group are pressured into conformity
• Mind guarding – actively protecting group from outside ideas that may contradict the group decision or ideas. Some members play the role of mind guard
• Apparent Unanimity – Everyone on the surface is in agreement, but there is probably some doubt being hidden from the group
Symptoms of Groupthink• Illusions of Invulnerability – feeling that the group is beyond harm
• Illusions of Morality – feeling that the group is right, good and moral therefore anything it odes is right, good and moral
Stokes Jolly Ltd
GroupthinkSome ‘Causes’ of
Groupthink• High Group Cohesion• Homogeneity• Insulation of Group form
Outside Influences• Lack of clear-cut rules to
guide decision making• Stress on Group and
Group Membership• Promotional Leadership
(leader promotes their favourite ideas, while neglecting alternatives)
Preventing Groupthink
• Leaders should encourage dissent
• Leader should remain impartial
• Subgroups work on problem independently
• Rethink group decisions in ‘second chance’ meetings
• Allow third party analysts to provide feedback to group
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Groupthink
Some ‘Causes’ of Groupthink
• High Group Cohesion• Homogeneity• Insulation of Group form
Outside Influences• Lack of clear-cut rules to
guide decision making• Stress on Group and
Group Membership• Promotional Leadership
(leader promotes their favourite ideas, while neglecting alternatives)
Preventing Groupthink
• Leaders should encourage dissent
• Leader should remain impartial
• Subgroups work on problem independently
• Rethink group decisions in ‘second chance’ meetings
• Allow third party analysts to provide feedback to group
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Avoiding Conformity Pressure- ‘Groupthink’
• Gather outside opinions• Handle, don’t avoid, group controversy• Question weak arguments• Consider carefully before taking decisions• Avoid censoring deviants
• Understand reason for deviance
• ‘Risky Shift’- when group decisions are more risky or more cautious than individuals
Stokes Jolly Ltd
What makes a group into a team?
• Shared Task with shared Accountability• Common Understanding of Aims and objectives• System of Roles• Managed Boundary: Resources and skills managed
within this
• System of Feedback – clear criteria for success and failure
• System of Review - Progress - Process
• Discusses, decides and does (not delegates) the work
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Behavioural Realities – non-team
behaviour is more natural1. The best senior leadership groups are rarely a true
team at the top—although they can and do function as real teams when major, unexpected events prompt that behaviour.
2. Most of them can optimize their performance as a group by consciously working to obtain a better balance between their team and non-team efforts—rather than by trying to become an ongoing single team.
3. The secret to a better balance lies in learning to integrate the discipline required for team performance with the discipline of executive (single-leader) behaviour—not in replacing one with the other.
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Top executives are supposed to: • Direct and lead the actions of large numbers of people—whereas a
team moulds the skills of a small number of people. • Exercise personal judgement in assessing risks, resources, and
strategic options—whereas a team makes collective judgements through open dialog, conflict resolution, and real work.
• Make assignments based largely on formal positions in the formal organizations—whereas team members' assignments are made on the basis of the specific required skills, regardless of their formal organizational role.
• Be primarily responsible for broad corporate strategy, policy, and objectives—whereas a team's purpose and goals must be more tightly focused on specific performance results.
• Leverage their time and experience through efficient organization and management processes—whereas a team is seldom the most efficient grouping or process for getting something accomplished.
• Pinpoint individual executives to make the critical decisions—whereas a team makes critical decisions in a variety of different ways, using whatever person or grouping will yield the best decision.
• Manage performance of the organization by establishing clear-cut, individual objectives and work products—whereas a team must establish joint objectives and deliver collective work products.
• Be individually accountable for "whatever happens on their watch"—whereas a team must hold itself mutually accountable for the collective results of all members.
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Power and AuthorityPower is an attribute of the PERSON
• Personal Power• Resource Power
- Expertise- Network- Information
• Position Power• Projected Power
Authority is an attribute of ROLE arising from a TASK –
ROLE: the idea in the mind by which an individual manages his/her self in relation to the system.
Power may be exercised without matching authorityAuthority cannot be exercised without matching power
Stokes Jolly Ltd
The Evidence That Enables Us to Predict Successes and Failures As
Future Senior ManagersIn a 10 year follow-up study of top executives who derailed (centre for creative leadership 1996) the two most common traits are those who failed were:Rigidity: they were unable to adapt their style to changes in the organisational culture, or they were unable to take in or respond to feedback about traits they needed to change or improve. They couldn't listen or learn. Poor relationships: The single most frequently mentioned factor: being too harshly critical, insensitive, or demanding, so that they alienated those they worked with.
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Other differentiators were:
Self-control: those who derailed handled pressure poorly, and were prone to moodiness and angry outbursts. The successful stayed composed under stress, remaining calm and confident - and dependable - in the heat of crisis.
Conscientiousness: The derailed group reacted to failure and criticism defensively - denying, covering up, or passing on the blame. The successful took responsibility by admitting their mistakes and failures, taking action to fix the problems, and moving on without ruminating about their lapse. Trustworthiness: The failures typically were overly ambitious, too ready to get ahead at the expense of other people. The successes had high integrity, with a strong concern for the needs of their subordinates and colleagues, and for the demands of the task at hand, giving these higher priority than impressing their own boss at any cost.
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Social skills: The failures lacked empathy and sensitivity, and so were often abrasive, arrogant, or given to intimidation of subordinates. While some were charming on occasion, even seeming concerned about others, the charm was purely manipulative. The successes were empathic and sensitive, showing tact and consideration in their dealings with everyone, superiors and subordinates alike.
Building bonds and leveraging diversity: The insensitivity and manipulative manner of the failed group meant that they failed to build a strong network of co-operative, mutually beneficial relationships. The successes were more appreciative of diversity, able to get along with people of all kinds. They built a network of contacts and friendships within and outside the firm.
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Successes vs. Failures
• Rigidity• Poor relationships• Self-control• Conscientiousness• Trustworthiness• Social skills• Building bonds and leveraging
diversity
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Needs in a Team
• Belonging• Sense of Achievement• Influence• Containment
Stokes Jolly Ltd
ContainerAn effective group or organisation needs to provide a container (vessel, crucible) – a setting of shared meaning and energy in which the intensity of human interactions, conflicting meanings, and experiences necessary to its work can unfold constructively.Eg, Family, Marriage, Institutions
The management of the container is a central task of management.
Stokes Jolly Ltd
What is Emotional Intelligence?
‘Anyone can become angry – that is easy. But to be angry with the right person, to the right degree, at the right time, for the right purpose, and in the right way – this is not
easy.’Aristotle, The Nicomachean
Ethics‘The capacity for recognizing our own feelings and those of others,
for motivating ourselves, for managing emotions well in
ourselves and in our relationships.’
Daniel Goleman, Emotional Inteligence
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Awareness Actions
Self
Self Awareness•Emotional Self-Awareness
•Self Confidence•Accurate Self-Assessment
Self Management•Self Control
•Trustworthiness•Conscientiousness
•Adaptability•Achievement Orientation
•Initiative
Others
Social Awareness •Empathy
•Organizational Awareness•Service Orientation
Influencing Others•Developing Others
•Leadership•Influence
•Communication•Change Catalyst
•Conflict Management•Building Bonds
•Teamwork and Collaboration
EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE – Goleman Model
Stokes Jolly Ltd
FIRO-BMeasures of Interpersonal
Need• Inclusion
• How much you generally include other people in your life and how much attention, contact and recognition you want from others (groups)
• Control• How much influence and responsibility you want
and how much you want others to lead and influence you
• Affection• How close and warm you are with others and
how close and warm you want others to be with you (1-on-1)
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Leadership Styles
• Coercive – demands compliance - do what I say
• Authoritative – mobilizes toward a vision - come with me
• Affiliative – builds bonds - people come first • Democratic – forges consensus - what do you
think?• Pacesetting – sets high standards - follow my
example • Coaching – develops people for future – try
this
Stokes Jolly Ltd
The Style in a Phrase
“Do what I tell you!”
Works Best When
In crisis, kick-starting a turnaround, and/or with
problem employees.
Overall Impact on
ClimateNegative
Underlying EI
Competencies
Achievement Orientation,
Initiative and Self Control
Coercive
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Authoritative
The Style in a Phrase
“Come with me.”
Works Best When
A new vision required and/or
clear direction needed.
Overall Impact on
ClimateMost strongly positive.
Underlying EI
Competencies
Self-Confidence, Empathy and
Change Catalyst
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Affiliative
The Style in a Phrase
“People come first.”
Works Best When
In stressful circumstances and/or healing rifts.
Overall Impact on
ClimatePositive
Underlying EI
Competencies
Empathy, Building Bonds and
Communication
Stokes Jolly Ltd
The Style in a Phrase
“What do you think?”
Works Best When
Building buy-in, working for consensus, and/or getting
input.
Overall Impact on
ClimatePositive
Underlying EI
Competencies
Teamwork, Collaboration,Leadership and Communication
Democratic
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Pacesetting
The Style in a Phrase
“Do as I do, now!”
Works Best When
Needing quick results from a highly motivated and
competent team.
Overall Impact on
ClimateNegative
Underlying EI
Competencies
Conscientiousness, Initiative and Achievement
Orientation
Stokes Jolly Ltd
The Style in a Phrase
“Try this.”
Works Best When
Improving performance and/or developing long-term
strengths.
Overall Impact on
ClimatePositive
Underlying EI
Competencies
Self-Awareness, Empathy and
Developing Others
Coaching
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Boundaries
The work place is a system that can be understood in terms of boundaries - within/without - and managed by these:• Task - What is my work/ what is not• Power - What authority do I have/ have not• Identity - Who am I/who am I not• Values - What is acceptable here/ What is not acceptable here
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Each member of the group inhabits three realms of reality
• Private Space - a personal internal world of thoughts, dreams, desires and feelings - personal reality - purely subjective
• Public Space - an agreed world, conceived of in space and time - scientific and common-sense reality - roles and tasks - realm of the objective
• Inter-subjective Space - a shared mental world of shared creations of the mind, fantasies, attitudes, values, assumptions and misgivings - mental events which nevertheless by virtue of being held in common have a great influence on the life of a group and in that sense extremely real - both me and not me/you - the inter-subjective world.
Stokes Jolly Ltd
The Organisation in the Mind
The conscious and unconscious ideas and feelings that make up the internal representation of ‘the organisation’ in the minds of its members
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Organisational Culture The nature of organisations means that they are "uncheckable fantasy space", the domain of myths and dreams as much as of reality, similar to the unconscious of psychoanalysis. These features include a facility for splitting, projecting & introjecting. Culture in the group is the analogue of the mind in the individual .
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Mythological structure of organisations
Myths are used to confront a problem and provide one or more solutions that allay anxiety. Whereas science offers rational explanations, it also tends to bypass the causes of anxiety - our primordial fears of being separate, detached, and lonely. These fears persist until some commonly held beliefs, expressed in myths, renew our sense of belonging and of the community of life. One's ultimate protection from anxiety is to belong to a strong, cohesive group.
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Organisational Culture
• The commonly held and relatively stable beliefs, attitudes and values that exist within the organisation
• ‘How you get things done around here’
• Different levels of culture• Artefacts: the constructed environment• Behaviours: visible and audible• Attitudes and espoused values: inferred• Underlying assumptions
• Can be articulated with effort• Unknown or unconscious• Covert
Stokes Jolly Ltd
How Culture is created
Primary Drivers of behaviour create the
culture:
• What leaders pay attention to and control
• Leader reaction to critical incidents and organisational crisis
• Deliberate role modelling, teaching, and coaching by leaders
• Criteria for allocation of rewards and status
• Criteria for recruitment, selection, promotion, retirement, and excommunication
Secondary articulation reinforcement mechanisms:
• The organisation's design and structure
• Organisational systems and procedures
• Design of physical space, facades, and buildings
• Stories, legends, myths and parables about important events and people
• Formal statements of Organisational philosophy and creeds and charters
Stokes Jolly Ltd
The fit between an organisation's culture and the demands of the
business environment determines an organisation's success
– Deal & KennedyThey argue that an organisation's culture
can be characterised by: • - the degree of risk associated with the
company's key activities • - the speed of feedback at which the
company and its employees get on whether their decisions and strategies have been successful
Stokes Jolly Ltd
High
Low
Risk
Big-Stakes
Eg. Oil
Big Corporates→ DeliberatenessProcess
Eg, Banks
Government
→ Technical Perfection
Low
Tough-Guy
Eg. Investment banks
Advertising
→ Insider/OutsiderTeam
Eg. Retailing
High Tech
→ Persistence
High Feedback
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Evolutionary Psychology
The apparently immutable characteristics of humans according to evolutionary psychology:
Dominance of emotion over the rational - emotions are the first reaction to everything seen or sensed. When we receive feedback, especially if it has a negative element, our natural disposition is not to think about it. We are easily manipulated, even when we realise it, because warm emotion is so much more important to us and call reason.
Predictably primitive behaviour • Co-operation, sharing, specialisation and friendliness • Stereotyping on first impressions - in a threatening and
complex environment it is necessary to classify things immediately on the most basic data.
• Breast-beating and mindless optimism • When life is random and terrifying the person who appears
less terrified and most confident slightly to attract followers, food and sex. Confidence becomes more high devalued and widespread than realism.
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Evolutionary PsychologyA taste for hierarchy - the desire to follow confident leaders and
to find security in a change of status relationships seems to be pronounced traits of primitive society.
• Conformism and herding - allied to hierarchy is the tendency to conform internally and be suspicious of those outside. High-status individuals are imitated. There is a natural tendency to do what a hierarchy once. A sense of identification within the group lead to cohesive behaviour in the face of external threat. Conformity pays.
• Hostility to out-groups - the strength of the clan and it conformity has the flipside of hostility to those outside. It appears that the more co-operative societies or the more violent the battles between them.
The avoidance of risk - hunter-gatherers tend to only take risk when faced with danger stop we appear to be risk-averse when we can afford risk, and yet risk-takers when losses are endemic.
• Mad scrambling when under serious threat - the more successful scramblers survived more often so that scrambling under threat is part of our genetic make-up. When he normally sane person is under pressure while driving 'road rage‘ or sudden panic may take over. When a factory closes, certain employees may become hysterical or aggressive.
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Technical vs. Adaptive challenges
Technical challenge – known problems with established solutions, execution is the key - the application of current know-how by technical experts/ authorities. Appropriate when what needs to be done is apparent,resources needed and capabilities required are clear.Leaders provide direction and solutions.
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Technical vs. Adaptive challenges
Adaptive challenge – either or both of the problem and the solution are not clear. Solution will require changes in norms, values, expectations and strategies. It will involve changes in roles, relationships, assumptions and require new values, behaviours, approaches, attitudes; the learning of new ways by the people with the problem. Leaders challenge and ask tough questions. People with the problem find the solution.
Stokes Jolly Ltd
Negative Capability“I had not a dispute but a disquisition with Dilke, on various
subjects; several things dovetailed in my mind, and at once
it struck me what quality went to form a Man of Achievement
especially in literature and which Shakespeare possessed so
enormously - I mean Negative Capability, that is when a man is
capable of being in uncertainties, Mysteries, doubt, without
any
irritable reaching after fact and reason.”
John Keats
Stokes Jolly Ltd
• What advice would you give to an about to be appointed new top team member ?
• What issues would it face you with ?
• What about your own organisation ?