Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European...

45
Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons and Nuclei” Milos Island, Greece September 12-15, 2007 Dan Dale Idaho State University

Transcript of Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European...

Page 1: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

Status of the PrimEx Experiment:A Precision Measurement of the Neutral

Pion Lifetime

7th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons and Nuclei”

Milos Island, GreeceSeptember 12-15, 2007

Dan DaleIdaho State University

Page 2: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

Participating Institutions

North Carolina A&T State University University of MassachusettsUniversity of Kentucky Idaho State UniversityJefferson Lab Hampton UniversityMIT University of North Carolina at WilmingtonCatholic University of America Arizona State UniversityUniversity of Virginia ITEP, RussiaIHEP, Russia Norfolk State UniversityUniversity of Illinois Kharkov Inst. of Physics and TechnologyChinese Institute of Atomic Energy IHEP, Chinese Academy of Sciences George Washington University Yerevan Physics Institute, ArmeniaSouthern University at New Orleans Tomsk Polytechnical University, RussiaUniversity of Sao Paulo

Page 3: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

A High Precision Measurement of

• Physics motivation• The Primakoff effect• Experimental setup• Towards high precision• Current analysis event selection radiative width extraction • Summary

Page 4: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

The axial anomaly

Leading order corrections (Donoghue, 1989)

Corrections O(p4)

Page 5: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

Current experimental and theoretical status

Expected PrimEx error bar,arbitrarily projected to theleading order chiral anomaly

decay

wid

th (

eV

)

Next to LeadingOrder, +- 1%

Page 6: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

Sum rule approach to axial-vector-vector (AVV) form factor.

f – f caused by strong interaction shown to be small.

Eta width only input parameter. o mixing included.

o eV

Recent Theoretical Advances(B.L. Ioffe and A.G. Oganesian, Phys. Lett. B647, p. 389, 2007)

Page 7: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.
Page 8: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.
Page 9: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

The Primakoff Effect

Radiative width Known, measured quantities

Page 10: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

Angular distributionenables separation ofamplitudes

Page 11: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

For high precision:

• Measure angular distribution well to separate various amplitudes

new state of the art o detector

• Measure on a variety of targets to test validity of background extraction (Primakoff

• Tight photon energy (peak4and flux control

photon tagging

• Measure QED processes (Compton and pair production) to validate setup and analysis techniques.

Page 12: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

incident electrons

Tagged photon beam

Page 13: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

Bremsstrahlung photon tagging

Electron beam

Post-brems electrons

Page 14: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

Tagging Ratios

Page 15: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

Photon Calorimetry – the HYCAL calorimeter

1152 PbWO4 and 576 lead glass modules

1.6% energy resolution

1-2 mm position resolution

Page 16: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

In-beam calibration

Page 17: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.
Page 18: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

Effect of periodicityof detector modules.

Page 19: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

Energy resolution – lead tungstate

Page 20: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.
Page 21: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

Luminosity analysis efforts

• Electron counting (absolute flux)

• Pair spectrometer (relative tagging ratios)

• TAC (absolute tagging ratios)

• Target thickness

• Known cross sections (pair production,

Compton)

Page 22: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

Online Flux Monitoring

e+ - e - pair spectrometer

dipolemagnet

plastic scintillators

Page 23: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

Stability of relative tagging ratios

Monitored during production data taking.

Page 24: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

Stability of relative tagging ratios

Stable to 1%.

Page 25: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

Relative tagging ratios versus rate

Independent of rate!

Page 26: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

Pair production cross section

(1)Bethe-Heitler (modified by nuclear form factor).

(2)Virtual Compton scattering.

(3)Radiative effects.

(4)Atomic screening.

(5)Electron field pair production.

Page 27: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

Compton Scattering--Stability of Setup

Page 28: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

Angular distribution for CarbonPrimakoff Peak

Page 29: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

UMass Analysis

HYCAL – Tagger timing

Invariant Mass Elasticity

Total Probability = Timing x Mass x Elasticity

Event selection:

Normalized probabilitydistributions for

Page 30: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

Elasticity versus invariant mass

Hybrid mass

Page 31: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

UMass Analysis: Radiative Width for Carbon

Primakoff peak

Nuclear coherent andPrimakoff – NC interference

Page 32: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

MIT/JLab Analysis: Event Selection

Invariant mass

HYCAL – Tagger timing

Elasticity

Page 33: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

Angular distributions and background

Carbon Lead

Page 34: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

MIT/JLab Analysis: Radiative Widths for Carbon and Lead

Carbon: = 8.20 ± 0.15 eV ± 0.20 eV Lead: = 8.11 ± 0.16 eV ± 0.20 eV

Page 35: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

ITEP/NCA&T Analysis: Radiative Width for Carbon

= 7.98 ± 0.18eV

All possible cluster combinations.Elasticity imposed.HYCAL – tagger timing < 4 nsec.

Page 36: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

ITEP/NCA&T Analysis: Radiative Width for Lead

= 7.94 ± 0.18eV

Page 37: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

ITEP/NCA&T Analysis: Radiative Width Combined Fit for Carbon and Lead

= 7.95 ± 0.13eV

Carbon

Lead

Page 38: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.
Page 39: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

Summary IUMass AnalysisCarbon 8.41 eV ± 0.15 eV ± 1.8%

MIT/JLab Analysis: Carbon: = 8.20 eV ± 0.15 eV ± 0.20 eVLead: = 8.11 eV ± 0.16 eV ± 0.20 eV

ITEP/NCA&T Analysis:Carbon: = 7.98 eV ± 0.18 eVLead: = 7.94 eV ± 0.18 eVCombined fit, Carbon and Lead: = 7.95 eV ± 0.13 eV

Page 40: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

Summary

• The neutral pion lifetime is a stringent test of confinement scale QCD.

• High precision of the experiment has pushed the limits of photon calorimetery, luminosity monitoring, and QED calculations.

• Experimental systematic errors controlled by pair production and Compton scattering.

• High quality data taken in late 2004. Three quasi-independent analyses.

• Our preliminary result is:

= 7.93 eV ± 2.1% (stat) ± 2.0% (stat)

• In good agreement with ChPT predictions.• Further studies of backgrounds underway.

Page 41: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

Extra Slides

Page 42: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

PDF1: HYCAL – Tagger timing

Page 43: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

PDF 3: Invariant mass

Page 44: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

PDF 2: Elasticity

Page 45: Status of the PrimEx Experiment: A Precision Measurement of the Neutral Pion Lifetime 7 th European Conference on “Electromagnetic Interactions with Nucleons.

Previous Experiment: The Direct Method(Phys. Lett., vol 158B, no. 1, 81, 1985)

o`s produced by 450 GeV protons in tungsten foils.

o decays observed by detection of 150 GeV/c positrons produced by decay rays converting in foils.

Y(d) = N[A + B(1-e-d/)]

Dalitz decay, conversion in first foil