Examination Report of the Bernalillo County Treasurer’s Office
STATE OF NEW MEXICO COUNTY OF BERNALILLO SECOND … DSLM 2017 Receiver Reports.pdfKevin A. Graham,...
Transcript of STATE OF NEW MEXICO COUNTY OF BERNALILLO SECOND … DSLM 2017 Receiver Reports.pdfKevin A. Graham,...
Page 1 of 6
STATE OF NEW MEXICO
COUNTY OF BERNALILLO
SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT
FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS DIVISION,
Petitioner,
v. NO. D-202-CV-2017-03838
HON. NAN NASH
DESERT STATE LIFE MANAGEMENT,
PAUL A. DONISTHORPE,
SPECTRUM CAPITAL MARKETS, LLC,
CORAZON CATTLE,
CORAZON-PITCHFORD, LLC,
PAUL A. DONISTHORPE, LLC, AKA PAD, LLC,
Respondents.
RECEIVER’S DECEMBER, 2017, MONTHLY REPORT
COMES NOW, Christopher Moya, court-appointed Receiver for Desert State Life
Management (DSLM) and Acting Director of the Financial Institutions Division (FID) of the
New Mexico Regulation and Licensing Department, by and through the FID’s attorney of record,
Kevin A. Graham, and provides the Court with the following Receiver’s December, 2017,
Monthly Report.
STATUS OF ACCOUNTS
1. Charles Schwab Accounts: The Receiver continues to work to obtain full
access and control over the electronic financial accounts of DSLM held with
Charles Schwab. Multiple communications have taken place between the
Receiver, assigned staff members from the FID, and representatives of Charles
Schwab. As of the date of the filing of this December, 2017, Monthly Report, the
Receiver has still not gained full access and control over the accounts held at
FILED IN MY OFFICEDISTRICT COURT CLERK
12/4/2017 3:22:52 PMJames A. Noel
Patsy Baca
Page 2 of 6
Charles Schwab, but it is believed that process will be completed within the next
thirty (30) days.
2. Funds: The Receiver is in control of the following bank accounts and
funds in the name of DSLM and account balances as of November 30, 2017, stand
at the following amounts:
DSLM Accounts with New Mexico Bank and Trust:
(1) “Operations” account: XXXX190 $ 0.00
(2) “Sweep” account: XXXX041 $ 0.00
(3) “Pooled Savings” account: XXXX119 $23,800.23
(4) “Trust Cash” account: XXXX127 $52,196.28
(5) “Recovery” account: XXXX309 $13,428.23
(6) “Trust Checks” account: XXXX116 $ 5,210.21
3. Examination of Records and Accounts:
Staff from the FID are working to complete the organization of the voluminous
paper records maintained by DSLM, and now in the possession of the
Receiver/FID. Those records continue to be reviewed and organized by the FID
staff. Efforts to organize the DSLM corporate records and verify data have led to
numerous determinations that certain vital records are missing from the DSLM
files and/or that records containing incorrect and intentionally falsified records
were created.
The FID’s staff working on this project continue to be focused on
producing verifiable accountings for each individual trust account and other client
accounts that can be provided to the individual trust beneficiaries and/or
conservatorship clients detailing the current balances in their respective accounts
Page 3 of 6
and the amount of total loss individually suffered. Providing this documentation
to the individuals determined to have suffered losses under the operation of
DSLM in recent years should provide the ability for those individuals to file
appropriate insurance claims as well as to pursue all appropriate claims through
the courts. Another continuing focus of the Receiver/FID has been to make
certain that any incoming funds to the accounts of DSLM are properly tracked
and credited to the individual trust and/or conservatorship accounts to which those
funds properly belong.
4. Conservatorships and Trust Clients: The Receiver is working to have new
conservators appointed for all clients of DSLM for whom DSLM had been
appointed conservator. [Receiver currently believes there to be a total of six (6)
individuals for whom DSLM is on record as conservator, with two (2) of those
individuals believed to be deceased.] The Receiver also continues to work to
move all trusts currently under the trusteeship of DSLM over to new, permanent
trustees. At this time, by necessity, the Receiver is serving in the temporary
capacity as trustee for sixty-three (63) trust accounts, as the Personal
Representative for one (1) individual, and there are seven (7) accounts for which
DSLM’s role (and thus, the Receiver’s role) is still undetermined based on the
transactions in those individual’s names. The Receiver has engaged in direct
efforts to reclaim funds identified as having been unlawfully taken from the
company and/or clients of the company.
5. Federal Criminal Prosecution: The Receiver is working in coordination
with the United States Attorney’s Office for the District of New Mexico to obtain
Page 4 of 6
restitution orders in the federal criminal case against Paul A. Donisthorpe. In the
federal criminal case, Case No. 2017-3311 JB in the United States District Court
for the District of New Mexico, Donisthorpe plead guilty on November 27, 2017,
to two (2) felony charges and stipulated to having stolen over $4.8 million dollars.
Donisthorpe’s plea also contained a stipulation to the forfeiture of parcels of real
property to be utilized for the purpose of obtaining restitution funds for the
victims of Donisthorpe’s crimes. The Receiver will continue to work with the
U.S. Attorney’s Office in efforts to recover funds through the criminal restitution
process for the clients of DSLM.
On behalf of the Receiver, Christopher Moya, the foregoing is respectfully
submitted by:
_________________________
Kevin A. Graham
Counsel to the Receiver/
Senior Enforcement Counsel
Financial Institutions Division
New Mexico Regulation and Licensing Department
2550 Cerrillos Road, 3rd Floor
P.O. Box 25101
Santa Fe, New Mexico 87505
(505) 476-4971
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE:
The undersigned hereby certifies that a true and correct copy of the foregoing pleading was
delivered by electronic mail and/or U.S. Mail, postage prepaid, addressed to each of the
following:
1. Paul A. Donisthorpe
and
Page 5 of 6
2. K. Stephen Royce
Cuddy & McCarthy, LLP
7770 Jefferson Street NE, Ste. 102
Albuquerque, NM 87109
Counsel for Desert State Life Management and L. Helen Bennet
3. Paul Kennedy
Paul Kennedy & Associates PC
201 12th Street NW
Albuquerque, NM 87102-1815
Counsel for Liane Kerr
4. Spectrum Capital Markets, LLC
and
5. Corazon Cattle
and
6. Corazon-Pitchford, LLC and/or Darrell Pitchford
and
and
Scott Fuqua
Fuqua Law & Policy, PC
P.O. Box 32015
Santa Fe, NM 87594
Counsel for Darrell Pitchford
7. Paul A. Donisthorpe, LLC
and
8. Kenneth C. Leach
Kenneth C. Leach & Associates, P.C.
320 Osuna Road NE, Unit G-4, Box 15
Albuquerque, NM 87107
Page 6 of 6
Counsel for Judith Mahar
9. Michael White 74760
OCPF EC-65
10 McGregar Range Rd.
Chaparral, NM 88081-7753
10. Bryan Biedscheid
Sawtell, Wirth & Biedscheid, P.C.
708 Paseo de Peralta
Santa Fe, NM 87501
_________________________
Kevin A. Graham
Page 1 of 15
STATE OF NEW MEXICO
COUNTY OF BERNALILLO
SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT
FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS DIVISION,
Petitioner,
v. NO. D-202-CV-2017-03838
HON. NAN NASH
DESERT STATE LIFE MANAGEMENT,
PAUL A. DONISTHORPE,
SPECTRUM CAPITAL MARKETS, LLC,
CORAZON CATTLE,
CORAZON-PITCHFORD, LLC,
PAUL A. DONISTHORPE, LLC, AKA PAD, LLC,
Respondents.
RECEIVER’S FINAL INVENTORY AND REPORT
(SUBJECT TO ADDENDUM AS MAY BE AUTHORIZED BY THE COURT)
COMES NOW, Christopher Moya, court-appointed Receiver for Desert State Life
Management (DSLM) and Acting Director of the Financial Institutions Division (FID) of the
New Mexico Regulation and Licensing Department, by and through the FID’s attorney of record,
Kevin A. Graham, and provides the Court with the following Final Inventory and Report
(Subject to Addendum as May be Authorized by the Court), and an update on the Receiver’s
actions in this matter since the filing of the Receiver’s Initial Inventory and report on September
5, 2017.
Despite the Receiver’s efforts, along with the efforts of additional staff members of the
FID who have been assigned to this matter, the Receiver is unable to provide a truly
comprehensive accounting for the business (or individual clients of the business) at this time.
The Receiver believes it will be necessary for the Receiver to submit an updated financial
accounting for the business and individual trust/client accounts after further investigation has
been completed. The Receiver hereby requests the Court approve the filing of an Addendum to
Page 2 of 15
this Final Inventory within ninety (90) days of the date of the filing of the present Final
Inventory.
FINAL INVENTORY OF RECEIVERSHIP ESTATE ASSETS
1. Real Estate:
The Receiver has identified funds that appear to have been unlawfully removed
from the business accounts of DSLM, client trust investment accounts, and/or
trust cash accounts of trusts under the administration of DSLM, and those funds
then utilized to pay mortgage payments, tax assessments or penalties, or other
bills concerning the following real properties, thereby creating at least a partial
ownership interest in these real properties for the Receivership Estate:
A. Office building located at 1011 4th Street NW, Albuquerque, New
Mexico, 87102, also known as Tract B and C of Boughs Subdivision, Bernalillo
County, New Mexico.
[Note: This property appears to be listed on public records as being
owned by “1011 Fourth Street NW LLC.” Per the “Amended Stipulated Marital
Settlement Agreement” filed in Sandoval County District Court Case No. D-
1329-DM-2017-0187 in the divorce action between Liane E. Kerr and Paul A.
Donisthorpe, which was made part of the Court’s “Final Decree of Dissolution of
Marriage” in that case on June 19, 2017, it is provided that Paul A. Donisthorpe
will waive all rights and interest in the 1011 Fourth Street NW LLC and his
interest in the LLC (and therefore his interest in the building at 1011 4th Street
NW) will be transferred by Paul A. Donisthorpe to Liane E. Kerr.]
Page 3 of 15
B. House, outbuildings and ten (10) acres of land located at 130
Hidden Lake Circle, Angel Fire, New Mexico, 87710, and set out in Plat Book 9,
Page 20, records of Colfax County, New Mexico.
[Note: Per the “Amended Stipulated Marital Settlement Agreement” filed
in Sandoval County District Court Case No. D-1329-DM-2017-0187 in the
divorce action between Liane E. Kerr and Paul A. Donisthorpe, which was made
part of the Court’s “Final Decree of Dissolution of Marriage” on June 19, 2017, it
is provided that Liane E. Kerr will waive all rights and interest in the house and
property at 130 Hidden Lake Circle and the house and property shall be the sole
property of Paul A. Donisthorpe.]
[Note: Lis pendens has been filed by the Receiver with the Colfax County
Clerk on this property.]
C. Ranch property, mobile home, barn, corrals and assorted out-
buildings located in the area of Athens, Texas, 75752, described as Atwood James
B. No. 19, Henderson County, Texas, which under a real estate sales contract in
the name of Corazon-Pitchford Cattle Co. LLC.
[Note #1: Per the “Amended Stipulated Marital Settlement Agreement”
filed in Sandoval County District Court Case No. D-1329-DM-2017-0187 in the
divorce action between Liane E. Kerr and Paul A. Donisthorpe, which was made
part of the Court’s “Final Decree of Dissolution of Marriage” on June 19, 2017, it
is provided that Liane E. Kerr will waive all rights and interest in Corazon-
Pitchford Cattle Co. LLC and this LLC and property owned by the LLC shall be
the sole property of Paul A. Donisthorpe.
Page 4 of 15
Note #2: On the date of October 25, 2017, the Receiver, along with legal
counsel, conducted a physical inspection of the above-described real estate,
livestock and other property located in Athens, Texas. On that date meetings
were held with Darrell Pitchford, a minority owner of Corazon-Pitchford LLC,
regarding issues surrounding the currents debts, assets and value of the property
that has been listed as being included within the receivership estate for DSLM.
Negotiations towards the achievement of a settlement whereby Mr. Pitchford
would provide a lump sum payment of cash to the receivership estate in exchange
for a release of claims by the receivership estate against the real property and
other assets of Corazon-Pitchford LLC, and against Mr. Pitchford and his wife as
minority owners of the company, are ongoing.]
D. House and outbuildings located at 10439 Fourth Street NW,
Albuquerque, New Mexico, 87114, also described as Tract C of Martinez
Subdivision Bernalillo County.
[Note: Per the “Amended Stipulated Marital Settlement Agreement” filed
in Sandoval County District Court Case No. D-1329-DM-2017-0187 in the
divorce action between Liane E. Kerr and Paul A. Donisthorpe, which was made
part of the Court’s “Final Decree of Dissolution of Marriage” on June 19, 2017, it
is provided that Paul A. Donisthorpe will waive all rights and interest in the
10439 Fourth Street NW property and the house and property shall be the sole
property of Liane E. Kerr.]
2. Office Equipment:
Page 5 of 15
Office equipment that was found by the Receiver/FID to be located at the
former offices of DSLM, located at 1011 4th Street NW, Albuquerque, New
Mexico, or within a rented storage unit at the “Justorage” document storage
facility located at 720 1st Street NW, Albuquerque, New Mexico, that has now
been taken into the physical custody of the Receiver/FID and stored within the
offices of the FID of the New Mexico Department of Regulation and Licensing in
Albuquerque, New Mexico, include:
A. Eight (8) personal computer towers;
B. Five (5) monitor screens for personal computers;
C. Five (5) desk-top printers for personal computers;
D. Three (3) “ten-key” electronic office calculator devices;
E. Twenty-six (26) four-drawer, standard-sized filing cabinets;
F. One (1) three-drawer, legal-sized, horizontal filing cabinet;
G. One (1) four-drawer, legal-sized, fire proof filing cabinet;
H. One (1) vertical, two-door, metal office supply cabinet containing
various disposable office supplies.
3. Miscellaneous:
A. 2012 Dodge Ram truck.
[Note: Per the “Amended Stipulated Marital Settlement Agreement” filed
in Sandoval County District Court Case No. D-1329-DM-2017-0187 in the
divorce action between Liane E. Kerr and Paul A. Donisthorpe, which was made
part of the Court’s “Final Decree of Dissolution of Marriage” on June 19, 2017, it
Page 6 of 15
is provided that this 2012 Dodge Ram truck will be the sole property of Paul A.
Donisthorpe.]
B. 2016 Merhow horse trailer with living quarters.
[Note: Per the “Amended Stipulated Marital Settlement Agreement” filed
in Sandoval County District Court Case No. D-1329-DM-2017-0187 in the
divorce action between Liane E. Kerr and Paul A. Donisthorpe, which was made
part of the Court’s “Final Decree of Dissolution of Marriage” on June 19, 2017, it
is provided that this trailer will be the sole property of Liane E. Kerr.]
C. Assorted cattle, including inseminated/bred cattle, and bovine
genetic materials believed to include bull semen and fertilized bovine embryos
held under the ownership of Corazon-Pitchford Cattle Co. LLC in and around the
area of Athens, Texas.
[Note #1: The Receiver is still in the process of determining the extent of
any assets of Corazon-Pitchford LLC that may be properly included within the
receivership estate.
Note #2: Please see the text of the “Note #2” to Section 1, paragraph C,
above.]
4. Trusts/Trust Investment Accounts:
A list of individual trusts currently under the trusteeship of DSLM
(identified by first initial of first name and first initial of last name) was attached
as “Exhibit A” to the Receiver’s Initial Inventory which was filed with the Court
on September 5, 2017.
Page 7 of 15
Exhibit A also reflects the following information:
A. Client accounts of DSLM where an associated individual trust
investment account exists, along with the name of the financial institution where
the account is held.
[Note: The Receiver has not yet completed individual accountings for
each of the trusts and/or trust investment accounts listed; individual company and
trust account balances are not being included in this report as such account
balances could not be verified for accuracy by the Receiver at the time of this
report. The Receiver is optimistic that account balances will be able to be
provided to trust beneficiaries (or their conservators, guardians or other
authorized representatives) within ninety (90) days of the filing of this Final
Inventory and Report.]
B. Client accounts for conservatorships where DSLM has been court-
ordered as the conservator for an individual.
REPORT OF RECEIVER’S ACTIVITIES - UPDATE
1. File and Computer Security:
A. To the knowledge of the Receiver, all hardcopy (paper) files of
DSLM have been taken into the Receiver’s physical custody. An electronic copy
of records related to the operation of DSLM that were in the possession of the
company known as “The Becerra Group” were obtained by the Receiver/FID on
the date of October 20, 2017.
Page 8 of 15
B. To the knowledge of the Receiver, all computers owned by DSLM
that were located by the Receiver and/or the FID within the former business
location of DSLM (1011 4th Street NW, Albuquerque, New Mexico) have been
taken into the physical custody of the Receiver.
[Note: The Receiver is aware that certain computerized records of the
business operations of DSLM may be contained on computers and/or other
electronic storage media (computer hard drives, thumb drives or other data
storage media) in the possession of Respondent Paul A. Donisthorpe, or others.
Prior to the Court’s order appointing Christopher Moya as Receiver in the above-
captioned matter, Mr. Moya, in his capacity as Acting Director of the FID, with
obtained temporary custody of a personal computer owned by Paul A.
Donisthorpe which contained a variety of electronic records related to the
operation of DSLM. Mr. Moya was able to have electronic copies made of the
relevant records from that computer before the computer was returned to Mr.
Donisthorpe via Mr. Scott Kominiak. The Receiver is in possession of the copy
of the records copied from Mr. Donisthorpe’s personal computer.]
C. The Receiver has obtained access to, and control over, the
electronic banking accounts of DSLM held at New Mexico Bank and Trust. All
access to those accounts has now been transferred to, and limited to, the Receiver
and FID staff members as designated by the Receiver.
D. The Receiver has obtained access to, and control over, the
electronic financial accounts of DSLM held with Vanguard. All access to those
Page 9 of 15
accounts has now been transferred to, and limited to, the Receiver and FID staff
members as designated by the Receiver.
E. The Receiver continues to work to obtain full access and control
over the electronic financial accounts of DSLM held with Charles Schwab.
Multiple communications have taken place between the Receiver, assigned staff
members from the FID, and representatives of Charles Schwab. As of the date of
the filing of this Final Inventory and Report, the Receiver has still not gained full
access and control over the accounts held at Charles Schwab, but it is believed
that process will be completed within the next thirty (30) days. The Charles
Schwab company has assured the Receiver that all access to those accounts has
been restricted pending a final transfer of control over those accounts to the
Receiver.
2. Contacts with Trust Beneficiaries/Concerned Individuals/Representatives:
A. On or about April 21, 2017, the FID, in advance of the Court’s
order appointing Christopher Moya as receiver in this matter, sent a first round of
correspondence to all identified clients and/or trust beneficiaries (or their
representatives) alerting as many affected individuals as possible of the FID’s
determination of serious irregularities in the accounts and operations of DSLM
and recommending all affected individuals consult with legal and/or financial
advisors concerning their rights.
B. Following the transmittal of the initial letter to DSLM’s clients and
other affected individuals in April, 2017, the FID has received contact from
Page 10 of 15
numerous DSLM clients and affected individuals, family members and
representatives for such individuals and legal counsel concerning the examination
the FID’s examination of DSLM, and now concerning the receivership for
DSLM.
C. On or about August 9, 2017, following this court’s order
establishing the receivership for DSLM and appointing Christopher Moya, Acting
Director of the FID, as receiver for the company, Mr. Moya caused another round
of correspondence to be mailed (and/or electronically transmitted) to all clients
and affected parties for whom the FID had collected contact information
(addressed to the affected parties directly or to their representatives or counsel, if
known.) This letter provided information concerning the court’s order of
receivership, a brief update on the status of DSLM and its continuing operations,
and again recommended that all affected parties seek out personal legal and
financial advice regarding their rights and options.
D. In order to assure that individuals affected by the operation of
DSLM (and now the receivership of the company) would be able to contact the
receiver/FID, Christopher Moya, Acting Director of the FID and Receiver for
DSLM, caused to be created a specific email address that is regularly reviewed by
staff members of the FID and is for the sole purpose of receiving/transmitting
communications related to DSLM issues; the email address is:
E. Likewise, Acting Director/Receiver Moya has set up a telephone
number, monitored by staff members from the FID, for the sole purpose of -
Page 11 of 15
receiving/transmitting communications related to DSLM issues; the telephone
number is: 505-476-4971.
F. Further, Receiver Moya (through the FID) has opened a U.S. Mail
post office box for receiving mailed correspondence and other materials related to
the operation of DSLM; the address for the post office box is: P.O. Box 93847,
Albuquerque, NM 87199.
3. Funds:
A. The following bank accounts and funds in the name/control of
DSLM have been located by the Receiver and the Receiver has taken over control
of the accounts (account balances as of October 31, 2017):
DSLM Accounts with New Mexico Bank and Trust:
(1) “Operations” account: XXXX190 $ 0.00
(2) “Sweep” account: XXXX041 $ 0.00
(3) “Pooled Savings” account: XXXX119 $14,985.37
(4) “Trust Cash” account: XXXX127 $55,562.52
(5) “Recovery” account: XXXX309 $13,428.23
(6) “Trust Checks” account: XXXX116 $ 7,663.57
B. Individual Trust Investment Accounts:
Please see the “Exhibit A” that was attached to the Receiver’s Initial Inventory and report
for a list of individual trust investment accounts that have been identified by the Receiver.
4. Examination of Records and Accounts:
Page 12 of 15
A. The Receiver has gained operational and legal control over all
bank accounts under the name of DSLM that are held at New Mexico Bank and
Trust (the primary banking institution utilized by DSLM for operational
accounts.)
B. The Receiver is engaged in ongoing contact with the Charles
Schwab investment company and the Vanguard investment company where a
number of individual trust investment accounts were located. The Receiver has
made efforts to insure that no other party may have access to these accounts
pending the accounts being put fully under the control of the Receiver.
C. Staff from the FID were assigned to complete an initial
organization of the voluminous paper records maintained by DSLM, and now in
the possession of the Receiver/FID. As was noted in the Initial Inventory and
Report, DSLM was conducting business via an almost entirely paper-based record
system which has proven extremely difficult to deal with and many
inconsistencies have been identified. Those records continue to be reviewed and
organized by the FID staff. As also previously noted, efforts to organize the
DSLM corporate records and verify data have led to numerous of determinations
that certain vital records appear to be missing from the DSLM files and/or that
records containing incorrect (possibly intentionally falsified) records have been
created.
The FID’s staff working on this project continue to be focused on
producing verifiable accountings for each individual trust account and other client
accounts that can be provided to the individual trust beneficiaries and/or
Page 13 of 15
conservatorship clients detailing the current balances in their respective accounts
and the amount of total loss individually suffered. Providing this documentation
to the individuals determined to have suffered losses under the operation of
DSLM in recent years should provide the ability for those individuals to file
appropriate insurance claims as well as to pursue all appropriate claims through
the courts. Another continuing focus of the Receiver/FID has been to make
certain that any incoming funds to the accounts of DSLM are properly tracked
and credited to the individual trust and/or conservatorship accounts to which those
funds properly belong.
5. Summary:
As was included in the Initial Inventory and Report, the Receiver has
determined that DSLM, as a business providing trustee and conservator services,
cannot be rehabilitated and that liquidation of the company is the only appropriate
course forward. Despite the best efforts of the Receiver and the FID staff, while
the picture of the current assets and liabilities of DSLM is clearer, accurate
accountings of each of the trust accounts under the control of DSLM have not yet
been completed. The Receiver is working to have new conservators appointed for
all clients of DSLM for whom DSLM has been appointed conservator. The
Receiver also continues to work to move all trusts currently under the trusteeship
of DSLM over to new and proper trustees. The Receiver has engaged in hands-on
efforts to reclaim funds identified as having been unlawfully taken from the
company and/or clients of the company and to return those funds to their rightful
owners.
Page 14 of 15
On behalf of the Receiver, Christopher Moya, the foregoing is respectfully
submitted by:
_________________________
Kevin A. Graham
Counsel to the Receiver/
Senior Enforcement Counsel
Financial Institutions Division
New Mexico Regulation and Licensing Department
2550 Cerrillos Road, 3rd Floor
P.O. Box 25101
Santa Fe, New Mexico 87505
(505) 476-4971
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE:
The undersigned hereby certifies that a true and correct copy of the foregoing pleading was
delivered by electronic mail and/or U.S. Mail, postage prepaid, addressed to each of the
following:
1. Paul A. Donisthorpe
1011 4th Street NW, Albuquerque, New Mexico, 87102
and
and
2. A. Blair Dunn
WARBA, LLP
400 Gold Ave SW, Suite 1000
Albuquerque, NM 87102
Counsel for Helen Bennet
3. Paul Kennedy
Paul Kennedy & Associates PC
201 12th Street NW
Albuquerque, NM 87102-1815
Counsel for Liane Kerr
4. Spectrum Capital Markets, LLC
1011 4th Street NW, Albuquerque, New Mexico, 87102
Page 15 of 15
and
5. Corazon Cattle
1011 4th Street NW, Albuquerque, New Mexico, 87102
and
6. Corazon-Pitchford, LLC and/or Darrell Pitchford
and
Scott Fuqua
Fuqua Law & Policy, PC
P.O. Box 32015
Santa Fe, NM 87594
Counsel for Darrell Pitchford
7. Paul A. Donisthorpe, LLC
1011 4th Street NW, Albuquerque, New Mexico, 87102
and
8. Judith D. Mahar
1398 Wilkes Way SE
Rio Rancho, NM 87124
9. Michael White 74760
OCPF EC-65
10 McGregar Range Rd.
Chaparral, NM 88081-7753
_________________________
Kevin A. Graham
Page 1 of 6
STATE OF NEW MEXICO
COUNTY OF BERNALILLO
SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT
FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS DIVISION,
Petitioner,
v. NO. D-202-CV-2017-03838
HON. NAN NASH
DESERT STATE LIFE MANAGEMENT,
PAUL A. DONISTHORPE,
SPECTRUM CAPITAL MARKETS, LLC,
CORAZON CATTLE,
CORAZON-PITCHFORD, LLC,
PAUL A. DONISTHORPE, LLC, AKA PAD, LLC,
Respondents.
RECEIVER’S SECOND MONTHLY REPORT, OCTOBER, 2017
COMES NOW, Christopher Moya, court-appointed Receiver for Desert State Life
Management (DSLM) and Acting Director of the Financial Institutions Division (FID) of the
New Mexico Regulation and Licensing Department, by and through the FID’s attorney of record,
Kevin A. Graham, and provides the Court with the following report of the Receiver’s actions
over the preceding month.
1. File and Computer Security:
A. The Receiver continues to work to obtain full access and control
over the electronic financial accounts of DSLM held with Charles Schwab. The
Receiver has been assured by the company that all access to those accounts has
been restricted pending a final transfer of control over those accounts to the
Receiver.
B. The Receiver has been in contact with Steven Becerra, of the
Becerra Group, regarding obtaining copies of all files and documentation in the
FILED IN MY OFFICEDISTRICT COURT CLERK
10/4/2017 2:23:33 PMJames A. Noel
Gena Lopez
Page 2 of 6
possession of Mr. Becerra or his company concerning the operations and finances
of DSLM and/or any clients of DSLM. Mr. Becerra has committed to providing
all such records to the Receiver in a timely manner.
2. Contacts with Trust Beneficiaries/Concerned Individuals/Representatives:
The Receiver, as well as staff members of the FID, continue to be in
contact with trust beneficiaries (or their guardians, conservators and legal counsel,
as appropriate) regarding the ongoing examination of the accounts and finances of
DSLM and all progress made towards rebuilding accurate account statements for
each of the DSLM client accounts.
3. Funds:
The Receiver and the FID staff continue to process requests for
disbursements from client trust accounts and make such distributions of funds as
are permissible under the terms of the relevant trust documents for all client
accounts in which there are funds remaining. A limited number of client
accounts are receiving income from sources such as annuities and for those
accounts, the Receiver and FID staff are processing such requests for distributions
of funds as may be covered by the incoming funds to those accounts or available
from known brokerage accounts. Obviously the Receiver cannot approve
disbursement of funds from client accounts where no trust funds remain and
cannot approve disbursements of funds from client accounts where the dollar
amount of the request(s) exceed the balance of the account.
Page 3 of 6
4. Examination of Records and Accounts:
A. The Receiver has gained operational and legal control over all
bank accounts under the name of DSLM that are held at New Mexico Bank and
Trust (the primary banking institution utilized by DSLM for operational
accounts).
B. The Receiver is engaged in ongoing contact with the Charles
Schwab investment company and the Vanguard investment company where a
number of individual trust investment accounts are located. The Receiver has
made efforts to insure that no other party may have access to these accounts
pending the accounts being put fully under the control of the Receiver.
C. Staff from the FID continue their efforts to complete an initial
organization of the voluminous paper records of DSLM that are now in the
possession of the Receiver/FID.
The FID’s staff working on this project continue to focus on producing
verifiable accountings for each individual trust account that can be provided to the
individual trust beneficiaries and/or conservatorship clients, which detail the
current balances in their respective accounts and the amount of total loss
individually suffered. The Receiver and FID staff also continue their efforts to
make certain any incoming funds to the accounts of DSLM are properly tracked
and credited to the individual trust and/or conservatorship accounts to which those
funds properly belong.
5. Summary:
Page 4 of 6
The Receiver continues to be of the opinion that DSLM, as a business
providing trustee and conservator services, cannot be rehabilitated and that
liquidation of the company is the only appropriate course forward at this time.
The Receiver will continue to work with the legal counsel, guardians, and courts
of proper jurisdiction to have new conservators appointed for all clients of DSLM
for whom DSLM has been appointed conservator. The Receiver will also
continue efforts to move all trusts currently under the trusteeship of DSLM over
to new and proper trustees for those trusts. Finding new, competent, and
appropriate trustees to take over the trust accounts at DSLM has proven to be
challenging due to the very low balances left in the great majority of the trust
accounts and the wording of many of the individual trust documents that limit
successor trustees to corporations providing trustee services. The Receiver is
continuing his efforts to identify and reclaim all funds unlawfully taken from the
company and/or clients of the company and to return those funds to their rightful
owners.
On behalf of the Receiver, Christopher Moya, the foregoing is respectfully
submitted by:
_________________________
Kevin A. Graham
Counsel to the Receiver/
Senior Enforcement Counsel
Financial Institutions Division
New Mexico Regulation and Licensing Department
2550 Cerrillos Road, 3rd Floor
P.O. Box 25101
Santa Fe, New Mexico 87505
(505) 476-4971
Page 5 of 6
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE:
The undersigned hereby certifies that a true and correct copy of the foregoing pleading was
delivered by electronic mail and/or U.S. Mail, postage prepaid, addressed to each of the
following:
1. Paul A. Donisthorpe
1011 4th Street NW, Albuquerque, New Mexico, 87102
and
and
2. A. Blair Dunn
WARBA, LLP
400 Gold Ave SW, Suite 1000
Albuquerque, NM 87102
Counsel for Helen Bennet
3. Paul Kennedy
Paul Kennedy & Associates PC
201 12th Street NW
Albuquerque, NM 87102-1815
Counsel for Liane Kerr
4. Spectrum Capital Markets, LLC
1011 4th Street NW, Albuquerque, New Mexico, 87102
and
5. Corazon Cattle
1011 4th Street NW, Albuquerque, New Mexico, 87102
and
6. Corazon-Pitchford, LLC and/or Darrell Pitchford
Scott Fuqua
Fuqua Law & Policy, PC
P.O. Box 32015
Santa Fe, NM 87594
Counsel for Darrell Pitchford
Page 6 of 6
7. Paul A. Donisthorpe, LLC
1011 4th Street NW, Albuquerque, New Mexico, 87102
and
and
8. Judith D. Mahar
1398 Wilkes Way SE
Rio Rancho, NM 87124
9. Bryan Biedscheid
Sawtell, Wirth & Biedscheid, P.C.
708 Paseo de Peralta
Santa Fe, NM 87501
_________________________
Kevin A. Graham