Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... ·...

28
Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017 Alissa M. Fitzgerald, Ph.D. Founder & CEO | [email protected]

Transcript of Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... ·...

Page 1: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications

Stanford PNT Symposium 2017Alissa M. Fitzgerald, Ph.D. Founder & CEO | [email protected]

Page 2: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

Overview

• Navigation• Developments in MEMS gyroscope technology• Other MEMS sensors for navigation• About AMFitzgerald

Stanford PNT Symposium 2017 © AMFitzgerald 2017Page 2

Page 3: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

Navigation has always depended on sensor fusion

Stanford PNT Symposium 2017 © AMFitzgerald 2017Page 3

Synthesis of information from multiple imperfect sources

Page 4: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

Today, GNSS provides highly accurate navigation information

Stanford PNT Symposium 2017 © AMFitzgerald 2017Page 4

Page 5: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

Stanford PNT Symposium 2017 © AMFitzgerald 2017Page 5

A proliferation of vehicles now depend on satellite navigation

Page 6: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

On land, GNSS-denied environments are everywhere

Stanford PNT Symposium 2017 © AMFitzgerald 2017Page 6

Page 7: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

How to operate safely in complex environments (without a $100K+ IMU)?

Stanford PNT Symposium 2017 © AMFitzgerald 2017Page 7

Page 8: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

MEMS: a powerful miniaturization technology

Navigation unit (1995) Navigation unit (2015)

Stanford PNT Symposium 2017 © AMFitzgerald 2017Page 8

Approx:150 mm x 150 mm x 150mm

MEMS inside

Page 9: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

MEMS are widely used in consumer and automotive applications

Stanford PNT Symposium 2017 © AMFitzgerald 2017Page 9

> 10 MEMS 1-2 MEMS > 100 MEMS!

Micro Electro Mechanical Systems

Page 10: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

© AMFitzgerald 2017Page 10

Silicon dioxide (a.k.a. sand, dirt)

Ingot Wafers

Made by silicon (semiconductor) process technology

Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

Fabrication

Wafer dicing Chip packaging Circuit board mount

Page 11: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

Stanford PNT Symposium 2017 © AMFitzgerald 2017Page 11

MEMS sensors useful for navigation

AccelerometersGyroscopes

MicrophonesPressure sensors IMUs(Accel+Gyro+Mag)

GE

Magnetometers

Page 12: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

MEMS sensor qualities

• What’s great about MEMS:– Tiny size and mass– Low(er) cost and power– High sensitivity– Compact electronics integration

• What’s not:– Tricky to package– Small signals, custom ASICs often

needed– Stability over long duration or

extreme environments

Stanford PNT Symposium 2017 © AMFitzgerald 2017Page 12

Gyroscope

Page 13: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

Grade Bias stability

Main Application Est. MEMS Price (in volume)

Example Maturity

Consumer 10 deg/sec Human motion $1 ST Micro CommercialAutomotive (safety) 1 deg/sec Stability control $5 Bosch CommercialIndustrial 10 deg/hr Munitions $20 ADI, Qualtre CommercialTactical; Assisted Nav 1 deg/hr Vehicle Nav $300 SSS CommercialShort-term Nav 0.1 deg/hr Missile Nav - UMich: Najafi R&D (TRL 6)Navigation 0.01 deg/hr Aeronautics Nav - UCI: Shkel R&D (TRL 4)Strategic 0.001 deg/hr Submarine Nav - DARPA

C-SCANR&D (TRL 2)

MEMS gyroscope application grade and bias stability

Stanford PNT Symposium 2017 © AMFitzgerald 2017Page 13

Performance needed for navigation in GNSS-denied environments

Page 14: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

MEMS comb-drive tuning fork gyro (consumer-automotive grade)

• Rotation of component exerts perpendicular Coriolis force on resonating proof mass

• Sealed in vacuum environment to maximize Q• Capacitive comb-drives to drive/sense mass

Stanford PNT Symposium 2017 © AMFitzgerald 2017Page 14

Page 15: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

MEMS comb-drive tuning fork gyro (consumer-automotive grade)

Stanford PNT Symposium 2017 © AMFitzgerald 2017Page 15

Source: ST, Chipworks iPhone 4 Teardown

2-axis gyro (infrared photo) 2-axis gyro (SEM image)

Source: ST, Chipworks iPhone 4 Teardown

Page 16: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

Bigger chips can span etch

zones

Edge of wafer etches faster

Manufacturing tolerances limit performance of comb-drive gyros

• Nearly all current gyro designs inherently limited by silicon etch accuracy– Non-uniform etching causes quadrature error and cross-axis coupling– Lower Q = higher power consumption

• Work-arounds to maximize gyro performance:– “Cherry-picking” a.k.a. binning– Mode-matching designs– Signal processing and compensation

Stanford PNT Symposium 2017 © AMFitzgerald 2017Page 16

Source: Intellisense

Top heavy etch Bottom heavy etch

Page 17: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

Bulk acoustic wave gyro (industrial grade)

Stanford PNT Symposium 2017 © AMFitzgerald 2017Page 17

Page 18: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

Precision single-axis with inductive drive/sense (tactical grade)

Source: Silicon Sensing Systems

Stanford PNT Symposium 2017 © AMFitzgerald 2017Page 18

Page 19: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

Micro-scale rate integrating gyros (navigation grade)

Stanford PNT Symposium 2017 © AMFitzgerald 2017Page 19

• 3D MEMS structures– Symmetric, atomically-smooth, high Q resonators

Source: UC Irvine, Shkel LabSource: U Michigan, Najafi Lab

Blown ultra low expansion silicate glass

Molded fused silica

Page 20: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

Atomic gyroscopes (strategic grade)

Stanford PNT Symposium 2017 © AMFitzgerald 2017Page 20

• DARPA Chip-Scale Combinatorial Atomic Navigator (C-SCAN)– Program Manager: R. Lutwak– Two architectures being explored:

Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Gyroscopes Atom-Interferometric Gyroscopes

• The ultimate gyroscope, which could one day enable Secretary Ash Carter’s vision of making GPS obsolete

• “MEMS-ish” components useful in physics package

Page 21: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

Other potentially useful MEMS for navigation and sensor fusion

Stanford PNT Symposium 2017 © AMFitzgerald 2017Page 21

Infrared Imager Ultrasonic RangingChirp Microsystems

SensirionGas Sensors

FLIR

MaradinMicro-mirrors: LIDAR

Page 22: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

Conclusions

• Navigation continues to be the practice of sensor fusion– MEMS sensors offer lightweight, low power (low CSWaP) measurements

• MEMS gyroscopes useful for navigation in GNSS-denied environments still in development, at least 5 years away

• Non-inertial sensors could augment navigation in specific applications

• GNSS will continue to be an essential navigation technology for at least 20 more years...while MEMS R&D grinds away on better gyros

Stanford PNT Symposium 2017 © AMFitzgerald 2017Page 22

Page 23: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

About AMFitzgerald

Page 24: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

AMFitzgerald creates MEMS and sensor solutions for specialty applications

© AMFitzgerald 2017Page 24

MEMS Innovation MEMS Solutions Technology Strategy

Paths to manufacturing and

market

Creation of novel devices and IP

Key insights from MEMS experts

Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

Page 25: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

• Custom MEMS development for commercial production• Rapid prototyping on state-of-the-art tools • Supply chain creation and management• Focus on high-performance, specialty silicon devices

© AMFitzgerald 2017

Strategic partners

Development services from concept to production

Page 25Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

Fab operations at 1500m2 UCB Marvell Nanolab

Headquarters in Burlingame, CA

AMFitzgerald in-house

Page 26: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

© AMFitzgerald 2017Page 26

Our work is at the leading edge in many markets

Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

AMFitzgerald typical annual revenue, by market

Cardiology guidewires,

pacemakers, pumps; diagnostic chips

Fiber optic networking, laser

system components,

infrared detectors

Atomic sensors, commercial print heads, quantum

computers

Microphones, pollution detectors

Aircraft, spacecraft sensors

Page 27: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

© AMFitzgerald 2017Page 27

Company contact information

700 Airport Blvd. Suite 210Burlingame, CA 94010, USAPhone: +1 (650) 347 MEMSFax: +1 (650) 347 6366

www.amfitzgerald.com

General Inquiries: [email protected]

Stanford PNT Symposium 2017

Page 28: Stanford PNT Symposium 2017web.stanford.edu/group/scpnt/pnt/PNT17/presentation_files/I07... · Recent Innovations in MEMS Sensors for PNT Applications Stanford PNT Symposium 2017