Stained Red - A Study of Stigma by Association with Blacklisted Artists during the ‘Red Scare’...

7/31/2019 Stained Red - A Study of Stigma by Association with Blacklisted Artists during the Red Scare in Hollywood, 1945-

1/52

_wjfhng ]ng; J _w~gv cb _wfl`j mv Jsscofjwfch |fwe Mdjoidfswng J}wfsws g~}fhl wen ]ng

_oj}n fh Ecddv|ccg$ :67>-:621

Ndf{jmnwe Qchwfins^hfrn}sfwv cb Oefojlc

Lfjoc`c Hnl}cN`c}v ^hfrn}sfwv

Ejvjl}nnrj ]jc_wjhbc}g ^hfrn}sfwv

\c}g oc~hw; :=$:


2/52

:

_wjfhng ]ng; J _w~gv cb _wfl`j mv Jsscofjwfch |fwe Mdjoidfswng J}wfsws g~}fhl wen ]ng

_oj}n fh Ecddv|ccg$ :67>-:621

Jmsw}jow

@c}jd qjhfos lnhn}jwn |fgnsq}njg bnj} cb j swfl`jwf{ng l}c~q( Ec|nrn}$ }ndjwfrndv bn|

fhgfrfg~jds b}c` wen gnrfjhw l}c~q wnhg wc mn wj}lnwng bc} gf}now q~hfwfrn jowfch( Lfrnh wefs$ ec|

fs scofjd ochw}cd nun}wng crn} jh nhwf}n qcq~djwfch3 \n s~llnsw wejw `c}jd qjhfos }ndv ch swfl`j

mv jsscofjwfch js j `noejhfs` cb scofjd ochw}cd jhg cbbn} we}nn j}l~`nhws( Bf}sw$ `n}n

jsscofjwfch |fwe j swfl`jwf{ng jbbfdfjwn fs nhc~le bc} swfl`j wc sq}njg( _nochg$ fhgfrfg~jds j}n

ej}`ng nrnh fb wen}n fs enwn}cqefdv fh `n}n jsscofjwfch wejw fs$ wenv |c}i |fwe gfssf`fdj}

jbbfdfjwns( Bfhjddv$ `c}jd qjhfos nun}w scofjd ochw}cd mnoj~sn nrnh efle-swjw~s fhgfrfg~jds ojh mn

swfl`jwf{ng mv `n}n jsscofjwfch jhg wenf} sjdfnhon o}njwns j m}cjgojsw nbbnow( \n ochg~ow jh

jhjdvsfs cb wen J`n}fojh bfd` fhg~sw}v b}c` :67> wc :621 jhg nuj`fhn ec| j}wfsws n`qdcv`nhw

fh bnjw~}n bfd`s |js fhbd~nhong mv wenf} jsscofjwfch |fwe oc|c}in}s |ec |n}n mdjoidfswng js

Oc``~hfsws jbwn} |c}ifhl |fwe wen bcojd j}wfsw( \n sec| wejw `n}n jsscofjwfch |fwe j

swfl`jwf{ng jbbfdfjwn }ng~ons jh j}wfsws oejhons cb |c}ifhl jljfh jhg wejw chn nuqcs~}n fs

nhc~le wc f`qjf} |c}i q}csqnows( Jowc}s gchw bfhg n`qdcv`nhw |enh |}fwn}s |fwe |ec` wenv

|c}ing |fwe fh j `crfn j}n mdjoidfswng js oc``~hfsws( @c}ncrn}$ wen hnljwfrn nbbnows cb

jsscofjwfch |fwe swfl`jwf{ng oc|c}in}s ecdg nrnh |enh wen bcojd j}wfsw ejs |ch jh Csoj} c}

|c}ing fh mcu-cbbfon efws( \n gfso~ss f`qdfojwfchs bc} wen q}cqjljwfch cb `c}jd qjhfos(


3/52

=

Jbwn} \c}dg \j} FF$ bfd` j}wfsws |ec |n}n hj`ng js s~sqnowng Oc``~hfsws |n}n mdjoidfswng mv

sw~gfcs jhg gnq}frng cb |c}i( Wen mdjoidfsw fh Ecddv|ccg ejs mnnh oc`qj}ng wc wen _qjhfse

Fhz~fsfwfch js j wccd cb scofjd ochw}cd %Onqdjf} jhg Nhld~hg$ :6

|enh wen mdjoidfsw swj}wng$ wc :621 |enh wen mdjoidfsw nhgng$ crn} ?5$111 j}wfsws |c}ing fh

Ecddv|ccg$ jhg `c}n wejh >$


4/52

?

fb qncqdn j}n o~dqjmdn g~n wc qjsw ojs~jd jsscofjwfchs$ wenh wen qccd cb s~sqnows l}c|s( Fhgnng$ fh

Ecddv|ccg$ cb wen ?5$111 ojsw `n`mn}s$ :1$=&( Ec|nrn}$ hnljwfrn fhbc}`jwfch fs

gfjlhcswfojddv qc|n}b~d jhg ojh w}jrn}sn scofjd gfrfgns %]c{fh jhg ]cv{`jh$ =11:&$ jhg sc

|enh swfl`j bdc|s we}c~le enwn}cqefdc~s ochwjow$ scofjd ochw}cd fs nuqjhgng( Bfhjddv$ `c}jd

qjhfos j}n s~swjfhng |enh swfl`j-mv-jsscofjwfch sw}fins gc|h efle-swjw~s fhgfrfg~jds |ec ejrn

|ch q~mdfo joodjf` jhg }noclhfwfch$ o}njwfhl j m}cjgojsw nbbnow(

\n fhrnswfljwn wensn fgnjs fh j sw~gv cb wen ]ng _oj}n fh wen Ecddv|ccg bfd` fhg~sw}v fh

wen qn}fcg swj}wfhl b}c` :67> jhg nhgfhl fh :621( Fh :677 j l}c~q cb q}cg~on}s$ ndfwn jowc}s jhg

|}fwn}s o}njwng wen @cwfch Qfow~}n Jddfjhons bc} wen Q}nsn}rjwfch cb J`n}fojh Fgnjds %@QJ& wc

nsqc~sn ochsn}rjwfrn oj~sns( Wen bc~hgn}s fhod~gng \jdw Gfshnv$ Kceh \jvhn$ Lj}v Occqn}$

Enggj Ecqqn}$ jhg ]cv M}n|swn}( Wen @QJ q}crfgng hj`ns cb jddnlng Oc``~hfsws wc wen

Ec~sn Oc``fwwnn ch ^h-J`n}fojh Jowfrfwfns %E^JO& wc bjofdfwjwn wen bf}sw mdjoidfswfhl cb ]ng

j}wfsws fh :67= jhg :6>7$

jhg nrnhw~jddv gnodfhng mv :621 %Mndb}jln$ :6


5/52

7

s~bbn}ng scofjd nuod~sfch jhg$ `csw f`qc}wjhwdv$ |n}n gnhfng |c}i mnoj~sn wenv |n}n c} |n}n

s~sqnowng wc mn ]ngs( Nrnh `c}n fhwn}nswfhl fs wen z~nswfch cb ec| bj} wen swfl`j sq}njg

g~}fhl wefs qjhfo( Wen mdjoidfswfhl |js qj}wdv j m~}nj~o}jwf{ng jhg svswn`jwfo q}conss$ |en}n

sw~gfcs jqqcfhwng wenf} c|h odnj}jhon cbbfon}s wc so}nnh wenf} n`qdcvnns( Js j }ns~dw$ chn `flew

nuqnow swfl`j-mv-jsscofjwfch nbbnows wc mn `fhf`jd sfhon fhgfrfg~jds |n}n oj}nb~ddv sndnowng bc}

mdjoidfswfhl( Vnw$ |n gco~`nhw wejw j}wfsws |ec |n}n `n}ndv jsscofjwng |fwe mdjoidfswng

fhgfrfg~jds m~w |n}n hcw mdjoidfswng wen`sndrns$ ejg gfbbfo~dwv bfhgfhl |c}i fh Ecddv|ccg g~}fhl

wen ]ng _oj}n( Fh qj}wfo~dj}$ j}wfsws |n}n dnss dfindv wc |c}i jljfh |enh wenf} jbbfdfjwns |n}n

mdjoidfswng js Oc``~hfsws jbwn}|c}ifhl fh wen sj`n bfd`%s& |fwe wen`( Onqdjf} jhg Nhld~hg

%:6


6/52

>

qcq~djwfch fs `jgn gnrfjhw ch wen mjsfs cb fgncdclv$ hjwfchjdfwv$ }ndflfch c} }jon( Fh sec}w$ j w}fmjd

c} ocddnowfrn swfl`j fs o}njwng(

Wen dfwn}jw~}n ch `c}jd qjhfos lfrns f`qc}wjhon wc jowfrfsws c} qj}wfsjhs |ec o}njwn wen

jhufnwv c} bnj} fh wen bf}sw qdjon( Vnw$ jh ~hnuqdc}ng fss~n fs ec| qj}wfsjhs c} jowfrfsws nun}w

scofjd ochw}cd |enh wenv q~hfse j bn| fhgfrfg~jds we}c~le gf}now jowfch( @c}ncrn}$ jowfrfsws ojh

mn fh sec}w s~qqdv jhg djoi jh c}ljhf{jwfchjd fhb}jsw}~ow~}n( Ec| wenh fs scofjd ochw}cd nun}wng

crn} j wj}lnw qcq~djwfch3

Qj}wfsjhs |ec sndnow jh fss~n jhg wj}lnw j l}c~q cbwnh ejrn fhoc`qdnwn c} j`mfl~c~s

fhbc}`jwfch jmc~w fhgfrfg~jds( Ec|nrn}$ |ejw ojh wenv ojh gc fs o}njwn j swn}ncwvqn djmnds wejw

mnoc`n ochhnowng wc hnljwfrn jww}fm~wns %Dfhi jhg Qendjh$ =11:&( J swn}ncwvqn }nbn}s wc wen

ochwnhw cb j snw cb jss~`ng oej}jown}fswfos jsscofjwng |fwe j qj}wfo~dj} scofjd l}c~q9 swn}ncwvqns

j}n fhrcdrng fh ocddnowfrn swfl`jwf{jwfch mnoj~sn hcw chdv fs wen }nsqchsn cb wen qn}onfrn}

hnljwfrn$ m~w jdsc mnoj~sn j sqnofbfo snw cb oej}jown}fswfos fs jss~`ng wc nufsw j`chl wen nhwf}n

l}c~q %Gcrfgfc$ @jkc} jhg O}coin}$ =11?&( Fh `c}jd qjhfos$ chon j ojwnlc}v bc} gnrfjhon ejs

mnnh ochsw}~owng jhg fs lnhn}jddv joonqwng$ swn}ncwvqfhl ojh endq k~swfbv scofnwvs sw}chl

ochgn`hjwfch cb s~sqnowng `n`mn}s cb wen gnrfjhw l}c~q %Lccgn jhg Mnh-Vne~gj$ :667&( Wen

swn}ncwvqns ochwjfh `j}in}s wejw jddc| fhgfrfg~jds wc mnoc`n gf}nowdv swfl`jwf{ng jhg q~hfseng(

M~w nrnh fb chdv j bn| fhgfrfg~jds j}n gf}nowdv q~hfseng$ swfl`j-mv-jsscofjwfch nuqjhgs wen

scofjd ochw}cd cb j qcq~djwfch jhg mv f`qdfojwfch$ q}cqjljwns wen `c}jd qjhfo(

@n}n Jsscofjwfch( Lcbb`jh %:62?& gnso}fmng oc~}wnsv swfl`j js wen wjfhw wejw jbbdfows

fhgfrfg~jds jsscofjwng |fwe cwen}s |ec j}n mdn`fseng mv `nhwjd fddhnss c} gfs}nq~wjmdn

coo~qjwfchs( _fhon wenh$ j h~`mn} cb djmc}jwc}v sw~gfns ejrn sec|h wejw swfl`j mv jsscofjwfch fs

}j`qjhw %M~}i jhg _en}$ :6619 Hn~mn}l nw jd($ :6679 Lcdgswnfh jhg Kcehsch$ :66


7/52

2

Fh ochrnhwfchjd djmc}jwc}v nuqn}f`nhws$ swfl`j sq}njgs bc}|j}gwc nlc b}c` jh jdwn} |ec

fs swfl`jwf{ng nu-jhwn( n(l($ wen qn}sch fs jd}njgv cmnsn c} s~bbn}s b}c` j gfsjmfdfwv( Fh s~oe

ojsns$ nlc ejs fhbc}`jwfch jmc~w jdwn} jhg vnw oeccsns wc jbbfdfjwn |fwe en}( Mv ochw}jsw$ swfl`j-

mv-jsscofjwfch ojh jdsc q}cqjljwn mjoi|j}gb}c` jh jbbfdfjwn |ec fs swfl`jwf{ng nu-qcsw$ c} jbwn}

wen jsscofjwfch |fwe nlc( Cb oc~}sn$ nlc djois ihc|dngln wejw jdwn} |fdd mnoc`n swfl`jwf{ng jhg

sc s~oe rcd~hwj}v jbbfdfjwfchs j}n mjsng ch f`qn}bnow fhbc}`jwfch( \enh qncqdn ojh mnoc`n

swfl`jwf{ng g~n wc nu-qcsw jbbfdfjwfchs$ swfl`j-mv-jsscofjwfch fs dfindv wc gfbb~sn qjhfo jhg

nuqjhg scofjd ochw}cd cb j wj}lnw qcq~djwfch( Fh `c}jd qjhfos$ swfl`j-mv-jsscofjwfch dfhis nlc wc

wen gnrfjhw l}c~q jhg dnjgs wc gfso}f`fhjwc}v mnejrfc}( Chn }ndnrjhw bc}` cb nuod~sfch fs

n`qdcv`nhw$ js fw gf}nowdv f`qjows mcwe scofjd jhg nochc`fo swjhgfhl( We~s$ wen w}jhs`fssfch cb

swfl`j we}c~le `n}n jsscofjwfch ojh ejrn l}jrn ochsnz~nhons bc} jh fhgfrfg~jd( Wjinh wclnwen}$

wensn j}l~`nhws f`qdv;

E:; @n}n jsscofjwfch |fwe jdwn}s |ec j}n swfl`jwf{ng jbwn} |c}ifhl |fwe nlc fs nhc~le wc

wjfhw nlc jhg wc ej}` kcm q}csqnows(

Ec| `n}n gc jsscofjwfchs hnng wc mn wc q}cg~on swfl`j3 Wen nbbnows cb swfl`j-mv-

jsscofjwfch j}n nsqnofjddv qc|n}b~d mnoj~sn wenv qn}sfsw jbwn} j sfhldn nuqcs~}n( ]fsnh jhg

Lfdcrfoe %=11


8/52

&( _f`fdj}fwv bcswn}s

nuoejhln$ fhbc}`jwfch sej}fhl jhg w}~sw$ jhg qc|n}s gfbb~sfch %@oQen}sch$ _`fwe-Dcrfh jhg

Occi$ =11:&( Ochrn}sndv$ swfl`j ojh sq}njg we}c~le enwn}cqefdv( Chn }njsch fs wejw hnljwfrn

fhbc}`jwfch fs sw}chln} wejh qcsfwfrn fhbc}`jwfch jhg sc ojh w}jrn}sn scofjd gfswjhons( Mjg nrnhws$

`n`c}fns$ cgc}s$ jhg }ndjwfchsefqs j}n `c}n sjdfnhw wejh lccg nrnhws$ `n`c}fns$ cgc}s jhg

}ndjwfchsefqs %Mj~`nfswn}$ M}jwsdjrsiv jhg Bfhinhj~n}$ =11:&( Bc} fhswjhon$ `fhf`jd ochwjow

|fwe dc|n} ojswns q}cg~ons `c}n ochwjlfch wejh ochwjow |fwe eflen} ojswns fh oc~hw}fns |fwe

ojswn svswn`s %@nfls$ :657&( Wensn bfhgfhls s~llnsw wejw j hnljwfrfwv mfjs nufsws fh scofjd

nrjd~jwfchs mnoj~sn hnljwfrn nrnhws j}n sjdfnhw$ vfndg oc`qdnu }nq}nsnhwjwfchs$ j}n qn}onfrng wc

mn `c}n gfjlhcswfo jhg nrcin |fgn} }nqn}wcf}ns wejh qcsfwfrn nrnhws %]c{fh jhg ]cv{`jh$ =11:&(

_wfl`j fs j }ndjwfchsefq mnw|nnh jh jww}fm~wn jhg j swn}ncwvqn %Kchns nw jd($ :657& }jwen} wejh

mnfhl sc`nwefhl w}flln}ng mv wen gfswfhowfrn z~jdfwfns cb jh fhgfrfg~jd( \fhwn} jhg ^dn`jh

%:657& s~llnsw wejw wen w}jhs`fssfch cb swfl`j efhlns ch w}jfw jowfrjwfch$ w}jfw jsscofjwfch jhg w}jfw

w}jhsbn}$ sc wejw swfl`j ojh mn w}jhsbn}}ng wc cwen} fhgfrfg~jds |fwe `fhf`jd ochwjow( Jhv ochwjow

fs jdd wejw fs hnonssj}v bc} jh nssnhon wc qjss mnw|nnh w|c jowc}s jhg dnjrn j w}jon %]c{fh jhg

Hn`n}cbb$ :661&( Chn f`qdfojwfch fs wejw wejw swfl`j w}jhsbn}s b}c` chn fhgfrfg~jd wc jhcwen}

nrnh fb wen w|c fhgfrfg~jds j}n gfssf`fdj}(

E?; @n}n jsscofjwfch |fwe jdwn}s |ec coo~qv gfssf`fdj} }cdns jhg j}n swfl`jwf{ng jbwn}

|c}ifhl |fwe nlc fs nhc~le wc wjfhw nlc jhg ej}` kcm q}csqnows(

Wen M}cjgojsw Nbbnow cb Efle-_wjw~s Rfowf`s; @c}jd qjhfos we}frn mnoj~sn swfl`j-mv-

jsscofjwfch ojh ej}` nrnh efle-swjw~s jhg q~mdfodv joodjf`ng fhgfrfg~jds( @n}wch %:625;2=&

s~llnswng wejw l}jgng }n|j}gs fh sofnhon j}n gfsw}fm~wng jooc}gfhl wc wen ocfh cb }noclhfwfch jhg

djmndng fw js wen @jwwen| nbbnow$ |efoe ochsfsws fh wen joo}~fhl cb l}njwn} fho}n`nhws cb


9/52

5

}noclhfwfch bc} qj}wfo~dj} sofnhwfbfo ochw}fm~wfchs wc sofnhwfsws cb ochsfgn}jmdn }nq~wn jhg wen

|fweecdgfhl cb }noclhfwfch b}c` sofnhwfsws |ec ejrn hcw vnw `jgn wenf} `j}i( J h~`mn} cb

sw~gfns sec| wejw fhgfrfg~jds |fwe l}njwn} }noclhfwfch }nonfrn `c}n }n|j}gs wejh dnss }noclhf{ng

qnn}s bc} |c}i cb sf`fdj} z~jdfwv %Qcgcdhv$ =11>&( Qefddfqs jhg [~oin}`jh %=11>& bc~hg wejw

efle-swjw~s jowc}s |c~dg mn nun`qw b}c` wen ej}`b~d ochsnz~nhons cb hc}` rfcdjwfchs( Wefs dfhn

cb }njschfhl f`qdfns wejw q~mdfo }noclhfwfch sec~dg m~bbn} wen ej}`b~d nbbnows cb `n}n jsscofjwfch

|fwe swfl`jwf{ng cwen}s(

Gcns wefs `njh wejw qncqdn |ec ejrn }nonfrng q~mdfo }noclhfwfch j}n f``~hn wc wen

ej}`b~d nbbnows cb `n}n jsscofjwfch |fwe swfl`j3 \n j}l~n hc( Fh `c}jd qjhfos$ gnrfjhon fs

jss~`ng wc d~}i fh jdd oc}hn}s cb wen scofjd bjm}fo$ jhg wefs jss~`qwfch bcswn}s |fgnsq}njg bnj}(

B~}wen}$ wen gfsocrn}v wejw |ndd }nlj}gng fhgfrfg~jds j}n qj}w cb wen gnrfjhw l}c~q ejs j

m}cjgojsw nbbnow wejw ~qecdgs wen jwwnhwfch bc} wen ochon}h jhg k~swfbfns j qn}rjsfrn snj}oe( Fh

wen N~}cqnjh |fwoe o}j{n$ jdwec~le |fgc|s jhg sqfhswn}s |n}n wen fhfwfjd rfowf`s$ fh djwn}

swjlns scofjd swjw~s jhg nrnh lnhgn} `jgn dfwwdn gfbbn}nhon sc wejw nrnhw~jddv jdd |c`nh jhg `nh

oc~dg mn wj}lnwng %Mnh-Vne~gj$ :651&(

L}njwn} }noclhfwfch ojh `jlhfbv nuqcs~}n wc swfl`j-mv-jsscofjwfch( _wfl`j-mv-

jsscofjwfch jhg swn}ncwvqfhl cqn}jwn we}c~le j~wc`jwfo oclhfwfch jhg }ndv ch en~}fswfos %Gcrfgfc

nw jd( :66


10/52

6

E7; @n}n jsscofjwfch |fwe jdwn}s |ec j}n swfl`jwf{ng jbwn} |c}ifhl |fwe nlc wjfhw nlc

jhg ej}` kcm q}csqnows nrnh fb nlc ejs }nonfrng q~mdfo }noclhfwfch(

WEN ]NG _OJ]N FH WEN ECDDV\CCG BFD@ FHG^_W]V9:67>-:621

Jbwn} \c}dg \j} FF$ j l}c~q cb q}cg~on}s$ jowc}s jhg |}fwn}s bc}`ng wen @QJ wc nsqc~sn jhwf-

Oc``~hfsw oj~sns$ jhg swj}wng ocddjmc}jwfhl |fwe wen Ec~sn Oc``fwwnn ch ^h-J`n}fojh

Jowfrfwfns %E^JO& j oc``fwwnn cb wen Ec~sn cb ]nq}nsnhwjwfrns fhrnswfljwfhl we}njws cb

s~mrn}sfch mv q}crfgfhl hj`ns cb jddnlng Oc``~hfsws( Wefs dng wc wen fhfwfjd mdjoidfswfhl cb

]ng j}wfsws fh :67< %Mndb}jln$ :6


11/52


12/52

::

Jowc}s q~w ch wen mdjoidfsw c} l}jvdfsw bjong fgnhwfojd ochsnz~nhons wenv dcsw wenf} kcms(

]jmmf Mnhkj`fh _oe~d{ |ec gf}nowng wen J`n}fojh Kn|fse Dnjl~n jljfhsw Oc``~hfs`$ jhg

s~qn}`j}inw c|hn}s we}njwnhng wc mcvocww bfd`s |fwe Oc``~hfsws( Dj~}nhon Kcehsch$ j

s~qn}`j}inw c|hn} fh _v}jo~sn$ Hn| Vc}i$ we}njwnhng wc qdjon sflhs fh efs swc}ns |j}hfhl

o~swc`n}s hcw wc m~v wen q}cg~ows cb jhv oc`qjhv wejw sqchsc}ng j q}cl}j` bnjw~}fhl chn cb

_wjdfh,s dfwwdn o}njw~}ns( _fhon wen sw~gfcs gnqnhgng ch mjhis bc} bfhjhofhl jhg fh w~}h$ mjhis

|n}n dnn}v cb mjoifhl bfd`s dfindv wc mn mcvocwwng fh wenjwn}s$ wen sw~gfc enjgs joonqwng wen ]ng

Oejhhnds l~fgn jdchl |fwe wen dfsw cb hj`ns s~qqdfng mv wen E^JO jhg mv _nhjwc} @oOj}wevs

swjbb js wen mjsfs bc} wenf} mdjoidfsw(

Jdwec~le mdjoidfswfhl rfcdjwng |c}in} q}cwnowfchs l~j}jhwnng mv wen Hjwfchjd Djmc}

]ndjwfchs Mcj}g$ mdjoidfswng j}wfsws gfg hcw }nonfrn s~qqc}w b}c` wen l~fdgs mnoj~sn `jhjln`nhw

bndw wen hnng wc qjhgn} wc ochsn}rjwfrn q~mdfo cqfhfch( Chn cb wen `n`mn}s cb wen fhrnswfljwfhl

oc``fwwnn z~cwng fh Ocldnv %:6>2;55& fhgfojwns wejw wen sw~gfcs njln}hnss wc nhbc}on mdjoidfsws

|js qj}wfjddv j }ns~dw cb wen sqnofjd hjw~}n cb bfd`; Wen nhwn}wjfh`nhw fhg~sw}v fs wen chdv chn F

ihc| |en}n dfrndfeccg gnqnhgs ch wen jwwfw~gn cb wen q~mdfo wc|j}g j qn}schs hj`n(

@oLfddfljh jhg M~edn %:661$ |enh

en} hj`n jqqnj}ng fh ]ng Oejhhnds$ sen |c}ing chdv we}nn |nnis\enh wen Ecddv|ccg


13/52

:=

enj}fhls |n}n }ns~`ng fh :6>:$ Jhhn ]nrn}n |js chn cb wen bf}sw s~mqcnhjng( _en fhrcing wen

Bf}sw jhg Bfbwe J`nhg`nhws jhg ejs hcw |c}ing fh bfd`s sfhon %Ocldnv$ :6>2;56&( J}wfsws ejg wc

jmjhgch wenf} oj}nn}s %n(l( Oej}dns Oejqdfh$ Kcsnqe Dcsnv& jhg `c}n wejh chn mdjoi-dfswnn nhgng

~q |jfwfhl wjmdns( _c`n |}fwn}s ~sng jdfjsns jhg sc~lew wc lnw |c}i$ jowc}s oc~dg hcw( [n}c

@cswnd sjfg F j` j `jh cb :111 bjons$ jdd cb wen` mdjoidfswng(

\efdn efswc}fjhs joihc|dngln wejw `csw j}wfsws ojddng wc wnswfbv mnbc}n E^JO ejg jowfrn

qcdfwfojd qjsws$ wenv jdsc hcwn wejw wen fhg~sw}vs mdjoidfsws jhg l}jvdfsws |n}n fhgfso}f`fhjwn jhg

j}wfsws fh wen bfd` fhg~sw}v |n}n wj}lnwng mnvchg wen }jwfchjd `joefhn cb wen enj}fhls( Onqdjf} jhg

Nhld~hg %:6=$

jhg l~nssng fw |js mnoj~sn efs |c}i |js }nrfn|ng fh j b}fnhgdv |jv mv Wen Gjfdv \c}in}$ wen

Oc``~hfsw Qj}wvs hn|sqjqn} %@oLfddfljh jhg M~edn$ :666 so}nnh|}fwn} Gjdwch W}~`mc

}nrnjdng wejw en |js mnefhg wen fgnhwfwv cb |}fwn} ]cmn}w ]foe$ |ec |c}ing ch wen so}fqw bc} wen

bfd` Wen M}jrn Chn$ %:6>


14/52


15/52

:7

l~fdw-mv-jsscofjwfch |fwe wen |njidv gnbfhng gfso}ngfwng ojwnlc}v( Fh sfw~jwfchs cb jhufnwv jhg

~hon}wjfhwv scofjd jowc}s |n}n `c}n dfindv wc qjss ch jhg }ndv ch hcfsv fhbc}`jwfch$ j mnejrfc}

swf`~djwng mv wen j`mfl~c~s hjw~}n cb Oc``~hfsw jbbfdfjwfchs %wejw |n}n jw dnjsw fh qj}w sno}nw&(

Nrnh |nji swf`~df dfin qjsw oc|c}in} jbbfdfjwfchs oc~dg snhsfwf{n wen bfd` oc``~hfwv wc wen

jdj}` cb Oc``~hfs` sc wejw gfbbn}nhw fgnhwfwfns |c~dg mn jssf`fdjwng fhwc wen sj`n oclhfwfrn

b}j`n|c}i(

GJWJ JHG @NWECG_

\n ljwen}ng gjwj ch wen Ecddv|ccg bfd` fhg~sw}v g~}fhl wen qn}fcg swj}wfhl fh :67> jhg nhgfhl

fh :621( C~} q}f`j}v sc~}on fs wen J`n}fojh Bfd` Fhswfw~wn Ojwjdcl cb @cwfch Qfow~}ns %JBF&$ j

oc`q}nenhsfrn nhovodcqngfo q~mdfojwfch wejw q}crfgns fhbc}`jwfch ch jdd `cwfch qfow~}ns

}ndnjsng fh wen ^(_( Wen JBF gf}nowc}v q}crfgns gnwjfdng fhbc}`jwfch ch njoe bfd` }ndnjsng

g~}fhl c~} sw~gv qn}fcg$ fhod~gfhl wen q}cg~owfch jhg gfsw}fm~wfch oc`qjhfns$ }ndnjsn gjwn$

dnhlwe$ ojsw$ jhg lnh}n( \n swj}w c~} cmsn}rjwfch qn}fcg fh :67> mnoj~sn f& wen jhufnwv jmc~w

Oc``~hfsw qnhnw}jwfch cb J`n}fojh scofnwv }njddv `jhfbnswng fwsndb jbwn} \c}dg \j} FF$ jhg ff&

fh wejw sj`n vnj} wen @QJ q}crfgng wen bf}sw hj`ns wc wen E^JO wc nsqc~sn ochsn}rjwfrn oj~sns$

fhj~l~}jwfhl wen mdjoidfswfhl cb Oc``~hfsws jhg sv`qjwef{n}s j`chl Ecddv|ccg j}wfsws( \n nhg

c~} cmsn}rjwfch fh :621 mnoj~sn jw wejw qcfhw wen mdjoidfsw |js nbbnowfrndv m}cinh |fwe wen q~mdfo

joihc|dngln`nhw cb Gjdwch W}~`mc js |}fwn} bc}_qj}wjo~s jhg Nucg~s %Onqdjf} jhg Nhld~hg$

:6


16/52

:>

fhod~gns q}cg~on}$ jsscofjwn q}cg~on}$ nuno~wfrn q}cg~on}$ jhg$ bc} bfd`s |en}n hc cwen}

q}cg~ofhl }cdn fs q}crfgng$ q}nsnhwn}9 wen jow}nss#jowc} }cdns fhod~gn wen bf}sw >1 o}ngfwng hj`ns

ch wen nhg cb wfwdn dfsw( \n }nsw}fowng c~} sj`qdn cb bfd`s mv nuod~gfhl bfd`s q}cg~ong jhg

}ndnjsng bc} hch-oc``n}ofjd q~}qcsns$ f`qc}wng bfd`s jhg sec}w bfd`s(

Gnqnhgnhw jhg Fhgnqnhgnhw Rj}fjmdns; \n fhrnswfljwn |enwen} swfl`j-mv-jsscofjwfch

ej}`ng kcm q}csqnows mv nswf`jwfhl wen dfindfeccg wejw jh fhgfrfg~jd }nonfrng n`qdcv`nhw( C~}

q}f`j}v gnqnhgnhw rj}fjmdn fs we~s jh j}wfsw-vnj} mfhj}v rj}fjmdn nz~jd wc : |enh j bcojd j}wfsw

ljfhng n`qdcv`nhw fh bfd` fh wen hnuw vnj}$ jhg 1 cwen}|fsn %Mfndmv jhg Mfndmv$ :6669

[~oin}`jh$ If`$ ^ijh|j jhg rch ]fww`jh$ =11?&( Fh s~qqdn`nhwj}v jhjdvsns$ |n jdsc jhjdv{n

|enwen} jh j}wfsw |js mdjoidfswng js j snochg gnqnhgnhw rj}fjmdn$ nz~jd wc : |enh j bcojd jowc}

|js mdjoidfswng fh wen o~}}nhw vnj}$ jhg 1 cwen}|fsn(

C~} fhgnqnhgnhw rj}fjmdns j}n `n}n jsscofjwfch |fwe mdjoidfswng j}wfsws$ wc wnsw

evqcwensns E:E?$ jhg |enwen} wen j}wfsw |js jh Csoj} |fhhn} c} |c}ing fh jw dnjsw chn bfd`

wejw |js bnjw~}ng fh wen wnh dj}lnsw mcu-cbbfon }nhwjds njoe vnj}$ wc wnsw E7( Gjwj bc} wen

mdjoidfswng j}wfsws }nbn} wc wecsn fhgfrfg~jds |ec |n}n dfswng |ecsn hj`ns |n}n dnjing mv wen

E^JO wc wen q}nss$ c} |n}n dfswng fh wen ~hcbbfofjd Mfmdn cb jddnlng Oc``~hfsw sv`qjwef{n}s$

jhg oc`n b}c` Rj~leh %=117& jhg ]ng Oejhhnds %:6>1&( Jh j}wfsw J ejs `n}n jsscofjwfch |fwe

j mdjoidfswng j}wfsw M jw wf`n w fb J jhg M ejg |c}ing fh %jw dnjsw& chn bfd` wclnwen} ~hwfd wf`n w f-:

jhg M fs mdjoidfswng jw wf`n w( \n wen}nbc}n nuj`fhn n`qdcv`nhw fh bfd` bc} jowc} J mnw|nnh

wf`n wf): jhg wF$ |fwe F 0 :621(Gjwj ch Csoj} |fhhn}s oc`n b}c` _ejdn %:66?& %m~w j}n jdsc

jrjfdjmdn b}c` wen Jojgn`v cb @cwfch Qfow~}n J}ws jhg _ofnhons |nmsfwn$ |||(csoj}(oc`& jhg

gjwj ch bfd` }nhwjds oc`n b}c` wen qn}fcgfojd Rj}fnwvs dfsws cb Jdd-wf`n Bfd` ]nhwjd Oej`qs(

\n chdv ochsfgn} `n}n jsscofjwfch$ sc |n gc hcw fhod~gn fh c~} }fsi snw wecsn j}wfsws

|ec |n}n wen`sndrns mdjoidfswng( Fh sc`n ojsns$ j}wfsws |c}ing |fwe jhcwen} j}wfsw |ec ejg

jd}njgv mnnh mdjoidfswng( Wensn ojsns gc hcw ochswfw~wn `n}n jsscofjwfch sfhon wen j}wfsw ejs nu-

jhwn fhbc}`jwfch$ jhg sc |n}n nuod~gng( \n gnbfhng wen `njs~}ns fhod~gng fh wen nswf`jwfch js

bcddc|s; `n}n jsscofjwfch |fwe mdjoidfswng j}wfsws fs wen h~`mn} cb j}wfsws |ec ejg |c}ing |fwe


17/52

:2

bcojd j}wfsw jhg mnnh mdjoidfswng jbwn} ejrfhl |c}ing |fwe wen bcojd j}wfsw( \n djllng wefs

`njs~}n mv chn vnj}(

Wc wnsw |enwen} chn jsscofjwfch fs nhc~le wc dnjg wc gfso}f`fhjwfch$ |n fhod~gn fh c~} }fsi

snw chdv wecsn j}wfsws |fwe `n}n nuqcs~}n cb dnss wejh c} nz~jd wc chn wecsn |ec ejrn chdv mnnh

fh j `crfn |fwe chn qn}sch s~msnz~nhwdv mdjoidfswng( \n nuj`fhn enwn}cqefdv mv `njs~}fhl

`n}n jsscofjwfch mnw|nnh j bcojd jowc} jhg mdjoidfswng |}fwn}s$ wen}nmv ojqw~}fhl }cdn

gfssf`fdj}fwv( \n nuqnow wejw |}fwn}s jhg jowc}s ejg `fhf`jd }cdn fhwn}gnqnhgnhon$ `juf`jd }cdn

gfswjhon$ jhg enhon$ rn}v efle gfssf`fdj}fwv( Bfhjddv$ wc fhrnswfljwn |enwen} q~mdfodv }noclhf{ng

j}wfsws j}n ej}`ng mv `n}n jsscofjwfch |fwe swfl`jwf{ng jdwn}s$ |n ~sn w|c `njs~}ns cb q~mdfo

}noclhfwfch; mcu cbbfon s~oonss jhg Csoj} |fhs( Fh wen bf}sw `cgnd$ |n snqj}jwn fhwc w|c rj}fjmdns

:& `n}n jsscofjwfch |fwe mdjoidfswng jdwn}s bc} j}wfsws |ec |c}ing fh j wcq-wnh mcu cbbfon }nhwjd

bfd` jhg =& `n}n jsscofjwfch |fwe mdjoidfswng jdwn}s bc} jdd cwen} j}wfsws( Fh wen snochg `cgnd$ |n

snqj}jwn fhwc w|c rj}fjmdns; :& `n}n jsscofjwfch |fwe swfl`jwf{ng jdwn}s bc} j}wfsws |ec ejg |ch

jh Csoj}$ jhg =& `n}n jsscofjwfch |fwe mdjoidfswng jdwn}s bc} jdd cwen} j}wfsws( \n ojh wenh

oc`qj}n wen nbbnows cb `n}n jsscofjwfch |fwe swfl`jwf{ng fhgfrfg~jds bc} o}fwfojddv joodjf`ng jhg

q~mdfodv }noclhf{ng j}wfsws js oc`qj}ng wc jdd cwen} j}wfsws(

Wen}n j}n ?5$111 ojsw `n`mn}s fh wen gjwj jhg >$5$6?7

ojsw-vnj} cmsn}rjwfchs( Cb wen ?5$111 ojsw `n`mn}s$ =2< |n}n cbbfofjddv mdjoidfswng mnw|nnh

:67> jhg :621( : Wen}n j}n ?:$


18/52


19/52


20/52

:6

@jhv cb wen sw}jwnlfns ~sng wc gnjd |fwe s~oe sndb-sndnowfch fss~ns j}n q}cmdn`jwfo( Bc}

nuj`qdn$ ochw}cddfhl bc} wf`n-rj}vfhl nhgclnhc~s ochbc~hgn}s fs gfbbfo~dw mnoj~sn nhgclnhc~s

wf`n-rj}vfhl ochbc~hgn}s ojh jdsc fhg~on j oc}}ndjwfch mnw|nnh wen w}njw`nhw jhg }nsqchsn nrnh

|enh hc oj~sjd jsscofjwfch nufsws %]cmfhs$ :666&( _f`fdj}dv$ fhsw}~`nhwjd rj}fjmdn jqq}cjoens

j}n q}cmdn`jwfo mnoj~sn bfhgfhl qdj~sfmdn fhsw}~`nhws wejw `nnw wen fgnhwfbvfhl o}fwn}fj fs

gfbbfo~dw( Cbwnh$ chn qn}schs fhsw}~`nhw fs jhcwen} qn}schs evqcwensf{ng nbbnow(

\n jgg}nss wen q}cmdn` cb ochbc~hgfhl rj}fjmdns mv fhrcifhl oc~hwn}bjow~jd `nwecgs

cb fhbn}nhon |en}n wen sj`qdn qcq~djwfch fs gfrfgng fhwc j w}njw`nhw l}c~q %wecsn |ec j}n

nuqcsng wc jbbfdfjwns wejw lnw mdjoidfswng djwn}& jhg j ochw}cd l}c~q %wecsn |ec j}n hcw&(

Oc~hwn}bjow~jd `nwecgs jss~`n njoe fhgfrfg~jd ejs w|c c~woc`ns( Wen bf}sw c~woc`n fs wen

w}njw`nhw ochgfwfch$ Vw($ jhg wen snochg fs wen ochw}cd ochgfwfch$ Vo( Bc} njoe fhgfrfg~jd$ chdv chn

cb wensn c~woc`ns ojh mn cmsn}rng( We~s$ fss~ns cb oj~sjdfwv j}n w}njwng js j `fssfhl gjwj

q}cmdn` cb wen ~hcmsn}rng oc~hwn}bjow~jd %\fhsefq jhg @c}ljh$ :666&$ ~s~jddv jgg}nssng fh

nuqn}f`nhwjwfch we}c~le }jhgc`f{jwfch( Fh cwen} |c}gs$ fb |n jss~`n nz~frjdnhon cb ochw}cds

jhg w}njw`nhws$ |n ojh nswf`jwn wen oj~sjd nbbnow$ Vw- Vo(

\enh wen w}njw`nhw$ wen ochbc~hgfhl ocrj}fjwns$ jhg wen c~woc`n rj}v crn} wf`n$

nswf`jwns ojh mn mfjsng %En}hh$ M}~`mjoi$ jhg ]cmfhs$ =11:9 ]cmfhs$ En}hh$ jhg M}~`mjoi$

=111&( Chn qc|n}b~d jqq}cjoe gnrndcqng mv ]cmfhs nw jd( %=111& fs fhrn}sn q}cmjmfdfwv cb

|nflewfhl w}njw`nhw %FQ\W& `cgnds |en}n njoe s~mknow f fs |nflewng jw wf`n imv wen fhrn}sn cb

wen q}cmjmfdfwv wejw wen s~mknow jow~jddv }nonfrng wen w}njw`nhw jw wf`n i( Wefs |nflew fs nswf`jwng

lfrnh q}fc} w}njw`nhw efswc}v$ wf`n-rj}vfhl$ jhg wf`n-fhrj}fjhw ocrj}fjwns( Bcddc|fhl ]cmfhs nw jd(

%=111& |n ~sn swjmfdf{ng |nflews$ |en}n wen gnhc`fhjwc} fs wen q}cmjmfdfwv wejw j s~mknow

}nonfrng efs cmsn}rng w}njw`nhw jw wf`n i lfrnh qjsw w}njw`nhw jhg ocrj}fjwn efswc}v$ jhg wen

h~`n}jwc} fs wen q}cmjmfdfwv wejw wen s~mknow }nonfrng wen qjsw w}njw`nhw efswc}v |fwec~w jgk~swfhl

bc} ocrj}fjwn efswc}v(

Wc oc`q~wn wen swjmfdf{ng |nflews |n ~sng wen ochw}cd rj}fjmdns %bc} wen h~`n}jwc} jhg

gnhc`fhjwc}& jhg j sn}fns cb fhgfojwc} rj}fjmdns %bc} wen gnhc`fhjwc}& `njs~}fhl |enwen} j


21/52


22/52

=:

fh j bfd` |fwe sc`nchn jd}njgv mdjoidfswng( @cgnd : fh wjmdn = sec|s wen nbbnows cb ochw}cd

rj}fjmdns( ]ns~dws sec| wejw wen q}fc} h~`mn} cb wcwjd jsscofjwfchs$ q}fc} h~`mn} cb bfd`s fh

|efoe wen j}wfsw ejs |c}ing$ h~`mn} cb Csoj} |fhs jhg h~`mn} cb wcq-wnh bfd`s fh |efoe jh j}wfsw

ejs |c}ing sflhfbfojhwdv fho}njsn wen cggs cb n`qdcv`nhw fh wen hnuw vnj}( H~`mn} cb Csoj}

|fhhfhl bfd`s fh |efoe jh j}wfsw ejs |c}ing gcns hcw ejrn j sflhfbfojhw nbbnow$ dfindv mnoj~sn cb

wen crn}djq |fwe wen j}wfsws Csoj} |fhs jhg ejrfhl |c}ing fh j mcu cbbfon oej`qfch bfd`(

_qnofjdfsws ljfh `c}n n`qdcv`nhw js }nrnjdng mv wen nbbnow cb wen ochonhw}jwfch }jwfc$ jhg wen

fhwn}jowfch cb %h~`mn} bfd`s u sqnofjdfs`& jdsc ejs sflhfbfojhw nbbnows ch wen cggs cb n`qdcv`nhw$

s~oe wejw `c}n nuqn}fnhong j}wfsws mnhnbfw dnss b}c` `c}n bco~sng lnh}n-mjsng oj}nn}s( \n we~s

}nqdfojwn wen }ns~dws bc~hg mv [~oin}`jh nw jd( %=11?&( Wen nbbnow cb j}wfsw wnh~}n fs hcw ochsfswnhw

jo}css wensn `cgnds9 qcssfmdv mnoj~sn |n swj}w w}joifhl wnh~}n b}c` :67>( Hcwn wejw q}fc}

}nsnj}oe ejs jdsc bc~hg ~hswjmdn nbbnows %[~oin}`jh nw jd( %=11?& bfhg qcsfwfrn nbbnows cb rnwn}jh

swjw~s m~w Mfndmv jhg Mfndmv %:666& bfhg hnljwfrn nbbnows cb wnh~}n jhg j}l~n wejw }nq~wjwfchs fh

wen nhwn}wjfh`nhw fhg~sw}v bjgn z~foidv sc nuqn}fnhon fs j gfsjgrjhwjln wc s~swjfhfhl j oj}nn}&( Fh

@cgnd 6 }nqc}wng djwn} |n jhjdv{n j }ng~ong gjwjsnw cb j}wfsws bc} |efoe |n ihc| oj}nn} efswc}fns

jhg bfhg wejw wen dchln} j}wfsws fhg~sw}v wnh~}n$ wen dc|n} wen cggs cb |c}ifhl fh wen hnuw vnj}(

%Wen nbbnows cb wen swfl`j mv jsscofjwfch$ ec|nrn}$ j}n swjmdn jo}css wen rj}fc~s sqnofbfojwfchs(&

J}wfsws wejw ejrn mnnh ~hn`qdcvng bc} dchl qn}fcgs c} ejrn |c}ing fh chdv chn bfd` ejrn dc|n}

cggs cb n`qdcv`nhw$ jhg wecsn jsscofjwng |fwe sw~gfcs ejrn eflen} cggs cb n`qdcv`nhw( Wen

h~`mn} cb bfd`s q}cg~ong$ wen h~`mn} cb q}cg~on} c}ljhf{jwfchs$ jhg jwwnhgjhon fh wenjwn}s

mccsw wen oejhons cb n`qdcv`nhw( Ch jrn}jln$ |}fwn}s jhg q}cg~on}s ejrn dc|n} oejhons cb

bfhgfhl n`qdcv`nhw wejh wecsn |ec qn}bc}` `~dwfqdn }cdns$ j bfhgfhl oc`qjwfmdn |fwe q}nrfc~s

sw~gfns cb }cdn fhwnl}jwfch %Mjin} jhg Bj~dihn}$ :66:&(

YFhsn}w Wjmdn = jmc~w en}nP

Nbbnows cb `n}n jsscofjwfch |fwe swfl`jwf{ng jdwn}s( @cgnd = wnsws evqcwensfs :$ |efoe j}l~ns wejw

|enh jh j}wfsw ejs |c}ing |fwe sc`nchn |ec fs djwn} mdjoidfswng$ wefs `n}n jsscofjwfch |fwe

swfl`j |fdd ej}` wen j}wfsws oejhons cb bfhgfhl |c}i( ]ns~dws s~qqc}w wefs evqcwensfs( @n}n


23/52


24/52


25/52


26/52


27/52


28/52


29/52


30/52


31/52


32/52


33/52


34/52


35/52


36/52


37/52


38/52


39/52


40/52


41/52


42/52


43/52


44/52


45/52


46/52


47/52


48/52


49/52


50/52


51/52


52/52

Stained Red - A Study of Stigma by Association with Blacklisted Artists during the ‘Red Scare’...

Documents

Transcript of Stained Red - A Study of Stigma by Association with Blacklisted Artists during the ‘Red Scare’...