Squeezing the CMB - University of...

31
Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki

Transcript of Squeezing the CMB - University of...

Page 1: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce

Squeezing the CMB

Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki

Page 2: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce

Outline

u  Introduce the CMB u What can we squeeze out of the data u Standard techniques – MCMC u We want cosmological parameters u  Linear data transform u Results and comparison to MCMC

Page 3: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce

The way forward

Usually we go from a sky map

Page 4: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce

The way forward

Express anisotropy as power spectrum

Page 5: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce

Cosmological Parameters

u  Compare data to theory (Bayesian) u  MCMC is the work horse standard u  Set of marginalized estimates

{ }τ,,,,, 22ssbc

LCDM Anhh ΛΩΩ=Θ

Page 6: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce

MCMC

Page 7: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce

Instead… Let us apply a matrix to the data, the Cls. Carry this operation such that locally the Fisher Matrix is unchanged.

arXiv:astro-ph/9603021v2

2^

121

lml al

Cx+

==

x=µ

Page 8: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce

Fisher Matrix

∑ ∑ ∂

∂= −

l YYXX j

YYl

iji

XXlCMB

ijCCovCF

,

1)(θθ

Page 9: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce

Key components:Covariance

Page 10: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce

Key components:Derivatives

Page 11: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce

How well can we recover the Fisher Matrix?

Page 12: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce
Page 13: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce
Page 14: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce
Page 15: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce
Page 16: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce
Page 17: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce

Let’s use these on some data

Page 18: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce

We need some data: Mocks!

( )ibaglm +=21

)(21 idchlm +=)(

21 ibaglm +=

Page 19: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce

How well can we recover a single parameter?

Page 20: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce
Page 21: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce
Page 22: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce
Page 23: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce
Page 24: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce
Page 25: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce

Chalk Talk

Page 26: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce

2D Results

Page 27: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce
Page 28: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce
Page 29: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce

This is the End…for now!

Page 30: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce
Page 31: Squeezing the CMB - University of Chicagobackground.uchicago.edu/~whu/Courses/Ast448_12/zablocki.pdf · Squeezing the CMB Astro448 Final Presentation -Alan Zablocki . Outline ! Introduce