SPE Seminar on ‘Introduction to E&P Projects’, 17 …€¦ · SPE Seminar on ‘Introduction to...
Transcript of SPE Seminar on ‘Introduction to E&P Projects’, 17 …€¦ · SPE Seminar on ‘Introduction to...
T: +44 (0)203 617 7020 E: info@upstream-advis ors.com
W: www.upstream-advisors.com
Upstream Advisors Ltd,
Bowman House, 29 Wilson Street
London, EC2M 2SJ
SPE Seminar on ‘Introduction to E&P Projects’,17 November 2016, London
“Managing E&P Projects”by Prabhat Garga,
Senior Advisor, Upstream Advisors Ltd.
Upstream Advisors – A niche independent consultancy
2
Our Key Business AreasOur Key Business Areas
Asset TransactionAsset Transaction Business ConsultingBusiness Consulting
• Business Process Improvement
• Change Management
• Corporate Strategy
• Business Process Improvement
• Change Management
• Corporate Strategy
Our Key Business AreasOur Key Business Areas
Business ConsultingBusiness ConsultingAsset TransactionAsset Transaction
• Due Diligence
• Asset Valuations
• Sales & Purchase Support
• Due Diligence
• Asset Valuations
• Sales & Purchase Support
Asset DevelopmentAsset Development
• Opportunity Realisation –Workflow to Perform Field Development
• Project Management
• Field Development Planning
• Commercial Services
• Audits & Peer Reviews
• Gas Master Planning
• Opportunity Realisation –Workflow to Perform Field Development
• Project Management
• Field Development Planning
• Commercial Services
• Audits & Peer Reviews
• Gas Master Planning
P.K. Garga - UAL Nov 2016, SPE Seminar
Context & Agenda
- Based mainly around management of large offshore projects(complex, deep water) .
- Introduction to good project management practices (based on learnings of professional PM bodies, APM & PMI)
- Some comparisons with large industrial & infrastructure projects.
- Key reasons for project under-performance
‘Managing E&P Projects’
3
P.K. Garga - UAL Nov 2016, SPE Seminar
Typical fixed platform based offshore development( ‘dry trees’, weather independent production)
4
gas
oil
pipelines to shore
P.K. Garga - UAL Nov 2016, SPE Seminar
Onshore Terminal
drilling & production facilities
Support platformfixed to sea-bed
Typical FPSO Development( ‘wet trees’ , weather dependent production )
FPSO
Shuttle
TankerRisers
Flowlines
Subsea Wells &
Manifold
P.K. Garga - UAL
5
Nov 2016, SPE Seminar
Project Management of Complex Projects
Characteristics of complex offshore oil & gas proj ects
� tight timescales with heavy overlap of work activities� high continuous and total expenditure� extended, possibly global supply chains� construction in disparate locations� very early procurement of key materials and services (installation vessels) to secure schedule� significant risks and uncertainties
• The cost of doing work offshore is so high that a large part ( and in huge physical
chunks) is done onshore and shipped to its offshore location to be installed by
complex and large installation vessels. These vessels, of limited supply ad huge
cost, have to be signed up almost at the beginning of the project, well before
design is complete.
6
P.K. Garga - UAL
6
Nov 2016, SPE Seminar
Professional project management bodies
• US – Project Management Institute, PMI
• UK – Association for Project Management, APM
• European – International Project Management Association, IPMA
� Best practices embodied in their ‘Bodies of Knowledge’ (BoK’s) and competency framework
7
P.K. Garga - UAL Nov 2016, SPE Seminar
Project management
“Project management is the process by which projects are defined planned, monitored, controlled and delivered such that the agreed benefits are realised ……. Projects bring about change and project management is recognised as the most efficient way of managing such change.”
- APM BoK ©
“Project management is the application of knowledge, skills, tools and techniques to project activities to meet project requirements. Project management is accomplished through the application and integration of project management processes of initiating, planning, executing, monitoring & controlling and closing.”
- PM BoK ©
P.K. Garga - UAL
8
Nov 2016, SPE Seminar
Projects – Cost, Time, Quality constraints
87
Cost Time
Quality
Safety, Health & Environment
P.K. Garga - UAL
9
Nov 2016, SPE Seminar
Project Life Cycle
Project Types
Studies, Investigations
FEED,Detailed designPrototype dev.
EngineeringEng & ProcurementConstructionEng, Procure & Construct (EPC)EPC Management (EPCM)
Asset Support& Upgrade Projects
HUC
Gates
Sanction Operate(Engineer, Procure, Construct,
Hook-up & Commission)
Select DefineAppraiseE P
Execute
COperate
HUC
Execute
CPE
P.K. Garga - UAL
10
Nov 2016, SPE Seminar
Influence on value – client perspective
11
Value(Profit, NPV,
IRR, etc.)
Contribution to Value (35-40%)
Contribution to Value (40-45%)
Time
Select Define
© Adept Knowledge Management
ExecuteSelect
P.K. Garga - UAL
11
Nov 2016, SPE Seminar
E&P Projects
Infra-structure Projects
Project life-cycle in E&P and Infra-structure projects
Appraise SelectExplore OperateDefine Execute
- High expenditure, short duration, high returns
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
- Moderate expenditure, long duration (often in stages), low returns
Appraise SelectMaster
Planning
Operate
( & Expand)Define Execute
P.K. Garga - UAL
12
Nov 2016, SPE Seminar
Core Project Management Processes
“Project management is accomplished through the application and integration of project management process of initiating, planning, executing, monitoring & controlling and closing.” - PMBOK ©
13
project inputs
project deliverables
executingthe plan
monitoring and controlling
closing the project
planning the project
initiating the project
project boundaries
P.K. Garga - UAL
13
Nov 2016, SPE Seminar
• Initiation
• Planning (schedule & cost)
• Execution
• Monitoring & Control
• Closing
• Stakeholder management
• Scope management
• Change management
• Supply change management
• Quality management
• HSE management
• Information management
• Risk management
& others
Core project management processes
14
P.K. Garga - UAL Nov 2016, SPE Seminar
Starting the project
Internal FactorsProcessesToolsResourcesHSEGovernanceFinance
External FactorsLawsRegulationsStandardsSocio-politicalMarket Issues
SanctionProjectInitiatorClient
TechnicalRequirements
FunctionalRequirements
Objectives
Define Scope&
ExecutionMethodology
i.e. PEP
Execute
Supply Contract
P.K. Garga - UAL
15
Nov 2016, SPE Seminar
Planning: Documents & Sequence
Network
S-Curve
Gantt chartWBS
Histogram
16
P.K. Garga - UAL Nov 2016, SPE Seminar
Why monitor and control?
• To know where you are against the plan at any given point in time,
- what have you achieved?
- how much you spent (or resources used) in getting there?
- how efficient and effective were you at getting there?
- what remains to be done?
• To be able to forecast what the completion duration and final cost might be
• To assist you in focusing on the key future management actions you need to take to redress any shortfalls or slippage
• To provide feedback to all your stakeholders (communications management)
P.K. Garga - UAL
17
Nov 2016, SPE Seminar
Stakeholder management
Stakeholders – anyone with an interest in the project
• Identify stakeholders
• Prioritise stakeholders
• Communicate to get their opinions
early and to gain their support
• Gain trust and understanding
• Requires continuous dialogue
Keep satisfied; don’t bore
them
High
Pow
er
Fully engage;Communicate
often
Monitor; but do not bore
with excessive
information
Keep informed, talk to them, can often be very helpful
LowLow Interest High
P.K. Garga - UAL
18
Nov 2016, SPE Seminar
Importance of Managing Stakeholders
• By definition there will be stakeholders external to the project delivery team. They will also need to be managed as they can influence the outcome of the project ( positively or negatively).
• The project team is not able to (and sometimes should not) communicate its issues to all stakeholders.
• Discussions on strategic issues can distract the attention of the project delivery team. The latter needs clear and timely decisions to stay in clear delivery mode.
• Some commercial and personnel related sensitive actions can only be taken and managed by a senior company person (sponsor).
‘Successful project management means successful pol itical management also’
P.K. Garga - UAL
19
Nov 2016, SPE Seminar
What is risk and risk management
Risk is :
• “An uncertain event, feature, activity, or situation that
can have a positive or a negative effect on objectives”
• Risk = opportunities + threats
Risk management is :
• “A formal process that enables identification, assessment, planning and management of risks”
• A formal approach is better than just an intuitive approach
P.K. Garga - UAL
20
Nov 2016, SPE Seminar
Quantifying risks
• Impact (I) is the magnitude of the consequence
• Probability (P) is the likelihood (chance) of occurrence
• Expected Value = I mpact (I) x Probability (P)
• Qualitative techniques use a rating system of adjectives or ranges to describe I&P (e.g. high, medium, low or 1 – 5 scale)
• Quantitative techniques use Expected Values to describe probable monetary value
- both allow individual risks to be graded to target management action
P.K. Garga - UAL
21
Nov 2016, SPE Seminar
Risks are mitigated or realised by taking action(effort, resources), not by ambitious words alone!
Managing change
• Change happens for many reasons and in many forms
• external – client, stakeholders, new regulations, changing environment, market changes, innovation
• internal – project team, materialising risks, inefficiencies, surprises (!), scope development, value adding ideas, performance slippage, poor initial scoping
• An organised systematic approach is needed to manage the positive or negative effects of the change on the project baseline objectives of cost, time and quality.
• Un-managed and ‘creeping’ changes usually cause havoc at the latter stages of a project. Often the cause of the major disputes between client and supplier.
• Documenting change is an important aspect of scope and configuration control, as well as being good commercial practice.
P.K. Garga - UAL
22
Nov 2016, SPE Seminar
APM - PM competence framework
Contextual(self and business
environment)e.g. GovernanceHSSECultural AwarenessCorporate StrategyBusiness Case
Technical(self knowledge & skills)e.g. Initiation
Stakeholder MangScope MangPlanningMonitoringChange MangRisk MangClose-out
Behavioural(self and others & work)e.g. Leadership
CreativityAdaptabilityJudgementCommunicationMotivationOrganising
‘Each competence element judged for knowledge and experience’
P.K. Garga - UAL
23
Nov 2016, SPE Seminar
Capex phase
E&P Projects, Under-performance Issues
24
Cost & Duration Actual
Planned
time
Production
time
Planned
Actual
Opex Phase
• cost & schedule over-runs• delayed production (& income)• dissatisfied stakeholders
P.K. Garga - UAL Nov 2016, SPE Seminar
� Incorrectly chosen
� Poor initial definition before sanction
� Poor project start-up
� Poor supply chainmanagement
� Late realisation ofimpending problems
+ many more!
(whim, speculative, ‘strategic’ (so-called!), poor governance)
Key Causes of Project Failure
2525
P.K. Garga - UAL Nov 2016, SPE Seminar
(rush to procure and build, inadequate planning, poor or non-existent control processes)
(un-manageable risks placed on suppliers, insufficient assessment of supplier capabilities, incorrect contracts formats for delivery)
(poor risk management, over-reliance on heroic recovery actions over sound pro-active management)
(rushed, heroic timescales and budgets, supressed risks, reliant on exceptional execution and delivery)