Southeast and Mid-Atlantic Challenges to Wind Development The Southeast & Mid-Atlantic Regional Wind...

21
Southeast and Mid-Atlantic Challenges to Wind Development The Southeast & Mid-Atlantic Regional Wind Summit, Raleigh, NC September 19, 2005 © 2005 Community Energy, Inc.

Transcript of Southeast and Mid-Atlantic Challenges to Wind Development The Southeast & Mid-Atlantic Regional Wind...

Page 1: Southeast and Mid-Atlantic Challenges to Wind Development The Southeast & Mid-Atlantic Regional Wind Summit, Raleigh, NC September 19, 2005 © 2005 Community.

Southeast and Mid-Atlantic Challenges to Wind Development

The Southeast & Mid-Atlantic Regional Wind Summit, Raleigh, NC

September 19, 2005

© 2005 Community Energy, Inc.

Page 2: Southeast and Mid-Atlantic Challenges to Wind Development The Southeast & Mid-Atlantic Regional Wind Summit, Raleigh, NC September 19, 2005 © 2005 Community.

Summary

• Community Energy, Inc. (CEI) Background

• The Economics of Wind

• The Wind Market

• Our 2005 Projects and Development Challenges

© 2003 Community Energy, Inc.© 2005 Community Energy, Inc.

Page 3: Southeast and Mid-Atlantic Challenges to Wind Development The Southeast & Mid-Atlantic Regional Wind Summit, Raleigh, NC September 19, 2005 © 2005 Community.

• Founded in 1999, with headquarters in Wayne, PA and offices in NYC, Binghamton, Chicago, Connecticut, New Jersey and Colorado

• 37 employees

• Marketing/Sales Division- Over 2 Billion kWh of wind under

contract (supporting 200 MW of wind)

- 100% Growth Rate over past 3 years

- 20-year PPAs with Exelon

CEI Overview

• Supply Development Division- Long-term PPAs with PPL, ComEd, & ACUA- 350,000 MWh under contract - Over 200 MW of new CEI developments (PA, NJ, MA, IL) under long-term PPA’s

© 2005 Community Energy, Inc.

Page 4: Southeast and Mid-Atlantic Challenges to Wind Development The Southeast & Mid-Atlantic Regional Wind Summit, Raleigh, NC September 19, 2005 © 2005 Community.

Business Model

Marketer DeveloperSupplier

• 20 utility partners• 40,000 residential & business customers• Pioneered sales to C&I customers• EPA Green Power Leadership Award Winner 2001-2004

• 350,000 MWh under contract• RPS Portfolio Management• RECs

Wind Solar Landfill Gas/

biomass Small hydro

• > 1500 MW wind farms under development• Developing the only 2 wind projects in Mid-Atlantic this year• Land under lease in more than 12 states © 2005 Community Energy, Inc.

Page 5: Southeast and Mid-Atlantic Challenges to Wind Development The Southeast & Mid-Atlantic Regional Wind Summit, Raleigh, NC September 19, 2005 © 2005 Community.

The Vision A world powered by clean, responsibly

developed renewable energy

The Model Linking customer

purchases with the development of new

regional wind supply to flip economics in positive

direction© 2005 Community Energy, Inc.

Page 6: Southeast and Mid-Atlantic Challenges to Wind Development The Southeast & Mid-Atlantic Regional Wind Summit, Raleigh, NC September 19, 2005 © 2005 Community.

Value of Wind Energy (in PJM): + $40-45/MWh

Cost of Wind Energy (in PJM): - $55-60/MWh

NET ECONOMIC IMPACT - $10-20/MWh Green Market Premium + $15-25/MWh

REVISED ECONOMIC IMPACT - $5 to +$15/MWh

The Economics of Wind

© 2005 Community Energy, Inc.

Page 7: Southeast and Mid-Atlantic Challenges to Wind Development The Southeast & Mid-Atlantic Regional Wind Summit, Raleigh, NC September 19, 2005 © 2005 Community.

Large Wind Buyers

© 2005 Community Energy, Inc.

Page 8: Southeast and Mid-Atlantic Challenges to Wind Development The Southeast & Mid-Atlantic Regional Wind Summit, Raleigh, NC September 19, 2005 © 2005 Community.

© 2005 Community Energy, Inc.

Page 9: Southeast and Mid-Atlantic Challenges to Wind Development The Southeast & Mid-Atlantic Regional Wind Summit, Raleigh, NC September 19, 2005 © 2005 Community.

The Wind Farms

242 MW Wethersfield, NY 6.6MW on-line 2000

Somerset, PA 15MW on-line 2001

Mill Run, PA 9MW on-line 2001

Fenner, NY 30MW on-line 2001

Mountaineer, WV 66MW on-line 2002

Waymart, PA 64.5MW on-line 2003

Crescent Ridge, IL 51MW on-line 2005

Under development:

Atlantic City, NJ 7.5MW Fall 2005

Bear Creek, PA 24MW Fall 2005

Princeton, MA 3MW 2006

Lempster, NH 24MW 2006

Jordanville, NY 150MW 2007

Wind Supply

© 2005 Community Energy, Inc.

Page 10: Southeast and Mid-Atlantic Challenges to Wind Development The Southeast & Mid-Atlantic Regional Wind Summit, Raleigh, NC September 19, 2005 © 2005 Community.

Deal Structure

Wind FarmWholesaler

(e.g., Exelon PPL, Enel, CEI,

etc.)

ISO (PJM)Bankable PPA

Wind kWh (with RECs) Wholesale Energy

Locational Marginal Price

RECs Premiums

REC Customers

© 2005 Community Energy, Inc.

Page 11: Southeast and Mid-Atlantic Challenges to Wind Development The Southeast & Mid-Atlantic Regional Wind Summit, Raleigh, NC September 19, 2005 © 2005 Community.

A Key Piece of the Puzzle: Long-Term Creditworthy REC Purchases

The University of Pennsylvania

- Original 5 year, 20,000 MWh/yr. purchase in 2001 supported new PA projects - Last year doubled to 10-year, 40,000 MWh/Yr. purchase - Term & credit behind commitment will directly support PA project in 2005

© 2005 Community Energy, Inc.

Page 12: Southeast and Mid-Atlantic Challenges to Wind Development The Southeast & Mid-Atlantic Regional Wind Summit, Raleigh, NC September 19, 2005 © 2005 Community.

CEI 2005 Projects

7.5-MW Jersey-Atlantic Project Atlantic City, NJOn-Line Late 2005

24-MW Bear Creek Project

Bear Creek, PAOn-Line Late 2005

© 2005 Community Energy, Inc.

Page 13: Southeast and Mid-Atlantic Challenges to Wind Development The Southeast & Mid-Atlantic Regional Wind Summit, Raleigh, NC September 19, 2005 © 2005 Community.

- Clean energy showcase visible to 30 million people per year

- Leadership by the Atlantic County Utility Authority

- 5 GE Turbines, 7.5 MW capacity, 15,000 - 20,000 MWh/Yr.

- Partially behind the meter (BTM) to ACUA, balance is merchant power delivered to PJM

- NJ BPU providing grant support to offset costs

Atlantic City Wind Farm

© 2005 Community Energy, Inc.

Page 14: Southeast and Mid-Atlantic Challenges to Wind Development The Southeast & Mid-Atlantic Regional Wind Summit, Raleigh, NC September 19, 2005 © 2005 Community.

• Visible from the Pennsylvania turnpike

• 12 Gamesa Turbines, 24 MW capacity, ~70,000 MWh/Yr.

• 20-year Power Purchase Agreement with PPL

• Central Hudson Group and Babcock and Brown

Bear Creek Wind Farm

© 2005 Community Energy, Inc.

Page 15: Southeast and Mid-Atlantic Challenges to Wind Development The Southeast & Mid-Atlantic Regional Wind Summit, Raleigh, NC September 19, 2005 © 2005 Community.

Development Aspects• Road design• FAA Permits• Foundation design• Avian studies• Other general topics

© 2005 Community Energy, Inc.

Page 16: Southeast and Mid-Atlantic Challenges to Wind Development The Southeast & Mid-Atlantic Regional Wind Summit, Raleigh, NC September 19, 2005 © 2005 Community.

Road Design – Bear Creek

• Heavy loads during brief construction period

• Pickup truck usage 20 years post-construction

• Erosion and sediment control• Discharges to streams

© 2005 Community Energy, Inc.

Page 17: Southeast and Mid-Atlantic Challenges to Wind Development The Southeast & Mid-Atlantic Regional Wind Summit, Raleigh, NC September 19, 2005 © 2005 Community.

FAA Permits – Bear Creek• Micrositing is a necessary component of

every wind project • Every adjustment establishes a new

“obstruction record”• Process streamlining is underway at FAA• CEI received excellent support from FAA

to resolve possible last minute conflicts

© 2005 Community Energy, Inc.

Page 18: Southeast and Mid-Atlantic Challenges to Wind Development The Southeast & Mid-Atlantic Regional Wind Summit, Raleigh, NC September 19, 2005 © 2005 Community.

Foundation Design - ACUA

• Design for hurricanes need to be considered– Foundation effect– Turbine effect

© 2005 Community Energy, Inc.

Page 19: Southeast and Mid-Atlantic Challenges to Wind Development The Southeast & Mid-Atlantic Regional Wind Summit, Raleigh, NC September 19, 2005 © 2005 Community.

Avian – Bear Creek and ACUA

• Misconceptions• Pre-construction studies done at both

sites• NJ Audubon/CEI cooperating on advanced

post-construction avian studies• PA Game Commission/CEI performing

post-construction avian and bat studies

© 2005 Community Energy, Inc.

Page 20: Southeast and Mid-Atlantic Challenges to Wind Development The Southeast & Mid-Atlantic Regional Wind Summit, Raleigh, NC September 19, 2005 © 2005 Community.

General Challenges

• Turbine size increase = transport vehicle size increase

• Land use compatibility– ACUA – co-located with County Sewage

Treatment Plant – existing brownfield site designed for utility use

• Role of community leaders

© 2005 Community Energy, Inc.

Page 21: Southeast and Mid-Atlantic Challenges to Wind Development The Southeast & Mid-Atlantic Regional Wind Summit, Raleigh, NC September 19, 2005 © 2005 Community.

Contact Information :

Matt HeckCommunity Energy, Inc.150 Strafford Avenue, Suite 210Wayne, PA [email protected]

www.CommunityEnergy.biz

© 2005 Community Energy, Inc.