Solar Cells Lecture 5: Organic Photovoltaics
-
Upload
devi-renewable-energies -
Category
Technology
-
view
2.415 -
download
2
description
Transcript of Solar Cells Lecture 5: Organic Photovoltaics
1
Lecture 5Physics of Organic Solar Cells
M. A. Alam and B. Ray
[email protected] and Computer Engineering
Purdue UniversityWest Lafayette, IN USA
NCN Summer School: July 2011Notes on the Fundamental of Solar Cell
2
copyright 2011
This material is copyrighted by M. Alam under the following Creative Commons license:
Conditions for using these materials is described at
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/2.5/
Alam 2011
33
Outline
1) Introduction: Rationale of organic solar cells
2) Planar Heterojunction OPV
3) Checkerbox Heterjunction OPV
4) Bulk Heterojunction devices
5) Percolation, fluctuation, and efficiency limits
6) Conclusions
Alam 2011
Different types of solar cells
4
Crystalline Silicon Flexible organicAmorphous silicon
*Google Images
p-n p-i-n m-i-m
Alam 2011
Economics of solar cells
5
C-Si CdTe a-Si CIGS OPV
Material/m2 207 50-60 64 100-125 37
Process/m2 123 86 73 130 23-37
Total/m2 350 130 138 230 50-80
Cost/W 1.75 0.94 -1.2 0.9-1.4 1.63 1-1.36
• All costs are approximate• J. Kalowekamo/E. Baker, Solar Energy, 2009.• Goodrich, PVSC Tutorial, 2011.
If efficiency exceeds 15% and lifetime 15 years, $/W ~0.36
Alam 2011
66
Outline
1) Introduction: Rationale of organic solar cells
2) Planar Heterojunction OPV
3) Checkerbox Heterjunction OPV
4) Bulk Heterojunction devices
5) Percolation, fluctuation, and efficiency limits
6) Conclusions
Alam 2011
Basics: Excitons, electrons, and holes
7
4
2 2 2 2 20
mqE = eV
32 01
1 113.6 mmπ ε κ κ
= ×
m= 0.1m , =10
E ~13.6 meV0
1 ~ 53Si SiBr A
κ
m= 0.1m = 3
E ~151 meV0
1 ~ 15poly polyBr A
κ Charge neutral excitons happily diffusing around …
H atomBr
20
B 2
4πr =
mq00.53
mA
mε
κ κ ×
=
Alam 2011
Basics: Excitons, electrons, and holes
8
E ~151 meV1 ~ 15poly polyBr A
Heterojunctions takes the exciton apart, Build-in field sweeps electrons/holes away
Aχ Bχ
MχMχ Mχ
Mχ
Band-diagram
DonorAcceptor
Bilayer Plastic Solar Cells
Side view
Exciton recombination before dissociation at the junction makes it a poor cell …
9Alam 2011
Photocurrent in bilayer cells
10
~ τex exD
/4, 1 e exWL exexex
ex ex ex
JJqG qG
D τ
− = = −
≡
, (0)L n n rec nE Sγ µ γ δ τ= = ≡
(0)(0)
ph n
ex n
J EJ E S
µµ
=+
0
nex
n
SJ
E Sµ
µ +exJ
,,
, , , ,
ph L pL n
ex L n R n rec L p R p rec
J
J
γγγ γ γ γ γ γ
= −
+ + + +
(0) bi
n
V VE
W−
===
≫≪
24 2
ex ex ex
ex ex
J qG WJ qG W W
Photocurrent in bilayer cells
11
,,
, , , ,
ph L pL n
ex L n R n rec L p R p rec
J
J
γγγ γ γ γ γ γ
= −
+ + + +
2 2(0) (0) (0) (0)ex n TJ n S E n n nγ µ γ υ = + + ≡ +
Interface recombination a key challenge
2 4
2T T ex
ph T
JJ
υ υ γυ
γ
− + + =
Defective interface
Alam 2011
Dark current in bilayer organic PV
12
// 2,0
( )/ 2,0
(0) (0)p Bn B
bi B
d
qEW K TqEW K TL R i
q V V K TL R i
J n p
n e p e n
n p e n
γ
γ
γ
−−
− −
≈
≈ × − = −
0 0.5 1
10-10
100
Voltage (V)
J (m
Acm
-2)
Exact
Approx.
Defective interface
Alam 2011
Summary: Total current in bilayer organic PV
13
( )/ 2,0
bi Bq V V K Td L R iJ n p e nγ − − = −
2 4
2T T ex
ph T
JJ
υ υ γυ
γ
− + + =
/21 e exWexex
JqG
− = −
T ph dJ J J= + -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6-10
-8
-6
-4
-2
0
Voltage (V)
J (m
Acm
-2)
μ =10-4 cm2/V.s
JT,approxJT,anall
JT,num
Jd
Anomalously low fill factor!
Current collection and charge pileup
14
V=0.0V=0.6
0
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9x 10
V=0.6
V=0.2
V=0.4E-
field
En
ergy
Position
(0)(0)
ph n
ex n
J EJ E S
µµ
=+
(0) bi
n
V VE
W−
<
The electrons stay too long close to a dangerous region …
-0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6-10
-8
-6
-4
-2
0
Voltage (V)
J (m
Acm
-2) JT,num
Jd
JT,anall
-0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6-10
-8
-6
-4
-2
0
Voltage (V)
J (m
Acm
-2)
Better mobility improves Fill factor
15
-0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6-10
-8
-6
-4
-2
0
Voltage (V)
J (m
Acm
-2)
μ =1e-4 μ =1e-3
JT,num
JT,anall
JT,num
JT,anall
Higher mobility improves Fill factorNonlinear series resistance ….
Alam 2011
The problem with planar heterojunction …
Making such thin film is essentially difficult, the layers will short out …
:ex ex exL D τ
:ex ex exL D τ
16
1717
Outline
1) Introduction: Rationale of organic solar cells
2) Planar Heterojunction OPV
3) Checkerbox Heterjunction OPV
4) Bulk Heterojunction devices
5) Percolation, fluctuation, and efficiency limits
6) Conclusions
Alam 2011
Checkerboard organic solar cellsDecoupling exciton and electron-hole paths
18
/2, 2 1 e s exWL exexex
JJN
qG qG− = = × −
:ex ex exL D τ
McGehee, MRS Bulletin, Feb. 2009A. Javey, Nature Materials, July 2009
the balancing act …
2 2F FN ~1 2S V = WS
Finger density …
2ex ex
ex ex
F(S) ~ 4S × D 2S
= 2 D S
τ
τ
Fraction of the charge collected/finger …
ex F F
ex ex
J = qG ×V ×F(S)×N
~ qG ×W D Sτ
Total charge collected …
S
Two blocks
19
W
Alam 2011
20
Photo and dark currents (like a p-i-n diode)
20
,,
0, , , ,( )
Wph L pL n
ex L n R n L p R p
Jdx
J R V
γγγ γ γ γ
= −
− + + ∫
0Lγ υ=
( )/0
E W xR e θγ υ − −=
2 2log cosh coth
2 2D D
D D
L LW WW W
W L W L
= × ≅ −
Sokel and Hughes, JAP, 53(11), 1982.
S
W
W
( )/
( ) /1
1B
bi B
qV nk Tn bid q V V k T
V V dJ A e
e
µ+ −
− = − +
Photocurrent with distributed recombination
Dark current with distributed recombination
Alam 2011
meso-structured organic solar cells
Mixed Layersbilayer
21
checkerboard
/2, 2 1 e
2
2
s exWL exexex
s
s
JJN
qG qGAW NW WN A W
− = = −
==
2222
Outline
1) Introduction: Rationale of organic solar cells
2) Planar Heterojunction OPV
3) Checkerbox Heterjunction OPV
4) Bulk Heterojunction OPV
5) Percolation, fluctuation, and efficiency limits
6) Conclusions
Alam 2011
Processing of a plastic bulk heterojunction cell
23
Polymer-A(Donor)
SolventPolymer-B(Acceptor)
X (nm)
Y (
nm
)
0 50 100
100
50
0
X (nm)
Y (
nm
)
0 50 100
100
50
0
X (nm)
Y (
nm
)
0 50 100
100
50
0
X (nm)
Y (
nm
)
0 50 100
100
50
0
X (nm)
Y (
nm
)
0 50 100
100
50
0
X (nm)
Y (
nm
)
0 50 100
100
50
0
X (nm)
Y (
nm
)
0 50 100
100
50
0
X (nm)
Y (
nm
)
0 50 100
100
50
0
Phase Separation occurs through Spinodal Decomposition
Anneal for a certain duration at moderate temperature
Cahn-Hilliard Eq:
2 40 2ϕ κ ϕ
ϕ ∂ ∂
= ∇ − ∇ ∂ ∂
fM
t
Nature Materials, 2009
Process model for phase segregation
24
Free energy:
Cahn-Hilliard Eq:
Surface tension
Energy ofmixing
free energy contains polymer details
EntropyEnthalpy
2 40 2ϕ κ ϕ
ϕ ∂ ∂
= ∇ − ∇ ∂ ∂
fM
t
= −mixf U TS
0 0.5 1
-0.5
0
0.5
ØA ØB
Ø0
Volume fraction, Ø (x,y)
Free
ene
rgy,
f(a.u
)
Ray et al., Solar Energy Mat and Solar Cells, 2011
Demixing and self-organization in thin films
Anneal time (sec)
Gra
in-s
ize
W(t
)
( )1 3at
/~
Anneal time
25
1/3atW(t)~
Alam 2011
Response of BHJ cells to light pulses
Electron
Holes
26
Movie: How excitons are taken apart by the heterojunction
Alam 2011
Photocurrent in BHJ OPV
W(tArea
L(t)× =)2
Anneal time
27
W(ta)L(ta)
1/3a
AreaL(
2 tt)~
×
1/3atW(t)~
Alam 2011
ex ex aQ = q D ×L(t )τEx
cito
nflu
x (a
.u)
Anneal time (a.u.)
28
W(ta)
L(ta)
Form defines function ….Should we anneal at all ?
1/3a
AreaL(
2 tt)~
×
exex
e/
ex1
x3
a
DQ 1=
tJ :
τ τ
Photocurrent and exciton flux
Photocurrent and annealing timeEx
cito
nFl
ux
Anneal time (a.u.)
1/R
29101 102
2
4
6
8
10
Anneal Time (min)
J SC(m
A/c
m2 )
ta(opt)
Ray et al., Solar Energy Mat and Solar Cells, 2011
How do they compare ?
30
0 0.2 0.4 0.6
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
Voltage (V)
Curr
ent (
mA
/cm
2 )
Bi-layerη= 3.56 %Jsc = 6.6 mAcm-2
Voc = 0.66VFF = 81.5 %
Typical BHJη= 5.5 %Jsc = 14.6 mAcm-2
Voc = 0.63VFF = 59.5 %
Ordered BHJη= 6.1 %Jsc = 15.2 mAcm-2
Voc = 0.66VFF = 63.3 %
Bi-layer Typical BHJ
Ordered BHJ
Bilayer Ordered BHJ
Typical BHJ
Ray et al., PVSC, 2011
Low currentPoor fill factor
Alam 2011
3131
Outline
1) Introduction: Rationale of organic solar cells
2) Planar Heterojunction OPV
3) Checkerbox Heterjunction OPV
4) Bulk Heterojunction devices
5) Percolation, fluctuation, and efficiency limits
6) Conclusions
Alam 2011
The challenge of a 15% cell …
32
New polymers with smaller bandgap
Change solvent and mixing ratio
Optimize anneal time Regularize morphology
Percolation dictates ~1:1 volume ratio
Solubility issues
Very limited play Random close to optimal
Conflicting system requires constraints the design, Need to consider all improvement within this context
0.2 0.4 0.6 0.80
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
Fraction of P3HT
Con
nect
ed V
olum
e 100 nm200 nm
Mixing ratio and percolation
100 102 1040
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
Anneal Time (s)C
onne
cted
Vol
ume
Fluctuation and Mixing Ratio
1:11:2
1:3
Moving away from 1:1 ratio is challenging ….
Ordered vs. Disordered Morphology
34
5 10 15 20 25
0.58
0.6
0.62
0.64
0.66
0.68
0.7
<WD>
FF
5 10 15 20 250.6
0.61
0.62
0.63
0.64
0.65
0.66
<WD>
V OC (V
)
5 10 15 20 253
3.5
4
4.5
5
5.5
6
6.5
<WD>
Effic
ienc
y (%
)
5 10 15 20 2560
80
100
120
140
160
180
<WD>
J SC (m
A/cm
2 )
Regular BHJ
Random BHJ
Regular BHJ
Random BHJ
Regular BHJ
Random BHJ
Regular BHJ
Random BHJ
Reduced variability, optimal for a range of anneal conditions
Ray et al., PVSC, 2011
35
Fundamental constraint of reliability
(i) ta = 0 s (ii) ta = 102s (iii) ta = 103s
(i) ts = 104 s (ii) ts = 105s (iii) ts = 106s
(i) ts = 104 s (ii) ts = 105s (iii) ts = 106s
(i) ts = 104 s (ii) ts = 105s (iii) ts = 106s
(a) Ta =1200C(ProcessingTemperature)
Stre
ss T
empe
ratu
re ,T
S
(d)
T S=
120
0 C
(
c) T
S=
100
0 C
(b
) T S
= 80
0 C
102 104 106
10
20
50
WC~ tSn
Stress Time (s)Cl
uste
r Siz
e, W
C(n
m) TS= 800, 1000, 1200 C
Continued coarseningwith anneal time
n
C a a eff a aW (t ,T ) D (T )t ∝ A a-E / kT
eff a 0D (T )= D e
The difference between Arizona sun and an oven is negligible
Derivation of the reliability formula
36
exSC
C
LJ
W (t)∝
A S
SC 0 s C 0
SC 0 C 0 s
n
eff 0 0
n
eff 0 0 eff s s
-n
-E / kT s
eq
J (t + t ) W (t )=
J (t ) W (t + t )
D (T )t=
D (T )t + D (T )t
t= 1+ e
t
ts = 10 hrs
Operating T (0C)Li
fetim
e (d
ays)
20 30 400
100
200
300
400
500JSC (deg) = 10, 20, 30%
Ea = 1.2 eVn = .25
100 hrs
103 104 105 106
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
Ts= 800, 1000, 1200 C
Anneal Time (s)
J SC
(nor
m)
102 104 106
10
20
50
WC~ tan
Anneal Time (s)
Clus
ter S
ize,
WC
(nm
) Ts= 800, 1000, 1200 C
Ray et al., APL, 2011 Lifetime less than a year!
ordered vs. spinodal films
Bulk Heterojunction Checkerboard Double Gyroid
Good … Best …
37
better …
Alam 2011
3838
Conclusions
Organic solar cells promises a low cost PV technology, lightweight, easy to install. Also, a beautiful physics problem with biomimetic transport.
Theory explains optimum of anneal time, the rationale of 1:1 mixing ratio, the fundamental constraints of reliability, limits of Voc and FF.
Reliability, variability, and efficiency are important concerns. Self assembled regularized structure, new class of optics, lower bandgap materials, may help us reach 15% efficiency targets.
Alam 2011