Social/Cultural Anthropology: Icanchu's Drum: An Orientation to Meaning in South American Religions....

1
SOCIA LICULTURA L ANTHROPOLOGY 1073 the urban ghettos of Latin America. The ra- cial and cultural alloying has not so far per- mitted social osmosis and improved living conditions for the Indians or for the Blacks of the region. Icanchu’s Drum: An Orientation to Mean- ing in South American Religions. Lawrence E. Sullivan. New York: Macmillan, 1988. 1,014 pp. $35.00 (cloth). JONATHAN HILL Southern Illinois Universio In Icanchu’s Drum, Lawrence Sullivan sets out to explore the religions of indigenous South American peoples as an endlessly crea- tive process of restyling primordial mythic time into symbolically ordered rhythms and configurations of cultural separateness. Using examples drawn from throughout the conti- nent (including some Afro-Brazilian cases), the author follows the dynamic movements between the stable unity of imagined mythic worlds and the changefulness of “a human ex- istence that is mortal, partial, imitative, sym- bolic, cyclic, multigenerational, socially di- vided, linguistically fractured, ritually re- stricted, and historically lived” (p. 101). Rit- ual and ceremonial performances of this “negative dialectic” are not simple reenact- ments of mythically imagined events but con- stitute a process of renewing time by multiply- ing the times ofexistence and assuring that the spaces and times of the mundane world are ex- perienced as a paradox “wherein the end be- comes the beginning and the celebration of the beginning marks an end to what has already unfolded” (p. 171). Icanchu’s Drum calls attention to the great importance of South American narratives about catastrophic floods and conflagrations as sources ofmythic imagery that mediates the creative tension between imagined, nonsym- bolic, primordial worlds and humanly fash- ioned orderings of body, society, and cosmos. Fiery transformations of the cosmos provide images of the coming-into-being of structured human life as an “endless cycle of consump- tion in which all is food” (p. 69). Ritual and ceremonial evocations of the cosmic fire form an ongoing process of constructing human so- cial worlds by regulating the passage of foods and other substances through bodily orifices and across collective boundaries. Cosmic floods, on the other hand, furnish mythic im- ages of the “gaping openness of bodily ori- fices” (p. 64) and an undifferentiated state of being. In collective rituals, flood imagery is transposed into a variety of sense modes to re- generate structured human life by revealing and symbolically containing the undifferen- tiated primordium that surrounds and infuses all cultural separateness. The book’s organization into four parts is designed to reflect indigenous South Ameri- can mythic time as a multilinear unfolding of creation, transformation, and destruction. Part 1, “Archaeology,” states the author’s ap- proach to comparative religious studies and explores various meanings of the mythic pri- mordium. Part 2, “Cosmology,” compares and contrasts the ways in which specific cul- tural orderings of space and time are carved out of the undifferentiated mythic primor- dium. Part 3, “Anthropology,” surveys sym- bolic processes of defining and transforming the meanings of humanness, human growth and creativity, and ritual specialists. Part 4, “Terminology,” focuses on indigenous under- standings of death and on ritual enactments that reaffirm life through symbolic contain- ments of death. A concluding chapter recapi- tulates the main arguments of the book. As the book’s title implies, Sullivan finds that the auditory symbolism ofhuman speech, musical performance, and other sound-pro- ducing events is crucial for understanding South American religions. Sound symbolism serves as the ultimate reality upon which tem- poral orders are founded (p. 223). Sound is the source of shamanistic power (p. 439), and songs are instruments for controlling the sounds ofdeath (p. 483). “Music, rather than language, is the ‘primary modeling system’ or- ganizing human bodies” (p. 282). Language is the basic instrument of socialization; musical sounds regenerate society and the individual by integrating performers into precultural or- ders of mythic creation and destruction. Icanchu’s Drum is a major synthesis of eth- nological knowledge about the religions of in- digenous South American peoples. In addi- tion to its primary focus on myth, ritual, and cosmology, the book touches on the dynamic interrelations between myth and history, the integration of dreams and visions into reli- gious performances, and the fusion of mythic imagination with everyday activities and ma- terial objects. For South Americanists, the book contains an impressive and highly useful bibliography cutting across the usual schol- arly division of labor between highland and lowland specialties. For the broader commu- nity of anthropologists, the book draws to- gether the results of a myriad of ethnographic studies, dispersed in hundreds of publications and written in several languages, into a coher- ent interpretation of basic themes in South American religions.

Transcript of Social/Cultural Anthropology: Icanchu's Drum: An Orientation to Meaning in South American Religions....

Page 1: Social/Cultural Anthropology: Icanchu's Drum: An Orientation to Meaning in South American Religions. Lawrence E. Sullivan

SOCIA LICULTURA L ANTHROPOLOGY 1073

the urban ghettos of Latin America. The ra- cial and cultural alloying has not so far per- mitted social osmosis and improved living conditions for the Indians or for the Blacks of the region.

Icanchu’s Drum: An Orientation to Mean- ing in South American Religions. Lawrence E. Sullivan. New York: Macmillan, 1988. 1,014 pp. $35.00 (cloth).

JONATHAN HILL Southern Illinois Universio

In Icanchu’s Drum, Lawrence Sullivan sets out to explore the religions of indigenous South American peoples as an endlessly crea- tive process of restyling primordial mythic time into symbolically ordered rhythms and configurations of cultural separateness. Using examples drawn from throughout the conti- nent (including some Afro-Brazilian cases), the author follows the dynamic movements between the stable unity of imagined mythic worlds and the changefulness of “a human ex- istence that is mortal, partial, imitative, sym- bolic, cyclic, multigenerational, socially di- vided, linguistically fractured, ritually re- stricted, and historically lived” (p. 101). Rit- ual and ceremonial performances of this “negative dialectic” are not simple reenact- ments of mythically imagined events but con- stitute a process of renewing time by multiply- ing the times ofexistence and assuring that the spaces and times of the mundane world are ex- perienced as a paradox “wherein the end be- comes the beginning and the celebration of the beginning marks an end to what has already unfolded” (p. 171) .

Icanchu’s Drum calls attention to the great importance of South American narratives about catastrophic floods and conflagrations as sources ofmythic imagery that mediates the creative tension between imagined, nonsym- bolic, primordial worlds and humanly fash- ioned orderings of body, society, and cosmos. Fiery transformations of the cosmos provide images of the coming-into-being of structured human life as an “endless cycle of consump- tion in which all is food” (p. 69). Ritual and ceremonial evocations of the cosmic fire form an ongoing process of constructing human so- cial worlds by regulating the passage of foods and other substances through bodily orifices and across collective boundaries. Cosmic floods, on the other hand, furnish mythic im- ages of the “gaping openness of bodily ori- fices” (p. 64) and an undifferentiated state of being. In collective rituals, flood imagery is transposed into a variety of sense modes to re-

generate structured human life by revealing and symbolically containing the undifferen- tiated primordium that surrounds and infuses all cultural separateness.

The book’s organization into four parts is designed to reflect indigenous South Ameri- can mythic time as a multilinear unfolding of creation, transformation, and destruction. Part 1, “Archaeology,” states the author’s ap- proach to comparative religious studies and explores various meanings of the mythic pri- mordium. Part 2, “Cosmology,” compares and contrasts the ways in which specific cul- tural orderings of space and time are carved out of the undifferentiated mythic primor- dium. Part 3, “Anthropology,” surveys sym- bolic processes of defining and transforming the meanings of humanness, human growth and creativity, and ritual specialists. Part 4, “Terminology,” focuses on indigenous under- standings of death and on ritual enactments that reaffirm life through symbolic contain- ments of death. A concluding chapter recapi- tulates the main arguments of the book.

As the book’s title implies, Sullivan finds that the auditory symbolism ofhuman speech, musical performance, and other sound-pro- ducing events is crucial for understanding South American religions. Sound symbolism serves as the ultimate reality upon which tem- poral orders are founded (p. 223). Sound is the source of shamanistic power (p. 439), and songs a re instruments for controlling the sounds ofdeath (p. 483). “Music, rather than language, is the ‘primary modeling system’ or- ganizing human bodies” (p. 282). Language is the basic instrument of socialization; musical sounds regenerate society and the individual by integrating performers into precultural or- ders of mythic creation and destruction.

Icanchu’s Drum is a major synthesis of eth- nological knowledge about the religions of in- digenous South American peoples. In addi- tion to its primary focus on myth, ritual, and cosmology, the book touches on the dynamic interrelations between myth and history, the integration of dreams and visions into reli- gious performances, and the fusion of mythic imagination with everyday activities and ma- terial objects. For South Americanists, the book contains an impressive and highly useful bibliography cutting across the usual schol- arly division of labor between highland and lowland specialties. For the broader commu- nity of anthropologists, the book draws to- gether the results of a myriad of ethnographic studies, dispersed in hundreds of publications and written in several languages, into a coher- ent interpretation of basic themes in South American religions.