SOA Governance Essentials - Total Architecturetotal-architecture.com/indexFiles/Governance/SOA...

25
SOA Governance Essentials Paul C. Brown Principal Software Architect Principal Software Architect © 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Transcript of SOA Governance Essentials - Total Architecturetotal-architecture.com/indexFiles/Governance/SOA...

Page 1: SOA Governance Essentials - Total Architecturetotal-architecture.com/indexFiles/Governance/SOA Governance... · SOA Governance Essentials ... © 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights

SOA Governance Essentials

Paul C. BrownPrincipal Software ArchitectPrincipal Software Architect

© 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Page 2: SOA Governance Essentials - Total Architecturetotal-architecture.com/indexFiles/Governance/SOA Governance... · SOA Governance Essentials ... © 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights

Agenda

SOA Governance Overview

Run-Time Governance

Design-Time Governance

Organizational Issues

Summary

© 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights Reserved.

2

Page 3: SOA Governance Essentials - Total Architecturetotal-architecture.com/indexFiles/Governance/SOA Governance... · SOA Governance Essentials ... © 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights

SOA Governance Overview

SOA = Sharing: the producer is not the consumer

Sharing requires Governance: rule creation andenforcement

R Ti D i TiRun-TimeGovernance

Design-TimeGovernance

ServiceUsage

ServiceOperation

ServiceEmployment

ServiceCreation

© 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights Reserved.

3

Page 4: SOA Governance Essentials - Total Architecturetotal-architecture.com/indexFiles/Governance/SOA Governance... · SOA Governance Essentials ... © 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights

SOA Governance Overview

SOA = Sharing: the producer is not the consumer

Sharing requires Governance: rule creation andenforcement

Run-TimeGovernance

Design-TimeGovernance

ServiceUsage

ServiceOperation

ServiceEmployment

ServiceCreation

Enforced by systems

Enforced by procedures

© 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights Reserved.

4

Organizational Issues

Page 5: SOA Governance Essentials - Total Architecturetotal-architecture.com/indexFiles/Governance/SOA Governance... · SOA Governance Essentials ... © 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights

SOA Governance Overview

SOA = Sharing: the producer is not the consumer

Sharing requires Governance: rule creation andenforcement

R Ti D i TiRun-TimeGovernance

Design-TimeGovernance

ServiceUsage

ServiceOperation

ServiceEmployment

ServiceCreation

Enforced by systems

Enforced by procedures

© 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights Reserved.

5

Organizational Issues

Page 6: SOA Governance Essentials - Total Architecturetotal-architecture.com/indexFiles/Governance/SOA Governance... · SOA Governance Essentials ... © 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights

R TiRun-Time Governance

© 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Page 7: SOA Governance Essentials - Total Architecturetotal-architecture.com/indexFiles/Governance/SOA Governance... · SOA Governance Essentials ... © 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights

Typical Types of Run-Time Rules

Access controlAuthenticationAuthorizationAuthorization

EncryptionDigital signaturesDigital signaturesData filteringLoggingogg gStatistics gathering

Invocation rateResponse times

Th li t i d d!

© 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights Reserved.

7

The list is open-ended!

Page 8: SOA Governance Essentials - Total Architecturetotal-architecture.com/indexFiles/Governance/SOA Governance... · SOA Governance Essentials ... © 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights

It Is Possible to Enforce Policies Within the Service

S iServiceLife-Cycle

ArchitectModify the service architecture to make provision for policyArchitect

Design

to make provision for policy enforcement

Design the manner in Design

Implement/

gwhich the rule will be implemented

Implement/Test Implement and test the

rule

Deploy the revised serviceDeploy Deploy the revised service(may be disruptive!)

© 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights Reserved.

8

Operate Service enforces the rule

Page 9: SOA Governance Essentials - Total Architecturetotal-architecture.com/indexFiles/Governance/SOA Governance... · SOA Governance Essentials ... © 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights

Enforcing Policies Within the Service Is Expensive!

S iServiceLife-Cycle

ArchitectModify the service architecture to makeArchitect

Design

architecture to make provision for policy enforcementDesign the manner inDesign

Implement/

Design the manner in which the rule will be implemented

Implement/Test Implement and test the

rule

Deploy the revisedDeploy Deploy the revised service(may be disruptive!)

© 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights Reserved.

9

Operate Service enforces the rule

Page 10: SOA Governance Essentials - Total Architecturetotal-architecture.com/indexFiles/Governance/SOA Governance... · SOA Governance Essentials ... © 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights

Solution: Separate Policy Enforcement From Service

Service Consumer

PolicyAgent

Service Providerg

Policy f tenforcement

Interface must still be

guarded

© 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights Reserved.

10

Page 11: SOA Governance Essentials - Total Architecturetotal-architecture.com/indexFiles/Governance/SOA Governance... · SOA Governance Essentials ... © 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights

Solution: Separate Policy Enforcement From Service

Single Process Space

Service Consumer

PolicyAgent

Service Provider

Single Process Space

g

Policy f tenforcement

Interface is now fully protected

© 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights Reserved.

11

Page 12: SOA Governance Essentials - Total Architecturetotal-architecture.com/indexFiles/Governance/SOA Governance... · SOA Governance Essentials ... © 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights

Enforcing Policies with a Policy Agent

ServiceLife-Cycle

Architect

PolicyLife-Cycle

Put the infrastructure in Architect

D i

place to use Policy Agents

Select or create theDesign

Implement/

Select or create the template for the type of rule you need

Implement/Test Configure the rule

Associate the rule with theDeploy Associate the rule with the services it governs

P li A t f th

© 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights Reserved.

12

OperatePolicy Agent enforces the rule

Page 13: SOA Governance Essentials - Total Architecturetotal-architecture.com/indexFiles/Governance/SOA Governance... · SOA Governance Essentials ... © 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights

D i TiDesign-Time Governance

© 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Page 14: SOA Governance Essentials - Total Architecturetotal-architecture.com/indexFiles/Governance/SOA Governance... · SOA Governance Essentials ... © 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights

Governance During Service Development

ServiceLife-Cycle

ArchitectArchitect

D i

• Will the service fit multiple usages?• Will the interface remain stable over time?

Design

Implement/Implement/Test• Is the testing adequate?• Is the documentation adequate?

Deploy

© 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights Reserved.

14

Operate• Manage service operation (start/stop)• Manage service versioning

Page 15: SOA Governance Essentials - Total Architecturetotal-architecture.com/indexFiles/Governance/SOA Governance... · SOA Governance Essentials ... © 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights

Governance During Solution Development

ServiceLife-Cycle

Architect

SolutionLife-Cycle

Architect

D i

• Are existing services being used?• Are new services being built appropriately?Design

Implement/

appropriately?

Implement/Test

• Has service capacity planning been done?

Deploy • Have policies been put in place for service access?

© 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights Reserved.

15

Operate• Coordinate with service operation• Track service versioning

Page 16: SOA Governance Essentials - Total Architecturetotal-architecture.com/indexFiles/Governance/SOA Governance... · SOA Governance Essentials ... © 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights

O i ti lOrganizational Issues

© 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Page 17: SOA Governance Essentials - Total Architecturetotal-architecture.com/indexFiles/Governance/SOA Governance... · SOA Governance Essentials ... © 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights

Who Manages Intra-Project Dependencies?

Solution XService A

Your Project•Project Manager•Business Process ArchitectSolution X(new) •Business Process Architect•Systems Architect

© 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights Reserved.

17

Page 18: SOA Governance Essentials - Total Architecturetotal-architecture.com/indexFiles/Governance/SOA Governance... · SOA Governance Essentials ... © 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights

Who Manages Inter-Project Dependencies?

Solution XService A

Your Project•Project Manager•Business Process ArchitectSolution X(new) •Business Process Architect•Systems Architect

Sister Project

Service B( ) Solution Y

•Project Manager•Business Process Architect(new) •Systems Architect

Future Project

Service C(future) Solution Z

•Project Manager•Business Process ArchitectS t A hit t

© 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights Reserved.

18

(future) •Systems Architect

Page 19: SOA Governance Essentials - Total Architecturetotal-architecture.com/indexFiles/Governance/SOA Governance... · SOA Governance Essentials ... © 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights

Enterprise Architecture Scope

E iEnterpriseArchitecture

Business ProcessArchitecture

SystemsArchitecture

DataArchitecture

SolutionArchitecture

InfrastructureArchitecture

ServiceArchitecture

Evaluate service opportunitiesParticipate in service specification

Provide technical coordination between projects

Provide look-ahead technical guidance (future

© 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights Reserved.

19

g (projects)

Page 20: SOA Governance Essentials - Total Architecturetotal-architecture.com/indexFiles/Governance/SOA Governance... · SOA Governance Essentials ... © 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights

Common Architecture Issues

Project levelThere is no architect (i.e. nobody responsible for overall business process and systems architecture)process and systems architecture)The architect has no authority

• The project manager may ignore the advice

Architecture is treated as an after the fact reviewArchitecture is treated as an after-the-fact review• Too late to make substantial changes

Enterprise LevelNo participation in actual projects

• No opportunity to guide them towards common goals• No opportunity to recognize issues in standards and best practices

No authorityNo authority• Projects do as they please

Project participation is at a review level• Too late to make substantial changes

© 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights Reserved.

20

Too late to make substantial changes

Page 21: SOA Governance Essentials - Total Architecturetotal-architecture.com/indexFiles/Governance/SOA Governance... · SOA Governance Essentials ... © 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights

Put All Architecture Under One Roof

Business Executive Sponsor

Total ArchitectureManagement

Sponsor

EnterpriseProjects

EnterpriseArchitecture

Business ProcessArchitecture

SystemsArchitecture

DataArchitecture

ProjectManager

ProjectManager

ProjectManager

Business Business Business Solution

ArchitectureInfrastructureArchitecture

Process Architect

Systems Architect

Process Architect

Systems Architect

Process Architect

Systems Architect

ServiceArchitecture

© 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights Reserved.

21

Page 22: SOA Governance Essentials - Total Architecturetotal-architecture.com/indexFiles/Governance/SOA Governance... · SOA Governance Essentials ... © 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights

Summary

© 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Page 23: SOA Governance Essentials - Total Architecturetotal-architecture.com/indexFiles/Governance/SOA Governance... · SOA Governance Essentials ... © 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights

SOA Governance Overview

SOA Sh iSOA = Sharing: the producer is not the consumer

Sharing requires Governance: rule creation andf tenforcement

Run-TimeGovernance

Design-TimeGovernanceGovernance Governance

Service Service ServiceServiceUsage Operation EmploymentCreation

Enforced by Enforced by systems

yprocedures

Organizational Issues

© 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights Reserved.

23

Page 24: SOA Governance Essentials - Total Architecturetotal-architecture.com/indexFiles/Governance/SOA Governance... · SOA Governance Essentials ... © 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights

SOA Governance Overview

SOA Sh i• Reuse SOA = Sharing: the producer is not the consumer

Sharing requires Governance: rule creation andf t

• Reuse• Isolation

enforcement

Run-TimeGovernance

Design-TimeGovernance

• Checkpoints

Governance Governance

Service Service ServiceServiceUsage Operation EmploymentCreation

Enforced by Enforced bysystems

Enforced by procedures

Organizational Issues• Separate policy from service

• Coordination

© 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights Reserved.

24

from service

Page 25: SOA Governance Essentials - Total Architecturetotal-architecture.com/indexFiles/Governance/SOA Governance... · SOA Governance Essentials ... © 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights

For More Information…

Succeeding with SOA• The business and organizational

perspectiveperspective• For:

• CIO, COO, CEO, CTOManagers• Managers

• Enterprise and project architects

Implementing SOA• Creating the total architecture• ForFor

• Enterprise and project architects• CTOs

© 2008 TIBCO Software Inc. All Rights Reserved.

25www.total-architecture.com