8/9/2019 So What if God Were Dead?

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/so-what-if-god-were-dead 1/5

Fxxly `jr Fxxly^ri{frx 

<

XJ ^AL[ I@ NJK ^F_F KFLK:

Ic{rjkvh{ijc

Ic <11?$ l Nfrglc }aidjxj}afr$ @rifkriha ^idafdg Cif{uxhaf$ glkf aigxfd` 

`lgjvx oy vxicn l glkglc ic aix ojjb$ [af Nly Xhifchf$ {j df{ {af ~jrdk bcj~ {al{ {af

kfl{a j` Njk alx hjgf#

/^ai{afr ix Njk:/ {af glkglc ic {af glrbf{}dlhf hrifk#

/I ~idd {fdd yjv# ^f alpf biddfk aig¿yjv lck I# Ldd j` vx

lrf aix gvrkfrfrx# # # Njk ix kflk# Njk rfglicx kflk# Lck ~f alpf

biddfk aig# Aj~ xaldd ~f hjg`jr{ jvrxfdpfx$ {af gvrkfrfrx j` ldd gvrkfrfrx:

^al{ ~lx ajdifx{ lck gina{ifx{ j` ldd {al{ {af ~jrdk alx yf{ j~cfk alx odfk 

{j kfl{a vckfr jvr bcipfx5 ~aj ~idd ~i}f {aix odjjk j`` vx: ^al{ ~l{fr ix

{afrf `jr vx {j hdflc jvrxfdpfx: ^al{ `fx{ipldx j` l{jcfgfc{$ ~al{ xlhrfk 

 nlgfx xaldd ~f alpf {j icpfc{: Ix cj{ {af nrfl{cfxx j` {aix kffk {jj nrfl{ 

 `jr vx: Gvx{ ~f jvrxfdpfx cj{ ofhjgf njkx xig}dy {j l}}flr ~jr{ay j` i{ 

!Xfh{ijc <?62 Nly Xhifchf$ <11?):

[afxf ~jrkx alk nipfc oir{a {j Cif{uxhaf lx {af ¸oriddilc{ ov{ ~idk ~ri{fr$ lc

iggjrldix{ lck ciaidix{$ lc fdi{ix{ lck cl{ijcldix{$ l kfx}ixfr j` ~jgfc lck Ef~x»

!¸Cif{uxhaf ix cj{ Kflk$» <99;)#

Ickffk$ olhb {afc$ {j xly {al{ ¸Njk ix kflk» ~lx dibf xlyicn {al{ pldvfx lrf cj{

loxjdv{f$ lck xj {af {flhaicnx j` {af havrha lojv{ {af kipicf hrfl{jr lrf ldd cjcxfcxf#

[aix ~lx ldxj xffc lx lc lccjvchfgfc{ j` {af ¸fck j` {af frl j` {afjdjny» !@rlcbf$

?==>)#

^i{a {aix x{l{fgfc{$ Cif{uxhaf ig}difk {al{ glc xig}dy icpfc{fk Njk ¸{j nipf aix

di`f gflcicn$ }vr}jxf$ lck l gjrld hfc{fr !_l{cfr'_jxfcalnfc ?==0)$ lck {al{ Njk ix l

gfrf `ih{ijc#

8/9/2019 So What if God Were Dead?

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/so-what-if-god-were-dead 2/5

Fxxly `jr Fxxly^ri{frx 

?

 Cl{vrlddy$ {af ofdifpfrx ~jvdk fckdfxxdy |vfx{ijc {afxf ikflx ~aiha lrf loxjdv{fdy

loxvrk `jr {afg#

Aj~fpfr$ i{ gina{ glbf gjrf xfcxf {j lxb$ ¸ Xj ~al{ i` Njk ~frf kflk:»

Iglnicf {afrf°x cj Cif{uxhaf

¸Njk ix kflk#» Yfx$ Cif{uxhaf xlik i{# Dl{fr$ {af gfkil lck {af lhlkfgf

 }j}vdlriufk {af ikfl#

[al{ Cif{uxhaf alx ¸hjc|vfrfk Lgfrihl» ix xjgf{aicn ki``ihvd{ {j kfcy !_l{cfr'

_jxfcalnfc ?==0)# [af gfkil lck {af lhlkfgf ¸kfdipfrfk» {af cf~x {j {af }fj}df vc{id

xj gvha ay}f ix hrfl{fk {al{ {af x{l{fgfc{ alx ofhjgf l }lr{ j` {af hjcxhijvxcfxx j` {ajxf ~aj aflrk i{#

I` ic {af }lx{$ {af }rj`fxxjrx ¸alk icx{rvh{fk x{vkfc{x ic {af xfrijvx hjc{fg}dl{ijc

j` {af njjk di`f$ {afy cj~ {lvna{ yjvcn gickx {al{ ¶rflxjc hlccj{ fx{lodixa pldvfx$ lck

R{afW ofdif` {al{ i{ hlc ix {af x{v}ikfx{ lck gjx{ }frcihijvx iddvxijc#°» !Odjjg$ <91>2 |{k#

ic _l{cfr'_jxfcalnfc$ ?==0)#

Jv{xikf {af lhlkfgf$ Cif{uxhaf ~lx ldxj lgjcn {af `lpjri{f {j}ihx ic gfkil$ of i{

ic cf~x}l}frx$ glnluicfx$ `idgx$ lkpfr{ixfgfc{x$ }dlyx$ cjpfdx jr fpfc ic }j}vdlr gvxih

!_l{cfr'_jxfcalnfc ?==0)#

I{ gvx{ of rfgfgofrfk {al{ Cif{uxhaf°x {arff'~jrk }rjcjvchfgfc{ ofhlgf

hjc{rjpfrxild lnlic jpfr 1= yflrx l`{fr {af }vodihl{ijc j` [af Nly Xhifchf ~afc [igf

 Glnluicf hlgf v} ~i{a lc ixxvf jc L}rid 1$ <900 rfi{frl{icn {af xj'hlddfk kfl{a j` Njk#

[af `lgjvx glnluicf rfdipfk Cif{uxhaf°x x{l{fgfc{ ofhlvxf j` ~al{ {af Lgfrihlc

 }fj}df alpf offc fq}frifchicn {al{ {igf5 lxxlxxicl{ijcx$ pijdfchf$ xfq$ krvnx$ f{h#

!Xafrgfr <991)#

8/9/2019 So What if God Were Dead?

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/so-what-if-god-were-dead 3/5

Fxxly `jr Fxxly^ri{frx 

8

Ic l Gf{ajkix{ x{vkfc{ glnluicf hlddfk Gj{ipf$ lc joi{vlry `jr Njk ~lx

 }vodixafk# I{ xlik5

 L[DLC[L$ Nl#$ Cjp# 9''Njk $ hrfl{jr j` {af vcipfrxf$

 }richi}ld kfi{y j` {af ~jrdk.x Ef~x$ vd{igl{f rfldi{y j` Harix{ilcx$

lck gjx{ fgicfc{ j` ldd kipici{ifx$ kifk dl{f yfx{frkly kvricn 

glejr xvrnfry vckfr{lbfc {j hjrrfh{ l glxxipf kigicixaicn ic`dvfchf#

[af glnluicf hi{fk ¸xfhvdlriul{ijc$ xhifchf$ vrolciul{ijc» lx {af hlvxfx j` Njk°x

kfl{a !Xafrgfr <991)#

Lkkicn {j {af ay}f ~lx {af }j}vdlr olck hlddfk {af Ofl{dfx$ ~i{a ~aiha Ejac

Dfccjc ofhlgf gjrf }j}vdlr ~afc af xlik$ ¸Harix{ilci{y ~idd nj# I{ ~idd plcixa lck

xaricb# I cffkc.{ lrnvf lojv{ {al{$ I.g `ina{ lck ~idd of }rjpfk rina{# ^f.rf gjrf }j}vdlr 

{alc Efxvx Harix{ rina{ cj~/ !]lrfdfx lck _jglcj~xbi$ <9182 |{k# ic Xafrgfr <991)#

[af <9>< ai{ xjcn Iglnicf oy Dfccjc ~lx {afc l rfglrblodf l{{fg}{ {j

 }rjdi`frl{f {af Njk'ix'kflk ikfl {al{ Cif{uxhaf x{lr{fk jpfr l avckrfk yflrx }rijr {j

Ofl{dfx° }j}vdlri{y !Xafrgfr <991)# [af xjcn jopijvxdy ig}difk l njkdfxx `v{vrf5

Iglnicf {afrf.x cj aflpfc$I{.x flxy i` yjv {ry#Cj afdd ofdj~ vx

 Lojpf vx jcdy xby Iglnicf ldd {af }fj}df

dipicn `jr {jkly###Iglnicf {afrf.x cj hjvc{rifx

I{ ixc.{ alrk {j kjCj{aicn {j bidd jr kif `jr  Lck cj rfdinijc {jj#

^al{ i` Njk ~frf Kflk:

L{ `irx{$ {af Cif{uxhaflc ikfl gina{ xjvck pfry l{afix{ih {al{ i{ djxfx i{x pldvfx#

Aj~fpfr$ l hdjxfr fqlgicl{ijc j` {af Njk'ix'kflk }rfgixf oricnx vx {j {af xj'hlddfk

8/9/2019 So What if God Were Dead?

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/so-what-if-god-were-dead 4/5

Fxxly `jr Fxxly^ri{frx 

;

 Cif{uxhaflc pir{vfx5 kripf$ xfd '̀kixhi}dicf$ lgoi{ijc¼ ~aiha hlc ¸fcalchf di`f»

!¸Cif{uxhaf ix cj{ Kflk$» <99;)#

Avglc }frxjcx ~i{ajv{ l njk {j rfdy jc hjvdk alpf gjrf j}}jr{vci{ifx {j kfpfdj}

{afir hrfl{ipi{y !Lrlgolc ?==9)# Icx{flk j` ofdifpicn {al{ {afir }vr}jxf lck `l{f alpf

ldrflky offc kfhikfk v}jc fpfc of`jrf {afy ~frf ojrc$ {afy ~jvdk alpf {j of hjcpichfk

{al{ {afy glbf {afir j~c `v{vrf$ lck {al{ {afir ¸fqix{fchf }rfhfkfx fxxfchf» !Olrlxa$

?==<)$ lx ~al{ Eflc']lvd Xlr{rf$ l `lgjvx fqix{fc{ildix{$ alx xlik#

Ldxj$ {j alpf cj njk gflcx {j alpf {af `rffkjg {j glbf kfhixijcx ~i{ajv{

`jddj~icn loxjdv{f x{lcklrkx jc gjrldi{y#

Ofrclrk ^iddilgx$ l Ori{ixa }aidjxj}afr$ xl~ cj{aicn vcvxvld lojv{ {aix ikfl# Ic

`lh{$ af rfi{frl{fk {al{ i{°x vxvld ¸{j xvx}fck {af cjrgld rvdfx `jr fqhf}{ijcld }fj}df»

!¸Cif{uxhaf ix cj{ Kflk$» <99;)#

^fdd$ j` hjvrxf$ j}}jxi{ijc ix ld~lyx }rfxfc{# @jr ]aidi}}l @jj{$ lc lcldy{ihld

 }aidjxj}afr$ Cif{uxhaf°x ikflx lrf ¸kf`fh{ipf» `jr i{ ig}difx {al{ {afrf hlc of cj evx{ihf l{

ldd ¼ {al{ rfx}fh{ hlc cj djcnfr of nvlrlc{ffk lgjcn avglc }frxjcx !¸Cif{uxhaf ix cj{

Kflk$» <99;)$ i` {afrf ~frf cj x{lcklrk rvdfx jc gjrldi{y lck njjkcfxx#

Hjchdvxijc

 Cif{uhaf°x x{l{fgfc{ ix gjrf j` l halddfcnf$ {alc lc l{afix{ih rfglrb# I{

halddfcnfx glc°x hl}lhi{y {j x{f} olhb lck glbf xjgf rf`dfh{ijcx jc {af bick j` di`f {afy

hajjxf {j dipf$ icx{flk j` xig}dy lhhf}{icn {af bick j` di`f l njk alx kfxincfk `jr {afg#

^af{afr Njk ix kflk jr ldipf xajvdk of j` di{{df ig}jr{lchf# ^i{a jr ~i{ajv{  

Njk$ glc xajvdk rfx}fh{ flha j{afrx° `rffkjg lck rfhjnciu f {afi r j~c d i gi{ l{i jcx#

L`{fr ldd$ fpfc i` Njk kifk$ Af ~idd rfglic iggjr{ld lgjcn {ajxf }fj}df ~ajxf dipfx af

alk {jvhafk#

8/9/2019 So What if God Were Dead?

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/so-what-if-god-were-dead 5/5

Fxxly `jr Fxxly^ri{frx 

6

^J_BX HI[FK

 Lrlgolc$ B# Njk ix Kfl{a# ?==9# Lplidlodf `rjga{{}5**~~~#xhriok#hjg*kjh*?;;>>??=*Njk'ix'Kfl{a Lhhfxxfk jc @forvlry ?6$ ?=<=#

Olrlxa K# Lgfrihl.x Fxxfchf5 ^al{ ^jvdk Xlr{rf Xly:# Harjcihdf j` Ainafr Fkvhl{ijc RxfrildjcdicfW# Evdy ?=$ ?==<2;>!;6)5O6# Lplidlodf `rjg5 Lhlkfgih Xjvrhf ]rfgifr$ I}x~iha$GL# Lhhfxxfk @forvlry ?;$ ?=<=#

@rlcbf ^# [af Kfl{ax j` Njk ic Afnfd lck Cif{uxhaf lck {af Hrixix j` Pldvfx ic XfhvdlrGjkfrci{y lck ]jx{'xfhvdlr ]jx{gjkfrci{y# _fdinijc & {af Lr{x Rxfrild jcdicfW# Evcf?==>2<<!?)5?<;'?;<# Lplidlodf `rjg5 Lhlkfgih Xjvrhf ]rfgifr$ I}x~iha$ GL# Lhhfxxfk @forvlry ?;$ ?=<=#

Cif{uxhaf ix cj{ kflk# Fhjcjgix{ Rxfrild jcdicfW# Jh{jofr <6$ <99;2888!>116)5<<>'<<1# Lplidlodf `rjg5 Lhlkfgih Xjvrhf ]rfgifr$ I}x~iha$ GL# Lhhfxxfk @forvlry ?;$ ?=<=#

]i}}ic _# Cif{uxhaf lck {af Gfdlchajdy j` Gjkfrci{y# Xjhild _fxflrha Rxfrild jcdicfW#Xvggfr99 <999200!?)5;96'6?=# Lplidlodf `rjg5 Lhlkfgih Xjvrhf ]rfgifr$ I}x~iha$GL# Lhhfxxfk @forvlry ?;$ ?=<=#

_l{cfr'_jxfcalnfc E# Hjcpfc{ijcld Ihjcjhdlxg5 [af Hvd{vrld ^jrb j` {af Cif{uxhaf Iglnf ic[~fc{if{a'Hfc{vry Lgfrihl# Ejvrcld j` Lgfrihlc Aix{jry Rxfrild jcdicfW# Kfhfgofr?==0298!8)5>?1'>6;# Lplidlodf `rjg5 Lhlkfgih Xjvrhf ]rfgifr$ I}x~iha$ GL# Lhhfxxfk @forvlry ?;$ ?=<=#

Xafrgfr G# Ix Njk kflk:# Xbf}{ih Rxfrild jcdicfW# Evcf <99120!8)51=# Lplidlodf `rjg5 Lhlkfgih Xjvrhf ]rfgifr$ I}x~iha$ GL# Lhhfxxfk @forvlry ?;$ ?=<=#

[af Nly Xhifchf# Blv`glcc$ ^# R{rlcxdl{jrW# Pic{lnf# <9>;# Lplidlodf ̀ rjga{{}5**~~~#xhriok#hjg*kjh*<><;?669*@rifkriha'Cif{uxhaf'[af'Nly'Xhifchf Lhhfxxfk@forvlry ?6$ ?=<=