Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin !...

35
ELIZABETH SMITH, MPH, ICCE, IBCLC, RLC COORDINATOR, PATIENT SERVICES UNIVERSITY OF UTAH HOSPITAL Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch

Transcript of Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin !...

Page 1: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

ELIZABETH SMITH, MPH, ICCE, IBCLC, RLC COORDINATOR, PATIENT SERVICES

UNIVERSITY OF UTAH HOSPITAL

Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch

Page 2: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

Objectives

�  Attendees will be able to define skin-to-skin �  Attendees will be able to identify three positive

outcomes for skin-to-skin �  Attendees will be able to verbalize how to implement

skin-to-skin with the mother and / or father �  Attendees will be able to understand how skin to skin

can be incorporated into the whole postpartum period

Page 3: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

Infant Crying

Page 4: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

Crying in the Newborn

�  Increases right atrial pressure – the foramen ovale opens, venous blood mixes with oxygenated blood, cynanosis results

�  Increases intra-cranial pressure �  Initiates a cascade of stress reactions �  Depletes energy reserves

Interferes with the infant’s ability to adapt to extra-uterine life

Page 5: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

Separation of Mother and Baby

Page 6: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

Separation of Mother and Baby

�  The infant develops the ability to better cope with stresses when he is with his mother

�  Connection allows the infant to expand his or her responses to cope more effectively with different stressors

�  “Stresses” are physical and psychological �  The separation causes a dis-regulation and impacts

the structural organization of the brain

�  Attachment = Regulation = Well-being

Page 7: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

New Research

�  A healthy gut is critical to a lifetime of health �  Colonization of the gut begins immediately after

birth

�  Optimal Health ¡  Vaginal birth and immediate skin to skin contact

�  What to do if ideal doesn’t happen?

Page 8: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

So Much Better!

Page 9: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

Benefits of Rooming In

�  Moms and Babies sleep an average of ½- 1 hr longer in a 24 hour period.

�  Mom learns early feeding cues �  Babies put skin to skin adapt better

¡  Higher glucose ¡  Better HR and Respiratory Rates ¡  Less crying ¡  Feeling of security

�  2nd Night!!!!

Page 10: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

History of Skin-to-Skin

�  Dr’s Rey and Martinez ¡  Bogota & Cali, Colombia, South America

�  Gene Cranston Anderson, R.N., Ph.D., F.A.A.N.

�  Dr. Nils Bergman ¡  Introduced KMK in South Africa in 1995

Page 11: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

Terms for Skin-to-Skin

�  KMC = Kangaroo Mother Care �  KC = Kangaroo Care �  STS = Skin-to-skin �  SSC = Skin-to-skin Contact

Page 12: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

Definition of skin-to-skin

�  Place the baby naked or with only a diaper prone on the mother’s / father’s bare chest

�  Usually takes place at birth or soon after �  Cover the baby with a warmed blanket �  Place a hat on the baby’s head

Page 13: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

Visual of skin-to-skin

Page 14: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

Skin to Skin in the OR

Page 15: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

Skin to Skin in Recovery

Page 16: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

Skin to Skin with Preemies

Page 17: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

Dads and Skin to Skin

Page 18: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

Infant Brain

�  By 20 weeks gestation all structures are formed ¡  Billions of neurons will form

�  At birth the highest number synapses will occur �  From there it’s the environment that determines

outcomes ¡  Wiring and firing ¡  Neurons that aren’t used will die off

�  Body will deal with underuse, eustress and distress ¡  Both underuse and distress can have detrimental impacts ¡  The usual place to learn adaptation is with the mother

÷ Another person can be substituted but mom is ideal

Page 19: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

Preterm Brain

�  Significant brain growth occurs between 36 and 40 weeks of gestation ¡  One of the reasons the March of Dimes pushed for “no early

delivery unless medically indicated” �  For early babies, skin to skin is even more critical

¡  In order to adapt and obtain regulation ¡  Organization of the brain occurs skin to skin

÷ Complex and subtle neurological/biological cues and behaviors

Page 20: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

Baby Friendly USA

Page 21: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

Baby Friendly Hospital Initiative

Step 4: Help mothers initiate breastfeeding

within an hour of birth.

Uninterrupted Skin to Skin in the first hour is the critical piece

Page 22: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

The W.H.O. Evidence for Skin-to-Skin

�  Takes advantage of the “alert” 1-2 hours after birth �  “Contact” and “suckling” are interrelated

¡  Suckling movements start at a peak of 45 minutes �  Increase in breastfeeding rates at 2 to 3 months �  Promotes maternal behavior �  Newborn skin temperatures were higher, higher

blood glucose levels, and plasma base-excess returned to normal faster

�  The newborn cried less

Page 23: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

Impact on breastfeeding duration of early infant-mother contact

Adapted from: DeChateau P, Wiberg B. Long term effect on mother-infant behavior of extra contact during the first hour postpartum. Acta Peadiatr, 1977, 66:145-151.

58%

26%

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

Early contact (n=21) Control (n=19)

Perc

ent s

till b

reas

tfeed

ing

at 3

mon

ths Early contact: 15-20 min suckling and

skin-to-skin contact within first hour after delivery

Control: No contact within first hour

World Health Organization - Evidence for the 10 Steps

Page 24: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin

�  Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and was “compared to usual hospital care” (Cochrane, p.7).

�  Looked only at studies with a control group, and that were of high quality, looked for bias.

�  With inclusion criteria – 30 studies, 29 were randomized control and one was quasi-randomized.

Page 25: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

The Cochrane Evidence for Skin-to-Skin

�  Breastfeeding outcomes �  Maternal feelings �  The Infant

Page 26: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

The Cochrane Evidence for Skin-to-Skin

•  Breastfeeding outcomes

•  More likely to breastfeed successfully during the first feed post

birth than those babies who were swaddled in blankets •  Infants held STS had more mouthing movements than those

who were not.

•  Statistically significant and better overall performance on all measures of breastfeeding status: duration (2-4 months)

Page 27: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

The Cochrane Evidence for Skin-to-Skin

•  Maternal feelings

•  Had less anxiety at 3 days post birth •  No difference in milk supply, number of breastfeeding

problems, or parenting confidence

•  Those who held their infant STS had a strong desire to do it for future deliveries

•  Maternal attachment behavior

Page 28: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

The Cochrane Evidence for Skin-to-Skin

•  Maternal attachment behavior

•  STS increased the amount of maternal affectionate behaviors – kissing, smiling, en-face (face-to-face contact)

•  Bias and questionable validity of multiple studies were noted

•  Hard to differentiate a mother’s perception of bonding/connection

•  One study from Vietnam, when Baby Friendly was implemented as a nation, showed a decrease in the abandonment rate and incidence of child abuse

Page 29: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

The Cochrane Evidence for Skin-to-Skin

�  Infant temperatures ¡  Mom warms and cools ¡  Others can warm a baby

�  Infant physiological

outcomes

Page 30: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

The Cochrane Evidence for Skin-to-Skin

•  Infant temperatures

•  STS infants had more skin temperatures in the neutral range than baby under the radiant warmer

•  Mean temperature for STS infants was higher than in control

group

Page 31: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

The Cochrane Evidence for Skin-to-Skin

•  Infant Physiological outcomes

•  STS infant had lower mean ht rate, respiratory rate

•  Blood glucose was statistically higher in one study (10.56 mg/dl higher)

•  Better stabilization using SCRIP scores (measures infant cardio-respiratory stability that uses ht rate, respiratory rate, and o2 sat)

•  No difference in the length of stay for late preterm infant

•  Multiple studies have shown that STS infants cry less

Page 32: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

The Cochrane Discussion for Skin-to-Skin

�  Success of first breastfeed �  Breastfeeding success at day three postpartum �  Breastfeeding duration at one to four months �  Maternal breast engorgement pain �  State anxiety �  Infant recognition of their mother's milk odor �  Maintenance of infant’s temperature �  Infant crying, blood glucose, SCRIP scores,

physiological parameters

Page 33: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

What about the father?

�  Father’s many times feel like outsiders �  Gives the father an opportunity to be a care-giver

from the time of birth �  Showed that when the father did skin-to-skin –

¡  Infant temperatures were within normal range ¡  Blood glucose levels were up ¡  Catecholamine levels were within normal range

Page 34: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and
Page 35: Skin to Skin Care Baby’s First Touch · The Cochrane Criteria for Studies of Skin-to-Skin ! Looked at all randomized or quasi-randomized studies that encouraged skin-to-skin and

References

�  Baby Friendly Hospital Initiative (n.d.). Retrieved from the World Health Organization web page on February 23, 2008 at site: http://www.who.int/nutrition/topics/bfhi/en/

�  Bergman, N. (2009), Breastfeeding and Skin-to-Skin, SWAG Conference, Berkeley, CA.

�  Christensson, k. (1996). Fathers can effectively achieve heat conservation in healthy newborn infants. Acta Paediatics. 85, p 1354-60.

�  Ferber, S.G. & Makhoul, I.R., (2004). The effect of skin-to-skin contact shortly after birth on the neurobehavioral responses of the term newborn: a randomized, controlled trial. Pediatrics, 113(4), p. 858-865.

�  Gill, N.E., White, M.A., & Anderson, G.C. (1984), Transitional newborn infants in a hospital nursery: from first oral cue to first sustained cry, Nursing Research, 33(4).

�  Moore, E.R., Anderson, G.C., Bergman, N., (2008). Early skin-to-skin contact for mothers and their healthy newborn infants. Cochrane Collaboration.

�  Schore, A.N. (2001), Effects of a secure attachment relationship on right brain development, affect regulation, and infant mental health, Infant Mental Health Journal, 22(1-2), 7-66.

�  Vallenas, C. & Savage, F. (1998) Evidence for the ten steps to successful breastfeeding . World Health Organization, Geneva.