SIOTN: Evaluation of Territorial Development in Navarre

SIOTN: Evaluation of Territorial Development in Navarre

Xabier Velasco

Observatorio Territorial de Navarra

1

CONTENT

1. Indicators and territorial strategies

2. Territorial Strategy of Navarre (ETN) – in search of synthetic indicators

2

3. A new proposal: indicators for territorial policies

4. The product – OTN indicator system

5. Conclusions

INDICATORS AND TERRITORIAL STRATEGIES

3

INDICATORS AND TERRITORIAL STRATEGIES

• Territorial Strategies – Orientations for future development based on a common future

• How do we translate this vision into tangible results?

4

• GDP, quality of life, cohesive society… But are they the results of a territorial strategy?

TERRITORIAL STRATEGY OF NAVARRE

• Based on 6 principles

• 18 strategic options, 32 policy objectives, 80 directives for action

5

COHESIÓNCOHESIÓNCOHESIÓNCOHESIÓN

COMPETITIVIDADCOMPETITIVIDADCOMPETITIVIDADCOMPETITIVIDAD CONSERVACIÓNCONSERVACIÓNCONSERVACIÓNCONSERVACIÓN

POLICENTRISMOPOLICENTRISMOPOLICENTRISMOPOLICENTRISMO

ACCESIBILIDADACCESIBILIDADACCESIBILIDADACCESIBILIDAD IDENTIDADIDENTIDADIDENTIDADIDENTIDAD

D T SE T N


• Use of synthetic indicators

6


26,5

38,0

33,1

42,742,9 45,946,9

60,748,3

53,754,3

65,9

10,0

20,0

30,0

40,0

50,0

60,0

70,0

80,0

10,0

20,0

30,0

40,0

50,0

60,0

70,0

80,0

7

3,7 5,30,0

Compet it ividadOutput

Competit ividadInput

Cohesión Social Sostenibilidad Policentrismo Acceso aInfraestruc. yConocimiento

GestiónPatrimonio

Natural y Cultural

0,0

Valor 2000 Valor 2005 Objetivo

• Results first evaluation 2000-2005

• Abstract figures, not comparable with other regions, no commitment

• No translation into policies “on the ground”

INDICATORS FOR TERRITORIAL POLICIES

• New proposal: translation into indicators measuring outcomes of “territorial policies”

• Used for evaluation of all instruments of spatial planning (territorial strategy and subregional spatial plans)

• Organized around “main issues” of spatial planning

8

ETN POT


Communications, transport and infrastructures

Digital accesibility

External connectivity

Internal connectivity

Sustainable mobility

Intermodality

Water

Natural and cultural heritage

Nature conservation

Pollution

Natural risks

Productivity

Landscape

Culture

Urban system

9

Energy

Waste

Coordination

Local cooperation

Regional cooperation

Spatial Planning

Territorial Cohesion

Urban system

External cohesion

Internal cohesiob

Social cohesion

Services

Housing

Economy and innovation

Rural development

Urbanism TOTAL: 125 indicators


• Strategic axis: natural and cultural heritage

• Theme: natural risks

• Indicator: new dwellings in flood prone areas

10

in flood prone areas


• Strategic axis: urban system

• Theme: urbanism

• Indicator: compactness

11


• Strategic axis: urban system

• Theme: urbanism

• Indicator: compactness

12

INIDICATORS FOR TERRITORIAL POLICIES

• Ejemplo vivienda (modelo de crecimiento)

• Strategic axis: communication, transport and infrastructure

• Theme: accessibility

• Indicator: access to

13

• Indicator: access to service centers

OTN INDICATOR SYSTEM: INPUT DATA

• Diverse data sources at national, regional and local level.

• Data availability

• Privacy policies

14

• Time series

• Data quality

• Data formats

• Different data models

TOTAL: 230 sources of data/ 70 responsibles

OTN INDICATOR SYSTEM: CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK

15

OTN INDICATOR SYSTEM

16


Three different outputs:

• Web-based tool (intranet): ASP.net 4.0, PYTHON, ArcGIS Desktop

• Biannual publication or evaluation report (http://www.nasursa.es/es/ObservatorioTerritorialNavar

17

(http://www.nasursa.es/es/ObservatorioTerritorialNavarra/sistema_indicadores.asp)

• Several Observation reports to deepen into specific themes (http://www.nasursa.es/es/ObservatorioTerritorialNavarra/observaciones_territoriales.asp).


18


19


20


DEMO

21

CONCLUSIONS

• Developing indicators for territorial policies require serious involvement from politicians.

• Danger of overload of information.

22

• Data availability remains low and quality and formats are still diverse.

• Statistical information outside SDI’s becomes and increasing problem.

CONCLUSIONS

• Problem in defining the appropriate scale of study for different issues.

• Integration towards SITNA/IDENA.

23

• Implementation in other regions: valid application of the conceptual framework/ adaptation to data availability.

CONCLUSIONS

Thank you for your attention!!

Further questions:

24

Further questions:

[email protected]

SIOTN: Evaluation of Territorial Development in Navarre

Technology

Transcript of SIOTN: Evaluation of Territorial Development in Navarre