SI SARE PPP Final Report - Savanna Institute · 2020-01-12 · Final Report: Crop Performance,...
Transcript of SI SARE PPP Final Report - Savanna Institute · 2020-01-12 · Final Report: Crop Performance,...
![Page 1: SI SARE PPP Final Report - Savanna Institute · 2020-01-12 · Final Report: Crop Performance, Pests, and Pollinators in Diverse Agroforestry Systems Sustainable Agriculture Research](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022011903/5f154d16276e2312433a0840/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
FinalReport:CropPerformance,Pests,andPollinatorsinDiverseAgroforestrySystems
SustainableAgricultureResearch&EducationPartnershipGrant
NorthCentralRegion
August28,2017
![Page 2: SI SARE PPP Final Report - Savanna Institute · 2020-01-12 · Final Report: Crop Performance, Pests, and Pollinators in Diverse Agroforestry Systems Sustainable Agriculture Research](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022011903/5f154d16276e2312433a0840/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
1
TableofContentsAbstract..........................................................................................................................................2
ProjectObjectives..........................................................................................................................2RESEARCH................................................................................................................................................2OUTREACH...............................................................................................................................................2
Background....................................................................................................................................3
Farms..............................................................................................................................................3
CropPerformance..........................................................................................................................3Managementapproach...........................................................................................................................4Varietyselection......................................................................................................................................5Treeprotection........................................................................................................................................5
PlantPathogens.............................................................................................................................5
ArthropodDiversity&Abundance.................................................................................................6
Outreach........................................................................................................................................7TimelapsePhotography...........................................................................................................................7ResultsDissemination..............................................................................................................................7
Outcomes&Impact.......................................................................................................................8
Acknowledgements........................................................................................................................8
Tables.............................................................................................................................................9
Figures..........................................................................................................................................11
![Page 3: SI SARE PPP Final Report - Savanna Institute · 2020-01-12 · Final Report: Crop Performance, Pests, and Pollinators in Diverse Agroforestry Systems Sustainable Agriculture Research](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022011903/5f154d16276e2312433a0840/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
2
AbstractDiverseAgroforestry(DA)systemsoffermanybenefitsforfarmersandsociety.Despite
theincreasingimplementationofthesesystemsatrelativelylargescales,therehasbeennorigorouson-farmevaluationoftheimpactofvariousmanagementstrategiesontheirperformance,pestissues,andbenefittopollinators.TheinherentcomplexityofDAsystemsmakeseffectiveresearchandoutreachdifficult,especiallywhenworkingwithadistributednetworkoffarms.FourcollaboratingMidwestfarmersintheSavannaInstitute’sCaseStudyProgrampartneredwithSavannaInstitutestaffandanentomologistinterntoevaluatethegrowthofDAsystemsacrossarangeofmanagementstrategies,identifybaselinepollinatorcommunities,andmonitorcroppathogens.Todisseminateresults,amulti-facetededucationandoutreachapproachleveragedtimelapsevideos,on-farmfielddays,andadigital/printedbulletin.Resultsofgrowthdatasuggestthatmanagementapproacheshaveadramaticimpactoncropsurvivalandgrowth.Weedcontrolanddiseasemanagementseemtobethekeyfactorsdrivinggrowthdifferences.FungalpathogenswerethedominantpestsobservedintheDAsystemsacrossfarms.AlthoughnopathogensweredocumentedthatarenoveltotheNorthCentralRegion,thecataloguedpestswillprovidefuturefarmerswithkeymonitoringtargetwithintheDAcrops.ThehighaverageabundanceofarthropodsobservedinDAsystemssuggeststhat,evenearlyintheirlifecycle,DAsystemshostbeesandotherpollinatorsbetterthanrowcropswhileyieldingadiversesetofhigh-valuecropscomparedtohay.
ProjectObjectivesRESEARCH
1) EvaluatethegrowthandyieldofDAsystemsacrossarangeofmanagementstrategies
2) IdentifybaselinepollinatorcommunitiespresentinandinteractingwithDAsystemscomparedtoadjacentland-uses
3) Identify&monitorpestsaffectingthenovelwoodyperennialcropsinDAsystemsOUTREACH
1) Documenttheestablishment&growthofDAsystemsviatime-lapsephotography2) Distributeresultsviaprintedmaterials,onlinemedia,andfielddays
![Page 4: SI SARE PPP Final Report - Savanna Institute · 2020-01-12 · Final Report: Crop Performance, Pests, and Pollinators in Diverse Agroforestry Systems Sustainable Agriculture Research](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022011903/5f154d16276e2312433a0840/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
3
BackgroundDiverseAgroforestry(DA)systemsintegratingfruit,nutandforagecomponentshave
potentialtorestoreecosystemserviceswhilesimultaneouslyprovidingeconomicallyviableandnutritionallyvaluablestaple-foodcropsatindustrialquantities.Despitetheincreasingimplementationofthesesystems–withcorecropssuchashazelnut,chestnut,currantandapple–therehasbeennorigorouson-farmevaluationoftheimpactofvariousmanagementstrategiesonthegrowthandyieldofthesesystems.Furthermore,manyofthecomponentcropsdrivingtheadoptionofDAsystemsarerelativelynoveltotheMidwest.Littleisknownaboutthepests/pathogensofthesecropsinthisregion,especiallyinaDAcontext.AlthoughDAsystemsareinherentlydiverse,andmatureagroforestrysystemsareknowntoincreasediversityofarthropodcommunities,verylittleisknownaboutthepotentialofyoungDAsystemstofosterarthropoddiversity.
TheSavannaInstituteinitiatedaCaseStudyProgramin2014toaidandlearnfromfarmersestablishingDAsystems.FarmersintheCaseStudyProgramvoluntarilydocumentcashflow,labor,inputs,andmanagementtechniquesintheirDAenterprise.ThisprojectisanextensionoftheCaseStudyProgram,workingmoredeeplywithfourdedicatedfarmerstoexplorespecificresearchobjectivesontheperformance,pests,andpollinatorsinDA.
FarmsFourfarmswereselectedfromexistingCaseStudyfarmstoconductmoreintensive
researchandoutreachunderthisprojectbasedon:1) DASystemSimilarity:CooperatingfarmscontainDAsystemsofsimilarcomposition.2) ManagementStrategy:Onefarmwasselectedforeachofthefollowing
managementstrategies:High-Input,High-Labor;Low-Input,High-Labor;High-Input,Low-Labor;andLow-Input,Low-Labor.
3) Location:Farmswereselectedtominimizetravel.Collaboratingfarmersincluded:
• CatheCapel–VulcanFarm–ChampaignCounty,IL(High-Input,High-Labor)• KatePotter–SunDappledFarm–PeoriaCounty,IL(Low-Input,Low-Labor)• MarciaPowell–LockieFarm–ChampaignCounty,IL(Low-Input,High-Labor)• ScottWilliams–FieldsRestored–OgleCounty,IL(High-Input,Low-Labor)
TheDAsystemsoneachfarmincludedrowsoffruitandnuttreesandshrubswithalleys
ofgrassoralfalfahay.Farmswereestablishedbetween2013and2015.Collaboratingfarmerswereexpectedtospendapproximatelytwohoursperweekcollectingon-farmdataassociatedwiththisproject,inexchangeforanhonorarium.RepresentativephotosfromeachforthefourcollaboratingfarmsareshowninFigure1.
CropPerformanceSmallyieldswereobtainedacrossallcollaboratingfarmsduringthisprojectduetotheir
young,establishingnature(Figure2).Mostofthecoreproductivecropsemphasizedateach
![Page 5: SI SARE PPP Final Report - Savanna Institute · 2020-01-12 · Final Report: Crop Performance, Pests, and Pollinators in Diverse Agroforestry Systems Sustainable Agriculture Research](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022011903/5f154d16276e2312433a0840/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
4
farmwerenotyetofbearingageduringthisproject.Consequently,weoptedtofocusonplantgrowthratherthanplantyieldsasourprimarymetricforperformance.Accuratelyquantifyingwoodycropgrowthisdifficultforfarmers.Toaccomplishthisgoal,theSavannaInstitutefieldresearchinternmeasuredgrowthannuallyviastemdiametermeasurementsusingadigitalcaliper.Thisgrowthdata,inconjunctionwithfarmercensusesofplantsurvival,offeredinsightintocropresponsestomanagementinDAsystems.Belowwepresent,severaldifferentexperimentsofcropperformanceasafunctionofthreecriticaltools:managementregime,varietyselection,andtreeprotection.
Managementapproach ThemostcommonandhighestpriorityquestionsthattheSavannaInstitutereceivesfromCastStudyfarmersallrelatetomanagementofcropsafterestablishment.CaseStudyfarmersadoptawiderangeofmanagementregimes,rangingfromlowtohighlabor(e.g.mulching,pruning)andlowtohighinputs(e.g.fertilizer,herbicide).ThefourcollaboratingfarmsstudiedinthisprojectspanthisspectrumandcanprovidesomegeneralinsightsintooptimalmanagementofDAsystems. Therelativegrowthoffourselectedspeciesthatwerepresentonallcollaboratingfarms–apple,Chinesechestnut,hybridhazelnut,andhybridpoplar–ispresentedhere.Throughoutthedurationofthisproject,relativebasalstemareagrowthrangedfrom-100%(wholesaledeath)to800%(Figure3).Datafromthelow-input,low-laborfarmwerenotcollectedattheendoftheprojectbecausemostplantshadeitherdiedorwereimpossibletofindamongtheweedspresentonthefarm.Thisisanimportantfirstconclusion,inthatcombiningbothlow-inputandlow-labormanagementapproachesprovedhighlyunsuccessfulasweedscompletelytookover.Inasimilarlight,overallresultsfromthehigh-input,high-laborfarmwerenotdramaticallybetterthanwhenjusthigh-inputorhigh-laborwereappliedsingularly. Forapple,bothVulcanfarmandLockieFarmexperiencedwholesalegraftfailure,resultinginsmallerplantsattheendoftheproject.FieldsRestored,however,hasnotyetattemptedtografttheirapples,sogrowthwasstillpositive.Chinesechestnutgrowthwassimilaracrossfarms.Despitethehigh-input,high-laborapproachatVulcanFarm,chestnutsdidnotgrowanyfasterthantheotherfarms.Severalenvironmentalfactors,suchasdroughtandfloodingatvarioustimes,mayhavecontributedtothis,suggestingthatenvironmentalfactorscantrumpeventhebestmanagementdependingonthespeciesandscenario.Hybridhazelnutgrowthwashigherinthelow-inputfarmcomparedtotheothertwohigh-inputfarms.Thismaybetheresultoffertilizerstuntinggrowthinthehazelnuts,whichhasbeendocumentedinpreviousstudies.Thisreiteratesthatmanagementmustspecies-specific;notalltree/shrubspecieshavethesamerequirementsorresponses.Finally,hybridpoplarwastheonlyspeciesforwhichthehigh-input,high-laborapproachatVulcanFarmcontributedtodramaticallyimprovedsuccess.Hybridpoplarisanextremelyfast-growingspeciesthatishighlyresponsivetofertilizerinputsandreducedcompetition.Forthisreason,hybridpoplargrowthseemedtoincreasewithanyincreasesinmanagementintensity.
![Page 6: SI SARE PPP Final Report - Savanna Institute · 2020-01-12 · Final Report: Crop Performance, Pests, and Pollinators in Diverse Agroforestry Systems Sustainable Agriculture Research](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022011903/5f154d16276e2312433a0840/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
5
Varietyselection Beforeafarmerevenhastheopportunitytomanagetheirplantsforoptimalgrowth,muchofaplant’sdensityhasalreadybeendeterminedgenetically.Whilevarietyselectioniswildlyknowntobecriticalfordiseaseresistance,fruitquality,andyield,itislessoftenthoughtofasfundamentaltoplantestablishmentandgrowth.Here,weusedchestnutsatLockieFarmasacasestudyoftheimpactthatgeneticshaveevenintheearlyyearsofplantgrowthinDA.BasalstemareavariedsignificantlyacrosstenChinesechestnutvarietiesbytheendoftheproject(Kruskal-Wallis,p<0.001)(Figure4).Overall,therewasatwo-foldrangeinbasalstemdiameterafterjusttwoyearsofgrowth.TheseresultssuggestthatvarietyselectioncouldplayanevenlargerrolethanplantmanagementinthesuccessfulestablishmentandearlygrowthoftreesinDAsystems.Treeprotection
OnecriticalaspectofcropmanagementintheearlyyearsofDAsystemsistreetrunkprotectionfromherbivoredamage.ThisisbyfarthemostcommonmanagementtechniqueadoptedbyCaseStudyfarmerstodate.Here,weusedhybridpoplaronVulcanFarm(thefarmwiththehighestdeerpressureofallcollaboratingfarms)ascasestudyoftheimpactthattreeprotectionwithplastictreetubeshasonplanthealth.Whilefarmerstypicallythinkoftreetubesasprotectingtreesfromdeerbrowse,hybridpoplargrowsorapidlythattheirgrowthtipsaretypicallyoutofdeerrangequitequickly.Instead,theprimaryissuewithdeerencounteredatVulcanFarmwasdeerantlerrubbingonthepoplartreetrunks.Sincethehybridpoplarwerebyfarthelargesttreesontheyoungfarm,thedeerdirectedthebruntoftheirrubbingonthem.
Thefrequencyofseveredeerantlerrubbingonhybridpoplarwasdependentontheuseof4’plastictreetubes(X2=56.8,df=3,p<0.01)(Table1).Eventhoughmuchrubbingwasobservedabove4’ontreeswithouttubes,therewasnosevererubbingonanytreeswith4’treetubes(Figure5).Thisindicatesthat,beyondphysicalprotectionofthetree,thetreetubesalsoactindirectlytodeterthedeerfromrubbing.Ourbestguessisthatthenoisecreatedbytheplastictubeswhenthedeerattempttorubonthosetreesisatplayhere.Fortreeswithouttreetubes,therewasahighfrequencyofseveredeerantlerrubbingacrosspruningapproaches,althoughthedamagefrequencywashigherintreesthathadallbranchesprunedinthefall(71%)thanintreesthathadnopruning(44%).Thereisaclearinteractiveeffectbetweennotreetubeandpruningapproach.Withnopruning,thehybridpoplartreeshadmanylateralbranches,evenaslowas2’offtheground.Thefallpruningapproachtoprunealllateralbrancheswasinitiatedbythefarmertoseeifthiswouldencouragethetreestogrowtallermorequickly.However,itseemsthatpruningoffthelateralbranchesmadethetreesmuchmoreappealingforantlerrubbing.Thisislikelybecausethelateralbranchescanbeuncomfortabletothedeerastheyrub,possiblypokingthemintheeyesorotheruncomfortableplaces.
PlantPathogensEachofthefourcollaboratingfarmswasvisitedmonthlybytheSavannaInstitute’sfield
researchinternduringthe2015and2016growingseasons(typicallyMay-September)toscout
![Page 7: SI SARE PPP Final Report - Savanna Institute · 2020-01-12 · Final Report: Crop Performance, Pests, and Pollinators in Diverse Agroforestry Systems Sustainable Agriculture Research](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022011903/5f154d16276e2312433a0840/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
6
forandcollectsamplesofplantpests(Figure6).Farmersaidedinthescoutingusingtheirobservationsofcropsduringthepriormonth.ThelackofsubstantialinsectpestsobservedoncropsacrossallcollaboratingfarmsleadustofocusprimarilyonplantpathogensastheprimarypestsinDAsystems.Nosubstantialdifferencesinpathogenabundancewereobservedacrossthecollaboratingfarms,soallresultswerepooledhere.CollectedsamplesofdiseasedplanttissuesweresubmittedtotheUniversityofIllinoisExtension’sPlantClinicforidentification.
Intotal,17pathogenspecieswereobservedon11plantspeciesacrossallfarms(Table2).Allobservedpathogenissueswerefungaldiseases.FungaldiseasesmaybeexacerbatedinDAsystemsduetotherelativelyhighdensityandmultiplelayeringofcrops,whichcandecreaseairflow.Reducedairflowisamajorcontributortofungaldiseasepressure.Inaddition,thespringseasonsofboth2015and2016experiencedabnormallyhighprecipitationatallstudiedfarms,whichcanalsoexacerbatefungaldiseaseissues.Nevertheless,allobservedpathogenshavepreviouslybeenobservedintheNorthCentralRegion;nounexpectedpathogenswereobserved.However,fewpathogenswereobservedatmorethanonefarm,indicatingthatthereishighvariabilityacrossenvironmentsandmanagementregimes.
ArthropodDiversity&AbundanceEachofthefourcollaboratingfarmswasvisitedmonthlybytheSavannaInstitute’sfield
researchinternduringthe2015and2016growingseasons(typicallyMay-September)tocollectsamplesofbaselinepollinatorcommunitiesinDA.SampleswerecollectedfromtheDAsystemsoneachfarmaswellas2-3otherecosystemtypesnearby:hay,rowcrops(maizeorsoybean),andforest(VulcanFarmandFieldsRestoredonly).
Toassesstheinsectcommunitiespresentineachsystem,weusedapantrappingtransectmethod.Pantrappingusessmallplasticbowlspaintedblue,white,andyellowtomimicbee-pollinatedflowers.Bowlsarefilledwithslightlysoapywatertocollectinsectsthatenterthetraps.Whilepantrapsaretargetedatbees,theyalsocapturearangeofflower-visitinginsectsinothertaxa.Asapassivetechnique,pantrappingminimizescollectorbiasinbeesamplingandrequiresrelativelyminimallabor.Becausepantrappingisbasedonvisibilitybytargetorganisms,trapsmustbeelevatedtotheheightofsurrounding.Whenvegetationwastall,thiswasachievedbyusingtapetoattachbowlstosturdystalks(Figure7A).Pantrapswerelaidinstraighttransectsof15bowls,laid5mapart(Figures7Band7C).Oncesampleswerereturnedtothelab,theSavannaInstitute’sentomologistinternsorted,preserved,andidentifiedallcollectedarthropodstotheorderlevelusingadissectingmicroscope.
Over13,500arthropodswerecollectedacrossallsystemsfrom29site-monthsthroughouttheproject.Arthropodsfromthefollowing10orderswerecollectedandcatalogued:Anthophila,Aranae,Coleoptera,Collembola,Diptera,Hemiptera,Hymenoptera,Lepidoptera,Orthoptera,Thysoptera.Asameasureofoverallarthropoddiversity,themeannumberofarthropodorderspresentinpantrapsampleswascalculatedforeachland-usesystem(Figure8).TheDAandhaysystemshadsignificantlyhigherdiversityattheorderlevelthantherowcropsystems(ANOVA&Tukey’sHSD,p<0.01).Therewerenosignificantdifferencesbetweenanyotherland-usecombinations.
Beyonddiversity,arthropodabundancevarieddramaticallyacrossland-usesystems.HayandDAweresimilarinbothoverallabundanceandcommunitycompositionin2015and2016(Figure9).Similarly,forestandrowcropsweresimilarinbothoverallabundanceand
![Page 8: SI SARE PPP Final Report - Savanna Institute · 2020-01-12 · Final Report: Crop Performance, Pests, and Pollinators in Diverse Agroforestry Systems Sustainable Agriculture Research](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022011903/5f154d16276e2312433a0840/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
7
communitycomposition,althoughbothsystemshadmuchlowerabundancethathayorDA.Thesimilaritybetweenforestandrowcropcommunitieswasunexpected,althoughmightbeexplainedbytherelativelysmallforestfragmentsthatwereavailableforstudywithinalandscapecontextdominatedbymaizeandsoybean.In2015,DipteraandHymenopterawerethetwomostcommonarthropodordersobserved,whereasCollembolaandThysanopteraweremostabundantin2016.
ManagementapproachwithinDAsystemswasalsoobservedtoaffecttheabundanceofsomearthropodorders.Onaverage,low-laborfarmshostedovertwiceasmanybees(Anthophila)comparedtohigh-laborfarms(ANOVA,p<0.05).Onepossibledriverforthisisthatlowlaborfarmstypicallyharboredamuchhigherabundanceandwiderdiversityofweeds,whichcancontributesubstantialnumbersofavailableflowerstothesystem.Atthesametime,thelow-laborfarmshostedlessthanhalfasmanyflies(Diptera)comparedtohigh-laborfarms(ANOVA,p<0.01).ThesecontrastingresultssuggestthatDAmanagementapproachescandifferentiallyimpacttheabundanceofarthropodswithinvariousphylogeneticorders.Theonlyarthropodssignificantlyaffectedbytheleveloffarminputswerethrips(Thysanoptera),whichwerealmostthreetimesmoreabundantinthelow-inputfarms(i.e.lesstonoherbicide)comparedtothehigh-inputfarms(ANOVA,p<0.05).Thripsaregenerallyherbivores,puncturingplantleavesandsuckingoutthecontents.Asforthebees,alikelyreasonforthehigherthripabundanceinlow-inputfarmsisthehigherweedbiomass.
Overall,itisquiteimpressivethatbotharthropoddiversityandabundancewerehigherintheyoung,establishingDAsystemsthanbothforestandrowcrops.Whilehigherinsectdiversityiswill-documentedinmatureagroforestrysystems,apositiveshiftindiversitywithinjustthefirst1-2yearsafterestablishmentisaveryimpressivesignoftheircapacitytofosterbiodiversity.Inaddition,itisinterestingtoseethatthecommunitycompositionoftheDAsystemsismostsimilartothecommunitypresentinthehaysystems.ThismakessensesincetheherbaceousgroundcoveristhedominantcomponentofplantbiomassintheearlyyearsofDAsystems,andisoftenofsimilarspeciescompositiontotheadjacenthaycommunities.ResultsalsosuggestthatvariationsinmanagementapproachwithinDAsystemsaffectinsects,particularlybeesandflies.Futureresearchshouldevaluatetherelationshipsbetweenlaborandinputclass,insectabundance,andyieldoutcomesasmoredataisavailable.
OutreachTimelapsePhotography
Weatherprooftimelapsecameraswereplacedateachcooperatingfarmandtookphotosdailythroughouttheproject.ThesephotoswerethenpiecedtogethertogreatimpactfulvisualsofhowDAsystemsdevelopovertime.Thetimelapsecameraswillcontinuetocapturethisvaluableeducationalassetevenafterthecompletionofthisproject.AssembledtimelapsevideostodateareavailableonanewpageontheSavannaInstitutewebsite:http://www.savannainstitute.org/timelapse-videos.html.ResultsDissemination
Fielddayswereheldannuallyateachparticipatingfarm,withtoursledbythefarmersandconversationsledbySavannaInstitutestaff(Figure10).Ateachfieldday,aswellasatthreeSavannaInstitutefielddaysonotherfarms,weintroducedtheDAsystemsandprovided
![Page 9: SI SARE PPP Final Report - Savanna Institute · 2020-01-12 · Final Report: Crop Performance, Pests, and Pollinators in Diverse Agroforestry Systems Sustainable Agriculture Research](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022011903/5f154d16276e2312433a0840/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
8
anoverviewofthisSARE-supportedstudy.Attendeeswereprovidedwithlightrefreshmentsandtimetodeveloprelationshipsamongthemselves.FielddayannouncementsandphotosfollowingtheeventsweresharedonsocialmediaandviatheSavannaInstitutenewsletter.Attheon-farmfielddays,~100attendeesobservedtheDAsystemsincludedinthisstudyandlearnedabouttheproject.Wehavewitnessedmanynewcollaborationsformasaresultofintroductionsmadeaton-farmfielddays.Furthermore,attheSavannaInstitute’sannualFarmerGatheringinFebruary2017,SavannaInstitutestaffpresentedto~60attendeesabouttheresultsofthisstudy.
Abulletinsummarizingtheresultsofthisprojectwasalsocreatedtoprovideafarmer-friendlyoverview.ThisbulletinhasbeendistributedviatheSavannaInstitutenewsletter,tonetworkcollaboratorsacrosstheMidwest,andisavailableontheSavannaInstitutewebsite.Inaddition,theresultsbulletinhasbeenprintedandwillbedistributedatthe2018annualFarmerGatheringaswellasatallSavannaInstitutefielddaysin2018.
Outcomes&ImpactThisprojectservesasafirststepinexploringtheinput/managementtradeoffsinDA
systemsandwillsupportinformeddecision-makingforcurrentfarmersandpotentialadopters.Moreover,theknowledgegainedofcriticalpests,arthropodcommunities,andmonitoringmethodswillsupportmanagementdecisionsandappropriatefuturestudiesinDAsystems.Furthermore,thedocumentedbenefitsofDAonarthropodcommunitieswillservetoeducatethepublicforpolicyandmarketingefforts.
TheresultsofthisprojecthavealreadyspurredconversationamongthecooperatingfarmersandmanyotherCaseStudyfarmersaroundadjustingtheirinput/managementstrategies.TheincreasedcapacityoftheSavannaInstituteCaseStudyProgramstimulatedbythisprojecthasalsomotivatedincreasedfarmerparticipationandexpandedtheprogramintoavibrantcommunityofpractice.
Inthelong-term,wehopethatourresearchresultsandmulti-facetededucationalapproacheswillservetoimprovetheviabilityofDA-basedfarmsandhelpdriveadoptionacrosstheNorthCentralRegion.Theresearchprotocols,findings,andrelationshipsdevelopedinthisprojectarealreadyallowingtheSavannainstitutetoexpanditshorizonsandestablishcollaborationswithresearchersatseverallandgrantuniversities.
AcknowledgementsTheSavannaInstitutethanksourtwofieldinterns,DaneHunterandAlexHiatt,fortheir
hardworkinvisitingthefarmsandcollectingdata.Inaddition,wethankourentomologistintern,AlessaLaserna,forherdiligentworkclassifyinginsectsinthelab.WearegratefulforadviceandsupportfromAdamKranzandDr.JamesMilleronexperimentaldesignandgenerouslysharinglabspaceandequipment.Finally,wethankourhard-workingCaseStudyfarmerswhoparticipatedinthisprojectandcontinuetosupportthevalueofresearchandeducationinagroforestryintheMidwest:CatheCapel,KatePotter,MarciaPowell,andScottWilliams.
![Page 10: SI SARE PPP Final Report - Savanna Institute · 2020-01-12 · Final Report: Crop Performance, Pests, and Pollinators in Diverse Agroforestry Systems Sustainable Agriculture Research](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022011903/5f154d16276e2312433a0840/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
9
Tables Table 1. Frequency of severe deer antler rubbing over the 2016-2017 winter season on 2-year-old hybrid poplars under different management practices at Vulcan Farm.
3' tree tube No tree tube 3' tree tube No tree tube0% 71% 0% 44%
Fall prune all branches No pruning
![Page 11: SI SARE PPP Final Report - Savanna Institute · 2020-01-12 · Final Report: Crop Performance, Pests, and Pollinators in Diverse Agroforestry Systems Sustainable Agriculture Research](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022011903/5f154d16276e2312433a0840/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
10
Table 2. Plant pathogens observed on four farms with young, establishing diverse agroforestry systems.
Plant-Scientific Plant-Common Pathogen-Scientific Pathogen-CommonAmelanchier sp. Serviceberry Colletotrichum AnthracnoseleafspotAroniamelanocarpa Chokeberry Septoria LeafspotCastenaeamollisima Chestnut Pestalotia LeafspotCorylus sp. Hazelnut Cylindrosporium LeafspotCorylus sp. Hazelnut Pestalotia LeafspotPopulus sp. Hybridpoplar Marssonina Blackleafspot;MarssoninaleafblightPopulus sp. Hybridpoplar Septoria LeafspotRibesnigrum Blackcurrant Alternaria LeafspotRibesnigrum BlackCurrant Colletotrichum AnthracnoseLeafspotRibesnigrum Blackcurrant Drepanopeziza(Pseudopeziza) RibesanthracnoseRibesrubrum Currant Cercospora LeafspotRibesrubrum Redcurrant Drepanopeziza(Gloeosporium)ribus RibesanthracnoseRibesrubrum Redcurrant Mycosphaerellagrossulariae CurrantleafspotSalixsp. Shrubwillow Venturia Willowleafblight;scapSambucuscanadensis Elderberry Alternaria LeafspotViburnumtrilobum Americancranberrybush Plasmoparaviburni ViburnumdownymildewVitislabrusca Grape Plasmoparaviticola Grapedownymildew
![Page 12: SI SARE PPP Final Report - Savanna Institute · 2020-01-12 · Final Report: Crop Performance, Pests, and Pollinators in Diverse Agroforestry Systems Sustainable Agriculture Research](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022011903/5f154d16276e2312433a0840/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
11
Figures
Figure 1. Representative photos from each for the four farms studied in this project: (A) Vulcan Farm, (B) Fields Restored, (C) Lockie Farm, and (D) Sun Dappled Farm.
![Page 13: SI SARE PPP Final Report - Savanna Institute · 2020-01-12 · Final Report: Crop Performance, Pests, and Pollinators in Diverse Agroforestry Systems Sustainable Agriculture Research](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022011903/5f154d16276e2312433a0840/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
12
Figure 2. Representative yields from four farms with young, establishing diverse agroforestry systems, including (A) cut flowers, (B) blackberries, (C) raspberries, (D) culinary herbs, and (E) cut floral stems.
![Page 14: SI SARE PPP Final Report - Savanna Institute · 2020-01-12 · Final Report: Crop Performance, Pests, and Pollinators in Diverse Agroforestry Systems Sustainable Agriculture Research](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022011903/5f154d16276e2312433a0840/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
13
Figure 3. Relative growth in basal stem area for selected species across the four collaborating farms. Farms are classified by their management regimes.
![Page 15: SI SARE PPP Final Report - Savanna Institute · 2020-01-12 · Final Report: Crop Performance, Pests, and Pollinators in Diverse Agroforestry Systems Sustainable Agriculture Research](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022011903/5f154d16276e2312433a0840/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
14
Figure 4. Basal stem area of ten Chinese chestnut varieties at the end of the project.
![Page 16: SI SARE PPP Final Report - Savanna Institute · 2020-01-12 · Final Report: Crop Performance, Pests, and Pollinators in Diverse Agroforestry Systems Sustainable Agriculture Research](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022011903/5f154d16276e2312433a0840/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
15
Figure 5. Hybrid poplar tree (A) without protection from deer rub was completely girdled during the winter, whereas trees (B) with protection via 3-foot plastic tree tube.
![Page 17: SI SARE PPP Final Report - Savanna Institute · 2020-01-12 · Final Report: Crop Performance, Pests, and Pollinators in Diverse Agroforestry Systems Sustainable Agriculture Research](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022011903/5f154d16276e2312433a0840/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
16
Figure 6. Examples of pathogen damage on four farms with young, establishing diverse agroforestry systems.
![Page 18: SI SARE PPP Final Report - Savanna Institute · 2020-01-12 · Final Report: Crop Performance, Pests, and Pollinators in Diverse Agroforestry Systems Sustainable Agriculture Research](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022011903/5f154d16276e2312433a0840/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
17
Figure 7. To sample pollinators in the various land-use systems, (A) bowl traps were set out in the morning and recollected at the end of the day. Example bowl traps in (B) forest and (C) soybean are also shown.
![Page 19: SI SARE PPP Final Report - Savanna Institute · 2020-01-12 · Final Report: Crop Performance, Pests, and Pollinators in Diverse Agroforestry Systems Sustainable Agriculture Research](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022011903/5f154d16276e2312433a0840/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
18
Figure 8. The mean number of arthropod orders per site-month in each of the four land-use systems studied. All months were average together for each site-year, and site-years taken as the unit of replication. Systems with the same letter are not significantly different.
![Page 20: SI SARE PPP Final Report - Savanna Institute · 2020-01-12 · Final Report: Crop Performance, Pests, and Pollinators in Diverse Agroforestry Systems Sustainable Agriculture Research](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022011903/5f154d16276e2312433a0840/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
19
Figure 9. Mean abundance of arthropods per site-month in each of the four land-use systems studied. All months at all four sites were average together for each year.
![Page 21: SI SARE PPP Final Report - Savanna Institute · 2020-01-12 · Final Report: Crop Performance, Pests, and Pollinators in Diverse Agroforestry Systems Sustainable Agriculture Research](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022011903/5f154d16276e2312433a0840/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
20
Figure 10. Representative photos from field days at the collaborating farms.