Should we Repair Rotator Cuffs? - Debate€¦ · Amit Sharad Chandra BidwaiX Ann B'rch 2 Saurabh...

19
Should we Repair Rotator Cuffs? - Debate Mr Mike Walton BMedSci BMBS MSc FRCS(T&O) MFSEM(UK) Consultant Shoulder Surgeon

Transcript of Should we Repair Rotator Cuffs? - Debate€¦ · Amit Sharad Chandra BidwaiX Ann B'rch 2 Saurabh...

Page 1: Should we Repair Rotator Cuffs? - Debate€¦ · Amit Sharad Chandra BidwaiX Ann B'rch 2 Saurabh Odak 4 Michael J Walton 2 John F Haines and Ian Trail . wrightngton Upper Limb Unit

Should we Repair Rotator Cuffs?

- DebateMr Mike Walton BMedSci BMBS MSc FRCS(T&O) MFSEM(UK)

Consultant Shoulder Surgeon

Page 2: Should we Repair Rotator Cuffs? - Debate€¦ · Amit Sharad Chandra BidwaiX Ann B'rch 2 Saurabh Odak 4 Michael J Walton 2 John F Haines and Ian Trail . wrightngton Upper Limb Unit

What / Which Evidence

• Population Based

• Intervention Based• PATIENT BASED

Page 3: Should we Repair Rotator Cuffs? - Debate€¦ · Amit Sharad Chandra BidwaiX Ann B'rch 2 Saurabh Odak 4 Michael J Walton 2 John F Haines and Ian Trail . wrightngton Upper Limb Unit

Population Based

• Gold Standard: “Best Evidence”

• Pragmatic, Multicentre, Randomised, Controlled Trials

Page 4: Should we Repair Rotator Cuffs? - Debate€¦ · Amit Sharad Chandra BidwaiX Ann B'rch 2 Saurabh Odak 4 Michael J Walton 2 John F Haines and Ian Trail . wrightngton Upper Limb Unit

“The” RCT

Page 5: Should we Repair Rotator Cuffs? - Debate€¦ · Amit Sharad Chandra BidwaiX Ann B'rch 2 Saurabh Odak 4 Michael J Walton 2 John F Haines and Ian Trail . wrightngton Upper Limb Unit

Outcomes

Page 6: Should we Repair Rotator Cuffs? - Debate€¦ · Amit Sharad Chandra BidwaiX Ann B'rch 2 Saurabh Odak 4 Michael J Walton 2 John F Haines and Ian Trail . wrightngton Upper Limb Unit
Page 7: Should we Repair Rotator Cuffs? - Debate€¦ · Amit Sharad Chandra BidwaiX Ann B'rch 2 Saurabh Odak 4 Michael J Walton 2 John F Haines and Ian Trail . wrightngton Upper Limb Unit
Page 8: Should we Repair Rotator Cuffs? - Debate€¦ · Amit Sharad Chandra BidwaiX Ann B'rch 2 Saurabh Odak 4 Michael J Walton 2 John F Haines and Ian Trail . wrightngton Upper Limb Unit
Page 9: Should we Repair Rotator Cuffs? - Debate€¦ · Amit Sharad Chandra BidwaiX Ann B'rch 2 Saurabh Odak 4 Michael J Walton 2 John F Haines and Ian Trail . wrightngton Upper Limb Unit

Cross Overs & ITT

Page 10: Should we Repair Rotator Cuffs? - Debate€¦ · Amit Sharad Chandra BidwaiX Ann B'rch 2 Saurabh Odak 4 Michael J Walton 2 John F Haines and Ian Trail . wrightngton Upper Limb Unit

Cross Overs & ITT

Page 11: Should we Repair Rotator Cuffs? - Debate€¦ · Amit Sharad Chandra BidwaiX Ann B'rch 2 Saurabh Odak 4 Michael J Walton 2 John F Haines and Ian Trail . wrightngton Upper Limb Unit

Healed Cuffs Do Best

Page 12: Should we Repair Rotator Cuffs? - Debate€¦ · Amit Sharad Chandra BidwaiX Ann B'rch 2 Saurabh Odak 4 Michael J Walton 2 John F Haines and Ian Trail . wrightngton Upper Limb Unit

Healed Cuffs Do Best

Page 13: Should we Repair Rotator Cuffs? - Debate€¦ · Amit Sharad Chandra BidwaiX Ann B'rch 2 Saurabh Odak 4 Michael J Walton 2 John F Haines and Ian Trail . wrightngton Upper Limb Unit

Healed Cuffs Do Best

Page 14: Should we Repair Rotator Cuffs? - Debate€¦ · Amit Sharad Chandra BidwaiX Ann B'rch 2 Saurabh Odak 4 Michael J Walton 2 John F Haines and Ian Trail . wrightngton Upper Limb Unit

Intervention Studies

Page 15: Should we Repair Rotator Cuffs? - Debate€¦ · Amit Sharad Chandra BidwaiX Ann B'rch 2 Saurabh Odak 4 Michael J Walton 2 John F Haines and Ian Trail . wrightngton Upper Limb Unit

Intervention Studies

Page 16: Should we Repair Rotator Cuffs? - Debate€¦ · Amit Sharad Chandra BidwaiX Ann B'rch 2 Saurabh Odak 4 Michael J Walton 2 John F Haines and Ian Trail . wrightngton Upper Limb Unit

Patient Based

Page 17: Should we Repair Rotator Cuffs? - Debate€¦ · Amit Sharad Chandra BidwaiX Ann B'rch 2 Saurabh Odak 4 Michael J Walton 2 John F Haines and Ian Trail . wrightngton Upper Limb Unit

AVOID SURGERY

Healed Cuff Repair

Patient Based

Page 18: Should we Repair Rotator Cuffs? - Debate€¦ · Amit Sharad Chandra BidwaiX Ann B'rch 2 Saurabh Odak 4 Michael J Walton 2 John F Haines and Ian Trail . wrightngton Upper Limb Unit

AVOID SURGERY

Healed Cuff Repair

Patient Based

Page 19: Should we Repair Rotator Cuffs? - Debate€¦ · Amit Sharad Chandra BidwaiX Ann B'rch 2 Saurabh Odak 4 Michael J Walton 2 John F Haines and Ian Trail . wrightngton Upper Limb Unit

Solution

• UNDERSTAND MORE

• Which patients will do well with cuff repair?

• Why do they fail rehabilitation - many do

• Rehaber and Rehabee

• Current (P)ROMS - not responsive

• NOT to avoid surgery at all costs